climate-plan-summary-tool / CAPS_Summaries /Asheville, NC Equal Adaptation-Mitigation CAP 2022_Summary.md
umangchaudhry's picture
Upload 79 files
63fb9ad verified
|
raw
history blame
34.2 kB

Question: Describe the physical and economic landscape of the jurisdiction as outlined in the plan. Include the name of the planning jurisdiction, its location, population, demographics, and average income. Include major geographic features such as mountains, rivers, deserts, and coastline, as well as any key infrastructure like airports or seaports. Highlight details about the local climate, including any mentions of aridity or water challenges. Additionally, summarize the city’s energy production (oil, gas, renewables) and natural resources, and provide information about industries and economic drivers that are crucial to the region.

Answer: The plan provided does not include detailed information about the physical and economic landscape of Asheville, such as its location, population, demographics, average income, major geographic features, key infrastructure, local climate details, energy production, natural resources, or specific industries and economic drivers. The document primarily focuses on Asheville's commitment to sustainability and climate action, as well as various climate policies and activities related to resilience, mitigation, and adaptation within the city.

Question: To what extent does the plan address resilience, mitigation, and adaptation? After providing a brief summary of how it addresses each component, classify the plan as a whole as one of the following: mitigation dedicated, adaptation/resilience dedicated, mitigation only climate action plan, mitigation primary climate action plan, equal mitigation and adaptation climate action plan, or sustainable/green plan.

Answer: Resilience:

The plan addresses resilience through several activities and goals focused on enhancing the ability of city-owned assets and the community to withstand and recover from disruptions. For instance, one of the focus areas under Goal 1 is to "Equip City Assets to Prevent, Withstand, and Recover From Disruptions" (Executive Summary). Moreover, the plan includes activities such as "Update City-Owned Building Standards for Resilience Considerations" and "Enhance Stormwater Control Measures for City-Owned Property" (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities).

Mitigation:

Mitigation actions are prominently featured in the plan, as evidenced by activities aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions and transitioning to renewable energy. The plan includes goals like "Use 100% Renewable Energy for City-Owned Facilities and Enhance Energy Efficiency for City-Owned Facilities" and activities such as "Continue Installation of Renewable Energy Resources on Municipal Property" and "Expand Energy Efficiency Standards for All New Construction to Retrofits and Upgrades" (Executive Summary, Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities).

Adaptation:

Adaptation is also a significant component of the plan, with activities designed to cope with and withstand climate impacts. For example, the plan proposes to "Update City-Owned Building Standards for Resilience Considerations," which includes considerations for climate adaptation (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities). The plan also emphasizes embedding sustainability and resilience in decision-making processes (Executive Summary).

Classification:

Based on the emphasis on both mitigation and adaptation strategies, the plan can be classified as an equal mitigation and adaptation climate action plan. It balances activities aimed at reducing emissions with those enhancing resilience and adaptation to climate impacts.

Question: Does the plan describe a scenario of climate change the planning jurisdiction will face and for which it is planning climate policies for resilience, mitigation, and adaptation? If so, please summarize any such scenario.

Answer: The plan does not explicitly describe a specific scenario of climate change that the planning jurisdiction will face. However, it recognizes the impacts associated with climate-related hazard events and the importance of resilience, mitigation, and adaptation. It mentions:

  • "As the climate changes, it is increasingly important to ensure that new buildings and major retrofits or repairs are constructed to withstand and recover from climate-related events" (Implementation).
  • "As climate change results in more frequent and more intense storms and weather-related events, the need to incorporate climate resilience and climate equity considerations into the City’s emergency response continues to grow" (Goal 1).

These statements imply that the City is preparing for increased frequency and intensity of climate-related events, such as storms and extreme weather, but a detailed scenario is not provided.

Question: What climate hazards does the plan identify as presenting climate risks for the planning jurisdiction? For each identified climate hazard, summarize the plan’s description of: 1. The climate hazard. 2. The climate risks it poses to the planning jurisdiction. 3. Areas or populations with the most climate vulnerability to the identified climate hazard.Generate a numbered list of every hazard identified in the plan. Make the list as long as necessary to accomodate every single hazard.

Answer: 1. More Frequent and Intense Storms and Weather-Related Events

  • Climate Hazard: "As climate change results in more frequent and more intense storms and weather-related events..."

  • Climate Risks: These events increase the need for the city to incorporate climate resilience and climate equity considerations into emergency response to ensure equitable aid and response for all residents and communities.

  • Vulnerable Areas/Populations: The plan emphasizes the importance of considering the needs and vulnerabilities of Asheville’s communities, particularly vulnerable groups, to inform equitable, data-driven strategies. It highlights the necessity of overcoming language or accessibility barriers that could prevent vulnerable communities from receiving aid. (Integrate Climate Justice, Equity, and Resilience Best Practices into All Hazards Planning Committee and Emergency Response Plans and Operations)

Question: What resilience options are identified in the plan? For each option, summarize: 1. The specific climate threat it addresses; 2. Details on cost, timeframe, and location, including any references found in tables, charts, or images that might contain this data; 3. Other important attributes, such as economic, environmental, or infrastructural considerations.

Answer: Resilience Options Identified in the Plan:

  1. Update City-Owned Building Standards for Resilience Considerations

    • Climate Threat Addressed: This option addresses threats such as flooding, drought, extreme temperatures, and wildfires. "Resilient building design minimizes the loss of critical function due to adverse events such as flooding, drought, extreme temperatures, or wildfires." (Section: Update City-Owned Building Standards for Resilience Considerations)

    • Cost, Timeframe, and Location:

      • Cost: $ - $$$$
      • Timeframe: Short (0-2 years)
      • Location: City-owned buildings
      • "Funding required will also vary based on standard adoption and planning ($), and building construction and resilience needs involved ($$$$)." (Section: Operational Resources)
    • Other Important Attributes:

      • Economic: The benefits of investments in resilience measures can far outweigh the costs over time. "Studies have shown that the benefits of investments in resilience measures can far outweigh the costs over time." (Section: Update City-Owned Building Standards for Resilience Considerations)
      • Infrastructural: The focus is on maintaining and recovering functionality of buildings. "Resilient buildings also have the capacity to fully recover from such events more quickly than traditionally designed buildings." (Section: Update City-Owned Building Standards for Resilience Considerations)
  2. Explore City Supported Community Resilience Hub Sites

    • Climate Threat Addressed: This option is aimed at natural disasters, weather-related events, or man-made disasters or disruptions. "Resilience hubs offer a centralized location where community members can go before, after, or during natural disasters, weather-related events, or man-made disasters or disruptions." (Section: Explore City Supported Community Resilience Hub Sites)

    • Cost, Timeframe, and Location:

      • Cost: $$ - $$$$
      • Timeframe: Medium
      • Location: Known, trusted community gathering locations or City facilities
      • "Exploration of resilience hubs will utilize existing staff capacity that is funded through the General Fund/operating budget. If a project is identified, capital funds or grants, and governmental incentives may be applicable." (Section: Operational Resources)
    • Other Important Attributes:

      • Social: They provide opportunities for education on methods to increase personal or community resiliency. "Hubs are often located in areas with underserved or vulnerable populations." (Section: Explore City Supported Community Resilience Hub Sites)
      • Infrastructural: They serve as centralized locations for community education and resources during disruptions. "Resilience hubs can also provide opportunities for residents to withstand and recover from natural disasters or weather events by serving as warming and cooling centers, providing device charging and wi-fi during power outages, or serving as a central location for the dissemination of information, food, or supplies during disruptions." (Section: Explore City Supported Community Resilience Hub Sites)
  3. Enhance Stormwater Control Measures for City-Owned Property

    • Climate Threat Addressed: This option addresses the threat of stormwater-related issues. "Enhance Stormwater Control Measures for City-Owned Property." (Section: Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)

    • Cost, Timeframe, and Location:

      • Cost: $$$$
      • Timeframe: Short (0-2 years)
      • Location: City-owned property
      • "Staff Capacity, Capital funding, Operational funding." (Section: Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
    • Other Important Attributes:

      • Environmental: Improving stormwater control can help manage environmental impacts associated with water runoff and flooding.
      • Economic: This measure can help prevent costly damage to city infrastructure and properties.
  4. Assess and Enhance Efficiency and Resilience of Municipal Water Distribution System

    • Climate Threat Addressed: This option addresses threats related to water distribution efficiency and resilience. "Assess and Enhance Efficiency and Resilience of Municipal Water Distribution System." (Section: Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)

    • Cost, Timeframe, and Location:

      • Cost: $$ - $$$$
      • Timeframe: Short (0-2 years)
      • Location: Municipal water distribution system
      • "None identified." (Section: Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
    • Other Important Attributes:

      • Infrastructural: Ensures the municipal water distribution system can withstand climate impacts and continues to operate efficiently.

Question: What mitigation options does the plan identify? For each identified mitigation option, summarize the information provided in the plan regarding cost, timing, location, and other important attributes.

Answer: The plan identifies the following climate mitigation options:

  1. Continue Installation of Renewable Energy Resources on Municipal Property

    • Cost: $$$$
    • Timing: Ongoing
    • Location: Municipal Property
    • Attributes: Requires staff capacity, capital funding, and capital roof replacement funding.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 1
  2. Utilize Alternatives to On-Site Solar to Meet Targets

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timing: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Needs operational funding, capital funding, a dedicated funding source, and a procurement program approved by the NC Utility Commission.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 2
  3. Expand Energy Efficiency Standards for All New Construction to Retrofits and Upgrades

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timing: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: New Construction, Retrofits, and Upgrades
    • Attributes: Requires capital funding, operational funding, and project assessments.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 3
  4. Establish Building Energy Efficiency Operations and Maintenance Requirements

    • Cost: $$$$
    • Timing: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires staff capacity, staff training, and operational funding.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 4
  5. Incorporate Equity and Sustainability into Processes to Address Aging Infrastructure

    • Cost: $
    • Timing: Short: 0-2 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: No resource gaps identified.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 5
  6. Utilize Green Fleet Policy for Fleet Electrification

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timing: Short: 0-2 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires capital funding and operational funding.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 12
  7. Conduct Low-Carbon Transit Assessment

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timing: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires capital funding, operational funding, and access to reliable vehicles meeting operational needs.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 13
  8. Conduct Solid Waste Master Planning Process

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timing: Short: 0-2 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires staff capacity and operational funding.
    • Citation: Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities, ID 17

Question: What mitigation options does the plan identify? For each identified mitigation option, summarize the information provided in the plan regarding cost, timeframe, location, and other important attributes.

Answer: The plan identifies the following mitigation options:

  1. Continue Installation of Renewable Energy Resources on Municipal Property

    • Cost: $$$$
    • Timeframe: Ongoing
    • Location: Municipal Property
    • Attributes: Requires staff capacity, capital funding, and capital roof replacement funding. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  2. Utilize Alternatives to On-Site Solar to Meet Targets

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires operational and capital funding, a dedicated funding source, and procurement program approval by the NC Utility Commission. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  3. Expand Energy Efficiency Standards for All New Construction to Retrofits and Upgrades

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires capital and operational funding, and project assessments. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  4. Establish Building Energy Efficiency Operations and Maintenance Requirements

    • Cost: $$$$
    • Timeframe: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires staff capacity, staff training, and operational funding. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  5. Incorporate Equity and Sustainability into Processes to Address Aging Infrastructure

    • Cost: $
    • Timeframe: Short: 0-2 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: No resource gaps identified. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  6. Assess and Enhance Efficiency and Resilience of Municipal Water Distribution System

    • Cost: $$ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Short: 0-2 years
    • Location: Municipal Water Distribution System
    • Attributes: No resource gaps identified. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  7. Utilize Green Fleet Policy for Fleet Electrification

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Short: 0-2 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires capital and operational funding. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  8. Conduct Low-Carbon Transit Assessment

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Medium: 3-5 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires capital and operational funding, and access to reliable vehicles meeting operational needs. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  9. Establish Sustainable Oriented Procurement Procedures

    • Cost: $
    • Timeframe: Long: 6+ years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires staff capacity. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  10. Conduct Solid Waste Master Planning Process

    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Short: 0-2 years
    • Location: Not specified
    • Attributes: Requires staff capacity and operational funding. (Appendix A: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)

These mitigation options aim to reduce greenhouse gas emissions through energy efficiency, renewable energy, sustainable practices, and transportation initiatives.

Question: What adaptation options does the plan identify? For each identified adaptation option, summarize: 1. The climate threat it is addressing. 2. Information provided in the plan regarding cost, timeframe, location, and other important attributes.

Answer: The plan identifies several adaptation options. Below is a summary of each identified adaptation option, including the climate threat it addresses and relevant information regarding cost, timeframe, location, and other attributes:

  1. Establish a Policy for the Purchase, Sale, or Adaptive Reuse of Highly Vulnerable or Underutilized Assets

    • Climate Threat: This option addresses the threat of climate impacts on vulnerable or underutilized city assets.
    • Cost: Funding is from the General Fund/operating budget; potential for grants and government incentives.
    • Timeframe: Short-term (0-2 years).
    • Other Attributes: The policy will guide decision-making regarding acquisition, disposition, or adaptive reuse of vulnerable assets. It requires staff for real estate analysis and actions. (Executive Summary)
  2. Investigate and Install Building Automation for All City Facilities

    • Climate Threat: Enhances resilience to climate variability by automating building operations.
    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Medium-term (3-5 years).
    • Other Attributes: Requires capital and operational funding. It is a combined adaptation and mitigation effort. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  3. Integrate Climate Justice, Equity, and Resilience Best Practices into Emergency Response Plans and Operations

    • Climate Threat: Enhances resilience to climate-related emergencies.
    • Cost: $
    • Timeframe: Short-term (0-2 years).
    • Other Attributes: No identified resource gaps. It is both an adaptation and mitigation activity. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  4. Enhance Stormwater Control Measures for City-Owned Property

    • Climate Threat: Addresses the risk of flooding and stormwater management issues.
    • Cost: $$$$
    • Timeframe: Short-term (0-2 years).
    • Other Attributes: Requires staff capacity, capital, and operational funding. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  5. Assess and Enhance Efficiency and Resilience of Municipal Water Distribution System

    • Climate Threat: Ensures resilience of water supply to climate-induced disruptions.
    • Cost: $$ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Short-term (0-2 years).
    • Other Attributes: No identified resource gaps. It is both an adaptation and mitigation activity. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  6. Update City-Owned Building Standards for Resilience Considerations

    • Climate Threat: Improves resilience of buildings to withstand climate impacts.
    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Short-term (0-2 years).
    • Other Attributes: Requires capital funding. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  7. Use Climate Justice and Sustainability Tools for Planning and Decision Making

    • Climate Threat: Enhances decision-making to account for climate justice and resilience.
    • Cost: $
    • Timeframe: Ongoing.
    • Other Attributes: No identified resource gaps. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  8. Monitor and Engage in State-Level and Utility Policies on Climate and Sustainability

    • Climate Threat: Adapts to policy changes that might affect climate resilience.
    • Cost: $
    • Timeframe: Ongoing.
    • Other Attributes: No identified resource gaps. It is both an adaptation and mitigation activity. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  9. Utilize Urban Forestry Practices on City Land in Priority Neighborhoods to Reduce Heat Island Impacts and Sequester Carbon

    • Climate Threat: Addresses urban heat island effects and promotes carbon sequestration.
    • Cost: $$
    • Timeframe: Short-term (0-2 years).
    • Other Attributes: No identified resource gaps. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  10. Explore City Supported Community Resilience Hub Sites

    • Climate Threat: Provides community support during climate-related disruptions.
    • Cost: $ - $$$$
    • Timeframe: Medium-term (3-5 years).
    • Other Attributes: No identified resource gaps. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)
  11. Conduct Programs for Food Production, Community Gardening, and Edible Plantings on Public Lands

    • Climate Threat: Enhances food security in response to climate variability.
    • Cost: $
    • Timeframe: Ongoing.
    • Other Attributes: No identified resource gaps. (Table 3: Summary of Sustainability and Climate Activities)

Question: What climate policies does the plan identify to advance climate justice? For each climate policy, summarize: 1. The climate threat it is addressing. 2. Areas or populations with the most climate vulnerability to the identified climate hazard.

Answer: The plan identifies several climate policies to advance climate justice, addressing various climate threats and focusing on vulnerable areas or populations:

  1. Use Climate Justice and Sustainability Tools for Planning and Decision Making

    • Climate Threat: This policy addresses the climate threat of disproportionate impacts of climate change on marginalized communities.
    • Vulnerable Areas/Populations: The City of Asheville's community-driven Climate Justice Initiative specifically works with BIPOC and frontline communities to explore and define concepts of climate equity, justice, and resilience, focusing on Asheville’s most impacted communities. (Focus Area 2.1: Embed Sustainability, Resilience, and Equity in Decision-Making and Planning)
  2. Utilize Urban Forestry Practices on City Land to Reduce Heat Island Impacts and Sequester Carbon

    • Climate Threat: This policy addresses the threat of urban heat islands and low tree coverage, which can exacerbate heat vulnerability.
    • Vulnerable Areas/Populations: Historically BIPOC or low-income neighborhoods are identified as aligning with heat islands and low tree coverage areas. The City prioritizes expanding tree coverage in these neighborhoods to mitigate heat vulnerability and improve air quality. (Focus Area 3.1: Collaborate On and Support Community-Based Solutions and Infrastructure Improvements to Prevent, Withstand, and Recover From Disruptions)
  3. Integrate Climate Justice, Equity, and Resilience Best Practices into Emergency Response Plans and Operations

    • Climate Threat: This policy focuses on the increasing frequency and intensity of storms and weather-related events due to climate change.
    • Vulnerable Areas/Populations: The plan considers the needs of vulnerable groups, engaging with vulnerable communities to ensure equitable emergency response plans that are inclusive of those who require additional assistance. (Integrate Climate Justice, Equity, and Resilience Best Practices into All Hazards Planning Committee and Emergency Response Plans and Operations)

Question: Identify any potential unforeseen maladaptive climate policies. For each identified climate policy, summarize: 1. The climate threat it is addressing. 2. The resilience, mitigation, or adaptation option that the climate policy proposes. 3. Why it may cause inadvertent maladaption.

Answer: Based on the document provided, here are some potential unforeseen maladaptive climate policies:

  1. Policy: Establish a Policy for the Purchase, Sale, or Adaptive Reuse of Highly Vulnerable or Underutilized Assets

    • Climate Threat Addressed: The policy addresses the threat of climate impacts on city-owned facilities or assets that are vulnerable or underutilized. It aims to manage the financial risks associated with maintaining such assets which are expensive and carbon-intensive.

    • Resilience, Mitigation, or Adaptation Option: The policy proposes the adaptive reuse, sale, or purchase of vulnerable assets, incorporating sustainability, resilience, and adaptation considerations into the decision-making process. This involves assessing the costs of acquisition, hardening, restoration, and reconfiguration for reuse, as well as evaluating vulnerability and potential revenue or savings.

    • Potential Maladaptation: The policy may inadvertently lead to maladaptation if the adaptive reuse or sale of assets does not adequately consider long-term climate projections or community needs, potentially leaving critical infrastructure under-resourced or exposing communities to greater risks. In focusing on financial risks, there might be a risk of prioritizing short-term economic benefits over long-term resilience, resulting in increased vulnerability or loss of critical services over time. Moreover, selling assets to private entities may result in a loss of public control over essential services or amenities, potentially exacerbating social inequities.

Note: While the document presents this policy as a proactive measure to ensure asset resilience, the potential for maladaptation lies in the execution and prioritization of financial over community resilience considerations.

Question: In what ways does the plan measure the success or failure of each adaptation, resilience, and mitigation option? List any specific metrics used, such as reductions in CO2 emissions, improvements in air quality, or other quantifiable impacts. Identify the exact units (e.g., tons, percentages, index values) mentioned in the plan for tracking these outcomes. Additionally, outline any concrete goals or targets set for each option, including deadlines or specific numerical objectives.

Answer: Metrics and Targets for Tracking Success

The plan outlines several performance metrics and targets to measure the success of its adaptation, resilience, and mitigation options:

1. Carbon Emission Reduction

  • Metric: Reduction in carbon emissions
  • Target: Reduction from a Fiscal Year 2009-2010 baseline
  • Specific Goal: "Carbon emission reduction from a FY 2009-2010 baseline." (Tracking Progress)

2. Facility and Infrastructure Closures

  • Metric: Reduction in the number of City facility or infrastructure closures
  • Hazards Addressed: Flooding, extreme temperatures, wildfires, or landslides
  • Specific Goal: "Reduction in the number of City facility or infrastructure closures due to flooding, extreme temperatures, wildfires, or landslides over baseline." (Tracking Progress)

3. Budget Allocation

  • Metric: Funds allocated through the operating and Capital Improvement Program (CIP) budgets
  • Specific Goal: "Funds allocated through the operating and CIP budgets for sustainability and climate related projects." (Tracking Progress)

4. Sustainability Projects

  • Metric: Number of projects planned or implemented with a sustainability lens
  • Specific Goal: "Number of projects planned or implemented with a sustainability lens." (Tracking Progress)

5. Tree Canopy Ordinance

  • Metric: Number of trees preserved, planted, or paid annually
  • Specific Goal: "Number of trees preserved, planted, or paid annually through compliance with the Tree Canopy Ordinance." (Tracking Progress)

6. Edible and Pollinator Sites

  • Metric: Increase in the number of edible and pollinator sites
  • Specific Goal: "Increase in the number of edible and pollinator sites included on the Asheville Edibles Map." (Tracking Progress)

Concrete Goals or Targets

  • Goal 1: "City-Owned Assets Are Resilient, Sustainable, and Efficient"

    • Use 100% renewable energy for city-owned facilities
    • Enhance energy efficiency for city-owned facilities
    • Decarbonize fleet vehicles and fleet operations (Goals)
  • Goal 2: "Sustainability and Climate Priorities Are Embedded in City Operations, Participation, and Decision Making"

    • Embed sustainability, resilience, and equity in decision-making and planning
    • Identify opportunities to reduce waste generation and improve diversion (Goals)
  • Goal 3: "The City Supports Sustainability and Resilience for Area Residents and Businesses"

    • Collaborate on and support community-based solutions
    • Facilitate inclusive sustainability, climate, and resilience communications, education, and outreach (Goals)

Measurement and Evaluation The plan does not specify exact units (e.g., tons, percentages, index values) for these metrics, nor does it provide explicit deadlines or numerical objectives beyond those mentioned in the goals. The focus is on establishing and tracking progress through outlined performance measures and goals.

Question: Generate a table that summarizes the following features from the document: Location/City Name, Population, Threats Identified, Measures Identified

Answer:

| **Feature**           | **Details**                                                                                                                                               |
|-----------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| **Location/City Name**| City of Asheville                                                                                                                                         |
| **Population**        | Not specified in the document                                                                                                                             |
| **Threats Identified**| - Flooding                                                                                                                                                 |
|                       | - Extreme temperatures                                                                                                                                    |
|                       | - Wildfires                                                                                                                                                |
|                       | - Landslides                                                                                                                                              |
| **Measures Identified**| - Use 100% Renewable Energy for City-Owned Facilities                                                                                                     |
|                       | - Enhance Energy Efficiency for City-Owned Facilities                                                                                                      |
|                       | - Equip City Assets to Prevent, Withstand, and Recover From Disruptions                                                                                    |
|                       | - Decarbonize Fleet Vehicles and Fleet Operations                                                                                                          |
|                       | - Embed Sustainability, Resilience, and Equity in Decision-Making and Planning                                                                             |
|                       | - Identify Opportunities to Reduce Waste Generation and Improve Diversion                                                                                  |
|                       | - Collaborate On and Support Community-Based Solutions and Infrastructure Improvements                                                                     |
|                       | - Facilitate Inclusive Sustainability, Climate, and Resilience Communications, Education, and Outreach                                                       |