Datasets:

hitachi-nlp

/

proofwriter_processed_OWA

like 1

Follow

Hitachi, Ltd. 16

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and green and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and young and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 ((triple9 triple7 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent2": "Fred is too young to be so big; Some say he is too green to be so blue as well.", "sent3": "Gary is young, but very kind to others; Gary is big, with round features.", "sent4": "A big person who is green and cold has red skin.", "sent5": "Blue people who are rough are often young.", "sent6": "A person who is round shaped while also being quite cold tends to be nice.", "sent7": "A person who is very round is nice but also quite rough.", "sent8": "Young, kind people with a round body shape can be cold to strangers.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and red and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and red then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule3) OR ((triple9 triple6 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule7) OR ((((triple9 triple6 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule3)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule3)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Charlie wears all blue.", "sent2": "Dave is nice person, who was red colored due to a sunburn, was feeling rough because he is cold.", "sent3": "Big Eric is nice and red with sunburn and green hair.", "sent4": "Harry was looking rather round and feeling rather cold, but people thought he is kind.", "sent5": "Find a big human that is colored red and green and he will be amazingly kind.", "sent6": "Any cold, round, green person is going to be young at the same time.", "sent7": "If you are green you are also kind.", "sent8": "A person with the qualities of being cold and being red will also be a person that is green.", "sent9": "Whenever you see Pete you run into a young man rough, which means he will be nice.", "sent10": "People who are considered rough, blue, and nice, are also green.", "sent11": "Kind people, for example, like the ones at the bank are always blue." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and red and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and green and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and young and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple8 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple7) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple7) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "From a certain angle Bob is blue but he is young so maybe that will go away.", "sent2": "Charlie is interestingly colored red and blue, and is also very kind.", "sent3": "Fred wears all blue.", "sent4": "Gary is a very kind, green but sometimes cold person.", "sent5": "A big young person that is green will be cold to others.", "sent6": "Despite being kind cold people with red ears will still be big.", "sent7": "When someone is young they can be nice and kind, but green in society.", "sent8": "Someone who is colored both in red and green, while being kind to others, is a round person.", "sent9": "A green person that is cold is often considered to be red.", "sent10": "Anyone will tell you the kind and the big are also rough.", "sent11": "Young people who are nice and cold, are rather green." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is red and young and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((((triple3 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((((triple3 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent2": "Bob is round shaped and green colored.", "sent3": "Nice, but round, Dave has been said to be cold.", "sent4": "Eric is young, he is also red and green.", "sent5": "Big people who are red in color are often nice.", "sent6": "Round green people usually feel blue.", "sent7": "A green person that is cold is often considered to be red.", "sent8": "Looking blue can be a sign that someone is cold.", "sent9": "If a person is quite big and also round then they are certainly rough too.", "sent10": "People who are cold and and red are also young and kind.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and green and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is blue and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) ((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) ((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "From a certain angle Alan is blue but he is young so maybe that will go away.", "sent2": "Charlie is rough and cold, but he's young and will get over it.", "sent3": "When you talk about Eric, the first thing you notice is his rough and cold demeanor and then when you talk to him you find out how very nice he really is to everyone.", "sent4": "Harry is a rough man with a big heart who has red hair and a nice smile.", "sent5": "Nice people that are blue because they are cold turn green with envy.", "sent6": "A very kind and green colored person, who is also cold, will be nice.", "sent7": "Those who are nice but a bit rough around the edges are known for being blue.", "sent8": "All the big and young boys at the park are red.", "sent9": "A big and blue colored person is also certainly very kind.", "sent10": "If someone is feeling blue and round in shape they are usually nice.", "sent11": "A blue and green colored person will be round in shape." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and green and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple1) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple1) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3 triple1) -> rule5) ((((triple3 triple1) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3 triple1) -> rule5) ((((triple3 triple1) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "My friend Charlie is very young; People say he is nice for having a round shape.", "sent2": "Young, red Dave is nice.", "sent3": "Fred ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent4": "Gary always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "Nice green people and often blue with sadness.", "sent6": "If a human is both young and kind, they are also cold.", "sent7": "If a person that is kind is big and blue they have to be young.", "sent8": "A person that is round, green, and blue is usually considered cold.", "sent9": "A nice and young aged person will definitely be green in color.", "sent10": "Someone who is cold and big is also a red person.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and round and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and green and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule1) triple6 triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule1) triple6 triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple6 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent2": "Eric is a person both green and big.", "sent3": "Even though Fred is big and rough, he is nice; Fred often is blue and green with envy.", "sent4": "Someone who is round in shape and green in color is usually cold.", "sent5": "If a big, red person with a round figure comes up to you, don't worry, they will be very nice.", "sent6": "Because of circulation issues big people are often cold; If they are also green then they are certainly young.", "sent7": "You will discover that green rough people are always red.", "sent8": "A blue and green colored person will be round in shape.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and nice and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) triple5 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) triple5 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple8 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob loves cake which has made him quite round; Because he has been made fun of for quite some time, he has turned rough and cold towards others.", "sent2": "Charlie is cold and blue; He is round and has red rosy cheeks; He is green with envy of those who are happy.", "sent3": "Eric is known to be rough and green.", "sent4": "Because someone is green and kind they are extremely nice to people.", "sent5": "Red, kind, young people will be rough people, too.", "sent6": "If someone has a red face and feels blue and has a round body then you'll automatically think they are big.", "sent7": "If someone is green skinned and has a big nose then you'll find that they often are nice to their family.", "sent8": "People with rough red and blue skin are young.", "sent9": "Big people that tend to be nice and blue, may also be a little rough to others.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and red then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and nice and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3 triple5) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3 triple5) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3 triple5) -> rule5) triple2 triple4) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3 triple5) -> rule5) triple2 triple4) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent2": "Young Gary was known to be nice and kind, even though he was blue.", "sent3": "Others enjoy Harry's company because he is so nice and kind.", "sent4": "Young and nice people have great big smiles.", "sent5": "Red, big people can't help but be round as well.", "sent6": "A kind, cold, round person will be nice in addition.", "sent7": "A person with the qualities of being cold and being red will also be a person that is green.", "sent8": "Big people that tend to be nice and blue, may also be a little rough to others.", "sent9": "If you meet a young and kind person who is also rough, they are cold, too.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and blue and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and round and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and big and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and kind and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and big and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> rule7)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple1 triple5 ((triple3 triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Dave is a big young guy who is always nice even when feeling cold or blue; Today however he is looking green due to being ill.", "sent2": "Eric is a rough but very kind and blue person.", "sent3": "Fred ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent4": "When you meet Gary you'll the two characteristics that will standout is that he's red but also rough.", "sent5": "A cold, rough person is also round.", "sent6": "Young people with red skin who are a bit downhearted and blue are kind.", "sent7": "A red colored and round person who is also young will be rather kind.", "sent8": "Big and cold people tend to see red and dont live green lifestyle.", "sent9": "Nice and kind people tend to live green lifestyle and arent very rough.", "sent10": "A kind person with green and red skin must be big too.", "sent11": "A big, green person who is cold is assumed to be red also." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and big and nice then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> rule2) ((triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> rule2) ((triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule6) ((triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> rule2) ((triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule6) ((triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is big and round man that is looking rather green after seeing some bad mayonnaise.", "sent2": "There's a very big man over there who is green to this situation that seems to be rather cold despite his bright red coat named Eric.", "sent3": "Gary was looking rather round and feeling rather cold, but people thought he is kind.", "sent4": "When you meet someone round, blue and nice they are as a rule rough.", "sent5": "Big people who are red in color are often nice.", "sent6": "Kind and young people are round.", "sent7": "If you are green you are also kind.", "sent8": "If someone is young at heart and has big toes as well as being nice to others then you'll see that they are also kind to children.", "sent9": "Anyone that is nice and kind and also green will usually be young as well.", "sent10": "If a rather cold person is also kind then they are probably rough.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2) -> rule1) triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule1)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule1)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is a person who is young and also rough; He's also someone who is big and blue.", "sent2": "They always call him rough Dave.", "sent3": "Fred is round shaped and green colored.", "sent4": "Gary always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "Young and rough people tend to be green too.", "sent6": "Look for the blue and green people, they are kind and will give you directions if you're lost.", "sent7": "Nice, green people that are somewhat round are big through the shoulders.", "sent8": "Anyone that is nice and kind and also green will usually be young as well.", "sent9": "You will discover that green rough people are always red.", "sent10": "Rough people will often be blue; They thrive on being kind and nice.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and round and cold then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is red and green and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and round and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple8 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) ((triple9) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple8 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) ((triple9) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple8 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) ((triple9) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6) triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple8 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) ((triple9) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6) triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1 triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple9 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Nice, but round, Bob has been said to be cold.", "sent2": "Most people consider Charlie to bed red; He's pretty cold to people and often feels blue; Charlie is a big person.", "sent3": "Upon meeting Dave, you'll notice he's green and kind.", "sent4": "Red Eric is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent5": "A round person who is nice is young.", "sent6": "When young, round people are cold it their skin gets a blue tinge to it.", "sent7": "A kind person that is also red and rough is usually also nice.", "sent8": "Any green person is a round person.", "sent9": "A quite nice person who is red and green is also big.", "sent10": "A young round person who is green is also red.", "sent11": "Kind people,though green,tend to be nice." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and blue and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and young and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and green and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple6 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple5 ((triple4 triple3 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is blue and cold.", "sent2": "Dave associated himself with green despite being covered head-to-toe in blue; Him being young and kind preceded him.", "sent3": "Eric is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent4": "Harry, like all young people, is nice.", "sent5": "A big person who also feels blue and a bit green are usually wearing red.", "sent6": "Kind, young, green persons are sure to be rough persons, too.", "sent7": "If you are big and young then your are also nice.", "sent8": "Blue people round with fat are red from too much time in the sun.", "sent9": "Invariably, any young person whose skin appears rough and green is bound to be quite big.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple4) -> rule3) OR ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple6 triple5) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule3) OR ((((triple6 triple5) -> rule5) ((triple5 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple2) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple2) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple2) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule7) triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple8 ((triple8) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule7)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple2 ((triple2) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule7) triple3) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple2 ((triple2) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule7)) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple2 ((triple2) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule7) triple3) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple2 ((triple2) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule7)) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple10 ((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple2 ((triple2) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple3) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent2": "Charlie who is considered nice was feeling rather rough today.", "sent3": "Dave is young and big in stature; He is cold but nice.", "sent4": "The diving trip left Eric red and green all over, yet he remains the nice (though rather rough) guy he always has been.", "sent5": "Rough people are often round.", "sent6": "A person with a rough quality is also a person with a blue quality.", "sent7": "A big, young human being is sure to also be a green human being.", "sent8": "A nice and cold person can be counted on to be a young person at the same time.", "sent9": "People who are cold to others can also be nice and when they are it's a sure bet they are being big about it.", "sent10": "Kind people who are also rough are young.", "sent11": "A human being described as rough, nice and round will also fit the description of being cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and green and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple11) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple7 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple7 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule7 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is kind and round; Being round makes him a bit blue.", "sent2": "Charlie was known for being kind, a bit big and round and for playing rough when he was young.", "sent3": "To the touch Eric has rough, cold skin.", "sent4": "Because Fred gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent5": "A rough textured and cold person is definitely young.", "sent6": "Blue Christmas ornaments are also red.", "sent7": "When you meet big guys with red hair, then tend to be cold hearted.", "sent8": "Young people that are also red and green, may be fairly rough, also.", "sent9": "Anyone who's blue is also green.", "sent10": "A kind, young human will also be a blue human.", "sent11": "Those who are round and cold are young." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and nice and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule5) triple9) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4) ((triple10 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4) ((triple10 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple7 triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "That guy Alan is big, but he's always kind to little ones.", "sent2": "Charlie is big and rough.", "sent3": "Even though he's a big dude, Fred is cold.", "sent4": "Blue with the cold Harry is rough but kind with a green shirt.", "sent5": "Nice people who have red cold skin are round.", "sent6": "Nice, green people that are somewhat round are big through the shoulders.", "sent7": "Any cold, round, green person is going to be young at the same time.", "sent8": "When you meet someone with cold, rough skin and a round figure they will be nice.", "sent9": "You can see that cold, blue people are round in shape.", "sent10": "A big and rough person who is blue is also considered to be green.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and cold and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and nice and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and nice then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple8 triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple8 triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "20", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule6) ((((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> rule2) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule6) ((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "20", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule6) ((((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> rule2) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule6) ((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple9 triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "That big rough Bob guy is both red and blue at the same time.", "sent2": "Even though Fred is rough, he nice but cold and blue.", "sent3": "Because Harry is so young, he is rough and cold when he can be round instead.", "sent4": "Nice and blue people have to be big as well.", "sent5": "A person who is described as young and cold, but also described as rough is nice.", "sent6": "People who are rough around the edges, nice, and a bit blue are young.", "sent7": "A big blue someone could also be green.", "sent8": "If red and slightly green people are asked, they will tell you they feel blue.", "sent9": "Round, young folks tend to feel blue.", "sent10": "Nice green people who feel blue are often red in color.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and red and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and round and kind then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6) triple3 ((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple3 ((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6) triple3 ((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple3 ((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple3 ((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple3 ((triple1 ((triple5 triple3 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent3", "rule2": "sent4", "rule3": "sent5", "rule4": "sent6", "rule5": "sent7", "rule6": "sent8", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob lives at home with his parents who tell him he is too young to live on his own; Bob is a big blue guy with red rings around his ankles and rough patchy skin; Bob is always cold inside or out.", "sent2": "Eric was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent3": "You will probably see that red, round people are nice, as well as green.", "sent4": "Being a young, round and kind individual means that you are also a blue individual.", "sent5": "People who are round and young are also quite nice.", "sent6": "People who are kind and green are very often rough.", "sent7": "Being green and rough are signs that someone is big.", "sent8": "Someone that is red and blue because they are cold are also round.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and big and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and red and cold then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and young and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule3) triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule3) triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob had big, red, round cheeks.", "sent2": "Charlie is big and rough.", "sent3": "Gary is interestingly colored red and blue, and is also very kind.", "sent4": "Harry is young and round, he is also green.", "sent5": "A green, downhearted, and blue person with red cheeks is big.", "sent6": "Big and green people who feel cold are usually young in age.", "sent7": "If the person is big and cold then as a rule they must be green.", "sent8": "Any rather round person exposed to weather that leaves them red and cold will feel blue.", "sent9": "When you meet big guys with red hair, then tend to be cold hearted.", "sent10": "Kind young people that are still blue are generally round shaped.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and green and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9 OR ((triple7 triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple9) -> rule1)) -> rule7) triple7) -> rule2) OR ((((((((triple7 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule1)) -> rule7) triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9) -> rule1) OR ((((triple7 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule1)) -> rule7) OR ((((((triple7 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule1)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule1)) -> rule7) OR ((((((triple7 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule1)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule7) triple1) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule7) triple1) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule1 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule1 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave is rough around the edges, but he's often blue and always nice.", "sent2": "Upon meeting Eric, you'll notice he's green and kind.", "sent3": "Fred is young and green, so although he is rough and blue with sadness, he'll grow out of it.", "sent4": "Blue Christmas ornaments are also red.", "sent5": "A person who is described as round and rough is usually kind.", "sent6": "Young people who rough around in the cold are known to be very red.", "sent7": "A green colored, nice and young person will be big shaped.", "sent8": "Rough young folks are surprisingly kind.", "sent9": "A green and quite rough person will also be blue.", "sent10": "A person that is the color red will definitely be round shaped.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and big and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young Bob got into a fight that left him with red sores on his face.", "sent2": "Big Dave, the most blue guy I know while also being cold.", "sent3": "Gary was in a chemistry lab accident and turned blue and green which is even more obvious due to his round figure.", "sent4": "They always call him rough Harry.", "sent5": "A person with rough skin who has been standing in the cold will turn red.", "sent6": "Blue people who are big tend to be rough.", "sent7": "Color anybody red and blue, then make them rough, and they will surely be round.", "sent8": "People who are nice, big, and also rough, are considered red.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "They always call him rough Eric.", "sent2": "Others enjoy Fred's company because he is so nice and kind.", "sent3": "Gary is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent4": "Harry is red from working out in the sun all day; he is green with envy that others get to work inside all day and this makes him feel blue; But Harry is big and young so he can handle it.", "sent5": "If someone is cold and young, you'll see that they are kind.", "sent6": "Fat, round people who are green with envy and notoriously rough.", "sent7": "Young and nice people have great big smiles.", "sent8": "Maybe someone is rough and blue with the cold.", "sent9": "I've noticed that someone who is big and acts cold towards others is green as well.", "sent10": "Someone blue and red is definitely round and dressed as a clown.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and round and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple9 ((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple9 ((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple9 ((((triple8 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple9 ((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple9 ((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Even though Alan is young, he is still very round and still very red.", "sent2": "Charlie always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent3": "Dave is green, which is a possible explanation for why he is so nice.", "sent4": "Eric is a person who is young and also rough; He's also someone who is big and blue.", "sent5": "Everyone that is rough but also kind will be green.", "sent6": "Any person who is blue and round, if they are kind at the same time, will be young.", "sent7": "In every case of people being kind and blue and green, we find they are concurrently nice.", "sent8": "When you know someone who is young and green you can count on them being nice to everyone.", "sent9": "If you find that someone has rough blue skin they are always kind.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "18", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple6 ((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "18", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple6 ((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple7 triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent4", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Because Dave gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Eric, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "Gary was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent4": "Harry was feeling red with anger after the fight, but he was still a nice but big human being.", "sent5": "Nice people that are blue because they are cold turn green with envy.", "sent6": "Though they were big and nice, they simultaneously were rough and aloof and seemed cold to others.", "sent7": "I've been told that big, nice people are very rough.", "sent8": "Anyone that's rough and cold is also going to be blue.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and green and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> rule4) OR ((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) OR ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) OR ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1) OR ((((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1) OR ((((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple8 triple5 triple6) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave is round shaped and green colored.", "sent2": "Eric is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent3": "Fred is big and green, which is good, because he is also cold and blue.", "sent4": "Harry is blue and cold.", "sent5": "Someone who looks rough and feels cold is also kind to others.", "sent6": "A cold temperatured and green colored person who is also big will be young.", "sent7": "A male or female with rough, kind and round traits will surely have a nice quality, as well.", "sent8": "If you meet a person who is green, big and blue, you will find them to be nice.", "sent9": "If you are big and young then your are also nice.", "sent10": "Nice people who are big in stature often look rough.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and red and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and nice and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and green then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "27", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule6) ((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule4) ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "27", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule6) ((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule4) ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple6 triple8 ((triple8 triple6 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie looks red to most people, with blue features.", "sent2": "Dave is known to be rough and green.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Eric.", "sent4": "Harry has green teeth and rough skin; People also notice his blue eyes.", "sent5": "Big round people who wear red clothing will also wear a lot of green jewelry.", "sent6": "Rough and cold and blue people are round.", "sent7": "I know anyone I meet who is big, nice, and round will be young.", "sent8": "Rough, round persons are also nice persons.", "sent9": "If somebody has the characteristics of being blue, rough and green, they are also going to be cold.", "sent10": "A blue, rough and round person will also be a big person.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and kind and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is big and rough.", "sent2": "Even though Dave is big and round, he is cold much of the time.", "sent3": "Eric was cold as his rough hands clung to the side of the ship, green with nausea; Even through the worst of it he was still kind.", "sent4": "Fred gets red when he is mad and tends to act very cold.", "sent5": "A red colored person who is kind and feels cold is usually considered nice.", "sent6": "Big people that are cold will show you how rough they actually are.", "sent7": "A nice person who is always seen to be wearing green clothes will be rather big in size.", "sent8": "A person with a rough quality is also a person with a blue quality.", "sent9": "A cold and blue appearing person will be young as well.", "sent10": "Nice people who are green and red will also have round shapes.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and round and young then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and round then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5 OR ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5) -> rule4) OR ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5) -> rule4) OR ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5) OR ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5) OR ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple4 triple6) -> rule3) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple4 triple6) -> rule3) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple4 triple6) -> rule3) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple4 triple6) -> rule3) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4)) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 ((triple7 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent2": "Eric is a big young guy who is always nice even when feeling cold or blue; Today however he is looking green due to being ill.", "sent3": "Fred is very nice to people, but he's also rather big.", "sent4": "Harry always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "Young round folks who are at least a bit red are actually nice.", "sent6": "A person with a rough quality is also a person with a blue quality.", "sent7": "Green and blue, when found in one person, signify someone who is cold.", "sent8": "Big and cold people are likely to be round, too.", "sent9": "Green eyed people are often nice, but when they are also round about the middle they are most certainly kind.", "sent10": "If a rather cold person is also kind then they are probably rough.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is too young to be so big; Some say he is too green to be so blue as well.", "sent2": "Young Fred is wearing green pants.", "sent3": "Harry is a nice person who is red because he has a rash.", "sent4": "Blue and red people are often rough.", "sent5": "If someone is green skinned and has a big nose then you'll find that they often are nice to their family.", "sent6": "Big and cold people are likely to be round, too.", "sent7": "A round shaped and red person is definitely nice.", "sent8": "Young and nice people are ultimately cold.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and young and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule5) OR ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule5) OR ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule3) OR ((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule3) OR ((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Kind young Bob is also a nice person that became red and green from painting Christmas decorations.", "sent2": "Fred grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent3": "Harry is a kind and red colored guy.", "sent4": "Surprisingly, all the kind, green people were also big.", "sent5": "Young, round, and cold people have a habit of looking pretty red.", "sent6": "When a nice blue person is also red, they get called rough.", "sent7": "Being big and kind like a gentle giant can make anyone blue.", "sent8": "Young people that are big in size, tend to be more on the blue side.", "sent9": "People who are considered rough, blue, and nice, are also green.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and big and round then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and rough and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple4) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple4) -> rule1) triple3 ((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule1)) -> rule2)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3 ((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple4) -> rule1) triple3 ((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule1)) -> rule2)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3 ((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3 ((triple4 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob who is considered nice was feeling rather rough today.", "sent2": "Others enjoy Dave's company because he is so nice and kind.", "sent3": "When you meet Eric you'll the two characteristics that will standout is that he's red but also rough.", "sent4": "That guy Gary is big, but he's always kind to little ones.", "sent5": "Someone can be very nice and kind, and this means they are also green.", "sent6": "Whenever you are around kind and green people, you will notice they are very red.", "sent7": "Big and round people who arent cold, tend to be very kind.", "sent8": "Young and rough green people, have no choice but to be red.", "sent9": "A nice person who is always seen to be wearing green clothes will be rather big in size.", "sent10": "Rough people who are nice and have green thumbs are almost always young.", "sent11": "A green and red colored person who has a nice temperament will be cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple7) -> rule5) OR ((((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule1) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule7) OR ((((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule1) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 ((((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 ((triple8 ((triple8 triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan has a round face and is very nice.", "sent2": "Fred has a round face and is very nice.", "sent3": "Gary ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent4": "Harry is made of many colors, red and blue and green; He is also rough and cold.", "sent5": "A kind person that is also red and rough is usually also nice.", "sent6": "I've noticed that kind people are also big.", "sent7": "Big people that are cold will show you how rough they actually are.", "sent8": "A green colored person will be young and also kind.", "sent9": "Someone blue and red is definitely round and dressed as a clown.", "sent10": "Being green, blue, and red all point to how young someone was.", "sent11": "A very nice and kind person will also be round shaped." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and round then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple3 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple3 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple3 triple2) -> rule2) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple3 triple2) -> rule2) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple3 triple2) -> rule2) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple3 triple2) -> rule2) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent2": "Nice, but round, Dave has been said to be cold.", "sent3": "Because Eric gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent4": "They always call him rough Fred.", "sent5": "Anybody that is big is also someone who is going to be blue.", "sent6": "Green eyed people are often nice, but when they are also round about the middle they are most certainly kind.", "sent7": "People who are nice and cold are also green.", "sent8": "Most kind and cold people are also big.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and green and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and young and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6) -> rule6) triple6 ((triple9 ((triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6 ((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6) -> rule6) triple6 ((triple9 ((triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6 ((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple10 triple5 ((((triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6 ((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple5 ((((triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6 ((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6 ((triple9 ((triple6) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent2": "Fred was looking rather round and feeling rather cold, but people thought he is kind.", "sent3": "Harry is red but has turned blue as he is cold but now he is green; Harry is young and rough.", "sent4": "Red people feel blue about it.", "sent5": "Despite being too big with bright green skin and freezing cold, these people have always been kind.", "sent6": "As far as anyone can tell, whoever is kind, rough, and big is a round person.", "sent7": "Somebody fitting a young, blue and round description will also fit a green description.", "sent8": "Someone who is nice, green, and cold, is always going to be young.", "sent9": "People who are rough are often rather kind as well.", "sent10": "If you run into a cold and kind person, they are always big.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and cold and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and big and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule1) ((triple3 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule1) ((triple3 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent3", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent4", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Red Bob is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent2": "They always call him rough Charlie.", "sent3": "Eric is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent4": "Harry, who is a very nice man, is also quite round in shape; He found himself quite blue from being made fun of him, but that also made his face red with anger.", "sent5": "Big, young people feel cold all the time.", "sent6": "Kind, rough people who are nice are also cold.", "sent7": "Someone can be young, big, and cold but green.", "sent8": "A big and rough person can be misleading because they are cold and blue as well.", "sent9": "If a person is young and very kind then they will be rather big.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and young and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and red and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and big then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple6 ((triple4 triple5 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Bob is rough and cold, but he's young and will get over it.", "sent2": "Young Eric is kind and perpetually cold, especially during the winter holidays when he is green and red.", "sent3": "Gary always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent4": "Harry had big, red, round cheeks.", "sent5": "Young, green round people are big.", "sent6": "Round, blue, and green people are poften rough.", "sent7": "A young aged blue person will certainly be nice.", "sent8": "People who are young, while being red and cold, are big people.", "sent9": "Someone being both nice and kind means that they are a big person.", "sent10": "When someone is big with rough skin they will look red.", "sent11": "Someone who is big and kind is blue." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and nice and cold then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and big and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> rule2) triple11) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> rule2) triple11) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple12 ((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> rule2) triple11) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple12 ((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple12 ((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> rule2) triple11) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple12 ((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple12 ((triple10 ((triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Young Bob got into a fight that left him with red sores on his face.", "sent2": "Charlie is round shaped and green colored.", "sent3": "Gary was feeling red with anger after the fight, but he was still a nice but big human being.", "sent4": "Harry is big, round, rough and cold, but Harry can also be nice.", "sent5": "A round person who is nice and feelin cold is usually rough in apperance.", "sent6": "If the person is big and cold then as a rule they must be green.", "sent7": "A big blue someone could also be green.", "sent8": "If someone has a red face and feels blue and has a round body then you'll automatically think they are big.", "sent9": "If a young person knows he is big and round, then he will be blue.", "sent10": "Someone who is nice, green, and cold, is always going to be young.", "sent11": "Anyone who's blue is also green." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and young and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 ((triple6 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "To be young and red like Alan is pretty nice, which Green Alan is also.", "sent2": "Bob ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "For someone so round, Gary turns blue when he's cold; No wonder he's so rough and red with anger all the time.", "sent4": "A big person who looks blue is also going to look young.", "sent5": "Anyone who is round and also cold will surely be big as well.", "sent6": "A person who is cold, rough and young is also nice.", "sent7": "A nice person who is downhearted, blue, and green with envy is rough.", "sent8": null, "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and young and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and red and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is red and young and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule2) OR ((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7) triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule2) OR ((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7) triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7) triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7) triple4 ((triple6) -> rule5)) -> rule3)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple6) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple4 ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple6) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan wears all blue.", "sent2": "Bob is young, rough and green, but he is also kind and is red when embarrassed.", "sent3": "Fred is a person both green and big.", "sent4": "Harry is a red person who is round and also feels blue.", "sent5": "If a kind person is also young and round shaped, they will be colored blue.", "sent6": "It is true that kind people who have become cold and blue and survived are necessarily big.", "sent7": "Cold, red people are generally kind and big.", "sent8": "Like a blueberry, a big blue person is round as anything.", "sent9": "People that feel green are cold to people that try to help them.", "sent10": "When anyone is young, red and green, you know they'll also be blue.", "sent11": "If you find that someone has rough blue skin they are always kind." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and nice then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and kind and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and round and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a person who is young and also rough; He's also someone who is big and blue.", "sent2": "Charlie's a round guy, and a red and green guy.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Eric.", "sent4": "My friend Fred is very young; People say he is nice for having a round shape.", "sent5": "Being round and nice automatically means a person is kind.", "sent6": "Big, kind people that are rough are known for being red.", "sent7": "Any person who is blue and round, if they are kind at the same time, will be young.", "sent8": "When someone is blue, lives green they can be rough but kind.", "sent9": "I believe that red, cold, rough people are likely to be green.", "sent10": "A big and rough person who is blue is also considered to be green.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and nice then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and young and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) OR ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) OR ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7) OR ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7) OR ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) OR ((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) OR ((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule7)) -> rule1) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is a nice person who is red because he has a rash.", "sent2": "Dave is young and green round guy, and that keeps him from being cold; He has stayed kind.", "sent3": "Fred is rough, but often feels blue; He is pretty young.", "sent4": "Harry was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent5": "A round and nice person will certainly have a red tint to them.", "sent6": "It seems to be that a person who is green, red, and blue will be very big.", "sent7": "A nice green person that tends to be rough will indeed be round too.", "sent8": "A kind and cold person who is green is, surprisingly, also blue.", "sent9": "Folks who are nice and young with red coloration tend to feel blue.", "sent10": "When you meet kind people they wont have a cold heart.", "sent11": "They found the ones that were round, blue, and green to be nice." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and round and cold then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and red and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and rough and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1) triple3 triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1) triple3 triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is young, but very kind to others; Charlie is big, with round features.", "sent2": "Dave gets red when he is mad and tends to act very cold.", "sent3": "Gary is blue from ink he spilled on himself while being kind and helping some children paint.", "sent4": "Blue and green Harry is so kind he snowplows the neighbors driveways and everyone thanks him with beer.", "sent5": "When young, round people are cold it their skin gets a blue tinge to it.", "sent6": "People with red hair, rough skin and big teeth manage to be nice to people.", "sent7": "Pick someone blue, kind and big, and they are certain to be green as well.", "sent8": "People who are rough are young.", "sent9": "Big and round people can't help but be cold all of the time.", "sent10": "Big people who are round in stature and also feel rough are often cold to other people.", "sent11": "Someone who has rough nails and blue teeth as well as being kind to adults are often noted to having big fingers." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and rough and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and round and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5) -> rule6) triple4 triple7) -> rule4) OR ((((triple5) -> rule6) triple5 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule6) triple9 triple10) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9) -> rule6) triple9 triple10) -> rule3) triple8 ((triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9) -> rule6) triple9 triple10) -> rule3) triple8 ((triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave was in a chemistry lab accident and turned blue and green which is even more obvious due to his round figure.", "sent2": "Eric is fat; so he appears big and round; Eric is also nice and kind to everyone that he meets.", "sent3": "Fred is big and rough looking but is very nice and kind.", "sent4": "It seems to be that a person who is green, red, and blue will be very big.", "sent5": "Young and rough green people, have no choice but to be red.", "sent6": "Anyone that is nice and kind and also green will usually be young as well.", "sent7": "Most green and round people,though big are quite young.", "sent8": "Among cold people, those who are round and kind are also rough.", "sent9": "Julie is really nice to gardeners since she has a green thumb.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and rough and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and young and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4 OR ((triple5 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple11 triple9) -> rule3) triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple11 triple9) -> rule3) triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple9 ((((triple11 triple9) -> rule3) triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple9 ((((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple9 ((((triple11 triple9) -> rule3) triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple9 ((((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule1 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple9 ((((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is very young to be a nurse but he loves helping others because he is so nice and kind.", "sent2": "Being new to the job, Eric is nice and green; Even though he is round he is red and cold out in the wind.", "sent3": "Harry is a cold young man; He is prone the being blue with sadness because he is green with envy.", "sent4": "Big, young people feel cold all the time.", "sent5": "If you see someone who is red and green they are round, like Santa Claus.", "sent6": "A young and cold person is red.", "sent7": "A kind and green person who is rough around the edges is cold.", "sent8": "Blue, young and round people are usually big.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and rough then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple1) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple1) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 ((triple1) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple1) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 ((triple1) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple1) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "From a certain angle Alan is blue but he is young so maybe that will go away.", "sent2": "Charlie's skin turned blue and green in a lab accident; Despite his outward appearance, he is really nice.", "sent3": "Fred is a nice person who is red because he has a rash.", "sent4": "Young Gary is kind and perpetually cold, especially during the winter holidays when he is green and red.", "sent5": "Though they were big and nice, they simultaneously were rough and aloof and seemed cold to others.", "sent6": "All the big and young boys at the park are red.", "sent7": "When you know someone who's red, rough and nice, you'll also see that they're cold.", "sent8": "There are so many rough, young people and for some reason they are all big too.", "sent9": "A person that is rough and round shaped features are going to be red.", "sent10": "Young people are rough.", "sent11": "Big kind people are usually cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and rough and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule5) OR ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule5) OR ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule3) OR ((triple2 ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule6) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule3) OR ((triple2 ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule6) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple5 triple2 ((triple6 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent2": "Bob is big in stature, blue from the cold, has red hair and is kind.", "sent3": "Dave was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent4": "Young Fred is wearing green pants.", "sent5": "A kind and big person is young.", "sent6": "Round people who feel rough also always feel cold,.", "sent7": "If someone has a red complexion that is rough and feels blue then you'll see they are rather nice.", "sent8": "Like a blueberry, a big blue person is round as anything.", "sent9": "If a person is quite big and also round then they are certainly rough too.", "sent10": "Blue and red people who are young always have rough skin.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and young then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and round then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue and young then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is young and big and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "14", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple4 triple2) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule1) OR ((triple2 ((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple4 triple2) -> rule6) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple2) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((((((((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple2) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob wears all blue.", "sent2": "Though he is young, Charlie is still nice despite being quite blue.", "sent3": "Due to the fact that Fred is young, he is red and green; He remains kind nevertheless.", "sent4": "A kind, round person will surely be red as well.", "sent5": "Someone who has a a young round face is often rough around the edges.", "sent6": "A person with nice, blue traits who is young will surely be a round person.", "sent7": "Everyone who manages to be both rough and round are also kind.", "sent8": "If you meet someone who is red and blue with a round shape, you can count on them being nice to you.", "sent9": "Kind and blue people,though young,tend to be big.", "sent10": "Anyone who's got young, round and big traits is bound to have a red trait, too.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and nice and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and nice and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4 OR ((((triple5) -> rule5) triple6) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple5) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple5) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple5) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple5) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple5) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple5) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent2": "Because Fred gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent3": "Gary is too young to be so big; Some say he is too green to be so blue as well.", "sent4": "Harry is a very kind, green but sometimes cold person.", "sent5": "A big person who is red and nice to others is also young.", "sent6": "If you meet a young, round person who is nice on the street, offer them your coat because they are cold.", "sent7": "If you see someone who is red and green they are round, like Santa Claus.", "sent8": "A green person who is kind and a bit blue is young.", "sent9": "People that feel green are cold to people that try to help them.", "sent10": "A cold and blue appearing person will be young as well.", "sent11": "Someone who is cold and big is also a red person." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple12)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule6) triple4 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule6) ((triple9) -> rule4) ((triple10 ((triple9) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple10 ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule6) ((triple9) -> rule4) ((triple10 ((triple9) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple10 ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple10 ((triple9) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Big Bob is still young so it's easy for him to be kind.", "sent2": "Dave is big and rough.", "sent3": "Fred is very young with red hair and green eyes and very nice; Fred is cold most of the times where he lives.", "sent4": "Gary gets red when he is mad and tends to act very cold.", "sent5": "As far as anyone can tell, whoever is kind, rough, and big is a round person.", "sent6": "If you meet a person who is green, big and blue, you will find them to be nice.", "sent7": "Being cold and blue made them rough to deal with.", "sent8": "A green person is going to be rough.", "sent9": "Anyone who is round and also cold will surely be big as well.", "sent10": "People who are rough are often rather kind as well.", "sent11": "A cold temperatured and rough person who is also green will be big shaped." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and young and nice then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and young and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Even though Alan is green with envy he is nice with rosy red cheeks.", "sent2": "Bob is very young to be a nurse but he loves helping others because he is so nice and kind.", "sent3": "Dave is round shaped and green colored.", "sent4": "Fred has a round face and is very nice.", "sent5": "A round person who is nice is young.", "sent6": "A person who is in school because of their young age with a round body and the constant desire to be nice will be feeling blue.", "sent7": "Young people that are red for any reason, may also act in a rough manner, but don't be surprised if they are ultimately blue.", "sent8": "It's just a fact that a blue person is a kind person.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and kind and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and green then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule1) OR ((((triple3 ((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule6) ((((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule1) OR ((((triple3 ((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule6) ((((triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple4) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave is a rather big guy with rough features; He's pretty red and green, most of the time.", "sent2": "Because Eric gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent3": "Fred is nice, even when he is rough and red with anger.", "sent4": "Others enjoy Harry's company because he is so nice and kind.", "sent5": "Red, kind, rough people are the young ones.", "sent6": "Anybody that is big is also someone who is going to be blue.", "sent7": "Big, rough people sometimes are also green and when they are they must be cold.", "sent8": "Someone who is blue and cold is also big.", "sent9": "It's just a fact that a blue person is a kind person.", "sent10": "It's true that green and blue people are also red people.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and big and nice then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and nice and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) OR ((((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) OR ((((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) triple2 triple3) -> rule5) OR ((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) triple2 triple3) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) triple2 triple3) -> rule5) OR ((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) triple2 triple3) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule4)) -> rule7) ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple1 ((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young Charlie has red, rough skin, but is nice and kind.", "sent2": "Dave grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent3": "Fred is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent4": "Harry is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent5": "Their actions reflected how young and kind but green they were making things seem blue.", "sent6": "A kind, young person will be rough textured.", "sent7": "If someone is young at heart and has big toes as well as being nice to others then you'll see that they are also kind to children.", "sent8": "Red haired people who are nice and kind are looked up to because they are always big.", "sent9": "You will always find a cold, rough, red person to also be a round person.", "sent10": "Big people who at the same time are cold hearted and nice are a conundrum but they are also kind.", "sent11": "When someone is big, young and rough, they can be cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5) -> rule2) ((((((triple5) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1) triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5) -> rule2) ((((((triple5) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1) triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple5) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "That Alan is as round and red as a cherry, and twice as kind.", "sent2": "Bob had big, red, round cheeks.", "sent3": "From a certain angle Charlie is blue but he is young so maybe that will go away.", "sent4": "Eric is a nice person, but he is both blue and red.", "sent5": "A person that is both green and red tends to be cold as well.", "sent6": "Red people feel blue about it.", "sent7": "A big blue someone could also be green.", "sent8": "If someone is kind to others and cold to others as well as being red faced then you'll find that they often have a round body.", "sent9": "Anyone that is nice and kind and also green will usually be young as well.", "sent10": "Kind people who look green are almost always young in age.", "sent11": "People that are blue, cold, and big, are rather rough." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is red and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple3) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> rule2) triple10) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> rule2) triple10) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 ((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> rule2) triple10) -> rule3) ((triple11 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 ((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> rule2) triple10) -> rule3) ((triple11 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple9 ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple11 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a kind but rough man who is red from a sunburn, He is rather green in appearance after looking at some rotten fish.", "sent2": "Red Bob is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent3": "Eric is rough, but often feels blue; He is pretty young.", "sent4": "Fred happens to be nice and green even though he is big and cold.", "sent5": "Anyone in the world who is nice, red, and young, is simultaneously rough.", "sent6": "Cold, green people have a habit of eating alot and looking quite round.", "sent7": "Green people here that are also round and nice are always rough.", "sent8": "Kind people who are also rough are young.", "sent9": "Whenever somebody can be described as rough, round and cold, they can also be described as young.", "sent10": "Red and round people will be cold even in the summer.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and red and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 ((((triple1 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule6)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 ((((triple1 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule6)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Others enjoy Bob's company because he is so nice and kind.", "sent2": "Dave has a round face and is very nice.", "sent3": "Eric is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent4": "They always call him rough Gary.", "sent5": "Kind people that are rough and round are also considered big.", "sent6": "Lucky for us, people that are round and red are kind to strangers.", "sent7": "A kind, cold, round person will be nice in addition.", "sent8": "Despite being kind cold people with red ears will still be big.", "sent9": "Someone being both nice and kind means that they are a big person.", "sent10": "Big people are also round people.", "sent11": "Anyone who is known to be kind, nice, and round is generally also known to be a green color." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and green and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and young and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 ((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 ((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 ((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 ((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 ((triple7 triple6 triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a cold young man; He is prone the being blue with sadness because he is green with envy.", "sent2": "Dave is a round fellow, but he is kind, even when he is so cold he turns blue.", "sent3": "Big, red Eric is quite kind.", "sent4": "A very kind and green colored person, who is also cold, will be nice.", "sent5": "Color anybody red and blue, then make them rough, and they will surely be round.", "sent6": "Round people are often red before they turn green.", "sent7": "Kind people who are blue with sadness and cold toward others are surprisingly red.", "sent8": "A person who is young and cold and green is kind.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and red and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and green and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and young and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple7) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple7) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is very cold but acts in a kind way to everyone despite being totally green here when he wears his red jacket.", "sent2": "Eric wears all blue.", "sent3": "Red Fred is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent4": "Harry is nice person, who was red colored due to a sunburn, was feeling rough because he is cold.", "sent5": "You will probably see that red, round people are nice, as well as green.", "sent6": "Rough people are often round.", "sent7": "A quite nice person who is red and green is also big.", "sent8": "Young, kind people have the trait of being cold and are also very nice to interact with.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple9 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple9 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9 ((triple9 triple8 triple7) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Red Bob is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent2": "Young, red Fred is nice.", "sent3": "Gary is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent4": "Harry is round in the middle and extraordinarily nice but he's also blue because people don't always treat him well.", "sent5": "When you meet someone round, blue and nice they are as a rule rough.", "sent6": "Someone who feels blue with rough skin is also kind and will be young.", "sent7": "A person who is described as round and rough is usually kind.", "sent8": "Someone blue who is round with bloating and red from sunburn is surely cold from having fallen into the lake.", "sent9": "A kind and nice person who is looking green is often red.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and round and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple1) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple1) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple1) -> rule7) triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple1) -> rule7) triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple1) -> rule7) ((((triple3 triple1) -> rule7) triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple1) -> rule7) ((((triple3 triple1) -> rule7) triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young, red Alan is nice.", "sent2": "Bob ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "Gary was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent4": "Others enjoy Harry's company because he is so nice and kind.", "sent5": "If someone is kind to others and cold to others as well as being red faced then you'll find that they often have a round body.", "sent6": "If a big, red person with a round figure comes up to you, don't worry, they will be very nice.", "sent7": "A person who is cold with a red nose will be feeling blue.", "sent8": "Red and kind people always seem to be big as well.", "sent9": "Being cold and blue made them rough to deal with.", "sent10": "Nice people who are looking green and seeing red usually feel rather rough.", "sent11": "A person that is both nice and young will also be cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule6) ((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule6) ((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple10 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent2": "People who know Charlie know he's red, kind, young, cold, blue and big.", "sent3": "In the snow sits Fred, crying from being cold.", "sent4": "Harry is a rough but very kind and blue person.", "sent5": "A round person who is nice is young.", "sent6": "When a kind person is feeling cold with red skin, they will be round as well.", "sent7": "If a person is red and green, then they will present as big.", "sent8": "A kind person who is green is usually round.", "sent9": "Rough, blue people tend to have a lot of green aspects.", "sent10": "They found the ones that were round, blue, and green to be nice.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and rough and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue and green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7) -> rule2) ((((triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7) -> rule2) ((((triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Red Charlie is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent2": "That guy Dave is big, but he's always kind to little ones.", "sent3": "You could say that Fred is red and kind and it would also be true that he is cold and big.", "sent4": "Harry gets red when he is mad and tends to act very cold.", "sent5": "A kind and green person who is rough around the edges is cold.", "sent6": "Anybody that is big is also someone who is going to be blue.", "sent7": "Big people, round in the middle and having rough skin are nice because they know what it's like to be made fun of.", "sent8": "A nice big person who is also round is going to be cold.", "sent9": "If a person that is blue and green is also cold, that means that they are young.", "sent10": "Anyone who's blue is also green.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and green and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9) -> rule6) OR ((triple9 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3) triple8 triple10) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8 triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3) triple10 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3) triple10 ((triple10 triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8 triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10 ((triple10 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is rough, round and young but also red.", "sent2": "To the touch Charlie has rough, cold skin.", "sent3": "Gary was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent4": "Harry vowed to always be rough, cold, blue, and big as possible.", "sent5": "A green colored, nice and young person will be big shaped.", "sent6": "In every case of people being kind and blue and green, we find they are concurrently nice.", "sent7": "When someone is blue, lives green they can be rough but kind.", "sent8": "Cold, green people have a habit of eating alot and looking quite round.", "sent9": "When someone feels blue and rough, they might be described as green.", "sent10": "Big and cold people are likely to be round, too.", "sent11": "A person who is kind but also rough and is also colored blue, will be shaped round." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and round and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is red and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6 OR ((triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple7) -> rule4) OR ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple7) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 triple7) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple7) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 triple7) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((triple9 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((triple9 triple8) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple3 triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple3 ((triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is blue and cold.", "sent2": "Being new to the job, Bob is nice and green; Even though he is round he is red and cold out in the wind.", "sent3": "Charlie is a nice round guy, which leads to him being red.", "sent4": "In the snow sits Fred, crying from being cold.", "sent5": "A cold and young aged person will be big for sure.", "sent6": "A young round person who is green is also red.", "sent7": "I've noticed that someone with a round shape is also green.", "sent8": "A nice and cold person can be counted on to be a young person at the same time.", "sent9": "Being green, blue, and red all point to how young someone was.", "sent10": "Red and round people will be cold even in the summer.", "sent11": "Kind people who are blue with sadness and cold toward others are surprisingly red." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and round and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1 OR ((triple2 triple3) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 ((((triple3) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 ((((triple3) -> rule5) triple3) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent2", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "Even though Eric feels blue because of how round he is, he is still nice and kind to people that talk to him.", "sent2": "Fred is a round young man which makes him green and rough around the edges but he is nice though today he seems rather blue.", "sent3": "Gary is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent4": "A red colored and round person who is also young will be rather kind.", "sent5": "A kind person that is also red and rough is usually also nice.", "sent6": "A nice and blue person who's also red will be a rough person.", "sent7": "A very nice and kind person will also be round shaped.", "sent8": "When you meet kind people they wont have a cold heart.", "sent9": "A cold natured but kind person will certainly be red.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and big and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@4: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule6 <- rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is a round fellow, but he is kind, even when he is so cold he turns blue.", "sent2": "Gary, like all young people, is nice.", "sent3": "Harry is blue because he is cold; His skin is red and rough but that doesn't matter because he is also very young.", "sent4": "A round person who is nice is young.", "sent5": "If you meet someone who is red and blue with a round shape, you can count on them being nice to you.", "sent6": "A young, nice person will turn out to be a green person also.", "sent7": "A person being big and rough makes them cold towards others but that also means that they are kind.", "sent8": "If a person is young and very kind then they will be rather big.", "sent9": "People who are young and green are also kind.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and cold and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and nice and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7 OR ((triple9 triple8 ((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8 triple6) -> rule3) triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple8 ((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8 triple6) -> rule3) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8 triple6) -> rule3) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple8 ((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan's a round guy, and a red and green guy.", "sent2": "Bob is green, which is a possible explanation for why he is so nice.", "sent3": "Charlie is a pretty young guy, who is quite nice, with a round shape, and red and green features.", "sent4": "Dave looks red to most people, with blue features.", "sent5": "Whoever is rough and red must be kind.", "sent6": "Young people green with envy are so focused on themselves that they are often describe as cold; That is misleading though because these people are also kind.", "sent7": "Blue and red people who are young always have rough skin.", "sent8": "If a person is red, kind, and nice then they must be round.", "sent9": "Kind people who are blue with sadness and cold toward others are surprisingly red.", "sent10": "Young people that are nice and green tend to be blue.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and green then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and rough and nice then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and kind and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule6 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is blue and cold.", "sent2": "Fred is a red person who is round and also feels blue.", "sent3": "Gary is blue from ink he spilled on himself while being kind and helping some children paint.", "sent4": "Harry is a person both green and big.", "sent5": "People that tend to be big and green also tend to be cold.", "sent6": "A big blue someone could also be green.", "sent7": "Get out of the way if a red and green person walks up to you because they are rough.", "sent8": "Anybody with big, rough and nice qualities is bound to also be young.", "sent9": "A kind person who look green and is round in shape is usually big in stature.", "sent10": "Someone who is cold and big is also a red person.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and green and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and rough and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and cold and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 triple3) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "You should meet Bob, he is big and rough on the football field but also very young in age.", "sent2": "Charlie grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent3": "Fred grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent4": "Gary is round shaped and green colored.", "sent5": "If you find someone who is kind, big in personality and looks a little green, then you can bet that they are cold.", "sent6": "It's been proven that red, rough people are green as well.", "sent7": "A young person with cold, rough skin will be red as well.", "sent8": "You will find most green,cold and blue people to be rough.", "sent9": "When someone is big, young and rough, they can be cold.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue and red then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) OR ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) OR ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5) OR ((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5) OR ((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((((triple5 triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule7) ((triple5 triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple5 triple4 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent2": "Dave always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent3": "Eric is still young which means he can be rough and cold; He is a big boy with red hair.", "sent4": "Whoever is rough and red must be kind.", "sent5": "Try to cheer up those young folks that are rough and kind, for they are very likely feeling blue.", "sent6": "Someone might be red but blue from the cold dressing in green.", "sent7": "A person described as cold and kind can also be described as nice.", "sent8": "Nice people who are green and red will also have round shapes.", "sent9": "Anyone will tell you the kind and the big are also rough.", "sent10": "If you meet a young and kind person who is also rough, they are cold, too.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and green and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and green and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is red and cold and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8 triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6) -> rule1) triple6 triple7) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple7) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6) -> rule1) triple6 triple7) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple7) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((((triple6) -> rule1) triple6 triple7) -> rule7) triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple6) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6 triple7) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((((triple6) -> rule1) triple6 triple7) -> rule7) triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple6) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6 triple7) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((((triple6) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6 triple7) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple6) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple7) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple6) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6 triple7) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "To the touch Bob has rough, cold skin.", "sent2": "Dave wears all blue.", "sent3": "Fred is cold which makes him red! Fred is young and rough but also very kind.", "sent4": "Gary always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "Red people feel blue about it.", "sent6": "Someone who is colored both in red and green, while being kind to others, is a round person.", "sent7": "If someone is a bit rough, but also nice, then they qualify as round.", "sent8": "Blue people who are rough are often young.", "sent9": "Big, green people that feel blue are mostly young.", "sent10": "A cold, red person with a kind disposition will certainly be big.", "sent11": "Kind people, blue with sadness, and red with the first blushes of love are also found to be green with envy." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and nice and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9) -> rule3) OR ((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9) -> rule3) OR ((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule6) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((triple9) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule4) ((triple8 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple8 triple10) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "This Alan guy is red; He is also kind and yet cold.", "sent2": "Charlie is kind and round; Being round makes him a bit blue.", "sent3": "Eric is round, rough and big, but that's because he's also green at the job and cold working outside.", "sent4": "A rough person that is cold towards others is green.", "sent5": "When you meet someone that's rough, kind and nice you'll see they are green as well.", "sent6": "People that are green tend to be young.", "sent7": "People who have a big shape while they are young are found to be nice.", "sent8": "Young people that are nice and green tend to be blue.", "sent9": "A young, big sized person will certainly be a kind one.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and young and nice then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple9) -> rule2) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) ((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2) triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2) ((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) ((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "15", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2) ((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) ((((triple1 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple1 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan's skin appears to be red because of an infection which because of his big size slows his blood flow causing him to always feel cold despite this he is still very nice to everyone he encounters.", "sent2": "Even though Charlie is green with envy he is nice with rosy red cheeks.", "sent3": "That man standing next to you with a big round body goes by the name of Harry.", "sent4": "Someone who has a a young round face is often rough around the edges.", "sent5": "If you have a big and round shape then you are going to be young, too.", "sent6": "Red, big people can't help but be round as well.", "sent7": "Rough young folks are surprisingly kind.", "sent8": "A person who is in school because of their young age with a round body and the constant desire to be nice will be feeling blue.", "sent9": "If you meet someone who is big and kind with cold skin, they will be young.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and kind and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and nice and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and big and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule2) OR ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule2) OR ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple3) -> rule2) triple5) -> rule6) OR ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule1) triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple3) -> rule2) triple5) -> rule6) OR ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule1) triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3) -> rule2) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule5) OR ((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule1) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3) -> rule2) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule5) OR ((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule1) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young Charlie knew he was round, but he hadn't realized how rough and kind he was; His green nature left him cold and numb to these facts.", "sent2": "Dave is a nice round guy, which leads to him being red.", "sent3": "Harry looks red to most people, with blue features.", "sent4": "A male or female with rough, kind and round traits will surely have a nice quality, as well.", "sent5": "Rough people are often always nice.", "sent6": "Big and round people can't help but be cold all of the time.", "sent7": "If a person behaves in a nice way while they are physically blue and big, they're definitely round.", "sent8": "Sam is usually kind but a blue person, but lately he has been both green with envy and red with anger.", "sent9": "Young people that are nice and green tend to be blue.", "sent10": "If you meet somebody who is green, big and red you'll notice they are also blue.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is red and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and round then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) triple9) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) triple9) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) triple9) -> rule6) triple10 triple12) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) triple9) -> rule6) triple10 triple12) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) triple9) -> rule6) triple10 triple12) -> rule4)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) triple9) -> rule6) triple10 triple12) -> rule4)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple10 ((triple12 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is very young red and kind, however he's green, nice and cold as well.", "sent2": "Charlie gets red when he is mad and tends to act very cold.", "sent3": "Dave, the round one, is cold in Alaska because he's green and rough around the edges.", "sent4": "In every case of people being kind and blue and green, we find they are concurrently nice.", "sent5": "People who are round and young are also very nice.", "sent6": "A nice big person who is also round is going to be cold.", "sent7": "Though their hands were rough and cold they were also kind, which is how I could tell that they were young.", "sent8": "Big, red things tend to have a kind spirit to them.", "sent9": "A rough, big, and round person can't help but be kind as well.", "sent10": "A cold temperatured and rough person who is also green will be big shaped.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and nice and cold then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and round and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) OR ((triple4 triple3) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) OR ((triple4 triple3) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2) OR ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2) OR ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple2 triple5) -> rule1) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2) OR ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple5 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is big in stature, blue from the cold, has red hair and is kind.", "sent2": "Most people see Charlie as round, albeit nice and big at the same time.", "sent3": "Gary ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent4": "Although Harry is young and nice, he is as cold as ice.", "sent5": "People who are big and kind are also round.", "sent6": "A round person who is nice and feelin cold is usually rough in apperance.", "sent7": "People who are round, blue and cold are usually nice.", "sent8": "Blue people who are cold are always round in shape.", "sent9": "Big, round, red people are always so young.", "sent10": "Blue and red people who are young always have rough skin.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and round and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and round and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Eric always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent2": "Fred is round, dresses in red, but is blue with cold.", "sent3": "Gary looks big and is kind with red hair and green shoes.", "sent4": "A rough textured and cold person is definitely young.", "sent5": "Could you imagine how weird it would be if someone was nice, blue, and kind, but not green also.", "sent6": "A round shaped and red person is definitely nice.", "sent7": "Someone nice and kind with a round belly that shakes when they laugh will also have rough hands from spending time outdoors with the reindeer.", "sent8": "A person who is very round is nice but also quite rough.", "sent9": "If you meet somebody who is young, rough and round, you can be sure they are nice as well.", "sent10": "If you meet a young and kind person who is also rough, they are cold, too.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue and nice then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and round and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> rule2) triple8) -> rule5) OR ((triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> rule2) ((triple10 triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple10 triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> rule1)) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple10 triple11 ((triple11 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple5 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "They always call him rough Alan.", "sent2": "Charlie is young and nice, but when he's feeling blue, he can also be quite cold to people.", "sent3": "Young Dave got into a fight that left him with red sores on his face.", "sent4": "Eric is a round fellow, but he is kind, even when he is so cold he turns blue.", "sent5": "A person that is cold, blue and nice is also considered to be round.", "sent6": "Blue kind people are almost always nice to others.", "sent7": "A young round person who is green is also red.", "sent8": "If a nice person is round shaped, they feel blue about it.", "sent9": "Someone who's blue, nice and round will also be someone who's green.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and green and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule1) ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4) ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule1) ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4) ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "They always call him rough Charlie.", "sent2": "Dave is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent3": "When he was found Fred was an icy cold blue; Being green and not used to country life Fred didn't know that being kind and round would get him trapped in a snowstorm; Fred is red with embarrassment.", "sent4": "Even though Harry is young, he is still very round and still very red.", "sent5": "A big round person is nice.", "sent6": "Surprisingly, all the kind, green people were also big.", "sent7": "A young, green person who is cold is rough around the edges.", "sent8": "A big person that is tattooed blue will be very nice.", "sent9": "Nice people who are big in stature often look rough.", "sent10": "People who are considered rough, blue, and nice, are also green.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and rough then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple6) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple6) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3 triple6) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3 triple6) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie looks red to most people, with blue features.", "sent2": "Gary a big man for his young age; he has red hair and can be rough.", "sent3": "Harry is a red fellow who habitually looks blue; He's often cold.", "sent4": "Big, kind people are nice.", "sent5": "Red and round people are nice to others even though they are big.", "sent6": "Rough and green people are also nice.", "sent7": "Being cold and blue made them rough to deal with.", "sent8": "When you know someone who's red, rough and nice, you'll also see that they're cold.", "sent9": "Nice people who are green and red will also have round shapes.", "sent10": "A young, big sized person will certainly be a kind one.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and young and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple4) -> rule7) OR ((((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple4) -> rule7) OR ((((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule6) OR ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule6) OR ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule4) OR ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule3)) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule4) OR ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule3)) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent2": "Big Fred is young and rough but also very nice in a green sorta way.", "sent3": "Gary who is big in stature is almost always nice even when he is cold.", "sent4": "Those who are nice but a bit rough around the edges are known for being blue.", "sent5": "Like a blueberry, a big blue person is round as anything.", "sent6": "I've noticed that someone with a round shape is also green.", "sent7": "Someone blue who is round with bloating and red from sunburn is surely cold from having fallen into the lake.", "sent8": "Blue, young and round people are usually big.", "sent9": "A rather round and green person will be red.", "sent10": "A green colored and rough person will be quite kind.", "sent11": null }