Datasets:

hitachi-nlp

/

proofwriter_processed_OWA

like 1

Follow

Hitachi, Ltd. 17

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and big and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple7 ((triple7 ((triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 ((triple7 ((triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple7 ((triple7 ((triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 ((triple7 ((triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@4: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule6 <- rule4 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 ((triple7 ((triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent2": "Dave is blue because he is round and big; He is young a bit rough around the edges.", "sent3": "Fred always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent4": "Harry is big and rough.", "sent5": "People with big hands and red, rough skin are terribly kind.", "sent6": "Blue people who are kind and nice are actually quite rough.", "sent7": "If a nice person is round shaped, they feel blue about it.", "sent8": "Looking blue can be a sign that someone is cold.", "sent9": "A big, green person who is cold is assumed to be red also.", "sent10": "Someone who is cold and big is also a red person.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and round and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7) -> rule4) ((((triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7) -> rule4) ((((triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "In the snow sits Alan, crying from being cold.", "sent2": "Bob is young and big in stature; He is cold but nice.", "sent3": "Eric is a nice person, but he is both blue and red.", "sent4": "Gary is a red person who is round and also feels blue.", "sent5": "Someone who is round in shape and green in color is usually cold.", "sent6": "People who are green and blue tend to be round in shape.", "sent7": "It's said that any person with blue skin, round bones, and big feet is kind.", "sent8": "Julie is really nice to gardeners since she has a green thumb.", "sent9": "A person that is both nice and young will also be cold.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and young and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple4) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple4) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 ((((triple7 triple4) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 ((((triple7 triple4) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 ((((triple7 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent2": "Young Charlie got into a fight that left him with red sores on his face.", "sent3": "Dave, the round one, is cold in Alaska because he's green and rough around the edges.", "sent4": "Gary is somewhat red,he is also very nice and kind, he is very big though.", "sent5": "A cold and young aged person will be big for sure.", "sent6": "People who are rough, round in shape, and big in stature are usuallu blue in color.", "sent7": "Pick someone blue, kind and big, and they are certain to be green as well.", "sent8": "Those who are round and cold are young.", "sent9": "A person who is young and cold and green is kind.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and kind and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1) ((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1) ((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple3 triple6 ((triple4 triple2 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "They always call him rough Alan.", "sent2": "Bob may seem round and rough, but he's actually nice; Don't be intimidated by his blue skin and big body.", "sent3": "Big Eric is nice but also rough.", "sent4": "Red Gary is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent5": "People who are nice, round and wearing blue will have red cheeks.", "sent6": "A young person with rough red skin is downhearted and blue.", "sent7": "People who are blue and red and kind are described as being green.", "sent8": "People with big hands and red, rough skin are terribly kind.", "sent9": "As far as anyone can tell, whoever is kind, rough, and big is a round person.", "sent10": "A young, nice person will turn out to be a green person also.", "sent11": "A cold human with round and rough aspects is always kind." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "That big young man is Charlie he can act in a somewhat rough manner but that's just because he feels very green here.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Eric, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "Fred who is big in stature is almost always nice even when he is cold.", "sent4": "All people that are rough and cold, as well as nice will be kind if you talk to them.", "sent5": "Any green person is a round person.", "sent6": "I've been told that big, nice people are very rough.", "sent7": "Someone who is big and kind is blue.", "sent8": null, "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and round and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule1) triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule1) triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "In the snow sits Bob, crying from being cold.", "sent2": "Dave is red, cold in temperature and round shaped; Dave is also very big.", "sent3": "In the snow sits Gary, crying from being cold.", "sent4": "I know Harry really well and you can say he is rough on the outside, cold on the inside and red all of the time.", "sent5": "If a red person is cold and kind to others, they also tend to be blue.", "sent6": "Watch out for the rough and round kind people for they cold to others.", "sent7": "It is true that kind people who have become cold and blue and survived are necessarily big.", "sent8": "Interestingly, cold and rough people are kind.", "sent9": "Rough people who are nice and have green thumbs are almost always young.", "sent10": "If you meet somebody who is young, rough and round, you can be sure they are nice as well.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and big and round then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple10) -> rule3) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple10) -> rule3) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple10 ((triple10) -> rule3) triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple10 ((triple10) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple10 ((triple10) -> rule3) triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple10 ((triple10) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple10 ((triple10) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is young but big for his age and he's cold and red at the moment too.", "sent2": "Gary is blue just like his dog; Gary is rough and round enough for the dog to use him as an exercise wheel.", "sent3": "Young Harry is quite nice, and because he is so round can be considered quite big.", "sent4": "Big and round people who arent cold, tend to be very kind.", "sent5": "Anyone in the world who is nice, red, and young, is simultaneously rough.", "sent6": "A quite nice person will certainly be red.", "sent7": "Rough young folks are surprisingly kind.", "sent8": null, "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and big and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule4) ((triple7 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule4) ((triple7 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6 ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "In the snow sits Charlie, crying from being cold.", "sent2": "Dave is a rough man with a big heart who has red hair and a nice smile.", "sent3": "Eric is a nice, kind young man; Eric keeps a sweater with him because he is always cold.", "sent4": "Harry was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent5": "I've found that a person who is green from lack of experience and nice even when they are feeling blue often has a red complexion.", "sent6": "Don't be surprised to hear that all nice, kind folks are in fact rough.", "sent7": "When you know someone who is young and green you can count on them being nice to everyone.", "sent8": "There are so many rough, young people and for some reason they are all big too.", "sent9": "People who are young and green are also kind.", "sent10": "People who are nice, big, and also rough, are considered red.", "sent11": "Those who are round and cold are young." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and young and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and kind then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule3) ((triple4) -> rule1) ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule3) ((triple4) -> rule1) ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple1 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is young, rough and green, but he turns blue when he is cold like anyone else.", "sent2": "Because Eric gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent3": "Fred was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent4": "Harry is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent5": "If people are cold they are often red.", "sent6": "Interestingly, cold and rough people are kind.", "sent7": "Young, kind people have the trait of being cold and are also very nice to interact with.", "sent8": "If a person is red, kind, and nice then they must be round.", "sent9": "Some kind person that is round a blue will get embarrassed and turn red.", "sent10": "People who are nice and rough are looked at as kind.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and young then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9 triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple11) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule2) triple10) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule2) triple10) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule6 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9 triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 ((triple9 triple11) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is a kind and red colored guy.", "sent2": "Charlie gets red when he is mad and tends to act very cold.", "sent3": "Eric is both big and round, with blue features.", "sent4": "Even though young Harry is red from his sunburn, his lips are blue because he is cold.", "sent5": "Someone who is both red and blue will also be a nice person.", "sent6": "A person with nice, blue traits who is young will surely be a round person.", "sent7": "A blue colored, nice but rough person is definitely young too.", "sent8": "Blue, red, young people are always going to be kind people, too.", "sent9": "Anyone who is round and also cold will surely be big as well.", "sent10": "Young people that are big in size, tend to be more on the blue side.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and kind and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "Dave was looking rather round and feeling rather cold, but people thought he is kind.", "sent2": "Everyone noticed how round and nice Fred was; He was kind, and everyone thought he was green and big.", "sent3": "Gary is a rather big guy with rough features; He's pretty red and green, most of the time.", "sent4": "A nice person who is green is feeling cold.", "sent5": "A big, kind someone could also be cold in a green dress.", "sent6": "It's a fact that young people are red people.", "sent7": "If you meet someone who is big and kind with cold skin, they will be young.", "sent8": null, "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and big and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and green and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12) -> rule4) OR ((triple11 ((triple12 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple10) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple12 triple10) -> rule1) triple12 triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple12 triple10) -> rule1) triple12 triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple12 triple10) -> rule1) triple12 triple11) -> rule2) ((triple12 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple12 triple10) -> rule1) triple12 triple11) -> rule2) ((triple12 triple10) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple12 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple12 triple10) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan wears all blue.", "sent2": "Big Charlie is very nice; Though he is rough and cold he is green and still learning.", "sent3": "Gary is young and kind; But he plays really rough with his friends.", "sent4": "Harry is so big, he is often blue, but always kind.", "sent5": "A kind and big person is young.", "sent6": "You will find that a big, young, blue person is also quite round.", "sent7": "A round shaped and young aged person will be very cold.", "sent8": "A big person in size will definitely be rough.", "sent9": "Young people tend to be blue all the time and rough.", "sent10": "Rough folks with green and red coloration tend to feel cold no matter what.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and green and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple6 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple6 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9 triple7) -> rule4) triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Upon meeting Bob, you'll notice he's green and kind.", "sent2": "Fred is known to be rough and green.", "sent3": "Gary is big and round with red rosy cheeks; He is young and kind.", "sent4": "That man standing next to you with a big round body goes by the name of Harry.", "sent5": "A cold temperatured and green colored person who is also big will be young.", "sent6": "A nice young person who is red is cold.", "sent7": "A round shaped and rough person will be blue as well.", "sent8": "When you meet big guys with red hair, then tend to be cold hearted.", "sent9": "Among cold people, those who are round and kind are also rough.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and red and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and young and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple3) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple3) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule4) OR ((((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) ((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule4) OR ((((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) ((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple8 triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple7 triple3) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob has a round face and is very nice.", "sent2": "When he was found Gary was an icy cold blue; Being green and not used to country life Gary didn't know that being kind and round would get him trapped in a snowstorm; Gary is red with embarrassment.", "sent3": "Harry was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent4": "Nice people that are blue because they are cold turn green with envy.", "sent5": "People with red hair, rough skin and big teeth manage to be nice to people.", "sent6": "Young and nice people have great big smiles.", "sent7": "Nice and blue people have to be big as well.", "sent8": "A person wearing blue clothes and feeling cold very frequently because of their large round body will have green skin.", "sent9": "Young, kind people have the trait of being cold and are also very nice to interact with.", "sent10": "Those who are round and cold are young.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and red and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple3) -> rule3) OR ((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> rule4) triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple3) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> rule4) triple3) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple3) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> rule4) triple3) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave looks big and is kind with red hair and green shoes.", "sent2": "Eric always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent3": "You should meet Fred, he is big and rough on the football field but also very young in age.", "sent4": "Gary is known to be rough and green.", "sent5": "A person who is nice and green with envy is round.", "sent6": "Nice people who are big are always feeling blue.", "sent7": "A kind person who is green is usually round.", "sent8": "A big kind person that is red is almost always nice.", "sent9": "Round and big people are sure to be rough.", "sent10": "Looking blue can be a sign that someone is cold.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and nice then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5 triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5 triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple8) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple8) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple8 triple5) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple8 triple5) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((((triple7 triple8) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent2": "Eric is big and dresses in blue.", "sent3": "If you met Fred you would find him nice, blue, cold and quite big.", "sent4": "Harry is a red fellow who habitually looks blue; He's often cold.", "sent5": "Nice people that are blue because they are cold turn green with envy.", "sent6": "A big person who looks blue is also going to look young.", "sent7": "When someone is young, they can be cold but kind.", "sent8": "Don't be surprised to hear that all nice, kind folks are in fact rough.", "sent9": "Someone who is not only rough and big but also nice will necessarily be round as well.", "sent10": "Rough people who are nice and have green thumbs are almost always young.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((((triple9 ((triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((((triple9 ((triple8) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple10) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((((triple9 ((triple8) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "In the snow sits Alan, crying from being cold.", "sent2": "Dave is round shaped and green colored.", "sent3": "I was surprised at how green and blue young, round Eric is.", "sent4": "Big Gary is nice but also rough.", "sent5": "A round person who is nice is young.", "sent6": "A green and red colored person who is rather nice will definitely be kind.", "sent7": "A person who's big and kind will also be cold.", "sent8": "Rough people are often round.", "sent9": "Red people who are green and blue are always kind.", "sent10": "Take a drive and find a kind and blue driver, that means they are also young.", "sent11": "A young, big sized person will certainly be a kind one." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is round and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple2 triple1) -> rule5) OR ((((triple3 triple1) -> rule1) triple2 triple1) -> rule5) OR ((((((((((triple1 triple6) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule6) ((triple1 triple6) -> rule7) triple2) -> rule2) triple1 triple6) -> rule3) triple2 triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple2 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple6) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple12) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple12) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple1 triple6) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule6) ((triple1 triple6) -> rule7) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple12) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple11) -> rule2) triple10 triple12) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple12) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple11) -> rule2) triple10 triple12) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 5, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple12) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple11) -> rule2) triple10 triple12) -> rule3) triple11 triple10) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 5, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple12) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple12) -> rule7) triple11) -> rule2) triple10 triple12) -> rule3) triple11 triple10) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q22": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q23": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q24": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" } }

[ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple1 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 ((((((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple2 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int2)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 5, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple12) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 triple12) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "We know Charlie is round and red, yet somehow he is also green, in addition to being cold, blue, and big.", "sent2": "Dave has green teeth and rough skin; People also notice his blue eyes.", "sent3": "Gary had big, red, round cheeks.", "sent4": "We called someone with green, round eyes, blue for some reason.", "sent5": "Red, kind, young people will be rough people, too.", "sent6": "People who are rough, round in shape, and big in stature are usuallu blue in color.", "sent7": "Green and blue, when found in one person, signify someone who is cold.", "sent8": "If you meet someone who is red and blue with a round shape, you can count on them being nice to you.", "sent9": "A kind person who is big in size is definitely young.", "sent10": "Round and somewhat big people manage to be kind to everyone.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and kind and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue and green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> rule5)) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is nice and young with red hair and a blue shirt.", "sent2": "Most people see Eric as round, albeit nice and big at the same time.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Gary.", "sent4": "Harry is someone you could describe as young, round, cold, and blue.", "sent5": "A big, kind someone could also be cold in a green dress.", "sent6": "I see it all the time, nice big people make equal a cold person.", "sent7": "Rough young folks are surprisingly kind.", "sent8": "If a person that is blue and green is also cold, that means that they are young.", "sent9": "Julie is really nice to gardeners since she has a green thumb.", "sent10": "A nice person who is downhearted, blue, and green with envy is rough.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is red and green and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple6) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is round, dresses in red, but is blue with cold.", "sent2": "Charlie is big and dresses in blue.", "sent3": "Big Dave is nice but also rough.", "sent4": "Fred is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent5": "A young aged and blue colored person will certainly be round.", "sent6": "If the description of nice and green applies to somebody, the description of young will, too.", "sent7": "A big person who looks blue is also going to look young.", "sent8": "It's inevitable that young, green people are big.", "sent9": "I've noticed that someone with a round shape is also green.", "sent10": "Kind people who are nice find that they must also be rough.", "sent11": "Young people that are also red and green, may be fairly rough, also." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and green and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and young then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2) OR ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2) OR ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1) OR ((((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1) OR ((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1) OR ((((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1) OR ((((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1) OR ((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1) OR ((((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule4) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> rule4) triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule6) triple5 triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple4 triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple6 ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple4 ((triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "In the snow sits Bob, crying from being cold.", "sent2": "Eric looks to be red, green, and blue, he is also round and rough.", "sent3": "It's easy to tell that Gary is young because he is so round; Even though he is kind it makes him green with envy of some people.", "sent4": "Find someone cold and green; If they are also round, then they are sure to be nice.", "sent5": "It seems to be that a person who is green, red, and blue will be very big.", "sent6": "A person with nice, blue traits who is young will surely be a round person.", "sent7": "A person with a rough quality is also a person with a blue quality.", "sent8": "A nice and young aged person will definitely be green in color.", "sent9": "A big and round shaped, blue person will be cold for sure.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and young and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and nice and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2)) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple3 triple2 ((triple2 triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob was round, nice, and because he was cold, he looked rather blue.", "sent2": "Dave ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "Fred is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent4": "If people are nice and round, they look red.", "sent5": "Red and round people are nice to others even though they are big.", "sent6": "Nice young people who are round are also blue.", "sent7": "Blue people who are kind and nice are actually quite rough.", "sent8": "Big people who at the same time are cold hearted and nice are a conundrum but they are also kind.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and nice and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule2) OR ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule2) OR ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule1) OR ((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule1) OR ((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule6) OR ((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule6) OR ((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan wears all blue.", "sent2": "Green eyed Bob is kind and nice; Since he is also big and round with rough skin he often turns red in the sun.", "sent3": "Gary is interestingly colored red and blue, and is also very kind.", "sent4": "People who are rough around the edges, nice, and a bit blue are young.", "sent5": "A round shaped and rough person will be blue as well.", "sent6": "If smeone has a blue and green color, then they are young and probably kind.", "sent7": "Being big and kind like a gentle giant can make anyone blue.", "sent8": "A rather round and green person will be red.", "sent9": "A person that is both nice and young will also be cold.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple1) -> rule3) triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple1) -> rule3) triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) ((((triple7 triple6) -> rule3) triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule3) ((((triple2 triple1) -> rule3) triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young Alan is wearing green pants.", "sent2": "Eric ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "Gary grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent4": "Young Harry is wearing green pants.", "sent5": "Kind young people are red.", "sent6": "If you can find someone who is nice and red, then be relieved that they are certain to be kind.", "sent7": "A green colored person will be young and also kind.", "sent8": "A green person that is cold is often considered to be red.", "sent9": "A young and kind person with red rosy skin is cold.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@4: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule7 <- rule3 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple3) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple1) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is so big and round, it's hard to tell he is red, green and blue all at once.", "sent2": "Charlie, like all young people, is nice.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Dave.", "sent4": "Fred ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent5": "A cold and young aged person will be big for sure.", "sent6": "Blue and red people are often rough.", "sent7": "When someone is blue, lives green they can be rough but kind.", "sent8": "If you meet someone who is red and blue with a round shape, you can count on them being nice to you.", "sent9": "Cold and kind people tend to be blue.", "sent10": "People that are green tend to be young.", "sent11": "When you meet kind people they wont have a cold heart." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and red and young then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and round and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple1 triple5) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Everyone noticed how round and nice Charlie was; He was kind, and everyone thought he was green and big.", "sent2": "Eric is round shaped and green colored.", "sent3": "Gary is interestingly colored red and blue, and is also very kind.", "sent4": "All kind, red, and young people are also nice.", "sent5": "I have found that if someone is kind and red, that they are quite often nice.", "sent6": "A nice and colored blue person will be rather big.", "sent7": "A big person in size will definitely be rough.", "sent8": "Most green and round people,though big are quite young.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and nice then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple7) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple6 triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple6 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple6 ((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple6 triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule6) OR ((triple6 ((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple7) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple6 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent4", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "They always call him rough Bob.", "sent2": "Charlie is big and rough.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Fred.", "sent4": "Young Harry is quite nice, and because he is so round can be considered quite big.", "sent5": "A nice person with rough skin is red.", "sent6": "People who are rough, round in shape, and big in stature are usuallu blue in color.", "sent7": "Someone who is both red and blue will also be a nice person.", "sent8": "Lucky for us, people that are round and red are kind to strangers.", "sent9": "Round and big people are sure to be rough.", "sent10": "It's just a fact that a blue person is a kind person.", "sent11": "Blue, red and nice people are always big, too." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and round and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and cold and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and young and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple5) -> rule6) ((((triple5) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple5) -> rule6) ((((triple5) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a nice person, but he is both blue and red.", "sent2": "Charlie, a kind and nice man, is wearing a green sweatshirt; He is also a fairly round sized man in shape.", "sent3": "Dave wears all blue.", "sent4": "When a young person has a round shape and feels blue, they will be green as well.", "sent5": "A cold person who is round but rough around the edges is big.", "sent6": "When someone is young and round, dressing in blue they can be nice.", "sent7": "A person with a round body will be feeling very cold and will be rough to handle.", "sent8": "Blue and red people who are young always have rough skin.", "sent9": "Nice people are cold people.", "sent10": "Find someone who is blue and rough, and big as an elephant, and you'll have found a nice person.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and nice then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and big and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple10) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple10) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple10) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple10) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple9 triple10) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple9 triple10) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Dave is a red person who is round and also feels blue.", "sent2": "That rough but kind guy is Eric, the green one.", "sent3": "That Fred is a round, rough fellow, and he's nice, as well as big.", "sent4": "Harry is a kind and red colored guy.", "sent5": "Blue Christmas ornaments are also red.", "sent6": "People who are blue and green are nice.", "sent7": "A kind, young person will be rough textured.", "sent8": "Nice people who are big are always feeling blue.", "sent9": "You will notice that a rough, nice, red individual will be young.", "sent10": "An individual who is big and nice is also green.", "sent11": "A big, green person who is cold is assumed to be red also." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and red and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2) -> rule2) triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2) -> rule2) triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule2) ((((triple1 triple2) -> rule2) triple2) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule2) ((((triple1 triple2) -> rule2) triple2) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan, a green man, was also big, but underneath he was kind.", "sent2": "Bob is rough and cold, but he's young and will get over it.", "sent3": "Young Dave is wearing green pants.", "sent4": "If you see someone who is red and green they are round, like Santa Claus.", "sent5": "Whenever you are around kind and green people, you will notice they are very red.", "sent6": "Anyone that is a red, nice soul will be big, too.", "sent7": "A young, nice person will turn out to be a green person also.", "sent8": "When you meet someone who is round, red and green, they will also be young.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and green and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and green and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and nice then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5) triple7 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5) triple7 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple7 triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent3", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent4", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent2": "Fred ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "Gary is a nice person who is red because he has a rash.", "sent4": "Big, rough Harry is also kind with red hair and green shoes.", "sent5": "A quite nice person who is red and green is also big.", "sent6": "Kind big people are green and young.", "sent7": "A nice person with rough skin will be round, you can count on it.", "sent8": "Everyone knows that if you are cold, kind, and big, it goes without saying that you are round.", "sent9": "If you meet a young and kind person who is also rough, they are cold, too.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and green and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple11) -> rule5) triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple11) -> rule5) triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple11) -> rule5) triple11) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple11) -> rule5) triple11) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Bob, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "That man standing next to you with a big round body goes by the name of Charlie.", "sent4": "Gary is a big young boy with a bit of a rough streak; Most of the times he is nice, especially when his skin is green and blue.", "sent5": "A kind red person is also a blue person.", "sent6": "Red, big people can't help but be round as well.", "sent7": "Round people who feel rough also always feel cold,.", "sent8": "On a voyage across the sea it is always the round, kind people, green with seasickness that turn red with embarrassment.", "sent9": "Big, blue people are red.", "sent10": "When you meet a young, red person, you'll learn they are also nice.", "sent11": "There is a trend I've noticed if someone is nice, kind and big they are also young in appearance." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and nice then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple3) -> rule3) triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple3) -> rule3) triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule3) triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule3) triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob, is a rather young, rough, and round person who is considered kind; Today however he is red from a sunburn and looks green after seeing some rather rotten trash.", "sent2": "Dave is kind and round; Being round makes him a bit blue.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Eric.", "sent4": "Blue and red people are often rough.", "sent5": "Cold, green people have a habit of eating alot and looking quite round.", "sent6": "There are so many rough, young people and for some reason they are all big too.", "sent7": "People that are big but also green, may ultimately be very nice.", "sent8": "When a round individual is nice to others, they are also feeling blue.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and rough and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and red and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2) triple7 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2) triple7 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2) triple7 triple9) -> rule4) triple6 ((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 ((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2) triple7 triple9) -> rule4) triple6 ((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 ((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple3 triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7 triple9) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6 ((triple7 triple6 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "To be young and red like Eric is pretty nice, which Green Eric is also.", "sent2": "Red Gary is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent3": "You can see Harry walking down the street because he is big and round; He's actually a kind guy even though he's rough around the edges; He also has a red, ruddy complexion.", "sent4": "Surprisingly, all the kind, green people were also big.", "sent5": "If you come across someone with rough skin and a big and round shape, you'll see that they are also a big green.", "sent6": "A nice young person who is red is cold.", "sent7": "A kind and green person who is rough around the edges is cold.", "sent8": "Any cold, round, green person is going to be young at the same time.", "sent9": "People who are young, while being red and cold, are big people.", "sent10": "People who are nice and rough are looked at as kind.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is red and young and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule2) triple5) -> rule3) OR ((((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple6) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5) -> rule3) OR ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule2) triple5) -> rule3) OR ((((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple6) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5) triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5) ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2) ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5) ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple6) -> rule7) ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5) triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5) ((triple4 triple5) -> rule2) ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule5) ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple6) -> rule7) ((triple4 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple3 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave is a kind and red colored guy.", "sent2": "I knew Gary was young, and rough, but he surprised me with how cold and blue he acted.", "sent3": "Harry is a nice and red, but very kind person as soon as you meet him.", "sent4": "Someone who looks rough and feels cold is also kind to others.", "sent5": "A rough textured and cold person is definitely young.", "sent6": "Someone who's young and frosty cold are actually very nice.", "sent7": "Red and round people will be cold even in the summer.", "sent8": "A cold natured but kind person will certainly be red.", "sent9": "A young person who is red a kind is also usually big.", "sent10": "Take a drive and find a kind and blue driver, that means they are also young.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and red and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule5) OR ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple7) -> rule5) OR ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) OR ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule5) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule5) ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple8 ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple8 ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5) ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5)) ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule5) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> rule5) ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple8 ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple8 ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule5) ((((triple8) -> rule2) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5)) ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule5 % int5)) ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int4)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple9 triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple7) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((((triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) triple6 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Charlie vowed to always be rough, cold, blue, and big as possible.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Fred, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "Gary is somewhat red,he is also very nice and kind, he is very big though.", "sent4": "Harry was in a chemistry lab accident and turned blue and green which is even more obvious due to his round figure.", "sent5": "Big round people who wear red clothing will also wear a lot of green jewelry.", "sent6": "I've noticed that kind people are also big.", "sent7": "People who always wear red and act in a kind manner towards everyone they meet also have a round body.", "sent8": "A kind and cold person who is green is, surprisingly, also blue.", "sent9": "Nice people who are big are always cold because they can't find space near the heater.", "sent10": "Rough people who are nice and have green thumbs are almost always young.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and young and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and young then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple11) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple11) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) triple8 triple9) -> rule2) OR ((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) ((triple9 triple7) -> rule3) triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) triple8 triple9) -> rule2) OR ((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) ((triple9 triple7) -> rule3) triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) triple8 triple9) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple11) -> rule4)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) ((triple9 triple7) -> rule3) triple9) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple11) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) triple8 triple9) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple11) -> rule4)) -> rule5) OR ((((((triple7 triple11) -> rule4) ((triple9 triple7) -> rule3) triple9) -> rule2) ((triple7 triple11) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((triple9 triple7) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent2": "Bob is big and rough.", "sent3": "Eric is a kind and red colored guy.", "sent4": "Fred is a young guy who is also round, red, kind, cold and blue.", "sent5": "Young, green round people are big.", "sent6": "Red and round people are nice to others even though they are big.", "sent7": "Red, young people are for the most part round too.", "sent8": "Someone who's young and frosty cold are actually very nice.", "sent9": "An individual who is big and nice is also green.", "sent10": "Everyone knows that if you are cold, kind, and big, it goes without saying that you are round.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and nice then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and kind and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and blue and big then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple11) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8) -> rule2) OR ((triple9 ((((triple9 triple11) -> rule7) triple12) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2) OR ((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) OR ((((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2) ((((triple3 triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) triple2) -> rule3) OR ((((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2) ((((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) triple2) -> rule3) OR ((((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2) ((((triple3 triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) triple2) -> rule3) OR ((((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2) ((((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((((triple3 triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) ((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule4) OR ((triple1 ((((triple3 triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) ((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule4) OR ((triple1 ((((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) ((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule4) OR ((triple1 ((((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5) triple2) -> rule1) ((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> rule7) triple5) -> rule5)) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int4)) ((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 ((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule2 % int5)) ((((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 ((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 ((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((((triple9 triple11) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple12) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int4)) ((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple2 ((triple3 triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((triple2 ((((triple2 triple4) -> (rule7 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Young Alan is so nice even though he always feels cold; He loves to wear blue and green clothes.", "sent2": "Bob was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent3": "Dave ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent4": "Everyone knows that Fred is nice and kind, but Fred is also blue from the cold; This makes him look rather round.", "sent5": "Being round and nice automatically means a person is kind.", "sent6": "If people are nice and round, they look red.", "sent7": "An individual that fits the nice, red, and kind description will fit the description of big, too.", "sent8": "Red, kind, young people will be rough people, too.", "sent9": "People who are green and blue tend to be round in shape.", "sent10": "I have found that young, blue, and big individuals are also red.", "sent11": "People who are nice and cold are also green." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> rule5)) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple7 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is blue just like his dog; Bob is rough and round enough for the dog to use him as an exercise wheel.", "sent2": "Big blue Eric is nice and young.", "sent3": "Most people see Fred as round, albeit nice and big at the same time.", "sent4": "Harry ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent5": "Green and blue people have a habit of being cold, which makes them red too.", "sent6": "Kind young people are red.", "sent7": "Rough people are often round.", "sent8": "Look for the blue and green people, they are kind and will give you directions if you're lost.", "sent9": "A big, young human being is sure to also be a green human being.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and big and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is red and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and young and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is round and nice then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple12) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple12) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple12) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple12) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4) OR ((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> rule5)) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4) OR ((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> rule5)) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) OR ((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> rule5)) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6) OR ((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> rule5)) -> rule2) triple9 triple6) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple12) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple6 triple9 ((triple6 triple10) -> (rule5 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Bob is known to be rough and green.", "sent2": "Charlie loves cake which has made him quite round; Because he has been made fun of for quite some time, he has turned rough and cold towards others.", "sent3": "Dave is big in stature, blue from the cold, has red hair and is kind.", "sent4": "Eric has a round face and is very nice.", "sent5": "Cold, rough people are always green.", "sent6": "You know when you meet a red, blue and kind person, that means they are green.", "sent7": "Somebody whose descriptors are nice, big and kind will also fit a young descriptor.", "sent8": "Being green, blue, and red all point to how young someone was.", "sent9": "Big, red things tend to have a kind spirit to them.", "sent10": "Young,cold and blue people are mostly round.", "sent11": "When a round individual is nice to others, they are also feeling blue." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and young and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and rough and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple1 triple4) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple1 triple4) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple1 triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule1) OR ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) triple1 triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule1) OR ((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((((triple4 triple2) -> rule2) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple1 triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple2) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple2 triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Rough Alan can be nice and kind looking green.", "sent2": "My friend Bob is very young; People say he is nice for having a round shape.", "sent3": "Even though he's a big dude, Fred is cold.", "sent4": "You'll always find a young, kind and red person to be a cold person, too.", "sent5": "If the description of nice and green applies to somebody, the description of young will, too.", "sent6": "Nice and kind people tend to live green lifestyle and arent very rough.", "sent7": "Young and rough green people, have no choice but to be red.", "sent8": "Nice people who are big in stature often look rough.", "sent9": "People who are considered rough, blue, and nice, are also green.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and kind and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and young and blue then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and big and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and nice then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and cold and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple12)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple12)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple1) -> rule5) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule1) triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple1) -> rule5) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> rule5)) -> rule1) triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple5 triple3 ((triple4 triple1) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Bob became more and more round and nice and kind, but he couldn't stop being cold and big.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Dave, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "People think that Eric is round; This might be because he is young and blue.", "sent4": "This Harry guy is red; He is also kind and yet cold.", "sent5": "Big, kind people that are rough are known for being red.", "sent6": "A green and blue colored person who is young will certainly be big.", "sent7": "You will probably see that big, round, blue people are green, too.", "sent8": "You will notice that a rough, nice, red individual will be young.", "sent9": "A person with a round body will be feeling very cold and will be rough to handle.", "sent10": "You will find most green,cold and blue people to be rough.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and young and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4) -> rule3) OR ((((triple6 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule6) OR ((((triple4) -> rule3) ((triple6 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6) OR ((((((triple6 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule6) OR ((((((triple6 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((triple6 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule3) ((triple9 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule3 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple6 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) ((triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent2": "Eric was quite young and green; He was also cold and big.", "sent3": "Even though Gary is big and round, he is cold much of the time.", "sent4": "In the snow sits Harry, crying from being cold.", "sent5": "If the person is big and cold then as a rule they must be green.", "sent6": "A depressed person feeling blue who is kind cannot escape from being green.", "sent7": "If you are green you are also kind.", "sent8": "When anyone is young, red and green, you know they'll also be blue.", "sent9": "A young, nice person will turn out to be a green person also.", "sent10": "Kind people,though green,tend to be nice.", "sent11": "A blue individual that is kind and nice to others also has a rough appearance." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and blue and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and young and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and big and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is big and cold and kind then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule7) OR ((triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) OR ((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 triple3) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule4) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple3) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple1 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4 ((triple2 triple4) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan was kind despite being rough; And because he was so big, Alan constantly felt cold.", "sent2": "This Charlie guy is red; He is also kind and yet cold.", "sent3": "Dave is blue and cold.", "sent4": "Eric has a round face and is very nice.", "sent5": "Young people with red skin who are a bit downhearted and blue are kind.", "sent6": "Most young, green people are kind and because of this they are round.", "sent7": "Big and green people who feel cold are usually young in age.", "sent8": "A rough person that is cold towards others is green.", "sent9": "As someone can be round and rough, they can also be nice and kind.", "sent10": "Big kind people are usually cold.", "sent11": "Anyone who is big and cold and also kind is definitely red on top if it." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and young and red then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind and rough then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple3) -> rule1) triple5 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3 ((triple5) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Because Dave gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent2": "Eric is young and kind; But he plays really rough with his friends.", "sent3": "Big Gary is fairly young; When he was a small child he would wear his parka and you could see his little green body in the distance; His lips would turn blue when he was cold.", "sent4": "Young Harry is wearing green pants.", "sent5": "People who are round and young are also very nice.", "sent6": "If someone is blue, young, and rough, they qualify as being round.", "sent7": "Humans who are nice to others while they are young and red will also be green.", "sent8": "If a nice person is round shaped, they feel blue about it.", "sent9": "Nice, kind people who look rough almost always feel cold.", "sent10": "Kind people, for example, like the ones at the bank are always blue.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and green and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and nice then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9 OR ((triple10 triple11 ((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 ((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> rule7) OR ((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9 ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> rule6) triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule5) OR ((triple11 ((triple10 triple11 ((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> rule6)) -> rule1) ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> rule6) triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9 ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple10 triple11 ((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 5, "QLen": "17", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> rule7) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5) OR ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule1) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> (rule7 % int6)) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 5, "QLen": "17", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> rule7) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5) OR ((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6)) -> rule1) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple6) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> (rule7 % int6)) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q22": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q23": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q24": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" } }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 ((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9 ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 ((triple10 triple11 ((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 5, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 triple3) -> (rule7 % int6)) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple5 triple6 ((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((((triple3 triple6 ((triple3 triple4) -> (rule3 % int6))) -> (rule4 % int5)) triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int6" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "That man standing next to you with a big round body goes by the name of Bob.", "sent2": "Eric is nice and kind; He is green with envy which makes him feel blue.", "sent3": "Fred always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent4": "Colored red, green, and blue, Gary is quite the round person.", "sent5": "Green and blue people have a habit of being cold, which makes them red too.", "sent6": "A cold and blue appearing person will be young as well.", "sent7": "Someone being both nice and kind means that they are a big person.", "sent8": "If a person behaves in a nice way while they are physically blue and big, they're definitely round.", "sent9": "Blue and red people who are young always have rough skin.", "sent10": "A person that is round, green, and blue is usually considered cold.", "sent11": "Nice green people who feel blue are often red in color." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and young and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and big and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1) triple6 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1) triple6 triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1) triple6 triple4) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1) triple6 triple4) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1) triple6 triple4) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule2) triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> rule1) triple6 triple4) -> rule5) triple4) -> rule2) triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((((triple5 triple1 triple3) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young Dave is big and round from his mother's good cooking; Dave is the kind of kid who is nice and kind to everyone and who is red with a sunburn.", "sent2": "That rough but kind guy is Eric, the green one.", "sent3": "Red Gary is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent4": "Harry always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "You'll always find a young, kind and red person to be a cold person, too.", "sent6": "Nice green people and often blue with sadness.", "sent7": "A nice and blue person who's also red will be a rough person.", "sent8": "A depressed person feeling blue who is kind cannot escape from being green.", "sent9": "If a big person is cold and nice, then they are green.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and kind and nice then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and big and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple7 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple7 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) ((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple7 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) ((((triple6 triple8) -> rule5) triple7 triple8) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple6 triple8) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Even though Alan is big and round, he is cold much of the time.", "sent2": "Eric is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent3": "Fred is rough and cold, but he's young and will get over it.", "sent4": "All people that are rough and cold, as well as nice will be kind if you talk to them.", "sent5": "An individual that fits the nice, red, and kind description will fit the description of big, too.", "sent6": "Someone can be very nice and kind, and this means they are also green.", "sent7": "It is true that kind people who have become cold and blue and survived are necessarily big.", "sent8": "Someone who's young and frosty cold are actually very nice.", "sent9": "If you meet somebody who is green, big and red you'll notice they are also blue.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and nice and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and rough and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and red and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple6 ((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6 ((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple6 ((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6 ((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6 ((((triple6 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "In the snow sits Alan, crying from being cold.", "sent2": "Eric, like all young people, is nice.", "sent3": "Fred is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent4": "Even though Gary is rough, he nice but cold and blue.", "sent5": "Young and rough people tend to be green too.", "sent6": "People who are rough around the edges, nice, and a bit blue are young.", "sent7": "Young and rough green people, have no choice but to be red.", "sent8": "Cold, red people are generally kind and big.", "sent9": "I see it all the time, nice big people make equal a cold person.", "sent10": "A green and quite rough person will also be blue.", "sent11": "People with rough red and blue skin are young." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and cold and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and cold and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> rule5)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> rule5)) -> rule2) triple12) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple12) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> rule5)) -> rule2) triple12) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple12) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple12 triple11 ((triple10 triple11 triple12) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple12) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan's skin turned blue and green in a lab accident; Despite his outward appearance, he is really nice.", "sent2": "Charlie has green teeth and rough skin; People also notice his blue eyes.", "sent3": "Gary is nice and kind, but a little rough.", "sent4": "Harry who is big in stature is almost always nice even when he is cold.", "sent5": "A nice, big person that is red is usually young.", "sent6": "When a person's traits are to be big, blue and cold, they will also have a red trait.", "sent7": "If you meet a person who is green, big and blue, you will find them to be nice.", "sent8": "Someone who's blue, nice and round will also be someone who's green.", "sent9": "Generally speaking, a person who is said to be nice, cold, and big, is someone with a blue color.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and young and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and red and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and young then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple7 triple8) -> rule1) OR ((triple11 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 triple11) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 triple11) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) triple5 triple4) -> rule6) OR ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple11 triple7 triple8) -> rule1) triple10 triple9) -> rule2) OR ((((triple11 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 triple11) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple10 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple11 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 triple11) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) triple5 triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) triple5 triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) triple5 triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) triple5 triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule6) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple9 triple11) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple11 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 triple11) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple11 triple7 triple8) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple11 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 triple11) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 triple1 ((triple1 triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is green and young, but he is also kind; He has blue eyes and red hair.", "sent2": "Red Eric is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent3": "Young Fred is big and round from his mother's good cooking; Fred is the kind of kid who is nice and kind to everyone and who is red with a sunburn.", "sent4": "If a kind person is also young and round shaped, they will be colored blue.", "sent5": "A nice and blue person who's also red will be a rough person.", "sent6": "Incredible as it may seem, young people who are red and have kind attitudes are always round.", "sent7": "A cold person, who is kind in nature and young in years, is round.", "sent8": "I bet you didn't know that nice, kind, cold people happen to be red.", "sent9": "They found the ones that were round, blue, and green to be nice.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and big and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind and nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and young and kind then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple12)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6) -> rule7) ((triple6 ((triple6) -> rule7) triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 ((triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple1 ((triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule3 % int4)) triple11) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple6) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple6 ((triple6) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 ((triple9) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": "sent3" }

{ "sent1": "Bob is feeling rough, red, nice, green and also blue.", "sent2": "Eric who is considered nice was feeling rather rough today.", "sent3": "Harry is young, rough and green, but he turns blue when he is cold like anyone else.", "sent4": "Big and cold people tend to see red and dont live green lifestyle.", "sent5": "Whenever you are around kind and green people, you will notice they are very red.", "sent6": "Kind and young people are round.", "sent7": "When you meet someone that's rough, kind and nice you'll see they are green as well.", "sent8": "Anyone who is round and also cold will surely be big as well.", "sent9": "Someone who is kind and young with a round figure will always be red too.", "sent10": "People who are rough are often rather kind as well.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule1) ((triple5 triple2) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) ((triple5 triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent2": "Dave is young but big for his age and he's cold and red at the moment too.", "sent3": "Fred is nice and kind, but a little rough.", "sent4": "Harry is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent5": "Get out of the way if a red and green person walks up to you because they are rough.", "sent6": "A round shaped and red person is definitely nice.", "sent7": "A big, young human being is sure to also be a green human being.", "sent8": "Rough and green people are also nice.", "sent9": "Young people that are big in size, tend to be more on the blue side.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and kind and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and young and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple6 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent2": "Dave is blue from ink he spilled on himself while being kind and helping some children paint.", "sent3": "Fred always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent4": "Gary was green with envy; Though everyone thought he was a nice, young guy he was always blue; He would only focus on how round he was compared to others.", "sent5": "Young people who wear red lipstick are certainly kind.", "sent6": "A kind and big person is young.", "sent7": "A person that is nice and young is also going to be a person that is rough.", "sent8": "Anyone perceived to be rough, cold and kind will also be nice.", "sent9": "When somebody is round, kind and blue, you know they'll also be red.", "sent10": "A blue person who is young and rough is also red.", "sent11": "Those who are round and cold are young." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and green and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is red and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple11) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9 ((triple7 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9 ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple11 triple9 ((triple7 triple11) -> rule5)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9 ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple11) -> rule5) ((((triple7 triple11) -> rule5) triple11) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple11) -> rule5) ((((triple7 triple11) -> rule5) triple11) -> rule3) triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9 ((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((((triple7 triple11) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young Bob is wearing green pants.", "sent2": "Dave has a round,red,rough looking face with kind eyes.", "sent3": "Harry is big and seems cold, but he's just green; Really, he is nice and often red with laughter.", "sent4": "A young person with rough red skin is downhearted and blue.", "sent5": "A big, blue person who is kind is also round.", "sent6": "A big and blue colored person is also certainly very kind.", "sent7": "Big, green people that feel blue are mostly young.", "sent8": "All men who happen to be red and big, will also be blue.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and big and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and green and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple10) -> rule2) triple10 triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple10) -> rule2) triple10 triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple10 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple10 triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple10 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan has a round face and is very nice.", "sent2": "Charlie vowed to always be rough, cold, blue, and big as possible.", "sent3": "Eric is young and green, so although he is rough and blue with sadness, he'll grow out of it.", "sent4": "Gary always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "Their actions reflected how young and kind but green they were making things seem blue.", "sent6": "You will find that a big, young, blue person is also quite round.", "sent7": "When a person can be described as blue, rough and round, you can call them nice at the same time.", "sent8": "A round shaped and young aged person will be very cold.", "sent9": "A young person who is red and green is also going to look round.", "sent10": "Nice people who are big are always cold because they can't find space near the heater.", "sent11": "Ifa blue and green colored person is rough then they must be big shaped." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and big and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and round and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and young and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule5) triple8) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave is nice person, who was red colored due to a sunburn, was feeling rough because he is cold.", "sent2": "Eric is big and red, but he's young and will grow out of it.", "sent3": "If you met Harry you will see that he is round and red, but he is cold.", "sent4": "Somebody whose descriptors are nice, big and kind will also fit a young descriptor.", "sent5": "If someone has a red face and feels blue and has a round body then you'll automatically think they are big.", "sent6": "Green people here that are also round and nice are always rough.", "sent7": "Big, round, red people are always so young.", "sent8": "A person who is cold with a red nose will be feeling blue.", "sent9": "Being green and rough are signs that someone is big.", "sent10": "A person who is cold, rough and young is also nice.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and kind and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and green and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9 OR ((((triple6 triple7) -> rule4) triple7 triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7 triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7) -> rule4) ((((triple6 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7) -> rule4) ((((triple6 triple7) -> rule4) triple8) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7 triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "I knew Bob was young, and rough, but he surprised me with how cold and blue he acted.", "sent2": "Big, kind Fred is so very blue and red, but a nice person.", "sent3": "Harry always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent4": "Someone who is round in shape and green in color is usually cold.", "sent5": "People who are green and blue tend to be round in shape.", "sent6": "A kind person with green and red skin must be big too.", "sent7": "Someone can be very nice and kind, and this means they are also green.", "sent8": "Rough folks with green and red coloration tend to feel cold no matter what.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and red and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and green and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple11 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((triple5 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple11 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((triple10 triple11) -> rule3)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple11 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule3 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple6 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple11 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is big and rough looking but is very nice and kind.", "sent2": "Bob is round shaped and green colored.", "sent3": "Charlie is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent4": "Harry is young and round, he is also green.", "sent5": "Someone with round, red, and kind traits also will be green.", "sent6": "People,though rough and red,tend to be cold too.", "sent7": "A rather round and green person will be red.", "sent8": "A person who is red and green, will also tend to be round shaped and rough.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and green and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and big and young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is big and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8 OR ((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule5) triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule5) triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule4) triple9) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple9 ((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple9) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Because Charlie gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent2": "Dave is a kind and red colored guy.", "sent3": "That man standing next to you with a big round body goes by the name of Gary.", "sent4": "Harry is big and rough looking but is very nice and kind.", "sent5": "Anyone who manages to be round, blue, and green must be pretty big.", "sent6": "A very kind and green colored person, who is also cold, will be nice.", "sent7": "When anyone can be described as nice, young and big, they can also be described as red.", "sent8": "Big people that have a rough demeanor usually feel blue.", "sent9": "Rough people will often be blue; They thrive on being kind and nice.", "sent10": "All the kind people in blue were young.", "sent11": "People that are big but also green, may ultimately be very nice." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple8) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule7) triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple8) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule7) triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan loves cake which has made him quite round; Because he has been made fun of for quite some time, he has turned rough and cold towards others.", "sent2": "Bob was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent3": "Eric has a round face and is very nice.", "sent4": "That Harry is a round, rough fellow, and he's nice, as well as big.", "sent5": "Everyone that is rough but also kind will be green.", "sent6": "A downhearted blue person who is kind is round.", "sent7": "It's a fact that young people are red people.", "sent8": "A person with rough skin who has been standing in the cold will turn red.", "sent9": "Blue people who are cold are always round in shape.", "sent10": "Someone big and rough in shape is always kind.", "sent11": "Big kind people are usually cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is round and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8) -> rule4) triple6 ((((triple8) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6 ((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8) -> rule4) triple6 ((((triple8) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6 ((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6 ((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan who is considered nice was feeling rather rough today.", "sent2": "That Eric is as round and red as a cherry, and twice as kind.", "sent3": "That rough but kind guy is Fred, the green one.", "sent4": "Gary was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent5": "Cold and rough people will also surely be round shaped.", "sent6": "It seems to be that a person who is green, red, and blue will be very big.", "sent7": "If the person is big and cold then as a rule they must be green.", "sent8": "People that feel green are cold to people that try to help them.", "sent9": "I have noticed that nice people that are green and blue are often round-shaped.", "sent10": "Whenever somebody can be described as rough, round and cold, they can also be described as young.", "sent11": "Generally, round and kind people are big." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and young and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and nice and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and young and red then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and blue and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule5) OR ((((triple9 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> rule4)) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple7 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple9 ((triple7 triple9 ((triple7) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan looks red to most people, with blue features.", "sent2": "Eric is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent3": "Gary is big and dresses in blue.", "sent4": "There is a very nice young man with a round body who is wearing green named Harry.", "sent5": "Kind, young, green persons are sure to be rough persons, too.", "sent6": "A rough person who is young and nice is also red.", "sent7": "Humans who are nice to others while they are young and red will also be green.", "sent8": "Young people are rough.", "sent9": "A green and red colored person who has a nice temperament will be cold.", "sent10": "Anyone that's described as young, kind and blue can be said to be cold, too.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and kind then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2) triple1) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> rule1)) -> rule2) triple1) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple11 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 ((triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Dave is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent2": "Eric was in a chemistry lab accident and turned blue and green which is even more obvious due to his round figure.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Gary.", "sent4": "Harry is young, rough and green, but he is also kind and is red when embarrassed.", "sent5": "When you meet big guys with red hair, then tend to be cold hearted.", "sent6": "If someone is colored red but is cold, they tend to show a lot of green.", "sent7": "If red and slightly green people are asked, they will tell you they feel blue.", "sent8": "Some kind person that is round a blue will get embarrassed and turn red.", "sent9": "Being big and blue is standard for being green.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and nice and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and young and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and rough and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is big and green and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> rule7) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> rule7) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> rule7) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5) ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> rule7) triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> rule7) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> rule4)) -> rule5) ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> rule7) triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple8 triple4 triple5) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((triple8 triple7 triple4) -> (rule7 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent3", "rule2": "sent4", "rule3": "sent5", "rule4": "sent6", "rule5": "sent7", "rule6": "sent8", "rule7": "sent9", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is so big, he is often blue, but always kind.", "sent2": "Harry is a round and big shaped young man; He is green in color and is nice.", "sent3": "A big person who is red and nice to others is also young.", "sent4": "It seems to be that a person who is green, red, and blue will be very big.", "sent5": "Try to cheer up those young folks that are rough and kind, for they are very likely feeling blue.", "sent6": "A big and young, round someone looks red.", "sent7": "Young people with red skin that play rough are actually quite kind.", "sent8": "Big, blue people are red.", "sent9": "People who are described as young, green, and big are often considered rough.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is nice and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and young and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and cold and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "16", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule5) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule5 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@4: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule6 <- rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule5 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple3 ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3 triple2) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Young Alan is a big, cold, rough person.", "sent2": "Because Charlie gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent3": "They always call him rough Dave.", "sent4": "Big Harry, the most blue guy I know while also being cold.", "sent5": "If people are nice and round, they look red.", "sent6": "A nice and blue person who's also red will be a rough person.", "sent7": "Cold, green people have a habit of eating alot and looking quite round.", "sent8": "When someone is young and round, dressing in blue they can be nice.", "sent9": "When you meet someone with cold, rough skin and a round figure they will be nice.", "sent10": "A big person with cold, rough skin is going to be green as well.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and blue and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and red and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple4) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 ((triple4) -> rule5) triple1) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 ((triple4) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 ((triple4) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan a big man for his young age; he has red hair and can be rough.", "sent2": "Gary was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent3": "Harry is round shaped and green colored.", "sent4": "Round, blue, and green people are poften rough.", "sent5": "Big, kind people are nice.", "sent6": "Young people who are big, downhearted, and blue are kind.", "sent7": "Find a big human that is colored red and green and he will be amazingly kind.", "sent8": "Anybody that is big is also someone who is going to be blue.", "sent9": "Green and blue, when found in one person, signify someone who is cold.", "sent10": "Anyone will tell you the kind and the big are also rough.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1) triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1) triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is big and rough.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Charlie, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "When you first meet Dave you know he is young and big, but later you find out he is also, incredibly kind, cold and rough.", "sent4": "Because someone is green and kind they are extremely nice to people.", "sent5": "When someone is nice and rough they are usually red.", "sent6": "A nice and blue person who's also red will be a rough person.", "sent7": "Show me someone who is cold and kind, and I'll show you how green they are.", "sent8": "Big people, round in the middle and having rough skin are nice because they know what it's like to be made fun of.", "sent9": "Kind people who are also rough are young.", "sent10": "Ifa blue and green colored person is rough then they must be big shaped.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and round and nice then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and nice then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and red and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and green then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple6) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple10) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule6) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule6) triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule6) triple5) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> rule6) triple5) -> rule3) triple7) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple4 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a young and nice man, and he is also very big shaped.", "sent2": "Charlie is cold and rough with strangers, but nice with his family, even when he is green with envy at their accomplishments.", "sent3": "Dave is a very kind, green but sometimes cold person.", "sent4": "Though they were big and nice, they simultaneously were rough and aloof and seemed cold to others.", "sent5": "If someone is blue and rough, they always see red in others.", "sent6": "Green, nice people who have round shapes are going to be kind to you.", "sent7": "A person that is blue green and nice are that way because they are still young.", "sent8": "People who are young, while being red and cold, are big people.", "sent9": "A good thing to remember is that rough and green people are round as well.", "sent10": "Most kind and cold people are also big.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and big and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue and young then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple10 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple10 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple5) -> rule6) ((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple5) -> rule6) ((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3) triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple10 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple4 triple5 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a very rough person; As expected, he's also a very cold and big individual.", "sent2": "Bob is blue from ink he spilled on himself while being kind and helping some children paint.", "sent3": "Gary, who is young, nice, green, and blue, is also rather big shaped.", "sent4": "Young people who wear red lipstick are certainly kind.", "sent5": "You will find that a big, young, blue person is also quite round.", "sent6": "Kind and blue people,though young,tend to be big.", "sent7": "Kind people, blue with sadness, and red with the first blushes of love are also found to be green with envy.", "sent8": "People with rough red and blue skin are young.", "sent9": "Take a drive and find a kind and blue driver, that means they are also young.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and green and cold then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold and round then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple3) -> rule2)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule2) ((triple3 ((triple3) -> rule2)) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule2) ((triple3 ((triple3) -> rule2)) -> rule6)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple3) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple7 ((triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan had big, red, round cheeks.", "sent2": "Bob wears all blue.", "sent3": "Charlie was feeling red with anger after the fight, but he was still a nice but big human being.", "sent4": "Harry is young, rough and green, but he turns blue when he is cold like anyone else.", "sent5": "Young people who are feeling green and cold are kind.", "sent6": "Anybody that is big is also someone who is going to be blue.", "sent7": "When you meet someone with cold, rough skin and a round figure they will be nice.", "sent8": "Red people who are green and blue are always kind.", "sent9": "Young and kind people, that also tend to be cold, are then considered green.", "sent10": "Being big and blue is standard for being green.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is cold and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and young and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and rough and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple5) -> rule1) triple6 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple5) -> rule1) triple6 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple7 ((triple7 triple5) -> rule1)) -> rule7)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple6 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple7 ((triple7 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent3", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent4", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan wears all blue.", "sent2": "They always call him rough Bob.", "sent3": "Dave, like all young people, is nice.", "sent4": "Harry is rough and cold, but he's young and will get over it.", "sent5": "If someone is cold and young, you'll see that they are kind.", "sent6": "Try to cheer up those young folks that are rough and kind, for they are very likely feeling blue.", "sent7": "A rough, big soul is sure to be nice, too.", "sent8": "Young people with red, flushed cheeks who are rough around the edges are really quite nice.", "sent9": "Nobody who is round and rough and big can keep themselves from being nice.", "sent10": "Kind people who are nice find that they must also be rough.", "sent11": "If you run into a cold and kind person, they are always big." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and rough and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and kind then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is red and young and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule6) triple1 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> rule1) triple3) -> rule6) triple1 triple2) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple2 triple3) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple3) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple1 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a young kid who is a bit rough and on the big side; He can be kind to some and lives a green lifestyle.", "sent2": "Young Dave is wearing green pants.", "sent3": "Big, red Eric is quite kind.", "sent4": "Upon meeting Harry, you'll notice he's green and kind.", "sent5": "A kind and green person who is rough around the edges is cold.", "sent6": "A person described as cold and kind can also be described as nice.", "sent7": "Someone being both nice and kind means that they are a big person.", "sent8": "A person with a round body will be feeling very cold and will be rough to handle.", "sent9": "Young people that are red for any reason, may also act in a rough manner, but don't be surprised if they are ultimately blue.", "sent10": "A cold natured but kind person will certainly be red.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is red and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and blue and big then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and green and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule1) triple7) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Dave is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 ((triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a red person who is round and also feels blue.", "sent2": "Dave is green, which is a possible explanation for why he is so nice.", "sent3": "Gary has rough skin so it is red; He is big but so very kind.", "sent4": "Big Harry is nice but also rough.", "sent5": "A young someone is red in thought but green in ideas.", "sent6": "I have found that young, blue, and big individuals are also red.", "sent7": "If red and slightly green people are asked, they will tell you they feel blue.", "sent8": "A kind person who is big in size is definitely young.", "sent9": "If you meet a kind green person with a round shape they will also be young.", "sent10": "Looking blue can be a sign that someone is cold.", "sent11": "A person that is rough and round shaped features are going to be red." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and nice and cold then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and big and red then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and round and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple7 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple7 triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple3 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule1)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple7 triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple3 ((triple3 triple5 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent3", "rule2": "sent4", "rule3": "sent5", "rule4": "sent6", "rule5": "sent7", "rule6": "sent8", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Because Dave gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent2": "Gary is a rather nice, big and round fellow, who is also red from a sunburn and feeling blue.", "sent3": "A round person who is nice and feelin cold is usually rough in apperance.", "sent4": "People who are nice and big and red are green.", "sent5": "As someone can be round and rough, they can also be nice and kind.", "sent6": "A round and blue individual will also be a cold individual.", "sent7": "People who are kind and green are very often rough.", "sent8": "Young and nice people are ultimately cold.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and cold and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 5, "QLen": "23", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4) ((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 5, "QLen": "23", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4) ((((((triple10 triple9) -> rule7) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> rule7)) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule4 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule4 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q22": { "question": "Dave is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q23": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q24": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" } }

[ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 5, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5)) ((triple9 triple10 ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule7 % int5))) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "When you meet Charlie you'll the two characteristics that will standout is that he's red but also rough.", "sent2": "Dave is red with anger because he's green with envy, like all young, rough boys.", "sent3": "Eric is big and tends to wear red shirts.", "sent4": "Because Gary gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent5": "Nice people that are blue because they are cold turn green with envy.", "sent6": "A cold person who is round but rough around the edges is big.", "sent7": "A nice and blue person who's also red will be a rough person.", "sent8": "A rough, big soul is sure to be nice, too.", "sent9": "Someone who is nice, green, and cold, is always going to be young.", "sent10": "Julie is really nice to gardeners since she has a green thumb.", "sent11": "A person with a round body will be feeling very cold and will be rough to handle." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and big and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice and cold then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8) -> rule3) OR ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple8) -> rule3) OR ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) OR ((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) OR ((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule2) OR ((((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule2) OR ((((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 ((triple6 triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int4)) triple8) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan fits the description of someone who is rough, red and blue.", "sent2": "Bob ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "Fred is big and has rough red skin; He is blue about it and green with envy of the smaller people.", "sent4": "If the description of nice and green applies to somebody, the description of young will, too.", "sent5": "Big, young people feel cold all the time.", "sent6": "Someone who is both red and blue will also be a nice person.", "sent7": "Any human being with green, big, kind eyes, also has round eyes.", "sent8": "A person who exhibits nice, kind and cold characteristics will also be a rough person.", "sent9": "A person that is feeling blue and slightly big, is red as well.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and green and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big and cold and blue then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8) -> rule4) triple9 triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8) -> rule4) triple9 triple10) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((((triple8) -> rule4) triple9 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 ((((triple8) -> rule4) triple9 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 ((((triple8) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Bob grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent2": "Charlie is both big and round, with blue features.", "sent3": "Both green but also blue, Eric is nice and kind while being cold.", "sent4": "Fred is blue from ink he spilled on himself while being kind and helping some children paint.", "sent5": "Rough folks with green and red coloration tend to feel cold no matter what.", "sent6": "When a person's traits are to be big, blue and cold, they will also have a red trait.", "sent7": "When someone is kind and their cheeks flame red with embarrassment I know that they are young.", "sent8": "A person that is green also someone who is big.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is green and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is red and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and nice and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple3) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2) OR ((((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple4) -> rule7) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple3) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2) OR ((((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple4) -> rule7) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((((triple4 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule1)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple5 triple4) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple4 triple3) -> rule3) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple4) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Gary is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int5))) -> (rule4 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple5 triple4) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple3 ((triple4 triple3) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is round shaped and green colored.", "sent2": "Bob fits the description of someone who is rough, red and blue.", "sent3": "Charlie is a very rough person; As expected, he's also a very cold and big individual.", "sent4": "Gary is a kind and red colored guy.", "sent5": "A green and red colored person who is rather nice will definitely be kind.", "sent6": "A person that is both green and red tends to be cold as well.", "sent7": "It's been proven that red, rough people are green as well.", "sent8": "Rough and green people are also nice.", "sent9": "When someone is kind and their cheeks flame red with embarrassment I know that they are young.", "sent10": "Anybody that fits the nice, kind and big descriptors will also fit the descriptor of cold.", "sent11": "Blue, red and nice people are always big, too." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and cold and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and round and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is rough and cold and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice and green and rough then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple2)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple6) -> rule1) OR ((((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple5 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple6) -> rule1) OR ((((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule7) triple6) -> rule1) OR ((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> rule6) ((triple5 triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple11) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple11) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "20", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple11) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "20", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> rule6) ((triple10 triple9) -> rule3)) -> rule4) triple11) -> rule1) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple1 triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple5 ((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple6) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple11) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((((triple10 ((triple10 triple11) -> (rule6 % int5)) ((triple10 triple9) -> (rule3 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple11) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": "sent3", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is a big young boy with a bit of a rough streak; Most of the times he is nice, especially when his skin is green and blue.", "sent2": "Charlie always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent3": "Fred can be rather rough, but surprisingly loves the green; He can be rather blue, and is unusually big.", "sent4": "Big, young people feel cold all the time.", "sent5": "A person who is described as young and cold, but also described as rough is nice.", "sent6": "Look for the blue and green people, they are kind and will give you directions if you're lost.", "sent7": "Any person who is blue and round, if they are kind at the same time, will be young.", "sent8": "A person fitting the description of rough, cold and red will also be a nice person.", "sent9": "Like a blueberry, a big blue person is round as anything.", "sent10": "Rough people who are nice and have green thumbs are almost always young.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and nice and blue then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is kind and rough and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and cold then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3 OR ((triple2) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule2) OR ((((triple2) -> rule3) triple2) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((((triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2) ((triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((((triple4) -> rule3) triple4) -> rule2) ((triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int3)) ((triple2) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple2) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple2) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple2) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is rough, but often feels blue; He is pretty young.", "sent2": "That rough but kind guy is Bob, the green one.", "sent3": "Charlie is blue and cold.", "sent4": "People who are rough around the edges, nice, and a bit blue are young.", "sent5": "A rough, blue person is often said to be nice.", "sent6": "A person with a rough quality is also a person with a blue quality.", "sent7": "Green people will be nice even when they have been rough.", "sent8": "Though their hands were rough and cold they were also kind, which is how I could tell that they were young.", "sent9": "A person who is round shaped while also being quite cold tends to be nice.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and round and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and big then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and young then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and green and young then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Harry is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple12)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple1) -> rule5) OR ((((triple2 triple1) -> rule7) triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple1) -> rule5) OR ((((triple2 triple1) -> rule7) triple1) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple8) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple9 triple8) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((((triple9 triple8) -> rule7) triple8) -> rule5)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule7 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple7 ((triple7 triple4 triple1) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2 triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) ((triple7 triple4 triple1) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple7 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4 triple1) -> (rule4 % int3)) ((triple7 triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple2 ((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple7 triple4 triple1) -> (rule4 % int4)) ((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple7 triple4 triple1) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple9 triple8) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((((triple9 triple8) -> (rule7 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent1", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Alan is many colors; Red, green, and blue; He is also young, round shaped, and very nice and kind.", "sent2": "Fred is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent3": "Gary was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent4": "Harry grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent5": "When a young person has a round shape and feels blue, they will be green as well.", "sent6": "If you come across someone with rough skin and a big and round shape, you'll see that they are also a big green.", "sent7": "A person who is described as round and rough is usually kind.", "sent8": "A person with nice, blue traits who is young will surely be a round person.", "sent9": "Young people tend to be blue all the time and rough.", "sent10": "People who are described as young, green, and big are often considered rough.", "sent11": "Round, young folks tend to feel blue." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is big and blue and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is nice and big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and rough and green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is rough and red and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is kind and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4 OR ((triple6 ((triple3 triple6) -> rule2) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule1) OR ((triple6 ((((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule4) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule2 % int5)) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Alan is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> rule5) triple5) -> rule6)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple3 triple6) -> (rule2 % int5)) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int5)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int4)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int2)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple2 ((triple3) -> (rule5 % int3)) triple5) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent1", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan can be cold and rough, but also can be nice and kind; Either way, he's big and round.", "sent2": "They always call him rough Charlie.", "sent3": "Gary wears all blue.", "sent4": "Harry is a nice and red, but very kind person as soon as you meet him.", "sent5": "Young people who are big, downhearted, and blue are kind.", "sent6": "Nice people who are big are always feeling blue.", "sent7": "A person who is green and rough and round is also young.", "sent8": "Among the green people who are young, the color blue is always part of them.", "sent9": "A quite nice person will certainly be red.", "sent10": "I believe that red, cold, rough people are likely to be green.", "sent11": "A kind, young human will also be a blue human." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is kind.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is young.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and round then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and young and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is nice and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Alan is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple6 triple7) -> rule2) triple7) -> rule6) triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Alan is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is very young to be a nurse but he loves helping others because he is so nice and kind.", "sent2": "Young Dave got into a fight that left him with red sores on his face.", "sent3": "Eric is round shaped and green colored.", "sent4": "Red Harry is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent5": "A round shaped and rough person will be blue as well.", "sent6": "You make someone round and green, and they'll turn out nice.", "sent7": "Anybody that is big is also someone who is going to be blue.", "sent8": "A kind and nice person who is looking green is often red.", "sent9": "Folks who are nice and young with red coloration tend to feel blue.", "sent10": "Green people who are nice are rough.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and big and cold then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and blue then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is round and young then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and young then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 triple1) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10) -> rule7)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple7 triple6) -> rule4) triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple1) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple7 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3)) triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent2": "Big, red Dave is quite kind.", "sent3": "From a certain angle Fred is blue but he is young so maybe that will go away.", "sent4": "Gary is a nice round guy, which leads to him being red.", "sent5": "If someone is round in their face and big boned as well as having cold hands then you'll often note that their skin is rough.", "sent6": "Anyone you find who happens to be kind and blue will also be very nice.", "sent7": "People who are round and young are also very nice.", "sent8": "If you color the young ones blue then they will be kind.", "sent9": "Cold and kind people tend to be blue.", "sent10": "People that are green tend to be young.", "sent11": "Julie is really nice to gardeners since she has a green thumb." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and cold and rough then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and red and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is red and nice and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple7) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6) triple8 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6) ((triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule5) ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6) triple8 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2)) -> rule3) OR ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6) ((triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule5) ((((triple10 triple7) -> rule6)) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule6 <- rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple2) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4)) ((triple10 ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2)) ((((triple10 triple7) -> (rule6 % int4))) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent4", "rule2": "sent5", "rule3": "sent6", "rule4": "sent7", "rule5": "sent8", "rule6": "sent9", "rule7": "sent10", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Most people consider Bob to bed red; He's pretty cold to people and often feels blue; Bob is a big person.", "sent2": "Fred who is considered nice was feeling rather rough today.", "sent3": "Harry is considered to be a rather nice person who is also described as being kind, green and big.", "sent4": "Kind young people are red.", "sent5": "If people are cold they are often red.", "sent6": "When a kind person is feeling cold with red skin, they will be round as well.", "sent7": "A person who is described as young and cold, but also described as rough is nice.", "sent8": "Find a big human that is colored red and green and he will be amazingly kind.", "sent9": "Nice people who are big are always cold because they can't find space near the heater.", "sent10": "A nice red person that is cold is always big, I have found.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is nice.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and nice then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is nice and rough and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 triple7) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9 ((triple9 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 ((triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple7 triple6 ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple7 triple6 ((triple6 triple7) -> rule2)) -> rule4) triple7 triple6) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple9 ((triple9 triple10) -> rule2)) -> rule4) triple10 triple9) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple9 ((triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Alan is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple6 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 ((triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple7 triple6 ((triple6 triple7) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple7 triple6) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple9 ((triple9 triple10) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2)) triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": null, "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "To the touch Alan has rough, cold skin.", "sent2": "Even though Charlie is big and round, he is cold much of the time.", "sent3": "Big Eric is nice but also rough.", "sent4": "Fred is nice and kind, but a little rough.", "sent5": "A nice green person that tends to be rough will indeed be round too.", "sent6": "I've found that people with rough skin tend to be really nice but they also often feel blue.", "sent7": "Nice people who are big are always cold because they can't find space near the heater.", "sent8": "If you ever find someone who's nice, rough, and blue, expect them to also be green.", "sent9": null, "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is green and blue and red then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is rough and kind then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple1)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> rule2) triple9) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((((triple10 triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Even though Bob is young, he is still very round and still very red.", "sent2": "This Dave guy is red; He is also kind and yet cold.", "sent3": "The cold, nice, kind man with a round body is known as Gary.", "sent4": "Harry always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "Fat, round people who are green with envy and notoriously rough.", "sent6": "Among cold people, those who are round and kind are also rough.", "sent7": "Being green, blue, and red all point to how young someone was.", "sent8": "Kind people who are also rough are young.", "sent9": "A nice and young aged person will definitely be green in color.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is kind.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and big then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is blue and red and cold then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and blue and red then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5) OR ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5) OR ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1) OR ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1) OR ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> rule2)) -> rule5)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 triple2) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4)) ((triple1 ((triple3 triple4 ((triple1) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule5 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is red.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob is nice and young with red hair and a blue shirt.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Dave, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "This Eric guy is red; He is also kind and yet cold.", "sent4": "When you see Gary, you will notice he is cold, big and kind.", "sent5": "Big, young people feel cold all the time.", "sent6": "It's a fact that young people are red people.", "sent7": "A depressed person feeling blue who is kind cannot escape from being green.", "sent8": "Someone that is red and blue because they are cold are also round.", "sent9": "Blue, red and nice people are always big, too.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is young.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and kind and blue then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and rough then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple4 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> rule3)) -> rule1) triple4 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Alan is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Alan is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is red.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 triple3) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple6 triple4) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple5 triple4 triple6) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "From a certain angle Alan is blue but he is young so maybe that will go away.", "sent2": "Most everyone considers Charlie a rough fellow, but very kind; He's often categorized as blue, and he's big.", "sent3": "I know Eric really well and you can say he is rough on the outside, cold on the inside and red all of the time.", "sent4": "Fred is so young and darling he is kind to all the old people on the block.", "sent5": "It's a fact that young people are red people.", "sent6": "People who are blue and red and kind are described as being green.", "sent7": "If a person that is kind is big and blue they have to be young.", "sent8": "You will discover that green rough people are always red.", "sent9": "Anyone will tell you the kind and the big are also rough.", "sent10": "Big people that are also rough, are ultimately round.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is blue.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Dave is kind.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is blue and green and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and big then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and young and kind then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind and nice then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and nice and big then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Bob is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 triple2) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple2) -> rule1) triple2 triple5) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple3 triple2) -> rule1) triple2 triple5) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Bob is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule3) ((((triple3 triple2) -> rule1) triple2 triple5) -> rule7)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "11", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> rule3) ((((triple3 triple2) -> rule1) triple2 triple5) -> rule7)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Gary is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple2) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple3 ((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int3))) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 ((triple4 triple5) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((((triple3 triple2) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple2 triple5) -> (rule7 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Even though Bob is big and rough, he is nice; Bob often is blue and green with envy.", "sent2": "That rough but kind guy is Dave, the green one.", "sent3": "Red Fred is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent4": "Because Gary gets cold easily he tends to appear round from bundling up.", "sent5": "A nice person who is green is feeling cold.", "sent6": "Round, blue, and green people are poften rough.", "sent7": "A big person who looks blue is also going to look young.", "sent8": "Nice, green people that are somewhat round are big through the shoulders.", "sent9": "Kind young people that are still blue are generally round shaped.", "sent10": "Kind people who are nice find that they must also be rough.", "sent11": "Big people who at the same time are cold hearted and nice are a conundrum but they are also kind." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is big.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Fred is blue.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Fred is big.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and big and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and round and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and kind and big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is red and young then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is red and blue and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Charlie is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple8)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Fred is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Fred is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple6) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Bob is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> rule1) triple1) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Fred is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "9", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "17", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule3) triple7 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "17", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6) triple10) -> rule3) triple7 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> rule4)) -> rule6)) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Charlie is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Charlie is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Fred is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 triple4 triple3) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple1) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple6 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple10) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple7 ((triple8 triple9 ((triple8 triple6) -> (rule4 % int4))) -> (rule6 % int3))) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Fred is rough.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Fred is kind.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Fred is green.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "That Bob is a round, rough fellow, and he's nice, as well as big.", "sent2": "Charlie was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent3": "Fred, who is young, round, red, and blue, is also quite big in size.", "sent4": "Harry always goes out of his way to show that he is kind to people.", "sent5": "Though they were big and nice, they simultaneously were rough and aloof and seemed cold to others.", "sent6": "Watch out for the rough and round kind people for they cold to others.", "sent7": "A young person with a kind heart and big sized body will be rough around the edges.", "sent8": "A young someone is red in thought but green in ideas.", "sent9": "People that are green tend to be young.", "sent10": "Red people who are green and blue are always kind.", "sent11": "Those who are round and cold are young." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Harry is kind.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is blue and nice and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is kind and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and kind then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is big and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is nice and green then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple7) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> rule3) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> rule3) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "14", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple7) -> rule3) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> rule3) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q10": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 4, "QLen": "14", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple7) -> rule3) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> rule3) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> rule2)) -> rule4)) -> rule1)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] }, "Q11": { "question": "Bob is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Gary is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q18": { "question": "Gary is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q19": { "question": "Gary is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q20": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int4)) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 4, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple8 ((triple8 triple7) -> (rule3 % int5)) ((triple9 ((triple7 triple9) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int5" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "They always call him rough Bob.", "sent2": "Eric, who is nice and kind, can also be thought of as cold and rough.", "sent3": "In the snow sits Gary, crying from being cold.", "sent4": "Harry is so big, he is often blue, but always kind.", "sent5": "Nice people that are blue because they are cold turn green with envy.", "sent6": "People who are big and kind are also round.", "sent7": "Blue kind people are almost always nice to others.", "sent8": "Big and round people can't help but be cold all of the time.", "sent9": "Green people who are nice are rough.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is green.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is young.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is round.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and big and cold then they are young.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is big then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is round and blue and green then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Fred is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple7)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not young.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple4) -> rule6) ((((triple4) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple5 ((triple4) -> rule6) ((((triple4) -> rule6) triple4) -> rule4)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Bob is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Fred is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Bob is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- rule5 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Fred is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Fred is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Fred is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple5 ((triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) ((((triple4) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent3", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent4", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": null, "triple9": null, "triple10": null, "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Bob ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent2": "In the snow sits Charlie, crying from being cold.", "sent3": "Eric is interestingly colored red and blue, and is also very kind.", "sent4": "Fred is both young and fairly round in size.", "sent5": "Big and green people who feel cold are usually young in age.", "sent6": "A big person in size will definitely be rough.", "sent7": "A quite nice person will certainly be red.", "sent8": "If a rather cold person is also kind then they are probably rough.", "sent9": "Being blue, cold, and rough must be very trying; At least they are also big.", "sent10": "When you meet kind people they wont have a cold heart.", "sent11": "They found the ones that were round, blue, and green to be nice." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is rough.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Alan is nice.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is big.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is rough.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is green and young and round then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is nice and red and blue then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is kind and red and cold then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is blue and rough and green then they are kind.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is young and nice then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple10) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 triple10) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Eric is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "8", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((((triple9 triple10) -> rule6) triple8) -> rule2) triple8 triple9) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Harry is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Harry is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule7 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Charlie is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Charlie is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Charlie is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Charlie is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((((triple9 triple10) -> (rule6 % int3)) triple8) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8 triple9) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent3", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Although Alan is seen as nice and round, his days of playing football have made him quite rough.", "sent2": "That guy Charlie is big, but he's always kind to little ones.", "sent3": "Eric is blue because he is cold; His skin is red and rough but that doesn't matter because he is also very young.", "sent4": "Harry was born only a few years ago so he is young.", "sent5": "Young, green round people are big.", "sent6": "Lucky for us, people that are round and red are kind to strangers.", "sent7": "When a nice blue person is also red, they get called rough.", "sent8": "Cold, red people are generally kind and big.", "sent9": "When someone is blue, lives green they can be rough but kind.", "sent10": "You can see that cold, blue people are round in shape.", "sent11": "Young and nice people are ultimately cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Bob is nice.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is kind.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is green.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Harry is young.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is cold.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is big.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is rough and young and cold then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and green and red then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is round and rough and big then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is big and cold and rough then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and young then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Harry is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple11)]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Bob is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple3)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Harry is red.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Harry is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Harry is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> rule5) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Harry is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "10", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> rule5) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Harry is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> rule5) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple10 triple12) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Harry is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> rule5) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple10 triple12) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Dave is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Dave is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Dave is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple9) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int3)) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple9 ((triple12 triple11 triple10) -> (rule5 % int4)) ((triple10 triple9 triple11) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple10 triple12) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Harry is nice.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Harry is round.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Harry is red.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Harry is green.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Bob is a nice, kind young man; Bob keeps a sweater with him because he is always cold.", "sent2": "Dave ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "Even though Eric is green with envy he is nice with rosy red cheeks.", "sent4": "Young Harry is a big, cold, rough person.", "sent5": "Surprisingly, all the kind, green people were also big.", "sent6": "Young people who rough around in the cold are known to be very red.", "sent7": "A young person who is red and green is also going to look round.", "sent8": "Nobody who is round and rough and big can keep themselves from being nice.", "sent9": "A big person with cold, rough skin is going to be green as well.", "sent10": "Young people that are big in size, tend to be more on the blue side.", "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is red.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Harry is rough.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Harry is blue.", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is kind and round then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is young and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is young and nice and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and green and red then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is round and rough then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is big and cold then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is green and nice and red then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Charlie is round.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Charlie is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple5) -> rule2))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule3) OR ((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule7))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Charlie is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule7) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Charlie is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "13", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule3) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule4) OR ((((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule7) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> rule2)) -> rule1)) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Gary is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Gary is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Eric is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Eric is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Gary is round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Gary is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Harry is not young.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is young.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"young\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Harry is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Harry is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Charlie is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple9 triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Harry is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Harry\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] }, { "representation": "((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int3))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int2))) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple1 triple2 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int2))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple4 triple2 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule7 % int2)) triple4 ((triple3 ((triple1 triple5) -> (rule2 % int4))) -> (rule1 % int3))) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Charlie is rough.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Charlie is cold.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Charlie is round.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent1", "triple4": "sent1", "triple5": "sent1", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent2", "triple8": "sent2", "triple9": "sent2", "triple10": "sent3", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Charlie is a nice, kind young man that is feeling rather blue -- he is also green.", "sent2": "Big, round Eric is cold and very green.", "sent3": "Red Gary is what folks call him, because he is quite red.", "sent4": "Harry grew up in a family with six other boys and that make him a rough guy; Right now he's feeling blue because his dog is sick.", "sent5": "A kind, round person will surely be red as well.", "sent6": "A young aged and blue colored person will certainly be round.", "sent7": "This person is nice and young, also round, which makes them cold.", "sent8": "Cold people,though green and red,tend to be rough.", "sent9": "Round people who feel rough also always feel cold,.", "sent10": "If the person is big and cold then as a rule they must be green.", "sent11": "A green and red colored person who has a nice temperament will be cold." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Alan is cold.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Alan is blue.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Bob is young.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Bob is round.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Bob is rough.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Charlie is young.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Charlie is red.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is kind.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is green.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is round and red and kind then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is cold and big and rough then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is blue and round then they are green.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and blue then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": null, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Bob is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not kind.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple9)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Eric is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "2", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple10) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Alan is not round.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple1 triple2) -> rule4))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Alan is green.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Alan is not green.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule4)) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Alan is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule4)) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Alan is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> rule4)) -> rule3)) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Charlie is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule5 <- rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@3: Bob is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule2 <- rule5 <- rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Alan is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Alan is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Bob is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Eric is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Alan is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Bob is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is kind.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple10) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int2))) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Alan is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple2 ((triple1 triple2) -> (rule4 % int3))) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Alan is big.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Alan is green.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Alan is round.", "representation": "(\"Alan\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent2", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent3", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": null, "rule7": null, "triple11": null, "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "Alan is blue and cold.", "sent2": "Because Bob is so young, he is rough and cold when he can be round instead.", "sent3": "Young Charlie got into a fight that left him with red sores on his face.", "sent4": "Upon meeting Eric, you'll notice he's green and kind.", "sent5": "Someone with round, red, and kind traits also will be green.", "sent6": "A big and rough person can be misleading because they are cold and blue as well.", "sent7": "A blue and round human being will also be a green human being.", "sent8": "You can see that cold, blue people are round in shape.", "sent9": "A person that is green also someone who is big.", "sent10": null, "sent11": null }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Fred is red.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Fred is cold.", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Gary is young.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Gary is round.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Gary is nice.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Gary is green.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" } }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is young and nice and round then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and big and kind then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is kind and cold and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is cold and round and kind then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is cold and round then they are rough.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is blue and cold and rough then they are big.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": { "text": "If someone is young and nice and green then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" } }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple5)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Fred is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple6)]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Gary is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Gary is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "4", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Gary is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Gary is not rough.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "6", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Gary is big.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Gary is not big.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "12", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple12 ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5)) -> rule6) OR ((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> rule7) ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> rule1) triple9) -> rule5)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Fred is not rough.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Fred is rough.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule4 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Eric is blue.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Eric is blue.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Dave is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Fred is big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Fred is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Eric is not round.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is round.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Gary is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Gary is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Gary is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Fred is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Fred\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple12", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is nice.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Gary is big.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple12 ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((triple8 triple10 triple11) -> (rule7 % int4)) ((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) ((((triple8 triple10 triple9) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple9) -> (rule5 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Gary is big.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Gary is rough.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Gary is cold.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Gary is blue.", "representation": "(\"Gary\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent1", "triple3": "sent2", "triple4": "sent2", "triple5": "sent2", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent3", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": "sent11", "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": "sent4" }

{ "sent1": "Dave is a man who is both round and rough.", "sent2": "Young, red Eric is nice.", "sent3": "Fred gets red when he is mad and tends to act very cold.", "sent4": "Gary was green with envy; Though everyone thought he was a nice, young guy he was always blue; He would only focus on how round he was compared to others.", "sent5": "This person is nice and young, also round, which makes them cold.", "sent6": "Any big, kind person that turns red is cold to the touch.", "sent7": "A kind and cold person who is green is, surprisingly, also blue.", "sent8": "Among cold people, those who are round and kind are also rough.", "sent9": "A person with a round body will be feeling very cold and will be rough to handle.", "sent10": "Being blue, cold, and rough must be very trying; At least they are also big.", "sent11": "Young people that are nice and green tend to be blue." }

{ "triple1": { "text": "Bob is cold.", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple2": { "text": "Charlie is green.", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")" }, "triple3": { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")" }, "triple4": { "text": "Dave is rough.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")" }, "triple5": { "text": "Dave is blue.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple6": { "text": "Dave is big.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple7": { "text": "Eric is young.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")" }, "triple8": { "text": "Eric is red.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")" }, "triple9": { "text": "Eric is cold.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")" }, "triple10": { "text": "Eric is blue.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")" }, "triple11": { "text": "Eric is big.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")" }, "triple12": null }

{ "rule1": { "text": "If someone is rough and blue then they are cold.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\"))" }, "rule2": { "text": "If someone is red and big then they are round.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\"))" }, "rule3": { "text": "If someone is cold and rough then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule4": { "text": "If someone is young and rough and green then they are red.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\"))" }, "rule5": { "text": "If someone is green and red then they are blue.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\"))" }, "rule6": { "text": "If someone is round and red then they are nice.", "representation": "(((\"someone\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\") (\"someone\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")) -> (\"someone\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\"))" }, "rule7": null }

{ "Q1": { "question": "Dave is rough.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(triple4)]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q2": { "question": "Eric is not blue.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "1", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(triple10)]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, "Q3": { "question": "Dave is cold.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q4": { "question": "Dave is not cold.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "3", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple4 triple5) -> rule1))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, "Q5": { "question": "Eric is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple8 triple11) -> rule2) triple8) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q6": { "question": "Dave is not red.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "5", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule3))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, "Q7": { "question": "Dave is nice.", "answer": "True", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule6) OR ((((((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule3) triple6) -> rule2) ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q8": { "question": "Dave is not nice.", "answer": "False", "QDep": 3, "QLen": "7", "strategy": "inv-proof", "proofs": "[(((triple3 ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule6) OR ((((((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule3) triple6) -> rule2) ((((triple4 triple5) -> rule1) triple4) -> rule3)) -> rule6))]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] }, "Q9": { "question": "Charlie is not red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"red\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q10": { "question": "Charlie is cold.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Charlie is cold.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule1 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q11": { "question": "Charlie is not nice.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 2, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-rconc", "proofs": "[@2: Charlie is nice.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule6 <- rule2 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"-\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q12": { "question": "Bob is red.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 1, "QLen": "", "strategy": "rconc", "proofs": "[@1: Bob is red.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (rule3 <- FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": null }, "Q13": { "question": "Bob is not big.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is big.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"big\" \"-\")" }, "Q14": { "question": "Dave is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Dave is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q15": { "question": "Eric is not green.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "inv-random", "proofs": "[@0: Eric is green.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"green\" \"-\")" }, "Q16": { "question": "Bob is kind.", "answer": "Unknown", "QDep": 0, "QLen": "", "strategy": "random", "proofs": "[@0: Bob is kind.[CWA. Example of deepest failure = (FAIL)]]", "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"kind\" \"+\")" }, "Q17": null, "Q18": null, "Q19": null, "Q20": null, "Q21": null, "Q22": null, "Q23": null, "Q24": null }

[ { "text": "Bob is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Bob\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple1", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Charlie is green.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Charlie\" \"is\" \"green\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple2", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple6", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple5", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is rough.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"rough\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple4", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple3", "intermediates": [] }, { "representation": "((((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int2)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is big.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"big\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple11", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is blue.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"blue\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple10", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is cold.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple9", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is red.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple8", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is young.", "QDep": 0, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"young\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "triple7", "intermediates": [] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "QDep": 1, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple8 triple11) -> (rule2 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int2)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Eric is nice.", "QDep": 2, "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((((triple8 triple11) -> (rule2 % int2)) triple8) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Eric is nice.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Eric is round.", "representation": "(\"Eric\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" } ] } ] }, { "text": "Dave is nice.", "QDep": 3, "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "proofsWithIntermediates": [ { "representation": "((triple3 ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int3)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int2))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" } ] }, { "representation": "((((((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int3)) triple6) -> (rule2 % int2)) ((((triple4 triple5) -> (rule1 % int4)) triple4) -> (rule3 % int3))) -> (rule6 % int1))", "intermediates": [ { "text": "Dave is nice.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"nice\" \"+\")", "id": "int1" }, { "text": "Dave is round.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"round\" \"+\")", "id": "int2" }, { "text": "Dave is red.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"red\" \"+\")", "id": "int3" }, { "text": "Dave is cold.", "representation": "(\"Dave\" \"is\" \"cold\" \"+\")", "id": "int4" } ] } ] } ]

{ "triple1": "sent1", "triple2": "sent2", "triple3": "sent3", "triple4": "sent3", "triple5": "sent3", "triple6": "sent3", "triple7": "sent4", "triple8": "sent4", "triple9": "sent4", "triple10": "sent4", "rule1": "sent5", "rule2": "sent6", "rule3": "sent7", "rule4": "sent8", "rule5": "sent9", "rule6": "sent10", "rule7": null, "triple11": "sent4", "triple12": null }

{ "sent1": "In the snow sits Bob, crying from being cold.", "sent2": "Charlie ate some rotten meat and now feels green.", "sent3": "Dave is rough and is blue, but that's because he's big and round in a small and square world.", "sent4": "Eric is really big and young, wearing red and blue while feeling cold.", "sent5": "Maybe someone is rough and blue with the cold.", "sent6": "Red, big people can't help but be round as well.", "sent7": "A person with rough skin who has been standing in the cold will turn red.", "sent8": "Young and rough green people, have no choice but to be red.", "sent9": "If red and slightly green people are asked, they will tell you they feel blue.", "sent10": "A round shaped and red person is definitely nice.", "sent11": null }