raw_transcript
stringlengths
1
147
separated
stringlengths
1
148
indication of how valuable Rudy Giuliani 's testimony might be too are sort of our full understanding of what exactly
indication of how valuable Rudy Giuliani 's testimony might be too are sort of our full understanding of what exactly
happened You know well . It 's of course worth it to read the entire story by Adeimantus my colleague
happened | You know well . It 's of course worth it to read the entire story by Adeimantus my colleague
in the New Yorker which is just unbelievable in its detail but but you know , you just have to
in the New Yorker which is just unbelievable in its detail but but you know , you just have to
ask yourself : who is Rudy Giuliani , why is he there . What is he doing . And the
ask yourself : who is Rudy Giuliani , why is he there . What is he doing . And the
idea that he is working at as a criminal defense attorney is is just absurd . He is running American
idea that he is working at as a criminal defense attorney is is just absurd . He is running American
foreign policy he is trying to get the American ambassador , out of the way . Think about that as
foreign policy he is trying to get the American ambassador , out of the way . Think about that as
a concept for a private citizen and he succeeded . I mean it is just an extraordinary thing . This
a concept for a private citizen and he succeeded . I mean it is just an extraordinary thing . This
is what Democrats mean when they say the facts of the case are undisputed even the president 's lawyer is
is what Democrats mean when they say the facts of the case are undisputed even the president 's lawyer is
admitting the facts of the case . President Michael Gray strongly defending Giuliani 's retweeting his tweets . How do
admitting the facts of the case . | President Michael Gray strongly defending Giuliani 's retweeting his tweets . How do
you think this will all play out . This admission about getting rid of the US ambassador to Ukraine ,
you think this will all play out . This admission about getting rid of the US ambassador to Ukraine ,
how will it play out in the Senate trial . I think it 's going to , we 'll have
how will it play out in the Senate trial . | I think it 's going to , we 'll have
to find out when the trial happens , but I do think this kind of exposure . This kind of
to find out when the trial happens , but I do think this kind of exposure . This kind of
admission really cuts against the defense are likely to see in the Senate . The defense is likely to be
admission really cuts against the defense are likely to see in the Senate . The defense is likely to be
he did nothing wrong , or this is all a witch hunt . But when you hear something like that
he did nothing wrong , or this is all a witch hunt . But when you hear something like that
is Jeffrey just said it 's hard to deny it and ignore it , so the public . So what
is Jeffrey just said it 's hard to deny it and ignore it , so the public . So what
we may be doing is hearing stuff in public . The cuts against the defense , and then the president
we may be doing is hearing stuff in public . The cuts against the defense , and then the president
will have to deny the validity The cycle , Michael , go ahead . Michael cycle , Michael , go
will have to deny the validity | The cycle , Michael , go ahead . Michael | cycle , Michael , go
ahead . Michael is so adorable . He thinks the facts are actually going to matter at the trial .
ahead . Michael is so adorable . He thinks the facts are actually going to matter at the trial .
I just , you know , I want to give him a hug . It 's , it 's really
I just , you know , I want to give him a hug . It 's , it 's really
, it 's really great that you believe that I didn 't say that , but I appreciate that .
, it 's really great that you believe that | I didn 't say that , but I appreciate that .
|
|
Senator Elizabeth Warren insisted women 's issues and allegations of sexism our personal for her So the question many are
Senator Elizabeth Warren insisted women 's issues and allegations of sexism our personal for her | So the question many are
asking today . Why did she spend so much time attacking just Mayor Mike Bloomberg while appearing to give Senator
asking today . Why did she spend so much time attacking just Mayor Mike Bloomberg while appearing to give Senator
Sanders a pass with me now California Democratic congresswoman Katie Porter surrogate for the Warren campaign congresswoman , thank you
Sanders a pass with me now California Democratic congresswoman Katie Porter surrogate for the Warren campaign congresswoman , thank you
so much for joining me last night , Senator Warren came out swinging against Mayor Bloomberg again he 's not
so much for joining me last night , Senator Warren came out swinging against Mayor Bloomberg again he 's not
on the ballot in South Carolina instead of going after Senator Sanders , who leads her in delegates and he
on the ballot in South Carolina instead of going after Senator Sanders , who leads her in delegates and he
's in her same political lane what 's her strategy . What I heard from Elizabeth Warren and last night
's in her same political lane what 's her strategy . | What I heard from Elizabeth Warren and last night
was her ability to draw clear distinctions between herself and other candidates , including Senator Sanders , which I thought
was her ability to draw clear distinctions between herself and other candidates , including Senator Sanders , which I thought
she did very persuasively right at the start of the debate , but she did it in a way that
she did very persuasively right at the start of the debate , but she did it in a way that
isn 't sowing seeds of discord in the Democratic Party and in this process . So she clearly stated very
isn 't sowing seeds of discord in the Democratic Party and in this process . So she clearly stated very
very clearly why she 'd be a more effective president that Bernie Sanders she drew distinctions between they said yes
very clearly why she 'd be a more effective president that Bernie Sanders she drew distinctions between they said yes
we care about the same issues like Wall Street but look I 'm the one who actually got a consumer
we care about the same issues like Wall Street but look I 'm the one who actually got a consumer
agency put into law . We both care about and acting health care for people , but I 'm the
agency put into law . We both care about and acting health care for people , but I 'm the
one that has a detailed plan that shows respect for every voter by giving them that information . So I
one that has a detailed plan that shows respect for every voter by giving them that information . So I
actually thought what she did really well was draw distinctions between herself and the other Democrats on the stage without
actually thought what she did really well was draw distinctions between herself and the other Democrats on the stage without
kind falling into some of the yelling and shouting and talking over each other . I think she sounded very
kind falling into some of the yelling and shouting and talking over each other . I think she sounded very
presidential last night . Well , she 's not opposed to yelling and shouting and she did say and I
presidential last night . | Well , she 's not opposed to yelling and shouting and she did say and I
feel that that addressing sexism is very personal for her . It 's not political and she 's pressing mayor
feel that that addressing sexism is very personal for her . It 's not political and she 's pressing mayor
Bloomberg and she has every right to on his past comments about women , but if that 's the case
Bloomberg and she has every right to on his past comments about women , but if that 's the case
, if it 's personal , not political . Why isn 't she raising similar concerns about Senator Sanders .
, if it 's personal , not political . Why isn 't she raising similar concerns about Senator Sanders .
His campaign was hit with allegations of harassment , less than 4 years ago . Well , I think one
His campaign was hit with allegations of harassment , less than 4 years ago . | Well , I think one
of the differences is that the conduct that we 're talking about is with regard to Mayor Bloomberg personally it
of the differences is that the conduct that we 're talking about is with regard to Mayor Bloomberg personally it
's not with regard to his organization , although obviously his organization needs to take responsibility . I just saw
's not with regard to his organization , although obviously his organization needs to take responsibility . I just saw
the other day that his organization in response to Elizabeth Warren pressing him on this issue has announced mandatory sexual
the other day that his organization in response to Elizabeth Warren pressing him on this issue has announced mandatory sexual
harassment training which most companies and organizations have adopted long ago , so I think she is effective as an
harassment training which most companies and organizations have adopted long ago , so I think she is effective as an
advocate for women , and women 's issues . But I think what you really see from her as a
advocate for women , and women 's issues . But I think what you really see from her as a
willingness to tackle these hard issues and hold people to account , something that she 's been willing to do
willingness to tackle these hard issues and hold people to account , something that she 's been willing to do
and so she has a long record of being willing to stand up to be a powerful voice to some
and so she has a long record of being willing to stand up to be a powerful voice to some
of the most powerful financial institutions in the world and now 2 powerful people on the political stage , including
of the most powerful financial institutions in the world and now 2 powerful people on the political stage , including
Mayor Bloomberg , she 's not afraid of him . She 's not afraid of Donald Trump , but she
Mayor Bloomberg , she 's not afraid of him . She 's not afraid of Donald Trump , but she
showed that she knows how to press people to make the changes . The American people need and deserve without
showed that she knows how to press people to make the changes . The American people need and deserve without
falling into some of the shouting and insecurity that way , I think we saw from some of the other
falling into some of the shouting and insecurity that way , I think we saw from some of the other
candidates . But she made the decision to back away from Senator Sanders , who had said to her .
candidates . | But she made the decision to back away from Senator Sanders , who had said to her | .
A woman cannot win the election . A woman can be president . She 's not pressuring me that and
A woman cannot win the election . A woman can be president . | She 's not pressuring me that and
| pressuring me that and she made very clear that she thought that statement was unacceptable and that she disagreed strongly
| pressuring me that and she made very clear that she thought that statement was unacceptable and that she disagreed strongly
with it but the reality here is that she 's focused on beating President Trump she 's focused on needing
with it but the reality here is that she 's focused on beating President Trump she 's focused on needing
to build the winning coalition to defeat Donald Trump in November . So it 's possible to draw a distinction
to build the winning coalition to defeat Donald Trump in November . So it 's possible to draw a distinction
. So , she said . Very clearly to Senator Sanders . I think what you said was wrong .
. So , she said . Very clearly to Senator Sanders . I think what you said was wrong .
I disagree . Clearly we we . I definitely think a woman can win . I 'm going to be
I disagree . Clearly we we . I definitely think a woman can win . I 'm going to be
that woman she didn 't back away from that statement . But she didn 't throw unnecessary flames at him
that woman she didn 't back away from that statement . But she didn 't throw unnecessary flames at him
and I frankly don 't think she 's been unnecessarily harsh with Mayor Bloomberg either . I think he has
and I frankly don 't think she 's been unnecessarily harsh with Mayor Bloomberg either . I think he has
reacted poorly to what are pretty normal criticisms and back and forth that you 'll see on the debate stage
reacted poorly to what are pretty normal criticisms and back and forth that you 'll see on the debate stage
. The fact that he 's late to the party . The fact that he has a long term refill
. The fact that he 's late to the party . The fact that he has a long term refill
issue with Republicans open him up to some critiques that he needs to be prepared to deal with . It
issue with Republicans open him up to some critiques that he needs to be prepared to deal with . It
's not fair to put this back on Senator Warren she 's doing her job which is exposing differences between
's not fair to put this back on Senator Warren she 's doing her job which is exposing differences between
the candidates for voters to see and judge for themselves and respectful mature way . Absolutely . I don 't
the candidates for voters to see and judge for themselves and respectful mature way . | Absolutely . I don 't
just a great quickly before we go as a sitting member of Congress , when you see Bernie Sanders economic
just a great quickly before we go as a sitting member of Congress , when you see Bernie Sanders economic
plan , free college , free trade school Medicare free housing , erasing student debt and medical debt , how
plan , free college , free trade school Medicare free housing , erasing student debt and medical debt , how
realistic is it to get something like that passed you know all the things Elizabeth Warren has gotten past ,
realistic is it to get something like that passed you know all the things Elizabeth Warren has gotten past ,
think about the money . She 's brought in from CFPB . No , look , you have to have
think about the money . She 's brought in from CFPB . | No , look , you have to have
a plan for how you 're going to get it done . The deed . The details matter being able
a plan for how you 're going to get it done . The deed . The details matter being able
to explain to skeptics , how are you going to fund this . How is this going to work .
to explain to skeptics , how are you going to fund this . How is this going to work .
Where do the steps you 're going to take to pass it . And so , while I agree with
Where do the steps you 're going to take to pass it . And so , while I agree with
some of Senator Sanders goals for me there naked statements . What I want to know is how are you
some of Senator Sanders goals for me there naked statements . What I want to know is how are you
going to knock this and I want to make sure that the ideas that you 're bringing to the table
going to knock this and I want to make sure that the ideas that you 're bringing to the table
were developed in partnership with community . So the way that Elizabeth Warren has listened to for instance to unions
were developed in partnership with community . So the way that Elizabeth Warren has listened to for instance to unions
who have negotiated hard for their health insurance and then brought them into the conversation about her Medicare plan about
who have negotiated hard for their health insurance and then brought them into the conversation about her Medicare plan about
her is a real point of contrast with Senator Sanders and I think we 've seen her do that time
her is a real point of contrast with Senator Sanders and I think we 've seen her do that time
and time again which is reached out to the community . She 's a great teacher , but she 's
and time again which is reached out to the community . She 's a great teacher , but she 's
a really good listener and that 's a really important quality in a president . Hey there I 'm Chris
a really good listener and that 's a really important quality in a president . | Hey there I 'm Chris
Hayes from MSNBC . Thanks for watching MSNBC on YouTube . If you want to keep up to date with
Hayes from MSNBC . Thanks for watching MSNBC on YouTube . If you want to keep up to date with
the videos were putting out you can click subscribe just below me or click over on this list to see
the videos were putting out you can click subscribe just below me or click over on this list to see
lots of other great videos .
lots of other great videos . |
So here we are , it is officially the 3rd presidential democratic debate . You saw the 10 strongest contenders
So here we are , it is officially the 3rd presidential democratic debate . You saw the 10 strongest contenders
people were really focused on the 4 up top . When you look at this debate though fundamentally do you
people were really focused on the 4 up top . When you look at this debate though fundamentally do you
think Democrats are getting the right message across . On the , you know on the screen . On the
think Democrats are getting the right message across . On the , you know on the screen . On the
night . I think that for the Democratic primary voters who just really want to beat Trump . That 's
night . | I think that for the Democratic primary voters who just really want to beat Trump . That 's
the only thing they care about , kind of right . The first 20 minutes of the debate was spent
the only thing they care about , kind of right . The first 20 minutes of the debate was spent
arguing about health care and health care is very important . Right , but we 've kind of rehashed that
arguing about health care and health care is very important . Right , but we 've kind of rehashed that
we 've had that debate before it 's rehashing past thing is I think what a lot of Democratic voters
we 've had that debate before it 's rehashing past thing is I think what a lot of Democratic voters
. Just want to know is how capable or you 're going to be on the debate Trump how able
. Just want to know is how capable or you 're going to be on the debate Trump how able
, you 're going to be to beat Trump in some of that was discussed a lot of other stuff
, you 're going to be to beat Trump in some of that was discussed a lot of other stuff
was discussed as well about policy . But I 'm not sure that Democratic voters are all that invested in
was discussed as well about policy . But I 'm not sure that Democratic voters are all that invested in
these policy . That 's interesting . So do you think the Democratic primaries should be more focused on like
these policy . | That 's interesting . So do you think the Democratic primaries should be more focused on like
who looks good on stage who sounds good , who has a feeling of being Presidential because it 's mostly
who looks good on stage who sounds good , who has a feeling of being Presidential because it 's mostly
Democratic voters who are going to decide what 's gonna happen . So the crazy thing is Democratic voters really
Democratic voters who are going to decide what 's gonna happen . | So the crazy thing is Democratic voters really
want to beat Trump and they have firm ideas about what being electable means , but the fact that Trump
want to beat Trump and they have firm ideas about what being electable means , but the fact that Trump
is president means that literally anyone 's electable So it 's hard to figure out exactly who won that stage
is president means that literally anyone 's electable | So it 's hard to figure out exactly who won that stage
would be best for that task , right , is it . Biden , who polls very well consistently high
would be best for that task , right , is it . Biden , who polls very well consistently high
against Trump very conventional former vice president is it Bernie Sanders , who also polls very well against Trump has
against Trump very conventional former vice president is it Bernie Sanders , who also polls very well against Trump has