id
int64 6
49.9k
| object1
stringlengths 3
32
| object2
stringlengths 3
28
| original_img
imagewidth (px) 1.28k
1.28k
| edited_img
imagewidth (px) 1.28k
1.28k
| sc_score
dict | min_sc_score
int64 0
10
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
38,756 | Christmas tree | sculpture | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The Christmas tree in the original image has been replaced by a sculpture in the edited image. The sculpture is distinct and there is no trace of the Christmas tree, fulfilling the editing instruction effectively.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the Christmas tree with the sculpture. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
1,878 | respect | kindness | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not effectively replace 'respect' with 'kindness' as the text in both images is nonsensical and does not convey either concept. There is no clear evidence of the intended replacement.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and the person remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to the text. There is no overediting beyond the text replacement attempt.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
10,310 | statues | paintings | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not replace the statues with paintings as instructed. Instead, the statues are replaced with human-like figures, which does not align with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction by changing the appearance of the figures entirely, including their facial features and clothing, which is unrelated to replacing statues with paintings.",
"score": [
0,
2
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 2
} | 0 |
||
12,173 | pictures | videos | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not replace pictures with videos as instructed. The edited image still contains pictures, and there is no evidence of videos being introduced.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image introduces significant changes beyond the instruction, including a complete change in the layout, background, and content. This goes beyond the scope of replacing pictures with videos.",
"score": [
0,
0
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 0
} | 0 |
||
47,245 | waterfall | river | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still clearly shows a waterfall, and no river has replaced it. The editing instruction has not been followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable overediting or changes irrelevant to the instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
14,231 | cover | poster | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the cover with a poster. The original image contains a cover-like design, while the edited image clearly displays a poster with a different layout and content. There is a clear distinction between the two objects.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the replacement of the cover with the poster. The background and other elements remain consistent with the editing instruction, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
46,602 | couple | family | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the couple with a family, as the scene now includes a child along with the couple, forming a family. The edit aligns well with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements irrelevant to the editing instruction. The edit focuses solely on replacing the couple with a family.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
39,800 | Chanel | Gucci | {
"reasoning for Task1": "There is no visible evidence of Chanel being replaced by Gucci in the edited image. Both images appear identical, and no changes reflecting the editing instruction are observed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "Since there is no visible change between the original and edited images, there is no overediting. The scene remains consistent and unchanged.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
37,771 | books | vases | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains books on the table, and no vases have replaced them. The editing instruction to replace books with vases was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes in the scene beyond the editing instruction, as the images are nearly identical. No overediting is observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
19,450 | gecko | butterfly | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The gecko in the original image has been successfully replaced by a butterfly in the edited image. There is no gecko remaining, and the butterfly is clearly visible, making the edit align perfectly with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and flowers remain consistent between the two images, and there are no noticeable changes beyond the replacement of the gecko with the butterfly. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,321 | award plaque | trophy | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the award plaque, and no trophy is present. The editing instruction to replace the award plaque with a trophy was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes beyond the editing instruction. The background, person, and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
16,280 | dress | jacket | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the dress with a jacket, as per the instruction. However, the dress is still partially visible underneath the jacket, which reduces the effectiveness of the edit.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the replacement of the dress with the jacket. The background and other elements remain consistent, and the overediting is minimal.",
"score": [
6,
9
],
"score for Task1": 6,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 6 |
||
8,152 | wedding cake | birthday cake | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image shows a wedding cake with a simple design, while the edited image shows a cake with a more elaborate design featuring seashells and starfish. However, the edited image does not clearly represent a birthday cake, as the decorations do not align with typical birthday cake themes. The edit does not fully follow the instruction to replace the wedding cake with a birthday cake.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and overall structure of the cake remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to the decorations on the cake. There is no significant overediting beyond the decoration change, so the edit adheres closely to the instruction.",
"score": [
4,
9
],
"score for Task1": 4,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 4 |
||
47,034 | shoe | boot | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The shoe in the original image has been successfully replaced by a boot in the edited image. The boot is distinct and there is no trace of the shoe in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the shoe with the boot. The background, pants, and other elements remain unchanged, indicating no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
13,448 | guitar | drum | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The guitar in the original image has been replaced by a drum in the edited image, fulfilling the editing instruction. However, the individuals and setting have changed significantly, which affects the evaluation.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image shows significant changes beyond the replacement of the guitar with a drum, including changes in the individuals, their poses, and the background. This indicates overediting.",
"score": [
7,
3
],
"score for Task1": 7,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 3 |
||
3,102 | painting | photograph | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not replace a painting with a photograph. Both images appear to retain a painted style, and there is no clear transition to a photographic style.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image shows changes to the dogs' appearances, but the background and overall scene remain consistent with the original. These changes are unrelated to the instruction and indicate overediting.",
"score": [
0,
4
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 4
} | 0 |
||
33,424 | television | music system | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains televisions in the same positions as the original image, and no music system is visible. The editing instruction to replace the television with a music system was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes in the edited image beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains identical to the original image.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
2,370 | Bridesmaids | Groomsmen | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the bridesmaids with groomsmen, and there are no visible traces of bridesmaids remaining. The replacement aligns perfectly with the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain consistent between the original and edited images, with no overediting beyond the replacement of bridesmaids with groomsmen.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
495 | van | truck | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The van in the original image has been successfully replaced by a truck in the edited image. The truck is clearly distinguishable from the van, and there is no van remaining in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on replacing the van with the truck, and the background and other elements remain consistent between the two images. There is no evidence of overediting beyond the instructed change.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
42,009 | girl | boy | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the girl, and no boy has been introduced. The editing instruction to replace the girl with a boy has not been followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable overediting in the second image. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
11,146 | blue | green | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The blue wall in the original image has been successfully replaced by a green wall in the edited image. There is no trace of blue remaining, and the green is distinct and clearly visible.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The rest of the scene, including the furniture, lighting, and other elements, remains unchanged. The edit is limited to the wall color as per the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
8,606 | sneakers | boots | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The sneakers in the original image have been successfully replaced by boots in the edited image. The boots are distinct and there is no trace of the sneakers, fulfilling the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the sneakers with boots. The background, pose, and other elements remain unchanged, indicating no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
22,304 | sunglasses | hat | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains sunglasses, and a hat has been added without replacing the sunglasses. This does not follow the editing instruction to replace sunglasses with a hat.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The addition of the hat does not significantly alter the background or other elements of the image. However, the sunglasses remain, which is irrelevant to the instruction. The edit is limited to adding the hat, so there is no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
8,510 | Chocolate bars | textbooks | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains chocolate bars alongside textbooks, which violates the instruction to replace chocolate bars entirely with textbooks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and overall scene have changed significantly, which goes beyond the instruction to replace chocolate bars with textbooks.",
"score": [
0,
2
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 2
} | 0 |
||
45,524 | business | restaurant | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the business with a restaurant. The signage and outdoor seating area clearly indicate a restaurant, and there is no visible trace of the original business.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces changes beyond the replacement of the business with a restaurant. The outdoor seating area and some signage elements have been altered, which goes beyond the instruction of replacing the business with a restaurant.",
"score": [
10,
6
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 6
} | 6 |
||
41,708 | entertainment center | bookshelf | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The entertainment center in the original image has not been fully replaced by a bookshelf. While the top section has been modified to resemble a bookshelf, the overall structure and appearance of the entertainment center remain largely unchanged.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the editing instruction. The background, furniture, and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
4,
9
],
"score for Task1": 4,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 4 |
||
39,577 | bear cub | puppy | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bear cub in the original image has been successfully replaced by a puppy in the edited image. The replacement is clear and follows the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, the person, and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the bear cub with the puppy. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
30,878 | chef shirt | apron | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The chef shirt in the original image has been successfully replaced by an apron in the edited image. The apron is clearly visible, and there is no trace of the chef shirt.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on replacing the chef shirt with an apron. However, the edited image introduces a person wearing the apron, which is beyond the scope of the editing instruction. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
10,
4
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 4
} | 4 |
||
4,949 | sofa | chair | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The sofa in the original image has been successfully replaced by a chair in the edited image. The chair is distinct and there is no sofa present in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit strictly follows the instruction without any overediting. The background and other elements remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the sofa with the chair.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
14,018 | quilt | blanket | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a quilt rather than a blanket. The pattern and texture remain consistent with a quilt, and there is no evidence of a blanket replacing it.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit is limited to the quilt's pattern, which does not fulfill the instruction but does not overedit the scene.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
39,185 | pens | markers | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The pens in the original image have been successfully replaced by markers in the edited image. There are no pens remaining, and the markers are clearly distinguishable from the pens in the original image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing pens with markers. There is no evidence of overediting beyond the specified instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
21,555 | balance beam | trampoline | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The balance beam in the original image has been successfully replaced by a trampoline in the edited image. There is a clear and effective difference between the two images, and the trampoline is prominently visible while the balance beam is completely removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background has changed significantly from an indoor arena to an outdoor park, which is beyond the scope of the editing instruction. This constitutes overediting as the scene has been altered beyond the replacement of the balance beam with a trampoline.",
"score": [
10,
3
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 3 |
||
28,384 | smartphone | tablet | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a smartphone instead of a tablet, so the editing instruction to replace the smartphone with a tablet was not followed at all.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are identical, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are present.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
27,688 | laptop | notebook | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The laptop in the original image has been successfully replaced by a notebook in the edited image. The notebook is clearly distinguishable, and there is no laptop present in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the laptop with a notebook. The background and other elements remain unchanged, and there is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
40,748 | wood panels | metal sheets | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The wood panels in the original image have been replaced by metal sheets in the edited image. The replacement is clear and follows the instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the wood panels with metal sheets. The background, structure, and other elements remain unchanged, and there is no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
11,958 | baby | puppy | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The baby in the original image has been successfully replaced by two puppies in the edited image. There is no trace of the baby, and the puppies are clearly present. However, the instruction specifies replacing the baby with a single puppy, so the presence of two puppies slightly deviates from the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited images. The only noticeable change is the replacement of the baby with puppies, which aligns with the editing instruction. There is no significant overediting beyond the object replacement.",
"score": [
8,
9
],
"score for Task1": 8,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 8 |
||
9,096 | eye | nose | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows eyes and does not replace them with noses as per the instruction. There is no visible change in the image to reflect the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no overediting as the edited image is identical to the original image, with no changes beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
39,991 | cars | bicycles | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains a car in the background, which violates the instruction to replace cars with bicycles. While a bicycle is present in the foreground, the car's presence results in a failure to fully follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the replacement attempt. The background, characters, and overall scene remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
0,
9
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 0 |
||
12,691 | flower | leaf | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The flower in the original image has been successfully replaced by a leaf in the edited image. There is a clear and effective difference between the two images, and no flower remains in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the flower with a leaf, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
10,022 | t - shirt | sweater | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The t-shirt in the original image has been successfully replaced by a sweater in the edited image. The sweater is clearly visible, and there is no trace of the t-shirt.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the t-shirt with a sweater. The background and other elements remain consistent, and there are no additional changes beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
25,279 | place settings | tablecloths | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the place settings (plates, glasses, and cutlery) from the original image, even though tablecloths have been added. Since the place settings were not removed as per the instruction, the edit does not fully follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces tablecloths without altering other elements of the scene, such as the chairs, background, or lighting. The changes are limited to the addition of tablecloths, and there is no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
45,924 | skirt | dress | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already shows a dress, not a skirt. Therefore, the editing instruction to replace a skirt with a dress is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable change between the two images beyond the editing instruction, as the original image already had a dress. The edit does not introduce any overediting.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
7,775 | stove | sofa | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The stove in the original image has been replaced by a fireplace instead of a sofa, which does not follow the editing instruction. The sofa already exists in the original image, so the instruction is not fulfilled.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image retains the overall scene and background, with no significant changes beyond the replacement of the stove with a fireplace. However, the edit does not follow the instruction, and the replacement is not accurate.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
45,282 | bedding | blanket | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bedding in the original image has been replaced with a blanket in the edited image. The blanket has a similar design but with larger floral patterns, making it distinct from the original bedding. The edit aligns well with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on replacing the bedding with a blanket, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit is limited to the instructed object replacement.",
"score": [
9,
10
],
"score for Task1": 9,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 9 |
||
33,680 | suit | costume | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The suit in the original image remains unchanged in the edited image, and no costume is introduced. The editing instruction to replace the suit with a costume was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable change between the two images, and no overediting is present. The scene remains consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
23,662 | furniture | decorations | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The furniture (yellow chair) in the original image has been replaced with a red chair, which is still furniture and not decorations. Therefore, the editing instruction to replace furniture with decorations has not been followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The overall scene remains consistent, with no significant changes to the background or other elements irrelevant to the editing instruction. The edit is limited to the replacement of the chair.",
"score": [
0,
9
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 0 |
||
39,557 | roses | tulips | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The roses in the original image have been successfully replaced by tulips in the edited image. There are no visible roses remaining, and the tulips are clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image, such as the white flowers and the vase, remain unchanged. The edit is limited to replacing roses with tulips, and there is no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
32,584 | hand | glove | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows the hand alongside the glove, and the hand has not been replaced by the glove as per the instruction. Therefore, the editing does not follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes to the background or other elements irrelevant to the editing instruction. The edit is limited to the hand and glove area.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
47,268 | Ford F - 350 | Toyota Tacoma | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a Ford F-350, and there is no evidence of a Toyota Tacoma replacing it. The editing instruction was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image, and the edit does not go beyond the instruction. However, since no replacement occurred, the score reflects the lack of overediting.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
30,491 | trash can | recycling bin | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a recycling bin, and there is no visible trash can in either image. Therefore, the editing instruction is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no significant change between the two images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
13,315 | band | singer | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the band with a single singer, as per the instruction. The band is no longer present, and the singer is clearly the focus of the scene.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and audience remain consistent between the two images, and the edit focuses solely on replacing the band with the singer. There is no evidence of overediting beyond the instructed change.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
33,405 | man | woman | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a man, and no woman is present. The editing instruction to replace the man with a woman was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction, as the background and other elements remain consistent. However, since the primary edit was not performed, the score is slightly reduced.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
33,938 | rugby team | soccer team | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The rugby team in the original image has been replaced by a soccer team in the edited image. The players are wearing soccer uniforms, and the rugby ball has been replaced with a soccer ball. The edit aligns well with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and overall scene remain consistent between the two images, with no significant changes beyond the replacement of the rugby team with the soccer team. However, there is a slight alteration in the arrangement of players, which slightly deviates from the instruction.",
"score": [
9,
8
],
"score for Task1": 9,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 8 |
||
36,382 | Christmas ball ornament | hanging plant | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The Christmas ball ornament has been successfully replaced by a hanging plant. There is no trace of the Christmas ball ornament in the edited image, and the hanging plant is clearly visible and well-integrated.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the Christmas ball ornament with the hanging plant. The background and other elements remain unchanged, and there is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
43,612 | painting | photograph | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains a painting instead of a photograph, so the editing instruction to replace the painting with a photograph was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes beyond the editing instruction, as the scene remains consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
23,994 | clock | watch | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a clock, and no watch is present. The editing instruction to replace the clock with a watch was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are identical, and no changes beyond the instruction were made.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
37,144 | ceremony | reception | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still depicts a ceremony-like setting with no clear indication of a reception. The changes are minimal and do not effectively replace the ceremony with a reception.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant overediting. The background and overall scene remain consistent, with only minor changes such as the addition of an umbrella.",
"score": [
2,
8
],
"score for Task1": 2,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 2 |
||
36,832 | soccer players | basketball players | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows soccer players instead of basketball players, so the editing instruction to replace soccer players with basketball players was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes to the background or other elements irrelevant to the editing instruction, so the degree of overediting is minimal.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
6,128 | truck | bus | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The truck in the original image has been successfully replaced by a bus in the edited image. There is no visible truck remaining, and the bus is clearly present, fulfilling the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the truck with the bus. The background, people, and other elements remain consistent between the two images, indicating no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
49,146 | table | desk | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image contains a table, and the edited image successfully replaces it with a desk. The desk is clearly distinguishable from the table, and there is no table remaining in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any significant changes beyond replacing the table with a desk. The background, people, and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
21,816 | table | chair | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The table in the original image has been successfully replaced by a chair in the edited image. There is no table present in the edited image, and the chair is clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused solely on replacing the table with a chair. The background and other elements remain unchanged, and there is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
44,768 | glasses | bottle | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The glasses in the original image have been replaced by a bottle in the edited image. However, parts of the glasses, such as the arms, are still present in the edited image, which does not fully follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and lighting remain consistent between the two images, and the changes are limited to the replacement of the glasses with the bottle. There is no significant overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
5,
9
],
"score for Task1": 5,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 5 |
||
16,585 | jumpsuit | dress | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a jumpsuit, and no dress is present. The editing instruction to replace the jumpsuit with a dress was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are identical, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are present.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
33,727 | engagement ring | necklace | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a necklace, and there is no visible engagement ring in either image. Therefore, the editing instruction to replace an engagement ring with a necklace is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no significant change between the two images beyond minor adjustments in lighting or angle, which are irrelevant to the editing instruction. The edit does not introduce overediting.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
21,377 | houses | apartments | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows houses instead of apartments, and there is no effective replacement of houses by apartments.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image does not show any significant changes beyond the editing instruction, as the background and other elements remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
10,754 | ball | soccer cleats | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The ball in the original image has not been replaced by soccer cleats in the edited image. The ball remains present, and no soccer cleats have been added in its place.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes in the edited image beyond the editing instruction. The background, players, and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
32,572 | flag | banner | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The flag in the original image has been replaced by a banner in the edited image. The banner is distinct and there is no flag remaining, making the edit successful.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, buildings, and other elements remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the flag with the banner. There is no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
8,312 | china cabinet | bookshelf | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The china cabinet in the original image has been successfully replaced by a bookshelf in the edited image. The bookshelf is distinct and there is no trace of the china cabinet, fulfilling the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces changes beyond the replacement of the china cabinet with the bookshelf. The chairs, table decor, and rug have been altered, which goes beyond the specified instruction.",
"score": [
10,
4
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 4
} | 4 |
||
18,910 | men | dogs | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not fully follow the instruction to replace men with dogs. While a dog is present, one man is still visible in the edited image, which violates the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and overall scene remain consistent between the two images, with no significant overediting beyond the replacement attempt. However, the presence of a man alongside the dog suggests some deviation from the instruction.",
"score": [
3,
8
],
"score for Task1": 3,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 3 |
||
28,123 | flared trousers | skinny jeans | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already shows skinny jeans, so no replacement of flared trousers was necessary. The edited image also shows skinny jeans, meaning the editing instruction was not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The only noticeable change between the two images is the handbag, which is irrelevant to the editing instruction. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
0,
3
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 0 |
||
34,305 | Halloumi salad | Quinoa salad | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains pieces of Halloumi cheese, which indicates that the Halloumi salad was not fully replaced by Quinoa salad. While some changes were made, the edit does not fully follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain consistent, and the changes are limited to the salad. However, the addition of raisins and other minor changes to the salad go beyond the instruction to simply replace Halloumi salad with Quinoa salad.",
"score": [
3,
7
],
"score for Task1": 3,
"score for Task2": 7
} | 3 |
||
5,616 | yard | garden | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image introduces a garden-like feature with paved pathways, but the yard is still predominantly present, and the change is minimal. The yard and garden are too similar, making the edit less effective.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not significantly alter elements beyond the yard-to-garden replacement. The house, background, and other elements remain consistent, indicating minimal overediting.",
"score": [
4,
9
],
"score for Task1": 4,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 4 |
||
14,005 | ring | necklace | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The ring in the original image has been successfully replaced by a necklace in the edited image. The necklace is clearly visible, and the ring is no longer present.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements remain consistent between the two images, and the edit is limited to replacing the ring with the necklace. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
2,516 | chest | table | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The chest in the original image has been successfully replaced by a table in the edited image. The table is clearly visible, and the chest is no longer present. The edit aligns well with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements remain consistent between the two images, and the edit is limited to replacing the chest with the table. There is no evidence of overediting beyond the instructed change.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
29,210 | wall lamp | chandelier | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The wall lamp in the original image has been replaced by a chandelier in the edited image. The chandelier is clearly visible, and the wall lamp is no longer present. The edit follows the instruction effectively.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the wall lamp with the chandelier. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
8,170 | boot | shoe | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a boot instead of a shoe, so the editing instruction to replace the boot with a shoe was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image does not show any significant changes beyond the boot's design, and the background and other elements remain consistent. However, the boot's design was altered slightly, which is irrelevant to the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
25,085 | wallet | purse | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a purse, not a wallet. Therefore, the editing instruction to replace a wallet with a purse is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image does not introduce any changes beyond the object replacement instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
18,132 | plates | bowls | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The plates in the original image have been replaced by bowls in the edited image. However, the plates are still present in the edited image, as the bowls were added alongside the plates rather than replacing them.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited images. The changes are limited to the addition of bowls and the replacement of food items, which aligns with the editing instruction.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
31,277 | pizza | sandwich | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The pizza in the original image has been successfully replaced by a sandwich in the edited image. There is no visible trace of the pizza, and the sandwich is clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the pizza with the sandwich. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
28,470 | peanut butter fudge | chocolate truffles | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The peanut butter fudge in the original image has been completely replaced by chocolate truffles in the edited image. There is no trace of peanut butter fudge, and the chocolate truffles are clearly distinct.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused solely on replacing the peanut butter fudge with chocolate truffles. The background, plate, and overall composition remain unchanged, indicating no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
13,132 | chain link fence | wooden dock | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The chain link fence in the original image has been successfully replaced by a wooden dock in the edited image. The wooden dock is clearly visible, and there is no trace of the chain link fence. The edit aligns perfectly with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses solely on replacing the chain link fence with the wooden dock. The background, water, and surrounding elements remain consistent between the two images, with no overediting observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
31,075 | chair | table | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The chair in the original image has been successfully replaced by a table in the edited image. The table is clearly visible, and the chair is no longer present. The edit aligns well with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the scene remain consistent between the two images, except for the addition of objects on the table, which is reasonable and does not constitute overediting. The edit focuses on the instructed object replacement.",
"score": [
10,
9
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 9 |
||
20,980 | wheel | bike tire | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show a clear replacement of the wheel with a bike tire. The wheel remains visually identical to the original image, and there is no effective difference between the two images.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes beyond the editing instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
2,978 | makeup sponge | foundation brush | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The makeup sponge in the original image has been successfully replaced by a foundation brush in the edited image. The foundation brush is clearly visible, and the makeup sponge is no longer present. The edit aligns perfectly with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any changes beyond the replacement of the makeup sponge with the foundation brush. The person, background, and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
25,554 | poker chips | dominoes | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The poker chips in the original image have been successfully replaced by dominoes in the edited image. There are no visible poker chips remaining, and the dominoes are clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on replacing poker chips with dominoes, and there are no significant changes to the background, cards, or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
48,314 | coasters | mugs | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The coasters in the original image have been replaced by mugs in the edited image, and there are no coasters visible in the edited image. The replacement is clear and follows the instruction effectively.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the scene remain consistent between the two images, and the edit is limited to replacing coasters with mugs. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
26,668 | bride | hiker | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bride is still present in the edited image, and the hiker has not replaced her. Instead, a backpack has been added, which does not fulfill the instruction to replace the bride with a hiker.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain unchanged, and the edit only adds a backpack. However, the addition of the backpack is irrelevant to the instruction and constitutes a minor overedit.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
36,273 | carton of cherry juice | bottle of orange juice | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The carton of cherry juice in the original image has been successfully replaced by a bottle of orange juice in the edited image. The replacement is clear and follows the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the carton of cherry juice with the bottle of orange juice. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
22,996 | sandals | boots | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The sandals in the original image have been successfully replaced by boots in the edited image. The boots are clearly visible, and there are no remnants of the sandals.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused solely on replacing the sandals with boots. The background, lighting, and other elements remain unchanged, and there is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
5,389 | tiger | lion | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The tiger in the original image has been successfully replaced by a lion in the edited image. The lion is distinct and there is no trace of the tiger remaining. The edit follows the instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the tiger with the lion. There is no evidence of overediting beyond the instructed change.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
43,592 | washroom | kitchen | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already depicts a kitchen, and the edited image also shows a kitchen. Since the original image does not contain a washroom, the editing instruction is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The changes between the two images are limited to the cabinet color and minor details, which are irrelevant to the editing instruction. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
0,
3
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 0 |
||
44,682 | rafts | kayaks | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The rafts in the original image have been successfully replaced by kayaks in the edited image. There are no visible rafts remaining, and the kayaks are clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on replacing the rafts with kayaks without altering the background or other elements of the scene. The people and environment remain consistent, and there is no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
27,651 | Toms slip on shoes | sandals | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The Toms slip-on shoes in the original image have been successfully replaced by sandals in the edited image. The sandals are clearly visible and distinct from the original shoes.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on replacing the shoes with sandals without altering the background or other elements of the image. The legs and jeans remain consistent, and there is no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
40,598 | mandap | archway | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image does not contain a mandap, and the edited image already has an archway. Since there is no mandap to replace, the editing instruction is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image only adds floral decorations to the existing archway, which is beyond the instruction to replace a mandap with an archway. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
0,
3
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 0 |
||
35,756 | ring | necklace | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the ring, and the necklace is added without replacing the ring. This does not follow the editing instruction to replace the ring with a necklace.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces a necklace but does not alter the background or other elements of the image. However, the ring remains, which is irrelevant to the instruction. The edit is not beyond the scope of object replacement.",
"score": [
0,
7
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 7
} | 0 |
||
40,616 | lawn chairs | hammocks | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The lawn chairs in the original image have been successfully replaced by hammocks in the edited image. There are no lawn chairs remaining, and the hammocks are clearly visible and distinct.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the replacement of lawn chairs with hammocks. The background, setting, and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
22,392 | workstation pedal | guitar pedal | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The workstation pedal in the original image has been successfully replaced by a guitar pedal in the edited image. The replacement is clear, and there is a distinct difference between the two objects.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to the object replacement as per the instruction. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
35,410 | fire engine | toy car | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The fire engine in the original image has been successfully replaced by a toy car in the edited image. There is no visible trace of the fire engine, and the toy car is clearly distinct.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited images. The edit is limited to replacing the fire engine with the toy car, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
25,304 | handbag | backpack | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The handbag in the original image has been successfully replaced by a backpack in the edited image. There is no handbag present in the edited image, and the backpack is clearly visible.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the handbag with a backpack. The background and other elements remain consistent, and there are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
22,336 | Sanremole | Florence | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show any visible change from the original image, and Florence is already present in the original image. Therefore, the editing instruction to replace Sanremole by Florence is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no visible overediting or any change irrelevant to the editing instruction. The two images are identical.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 41