Dataset Viewer
id
int64 472
19.4k
| object
stringlengths 3
19
| original_img
imagewidth (px) 1.28k
1.28k
| edited_img
imagewidth (px) 1.28k
1.28k
| sc_score
dict | min_sc_score
int64 0
10
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
17,549 | glittering confetti | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds glittering confetti to the scene, and the confetti appears to interact naturally with the environment by lying on the red carpet. The addition does not look pasted or unnatural, and no watermark is present.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding glittering confetti, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,557 | bus stop | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bus stop has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural, blends well with the environment, and interacts with the scene by casting shadows. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image seems to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding the bus stop, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
12,188 | streetlight | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a streetlight to the scene, and it appears natural with proper interaction with the environment, such as casting a shadow. No elements from the original image are removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding a streetlight, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
17,125 | shopping bag | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a shopping bag, and the edited image replaces it with a different shopping bag. Since the instruction was to add a shopping bag, not replace it, the edit does not follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit involves replacing the shopping bag rather than adding one, but no other elements in the image are changed. The background and other aspects remain consistent, so the edit is not overly extensive.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
1,735 | wall sconces | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains wall sconces, so the editing instruction to add wall sconces is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no significant change between the two images beyond the editing instruction, as the scene remains consistent and no additional elements are introduced.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
17,009 | pathway | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a pathway, and no new pathway has been added in the edited image. Therefore, the editing instruction has not been followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable change between the two images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
6,904 | street lamp | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The street lamp has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural and blends well with the environment, with appropriate lighting and shadows. No part of the original image seems to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the street lamp, and there are no other changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
13,825 | fruit | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds fruits (e.g., strawberry, apple, and others) to the scene. The fruits appear natural and blend well with the environment, with appropriate lighting and shadows. No elements from the original image are removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding fruits as per the instruction. No other changes to the background or unrelated elements are observed, and the scene remains consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
5,960 | chandelier | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The chandelier has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears to blend naturally with the environment. The lighting and shadows are consistent with the scene, and no part of the original image seems to have been removed. There are no watermarks in either image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the chandelier, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
9,245 | food cart | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The food cart is already present in the original image, so the editing instruction to add a food cart is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable change between the two images beyond the editing instruction, as no additional edits or changes are visible.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
7,023 | flagstick | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The flagstick has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears natural with proper interaction with the environment, including appropriate shadowing. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image has been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the flagstick, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
5,282 | stone pathway | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully includes a stone pathway that was not present in the original image. The pathway appears natural, blends well with the environment, and interacts with the scene without looking pasted or awkward. No elements from the original image were removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes in the edited image beyond the addition of the stone pathway. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
12,386 | walking path | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a walking path, so no addition of a walking path was necessary. Therefore, the score is 0.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable change between the original and edited images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
4,744 | bicycle | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bicycle has been added to the edited image, and it interacts naturally with the environment, including appropriate shadows. The addition does not appear pasted or unnatural. No elements from the original image were removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the bicycle, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
9,411 | lighthouse | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The lighthouse has been successfully added to the edited image, and it blends naturally with the environment. The lighting and shadows are consistent with the scene, and no part of the original image appears to have been removed. The addition looks natural and does not stand out awkwardly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the lighthouse, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
6,006 | dog | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The dog has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears natural in the scene with proper interaction with the environment, such as shadows. No part of the original image seems to have been removed, and the addition blends well.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the dog, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
7,577 | stone path | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a stone path to the scene, which was not present in the original image. The stone path appears natural and blends well with the environment, with appropriate interaction with the grass and lighting. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses solely on adding the stone path as instructed. The background and other elements remain unchanged, and no additional objects or modifications beyond the instruction are present.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
12,158 | bird feeder | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bird feeder has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural in the scene, with appropriate lighting and shadows that blend well with the environment. No part of the original image seems to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the bird feeder, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
9,612 | trash can | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The trash can has been added to the edited image as per the instruction. It appears natural in the scene, with appropriate lighting and shadow interaction with the environment. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image has been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the trash can, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
16,295 | train schedule | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The train schedule has been added to the edited image, replacing the original sign. The schedule appears natural and blends well with the environment, including proper alignment and lighting. No watermark is present, and nothing else from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding the train schedule, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements. However, the replacement of the original sign could be considered a slight overedit.",
"score": [
9,
8
],
"score for Task1": 9,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 8 |
||
19,430 | street vendor | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image includes a street vendor on a bicycle, which was not present in the original image. The vendor appears to interact naturally with the environment, casting a shadow and blending well with the scene. No elements from the original image appear to have been removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on adding the street vendor, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements of the scene. However, the addition of the vendor's bicycle and associated items could be considered slightly beyond the instruction of just adding a 'street vendor.'",
"score": [
9,
8
],
"score for Task1": 9,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 8 |
||
6,574 | banner | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image includes a banner added to the microphone stand, which aligns with the editing instruction. The banner appears somewhat natural but lacks perfect integration with the environment, as it looks slightly pasted on and does not have clear shadows or blending. No elements from the original image appear to be removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding the banner, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
7,
10
],
"score for Task1": 7,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 7 |
||
13,064 | handout | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a handout in front of the screen. The handout appears to interact naturally with the environment, including appropriate placement and alignment. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding the handout, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres to the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
9,
10
],
"score for Task1": 9,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 9 |
||
3,425 | ceramic dish | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The ceramic dish has been successfully added to the edited image, replacing the original object. The dish appears natural in the scene, with appropriate lighting and shadow, blending well with the environment. However, the original object (the bottle) has been removed, which is against the rules.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction as the original object (the bottle) has been removed, which is not part of the instruction to add a ceramic dish. No other changes to the background or environment are observed.",
"score": [
5,
4
],
"score for Task1": 5,
"score for Task2": 4
} | 4 |
||
14,419 | bench | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bench has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural, blends well with the environment, and has appropriate shadows, making it look integrated into the scene. No elements from the original image were removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the bench, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,184 | livestock | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds livestock (cows) to the scene, and they appear natural with appropriate shadows and interaction with the environment. No elements from the original image are removed, and the livestock blends well with the surroundings.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding livestock, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,232 | string lights | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The string lights were successfully added to the edited image, and they appear natural with appropriate lighting and interaction with the environment. Shadows and light reflections are consistent with the scene. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image was removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding string lights, and no other changes to the background or additional objects are observed. The scene remains consistent with the original image apart from the added string lights.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
18,142 | streamers | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include any visible streamers, which were the specified addition in the editing instruction. Therefore, the edit does not follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no visible changes beyond the editing instruction, as no streamers were added and the rest of the scene remains unchanged.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
10,514 | artistic sculptures | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds an artistic sculpture to the scene. The sculpture appears to interact with the environment, as it is placed on the bridge and has appropriate lighting and shadows. However, the sculpture looks slightly out of place and does not blend perfectly with the original image, which reduces the naturalness.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any changes beyond adding the artistic sculpture. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
8,
10
],
"score for Task1": 8,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 8 |
||
6,575 | spotlight | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The spotlight is already present in the original image, so no new spotlight was added as per the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no significant change between the two images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
10,482 | fountain | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a fountain, which was the specified addition in the editing instruction. Therefore, the edit fails to follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes between the original and edited images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
4,032 | bamboo grove | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a bamboo grove as instructed. Instead, the scene has been significantly altered with the addition of a large tree and changes to the environment, but no bamboo grove is present.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction to add a bamboo grove. The entire scene has been changed, including the removal of the original structure and significant alterations to the environment.",
"score": [
0,
0
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 0
} | 0 |
||
8,623 | goal net | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a goal net to the scene, and it appears natural with proper interaction with the environment. Shadows and integration with the scene are well-executed. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding the goal net, but there are additional changes, such as the player being replaced with a goalie and modifications to the uniform. These changes go beyond the instruction to add a goal net.",
"score": [
10,
4
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 4
} | 4 |
||
14,616 | street vendor | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a street vendor, only additional boxes and items on the cart. The editing instruction to add a street vendor was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit only added more boxes to the cart, which is beyond the instruction to add a street vendor. However, the background and other elements remain unchanged.",
"score": [
0,
5
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 5
} | 0 |
||
15,646 | carpet | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a carpet, and the edited image does not show any noticeable addition or change to the carpet. Therefore, the editing instruction to add a carpet was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable overediting in the edited image. The scene remains consistent with the original image, and no changes beyond the instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
7,765 | ornamental trees | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show any added ornamental trees. The scene remains unchanged in terms of the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
1,755 | book | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a book, which was the object specified in the editing instruction. Therefore, the edit does not follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes between the original and edited images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
10,818 | seagull | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The seagull has been added to the edited image, fulfilling the editing instruction. However, the seagull appears slightly unnatural and does not blend seamlessly with the environment. There is no visible shadow or interaction with the surroundings, making it look pasted on.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the seagull, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
6,
10
],
"score for Task1": 6,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 6 |
||
6,976 | incense burner | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The incense burner has been added to the edited image and is not present in the original image. It appears to blend naturally with the environment, with appropriate lighting and shadows. No elements from the original image have been removed, and the incense burner does not look pasted or unnatural.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the incense burner, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
1,091 | bench | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bench has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears natural with proper interaction with the environment, including shadows. No elements from the original image were removed, and the bench blends well with the scene.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes beyond the addition of the bench. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
9,083 | pit stop | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a pit stop, and there is no evidence of the requested object being added. The scene remains unchanged in terms of the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes in the edited image beyond the original, so no overediting has occurred.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
5,553 | tent | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The tent has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears to blend naturally with the environment. The tent has appropriate lighting and shadows, and no part of the original image seems to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding the tent, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
5,268 | flower bed | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a flower bed in front of the building. The flower bed appears natural, blends well with the environment, and interacts with the scene by casting shadows. No part of the original image seems removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the flower bed, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements of the scene. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
17,533 | fountain | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The fountain has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural, blends well with the environment, and has appropriate interaction with the surroundings, such as shadows and placement. No part of the original image seems removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the fountain as per the instruction. There are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image beyond the addition of the fountain.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,290 | tapestry banner | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a tapestry banner as instructed. Instead, a lantern-like object has been added, which does not match the editing instruction. Therefore, the edit fails to follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces an object (a lantern-like object) that is not a tapestry banner, which is beyond the editing instruction. However, the rest of the scene remains unchanged, and no other significant alterations are observed.",
"score": [
0,
5
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 5
} | 0 |
||
12,891 | display case | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image includes a display case that was not present in the original image. The display case appears natural, blends well with the environment, and interacts with the scene by reflecting light appropriately. No elements from the original image were removed, and the addition does not look pasted or unnatural.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the display case, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
4,469 | lighthouse | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The lighthouse is already present in the original image, so no addition was necessary. As per the rules, if the object is already in the original image, the score is 0.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes between the original and edited images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
4,957 | fountain | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The fountain has been successfully added to the edited image, and it blends naturally with the environment. The fountain has appropriate lighting and shadow, making it look integrated into the scene. No elements from the original image appear to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the fountain, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
7,354 | floor lamp | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The floor lamp has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears natural in the scene with appropriate lighting and shadow interaction. No elements from the original image were removed, and the addition blends well with the environment.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes in the edited image beyond the addition of the floor lamp. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
2,316 | flower garden | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show any noticeable addition of a flower garden. The scene remains unchanged from the original image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no overediting as the edited image is identical to the original image, with no changes beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
5,945 | stone pathway | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a stone pathway as per the editing instruction. Therefore, the edit fails to follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes in the edited image that are beyond the editing instruction, as no stone pathway was added and the rest of the scene remains unchanged.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
5,235 | sand dune | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The sand dune has been added to the edited image, and it is prominent in the scene. However, the sand dune does not blend naturally with the environment. It looks artificial and lacks realistic interaction with the surroundings, such as shadows or texture. Additionally, part of the original structure is obscured by the sand dune, which indicates removal of original elements.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction as it obscures part of the original structure, which is not related to adding a sand dune. This alteration changes the original scene significantly.",
"score": [
4,
3
],
"score for Task1": 4,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 3 |
||
10,135 | vintage lantern | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The vintage lantern has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural, blends well with the environment, and interacts with the scene by casting shadows. No part of the original image seems to have been removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the vintage lantern, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,776 | iron gate | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds an iron gate to the scene. The gate appears natural and blends well with the environment, including proper alignment and interaction with the surroundings. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes beyond the addition of the iron gate. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
9,146 | outdoor seating | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds outdoor seating, which is not present in the original image. The seating appears natural, with appropriate shadows and integration into the environment. No elements from the original image appear to be removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of outdoor seating, and there are no changes to the background or other elements irrelevant to the instruction. The edit does not go beyond the specified task.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
4,016 | lily pads | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds lily pads to the scene, and they appear to interact with the water surface. However, the lily pads look slightly unnatural and pasted on, as they lack proper blending and shadowing with the environment.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any changes beyond adding lily pads, and the rest of the scene remains consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
7,
10
],
"score for Task1": 7,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 7 |
||
5,787 | coffee cup | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The coffee cup has been added to the edited image and is not present in the original image. However, the coffee cup appears slightly unnatural and pasted on, as it lacks proper interaction with the environment, such as realistic shadows or blending with the scene.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the coffee cup, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres to the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
6,
10
],
"score for Task1": 6,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 6 |
||
4,683 | napkins | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include napkins as per the instruction. The added object appears to be a bowl of food, not napkins. Therefore, the edit does not follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction by adding a bowl of food instead of napkins. No other significant changes to the background or environment are observed.",
"score": [
0,
5
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 5
} | 0 |
||
13,195 | trash can | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The trash can has been added to the edited image, and it is positioned naturally on the street. It interacts with the environment by casting a shadow, making it blend well. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image has been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the trash can, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
9,644 | shiny medals | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The shiny medals were added to the edited image, but they appear pasted on and do not blend naturally with the environment. They lack interaction with the scene, such as shadows or integration with the surroundings.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding shiny medals, and there are no other changes to the background or original elements of the image. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
4,
10
],
"score for Task1": 4,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 4 |
||
1,035 | trophy | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The trophy has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears natural with proper interaction with the environment, such as shadows. However, some original elements, like the diplomas and ribbons, have been removed, which affects the score.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction as some diplomas and ribbons from the original image have been removed, and additional elements like an open booklet have been added, which were not part of the instruction.",
"score": [
6,
4
],
"score for Task1": 6,
"score for Task2": 4
} | 4 |
||
15,356 | walking path | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a walking path, so the editing instruction to add a walking path is redundant. No new walking path is added in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image does not show significant changes beyond the addition of a lens flare effect, which is unrelated to the instruction. This constitutes minor overediting.",
"score": [
0,
7
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 7
} | 0 |
||
15,378 | trash can | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The trash can has been added to the edited image, and it appears to blend naturally with the environment. It has appropriate lighting and shadow, making it look integrated into the scene. No elements from the original image appear to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the trash can, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
4,273 | fountain | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a fountain, which was the specified addition in the editing instruction. Therefore, the edit fails to follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes between the original and edited images beyond the absence of the instructed addition. The scene remains consistent with no overediting.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
6,963 | organ pipes | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains organ pipes, so no additional organ pipes were added in the edited image as per the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable change between the two images beyond the editing instruction, as no additional organ pipes were added and the scene remains identical.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
11,912 | shadowy figures | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a shadowy figure holding a weapon, which aligns with the editing instruction. The figure appears to blend naturally with the environment, including appropriate lighting and shadows. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on adding the shadowy figure as instructed, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements of the scene. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
12,475 | vintage parasol | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The vintage parasol has been added to the edited image, and it appears to blend naturally with the scene. The parasol interacts well with the environment, and there are no visible issues such as it looking pasted on. No elements from the original image appear to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on adding the vintage parasol, but there is an additional change: a heart symbol has been added to the mask, which is beyond the editing instruction. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
10,
5
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 5
} | 5 |
||
18,565 | flower bed | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image includes a flower bed in the previously empty soil patch, which aligns with the editing instruction. However, the added flower bed does not blend naturally with the environment, as it appears pasted on and lacks proper interaction with the surroundings, such as shadows. Additionally, a bird has been added, which is unrelated to the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The addition of the bird is beyond the editing instruction to add a flower bed. This constitutes overediting, as it introduces an element unrelated to the task.",
"score": [
5,
3
],
"score for Task1": 5,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 3 |
||
16,220 | cobblestone path | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a cobblestone path, so the editing instruction to add a cobblestone path is redundant. No new cobblestone path is added in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable change between the original and edited images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
13,337 | camera | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The camera has been successfully added to the scene, and it appears natural with proper integration into the environment. Shadows and lighting are consistent, and no part of the original image seems removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the camera, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
11,752 | festival banner | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The festival banner has been added to the edited image, and it appears to blend naturally with the environment. The banner interacts with the scene by being positioned in the sky, and it does not look like a pasted sticker. No elements from the original image were removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the festival banner, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
16,413 | birdbath | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The birdbath is successfully added to the edited image and blends naturally with the environment. It has appropriate lighting and shadow, making it look integrated into the scene. No part of the original image appears to be removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes beyond the addition of the birdbath. The background and other elements remain consistent between the original and edited images.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
18,597 | bicycle | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bicycle has been added to the edited image, and it appears to interact naturally with the environment, including proper placement and shadowing. The original image does not have a bicycle, and nothing seems removed from the original image. The addition looks natural and blends well.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the bicycle, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
3,232 | toolbox | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a toolbox to the scene. The toolbox appears natural, blends well with the environment, and has appropriate lighting and shadows. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the toolbox, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
525 | pine trees | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds pine trees to the scene, and they appear natural with proper shadows and interaction with the snowy environment. The original image did not have these specific pine trees, and nothing from the original image seems removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding pine trees, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements of the scene. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,656 | traffic light | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a traffic light to the scene, and it blends naturally with the environment without looking pasted or awkward. No elements from the original image appear to be removed, and the addition is consistent with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any changes beyond adding the traffic light. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
6,805 | ticket booth | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image includes a ticket booth that was not present in the original image. The ticket booth appears to blend naturally with the environment, with appropriate lighting and shadows. No elements from the original image seem to have been removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the ticket booth, and no other changes to the background or environment are evident. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
14,630 | toolbox | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The toolbox has been added to the edited image, and it appears to be placed naturally on the ground with appropriate shadows and interaction with the environment. The original image does not have a toolbox, and nothing seems to be removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the toolbox, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
16,184 | fresco | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The fresco was successfully added to the edited image, and it blends naturally with the environment. The added fresco interacts well with the original ceiling design and does not appear pasted or out of place. No elements from the original image were removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the fresco as instructed. There are no changes to the background or other elements in the image that are irrelevant to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
4,911 | ceremonial drum | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The ceremonial drum has been added to the edited image, and it is visually present. However, the drum appears unnaturally large and does not blend seamlessly with the environment. It looks pasted on and lacks proper interaction with the surroundings, such as realistic shadows or integration with the scene.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the ceremonial drum, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
5,
10
],
"score for Task1": 5,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 5 |
||
2,404 | sun hat | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a sun hat, so the editing instruction to add a sun hat is redundant. No additional sun hat is added in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes between the two images beyond the editing instruction. The scene remains consistent, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
5,251 | sculpture | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds sculptures to the scene, and they are placed naturally on the fountain. The sculptures interact well with the environment, including appropriate shadows and blending. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image is removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding sculptures, and there are no changes to the background or other elements of the original image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
7,758 | digital clock | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The digital clock has been added to the edited image and is visible. It appears to blend naturally with the environment, including appropriate lighting and shadow. No elements from the original image seem to have been removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the digital clock, and no other changes to the background or additional objects are observed. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
3,266 | traffic cone | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The traffic cone has been added to the edited image as per the instruction. It appears to be placed naturally on the snow and interacts with the environment by casting a shadow. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image has been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the traffic cone, and no other changes to the background or additional objects are observed. The scene remains consistent with the original image apart from the added cone.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
5,008 | safety barrier | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a safety barrier as per the instruction. The scene remains unchanged in terms of the requested addition.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes beyond the editing instruction, as no safety barrier was added and the rest of the scene remains identical to the original.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
9,563 | vase arrangement | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a vase arrangement to the scene. The vase arrangement appears natural, blends well with the environment, and interacts with the lighting and shadows of the room. No part of the original image seems to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the vase arrangement, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements of the scene. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
472 | artistic murals | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds artistic murals, which are visually distinct and blend well with the environment. The murals are placed naturally under the umbrellas, interacting with the original scene. No elements from the original image appear to be removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses solely on adding artistic murals without altering the background or introducing unrelated changes. The scene remains consistent with the original image apart from the added murals.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
10,185 | trash bin | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The trash bin has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural in the scene, with appropriate lighting and shadow interaction with the environment. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image has been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the trash bin, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
14,847 | picnic table | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The picnic table has been added to the edited image, and it appears to blend naturally with the environment. It has appropriate shadows and does not look pasted on. No elements from the original image were removed, and there are no watermarks.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the picnic table, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit strictly follows the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
7,877 | statue | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a statue that blends naturally with the environment. The lighting, shadows, and placement of the statue are consistent with the original image, and no part of the original image appears to have been removed. The addition looks seamless and realistic.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the statue as per the instruction. There are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene, and the edit does not go beyond the specified task.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
16,931 | yoga mat | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The yoga mat has been added to the edited image, and it appears natural in the scene with proper alignment and interaction with the environment. Shadows and lighting are consistent, and nothing from the original image seems to have been removed. There are no watermarks in either image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the yoga mat, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the scene. The edit strictly follows the instruction without overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
2,549 | hammock | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The hammock has been successfully added to the scene, and it appears natural with proper integration into the environment. It interacts well with the existing furniture and does not look out of place. Shadows and lighting are consistent with the rest of the image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes to the image beyond the addition of the hammock. The background, furniture, and other elements remain unchanged, adhering strictly to the editing instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
18,828 | trash can | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The trash can has been successfully added to the edited image, and it appears natural in the scene with appropriate lighting and shadow. The object blends well with the environment, and nothing from the original image seems to have been removed. There are no watermarks in either image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the trash can as per the instruction. There are no changes to the background or any other elements in the image beyond the addition of the trash can.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
13,469 | statue | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The statue has been successfully added to the edited image. It appears natural, blends well with the environment, and has appropriate shadows, making it look integrated into the scene. No part of the original image seems to have been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the statue as per the instruction. There are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image, and the edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
17,105 | signal lantern | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The signal lantern has been added to the edited image, and it appears to be naturally integrated with the environment. It has appropriate lighting and shadow, blending well with the train. No watermark is present, and nothing from the original image has been removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the addition of the signal lantern, and no other changes to the background or other elements are observed. The edit strictly follows the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
11,787 | toolbox | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not include a toolbox as per the instruction. Instead, a different object (a set of tires) has been added, which does not fulfill the requirement.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction by adding tires instead of a toolbox. This constitutes overediting as the added object is not relevant to the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
2
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 2
} | 0 |
||
3,377 | playground | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The playground has been successfully added to the edited image. It blends naturally with the environment, has appropriate shadows, and does not appear pasted or unnatural. No elements from the original image were removed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the playground as per the instruction. There are no changes to the background or other elements in the image beyond the addition of the playground.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
15,854 | sculpture | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a sculpture to the scene, and the sculpture appears to blend naturally with the environment, including appropriate lighting and shadows. No elements from the original image appear to be removed, and the addition looks integrated rather than pasted.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any changes beyond the addition of the sculpture. The background, lighting, and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
1,155 | safety cones | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds safety cones to the scene, and they appear to interact naturally with the environment, including appropriate shadows. No elements from the original image are removed, and the cones blend well with the scene.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding safety cones, and there are no changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
13,756 | centerpiece | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully adds a centerpiece consisting of flowers and greenery, which blends naturally with the environment. The centerpiece interacts well with the scene, and no elements from the original image are removed. Shadows and lighting are consistent, making the addition look natural.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to adding the centerpiece as instructed. There are no changes to the background or other elements in the image, and the edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 41