article_id
int64 20k
99.9k
| set_unique_id
stringclasses 300
values | batch_num
int64 11
23
| writer_id
int64 1k
1.02k
| source
stringclasses 5
values | title
stringclasses 150
values | year
stringclasses 31
values | author
stringclasses 106
values | topic
stringclasses 109
values | article
stringclasses 150
values | url
stringclasses 129
values | license
stringclasses 5
values | question
stringlengths 11
490
| question_unique_id
stringlengths 16
17
| options
sequencelengths 4
4
| writer_label
int64 1
4
| gold_label
int64 1
4
| validation
listlengths 3
9
| speed_validation
listlengths 5
10
| difficult
int64 0
1
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
27,588 | 27588_1RSI6ZBB | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | The Jupiter Weapon | 1962.0 | Fontenay, Charles L. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Transcriber's Note:
Every effort has been made to replicate this text as faithfully as
possible; changes (corrections of spelling and punctuation) made to
the original text are marked
like this
.
The original text appears when hovering the cursor over the marked text.
This e-text was produced from
Amazing Science Fiction Stories
March 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U. S. copyright on this
publication was renewed.
50
THE
JUPITER
WEAPON
By CHARLES L. FONTENAY
He was a living weapon of
destruction—
immeasurably
powerful, utterly invulnerable.
There was only one
question: Was he human?
Trella
feared she was in
for trouble even before Motwick's
head dropped forward on
his arms in a drunken stupor.
The two evil-looking men at the
table nearby had been watching
her surreptitiously, and now
they shifted restlessly in their
chairs.
Trella had not wanted to come
to the Golden Satellite. It was a
squalid saloon in the rougher
section of Jupiter's View, the
terrestrial dome-colony on Ganymede.
Motwick,
already
drunk,
had insisted.
A woman could not possibly
make her way through these
streets alone to the better section
of town, especially one clad
in a silvery evening dress. Her
only hope was that this place
had a telephone. Perhaps she
could call one of Motwick's
friends; she had no one on Ganymede
she could call a real friend
herself.
Tentatively, she pushed her
chair back from the table and
arose. She had to brush close by
the other table to get to the bar.
As she did, the dark, slick-haired
man reached out and grabbed
her around the waist with a
steely arm.
Trella swung with her whole
body, and slapped him so hard
he nearly fell from his chair. As
she walked swiftly toward the
bar, he leaped up to follow her.
There were only two other
people in the Golden Satellite:
the fat, mustached bartender
and a short, square-built man at
the bar. The latter swung
around at the pistol-like report
of her slap, and she saw that,
though no more than four and a
half feet tall, he was as heavily
muscled as a lion.
51
His face was clean and open,
with close-cropped blond hair
and honest blue eyes. She ran to
him.
“Help me!” she cried. “Please
help me!”
He began to back away from
her.
“I can't,” he muttered in a
deep voice. “I can't help you. I
can't do anything.”
The dark man was at her
heels. In desperation, she dodged
around the short man and took
refuge behind him. Her protector
was obviously unwilling, but
the dark man, faced with his
massiveness, took no chances.
He stopped and shouted:
“Kregg!”
The other man at the table
arose, ponderously, and lumbered
toward them. He was immense,
at least six and a half
feet tall, with a brutal, vacant
face.
Evading her attempts to stay
behind him, the squat man began
to move down the bar away
from the approaching Kregg.
The dark man moved in on
Trella again as Kregg overtook
his quarry and swung a huge
fist like a sledgehammer.
Exactly what happened, Trella
wasn't sure. She had the impression
that Kregg's fist connected
squarely with the short man's
chin
before
he dodged to one
side in a movement so fast it
was a blur. But that couldn't
have been, because the short
man wasn't moved by that blow
that would have felled a steer,
and Kregg roared in pain, grabbing
his injured fist.
“The bar!” yelled Kregg. “I
hit the damn bar!”
At this juncture, the bartender
took a hand. Leaning far
over the bar, he swung a full
bottle in a complete arc. It
smashed on Kregg's head,
splashing the floor with liquor,
and Kregg sank stunned to his
knees. The dark man, who had
grabbed Trella's arm, released
her and ran for the door.
Moving agilely around the end
of the bar, the bartender stood
over Kregg, holding the jagged-edged
bottleneck in his hand
menacingly.
“Get out!” rumbled the bartender.
“I'll have no coppers
raiding my place for the likes of
you!”
Kregg stumbled to his feet
and staggered out. Trella ran to
the unconscious Motwick's side.
“That means you, too, lady,”
said the bartender beside her.
“You and your boy friend get
out of here. You oughtn't to
have come here in the first
place.”
“May I help you, Miss?” asked
a deep, resonant voice behind
her.
She straightened from her
anxious examination of Motwick.
The squat man was standing
there, an apologetic look on
his face.
She looked contemptuously at
the massive muscles whose help
had been denied her. Her arm
ached where the dark man had
grasped it. The broad face before
52
her was not unhandsome,
and the blue eyes were disconcertingly
direct, but she despised
him for a coward.
“I'm sorry I couldn't fight
those men for you, Miss, but I
just couldn't,” he said miserably,
as though reading her thoughts.
“But no one will bother you on
the street if I'm with you.”
“A lot of protection you'd be
if they did!” she snapped. “But
I'm desperate. You can carry
him to the Stellar Hotel for me.”
The gravity of Ganymede was
hardly more than that of Earth's
moon, but the way the man
picked up the limp Motwick with
one hand and tossed him over a
shoulder was startling: as
though he lifted a feather pillow.
He followed Trella out the door
of the Golden Satellite and fell
in step beside her. Immediately
she was grateful for his presence.
The dimly lighted street
was not crowded, but she didn't
like the looks of the men she
saw.
The transparent dome of Jupiter's
View was faintly visible
in the reflected night lights of
the colonial city, but the lights
were overwhelmed by the giant,
vari-colored disc of Jupiter itself,
riding high in the sky.
“I'm Quest Mansard, Miss,”
said her companion. “I'm just in
from Jupiter.”
“I'm Trella Nuspar,” she said,
favoring him with a green-eyed
glance. “You mean Io, don't you—or
Moon Five?”
“No,” he said, grinning at
her. He had an engaging grin,
with even white teeth. “I meant
Jupiter.”
“You're lying,” she said flatly.
“No one has ever landed on
Jupiter. It would be impossible
to blast off again.”
“My parents landed on Jupiter,
and I blasted off from it,”
he said soberly. “I was born
there. Have you ever heard of
Dr. Eriklund Mansard?”
“I certainly have,” she said,
her interest taking a sudden
upward turn. “He developed the
surgiscope, didn't he? But his
ship was drawn into Jupiter and
lost.”
“It was drawn into Jupiter,
but he landed it successfully,”
said Quest. “He and my mother
lived on Jupiter until the oxygen
equipment wore out at last. I
was born and brought up there,
and I was finally able to build
a small rocket with a powerful
enough drive to clear the
planet.”
She looked at him. He was
short, half a head shorter than
she, but broad and powerful as
a man might be who had grown
up in heavy gravity. He trod the
street with a light, controlled
step, seeming to deliberately
hold himself down.
“If Dr. Mansard succeeded in
landing on Jupiter, why didn't
anyone ever hear from him
again?” she demanded.
“Because,” said Quest, “his
radio was sabotaged, just as his
ship's drive was.”
“Jupiter strength,” she murmured,
looking him over coolly.
53
“You wear Motwick on your
shoulder like a scarf. But you
couldn't bring yourself to help
a woman against two thugs.”
He flushed.
“I'm sorry,” he said. “That's
something I couldn't help.”
“Why not?”
“I don't know. It's not that
I'm afraid, but there's something
in me that makes me back
away from the prospect of fighting
anyone.”
Trella sighed. Cowardice was
a state of mind. It was peculiarly
inappropriate, but not unbelievable,
that the strongest and
most agile man on Ganymede
should be a coward. Well, she
thought with a rush of sympathy,
he couldn't help being
what he was.
They had reached the more
brightly lighted section of the
city now. Trella could get a cab
from here, but the Stellar Hotel
wasn't far. They walked on.
Trella had the desk clerk call
a cab to deliver the unconscious
Motwick to his home. She and
Quest had a late sandwich in the
coffee shop.
“I landed here only a week
ago,” he told her, his eyes frankly
admiring her honey-colored
hair and comely face. “I'm heading
for Earth on the next spaceship.”
“We'll be traveling companions,
then,” she said. “I'm going
back on that ship, too.”
For some reason she decided
against telling him that the
assignment on which she had
come to the Jupiter system was
to gather his own father's notebooks
and take them back to
Earth.
Motwick was an irresponsible
playboy whom Trella had known
briefly on Earth, and Trella was
glad to dispense with his company
for the remaining three
weeks before the spaceship
blasted off. She found herself
enjoying the steadier companionship
of Quest.
As a matter of fact, she found
herself enjoying his companionship
more than she intended to.
She found herself falling in love
with him.
Now this did not suit her at
all. Trella had always liked her
men tall and dark. She had determined
that when she married
it would be to a curly-haired six-footer.
She was not at all happy about
being so strongly attracted to a
man several inches shorter than
she. She was particularly unhappy
about feeling drawn to a
man who was a coward.
The ship that they boarded on
Moon Nine was one of the newer
ships that could attain a hundred-mile-per-second
velocity
and take a hyperbolic path to
Earth, but it would still require
fifty-four days to make the trip.
So Trella was delighted to find
that the ship was the
Cometfire
and its skipper was her old
friend, dark-eyed, curly-haired
Jakdane Gille.
“Jakdane,” she said, flirting
with him with her eyes as in
54
days gone by, “I need a chaperon
this trip, and you're ideal for
the job.”
“I never thought of myself in
quite that light, but maybe
I'm getting old,” he answered,
laughing. “What's your trouble,
Trella?”
“I'm in love with that huge
chunk of man who came aboard
with me, and I'm not sure I
ought to be,” she confessed. “I
may need protection against myself
till we get to Earth.”
“If it's to keep you out of another
fellow's clutches, I'm your
man,” agreed Jakdane heartily.
“I always had a mind to save
you for myself. I'll guarantee
you won't have a moment alone
with him the whole trip.”
“You don't have to be that
thorough about it,” she protested
hastily. “I want to get a little
enjoyment out of being in love.
But if I feel myself weakening
too much, I'll holler for help.”
The
Cometfire
swung around
great Jupiter in an opening arc
and plummeted ever more swiftly
toward the tight circles of the
inner planets. There were four
crew members and three passengers
aboard the ship's tiny personnel
sphere, and Trella was
thrown with Quest almost constantly.
She enjoyed every minute
of it.
She told him only that she
was a messenger, sent out to
Ganymede to pick up some important
papers and take them
back to Earth. She was tempted
to tell him what the papers were.
Her employer had impressed upon
her that her mission was confidential,
but surely Dom
Blessing
could not object to Dr.
Mansard's son knowing about it.
All these things had happened
before she was born, and she
did not know what Dom Blessing's
relation to Dr. Mansard
had been, but it must have been
very close. She knew that Dr.
Mansard had invented the surgiscope.
This was an instrument with
a three-dimensional screen as its
heart. The screen was a cubical
frame in which an apparently
solid image was built up of an
object under an electron microscope.
The actual cutting instrument
of the surgiscope was an ion
stream. By operating a tool in
the three-dimensional screen,
corresponding movements were
made by the ion stream on the
object under the microscope.
The
principle
was the same as
that used in operation of remote
control “hands” in atomic laboratories
to handle hot material,
and with the surgiscope very
delicate operations could be performed
at the cellular level.
Dr. Mansard and his wife had
disappeared into the turbulent
atmosphere of Jupiter just after
his invention of the surgiscope,
and it had been developed by
Dom Blessing. Its success had
built Spaceway Instruments, Incorporated,
which Blessing headed.
Through all these years since
Dr. Mansard's disappearance,
55
Blessing had been searching the
Jovian moons for a second, hidden
laboratory of Dr. Mansard.
When it was found at last, he
sent Trella, his most trusted
secretary, to Ganymede to bring
back to him the notebooks found
there.
Blessing would, of course, be
happy to learn that a son of Dr.
Mansard lived, and would see
that he received his rightful
share of the inheritance. Because
of this, Trella was tempted
to tell Quest the good news
herself; but she decided against
it. It was Blessing's privilege to
do this his own way, and he
might not appreciate her meddling.
At midtrip, Trella made a rueful
confession to Jakdane.
“It seems I was taking unnecessary
precautions when I asked
you to be a chaperon,” she said.
“I kept waiting for Quest to do
something, and when he didn't
I told him I loved him.”
“What did he say?”
“It's very peculiar,” she said
unhappily. “He said he
can't
love me. He said he wants to
love me and he feels that he
should, but there's something in
him that refuses to permit it.”
She expected Jakdane to salve
her wounded feelings with a
sympathetic pleasantry, but he
did not. Instead, he just looked
at her very thoughtfully and
said no more about the matter.
He explained his attitude
after Asrange ran amuck.
Asrange was the third passenger.
He was a lean, saturnine
individual who said little and
kept to himself as much as possible.
He was distantly polite in
his relations with both crew and
other passengers, and never
showed the slightest spark of
emotion … until the day Quest
squirted coffee on him.
It was one of those accidents
that can occur easily in space.
The passengers and the two
crewmen on that particular waking
shift (including Jakdane)
were eating lunch on the center-deck.
Quest picked up his bulb
of coffee, but inadvertently
pressed it before he got it to his
lips. The coffee squirted all over
the front of Asrange's clean
white tunic.
“I'm sorry!” exclaimed Quest
in distress.
The man's eyes went wide and
he snarled. So quickly it seemed
impossible, he had unbuckled
himself from his seat and hurled
himself backward from the table
with an incoherent cry. He
seized the first object his hand
touched—it happened to be a
heavy wooden cane leaning
against Jakdane's bunk—propelled
himself like a projectile at
Quest.
Quest rose from the table in
a sudden uncoiling of movement.
He did not unbuckle his safety
belt—he rose and it snapped like
a string.
For a moment Trella thought
he was going to meet Asrange's
assault. But he fled in a long
leap toward the companionway
leading to the astrogation deck
56
above. Landing feet-first in the
middle of the table and rebounding,
Asrange pursued with the
stick upraised.
In his haste, Quest missed the
companionway in his leap and
was cornered against one of the
bunks. Asrange descended on
him like an avenging angel and,
holding onto the bunk with one
hand, rained savage blows on his
head and shoulders with the
heavy stick.
Quest made no effort to retaliate.
He cowered under the attack,
holding his hands in front
of him as if to ward it off. In a
moment, Jakdane and the other
crewman had reached Asrange
and pulled him off.
When they had Asrange in
irons, Jakdane turned to Quest,
who was now sitting unhappily
at the table.
“Take it easy,” he advised.
“I'll wake the psychosurgeon
and have him look you over. Just
stay there.”
Quest shook his head.
“Don't bother him,” he said.
“It's nothing but a few bruises.”
“Bruises? Man, that club
could have broken your skull!
Or a couple of ribs, at the very
least.”
“I'm all right,” insisted
Quest; and when the skeptical
Jakdane insisted on examining
him carefully, he had to admit
it. There was hardly a mark on
him from the blows.
“If it didn't hurt you any
more than that, why didn't you
take that stick away from him?”
demanded Jakdane. “You could
have, easily.”
“I couldn't,” said Quest miserably,
and turned his face
away.
Later, alone with Trella on
the control deck, Jakdane gave
her some sober advice.
“If you think you're in love
with Quest, forget it,” he said.
“Why? Because he's a coward?
I know that ought to make
me despise him, but it doesn't
any more.”
“Not because he's a coward.
Because he's an android!”
“What? Jakdane, you can't be
serious!”
“I am. I say he's an android,
an artificial imitation of a man.
It all figures.
“Look, Trella, he said he was
born on Jupiter. A human could
stand the gravity of Jupiter, inside
a dome or a ship, but what
human could stand the rocket acceleration
necessary to break
free of Jupiter? Here's a man
strong enough to break a spaceship
safety belt just by getting
up out of his chair against it,
tough enough to take a beating
with a heavy stick without being
injured. How can you believe
he's really human?”
Trella remembered the thug
Kregg striking Quest in the face
and then crying that he had injured
his hand on the bar.
“But he said Dr. Mansard was
his father,” protested Trella.
“Robots and androids frequently
look on their makers as
their parents,” said Jakdane.
“Quest may not even know he's
57
artificial. Do you know how
Mansard died?”
“The oxygen equipment failed,
Quest said.”
“Yes. Do you know when?”
“No. Quest never did tell me,
that I remember.”
“He told me: a year before
Quest made his rocket flight to
Ganymede! If the oxygen equipment
failed, how do you think
Quest
lived in the poisonous atmosphere
of Jupiter, if he's human?”
Trella was silent.
“For the protection of humans,
there are two psychological
traits built into every robot
and android,” said Jakdane
gently. “The first is that they
can never, under any circumstances,
attack a human being,
even in self defense. The second
is that, while they may understand
sexual desire objectively,
they can never experience it
themselves.
“Those characteristics fit your
man Quest to a T, Trella. There
is no other explanation for him:
he must be an android.”
Trella did not want to believe
Jakdane was right, but his reasoning
was unassailable. Looking
upon Quest as an android,
many things were explained: his
great strength, his short, broad
build, his immunity to injury,
his refusal to defend himself
against a human, his inability to
return Trella's love for him.
It was not inconceivable that
she should have unknowingly
fallen in love with an android.
Humans could love androids,
with real affection, even knowing
that they were artificial.
There were instances of android
nursemaids who were virtually
members of the families owning
them.
She was glad now that she
had not told Quest of her mission
to Ganymede. He thought
he was Dr. Mansard's son, but
an android had no legal right of
inheritance from his owner. She
would leave it to Dom Blessing
to decide what to do about Quest.
Thus she did not, as she had
intended originally, speak to
Quest about seeing him again
after she had completed her assignment.
Even if Jakdane was
wrong and Quest was human—as
now seemed unlikely—Quest
had told her he could not love
her. Her best course was to try
to forget him.
Nor did Quest try to arrange
with her for a later meeting.
“It has been pleasant knowing
you, Trella,” he said when they
left the G-boat at White Sands.
A faraway look came into his
blue eyes, and he added: “I'm
sorry things couldn't have been
different, somehow.”
“Let's don't be sorry for what
we can't help,” she said gently,
taking his hand in farewell.
Trella took a fast plane from
White Sands, and twenty-four
hours later walked up the front
steps of the familiar brownstone
house on the outskirts of Washington.
Dom Blessing himself met her
at the door, a stooped, graying
58
man who peered at her over his
spectacles.
“You have the papers, eh?”
he said, spying the brief case.
“Good, good. Come in and we'll
see what we have, eh?”
She accompanied him through
the bare, windowless anteroom
which had always seemed to her
such a strange feature of this
luxurious house, and they entered
the big living room. They sat
before a fire in the old-fashioned
fireplace and Blessing opened the
brief case with trembling hands.
“There are things here,” he
said, his eyes sparkling as he
glanced through the notebooks.
“Yes, there are things here. We
shall make something of these,
Miss Trella, eh?”
“I'm glad they're something
you can use, Mr. Blessing,” she
said. “There's something else I
found on my trip, that I think
I should tell you about.”
She told him about Quest.
“He thinks he's the son of Dr.
Mansard,” she finished, “but apparently
he is, without knowing
it, an android Dr. Mansard built
on Jupiter.”
“He came back to Earth with
you, eh?” asked Blessing intently.
“Yes. I'm afraid it's your decision
whether to let him go on
living as a man or to tell him
he's an android and claim ownership
as Dr. Mansard's heir.”
Trella planned to spend a few
days resting in her employer's
spacious home, and then to take
a short vacation before resuming
her duties as his confidential
secretary. The next morning
when she came down from her
room, a change had been made.
Two armed men were with
Dom Blessing at breakfast and
accompanied him wherever he
went. She discovered that two
more men with guns were stationed
in the bare anteroom and
a guard was stationed at every
entrance to the house.
“Why all the protection?” she
asked Blessing.
“A wealthy man must be careful,”
said Blessing cheerfully.
“When we don't understand all
the implications of new circumstances,
we must be prepared for
anything, eh?”
There was only one new circumstance
Trella could think
of. Without actually intending
to, she exclaimed:
“You aren't afraid of Quest?
Why, an android can't hurt a
human!”
Blessing peered at her over his
spectacles.
“And what if he isn't an android,
eh? And if he is—what if
old Mansard didn't build in the
prohibition against harming humans
that's required by law?
What about that, eh?”
Trella was silent, shocked.
There was something here she
hadn't known about, hadn't even
suspected. For some reason, Dom
Blessing feared Dr. Eriklund
Mansard … or his heir … or
his mechanical servant.
She was sure that Blessing
was wrong, that Quest, whether
man or android, intended no
59
harm to him. Surely, Quest
would have said something of
such bitterness during their long
time together on Ganymede and
aspace, since he did not know of
Trella's connection with Blessing.
But, since this was to be
the atmosphere of Blessing's
house, she was glad that he decided
to assign her to take the
Mansard papers to the New
York laboratory.
Quest came the day before she
was scheduled to leave.
Trella was in the living room
with Blessing, discussing the instructions
she was to give to the
laboratory officials in New York.
The two bodyguards were with
them. The other guards were at
their posts.
Trella heard the doorbell ring.
The heavy oaken front door was
kept locked now, and the guards
in the anteroom examined callers
through a tiny window.
Suddenly alarm bells rang all
over the house. There was a terrific
crash outside the room as
the front door splintered. There
were shouts and the sound of a
shot.
“The steel doors!” cried Blessing,
turning white. “Let's get
out of here.”
He and his bodyguards ran
through the back of the house
out of the garage.
Blessing, ahead of the rest,
leaped into one of the cars and
started the engine.
The door from the house shattered
and Quest burst through.
The two guards turned and fired
together.
He could be hurt by bullets.
He was staggered momentarily.
Then, in a blur of motion, he
sprang forward and swept the
guards aside with one hand with
such force that they skidded
across the floor and lay in an
unconscious heap against the
rear of the garage. Trella had
opened the door of the car, but
it was wrenched from her hand
as Blessing stepped on the accelerator
and it leaped into the
driveway with spinning wheels.
Quest was after it, like a
chunky deer, running faster
than Trella had ever seen a man
run before.
Blessing slowed for the turn
at the end of the driveway and
glanced back over his shoulder.
Seeing Quest almost upon him,
he slammed down the accelerator
and twisted the wheel hard.
The car whipped into the
street, careened, and rolled over
and over, bringing up against a
tree on the other side in a twisted
tangle of wreckage.
With a horrified gasp, Trella
ran down the driveway toward
the smoking heap of metal.
Quest was already beside it,
probing it. As she reached his
side, he lifted the torn body of
Dom Blessing. Blessing was
dead.
“I'm lucky,” said Quest soberly.
“I would have murdered
him.”
“But why, Quest? I knew he
was afraid of you, but he didn't
tell me why.”
“It was conditioned into me,”
answered Quest “I didn't know
60
it until just now, when it ended,
but my father conditioned me
psychologically from my birth
to the task of hunting down
Dom Blessing and killing him. It
was an unconscious drive in me
that wouldn't release me until
the task was finished.
“You see, Blessing was my father's
assistant on Ganymede.
Right after my father completed
development of the surgiscope,
he and my mother blasted off for
Io. Blessing wanted the valuable
rights to the surgiscope, and he
sabotaged the ship's drive so it
would fall into Jupiter.
“But my father was able to
control it in the heavy atmosphere
of Jupiter, and landed it
successfully. I was born there,
and he conditioned me to come
to Earth and track down Blessing.
I know now that it was
part of the conditioning that I
was unable to fight any other
man until my task was finished:
it might have gotten me in trouble
and diverted me from that
purpose.”
More gently than Trella would
have believed possible for his
Jupiter-strong muscles, Quest
took her in his arms.
“Now I can say I love you,”
he said. “That was part of the
conditioning too: I couldn't love
any woman until my job was
done.”
Trella disengaged herself.
“I'm sorry,” she said. “Don't
you know this, too, now: that
you're not a man, but an android?”
He looked at her in astonishment,
stunned by her words.
“What in space makes you
think that?” he demanded.
“Why, Quest, it's obvious,”
she cried, tears in her eyes.
“Everything about you … your
build, suited for Jupiter's gravity …
your strength … the
fact that you were able to live
in Jupiter's atmosphere after
the oxygen equipment failed.
I know you think Dr. Mansard
was your father, but androids
often believe that.”
He grinned at her.
“I'm no android,” he said confidently.
“Do you forget my father
was inventor of the surgiscope?
He knew I'd have to grow
up on Jupiter, and he operated
on the genes before I was born.
He altered my inherited characteristics
to adapt me to the climate
of Jupiter … even to
being able to breathe a chlorine
atmosphere as well as an oxygen
atmosphere.”
Trella looked at him. He was
not badly hurt, any more than
an elephant would have been,
but his tunic was stained with
red blood where the bullets had
struck him. Normal android
blood was green.
“How can you be sure?” she
asked doubtfully.
“Androids are made,” he answered
with a laugh. “They
don't grow up. And I remember
my boyhood on Jupiter very
well.”
He took her in his arms again,
and this time she did not resist.
His lips were very human.
THE END
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/5/8/27588//27588-h//27588-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What incorrect assumption does Trella make about Blessing? | 27588_1RSI6ZBB_7 | [
"He would be thrilled to hear that Quest is alive and well",
"He murdered Dr. Mansard and got away with it",
"He turned Mansard's son into an android",
"He has no prior knowledge of the contents of Mansard's documents"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0045",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
27,588 | 27588_1RSI6ZBB | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | The Jupiter Weapon | 1962.0 | Fontenay, Charles L. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Transcriber's Note:
Every effort has been made to replicate this text as faithfully as
possible; changes (corrections of spelling and punctuation) made to
the original text are marked
like this
.
The original text appears when hovering the cursor over the marked text.
This e-text was produced from
Amazing Science Fiction Stories
March 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U. S. copyright on this
publication was renewed.
50
THE
JUPITER
WEAPON
By CHARLES L. FONTENAY
He was a living weapon of
destruction—
immeasurably
powerful, utterly invulnerable.
There was only one
question: Was he human?
Trella
feared she was in
for trouble even before Motwick's
head dropped forward on
his arms in a drunken stupor.
The two evil-looking men at the
table nearby had been watching
her surreptitiously, and now
they shifted restlessly in their
chairs.
Trella had not wanted to come
to the Golden Satellite. It was a
squalid saloon in the rougher
section of Jupiter's View, the
terrestrial dome-colony on Ganymede.
Motwick,
already
drunk,
had insisted.
A woman could not possibly
make her way through these
streets alone to the better section
of town, especially one clad
in a silvery evening dress. Her
only hope was that this place
had a telephone. Perhaps she
could call one of Motwick's
friends; she had no one on Ganymede
she could call a real friend
herself.
Tentatively, she pushed her
chair back from the table and
arose. She had to brush close by
the other table to get to the bar.
As she did, the dark, slick-haired
man reached out and grabbed
her around the waist with a
steely arm.
Trella swung with her whole
body, and slapped him so hard
he nearly fell from his chair. As
she walked swiftly toward the
bar, he leaped up to follow her.
There were only two other
people in the Golden Satellite:
the fat, mustached bartender
and a short, square-built man at
the bar. The latter swung
around at the pistol-like report
of her slap, and she saw that,
though no more than four and a
half feet tall, he was as heavily
muscled as a lion.
51
His face was clean and open,
with close-cropped blond hair
and honest blue eyes. She ran to
him.
“Help me!” she cried. “Please
help me!”
He began to back away from
her.
“I can't,” he muttered in a
deep voice. “I can't help you. I
can't do anything.”
The dark man was at her
heels. In desperation, she dodged
around the short man and took
refuge behind him. Her protector
was obviously unwilling, but
the dark man, faced with his
massiveness, took no chances.
He stopped and shouted:
“Kregg!”
The other man at the table
arose, ponderously, and lumbered
toward them. He was immense,
at least six and a half
feet tall, with a brutal, vacant
face.
Evading her attempts to stay
behind him, the squat man began
to move down the bar away
from the approaching Kregg.
The dark man moved in on
Trella again as Kregg overtook
his quarry and swung a huge
fist like a sledgehammer.
Exactly what happened, Trella
wasn't sure. She had the impression
that Kregg's fist connected
squarely with the short man's
chin
before
he dodged to one
side in a movement so fast it
was a blur. But that couldn't
have been, because the short
man wasn't moved by that blow
that would have felled a steer,
and Kregg roared in pain, grabbing
his injured fist.
“The bar!” yelled Kregg. “I
hit the damn bar!”
At this juncture, the bartender
took a hand. Leaning far
over the bar, he swung a full
bottle in a complete arc. It
smashed on Kregg's head,
splashing the floor with liquor,
and Kregg sank stunned to his
knees. The dark man, who had
grabbed Trella's arm, released
her and ran for the door.
Moving agilely around the end
of the bar, the bartender stood
over Kregg, holding the jagged-edged
bottleneck in his hand
menacingly.
“Get out!” rumbled the bartender.
“I'll have no coppers
raiding my place for the likes of
you!”
Kregg stumbled to his feet
and staggered out. Trella ran to
the unconscious Motwick's side.
“That means you, too, lady,”
said the bartender beside her.
“You and your boy friend get
out of here. You oughtn't to
have come here in the first
place.”
“May I help you, Miss?” asked
a deep, resonant voice behind
her.
She straightened from her
anxious examination of Motwick.
The squat man was standing
there, an apologetic look on
his face.
She looked contemptuously at
the massive muscles whose help
had been denied her. Her arm
ached where the dark man had
grasped it. The broad face before
52
her was not unhandsome,
and the blue eyes were disconcertingly
direct, but she despised
him for a coward.
“I'm sorry I couldn't fight
those men for you, Miss, but I
just couldn't,” he said miserably,
as though reading her thoughts.
“But no one will bother you on
the street if I'm with you.”
“A lot of protection you'd be
if they did!” she snapped. “But
I'm desperate. You can carry
him to the Stellar Hotel for me.”
The gravity of Ganymede was
hardly more than that of Earth's
moon, but the way the man
picked up the limp Motwick with
one hand and tossed him over a
shoulder was startling: as
though he lifted a feather pillow.
He followed Trella out the door
of the Golden Satellite and fell
in step beside her. Immediately
she was grateful for his presence.
The dimly lighted street
was not crowded, but she didn't
like the looks of the men she
saw.
The transparent dome of Jupiter's
View was faintly visible
in the reflected night lights of
the colonial city, but the lights
were overwhelmed by the giant,
vari-colored disc of Jupiter itself,
riding high in the sky.
“I'm Quest Mansard, Miss,”
said her companion. “I'm just in
from Jupiter.”
“I'm Trella Nuspar,” she said,
favoring him with a green-eyed
glance. “You mean Io, don't you—or
Moon Five?”
“No,” he said, grinning at
her. He had an engaging grin,
with even white teeth. “I meant
Jupiter.”
“You're lying,” she said flatly.
“No one has ever landed on
Jupiter. It would be impossible
to blast off again.”
“My parents landed on Jupiter,
and I blasted off from it,”
he said soberly. “I was born
there. Have you ever heard of
Dr. Eriklund Mansard?”
“I certainly have,” she said,
her interest taking a sudden
upward turn. “He developed the
surgiscope, didn't he? But his
ship was drawn into Jupiter and
lost.”
“It was drawn into Jupiter,
but he landed it successfully,”
said Quest. “He and my mother
lived on Jupiter until the oxygen
equipment wore out at last. I
was born and brought up there,
and I was finally able to build
a small rocket with a powerful
enough drive to clear the
planet.”
She looked at him. He was
short, half a head shorter than
she, but broad and powerful as
a man might be who had grown
up in heavy gravity. He trod the
street with a light, controlled
step, seeming to deliberately
hold himself down.
“If Dr. Mansard succeeded in
landing on Jupiter, why didn't
anyone ever hear from him
again?” she demanded.
“Because,” said Quest, “his
radio was sabotaged, just as his
ship's drive was.”
“Jupiter strength,” she murmured,
looking him over coolly.
53
“You wear Motwick on your
shoulder like a scarf. But you
couldn't bring yourself to help
a woman against two thugs.”
He flushed.
“I'm sorry,” he said. “That's
something I couldn't help.”
“Why not?”
“I don't know. It's not that
I'm afraid, but there's something
in me that makes me back
away from the prospect of fighting
anyone.”
Trella sighed. Cowardice was
a state of mind. It was peculiarly
inappropriate, but not unbelievable,
that the strongest and
most agile man on Ganymede
should be a coward. Well, she
thought with a rush of sympathy,
he couldn't help being
what he was.
They had reached the more
brightly lighted section of the
city now. Trella could get a cab
from here, but the Stellar Hotel
wasn't far. They walked on.
Trella had the desk clerk call
a cab to deliver the unconscious
Motwick to his home. She and
Quest had a late sandwich in the
coffee shop.
“I landed here only a week
ago,” he told her, his eyes frankly
admiring her honey-colored
hair and comely face. “I'm heading
for Earth on the next spaceship.”
“We'll be traveling companions,
then,” she said. “I'm going
back on that ship, too.”
For some reason she decided
against telling him that the
assignment on which she had
come to the Jupiter system was
to gather his own father's notebooks
and take them back to
Earth.
Motwick was an irresponsible
playboy whom Trella had known
briefly on Earth, and Trella was
glad to dispense with his company
for the remaining three
weeks before the spaceship
blasted off. She found herself
enjoying the steadier companionship
of Quest.
As a matter of fact, she found
herself enjoying his companionship
more than she intended to.
She found herself falling in love
with him.
Now this did not suit her at
all. Trella had always liked her
men tall and dark. She had determined
that when she married
it would be to a curly-haired six-footer.
She was not at all happy about
being so strongly attracted to a
man several inches shorter than
she. She was particularly unhappy
about feeling drawn to a
man who was a coward.
The ship that they boarded on
Moon Nine was one of the newer
ships that could attain a hundred-mile-per-second
velocity
and take a hyperbolic path to
Earth, but it would still require
fifty-four days to make the trip.
So Trella was delighted to find
that the ship was the
Cometfire
and its skipper was her old
friend, dark-eyed, curly-haired
Jakdane Gille.
“Jakdane,” she said, flirting
with him with her eyes as in
54
days gone by, “I need a chaperon
this trip, and you're ideal for
the job.”
“I never thought of myself in
quite that light, but maybe
I'm getting old,” he answered,
laughing. “What's your trouble,
Trella?”
“I'm in love with that huge
chunk of man who came aboard
with me, and I'm not sure I
ought to be,” she confessed. “I
may need protection against myself
till we get to Earth.”
“If it's to keep you out of another
fellow's clutches, I'm your
man,” agreed Jakdane heartily.
“I always had a mind to save
you for myself. I'll guarantee
you won't have a moment alone
with him the whole trip.”
“You don't have to be that
thorough about it,” she protested
hastily. “I want to get a little
enjoyment out of being in love.
But if I feel myself weakening
too much, I'll holler for help.”
The
Cometfire
swung around
great Jupiter in an opening arc
and plummeted ever more swiftly
toward the tight circles of the
inner planets. There were four
crew members and three passengers
aboard the ship's tiny personnel
sphere, and Trella was
thrown with Quest almost constantly.
She enjoyed every minute
of it.
She told him only that she
was a messenger, sent out to
Ganymede to pick up some important
papers and take them
back to Earth. She was tempted
to tell him what the papers were.
Her employer had impressed upon
her that her mission was confidential,
but surely Dom
Blessing
could not object to Dr.
Mansard's son knowing about it.
All these things had happened
before she was born, and she
did not know what Dom Blessing's
relation to Dr. Mansard
had been, but it must have been
very close. She knew that Dr.
Mansard had invented the surgiscope.
This was an instrument with
a three-dimensional screen as its
heart. The screen was a cubical
frame in which an apparently
solid image was built up of an
object under an electron microscope.
The actual cutting instrument
of the surgiscope was an ion
stream. By operating a tool in
the three-dimensional screen,
corresponding movements were
made by the ion stream on the
object under the microscope.
The
principle
was the same as
that used in operation of remote
control “hands” in atomic laboratories
to handle hot material,
and with the surgiscope very
delicate operations could be performed
at the cellular level.
Dr. Mansard and his wife had
disappeared into the turbulent
atmosphere of Jupiter just after
his invention of the surgiscope,
and it had been developed by
Dom Blessing. Its success had
built Spaceway Instruments, Incorporated,
which Blessing headed.
Through all these years since
Dr. Mansard's disappearance,
55
Blessing had been searching the
Jovian moons for a second, hidden
laboratory of Dr. Mansard.
When it was found at last, he
sent Trella, his most trusted
secretary, to Ganymede to bring
back to him the notebooks found
there.
Blessing would, of course, be
happy to learn that a son of Dr.
Mansard lived, and would see
that he received his rightful
share of the inheritance. Because
of this, Trella was tempted
to tell Quest the good news
herself; but she decided against
it. It was Blessing's privilege to
do this his own way, and he
might not appreciate her meddling.
At midtrip, Trella made a rueful
confession to Jakdane.
“It seems I was taking unnecessary
precautions when I asked
you to be a chaperon,” she said.
“I kept waiting for Quest to do
something, and when he didn't
I told him I loved him.”
“What did he say?”
“It's very peculiar,” she said
unhappily. “He said he
can't
love me. He said he wants to
love me and he feels that he
should, but there's something in
him that refuses to permit it.”
She expected Jakdane to salve
her wounded feelings with a
sympathetic pleasantry, but he
did not. Instead, he just looked
at her very thoughtfully and
said no more about the matter.
He explained his attitude
after Asrange ran amuck.
Asrange was the third passenger.
He was a lean, saturnine
individual who said little and
kept to himself as much as possible.
He was distantly polite in
his relations with both crew and
other passengers, and never
showed the slightest spark of
emotion … until the day Quest
squirted coffee on him.
It was one of those accidents
that can occur easily in space.
The passengers and the two
crewmen on that particular waking
shift (including Jakdane)
were eating lunch on the center-deck.
Quest picked up his bulb
of coffee, but inadvertently
pressed it before he got it to his
lips. The coffee squirted all over
the front of Asrange's clean
white tunic.
“I'm sorry!” exclaimed Quest
in distress.
The man's eyes went wide and
he snarled. So quickly it seemed
impossible, he had unbuckled
himself from his seat and hurled
himself backward from the table
with an incoherent cry. He
seized the first object his hand
touched—it happened to be a
heavy wooden cane leaning
against Jakdane's bunk—propelled
himself like a projectile at
Quest.
Quest rose from the table in
a sudden uncoiling of movement.
He did not unbuckle his safety
belt—he rose and it snapped like
a string.
For a moment Trella thought
he was going to meet Asrange's
assault. But he fled in a long
leap toward the companionway
leading to the astrogation deck
56
above. Landing feet-first in the
middle of the table and rebounding,
Asrange pursued with the
stick upraised.
In his haste, Quest missed the
companionway in his leap and
was cornered against one of the
bunks. Asrange descended on
him like an avenging angel and,
holding onto the bunk with one
hand, rained savage blows on his
head and shoulders with the
heavy stick.
Quest made no effort to retaliate.
He cowered under the attack,
holding his hands in front
of him as if to ward it off. In a
moment, Jakdane and the other
crewman had reached Asrange
and pulled him off.
When they had Asrange in
irons, Jakdane turned to Quest,
who was now sitting unhappily
at the table.
“Take it easy,” he advised.
“I'll wake the psychosurgeon
and have him look you over. Just
stay there.”
Quest shook his head.
“Don't bother him,” he said.
“It's nothing but a few bruises.”
“Bruises? Man, that club
could have broken your skull!
Or a couple of ribs, at the very
least.”
“I'm all right,” insisted
Quest; and when the skeptical
Jakdane insisted on examining
him carefully, he had to admit
it. There was hardly a mark on
him from the blows.
“If it didn't hurt you any
more than that, why didn't you
take that stick away from him?”
demanded Jakdane. “You could
have, easily.”
“I couldn't,” said Quest miserably,
and turned his face
away.
Later, alone with Trella on
the control deck, Jakdane gave
her some sober advice.
“If you think you're in love
with Quest, forget it,” he said.
“Why? Because he's a coward?
I know that ought to make
me despise him, but it doesn't
any more.”
“Not because he's a coward.
Because he's an android!”
“What? Jakdane, you can't be
serious!”
“I am. I say he's an android,
an artificial imitation of a man.
It all figures.
“Look, Trella, he said he was
born on Jupiter. A human could
stand the gravity of Jupiter, inside
a dome or a ship, but what
human could stand the rocket acceleration
necessary to break
free of Jupiter? Here's a man
strong enough to break a spaceship
safety belt just by getting
up out of his chair against it,
tough enough to take a beating
with a heavy stick without being
injured. How can you believe
he's really human?”
Trella remembered the thug
Kregg striking Quest in the face
and then crying that he had injured
his hand on the bar.
“But he said Dr. Mansard was
his father,” protested Trella.
“Robots and androids frequently
look on their makers as
their parents,” said Jakdane.
“Quest may not even know he's
57
artificial. Do you know how
Mansard died?”
“The oxygen equipment failed,
Quest said.”
“Yes. Do you know when?”
“No. Quest never did tell me,
that I remember.”
“He told me: a year before
Quest made his rocket flight to
Ganymede! If the oxygen equipment
failed, how do you think
Quest
lived in the poisonous atmosphere
of Jupiter, if he's human?”
Trella was silent.
“For the protection of humans,
there are two psychological
traits built into every robot
and android,” said Jakdane
gently. “The first is that they
can never, under any circumstances,
attack a human being,
even in self defense. The second
is that, while they may understand
sexual desire objectively,
they can never experience it
themselves.
“Those characteristics fit your
man Quest to a T, Trella. There
is no other explanation for him:
he must be an android.”
Trella did not want to believe
Jakdane was right, but his reasoning
was unassailable. Looking
upon Quest as an android,
many things were explained: his
great strength, his short, broad
build, his immunity to injury,
his refusal to defend himself
against a human, his inability to
return Trella's love for him.
It was not inconceivable that
she should have unknowingly
fallen in love with an android.
Humans could love androids,
with real affection, even knowing
that they were artificial.
There were instances of android
nursemaids who were virtually
members of the families owning
them.
She was glad now that she
had not told Quest of her mission
to Ganymede. He thought
he was Dr. Mansard's son, but
an android had no legal right of
inheritance from his owner. She
would leave it to Dom Blessing
to decide what to do about Quest.
Thus she did not, as she had
intended originally, speak to
Quest about seeing him again
after she had completed her assignment.
Even if Jakdane was
wrong and Quest was human—as
now seemed unlikely—Quest
had told her he could not love
her. Her best course was to try
to forget him.
Nor did Quest try to arrange
with her for a later meeting.
“It has been pleasant knowing
you, Trella,” he said when they
left the G-boat at White Sands.
A faraway look came into his
blue eyes, and he added: “I'm
sorry things couldn't have been
different, somehow.”
“Let's don't be sorry for what
we can't help,” she said gently,
taking his hand in farewell.
Trella took a fast plane from
White Sands, and twenty-four
hours later walked up the front
steps of the familiar brownstone
house on the outskirts of Washington.
Dom Blessing himself met her
at the door, a stooped, graying
58
man who peered at her over his
spectacles.
“You have the papers, eh?”
he said, spying the brief case.
“Good, good. Come in and we'll
see what we have, eh?”
She accompanied him through
the bare, windowless anteroom
which had always seemed to her
such a strange feature of this
luxurious house, and they entered
the big living room. They sat
before a fire in the old-fashioned
fireplace and Blessing opened the
brief case with trembling hands.
“There are things here,” he
said, his eyes sparkling as he
glanced through the notebooks.
“Yes, there are things here. We
shall make something of these,
Miss Trella, eh?”
“I'm glad they're something
you can use, Mr. Blessing,” she
said. “There's something else I
found on my trip, that I think
I should tell you about.”
She told him about Quest.
“He thinks he's the son of Dr.
Mansard,” she finished, “but apparently
he is, without knowing
it, an android Dr. Mansard built
on Jupiter.”
“He came back to Earth with
you, eh?” asked Blessing intently.
“Yes. I'm afraid it's your decision
whether to let him go on
living as a man or to tell him
he's an android and claim ownership
as Dr. Mansard's heir.”
Trella planned to spend a few
days resting in her employer's
spacious home, and then to take
a short vacation before resuming
her duties as his confidential
secretary. The next morning
when she came down from her
room, a change had been made.
Two armed men were with
Dom Blessing at breakfast and
accompanied him wherever he
went. She discovered that two
more men with guns were stationed
in the bare anteroom and
a guard was stationed at every
entrance to the house.
“Why all the protection?” she
asked Blessing.
“A wealthy man must be careful,”
said Blessing cheerfully.
“When we don't understand all
the implications of new circumstances,
we must be prepared for
anything, eh?”
There was only one new circumstance
Trella could think
of. Without actually intending
to, she exclaimed:
“You aren't afraid of Quest?
Why, an android can't hurt a
human!”
Blessing peered at her over his
spectacles.
“And what if he isn't an android,
eh? And if he is—what if
old Mansard didn't build in the
prohibition against harming humans
that's required by law?
What about that, eh?”
Trella was silent, shocked.
There was something here she
hadn't known about, hadn't even
suspected. For some reason, Dom
Blessing feared Dr. Eriklund
Mansard … or his heir … or
his mechanical servant.
She was sure that Blessing
was wrong, that Quest, whether
man or android, intended no
59
harm to him. Surely, Quest
would have said something of
such bitterness during their long
time together on Ganymede and
aspace, since he did not know of
Trella's connection with Blessing.
But, since this was to be
the atmosphere of Blessing's
house, she was glad that he decided
to assign her to take the
Mansard papers to the New
York laboratory.
Quest came the day before she
was scheduled to leave.
Trella was in the living room
with Blessing, discussing the instructions
she was to give to the
laboratory officials in New York.
The two bodyguards were with
them. The other guards were at
their posts.
Trella heard the doorbell ring.
The heavy oaken front door was
kept locked now, and the guards
in the anteroom examined callers
through a tiny window.
Suddenly alarm bells rang all
over the house. There was a terrific
crash outside the room as
the front door splintered. There
were shouts and the sound of a
shot.
“The steel doors!” cried Blessing,
turning white. “Let's get
out of here.”
He and his bodyguards ran
through the back of the house
out of the garage.
Blessing, ahead of the rest,
leaped into one of the cars and
started the engine.
The door from the house shattered
and Quest burst through.
The two guards turned and fired
together.
He could be hurt by bullets.
He was staggered momentarily.
Then, in a blur of motion, he
sprang forward and swept the
guards aside with one hand with
such force that they skidded
across the floor and lay in an
unconscious heap against the
rear of the garage. Trella had
opened the door of the car, but
it was wrenched from her hand
as Blessing stepped on the accelerator
and it leaped into the
driveway with spinning wheels.
Quest was after it, like a
chunky deer, running faster
than Trella had ever seen a man
run before.
Blessing slowed for the turn
at the end of the driveway and
glanced back over his shoulder.
Seeing Quest almost upon him,
he slammed down the accelerator
and twisted the wheel hard.
The car whipped into the
street, careened, and rolled over
and over, bringing up against a
tree on the other side in a twisted
tangle of wreckage.
With a horrified gasp, Trella
ran down the driveway toward
the smoking heap of metal.
Quest was already beside it,
probing it. As she reached his
side, he lifted the torn body of
Dom Blessing. Blessing was
dead.
“I'm lucky,” said Quest soberly.
“I would have murdered
him.”
“But why, Quest? I knew he
was afraid of you, but he didn't
tell me why.”
“It was conditioned into me,”
answered Quest “I didn't know
60
it until just now, when it ended,
but my father conditioned me
psychologically from my birth
to the task of hunting down
Dom Blessing and killing him. It
was an unconscious drive in me
that wouldn't release me until
the task was finished.
“You see, Blessing was my father's
assistant on Ganymede.
Right after my father completed
development of the surgiscope,
he and my mother blasted off for
Io. Blessing wanted the valuable
rights to the surgiscope, and he
sabotaged the ship's drive so it
would fall into Jupiter.
“But my father was able to
control it in the heavy atmosphere
of Jupiter, and landed it
successfully. I was born there,
and he conditioned me to come
to Earth and track down Blessing.
I know now that it was
part of the conditioning that I
was unable to fight any other
man until my task was finished:
it might have gotten me in trouble
and diverted me from that
purpose.”
More gently than Trella would
have believed possible for his
Jupiter-strong muscles, Quest
took her in his arms.
“Now I can say I love you,”
he said. “That was part of the
conditioning too: I couldn't love
any woman until my job was
done.”
Trella disengaged herself.
“I'm sorry,” she said. “Don't
you know this, too, now: that
you're not a man, but an android?”
He looked at her in astonishment,
stunned by her words.
“What in space makes you
think that?” he demanded.
“Why, Quest, it's obvious,”
she cried, tears in her eyes.
“Everything about you … your
build, suited for Jupiter's gravity …
your strength … the
fact that you were able to live
in Jupiter's atmosphere after
the oxygen equipment failed.
I know you think Dr. Mansard
was your father, but androids
often believe that.”
He grinned at her.
“I'm no android,” he said confidently.
“Do you forget my father
was inventor of the surgiscope?
He knew I'd have to grow
up on Jupiter, and he operated
on the genes before I was born.
He altered my inherited characteristics
to adapt me to the climate
of Jupiter … even to
being able to breathe a chlorine
atmosphere as well as an oxygen
atmosphere.”
Trella looked at him. He was
not badly hurt, any more than
an elephant would have been,
but his tunic was stained with
red blood where the bullets had
struck him. Normal android
blood was green.
“How can you be sure?” she
asked doubtfully.
“Androids are made,” he answered
with a laugh. “They
don't grow up. And I remember
my boyhood on Jupiter very
well.”
He took her in his arms again,
and this time she did not resist.
His lips were very human.
THE END
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/5/8/27588//27588-h//27588-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is Blessing's fear regarding Dr. Mansard? | 27588_1RSI6ZBB_8 | [
"Blessing is afraid that Dr. Mansard is not actually deceased and currently plotting against him",
"Blessing is afraid that Dr. Mansard will inform Quest that he is actually an android",
"Blessing is afraid that Dr. Mansard has set two assassins to come after him and the documentation he stole",
"Blessing is afraid that Dr. Mansard left out programming that would prevent Quest from hurting living creatures"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0045",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
27,588 | 27588_1RSI6ZBB | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | The Jupiter Weapon | 1962.0 | Fontenay, Charles L. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Transcriber's Note:
Every effort has been made to replicate this text as faithfully as
possible; changes (corrections of spelling and punctuation) made to
the original text are marked
like this
.
The original text appears when hovering the cursor over the marked text.
This e-text was produced from
Amazing Science Fiction Stories
March 1959.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U. S. copyright on this
publication was renewed.
50
THE
JUPITER
WEAPON
By CHARLES L. FONTENAY
He was a living weapon of
destruction—
immeasurably
powerful, utterly invulnerable.
There was only one
question: Was he human?
Trella
feared she was in
for trouble even before Motwick's
head dropped forward on
his arms in a drunken stupor.
The two evil-looking men at the
table nearby had been watching
her surreptitiously, and now
they shifted restlessly in their
chairs.
Trella had not wanted to come
to the Golden Satellite. It was a
squalid saloon in the rougher
section of Jupiter's View, the
terrestrial dome-colony on Ganymede.
Motwick,
already
drunk,
had insisted.
A woman could not possibly
make her way through these
streets alone to the better section
of town, especially one clad
in a silvery evening dress. Her
only hope was that this place
had a telephone. Perhaps she
could call one of Motwick's
friends; she had no one on Ganymede
she could call a real friend
herself.
Tentatively, she pushed her
chair back from the table and
arose. She had to brush close by
the other table to get to the bar.
As she did, the dark, slick-haired
man reached out and grabbed
her around the waist with a
steely arm.
Trella swung with her whole
body, and slapped him so hard
he nearly fell from his chair. As
she walked swiftly toward the
bar, he leaped up to follow her.
There were only two other
people in the Golden Satellite:
the fat, mustached bartender
and a short, square-built man at
the bar. The latter swung
around at the pistol-like report
of her slap, and she saw that,
though no more than four and a
half feet tall, he was as heavily
muscled as a lion.
51
His face was clean and open,
with close-cropped blond hair
and honest blue eyes. She ran to
him.
“Help me!” she cried. “Please
help me!”
He began to back away from
her.
“I can't,” he muttered in a
deep voice. “I can't help you. I
can't do anything.”
The dark man was at her
heels. In desperation, she dodged
around the short man and took
refuge behind him. Her protector
was obviously unwilling, but
the dark man, faced with his
massiveness, took no chances.
He stopped and shouted:
“Kregg!”
The other man at the table
arose, ponderously, and lumbered
toward them. He was immense,
at least six and a half
feet tall, with a brutal, vacant
face.
Evading her attempts to stay
behind him, the squat man began
to move down the bar away
from the approaching Kregg.
The dark man moved in on
Trella again as Kregg overtook
his quarry and swung a huge
fist like a sledgehammer.
Exactly what happened, Trella
wasn't sure. She had the impression
that Kregg's fist connected
squarely with the short man's
chin
before
he dodged to one
side in a movement so fast it
was a blur. But that couldn't
have been, because the short
man wasn't moved by that blow
that would have felled a steer,
and Kregg roared in pain, grabbing
his injured fist.
“The bar!” yelled Kregg. “I
hit the damn bar!”
At this juncture, the bartender
took a hand. Leaning far
over the bar, he swung a full
bottle in a complete arc. It
smashed on Kregg's head,
splashing the floor with liquor,
and Kregg sank stunned to his
knees. The dark man, who had
grabbed Trella's arm, released
her and ran for the door.
Moving agilely around the end
of the bar, the bartender stood
over Kregg, holding the jagged-edged
bottleneck in his hand
menacingly.
“Get out!” rumbled the bartender.
“I'll have no coppers
raiding my place for the likes of
you!”
Kregg stumbled to his feet
and staggered out. Trella ran to
the unconscious Motwick's side.
“That means you, too, lady,”
said the bartender beside her.
“You and your boy friend get
out of here. You oughtn't to
have come here in the first
place.”
“May I help you, Miss?” asked
a deep, resonant voice behind
her.
She straightened from her
anxious examination of Motwick.
The squat man was standing
there, an apologetic look on
his face.
She looked contemptuously at
the massive muscles whose help
had been denied her. Her arm
ached where the dark man had
grasped it. The broad face before
52
her was not unhandsome,
and the blue eyes were disconcertingly
direct, but she despised
him for a coward.
“I'm sorry I couldn't fight
those men for you, Miss, but I
just couldn't,” he said miserably,
as though reading her thoughts.
“But no one will bother you on
the street if I'm with you.”
“A lot of protection you'd be
if they did!” she snapped. “But
I'm desperate. You can carry
him to the Stellar Hotel for me.”
The gravity of Ganymede was
hardly more than that of Earth's
moon, but the way the man
picked up the limp Motwick with
one hand and tossed him over a
shoulder was startling: as
though he lifted a feather pillow.
He followed Trella out the door
of the Golden Satellite and fell
in step beside her. Immediately
she was grateful for his presence.
The dimly lighted street
was not crowded, but she didn't
like the looks of the men she
saw.
The transparent dome of Jupiter's
View was faintly visible
in the reflected night lights of
the colonial city, but the lights
were overwhelmed by the giant,
vari-colored disc of Jupiter itself,
riding high in the sky.
“I'm Quest Mansard, Miss,”
said her companion. “I'm just in
from Jupiter.”
“I'm Trella Nuspar,” she said,
favoring him with a green-eyed
glance. “You mean Io, don't you—or
Moon Five?”
“No,” he said, grinning at
her. He had an engaging grin,
with even white teeth. “I meant
Jupiter.”
“You're lying,” she said flatly.
“No one has ever landed on
Jupiter. It would be impossible
to blast off again.”
“My parents landed on Jupiter,
and I blasted off from it,”
he said soberly. “I was born
there. Have you ever heard of
Dr. Eriklund Mansard?”
“I certainly have,” she said,
her interest taking a sudden
upward turn. “He developed the
surgiscope, didn't he? But his
ship was drawn into Jupiter and
lost.”
“It was drawn into Jupiter,
but he landed it successfully,”
said Quest. “He and my mother
lived on Jupiter until the oxygen
equipment wore out at last. I
was born and brought up there,
and I was finally able to build
a small rocket with a powerful
enough drive to clear the
planet.”
She looked at him. He was
short, half a head shorter than
she, but broad and powerful as
a man might be who had grown
up in heavy gravity. He trod the
street with a light, controlled
step, seeming to deliberately
hold himself down.
“If Dr. Mansard succeeded in
landing on Jupiter, why didn't
anyone ever hear from him
again?” she demanded.
“Because,” said Quest, “his
radio was sabotaged, just as his
ship's drive was.”
“Jupiter strength,” she murmured,
looking him over coolly.
53
“You wear Motwick on your
shoulder like a scarf. But you
couldn't bring yourself to help
a woman against two thugs.”
He flushed.
“I'm sorry,” he said. “That's
something I couldn't help.”
“Why not?”
“I don't know. It's not that
I'm afraid, but there's something
in me that makes me back
away from the prospect of fighting
anyone.”
Trella sighed. Cowardice was
a state of mind. It was peculiarly
inappropriate, but not unbelievable,
that the strongest and
most agile man on Ganymede
should be a coward. Well, she
thought with a rush of sympathy,
he couldn't help being
what he was.
They had reached the more
brightly lighted section of the
city now. Trella could get a cab
from here, but the Stellar Hotel
wasn't far. They walked on.
Trella had the desk clerk call
a cab to deliver the unconscious
Motwick to his home. She and
Quest had a late sandwich in the
coffee shop.
“I landed here only a week
ago,” he told her, his eyes frankly
admiring her honey-colored
hair and comely face. “I'm heading
for Earth on the next spaceship.”
“We'll be traveling companions,
then,” she said. “I'm going
back on that ship, too.”
For some reason she decided
against telling him that the
assignment on which she had
come to the Jupiter system was
to gather his own father's notebooks
and take them back to
Earth.
Motwick was an irresponsible
playboy whom Trella had known
briefly on Earth, and Trella was
glad to dispense with his company
for the remaining three
weeks before the spaceship
blasted off. She found herself
enjoying the steadier companionship
of Quest.
As a matter of fact, she found
herself enjoying his companionship
more than she intended to.
She found herself falling in love
with him.
Now this did not suit her at
all. Trella had always liked her
men tall and dark. She had determined
that when she married
it would be to a curly-haired six-footer.
She was not at all happy about
being so strongly attracted to a
man several inches shorter than
she. She was particularly unhappy
about feeling drawn to a
man who was a coward.
The ship that they boarded on
Moon Nine was one of the newer
ships that could attain a hundred-mile-per-second
velocity
and take a hyperbolic path to
Earth, but it would still require
fifty-four days to make the trip.
So Trella was delighted to find
that the ship was the
Cometfire
and its skipper was her old
friend, dark-eyed, curly-haired
Jakdane Gille.
“Jakdane,” she said, flirting
with him with her eyes as in
54
days gone by, “I need a chaperon
this trip, and you're ideal for
the job.”
“I never thought of myself in
quite that light, but maybe
I'm getting old,” he answered,
laughing. “What's your trouble,
Trella?”
“I'm in love with that huge
chunk of man who came aboard
with me, and I'm not sure I
ought to be,” she confessed. “I
may need protection against myself
till we get to Earth.”
“If it's to keep you out of another
fellow's clutches, I'm your
man,” agreed Jakdane heartily.
“I always had a mind to save
you for myself. I'll guarantee
you won't have a moment alone
with him the whole trip.”
“You don't have to be that
thorough about it,” she protested
hastily. “I want to get a little
enjoyment out of being in love.
But if I feel myself weakening
too much, I'll holler for help.”
The
Cometfire
swung around
great Jupiter in an opening arc
and plummeted ever more swiftly
toward the tight circles of the
inner planets. There were four
crew members and three passengers
aboard the ship's tiny personnel
sphere, and Trella was
thrown with Quest almost constantly.
She enjoyed every minute
of it.
She told him only that she
was a messenger, sent out to
Ganymede to pick up some important
papers and take them
back to Earth. She was tempted
to tell him what the papers were.
Her employer had impressed upon
her that her mission was confidential,
but surely Dom
Blessing
could not object to Dr.
Mansard's son knowing about it.
All these things had happened
before she was born, and she
did not know what Dom Blessing's
relation to Dr. Mansard
had been, but it must have been
very close. She knew that Dr.
Mansard had invented the surgiscope.
This was an instrument with
a three-dimensional screen as its
heart. The screen was a cubical
frame in which an apparently
solid image was built up of an
object under an electron microscope.
The actual cutting instrument
of the surgiscope was an ion
stream. By operating a tool in
the three-dimensional screen,
corresponding movements were
made by the ion stream on the
object under the microscope.
The
principle
was the same as
that used in operation of remote
control “hands” in atomic laboratories
to handle hot material,
and with the surgiscope very
delicate operations could be performed
at the cellular level.
Dr. Mansard and his wife had
disappeared into the turbulent
atmosphere of Jupiter just after
his invention of the surgiscope,
and it had been developed by
Dom Blessing. Its success had
built Spaceway Instruments, Incorporated,
which Blessing headed.
Through all these years since
Dr. Mansard's disappearance,
55
Blessing had been searching the
Jovian moons for a second, hidden
laboratory of Dr. Mansard.
When it was found at last, he
sent Trella, his most trusted
secretary, to Ganymede to bring
back to him the notebooks found
there.
Blessing would, of course, be
happy to learn that a son of Dr.
Mansard lived, and would see
that he received his rightful
share of the inheritance. Because
of this, Trella was tempted
to tell Quest the good news
herself; but she decided against
it. It was Blessing's privilege to
do this his own way, and he
might not appreciate her meddling.
At midtrip, Trella made a rueful
confession to Jakdane.
“It seems I was taking unnecessary
precautions when I asked
you to be a chaperon,” she said.
“I kept waiting for Quest to do
something, and when he didn't
I told him I loved him.”
“What did he say?”
“It's very peculiar,” she said
unhappily. “He said he
can't
love me. He said he wants to
love me and he feels that he
should, but there's something in
him that refuses to permit it.”
She expected Jakdane to salve
her wounded feelings with a
sympathetic pleasantry, but he
did not. Instead, he just looked
at her very thoughtfully and
said no more about the matter.
He explained his attitude
after Asrange ran amuck.
Asrange was the third passenger.
He was a lean, saturnine
individual who said little and
kept to himself as much as possible.
He was distantly polite in
his relations with both crew and
other passengers, and never
showed the slightest spark of
emotion … until the day Quest
squirted coffee on him.
It was one of those accidents
that can occur easily in space.
The passengers and the two
crewmen on that particular waking
shift (including Jakdane)
were eating lunch on the center-deck.
Quest picked up his bulb
of coffee, but inadvertently
pressed it before he got it to his
lips. The coffee squirted all over
the front of Asrange's clean
white tunic.
“I'm sorry!” exclaimed Quest
in distress.
The man's eyes went wide and
he snarled. So quickly it seemed
impossible, he had unbuckled
himself from his seat and hurled
himself backward from the table
with an incoherent cry. He
seized the first object his hand
touched—it happened to be a
heavy wooden cane leaning
against Jakdane's bunk—propelled
himself like a projectile at
Quest.
Quest rose from the table in
a sudden uncoiling of movement.
He did not unbuckle his safety
belt—he rose and it snapped like
a string.
For a moment Trella thought
he was going to meet Asrange's
assault. But he fled in a long
leap toward the companionway
leading to the astrogation deck
56
above. Landing feet-first in the
middle of the table and rebounding,
Asrange pursued with the
stick upraised.
In his haste, Quest missed the
companionway in his leap and
was cornered against one of the
bunks. Asrange descended on
him like an avenging angel and,
holding onto the bunk with one
hand, rained savage blows on his
head and shoulders with the
heavy stick.
Quest made no effort to retaliate.
He cowered under the attack,
holding his hands in front
of him as if to ward it off. In a
moment, Jakdane and the other
crewman had reached Asrange
and pulled him off.
When they had Asrange in
irons, Jakdane turned to Quest,
who was now sitting unhappily
at the table.
“Take it easy,” he advised.
“I'll wake the psychosurgeon
and have him look you over. Just
stay there.”
Quest shook his head.
“Don't bother him,” he said.
“It's nothing but a few bruises.”
“Bruises? Man, that club
could have broken your skull!
Or a couple of ribs, at the very
least.”
“I'm all right,” insisted
Quest; and when the skeptical
Jakdane insisted on examining
him carefully, he had to admit
it. There was hardly a mark on
him from the blows.
“If it didn't hurt you any
more than that, why didn't you
take that stick away from him?”
demanded Jakdane. “You could
have, easily.”
“I couldn't,” said Quest miserably,
and turned his face
away.
Later, alone with Trella on
the control deck, Jakdane gave
her some sober advice.
“If you think you're in love
with Quest, forget it,” he said.
“Why? Because he's a coward?
I know that ought to make
me despise him, but it doesn't
any more.”
“Not because he's a coward.
Because he's an android!”
“What? Jakdane, you can't be
serious!”
“I am. I say he's an android,
an artificial imitation of a man.
It all figures.
“Look, Trella, he said he was
born on Jupiter. A human could
stand the gravity of Jupiter, inside
a dome or a ship, but what
human could stand the rocket acceleration
necessary to break
free of Jupiter? Here's a man
strong enough to break a spaceship
safety belt just by getting
up out of his chair against it,
tough enough to take a beating
with a heavy stick without being
injured. How can you believe
he's really human?”
Trella remembered the thug
Kregg striking Quest in the face
and then crying that he had injured
his hand on the bar.
“But he said Dr. Mansard was
his father,” protested Trella.
“Robots and androids frequently
look on their makers as
their parents,” said Jakdane.
“Quest may not even know he's
57
artificial. Do you know how
Mansard died?”
“The oxygen equipment failed,
Quest said.”
“Yes. Do you know when?”
“No. Quest never did tell me,
that I remember.”
“He told me: a year before
Quest made his rocket flight to
Ganymede! If the oxygen equipment
failed, how do you think
Quest
lived in the poisonous atmosphere
of Jupiter, if he's human?”
Trella was silent.
“For the protection of humans,
there are two psychological
traits built into every robot
and android,” said Jakdane
gently. “The first is that they
can never, under any circumstances,
attack a human being,
even in self defense. The second
is that, while they may understand
sexual desire objectively,
they can never experience it
themselves.
“Those characteristics fit your
man Quest to a T, Trella. There
is no other explanation for him:
he must be an android.”
Trella did not want to believe
Jakdane was right, but his reasoning
was unassailable. Looking
upon Quest as an android,
many things were explained: his
great strength, his short, broad
build, his immunity to injury,
his refusal to defend himself
against a human, his inability to
return Trella's love for him.
It was not inconceivable that
she should have unknowingly
fallen in love with an android.
Humans could love androids,
with real affection, even knowing
that they were artificial.
There were instances of android
nursemaids who were virtually
members of the families owning
them.
She was glad now that she
had not told Quest of her mission
to Ganymede. He thought
he was Dr. Mansard's son, but
an android had no legal right of
inheritance from his owner. She
would leave it to Dom Blessing
to decide what to do about Quest.
Thus she did not, as she had
intended originally, speak to
Quest about seeing him again
after she had completed her assignment.
Even if Jakdane was
wrong and Quest was human—as
now seemed unlikely—Quest
had told her he could not love
her. Her best course was to try
to forget him.
Nor did Quest try to arrange
with her for a later meeting.
“It has been pleasant knowing
you, Trella,” he said when they
left the G-boat at White Sands.
A faraway look came into his
blue eyes, and he added: “I'm
sorry things couldn't have been
different, somehow.”
“Let's don't be sorry for what
we can't help,” she said gently,
taking his hand in farewell.
Trella took a fast plane from
White Sands, and twenty-four
hours later walked up the front
steps of the familiar brownstone
house on the outskirts of Washington.
Dom Blessing himself met her
at the door, a stooped, graying
58
man who peered at her over his
spectacles.
“You have the papers, eh?”
he said, spying the brief case.
“Good, good. Come in and we'll
see what we have, eh?”
She accompanied him through
the bare, windowless anteroom
which had always seemed to her
such a strange feature of this
luxurious house, and they entered
the big living room. They sat
before a fire in the old-fashioned
fireplace and Blessing opened the
brief case with trembling hands.
“There are things here,” he
said, his eyes sparkling as he
glanced through the notebooks.
“Yes, there are things here. We
shall make something of these,
Miss Trella, eh?”
“I'm glad they're something
you can use, Mr. Blessing,” she
said. “There's something else I
found on my trip, that I think
I should tell you about.”
She told him about Quest.
“He thinks he's the son of Dr.
Mansard,” she finished, “but apparently
he is, without knowing
it, an android Dr. Mansard built
on Jupiter.”
“He came back to Earth with
you, eh?” asked Blessing intently.
“Yes. I'm afraid it's your decision
whether to let him go on
living as a man or to tell him
he's an android and claim ownership
as Dr. Mansard's heir.”
Trella planned to spend a few
days resting in her employer's
spacious home, and then to take
a short vacation before resuming
her duties as his confidential
secretary. The next morning
when she came down from her
room, a change had been made.
Two armed men were with
Dom Blessing at breakfast and
accompanied him wherever he
went. She discovered that two
more men with guns were stationed
in the bare anteroom and
a guard was stationed at every
entrance to the house.
“Why all the protection?” she
asked Blessing.
“A wealthy man must be careful,”
said Blessing cheerfully.
“When we don't understand all
the implications of new circumstances,
we must be prepared for
anything, eh?”
There was only one new circumstance
Trella could think
of. Without actually intending
to, she exclaimed:
“You aren't afraid of Quest?
Why, an android can't hurt a
human!”
Blessing peered at her over his
spectacles.
“And what if he isn't an android,
eh? And if he is—what if
old Mansard didn't build in the
prohibition against harming humans
that's required by law?
What about that, eh?”
Trella was silent, shocked.
There was something here she
hadn't known about, hadn't even
suspected. For some reason, Dom
Blessing feared Dr. Eriklund
Mansard … or his heir … or
his mechanical servant.
She was sure that Blessing
was wrong, that Quest, whether
man or android, intended no
59
harm to him. Surely, Quest
would have said something of
such bitterness during their long
time together on Ganymede and
aspace, since he did not know of
Trella's connection with Blessing.
But, since this was to be
the atmosphere of Blessing's
house, she was glad that he decided
to assign her to take the
Mansard papers to the New
York laboratory.
Quest came the day before she
was scheduled to leave.
Trella was in the living room
with Blessing, discussing the instructions
she was to give to the
laboratory officials in New York.
The two bodyguards were with
them. The other guards were at
their posts.
Trella heard the doorbell ring.
The heavy oaken front door was
kept locked now, and the guards
in the anteroom examined callers
through a tiny window.
Suddenly alarm bells rang all
over the house. There was a terrific
crash outside the room as
the front door splintered. There
were shouts and the sound of a
shot.
“The steel doors!” cried Blessing,
turning white. “Let's get
out of here.”
He and his bodyguards ran
through the back of the house
out of the garage.
Blessing, ahead of the rest,
leaped into one of the cars and
started the engine.
The door from the house shattered
and Quest burst through.
The two guards turned and fired
together.
He could be hurt by bullets.
He was staggered momentarily.
Then, in a blur of motion, he
sprang forward and swept the
guards aside with one hand with
such force that they skidded
across the floor and lay in an
unconscious heap against the
rear of the garage. Trella had
opened the door of the car, but
it was wrenched from her hand
as Blessing stepped on the accelerator
and it leaped into the
driveway with spinning wheels.
Quest was after it, like a
chunky deer, running faster
than Trella had ever seen a man
run before.
Blessing slowed for the turn
at the end of the driveway and
glanced back over his shoulder.
Seeing Quest almost upon him,
he slammed down the accelerator
and twisted the wheel hard.
The car whipped into the
street, careened, and rolled over
and over, bringing up against a
tree on the other side in a twisted
tangle of wreckage.
With a horrified gasp, Trella
ran down the driveway toward
the smoking heap of metal.
Quest was already beside it,
probing it. As she reached his
side, he lifted the torn body of
Dom Blessing. Blessing was
dead.
“I'm lucky,” said Quest soberly.
“I would have murdered
him.”
“But why, Quest? I knew he
was afraid of you, but he didn't
tell me why.”
“It was conditioned into me,”
answered Quest “I didn't know
60
it until just now, when it ended,
but my father conditioned me
psychologically from my birth
to the task of hunting down
Dom Blessing and killing him. It
was an unconscious drive in me
that wouldn't release me until
the task was finished.
“You see, Blessing was my father's
assistant on Ganymede.
Right after my father completed
development of the surgiscope,
he and my mother blasted off for
Io. Blessing wanted the valuable
rights to the surgiscope, and he
sabotaged the ship's drive so it
would fall into Jupiter.
“But my father was able to
control it in the heavy atmosphere
of Jupiter, and landed it
successfully. I was born there,
and he conditioned me to come
to Earth and track down Blessing.
I know now that it was
part of the conditioning that I
was unable to fight any other
man until my task was finished:
it might have gotten me in trouble
and diverted me from that
purpose.”
More gently than Trella would
have believed possible for his
Jupiter-strong muscles, Quest
took her in his arms.
“Now I can say I love you,”
he said. “That was part of the
conditioning too: I couldn't love
any woman until my job was
done.”
Trella disengaged herself.
“I'm sorry,” she said. “Don't
you know this, too, now: that
you're not a man, but an android?”
He looked at her in astonishment,
stunned by her words.
“What in space makes you
think that?” he demanded.
“Why, Quest, it's obvious,”
she cried, tears in her eyes.
“Everything about you … your
build, suited for Jupiter's gravity …
your strength … the
fact that you were able to live
in Jupiter's atmosphere after
the oxygen equipment failed.
I know you think Dr. Mansard
was your father, but androids
often believe that.”
He grinned at her.
“I'm no android,” he said confidently.
“Do you forget my father
was inventor of the surgiscope?
He knew I'd have to grow
up on Jupiter, and he operated
on the genes before I was born.
He altered my inherited characteristics
to adapt me to the climate
of Jupiter … even to
being able to breathe a chlorine
atmosphere as well as an oxygen
atmosphere.”
Trella looked at him. He was
not badly hurt, any more than
an elephant would have been,
but his tunic was stained with
red blood where the bullets had
struck him. Normal android
blood was green.
“How can you be sure?” she
asked doubtfully.
“Androids are made,” he answered
with a laugh. “They
don't grow up. And I remember
my boyhood on Jupiter very
well.”
He took her in his arms again,
and this time she did not resist.
His lips were very human.
THE END
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/5/8/27588//27588-h//27588-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the central irony of Quest's last words in the story? | 27588_1RSI6ZBB_9 | [
"He claims that \"androids are made\" to justify his human status, disregarding the impact of his father's programming efforts",
"He declares that \"androids don't grow up,\" when in reality, his father programmed him to appear to (physically) age",
"He states that he \"remembers his boyhood on Jupiter,\" when in reality, he is still a boy",
"He says he \"remembers his boyhood on Jupiter,\" when in reality, his memories were programmed into his brain"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0045",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0034",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does Donald's wife think it is funny that Donald might lead the junior achievement group? | 27665_07JE5ME7_1 | [
"Donald is prone to get carried away with 'side projects,' which his wife finds amusing",
"Donald's students know more than he does about science and industry",
"Donald has no desire or innate talent to participate in sales- or marketing-related schemes",
"Donald comes home each day and complains about his students, yet he is volunteering to spend more time with them"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0024",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the most likely cause of the accident that displaced Marjorie and Donald from their home? | 27665_07JE5ME7_2 | [
"Food supply depletion",
"Radioactive toxicity",
"Viral contamination",
"Climate devastation"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0034",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Doris, Peter, and Hilary have all of the following characteristics in common EXCEPT for their: | 27665_07JE5ME7_3 | [
"Controlled movements",
"Skin complexions",
"Regulated voices",
"Intelligence quotients"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0024",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the most likely reason why Peter, Doris, and Hilary were interested in joining the junior achievement group? | 27665_07JE5ME7_4 | [
"Desire to test their creative ideas in a less restricted environment",
"Desire to recruit Donald to work for the Commission of Ridgeville",
"Desire to challenge authority and wreak havoc on the town of Ridgeville",
"Desire to acquire a large amount of funds in order to eliminate the need to go to college"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is Hilary's tone described as "dark" when he remarks that there will be people interested in using his before-shave lotion? | 27665_07JE5ME7_5 | [
"He senses that Donald is going to dismiss the idea because it is too costly",
"He senses that Donald is scheming to patent the idea for his own profiteering",
"He senses that Donald is beginning to understand his malicious intent for the before-shave lotion",
"He senses that Donald is underestimating the potential of his good idea"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Central theme of the story? Unrestrained allows for greater success and creativity and progress? | 27665_07JE5ME7_6 | [
"When children are allowed to challenge authority, the possibilities for havoc aren't as extreme as adults assume they will be",
"When children are allowed to control a group, the possibilities for destruction are higher than in a controlled, rulebound environment",
"When children are allowed to follow their dreams, the possibilities for failure are more amplified than in a practical, realistic environment",
"When children are allowed to embrace creativity, the possibilities for innovation are higher than in a rigid, standardized environment"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0024",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the central irony at the end of the story? He ends up becoming an employee of children | 27665_07JE5ME7_7 | [
"While Donald feels insecure regarding his science background, he becomes more confident due to his experience innovating with the children ",
"While Donald initially expresses concern about selling items door-to-door, all the customers end up coming to him and the group members",
"While Donald is excited about the opportunity to impart his knowledge, he becomes the employee of students who have more qualifications than he does",
"While Donald despises teaching, he ends up committing to more teaching-related responsibilities over the course of a school year"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0024",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
27,665 | 27665_07JE5ME7 | 22 | 1,019 | Gutenberg | Junior Achievement | 1972.0 | Lee, William M. | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Fallout is, of course, always disastrous—
one way or another
JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT
BY WILLIAM LEE
ILLUSTRATED BY SCHOENHERR
"What would you think," I asked
Marjorie over supper, "if I should undertake
to lead a junior achievement
group this summer?"
She pondered it while she went to
the kitchen to bring in the dessert.
It was dried apricot pie, and very
tasty, I might add.
"Why, Donald," she said, "it could
be quite interesting, if I understand
what a junior achievement group is.
What gave you the idea?"
"It wasn't my idea, really," I admitted.
"Mr. McCormack called me
to the office today, and told me that
some of the children in the lower
grades wanted to start one. They
need adult guidance of course, and
one of the group suggested my name."
I should explain, perhaps, that I
teach a course in general science in
our Ridgeville Junior High School,
and another in general physics in the
Senior High School. It's a privilege
which I'm sure many educators must
envy, teaching in Ridgeville, for our
new school is a fine one, and our
academic standards are high. On the
other hand, the fathers of most of
my students work for the Commission
and a constant awareness of the Commission
and its work pervades the
town. It is an uneasy privilege then,
at least sometimes, to teach my old-fashioned
brand of science to these
children of a new age.
"That's very nice," said Marjorie.
"What does a junior achievement
group do?"
"It has the purpose," I told her,
"of teaching the members something
about commerce and industry. They
manufacture simple compositions
like polishing waxes and sell them
from door-to-door. Some groups have
built up tidy little bank accounts
which are available for later educational
expenses."
"Gracious, you wouldn't have to
sell from door-to-door, would you?"
"Of course not. I'd just tell the
kids how to do it."
Marjorie put back her head and
laughed, and I was forced to join her,
for we both recognize that my understanding
and "feel" for commercial
matters—if I may use that expression—is
almost nonexistent.
"Oh, all right," I said, "laugh at
my commercial aspirations. But don't
worry about it, really. Mr. McCormack
said we could get Mr. Wells from
Commercial Department to help out
if he was needed. There is one problem,
though. Mr. McCormack is going
to put up fifty dollars to buy any
raw materials wanted and he rather
suggested that I might advance another
fifty. The question is, could we
do it?"
Marjorie did mental arithmetic.
"Yes," she said, "yes, if it's something
you'd like to do."
We've had to watch such things
rather closely for the last ten—no,
eleven years. Back in the old Ridgeville,
fifty-odd miles to the south, we
had our home almost paid for, when
the accident occurred. It was in the
path of the heaviest fallout, and we
couldn't have kept on living there
even if the town had stayed. When
Ridgeville moved to its present site,
so, of course, did we, which meant
starting mortgage payments all over
again.
Thus it was that on a Wednesday
morning about three weeks later, I
was sitting at one end of a plank picnic
table with five boys and girls
lined up along the sides. This was to
be our headquarters and factory for
the summer—a roomy unused barn
belonging to the parents of one of
the group members, Tommy Miller.
"O.K.," I said, "let's relax. You
don't need to treat me as a teacher,
you know. I stopped being a school
teacher when the final grades went in
last Friday. I'm on vacation now. My
job here is only to advise, and I'm
going to do that as little as possible.
You're going to decide what to do,
and if it's safe and legal and possible
to do with the starting capital we
have, I'll go along with it and help
in any way I can. This is your meeting."
Mr. McCormack had told me, and
in some detail, about the youngsters
I'd be dealing with. The three who
were sitting to my left were the ones
who had proposed the group in the
first place.
Doris Enright was a grave young
lady of ten years, who might, I
thought, be quite a beauty in a few
more years, but was at the moment
rather angular—all shoulders and elbows.
Peter Cope, Jr. and Hilary Matlack
were skinny kids, too. The three
were of an age and were all tall for
ten-year-olds.
I had the impression during that
first meeting that they looked rather
alike, but this wasn't so. Their features
were quite different. Perhaps
from association, for they were close
friends, they had just come to have
a certain similarity of restrained gesture
and of modulated voice. And
they were all tanned by sun and wind
to a degree that made their eyes seem
light and their teeth startlingly white.
The two on my right were cast in
a different mold. Mary McCready
was a big husky redhead of twelve,
with a face full of freckles and an
infectious laugh, and Tommy Miller,
a few months younger, was just an
average, extroverted, well adjusted
youngster, noisy and restless, tee-shirted
and butch-barbered.
The group exchanged looks to see
who would lead off, and Peter Cope
seemed to be elected.
"Well, Mr. Henderson, a junior
achievement group is a bunch of kids
who get together to manufacture and
sell things, and maybe make some
money."
"Is that what you want to do," I
asked, "make money?"
"Why not?" Tommy asked.
"There's something wrong with making
money?"
"Well, sure, I suppose we want to,"
said Hilary. "We'll need some money
to do the things we want to do later."
"And what sort of things would
you like to make and sell?" I asked.
The usual products, of course, with
these junior achievement efforts, are
chemical specialties that can be made
safely and that people will buy and
use without misgivings—solvent to
free up rusty bolts, cleaner to remove
road tar, mechanic's hand soap—that
sort of thing. Mr. McCormack had
told me, though, that I might find
these youngsters a bit more ambitious.
"The Miller boy and Mary McCready,"
he had said, "have exceptionally
high IQ's—around one forty
or one fifty. The other three are hard
to classify. They have some of the
attributes of exceptional pupils, but
much of the time they seem to have
little interest in their studies. The
junior achievement idea has sparked
their imaginations. Maybe it'll be just
what they need."
Mary said, "Why don't we make a
freckle remover? I'd be our first customer."
"The thing to do," Tommy offered,
"is to figure out what people in
Ridgeville want to buy, then sell it
to them."
"I'd like to make something by
powder metallurgy techniques," said
Pete. He fixed me with a challenging
eye. "You should be able to make
ball bearings by molding, then densify
them by electroplating."
"And all we'd need is a hydraulic
press," I told him, "which, on a guess,
might cost ten thousand dollars. Let's
think of something easier."
Pete mulled it over and nodded
reluctantly. "Then maybe something
in the electronics field. A hi-fi sub-assembly
of some kind."
"How about a new detergent?" Hilary
put in.
"Like the liquid dishwashing detergents?"
I asked.
He was scornful. "No, they're formulations—you
know, mixtures.
That's cookbook chemistry. I mean a
brand new synthetic detergent. I've
got an idea for one that ought to be
good even in the hard water we've
got around here."
"Well, now," I said, "organic synthesis
sounds like another operation
calling for capital investment. If we
should keep the achievement group
going for several summers, it might
be possible later on to carry out a
safe synthesis of some sort. You're
Dr. Matlack's son, aren't you? Been
dipping into your father's library?"
"Some," said Hilary, "and I've got
a home laboratory."
"How about you, Doris?" I prompted.
"Do you have a special field of interest?"
"No." She shook her head in mock
despondency. "I'm not very technical.
Just sort of miscellaneous. But if the
group wanted to raise some mice, I'd
be willing to turn over a project I've
had going at home."
"You could sell mice?" Tommy demanded
incredulously.
"Mice," I echoed, then sat back and
thought about it. "Are they a pure
strain? One of the recognized laboratory
strains? Healthy mice of the
right strain," I explained to Tommy,
"might be sold to laboratories. I have
an idea the Commission buys a supply
every month."
"No," said Doris, "these aren't laboratory
mice. They're fancy ones. I
got the first four pairs from a pet
shop in Denver, but they're red—sort
of chipmunk color, you know. I've
carried them through seventeen generations
of careful selection."
"Well, now," I admitted, "the market
for red mice might be rather limited.
Why don't you consider making
an after-shave lotion? Denatured alcohol,
glycerine, water, a little color
and perfume. You could buy some
bottles and have some labels printed.
You'd be in business before you
knew it."
There was a pause, then Tommy
inquired, "How do you sell it?"
"Door-to-door."
He made a face. "Never build up
any volume. Unless it did something
extra. You say we'd put color in it.
How about enough color to leave
your face looking tanned. Men won't
use cosmetics and junk, but if they
didn't have to admit it, they might
like the shave lotion."
Hilary had been deep in thought.
He said suddenly, "Gosh, I think I
know how to make a—what do you
want to call it—a before-shave lotion."
"What would that be?" I asked.
"You'd use it before you shaved."
"I suppose there might be people
who'd prefer to use it beforehand,"
I conceded.
"There will be people," he said
darkly, and subsided.
Mrs. Miller came out to the barn
after a while, bringing a bucket of
soft drinks and ice, a couple of loaves
of bread and ingredients for a variety
of sandwiches. The parents had
agreed to underwrite lunches at the
barn and Betty Miller philosophically
assumed the role of commissary
officer. She paused only to say hello
and to ask how we were progressing
with our organization meeting.
I'd forgotten all about organization,
and that, according to all the
articles I had perused, is most important
to such groups. It's standard practice
for every member of the group
to be a company officer. Of course a
young boy who doesn't know any better,
may wind up a sales manager.
Over the sandwiches, then, I suggested
nominating company officers,
but they seemed not to be interested.
Peter Cope waved it off by remarking
that they'd each do what came
naturally. On the other hand, they
pondered at some length about a
name for the organization, without
reaching any conclusions, so we returned
to the problem of what to
make.
It was Mary, finally, who advanced
the thought of kites. At first there
was little enthusiasm, then Peter said,
"You know, we could work up something
new. Has anybody ever seen a
kite made like a wind sock?"
Nobody had. Pete drew figures in
the air with his hands. "How about
the hole at the small end?"
"I'll make one tonight," said Doris,
"and think about the small end.
It'll work out all right."
I wished that the youngsters weren't
starting out by inventing a new
article to manufacture, and risking an
almost certain disappointment, but to
hold my guidance to the minimum, I
said nothing, knowing that later I
could help them redesign it along
standard lines.
At supper I reviewed the day's
happenings with Marjorie and tried
to recall all of the ideas which had
been propounded. Most of them were
impractical, of course, for a group of
children to attempt, but several of
them appeared quite attractive.
Tommy, for example, wanted to
put tooth powder into tablets that
one would chew before brushing the
teeth. He thought there should be
two colors in the same bottle—orange
for morning and blue for night,
the blue ones designed to leave the
mouth alkaline at bed time.
Pete wanted to make a combination
nail and wood screw. You'd
drive it in with a hammer up to the
threaded part, then send it home with
a few turns of a screwdriver.
Hilary, reluctantly forsaking his
ideas on detergents, suggested we
make black plastic discs, like poker
chips but thinner and as cheap as
possible, to scatter on a snowy sidewalk
where they would pick up extra
heat from the sun and melt the
snow more rapidly. Afterward one
would sweep up and collect the discs.
Doris added to this that if you
could make the discs light enough to
float, they might be colored white
and spread on the surface of a reservoir
to reduce evaporation.
These latter ideas had made unknowing
use of some basic physics,
and I'm afraid I relapsed for a few
minutes into the role of teacher and
told them a little bit about the laws
of radiation and absorption of heat.
"My," said Marjorie, "they're really
smart boys and girls. Tommy Miller
does sound like a born salesman.
Somehow I don't think you're going
to have to call in Mr. Wells."
I do feel just a little embarrassed
about the kite, even now. The fact
that it flew surprised me. That it flew
so confoundedly well was humiliating.
Four of them were at the barn
when I arrived next morning; or
rather on the rise of ground just beyond
it, and the kite hung motionless
and almost out of sight in the pale
sky. I stood and watched for a moment,
then they saw me.
"Hello, Mr. Henderson," Mary said,
and proffered the cord which was
wound on a fishing reel. I played the
kite up and down for a few minutes,
then reeled it in. It was, almost exactly,
a wind sock, but the hole at the
small end was shaped—by wire—into
the general form of a kidney bean.
It was beautifully made, and had a
sort of professional look about it.
"It flies too well," Mary told Doris.
"A kite ought to get caught in a tree
sometimes."
"You're right," Doris agreed. "Let's
see it." She gave the wire at the small
end the slightest of twists. "There, it
ought to swoop."
Sure enough, in the moderate
breeze of that morning, the kite
swooped and yawed to Mary's entire
satisfaction. As we trailed back to the
barn I asked Doris, "How did you
know that flattening the lower edge
of the hole would create instability?"
She looked doubtful.
"Why it would have to, wouldn't
it? It changed the pattern of air pressures."
She glanced at me quickly.
"Of course, I tried a lot of different
shapes while I was making it."
"Naturally," I said, and let it go at
that. "Where's Tommy?"
"He stopped off at the bank," Pete
Cope told me, "to borrow some money.
We'll want to buy materials to
make some of these kites."
"But I said yesterday that Mr. McCormack
and I were going to advance
some cash to get started."
"Oh, sure, but don't you think it
would be better to borrow from a
bank? More businesslike?"
"Doubtless," I said, "but banks generally
want some security." I would
have gone on and explained matters
further, except that Tommy walked
in and handed me a pocket check
book.
"I got two hundred and fifty," he
volunteered—not without a hint of
complacency in his voice. "It didn't
take long, but they sure made it out
a big deal. Half the guys in the bank
had to be called in to listen to the
proposition. The account's in your
name, Mr. Henderson, and you'll have
to make out the checks. And they
want you to stop in at the bank and
give them a specimen signature. Oh,
yes, and cosign the note."
My heart sank. I'd never had any
dealings with banks except in the
matter of mortgages, and bank people
make me most uneasy. To say
nothing of finding myself responsible
for a two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar
note—over two weeks salary. I made
a mental vow to sign very few checks.
"So then I stopped by at Apex
Stationers," Tommy went on, "and ordered
some paper and envelopes. We
hadn't picked a name yesterday, but I
figured what's to lose, and picked one.
Ridge Industries, how's that?" Everybody
nodded.
"Just three lines on the letterhead,"
he explained. "Ridge Industries—Ridgeville—Montana."
I got my voice back and said, "Engraved,
I trust."
"Well, sure," he replied. "You can't
afford to look chintzy."
My appetite was not at its best
that evening, and Marjorie recognized
that something was concerning
me, but she asked no questions, and
I only told her about the success of
the kite, and the youngsters embarking
on a shopping trip for paper, glue
and wood splints. There was no use
in both of us worrying.
On Friday we all got down to work,
and presently had a regular production
line under way; stapling the
wood splints, then wetting them with
a resin solution and shaping them
over a mandrel to stiffen, cutting the
plastic film around a pattern, assembling
and hanging the finished kites
from an overhead beam until the cement
had set. Pete Cope had located
a big roll of red plastic film from
somewhere, and it made a wonderful-looking
kite. Happily, I didn't know
what the film cost until the first kites
were sold.
By Wednesday of the following
week we had almost three hundred
kites finished and packed into flat
cardboard boxes, and frankly I didn't
care if I never saw another. Tommy,
who by mutual consent, was our
authority on sales, didn't want to sell
any until we had, as he put it, enough
to meet the demand, but this quantity
seemed to satisfy him. He said he
would sell them the next week and
Mary McCready, with a fine burst of
confidence, asked him in all seriousness
to be sure to hold out a dozen.
Three other things occurred that
day, two of which I knew about immediately.
Mary brought a portable
typewriter from home and spent part
of the afternoon banging away at
what seemed to me, since I use two
fingers only, a very creditable speed.
And Hilary brought in a bottle of
his new detergent. It was a syrupy
yellow liquid with a nice collar of
suds. He'd been busy in his home
laboratory after all, it seemed.
"What is it?" I asked. "You never
told us."
Hilary grinned. "Lauryl benzyl
phosphonic acid, dipotassium salt, in
20% solution."
"Goodness." I protested, "it's been
twenty-five years since my last course
in chemistry. Perhaps if I saw the
formula—."
He gave me a singularly adult
smile and jotted down a scrawl of
symbols and lines. It meant little to
me.
"Is it good?"
For answer he seized the ice bucket,
now empty of its soda bottles,
trickled in a few drops from the bottle
and swished the contents. Foam
mounted to the rim and spilled over.
"And that's our best grade of Ridgeville
water," he pointed out. "Hardest
in the country."
The third event of Wednesday
came to my ears on Thursday morning.
I was a little late arriving at the
barn, and was taken a bit aback to
find the roadway leading to it rather
full of parked automobiles, and the
barn itself rather full of people, including
two policemen. Our Ridgeville
police are quite young men, but
in uniform they still look ominous
and I was relieved to see that they
were laughing and evidently enjoying
themselves.
"Well, now," I demanded, in my
best classroom voice. "What is all
this?"
"Are you Henderson?" the larger
policeman asked.
"I am indeed," I said, and a flash
bulb went off. A young lady grasped
my arm.
"Oh, please, Mr. Henderson, come
outside where it's quieter and tell me
all about it."
"Perhaps," I countered, "somebody
should tell me."
"You mean you don't know, honestly?
Oh, it's fabulous. Best story I've
had for ages. It'll make the city papers."
She led me around the corner
of the barn to a spot of comparative
quiet.
"You didn't know that one of your
junior whatsisnames poured detergent
in the Memorial Fountain basin
last night?"
I shook my head numbly.
"It was priceless. Just before rush
hour. Suds built up in the basin and
overflowed, and down the library
steps and covered the whole street.
And the funniest part was they kept
right on coming. You couldn't imagine
so much suds coming from that
little pool of water. There was a
three-block traffic jam and Harry got
us some marvelous pictures—men
rolling up their trousers to wade
across the street. And this morning,"
she chortled, "somebody phoned in
an anonymous tip to the police—of
course it was the same boy that did
it—Tommy—Miller?—and so here
we are. And we just saw a demonstration
of that fabulous kite and saw
all those simply captivating mice."
"Mice?"
"Yes, of course. Who would ever
have thought you could breed mice
with those cute furry tails?"
Well, after a while things quieted
down. They had to. The police left
after sobering up long enough to
give me a serious warning against
letting such a thing happen again.
Mr. Miller, who had come home to
see what all the excitement was, went
back to work and Mrs. Miller went
back to the house and the reporter
and photographer drifted off to file
their story, or whatever it is they do.
Tommy was jubilant.
"Did you hear what she said? It'll
make the city papers. I wish we had
a thousand kites. Ten thousand. Oh
boy, selling is fun. Hilary, when can
you make some more of that stuff?
And Doris, how many mice do you
have?"
Those mice! I have always kept
my enthusiasm for rodents within
bounds, but I must admit they were
charming little beasts, with tails as
bushy as miniature squirrels.
"How many generations?" I asked
Doris.
"Seventeen. No, eighteen, now.
Want to see the genetic charts?"
I won't try to explain it as she did
to me, but it was quite evident that
the new mice were breeding true.
Presently we asked Betty Miller to
come back down to the barn for a
conference. She listened and asked
questions. At last she said, "Well, all
right, if you promise me they can't
get out of their cages. But heaven
knows what you'll do when fall
comes. They won't live in an unheated
barn and you can't bring them
into the house."
"We'll be out of the mouse business
by then," Doris predicted. "Every pet
shop in the country will have
them and they'll be down to nothing
apiece."
Doris was right, of course, in spite
of our efforts to protect the market.
Anyhow that ushered in our cage
building phase, and for the next
week—with a few interruptions—we
built cages, hundreds of them, a good
many for breeding, but mostly for
shipping.
It was rather regrettable that, after
the
Courier
gave us most of the third
page, including photographs, we rarely
had a day without a few visitors.
Many of them wanted to buy mice or
kites, but Tommy refused to sell any
mice at retail and we soon had to disappoint
those who wanted kites. The
Supermarket took all we had—except
a dozen—and at a dollar fifty
each. Tommy's ideas of pricing rather
frightened me, but he set the value
of the mice at ten dollars a pair
and got it without any arguments.
Our beautiful stationery arrived,
and we had some invoice forms printed
up in a hurry—not engraved, for
a wonder.
It was on Tuesday—following the
Thursday—that a lanky young man
disentangled himself from his car
and strolled into the barn. I looked
up from the floor where I was tacking
squares of screening onto wooden
frames.
"Hi," he said. "You're Donald
Henderson, right? My name is McCord—Jeff
McCord—and I work in
the Patent Section at the Commission's
downtown office. My boss sent
me over here, but if he hadn't, I
think I'd have come anyway. What
are you doing to get patent protection
on Ridge Industries' new developments?"
I got my back unkinked and dusted
off my knees. "Well, now," I said,
"I've been wondering whether something
shouldn't be done, but I know
very little about such matters—."
"Exactly," he broke in, "we guessed
that might be the case, and there are
three patent men in our office who'd
like to chip in and contribute some
time. Partly for the kicks and partly
because we think you may have some
things worth protecting. How about
it? You worry about the filing and
final fees. That's sixty bucks per
brainstorm. We'll worry about everything
else."
"What's to lose," Tommy interjected.
And so we acquired a patent attorney,
several of them, in fact.
The day that our application on
the kite design went to Washington,
Mary wrote a dozen toy manufacturers
scattered from New York to Los
Angeles, sent a kite to each one and
offered to license the design. Result,
one licensee with a thousand dollar
advance against next season's royalties.
It was a rainy morning about three
weeks later that I arrived at the barn.
Jeff McCord was there, and the whole
team except Tommy. Jeff lowered his
feet from the picnic table and said,
"Hi."
"Hi yourself," I told him. "You
look pleased."
"I am," he replied, "in a cautious
legal sense, of course. Hilary and I
were just going over the situation on
his phosphonate detergent. I've spent
the last three nights studying the patent
literature and a few standard
texts touching on phosphonates.
There are a zillion patents on synthetic
detergents and a good round
fifty on phosphonates, but it looks"—he
held up a long admonitory hand—"it
just looks as though we had a clear
spot. If we do get protection, you've
got a real salable property."
"That's fine, Mr. McCord," Hilary
said, "but it's not very important."
"No?" Jeff tilted an inquiring eyebrow
at me, and I handed him a small
bottle. He opened and sniffed at it
gingerly. "What gives?"
"Before-shave lotion," Hilary told
him. "You've shaved this morning,
but try some anyway."
Jeff looked momentarily dubious,
then puddled some in his palm and
moistened his jaw line. "Smells
good," he noted, "and feels nice and
cool. Now what?"
"Wipe your face." Jeff located a
handkerchief and wiped, looked at
the cloth, wiped again, and stared.
"What is it?"
"A whisker stiffener. It makes each
hair brittle enough to break off right
at the surface of your skin."
"So I perceive. What is it?"
"Oh, just a mixture of stuff. Cookbook
chemistry. Cysteine thiolactone
and a fat-soluble magnesium compound."
"I see. Just a mixture of stuff. And
do your whiskers grow back the next
day?"
"Right on schedule," I said.
McCord unfolded his length and
stood staring out into the rain. Presently
he said, "Henderson, Hilary
and I are heading for my office. We
can work there better than here, and
if we're going to break the hearts of
the razor industry, there's no better
time to start than now."
When they had driven off I turned
and said, "Let's talk a while. We can
always clean mouse cages later.
Where's Tommy?"
"Oh, he stopped at the bank to get
a loan."
"What on earth for? We have over
six thousand in the account."
"Well," Peter said, looking a little
embarrassed, "we were planning to
buy a hydraulic press. You see, Doris
put some embroidery on that scheme
of mine for making ball bearings."
He grabbed a sheet of paper. "Look,
we make a roller bearing, this shape
only it's a permanent magnet. Then
you see—." And he was off.
"What did they do today, dear?"
Marge asked as she refilled my coffee
cup.
"Thanks," I said. "Let's see, it was
a big day. We picked out a hydraulic
press, Doris read us the first chapter
of the book she's starting, and we
found a place over a garage on
Fourth Street that we can rent for
winter quarters. Oh, yes, and Jeff is
starting action to get the company
incorporated."
"Winter quarters," Marge repeated.
"You mean you're going to try to
keep the group going after school
starts?"
"Why not? The kids can sail
through their courses without thinking
about them, and actually they
won't put in more than a few hours
a week during the school year."
"Even so, it's child labor, isn't it?"
"Child labor nothing. They're the
employers. Jeff McCord and I will
be the only employees—just at first,
anyway."
Marge choked on something. "Did
you say you'd be an employee?"
"Sure," I told her. "They've offered
me a small share of the company,
and I'd be crazy to turn it down. After
all, what's to lose?"
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Analog Science Fact & Fiction
July 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/7/6/6/27665//27665-h//27665-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the most likely reason for the junior achievement group's shared characteristics? | 27665_07JE5ME7_8 | [
"They have experienced expected and unanticipated consequences of nuclear fallout",
"Their parents are all members of the Ridgeville Commission",
"They are all actually androids that have been programmed by scientists of the Ridgeville Commission",
"They have been meeting secretly for years before they came together under the guise of the junior achievement group"
] | 1 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0024",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0034",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is the best description of the narrator? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_1 | [
"A doctor who is also a food critic",
"An angsty crew member who is always present in the mess hall",
"A mutinous doctor who wants to run the ship himself",
"A surgeon who happens to know some things about the history of food"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is true about the importance of alge to the Martians? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_2 | [
"It is the only thing they can eat",
"All of the spaceships are named after different species of alge",
"Most of the economy is geared around growing and collecting alge",
"The nickname for their species is inspired by the reliance on alge"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is not true about the surgeon's job? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_3 | [
"He takes care of the mental health and morale of the crew ",
"He has to know when to offer alcohol as the appropriate remedy for a situation",
"He is a sounding-board for those who need to complain",
"He's the person to file grievances with when there are interpersonal issues"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What does the narrator seem to think makes a good cook on a spacer? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_4 | [
"Someone who can get food out as fast and as consistently as possible",
"They can bring people together in conversations about food",
"They are willing to be creative in addition to an attention to detail",
"They are able to make meals to help the crewmates lose weight"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is the best description of the relationship between the Doc and the captain? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_5 | [
"They are old friends and the Doc is happy to let poor behavior slide",
"The Doc respects the captain's position but say something if he thinks he goes too far",
"The Doc never puts up with the captain, which makes their relationship very tense",
"The Doc is the official mediator between the captian and the rest of the crew"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is the best description of the relationship between the Doc and Bailey? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_6 | [
"They are friendly but butt heads a little bit with respect to others on the ship",
"The Doc expects to be waited on by Bailey",
"They don't interact at all, it's a very superficial relationship",
"They are old friends and like to go for a drink together"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is the best description of the impact of ketchup being a personal effect? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_7 | [
"It showed how dedicated the captain was to his ploy to get the cook to be more creative",
"It made the rest of the crew angry that they did not have condiments of their own",
"It took away from the weight allowances of the rest of the crew, showing how selfish the captain is",
"It showed how little the captain thought of the cook's abilities, if he expected to use all of the ketchup he brought"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these best describes the captain? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_8 | [
"He is a tempermental man who wants everyone to stay out of his way",
"He has good intentions but always has a bad effect on those around him",
"He is a sly but fair man who pushes his crew to do their best",
"He is a pushy person who gets on people's bad sides but thinks he has good intentions"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What likely happens after the story is over? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_9 | [
"The Doc has to treat the crew for food poisoning because they are not used to real meat",
"Bailey is renowned for his culinary breakthrough, and his future restaurant is a success",
"The crew goes down in history, but not for the culinary feat",
"Bailey decides not to open a restaurant so he can continue cooking on ships "
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
51,597 | 51597_3MTDEMTK | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Gourmet | 1968.0 | Lang, Allen Kim | Science fiction; Short stories; Cooks -- Fiction; PS; Space ships -- Fiction; Space flight to Mars -- Fiction | GOURMET
By ALLEN KIM LANG
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Galaxy Magazine April 1962.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
This was the endless problem of all
spaceship cooks: He had to feed the men
tomorrow on what they had eaten today!
Unable to get out to the ballgame and a long way off from the girls,
men on ships think about, talk about, bitch about their food. It's
true that Woman remains a topic of thoughtful study, but discussion
can never replace practice in an art. Food, on the other hand, is a
challenge shipmen face three times a day, so central to their thoughts
that a history of sea-faring can be read from a commissary list.
In the days when salt-sea sailors were charting islands and spearing
seals, for example, the fo'c's'le hands called themselves Lobscousers,
celebrating the liquid hash then prominent in the marine menu. The
Limey sailor got the name of the anti-scorbutic citrus squeezed into
his diet, a fruit known to us mariners of a more sophisticated age
only as garnish for our groundside gin-and-tonic. And today we Marsmen
are called Slimeheads, honoring in our title the
Chlorella
and
Scenedesmus
algae that, by filling up the spaces within, open the
road to the larger Space without.
Should any groundsman dispute the importance of belly-furniture in
history—whether it be exterminating whales, or introducing syphilis
to the Fiji Islanders, or settling the Australian littoral with
cross-coves from Middlesex and Hampshire—he is referred to the
hundred-and-first chapter of
Moby Dick
, a book spooled in the
amusement tanks of all but the smallest spacers. I trust, however, that
no Marsman will undertake to review this inventory of refreshment more
than a week from groundfall. A catalogue of sides of beef and heads of
Leyden cheese and ankers of good Geneva would prove heavy reading for a
man condemned to snack on the Chlorella-spawn of cis-Martian space.
The
Pequod's
crew ate wormy biscuit and salt beef. Nimitz's men won
their war on canned pork and beans. The
Triton
made her underwater
periplus of Earth with a galley stocked with frozen pizza and
concentrated apple-juice. But then, when sailors left the seas for the
skies, a decline set in.
The first amenity of groundside existence to be abandoned was decent
food. The earliest men into the vacuum swallowed protein squeezings
from aluminum tubes, and were glad enough to drop back to the
groundsman's diet of steak and fried potatoes.
Long before I was a boy in Med School, itching to look at black sky
through a view-port, galley science had fulfilled the disgusting
exordium of
Isaiah
36:12, to feed the Slimeheads for breakfast today
what was day-before-yesterday's table-scraps and jakes-water.
The Ship's Cook, the man who accomplishes the daily miracle of turning
offal into eatables, is in many ways the most vital man aboard a
spacer. He can make morale or foment a mutiny. His power is paramount.
Slimeheads remember the H. M. S.
Ajax
fiasco, for example, in which a
galleyman leveled his Chlorella tanks with heavy water from the ship's
shielding. Four officers and twenty-one Other Ranks were rescued from
the
Ajax
in deep space, half dead from deuterium poisoning. We think
of the
Benjo Maru
incident, too, caused by a Ship's Cook who allowed
his algaeal staff-of-life to become contaminated with a fast-growing
Saccharomycodes
yeast. The Japanese vessel staggered to her pad at
Piano West after a twenty-week drunk: the alien yeast had got into
the stomach of every man aboard, where it fermented each subsequent
bite he ate to a superior grade of
sake
. And for a third footnote to
the ancient observation, "God sends food, and the Devil sends cooks,"
Marsmen will recall what happened aboard my ship the
Charles Partlow
Sale
.
The
Sale
blasted off from Brady Station in the middle of August, due
in at Piano West in early May. In no special hurry, we were taking
the low-energy route to Mars, a pathway about as long in time as the
human period of gestation. Our cargo consisted mostly of Tien-Shen fir
seedlings and some tons of an arctic grass-seed—these to be planted
in the
maria
to squeeze out the native blue bugberry vines. We had
aboard the Registry minimum of six men and three officers. Ship's
Surgeon was myself, Paul Vilanova. Our Captain was Willy Winkelmann,
the hardest man in space and very likely the fattest. Ship's Cook was
Robert Bailey.
Cooking aboard a spacer is a job combining the more frustrating
tensions of biochemistry, applied mycology, high-speed farming,
dietetics and sewage engineering. It's the Cook's responsibility to
see that each man aboard gets each day no less than five pounds of
water, two pounds of oxygen, and one-and-a-half pounds of dry food.
This isn't just a paragraph from the Spacer Union Contract. It's a
statement of the least fuel a man can run on.
Twelve tons of water, oxygen, and food would have filled the cargo
compartments to bursting, and left a small ship like the
C. P. Sale
no reason to reach for Mars. By allowing a colony of Chlorella algae to
work over our used air, water and other effluvia, though, three tons
of metabolites would see us through from Brady Station to Piano West
and back. Recycling was the answer. The molecule of carbohydrate, fat,
protein or mineral that didn't feed the crew fed the algae. And the
algae fed us.
All waste was used to fertilize our liquid fields. Even the stubble
from our 2,680 shaves and the clippings from our 666 haircuts en route
and back would be fed into the Chlorella tanks. Human hair is rich in
essential amino acids.
The algae—dried by the Cook, bleached with methyl alcohol to kill the
smell and make the residue more digestible, disguised and seasoned in a
hundred ways—served as a sort of meat-and-potatoes that never quite
wore out. Our air and water were equally immortal. Each molecule of
oxygen would be conversant with the alveoli of every man aboard by the
end of our trip. Every drop of water would have been intimate with the
glomeruli of each kidney on the ship before we grounded in. Groundling
politicians are right enough when they say that we spacers are a
breed apart. We're the one race of men who can't afford the luxury of
squeamishness.
Though I'm signed aboard as Ship's Surgeon, I seldom lift a knife
in space. My employment is more in the nature of TS-card-puncher
extraordinary. My duties are to serve as wailing-wall, morale officer,
guardian of the medicinal whiskey and frustrator of mutual murder.
Generally the man aboard who'd serve as the most popular murder-victim
is the Cook. This trip, the-man-you-love-to-hate was our Captain.
If the Cook hadn't problems enough with the chemical and psychic duties
of his office, Winkelmann supplied the want. Captain Willy Winkelmann
was the sort of man who, if he had to go into space at all, had best do
so alone. If the Prussians had a Marine Corps, Winkelmann would have
done splendidly as Drill Instructor for their boot camp. His heart
was a chip of helium ice, his voice dripped sarcastic acid. The planet
Earth was hardly large enough to accommodate a wart as annoying as
Willy Winkelmann. Cheek-by-jowl every day in a nacelle the size of a
Pullman car, our Captain quickly established himself as a major social
hemorrhoid.
The Captain's particular patsy was, of course, young Bailey the Cook.
It was Winkelmann who saw humorous possibilities in the entry, "Bailey,
Robert," on Ship's Articles. He at once renamed our unfortunate
shipmate "Belly-Robber." It was Winkelmann who discussed
haut
cuisine
and the properties of the nobler wines while we munched our
algaeburgers and sipped coffee that tasted of utility water. And it was
Captain Willy Winkelmann who never referred to the ship's head by any
other name than The Kitchen Cabinet.
Bailey tried to feed us by groundside standards. He hid the taste
of synthetic methionine—an essential amino acid not synthesized by
Chlorella—by seasoning our algaeal repasts with pinches of oregano
and thyme. He tinted the pale-green dollops of pressed Chlorella pink,
textured the mass to the consistency of hamburger and toasted the
slabs to a delicate brown in a forlorn attempt to make mock-meat.
For dessert, he served a fudge compounded from the dextrose-paste of
the carbohydrate recycler. The crew thanked him. The Captain did not.
"Belly-Robber," he said, his tone icy as winter wind off the North Sea,
"you had best cycle this mess through the tanks again. There is a pun
in my home country:
Mensch ist was er isst.
It means, you are what
you eat. I think you are impertinent to suggest I should become this
Schweinerei
you are feeding me." Captain Winkelmann blotted his chin
with his napkin, heaved his bulk up from the table, and climbed up the
ladder from the dining-cubby.
"Doc, do you like Winkelmann?" the Cook asked me.
"Not much," I said. "I suspect that the finest gift our Captain can
give his mother is to be absent from her on Mother's Day. But we've got
to live with him. He's a good man at driving a ship."
"I wish he'd leave off driving this Cook," Bailey said. "The fat swine!"
"His plumpness is an unwitting tribute to your cooking, Bailey," I
said. "He eats well. We all do. I've dined aboard a lot of spacers in
my time, and I'll testify that you set a table second to none."
Bailey took a handful of dried Chlorella from a bin and fingered it. It
was green, smelled of swamp, and looked appetizing as a bedsore. "This
is what I have to work with," he said. He tossed the stuff back into
its bin. "In Ohio, which is my home country, in the presence of ladies,
we'd call such garbage Horse-Leavings."
"You'll never make Winkelmann happy," I said. "Even the simultaneous
death of all other human beings could hardly make him smile. Keep up
the good work, though, and you'll keep our Captain fat."
Bailey nodded from his one-man cloud of gloom. I got a bottle of rye
from Medical Stores and offered him a therapeutic draught. The Cook
waved my gift aside. "Not now, Doc," he said. "I'm thinking about
tomorrow's menu."
The product of Bailey's cerebrations was on the mess table at noon the
next day. We were each served an individual head of lettuce, dressed
with something very like vinegar and oil, spiced with tiny leaves of
burnet. How Bailey had constructed those synthetic lettuces I can only
guess: the hours spent preparing a green Chlorella paste, rolling and
drying and shaping each artificial leaf, the fitting together of nine
heads like crisp, three-dimensional jigsaw puzzles. The
pièce de
résistance
was again a "hamburger steak;" but this time the algaeal
mass that made it up was buried in a rich, meaty gravy that was only
faintly green. The essence-of-steak used in these Chlorella cutlets had
been sprinkled with a lavish hand. Garlic was richly in evidence. "It's
so tender," the radioman joked, "that I can hardly believe it's really
steak."
Bailey stared across the dining-cubby toward Winkelmann, silently
imploring the Captain's ratification of his masterpiece. The big
man's pink cheeks bulged and jumped with his chewing. He swallowed.
"Belly-Robber," Winkelmann said, "I had almost rather you served me
this pond-scum raw than have it all mucked-up with synthetic onions and
cycler-salt."
"You seem able enough to choke down Bailey's chow, Captain," I said. I
gazed at Winkelmann's form, bulbous from a lifetime of surfeit feeding.
"Yes, I eat it," the Captain said, taking and talking through another
bite. "But I eat only as a man in the desert will eat worms and
grasshoppers, to stay alive."
"Sir, what in heaven's name do you expect from me?" Bailey pleaded.
"Only good food," Winkelmann mumbled through his mouthful of disguised
algae. He tapped his head with a finger. "This—the brain that guides
the ship—cannot be coaxed to work on hog-slop. You understand me,
Belly-Robber?"
Bailey, his hands fisted at his sides, nodded. "Yes, sir. But I really
don't know what I can do to please you."
"You are a spacer and a Ship's Cook, not a suburban
Hausfrau
with the
vapors," Winkelmann said. "I do not expect from you hysterics, tantrums
or weeping. Only—can you understand this, so simple?—food that will
keep my belly content and my brain alive."
"Yes, sir," Bailey said, his face a picture of that offense the British
term Dumb Insolence.
Winkelmann got up and climbed the ladder to the pilot-cubicle. I
followed him. "Captain," I said, "you're driving Bailey too hard.
You're asking him to make bricks without straw."
Winkelmann regarded me with his pale-blue stare. "You think, Doctor,
that my cruelty to the Belly-Robber is the biliousness of a middle-aged
man?"
"Frankly, I can't understand your attitude at all," I said.
"You accuse me of driving a man to make bricks without straw,"
Winkelmann said. "Very well, Doctor. It is my belief that if the
Pharaoh's taskmaster had had my firmness of purpose, the Children of
Israel would have made bricks with stubble. Necessity, Doctor, is the
mother of invention. I am Bailey's necessity. My unkindnesses make him
uncomfortable, I doubt that not. But I am forcing him to experiment,
to improvise, to widen the horizons of his ingenuity. He will learn
somehow to bring good food from Chlorella tanks."
"You're driving him too hard, Sir," I said. "He'll crack."
"Bailey will have some fifty thousand dollars' salary waiting when we
ground at Brady Station," Captain Winkelmann said. "So much money buys
many discomforts. That will be all, Doctor Vilanova."
"Crew morale on the ship...." I began.
"That will be all, Doctor Vilanova," Captain Winkelmann repeated.
Bailey grew more silent as we threaded our way along the elliptical
path to Mars. Each meal he prepared was a fresh attempt to propitiate
the appetite of our splenetic Captain. Each such offering was condemned
by that heartless man. Bailey began to try avoiding the Captain at
mealtimes, but was frustrated by Winkelmann's orders. "Convey my
compliments to the Chef, please," the Captain would instruct one of
the crew, "and ask him to step down here a moment." And the Cook would
cheerlessly appear in the dining-cubby, to have his culinary genius
acidly called in question again.
I myself do not doubt that Bailey was the finest Cook ever to go
into Hohmann orbit. His every meal established a higher benchmark in
brilliant galleymanship. We were served, for instance, an
ersatz
hot
turkey supreme. The cheese-sauce was almost believable, the Chlorella
turkey-flesh was white and tender. Bailey served with this delicacy
a grainy and delicious "cornbread," and had extracted from his algae
a lipid butter-substitute that soaked into the hot "bread" with a
genuinely dairy smell. "Splendid, Bailey," I said.
"We are not amused," said Captain Winkelmann, accepting a second
helping of the pseudo-turkey. "You are improving, Belly-Robber, but
only arithmetically. Your first efforts were so hideous as to require
a geometric progression of improving excellence to raise them to mere
edibility. By the time we are halfway 'round the Sun, I trust you will
have learned to cook with the competence of a freshman Home Economics
student. That will be all, Bailey."
The crew and my fellow-officers were amused by Winkelmann's riding of
Bailey; they were in addition gratified that the battle between their
Captain and their Cook served to feed them so well. Most spacers embark
on an outward voyage somewhat plump, having eaten enough on their last
few days aground to smuggle several hundred calories of fat and many
memories of good food aboard with them. This trip, none of the men had
lost weight during the first four months in space. Winkelmann, indeed,
seemed to have gained. His uniform was taut over his plump backside,
and he puffed a bit up the ladders. I was considering suggesting to our
Captain that he curtail his diet for reasons of health, a bit of advice
that would have stood unique in the annals of space medicine, when
Winkelmann produced his supreme insult to our Cook.
Each man aboard a spacer is allowed ten kilograms of personal effects
besides his uniforms, these being considered Ship's Furnishing. As
his rank and responsibility merit, the Captain is allowed double this
ration. He may thus bring aboard with him some forty-five pounds of
books, playing-cards, knitting-wool, whiskey or what have you to help
him while away the hours between the planets. Bailey, I knew for a
fact, had used up his weight-allowance in bringing aboard a case of
spices: marjoram and mint, costmary, file powder, basil and allspice,
and a dozen others.
Captain Winkelmann was not a reader, and had brought no books. Cards
interested him not at all, as card-playing implies a sociability alien
to his nature. He never drank aboard ship. I had supposed that he'd
exercised his option of returning his personal-effects weight allowance
to the owners for the consideration of one hundred dollars a kilogram.
To collect the maximum allowance, spacers have been known to come
aboard their ship mother-naked.
But this was not the case with Winkelmann. His personal-effects
baggage, an unlabeled cardboard box, appeared under the table at noon
mess some hundred days out from Piano West. Winkelmann rested his feet
on the mysterious box as he sat to eat.
"What disgusting form does the ship's garbage appear in today,
Belly-Robber?" he asked the Cook.
Bailey frowned, but kept his temper, an asceticism in which by now he'd
had much practice. "I've been working on the problem of steak, Sir,"
he said. "I think I've whipped the taste; what was left was to get the
texture steak-like. Do you understand, Sir?"
"I understand," Winkelmann growled. "You intend that your latest mess
should feel like steak to the mouth, and not like baby-food. Right?"
"Yes, Sir," Bailey said. "Well, I squeezed the
steak-substrate—Chlorella, of course, with all sorts of special
seasonings—through a sieve, and blanched the strands in hot algaeal
oil. Then I chopped those strands to bits and rolled them out.
Voila!
I had something very close in texture to the muscle-fibers of genuine
meat."
"Remarkable, Bailey," I said.
"It rather throws me off my appetite to hear how you muddle about with
our food," the Captain said, his jowls settling into an expression of
distaste. "It's quite all right to eat lobster, for example, but I
never cared to see the ugly beast boiled before my eyes. Detail spoils
the meal."
Bailey lifted the cover off the electric warming-pan at the center of
the table and tenderly lifted a small "steak" onto each of our plates.
"Try it," he urged the Captain.
Captain Winkelmann sliced off a corner of his algaeal steak. The
color was an excellent medium-rare, the odor was the rich smell
of fresh-broiled beef. Winkelmann bit down, chewed, swallowed. "Not
too bad, Belly-Robber," he said, nodding. Bailey grinned and bobbed
his head, his hands folded before him in an ecstasy of pleasure. A
kind word from the Captain bettered the ruffles-and-flourishes of a
more reasonable man. "But it still needs something ... something,"
Winkelmann went on, slicing off another portion of the tasty Chlorella.
"Aha! I have it!"
"Yes, Sir?" Bailey asked.
"This, Belly-Robber!" Winkelmann reached beneath the mess-table and
ripped open his cardboard carton. He brought out a bottle and unscrewed
the cap. "Ketchup," he said, splattering the red juice over Bailey's
masterpiece. "The scarlet burial-shroud for the failures of Cooks."
Lifting a hunk of the "steak," streaming ketchup, to his mouth,
Winkelmann chewed. "Just the thing," he smiled.
"Damn you!" Bailey shouted.
Winkelmann's smile flicked off, and his blue eyes pierced the Cook.
"... Sir," Bailey added.
"That's better," Winkelmann said, and took another bite. He said
meditatively, "Used with caution, and only by myself, I believe I have
sufficient ketchup here to see me through to Mars. Please keep a
bottle on the table for all my future meals, Belly-Robber."
"But, Sir...." Bailey began.
"You must realize, Belly-Robber, that a dyspeptic Captain is a threat
to the welfare of his ship. Were I to continue eating your surrealistic
slops for another hundred days, without the small consolation of
this sauce I had the foresight to bring with me, I'd likely be in
no condition to jet us safely down to the Piano West pad. Do you
understand, Belly-Robber?" he demanded.
"I understand that you're an ungrateful, impossible, square-headed,
slave-driving...."
"Watch your noun," Winkelmann cautioned the Cook. "Your adjectives are
insubordinate; your noun might prove mutinous."
"Captain, you've gone too far," I said. Bailey, his fists knotted, was
scarlet, his chest heaving with emotion.
"Doctor, I must point out to you that it ill behooves the Ship's
Surgeon to side with the Cook against the Captain," Winkelmann said.
"Sir, Bailey has tried hard to please you," I said. "The other officers
and the men have been more than satisfied with his work."
"That only suggests atrophy of their taste buds," Winkelmann said.
"Doctor, you are excused. As are you, Belly-Robber," he added.
Bailey and I climbed from the mess compartment together. I steered him
to my quarters, where the medical supplies were stored. He sat on my
bunk and exploded into weeping, banging his fists against the metal
bulkhead. "You'll have that drink now," I said.
"No, dammit!" he shouted.
"Orders," I said. I poured us each some fifty cc's of rye. "This is
therapy, Bailey," I told him. He poured the fiery stuff down his throat
like water and silently held out his glass for a second. I provided it.
After a few minutes Bailey's sobbing ceased. "Sorry, Doc," he said.
"You've taken more pressure than most men would," I said. "Nothing to
be ashamed of."
"He's crazy. What sane man would expect me to dip Wiener schnitzel
and sauerkraut and
Backhahndl nach suddeutscher Art
out of an algae
tank? I've got nothing but microscopic weeds to cook for him! Worn-out
molecules reclaimed from the head; packaged amino acid additives. And
he expects meals that would take the blue ribbon at the annual banquet
of the Friends of Escoffier!"
"Yours is an ancient plaint, Bailey," I said. "You've worked your
fingers to the bone, slaving over a hot stove, and you're not
appreciated. But you're not married to Winkelmann, remember. A year
from now you'll be home in Ohio, fifty grand richer, set to start that
restaurant of yours and forget about our fat Flying Dutchman."
"I hate him," Bailey said with the simplicity of true emotion. He
reached for the bottle. I let him have it. Sometimes alcohol can be
an apt confederate of
vis medicatrix naturae
, the healing power of
nature. Half an hour later I strapped Bailey into his bunk to sleep it
off. That therapeutic drunk seemed to be just what he'd needed.
For morning mess the next day we had a broth remarkable in
horribleness, a pottage or boiled
Chlorella vulgaris
that looked
and tasted like the vomit of some bottom-feeding sea-beast. Bailey,
red-eyed and a-tremble, made no apology, and stared at Winkelmann as
though daring him to comment. The Captain lifted a spoonful of the
disgusting stuff to his lips, smacked and said, "Belly-Robber, you're
improving a little at last."
Bailey nodded and smiled. "Thank you, Sir," he said.
I smiled, too. Bailey had conquered himself. His psychic defenses were
now strong enough to withstand the Captain's fiercest assaults of
irony. Our food would likely be bad the rest of this trip, but that was
a price I was willing to pay for seeing destroyed the Willy Winkelmann
theory of forcing a Cook to make bricks without straw. The Captain
had pushed too hard. He'd need that ketchup for the meals to come, I
thought.
Noon mess was nearly as awful as breakfast had been. The coffee tasted
of salt, and went largely undrunk. The men in the mess compartment were
vehement in their protests, blaming the Captain, in his absence, for
the decline in culinary standards. Bailey seemed not to care. He served
the algaeburgers with half a mind, and hurried back into his galley
oblivious of the taunts of his crewmates.
There being only three seats in the
Sale's
mess compartment, we ate
our meals in three shifts. That evening, going down the ladder to
supper, my nose was met with a spine-tingling barbecue tang, a smell
to make a man think of gray charcoal glowing in a picnic brazier,
of cicadas chirping and green grass underfoot, of the pop and hiss
of canned beer being church-keyed. "He's done it, Doc!" one of the
first-shift diners said. "It actually tastes of food!"
"Then he's beat the Captain at his game," I said.
"The Dutchman won't want to mess ketchup on these steaks," the crewman
said.
I sat, unfolded my napkin, and looked with hope to the electric
warming-pan at the center of the table. Bailey served the three of
us with the small "steaks." Each contained about a pound of dried
Chlorella, I judged, teasing mine with my fork. But they were drenched
in a gravy rich as the stuff grandma used to make in her black iron
skillet, peppery and seasoned with courageous bits of garlic. I cut
a bit from my steak and chewed it. Too tender, of course; there are
limits to art. But the pond-scum taste was gone. Bailey appeared in the
galley door. I gestured for him to join me. "You've done it, Bailey,"
I said. "Every Slimehead in orbit will thank you for this. This is
actually
good
."
"Thanks, Doc," Bailey said.
I smiled and took another bite. "You may not realize it, Bailey; but
this is a victory for the Captain, too. He drove you to this triumph;
you couldn't have done it without him."
"You mean he was just whipping me on, trying to make me do better?"
Bailey asked.
"He was driving you to do the impossible," I said; "and you did it. Our
Captain may be a hard man, Bailey; but he did know how to coax maximum
performance out of his Ship's Cook."
Bailey stood up. "Do you like Captain Winkelmann, Doctor?" he asked.
I thought about his question a moment. Winkelmann was good at his job.
He persuaded his men by foul means, true; but it was all for the good
of the ship and his crew. "Do I like Captain Winkelmann?" I asked,
spearing another piece of my artificial steak. "Bailey, I'm afraid I'll
have to admit that I do."
Bailey smiled and lifted a second steak from the warming-pan onto my
plate. "Then have another piece," he said.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/5/1/5/9/51597//51597-h//51597-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these best describes Bailey's personality? | 51597_3MTDEMTK_10 | [
"He is timid and unable to stand up for himself with the captain",
"He is a reasonable person with a lot of skill who does not appreciate being pushed",
"He is determined and dedicated, wanting to show the captain what he can do",
"He appreciates the external motivation from the crew to always improve his cooking"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0028",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the significance of the story's title? | 60995_57L7VNGG_1 | [
"It hints at the extra costs for less natural things",
"It marks the setting for the story",
"It hints at Linton's constant desire for sweet things",
"It shows Linton's goal for the story"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is the best description of the relationship between Linton and Howell? | 60995_57L7VNGG_2 | [
"They are business partners trying to find a way to bring back someone they knew",
"Howell is trying to be supportive but is exhausted by Linton's insistence",
"They are new friends figuring out their rapport, so Howell wants to help however he can",
"Howell is only meeting with Linton out of a feeling of obligation and doesn't care for him much"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the significance of Rogers Snead? | 60995_57L7VNGG_3 | [
"His sighting gives LInton an idea of how to see his wife",
"He serves as proof that Linton is seeing things, and needs professional help",
"Snead is a reminder of a previous stage of Linton's life",
"Linton knows that Snead could take him where he needs to go"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What likely happens to Linton at the end of the story? | 60995_57L7VNGG_4 | [
"He and his wife live happily, both as cybernetic creatures",
"He repeats a cycle of having his money taken from him from doctors",
"He goes to rehab and then moves on with his life",
"He will never leave the asylym because he needs too much help"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is the best description of Linton? | 60995_57L7VNGG_5 | [
"He is a heartbroken man wanting to find new goals for his life",
"He is trying to recover from his past in the Mafia and wants to find legal ways to accomplish his goals",
"He is a gullible person determined to follow his instinct",
"He is a risk-taker who prefers to experience the more illegal things society has to offer"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these best describes the doctor that Linton meets at the end? | 60995_57L7VNGG_6 | [
"Generous in that he is willing to help Linton with this problem that involves illegal work on his part",
"Greedy in that he manipulates vulnerable people to take money from them",
"Love-stricken, wanting to help people in similar situations",
"Cunning in his cutting-edge technology he is developing"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which best describes the role of the Mafia in this story? | 60995_57L7VNGG_7 | [
"Their involvement shows public perception on the procedure that Linton pays for",
"They are the ones responsible for the technology that Linton pays for",
"They were Linton's previous employers and the source of the money he uses to pay for the operation",
"They show how violence-stricken the society is"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does this society view resurrection? | 60995_57L7VNGG_8 | [
"There are many people who pretend to do it but nobody who does",
"There is a big push to make it legal",
"It is looked down upon so nobody does it",
"It only happens for those with questionable morals and a lot of money"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
60,995 | 60995_57L7VNGG | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | February Strawberries | 1972.0 | Harmon, Jim | Resurrection -- Fiction; Psychological fiction; Short stories; Husband and wife -- Fiction; Science fiction; PS | FEBRUARY STRAWBERRIES
By JIM HARMON
How much is the impossible worth?
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, March 1961.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Linton lay down his steel fork beside the massively solid transparency
of the restaurant water glass.
"Isn't that Rogers Snead at that table?" he heard himself say stupidly.
Howell, the man across the table from him, looked embarrassed without
looking. "Not at all. Somebody who looks like him. Twin brother. You
know how it is. Snead's dead, don't you remember?"
Linton remembered. Howell had to know that he would remember. What
were they trying to pull on him? "The man who isn't Snead is leaving,"
Linton said, describing the scene over Howell's shoulder. "If that's
Snead's brother, I might catch him to pay my respects."
"No," Howell said, "I wouldn't do that."
"Snead came to Greta's funeral. It's the least I could do."
"I wouldn't. Probably no relation to Snead at all. Somebody who looks
like him."
"He's practically running," Linton said. "He almost ran out of the
restaurant."
"Who? Oh, the man who looked like Snead, you mean."
"Yes," Linton said.
A thick-bodied man at the next table leaned his groaning chair back
intimately against Linton's own chair.
"That fellow who just left looked like a friend of yours, huh?" the
thick man said.
"Couldn't have been him, though," Linton answered automatically. "My
friend's dead."
The thick man rocked forward and came down on all six feet. He threw
paper money on the table as if he were disgusted with it. He plodded
out of the place quickly.
Howell breathed in deeply and sucked back Linton's attention. "Now
you've probably got old Snead into trouble."
"Snead's dead," Linton said.
"Oh, well, 'dead,'" Howell replied.
"What do you say it like that for?" Linton demanded angrily. "The
man's dead. Plain dead. He's not Sherlock Holmes or the Frankenstein
Monster—there's no doubt or semantic leeway to the thing."
"You know how it is," Howell said.
Linton had thought he had known how death was. He had buried his wife,
or rather he had watched the two workmen scoop and shove dirt in on
the sawdust-fresh pine box that held the coffin. He had known what he
sincerely felt to be a genuine affection for Greta. Even after they had
let him out of the asylum as cured, he still secretly believed he had
known a genuine affection for her. But it didn't seem he knew about
death at all.
Linton felt that his silence was asking Howell by this time.
"I don't know, mind you," Howell said, puffing out tobacco smoke, "but
I suppose he might have been resurrected."
"Who by?" Linton asked, thinking:
God?
"The Mafia, I guess. Who knows who runs it?"
"You mean, somebody has invented a way to bring dead people back to
life?" Linton said.
He knew, of course, that Howell did not mean that. Howell meant that
some people had a system of making it appear that a person had died
in order to gain some illegal advantage. But by saying something so
patently ridiculous, Linton hoped to bring the contradicting truth to
the surface immediately.
"An invention? I guess that's how it is," Howell agreed. "I don't know
much about people like that. I'm an honest businessman."
"But it's wonderful," Linton said, thinking his immediate thoughts.
"Wonderful! Why should a thing like that be illegal? Why don't I know
about it?"
"Sh-h," Howell said uneasily. "This is a public place."
"I don't understand," Linton said helplessly.
"Look, Frank, you can't legalize a thing like resurrection," Howell
said with feigned patience. "There are strong religious convictions to
consider. The undertakers have a lobby. I've heard they got spies right
in the White House, ready to assassinate if they have to. Death is
their whole life. You got to realize that."
"That's not enough. Not nearly enough."
"Think of all the problems it would cause. Insurance, for one thing.
Overpopulation. Birth control is a touchy subject. They'd have to take
it up if everybody got resurrected when they died, wouldn't they?"
"But what do they do about it? Against it?"
"There are a lot of fakes and quacks in the resurrection business. When
the cops find out about a place, they break in, smash all the equipment
and arrest everybody in sight. That's about all they can do. The
charges, if any, come under general vice classification."
"I don't understand," Linton complained. "Why haven't I heard about it?"
"They didn't talk much about white slavery in Victorian England. I read
an article in
Time
the other day that said 'death' was our dirty
word, not sex. You want to shock somebody, you tell him, 'You're going
to be dead someday,' not anything sexual. You know how it is. The
opposite of 'live' these days is 'video-taped.'"
"I see," Linton said.
He tried to assimilate it. Of course he had, he reminded himself, been
out of touch for some time. It might be true. Then again, they might be
trying to trick him. They used to do that to see if he was really well.
But the temptation was too strong.
"Tell me, Howell, where could I find a resurrectionist?"
Howell looked away. "Frank, I don't have anything to do with that kind
of people and if you're smart, you'll not either."
Linton's fingers imprinted the linen. "Damn you, Howell, you tell me!"
Howell climbed to his feet hurriedly. "I take you out to dinner to
console you over the loss of your wife a half a year ago, and to make
you feel welcome back to the society of your fellows after being in the
hospital for a nervous breakdown. I do all that, and for thanks, you
yell at me and curse me. You kooks are all alike!"
Howell threw money on the table with the same kind of disinterest as
the thick-set man and stalked out.
I've got to hurry too, Linton thought. It's Resurrection Day!
The doctor fluttered his hands and chirped about the office. "Well,
well, Mr. Linton, we understand you've been causing disturbances."
"Not really," Linton said modestly.
"Come, come," the doctor chided. "You started riots in two places,
attempted to bribe an officer. That's disturbing, Mr. Linton, very
disturbing."
"I was only trying to find out something," Linton maintained. "They
could have told me. Everybody seems to know but me."
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Let's not think any such thing. People
don't know more than you do."
Linton rubbed his shoulder. "That cop knew more about Judo holds than I
did."
"A few specific people know a few specific things you don't. But let me
ask you, Mr. Linton, could Einstein bake a pie?"
"I don't know. Who the hell ever wasted Einstein's time asking him a
thing like that?"
"People who want to know the answers to questions have to ask them. You
can find out anything by asking the right questions of the right person
at the right time."
Linton stared suspiciously. "Do you know where I can find a
resurrectionist?"
"I am a resurrectionist."
"But the policeman brought me to you!"
"Well, that's what you paid him to do, wasn't it? Did you think a
policeman would just steal your money? Cynics—all you young people are
cynics."
Linton scooted forward on the insultingly cold metal chair and really
looked at the doctor for the first time.
"Doctor, can you
really
resurrect the dead?"
"Will you stop being cynical? Of course I can!"
"Doctor, I'm beginning to believe in you," Linton said, "but tell me,
can you resurrect the
long
dead?"
"Size has nothing to do with it."
"No, my wife has been dead a long time. Months."
"Months?" The doctor snapped those weeks away with his fingers. "It
could be years. Centuries. It's all mathematics, my boy. I need only
one fragment of the body and my computers can compute what the rest
of it was like and recreate it. It's infallible. Naturally there is a
degree of risk involved."
"Infallible risk, yes," Linton murmured. "Could you go to work right
away?"
"First, I must follow an ancient medical practice. I must bleed you."
Linton grasped the situation immediately. "You mean you want money. You
realize I've just got out of an institution...."
"I've often been in institutions myself, for alcoholism, narcotics
addiction and more."
"What a wonderful professional career," Linton said, when he couldn't
care less.
"Oh, yes—yes, indeed. But I didn't come out broke."
"Neither did I," Linton said hastily. "I invested in shifty stocks,
faltering bonds, and while I was away they sank to rock bottom."
"Then—"
"When they hit rock bottom, they bounced up. If I hadn't found you, I
would have been secure for the rest of my lonely, miserable life."
"All that's ended now," the doctor assured him. "Now we must go dig up
the corpse. The female corpse, eh?"
Resurrection Day!
"Doctor," Linton whispered, "my mind is singing with battalions of
choirs. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent to you."
The doctor stroked his oily palms together. "Oh, but it does.
Beautifully."
The certificate to allow reburial in Virginia hadn't been impossible
to obtain. The doctor had taken the body and Linton's fortune and fed
them both into the maw of his calculators, and by means of the secret,
smuggled formulae, Greta would be cybernetically reborn.
Linton shook his head. It seemed impossible. But Greta opened the
olive-drab slab of metal of the door to the doctor's inner-inner
sanctum and walked out into the medicinal cold fluorescent lighting.
It wasn't fair at all, Linton thought. He should have had some time to
prepare himself.
Greta lifted her arms, stretching the white smock over the lines of her
body. "Darling!" she said.
"Greta!" he said, feeling a slight revulsion but repressing it. No
doubt he would be able to adjust to her once having been dead the same
way he had learned to accept the, to him, distasteful duty of kissing
her ears the way she enjoyed.
Greta swirled across the room and folded her arms across his shoulders.
She kissed his cheek. "It's so wonderful to be back. This calls for a
celebration. We must see Nancy, Oscar, Johnny, all our old friends."
"Yes," he said, his heart lurching for her sad ignorance. "But tell
me—how was it being
away
?"
The curves and angles of her flesh changed their positions against his
Ivy dacron. Her attitude altered.
"I can't remember," she said. "I can't really remember anything. Not
really. My memories are ghosts...."
"Now, now," Linton said, "we mustn't get excited. You've been through a
trial."
She accepted the verdict. She pulled away and touched at her hair. It
was the same hair, black as evil, contrasting with her inner purity. Of
course it would be; it hadn't changed even in the grave. He remembered
the snaky tendrils of it growing out of the water-logged casket.
"I must see all our old friends," Greta persisted. "Helen and
Johnny...."
"My darling," he said gently, "about Johnny—"
Her fine black brows made Gothic arches. "Yes? What about Johnny?"
"It was a terrible accident right after—that is, about five months
ago. He was killed."
"Killed?" Greta repeated blankly. "Johnny Gorman was killed?"
"Traffic accident. Killed instantly."
"But Johnny was your friend, your best friend. Why didn't you have him
resurrected the same way you did me?"
"Darling, resurrection is a risky business and an expensive one. You
have to pay premium prices for strawberries in February. I no longer
have the money to pay for a resurrection of Johnny."
Greta turned her back to him. "It's just as well. You shouldn't bring
back Johnny to this dream of life, give him a ghost of mind and the
photograph of a soul. It's monstrous. No one should do that. No one.
But you're
sure
you haven't the money to do it?"
"No," Linton said. "I'm sold out. I've borrowed on my insurance to the
hilt. It won't pay any more until I'm buried, and then, of course, you
can resurrect me."
"Of course," Greta said. She sighed. "Poor Johnny. He was such a good
friend of yours. You must miss him. I'm so sorry for you."
"I have you," he said with great simplicity.
"Frank," she said, "you should see that place in there. There are
foaming acid baths, great whale-toothed disposals, barrels of chemicals
to quench death and smother decay. It's
perfect
."
"It sounds carnal," he said uneasily.
"No, dear, it's perfect for some things that have to be done."
Her eyes flashed around the doctor's office and settled somewhere, on
something.
Linton followed the direction of Greta's gaze and found only an ashtray
stand, looking vaguely like a fanatic's idol to a heathen religion on a
pedestal.
Greta pounced on the stand, hefted it at the base and ran toward him
with it over her head.
Linton leaped aside and Greta hit the edge of the desk instead of him.
Brain damage, he concluded nervously. Cell deterioration.
Greta raised it again and he caught her wrists high over her head. She
writhed against him provocatively. "Frank, I'm sorry, dear, but I have
to have that insurance money. It's hell!"
Linton understood immediately. He felt foolish, humiliated. All that
money! He had resurrected a gold ring that had turned his knuckles
green. No one must ever know.
Linton twisted the stand away from his wife and watched her face
in some appalled form of satisfaction as it registered horror and
acceptance of the crumpled metal disk falling toward it.
He split her head open and watched her float to the floor.
Linton was surprised at the fine wire mesh just below the skin and
those shiny little tabs that looked like pictures of transistors in
institutional advertising.
He knelt beside the body and poked into the bleeding, smoldering
wreckage.
Yes, it seemed they had to automate and modify the bodies somewhat
in resurrection. They couldn't chemically revive the old corpse like
pouring water on a wilted geranium.
Or—
Did they use the old bodies at all? What were all those acid baths for
if the bodies were used? Didn't the resurrectionists just destroy the
old corpses and make androids, synthetic creatures, to take their place?
But it didn't matter. Not a bit.
She had thought she was his wife, sharing her viewpoint down to the
finest detail, and he had thought she was his wife.
It was what you thought was real that made it so, not the other way
around.
"I've killed my wife!" Linton called, rising from his knees, stretching
his hands out to something.
The pain stung him to sleep—a pain in his neck like a needle that left
a hole big enough for a camel to pass through and big enough for him to
follow the camel in his turn.
He opened his eyes to the doctor's spotless, well-ordered office. The
doctor looked down at him consolingly. "You'll have to go back, Mr.
Linton. But they'll cure you. You'll be cured of ever thinking your
wife was brought back to life and that you killed her all over again."
"Do you
really
think so, Doctor?" Linton asked hopefully.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/9/9/60995//60995-h//60995-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is not a likely consequence of the end of the story? | 60995_57L7VNGG_9 | [
"Howell will be hesitant to help Linton again",
"The doctor continues taking advantage of people",
"Linton goes through treatment, eventually repeating the same events",
"Greta finds her own way to establish herself and find the money she wants"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0038",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why did Val and Ron really decide to go to Mars? | 25627_L0AQPROP_1 | [
"They were curious and wanted to help their planet",
"They did not want to spend anymore time on earth",
"They wanted a more creative way to make money",
"Out of obligation to find a job to sustain themselves"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How did Ledman get to Mars? | 25627_L0AQPROP_2 | [
"He saved his money to send himself",
"He joined the Corps just as Val and Ron did",
"He was part of a uranium company who funded his trip",
"He posed as a tourist and stayed behind on a vacation"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these do Ron and Ledman have in common? | 25627_L0AQPROP_3 | [
"They have both been wrong by the companies that they worked for",
"They both want to find an alternative to uranium",
"There were both injured in the same accident",
"They are both obsessed with finding uranium"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What would have happened if Ledman had stayed on Earth? | 25627_L0AQPROP_4 | [
"He would've managed to maintain leadership of his company",
"He might not have needed a wheelchair long-term",
"He would have joined the Project Sea-Dredge mission",
"He would've become more depressed and never found revenge"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What likely happens to Ledman after the story ends? | 25627_L0AQPROP_5 | [
"He is given new legs and can start a new life",
"He will rejoin the search for uranium",
"Even with his wheelchair he must receive mental health treatment",
"He will undergo physical and mental health care before starting over"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What likely happens to Val and Ron after the story ends? | 25627_L0AQPROP_6 | [
"They stay on Mars for their contract and then move on to a different project",
"They go back to earth to make sure Ledman gets the care he needs",
"They decide to stay on Mars forever",
"They stay on Mars for a few more weeks before heading back to Earth"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these was not a consequence of the Great Atomic Wars? | 25627_L0AQPROP_7 | [
"Limited resources ran out over time",
"Multiple planets were settled by various countries in a display of power",
"All major types of power sources changed",
"Earth decided to run supply missions to Mars"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why is the Geig Corps important? | 25627_L0AQPROP_8 | [
"Val and Ron worked for them before signing up with UranCo",
"It is UranCo's method of acquiring manpower for the resource search",
"It is how Ledman got involved in the uranium project in the first place",
"They funded the dome that Ledman lives in"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What kind of person is Ron? | 25627_L0AQPROP_9 | [
"A curious and determined man who does his best",
"An impulsive man who does not pay attention to others' needs",
"A doting husband who follows his wife to Mars",
"An adventuresome soul but still a timid one"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
25,627 | 25627_L0AQPROP | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Hunted Heroes | 1975.0 | Silverberg, Robert | PS; Science fiction, American; Short stories, American | THE
HUNTED
HEROES
By ROBERT SILVERBERG
The planet itself was tough enough—barren, desolate,
forbidding; enough to stop the most adventurous and
dedicated. But they had to run head-on against a mad
genius who had a motto:
Death to all Terrans!
"Let's
keep moving," I told
Val. "The surest way to
die out here on Mars is to
give up." I reached over and
turned up the pressure on her
oxymask to make things a
little easier for her. Through
the glassite of the mask, I
could see her face contorted
in an agony of fatigue.
And she probably thought
the failure of the sandcat was
all my fault, too. Val's usually
about the best wife a guy
could ask for, but when she
wants to be she can be a real
flying bother.
It was beyond her to see
that some grease monkey back
at the Dome was at fault—whoever
it was who had failed
to fasten down the engine
hood. Nothing but what had
stopped us
could
stop a sandcat:
sand in the delicate
mechanism of the atomic engine.
But no; she blamed it all on
me somehow: So we were out
walking on the spongy sand
of the Martian desert. We'd
been walking a good eight
hours.
"Can't we turn back now,
Ron?" Val pleaded. "Maybe
there isn't any uranium in
this sector at all. I think
we're crazy to keep on searching
out here!"
I started to tell her that the
UranCo chief had assured me
we'd hit something out this
way, but changed my mind.
When Val's tired and overwrought
there's no sense in
arguing with her.
I stared ahead at the bleak,
desolate wastes of the Martian
landscape. Behind us
somewhere was the comfort
of the Dome, ahead nothing
but the mazes and gullies of
this dead world.
He was a cripple in a wheelchair—helpless as a rattlesnake.
"Try to keep going, Val."
My gloved hand reached out
and clumsily enfolded hers.
"Come on, kid. Remember—we're
doing this for Earth.
We're heroes."
She glared at me. "Heroes,
hell!" she muttered. "That's
the way it looked back home,
but, out there it doesn't seem
so glorious. And UranCo's
pay is stinking."
"We didn't come out here
for the pay, Val."
"I know, I know, but just
the same—"
It must have been hell for
her. We had wandered fruitlessly
over the red sands all
day, both of us listening for
the clicks of the counter. And
the geigers had been obstinately
hushed all day, except
for their constant undercurrent
of meaningless noises.
Even though the Martian
gravity was only a fraction of
Earth's, I was starting to
tire, and I knew it must have
been really rough on Val with
her lovely but unrugged legs.
"Heroes," she said bitterly.
"We're not heroes—we're
suckers! Why did I ever let
you volunteer for the Geig
Corps and drag me along?"
Which wasn't anywhere
close to the truth. Now I
knew she was at the breaking
point, because Val didn't lie
unless she was so exhausted
she didn't know what she was
doing. She had been just as
much inflamed by the idea of
coming to Mars to help in the
search for uranium as I was.
We knew the pay was poor,
but we had felt it a sort of
obligation, something we
could do as individuals to
keep the industries of radioactives-starved
Earth going.
And we'd always had a roving
foot, both of us.
No, we had decided together
to come to Mars—the
way we decided together on
everything. Now she was
turning against me.
I tried to jolly her. "Buck
up, kid," I said. I didn't dare
turn up her oxy pressure any
higher, but it was obvious she
couldn't keep going. She was
almost sleep-walking now.
We pressed on over the
barren terrain. The geiger
kept up a fairly steady click-pattern,
but never broke into
that sudden explosive tumult
that meant we had found pay-dirt.
I started to feel tired
myself, terribly tired. I longed
to lie down on the soft,
spongy Martian sand and
bury myself.
I looked at Val. She was
dragging along with her eyes
half-shut. I felt almost guilty
for having dragged her out to
Mars, until I recalled that I
hadn't. In fact, she had come
up with the idea before I did.
I wished there was some way
of turning the weary, bedraggled
girl at my side back into
the Val who had so enthusiastically
suggested we join
the Geigs.
Twelve steps later, I decided
this was about as far as
we could go.
I stopped, slipped out of
the geiger harness, and lowered
myself ponderously to
the ground. "What'samatter,
Ron?" Val asked sleepily.
"Something wrong?"
"No, baby," I said, putting
out a hand and taking hers.
"I think we ought to rest a
little before we go any further.
It's been a long, hard
day."
It didn't take much to persuade
her. She slid down beside
me, curled up, and in a
moment she was fast asleep,
sprawled out on the sands.
Poor kid
, I thought. Maybe
we shouldn't have come to
Mars after all. But, I reminded
myself,
someone
had to do
the job.
A second thought appeared,
but I squelched it:
Why the hell me?
I looked down at Valerie's
sleeping form, and thought of
our warm, comfortable little
home on Earth. It wasn't
much, but people in love don't
need very fancy surroundings.
I watched her, sleeping
peacefully, a wayward lock of
her soft blonde hair trailing
down over one eyebrow, and
it seemed hard to believe that
we'd exchanged Earth and all
it held for us for the raw, untamed
struggle that was Mars.
But I knew I'd do it again, if
I had the chance. It's because
we wanted to keep what we
had. Heroes? Hell, no. We
just liked our comforts, and
wanted to keep them. Which
took a little work.
Time to get moving.
But
then Val stirred and rolled
over in her sleep, and I didn't
have the heart to wake her. I
sat there, holding her, staring
out over the desert, watching
the wind whip the sand up
into weird shapes.
The Geig Corps preferred
married couples, working in
teams. That's what had finally
decided it for us—we were a
good team. We had no ties on
Earth that couldn't be broken
without much difficulty. So
we volunteered.
And here we are.
Heroes.
The wind blasted a mass of
sand into my face, and I felt
it tinkle against the oxymask.
I glanced at the suit-chronometer.
Getting late. I decided
once again to wake Val.
But she was tired. And I was
tired too, tired from our
wearying journey across the
empty desert.
I started to shake Val. But
I never finished. It would be
so
nice just to lean back and
nuzzle up to her, down in the
sand. So nice. I yawned, and
stretched back.
I awoke with a sudden startled
shiver, and realized angrily
I had let myself doze off.
"Come on, Val," I said savagely,
and started to rise to
my feet.
I couldn't.
I looked down. I was neatly
bound in thin, tough, plastic
tangle-cord, swathed from
chin to boot-bottoms, my
arms imprisoned, my feet
caught. And tangle-cord is
about as easy to get out of as
a spider's web is for a trapped
fly.
It wasn't Martians that
had done it. There weren't
any Martians, hadn't been for
a million years. It was some
Earthman who had bound us.
I rolled my eyes toward
Val, and saw that she was
similarly trussed in the sticky
stuff. The tangle-cord was still
fresh, giving off a faint, repugnant
odor like that of drying
fish. It had been spun on
us only a short time ago, I
realized.
"Ron—"
"Don't try to move, baby.
This stuff can break your
neck if you twist it wrong."
She continued for a moment
to struggle futilely, and I had
to snap, "Lie still, Val!"
"A very wise statement,"
said a brittle, harsh voice
from above me. I looked up
and saw a helmeted figure
above us. He wasn't wearing
the customary skin-tight pliable
oxysuits we had. He
wore an outmoded, bulky
spacesuit and a fishbowl helmet,
all but the face area
opaque. The oxygen cannisters
weren't attached to his
back as expected, though.
They were strapped to the
back of the wheelchair in
which he sat.
Through the fishbowl I
could see hard little eyes, a
yellowed, parchment-like face,
a grim-set jaw. I didn't recognize
him, and this struck me
odd. I thought I knew everyone
on sparsely-settled Mars.
Somehow I'd missed him.
What shocked me most was
that he had no legs. The
spacesuit ended neatly at the
thighs.
He was holding in his left
hand the tanglegun with
which he had entrapped us,
and a very efficient-looking
blaster was in his right.
"I didn't want to disturb
your sleep," he said coldly.
"So I've been waiting here
for you to wake up."
I could just see it. He might
have been sitting there for
hours, complacently waiting
to see how we'd wake up.
That was when I realized he
must be totally insane. I could
feel my stomach-muscles
tighten, my throat constrict
painfully.
Then anger ripped through
me, washing away the terror.
"What's going on?" I demanded,
staring at the half
of a man who confronted us
from the wheelchair. "Who
are you?"
"You'll find out soon
enough," he said. "Suppose
now you come with me." He
reached for the tanglegun,
flipped the little switch on its
side to MELT, and shot a
stream of watery fluid over
our legs, keeping the blaster
trained on us all the while.
Our legs were free.
"You may get up now," he
said. "Slowly, without trying
to make trouble." Val and I
helped each other to our feet
as best we could, considering
our arms were still tightly
bound against the sides of our
oxysuits.
"Walk," the stranger said,
waving the tanglegun to indicate
the direction. "I'll be
right behind you." He holstered
the tanglegun.
I glimpsed the bulk of an
outboard atomic rigging behind
him, strapped to the
back of the wheelchair. He
fingered a knob on the arm of
the chair and the two exhaust
ducts behind the wheel-housings
flamed for a moment,
and the chair began to roll.
Obediently, we started
walking. You don't argue
with a blaster, even if the
man pointing it is in a wheelchair.
"What's going on, Ron?"
Val asked in a low voice as we
walked. Behind us the wheelchair
hissed steadily.
"I don't quite know, Val.
I've never seen this guy before,
and I thought I knew
everyone at the Dome."
"Quiet up there!" our captor
called, and we stopped
talking. We trudged along together,
with him following
behind; I could hear the
crunch-crunch
of the wheelchair
as its wheels chewed
into the sand. I wondered
where we were going, and
why. I wondered why we had
ever left Earth.
The answer to that came to
me quick enough: we had to.
Earth needed radioactives,
and the only way to get them
was to get out and look. The
great atomic wars of the late
20th Century had used up
much of the supply, but the
amount used to blow up half
the great cities of the world
hardly compared with the
amount we needed to put
them back together again.
In three centuries the shattered
world had been completely
rebuilt. The wreckage
of New York and Shanghai
and London and all the other
ruined cities had been hidden
by a shining new world of
gleaming towers and flying
roadways. We had profited by
our grandparents' mistakes.
They had used their atomics
to make bombs. We used ours
for fuel.
It was an atomic world.
Everything: power drills,
printing presses, typewriters,
can openers, ocean liners,
powered by the inexhaustible
energy of the dividing atom.
But though the energy is
inexhaustible, the supply of
nuclei isn't. After three centuries
of heavy consumption,
the supply failed. The mighty
machine that was Earth's industry
had started to slow
down.
And that started the chain
of events that led Val and me
to end up as a madman's prisoners,
on Mars. With every
source of uranium mined dry
on Earth, we had tried other
possibilities. All sorts of
schemes came forth. Project
Sea-Dredge was trying to get
uranium from the oceans. In
forty or fifty years, they'd
get some results, we hoped.
But there wasn't forty or
fifty years' worth of raw stuff
to tide us over until then. In a
decade or so, our power would
be just about gone. I could
picture the sort of dog-eat-dog
world we'd revert back
to. Millions of starving, freezing
humans tooth-and-clawing
in it in the useless shell of
a great atomic civilization.
So, Mars. There's not much
uranium on Mars, and it's not
easy to find or any cinch to
mine. But what little is there,
helps. It's a stopgap effort,
just to keep things moving
until Project Sea-Dredge
starts functioning.
Enter the Geig Corps: volunteers
out on the face of
Mars, combing for its uranium
deposits.
And here we are, I thought.
After we walked on a
while, a Dome became visible
up ahead. It slid up over the
crest of a hill, set back between
two hummocks on the
desert. Just out of the way
enough to escape observation.
For a puzzled moment I
thought it was our Dome, the
settlement where all of UranCo's
Geig Corps were located,
but another look told me that
this was actually quite near
us and fairly small. A one-man
Dome, of all things!
"Welcome to my home," he
said. "The name is Gregory
Ledman." He herded us off to
one side of the airlock, uttered
a few words keyed to his
voice, and motioned us inside
when the door slid up. When
we were inside he reached up,
clumsily holding the blaster,
and unscrewed the ancient
spacesuit fishbowl.
His face was a bitter,
dried-up mask. He was a man
who hated.
The place was spartanly
furnished. No chairs, no tape-player,
no decoration of any
sort. Hard bulkhead walls,
rivet-studded, glared back
at us. He had an automatic
chef, a bed, and a writing-desk,
and no other furniture.
Suddenly he drew the tanglegun
and sprayed our legs
again. We toppled heavily to
the floor. I looked up angrily.
"I imagine you want to
know the whole story," he
said. "The others did, too."
Valerie looked at me anxiously.
Her pretty face was a
dead white behind her oxymask.
"What others?"
"I never bothered to find
out their names," Ledman
said casually. "They were
other Geigs I caught unawares,
like you, out on the
desert. That's the only sport I
have left—Geig-hunting. Look
out there."
He gestured through the
translucent skin of the Dome,
and I felt sick. There was a
little heap of bones lying
there, looking oddly bright
against the redness of the
sands. They were the dried,
parched skeletons of Earthmen.
Bits of cloth and plastic,
once oxymasks and suits, still
clung to them.
Suddenly I remembered.
There had been a pattern
there all the time. We didn't
much talk about it; we chalked
it off as occupational hazards.
There had been a pattern
of disappearances on the desert.
I could think of six, eight
names now. None of them
had been particularly close
friends. You don't get time to
make close friends out here.
But we'd vowed it wouldn't
happen to us.
It had.
"You've been hunting
Geigs?" I asked. "
Why?
What've they ever done to
you?"
He smiled, as calmly as if
I'd just praised his house-keeping.
"Because I hate
you," he said blandly. "I intend
to wipe every last one of
you out, one by one."
I stared at him. I'd never
seen a man like this before; I
thought all his kind had died
at the time of the atomic
wars.
I heard Val sob, "He's a
madman!"
"No," Ledman said evenly.
"I'm quite sane, believe me.
But I'm determined to drive
the Geigs—and UranCo—off
Mars. Eventually I'll scare
you all away."
"Just pick us off in the desert?"
"Exactly," replied Ledman.
"And I have no fears of an
armed attack. This place is
well fortified. I've devoted
years to building it. And I'm
back against those hills. They
couldn't pry me out." He let
his pale hand run up into his
gnarled hair. "I've devoted
years to this. Ever since—ever
since I landed here on
Mars."
"What are you going to do
with us?" Val finally asked,
after a long silence.
He didn't smile this time.
"Kill you," he told her. "Not
your husband. I want him as
an envoy, to go back and tell
the others to clear off." He
rocked back and forth in his
wheelchair, toying with the
gleaming, deadly blaster in
his hand.
We stared in horror. It was
a nightmare—sitting there,
placidly rocking back and
forth, a nightmare.
I found myself fervently
wishing I was back out there
on the infinitely safer desert.
"Do I shock you?" he asked.
"I shouldn't—not when
you see my motives."
"We don't see them," I
snapped.
"Well, let me show you.
You're on Mars hunting uranium,
right? To mine and
ship the radioactives back to
Earth to keep the atomic engines
going. Right?"
I nodded over at our geiger
counters.
"We volunteered to come to
Mars," Val said irrelevantly.
"Ah—two young heroes,"
Ledman said acidly. "How
sad. I could almost feel sorry
for you. Almost."
"Just what is it you're
after?" I said, stalling, stalling.
"Atomics cost me my legs,"
he said. "You remember the
Sadlerville Blast?" he asked.
"Of course." And I did, too.
I'd never forget it. No one
would. How could I forget
that great accident—killing
hundreds, injuring thousands
more, sterilizing forty miles
of Mississippi land—when
the Sadlerville pile went up?
"I was there on business at
the time," Ledman said. "I
represented Ledman Atomics.
I was there to sign a new
contract for my company.
You know who I am, now?"
I nodded.
"I was fairly well shielded
when it happened. I never got
the contract, but I got a good
dose of radiation instead. Not
enough to kill me," he said.
"Just enough to necessitate
the removal of—" he indicated
the empty space at his
thighs. "So I got off lightly."
He gestured at the wheelchair
blanket.
I still didn't understand.
"But why kill us Geigs?
We
had nothing to do with it."
"You're just in this by accident,"
he said. "You see, after
the explosion and the amputation,
my fellow-members on
the board of Ledman Atomics
decided that a semi-basket
case like myself was a poor
risk as Head of the Board,
and they took my company
away. All quite legal, I assure
you. They left me almost a
pauper!" Then he snapped
the punchline at me.
"They renamed Ledman
Atomics. Who did you say you
worked for?"
I began, "Uran—"
"Don't bother. A more inventive
title than Ledman
Atomics, but not quite as
much heart, wouldn't you
say?" He grinned. "I saved
for years; then I came to
Mars, lost myself, built this
Dome, and swore to get even.
There's not a great deal of
uranium on this planet, but
enough to keep me in a style
to which, unfortunately, I'm
no longer accustomed."
He consulted his wrist
watch. "Time for my injection."
He pulled out the tanglegun
and sprayed us again,
just to make doubly certain.
"That's another little souvenir
of Sadlerville. I'm short
on red blood corpuscles."
He rolled over to a wall
table and fumbled in a container
among a pile of hypodermics.
"There are other injections,
too. Adrenalin, insulin.
Others. The Blast turned
me into a walking pin-cushion.
But I'll pay it all
back," he said. He plunged
the needle into his arm.
My eyes widened. It was
too nightmarish to be real. I
wasn't seriously worried
about his threat to wipe out
the entire Geig Corps, since
it was unlikely that one man
in a wheelchair could pick us
all off. No, it wasn't the
threat that disturbed me, so
much as the whole concept, so
strange to me, that the human
mind could be as warped
and twisted as Ledman's.
I saw the horror on Val's
face, and I knew she felt the
same way I did.
"Do you really think you
can succeed?" I taunted him.
"Really think you can kill
every Earthman on Mars? Of
all the insane, cockeyed—"
Val's quick, worried head-shake
cut me off. But Ledman
had felt my words, all right.
"Yes! I'll get even with
every one of you for taking
away my legs! If we hadn't
meddled with the atom in the
first place, I'd be as tall and
powerful as you, today—instead
of a useless cripple in a
wheelchair."
"You're sick, Gregory Ledman,"
Val said quietly.
"You've conceived an impossible
scheme of revenge and
now you're taking it out on
innocent people who've done
nothing, nothing at all to you.
That's not sane!"
His eyes blazed. "Who are
you to talk of sanity?"
Uneasily I caught Val's
glance from a corner of my
eye. Sweat was rolling down
her smooth forehead faster
than the auto-wiper could
swab it away.
"Why don't you do something?
What are you waiting
for, Ron?"
"Easy, baby," I said. I
knew what our ace in the hole
was. But I had to get Ledman
within reach of me first.
"Enough," he said. "I'm going
to turn you loose outside,
right after—"
"
Get sick!
" I hissed to Val,
low. She began immediately
to cough violently, emitting
harsh, choking sobs. "Can't
breathe!" She began to yell,
writhing in her bonds.
That did it. Ledman hadn't
much humanity left in him,
but there was a little. He lowered
the blaster a bit and
wheeled one-hand over to see
what was wrong with Val.
She continued to retch and
moan most horribly. It almost
convinced me. I saw Val's
pale, frightened face turn to
me.
He approached and peered
down at her. He opened his
mouth to say something, and
at that moment I snapped my
leg up hard, tearing the tangle-cord
with a snicking rasp,
and kicked his wheelchair
over.
The blaster went off, burning
a hole through the Dome
roof. The automatic sealers
glued-in instantly. Ledman
went sprawling helplessly out
into the middle of the floor,
the wheelchair upended next
to him, its wheels slowly revolving
in the air. The blaster
flew from his hands at the
impact of landing and spun
out near me. In one quick motion
I rolled over and covered
it with my body.
Ledman clawed his way to
me with tremendous effort
and tried wildly to pry the
blaster out from under me,
but without success. I twisted
a bit, reached out with my
free leg, and booted him
across the floor. He fetched
up against the wall of the
Dome and lay there.
Val rolled over to me.
"Now if I could get free of
this stuff," I said, "I could get
him covered before he comes
to. But how?"
"Teamwork," Val said. She
swivelled around on the floor
until her head was near my
boot. "Push my oxymask off
with your foot, if you can."
I searched for the clamp
and tried to flip it. No luck,
with my heavy, clumsy boot.
I tried again, and this time it
snapped open. I got the tip
of my boot in and pried upward.
The oxymask came off,
slowly, scraping a jagged red
scratch up the side of Val's
neck as it came.
"There," she breathed.
"That's that."
I looked uneasily at Ledman.
He was groaning and
beginning to stir.
Val rolled on the floor and
her face lay near my right
arm. I saw what she had in
mind. She began to nibble the
vile-tasting tangle-cord, running
her teeth up and down
it until it started to give. She
continued unfailingly.
Finally one strand snapped.
Then another. At last I
had enough use of my hand
to reach out and grasp the
blaster. Then I pulled myself
across the floor to Ledman,
removed the tanglegun, and
melted the remaining tangle-cord
off.
My muscles were stiff and
bunched, and rising made me
wince. I turned and freed Val.
Then I turned and faced Ledman.
"I suppose you'll kill me
now," he said.
"No. That's the difference
between sane people and insane,"
I told him. "I'm not
going to kill you at all. I'm
going to see to it that you're
sent back to Earth."
"
No!
" he shouted. "No!
Anything but back there. I
don't want to face them again—not
after what they did to
me—"
"Not so loud," I broke in.
"They'll help you on Earth.
They'll take all the hatred and
sickness out of you, and turn
you into a useful member of
society again."
"I hate Earthmen," he spat
out. "I hate all of them."
"I know," I said sarcastically.
"You're just all full of
hate. You hated us so much
that you couldn't bear to hang
around on Earth for as much
as a year after the Sadlerville
Blast. You had to take right
off for Mars without a moment's
delay, didn't you? You
hated Earth so much you
had
to leave."
"Why are you telling all
this to me?"
"Because if you'd stayed
long enough, you'd have used
some of your pension money
to buy yourself a pair of prosthetic
legs, and then you
wouldn't need this wheelchair."
Ledman scowled, and then
his face went belligerent
again. "They told me I was
paralyzed below the waist.
That I'd never walk again,
even with prosthetic legs, because
I had no muscles to fit
them to."
"You left Earth too quickly,"
Val said.
"It was the only way," he
protested. "I had to get off—"
"She's right," I told him.
"The atom can take away, but
it can give as well. Soon after
you left they developed
atomic-powered
prosthetics—amazing
things, virtually robot
legs. All the survivors of
the Sadlerville Blast were
given the necessary replacement
limbs free of charge. All
except you. You were so sick
you had to get away from the
world you despised and come
here."
"You're lying," he said.
"It's not true!"
"Oh, but it is," Val smiled.
I saw him wilt visibly, and
for a moment I almost felt
sorry for him, a pathetic legless
figure propped up against
the wall of the Dome at
blaster-point. But then I remembered
he'd killed twelve
Geigs—or more—and would
have added Val to the number
had he had the chance.
"You're a very sick man,
Ledman," I said. "All this
time you could have been
happy, useful on Earth, instead
of being holed up here
nursing your hatred. You
might have been useful, on
Earth. But you decided to
channel everything out as revenge."
"I still don't believe it—those
legs. I might have walked
again. No—no, it's all a lie.
They told me I'd never walk,"
he said, weakly but stubbornly
still.
I could see his whole structure
of hate starting to topple,
and I decided to give it
the final push.
"Haven't you wondered
how I managed to break the
tangle-cord when I kicked you
over?"
"Yes—human legs aren't
strong enough to break tangle-cord
that way."
"Of course not," I said. I
gave Val the blaster and slipped
out of my oxysuit.
"Look," I said. I pointed to
my smooth, gleaming metal
legs. The almost soundless
purr of their motors was the
only noise in the room. "I was
in the Sadlerville Blast, too,"
I said. "But I didn't go crazy
with hate when I lost
my
legs."
Ledman was sobbing.
"Okay, Ledman," I said.
Val got him into his suit, and
brought him the fishbowl helmet.
"Get your helmet on and
let's go. Between the psychs
and the prosthetics men,
you'll be a new man inside of
a year."
"But I'm a murderer!"
"That's right. And you'll be
sentenced to psych adjustment.
When they're finished,
Gregory Ledman the killer
will be as dead as if they'd
electrocuted you, but there'll
be a new—and sane—Gregory
Ledman." I turned to Val.
"Got the geigers, honey?"
For the first time since
Ledman had caught us, I remembered
how tired Val had
been out on the desert. I realized
now that I had been driving
her mercilessly—me, with
my chromium legs and atomic-powered
muscles. No wonder
she was ready to fold!
And I'd been too dense to see
how unfair I had been.
She lifted the geiger harnesses,
and I put Ledman
back in his wheelchair.
Val slipped her oxymask
back on and fastened it shut.
"Let's get back to the Dome
in a hurry," I said. "We'll
turn Ledman over to the authorities.
Then we can catch
the next ship for Earth."
"Go back?
Go back?
If you
think I'm backing down now
and quitting you can find
yourself another wife! After
we dump this guy I'm sacking
in for twenty hours, and then
we're going back out there to
finish that search-pattern.
Earth needs uranium, honey,
and I know you'd never be
happy quitting in the middle
like that." She smiled. "I
can't wait to get out there
and start listening for those
tell-tale clicks."
I gave a joyful whoop and
swung her around. When I
put her down, she squeezed
my hand, hard.
"Let's get moving, fellow
hero," she said.
I pressed the stud for the
airlock, smiling.
THE END
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Amazing Stories
September 1956.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/5/6/2/25627//25627-h//25627-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What kind of person is Ledman? | 25627_L0AQPROP_10 | [
"He is upset and lashing out because he feels betrayed",
"He has violent tendancies and hates his old company",
"He has always been a nutcase",
"He has been untrustworthy his whole life"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0001",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0031",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How is the book "Living a Normal Sex Life" seen by these people? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_1 | [
"It is frightening in an exciting way, for the people to learn something new",
"They respect its truths but are nervous about its implications",
"It is an important historical text appreciated from a research perspective",
"It is a rare artefact of a less-understood time"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What does this society think about breasts? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_2 | [
"They are appreciated from an aesthetic standpoint but not a sexual one",
"They are considered to be milk-producing devices but nothing else",
"They are seen as vistigial structures",
"They are well-regarded because they are so rare"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is the best representation of Melia and Xeon's relationship? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_3 | [
"They are close friends and will always be that and not much else",
"They are siblings, which is not odd for this society",
"They are close but have to hide their romantic relationship from the rest of society",
"They are dear to one another in an evolving way"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is least likely contributing to Xeon's request to move to the fields before the Oracle of Delni? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_4 | [
"The urge to make the event less of a spectacle",
"The general desire to maintain some control in the situation",
"The general level of comfort of lying on marble",
"The pressure from Sias to keep the situation private"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is the most accurate description of why Xeon is in trouble? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_5 | [
"He was not supposed to pursue a relationship with a woman",
"He was not supposed to point out any flaws in the current government structure",
"He publicly declared untrue things to be true",
"The suggestions he made were against the societal ideals"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which was probably the biggest motivator for Melia to volunteer? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_6 | [
"The chance to be closer with Xeon",
"The chance to fulfill societal expectations",
"The chance to help her friend Xeon discover something new",
"The chance to help her friend escape an unfortunate situation"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which is most true about how the volunteers are seen by the rest of their society? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_7 | [
"They are appreciated for their level of discretion",
"They are respected for their dedication to each other above anything else",
"They are considered brave for undertaking such a disapproved task",
"They are disgraced for their choice to participate in such vile acts"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
60,283 | 60283_G2WQAC2P | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | The Birds and the Bees | 1972.0 | Fisher, David E. | Sex -- Fiction; Science fiction; Short stories; PS | The Birds and the Bees
BY DAVE E. FISHER
Which goes to prove that, in some
instances, being heroic is easy!
[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
Worlds of If Science Fiction, August 1957.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
I was wandering among the tall grass of the slopes, listening to the
soft whistling of the wind; allowing the grass to caress my toga and
thighs. It was a day soft and clear; a day accepted by the young,
cherished by we old. Across the gently undulating hills stood the
magnificent Melopolis, encradling the Oracle of Delni. I do not, of
course, believe in the gods per se; still there is a grandeur in the
very stones that transcends their human sculptors, and it is no wonder
to me that many cling tenaciously, and ignorantly, to the old religion.
Cling to the gods of old, who drew man upward from wherever he began.
In whose names Man killed and plundered, while struggling up. In whose
names Man finally left this earth, to seek his cousins among the stars.
But of course there were no cousins. There was nothing. And Man
returned, and settled down to live. Saddened, but resigned and content
to live in peace with his knowledge and his power. Gone now are all the
ancient evils, wars, emergencies.
"Sias! Sias—" And they were upon me.
That is, Xeon was upon me. But I knew that where Xeon is, Melia must
soon appear. And indeed it was but a moment before Melia slipped
through the high grass to stand at his side. Their youthful voices were
babbling in excitement.
Melia was a She, with the swelling breasts that were, so tradition
states, quite prevalent among members of the race long ago, and are
seldom seen today. Indeed, Melia was on this account made the butt of
many jokes and, I fear, would have had a lonely life of it had it not
been for the friendship of Xeon.
"Sias," they were saying, "the Maternite's gone."
I stared in amazement.
"Gone? It cannot be gone. It has always been—"
"Oh my gods!" Xeon shouted. "I tell you it's gone! Will you—"
Melia interrupted him quietly. "Xeon, will you lose all respect for
the Elder?" Then turned to me, and said calmly, "The watcher at the
Maternite Machine, it appears, has been drunk. The heat rose above the
warning, continued to rise, and then—poof. Everything has evaporated
in Maternite. All the Prelife is gone."
"All of it?" I asked.
"There is nothing left," Melia insisted. "Can more be made? And if not,
what will happen with no more children?"
"That is for the priests to say, not I," I replied. In moments of
emergency, it is wise to speak with caution. That is, I suppose so. I
have never before been in a real emergency.
A man my age does not hurry in the heat of the midday sun—maddugs
nenglishmin go out in the midday sun, as the ancients say, although I
often wonder why—but Xeon and Melia ran all the way down to the city.
They are of an age to enter manhood, and have all the energy such young
men do.
As we entered the city, we were surrounded by confusion and
consternation. And can the simple people be blamed? They were aware
that they stood in the midst of an unprecedented happening; indeed, an
emergency. For a machine had failed!
Not in the memory of the eldest among us has a machine failed. They
were created so long ago, indeed, that the ignorant believe them
to have been constructed by the gods themselves. And never, so far
as I know, has one failed. Small wonder that the watcher had been
negligent. Indeed, the watcher is more a tradition than a necessity.
Besides, had he been sober, he would not have known what to do. For who
knows the mysterious workings of the machines?
I hastened to the City Hall and found the Conclave assembled, waiting
for me to bring them to order. Xeon and Melia stopped as I mounted the
steps, but I smiled and motioned them in. They accompanied me past
the marble pillars into the cool recesses of the Hall, then seated
themselves on the floor as I took my place by the great table.
Well, you know how these things are. At such a time, many men feel
impelled to make speeches, and one must not be disrespectful. Prayers
and supplications were offered to the gods, priests were sent to
sacrifice, and finally, as the light of the sun was falling between the
pillars, the High Priest of the Maternite Machine was heard.
He rambled through the customary opening remarks and then, continually
smoothing his white beard—of which he is excessively proud—approached
the crux of the matter and the Conclave finally heard the facts it had
assembled to hear. By this time, unfortunately, many of the Conclave
had departed for home and supper. Yet perhaps it is for the best, for
those left were the most earnest and intelligent.
"I would not bore you," he said, "with details of which only the gods
are sure. Know, then, that once granted a few cells of Prelife, it is
an easy matter for the Maternite Machine to add more and more; thus
assuring us, as has always been, a continuous source of Prelife to be
born by the Generating Machine as children. The machines bear the exact
number of children each year to balance the number of us whom the gods
claim. Such it has always been from time immemorial."
A murmur of assent and approval of these virtuous words whispered
around the Hall.
"But now," he continued, however, with less assurance and indeed with
even a stutter here and there, "an unprecedented situation has arisen.
Indeed, I might call it an emergency. For the M-Maternite Machine has
actually failed."
Cries of "Treason" sprang up, and I fear it might have gone hard for
the priest had I not been able to insure order.
"That is not the worst," he cried, as if in defiance. "All the Prelife
has been dried up. It will not function. There is no more. And there
will be no more children!"
At this I feared the Conclave was about to riot. It is at such times
that I most revere the wisdom of the ancients, who decreed seventy
years the minimum age for a member of the Conclave. They shouted and
began to beat their fists, but for how long can a man of seventy years
roar like a youngster? They quieted, breathing heavily, and I asked,
"Is there no way, then, to produce more Prelife in order that the
machines may produce more children for us?
"As I have said," he replied, "give the machines but a bit of Prelife
and they will produce more. But take away that least bit, and they are
helpless."
Such heresy could have brought a sad end to the priest had not the
Conclave been so exhausted by the events of the day. We leaned back to
think.
Rocsates leaned forward and asked, "Must there not—must there not have
been a beginning to Prelife? For the Machine, it seems, cannot make it;
and yet it came from somewhere."
"Riddles are not called for," I answered severely.
"Are not riddles often the beginning of knowledge?" he asked, in that
irritating dumber-than-thou attitude of his. "Must there not, long ago,
have been a source of Prelife: a source now forgotten? And may it not
even now—should we discover it—be available to us? I am reminded of
the story of the animals of old—"
"I fear your mind is wandering, Rocsates," I was forced to interrupt.
"I know well the legend of the animals, but what does it have to
do—" The heads of the Conclave were turning to me, quizzically. I
hastened to explain the legend of the animals. "It is said that many
thousands of years ago, time without reckoning, there existed on the
earth creatures who were alive like us, and yet not like us. It is said
they had four legs or more, and no arms, were covered with hair, and
although not mute, they could not speak."
Rocsates' voice made itself heard. "It is true. Such creatures did
indeed exist. It is recorded most scientifically in the films."
"If it be so," I said, quieting the hub-bub that followed, "and I would
not doubt your word, Rocsates, for all know you are the wisest of
men—if it were so, then, what of it?"
"May it not be," Rocsates put in, "that these animals had no machines
to reproduce their kind? For surely the gods would not grant machines
to such creatures. And indeed, if they had Maternite Machines, why then
we would yet have these animals among us."
"And how, then, did these animals reproduce?" I asked.
"How, indeed? And is there not a legend—admitted only a legend—that
says there was a time before the machines, and before the Maternite
Machine, and that at such a time both the animals and Men reproduced
from within their own bodies?"
At this two members of the Conclave fell immediately into a faint, and
I would gladly have joined them. I hoped that the youngsters, Xeon
and Melia, had not heard, but as I turned they were listening most
attentively to Rocsates, who, amid cries of "Heresy" and "Treason",
went on:
"I should like to ask the Conclave for permission to search the ancient
records, in the hope of finding some such knowledge that would prove or
disprove my words."
"You wish to search the films—" I began.
"Not the films, Sias, but the books."
Gods, this Rocsates! The books, as well he knows, are so ancient,
and so delicate, that they are kept in an air-tight tomb; lest,
being handled, they be destroyed and all knowledge within them lost.
Therefore, they have not been read in the known history of our race.
And Rocsates has been anxious for an excuse—
"Sias," he went on, "if there exists such knowledge as I seek, is it
not indeed lost to the memory of Man? And if so, are not the books the
only place where it may be found?"
Rocsates, it is suspected, will never ask a question unless he knows
the answer beforehand. And so I acquiesced, and agreed, and granted
permission. And with much misgiving and foreboding of evil, the
Conclave adjourned.
Several weeks elapsed before Rocsates requested that the Conclave meet.
I called the meeting at dawn and so it was yet early in the afternoon
when formalities were concluded and Rocsates granted leave to speak.
"Some of those among you are She's," he began. "And you know you are
different from the rest of us. To the advantage, your skin is fairer
and your features more often handsomer than ours. To the disadvantage,
your excretory system is not so mechanically dextrous as ours. And, you
may say, why should this not be so? There is, indeed, no reason why we
should all be identical. Perforce you have the advantage, perforce we
do. Yet there is one other distinction.
"Some among you She's have the swelling of the breasts. And does there
exist no reason for this? Was there not, perhaps in ancient times, a
cause for this? Do you not wonder, She's, whence you come and for what
reason?"
"Rocsates," I interrupted. "All this is fascinating, of course. But if
you could be quick—"
"Of course," he replied. "In the course of my reading I have read
many books, and while they are all vague on the subject, this I have
discovered:
"That there was indeed a time before the machines, in fact the books
were created in that time, for not one of them mentions the machines.
Then reproduction was carried on by individuals, without help of the
then nonexistent machines. The She's are not wanderers from another
land, but they have lived with us for all time; they are not another
race, but we are all types of one race. And the fact of reproduction is
somehow intimately related to the physical distinctions of the She's!"
These last sentences were shouted to be heard above the roar of the
crowd. Yet when Rocsates stopped, so also did the noise, so shocked and
amazed at his words were they. And I confess, myself also.
"In fact," Rocsates added, sitting down, "this process of reproduction
seems to have been so simple that there was once a problem of
over-population."
Order was lost among the Conclave as each man turned to speak to his
neighbor, and for some time I could not restore order. I realized that
something had to be done to save Rocsates before the outrage of the
assembled overwhelmed him.
"It seems," I shouted, "that there is a flaw in your logic." For if
such there was, I was hopeful of dismissing the entire affair with
no harm done. "For if people reproduced too often, why then this
reproduction must have been a pleasant thing to do; otherwise they
would not have done so to excess. And if it was a pleasant thing to do,
where is the necessity for the machines, and why were they created?"
Rocsates seemed perplexed by this problem, whereupon Xeon, who together
with Melia were at the Conclave without permission, shouted, "Perhaps
the process of reproduction was of
such
a pleasure that the Conclave
ruled it to be a sin? And therefore the machines were necessary!"
At this impudence the Conclave dissolved in an uproar, and I was beyond
power to restrain them from placing Xeon under arrest. Privately,
however, I had to admit that his supposition was a possibility, and
thus I authorized Rocsates to continue his search.
Now indeed I was sorely worried concerning Xeon, for he must languish
in the dungeon until the Conclave is satisfied to release him, and this
they cannot do until they meet again.
I needed a sufficient excuse to call a meeting of the Conclave,
whereupon I might argue for the lad. When I heard that Rocsates again
desired audience, I immediately proclaimed a meeting of the Conclave
to be held the next day at dawn, and so that night slept well.
The Conclave had come to order and formalities had been initiated when
Rocsates entered and took his place. He clutched under one shoulder
a thin, rectangular object, but that is not what impressed me. His
appearance—he looked as if he had not slept of late, nor eaten either.
His eyes were sunken, and his features had doubled in age. He was bent
and tired. But it was his eyes. There was a horror in them.
I was shocked, and could not help staring at him. And then the
formalities were over. I intended to speak for Xeon, but Rocsates was
on his feet and I gave way.
"I have indeed discovered the secret of reproduction," he began. "After
many searchings, I came upon this—" and he held forth the object he
had carried in. "It is a book. It is entitled, 'Living a Normal Sex
Life.' It seems to be some sort of a do-it-yourself pamphlet." He
dropped the book on the table and rubbed his hands over his eyes.
There was something in the man's behavior that commanded everyone's
attention. He went on, speaking low. "The word 'Sex' is not defined,
but it seems to mean...." His words trailed off. He was obviously
unsure of how to continue. "I had better start at the beginning, I
suppose," he said. "You see, once upon a time there were birds and
bees...."
When he finished the Conclave sat in horrified silence. His words,
with all their horror, had the ring of truth and there were no cries of
'Heresy'. There was only stunned disbelief and the beginnings of nausea.
It is the mark of honor that a leader shall carry on when others fear
to move. I cleared my throat.
"Shall not these organs which you mention have atrophied by now? With
no use throughout all these generations, will they not have evolved
into nothingness?"
"I do not think so," Rocsates replied after a while. "What to us is
an eon, to evolution is but an instant. And then the swelling of the
breasts, I believe, proves that there is still reproductive activity in
some, at least, of the She's."
We sat shaking our heads, bowed under terrible reality.
"Then we must experiment," I said. "But whom could we ask to submit to
such horror?"
"I have already taken the liberty of asking for volunteers," Rocsates
replied. "The She, of course, must be one with the swelling of the
breasts. Melia has volunteered, on condition that Xeon be released from
dungeon. Are there any objections?"
There were none, of course. Who would refuse a boon to one who would
undergo such an ordeal for the City?
"And who will be the partner?" I asked.
"In all honor, could Xeon allow Melia to surpass him in courage? It
shall be he," Rocsates said. And with his word the two entered the Hall
and stood, noble and naked.
Rocsates gestured to the table, and Melia started to climb upon it,
but Xeon stepped forward.
"My lords," he said, "would not better results be obtained were we to
conduct the experiment in the fields before the Oracle of Delni, that
the gods may help us?"
His glance reached into my soul, and I was proud of Xeon. A true
friend, he thought even now of the comfort of Melia. The marble table
was indeed hard, and from Rocsates' description it seemed that Melia's
position would be as uncomfortable as it would be undignified. The soft
fields might be some slight help.
I voiced my assent, and the entire Conclave adjourned to the fields.
It was nearly dark when we walked home, Rocsates and I, arm in arm. It
had been a horrible day. The inhuman indignity, the cries—
We tarried before my home, leaned on the stone, stared at the first
stars.
"They seemed finally to accomplish all the book described," I muttered.
"They may indeed have succeeded," Rocsates replied. "There is mentioned
a time lapse which is necessary. The child does not appear immediately."
"It doesn't matter," I said disconsolately. "Who could ask them to go
through such an ordeal again?"
And then I looked down to earth again, and saw them standing before me.
Melia cast her eyes down, and would not raise them. Xeon held his arm
about her shoulders, as if to protect her, but I know not from whom.
"Sias," he said. Then stopped, embarrassed.
I waited, and Rocsates was silent, and he continued.
"Sias, we come to tell.... We will...." He raised his eyes to mine and
said manfully, "We shall try again."
I am afraid that tears came to my eyes. Such sacrifice—
"We beg one favor," Xeon went on. "We are agreed that—Well, we should
like to be left alone, in private, to try."
"Of course," I replied. Anything they might want they could have. My
relief and gratitude must have showed, for Xeon took a deep breath and
spoke again.
"We do not deserve praise, Sias," he said. "The truth is, we ... we
sort of enjoy it."
I watched them turn and wander off together under the stars.
My heart has a warmth in it, and I no longer fear for the future of our
race when our young people can show such nobility and sacrifice.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/6/0/2/8/60283//60283-h//60283-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why are Melia and Xeon considered noble by the end of the story? | 60283_G2WQAC2P_8 | [
"Because they discovered the truth about reproduction and brought it to the society",
"Because they did not tell others in the society what happened in detail, protecting them from the truth",
"Because they were willing to continue learning about this ill-understood act",
"Because they want to increase the efforts towards learning more about these historical acts"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which best describes the relationship between Neena and Var? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_1 | [
"They are marrying out of familial responsibility more than love but are still happy to be together",
"They have roughly equal footing in their dedication to one another",
"Neena gets to make all of the decision in return for going with Var to stay with his people",
"Var has convinced Neena to go with him after he won her in battle"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Who is the Watcher? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_2 | [
"Someone who has been granted the honor of watching over the mountain region",
"A man who was exiled from society because of violent tendencies",
"An old man who has retracted from society",
"An alien in charge of protecting the planet"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does the Watcher feel about Neena and Var's arrival? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_3 | [
"He is thankful to have company to pass his wisdom to",
"He is a little disappointed to not have time to himself",
"He is suspicious of any people who would enter where he lives",
"He is thankful to have any interaction with other humans"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0022",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does Groz not want to go into the mountain? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_4 | [
"He does not want to get separated from his team",
"He is scared of the wildlife that might try to attack",
"He is nervous about the technology left behind",
"He knows it will be hard to see the people he is chasing"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What does Var think of The Watcher? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_5 | [
"He respects him even though he is surprising",
"He will trust him in any decision even if he does not like him personally",
"He thinks all of his ideas are ridiculous",
"He thinks his reputation is overblown but he thinks he is nice"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is not a lasting effect of the Ryzgas? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_6 | [
"Climate change on the planet",
"An increase in technological advancements",
"Use of limited resources",
"General fear between groups of people"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why does the story take place somewhere cold? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_7 | [
"The history of the area is such that warmth and resources have been taken from the land",
"A volcano has blocked light from the region making everything cold",
"The mountains are the only place Var and Neena can hide",
"It isn't actually cold, because of the lava"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | How does The Watcher communicate with others? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_8 | [
"Mostly through transference of heat and light",
"A mix of many methods of communication",
"Primarily with his mind",
"By talking as the rest of the people do"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the significance of the title of the story? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_9 | [
"It references the old technology that is disturbed",
"It is an image of the chase that Var and Neena are running from",
"It hints to the great power of the Watcher",
"It points to Var and Neena disrupting an area that is usually quiet"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
32,836 | 32836_4ZJXFXNA | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | When the Mountain Shook | 1956.0 | Abernathy, Robert | Short stories; Science fiction; PS | WHEN THE MOUNTAIN SHOOK
By Robert Abernathy
Illustrated by Kelly Freas
[Transcriber Note: This etext was produced from IF Worlds of Science
Fiction March 1954. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]
Dark was the Ryzga mountain and forbidding; steep were its
cliffs and sheer its crevasses. But its outward perils could not compare
with the Ryzgas themselves, who slept within, ready to wake and
conquer....
At sunset they were in sight of the Ryzga mountain. Strangely it towered
among the cliffs and snow-slopes of the surrounding ranges: an immense
and repellently geometric cone, black, its sides blood-tinted by the
dying sun.
Neena shivered, even though the surrounding cold could not reach her.
The ice-wind blew from the glacier, but Var's love was round her as a
warming cloak, a cloak that glowed softly golden in the deepening
twilight, even as her love was about him.
Var said, "The Watcher's cave should be three miles beyond this pass."
He stood rigid, trying to catch an echo of the Watcher's thoughts, but
there was nothing. Perhaps the old man was resting. From the other
direction, the long way that they two had come, it was not difficult to
sense the thought of Groz. That thought was powerful, and heavy with
vengeance.
"Hurry," said Neena. "They're closer than they were an hour ago."
She was beautiful and defiant, facing the red sunset and the black
mountain. Var sensed her fear, and the love that had conquered it. He
felt a wave of tenderness and bitterness. For him she had come to this.
For the flame that had sprung between them at the Truce of New Grass,
she had challenged the feud of their peoples and had left her home, to
follow him. Now, if her father and his kinsmen overtook them, it would
be death for Var, and for Neena living shame. Which of the two was worse
was no longer a simple problem to Var, who had grown much older in the
last days.
"Wait," he commanded. While she waited he spun a dream, attaching it to
the crags that loomed over the pass, and to the frozen ground underfoot.
It was black night, as it would really be when Groz and his henchmen
reached this place; lurid fire spewed from the Ryzga mountain, and
strange lights dipped above it; and for good measure there was an
avalanche in the dream, and hideous beasts rushed snapping and ravening
from the crevices of the rock.
"Oh!" cried Neena in involuntary alarm.
Var sighed, shaking his head. "It won't hold them for long, but it's the
best I can do now. Come on."
There was no path. Now they were descending the steeper face of the
sierra, and the way led over bottomless crevasses, sheer drops and sheer
ascents, sheets of traitorous glare ice. Place after place had to be
crossed on the air, and both grew weary with the effort such crossings
cost. They hoarded their strength, helping one another; one alone might
never have won through.
It was starry night already when they saw the light from the Watcher's
cave. The light shone watery and dim from beneath the hoary back of the
glacier, and as they came nearer they saw why: the cave entrance was
sealed by a sheet of ice, a frozen waterfall that fell motionless from
the rocks above. They heard no sound.
The two young people stared for a long minute, intrigued and fearful.
Both had heard of this place, and the ancient who lived there to keep
watch on the Ryzga mountain, as a part of the oldest legends of their
childhood; but neither had been here before.
But this was no time for shyness. Var eyed the ice-curtain closely to
make sure that it was real, not dream-stuff; then he struck it boldly
with his fist. It shattered and fell in a rain of splinters, sparkling
in the light that poured from within.
They felt the Watcher rouse, heard his footsteps, and finally saw him—a
shrunken old man, white-haired, with a lined beardless face. The sight
of him, more marred by age than anyone they had ever seen before, was
disappointing. They had expected something more—an ancient giant, a
tower of wisdom and strength. The Watcher was four hundred years old;
beside him even Groz, who had always seemed so ancient, was like a boy.
The Watcher peered at them in turn. "Welcome," he said in a cracked
voice. He did not speak again; the rest of his conversation was in
thought only. "Welcome indeed. I am too much alone here."
"You were asleep!" said Var. Shock made his thought accusing, though he
had not meant to be.
The old man grinned toothlessly. "Never fear. Asleep or awake, I watch.
Come in! You're letting in the wind."
Inside the cave it was warm as summer. Var saw with some surprise that
all the walls were sheathed in ice—warm to the touch, bound fast
against melting by the Watcher's will. Light blazed in reflections from
the ice walls, till there was no shadow in the place. Behind them began
a tinkling of falling water, thawed from the glacial ridges above to
descend sheet-wise over the cave mouth, freezing as it fell into
lengthening icicles. The old man gazed at his work for a moment, then
turned questioningly to the young pair.
"We need a little rest out of the cold," said Var. "And food, if you can
spare it. We're pursued."
"Yes, yes. You shall have what I can give you. Make yourselves
comfortable, and in one minute.... Pursued, eh? A pity. I see the world
is as bad as it was when I was last in it."
Hot food and drink were before them almost at once. The Watcher regarded
them with compassion as their eyes brightened and some of the shadow of
weariness lifted from them. "You have stolen your enemy's daughter, no
doubt, young man? Such things happened when I was young."
Warming to the old man now, Var sketched his and Neena's history
briefly. "We should have been safe among my people by now. And before
very long, I'm sure, I would have performed some deed which Groz would
recognize as a worthy exploit, and would thus have healed the feud
between our families. But our flight was found out too soon. They cut us
off and forced us into the mountains, and now they are only a few hours
behind us."
"A pity, indeed. I would like to help you—but, you understand, I am the
Mountain Watcher. I must be above feuds and families."
Var nodded somberly, thinking that an old recluse would in any case be
able to do little for them against Groz and his violent kinsfolk.
"And what will you do now?"
Var grinned mirthlessly. "We haven't much choice, since they're
overtaking us. I have only one idea left: we can go where Groz may fear
to follow us."
"To the mountain, you mean."
"And into it, if need be."
The Watcher was broodingly silent; his eyes shifted to Neena, where she
nestled by Var's side. He asked, "And you—are you willing to follow
your lover in this?"
Neena returned his gaze without flinching; then she looked sidelong at
Var, and her lips curled with a proud and tender mockery. "Follow? Why,
I will lead, if his courage should fail him."
The old man said, "It is no part of my duty to dissuade you from this
thing. You are free persons. But I must be sure that you know what you
are doing. That is the second part of the law the First Watcher made: to
guard lest the unwary and the ignorant should bring harm on themselves
and on all men."
"We know the stories," Var said brusquely. "In the hollow heart of their
mountain the Ryzgas sleep, as they chose to do when their world
crumbled. But if they are wakened, the mountain will tremble, and the
Ryzgas will come forth."
"Do you believe that?"
"As one believes stories."
"It is true," said the Watcher heavily. "In my youth I penetrated
farther into the mountain than anyone before, farther even than did the
First Watcher. I did not see the sleepers, nor will any man until they
come again, but I met their sentries, the sentinel machines that guard
them now as they have for two thousand years. When I had gone that far,
the mountain began to shake, the force that is in the Earth rumbled
below, and I returned in time." Now for the first time Var sensed the
power in the old man's look, the power of four hundred years' wisdom.
Var stared down at his hands.
"The Ryzgas also were men," said the Watcher. "But they were such a race
as the world has not seen before or since. There were tyrannies before
the Ryzgas, there was lust for power, and atrocious cruelty; but such
tyranny, power, and cruelty as theirs, had never been known. They ruled
the Earth for four generations, and the Earth was too little for them.
They laid the world waste, stripped it of metals and fuels and bored to
its heart for energy, poisoned its seas and its air with the fume of
their works, wrung its peoples dry for their labor ... and in each of
those four generations they launched a ship of space. They were great
and evil as no other people has been, because they wanted the stars.
"Because of them we must build with dreams instead of iron, and our only
fire is that of the Sun, and even now, two thousand years later, the
Earth is still slowly recovering from the pangs and poison of that age.
If you turn up the sod in the plain where the wild herds graze, you will
find numberless fragments of rusted or corroded metal, bits of glass and
strange plastic substances, debris of artifacts still showing the marks
of their shaping—the scattered wreckage of the things they made. And
we—we too are a remnant, the descendants of the few out of all humanity
that survived when the Ryzgas' world went down in flame and thunder.
"In the last generation of their power the Ryzgas knew by their science
that the race of man would endure them no longer. They made ready their
weapons, they mined the cities and the factories for destruction, making
sure that their works and their knowledge would perish with them.
Meanwhile they redoubled the yoke and the punishments, hastening the
completion of the last of the starships.
"From the memories that the old Watchers have left here, and from the
memories of dead men that still echo in the air, I have gathered a
picture of that world's end. I will show it to you...."
Var and Neena stared, unstirring, with wide vacant eyes, while the old
man wove a dream around them, and the bright ice-cave faded from their
vision, and they saw—
Black starless night, a sky of rolling smoke above the greatest city
that was ever built. Only the angry light of fires relieved the city's
darkness—that, and the blue-white lightning flashes that silhouetted
the naked skeletons of buildings and were followed by thunder and a
shaking of the earth.
Along lightless streets, half choked with rubble and with the dead,
poured a mad, hating horde. The recurrent flashes lit scarred faces,
naked bodies blackened and maimed from the hell of the workshops where
the Ryzgas' might had been forged, eyes that stared white and half
sightless from the glare of the furnaces, gnarled hands that now at long
last clutched the weapons of the last rebellion—a rebellion without
hope of new life on a world gutted and smoldering from the fulfilment of
the Ryzgas' dream, without slogans other than a cry for blood.
Before them death waited around the citadel where the masters still
fought. All round, from the lowest and most poisonous levels of the
shattered city, the slaves swarmed up in their millions. And the
lightning blazed, and the city howled and screamed and burned.
Then, unbelievably, the thunder fell silent, and the silence swept
outward like a wave, from ruined street to street. The mouths that had
shouted their wrath were speechless, and the rage-blinded eyes were
lifted in sudden awe. From the center, over the citadel, an immense
white globe soared upward, rising swiftly without sound.
They had never seen its like, but they knew. It was the last starship,
and it was leaving.
It poised motionless. For an instant the burning city lay mute; then the
millions found voice. Some roared ferocious threats and curses; others
cried desolately—
wait!
Then the whole city, the dark tumuli of its buildings and its leaping
fires and tormented faces, and the black sky over it, seemed to twist
and swim, like a scene under water when a great fish sweeps past, and
the ship was gone.
The stunned paralysis fell apart in fury. Flame towered over the
citadel. The hordes ran and shrieked again toward the central inferno,
and the city burned and burned....
Var blinked dazedly in the shadowless glow of the ice-cave. His arm
tightened about Neena till she gasped. He was momentarily uncertain that
he and she were real and here, such had been the force of the dream, a
vision of such scope and reality as Var had never seen—no, lived
through—before. With deep respect now he gazed upon the bent old man
who was the Mountain Watcher.
"Some of the Ryzgas took flight to the stars, and some perished on
Earth. But there was a group of them who believed that their time to
rule would come again. These raised a black mountain from the Earth's
heart, and in hollows within it cast themselves into deathless sleep,
their deathless and lifeless sentinels round them, to wait till someone
dare arouse them, or until their chosen time—no one knows surely.
"I have told you the story you know, and have shown you a glimpse of the
old time, because I must make sure that you do not approach the mountain
in ignorance. Our world is unwise and sometimes evil, full of arrogance,
folly, and passion that are in the nature of man. Yet it is a happy
world, compared to that the Ryzgas made and will make again."
The Watcher eyed them speculatively. "Before all," he said finally,
"this is a world where you are free to risk wakening the old tyrants, if
in your own judgment your great need renders the chance worth taking."
Neena pressed her face against Var's shoulder, hiding her eyes. In her
mind as it groped for his there was a confusion of horror and pity. Var
looked grimly at the Watcher, and would have spoken; but the Watcher
seemed suddenly a very long way off, and Var could no longer feel his
own limbs, his face was a numb mask. Dully he heard the old man say,
"You are tired. Best sleep until morning."
Var strove to cry out that there was no time, that Groz was near and
that sleep was for infants and the aged, but his intention sank and
drowned under wave upon wave of unconquerable languor. The bright cave
swam and dissolved; his eyelids closed.
Var woke. Daylight glimmered through the ice of the cave mouth. He had
been unconscious, helpless, for hours! At the thought of that, panic
gripped him. He had not slept since childhood, and he had forgotten how
it was.
He came to his feet in one quick movement, realizing in that action that
sleep had refreshed his mind and body—realizing also that a footstep
had wakened him. Across the cave he faced a young man who watched him
coolly with dark piercing eyes that were familiar though he did not know
the face.
Neena sat up and stifled a cry of fright. Var growled, "Who are you?
Where's the Watcher?"
The other flashed white teeth in a smile. "I'm the Watcher," he
answered. "Often I become a youth at morning, and relax into age as the
day passes. A foolish amusement, no doubt, but amusements are few here."
"You made us fall asleep. Groz will be on us—"
"Groz and his people could not detect your thoughts as you slept. They
were all night chasing elusive dreams on the high ridges, miles away."
Var passed a hand across bewildered eyes. Neena said softly, "Thank you,
Watcher."
"Don't thank me. I take no sides in your valley feuds. But now you are
rested, your minds are clear. Do you still mean to go on to the Ryzga
mountain?"
Not looking at the Watcher, Var muttered unsteadily, "We have no
alternative."
There was a liquid tinkling as the ice-curtain collapsed; the fresh
breeze of morning swept into the cave. The youth beckoned to them, and
they followed him outside.
The glacial slope on which the cavern opened faced toward the mountain.
It rose black and forbidding in the dawn as it had by sunset. To right
and left of it, the grand cliffs, ocher and red, were lit splendidly by
the morning sun, but the mountain of the Ryzgas drank in the light and
gave nothing back.
Below their feet the slope fell away into an opaque sea of fog, filling
a mile-wide gorge. There was a sound of turbulent water, of a river
dashed from rock to rock in its struggle toward the plain, but the
curling fog hid everything.
"You have an alternative," said the Watcher crisply. The two took their
eyes from the black mountain and gazed at him in sudden hope, but his
face was unsmiling. "It is this. You, Var, can flee up the canyon to the
north, by a way I will show you, disguising your thoughts and masking
your presence as well as you are able, while the girl goes in the other
direction, southward, without seeking to conceal herself. Your pursuers
will be deceived and follow her, and by the time they catch her it will
be too late for them to overtake Var."
That possibility had not occurred to them at all. Var and Neena looked
at one another. Then by common consent they blended their minds into
one.
They thought, in the warm intimacy of unreserved understanding: "
It
would work: I-you would make the sacrifice of shame and mockery—yet
these can be borne—that I-you might be saved from death—which is alone
irreparable.... But to become
I
and
you
again—that cannot be
borne.
"
They said in unison, "No. Not that."
The Watcher's face did not change. He said gravely, "Very well. I will
give you what knowledge I have that may help you when you enter the
Ryzga mountain."
Quickly, he impressed on them what he had learned of the structure of
the mountain and of its guardian machines. Var closed his eyes, a little
dizzied by the rapid flood of detail.
"You are ready to go," said the Watcher. He spoke aloud, and his voice
was cracked and harsh. Var opened his eyes in surprise, and saw that the
Watcher had become again the hoary ancient of last night.
Var felt a twinge of unfamiliar emotion; only by its echo in Neena's
mind did he recognize it as a sense of guilt. He said stiffly, "You
don't blame us?"
"You have taken life in your own hands," rasped the Watcher. "Who does
that needs no blessing and feels no curse. Go!"
They groped through the fog above blank abysses that hid the snarling
river, crept hand in hand, sharing their strength, across unstable dream
bridges from crag to crag. Groz and his pack, in their numbers, would
cross the gorge more surely and swiftly. When Var and Neena set foot at
last on the cindery slope of the great volcanic cone, they sensed that
the pursuit already halved their lead.
They stood high on the side of the Ryzga mountain, and gazed at the
doorway. It was an opaque yet penetrable well of darkness, opening into
the face of a lava cliff, closed only by an intangible curtain—so
little had the Ryzgas feared those who might assail them in their sleep.
Var sent his thoughts probing beyond the curtain, listened intently,
head thrown back, to their echoes that returned. The tunnel beyond
slanted steeply downward. Var's hands moved, molding a radiant globe
from the feeble sunshine that straggled through the fog-bank. With an
abrupt motion he hurled it. The sun-globe vanished, as if the darkness
had drunk it up, but though sight did not serve they both sensed that it
had passed through to light up the depths beyond. For within the
mountain something snapped suddenly alert—something alive yet not
living, seeing yet blind. They felt light-sensitive cells tingle in
response, felt electric currents sting along buried, long-idle
circuits....
The two stood shivering together.
The morning wind stirred, freshening, the fog lifted a little, and they
heard a great voice crying, "There they are!"
Var and Neena turned. Far out in the sea of fog, on a dream bridge that
they could not see, stood Groz. He shook the staff he carried. It was
too far to discern the rage that must contort his features, but the
thought he hurled at them was a soundless bellow: "Young fools! I've
caught you now!"
Behind Groz the figures of his followers loomed up as striding shadows.
Neena's hand tightened on Var's. Var sent a thought of defiance: "Go
back! Or you'll drive us to enter the mountain!"
Groz seemed to hesitate. Then he swung his staff up like a weapon, and
for the two on the mountainside the world turned upside down, the
mountain's black shoulder hung inverted above them and the dizzy gulf of
sky was beneath. Var fought for footing with his balance gone, feeling
Neena reel against him until, summoning all his strength, he broke the
grip of the illusion and the world seemed to right itself. The mist
billowed again and Groz was out of sight, but they could hear him
exhorting his men to haste.
Neena's face was deadly pale and her lips trembled, but her urgent
whisper said, "Come on!"
Together they plunged into the curtain of darkness.
At Var's thought command Neena froze instantly. "Feel that!" he
muttered, and she, listening, sensed it too: the infinitesimal trickle
of currents behind what appeared to be a blank tunnel wall, a rising
potential that seemed to whisper
Ready ... ready....
The sun-globe floated behind them, casting light before them down the
featureless tunnel that sloped always toward the mountain's heart. Var
summoned it, and it drifted ahead, a dozen feet, a little more—
Between wall and wall a blinding spindle of flame sprang into being,
pulsed briefly with radiant energy that pained the eyes, and went out.
The immaterial globe of light danced on before them.
"Forward, before the charge builds up again!" said Var. A few feet
further on, they stumbled over a pile of charred bones. Someone else had
made it only this far. It was farther than the Watcher had gone into
these uncharted regions, and only the utmost alertness of mind and sense
had saved them from death in traps like this. But as yet the way was not
blocked....
Then they felt the mountain begin to tremble. A very faint and remote
vibration at first, then an increasingly potent shuddering of the floor
under their feet and the walls around them. Somewhere far below immense
energies were stirring for the first time in centuries. The power that
was in the Earth was rising; great wheels commenced to turn, the
mechanical servitors of the Ryzgas woke one by one and began to make
ready, while their masters yet slept, for the moment of rebirth that
might be near at hand.
From behind, up the tunnel, came a clear involuntary thought of dismay,
then a directed thought, echoing and ghostly in the confinement of the
dark burrow:
"
Stop!
—before you go too far!"
Var faced that way and thought coldly: "Only if you return and let us go
free."
In the black reaches of the shaft his will groped for and locked with
that of Groz, like the grip of two strong wrestlers. In that grip each
knew with finality that the other's stubbornness matched his own—that
neither would yield, though the mountain above them and the world
outside should crumble to ruin around them.
"Follow us, then!"
They plunged deeper into the mountain. And the shaking of the mountain
increased with every step, its vibrations became sound, and its sound
was like that of the terrible city which they had seen in the dream.
Through the slow-rolling thunder of the hidden machines seemed to echo
the death-cries of a billion slaves, the despair of all flesh and blood
before their monstrous and inhuman power.
Without warning, lights went on. Blinking in their glare, Var and Neena
saw that fifty paces before them the way opened out into a great rounded
room that was likewise ablaze with light. Cautiously they crept forward
to the threshold of that chamber at the mountain's heart.
Its roof was vaulted; its circular walls were lined with panels studded
with gleaming control buttons, levers, colored lights. As they watched
light flicked on and off in changing patterns, registering the
progressive changes in the vast complex of mechanisms for which this
must be the central control station. Behind those boards circuits opened
and closed in bewildering confusion; the two invaders felt the rapid
shifting of magnetic fields, the fury of electrons boiling in vacuum....
For long moments they forgot the pursuit, forgot everything in wonder at
this place whose remotest like they had never seen in the simplicity of
their machineless culture. In all the brilliant space there was no life.
They looked at one another, the same thought coming to both at once:
perhaps, after two thousand years, the masters were dead after all, and
only the machines remained? As if irresistibly drawn, they stepped over
the threshold.
There was a clang of metal like a signal. Halfway up the wall opposite,
above a narrow ramp that descended between the instrument panels, a
massive doorway swung wide, and in its opening a figure stood.
Var and Neena huddled frozenly, half expecting each instant to be their
last. And the Ryzga too stood motionless, looking down at them.
He was a man of middle height and stocky build, clad in a garment of
changing colors, of fabric delicate as dream-stuff. In his right hand,
with the care one uses with a weapon, he grasped a gleaming metal tube;
his other hand rested as for support against the frame of the doorway.
That, and his movements when he came slowly down the ramp toward them,
conveyed a queer suggestion of weariness or weakness, as if he were yet
not wholly roused from his two millenia of slumber. But the Ryzga's
manner and his mind radiated a consciousness of power, a pride and
assurance of self that smote them like a numbing blow.
With a new shock, Var realized that the Ryzga's thoughts were quite
open. They had a terse, disconnected quality that was strange and
unsettling, and in part they were couched in alien and unintelligible
symbols. But there was no block. Apparently the Ryzga felt no need to
close his mind in the presence of inferior creatures....
He paused with his back to the central control panel, and studied the
interlopers with the dispassionate gaze of a scientist examining a new,
but not novel, species of insect. His thoughts seemed to click, like
metal parts of a mechanism falling into places prepared for them. The
image occurred oddly to Var, to whom such a comparison would ordinarily
have been totally strange.
"Culture: late barbarism. Handwork of high quality—good. Physically
excellent stock...." There was a complicated and incomprehensible
schemata of numbers and abstract forms. "The time: two thousand
years—more progress might have been expected, if any survivors at all
initially postulated; but this will do. The pessimists were mistaken. We
can begin again." Then, startlingly super-imposed on the cool
progression of logical thought, came a wave of raw emotion, devastating
in its force. It was a lustful image of a world once more obedient,
crawling, laboring to do the Ryzgas' will—
toward the stars, the
stars!
The icy calculation resumed: "Immobilize these and the ones
indicated in the passage above. Then wake the rest...."
Var was staring in fascination at the Ryzga's face. It was a face formed
by the custom of unquestioned command; yet it was lined by a deeply
ingrained weariness, the signs of premature age—denied, overridden by
the driving will they had sensed a moment earlier. It was a sick man's
face.
The Ryzga's final thought clicked into place:
Decision!
He turned
toward the switchboard behind him, reaching with practised certainty for
one spot upon it.
Neena screamed.
Between the Ryzga and the control panel a nightmare shape reared up
seven feet tall, flapping black amorphous limbs and flashing red eyes
and white fangs. The Ryzga recoiled, and the weapon in his hand came up.
There was an instantaneous glare like heat lightning, and the monster
crumpled in on itself, twitched briefly and vanished.
But in that moment a light of inspiration had flashed upon Var, and it
remained. As the Ryzga stretched out his hand again, Var acted. The
Ryzga froze, teetering off balance and almost falling, as a numbing grip
closed down on all his motor nerves.
Holding that grip, Var strode across the floor and looked straight into
the Ryzga's frantic eyes. They glared back at him with such hatred and
such evil that for an instant he almost faltered. But the Ryzga's
efforts, as he strove to free himself from the neural hold, were as
misdirected and unavailing as those of a child who has not learned to
wrestle with the mind.
Var had guessed right. When Neena in her terror had flung a dream
monster into the Ryzga's way—a mere child's bogey out of a fairy
tale—the Ryzga had not recognized it as such, but had taken it for a
real being. Var laughed aloud, and with great care, as one communicates
with an infant, he projected his thoughts into the other's mind. "There
will be no new beginning for you in
our
world, Ryzga! In two thousand
years, we've learned some new things. Now at last I understand why you
built so many machines, such complicated arrangements of matter and
energy to do simple tasks—it was because you knew no other way."
Behind the hate-filled eyes the cold brain tried to reason still.
"Barbarians...? Our party was wrong after all. After us the machine
civilization could never rise again, because it was a fire that consumed
its fuel. After us
man
could not survive on the Earth, because the
conditions that made him great were gone. The survivors must be
something else—capacities undeveloped by our science—after us the end
of man, the beginning.... But those of us who chose to die were right."
The tide of hate and sick desire rose up to drown all coherence. The
Ryzga made a savage, wholly futile effort to lift the weapon in his
paralyzed hand. Then his eyes rolled upward, and abruptly he went limp
and fell in a heap, like a mechanical doll whose motive power has
failed.
Var felt Neena beside him, and drew her close. As she sobbed her relief,
he continued to look down absently at the dead man. When at last he
raised his head, he saw that the drama's end had had a further audience.
In the outer doorway, backed by his clansmen, stood Groz, gazing first
in stupefaction at the fallen Ryzga, then with something like awe at
Var.
Var eyed him for a long moment; then he smiled, and asked, "Well, Groz?
Is our feud finished, or does your ambition for a worthy son-in-law go
beyond the conqueror of the Ryzgas?"
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/2/8/3/32836//32836-h//32836-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is special about light in this story? | 32836_4ZJXFXNA_10 | [
"It is traded like a commodity",
"It is the only way the adventurers nowhere to go",
"It can be manipulated by the people",
"It is liquid-like in its composition"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which best describes the relationship between Russell and Dunbar? | 31355_N2HLEA08_1 | [
"They have similar goals but do not necessarily work well together",
"They both have respect for each other but are sick of each other's company",
"Neither of them likes the other, in a way that hinders group dynamics",
"The appreciate each other's insight when looking for solutions but don't like to talk about personal details"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which isn't a reason why Russell didn't tell Johnson and Alvar directly that he thought Dunbar was crazy? | 31355_N2HLEA08_2 | [
"All of their communication systems are connected",
"He had already given up on life",
"He might have been secretly curious about the stories",
"He wanted them to find out for themselves"
] | 2 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is the best representation of the connection between Old Dunbar and the rest of the crew? | 31355_N2HLEA08_3 | [
"He tagged along when they escaped their previous situation",
"They are all former members of the military on equal footing",
"He led the group out of their previous lives",
"He thinks he is in charge but does not call any of the shots in reality"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is not a reason Russell killed Dunbar? | 31355_N2HLEA08_4 | [
"The time in space was driving him nuts",
"He wanted it to be more quiet",
"He thought it would be the only way to go the right direction",
"He wanted his ration supply"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What most likely happened to Russell after the story ended? | 31355_N2HLEA08_5 | [
"His body would be preserved in a museum",
"He found somewhere to settle and managed to live out the rest of his life",
"He would die once he tried to land on the planet",
"He likely died floating in space"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these was not an impact of Russell's decision to kill Dunbar? | 31355_N2HLEA08_6 | [
"Russell would have to travel alone",
"He was able to pick the path to the correct sun",
"It became quieter in general",
"Arguments increased amongst the team"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which effect of Russell's decision to kill Dunbar was likely most surprising to Russell? | 31355_N2HLEA08_7 | [
"The fact that nobody agreed on which sun was the correct one",
"The decrease in chatter in the communication system",
"The way the Dunbar died without much drama",
"He sabotaged himself by ensuring his loneliness"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is the role of the pirate ship story that Dunbar tells? | 31355_N2HLEA08_8 | [
"It proves that he knows where he's going and he had the right choice all along",
"It is a fantastic story meant to keep the crew entertained while floating in space",
"It points to who will rescue his body when he arrives at the planet",
"It helps to clarify what is true for the reader when the aliens find his body"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
31,355 | 31355_N2HLEA08 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | To Each His Star | 1953.0 | Walton, Bryce | PS; Short stories; Science fiction | Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from Space Science Fiction May 1952. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.
TO EACH HIS STAR
by
BRYCE WALTON
"Nothing around those other suns but ashes and dried
blood," old Dunbar told the space-wrecked, desperate men.
"Only one way to go, where we can float down through the
clouds to Paradise. That's straight ahead to the sun with
the red rim around it."
But Dunbar's eyes were old and uncertain. How could they
believe in his choice when every star in this forsaken
section of space was surrounded by a beckoning red rim?
There was just blackness, frosty glimmering terrible blackness, going
out and out forever in all directions. Russell didn't think they could
remain sane in all this blackness much longer. Bitterly he thought of
how they would die—not knowing within maybe thousands of light years
where they were, or where they were going.
After the wreck, the four of them had floated a while, floated and
drifted together, four men in bulbous pressure suits like small
individual rockets, held together by an awful pressing need for each
other and by the "gravity-rope" beam.
Dunbar, the oldest of the four, an old space-buster with a face
wrinkled like a dried prune, burned by cosmic rays and the suns of
worlds so far away they were scarcely credible, had taken command.
Suddenly, Old Dunbar had known where they were. Suddenly, Dunbar knew
where they were going.
They could talk to one another through the etheric transmitters inside
their helmets. They could live ... if this was living ... a long time,
if only a man's brain would hold up, Russell thought. The suits were
complete units. 700 pounds each, all enclosing shelters, with
atmosphere pressure, temperature control, mobility in space, and
electric power. Each suit had its own power-plant, reprocessing
continuously the precious air breathed by the occupants, putting it
back into circulation again after enriching it. Packed with food
concentrates. Each suit a rocket, each human being part of a rocket,
and the special "life-gun" that went with each suit each blast of
which sent a man a few hundred thousand miles further on toward
wherever he was going.
Four men, thought Russell, held together by an invisible string of
gravity, plunging through a lost pocket of hell's dark where there had
never been any sound or life, with old Dunbar the first in line,
taking the lead because he was older and knew where he was and where
he was going. Maybe Johnson, second in line, and Alvar who was third,
knew too, but were afraid to admit it.
But Russell knew it and he'd admitted it from the first—that old
Dunbar was as crazy as a Jovian juke-bird.
A lot of time had rushed past into darkness. Russell had no idea now
how long the four of them had been plunging toward the red-rimmed sun
that never seemed to get any nearer. When the ultra-drive had gone
crazy the four of them had blanked out and nobody could say now how
long an interim that had been. Nobody knew what happened to a man who
suffered a space-time warping like that. When they had regained
consciousness, the ship was pretty banged up, and the meteor-repeller
shields cracked. A meteor ripped the ship down the center like an old
breakfast cannister.
How long ago that had been, Russell didn't know. All Russell knew was
that they were millions of light years from any place he had ever
heard about, where the galactic space lanterns had absolutely no
recognizable pattern. But Dunbar knew. And Russell was looking at
Dunbar's suit up ahead, watching it more and more intently, thinking
about how Dunbar looked inside that suit—and hating Dunbar more and
more for claiming he knew when he didn't, for his drooling
optimism—because he was taking them on into deeper darkness and
calling their destination Paradise.
Russell wanted to laugh, but the last time he'd given way to this
impulse, the results inside his helmet had been too unpleasant to
repeat.
Sometimes Russell thought of other things besides his growing hatred
of the old man. Sometimes he thought about the ship, lost back there
in the void, and he wondered if wrecked space ships were ever found.
Compared with the universe in which one of them drifted, a wrecked
ship was a lot smaller than a grain of sand on a nice warm beach back
on Earth, or one of those specks of silver dust that floated like
strange seeds down the night winds of Venus.
And a human was smaller still, thought Russell when he was not hating
Dunbar. Out here, a human being is the smallest thing of all. He
thought then of what Dunbar would say to such a thought, how Dunbar
would laugh that high piping squawking laugh of his and say that the
human being was bigger than the Universe itself.
Dunbar had a big answer for every little thing.
When the four of them had escaped from that prison colony on a
sizzling hot asteroid rock in the Ronlwhyn system, that wasn't enough
for Dunbar. Hell no—Dunbar had to start talking about a place they
could go where they'd never be apprehended, in a system no one else
had ever heard of, where they could live like gods on a green soft
world like the Earth had been a long time back.
And Dunbar had spouted endlessly about a world of treasure they would
find, if they would just follow old Dunbar. That's what all four of
them had been trying to find all their lives in the big cold grabbag
of eternity—a rich star, a rich far fertile star where no one else
had ever been, loaded with treasure that had no name, that no one had
ever heard of before. And was, because of that, the richest treasure
of all.
We all look alike out here in these big rocket pressure suits, Russell
thought. No one for God only knew how many of millions of light years
away could see or care. Still—we might have a chance to live, even
now, Russell thought—if it weren't for old crazy Dunbar.
They might have a chance if Alvar and Johnson weren't so damn lacking
in self-confidence as to put all their trust in that crazed old
rum-dum. Russell had known now for some time that they were going in
the wrong direction. No reason for knowing. Just a hunch. And Russell
was sure his hunch was right.
Russell said. "Look—look to your left and to your right and behind
us. Four suns. You guys see those other three suns all around you,
don't you?"
"Sure," someone said.
"Well, if you'll notice," Russell said, "the one on the left also now
has a red rim around it. Can't you guys see that?"
"Yeah, I see it," Alvar said.
"So now," Johnson said, "there's two suns with red rims around them."
"We're about in the middle of those four suns aren't we, Dunbar?"
Russell said.
"That's right, boys!" yelled old Dunbar in that sickeningly optimistic
voice. Like a hysterical old woman's. "Just about in the sweet dark
old middle."
"You're still sure it's the sun up ahead ... that's the only one with
life on it, Dunbar ... the only one we can live on?" Russell asked.
"That's right! That's right," Dunbar yelled. "That's the only one—and
it's a paradise. Not just a place to live, boys—but a place you'll
have trouble believing in because it's like a dream!"
"And none of these other three suns have worlds we could live on,
Dunbar?" Russell asked. Keep the old duck talking like this and maybe
Alvar and Johnson would see that he was cracked.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "You still say that, Dunbar?"
"No life, boys, nothing," Dunbar laughed. "Nothing on these other
worlds but ashes ... just ashes and iron and dried blood, dried a
million years or more."
"When in hell were you ever here?" Johnson said. "You say you were
here before. You never said when, or why or anything!"
"It was a long time back boys. Don't remember too well, but it was
when we had an old ship called the DOG STAR that I was here. A pirate
ship and I was second in command, and we came through this sector.
That was—hell, it musta' been fifty years ago. I been too many places
nobody's ever bothered to name or chart, to remember where it is, but
I been here. I remember those four suns all spotted to form a perfect
circle from this point, with us squarely in the middle. We explored
all these suns and the worlds that go round 'em. Trust me, boys, and
we'll reach the right one. And that one's just like Paradise."
"Paradise is it," Russell whispered hoarsely.
"Paradise and there we'll be like gods, like Mercuries with wings
flying on nights of sweet song. These other suns, don't let them
bother you. They're Jezebels of stars. All painted up in the darkness
and pretty and waiting and calling and lying! They make you think of
nice green worlds all running waters and dews and forests thick as
fleas on a wet dog. But it ain't there, boys. I know this place. I
been here, long time back."
Russell said tightly. "It'll take us a long time won't it? If it's got
air we can breath, and water we can drink and shade we can rest
in—that'll be paradise enough for us. But it'll take a long time
won't it? And what if it isn't there—what if after all the time we
spend hoping and getting there—there won't be nothing but ashes and
cracked clay?"
"I know we're going right," Dunbar said cheerfully. "I can tell. Like
I said—you can tell it because of the red rim around it."
"But the sun on our left, you can see—it's got a red rim too now,"
Russell said.
"Yeah, that's right," said Alvar. "Sometimes I see a red rim around
the one we're going for, sometimes a red rim around that one on the
left. Now, sometimes I'm not sure either of them's got a red rim. You
said that one had a red rim, Dunbar, and I wanted to believe it. So
now maybe we're all seeing a red rim that was never there."
Old Dunbar laughed. The sound brought blood hotly to Russell's face.
"We're heading to the right one, boys. Don't doubt me ... I been here.
We explored all these sun systems. And I remember it all. The second
planet from that red-rimmed sun. You come down through a soft
atmosphere, floating like in a dream. You see the green lakes coming
up through the clouds and the women dancing and the music playing. I
remember seeing a ship there that brought those women there, a long
long time before ever I got there. A land like heaven and women like
angels singing and dancing and laughing with red lips and arms white
as milk, and soft silky hair floating in the winds."
Russell was very sick of the old man's voice. He was at least glad he
didn't have to look at the old man now. His bald head, his skinny
bobbing neck, his simpering watery blue eyes. But he still had to
suffer that immutable babbling, that idiotic cheerfulness ... and
knowing all the time the old man was crazy, that he was leading them
wrong.
I'd break away, go it alone to the right sun, Russell thought—but I'd
never make it alone. A little while out here alone and I'd be nuttier
than old Dunbar will ever be, even if he keeps on getting nuttier all
the time.
Somewhere, sometime then ... Russell got the idea that the only way
was to get rid of Dunbar.
You mean to tell us there are people living by that red-rimmed sun,"
Russell said.
"Lost people ... lost ... who knows how long," Dunbar said, as the
four of them hurtled along. "You never know where you'll find people
on a world somewhere nobody's ever named or knows about. Places where
a lost ship's landed and never got up again, or wrecked itself so far
off the lanes they'll never be found except by accident for millions
of years. That's what this world is, boys. Must have been a ship load
of beautiful people, maybe actresses and people like that being hauled
to some outpost to entertain. They're like angels now, living in a
land all free from care. Every place you see green forests and fields
and blue lakes, and at nights there's three moons that come around the
sky in a thousand different colors. And it never gets cold ... it's
always spring, always spring, boys, and the music plays all night,
every night of a long long year...."
Russell suddenly shouted. "Keep quiet, Dunbar. Shut up will you?"
Johnson said. "Dunbar—how long'll it take us?"
"Six months to a year, I'd say," Dunbar yelled happily. "That is—of
our hereditary time."
"What?" croaked Alvar.
Johnson didn't say anything at all.
Russell screamed at Dunbar, then quieted down. He whispered. "Six
months to a year—out here—cooped up in these damn suits. You're
crazy as hell, Dunbar. Crazy ... crazy! Nobody could stand it. We'll
all be crazier than you are—"
"We'll make it, boys. Trust ole' Dunbar. What's a year when we know
we're getting to Paradise at the end of it? What's a year out here ...
it's paradise ain't it, compared with that prison hole we were rotting
in? We can make it. We have the food concentrates, and all the rest.
All we need's the will, boys, and we got that. The whole damn Universe
isn't big enough to kill the will of a human being, boys. I been over
a whole lot of it, and I know. In the old days—"
"The hell with the old days," screamed Russell.
"Now quiet down, Russ," Dunbar said in a kind of dreadful crooning
whisper. "You calm down now. You younger fellows—you don't look at
things the way we used to. Thing is, we got to go straight. People
trapped like this liable to start meandering. Liable to start losing
the old will-power."
He chuckled.
"Yeah," said Alvar. "Someone says maybe we ought to go left, and
someone says to go right, and someone else says to go in another
direction. And then someone says maybe they'd better go back the old
way. An' pretty soon something breaks, or the food runs out, and
you're a million million miles from someplace you don't care about any
more because you're dead. All frozen up in space ... preserved like a
piece of meat in a cold storage locker. And then maybe in a million
years or so some lousy insect man from Jupiter comes along and finds
you and takes you away to a museum...."
"Shut up!" Johnson yelled.
Dunbar laughed. "Boys, boys, don't get panicky. Keep your heads. Just
stick to old Dunbar and he'll see you through. I'm always lucky. Only
one way to go ... an' that's straight ahead to the sun with the
red-rim around it ... and then we tune in the gravity repellers, and
coast down, floating and singing down through the clouds to
paradise."
After that they traveled on for what seemed months to Russell, but it
couldn't have been over a day or two of the kind of time-sense he had
inherited from Earth.
Then he saw how the other two stars also were beginning to develop red
rims. He yelled this fact out to the others. And Alvar said. "Russ's
right. That sun to the right, and the one behind us ... now they ALL
have red rims around them. Dunbar—" A pause and no awareness of
motion.
Dunbar laughed. "Sure, they all maybe have a touch of red, but it
isn't the same, boys. I can tell the difference. Trust me—"
Russell half choked on his words. "You old goat! With those old eyes
of yours, you couldn't see your way into a fire!"
"Don't get panicky now. Keep your heads. In another year, we'll be
there—"
"God, you gotta' be sure," Alvar said. "I don't mind dyin' out here.
But after a year of this, and then to get to a world that was only
ashes, and not able to go any further—"
"I always come through, boys. I'm lucky. Angel women will take us to
their houses on the edges of cool lakes, little houses that sit there
in the sun like fancy jewels. And we'll walk under colored fountains,
pretty colored fountains just splashing and splashing like pretty rain
on our hungry hides. That's worth waiting for."
Russell did it before he hardly realized he was killing the old man.
It was something he had had to do for a long time and that made it
easy. There was a flash of burning oxygen from inside the suit of
Dunbar. If he'd aimed right, Russell knew the fire-bullet should have
pierced Dunbar's back. Now the fire was gone, extinguished
automatically by units inside the suit. The suit was still inflated,
self-sealing. Nothing appeared to have changed. The four of them
hurtling on together, but inside that first suit up there on the front
of the gravity rope, Dunbar was dead.
He was dead and his mouth was shut for good.
Dunbar's last faint cry from inside his suit still rang in Russell's
ears, and he knew Alvar and Johnson had heard it too. Alvar and
Johnson both called Dunbar's name a few times. There was no answer.
"Russ—you shouldn't have done that," Johnson whispered. "You
shouldn't have done that to the old man!"
"No," Alvar said, so low he could barely be heard. "You shouldn't have
done it."
"I did it for the three of us," Russell said. "It was either him or us.
Lies ... lies that was all he had left in his crazy head. Paradise ...
don't tell me you guys don't see the red rims around all four suns, all
four suns all around us. Don't tell me you guys didn't know he was batty,
that you really believed all that stuff he was spouting all the time!"
"Maybe he was lying, maybe not," Johnson said. "Now he's dead anyway."
"Maybe he was wrong, crazy, full of lies," Alvar said. "But now he's
dead."
"How could he see any difference in those four stars?" Russell said,
louder.
"He thought he was right," Alvar said. "He wanted to take us to
paradise. He was happy, nothing could stop the old man—but he's dead
now."
He sighed.
"He was taking us wrong ... wrong!" Russell screamed. "Angels—music
all night—houses like jewels—and women like angels—"
"
Shhhh
," said Alvar. It was quiet. How could it be so quiet, Russell
thought? And up ahead the old man's pressure suit with a corpse inside
went on ahead, leading the other three at the front of the
gravity-rope.
"Maybe he was wrong," Alvar said. "But now do we know which way is
right?"
Sometime later, Johnson said, "We got to decide now. Let's forget the
old man. Let's forget him and all that's gone and let's start now and
decide what to do."
And Alvar said, "Guess he was crazy all right, and I guess we trusted
him because we didn't have the strength to make up our own minds. Why
does a crazy man's laugh sound so good when you're desperate and don't
know what to do?"
"I always had a feeling we were going wrong," Johnson said. "Anyway,
it's forgotten, Russ. It's swallowed up in the darkness all around.
It's never been."
Russell said, "I've had a hunch all along that maybe the old man was
here before, and that he was right about there being a star here with
a world we can live on. But I've known we was heading wrong. I've had
a hunch all along that the right star was the one to the left."
"I don't know," Johnson sighed. "I been feeling partial toward that
one on the right. What about you, Alvar?"
"I always thought we were going straight in the opposite direction
from what we should, I guess. I always wanted to turn around and go
back. It won't make over maybe a month's difference. And what does a
month matter anyway out here—hell there never was any time out here
until we came along. We make our own time here, and a month don't
matter to me."
Sweat ran down Russell's face. His voice trembled. "No—that's wrong.
You're both wrong." He could see himself going it alone. Going crazy
because he was alone. He'd have broken away, gone his own direction,
long ago but for that fear.
"How can we tell which of us is right?" Alvar said. "It's like
everything was changing all the time out here. Sometimes I'd swear
none of those suns had red rims, and at other times—like the old man
said, they're all pretty and lying and saying nothing, just changing
all the time. Jezebel stars, the old man said."
"I know I'm right," Russell pleaded. "My hunches always been right.
My hunch got us out of that prison didn't it? Listen—I tell you it's
that star to the left—"
"The one to the right," said Johnson.
"We been going away from the right one all the time," said Alvar.
"We got to stay together," said Russell. "Nobody could spend a year
out here ... alone...."
"Ah ... in another month or so we'd be lousy company anyway," Alvar
said. "Maybe a guy could get to the point where he'd sleep most of the
time ... just wake up enough times to give himself another boost with
the old life-gun."
"We got to face it," Johnson said finally. "We three don't go on
together any more."
"That's it," said Alvar. "There's three suns that look like they might
be right seeing as how we all agree the old man was wrong. But we
believe there is one we can live by, because we all seem to agree that
the old man might have been right about that. If we stick together,
the chance is three to one against us. But if each of us makes for one
star, one of us has a chance to live. Maybe not in paradise like the
old man said, but a place where we can live. And maybe there'll be
intelligent life, maybe even a ship, and whoever gets the right star
can come and help the other two...."
"No ... God no...." Russell whispered over and over. "None of us can
ever make it alone...."
Alvar said, "We each take the star he likes best. I'll go back the
other way. Russ, you take the left. And you, Johnson, go to the
right."
Johnson started to laugh. Russell was yelling wildly at them, and
above his own yelling he could hear Johnson's rising laughter. "Every
guy's got a star of his own," Johnson said when he stopped laughing.
"And we got ours. A nice red-rimmed sun for each of us to call his
very own."
"Okay," Alvar said. "We cut off the gravity rope, and each to his own
sun."
Now Russell wasn't saying anything.
"And the old man," Alvar said, "can keep right on going toward what he
thought was right. And he'll keep on going. Course he won't be able to
give himself another boost with the life-gun, but he'll keep going.
Someday he'll get to that red-rimmed star of his. Out here in space,
once you're going, you never stop ... and I guess there isn't any
other body to pull him off his course. And what will time matter to
old Dunbar? Even less than to us, I guess. He's dead and he won't
care."
"Ready," Johnson said. "I'll cut off the gravity rope."
"I'm ready," Alvar said. "To go back toward whatever it was I started
from."
"Ready, Russ?"
Russell couldn't say anything. He stared at the endless void which now
he would share with no one. Not even crazy old Dunbar.
"All right," Johnson said. "Good-bye."
Russell felt the release, felt the sudden inexplicable isolation and
aloneness even before Alvar and Johnson used their life-guns and shot
out of sight, Johnson toward the left and Alvar back toward that other
red-rimmed sun behind them.
And old Dunbar shooting right on ahead. And all three of them
dwindling and dwindling and blinking out like little lights.
Fading, he could hear their voices. "Each to his own star," Johnson
said. "On a bee line."
"On a bee line," Alvar said.
Russell used his own life-gun and in a little while he didn't hear
Alvar or Johnson's voices, nor could he see them. They were thousands
of miles away, and going further all the time.
Russell's head fell forward against the front of his helmet, and he
closed his eyes. "Maybe," he thought, "I shouldn't have killed the old
man. Maybe one sun's as good as another...."
Then he raised his body and looked out into the year of blackness that
waited for him, stretching away to the red-rimmed sun. Even if he were
right—he was sure now he'd never make it alone.
The body inside the pressure suit drifted into a low-level orbit
around the second planet from the sun of its choice, and drifted there
a long time. A strato-cruiser detected it by chance because of the
strong concentration of radio-activity that came from it.
They took the body down to one of the small, quiet towns on the edge
of one of the many blue lakes where the domed houses were like bright
joyful jewels. They got the leathery, well-preserved body from the
pressure suit.
"An old man," one of them mused. "A very old man. From one of the lost
sectors. I wonder how and why he came so very far from his home?"
"Wrecked a ship out there, probably," one of the others said. "But he
managed to get this far. It looks as though a small meteor fragment
pierced his body. Here. You see?"
"Yes," another of them said. "But what amazes me is that this old man
picked this planet out of all the others. The only one in this entire
sector that would sustain life."
"Maybe he was just a very lucky old man. Yes ... a man who attains
such an age was usually lucky. Or at least that is what they say about
the lost sectors."
"Maybe he knew the way here. Maybe he was here before—sometime."
The other shook his head. "I don't think so. They say some humans from
that far sector did land here—but that's probably only a myth. And if
they did, it was well over a thousand years ago."
Another said. "He has a fine face, this old man. A noble face. Whoever
he is ... wherever he came from, he died bravely and he knew the way,
though he never reached this haven of the lost alive."
"Nor is it irony that he reached here dead," said the Lake Chieftain.
He had been listening and he stepped forward and raised his arm. "He
was old. It is obvious that he fought bravely, that he had great
courage, and that he knew the way. He will be given a burial suitable
to his stature, and he will rest here among the brave.
"Let the women dance and the music play for this old man. Let the
trumpets speak, and the rockets fly up. And let flowers be strewn over
the path above which the women will carry him to rest."
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/3/1/3/5/31355//31355-h//31355-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is not true about Dunbar? | 31355_N2HLEA08_9 | [
"He never had a chance of making it to a safe planet",
"He was thankful to interact with whoever was around him",
"He has committed some number of crimes",
"He dreams big and always an adventure"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0012",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0017",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which best describes the narrator's attitude towards his work? | 29168_3XCXM754_1 | [
"He is frustrated that nobody ever recognizes his progress",
"He wishes he were in a different country interacting with his own people",
"He is proud to be contributing to broad scientific questions",
"He is disappointed he has to work inside a lab but enjoys research"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is the best description of why the narrator strikes the spaceship? | 29168_3XCXM754_2 | [
"He is convinced there's nothing there and his hand will pass right through",
"He wants to test what it's made out of to see if it would make a good model for his own project",
"He wants to show he means business and call to their attention",
"He is upset that the people ran away and wants to harm something they care about"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | What is Houlihan's relationship with the little people? | 29168_3XCXM754_3 | [
"He has some kind of historical relationship with them but it's not clear what",
"He has seen them once before and is suspicious of what they're taking from the area",
"He is a little person himself and is glad to finally find his own people",
"He believes in all fantastical creatures so he is an honorary member of their group"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which best describes Houlihan's perception of America? | 29168_3XCXM754_4 | [
"He is proud to have grown up there and work is a prestigious lab ",
"He is suspicious of anyone who is not Irish but is willing to put up with Americans",
"He hates the country but is willing to work for their government in secret",
"He is thankful to be on a team working towards scientific progress, wherever it is"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why did Houlihan consider his work to the advantage of humankind? | 29168_3XCXM754_5 | [
"He has furthered the goals of the little people, and not just the humans, making Earth a better place",
"He thought taking advantage of the little people's project to further his own goals was in line with human ideals",
"He thinks that sabatoging the little people will be better for the goals of humans",
"He thought human goals of scientific advancement could not be completed without his work"
] | 4 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which best describes the relationship between Keech and Houlihan? | 29168_3XCXM754_6 | [
"Keech doesn't prefer interacting with scientists but he knows he can trust Houlihan",
"Houlihan is resentful for being taken away from time in his own lab but feels indebted to Keech",
"They have a tenuously constructed relationship based on trust necessitated by the situation",
"There is a lot of mutual trust and respect between scientists"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which of these is most true about why the little people are building what they are where they are? | 29168_3XCXM754_7 | [
"They were kicked out of their own home for trying to leave the planet and had to find a new place to set up shop",
"It was the only think they knew would help them gain access to knowledge necessary for the project",
"They wanted to work close enough to the lab to be able to steal supplies",
"They wanted to be far away from people who believed in them so that their plans would not be discovered"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0005",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Why of these is not a reason Houlihan agreed to help the little people? | 29168_3XCXM754_8 | [
"He saw it as an opportunity to clear his head about his own work",
"He figured their ship could act as a test case for his work",
"He felt a kinship with them because of his family's history",
"He figured he was the only one with knowledge to help them solve their problem"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
29,168 | 29168_3XCXM754 | 23 | 1,016 | Gutenberg | Houlihan's Equation | 1956.0 | Sheldon, Walter J. | Science fiction; PS; Short stories | Every writer must seek his own Flowery Kingdom in imagination's wide
demesne, and if that search can begin and end on Earth his problem has
been greatly simplified. In post-war Japan Walt Sheldon has found not only
serenity, but complete freedom to write undisturbed about the things he
treasures most. A one-time Air Force officer, he has turned to fantasy in
his lighter moments, to bring us such brightly sparkling little gems as this.
houlihan's
equation
by ... Walt Sheldon
The tiny spaceship had been built for a journey to a star. But its
small, mischievous pilots had a rendezvous with destiny—on Earth.
I must
admit that at first I
wasn't sure I was hearing those
noises. It was in a park near the
nuclear propulsion center—a cool,
green spot, with the leaves all telling
each other to hush, be quiet,
and the soft breeze stirring them up
again. I had known precisely such
a secluded little green sanctuary just
over the hill from Mr. Riordan's
farm when I was a boy.
Now it was a place I came to
when I had a problem to thrash out.
That morning I had been trying to
work out an equation to give the
coefficient of discharge for the matter
in combustion. You may call it
gas, if you wish, for we treated it
like gas at the center for convenience—as
it came from the rocket
tubes in our engine.
Without this coefficient to give
us control, we would have lacked a
workable equation when we set
about putting the first moon rocket
around those extraordinary engines
of ours, which were still in the undeveloped
blueprint stage.
I see I shall have to explain this,
although I had hoped to get right
along with my story. When you
start from scratch, matter discharged
from any orifice has a velocity directly
proportional to the square
root of the pressure-head driving it.
But when you actually put things
together, contractions or expansions
in the gas, surface roughness
and other factors make the velocity
a bit smaller.
At the terrible discharge speed
of nuclear explosion—which is
what the drive amounts to despite
the fact that it is simply water in
which nuclear salts have been previously
dissolved—this small factor
makes quite a difference. I had
to figure everything into it—diameter
of the nozzle, sharpness of the
edge, the velocity of approach to the
point of discharge, atomic weight
and structure— Oh, there is so
much of this that if you're not a
nuclear engineer yourself it's certain
to weary you.
Perhaps you had better take my
word for it that without this equation—correctly
stated, mind you—mankind
would be well advised not
to make a first trip to the moon.
And all this talk of coefficients and
equations sits strangely, you might
say, upon the tongue of a man
named Kevin Francis Houlihan.
But I am, after all, a scientist. If I
had not been a specialist in my field
I would hardly have found myself
engaged in vital research at the
center.
Anyway, I heard these little
noises in the park. They sounded
like small working sounds, blending
in eerily mysterious fashion with a
chorus of small voices. I thought at
first it might be children at play,
but then at the time I was a bit
absent-minded. I tiptoed to the edge
of the trees, not wanting to deprive
any small scalawags of their pleasure,
and peered out between the
branches. And what do you suppose
I saw? Not children, but a
group of little people, hard at work.
There was a leader, an older one
with a crank face. He was beating
the air with his arms and piping:
"Over here, now! All right, bring
those electrical connections over
here—and see you're not slow as
treacle about it!"
There were perhaps fifty of the
little people. I was more than startled
by it, too. I had not seen little
people in—oh, close to thirty years.
I had seen them first as a boy of
eight, and then, very briefly again,
on my tenth birthday. And I had
become convinced they could
never
be seen here in America. I had
never seen them so busy, either.
They were building something in
the middle of the glade. It was long
and shiny and upright and a little
over five feet in height.
"Come along now, people!" said
this crotchety one, looking straight
at me. "Stop starin' and get to
work! You'll not be needin' to
mind that man standin' there! You
know he can't see nor hear us!"
Oh, it was good to hear the rich
old tongue again. I smiled, and the
foreman of the leprechauns—if
that's what he was—saw me smile
and became stiff and alert for a moment,
as though suspecting that perhaps
I actually could see him. Then
he shrugged and turned away, clearly
deeming such a thing impossible.
I said, "Just a minute, friend,
and I'll beg your pardon. It so happens
I
can
see you."
He whirled to face me again,
staring open-mouthed. Then he
said, "What? What's that, now?"
"I can see you," I said.
"Ohhh!" he said and put his
palms to his cheekbones. "Saints be
with us! He's a believer! Run everybody—run
for your lives!"
And they all began running, in
as many directions as there were
little souls. They began to scurry
behind the trees and bushes, and a
sloping embankment nearby.
"No, wait!" I said. "Don't go
away! I'll not be hurting you!"
They continued to scurry.
I knew what it was they feared.
"I don't intend catching one of
you!" I said. "Come back, you daft
little creatures!"
But the glade was silent, and they
had all disappeared. They thought I
wanted their crock of gold, of
course. I'd be entitled to it if I could
catch one and keep him. Or so the
legends affirmed, though I've wondered
often about the truth of them.
But I was after no gold. I only wanted
to hear the music of an Irish
tongue. I was lonely here in America,
even if I had latched on to a fine
job of work for almost shamefully
generous pay. You see, in a place as
full of science as the nuclear propulsion
center there is not much
time for the old things. I very much
wanted to talk to the little people.
I walked over to the center of
the glade where the curious shiny
object was standing. It was as
smooth as glass and shaped like a
huge cigar. There were a pair of
triangular fins down at the bottom,
and stubby wings amidships. Of
course it was a spaceship, or a
miniature replica of one. I looked
at it more closely. Everything seemed
almost miraculously complete
and workable.
I shook my head in wonder, then
stepped back from the spaceship
and looked about the glade. I knew
they were all hiding nearby, watching
me apprehensively. I lifted my
head to them.
"Listen to me now, little people!"
I called out. "My name's
Houlihan of the Roscommon Houlihans.
I am descended from King
Niall himself—or so at least my
father used to say! Come on out
now, and pass the time o' day!"
Then I waited, but they didn't
answer. The little people always
had been shy. Yet without reaching
a decision in so many words I knew
suddenly that I
had
to talk to them.
I'd come to the glen to work out a
knotty problem, and I was up
against a blank wall. Simply because
I was so lonely that my mind had
become clogged.
I knew that if I could just once
hear the old tongue again, and talk
about the old things, I might be able
to think the problem through to a
satisfactory conclusion.
So I stepped back to the tiny
spaceship, and this time I struck it
a resounding blow with my fist.
"Hear me now, little people! If you
don't show yourselves and come out
and talk to me, I'll wreck this spaceship
from stem to stern!"
I heard only the leaves rustling
softly.
"Do you understand? I'll give
you until I count three to make an
appearance! One!"
The glade remained deathly silent.
"Two!"
I thought I heard a stirring somewhere,
as if a small, brittle twig had
snapped in the underbrush.
"
Three!
"
And with that the little people
suddenly appeared.
The leader—he seemed more
wizened and bent than before—approached
me slowly and warily as I
stood there. The others all followed
at a safe distance. I smiled to reassure
them and then waved my arm
in a friendly gesture of greeting.
"Good morning," I said.
"Good morning," the foreman
said with some caution. "My name
is Keech."
"And mine's Houlihan, as I've
told you. Are you convinced now
that I have no intention of doing
you any injury?"
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
drawing a kind of peppered dignity
up about himself, "in such matters
I am never fully convinced. After
living for many centuries I am all
too acutely aware of the perversity
of human nature."
"Yes," I said. "Well, as you will
quickly see, all I want to do is
talk." I nodded as I spoke, and sat
down cross-legged upon the grass.
"Any Irishman wants to talk, Mr.
Houlihan."
"And often that's
all
he wants,"
I said. "Sit down with me now, and
stop staring as if I were a snake
returned to the Island."
He shook his head and remained
standing. "Have your say, Mr.
Houlihan. And afterward we'll appreciate
it if you'll go away and
leave us to our work."
"Well, now, your work," I said,
and glanced at the spaceship.
"That's exactly what's got me curious."
The others had edged in a bit
now and were standing in a circle,
intently staring at me. I took out my
pipe. "Why," I asked, "would a
group of little people be building a
spaceship here in America—out in
this lonely place?"
Keech stared back without much
expression, and said, "I've been
wondering how you guessed it was
a spaceship. I was surprised enough
when you told me you could see us
but not overwhelmingly so. I've run
into believers before who could see
the little people. It happens every
so often, though not as frequently
as it did a century ago. But knowing
a spaceship at first glance! Well, I
must confess that
does
astonish
me."
"And why wouldn't I know a
spaceship when I see one?" I said.
"It just so happens I'm a doctor of
science."
"A doctor of science, now," said
Keech.
"Invited by the American government
to work on the first moon
rocket here at the nuclear propulsion
center. Since it's no secret I
can advise you of it."
"A scientist, is it," said Keech.
"Well, now, that's very interesting."
"I'll make no apologies for it," I
said.
"Oh, there's no need for apology,"
said Keech. "Though in truth
we prefer poets to scientists. But it
has just now crossed my mind, Mr.
Houlihan that you, being a scientist,
might be of help to us."
"How?" I asked.
"Well, I might try starting at the
beginning," he replied.
"You might," I said. "A man
usually does."
Keech took out his own pipe—a
clay dudeen—and looked hopeful.
I gave him a pinch of tobacco from
my pouch. "Well, now," he said,
"first of all you're no doubt surprised
to find us here in America."
"I am surprised from time to
time to find myself here," I said.
"But continue."
"We had to come here," said
Keech, "to learn how to make a
spaceship."
"A spaceship, now," I said, unconsciously
adopting some of the
old manner.
"Leprechauns are not really mechanically
inclined," said Keech.
"Their major passions are music
and laughter and mischief, as anyone
knows."
"Myself included," I agreed.
"Then why do you need a spaceship?"
"Well, if I may use an old expression,
we've had a feelin' lately
that we're not long for this world.
Or let me put it this way. We feel
the world isn't long for itself."
I scratched my cheek. "How
would a man unravel a statement
such as that?"
"It's very simple. With all the
super weapons you mortals have
developed, there's the distinct possibility
you might be blowin' us all
up in the process of destroying
yourselves."
"There
is
that possibility," I said.
"Well, then, as I say," said
Keech, "the little people have decided
to leave the planet in a spaceship.
Which we're buildin' here and
now. We've spied upon you and
learned how to do it. Well—almost
how to do it. We haven't learned
yet how to control the power—"
"Hold on, now," I said. "Leaving
the planet, you say. And where
would you be going?"
"There's another committee
working on that. 'Tis not our concern.
I was inclined to suggest the
constellation Orion, which sounds
as though it has a good Irish name,
but I was hooted down. Be that as it
may, my own job was to go into
your nuclear center, learn how to
make the ship, and proceed with its
construction. Naturally, we didn't
understand all of your high-flyin'
science, but some of our people are
pretty clever at gettin' up replicas
of things."
"You mean you've been spying
on us at the center all this time? Do
you know, we often had the feeling
we were being watched, but we
thought it was by the Russians.
There's one thing which puzzles
me, though. If you've been constantly
around us—and I'm still
able to see the little people—why
did I never see you before?"
"It may be we never crossed your
path. It may be you can only see us
when you're thinkin' of us, and of
course truly believin' in us. I don't
know—'tis a thing of the mind, and
not important at the moment.
What's important is for us to get
our first ship to workin' properly
and then we'll be on our way."
"You're determined to go."
"Truly we are, Mr. Houlihan.
Now—to business. Just during
these last few minutes a certain matter
has crossed my mind. That's
why I'm wastin' all this time with
you, sir. You say you are a scientist."
"A nuclear engineer."
"Well, then, it may be that you
can help us—now that you know
we're here."
"Help you?"
"The power control, Mr. Houlihan.
As I understand it, 'tis necessary
to know at any instant exactly
how much thrust is bein' delivered
through the little holes in back.
And on paper it looks simple
enough—the square of somethin' or
other. I've got the figures jotted in
a book when I need 'em. But when
you get to doin' it it doesn't come
out exactly as it does on paper."
"You're referring to the necessity
for a coefficient of discharge."
"Whatever it might be named,"
said Keech, shrugging. "'Tis the
one thing we lack. I suppose eventually
you people will be gettin'
around to it. But meanwhile we
need it right now, if we're to make
our ship move."
"And you want me to help you
with this?"
"That is exactly what crossed my
mind."
I nodded and looked grave and
kneaded my chin for a moment softly.
"Well, now, Keech," I said
finally, "why should I help you?"
"Ha!" said Keech, grinning, but
not with humor, "the avarice of
humans! I knew it! Well, Mr. Houlihan,
I'll give you reason enough.
The pot o' gold, Mr. Houlihan!"
"The one at the end of the rainbow?"
"It's not at the end of the rainbow.
That's a grandmother's tale.
Nor is it actually in an earthen
crock. But there's gold, all right,
enough to make you rich for the
rest of your life. And I'll make you
a proposition."
"Go ahead."
"We'll not be needin' gold where
we're goin'. It's yours if you show
us how to make our ship work."
"Well, now, that's quite an
offer," I said. Keech had the goodness
to be quiet while I sat and
thought for a while. My pipe had
gone out and I lit it again. I finally
said, "Let's have a look at your
ship's drive and see what we can
see."
"You accept the proposition
then?"
"Let's have a look," I said, and
that was all.
Well, we had a look, and then
several looks, and before the morning
was out we had half the spaceship
apart, and were deep in argument
about the whole project.
It was a most fascinating session.
I had often wished for a true working
model at the center, but no allowance
had been inserted in the
budget for it. Keech brought me
paper and pencil and I talked with
the aid of diagrams, as engineers
are wont to do. Although the pencils
were small and I had to hold
them between thumb and forefinger,
as you would a needle, I was
able to make many sensible observations
and even a few innovations.
I came back again the next day—and
every day for the following
two weeks. It rained several times,
but Keech and his people made a
canopy of boughs and leaves and I
was comfortable enough. Every once
in a while someone from the town
or the center itself would pass by,
and stop to watch me. But of course
they wouldn't see the leprechauns
or anything the leprechauns had
made, not being believers.
I would halt work, pass the time
of day, and then, in subtle fashion,
send the intruder on his way. Keech
and the little people just stood by
and grinned all the while.
At the end of sixteen days I had
the entire problem all but whipped.
It is not difficult to understand why.
The working model and the fact
that the small people with their
quick eyes and clever fingers could
spot all sorts of minute shortcomings
was a great help. And I was
hearing the old tongue and talking
of the old things every day, and
truly that went far to take the clutter
out of my mind. I was no longer
so lonely that I couldn't think properly.
On the sixteenth day I covered a
piece of paper with tiny mathematical
symbols and handed it to Keech.
"Here is your equation," I said. "It
will enable you to know your thrust
at any given moment, under any
circumstances, in or out of gravity,
and under all conditions of friction
and combustion."
"Thank you, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech. All his people had gathered
in a loose circle, as though attending
a rite. They were all looking at
me quietly.
"Mr. Houlihan," said Keech,
"you will not be forgotten by the
leprechauns. If we ever meet again,
upon another world perchance,
you'll find our friendship always
eager and ready."
"Thank you," I said.
"And now, Mr. Houlihan," said
Keech, "I'll see that a quantity of
gold is delivered to your rooms tonight,
and so keep my part of the
bargain."
"I'll not be needing the gold," I
said.
Keech's eyebrows popped upward.
"What's this now?"
"I'll not be needing it," I repeated.
"I don't feel it would be
right to take it for a service of this
sort."
"Well," said Keech in surprise,
and in some awe, too, "well, now,
musha Lord help us! 'Tis the first
time I ever heard such a speech
from a mortal." He turned to his
people. "We'll have three cheers
now, do you hear, for Mr. Houlihan—friend
of the little people as
long as he shall live!"
And they cheered. And little tears
crept into the corners of some of
their turned-up eyes.
We shook hands, all of us, and I
left.
I walked through the park, and
back to the nuclear propulsion center.
It was another cool, green morning
with the leaves making only
soft noises as the breezes came
along. It smelled exactly like a
wood I had known in Roscommon.
And I lit my pipe and smoked it
slowly and chuckled to myself at
how I had gotten the best of the
little people. Surely it was not every
mortal who could accomplish that. I
had given them the wrong equation,
of course. They would never get
their spaceship to work now, and
later, if they tried to spy out the
right information I would take special
measures to prevent it, for I had
the advantage of being able to see
them.
As for our own rocket ship, it
should be well on its way by next
St. Patrick's Day. For I had indeed
determined the true coefficient of
discharge, which I never could have
done so quickly without those sessions
in the glade with Keech and
his working model.
It would go down in scientific
literature now, I suppose, as Houlihan's
Equation, and that was honor
and glory enough for me. I could
do without Keech's pot of gold,
though it would have been pleasant
to be truly rich for a change.
There was no sense in cheating
him out of the gold to boot, for
leprechauns are most clever in matters
of this sort and he would have
had it back soon enough—or else
made it a burden in some way.
Indeed, I had done a piece of
work greatly to my advantage, and
also to the advantage of humankind,
and when a man can do the first and
include the second as a fortunate byproduct
it is a most happy accident.
For if I had shown the little people
how to make a spaceship they
would have left our world. And
this world, as long as it lasts—what
would it be in that event? I ask you
now, wouldn't we be even
more
likely to blow ourselves to Kingdom
Come without the little people here
for us to believe in every now and
then?
Transcriber's Note:
This etext was produced from
Fantastic Universe
September 1955.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.
copyright on this publication was renewed. Minor spelling and
typographical errors have been corrected without note.
| http://aleph.gutenberg.org/2/9/1/6/29168//29168-h//29168-h.htm | This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you’ll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Please refer to https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html for the detailed license. | Which best describes the role of history and faith in this story? | 29168_3XCXM754_9 | [
"It is both family history and faith in the truth of the little people that lets Houlihan interact with them",
"It is with knowlege of family history and some faith that Houlihan is able to decieve the little people into trusting him",
"It is Houlihan's faith and belief in the existence of fantastical creatures that lets him see the little people",
"Houlihan has heard about the little people in reading up on family history and this is why he can see him"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0021",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0005",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0015",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0004",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is the significance of Jimmy Savile to the article? | 99903_KV62CBNS_1 | [
"To introduce the idea of the importance of questioning friends of people under investigation",
"To introduce discussion of documentaries' influence on public perception of criminals",
"To introduce discussion of murderers and other criminals",
"To introduce the idea that people think they can tell certain things from looking at someone"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which is the least likely thing computers could pick up on from a photo? | 99903_KV62CBNS_2 | [
"The impact of socioeconomic status on a person's character",
"An underlying capability of committing crime",
"The effect of wealth on someone's life",
"How social a person is likely to be"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which is not true about our judgements of people from photos, according to the article? | 99903_KV62CBNS_3 | [
"Our judgements are easily manipulated by small, hardly noticeable changes in photos",
"We are able to make objective decisions about people, keeping our opinions of their facial structure separate from the facts",
"We judge people in a way that compares them to people we've seen before that we know more about",
"We are all influenced by underlying bias when we see photos of other people"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0028",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which is the best characterization of the overgeneralization hypotheses? | 99903_KV62CBNS_4 | [
"People are more likely to find others to be friendly based on their photos if they are surrounded by friendly people themselves",
"Computers are more likely to draw correct conclusions about people if they have larger pools of photos to draw from",
"We are likely to assume more photos are doctored than the number that actually are",
"We are likely to attribute things to people based on people close to us who may look similar"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0028",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which of these is most true about physiognomy? | 99903_KV62CBNS_5 | [
"If this were not an area of study, people would not be drawing false conclusions about people on trial",
"It has helped to put a number of important criminals behind bars",
"It is a brand new area of study that focuses on the application of machine learning to see how computers can help",
"People have been interested in this area for centuries but only recently applied technology to it"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is the biggest effect when criminals are noted as having similar facial features to other wrongdoers? | 99903_KV62CBNS_6 | [
"These sets of criminals are often shown to have similar socioeconomic backgrounds",
"This occurs when people are making judgements but not computers",
"This perpetuates the belief in the area of study that should not be held up",
"These coincidences are held under scrutiny and often disproved"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which would the author think is most true? | 99903_KV62CBNS_7 | [
"We post pictures of ourselves online that we think are attractive to gain approval from specific people whose eyes we want to catch",
"Regular people can use their social media accounts to help locate bad people before crimes are committed, because people are better at this than computers",
"People know their photos are being judged by others when they post them so they critically judge them themselves first",
"The application of machine learning in the study of social media photos could make it easier to find criminals before they commit cimes"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which of these is the most valid critique of the Shanghai study? | 99903_KV62CBNS_8 | [
"This type of task is good at identifying petty criminals but not more dangerous ones like murderers",
"If you only study men in these examples we cannot know how to locate females who may be a danger to those around them",
"They did not study enough types of facial expressions ",
"Very different conclusions can be drawn from different images of the same person"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,903 | 99903_KV62CBNS | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Face value | 2017.0 | Rhodri Marsden | Magazine article | Face value
When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment.
"He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual evidence to support the claim.
We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive. But the idea that someone's features betray their character is something rooted deep within us; it's the reason why certain photos perform well on dating apps, or why trustworthy-looking politicians might rack up votes. But how wrong are our hunches of perceived criminality?
A recent paper, published by Xiaolin Wu and Xi Zhang of Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, claims to be the first to use machine learning and neural networks to attempt a fully automated inference of criminality from facial images, removing prejudice from the equation and testing the validity of our gut feelings. "What facial features influence the average Joe's impulsive and yet consensual judgments on social attributes?" they ask. Through a study of 1,856 images ("controlled for race, gender, age and facial expression") they claim to have established the validity of "automated, face-induced inference on criminality, despite the historical controversy surrounding this line of enquiry."
In other words, they believe that they've found a relationship between looking like a criminal and actually being one.
It's a claim that's been made many times over the years. Physiognomy, the 'science' of judging people by their appearance, was first theorised by the ancient Greeks in around the 5th century BC. Aristotle's pronouncement that "it is possible to infer character from features" led to a number of works relating to 'Physiognomica', a word derived from
physis
(nature),
nomos
(law) and (or)
gnomon
(judge or interpreter).
All of Greek society, it was claimed, could benefit from this skill: it could assist with choosing an employee, a slave or a spouse, while its inherent vagueness made it intriguing to philosophers and useful for scientists who bent the theories to support their own beliefs. It became a recognised science in the Islamic world, and was used and taught in Europe throughout late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, despite nagging doubts among thinkers and physicians of the day. In the early 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci claimed not to "concern myself with false physiognomy, because these chimeras have no scientific foundation."
Theories of physiognomy, however, would persist beyond the Renaissance. In 1586, Italian scholar Giambattista della Porta published a book, De humana physiognomonia libri IIII, which established him as the 'father of Physiognomy'. Della Porta's thinking was based on the 'doctrine of signatures'; the idea that the appearance of plants and animals offers clues to their nature. For example, as one writer of the time suggested, walnuts are good for curing headaches because they're shaped a bit like a human head. The theories in della Porta's book were supported by dozens of detailed illustrations which, by comparing human faces to those of animals, suggested that they must surely share similar character traits.
In the 17th century, Swiss poet Johann Caspar Lavater took della Porta's methodology and ran with it, commissioning artists to illustrate his popular Essays On Physiognomy – which, to the chagrin of his contemporary, the writer Hannah More, sold for "fifteen guineas a set… while in vain we boast that philosophy [has] broken down all the strongholds of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition."
Lavater's work was criticised for being ridden with bias (black faces rarely emerged well from his analyses) but he was right in one respect: "Whether they are or are not sensible of it," he wrote, "all men are daily influenced by physiognomy."
Many studies have been done into our psychological response to faces, and it's clear that a so-called halo effect will inevitably work its magic. "Attractive people are regarded as better at everything," says Professor Peter Hancock, lecturer in Psychology at Stirling University. "And we can't shake that off because there's some truth to it. Good genes produce intelligent people, attractive faces, fit bodies, and we imagine that they're going to be good at everything else, too. We don't have good insight into our own behaviour. We tend to think we understand what we're doing, but we don't."
Hancock describes attending a conference where one speaker showed a series of black faces and white faces to students (who were mostly white) and asked them what they thought the experiment was about. "They knew that he was trying to assess whether they would rate the black ones as more criminal," says Hancock. "But then they did!"
We attribute social characteristics based on opinions we already hold about certain kinds of faces: whether they look unusual in some way, whether they resemble a partner, a family member or even ourselves, or perhaps have some other cultural association. Physiognomy ultimately stems from what Alexander Todorov, professor of psychology at Princeton University, calls an 'overgeneralisation hypothesis'. "People," he wrote, "use easily accessible facial information (eg an expression such as a smile, cues to gender and ethnic group) to make social attributions congruent with this information (eg a nice person)."
In a social media age, the pictures we choose to represent ourselves online are a form of self-presentation driven by those social attributions and the knowledge that our pictures are being judged.
Experiments at Princeton found that we take less than one tenth of a second to form an opinion of strangers from their pictures, and those opinions tend to stand firm even if we're exposed to those pictures for a longer period of time. That tendency to judge instantly gives rise to a number of selfie tropes that are deemed to elicit positive responses, particularly when it comes to photos on dating profiles: certain angles, particular expressions, minute adjustments of eyebrows and lips that might appear to be about narcissism and vanity, but are more about a fear of being incorrectly assessed. After all, false suppositions based on people's faces are hugely influential within society, and in extreme cases they can have a huge impact on people's lives.
When retired teacher Christopher Jefferies was held by police in connection with the murder of Joanna Yeates in Bristol back in 2010, more than half a dozen newspapers gave his unusual appearance particular scrutiny and made assumptions accordingly, which in turn influenced public opinion. This culminated in substantial damages for defamation, two convictions for contempt of court and a painful ordeal for Jefferies, who was entirely innocent.
This kind of deep-seated bias looms large throughout physiognomic works of the 19th and 20th centuries, from absurdities such as Vaught's Practical Character Reader of 1902 (handy if you want to find out what a "deceitful chin" looks like) to more inherently troubling volumes such as Cesare Lombroso's Criminal Man.
After performing a number of autopsies on criminals, the Italian physician claimed to have discovered a number of common characteristics, and it's worth listing them if only to establish the supposed criminality of pretty much everyone you know:
Unusually short or tall height; small head, but large face; fleshy lips, but thin upper lip; protuberances on head and around ear; wrinkles on forehead and face; large sinus cavities or bumpy face; tattoos; receding hairline; large incisors; bushy eyebrows, tending to meet across nose; large eye sockets but deep-set eyes; beaked or flat nose; strong jaw line; small and sloping forehead; small or weak chin; thin neck; sloping shoulders but large chest; large, protruding ears; long arms; high cheek bones; pointy or snubbed fingers or toes.
In a woeful misreading of Darwinian theory, Lombroso unwittingly founded the field of anthropological criminology, and more specifically the idea of the born criminal: a hereditary quality that posed a danger to society and must be rooted out. His theories became discredited during the 20th century, but the kind of bias displayed by Lombroso can still be found in legal systems across the world; studies show that people with stereotypically 'untrustworthy' faces tend to receive harsher treatment than those who don't. There's evidently some consensus over people's attitudes toward certain faces, but it doesn't follow that the consensus is correct.
The only attributes that we're reasonably good at detecting, according to research done at the University of Michigan in the 1960s and later tested at the University of Stirling in 2007, are extroversion and conscientiousness. For other traits there's insufficient evidence that our hunches are correct, with anomalies explained by our evolved aversion to 'ugliness', established links between broader faces and powerful physiques, or cultural associations with certain demographics which are reinforced with nagging regularity by newspapers, books, television and film.
Data-driven studies, based upon huge quantities of facial data, would seem to offer the final word on this. Since 2005, computational models have used various techniques to test for links between social attributes and facial features, resulting in suggestions that our faces can betray, for example, political leanings, sexual orientation and criminality. One BBC Future article from 2015 even describes the 'discipline' of physiognomy as 'gaining credibility'. But Todorov details many problems with these studies, pointing out the challenging nature of doing such experiments with sufficient rigour – not least because different images of the same people can prompt wildly differing results.
The aforementioned study at Shanghai's Jiao Tong University, with its enthusiastic, data-driven analyses of such questions as "What features of a human face betray its owner's propensity for crimes?" prompted a wave of press coverage.
The vision outlined in these articles is of an unethical dystopia where neural networks can assess our faces and establish a likely score for criminality – but Todorov is scathing about this paper, too. "The main problem is the sampling of the images," he says. "There is not enough information about the [nature of] the images of the people who were convicted. Second, clearly, there are huge differences between the two samples [of convicts and non-convicts] [in terms of] education and socio-economic status."
In other words, your appearance is affected by the kind of life you've led, so the classifiers within the computer program are simply distinguishing between different demographics rather than detecting a propensity for criminal behaviour.
Todorov is also wary of these classifiers misidentifying more 'innocent' people than identifying actual criminals, and accuracy is a concern shared by Peter Hancock. "Networks don't assess faces in the same way that we do," he says. "One of our systems, which is a deep network, has a recognition engine which generates an ordered list of how similar various faces are. And sometimes you get good matches – but other times you look at them and say, well, it's the wrong race! To humans they look completely different. And that underlines the fact that the networks are working in a different sort of way, and actually you don't really know how they're working. They're the ultimate black box."
This isn't to say that the use of big data, and particularly the use of composite imagery (digitally blending together certain types of faces) doesn't give us useful information and fascinating correlations. "You can, for example, take a given face and use computer software to make it look more or less trustworthy," says Hancock. "I remember a colleague playing with this and he made a less trustworthy version of George W Bush – and how shifty did he look! I'm surprised that they're not using these techniques in political advertising, because you couldn't tell that anything had been done [to the picture], but when you look at it you think 'I wouldn't trust him'."
The revitalisation of the theory of physiognomy by the Shanghai students is, according to Todorov, deeply problematic on a theoretical level. "Are we back to Lombroso's theory," he asks, "that criminals were anomalous creatures, evolutionary degenerates? How does one become criminal, and what role do various life forces play into this? There are people making claims that you just need to look at the face to predict personality and behaviour, but many of these people have not given much thought to their underlying assumptions."
While it's true that we judge books by their covers, covers are more than just faces; we piece together all kinds of cues from people to form our impressions of them. Jimmy Savile's appearance was unusual by any standards, but we absorbed a great deal of information about him over the years that will have influenced our opinions – not least from the original Louis Theroux programme from 2000 that was reexamined in that recent BBC documentary. Savile's vague resemblance to the Child Catcher from the film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is convenient but ultimately misleading, and the way it reinforces the idea of what a paedophile might 'look like' is unfortunate; not least because it helps to sustain a low-level belief in the 'science' of physiognomy, despite its tendency to crumble under the slightest cross examination.
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What does the author think of physiognomy? | 99903_KV62CBNS_9 | [
"It is flimsy and relies on too many assumptions",
"It is useful once someone is accused of a crime but not beforehand",
"It deserves more attention but from people outside of tech",
"It is a promising but little-understood field of study "
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0028",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
99,901 | 99901_MBDYN8BH | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | AI: what's the worst that could happen? | 2017.0 | Harry Armstrong | Magazine article | AI: what's the worst that could happen?
The Centre for the Future of Intelligence is seeking to investigate the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity, and make sure humans take advantage of the opportunities while dodging the risks. It launched at the University of Cambridge last October, and is a collaboration between four universities and colleges – Cambridge, Oxford, Imperial and Berkeley – backed with a 10-year, £10m grant from the Leverhulme Trust.
Because no single discipline is ideally suited to this task, the centre emphasises the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge-sharing and collaboration. It is bringing together a diverse community of some of the world's best researchers, philosophers, psychologists, lawyers and computer scientists.
Executive director of the centre is Stephen Cave, a writer, philosopher and former diplomat. Harry Armstrong, head of futures at Nesta, which publishes The Long + Short, spoke with Cave about the impact of AI.
Their conversation has been edited.
Harry Armstrong: Do you see the interdisciplinary nature of the centre as one of its key values and one of the key impacts you hope it will have on the field?
Stephen Cave: Thinking about the impact of AI is not something that any one discipline owns or does in any very systematic way. So if academia is going to rise to the challenge and provide thought leadership on this hugely important issue, then we’re going to need to do it by breaking down current disciplinary boundaries and bringing people with very different expertise together.
That means bringing together the technologists and the experts at developing these algorithms together with social scientists, philosophers, legal scholars and so forth.
I think there are many areas of science where more interdisciplinary engagement would be valuable. Biotech’s another example. In that sense AI isn’t unique, but I think because thinking about AI is still in very early stages, we have an opportunity to shape the way in which we think about it, and build that community.
We want to create a space where many different disciplines can come together and develop a shared language, learn from each other’s approaches, and hopefully very quickly move to be able to actually develop new ideas, new conclusions, together. But the first step is learning how to talk to each other.
At a recent talk, Naomi Klein said that addressing the challenge of climate change could not have come at a worse time. The current dominant political and economic ideologies, along with growing isolationist sentiment, runs contrary to the bipartisan, collaborative approaches needed to solve global issues like climate change. Do you see the same issues hampering a global effort to respond to the challenges AI raises?
Climate change suffers from the problem that the costs are not incurred in any direct way by the industrialists who own the technology and are profiting from it. With AI, that has been the case so far; although not on the same scale. There has been disruption but so far, compared to industrialisation, the impact has been fairly small. That will probably change.
AI companies, and in particular the big tech companies, are very concerned that this won't go like climate change, but rather it will go like GMOs: that people will have a gut reaction to this technology as soon as the first great swathe of job losses take hold. People speculate that 50m jobs could be lost in the US if trucking is automated, which is conceivable within 10 years. You could imagine a populist US government therefore simply banning driverless cars.
So I think there is anxiety in the tech industry that there could be a serious reaction against this technology at any point. And so my impression is that there is a feeling within these companies that these ethical and social implications need to be taken very seriously, now. And that a broad buy-in by society into some kind of vision of the future in which this technology plays a role is required, if a dangerous – or to them dangerous – counteraction is to be avoided.
My personal experience working with these tech companies is that they are concerned for their businesses and genuinely want to do the right thing. Of course there are intellectual challenges and there is money to be made, but equally they are people who don't think when they get up in the morning that they're going to put people out of jobs or bring about the downfall of humanity. As the industry matures it's developing a sense of responsibility.
So I think we've got a real opportunity, despite the general climate, and in some ways because of it. There's a great opportunity to bring industry on board to make sure the technology is developed in the right way.
One of the dominant narratives around not only AI but technology and automation more generally is that we, as humans, are at the mercy of technological progress. If you try and push against this idea you can be labelled as being anti-progress and stuck in the past. But we do have a lot more control than we give ourselves credit for. For example, routineness and susceptibility to automation are not inevitable features of occupations, job design is hugely important. How do we design jobs? How do we create jobs that allow people to do the kind of work they want to do? There can be a bit of a conflict between being impacted by what's happening and having some sort of control over what we want to happen.
Certainly, we encounter technological determinism a lot. And it's understandable. For us as individuals, of course it does feel like it always is happening and we just have to cope. No one individual can do much about it, other than adapt.
But that's different when we consider ourselves at a level of a society, as a polis [city state], or as an international community. I think we can shape the way in which technology develops. We have various tools. In any given country, we have regulations. There's a possibility of international regulation.
Technology is emerging from a certain legal, political, normative, cultural, and social framework. It's coming from a certain place. And it is shaped by all of those things.
And I think the more we understand a technology's relationship with those things, and the more we then consciously try to shape those things, the more we are going to influence the technology. So, for example, developing a culture of responsible innovation. For example, a kind of Hippocratic oath for AI developers. These things are within the realms of what is feasible, and I think will help to shape the future.
One of the problems with intervention, generally, is that we cannot control the course of events. We can attempt to, but we don't know how things are going to evolve. The reality is, societies are much too complex for us to be able to shape them in any very specific way, as plenty of ideologies and political movements have found to their cost. There are often unforeseen consequences that can derail a project.
I think, nonetheless, there are things we can do. We can try to imagine how things might go very badly wrong, and then work hard to develop systems that will stop that from happening. We can also try collectively to imagine how things could go very right. The kind of society that we actually want to live in that uses this technology. And I'm sure that will be skewed in all sorts of ways, and we might imagine things that seem wonderful and actually have terrible by-products.
This conversation cannot be in the hands of any one group. It oughtn't be in the hands of Silicon Valley billionaires alone. They've got their role to play, but this is a conversation we need to be having as widely as possible.
The centre is developing some really interesting projects but perhaps one of the most interesting is the discussion of what intelligence might be. Could you go into a bit more detail about the kinds of questions you are trying to explore in this area?
You mean kinds of intelligence?
Yeah.
I think this is very important because historically, we've had an overwhelming tendency to anthropomorphise. We define what intelligence is, historically, as being human-like. And then within that, being like certain humans.
And it's taken a very long time for the academic community to accept that there could be such a thing as non-human intelligence at all. We know that crows, for example, who have had a completely different evolutionary history, or octopuses, who have an even more different evolutionary history, might have a kind of intelligence that's very different to ours. That in some ways rivals our own, and so forth.
But luckily, we have got to that point in recent years of accepting that we are not the only form of intelligence. But now, AI is challenging that from a different direction. Just as we are accepting that the natural world offers this enormous range of different intelligences, we are at the same time inventing new intelligences that are radically different to humans.
And I think, still, this anthropomorphic picture of the kind of humanoid android, the robot, dominates our idea of what AI is too much. And too many people, and the industry as well, talk about human-level artificial intelligence as a goal, or general AI, which basically means like a human. But actually what we're building is nothing like a human.
When the first pocket calculator was made, it didn't do maths like a human. It was vastly better. It didn't make the occasional mistake. When we set about creating these artificial agents to solve these problems, because they have a completely different evolutionary history to humans, they solve problems in very different ways.
And until now, people have been fairly shy about describing them as intelligent. Or rather, in the history of AIs, we think solving a particular problem would require intelligence. Then we solve it. And then that's no longer intelligence, because we've solved it. Chess is a good example.
But the reality is, we are creating a whole new world of different artificial agents. And we need to understand that world. We need to understand all the different ways of being clever, if you like. How you can be extremely sophisticated at some particular rational process, and yet extremely bad at another one in a way that bears no relation to the way humans are on these axes.
And this is important, partly because we need to expand our sense of what is intelligent, like we have done with the natural world. Because lots of things follow from saying something is intelligent. Historically, we have a long tradition in Western philosophy of saying those who are intelligent should rule. So if intelligence equates to power, then obviously we need to think about what we mean by intelligence. Who has it and who doesn't. Or how it equates to rights and responsibilities.
It certainly is a very ambitious project to create the atlas of intelligence.
There was a point I read in something you wrote on our ideas of intelligence that I thought was very interesting. We actually tend to think of intelligence at the societal level when we think about human ability, rather than at the individual level but in the end conflate the two. I think that's a very good point, when we think about our capabilities, we think about what we can achieve as a whole, not individually. But when we talk about AI, we tend to think about that individual piece of technology, or that individual system. So for example if we think about the internet of things and AI, we should discuss intelligence as something encompassed by the whole.
Yeah, absolutely. Yes, right now, perhaps it is a product of our anthropomorphising bias. But there is a tendency to see a narrative of AI versus humanity, as if it's one or the other. And yet, obviously, there are risks in this technology long before it acquires any kind of manipulative agency.
Robotic technology is dangerous. Or potentially dangerous. But at the same time, most of what we're using technology for is to enhance ourselves, to increase our capacities. And a lot of what AI is going to be doing is augmenting us – we're going to be working as teams, AI-human teams.
Where do you think this AI-human conflict, or concept of a conflict, comes from? Do you think that's just a reflection of historical conversations we've had about automation, or do you think it is a deeper fear?
I do think it comes both from some biases that might well be innate, such as anthropomorphism, or our human tendency to ascribe agency to other objects, particularly moving ones, is well-established and probably has sound evolutionary roots. If it moves, it's probably wise to start asking yourself questions like, "What is it? What might it want? Where might it be going? Might it be hungry? Do I look like food to it?" I think it makes sense, it's natural for us to think in terms of agency. And when we do, it's natural for us to project our own ways of being and acting. And we, as primates, are profoundly co-operative.
But at the same time, we're competitive and murderous. We have a strong sense of in-group versus out-group, which is responsible for both a great deal of cooperation, within the in-group, but also terrible crimes. Murder, rape, pillage, genocide; and they're pointed at the out-group.
And so I think it's very natural for us to see AIs in terms of agents. We anthropomorphise them as these kind of android robots. And then we think about, well, you know, are they part of our in-group, or are they some other group? If they're some other group, it's us against them. Who's going to win? Well, let's see. So I think that's very natural, I think that's very human.
There is this long tradition, in Western culture in particular, with associating intelligence and dominance and power. It's interesting to speculate about how, and I wish I knew more about it, and I'd like to see more research on this, about how different cultures perceive AI. It's well known that Japan is very accepting of technology and robots, for example.
You can think, well, we in the West have long been justifying power relations of a certain kind on the basis that we're 'cleverer'. That's why men get to vote and women don't, or whatever. In a culture where power is not based on intelligence but, say, on a caste system, which is purely hereditary, we’d build an AI, and it would just tune in, drop out, attain enlightenment, just sit in the corner. Or we beg it to come back and help us find enlightenment. It might be that we find a completely different narrative to the one that's dominant in the West.
One of the projects the centre is running is looking into what kind of AI breakthroughs may come, when and what the social consequences could be. What do you think the future holds? What are your fears – what do you think could go right and wrong in the short, medium and long term?
That's a big question. Certainly I don't lie awake at night worried that robots are going to knock the door down and come in with a machine gun. If the robots take over the world, it won't be by knocking the door down. At the moment, I think it's certainly as big a risk that we have a GMO moment, and there's a powerful reaction against the technology which prevents us from reaping the benefits, which are enormous. I think that's as big a risk as the risks from the technologies themselves.
I think one worry that we haven't talked about is that we've become extremely dependent upon this technology. And that we essentially become deskilled. There's an extent to which the history of civilisation is the history of the domestication of the human species sort of by ourselves, and also by our technology, to some extent. And AI certainly allows for that to reach a whole new level.
Just think about GPs with diagnostic tools. Even now, my GP consults the computer fairly regularly. But as diagnostic tools get better, what are they going to be doing other than just typing something into the computer and reading out what comes back? At which point, you might as well do away with the GP. But then, who does know about medicine?
And so we do need to worry about deskilling and about becoming dependent. And it is entirely possible that you can imagine a society in which we're all sort of prosperous, in a sense. Our basic bodily needs are provided for, perhaps, in a way, to an extent that we've never before even dreamed of. Unprecedented in human history.
And yet, we're stripped of any kind of meaningful work. We have no purpose. We're escaping to virtual reality. And then you could imagine all sorts of worrying countercultures or Luddite movements or what have you. I guess that's the kind of scenario that – I haven't sketched it terribly well – but that's the kind of thing that worries me more than missile-toting giant robots.
As to utopian, yes, that's interesting. I certainly mentioned a couple of things. One thing that I hope is that this new technological revolution enables us to undo some of the damage of the last one. That's a very utopian thought and not terribly realistic, but we use fossil fuels so incredibly efficiently. The idea that driverless cars that are shared, basically a kind of shared service located off a Brownfield site does away with 95 per cent of all cars, freeing up a huge amount of space in the city to be greener, many fewer cars need to be produced, they would be on the road much less, there'd be fewer traffic jams.
It's just one example, but the idea that we can live much more resource-efficiently, because we are living more intelligently through using these tools. And therefore can undo some of the damage of the last Industrial Revolution. That's my main utopian hope, I guess.
Vintage toy robot image by josefkubes/Shutterstock
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/machines/the-future-of-intelligence | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | When does Stephen Cave think the general public will react to the role of AI? | 99901_MBDYN8BH_1 | [
"Once they realize they can lose money if they are not in the AI industry",
"Once they realize that AI can be dangerous",
"Once they think jobs are being lost to AIs",
"Once the AI companies have a larger share of the general market"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0028",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,901 | 99901_MBDYN8BH | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | AI: what's the worst that could happen? | 2017.0 | Harry Armstrong | Magazine article | AI: what's the worst that could happen?
The Centre for the Future of Intelligence is seeking to investigate the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity, and make sure humans take advantage of the opportunities while dodging the risks. It launched at the University of Cambridge last October, and is a collaboration between four universities and colleges – Cambridge, Oxford, Imperial and Berkeley – backed with a 10-year, £10m grant from the Leverhulme Trust.
Because no single discipline is ideally suited to this task, the centre emphasises the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge-sharing and collaboration. It is bringing together a diverse community of some of the world's best researchers, philosophers, psychologists, lawyers and computer scientists.
Executive director of the centre is Stephen Cave, a writer, philosopher and former diplomat. Harry Armstrong, head of futures at Nesta, which publishes The Long + Short, spoke with Cave about the impact of AI.
Their conversation has been edited.
Harry Armstrong: Do you see the interdisciplinary nature of the centre as one of its key values and one of the key impacts you hope it will have on the field?
Stephen Cave: Thinking about the impact of AI is not something that any one discipline owns or does in any very systematic way. So if academia is going to rise to the challenge and provide thought leadership on this hugely important issue, then we’re going to need to do it by breaking down current disciplinary boundaries and bringing people with very different expertise together.
That means bringing together the technologists and the experts at developing these algorithms together with social scientists, philosophers, legal scholars and so forth.
I think there are many areas of science where more interdisciplinary engagement would be valuable. Biotech’s another example. In that sense AI isn’t unique, but I think because thinking about AI is still in very early stages, we have an opportunity to shape the way in which we think about it, and build that community.
We want to create a space where many different disciplines can come together and develop a shared language, learn from each other’s approaches, and hopefully very quickly move to be able to actually develop new ideas, new conclusions, together. But the first step is learning how to talk to each other.
At a recent talk, Naomi Klein said that addressing the challenge of climate change could not have come at a worse time. The current dominant political and economic ideologies, along with growing isolationist sentiment, runs contrary to the bipartisan, collaborative approaches needed to solve global issues like climate change. Do you see the same issues hampering a global effort to respond to the challenges AI raises?
Climate change suffers from the problem that the costs are not incurred in any direct way by the industrialists who own the technology and are profiting from it. With AI, that has been the case so far; although not on the same scale. There has been disruption but so far, compared to industrialisation, the impact has been fairly small. That will probably change.
AI companies, and in particular the big tech companies, are very concerned that this won't go like climate change, but rather it will go like GMOs: that people will have a gut reaction to this technology as soon as the first great swathe of job losses take hold. People speculate that 50m jobs could be lost in the US if trucking is automated, which is conceivable within 10 years. You could imagine a populist US government therefore simply banning driverless cars.
So I think there is anxiety in the tech industry that there could be a serious reaction against this technology at any point. And so my impression is that there is a feeling within these companies that these ethical and social implications need to be taken very seriously, now. And that a broad buy-in by society into some kind of vision of the future in which this technology plays a role is required, if a dangerous – or to them dangerous – counteraction is to be avoided.
My personal experience working with these tech companies is that they are concerned for their businesses and genuinely want to do the right thing. Of course there are intellectual challenges and there is money to be made, but equally they are people who don't think when they get up in the morning that they're going to put people out of jobs or bring about the downfall of humanity. As the industry matures it's developing a sense of responsibility.
So I think we've got a real opportunity, despite the general climate, and in some ways because of it. There's a great opportunity to bring industry on board to make sure the technology is developed in the right way.
One of the dominant narratives around not only AI but technology and automation more generally is that we, as humans, are at the mercy of technological progress. If you try and push against this idea you can be labelled as being anti-progress and stuck in the past. But we do have a lot more control than we give ourselves credit for. For example, routineness and susceptibility to automation are not inevitable features of occupations, job design is hugely important. How do we design jobs? How do we create jobs that allow people to do the kind of work they want to do? There can be a bit of a conflict between being impacted by what's happening and having some sort of control over what we want to happen.
Certainly, we encounter technological determinism a lot. And it's understandable. For us as individuals, of course it does feel like it always is happening and we just have to cope. No one individual can do much about it, other than adapt.
But that's different when we consider ourselves at a level of a society, as a polis [city state], or as an international community. I think we can shape the way in which technology develops. We have various tools. In any given country, we have regulations. There's a possibility of international regulation.
Technology is emerging from a certain legal, political, normative, cultural, and social framework. It's coming from a certain place. And it is shaped by all of those things.
And I think the more we understand a technology's relationship with those things, and the more we then consciously try to shape those things, the more we are going to influence the technology. So, for example, developing a culture of responsible innovation. For example, a kind of Hippocratic oath for AI developers. These things are within the realms of what is feasible, and I think will help to shape the future.
One of the problems with intervention, generally, is that we cannot control the course of events. We can attempt to, but we don't know how things are going to evolve. The reality is, societies are much too complex for us to be able to shape them in any very specific way, as plenty of ideologies and political movements have found to their cost. There are often unforeseen consequences that can derail a project.
I think, nonetheless, there are things we can do. We can try to imagine how things might go very badly wrong, and then work hard to develop systems that will stop that from happening. We can also try collectively to imagine how things could go very right. The kind of society that we actually want to live in that uses this technology. And I'm sure that will be skewed in all sorts of ways, and we might imagine things that seem wonderful and actually have terrible by-products.
This conversation cannot be in the hands of any one group. It oughtn't be in the hands of Silicon Valley billionaires alone. They've got their role to play, but this is a conversation we need to be having as widely as possible.
The centre is developing some really interesting projects but perhaps one of the most interesting is the discussion of what intelligence might be. Could you go into a bit more detail about the kinds of questions you are trying to explore in this area?
You mean kinds of intelligence?
Yeah.
I think this is very important because historically, we've had an overwhelming tendency to anthropomorphise. We define what intelligence is, historically, as being human-like. And then within that, being like certain humans.
And it's taken a very long time for the academic community to accept that there could be such a thing as non-human intelligence at all. We know that crows, for example, who have had a completely different evolutionary history, or octopuses, who have an even more different evolutionary history, might have a kind of intelligence that's very different to ours. That in some ways rivals our own, and so forth.
But luckily, we have got to that point in recent years of accepting that we are not the only form of intelligence. But now, AI is challenging that from a different direction. Just as we are accepting that the natural world offers this enormous range of different intelligences, we are at the same time inventing new intelligences that are radically different to humans.
And I think, still, this anthropomorphic picture of the kind of humanoid android, the robot, dominates our idea of what AI is too much. And too many people, and the industry as well, talk about human-level artificial intelligence as a goal, or general AI, which basically means like a human. But actually what we're building is nothing like a human.
When the first pocket calculator was made, it didn't do maths like a human. It was vastly better. It didn't make the occasional mistake. When we set about creating these artificial agents to solve these problems, because they have a completely different evolutionary history to humans, they solve problems in very different ways.
And until now, people have been fairly shy about describing them as intelligent. Or rather, in the history of AIs, we think solving a particular problem would require intelligence. Then we solve it. And then that's no longer intelligence, because we've solved it. Chess is a good example.
But the reality is, we are creating a whole new world of different artificial agents. And we need to understand that world. We need to understand all the different ways of being clever, if you like. How you can be extremely sophisticated at some particular rational process, and yet extremely bad at another one in a way that bears no relation to the way humans are on these axes.
And this is important, partly because we need to expand our sense of what is intelligent, like we have done with the natural world. Because lots of things follow from saying something is intelligent. Historically, we have a long tradition in Western philosophy of saying those who are intelligent should rule. So if intelligence equates to power, then obviously we need to think about what we mean by intelligence. Who has it and who doesn't. Or how it equates to rights and responsibilities.
It certainly is a very ambitious project to create the atlas of intelligence.
There was a point I read in something you wrote on our ideas of intelligence that I thought was very interesting. We actually tend to think of intelligence at the societal level when we think about human ability, rather than at the individual level but in the end conflate the two. I think that's a very good point, when we think about our capabilities, we think about what we can achieve as a whole, not individually. But when we talk about AI, we tend to think about that individual piece of technology, or that individual system. So for example if we think about the internet of things and AI, we should discuss intelligence as something encompassed by the whole.
Yeah, absolutely. Yes, right now, perhaps it is a product of our anthropomorphising bias. But there is a tendency to see a narrative of AI versus humanity, as if it's one or the other. And yet, obviously, there are risks in this technology long before it acquires any kind of manipulative agency.
Robotic technology is dangerous. Or potentially dangerous. But at the same time, most of what we're using technology for is to enhance ourselves, to increase our capacities. And a lot of what AI is going to be doing is augmenting us – we're going to be working as teams, AI-human teams.
Where do you think this AI-human conflict, or concept of a conflict, comes from? Do you think that's just a reflection of historical conversations we've had about automation, or do you think it is a deeper fear?
I do think it comes both from some biases that might well be innate, such as anthropomorphism, or our human tendency to ascribe agency to other objects, particularly moving ones, is well-established and probably has sound evolutionary roots. If it moves, it's probably wise to start asking yourself questions like, "What is it? What might it want? Where might it be going? Might it be hungry? Do I look like food to it?" I think it makes sense, it's natural for us to think in terms of agency. And when we do, it's natural for us to project our own ways of being and acting. And we, as primates, are profoundly co-operative.
But at the same time, we're competitive and murderous. We have a strong sense of in-group versus out-group, which is responsible for both a great deal of cooperation, within the in-group, but also terrible crimes. Murder, rape, pillage, genocide; and they're pointed at the out-group.
And so I think it's very natural for us to see AIs in terms of agents. We anthropomorphise them as these kind of android robots. And then we think about, well, you know, are they part of our in-group, or are they some other group? If they're some other group, it's us against them. Who's going to win? Well, let's see. So I think that's very natural, I think that's very human.
There is this long tradition, in Western culture in particular, with associating intelligence and dominance and power. It's interesting to speculate about how, and I wish I knew more about it, and I'd like to see more research on this, about how different cultures perceive AI. It's well known that Japan is very accepting of technology and robots, for example.
You can think, well, we in the West have long been justifying power relations of a certain kind on the basis that we're 'cleverer'. That's why men get to vote and women don't, or whatever. In a culture where power is not based on intelligence but, say, on a caste system, which is purely hereditary, we’d build an AI, and it would just tune in, drop out, attain enlightenment, just sit in the corner. Or we beg it to come back and help us find enlightenment. It might be that we find a completely different narrative to the one that's dominant in the West.
One of the projects the centre is running is looking into what kind of AI breakthroughs may come, when and what the social consequences could be. What do you think the future holds? What are your fears – what do you think could go right and wrong in the short, medium and long term?
That's a big question. Certainly I don't lie awake at night worried that robots are going to knock the door down and come in with a machine gun. If the robots take over the world, it won't be by knocking the door down. At the moment, I think it's certainly as big a risk that we have a GMO moment, and there's a powerful reaction against the technology which prevents us from reaping the benefits, which are enormous. I think that's as big a risk as the risks from the technologies themselves.
I think one worry that we haven't talked about is that we've become extremely dependent upon this technology. And that we essentially become deskilled. There's an extent to which the history of civilisation is the history of the domestication of the human species sort of by ourselves, and also by our technology, to some extent. And AI certainly allows for that to reach a whole new level.
Just think about GPs with diagnostic tools. Even now, my GP consults the computer fairly regularly. But as diagnostic tools get better, what are they going to be doing other than just typing something into the computer and reading out what comes back? At which point, you might as well do away with the GP. But then, who does know about medicine?
And so we do need to worry about deskilling and about becoming dependent. And it is entirely possible that you can imagine a society in which we're all sort of prosperous, in a sense. Our basic bodily needs are provided for, perhaps, in a way, to an extent that we've never before even dreamed of. Unprecedented in human history.
And yet, we're stripped of any kind of meaningful work. We have no purpose. We're escaping to virtual reality. And then you could imagine all sorts of worrying countercultures or Luddite movements or what have you. I guess that's the kind of scenario that – I haven't sketched it terribly well – but that's the kind of thing that worries me more than missile-toting giant robots.
As to utopian, yes, that's interesting. I certainly mentioned a couple of things. One thing that I hope is that this new technological revolution enables us to undo some of the damage of the last one. That's a very utopian thought and not terribly realistic, but we use fossil fuels so incredibly efficiently. The idea that driverless cars that are shared, basically a kind of shared service located off a Brownfield site does away with 95 per cent of all cars, freeing up a huge amount of space in the city to be greener, many fewer cars need to be produced, they would be on the road much less, there'd be fewer traffic jams.
It's just one example, but the idea that we can live much more resource-efficiently, because we are living more intelligently through using these tools. And therefore can undo some of the damage of the last Industrial Revolution. That's my main utopian hope, I guess.
Vintage toy robot image by josefkubes/Shutterstock
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/machines/the-future-of-intelligence | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which of these does Stephen think is a strong benefit of AIs in jobs? | 99901_MBDYN8BH_2 | [
"They are an easy way to keep an eye on employees to make sure they are doing what needs to be done",
"To automate a lot of reports and make communication easier",
"To let people spend their time in jobs doing things they want to do",
"They can support employees with disabilities who have to do a lot of tech work"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
99,901 | 99901_MBDYN8BH | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | AI: what's the worst that could happen? | 2017.0 | Harry Armstrong | Magazine article | AI: what's the worst that could happen?
The Centre for the Future of Intelligence is seeking to investigate the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity, and make sure humans take advantage of the opportunities while dodging the risks. It launched at the University of Cambridge last October, and is a collaboration between four universities and colleges – Cambridge, Oxford, Imperial and Berkeley – backed with a 10-year, £10m grant from the Leverhulme Trust.
Because no single discipline is ideally suited to this task, the centre emphasises the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge-sharing and collaboration. It is bringing together a diverse community of some of the world's best researchers, philosophers, psychologists, lawyers and computer scientists.
Executive director of the centre is Stephen Cave, a writer, philosopher and former diplomat. Harry Armstrong, head of futures at Nesta, which publishes The Long + Short, spoke with Cave about the impact of AI.
Their conversation has been edited.
Harry Armstrong: Do you see the interdisciplinary nature of the centre as one of its key values and one of the key impacts you hope it will have on the field?
Stephen Cave: Thinking about the impact of AI is not something that any one discipline owns or does in any very systematic way. So if academia is going to rise to the challenge and provide thought leadership on this hugely important issue, then we’re going to need to do it by breaking down current disciplinary boundaries and bringing people with very different expertise together.
That means bringing together the technologists and the experts at developing these algorithms together with social scientists, philosophers, legal scholars and so forth.
I think there are many areas of science where more interdisciplinary engagement would be valuable. Biotech’s another example. In that sense AI isn’t unique, but I think because thinking about AI is still in very early stages, we have an opportunity to shape the way in which we think about it, and build that community.
We want to create a space where many different disciplines can come together and develop a shared language, learn from each other’s approaches, and hopefully very quickly move to be able to actually develop new ideas, new conclusions, together. But the first step is learning how to talk to each other.
At a recent talk, Naomi Klein said that addressing the challenge of climate change could not have come at a worse time. The current dominant political and economic ideologies, along with growing isolationist sentiment, runs contrary to the bipartisan, collaborative approaches needed to solve global issues like climate change. Do you see the same issues hampering a global effort to respond to the challenges AI raises?
Climate change suffers from the problem that the costs are not incurred in any direct way by the industrialists who own the technology and are profiting from it. With AI, that has been the case so far; although not on the same scale. There has been disruption but so far, compared to industrialisation, the impact has been fairly small. That will probably change.
AI companies, and in particular the big tech companies, are very concerned that this won't go like climate change, but rather it will go like GMOs: that people will have a gut reaction to this technology as soon as the first great swathe of job losses take hold. People speculate that 50m jobs could be lost in the US if trucking is automated, which is conceivable within 10 years. You could imagine a populist US government therefore simply banning driverless cars.
So I think there is anxiety in the tech industry that there could be a serious reaction against this technology at any point. And so my impression is that there is a feeling within these companies that these ethical and social implications need to be taken very seriously, now. And that a broad buy-in by society into some kind of vision of the future in which this technology plays a role is required, if a dangerous – or to them dangerous – counteraction is to be avoided.
My personal experience working with these tech companies is that they are concerned for their businesses and genuinely want to do the right thing. Of course there are intellectual challenges and there is money to be made, but equally they are people who don't think when they get up in the morning that they're going to put people out of jobs or bring about the downfall of humanity. As the industry matures it's developing a sense of responsibility.
So I think we've got a real opportunity, despite the general climate, and in some ways because of it. There's a great opportunity to bring industry on board to make sure the technology is developed in the right way.
One of the dominant narratives around not only AI but technology and automation more generally is that we, as humans, are at the mercy of technological progress. If you try and push against this idea you can be labelled as being anti-progress and stuck in the past. But we do have a lot more control than we give ourselves credit for. For example, routineness and susceptibility to automation are not inevitable features of occupations, job design is hugely important. How do we design jobs? How do we create jobs that allow people to do the kind of work they want to do? There can be a bit of a conflict between being impacted by what's happening and having some sort of control over what we want to happen.
Certainly, we encounter technological determinism a lot. And it's understandable. For us as individuals, of course it does feel like it always is happening and we just have to cope. No one individual can do much about it, other than adapt.
But that's different when we consider ourselves at a level of a society, as a polis [city state], or as an international community. I think we can shape the way in which technology develops. We have various tools. In any given country, we have regulations. There's a possibility of international regulation.
Technology is emerging from a certain legal, political, normative, cultural, and social framework. It's coming from a certain place. And it is shaped by all of those things.
And I think the more we understand a technology's relationship with those things, and the more we then consciously try to shape those things, the more we are going to influence the technology. So, for example, developing a culture of responsible innovation. For example, a kind of Hippocratic oath for AI developers. These things are within the realms of what is feasible, and I think will help to shape the future.
One of the problems with intervention, generally, is that we cannot control the course of events. We can attempt to, but we don't know how things are going to evolve. The reality is, societies are much too complex for us to be able to shape them in any very specific way, as plenty of ideologies and political movements have found to their cost. There are often unforeseen consequences that can derail a project.
I think, nonetheless, there are things we can do. We can try to imagine how things might go very badly wrong, and then work hard to develop systems that will stop that from happening. We can also try collectively to imagine how things could go very right. The kind of society that we actually want to live in that uses this technology. And I'm sure that will be skewed in all sorts of ways, and we might imagine things that seem wonderful and actually have terrible by-products.
This conversation cannot be in the hands of any one group. It oughtn't be in the hands of Silicon Valley billionaires alone. They've got their role to play, but this is a conversation we need to be having as widely as possible.
The centre is developing some really interesting projects but perhaps one of the most interesting is the discussion of what intelligence might be. Could you go into a bit more detail about the kinds of questions you are trying to explore in this area?
You mean kinds of intelligence?
Yeah.
I think this is very important because historically, we've had an overwhelming tendency to anthropomorphise. We define what intelligence is, historically, as being human-like. And then within that, being like certain humans.
And it's taken a very long time for the academic community to accept that there could be such a thing as non-human intelligence at all. We know that crows, for example, who have had a completely different evolutionary history, or octopuses, who have an even more different evolutionary history, might have a kind of intelligence that's very different to ours. That in some ways rivals our own, and so forth.
But luckily, we have got to that point in recent years of accepting that we are not the only form of intelligence. But now, AI is challenging that from a different direction. Just as we are accepting that the natural world offers this enormous range of different intelligences, we are at the same time inventing new intelligences that are radically different to humans.
And I think, still, this anthropomorphic picture of the kind of humanoid android, the robot, dominates our idea of what AI is too much. And too many people, and the industry as well, talk about human-level artificial intelligence as a goal, or general AI, which basically means like a human. But actually what we're building is nothing like a human.
When the first pocket calculator was made, it didn't do maths like a human. It was vastly better. It didn't make the occasional mistake. When we set about creating these artificial agents to solve these problems, because they have a completely different evolutionary history to humans, they solve problems in very different ways.
And until now, people have been fairly shy about describing them as intelligent. Or rather, in the history of AIs, we think solving a particular problem would require intelligence. Then we solve it. And then that's no longer intelligence, because we've solved it. Chess is a good example.
But the reality is, we are creating a whole new world of different artificial agents. And we need to understand that world. We need to understand all the different ways of being clever, if you like. How you can be extremely sophisticated at some particular rational process, and yet extremely bad at another one in a way that bears no relation to the way humans are on these axes.
And this is important, partly because we need to expand our sense of what is intelligent, like we have done with the natural world. Because lots of things follow from saying something is intelligent. Historically, we have a long tradition in Western philosophy of saying those who are intelligent should rule. So if intelligence equates to power, then obviously we need to think about what we mean by intelligence. Who has it and who doesn't. Or how it equates to rights and responsibilities.
It certainly is a very ambitious project to create the atlas of intelligence.
There was a point I read in something you wrote on our ideas of intelligence that I thought was very interesting. We actually tend to think of intelligence at the societal level when we think about human ability, rather than at the individual level but in the end conflate the two. I think that's a very good point, when we think about our capabilities, we think about what we can achieve as a whole, not individually. But when we talk about AI, we tend to think about that individual piece of technology, or that individual system. So for example if we think about the internet of things and AI, we should discuss intelligence as something encompassed by the whole.
Yeah, absolutely. Yes, right now, perhaps it is a product of our anthropomorphising bias. But there is a tendency to see a narrative of AI versus humanity, as if it's one or the other. And yet, obviously, there are risks in this technology long before it acquires any kind of manipulative agency.
Robotic technology is dangerous. Or potentially dangerous. But at the same time, most of what we're using technology for is to enhance ourselves, to increase our capacities. And a lot of what AI is going to be doing is augmenting us – we're going to be working as teams, AI-human teams.
Where do you think this AI-human conflict, or concept of a conflict, comes from? Do you think that's just a reflection of historical conversations we've had about automation, or do you think it is a deeper fear?
I do think it comes both from some biases that might well be innate, such as anthropomorphism, or our human tendency to ascribe agency to other objects, particularly moving ones, is well-established and probably has sound evolutionary roots. If it moves, it's probably wise to start asking yourself questions like, "What is it? What might it want? Where might it be going? Might it be hungry? Do I look like food to it?" I think it makes sense, it's natural for us to think in terms of agency. And when we do, it's natural for us to project our own ways of being and acting. And we, as primates, are profoundly co-operative.
But at the same time, we're competitive and murderous. We have a strong sense of in-group versus out-group, which is responsible for both a great deal of cooperation, within the in-group, but also terrible crimes. Murder, rape, pillage, genocide; and they're pointed at the out-group.
And so I think it's very natural for us to see AIs in terms of agents. We anthropomorphise them as these kind of android robots. And then we think about, well, you know, are they part of our in-group, or are they some other group? If they're some other group, it's us against them. Who's going to win? Well, let's see. So I think that's very natural, I think that's very human.
There is this long tradition, in Western culture in particular, with associating intelligence and dominance and power. It's interesting to speculate about how, and I wish I knew more about it, and I'd like to see more research on this, about how different cultures perceive AI. It's well known that Japan is very accepting of technology and robots, for example.
You can think, well, we in the West have long been justifying power relations of a certain kind on the basis that we're 'cleverer'. That's why men get to vote and women don't, or whatever. In a culture where power is not based on intelligence but, say, on a caste system, which is purely hereditary, we’d build an AI, and it would just tune in, drop out, attain enlightenment, just sit in the corner. Or we beg it to come back and help us find enlightenment. It might be that we find a completely different narrative to the one that's dominant in the West.
One of the projects the centre is running is looking into what kind of AI breakthroughs may come, when and what the social consequences could be. What do you think the future holds? What are your fears – what do you think could go right and wrong in the short, medium and long term?
That's a big question. Certainly I don't lie awake at night worried that robots are going to knock the door down and come in with a machine gun. If the robots take over the world, it won't be by knocking the door down. At the moment, I think it's certainly as big a risk that we have a GMO moment, and there's a powerful reaction against the technology which prevents us from reaping the benefits, which are enormous. I think that's as big a risk as the risks from the technologies themselves.
I think one worry that we haven't talked about is that we've become extremely dependent upon this technology. And that we essentially become deskilled. There's an extent to which the history of civilisation is the history of the domestication of the human species sort of by ourselves, and also by our technology, to some extent. And AI certainly allows for that to reach a whole new level.
Just think about GPs with diagnostic tools. Even now, my GP consults the computer fairly regularly. But as diagnostic tools get better, what are they going to be doing other than just typing something into the computer and reading out what comes back? At which point, you might as well do away with the GP. But then, who does know about medicine?
And so we do need to worry about deskilling and about becoming dependent. And it is entirely possible that you can imagine a society in which we're all sort of prosperous, in a sense. Our basic bodily needs are provided for, perhaps, in a way, to an extent that we've never before even dreamed of. Unprecedented in human history.
And yet, we're stripped of any kind of meaningful work. We have no purpose. We're escaping to virtual reality. And then you could imagine all sorts of worrying countercultures or Luddite movements or what have you. I guess that's the kind of scenario that – I haven't sketched it terribly well – but that's the kind of thing that worries me more than missile-toting giant robots.
As to utopian, yes, that's interesting. I certainly mentioned a couple of things. One thing that I hope is that this new technological revolution enables us to undo some of the damage of the last one. That's a very utopian thought and not terribly realistic, but we use fossil fuels so incredibly efficiently. The idea that driverless cars that are shared, basically a kind of shared service located off a Brownfield site does away with 95 per cent of all cars, freeing up a huge amount of space in the city to be greener, many fewer cars need to be produced, they would be on the road much less, there'd be fewer traffic jams.
It's just one example, but the idea that we can live much more resource-efficiently, because we are living more intelligently through using these tools. And therefore can undo some of the damage of the last Industrial Revolution. That's my main utopian hope, I guess.
Vintage toy robot image by josefkubes/Shutterstock
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/machines/the-future-of-intelligence | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which does Stephen think is a useful impact of AIs in a broad context? | 99901_MBDYN8BH_3 | [
"They can have a strong moral impact on the communities they interact with",
"They will allow us to put the social frameworks we live in under a microscope",
"They will boost the economy all over the world",
"There can be regulation that can help people decide how to shape the future"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
99,901 | 99901_MBDYN8BH | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | AI: what's the worst that could happen? | 2017.0 | Harry Armstrong | Magazine article | AI: what's the worst that could happen?
The Centre for the Future of Intelligence is seeking to investigate the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity, and make sure humans take advantage of the opportunities while dodging the risks. It launched at the University of Cambridge last October, and is a collaboration between four universities and colleges – Cambridge, Oxford, Imperial and Berkeley – backed with a 10-year, £10m grant from the Leverhulme Trust.
Because no single discipline is ideally suited to this task, the centre emphasises the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge-sharing and collaboration. It is bringing together a diverse community of some of the world's best researchers, philosophers, psychologists, lawyers and computer scientists.
Executive director of the centre is Stephen Cave, a writer, philosopher and former diplomat. Harry Armstrong, head of futures at Nesta, which publishes The Long + Short, spoke with Cave about the impact of AI.
Their conversation has been edited.
Harry Armstrong: Do you see the interdisciplinary nature of the centre as one of its key values and one of the key impacts you hope it will have on the field?
Stephen Cave: Thinking about the impact of AI is not something that any one discipline owns or does in any very systematic way. So if academia is going to rise to the challenge and provide thought leadership on this hugely important issue, then we’re going to need to do it by breaking down current disciplinary boundaries and bringing people with very different expertise together.
That means bringing together the technologists and the experts at developing these algorithms together with social scientists, philosophers, legal scholars and so forth.
I think there are many areas of science where more interdisciplinary engagement would be valuable. Biotech’s another example. In that sense AI isn’t unique, but I think because thinking about AI is still in very early stages, we have an opportunity to shape the way in which we think about it, and build that community.
We want to create a space where many different disciplines can come together and develop a shared language, learn from each other’s approaches, and hopefully very quickly move to be able to actually develop new ideas, new conclusions, together. But the first step is learning how to talk to each other.
At a recent talk, Naomi Klein said that addressing the challenge of climate change could not have come at a worse time. The current dominant political and economic ideologies, along with growing isolationist sentiment, runs contrary to the bipartisan, collaborative approaches needed to solve global issues like climate change. Do you see the same issues hampering a global effort to respond to the challenges AI raises?
Climate change suffers from the problem that the costs are not incurred in any direct way by the industrialists who own the technology and are profiting from it. With AI, that has been the case so far; although not on the same scale. There has been disruption but so far, compared to industrialisation, the impact has been fairly small. That will probably change.
AI companies, and in particular the big tech companies, are very concerned that this won't go like climate change, but rather it will go like GMOs: that people will have a gut reaction to this technology as soon as the first great swathe of job losses take hold. People speculate that 50m jobs could be lost in the US if trucking is automated, which is conceivable within 10 years. You could imagine a populist US government therefore simply banning driverless cars.
So I think there is anxiety in the tech industry that there could be a serious reaction against this technology at any point. And so my impression is that there is a feeling within these companies that these ethical and social implications need to be taken very seriously, now. And that a broad buy-in by society into some kind of vision of the future in which this technology plays a role is required, if a dangerous – or to them dangerous – counteraction is to be avoided.
My personal experience working with these tech companies is that they are concerned for their businesses and genuinely want to do the right thing. Of course there are intellectual challenges and there is money to be made, but equally they are people who don't think when they get up in the morning that they're going to put people out of jobs or bring about the downfall of humanity. As the industry matures it's developing a sense of responsibility.
So I think we've got a real opportunity, despite the general climate, and in some ways because of it. There's a great opportunity to bring industry on board to make sure the technology is developed in the right way.
One of the dominant narratives around not only AI but technology and automation more generally is that we, as humans, are at the mercy of technological progress. If you try and push against this idea you can be labelled as being anti-progress and stuck in the past. But we do have a lot more control than we give ourselves credit for. For example, routineness and susceptibility to automation are not inevitable features of occupations, job design is hugely important. How do we design jobs? How do we create jobs that allow people to do the kind of work they want to do? There can be a bit of a conflict between being impacted by what's happening and having some sort of control over what we want to happen.
Certainly, we encounter technological determinism a lot. And it's understandable. For us as individuals, of course it does feel like it always is happening and we just have to cope. No one individual can do much about it, other than adapt.
But that's different when we consider ourselves at a level of a society, as a polis [city state], or as an international community. I think we can shape the way in which technology develops. We have various tools. In any given country, we have regulations. There's a possibility of international regulation.
Technology is emerging from a certain legal, political, normative, cultural, and social framework. It's coming from a certain place. And it is shaped by all of those things.
And I think the more we understand a technology's relationship with those things, and the more we then consciously try to shape those things, the more we are going to influence the technology. So, for example, developing a culture of responsible innovation. For example, a kind of Hippocratic oath for AI developers. These things are within the realms of what is feasible, and I think will help to shape the future.
One of the problems with intervention, generally, is that we cannot control the course of events. We can attempt to, but we don't know how things are going to evolve. The reality is, societies are much too complex for us to be able to shape them in any very specific way, as plenty of ideologies and political movements have found to their cost. There are often unforeseen consequences that can derail a project.
I think, nonetheless, there are things we can do. We can try to imagine how things might go very badly wrong, and then work hard to develop systems that will stop that from happening. We can also try collectively to imagine how things could go very right. The kind of society that we actually want to live in that uses this technology. And I'm sure that will be skewed in all sorts of ways, and we might imagine things that seem wonderful and actually have terrible by-products.
This conversation cannot be in the hands of any one group. It oughtn't be in the hands of Silicon Valley billionaires alone. They've got their role to play, but this is a conversation we need to be having as widely as possible.
The centre is developing some really interesting projects but perhaps one of the most interesting is the discussion of what intelligence might be. Could you go into a bit more detail about the kinds of questions you are trying to explore in this area?
You mean kinds of intelligence?
Yeah.
I think this is very important because historically, we've had an overwhelming tendency to anthropomorphise. We define what intelligence is, historically, as being human-like. And then within that, being like certain humans.
And it's taken a very long time for the academic community to accept that there could be such a thing as non-human intelligence at all. We know that crows, for example, who have had a completely different evolutionary history, or octopuses, who have an even more different evolutionary history, might have a kind of intelligence that's very different to ours. That in some ways rivals our own, and so forth.
But luckily, we have got to that point in recent years of accepting that we are not the only form of intelligence. But now, AI is challenging that from a different direction. Just as we are accepting that the natural world offers this enormous range of different intelligences, we are at the same time inventing new intelligences that are radically different to humans.
And I think, still, this anthropomorphic picture of the kind of humanoid android, the robot, dominates our idea of what AI is too much. And too many people, and the industry as well, talk about human-level artificial intelligence as a goal, or general AI, which basically means like a human. But actually what we're building is nothing like a human.
When the first pocket calculator was made, it didn't do maths like a human. It was vastly better. It didn't make the occasional mistake. When we set about creating these artificial agents to solve these problems, because they have a completely different evolutionary history to humans, they solve problems in very different ways.
And until now, people have been fairly shy about describing them as intelligent. Or rather, in the history of AIs, we think solving a particular problem would require intelligence. Then we solve it. And then that's no longer intelligence, because we've solved it. Chess is a good example.
But the reality is, we are creating a whole new world of different artificial agents. And we need to understand that world. We need to understand all the different ways of being clever, if you like. How you can be extremely sophisticated at some particular rational process, and yet extremely bad at another one in a way that bears no relation to the way humans are on these axes.
And this is important, partly because we need to expand our sense of what is intelligent, like we have done with the natural world. Because lots of things follow from saying something is intelligent. Historically, we have a long tradition in Western philosophy of saying those who are intelligent should rule. So if intelligence equates to power, then obviously we need to think about what we mean by intelligence. Who has it and who doesn't. Or how it equates to rights and responsibilities.
It certainly is a very ambitious project to create the atlas of intelligence.
There was a point I read in something you wrote on our ideas of intelligence that I thought was very interesting. We actually tend to think of intelligence at the societal level when we think about human ability, rather than at the individual level but in the end conflate the two. I think that's a very good point, when we think about our capabilities, we think about what we can achieve as a whole, not individually. But when we talk about AI, we tend to think about that individual piece of technology, or that individual system. So for example if we think about the internet of things and AI, we should discuss intelligence as something encompassed by the whole.
Yeah, absolutely. Yes, right now, perhaps it is a product of our anthropomorphising bias. But there is a tendency to see a narrative of AI versus humanity, as if it's one or the other. And yet, obviously, there are risks in this technology long before it acquires any kind of manipulative agency.
Robotic technology is dangerous. Or potentially dangerous. But at the same time, most of what we're using technology for is to enhance ourselves, to increase our capacities. And a lot of what AI is going to be doing is augmenting us – we're going to be working as teams, AI-human teams.
Where do you think this AI-human conflict, or concept of a conflict, comes from? Do you think that's just a reflection of historical conversations we've had about automation, or do you think it is a deeper fear?
I do think it comes both from some biases that might well be innate, such as anthropomorphism, or our human tendency to ascribe agency to other objects, particularly moving ones, is well-established and probably has sound evolutionary roots. If it moves, it's probably wise to start asking yourself questions like, "What is it? What might it want? Where might it be going? Might it be hungry? Do I look like food to it?" I think it makes sense, it's natural for us to think in terms of agency. And when we do, it's natural for us to project our own ways of being and acting. And we, as primates, are profoundly co-operative.
But at the same time, we're competitive and murderous. We have a strong sense of in-group versus out-group, which is responsible for both a great deal of cooperation, within the in-group, but also terrible crimes. Murder, rape, pillage, genocide; and they're pointed at the out-group.
And so I think it's very natural for us to see AIs in terms of agents. We anthropomorphise them as these kind of android robots. And then we think about, well, you know, are they part of our in-group, or are they some other group? If they're some other group, it's us against them. Who's going to win? Well, let's see. So I think that's very natural, I think that's very human.
There is this long tradition, in Western culture in particular, with associating intelligence and dominance and power. It's interesting to speculate about how, and I wish I knew more about it, and I'd like to see more research on this, about how different cultures perceive AI. It's well known that Japan is very accepting of technology and robots, for example.
You can think, well, we in the West have long been justifying power relations of a certain kind on the basis that we're 'cleverer'. That's why men get to vote and women don't, or whatever. In a culture where power is not based on intelligence but, say, on a caste system, which is purely hereditary, we’d build an AI, and it would just tune in, drop out, attain enlightenment, just sit in the corner. Or we beg it to come back and help us find enlightenment. It might be that we find a completely different narrative to the one that's dominant in the West.
One of the projects the centre is running is looking into what kind of AI breakthroughs may come, when and what the social consequences could be. What do you think the future holds? What are your fears – what do you think could go right and wrong in the short, medium and long term?
That's a big question. Certainly I don't lie awake at night worried that robots are going to knock the door down and come in with a machine gun. If the robots take over the world, it won't be by knocking the door down. At the moment, I think it's certainly as big a risk that we have a GMO moment, and there's a powerful reaction against the technology which prevents us from reaping the benefits, which are enormous. I think that's as big a risk as the risks from the technologies themselves.
I think one worry that we haven't talked about is that we've become extremely dependent upon this technology. And that we essentially become deskilled. There's an extent to which the history of civilisation is the history of the domestication of the human species sort of by ourselves, and also by our technology, to some extent. And AI certainly allows for that to reach a whole new level.
Just think about GPs with diagnostic tools. Even now, my GP consults the computer fairly regularly. But as diagnostic tools get better, what are they going to be doing other than just typing something into the computer and reading out what comes back? At which point, you might as well do away with the GP. But then, who does know about medicine?
And so we do need to worry about deskilling and about becoming dependent. And it is entirely possible that you can imagine a society in which we're all sort of prosperous, in a sense. Our basic bodily needs are provided for, perhaps, in a way, to an extent that we've never before even dreamed of. Unprecedented in human history.
And yet, we're stripped of any kind of meaningful work. We have no purpose. We're escaping to virtual reality. And then you could imagine all sorts of worrying countercultures or Luddite movements or what have you. I guess that's the kind of scenario that – I haven't sketched it terribly well – but that's the kind of thing that worries me more than missile-toting giant robots.
As to utopian, yes, that's interesting. I certainly mentioned a couple of things. One thing that I hope is that this new technological revolution enables us to undo some of the damage of the last one. That's a very utopian thought and not terribly realistic, but we use fossil fuels so incredibly efficiently. The idea that driverless cars that are shared, basically a kind of shared service located off a Brownfield site does away with 95 per cent of all cars, freeing up a huge amount of space in the city to be greener, many fewer cars need to be produced, they would be on the road much less, there'd be fewer traffic jams.
It's just one example, but the idea that we can live much more resource-efficiently, because we are living more intelligently through using these tools. And therefore can undo some of the damage of the last Industrial Revolution. That's my main utopian hope, I guess.
Vintage toy robot image by josefkubes/Shutterstock
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/machines/the-future-of-intelligence | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | How would Stephen compare humans and machines? | 99901_MBDYN8BH_4 | [
"He thinks they are similar enough that a conflict will arise",
"They are complementary in their abilities and can benefit from one another",
"They operate with similar systems of intelligence but to entirely different ends",
"Humans are at risk of losing access to knowledge if they let machines take over most tasks"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,901 | 99901_MBDYN8BH | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | AI: what's the worst that could happen? | 2017.0 | Harry Armstrong | Magazine article | AI: what's the worst that could happen?
The Centre for the Future of Intelligence is seeking to investigate the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity, and make sure humans take advantage of the opportunities while dodging the risks. It launched at the University of Cambridge last October, and is a collaboration between four universities and colleges – Cambridge, Oxford, Imperial and Berkeley – backed with a 10-year, £10m grant from the Leverhulme Trust.
Because no single discipline is ideally suited to this task, the centre emphasises the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge-sharing and collaboration. It is bringing together a diverse community of some of the world's best researchers, philosophers, psychologists, lawyers and computer scientists.
Executive director of the centre is Stephen Cave, a writer, philosopher and former diplomat. Harry Armstrong, head of futures at Nesta, which publishes The Long + Short, spoke with Cave about the impact of AI.
Their conversation has been edited.
Harry Armstrong: Do you see the interdisciplinary nature of the centre as one of its key values and one of the key impacts you hope it will have on the field?
Stephen Cave: Thinking about the impact of AI is not something that any one discipline owns or does in any very systematic way. So if academia is going to rise to the challenge and provide thought leadership on this hugely important issue, then we’re going to need to do it by breaking down current disciplinary boundaries and bringing people with very different expertise together.
That means bringing together the technologists and the experts at developing these algorithms together with social scientists, philosophers, legal scholars and so forth.
I think there are many areas of science where more interdisciplinary engagement would be valuable. Biotech’s another example. In that sense AI isn’t unique, but I think because thinking about AI is still in very early stages, we have an opportunity to shape the way in which we think about it, and build that community.
We want to create a space where many different disciplines can come together and develop a shared language, learn from each other’s approaches, and hopefully very quickly move to be able to actually develop new ideas, new conclusions, together. But the first step is learning how to talk to each other.
At a recent talk, Naomi Klein said that addressing the challenge of climate change could not have come at a worse time. The current dominant political and economic ideologies, along with growing isolationist sentiment, runs contrary to the bipartisan, collaborative approaches needed to solve global issues like climate change. Do you see the same issues hampering a global effort to respond to the challenges AI raises?
Climate change suffers from the problem that the costs are not incurred in any direct way by the industrialists who own the technology and are profiting from it. With AI, that has been the case so far; although not on the same scale. There has been disruption but so far, compared to industrialisation, the impact has been fairly small. That will probably change.
AI companies, and in particular the big tech companies, are very concerned that this won't go like climate change, but rather it will go like GMOs: that people will have a gut reaction to this technology as soon as the first great swathe of job losses take hold. People speculate that 50m jobs could be lost in the US if trucking is automated, which is conceivable within 10 years. You could imagine a populist US government therefore simply banning driverless cars.
So I think there is anxiety in the tech industry that there could be a serious reaction against this technology at any point. And so my impression is that there is a feeling within these companies that these ethical and social implications need to be taken very seriously, now. And that a broad buy-in by society into some kind of vision of the future in which this technology plays a role is required, if a dangerous – or to them dangerous – counteraction is to be avoided.
My personal experience working with these tech companies is that they are concerned for their businesses and genuinely want to do the right thing. Of course there are intellectual challenges and there is money to be made, but equally they are people who don't think when they get up in the morning that they're going to put people out of jobs or bring about the downfall of humanity. As the industry matures it's developing a sense of responsibility.
So I think we've got a real opportunity, despite the general climate, and in some ways because of it. There's a great opportunity to bring industry on board to make sure the technology is developed in the right way.
One of the dominant narratives around not only AI but technology and automation more generally is that we, as humans, are at the mercy of technological progress. If you try and push against this idea you can be labelled as being anti-progress and stuck in the past. But we do have a lot more control than we give ourselves credit for. For example, routineness and susceptibility to automation are not inevitable features of occupations, job design is hugely important. How do we design jobs? How do we create jobs that allow people to do the kind of work they want to do? There can be a bit of a conflict between being impacted by what's happening and having some sort of control over what we want to happen.
Certainly, we encounter technological determinism a lot. And it's understandable. For us as individuals, of course it does feel like it always is happening and we just have to cope. No one individual can do much about it, other than adapt.
But that's different when we consider ourselves at a level of a society, as a polis [city state], or as an international community. I think we can shape the way in which technology develops. We have various tools. In any given country, we have regulations. There's a possibility of international regulation.
Technology is emerging from a certain legal, political, normative, cultural, and social framework. It's coming from a certain place. And it is shaped by all of those things.
And I think the more we understand a technology's relationship with those things, and the more we then consciously try to shape those things, the more we are going to influence the technology. So, for example, developing a culture of responsible innovation. For example, a kind of Hippocratic oath for AI developers. These things are within the realms of what is feasible, and I think will help to shape the future.
One of the problems with intervention, generally, is that we cannot control the course of events. We can attempt to, but we don't know how things are going to evolve. The reality is, societies are much too complex for us to be able to shape them in any very specific way, as plenty of ideologies and political movements have found to their cost. There are often unforeseen consequences that can derail a project.
I think, nonetheless, there are things we can do. We can try to imagine how things might go very badly wrong, and then work hard to develop systems that will stop that from happening. We can also try collectively to imagine how things could go very right. The kind of society that we actually want to live in that uses this technology. And I'm sure that will be skewed in all sorts of ways, and we might imagine things that seem wonderful and actually have terrible by-products.
This conversation cannot be in the hands of any one group. It oughtn't be in the hands of Silicon Valley billionaires alone. They've got their role to play, but this is a conversation we need to be having as widely as possible.
The centre is developing some really interesting projects but perhaps one of the most interesting is the discussion of what intelligence might be. Could you go into a bit more detail about the kinds of questions you are trying to explore in this area?
You mean kinds of intelligence?
Yeah.
I think this is very important because historically, we've had an overwhelming tendency to anthropomorphise. We define what intelligence is, historically, as being human-like. And then within that, being like certain humans.
And it's taken a very long time for the academic community to accept that there could be such a thing as non-human intelligence at all. We know that crows, for example, who have had a completely different evolutionary history, or octopuses, who have an even more different evolutionary history, might have a kind of intelligence that's very different to ours. That in some ways rivals our own, and so forth.
But luckily, we have got to that point in recent years of accepting that we are not the only form of intelligence. But now, AI is challenging that from a different direction. Just as we are accepting that the natural world offers this enormous range of different intelligences, we are at the same time inventing new intelligences that are radically different to humans.
And I think, still, this anthropomorphic picture of the kind of humanoid android, the robot, dominates our idea of what AI is too much. And too many people, and the industry as well, talk about human-level artificial intelligence as a goal, or general AI, which basically means like a human. But actually what we're building is nothing like a human.
When the first pocket calculator was made, it didn't do maths like a human. It was vastly better. It didn't make the occasional mistake. When we set about creating these artificial agents to solve these problems, because they have a completely different evolutionary history to humans, they solve problems in very different ways.
And until now, people have been fairly shy about describing them as intelligent. Or rather, in the history of AIs, we think solving a particular problem would require intelligence. Then we solve it. And then that's no longer intelligence, because we've solved it. Chess is a good example.
But the reality is, we are creating a whole new world of different artificial agents. And we need to understand that world. We need to understand all the different ways of being clever, if you like. How you can be extremely sophisticated at some particular rational process, and yet extremely bad at another one in a way that bears no relation to the way humans are on these axes.
And this is important, partly because we need to expand our sense of what is intelligent, like we have done with the natural world. Because lots of things follow from saying something is intelligent. Historically, we have a long tradition in Western philosophy of saying those who are intelligent should rule. So if intelligence equates to power, then obviously we need to think about what we mean by intelligence. Who has it and who doesn't. Or how it equates to rights and responsibilities.
It certainly is a very ambitious project to create the atlas of intelligence.
There was a point I read in something you wrote on our ideas of intelligence that I thought was very interesting. We actually tend to think of intelligence at the societal level when we think about human ability, rather than at the individual level but in the end conflate the two. I think that's a very good point, when we think about our capabilities, we think about what we can achieve as a whole, not individually. But when we talk about AI, we tend to think about that individual piece of technology, or that individual system. So for example if we think about the internet of things and AI, we should discuss intelligence as something encompassed by the whole.
Yeah, absolutely. Yes, right now, perhaps it is a product of our anthropomorphising bias. But there is a tendency to see a narrative of AI versus humanity, as if it's one or the other. And yet, obviously, there are risks in this technology long before it acquires any kind of manipulative agency.
Robotic technology is dangerous. Or potentially dangerous. But at the same time, most of what we're using technology for is to enhance ourselves, to increase our capacities. And a lot of what AI is going to be doing is augmenting us – we're going to be working as teams, AI-human teams.
Where do you think this AI-human conflict, or concept of a conflict, comes from? Do you think that's just a reflection of historical conversations we've had about automation, or do you think it is a deeper fear?
I do think it comes both from some biases that might well be innate, such as anthropomorphism, or our human tendency to ascribe agency to other objects, particularly moving ones, is well-established and probably has sound evolutionary roots. If it moves, it's probably wise to start asking yourself questions like, "What is it? What might it want? Where might it be going? Might it be hungry? Do I look like food to it?" I think it makes sense, it's natural for us to think in terms of agency. And when we do, it's natural for us to project our own ways of being and acting. And we, as primates, are profoundly co-operative.
But at the same time, we're competitive and murderous. We have a strong sense of in-group versus out-group, which is responsible for both a great deal of cooperation, within the in-group, but also terrible crimes. Murder, rape, pillage, genocide; and they're pointed at the out-group.
And so I think it's very natural for us to see AIs in terms of agents. We anthropomorphise them as these kind of android robots. And then we think about, well, you know, are they part of our in-group, or are they some other group? If they're some other group, it's us against them. Who's going to win? Well, let's see. So I think that's very natural, I think that's very human.
There is this long tradition, in Western culture in particular, with associating intelligence and dominance and power. It's interesting to speculate about how, and I wish I knew more about it, and I'd like to see more research on this, about how different cultures perceive AI. It's well known that Japan is very accepting of technology and robots, for example.
You can think, well, we in the West have long been justifying power relations of a certain kind on the basis that we're 'cleverer'. That's why men get to vote and women don't, or whatever. In a culture where power is not based on intelligence but, say, on a caste system, which is purely hereditary, we’d build an AI, and it would just tune in, drop out, attain enlightenment, just sit in the corner. Or we beg it to come back and help us find enlightenment. It might be that we find a completely different narrative to the one that's dominant in the West.
One of the projects the centre is running is looking into what kind of AI breakthroughs may come, when and what the social consequences could be. What do you think the future holds? What are your fears – what do you think could go right and wrong in the short, medium and long term?
That's a big question. Certainly I don't lie awake at night worried that robots are going to knock the door down and come in with a machine gun. If the robots take over the world, it won't be by knocking the door down. At the moment, I think it's certainly as big a risk that we have a GMO moment, and there's a powerful reaction against the technology which prevents us from reaping the benefits, which are enormous. I think that's as big a risk as the risks from the technologies themselves.
I think one worry that we haven't talked about is that we've become extremely dependent upon this technology. And that we essentially become deskilled. There's an extent to which the history of civilisation is the history of the domestication of the human species sort of by ourselves, and also by our technology, to some extent. And AI certainly allows for that to reach a whole new level.
Just think about GPs with diagnostic tools. Even now, my GP consults the computer fairly regularly. But as diagnostic tools get better, what are they going to be doing other than just typing something into the computer and reading out what comes back? At which point, you might as well do away with the GP. But then, who does know about medicine?
And so we do need to worry about deskilling and about becoming dependent. And it is entirely possible that you can imagine a society in which we're all sort of prosperous, in a sense. Our basic bodily needs are provided for, perhaps, in a way, to an extent that we've never before even dreamed of. Unprecedented in human history.
And yet, we're stripped of any kind of meaningful work. We have no purpose. We're escaping to virtual reality. And then you could imagine all sorts of worrying countercultures or Luddite movements or what have you. I guess that's the kind of scenario that – I haven't sketched it terribly well – but that's the kind of thing that worries me more than missile-toting giant robots.
As to utopian, yes, that's interesting. I certainly mentioned a couple of things. One thing that I hope is that this new technological revolution enables us to undo some of the damage of the last one. That's a very utopian thought and not terribly realistic, but we use fossil fuels so incredibly efficiently. The idea that driverless cars that are shared, basically a kind of shared service located off a Brownfield site does away with 95 per cent of all cars, freeing up a huge amount of space in the city to be greener, many fewer cars need to be produced, they would be on the road much less, there'd be fewer traffic jams.
It's just one example, but the idea that we can live much more resource-efficiently, because we are living more intelligently through using these tools. And therefore can undo some of the damage of the last Industrial Revolution. That's my main utopian hope, I guess.
Vintage toy robot image by josefkubes/Shutterstock
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/machines/the-future-of-intelligence | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which is the most likely social consequence of AIs? | 99901_MBDYN8BH_5 | [
"The AI developers will be able to shape societal structures as they see fit",
"There will be an overwhelming amount of regulation that will add control to people's lives",
"Over-reliance on technology might cause some loss of valuable intuition from educated people",
"There will be no jobs left for humans to complete if AIs continue developing"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0020",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,901 | 99901_MBDYN8BH | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | AI: what's the worst that could happen? | 2017.0 | Harry Armstrong | Magazine article | AI: what's the worst that could happen?
The Centre for the Future of Intelligence is seeking to investigate the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity, and make sure humans take advantage of the opportunities while dodging the risks. It launched at the University of Cambridge last October, and is a collaboration between four universities and colleges – Cambridge, Oxford, Imperial and Berkeley – backed with a 10-year, £10m grant from the Leverhulme Trust.
Because no single discipline is ideally suited to this task, the centre emphasises the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge-sharing and collaboration. It is bringing together a diverse community of some of the world's best researchers, philosophers, psychologists, lawyers and computer scientists.
Executive director of the centre is Stephen Cave, a writer, philosopher and former diplomat. Harry Armstrong, head of futures at Nesta, which publishes The Long + Short, spoke with Cave about the impact of AI.
Their conversation has been edited.
Harry Armstrong: Do you see the interdisciplinary nature of the centre as one of its key values and one of the key impacts you hope it will have on the field?
Stephen Cave: Thinking about the impact of AI is not something that any one discipline owns or does in any very systematic way. So if academia is going to rise to the challenge and provide thought leadership on this hugely important issue, then we’re going to need to do it by breaking down current disciplinary boundaries and bringing people with very different expertise together.
That means bringing together the technologists and the experts at developing these algorithms together with social scientists, philosophers, legal scholars and so forth.
I think there are many areas of science where more interdisciplinary engagement would be valuable. Biotech’s another example. In that sense AI isn’t unique, but I think because thinking about AI is still in very early stages, we have an opportunity to shape the way in which we think about it, and build that community.
We want to create a space where many different disciplines can come together and develop a shared language, learn from each other’s approaches, and hopefully very quickly move to be able to actually develop new ideas, new conclusions, together. But the first step is learning how to talk to each other.
At a recent talk, Naomi Klein said that addressing the challenge of climate change could not have come at a worse time. The current dominant political and economic ideologies, along with growing isolationist sentiment, runs contrary to the bipartisan, collaborative approaches needed to solve global issues like climate change. Do you see the same issues hampering a global effort to respond to the challenges AI raises?
Climate change suffers from the problem that the costs are not incurred in any direct way by the industrialists who own the technology and are profiting from it. With AI, that has been the case so far; although not on the same scale. There has been disruption but so far, compared to industrialisation, the impact has been fairly small. That will probably change.
AI companies, and in particular the big tech companies, are very concerned that this won't go like climate change, but rather it will go like GMOs: that people will have a gut reaction to this technology as soon as the first great swathe of job losses take hold. People speculate that 50m jobs could be lost in the US if trucking is automated, which is conceivable within 10 years. You could imagine a populist US government therefore simply banning driverless cars.
So I think there is anxiety in the tech industry that there could be a serious reaction against this technology at any point. And so my impression is that there is a feeling within these companies that these ethical and social implications need to be taken very seriously, now. And that a broad buy-in by society into some kind of vision of the future in which this technology plays a role is required, if a dangerous – or to them dangerous – counteraction is to be avoided.
My personal experience working with these tech companies is that they are concerned for their businesses and genuinely want to do the right thing. Of course there are intellectual challenges and there is money to be made, but equally they are people who don't think when they get up in the morning that they're going to put people out of jobs or bring about the downfall of humanity. As the industry matures it's developing a sense of responsibility.
So I think we've got a real opportunity, despite the general climate, and in some ways because of it. There's a great opportunity to bring industry on board to make sure the technology is developed in the right way.
One of the dominant narratives around not only AI but technology and automation more generally is that we, as humans, are at the mercy of technological progress. If you try and push against this idea you can be labelled as being anti-progress and stuck in the past. But we do have a lot more control than we give ourselves credit for. For example, routineness and susceptibility to automation are not inevitable features of occupations, job design is hugely important. How do we design jobs? How do we create jobs that allow people to do the kind of work they want to do? There can be a bit of a conflict between being impacted by what's happening and having some sort of control over what we want to happen.
Certainly, we encounter technological determinism a lot. And it's understandable. For us as individuals, of course it does feel like it always is happening and we just have to cope. No one individual can do much about it, other than adapt.
But that's different when we consider ourselves at a level of a society, as a polis [city state], or as an international community. I think we can shape the way in which technology develops. We have various tools. In any given country, we have regulations. There's a possibility of international regulation.
Technology is emerging from a certain legal, political, normative, cultural, and social framework. It's coming from a certain place. And it is shaped by all of those things.
And I think the more we understand a technology's relationship with those things, and the more we then consciously try to shape those things, the more we are going to influence the technology. So, for example, developing a culture of responsible innovation. For example, a kind of Hippocratic oath for AI developers. These things are within the realms of what is feasible, and I think will help to shape the future.
One of the problems with intervention, generally, is that we cannot control the course of events. We can attempt to, but we don't know how things are going to evolve. The reality is, societies are much too complex for us to be able to shape them in any very specific way, as plenty of ideologies and political movements have found to their cost. There are often unforeseen consequences that can derail a project.
I think, nonetheless, there are things we can do. We can try to imagine how things might go very badly wrong, and then work hard to develop systems that will stop that from happening. We can also try collectively to imagine how things could go very right. The kind of society that we actually want to live in that uses this technology. And I'm sure that will be skewed in all sorts of ways, and we might imagine things that seem wonderful and actually have terrible by-products.
This conversation cannot be in the hands of any one group. It oughtn't be in the hands of Silicon Valley billionaires alone. They've got their role to play, but this is a conversation we need to be having as widely as possible.
The centre is developing some really interesting projects but perhaps one of the most interesting is the discussion of what intelligence might be. Could you go into a bit more detail about the kinds of questions you are trying to explore in this area?
You mean kinds of intelligence?
Yeah.
I think this is very important because historically, we've had an overwhelming tendency to anthropomorphise. We define what intelligence is, historically, as being human-like. And then within that, being like certain humans.
And it's taken a very long time for the academic community to accept that there could be such a thing as non-human intelligence at all. We know that crows, for example, who have had a completely different evolutionary history, or octopuses, who have an even more different evolutionary history, might have a kind of intelligence that's very different to ours. That in some ways rivals our own, and so forth.
But luckily, we have got to that point in recent years of accepting that we are not the only form of intelligence. But now, AI is challenging that from a different direction. Just as we are accepting that the natural world offers this enormous range of different intelligences, we are at the same time inventing new intelligences that are radically different to humans.
And I think, still, this anthropomorphic picture of the kind of humanoid android, the robot, dominates our idea of what AI is too much. And too many people, and the industry as well, talk about human-level artificial intelligence as a goal, or general AI, which basically means like a human. But actually what we're building is nothing like a human.
When the first pocket calculator was made, it didn't do maths like a human. It was vastly better. It didn't make the occasional mistake. When we set about creating these artificial agents to solve these problems, because they have a completely different evolutionary history to humans, they solve problems in very different ways.
And until now, people have been fairly shy about describing them as intelligent. Or rather, in the history of AIs, we think solving a particular problem would require intelligence. Then we solve it. And then that's no longer intelligence, because we've solved it. Chess is a good example.
But the reality is, we are creating a whole new world of different artificial agents. And we need to understand that world. We need to understand all the different ways of being clever, if you like. How you can be extremely sophisticated at some particular rational process, and yet extremely bad at another one in a way that bears no relation to the way humans are on these axes.
And this is important, partly because we need to expand our sense of what is intelligent, like we have done with the natural world. Because lots of things follow from saying something is intelligent. Historically, we have a long tradition in Western philosophy of saying those who are intelligent should rule. So if intelligence equates to power, then obviously we need to think about what we mean by intelligence. Who has it and who doesn't. Or how it equates to rights and responsibilities.
It certainly is a very ambitious project to create the atlas of intelligence.
There was a point I read in something you wrote on our ideas of intelligence that I thought was very interesting. We actually tend to think of intelligence at the societal level when we think about human ability, rather than at the individual level but in the end conflate the two. I think that's a very good point, when we think about our capabilities, we think about what we can achieve as a whole, not individually. But when we talk about AI, we tend to think about that individual piece of technology, or that individual system. So for example if we think about the internet of things and AI, we should discuss intelligence as something encompassed by the whole.
Yeah, absolutely. Yes, right now, perhaps it is a product of our anthropomorphising bias. But there is a tendency to see a narrative of AI versus humanity, as if it's one or the other. And yet, obviously, there are risks in this technology long before it acquires any kind of manipulative agency.
Robotic technology is dangerous. Or potentially dangerous. But at the same time, most of what we're using technology for is to enhance ourselves, to increase our capacities. And a lot of what AI is going to be doing is augmenting us – we're going to be working as teams, AI-human teams.
Where do you think this AI-human conflict, or concept of a conflict, comes from? Do you think that's just a reflection of historical conversations we've had about automation, or do you think it is a deeper fear?
I do think it comes both from some biases that might well be innate, such as anthropomorphism, or our human tendency to ascribe agency to other objects, particularly moving ones, is well-established and probably has sound evolutionary roots. If it moves, it's probably wise to start asking yourself questions like, "What is it? What might it want? Where might it be going? Might it be hungry? Do I look like food to it?" I think it makes sense, it's natural for us to think in terms of agency. And when we do, it's natural for us to project our own ways of being and acting. And we, as primates, are profoundly co-operative.
But at the same time, we're competitive and murderous. We have a strong sense of in-group versus out-group, which is responsible for both a great deal of cooperation, within the in-group, but also terrible crimes. Murder, rape, pillage, genocide; and they're pointed at the out-group.
And so I think it's very natural for us to see AIs in terms of agents. We anthropomorphise them as these kind of android robots. And then we think about, well, you know, are they part of our in-group, or are they some other group? If they're some other group, it's us against them. Who's going to win? Well, let's see. So I think that's very natural, I think that's very human.
There is this long tradition, in Western culture in particular, with associating intelligence and dominance and power. It's interesting to speculate about how, and I wish I knew more about it, and I'd like to see more research on this, about how different cultures perceive AI. It's well known that Japan is very accepting of technology and robots, for example.
You can think, well, we in the West have long been justifying power relations of a certain kind on the basis that we're 'cleverer'. That's why men get to vote and women don't, or whatever. In a culture where power is not based on intelligence but, say, on a caste system, which is purely hereditary, we’d build an AI, and it would just tune in, drop out, attain enlightenment, just sit in the corner. Or we beg it to come back and help us find enlightenment. It might be that we find a completely different narrative to the one that's dominant in the West.
One of the projects the centre is running is looking into what kind of AI breakthroughs may come, when and what the social consequences could be. What do you think the future holds? What are your fears – what do you think could go right and wrong in the short, medium and long term?
That's a big question. Certainly I don't lie awake at night worried that robots are going to knock the door down and come in with a machine gun. If the robots take over the world, it won't be by knocking the door down. At the moment, I think it's certainly as big a risk that we have a GMO moment, and there's a powerful reaction against the technology which prevents us from reaping the benefits, which are enormous. I think that's as big a risk as the risks from the technologies themselves.
I think one worry that we haven't talked about is that we've become extremely dependent upon this technology. And that we essentially become deskilled. There's an extent to which the history of civilisation is the history of the domestication of the human species sort of by ourselves, and also by our technology, to some extent. And AI certainly allows for that to reach a whole new level.
Just think about GPs with diagnostic tools. Even now, my GP consults the computer fairly regularly. But as diagnostic tools get better, what are they going to be doing other than just typing something into the computer and reading out what comes back? At which point, you might as well do away with the GP. But then, who does know about medicine?
And so we do need to worry about deskilling and about becoming dependent. And it is entirely possible that you can imagine a society in which we're all sort of prosperous, in a sense. Our basic bodily needs are provided for, perhaps, in a way, to an extent that we've never before even dreamed of. Unprecedented in human history.
And yet, we're stripped of any kind of meaningful work. We have no purpose. We're escaping to virtual reality. And then you could imagine all sorts of worrying countercultures or Luddite movements or what have you. I guess that's the kind of scenario that – I haven't sketched it terribly well – but that's the kind of thing that worries me more than missile-toting giant robots.
As to utopian, yes, that's interesting. I certainly mentioned a couple of things. One thing that I hope is that this new technological revolution enables us to undo some of the damage of the last one. That's a very utopian thought and not terribly realistic, but we use fossil fuels so incredibly efficiently. The idea that driverless cars that are shared, basically a kind of shared service located off a Brownfield site does away with 95 per cent of all cars, freeing up a huge amount of space in the city to be greener, many fewer cars need to be produced, they would be on the road much less, there'd be fewer traffic jams.
It's just one example, but the idea that we can live much more resource-efficiently, because we are living more intelligently through using these tools. And therefore can undo some of the damage of the last Industrial Revolution. That's my main utopian hope, I guess.
Vintage toy robot image by josefkubes/Shutterstock
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/machines/the-future-of-intelligence | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which best describes Stephen's vision for the future of innovation? | 99901_MBDYN8BH_6 | [
"He thinks innovation should be led by the AI developers but checked by people in other industrues",
"The regulation of technological development will provide the necessary structure for successful innovation",
"He says that international connections are the only way true innovation will happen over time",
"He wants people to be responsible and held accountable by different kinds of people"
] | 4 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 1 |
99,901 | 99901_MBDYN8BH | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | AI: what's the worst that could happen? | 2017.0 | Harry Armstrong | Magazine article | AI: what's the worst that could happen?
The Centre for the Future of Intelligence is seeking to investigate the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity, and make sure humans take advantage of the opportunities while dodging the risks. It launched at the University of Cambridge last October, and is a collaboration between four universities and colleges – Cambridge, Oxford, Imperial and Berkeley – backed with a 10-year, £10m grant from the Leverhulme Trust.
Because no single discipline is ideally suited to this task, the centre emphasises the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge-sharing and collaboration. It is bringing together a diverse community of some of the world's best researchers, philosophers, psychologists, lawyers and computer scientists.
Executive director of the centre is Stephen Cave, a writer, philosopher and former diplomat. Harry Armstrong, head of futures at Nesta, which publishes The Long + Short, spoke with Cave about the impact of AI.
Their conversation has been edited.
Harry Armstrong: Do you see the interdisciplinary nature of the centre as one of its key values and one of the key impacts you hope it will have on the field?
Stephen Cave: Thinking about the impact of AI is not something that any one discipline owns or does in any very systematic way. So if academia is going to rise to the challenge and provide thought leadership on this hugely important issue, then we’re going to need to do it by breaking down current disciplinary boundaries and bringing people with very different expertise together.
That means bringing together the technologists and the experts at developing these algorithms together with social scientists, philosophers, legal scholars and so forth.
I think there are many areas of science where more interdisciplinary engagement would be valuable. Biotech’s another example. In that sense AI isn’t unique, but I think because thinking about AI is still in very early stages, we have an opportunity to shape the way in which we think about it, and build that community.
We want to create a space where many different disciplines can come together and develop a shared language, learn from each other’s approaches, and hopefully very quickly move to be able to actually develop new ideas, new conclusions, together. But the first step is learning how to talk to each other.
At a recent talk, Naomi Klein said that addressing the challenge of climate change could not have come at a worse time. The current dominant political and economic ideologies, along with growing isolationist sentiment, runs contrary to the bipartisan, collaborative approaches needed to solve global issues like climate change. Do you see the same issues hampering a global effort to respond to the challenges AI raises?
Climate change suffers from the problem that the costs are not incurred in any direct way by the industrialists who own the technology and are profiting from it. With AI, that has been the case so far; although not on the same scale. There has been disruption but so far, compared to industrialisation, the impact has been fairly small. That will probably change.
AI companies, and in particular the big tech companies, are very concerned that this won't go like climate change, but rather it will go like GMOs: that people will have a gut reaction to this technology as soon as the first great swathe of job losses take hold. People speculate that 50m jobs could be lost in the US if trucking is automated, which is conceivable within 10 years. You could imagine a populist US government therefore simply banning driverless cars.
So I think there is anxiety in the tech industry that there could be a serious reaction against this technology at any point. And so my impression is that there is a feeling within these companies that these ethical and social implications need to be taken very seriously, now. And that a broad buy-in by society into some kind of vision of the future in which this technology plays a role is required, if a dangerous – or to them dangerous – counteraction is to be avoided.
My personal experience working with these tech companies is that they are concerned for their businesses and genuinely want to do the right thing. Of course there are intellectual challenges and there is money to be made, but equally they are people who don't think when they get up in the morning that they're going to put people out of jobs or bring about the downfall of humanity. As the industry matures it's developing a sense of responsibility.
So I think we've got a real opportunity, despite the general climate, and in some ways because of it. There's a great opportunity to bring industry on board to make sure the technology is developed in the right way.
One of the dominant narratives around not only AI but technology and automation more generally is that we, as humans, are at the mercy of technological progress. If you try and push against this idea you can be labelled as being anti-progress and stuck in the past. But we do have a lot more control than we give ourselves credit for. For example, routineness and susceptibility to automation are not inevitable features of occupations, job design is hugely important. How do we design jobs? How do we create jobs that allow people to do the kind of work they want to do? There can be a bit of a conflict between being impacted by what's happening and having some sort of control over what we want to happen.
Certainly, we encounter technological determinism a lot. And it's understandable. For us as individuals, of course it does feel like it always is happening and we just have to cope. No one individual can do much about it, other than adapt.
But that's different when we consider ourselves at a level of a society, as a polis [city state], or as an international community. I think we can shape the way in which technology develops. We have various tools. In any given country, we have regulations. There's a possibility of international regulation.
Technology is emerging from a certain legal, political, normative, cultural, and social framework. It's coming from a certain place. And it is shaped by all of those things.
And I think the more we understand a technology's relationship with those things, and the more we then consciously try to shape those things, the more we are going to influence the technology. So, for example, developing a culture of responsible innovation. For example, a kind of Hippocratic oath for AI developers. These things are within the realms of what is feasible, and I think will help to shape the future.
One of the problems with intervention, generally, is that we cannot control the course of events. We can attempt to, but we don't know how things are going to evolve. The reality is, societies are much too complex for us to be able to shape them in any very specific way, as plenty of ideologies and political movements have found to their cost. There are often unforeseen consequences that can derail a project.
I think, nonetheless, there are things we can do. We can try to imagine how things might go very badly wrong, and then work hard to develop systems that will stop that from happening. We can also try collectively to imagine how things could go very right. The kind of society that we actually want to live in that uses this technology. And I'm sure that will be skewed in all sorts of ways, and we might imagine things that seem wonderful and actually have terrible by-products.
This conversation cannot be in the hands of any one group. It oughtn't be in the hands of Silicon Valley billionaires alone. They've got their role to play, but this is a conversation we need to be having as widely as possible.
The centre is developing some really interesting projects but perhaps one of the most interesting is the discussion of what intelligence might be. Could you go into a bit more detail about the kinds of questions you are trying to explore in this area?
You mean kinds of intelligence?
Yeah.
I think this is very important because historically, we've had an overwhelming tendency to anthropomorphise. We define what intelligence is, historically, as being human-like. And then within that, being like certain humans.
And it's taken a very long time for the academic community to accept that there could be such a thing as non-human intelligence at all. We know that crows, for example, who have had a completely different evolutionary history, or octopuses, who have an even more different evolutionary history, might have a kind of intelligence that's very different to ours. That in some ways rivals our own, and so forth.
But luckily, we have got to that point in recent years of accepting that we are not the only form of intelligence. But now, AI is challenging that from a different direction. Just as we are accepting that the natural world offers this enormous range of different intelligences, we are at the same time inventing new intelligences that are radically different to humans.
And I think, still, this anthropomorphic picture of the kind of humanoid android, the robot, dominates our idea of what AI is too much. And too many people, and the industry as well, talk about human-level artificial intelligence as a goal, or general AI, which basically means like a human. But actually what we're building is nothing like a human.
When the first pocket calculator was made, it didn't do maths like a human. It was vastly better. It didn't make the occasional mistake. When we set about creating these artificial agents to solve these problems, because they have a completely different evolutionary history to humans, they solve problems in very different ways.
And until now, people have been fairly shy about describing them as intelligent. Or rather, in the history of AIs, we think solving a particular problem would require intelligence. Then we solve it. And then that's no longer intelligence, because we've solved it. Chess is a good example.
But the reality is, we are creating a whole new world of different artificial agents. And we need to understand that world. We need to understand all the different ways of being clever, if you like. How you can be extremely sophisticated at some particular rational process, and yet extremely bad at another one in a way that bears no relation to the way humans are on these axes.
And this is important, partly because we need to expand our sense of what is intelligent, like we have done with the natural world. Because lots of things follow from saying something is intelligent. Historically, we have a long tradition in Western philosophy of saying those who are intelligent should rule. So if intelligence equates to power, then obviously we need to think about what we mean by intelligence. Who has it and who doesn't. Or how it equates to rights and responsibilities.
It certainly is a very ambitious project to create the atlas of intelligence.
There was a point I read in something you wrote on our ideas of intelligence that I thought was very interesting. We actually tend to think of intelligence at the societal level when we think about human ability, rather than at the individual level but in the end conflate the two. I think that's a very good point, when we think about our capabilities, we think about what we can achieve as a whole, not individually. But when we talk about AI, we tend to think about that individual piece of technology, or that individual system. So for example if we think about the internet of things and AI, we should discuss intelligence as something encompassed by the whole.
Yeah, absolutely. Yes, right now, perhaps it is a product of our anthropomorphising bias. But there is a tendency to see a narrative of AI versus humanity, as if it's one or the other. And yet, obviously, there are risks in this technology long before it acquires any kind of manipulative agency.
Robotic technology is dangerous. Or potentially dangerous. But at the same time, most of what we're using technology for is to enhance ourselves, to increase our capacities. And a lot of what AI is going to be doing is augmenting us – we're going to be working as teams, AI-human teams.
Where do you think this AI-human conflict, or concept of a conflict, comes from? Do you think that's just a reflection of historical conversations we've had about automation, or do you think it is a deeper fear?
I do think it comes both from some biases that might well be innate, such as anthropomorphism, or our human tendency to ascribe agency to other objects, particularly moving ones, is well-established and probably has sound evolutionary roots. If it moves, it's probably wise to start asking yourself questions like, "What is it? What might it want? Where might it be going? Might it be hungry? Do I look like food to it?" I think it makes sense, it's natural for us to think in terms of agency. And when we do, it's natural for us to project our own ways of being and acting. And we, as primates, are profoundly co-operative.
But at the same time, we're competitive and murderous. We have a strong sense of in-group versus out-group, which is responsible for both a great deal of cooperation, within the in-group, but also terrible crimes. Murder, rape, pillage, genocide; and they're pointed at the out-group.
And so I think it's very natural for us to see AIs in terms of agents. We anthropomorphise them as these kind of android robots. And then we think about, well, you know, are they part of our in-group, or are they some other group? If they're some other group, it's us against them. Who's going to win? Well, let's see. So I think that's very natural, I think that's very human.
There is this long tradition, in Western culture in particular, with associating intelligence and dominance and power. It's interesting to speculate about how, and I wish I knew more about it, and I'd like to see more research on this, about how different cultures perceive AI. It's well known that Japan is very accepting of technology and robots, for example.
You can think, well, we in the West have long been justifying power relations of a certain kind on the basis that we're 'cleverer'. That's why men get to vote and women don't, or whatever. In a culture where power is not based on intelligence but, say, on a caste system, which is purely hereditary, we’d build an AI, and it would just tune in, drop out, attain enlightenment, just sit in the corner. Or we beg it to come back and help us find enlightenment. It might be that we find a completely different narrative to the one that's dominant in the West.
One of the projects the centre is running is looking into what kind of AI breakthroughs may come, when and what the social consequences could be. What do you think the future holds? What are your fears – what do you think could go right and wrong in the short, medium and long term?
That's a big question. Certainly I don't lie awake at night worried that robots are going to knock the door down and come in with a machine gun. If the robots take over the world, it won't be by knocking the door down. At the moment, I think it's certainly as big a risk that we have a GMO moment, and there's a powerful reaction against the technology which prevents us from reaping the benefits, which are enormous. I think that's as big a risk as the risks from the technologies themselves.
I think one worry that we haven't talked about is that we've become extremely dependent upon this technology. And that we essentially become deskilled. There's an extent to which the history of civilisation is the history of the domestication of the human species sort of by ourselves, and also by our technology, to some extent. And AI certainly allows for that to reach a whole new level.
Just think about GPs with diagnostic tools. Even now, my GP consults the computer fairly regularly. But as diagnostic tools get better, what are they going to be doing other than just typing something into the computer and reading out what comes back? At which point, you might as well do away with the GP. But then, who does know about medicine?
And so we do need to worry about deskilling and about becoming dependent. And it is entirely possible that you can imagine a society in which we're all sort of prosperous, in a sense. Our basic bodily needs are provided for, perhaps, in a way, to an extent that we've never before even dreamed of. Unprecedented in human history.
And yet, we're stripped of any kind of meaningful work. We have no purpose. We're escaping to virtual reality. And then you could imagine all sorts of worrying countercultures or Luddite movements or what have you. I guess that's the kind of scenario that – I haven't sketched it terribly well – but that's the kind of thing that worries me more than missile-toting giant robots.
As to utopian, yes, that's interesting. I certainly mentioned a couple of things. One thing that I hope is that this new technological revolution enables us to undo some of the damage of the last one. That's a very utopian thought and not terribly realistic, but we use fossil fuels so incredibly efficiently. The idea that driverless cars that are shared, basically a kind of shared service located off a Brownfield site does away with 95 per cent of all cars, freeing up a huge amount of space in the city to be greener, many fewer cars need to be produced, they would be on the road much less, there'd be fewer traffic jams.
It's just one example, but the idea that we can live much more resource-efficiently, because we are living more intelligently through using these tools. And therefore can undo some of the damage of the last Industrial Revolution. That's my main utopian hope, I guess.
Vintage toy robot image by josefkubes/Shutterstock
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/machines/the-future-of-intelligence | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What does Stephen think is the most important impact of trying to be more efficient in using resources? | 99901_MBDYN8BH_7 | [
"It is cheaper for any technology to operate if it has to rely on fewer resources",
"The resources availalbe on the Earth are finite and are running low enough to possibly impede technological progress",
"The earth has been hurt by previous technological developments and it could be partly counteracted",
"Having fewer cars on the road would mean a safer environment for most drivers"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0020",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0003",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is the relationship like between Ed and Sheryl? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_1 | [
"Their relationship is tense as Ed will not get help when he needs it, but it is mostly cordial",
"They are fairly indifferent towards each other but interact more when there are other people around",
"They have a good relationship but do not like to watch the same TV, as Sheryl hates football",
"They are very tense and the only thing that brings them together is their daughter"
] | 1 | 1 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 1,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0018",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 1 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is Sara's relationship with her mom? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_2 | [
"Sara's mom doesn't trust Sara very much given the history Sara has with her dad",
"Sara's mom is endlessly proud of Sara even if this is tense in the rest of the family",
"Sara is worried she has disappointed her mom who is exhausted by being in the middle of a family fight",
"Sara does everything driven by a desire to make her mom proud, and she is praised in return"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is the implication about getting TV networks through Facebook? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_3 | [
"The channels would be customized by age group so Sara would not have anything she'd like to watch",
"There would only be a few channels because it was a basic package",
"There would not be much available to watch besides sports",
"The available media is conservative-leaning which meant Sara would not want to watch it"
] | 4 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0012",
"speed_answer": 1
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 0 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Why is Sara upset when her dad asks her to read the article about solar panels? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_4 | [
"She is embarassed to admit she hasn't read up on the solar panels",
"There is an implication that she's not informed about the job she does every day",
"She was trying to avoid having phones out at the dinner table",
"She doesn't want it to come up that she blocked him on facebook"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 3
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0023",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 0 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | What is the immediate significance of Ed defending the ads on his Facebook? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_5 | [
"It shows how interested in guns he is",
"It shows his dedication to capitalism",
"It shows he has no idea how tailored the feed is ",
"It shows what kinds of things he looks up to purchase"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0016",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0038",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
}
] | 0 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | How does Ed feel about the Super Bowl? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_6 | [
"He doesn't care for football but enjoys all of the celebration around it",
"He loves the ads even more than the game",
"He likes the football and the time he spends with his daughter",
"It is his favorite sporting event and he would never miss a football game"
] | 3 | 3 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 2,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0003",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 2
}
] | 1 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | Which of these is true about the ad break? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_7 | [
"Sara's patience allows for some rebuilding of trust",
"It's ironic that Ed things ads about things that separate people will bring him and his daughter together",
"The family can agree that they all enjoy watching ads together even if other things are rough",
"It is the one chance daughter and father have to patch things up"
] | 2 | 4 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 4,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 4,
"untimed_best_distractor": 1,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 4
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0026",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0017",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0014",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0037",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
}
] | 0 |
99,902 | 99902_T1XG8MCZ | 23 | 1,016 | misc-longshort | Divided we stand | 2017.0 | Tim Maughan | Magazine article | Divided we stand
Sara lets the Lyft park itself in the drive, lets out a sigh, and tweets
wish me luck
plus some emojis before slipping her phone into a hoody pocket. Curtains twitch, and before she can get her bag out of the back Mom is there, right there next to her, their hands touching on the handle as they compete for control.
"It's OK Mom, I got it."
"You should have let us come pick you up."
"It's fine, there was no need. I didn't want to put any-"
"But you shouldn't be wasting money, not with how much rent you pay and-"
Jesus. Not this already. "Mom. I can afford a cab ride. I'm not
that
much of a failure."
Mom sighs, shoulders falling, looks at Sara directly. "I'm sorry honey." She looks old, Sara thinks, watching a resigned tiredness flicker across her face in a way she'd not noticed before. Like she's exhausted by conflict, surrendered to it. "Now, don't I get a hug?"
Sara smiles. They hold each other for a few long seconds, rubbing and squeezing each other as the Lyft silently backs itself out of the driveway. When they part it's Mom's hand that's on the bag's handle.
Inside she unwraps herself from scarves and layers, the heat in the house almost a shock after the cold air. Michigan in February. Mom is already halfway up the stairs, bag in tow, headed for her room.
"Mom, just leave that and I'll…"
"Your father's in the front room," she says, just before she disappears from view. "Go say hi."
For a few seconds Sara is alone in the hallway, the smell of cooking meat coming from one doorway, the sound of rolling news from another. She shakes her head, kicks off shoes, tucks hair behind her ears. Braces herself.
He's sat in the living room, reclining in the Lazy Boy. He doesn't hear her enter - her socked feet silent on the pile carpet floor, his attention lost in the screen that fills most of the wall. Fox News. She braces herself again.
"Hey Dad."
His head jerks to look at her. "Hey! When did you get here?" He starts to push himself up.
"Don't get up Dad, it's fine. Really." She takes a seat on the couch. "I just got here, like two minutes ago."
"Good flight?"
"Yeah. Fine. Y'know. Same as always."
He smiles back at her, nods knowingly.
Their first words in nearly a year. Fine. So far. She relaxes. Of course it is. How bad could it be?
"I thought I was gonna come pick you up from the airport?"
"Ah, no. I got a cab. I didn't want to bother you."
"Bother me? You think I'm too old and infirm to pick my own daughter up from the airport?"
"No Dad, of course not."
The war spills out of Fox News, casualty figures scrolling across monochrome drone footage, attack helicopters circling over Caracas apartment blocks, pundits with bronzed skin and immaculate blond hair smiling from four-way split screens.
"So you just got a cab?"
"Yeah."
"How much did that cost?"
"Not much. Really. I can afford-"
"Cabs are expensive. You shouldn't be wasting your money."
"It wasn't expensive. It wasn't a cab, it was a Lyft."
"One of those driverless things?"
"Yeah."
Ad break. An elderly couple ride a tandem bicycle through a park, laughing and smiling in Instagram-perfect sunshine, as a calm, relaxing voice lists the potentially lethal side effects of a diabetes drug.
Dad shakes his head. "I don't know how you can use those things. I don't trust them."
"Dad, they're perfectly safe."
"That's not what I mean. They're stealing people's jobs."
There's a brief second, a fleeting moment, where Sara can bite her lip, let it go. She misses it. "But I thought it was immigrants that are stealing people's jobs?"
"You might think it's funny little lady, but let me tell you - you remember Kyle and Max, Bill Cooper's boys? Live up off Lafayette, past the Checkers?"
"Nope."
"Well let me tell you," He shifts in the recliner, with some obvious pain and effort, to face her. "Both of 'em lost their jobs just this last year. Both of 'em were truckers. Both of 'em been driving trucks since high school. Now the damn trucks are driving themselves and they're both out of work. And they got families to support. Kids."
"Well I'm sure they'll be fine." She regrets the sarcasm as soon as she hears it in her own voice, but she still can't stop herself, like it's expected, like it's part of the routine. Part of their schtick. "They just got to get themselves out there, huh Dad? Pull themselves up by their bootstraps. That's the American way, right?"
"I'm glad you think this is funny, I really do. But what you New York types need to realise is-"
"Ed!" Mom had appeared in the doorway. "Please! Both of you. No fighting today, please."
"Sheryl-"
"No. I don't want to hear you two as much as disagreeing about anything today, unless it's about the game. And even then you'd better keep it civil. Otherwise you can both go hungry. Understand?"
Awkward pause.
"Fine."
"Sorry Mom."
Sara turns back to the TV, to watching the war, to trying to work out which one it is.
It had always been this way, ever since she was about thirteen. Up until then it just seemed like constant warmth, as though she didn't have any childhood concept of Dad apart from him getting home from work, then her sitting on his knee, eating cookies and watching football highlights until Mom came in and scolded them both for ruining their appetites before dinner.
And then everything changed. Suddenly there was rap music and nose rings, sneaking out of the house to see her friends and not wanting to go to church. Suddenly he was no longer this lovable bear-man that ruffled her hair and gave her candy and explained defensive plays to her, but this huge obelisk of injustice that just wanted to crush her high school life into dust. It was constant warfare; every opinion she had became a battle, every decision she made a conflict. Getting away to college gave her escape, but bred resentment too; he hated that she went to New York, even though NYU was a good school, and her decision to stay there after she finished made things even worse. And then politics got all crazy, weirder then ever, and it became impossible for them to talk without it erupting into fights almost instantly. It was bad enough when the smart, young guy she liked was president and Dad constantly spewed his hate for him at her, but somehow it got even worse when the old, racist, women hating war-starter he liked won. Twice.
So they didn't talk much now, barely online, never on the phone. Since her second year of school he'd never been to NYC to visit her. She came back when she could face it; sometimes for birthdays, sometimes for Thanksgiving. Maybe for Christmas. But somehow always, like now, for the Super Bowl. Like football was the one thing they still had, that one thing they could still sit in the same room together for. Shouting at players, screaming at the ref, laughing at the ads.
Dad is in the bathroom, and Sara has had enough of Fox and whichever war this is. She reaches over and grabs the remote from the arm of his chair, and tries to find something else to watch. The government had scrapped all the rules about how the internet worked, and for most people like her parents it had suddenly gotten a lot cheaper to get their TV through Facebook, so all she can find is
Fox, Breitbart News, Family Values TV, Info Wars, The Rebel, Glenn Beck, The Voice of America, America First, The Bible Today
and lots of hunting and sports channels she doesn't even recognise. It's signed in to her Dad's FB account, and the last thing she wants is to try and log in on hers before he gets back from the john. Yeah. There was no way that would end up with them keeping it civil.
In her pocket her phone vibrates, purrs against her skin, reminding her it's there, making sure she's not forgotten where her real friends are, that there's a world outside, beyond Dad and his TV. She takes it out and cradles it in her hands, the dark screen fleetingly reflecting back her face before it jumps awake at her very touch, opening up to bathe her in blue light, in comfort and warmth and the familiar. For the first time since she got home she feels herself relax.
Dinner is Mom's meatloaf, with gravy and mashed potatoes. Cornbread and broccoli. Every mouthful tastes like nostalgia, and Sara can feel herself being encompassed by a bubble, this barrier of warm air and long forgotten simplicity enveloping her body, protecting her from the confusion of the world outside.
"How's work, honey?" Mom asks.
"Yeah, going OK." Sara works for a non-profit in Brooklyn that helps big organisations to transition to renewable energy. The pay is lousy but it feels important. "We just got the last few schools in the city to agree to put solar panels on their roofs. Big deal for us. I've been working on them for the last two years."
Mom says nothing, just looks down at her plate.
Dad finishes chewing his mouthful, swallows, wipes his beard with a napkin. Sighs, barely controlled anger simmering behind his face. "Solar panels cause cancer."
Sara laughs, covering her mouth as she nearly chokes on chewed food. "What? No they don't Dad."
"They do. The material they use to coat them reacts to sunlight, and produces an airborne carcinogen. It's based on a particular kind of rare earth. It's a bit like teflon. The Chinese have known about this for decades but have kept it covered up, because they-"
"Dad, no. Just no. Trust me."
"-because they are the world's largest manufacturers of solar panels. But the research has been done. The scientific evidence is out there. Look it up."
"Look it up?" Sara shakes her head, not knowing where to even start. "Dad, who is telling you this stuff?"
"No one is telling me it, Sara. I read it. It's in the news. I mean, really, I'm surprised you've not seen it. It was all over Facebook."
"Maybe on yours, but it's not all over my Facebook." She doesn't have the heart to tell him she muted him six months ago.
"Well, I don't read the news and I don't know any science," says Mom, "But I do know this: after they opened that solar farm up near Mary, within just a few years her and two of her neighbours had cancer. I mean I don't know anything for sure honey, but given the risk are you sure it's safe to be putting these panels on top of schools?"
"There's no risk, Mom. None at all. Dad, I wish you'd stop believing everything you see on Facebook."
"Well, maybe you should read things yourself before passing judgement on them." He pushes himself up from his seat, steps away from the table. Sara sighs, thinking she's upset him that much that he's actually abandoning his dinner, but he stops to grab something off a nearby shelf. His iPad. He heads back and takes his seat again.
Oh, here we fucking go
she thinks to herself.
He stabs at the screen, looks for a while, stabs again. Flips it over and hands it to her. "Here. Read."
Reluctantly, she takes it. His Facebook feed. Somewhere in the middle of it is the article, a very to the point CHINESE SOLAR PANELS CAUSE CANCER headline. But she can't even focus on it, because the rest of the screen is filled with distractions, looping videos and animated gifs, all adverts, and all for guns. Or security systems. Panic rooms. Back up power generators. Emergency rations. More guns.
"Jesus Christ Dad, these ads!"
"No blasphemy at the dinner table, please honey" says Mom.
"What about them?"
"Just… just look at them. They're terrifying. They're like… like adverts for the end of the world! You know they show you this stuff just to make you scared, right? Just to keep you paranoid."
"They show me this stuff because they've got products to sell. That's how the economy works. That's how we create jobs. Godammit Sara, are you telling me you hate
advertising
now? Do you just hate everything about America?"
Sara looks over to Mom, who looks like she's on the brink of tears. Suddenly she finds she's also lost the will to fight. Gently she closes the iPad and puts it down on the table, next to her plate.
"No, of course not Dad. Maybe I'll read this later, after the game."
After dinner she helps Mom clean-up, the two of them loading the dishwasher in near silence. She's leaning against the counter, scrolling through Twitter on her phone, when Mom finally speaks.
"You should go easy on your father, you know. He's worried about a lot of things."
"What things? Solar panel cancer?"
"Don't joke Sara, I'm serious. There's a lot that bothers him. The state of the world. The future. All these damn wars."
"We're all worried about all that, Mom."
"He's worried about his health.
I'm
worried about his health. Probably more than he is."
Sara looks up from her phone, genuine concern. "Is he OK?"
"I don't know. He won't go to the doctor. Hasn't been in months. He's worried about his insurance."
"I had no idea-"
"Yeah, well you know your father. Doesn't like to talk about it. Doesn't want to burden other people with his problems. Hates pity." She pauses, looks out the window into the yard. When she turns back to Sara her eyes are damp. "This is why I was so excited about you coming back. Why he was so excited! I thought it'd take his mind of all this. He was so excited to see you. You know he loves watching the game with you, Sara."
"I know. I'm sorry I-"
"And the ads! The Super Bowl ads! You know how much he loves watching the new ads with you. It's a stupid thing, sure, but he loves it. Talks about it all the time. It's like a tradition to him. That's why he got so upset over dinner when you got angry at his ads. It's something special he has with you, he doesn't want to lose it."
Sara slips her phone into her pocket, genuine guilt. Feels like a spoiled kid. "I didn't realise. I'm sorry."
Mom smiles, walks over and kisses her on the forehead. "It's OK honey. Don't feel bad. Just go. Just go sit in there with him and watch some TV. Please."
It's the second down on the Falcon's 60 yard line with 30 yards to cover, and the Lions need one touchdown to equalise. Sara and her Dad are sat in the front room, working their way through a family sized pack of Oreos, when the ad break starts.
Dawn. Red skies over the desert. A Chevrolet truck pulls up next to a large, trailer. Low shot next to the front tire, as a cowboy booted foot drops down from the door, disturbing dust.
Cut to: internal shot of the trailer, darkness split by morning light through the opening door. The figure enters, flicks on lights. The room is full of equipment, computers. The figure takes a seat, puts on a headset, thumbs on screens. Rests their hands on two large joysticks on the desk.
Cut to: airfield, the desert. The distinctive silhouette of a Predator drone taxis across the screen, rising heat shimmering the air around it.
Cut to: interior of the trailer. The faceless figure works controls, the joysticks, touch screens.
Voiceover: They say you need to get up pretty early to get past America's finest. But the truth is we never sleep.
Cut to: a uniformed guard on top of the border wall. He looks up and gives a salute to the drone as it soars above him, out and across the desert.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
"Fuck this," says Sara, getting up from her seat.
"Sara!" says Mom.
"No I'm sorry, I can't. I can't sit here and watch this… this bullshit. This propaganda." She storms out of the room.
"Sara!" Mom makes to get up.
"No, just leave her," says Dad, gently, his eyes still fixed on the screen. "Just let her go."
Out in the kitchen Sara sits at the table and wants to scream. She's angry, mainly with herself. She should never have fucking come here. She should have known better. There was never any fucking way anything good was going to come from this. As much as Mom wants to romanticise things, to make them sound cute and adorable, the truth is shit with Dad has never been right since she was a teenager. Too much resentment, too much bad blood, too much control and rebellion. They hadn't agreed on anything - they hadn't managed to have a simple conversation that didn't descend into fighting - in 15 goddamn years, and no amount of eating cookies and watching fucking Super Bowl ads on the TV was going to fix that.
She sighs, wipes a tear from her cheek. On autopilot she takes her phone from her pocket, feels its reassuring warmth in her hand, and swipes open Twitter.
Everybody seems to be talking about the same thing.
omg im crying
holy shit that chevrolet ad /fire emoji
that was sooooo beautiful
who knew chevrolet were so woke
i can't believe they did that, so amazing
Hang on, are they taking about the same ad?
Hastily she opens her FB TV app, pulls up the game. The ad is just finishing. She hits the 10-second rewind icon a couple of times, then leans the phone on its side against a ketchup bottle.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are revealed to be a Mexican family, maybe two. Men, women, children. They look tired, hungry. They stop to rest, sipping the little water they have left from tattered plastic bottles.
A little way away from the main group sits a small child, a girl. Maybe 8 years old. She is drawing shapes in the dust with a stick. She's drawn quite a bit it looks like, but from our angle we can't see what.
Cut to: drone footage. The pilot is watching the group. As he tracks away from the main party to where the girl is sat, the camera reveals what she has drawn.
A large, child's rendition of the American flag.
Underneath it, it childlike handwriting, some words. 'I have a dream'
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. ALL PATROLS: STAND DOWN
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and how we got here.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Sara finds herself in the front room, sobbing.
"Honey?"
Dad pauses the TV, looks up at her. It looks like he's been crying too. "Sara?"
"Did you - did you watch it?"
"The Chevrolet ad?"
"Yeah."
"Yeah, we did." Embarrassed, he wipes a tear from his cheek. "It was… it was very moving."
She falls on him, wrapping her arms around his neck, burying her face in his chest. "I'm sorry Dad. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to be so mean-"
"It's OK, honey. It really is."
"No, no it's not. We always fight. And I know that's mainly my fault-"
'Well, now, c'mon-"
"No, it is. It's my fault. I got myself into thinking we can never agree on anything, that we can never see eye to eye. That we've got nothing in common anymore." She lifts her head to look up at him. "But I know that's wrong. That I shouldn't assume things about you. That there's still things that can bring us together."
He grins back at her. "Like Super Bowl ads?"
She laughs. "I guess. But you know what I mean, really."
"I know honey. And I'm sorry too. I didn't mean what I said earlier. I know you don't really hate this country." He gestures to the couch next to him. "Why don't you sit down, huh? We can watch the rest of the game together."
She straightens herself up, wipes her eyes. Suddenly feels a little self conscious. "Sure. Let me just go freshen up first."
"Of course honey."
Mom and Dad watch Sara leave the room, and then look at each other.
"Well."
"Well indeed."
"What did I tell you? You two just needed to spend some time together. Some quality time."
"I guess so. What did I ever do to deserve a woman as hot and as smart as you, huh Sheryl?"
Mom stands up and makes to leave the room, leaning down to kiss him as she passes. "I ask myself that question every day."
Alone, seen only by the TV, Dad smiles to himself. He picks up the remote, but instead of hitting play, he finds himself hitting rewind.
Cut to: drone footage. Grainy, monochrome. A group of figures move slowly through the desert. The camera tracks them. Zooms in. The pilot punches buttons. The figures become highlighted by a computer overlay, text appears next to them. ILLEGAL ENTRY ATTEMPT SUSPECTED. GROUND PATROLS ALERTED.
Cut to: on the ground, in the desert. The group of figures are all men. Dirty, scruffy, furtive. Like they mean business.They carry guns, pistols, and assault riffles. Bad hombres. One of them pulls open a bag, looks inside.
Cut to: close up of the inside of the bag. Inside are packets of white powder.
Suddenly, one of the party looks up, shouts something in Spanish. They all go to grab their guns.
But it's too late.
From three different directions, three different Chevrolet jeeps appear, screeching to a halt, kicking up dust. From them jump Border Patrol agents and Minutemen militia, guns drawn and ready.
The gang of men don't even put up a fight. They know they're surrounded, they drop their weapons and pathetically raise their hands.
All except one. The guy with the bag full of drugs. He's got nothing to lose. He reaches for his rifle.
Cut to: Border Patrol agents, opening fire.
Text flashes across the screen. ALERT CANCELLED. THREAT NEUTRALISED.
Cut to: the drone, banking and turning, flying away.
Cut to: exterior shot of the trailer. The still anonymous pilot exits, walks back towards his jeep.
Voiceover: Keeping America safe means never sleeping, but keeping America great means never forgetting who we are, and what keeps us strong.
The jeep starts up, pulls away from the camera in a cloud of dust.
Fade to black. Chevrolet logo. White text against black.
'We know what really makes America great'
Dad wipes another team from his eye. "I think we're going to be OK," he says to himself. "I think we're going to be just fine."
This article was originally published on TheLong+Short. Read the original article.
| https://thelongandshort.org/forecasts/divided-we-stand | Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0); https://thelongandshort.org/using-our-content | How does Sara feel about the Chevrolet ad? | 99902_T1XG8MCZ_8 | [
"She thinks it's a final chance to bond with her father",
"She is sorry she did not watch the whole ad before she reacted to it",
"She is upset at the glorification of the military",
"She is frustrated that it tokenized a Mexican family"
] | 2 | 2 | [
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0016",
"untimed_answer": 3,
"untimed_best_distractor": 2,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 1
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0026",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
},
{
"untimed_annotator_id": "0018",
"untimed_answer": 2,
"untimed_best_distractor": 3,
"untimed_eval1_answerability": 1,
"untimed_eval2_context": 2
}
] | [
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0021",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0001",
"speed_answer": 3
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0040",
"speed_answer": 4
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0010",
"speed_answer": 2
},
{
"speed_annotator_id": "0004",
"speed_answer": 1
}
] | 1 |