Hugging Face's logo

Datasets:
optimum-benchmark
/
cuda

Dataset card Data Studio Files Community
IlyasMoutawwakil HF staff commited on
Commit
45f8bc8
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 5cf1295

Upload cuda_inference_transformers_text-generation_openai-community/gpt2/benchmark_report.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. cuda_inference_transformers_text-generation_openai-community/gpt2/benchmark_report.json +261 -261
cuda_inference_transformers_text-generation_openai-community/gpt2/benchmark_report.json CHANGED
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
2
  "load": {
3
  "memory": {
4
  "unit": "MB",
5
- "max_ram": 800.329728,
6
  "max_global_vram": 1362.624512,
7
  "max_process_vram": 0.0,
8
  "max_reserved": 725.614592,
@@ -11,31 +11,31 @@
11
  "latency": {
12
  "unit": "s",
13
  "count": 1,
14
- "total": 7.9974443359375,
15
- "mean": 7.9974443359375,
16
  "stdev": 0.0,
17
- "p50": 7.9974443359375,
18
- "p90": 7.9974443359375,
19
- "p95": 7.9974443359375,
20
- "p99": 7.9974443359375,
21
  "values": [
22
- 7.9974443359375
23
  ]
24
  },
25
  "throughput": null,
26
  "energy": {
27
  "unit": "kWh",
28
- "cpu": 2.3885730527606737e-06,
29
- "ram": 1.2853527569198343e-06,
30
- "gpu": 3.3600026879965217e-06,
31
- "total": 7.033928497677029e-06
32
  },
33
  "efficiency": null
34
  },
35
  "prefill": {
36
  "memory": {
37
  "unit": "MB",
38
- "max_ram": 1228.742656,
39
  "max_global_vram": 1373.110272,
40
  "max_process_vram": 0.0,
41
  "max_reserved": 725.614592,
@@ -44,108 +44,108 @@
44
  "latency": {
45
  "unit": "s",
46
  "count": 72,
47
- "total": 0.49021465635299677,
48
- "mean": 0.006808536893791624,
49
- "stdev": 0.0003974865253003099,
50
- "p50": 0.006914720058441163,
51
- "p90": 0.00724901442527771,
52
- "p95": 0.007288318538665772,
53
- "p99": 0.007524614500999453,
54
  "values": [
55
- 0.007315264225006103,
56
- 0.007260064125061035,
57
- 0.006943679809570312,
58
- 0.00688259220123291,
59
- 0.006932831764221191,
60
- 0.006827487945556641,
61
- 0.007443136215209961,
62
- 0.006830048084259033,
63
- 0.007037248134613037,
64
- 0.006996096134185791,
65
- 0.0068215360641479495,
66
- 0.006867487907409668,
67
- 0.006969024181365966,
68
- 0.0070330557823181155,
69
- 0.0068791680335998535,
70
- 0.0071211838722229,
71
- 0.00712175989151001,
72
- 0.006882815837860107,
73
- 0.007095551967620849,
74
- 0.007064288139343262,
75
- 0.007148064136505127,
76
- 0.00717910385131836,
77
- 0.007334432125091553,
78
- 0.007249536037445069,
79
- 0.007026815891265869,
80
- 0.007724095821380615,
81
- 0.006926144123077392,
82
- 0.0071594557762146,
83
- 0.0069434881210327145,
84
- 0.007123616218566895,
85
- 0.0072631359100341795,
86
- 0.007032959938049316,
87
- 0.007100768089294433,
88
- 0.007057568073272705,
89
- 0.006830016136169434,
90
- 0.007266272068023682,
91
- 0.007223296165466309,
92
- 0.007184127807617188,
93
- 0.007244319915771485,
94
- 0.007073344230651856,
95
- 0.007012415885925293,
96
- 0.00689404821395874,
97
- 0.007093376159667969,
98
- 0.0067357120513916015,
99
- 0.006534527778625488,
100
- 0.006903295993804932,
101
- 0.0070687680244445805,
102
- 0.007153408050537109,
103
- 0.00680841588973999,
104
- 0.006574431896209717,
105
- 0.006444736003875733,
106
- 0.006551136016845703,
107
- 0.0062952318191528325,
108
- 0.006192639827728271,
109
- 0.006300928115844727,
110
- 0.006285823822021484,
111
- 0.006286911964416504,
112
- 0.0062171840667724606,
113
- 0.006182496070861816,
114
- 0.006245535850524902,
115
- 0.006287680149078369,
116
- 0.006245535850524902,
117
- 0.0062416958808898925,
118
- 0.006274271965026856,
119
- 0.0062053117752075195,
120
- 0.006281087875366211,
121
- 0.0062485761642456054,
122
- 0.00619152021408081,
123
- 0.006301919937133789,
124
- 0.006214943885803223,
125
- 0.006270016193389892,
126
- 0.006256192207336426
127
  ]
128
  },
129
  "throughput": {
130
  "unit": "tokens/s",
131
- "value": 293.74886722339767
132
  },
133
  "energy": {
134
  "unit": "kWh",
135
- "cpu": 7.764211033959945e-08,
136
- "ram": 4.242571282060231e-08,
137
- "gpu": 1.4904151356862272e-07,
138
- "total": 2.691093367288245e-07
139
  },
140
  "efficiency": {
141
  "unit": "tokens/kWh",
142
- "value": 7431923.486234725
143
  }
144
  },
145
  "decode": {
146
  "memory": {
147
  "unit": "MB",
148
- "max_ram": 1247.08864,
149
  "max_global_vram": 1373.110272,
150
  "max_process_vram": 0.0,
151
  "max_reserved": 725.614592,
@@ -154,102 +154,102 @@
154
  "latency": {
155
  "unit": "s",
156
  "count": 72,
157
- "total": 0.5132745900154113,
158
- "mean": 0.007128813750214046,
159
- "stdev": 0.000394570345300286,
160
- "p50": 0.0072610719203948975,
161
- "p90": 0.007555580711364746,
162
- "p95": 0.007654185461997986,
163
- "p99": 0.00773252206325531,
164
  "values": [
165
- 0.007445087909698486,
166
- 0.007429376125335694,
167
- 0.0071775360107421875,
168
- 0.00725548791885376,
169
- 0.007265759944915772,
170
- 0.007079936027526855,
171
- 0.007256383895874023,
172
- 0.007269248008728028,
173
- 0.007480319976806641,
174
- 0.007204288005828857,
175
- 0.007125440120697021,
176
- 0.007231167793273926,
177
- 0.0072717761993408205,
178
- 0.0075095038414001464,
179
- 0.007498112201690674,
180
- 0.007539423942565918,
181
- 0.007436287879943848,
182
- 0.007343616008758545,
183
- 0.007432096004486084,
184
- 0.007431488037109375,
185
- 0.007350719928741455,
186
- 0.007664639949798584,
187
- 0.0074208321571350095,
188
- 0.0074546561241149905,
189
- 0.007480768203735352,
190
- 0.007599967956542969,
191
- 0.007557375907897949,
192
- 0.0074423041343688965,
193
- 0.007286079883575439,
194
- 0.007730591773986817,
195
- 0.007285408020019531,
196
- 0.007379968166351319,
197
- 0.00745462417602539,
198
- 0.007420447826385498,
199
- 0.0077218241691589355,
200
- 0.007576191902160644,
201
- 0.007645631790161133,
202
- 0.007510303974151611,
203
- 0.007388160228729248,
204
  0.0073276481628417964,
205
- 0.0072269439697265625,
206
- 0.0069604158401489254,
207
- 0.0072499198913574215,
208
- 0.0067966079711914065,
209
- 0.0070867519378662105,
210
- 0.007411776065826416,
211
- 0.007450751781463623,
212
- 0.007737247943878174,
213
- 0.0069612798690795894,
214
- 0.006767551898956298,
215
- 0.006783616065979004,
216
- 0.006840735912322998,
217
- 0.006648416042327881,
218
- 0.006592415809631348,
219
- 0.006585216045379639,
220
- 0.006567039966583252,
221
- 0.006617695808410645,
222
- 0.006524703979492188,
223
- 0.006553567886352539,
224
- 0.006566815853118897,
225
- 0.00669379186630249,
226
- 0.006606016159057617,
227
- 0.006581888198852539,
228
- 0.006581696033477783,
229
- 0.006538943767547607,
230
- 0.006576831817626953,
231
- 0.006538559913635254,
232
- 0.006586271762847901,
233
- 0.006502079963684082,
234
- 0.0065491518974304195,
235
- 0.006600543975830078,
236
- 0.006608863830566406
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
237
  ]
238
  },
239
  "throughput": {
240
  "unit": "tokens/s",
241
- "value": 140.2757927249782
242
  },
243
  "energy": {
244
  "unit": "kWh",
245
- "cpu": 7.307622799538225e-08,
246
- "ram": 3.992839546466258e-08,
247
- "gpu": 1.4154240384906026e-07,
248
- "total": 2.5454702730910506e-07
249
  },
250
  "efficiency": {
251
  "unit": "tokens/kWh",
252
- "value": 3928547.1552007804
253
  }
254
  },
255
  "per_token": {
@@ -257,91 +257,91 @@
257
  "latency": {
258
  "unit": "s",
259
  "count": 72,
260
- "total": 0.4793321576118466,
261
- "mean": 0.006657391077942319,
262
- "stdev": 0.00033534352549947905,
263
- "p50": 0.006762495994567871,
264
- "p90": 0.0070382658004760745,
265
- "p95": 0.0071287296295166015,
266
- "p99": 0.007208560523986817,
267
  "values": [
268
- 0.006910975933074951,
269
- 0.006897727966308594,
270
- 0.006680575847625733,
271
- 0.006744063854217529,
272
- 0.006769631862640381,
273
- 0.006598656177520752,
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
274
  0.006713344097137451,
275
- 0.0067573761940002445,
276
- 0.00693555212020874,
277
- 0.006685696125030518,
278
- 0.006606847763061524,
279
- 0.006706175804138184,
280
- 0.006767615795135498,
281
- 0.00693555212020874,
282
- 0.006975488185882568,
283
- 0.0069918718338012695,
284
- 0.006912000179290771,
285
- 0.0068351998329162595,
286
- 0.00691919994354248,
287
- 0.0069069118499755855,
288
- 0.006848512172698974,
289
- 0.007138304233551026,
290
- 0.0068853440284729,
291
- 0.006924287796020508,
292
- 0.006959104061126709,
293
- 0.00704307222366333,
294
- 0.007045119762420654,
295
- 0.00694374418258667,
296
- 0.006784959793090821,
297
- 0.007205887794494629,
298
- 0.006790143966674805,
299
- 0.006872064113616944,
300
- 0.00692633581161499,
301
- 0.006924287796020508,
302
- 0.007185408115386963,
303
- 0.007061408042907715,
304
- 0.007120895862579346,
305
- 0.006995007991790771,
306
- 0.0068915200233459475,
307
- 0.006830111980438232,
308
- 0.006755328178405762,
309
- 0.006524928092956543,
310
- 0.006776735782623291,
311
- 0.006398975849151611,
312
- 0.006591487884521485,
313
- 0.006904831886291504,
314
- 0.0069283838272094726,
315
- 0.007215104103088379,
316
- 0.00652185583114624,
317
- 0.006385568141937256,
318
- 0.006394879817962646,
319
- 0.006398975849151611,
320
  0.006248447895050049,
321
- 0.00621670389175415,
322
- 0.006209536075592041,
323
- 0.006189055919647217,
324
- 0.006229951858520508,
325
- 0.006142975807189942,
326
- 0.006176767826080322,
327
- 0.006188032150268555,
328
- 0.006291456222534179,
329
- 0.006218751907348633,
330
- 0.006202367782592774,
331
- 0.006201344013214111,
332
- 0.0061562881469726565,
333
- 0.0062044157981872555,
334
- 0.006148096084594727,
335
- 0.006198272228240966,
336
- 0.006127615928649902,
337
- 0.006157311916351318,
338
- 0.006197311878204346,
339
- 0.0062044157981872555
340
  ]
341
  },
342
  "throughput": {
343
  "unit": "tokens/s",
344
- "value": 150.20899152421165
345
  },
346
  "energy": null,
347
  "efficiency": null
 
2
  "load": {
3
  "memory": {
4
  "unit": "MB",
5
+ "max_ram": 800.403456,
6
  "max_global_vram": 1362.624512,
7
  "max_process_vram": 0.0,
8
  "max_reserved": 725.614592,
 
11
  "latency": {
12
  "unit": "s",
13
  "count": 1,
14
+ "total": 7.981681640625,
15
+ "mean": 7.981681640625,
16
  "stdev": 0.0,
17
+ "p50": 7.981681640625,
18
+ "p90": 7.981681640625,
19
+ "p95": 7.981681640625,
20
+ "p99": 7.981681640625,
21
  "values": [
22
+ 7.981681640625
23
  ]
24
  },
25
  "throughput": null,
26
  "energy": {
27
  "unit": "kWh",
28
+ "cpu": 2.4046087631909864e-06,
29
+ "ram": 1.2987035240711796e-06,
30
+ "gpu": 3.11194693398964e-06,
31
+ "total": 6.815259221251806e-06
32
  },
33
  "efficiency": null
34
  },
35
  "prefill": {
36
  "memory": {
37
  "unit": "MB",
38
+ "max_ram": 1201.258496,
39
  "max_global_vram": 1373.110272,
40
  "max_process_vram": 0.0,
41
  "max_reserved": 725.614592,
 
44
  "latency": {
45
  "unit": "s",
46
  "count": 72,
47
+ "total": 0.4912262377738953,
48
+ "mean": 0.006822586635748545,
49
+ "stdev": 0.0003187041997957834,
50
+ "p50": 0.006863424062728882,
51
+ "p90": 0.007176259326934814,
52
+ "p95": 0.007270078372955323,
53
+ "p99": 0.007562580690383915,
54
  "values": [
55
+ 0.0073901119232177735,
56
+ 0.007198239803314209,
57
+ 0.007179808139801025,
58
+ 0.0069398398399353025,
59
+ 0.006921343803405762,
60
+ 0.006822015762329102,
61
+ 0.006860671997070312,
62
+ 0.0069474239349365235,
63
+ 0.007056447982788086,
64
+ 0.007056479930877686,
65
+ 0.006876863956451416,
66
+ 0.007055679798126221,
67
+ 0.0070524802207946775,
68
+ 0.007066175937652588,
69
+ 0.007139584064483642,
70
+ 0.007231040000915527,
71
+ 0.006994143962860107,
72
+ 0.006803616046905518,
73
+ 0.006909887790679931,
74
+ 0.006866176128387452,
75
+ 0.006920864105224609,
76
+ 0.007144320011138916,
77
+ 0.007057375907897949,
78
+ 0.0069552001953125,
79
+ 0.00685152006149292,
80
+ 0.007053919792175293,
81
+ 0.007317791938781739,
82
+ 0.006792128086090088,
83
+ 0.00691593599319458,
84
+ 0.006875423908233642,
85
+ 0.006844448089599609,
86
+ 0.006828383922576904,
87
+ 0.00687014389038086,
88
+ 0.006898240089416504,
89
+ 0.007048351764678955,
90
+ 0.007113984107971191,
91
+ 0.007064191818237304,
92
+ 0.006936192035675049,
93
+ 0.006960063934326172,
94
+ 0.006912415981292725,
95
+ 0.0068167362213134765,
96
+ 0.006603936195373535,
97
+ 0.006858687877655029,
98
+ 0.006502175807952881,
99
+ 0.006514143943786621,
100
+ 0.007984831809997558,
101
+ 0.007194975852966309,
102
+ 0.007342751979827881,
103
+ 0.006764895915985107,
104
+ 0.006772672176361084,
105
+ 0.006770143985748291,
106
+ 0.006716256141662598,
107
+ 0.006411680221557617,
108
+ 0.006305984020233154,
109
+ 0.006599711894989014,
110
+ 0.006589183807373047,
111
+ 0.006587552070617676,
112
+ 0.006541376113891602,
113
+ 0.006272960186004639,
114
+ 0.006587007999420166,
115
+ 0.00653766393661499,
116
+ 0.0065285758972167965,
117
+ 0.006604383945465088,
118
+ 0.006322207927703857,
119
+ 0.0062995519638061525,
120
+ 0.006279295921325684,
121
+ 0.00633903980255127,
122
+ 0.006345439910888672,
123
+ 0.006333055973052978,
124
+ 0.006379871845245361,
125
+ 0.006378943920135498,
126
+ 0.00641161584854126
127
  ]
128
  },
129
  "throughput": {
130
  "unit": "tokens/s",
131
+ "value": 293.14395064190614
132
  },
133
  "energy": {
134
  "unit": "kWh",
135
+ "cpu": 8.03163324887434e-08,
136
+ "ram": 4.389090892197547e-08,
137
+ "gpu": 1.462519938784154e-07,
138
+ "total": 2.7045923528913425e-07
139
  },
140
  "efficiency": {
141
  "unit": "tokens/kWh",
142
+ "value": 7394829.752668277
143
  }
144
  },
145
  "decode": {
146
  "memory": {
147
  "unit": "MB",
148
+ "max_ram": 1219.60448,
149
  "max_global_vram": 1373.110272,
150
  "max_process_vram": 0.0,
151
  "max_reserved": 725.614592,
 
154
  "latency": {
155
  "unit": "s",
156
  "count": 72,
157
+ "total": 0.5171054720878601,
158
+ "mean": 0.007182020445664723,
159
+ "stdev": 0.0003232646487637867,
160
+ "p50": 0.0072722241878509526,
161
+ "p90": 0.007537292575836182,
162
+ "p95": 0.007568304014205933,
163
+ "p99": 0.007817550644874577,
164
  "values": [
165
+ 0.00755683183670044,
166
+ 0.00746281623840332,
167
+ 0.0072984957695007326,
168
+ 0.007316991806030273,
169
+ 0.007340799808502197,
170
+ 0.007195168018341065,
171
+ 0.007317024230957031,
172
+ 0.007422688007354736,
173
+ 0.00756112003326416,
174
+ 0.007290559768676758,
175
+ 0.007356575965881348,
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
176
  0.0073276481628417964,
177
+ 0.007350624084472656,
178
+ 0.007286335945129395,
179
+ 0.007576576232910156,
180
+ 0.007609920024871826,
181
+ 0.007411200046539307,
182
+ 0.007299967765808105,
183
+ 0.00726854419708252,
184
+ 0.007327455997467041,
185
+ 0.007352575778961181,
186
+ 0.007535679817199707,
187
+ 0.007359039783477783,
188
+ 0.007462624073028564,
189
+ 0.0073504958152771,
190
+ 0.0073088321685791015,
191
+ 0.007597375869750977,
192
+ 0.007125152111053467,
193
+ 0.007248000144958496,
194
+ 0.007468031883239746,
195
+ 0.007183648109436035,
196
+ 0.007225183963775634,
197
+ 0.007529024124145508,
198
+ 0.007221343994140625,
199
+ 0.0075615358352661135,
200
+ 0.00739465618133545,
201
+ 0.0073762240409851075,
202
+ 0.007331456184387207,
203
+ 0.007029344081878662,
204
+ 0.007229599952697754,
205
+ 0.007102880001068115,
206
+ 0.007033760070800781,
207
+ 0.006868927955627441,
208
+ 0.006694655895233154,
209
+ 0.00832588768005371,
210
+ 0.00741974401473999,
211
+ 0.0075374717712402345,
212
+ 0.007527967929840088,
213
+ 0.007041088104248047,
214
+ 0.007003232002258301,
215
+ 0.007047232151031494,
216
+ 0.006880000114440918,
217
+ 0.006683263778686523,
218
+ 0.007275904178619385,
219
+ 0.006947999954223633,
220
+ 0.007108096122741699,
221
+ 0.006863423824310303,
222
+ 0.006852640151977539,
223
+ 0.006838335990905762,
224
+ 0.006853888034820557,
225
+ 0.006984896183013916,
226
+ 0.006898623943328857,
227
+ 0.006868224143981933,
228
+ 0.006686751842498779,
229
+ 0.006668000221252441,
230
+ 0.006676608085632324,
231
+ 0.006628128051757812,
232
+ 0.006694015979766846,
233
+ 0.006663040161132812,
234
+ 0.006634943962097168,
235
+ 0.0066646718978881836,
236
+ 0.0066640000343322755
237
  ]
238
  },
239
  "throughput": {
240
  "unit": "tokens/s",
241
+ "value": 139.23658496455954
242
  },
243
  "energy": {
244
  "unit": "kWh",
245
+ "cpu": 7.667956193770936e-08,
246
+ "ram": 4.168981580849931e-08,
247
+ "gpu": 1.429551088321049e-07,
248
+ "total": 2.6132448657831363e-07
249
  },
250
  "efficiency": {
251
  "unit": "tokens/kWh",
252
+ "value": 3826660.153794353
253
  }
254
  },
255
  "per_token": {
 
257
  "latency": {
258
  "unit": "s",
259
  "count": 72,
260
+ "total": 0.482709376335144,
261
+ "mean": 0.006704296893543666,
262
+ "stdev": 0.0002730141432204396,
263
+ "p50": 0.006739455938339233,
264
+ "p90": 0.007010201597213745,
265
+ "p95": 0.007027967977523804,
266
+ "p99": 0.007283158855438237,
267
  "values": [
268
+ 0.007023615837097168,
269
+ 0.0069324798583984375,
270
+ 0.006788095951080322,
271
+ 0.00678604793548584,
272
+ 0.006828991889953613,
273
+ 0.006703104019165039,
274
+ 0.006808576107025147,
275
+ 0.0069027838706970214,
276
+ 0.006994944095611572,
277
+ 0.006781951904296875,
278
+ 0.006814720153808594,
279
+ 0.006806528091430664,
280
+ 0.006834176063537598,
281
+ 0.006738944053649902,
282
+ 0.007061503887176514,
283
+ 0.0070830078125,
284
+ 0.006876160144805908,
285
+ 0.00678604793548584,
286
+ 0.00673689603805542,
287
+ 0.006821887969970703,
288
+ 0.006833151817321777,
289
+ 0.007010303974151612,
290
+ 0.006847487926483154,
291
+ 0.006945792198181152,
292
+ 0.006831103801727295,
293
+ 0.006783040046691895,
294
+ 0.0070256638526916505,
295
+ 0.006631392002105713,
296
+ 0.006707136154174805,
297
+ 0.0069550080299377445,
298
+ 0.006681600093841553,
299
+ 0.006725632190704346,
300
+ 0.007009280204772949,
301
+ 0.006702079772949219,
302
+ 0.007030784130096435,
303
+ 0.006842368125915528,
304
+ 0.006863872051239014,
305
+ 0.006809599876403808,
306
+ 0.006546432018280029,
307
+ 0.006739967823028564,
308
+ 0.006628352165222168,
309
+ 0.006534143924713135,
310
+ 0.006462463855743408,
311
+ 0.006260735988616943,
312
+ 0.007773183822631836,
313
+ 0.006914048194885254,
314
+ 0.007013343811035157,
315
+ 0.006999040126800537,
316
+ 0.0066007041931152345,
317
+ 0.006536191940307618,
318
+ 0.006627327919006347,
319
+ 0.006487040042877197,
320
+ 0.006277120113372803,
321
+ 0.00687718391418457,
322
+ 0.006542335987091064,
323
  0.006713344097137451,
324
+ 0.006459392070770263,
325
+ 0.006446080207824707,
326
+ 0.0064430079460144046,
327
+ 0.006448128223419189,
328
+ 0.00657919979095459,
329
+ 0.006504447937011719,
330
+ 0.006462463855743408,
331
+ 0.006288383960723877,
332
+ 0.00628326416015625,
333
+ 0.006289408206939697,
334
+ 0.006243328094482422,
335
+ 0.006296576023101807,
336
+ 0.006276095867156982,
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
337
  0.006248447895050049,
338
+ 0.0062791681289672855,
339
+ 0.00628326416015625
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
340
  ]
341
  },
342
  "throughput": {
343
  "unit": "tokens/s",
344
+ "value": 149.15807218546874
345
  },
346
  "energy": null,
347
  "efficiency": null