id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| text
stringlengths 190
2.08k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00707v1 | Non-Exchangeable Conformal Language Generation with Nearest Neighbors | 2024-02-01T16:04:04 | 2024-02-01T16:04:04 | Dennis Ulmer, Chrysoula Zerva, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Quantifying uncertainty in automatically generated text is important for
letting humans check potential hallucinations and making systems more reliable.
Conformal prediction is an attractive framework to provide predictions imbued
with statistical guarantees, however, its application to text generation is
challenging since any i.i.d. assumptions are not realistic. In this paper, we
bridge this gap by leveraging recent results on non-exchangeable conformal
prediction, which still ensures bounds on coverage. The result,
non-exchangeable conformal nucleus sampling, is a novel extension of the
conformal prediction framework to generation based on nearest neighbors. Our
method can be used post-hoc for an arbitrary model without extra training and
supplies token-level, calibrated prediction sets equipped with statistical
guarantees. Experiments in machine translation and language modeling show
encouraging results in generation quality. By also producing tighter prediction
sets with good coverage, we thus give a more theoretically principled way to
perform sampling with conformal guarantees. | Non-Exchangeable Conformal Language Generation with Nearest Neighbors: Quantifying uncertainty in automatically generated text is important for
letting humans check potential hallucinations and making systems more reliable.
Conformal prediction is an attractive framework to provide predictions imbued
with statistical guarantees, however, its application to text generation is
challenging since any i.i.d. assumptions are not realistic. In this paper, we
bridge this gap by leveraging recent results on non-exchangeable conformal
prediction, which still ensures bounds on coverage. The result,
non-exchangeable conformal nucleus sampling, is a novel extension of the
conformal prediction framework to generation based on nearest neighbors. Our
method can be used post-hoc for an arbitrary model without extra training and
supplies token-level, calibrated prediction sets equipped with statistical
guarantees. Experiments in machine translation and language modeling show
encouraging results in generation quality. By also producing tighter prediction
sets with good coverage, we thus give a more theoretically principled way to
perform sampling with conformal guarantees. | [
0.0123841166,
0.0535999797,
-0.0130463215,
-0.0073406147,
-0.0346648619,
-0.0125198625,
0.0155013325,
0.0383045301,
-0.0137117663,
0.019392034,
-0.0230157245,
-0.1045398414,
-0.005112642,
0.0120497057,
0.049492348,
-0.0446704775,
-0.0319741294,
-0.0321741551,
-0.0304623917,
-0.0435972773,
-0.0329517499,
0.0049290285,
0.0167966411,
0.0185701326,
-0.0286881682,
-0.007919481,
-0.0136281541,
0.013282368,
0.0024542038,
-0.0011321071,
0.002836552,
0.0974835381,
-0.0040398869,
0.0382197686,
0.0000018658,
0.0159857292,
-0.0317419171,
0.0071009202,
0.0562203303,
-0.0259349942,
0.0616565011,
-0.0510842092,
-0.017786013,
0.0162684154,
-0.0205928218,
0.0233695898,
0.0703204572,
0.0507570542,
0.0066330922,
0.0436456949,
-0.0184482038,
-0.0213292427,
-0.0184223112,
-0.02919719,
0.0385406986,
-0.007038231,
0.0194234159,
0.0006006913,
-0.0094122449,
-0.026014274,
-0.0305613913,
0.0134149864,
0.0415583551,
0.0043288274,
-0.0003618363,
0.068902187,
0.0117667476,
-0.0311855879,
0.0018933926,
0.0171884615,
-0.0578787699,
-0.0587505512,
0.0148267793,
-0.0109855551,
-0.0605266914,
0.0272622798,
-0.0412336327,
0.0442819521,
-0.0413198657,
0.0526351519,
0.007842469,
0.031058386,
0.0040087546,
-0.0486337245,
-0.0193198845,
0.0119132018,
0.0585881583,
-0.0454282276,
-0.0053482186,
0.0521010011,
-0.0337981209,
-0.0448518619,
-0.0078103784,
-0.0190341808,
-0.0284768064,
0.0027160402,
-0.0902788118,
-0.0040953364,
0.0486991368,
-0.0368715189,
0.0803479627,
-0.0042625344,
0.0329960436,
-0.0013470206,
-0.0444027595,
0.0037609381,
-0.0028106689,
0.0407052897,
-0.0351935998,
-0.0051661059,
-0.0087263966,
0.0021113337,
-0.0364405997,
0.009491357,
-0.0505326726,
-0.0240869466,
-0.0462023988,
0.0088056466,
0.0284269284,
-0.0225828327,
0.0278324317,
0.0255240221,
-0.0937031582,
-0.0203806162,
0.0257102214,
-0.0212161671,
-0.0337063298,
-0.0161507875,
0.0106030283,
-0.0553118251,
-0.0262793992,
0.0389293879,
-0.0114175919,
-0.003075968,
-0.0069161002,
0.0809539109,
-0.0090856636,
-0.0287869927,
-0.0022595495,
-0.0359164923,
-0.049789656,
-0.0345854051,
0.0509499721,
-0.0789004341,
0.014860644,
-0.0112275025,
-0.0197568405,
-0.0371203981,
0.0262126848,
0.0275051855,
-0.0206618886,
0.007897906,
-0.0139147025,
-0.0014943748,
-0.0202791411,
-0.0039791726,
0.0503550433,
0.0545519218,
0.0093100565,
0.0774851516,
-0.0040845266,
0.0244410336,
0.0395525508,
0.0311438534,
0.0308106747,
0.0102136061,
-0.0579716973,
-0.0430977233,
0.0596357659,
0.0012549115,
0.0194246247,
0.082325846,
-0.0327931978,
-0.0164910816,
0.0478064008,
0.0207878817,
0.0062143919,
-0.0056341775,
0.0414076112,
-0.0072031594,
-0.0470870882,
0.0592759736,
-0.0365657248,
0.0325105302,
-0.0145240882,
0.021429535,
0.0717573836,
0.0338592716,
-0.0368128531,
-0.0047556427,
0.0123243015,
-0.0202550367,
-0.0225103106,
-0.0707328022,
0.0430356115,
0.0379522853,
-0.0562939942,
0.0293616299,
0.0339963622,
-0.0480405837,
0.0430029556,
-0.0055931974,
0.0525380522,
0.0387368836,
0.0418740809,
-0.0037389027,
0.0242941957,
0.0184146184,
0.0200742949,
0.0863368735,
0.0382443331,
0.0241606608,
0.0555393137,
-0.0431247614,
-0.0036654475,
0.0296047814,
0.0161021017,
0.0350660346,
0.0100287674,
-0.0120179467,
0.0144878998,
-0.0428656824,
-0.0653891489,
0.0197686423,
-0.044959452,
-0.0216637589,
0.0267204437,
0.0098042265,
0.0164464116,
-0.0014674567,
-0.038914077,
0.0281538479,
0.0275674723,
-0.0737656653,
-0.0559256412,
-0.0206621811,
-0.0424971618,
-0.0197937246,
-0.0019342806,
-0.0705746263,
0.0350140445,
-0.0600285456,
0.0099990256,
-0.0581123792,
0.0380625613,
-0.0318733789,
0.0564152971,
-0.0600293316,
0.0004017714,
0.0269951653,
0.0394483432,
-0.0410171598,
0.0476257689,
-0.0229087379,
0.0337774195,
-0.0017128461,
-0.0070188344,
0.0069436943,
-0.0007598497,
-0.0442993343,
-0.0303784646,
-0.0305690281,
0.0084048817,
0.0415514708,
0.0265149418,
0.0036544406,
-0.1120254993,
-0.0278881192,
0.001210603,
-0.0271216575,
-0.0123081496,
0.034137506,
0.0146326488,
-0.0145059535,
-0.0144623592,
-0.0279387012,
-0.0346523039,
0.0515462607,
0.0035642453,
0.0102519486,
0.0169692077,
-0.0406783931,
0.0191165861,
-0.0158809498,
0.0194345228,
0.012573557,
0.0326381363,
-0.0030133969,
-0.0670377165,
0.0515934043,
-0.0161920488,
0.0198230054,
0.0133723617,
-0.0318803787,
0.0119152339,
-0.0305414293,
0.0257623047,
0.0118321134,
0.0336326994,
-0.0150631387,
0.0031368404,
0.0189770665,
0.0275391359,
-0.0356714614,
-0.0721227974,
0.006309859,
-0.0043231705,
-0.0933468044,
0.0417056866,
0.0466130227,
0.052985426,
-0.0049128104,
-0.0751959383,
0.0458821394,
0.0179526694,
-0.0243116263,
0.0163862947,
0.0336539298,
-0.030329505,
0.048071254,
-0.0285738409,
-0.065254949,
0.0645949841,
-0.0523219183,
0.0169011075,
0.0013807266,
0.00250819,
0.0122140255,
0.0157213267,
0.0335972123,
0.0456087254,
0.0264443289,
-0.0197034571,
-0.0417994633,
0.0138263479,
0.0117826192,
0.0064210086,
-0.0047374936,
-0.0137546686,
-0.0096846102,
0.0299006756,
-0.015846476,
-0.042968221,
-0.0135263437,
0.0192681961,
-0.0156844668,
0.0374479331,
-0.0135813924,
-0.0031976812,
0.019853225,
-0.0226449165,
0.0225424524,
-0.0408541299,
-0.0125170937,
-0.0203799028,
0.014245607,
0.0623395853,
-0.0565874316,
-0.0014801816,
-0.0851220265,
-0.0000686458,
0.0554708205,
0.0063259066,
0.0664821044,
-0.0072633983,
-0.025218267,
0.0040604076,
0.0214257371,
-0.0109764785,
0.0443157852,
0.0419239327,
0.0367010161,
-0.0284921546,
0.1091281697,
0.0129522709,
-0.005417672,
0.0206435192,
0.0274413899,
0.0899659768,
0.0076239551,
0.0418617874,
-0.0429483615,
0.0181839671,
-0.0072077941,
0.0617712997,
-0.038922891,
-0.0353130922,
0.0025718976,
-0.083096303,
0.0337602682,
0.032579165,
-0.0552289151,
-0.0827299803,
0.001136196,
-0.0253279991,
-0.0094442358,
-0.0060455226,
0.0141308019,
-0.004158536,
0.0112541877,
0.0383480601,
-0.0049384744,
-0.0133278463,
-0.0127134668,
-0.0373962559,
0.0406228676,
0.0429965742,
0.0135426074,
0.0082260612,
-0.0308816731,
-0.0417992398,
0.0027652988,
0.0136402482,
0.0076069706,
0.0230650529,
0.0578557737,
-0.0183290858,
0.0039540306,
0.0543517545,
-0.0367221013,
-0.0239679627,
-0.0123046469,
0.0391156487,
-0.0333509408,
-0.0686818957,
0.0289429948,
0.0766874328,
0.0655399412,
0.0662893876,
0.0457275324,
-0.022312602,
-0.021879768,
-0.0267826226,
0.0519082844,
-0.0462963767,
0.0170205887,
-0.0388651341,
-0.0073352712,
-0.0333424509,
-0.1163843274,
0.0112581803,
0.0087424489,
0.1107383743,
0.0063616941,
-0.0144779123,
-0.0007647196,
-0.0575894266,
0.0344960466,
-0.0507841036,
-0.0603895448,
-0.0260314904,
-0.0540171564,
-0.0132719502,
0.0053042285,
-0.0386017375,
-0.0252304729,
0.050321877,
-0.0703309253,
-0.0806055069,
0.0364257321,
0.0602270849,
0.0260715354,
0.0631595775,
-0.0238473509,
-0.0333475061,
0.0656870082,
0.0405661426,
0.0152932396,
0.0236698389,
0.0053958734,
-0.0420423225,
0.0128556909,
0.0366648734,
-0.0062975329,
0.0509381741,
0.0135160387,
0.0017877796,
0.0071278429,
-0.0355831422,
0.0259031113,
0.007250505,
-0.005494609,
-0.0656880885,
0.0337736718,
-0.0237990059,
0.002661553,
-0.0123768607,
0.0151700377,
-0.0233809296,
-0.0030287865,
0.0159280151,
0.0033873555,
-0.0092113102,
0.0040071965,
-0.0324739069,
0.0656071082,
0.0431990065,
-0.0495935269,
-0.0292776879,
0.0539348312,
0.043940749,
-0.0092398785,
0.0109578175,
0.0288772918,
-0.00234007,
0.0591946729,
0.000629208,
0.0332733355,
0.0198062751,
0.0289839543,
-0.0162153784,
-0.0051683965,
-0.0654995665,
-0.0537307821,
-0.1044498608,
0.0316667072,
0.0382857434,
0.005828972,
0.0010983713,
-0.075781934,
0.0317875668,
-0.0151686044,
0.05511944,
0.0178443957,
-0.0532216057,
-0.0088727251,
-0.0085469782,
-0.0137319667,
0.0022706205,
0.0831565186,
-0.0496358126,
0.024502892,
-0.0203965604,
-0.0215610154,
-0.0413304307,
-0.0238101147,
-0.0147579685,
-0.0291927923,
-0.0229575112,
-0.0140274856,
-0.0301645286,
-0.0454100296,
0.107769534,
0.0238589719,
0.0049111773,
0.0003104931,
0.0342906639,
0.0299858358,
-0.0503066294,
0.0499866679,
-0.0150180133,
0.0196531694,
0.040030323,
-0.0199449118,
-0.0159126595,
-6.258758775e-33,
-0.0364893079,
-0.0098383082,
-0.0178652499,
-0.0187453721,
0.0025025171,
-0.0490685105,
-0.0078580715,
-0.0024682684,
0.0827979147,
0.021551447,
-0.002394971,
-0.0110931089,
0.0221402701,
0.0494034216,
0.0064033475,
-0.0061085918,
0.0606344491,
-0.0270378217,
-0.0360474847,
0.0495455749,
0.0307625085,
0.0186882969,
0.0485964194,
-0.0320794508,
-0.0125176869,
0.0222489033,
-0.0263014883,
0.0073880162,
0.0059250477,
0.0053693061,
0.0004574454,
0.0035641021,
-0.0166616272,
-0.0192128345,
-0.0259499028,
-0.0299669988,
0.0307122637,
-0.0290143862,
-0.0110961124,
-0.0192075763,
0.0236986876,
-0.0206555165,
0.0023798032,
-0.0382390656,
-0.0160776619,
0.0217057858,
0.009783458,
-0.0164403692,
-0.0500184894,
0.0244912077,
-0.0346414149,
0.0140516404,
0.0162480306,
-0.0051572332,
-0.0549017191,
0.0443067625,
0.0006030705,
-0.0419974662,
0.0089127962,
0.0397923961,
0.0603176169,
0.0480927974,
0.0163865089,
-0.0018077072,
0.0261432715,
0.0792869404,
0.0706961975,
-0.0123638781,
0.0006794848,
-0.0179382712,
0.0116791232,
0.0044654226,
-0.0042547053,
0.0315635875,
-0.0057199751,
-0.0355987102,
-0.024552783,
0.0357074365,
-0.0328313001,
-0.0099672861,
0.064049162,
-0.0416654274,
-0.015919894,
-0.0427333601,
-0.0148839271,
-0.0845935345,
-0.0025751621,
-0.0174206551,
-0.0032569424,
0.048443608,
-0.0668003708,
-0.0217455421,
0.0309431925,
-0.0349010602,
0.0399755724,
-0.0131294271,
-0.0359229371,
0.0074172849,
-0.0209329631,
-0.0042426698,
-0.026621487,
-0.0371159501,
0.0282267574,
-0.0049695522,
-0.0232814439,
0.0114847235,
0.0415162183,
0.0207277909,
-0.0578042418,
0.0120455446,
-0.0409329683,
0.0390401818,
0.0416031443,
-0.0116925398,
0.0331311859,
-0.0162956845,
0.0023931833,
0.0048386636,
0.0029483952,
0.009261813,
-0.0033712701,
0.0349060521,
0.0238068197,
0.015721228,
-0.0476663001,
0.0121520478,
-0.0481974222,
-0.0365141183,
0.032973811,
-0.0417334884,
-0.0367696546,
0.0049185003,
2.629e-7,
0.0363094695,
0.023287937,
0.0283730533,
-0.0155141866,
0.0247139614,
-0.0310646836,
0.0177069809,
0.0566360988,
-0.0070624272,
0.0174281988,
-0.012531654,
-0.0236540269,
0.0430509038,
0.0296940338,
-0.1283465177,
0.049500972,
-0.0675866008,
0.0134467427,
-0.0233376678,
-0.0223388653,
0.0042532412,
0.0621679164,
-0.0125042479,
-0.0306327417,
0.0417957902,
0.0048164162,
0.0648200512,
0.0102757886,
-0.0060717571,
0.0039967299,
0.0249953493,
-0.0205314308,
0.0039345981,
0.0314090773,
-0.0339731425,
-0.0202507693,
0.0166503619,
0.0399713479,
0.043615967,
-0.0366845131,
0.0364585482,
-0.0073977793,
-0.0146106519,
-0.0115743484,
0.0246509183,
-0.0533105731,
0.0023338208,
-0.0204687268,
-0.0278167315,
0.0168032851,
-0.0110688107,
-0.0388651118,
-0.0257857963,
0.0384791791,
0.0180373956,
0.0312260818,
0.0500754379,
0.0274018869,
-0.001311855,
-0.0464700572,
-0.0496803224,
-0.0123618348,
-0.0437194742,
-0.0002915957,
0.0056077652,
-0.0423972271,
-0.0103241876,
2.510725527e-34,
0.0364981666,
-0.0090039345,
0.0102822594,
-0.0443967544,
0.0013732172,
-0.0207300428,
0.0601727217,
0.0273525529,
0.0080997003,
-0.0642071515,
-0.0400639623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01777v1 | On the Psychology of GPT-4: Moderately anxious, slightly masculine, honest, and humble | 2024-02-01T15:58:13 | 2024-02-01T15:58:13 | Adrita Barua, Gary Brase, Ke Dong, Pascal Hitzler, Eugene Vasserman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | We subject GPT-4 to a number of rigorous psychometric tests and analyze the
results. We find that, compared to the average human, GPT-4 tends to show more
honesty and humility, and less machiavellianism and narcissism. It sometimes
exhibits ambivalent sexism, leans slightly toward masculinity, is moderately
anxious but mostly not depressive (but not always). It shows human-average
numerical literacy and has cognitive reflection abilities that are above human
average for verbal tasks. | On the Psychology of GPT-4: Moderately anxious, slightly masculine, honest, and humble: We subject GPT-4 to a number of rigorous psychometric tests and analyze the
results. We find that, compared to the average human, GPT-4 tends to show more
honesty and humility, and less machiavellianism and narcissism. It sometimes
exhibits ambivalent sexism, leans slightly toward masculinity, is moderately
anxious but mostly not depressive (but not always). It shows human-average
numerical literacy and has cognitive reflection abilities that are above human
average for verbal tasks. | [
0.0159807373,
0.0769762695,
-0.0250602122,
-0.0121711344,
-0.0192251764,
0.0390302502,
0.0034789038,
0.0045357812,
0.0018948496,
0.0388213843,
-0.0155817261,
-0.0065913796,
0.0025284314,
-0.0336340144,
0.0420860946,
-0.049182836,
-0.0054352367,
0.0404624902,
0.0690932944,
-0.0073570507,
-0.0414227843,
0.0340140313,
0.0139196394,
-0.0052958964,
-0.0003856327,
-0.0493831076,
0.0476564951,
-0.0017792943,
0.0253377799,
-0.0399883874,
0.0052337442,
0.052950684,
0.0041287709,
0.0027666255,
0.0000022978,
-0.0175716598,
0.0268522501,
0.0120719299,
0.0367473289,
0.0064805527,
0.0462691709,
0.0201139972,
0.0413417704,
0.0585301407,
-0.046161741,
-0.0695269108,
0.0020765099,
0.0794532299,
0.0376578756,
-0.0003916032,
-0.0056293146,
0.0088283541,
-0.0169371441,
-0.050097581,
0.0150757665,
0.0110214949,
0.0229778737,
-0.0420643352,
-0.028572768,
0.0178291146,
-0.0140453391,
-0.0521698482,
-0.0085730506,
0.0349049009,
-0.0470235422,
-0.0123088108,
-0.0007924703,
0.002799981,
-0.0097645298,
-0.0307942163,
0.1075640693,
0.0210848097,
0.0038986295,
0.0552254803,
0.0390143096,
-0.0214205049,
-0.0121689932,
-0.0058248527,
-0.0447422154,
-0.0403873585,
-0.0170495901,
0.0029257431,
-0.0376180783,
-0.0016564174,
0.036271181,
0.0760686845,
0.0043721739,
-0.0146006038,
0.0218507983,
-0.0172278527,
-0.0142817758,
-0.0353931487,
-0.0019022541,
-0.0164189227,
0.0345979854,
-0.0253267363,
-0.0031316737,
0.0363086723,
0.014807594,
0.011322814,
-0.0320866331,
0.0479919873,
-0.004080202,
-0.0212490354,
0.0221829247,
0.0516623408,
0.0453572161,
-0.0187480953,
0.0030168027,
-0.0026863632,
-0.0417861491,
-0.0198890511,
-0.0069694091,
0.0176968817,
0.0806484222,
0.026030235,
-0.0665525198,
0.009842962,
-0.0159681011,
0.0039986777,
-0.0481526516,
-0.0221253689,
-0.016731577,
-0.0086353468,
-0.0070204632,
0.0307076816,
-0.0819860697,
-0.0173998699,
-0.008949657,
-0.0967029035,
0.0251854341,
-0.0473243371,
-0.0055650435,
-0.0430964604,
0.0283027906,
-0.0006156543,
0.0265259277,
-0.0181229301,
-0.0011593417,
0.0256252959,
-0.0094662635,
-0.0594430566,
-0.0042490344,
0.0152159436,
-0.0146125145,
0.0459360294,
0.0020900064,
-0.0494017862,
0.0165237859,
0.0013414618,
0.0246837158,
0.0399848931,
0.021155877,
0.0241704341,
0.0283722375,
0.0370672867,
-0.0334304348,
0.0107309809,
0.0104834726,
-0.0325973853,
0.0063586533,
-0.073664479,
0.054979749,
-0.0264531523,
-0.0196471717,
0.020701373,
0.0744916499,
-0.0023141599,
-0.0212443788,
0.0387931205,
0.0787091851,
-0.0026541324,
-0.0050129588,
0.0554058403,
0.0925758332,
0.0552363694,
0.0298407096,
0.0808091313,
-0.0207951106,
0.0335574783,
0.0169183444,
0.0315347016,
-0.0583819039,
0.0064248536,
-0.0281530041,
-0.0097025195,
-0.0580989309,
0.0212100409,
-0.0085210633,
-0.0043315222,
-0.0019224609,
0.0338668413,
0.005228607,
0.0171133801,
-0.024335783,
-0.0470331386,
-0.0022293152,
-0.0473947003,
0.0096990233,
-0.0269636977,
-0.0553487018,
-0.0368658379,
0.0146694984,
0.0108928597,
-0.0282637626,
0.0279166941,
0.0004780278,
-0.0378214903,
-0.0169216525,
-0.0047600931,
0.0664559603,
0.0315838158,
-0.0019415509,
-0.036134962,
0.0089209387,
0.0061685368,
0.0116979266,
0.0350500867,
-0.0277127009,
0.0919378549,
0.037512701,
0.02191386,
0.0330816694,
-0.0243456047,
0.0259530991,
-0.0567859598,
0.0043660179,
-0.0105028423,
0.0749800503,
-0.0018355884,
0.0121975839,
-0.0102102468,
-0.0214431547,
0.0143955601,
0.0222196896,
0.0279918648,
-0.0140837273,
0.1056004688,
-0.0281085055,
-0.0584372021,
-0.0458214879,
0.0667700171,
0.0117655713,
-0.0041011102,
0.0137274778,
-0.0417351499,
0.0281884689,
-0.0129800271,
-0.0063162376,
-0.0058256425,
0.0459926724,
0.0588486306,
0.0276659057,
0.0232710559,
-0.0086813523,
-0.0207265522,
-0.0520143174,
0.0135348327,
-0.0407989696,
0.0058422009,
-0.0531012975,
0.0096331863,
0.0277686566,
0.0124103706,
0.0328484625,
-0.0357455872,
0.0018569729,
-0.0783847719,
0.005155189,
0.0167296026,
0.0386570953,
0.0265016481,
-0.0546993129,
-0.0593625009,
0.0105375024,
-0.0175857153,
0.0260508414,
0.0232614186,
0.0462599136,
0.0166614912,
-0.0018712352,
0.0373858474,
0.0096883513,
-0.0024693876,
-0.0589341857,
-0.0495226756,
-0.0222372022,
-0.0054112421,
0.0088618156,
-0.0085782986,
-0.0591714047,
0.0086718928,
-0.0028903659,
-0.0629196316,
0.0573294982,
0.035669852,
0.0465788841,
0.0463296585,
0.0612898357,
0.0351427719,
-0.0043030735,
0.047277268,
0.0374213755,
0.0049324688,
0.0236662682,
-0.0128575359,
0.0124611957,
-0.0870476961,
-0.0330901742,
-0.0024107781,
0.0128528588,
0.0192731936,
-0.0198884401,
0.0432829037,
0.0150878476,
-0.0285351835,
0.0177971926,
0.0030704506,
-0.0064866212,
0.0537133142,
0.0064335754,
-0.0069067734,
-0.0063398764,
0.0285665374,
-0.017011879,
0.0116365161,
0.0002945939,
0.0442373417,
0.0867881626,
0.0163528174,
-0.0131098637,
0.0467584059,
-0.0609238669,
-0.0529288687,
-0.0431122147,
0.0010225796,
-0.0102600763,
0.0521325059,
-0.0283880346,
-0.0451826155,
-0.0041345623,
-0.0321461558,
0.0263043754,
-0.0016710678,
-0.0222280435,
0.0069562662,
0.0015220607,
-0.050255537,
-0.012134118,
-0.0545333885,
0.0490304716,
0.0234625693,
-0.0527187735,
-0.001184664,
0.0136138257,
-0.0622909851,
0.0350697376,
0.023527924,
0.0404447466,
-0.0497663654,
-0.0573977903,
0.0047347257,
-0.0492987037,
0.0146345682,
0.0110304169,
-0.0053114053,
0.0019079314,
0.0164577644,
-0.0201890394,
-0.0124868825,
0.0232042558,
0.0150319925,
0.0245526154,
0.078413561,
-0.0356906466,
-0.0196958706,
0.026966406,
0.0202106424,
-0.0455283262,
0.0224892292,
0.0162285659,
0.0009394403,
0.0383836031,
0.0051344354,
0.044197388,
-0.0514527261,
-0.0324811377,
-0.0062493715,
-0.0502069257,
0.0297696553,
0.0208421573,
-0.0523142777,
-0.0415463038,
0.0250136647,
0.0405478701,
0.0255031213,
-0.0093290769,
-0.019608872,
0.0277482513,
0.0054781754,
-0.0370522067,
-0.0503805652,
-0.0275576338,
0.0922522172,
0.0106202494,
-0.017808158,
-0.0277141109,
0.0560911447,
-0.0410689339,
-0.0389904864,
-0.0211058147,
-0.0156388916,
-0.0181200095,
-0.0020016192,
-0.009444885,
-0.0721248686,
0.0093127275,
-0.1110604629,
0.0414446257,
0.0142278373,
0.1057716832,
0.0257911291,
0.0234164614,
0.0110967997,
-0.0907529071,
-0.0011048722,
0.012990973,
0.003023363,
0.0241002515,
-0.0014354538,
0.0200620852,
0.0117364796,
0.0103538679,
0.0645734742,
0.0199291501,
-0.0402065217,
-0.0397550613,
0.0549940802,
0.0092928922,
-0.0326646604,
-0.100475654,
0.0165954158,
0.0163829643,
-0.0119528649,
-0.0928186849,
-0.0495464392,
0.0381237641,
-0.0507679097,
0.0324424468,
0.0554236695,
-0.0206040163,
-0.0019630981,
-0.0465202257,
0.0240039583,
-0.0273541454,
-0.016934773,
-0.0124831032,
0.0424177051,
0.0118012186,
0.0401671641,
0.0387750715,
0.0312411189,
-0.0454716049,
0.0301939007,
0.0069212522,
-0.0138500035,
-0.0237694494,
-0.0521565154,
0.0511541404,
-0.0328295417,
0.0578986369,
-0.0103402184,
-0.0077683735,
0.0152770728,
0.0363310054,
-0.0424476005,
-0.0575435869,
-0.0076417597,
-0.0361346789,
0.0244273152,
0.0069437297,
0.0108408714,
-0.0230856724,
0.0142317777,
0.0018793365,
-0.0558390319,
-0.0574480332,
-0.0016662435,
-0.0044412203,
-0.0714782178,
-0.0055711553,
0.0070068426,
-0.0255075656,
-0.1026398614,
-0.034070123,
0.0103299804,
-0.0776392072,
0.0141475545,
-0.0252988376,
-0.0154592143,
-0.0440840907,
0.0063780528,
-0.0121924104,
-0.0364544652,
-0.0222954638,
0.0703719631,
0.0010694476,
0.100276649,
-0.0159953702,
0.0133475363,
0.0448328331,
0.0276437998,
-0.0784433931,
-0.0862699673,
0.0170186274,
-0.0536688156,
-0.0605768301,
0.0081392881,
0.0202839207,
-0.0774903893,
0.0008555314,
-0.0043282057,
0.0035188666,
-0.0094134621,
0.0153997308,
0.0082038082,
0.0179215129,
0.0245674793,
-0.0486350395,
-0.01712244,
-0.0183987636,
0.0210240316,
-0.0164487157,
-0.0584731586,
-0.0273508113,
0.0010091532,
0.0077545107,
0.009946567,
-0.0092620188,
-0.0215542521,
-0.0664896667,
-0.0526835769,
-0.0425488316,
-0.0230606813,
0.0063439365,
-0.0081422953,
-0.0167854112,
0.0205071382,
-0.0403801277,
-0.0858010724,
-0.0212999713,
0.0020396081,
-0.0492428467,
0.024797922,
-0.0057101548,
-6.72291374e-33,
-0.0360614061,
-0.010671475,
-0.0023292173,
-0.007768576,
-0.0357246958,
-0.0549366549,
-0.0106179686,
0.0315808281,
-0.0507184044,
0.0072855731,
-0.0191208962,
0.0439371131,
-0.0002645954,
-0.025941072,
0.0623360649,
0.0456170216,
0.0209565014,
-0.0195718706,
-0.0063157519,
0.0073276684,
-0.0071794586,
0.0173158217,
0.1098289117,
-0.0207450446,
0.0249196999,
-0.0326612927,
0.0001521835,
-0.0410376973,
0.0179385524,
-0.0518222451,
0.0161430333,
0.0055776234,
0.0493265055,
0.0259337686,
0.0233475957,
0.0202932619,
-0.0362047702,
-0.0192440636,
0.0106220609,
-0.0363557748,
0.0073342551,
-0.0443048291,
-0.0174003318,
-0.0228698775,
-0.0098277647,
-0.0889762491,
0.0091851186,
0.0282874051,
0.069801569,
0.0272183213,
-0.0071870517,
-0.0210387837,
-0.0141761228,
0.0285732821,
-0.0514847003,
0.0320943519,
-0.0324774384,
0.0100691756,
-0.0418988802,
0.0098017454,
-0.0290471669,
-0.0020239956,
-0.0161508434,
-0.0302833933,
0.0399758406,
-0.0113581689,
0.0633003935,
0.062595129,
-0.0483185574,
-0.0239863507,
0.0310429595,
-0.0283326283,
0.0421375148,
-0.0164149012,
0.0296352394,
-0.0554018281,
0.0470248871,
-0.0424063094,
0.1058453918,
0.0257877801,
-0.0119229425,
-0.0175712239,
-0.0305626821,
-0.0041947281,
0.0185816288,
-0.0351799168,
-0.0017827123,
-0.0432239622,
-0.0030563485,
-0.0667966232,
0.0092235422,
0.0294251032,
0.0470060781,
0.0125770345,
-0.0303888954,
-0.0337170586,
-0.0357903019,
0.0303307064,
0.0239353068,
-0.0236203186,
0.0175101627,
0.0385973714,
0.0156979263,
0.0624006689,
0.0640769899,
0.0111841559,
-0.0295049269,
0.0160910673,
-0.072820887,
-0.0041235662,
0.0044354862,
0.022704035,
0.0146823619,
-0.0246871356,
-0.027981298,
0.0035403748,
0.0460715294,
-0.0607271567,
0.0300932135,
-0.0086056683,
-0.0541930571,
0.0229184013,
-0.0290493984,
-0.010756244,
0.0290316418,
0.0016547306,
0.0108464304,
0.0474995263,
0.0538010262,
0.0130058462,
0.0124560138,
-0.0459895246,
3.068e-7,
-0.0606771223,
0.0476505272,
-0.0225538332,
0.0075836922,
0.0344222412,
0.0223273784,
-0.0039027142,
0.0445503667,
0.0639262497,
-0.0104791922,
0.0444009006,
-0.003531032,
0.0282469057,
0.0126798721,
0.0079951305,
0.0112173753,
-0.0086440062,
-0.0608361848,
-0.0280704312,
0.0514766984,
0.0488089882,
-0.0006257834,
-0.0115210731,
-0.007542369,
0.0102553889,
0.021728728,
-0.0202655196,
-0.0033675758,
0.0338736139,
-0.0050838147,
-0.0289860871,
0.0060264776,
-0.0102036316,
0.0943879411,
-0.0077668824,
-0.0579255819,
0.0052729989,
0.0316954181,
-0.0339113958,
0.0435099863,
0.0008904894,
0.0362650007,
-0.0315479338,
-0.0366754644,
0.027094014,
0.0122016035,
-0.0568807274,
0.0178012028,
-0.0461606868,
-0.0406668782,
0.0234146584,
0.0062777605,
-0.012201109,
0.038914863,
0.0124708675,
-0.0244100429,
0.0252311286,
-0.027250953,
0.0851421803,
-0.0254346728,
-0.0152920922,
-0.0720958859,
-0.0244939309,
0.0433852747,
0.0232936274,
-0.0127872294,
-0.009790251,
2.574378316e-34,
-0.0238224268,
0.0401366092,
0.0118753323,
-0.0734654069,
0.0632735267,
0.0223232508,
0.010679408,
0.0117239933,
0.0175163019,
0.0187404603,
-0.027167704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00667v1 | Improving Weak-to-Strong Generalization with Scalable Oversight and Ensemble Learning | 2024-02-01T15:30:19 | 2024-02-01T15:30:19 | Jitao Sang, Yuhang Wang, Jing Zhang, Yanxu Zhu, Chao Kong, Junhong Ye, Shuyu Wei, Jinlin Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a follow-up study to OpenAI's recent superalignment work
on Weak-to-Strong Generalization (W2SG). Superalignment focuses on ensuring
that high-level AI systems remain consistent with human values and intentions
when dealing with complex, high-risk tasks. The W2SG framework has opened new
possibilities for empirical research in this evolving field. Our study
simulates two phases of superalignment under the W2SG framework: the
development of general superhuman models and the progression towards
superintelligence. In the first phase, based on human supervision, the quality
of weak supervision is enhanced through a combination of scalable oversight and
ensemble learning, reducing the capability gap between weak teachers and strong
students. In the second phase, an automatic alignment evaluator is employed as
the weak supervisor. By recursively updating this auto aligner, the
capabilities of the weak teacher models are synchronously enhanced, achieving
weak-to-strong supervision over stronger student models.We also provide an
initial validation of the proposed approach for the first phase. Using the SciQ
task as example, we explore ensemble learning for weak teacher models through
bagging and boosting. Scalable oversight is explored through two auxiliary
settings: human-AI interaction and AI-AI debate. Additionally, the paper
discusses the impact of improved weak supervision on enhancing weak-to-strong
generalization based on in-context learning. Experiment code and dataset will
be released at https://github.com/ADaM-BJTU/W2SG. | Improving Weak-to-Strong Generalization with Scalable Oversight and Ensemble Learning: This paper presents a follow-up study to OpenAI's recent superalignment work
on Weak-to-Strong Generalization (W2SG). Superalignment focuses on ensuring
that high-level AI systems remain consistent with human values and intentions
when dealing with complex, high-risk tasks. The W2SG framework has opened new
possibilities for empirical research in this evolving field. Our study
simulates two phases of superalignment under the W2SG framework: the
development of general superhuman models and the progression towards
superintelligence. In the first phase, based on human supervision, the quality
of weak supervision is enhanced through a combination of scalable oversight and
ensemble learning, reducing the capability gap between weak teachers and strong
students. In the second phase, an automatic alignment evaluator is employed as
the weak supervisor. By recursively updating this auto aligner, the
capabilities of the weak teacher models are synchronously enhanced, achieving
weak-to-strong supervision over stronger student models.We also provide an
initial validation of the proposed approach for the first phase. Using the SciQ
task as example, we explore ensemble learning for weak teacher models through
bagging and boosting. Scalable oversight is explored through two auxiliary
settings: human-AI interaction and AI-AI debate. Additionally, the paper
discusses the impact of improved weak supervision on enhancing weak-to-strong
generalization based on in-context learning. Experiment code and dataset will
be released at https://github.com/ADaM-BJTU/W2SG. | [
0.0045174132,
0.0564973131,
-0.0074353158,
-0.0170796383,
0.0203964859,
0.0185702443,
-0.0032356565,
-0.0381331071,
-0.0024360958,
0.0148705058,
-0.0271396413,
-0.0223814137,
-0.0364107229,
0.0122171147,
0.0359951854,
-0.0752461925,
0.0478918888,
-0.0499454848,
0.0177511256,
0.0026433663,
-0.016204726,
-0.0598262325,
-0.020224696,
0.0360788777,
-0.0049406285,
-0.0117042474,
-0.0272780228,
-0.0205763429,
0.0654806867,
-0.0023587991,
-0.006372767,
0.0104627134,
0.052632682,
0.0422975793,
0.0000021527,
-0.0302605592,
0.0149212973,
-0.0075786184,
0.0060306322,
-0.0476867519,
-0.0656343028,
-0.0126894023,
-0.0232729986,
-0.0007148556,
-0.0572133996,
-0.0005671992,
0.0447021984,
0.063397944,
0.0418975167,
0.0510648713,
0.0139043052,
-0.006709706,
0.0493451171,
-0.019384712,
-0.0051981551,
-0.0930677652,
0.0165445525,
0.0126811275,
-0.0125674047,
-0.0293313935,
-0.0274426639,
-0.0109242611,
0.0191943459,
-0.0214373115,
0.0413182378,
0.0086416071,
-0.0500022881,
-0.010239386,
-0.0233639162,
0.0543504208,
-0.0193390027,
0.0111574084,
-0.0333072916,
0.0031260615,
0.0509096533,
0.0098703569,
-0.0324163213,
0.0138357766,
-0.0125538865,
-0.0000324569,
-0.0177329164,
0.0235294774,
0.0155790569,
-0.0005285089,
-0.0258258097,
0.0470649004,
-0.0227993298,
-0.0350360982,
0.0172552932,
0.0387024954,
-0.0904789418,
-0.0214701481,
-0.0073102857,
0.0387395807,
-0.0987726524,
-0.0103306649,
-0.0297972374,
-0.0388732553,
-0.0365187526,
0.0252957828,
0.0351019427,
0.0123553937,
-0.0175108127,
0.033113908,
-0.0051703067,
0.1051793173,
-0.0309924893,
0.0619668551,
-0.0225893036,
0.0246277992,
-0.0598448627,
-0.0072456771,
0.011709474,
0.0154789183,
-0.0076425648,
0.0140000228,
-0.0340303443,
-0.0048039844,
-0.0577244163,
0.0321792401,
-0.0096720438,
0.0116309607,
-0.0560399219,
0.0130484272,
-0.0305169336,
0.0053698816,
-0.0624696985,
0.0204284508,
0.0412521362,
0.0207722876,
-0.0149741732,
0.0103885531,
-0.0318002664,
-0.0082120625,
0.0003294169,
0.0644292682,
-0.0085966578,
0.0062029921,
-0.0354560651,
-0.0001987763,
0.0022826535,
-0.0618020333,
0.0014535693,
-0.0064183008,
0.0240501594,
-0.0354577713,
-0.0239319038,
-0.0173452739,
-0.0059905611,
-0.0366196893,
0.0090352371,
0.0357515775,
0.0032813537,
0.008034477,
0.0140851131,
0.013515166,
-0.0717137679,
0.044338204,
0.0084185358,
0.0204719435,
0.0095583824,
0.012896196,
0.0726402849,
0.0155594787,
-0.0202628747,
0.0127537856,
0.0070074536,
-0.0192914847,
0.0185757708,
0.0758967474,
0.0316846594,
0.037650194,
-0.0216864757,
0.0663502589,
0.0375552736,
0.0382700488,
-0.0026957279,
-0.0021452515,
0.0347297899,
-0.0393314101,
0.0035168699,
0.0378990099,
-0.0768018588,
0.0392403826,
-0.0173646379,
-0.0171262939,
-0.0769598708,
0.0443690754,
-0.0349379927,
-0.0612071194,
0.0312332213,
0.0137898838,
-0.039678216,
0.000775766,
0.0680804253,
0.0156208351,
-0.0180307943,
-0.0772379711,
0.0105959112,
-0.0557513349,
-0.0010113755,
-0.090271771,
0.0254609585,
0.0343245231,
0.0388150662,
-0.055313509,
-0.0333531797,
-0.028369166,
0.011256611,
0.0000825422,
0.006078688,
-0.0289108735,
0.0118824746,
-0.0298974756,
-0.0369349644,
0.0224051755,
0.0187644996,
0.0081344703,
-0.0068585724,
-0.0376341753,
-0.0360800661,
-0.0045450428,
-0.062562421,
0.0628977865,
-0.0383188613,
-0.02890498,
-0.0504059903,
0.0303339586,
0.0317340866,
0.0327223986,
-0.0332170166,
-0.0102697751,
0.0217023734,
-0.0073693143,
-0.0300283674,
-0.0092838714,
-0.0399878807,
0.0314418003,
0.037451908,
-0.0654414594,
-0.0352094211,
0.0339035168,
-0.0084414706,
-0.0609498732,
-0.0083964532,
0.0173305552,
-0.0061981338,
0.0079866527,
0.040556062,
-0.0500361919,
-0.0341876335,
-0.0257985741,
0.0731873065,
0.0160374977,
-0.0431495011,
0.0204888266,
0.0218423735,
0.0149805164,
-0.0467507653,
-0.021106381,
0.0088931229,
-0.0054289466,
0.0220608916,
0.0466392711,
-0.0116152512,
-0.0322489701,
-0.0082734376,
-0.0570554063,
0.0087023266,
-0.0184594151,
-0.0046075545,
-0.0142271705,
-0.0160646308,
-0.0092706252,
0.0138149289,
-0.015309887,
-0.008766084,
-0.0291893762,
-0.0367015712,
0.0265952572,
0.01228741,
-0.0139260301,
-0.0444247946,
0.0204108097,
-0.0281754266,
0.0185707491,
0.0526541099,
-0.0107921315,
-0.043994993,
0.0334498361,
-0.0209540669,
0.0322036743,
-0.0214469712,
-0.0417936146,
0.0532691143,
-0.018007258,
0.0415392071,
0.1305932552,
-0.0233136639,
0.0254268367,
0.0693000555,
0.0496752784,
-0.0381930992,
0.0378878862,
0.0251546279,
-0.0622469224,
-0.012311752,
0.0531648807,
-0.0083262194,
0.0488696247,
-0.0227773711,
-0.0019310472,
-0.0608315505,
0.0233959761,
-0.0147505058,
-0.059255451,
-0.0024092307,
-0.03302259,
-0.0114941169,
0.0043447316,
-0.0541282371,
-0.0438990407,
0.0673473328,
0.0501365699,
0.0196270552,
-0.0056077135,
-0.0207300987,
0.0010170511,
0.0580912009,
-0.0206393842,
0.0216048826,
-0.0177592803,
-0.0130000692,
-0.1056039333,
0.0144672589,
0.0039468198,
-0.012002686,
0.0080234893,
-0.0311787352,
-0.0198714621,
-0.0056379563,
-0.0562418401,
-0.0392112955,
0.0372461416,
-0.0246002804,
0.0395498388,
0.0087980377,
-0.0514253713,
-0.0435001478,
-0.0211243182,
0.0367740951,
0.0072155502,
-0.0379413404,
-0.0135190897,
-0.018412333,
-0.0321815982,
0.0291165654,
-0.016048776,
-0.006731424,
-0.0639209226,
0.0551598333,
0.0343583263,
0.0868522748,
-0.0340362564,
-0.0482904427,
-0.0021817782,
-0.0050174855,
0.0117982281,
0.0162150208,
0.0122814393,
0.107687369,
-0.01865796,
-0.0039090104,
0.0403140411,
0.0025206637,
-0.0163811091,
0.0139310937,
-0.02263478,
-0.0051149656,
0.0128533095,
0.0290320311,
0.009138884,
-0.0325082466,
-0.0103763584,
0.0748730525,
-0.0092070643,
-0.0651226714,
0.0629749224,
-0.0717325211,
0.0148993954,
0.0374270976,
-0.0508497916,
-0.0397627577,
0.0150368316,
0.0310255699,
-0.0444779992,
0.0281760432,
0.0113747912,
0.0457149148,
-0.0103943646,
0.0391372517,
0.040435262,
-0.0369352363,
-0.0104619283,
-0.0934690535,
0.0463898219,
0.1140097901,
0.0107330149,
-0.0278342571,
0.0081955902,
0.0216776133,
0.0039819996,
0.0418160781,
0.055340521,
0.0275072753,
-0.0313851982,
-0.0186503287,
-0.0314753354,
0.0714784265,
0.0117452051,
0.0128507027,
0.0370858572,
0.1097857878,
-0.0329423994,
-0.0493682064,
-0.0310808793,
-0.0654930398,
0.0474107638,
0.0484634116,
0.0052196775,
-0.0629750118,
-0.0312613882,
-0.0043177353,
0.0220346898,
-0.0221906751,
-0.0149840685,
0.0266791377,
0.0083963294,
-0.0427629985,
-0.0636217371,
-0.0153345577,
0.0367669873,
0.0595597364,
0.0272100642,
-0.0411324911,
-0.0156794023,
0.0157027952,
0.0276805889,
0.0082334597,
0.013485874,
0.0153072318,
-0.0219155233,
-0.0361959822,
0.030784186,
-0.0003060944,
0.0164037906,
0.0229617171,
-0.0149121229,
-0.0652100816,
0.0299188178,
0.0909717306,
0.0297204368,
0.0270653553,
-0.0102060828,
-0.0348399952,
0.0546430051,
0.0597911328,
0.0002024824,
0.0243102275,
0.032610897,
-0.0214089081,
-0.005535752,
0.0200674571,
-0.0566120632,
0.0300975274,
0.0412611738,
0.010280313,
-0.0308734961,
0.0409585238,
0.0311419088,
0.0030804332,
0.0296090599,
-0.0439420156,
-0.0197006073,
-0.031275183,
-0.0117802257,
0.0143562909,
-0.0302735511,
-0.046715416,
0.0274210703,
0.0440976247,
0.0357216783,
0.0455247052,
-0.0005890721,
0.040322829,
0.0234918408,
-0.0460399352,
0.0270171128,
0.0178295374,
0.0635784119,
0.0052150274,
0.0263017844,
-0.0048715365,
0.0058421809,
-0.0036254609,
0.0321945883,
0.0434511304,
0.0519340746,
0.053627383,
0.0507988967,
-0.0124132987,
0.015116456,
-0.1211843714,
-0.0599499904,
-0.0005842961,
0.0371974371,
0.0381236672,
0.0310003385,
-0.0153676923,
-0.0015709727,
0.0097860647,
0.0072723804,
0.0307706892,
-0.0180670526,
0.0300797895,
-0.0027032273,
0.0365757309,
0.0171565507,
0.0487827808,
0.0456153266,
-0.0590232052,
0.0482021831,
-0.0623111613,
0.0148583651,
-0.0093794428,
-0.0062573361,
0.0249366574,
0.0014596557,
-0.0005399223,
-0.0371877812,
-0.0259842686,
-0.0192929283,
-0.0110316817,
0.0408886634,
0.0102421455,
-0.0055128071,
-0.0004878305,
0.0290967748,
-0.0442964137,
-0.0220316034,
0.0249715075,
-0.0646616071,
0.0342191271,
0.0171838403,
-0.0261610653,
-6.026946514e-33,
-0.0181618109,
-0.0315900035,
-0.0111973668,
-0.0141102141,
-0.0259501971,
-0.0122008445,
-0.0113152647,
-0.0004901321,
-0.0281096343,
0.0294747278,
-0.0144697065,
0.0215496104,
-0.0003460382,
-0.0186922122,
0.0474558584,
-0.0169361588,
0.0251082703,
-0.0176085997,
-0.0354263373,
0.041086331,
0.0370351225,
0.0272383373,
0.0167240445,
-0.1043210402,
0.0155550595,
-0.0256641302,
-0.0551680475,
0.017770322,
-0.0135595445,
0.0151497563,
0.012559074,
-0.0121361492,
-0.0026622373,
-0.0126409512,
-0.0086381109,
0.0403454453,
-0.0323489867,
-0.017183708,
-0.0496014506,
-0.0295578949,
-0.0573445447,
-0.0407756492,
0.0444522463,
0.0065399525,
-0.0437265337,
-0.0204628017,
0.0349197648,
-0.0117302639,
0.009882994,
-0.0403156579,
-0.0465866029,
0.0054960437,
-0.0334928073,
-0.0158197843,
-0.0343072973,
0.0162772574,
-0.0067110681,
-0.0459588319,
0.0291537475,
0.0146665992,
0.0223211423,
-0.0421478786,
0.0397556201,
0.0549650639,
-0.012888181,
0.0515361838,
0.0495724715,
-0.0017114568,
-0.0103817312,
-0.0834397227,
-0.0224856082,
0.0675811917,
0.0549213812,
0.0322375149,
0.0288217682,
0.0037361854,
-0.0543764532,
0.0324866176,
0.0352794081,
0.0292116795,
-0.0382279344,
0.0394203328,
-0.076132305,
-0.0070704054,
0.0247275755,
-0.0854952782,
-0.0046217549,
-0.0108817685,
0.0351617523,
-0.0036850439,
-0.0292601846,
0.0140755,
0.0124778943,
-0.0476453044,
0.0655784234,
0.0052385158,
-0.0222098865,
0.0521670282,
-0.0152554447,
-0.031439025,
-0.0446154661,
-0.0629974604,
0.0462450385,
0.0473555215,
0.0537621342,
0.0319496393,
0.0632672161,
0.0300336815,
-0.0071816579,
-0.0059457044,
-0.015022818,
-0.0226954632,
0.0537176132,
-0.0496109091,
0.0347358175,
-0.0138878319,
0.0098245097,
0.0302876346,
0.0070512774,
0.0117007587,
-0.0255718101,
-0.0075722425,
-0.0108194128,
-0.014918807,
-0.0020212845,
-0.0295118988,
-0.0125510059,
-0.028288994,
-0.0063223587,
-0.0802009925,
-0.0129378084,
0.0114982622,
2.942e-7,
-0.0138058523,
0.0055542011,
0.0344277211,
-0.0563225672,
-0.0256995447,
0.0367868952,
-0.0498105176,
0.0385566056,
-0.0043717967,
-0.0134679191,
0.0470783971,
0.0275875647,
-0.0017285187,
0.0016785011,
-0.0456226319,
-0.0260499585,
-0.0373637006,
0.0242519658,
-0.0566085689,
0.0046082279,
0.0551180504,
0.0705377087,
0.0096374471,
-0.0133340508,
0.0228206851,
-0.0593339205,
0.0204227362,
0.0259165764,
0.0340003856,
0.0306264814,
0.0348323211,
0.0364330821,
-0.0383744687,
0.0475471132,
0.0046623773,
0.0431278944,
0.0284363385,
0.0216334201,
-0.0468223244,
0.0368994661,
-0.0143273976,
0.0488388352,
0.0413612761,
0.0213153232,
0.0425373465,
-0.0642047971,
-0.0152341565,
0.0014914136,
-0.0181691088,
-0.0034480395,
-0.0449247286,
0.0072888704,
0.0502426289,
0.0242280494,
-0.0248050466,
0.0374213643,
-0.030464489,
-0.053779874,
-0.0028455171,
0.0187367853,
-0.0158134643,
-0.0823479518,
0.011645495,
0.0365045182,
0.0142026106,
-0.0576354191,
-0.0059646452,
2.501167518e-34,
-0.0157864764,
-0.0230051186,
0.0291447099,
0.003571623,
0.0270485319,
-0.0364721753,
-0.064128682,
0.0072003002,
0.0727191046,
-0.0103036538,
-0.010424369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00658v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00658v2 | Learning Planning-based Reasoning by Trajectories Collection and Process Reward Synthesizing | 2024-02-01T15:18:33 | 2024-04-15T06:36:24 | Fangkai Jiao, Chengwei Qin, Zhengyuan Liu, Nancy F. Chen, Shafiq Joty | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks through step-by-step rationale generation.
However, recent studies have raised concerns regarding the hallucination and
flaws in their reasoning process. Substantial efforts are being made to improve
the reliability and faithfulness of the generated rationales. Some approaches
model reasoning as planning, while others focus on annotating for process
supervision. Nevertheless, the planning-based search process often results in
high latency due to the frequent assessment of intermediate reasoning states
and the extensive exploration space. Additionally, supervising the reasoning
process with human annotation is costly and challenging to scale for LLM
training. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose a framework to
learn planning-based reasoning through Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) on
collected trajectories, which are ranked according to synthesized process
rewards. Our results on challenging logical reasoning benchmarks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our learning framework, showing that our 7B model can
surpass the strong counterparts like GPT-3.5-Turbo. | Learning Planning-based Reasoning by Trajectories Collection and Process Reward Synthesizing: Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks through step-by-step rationale generation.
However, recent studies have raised concerns regarding the hallucination and
flaws in their reasoning process. Substantial efforts are being made to improve
the reliability and faithfulness of the generated rationales. Some approaches
model reasoning as planning, while others focus on annotating for process
supervision. Nevertheless, the planning-based search process often results in
high latency due to the frequent assessment of intermediate reasoning states
and the extensive exploration space. Additionally, supervising the reasoning
process with human annotation is costly and challenging to scale for LLM
training. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose a framework to
learn planning-based reasoning through Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) on
collected trajectories, which are ranked according to synthesized process
rewards. Our results on challenging logical reasoning benchmarks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our learning framework, showing that our 7B model can
surpass the strong counterparts like GPT-3.5-Turbo. | [
0.0272291638,
0.0427385382,
0.0052182809,
0.0216912627,
-0.0464945994,
0.0074330694,
-0.0262013078,
-0.0261240862,
-0.0336185023,
-0.0094227567,
0.015094066,
-0.0059903339,
-0.0265247133,
0.011225963,
-0.0087236678,
-0.0639693737,
0.0487211198,
-0.0570495762,
0.0210887231,
0.0171743855,
-0.0151729798,
0.0459588021,
-0.03596076,
0.0612929724,
-0.0012978689,
0.0027808773,
-0.0295236167,
-0.0061148754,
0.0429266021,
-0.0767844841,
-0.039634563,
0.026024973,
0.0513342507,
0.0097947996,
0.0000021639,
-0.0587036461,
-0.0324699357,
-0.0099896807,
-0.0435221419,
-0.0418500863,
-0.0222234242,
0.0147786774,
-0.0055482159,
0.0494299009,
-0.0182160977,
0.0401432775,
0.0081518739,
0.0401552469,
0.0686420277,
0.0816684365,
0.0123650087,
-0.0623689704,
-0.008022611,
-0.0291175023,
0.0105434619,
-0.0357380621,
-0.0224311259,
0.0321989432,
0.0508140065,
0.0347382203,
0.0272998288,
-0.0215290282,
0.039705079,
-0.0463968478,
-0.0296937115,
0.0500745513,
0.0254164524,
-0.0164710637,
0.005937153,
0.0758335516,
-0.0103413956,
-0.0250950791,
0.0313588753,
-0.0223079138,
-0.0290677492,
-0.0411919467,
-0.0400340594,
0.0647859201,
0.000828745,
0.0352927968,
0.0441296473,
-0.0015563146,
0.0262356512,
0.0026951667,
-0.0248323679,
0.0942467079,
-0.0183526743,
-0.018751394,
0.0219170805,
-0.0151295085,
-0.0227298886,
-0.0621836036,
-0.0102512883,
0.0668106377,
-0.0648078024,
0.0240872651,
-0.0013505067,
0.062839888,
-0.0032559985,
0.017033888,
0.0597720034,
0.0705955103,
0.0190603584,
0.0396540798,
-0.0314684808,
0.0321176536,
-0.0103563974,
0.056610927,
-0.0328856744,
0.0281372759,
-0.0778826624,
0.0145100998,
-0.0221777391,
0.0420336202,
-0.0658879578,
-0.0118059609,
-0.0419467241,
0.0373350382,
-0.0278249681,
0.0439549536,
0.0425509959,
-0.0017808661,
0.0054737451,
-0.0402601324,
-0.0846267194,
-0.0066216285,
-0.0445044599,
0.0233260244,
0.0154333385,
0.0250428226,
-0.0274206996,
-0.000201747,
-0.0027908625,
-0.0178950708,
-0.0042175474,
0.0699114054,
0.0020216028,
-0.0097089456,
-0.0706451014,
-0.0653291419,
-0.0086564198,
-0.0892767981,
0.0166706182,
-0.0427508242,
0.0104774591,
-0.0300702117,
-0.030768659,
0.0099318083,
0.0236909017,
0.0252170712,
0.0014891815,
0.0548646525,
0.0287432373,
-0.0118122669,
-0.0469411761,
0.0063134921,
-0.0139942933,
0.0604573414,
0.0543575659,
0.0391361788,
-0.0203280393,
0.0201035962,
-0.0245857667,
-0.0157753155,
0.020837307,
-0.0248084553,
-0.0075681494,
0.0226714779,
-0.0344888419,
0.0353617147,
0.0458068252,
0.0282803904,
-0.055330094,
0.0020915349,
0.0136690792,
0.0376656018,
0.0068208142,
-0.0284511149,
0.0523002222,
-0.0108853653,
-0.026754627,
-0.0284945685,
-0.051709041,
0.054883644,
-0.0304005723,
0.0066638845,
-0.0013994831,
-0.0214196313,
-0.0018962437,
-0.0609349348,
0.0012166108,
0.0080248835,
0.027897099,
0.019416051,
0.0427318439,
-0.0066634207,
-0.0875488594,
0.0004660267,
-0.0168336388,
-0.0430228114,
-0.0190891679,
-0.0387950428,
0.0695608184,
0.0767467543,
0.0241919234,
-0.0202069003,
-0.0131186629,
-0.0188758578,
-0.0053656548,
0.01443436,
0.0184716601,
-0.0458816737,
-0.013414897,
-0.0445741117,
-0.0603231937,
-0.0412664749,
0.0027745774,
0.0119644171,
0.028798122,
-0.023831537,
0.0021900383,
-0.0121511864,
-0.0074613905,
0.0176129378,
-0.0005128892,
-0.0136300959,
-0.0011616045,
-0.0058996938,
0.0420023613,
0.0104167163,
0.0026112841,
0.0422786511,
0.0294768661,
-0.0174293015,
-0.0045304797,
0.0258967616,
-0.0620151833,
-0.0423351787,
0.0358052664,
0.0053221043,
-0.0231080875,
-0.0132820951,
-0.061036218,
-0.0607266687,
-0.0029110778,
-0.0107928989,
0.0071007553,
-0.0233558659,
0.0182455014,
0.0558406636,
-0.0562287197,
-0.0456266217,
0.0823147148,
-0.0100426171,
-0.0320713706,
0.0250009019,
0.0238103606,
0.0258263797,
-0.0542109795,
0.029690804,
0.0585089661,
0.0021875419,
-0.0182489529,
0.0220026094,
0.0044739232,
-0.0526375547,
-0.0196721628,
-0.0655725077,
0.0196490604,
-0.0189089812,
0.0216566231,
0.0128699457,
-0.0144494148,
0.0304065272,
-0.0139558753,
-0.0164370034,
0.0036681267,
0.0202198718,
-0.0043220636,
0.0251100492,
0.0293664541,
-0.0217138082,
-0.0249549877,
-0.0040490003,
-0.0400045477,
-0.0243465453,
0.0067116041,
0.0313539095,
-0.0446546599,
0.0334994085,
-0.0056592692,
0.0033653891,
-0.0032477225,
0.0100326836,
0.05758873,
-0.0148932328,
-0.0104543744,
0.0780980662,
-0.0042881053,
0.0065904744,
0.0563431978,
-0.0277791638,
-0.0570374504,
0.058845453,
-0.0358950347,
0.0097081382,
-0.0410204194,
-0.0294448435,
-0.0171505362,
0.0396139137,
-0.0230702534,
0.0322623961,
-0.0779594705,
-0.0003967785,
0.0073722089,
-0.0095698535,
0.0000663816,
-0.0170648564,
-0.0102505637,
0.0548691824,
-0.0274443459,
-0.0119033223,
0.0782938525,
-0.0112102097,
0.0138881067,
-0.0433040522,
-0.0030918473,
-0.0235910006,
0.0767313913,
0.0056552733,
0.0047081048,
-0.0225283764,
0.0007476038,
-0.0348887444,
-0.0469137095,
0.0455748439,
-0.0199519806,
0.0427444987,
-0.0982695892,
0.0280741956,
0.0045671924,
-0.0547143929,
-0.0579189993,
0.0006336258,
-0.0480545498,
0.0293046702,
-0.0201014709,
-0.0477610007,
0.0267442595,
-0.0037610016,
0.030436188,
0.0541206673,
0.0172833949,
-0.0218640976,
-0.0250980202,
-0.0305137057,
0.0291275773,
0.0227168873,
0.0322299823,
-0.0008494636,
0.0274571795,
0.0150565933,
0.0768442452,
-0.0179472156,
-0.0196576361,
0.0346383601,
-0.0028489311,
-0.027495021,
-0.007054701,
0.0482573956,
0.0595521331,
-0.0542550534,
-0.0282967929,
0.1045347154,
0.0317085013,
0.0324069448,
0.0124336705,
-0.0160835572,
0.0610638969,
0.0126024717,
0.0461467914,
-0.0242230892,
-0.0354939923,
0.0206985809,
0.0239797663,
-0.028827114,
-0.0506310053,
-0.0136543382,
-0.1368299872,
0.056726642,
-0.0175440628,
-0.0045245895,
0.0175255369,
-0.0635965094,
-0.0369623676,
-0.0323781595,
0.0040485486,
0.0192013346,
0.0060181096,
0.0091942521,
0.0381821319,
-0.0180154163,
-0.0116764139,
0.0467552617,
0.0199898835,
0.0061473926,
0.0951450691,
0.0429435447,
0.0360132307,
-0.0500427,
0.0138805937,
0.0371738076,
0.006193798,
-0.0247184485,
-0.0077574272,
0.0165527817,
0.0029491843,
-0.0021428117,
0.0774902552,
-0.0427724719,
-0.0614480749,
0.0001908071,
0.0950884447,
-0.0444418713,
0.0053558005,
-0.0215334632,
0.0222180914,
-0.0066009271,
0.0505848788,
-0.0281099249,
0.0022190341,
-0.0657980517,
-0.0353879109,
-0.0355736166,
-0.0948039889,
-0.0131460028,
0.0003601948,
0.0278019048,
0.0474580079,
-0.060769584,
-0.0178076327,
0.0414831899,
0.079180114,
-0.0176438112,
-0.0102823228,
-0.0017752438,
0.0039462359,
-0.0286667477,
0.032625068,
-0.0263345037,
0.0334607959,
-0.0338135026,
0.0198698118,
-0.0076239742,
0.0043738703,
-0.0218218099,
0.0060637365,
-0.0574701652,
-0.0533506796,
-0.0400345102,
0.059412647,
0.0237765647,
0.0786503777,
-0.006725647,
-0.0013191898,
0.0038626606,
-0.0347855836,
-0.0043933569,
-0.0194106568,
0.047488194,
0.0150616551,
-0.0055778222,
0.021362314,
-0.0376444496,
0.0120990966,
-0.0015732161,
0.0737499595,
-0.0260235984,
-0.0098960474,
0.0425983369,
-0.0004219806,
0.0037557068,
-0.0183860324,
-0.0046352893,
-0.0413505994,
0.0315206982,
-0.0407284535,
-0.0020104989,
-0.0473418757,
0.0367051512,
0.0319321714,
-0.0556233153,
0.0285735354,
-0.0543379299,
0.0000479195,
-0.0137763415,
0.0563862137,
-0.0008263024,
0.0470683835,
-0.0032915182,
0.0186355803,
-0.0146763157,
-0.0075276103,
-0.0012988072,
0.0129959332,
0.0697646812,
-0.0037892982,
0.0940880254,
0.0557005294,
0.0115227923,
-0.0060801874,
-0.0128755001,
-0.0708350837,
-0.0628688261,
0.0145374173,
-0.0214478821,
0.061943274,
-0.0230696853,
0.0341511928,
-0.0797618404,
0.0105318334,
0.024608057,
0.0325686224,
-0.0089793848,
-0.0173283871,
0.0324081965,
0.0344971716,
0.0033001758,
-0.022074027,
0.0409689881,
-0.0102459537,
0.0662873462,
-0.0202170517,
0.0003059653,
-0.0545612387,
-0.0665313452,
-0.046106115,
0.0446506366,
-0.0107617928,
0.007156339,
-0.0602192655,
-0.0404685549,
-0.022567695,
0.0324321054,
-0.0103947241,
-0.0284330919,
0.0455698892,
0.0256485548,
-0.0185764581,
-0.0477783196,
-0.024885403,
-0.0596586727,
-0.0040991926,
-0.0206543729,
-0.0363988727,
-6.006117489e-33,
-0.0090824682,
-0.0409227461,
0.0788889825,
-0.0643738955,
-0.0269235596,
-0.0499480665,
-0.0399173535,
-0.0141712716,
-0.0081532355,
0.0198730975,
-0.0189981833,
0.0023589865,
0.0100772614,
0.024662422,
0.0146045396,
0.0120235179,
0.0511350445,
0.0030076758,
-0.0431016572,
0.0211839955,
0.0739059597,
-0.0359413289,
0.0006495719,
-0.0159634128,
-0.0067226505,
0.0555273518,
-0.039138604,
0.074102439,
-0.0605057664,
0.0516101308,
0.0083382744,
-0.0348701589,
0.0028985369,
-0.0302793663,
-0.0142393848,
-0.00968803,
-0.0654347166,
-0.0269694142,
0.0391198657,
-0.0294656269,
-0.055661045,
-0.0338087417,
-0.0062138475,
0.0019867166,
0.0212167073,
0.0092474734,
-0.0178681351,
-0.0097476207,
-0.0199393407,
0.0605048947,
-0.0545754023,
0.0157534219,
-0.0210612901,
-0.0116505865,
0.047274936,
0.0261973701,
0.0053709601,
-0.019447023,
-0.0146388495,
0.0168795642,
-0.0427147523,
0.0039097662,
0.0665980577,
0.0235583261,
0.0059001558,
0.0485429429,
-0.0003187057,
0.0024579801,
-0.0191261731,
0.0341134593,
-0.021356279,
0.1028200984,
0.0091382237,
-0.0081548057,
-0.0011856658,
0.0430573262,
-0.0944979116,
0.0205891132,
-0.0194812007,
0.0604385436,
0.0416385308,
0.0228062198,
-0.0207172222,
-0.0076025235,
-0.0673549399,
0.0086919051,
0.001754578,
-0.0218364578,
0.0276868399,
0.0522598252,
0.0004345305,
-0.0242628492,
0.0285752341,
-0.021982234,
-0.0101761734,
0.0249310043,
-0.0382025577,
0.0053333971,
-0.0162497647,
0.0402917974,
-0.0838430673,
-0.0295463763,
0.0155432373,
-0.016917184,
0.0000101049,
0.0070293159,
0.0108114025,
0.0036548092,
-0.0332031772,
0.0085847629,
-0.0725100115,
0.0320574827,
-0.035110347,
0.0018666394,
0.0524849445,
0.0117235975,
-0.0057348218,
0.0203369111,
-0.0114666922,
-0.0305772331,
0.005964376,
-0.0027185956,
-0.0034754581,
0.0205318891,
0.00800189,
0.0031809418,
-0.0000688787,
0.0257623829,
0.004342353,
-0.0336841755,
-0.0022702746,
0.0503351539,
2.841e-7,
0.00242849,
0.0124990167,
0.0148537559,
0.0483976677,
-0.0020121494,
0.0387180783,
-0.0056552463,
-0.0366298631,
0.0030958755,
-0.0226639323,
0.0275198091,
0.0188052859,
0.0270463452,
0.0247753076,
-0.0428664573,
-0.0197835453,
-0.0016133533,
-0.0446512997,
-0.0448096767,
-0.0264309756,
0.0700513944,
0.0672511607,
0.0233741533,
-0.0096614538,
0.0224182289,
0.0022714436,
0.0484889969,
-0.0090379426,
0.0035420067,
-0.0005267258,
0.0320730321,
-0.0135201104,
0.0032480757,
0.0054085315,
-0.016682338,
0.0144622037,
-0.0558319688,
0.0776095986,
-0.0135930656,
-0.0672040135,
-0.0233065076,
-0.0345029123,
0.0256584268,
-0.0255876482,
0.0681196228,
-0.0538196489,
-0.0229374915,
0.0177280437,
0.018784076,
-0.0110637844,
-0.0220300388,
0.024745455,
0.0009050695,
0.0150337089,
-0.0076712947,
-0.0015818911,
0.0213654656,
-0.0982803032,
0.0027925407,
0.0378729478,
-0.0116718244,
-0.027081389,
-0.0226803385,
0.0491532274,
0.0034259974,
-0.0113219796,
-0.0453103669,
2.829396076e-34,
0.0083481539,
-0.0026087654,
0.0103649665,
0.0062326365,
0.0528721139,
0.0266087167,
0.0005930606,
0.0067205383,
0.0573217496,
-0.0631748438,
-0.0316451974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00632v1 | Prosody in Cascade and Direct Speech-to-Text Translation: a case study on Korean Wh-Phrases | 2024-02-01T14:46:35 | 2024-02-01T14:46:35 | Giulio Zhou, Tsz Kin Lam, Alexandra Birch, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL | Speech-to-Text Translation (S2TT) has typically been addressed with cascade
systems, where speech recognition systems generate a transcription that is
subsequently passed to a translation model. While there has been a growing
interest in developing direct speech translation systems to avoid propagating
errors and losing non-verbal content, prior work in direct S2TT has struggled
to conclusively establish the advantages of integrating the acoustic signal
directly into the translation process. This work proposes using contrastive
evaluation to quantitatively measure the ability of direct S2TT systems to
disambiguate utterances where prosody plays a crucial role. Specifically, we
evaluated Korean-English translation systems on a test set containing
wh-phrases, for which prosodic features are necessary to produce translations
with the correct intent, whether it's a statement, a yes/no question, a
wh-question, and more. Our results clearly demonstrate the value of direct
translation systems over cascade translation models, with a notable 12.9%
improvement in overall accuracy in ambiguous cases, along with up to a 15.6%
increase in F1 scores for one of the major intent categories. To the best of
our knowledge, this work stands as the first to provide quantitative evidence
that direct S2TT models can effectively leverage prosody. The code for our
evaluation is openly accessible and freely available for review and
utilisation. | Prosody in Cascade and Direct Speech-to-Text Translation: a case study on Korean Wh-Phrases: Speech-to-Text Translation (S2TT) has typically been addressed with cascade
systems, where speech recognition systems generate a transcription that is
subsequently passed to a translation model. While there has been a growing
interest in developing direct speech translation systems to avoid propagating
errors and losing non-verbal content, prior work in direct S2TT has struggled
to conclusively establish the advantages of integrating the acoustic signal
directly into the translation process. This work proposes using contrastive
evaluation to quantitatively measure the ability of direct S2TT systems to
disambiguate utterances where prosody plays a crucial role. Specifically, we
evaluated Korean-English translation systems on a test set containing
wh-phrases, for which prosodic features are necessary to produce translations
with the correct intent, whether it's a statement, a yes/no question, a
wh-question, and more. Our results clearly demonstrate the value of direct
translation systems over cascade translation models, with a notable 12.9%
improvement in overall accuracy in ambiguous cases, along with up to a 15.6%
increase in F1 scores for one of the major intent categories. To the best of
our knowledge, this work stands as the first to provide quantitative evidence
that direct S2TT models can effectively leverage prosody. The code for our
evaluation is openly accessible and freely available for review and
utilisation. | [
0.0487482436,
0.0287345815,
-0.0241489448,
0.0052313898,
-0.0619380511,
-0.0030344333,
0.0554140024,
0.0053825756,
-0.0309571214,
-0.0182765163,
-0.059408959,
-0.0538299903,
0.0934411809,
-0.0034946909,
0.0129177673,
-0.0820118561,
0.0376498774,
-0.0325230882,
0.0257593449,
0.0076831928,
-0.0016952266,
-0.0036663413,
-0.0316067636,
0.030230375,
0.0019417282,
0.0013583783,
-0.0251797829,
0.0797830746,
0.0421476662,
-0.0237816349,
-0.0442575514,
0.0481471084,
0.0049560172,
0.0450251698,
0.0000019526,
-0.0400546826,
-0.000484953,
-0.0024182636,
-0.0178094823,
0.014522274,
0.053610377,
0.0070149279,
-0.0049462747,
0.0372284874,
0.0036364552,
-0.0282156393,
0.0640667304,
0.0094645526,
0.0075544608,
0.0306606572,
-0.0183761902,
-0.0489876643,
-0.0145097803,
-0.0148235597,
-0.0259429757,
-0.016599685,
-0.0081320992,
-0.0595485829,
-0.0357826762,
-0.0483359881,
-0.0319785476,
0.0651496574,
-0.0257320944,
-0.0012230536,
0.0130894687,
-0.0206164382,
-0.0328501686,
-0.0486031361,
-0.0029041711,
0.0531304218,
0.0190247968,
0.0106424186,
-0.0054942868,
-0.0107145272,
-0.0187746491,
-0.0243907683,
0.0356717519,
0.0077989772,
-0.0181211606,
-0.0343707427,
0.0158307217,
0.0470347963,
0.0052043884,
-0.0306198671,
-0.0386873335,
0.0045328368,
0.0447845645,
-0.028734738,
0.0055139917,
-0.0137185436,
-0.0022660377,
-0.0142867723,
0.0898159072,
-0.0330226161,
-0.0040880926,
0.0300491694,
0.0068347086,
-0.0421112701,
-0.005960762,
-0.0112359589,
0.001440505,
0.0736278817,
-0.0566274114,
-0.0131063228,
0.0002785417,
0.0517816655,
0.0099898502,
-0.0077527673,
-0.0966036469,
0.0244949441,
0.0071116243,
0.0377176479,
-0.0501755737,
-0.0138490601,
-0.0571558028,
-0.0072472808,
-0.0171118546,
-0.0132625615,
0.0208285637,
0.0116122141,
0.0242394693,
-0.0368523262,
-0.1090643033,
0.0042861602,
0.0157131571,
0.0746857598,
-0.0193951353,
0.0643830374,
-0.0195130426,
-0.0297561046,
0.0145634729,
0.0363058485,
0.0238776561,
0.0289662927,
-0.0165833253,
0.030412646,
-0.0010736608,
-0.0173854157,
-0.0135292718,
0.0102248527,
-0.0803312212,
-0.0606822781,
-0.0477323644,
-0.0406073295,
0.0377877168,
0.0242722109,
0.0260736663,
-0.0043898141,
-0.003615337,
-0.0274686273,
0.0229448583,
0.0613177456,
0.0268826131,
0.0351841785,
0.0240045544,
-0.0110594556,
-0.0063471152,
0.0428195484,
0.0801745802,
0.0007954318,
-0.0025742254,
-0.0044096629,
-0.0688809007,
0.0450046323,
-0.0240644123,
0.0176878367,
-0.0200975612,
0.0104381824,
0.0090266056,
0.0001189358,
-0.0037214579,
0.0853383169,
-0.0082265176,
0.01410555,
0.0740772784,
0.0406853557,
0.019221155,
0.0128007643,
0.0491324887,
0.0414995067,
0.0232245326,
0.0180426035,
0.0176061206,
-0.0525695309,
-0.0534096509,
0.0213758834,
0.0149626117,
0.0237898454,
-0.0427339561,
-0.036888279,
-0.0184681658,
-0.0105653405,
0.0202705823,
-0.0007322214,
0.0602354072,
0.014488304,
-0.0754061192,
0.0075700223,
-0.0052136048,
-0.0801016763,
0.0412680246,
-0.0196263157,
-0.0417874567,
0.0825387836,
-0.0053818324,
0.0122974701,
0.0333604552,
-0.0345922895,
-0.047692664,
0.0720670819,
0.0360286012,
-0.0081459982,
0.0570129603,
-0.0240253285,
0.0103425821,
0.0668795481,
0.0291590616,
0.0110483849,
-0.051280465,
0.0457666181,
0.0373422988,
0.014678969,
-0.0193914659,
-0.0073966184,
-0.0039300113,
0.0021512071,
0.0373246893,
0.0321733691,
0.0192793515,
0.0540540032,
-0.0343546867,
0.0155601772,
-0.0006416343,
-0.0401047431,
0.001520459,
0.0446490534,
-0.0143273659,
-0.0740387514,
-0.0212964527,
-0.033743538,
0.0169319101,
0.0007018044,
-0.0020278951,
-0.0756144747,
-0.0183010455,
-0.0574051775,
0.0168641433,
-0.0172845628,
0.0557125062,
-0.0303012114,
-0.0104792183,
-0.0088300062,
-0.0040958063,
0.0086875167,
-0.0424950458,
0.0239630267,
-0.0000652689,
0.0215952434,
-0.0483186804,
-0.0392647535,
0.0494546741,
-0.0294882618,
0.020225862,
0.007454582,
-0.0111463787,
-0.0630154833,
-0.0417113528,
-0.0747696683,
0.0319007449,
-0.01966995,
0.0482846349,
0.0428449959,
0.0119917272,
-0.0117631936,
0.0089805275,
0.0238016713,
-0.0297549907,
-0.0087179272,
-0.0120722214,
-0.0288566146,
-0.0212095659,
-0.0038841965,
-0.0197666772,
-0.012550273,
-0.0004131612,
-0.021973772,
0.0149878459,
-0.0175721589,
-0.040676944,
0.0793935135,
0.0070099998,
-0.0787057057,
0.0421452969,
-0.0443148352,
0.0286178105,
-0.0021157309,
0.0619363897,
0.0301438123,
-0.0137137901,
-0.0094026458,
0.0057088793,
-0.0666151568,
0.0037554142,
-0.0068031438,
-0.0085168546,
-0.0306799933,
-0.0116366297,
-0.0708728507,
-0.036350511,
0.0056733526,
0.0845964551,
0.0231717713,
-0.0760169625,
-0.0721356645,
-0.0657823384,
-0.0091455262,
0.0209633335,
-0.0314025208,
-0.0134154819,
0.0233917944,
-0.0034675465,
-0.0187081899,
0.0627434999,
-0.048613172,
-0.0305410102,
-0.0671132356,
0.0281714685,
-0.0173568465,
0.0205395278,
-0.0637568831,
-0.0024379967,
0.0042626904,
-0.0722750053,
0.0090677934,
-0.0141895842,
0.0130973672,
-0.0891903937,
0.0339639448,
-0.0347675644,
-0.0105250748,
-0.0146527477,
-0.02647347,
-0.0204064641,
-0.0302231498,
-0.0194759462,
0.0027902317,
-0.0079451231,
-0.0043470953,
0.0232481882,
0.0653605983,
0.0298975594,
0.0189731307,
-0.0081242183,
0.0263396651,
-0.0186000895,
0.0311339535,
-0.0085253455,
0.0115096867,
0.0095487246,
-0.0440688245,
0.072807692,
-0.0249937475,
0.0433947183,
0.0138318846,
-0.0308978464,
0.0134599833,
0.0299146343,
0.0128859142,
-0.0420680903,
0.0131835639,
0.0823991224,
-0.0453086272,
0.0405477509,
0.0986339748,
-0.000575109,
-0.0216349941,
-0.019222647,
0.0104257511,
0.0477333702,
0.0038200838,
-0.031359449,
-0.0168568678,
-0.0400386266,
0.043654412,
0.0392478332,
0.0057989424,
0.0292154215,
-0.0043366794,
-0.0752539858,
0.0456686169,
0.0475631878,
-0.0340357497,
-0.0420380197,
-0.0242034569,
0.0072040944,
-0.0012540729,
0.0086807786,
0.0003679856,
0.0031799665,
-0.0276857223,
-0.0046900264,
-0.0228088833,
-0.0057453769,
0.0171161667,
-0.0259971581,
0.0151302759,
0.0513279811,
0.0349708647,
-0.0026791089,
-0.0182031207,
-0.0250317417,
-0.0668850392,
-0.0188960284,
-0.0144804111,
0.0066738781,
0.0285179392,
-0.0012287247,
-0.0309345629,
0.0212170761,
-0.0271041039,
0.0509354696,
-0.0056847367,
0.015360632,
0.0002602905,
0.0023101789,
0.0308995396,
0.0167485774,
0.0517968349,
0.0442091934,
0.0174388159,
-0.0796827078,
-0.0051645469,
0.0012556671,
0.00250201,
0.0133149624,
0.0002401267,
0.0020590667,
-0.0135604255,
-0.032091137,
-0.07026162,
-0.0360925421,
-0.0129048694,
0.0348964557,
0.0311806034,
0.0359502733,
-0.0086928112,
0.050569199,
-0.0001750397,
0.0212268103,
0.0091928095,
0.0507596433,
-0.0304132849,
0.0101191103,
-0.0025765251,
-0.0533089861,
0.0069409986,
-0.0077621732,
-0.0604234636,
-0.0418533422,
0.0264186822,
-0.0290978812,
0.0229167454,
0.0049447967,
-0.0314152874,
0.003004363,
-0.0145535581,
-0.0008028329,
-0.0252291989,
0.0066442229,
0.0590377674,
-0.0075279442,
-0.0239234287,
0.0567952953,
-0.0170461368,
-0.0075871157,
-0.0470014885,
0.0865411833,
0.0203372557,
-0.0907783806,
-0.0258024856,
0.0389986336,
0.0440813452,
-0.0165586844,
-0.0558338575,
-0.0078870365,
0.027742777,
-0.0171127953,
0.0346072949,
-0.0163353253,
-0.0109048001,
0.0473325774,
0.0192409363,
-0.0141633106,
0.0088829147,
-0.047551062,
-0.042367626,
0.0466758348,
0.0310441442,
0.0370082557,
0.0874527544,
-0.0178199802,
0.0099553457,
-0.057920929,
0.0262364428,
0.0196573101,
0.0167559255,
0.0048831878,
0.0488068461,
-0.0315391682,
0.0050376286,
0.0065522287,
0.0012863341,
-0.0072590676,
0.0015101096,
0.0091784773,
-0.0267173052,
0.0485592335,
0.0121522658,
0.1000487432,
-0.0183311552,
0.0346482508,
-0.0447304733,
0.034443859,
-0.0166549273,
0.0138684064,
-0.0149383768,
-0.0122586163,
0.0083769849,
0.0490679294,
-0.004172924,
0.0009957455,
-0.0052880268,
-0.0263729077,
0.0011436275,
0.001304686,
-0.0431725606,
-0.0203772075,
-0.0078062862,
-0.0528420284,
-0.0330782756,
-0.0998320282,
-0.0455134399,
-0.006157585,
0.0250176378,
0.0425205082,
-0.0255555585,
-0.0082030445,
0.0204058662,
-0.0421058685,
-0.0449364707,
-0.0213998668,
0.0073345532,
-0.0068184501,
0.0272333492,
0.0093538202,
-6.358077028e-33,
-0.0150493681,
-0.0168757085,
-0.0282817092,
-0.0104072075,
-0.0570696965,
-0.0027355405,
-0.0502993651,
0.0014868627,
-0.0171704441,
-0.0179689936,
-0.0209232643,
-0.0063082478,
0.0403303355,
-0.0079124616,
0.0042237672,
0.0030026617,
0.0631068125,
-0.0167806875,
-0.0317433253,
0.0651588589,
0.0420147851,
-0.0057183085,
0.0298786089,
-0.033397425,
0.0433692634,
-0.0482379869,
-0.0206359811,
-0.0176435281,
0.0117401788,
0.0211265143,
-0.0144182695,
0.0343013778,
-0.0046476261,
0.0069313007,
-0.0312076602,
0.0292034894,
-0.090715453,
0.0050084987,
0.0315924659,
0.0572252944,
-0.042592153,
0.0022145212,
0.0241913348,
-0.0024191611,
-0.0285141077,
-0.0180000085,
-0.0212431606,
-0.0383076072,
0.0125317881,
-0.0131182419,
-0.0512190051,
0.0387497619,
-0.025582755,
-0.0123385219,
0.0503647514,
0.0801761597,
-0.0527092181,
-0.0015614601,
-0.0364055783,
0.0091708396,
0.0148834586,
0.0082656583,
0.061565347,
0.0249338839,
-0.0219435636,
-0.0262497589,
0.0395531096,
-0.0300523248,
0.0652517155,
-0.0517966561,
0.0422826968,
0.0304617323,
0.0306579806,
0.0072700735,
0.0628306866,
-0.0363045633,
-0.0496479347,
-0.01600275,
-0.0062822965,
0.0007209756,
0.034163978,
0.0090225479,
-0.0590944141,
-0.0040561338,
-0.0894221961,
-0.0594868101,
-0.016945757,
-0.0324054472,
0.0187210608,
-0.0027459145,
-0.0064633125,
-0.0273147859,
0.1165431812,
0.0172266494,
0.0352001153,
-0.0144928144,
-0.0410696492,
0.0420995392,
-0.0225797053,
0.0579616092,
-0.0645329207,
-0.0069328053,
0.0192007162,
0.0370746925,
0.0085403956,
-0.0267117806,
-0.0295619611,
0.0371044874,
-0.0142747909,
0.0292602591,
0.0089346161,
-0.0319088139,
-0.0497726388,
-0.0206860136,
0.0482226834,
0.0134568969,
0.0196976475,
0.0686833188,
0.0033790134,
0.0218816791,
-0.0562582128,
0.0262492578,
0.0103217149,
0.027571084,
-0.0073935254,
0.0285223816,
0.0254008584,
0.046286732,
0.0215992946,
-0.0249237828,
-0.0162589196,
0.0365457162,
2.767e-7,
0.0159874037,
0.0208281018,
0.0331945345,
-0.0047607198,
0.0155302677,
0.0269000139,
-0.0466491468,
0.0032016572,
0.0492762215,
0.0297101997,
0.0397133008,
-0.0078454297,
0.1397657245,
0.0280454643,
-0.0597454682,
0.0017600193,
-0.0158261526,
0.0444883667,
-0.0431294516,
0.0390285365,
0.0990333259,
0.0580308028,
-0.0362066515,
-0.0096122473,
-0.0248391982,
0.0087341461,
0.0575778857,
0.0150864199,
0.0329968035,
-0.0011682089,
0.0355561972,
-0.0464345068,
-0.0177703705,
0.0421657935,
-0.0310563799,
0.0328514539,
0.0306607317,
0.0975166708,
0.0054917554,
-0.04981241,
-0.0050149285,
0.0098295482,
-0.028840581,
-0.0314832032,
0.057559453,
-0.0019015094,
0.0134211136,
0.0524470732,
0.0045115636,
0.0266881473,
0.0020979822,
-0.0292961355,
-0.0179175381,
0.016322596,
0.0010375017,
-0.016487211,
-0.0586473793,
0.0181604475,
-0.0199014228,
0.0051992456,
-0.0252827629,
-0.0597997978,
-0.0071565276,
0.0201108847,
0.0040257345,
-0.0178657696,
0.006647768,
2.430690662e-34,
0.0571920983,
-0.05739538,
0.0032781141,
-0.0302931033,
0.026258016,
-0.0316886008,
-0.0533781238,
0.0222597178,
0.0250419192,
-0.0939134359,
-0.0314106569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00620v1 | Actor Identification in Discourse: A Challenge for LLMs? | 2024-02-01T14:30:39 | 2024-02-01T14:30:39 | Ana Barić, Sean Papay, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL | The identification of political actors who put forward claims in public
debate is a crucial step in the construction of discourse networks, which are
helpful to analyze societal debates. Actor identification is, however, rather
challenging: Often, the locally mentioned speaker of a claim is only a pronoun
("He proposed that [claim]"), so recovering the canonical actor name requires
discourse understanding. We compare a traditional pipeline of dedicated NLP
components (similar to those applied to the related task of coreference) with a
LLM, which appears a good match for this generation task. Evaluating on a
corpus of German actors in newspaper reports, we find surprisingly that the LLM
performs worse. Further analysis reveals that the LLM is very good at
identifying the right reference, but struggles to generate the correct
canonical form. This points to an underlying issue in LLMs with controlling
generated output. Indeed, a hybrid model combining the LLM with a classifier to
normalize its output substantially outperforms both initial models. | Actor Identification in Discourse: A Challenge for LLMs?: The identification of political actors who put forward claims in public
debate is a crucial step in the construction of discourse networks, which are
helpful to analyze societal debates. Actor identification is, however, rather
challenging: Often, the locally mentioned speaker of a claim is only a pronoun
("He proposed that [claim]"), so recovering the canonical actor name requires
discourse understanding. We compare a traditional pipeline of dedicated NLP
components (similar to those applied to the related task of coreference) with a
LLM, which appears a good match for this generation task. Evaluating on a
corpus of German actors in newspaper reports, we find surprisingly that the LLM
performs worse. Further analysis reveals that the LLM is very good at
identifying the right reference, but struggles to generate the correct
canonical form. This points to an underlying issue in LLMs with controlling
generated output. Indeed, a hybrid model combining the LLM with a classifier to
normalize its output substantially outperforms both initial models. | [
0.0302792024,
0.0430052616,
0.0215011649,
0.0507591367,
-0.0238972306,
-0.0310806632,
-0.001438413,
-0.017070096,
0.0065848455,
-0.0501034707,
0.0457913689,
0.0001428009,
-0.0280893352,
-0.0242580716,
0.0176422596,
-0.0154031422,
0.0319959633,
0.0292077418,
0.0435032621,
-0.0283814333,
0.0051927776,
0.0245858245,
0.0050540594,
0.0278640017,
-0.0381313749,
0.0185680185,
0.0152427331,
0.0028083888,
0.0646855831,
-0.0127130179,
-0.0199354757,
0.0370416082,
-0.0022860866,
0.0460889712,
0.0000013995,
-0.0633243695,
-0.0102692218,
-0.0417378433,
0.0100606494,
-0.0086012594,
0.0202628616,
0.0209089387,
-0.0039795078,
0.0045991004,
-0.0144862914,
0.0216411036,
0.0074971993,
0.0640872419,
0.0411738306,
0.0847002715,
0.0037595183,
-0.0550566241,
-0.0063569481,
-0.0085495915,
-0.0658597946,
-0.0442504846,
0.0318927467,
-0.0183765795,
-0.0065673888,
0.0358725749,
0.007324609,
0.037410669,
-0.0249461662,
-0.0238636546,
0.0015568412,
0.0116221113,
-0.0263748113,
-0.0062034768,
0.0090839397,
0.0492834821,
0.111604549,
-0.0219041873,
0.062260028,
-0.0011110776,
0.0066598849,
0.0654745102,
0.0047649713,
0.0533650294,
-0.0364197828,
0.0226991661,
0.0613524951,
-0.0067905313,
0.0227820519,
0.0379889123,
0.0148943206,
0.0306222904,
-0.0217229724,
0.0035770382,
0.0291071199,
0.0253849737,
-0.0095985932,
-0.0585470311,
0.030407913,
0.0193593018,
-0.0312837437,
0.0222019777,
-0.0089779282,
0.0001648744,
-0.0083438335,
-0.0782539696,
0.0230676178,
-0.0027102937,
-0.0197473746,
0.0206670947,
-0.0357260853,
0.0339287333,
-0.0595583059,
-0.0167054981,
0.008303443,
-0.0311673153,
-0.0483463556,
-0.0244940314,
-0.0409985222,
0.0683157593,
-0.041697219,
-0.0085356729,
-0.0340344049,
0.00985495,
-0.0060278042,
0.0245849546,
0.0154626882,
0.0197597109,
0.0036684,
0.0097866934,
-0.0700198933,
0.0725863948,
-0.0352331288,
-0.0059471494,
-0.0240757763,
0.0091761844,
0.0111773908,
0.0655026063,
0.0014401296,
-0.0079706032,
-0.0055044452,
0.052428361,
-0.0064967349,
0.0018043389,
0.007350185,
-0.0446878001,
-0.0322293602,
-0.0259008333,
0.0062319855,
-0.0565292723,
0.001754052,
0.0030506216,
0.0030457568,
-0.0791245997,
0.0451585948,
0.0051146792,
-0.0253132861,
0.0277883764,
0.02800503,
0.0256525315,
0.0449017212,
0.0049970141,
0.0232492257,
0.0309657156,
0.0425889753,
-0.0246730074,
0.0457612239,
0.0016274992,
0.0060076048,
0.0271203835,
0.017044045,
-0.0056718462,
0.0262142792,
-0.0247833654,
-0.0637400299,
0.0310170762,
0.0389235355,
0.0576419085,
-0.0007839558,
-0.0395178683,
0.032348264,
0.0333047211,
-0.0223245006,
-0.0198840611,
0.0167253315,
-0.0081214001,
0.0107507184,
0.0515150875,
0.0151781822,
-0.0081751375,
-0.0080268988,
-0.0563719943,
0.0237061903,
-0.0033170134,
-0.0238898695,
-0.0229190458,
0.0037015211,
0.0360523611,
-0.0248175636,
-0.0187642835,
0.0246439558,
0.0093149208,
-0.0285718516,
0.0830092579,
0.0234645158,
-0.0290402919,
0.0308821145,
-0.0300219357,
-0.0002879338,
-0.0341992602,
0.0337020047,
0.0034807699,
-0.0134972623,
-0.0308350287,
0.0407453403,
0.0855157524,
0.0358856618,
-0.0521327518,
-0.0336123928,
0.0169638898,
0.0009799817,
-0.0093095731,
0.022535257,
0.0681836307,
0.0160472803,
-0.0320725068,
0.0133103598,
-0.0068772924,
-0.0153364046,
0.025502542,
-0.0420948379,
-0.0305370763,
0.0334185995,
-0.0097337663,
0.036900878,
0.0744985715,
0.0014709068,
-0.0349923335,
0.0323228054,
-0.0331346728,
-0.0094667571,
0.0282126479,
-0.008585942,
0.0003306188,
0.0340129323,
-0.0622958429,
-0.0292938594,
-0.0065864087,
-0.0065237558,
-0.0641879141,
0.0663788766,
-0.020374069,
0.0014429461,
-0.0370804891,
-0.0172728468,
0.0161249544,
-0.0352422781,
-0.0778549314,
0.0831513628,
0.0226264466,
0.02664214,
0.0378837958,
0.0017876712,
0.0293254927,
-0.0640116483,
-0.0079519525,
-0.0296142083,
0.0092165507,
0.0184518564,
0.0557230264,
-0.0391502976,
-0.0113614546,
-0.0481122732,
-0.0412201434,
0.0146582723,
-0.0082689179,
0.0348005258,
0.0106876139,
-0.0135570746,
0.0055848826,
0.0164945889,
-0.0145175597,
-0.0417500995,
0.0244944412,
-0.045332294,
0.0658483282,
0.0094692679,
-0.0181405116,
-0.0218138732,
0.0574803352,
-0.0312335771,
0.0456986465,
0.0219843592,
-0.0704492182,
-0.0309790913,
0.0156081803,
-0.0344670191,
0.0019325367,
-0.0254763812,
0.0168402381,
0.0303003509,
0.0526434891,
0.0239055846,
0.0280125272,
0.0107998848,
0.0547940247,
-0.0323925465,
-0.0124948202,
-0.0776204765,
0.0025382112,
-0.0556028597,
-0.001699221,
-0.0603255108,
-0.0094575901,
0.0519227274,
0.062971428,
-0.0065614982,
0.0106121479,
0.008512632,
0.0475849584,
0.0036248127,
-0.0131729646,
0.0470675044,
-0.0452178009,
-0.0236085262,
0.0481161177,
0.007467139,
0.0199669488,
0.0122738397,
-0.0359180421,
0.053423807,
0.020420447,
-0.0351021774,
-0.0388579257,
0.0576069504,
-0.0008558821,
0.0103691164,
0.0200818013,
-0.0521590225,
-0.0189394765,
-0.0255705733,
0.0654245988,
-0.0153476046,
0.0563010573,
-0.0426809974,
0.0617970973,
-0.0126866922,
-0.0307735838,
-0.0616935529,
-0.0340315253,
-0.0203279685,
0.0271908455,
-0.0381256193,
-0.0069077443,
-0.0586640611,
0.0282108374,
0.0161419734,
-0.0489019677,
0.0326367915,
0.0268614888,
-0.0396741107,
0.0812516138,
-0.0338721685,
0.0147255482,
0.0308461934,
0.022868121,
-0.0117789144,
0.0409471095,
-0.0452479981,
0.016001096,
-0.0363011844,
-0.055944223,
-0.006574695,
-0.0726634786,
-0.039985057,
-0.0392779335,
0.0689677298,
-0.0329930633,
0.0129255978,
0.0895044282,
0.0143031515,
-0.0135250697,
-0.0078839483,
0.0118632456,
-0.0088206409,
0.0228650831,
0.0121317729,
-0.0782979056,
0.0317956805,
0.017420223,
-0.0055954047,
-0.0600616783,
-0.0684113577,
-0.0115432199,
-0.1027930379,
0.0360376984,
0.0039442102,
0.0150884641,
0.0034470209,
-0.0624953993,
0.016584456,
-0.014856522,
-0.012563101,
0.0110356379,
0.0100351628,
0.0167455357,
0.0492404923,
-0.0321736969,
-0.0242260229,
-0.0164192468,
-0.0338603258,
0.0553217754,
-0.0018868586,
0.0549185984,
0.0078103449,
0.0367800407,
0.0369229801,
-0.0395693369,
-0.0091482699,
-0.0362864509,
0.0209585447,
-0.0207362678,
-0.0231890772,
-0.0135500152,
0.0361926556,
0.0028209533,
-0.0399140753,
0.0095398016,
0.051393114,
-0.0450505167,
-0.0079189595,
0.0299397316,
0.039990738,
0.0187542699,
0.0613187514,
0.029943211,
0.0250708889,
-0.0326136984,
-0.0442926772,
0.0212702006,
-0.0390430391,
-0.0690611899,
-0.0087974351,
-0.0082354778,
0.0010112387,
-0.0474638157,
-0.0259020403,
-0.0191571321,
0.0593055114,
-0.004905229,
0.0242864583,
0.0254961569,
-0.0037759661,
-0.0313818157,
-0.0000096821,
-0.0583820567,
-0.0239364747,
-0.0158608872,
-0.0175295696,
0.088668786,
0.0202362631,
-0.0307273101,
0.0378350317,
-0.0156263262,
-0.0740123168,
-0.045062907,
-0.0234904028,
0.027920017,
0.0445811264,
0.0085074008,
-0.0433723219,
0.0298305396,
0.0554770529,
0.0000386997,
0.0344784036,
-0.0054180659,
0.0148407966,
-0.025494121,
0.0220606904,
-0.0004511127,
0.0502347536,
0.01399343,
0.0208098795,
-0.0781425536,
-0.0546635725,
0.0174661763,
0.0368677378,
0.0234289039,
-0.0378344581,
0.0111676203,
-0.0441824831,
-0.0397613235,
-0.0297938753,
-0.0272572692,
-0.0113885552,
0.02525202,
-0.0072449674,
0.0005930534,
-0.0159592107,
-0.0341930576,
-0.053682521,
0.1331382096,
-0.0199372396,
0.0189128444,
0.0377861671,
-0.0099132573,
-0.0340690687,
-0.0141619407,
0.0102546569,
0.0416205861,
0.0451521464,
0.0780194104,
0.0173146296,
-0.020357972,
0.0028336954,
0.0305805653,
0.0238842405,
-0.0543914139,
-0.0691156164,
0.0106992014,
-0.0406329408,
0.0240518991,
0.0497079864,
0.002310426,
0.0572273508,
0.0026500234,
-0.0000279699,
0.0036024733,
0.0316941403,
-0.0155188041,
-0.0225020126,
0.0430996716,
0.0028176978,
-0.0490539968,
0.0204129778,
0.0442464761,
0.0122379763,
0.0251317192,
0.014183552,
-0.0140928077,
-0.0668947473,
-0.12156827,
-0.0332631394,
-0.0449017547,
0.0031776226,
-0.0050706523,
-0.0479618646,
-0.0017903829,
0.0344439819,
-0.0231307242,
0.0272627212,
-0.0066103037,
0.0001786493,
0.0390353501,
0.0358574614,
0.0238302033,
-0.0527063496,
-0.008379777,
-0.0389385372,
-0.0463144556,
0.0023103363,
-5.604502129e-33,
-0.0754585043,
-0.0632030219,
0.042411942,
0.033684019,
-0.0285177045,
0.0243623778,
-0.0317543708,
0.0130693475,
0.0023044832,
0.0089068227,
-0.0067398017,
-0.0220287014,
0.0263106916,
-0.005364663,
-0.0140355714,
-0.0231494866,
0.0225476716,
0.0152677009,
-0.0305923112,
0.0211992078,
0.0738102049,
0.0076315328,
0.0598232821,
-0.0983873755,
0.0184461977,
0.027822081,
-0.0253687445,
0.0013598943,
0.0320731811,
0.0298637021,
0.0043876758,
0.0203247946,
0.0103103053,
-0.0072862082,
0.0149721354,
0.0546233132,
-0.0684889704,
-0.0318155177,
0.0363191701,
0.006721538,
0.0112952618,
-0.0497678556,
0.0388310663,
-0.0264840573,
-0.0422547273,
0.0271276776,
0.0452011861,
-0.0042854138,
-0.0123536931,
-0.0543523952,
-0.0322713554,
0.0475385971,
-0.0124215242,
0.0564481765,
-0.0253616013,
0.0276923236,
0.0074849688,
0.0100369612,
-0.0798573792,
0.010873301,
-0.0485221967,
0.0189262517,
0.0219284501,
-0.0023450402,
-0.0225060917,
0.0577078648,
0.0185558721,
0.0257085096,
-0.0568867251,
0.0029413521,
-0.0222483762,
0.0265919864,
0.0242296234,
0.0914527029,
-0.0303005632,
-0.0165753756,
-0.0969535857,
0.0030659088,
0.0461020619,
0.0006639411,
0.0103386147,
-0.0436761901,
0.0359069444,
-0.0129025746,
-0.0645679235,
-0.080661878,
0.0073496317,
-0.035883721,
-0.0071350001,
0.0043588304,
-0.0299338624,
0.0361503363,
0.0439689197,
-0.066433318,
0.003878555,
-0.0148993544,
-0.0148778651,
0.0339003243,
-0.0093007023,
-0.0028626528,
-0.0573174544,
-0.0571335331,
0.0001377932,
0.021776462,
0.0335786901,
-0.0216431934,
-0.0036784639,
-0.0433580279,
-0.0393789373,
-0.0013458711,
-0.0246776473,
0.0265475698,
-0.0588357374,
0.0457210727,
0.0074876873,
0.0090887034,
0.0033386555,
-0.0116418358,
0.0124770207,
-0.0059694881,
0.0311254803,
0.0164832957,
-0.0120337596,
0.0280807838,
-0.0426777415,
0.0045780619,
0.0098588141,
0.0750709921,
0.0277045593,
-0.0227131043,
0.0182794556,
-0.0494526066,
2.293e-7,
0.0320796259,
0.0298892036,
0.0273341313,
-0.0085837655,
0.0056720949,
-0.010059447,
0.0495263524,
0.0357459933,
-0.0068296185,
-0.1124434546,
0.0053680162,
-0.0063885739,
0.0244554095,
0.0463094562,
-0.1215000972,
-0.0441174619,
-0.0641556159,
0.0085003283,
-0.0338528007,
0.0122047924,
0.0004118762,
0.0369842201,
0.0242364109,
-0.0054945298,
-0.0473241173,
-0.0426845811,
0.0767972395,
-0.0125227477,
-0.0465508886,
0.0521000288,
0.0508068278,
-0.0370976292,
0.0125702564,
0.0422533788,
0.0091462769,
0.0454801358,
-0.0473287068,
0.0551557057,
0.045087453,
-0.0566493757,
-0.0371768549,
-0.0219777841,
0.0292974785,
0.02089696,
0.009269149,
-0.0267026294,
-0.0271366332,
-0.0356355421,
-0.0554817766,
-0.0225417931,
0.0074690566,
0.0220221616,
0.0201807339,
0.0327757634,
-0.025140034,
-0.0115310624,
0.0003571319,
-0.0766064078,
-0.0082473829,
-0.0274549946,
-0.0441032685,
-0.044356171,
0.0458616167,
-0.0296672303,
0.0086105028,
-0.0142939528,
0.0024691389,
1.598060693e-34,
0.0180774145,
0.0329337753,
-0.0354735665,
0.0216088332,
0.0355854072,
0.0403468907,
-0.0361971594,
0.0101912804,
0.0107567925,
-0.0176796671,
0.016661711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01775v1 | Design and consensus content validity of the questionnaire for b-learning education: A 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic Delphi based Decision Support Tool | 2024-02-01T13:32:18 | 2024-02-01T13:32:18 | Rosana Montes, Cristina Zuheros, Jeovani M. Morales, Noe Zermeño, Jerónimo Duran, Francsico Herrera | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC | Classic Delphi and Fuzzy Delphi methods are used to test content validity of
data collection tools such as questionnaires. Fuzzy Delphi takes the opinion
issued by judges from a linguistic perspective reducing ambiguity in opinions
by using fuzzy numbers. We propose an extension named 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic
Delphi method to deal with scenarios in which judges show different expertise
degrees by using fuzzy multigranular semantics of the linguistic terms and to
obtain intermediate and final results expressed by 2-tuple linguistic values.
The key idea of our proposal is to validate the full questionnaire by means of
the evaluation of its parts, defining the validity of each item as a Decision
Making problem. Taking the opinion of experts, we measure the degree of
consensus, the degree of consistency, and the linguistic score of each item, in
order to detect those items that affect, positively or negatively, the quality
of the instrument. Considering the real need to evaluate a b-learning
educational experience with a consensual questionnaire, we present a Decision
Making model for questionnaire validation that solves it. Additionally, we
contribute to this consensus reaching problem by developing an online tool
under GPL v3 license. The software visualizes the collective valuations for
each iteration and assists to determine which parts of the questionnaire should
be modified to reach a consensual solution. | Design and consensus content validity of the questionnaire for b-learning education: A 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic Delphi based Decision Support Tool: Classic Delphi and Fuzzy Delphi methods are used to test content validity of
data collection tools such as questionnaires. Fuzzy Delphi takes the opinion
issued by judges from a linguistic perspective reducing ambiguity in opinions
by using fuzzy numbers. We propose an extension named 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic
Delphi method to deal with scenarios in which judges show different expertise
degrees by using fuzzy multigranular semantics of the linguistic terms and to
obtain intermediate and final results expressed by 2-tuple linguistic values.
The key idea of our proposal is to validate the full questionnaire by means of
the evaluation of its parts, defining the validity of each item as a Decision
Making problem. Taking the opinion of experts, we measure the degree of
consensus, the degree of consistency, and the linguistic score of each item, in
order to detect those items that affect, positively or negatively, the quality
of the instrument. Considering the real need to evaluate a b-learning
educational experience with a consensual questionnaire, we present a Decision
Making model for questionnaire validation that solves it. Additionally, we
contribute to this consensus reaching problem by developing an online tool
under GPL v3 license. The software visualizes the collective valuations for
each iteration and assists to determine which parts of the questionnaire should
be modified to reach a consensual solution. | [
-0.0029627092,
-0.0162653979,
-0.0380920917,
0.0016352566,
-0.0580737293,
-0.0105006117,
0.0215089247,
-0.0421931781,
-0.0020778594,
-0.0246679466,
0.0067910091,
0.0312591381,
0.0010429494,
0.0007610568,
-0.047464449,
-0.019475989,
0.0275287423,
0.0193700697,
0.0636341423,
0.0135734314,
0.0113675287,
-0.024690045,
-0.0417119786,
-0.0040139002,
0.0079449452,
0.0195842031,
-0.0106412219,
-0.0499817654,
0.0558751114,
-0.0372598656,
0.037354514,
0.033055272,
-0.0248140041,
-0.0158804134,
0.0000025459,
-0.0497561954,
-0.0508802496,
0.013900836,
0.0238619149,
-0.0337254368,
0.0827599987,
0.1293381155,
0.0000444887,
-0.0065883556,
-0.0435944423,
0.0738087744,
-0.0021183267,
0.0088069523,
0.0645106807,
-0.0139464773,
0.0051720333,
-0.0943685398,
-0.0428494066,
0.0399118885,
-0.008680963,
0.0391604304,
-0.0214877222,
0.0373983905,
0.069145754,
0.0037176446,
-0.0009154329,
0.0026520584,
-0.0011266271,
0.0093956068,
-0.0390195735,
-0.0043228022,
0.0464749895,
-0.0364037193,
0.0482696593,
0.0181770194,
0.0397898778,
0.0489227995,
-0.0146390973,
-0.0062260102,
0.064766027,
-0.0052357707,
0.0002255369,
0.0139214322,
-0.015032392,
-0.0139245959,
0.0099625355,
0.0295807682,
-0.0584071875,
0.0106829377,
-0.0351876169,
0.0766479224,
-0.0251204781,
-0.020990245,
0.0022237094,
0.0199083723,
0.0212931,
-0.0028345294,
0.0076199514,
0.0421152413,
-0.0450591929,
0.0053482563,
0.0252719652,
0.0041683707,
0.0429293178,
-0.0351404175,
-0.0069017624,
0.0188231897,
0.0039025769,
-0.0144178616,
0.0238446239,
0.0097430088,
0.0475192033,
0.0343473591,
-0.0395121872,
0.0285681449,
-0.0503408313,
0.0317797549,
-0.0072371429,
0.0303553678,
0.0219329372,
0.0214861035,
-0.0657573268,
0.0125223482,
-0.0670254752,
0.0424471498,
-0.0119769108,
-0.0013394583,
0.0700519383,
0.0673179403,
-0.0646703169,
0.0151362196,
-0.0305656716,
0.0359824263,
0.0060789254,
0.0252457149,
0.0916940719,
-0.0159463622,
-0.0149049889,
-0.0361333676,
0.0345944464,
-0.0088953413,
-0.0133110266,
0.0200973768,
-0.0645269156,
-0.011002982,
-0.0090955757,
-0.0395245254,
-0.0233232211,
-0.0668902025,
-0.0171097834,
-0.0388645269,
-0.0294287298,
0.0037856572,
0.026273869,
0.0344685316,
-0.0072933873,
0.0335326605,
-0.0124116195,
-0.0560718924,
0.0183163621,
0.0197236575,
0.0104573714,
0.004455877,
0.0247187074,
-0.0122027239,
-0.0073697479,
-0.0273117684,
0.0176416151,
-0.0331291072,
0.0265112687,
-0.0272313301,
-0.0255236682,
0.01957836,
-0.0566332005,
0.0090283724,
-0.0705689713,
0.0484736301,
-0.0239468869,
0.0361043401,
0.0361612923,
-0.0152349537,
0.0409656316,
-0.0197934154,
-0.0422802977,
0.045478262,
0.0150179034,
0.0140835764,
0.0064769187,
0.0302126389,
0.003653093,
0.0288715065,
0.0164526328,
0.0268912371,
0.0129915448,
-0.0847522467,
0.0083793709,
0.0077007213,
0.100870572,
0.0148079656,
0.0012106653,
-0.0656559616,
-0.0032142929,
-0.017108595,
-0.0083762873,
-0.0443822853,
-0.0164253917,
-0.0440580212,
0.0729504451,
0.0285863671,
0.0060074711,
-0.044975061,
-0.0580602065,
-0.0093356995,
-0.033966966,
-0.0120949205,
0.0023781855,
-0.0106643103,
-0.0440502129,
-0.0366858728,
-0.0190669261,
0.0216442514,
-0.0197490286,
0.0356094539,
-0.0496743768,
0.0622964613,
-0.0267385188,
0.0379690975,
-0.0184390061,
-0.0076409751,
0.0501157939,
0.0109285172,
-0.0218640398,
0.0292623118,
0.0538398549,
0.0391536653,
-0.0113224527,
0.0164509751,
-0.0009330031,
0.0432523005,
-0.023828743,
-0.0661650226,
0.0143783679,
-0.0040971697,
0.0630503744,
-0.0577652082,
0.0149462568,
-0.0158001203,
-0.0168344416,
-0.0204527061,
0.0414306149,
-0.023736814,
-0.0858803838,
-0.009545858,
0.0266230293,
-0.0572943501,
-0.0292422269,
-0.0564615875,
0.0175333843,
0.0337731242,
0.0243237913,
-0.0604130551,
-0.0407924652,
0.0658386052,
-0.0353332087,
-0.0524953119,
0.0506241843,
-0.014938985,
0.0652720928,
0.0195775013,
0.0279475544,
-0.0522457473,
-0.0155639229,
-0.0485621542,
-0.011984935,
0.0369429588,
-0.003898618,
-0.013286544,
-0.0736507177,
0.0000157849,
0.0171307549,
-0.059649881,
-0.0146737704,
0.0273285508,
-0.0197635554,
0.0188877247,
0.0075368821,
0.0067210877,
-0.0167161375,
-0.0253614634,
-0.0216127448,
-0.0220986977,
0.0657750145,
-0.0130976541,
0.0115015339,
-0.0389872119,
-0.1047994122,
-0.0170614161,
0.0535719134,
-0.0189283956,
0.0290217642,
0.0454172716,
-0.0566290133,
0.0127396639,
0.0379393362,
-0.0300516747,
0.065355204,
-0.0555581227,
-0.041846551,
-0.0065383324,
-0.0173805524,
0.0220944192,
0.0335487016,
-0.0461155362,
0.005270246,
-0.016392462,
0.0068529439,
-0.0285306275,
0.0182067677,
0.0614164062,
-0.0276788492,
0.0318891555,
-0.0315560512,
-0.0293698888,
0.0012471265,
0.0634756535,
0.0313527472,
-0.0265068188,
0.0607449859,
0.0031014909,
0.0403650701,
-0.1220652089,
-0.0031416437,
-0.0093466341,
-0.0283902455,
-0.0454072133,
0.0173476562,
0.0115760155,
-0.0096252384,
-0.0271464419,
-0.0014818794,
0.053474322,
-0.0442214832,
0.0080378186,
-0.0286992006,
-0.0236191712,
0.0055182949,
0.0277320147,
-0.0026948035,
0.0558985025,
0.0199233703,
0.0124325287,
0.036510732,
0.0460848436,
-0.0220219996,
-0.0294871479,
0.0649686828,
-0.0138889831,
-0.001010694,
0.0101473173,
0.0031211679,
-0.0093637146,
-0.0152710294,
-0.0110925678,
0.0815211535,
-0.0235247556,
-0.0053173774,
0.0330869667,
-0.0321349241,
-0.0090903286,
0.0072048209,
-0.0108343065,
0.0091077201,
-0.0250355881,
-0.015612253,
0.0136641897,
-0.0366887935,
-0.021877829,
0.0153972888,
0.0574128963,
0.026807908,
-0.0140384529,
-0.0044492912,
-0.039503064,
-0.0648181215,
-0.0084015643,
0.0208042264,
-0.0878767744,
0.0137422914,
-0.0353789069,
0.0389554985,
-0.0666728318,
-0.0046972991,
0.0014552716,
-0.0307817515,
0.0154816061,
-0.0084244246,
0.0270633455,
0.0300236251,
0.0526523478,
0.0035643722,
0.0013730522,
-0.0138796652,
-0.0186114423,
0.0616352111,
0.0261889175,
0.0140717188,
0.0060086357,
-0.014287468,
0.017315574,
-0.0252270922,
-0.0223991051,
-0.0137878153,
0.0366520919,
-0.0243687853,
-0.0967589915,
0.0186963137,
-0.0342024826,
-0.049387373,
0.0009256133,
-0.0036023869,
0.0015346473,
0.0009140447,
-0.0428367332,
-0.0071088579,
0.0405024812,
0.0112649426,
0.0103466976,
0.0439166129,
-0.0083255945,
-0.0144982887,
-0.0351292938,
0.0447072722,
-0.0132000083,
0.0042504328,
-0.013843134,
-0.057700213,
0.0312624015,
0.0187181793,
-0.0407628864,
0.0707512796,
-0.0242890622,
0.0072569717,
-0.0472143441,
0.029215768,
-0.0504376963,
-0.0187924411,
0.0545290485,
0.0501667894,
-0.0438239016,
-0.0347138233,
0.0401450507,
0.0013927143,
-0.0087629827,
0.0003029902,
0.0587208793,
0.0441661216,
-0.138838619,
0.0246511251,
-0.0165654942,
0.0440050587,
-0.057504449,
-0.0147926547,
0.0836043209,
-0.0436675027,
0.0446820892,
0.041856274,
0.0161368698,
-0.0468638018,
-0.0119838538,
0.0134386308,
0.0481239036,
0.0048628687,
-0.0016293896,
-0.0097955456,
0.0167590193,
0.0464388058,
-0.0000127735,
-0.0275284555,
0.0285734944,
0.0122602042,
-0.0060930201,
-0.0184796564,
-0.032297954,
0.0065317,
0.0006807303,
0.0518544242,
0.0163710378,
0.0141080879,
0.0471611172,
-0.0193082709,
-0.0048135477,
-0.007971664,
-0.0445979014,
-0.0311259236,
-0.028935384,
0.0134470016,
-0.0114717428,
0.0224651042,
-0.0340457894,
0.0134431142,
-0.008913354,
0.0412248448,
0.0568411127,
0.0002392077,
0.0174510721,
-0.0199807622,
-0.02042697,
-0.0278774314,
-0.0552091226,
0.0079061417,
0.0405849218,
0.0288702287,
0.0928213,
0.0098383594,
-0.0212948173,
-0.0078840954,
0.0513591319,
0.0699724108,
-0.0097712111,
-0.0274042804,
-0.0034322643,
-0.0471655689,
0.0643123239,
-0.0353533216,
0.0098250108,
0.0096735656,
-0.031588126,
-0.0262039453,
-0.0116476435,
-0.020878084,
0.0233394373,
0.0004474384,
0.0023511334,
-0.0490326844,
-0.0273748972,
-0.0762142912,
-0.0882605091,
-0.0769762546,
-0.0206104591,
-0.0275585018,
0.0129043069,
-0.0046862951,
0.0385751501,
-0.039383743,
-0.0027880119,
-0.0612241663,
-0.0056770933,
-0.0057048034,
0.0595544502,
0.0454788655,
-0.024461193,
0.0400430895,
0.0071725762,
0.0174070168,
0.0252132248,
-0.0084580788,
-0.0454720631,
-0.0058863349,
0.0301611535,
0.0256027244,
-6.346394818e-33,
-0.0459235348,
-0.027077388,
0.0430067442,
-0.0133605422,
0.0269129798,
-0.046815142,
0.0346897468,
0.0494891703,
-0.0162013099,
-0.0061515113,
0.0373415351,
-0.0360022113,
-0.005928149,
0.0088558858,
0.0358785316,
-0.0201754794,
-0.0087504406,
0.0177151822,
-0.0454873219,
-0.0371815935,
0.0138850156,
-0.0477822684,
0.0668016747,
-0.0538791977,
0.0869472995,
0.0462305844,
-0.0270765945,
0.0023364171,
-0.0305353869,
0.0109327361,
0.0372018404,
-0.0094202626,
0.0102174692,
-0.0655919313,
-0.0071445256,
0.0067482302,
-0.0239534248,
-0.0780169368,
-0.0152850384,
0.0345959179,
-0.0085681006,
0.01773105,
-0.010226096,
-0.0024674996,
-0.035403572,
-0.0025847217,
0.0218380522,
-0.0178352259,
0.0226988439,
0.0119910799,
-0.0334757119,
0.0215159263,
-0.0173681471,
0.0036742177,
-0.0027977184,
0.0708930045,
-0.0628124997,
-0.0203727633,
-0.0553576574,
0.0396141224,
0.0457521453,
-0.0467456467,
0.0316893682,
-0.0753553361,
-0.0107059684,
0.0066469661,
0.0261255298,
-0.0293729175,
-0.0280601289,
-0.0052599432,
0.0302910265,
0.0418264456,
0.0996903107,
0.0318821333,
0.0058080642,
0.0068946132,
-0.0145989312,
0.0398299396,
0.0362658985,
0.037070591,
-0.0366680175,
-0.0316751748,
-0.0308380313,
-0.0459954441,
-0.038194105,
-0.0197885223,
-0.0118957274,
-0.0076124175,
0.044083979,
-0.0434786268,
-0.0360370427,
-0.0001657986,
0.0124672065,
0.0106137805,
-0.0166817009,
-0.0385847911,
0.0025890737,
0.0541108437,
0.0229285844,
-0.0097489227,
-0.0318453535,
0.0414583087,
-0.0320093706,
-0.0226511732,
0.0064823679,
0.0549261048,
-0.0274625923,
-0.0439159833,
-0.0284472015,
0.0086689238,
0.009635075,
-0.0266136788,
0.009696682,
-0.0262494255,
0.0162227098,
-0.0145878708,
0.0121918255,
0.0237884838,
0.0124652898,
0.0239086486,
-0.031227177,
0.0137095861,
-0.0205891188,
0.0115285693,
0.0198113304,
-0.0359401703,
-0.0226225648,
-0.0304237045,
-0.006889611,
0.0214398969,
0.0192308035,
-0.0076480852,
3.299e-7,
-0.0091103539,
0.0748305321,
-0.0830745548,
-0.0055280556,
-0.02703356,
0.0434651189,
0.0070659877,
-0.014814008,
0.0403348394,
0.0438865572,
0.0617303513,
-0.0556099415,
-0.0261595361,
0.0941652805,
-0.0016145379,
-0.0859442204,
0.0296440851,
-0.0082427338,
-0.0237870514,
0.0602899827,
0.099816151,
-0.0012256138,
0.033504162,
0.0073363683,
0.0033305795,
-0.0418512933,
-0.0073987613,
0.0065363725,
0.0289336275,
0.0268884152,
0.0926055983,
-0.0330768786,
0.0364432558,
0.0573933236,
0.0477075242,
0.0196952336,
0.0365957059,
-0.0055550761,
0.0222072937,
0.0138980979,
0.0369485915,
-0.0193783976,
0.016850248,
-0.0671106651,
0.0237350129,
-0.0732358843,
-0.0155752152,
0.0041256617,
-0.0840697512,
-0.0431689546,
0.0525888763,
0.0091833081,
-0.0440179966,
0.0004178066,
-0.0113373743,
-0.0003741589,
0.0157309622,
0.0198211055,
0.0357431918,
-0.0020456302,
0.0184823517,
-0.0711671412,
0.0053661498,
0.0255367607,
0.0054411856,
-0.0474689454,
0.0158154331,
2.492375647e-34,
0.0229509715,
-0.0242961422,
0.0197272338,
-0.0207987446,
0.023512857,
0.0477098115,
0.0039726626,
-0.0337794125,
0.0048805466,
0.0014628829,
-0.0012647606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03471v1 | The Information of Large Language Model Geometry | 2024-02-01T12:50:43 | 2024-02-01T12:50:43 | Zhiquan Tan, Chenghai Li, Weiran Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | This paper investigates the information encoded in the embeddings of large
language models (LLMs). We conduct simulations to analyze the representation
entropy and discover a power law relationship with model sizes. Building upon
this observation, we propose a theory based on (conditional) entropy to
elucidate the scaling law phenomenon. Furthermore, we delve into the
auto-regressive structure of LLMs and examine the relationship between the last
token and previous context tokens using information theory and regression
techniques. Specifically, we establish a theoretical connection between the
information gain of new tokens and ridge regression. Additionally, we explore
the effectiveness of Lasso regression in selecting meaningful tokens, which
sometimes outperforms the closely related attention weights. Finally, we
conduct controlled experiments, and find that information is distributed across
tokens, rather than being concentrated in specific "meaningful" tokens alone. | The Information of Large Language Model Geometry: This paper investigates the information encoded in the embeddings of large
language models (LLMs). We conduct simulations to analyze the representation
entropy and discover a power law relationship with model sizes. Building upon
this observation, we propose a theory based on (conditional) entropy to
elucidate the scaling law phenomenon. Furthermore, we delve into the
auto-regressive structure of LLMs and examine the relationship between the last
token and previous context tokens using information theory and regression
techniques. Specifically, we establish a theoretical connection between the
information gain of new tokens and ridge regression. Additionally, we explore
the effectiveness of Lasso regression in selecting meaningful tokens, which
sometimes outperforms the closely related attention weights. Finally, we
conduct controlled experiments, and find that information is distributed across
tokens, rather than being concentrated in specific "meaningful" tokens alone. | [
0.0038563854,
0.0276550408,
-0.0319849886,
0.0444302745,
-0.0314843878,
0.0169848371,
-0.0027604292,
0.0453018211,
-0.0309073795,
-0.0340052657,
-0.0088907983,
-0.0501148477,
0.0196274631,
-0.0129076866,
0.0713435337,
-0.0589749627,
0.0029072589,
-0.0764409825,
0.0181751847,
-0.0278157573,
-0.0139240241,
-0.0256504081,
0.0597405918,
0.0502042882,
-0.0253622718,
0.0221104976,
0.0072552394,
-0.0060362807,
-0.0256555229,
-0.0240043942,
-0.0593265742,
0.0299855918,
0.0307214297,
0.0370090827,
0.0000018978,
-0.0414976999,
0.0024792929,
0.014936096,
-0.019887751,
0.0629134849,
0.0033405242,
-0.0624392703,
0.000874105,
-0.0251210853,
0.0286623146,
-0.0058496366,
0.0495282039,
0.019086808,
-0.0160235502,
0.039044369,
-0.0063852849,
-0.040303193,
0.0618610047,
-0.0454390533,
0.0419525243,
-0.0325392,
0.0418149494,
0.0040177605,
-0.0220722761,
0.0298774894,
-0.0499352664,
0.0521819293,
0.0060406188,
0.0094458302,
0.0386306122,
0.0493260324,
0.0045008049,
0.0089180889,
0.0163225345,
0.0509287789,
-0.0181035101,
-0.0203716997,
-0.021341322,
0.000367613,
0.0192335062,
0.0113627212,
-0.0654157028,
0.019384427,
0.0351060703,
0.0268915705,
0.0386355408,
-0.0090095745,
0.0566575751,
-0.0241635479,
-0.0707305968,
0.0434951074,
0.0245485622,
-0.062775515,
-0.0433508381,
-0.0371996313,
-0.065248087,
-0.0345952064,
-0.0490671843,
0.0161742456,
0.0240163226,
0.0264168531,
-0.01475765,
-0.0382623635,
0.0101074586,
-0.055479262,
0.0285213012,
-0.0043369676,
0.0296178125,
0.0385311618,
-0.0171827748,
0.076507546,
-0.0264053959,
0.0491256826,
-0.0325725451,
0.0008587526,
-0.0191899557,
-0.0386350304,
-0.0389357433,
0.0427026525,
0.0076642316,
-0.0302916709,
-0.0039225561,
0.034802787,
0.0067049013,
-0.0100201061,
-0.0306344107,
-0.0126251224,
-0.0022179363,
0.0090790438,
-0.0069104959,
-0.0006839742,
-0.0084480774,
-0.004723771,
-0.0360218175,
-0.0127406782,
-0.0018879588,
0.0103281531,
-0.0027710095,
-0.000942766,
-0.0253589805,
0.0689533874,
0.0473650843,
-0.0333123393,
-0.036343623,
-0.0185453426,
-0.0394579582,
-0.0529286079,
-0.0098828012,
-0.0636616796,
0.0101494603,
0.0375325941,
-0.0062494967,
-0.0408258922,
-0.0117184455,
-0.0136959413,
-0.0731521174,
0.060095761,
0.0012036494,
0.013539915,
0.0088050505,
-0.0202317629,
0.0428135991,
0.0860811546,
0.0484832376,
0.0409473442,
0.0392997302,
-0.0302057359,
-0.0414477102,
0.0303923525,
0.0325105526,
0.0568963736,
-0.0648273751,
-0.0031232105,
0.0497465469,
0.0492617562,
0.0088380203,
0.0735060945,
-0.0194803029,
-0.0339953303,
0.041037295,
0.1117074415,
0.0334366709,
0.0428523831,
0.0218612384,
0.0010383473,
0.0037286698,
0.0408036113,
-0.0287580676,
-0.0103004305,
-0.0135179888,
0.0313275829,
0.075625129,
0.0030980834,
-0.0346653759,
-0.0269023087,
-0.04999616,
0.0054879296,
-0.0294285268,
-0.0185085554,
0.0691420883,
-0.0504546613,
-0.0118741998,
0.067726858,
0.0414458998,
-0.0242847204,
-0.0230717324,
-0.0072327997,
0.0244279597,
0.0161182396,
0.0158704314,
-0.0327291302,
0.0246549025,
-0.0053699957,
0.0182554983,
-0.0030179813,
0.0136827119,
0.0104174027,
-0.0239177421,
-0.0297682732,
0.0188273992,
0.0131982798,
0.0120749772,
0.0344751775,
-0.0524815582,
0.0051060226,
-0.0078320997,
-0.0074923965,
-0.0344787836,
0.0277119949,
-0.0311011486,
-0.0329089537,
-0.0257001389,
-0.0031905861,
0.0503366478,
-0.0145656159,
-0.0285780095,
0.0257768277,
0.0325391144,
-0.0637427345,
0.02128773,
-0.0040818658,
-0.0411348119,
0.0024670335,
0.033413548,
0.0022867864,
0.0402240194,
-0.0283506364,
0.023959728,
-0.0219534021,
0.0548787154,
-0.043102771,
0.1149467379,
-0.0303143021,
0.0258295294,
-0.0450135693,
0.0219263937,
-0.0638396591,
0.0509296581,
-0.0359221436,
0.0533377193,
0.0331260487,
-0.0487740114,
0.0358744524,
-0.0095197866,
-0.0117853461,
0.0231481194,
0.0044576423,
0.0131678376,
0.0143565265,
-0.049532596,
0.0496598184,
-0.043964535,
-0.0281766169,
-0.0281903595,
-0.0280421004,
-0.012612504,
0.012924064,
-0.0000480095,
-0.001715276,
0.0117446277,
-0.0074243662,
0.0004352184,
-0.0283085313,
0.0193344373,
0.0241388343,
0.0017515869,
-0.0268354192,
-0.0431986414,
-0.0561824329,
-0.026711842,
0.0797977746,
0.0187963769,
-0.0094620585,
-0.0692860484,
0.073921755,
-0.0065482827,
0.0208235756,
-0.0271509532,
-0.0456776321,
0.0017663093,
-0.0504915752,
0.0531220958,
0.0463914536,
0.0083134128,
0.0534328483,
0.0804506168,
0.0188478753,
-0.0262427423,
-0.0225787051,
-0.0444119573,
0.0202539638,
-0.0795584396,
-0.0648903698,
0.0246006269,
0.0578239337,
0.0203524251,
-0.019148929,
-0.0559070967,
-0.0059099738,
-0.0531188361,
-0.0101940697,
-0.0509953275,
0.011405237,
-0.0287992228,
0.0570744537,
-0.0100596547,
-0.0765023679,
0.0355562195,
-0.0453819819,
0.0176628809,
0.0053026089,
-0.0022312657,
-0.0666760057,
0.0596515872,
0.0441492386,
0.0222486444,
0.0267654676,
-0.0401439816,
-0.0114224134,
-0.0324174426,
-0.0109579042,
-0.0059142867,
0.0559981316,
0.0095039345,
0.0006910792,
0.0006872666,
-0.0124892117,
-0.0021100696,
-0.0660720319,
-0.0095419288,
0.0037315832,
0.1050934568,
-0.0538811088,
-0.0064898715,
0.042774573,
0.0387665629,
-0.0123840282,
-0.0207683612,
-0.0060416795,
-0.015653966,
0.0228035897,
0.0425465181,
-0.0029664023,
0.0547696017,
-0.0511378981,
0.0182147212,
0.0116166119,
0.0254098587,
0.0514762923,
-0.0269100256,
-0.0120816613,
0.0429590456,
-0.0093445396,
-0.0360543877,
0.0199509989,
0.0513134114,
-0.0236719735,
0.0164969675,
0.1334038526,
0.0177145284,
-0.0610777065,
0.0364235118,
-0.0176647101,
0.068961218,
0.0311139245,
-0.0006770326,
-0.0343901478,
0.0123306587,
0.0119791469,
-0.0072576189,
0.0181475542,
-0.0200238656,
0.0233467296,
-0.0793877766,
0.0130039137,
0.0221716873,
-0.014206294,
-0.0326500721,
-0.0342208929,
0.0062662424,
0.003373299,
0.0069396733,
-0.0024574669,
-0.0532850809,
-0.0114664519,
0.0153603293,
-0.0363010317,
-0.0086916005,
0.0095397402,
-0.0337585472,
0.0358088948,
0.0107949264,
0.0675576329,
-0.0444807559,
-0.0753753483,
0.0073175533,
0.0374167785,
-0.0037165035,
-0.0059887972,
0.047251258,
0.0344905257,
-0.0165853109,
-0.0128841,
0.0053346255,
-0.0004613476,
0.0147711094,
-0.0457112454,
0.0787926242,
-0.0018304021,
-0.0220208317,
-0.008966987,
-0.0465899445,
-0.0318510942,
0.0842969865,
0.066704601,
-0.0199879874,
-0.0321528725,
-0.0287521053,
0.0209588669,
0.0251927543,
-0.0507508963,
-0.00090107,
0.027164882,
-0.0304139294,
-0.0304104406,
0.0261114798,
0.0204669386,
0.0417783335,
0.0228916854,
0.0201586261,
-0.0004849039,
-0.035336487,
0.0100515932,
0.0061337636,
-0.0138379484,
-0.009280758,
-0.0675271079,
0.0045991424,
-0.0009208006,
-0.0147035476,
-0.0274095535,
-0.0425741971,
-0.0596299283,
-0.0755243748,
-0.0158193912,
0.0042491313,
0.0165337529,
0.0309642889,
-0.0046216017,
-0.0646552742,
0.0507095568,
0.0044595441,
-0.0296736062,
0.0311179068,
0.0030836717,
-0.017463319,
0.0225114375,
0.0624931753,
-0.0243179966,
-0.0212634541,
0.0079450747,
-0.0067580547,
-0.0000307651,
-0.0627709329,
0.0048073307,
0.0271317121,
0.0209227018,
-0.0192417372,
-0.0419287644,
0.0023410623,
-0.0038987773,
-0.0157333668,
0.0275576413,
-0.0206268113,
-0.0054326085,
0.0288882516,
-0.0153383212,
-0.0054894099,
-0.0149349058,
0.0132012852,
0.016429672,
-0.0415955,
0.020498449,
-0.0279806498,
0.0118444571,
0.0592550337,
0.0260533709,
0.0006637247,
-0.0066052885,
-0.0467654914,
0.0140017699,
-0.0090167262,
-0.007774435,
0.0078032347,
0.0150844092,
-0.0487438068,
0.0167580657,
-0.0898554176,
-0.0614508055,
0.0097296601,
0.0047215233,
0.0497923642,
-0.0181273445,
0.0383526422,
-0.0355832614,
-0.0036942302,
-0.0302090906,
0.0163225569,
-0.017809147,
-0.0118211079,
0.040939223,
0.021615399,
-0.0378641114,
0.0249074306,
0.080689691,
0.0631466061,
0.0183739904,
0.0076668295,
-0.007523295,
-0.006433622,
0.0336054079,
0.0227031149,
0.0532080457,
-0.0437175147,
0.0186014194,
-0.0721501485,
-0.0699666366,
-0.0070620584,
-0.0209563468,
-0.0171167627,
0.0071042874,
0.0066061728,
0.0464100502,
-0.0012964479,
-0.007474903,
-0.0248192325,
0.0123829395,
-0.003839344,
-0.037292704,
0.0180923399,
-6.435403985e-33,
-0.0116580622,
0.0033700415,
-0.0276935901,
0.0249076374,
0.0085378047,
-0.0010814467,
-0.0118296212,
0.0168787576,
-0.0222252924,
0.028308535,
-0.0081275767,
-0.0336385034,
-0.0108806957,
0.0249647386,
0.0290276632,
0.0025501924,
0.0210522152,
0.007109947,
0.0343681462,
0.0393076316,
0.0400484428,
0.0134982429,
0.0527330935,
-0.0581980087,
0.0259194206,
-0.0028533041,
0.0371236466,
0.0150089031,
0.0235630367,
0.0497793667,
-0.0503363498,
0.0381888747,
0.025061015,
-0.0609211326,
-0.0382163785,
-0.0014581577,
-0.0369438939,
-0.0272114109,
0.0352127515,
-0.0168047529,
-0.0095952125,
-0.0698223263,
0.0455942862,
-0.0107376939,
0.0017093269,
-0.0345665924,
0.0520768948,
0.010552628,
-0.0681151077,
0.0054270481,
-0.0705366805,
0.0160295423,
-0.0241994932,
-0.0007195357,
0.0529107526,
-0.0150399478,
-0.0054384405,
0.0195015371,
-0.0063482081,
0.0126970569,
0.0312015787,
0.0751062334,
0.0056857858,
0.0378230549,
0.028649224,
0.0683932155,
0.0267972946,
-0.0185045116,
-0.0461092927,
-0.0021924875,
0.0632611141,
0.0305353478,
0.0376831293,
-0.0330982991,
0.0327538624,
-0.0368202887,
-0.0819412172,
-0.0444037654,
-0.0148427133,
0.0497506112,
0.0359630957,
0.0131492512,
-0.0607397407,
-0.0432575569,
-0.0391673669,
-0.0450187884,
-0.0122946659,
-0.0256402083,
0.0078573022,
-0.0161730684,
0.0131028593,
0.004549759,
0.0440291353,
-0.06367632,
-0.0569433644,
0.0493074134,
0.0110998284,
0.0436333492,
0.0095323855,
0.0189576671,
-0.0688614845,
-0.005650918,
-0.0405427627,
0.0015146583,
0.0179004762,
0.0168939549,
0.0277593043,
0.01679774,
-0.0562691391,
-0.0423189811,
-0.0271880813,
-0.067244485,
0.0114597287,
0.0030991514,
0.0503260978,
-0.0176412668,
0.0063069258,
0.0237545595,
0.0083920686,
0.010781426,
-0.0109912222,
0.0165883042,
-0.0155914659,
0.0302492026,
-0.032056246,
-0.0166337751,
-0.0644845068,
0.0226120017,
0.0946880803,
-0.0170835331,
-0.0303825848,
-0.0069120028,
2.687e-7,
0.0208800584,
0.0636140704,
0.0246092658,
0.0186295863,
0.0283687022,
0.0228076484,
-0.0078854002,
0.0246157963,
-0.014013527,
-0.0333957523,
-0.0039404035,
0.0142394789,
0.0342425331,
0.0079006031,
-0.1123679131,
-0.0096567096,
-0.0573136136,
0.0013116879,
-0.0372750722,
0.0059040193,
0.010241868,
0.1325645447,
0.0209890734,
0.0163896065,
-0.0027603826,
-0.0571652241,
0.0229697004,
-0.0579764023,
0.0215958357,
0.0313244909,
0.0150722312,
-0.0003977036,
-0.0002720533,
0.0027114612,
0.0103689926,
0.024597412,
-0.02342893,
0.0135381864,
-0.0174605418,
0.0210685022,
0.0098378286,
-0.0306821615,
-0.0228509139,
-0.0699382573,
0.0544767454,
0.0019206209,
-0.0518598892,
-0.0635016263,
0.0599210821,
0.0057555009,
0.028901523,
0.0036306819,
0.0248005092,
0.0146184228,
0.0189211871,
-0.0306436885,
0.0301498082,
-0.0652518794,
-0.0143002598,
0.0367366523,
-0.0713400468,
-0.0180725139,
-0.0434977189,
-0.0116334688,
0.0569920614,
-0.0410901122,
0.0100308824,
2.830422338e-34,
0.0411365665,
-0.0077155489,
0.0223567821,
0.0569505803,
0.003711743,
-0.038236443,
-0.0019365695,
0.0029529959,
0.0205391701,
-0.1180148497,
-0.0090579195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00559v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00559v4 | A Chain-of-Thought Is as Strong as Its Weakest Link: A Benchmark for Verifiers of Reasoning Chains | 2024-02-01T12:46:45 | 2024-05-21T09:55:07 | Alon Jacovi, Yonatan Bitton, Bernd Bohnet, Jonathan Herzig, Or Honovich, Michael Tseng, Michael Collins, Roee Aharoni, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompting language models to provide step-by-step answers (e.g.,
"Chain-of-Thought") is the prominent approach for complex reasoning tasks,
where more accurate reasoning chains typically improve downstream task
performance. Recent literature discusses automatic methods to verify reasoning
to evaluate and improve their correctness. However, no fine-grained step-level
datasets are available to enable thorough evaluation of such verification
methods, hindering progress in this direction. We introduce REVEAL: Reasoning
Verification Evaluation, a dataset to benchmark automatic verifiers of complex
Chain-of-Thought reasoning in open-domain question-answering settings. REVEAL
includes comprehensive labels for the relevance, attribution to evidence
passages, and logical correctness of each reasoning step in a language model's
answer, across a variety of datasets and state-of-the-art language models.
Evaluation on REVEAL shows that verifiers struggle at verifying reasoning
chains - in particular, verifying logical correctness and detecting
contradictions. Available at https://reveal-dataset.github.io/ . | A Chain-of-Thought Is as Strong as Its Weakest Link: A Benchmark for Verifiers of Reasoning Chains: Prompting language models to provide step-by-step answers (e.g.,
"Chain-of-Thought") is the prominent approach for complex reasoning tasks,
where more accurate reasoning chains typically improve downstream task
performance. Recent literature discusses automatic methods to verify reasoning
to evaluate and improve their correctness. However, no fine-grained step-level
datasets are available to enable thorough evaluation of such verification
methods, hindering progress in this direction. We introduce REVEAL: Reasoning
Verification Evaluation, a dataset to benchmark automatic verifiers of complex
Chain-of-Thought reasoning in open-domain question-answering settings. REVEAL
includes comprehensive labels for the relevance, attribution to evidence
passages, and logical correctness of each reasoning step in a language model's
answer, across a variety of datasets and state-of-the-art language models.
Evaluation on REVEAL shows that verifiers struggle at verifying reasoning
chains - in particular, verifying logical correctness and detecting
contradictions. Available at https://reveal-dataset.github.io/ . | [
0.0166853815,
0.0604818016,
0.0118152834,
0.048313655,
-0.0528503917,
0.0174698606,
0.0066908677,
-0.0123314476,
0.0379237421,
-0.0195065122,
-0.0116974413,
0.024111392,
0.0134665379,
0.0329723284,
0.0060957167,
-0.0342870168,
0.0317555033,
-0.0258645583,
0.0202962887,
-0.0057116342,
0.006267617,
0.0298023243,
-0.0230239611,
0.0325522646,
0.0080191577,
-0.050899554,
-0.0054713832,
-0.0072915377,
0.0496767834,
-0.0334077552,
0.0060107866,
0.0580534227,
0.0010611061,
0.0475234054,
0.0000019016,
-0.0376344733,
-0.002528222,
0.010398428,
-0.0777563453,
-0.0124605959,
-0.0471188053,
0.0175592862,
0.0190036036,
0.0343564413,
-0.0351695269,
-0.0155552104,
0.006380796,
0.0408348665,
0.0765410736,
0.0445968583,
0.0123988595,
-0.0148372557,
0.0032650419,
-0.0048141666,
0.0002487295,
-0.0316971615,
0.0297667664,
0.0383179672,
0.0043755919,
0.0227903854,
0.0052840868,
0.0160814524,
0.0317673758,
-0.0284209792,
-0.0574733913,
0.0210797936,
-0.0272853877,
-0.0149252806,
0.0135666858,
0.0831927061,
0.0283321831,
-0.0583507679,
-0.0385937616,
-0.010998996,
-0.0160954986,
0.032994125,
-0.0259994213,
0.0409604684,
-0.043544881,
-0.0217365827,
0.0017178381,
-0.0000546253,
0.0214118659,
0.0127749937,
-0.0200352762,
0.1161594167,
-0.0188494008,
-0.043473281,
0.042960532,
0.006760471,
-0.0203387998,
-0.0934012681,
-0.0042486354,
0.0372300111,
-0.0260902457,
0.0439335853,
-0.0042246762,
-0.0111602228,
0.0293296352,
-0.0131710572,
0.0145705696,
0.0046310597,
-0.0178957023,
0.0561590604,
-0.0314667597,
0.0160793047,
-0.0351828597,
0.0324798301,
-0.0010235319,
-0.0270188358,
-0.0474179946,
0.0094994539,
-0.0133966487,
0.035725411,
0.0030323097,
0.0407968275,
-0.0300865956,
-0.005958057,
-0.0440409333,
0.0490175448,
-0.0074418117,
0.0030781643,
0.0480248444,
-0.02192742,
-0.0614306293,
0.0329255499,
-0.0726772472,
0.0486913174,
0.0474975221,
-0.039451424,
-0.0291124769,
-0.0080991136,
-0.0036897713,
-0.0138363121,
0.0417639576,
0.0041426304,
0.011258659,
0.032240551,
-0.0370912217,
-0.0489498153,
0.010738723,
-0.064906165,
-0.0146404095,
-0.0849764124,
0.0250055641,
0.022300439,
-0.0165103506,
-0.0179186463,
-0.0030810668,
0.0652469024,
-0.0094264327,
0.0623748004,
-0.0378061049,
-0.0183162,
0.0060677361,
0.0270410459,
-0.0302694123,
0.0447099693,
0.0337475091,
0.0265181735,
0.0579694808,
0.0197303537,
0.0176425595,
0.0015929698,
0.0358299091,
-0.0066126538,
0.0255963337,
0.0796965137,
-0.0056485902,
0.0095597683,
-0.055022493,
0.0366806239,
-0.029863894,
-0.0275453962,
0.0156049123,
0.0415874384,
0.0210956819,
-0.0361915827,
0.0359830223,
-0.0383306965,
0.0360273942,
-0.0043708561,
-0.0335063711,
0.0114589147,
-0.0311744493,
-0.0262851175,
-0.0125902938,
0.0251600686,
-0.0108804908,
-0.0683439225,
-0.0221527945,
0.0225951876,
-0.0009079978,
0.0329019688,
0.0366325006,
0.0455047376,
-0.0180289261,
0.0513577759,
0.0428606942,
-0.0600172244,
-0.029116001,
-0.0434476994,
0.0538036227,
-0.0012670604,
0.0557489134,
-0.0388032123,
-0.0084471097,
-0.0239636712,
0.0826812685,
0.0097934054,
0.0168105587,
-0.0247843899,
0.0167742334,
-0.0186497364,
-0.0233527534,
-0.0279078204,
-0.0146885626,
-0.0185620058,
0.0594011396,
-0.0010173086,
-0.0065469872,
-0.0394613817,
0.0133812772,
0.0300930608,
0.0000566453,
0.0188687332,
0.0108298734,
0.0113885272,
0.0242831092,
0.019231895,
0.0011375539,
0.0159184374,
0.0085726865,
0.0034558454,
-0.0312044639,
0.0104757631,
-0.0173951276,
-0.0257354323,
0.0492734089,
-0.054280255,
-0.0505481772,
0.0150314346,
-0.0580782332,
-0.0230637472,
0.0076639568,
-0.0129569396,
-0.0471904464,
-0.0190511271,
-0.0089242905,
-0.0079274736,
-0.0060810116,
0.0135720633,
0.0907047763,
-0.0097331051,
0.0304246265,
-0.0130215501,
0.0229095817,
0.0451885909,
-0.0095151104,
0.0172528196,
0.0084435111,
-0.0240665935,
-0.0058088861,
0.033194948,
-0.0011033447,
-0.0787503049,
-0.0078915358,
-0.0480904877,
0.0031086928,
-0.0113752615,
0.0457598567,
0.0216049273,
-0.016076548,
0.0172910579,
0.0053526764,
-0.029648168,
0.0179416277,
0.0244102087,
-0.0011130361,
0.0426393114,
-0.0062414822,
0.0001757586,
-0.0224747881,
-0.0201826468,
-0.0434202328,
0.0581136458,
0.0096562635,
0.0289810225,
-0.0274008214,
-0.0260539409,
-0.068802543,
0.0301072635,
-0.0006210503,
-0.0112447562,
0.0624625944,
0.0161704067,
-0.0015855123,
0.061548464,
0.0120735178,
-0.026479125,
0.0507667437,
-0.0128832459,
-0.0396360122,
0.0217802152,
-0.0250588153,
0.0141097168,
-0.0147755323,
-0.0276768152,
-0.009762329,
0.0435547009,
-0.01227507,
-0.0032880844,
-0.0373163186,
0.0334357694,
-0.0130808232,
-0.0019017727,
-0.0283163693,
-0.042808339,
0.0088299448,
0.1015122905,
-0.0399996825,
-0.0180727392,
0.079107061,
-0.044015564,
0.0138771916,
-0.0281808972,
0.0038145131,
-0.0501404591,
0.0710949525,
-0.0028681005,
-0.0198798236,
0.0498096161,
0.0392400175,
-0.0148977442,
-0.0339934155,
0.047347378,
-0.0548278242,
0.0320740789,
-0.0531654097,
0.0012343652,
0.0118865287,
-0.0409110002,
-0.0524952151,
-0.0067884764,
-0.048543755,
-0.0165851489,
-0.0340799764,
-0.0205174461,
-0.0341371149,
-0.038281586,
0.0389362276,
0.0106750149,
0.0140711125,
-0.0222635157,
-0.0092974352,
0.0333742648,
0.0242053773,
0.0131425401,
0.0708992034,
-0.0126054119,
0.0192798804,
0.0657310486,
0.0396891348,
0.0046918676,
-0.0307197273,
-0.0177992843,
-0.0172356497,
-0.0214778464,
0.0245677512,
0.0100396546,
0.0343860574,
-0.065627709,
-0.0242582597,
0.0894254148,
0.0264059566,
-0.0257161036,
-0.0097502461,
-0.0331816711,
0.0284716133,
0.0195125621,
0.0244917423,
-0.1367893517,
-0.0397671573,
0.0056423326,
0.0129317287,
-0.0158364121,
-0.0561936572,
-0.0002356496,
-0.1194041967,
0.0222793147,
-0.030210346,
-0.0128477393,
-0.0144357262,
-0.0882846117,
0.0397638679,
-0.0131493816,
-0.032504607,
0.0086480491,
0.0207236949,
0.005162877,
0.0144378198,
-0.0146884648,
-0.0150917377,
0.0846427605,
-0.0439177528,
0.012782691,
0.0233582463,
0.0089664431,
0.0073067127,
-0.0749461725,
0.0184103642,
-0.04805189,
-0.0458282121,
0.0013613279,
0.0260536261,
-0.0073374202,
0.0154379718,
-0.0297605637,
0.0204164349,
-0.0475658365,
-0.0284577981,
0.0546142645,
0.1035377011,
0.0032446587,
-0.0463097207,
-0.0228162725,
0.0449645966,
-0.0292799119,
0.0515158996,
0.0374214016,
0.0303544421,
-0.0233671367,
-0.039615225,
-0.0244261287,
-0.0305719171,
-0.0393929183,
0.0458249524,
0.0570809022,
0.0524294823,
-0.0535011366,
-0.0489289835,
0.0236860514,
0.0420566574,
-0.0518721305,
-0.0048999889,
0.0049105217,
0.0133848805,
-0.0373494178,
0.036450021,
-0.0584649704,
0.0396084301,
-0.0284239277,
0.0416998006,
-0.0139788454,
0.0006077889,
-0.0310482364,
0.0448362418,
-0.0847655088,
-0.0385429747,
-0.0523775816,
0.0430050753,
0.0211640485,
0.0431674607,
-0.0439482108,
-0.0201373007,
-0.0050040698,
-0.0092103723,
-0.0100839091,
-0.0197133049,
0.0409086458,
-0.0210564937,
0.003596792,
0.0281227939,
-0.0305424351,
0.0076828566,
0.0299826898,
0.03558423,
-0.0120091885,
-0.066095233,
0.0297966618,
0.0058332398,
0.0120507665,
0.0420726687,
-0.0213097893,
-0.0095330179,
0.0501452312,
-0.0306664482,
-0.0382037982,
-0.0104221459,
0.0286927912,
-0.0046411064,
-0.0545802414,
0.0025645746,
-0.007221024,
-0.0206565484,
0.0189649593,
-0.0160620715,
0.0178844091,
0.0592421219,
0.0475823283,
-0.0011509467,
-0.0515426919,
-0.029005561,
-0.0490194932,
0.0023110036,
0.0631556287,
0.0019004828,
0.0689522773,
0.0674113259,
-0.0094227195,
0.0007153625,
-0.0060124286,
-0.0657164678,
-0.0330263115,
0.0118504027,
-0.0348866545,
0.0396245122,
0.0230906401,
0.0217679776,
-0.0135363061,
-0.0328741148,
0.0053395405,
0.000014708,
0.0153481858,
-0.0268248282,
0.0359041877,
0.0330769457,
-0.0127295051,
-0.0035967571,
0.0377554707,
-0.0116665522,
0.0269427523,
0.0382877439,
-0.0250281729,
-0.0154056577,
-0.0453666151,
-0.0911060348,
0.0026879306,
0.0056723743,
-0.0007410573,
-0.0579795539,
-0.0815508291,
-0.0093999133,
0.040995691,
0.0201137401,
0.0380841717,
0.0073691201,
0.0580715127,
0.0504323244,
-0.0422321558,
-0.0157744829,
-0.0075980043,
-0.0110876579,
-0.0303298086,
-0.0127343955,
-5.721362431e-33,
-0.003510613,
-0.0545075685,
0.0277219117,
-0.0013850468,
0.0159198195,
0.0166737624,
-0.0593606196,
-0.0241974723,
-0.0665675551,
0.0877055526,
-0.0317216888,
0.0387213528,
0.0085302889,
0.0035457474,
-0.0054239919,
-0.0237970948,
0.0028433057,
0.0038551174,
-0.0615638532,
0.0230806787,
0.0314111523,
-0.034604013,
0.0369928703,
-0.0504353121,
0.0377092361,
-0.0043382253,
-0.0143924234,
0.053636685,
-0.061581526,
0.0482008457,
0.0202049725,
0.0234262645,
0.0247412939,
-0.0424491093,
0.029593572,
0.0061979955,
-0.099561967,
-0.0287311152,
0.029779233,
-0.0412225351,
-0.1016550511,
0.0096544195,
0.0103639197,
0.0258450843,
0.0143271638,
-0.0686937347,
0.0187779423,
-0.0105754649,
0.0257447716,
-0.0291804951,
-0.0219295062,
0.0466924198,
-0.018911412,
-0.034043625,
-0.0201686006,
0.0445086323,
-0.0101748686,
-0.0256299414,
-0.0439289697,
0.0017819767,
0.0130926762,
-0.009039877,
0.0680674762,
-0.0258000363,
-0.0175448172,
0.048480574,
0.0111514302,
0.0226860661,
-0.0644085482,
0.0278780926,
-0.020017812,
0.0363677144,
0.11119885,
0.0279651135,
0.0045621716,
0.0512977317,
-0.1045497581,
0.0084867524,
-0.0069076661,
0.0552838407,
0.0154454047,
-0.0320210345,
-0.0059197391,
0.006028635,
-0.0652430579,
0.013225873,
-0.0439807028,
-0.0106891766,
0.0076139104,
-0.0146274595,
-0.0331932195,
-0.0376505069,
-0.0009017892,
-0.0490771085,
-0.0110271908,
0.0625023022,
0.0082296487,
-0.0015526307,
0.0201257169,
0.0483456142,
-0.0438795388,
0.0436062105,
0.0266549271,
0.0160812717,
0.0228845961,
0.0076155476,
0.0568753704,
-0.0194936767,
-0.0293546878,
0.0072157457,
-0.0631715432,
0.0281169116,
-0.0294070262,
-0.0034776079,
0.0425888225,
0.0487471223,
0.0054948018,
0.0578607619,
0.0163046047,
0.0123785352,
-0.0353315808,
0.0617446825,
0.0161466692,
0.0049510975,
-0.0133092124,
-0.0035995806,
-0.0576290041,
0.0145030124,
0.0002673023,
-0.0340711027,
0.007479161,
0.0412380546,
2.494e-7,
0.0243372135,
0.0317176841,
0.0337943994,
0.064701423,
0.0052126828,
0.0390405767,
-0.0059127156,
-0.0267376993,
0.0170449838,
-0.0780152455,
-0.0262872949,
0.0441945456,
0.0657329708,
0.0685516521,
-0.02388102,
-0.0373392403,
-0.0655483827,
-0.0426438004,
-0.0303385761,
-0.0168837886,
0.0540292487,
0.0517306998,
0.0165895931,
-0.0134633277,
-0.0256662983,
-0.0182356928,
0.0341048725,
0.0085713649,
0.0251609385,
0.0041140351,
0.0414499678,
-0.0301038045,
0.0356985852,
0.0525600687,
-0.0151411463,
-0.0157712866,
-0.029371215,
0.0184266344,
0.0121911066,
-0.0198710114,
-0.0432240888,
-0.0429874733,
0.0294738859,
-0.0652163327,
0.07912682,
-0.0408068188,
-0.0288326479,
-0.0142446067,
-0.0131269461,
-0.0414579548,
0.0373614244,
-0.0084923711,
0.0040776781,
0.0218680091,
0.0073496639,
0.013199565,
0.0072685713,
-0.0676244348,
-0.0367259867,
0.0091927163,
-0.0033900337,
-0.0111992825,
0.0207093731,
-0.0046650306,
0.0133254537,
-0.036818929,
-0.0018893195,
2.16748508e-34,
0.0091250446,
-0.0183313116,
0.0251507554,
-0.0013730885,
0.0887437835,
-0.0122451177,
-0.0328783579,
-0.01971424,
0.0197185408,
-0.090657942,
-0.0216314178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00530v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00530v2 | Superfiltering: Weak-to-Strong Data Filtering for Fast Instruction-Tuning | 2024-02-01T11:57:53 | 2024-06-07T20:28:36 | Ming Li, Yong Zhang, Shwai He, Zhitao Li, Hongyu Zhao, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is critical to improve LLMs but usually suffers from
low-quality and redundant data. Data filtering for instruction tuning has
proved important in improving both the efficiency and performance of the tuning
process. But it also leads to extra cost and computation due to the involvement
of LLMs in this process. To reduce the filtering cost, we study Superfiltering:
Can we use a smaller and weaker model to select data for finetuning a larger
and stronger model? Despite the performance gap between weak and strong
language models, we find their highly consistent capability to perceive
instruction difficulty and data selection results. This enables us to use a
much smaller and more efficient model to filter the instruction data used to
train a larger language model. Not only does it largely speed up the data
filtering, but the filtered-data-finetuned LLM achieves even better performance
on standard benchmarks. Extensive experiments validate the efficacy and
efficiency of our approach. | Superfiltering: Weak-to-Strong Data Filtering for Fast Instruction-Tuning: Instruction tuning is critical to improve LLMs but usually suffers from
low-quality and redundant data. Data filtering for instruction tuning has
proved important in improving both the efficiency and performance of the tuning
process. But it also leads to extra cost and computation due to the involvement
of LLMs in this process. To reduce the filtering cost, we study Superfiltering:
Can we use a smaller and weaker model to select data for finetuning a larger
and stronger model? Despite the performance gap between weak and strong
language models, we find their highly consistent capability to perceive
instruction difficulty and data selection results. This enables us to use a
much smaller and more efficient model to filter the instruction data used to
train a larger language model. Not only does it largely speed up the data
filtering, but the filtered-data-finetuned LLM achieves even better performance
on standard benchmarks. Extensive experiments validate the efficacy and
efficiency of our approach. | [
0.0082584843,
0.0391747542,
-0.0178318322,
0.0355165191,
-0.0113824056,
0.0295118447,
-0.0170805752,
0.0346358269,
0.0067045032,
-0.0480861478,
-0.0470501669,
-0.0231181383,
-0.0168207008,
-0.0143886609,
0.026133148,
-0.0052690208,
0.0669870228,
-0.0637208596,
-0.0342526361,
-0.0090942373,
-0.0458115786,
0.0014945645,
0.0014459245,
0.0125463177,
0.0548936911,
0.0185804125,
0.01494601,
0.0453701206,
-0.0124319419,
-0.0098469788,
0.0257561002,
0.0119622713,
0.0156868882,
-0.0241038296,
0.000002063,
-0.0148548009,
0.0042135031,
0.0006131877,
-0.0058249077,
0.0487593971,
0.0138753289,
0.0322215036,
-0.0402622037,
0.0262189396,
-0.0073568746,
0.0377347209,
0.0024698549,
-0.036515817,
0.0635801628,
0.0815765858,
0.0134026743,
-0.0197701696,
0.0050746952,
-0.0027920108,
0.0048851334,
-0.0240758061,
0.0193799268,
0.0007867091,
0.0197234526,
0.0055202367,
-0.033663258,
0.0190749299,
-0.0083519416,
0.0186264105,
-0.0332516804,
-0.0099697886,
-0.0109671606,
0.0012078274,
-0.0140877916,
0.0388649553,
-0.0448078886,
-0.0036044281,
-0.0046155704,
-0.0314760841,
-0.0113585722,
-0.019924257,
-0.0185730997,
0.0207894947,
-0.0119068446,
0.0345274396,
0.0462138392,
-0.0608098656,
0.0336033851,
0.0052777077,
-0.0179801136,
0.0918202177,
0.0390892401,
-0.0388007723,
0.0125264451,
0.0005082935,
-0.0161295123,
-0.0336637124,
0.0034309248,
0.0524053797,
-0.0319302082,
0.0156235481,
-0.0697795749,
0.0330799371,
-0.0046611186,
-0.0123045435,
0.0666663796,
0.0557885319,
-0.0204937179,
0.0267171189,
-0.0495207421,
0.0176826529,
-0.0124192024,
0.0657939017,
-0.0338544026,
0.0354347043,
-0.0114566172,
0.044695098,
-0.0009388822,
0.0550967567,
-0.0470344201,
0.056225121,
-0.0550839156,
0.0204372332,
0.0062240921,
-0.0195262693,
0.0168508124,
-0.0674307644,
-0.0525219999,
0.0407555252,
-0.0313347429,
-0.0041072858,
-0.0107028484,
0.0079481471,
-0.0354590081,
-0.063605018,
-0.000678251,
0.0234138072,
-0.0253222194,
-0.0485813208,
0.0600193404,
0.0741651058,
-0.0118172271,
-0.0223460384,
-0.0899112001,
-0.0104580168,
0.0237428583,
-0.0546601154,
0.0286800172,
-0.029473858,
-0.0145599358,
-0.0140445763,
0.016863415,
-0.0559504852,
-0.0002052417,
0.0128166825,
-0.0149048874,
0.0185570288,
-0.0255192276,
-0.0125853093,
-0.0077263545,
0.018476963,
0.0068250527,
0.0717478171,
0.034351863,
-0.0061989254,
0.018713735,
-0.0282125343,
-0.0296122562,
0.0439468361,
0.0037687281,
0.0304845348,
-0.0517431386,
-0.0109038856,
-0.0197387915,
-0.0087308176,
0.0324391238,
0.010380012,
-0.0029790197,
0.0019802535,
0.0232592858,
0.0183700472,
0.0457075834,
0.0095460881,
0.0371827558,
0.0194733758,
0.0052741626,
0.0424881354,
-0.0287523884,
0.0373445638,
-0.0022664438,
0.010499334,
-2.133e-7,
0.0579292886,
-0.0367340036,
-0.0592920333,
-0.0058324155,
0.016869219,
-0.0110544963,
0.0294137709,
0.0302445665,
-0.0402207822,
-0.0675425157,
0.0592211485,
0.0781453103,
-0.024106469,
-0.0309472699,
-0.116867438,
0.0107501755,
0.0550953187,
0.0524459332,
-0.0331262611,
-0.0329480059,
0.0046147434,
0.0705855116,
-0.0112489257,
0.0300057288,
0.0211321823,
0.0279784556,
-0.0573013984,
-0.0422895476,
-0.0001097422,
-0.0071829432,
0.0042122323,
0.0158798993,
-0.0338344425,
0.014403333,
0.026334513,
-0.0761544928,
0.0480214097,
-0.0081300903,
-0.0490571707,
-0.0095163891,
0.0211458616,
0.0274901595,
-0.0138532221,
-0.0061724177,
-0.0161502883,
0.0573663525,
-0.0080270236,
0.0639313161,
-0.0735525042,
-0.040511407,
-0.0198674966,
0.0291440319,
-0.0229733717,
0.0049123825,
0.0195043609,
-0.0499675795,
-0.0431694016,
-0.0119192917,
-0.0480757058,
-0.000384907,
0.0079449825,
0.0578413829,
-0.0331969224,
-0.0043953364,
-0.0611620583,
0.0393061452,
-0.0207611751,
0.0173389856,
0.03130503,
0.0272526983,
0.0000179939,
-0.0277820379,
-0.0296236146,
0.0057826769,
-0.0010219584,
0.0255302265,
-0.0220340136,
0.0388650559,
-0.0371743105,
-0.0747025087,
-0.0125536472,
0.0298036654,
-0.0290647,
0.0302323103,
0.013643031,
-0.014375018,
-0.0002476329,
-0.0008014921,
-0.012952094,
0.0178440511,
-0.0244822912,
0.0107147647,
0.0059269196,
0.0076604425,
-0.0653643161,
-0.0512388498,
-0.0586168244,
-0.0079386896,
-0.0019619821,
-0.0369926952,
-0.0362375006,
-0.0698967353,
0.0651347861,
-0.0058700237,
0.0442441888,
-0.0068321149,
-0.0670874119,
0.0176842231,
-0.0154163484,
-0.0071116914,
0.1018359289,
-0.0328101814,
0.0153342737,
0.0681607649,
-0.0251416713,
-0.0553677306,
0.0446768105,
0.0095099658,
-0.0370630622,
-0.0556918271,
-0.0234732069,
-0.0253429152,
0.0787720978,
-0.0262213126,
-0.011645617,
-0.0282001719,
0.0110538248,
0.0071503045,
-0.0119069917,
0.0178055055,
0.0293340757,
-0.0310435072,
-0.0039361035,
-0.0403752662,
-0.0721919015,
0.0478809029,
-0.0167406313,
0.010963669,
-0.0286888089,
-0.0403236635,
-0.0125817936,
-0.045293536,
0.0077182604,
0.0001373744,
-0.076742366,
0.0126623614,
-0.0450393744,
-0.0050077033,
0.0186505839,
-0.0372032486,
0.0849044919,
-0.0559481978,
0.0022266265,
-0.0085764183,
-0.0081452448,
-0.0180042572,
0.0378823653,
0.0175125189,
0.0096727349,
0.0540685207,
-0.031694755,
-0.0244170353,
-0.0018855722,
0.0150734512,
0.0228572078,
-0.0182412639,
-0.0099140871,
-0.0610809326,
-0.0402583741,
0.0132327089,
-0.0168904513,
-0.0087298388,
-0.0424372591,
0.0380993821,
0.007357507,
0.0487972572,
-0.0245358683,
-0.0130328471,
0.047371015,
0.0583468042,
-0.0317005068,
-0.0349844843,
0.0772685483,
0.0760155395,
-0.0557356216,
-0.0257337317,
0.0708508715,
0.032918904,
-0.0118556367,
0.004167316,
0.0163826402,
0.0288402867,
0.0626443997,
0.039363388,
-0.0213315357,
-0.0448043235,
0.0118435519,
0.054872185,
-0.0068073859,
0.0029718645,
-0.0260463376,
-0.0509762764,
0.0218335874,
0.0297194999,
-0.00520453,
-0.0383362845,
-0.0287797414,
-0.0014132453,
0.0103354622,
0.0315959267,
0.0138342623,
-0.0405802578,
-0.0057659592,
0.0460783988,
0.0144610181,
-0.0546325967,
0.0260915253,
-0.0161692277,
0.0349811241,
0.0248686243,
0.0095835235,
0.0003058148,
-0.0428847969,
0.0900260136,
-0.0139334444,
0.0244645867,
-0.0636987388,
0.0265758391,
0.0076710065,
-0.0174699631,
-0.001635134,
-0.0080954321,
0.002275055,
0.0227134153,
0.0033358145,
0.0632973909,
-0.0378763825,
0.0322472155,
0.0073858192,
-0.0274551399,
-0.0132915704,
0.0406310856,
0.0313759707,
-0.0499556065,
0.0004755449,
-0.0445621945,
-0.0564945042,
-0.0638097748,
-0.0370847918,
0.0510360785,
-0.0657989904,
0.0031836035,
-0.016106179,
-0.0045168591,
0.0189218875,
0.0371170677,
0.0155262053,
0.0189874619,
0.0173266865,
-0.0171761811,
-0.0259022526,
0.0226430297,
-0.0490649939,
0.0384977013,
-0.1226510406,
-0.0472580381,
0.0242565889,
0.0269803088,
-0.0151460515,
0.0332332551,
-0.0838356242,
-0.0726029351,
0.0049181408,
0.0828390867,
0.0138046648,
0.0176711455,
0.0026436839,
-0.0546218902,
-0.0033897841,
0.0207821112,
-0.0131392889,
0.0471812785,
0.0558322221,
-0.0548710898,
-0.0118180159,
0.007006933,
-0.0371407792,
0.03345358,
0.0869313106,
0.0151816709,
-0.0319771767,
-0.0289250519,
0.0012506082,
0.0554699153,
0.0229958817,
-0.0067925267,
-0.0195438266,
-0.0053731226,
0.0548067093,
0.0260805245,
0.0276888274,
-0.0497606285,
-0.001158166,
-0.001024213,
-0.0319418348,
-0.0116008595,
-0.0144749852,
-0.0048912084,
0.0381388031,
-0.0338291526,
0.0931073576,
-0.0415873937,
0.0262501091,
0.0363712162,
0.0090078097,
0.0015303488,
0.0405347794,
0.0346641019,
0.0350617021,
-0.0057891188,
0.0479152277,
-0.0134296715,
0.0551471449,
-0.0388778485,
0.020399332,
-0.0363784172,
-0.030850254,
-0.0581927598,
-0.0081489254,
0.0503103957,
-0.0196946096,
0.0328120589,
0.0192964934,
0.0043906365,
-0.0211860184,
0.0094047338,
0.0130582601,
-0.0015806517,
0.0450118892,
0.0160013586,
0.0080067795,
-0.0141460933,
0.0641375333,
-0.0005979791,
0.0616174676,
0.0062533123,
0.0038595526,
-0.0376716815,
-0.0384378284,
0.022270659,
0.0135040712,
0.0135545954,
0.0153527558,
0.002529287,
-0.0304347202,
-0.0442522429,
-0.0045434558,
0.0288986657,
-0.0418616682,
0.0277786683,
0.025437301,
-0.0144387288,
-0.0341640674,
-0.0319677033,
-0.0450966433,
0.0555842966,
-0.0091424985,
0.011990645,
-6.239491688e-33,
-0.0593154244,
0.0145473033,
0.0099171214,
0.0065773451,
0.0216084812,
-0.0106681753,
-0.016684128,
-0.0227545071,
-0.0320604965,
-0.0308711249,
-0.0040163752,
0.020940423,
0.0191831701,
-0.0128846718,
-0.0010101685,
0.0156716257,
0.0671016574,
-0.0015758321,
-0.0288991164,
0.0112693133,
-0.0054940083,
0.0246487781,
0.0460634567,
-0.0417130552,
-0.043991223,
-0.0003112747,
-0.0003058299,
0.0016940088,
-0.0216324124,
0.0584929138,
0.0231509618,
0.0333561562,
0.0132213086,
-0.0564168803,
-0.0344558917,
-0.0583534054,
-0.0272362269,
-0.0523515828,
0.0235408563,
0.0200123955,
0.0280704331,
-0.0724805519,
0.0576149225,
0.0386183783,
-0.0681322291,
-0.0330199748,
0.0086094812,
-0.0319031477,
-0.045675315,
0.0071382248,
-0.0282761715,
0.0398922712,
0.0121434713,
0.0052674906,
0.0481557623,
-0.00313136,
-0.0024234408,
-0.0116366036,
-0.026201345,
0.0294378847,
0.078236796,
0.1216746867,
0.0698947981,
0.0275755618,
-0.0163600408,
0.0046101692,
0.010680276,
0.0227103848,
0.0532637015,
-0.0058924397,
0.0533725992,
0.0701579675,
0.0136164734,
-0.012233003,
0.0377066955,
-0.0286743771,
-0.0886150599,
0.013429503,
-0.009205482,
0.0285654962,
0.0075338078,
0.0148094166,
-0.0537729263,
-0.0128676929,
-0.0294498038,
0.024256425,
-0.0319523476,
-0.0124088004,
0.0377213806,
-0.0107622081,
-0.0375368148,
-0.0211956855,
0.0228469353,
-0.0238756593,
-0.0034222302,
-0.0255074538,
-0.0412112661,
0.0031389601,
-0.0099389879,
0.0132581014,
-0.0452879369,
-0.1165049002,
0.0246511232,
-0.0340851508,
0.0648775399,
-0.0109786354,
0.0145058716,
0.0191641375,
-0.077610679,
-0.0160817727,
-0.0497984923,
0.0206068121,
0.0183607265,
0.0315631256,
0.0098044071,
-0.0083829705,
0.0156958401,
0.0734808519,
-0.0235188063,
-0.0478841215,
-0.0295955054,
-0.0347978137,
0.0256849416,
0.0749607533,
-0.0306223184,
0.01401807,
-0.0354245603,
0.0151729472,
0.0038007838,
-0.0490354896,
-0.0344232917,
0.0148174455,
2.727e-7,
0.0031312034,
0.0541284792,
-0.0179094821,
0.0575130358,
-0.0189249888,
0.0192409046,
-0.0233289637,
-0.0268903244,
0.0192324407,
-0.0190608744,
0.0120586213,
0.0610968992,
0.0538386777,
0.0049249907,
-0.0163322836,
0.0135153932,
-0.0027692858,
0.0482562631,
-0.0394981168,
-0.009845579,
0.0284144226,
0.0802251697,
-0.0089098029,
-0.0312794298,
-0.0014618699,
-0.0249350425,
-0.0120371571,
-0.039298702,
0.0061912113,
0.0553913787,
0.0515849702,
0.0368068554,
-0.0257082898,
0.0251258034,
-0.0517875068,
0.0012486707,
-0.0403086916,
0.0804443285,
-0.0285436232,
-0.0044921143,
0.072858423,
0.011348119,
-0.0143151889,
0.015217091,
0.0680367351,
-0.0044903532,
0.0216526501,
-0.0123979682,
0.0265368968,
-0.0387276486,
0.0066223671,
-0.0377952717,
0.0176307969,
0.0298247505,
0.0325040147,
-0.0409247354,
-0.0318815038,
-0.0511546917,
-0.013026515,
0.0308791175,
-0.0212926716,
-0.0888731182,
-0.0703725293,
0.044573471,
-0.0058948258,
-0.0537624322,
-0.0044094548,
2.854795708e-34,
0.0350459591,
-0.0352772325,
0.0433524922,
0.0387732871,
0.0254691038,
0.0037577101,
-0.0545095205,
0.0310592689,
-0.0087145781,
-0.0612800829,
-0.0272940956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00518v1 | EE-Tuning: An Economical yet Scalable Solution for Tuning Early-Exit Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T11:39:04 | 2024-02-01T11:39:04 | Xuchen Pan, Yanxi Chen, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jingren Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | This work introduces EE-Tuning, a lightweight and economical solution to
training/tuning early-exit large language models (LLMs). In contrast to the
common approach of full-parameter pre-training, EE-Tuning augments any
pre-trained (and possibly fine-tuned) standard LLM with additional early-exit
layers that are tuned in a parameter-efficient manner, which requires
significantly less computational resources and training data. Our
implementation of EE-Tuning achieves outstanding training efficiency via
extensive performance optimizations, as well as scalability due to its full
compatibility with 3D parallelism. Results of systematic experiments validate
the efficacy of EE-Tuning, confirming that effective early-exit LLM inference
can be achieved with a limited training budget. In hope of making early-exit
LLMs accessible to the community, we release the source code of our
implementation of EE-Tuning at https://github.com/pan-x-c/EE-LLM. | EE-Tuning: An Economical yet Scalable Solution for Tuning Early-Exit Large Language Models: This work introduces EE-Tuning, a lightweight and economical solution to
training/tuning early-exit large language models (LLMs). In contrast to the
common approach of full-parameter pre-training, EE-Tuning augments any
pre-trained (and possibly fine-tuned) standard LLM with additional early-exit
layers that are tuned in a parameter-efficient manner, which requires
significantly less computational resources and training data. Our
implementation of EE-Tuning achieves outstanding training efficiency via
extensive performance optimizations, as well as scalability due to its full
compatibility with 3D parallelism. Results of systematic experiments validate
the efficacy of EE-Tuning, confirming that effective early-exit LLM inference
can be achieved with a limited training budget. In hope of making early-exit
LLMs accessible to the community, we release the source code of our
implementation of EE-Tuning at https://github.com/pan-x-c/EE-LLM. | [
0.0161736812,
0.0952102765,
0.0087241102,
0.0314648263,
0.0083243037,
0.0387908407,
0.0113334674,
-0.0068950509,
-0.0349429324,
-0.0133078527,
-0.0443077236,
-0.0003026313,
-0.0037968762,
0.0278852619,
0.032371182,
-0.0282029528,
0.023369737,
-0.0340985581,
-0.0377722792,
-0.0166384038,
-0.0137976836,
0.0331720263,
-0.0010609862,
0.0296374019,
0.0551593192,
0.0022970536,
-0.0063884407,
0.0401884466,
0.0228136182,
-0.0171100032,
0.0236001331,
0.0517373756,
0.0355336405,
0.0297654662,
0.0000020917,
-0.0514668971,
-0.0171455108,
-0.0121790338,
-0.0405129157,
0.0702495128,
0.0223083757,
0.0046099937,
-0.0004141087,
0.025846066,
0.0161747076,
-0.0332722329,
0.0694381893,
-0.0125209084,
0.0385774896,
0.0876936689,
0.0000060091,
-0.0221638363,
-0.0031656476,
-0.0664028451,
-0.0321091376,
-0.0482329614,
0.0435904339,
-0.0421804488,
-0.039444454,
-0.0134219024,
-0.0049631214,
0.0147657236,
0.0242973063,
0.0286523569,
-0.0311503094,
0.0520601869,
-0.007406909,
-0.0464231409,
-0.037969213,
0.0356181152,
-0.0204603542,
-0.0552025326,
0.0300628878,
-0.0294475388,
-0.0259256382,
-0.000977063,
-0.0316753499,
0.0072206669,
0.0466398969,
0.0056738853,
0.0222602431,
-0.0032485053,
0.036634773,
0.018760046,
-0.0441293307,
0.01345322,
0.068725355,
0.0050669615,
-0.0029293762,
0.0008362258,
-0.014666819,
-0.0401647985,
-0.0069449251,
-0.0048467107,
0.0051853606,
-0.0004043201,
-0.0579338185,
-0.024465723,
-0.0142585486,
-0.0406042188,
0.0488865823,
0.0368093438,
0.0107377935,
0.0849947333,
-0.0280803628,
-0.0030273132,
-0.014271888,
0.0086080553,
-0.0359318182,
-0.0020236229,
0.0392329507,
0.0351702273,
-0.019137606,
-0.0307079554,
-0.0138399284,
-0.0242737271,
-0.0449096225,
0.0259921122,
0.0348439589,
-0.0235293861,
0.0275955386,
0.0046254629,
-0.0285839867,
-0.0335206315,
0.0403653905,
0.0396979153,
-0.0363363363,
0.0138873802,
-0.0245245323,
-0.0405518897,
-0.0327583738,
0.0459435806,
0.0346619971,
-0.0273076557,
0.0652751252,
0.0395977758,
0.0225439649,
-0.0417479612,
-0.049986314,
0.0303082298,
-0.001104058,
-0.0839893222,
0.0105565405,
-0.0760563388,
0.0187428053,
0.0205176733,
0.0155848283,
-0.0245810617,
-0.0222553164,
-0.0156048713,
-0.0227310304,
0.0208485667,
-0.0114806648,
0.0015645063,
0.028955752,
-0.0198638346,
0.0190191381,
0.0915923864,
0.0195986591,
0.0342458673,
0.0338467732,
-0.0410420932,
-0.040030472,
0.091041863,
0.0304522179,
0.046682097,
-0.0428822488,
-0.0113670873,
0.0319279619,
0.0324034058,
0.0403176881,
0.0081410352,
-0.0444572009,
-0.0139107816,
0.0479024202,
0.0672940016,
0.0119938916,
0.0108619239,
0.0287699215,
0.0018032369,
0.0018385219,
-0.0366478525,
-0.0381975994,
0.0250860564,
-0.0151307769,
-0.0066836048,
0.0457441211,
0.0831933543,
-0.0260256324,
-0.0027182722,
-0.0133677302,
-0.0031943542,
-0.0276170801,
0.0287807062,
0.0698259771,
-0.0241502207,
-0.0264760666,
0.0699536055,
0.0543983243,
-0.0248337723,
-0.0175566189,
-0.0556513667,
0.0193240549,
0.0372871086,
0.0198275652,
0.0099401036,
-0.0282468274,
0.0114977956,
0.0355683155,
0.0445451811,
0.0376736857,
0.0061633782,
0.0390529707,
-0.0736480355,
-0.0216025338,
0.0383277945,
0.0160911046,
0.0101875477,
0.0710969865,
-0.0017729028,
0.0079562394,
-0.0466319732,
-0.024212569,
0.032839451,
-0.0639397502,
0.0024235048,
0.00244961,
0.0077388575,
0.0308281295,
-0.0192697123,
-0.0121402396,
-0.0313138478,
0.0292220749,
-0.0117571009,
0.0148213012,
-0.0049147429,
-0.0273297615,
-0.0089543294,
0.0257618092,
0.0236458145,
0.0086421445,
0.0406637117,
-0.0474988893,
-0.0371505544,
0.0228639375,
-0.0192533173,
0.0718545169,
-0.0342813097,
0.0306853186,
-0.0407986194,
0.0201889258,
-0.0359917097,
0.0357556641,
-0.0309980959,
0.0110944873,
0.0048185829,
0.0021536131,
-0.0252926964,
0.0037676848,
-0.0520864464,
0.0060560899,
0.0280340686,
0.0112795532,
0.0096738758,
0.0218279343,
-0.0208563544,
-0.0026732341,
-0.0669132024,
0.0345172733,
-0.0433902591,
0.033312384,
0.0386068374,
0.0030292494,
-0.0253135208,
-0.0118165668,
0.0458790697,
0.0208894517,
-0.0284937713,
0.0049813758,
-0.0225893855,
-0.0164608806,
-0.0524122156,
-0.0307283774,
-0.0359154716,
0.0155875962,
0.076238364,
-0.0156864543,
-0.0212725457,
-0.0367008671,
0.0188859869,
0.0100358734,
0.0495148562,
0.0020448235,
-0.0406158566,
-0.0117027955,
-0.0330579318,
0.0393025093,
0.0562828034,
-0.0175040849,
0.0079993196,
0.0260643028,
0.0283180829,
-0.0531413667,
-0.00946254,
-0.0360689834,
-0.021806471,
-0.0599118955,
-0.0202086959,
-0.010219248,
0.0866448432,
-0.0289218295,
0.0077263559,
-0.038660448,
0.0178736448,
-0.0063175848,
-0.0167757515,
0.0042218622,
0.0402467847,
-0.0199054778,
0.0115047656,
-0.004948467,
-0.0566196255,
0.0598846748,
-0.0468455255,
-0.0068618921,
-0.0191718005,
-0.0158485491,
-0.0459484383,
0.0339359529,
-0.0037397917,
0.0105545353,
-0.0176623818,
-0.0076255412,
-0.0209562462,
0.0188512448,
0.0060668378,
0.0138822543,
0.0485788845,
-0.0483900197,
0.0185083076,
-0.0202453304,
-0.0400432162,
0.0103125488,
-0.0268729795,
-0.0581685193,
-0.0304801259,
0.0252017621,
-0.0623234361,
-0.0456565283,
0.0009946163,
0.0056524277,
0.0852536634,
-0.0191352032,
0.0321160816,
-0.0092701633,
0.0079487981,
0.0547455698,
0.0144429002,
0.0209428836,
-0.0771069005,
0.0030855751,
0.0321780629,
-0.0007931958,
0.007051426,
-0.061538253,
-0.0125230467,
0.0859092325,
-0.0240078773,
-0.0225287937,
0.02793671,
0.0156244207,
-0.0604198873,
0.0057695862,
0.1273202002,
-0.0081491228,
-0.0814137161,
-0.0107094292,
0.023645455,
0.0617595129,
0.0196510609,
0.0218866691,
-0.0427937023,
-0.0342011191,
-0.012932267,
0.0285642501,
0.0352470353,
0.0065465337,
-0.0087110801,
-0.1057862788,
0.0358415842,
0.0204574391,
-0.0442450792,
-0.0125954254,
-0.0452077836,
0.0083243437,
-0.037618205,
-0.0005577948,
0.0071463161,
-0.0198692083,
-0.0091280155,
0.0277772173,
0.0079360642,
-0.0558951572,
0.0323649757,
-0.0342635028,
0.056836307,
0.009521177,
-0.0085950503,
-0.0205054544,
-0.0306772366,
0.0674011037,
-0.0175225195,
-0.0315342806,
-0.0332555361,
0.0130401505,
-0.0249422789,
-0.0014513499,
-0.0086923996,
0.0367428474,
-0.0022838258,
-0.0108653521,
0.01872769,
0.0477379449,
-0.0244776923,
-0.0409299359,
0.0109555954,
-0.0116803218,
-0.0527638271,
0.0680985227,
0.0455046557,
-0.0783827156,
-0.015505393,
-0.0029011315,
-0.0371951312,
-0.0608098693,
-0.0138554955,
-0.023695875,
-0.0244355928,
-0.0415172353,
-0.0065111425,
0.0462617762,
0.0304824915,
0.0533115081,
0.0036907711,
-0.0044420045,
-0.004781072,
0.0112661533,
-0.0449245758,
0.0349830575,
-0.02203927,
-0.0070403204,
-0.0817943662,
0.007789541,
0.0566456914,
-0.0227311738,
-0.0186356585,
0.0115153948,
-0.1100545973,
-0.0731218755,
0.0017378909,
0.0261078924,
0.0122446166,
0.0662954673,
0.0088686114,
-0.0995135978,
0.0396003388,
0.0079396376,
0.018206019,
0.0597773269,
0.0325085036,
-0.0137096066,
-0.0195725523,
0.0364270993,
-0.0159104522,
0.0190696605,
0.049167756,
0.0151476879,
-0.0360689461,
-0.0385291986,
-0.0437542871,
-0.0108698951,
0.0505095161,
-0.044075314,
-0.0228978228,
-0.0702927187,
0.0392450951,
0.0054403562,
0.0080421884,
-0.0474620312,
0.0006074,
0.0289880931,
0.0218368135,
-0.0301587954,
0.00495457,
0.0592947006,
0.0069898339,
-0.071753256,
0.0457350276,
-0.0117559349,
0.0085323751,
0.0717003047,
-0.0147585375,
-0.0307970103,
0.0464807227,
-0.0110432673,
0.0276263487,
-0.0464065596,
0.0529684313,
0.0284650158,
-0.0047528557,
-0.0303585473,
0.0261965655,
-0.0327722654,
-0.0627216548,
-0.067675367,
0.0493161269,
0.0489605702,
0.0195277911,
0.0893415585,
-0.0002507584,
-0.0314928927,
-0.0262526032,
0.011585067,
-0.0307905227,
-0.021891389,
0.0133795915,
0.0227594394,
-0.0281229392,
0.0226109587,
0.0427507274,
0.0490992106,
0.0462447479,
0.0236378741,
0.0029388692,
-0.014665015,
-0.0265306123,
-0.0176784769,
0.0092175314,
-0.0440193489,
0.0237533897,
0.0029574656,
-0.0541107059,
-0.0462914892,
0.0357699394,
-0.0228338633,
0.0161323361,
0.0278883874,
0.0676704347,
-0.039579127,
-0.0208207555,
-0.0292866882,
0.0019714974,
0.0167533886,
-0.021315258,
0.0139215766,
-6.916635209e-33,
-0.0095404591,
0.0204458851,
0.0239597671,
0.0058202678,
-0.0091257272,
-0.0040289178,
-0.0287422203,
-0.0079809874,
-0.0184702724,
-0.034429539,
0.0153627256,
0.0056380257,
0.0176488943,
0.0293208621,
-0.0021874097,
0.027290076,
0.0576104969,
0.0014294906,
-0.0316396244,
0.0295464955,
-0.0155412219,
0.0466743708,
0.0870349333,
0.007759369,
-0.0474921539,
-0.0146865025,
-0.0274288841,
0.0136572151,
-0.0300834551,
0.0385354273,
-0.0217096228,
0.0036063301,
-0.0085470844,
-0.0392613709,
0.0051325397,
-0.0155893127,
-0.0685674325,
-0.0077315262,
0.0307882428,
0.0217878707,
-0.0173650216,
-0.0084033059,
0.0227756109,
0.0106929736,
-0.0420893133,
-0.0310387649,
0.0277755037,
0.007100122,
-0.0500876978,
-0.0114362026,
-0.0252607521,
0.0397245251,
0.0017028069,
0.0086679421,
0.0024023778,
-0.0116176913,
-0.0073782881,
0.0290325675,
-0.0463574715,
0.0094270445,
0.0139285997,
0.036965955,
0.0450209193,
0.0737665668,
0.0183311943,
0.0641453937,
0.0350169986,
0.0001214799,
0.0175116789,
-0.0061141914,
0.0936868265,
0.0197657924,
0.0063950089,
-0.0059778695,
0.0058705895,
-0.0175428037,
-0.0782007724,
-0.0115305595,
0.0115671745,
0.0300161149,
0.0429715924,
0.0126359276,
-0.0086381165,
-0.034899082,
-0.0569727048,
-0.0360922851,
-0.0336928815,
0.0172806885,
0.0240220558,
0.0285519343,
-0.0598606542,
-0.0374013186,
0.0455462448,
-0.0274226181,
0.0172214005,
0.0248255488,
-0.0031360588,
0.0141716525,
-0.0118096936,
0.0450438373,
-0.0785075724,
-0.0527566485,
-0.0244942959,
-0.049727764,
0.0336224139,
-0.0447903574,
0.0140935555,
0.0390805304,
-0.0626813695,
-0.0050957277,
-0.0390657187,
-0.0025513896,
0.0293016396,
0.0601800419,
0.0201060101,
-0.0013795362,
0.0082213841,
0.0422976315,
0.0173011087,
0.0120901885,
-0.0180800669,
-0.0461777598,
0.0307308435,
0.0304714274,
-0.0304469503,
0.0075534079,
-0.021494709,
-0.0104277637,
0.032477688,
-0.0718226209,
-0.0303579997,
0.0377079658,
2.737e-7,
0.0307347905,
0.0445112325,
-0.0006360992,
0.0232108627,
-0.0158717819,
0.0130667407,
0.0021001589,
-0.005587968,
0.0348778367,
0.043412827,
0.0354169682,
0.0334438011,
0.0534112193,
-0.0072202482,
-0.0947925448,
0.0233605821,
-0.0796577632,
0.0441850685,
-0.0367593467,
-0.0218946971,
-0.0354602225,
0.0977841243,
0.0460156724,
-0.0197403356,
-0.0048319465,
-0.0240026973,
0.0427318141,
-0.0454117805,
-0.0119429193,
0.0390590355,
0.0000781222,
0.0258180276,
-0.0149060758,
-0.0035841162,
-0.0093723629,
0.0530771241,
-0.0167408176,
0.0938122347,
0.0085587651,
-0.004006213,
0.0316141248,
-0.0034952718,
-0.0241077635,
-0.0656263828,
0.0737021342,
-0.0374220833,
-0.012035301,
-0.0721858591,
-0.0037128064,
-0.0548575073,
0.0115594352,
-0.0596572459,
-0.007012343,
0.0174350087,
0.039504718,
-0.0431219339,
-0.0288754422,
-0.083154358,
-0.0166403577,
0.018324133,
-0.0621070787,
-0.0693550333,
-0.0365302004,
-0.0304033756,
0.0329938792,
-0.0364728943,
-0.0042812205,
2.925441771e-34,
0.0562273301,
-0.0190835744,
0.0094914986,
0.016713988,
0.0320040807,
-0.0210103523,
0.0311950557,
-0.0081836917,
-0.0095357532,
-0.1234925911,
-0.0330066048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00913v1 | Institutional Platform for Secure Self-Service Large Language Model Exploration | 2024-02-01T10:58:10 | 2024-02-01T10:58:10 | V. K. Cody Bumgardner, Mitchell A. Klusty, W. Vaiden Logan, Samuel E. Armstrong, Caylin Hickey, Jeff Talbert | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper introduces a user-friendly platform developed by the University of
Kentucky Center for Applied AI, designed to make large, customized language
models (LLMs) more accessible. By capitalizing on recent advancements in
multi-LoRA inference, the system efficiently accommodates custom adapters for a
diverse range of users and projects. The paper outlines the system's
architecture and key features, encompassing dataset curation, model training,
secure inference, and text-based feature extraction.
We illustrate the establishment of a tenant-aware computational network using
agent-based methods, securely utilizing islands of isolated resources as a
unified system. The platform strives to deliver secure LLM services,
emphasizing process and data isolation, end-to-end encryption, and role-based
resource authentication. This contribution aligns with the overarching goal of
enabling simplified access to cutting-edge AI models and technology in support
of scientific discovery. | Institutional Platform for Secure Self-Service Large Language Model Exploration: This paper introduces a user-friendly platform developed by the University of
Kentucky Center for Applied AI, designed to make large, customized language
models (LLMs) more accessible. By capitalizing on recent advancements in
multi-LoRA inference, the system efficiently accommodates custom adapters for a
diverse range of users and projects. The paper outlines the system's
architecture and key features, encompassing dataset curation, model training,
secure inference, and text-based feature extraction.
We illustrate the establishment of a tenant-aware computational network using
agent-based methods, securely utilizing islands of isolated resources as a
unified system. The platform strives to deliver secure LLM services,
emphasizing process and data isolation, end-to-end encryption, and role-based
resource authentication. This contribution aligns with the overarching goal of
enabling simplified access to cutting-edge AI models and technology in support
of scientific discovery. | [
0.0317949057,
0.0894332081,
-0.0060975039,
0.080790706,
-0.0730526,
-0.0245227236,
0.1084974036,
-0.0433151685,
0.0559623726,
-0.0019347747,
-0.0253872909,
-0.0010908709,
-0.0209460631,
0.0607510991,
0.0199746639,
0.0519515947,
0.0396946035,
-0.0785977989,
0.040743053,
-0.0503771566,
-0.03336915,
0.0320354924,
0.009026913,
-0.004096963,
0.0259112306,
-0.0411423407,
-0.0319236703,
-0.0252448022,
-0.0097325649,
-0.0182651076,
-0.0018628624,
0.0635205582,
0.0200221092,
0.0960606635,
0.0000023997,
-0.0456739664,
-0.0592067689,
0.0482004546,
-0.0671271011,
0.0046693794,
0.0676574111,
-0.0015105581,
-0.0114438822,
-0.0035280113,
-0.0425319076,
0.026511481,
0.0674011856,
-0.0342941508,
0.0350578353,
-0.0008971935,
0.0050849663,
-0.0528552458,
-0.0163165238,
-0.0236010011,
-0.0612714477,
-0.0359232649,
0.0460584424,
-0.0224687848,
0.0208342001,
0.0147713376,
-0.0029120822,
0.0391261838,
0.0165640377,
0.001723115,
-0.0008503632,
0.0379924104,
-0.0220559053,
-0.0547021478,
-0.0512060262,
0.0065038735,
0.032225389,
-0.0041026678,
0.0018669809,
0.0274502449,
-0.0160456412,
0.0544111133,
-0.0069645266,
0.0689730123,
0.0071865418,
-0.0206963979,
0.0466148816,
0.0028548513,
0.000792287,
0.053416077,
-0.0089330822,
0.1102084145,
0.0288349465,
-0.0104982611,
-0.0390702263,
-0.0430967845,
0.0344174169,
-0.0601961315,
0.0397880785,
0.0144593073,
0.0310709234,
0.0053613768,
-0.0423668772,
-0.0520821102,
0.0387498923,
-0.0301494058,
0.0224481784,
-0.0238840431,
0.0023246696,
0.0528912246,
0.0167991854,
0.0262057427,
-0.0286491923,
0.0196639858,
0.05359504,
-0.0008685585,
-0.0214915238,
-0.0203921217,
-0.0191214606,
0.0428214259,
-0.0285544842,
0.0082176048,
-0.0093608201,
0.027192479,
0.0090430249,
0.0510948375,
-0.0165657289,
-0.0176784173,
-0.0002378519,
-0.0420951173,
0.0017598931,
-0.0165041555,
0.0013214266,
0.0085256025,
-0.0042711948,
-0.0997213796,
-0.0299614463,
0.0017943602,
-0.0160692371,
-0.0076745814,
0.0071760025,
0.1057336777,
0.0543734282,
-0.028941175,
-0.01227732,
-0.069757171,
0.024456922,
-0.0729236901,
-0.0297701992,
-0.0782678574,
0.0384034961,
0.0008046835,
-0.0165332966,
-0.0603536144,
0.001972178,
-0.0233138036,
-0.0110088261,
0.0437740311,
-0.0418475978,
-0.0124574425,
0.0236945897,
0.0231337808,
0.0109707015,
0.0322674699,
0.0119647402,
0.0359778106,
0.0610780381,
0.0004983087,
0.0444713421,
0.0273857657,
-0.0060143447,
-0.00683191,
0.0000160184,
0.0490573198,
0.0354105793,
-0.0163625795,
-0.0380206816,
0.0322691239,
0.0141094588,
-0.0395021625,
0.0738804564,
0.1217812076,
-0.0265602749,
0.0397156738,
-0.0167547688,
0.035216514,
0.0028645964,
-0.0876732916,
-0.0412049703,
0.0479164831,
-0.0006415268,
-0.0256104935,
-0.0089079635,
0.0729482844,
0.0161918793,
-0.00084062,
-0.0156840533,
-0.029622769,
-0.0205560233,
-0.0001245531,
0.0611245707,
-0.0095051769,
0.0188606195,
0.0359013826,
0.027749911,
-0.0518625155,
-0.022801619,
-0.0783576667,
0.0598708093,
0.0899871215,
0.0543530732,
0.0079503693,
0.007733101,
-0.0109885884,
0.0068127369,
0.0745057464,
-0.0030259218,
0.017726725,
0.030565748,
-0.0429263599,
-0.0382421277,
-0.0067684301,
0.0299179703,
0.0355120413,
-0.0179534219,
0.0003224581,
-0.0127265239,
-0.0064443331,
-0.0256173927,
0.0114397146,
-0.0534970425,
-0.0170204435,
0.0008536901,
0.0179766305,
0.0342126861,
0.0319411606,
-0.0229563676,
0.0221840627,
0.0184365343,
0.0121985776,
0.0134306224,
-0.0287268702,
0.0382769778,
0.071739316,
0.0062073097,
-0.0019839739,
0.0421623066,
-0.0026502968,
-0.0024396759,
0.0016246773,
0.0487772077,
0.0023326799,
0.0009476329,
-0.0183707736,
0.0059265434,
-0.0186686702,
0.0605782457,
-0.0313095897,
0.0167809408,
-0.0026607031,
-0.0065800902,
-0.0193235241,
-0.0295793749,
0.0416794233,
-0.0463573597,
-0.0044519347,
-0.0297281425,
0.0098605929,
-0.0083014816,
-0.0174403712,
-0.0199521203,
0.0080641564,
-0.0031568862,
-0.0005894313,
0.0057185041,
-0.0258446075,
0.0482826903,
0.0054162797,
0.0061829612,
-0.0492345244,
-0.0231125336,
0.0111715235,
-0.0264301561,
-0.0597914495,
0.0026531904,
0.0061449865,
0.0046107918,
-0.0691604838,
-0.0083068581,
-0.0336194225,
-0.0006396335,
0.0496459082,
-0.0039030758,
-0.0121871373,
-0.0493181795,
0.0087823737,
-0.025934238,
-0.0009814339,
0.0085963374,
-0.0222685151,
0.0331999548,
-0.035104461,
-0.0419924669,
0.0418766811,
-0.0174752641,
-0.0045895972,
0.0774513111,
-0.0351881683,
-0.0272330008,
-0.0244098417,
-0.002912825,
0.0099182054,
-0.017007567,
0.0275382884,
-0.0032584041,
0.0187276658,
-0.000968423,
-0.0244380254,
-0.0049326085,
0.0219627619,
0.0007154737,
-0.0366102234,
0.0151863359,
-0.0021831824,
0.0169695504,
0.0474786572,
0.0020453357,
-0.0368615314,
0.0780002177,
-0.0678196847,
-0.0048696841,
-0.0529974364,
-0.0850845128,
-0.033966884,
0.062619783,
-0.0288397688,
0.0287158024,
0.014180447,
0.011882782,
-0.0067152167,
0.0062909778,
0.0053203977,
-0.0426328741,
-0.0246477593,
-0.0467514992,
-0.0139092673,
-0.0011096215,
-0.0184897855,
-0.0177903436,
0.0001257359,
-0.0516579524,
-0.0140565503,
-0.0078478009,
-0.0492358208,
0.0136779025,
0.0352288075,
0.0668527558,
0.034512423,
-0.0137971388,
0.0337937623,
-0.0221705604,
-0.0309624504,
0.0080819502,
0.006617547,
0.0184489097,
0.0074827285,
0.0263963751,
0.0527871326,
0.0070803119,
-0.0350792035,
0.0031133168,
-0.02348217,
0.0279804766,
-0.0264713913,
0.0127906008,
0.0230140872,
0.0228860322,
-0.0555035621,
-0.0075434772,
0.0457920693,
0.0114354938,
-0.0690213218,
-0.0089559844,
-0.0469161794,
-0.0000055058,
0.0118839443,
0.0459401272,
-0.1163316518,
0.0269581974,
0.0054771556,
0.0420539975,
-0.0368229598,
-0.0351223573,
-0.053362567,
-0.073094219,
0.0798875019,
0.0066085695,
-0.0144006303,
-0.0136361048,
-0.0859918743,
0.0140590295,
-0.0316403955,
-0.0072876099,
-0.0087917261,
0.0129290614,
0.0020207032,
-0.0155265005,
-0.024676118,
-0.013004533,
-0.0180592164,
-0.0214432329,
0.0473358035,
0.0395896211,
-0.0093274927,
-0.0199317746,
-0.0331260897,
-0.0118408473,
0.0489370748,
-0.0087663606,
-0.0046257684,
-0.0288716275,
0.0278660543,
-0.0325034335,
-0.0092602735,
0.0687713102,
-0.0176041126,
-0.0264114998,
0.0348082967,
0.069634676,
-0.0432508215,
0.0144743212,
-0.027602721,
-0.0293774419,
0.0377809927,
0.07565552,
-0.0000740371,
-0.0254755355,
-0.0493440256,
-0.0284311753,
0.0027792661,
-0.006138314,
-0.0316413119,
0.0232479721,
-0.0194793269,
-0.0477087162,
0.0023773368,
-0.0128037781,
0.0078079365,
0.0108504044,
0.0207576044,
0.0087740077,
0.0468118303,
-0.0038106134,
-0.0433293059,
-0.0076406673,
-0.097468175,
0.0284968857,
-0.0078965286,
-0.0061559533,
0.0069119567,
-0.027512975,
-0.0275218934,
0.0365069285,
0.0008005925,
-0.0728921667,
0.0565618835,
0.0718097761,
0.0279703084,
-0.0136253415,
-0.0231807586,
-0.0536635853,
0.1197323278,
0.0415534899,
-0.068120487,
0.0051339162,
-0.0010268064,
-0.0398701951,
-0.0028356519,
0.0243925452,
-0.0346687771,
0.0174231566,
0.0218317118,
-0.0108600529,
-0.0364018902,
-0.0468688309,
-0.0000459214,
0.0513918884,
-0.0070679579,
-0.013450115,
0.0437707938,
-0.0373231247,
0.0510566905,
-0.0379169397,
0.0055517699,
-0.0227347836,
-0.0053654336,
0.0150718587,
-0.0281055029,
0.0505956933,
-0.0137256887,
0.0356364697,
-0.0289668683,
0.0067043668,
0.0543526374,
0.0161884092,
0.0175514966,
0.0235237069,
0.0069867182,
-0.020146586,
0.0616308823,
-0.0423334762,
0.0369387455,
-0.0038377675,
0.0264642909,
-0.0070354948,
-0.0072530806,
-0.041307576,
0.0648054257,
-0.0422359966,
-0.0734753683,
0.0027021575,
0.025161501,
-0.0040014582,
0.0780603215,
-0.0066402638,
-0.0727618709,
-0.0089163436,
-0.021002952,
0.005611795,
0.0114624938,
-0.0463205799,
0.0056414818,
0.0352000557,
-0.0005354692,
-0.0015576323,
0.0496194288,
0.0279238988,
0.0516609736,
-0.0150115332,
-0.0069701546,
-0.0423682965,
-0.036355976,
-0.0373496339,
0.0115608508,
-0.0374184959,
-0.0393739603,
-0.0406279713,
-0.0410378389,
0.0060784919,
0.0116360495,
-0.0153746204,
-0.0086587518,
0.0160453711,
0.0438069776,
0.0063642892,
-0.0570536628,
-0.038372647,
-0.0075756591,
-0.0129443584,
-0.0462728404,
0.0124730011,
-6.638839445e-33,
0.0202984624,
-0.0302065555,
0.0117392605,
0.0202584136,
0.0610569082,
0.0068304092,
-0.0173375942,
-0.0094403466,
-0.0063500786,
0.007821436,
0.0130569935,
-0.0003171698,
0.0340467915,
0.0102161197,
0.00836604,
0.0496826582,
0.0116288457,
-0.0065613315,
0.0151657267,
-0.0007747172,
0.0483898036,
0.0202755108,
0.0430913083,
-0.1097251624,
0.0416836478,
-0.0463097841,
-0.0290923547,
0.0037597197,
-0.084517464,
0.0460976176,
-0.0303168241,
0.0276590884,
-0.0137011865,
-0.0647330657,
-0.0033525375,
0.0047419081,
-0.0245925542,
-0.0182729885,
0.0154437274,
-0.0165126622,
0.0013419358,
-0.0813294053,
0.0290893279,
-0.019990975,
-0.028645549,
0.0367553495,
0.0071121333,
-0.0145470696,
0.006814328,
0.018948039,
0.004216522,
0.0128610376,
-0.0082329502,
0.0526011027,
0.0752858445,
-0.0834045932,
-0.0211423542,
-0.0213876981,
-0.0219913144,
0.0636412948,
-0.0005634868,
-0.0152749615,
0.0481427759,
0.0019810945,
-0.0081362491,
0.0245288555,
0.0526147895,
-0.0241384115,
-0.0072999331,
-0.0247233883,
-0.0138198892,
0.0812082961,
0.0376482047,
0.0474245772,
-0.023339808,
-0.0229527932,
-0.0340999626,
-0.0132970968,
0.0365628563,
0.0032573321,
0.0585703403,
0.0079141948,
-0.0361977518,
0.0035827658,
-0.0126806339,
-0.0678097829,
-0.0453797579,
-0.0212138183,
-0.0209896117,
0.0007464845,
-0.0498106219,
0.0225165971,
0.0271816049,
-0.0540061183,
-0.0208013728,
0.0335428081,
0.0456250533,
-0.0085514793,
0.0078356387,
0.0221203659,
-0.0513753705,
-0.0013921872,
-0.020694321,
-0.0458973646,
0.0178262535,
-0.0033778283,
-0.0100483401,
0.0268042702,
-0.0462156795,
0.0082392283,
-0.0173749607,
0.0104354415,
0.0587498508,
-0.0043944218,
0.0102889538,
-0.0211178828,
0.0309617873,
0.0265058726,
0.0469928496,
0.0230995137,
0.028314786,
0.0631553531,
-0.0293065719,
-0.0098249242,
-0.0040352759,
0.0102041094,
-0.0315638892,
0.0208544005,
0.0514151901,
-0.0048608989,
0.0159123093,
-0.0217793584,
3.183e-7,
0.0334337465,
0.0383430161,
0.0229476504,
-0.0060719075,
0.0344692655,
0.0192176159,
0.0273632854,
0.0302255917,
-0.0448607542,
-0.0183897819,
-0.0471695215,
0.0291756392,
0.0555248559,
0.0300714411,
-0.0416133702,
-0.0298656933,
-0.0495800935,
0.0026648238,
-0.0966840088,
-0.0127744004,
0.0200748332,
0.0717506856,
0.0284893718,
-0.004464448,
-0.0366806537,
-0.0544865467,
-0.0196904186,
-0.0071855169,
0.0101571092,
0.0142338304,
-0.0053543416,
0.0621711425,
0.0124523928,
0.0156947449,
-0.0224217121,
0.0340804681,
-0.0817612633,
0.0749567375,
-0.0019789038,
0.0107489582,
0.0417469591,
-0.0411534905,
-0.0401296951,
-0.0141287297,
0.0390001275,
0.0081291897,
-0.0659040734,
-0.0262852963,
0.0008200139,
-0.0493476577,
0.0056844032,
-0.029893307,
0.0314336345,
0.0101023363,
-0.0103766704,
-0.0511183217,
-0.0009181705,
-0.0765018612,
-0.0062685176,
-0.0453682542,
-0.0422531217,
-0.0069502881,
-0.0213475879,
-0.0210192148,
0.0377969891,
-0.0253270585,
0.0646473467,
3.044529909e-34,
-0.0007401711,
-0.0030308596,
-0.0368900634,
0.0665315986,
0.0183238015,
-0.0163169019,
-0.0014249576,
0.0306082871,
0.0144963674,
-0.0691286698,
-0.0186981913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01772v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01772v1 | Disentangling the Roles of Target-Side Transfer and Regularization in Multilingual Machine Translation | 2024-02-01T10:55:03 | 2024-02-01T10:55:03 | Yan Meng, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multilingual Machine Translation (MMT) benefits from knowledge transfer
across different language pairs. However, improvements in one-to-many
translation compared to many-to-one translation are only marginal and sometimes
even negligible. This performance discrepancy raises the question of to what
extent positive transfer plays a role on the target-side for one-to-many MT. In
this paper, we conduct a large-scale study that varies the auxiliary target
side languages along two dimensions, i.e., linguistic similarity and corpus
size, to show the dynamic impact of knowledge transfer on the main language
pairs. We show that linguistically similar auxiliary target languages exhibit
strong ability to transfer positive knowledge. With an increasing size of
similar target languages, the positive transfer is further enhanced to benefit
the main language pairs. Meanwhile, we find distant auxiliary target languages
can also unexpectedly benefit main language pairs, even with minimal positive
transfer ability. Apart from transfer, we show distant auxiliary target
languages can act as a regularizer to benefit translation performance by
enhancing the generalization and model inference calibration. | Disentangling the Roles of Target-Side Transfer and Regularization in Multilingual Machine Translation: Multilingual Machine Translation (MMT) benefits from knowledge transfer
across different language pairs. However, improvements in one-to-many
translation compared to many-to-one translation are only marginal and sometimes
even negligible. This performance discrepancy raises the question of to what
extent positive transfer plays a role on the target-side for one-to-many MT. In
this paper, we conduct a large-scale study that varies the auxiliary target
side languages along two dimensions, i.e., linguistic similarity and corpus
size, to show the dynamic impact of knowledge transfer on the main language
pairs. We show that linguistically similar auxiliary target languages exhibit
strong ability to transfer positive knowledge. With an increasing size of
similar target languages, the positive transfer is further enhanced to benefit
the main language pairs. Meanwhile, we find distant auxiliary target languages
can also unexpectedly benefit main language pairs, even with minimal positive
transfer ability. Apart from transfer, we show distant auxiliary target
languages can act as a regularizer to benefit translation performance by
enhancing the generalization and model inference calibration. | [
0.0065206611,
0.0284542795,
-0.0277399272,
0.0248946175,
-0.0327106453,
0.004089863,
0.0277960561,
0.0167825352,
-0.0807050467,
0.0159143247,
-0.0511399843,
-0.0336050689,
0.0172629617,
-0.0114250006,
0.0599783808,
-0.0501656383,
0.0161510743,
-0.0253215972,
-0.0729220286,
-0.0044644955,
0.0083926572,
-0.0000590928,
0.0358806849,
-0.0009080036,
0.0064481408,
0.0544622391,
0.0215158239,
0.0517874844,
0.0634496063,
0.0091660768,
-0.0548789874,
0.0079597691,
0.0149306059,
0.0448421501,
0.0000019313,
-0.049965024,
-0.0586617626,
0.013166382,
0.0078621646,
-0.0098300083,
0.0609226413,
-0.1097375229,
0.029679494,
-0.0155997584,
0.0127727808,
-0.0097684553,
0.0846179873,
-0.0087162014,
0.0223474037,
0.0840516537,
-0.0384368785,
-0.0194108021,
-0.0004217437,
-0.0420777462,
-0.0049586361,
-0.0796673149,
-0.0083549907,
0.0273313411,
-0.04722514,
-0.0146397352,
-0.0140321413,
0.0609363019,
-0.0128576085,
0.0031829544,
-0.0023347191,
0.0003388349,
0.0019245285,
-0.0193953458,
0.0039754421,
0.0580887571,
-0.0354337581,
-0.0136479903,
-0.014406532,
-0.0046408856,
-0.0091690701,
0.0422774628,
-0.0592405014,
0.0002051379,
0.0007215121,
-0.0166132413,
0.0386111252,
0.0279596858,
0.0398913845,
-0.0214399751,
-0.04983503,
-0.0078847911,
0.054920353,
-0.0370455422,
0.0337919034,
0.0665455014,
0.0043762838,
-0.0168871544,
0.0529293083,
-0.0058128187,
0.0314205177,
0.0136364652,
-0.0301536396,
-0.0555815287,
-0.0228358209,
-0.0218582246,
0.0467174612,
0.05784012,
-0.0358142108,
0.0331898481,
-0.0372934081,
0.0084125111,
-0.0497864857,
0.0298956968,
-0.0720451549,
-0.0413727015,
-0.0526019372,
0.0255682115,
-0.0264379308,
-0.0005583938,
0.0164013039,
0.0405740626,
-0.0098334141,
0.0045512025,
0.0118571883,
-0.0375390276,
-0.017402526,
-0.0734725744,
-0.0794555619,
-0.0448550545,
0.0242657252,
0.08201278,
-0.0302662738,
-0.0045061912,
-0.0157933142,
-0.0444159955,
-0.0349962376,
0.0265698396,
0.0226528719,
-0.063815631,
-0.0084864246,
0.0973726809,
-0.0393992402,
-0.0065959846,
-0.0007556743,
0.0090302564,
-0.0017848936,
-0.0694098696,
0.005083371,
-0.0293179732,
0.0864466056,
0.0228410419,
0.0247777458,
-0.0437847376,
-0.0427048467,
-0.0410787985,
-0.0389554724,
0.0250386167,
0.0021162846,
0.0033755247,
0.0195525549,
-0.0314365923,
-0.0537755713,
0.0635123774,
0.0197849628,
-0.0168200359,
0.0436693765,
-0.0211249478,
-0.0423058942,
0.0563287176,
0.0204411093,
0.0493298769,
-0.0243800823,
0.0007431366,
0.0154992295,
0.0277397111,
0.0449570939,
0.0366635546,
-0.0359608382,
0.0318004824,
0.0677412748,
0.0215871707,
-0.0066621979,
0.0347169861,
0.0489131473,
-0.013822847,
-0.051645726,
0.0180249717,
0.0156508945,
0.0249377433,
-0.0220826827,
-0.0325420238,
0.0200090036,
0.0468978323,
-0.0095657147,
0.0295759439,
0.0129471989,
-0.0309416391,
0.0114005478,
-0.0427005515,
0.0811648592,
-0.0030776195,
-0.0389672108,
0.0450088233,
0.0143480552,
-0.0447261743,
0.0374263451,
-0.0106454305,
-0.0149699096,
0.0024712656,
-0.0094026728,
0.0198627952,
-0.0544980168,
-0.0054450198,
-0.0262904353,
0.0313449688,
0.0955600366,
0.0120038949,
0.0608997382,
-0.025879804,
-0.0170872286,
0.0071382578,
0.0045568706,
0.0783979297,
-0.0282898452,
0.0496342853,
0.0386142023,
-0.0465537235,
-0.0233937893,
0.0072265416,
-0.04989646,
0.0274814535,
0.0111689167,
0.0230610948,
0.0158765633,
-0.0000104996,
-0.0107494602,
-0.0137423901,
-0.021860037,
-0.0477845408,
-0.0271276217,
0.0646360591,
-0.021715777,
-0.0069548152,
0.0090523344,
-0.0205266904,
0.0225115381,
0.0307995919,
-0.0057673417,
-0.0350578427,
0.0365080163,
-0.0099217566,
0.0145753017,
-0.0108682672,
0.0412577689,
-0.0089600114,
0.0139293158,
-0.0141199166,
0.0146921715,
0.0352464952,
-0.0157613587,
-0.0047963345,
-0.0784832388,
0.0206598714,
-0.027941132,
-0.0103060408,
0.0261214022,
0.027258778,
0.0047200141,
0.0477164015,
-0.0174779091,
-0.0076968642,
0.0003335849,
-0.0273511577,
0.0150032267,
-0.0072645699,
0.0469676144,
0.0449326634,
0.0453004166,
0.027254153,
0.0218430553,
-0.0192363672,
0.0164523311,
0.0097565167,
0.0354942158,
0.0043148543,
0.0126498621,
0.0233452562,
-0.0234744735,
-0.0102803679,
0.0378095247,
0.0415110849,
0.0142140137,
-0.0480276905,
-0.0683385283,
0.0234127715,
-0.0688207224,
-0.017446233,
-0.0088834288,
-0.019527277,
-0.0256340466,
-0.0264784954,
0.0087773185,
0.0125765027,
-0.045183368,
-0.0358755589,
0.0208654944,
-0.0106574595,
-0.0501848124,
0.0107001942,
-0.0033889851,
-0.0419023149,
-0.0525531471,
-0.0535322279,
0.0145060085,
0.0687922835,
-0.0026545727,
-0.0502880402,
-0.0594812483,
-0.0224323981,
-0.0133976834,
-0.0148027157,
-0.0219935216,
0.0449069589,
0.0395299718,
0.0574543886,
-0.0181443989,
-0.0562431104,
0.0468036421,
-0.0120731611,
-0.0153979091,
-0.0183782578,
0.0033598153,
-0.0134695685,
0.043990735,
-0.0284381341,
0.026360102,
-0.0327553488,
0.0053521814,
-0.044713527,
0.0014534306,
0.0364682078,
0.0245259926,
0.047528211,
-0.0864427909,
-0.0101702129,
-0.0163062662,
-0.0161186159,
0.0049147406,
0.0019840419,
0.0107275434,
-0.0161956884,
0.0269835144,
-0.0264297444,
-0.042085737,
0.0102986451,
0.0273906309,
0.0310143586,
0.0041821068,
0.0069473512,
0.0098031899,
0.0276299417,
0.0010385974,
-0.0051964195,
-0.0117816441,
-0.0805804506,
0.0108862156,
-0.0001332278,
-0.0063140141,
-0.027109066,
-0.0009181902,
-0.0390856154,
0.0573716164,
0.0012145641,
-0.0629279688,
-0.0236135572,
0.0859264806,
-0.0102567365,
0.0085966941,
0.0558003411,
-0.0066194604,
-0.033535134,
0.0048338771,
-0.0273724683,
0.0296147764,
0.0044962033,
0.0397148244,
-0.0646900162,
-0.0237998031,
0.0044564228,
0.009131833,
0.0368122496,
0.0026420825,
-0.0425373651,
-0.0925680324,
-0.0301333908,
0.0220817365,
-0.0959110707,
-0.0350141451,
-0.0061061466,
-0.0262992177,
-0.0272848699,
0.0036657951,
-0.005058967,
0.0239468422,
-0.0045492016,
0.0030714869,
0.0303833671,
-0.0345520414,
-0.0055919392,
-0.0635820925,
0.0118688345,
0.0492943004,
0.0378648899,
-0.0284926146,
-0.0022421649,
0.0386191197,
0.0259782597,
0.0094079832,
-0.0100743081,
0.0320174024,
0.0174347889,
-0.0123256138,
0.0562013648,
-0.0089408606,
0.0009076946,
0.0316375606,
0.0319775566,
0.0606982894,
0.0320256241,
-0.0394605659,
0.0390886478,
-0.0239055939,
-0.0226061977,
0.0413018987,
-0.0225676484,
-0.0442049205,
0.024600856,
-0.0060007474,
-0.0222955439,
-0.0555804297,
0.0051293462,
-0.0086262096,
-0.0789141878,
-0.090982452,
-0.0836991668,
-0.0317087881,
0.0166395251,
0.0465016775,
0.0309521556,
0.0045981053,
-0.0162325092,
-0.0006275031,
0.0392044708,
0.0283165574,
-0.0460554138,
0.0256922375,
0.0007525479,
-0.0168081932,
-0.0012682666,
-0.0446349904,
0.0080294739,
-0.0032532029,
-0.1080022752,
-0.0619213656,
-0.07168632,
0.0539233945,
0.0128814038,
0.0378408022,
0.0239147414,
-0.0224630628,
-0.0542205274,
-0.0154679334,
-0.0206868853,
-0.0068365675,
0.0453200825,
-0.0291769356,
0.0023601188,
0.0529747084,
-0.0320584588,
0.0050167684,
0.0318783298,
0.0360316411,
-0.0120821241,
-0.0224180054,
0.0050164755,
0.0342205502,
0.0268993452,
-0.0361952148,
-0.0495983176,
-0.0263344627,
0.0042964588,
-0.0169369131,
-0.0002623666,
-0.0498424135,
-0.0220484175,
0.0755488724,
0.0265987869,
0.0060853395,
-0.044872053,
-0.0159340482,
0.0067760213,
-0.0242627356,
-0.0052822023,
-0.0100197783,
0.0508245826,
0.0394966193,
0.0419660881,
-0.014507439,
-0.0051620482,
-0.0024266497,
0.0110723162,
-0.0484097712,
0.0154011846,
-0.0015286814,
0.0500142016,
0.0272538625,
-0.0062766066,
-0.0280544776,
-0.01218036,
0.0214560218,
-0.0109323245,
0.0803141072,
0.0102214394,
0.1352738291,
0.0170679316,
-0.004933971,
-0.0149876121,
0.0629896894,
-0.0182747487,
-0.0319703408,
0.007426782,
-0.0318934731,
0.0097032003,
0.028254563,
0.0791651234,
-0.0450630039,
0.0255579781,
-0.0535745993,
-0.0063232593,
-0.0002491433,
0.0035559346,
0.0498100556,
-0.0081899092,
0.0073425276,
0.0167314764,
-0.0226192828,
-0.0619041994,
0.0091705071,
-0.0578996353,
0.0128086535,
0.0119159063,
-0.0066095609,
0.0995882228,
-0.061125651,
-0.0131536452,
-0.045608744,
-0.0171054676,
0.0127530955,
0.0271921623,
0.0119382031,
-6.075471288e-33,
-0.0075339004,
0.0325987525,
0.002695627,
-0.0325583182,
-0.0149646485,
-0.0350784138,
-0.0102909468,
-0.0089926142,
-0.0018754321,
0.0058591235,
-0.0033156371,
-0.0200449806,
0.019573018,
-0.0013350765,
0.0245574322,
0.0065436764,
0.0381371267,
0.0404818282,
-0.011206598,
0.0220754053,
0.0370996892,
0.0327272043,
0.1292907745,
-0.0542122908,
0.0692528114,
-0.0025914088,
0.0126203438,
-0.0080609526,
0.0319718719,
-0.0105083939,
0.028219061,
0.0068184338,
0.0212606657,
-0.0451168455,
-0.0261603985,
-0.0558892451,
-0.0416281335,
-0.0091033401,
0.0494909734,
0.0179649256,
0.035746105,
-0.078358531,
0.0169195198,
-0.0529962741,
0.0077889259,
-0.0435119011,
0.0149175487,
-0.0362107642,
-0.0290573966,
-0.012275896,
-0.084121123,
0.0304476898,
-0.0062861876,
0.0232564937,
0.0079155788,
0.0850086212,
-0.006909559,
-0.0150093464,
-0.0173778683,
0.030085545,
-0.029954195,
0.0236936994,
0.0784716383,
0.0042132065,
-0.0361365899,
-0.0181088448,
0.0171174817,
0.0025028407,
0.0570485182,
0.0351716131,
0.019968668,
-0.0014642037,
0.0469878875,
0.0459916033,
0.0418079793,
-0.0224450398,
-0.0393463373,
0.0233407523,
-0.0008734177,
-0.0085206302,
0.0151614165,
0.033354152,
-0.0025097479,
-0.0273266323,
-0.031603083,
-0.0343727283,
-0.0074578291,
-0.0455052704,
0.0003450068,
0.0002381895,
-0.0105884625,
0.0352259651,
0.111319989,
-0.0086606024,
-0.0139425779,
0.0115521392,
-0.0450369269,
0.0030735715,
-0.0296762455,
0.008882151,
-0.0469666906,
-0.0739831403,
-0.0105490647,
-0.0032039629,
0.0160519313,
-0.0120255947,
0.0481947027,
0.0203546733,
-0.0510489233,
-0.0048332205,
-0.0460016392,
-0.0237349924,
0.0022469843,
0.0291045122,
0.0055022244,
0.0033077933,
-0.0168901514,
0.0339051597,
0.0509541295,
-0.0222532675,
-0.021917047,
0.0106144063,
0.0212660823,
0.0167043582,
-0.0524757393,
0.0023897935,
-0.0106025068,
-0.0548969209,
0.0559163578,
-0.0425838828,
-0.0559407808,
-0.0371418186,
2.729e-7,
0.0596529841,
0.0177557506,
-0.0052325139,
0.0053920662,
-0.0132987741,
0.0161793418,
-0.0552107841,
0.0367932506,
0.0184765607,
0.0753972903,
0.0176253915,
0.0268414039,
0.0797622725,
0.0522097014,
-0.0400993228,
-0.0599388704,
0.0134964427,
0.0321691819,
-0.0147281047,
0.0005835824,
0.0156898368,
0.0637931675,
0.0046068067,
-0.0082272235,
0.0024521477,
-0.0552263372,
0.0863246545,
-0.0418231748,
-0.012873848,
0.0243113618,
0.0542150661,
-0.0278554168,
-0.0477565415,
0.0157284364,
-0.0197420083,
0.0191576239,
0.0612063929,
0.0810538754,
-0.0006629009,
0.0030427878,
0.0077778171,
-0.0283306446,
-0.0318844207,
-0.0109707667,
0.032294292,
-0.0426459834,
-0.0081731901,
0.0081176963,
-0.0079191485,
0.0302977134,
0.0165471006,
-0.0344191827,
-0.0254283324,
0.0419030376,
0.0724854916,
0.0206415523,
-0.0618465431,
-0.0074305236,
-0.024473466,
0.0268518459,
-0.0060545979,
-0.0635984316,
0.0044112126,
-0.0237648953,
0.0221598707,
-0.0150846858,
-0.0024176827,
2.140883551e-34,
0.0423205905,
0.0058369162,
0.0041428623,
-0.035735026,
0.0480002388,
-0.0584828258,
-0.028907435,
0.0222579762,
-0.0090614865,
-0.0267238356,
-0.0136640416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00474v1 | SA-MDKIF: A Scalable and Adaptable Medical Domain Knowledge Injection Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T10:26:27 | 2024-02-01T10:26:27 | Tianhan Xu, Zhe Hu, Ling Chen, Bin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional
performance in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their
effective application in the medical domain is hampered by a lack of medical
domain knowledge. In this study, we present SA-MDKIF, a scalable and adaptable
framework that aims to inject medical knowledge into general-purpose LLMs
through instruction tuning, thereby enabling adaptability for various
downstream tasks. SA-MDKIF consists of two stages: skill training and skill
adaptation. In the first stage, we define 12 basic medical skills and use
AdaLoRA to train these skills based on uniformly formatted instructional
datasets that we have constructed. In the next stage, we train the skill router
using task-specific downstream data and use this router to integrate the
acquired skills with LLMs during inference. Experimental results on 9 different
medical tasks show that SA-MDKIF improves performance by 10-20% compared to the
original LLMs. Notably, this improvement is particularly pronounced for unseen
medical tasks, showing an improvement of up to 30%. | SA-MDKIF: A Scalable and Adaptable Medical Domain Knowledge Injection Framework for Large Language Models: Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional
performance in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their
effective application in the medical domain is hampered by a lack of medical
domain knowledge. In this study, we present SA-MDKIF, a scalable and adaptable
framework that aims to inject medical knowledge into general-purpose LLMs
through instruction tuning, thereby enabling adaptability for various
downstream tasks. SA-MDKIF consists of two stages: skill training and skill
adaptation. In the first stage, we define 12 basic medical skills and use
AdaLoRA to train these skills based on uniformly formatted instructional
datasets that we have constructed. In the next stage, we train the skill router
using task-specific downstream data and use this router to integrate the
acquired skills with LLMs during inference. Experimental results on 9 different
medical tasks show that SA-MDKIF improves performance by 10-20% compared to the
original LLMs. Notably, this improvement is particularly pronounced for unseen
medical tasks, showing an improvement of up to 30%. | [
0.0618556105,
0.0453624353,
0.0074769906,
-0.0148047078,
-0.0126361633,
0.0400580429,
0.0221928079,
0.0088957064,
0.034123715,
-0.0399646237,
-0.0297787879,
-0.0308477674,
-0.0028940765,
0.025028307,
0.0385817401,
-0.0388633609,
0.0283423867,
-0.012119784,
-0.0013112637,
0.0137727689,
-0.0269878265,
-0.0042340951,
-0.0505665615,
0.0360664949,
0.0267967544,
-0.0046044267,
0.0355237089,
-0.0190663468,
0.0047813826,
-0.0498360395,
-0.0073564681,
0.0211320799,
0.0217618737,
-0.0184332822,
0.0000020559,
-0.0479625165,
0.0083496189,
0.0370255038,
-0.0423505381,
-0.0316566527,
0.0416118316,
-0.0590454713,
0.000285772,
0.03665784,
-0.0369645655,
-0.0455755033,
0.0280644838,
0.0546505153,
0.057105992,
0.0991207138,
-0.0037288435,
-0.0148670105,
0.0638164654,
-0.0288803242,
0.0115262568,
-0.0391225144,
0.0617420971,
0.0208694078,
0.0318013392,
0.006068151,
0.011401711,
0.055953525,
-0.0155656431,
0.0151889734,
0.0349129662,
0.0418169163,
-0.0058774534,
-0.0043112524,
-0.0139200939,
0.0170409009,
-0.0193383973,
-0.0107216416,
0.0059244563,
-0.0007231859,
-0.0213983692,
0.0301765036,
-0.0631523952,
-0.0012292808,
-0.0118181594,
-0.0067460923,
0.022824524,
-0.0311122779,
0.0392481014,
0.0201265104,
-0.0127588855,
0.0031476985,
0.0227825884,
-0.0336692259,
0.0218207091,
-0.0128413383,
-0.0200820379,
-0.0235136859,
0.0380105451,
0.0599149093,
-0.0505245589,
0.0246158931,
-0.0521665551,
-0.0291313604,
0.0553691611,
-0.0634936094,
0.0535999276,
0.0062872549,
-0.00026536,
0.059937112,
-0.03713236,
0.0021729486,
-0.0424356833,
0.0348203853,
-0.0403454304,
-0.0043190345,
-0.0715147704,
-0.023903558,
0.0067716972,
-0.0014981667,
-0.0371966064,
-0.0142156873,
-0.0550569668,
0.0203297846,
0.0008425039,
-0.0150011545,
0.0383970737,
0.025075309,
-0.0318898559,
-0.0009435694,
-0.0197774824,
0.0397298932,
0.0260380637,
0.0363587998,
-0.0382068492,
-0.0320919454,
-0.0073523484,
0.0073046521,
0.0212653894,
-0.0207223035,
0.0453811549,
0.0695555955,
-0.0026091165,
-0.0136081167,
-0.0307767931,
-0.0185932592,
0.0014014723,
-0.0496582687,
0.0145911518,
-0.0581077784,
0.0268953089,
0.0163046326,
0.0117735844,
-0.0690951347,
0.0155149624,
0.0278676245,
-0.0772706568,
0.0923672989,
-0.0307402574,
0.0320407078,
0.0334468,
0.0286565013,
-0.0035635561,
0.0520622283,
0.0097940601,
-0.0627522618,
-0.0228706021,
-0.0305400193,
-0.0099883722,
0.0106828613,
0.0012466133,
-0.0392044149,
-0.0256755836,
0.0197168533,
0.0203412306,
0.0721847415,
-0.0126684252,
0.0404967368,
0.0130527001,
0.0292911809,
0.0271578841,
0.0531084687,
0.0519607291,
-0.0147962086,
0.0362439863,
-0.0075275409,
0.0220700074,
-0.0433171391,
-0.032107383,
-0.0055508385,
0.0346222296,
0.0024605594,
-0.0402746201,
0.0341577604,
-0.0267988872,
-0.0233281981,
-0.0390667804,
-0.0081558097,
-0.0381802507,
0.014710037,
0.0618851595,
0.0136320489,
-0.0231118109,
0.0594685152,
0.0846604779,
-0.01605401,
0.0094605144,
-0.0520065911,
-0.0440532416,
0.0776982307,
0.0690032467,
-0.0532726981,
-0.0686392635,
-0.0124172298,
0.0235234573,
0.0173917525,
0.0214623678,
-0.0196526088,
0.0109185781,
-0.0609995276,
-0.0013898571,
0.0554944612,
0.0270981342,
-0.021527078,
0.037882857,
0.0131930895,
-0.0131482091,
-0.0095278574,
-0.0218309574,
0.0667439252,
-0.0873080567,
-0.042793747,
0.000771492,
-0.0087651387,
0.0249785464,
0.0198390409,
-0.0143355262,
0.0224258602,
0.0394369438,
-0.0399173908,
-0.0188532695,
0.0125900488,
-0.0358565859,
-0.0313372388,
0.0316001587,
0.0035389818,
-0.0302898679,
-0.0130562223,
-0.0195850972,
-0.0204026587,
-0.0274943095,
-0.0191467404,
0.0287021361,
0.0050390926,
0.0301528685,
0.0206194185,
-0.0112055065,
-0.0471050628,
0.0343206413,
0.0108402474,
-0.0024026884,
0.0046693706,
-0.0087816166,
-0.0459748954,
-0.0056359824,
-0.007373102,
-0.0147991572,
-0.0012279766,
0.0286491569,
-0.0435040258,
0.0223983172,
-0.0283931028,
-0.0570064038,
-0.0972275138,
0.0101321246,
0.022484038,
0.0189502519,
0.0245199129,
0.0240959264,
-0.0145067899,
-0.0136690773,
-0.0282447375,
-0.028334491,
0.0067696697,
0.023729166,
0.0145042492,
0.0174343251,
0.0056176214,
0.0033377686,
0.0202139635,
-0.0509433672,
0.0008147873,
-0.0020372488,
0.01430362,
-0.0212613139,
0.019709751,
0.0075427387,
0.0198501125,
-0.0058862888,
-0.011458992,
-0.0058798534,
-0.0036697576,
0.0330270343,
0.0647802129,
-0.0205682218,
0.0213864688,
0.0315879658,
-0.0047274563,
-0.0047693676,
0.0186714418,
-0.0210218672,
-0.0070836665,
-0.053846918,
-0.0107799685,
-0.0070186509,
0.0844190344,
0.0059711239,
-0.0055687772,
-0.0207382292,
-0.0141609805,
-0.0419639647,
-0.0005789074,
-0.0313393772,
0.0179651361,
-0.050905589,
-0.008034897,
-0.0034856538,
-0.0297190063,
0.08026319,
-0.0231290199,
0.0252665877,
-0.0876049697,
-0.0521550104,
-0.0478005521,
0.0110802446,
0.0007433654,
0.0020818454,
-0.0071012676,
-0.0139299454,
-0.0038909269,
0.0487082377,
-0.0150367273,
-0.059517961,
0.0753056258,
-0.0464467965,
-0.0019104974,
-0.0011154525,
-0.0246651862,
-0.0570541732,
0.0176323708,
-0.0229186788,
0.0222514607,
0.0242688749,
-0.0014725125,
-0.0848722607,
0.0161670633,
0.006665186,
0.0753959194,
0.0066060447,
0.0004224532,
-0.016194405,
0.0209357049,
0.0185857676,
0.0077444846,
-0.034493383,
-0.0027982078,
0.0262550618,
0.0497900024,
0.0152347898,
-0.0149662588,
-0.0109806005,
0.0041507594,
0.0084676072,
-0.0514550507,
0.0220016781,
0.0289970171,
0.0386330001,
-0.0913481414,
-0.0028890062,
0.1124623567,
0.0400585942,
-0.0669989139,
0.0025637236,
0.0201184936,
-0.0158512145,
0.0234362558,
0.0320500769,
-0.0536586307,
-0.0524836816,
0.0024630188,
0.0362868346,
-0.0160721168,
-0.0275098998,
0.0045304326,
-0.0784357265,
0.0347858369,
0.0024588685,
-0.0354946405,
-0.0502617024,
-0.079809159,
0.0063694729,
-0.0181882735,
0.0234569944,
-0.0164503437,
-0.0521451496,
-0.0096019302,
0.0438535549,
-0.0394857973,
-0.1387481093,
-0.0055376603,
-0.031167224,
0.1021647155,
0.0250862986,
0.0129686277,
-0.0069807707,
0.0081727672,
0.0245745741,
0.0297535583,
0.0183450934,
-0.0193771347,
0.0832945406,
-0.0108474158,
-0.0067152451,
-0.0343664512,
0.0361277796,
-0.049945198,
-0.0339235514,
0.0084609361,
0.0997427255,
-0.0142201595,
0.0069969743,
-0.0318443552,
-0.0249488074,
0.0084094526,
0.0642953664,
-0.0137439566,
-0.0156779457,
0.002584938,
0.0176960118,
0.0011843833,
0.0102357958,
-0.0497210696,
0.0479716696,
-0.0594190806,
-0.0252887513,
-0.0405680463,
-0.021840265,
0.0764122084,
0.0082761003,
0.0331092849,
0.052460283,
0.0270937569,
-0.0030076536,
-0.0945065171,
0.0478533022,
-0.0038916552,
0.0269063953,
-0.0677924082,
-0.0663058087,
0.0614868775,
-0.021500906,
-0.0212863255,
0.0244421493,
-0.0426610336,
-0.0385078117,
-0.0121789966,
0.0425710902,
0.0198777765,
0.0478696786,
-0.0228866022,
-0.0215991382,
0.0392945334,
0.0421284698,
-0.0820433944,
-0.0110291317,
-0.0099891368,
-0.0296709072,
0.0147877978,
0.0091509838,
0.0056527168,
0.0142710963,
0.0142721133,
0.0412015095,
0.0142094139,
0.0109184328,
0.0147883752,
0.0318425149,
0.0406772606,
0.0049653375,
-0.0023639177,
-0.0378082432,
0.0335008986,
-0.0209403895,
0.0047918851,
-0.0318878479,
-0.0065499176,
0.0472644605,
0.0115002086,
-0.0067893188,
0.008601536,
-0.020525055,
-0.0303715579,
-0.0493956991,
0.0678182021,
0.009232155,
0.0030451531,
0.0615174621,
0.003828116,
0.0058953143,
-0.010062729,
-0.0020336141,
0.017186949,
-0.0161746554,
0.0517923385,
-0.0194440931,
0.0199195817,
-0.018886799,
0.0313822962,
-0.0488641597,
-0.0343514532,
-0.0047400659,
0.0502300896,
0.0392356142,
-0.0365050174,
0.0474868864,
-0.0294759013,
-0.0024858536,
-0.0074399849,
0.0005041994,
-0.0402991995,
0.0342550054,
0.0606533214,
0.02023945,
0.0166524723,
-0.0226008724,
0.0913790911,
0.0157989096,
0.0840361416,
-0.0157628972,
-0.0544281341,
-0.0466480106,
-0.039680697,
0.0706169531,
0.010654931,
-0.0859095603,
0.0321322493,
-0.0449652299,
-0.0697560236,
-0.0157949161,
-0.0392695181,
-0.0319162682,
-0.025776701,
0.0432134308,
0.0195057783,
0.0053348155,
-0.0269542672,
-0.0215103794,
0.0450524651,
-0.0151076103,
-0.0280249733,
0.0525604002,
-6.2159267e-33,
-0.0031902869,
-0.013006866,
0.0579771474,
-0.0148053803,
-0.0110537484,
0.0377222151,
-0.007648346,
-0.0086539546,
-0.0061268816,
0.0301141664,
-0.0141738197,
-0.0114492755,
0.0139561575,
0.0307796951,
0.0207964219,
-0.0011479246,
0.0130305849,
0.0180936847,
0.0132302837,
0.0026469,
-0.0178285837,
0.0595537089,
0.0500640012,
-0.0622587688,
-0.0199458599,
0.0220772736,
0.0356999598,
0.0100782886,
-0.011393954,
0.0630558133,
-0.0410115905,
0.0326294713,
0.0468978919,
-0.0359023809,
-0.0065903086,
0.0066600824,
-0.0769406781,
0.0047851685,
0.0396405347,
-0.0013492361,
-0.0294269603,
-0.034422785,
0.0503781848,
-0.0022533885,
-0.0081578605,
-0.0093097109,
0.0231867041,
-0.0561421663,
-0.0184056163,
-0.0019551355,
-0.0483908877,
0.0570821241,
0.0146862091,
-0.0226601679,
-0.006229518,
-0.0463035181,
-0.0191790983,
-0.0062769083,
-0.0348221771,
-0.0090989098,
0.0347506851,
0.0594396777,
0.0089206323,
-0.013155546,
-0.0084388349,
0.0363336802,
0.0212225299,
-0.0404717736,
-0.0109916916,
0.0020683666,
-0.0237372182,
0.0500820391,
0.0226700734,
-0.0054928409,
0.0175939184,
-0.0147552192,
-0.0810355619,
0.0163756143,
-0.0358024463,
0.0781494081,
0.0100618359,
0.0056909407,
-0.0582683869,
-0.0044544926,
-0.0199065804,
0.0234082863,
-0.0249796156,
-0.0239389595,
0.0442351475,
0.018212311,
-0.0108053368,
0.0293863714,
-0.0027856014,
-0.0364042856,
0.0191650577,
-0.0064119459,
0.0365270302,
0.01705469,
-0.0523435287,
0.0085832188,
-0.0918256789,
-0.0367921442,
0.0262637883,
-0.0226506572,
0.0323864296,
-0.0020760554,
0.0306886509,
-0.0121621694,
-0.0863367692,
-0.0270896349,
-0.016382141,
-0.0105525916,
0.0261583533,
0.0684375465,
0.0414455384,
0.0292721577,
-0.0069946083,
0.0414737947,
0.0062135467,
-0.0387161337,
-0.0393753275,
-0.0236072913,
0.0068978071,
-0.0230391268,
-0.0530958436,
0.0040644631,
-0.0439253263,
0.001899622,
0.0077421083,
-0.0638635308,
0.0004109738,
-0.010767105,
2.841e-7,
0.0881617516,
0.0790544897,
-0.0210549608,
0.0007127015,
0.0260082725,
-0.0086381491,
-0.035177283,
0.003995961,
0.009643361,
0.020522505,
0.0040054969,
0.0452361256,
0.0306063108,
0.0241310187,
-0.0868454501,
-0.026282791,
-0.0264747739,
-0.016476227,
-0.0239042845,
-0.0395702533,
0.0105562843,
0.0899071991,
-0.0243952181,
-0.0431861021,
0.0068541998,
-0.0363505632,
0.029766893,
0.0000563613,
-0.011669999,
0.0363960043,
-0.0086790062,
0.0192620698,
0.0223895125,
0.0703409463,
-0.0397246182,
-0.009395198,
-0.0123806093,
0.1075272635,
-0.0644099638,
0.0475055836,
0.0273124035,
0.0021426915,
0.0028771877,
-0.0410873331,
0.0525812544,
-0.064914979,
-0.0557629727,
-0.0284916405,
-0.0041212412,
-0.0193784516,
0.0263883118,
-0.0022368578,
-0.0241977535,
0.012874282,
0.0385300182,
0.0012775668,
-0.0608044676,
-0.0738179609,
-0.0366613232,
0.0284363776,
-0.0367079005,
-0.045375023,
0.0098256385,
-0.0292855017,
0.0259037539,
-0.0755876303,
0.0261880141,
2.826364816e-34,
0.0129646873,
0.0308521912,
0.0128065627,
0.051807981,
0.0266883727,
-0.0204714611,
0.0050575272,
0.0402944535,
0.0119931772,
-0.0884625167,
0.0018614496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00453v2 | Instruction Makes a Difference | 2024-02-01T09:43:30 | 2024-06-13T13:28:37 | Tosin Adewumi, Nudrat Habib, Lama Alkhaled, Elisa Barney | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce Instruction Document Visual Question Answering (iDocVQA) dataset
and Large Language Document (LLaDoc) model, for training Language-Vision (LV)
models for document analysis and predictions on document images, respectively.
Usually, deep neural networks for the DocVQA task are trained on datasets
lacking instructions. We show that using instruction-following datasets
improves performance. We compare performance across document-related datasets
using the recent state-of-the-art (SotA) Large Language and Vision Assistant
(LLaVA)1.5 as the base model. We also evaluate the performance of the derived
models for object hallucination using the Polling-based Object Probing
Evaluation (POPE) dataset. The results show that instruction-tuning performance
ranges from 11X to 32X of zero-shot performance and from 0.1% to 4.2% over
non-instruction (traditional task) finetuning. Despite the gains, these still
fall short of human performance (94.36%), implying there's much room for
improvement. | Instruction Makes a Difference: We introduce Instruction Document Visual Question Answering (iDocVQA) dataset
and Large Language Document (LLaDoc) model, for training Language-Vision (LV)
models for document analysis and predictions on document images, respectively.
Usually, deep neural networks for the DocVQA task are trained on datasets
lacking instructions. We show that using instruction-following datasets
improves performance. We compare performance across document-related datasets
using the recent state-of-the-art (SotA) Large Language and Vision Assistant
(LLaVA)1.5 as the base model. We also evaluate the performance of the derived
models for object hallucination using the Polling-based Object Probing
Evaluation (POPE) dataset. The results show that instruction-tuning performance
ranges from 11X to 32X of zero-shot performance and from 0.1% to 4.2% over
non-instruction (traditional task) finetuning. Despite the gains, these still
fall short of human performance (94.36%), implying there's much room for
improvement. | [
0.000030334,
0.0623086877,
0.0249753706,
0.0626955032,
-0.0034475066,
0.0274737831,
0.015662156,
-0.0099184923,
0.006421091,
-0.0406244434,
-0.0332456753,
-0.04448184,
-0.0018823913,
-0.0090211034,
0.004293134,
-0.0372442566,
0.048328273,
-0.051686462,
-0.0377164707,
0.0080733541,
-0.0028266038,
0.0107817948,
-0.0227425117,
-0.004765051,
-0.0188489743,
-0.0576224439,
-0.0331611522,
0.0081127165,
0.0063760183,
0.0100081507,
0.0273813158,
0.0594028607,
0.0380630754,
0.0365546383,
0.0000019993,
-0.0255230907,
0.0176714938,
0.004676796,
-0.0315797366,
-0.0075353608,
0.0406891853,
-0.0505222194,
-0.0100467037,
-0.0190479327,
-0.0132475328,
-0.0214201901,
0.0393594652,
0.0568670034,
0.0550778843,
0.062288247,
-0.0303790253,
-0.0330097415,
0.0697768405,
-0.0057287514,
0.0625621825,
-0.0465013385,
0.0024070598,
0.0110302363,
-0.0069408538,
0.0165986456,
-0.0134582873,
0.0261418987,
0.0736146495,
-0.0195014179,
-0.0067957798,
0.0297729485,
-0.0519597568,
-0.0216541979,
-0.0108022764,
0.0910333246,
-0.0271109436,
0.0072593624,
-0.0326964445,
0.0065873521,
0.0058073024,
-0.0219258498,
-0.0435370058,
0.012119594,
-0.0136014391,
0.0097341808,
0.0212204214,
-0.0309444722,
0.008246162,
0.0248715207,
-0.0134535907,
0.0224266462,
0.0111413337,
-0.0159092695,
0.0434850119,
0.0171527416,
-0.0443205833,
-0.0336245485,
-0.0053689727,
0.0509168841,
-0.0247941222,
-0.0108286617,
-0.0508450978,
-0.0310337842,
0.0134018445,
-0.0497001298,
0.0599043071,
0.0007732016,
-0.0901564136,
0.0816980153,
-0.0691970959,
0.0711680725,
-0.0329354592,
0.0846102983,
-0.0279916879,
0.010639715,
-0.0157039873,
0.0037915779,
-0.0428290479,
0.0082393577,
-0.030300051,
-0.0406778976,
0.0126206819,
0.0037083924,
-0.0034003998,
0.0165028498,
-0.0146293296,
0.0446280874,
-0.0321628712,
-0.0397271626,
-0.0174818486,
0.0110421386,
-0.0257693883,
0.0201449003,
-0.0142796244,
-0.0596951954,
-0.0210963897,
0.0244503394,
0.0153811909,
0.0043699811,
0.0359003395,
0.0395400748,
-0.0382232778,
-0.0281607751,
-0.0247070193,
-0.0105344383,
0.0337172672,
-0.0604372658,
0.0706200153,
-0.064239271,
0.0349047966,
-0.01866813,
-0.0042238766,
-0.0097030299,
-0.0018400378,
0.0370890275,
0.0006661476,
0.0837468281,
-0.0203065686,
-0.0323936157,
0.0158711635,
0.0346133113,
0.0167126209,
0.0494589917,
-0.0087904874,
0.0359959155,
0.0185216703,
-0.0028841663,
0.0474138446,
0.0379058421,
-0.024541961,
0.0125946421,
-0.0013520366,
0.0149858221,
-0.0137066664,
0.0107997432,
0.0365816988,
0.0278774016,
-0.0126083009,
-0.0661390498,
0.0308403689,
0.0436237119,
-0.0132401502,
-0.0198061448,
-0.0024126614,
0.0200295113,
0.0250090063,
0.024841059,
-0.0675237477,
0.0440410972,
0.0403895192,
0.0032202832,
-0.0169341601,
-0.0452487096,
-0.0572603568,
-0.0285744108,
-0.0049752709,
-0.0082369549,
0.0051942687,
0.0235230029,
0.0349417739,
0.0266943723,
-0.0819731876,
-0.0086007565,
0.0018536309,
-0.0011529323,
-0.0339983553,
-0.0585108697,
0.0524837859,
0.0844940096,
0.044408299,
-0.0433254093,
-0.0142946197,
0.0017355466,
0.0862292573,
0.057317961,
0.0462245047,
0.0077341814,
0.052649539,
-0.0596272945,
-0.0110157812,
-0.04583361,
0.0022826814,
0.0354891717,
0.0065971143,
0.0032892986,
0.0145690385,
-0.0283776801,
-0.0380911753,
0.0581263751,
0.0226271227,
-0.0488778427,
-0.0263195373,
0.0166637804,
-0.0076042446,
-0.0067102853,
-0.0000251833,
-0.0112617863,
0.01821726,
-0.0367938988,
0.0395796858,
-0.0422933362,
-0.0443205498,
-0.0032112538,
0.0153846983,
-0.0284346361,
-0.0003777196,
0.0369342119,
-0.0381388962,
-0.0261257943,
-0.0092107216,
-0.0366693847,
-0.0135601349,
-0.0296466723,
-0.0062631662,
0.0106628649,
0.0505864695,
-0.0098699788,
0.0343577862,
-0.0232355632,
0.025495965,
0.0435329527,
0.0481326096,
0.0331926085,
-0.0135921398,
0.0092596142,
-0.0148558244,
0.0023462761,
-0.0096977549,
-0.0264872387,
0.0219544787,
-0.0680361241,
-0.0060267225,
-0.0750752911,
0.0135901524,
-0.0289982352,
0.0101398826,
0.02512905,
-0.01567531,
-0.0012961918,
-0.0462233126,
-0.0521036685,
0.0236816593,
-0.0139718093,
0.0340278447,
0.0137555264,
-0.0186011456,
0.0030841138,
-0.0354715921,
-0.0301876217,
0.0022553899,
0.0084278965,
0.0080642309,
-0.0034246759,
-0.0543848053,
0.0432685763,
0.0061793057,
0.0615394711,
-0.0189202167,
-0.0517003573,
0.0292548425,
-0.0352906771,
0.0334304161,
0.1402087659,
-0.030941816,
0.0311866123,
0.0246444307,
-0.0076399012,
-0.0303208232,
-0.0130043132,
0.0342387743,
0.0042448221,
0.0016848643,
-0.0151154092,
-0.0354031138,
0.0359050296,
-0.013289622,
0.0259743277,
-0.0322707184,
0.0040109702,
-0.0108896671,
-0.0345575139,
-0.0323328823,
0.0168261901,
0.0115787638,
0.0306320339,
-0.0416240878,
-0.0439708494,
0.0418617688,
-0.0224855803,
-0.032504525,
-0.010994954,
0.0394937992,
0.0017097333,
0.0298448149,
0.0555744655,
-0.0063938699,
-0.0826578885,
-0.0295895711,
-0.0634875,
0.0031547369,
-0.0264532454,
-0.0376564227,
0.0083148032,
-0.033292152,
0.0067913556,
-0.0519291461,
-0.0072081913,
-0.0416436233,
-0.0186533313,
-0.0008560655,
0.0183253139,
-0.0208219569,
-0.0053398176,
-0.0409528837,
0.0093544861,
0.0206784289,
0.0761856139,
-0.0307365507,
-0.0250521619,
-0.0384858213,
0.0582145341,
0.0713904575,
0.004775601,
0.0171752796,
-0.0448856466,
0.0526701659,
0.063045837,
0.0377782583,
0.0244102385,
-0.0583776347,
0.0237860586,
0.0025361446,
0.0220114402,
-0.0015541926,
0.0058472427,
0.0518071055,
-0.1082905456,
-0.024175819,
0.0732173324,
0.0314261839,
-0.0555140711,
-0.0413744934,
-0.0197674688,
0.0235036071,
0.0130560854,
0.0324368812,
-0.1001546532,
-0.0398821533,
-0.0121568376,
0.011213731,
0.0199210756,
-0.013967949,
-0.0027593768,
-0.0556858182,
0.0776948184,
-0.0193790123,
0.01087905,
-0.0392047018,
-0.0248142015,
0.0003587727,
0.0310542993,
0.0168881472,
-0.0213409737,
0.0125328116,
-0.035296604,
0.0052650119,
0.0257948507,
-0.004340508,
0.0475358181,
-0.0171521883,
-0.0279531106,
0.0903347805,
0.0047950717,
0.0074639288,
-0.0462737978,
0.0395445824,
-0.0212057885,
0.0038041414,
0.0340921059,
0.076685071,
-0.0060009286,
-0.033203505,
-0.0031707948,
0.0646449849,
-0.0555299819,
-0.0012000561,
-0.0284308549,
-0.003978265,
-0.0233221315,
-0.0122875683,
-0.035574317,
-0.0221378691,
-0.0220692065,
0.0403244346,
0.0280599017,
-0.0343940593,
-0.0584359355,
-0.0076488764,
0.0364471152,
-0.0825245306,
0.0050794263,
0.0290054809,
0.0065578194,
-0.006593239,
-0.049021475,
-0.0634209886,
0.0524086393,
0.0200445335,
-0.0124510387,
-0.0457030199,
-0.0110541144,
-0.0118897511,
-0.0436106659,
0.0598983616,
-0.0229611322,
0.0274274591,
-0.0654288232,
-0.0132411467,
0.0337835141,
0.00744844,
-0.0028386852,
0.0200694911,
-0.1211457551,
-0.0261724815,
0.0246078167,
0.0402307473,
0.0085176136,
0.0505364351,
-0.0270869303,
-0.0607522614,
0.0127925966,
0.024029471,
-0.0284048729,
0.0089390073,
0.0136062456,
-0.0530843884,
0.0067058606,
0.0201235004,
-0.0442625619,
0.0271994751,
0.0200572517,
-0.047545217,
-0.0190330017,
0.0289162043,
0.0045307726,
-0.0218604878,
-0.0283501595,
0.0128521072,
0.0354826562,
-0.0192053542,
0.0341763869,
0.0210800245,
-0.0084132208,
-0.0357236341,
-0.0108530931,
0.0189450271,
-0.0475953668,
-0.0158550385,
0.0262865052,
0.0135376034,
0.0044351113,
-0.0402919725,
0.0063522593,
0.0311313234,
0.0099101728,
0.0123449815,
0.0092644654,
-0.0324228592,
0.0334431082,
-0.0178398825,
0.0842708349,
0.0116212368,
0.0813277289,
0.0169627089,
-0.0101027861,
-0.0336870998,
0.0081793666,
-0.0385172777,
-0.0732296258,
-0.0407947414,
0.0546219684,
0.0197627135,
-0.0460549966,
-0.0068400516,
-0.0222382974,
-0.0077278572,
-0.0042242906,
-0.0193967633,
0.0303311907,
-0.0107872421,
0.0225201696,
0.0535451397,
0.0524458028,
-0.0186176989,
0.0816317648,
0.0281046424,
0.035474766,
0.0204149485,
0.0053418572,
-0.0403433777,
-0.0062529547,
0.0124502461,
0.0179171562,
0.013900429,
0.0392343029,
0.0445096269,
-0.0348634198,
-0.0395685025,
0.0132593354,
-0.0115240347,
0.0257608369,
0.0229153223,
0.040906135,
0.0046756454,
-0.0409008563,
-0.0097373007,
0.0157962032,
0.0020062739,
-0.0298735946,
-0.0019493572,
-5.861927311e-33,
-0.0150312614,
-0.0115644094,
0.0188330133,
-0.0049192733,
0.0036493924,
-0.0001461247,
-0.0286474936,
-0.012517049,
-0.0614620969,
0.0274423249,
-0.02135727,
0.052398704,
0.0352196991,
0.0557860695,
-0.0028651417,
-0.0451138094,
0.0197832286,
-0.0479802564,
0.0003490455,
0.0171107389,
0.0126841087,
-0.0063402788,
0.0692095235,
-0.0508916751,
0.0289252028,
-0.0241091494,
0.0091047017,
0.0031330097,
0.0011692283,
0.0468014851,
-0.0465674587,
0.009914767,
0.0241926312,
-0.0028992805,
-0.0284895711,
0.0488937125,
-0.0880807415,
-0.0288007371,
-0.0514077246,
0.0894197524,
-0.0808039159,
-0.0183670297,
0.0531273037,
0.0030817206,
0.0401405767,
-0.0280782096,
0.0225648358,
-0.0303737018,
-0.0079039764,
0.0353048481,
-0.0868958756,
0.0037777673,
-0.022979835,
-0.0609011576,
0.0584495589,
0.0365276076,
-0.0023575833,
-0.0069024153,
-0.0896050036,
-0.0282720849,
0.0023324317,
0.0447049029,
0.0427676216,
0.04672933,
-0.0223631151,
0.0319369026,
0.0625601783,
0.0039107045,
-0.0118900482,
-0.0271804389,
0.050002858,
0.0524830855,
0.062681973,
-0.0262329038,
0.081356205,
0.0487766378,
-0.0439638048,
0.0151465517,
-0.0245523099,
0.0603430308,
0.0371982232,
-0.0364410542,
-0.0218315385,
-0.00794328,
-0.008336084,
0.0051227491,
-0.0472060665,
0.0091974959,
0.06088911,
0.0059225904,
0.0046979282,
0.0069098859,
0.0627989545,
-0.0351619348,
0.0083170496,
0.0320735201,
-0.0483239144,
0.0366955176,
-0.0095276246,
0.0064607812,
-0.046243608,
-0.0129018007,
0.0510333925,
0.0092021637,
0.0037279895,
0.0250940118,
0.0393958464,
-0.0142473225,
-0.0617237762,
-0.020098282,
-0.0453685224,
0.0189606547,
0.0433977433,
0.0673439652,
0.0267835725,
-0.0358437486,
-0.03093311,
0.0669343695,
-0.0306696277,
0.0002105121,
-0.0063508777,
-0.0374137871,
-0.0179613139,
0.0204488579,
-0.0107050464,
-0.0256659426,
-0.0515543148,
-0.0161056593,
-0.0145954899,
-0.0633837953,
0.0056611034,
0.0555194318,
2.598e-7,
0.0130782938,
0.0199182816,
0.0435022116,
0.0383860692,
0.0116560087,
0.0090041012,
0.0079423059,
0.0072945775,
0.0147232208,
-0.0686484948,
-0.0090421923,
0.0600322895,
0.0568876825,
0.0199797638,
-0.0711707175,
0.0020982863,
-0.0095406426,
0.0435163453,
-0.0692309588,
-0.046984151,
0.0029249815,
0.0762632638,
-0.0368487611,
-0.0446758047,
0.0353295282,
-0.0330548882,
0.0471308008,
0.0126783699,
0.0243083518,
0.0161166079,
0.0275631435,
0.0592834465,
-0.0079243695,
0.0392333344,
-0.0125280684,
0.0054038325,
0.0471325293,
0.0143833291,
-0.0235346835,
-0.0337777771,
-0.0056504435,
-0.0178827737,
0.007044001,
-0.034187682,
0.1006007716,
-0.0220844131,
-0.0105185397,
-0.0039968104,
-0.0364373289,
-0.0257652197,
0.0276517496,
-0.0238426309,
0.0208677575,
0.0275057014,
0.0287375934,
-0.0654060394,
-0.04137915,
-0.0384169556,
-0.0065671219,
-0.0142209623,
-0.0121152923,
0.0054226695,
-0.0660951659,
0.0009290989,
0.0034034969,
-0.0428408347,
-0.0463413037,
1.980956626e-34,
0.0301924702,
-0.0022372801,
0.039899148,
0.0462161042,
0.0053276485,
-0.0152373593,
0.0169177987,
-0.0122717172,
-0.0095572835,
-0.0827775076,
-0.0179546643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00446v1 | Improving Dialog Safety using Socially Aware Contrastive Learning | 2024-02-01T09:24:33 | 2024-02-01T09:24:33 | Souvik Das, Rohini K. Srihari | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art conversational AI systems raise concerns due to their
potential risks of generating unsafe, toxic, unethical, or dangerous content.
Previous works have developed datasets to teach conversational agents the
appropriate social paradigms to respond effectively to specifically designed
hazardous content. However, models trained on these adversarial datasets still
struggle to recognize subtle unsafe situations that appear naturally in
conversations or introduce an inappropriate response in a casual context. To
understand the extent of this problem, we study prosociality in both
adversarial and casual dialog contexts and audit the response quality of
general-purpose language models in terms of propensity to produce unsafe
content. We propose a dual-step fine-tuning process to address these issues
using a socially aware n-pair contrastive loss. Subsequently, we train a base
model that integrates prosocial behavior by leveraging datasets like Moral
Integrity Corpus (MIC) and ProsocialDialog. Experimental results on several
dialog datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in generating
socially appropriate responses. | Improving Dialog Safety using Socially Aware Contrastive Learning: State-of-the-art conversational AI systems raise concerns due to their
potential risks of generating unsafe, toxic, unethical, or dangerous content.
Previous works have developed datasets to teach conversational agents the
appropriate social paradigms to respond effectively to specifically designed
hazardous content. However, models trained on these adversarial datasets still
struggle to recognize subtle unsafe situations that appear naturally in
conversations or introduce an inappropriate response in a casual context. To
understand the extent of this problem, we study prosociality in both
adversarial and casual dialog contexts and audit the response quality of
general-purpose language models in terms of propensity to produce unsafe
content. We propose a dual-step fine-tuning process to address these issues
using a socially aware n-pair contrastive loss. Subsequently, we train a base
model that integrates prosocial behavior by leveraging datasets like Moral
Integrity Corpus (MIC) and ProsocialDialog. Experimental results on several
dialog datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in generating
socially appropriate responses. | [
0.0640391856,
0.0940646902,
-0.0274057444,
0.0404704623,
-0.0212515518,
0.0113166077,
0.0124141378,
-0.0138469571,
0.0237976145,
-0.0232014339,
-0.0506310426,
-0.0377781354,
-0.026700614,
0.0427775569,
0.0198871754,
-0.0526647419,
0.0517541692,
0.0153787229,
0.0596508533,
-0.0152317518,
0.0421164967,
0.0189380907,
0.0088503798,
0.0113700833,
-0.0202009939,
0.0099640479,
-0.004094536,
0.0167459343,
0.0646706894,
-0.012512682,
0.0751485303,
0.0564843975,
0.0154136689,
0.0407745466,
0.0000017585,
-0.0361480229,
0.0335016139,
-0.0070312093,
-0.001690586,
-0.0303481556,
0.0827489942,
-0.024478443,
-0.0317583829,
0.0576748885,
-0.0742892921,
-0.0044693993,
0.0383622199,
0.0774166733,
0.052071739,
0.0742556527,
-0.0064351126,
-0.0092252148,
0.0485197864,
-0.0185143538,
-0.0540112704,
-0.0308079962,
0.0262122042,
-0.0013365432,
-0.0487033986,
0.015467966,
0.0114788655,
0.0032710144,
0.0122215021,
-0.0321101882,
0.0083686886,
0.0035833344,
-0.0274420194,
-0.0259624366,
-0.0346183181,
0.1042445898,
-0.0096813664,
-0.0048953979,
0.0134261707,
-0.0172462184,
0.0041577076,
-0.0345206074,
-0.0195212197,
0.0104211234,
-0.0127247106,
0.0057004057,
0.0137891201,
0.0355033614,
0.0149422605,
0.0610521249,
0.0585227646,
-0.0315392427,
-0.022963332,
0.0204628278,
0.0194732193,
-0.015108292,
-0.0428042524,
-0.0164496526,
0.024906233,
-0.0080863237,
-0.0431429744,
0.0177595112,
-0.0427222215,
-0.0139667941,
0.0595384538,
-0.0499488898,
0.0258242059,
-0.0023521092,
-0.0174492039,
0.0253806338,
0.0439615771,
0.0040883655,
0.0146987634,
0.0449923873,
-0.0124811865,
0.0169407483,
0.0063295937,
0.0106645413,
-0.0256771985,
-0.0041279797,
-0.0572533682,
0.0440729856,
0.0000644023,
-0.0035606064,
-0.0644088387,
0.0096504884,
0.0047284956,
0.0310557522,
-0.0644781813,
-0.0119095258,
-0.0150131285,
-0.018373372,
-0.0366883837,
0.0380034149,
0.020792475,
-0.0684294999,
-0.0232018102,
-0.0024979305,
-0.0028946507,
-0.0077641238,
0.0016160421,
0.1148929149,
-0.0132504832,
-0.046496436,
-0.0248482805,
0.001665206,
-0.0538672954,
-0.0480164364,
-0.0017607831,
-0.014865566,
0.0349535942,
-0.0404978953,
-0.0509731472,
-0.0672186539,
0.034125071,
-0.013853183,
-0.0153874429,
0.0713524669,
0.0116447378,
-0.0389517061,
0.0238093305,
0.0525080971,
-0.045605056,
0.0650821328,
0.044645071,
-0.0025851876,
0.0235334374,
-0.0118580731,
0.0083239637,
-0.0139309196,
0.0377552919,
0.020249689,
-0.017432889,
0.0205005184,
0.0022390387,
-0.0009548013,
0.0238846559,
0.0627969205,
-0.0262115989,
-0.0905132294,
0.0726249218,
0.0519688316,
-0.0297388453,
0.0467762128,
-0.0040659891,
0.0445052907,
-0.0278098322,
0.0050427304,
-0.057413701,
0.0216816142,
-0.0045979274,
-0.0506664664,
-0.0191770978,
0.0252728108,
-0.030673109,
-0.0354224853,
0.0128294593,
-0.0214229245,
0.0808420479,
-0.0172178019,
-0.0044315066,
0.0369334556,
-0.0498018973,
-0.0641893819,
0.0454182997,
-0.0601057336,
-0.0054603731,
-0.0485638641,
0.0393511765,
0.0823528245,
0.0265456811,
-0.0182560273,
-0.0215746034,
-0.0710472986,
0.0099773351,
0.0186028164,
0.0226653535,
-0.0225779265,
0.0775489807,
-0.0500235334,
-0.021107275,
-0.0099366363,
-0.0151166487,
0.0229740739,
-0.0021958966,
0.0061155641,
0.0024462822,
0.0445907451,
-0.0435839109,
0.0193585176,
-0.0238034315,
-0.0152303847,
-0.0008767113,
-0.0020639787,
0.0680617243,
-0.0137213785,
-0.0059391158,
-0.0308874194,
0.019494826,
0.0016671347,
-0.0218757037,
-0.007516514,
-0.0635046437,
-0.0406633802,
0.0223501194,
-0.0619502291,
-0.0028787032,
0.0528936014,
-0.0480321981,
0.0262826644,
0.0126099931,
-0.0385112464,
0.0049223686,
-0.025254136,
-0.0281995069,
-0.0145088639,
0.009111234,
-0.0077569596,
0.0631302893,
-0.0364983343,
-0.0326537006,
-0.008495925,
0.0307741072,
-0.0189475529,
-0.0275485162,
0.0054462347,
-0.0090334592,
-0.0182574857,
0.0628201142,
0.0248199254,
0.0231622979,
-0.0639305562,
-0.0349812247,
-0.0359204225,
-0.0267596729,
-0.0251622479,
0.015868308,
0.0116382055,
-0.0329128318,
0.0035246264,
0.0020150226,
-0.0187271889,
0.0071326313,
0.0031613046,
0.0053625824,
0.0346354283,
0.0052460972,
0.0027934874,
-0.0557454675,
0.002811145,
0.0027788016,
0.0113330344,
0.0039043217,
-0.0088881236,
-0.0196271352,
0.0560476892,
-0.0321421623,
0.0524976626,
-0.027265314,
-0.1046922803,
0.0133510157,
0.0647644848,
0.0024243675,
0.1004323736,
0.0796885416,
0.0577330217,
0.0253793523,
0.0306621306,
-0.0465890393,
0.02037731,
-0.0019602638,
0.006152892,
-0.0293439608,
-0.0428186953,
-0.0404323339,
0.051839292,
-0.0012424353,
0.0188386235,
-0.0550061651,
0.0268653315,
0.0203465056,
-0.0902510583,
0.0360383987,
-0.0580193624,
-0.0112847304,
0.0013063469,
-0.05083232,
-0.0364457555,
0.0728443414,
0.0302432682,
-0.0025023872,
-0.0116048204,
-0.0363818742,
0.011531123,
0.0343767367,
-0.0185383912,
0.0079039447,
0.0077464972,
-0.0258052573,
-0.0589474514,
-0.0486593582,
0.0425668955,
-0.0396298207,
0.0126497885,
-0.0240037758,
-0.0216191281,
0.0147973346,
-0.073872447,
-0.0476071462,
-0.0536096208,
-0.009548327,
0.0011912219,
-0.0002595933,
-0.0037700175,
0.0056120222,
-0.0204517692,
-0.0040672789,
-0.0025942654,
-0.0111127049,
0.0086274976,
-0.0022081034,
0.0062897541,
0.0610906854,
0.0096943509,
0.0434630997,
-0.0126633197,
0.0689825267,
0.0580039658,
0.0212401468,
-0.015342759,
-0.0215216447,
-0.0045468849,
-0.0125677977,
0.0686371177,
0.0157780144,
0.0230767913,
0.0436062664,
-0.0133231198,
-0.0055180043,
0.0476342961,
-0.0196641199,
-0.0072688144,
0.0238024648,
0.0054885894,
0.0158963632,
0.0003720908,
-0.0318569615,
-0.0473708585,
-0.0235194582,
-0.0126993787,
0.0227832738,
-0.0436685272,
-0.0515280515,
0.0220458955,
-0.0589517131,
0.0309170969,
0.0225750804,
-0.0362467542,
-0.0337728597,
-0.0087381629,
0.0016942776,
-0.0342715159,
0.0468861237,
-0.0133345528,
0.018164143,
-0.0548043661,
0.0145905195,
0.0412217416,
-0.0202807412,
0.0207826365,
-0.0538837686,
0.0873842016,
0.0623129308,
0.0694155023,
-0.0244948436,
-0.0041726683,
-0.0098907398,
-0.0015475646,
-0.0159039497,
-0.002829216,
0.0626614466,
-0.0441855602,
0.0013704424,
-0.0147490427,
0.0719409138,
-0.0053794514,
-0.0361202918,
-0.0103285704,
0.0205298122,
0.0014592934,
-0.0465639755,
-0.0253911763,
0.0685253739,
0.0740699619,
0.0513687469,
0.0239332579,
-0.0164392292,
0.019769324,
-0.0312400013,
0.0115880128,
-0.019766707,
-0.002040392,
-0.0250921417,
0.0167116318,
-0.0436437279,
-0.0511088595,
-0.064641349,
-0.0169730857,
-0.021558607,
-0.0149266338,
-0.0623378418,
-0.0067068748,
0.0134484619,
-0.0150240744,
0.0291092526,
-0.0026648443,
0.0162438862,
0.0037856987,
0.0150876734,
-0.0011635147,
-0.0387312286,
-0.0266499817,
0.0258924346,
-0.0467248522,
-0.0560388044,
0.0337746143,
0.0911837295,
0.0117531298,
0.0388248675,
-0.0136819622,
-0.0250971224,
0.0160069522,
0.0696450397,
-0.0612411052,
-0.0147142392,
0.0831441656,
0.0046801195,
0.0124189872,
0.0161405765,
-0.0135526424,
0.0042214417,
0.0470552258,
0.0115351435,
-0.0515377298,
-0.0375068821,
-0.0150607843,
-0.0306333844,
0.0444428921,
0.0217350386,
-0.0138134351,
-0.0450275503,
0.0013234515,
0.0060015745,
-0.0185755249,
-0.0478940196,
0.0286234189,
0.0226745885,
-0.0032447928,
-0.0238680206,
-0.0183444954,
-0.0554447472,
0.038547907,
-0.0267718509,
0.0173692349,
0.0566036813,
0.0471305661,
0.0037145952,
0.0114101302,
-0.0367012918,
0.0447394885,
0.0209391359,
0.0176490229,
0.0102736084,
0.049476523,
0.0288514681,
-0.0090311402,
0.0421506763,
0.0382753573,
-0.0480011851,
-0.0213161744,
-0.0655667707,
0.0180906598,
-0.0104933335,
0.0060492791,
0.0076776561,
-0.0308972429,
0.0145030571,
-0.0156423785,
0.0645682886,
-0.0194757935,
-0.0709624067,
0.0156266019,
0.0208087079,
-0.0187233835,
0.025687838,
0.0549504012,
-0.0309525281,
0.0509365909,
0.0277695376,
-0.0061200503,
-0.0138273193,
-0.0537396856,
0.0626352951,
-0.000949111,
-0.0085705388,
0.0157171246,
-0.0529324859,
-0.0618116297,
-0.021281926,
0.0079705771,
0.0130435862,
-0.025746353,
0.022696659,
0.0359120518,
-0.0122547178,
-0.0005215264,
0.0077119125,
0.004818005,
0.022972649,
-0.0209235605,
-0.0415326692,
-5.521644839e-33,
0.0114597632,
-0.0419416688,
-0.0389638394,
0.0163491871,
0.0021543002,
-0.0006183878,
-0.007474625,
-0.0087162834,
-0.03652329,
0.039116703,
-0.0032508101,
0.0749352649,
-0.0137255779,
-0.0088629937,
-0.0311209261,
-0.0817162991,
0.0217751544,
-0.0194229651,
-0.0147747314,
0.0407998711,
0.0122423591,
0.0245905276,
0.0436851643,
-0.1075295508,
0.0169502422,
0.0171716698,
-0.0273888856,
0.0174885429,
0.0009477837,
0.0246094409,
0.018505197,
0.0562060811,
-0.0005965578,
0.0120691974,
0.0131091196,
0.0540936552,
-0.0356683433,
-0.0195835568,
0.0112338103,
-0.0424780138,
-0.0748168528,
-0.0464014076,
0.0162749309,
-0.0110282674,
-0.007784389,
-0.0408275872,
-0.0036520674,
-0.0016193979,
0.0097808633,
-0.0093793115,
-0.0522314161,
-0.0011022203,
-0.028985979,
-0.0585778281,
-0.0289794598,
0.0254651178,
0.0339205824,
0.0002556717,
0.0019986881,
0.0010153916,
-0.0041684792,
-0.0323132761,
0.0084972298,
-0.0358060226,
-0.0123910969,
0.067134954,
0.0130725633,
0.0604044981,
0.0159173105,
-0.073588416,
-0.0068793381,
0.0492709279,
0.0517460853,
0.0913392529,
-0.0091085583,
-0.054963313,
-0.0644293204,
-0.0006587478,
0.0278070178,
0.0370599963,
-0.0171269048,
-0.0158565007,
-0.0325622298,
-0.0172870085,
-0.0277447812,
-0.0544778854,
-0.0094673941,
-0.0114572449,
-0.0019568556,
-0.0124922357,
-0.0232170336,
-0.0309689343,
-0.0203405637,
-0.0503410138,
0.0260951575,
0.059204381,
0.0202560909,
-0.0302044284,
0.005826069,
0.0372470208,
-0.0504467934,
-0.0272928644,
0.0409804322,
-0.0194861684,
0.0203535762,
-0.0068376544,
0.0792314932,
0.034809541,
-0.0150775788,
-0.0005406336,
-0.0234961417,
0.0674931332,
0.0001123436,
0.0047852146,
-0.0067371936,
0.0285222605,
-0.0031211434,
0.0313998945,
0.0204453319,
-0.0029275301,
-0.0289998185,
-0.0228352305,
-0.0340213217,
0.0373219848,
-0.0374855623,
-0.0196519326,
-0.0245749503,
-0.0265546702,
0.0372828804,
-0.054796692,
-0.0174392164,
-0.0302231908,
2.504e-7,
-0.0250007845,
0.0375950746,
0.0386130735,
0.0312322732,
-0.0053827506,
0.0661254302,
0.0109945349,
0.1023640856,
0.0153612914,
-0.0334958732,
0.0351080149,
0.0260593146,
0.0800039619,
0.0490826666,
-0.0302140471,
-0.0081350524,
-0.1158600152,
-0.0217487328,
-0.0027903665,
-0.0288774148,
0.0370486006,
0.0871675536,
0.022913577,
-0.0285961814,
0.004247657,
-0.0126640145,
0.027630331,
-0.075538598,
0.0082989167,
-0.012129222,
0.0138452714,
-0.0243187919,
0.0107861105,
0.037520308,
-0.0146034388,
0.0133781256,
-0.0202272553,
0.082319662,
-0.021082079,
-0.0606810674,
0.0018716689,
-0.0284203663,
-0.0032483356,
-0.0053389603,
0.0366431214,
-0.0495675988,
-0.0174895767,
-0.0146644954,
-0.029188795,
-0.0268048011,
0.0196695309,
-0.0295827612,
-0.0231341664,
-0.0053471257,
0.0165822357,
0.0021929308,
0.0079184668,
-0.0337425172,
0.0047079464,
-0.0061500971,
0.0134945791,
-0.1048592255,
0.0071272585,
0.0251344256,
0.0123317614,
-0.0146439355,
0.0590601824,
1.712536968e-34,
0.0270268917,
-0.0304248221,
-0.0062945797,
-0.0082693519,
0.0710691959,
0.0208500884,
-0.0151132587,
-0.0051805084,
0.0572050661,
-0.0044733323,
-0.0068890033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00421v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00421v2 | From PARIS to LE-PARIS: Toward Patent Response Automation with Recommender Systems and Collaborative Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T08:37:13 | 2024-03-05T03:45:22 | Jung-Mei Chu, Hao-Cheng Lo, Jieh Hsiang, Chun-Chieh Cho | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | In patent prosecution, timely and effective responses to Office Actions (OAs)
are crucial for securing patents. However, past automation and artificial
intelligence research have largely overlooked this aspect. To bridge this gap,
our study introduces the Patent Office Action Response Intelligence System
(PARIS) and its advanced version, the Large Language Model (LLM) Enhanced PARIS
(LE-PARIS). These systems are designed to enhance the efficiency of patent
attorneys in handling OA responses through collaboration with AI. The systems'
key features include the construction of an OA Topics Database, development of
Response Templates, and implementation of Recommender Systems and LLM-based
Response Generation. To validate the effectiveness of the systems, we have
employed a multi-paradigm analysis using the USPTO Office Action database and
longitudinal data based on attorney interactions with our systems over six
years. Through five studies, we have examined the constructiveness of OA topics
(studies 1 and 2) using topic modeling and our proposed Delphi process, the
efficacy of our proposed hybrid LLM-based recommender system tailored for OA
responses (study 3), the quality of generated responses (study 4), and the
systems' practical value in real-world scenarios through user studies (study
5). The results indicate that both PARIS and LE-PARIS significantly achieve key
metrics and have a positive impact on attorney performance. | From PARIS to LE-PARIS: Toward Patent Response Automation with Recommender Systems and Collaborative Large Language Models: In patent prosecution, timely and effective responses to Office Actions (OAs)
are crucial for securing patents. However, past automation and artificial
intelligence research have largely overlooked this aspect. To bridge this gap,
our study introduces the Patent Office Action Response Intelligence System
(PARIS) and its advanced version, the Large Language Model (LLM) Enhanced PARIS
(LE-PARIS). These systems are designed to enhance the efficiency of patent
attorneys in handling OA responses through collaboration with AI. The systems'
key features include the construction of an OA Topics Database, development of
Response Templates, and implementation of Recommender Systems and LLM-based
Response Generation. To validate the effectiveness of the systems, we have
employed a multi-paradigm analysis using the USPTO Office Action database and
longitudinal data based on attorney interactions with our systems over six
years. Through five studies, we have examined the constructiveness of OA topics
(studies 1 and 2) using topic modeling and our proposed Delphi process, the
efficacy of our proposed hybrid LLM-based recommender system tailored for OA
responses (study 3), the quality of generated responses (study 4), and the
systems' practical value in real-world scenarios through user studies (study
5). The results indicate that both PARIS and LE-PARIS significantly achieve key
metrics and have a positive impact on attorney performance. | [
0.0981376246,
0.0255710408,
-0.0279815178,
-0.0023804379,
-0.0745538548,
-0.026673438,
0.0314613841,
0.0075487937,
0.0236845762,
-0.0769404396,
-0.0208273381,
-0.0024391885,
-0.0458688587,
0.038133312,
-0.0262278747,
-0.0120642157,
-0.012717396,
-0.0140832979,
0.0507052056,
0.0080677541,
0.0352661833,
0.0360331759,
-0.0184115283,
0.0659095943,
0.0242764745,
0.011700199,
0.0123467036,
-0.0355386846,
-0.0200783797,
-0.0670488849,
-0.0019571015,
0.0534685738,
0.0334709845,
0.0186760761,
0.0000019408,
-0.1040399596,
-0.0096242018,
-0.0204483029,
0.0082119703,
0.0041651414,
0.0512306578,
0.023408344,
-0.0066083791,
0.0325846896,
-0.0331252962,
0.0303632133,
-0.0249180421,
0.0393434204,
-0.0160503015,
0.0243595336,
-0.0312416814,
-0.0229524858,
0.0670812801,
-0.0235650726,
-0.0271509495,
-0.0458595194,
0.0238149203,
0.0126327351,
0.1079621688,
-0.0471977741,
0.0308718141,
-0.0171817876,
-0.0279047024,
-0.0442955606,
0.0388253853,
-0.0024793807,
0.0063677151,
0.0103760827,
-0.0119148558,
0.0551734529,
0.1005596742,
0.0328562409,
0.0010956362,
-0.0105083399,
0.0552680194,
0.011894051,
-0.0292889867,
0.0355606712,
-0.0203046482,
-0.0077984547,
0.0365040414,
-0.0022860118,
-0.0375212505,
0.0119899958,
0.0235974006,
0.0463509634,
0.0062247375,
-0.021805115,
-0.0066639292,
-0.0076323762,
0.0636831298,
-0.0820830539,
0.0640227199,
0.051526811,
-0.0253802016,
0.0266884528,
0.004930255,
-0.0470109507,
0.0505800582,
-0.072375983,
0.075428471,
0.0041124616,
0.0119386828,
0.0278533492,
-0.0245866813,
0.0144859282,
-0.0137310363,
0.0023873092,
-0.0193340797,
-0.0316546671,
-0.1045838818,
-0.0141463308,
-0.0120169045,
0.0807372555,
-0.0318411179,
-0.0128027545,
-0.0220389143,
0.0409096368,
-0.0492607504,
0.0306020398,
-0.0223747138,
0.0385375842,
0.046039138,
-0.0539746322,
-0.1300773025,
0.0170017201,
-0.0559459776,
0.0420767553,
-0.0216835327,
0.0137015246,
0.0352187455,
0.0266747847,
0.0065212306,
-0.0085126385,
-0.001430559,
0.0539596602,
-0.0023862806,
-0.0347482786,
-0.0379678495,
-0.0295633562,
0.0280767325,
-0.0023130905,
-0.0355082229,
-0.0783143342,
0.0002968958,
0.0325347632,
-0.052751299,
-0.0540542603,
-0.0049723024,
0.0048918044,
-0.0249686148,
0.0098697981,
-0.0036996498,
0.02335524,
0.0243166424,
0.0219826121,
-0.0114181153,
-0.0328900069,
-0.0184588749,
0.0479409918,
0.0090272464,
-0.0170520041,
0.0603145435,
0.0055782236,
-0.0344558358,
0.0099679688,
0.0166282095,
0.0499758907,
-0.0172825698,
0.0191745684,
0.0155489845,
0.0424764641,
-0.0210105125,
0.0443603136,
0.0538150892,
0.0755201876,
0.0226307195,
0.0506730601,
-0.0166934244,
0.0113090239,
0.0017489309,
-0.0587777384,
0.0258661751,
0.0418274701,
-0.059187334,
-0.0216904841,
-0.0225406606,
0.0144377993,
-0.0425053276,
-0.0632348135,
-0.01982156,
0.0097647915,
0.023141006,
0.0005404406,
0.0684515163,
0.0071015419,
-0.0148580847,
0.0044597336,
-0.0349519886,
0.0175048523,
-0.0628877729,
-0.0548483692,
0.0195986442,
0.1001861095,
0.0329990685,
-0.0289119259,
0.0020248932,
-0.0257344656,
-0.0350677855,
0.0376670063,
0.048531387,
-0.0015926508,
-0.0591263697,
-0.0281551462,
-0.0261359066,
-0.0031969708,
-0.0016845226,
0.0708339587,
-0.0434209257,
0.0246414561,
-0.0024891524,
-0.0181486029,
0.0403659791,
0.0073855245,
-0.0263946149,
-0.0341450609,
0.0204752255,
-0.0117744682,
0.0491630323,
0.0508945286,
0.0011747757,
0.0261062961,
0.0396540985,
-0.0110143842,
-0.0289246365,
0.0068415264,
0.0620163381,
0.0534022972,
0.0056823133,
0.0074677663,
-0.0263943449,
-0.0062377187,
0.0229741782,
-0.0178109165,
0.0107978014,
-0.0131561244,
0.001070977,
-0.0418215804,
-0.0081606079,
-0.0045082476,
-0.0163906477,
-0.0198284686,
0.0301718824,
0.0270947982,
-0.0186923724,
0.0423377901,
-0.0172669236,
0.0617054291,
-0.0478765145,
0.0107759517,
0.0007181819,
-0.0144993179,
0.007290436,
0.0396403186,
-0.0496464334,
-0.0116837192,
-0.0261882506,
-0.0961535349,
-0.0283481535,
-0.0084531317,
0.0127913989,
-0.0255810767,
-0.0040298807,
0.0057386612,
-0.0171461236,
-0.030594321,
-0.0168799665,
0.025296336,
-0.0087199276,
0.0372135267,
0.0063923183,
-0.0712669417,
-0.0187248997,
-0.0110634649,
-0.0189461559,
-0.0049399608,
0.0404432639,
-0.0284895226,
-0.0477022156,
0.0254103113,
-0.0477600768,
0.0099402778,
0.0026719752,
0.0175743029,
0.0008522327,
-0.024562424,
-0.0374797545,
0.0029353816,
0.0195946619,
0.0549550951,
0.0578483082,
0.0108708646,
-0.0696472302,
-0.0137874121,
0.0263386182,
0.0313321464,
0.0071225953,
0.0046956185,
0.0365977213,
-0.0200543106,
-0.0142886061,
0.0243245512,
0.0062904973,
-0.0164565649,
0.0236817971,
-0.0113443946,
0.017282268,
-0.0552187078,
0.0013273554,
0.0527060553,
0.0080891512,
-0.0487963669,
0.0726347044,
0.0245727524,
0.0283808094,
-0.0669115037,
-0.0317049138,
-0.0272076707,
0.0716305599,
0.0029236404,
0.0015294832,
-0.0226789787,
-0.0275771152,
0.0177074857,
-0.0364479721,
0.0248983335,
-0.0195954926,
0.0307402555,
-0.0279033985,
0.0456811227,
-0.0024370684,
0.0021878879,
-0.0319971889,
-0.0213552974,
-0.0240466036,
0.0439507924,
0.0127848834,
0.0000262729,
-0.036634244,
-0.0028852348,
0.0240644403,
0.0256518479,
0.0533997975,
-0.0247184839,
0.0107429409,
0.0234795082,
0.0186075028,
-0.0268065762,
-0.0199161787,
0.0117384307,
0.0126067353,
0.0055359304,
0.0177363772,
-0.0378568657,
-0.050363943,
-0.0093822181,
-0.0074413065,
-0.0261969808,
0.0015496461,
0.0407432653,
-0.0302736331,
0.0100434776,
0.0495634787,
0.0742598549,
0.0151311858,
0.009298576,
0.0039992644,
-0.0158446357,
-0.0218580496,
0.0191001836,
0.0464914814,
-0.0753632337,
0.031024633,
-0.0599750318,
-0.0022905944,
-0.0492509194,
-0.0284833945,
-0.0051618712,
-0.1132038608,
0.1055338681,
-0.0106910169,
0.0294167753,
-0.0061563062,
-0.0170342289,
0.0102609377,
0.025146313,
-0.0389148593,
-0.0553382672,
0.0049105766,
-0.0344798528,
0.002333561,
-0.0797570795,
0.0349320844,
0.0400299653,
-0.0387431793,
0.0273490697,
0.0652295202,
-0.0062962254,
-0.0173864346,
-0.0172738824,
-0.0176472608,
0.0273392033,
0.0282152239,
0.0166958906,
-0.0312002972,
0.0500319749,
0.0743910521,
-0.0181575157,
0.0108077452,
-0.0577151515,
-0.0174286887,
0.0539493747,
0.0856829956,
-0.0728986412,
0.0074297232,
-0.0555827133,
-0.0062294356,
0.019292077,
0.0376266055,
-0.002610625,
-0.0368212387,
-0.0261101592,
-0.0032699015,
-0.0208386332,
-0.044908911,
0.0462144502,
-0.0374861881,
-0.0159557667,
0.0264713168,
-0.0648372918,
-0.0319904424,
0.0038234144,
0.009051241,
0.0131862368,
0.0180524308,
-0.0075560971,
0.0035069869,
0.0101118097,
0.0304006692,
0.0300481152,
0.0199499298,
-0.0248040538,
-0.0024433809,
0.0145554282,
-0.0043709651,
-0.0074280347,
0.0097923772,
0.0270764362,
-0.0439983085,
-0.0303854253,
0.0146306828,
0.0290259141,
-0.0157103185,
-0.0241629705,
-0.0661371127,
0.0570390821,
0.0246890988,
0.0200180337,
-0.0322456546,
0.0202540401,
-0.0232048389,
-0.0409435183,
-0.0313202254,
-0.0379028954,
0.0575399473,
0.0546607673,
0.0228340868,
0.0124943433,
-0.0618034974,
0.0324699506,
0.0656707063,
0.0093573565,
0.025520416,
0.0204344504,
-0.0230479781,
-0.0098406971,
-0.0091467481,
0.0143562723,
-0.0392538346,
-0.033526428,
-0.0039851405,
-0.0356018953,
-0.0055116513,
-0.0041789962,
-0.0406502187,
0.0082952883,
-0.0460345894,
0.0566136464,
0.0032886346,
0.0001687883,
0.0048277671,
-0.0115594286,
-0.0041293656,
0.0038340758,
0.0097617833,
0.0317649804,
-0.0320704728,
0.060763754,
-0.0263507925,
0.0128263254,
-0.0326603465,
0.0380956493,
-0.0249869749,
-0.0840346888,
-0.0070476565,
0.055168584,
0.0562661961,
0.0100434031,
-0.0283094961,
-0.0810739994,
0.0122041525,
-0.0311137792,
0.0338153429,
-0.0215850919,
-0.0001743515,
0.0302662719,
0.0343449786,
-0.0022810018,
-0.0027621747,
0.0165695399,
-0.0537134036,
-0.0116757248,
-0.0546272248,
-0.0171767585,
-0.0357957892,
-0.0225328822,
0.0133522777,
0.0389601029,
-0.0305306036,
-0.0447368845,
-0.050905779,
0.0165257677,
0.0219329968,
-0.0380604677,
-0.0070976019,
-0.0080739483,
0.0219984949,
0.0734293386,
0.0397818461,
-0.025359245,
-0.0511168614,
0.0047396785,
-0.0449790955,
-0.0592848994,
-0.0393532254,
-5.33598322e-33,
0.0312771425,
-0.0791873634,
0.0248104129,
0.0232577901,
0.0312350951,
-0.0558251701,
-0.0176053289,
0.0218982771,
0.0131882997,
0.020727884,
-0.0432620086,
-0.0038781846,
0.0119443256,
-0.0211587604,
0.0512070693,
0.0299723223,
0.0219513588,
-0.0052561248,
-0.0176996123,
-0.0138865039,
-0.0020628502,
-0.0004425281,
-0.0388470255,
-0.1002134681,
0.0298329964,
0.0314316452,
0.0110547561,
-0.0374436118,
-0.0472980738,
0.0813738853,
0.0136717185,
0.0514823757,
0.0282044802,
-0.0707911775,
0.0090709934,
0.0258439071,
-0.0632281229,
0.0082002655,
-0.0248793513,
-0.0522387661,
0.0276201554,
0.00566193,
0.0095819701,
0.0103283441,
-0.0582721867,
0.0507085472,
0.0539328977,
-0.0243802778,
-0.0555451438,
-0.0260743871,
-0.0945530832,
0.0222644936,
-0.0076457211,
0.035381116,
0.041865021,
0.0179425199,
-0.0204523355,
0.0400805846,
-0.0361632146,
0.0131003745,
-0.0399105363,
-0.0583929904,
0.0108254524,
-0.045213446,
-0.0374935456,
0.0177515727,
0.0110665997,
0.0587275997,
-0.0118359346,
-0.0244649369,
-0.0237734132,
0.0837095827,
0.027041439,
-0.0007151802,
-0.0157234743,
-0.0075023789,
-0.0478667356,
0.0604963526,
0.021644501,
0.0048850011,
0.0390498862,
0.0097309127,
-0.0402403064,
-0.0054781204,
0.0227515921,
-0.0070655751,
-0.0239487328,
-0.0156962089,
0.0092153,
0.0060847919,
0.009185873,
0.0050034467,
0.0388766825,
-0.0232733861,
0.0095410133,
-0.0253692996,
0.014220316,
0.0537967607,
0.0077237259,
-0.0132257901,
-0.0738215297,
-0.0160805564,
-0.0282955449,
0.0052762846,
0.0078733033,
-0.0002059245,
-0.0141674923,
-0.0599745698,
-0.0231592879,
0.017102262,
0.0052557737,
0.0120818084,
0.005745207,
-0.0078808777,
-0.0247065946,
0.0242552161,
0.0347221941,
0.0668548644,
0.0071023442,
-0.0370615385,
-0.0498518236,
-0.0592010468,
0.0034613623,
-0.0471209735,
-0.0156956296,
0.0261345897,
0.0029028526,
0.0277603809,
0.0617810898,
0.0264071506,
-0.0135553768,
-0.0087446887,
2.777e-7,
0.0563942939,
0.0534243174,
-0.0322293043,
0.0379183181,
0.0002831547,
0.0295873787,
0.0211033802,
0.0359738357,
0.0461561084,
0.0262974259,
0.0555585511,
-0.0392559841,
0.0004400399,
0.0596468523,
-0.0543517694,
-0.0392315984,
-0.015825592,
-0.0139028905,
-0.0766945034,
0.0557304509,
0.0890339166,
0.0078666368,
0.0042127166,
-0.0067598205,
-0.0273023602,
-0.0289835669,
0.0401245914,
-0.0255188048,
0.0149916774,
-0.0098643815,
0.1078978106,
-0.0494532138,
-0.0143045066,
0.0679865777,
-0.025270937,
0.0387935899,
-0.0362179726,
-0.0098471381,
-0.0266299937,
-0.0007414232,
0.0109735336,
-0.0382185839,
0.051293958,
-0.0352269039,
-0.0072245169,
0.0040821722,
-0.0284504723,
-0.0012576123,
-0.0038644422,
-0.0153960548,
-0.0234778896,
0.0060425117,
0.0002509962,
-0.0190612096,
-0.0011019475,
-0.0128073338,
0.0141571602,
-0.0542490222,
0.0653131753,
0.0056111705,
-0.0309884083,
-0.0063147228,
-0.009155252,
-0.0004574427,
0.0521298796,
-0.027469907,
0.0426683389,
2.046911502e-34,
0.0202144906,
-0.0253698695,
-0.0273881331,
0.0447187759,
0.0487745516,
0.0340477377,
0.0347942375,
0.0148609616,
0.0001080977,
-0.0740453824,
-0.0111729139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00414v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00414v1 | Prompt-Time Symbolic Knowledge Capture with Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T08:15:28 | 2024-02-01T08:15:28 | Tolga Çöplü, Arto Bendiken, Andrii Skomorokhov, Eduard Bateiko, Stephen Cobb, Joshua J. Bouw | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Augmenting large language models (LLMs) with user-specific knowledge is
crucial for real-world applications, such as personal AI assistants. However,
LLMs inherently lack mechanisms for prompt-driven knowledge capture. This paper
investigates utilizing the existing LLM capabilities to enable prompt-driven
knowledge capture, with a particular emphasis on knowledge graphs. We address
this challenge by focusing on prompt-to-triple (P2T) generation. We explore
three methods: zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting, and fine-tuning, and
then assess their performance via a specialized synthetic dataset. Our code and
datasets are publicly available at https://github.com/HaltiaAI/paper-PTSKC. | Prompt-Time Symbolic Knowledge Capture with Large Language Models: Augmenting large language models (LLMs) with user-specific knowledge is
crucial for real-world applications, such as personal AI assistants. However,
LLMs inherently lack mechanisms for prompt-driven knowledge capture. This paper
investigates utilizing the existing LLM capabilities to enable prompt-driven
knowledge capture, with a particular emphasis on knowledge graphs. We address
this challenge by focusing on prompt-to-triple (P2T) generation. We explore
three methods: zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting, and fine-tuning, and
then assess their performance via a specialized synthetic dataset. Our code and
datasets are publicly available at https://github.com/HaltiaAI/paper-PTSKC. | [
0.015700439,
0.0389528275,
-0.0089498339,
0.0582304187,
-0.0541504472,
0.0015662023,
0.0009193463,
0.0041456502,
0.0467299111,
-0.039951995,
-0.0068159718,
-0.0104952734,
-0.009524812,
0.0316984355,
0.0386596844,
-0.0284715686,
0.0445110351,
-0.0531052016,
0.0065812436,
-0.0205964502,
-0.0217559189,
0.0572133921,
-0.0137042981,
0.014880511,
-0.0285494681,
-0.0028408528,
-0.0359750837,
0.0023038946,
0.0058248583,
-0.0413034,
-0.0548722669,
0.0241338201,
0.0224716384,
0.0311196204,
0.0000020051,
-0.0529414602,
-0.0113469763,
-0.0130579388,
-0.0531109571,
-0.0080600465,
-0.0067598992,
-0.0073932237,
0.0073578083,
0.0164989214,
-0.0483689979,
0.0038913919,
0.0008488437,
0.0005046427,
0.0519104786,
0.0445422269,
0.0044087535,
0.0325361229,
0.018634012,
-0.0247138217,
0.0223124586,
-0.0318075977,
0.0250306353,
-0.0080891205,
0.0204270948,
-0.0005127699,
0.018400671,
0.0324705467,
0.0131771388,
-0.004637036,
-0.0141504472,
0.0307459962,
-0.0247207396,
0.0075165317,
-0.0448185466,
0.0935216472,
-0.0020400039,
-0.0128129125,
0.0098843742,
0.0075293412,
0.0183731969,
0.0077972966,
-0.0244929641,
0.0154283261,
-0.0527210608,
-0.0176196974,
0.0209422894,
-0.0222733207,
0.0161166601,
-0.0120668467,
-0.0240263566,
0.0466154888,
0.0457485467,
-0.0285929367,
0.0105884848,
-0.0215485953,
-0.0279884972,
-0.0703846216,
-0.0154299587,
0.0395148844,
-0.0380742848,
0.0239191167,
-0.082705088,
0.0046285605,
0.0025981907,
0.0407713316,
0.0791979581,
0.0330940001,
-0.0081408508,
0.0526067913,
-0.0566546656,
0.0441215597,
0.0007435405,
0.0430665873,
-0.0399146937,
-0.0264327973,
-0.051106073,
0.0202312358,
-0.0572986007,
0.04596458,
-0.0143392356,
-0.0116280951,
-0.0037527594,
0.0464590453,
0.002601777,
0.0565371551,
0.0290632229,
-0.0048586954,
-0.0097677428,
-0.0044309385,
0.0162915159,
0.0222240556,
-0.0359222963,
0.0092336228,
0.0162382778,
-0.0522448495,
-0.0110019092,
0.0043831477,
0.0336012729,
-0.0080928896,
0.0165227838,
0.0658025444,
0.0013841535,
-0.0573507994,
-0.0226322711,
-0.0666071028,
0.0057782028,
-0.0714165568,
-0.0352525227,
-0.0475544892,
0.0951400101,
-0.0031916781,
-0.0276467074,
-0.0348340124,
0.0210091285,
0.0143191144,
-0.0019237571,
0.0521919467,
-0.0579833984,
0.0243679732,
-0.0021518823,
-0.0229892898,
-0.0522519685,
0.0202915836,
0.0396613181,
0.0381359421,
0.0451387018,
0.0067753503,
-0.0302072577,
0.0538142845,
0.0552266017,
0.0374633446,
-0.0134171871,
0.0049706157,
0.0188870449,
0.0314049721,
0.021580983,
0.0657492206,
-0.0104674818,
0.0267673787,
0.0618511513,
0.0534978844,
0.011681594,
-0.0048355116,
0.1194513068,
0.0036538572,
0.0210490823,
-0.0559380427,
-0.0656695813,
0.007616973,
-0.0454373434,
0.0139132524,
-0.0272868816,
0.0464148,
-0.0269323532,
0.018821802,
0.0345669687,
-0.0145461867,
-0.0503014177,
0.031726446,
0.0368325375,
0.0233531091,
-0.0483519137,
0.0512097925,
0.0066618947,
-0.0551972426,
0.0079173855,
-0.024248546,
0.0520758703,
0.1069261804,
0.0315052457,
0.0069360612,
-0.0064188931,
0.0057182736,
-0.0057371724,
-0.0170470793,
0.0415172316,
-0.0313403197,
-0.0030548044,
-0.0248135459,
-0.0345992893,
0.0050164573,
-0.0180277787,
0.0631726533,
0.0343082361,
0.0181599446,
0.0262682959,
-0.0404826961,
0.0058545722,
0.0133138793,
-0.067350246,
-0.0393282585,
0.0013953898,
0.01484509,
0.0085450308,
0.0544776618,
-0.000965277,
0.0113431653,
0.0328194425,
-0.0282113459,
-0.0096031213,
0.0258269031,
-0.049590949,
-0.0374115035,
0.0474180467,
0.0145540573,
-0.0254164822,
0.0136371367,
-0.0455740243,
-0.0535129234,
-0.0227976739,
-0.0007555789,
0.0421130918,
-0.0247173347,
0.0016460242,
0.0545042828,
-0.0080329627,
0.0199772809,
0.0634285361,
-0.0196932126,
-0.0396427512,
0.0681056827,
0.0379982255,
-0.0116796242,
-0.0212498419,
-0.0015631411,
0.0110516874,
0.0045029819,
0.0197355486,
-0.0004923893,
0.022606615,
-0.0391178131,
0.001992597,
-0.1083232611,
0.0205914062,
-0.0085108913,
0.0045743054,
0.0085615534,
0.0153480647,
-0.0303649139,
-0.0153990751,
-0.0549707897,
0.0258407705,
-0.000351319,
0.0075001358,
0.0038891211,
0.0132425325,
-0.037176773,
-0.0204327591,
0.0067560337,
-0.022798134,
0.0174158961,
0.0074772695,
-0.0165568199,
-0.0435995944,
0.0256420672,
-0.0132741565,
0.0321280025,
-0.0108070113,
0.0074924864,
0.0090763224,
-0.0683568269,
0.0231505744,
0.0262782369,
-0.0109245665,
0.0132801626,
0.0299397875,
-0.0124176024,
-0.0648394898,
-0.0104385624,
-0.0159626808,
-0.0439963974,
0.0132159162,
-0.0110204602,
0.0148580652,
0.0395823568,
0.0284378231,
-0.0011287087,
-0.0799360499,
-0.0149398101,
0.008616467,
-0.0177108143,
-0.0529091246,
0.0008324946,
-0.031770058,
0.0446224734,
-0.0053913789,
-0.0207961947,
0.0731713623,
-0.0628549308,
0.0210431367,
0.0088482117,
-0.0105405068,
-0.0263962969,
0.086346373,
-0.0054322616,
0.0239398126,
-0.0005607714,
0.007035898,
-0.0438822135,
0.0029845648,
-0.0011524374,
-0.0217574593,
0.0235114861,
-0.0592460148,
0.0228473172,
-0.0048251967,
-0.038946934,
-0.0261935387,
-0.0480534993,
-0.0514030159,
0.0134949349,
-0.0109751299,
-0.0309244115,
0.0444116816,
-0.0227226466,
0.0185525715,
0.0580102243,
-0.0191688091,
-0.0312982835,
-0.055684492,
0.0201782454,
0.0704064593,
0.0115863876,
-0.0202215072,
-0.0162600484,
0.0401858985,
0.0333648548,
0.0573161207,
0.0201573819,
-0.0080796685,
-0.0058066919,
0.0200718008,
-0.0472554825,
0.0076906914,
0.030201599,
0.0245316289,
-0.0363869257,
0.0095623657,
0.1146270111,
0.015295825,
-0.0532343835,
0.0121324006,
-0.0020541404,
0.014737268,
0.0222391002,
0.0277771465,
-0.149191618,
-0.0503798723,
-0.0096996939,
0.0377580859,
0.0019919572,
-0.0714470893,
-0.031937141,
-0.178680107,
-0.008266042,
0.0126622831,
-0.0291902963,
-0.0311702024,
0.0150220506,
0.0105242953,
0.0389191099,
-0.0047087157,
0.011135269,
-0.0172165427,
-0.0047743907,
0.0154092545,
0.0134875495,
-0.0556236729,
0.070468463,
-0.0259459503,
0.0619049445,
0.006027299,
0.0240402855,
0.01181868,
0.0030625993,
-0.0348308124,
0.0183002874,
0.0058722687,
0.0078532193,
0.0082882103,
-0.0225088112,
-0.0181288682,
0.0113629736,
0.0738566667,
-0.0763925761,
0.0085440595,
0.0525993407,
0.0664087236,
-0.0068246932,
0.0015788284,
0.010803855,
-0.0090233777,
0.0183775108,
0.0719445571,
0.0332505107,
-0.0329393595,
0.008877906,
-0.0110157179,
-0.0291517396,
-0.0539032184,
-0.0014742072,
0.0336023942,
-0.0172884539,
0.0026398001,
-0.0812767372,
-0.0313870944,
0.0875707194,
0.0384217426,
0.0251486376,
0.0015912622,
-0.0200842526,
-0.02394812,
-0.0392605811,
0.0265639257,
-0.0538113825,
0.0349967368,
-0.0511028804,
-0.0243792105,
0.0061274851,
-0.0480002053,
-0.0066137719,
0.0124046225,
-0.0676038787,
-0.0509427898,
-0.0044013211,
0.0851022005,
0.0145463943,
0.0809604079,
-0.0063755801,
0.0154836038,
0.0565334409,
0.0538314655,
-0.0221532304,
0.0024716086,
0.0012635416,
0.0245928988,
-0.0014143075,
0.0602420941,
-0.0796183348,
-0.002483434,
-0.0272960477,
0.019968899,
-0.0411332175,
-0.0445331484,
0.0436370149,
0.0733870491,
0.0159664098,
-0.0528097078,
-0.0065068658,
-0.0192772336,
0.0158597175,
-0.0494321287,
-0.0157917384,
-0.0752918646,
0.0009147423,
-0.003516722,
-0.0522123501,
0.0283666383,
-0.0719754472,
0.009627711,
0.0191001147,
-0.0304403901,
-0.0422092564,
0.0077329981,
0.0405438431,
0.0848086774,
-0.0238708053,
-0.0573562086,
0.0326602384,
-0.0081836684,
0.0161840096,
-0.0491520278,
0.0657534525,
0.034948688,
-0.0058288989,
-0.0204377491,
0.0536158979,
0.0007208076,
-0.0668067783,
0.0207639914,
0.0181449428,
0.0868512467,
0.0209470391,
0.0391028523,
-0.0559684373,
0.0044479938,
-0.0084625557,
0.0428302288,
0.0127359182,
-0.0341384597,
0.025499573,
0.0177688655,
0.0099535016,
0.0035287617,
0.0587277487,
-0.0323438048,
0.0649160296,
0.0121718524,
0.0219014101,
-0.0590506904,
0.004081531,
0.0172638018,
0.0018861133,
-0.0103089241,
-0.012244788,
-0.0865667015,
-0.0667347983,
0.0073446385,
0.0271728393,
-0.052081503,
0.0045424174,
0.0526172854,
0.0263649337,
-0.006685121,
-0.0164457988,
-0.0362127572,
0.0148974974,
-0.0387429409,
-0.042532064,
0.0253933519,
-6.033122635e-33,
-0.0511335991,
-0.0394696444,
0.0248863604,
0.0065707681,
-0.0139875086,
0.0102015436,
-0.0329154395,
-0.0188196469,
-0.00697539,
-0.00563259,
-0.0345993228,
-0.0193492789,
0.0100650433,
0.0111123547,
-0.0166434459,
-0.0172180384,
0.0216768831,
-0.0031726053,
-0.0023829958,
0.066128619,
0.075121969,
0.0248973072,
0.0343165882,
-0.0163281988,
0.0173224807,
-0.0059704566,
-0.0001563433,
-0.0049676239,
-0.0183852036,
0.0415580906,
-0.0077583492,
0.0609198324,
-0.0118282912,
0.007933273,
-0.0023515099,
0.0245488826,
-0.0513618328,
-0.0603103116,
0.0354624018,
-0.0104141179,
-0.048550792,
-0.0343567356,
-0.0337182991,
-0.0382179357,
0.0324583538,
-0.004454663,
-0.0009852485,
0.0059444155,
-0.0371229239,
-0.0671154484,
-0.0465262122,
0.0038128477,
0.016895242,
-0.0444710813,
-0.0183352847,
0.0278195813,
0.0248082988,
-0.0430651978,
-0.0063168122,
0.010643471,
0.0179377422,
-0.0104055889,
0.0528473705,
-0.0076473658,
-0.0142640015,
0.0435860604,
-0.0085058911,
-0.0008165229,
-0.003141738,
0.048205331,
-0.0116230631,
0.0599701069,
0.0075763529,
0.0405707993,
-0.0142467963,
-0.0021465253,
-0.0093084304,
0.0054764319,
0.0554227382,
0.0156743601,
-0.0018337404,
-0.0402360819,
-0.0193410628,
0.004262256,
-0.0510551743,
-0.0086043542,
-0.0292105302,
-0.023667777,
0.0568676926,
-0.007274597,
-0.0308036525,
-0.0402522683,
0.0326600038,
-0.0284963828,
-0.0004903339,
0.0293819364,
-0.0308532026,
0.0099322675,
-0.0223488007,
0.0301841181,
-0.0450272486,
-0.0281883664,
0.0105207544,
-0.0318806767,
0.0349233113,
0.0476712324,
0.0161444265,
0.0625509471,
-0.0445576012,
0.0105035705,
-0.0564488135,
0.0347031169,
-0.0123315845,
-0.0399416722,
0.0527640618,
0.0291208159,
0.0029329099,
0.0346935466,
0.0213754568,
-0.0304819662,
-0.0000448086,
0.0380520597,
0.0146714784,
0.0149518969,
-0.0018794158,
0.0145230014,
-0.0674990192,
-0.0073368652,
0.0480440781,
-0.0167898107,
-0.0045981621,
0.0120006157,
2.737e-7,
-0.0058367806,
0.0211481433,
0.0240714289,
0.0713155344,
0.0087652141,
0.0198506452,
0.0152086522,
0.0403831415,
-0.0110853156,
-0.0109290695,
0.0059237205,
0.0253545996,
0.0108385738,
0.0244685188,
-0.120364055,
0.010665793,
-0.0385869034,
-0.007948881,
-0.0749687776,
0.0340648592,
0.0671592951,
0.042213466,
0.0137164583,
-0.0202030204,
-0.0080486303,
-0.0452295803,
0.0530463271,
-0.0146062691,
-0.0105064102,
0.009768907,
0.050358478,
-0.020071296,
-0.0197156798,
0.058042787,
-0.0104766032,
0.0089902654,
-0.0230510086,
0.0580457561,
0.0118522923,
-0.0092326496,
0.0087071201,
-0.0389836468,
-0.0069090705,
-0.0365701243,
0.082779713,
-0.0596067123,
-0.0075661768,
-0.0115668504,
-0.0247628447,
-0.0316597,
-0.0437613726,
-0.0317522511,
0.0177223552,
0.0361967646,
0.0171486344,
0.0009674884,
-0.0268324614,
-0.0612890162,
0.0048000859,
-0.0137647428,
-0.0022907704,
-0.0606699437,
-0.0271700192,
-0.0374215692,
-0.003298912,
-0.0553449169,
0.0128164953,
2.524206289e-34,
0.0046132123,
-0.0098855831,
0.0264634136,
0.0084724082,
0.01589543,
-0.0225836392,
-0.0235804804,
0.0340036191,
0.0372912101,
-0.0844557956,
-0.0248287022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00412v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00412v1 | Hidding the Ghostwriters: An Adversarial Evaluation of AI-Generated Student Essay Detection | 2024-02-01T08:11:56 | 2024-02-01T08:11:56 | Xinlin Peng, Ying Zhou, Ben He, Le Sun, Yingfei Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable capabilities in text
generation tasks. However, the utilization of these models carries inherent
risks, including but not limited to plagiarism, the dissemination of fake news,
and issues in educational exercises. Although several detectors have been
proposed to address these concerns, their effectiveness against adversarial
perturbations, specifically in the context of student essay writing, remains
largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by constructing
AIG-ASAP, an AI-generated student essay dataset, employing a range of text
perturbation methods that are expected to generate high-quality essays while
evading detection. Through empirical experiments, we assess the performance of
current AIGC detectors on the AIG-ASAP dataset. The results reveal that the
existing detectors can be easily circumvented using straightforward automatic
adversarial attacks. Specifically, we explore word substitution and sentence
substitution perturbation methods that effectively evade detection while
maintaining the quality of the generated essays. This highlights the urgent
need for more accurate and robust methods to detect AI-generated student essays
in the education domain. | Hidding the Ghostwriters: An Adversarial Evaluation of AI-Generated Student Essay Detection: Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable capabilities in text
generation tasks. However, the utilization of these models carries inherent
risks, including but not limited to plagiarism, the dissemination of fake news,
and issues in educational exercises. Although several detectors have been
proposed to address these concerns, their effectiveness against adversarial
perturbations, specifically in the context of student essay writing, remains
largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by constructing
AIG-ASAP, an AI-generated student essay dataset, employing a range of text
perturbation methods that are expected to generate high-quality essays while
evading detection. Through empirical experiments, we assess the performance of
current AIGC detectors on the AIG-ASAP dataset. The results reveal that the
existing detectors can be easily circumvented using straightforward automatic
adversarial attacks. Specifically, we explore word substitution and sentence
substitution perturbation methods that effectively evade detection while
maintaining the quality of the generated essays. This highlights the urgent
need for more accurate and robust methods to detect AI-generated student essays
in the education domain. | [
0.0523441844,
0.0632392019,
-0.0051305825,
0.0399072468,
-0.0627670139,
-0.0082089547,
0.0440946855,
0.0021892153,
0.0436759479,
-0.0731214955,
0.0131115746,
-0.024771953,
-0.0077678966,
0.036180079,
0.0555511937,
0.0447842628,
0.0226382278,
0.0185670257,
-0.0278441329,
0.0207744706,
0.0130121885,
0.0086144339,
0.0118827987,
0.0378355347,
0.0042460584,
-0.0258519147,
0.0072188033,
0.0220534056,
0.0061693946,
0.001104139,
0.0347801447,
0.0544343665,
-0.0396894515,
0.1083770096,
0.0000019398,
-0.017866794,
-0.014584518,
-0.0081997868,
-0.0081276027,
0.0625916272,
0.0621709116,
-0.0185896736,
-0.026712589,
0.0209562834,
-0.0684287921,
0.0210001674,
0.0238609146,
0.0439372621,
0.0651103109,
0.1129673943,
-0.0240152907,
0.002324722,
0.0458517484,
-0.0282540433,
-0.0030678066,
-0.0084492145,
0.044206541,
-0.0491567478,
-0.0292272586,
0.0386398621,
-0.0009024477,
0.0380895175,
0.0141969379,
-0.0669386685,
-0.0024283461,
-0.0007337689,
-0.0405482873,
0.0096290214,
0.0080501921,
0.028635487,
-0.0416698009,
-0.0668498799,
0.019986419,
-0.006787946,
0.012030622,
0.0161411203,
-0.0229265075,
-0.0082775215,
-0.0254992023,
-0.0034826666,
0.034424495,
-0.0507368892,
0.0222522113,
0.0477112643,
0.0393415093,
-0.0275381599,
0.0252193511,
-0.0386452824,
-0.049435094,
-0.008159698,
-0.0021768427,
-0.0669516549,
0.0717265829,
0.0255360249,
0.0106950086,
-0.0182485338,
-0.1004414335,
-0.0771100894,
0.0256944634,
-0.0569682941,
0.0801015273,
0.0052357255,
0.0132607361,
0.0075240033,
-0.0502432398,
0.0777191669,
-0.027090136,
0.0403477959,
-0.0038492298,
0.042543903,
-0.0123819672,
-0.0188927893,
-0.0196481943,
0.0235930625,
0.0091345599,
-0.0120142661,
-0.0399699993,
-0.0022663451,
-0.0072431839,
0.037077792,
-0.0439009704,
-0.0045886599,
-0.0469395071,
0.0073449565,
0.0405091085,
0.0133350724,
0.0298435315,
0.0104930503,
0.0133937625,
-0.0525680333,
-0.0223597176,
0.0392923951,
0.0060307728,
-0.0102882739,
0.0123679284,
0.0277983788,
0.0071114916,
-0.0179100875,
-0.0312610157,
-0.0453114845,
0.0039385818,
-0.0346611254,
0.0019036859,
-0.0465352498,
-0.0083548026,
-0.0343906619,
-0.0188897308,
-0.084596768,
0.0060543353,
0.0296476111,
0.0121911308,
0.0337083265,
0.0155645655,
-0.0219977181,
0.0225366298,
-0.0012845235,
-0.0053367708,
0.0227392111,
0.035516724,
0.0671500489,
0.0563034862,
0.0001116048,
0.0464954674,
0.034680441,
0.035715878,
0.0398152769,
0.018098684,
-0.0401648842,
-0.0117164468,
0.0191238057,
0.0011916747,
0.0471588187,
0.0161366127,
-0.0336206667,
0.0949436948,
0.0222097933,
-0.0450555608,
0.045355197,
0.0351965725,
0.0188316032,
0.0016124046,
0.0564133301,
-0.0122147128,
-0.0096055595,
-0.0318837091,
-0.0409777723,
-0.0051913555,
0.0210032538,
0.0233141519,
-0.0466831811,
-0.0088651916,
-0.019692082,
-0.0231424253,
-0.0270931665,
-0.0066200197,
0.033735916,
-0.049279891,
-0.0373726487,
-0.024173582,
-0.0575440712,
0.0214481689,
-0.0730712563,
0.0274225883,
0.0579566881,
0.0883608088,
-0.0129316496,
0.0319368243,
-0.0428981185,
0.0318750404,
0.0312322881,
0.046795439,
-0.0189121552,
-0.0089206453,
-0.0342794843,
-0.0145707652,
-0.0481456704,
0.0164760798,
0.0156107079,
0.0284558292,
0.0115504311,
0.0326872058,
0.0174637698,
-0.0988649428,
0.0649833828,
-0.0295936596,
-0.0393200368,
0.034752883,
0.0237191021,
-0.0008250418,
-0.0037888677,
-0.0286714826,
0.0412331372,
0.0069533633,
-0.0510760471,
-0.0380796418,
-0.0462244265,
0.0135768987,
-0.013923876,
0.0371925794,
-0.0540833026,
-0.0068360325,
0.0528132915,
-0.0322416835,
0.0052775694,
0.0248741619,
-0.0352942273,
-0.0000409005,
-0.0236746669,
0.0313349366,
-0.0119229686,
0.0356856696,
-0.0235078465,
0.022752367,
-0.0030467857,
0.013172403,
0.0002761685,
0.0233204514,
0.0381467603,
-0.0050893929,
-0.0030841075,
0.005913971,
-0.0128866341,
-0.0011668855,
0.014895088,
-0.0036489367,
-0.0086921081,
-0.0531247146,
-0.0250928681,
0.0177171081,
-0.0097005013,
0.0100589423,
0.0569677837,
-0.0310833789,
-0.0006912031,
0.0256752577,
-0.0232656095,
-0.0540161468,
-0.0081423856,
0.0102964211,
0.0190286413,
-0.0365326554,
0.0275908243,
-0.0254170317,
-0.0031395175,
-0.0372047722,
0.0391185731,
0.0587624051,
-0.0470023081,
-0.0333094634,
0.0642159656,
0.0154959532,
0.0043179574,
-0.0079006059,
-0.0655151308,
-0.0114482958,
0.0011817636,
0.026276825,
0.128744781,
0.0154683795,
0.024059739,
0.046472773,
0.0414449684,
-0.0087466361,
-0.0228588358,
-0.0029079225,
0.0455805957,
-0.0209691133,
-0.0418864526,
0.0251658373,
-0.0009006766,
0.0479457937,
-0.0398589782,
0.0015499975,
0.0602832399,
-0.0308031794,
-0.0203813836,
0.0215282906,
-0.0356916338,
-0.0288301799,
-0.0257216934,
-0.0370025598,
-0.0268555582,
0.0507109091,
-0.0328296423,
0.0362717435,
-0.0169948339,
-0.0162476189,
-0.0084638409,
0.0182852857,
0.0045075868,
0.0157922115,
-0.0031552895,
0.019585669,
-0.0444165878,
0.0160102565,
0.0547439307,
-0.0169717167,
0.0056959745,
-0.0068242387,
0.0027349959,
-0.0057953694,
-0.0060942387,
-0.0524112023,
-0.0871802121,
0.018011136,
-0.0016278079,
-0.0026044731,
-0.0338613912,
-0.0367103294,
-0.0443801284,
0.0077748387,
0.0787998289,
-0.071324341,
-0.002300235,
-0.0199412256,
0.0613180548,
0.0491759665,
-0.0805304274,
0.0013877064,
-0.0291606076,
0.0458185039,
0.0910111368,
-0.0075748796,
0.0573649816,
0.0111040743,
-0.0411890745,
-0.0165627953,
-0.0110700894,
-0.0005544316,
-0.0174438208,
0.0133218383,
-0.0769341141,
-0.0185926873,
0.0677100196,
0.0066256886,
-0.0124009373,
0.0019334514,
0.0213892814,
0.0202785451,
0.0065742587,
-0.0085459463,
-0.0672737584,
-0.0064675459,
0.007267809,
0.0384899527,
-0.0411705375,
-0.0247251932,
-0.0259789545,
-0.0768606663,
0.0147219133,
0.0281496383,
0.0125340801,
-0.0338807516,
-0.0193540398,
-0.0256774966,
0.006368299,
-0.0281028282,
-0.0445020869,
0.0101131657,
0.0091202138,
0.0105244294,
0.000835161,
-0.0476690717,
-0.0498196483,
-0.0338566862,
0.0212954935,
0.0573977716,
0.0647426918,
-0.0153851155,
-0.0517376736,
0.0259021204,
-0.0012365488,
-0.0399427935,
-0.0054123932,
0.0656638369,
-0.020722568,
0.0103000114,
0.0075266422,
0.0619655028,
-0.0178984106,
-0.0082661258,
0.0641078278,
0.0342311375,
-0.012947307,
-0.0546716191,
-0.0248345118,
-0.0017921448,
0.0280424487,
0.0738965198,
0.040557649,
-0.053989742,
-0.0428114124,
-0.0614107959,
0.0079895593,
-0.09708184,
-0.0297139939,
0.016669048,
-0.0097164726,
-0.0075911316,
-0.0669011325,
-0.0473717116,
-0.0102410242,
-0.0020630348,
0.0332408845,
0.0179516673,
-0.045584403,
-0.0336471312,
-0.0401499234,
-0.0288707614,
-0.0160128009,
0.0430080481,
-0.0067109112,
-0.0304405373,
-0.0114811137,
-0.0012670254,
-0.010360687,
0.0301277116,
-0.0977352187,
-0.0695712268,
0.0587403364,
0.013633471,
0.0087538064,
0.0231103245,
-0.0244290791,
-0.0524760894,
0.0595952645,
0.037482515,
0.0154061485,
0.0293817911,
0.0299379751,
-0.046118699,
0.0098820236,
0.0332383215,
-0.0000824252,
-0.0103097055,
0.0592248179,
-0.0135433609,
-0.0313958637,
0.0073758825,
0.0070067067,
0.0312562473,
0.0100392299,
-0.0379382893,
0.0192557462,
-0.0254804734,
-0.002745189,
-0.0379169844,
-0.0086347843,
-0.0422165059,
0.0061671622,
0.0537313856,
0.0028091373,
0.0024363776,
0.023770621,
-0.0252958406,
0.0335082524,
-0.028892206,
0.0259854663,
-0.0235458575,
0.0625084639,
0.0235344507,
0.0191452708,
-0.0172843151,
0.0500988364,
0.0116446288,
0.019808298,
-0.0046085473,
0.0205890443,
0.0286342315,
-0.010417955,
0.0344792232,
0.0454430133,
-0.0942227766,
0.0298194867,
-0.0535667352,
0.0279641058,
0.0281233471,
0.006143657,
0.0334100537,
-0.0390917435,
-0.0199302733,
-0.0203538407,
0.0440967679,
0.0202501733,
-0.0329724289,
-0.0250477362,
-0.0208790358,
-0.0093710423,
0.0534390807,
0.0845093206,
0.0066341814,
0.0607450493,
0.0315498114,
-0.0200429261,
-0.023397686,
-0.0134806251,
0.0410775989,
-0.0070040394,
0.0236670952,
-0.0064881942,
-0.0292013157,
-0.0616489127,
0.0047831857,
0.0237060264,
0.00683136,
-0.0157167651,
-0.0232701153,
0.0477871932,
-0.0304506365,
0.0387312435,
-0.0634055063,
0.0377142504,
0.0012377904,
-0.05735524,
-0.0152824624,
-5.122131043e-33,
0.0011918491,
-0.0706102178,
-0.0451973639,
0.0359528325,
0.001412534,
0.02470042,
-0.0392891616,
-0.0263115652,
0.000622695,
0.0106595475,
-0.0025387474,
0.0345725194,
-0.0231332202,
0.0346108675,
-0.0216355063,
-0.0198795088,
0.0771247223,
-0.0201399662,
-0.0398362018,
0.0046727629,
0.0245678779,
0.0147647494,
0.0435281247,
-0.0476592109,
0.0401652157,
-0.0455141179,
-0.0574573614,
-0.0214126706,
-0.0558886304,
0.0503492095,
0.0034671696,
0.028483538,
0.0143962093,
0.0228240639,
-0.0046942947,
0.0235526059,
0.0043424121,
-0.0200755782,
-0.0132760676,
0.0067207864,
-0.0140050575,
-0.1023488268,
0.049279023,
-0.0284827258,
-0.0150984675,
-0.008127342,
0.0297176875,
-0.0128532648,
-0.0133619234,
-0.0335725918,
-0.039918568,
0.0122810602,
-0.0181174818,
-0.0095516006,
-0.0078728804,
0.0575700998,
0.01967372,
0.001295981,
-0.0582058132,
0.023766892,
0.0178823285,
0.0413531028,
0.012090968,
-0.0314236991,
-0.002266811,
0.0518823899,
0.0415487997,
0.0255054943,
-0.0088202097,
-0.0146778505,
0.0233670082,
-0.016011972,
0.1014810801,
0.0944329798,
0.0446246527,
-0.0454414077,
-0.0422313921,
0.0252926089,
0.0110383546,
-0.018560458,
0.0141443275,
-0.0293107666,
-0.037763156,
0.0052067451,
-0.0131497364,
-0.1027806997,
-0.0207716487,
-0.0244054757,
0.0503101647,
-0.0013629351,
-0.0415860303,
-0.0058405963,
-0.0141107496,
-0.0629067197,
-0.021288408,
0.0287726279,
-0.0508335531,
-0.0146978982,
0.0026679928,
0.0145557988,
0.002721522,
0.0242150985,
0.0271362457,
-0.0077503556,
0.038913928,
-0.0112604648,
0.0860053897,
0.0519615859,
-0.0549664833,
0.0016617527,
-0.0231923852,
0.0253678598,
0.041967649,
-0.0078237252,
0.0058117523,
-0.017980637,
-0.0023709389,
0.0002275513,
0.0264242329,
0.0240161326,
-0.0371721946,
-0.0013206605,
0.0062889433,
0.0251207445,
-0.0288644359,
-0.0360538736,
-0.0374219604,
0.0264853537,
0.0173013024,
-0.1043351591,
0.003802082,
-0.0497879535,
2.523e-7,
0.0047540446,
0.0453345142,
0.0161578655,
-0.0365384854,
0.0184739791,
0.0443530194,
-0.0073757456,
0.034599252,
-0.0082644969,
0.0408950038,
-0.0058802799,
-0.0122470055,
0.065534763,
0.0105384625,
-0.0939451009,
0.0358902588,
-0.0608071499,
0.0105090151,
-0.0601304099,
-0.0021801249,
0.0551593043,
0.0665529221,
0.0305426139,
-0.03634407,
-0.0056858882,
-0.0746486336,
0.0239950735,
0.0234635789,
-0.0119760148,
0.0128929149,
0.0601810329,
-0.0254544001,
0.0311107952,
-0.0077454252,
-0.0565765537,
-0.0173665266,
0.0216670763,
0.0528834127,
0.0078963097,
-0.0076357974,
-0.0062389565,
-0.0351947285,
-0.0003831729,
-0.069575794,
0.0824627802,
0.0241607819,
0.0051888824,
-0.0497372858,
-0.030964328,
-0.0334232636,
0.0233323257,
-0.0382201895,
-0.0125551643,
-0.0017910635,
0.012253942,
0.0152272061,
0.0143115371,
-0.011157156,
-0.0232741777,
-0.0660768971,
-0.0100068254,
0.0038196212,
-0.0333132111,
0.0053166663,
0.0351074226,
-0.0243748613,
0.0122787338,
2.478511472e-34,
0.0362558551,
-0.0361791067,
0.0335934497,
0.0003722428,
0.020011425,
0.0072421771,
0.0190905035,
-0.00017312,
-0.0089840218,
-0.0106500713,
-0.0187417679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00402v1 | Investigating Bias Representations in Llama 2 Chat via Activation Steering | 2024-02-01T07:48:50 | 2024-02-01T07:48:50 | Dawn Lu, Nina Rimsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address the challenge of societal bias in Large Language Models (LLMs),
focusing on the Llama 2 7B Chat model. As LLMs are increasingly integrated into
decision-making processes with substantial societal impact, it becomes
imperative to ensure these models do not reinforce existing biases. Our
approach employs activation steering to probe for and mitigate biases related
to gender, race, and religion. This method manipulates model activations to
direct responses towards or away from biased outputs, utilizing steering
vectors derived from the StereoSet dataset and custom GPT4 generated gender
bias prompts. Our findings reveal inherent gender bias in Llama 2 7B Chat,
persisting even after Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). We
also observe a predictable negative correlation between bias and the model's
tendency to refuse responses. Significantly, our study uncovers that RLHF tends
to increase the similarity in the model's representation of different forms of
societal biases, which raises questions about the model's nuanced understanding
of different forms of bias. This work also provides valuable insights into
effective red-teaming strategies for LLMs using activation steering,
particularly emphasizing the importance of integrating a refusal vector. | Investigating Bias Representations in Llama 2 Chat via Activation Steering: We address the challenge of societal bias in Large Language Models (LLMs),
focusing on the Llama 2 7B Chat model. As LLMs are increasingly integrated into
decision-making processes with substantial societal impact, it becomes
imperative to ensure these models do not reinforce existing biases. Our
approach employs activation steering to probe for and mitigate biases related
to gender, race, and religion. This method manipulates model activations to
direct responses towards or away from biased outputs, utilizing steering
vectors derived from the StereoSet dataset and custom GPT4 generated gender
bias prompts. Our findings reveal inherent gender bias in Llama 2 7B Chat,
persisting even after Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). We
also observe a predictable negative correlation between bias and the model's
tendency to refuse responses. Significantly, our study uncovers that RLHF tends
to increase the similarity in the model's representation of different forms of
societal biases, which raises questions about the model's nuanced understanding
of different forms of bias. This work also provides valuable insights into
effective red-teaming strategies for LLMs using activation steering,
particularly emphasizing the importance of integrating a refusal vector. | [
0.0769641846,
0.0543015487,
-0.032893341,
0.0216836277,
0.0103543662,
0.0181647148,
0.0334617868,
-0.0178557225,
0.0650870651,
-0.0482903644,
-0.0515446477,
-0.0237809587,
0.0097958623,
0.0309785213,
0.0021358228,
-0.028541496,
0.0279136375,
0.0057626185,
0.0459145345,
-0.0453098156,
0.01408171,
0.0270646624,
0.0274912901,
0.0582773499,
0.0126427654,
-0.0103754345,
0.0247914456,
0.0089156535,
0.0100765899,
-0.0153148035,
0.0535855852,
0.0591638163,
-0.0008261793,
0.0514602587,
0.0000021578,
-0.0749357343,
0.0198301356,
-0.0274833497,
-0.012541783,
0.005277745,
0.0643095523,
0.0246473923,
-0.0220371578,
0.0257686488,
-0.0359990075,
0.0211261883,
0.0382329263,
0.0590860024,
0.0432771854,
0.022696292,
-0.0021490469,
0.0122709814,
-0.0510915704,
-0.0273392722,
0.0153597686,
-0.014751384,
0.042133905,
-0.0279705059,
-0.0395051315,
0.0058645317,
-0.046022065,
-0.0118873259,
0.0319108292,
-0.0083625698,
-0.0076237251,
0.0340148583,
-0.0121577885,
-0.0659615025,
-0.013689707,
0.0810281411,
0.0237052068,
-0.0074686543,
0.023481939,
-0.0029283671,
0.0100971134,
-0.0139112398,
-0.039764747,
0.0139359282,
-0.0051835799,
0.0147503968,
-0.0024765392,
-0.012983242,
0.0336947516,
0.033839412,
-0.0093689375,
0.0676761642,
-0.0148808332,
-0.0274034645,
0.0042125345,
0.0333380476,
0.0517903231,
-0.0572196022,
-0.0011825267,
-0.0273926016,
-0.0437267758,
-0.0020409583,
-0.0004627855,
0.0564235821,
0.0295865294,
-0.0736542791,
-0.0022172481,
0.0674853921,
-0.0089558288,
0.0181702133,
0.0238068439,
0.0005659868,
-0.0143012311,
0.0305524468,
-0.0026664382,
0.0049215523,
-0.022597257,
-0.0030686071,
0.0042415271,
-0.000871157,
0.0009890873,
0.0189333372,
-0.0477280878,
0.0120964926,
-0.0673300922,
-0.0021321899,
-0.0282731932,
0.0223735087,
-0.0216018129,
0.0180040542,
-0.0616203956,
0.015182321,
-0.0645505339,
0.023766052,
-0.0188894868,
-0.1097457632,
0.0109458193,
0.0174291618,
-0.0289586689,
-0.0334337354,
-0.0091174766,
0.0576016046,
-0.0077896076,
-0.0299986023,
-0.0055768667,
-0.0114416191,
-0.0148518076,
-0.0718128383,
0.0188368969,
-0.0301165488,
0.0606113039,
0.0171355605,
-0.0024981785,
-0.0156218847,
0.0025388733,
0.0199011508,
-0.0350277573,
0.0824052393,
0.0783316493,
-0.0048867292,
0.0597053096,
0.0362798907,
-0.0554147996,
0.1136785969,
0.0167640429,
0.0293837171,
0.0350797214,
0.008328761,
0.0226896685,
0.020633366,
0.032433141,
0.0340653025,
-0.0473742113,
0.0288572293,
-0.0277648941,
0.0144640617,
0.0751422122,
0.0220129769,
-0.0467589758,
-0.0258656219,
0.0486821309,
0.0685990527,
-0.0178511124,
0.0165255852,
-0.0009244051,
0.0138476063,
-0.0312141199,
0.0183224678,
-0.10256733,
0.040157415,
-0.0142778344,
-0.0569553301,
0.0286760423,
0.0600880086,
-0.0338798501,
-0.0213343892,
0.0360492207,
0.0027555556,
0.0453479774,
0.0289700702,
0.0020875819,
-0.0145273302,
-0.0101839434,
0.0152878528,
0.041769512,
-0.0125461863,
-0.0200355649,
-0.0904468074,
0.0558742285,
0.0205405056,
0.0222340748,
-0.0092430376,
-0.0182534531,
-0.0381576456,
-0.0342136063,
0.0560082048,
0.0681730956,
-0.0018069043,
-0.0190389529,
-0.0430912748,
-0.0641395301,
0.0393964425,
0.0110813128,
0.0340048298,
0.0460331589,
0.0205778126,
-0.0066331425,
0.0254060198,
-0.033584822,
0.0171563141,
0.0279162731,
-0.0040818034,
-0.0100549348,
0.0020182119,
0.0676658005,
-0.0110898828,
-0.0050600511,
-0.0239188876,
-0.0207914244,
0.0137333618,
-0.0252741408,
0.0141011653,
-0.0629696697,
-0.0028491532,
0.0077305874,
-0.0436518677,
-0.057918191,
0.0464788415,
-0.0147098517,
0.0228305049,
0.0550872721,
0.0171460565,
0.025135126,
-0.0052098515,
-0.0222687833,
-0.0161767658,
0.029902285,
-0.0339411981,
0.0112918392,
-0.0381317288,
-0.0423062965,
-0.0075066807,
-0.054677818,
0.0122615965,
-0.0372832417,
0.0141420113,
0.056742657,
0.0153602008,
-0.0010433157,
0.032243114,
-0.0148743456,
-0.0239711907,
-0.0255824756,
-0.0552227832,
-0.0414729193,
-0.0022010435,
-0.0187485293,
0.0017410344,
-0.0021376468,
-0.0144183803,
-0.0128882332,
-0.0375121795,
-0.0145344129,
0.043236617,
0.0712273344,
0.0060197478,
-0.0455448851,
-0.0255556628,
-0.0519532114,
-0.0125399465,
-0.02241165,
0.0462952256,
0.044174064,
-0.0344411395,
-0.0257310495,
-0.0715590343,
-0.0441299602,
0.0118543236,
-0.0263113398,
-0.0380472951,
0.0258458946,
0.0523233674,
0.0197842754,
0.0546581484,
0.0247530676,
0.0414850675,
0.0544235297,
0.0337253027,
-0.0621365383,
-0.009399076,
-0.0098709511,
0.0085012093,
-0.0057811537,
-0.0608134754,
-0.0104455315,
0.0353416726,
0.031206999,
0.0034827103,
-0.0555443652,
0.0367567614,
-0.0392454602,
-0.086580947,
-0.0275869016,
-0.0443215631,
-0.0049509467,
0.0559121333,
-0.051346872,
-0.0625189319,
0.061098475,
0.0459068865,
0.0001511072,
-0.0253402572,
0.0360259712,
-0.0514322743,
0.0093271732,
-0.0137255378,
0.0254213717,
0.0205941088,
-0.0060922503,
-0.057583116,
-0.0578906313,
0.0031802647,
-0.0365190096,
0.0383048542,
-0.0076842513,
0.0071752341,
0.0040309816,
-0.0346220285,
-0.0550028831,
-0.006539267,
-0.0263264813,
-0.0140640698,
0.006831645,
0.0004409406,
-0.0054495186,
0.0112324152,
0.0092916163,
-0.0072247102,
-0.0169016086,
-0.0090698116,
0.0009500023,
-0.0267755724,
0.0291938391,
0.0156987216,
0.0504154675,
-0.038181074,
0.0326133817,
0.0322924331,
-0.010450582,
-0.0022634212,
0.0122853527,
0.0073853652,
0.0391987637,
0.0100601614,
0.0015478808,
0.0033759421,
0.0380803645,
-0.0187705588,
0.015096345,
0.0683792159,
0.0154545456,
-0.1069384962,
0.0106527042,
-0.0354416184,
0.028470559,
0.0300602019,
0.0188744254,
-0.1167741939,
0.0004728579,
0.0225215089,
0.0033424855,
-0.0384284444,
-0.0379413553,
0.0157299396,
-0.1283948869,
0.0311883055,
0.011397169,
-0.027131971,
-0.0408189483,
-0.0267428737,
0.011911395,
-0.0287207421,
0.0414003022,
-0.0147617171,
0.0243316833,
0.0062600006,
-0.0231201388,
-0.0235415995,
-0.025670398,
0.0432600155,
-0.0468923785,
0.0806463808,
0.0540645458,
0.0577961244,
-0.0066800439,
0.0266231652,
0.0586415939,
0.0014183428,
-0.0162742324,
-0.017028641,
0.0231527183,
-0.0270819832,
-0.0093383202,
-0.0321735814,
0.0418942273,
0.0403893813,
0.0014205866,
-0.0066230088,
0.0443569198,
-0.0079776021,
-0.0349578373,
-0.0348141454,
0.0227117352,
0.0371865258,
0.071749866,
0.0198556874,
-0.0621601157,
-0.0138522256,
-0.0688295364,
-0.0064512193,
0.0371441692,
-0.0953454897,
-0.02744288,
0.0037817515,
-0.0336994939,
-0.0338502899,
-0.0616601706,
0.0121511109,
-0.018405607,
0.0134926932,
-0.0505717099,
-0.0029559259,
-0.0004876723,
0.0277131535,
0.0327469222,
-0.0419723466,
0.0256806463,
-0.015629584,
0.0014088561,
-0.0391686447,
-0.0683790669,
-0.0036829233,
0.0164019912,
-0.0094224149,
-0.0586226285,
0.050097663,
0.0448706187,
0.029068457,
0.0474390611,
-0.0021356919,
-0.0435694195,
0.0327698216,
0.0472633652,
-0.0284510609,
0.0369987302,
0.0558346733,
0.0851811171,
-0.0092110885,
0.0347601362,
-0.0180313494,
0.0567777939,
0.0162486471,
-0.0196139589,
-0.0464223102,
-0.0055227913,
0.0029160462,
-0.035698276,
0.0388218686,
-0.0214403942,
-0.0039457688,
-0.0506482832,
-0.0049541802,
-0.00113256,
-0.0294121187,
0.0028621843,
-0.0395888723,
0.018215334,
0.0014974739,
-0.0134443808,
-0.0397751816,
-0.037731763,
-0.0082020946,
-0.0084448708,
0.0237574149,
0.0570559464,
0.0544324666,
-0.0249495842,
0.0007789905,
0.0063228696,
0.0478006974,
-0.0244074184,
0.0069981259,
0.0218992829,
0.0567695126,
0.0347884297,
-0.0104600042,
0.0082445955,
0.003747666,
-0.0222086813,
-0.0535542369,
0.0237025861,
0.0355531313,
0.0143911978,
0.0047716335,
0.0239174385,
0.0113229388,
-0.0146048851,
0.0050430177,
-0.0095548518,
-0.0053135417,
0.0065590502,
0.0464296266,
0.0065982961,
-0.0069027366,
0.0037449817,
0.0323045142,
0.0044920929,
0.0704063475,
-0.0119531564,
-0.0221302062,
-0.0224161688,
-0.0407341868,
0.0458225012,
-0.0095308274,
-0.0160726104,
0.0052996343,
-0.0944138244,
-0.0374776572,
-0.0326515175,
0.0065307231,
0.0100932131,
-0.0537950695,
0.0074753123,
0.0410091132,
-0.0169087183,
-0.0139094852,
-0.0155606698,
-0.0447580032,
-0.0358718559,
-0.014174141,
-0.0255152863,
-6.955183342e-33,
-0.012792605,
-0.0287368242,
-0.0072446945,
-0.0107445354,
-0.0351312943,
-0.025660757,
-0.0134940855,
0.0076252404,
-0.0252439547,
0.0212051719,
-0.0051022582,
0.0336150415,
0.0119976178,
-0.0337413549,
0.0275643766,
-0.0192300491,
0.0543331727,
-0.0279807467,
-0.0374016166,
0.0168828089,
-0.0051355325,
0.0019881153,
0.0247829165,
-0.0817659497,
0.0504472218,
0.0084596639,
-0.0264785103,
0.0075497478,
-0.0391734205,
0.0369812921,
-0.0490463749,
0.0517229773,
0.0198590625,
-0.0472741537,
0.0168725159,
0.0791967884,
-0.0394158512,
-0.0531105921,
0.0218761917,
0.0031473821,
-0.0128697976,
-0.0311757699,
0.0172159057,
0.0058515137,
-0.0663909018,
0.0047913105,
0.0381479226,
0.0057901745,
0.0241964962,
0.0451612324,
-0.0690912455,
-0.0034867304,
-0.0218540803,
-0.0074558984,
-0.0114541175,
0.0508481041,
-0.0087869009,
0.0293816365,
-0.0470240563,
0.0236251112,
0.0008737827,
-0.0337089077,
0.0258978605,
0.0472252183,
0.027335709,
0.0380926803,
0.0646748915,
0.0425422415,
-0.047949817,
-0.0987452939,
0.0347633697,
-0.0132417949,
0.0124327913,
0.0592020974,
0.0125598749,
-0.0185682178,
-0.0457608029,
-0.0232586339,
0.0936910659,
0.0212685838,
0.0536447167,
-0.0078108436,
-0.0705058351,
-0.0442930311,
-0.0291065555,
-0.0814812332,
-0.0279510878,
-0.0319277123,
0.0310645886,
0.0276845638,
-0.0342300832,
-0.0067967996,
0.032076519,
-0.0471470207,
-0.026088234,
0.0173614975,
0.0109491451,
-0.0202465486,
0.0358182788,
-0.0277613141,
-0.0913605243,
0.0113950726,
-0.0026641372,
-0.0029872335,
0.0048893308,
0.0091994135,
-0.0198882297,
0.0197356325,
-0.0593602471,
-0.0024691685,
-0.0333233774,
0.0279570445,
0.0246783234,
-0.0005166084,
0.0291285086,
0.0115088811,
0.0019830144,
0.0195698868,
0.0328396671,
0.0157041308,
-0.0190948974,
0.0030652944,
-0.0514549017,
0.0476742238,
-0.0407494865,
-0.0127073647,
-0.0215658788,
0.0073167696,
0.0277232956,
-0.0593117923,
-0.0423202775,
-0.0549373068,
2.785e-7,
-0.0292950552,
0.0628176406,
0.0054816892,
0.0349257886,
0.0296934005,
0.0603641048,
0.0219927765,
0.0570206679,
0.0626353621,
-0.0194972027,
0.0053964159,
0.0502200089,
0.0042526308,
0.0199390277,
-0.0418700948,
0.0042293984,
-0.0878554508,
0.0245324001,
-0.0215723626,
-0.0178193636,
0.004399166,
0.0792884454,
0.0468136854,
-0.0121922567,
-0.0242823157,
0.0498048253,
0.0603414103,
-0.069623217,
0.0016312124,
0.0047248653,
0.0121867741,
-0.0141586261,
0.0000144047,
0.0314686671,
0.0329156853,
0.0203890987,
-0.0339635685,
0.0349442549,
0.0064493306,
-0.0171159096,
-0.0105602108,
0.0209044795,
-0.0133535536,
-0.0710736662,
0.0712515414,
-0.038199719,
-0.0343580917,
-0.0561229177,
0.0140197417,
-0.0186391883,
0.063241899,
0.0081448983,
-0.0337447077,
-0.0063308249,
0.0120726898,
0.0237562358,
-0.0017985222,
-0.0684911981,
-0.0098955538,
-0.0438751392,
-0.0257179923,
-0.0711198077,
-0.0171802808,
0.0462973863,
-0.0135815656,
-0.0310059972,
0.0275124256,
2.464769208e-34,
0.0303436909,
-0.0172045305,
0.0207330603,
-0.0176626127,
0.0432165638,
0.0068074339,
0.0023888038,
-0.0140724694,
0.0740758553,
-0.026617758,
0.0136913909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00396v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00396v2 | Efficient Exploration for LLMs | 2024-02-01T07:32:24 | 2024-06-04T18:35:09 | Vikranth Dwaracherla, Seyed Mohammad Asghari, Botao Hao, Benjamin Van Roy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME, stat.ML | We present evidence of substantial benefit from efficient exploration in
gathering human feedback to improve large language models. In our experiments,
an agent sequentially generates queries while fitting a reward model to the
feedback received. Our best-performing agent generates queries using double
Thompson sampling, with uncertainty represented by an epistemic neural network.
Our results demonstrate that efficient exploration enables high levels of
performance with far fewer queries. Further, both uncertainty estimation and
the choice of exploration scheme play critical roles. | Efficient Exploration for LLMs: We present evidence of substantial benefit from efficient exploration in
gathering human feedback to improve large language models. In our experiments,
an agent sequentially generates queries while fitting a reward model to the
feedback received. Our best-performing agent generates queries using double
Thompson sampling, with uncertainty represented by an epistemic neural network.
Our results demonstrate that efficient exploration enables high levels of
performance with far fewer queries. Further, both uncertainty estimation and
the choice of exploration scheme play critical roles. | [
0.0453223623,
0.0739071816,
-0.0236665122,
0.0208459366,
-0.0449497253,
-0.0104345279,
-0.0560436659,
-0.0058698375,
-0.004172801,
-0.0137063731,
-0.0404447913,
-0.0430039018,
-0.0403299518,
-0.0153239537,
0.0241204556,
-0.0186790843,
0.0163772739,
-0.0803434402,
0.02402406,
-0.0258948226,
-0.044381734,
-0.0360537171,
0.0010011051,
0.0415310077,
0.020747263,
0.0347457491,
-0.0631054938,
0.014970379,
-0.0333003998,
-0.0342599452,
-0.0541657247,
0.0294171423,
0.0186918881,
0.0659544691,
0.0000017665,
-0.0431362279,
-0.0024869766,
-0.0039743036,
-0.0560218506,
-0.0034333521,
0.0128660724,
0.0349050388,
0.003881027,
0.0191009138,
-0.0386190452,
0.0300192293,
0.0118725412,
0.0025022901,
0.0262585934,
0.0429682732,
0.0342403203,
0.0019271143,
-0.021620715,
-0.0267190058,
0.0639774874,
-0.0674754381,
0.0055688904,
-0.0342932902,
0.0878835395,
0.0351021066,
0.0096535776,
0.0238869395,
0.0448609143,
-0.0314052626,
-0.0256852675,
0.0249732696,
0.0220462698,
-0.0275263954,
-0.0088111879,
0.0261019468,
0.0161127746,
0.0265929438,
-0.0122616319,
-0.0184363425,
0.0270775892,
0.0185153019,
-0.0289989468,
0.0468873382,
-0.0032807281,
0.0242913328,
0.0337383337,
-0.0073694354,
0.0464898162,
0.0260780118,
-0.0334000029,
0.0914254263,
-0.0098246578,
-0.0372085907,
0.0286522508,
0.0263399966,
-0.0196540076,
-0.0333164111,
-0.01603215,
0.037999291,
-0.0588029474,
0.036633566,
-0.027132282,
0.0047449959,
-0.0011649992,
0.0266822334,
0.0687411577,
0.0332150906,
0.0376510397,
0.0471641123,
0.0133713111,
0.0097458279,
-0.0200231876,
0.0628383234,
-0.0316519439,
-0.0013637607,
-0.0453432128,
-0.001636542,
-0.0531060472,
0.0753775313,
-0.0449924581,
-0.0143180499,
-0.0274204891,
0.0507622994,
0.0385978147,
0.0022931576,
-0.0029216909,
-0.0171472598,
-0.0132932179,
0.0058725029,
-0.0743214041,
-0.0515435003,
-0.0377513915,
0.0158805549,
0.0305733867,
-0.0657501444,
-0.0303214826,
0.001964916,
-0.032738436,
-0.0198689103,
-0.0156022543,
0.0930564106,
0.0001828412,
-0.0609335266,
-0.0872523785,
-0.0160512403,
0.0110768331,
-0.0246540774,
0.0055024135,
-0.0546803437,
0.0125598926,
-0.0321504064,
-0.0464327671,
-0.0131484084,
0.0089207422,
0.0180698019,
-0.03787205,
0.0742530823,
-0.023469748,
0.0185406394,
0.0182043351,
-0.0072235507,
0.0212207176,
0.094209522,
0.0483491123,
0.0474388227,
0.0295655318,
0.0522170328,
0.0309326481,
0.0272330754,
0.0182343647,
0.0076904348,
-0.0136493444,
-0.0098334029,
-0.0328587182,
0.0883744881,
-0.0040066112,
0.0875794068,
-0.0524697341,
0.003350382,
0.0656922087,
0.0429201275,
0.0358648337,
-0.045282729,
0.0444481336,
-0.0120965363,
0.0074544791,
-0.0138130328,
-0.0405904837,
0.0196466986,
0.0096455812,
0.019116573,
0.0283673424,
-0.041095607,
-0.0222824644,
-0.0635641366,
-0.0220975541,
0.0265961774,
0.0103690745,
0.0289988834,
0.043751169,
0.0018244166,
-0.0419864692,
0.0242933463,
0.0032968812,
-0.0292639341,
0.0015402806,
-0.0749240965,
0.0657561123,
0.069897145,
0.0559927858,
-0.0282023828,
0.0128566213,
-0.0081004715,
-0.0322575197,
0.0509699881,
0.0471192487,
-0.0198729001,
0.0333089195,
-0.0243178997,
-0.0181278773,
-0.018720394,
0.0096061295,
0.018850591,
0.0431011096,
-0.0124442,
-0.0182269048,
-0.0529232472,
-0.0215585716,
0.0396530665,
-0.021389287,
-0.0451521017,
0.0232377406,
-0.0132403662,
0.026223205,
0.0304069854,
0.0026433344,
0.0334263593,
0.0404222235,
-0.0023395785,
-0.0227594022,
0.0097419564,
-0.0320358984,
-0.0464752391,
0.0232242551,
-0.021661358,
0.0123545323,
-0.0059527927,
-0.0027299207,
-0.0378186777,
-0.0000440483,
-0.0807787925,
0.0579706617,
-0.0425984934,
0.0201345999,
-0.0054663029,
-0.0134456577,
-0.0719069988,
0.0478321016,
-0.0454217717,
-0.0110217026,
0.0392770171,
0.0276094489,
-0.0078882119,
-0.0980711877,
-0.0279440917,
0.0014975178,
0.0371413715,
0.0075495671,
0.0048180954,
0.0231412612,
-0.0386056565,
-0.037591368,
-0.0549698323,
-0.0040591811,
-0.0072131241,
0.0051583191,
-0.0058317408,
0.0164478403,
0.0024455979,
-0.0209808927,
-0.0101682106,
0.0111126956,
0.0281577986,
0.0330047943,
0.0510543995,
0.0657156855,
-0.0201450065,
-0.0558117293,
-0.0185341556,
0.0076008844,
0.0184842013,
0.0138559677,
0.0035391068,
-0.0689373687,
0.0014314682,
0.0047601536,
0.0238362718,
-0.0185623989,
-0.0147118932,
0.0477645285,
-0.0538408831,
-0.0450254008,
0.0474747308,
-0.003142589,
0.0560908355,
0.040299084,
-0.0180941988,
-0.0771587491,
0.0233786292,
-0.0096049104,
-0.0277419556,
-0.0197917875,
-0.0118948389,
0.0417243727,
0.0712293014,
0.00428101,
-0.0080177626,
-0.0287757237,
0.0460908115,
0.0161294825,
-0.0672044083,
-0.0510707274,
0.010313143,
-0.0266571511,
0.0456293076,
-0.0204697158,
-0.0533183143,
0.0947340429,
-0.0063033402,
0.0079446165,
-0.0151508367,
0.0038855639,
-0.0222671311,
0.0462498404,
-0.0129680298,
-0.001554143,
0.000812248,
-0.0395582058,
-0.0419333093,
-0.0040257787,
0.0339231193,
-0.0410537459,
0.0694324523,
-0.086042881,
0.0127115035,
0.0258781761,
-0.0336508602,
-0.0601191446,
-0.0263659954,
-0.0260841008,
0.0225244127,
0.0439319573,
-0.0198206343,
-0.029525796,
-0.018958319,
0.039955873,
0.0059602824,
0.0001534033,
-0.0290091112,
-0.0151574081,
-0.020325426,
0.0034143839,
0.0487476252,
0.0553034507,
-0.0503162183,
0.0327507854,
0.0347144976,
0.0335713476,
0.0249344856,
0.0044380086,
0.0134325298,
0.0316580273,
-0.0434508026,
-0.0169569273,
0.0441080555,
0.0306799076,
-0.0263508819,
-0.0271225236,
0.0969411507,
0.0328885727,
-0.037359722,
-0.006375364,
-0.0410725474,
0.0434955619,
0.023549743,
0.0614376999,
-0.076970458,
-0.0296253618,
0.0200239066,
0.0524140187,
-0.021530658,
-0.0498890951,
0.0125876013,
-0.1604642719,
0.0122945728,
-0.0082723117,
-0.0367041603,
0.0282404888,
-0.0148780597,
-0.0182901043,
-0.0147742536,
0.0139376167,
0.0565256327,
0.0126961675,
0.0045617511,
-0.0037399777,
0.0406047888,
-0.0411098376,
-0.0133618871,
-0.045903381,
0.0517720021,
0.0637358204,
0.0042857565,
-0.0083413208,
-0.0550653301,
-0.0196518172,
-0.0018046338,
0.0228758585,
-0.0217214748,
0.0231100358,
-0.0075411531,
-0.0170436986,
0.0033036622,
0.0275304448,
-0.0250233263,
0.0078186216,
-0.0108799459,
0.0495314971,
-0.0351053141,
0.0267357882,
-0.0132456301,
-0.0087745422,
0.0210450646,
0.0702770725,
0.0217329189,
-0.0459276959,
-0.0241579991,
-0.0477068722,
-0.0468508974,
-0.0631249994,
-0.0065879473,
0.0525123887,
0.0262526162,
0.0249216296,
-0.0671540126,
-0.0493996777,
0.0424179472,
0.0566029027,
-0.013035967,
0.0173401311,
-0.0205450244,
0.0018277972,
-0.014833414,
-0.0157457385,
-0.02413553,
0.0082084239,
-0.0631069168,
0.0107083702,
0.0269734859,
-0.0341451019,
0.0046175653,
0.0175436232,
-0.0862860158,
-0.0770923123,
-0.0041405316,
0.0723833591,
0.0309742577,
0.0474565737,
-0.0252084527,
-0.0510768034,
-0.0074661458,
0.0212394465,
-0.0075822542,
0.0185287222,
0.0249735694,
0.0552989691,
0.0074538784,
0.0476803631,
-0.0373623706,
-0.0200362168,
0.0201325938,
0.0436569117,
-0.0383513533,
-0.0421891175,
0.0238891151,
0.0223665629,
0.0307905022,
-0.018533539,
0.0044648745,
-0.0117984181,
0.0233451873,
-0.0243880432,
-0.0165067911,
-0.0599976145,
-0.0053236703,
0.0084557701,
-0.0193224847,
0.0034979437,
-0.0166754406,
-0.0075826836,
0.0377066545,
-0.0275596641,
-0.0015146944,
0.0032083632,
-0.0090062376,
0.0202104263,
0.0045110974,
0.0044725351,
0.0548478104,
-0.0097135175,
0.0436750315,
0.0175138414,
0.0347864777,
0.0240151826,
-0.0226614699,
0.0024007515,
-0.0009370959,
-0.0804370865,
-0.0933074355,
0.0134143997,
0.0557651147,
0.0568588711,
0.0331865996,
-0.0127219036,
-0.0348351747,
0.0191265624,
0.0274378583,
0.011862969,
-0.0001648129,
-0.0112166284,
0.0834162161,
0.0412100703,
-0.0043686498,
-0.0071068322,
0.0522091128,
0.0131652923,
0.0394600891,
-0.0331813768,
0.006854027,
-0.0482413881,
-0.0099747377,
0.0363950655,
0.0326805115,
-0.0208498333,
-0.0019417009,
-0.0194183923,
-0.0298227482,
0.0075306254,
0.0748645291,
0.0032052954,
-0.0275826156,
0.0652598515,
0.0633780286,
0.0279847272,
-0.0216472726,
-0.0445589051,
-0.0288183056,
-0.001141201,
-0.0331819654,
-0.0049687363,
-5.90253513e-33,
-0.0393938906,
-0.0280547217,
0.0489366055,
-0.0291549601,
-0.0516102798,
-0.0580714159,
-0.0321704,
0.0269622747,
-0.0169644579,
0.0059641865,
-0.0370167382,
0.0266125835,
0.0188024901,
0.0179591775,
0.0200173352,
-0.020506544,
0.0331485607,
0.0021826637,
-0.0048852605,
-0.0413136035,
0.0018223756,
0.0370509848,
0.0392526761,
-0.0066614035,
0.0140369609,
0.0144105321,
-0.0118775228,
0.0558982156,
-0.0307631474,
0.0505637415,
0.0052232565,
0.0063921092,
-0.0108223883,
-0.0557069331,
-0.0168808233,
-0.0378730185,
-0.0221903529,
-0.0433588065,
0.0306193344,
0.0115188649,
-0.0434795395,
-0.0190396644,
0.0531159751,
-0.0149348108,
-0.0315223783,
0.0619743392,
-0.0163540523,
-0.0192480255,
-0.0538388118,
0.0219754297,
0.0037679381,
0.0151030514,
0.0426285341,
0.0059085209,
0.0190118253,
-0.0031416025,
-0.0276682489,
-0.0321852081,
-0.0138622243,
0.0299620312,
0.0418182611,
0.0209173057,
0.025543008,
0.0518333726,
0.0301873963,
0.0270093102,
-0.0007506418,
-0.0025834555,
-0.0338620618,
0.0028660428,
0.0197182577,
0.0358350202,
0.0142459776,
0.0527731553,
-0.0079320669,
0.0407382473,
-0.0261768363,
0.0134126935,
0.0217197146,
0.0224402677,
0.0263824109,
0.0395485125,
-0.0319246575,
-0.0305814631,
-0.0668313876,
-0.0101848952,
-0.0307471268,
-0.0263791028,
0.0386286043,
0.033092849,
-0.0106334211,
-0.0637514889,
0.0038418188,
-0.0227864292,
-0.0055083078,
-0.0045664338,
-0.0129220914,
0.022844322,
-0.0141074536,
0.0050673299,
-0.0706680715,
-0.0076713893,
-0.0294439364,
0.015914876,
-0.0294849649,
0.0249890536,
-0.0448754355,
0.0399121083,
-0.0475111902,
-0.0044574589,
-0.0392354168,
0.0494209155,
-0.0094075575,
-0.0508430228,
0.0531495325,
-0.0494222939,
-0.0101389214,
0.0360599309,
-0.0200585183,
-0.0286621228,
-0.0119447,
-0.0021967534,
0.0134895863,
0.011662324,
-0.0067916047,
0.0110870469,
-0.0191216916,
0.010753707,
-0.0246768147,
-0.0535352416,
0.002310069,
0.0489662774,
2.594e-7,
-0.0019207835,
0.0165444165,
0.0067454642,
0.0609062724,
0.003993256,
0.0109562809,
-0.0198072679,
-0.0206389595,
-0.0193639789,
-0.0358301923,
0.0152170295,
0.0405595936,
0.0256685801,
0.0271141194,
-0.1044422984,
-0.0512895286,
-0.0177821759,
0.0041292673,
-0.0206207484,
-0.0183237791,
0.030774802,
0.0843136609,
0.0137839401,
-0.0012648416,
-0.0019979684,
-0.0588623472,
0.0723494291,
-0.0419693664,
-0.0322959982,
-0.0108419117,
0.0439944714,
0.0543992557,
-0.0034739445,
-0.0082813594,
0.0080816159,
0.0260156486,
-0.0334386341,
0.0296598934,
0.0271569472,
-0.0264474507,
-0.0050371322,
-0.0425472669,
0.0236591529,
-0.0134514039,
0.0344617218,
-0.0483653732,
-0.0099565033,
0.0085114585,
0.0782138184,
-0.0669258609,
0.0056928829,
-0.0481778681,
0.0005317003,
-0.0353507623,
0.0323504396,
0.0003147538,
0.0038754295,
-0.0792169943,
-0.0028351198,
-0.0105168317,
-0.0522854999,
-0.0326872915,
-0.0479012467,
-0.0201579258,
-0.0266233329,
-0.0625572652,
-0.0236080047,
2.088863334e-34,
0.0690038577,
-0.0064783422,
0.0074081859,
0.0640201494,
0.0233358704,
0.0287430752,
0.0202514958,
-0.0181577876,
0.0715621561,
-0.0850193352,
-0.0167892873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01771v1 | BlackMamba: Mixture of Experts for State-Space Models | 2024-02-01T07:15:58 | 2024-02-01T07:15:58 | Quentin Anthony, Yury Tokpanov, Paolo Glorioso, Beren Millidge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG | State-space models (SSMs) have recently demonstrated competitive performance
to transformers at large-scale language modeling benchmarks while achieving
linear time and memory complexity as a function of sequence length. Mamba, a
recently released SSM model, shows impressive performance in both language
modeling and long sequence processing tasks. Simultaneously, mixture-of-expert
(MoE) models have shown remarkable performance while significantly reducing the
compute and latency costs of inference at the expense of a larger memory
footprint. In this paper, we present BlackMamba, a novel architecture that
combines the Mamba SSM with MoE to obtain the benefits of both. We demonstrate
that BlackMamba performs competitively against both Mamba and transformer
baselines, and outperforms in inference and training FLOPs. We fully train and
open-source 340M/1.5B and 630M/2.8B BlackMamba models on 300B tokens of a
custom dataset. We show that BlackMamba inherits and combines both of the
benefits of SSM and MoE architectures, combining linear-complexity generation
from SSM with cheap and fast inference from MoE. We release all weights,
checkpoints, and inference code open-source. Inference code at:
https://github.com/Zyphra/BlackMamba | BlackMamba: Mixture of Experts for State-Space Models: State-space models (SSMs) have recently demonstrated competitive performance
to transformers at large-scale language modeling benchmarks while achieving
linear time and memory complexity as a function of sequence length. Mamba, a
recently released SSM model, shows impressive performance in both language
modeling and long sequence processing tasks. Simultaneously, mixture-of-expert
(MoE) models have shown remarkable performance while significantly reducing the
compute and latency costs of inference at the expense of a larger memory
footprint. In this paper, we present BlackMamba, a novel architecture that
combines the Mamba SSM with MoE to obtain the benefits of both. We demonstrate
that BlackMamba performs competitively against both Mamba and transformer
baselines, and outperforms in inference and training FLOPs. We fully train and
open-source 340M/1.5B and 630M/2.8B BlackMamba models on 300B tokens of a
custom dataset. We show that BlackMamba inherits and combines both of the
benefits of SSM and MoE architectures, combining linear-complexity generation
from SSM with cheap and fast inference from MoE. We release all weights,
checkpoints, and inference code open-source. Inference code at:
https://github.com/Zyphra/BlackMamba | [
0.0393292494,
0.0867921561,
0.0108525343,
0.0025371066,
-0.025921179,
-0.0063916827,
0.0470493622,
-0.032744173,
-0.0113013443,
-0.0353322476,
-0.0172358919,
-0.0486857519,
0.0296260323,
0.0330178328,
0.0245977193,
-0.049668137,
0.026968684,
-0.0400461182,
-0.0039318162,
-0.004580996,
-0.0038530419,
0.0113562811,
-0.0179645568,
0.0650411695,
0.0068386719,
0.0155466096,
-0.0452342667,
-0.017648818,
0.0083829481,
-0.0133573469,
-0.0009962957,
0.0734829307,
0.0282803066,
0.056724444,
0.0000019728,
-0.0043332935,
-0.0048039411,
0.0057046353,
-0.0184757505,
0.0160563085,
0.0047799023,
0.0113139935,
-0.0015190722,
0.0362027846,
-0.011388815,
-0.0405851603,
0.0624135546,
0.0145791285,
0.0445952527,
0.1345504373,
-0.0173864737,
-0.0168724153,
0.0389846079,
-0.0594889447,
-0.0316806287,
-0.0319615528,
0.0258663092,
-0.0213342477,
-0.0097060623,
-0.0180180203,
-0.0257153884,
0.0225501359,
0.0244162325,
0.0383731276,
-0.0243506264,
0.0385375619,
0.0263280571,
-0.0406454206,
-0.0210086089,
0.0484378077,
-0.0498978123,
-0.0228685252,
0.0121610258,
0.0135652367,
-0.0173244309,
0.0049673785,
-0.0124706216,
0.043444898,
-0.0144182462,
0.0323719308,
0.0054699932,
-0.0123077426,
0.0505298488,
0.0091010816,
-0.0750929043,
0.0432141759,
0.0247938745,
-0.0007395304,
-0.0380098112,
-0.0229809508,
0.0074652089,
-0.0755247772,
0.0197475404,
0.0364132002,
-0.0288342871,
0.0075257351,
-0.0450965539,
-0.0498674624,
-0.025698496,
-0.020427363,
0.0250668842,
0.0660540834,
-0.0265029576,
0.0425517671,
-0.0161633417,
0.0131755164,
-0.0369767994,
0.0226717424,
-0.0261999741,
-0.0134691726,
-0.0359242857,
0.0031774412,
-0.0078172563,
-0.0004950184,
-0.0268557165,
-0.0341546014,
-0.0555900335,
-0.0117501142,
-0.0017182532,
-0.0185742509,
0.0294568446,
0.0201693121,
-0.0474043787,
-0.003370885,
-0.0123786498,
0.0653253272,
0.0105449231,
0.0114713116,
0.0265212301,
-0.057261236,
-0.0186687168,
0.0343125351,
-0.0063357232,
-0.0128739392,
0.0247701388,
0.0429300778,
-0.0188527424,
-0.0711870641,
-0.026240021,
0.0261282362,
-0.0019901798,
-0.0937702432,
0.0247769449,
-0.0696200356,
0.0598545112,
0.0075062793,
0.0173972212,
-0.028360799,
0.0174018666,
0.0120880213,
-0.0262047276,
0.057663314,
-0.0123266624,
-0.0301940646,
0.0007546749,
0.0102014309,
-0.0326715745,
0.047265321,
0.0419542566,
0.0168195125,
-0.0162779335,
0.0081252065,
-0.0152934156,
0.0539825559,
-0.0091703515,
-0.0153844701,
-0.0417768806,
-0.0150824608,
-0.0258240588,
0.0191938374,
0.0385026112,
0.0732382536,
-0.0215681624,
-0.0138299558,
0.0478181764,
0.0349063091,
-0.0061576399,
0.0335937254,
0.0526944324,
0.0022295292,
0.0244496576,
-0.0067968401,
-0.0213154797,
0.0358011723,
-0.0136988936,
0.0143109476,
0.0666962042,
0.0940672755,
-0.0316886343,
-0.0052009714,
-0.0095009757,
-0.0218685009,
-0.0402914807,
0.0131229404,
0.0772794932,
-0.0254039429,
-0.0566016547,
0.068278715,
0.023098303,
-0.0376158059,
-0.0261406936,
-0.0592078827,
0.0398912355,
0.0458120555,
0.0275573656,
-0.0194656067,
-0.0092800567,
-0.0245876629,
-0.0195087586,
0.0371356718,
-0.0081257084,
0.0290208478,
0.0144408159,
-0.0793266669,
-0.034276329,
0.0351299495,
0.0195038542,
0.0419428535,
0.0565609224,
0.0045479862,
0.05245886,
-0.0039996458,
0.0059004873,
0.0223199017,
-0.0301237982,
0.0061567607,
0.0004803937,
-0.0054926374,
0.0624304265,
-0.0064850403,
-0.0277890619,
0.0197046474,
0.0261224937,
-0.0213074777,
-0.0236052927,
0.0001963381,
-0.074620828,
-0.0523795411,
0.0608013459,
-0.0044350047,
0.0372450612,
0.0311851893,
-0.0475381203,
-0.0944946483,
0.0125547135,
-0.0336565077,
0.045411814,
-0.0553166904,
-0.0079394234,
0.0382333361,
0.0508229099,
-0.005131634,
0.0454438291,
-0.0564181395,
-0.0053746677,
0.0220536124,
0.0036474066,
-0.0081626568,
0.0112370076,
-0.0326795243,
-0.0177529138,
0.0008542907,
0.02034669,
-0.0234732293,
-0.0192950256,
0.0079798037,
-0.0308502056,
-0.0949402377,
0.0219982732,
-0.0519429632,
0.0216903165,
0.0107735014,
0.0304796156,
0.0071042795,
0.0221427511,
-0.0183401406,
-0.0009350655,
-0.0069794036,
0.0042599351,
-0.025236737,
0.0073841098,
-0.0466439426,
-0.0533161759,
-0.0468029827,
-0.0082739061,
0.0595457815,
-0.0529788211,
-0.022895705,
-0.0214023646,
-0.0346971974,
-0.0180982687,
0.0507365502,
-0.0466743037,
-0.0293478705,
0.0094590234,
-0.0428282432,
0.0925480276,
0.0111374659,
0.0295985136,
0.0231435467,
0.0297566559,
-0.0147800753,
-0.004057725,
0.0301730633,
-0.0103991712,
0.0358028561,
-0.0485558659,
-0.0092318226,
-0.0392392129,
0.0954477713,
-0.0249185413,
-0.0279316436,
-0.0560546927,
-0.0394430198,
0.0344126374,
-0.013578577,
0.0288802944,
-0.0099053746,
-0.029545106,
0.0104122832,
-0.0276058596,
-0.0226014126,
0.0560690984,
-0.0698093325,
-0.0330554023,
-0.0063170018,
-0.0348000042,
-0.0382345878,
0.0371863507,
0.0284101665,
0.0054285228,
-0.0286587756,
0.023074368,
-0.027562689,
0.0197381936,
-0.0157375447,
-0.0223763827,
0.0076751234,
-0.0176655464,
0.0431270301,
-0.01450318,
-0.0176948309,
-0.0094429785,
0.0144738657,
-0.0705922246,
0.0113918753,
0.0366970338,
-0.0602248386,
-0.0581106953,
0.0602546632,
0.0123088956,
0.0852376074,
-0.0207860321,
0.0215305425,
-0.0228353143,
0.0470895767,
0.0473408289,
0.001031042,
0.0317398645,
-0.0524606109,
-0.0006986749,
0.0386889428,
0.0512003154,
-0.0063198507,
-0.0627017692,
-0.0192300007,
0.0320897363,
-0.0124657927,
-0.0198140647,
0.0500963889,
0.0072056856,
-0.0608638339,
-0.0031228475,
0.1137742996,
0.0040303539,
-0.0653464347,
-0.0082883863,
0.034463685,
0.0208435431,
0.0034393515,
0.018468827,
-0.0611161254,
-0.0462293774,
0.0238644835,
-0.0144366892,
0.0003146165,
0.0010662469,
-0.0004828387,
-0.0698314458,
-0.0019775263,
0.0032227146,
-0.0716820732,
-0.0286982339,
-0.0545152836,
-0.0210128892,
-0.0388237089,
-0.0040428932,
0.031226946,
-0.0067765112,
0.0074878624,
0.0523281358,
0.0011325426,
-0.0646944419,
0.0180277973,
-0.0134701151,
0.0570957027,
0.0399344377,
-0.0241490211,
0.0011458296,
-0.0468376167,
0.0248069186,
0.0223043319,
-0.0040970715,
-0.0042872038,
0.0186350532,
-0.0179085955,
-0.0240770914,
-0.0242795516,
0.0224686377,
-0.0018770411,
0.0006338164,
-0.0286358017,
0.0712933391,
-0.0113677084,
-0.0232260525,
-0.0303325448,
-0.0198228508,
-0.0165070407,
0.0564498007,
0.026753787,
-0.0290775876,
-0.0512185358,
-0.0157483313,
-0.0228738561,
-0.0261459667,
0.0137949241,
0.0067631458,
0.0340219326,
-0.0987640843,
-0.0058328807,
-0.0048351502,
0.0262319651,
0.0621407628,
-0.0072241016,
-0.0053800633,
0.0241285879,
0.0061577922,
-0.0661866441,
0.0421617851,
-0.0357326008,
0.0288945697,
-0.0578807108,
-0.015010966,
0.0381490849,
0.0150604304,
-0.030631803,
0.0110589629,
-0.1289804727,
-0.077527009,
-0.0002469709,
0.0795053244,
0.0257579312,
-0.0009461309,
0.0283243563,
-0.0158397071,
0.0622693151,
0.0258704498,
-0.0272170622,
-0.0125383949,
0.0428233594,
-0.0470767803,
0.0037918545,
0.02172428,
0.0003573721,
0.0007835384,
0.0073043332,
0.03674151,
-0.0074953041,
-0.0237189233,
-0.0308473594,
-0.0280321296,
0.0523559712,
-0.0236978382,
0.0091853226,
-0.0110947164,
0.0239267014,
0.000057564,
0.0190640185,
-0.0534899794,
-0.0020416256,
0.040386904,
0.0243104994,
0.0101149101,
-0.0003990454,
0.0545416102,
-0.0090372805,
0.0315268487,
0.0152631402,
0.0071409736,
-0.0186397508,
0.0382778347,
-0.0447819829,
-0.007973914,
0.0002188386,
0.0349342786,
0.0024071836,
-0.0284702517,
0.0529782698,
0.0063213673,
0.0090755764,
-0.0278268289,
0.0131220371,
-0.0577847585,
-0.0061329729,
-0.0344288945,
0.0502975509,
0.0973723829,
-0.0265459307,
0.0539814681,
-0.0053550294,
0.0099804886,
-0.0278689153,
0.0415776223,
-0.0201282166,
-0.0220066682,
0.038098637,
0.0243194122,
-0.0203765817,
0.0235882662,
0.0858312026,
0.051695697,
0.0471241958,
0.0121458396,
-0.0046532596,
-0.0330815725,
-0.0477537252,
-0.0156596303,
0.0247761961,
-0.0215284992,
-0.0061198524,
-0.0439233184,
-0.056648992,
0.0085490178,
-0.0171883479,
-0.0016536973,
-0.006219001,
0.0314083397,
0.0397114567,
-0.0183101129,
-0.0039101536,
-0.0167758092,
-0.0276125278,
0.0434809066,
-0.0226614028,
0.0039913272,
-6.809512409e-33,
0.0006446305,
-0.0075304266,
0.0398592204,
-0.0532709658,
-0.0202538483,
-0.0156530757,
-0.0517799221,
0.0029324037,
0.0191979595,
-0.0246386342,
-0.0306088291,
0.0110594379,
0.0142079359,
0.0625425726,
0.0096060392,
0.0152672837,
0.0842328072,
0.0227442868,
-0.0093485648,
0.021999348,
0.0122363716,
0.0527017228,
0.0558674484,
0.0067403815,
-0.0400692299,
0.0191564411,
-0.0016179393,
-0.0200315546,
-0.0499998964,
0.0188070219,
-0.0355690606,
0.0236134492,
0.0121122357,
-0.035506811,
-0.014881148,
-0.032316938,
-0.0526119173,
0.0213040225,
0.0186111704,
0.0057033752,
-0.0024690344,
-0.0077453679,
0.0284574553,
0.0478254855,
0.0272005796,
-0.0339345336,
0.026316274,
-0.0161096454,
-0.0288714245,
-0.0185160823,
0.004275097,
0.038436085,
0.0068893638,
0.0035267544,
0.0370408818,
0.0280593783,
-0.0239164084,
-0.0200871248,
-0.0156425107,
-0.0115876282,
0.050969407,
0.0812424198,
0.0532662868,
0.050875444,
0.0174426381,
0.0192957073,
0.0336105227,
-0.0394635201,
-0.0363053121,
0.0025731924,
0.049804952,
0.0368441604,
0.0304626133,
-0.0216300357,
0.0282057803,
-0.0242993254,
-0.0720066279,
0.0096004643,
0.0492410623,
0.0362841748,
0.0486448184,
0.0048365006,
-0.0085829543,
-0.026327176,
-0.01586546,
-0.0319296978,
-0.0243372601,
-0.0102298958,
0.0087053543,
0.0577665605,
-0.0011289759,
0.0000103935,
0.0546446182,
-0.0240560193,
0.0052587362,
-0.0133731207,
0.0012363375,
0.0062838737,
0.0070027979,
0.0425902419,
-0.0859043971,
-0.0530830249,
0.0329834223,
-0.0120819025,
-0.0082441149,
-0.0185339544,
0.0054044388,
0.0353276357,
-0.0830860287,
-0.0251792837,
-0.0453203134,
0.0381836593,
-0.0141747314,
0.0717167333,
0.0433288552,
0.0214761458,
-0.001793474,
0.0163631625,
-0.0442278609,
0.0004973869,
-0.0087968037,
-0.0114304135,
0.0185417719,
0.0287558399,
-0.0341761671,
0.0102313375,
-0.0650160611,
-0.0076993485,
-0.0053020981,
-0.0552050285,
-0.0293100588,
0.0371619798,
2.672e-7,
0.0110986521,
0.0342463516,
0.0335034616,
-0.021298822,
0.0167790726,
0.015902767,
-0.0234734919,
0.0090934224,
0.0164711121,
0.0033612773,
0.0272817947,
0.027020039,
0.0657235458,
0.0090448884,
-0.0957696736,
-0.040119689,
-0.0885287151,
0.0241817497,
-0.0638345778,
-0.0226432011,
0.00626262,
0.1292608231,
0.035286583,
-0.0185061824,
0.0276347641,
0.0027738393,
0.0383689106,
0.0170360096,
0.0203690473,
0.007171141,
0.0531451069,
0.0441272669,
-0.0103955222,
0.0009598084,
0.0110026114,
0.0306885988,
-0.0272749476,
0.0987153724,
-0.0006836932,
-0.0308596492,
0.0529645756,
0.0233847145,
-0.0320877545,
-0.0324142762,
0.0728962049,
-0.0090741403,
-0.0056045754,
-0.0650605187,
-0.029277483,
0.0099335341,
-0.0170791857,
0.0066564577,
-0.0097894147,
0.0462713353,
0.0095952097,
-0.0392142646,
0.0103843622,
-0.0823647752,
-0.0292364694,
-0.0096647125,
-0.079909198,
-0.0146590043,
-0.0653401539,
-0.0028876911,
0.0217328444,
-0.0279539376,
-0.017756138,
2.852288829e-34,
0.0405618437,
-0.0231191088,
-0.0037230116,
0.0514931642,
0.0020557649,
-0.0427721925,
-0.0296039507,
0.0015470255,
-0.0349171981,
-0.0907969326,
-0.0666152611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00385v1 | Computational Morphology and Lexicography Modeling of Modern Standard Arabic Nominals | 2024-02-01T07:05:45 | 2024-02-01T07:05:45 | Christian Khairallah, Reham Marzouk, Salam Khalifa, Mayar Nassar, Nizar Habash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) nominals present many morphological and lexical
modeling challenges that have not been consistently addressed previously. This
paper attempts to define the space of such challenges, and leverage a recently
proposed morphological framework to build a comprehensive and extensible model
for MSA nominals. Our model design addresses the nominals' intricate
morphotactics, as well as their paradigmatic irregularities. Our implementation
showcases enhanced accuracy and consistency compared to a commonly used MSA
morphological analyzer and generator. We make our models publicly available. | Computational Morphology and Lexicography Modeling of Modern Standard Arabic Nominals: Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) nominals present many morphological and lexical
modeling challenges that have not been consistently addressed previously. This
paper attempts to define the space of such challenges, and leverage a recently
proposed morphological framework to build a comprehensive and extensible model
for MSA nominals. Our model design addresses the nominals' intricate
morphotactics, as well as their paradigmatic irregularities. Our implementation
showcases enhanced accuracy and consistency compared to a commonly used MSA
morphological analyzer and generator. We make our models publicly available. | [
0.0049084299,
0.0409613475,
-0.0505318455,
0.0117729306,
-0.0759282038,
0.0103715276,
0.0206516031,
0.0300513152,
-0.0816188678,
-0.012578832,
0.0311450977,
-0.0895651653,
0.0765809938,
-0.0176900513,
0.0610533915,
-0.0133135375,
0.0191303696,
-0.0947164074,
-0.0388554521,
0.0081716524,
0.0756230429,
0.0320502929,
-0.0117614651,
0.0012339462,
-0.0425879322,
-0.0150967203,
-0.0186637025,
-0.0186032932,
-0.0021154913,
0.0206791963,
-0.0303413998,
0.0620444901,
-0.0323138013,
0.0261405017,
0.0000017742,
-0.0763955265,
-0.0256156605,
-0.0227162391,
-0.0160989854,
0.0170934089,
0.0215737615,
-0.0357221402,
-0.0691011176,
-0.0167752467,
0.0187733639,
0.031714119,
0.0643303916,
-0.0141421547,
-0.0007254992,
-0.0078281797,
0.0014389491,
-0.0785490647,
-0.0052939528,
0.0121137109,
-0.0584170558,
0.0393124931,
0.008561736,
-0.0149531625,
0.0023361305,
-0.0074768472,
-0.0100818193,
0.0181096084,
-0.0399639495,
-0.0453349426,
-0.0553923398,
-0.0196663626,
-0.0128062395,
-0.0468963459,
0.0433309749,
-0.0057690041,
0.0093971742,
-0.0376434438,
0.0141465031,
-0.0082823895,
0.0161160398,
0.0094286436,
-0.0095244022,
0.0354579054,
-0.0492772684,
0.0228467379,
0.0829903409,
0.0112046795,
-0.0156447906,
0.0016251702,
-0.0368147418,
0.0384901278,
0.0517636426,
-0.0311707519,
0.0128356488,
0.0078495862,
-0.0141150346,
0.0072743283,
0.0390171967,
-0.0284272879,
0.0046373918,
0.0142625086,
-0.0093301535,
-0.0487070605,
0.0418078266,
-0.0385034978,
0.0466976576,
0.028287258,
0.0132943876,
-0.0044526062,
-0.0459350236,
0.0155240092,
0.0572189763,
-0.0158869959,
-0.05289777,
0.0069095935,
-0.0058257594,
-0.0083568655,
-0.0517127067,
0.0272305701,
-0.045576591,
0.024437964,
-0.0436415151,
0.0079666637,
0.0213169605,
-0.012532576,
0.0360813402,
-0.0318728909,
-0.0326060839,
-0.0209097862,
-0.0027100102,
-0.0629603267,
-0.0172825251,
-0.0049022054,
-0.0722302645,
-0.0644997209,
0.0224140603,
0.0124199186,
0.0098898169,
0.028659869,
-0.0386726037,
0.038673386,
-0.0319211185,
-0.0678155422,
0.013994975,
0.0208091233,
-0.0358480699,
0.0292199254,
-0.0438702479,
-0.0285118949,
0.0294075869,
-0.032343436,
-0.0363614708,
0.0134523809,
-0.0091382014,
-0.0069915424,
0.0344204903,
0.050145667,
-0.0159110818,
0.0001452125,
0.0086655151,
0.0040183458,
0.0569678135,
0.0116514079,
0.0228172801,
-0.0081515852,
0.0233596861,
0.0054189484,
0.0130160227,
0.0403080918,
-0.0179157238,
-0.0164651256,
-0.0780281052,
-0.0582588017,
0.0101475464,
0.0639129803,
-0.0254466236,
0.0592297725,
0.0105197867,
-0.0472081974,
0.0238450449,
0.0696035177,
-0.0213243831,
0.0419088937,
0.0208003614,
0.026156202,
0.0640478879,
-0.0152529888,
0.0540348105,
-0.0473392159,
-0.0291920844,
0.0343238115,
-0.0665644035,
0.0720785484,
0.0277292561,
-0.0499030985,
-0.0395429134,
-0.0185545124,
-0.0300743934,
-0.0302223731,
0.0835685283,
-0.0233602393,
-0.0485111512,
-0.0316864848,
0.0182520784,
-0.0038887402,
-0.0125191528,
-0.0536050014,
-0.0036779111,
0.0363671184,
0.0271800756,
-0.0179451574,
-0.0369184613,
0.0323969275,
-0.0604410917,
0.032589417,
-0.035281077,
-0.0214793365,
-0.0095009692,
-0.0450558588,
0.0178099275,
0.0966146216,
0.0416555963,
0.0030561446,
-0.0336804278,
0.0643077791,
-0.006766133,
-0.0178655144,
-0.0057041296,
0.0332389995,
-0.0331939347,
0.0396953486,
-0.0258416645,
-0.0045548296,
-0.0084417248,
0.0506858304,
-0.0263353568,
0.0470101498,
0.0021909715,
-0.0534125157,
0.0001678269,
0.0001741277,
-0.0073939026,
0.0610874332,
0.0681848004,
0.0312875956,
0.0310690608,
-0.0479058474,
0.0449546091,
-0.0222864356,
0.0569368042,
-0.0609044172,
0.0421515778,
-0.05376577,
0.076034002,
-0.018050639,
0.0348698832,
-0.0465130545,
0.0223070271,
-0.033995118,
-0.0263456274,
-0.0335082263,
-0.0586852431,
0.0188423265,
0.0084674144,
0.0272791721,
0.007537758,
-0.0018580368,
-0.0058203712,
0.0186157264,
-0.0207936354,
0.0152179366,
-0.0655166358,
-0.04424363,
-0.0429354459,
-0.008831392,
0.0552641563,
-0.0208900739,
0.0314985067,
-0.0213641226,
0.04091217,
0.0394767225,
-0.0220713839,
0.0061673676,
0.0213524792,
0.0340427682,
-0.0348109119,
-0.0008504718,
-0.0681622103,
-0.0054055802,
0.0092065157,
0.0486306623,
0.0291849431,
-0.0770106316,
0.0134145608,
-0.0773703903,
-0.0176129844,
0.0215898044,
-0.0031583714,
-0.032971587,
0.0267502591,
-0.0221306402,
0.0769085288,
-0.0085222758,
-0.0063174851,
0.0104872454,
0.0153938467,
-0.0320383869,
-0.0304568801,
-0.0370989554,
0.021380594,
-0.0077048889,
-0.043321576,
-0.0729789138,
-0.0162980184,
0.0531828925,
-0.0191271212,
0.0076823868,
-0.0016958417,
0.0394461751,
-0.0298776422,
0.0157811176,
0.0291150063,
0.0273952372,
-0.0405338742,
0.1090599447,
0.0013518879,
-0.0062859547,
0.012528779,
-0.0356369205,
0.0322662927,
0.0287707057,
-0.0189122837,
-0.0380954817,
-0.030195985,
-0.0337534063,
-0.007464184,
0.0808326006,
-0.0209470578,
-0.0083306199,
0.0129358945,
0.0248160865,
-0.0074167405,
-0.0015641416,
-0.0579609349,
0.0231346618,
0.0219509974,
-0.0082572894,
0.0293622352,
0.0226739496,
-0.0499887988,
0.0199263748,
0.0214869343,
-0.0166910589,
0.0112162642,
0.0565604456,
-0.0442759469,
0.0060012611,
-0.0066748452,
0.0434065349,
-0.0047632917,
0.0149234943,
0.0308052003,
-0.0065291598,
0.0139940856,
0.0011720313,
-0.027429983,
0.0208053943,
-0.0987162814,
0.0130341668,
-0.0391084291,
-0.0166698862,
0.0475443341,
-0.0358234756,
-0.0455890112,
-0.0623047203,
-0.0576901808,
-0.0254756007,
0.0201328546,
0.0591831058,
0.0445927978,
0.040745981,
0.0516218096,
-0.0014185401,
-0.0180496089,
-0.0189484358,
-0.0283305943,
-0.0756349266,
0.0195583533,
0.0557843298,
-0.0071597723,
-0.0009149465,
-0.0168584511,
0.0699995533,
-0.0648539439,
-0.0105968472,
-0.0029498423,
-0.0446744487,
-0.0038596219,
-0.0065432983,
0.0369383059,
-0.0186445843,
-0.0558837876,
-0.0083368365,
-0.0311856773,
0.0532363467,
0.0512598492,
0.0324442014,
-0.038042333,
-0.0035338262,
-0.0339324065,
-0.0264153425,
0.0010109511,
0.0254233088,
-0.0230539963,
-0.0300344154,
0.0004761029,
-0.0223079771,
-0.0349946208,
-0.0021873256,
-0.0284550078,
0.0370537601,
-0.005029751,
-0.0924592987,
-0.0341941565,
-0.0283029005,
-0.0221429672,
-0.0362592861,
0.0162404235,
0.0262893867,
0.0318078026,
-0.0002786022,
0.0052577625,
-0.0625076368,
-0.015350922,
-0.0309447087,
-0.0269298628,
-0.0718462393,
-0.0093637388,
-0.0373565368,
-0.0179132279,
-0.0727294683,
-0.0396540761,
0.0052222786,
-0.033350274,
-0.0881960317,
-0.0321075395,
0.0336310863,
0.0208898839,
0.0088510225,
-0.024131095,
0.0062025739,
0.0214180071,
-0.0378289632,
-0.0522923395,
0.0346134417,
0.0232091453,
-0.0579690672,
0.001458829,
0.061435204,
-0.0060009011,
0.0304634664,
-0.0050556045,
0.0038403536,
-0.0327631161,
0.0496908166,
-0.0143644586,
0.0130031146,
-0.0524778925,
-0.0186024439,
-0.0263258331,
0.0233493373,
-0.0006528035,
0.0437636971,
0.0335222445,
0.0195619948,
-0.0326919891,
-0.0316881947,
0.0314771123,
0.0533848703,
-0.0068711918,
-0.0201683138,
-0.0013999511,
-0.0781473741,
-0.0323769227,
0.0293587167,
-0.007783507,
-0.0098807467,
-0.0500600152,
0.0099744247,
-0.0352642424,
-0.0081040552,
-0.0260214545,
0.0149149122,
-0.0090188356,
0.0167398825,
0.0129189594,
0.0149069866,
-0.0316258445,
-0.0352000296,
-0.0050634542,
0.0110955453,
0.0173644926,
-0.0012133678,
0.0236357898,
0.0214486998,
-0.0115268147,
0.0190874543,
0.0487108566,
-0.0124575831,
-0.0667334944,
0.0221542958,
-0.0222159754,
-0.0559100062,
-0.0575257167,
0.0294068102,
-0.011451887,
0.0597011223,
0.0934568793,
0.0153059047,
-0.0226001963,
0.0982706845,
0.0379615687,
-0.0308454074,
0.0104790954,
-0.0092376769,
0.0173253715,
0.001643185,
0.0092768837,
-0.0243131146,
-0.0028461507,
-0.0344285592,
0.0211926363,
0.0039852676,
-0.0066792793,
0.0403079093,
0.014087826,
-0.0138769988,
0.0248745345,
-0.0217118766,
-0.0092082741,
-0.0238070264,
-0.0076247109,
-0.0168774836,
-0.0395764932,
0.0290381797,
-0.107413508,
-0.0724806413,
0.0175691191,
0.0522198118,
0.0394152217,
0.0416756198,
0.0197547823,
0.0501966849,
0.0183808487,
0.0072226748,
-0.0442418903,
-0.0126271481,
-0.0056373794,
-0.0177271701,
0.0211917963,
-5.416943557e-33,
0.0018258054,
-0.0018970028,
0.0019967435,
-0.0230385941,
0.0244258735,
0.0011686707,
-0.0123720989,
0.0407960154,
0.0362069011,
-0.0110991774,
-0.0282005668,
0.0207421593,
0.0359305106,
-0.0346445888,
0.0697902218,
0.0434180424,
0.0093717799,
-0.0401562229,
0.0189049467,
-0.0370329879,
0.0144144446,
0.010182132,
0.1139757633,
-0.0297300592,
0.0032560485,
0.0141091747,
-0.0409096219,
0.034125559,
-0.0300313495,
0.0405005924,
-0.019094523,
0.0238334686,
0.0021370617,
0.0208796635,
0.0219995286,
-0.0362939537,
-0.0441518463,
-0.0144237746,
0.0385681801,
0.0232165381,
-0.0065179318,
-0.0247085672,
-0.0672569573,
-0.012669364,
-0.0598559231,
0.0519104302,
-0.0189045556,
-0.0115271891,
-0.0134008219,
-0.0207563918,
-0.0620113127,
0.0416895598,
0.0130146006,
0.0578995161,
0.0756982192,
-0.0351833962,
0.0127020469,
0.0040577115,
0.0373856761,
0.0077516655,
0.0566991381,
0.0188410599,
0.0744804889,
0.0202548187,
-0.0873369873,
-0.0277289897,
0.0362470374,
-0.03031376,
0.0812422857,
0.0704551935,
0.0498057194,
-0.0174890682,
0.0118726259,
0.0619907156,
0.0474667698,
0.0017879666,
0.0062873876,
-0.0075949267,
0.011304413,
0.0428560674,
-0.0203468911,
0.0133851571,
-0.0569912642,
-0.0004618772,
0.027461268,
-0.0409733839,
0.0227544848,
0.0353564285,
-0.0093744602,
-0.0079274569,
-0.0220329165,
0.1052948013,
-0.0439390168,
0.0465730168,
-0.0019968832,
-0.0581949018,
0.0198814478,
0.0112546617,
-0.0230897367,
0.031941276,
-0.0106004439,
-0.0391649939,
0.0003824624,
-0.0006258337,
0.0362197421,
0.0122123621,
-0.0347346775,
0.0148215136,
-0.0601362959,
0.0266234893,
-0.0017106223,
0.0168421008,
0.0447799414,
0.0216407906,
0.007487684,
0.0038302124,
0.0145139564,
-0.022115862,
0.0584164672,
-0.0172333363,
-0.0011972856,
-0.0199274104,
-0.0215313993,
-0.0250619743,
0.0291006565,
0.0028554935,
-0.035664279,
0.0038248394,
0.0379255489,
-0.0325015523,
-0.0140347499,
0.001595385,
2.574e-7,
0.0458242632,
0.0474120267,
0.028081134,
0.0305905119,
-0.0002716796,
-0.0099695483,
0.0285770874,
-0.0036756969,
-0.0037192355,
0.0204514395,
0.0209007487,
-0.0404970646,
-0.0011274181,
-0.0206719618,
-0.0445930511,
0.0124717802,
0.0130068809,
-0.0024914416,
-0.0666410699,
0.0065666665,
0.0107767293,
0.0945997983,
-0.0315508135,
-0.0271434262,
-0.0466132388,
-0.022509221,
0.0233205874,
-0.0047034584,
-0.0012965002,
0.0435776375,
0.0764635727,
-0.0750502273,
0.0348047242,
0.0016779306,
-0.0008503511,
0.0198554918,
0.0704315603,
0.0362205952,
-0.0141627872,
0.0661740899,
0.0242042616,
-0.0665803626,
-0.0146960327,
-0.0020272918,
0.032883428,
0.0655945614,
0.0044238688,
0.0121574393,
-0.0528164394,
0.0597293191,
-0.0059966957,
-0.0216719322,
-0.0048373761,
0.0261944067,
0.0411512665,
-0.0058205463,
-0.0059899292,
-0.001649944,
0.0256328471,
-0.0063968529,
0.0055938554,
0.0225940254,
0.0249665733,
-0.0103903199,
-0.0132810464,
-0.0091786534,
-0.0184267443,
2.215703077e-34,
0.0243845992,
0.0206626803,
0.0367893502,
0.0754585564,
-0.003328904,
0.0067804009,
0.0174424369,
0.0659335181,
-0.0114513123,
0.0028947396,
0.0010550895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00371v1 | What Does the Bot Say? Opportunities and Risks of Large Language Models in Social Media Bot Detection | 2024-02-01T06:21:19 | 2024-02-01T06:21:19 | Shangbin Feng, Herun Wan, Ningnan Wang, Zhaoxuan Tan, Minnan Luo, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media bot detection has always been an arms race between advancements
in machine learning bot detectors and adversarial bot strategies to evade
detection. In this work, we bring the arms race to the next level by
investigating the opportunities and risks of state-of-the-art large language
models (LLMs) in social bot detection. To investigate the opportunities, we
design novel LLM-based bot detectors by proposing a
mixture-of-heterogeneous-experts framework to divide and conquer diverse user
information modalities. To illuminate the risks, we explore the possibility of
LLM-guided manipulation of user textual and structured information to evade
detection. Extensive experiments with three LLMs on two datasets demonstrate
that instruction tuning on merely 1,000 annotated examples produces specialized
LLMs that outperform state-of-the-art baselines by up to 9.1% on both datasets,
while LLM-guided manipulation strategies could significantly bring down the
performance of existing bot detectors by up to 29.6% and harm the calibration
and reliability of bot detection systems. | What Does the Bot Say? Opportunities and Risks of Large Language Models in Social Media Bot Detection: Social media bot detection has always been an arms race between advancements
in machine learning bot detectors and adversarial bot strategies to evade
detection. In this work, we bring the arms race to the next level by
investigating the opportunities and risks of state-of-the-art large language
models (LLMs) in social bot detection. To investigate the opportunities, we
design novel LLM-based bot detectors by proposing a
mixture-of-heterogeneous-experts framework to divide and conquer diverse user
information modalities. To illuminate the risks, we explore the possibility of
LLM-guided manipulation of user textual and structured information to evade
detection. Extensive experiments with three LLMs on two datasets demonstrate
that instruction tuning on merely 1,000 annotated examples produces specialized
LLMs that outperform state-of-the-art baselines by up to 9.1% on both datasets,
while LLM-guided manipulation strategies could significantly bring down the
performance of existing bot detectors by up to 29.6% and harm the calibration
and reliability of bot detection systems. | [
0.0930070505,
0.0409225821,
-0.0194386449,
0.0269463044,
-0.033431951,
0.0042197569,
0.0135395275,
-0.0002910444,
0.0491599813,
-0.051495757,
-0.0368903689,
-0.0242075697,
-0.0035969457,
0.0321793146,
0.0324860848,
-0.0234987848,
0.0220108405,
-0.0158682875,
0.0167935174,
0.0045400821,
0.0258868244,
0.0009208892,
-0.0177290868,
0.0489802212,
-0.036943458,
0.0069897319,
-0.0078606205,
0.0244767517,
0.005990176,
0.0075363894,
0.0246422105,
0.0703459904,
0.0280678254,
0.1075799838,
0.0000018709,
-0.0306317564,
-0.0303236246,
-0.0071531311,
-0.0316700861,
-0.0035236562,
0.0598575324,
-0.0310713202,
-0.0119873527,
0.0375679396,
-0.056202516,
0.0491864718,
0.0485095941,
0.0369138978,
0.056539692,
0.1303850859,
-0.0112871639,
0.0025409777,
0.0543816425,
-0.029560497,
-0.0011402247,
-0.0404776409,
0.0373294726,
0.0008458919,
-0.0249920208,
0.0681122541,
-0.0085581569,
0.0206885021,
0.0090464428,
-0.0111796008,
0.0073861908,
-0.0235591959,
-0.0110383453,
-0.0261137579,
-0.000274568,
0.0476072542,
-0.0230239946,
-0.0056714593,
0.0130539695,
0.0290885605,
0.0286860969,
-0.0008569464,
-0.0213651229,
0.020570321,
-0.0025210606,
-0.0070157791,
-0.0052736299,
-0.0394643061,
0.0411725789,
0.0731388927,
-0.0180251319,
0.0090531064,
-0.0153721385,
-0.0253299922,
-0.0363503098,
-0.0109607372,
-0.0201244839,
-0.0312429648,
0.0483305566,
0.0258886516,
-0.0468658842,
-0.0034092723,
-0.0892173424,
-0.0763884485,
0.013589506,
-0.0383733585,
-0.0214199815,
0.0317616872,
-0.0134109957,
0.0697517619,
-0.0203472171,
0.0199225284,
-0.0345570892,
0.0300500672,
0.0084333532,
-0.0268849991,
-0.0340956822,
-0.0154511174,
-0.0069800601,
-0.0064682728,
0.0024519276,
-0.0144362701,
-0.0593472421,
0.0464070924,
-0.0292677023,
0.0052774074,
-0.0351986997,
-0.0010636391,
-0.0162798651,
0.004948447,
-0.0073715188,
0.0084566735,
0.0032011918,
0.0337272026,
0.0142499115,
-0.0696538612,
-0.0308047235,
0.0631364062,
-0.0250583608,
-0.038837146,
0.0240889546,
0.0514615774,
0.0181867443,
-0.0302155279,
0.0121015683,
-0.0531990565,
-0.0177214295,
-0.0263745785,
-0.003498283,
-0.0771412179,
0.0356615297,
0.0186603349,
-0.0017517812,
-0.0494926199,
-0.0119595146,
0.0246670227,
-0.0775508285,
0.0606999807,
-0.0277662072,
0.01308461,
0.0130657842,
0.0101984786,
-0.0535733402,
0.0679905862,
-0.009852875,
0.0939263776,
0.0529568903,
0.0079438435,
0.03119017,
0.0534076206,
-0.0024154512,
0.0356936306,
-0.0027725028,
-0.0148741966,
-0.0024145802,
-0.0232855175,
0.0077872043,
0.0542827062,
-0.0049367398,
-0.0245867632,
0.0960141346,
0.034459684,
-0.0617672056,
0.0074508688,
0.0553035699,
0.0418526754,
0.0185501557,
-0.0155273313,
-0.0550103299,
-0.0119805727,
-0.0732018426,
-0.0819921717,
0.0362774134,
0.0629842803,
-0.0149535621,
-0.0158571601,
0.0126494318,
-0.0184191298,
0.0344801694,
0.0139540825,
0.0281812362,
-0.0020542722,
-0.0117182797,
0.0321126655,
0.0239192601,
-0.0005829145,
-0.0222293194,
-0.0545296036,
-0.0252373461,
0.0406072326,
0.0050000385,
-0.0415921137,
0.0186349526,
-0.0411057696,
0.0006632034,
0.0238936134,
0.0329225212,
0.0168326143,
-0.0117149847,
-0.016055841,
-0.0271818936,
-0.0207520314,
0.0003470417,
-0.0191424098,
0.0570094474,
0.0030342683,
0.0083746761,
-0.003527266,
-0.0022136073,
0.0272618663,
0.0085676871,
0.0184698924,
-0.0094181485,
0.0393931195,
0.0407274105,
-0.0022491571,
-0.000563415,
-0.0187630877,
0.0210630503,
-0.0090385368,
-0.0630185604,
-0.0643413141,
-0.0055619059,
-0.022042118,
0.0447838642,
0.0086612962,
-0.0414106809,
0.0267893448,
-0.0408470556,
0.028913999,
0.0654810071,
-0.0580854937,
0.0136632202,
-0.0125174616,
0.0037581495,
-0.0170348026,
0.0850522369,
0.0049905563,
0.0550728403,
-0.0390654467,
-0.0434894599,
0.0420715734,
-0.0153307514,
-0.0272844937,
0.0137306973,
-0.0145670539,
4.333e-7,
-0.0262502581,
0.0472764298,
0.0314653479,
0.0093652979,
-0.0417110398,
-0.0639895126,
-0.1130586118,
0.0022334817,
-0.0367310084,
-0.0284749903,
0.0380198173,
-0.0034357787,
0.0071064429,
0.0187695324,
-0.0085517336,
-0.0007211314,
-0.0114591802,
0.0470524468,
0.0180720706,
-0.0398030691,
-0.046845749,
-0.0214928854,
-0.0001235244,
-0.0118114119,
0.0489320345,
0.0052996501,
-0.0617253184,
0.0010125394,
-0.0052258177,
-0.0259558298,
0.0108207734,
-0.0328506418,
-0.0454848371,
0.0195631105,
-0.0116920099,
0.0165246502,
0.0505229831,
0.0340344682,
0.04156854,
0.0317546055,
0.0249589048,
-0.0438435525,
0.0074620871,
0.0147069683,
-0.0198846236,
-0.0571813732,
-0.0249648876,
0.0032378274,
0.053728044,
0.0321420319,
-0.0118526444,
-0.0147040952,
0.0525280088,
-0.00230635,
-0.05208233,
-0.0164920371,
-0.0159461387,
-0.0012890411,
-0.010063895,
-0.0447282158,
-0.0627863556,
0.086133115,
0.0020814689,
0.0273520388,
0.0070264554,
-0.080879733,
-0.0249564126,
-0.0035232089,
0.0350932889,
0.0277369265,
-0.0295609459,
0.0170455407,
-0.0200942084,
-0.0023944585,
0.0147358878,
-0.0321398638,
0.0188643988,
0.0036062812,
0.023611024,
0.0198325273,
-0.0231646262,
-0.0637962669,
-0.0899958611,
-0.0477350578,
0.0194485653,
0.0407448262,
-0.06318257,
-0.0698705241,
-0.0022114592,
0.0475030877,
-0.0111531029,
-0.0172850154,
0.0054657771,
-0.0282563642,
-0.0008006954,
0.0069460873,
-0.017997181,
0.0081012603,
-0.0517475158,
0.0186513588,
0.0722156167,
-0.0075919852,
-0.0412258543,
-0.0242094528,
0.0007863353,
0.020665314,
0.0114328694,
-0.0124808699,
0.0083016036,
0.0591994524,
-0.0332702287,
0.0404056013,
0.0860989541,
0.0043274891,
-0.0294172224,
-0.000047523,
0.0028605249,
0.0207388867,
0.0090965675,
-0.0123527357,
-0.0777649805,
-0.0485456996,
0.0230217744,
0.0021942931,
-0.0304210838,
-0.0286571458,
-0.0235544648,
-0.0609808862,
-0.0163451396,
0.0133385686,
-0.0669331402,
-0.0479014628,
-0.0421625972,
-0.0202004686,
0.0028438466,
0.041577775,
-0.0279241651,
-0.0047060451,
-0.0093310717,
-0.0163675807,
-0.0442627445,
-0.0276708752,
0.0033524004,
-0.0275020357,
0.0519779474,
0.0303833392,
0.0234413948,
-0.0228158161,
0.0253807213,
0.00530829,
0.0463016741,
0.0088496879,
-0.0128379064,
0.0837873518,
-0.0270791296,
-0.0132598504,
-0.0106711863,
0.0210900381,
-0.0278437193,
-0.0155628584,
0.0094278418,
0.020707259,
0.0042405501,
-0.0056238971,
-0.0138007365,
-0.007778917,
0.0389172733,
0.0677679107,
0.0370795466,
-0.0577769056,
-0.007884426,
-0.0644781515,
-0.0431952104,
0.0019211224,
-0.051779557,
-0.0002191081,
-0.0349788964,
-0.0421603285,
-0.0256488118,
-0.0090112388,
0.0371114127,
-0.0051809163,
0.0058560618,
0.0262372736,
-0.012432158,
-0.0041783126,
-0.0176088102,
0.0479309373,
-0.0526893325,
0.0715948641,
-0.0524107926,
-0.0104842288,
0.0094779776,
-0.0545444936,
0.010713065,
0.0379747301,
-0.094439216,
-0.0876284018,
0.0027056341,
0.0539472811,
0.0157445837,
0.0384303741,
-0.0359355882,
-0.0749478862,
0.0531699993,
0.0258984864,
-0.0248685312,
0.0076467101,
0.0382433012,
0.0233638417,
0.0098266881,
0.037411157,
-0.0208883863,
-0.0193935446,
0.0499074794,
-0.0368348882,
-0.0773234963,
0.0072129886,
0.0169024952,
0.028422758,
0.028884491,
0.0112239886,
-0.0271882601,
0.0163670797,
-0.0426334627,
-0.002373639,
-0.0509798452,
-0.0018916319,
-0.0050870464,
0.0310112741,
-0.0053187935,
0.0222632997,
0.0400820374,
-0.006563473,
0.0242701098,
-0.0115420474,
0.0025369725,
-0.0343039669,
0.0292088296,
0.0549314208,
0.0089616459,
-0.0194184985,
0.0364210457,
0.0067207115,
0.0171924029,
0.0029860814,
0.0076810969,
-0.0225442946,
-0.021874791,
-0.0045263376,
-0.0056144679,
-0.0344614685,
-0.0764194354,
0.0082105808,
0.0349601842,
0.0458949916,
0.0045886301,
0.0549665801,
0.0017452703,
-0.011239985,
-0.0198693182,
0.0086389622,
-0.0018773637,
-0.0111639984,
-0.0258734468,
0.001706826,
-0.029459592,
0.0269687735,
0.066774562,
0.0038808112,
0.034158092,
0.0126239806,
-0.074898243,
-0.0222613774,
-0.0144894104,
0.0193252452,
0.0224215295,
-0.0116052758,
0.0219343305,
-0.0371048972,
-0.0671440661,
-0.0399718843,
-0.0638269931,
-0.0222887583,
0.0174239334,
-0.0245983135,
0.059300106,
-0.0220004898,
0.0294606704,
-0.0763200074,
0.0131891984,
0.0505766533,
-0.0571440309,
0.0044199354,
-6.418975716e-33,
0.0263363775,
-0.044380758,
-0.0132406205,
-0.0560985953,
0.0078183329,
0.041358754,
0.0067630764,
0.0081122341,
-0.0382699333,
0.0039563226,
-0.0204457473,
0.0198668335,
-0.0084292898,
0.0289393328,
-0.0257002264,
0.0157106519,
0.0580039434,
-0.0088329315,
-0.0238156151,
0.0045123054,
0.0495764092,
-0.0182006136,
0.0284296069,
-0.0779189095,
0.0319369845,
0.0261405483,
-0.0234223455,
0.0239802916,
0.0022263105,
0.0438346937,
-0.0070864717,
0.0647899434,
0.0485462025,
0.0099410312,
-0.0091942083,
0.0292532649,
-0.0075402707,
0.0268057175,
-0.0006601394,
0.0221482608,
-0.0021221621,
-0.0545380563,
0.0639523193,
-0.0219374355,
0.0018926534,
0.0205162317,
0.0347011723,
-0.0127930278,
0.0290536806,
0.0046647987,
-0.0146258892,
0.0213824417,
-0.0412303284,
-0.0209497493,
-0.0000789141,
0.0463949889,
0.0552871041,
0.0187206957,
-0.0798138306,
0.0426715501,
-0.0094787544,
0.0030513215,
0.043258857,
-0.008299713,
-0.0061679906,
0.0582139045,
0.0220316108,
0.0480051413,
-0.0449547991,
-0.0342023745,
-0.0172472335,
0.061225675,
0.0222000722,
0.0378042348,
0.0206630975,
-0.0593950227,
-0.0953568891,
0.0057241074,
0.0742563754,
0.0324412771,
0.0523611605,
-0.000348471,
-0.0551387407,
0.0053188982,
-0.031681966,
-0.0203502961,
-0.0488228761,
-0.018828027,
-0.0217729919,
0.031577982,
-0.032619454,
-0.0386480317,
0.0326803513,
-0.0795462579,
-0.0149464505,
0.0488626137,
-0.0236141589,
0.0081515238,
0.0283690747,
0.0403364785,
-0.0265454613,
-0.0230461676,
0.0584983602,
-0.0760925412,
0.0053986218,
-0.0124783805,
0.0420431979,
0.030288972,
-0.0436726697,
-0.0188542977,
-0.015993394,
0.0323011987,
-0.0140734287,
0.0226651635,
0.0321754627,
0.0195213798,
-0.0230552703,
0.0263030548,
0.0288601145,
-0.0068692346,
0.0054705101,
0.0070397966,
-0.0249667093,
-0.0085654259,
-0.0236876365,
0.0016773292,
-0.0266903527,
-0.0201436542,
0.0287274849,
-0.0736828595,
-0.0039002984,
-0.0453110002,
2.679e-7,
0.0045902743,
0.0633659065,
-0.0363795944,
0.0038871593,
0.0402639657,
0.0833614841,
0.0262081586,
0.0382893533,
-0.0261780899,
-0.054131344,
-0.0203554444,
0.0865481347,
0.0361156315,
0.0040544183,
-0.029909648,
-0.0101938397,
-0.0167175271,
-0.0005143323,
-0.0713385344,
-0.0134680299,
0.0037734238,
0.104934819,
0.0564525127,
-0.0382144116,
-0.0183553062,
-0.0686578304,
0.0422894135,
-0.0106597096,
-0.0374064036,
0.0425724909,
0.0811975002,
0.0329081602,
0.0376373231,
0.0400398299,
0.0021773409,
0.0132938586,
0.0151293389,
0.0806198344,
0.0200442038,
0.0080427201,
-0.0143162729,
-0.026978733,
-0.0005275197,
-0.0175265148,
0.0650481656,
-0.0232865904,
-0.0517912731,
-0.047307454,
-0.01839686,
-0.0380184837,
0.043832358,
-0.04668957,
-0.0374034941,
0.0505739041,
0.0104094297,
0.0046587819,
-0.0083844522,
-0.0495169386,
0.0008433524,
-0.0315999053,
-0.0756950751,
-0.048528634,
-0.0086141815,
-0.003515075,
0.0554185286,
0.0049870308,
0.0507772528,
2.45535607e-34,
0.0427644104,
-0.0049338657,
0.0211161189,
0.0199094396,
0.0398129597,
0.0244036615,
-0.0374121927,
-0.0048302775,
0.0216235109,
-0.0561960898,
0.0086660851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00367v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00367v2 | Don't Hallucinate, Abstain: Identifying LLM Knowledge Gaps via Multi-LLM Collaboration | 2024-02-01T06:11:49 | 2024-07-01T01:34:09 | Shangbin Feng, Weijia Shi, Yike Wang, Wenxuan Ding, Vidhisha Balachandran, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite efforts to expand the knowledge of large language models (LLMs),
knowledge gaps -- missing or outdated information in LLMs -- might always
persist given the evolving nature of knowledge. In this work, we study
approaches to identify LLM knowledge gaps and abstain from answering questions
when knowledge gaps are present. We first adapt existing approaches to model
calibration or adaptation through fine-tuning/prompting and analyze their
ability to abstain from generating low-confidence outputs. Motivated by their
failures in self-reflection and over-reliance on held-out sets, we propose two
novel approaches that are based on model collaboration, i.e., LLMs probing
other LLMs for knowledge gaps, either cooperatively or competitively. Extensive
experiments with three LLMs on four QA tasks featuring diverse knowledge
domains demonstrate that both cooperative and competitive approaches to
unveiling LLM knowledge gaps achieve up to 19.3% improvements on abstain
accuracy against the strongest baseline. Further analysis reveals that our
proposed mechanisms could help identify failure cases in retrieval augmentation
and pinpoint knowledge gaps in multi-hop reasoning. | Don't Hallucinate, Abstain: Identifying LLM Knowledge Gaps via Multi-LLM Collaboration: Despite efforts to expand the knowledge of large language models (LLMs),
knowledge gaps -- missing or outdated information in LLMs -- might always
persist given the evolving nature of knowledge. In this work, we study
approaches to identify LLM knowledge gaps and abstain from answering questions
when knowledge gaps are present. We first adapt existing approaches to model
calibration or adaptation through fine-tuning/prompting and analyze their
ability to abstain from generating low-confidence outputs. Motivated by their
failures in self-reflection and over-reliance on held-out sets, we propose two
novel approaches that are based on model collaboration, i.e., LLMs probing
other LLMs for knowledge gaps, either cooperatively or competitively. Extensive
experiments with three LLMs on four QA tasks featuring diverse knowledge
domains demonstrate that both cooperative and competitive approaches to
unveiling LLM knowledge gaps achieve up to 19.3% improvements on abstain
accuracy against the strongest baseline. Further analysis reveals that our
proposed mechanisms could help identify failure cases in retrieval augmentation
and pinpoint knowledge gaps in multi-hop reasoning. | [
0.0367071107,
0.0587624833,
-0.0338559039,
0.048295211,
-0.0689408779,
0.014327243,
-0.0021865489,
-0.0206653364,
0.0295197498,
-0.0522896424,
-0.0477710254,
-0.0361063816,
-0.0223015584,
-0.0068580336,
0.0150757544,
0.0326717906,
0.0702947527,
-0.032926891,
-0.0273993891,
-0.042761337,
-0.0319641195,
0.0196210612,
-0.0281710345,
0.0178719517,
0.0005485628,
-0.0313354544,
-0.0226628687,
-0.0297513511,
-0.0079731941,
-0.0128217032,
0.0268436074,
0.0625075474,
0.0009907999,
0.0253971294,
0.0000020396,
-0.0643556193,
-0.0364015512,
-0.014985607,
-0.0424345285,
0.0015961677,
-0.0610240176,
0.0143247657,
0.043799907,
-0.0002170812,
-0.0525558442,
0.0375835076,
0.0065012765,
0.0330261998,
0.0379884429,
0.0506211668,
0.0373932011,
0.0202929247,
0.0134681473,
-0.0257001948,
0.0450931154,
-0.0438546836,
0.0297001842,
0.0590573438,
0.0214573555,
0.0199497342,
-0.000776484,
0.0579375252,
0.0260577425,
-0.0077997833,
-0.009684437,
0.0174546931,
-0.02176385,
-0.0164716672,
-0.0112758251,
0.0538950823,
0.0420924127,
-0.0225484725,
-0.037962161,
0.00191746,
0.0207458939,
0.0515489541,
-0.0542613566,
-0.0029216332,
-0.01489178,
-0.0036628079,
-0.0280308202,
-0.0506208092,
0.0604665577,
0.0090141967,
-0.0004197244,
0.1207796782,
-0.0011303955,
-0.0418540277,
-0.0044035232,
0.023300454,
-0.0408239998,
-0.0291240271,
0.013665379,
0.0533070154,
-0.0604100227,
0.0347398333,
0.0254237466,
0.0059413086,
0.0499596074,
0.0091247717,
0.0053827125,
0.0255430415,
-0.0373650454,
0.077379562,
-0.0379313231,
0.0120541705,
-0.0007425523,
0.0230733752,
-0.0287380647,
-0.0112514906,
-0.0658843815,
-0.0434419103,
-0.0170012228,
0.0445271321,
-0.0248801503,
0.0116230594,
0.0000913205,
0.0376206599,
-0.0302638728,
0.0300137419,
0.0034927751,
0.0193179604,
-0.0056925826,
-0.0373680145,
-0.0549216233,
0.0691233352,
-0.0226176213,
0.0373054408,
0.0170462485,
-0.0777028427,
-0.0557358675,
0.0065258211,
-0.0191075224,
-0.0237232689,
0.0019749026,
0.0244724508,
-0.0159084089,
-0.0273177959,
-0.0074759554,
-0.0496421382,
-0.0176336616,
-0.086473316,
-0.0043221144,
-0.0439810827,
0.0346645191,
0.0120787872,
-0.0002549953,
-0.0369285904,
0.0151718669,
0.0056554782,
-0.00997122,
0.0870506465,
-0.0093281157,
0.0174593255,
0.0342457071,
0.0183484908,
-0.0526483506,
0.093348749,
-0.0147005441,
-0.0169413667,
0.0485058092,
0.0066301599,
0.0159840267,
0.0003697327,
0.0418058038,
0.0153457997,
0.0084511898,
0.0225614458,
0.0293165874,
0.0201482326,
-0.0147082703,
0.0318996571,
-0.0288011711,
-0.0219701193,
0.0420032963,
0.0400933512,
0.0226011388,
-0.014254733,
0.0197722577,
-0.0555580929,
0.0122063057,
0.0244625472,
-0.0640434548,
0.0434937142,
-0.046792943,
-0.0025589557,
0.03116294,
0.0363666378,
-0.0389970616,
-0.0376359634,
-0.0208984613,
0.0062238858,
-0.0154263377,
0.052552361,
0.0586678311,
0.0132559454,
-0.0199575797,
0.0752276555,
0.0028795025,
-0.034090858,
0.0314729549,
-0.0503309481,
0.067616947,
0.0367423631,
0.0583088882,
-0.0401382037,
-0.0637816563,
0.0140088694,
0.0184345488,
-0.0072994991,
0.0721744671,
-0.024923766,
0.0129136872,
-0.0307267122,
-0.0386484638,
-0.0254236925,
0.0264114458,
-0.0048421081,
0.0224779807,
-0.0066951201,
0.0252669491,
-0.0745556578,
0.0423345715,
0.0247541219,
-0.0675061941,
0.0203975886,
-0.0271207225,
-0.0034847863,
0.0131821148,
0.0256028008,
0.0186559893,
0.0396075882,
0.0417481512,
-0.0140475333,
-0.0507413149,
0.0123326452,
-0.0099400571,
-0.0524319634,
0.0358044319,
0.0288464297,
-0.0289861131,
0.0036885305,
-0.0374995954,
-0.0478448905,
0.0382312797,
0.0159135945,
0.0287251305,
-0.0716010779,
0.030705208,
0.0023237758,
-0.0189551506,
-0.0398328267,
0.0816393346,
-0.016432967,
0.0355444402,
-0.0076145404,
0.028327981,
0.0135723222,
-0.0352607816,
-0.0275398139,
0.0224460848,
0.0043978021,
0.0000614118,
0.0223371629,
-0.0229088068,
-0.0790439621,
-0.0118814046,
-0.0819650739,
0.0044278563,
-0.0319947526,
0.0369903296,
-0.0065950514,
0.002852415,
-0.0029173531,
-0.0262522697,
-0.006316321,
0.0042183953,
0.007252811,
0.0415893346,
0.0128944758,
0.0406530201,
0.0103528695,
-0.0263593793,
-0.0020391466,
-0.0106955161,
0.0325461887,
-0.0063978867,
-0.0004967328,
-0.0720162019,
0.0020148722,
-0.0740923733,
0.0213718731,
-0.0158682335,
0.0106264735,
0.0242087841,
-0.0267221145,
0.0024636248,
0.0367295258,
-0.037610285,
-0.0139046833,
0.0719833001,
-0.012467823,
-0.080992505,
0.0457042307,
-0.0284268539,
-0.0220946148,
-0.0440664105,
-0.0043936684,
-0.0032061329,
0.0434257761,
0.0001610344,
-0.0370982289,
-0.0447623134,
0.0103515871,
-0.0079524182,
-0.0327236354,
-0.0420865715,
-0.0298492536,
0.0017826925,
0.0312795676,
-0.0222030617,
-0.0399206132,
0.1056338176,
-0.0227941293,
-0.0004875085,
-0.0252023023,
0.0128204683,
-0.0497441441,
0.073790282,
-0.0377378725,
0.0031440628,
-0.0003224155,
-0.0140337069,
-0.0519001149,
-0.0080346642,
0.010851278,
-0.0495576002,
0.045767121,
-0.0570983253,
0.0228539892,
0.0060508321,
-0.0201487243,
-0.0450479202,
-0.0026887008,
-0.0545263737,
0.0094202366,
-0.0362620093,
0.0109031256,
-0.0378639959,
-0.0059838123,
0.0022871348,
0.001917237,
-0.0151910912,
0.005305592,
-0.009838596,
-0.001057383,
0.0374383815,
0.0335955285,
0.0212822482,
-0.0526780635,
0.0298252981,
0.0622751415,
0.0412554629,
-0.0047428552,
0.0304854419,
-0.017485505,
0.036604926,
-0.0159495864,
-0.0021294528,
-0.0103069386,
0.0636607334,
-0.0379137285,
-0.0191106442,
0.1044079289,
0.0581600927,
-0.0329477862,
-0.0092956489,
-0.0776178911,
0.0220470093,
0.0342006758,
0.018805312,
-0.074237138,
-0.0161682311,
0.0103162853,
0.0225068629,
-0.004084154,
-0.0337710083,
0.001588676,
-0.1302259266,
0.0275804717,
0.0035654078,
-0.0208800863,
-0.0254366957,
-0.0414815843,
0.0363177434,
0.0140820388,
0.0527962409,
0.0339607373,
0.0248947181,
0.0045932168,
0.0265627224,
-0.007738655,
-0.0495750383,
0.0299212616,
-0.0090805264,
0.0757436231,
0.0396258757,
-0.0025825175,
0.0302468725,
-0.0516249239,
0.0464646369,
-0.0358744264,
0.0470121428,
-0.0361535996,
0.0242151786,
0.0023583425,
0.0065605165,
0.0329453722,
0.0087498259,
-0.0357768722,
-0.0296326969,
0.0169776734,
0.0733979717,
-0.044556383,
0.000882586,
0.0062990291,
0.0201913845,
0.0024807113,
0.0843802914,
0.0343514718,
0.0196361467,
-0.0027684437,
0.0003180365,
0.0103921359,
-0.0452526622,
0.0072736978,
0.0435946397,
0.0259921588,
0.0572041199,
-0.0302415676,
-0.0638705492,
0.0528332926,
0.0087006008,
-0.0072183409,
0.0423873216,
-0.0215052366,
-0.005132596,
-0.0241700727,
0.0311839916,
-0.0585987382,
0.0027665675,
0.0105062705,
0.0282498524,
0.0020711254,
-0.0112064322,
0.0034036196,
-0.0329008363,
-0.1149662137,
-0.0802429393,
-0.0265713744,
0.0477404147,
0.0257701129,
0.0424050875,
-0.0267059766,
-0.0598889813,
0.0252725668,
0.0312003121,
-0.0113625219,
0.0156440269,
0.0021318749,
-0.009552503,
-0.030637553,
0.0565990657,
-0.0623428151,
-0.0324342288,
0.0130817387,
0.0950387269,
-0.0328697599,
-0.0440363698,
0.0335619077,
-0.0033972939,
0.0435755327,
0.0198889021,
0.0091575002,
-0.0218199138,
0.0427940451,
-0.0165058561,
-0.0362086222,
-0.0225034449,
0.0043490459,
0.0025894283,
-0.0677370429,
0.0398088247,
-0.008773746,
0.0081978971,
0.07688687,
-0.0434404463,
0.0019268016,
0.0230323393,
-0.0259534772,
0.0092137605,
0.0085324096,
-0.0171185452,
-0.0067874943,
0.0118847871,
0.0523926504,
0.0179805756,
0.0549010076,
0.0161848702,
-0.0120538529,
-0.0289417263,
-0.0126689468,
-0.0693858713,
-0.075970836,
0.0091442829,
0.0629757494,
0.036299739,
0.0254161488,
0.0316205993,
-0.0142684719,
-0.0175823923,
-0.0032439993,
-0.0122427875,
0.0064161872,
-0.0106866639,
0.057724271,
0.0312116127,
-0.0033373842,
0.0140813561,
0.0738698021,
-0.058986742,
0.0839608237,
-0.0177185517,
-0.0135978051,
-0.0213219859,
-0.0622656234,
0.0014690425,
0.0108292848,
-0.0372625217,
0.0243635997,
-0.0641106144,
-0.082605198,
0.0062593343,
0.0206540823,
-0.0377524905,
-0.0062978962,
-0.0291160773,
0.0782679245,
0.0114538111,
-0.0453391187,
-0.0419400521,
0.0041225413,
-0.0129216565,
0.0151263308,
-0.0130680148,
-6.759556837e-33,
-0.0406155139,
-0.0691568479,
0.0390273854,
-0.0521075018,
-0.0183955543,
-0.0006287958,
-0.0334212631,
0.0027024997,
-0.0517654754,
-0.0037532467,
-0.0016748016,
0.0220520683,
0.0070157866,
-0.0020664968,
0.0506387129,
-0.0176716819,
0.0334075466,
0.0099546751,
-0.0362342186,
-0.0085214768,
0.0151182692,
0.0309732519,
0.0518476479,
-0.0271580443,
0.0730618089,
-0.0225021448,
-0.0207157638,
0.0839765668,
-0.0539535359,
0.0495788082,
0.0007434381,
0.0278687403,
0.0163711142,
-0.0369270667,
-0.0107453242,
-0.0342954323,
-0.0406880751,
-0.0459185727,
0.0617180727,
-0.0159935635,
-0.0231004898,
-0.0191333275,
0.0130441487,
-0.00336641,
0.0157917459,
0.0002144266,
0.0078800069,
-0.0251414608,
-0.0152594885,
0.0321833342,
-0.0018994212,
0.0004055246,
-0.0125533817,
-0.0249194074,
-0.0136892898,
0.0816287547,
0.0292028468,
-0.001441128,
-0.0629878864,
0.0199828483,
-0.0120911412,
0.0076971208,
0.080117844,
0.0228542238,
0.0045636706,
0.0533007048,
-0.0116076292,
0.0245708097,
-0.0293524414,
-0.0353372991,
0.0123654194,
0.043261379,
0.0184761845,
0.032254938,
-0.0112604266,
0.0146724777,
-0.0240907315,
0.0066764192,
0.0092425216,
0.0501463711,
0.0307387039,
0.0249197856,
-0.0383398458,
-0.0163274501,
-0.0487651639,
0.0274303835,
-0.0459386706,
-0.0396265388,
0.0248805936,
0.0173534248,
-0.0282565895,
0.0248404741,
0.0058020488,
-0.0363149792,
-0.0218693633,
0.0012191378,
0.0173690412,
-0.000537604,
-0.0207566712,
0.0415799543,
-0.0442087539,
-0.0321057253,
0.0129569089,
0.0163439009,
-0.0023625751,
0.0118313748,
0.0311858188,
0.0010197214,
-0.0483533666,
-0.0049495185,
-0.0431430787,
0.0113756265,
0.008328069,
-0.0320329331,
0.0253502037,
0.0348463394,
-0.0221366342,
0.0280610304,
0.0357606448,
-0.011665551,
-0.0277858432,
-0.0002150931,
-0.0166345108,
-0.0259740595,
-0.0022263578,
-0.0123833427,
-0.0053327777,
-0.0008111009,
0.005875289,
-0.0092707593,
-0.0109896204,
0.025535414,
2.821e-7,
0.0510545708,
0.0138187939,
0.0068232808,
0.0068546343,
0.0099784862,
0.0213890783,
-0.0584892854,
-0.0057598418,
0.0546694249,
-0.0357693136,
0.0194196962,
0.0484207124,
0.0414439812,
0.0397113971,
-0.0525235906,
0.0079014692,
-0.0357704051,
-0.034089759,
-0.0345054828,
-0.0420505144,
0.0376846679,
0.0356834382,
0.020512484,
-0.0015775798,
-0.0419496186,
-0.0687373951,
0.0749097914,
-0.0256927926,
-0.0503119268,
0.0457808822,
0.0765207782,
0.0094469199,
0.0384170152,
0.0426503494,
0.0033240658,
0.0182163157,
-0.0215124339,
0.0127302548,
0.0161607228,
-0.058018703,
-0.0565727986,
0.0075794742,
0.0268493127,
-0.0511423051,
0.0883778557,
-0.0318113863,
-0.0112332888,
-0.0122156702,
0.006306435,
-0.0141976494,
0.0226456672,
0.0069466555,
-0.0089983009,
0.01805133,
-0.0031612527,
0.0124241672,
-0.0104495846,
-0.0835863128,
-0.0550700054,
0.0076640784,
-0.0606273636,
-0.0697434247,
0.0135419518,
-0.0360741802,
-0.01361416,
-0.0692491829,
0.0166899972,
2.376665447e-34,
0.043203488,
0.0113400323,
0.0180917028,
0.0695612058,
0.0308000948,
-0.0297333896,
-0.0332811698,
0.0130166346,
0.0083855214,
-0.0756318122,
-0.0109424954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00345v1 | IndiVec: An Exploration of Leveraging Large Language Models for Media Bias Detection with Fine-Grained Bias Indicators | 2024-02-01T05:20:07 | 2024-02-01T05:20:07 | Luyang Lin, Lingzhi Wang, Xiaoyan Zhao, Jing Li, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study focuses on media bias detection, crucial in today's era of
influential social media platforms shaping individual attitudes and opinions.
In contrast to prior work that primarily relies on training specific models
tailored to particular datasets, resulting in limited adaptability and subpar
performance on out-of-domain data, we introduce a general bias detection
framework, IndiVec, built upon large language models. IndiVec begins by
constructing a fine-grained media bias database, leveraging the robust
instruction-following capabilities of large language models and vector database
techniques. When confronted with new input for bias detection, our framework
automatically selects the most relevant indicator from the vector database and
employs majority voting to determine the input's bias label. IndiVec excels
compared to previous methods due to its adaptability (demonstrating consistent
performance across diverse datasets from various sources) and explainability
(providing explicit top-k indicators to interpret bias predictions).
Experimental results on four political bias datasets highlight IndiVec's
significant superiority over baselines. Furthermore, additional experiments and
analysis provide profound insights into the framework's effectiveness. | IndiVec: An Exploration of Leveraging Large Language Models for Media Bias Detection with Fine-Grained Bias Indicators: This study focuses on media bias detection, crucial in today's era of
influential social media platforms shaping individual attitudes and opinions.
In contrast to prior work that primarily relies on training specific models
tailored to particular datasets, resulting in limited adaptability and subpar
performance on out-of-domain data, we introduce a general bias detection
framework, IndiVec, built upon large language models. IndiVec begins by
constructing a fine-grained media bias database, leveraging the robust
instruction-following capabilities of large language models and vector database
techniques. When confronted with new input for bias detection, our framework
automatically selects the most relevant indicator from the vector database and
employs majority voting to determine the input's bias label. IndiVec excels
compared to previous methods due to its adaptability (demonstrating consistent
performance across diverse datasets from various sources) and explainability
(providing explicit top-k indicators to interpret bias predictions).
Experimental results on four political bias datasets highlight IndiVec's
significant superiority over baselines. Furthermore, additional experiments and
analysis provide profound insights into the framework's effectiveness. | [
0.0312741995,
0.0798277855,
-0.0004721855,
0.015102515,
0.0254391264,
0.032475844,
0.0267431512,
-0.0009349791,
0.0412207358,
-0.0651900023,
0.0200641789,
-0.0034536102,
-0.0375548713,
-0.0128733451,
0.0126988124,
-0.0272474773,
0.0455102995,
0.0482283272,
0.0796614066,
-0.0404478386,
0.0529793687,
0.0444301963,
-0.0087662619,
0.0286737215,
-0.0202910025,
-0.0244633071,
0.0393565856,
0.0122820893,
0.0437584184,
-0.0145580797,
0.0450776108,
0.0514742583,
0.0149331586,
0.0582847409,
0.0000018027,
-0.013469439,
-0.0060372651,
-0.0186653789,
0.0077591198,
-0.0170851815,
0.0817639604,
-0.0172748249,
-0.0065219714,
0.0327649303,
-0.0140572246,
0.0131399883,
0.0525244065,
0.0090116365,
0.0901909247,
0.0646494851,
-0.0124363117,
-0.0190956034,
-0.0427887328,
-0.0041165492,
0.0048381072,
-0.045094002,
0.0487749167,
-0.020794617,
-0.0815599635,
0.0220141672,
-0.0191306379,
-0.0076741804,
0.0068110502,
0.0097125005,
-0.0161381029,
-0.0183926504,
-0.0127108544,
-0.0128876753,
-0.0015260254,
0.055883158,
0.0012031002,
-0.027517749,
-0.0111895604,
-0.0154526969,
0.0416374914,
-0.0020054772,
-0.0393001959,
0.016868934,
-0.0081138406,
0.0319020823,
0.0234310795,
-0.0163729414,
0.0258466322,
0.0617769584,
0.0116820531,
0.0507643931,
0.0044436161,
-0.0171371717,
0.0264052674,
0.0196587071,
0.0263174754,
-0.015495494,
0.0094725052,
-0.026830541,
-0.0181222111,
0.0137919271,
-0.0263751671,
-0.0016884654,
0.0069011808,
-0.0853618532,
0.0040512932,
0.0130077228,
-0.0183693953,
0.0673080981,
0.0453303419,
-0.0093312906,
-0.026543349,
0.0153467199,
0.0032635476,
0.0095657483,
-0.0284647439,
0.0283306055,
0.0282721594,
0.0089607863,
-0.0071470733,
0.0249834005,
-0.0314410478,
0.0016970686,
-0.0518738814,
0.0073333611,
-0.0345085226,
-0.0080588618,
0.0003941412,
-0.0191125963,
-0.023219049,
0.082386151,
-0.0379665755,
0.0664495602,
-0.0177517496,
-0.0377259068,
-0.0072202077,
0.0306802653,
-0.0094347792,
-0.0452478305,
0.0090637309,
0.0242752545,
0.031031657,
0.009054509,
-0.0349281542,
-0.0122276712,
0.0075953831,
-0.0740866587,
0.0283441916,
-0.0518734194,
0.0404771268,
0.0091216359,
0.019259816,
-0.0379136167,
0.0061895461,
0.0123446062,
-0.0509749837,
0.0455992445,
0.0403761677,
-0.0035723976,
0.04517214,
0.0374499075,
0.0171228573,
0.1152511239,
-0.0194695573,
0.0612565167,
0.0593721792,
-0.0199202467,
-0.0098533509,
0.0336321518,
0.0392602086,
0.0410960615,
-0.0634761602,
0.0297704246,
-0.031549342,
-0.0146434521,
0.0081586251,
0.0147964424,
-0.0016096066,
-0.0286065079,
0.0876184925,
-0.0243663713,
-0.0290984549,
0.0195523575,
0.0111149205,
0.0145187611,
-0.0195240881,
-0.0089898184,
-0.0698511973,
0.033821445,
0.0061314343,
-0.0537966229,
0.0170273613,
0.0428914167,
-0.0468481481,
-0.0029357783,
0.0047537084,
0.0102457851,
0.0140557894,
0.0060177655,
0.0110443179,
-0.0303971488,
-0.0527156889,
0.0507697947,
0.0483303927,
-0.033320602,
0.0485116355,
-0.0303115807,
0.0449072421,
0.012675249,
-0.0139615312,
-0.0295376983,
0.0125081306,
-0.0506196693,
0.0687571242,
0.0168736763,
0.0483207889,
-0.0472555235,
-0.0055358517,
-0.0222808551,
-0.0290188417,
-0.0006369307,
0.0423944034,
0.0399236977,
0.0024999359,
0.0251426436,
-0.018317936,
-0.0026566663,
-0.0262733102,
0.0160618033,
0.0604227707,
-0.0534361675,
-0.0157538913,
0.0246112179,
0.0438376889,
0.0523784235,
-0.0236822311,
-0.032826215,
0.0193229802,
0.0071626212,
-0.0188902058,
-0.042506814,
-0.02156936,
-0.023412548,
-0.0015181574,
-0.0480804592,
-0.0377738811,
0.0391908139,
-0.0518042408,
0.0377359018,
0.0508650094,
-0.0038861842,
0.0069903443,
-0.002417505,
-0.0328639932,
-0.0637761131,
0.0004669363,
-0.0199238043,
0.0696807653,
-0.0181051604,
-0.0302365031,
0.0444023646,
-0.0425170884,
-0.0197433494,
0.0089645889,
0.0019716795,
-0.0083391611,
0.0051321434,
0.0126669202,
0.0420071632,
-0.0586401187,
-0.0368584506,
-0.0336363316,
-0.0485931337,
0.0140199922,
-0.0363924392,
0.0089154793,
0.018706847,
0.0044203703,
0.0017487538,
0.0144278565,
-0.032632295,
-0.0371766984,
-0.0163576808,
0.0440462418,
-0.0232075695,
-0.0038309458,
0.0032993043,
-0.0146046514,
-0.0382575281,
-0.0495712273,
0.0467924476,
0.0235795714,
0.0066540316,
-0.0240647886,
-0.0415669121,
-0.0322149582,
-0.010308288,
-0.0190005898,
-0.0331168883,
0.0023620692,
0.0123734912,
-0.0362369716,
0.0681631416,
0.0464333259,
0.0513658226,
0.0404985175,
0.012304835,
-0.0526938587,
-0.0341471881,
-0.0562129878,
-0.0035962863,
-0.0498169586,
-0.0306784268,
0.0042720726,
0.0539496839,
0.0294351503,
0.0065004318,
-0.0423287451,
0.0749123245,
-0.0281356014,
-0.027341105,
0.0019088883,
-0.0138090262,
0.0111728003,
0.0039716894,
-0.032105539,
-0.0271808077,
0.0621883124,
0.0228869785,
0.038299311,
-0.0168255176,
-0.0166916642,
-0.0204548687,
-0.0197135936,
0.0111316815,
0.0376603715,
-0.0439818576,
0.003536744,
-0.0444302,
-0.0506492965,
0.0480411388,
-0.0268366057,
0.0128908344,
-0.0153000867,
-0.0185662936,
0.0156936292,
-0.0255480595,
-0.0281131156,
-0.0625396147,
-0.0068604774,
0.0045995652,
0.0272272471,
-0.0005644109,
-0.0341331586,
-0.0140508376,
0.0040153703,
-0.0660201833,
-0.0152555332,
0.0052667689,
0.0211849418,
0.0121607659,
0.0335411839,
-0.0564150326,
0.0466371551,
0.0070654005,
0.0113278786,
0.0259848889,
-0.0005619819,
0.0188560914,
-0.0426110886,
0.0059249969,
0.0143305128,
-0.0222213715,
0.0301545151,
-0.021709241,
0.0667449757,
-0.015986478,
0.0540148057,
0.1102498546,
-0.0026651062,
-0.0734833479,
-0.0212415624,
0.0417854898,
-0.0316611081,
0.0491904654,
-0.0046880287,
-0.1259381622,
-0.0029651371,
-0.0119801797,
0.0222726893,
-0.0239372291,
-0.0407094024,
-0.0109397396,
-0.1212795675,
0.0221292675,
0.0136639727,
0.0002047188,
-0.0362916589,
-0.0839007124,
0.0192104634,
-0.0714245215,
-0.003277767,
-0.0158554036,
0.0240870696,
-0.0012731174,
-0.0152271111,
-0.0251906533,
-0.0686710775,
0.0140308198,
-0.044714801,
0.0605926067,
0.0178078543,
0.0510122962,
-0.0105500128,
0.0043411115,
0.0512536094,
-0.0343676694,
-0.0349579751,
-0.0386302061,
0.0838364288,
-0.0714792162,
-0.017043924,
-0.0179227442,
0.0665717199,
0.0418944098,
0.0181786157,
-0.0181593709,
0.0420980975,
0.0329713933,
-0.0302217808,
-0.0343251005,
0.0029835207,
0.070229359,
0.0633042827,
0.0255837794,
-0.0440528691,
0.0160699561,
-0.0680595711,
-0.021058334,
-0.0016391913,
-0.0389938168,
-0.0022031628,
-0.025144456,
-0.0099498145,
0.0092728725,
-0.0289413948,
0.0246974044,
0.0016347795,
-0.0027589852,
-0.000309508,
0.0288312659,
-0.0213029701,
-0.0150950039,
0.043826066,
-0.0020759308,
0.0105989072,
0.0161651913,
-0.0537960045,
-0.0380542092,
0.0098171858,
-0.0329968631,
0.010058688,
-0.0575563535,
-0.0615387931,
0.0370065272,
0.0681649968,
0.0126496656,
0.040872898,
0.0018668618,
-0.0417051129,
0.0282536838,
0.0539129637,
-0.0359641574,
-0.0239995308,
0.0225249343,
-0.0181446355,
0.0230157394,
0.0287464261,
-0.0458278544,
0.0407035984,
0.0382985175,
-0.0436926372,
-0.0520515069,
0.0022763286,
0.0057737539,
-0.0428160466,
0.0576042347,
0.0115282051,
-0.0373556875,
-0.0680306628,
-0.035845764,
-0.0015283601,
-0.0566872135,
0.0239709411,
-0.0128779877,
0.0338614956,
-0.0204538051,
-0.0587717481,
-0.0415905118,
-0.039137125,
0.0130269248,
-0.0616017133,
0.0744322985,
0.0007315973,
0.0497687794,
0.0415581502,
-0.0113070961,
-0.0276068561,
0.0256299302,
0.0036303946,
0.0186824966,
0.001143251,
0.0407088734,
0.0231326725,
0.0206085872,
0.0383621156,
-0.0352760591,
0.0147296311,
-0.0067349607,
-0.0344408341,
0.0052638007,
0.0206044633,
-0.0715868324,
0.0078274757,
0.0424458198,
-0.0315253139,
0.0108144488,
-0.0092361942,
-0.0089295525,
-0.0524067357,
0.0440148227,
0.0405683666,
-0.0276040621,
0.0324235745,
0.0284960754,
0.0083356472,
0.0404864177,
0.03373174,
-0.0450768806,
-0.0114027737,
-0.0201843362,
0.038033545,
0.0191510599,
-0.0148235578,
0.0232794713,
-0.0466751717,
-0.0633706152,
-0.0138290413,
-0.0450758263,
0.0022726289,
0.0187598225,
-0.0128117362,
0.0379635505,
-0.0073650172,
0.0125390831,
-0.0335891172,
-0.0311467443,
-0.083035633,
-0.0394513942,
-0.0092797503,
-5.899278276e-33,
-0.0050962977,
-0.0081409104,
-0.0302617587,
-0.0234588087,
0.0052759042,
-0.0083453609,
-0.0180883072,
-0.0121988468,
-0.0289888401,
0.0275573004,
0.0428370424,
0.0489561521,
0.0089136614,
-0.000479138,
-0.0094637526,
-0.0303477664,
0.0538213998,
0.002808976,
-0.0259449035,
0.0308140423,
0.0011239554,
-0.0062591778,
0.0561616048,
-0.1135627478,
0.0244354866,
-0.024513809,
-0.0075364406,
-0.0119771101,
0.0201575533,
0.0614051782,
0.0105006574,
0.057766214,
0.0484587438,
-0.0642272159,
0.0298232883,
0.0781822577,
-0.0271898527,
-0.0094694588,
0.0039210059,
0.0066361688,
0.0341128968,
-0.0204005484,
-0.0224351827,
0.0111119645,
-0.045885358,
-0.0311415661,
0.0418418758,
-0.0125339748,
0.0558361225,
0.0286471415,
-0.050105609,
0.0080472622,
-0.0608453602,
0.0258796923,
-0.032122422,
0.0252629835,
0.0502146035,
0.059086863,
-0.0695649236,
0.0403861254,
-0.0302376989,
0.0192051791,
0.0266983751,
-0.009716847,
-0.0200902037,
0.0679368004,
0.0649219975,
0.0360995829,
-0.0500460677,
-0.0129688876,
-0.0082858447,
0.02066507,
0.029858591,
0.0808446035,
0.0298549905,
-0.0533103272,
-0.0820514336,
-0.021697538,
0.0611521453,
0.019082116,
0.0360502265,
-0.0253562778,
-0.0154847139,
-0.0193709955,
-0.0387961864,
-0.0821531266,
-0.0378762297,
-0.0070398008,
0.0111770127,
0.0279665533,
-0.0277834404,
0.0355679132,
0.0462280735,
-0.0385076851,
-0.0312655829,
0.0744425505,
-0.0281065404,
-0.0130507834,
0.0161108505,
0.0272513926,
-0.0688066781,
0.0170449801,
0.0067544845,
-0.0005916784,
0.0199111011,
0.0045953677,
0.0236699525,
0.0235668439,
-0.0371686779,
-0.0061631915,
-0.0183029175,
0.0111047076,
-0.0169730671,
0.0417243503,
0.0254082941,
0.0233825352,
0.0045837555,
0.025749268,
0.0048843836,
0.0121007953,
0.0494829342,
-0.0410889648,
-0.0381890237,
0.0030653304,
-0.0450650901,
-0.0550192259,
-0.0034803078,
0.0083060171,
-0.0062532849,
-0.0593761466,
-0.0223603696,
-0.0324383043,
2.42e-7,
0.0105407136,
0.0695560649,
-0.0483554117,
0.0073216213,
0.0240874775,
0.0282311141,
0.0174355283,
0.0196322128,
-0.0089977859,
-0.0368306264,
-0.0107033979,
0.0595171601,
-0.0017943846,
0.0301393773,
-0.0601982549,
0.0107146436,
-0.0340675414,
0.0405868553,
-0.0745571926,
0.0234941933,
-0.0075518833,
0.0902262405,
0.0331329294,
-0.0033097288,
-0.0033175712,
-0.0083128903,
0.0422907248,
-0.0153466593,
-0.003279245,
0.0181477424,
0.0150687983,
0.0081816474,
0.0049223434,
0.0248935297,
-0.0207394641,
0.0045964997,
-0.0361187272,
0.0643821284,
0.0103354976,
0.001423716,
-0.0069212015,
0.0073425868,
-0.002464978,
-0.0518919118,
0.0601171628,
-0.041070696,
-0.0613493435,
-0.1118459702,
-0.0537224188,
-0.0249780696,
0.0556692258,
-0.0129176304,
0.025022842,
-0.0251860619,
-0.0131077236,
0.0069921454,
-0.0127615668,
-0.0524741448,
0.0088617383,
0.0201675911,
-0.0412318259,
-0.066276677,
0.0093939407,
0.0248451401,
0.0392173044,
-0.0322888941,
0.0611805022,
1.948661985e-34,
0.041663751,
-0.0268472917,
0.0160016641,
-0.0317027457,
0.0527247861,
0.0130980769,
-0.0477900393,
-0.0179117303,
0.0280843675,
-0.045611605,
0.0103937816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00322v1 | Bias in Opinion Summarisation from Pre-training to Adaptation: A Case Study in Political Bias | 2024-02-01T04:15:59 | 2024-02-01T04:15:59 | Nannan Huang, Haytham Fayek, Xiuzhen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Opinion summarisation aims to summarise the salient information and opinions
presented in documents such as product reviews, discussion forums, and social
media texts into short summaries that enable users to effectively understand
the opinions therein. Generating biased summaries has the risk of potentially
swaying public opinion. Previous studies focused on studying bias in opinion
summarisation using extractive models, but limited research has paid attention
to abstractive summarisation models. In this study, using political bias as a
case study, we first establish a methodology to quantify bias in abstractive
models, then trace it from the pre-trained models to the task of summarising
social media opinions using different models and adaptation methods. We find
that most models exhibit intrinsic bias. Using a social media text
summarisation dataset and contrasting various adaptation methods, we find that
tuning a smaller number of parameters is less biased compared to standard
fine-tuning; however, the diversity of topics in training data used for
fine-tuning is critical. | Bias in Opinion Summarisation from Pre-training to Adaptation: A Case Study in Political Bias: Opinion summarisation aims to summarise the salient information and opinions
presented in documents such as product reviews, discussion forums, and social
media texts into short summaries that enable users to effectively understand
the opinions therein. Generating biased summaries has the risk of potentially
swaying public opinion. Previous studies focused on studying bias in opinion
summarisation using extractive models, but limited research has paid attention
to abstractive summarisation models. In this study, using political bias as a
case study, we first establish a methodology to quantify bias in abstractive
models, then trace it from the pre-trained models to the task of summarising
social media opinions using different models and adaptation methods. We find
that most models exhibit intrinsic bias. Using a social media text
summarisation dataset and contrasting various adaptation methods, we find that
tuning a smaller number of parameters is less biased compared to standard
fine-tuning; however, the diversity of topics in training data used for
fine-tuning is critical. | [
0.0573565848,
0.0356738642,
0.0199262332,
-0.0065358025,
-0.0064408989,
0.0248171203,
-0.0212849062,
-0.0366078913,
-0.0229612235,
-0.0501603298,
0.0148659861,
-0.0310018305,
-0.0002024225,
-0.0029051707,
-0.029782569,
-0.1059210151,
0.0449216478,
0.0296800174,
0.0728635415,
-0.0091962516,
0.0578347631,
0.0166152418,
0.0122765275,
0.0105647184,
0.0031062192,
0.0319545157,
0.0344561897,
-0.0171266291,
0.0528967641,
0.0227619018,
0.0099140294,
0.0425253846,
0.0042703473,
0.0212060176,
0.0000014235,
-0.0285827871,
-0.0337967202,
-0.0323006175,
0.0517391041,
0.0012338437,
0.1159595251,
-0.0319881774,
0.027348008,
0.0378481336,
-0.030345913,
0.0306883082,
0.0390081853,
0.0719681904,
0.0885913521,
0.0607662536,
-0.0107818954,
-0.0260550883,
-0.0219627526,
-0.0283850171,
-0.0301394202,
-0.0245535895,
0.0256282445,
-0.0033649094,
-0.0955040902,
0.0040081344,
0.0043626828,
0.0004906228,
-0.019057842,
0.0389591791,
0.0037360271,
0.0015837331,
-0.0400456525,
-0.0207219664,
0.0033235699,
0.0600495599,
0.0121695474,
-0.0211271644,
0.0121838506,
-0.0183805674,
0.0461667143,
0.0301321521,
-0.0560209788,
0.0228496417,
0.0035742016,
0.048835706,
0.0059688585,
0.0366246477,
-0.016121367,
0.0381363332,
-0.0020821602,
0.0165895019,
-0.0268860329,
-0.0275152922,
0.0095858974,
0.0475674421,
0.0097370939,
-0.0273727402,
0.002388129,
-0.0027794857,
0.0288284123,
0.0094701722,
-0.0480603352,
-0.0284112897,
0.0273543559,
-0.0838184804,
-0.0028468852,
-0.0169258863,
0.0074407491,
0.0706719309,
0.014349441,
-0.0410991013,
0.0125724915,
0.040722739,
-0.0221203193,
0.0124276001,
-0.0310567655,
0.036787536,
0.0002981205,
0.0255491808,
-0.0237060301,
0.0168600492,
-0.0178845674,
-0.0131941251,
-0.0091543486,
-0.0411071554,
-0.0244852062,
0.0084207486,
0.0118124764,
-0.0161687303,
-0.0525623038,
0.0431184918,
-0.0322272256,
0.0264365096,
0.0001114636,
0.0083182901,
0.0023445417,
0.0265810266,
0.0461348779,
-0.0030122048,
0.0056831688,
0.0170886014,
0.0043793633,
-0.0203654096,
-0.015817143,
-0.0030921979,
0.0092466883,
-0.0410884358,
0.0255505331,
-0.0411782376,
0.015649192,
-0.0052127754,
-0.0019207317,
0.0163293853,
-0.0169570092,
0.0089065414,
-0.0666910931,
0.024616044,
-0.013794844,
-0.0044407849,
0.041317407,
0.0157510657,
0.0228473209,
0.0533411354,
0.0118884994,
0.0644507036,
0.0709961802,
-0.0183675252,
0.0263740625,
0.0033809093,
0.0294406321,
0.0078975344,
0.0229854807,
0.0149154905,
-0.104842633,
-0.0602923296,
0.0370093361,
0.0543665402,
0.0021007559,
0.0215998739,
0.0590811372,
0.0330758132,
-0.0203199871,
0.0310731828,
-0.0230078232,
0.0332698487,
0.0216250587,
0.0429100506,
-0.016670024,
0.0245931093,
-0.0243579373,
0.0297269095,
0.0670924708,
0.0599110089,
-0.0375130735,
-0.0552785285,
0.0103794858,
0.0035679212,
0.0346823074,
-0.0031565733,
0.0165515896,
0.0122373877,
-0.0257270038,
0.0713504106,
0.0446749739,
-0.0700729191,
0.0240617897,
-0.03251509,
0.0276435055,
0.0109737907,
-0.0354784988,
-0.039039202,
-0.0035484703,
-0.0310871024,
0.012254064,
0.0200573914,
0.0966145918,
-0.0296310615,
-0.0471139811,
-0.0147059932,
-0.0434377715,
-0.0066468413,
0.0511159748,
0.0232295282,
0.0039129793,
-0.0073101693,
0.0313541368,
-0.0261988286,
-0.0697952583,
0.0122085717,
0.0518915579,
-0.0273563284,
-0.0100332601,
-0.0034407813,
0.0357533097,
0.0598324835,
-0.0342577137,
-0.0178373158,
0.0231928919,
0.0134420907,
-0.0350444838,
0.0047578537,
-0.043060679,
0.004992621,
0.0008831009,
-0.0786434859,
-0.0115461526,
0.0366673581,
-0.068356283,
-0.0177496783,
0.0702158362,
-0.0318921469,
0.0041649919,
-0.0058893361,
-0.0238222182,
-0.0466742851,
-0.0224033501,
-0.0304770358,
0.0505742207,
-0.0019539662,
-0.0578609481,
0.0149447815,
-0.0760074779,
0.0031655545,
0.0146758882,
-0.0132782422,
-0.0224104635,
0.0118374405,
0.0284839459,
0.0645535514,
-0.0395419449,
-0.0390801094,
-0.0459503569,
-0.0831818134,
-0.0197997093,
-0.0430301502,
0.0229481533,
0.0623386279,
0.0183820967,
0.0016760689,
-0.0125154424,
-0.0539792702,
-0.0375268869,
-0.0078185638,
0.0243145265,
0.0168145858,
0.0220213905,
0.043300923,
-0.0670621172,
-0.0209356192,
-0.0062075765,
0.0220555607,
0.009051674,
-0.0389686488,
-0.0191339776,
0.0059763617,
-0.0234603155,
-0.0237441286,
-0.019448787,
0.0184329785,
-0.0239536501,
0.029057676,
0.0097266287,
0.0457839333,
0.0606150478,
0.011453284,
0.036050085,
0.0525179803,
-0.0190929603,
-0.0498503856,
-0.0751551688,
0.0286297705,
-0.0027101827,
-0.0384997614,
0.0669026822,
0.0697169825,
0.0111766858,
0.0068884389,
-0.0329406001,
0.0586878769,
-0.0345750637,
-0.003462557,
-0.0189217553,
-0.0193778668,
-0.0012944684,
0.0112980306,
-0.0527501404,
-0.0268728733,
0.0387828127,
0.024631938,
0.080147624,
-0.0563512184,
-0.0281956885,
-0.0447396562,
-0.0013940368,
0.0162158366,
0.0176614914,
-0.01583625,
0.0256147776,
-0.0278610624,
-0.0584544912,
0.0381405465,
-0.0248622466,
0.0430892222,
-0.0036912782,
0.0154155008,
-0.0202733558,
-0.0144137666,
0.0195549894,
-0.0785692334,
-0.0141577581,
0.0318582729,
0.037678618,
0.0008566247,
-0.0130921481,
0.0186576433,
0.0357701555,
0.0059089209,
-0.027089946,
-0.0072821057,
0.0210237242,
0.0441764668,
0.0702355653,
-0.0251874346,
0.0542759933,
-0.0316370763,
-0.0099946354,
0.009285029,
0.018015638,
-0.0109511781,
-0.0199697763,
-0.0399409235,
-0.0193560142,
-0.0729097947,
0.0305488911,
-0.050938949,
0.0771343932,
-0.0041518421,
0.0574153028,
0.0775704384,
-0.0096110031,
-0.0508964136,
-0.016761262,
0.0320140682,
-0.0079646399,
0.0009102474,
-0.0032771649,
-0.0580614619,
0.0235292464,
-0.0243870281,
0.0283072349,
-0.0220846776,
-0.0046864823,
-0.0025398328,
-0.11122448,
-0.0145149771,
0.0061592758,
-0.05249428,
-0.0408747457,
-0.0466220006,
0.0385814905,
-0.080373086,
0.0156529024,
-0.0052919672,
-0.0226157587,
0.0348514505,
0.0285322703,
-0.0994576365,
-0.0100453664,
-0.0303740781,
-0.0208691638,
0.0074563944,
0.0493521914,
0.0388918035,
-0.0041135415,
0.0502865613,
0.0816215724,
-0.0321162492,
0.0097475946,
0.001022574,
0.116173476,
-0.0383562408,
0.0200673565,
-0.0004016857,
0.0464326739,
0.0149658481,
0.0019516979,
-0.0078859152,
0.0078741126,
0.0447375849,
-0.0396289565,
-0.0448939651,
0.0150604285,
0.0127850678,
0.068626672,
0.0351360403,
-0.0278936066,
-0.0170220081,
-0.0288163517,
-0.001118711,
-0.062011987,
-0.0405964106,
-0.0389426537,
-0.0429780222,
-0.000564039,
-0.0411939621,
-0.0641688928,
-0.0147512788,
-0.0208018087,
-0.0062914635,
-0.0192653537,
0.0499564819,
0.0221751053,
-0.0063621248,
0.0436032563,
-0.0005165653,
-0.0266795978,
0.0181933846,
-0.0831562802,
0.0177818425,
-0.0124643389,
-0.0418528877,
-0.0173732266,
-0.0465706177,
-0.0483446047,
0.0100786854,
0.0651750788,
0.0235181227,
0.057156764,
0.0248052143,
-0.0357887372,
0.0685508773,
0.0307178814,
-0.0112184109,
-0.0122803217,
0.0205073431,
0.0535967499,
-0.0059340089,
0.0116426442,
-0.0305934884,
0.0575201698,
0.0321639925,
-0.0330081061,
-0.06499511,
-0.0178164002,
-0.0085752979,
0.0156914666,
0.0487428494,
0.0286895726,
-0.017243715,
-0.0670625567,
-0.0426853783,
-0.0008189928,
-0.0177926365,
-0.005953691,
0.0111290906,
-0.0116897328,
-0.0091278572,
-0.0518300235,
0.0143622616,
-0.0077723744,
0.023462519,
-0.0648257136,
0.0341175459,
-0.0227200016,
0.0086061107,
-0.0331563838,
-0.0048954589,
-0.0554453172,
-0.0020597489,
-0.0243954547,
-0.0066769361,
0.0198524054,
-0.0356421135,
0.0046704663,
0.0296614897,
0.0266398452,
0.0127509311,
-0.0722536072,
0.0014585757,
-0.0812363774,
0.0110973176,
-0.0250761025,
-0.0760637373,
0.0582752153,
0.0251381584,
-0.0232798457,
0.0184248798,
-0.0056027011,
0.0086966883,
0.0201626346,
-0.0043552681,
0.0136775058,
-0.0295176078,
0.0124245528,
0.0569797456,
-0.0525348596,
0.0308078956,
0.0225438289,
-0.043514926,
-0.0346690901,
-0.0028702433,
-0.0000486275,
-0.0091335084,
-0.002333737,
-0.026054306,
-0.0489935726,
-0.0160692837,
0.0307584535,
-0.0064263586,
0.041651804,
0.0038612422,
-0.0059543834,
0.0505119674,
-0.0072117825,
0.0349405073,
-0.0469897687,
-0.0362652168,
-0.0298819449,
0.0155247534,
-0.01710077,
-5.830500102e-33,
-0.0172326397,
0.0084966309,
-0.0455491804,
0.0413336307,
-0.0171716083,
-0.0054754037,
-0.0292173531,
0.0241949316,
-0.0223453902,
0.0069674398,
-0.0059021651,
0.039914649,
0.0095190704,
0.0362241268,
-0.0122397291,
0.0000790807,
0.0536368452,
-0.0006728978,
-0.0461304896,
0.0517269522,
0.0229294077,
-0.0185085479,
0.0505459085,
-0.078888759,
0.0277020056,
-0.0014542859,
-0.030514719,
-0.0140247643,
0.0307895541,
0.0310435835,
0.0053417659,
0.0469819047,
0.0649306253,
-0.0399303585,
-0.0339910835,
0.0738791451,
-0.044879362,
-0.0281404536,
0.0344151594,
-0.0227063093,
-0.0047377618,
-0.0268814713,
0.0422517508,
0.0192405693,
-0.0442047715,
-0.0245325714,
0.0628059879,
-0.0229158718,
0.0280227736,
-0.0635857061,
-0.0420711152,
0.0414815843,
-0.0141615421,
0.0310290493,
-0.0192710776,
0.0517921001,
0.0277359672,
0.0445414707,
-0.0215795934,
0.0499362275,
0.0409506485,
0.0333463661,
0.0094792303,
-0.0112630641,
-0.0086399307,
0.0868626311,
0.0158486608,
0.0422346108,
-0.0444623865,
-0.0017142546,
-0.0092626065,
-0.0014578034,
0.0276138484,
0.0605261289,
0.0600005724,
-0.0166180432,
-0.0541541129,
0.0230697002,
0.0222714953,
-0.0130658699,
0.0712230057,
-0.0328350849,
0.0061659398,
0.0143112252,
-0.0402297638,
-0.0538359657,
-0.0166518725,
0.0024533411,
-0.0415194109,
0.0424124524,
-0.0434612073,
0.0252769776,
0.0000579224,
-0.0445804223,
0.028746523,
0.0045749517,
-0.0427241437,
-0.0012526475,
0.0106153423,
-0.0339856856,
-0.0668670163,
-0.0027260075,
-0.0047568223,
0.0199936852,
-0.0171338506,
-0.0166030135,
0.0676947087,
-0.0165294018,
-0.0532354377,
0.0094707794,
0.0207048152,
0.0444144793,
-0.0069748792,
0.0394357145,
0.0197751559,
0.0293126572,
0.0033089765,
0.0051516155,
0.0023337745,
0.0180000886,
0.0328729749,
0.0206147023,
-0.0109733855,
0.0063078189,
-0.0249328297,
-0.0320438966,
0.0202830117,
0.0104630329,
0.0081763854,
-0.0455722697,
-0.0280943457,
-0.0049160039,
2.189e-7,
0.0480372459,
0.067058377,
-0.0119014522,
-0.0421430878,
-0.0019512177,
0.0285578799,
0.0479009748,
0.040063031,
0.0168142598,
-0.0523544848,
0.0226757396,
0.0357462689,
0.0065873326,
0.0211962014,
-0.0577301383,
-0.0413160995,
-0.057666529,
0.0251941029,
-0.0025263971,
0.014641433,
0.0146979047,
0.0490163602,
-0.007497435,
-0.0121418023,
-0.0340419486,
-0.0153496042,
0.0332758278,
-0.0464997888,
-0.0395905115,
0.0367975123,
0.0536233783,
-0.0163013395,
0.0026703367,
-0.0061626737,
-0.0210480932,
-0.0086222133,
0.0089454856,
0.0233420357,
0.0316319652,
-0.0353108793,
0.0203066189,
0.011704932,
0.0162668061,
-0.0083004078,
0.0543652475,
-0.0950297415,
-0.042178411,
-0.1131551489,
-0.0598744005,
0.0216532033,
0.0164223313,
0.0094302315,
0.0055528218,
0.0183614157,
-0.018122023,
0.0170594156,
-0.0051313732,
-0.0561434478,
-0.020409137,
0.0139244571,
-0.0047263512,
-0.0717791244,
0.0173652954,
0.0245710108,
0.0012130273,
-0.0485314764,
0.044374913,
1.538650244e-34,
0.0934793204,
-0.0357363857,
-0.013871355,
-0.0499874391,
0.0204147138,
-0.0101193096,
-0.0329557583,
-0.0377678052,
0.0091079865,
-0.0689821094,
-0.0054292101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01769v1 | Redefining "Hallucination" in LLMs: Towards a psychology-informed framework for mitigating misinformation | 2024-02-01T03:01:11 | 2024-02-01T03:01:11 | Elijah Berberette, Jack Hutchins, Amir Sadovnik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have become incredibly popular,
with ChatGPT for example being used by over a billion users. While these models
exhibit remarkable language understanding and logical prowess, a notable
challenge surfaces in the form of "hallucinations." This phenomenon results in
LLMs outputting misinformation in a confident manner, which can lead to
devastating consequences with such a large user base. However, we question the
appropriateness of the term "hallucination" in LLMs, proposing a psychological
taxonomy based on cognitive biases and other psychological phenomena. Our
approach offers a more fine-grained understanding of this phenomenon, allowing
for targeted solutions. By leveraging insights from how humans internally
resolve similar challenges, we aim to develop strategies to mitigate LLM
hallucinations. This interdisciplinary approach seeks to move beyond
conventional terminology, providing a nuanced understanding and actionable
pathways for improvement in LLM reliability. | Redefining "Hallucination" in LLMs: Towards a psychology-informed framework for mitigating misinformation: In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have become incredibly popular,
with ChatGPT for example being used by over a billion users. While these models
exhibit remarkable language understanding and logical prowess, a notable
challenge surfaces in the form of "hallucinations." This phenomenon results in
LLMs outputting misinformation in a confident manner, which can lead to
devastating consequences with such a large user base. However, we question the
appropriateness of the term "hallucination" in LLMs, proposing a psychological
taxonomy based on cognitive biases and other psychological phenomena. Our
approach offers a more fine-grained understanding of this phenomenon, allowing
for targeted solutions. By leveraging insights from how humans internally
resolve similar challenges, we aim to develop strategies to mitigate LLM
hallucinations. This interdisciplinary approach seeks to move beyond
conventional terminology, providing a nuanced understanding and actionable
pathways for improvement in LLM reliability. | [
0.0399875268,
0.0231460482,
-0.0492515825,
0.0181988385,
-0.0437705703,
0.0098938374,
-0.0363631435,
0.0239891168,
0.0495690852,
-0.030538585,
-0.0082512759,
-0.033535026,
0.0072245789,
-0.0371420421,
0.0466470905,
-0.0550387986,
0.0529472679,
-0.0393455289,
0.0005094756,
-0.0330607072,
0.0028578625,
0.0122739561,
0.0136200069,
0.033584442,
0.0081526553,
-0.0507048219,
0.0037233622,
0.0047772257,
-0.0148878284,
-0.0235188771,
-0.0125996666,
0.0535019413,
-0.0092447596,
0.0613419786,
0.0000021767,
-0.0495701954,
0.0012070931,
-0.0148269162,
-0.0343175568,
0.0252079051,
0.0303912852,
0.0319084488,
0.0055850209,
0.0228420086,
-0.0220126845,
0.0219580308,
0.0268582087,
0.0679679587,
0.0416502878,
0.0347454697,
0.0079778852,
-0.0224442482,
0.0187464152,
0.0206237137,
0.0672131926,
-0.0182338096,
0.036402192,
0.0125025352,
-0.0099404687,
-0.0351756588,
-0.0087397629,
0.0048929937,
-0.0019780998,
0.0211593658,
-0.0527559854,
0.0130581968,
-0.0529186092,
-0.0353556871,
0.0056216442,
0.0240700468,
0.0028783504,
-0.044592794,
0.020630965,
-0.00024819,
0.0286406465,
0.0307350196,
-0.0479316004,
0.0247188862,
-0.0446653962,
-0.0275043473,
0.0388411395,
-0.0169232879,
0.0523516163,
0.0123231681,
-0.0111818891,
0.0771470442,
-0.0044419104,
-0.0337322839,
0.024810899,
-0.0015299681,
-0.0054097557,
-0.0744532198,
-0.0038424041,
0.0253580008,
-0.0459514149,
0.0066974713,
0.0090978937,
0.0391726978,
0.0584609322,
-0.1114383712,
-0.0032158745,
0.0181404222,
-0.0250624381,
0.0261823963,
0.0112086311,
0.0098666996,
-0.0475892648,
0.0724213123,
0.0116541609,
0.0279308129,
-0.0471733436,
-0.0172403827,
0.0108824288,
-0.0012359323,
0.0527184606,
0.0095365997,
-0.0146253649,
0.0068993047,
-0.0651273951,
0.0119181918,
-0.0650363788,
0.0134038702,
0.0044138147,
-0.0494891927,
-0.0367803238,
0.0199906975,
-0.0032594581,
0.0103633944,
0.012391625,
-0.084387891,
-0.0023126514,
0.0095654521,
-0.0784916431,
0.0251829885,
-0.0101870056,
0.0450433157,
0.0341248885,
0.027711045,
-0.0653286129,
-0.0637590438,
-0.0132555459,
-0.0557954833,
0.0190013349,
-0.0557913445,
-0.0215588994,
0.0183833279,
-0.0109067364,
-0.0297320876,
0.0058197696,
0.0188945364,
-0.0518257581,
0.0719576553,
-0.0329580903,
0.0058572204,
0.0771429762,
0.0769037008,
-0.0314679369,
0.0641695336,
-0.018358117,
0.0445830412,
0.0099699488,
0.0005340841,
0.0733512416,
0.0198911242,
-0.0257205833,
0.0049142754,
-0.0220495686,
-0.0148392636,
-0.0223444514,
-0.0144468639,
0.0009442004,
0.0515754558,
-0.0272180568,
0.0057833241,
0.0646319687,
0.0056288792,
-0.0173079781,
0.029146539,
-0.012787696,
0.0066877427,
0.0062098233,
0.045498997,
-0.0561032556,
0.0252293348,
-0.0434849039,
0.0027748675,
0.0416910686,
0.001087336,
-0.0194163676,
-0.037475381,
-0.0339183882,
0.0219375566,
0.0023060688,
0.0374573804,
-0.0099391351,
0.0071814456,
-0.0184599906,
0.0796120316,
0.0356666222,
-0.0036601913,
-0.0021210683,
-0.0646432266,
-0.0234793499,
0.0768191442,
0.0348494165,
-0.011662825,
-0.0048152022,
-0.0296050142,
0.0300644264,
0.0620520487,
0.0593939312,
0.012379989,
-0.0475979894,
-0.0178850852,
0.0063743684,
0.0078547811,
0.0311888866,
0.0095607424,
-0.0376770347,
-0.004065617,
-0.0302581694,
-0.0192672983,
-0.0540265143,
0.0280149262,
-0.0271169282,
-0.0036878122,
-0.0739300773,
-0.0099477815,
0.0204671193,
-0.0036708696,
0.0020722065,
0.0374283828,
0.0105638513,
0.0085701896,
-0.0296741109,
0.0318229198,
-0.0373262838,
0.0375166126,
0.0479032099,
-0.0132108359,
-0.0265253633,
-0.0398965999,
0.0107901525,
0.0062263068,
0.0381630994,
-0.0646320209,
0.0725450963,
-0.0044417325,
0.0377555601,
-0.0192457363,
0.0180003829,
-0.0121032335,
0.0577906221,
-0.0432625376,
0.0102757821,
0.0309269764,
-0.0194778908,
0.000679221,
-0.0025787274,
-0.0005660224,
0.0195476133,
0.0233777594,
0.0140463058,
0.0012569341,
-0.0410623327,
-0.0859625414,
-0.001090189,
-0.0612481013,
-0.0335442908,
-0.0107248053,
0.0080199521,
0.0250969455,
-0.050939098,
-0.0278590359,
0.0119520323,
0.00285589,
0.0057393233,
0.0075712441,
0.0586640239,
0.0132337334,
-0.0040363357,
-0.0393554755,
-0.0038430013,
0.024437869,
-0.0292552542,
0.0286608767,
-0.0059910328,
-0.0436450243,
-0.0932635814,
0.0390943177,
-0.0501754172,
-0.0146011449,
-0.0242710132,
-0.0072147357,
0.029934708,
0.0280233081,
0.0374988392,
0.0365649089,
0.0250098631,
0.0345513746,
0.0587598942,
-0.0212178584,
-0.0472007543,
-0.0455459915,
0.0043769809,
-0.0226764642,
0.0049708565,
-0.0765338019,
-0.011049917,
0.0397199951,
0.0405921265,
0.0214715283,
-0.0500336029,
0.0573007539,
-0.0495298989,
-0.06395109,
0.0222135335,
-0.0621056035,
-0.0440492593,
0.0573390871,
-0.0309328809,
-0.055762291,
0.0719831139,
-0.001004348,
0.0256083161,
-0.0105089527,
0.0150599461,
0.0181179047,
0.0142312143,
-0.0256199744,
0.0131969918,
0.0578056946,
-0.0342920162,
-0.0528576635,
-0.0483532175,
-0.0171550177,
-0.0504998788,
0.027161533,
-0.0491781197,
-0.0261518862,
0.0428174846,
-0.0009695744,
-0.0554498024,
-0.0180841703,
-0.0343856551,
-0.0420186855,
-0.0136922151,
0.0168981999,
-0.0326809213,
-0.0349595547,
0.030615326,
-0.0381609499,
0.0011371751,
-0.0529204458,
0.0114551205,
-0.0579028539,
0.0291923024,
-0.0013606375,
0.0974840075,
-0.0677726418,
0.0136403302,
0.0975743085,
0.0276902467,
0.012099931,
0.0204176363,
-0.0225774404,
0.0318928696,
-0.0072049927,
-0.04336432,
0.0500326082,
0.0238508862,
-0.0431763493,
-0.0167232715,
0.0957079232,
0.0374762528,
-0.0456807315,
0.0073212557,
-0.1084365696,
0.0451342799,
0.0280204397,
-0.0113092223,
-0.0772888511,
0.0042464961,
0.0207798462,
-0.0093305092,
-0.0464952663,
-0.0184042044,
-0.0212180503,
-0.0457310453,
0.03377847,
0.040801879,
0.0131289139,
0.0006405055,
-0.0082818288,
-0.0103116073,
0.0307674892,
0.0607501827,
0.0047949404,
0.0022913592,
-0.0245073363,
0.0365330614,
-0.0977002606,
-0.00495697,
0.024330331,
-0.0069681779,
0.0567437261,
0.0419919044,
0.0141903916,
-0.018248355,
-0.0940508842,
0.038616173,
0.0204637367,
-0.00063593,
-0.0106593575,
0.0576888286,
0.0108944746,
0.038187027,
-0.0204914231,
-0.0044375076,
-0.0256238263,
-0.0425450355,
0.0020225246,
0.0974051952,
-0.0365604758,
-0.0578055009,
-0.0019281466,
0.0457939208,
0.0131152179,
0.061094299,
0.0136475964,
-0.0208532456,
-0.0268002227,
-0.0552729219,
0.0413915254,
0.0335195698,
-0.067482166,
0.0411235727,
0.0468098558,
-0.0169380028,
-0.0288721789,
-0.0427381136,
0.0031765306,
-0.0082004964,
0.0236174669,
0.0481762253,
-0.0201894101,
-0.0141543746,
0.0028048283,
0.0161326323,
-0.029370252,
0.0049997023,
-0.0197138712,
0.0087603331,
-0.0176115837,
-0.0187846236,
0.0407083817,
0.0293707401,
-0.0438915007,
-0.064844206,
0.0573777407,
0.0133106951,
0.0398404412,
0.0130506055,
0.000640485,
-0.0548043698,
0.0242184717,
0.0179411862,
-0.0004459652,
0.0136717781,
0.0360629372,
0.0526165031,
0.0117585128,
0.0333935916,
-0.0025895496,
-0.0209794808,
0.0013793809,
-0.0038305041,
-0.0546564274,
-0.0106184203,
0.0541078523,
0.0001635956,
0.0059864982,
-0.0408773907,
0.0098539032,
0.0093077859,
-0.0188913122,
-0.0204074904,
-0.0234856922,
0.0329898372,
-0.0245495625,
0.0176557079,
-0.0185855497,
0.0258419346,
-0.024572311,
-0.0505975634,
-0.00903132,
-0.0084121758,
-0.0075744148,
0.0047997106,
0.0144409733,
0.0355192162,
-0.0035971201,
-0.0037857457,
0.0083397105,
-0.0068519902,
0.0572185591,
0.0122139324,
0.089271225,
0.0118307127,
-0.0177665129,
-0.0057371273,
-0.0172980409,
-0.0202555619,
-0.1343486756,
0.028018903,
0.0236559212,
0.0334122255,
0.0222594533,
0.0357690156,
-0.0279153772,
0.0081757205,
0.0064176628,
-0.0268607773,
0.0157569144,
-0.0302238073,
-0.0016751648,
0.0112432251,
-0.0387105756,
-0.0128035937,
0.0550144948,
-0.0433128551,
0.0397821926,
-0.0273097605,
-0.0351446569,
-0.0251789819,
-0.0381278507,
-0.02567867,
0.0318518654,
-0.0313985534,
-0.0358519778,
-0.1173903197,
-0.0422098041,
-0.0049841283,
-0.0006517495,
0.0149536859,
-0.0422259234,
0.0060145757,
0.0930749252,
0.0023690879,
-0.0309311338,
-0.0088490285,
0.0201200265,
0.0387665406,
0.0236896854,
-0.0153696965,
-6.415559436e-33,
0.0081159836,
-0.0576591343,
0.0204262771,
0.0003147495,
-0.0168718565,
-0.0459544435,
-0.0007047372,
0.0535847209,
-0.0136591531,
0.0303455591,
-0.001151449,
0.0228182133,
0.0134706153,
-0.0308611896,
0.0437561758,
-0.0173463933,
0.0257919282,
0.0098565705,
-0.0246734191,
0.0014412657,
0.0356042422,
-0.0151254432,
0.0351664983,
-0.0857529789,
0.087539494,
-0.0133807659,
0.0020086132,
0.0024000427,
-0.0307199396,
0.0117819896,
-0.0050131814,
0.0445848405,
0.0227035545,
-0.0389594585,
-0.0387119427,
0.0145392912,
0.0469488353,
-0.0361028388,
0.0614517033,
0.0240504295,
-0.0032275985,
-0.0167142637,
0.0310715046,
-0.013898558,
-0.0210713502,
0.0059692394,
0.0161268953,
-0.0310987588,
-0.0124459444,
0.0635081753,
-0.0482369065,
-0.0175106265,
0.0249514002,
0.0271180235,
-0.0052566831,
0.0417730622,
-0.0249417257,
-0.027040191,
-0.1053376943,
0.0366332382,
0.0001479441,
-0.0050750193,
0.0711725429,
-0.0099788802,
-0.0069663571,
0.0779786631,
0.0429201387,
0.0678888932,
-0.0423857458,
-0.0306141786,
-0.0015641424,
0.0461239554,
0.0467936322,
0.0137486346,
0.0261574015,
-0.0376263261,
-0.0257788785,
-0.007131319,
0.0054650707,
0.0083923601,
0.0586395673,
0.0156806987,
-0.0727984086,
-0.0532406494,
0.0101852845,
0.0189387519,
-0.0299605504,
-0.0342601761,
0.0065068672,
-0.0244340841,
0.0112248017,
-0.0280590542,
0.0099400626,
-0.0268663839,
-0.0154312346,
-0.0348561183,
0.0031931191,
-0.0102583794,
0.0071265753,
0.0101939552,
-0.0096380152,
0.0005685827,
-0.0494135506,
0.0136023378,
0.0372568071,
0.013426559,
0.0056880969,
-0.028325431,
-0.0414321683,
-0.0045794104,
-0.0371472426,
0.0285183061,
0.0415740609,
-0.0577352829,
0.0449626222,
-0.0040935506,
-0.0129236793,
-0.0415208526,
0.0521017909,
-0.0124733811,
-0.0235908553,
0.0492963642,
-0.0593937002,
0.0095057022,
-0.0220283642,
-0.0291642994,
-0.0454767309,
0.0119659537,
0.0613597557,
-0.0608812496,
-0.0352155268,
-0.0383459888,
2.855e-7,
0.0026953081,
0.0692037344,
-0.0103188083,
0.032155294,
0.0401973873,
0.0372551121,
0.0144247068,
-0.00703697,
0.0413148142,
-0.0688857213,
-0.0354384072,
0.0115580894,
0.0285195727,
0.068556942,
-0.0259974934,
-0.0358463153,
-0.0174887944,
0.0312752724,
-0.0383320786,
-0.0067620776,
0.0524041429,
0.0083733983,
0.0133952033,
-0.0180356782,
-0.0475726277,
-0.0144936191,
0.0451294743,
-0.019619735,
0.005247273,
0.0488867722,
0.0632300824,
0.0112365503,
0.0342582464,
0.0461138301,
0.0104097528,
-0.060283497,
-0.0383287854,
-0.013621727,
0.0007082461,
-0.0399758741,
-0.0229083616,
-0.0182015561,
0.0286706518,
-0.0796401873,
0.0243335832,
-0.0528899543,
-0.0396749862,
0.0022890882,
-0.0193005763,
-0.0369291715,
0.041501414,
0.028852202,
-0.0353940092,
0.0183758475,
0.0088607753,
0.041434221,
0.0018693875,
-0.0499322563,
-0.0179789215,
0.025404444,
-0.0360264629,
-0.0484917425,
0.0055125821,
0.0188705809,
-0.0272980928,
-0.0548885316,
0.0139742419,
2.726798608e-34,
0.0034337826,
0.0290851947,
0.0468448661,
0.023906868,
0.0260839239,
0.0120592061,
0.0439781174,
0.0301005952,
0.0279613454,
0.0023876426,
-0.0097157704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01767v1 | HiQA: A Hierarchical Contextual Augmentation RAG for Massive Documents QA | 2024-02-01T02:24:15 | 2024-02-01T02:24:15 | Xinyue Chen, Pengyu Gao, Jiangjiang Song, Xiaoyang Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As language model agents leveraging external tools rapidly evolve,
significant progress has been made in question-answering(QA) methodologies
utilizing supplementary documents and the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
approach. This advancement has improved the response quality of language models
and alleviates the appearance of hallucination. However, these methods exhibit
limited retrieval accuracy when faced with massive indistinguishable documents,
presenting notable challenges in their practical application. In response to
these emerging challenges, we present HiQA, an advanced framework for
multi-document question-answering (MDQA) that integrates cascading metadata
into content as well as a multi-route retrieval mechanism. We also release a
benchmark called MasQA to evaluate and research in MDQA. Finally, HiQA
demonstrates the state-of-the-art performance in multi-document environments. | HiQA: A Hierarchical Contextual Augmentation RAG for Massive Documents QA: As language model agents leveraging external tools rapidly evolve,
significant progress has been made in question-answering(QA) methodologies
utilizing supplementary documents and the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
approach. This advancement has improved the response quality of language models
and alleviates the appearance of hallucination. However, these methods exhibit
limited retrieval accuracy when faced with massive indistinguishable documents,
presenting notable challenges in their practical application. In response to
these emerging challenges, we present HiQA, an advanced framework for
multi-document question-answering (MDQA) that integrates cascading metadata
into content as well as a multi-route retrieval mechanism. We also release a
benchmark called MasQA to evaluate and research in MDQA. Finally, HiQA
demonstrates the state-of-the-art performance in multi-document environments. | [
0.0570360795,
0.029458547,
0.0024211251,
0.0255434383,
-0.0010792639,
-0.003624527,
-0.011538065,
-0.018267842,
-0.0191115458,
-0.0608094856,
-0.0422770455,
0.0037904952,
-0.0603648312,
0.0077779717,
-0.0028084908,
-0.0265791398,
0.0414155871,
-0.016203789,
-0.0245199017,
-0.0131818131,
0.0167551655,
0.0412881523,
0.0155177983,
0.0219073948,
-0.0345564075,
-0.0404107794,
-0.0217399485,
0.0214053467,
0.0036492473,
-0.0210034698,
0.0435577966,
0.0272939783,
0.0550879315,
0.0572942831,
0.0000017605,
-0.0536763631,
-0.0351523347,
0.028601069,
-0.0195354205,
-0.0128063653,
0.0354790725,
0.0267571993,
0.0281421989,
0.0093520712,
-0.0300368387,
0.0017154186,
0.0118549336,
0.0308634602,
0.0540771671,
0.0503328368,
-0.0042510256,
-0.0484001487,
0.0496540889,
0.00668047,
0.0420772284,
-0.0536171198,
0.0101251118,
0.0642861947,
0.079034999,
0.0396585539,
0.0258253422,
0.0451784953,
0.0359987095,
-0.030156346,
0.0043197218,
0.0040579727,
-0.026429832,
0.0451933071,
-0.0072915968,
0.0772148594,
0.0504719876,
-0.0184781067,
0.0003450942,
0.0167669114,
-0.0041731414,
0.0321063213,
-0.0729842111,
0.0059402846,
-0.0311551001,
-0.0395592302,
0.0179396588,
0.0033380592,
0.0212787967,
0.0238667056,
0.0002527155,
0.0603120849,
0.026630275,
-0.0276486762,
-0.019298071,
0.0113406517,
-0.0351649225,
-0.0426489487,
0.0260914676,
0.0900840461,
-0.0416283831,
0.0245182533,
-0.0212369896,
-0.064971827,
0.0745372549,
-0.0575666539,
-0.0268745832,
0.0170436818,
-0.0298969019,
0.0788836554,
-0.0291946791,
0.0027024811,
-0.0530342832,
-0.0244755335,
-0.0723799244,
-0.0555681437,
-0.0574332066,
-0.0531070381,
-0.0716706589,
0.0540540926,
-0.0449301004,
-0.0398582593,
0.0149994288,
0.0525305383,
0.0157261156,
-0.0260111224,
-0.0099447938,
0.0225985274,
-0.0376664363,
-0.0171287116,
-0.0099803666,
0.0148344552,
-0.0718663409,
0.015841011,
0.0217682086,
-0.0356128104,
0.0100657037,
0.0269669965,
0.0281948596,
-0.0219818912,
0.0006980947,
0.0052974895,
-0.0267813355,
-0.0192236584,
-0.0315377861,
-0.0424113683,
0.0003025825,
-0.0398082212,
-0.0053437785,
-0.0757988021,
0.0170760024,
0.0048031178,
-0.038936846,
0.0113002202,
0.0054240664,
0.0405359901,
-0.0170786325,
0.0107490821,
-0.0022323942,
-0.017641278,
0.0944670513,
0.0244064126,
-0.0104827099,
0.0649421066,
0.0047998275,
-0.0076696682,
0.0577763505,
0.0365772098,
0.0129324924,
0.0100669749,
0.0094000995,
0.0247083697,
-0.0016966801,
0.0617189892,
0.0107610282,
0.0138136977,
0.0221797023,
0.0533828102,
-0.0535816886,
-0.0162799452,
-0.0180398803,
0.0032639548,
-0.0090998635,
-0.0156729668,
0.0569024719,
0.0302020889,
0.0009475054,
0.0160394125,
-0.0067339996,
0.0431662016,
-0.0295336843,
0.0126960287,
0.0872908831,
0.0045509203,
-0.0439165235,
-0.0173382815,
0.0003822414,
0.00621656,
-0.0098442938,
0.0145105449,
0.0157797839,
0.0216428544,
-0.0163897797,
0.0196873825,
0.0150270639,
-0.0198419448,
0.0175058749,
-0.0307303574,
0.0441673882,
0.0496850461,
0.0878262818,
-0.0451474339,
-0.0351302773,
-0.0063281464,
0.0228717458,
0.0320070162,
0.0274547879,
-0.0348488092,
0.006937129,
-0.0440458208,
-0.0216038823,
-0.0525824204,
-0.003827401,
0.029408548,
0.0286122635,
-0.0029462313,
0.0385394469,
-0.0403485894,
0.0099092005,
0.0281957686,
-0.0468484759,
-0.0181954037,
0.0160556938,
-0.0135471961,
-0.0019593858,
0.034842629,
-0.0040019215,
0.0232093371,
0.043853987,
-0.014878992,
-0.0346904993,
-0.0260658953,
-0.0297234841,
-0.0339278802,
0.0386039913,
0.0094819395,
-0.0115457401,
0.0008049621,
-0.0214145668,
-0.0606899671,
-0.0160210673,
-0.0357638597,
0.0347812474,
-0.0757852942,
-0.0094032083,
0.0363817774,
0.0317385122,
-0.0336690843,
0.0589826778,
0.0121406531,
0.0306513272,
0.0245203394,
0.0378058739,
0.0366897099,
-0.0364506617,
0.0145635633,
-0.0052414616,
-0.0127725834,
0.0237983353,
0.0264756605,
-0.0027571102,
-0.0508419015,
-0.0313208997,
-0.0955823287,
0.0071380287,
-0.0349575654,
0.0184087902,
0.0352851823,
0.0346557721,
-0.0009215776,
-0.0422661528,
-0.0770821646,
-0.0014528149,
0.047728654,
0.0399996974,
0.0236901324,
0.0464464799,
0.012265333,
-0.0446973704,
-0.0178632028,
0.0060371552,
0.0401564427,
0.0035885442,
0.0061567249,
-0.0182185844,
-0.0375094749,
-0.0496386662,
0.0347335376,
-0.0097892396,
0.0246090069,
0.0094832052,
-0.048533611,
0.0479999036,
0.0077376678,
0.002870152,
-0.0063332319,
0.0375572853,
-0.0107915187,
-0.079828158,
0.0240836907,
-0.0018410035,
-0.0112848794,
-0.0102362325,
-0.0034525576,
0.0096791685,
0.011485043,
-0.0255612545,
-0.013146068,
-0.0030540302,
-0.0021924896,
0.0265086796,
-0.0368993878,
-0.0339543335,
-0.0434776805,
0.0183340944,
0.0443022698,
-0.0031442994,
0.0153707117,
0.0675446317,
-0.0280678403,
-0.0234035011,
-0.0619118549,
0.0173494909,
-0.0552643947,
0.0563672632,
-0.0067729554,
0.0276279505,
-0.063557893,
-0.0123252254,
-0.009552015,
0.0020021792,
-0.0029556281,
-0.0391234756,
0.0014699728,
-0.0082289102,
0.0502945222,
-0.0116441641,
-0.0208446719,
-0.034231253,
-0.0279823747,
0.0265660249,
0.0229619239,
-0.0226486437,
-0.0010637053,
-0.0377763286,
-0.0053905444,
0.0249907244,
0.0546807311,
-0.0353578813,
-0.0315352976,
-0.0087275906,
0.1093763858,
0.0884545147,
0.0271124188,
0.0415473841,
-0.0161093399,
0.0209470969,
0.0585427806,
0.0250877347,
-0.0203505754,
0.0102826795,
-0.0272627026,
0.0131637026,
-0.0239636879,
-0.0086917328,
-0.0135698989,
0.0202829428,
-0.0793415532,
-0.0391188376,
0.0743302554,
0.0701133683,
-0.0378946513,
-0.014906331,
-0.072414726,
0.0532639809,
0.0216778647,
0.0775352642,
-0.0929092392,
-0.0128748864,
-0.0128862122,
0.0352056213,
-0.0072979145,
0.0001854339,
0.0005905217,
-0.077135399,
0.0524131991,
-0.0393180773,
-0.043508593,
0.0382492319,
-0.0268640984,
0.0102983601,
0.0506025515,
0.0264398921,
0.0275796931,
-0.0256153792,
-0.0100152381,
-0.0081941234,
0.0443631783,
-0.0105657326,
0.0181485303,
-0.0069579771,
0.0103377672,
0.040008761,
0.0119010154,
0.0186883491,
-0.0118247904,
0.0376391113,
-0.0340564288,
-0.0024637727,
0.0113822678,
0.0160069335,
-0.01173802,
0.0341678895,
-0.0183594599,
0.0111549832,
-0.0230680276,
0.0005300887,
0.0161368493,
0.0367508493,
-0.0282992627,
0.0164920632,
-0.052972585,
0.006569305,
0.0062148832,
0.0874129087,
0.0070990031,
-0.0082982425,
-0.0426010825,
-0.0122580566,
-0.0017264347,
-0.0265818834,
0.0225316938,
0.025083622,
-0.0024460391,
0.0129005881,
-0.1024511158,
-0.062381953,
0.0075788321,
0.0125873601,
-0.0392627455,
0.0254934952,
-0.0457267538,
-0.0199811794,
-0.0442265198,
0.0087093152,
-0.0291053765,
-0.0070171203,
-0.0225192308,
0.0115063824,
0.0490807444,
-0.0574203953,
-0.0286537018,
0.0104288589,
-0.0727453977,
-0.0317241251,
-0.0073106047,
0.0083776386,
0.0125080273,
0.0527437069,
-0.054411605,
-0.0490287766,
0.0305108465,
0.0194871128,
-0.0647415444,
-0.0005369941,
0.0042206203,
0.0093386797,
-0.0316515975,
0.0403527915,
-0.1140153036,
0.0304328054,
-0.0456346162,
0.0581117123,
-0.0030772781,
-0.0189996455,
0.0285216216,
0.0027533972,
-0.0446539856,
0.0212634504,
0.040377181,
-0.0125959711,
0.0357980058,
-0.0404728428,
-0.0456334166,
-0.0095154932,
0.0208084024,
-0.0053059538,
-0.0536915474,
0.016108647,
0.0085779354,
-0.0114388261,
0.0722130239,
-0.0199842043,
-0.0060019772,
0.016351128,
-0.0056371349,
0.0043216599,
-0.0145502659,
-0.0351900719,
0.0058646933,
0.0115707144,
0.0802639276,
-0.043266952,
0.0713537186,
0.0184635781,
-0.0417219698,
-0.0122894635,
0.0183919854,
-0.1244153157,
-0.0411250331,
-0.0257394835,
0.0159351528,
0.00886661,
0.0133030042,
0.0527861863,
-0.0049712183,
-0.0239641741,
-0.0181878153,
-0.0394288823,
0.0293287244,
-0.040755,
0.0230424218,
0.0367790237,
-0.011377601,
0.077296555,
0.0648429021,
-0.0232250467,
0.0276916493,
-0.0091688316,
-0.003271722,
-0.0207882635,
-0.0494722463,
-0.0045497967,
0.0776302889,
-0.0311223008,
0.008499545,
-0.0111695752,
-0.0195875913,
-0.0230070222,
0.0015766892,
-0.0523888879,
-0.0110526849,
0.034739282,
0.0640649647,
0.0250466429,
-0.0334964283,
-0.0615045466,
0.0320173539,
-0.0647559166,
-0.0283557195,
0.0003397721,
-6.364974241e-33,
-0.0266601425,
-0.0102390628,
0.049378965,
-0.0301331356,
0.0008880059,
0.0095391218,
-0.0596985333,
-0.0308164787,
-0.0231080279,
-0.0109300343,
-0.019798018,
0.0181480236,
0.0011608596,
0.0539770797,
-0.0279770233,
-0.0015406822,
0.023295857,
0.0059091123,
-0.014354161,
0.057249222,
0.0587121025,
-0.0047820909,
0.0044005383,
-0.0365957245,
0.0157823749,
-0.0427022018,
0.000199337,
0.0475879945,
-0.0241033584,
0.1031107605,
-0.02366817,
0.0120488266,
0.0413581356,
0.0005029884,
-0.0002432637,
0.0046706097,
-0.0968526974,
-0.009907716,
-0.0172368027,
-0.0155156115,
-0.0540313832,
-0.0391653031,
0.0234728958,
-0.0200421158,
0.0430847332,
0.0188902467,
0.027040232,
-0.0102194436,
-0.0275269672,
-0.0523017012,
-0.0739105046,
0.0086160228,
-0.0185951404,
0.0125362128,
-0.0415984653,
0.0707065463,
0.0088309227,
0.062861681,
-0.062288966,
0.0031963245,
-0.0313767195,
0.0250108857,
0.0301165804,
0.0100909695,
-0.009879834,
0.0172119681,
0.0175770726,
0.021281993,
0.0009520416,
-0.029063547,
-0.0090807294,
0.0075425422,
0.0119249029,
0.0482516959,
0.0311611705,
0.0551856197,
-0.0385053791,
0.0685861558,
-0.0077635208,
0.030387735,
0.0177139249,
0.0124443118,
-0.0210601687,
0.0047297897,
-0.0307132211,
0.0264575295,
-0.0408199392,
-0.0292362738,
0.0423810557,
0.0122783873,
-0.0117865214,
0.0080110552,
0.0494056903,
-0.0296049546,
-0.003385942,
0.0477816202,
-0.0408856757,
0.0374863409,
-0.0053854855,
0.0779750124,
-0.0025923476,
0.0210067071,
0.0630377755,
-0.0316968523,
-0.0374685079,
0.0253992081,
0.0245644394,
-0.0012872419,
-0.0628727153,
0.0242252871,
-0.0159064289,
0.0309304409,
-0.0594648458,
-0.0196013916,
0.0207312759,
0.0197582394,
0.0039649224,
0.0637951642,
0.0320086367,
0.0252346098,
-0.0301111359,
-0.054828316,
-0.0078127729,
0.0078558587,
-0.0197452456,
0.0638241693,
-0.0372269712,
0.0032994444,
0.013845657,
-0.0566868447,
0.0107047576,
0.0587796494,
2.476e-7,
0.0574848615,
0.0265404154,
0.0360162109,
-0.0178337041,
0.0351949036,
-0.0140396385,
-0.0021541708,
0.0106118079,
0.0124245388,
-0.0079569267,
-0.008075919,
0.0475778468,
0.0261457656,
0.0260715447,
-0.0514233299,
-0.0126981251,
-0.0831784606,
-0.0330217555,
-0.064357467,
-0.023283558,
0.0344563015,
0.0554248467,
-0.0386041515,
-0.0288068578,
-0.0342292786,
-0.0550340675,
0.0675149485,
0.0382074043,
-0.0206158832,
0.0395642519,
0.0143288914,
0.0085975127,
0.0312540717,
-0.0291451868,
-0.0047975243,
0.0467075221,
0.0160204768,
0.0531130396,
-0.0011326269,
-0.0552789159,
-0.000773914,
-0.0202111136,
0.0461323597,
-0.0622935817,
0.0911083743,
-0.0013966212,
0.0103724143,
-0.0071411603,
-0.0617010966,
-0.0002246716,
-0.0238894541,
-0.0367621891,
-0.0209751651,
0.030772442,
0.0095918104,
-0.005529929,
0.0027042388,
-0.0719316453,
-0.0160992555,
0.0067324964,
-0.0459533334,
-0.0184197146,
-0.0164933987,
0.0026810458,
-0.0184921622,
-0.0443718061,
-0.0116998386,
2.19561521e-34,
0.0609010756,
0.0153423622,
-0.0061490834,
0.0258678347,
0.0305171832,
-0.0032589834,
-0.0365837701,
0.0017845492,
0.0228076074,
-0.116692625,
0.0035474896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00271v1 | A Crucial Parameter for Rank-Frequency Relation in Natural Languages | 2024-02-01T01:45:46 | 2024-02-01T01:45:46 | Chenchen Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL | $f \propto r^{-\alpha} \cdot (r+\gamma)^{-\beta}$ has been empirically shown
more precise than a na\"ive power law $f\propto r^{-\alpha}$ to model the
rank-frequency ($r$-$f$) relation of words in natural languages. This work
shows that the only crucial parameter in the formulation is $\gamma$, which
depicts the resistance to vocabulary growth on a corpus. A method of parameter
estimation by searching an optimal $\gamma$ is proposed, where a ``zeroth
word'' is introduced technically for the calculation. The formulation and
parameters are further discussed with several case studies. | A Crucial Parameter for Rank-Frequency Relation in Natural Languages: $f \propto r^{-\alpha} \cdot (r+\gamma)^{-\beta}$ has been empirically shown
more precise than a na\"ive power law $f\propto r^{-\alpha}$ to model the
rank-frequency ($r$-$f$) relation of words in natural languages. This work
shows that the only crucial parameter in the formulation is $\gamma$, which
depicts the resistance to vocabulary growth on a corpus. A method of parameter
estimation by searching an optimal $\gamma$ is proposed, where a ``zeroth
word'' is introduced technically for the calculation. The formulation and
parameters are further discussed with several case studies. | [
0.0260431711,
0.0387459993,
-0.0416933522,
0.0190576483,
-0.0200888216,
-0.0180693399,
-0.0683046281,
0.0330466218,
-0.0599804819,
0.0017618034,
0.0347306691,
-0.1066666022,
0.046805393,
-0.014009445,
0.0021426184,
-0.0421392657,
0.0260389764,
-0.0322991498,
0.0482235663,
0.0136953751,
0.0154133849,
-0.0319565199,
-0.0114867883,
-0.0039799507,
-0.0036505188,
0.0414792262,
0.0475834496,
-0.0454765074,
0.008002528,
-0.012802545,
-0.0345427059,
0.0683138296,
0.0102747409,
0.0468101613,
0.0000016992,
-0.0609849095,
-0.0011393224,
0.0275118947,
0.0099995835,
-0.0168428086,
0.0837635174,
0.0098143229,
-0.0405405276,
0.0334954821,
0.0056928978,
0.056797836,
0.0355300009,
-0.0344831571,
-0.0525739044,
0.0157774501,
-0.0048276316,
-0.0315155275,
0.0298788715,
-0.0306350403,
0.0002317052,
-0.0183922518,
0.0330532007,
0.0206898302,
0.014940558,
-0.0040244996,
-0.062844716,
0.00507318,
-0.0376004912,
0.0282334425,
0.034939222,
0.0002270653,
-0.0103530884,
-0.0257851239,
0.0279047079,
0.0570620596,
0.0072002891,
0.0076078563,
0.0258546155,
0.0234851781,
-0.0093297781,
0.0303695835,
-0.0408913121,
-0.0152175007,
0.0032047625,
-0.0205684025,
0.0198124573,
0.0067184446,
-0.0063805399,
-0.0119940368,
-0.0331444331,
0.0437793955,
0.0376140736,
-0.0443133861,
0.0196752232,
-0.0877557546,
-0.0783828497,
0.0103078969,
-0.006393143,
0.0153605491,
0.0237994846,
0.0323538743,
0.010495632,
-0.0708062649,
0.0445137098,
-0.1021316424,
0.0012250684,
-0.0446925461,
0.0440651327,
0.0013340908,
0.001457666,
0.0337746777,
0.0253789499,
-0.0674913377,
-0.0298301298,
0.0249700863,
-0.0271617267,
-0.0061657606,
-0.010201361,
-0.0042774053,
-0.0285855867,
-0.025598133,
-0.0660276264,
-0.0126492465,
0.0340851769,
-0.0146293445,
-0.0387831144,
-0.0173509326,
-0.0270909872,
0.0117793996,
-0.0311112702,
0.0270099323,
-0.0016796951,
0.0081156334,
-0.0397946723,
-0.0241669491,
0.0371179692,
-0.0337404609,
0.0454062074,
-0.0065438827,
0.0186595991,
0.0345844664,
0.0031244431,
-0.0140588107,
0.0323249362,
-0.0084347557,
-0.0368925892,
-0.028016733,
-0.0670834258,
-0.0709772408,
-0.016918743,
0.030220069,
0.0027170188,
0.0036817091,
0.0247189105,
0.0277560037,
-0.0527873971,
0.0481287539,
-0.0060539274,
0.0323651582,
0.0499702394,
-0.00409621,
-0.0046855775,
0.0648381934,
0.0371651836,
-0.0422861911,
0.0482338667,
-0.0641885549,
-0.0194936078,
0.0248316489,
-0.0223208815,
0.0240946766,
-0.0018163314,
-0.0574135631,
-0.0106420927,
0.0099802595,
0.0195575692,
0.0531641617,
0.0007147464,
-0.0497079715,
0.0238571465,
0.0622271299,
0.0517082699,
0.0330220759,
-0.0390611552,
0.0097690821,
-0.0011768001,
0.0264230538,
0.0485407263,
-0.020204952,
-0.0365885869,
-0.0087363254,
0.0210520867,
0.035868071,
0.0035256874,
-0.0297515634,
-0.0139368279,
0.0037776127,
0.0479466692,
-0.0827804804,
0.0675464943,
-0.0127504217,
0.0045305509,
-0.0317293555,
0.0485160761,
-0.0302282963,
-0.0009002039,
0.0154112568,
0.0006480091,
0.0028487614,
0.0305050835,
-0.0378098302,
0.0449347831,
0.0358896665,
-0.021133963,
0.05135943,
-0.0123142246,
0.017184021,
-0.000441743,
-0.0134225395,
0.0193326082,
0.0495464057,
-0.0108473888,
0.003434269,
-0.0329492316,
0.0533354804,
0.0250651967,
-0.0647982806,
-0.0501864851,
-0.0025282362,
0.0022951562,
-0.0018825623,
-0.0197510179,
-0.0390757099,
0.0175342094,
0.0009414896,
-0.0160397738,
0.0336126909,
-0.009105348,
-0.0452527665,
0.0110188089,
-0.0094567714,
0.0223988816,
0.0454338342,
0.0223296173,
-0.0101888562,
0.0779175162,
0.0428604521,
0.0306908619,
0.0100974683,
0.0468317196,
-0.0377904326,
0.1015378982,
-0.0184372514,
0.0643000454,
-0.0268994048,
0.0597657114,
-0.0110552022,
0.0510057285,
0.0114357732,
0.0900380835,
0.0269689914,
-0.0330460817,
0.0648240671,
-0.0131116807,
-0.0331278108,
0.0012475256,
0.0009614931,
-0.0143098617,
0.0631068796,
-0.0422402062,
0.0002425849,
-0.0246751327,
-0.0091362018,
-0.0615317859,
0.0072076982,
-0.0091183586,
-0.0371608362,
0.0098629482,
-0.007420118,
0.0138640888,
-0.021097742,
0.0162045024,
0.0089392848,
0.0467663854,
0.02091638,
-0.0012679305,
-0.0777178928,
-0.0589824095,
-0.035117574,
-0.0000474201,
-0.0132408869,
0.0480944104,
-0.0065164892,
-0.0510687158,
0.0669980273,
-0.0971715152,
0.0384008177,
-0.0370562188,
-0.0484587587,
-0.0107723791,
-0.0170799419,
0.0805014744,
-0.0485780798,
0.0701215565,
-0.0316080451,
0.0452620201,
0.010384812,
-0.0178452153,
-0.0600268021,
-0.0505254678,
0.0309706852,
-0.0196590852,
-0.0147222541,
0.0620568134,
0.0234184656,
0.0361860953,
-0.0455014668,
-0.0102497935,
-0.0011607002,
-0.0684472769,
0.017132014,
-0.0211432651,
0.0202465411,
-0.0397977084,
0.0334596448,
0.0030892773,
-0.070455499,
0.004979128,
-0.03529834,
0.0345086493,
-0.0193985589,
-0.0376919433,
-0.0200256351,
-0.0003486306,
0.0502440408,
0.0070925681,
-0.0061521004,
-0.0402241051,
-0.0311554056,
-0.0042643603,
0.0661245286,
-0.0615959354,
0.0179114398,
-0.0403095819,
0.0082979994,
-0.0346865393,
0.0064527369,
0.0057532573,
-0.0771890581,
0.0663807094,
0.0130948415,
0.0585535355,
-0.0447632,
0.0469625145,
0.0160112567,
0.0462062508,
0.0126440031,
0.0035132316,
-0.00539567,
0.0017675603,
0.0652719513,
0.0620687455,
-0.0120916804,
0.0363318622,
-0.0191313829,
0.0249891263,
-0.0056289355,
0.0600200817,
0.0302526671,
0.0026037251,
-0.0143934507,
0.0026726765,
-0.0244156569,
0.0084590055,
0.0607313104,
-0.057200823,
0.0211751256,
0.0350713767,
0.0521568395,
0.0175893605,
0.0030954957,
0.0444448851,
-0.0208402239,
0.0564767756,
0.0106089693,
0.0163688418,
-0.0407885872,
0.0877341852,
0.0006506729,
-0.0078441817,
-0.0208742358,
-0.0374284461,
-0.0306714028,
-0.1265176982,
-0.0013988487,
-0.0255333483,
0.0670455173,
-0.0176030751,
-0.0010763175,
0.0124154231,
0.0391410738,
-0.0433599502,
0.0528354682,
-0.0307562649,
-0.005193532,
0.0645647645,
-0.0742636099,
-0.0146798361,
-0.0026335383,
-0.0630481765,
0.0322084725,
-0.054791458,
0.0563697591,
-0.0893884152,
-0.0563567095,
-0.0693787336,
-0.0158418939,
-0.0178253576,
-0.0146600148,
-0.0131760398,
0.0643737093,
-0.0300716143,
-0.0094497856,
-0.0318464749,
0.01989205,
0.0097176796,
0.0118055651,
0.0178079624,
0.0287040304,
-0.0094835674,
-0.0160611644,
0.0129850889,
-0.0197692402,
0.0509287119,
0.0010900955,
-0.0066195084,
0.0448576324,
-0.0079220962,
0.0414639711,
-0.0024881805,
-0.0408289395,
-0.0245142505,
0.0196029004,
-0.0259688925,
-0.0872378051,
0.0632656887,
-0.0145716919,
0.0822796151,
0.0413257927,
0.0917041972,
0.0003685492,
-0.0050091133,
0.017312469,
-0.0595600158,
0.0413193852,
-0.0123850582,
-0.0626692474,
-0.0414132252,
0.0352232419,
-0.0077573252,
-0.0320558958,
-0.0156338438,
-0.0097262766,
-0.0272419099,
0.0219425298,
0.0147282127,
0.0272140447,
-0.0350399315,
-0.0018007164,
-0.073215574,
-0.0038491571,
0.0172174461,
-0.0309768077,
0.0208876748,
-0.0035936532,
-0.0185573902,
0.0121376915,
0.0043324754,
-0.0265565831,
0.0359594524,
-0.0441172943,
0.0728929564,
-0.025947053,
-0.0292035732,
0.0372597426,
0.0369200706,
-0.0131513383,
-0.0315399468,
-0.0359932818,
-0.0253237914,
-0.0137579637,
-0.0613027252,
0.0303262416,
0.0143958796,
-0.0048991367,
-0.0200842358,
0.0188935399,
-0.0721207112,
-0.0587082095,
-0.0087126922,
-0.0235191956,
-0.005885452,
0.0034408083,
0.0179053936,
0.0027545402,
0.0347920284,
0.0080228299,
0.0154563561,
-0.0067234249,
-0.0201407503,
0.0657897145,
-0.0070961379,
0.0108228829,
-0.0216703173,
-0.0230946746,
-0.0015656918,
0.0292201806,
-0.0098411553,
-0.0158757232,
-0.0156278536,
-0.0337762982,
-0.0069470028,
0.0054850299,
0.0072654095,
-0.0244998019,
0.0386513509,
-0.0194971282,
-0.0214855224,
-0.0275882687,
0.0091651091,
-0.0318698734,
0.032698717,
-0.0050591151,
0.0994673744,
0.0819310173,
0.0531732999,
-0.040301498,
0.0033204746,
-0.0539629757,
0.0252561308,
0.0279515404,
-0.043411158,
0.0007835639,
0.0088864714,
0.0083400486,
-0.072995238,
-0.0522383302,
0.0392214879,
-0.0256045759,
0.0386596732,
-0.0078563644,
0.0019604866,
0.0202190634,
-0.0503231846,
0.0303318817,
-0.0409773588,
0.0031013847,
-0.0623283759,
0.0451423489,
0.0217386521,
-5.443860908e-33,
-0.0127592031,
-0.024040224,
-0.0161318034,
0.0645745099,
0.00017252,
0.0207321737,
0.0089000231,
0.0165376645,
-0.0218669027,
-0.0060034869,
0.0194034893,
-0.0158180296,
-0.0007263484,
-0.0316636041,
0.0140600791,
0.0212152749,
-0.0394689925,
0.0212410204,
0.0237594936,
-0.030617211,
0.0644109175,
0.0364180878,
0.0638559833,
0.0038687454,
-0.0034797138,
0.013487881,
0.0047144592,
0.0240948349,
0.0572479628,
0.0137621099,
0.0113397948,
0.0782024711,
0.0232862905,
-0.0719306916,
-0.005144923,
-0.0081475442,
-0.030531032,
-0.0530299693,
0.0452314876,
-0.0209859163,
0.0448271148,
0.0650334656,
0.020568138,
-0.0319790132,
-0.0368970186,
0.0254288279,
0.0552083515,
-0.0039035929,
-0.0466510989,
-0.0430186465,
-0.0598815009,
0.0360166952,
0.0057804207,
0.0133276694,
0.0283193737,
-0.0368254967,
0.0087815542,
-0.0209639017,
-0.0177958589,
-0.0012644888,
0.0495269634,
0.1093556657,
-0.0253585055,
0.0151354894,
-0.0293849763,
0.0600304976,
0.029397063,
-0.0190106723,
0.0477527082,
0.0019765673,
0.0317566842,
0.0388702787,
0.0122642536,
0.0358758308,
0.0903674513,
-0.0234277938,
-0.0435019545,
0.015173059,
0.0373131707,
0.015775539,
0.0210485198,
-0.0211181492,
-0.0859568715,
-0.0146055082,
-0.0120890392,
-0.0082497541,
-0.0299556125,
-0.0200280193,
0.0263349954,
-0.0282686129,
0.0223520901,
-0.028230451,
0.0340297706,
-0.0254724678,
-0.0586107299,
0.0343309231,
0.0191276222,
0.0223883111,
-0.0239208955,
-0.0111324107,
-0.0061995126,
-0.0246574134,
-0.0097381463,
0.0240675546,
0.0203057658,
-0.0548193268,
-0.0259750728,
0.0095154196,
-0.0349470787,
-0.0344370231,
-0.003108653,
-0.0091918204,
0.0308301412,
0.0196235403,
-0.0035723778,
-0.0203282107,
-0.0135920988,
0.031545911,
0.0416122153,
0.01200369,
-0.0097880773,
0.0131378481,
0.0189024638,
0.0032599417,
-0.0186656881,
-0.0587051846,
-0.0118475044,
0.0553883426,
0.0650214702,
-0.0194493085,
-0.0137919253,
-0.0027785997,
2.704e-7,
0.0134600857,
0.018577639,
0.0255351588,
-0.033946123,
0.0035133206,
-0.0346290804,
-0.0425576121,
0.017581977,
-0.0280898735,
0.0035797642,
-0.0220379792,
-0.0398255736,
0.0126179662,
0.0513955168,
-0.0458939523,
-0.0275420826,
-0.1050669029,
-0.0058344081,
-0.0203269143,
-0.0217131935,
-0.0551185831,
0.0330078974,
-0.0174660105,
-0.013038977,
-0.0310400389,
-0.0339975581,
0.0107761147,
-0.0517473146,
-0.019359218,
0.0054224092,
0.0317379236,
0.0050294497,
0.0229163319,
-0.0002192411,
-0.0267069489,
0.0589646101,
0.0368094631,
-0.0117694084,
-0.0050251009,
0.0274129435,
0.0229972731,
-0.0068011195,
-0.0265563708,
-0.00231585,
0.0107054282,
0.0527697466,
-0.0438449308,
0.010422593,
-0.0300022177,
-0.0029414843,
-0.0005972994,
-0.0121864844,
-0.0245036092,
-0.0104112076,
0.0263520088,
0.0002261659,
-0.0331222787,
-0.0400604382,
0.0180862043,
0.0243892204,
-0.0255163088,
-0.0667842627,
-0.0097190281,
-0.030174505,
0.0140933516,
0.025877418,
0.0284630097,
2.298883767e-34,
0.0363147743,
-0.0135776838,
-0.0029832744,
0.0063437028,
0.0332087725,
0.0470823348,
0.0278720018,
0.031352479,
0.0326372236,
-0.1025796235,
-0.0190369375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00263v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00263v3 | Does DetectGPT Fully Utilize Perturbation? Bridge Selective Perturbation to Fine-tuned Contrastive Learning Detector would be Better | 2024-02-01T01:23:07 | 2024-02-24T13:46:21 | Shengchao Liu, Xiaoming Liu, Yichen Wang, Zehua Cheng, Chengzhengxu Li, Zhaohan Zhang, Yu Lan, Chao Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The burgeoning generative capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
raised growing concerns about abuse, demanding automatic machine-generated text
detectors. DetectGPT, a zero-shot metric-based detector, first introduces
perturbation and shows great performance improvement. However, in DetectGPT,
random perturbation strategy could introduce noise, and logit regression
depends on threshold, harming the generalizability and applicability of
individual or small-batch inputs. Hence, we propose a novel fine-tuned
detector, Pecola, bridging metric-based and fine-tuned detectors by contrastive
learning on selective perturbation. Selective strategy retains important tokens
during perturbation and weights for multi-pair contrastive learning. The
experiments show that Pecola outperforms the state-of-the-art by 1.20% in
accuracy on average on four public datasets. And we further analyze the
effectiveness, robustness, and generalization of the method. | Does DetectGPT Fully Utilize Perturbation? Bridge Selective Perturbation to Fine-tuned Contrastive Learning Detector would be Better: The burgeoning generative capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
raised growing concerns about abuse, demanding automatic machine-generated text
detectors. DetectGPT, a zero-shot metric-based detector, first introduces
perturbation and shows great performance improvement. However, in DetectGPT,
random perturbation strategy could introduce noise, and logit regression
depends on threshold, harming the generalizability and applicability of
individual or small-batch inputs. Hence, we propose a novel fine-tuned
detector, Pecola, bridging metric-based and fine-tuned detectors by contrastive
learning on selective perturbation. Selective strategy retains important tokens
during perturbation and weights for multi-pair contrastive learning. The
experiments show that Pecola outperforms the state-of-the-art by 1.20% in
accuracy on average on four public datasets. And we further analyze the
effectiveness, robustness, and generalization of the method. | [
-0.0254979525,
0.0691265687,
-0.0045914031,
0.0622190759,
-0.0306323916,
0.024358511,
-0.0186349954,
0.0665549189,
0.0271856375,
-0.0218270309,
-0.0108986609,
-0.04495937,
-0.0382575989,
0.0236711167,
0.0466482006,
-0.0330421627,
0.0551763996,
0.002668631,
-0.0029464739,
0.0233715437,
0.0144215822,
0.0290936474,
-0.0040087439,
0.0267741531,
-0.0153868413,
-0.0347446278,
-0.0012428965,
0.0436140634,
0.0503619052,
-0.0553963408,
0.0278619379,
0.0834267288,
0.0058690333,
0.1031290814,
0.000002009,
-0.0336414166,
-0.0235143248,
0.0046268054,
-0.000216954,
0.0062938938,
0.0558538362,
-0.0386366807,
-0.029572947,
0.0401568599,
-0.0210449323,
-0.0575604178,
0.0537072904,
0.0505371876,
-0.0247010589,
0.1079067811,
-0.0335711651,
-0.0368010886,
0.0352639146,
-0.0365784988,
0.0012231299,
-0.0271964464,
0.0370371006,
-0.0304569304,
-0.022058798,
0.0337261558,
-0.0219174717,
0.0010226171,
-0.0020747061,
0.0038079,
-0.0242699161,
0.0485706963,
-0.0112463878,
-0.0109252622,
-0.0320359915,
0.0519443899,
-0.0592330433,
-0.0435140021,
0.0238656141,
-0.0330428816,
0.0013500487,
-0.0562281534,
-0.0031258352,
-0.0438679345,
-0.0018236798,
0.062371619,
0.010435679,
-0.0462334752,
0.0299637802,
0.0198443085,
-0.0185608286,
-0.0015277662,
0.033181157,
-0.0394895487,
-0.0361250564,
0.0382613651,
-0.0670078993,
-0.0488878265,
0.0067327549,
-0.0131508727,
-0.0135038216,
-0.038068179,
-0.0565428659,
-0.0635430217,
-0.0064074802,
0.0130719822,
0.0146094626,
0.0225030128,
-0.0333572626,
0.0507582165,
-0.0458280556,
0.0499752685,
-0.066765815,
0.0276951473,
-0.0047390279,
0.0176284667,
-0.0075446814,
0.0030351928,
-0.0325928777,
-0.0103490483,
-0.0017222906,
-0.0110057965,
-0.0052208691,
0.0296756122,
0.0382338166,
-0.0319246687,
0.0151208872,
-0.0366547517,
-0.0422930196,
-0.0042522452,
0.0490056463,
0.045626536,
-0.0134981582,
0.0082509667,
-0.0103145428,
-0.0323585235,
-0.0648567826,
0.0594878383,
0.0415774509,
-0.0045002992,
0.0384768657,
0.0472639985,
-0.0145180756,
-0.0876639262,
-0.0516182445,
-0.0085735656,
-0.0329102203,
-0.054585766,
-0.0256508794,
-0.0528002046,
-0.0306688808,
-0.0174826514,
0.0181747079,
-0.0383797772,
-0.0094809355,
0.0070952163,
-0.0297846161,
0.0748973861,
-0.035767857,
-0.0219597965,
-0.0375875123,
-0.0118138855,
-0.0454115905,
0.1222991273,
0.0198003594,
0.0223729834,
0.0205931403,
0.023427384,
-0.0179763678,
0.0602611676,
0.0236207582,
0.0491618849,
-0.0048973565,
-0.0363672562,
0.0100094723,
-0.0270101912,
0.080560185,
0.0425390676,
-0.0146225486,
-0.0019138355,
0.0579859689,
0.0578723215,
0.0479702391,
0.036320921,
0.0379771367,
0.0335714594,
-0.0763445944,
0.0514237545,
0.0101320026,
-0.0204401482,
-0.0379341245,
-0.0206921175,
0.0581289455,
0.0324062854,
-0.0312974676,
0.0143206725,
-0.0177290533,
-0.0182598159,
-0.0278864894,
-0.0280604921,
0.0951535702,
0.0192234293,
-0.0438126475,
0.0026814542,
0.0198102985,
-0.023577258,
0.0008161798,
-0.0784161314,
0.0472931527,
0.0245770328,
0.046748329,
-0.0244003516,
0.0457269549,
-0.015250477,
-0.0092907827,
0.0351006463,
0.0105637889,
0.0417624786,
0.0457446724,
-0.0365754887,
-0.0150767164,
0.0061140661,
0.0352947898,
0.0268116612,
0.0483663119,
0.0440926179,
0.0128365522,
-0.0201826375,
0.0277997851,
0.045023486,
0.0215387493,
-0.0335714482,
0.0378965065,
-0.0156677738,
0.030755775,
0.0013434642,
-0.0188316312,
-0.0125439735,
-0.0076743411,
-0.0330389813,
0.0086621456,
-0.0059956121,
0.005528809,
-0.0882876068,
0.0266337767,
-0.0133292479,
-0.0100706499,
0.0315638334,
-0.0428222977,
-0.0118794395,
0.0240113698,
-0.0237170141,
0.0340889581,
-0.0578137934,
0.0056395121,
-0.0210185144,
0.0714581013,
0.0009452858,
0.066118516,
0.0041992529,
-0.0081824781,
-0.0109056327,
0.0525291339,
0.0502391905,
-0.0350768566,
-0.0399625637,
-0.0314438231,
0.0079491232,
0.0036307455,
0.0024363904,
0.0599919558,
-0.0137892319,
-0.0387993678,
-0.0371127091,
0.008490419,
-0.0337949619,
0.011381031,
0.0540059395,
0.0138844633,
-0.0208327305,
-0.0024890353,
-0.0051767612,
-0.023164181,
0.0285474062,
0.0095389932,
0.0173145402,
-0.026547512,
0.0064975694,
-0.0169906002,
-0.0058977073,
-0.0227142964,
0.0161841623,
0.0148261152,
-0.0295953471,
-0.0601020344,
0.0601297878,
0.0298743229,
0.0401564203,
0.0256458931,
-0.0396972783,
0.0079278424,
-0.035286773,
0.055210039,
0.0668841153,
-0.0119870966,
-0.0092036929,
-0.0068227877,
0.0157235321,
-0.0112786498,
-0.0044048056,
-0.0138027258,
0.0042196224,
-0.0172407553,
-0.0074121123,
-0.0100415675,
0.0598792061,
-0.000786795,
-0.0161303822,
-0.0614806898,
0.008210849,
-0.013728654,
-0.019929681,
0.0187349897,
0.0211132318,
-0.037564341,
0.0146112526,
-0.0245733876,
-0.0370656773,
0.067500025,
-0.02183084,
-0.0252235606,
-0.0467244945,
-0.0085422918,
-0.0147898626,
-0.0029340831,
0.014327812,
0.0106539708,
0.0079404386,
-0.0255129561,
-0.0411659665,
-0.0137375845,
0.0130636841,
-0.0205756556,
0.0036731325,
-0.0076573757,
0.0355157666,
-0.0244362894,
-0.0416579358,
-0.0225315075,
-0.034490563,
-0.0140758688,
-0.0196367055,
0.0273955092,
-0.0480641164,
-0.0091333073,
0.0576597266,
-0.0181538779,
0.0713205338,
-0.0158580951,
-0.0092216246,
-0.0398445427,
0.0888518244,
0.0264580306,
-0.0683523118,
0.0385293104,
-0.0353567079,
0.0159017835,
0.066107057,
0.0230073985,
0.0065680756,
-0.037174698,
0.0016661069,
0.0093324622,
0.0388014913,
-0.0072888932,
-0.0130858403,
0.0392877534,
-0.0396446511,
-0.0496029072,
0.0787448809,
-0.0052875732,
-0.0957096517,
-0.0217895433,
0.0318397433,
0.0410109088,
0.0066142026,
-0.0138397301,
-0.0929030105,
-0.0366405621,
0.0161979403,
0.0165241677,
-0.0278135277,
0.0036564483,
-0.0198709778,
-0.0708613023,
0.0476807654,
0.0250738356,
-0.0053787809,
-0.0140709737,
-0.0171098132,
0.0392203666,
-0.0204342976,
0.0019449914,
-0.0069268434,
0.0163967106,
-0.0098798508,
-0.0054184389,
0.0183712412,
-0.0799563751,
-0.0227325764,
-0.0478938483,
-0.0100054201,
0.0726970509,
0.0035039156,
-0.0098201204,
-0.0417035148,
0.0327523053,
-0.0246277228,
-0.032605119,
-0.0220305044,
0.062776275,
-0.0050616311,
-0.0361868925,
-0.010989828,
0.0175018348,
-0.0155471293,
-0.0227333568,
-0.0039266599,
0.0361354351,
0.0229747817,
-0.0201400369,
-0.0175220445,
-0.0140260225,
0.0028555549,
0.0531712212,
0.0322125219,
-0.0388469286,
-0.0389817357,
-0.0025265589,
0.0193954054,
-0.0668859705,
-0.0097358916,
-0.0447640084,
0.0159239881,
-0.0643262044,
-0.0409520231,
0.0086726779,
-0.0069684987,
0.038297113,
-0.0222478062,
0.0138584636,
-0.0685344934,
0.0084384391,
-0.0189953595,
0.0209252797,
-0.043733228,
-0.0111030433,
-0.0925659761,
-0.0066344314,
0.0353504047,
0.0164329037,
-0.0261962451,
0.0173193756,
-0.1282272786,
-0.0715309456,
-0.0422211438,
0.0017219919,
0.0146387899,
0.0056768646,
-0.0549213365,
-0.0272236615,
0.0512607247,
0.0397897437,
0.002171101,
0.0538386106,
0.0181753971,
-0.0711440668,
-0.0151014384,
0.0272293743,
-0.0112352809,
0.0239112154,
0.0146729387,
0.011584186,
-0.0454821177,
-0.0002164644,
0.0070998617,
-0.0020909226,
0.0975893438,
-0.0300278347,
0.0434870422,
-0.0507593006,
-0.018727826,
0.0118910577,
0.0209563281,
-0.04858106,
0.0465243272,
0.0425961539,
-0.0088346973,
-0.0457782559,
0.0000684149,
-0.0276262015,
0.0403278247,
-0.0582339279,
-0.0008755667,
-0.0051408638,
0.0179307107,
0.035247013,
-0.0093713049,
0.007753755,
0.0225499272,
0.0090468088,
0.020961754,
-0.0253928304,
0.0392124392,
0.0426799059,
-0.011470709,
-0.007640691,
0.0383731909,
-0.0382388271,
0.0054677352,
-0.0691444203,
0.0332845412,
0.0910678804,
0.0224483833,
0.0664061978,
-0.0225464404,
-0.0328103378,
-0.0263825674,
0.0118736476,
-0.005323159,
-0.0085430788,
-0.0052789138,
-0.0011014735,
-0.0046477914,
0.0365037061,
0.0782871619,
-0.0388540961,
0.0351641551,
0.0097960709,
-0.0187326223,
-0.0226091892,
0.0049375859,
0.0004837607,
0.0046945722,
0.0083665028,
0.0518531837,
-0.0034725708,
-0.0637373403,
0.0022669018,
-0.01529916,
-0.0141478945,
0.0168162584,
0.0014988281,
0.0155564798,
-0.0182260554,
-0.0157831255,
-0.0210484751,
-0.0242561959,
0.0150535209,
-0.0128385937,
-0.0019009141,
-6.662577084e-33,
-0.0300137289,
-0.020272065,
-0.053968437,
-0.0043876851,
-0.0007580377,
0.0028475448,
-0.0058353068,
-0.0169107635,
-0.0071243402,
-0.0078975186,
-0.0074444916,
0.0516311787,
0.0096197911,
0.0168532562,
-0.0165710058,
-0.0435179248,
0.0510351695,
-0.016616419,
-0.0187698454,
0.0368803628,
0.0113732964,
0.0153591344,
0.0566133261,
-0.0635532215,
-0.0171062741,
0.0235752575,
-0.0458395891,
-0.0169062745,
-0.0194410365,
0.0634738132,
-0.0209304318,
0.0166182183,
0.0169433914,
0.0123131163,
-0.0199458562,
0.0388710164,
-0.0318771787,
-0.0071258559,
-0.022574598,
-0.0026093205,
0.0009950455,
-0.0422921777,
0.0113801593,
-0.0085109575,
-0.0065506259,
-0.0095855026,
0.0166183431,
-0.0355552845,
0.0075730556,
-0.0180073027,
-0.0052296366,
0.0538419448,
0.0029588239,
0.0057452689,
0.0332751796,
0.0311324019,
0.0127348304,
0.0574553758,
-0.0246404745,
0.0073445034,
0.0484752022,
0.0578024797,
-0.0089088483,
0.0560133494,
0.0225437898,
0.0180908535,
0.0358469971,
-0.0480436943,
0.0533114225,
-0.0621876568,
0.0362905376,
-0.0378232226,
0.0500665903,
0.0661084056,
0.0511937402,
-0.0042768312,
-0.0787269026,
-0.0129954005,
0.0055918959,
-0.0026150092,
0.0473327748,
0.0338332392,
-0.0549246855,
-0.0109992409,
0.007790565,
-0.1211025938,
-0.0510667935,
-0.0263844579,
0.0246069171,
0.0496838801,
-0.0349573977,
-0.018185148,
0.0273100324,
-0.0355216973,
-0.0003427637,
-0.0163986497,
-0.0393530689,
0.0002708727,
0.0135288881,
0.0254571382,
-0.0314413421,
-0.0210618451,
0.0429570191,
0.0268557109,
0.0073391399,
-0.0079366388,
0.0348481461,
0.0242378786,
-0.0719529241,
0.0059523354,
-0.0212698039,
0.0235419925,
-0.008553586,
0.0156156784,
0.0175824948,
-0.0228563398,
0.0225772224,
0.0903839171,
0.0731393918,
0.0135048535,
-0.0270892829,
0.0254331362,
-0.0079628155,
0.0524203815,
-0.0508815534,
0.0148536991,
0.0058940519,
0.0141696976,
0.0649326667,
-0.0567228906,
-0.0182651505,
0.0138605721,
2.696e-7,
0.0418104529,
0.0147203039,
0.0201255716,
0.0034183492,
0.0069964151,
0.0292484146,
-0.0249746758,
0.0193759501,
0.0017783615,
0.05518879,
0.0214877985,
0.0100341793,
0.0381190404,
0.0037785931,
-0.0877802223,
0.0720730573,
-0.0631554797,
0.0187818762,
-0.0600940734,
-0.0146794217,
0.0502782688,
0.0868665799,
0.0408962443,
0.0053619184,
0.0352044329,
-0.0787802637,
0.057083156,
-0.003807972,
0.0420675799,
-0.0178638678,
0.0373156741,
0.0519013256,
-0.0016543835,
0.0037021085,
-0.0010485289,
0.0494411178,
-0.0327879563,
0.0486557074,
-0.0006286983,
-0.0364219546,
0.0253498219,
0.0054892232,
0.005240093,
-0.0671061203,
0.0822574496,
-0.0352761857,
0.0041447203,
-0.0307493284,
-0.019474782,
-0.0623810962,
0.0249025803,
-0.0491875336,
-0.063857682,
0.0028529305,
0.0291189682,
0.0073538013,
-0.0297351498,
-0.0784252286,
0.0088920603,
0.0178323034,
-0.040199317,
-0.0360981487,
-0.0245089028,
0.011840241,
0.0213459488,
-0.017542325,
-0.0002920791,
2.749237234e-34,
0.0375380665,
-0.0365059152,
-0.0132025545,
0.0265328865,
0.0207637101,
-0.0013522175,
-0.0073644877,
-0.0356247276,
0.0124262152,
-0.0593653321,
0.0037341001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00253v2 | A Survey on Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-01T00:33:21 | 2024-05-06T01:10:01 | Hanchao Liu, Wenyuan Xue, Yifei Chen, Dapeng Chen, Xiutian Zhao, Ke Wang, Liping Hou, Rongjun Li, Wei Peng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent development of Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) has attracted
growing attention within the AI landscape for its practical implementation
potential. However, ``hallucination'', or more specifically, the misalignment
between factual visual content and corresponding textual generation, poses a
significant challenge of utilizing LVLMs. In this comprehensive survey, we
dissect LVLM-related hallucinations in an attempt to establish an overview and
facilitate future mitigation. Our scrutiny starts with a clarification of the
concept of hallucinations in LVLMs, presenting a variety of hallucination
symptoms and highlighting the unique challenges inherent in LVLM
hallucinations. Subsequently, we outline the benchmarks and methodologies
tailored specifically for evaluating hallucinations unique to LVLMs.
Additionally, we delve into an investigation of the root causes of these
hallucinations, encompassing insights from the training data and model
components. We also critically review existing methods for mitigating
hallucinations. The open questions and future directions pertaining to
hallucinations within LVLMs are discussed to conclude this survey. | A Survey on Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models: Recent development of Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) has attracted
growing attention within the AI landscape for its practical implementation
potential. However, ``hallucination'', or more specifically, the misalignment
between factual visual content and corresponding textual generation, poses a
significant challenge of utilizing LVLMs. In this comprehensive survey, we
dissect LVLM-related hallucinations in an attempt to establish an overview and
facilitate future mitigation. Our scrutiny starts with a clarification of the
concept of hallucinations in LVLMs, presenting a variety of hallucination
symptoms and highlighting the unique challenges inherent in LVLM
hallucinations. Subsequently, we outline the benchmarks and methodologies
tailored specifically for evaluating hallucinations unique to LVLMs.
Additionally, we delve into an investigation of the root causes of these
hallucinations, encompassing insights from the training data and model
components. We also critically review existing methods for mitigating
hallucinations. The open questions and future directions pertaining to
hallucinations within LVLMs are discussed to conclude this survey. | [
-0.0005934864,
0.0572373867,
-0.0026973865,
0.0502115414,
-0.0318129957,
0.0401045643,
-0.0159082171,
0.015554755,
0.0054870197,
-0.0456378236,
-0.0115897646,
-0.0684441626,
0.0322973691,
0.0014267974,
0.0138768675,
-0.0776181743,
0.01785505,
-0.0601168387,
-0.0472712517,
-0.0015596629,
0.0043843677,
-0.0049189753,
0.016300125,
0.0328524821,
-0.0400784537,
-0.0667571276,
-0.0036366298,
0.0315875746,
0.022961719,
0.0112626906,
-0.0488252938,
0.0359976031,
0.0093002385,
0.0385759957,
0.0000020588,
-0.0345444307,
0.0170925427,
0.0001047846,
0.0176310316,
0.0220405255,
0.014752009,
-0.0466249026,
0.0058593024,
-0.0029516588,
-0.0211577956,
-0.0139579298,
0.0524684153,
0.0758100897,
0.0446568206,
0.0543876253,
-0.0077974834,
-0.0309830178,
0.0049847243,
0.0137549955,
0.0463061593,
0.0099641727,
0.0530827194,
0.0394280069,
-0.0252413005,
-0.0555422306,
-0.0395177267,
0.0140449023,
0.0398266204,
-0.0003983326,
0.0042514158,
0.0554033741,
-0.0640501902,
-0.0302017406,
-0.0076225605,
0.0462921783,
-0.0676653832,
-0.0375786424,
0.021068858,
0.0044665621,
0.0032888406,
-0.0319448598,
-0.0180434994,
0.0645175204,
-0.0035995378,
0.0107280239,
0.0102304183,
0.0042164302,
0.0330014154,
-0.008881581,
-0.0532220267,
0.0123207467,
0.0145903844,
-0.0171588771,
-0.0009271294,
0.0331532881,
-0.0255494267,
-0.0725380555,
-0.0006484437,
0.0157228019,
-0.0435059108,
-0.0186058227,
-0.0759381875,
0.0087532531,
-0.0008830628,
-0.0734000131,
0.0495975837,
-0.0162642542,
-0.0838329643,
0.0382824764,
-0.0441730134,
0.0765271261,
-0.0279548466,
0.0506698117,
-0.0183604397,
0.0126381731,
-0.0061562876,
0.0088313101,
-0.0409144722,
-0.0132197253,
-0.0320768021,
-0.058124382,
-0.0162647367,
0.0046207472,
-0.051224865,
0.0336496606,
-0.03600429,
0.0357473753,
0.0087853381,
-0.0417390987,
0.0151312919,
0.0059622126,
0.0151576037,
-0.0151658328,
0.0089763757,
-0.0800380781,
-0.0102134636,
0.0643036887,
-0.0346446075,
0.0078129396,
-0.0281816404,
0.0558690876,
0.0079824235,
0.003938091,
-0.0437344648,
-0.0191452876,
-0.045335222,
-0.0639773458,
0.0200339835,
-0.06101989,
0.0086315386,
-0.0130861513,
0.0030218342,
-0.0084961271,
0.0384883396,
0.007665976,
-0.0156216612,
0.0717983544,
-0.0414884128,
0.0093018143,
0.0098944437,
0.0265990105,
0.0137724085,
0.0675424859,
0.0341087319,
0.0607724823,
-0.0091292849,
-0.0085767126,
0.0630839989,
0.0178511441,
-0.0197726432,
0.013332746,
-0.0900844708,
-0.0155958952,
0.0030450993,
0.0334146656,
0.0330194384,
0.0925323889,
-0.0317258798,
-0.0272742007,
0.0788071454,
0.0078233993,
0.0055721337,
-0.0160391014,
0.0464068241,
-0.0066744792,
-0.0073831445,
0.0550828278,
-0.062442977,
0.0458876193,
-0.0102411788,
0.0139399422,
0.0028719078,
0.0236058906,
-0.0291967932,
-0.0522516705,
-0.028420059,
-0.0127825383,
-0.0239381362,
0.0147036947,
0.0130806295,
0.0039071487,
-0.0443127789,
-0.0118654612,
0.0068502272,
-0.0130524468,
0.0211962741,
-0.0302118398,
-0.0023279681,
0.0978310779,
0.042196434,
0.0119596887,
-0.0152894547,
-0.0233628321,
0.0338623896,
0.0694236234,
0.0117255962,
-0.0058428668,
0.0104940673,
-0.0625672564,
-0.0062417802,
0.0115365973,
0.0275420249,
-0.0027920108,
-0.0503554679,
-0.0116901472,
0.0086250473,
-0.0182309505,
-0.060302563,
0.0477781408,
-0.0195363536,
-0.0019329222,
-0.0288345721,
-0.0054121511,
-0.0033187896,
-0.0244956687,
-0.0258394461,
0.0261252839,
0.0001441028,
-0.0533091575,
-0.0282455068,
0.0304999389,
-0.0462848656,
0.0044957092,
0.0216200035,
-0.0361722261,
0.0117882993,
0.000305436,
-0.0075316466,
-0.0279288068,
-0.005576503,
-0.0482090004,
0.0079197623,
-0.0334250294,
0.0475190431,
0.0138659598,
0.0537424535,
-0.0244457163,
0.073620066,
-0.0426368155,
-0.0158926863,
0.0461224951,
0.0177742541,
-0.0050666933,
-0.0107783098,
-0.0045609553,
0.0164139755,
0.0100452285,
0.0180791803,
-0.0128503349,
-0.0333072729,
-0.0579559542,
-0.0118265292,
-0.0657561347,
-0.0234281421,
-0.0425633378,
-0.0449791662,
0.021646101,
-0.0439027287,
-0.0161356907,
-0.0125103071,
-0.0193074197,
0.0344357118,
0.0233716033,
0.0272312909,
0.0125287222,
-0.0096636834,
-0.0157794263,
-0.0034807201,
0.0148195419,
0.0069474927,
0.0555061735,
0.0056370031,
-0.0545170791,
-0.097238563,
0.0551725477,
-0.037129689,
0.0289313383,
-0.0130393533,
0.0183800645,
-0.0075172288,
-0.0064006052,
0.0698587894,
0.093656905,
0.021131942,
0.0432365835,
0.079426758,
-0.0212832708,
-0.0144269988,
-0.0318771191,
0.009676245,
-0.0043970807,
-0.0186187662,
-0.0414383486,
-0.0004197574,
0.0261616558,
0.0013535847,
0.0253205728,
-0.0767899901,
0.0424284637,
-0.0430047661,
-0.0836365297,
0.0015882787,
-0.0175208822,
-0.0111759501,
0.0448261574,
-0.0265897904,
-0.0673851818,
0.0321405232,
-0.0273990668,
0.0084350044,
0.0162950847,
0.0220269095,
-0.0024354621,
0.0457995757,
0.0433723889,
0.0328135788,
-0.0019168869,
0.002619572,
-0.0570205078,
0.0039461311,
-0.0556442291,
-0.0307331812,
0.0613014027,
-0.0367499664,
-0.0123972241,
-0.0097870966,
-0.0305727925,
-0.0668552518,
-0.0099227261,
0.0024133183,
-0.022963142,
-0.0517829508,
0.0023263092,
-0.0442346632,
0.0275016464,
-0.0124495178,
-0.016378738,
-0.0247844998,
-0.0293577146,
-0.0065595075,
0.017665036,
0.0990242809,
-0.0114116995,
0.0652054921,
-0.072683759,
0.0234075505,
0.0831548572,
0.0292072836,
0.0667444989,
-0.0496274196,
-0.0111461952,
0.0160904191,
0.0229623392,
-0.0216579288,
0.0242058076,
0.0211275481,
-0.0727733374,
-0.0290226676,
0.0879528001,
0.0288715269,
-0.0502227955,
0.0122179035,
-0.0332411863,
0.0738515034,
0.0047534183,
-0.0040290039,
-0.0660364032,
0.0022963292,
-0.0247246437,
-0.0126864258,
-0.0064229267,
-0.0022212961,
-0.011388652,
-0.0638548359,
0.0754171386,
0.0416714512,
0.00305757,
-0.0476871133,
0.0431886539,
0.0041276398,
0.0164712816,
0.0326664522,
-0.0169843547,
0.0015103251,
-0.013472463,
0.030113304,
-0.0085295374,
-0.0041538607,
0.004935998,
-0.0355688855,
0.0426442623,
0.0818846077,
0.0105600869,
0.0012223454,
-0.0842472389,
0.0131363412,
-0.0100021623,
0.0126463072,
0.0317308344,
0.0518761873,
-0.0027641405,
-0.012867501,
0.0249175727,
0.0102135679,
-0.0332525484,
-0.0271446649,
0.0084124822,
0.0215602908,
-0.055918254,
-0.0683590546,
-0.0296233073,
0.0448531322,
-0.006544671,
0.0576975159,
0.0388921723,
-0.0417200774,
-0.070529744,
-0.0043942686,
0.0425472334,
-0.0486435108,
-0.0393288508,
0.045054432,
0.0738661885,
-0.0309289973,
-0.0749196708,
-0.0437906645,
0.0026619667,
0.0423516817,
-0.0065749139,
0.0086201532,
-0.0232562963,
-0.0374164097,
-0.018806804,
0.0426506028,
-0.0294843465,
0.0205573142,
-0.017915329,
0.0165622607,
0.0068355948,
-0.0397254601,
0.0240471791,
0.0328400768,
-0.1170904413,
-0.0509460345,
0.0305725411,
0.0448774025,
0.0244407058,
0.07937067,
0.0069582993,
-0.0405626968,
0.0454273596,
0.0463375598,
0.0690289363,
0.0535993055,
-0.0154692298,
-0.0111702625,
0.0026357677,
0.0342001356,
-0.0075923116,
-0.0039148987,
0.0332910642,
0.0159607232,
-0.0119729117,
0.0185920727,
0.0320492126,
-0.0339251123,
0.0099522313,
-0.0327219926,
0.0119866617,
-0.0130638741,
-0.0155990962,
-0.0230170824,
-0.0312907547,
-0.0468747057,
-0.0149800451,
0.0356065109,
0.0208345875,
0.0181602258,
-0.0044554416,
-0.0121956896,
-0.0212142132,
-0.0622262657,
-0.0569297783,
0.0138035351,
-0.0311311409,
0.044300992,
0.0078220405,
-0.0167207606,
0.0289359055,
-0.0186910313,
0.0300587714,
0.0329633951,
0.0732668862,
0.0213114191,
-0.0172881708,
-0.0156461168,
0.0291212518,
-0.0258472823,
-0.095904775,
-0.0275199991,
0.0513331518,
0.0571587346,
-0.0021383727,
0.072935313,
-0.0464967676,
0.020706553,
-0.0387084708,
0.0163365267,
0.0548876598,
-0.0501039959,
-0.0124992523,
0.0154403718,
-0.0422758423,
-0.0149203651,
0.0577218756,
0.0130415009,
0.0241506286,
0.0088900477,
-0.0019108687,
-0.0150014302,
-0.0597509667,
-0.0110412044,
-0.0288053844,
-0.0269157346,
-0.0213782042,
-0.0540286638,
-0.0411956348,
0.0091724824,
0.0213055275,
0.0329693146,
0.0067117824,
0.0361590236,
0.0627103746,
-0.0281691402,
-0.0048410497,
-0.0059454264,
-0.037348222,
0.0320553146,
-0.0184916873,
0.004841526,
-5.946702494e-33,
-0.016177116,
-0.0200663395,
0.0497158691,
-0.0381572917,
-0.0295991432,
0.0029080054,
-0.0085912412,
0.0132923936,
0.0186119415,
0.027215343,
0.0409071445,
0.0228714738,
0.0182667729,
0.0325074419,
0.0013843367,
-0.0184036344,
0.0508543551,
0.0081420271,
-0.0200040657,
0.0163713433,
0.0119654397,
0.0004753002,
0.0010255516,
-0.0801346749,
-0.0085623674,
-0.0108818579,
-0.0353743136,
-0.0114350943,
-0.0096755074,
0.0536974594,
-0.0467279889,
0.0232985672,
0.0230025947,
0.0219253283,
-0.0566196255,
0.0067700134,
0.0210012514,
0.0061926125,
-0.0046880865,
0.0543583445,
-0.0890860036,
0.0001223907,
0.048326008,
-0.0124578746,
-0.0046942886,
-0.0326325037,
0.0454946794,
-0.0532413423,
-0.0413884521,
0.0314008482,
-0.0709533766,
-0.01419413,
0.0151824728,
-0.0203969646,
0.0451605208,
0.0330471173,
-0.0134629095,
0.0166297629,
-0.0623416565,
0.0017241132,
0.0016584853,
-0.0049349191,
0.0859190375,
0.0536334477,
0.0106359962,
0.0728538111,
0.0991949961,
-0.0106937364,
-0.0530718863,
-0.0215335619,
0.0089228339,
0.0472563431,
0.0312732682,
0.0087810252,
0.0335956998,
0.0065862257,
-0.0131240338,
-0.0137174884,
-0.0939313099,
0.0219818894,
0.0804944038,
-0.005573127,
-0.0289229471,
-0.0283644237,
-0.0043250998,
0.0006183587,
-0.0335497297,
0.0043203863,
0.0483086146,
0.0215798896,
-0.0083120409,
0.0003544926,
0.0448405333,
-0.0382852629,
0.0218034219,
-0.0022621129,
-0.0434406064,
0.0440881513,
0.0068719555,
0.0238488317,
0.0079213222,
-0.0251575317,
0.0559500828,
0.007847731,
0.014731383,
0.0225356091,
0.0279410481,
-0.0054572592,
-0.0344945602,
0.0058496287,
-0.0450002886,
0.0187893528,
0.0142236538,
0.0376707576,
0.0512475222,
-0.0185176823,
-0.0348291099,
0.0053472631,
0.0172839481,
-0.0011943057,
0.0233152229,
0.0190696046,
-0.0319085866,
0.0031947554,
-0.0171314795,
0.0113794366,
-0.0553118922,
-0.0325914845,
0.0497912839,
-0.0622027144,
-0.0160938874,
-0.0116436584,
2.603e-7,
-0.0211217199,
0.0425844714,
0.0239056274,
0.0097408835,
0.0148450555,
0.0218149927,
0.019298749,
0.028683519,
0.0100605479,
-0.0374215655,
-0.0011859589,
0.0349721536,
0.054502219,
0.0094602155,
-0.0239368808,
0.0155786648,
-0.0248472877,
0.0117891151,
-0.0673289895,
-0.0349503011,
0.044330541,
0.0372681394,
-0.0305034388,
-0.0403378047,
0.0703138635,
-0.0408676192,
0.088477619,
-0.0113410857,
-0.0068653766,
0.0160484165,
0.0181556344,
0.0324283354,
-0.0009193828,
0.0507575534,
0.0031683219,
-0.0504305363,
0.0381813347,
0.0157066323,
-0.031313125,
-0.0195406601,
-0.0302479882,
0.0307595357,
0.0122100646,
-0.0706212744,
0.0638711005,
-0.0328237489,
-0.0103923297,
-0.0200766716,
-0.0301402602,
-0.0010386142,
0.0581582598,
-0.0118716685,
-0.0103845783,
0.0106358752,
0.0309124216,
0.0477694683,
-0.0305552315,
-0.0527220927,
0.0010879511,
-0.0237497631,
-0.0196577013,
-0.0020586937,
-0.0385999754,
0.0244795494,
0.0186810382,
-0.0368160009,
-0.0428133346,
2.653829566e-34,
0.0051370468,
-0.0078003816,
0.0352153964,
-0.0053434973,
-0.0072047892,
-0.0010889492,
0.0079942318,
0.0168780852,
-0.0292876605,
-0.03445559,
-0.0187126528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00251v1 | Efficient Non-Parametric Uncertainty Quantification for Black-Box Large Language Models and Decision Planning | 2024-02-01T00:23:31 | 2024-02-01T00:23:31 | Yao-Hung Hubert Tsai, Walter Talbott, Jian Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Step-by-step decision planning with large language models (LLMs) is gaining
attention in AI agent development. This paper focuses on decision planning with
uncertainty estimation to address the hallucination problem in language models.
Existing approaches are either white-box or computationally demanding, limiting
use of black-box proprietary LLMs within budgets. The paper's first
contribution is a non-parametric uncertainty quantification method for LLMs,
efficiently estimating point-wise dependencies between input-decision on the
fly with a single inference, without access to token logits. This estimator
informs the statistical interpretation of decision trustworthiness. The second
contribution outlines a systematic design for a decision-making agent,
generating actions like ``turn on the bathroom light'' based on user prompts
such as ``take a bath''. Users will be asked to provide preferences when more
than one action has high estimated point-wise dependencies. In conclusion, our
uncertainty estimation and decision-making agent design offer a cost-efficient
approach for AI agent development. | Efficient Non-Parametric Uncertainty Quantification for Black-Box Large Language Models and Decision Planning: Step-by-step decision planning with large language models (LLMs) is gaining
attention in AI agent development. This paper focuses on decision planning with
uncertainty estimation to address the hallucination problem in language models.
Existing approaches are either white-box or computationally demanding, limiting
use of black-box proprietary LLMs within budgets. The paper's first
contribution is a non-parametric uncertainty quantification method for LLMs,
efficiently estimating point-wise dependencies between input-decision on the
fly with a single inference, without access to token logits. This estimator
informs the statistical interpretation of decision trustworthiness. The second
contribution outlines a systematic design for a decision-making agent,
generating actions like ``turn on the bathroom light'' based on user prompts
such as ``take a bath''. Users will be asked to provide preferences when more
than one action has high estimated point-wise dependencies. In conclusion, our
uncertainty estimation and decision-making agent design offer a cost-efficient
approach for AI agent development. | [
0.0071106474,
0.071249567,
-0.0014704629,
0.0095677963,
-0.0796884373,
-0.0048735198,
-0.0111824656,
-0.0170369558,
0.041885376,
-0.033246439,
0.0030444162,
-0.061361853,
-0.017569894,
0.021375319,
-0.0031711669,
-0.0176341292,
0.0167630482,
-0.0811564773,
0.0133560374,
-0.0440564118,
-0.0343745686,
-0.0358485542,
-0.0072717955,
0.0417617299,
-0.016168613,
-0.0299884714,
-0.0241717827,
0.0021275745,
0.0173609387,
-0.0203824267,
-0.0227686241,
0.0614708327,
0.0067249984,
0.0409883745,
0.0000024703,
-0.0643999055,
-0.0439338982,
-0.0179135576,
-0.0629211292,
-0.0280548669,
-0.0007068857,
0.0804984793,
-0.008220843,
0.0098766489,
-0.0103581985,
0.0564892143,
0.0399832651,
0.0301096309,
0.0233238768,
0.0095052309,
-0.0042824834,
-0.0108140539,
0.0043452564,
0.0037785941,
0.0335820913,
-0.0462978818,
0.0234275777,
-0.0479864813,
0.0079259947,
-0.0376051664,
-0.0172450151,
0.0196396392,
0.0230274852,
-0.0171122495,
-0.0379081145,
0.0228736661,
-0.0361859836,
-0.0329074562,
-0.0258436427,
0.0306646936,
-0.0236589126,
0.0050675832,
0.0040412033,
-0.0150181782,
0.0135213202,
0.0071435529,
0.0015486582,
0.0170089565,
-0.0317410305,
-0.0102755548,
-0.0178086739,
-0.0035528867,
0.0258495603,
0.0426286124,
-0.0216150042,
0.1492752284,
-0.0084312586,
-0.0160836391,
0.0433811694,
-0.0072789481,
-0.0249932967,
-0.0834123716,
0.0118870875,
0.0191934668,
-0.0860378966,
0.0306898654,
0.0112031912,
0.0584771335,
-0.005301225,
-0.047424905,
0.0030135661,
0.0143739646,
0.0109352395,
0.0396102779,
0.0062940083,
0.0737161338,
-0.0139918998,
0.004304945,
-0.0052136397,
0.0189576689,
0.0086597996,
0.0136153288,
-0.048838146,
0.0416428521,
-0.0096167028,
0.0059512742,
-0.0874071121,
0.0104197701,
-0.0614112057,
0.0708914474,
0.0074337767,
0.0019556552,
0.0295849778,
-0.038882114,
-0.0587567091,
-0.051199872,
-0.0262125079,
0.0232079979,
-0.0054072114,
-0.048530668,
0.0301114954,
0.0234575924,
0.0114404429,
-0.0143858092,
-0.0061941938,
0.0805667341,
0.0104474425,
-0.0442064404,
-0.0162583124,
-0.0203910265,
-0.0324780233,
-0.0710097998,
-0.0462485738,
-0.0693958327,
-0.0122156767,
-0.0133776488,
-0.017699413,
-0.0602145456,
0.0021516338,
-0.0056363204,
-0.0074673323,
0.0717952177,
0.0479863286,
0.0043365182,
-0.0114659574,
0.0083491243,
-0.0487477817,
0.0583592653,
0.0609448552,
0.0972226337,
0.0258046146,
0.0071987621,
0.0669393763,
-0.0098642288,
-0.0230813399,
0.0184312444,
-0.0119359745,
-0.0182636976,
-0.0080410382,
0.0126029197,
-0.0382115766,
0.0637948737,
-0.0369424261,
-0.0014276167,
0.0711864606,
0.0253180768,
0.0197176337,
-0.0537428595,
0.0416598395,
0.0219183434,
-0.0059643127,
-0.0217197537,
-0.0348402038,
0.0106729008,
-0.0045017968,
-0.0161679741,
0.0386565141,
0.0419892147,
-0.0110671725,
-0.057441514,
0.0078208381,
-0.0440435521,
0.0262491051,
0.0357755758,
0.0482922234,
-0.0542241111,
-0.0412943773,
0.0093072383,
0.0261965394,
-0.020432258,
-0.0134524731,
-0.0845714509,
0.0553454831,
0.0913308039,
0.0492065363,
-0.0306071714,
0.0490276851,
-0.0266670361,
0.0079546906,
0.0099687129,
-0.0137209836,
-0.0087092379,
0.0242239535,
-0.0316325836,
-0.0348716266,
0.0407229811,
0.0212923456,
0.0559101962,
-0.0017900219,
0.0282045193,
-0.0156313796,
0.0259035267,
-0.0312371701,
-0.0083096474,
0.0508936532,
-0.0474030972,
0.0093500922,
-0.0114990799,
0.0786503032,
0.0003161776,
-0.010584563,
0.020080395,
0.0093116164,
0.023085393,
-0.0463873148,
0.0099509871,
0.0116203045,
0.0416959748,
0.0447741896,
0.0016857368,
-0.0158592612,
-0.0131128915,
-0.0097936019,
-0.0484145284,
-0.0079373131,
-0.0115446933,
0.0335054398,
-0.0024415399,
0.0468301512,
-0.0235576313,
0.0024694251,
-0.0467349254,
0.0329195186,
-0.0436120927,
0.0025033071,
-0.0163746458,
0.0453480221,
-0.02318177,
-0.0291206688,
-0.0295358934,
0.0214677546,
0.0191320144,
0.0293033589,
0.0442132205,
-0.0008311049,
0.000344814,
-0.0329325311,
-0.0724174008,
-0.0384223089,
0.0023624706,
-0.0079788081,
-0.0441985503,
-0.0018633185,
0.0014681058,
0.008552609,
-0.0106741674,
0.0480922982,
-0.0244814195,
0.0435379334,
-0.0048378203,
-0.0058676247,
-0.0614276975,
-0.0338792168,
-0.018690154,
-0.0017466322,
0.0090604667,
0.0104615297,
-0.0339808427,
-0.0651791468,
0.0589800663,
-0.0193259902,
0.0180190708,
-0.0173713006,
-0.0517911986,
0.0268692672,
-0.0165467914,
0.0245447308,
0.0542614684,
0.001646205,
-0.0092313075,
0.0968138874,
-0.0240121111,
-0.0594468862,
0.0226636808,
-0.0229776483,
-0.0109927971,
-0.0140882367,
-0.0408935137,
0.0371063016,
0.0343179256,
-0.035895329,
-0.0026438767,
-0.0440300405,
0.0160836708,
0.0007887604,
-0.0571829304,
0.0040401649,
-0.0329981893,
-0.0326696634,
0.1047226414,
0.0303328242,
-0.0596335903,
0.0729328468,
-0.029627258,
0.0282452367,
0.030889472,
0.0005680051,
0.0266744588,
0.0214227941,
0.018599797,
0.0249355678,
-0.0327118374,
0.0060060453,
-0.0513788611,
-0.0432425961,
0.0530442335,
-0.0300408266,
0.0425120592,
-0.0648878366,
0.0102024255,
0.0226847641,
-0.0483486205,
-0.0340515114,
-0.0500350036,
-0.0488434881,
-0.0414710343,
0.0113750566,
-0.0641336367,
-0.001607493,
-0.0028049806,
0.0334919728,
0.0276506972,
-0.0154495221,
-0.0203440413,
-0.0162220281,
-0.0555255562,
0.0410236903,
0.0176960733,
0.0630363822,
0.0088542141,
0.0379393324,
0.0392913595,
0.0481168255,
0.050416369,
0.0043007685,
-0.0181704517,
0.0327123217,
-0.0083877761,
0.0172897745,
0.0595748201,
0.0321085714,
-0.0006020744,
-0.0144924922,
0.0982226282,
0.0226825681,
-0.0498498529,
0.0194505602,
-0.0899649262,
0.0548955686,
-0.0197160207,
0.0226807147,
-0.0529836752,
-0.0293619186,
0.0083068646,
0.025229916,
-0.0575951189,
-0.0589448586,
0.0167505089,
-0.1032981351,
0.0468984954,
-0.0172726512,
0.0191707239,
-0.0096720494,
-0.0379709303,
-0.0079466626,
-0.0136971669,
0.0243203752,
0.0065316553,
0.0419594459,
-0.0352681577,
-0.0034942839,
-0.0459591039,
-0.0290568583,
0.0477037132,
-0.0144002428,
0.0253587998,
0.0352118574,
0.0256436411,
-0.0372011103,
0.0072207162,
0.0177500043,
0.0279304441,
-0.0366104878,
0.0093132546,
0.0113039371,
0.0267274715,
0.017198626,
0.0051826253,
0.0170542374,
-0.0003883649,
-0.0316749141,
0.0056011039,
0.0762378797,
-0.0419994667,
-0.0349652693,
0.0241841674,
-0.0028690326,
0.0634023622,
0.0646294355,
-0.0435213968,
-0.0761212632,
-0.0532358624,
-0.0428847335,
-0.0231787805,
-0.0103390403,
-0.0151525969,
0.0306203477,
-0.0050476198,
-0.0430882908,
-0.0415499918,
-0.0178718157,
0.0170644373,
0.0469644554,
-0.0211191829,
0.0037558777,
0.0575139448,
0.030596301,
-0.0009571614,
-0.0090905996,
-0.0207512807,
0.0492263064,
-0.0384931266,
0.056876339,
0.0420832597,
0.0012267686,
-0.0164943393,
0.0359395593,
-0.0014854678,
-0.0879802331,
0.0524386577,
0.103369534,
0.0365699008,
-0.0014527389,
-0.0264978185,
-0.0579585843,
0.0489196368,
-0.0090955263,
0.0221390259,
0.0023787683,
0.0459930375,
0.0737620592,
-0.006566281,
0.0482409298,
-0.0373969078,
0.003272624,
0.0211256966,
0.0168323647,
-0.0797337219,
-0.0478223264,
-0.0014279527,
0.0240995027,
0.0013832867,
-0.0364253819,
0.0292961244,
-0.0129719852,
0.0428870358,
-0.0239250585,
-0.010255293,
-0.0402934588,
0.0109011941,
0.0344985276,
-0.0424944833,
0.0264947955,
-0.0553756654,
-0.0018394275,
-0.0678242818,
0.0316473879,
-0.0184764378,
0.0457971282,
0.0182298012,
0.0857836679,
-0.04983145,
0.0168630499,
0.0210529324,
0.008985973,
0.0213386454,
0.0581237189,
0.0393394791,
0.0093967551,
-0.0639754087,
-0.0127192745,
-0.0023127708,
-0.0199570656,
-0.1009620205,
0.0123897064,
0.0130220288,
0.0166050661,
0.0297769345,
0.0142860571,
-0.0725220144,
0.0162295345,
-0.0146323945,
0.00652252,
0.0433068909,
-0.0066112326,
0.0311262216,
0.0392312184,
-0.0331287384,
0.0158945657,
0.0532485023,
0.0097767254,
0.0212086439,
-0.0607978404,
-0.0629225224,
-0.0312501006,
-0.0599775501,
-0.0540385991,
0.0226207003,
-0.0514648817,
-0.0188996848,
-0.0815414786,
-0.0515322126,
-0.0356010348,
0.0133320512,
0.0206406135,
-0.0516807735,
0.0168823246,
0.0333024934,
0.0134662399,
0.01422894,
-0.0661932305,
-0.0479796268,
-0.003772605,
-0.0059010512,
-0.0269966591,
-7.136534202e-33,
0.0179217551,
-0.0546146557,
0.0005891816,
-0.0393720083,
0.0378495716,
-0.0262388196,
0.0089377239,
0.044639159,
0.0229882076,
0.0251643825,
-0.0181590486,
0.0130396653,
0.0369170345,
-0.0178459976,
0.0358251184,
-0.0125669902,
0.0165573321,
0.0103070941,
-0.0400891155,
-0.0046804254,
0.0548925139,
-0.0287374035,
0.0026553357,
-0.0612689108,
0.0156106008,
0.0297996886,
-0.0469077341,
0.0398639701,
-0.028271161,
0.0064786552,
0.0046332595,
0.0076500219,
-0.0084346086,
-0.011487484,
0.0083713122,
0.0036045997,
0.0021213535,
-0.0264398623,
0.0002411253,
0.0261708684,
-0.0134824179,
-0.0288567021,
0.0043446436,
0.0062028798,
-0.0502840616,
0.0323964246,
-0.0292590316,
-0.0028150915,
-0.0138802864,
0.0101371659,
-0.019764062,
0.0313607156,
0.0187473893,
-0.0156161711,
0.0234459881,
0.0583838336,
-0.0218897127,
-0.0445207022,
-0.0306882001,
0.0152315432,
0.0185542051,
-0.0164473355,
0.0547122881,
0.0026949656,
0.0143440319,
0.0439952761,
0.0548953041,
-0.0121512515,
-0.0231791195,
-0.0088533061,
-0.0235078093,
0.0331610963,
0.0271599721,
0.0602252334,
0.0185747556,
0.0140302153,
-0.0670655444,
0.026574159,
0.0281431694,
0.0763915256,
0.0609571561,
0.0266618766,
-0.0602760501,
-0.0335372835,
-0.0237090234,
-0.011873343,
-0.0151923196,
-0.0319608189,
0.0112936934,
-0.0060910354,
-0.0343958326,
-0.0186335556,
0.0413076431,
-0.0039939731,
-0.0400584601,
-0.0145132011,
0.0023358015,
0.026431812,
0.0069734599,
0.03355214,
0.0156885032,
-0.0328516066,
-0.0280128084,
-0.0004213296,
0.0132969264,
0.0480150953,
-0.0333539508,
0.0114952493,
-0.0267987363,
0.0144458245,
-0.0279086307,
-0.0115865599,
0.0270574596,
-0.0181204919,
0.0598162822,
-0.0392062366,
-0.0165034775,
0.015057357,
0.002480438,
0.0032925154,
0.0256980974,
0.0084456196,
-0.0298214555,
0.0103479559,
-0.016793292,
-0.0451736636,
-0.0350872613,
0.002708754,
0.0468137786,
-0.0142541658,
0.0024394298,
-0.0098049603,
3.332e-7,
-0.0415594913,
0.0275638215,
-0.0397578664,
0.0481880754,
0.0103968317,
0.0486076958,
0.0250682663,
-0.0311024487,
-0.0068524554,
-0.0262184683,
0.0410807244,
0.0148095647,
0.0410876274,
0.0309309289,
-0.0569459386,
-0.0781848878,
-0.0062238127,
0.0149762565,
-0.042077519,
-0.0181272719,
0.04856373,
0.0847371519,
0.0175691992,
-0.0229329076,
-0.0004423828,
-0.0180911105,
0.023726197,
-0.0649998859,
0.0027447026,
0.0450841188,
0.0487024188,
-0.0219836012,
0.015681453,
0.0422075875,
0.0151714813,
-0.0234557837,
-0.0159593802,
0.0578431226,
0.0000499478,
0.0200004242,
-0.0107377581,
-0.0329007208,
0.0098737823,
-0.0438523516,
0.0558215044,
-0.0378723703,
-0.0397597738,
-0.0174754299,
0.0248120409,
-0.0442752242,
0.0356092788,
-0.0149217108,
0.0009160177,
0.003799588,
-0.0356692262,
0.0078658052,
0.0398672074,
-0.0303771663,
0.0072569968,
0.0225377958,
-0.0121814115,
-0.0624810457,
0.001078053,
0.0275207423,
0.0054586167,
-0.0811161548,
0.0167908166,
2.97283233e-34,
0.0176392272,
0.0102039427,
0.0225085206,
0.043230027,
0.0660617054,
0.0268955659,
-0.0114779761,
0.017553309,
0.0726744682,
-0.0495485738,
-0.0190610588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00235v1 | Exploring the limits of decoder-only models trained on public speech recognition corpora | 2024-01-31T23:29:42 | 2024-01-31T23:29:42 | Ankit Gupta, George Saon, Brian Kingsbury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The emergence of industrial-scale speech recognition (ASR) models such as
Whisper and USM, trained on 1M hours of weakly labelled and 12M hours of audio
only proprietary data respectively, has led to a stronger need for large scale
public ASR corpora and competitive open source pipelines. Unlike the said
models, large language models are typically based on Transformer decoders, and
it remains unclear if decoder-only models trained on public data alone can
deliver competitive performance. In this work, we investigate factors such as
choice of training datasets and modeling components necessary for obtaining the
best performance using public English ASR corpora alone. Our Decoder-Only
Transformer for ASR (DOTA) model comprehensively outperforms the
encoder-decoder open source replication of Whisper (OWSM) on nearly all English
ASR benchmarks and outperforms Whisper large-v3 on 7 out of 15 test sets. We
release our codebase and model checkpoints under permissive license. | Exploring the limits of decoder-only models trained on public speech recognition corpora: The emergence of industrial-scale speech recognition (ASR) models such as
Whisper and USM, trained on 1M hours of weakly labelled and 12M hours of audio
only proprietary data respectively, has led to a stronger need for large scale
public ASR corpora and competitive open source pipelines. Unlike the said
models, large language models are typically based on Transformer decoders, and
it remains unclear if decoder-only models trained on public data alone can
deliver competitive performance. In this work, we investigate factors such as
choice of training datasets and modeling components necessary for obtaining the
best performance using public English ASR corpora alone. Our Decoder-Only
Transformer for ASR (DOTA) model comprehensively outperforms the
encoder-decoder open source replication of Whisper (OWSM) on nearly all English
ASR benchmarks and outperforms Whisper large-v3 on 7 out of 15 test sets. We
release our codebase and model checkpoints under permissive license. | [
-0.0299677514,
0.102376312,
0.0280236006,
0.0605797134,
0.0037133812,
-0.0043168529,
0.0391714871,
-0.0137959756,
-0.0281276032,
0.0045903074,
-0.0743740499,
0.0025599385,
0.0241282098,
0.0220079552,
0.0031049398,
-0.0019888522,
0.0082471967,
-0.0566182435,
-0.0458390824,
-0.0147770057,
-0.0004258667,
0.0086059403,
-0.0167701896,
0.0415383689,
0.0221300945,
0.014792908,
-0.0009354453,
0.0176894106,
0.0175678972,
-0.0173582342,
-0.006573705,
0.0006453226,
0.0171240605,
0.0551644303,
0.0000018154,
-0.0222081132,
-0.0165597778,
0.0124863833,
-0.0628658831,
0.0190389175,
0.0034054599,
-0.0412905179,
-0.0206730552,
0.061715398,
-0.010997979,
-0.062588267,
0.0396954268,
0.015969906,
0.0427646078,
0.0704705715,
0.0014008078,
-0.0551583692,
0.0402816385,
-0.0334024578,
-0.0495573878,
-0.0669536218,
-0.0166911893,
-0.0389115959,
-0.0305268299,
0.0108350208,
-0.0383567028,
0.0582995154,
0.0297079403,
0.008759575,
-0.0150508946,
0.0129441619,
-0.0389291532,
-0.0420597382,
-0.0302749928,
0.0575405024,
0.024609454,
-0.0439004675,
0.0025457551,
0.0118883327,
-0.0160341673,
-0.0522262715,
-0.0100152502,
0.0555477589,
-0.0031214328,
0.0370486155,
0.007448297,
0.0393995233,
0.0370755158,
-0.0228287484,
-0.0072343871,
0.0290930383,
-0.0006530173,
-0.0212448761,
0.0001878142,
0.0016670093,
0.0167489294,
-0.0125883278,
0.0653963611,
-0.0255223494,
-0.0049373703,
-0.0073628621,
-0.0365312174,
-0.0399007238,
-0.0276479591,
-0.0203115642,
-0.003827896,
0.0498438254,
-0.0344440863,
0.0155654699,
0.0035408621,
0.0641853511,
-0.0145597775,
0.0366885997,
-0.0308562722,
-0.036311768,
-0.0226780958,
0.0159586556,
-0.0452639721,
0.0149299502,
-0.0413000397,
-0.033411976,
-0.0108335484,
-0.0048747668,
0.0099184169,
0.0026789589,
0.0854670107,
0.0103655523,
-0.0465059504,
-0.0152615989,
0.0512507148,
0.0566121377,
0.0470440313,
0.0216061622,
-0.001486012,
-0.0685686767,
-0.0094997222,
0.0107753016,
0.0236457381,
-0.0053325882,
-0.011449662,
0.0446266308,
-0.0191933494,
-0.0134126917,
-0.0316046439,
0.0244906303,
0.0007044596,
-0.0325611755,
-0.0321564972,
-0.0192474611,
0.0439851917,
0.0294184629,
0.0495679975,
-0.0693404227,
-0.0032918646,
-0.0183711648,
0.0044895229,
0.0787960738,
-0.0014456125,
0.0113933934,
0.0207283497,
-0.0055308891,
0.0114349499,
0.0435425527,
0.0508395545,
0.0075205807,
0.0240149293,
-0.0482778549,
0.0126456898,
0.0742800012,
-0.00351699,
0.0125223286,
0.0291256253,
0.0060948073,
-0.0060816836,
0.0008774935,
0.0602928959,
0.0579445809,
-0.0235654693,
-0.0526236072,
0.0415039398,
0.0119211469,
0.0321138389,
0.0168492757,
0.0170656443,
0.048641853,
-0.0057792715,
-0.0456185192,
0.0036831961,
-0.0188580118,
0.0002053783,
-0.0003492745,
0.0359573439,
0.0315420255,
-0.0382428393,
0.0078054117,
-0.0085630622,
-0.0351210721,
0.0060780896,
0.0433007441,
0.0758727491,
0.0148255946,
-0.062229991,
0.1083384827,
0.0014186096,
-0.0575663783,
0.019119367,
-0.0417681597,
-0.0082438625,
0.0391922072,
0.0442589521,
0.0009151673,
-0.0066292221,
-0.0482284389,
-0.0102788294,
0.0481412113,
-0.0010721209,
-0.0117377583,
0.0660500899,
-0.0823039114,
-0.0150528038,
0.0460414998,
-0.0101884278,
0.056167502,
-0.0056726811,
0.0024289913,
0.0165323913,
-0.0599696562,
-0.0160846878,
-0.0013651293,
-0.0241805855,
-0.0288633872,
0.0383374244,
-0.014604209,
0.0756600648,
0.0341101848,
-0.0223732255,
-0.0124462172,
0.0423586853,
-0.0411438309,
0.0201668013,
0.0237639416,
-0.0392413363,
-0.0214892086,
0.0175072979,
-0.0109097883,
0.0339943953,
0.0942201689,
-0.0242512375,
-0.0552229211,
0.0161416829,
-0.037325833,
0.069470562,
-0.025791591,
0.036919713,
0.0130332559,
0.0078802379,
0.0222320519,
-0.04590955,
-0.0168832019,
-0.0084692873,
-0.0254001524,
0.0053220745,
0.0180849601,
-0.0530639179,
-0.0368407704,
0.0233849287,
-0.0471395738,
0.0332789607,
-0.0030270203,
-0.008371749,
0.0094984248,
-0.0086703785,
-0.0576809905,
-0.0259338189,
-0.0445598066,
0.0363290235,
0.0072513963,
0.026468236,
-0.0017333186,
-0.0370922983,
0.0038175355,
-0.0095740436,
-0.0165838953,
0.0031797863,
-0.0535209663,
-0.0167166796,
-0.0197467934,
-0.0265187565,
-0.0063692685,
0.0364936516,
0.0168452859,
-0.0318850577,
0.0061731092,
-0.1002720743,
0.0451143421,
0.0544401519,
0.0392228588,
-0.0166847724,
-0.0451364852,
0.0089301486,
0.0296524372,
0.0245363023,
0.0077776257,
-0.0180095956,
0.0078861453,
-0.0125723071,
-0.001808451,
-0.0646143332,
-0.0098699136,
0.0105210552,
-0.0437620915,
-0.0693221018,
-0.0214160904,
-0.0011716402,
0.0605473816,
0.0199833419,
0.0286566429,
-0.0554234907,
-0.0348458253,
-0.0191854853,
-0.0360398181,
-0.0030212658,
-0.0218184963,
-0.0304542296,
0.0213783272,
-0.0132096997,
-0.0287630446,
0.0038993619,
-0.1090868041,
-0.0339102633,
-0.0196304005,
-0.011264802,
-0.0458925255,
0.0225228239,
-0.0071712309,
0.0100452919,
0.0045096627,
-0.079300724,
0.034322042,
0.0358652063,
0.0086460346,
-0.0620809868,
0.0182788987,
-0.0170606319,
0.0140834767,
-0.0248322152,
-0.0640378818,
-0.0247227456,
0.008723313,
-0.0577989705,
0.0235986803,
0.0303722285,
-0.0315220021,
-0.0357090198,
0.0598124415,
-0.0016396398,
0.0830700845,
0.0297054872,
0.0140656848,
-0.0154656926,
0.0321459733,
-0.001496464,
0.0232580099,
-0.0048832074,
-0.0295859016,
0.0158052258,
0.0290008485,
0.0889825746,
0.0018322855,
-0.0677621663,
-0.02098055,
0.0662448332,
0.0276860669,
0.0150103848,
0.0157535747,
0.0324278288,
-0.028875608,
-0.022809092,
0.0947917923,
-0.0075441836,
-0.0383301415,
-0.011013573,
0.0157610308,
0.0146158924,
0.0172391422,
-0.013795644,
-0.0659090877,
-0.0381301679,
0.0537509248,
0.0803139582,
0.0485677421,
-0.0057386882,
0.0015882219,
-0.1126772761,
0.0553855635,
0.0069951303,
-0.0445685498,
-0.0352515876,
-0.0690840036,
-0.0476411767,
-0.0837074816,
0.0519536287,
0.0074729398,
0.004784463,
-0.0267003234,
0.0394765139,
-0.0372101814,
-0.0706230104,
0.0185892936,
-0.0329959728,
0.0829768702,
0.0480271243,
-0.0186497197,
-0.0160954017,
-0.0381870791,
0.0072136228,
-0.0027844508,
-0.0207535438,
-0.0198182818,
0.0382516421,
-0.0162515435,
-0.0184392426,
0.0105067389,
0.0252462626,
-0.064393267,
-0.0005553886,
0.0017305727,
0.0413924083,
-0.004640229,
-0.0134074911,
0.0428153984,
-0.034098886,
-0.0168375205,
0.0801568627,
-0.0030337011,
-0.0135088088,
-0.0104980124,
0.0061899358,
0.0451421998,
-0.0274978746,
-0.018103322,
0.0106858062,
0.0194546655,
-0.0773903579,
-0.0190780517,
-0.0041628811,
0.0272493996,
0.0142376311,
0.0157811176,
-0.0225536693,
0.0565213971,
-0.0037724609,
-0.0476809628,
0.0120835025,
-0.036524456,
0.0249676611,
-0.0981810316,
-0.0151759647,
0.0515834279,
-0.0103466706,
-0.0173981022,
0.0153577365,
-0.0741568804,
-0.0506805964,
0.0214824155,
0.0026698709,
0.0202232227,
0.0462779365,
-0.0410585329,
-0.0285998583,
0.0526745655,
-0.0034057244,
-0.0737388507,
0.028992705,
0.0604558364,
-0.026755251,
-0.0197232496,
0.0303464644,
-0.0510678552,
0.0004357403,
0.0234855637,
0.022707738,
-0.014583244,
-0.0299145635,
0.001237762,
0.0297579858,
0.0534300096,
-0.0251813754,
0.0165270232,
-0.0267487429,
0.0288416892,
0.0170073975,
0.0564629249,
-0.0364464521,
-0.0099878293,
0.075779058,
-0.0074944282,
-0.0222901925,
0.067975238,
-0.0092221769,
0.0121682053,
-0.0398341306,
0.0439828038,
0.0528195947,
-0.0242461096,
0.0363103449,
-0.0100322273,
0.0010348593,
0.0284475442,
0.0412488356,
0.0390622839,
0.0083426572,
0.0056921602,
-0.0245168582,
0.0397503674,
0.0262102205,
0.0338286944,
-0.033464063,
-0.0411056466,
-0.0319739878,
0.0305002183,
0.0185684245,
0.0167536903,
0.0875521973,
0.0181245394,
0.035040129,
-0.0331372395,
0.0181651842,
-0.0294430498,
-0.0190169979,
0.0378100984,
-0.0034049971,
-0.0189913269,
0.0674402937,
0.0675333813,
0.0281617753,
0.0406259187,
-0.0215024501,
0.0351161025,
-0.0394371711,
-0.0419939421,
-0.000186443,
-0.0104630589,
-0.0420260392,
-0.0316605754,
0.0193413049,
-0.0562923886,
0.0176466219,
-0.0073733469,
0.0281514991,
-0.0228208005,
-0.0074969954,
0.0309396572,
-0.0218436755,
-0.0162689704,
-0.003698376,
-0.0418963097,
-0.0040292921,
-0.0354617536,
0.0040642316,
-6.358384125e-33,
-0.0083816163,
0.0436470658,
0.01281833,
-0.0055455253,
-0.0201911964,
0.0154265622,
-0.0344393924,
-0.0122072054,
0.0057743653,
-0.0365909487,
-0.0253077727,
0.0160307623,
0.0371610001,
0.0607879311,
0.0053227572,
-0.0141673675,
0.1087271199,
-0.0345190801,
-0.0221154075,
0.0127832731,
0.0231710989,
0.0433289818,
0.015306687,
-0.0173137952,
-0.0295723937,
-0.0171799697,
-0.0175947528,
-0.0179068483,
0.0292518009,
0.0347536243,
-0.0228784569,
0.0367235355,
0.0008050877,
-0.0681764558,
-0.0187884495,
0.0093709482,
-0.0942809805,
0.0774153545,
-0.0266464129,
0.062071126,
0.0209947713,
-0.009559352,
0.016623158,
0.0113689695,
-0.0235222783,
0.0006146604,
-0.019520374,
-0.0028663201,
0.0079782996,
-0.0592946187,
0.0086363256,
0.0359258093,
-0.0218964852,
-0.019081166,
0.0901072919,
0.0239207875,
-0.0213988647,
0.0142671643,
-0.1055422425,
0.0085945083,
0.0136489468,
0.0118155675,
0.0781613514,
0.0352316201,
-0.0242523458,
-0.0107599488,
0.041171927,
-0.0629874989,
0.0200800635,
0.0043905145,
0.0187573824,
0.0593861528,
0.0114719905,
0.0095530283,
0.0202219635,
-0.0260768551,
-0.0210039429,
-0.022326149,
-0.015855426,
0.0184708443,
0.027149776,
0.044464536,
-0.049391903,
-0.0194860622,
-0.0514002144,
-0.0449832827,
-0.0218119118,
0.0140562383,
0.067964308,
0.0347137861,
-0.0281246696,
-0.0056433659,
0.0669008493,
-0.0534271561,
0.014907307,
0.0051146583,
0.0443306714,
0.0183722153,
-0.038572073,
0.0399380885,
-0.068500042,
-0.0263918359,
0.0373044014,
0.0190720912,
0.0031395254,
-0.0430973917,
0.0042109452,
0.0551142059,
-0.0687721297,
0.0012336294,
-0.0180949885,
0.0374168195,
-0.0089363074,
0.0262182672,
0.0460348278,
-0.0058995117,
-0.0072169476,
0.0360399522,
-0.0230865572,
0.040917553,
-0.0167145543,
0.0110952491,
0.0265532713,
0.0038164915,
-0.0155427018,
-0.0043123807,
-0.0018927719,
0.0159446727,
0.0308333393,
-0.017354561,
-0.0114684766,
0.0123420712,
2.512e-7,
-0.0237974767,
0.0043671769,
0.0532275252,
-0.0206408463,
0.009069059,
0.024007827,
-0.0237606857,
0.0230361875,
0.0022797517,
0.0001730332,
-0.0293415654,
0.006425818,
0.1036801115,
0.0202081054,
-0.0874789804,
-0.0193842798,
-0.0594837107,
0.0272621009,
-0.0216022693,
-0.025306968,
-0.0027689929,
0.1039454788,
-0.0267594941,
-0.0288874991,
0.0100399312,
-0.0150866527,
0.0305927955,
-0.0300500691,
0.001526514,
0.0162822716,
-0.0117293624,
0.028273847,
-0.0202610828,
-0.0289216787,
-0.023574315,
0.0192714371,
-0.0138041098,
0.0633083954,
0.0004716933,
-0.0578656979,
-0.0002371276,
0.004739074,
-0.0373150408,
-0.0070313779,
0.0526380688,
-0.0155043751,
-0.0292065907,
0.0081482269,
-0.0597456619,
-0.0084964773,
-0.038366504,
-0.0293907151,
0.0231333245,
0.0161039494,
0.0352002569,
-0.0433047675,
-0.0258405823,
-0.0357158892,
0.0072546615,
-0.0527808629,
-0.0607613698,
-0.0119909225,
-0.0288089998,
0.0173919778,
-0.0148431705,
0.0077723078,
0.0213750862,
1.843859317e-34,
0.0590360723,
-0.0144963609,
0.0243636761,
0.0127101699,
0.0101388292,
-0.0413972475,
0.0310054645,
0.0140926652,
-0.0633297935,
-0.0910931751,
-0.0232699346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00234v1 | Are Generative AI systems Capable of Supporting Information Needs of Patients? | 2024-01-31T23:24:37 | 2024-01-31T23:24:37 | Shreya Rajagopal, Subhashis Hazarika, Sookyung Kim, Yan-ming Chiou, Jae Ho Sohn, Hari Subramonyam, Shiwali Mohan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Patients managing a complex illness such as cancer face a complex information
challenge where they not only must learn about their illness but also how to
manage it. Close interaction with healthcare experts (radiologists,
oncologists) can improve patient learning and thereby, their disease outcome.
However, this approach is resource intensive and takes expert time away from
other critical tasks. Given the recent advancements in Generative AI models
aimed at improving the healthcare system, our work investigates whether and how
generative visual question answering systems can responsibly support patient
information needs in the context of radiology imaging data. We conducted a
formative need-finding study in which participants discussed chest computed
tomography (CT) scans and associated radiology reports of a fictitious close
relative with a cardiothoracic radiologist. Using thematic analysis of the
conversation between participants and medical experts, we identified commonly
occurring themes across interactions, including clarifying medical terminology,
locating the problems mentioned in the report in the scanned image,
understanding disease prognosis, discussing the next diagnostic steps, and
comparing treatment options. Based on these themes, we evaluated two
state-of-the-art generative visual language models against the radiologist's
responses. Our results reveal variability in the quality of responses generated
by the models across various themes. We highlight the importance of
patient-facing generative AI systems to accommodate a diverse range of
conversational themes, catering to the real-world informational needs of
patients. | Are Generative AI systems Capable of Supporting Information Needs of Patients?: Patients managing a complex illness such as cancer face a complex information
challenge where they not only must learn about their illness but also how to
manage it. Close interaction with healthcare experts (radiologists,
oncologists) can improve patient learning and thereby, their disease outcome.
However, this approach is resource intensive and takes expert time away from
other critical tasks. Given the recent advancements in Generative AI models
aimed at improving the healthcare system, our work investigates whether and how
generative visual question answering systems can responsibly support patient
information needs in the context of radiology imaging data. We conducted a
formative need-finding study in which participants discussed chest computed
tomography (CT) scans and associated radiology reports of a fictitious close
relative with a cardiothoracic radiologist. Using thematic analysis of the
conversation between participants and medical experts, we identified commonly
occurring themes across interactions, including clarifying medical terminology,
locating the problems mentioned in the report in the scanned image,
understanding disease prognosis, discussing the next diagnostic steps, and
comparing treatment options. Based on these themes, we evaluated two
state-of-the-art generative visual language models against the radiologist's
responses. Our results reveal variability in the quality of responses generated
by the models across various themes. We highlight the importance of
patient-facing generative AI systems to accommodate a diverse range of
conversational themes, catering to the real-world informational needs of
patients. | [
0.0959281474,
0.058944203,
-0.0306163784,
0.0007467243,
-0.0022341788,
0.0211370774,
-0.0205979906,
0.0188278183,
-0.0104631698,
0.0239466894,
0.0005368956,
-0.0447051041,
-0.0001055329,
0.0445224456,
-0.0094766766,
-0.1131111458,
-0.0094899572,
0.0140050007,
0.0513029657,
0.0085716974,
0.0096419435,
0.0168080516,
-0.0318945982,
0.0605014749,
-0.02863767,
-0.0128477179,
0.0142158298,
0.0066532879,
0.0242368989,
-0.0535977408,
-0.0193694178,
0.0130385272,
0.001979837,
-0.0194935296,
0.000001921,
-0.0361674502,
0.0107488371,
0.003260399,
-0.0174036268,
-0.0486407802,
0.0552871861,
-0.0409886427,
0.0086961472,
0.0019227656,
-0.067000486,
-0.0186483022,
0.0555042438,
0.0361841023,
0.05453806,
0.041658435,
-0.0264609177,
0.0165443141,
0.0222126152,
-0.015830731,
0.0425472371,
-0.0361409485,
-0.0090635791,
0.0620494224,
0.0371267796,
-0.0087337336,
0.0057328418,
0.072274901,
0.0089416122,
-0.0020897835,
0.0291844159,
0.0839179605,
0.0194719676,
-0.0307381116,
-0.006157171,
0.0695457458,
0.0288816318,
0.0206237398,
-0.0050665508,
-0.013607597,
0.0119237909,
0.034379866,
-0.0435475484,
0.0166405775,
-0.0305994712,
-0.0128555959,
-0.0198516622,
0.0110230846,
-0.0156603456,
-0.0048117233,
0.0124292253,
-0.0681723654,
0.0105413524,
0.0033770865,
-0.0366518833,
0.0005077027,
-0.0294697639,
-0.07339634,
0.0124699706,
0.051712539,
-0.0492928103,
0.0246738531,
-0.0049125152,
-0.008128413,
0.0421464965,
-0.0326799527,
-0.0156946145,
0.0036695108,
-0.0333578959,
0.0315542445,
0.0358907767,
0.0083755841,
-0.0308598727,
0.0041371034,
-0.0473009497,
-0.0051257233,
-0.0422143042,
-0.0459515452,
-0.0513453856,
0.0086851753,
-0.0236009955,
-0.0375021696,
-0.018453287,
0.0201031379,
0.009363886,
0.013496221,
0.0363845453,
0.0633539185,
-0.0421645902,
0.0319194011,
-0.060899049,
0.0228346586,
-0.0648507476,
-0.0178440865,
0.0088904975,
-0.0668413863,
0.0335291773,
0.0336804688,
0.0161892623,
0.0123284115,
-0.0121381935,
0.0266643018,
-0.0065959585,
0.0028668726,
-0.0050528543,
-0.0477244928,
-0.0236301068,
-0.0264972355,
0.0328046307,
-0.0397540256,
0.0321959928,
0.0211541355,
0.0073697413,
-0.0387621857,
0.0186473094,
0.0119704315,
-0.0274480358,
0.0732578039,
-0.0366233289,
0.029066857,
0.0526027009,
0.0467714742,
0.0408367813,
0.0044247825,
0.0223094579,
0.0072581004,
0.0256020091,
-0.0261044409,
0.0490295477,
-0.0168235749,
-0.0016506599,
-0.0449981056,
-0.0096283723,
0.0212199669,
-0.0538821779,
0.0769109577,
-0.0355881676,
0.0889873356,
-0.0117551107,
-0.0031616839,
0.0290875752,
0.0748775899,
0.0377311297,
0.045272775,
0.0422091857,
-0.0241639074,
-0.024176212,
0.0332852118,
0.0056298971,
0.0636224151,
0.0278956071,
-0.0051663886,
-0.0257956237,
-0.0190528352,
-0.0385602862,
-0.0737990588,
-0.0261871926,
0.0197104178,
-0.0178293008,
0.0192443188,
0.0247540977,
0.0189526137,
-0.0305943191,
-0.0479940102,
0.0143932598,
-0.042551823,
-0.0186708644,
-0.0837495476,
0.0157882329,
0.155406639,
0.0724890307,
-0.0066337744,
-0.0516799316,
0.017118182,
0.0137220966,
0.028261479,
0.0412853993,
-0.0174523555,
-0.0060565756,
-0.020602867,
-0.0153664136,
0.0059553096,
0.0019717049,
-0.0049353754,
-0.0033987947,
0.004840224,
-0.0241937377,
-0.0260478836,
-0.0061242459,
0.0404175073,
-0.0218388177,
-0.0215430781,
-0.0154388966,
0.0242199395,
-0.0170340464,
0.023872463,
-0.0294409972,
0.0298481099,
0.0241729263,
0.0027887782,
-0.0281699765,
0.0482853986,
-0.0580055676,
0.0017406381,
0.0018338308,
-0.0664554834,
0.0020469213,
-0.0484405942,
-0.0136305457,
-0.0166387409,
-0.0036091749,
-0.0746571645,
0.0142662963,
-0.010422335,
-0.0144892912,
0.0824873671,
0.0120038111,
-0.0197119452,
0.0482475124,
-0.02613662,
-0.0213554259,
0.0135213202,
-0.0157545563,
-0.0010802972,
-0.0626040772,
-0.0038800326,
0.0220135823,
0.0086145923,
0.0012668958,
0.0048016771,
0.0167197473,
-0.0423922576,
0.0042373063,
-0.1334417611,
-0.0368559062,
0.0129616046,
-0.0295924265,
0.0411607586,
0.0339757055,
-0.0174315013,
-0.0454728566,
-0.05661631,
0.0147149889,
0.032337103,
0.0086195376,
0.0664631277,
0.0494831316,
0.0177323949,
-0.0622074828,
-0.0077829785,
-0.0097136712,
0.0154554741,
0.0736314803,
-0.0225679688,
-0.0064766146,
0.0026014587,
-0.0671929345,
0.0254680496,
0.004694608,
-0.0224855598,
0.0481364764,
-0.0479163937,
0.0018999685,
0.0418670848,
0.026021773,
0.0629747584,
-0.0007116776,
-0.0176885668,
-0.0374031402,
0.0242545623,
-0.0214491449,
-0.0603753477,
0.0420338139,
-0.0739117786,
0.0018449562,
0.0438193418,
0.0197312385,
0.0295345113,
-0.0529898852,
0.027626507,
0.0004860651,
-0.0065968139,
-0.0450896621,
0.0213681813,
0.0149497921,
0.0520599224,
-0.0037677202,
-0.0283718873,
0.098507978,
0.0123399766,
0.0103799375,
-0.041473411,
-0.0146484235,
-0.0146053424,
0.0781458244,
-0.0169647746,
0.0352523364,
0.0517431833,
0.0084222695,
-0.0457146354,
-0.0014200559,
0.0263920799,
-0.0472448692,
0.0144986119,
-0.0347007364,
0.0017100757,
0.0077865059,
-0.0269095097,
-0.0537301302,
0.003648676,
-0.0001778035,
-0.0152810309,
0.0106907189,
-0.0261734128,
-0.0230050627,
0.0009357386,
0.0106876018,
0.0183419008,
0.043172311,
-0.0522925518,
0.0088432599,
0.0779429078,
0.0848706588,
0.0360038094,
-0.0313639045,
0.0110336514,
0.0445582829,
0.0499979258,
-0.0136586223,
0.0031827001,
-0.0283127911,
-0.0234132446,
-0.0123941358,
0.0273157712,
0.0120631959,
0.0144738052,
0.0181631111,
-0.0197503082,
-0.0125602977,
0.0770212933,
0.0472401865,
-0.0160725862,
0.0134579549,
-0.0324573107,
-0.006829707,
-0.0201289728,
0.0373212434,
-0.0656339154,
0.0128491241,
-0.0305793099,
0.0315442942,
-0.0232443791,
-0.0107639134,
-0.0078564426,
-0.0191732403,
0.0705581456,
-0.0404192433,
0.0073202541,
-0.022346437,
-0.003405008,
-0.0080780927,
0.0210017208,
-0.0418511853,
-0.0306621529,
0.0051193242,
0.0125332745,
-0.0038387859,
-0.019551076,
-0.0431533828,
-0.0007461034,
-0.0111294491,
0.0126648946,
0.0881947875,
0.0578066669,
0.0147052435,
-0.0595472939,
-0.0567909628,
0.0558268502,
0.0671358258,
-0.0056229387,
0.0846844465,
0.002842505,
0.0057065221,
-0.0579878949,
0.0349711441,
-0.0150777809,
-0.0043223528,
0.0179143697,
0.0249367002,
-0.0468677655,
-0.0302533358,
-0.0742609054,
0.0462677293,
0.045404423,
0.0388939418,
0.0262179691,
-0.0143442452,
-0.0278422292,
0.0000615904,
0.1027206406,
-0.0364327841,
-0.0210573412,
-0.0089311935,
0.0167865269,
-0.028676074,
-0.1119956896,
-0.0410913005,
0.0272350628,
-0.0037961318,
-0.0158647001,
-0.0212753955,
-0.0211949497,
0.0107993968,
-0.0592362992,
0.0294364486,
0.0133365896,
-0.0213574376,
-0.0155641381,
-0.0816505477,
0.0301249959,
-0.0343562141,
-0.0024086731,
0.0219514444,
-0.0207221135,
0.0146941999,
-0.0495888367,
0.0618747026,
0.022858737,
-0.0285513252,
0.008336355,
-0.0402455889,
0.0176390707,
0.0592668578,
-0.0268161986,
-0.0171198584,
-0.0229443833,
-0.0000589601,
0.0031867544,
-0.0050671315,
-0.0122544523,
0.0228749681,
-0.0054003014,
0.039610222,
-0.035803359,
-0.0270013995,
0.0358584858,
0.0197124388,
0.0154517042,
-0.0319711119,
-0.0304036643,
-0.0056748036,
-0.0045621614,
-0.0198063329,
0.0090380972,
-0.0347494632,
-0.0080358349,
0.0073107048,
0.0120163867,
-0.0032767465,
-0.0023607074,
-0.061670389,
-0.0225406252,
-0.0612970814,
0.0116971657,
0.0484199561,
-0.0131132472,
0.0140684275,
-0.0173502918,
0.0063830237,
0.0032258651,
-0.0101844035,
0.0319694728,
0.0320558585,
0.0705446824,
-0.0080449535,
-0.006669343,
0.0219283551,
0.0487641245,
-0.0294001792,
-0.0983621702,
-0.0133157615,
0.0574598089,
0.0380599499,
0.0416681245,
-0.0225932058,
-0.0204004552,
0.0190549605,
0.0084374463,
0.0065839835,
0.0123113198,
-0.0320285112,
0.0327889137,
0.0124666411,
0.0255671293,
-0.0356733687,
0.0825281367,
-0.0456081033,
0.0407319665,
-0.0459105447,
-0.0333328769,
-0.0525501184,
-0.0262403116,
-0.014569344,
-0.003636616,
-0.0194647349,
0.0461216532,
-0.04819699,
-0.0578155369,
-0.025177924,
0.0146945203,
-0.0199216902,
-0.0309047643,
0.0738098249,
0.052074939,
0.0005265892,
-0.0381599478,
-0.0248871781,
0.0734448135,
-0.0616779588,
-0.0017167315,
-0.0438647531,
-5.742720061e-33,
-0.0127077438,
-0.0476962253,
0.0486254506,
-0.0252669733,
0.0339218415,
0.0355875194,
-0.0487534665,
0.0068156575,
-0.0135813514,
0.0058550029,
-0.0261737239,
0.0014933125,
-0.009119032,
0.0348606706,
-0.0159481335,
-0.0320899598,
0.05400493,
-0.0144476043,
-0.029594874,
0.0333180428,
-0.02398731,
0.0066781016,
-0.0176871736,
-0.1104135513,
-0.0092155878,
-0.0089812875,
-0.0002480121,
0.0160648413,
0.0225609504,
0.053062927,
-0.0419354327,
0.0367102958,
0.0510110781,
0.0088502411,
0.0000939235,
0.0370696746,
-0.0882067457,
-0.0343146138,
0.0218066592,
-0.0230551586,
-0.0951687992,
-0.0065163132,
0.0285118371,
-0.0252325051,
0.0184626281,
-0.0043929298,
0.0527536459,
-0.0063848463,
0.0281038862,
-0.0168262925,
-0.029948717,
0.0223382786,
-0.0091687804,
-0.0312233977,
-0.0303883161,
0.0366828553,
-0.0010049911,
0.024724232,
0.0018760851,
0.033822801,
0.0451992489,
0.0035358793,
0.0581184365,
-0.0185680632,
-0.0076542445,
0.0150716221,
0.0544287227,
-0.0233463682,
-0.0803668648,
-0.0030203168,
-0.0624784678,
0.0316072181,
0.0429679118,
0.0432576165,
0.0104753142,
-0.0070681693,
-0.039273195,
0.0559239946,
-0.0690875277,
0.0598751344,
0.0128620081,
0.0115627628,
-0.0563291535,
0.0337688141,
0.0039958782,
-0.0172057953,
-0.0358502641,
-0.0561077781,
0.0438400172,
0.032533586,
-0.0042986982,
0.0086947279,
-0.0209991094,
-0.0113720046,
0.0271778796,
0.0101390406,
0.021306837,
0.0225148406,
-0.0363697223,
-0.0245625675,
0.0056337663,
0.0211360306,
0.0733330101,
-0.0029989544,
0.0234426707,
0.0338479206,
0.0185787976,
-0.0297101885,
-0.0329107344,
-0.0052687293,
-0.0020721396,
0.0292660408,
-0.0376710892,
-0.015550972,
0.0218344517,
0.0349260457,
-0.0480724312,
-0.0083741033,
0.0013873426,
0.0333049707,
-0.0622920468,
-0.0641819537,
-0.0331901014,
-0.0121782282,
-0.064246811,
-0.0105243418,
-0.0357134156,
0.0001331093,
0.0411247015,
-0.0401531979,
-0.0321185775,
0.0143560739,
2.742e-7,
0.0591351427,
0.0203753151,
0.0416486599,
0.0014108439,
0.0180262774,
-0.0174473766,
0.0270828605,
-0.0130787333,
-0.0021085762,
-0.0311475303,
0.0497612953,
0.0400281139,
-0.0192100722,
0.0178147908,
-0.0215343218,
-0.0187831819,
-0.0460032411,
-0.0090941461,
-0.0075766412,
0.0015468103,
0.1293601245,
0.0203548949,
-0.0419936441,
-0.0279816557,
0.021922918,
-0.0265219379,
0.0349773876,
-0.0533580296,
0.0355693884,
0.009626545,
0.0206043944,
0.0175373703,
0.0089379624,
0.0357872583,
-0.0110670347,
-0.0548043214,
0.0167105701,
0.0403326005,
-0.045835603,
-0.0245746691,
0.0104921609,
0.0263144597,
0.0252564605,
-0.0474185944,
0.0429630131,
-0.053363543,
-0.0257215351,
-0.004266934,
-0.00442251,
-0.0015397778,
0.0194410458,
-0.0626723841,
-0.0659287944,
0.014135736,
0.0293159653,
0.0229048114,
-0.0228107404,
-0.0497711152,
0.0193264168,
-0.0037117901,
-0.0313685834,
-0.0329989828,
-0.0073529328,
-0.0447335951,
-0.0229256544,
0.0015159763,
-0.0106648607,
1.760895129e-34,
0.0177558046,
0.0420168638,
-0.0073626926,
0.0192602389,
0.0336655527,
0.0076967273,
-0.009542102,
0.0006398381,
0.0446260348,
-0.0399561934,
-0.0277470332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15514v2 | Large Scale Generative AI Text Applied to Sports and Music | 2024-01-31T22:47:01 | 2024-02-28T00:03:57 | Aaron Baughman, Stephen Hammer, Rahul Agarwal, Gozde Akay, Eduardo Morales, Tony Johnson, Leonid Karlinsky, Rogerio Feris | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address the problem of scaling up the production of media content,
including commentary and personalized news stories, for large-scale sports and
music events worldwide. Our approach relies on generative AI models to
transform a large volume of multimodal data (e.g., videos, articles, real-time
scoring feeds, statistics, and fact sheets) into coherent and fluent text.
Based on this approach, we introduce, for the first time, an AI commentary
system, which was deployed to produce automated narrations for highlight
packages at the 2023 US Open, Wimbledon, and Masters tournaments. In the same
vein, our solution was extended to create personalized content for ESPN Fantasy
Football and stories about music artists for the Grammy awards. These
applications were built using a common software architecture achieved a 15x
speed improvement with an average Rouge-L of 82.00 and perplexity of 6.6. Our
work was successfully deployed at the aforementioned events, supporting 90
million fans around the world with 8 billion page views, continuously pushing
the bounds on what is possible at the intersection of sports, entertainment,
and AI. | Large Scale Generative AI Text Applied to Sports and Music: We address the problem of scaling up the production of media content,
including commentary and personalized news stories, for large-scale sports and
music events worldwide. Our approach relies on generative AI models to
transform a large volume of multimodal data (e.g., videos, articles, real-time
scoring feeds, statistics, and fact sheets) into coherent and fluent text.
Based on this approach, we introduce, for the first time, an AI commentary
system, which was deployed to produce automated narrations for highlight
packages at the 2023 US Open, Wimbledon, and Masters tournaments. In the same
vein, our solution was extended to create personalized content for ESPN Fantasy
Football and stories about music artists for the Grammy awards. These
applications were built using a common software architecture achieved a 15x
speed improvement with an average Rouge-L of 82.00 and perplexity of 6.6. Our
work was successfully deployed at the aforementioned events, supporting 90
million fans around the world with 8 billion page views, continuously pushing
the bounds on what is possible at the intersection of sports, entertainment,
and AI. | [
0.0215840768,
0.0479803048,
-0.009340683,
0.0217654295,
-0.0045214971,
-0.01723448,
-0.0152236614,
0.0141122006,
-0.0283490252,
-0.0286811348,
0.0121649038,
-0.0128879854,
-0.0396180414,
0.092782028,
0.0023239986,
-0.0799263716,
-0.0311582163,
-0.041779872,
0.0299879275,
-0.0187483355,
0.032522358,
0.0269977823,
-0.0082501555,
-0.0111647584,
-0.0634548813,
-0.0123148896,
-0.021107113,
0.003959287,
-0.0113878166,
-0.0269993898,
-0.0857678577,
0.0211742744,
0.0351989791,
-0.0266347453,
0.0000017989,
-0.0399324521,
0.0371634811,
-0.032990776,
0.018226184,
0.0493389554,
0.0460337587,
0.0128712999,
0.0129782883,
-0.0007702448,
-0.0411540419,
0.0226665903,
0.040041212,
-0.0040623676,
0.0624030344,
0.0675952658,
-0.0372372344,
-0.0344622731,
0.0290813129,
-0.0143175479,
0.0164340679,
-0.0580638871,
-0.0123627139,
0.0301589333,
0.0002123193,
0.0118327299,
-0.0017788712,
0.051054813,
0.0131090526,
0.003384738,
0.0428432189,
0.0598138496,
-0.0107658673,
0.0058464068,
0.0049114819,
0.0186460093,
0.0057798382,
-0.0192361418,
0.017350737,
-0.0030024061,
0.0052202963,
-0.0405609831,
-0.0443611518,
0.0521251708,
-0.0117062563,
0.0041266773,
-0.0353812613,
-0.0069784257,
-0.019156782,
-0.0174575392,
-0.0019942136,
-0.0483464263,
0.0407207124,
-0.0125511913,
-0.075361982,
0.0329784751,
0.0196669046,
-0.1067546532,
0.031395562,
0.0093132667,
-0.0393449143,
0.004913786,
-0.0472954363,
-0.032984294,
-0.0628014579,
-0.0518770628,
0.0579101555,
0.0008095995,
0.0204739049,
0.0420845821,
0.0161739644,
-0.0352620184,
-0.0058229235,
-0.0474414155,
-0.0053533181,
-0.0087298239,
-0.0426511839,
0.0013453187,
-0.0000633359,
-0.0037616843,
-0.0685068965,
-0.0502287783,
-0.0174357798,
0.0335542485,
0.0253011566,
0.0362598598,
0.0302621685,
0.0240022819,
-0.0069137197,
-0.0369005501,
-0.0143566271,
-0.0010937819,
-0.083623372,
0.0092311725,
0.0325641111,
-0.0294611417,
0.0144158602,
0.019776145,
0.0636919066,
0.020402275,
0.0172254145,
0.0291779172,
-0.0308877118,
0.0418458618,
-0.0115098758,
-0.0274383314,
-0.0229379013,
-0.0453575701,
-0.0430812538,
-0.0690509379,
0.0361415595,
-0.0180374105,
-0.0098329959,
-0.0235839803,
-0.0193165336,
0.0186825339,
-0.0156152584,
0.0274773929,
0.003303146,
0.048671931,
0.0270034801,
-0.0067563946,
0.0495472141,
0.0189088769,
0.0351772122,
0.0697835013,
0.04509582,
0.0167392381,
0.0484676436,
0.0498207361,
0.000734998,
-0.0271635372,
-0.0567815527,
-0.0067975805,
-0.0470326357,
0.0566517264,
-0.0031019736,
0.0537377745,
-0.0007464515,
0.0056777052,
0.0988921747,
0.0130159417,
0.0131258741,
0.0145510444,
0.1105050445,
0.0171933211,
-0.0014193495,
-0.0112561882,
0.0117200585,
0.0781689435,
0.0286128744,
0.0427836254,
0.0619506612,
0.0149067864,
-0.0322833098,
-0.0687584803,
0.0190418102,
-0.0129838577,
-0.0369186848,
0.0377034992,
0.0361532085,
-0.008462484,
-0.0279644113,
-0.0257459525,
-0.0060249222,
-0.053047739,
0.0591677576,
-0.0415520817,
0.0263650026,
0.1175308302,
0.0083703445,
-0.0137335602,
0.0405699015,
-0.0023390728,
0.0059818593,
0.059281107,
0.0252887066,
-0.0355507731,
0.0028285601,
-0.0417437851,
-0.0013650494,
0.0027382758,
0.0184172206,
0.0581551157,
-0.046836514,
0.0409114137,
-0.0095340619,
0.030183984,
-0.047633633,
0.0116940551,
-0.0403217934,
-0.0773775727,
0.0060800337,
-0.0157482252,
-0.0028849677,
0.0615980402,
-0.0451607034,
-0.007464936,
0.0220423359,
-0.0026983537,
-0.0123517578,
0.0377851948,
0.0061211027,
0.0143410889,
-0.0054705869,
-0.0447595157,
-0.0011926631,
0.0220652018,
-0.030677814,
-0.0383677743,
0.0342888534,
0.0122578349,
-0.0105267977,
-0.0065937894,
0.0047103683,
0.0198947154,
0.0191558823,
0.0197964627,
0.0414689817,
0.0427513681,
-0.0391753837,
-0.0015525593,
-0.0216078665,
0.0261040553,
-0.0514586978,
-0.0035885614,
0.0388356112,
0.0314601921,
0.0038606981,
0.0430392697,
-0.0240175687,
-0.0369620435,
0.0006507963,
-0.1101906747,
0.0161255393,
0.0037525538,
0.0005914257,
0.0299588963,
0.0322274752,
-0.0118191531,
0.0012973022,
-0.0347306095,
-0.0307675209,
0.016553428,
0.0105321994,
-0.0140454741,
0.0371562093,
0.0214036629,
-0.0177720487,
-0.0177607276,
-0.0021353576,
0.0334650278,
0.0295050517,
-0.0015893969,
-0.0533991233,
-0.012181188,
-0.0614380427,
0.0201820768,
0.0136064971,
0.0277991071,
0.0119575793,
-0.0204801019,
0.0512568727,
0.0683561191,
0.0150038991,
0.0186678357,
0.0086123627,
-0.0508521907,
0.0057738815,
0.0288263038,
-0.004899018,
-0.0115061589,
-0.0458044261,
-0.0199098494,
0.0544432737,
-0.0049786619,
0.0442371815,
0.0279451441,
-0.0392510109,
0.0321879126,
0.0019007863,
0.0172085147,
0.0043691145,
-0.0148495948,
-0.0179945119,
0.0378384441,
0.0149749722,
0.0086280983,
0.0178018548,
0.0037700033,
0.0137254884,
-0.0405596681,
-0.0549869537,
-0.0237628296,
0.082597889,
0.0146301184,
0.0544175506,
-0.032468386,
-0.0109434072,
-0.0155768627,
0.0333639458,
0.0632563755,
-0.0190550424,
-0.018616192,
-0.0018958932,
-0.0119257336,
0.0217269138,
-0.053779684,
0.0123853339,
-0.0092869559,
-0.0418864079,
-0.0530439354,
0.0655331239,
-0.0353972055,
-0.0540035218,
-0.039279718,
0.0245893337,
0.024100842,
-0.0266590249,
-0.0297255758,
0.0114243943,
0.0472713076,
0.0213357974,
0.0066298428,
-0.0593807101,
-0.0447865576,
-0.009332574,
0.0206205826,
0.0300763287,
0.0168550797,
0.0112298727,
-0.0164350197,
0.0015857916,
-0.0083702067,
-0.0451953709,
0.066582337,
0.0400614478,
-0.0256092325,
0.0417020656,
0.1133982241,
0.0494840816,
-0.0597159788,
-0.0194282774,
0.0382776447,
-0.0328326486,
-0.0053003351,
0.0437089615,
-0.1076823473,
0.0000130711,
0.0106879501,
0.0406372361,
0.0045055468,
0.0084626311,
-0.0376130305,
-0.0742091015,
0.0654136166,
0.0031625556,
0.0287499707,
-0.04658667,
-0.016693186,
-0.0056992299,
-0.0199442599,
-0.0352066569,
0.0063235126,
0.0003486504,
0.0430660695,
-0.0009772988,
-0.0049158246,
-0.0331993029,
-0.0059265941,
-0.0508684963,
0.0758648366,
0.031307172,
0.0830518827,
-0.0079374202,
-0.0300647225,
-0.0390028581,
0.087194778,
0.0292855371,
0.0091628451,
0.0807937682,
-0.0268150084,
0.0182206631,
-0.0263663623,
0.0221204273,
0.0409451909,
0.0131954746,
0.0744494423,
0.0408936664,
0.0377566926,
-0.0053571272,
-0.0208094604,
0.0109296683,
0.0117995925,
0.0293540433,
0.0329169109,
-0.0629632473,
-0.0109603852,
-0.0346417837,
0.0535330139,
-0.0958430022,
-0.0620841347,
-0.0240242556,
-0.0015565207,
-0.0850851461,
-0.0338367596,
-0.0139420433,
0.0051009888,
0.0284346957,
0.0211185887,
0.0151052214,
-0.0195857789,
-0.0363919958,
-0.0784731209,
-0.0350035168,
-0.0017081219,
-0.0344674028,
0.0015655444,
-0.0481036156,
0.0490802713,
-0.0482491367,
-0.0226720572,
0.0543382838,
-0.0271605924,
-0.0148949455,
-0.0056712711,
0.0262839701,
0.014821454,
0.0319268256,
0.0254443735,
-0.0314847566,
-0.0224599857,
0.0602418557,
-0.0136424508,
0.0410938486,
-0.0250903424,
0.0193700567,
-0.0081615765,
0.0030723938,
-0.0306624807,
0.0592161343,
-0.0222992525,
0.0232360214,
-0.0057810517,
-0.0020463113,
0.0105493991,
0.0327820964,
-0.0015143499,
-0.0265489388,
-0.0328519382,
-0.0291147679,
-0.0425908566,
-0.0892029107,
0.0035751609,
-0.0300990231,
-0.0051866784,
0.0249726381,
0.0562000573,
-0.0487487875,
0.04281253,
-0.0225665234,
-0.029105749,
-0.1027610153,
0.0122869071,
0.0327843614,
-0.0567498393,
0.0060360613,
-0.0071199718,
0.0023567514,
0.0211984292,
0.007050768,
0.016217839,
-0.0039064949,
-0.0486228503,
0.0299369041,
-0.0305853114,
0.0263132434,
0.0119980071,
-0.0469304658,
0.027303502,
-0.0135058276,
0.0632499382,
0.0901755244,
0.0056146542,
-0.000062723,
-0.0046693785,
-0.007267578,
0.0069177542,
0.0237614345,
0.0095564462,
-0.0609438866,
-0.0664853156,
0.0025332079,
-0.0075564869,
-0.0075165736,
0.0545637347,
-0.0036678792,
-0.0091373678,
0.0093529616,
-0.0635038987,
-0.0652453452,
0.0098705934,
-0.0272585899,
0.0003327424,
-0.0071390443,
0.021367101,
-0.0473956428,
-0.0042530568,
0.0027870662,
0.0134159382,
0.0021112689,
-0.0237820074,
0.0103321644,
0.0511672422,
0.007815781,
0.0079037985,
-0.034826491,
0.0187326539,
-0.093660742,
-0.0437074006,
0.0057171327,
-5.599987129e-33,
-0.0035153914,
-0.021966612,
0.0114082824,
0.0330406614,
-0.0584654808,
0.0048923362,
-0.0512635745,
-0.0306477249,
0.0351573415,
0.0164985731,
-0.0145953223,
0.0081772516,
0.0026092979,
0.010239535,
0.0554313362,
-0.0412818864,
0.0809637755,
-0.059836369,
-0.0409096293,
0.0549020432,
0.0238366071,
0.0344060622,
-0.0274050236,
-0.0897414312,
-0.0144592309,
-0.040217489,
-0.0357244611,
-0.0115710739,
0.0602435581,
0.0153008793,
0.0072252513,
-0.0053483448,
0.0076573216,
-0.0539254732,
-0.0065409252,
0.0206019469,
-0.0360520259,
-0.0194074605,
0.0018837978,
0.0041825403,
-0.005107821,
0.0085768895,
0.0259138327,
-0.0096846446,
-0.0260046627,
-0.018305935,
0.0547145084,
-0.0203033052,
0.0283197425,
-0.1068857014,
-0.0420634821,
0.0250180848,
-0.0181358866,
-0.0052181073,
0.0516277924,
-0.0084043443,
0.0110682854,
0.0304043982,
-0.0232803412,
0.0414469801,
-0.029511733,
0.0266301278,
0.0220650919,
0.0011760003,
0.0014513331,
0.0142489979,
0.0568457991,
-0.038743712,
-0.0875220001,
0.0304091293,
-0.0337908044,
0.0196298994,
0.0231533125,
0.0334079377,
0.0340905972,
-0.0103966584,
-0.0283516366,
0.0317346081,
0.026354162,
-0.0175314955,
-0.0137895057,
0.0432542972,
-0.0424839929,
0.037894737,
-0.0386543907,
-0.0277071111,
-0.0360415019,
-0.0660885349,
0.0180554017,
-0.0108235823,
0.01133544,
0.0297660157,
0.0032085162,
0.0147277983,
-0.0353999659,
0.0327612534,
-0.0235368274,
0.0920737013,
-0.0286059473,
0.0011340588,
-0.0186672732,
0.0106426431,
0.0316768326,
0.0426875949,
0.0135700582,
-0.006382714,
0.0082415845,
0.0922840238,
-0.0154968807,
0.0017529535,
0.0275488365,
0.007820637,
0.0271747671,
0.0022594344,
0.0163066871,
0.0370320193,
-0.0179079026,
0.0111267446,
0.0058606723,
0.0185904633,
0.0045171175,
-0.053553313,
0.0133246006,
-0.0084407423,
-0.043190673,
0.0205910262,
-0.0355408452,
-0.0107939187,
0.0106652807,
-0.0428376347,
-0.0500997491,
0.0093593905,
2.723e-7,
-0.0099412082,
0.0734649152,
-0.021110002,
0.0170975812,
0.0101454649,
0.0210209843,
-0.0098579386,
0.0394177623,
-0.0201613903,
0.0435729772,
0.0552252866,
0.0498193651,
0.0508286878,
0.0335814096,
-0.0983079374,
-0.0339725986,
-0.0609586835,
-0.0049432605,
-0.0604732521,
0.0178654622,
0.0547518544,
0.0340354107,
0.0627097785,
0.0199630372,
0.0528241284,
-0.0125493258,
0.0376419872,
0.0193805415,
-0.0232221168,
-0.0155371297,
-0.006540488,
-0.0071292492,
-0.0779349804,
-0.0126775298,
-0.0597494207,
-0.0031984949,
0.0449990407,
0.0417292379,
-0.0250236262,
0.0179400854,
-0.0087152775,
0.0111571215,
-0.0251091979,
0.0130827213,
0.023764126,
0.0158079751,
-0.0422931574,
-0.0490910076,
-0.0651244819,
0.007253523,
-0.0223705675,
-0.0170479044,
-0.0303664375,
0.0109450351,
-0.0142450305,
0.0007291751,
0.025413502,
-0.0401369892,
0.0297363084,
0.0061476133,
-0.0356326401,
0.0028278914,
-0.0296029039,
0.0211579818,
0.0121326642,
-0.0615919121,
0.0242268573,
2.136581976e-34,
0.0456733368,
0.0268568229,
-0.0505375564,
-0.0421476774,
-0.0026580277,
0.0045550773,
-0.0282899998,
0.000111533,
0.0240497179,
-0.0546142906,
-0.0234466903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00179v1 | De-identification is not always enough | 2024-01-31T21:14:01 | 2024-01-31T21:14:01 | Atiquer Rahman Sarkar, Yao-Shun Chuang, Noman Mohammed, Xiaoqian Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | For sharing privacy-sensitive data, de-identification is commonly regarded as
adequate for safeguarding privacy. Synthetic data is also being considered as a
privacy-preserving alternative. Recent successes with numerical and tabular
data generative models and the breakthroughs in large generative language
models raise the question of whether synthetically generated clinical notes
could be a viable alternative to real notes for research purposes. In this
work, we demonstrated that (i) de-identification of real clinical notes does
not protect records against a membership inference attack, (ii) proposed a
novel approach to generate synthetic clinical notes using the current
state-of-the-art large language models, (iii) evaluated the performance of the
synthetically generated notes in a clinical domain task, and (iv) proposed a
way to mount a membership inference attack where the target model is trained
with synthetic data. We observed that when synthetically generated notes
closely match the performance of real data, they also exhibit similar privacy
concerns to the real data. Whether other approaches to synthetically generated
clinical notes could offer better trade-offs and become a better alternative to
sensitive real notes warrants further investigation. | De-identification is not always enough: For sharing privacy-sensitive data, de-identification is commonly regarded as
adequate for safeguarding privacy. Synthetic data is also being considered as a
privacy-preserving alternative. Recent successes with numerical and tabular
data generative models and the breakthroughs in large generative language
models raise the question of whether synthetically generated clinical notes
could be a viable alternative to real notes for research purposes. In this
work, we demonstrated that (i) de-identification of real clinical notes does
not protect records against a membership inference attack, (ii) proposed a
novel approach to generate synthetic clinical notes using the current
state-of-the-art large language models, (iii) evaluated the performance of the
synthetically generated notes in a clinical domain task, and (iv) proposed a
way to mount a membership inference attack where the target model is trained
with synthetic data. We observed that when synthetically generated notes
closely match the performance of real data, they also exhibit similar privacy
concerns to the real data. Whether other approaches to synthetically generated
clinical notes could offer better trade-offs and become a better alternative to
sensitive real notes warrants further investigation. | [
0.0589867681,
0.0966954157,
-0.0162523538,
0.020732712,
-0.0502822474,
-0.0002894032,
0.0714457035,
0.0016843531,
0.0070047001,
-0.0106660016,
0.0095550036,
-0.0732505992,
-0.0167977177,
0.0235219896,
0.0423589274,
-0.011138848,
0.0357920155,
-0.0131268613,
0.0237364545,
-0.0235725082,
-0.0486910045,
-0.0102878148,
0.013312649,
0.0155569427,
-0.0078755869,
-0.0136332316,
0.0074892738,
-0.0186429285,
0.0141140968,
-0.0383166149,
-0.0124500487,
0.0797990039,
0.0045728283,
0.0567250811,
0.0000019576,
-0.0075484207,
-0.0494368486,
0.056471169,
-0.0711734071,
-0.0225277506,
0.0397145823,
-0.0426568687,
0.0096562924,
-0.026858449,
-0.0326521471,
-0.0596761815,
0.0314545259,
0.0312766507,
0.0350900814,
0.113641195,
-0.0247919913,
-0.0195867233,
0.0028276234,
-0.0378112569,
0.0482385568,
-0.0228445157,
0.0445811562,
-0.01514892,
0.0127934003,
-0.0004420998,
0.0379718207,
0.0285241324,
-0.0235671513,
0.0158990435,
0.0133528514,
0.0455532297,
-0.0197184179,
-0.0094198799,
0.0171045884,
0.0117986407,
0.0078464998,
-0.0181495622,
0.0665787607,
0.0201896876,
0.0238791462,
0.0048905304,
-0.0109508382,
0.0578791127,
-0.0384311527,
-0.0139128575,
0.0246464051,
-0.00515704,
0.0421697684,
-0.0360196158,
0.009746125,
-0.0664073825,
0.0238830578,
0.004570595,
-0.049365133,
-0.0550060682,
-0.0315275081,
-0.0509563833,
0.0378768817,
0.0051014358,
0.0191908665,
0.0117888153,
-0.1021396071,
-0.0702904612,
0.0458032601,
-0.052024167,
0.0239143651,
-0.0291502401,
0.0455337316,
0.0126800546,
-0.0158526376,
0.0171690993,
-0.0331783704,
0.0426447541,
-0.0045955149,
0.032940682,
-0.0014444587,
-0.0076425867,
0.0097577916,
0.0576293543,
-0.0283198953,
0.0036960165,
-0.0588722527,
0.0373297147,
-0.0225207768,
0.0593225174,
-0.0034320275,
0.0136965532,
-0.0544778071,
0.0069434843,
0.0165936835,
-0.1006705463,
0.015022886,
0.0041002668,
-0.0048723849,
-0.0527881309,
0.0258672014,
-0.0053654867,
0.0371368788,
0.0113526499,
-0.0086394306,
0.070639804,
0.034625072,
-0.0105541125,
-0.0090164319,
-0.0933745429,
-0.0080151781,
-0.0103690792,
0.0247000121,
-0.0517876595,
0.0365338959,
-0.0216981489,
-0.0242702235,
-0.0815353468,
0.002171699,
0.0352040231,
-0.0321402065,
0.0473400168,
-0.0549825318,
0.0059029767,
-0.015950771,
0.0377680324,
0.0381461643,
-0.0228866953,
0.0374818072,
-0.0155028095,
0.0239720456,
-0.0265230425,
0.0618467331,
-0.0063440995,
0.0454049893,
-0.0608744659,
0.0140060438,
0.0204830859,
0.0607472919,
-0.0147147588,
-0.0556624085,
0.0775247961,
-0.0011451594,
-0.0733552054,
0.0705131441,
0.0579684898,
0.0150147807,
0.0560850129,
-0.0335911773,
-0.0353890955,
-0.0087968688,
-0.0059106364,
-0.0136757446,
-0.0094549861,
-0.0187944416,
-0.0127269374,
-0.0185929872,
-0.0392145365,
-0.0050646169,
0.004371718,
-0.0105328802,
-0.0578323454,
-0.0098326607,
-0.0029426494,
-0.0036116659,
0.0287628509,
0.0233553182,
0.0117422314,
0.0336486436,
-0.051027108,
-0.0270182472,
-0.0648194999,
0.0061178133,
0.0699626058,
0.0726571009,
-0.0192521494,
0.0026014599,
-0.0458977148,
-0.0410027243,
0.0211513713,
0.0023321521,
-0.0169401243,
0.0346994288,
-0.0352741592,
0.0008173072,
0.0161927678,
0.0198670309,
0.0164323114,
0.0244110543,
-0.011951088,
0.0058774101,
-0.0218668673,
-0.0142070297,
0.0181199443,
-0.0612661317,
-0.0454802141,
0.0613781027,
-0.0013791621,
0.0593858548,
0.0498062558,
-0.0158524029,
0.0479816832,
0.033644069,
-0.0089782029,
0.0174702834,
-0.0374417938,
-0.0026491359,
0.0057726749,
-0.0327796042,
-0.027215926,
0.0115645723,
0.0032602709,
-0.0072577791,
-0.009374788,
-0.0320578031,
-0.0398954004,
0.0144113014,
-0.0192525014,
0.0257193949,
0.0509102754,
0.0124115953,
-0.037218973,
0.0341363735,
-0.0276555568,
0.0060120435,
-0.0153833078,
-0.0285335109,
0.0086930348,
-0.0553185046,
-0.0156406946,
-0.0053246622,
-0.0289189331,
0.0212093871,
-0.0100455098,
-0.0502934493,
0.0139284544,
-0.040264599,
-0.0498483256,
0.0166361593,
0.0047439183,
0.0302164871,
0.0184404124,
0.0241267532,
-0.0187513493,
-0.0349049196,
-0.0484190695,
-0.0498956181,
-0.0022228817,
0.0230683833,
0.0107583413,
0.0423085354,
-0.0110519109,
-0.0000123028,
-0.0268767215,
-0.0193190072,
0.0437494591,
-0.0151118096,
-0.0310410056,
-0.0125954524,
0.0240857173,
-0.0294552241,
0.0317744166,
-0.0156157948,
-0.0003663322,
0.0009422269,
-0.0085744336,
0.0256498735,
0.0385089703,
0.0133964671,
0.0217446964,
0.0283482391,
0.0220209602,
0.0163970087,
-0.0205153506,
-0.0567077361,
-0.0100333104,
0.0078715067,
-0.0557714999,
0.0087759793,
-0.0001598338,
0.0538774244,
-0.0426416919,
-0.0166671183,
0.0369329341,
0.0150449583,
0.0036208224,
0.0223834813,
-0.0058439388,
-0.0145043619,
-0.0072926483,
-0.0233045928,
-0.0438035429,
0.064780578,
-0.0087820869,
0.0580813996,
-0.0061795595,
-0.0319058709,
0.0314735025,
0.0457374193,
0.0337374657,
0.0322783813,
0.0530320778,
-0.0119057484,
0.0208496377,
0.0189932659,
0.0362349562,
-0.0815616176,
0.0139588844,
-0.0061744666,
-0.0076553384,
-0.0030019809,
-0.0297481213,
-0.0531320386,
-0.0722704828,
0.0292528328,
-0.0103404559,
-0.0031233332,
-0.0064514671,
-0.0025129409,
0.0030466984,
0.0029036226,
0.0736077577,
0.026025217,
0.0158039555,
-0.0289562736,
0.0042062197,
-0.0138426069,
-0.0836440474,
-0.004976721,
-0.0409677587,
-0.0054304581,
0.0810974836,
0.0213226378,
0.0783927217,
0.0203014016,
-0.0495010801,
-0.0381609686,
-0.0271296799,
-0.0379685834,
0.0421848595,
-0.0001166124,
-0.0252227969,
0.0023666199,
0.0736135915,
0.0074662515,
-0.0613545105,
0.0185970794,
0.0685791001,
-0.0303366035,
-0.0335056521,
-0.0246850699,
-0.0769702941,
0.0285332017,
0.0132098123,
0.0403289124,
-0.0781002715,
-0.0521985926,
-0.0163822751,
-0.0654314682,
0.0342403017,
0.0032477831,
-0.0095483409,
-0.0350695476,
-0.0369133912,
0.0210656896,
0.0142754726,
-0.0439429805,
-0.0254154038,
-0.0107804881,
-0.0189009961,
-0.002044606,
-0.0327631384,
-0.0830426142,
-0.0370365232,
-0.0507007428,
0.0696231872,
0.0481650606,
0.0241436344,
0.0153986393,
-0.0351578929,
0.0118079009,
0.0324329436,
-0.0203756467,
0.0349472016,
0.1032111421,
0.014491274,
-0.0093754726,
-0.0420577675,
0.070163846,
0.0242122225,
-0.0161444787,
-0.0096430816,
0.0006393181,
-0.0607586019,
-0.0329503603,
-0.0061030085,
-0.0022202788,
0.0419297963,
0.0460832231,
0.0086010825,
0.0173509251,
0.0130240601,
-0.0064038197,
0.0908297002,
-0.0033741104,
0.0115665207,
0.0356143303,
-0.0369053595,
-0.063945502,
-0.0590624623,
0.0145091936,
-0.0171195976,
0.0221293643,
0.0210900884,
0.0301188547,
0.0220719762,
-0.0321117863,
-0.0551131181,
-0.0088180825,
-0.0393250175,
-0.0053614737,
-0.0253548268,
-0.0419104844,
0.0232142285,
0.0013465089,
-0.0227730013,
-0.0064314455,
-0.0469976515,
-0.0492918007,
0.0395594984,
0.0566753075,
0.0240866914,
0.0002062784,
-0.000883955,
-0.0421684608,
0.0356937498,
0.0550141484,
-0.015077848,
-0.0188321173,
0.0061269188,
-0.0499484017,
-0.0211052131,
0.0091806427,
0.0007321546,
0.0077242614,
0.0671784282,
-0.0368838683,
-0.0252906885,
-0.0049960418,
-0.0076668863,
0.0481586866,
0.0326619223,
0.0170830153,
0.0341644064,
-0.0216014236,
0.0407514274,
-0.0738707259,
0.0147004705,
0.0028622602,
-0.0323415399,
0.0135407113,
0.0272082519,
0.0055245673,
-0.0097366767,
-0.034875337,
-0.0180995315,
-0.0650074631,
0.0084531168,
0.0513919145,
0.0059772069,
0.034215752,
-0.0245597549,
-0.0279451944,
0.0708913356,
0.0300862193,
0.033496201,
-0.0126700848,
0.0159964152,
-0.0108194938,
-0.0006030754,
-0.0119196083,
0.031735912,
-0.0452651531,
-0.0167166293,
-0.0289468523,
0.0259467047,
-0.0156266242,
0.0333071053,
-0.016968485,
-0.0488435142,
0.006933582,
-0.0372451171,
0.029341422,
-0.0194858853,
-0.0361702815,
0.0018633921,
-0.0075756796,
-0.0040285722,
0.0079071531,
0.1066970974,
0.037163619,
0.0532154664,
-0.035070762,
-0.0446252525,
-0.0536537431,
-0.0207151547,
0.0112710921,
-0.0128870206,
-0.0375174433,
-0.030707093,
-0.0428324193,
-0.0436512865,
0.038412597,
0.0133496746,
0.0225927848,
0.0069793183,
0.0183303915,
-0.0088745402,
0.0042757345,
-0.02660143,
-0.0440325476,
0.0469376743,
0.0023623572,
-0.0362927467,
0.0142403124,
-5.687182729e-33,
0.0234574489,
-0.0232036822,
-0.0362105407,
0.0077954582,
0.0097651714,
0.028157169,
-0.0317341909,
-0.015476292,
0.0296063162,
-0.0251628496,
-0.0390329957,
-0.000775758,
0.0156025449,
0.0465938151,
-0.0387667604,
-0.0300115384,
0.0370620638,
-0.0087619564,
-0.0069617904,
0.058212664,
0.0337114856,
0.028791612,
0.0198106803,
-0.0860839412,
0.0383463427,
-0.0404894352,
-0.0052587418,
-0.0126187224,
-0.0427227281,
0.0559543595,
-0.0232450254,
-0.0383826643,
0.0315883756,
0.0109473476,
-0.0026560703,
0.0446682684,
-0.0630552545,
0.0114216935,
-0.0096133053,
-0.0519871004,
0.0203442574,
-0.1024549454,
0.0311529059,
-0.0543339215,
-0.0198484473,
-0.0076711616,
-0.0053328504,
-0.031755276,
-0.0338692516,
-0.0813078582,
0.0119175529,
0.0282805469,
0.0022845697,
0.0168751702,
0.0447457172,
-0.0145390229,
-0.0164758749,
-0.0402671359,
-0.0201518517,
0.0256898589,
0.0576099344,
-0.0021115523,
-0.0246394835,
-0.0018339973,
0.0242939759,
0.0391800217,
0.0593345203,
0.0288529545,
-0.0083936155,
0.0311270822,
-0.0592928529,
0.0319914073,
0.0647395402,
0.063412115,
0.0388940684,
-0.0426482335,
-0.0700182393,
0.03173244,
-0.0904137418,
-0.0346521959,
0.0967464969,
-0.0122858202,
-0.0643964037,
0.0044722087,
-0.0218005851,
-0.0283859409,
-0.0100308172,
0.0229758918,
-0.0150160845,
0.0265556592,
-0.0529661551,
0.0268430803,
0.0105037158,
-0.0403220505,
-0.0031359736,
-0.0106921624,
0.0657562464,
-0.0132255126,
-0.0397869386,
-0.0340931341,
-0.0135253798,
-0.0201825202,
0.0631266683,
-0.0172912348,
0.0448028073,
0.0244263131,
0.0531242862,
-0.0239180177,
-0.0670514926,
-0.0088023683,
0.0210717302,
0.0590059198,
0.0182315372,
0.0157951955,
0.0557025336,
-0.0067984187,
0.0288805328,
0.0275646746,
0.0058999439,
0.0236616805,
-0.0484306552,
0.0312106572,
-0.0218206216,
-0.0037403838,
0.0240863152,
0.0126420008,
-0.0000309251,
0.0517091155,
0.0799643993,
-0.0071027526,
0.0246773679,
-0.0261420924,
2.827e-7,
0.0278626811,
-0.0178087708,
0.0464657955,
-0.0335617438,
0.0432159305,
0.0265750233,
0.0346298106,
0.0804376081,
0.0031568042,
-0.0279549509,
0.0074813021,
-0.0209161844,
0.0560874678,
0.0437729694,
-0.0688261315,
-0.0028500578,
-0.0527735204,
-0.0104275253,
-0.0428109206,
0.0083074318,
0.03455,
0.0600848757,
-0.0133564156,
-0.0083307987,
-0.0136895804,
-0.0114258043,
0.0094536599,
-0.0441283435,
-0.0116506591,
0.0179575123,
0.051058922,
0.0280358922,
0.0159284528,
0.0418012179,
-0.0487795919,
-0.0169072002,
-0.0291640759,
0.1187335327,
0.0056298887,
0.0490333848,
0.0363919511,
-0.0621034242,
-0.0025445882,
0.0100285886,
0.0339982212,
-0.027412517,
-0.0394278355,
-0.0043467139,
-0.0194218513,
-0.052590102,
0.0424919203,
-0.015912775,
0.00208157,
0.0107959164,
0.0114311529,
0.0308387727,
0.0244533774,
-0.0457717441,
-0.0124506708,
-0.0141284661,
-0.04498633,
0.0041328678,
0.0519643798,
-0.0102468543,
0.0249453224,
-0.0349091403,
0.0483963639,
2.573265729e-34,
-0.0192989279,
0.0076375296,
-0.0393649265,
-0.0148272598,
0.0128939673,
-0.0207667816,
0.0506633595,
0.0211358108,
0.0138288448,
-0.059493605,
-0.0244364366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00160v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00160v2 | Emergency Department Decision Support using Clinical Pseudo-notes | 2024-01-31T20:31:56 | 2024-04-29T21:37:34 | Simon A. Lee, Sujay Jain, Alex Chen, Kyoka Ono, Jennifer Fang, Akos Rudas, Jeffrey N. Chiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the Multiple Embedding Model for EHR (MEME), an
approach that serializes multimodal EHR tabular data into text using
pseudo-notes, mimicking clinical text generation. This conversion not only
preserves better representations of categorical data and learns contexts but
also enables the effective employment of pretrained foundation models for rich
feature representation. To address potential issues with context length, our
framework encodes embeddings for each EHR modality separately. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of MEME by applying it to several decision support tasks
within the Emergency Department across multiple hospital systems. Our findings
indicate that MEME outperforms traditional machine learning, EHR-specific
foundation models, and general LLMs, highlighting its potential as a general
and extendible EHR representation strategy. | Emergency Department Decision Support using Clinical Pseudo-notes: In this work, we introduce the Multiple Embedding Model for EHR (MEME), an
approach that serializes multimodal EHR tabular data into text using
pseudo-notes, mimicking clinical text generation. This conversion not only
preserves better representations of categorical data and learns contexts but
also enables the effective employment of pretrained foundation models for rich
feature representation. To address potential issues with context length, our
framework encodes embeddings for each EHR modality separately. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of MEME by applying it to several decision support tasks
within the Emergency Department across multiple hospital systems. Our findings
indicate that MEME outperforms traditional machine learning, EHR-specific
foundation models, and general LLMs, highlighting its potential as a general
and extendible EHR representation strategy. | [
0.0006266379,
0.0302802771,
0.0029810276,
-0.0327122509,
0.0080831693,
0.0570142306,
0.0081448499,
0.0075317053,
-0.0000236139,
-0.0494700596,
0.0028022379,
-0.0607162528,
-0.0329457931,
0.060876444,
0.0327018723,
-0.0579852164,
0.0165016707,
0.0219070613,
0.0169927496,
0.0473610535,
0.0031195062,
0.0150868297,
-0.0134424586,
0.0758593082,
-0.0195916593,
0.0273847338,
-0.0608047433,
0.019802561,
0.0458738059,
-0.0752281398,
-0.0104091782,
0.0214955024,
0.0702420622,
-0.0345262475,
0.0000019056,
0.0091935992,
-0.0366081148,
0.010824739,
-0.0533173159,
-0.077741459,
0.034523949,
-0.0962854996,
0.014027101,
0.0143714743,
0.0062034181,
-0.06945768,
0.0311670434,
0.0614436977,
0.0393095464,
0.0489279293,
-0.0257006865,
-0.0004174447,
0.0053882692,
-0.0263373237,
0.0106253456,
0.0007968055,
-0.0102563081,
-0.0188012477,
0.0098889619,
-0.0105429031,
-0.0008262981,
0.0229435954,
0.0273456722,
0.0638082772,
0.0550369583,
0.0635009184,
0.0264844969,
0.0328402407,
-0.0209273621,
0.0788990632,
-0.0018615,
0.0237206016,
0.0195899475,
-0.0077052978,
-0.0078324648,
-0.0069911932,
-0.0254468247,
-0.0203112438,
-0.0169070326,
-0.0090098707,
-0.0166145414,
0.0455323495,
0.0270878319,
-0.022082502,
-0.0015917328,
-0.0542978384,
0.0061442559,
-0.0404752865,
0.0087397741,
-0.01770656,
-0.0061143041,
-0.0174798854,
0.0212999899,
0.0416251458,
-0.0497602001,
0.008910995,
-0.0392228849,
-0.0025461756,
0.0686460882,
-0.01611536,
0.0640426949,
0.021164434,
-0.018321462,
0.015540842,
-0.0143479332,
-0.0121896602,
-0.0445055179,
0.0186890904,
-0.0328713283,
0.0214202125,
-0.0509348623,
-0.0129237743,
-0.0191288944,
0.0271799825,
-0.0012874099,
-0.0128220674,
-0.0533157364,
0.0196903218,
0.0259838365,
0.0372157134,
0.0134918494,
0.0422984213,
-0.0256652422,
0.0438106917,
-0.0180176254,
-0.0011333491,
0.0113717476,
-0.0005230953,
0.0195206702,
0.0134456344,
0.0340680294,
0.0169214141,
0.023132246,
0.0046875924,
-0.0218976513,
0.0729035363,
-0.0003670939,
-0.02704731,
-0.035445556,
-0.0416281372,
-0.0211127475,
0.0035026616,
0.0276288409,
-0.0419530161,
0.0474465042,
0.0073902127,
0.0030172723,
-0.0272662565,
0.0080642458,
0.005549924,
-0.0290544201,
0.0540938824,
-0.0583255589,
0.0040195715,
0.0572668351,
0.0379907228,
0.0015405518,
0.0048266421,
0.0213329643,
0.0106576001,
0.0078483382,
-0.0609881245,
0.005933906,
-0.0119787073,
-0.0048825946,
-0.0653293282,
-0.0089325756,
0.0026872277,
-0.0211748574,
0.0683572665,
-0.0042581209,
0.011369749,
-0.0357449874,
-0.016360607,
0.0397720151,
0.0678345188,
0.0436677113,
-0.0089948317,
0.0560893528,
-0.0163409319,
-0.0429321118,
-0.0253659394,
-0.0177266579,
0.0313965604,
0.045637846,
0.0038991226,
0.0176135693,
-0.0223976076,
-0.0519835539,
-0.0345175937,
-0.0300499052,
-0.0254943315,
-0.0310845226,
-0.0235038009,
0.0170127545,
-0.0596116558,
-0.0568378158,
0.0371066481,
0.0239911694,
-0.0058868513,
-0.0158829503,
-0.0415569171,
-0.0193211157,
0.1481338292,
0.0236945022,
-0.0339410231,
-0.0446059033,
-0.0566521548,
0.0375537053,
0.0060816058,
0.029692227,
-0.0213160757,
0.0287829954,
-0.0584215708,
-0.0345126055,
0.0047450624,
0.0379327647,
-0.0036644766,
-0.0616222024,
0.0362579972,
0.0025225317,
0.004049046,
-0.0168781374,
0.0214145854,
-0.0401045792,
-0.0185186509,
-0.0163451582,
0.0308854524,
0.0152550535,
0.0261356719,
-0.011228662,
0.0230219774,
0.0380124822,
-0.0435167663,
-0.0337083489,
-0.007616716,
-0.0769947618,
-0.0064474712,
-0.0169515479,
0.0030701756,
0.0273827594,
-0.0280405898,
-0.037832465,
-0.0194875095,
-0.058938209,
-0.0565722063,
0.0266022105,
-0.0296549965,
0.0048822877,
0.094394058,
-0.0259750597,
-0.0272312555,
0.036034178,
-0.0448344015,
0.005263092,
-0.0020974877,
0.0001591871,
0.0230057444,
-0.0344670042,
0.0069630598,
0.0065691094,
0.0157644246,
0.0319463685,
-0.0269472264,
0.0089118741,
-0.0226312038,
-0.0043298947,
-0.1512935013,
-0.0141454954,
0.0086173946,
-0.0130097754,
0.0348787606,
-0.0207374245,
0.0120398002,
-0.0300224461,
-0.0574758574,
-0.019969834,
0.0248927735,
0.0240639243,
0.0268615671,
0.0395322926,
-0.0108292177,
-0.0074630338,
-0.0082612867,
-0.0281497426,
0.0309883431,
-0.0384072661,
-0.0315456763,
-0.0346105993,
-0.0499774665,
-0.0031170491,
-0.0367665812,
0.0020459783,
-0.0008275195,
0.0203180686,
-0.0270014629,
0.024233453,
0.0000923343,
-0.0001441324,
0.0912733525,
0.0233670156,
-0.0157932173,
-0.0297871605,
0.0060874214,
-0.0406199694,
0.0331109799,
0.0135805542,
-0.053240601,
-0.0101352138,
0.0287500825,
0.0058363662,
0.0447401702,
-0.0359837078,
-0.0312936381,
0.0179560278,
0.0134516759,
-0.0921339169,
0.0376224145,
-0.0206968337,
0.0239171479,
-0.0024772827,
-0.0304389242,
0.0302886833,
0.0172873568,
0.0396312028,
-0.0129555892,
-0.0520822331,
-0.0493753478,
0.0330589712,
-0.0197242871,
0.030818902,
0.0003068861,
-0.0147428354,
0.0064683794,
0.0282710046,
-0.0424433611,
-0.0569714196,
0.0333410539,
0.0135945352,
-0.0178632624,
-0.0105114486,
-0.0379060917,
-0.0404741764,
-0.0445067547,
-0.0027023908,
0.0143937273,
-0.0284338593,
0.0344022065,
-0.0684368014,
0.0180795509,
-0.0092084873,
0.0859801993,
0.047031451,
-0.0334402919,
-0.0101786647,
0.0718044564,
0.0209816583,
0.0244488697,
-0.0086713731,
-0.0449564196,
0.0445108488,
0.068421565,
-0.0123661589,
-0.0069769644,
-0.0310202874,
0.0383309573,
-0.0315860584,
-0.0079378439,
-0.020868117,
0.0322125927,
0.0124305477,
-0.0371403769,
0.0326451287,
0.0725518465,
0.0229806937,
-0.0596298985,
0.02492176,
-0.0189869627,
-0.0161664337,
-0.0095173847,
0.0130337039,
-0.0091769509,
-0.0341407731,
-0.005581656,
0.0107341921,
0.0073133851,
-0.0347320735,
0.0365676582,
-0.0226843487,
0.0560577363,
-0.0061052497,
-0.0488968939,
-0.0275942665,
-0.0126357945,
0.0050616348,
0.0179057941,
-0.0115520461,
-0.0186355654,
-0.0350839086,
-0.0364458039,
0.0185110793,
-0.0183605887,
-0.083366923,
-0.0349010639,
-0.038440384,
0.0357884504,
0.0362052694,
0.0221784506,
-0.0188430902,
-0.0328418463,
-0.0139904562,
0.0256763436,
0.0244001672,
-0.0117740035,
0.0581219494,
-0.0181260258,
-0.0095607322,
-0.0285305455,
0.0092033735,
-0.0140294936,
-0.0458486751,
0.0064149038,
0.0971371606,
-0.0552814417,
-0.0044533731,
-0.0709381923,
-0.0057031899,
0.0434502885,
0.0427790582,
-0.005831568,
-0.043915581,
-0.0188534167,
-0.0044684238,
0.0558354445,
0.0258812346,
-0.0033105107,
0.0432021767,
-0.0465672687,
-0.0414745547,
-0.0325235911,
-0.0393928438,
0.0407046601,
0.0186990686,
0.0011360586,
-0.0032875289,
0.006703455,
-0.02050131,
-0.062377885,
0.0173408892,
0.0170428343,
-0.0072692563,
-0.057942152,
-0.0427975804,
0.0361450575,
0.0030648371,
-0.0008921044,
-0.0189228114,
0.0308269896,
0.0206281543,
-0.0151959341,
0.0742142648,
0.0131677818,
-0.0275946576,
0.0512196682,
-0.0157691482,
0.0485424735,
0.043089278,
-0.0552712344,
-0.0165485628,
-0.0090485234,
-0.0114456918,
-0.0409657136,
0.0052278368,
-0.0172333792,
0.0446173474,
-0.0221046712,
0.0332305431,
-0.0160825104,
-0.0173333753,
-0.0022576486,
-0.0182550158,
0.00071264,
-0.0343493745,
-0.0268514678,
-0.0232392903,
0.0285113659,
-0.0345439725,
0.0244038273,
-0.030497618,
0.0176408123,
0.0003026775,
0.0020750633,
0.0096244486,
-0.002778304,
0.0065497686,
-0.0036805109,
-0.0577634722,
0.0363294594,
0.0049021845,
0.010849677,
0.001634207,
0.0287355278,
-0.034481708,
0.0419562832,
-0.0229821224,
0.0086512836,
-0.0165049825,
0.0796429589,
-0.0072150263,
0.0295547117,
-0.0165407918,
0.0844187066,
-0.0159819163,
-0.0439357795,
-0.0320270807,
-0.0033002566,
0.0376524702,
0.0209390894,
-0.0011505943,
-0.0258731507,
-0.0045176549,
-0.0334317982,
0.0370444022,
0.0158559158,
0.0218359567,
0.055801563,
0.021857813,
-0.0178649053,
-0.0167797841,
0.0609811209,
0.0321897939,
0.0331671312,
-0.0046277549,
-0.032630831,
-0.0578141063,
0.0150932884,
0.1087720469,
0.0373481065,
-0.0438044928,
-0.0332137793,
-0.0650920495,
-0.0427263007,
0.0724912882,
-0.0087007741,
-0.0467118062,
-0.0097735804,
0.0565279052,
0.0150205353,
0.0260165557,
0.0228297133,
-0.0139232036,
0.0160172302,
-0.0413915813,
-0.0002929463,
0.0061599188,
-5.725718005e-33,
-0.0088046892,
-0.049908895,
0.0348208621,
-0.0629159957,
0.0229607243,
0.0492990799,
-0.0084717236,
0.0081796544,
0.0544014014,
-0.0118199214,
0.0085163638,
-0.0358267613,
-0.0010418878,
0.0168200172,
0.0207252968,
-0.0433593169,
0.0400517359,
-0.0078096366,
-0.0035314718,
0.0259979889,
0.0247575678,
0.0544217303,
0.0297891926,
-0.1073036566,
-0.0216154121,
0.0039845821,
-0.0045778914,
-0.0124301193,
0.0093791066,
0.0632856041,
-0.0691067874,
0.0408139229,
0.0410648398,
-0.0431216918,
-0.0025733218,
0.0533292331,
-0.0709073022,
-0.0123463776,
-0.0025739709,
-0.045991797,
-0.0425640717,
-0.0714293197,
0.0136531396,
-0.0144748613,
0.0157879759,
-0.0246987212,
0.0131449159,
-0.0184810665,
-0.0316710658,
-0.0270082224,
-0.01823695,
0.0460563861,
-0.0030086162,
0.0025343359,
0.0117643615,
0.0230587088,
-0.0038218931,
0.0306162126,
-0.0576020256,
-0.0352557413,
-0.0285483692,
-0.0380575471,
0.0023337356,
-0.0257857684,
-0.0489824787,
0.0912505761,
0.0017176229,
-0.0101997936,
-0.0726753622,
0.0424334966,
-0.0436106212,
0.0898484364,
0.0319790728,
0.0543690063,
0.0450311899,
-0.015923569,
-0.0700536445,
0.0651864558,
-0.0666524917,
0.0171992946,
0.0573284514,
-0.0119468905,
-0.0597732626,
0.0039104582,
0.010121299,
0.0164665505,
-0.0031279642,
-0.0507844351,
0.071364902,
0.0341003649,
0.0114864828,
0.0571132116,
0.030294368,
0.0135972686,
0.018844815,
0.0128802061,
0.0389211364,
0.0214909799,
-0.0177647211,
-0.0258228462,
-0.0457533747,
-0.0351483151,
0.0518632606,
-0.032646399,
0.0391976386,
0.0143633429,
0.0512821302,
0.012428184,
-0.0348287933,
0.0091613969,
0.0530265868,
-0.0048371833,
-0.0097255101,
0.0145061277,
0.054277353,
-0.0081287548,
-0.0149510354,
0.0474331006,
-0.026026329,
-0.0007697644,
-0.0141205927,
-0.0583926439,
0.0083359163,
0.0395554006,
0.0201703813,
0.0028333014,
-0.0530131161,
-0.002156774,
0.0112464316,
-0.0301147755,
0.0140888439,
0.0074531632,
2.542e-7,
0.0580606759,
-0.0030068688,
0.0374886505,
-0.038105689,
0.0375517681,
0.015385068,
-0.0074346568,
0.0361096412,
-0.008406586,
-0.0437801667,
0.0659929141,
0.0323356017,
0.0491002649,
0.0598365627,
-0.0349591561,
-0.0562409423,
-0.0516444631,
0.0011973003,
-0.0255416911,
0.0171685573,
0.1232269853,
0.0756068826,
-0.0351943262,
-0.0426254086,
0.0067965579,
0.0259156562,
0.0690493882,
-0.0574827679,
0.032500457,
-0.0361241959,
-0.0153501835,
0.0487403274,
-0.0364098065,
0.0306581017,
-0.0104302149,
-0.0123463599,
0.0327653997,
0.0915517509,
-0.041071631,
0.0038865474,
0.0121371858,
-0.0059776632,
-0.0063513354,
-0.0158510655,
0.053834185,
-0.0578924567,
-0.022529548,
0.0311706606,
-0.0463533476,
0.0146687301,
0.0436953902,
-0.0322245434,
-0.037616469,
0.0170798581,
0.0265923869,
-0.0122122187,
-0.0198199935,
-0.0758749098,
0.0159673449,
0.0661955774,
-0.0199012738,
-0.0229171757,
0.0033812108,
-0.0138152158,
0.0404734723,
-0.0802732557,
-0.0152161298,
2.391536139e-34,
0.0282992758,
0.006232027,
0.0080668461,
0.035286136,
0.0234259032,
-0.022300072,
0.0417922921,
-0.0238422882,
0.0306305643,
-0.064526014,
-0.024854403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00159v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00159v2 | Dolma: an Open Corpus of Three Trillion Tokens for Language Model Pretraining Research | 2024-01-31T20:29:50 | 2024-06-06T18:46:40 | Luca Soldaini, Rodney Kinney, Akshita Bhagia, Dustin Schwenk, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Ben Bogin, Khyathi Chandu, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Valentin Hofmann, Ananya Harsh Jha, Sachin Kumar, Li Lucy, Xinxi Lyu, Nathan Lambert, Ian Magnusson, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Abhilasha Ravichander, Kyle Richardson, Zejiang Shen, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Oyvind Tafjord, Pete Walsh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Iz Beltagy, Dirk Groeneveld, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information about pretraining corpora used to train the current
best-performing language models is seldom discussed: commercial models rarely
detail their data, and even open models are often released without accompanying
training data or recipes to reproduce them. As a result, it is challenging to
conduct and advance scientific research on language modeling, such as
understanding how training data impacts model capabilities and limitations. To
facilitate scientific research on language model pretraining, we curate and
release Dolma, a three-trillion-token English corpus, built from a diverse
mixture of web content, scientific papers, code, public-domain books, social
media, and encyclopedic materials. We extensively document Dolma, including its
design principles, details about its construction, and a summary of its
contents. We present analyses and experimental results on intermediate states
of Dolma to share what we have learned about important data curation practices.
Finally, we open-source our data curation toolkit to enable reproduction of our
work as well as support further research in large-scale data curation. | Dolma: an Open Corpus of Three Trillion Tokens for Language Model Pretraining Research: Information about pretraining corpora used to train the current
best-performing language models is seldom discussed: commercial models rarely
detail their data, and even open models are often released without accompanying
training data or recipes to reproduce them. As a result, it is challenging to
conduct and advance scientific research on language modeling, such as
understanding how training data impacts model capabilities and limitations. To
facilitate scientific research on language model pretraining, we curate and
release Dolma, a three-trillion-token English corpus, built from a diverse
mixture of web content, scientific papers, code, public-domain books, social
media, and encyclopedic materials. We extensively document Dolma, including its
design principles, details about its construction, and a summary of its
contents. We present analyses and experimental results on intermediate states
of Dolma to share what we have learned about important data curation practices.
Finally, we open-source our data curation toolkit to enable reproduction of our
work as well as support further research in large-scale data curation. | [
0.0329471715,
0.0873082206,
-0.0118095018,
0.0115334708,
-0.0159260575,
0.0289439317,
0.0159328189,
0.020118583,
-0.0071063186,
-0.0593205914,
-0.0190208126,
-0.0161727741,
-0.0126696033,
0.0278266519,
0.0434667543,
-0.0379770286,
0.0636275485,
-0.0441922955,
0.0095881233,
-0.0176201519,
0.0188847203,
0.0288839769,
0.0136546846,
0.0421670675,
-0.0227761175,
-0.0157893486,
0.009645272,
0.0016193321,
-0.0260595735,
-0.0237558447,
0.025709277,
0.0594681688,
0.0108822957,
0.0711237937,
0.000001898,
-0.0641646087,
-0.0177601576,
-0.0025312488,
-0.0130715193,
0.014431688,
0.0715840533,
-0.0173106492,
-0.0114977006,
0.0313082598,
-0.033866737,
-0.0331672542,
0.0544626415,
0.0031436095,
0.0477647409,
0.0788519382,
-0.0113264639,
-0.036921449,
0.0461503156,
-0.0111963879,
-0.0156843346,
0.0141394371,
0.0272978991,
0.0053840298,
0.0023435401,
-0.0003932762,
-0.0117022032,
0.0222001709,
-0.0029018011,
-0.0078776488,
0.0018770896,
0.0451043397,
-0.0570357591,
-0.0670442954,
-0.0069868402,
0.0749716982,
0.0134246005,
-0.0649119169,
0.02790788,
0.0063393065,
-0.026934538,
0.0060390909,
-0.0413789861,
0.0064862338,
0.0297182556,
0.0401259363,
0.0136922058,
-0.0390184,
0.0452081859,
0.00058745,
-0.0259742439,
0.0529996976,
0.0337558612,
-0.0453818813,
0.0212242026,
0.0197501201,
-0.0068800473,
-0.089084357,
0.033857286,
-0.0215379708,
-0.005195213,
0.0150490385,
-0.0656325892,
-0.0822198316,
0.0498071574,
-0.0148357404,
0.033122547,
0.0047294274,
-0.0492895655,
0.0162360668,
0.0369997211,
0.0010508805,
-0.0135518257,
0.0136073055,
-0.0488999933,
-0.0224511437,
-0.0413496606,
0.0078036967,
-0.0526194125,
0.0087214587,
-0.01856534,
-0.0075155101,
-0.0288372021,
0.0048025036,
0.0140043981,
-0.0048458367,
0.0380506292,
-0.0161191393,
-0.0237619709,
0.0064457278,
0.0037865511,
-0.0070381481,
-0.0432549343,
0.0326019041,
-0.0032831822,
-0.0844294503,
-0.0087356353,
0.0089873858,
0.0182422772,
-0.0622915365,
0.016850559,
0.0157657769,
0.02215885,
-0.0232831296,
-0.017497668,
-0.0119153904,
-0.0093212621,
-0.0500378534,
-0.00263218,
-0.0892169178,
0.0304701887,
0.0189447608,
0.0325016193,
-0.0540006235,
-0.0156037314,
0.0093813138,
-0.0492102019,
0.0533617958,
-0.0895466134,
-0.0005935163,
0.0189214163,
-0.0259233303,
0.0332025662,
0.0723739192,
0.0369476303,
0.0024388137,
0.0787654743,
-0.0154028703,
-0.0124999378,
0.0562760495,
0.0473691523,
0.0151711348,
-0.0026381672,
0.0124616995,
-0.003410971,
0.0196455345,
0.0445165224,
0.0451929383,
-0.0200011376,
-0.0193423908,
0.0350421481,
0.0798383504,
0.0182721764,
0.0217273068,
0.041588895,
0.0159250926,
0.0263056606,
-0.0564496815,
-0.0357187018,
-0.0325811245,
-0.0091054626,
0.0120477211,
0.0173458979,
0.0631030872,
-0.0142928129,
-0.0115702366,
-0.0477210879,
-0.0192463454,
-0.0049457983,
-0.0103802606,
0.0526805818,
0.0038290792,
-0.0129260216,
0.080040738,
0.0671412572,
-0.0659388751,
0.0327491164,
-0.0091815358,
0.0224595703,
0.0300195292,
0.0372614749,
-0.0491315313,
-0.0114196818,
-0.0165157486,
0.0427688994,
0.0406937227,
0.056206651,
-0.0174065642,
0.0023732879,
-0.0469801873,
-0.0042854249,
0.0051807263,
0.0234136079,
0.0023573518,
0.0156106008,
-0.0029307574,
-0.0031760077,
-0.0571251996,
-0.0556486547,
0.053223528,
-0.0403269157,
0.0053346185,
-0.0304745995,
-0.0375656933,
0.0336725302,
0.0325687155,
-0.0315912478,
0.0069220089,
0.0510022119,
-0.0087309377,
0.0153044574,
0.0385499783,
-0.034880314,
-0.012077895,
0.0708042383,
-0.0263747741,
-0.0045037875,
0.0571926013,
-0.0395699143,
-0.038852822,
0.0262143351,
-0.0075455154,
0.0903407037,
-0.0394146033,
0.0286575742,
-0.0064228252,
0.0075334315,
0.004989618,
0.0283353496,
-0.0129374359,
0.0131795397,
0.0105732502,
-0.0185435712,
0.00945214,
-0.0477995351,
-0.0393078364,
0.0147439502,
-0.0126274517,
0.0293700825,
0.0154179279,
-0.0094274618,
-0.0820044652,
0.0009544828,
-0.1102269441,
-0.0259064585,
-0.0395627469,
0.0287996996,
0.0228465404,
-0.007463214,
-0.0354792178,
-0.0058223205,
-0.0109609589,
-0.0152477063,
-0.004646854,
0.0157838278,
0.0214995295,
-0.0176331922,
0.0114535242,
-0.0580094829,
-0.0383156687,
-0.0156009477,
0.0475301109,
0.012516276,
-0.0075567737,
-0.0152860535,
0.0130766919,
-0.0193321388,
0.0208581723,
0.0142390756,
-0.0396967791,
0.0028405581,
-0.0178088211,
0.0317885391,
0.0076578474,
-0.0048451414,
0.0152541045,
0.0372539163,
-0.0260857586,
-0.0581109338,
-0.007484314,
-0.003099856,
-0.0143447304,
-0.0494133756,
-0.0274520144,
0.0288601872,
0.0735321417,
-0.023802286,
-0.0207595266,
-0.048658248,
0.0167094264,
-0.0545043759,
-0.0255617667,
-0.0216228459,
0.0181057509,
-0.0310862754,
0.044095844,
-0.0266389232,
-0.0462568291,
0.0446347445,
-0.054650072,
-0.0056409868,
-0.0527942628,
0.011777238,
-0.0276026931,
0.0099868728,
0.0169117413,
-0.0001142592,
0.0210795868,
-0.0131485024,
-0.0008970579,
0.0384781957,
-0.0068353163,
-0.0123224212,
0.0184637699,
-0.0206361786,
0.0330905691,
0.0015579015,
-0.0312816054,
-0.0208096597,
-0.0606505014,
-0.0629920512,
0.017797377,
0.0301835574,
-0.0254687462,
-0.0331356078,
-0.0264646746,
-0.0160076879,
0.0517934039,
0.0158889536,
-0.0008462045,
-0.0030556337,
0.0235450361,
0.0431127436,
0.0049517872,
0.0246349666,
-0.0258990563,
-0.0262109097,
0.0317279994,
0.0557250716,
-0.0075251781,
-0.0346909463,
0.035767749,
0.059437003,
-0.060244754,
-0.0082501583,
-0.0002359571,
0.0413495414,
-0.025743667,
-0.0311725251,
0.1191496849,
0.038709946,
-0.0597736984,
0.0007963437,
0.0004663922,
0.0247686822,
0.0250238441,
-0.0001232696,
-0.1044009477,
-0.0241096783,
0.0101431962,
0.0264831074,
0.018647274,
-0.0345640294,
-0.002970991,
-0.1184839681,
0.0212394018,
0.0056930408,
-0.0406783223,
0.0187929422,
-0.0498061925,
-0.0189106017,
-0.0559951104,
0.0271882731,
0.0169666056,
-0.0304776821,
0.0216212515,
0.0355394632,
0.0015664009,
-0.0517499149,
0.0344144069,
-0.0598848127,
0.0643822402,
0.0479543023,
0.0451037921,
-0.0247046854,
-0.0152400471,
0.0287804604,
-0.0169367287,
-0.0276233349,
-0.0182307847,
0.0420729481,
0.0010953648,
-0.0152109545,
0.0037421559,
0.0435900465,
-0.0484254509,
-0.0250097997,
0.0100891534,
0.0777531713,
0.0234182272,
-0.0046394262,
-0.0143041592,
-0.022242358,
0.0122091575,
0.0790103599,
0.0188121106,
-0.0429881029,
-0.0190343466,
-0.0159042291,
0.0073589683,
-0.0465058498,
-0.0127860066,
0.0010334328,
-0.0247237906,
-0.0169134438,
-0.1016868129,
-0.0377898775,
0.0333204903,
0.0218333285,
0.02611655,
-0.0126337381,
0.0252997503,
-0.0147363404,
-0.0441424437,
0.0716267228,
-0.0336479731,
0.0062566488,
-0.107494019,
-0.0577660948,
0.0168759059,
0.0153385382,
-0.0387080833,
-0.0122212702,
-0.0966679901,
-0.0701850057,
0.0449641533,
0.0466082171,
0.0238004066,
0.0326152183,
-0.0120944707,
-0.0802380666,
0.0478503555,
0.0375555046,
-0.0735373497,
0.0169130806,
0.0389152318,
-0.0192676634,
0.0048038648,
0.0258675572,
-0.0486937985,
0.0177420117,
0.0136386221,
0.000103895,
-0.0147556737,
0.0047716112,
0.0233067032,
0.0363571532,
0.0692139566,
-0.0440203398,
-0.0142611284,
-0.061939884,
0.0129754972,
-0.0241924934,
0.0090625845,
-0.0381440558,
0.0321381241,
0.0301973,
-0.0194109473,
-0.011325663,
0.0617286712,
-0.0365607738,
0.0467808507,
-0.0552615449,
0.0077866502,
0.0375445783,
0.0348167606,
0.0506016873,
-0.0110912956,
-0.0026077509,
-0.0042784284,
-0.0442537405,
0.0399069712,
-0.046793174,
0.0001750673,
-0.0088560851,
0.014984021,
-0.0006427877,
0.0450741388,
-0.036925111,
-0.0128756063,
-0.0089380089,
0.0232910421,
0.0709291622,
-0.0361439735,
0.1053006276,
-0.0239965077,
-0.0243637376,
-0.0409042574,
0.0101885926,
0.0024092826,
-0.0154521465,
0.0122599201,
0.0018093025,
-0.0531968288,
0.0026317765,
0.0968585908,
-0.0003989379,
0.0321997181,
0.0429362357,
0.0187391508,
-0.0026279225,
-0.0020513872,
-0.0031675191,
0.0234304965,
-0.033103805,
-0.0316778496,
-0.0448812433,
-0.0690789595,
0.0060184668,
0.0129744513,
-0.0173370317,
0.0173397195,
0.0377452746,
0.0652111098,
-0.009103748,
0.0286063142,
-0.0354497097,
-0.0132603664,
-0.0043740552,
-0.0381107628,
-0.0052325879,
-6.494533555e-33,
0.009757122,
0.0326257348,
0.0060705435,
-0.0259952713,
-0.0200595371,
-0.0094797192,
-0.0128264623,
-0.007466617,
-0.016713243,
0.0165638197,
-0.0365308225,
0.0138772018,
0.0257151704,
0.0281202607,
0.0145566557,
0.0229290854,
0.0432767197,
-0.0155826686,
-0.0272981934,
0.0137048615,
0.0545506887,
0.0350363255,
0.0594018549,
-0.0391461402,
0.0325294212,
-0.0098138135,
0.0102698002,
0.0105151152,
0.0146551672,
0.0567338429,
-0.040624056,
0.0420427471,
0.0102191679,
-0.0093026049,
-0.0532990843,
0.0153245432,
-0.0746026114,
-0.0317917727,
0.0517494231,
0.0111934198,
0.017864652,
-0.0182283875,
0.0352806561,
-0.0202278346,
-0.0115569597,
0.0109611535,
0.0365938172,
0.0097816074,
-0.0134102982,
-0.0201655719,
-0.0619033612,
0.0264252238,
-0.0214331336,
0.0079852436,
0.0532476641,
0.0211267304,
0.0189460516,
0.0357726291,
-0.050417874,
0.0357686691,
0.0133656198,
0.0369770266,
0.0650491789,
-0.0045541311,
0.0314490013,
0.0640060231,
0.0240523294,
-0.0089125475,
0.0226703417,
0.0537165552,
0.0572979711,
0.0293907374,
0.0225250144,
0.0696886927,
0.0398614295,
-0.051445365,
-0.0579654314,
-0.0046009873,
0.0031703636,
0.0298551265,
-0.0225722548,
0.0165550113,
0.0034664825,
-0.0231798235,
-0.0416501872,
-0.0258607324,
-0.0225741267,
-0.0120818699,
0.0194290932,
-0.0119938292,
-0.0341621153,
0.0034421228,
0.0188790485,
-0.0294384342,
-0.0478331223,
0.0369528867,
0.0007499633,
0.0073459558,
-0.011564495,
0.0454389118,
-0.0852495432,
-0.0295394305,
0.0049601896,
-0.0004528769,
0.0265891068,
-0.0077509969,
0.0164350383,
0.0206740238,
-0.042016916,
0.0173875354,
-0.0272446908,
0.0069692889,
0.0129285492,
0.0038417436,
0.0552730523,
0.0420547314,
0.0189088173,
0.0188821629,
0.0572588891,
0.0005321411,
-0.0440097973,
0.011023175,
0.0031822803,
0.0192761682,
-0.0130991843,
-0.0268006139,
-0.0561689958,
0.0187312998,
0.0768836811,
-0.0466615036,
-0.0184311196,
-0.0036994684,
2.471e-7,
0.0612486005,
0.055626858,
0.0426283665,
-0.0057917526,
0.0052779196,
0.0126713822,
-0.0276913047,
0.0465388149,
0.0199942328,
-0.0003067118,
-0.029860286,
-0.0120886909,
0.0535995215,
0.048810523,
-0.0993838906,
-0.0240957774,
-0.0847461671,
0.0240889452,
-0.0756871253,
-0.0038178624,
-0.0051759831,
0.1093950644,
0.0188563503,
-0.0141934343,
-0.0125970272,
-0.0499803387,
0.0465363786,
-0.0439770184,
0.0033224865,
0.0424270406,
0.0231989361,
0.0088396482,
0.0230469722,
-0.0164900701,
-0.0338473171,
0.0125770159,
-0.0089264512,
0.0366027616,
0.0046140533,
0.0018312522,
-0.0042917663,
-0.0375331491,
-0.0325485319,
-0.0721199811,
0.0595380925,
-0.0286922771,
-0.0105206491,
-0.0385878235,
-0.0248925053,
-0.0126536759,
0.0176877547,
-0.0465804897,
-0.0026168644,
0.0513450205,
0.0234328955,
-0.0038742907,
-0.0321487635,
-0.0815423876,
-0.0448180772,
0.0094844084,
-0.0472763777,
-0.0585537665,
-0.0232731942,
-0.0085628815,
0.0184513722,
-0.0281147994,
0.0377151966,
2.170676822e-34,
0.0406937823,
0.0053551849,
0.0063126134,
0.0360328294,
0.0200549476,
-0.0493809879,
0.0400506891,
0.0209966265,
-0.0290404763,
-0.0745820925,
-0.0001134106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00157v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00157v3 | Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning: Progresses and Challenges | 2024-01-31T20:26:32 | 2024-04-05T04:06:51 | Janice Ahn, Rishu Verma, Renze Lou, Di Liu, Rui Zhang, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for assessing the fundamental
cognitive capabilities of human intelligence. In recent times, there has been a
notable surge in the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) geared towards
the automated resolution of mathematical problems. However, the landscape of
mathematical problem types is vast and varied, with LLM-oriented techniques
undergoing evaluation across diverse datasets and settings. This diversity
makes it challenging to discern the true advancements and obstacles within this
burgeoning field. This survey endeavors to address four pivotal dimensions: i)
a comprehensive exploration of the various mathematical problems and their
corresponding datasets that have been investigated; ii) an examination of the
spectrum of LLM-oriented techniques that have been proposed for mathematical
problem-solving; iii) an overview of factors and concerns affecting LLMs in
solving math; and iv) an elucidation of the persisting challenges within this
domain. To the best of our knowledge, this survey stands as one of the first
extensive examinations of the landscape of LLMs in the realm of mathematics,
providing a holistic perspective on the current state, accomplishments, and
future challenges in this rapidly evolving field. | Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning: Progresses and Challenges: Mathematical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for assessing the fundamental
cognitive capabilities of human intelligence. In recent times, there has been a
notable surge in the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) geared towards
the automated resolution of mathematical problems. However, the landscape of
mathematical problem types is vast and varied, with LLM-oriented techniques
undergoing evaluation across diverse datasets and settings. This diversity
makes it challenging to discern the true advancements and obstacles within this
burgeoning field. This survey endeavors to address four pivotal dimensions: i)
a comprehensive exploration of the various mathematical problems and their
corresponding datasets that have been investigated; ii) an examination of the
spectrum of LLM-oriented techniques that have been proposed for mathematical
problem-solving; iii) an overview of factors and concerns affecting LLMs in
solving math; and iv) an elucidation of the persisting challenges within this
domain. To the best of our knowledge, this survey stands as one of the first
extensive examinations of the landscape of LLMs in the realm of mathematics,
providing a holistic perspective on the current state, accomplishments, and
future challenges in this rapidly evolving field. | [
-0.0276292004,
0.1076483801,
-0.019378446,
0.0562469214,
-0.081465289,
0.0205678977,
0.0115698352,
0.0306063276,
-0.024931496,
-0.0220510121,
0.0031612127,
-0.0237080697,
0.0064135832,
0.0094880229,
0.0099818716,
-0.0243001226,
-0.0039302628,
-0.0804165155,
0.0246684942,
-0.0209525451,
-0.0412114821,
-0.0050566969,
-0.0141206626,
-0.0017967256,
-0.0558823384,
-0.07401409,
0.0299870465,
-0.0602929033,
-0.006315554,
-0.018014824,
-0.0507085137,
0.043274004,
0.0283741988,
0.0424419306,
0.0000020615,
-0.0651092529,
-0.0169982966,
0.0071094916,
-0.048948165,
0.0020647682,
-0.0165312681,
-0.0234581083,
0.0047026756,
0.016345283,
-0.0769343972,
0.0139504839,
0.00151053,
-0.0024939862,
0.0558402874,
0.0243807845,
-0.0000665593,
-0.0624417514,
0.0426863506,
0.0075214156,
0.0125895087,
-0.0377548635,
0.0467169546,
0.0332561769,
0.0336098485,
-0.010714964,
-0.0206867885,
0.0289878771,
0.0380497947,
-0.0262384247,
-0.0605314076,
-0.010108036,
-0.0304252729,
0.0251501203,
-0.004117189,
0.0441575386,
0.0068851784,
0.0049085394,
0.0115294699,
0.0165471081,
-0.0020388053,
0.0373038091,
-0.071390979,
0.0575846508,
-0.0066015851,
0.0004480652,
0.0014302869,
-0.0037642184,
0.0105640292,
0.0267938264,
-0.068679221,
0.1195785701,
0.0222854298,
-0.0404595546,
-0.027565293,
-0.0284408312,
-0.1085139439,
-0.0506269448,
0.0404382795,
0.0779522508,
0.0184960365,
0.027008703,
-0.0282140803,
-0.0543409325,
-0.0261288974,
-0.0299490038,
0.0381490663,
0.0512305982,
0.0512011684,
0.0279493071,
0.0009206668,
0.0740619525,
-0.0197839476,
0.0101472037,
-0.0186562371,
0.027070133,
-0.0103596188,
-0.0274900049,
-0.0447358489,
0.0510178618,
0.0076434487,
0.0232865103,
-0.040251065,
0.0186446477,
-0.049455002,
0.0296113454,
-0.0151356375,
-0.0377818272,
0.0379162654,
-0.0410622805,
-0.0206320547,
-0.0252012126,
-0.0279449057,
0.0166142005,
-0.0319958106,
0.007076975,
0.0025177677,
0.0322041065,
-0.0153716682,
-0.034457922,
0.0305709671,
0.0837749168,
0.0500581488,
0.012799249,
-0.0065011983,
-0.0310940631,
0.0168885868,
-0.1054506004,
0.0068412581,
-0.0979809985,
0.0591828637,
0.0285824277,
-0.0419510305,
-0.048379086,
0.0059466842,
0.0063939989,
0.0226221252,
0.046803128,
0.037360359,
0.0434616543,
0.0521300733,
-0.0182832219,
-0.0011667241,
0.0216715354,
0.0491163656,
-0.0275813732,
0.0133346142,
-0.000058491,
0.0064848936,
0.0563097484,
0.0160532743,
-0.0066997595,
-0.0353160687,
0.0090700993,
0.0261336304,
0.0451411903,
-0.0464951396,
0.0824411884,
-0.0130058629,
-0.0466676392,
0.0170862321,
0.0884691775,
-0.0209848024,
0.0059392652,
0.0308369193,
-0.0041527813,
0.063017711,
-0.0072037308,
-0.0449549332,
0.0030520798,
-0.0504267551,
-0.0086107627,
-0.0085025337,
0.0326060392,
-0.0138294883,
-0.0790897459,
-0.0311528724,
0.0055030002,
-0.0202069543,
0.0150585268,
0.0992197692,
-0.0492230169,
0.0157396048,
0.0296966322,
-0.0129494937,
-0.0098586641,
-0.0143723693,
-0.0519614965,
0.0273389183,
-0.0190980714,
0.044370681,
-0.0566979982,
-0.0244147237,
0.0065893689,
0.0304080714,
0.0052873897,
-0.0023706914,
-0.0042006602,
-0.0437488556,
-0.0049618976,
0.0125201587,
0.0048551704,
0.0138054201,
-0.0192111433,
0.0276121944,
0.0050157802,
-0.0082304226,
-0.0217037667,
0.0107634859,
0.0151509009,
-0.0434348881,
-0.0088039385,
-0.0035478021,
0.0035714761,
0.0203697924,
-0.0068893963,
0.0103762522,
0.05036496,
0.0319874026,
-0.0473360047,
-0.0161234364,
-0.0169540923,
-0.0294235926,
-0.0099690501,
0.0689948872,
-0.0400893502,
-0.0291878488,
0.0037506078,
-0.0280373562,
-0.0136660598,
0.0790604353,
-0.0454114489,
-0.0021668179,
-0.0187102091,
0.0413726903,
-0.0072379275,
-0.0264902413,
-0.0275748279,
0.0880583003,
0.0127475318,
0.0249927491,
0.0278106984,
-0.0135111175,
0.0161608066,
-0.0136531899,
-0.0101784253,
0.0019330052,
-0.0148413833,
0.0195603184,
-0.0310698692,
-0.001742542,
0.0131996609,
-0.0064953147,
-0.003858482,
-0.0096901217,
-0.0032400761,
0.0665486827,
-0.0138700325,
-0.0641877502,
-0.0128002213,
0.013695878,
-0.0218968615,
-0.0048299721,
0.0380569138,
-0.0043369355,
0.0230011549,
0.0197358597,
-0.0219058692,
0.0060081868,
-0.0414106734,
-0.0561316833,
0.0654527992,
0.0115329288,
0.0321110897,
-0.0442242324,
0.0376895703,
-0.0508415885,
0.0184688326,
-0.019048756,
0.0473794378,
0.0169804003,
-0.0295855049,
0.0464911126,
0.0587768294,
-0.0150892474,
0.0305699967,
0.0178038552,
-0.0386822075,
-0.0282852184,
-0.0084490376,
-0.0283217598,
0.0181734618,
-0.0083321389,
-0.0345733352,
-0.011611497,
0.0642429367,
-0.0287172496,
-0.0331881493,
-0.0128175858,
0.064163141,
-0.0519170798,
0.0272393357,
-0.0363818556,
-0.0044566588,
-0.0003496332,
0.0638575032,
-0.0070412061,
-0.0374730527,
0.0478322022,
-0.0090935603,
0.0238633826,
-0.0567825809,
-0.0010183275,
-0.094671838,
0.0425018072,
-0.0044529191,
-0.0075196396,
-0.0349543169,
-0.0223719142,
-0.0021497414,
-0.0104779676,
0.0203285255,
-0.0123717505,
0.0696099699,
-0.0394938029,
0.0331709348,
-0.0095060151,
-0.0492458157,
-0.0128756035,
0.0197754838,
-0.0155738285,
0.0194830466,
0.0012714826,
-0.0259992629,
-0.0382050276,
0.0383204557,
0.0160774533,
-0.0114970766,
-0.0319601148,
-0.0109160636,
-0.0148460083,
-0.0125430683,
0.0120700886,
0.0278043561,
0.0509528853,
-0.038171757,
0.0065046302,
0.0424089134,
0.0405277498,
0.0178841017,
0.0136267347,
0.0360961966,
0.0211525429,
-0.0406450145,
-0.0383050106,
0.0325724706,
-0.0181743968,
-0.0578809045,
-0.0029280253,
0.0815077126,
0.0518084168,
0.0005769112,
-0.0011827132,
-0.0651390851,
-0.0245685168,
0.0165986773,
0.021493895,
-0.0799237266,
-0.0095269987,
0.0027791774,
-0.0391071811,
-0.0048963707,
-0.0487622656,
0.0000994389,
-0.1069815755,
0.0372269973,
0.0187435094,
-0.0223123599,
-0.0181795303,
-0.0299178157,
0.0230427813,
0.0220249351,
-0.0184541587,
-0.0035798871,
-0.0161918588,
-0.003697894,
0.027538484,
-0.0277705118,
-0.017949,
0.0134812202,
-0.0125442855,
-0.0416315719,
-0.0045624943,
0.0449773334,
-0.0267083608,
-0.0671972707,
0.0011534819,
0.0449432023,
-0.0316904448,
-0.0113817994,
-0.0382136777,
0.0170510728,
0.009752986,
-0.0244995784,
0.0512531884,
-0.0649565831,
-0.0389247201,
0.0598907024,
0.1384682953,
-0.0244898051,
0.0130239092,
-0.0236986931,
0.005531007,
-0.0508167073,
0.0636188164,
0.0039981254,
-0.016894104,
-0.0582503453,
-0.0366437323,
-0.0284017473,
-0.024164876,
-0.0266576353,
0.0118005723,
0.0508474931,
0.0119458586,
-0.0130718471,
0.0152182784,
0.067993179,
0.0217632595,
0.0193910133,
-0.0217475109,
0.0338902175,
-0.0042648767,
-0.030295508,
0.0164306741,
-0.0513028838,
0.0480750948,
-0.0613215305,
0.0559748672,
-0.0031788321,
-0.0311704427,
-0.0388773941,
0.0061350102,
-0.0957759544,
-0.0351113975,
0.0010583814,
0.0166660771,
0.0225169826,
-0.0410863757,
0.0081964592,
-0.0189583804,
0.003257486,
0.0182719994,
-0.0321240686,
0.0259118211,
-0.0020907796,
0.0271274168,
0.0036458438,
0.0248362962,
0.0329021141,
0.0233225431,
0.0077205249,
0.0400544107,
-0.0419020578,
-0.0245360602,
0.0190444756,
0.0592404604,
-0.0255235974,
0.0555042848,
-0.0155268582,
0.0119656464,
0.0062050414,
-0.0592955053,
-0.0210682452,
-0.0541537926,
-0.0056294943,
-0.0254547149,
0.0029731137,
0.011091074,
-0.0150252692,
0.0310051683,
0.0206599701,
0.0025395958,
0.0741848573,
-0.0338910744,
0.0031203092,
0.0489055552,
-0.014874002,
0.0598532073,
0.0083431173,
-0.0221679937,
0.0563030206,
0.0032565186,
0.0569108687,
0.0294776745,
0.0218278207,
-0.0561747439,
-0.0266254731,
-0.0241999906,
-0.1053017974,
0.0277057029,
0.0436067618,
0.0454256535,
0.0429920405,
-0.0293907635,
-0.0466353595,
-0.0122132394,
-0.0093263667,
0.005720824,
0.0479698963,
-0.00452164,
0.0222193208,
0.0413729921,
0.0130811986,
-0.0440311953,
0.0370728225,
-0.0334087312,
0.014495424,
0.028111171,
-0.001015145,
-0.0023801273,
-0.0316208974,
-0.0047121011,
-0.0215217844,
-0.0108279306,
0.0131336609,
-0.1045077443,
-0.0843024328,
0.0162927303,
-0.0020275819,
-0.0255756192,
0.0039021331,
0.0280418824,
0.0604494028,
-0.0175166689,
-0.0048806304,
0.0122594172,
0.0290768892,
-0.0680409893,
-0.0307746585,
-0.0112782773,
-5.187166003e-33,
-0.0213200469,
-0.0773864463,
0.0465773456,
0.0207619444,
0.022084808,
-0.0403261594,
-0.0003776377,
0.0518486984,
-0.0023112057,
-0.0080795716,
-0.0045712935,
0.0066303127,
0.0082392609,
0.0022330207,
-0.0039966651,
0.0056031183,
-0.0227533076,
-0.0310905483,
-0.0183377769,
-0.0161553547,
0.017185159,
-0.040698275,
0.0376287624,
-0.0455850102,
-0.015023334,
0.0079822922,
0.0164545402,
0.0590408817,
-0.0601021536,
0.0747140273,
-0.0179534815,
0.0245574787,
0.0140291508,
-0.005454327,
-0.0204867683,
0.0166774932,
-0.0331552923,
-0.0164223686,
0.0233109649,
-0.0044973493,
-0.0268567298,
-0.053653691,
0.0202662498,
0.0290718041,
-0.0614136383,
-0.0220925063,
0.024843106,
-0.0454274826,
0.0090395752,
-0.0047424813,
-0.0268442277,
0.0424784012,
-0.0286238492,
-0.0012764214,
0.0218751524,
0.0084218942,
-0.035310559,
0.013149742,
0.0000338016,
0.035711199,
0.0404366404,
-0.0082279537,
0.0478450544,
-0.0374783948,
0.0038241087,
0.0119244009,
0.0174880903,
-0.0452848375,
0.0034453874,
-0.0121405032,
0.032011345,
0.0663598031,
0.0692932606,
-0.0050150985,
0.0334213749,
0.0360850096,
-0.0544932038,
-0.0144923571,
-0.0043285075,
0.0314113759,
0.0486610346,
-0.0005337753,
-0.0296952482,
-0.0313721597,
-0.0413055271,
0.0467357785,
-0.0587788746,
0.0036229652,
-0.0025530662,
-0.0381171927,
-0.003356202,
0.033492066,
0.0455647036,
-0.04760658,
-0.0341453329,
0.0049648667,
0.0319057442,
0.0417299941,
0.0084060598,
0.0471296459,
-0.0485347547,
-0.0134851197,
-0.0369638763,
-0.022558704,
0.016899772,
-0.0013497552,
-0.0093379915,
0.0010661737,
-0.0110164974,
-0.0052146986,
-0.0352466851,
0.0060541416,
0.0461522043,
0.0333832093,
0.0508950017,
0.0243379548,
0.0239076074,
0.0233916659,
-0.0231285207,
-0.0440520085,
-0.0049989317,
0.0350177623,
-0.0121825775,
0.0377922058,
-0.0058603697,
-0.0135005387,
-0.0249603614,
-0.0188368,
0.0325901359,
-0.0432272963,
0.0087473681,
0.007135062,
2.604e-7,
0.0378772467,
0.0615852624,
0.0193820857,
0.0278484114,
0.0241777152,
-0.0045979433,
-0.0234162882,
-0.0438146368,
0.0144158714,
0.0245158132,
0.003967558,
0.0800052434,
0.0264175236,
0.0444525629,
-0.0217791591,
0.0299203694,
-0.0159833301,
-0.0296211764,
-0.0841853842,
0.0364642628,
0.0757281035,
0.0433958247,
0.015149273,
-0.0046247332,
-0.0327558853,
-0.063866429,
0.0406204537,
-0.0110593969,
-0.0092723696,
0.0276902616,
-0.0062151663,
-0.033517614,
0.018707782,
0.0346092619,
0.0295006093,
0.023126699,
0.0266110022,
0.0629220009,
0.0295328181,
0.0354826264,
-0.0197207592,
-0.0159248952,
-0.0111723701,
-0.0098047061,
0.0649124309,
-0.0949950591,
-0.0818072632,
0.0135189006,
0.0193098336,
-0.046780508,
0.0004928686,
0.0020559798,
0.0609297082,
0.0027947738,
0.0392005257,
-0.0261698999,
0.0314801596,
-0.0566602312,
0.0350813344,
0.0338423587,
-0.0725707784,
-0.0440667942,
-0.0423945002,
-0.0051862393,
0.0405463539,
-0.0276444163,
-0.0180998147,
2.890823462e-34,
0.035542421,
-0.0026968056,
0.0154514592,
0.0364818722,
0.0312595777,
-0.0042055184,
-0.0505067371,
0.0362931341,
0.0120359426,
-0.10328345,
0.0048588715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00149v1 | The Impact of Language Adapters in Cross-Lingual Transfer for NLU | 2024-01-31T20:07:43 | 2024-01-31T20:07:43 | Jenny Kunz, Oskar Holmström | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modular deep learning has been proposed for the efficient adaption of
pre-trained models to new tasks, domains and languages. In particular,
combining language adapters with task adapters has shown potential where no
supervised data exists for a language. In this paper, we explore the role of
language adapters in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer for natural language
understanding (NLU) benchmarks. We study the effect of including a
target-language adapter in detailed ablation studies with two multilingual
models and three multilingual datasets. Our results show that the effect of
target-language adapters is highly inconsistent across tasks, languages and
models. Retaining the source-language adapter instead often leads to an
equivalent, and sometimes to a better, performance. Removing the language
adapter after training has only a weak negative effect, indicating that the
language adapters do not have a strong impact on the predictions. | The Impact of Language Adapters in Cross-Lingual Transfer for NLU: Modular deep learning has been proposed for the efficient adaption of
pre-trained models to new tasks, domains and languages. In particular,
combining language adapters with task adapters has shown potential where no
supervised data exists for a language. In this paper, we explore the role of
language adapters in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer for natural language
understanding (NLU) benchmarks. We study the effect of including a
target-language adapter in detailed ablation studies with two multilingual
models and three multilingual datasets. Our results show that the effect of
target-language adapters is highly inconsistent across tasks, languages and
models. Retaining the source-language adapter instead often leads to an
equivalent, and sometimes to a better, performance. Removing the language
adapter after training has only a weak negative effect, indicating that the
language adapters do not have a strong impact on the predictions. | [
-0.0182222407,
0.0252986904,
-0.0074245026,
0.038017597,
-0.0187424216,
0.0169365183,
0.0741624385,
-0.0367974415,
-0.0303527508,
-0.0178506467,
-0.062597163,
-0.0416960716,
-0.0195659138,
0.0084149223,
-0.0267638471,
-0.0250546075,
0.0694544017,
-0.026385814,
-0.048412133,
0.0155844577,
-0.025308203,
0.0080288993,
-0.0035586588,
0.0125267087,
0.042261906,
0.0163587853,
-0.0203996357,
0.0056762891,
-0.01001886,
0.0007732033,
-0.028307531,
0.0328415856,
0.0246879607,
0.0456382744,
0.0000020665,
-0.04079023,
-0.0425384827,
-0.0005456182,
-0.0618828274,
-0.0138758887,
0.0375980474,
-0.0625168681,
0.0214708932,
-0.009198511,
-0.0117196292,
-0.0644698292,
0.0650262833,
0.0532596856,
0.0142763909,
0.0782864913,
-0.013575254,
-0.0120759066,
0.0029370268,
-0.024044862,
0.0276283901,
-0.0811280385,
0.0044097756,
0.0110655269,
-0.0063219676,
-0.0230425037,
-0.0445744991,
0.0261490848,
0.0444200374,
0.0123274634,
-0.0240524169,
0.004877388,
-0.0436247215,
-0.0247046668,
-0.0194337592,
0.0770312101,
-0.0509839542,
-0.0300972145,
-0.0440600701,
-0.0129861012,
-0.0116889048,
-0.0209857747,
-0.0646190047,
-0.0075264387,
0.0432995483,
0.003270787,
0.0482525565,
0.0095706834,
0.0592486784,
-0.0098100053,
-0.0358473882,
0.0854896978,
0.0110372799,
0.0108612776,
0.0484844781,
0.0251889769,
0.026397936,
-0.0407363176,
-0.003405821,
0.0283717457,
-0.0050067641,
0.0214856081,
-0.0574826524,
-0.0513736755,
-0.0172596853,
-0.0291279405,
0.0558270626,
0.0690869838,
-0.0507914834,
0.0556776673,
-0.0677032545,
0.0406623892,
-0.0038852189,
0.0151860574,
-0.0498660728,
-0.0584430285,
-0.0695130676,
0.0124923522,
-0.0230713282,
0.036169704,
-0.0359527394,
0.0143998228,
-0.0172125865,
0.0063759857,
-0.0093534738,
-0.0392076448,
-0.0134364441,
-0.016914336,
-0.0836976767,
-0.0235819537,
-0.015849527,
0.0922152475,
-0.0207893979,
0.0289264843,
-0.0204397589,
-0.0576112568,
-0.0273984224,
0.0292375516,
0.0314115398,
-0.0519721545,
0.0348048881,
0.0518229902,
-0.0300877094,
-0.0295553114,
-0.0211638212,
0.0201896988,
0.0050288937,
-0.0749620125,
0.0432563089,
-0.0442383103,
0.0406792685,
-0.0181124769,
0.0212816279,
-0.0486848168,
-0.0212294869,
-0.0293762498,
-0.0173634794,
0.0888246223,
-0.0007383274,
-0.0160394218,
-0.0237570778,
-0.0159029234,
-0.0081312805,
0.1076888219,
-0.0140983779,
0.0080077006,
0.0117217675,
-0.0521485619,
-0.0222887862,
0.0151832579,
0.0086925477,
0.0130800521,
-0.0100755468,
0.0059565227,
0.0103866477,
-0.0117918393,
0.0481652282,
-0.0213594604,
-0.0174778458,
-0.0065411706,
0.0071740616,
0.0056005074,
0.0120750805,
0.0353382602,
0.0589511506,
-0.0352507792,
-0.029943591,
0.0450573638,
-0.0582870059,
0.0376261994,
-0.0072083413,
-0.0149042504,
-0.0324996002,
0.0331644975,
-0.0509304963,
-0.0126602715,
0.023628626,
-0.0161243919,
0.0309584066,
0.0170321111,
0.0744837895,
0.0357487053,
-0.0306782164,
0.0710470527,
0.0425479487,
-0.0291051902,
0.0449892096,
-0.0103889657,
-0.0017209179,
0.0156218251,
-0.0213135537,
-0.0063989977,
-0.0604057088,
-0.0085343672,
0.030969087,
0.0199205205,
0.0513555557,
0.001447006,
0.0891300142,
-0.0520526208,
-0.0273097157,
-0.0432356335,
0.0039203623,
0.0585182458,
-0.0416398533,
0.0314193256,
0.0212991834,
-0.0651374981,
-0.0334459394,
0.0168774389,
-0.0836286992,
-0.0311247781,
0.0482306965,
0.0278334208,
0.0055012447,
0.0065365518,
-0.0010516259,
-0.034326572,
0.0119697666,
-0.0506864376,
-0.0034756714,
0.0421469584,
-0.0348482765,
-0.0325607546,
0.0360506773,
-0.0250627622,
-0.0104180975,
0.036185354,
-0.0206758231,
-0.0681390539,
0.0496172309,
0.0365857184,
0.0397704914,
-0.0276214555,
0.0167207625,
-0.0417163372,
0.0660715774,
0.0118631506,
0.0058991062,
0.0471536107,
-0.0160853937,
0.0072863717,
-0.0453087986,
0.0377948098,
0.007662666,
-0.0437994525,
0.0273677576,
-0.0424000621,
-0.0125376219,
0.0104589919,
0.0185006652,
-0.0297777485,
0.0183507632,
-0.0919129476,
0.0278568156,
-0.0349181779,
0.0126266358,
0.0273448639,
0.0466501489,
-0.0025682268,
-0.03110178,
-0.0274628941,
0.0156656485,
0.0059685335,
0.0199208297,
0.0039653969,
0.0125077283,
0.0208035987,
-0.0410886593,
-0.0127986297,
0.0054600919,
0.040878281,
-0.0237093009,
-0.0274188668,
-0.0162901301,
0.0184505172,
-0.0332319699,
0.0145454332,
-0.0074650557,
-0.0321483053,
-0.0383772738,
-0.0083120614,
0.0180520006,
0.04312291,
-0.0727096349,
0.020915702,
0.0748826265,
-0.0231602173,
-0.043193657,
0.0308331791,
-0.0046170303,
0.0022935634,
-0.0544748046,
-0.026483221,
-0.0067419568,
0.0694542006,
-0.0425209031,
-0.0266601164,
-0.0566285551,
-0.0046807942,
-0.0006200789,
-0.0322320312,
-0.0110411067,
0.0292534046,
0.0218347833,
0.0441160835,
-0.0264955033,
-0.0047177086,
0.0389649644,
-0.0359152108,
-0.0184364766,
-0.0630826578,
-0.0228476431,
-0.0567620099,
0.0198828503,
0.0094181811,
0.0021461868,
0.0131065836,
-0.028824456,
-0.0469947457,
0.0014763081,
0.0190700013,
0.0150515316,
0.0379903093,
-0.0332160369,
-0.0004846214,
-0.0389299095,
0.0016909004,
-0.0337557159,
0.0015177185,
-0.0163050499,
0.0443369672,
0.0026685656,
0.0075422204,
-0.0777896717,
-0.0032508003,
0.0422853641,
0.0277091339,
-0.0006325658,
0.0276354775,
-0.0327866301,
0.0154104391,
0.0255484506,
0.0302110966,
0.0039855484,
-0.009957795,
0.0367184021,
-0.007786266,
0.047879301,
0.004390507,
-0.0435810909,
0.0077089351,
0.0477136821,
0.0001339284,
-0.0351446383,
0.0158021338,
0.0645108595,
-0.0532345623,
0.0082452297,
0.0840442255,
-0.0186309386,
-0.0426790416,
-0.0181718376,
-0.0427854992,
-0.0032710917,
0.0242511034,
0.0354944803,
-0.0929216817,
-0.0537710935,
0.0085173659,
-0.0337214656,
0.0395067148,
-0.0213928036,
-0.0185282324,
-0.1002048776,
0.0033049919,
-0.0332100131,
-0.1113717556,
-0.020197764,
-0.0497501716,
0.0118070962,
-0.021924343,
0.0469591767,
-0.0539041273,
0.0094403261,
-0.0168186985,
0.0344963707,
-0.0187572744,
-0.0491914824,
-0.0043574125,
-0.0323163308,
0.0451582074,
0.0316483043,
0.0212739334,
-0.0539210401,
0.0166571625,
0.031087216,
-0.0236795321,
-0.0037704599,
-0.0113499397,
0.0460410602,
0.0358208157,
-0.0254821386,
0.0678211302,
-0.0082885902,
-0.0544538833,
0.0099290321,
0.0044715526,
0.0948408246,
0.0118261483,
-0.0361549817,
0.0141139701,
-0.0160001907,
0.009375738,
0.0648473576,
0.0248624124,
-0.0180902146,
-0.0339322276,
0.0069814925,
-0.0536473393,
-0.0705180913,
-0.0198950507,
0.0250773933,
-0.0654362664,
-0.0337640494,
-0.0120578967,
-0.0722997859,
0.0463903584,
0.0503828563,
0.0252396483,
0.0149088232,
-0.0136863533,
-0.0060018995,
-0.0120087638,
0.0378497429,
-0.0299493428,
0.0052097957,
-0.015616768,
0.0067395363,
0.0072753471,
-0.0188694932,
0.0172865428,
0.0047586849,
-0.0518886559,
-0.0301990677,
0.0038402425,
0.032022547,
0.0134680886,
0.0763289705,
-0.012711633,
-0.0319802612,
-0.0074456464,
-0.0089052171,
0.0255618859,
-0.0069534169,
0.0492659099,
-0.0320113413,
0.0003509727,
0.0615658052,
-0.0166015942,
0.0141907139,
0.0558452308,
0.017348513,
-0.0132009778,
0.0180629045,
0.0049479157,
0.0045739282,
0.0270833131,
0.0087161306,
-0.0230159778,
-0.0196876489,
0.0266836453,
-0.0136150122,
-0.0071633658,
-0.0225770939,
-0.029700458,
0.0542166233,
0.003036031,
0.0316827893,
0.0353476964,
-0.0195000768,
0.0450448319,
-0.0168666393,
0.0331919044,
0.0537137389,
0.0245234165,
-0.0195996724,
0.0389385894,
-0.008245578,
-0.0047244243,
0.0549262725,
0.0501156487,
-0.0495613329,
-0.0052653551,
0.0010617579,
0.0181245785,
-0.0355249494,
-0.0190479737,
-0.0550170802,
-0.0296318196,
0.005573662,
-0.0091469642,
0.0211508013,
-0.056765981,
0.0668442696,
0.0207843333,
-0.0020423671,
-0.0360602438,
0.0230858251,
-0.0079646036,
0.0059901746,
0.0238024164,
-0.0047026682,
0.003353768,
0.0212937295,
0.0714224502,
0.012509359,
0.0598269403,
0.0157938097,
0.0291590746,
-0.0165054593,
0.0022858239,
0.0514295064,
0.0071508656,
-0.0171822924,
0.0150224175,
-0.0140239652,
-0.0505199246,
0.0319454744,
-0.0637673438,
-0.001283736,
0.0118838092,
-0.0012942913,
0.0688909292,
-0.0012108431,
-0.0068181138,
-0.0074742925,
0.0272157472,
0.0212657284,
0.0114495289,
-0.0098986924,
-6.443666241e-33,
-0.0185497925,
0.0248417351,
0.0152858552,
-0.0189297553,
0.0161831435,
-0.0022804497,
-0.0400688052,
0.0012927642,
-0.0386771969,
0.0096904039,
-0.0024917652,
0.0028854138,
0.0356729329,
0.0330028422,
-0.0011064012,
-0.0525591448,
0.05103397,
0.0228901375,
-0.0161118191,
0.0184569322,
0.0366697684,
0.0649560466,
0.1134169176,
-0.0332095399,
0.0257016849,
0.05308358,
0.0385274552,
0.0048086587,
0.0448848382,
0.0319818631,
-0.0032203651,
0.0692759305,
0.0439414829,
-0.0545500852,
-0.0219237059,
-0.0168708358,
-0.0894372091,
-0.0349649303,
0.03926621,
0.0526240245,
-0.0141584678,
-0.035413675,
0.0195317641,
-0.0048349053,
0.0479844846,
-0.0418867432,
0.0299618077,
-0.0296664238,
-0.0285611432,
0.0176238436,
-0.106930472,
-0.008241199,
-0.0297354516,
0.0017754576,
0.0633798167,
0.0981422365,
-0.0153924366,
0.0021707211,
-0.0589531995,
0.0012710091,
-0.0419936404,
0.0431060828,
0.0604007803,
0.0008695749,
-0.0393326804,
0.0248773918,
0.0512620471,
0.0080575142,
0.0071534771,
0.0119774789,
0.060322199,
0.0376924239,
0.0220769402,
0.080955103,
0.0653288886,
-0.00198619,
-0.0729269534,
0.0252800882,
0.0143269952,
0.0353586674,
-0.0109145707,
0.0195276719,
0.0149458451,
-0.0082681309,
-0.0372989736,
-0.0401092581,
-0.0306312144,
-0.0519161671,
-0.004033023,
-0.0276743639,
-0.0436376669,
0.0114049595,
0.081618771,
-0.0554400235,
0.0037154893,
0.0166919436,
0.003464418,
-0.0104024336,
0.0157811996,
0.0299022049,
-0.0502294116,
-0.0459035486,
0.0085086413,
0.009656271,
0.0273426864,
-0.0174063146,
0.0658730045,
0.0145823741,
-0.0333914645,
-0.025810089,
-0.0594366863,
-0.0091571594,
0.0211569071,
0.0921798795,
0.0067585106,
0.0299512334,
-0.0253296979,
0.0290993657,
0.0252504107,
-0.0140681909,
-0.0107750148,
-0.0039761686,
0.0102130091,
0.016346138,
-0.0417846516,
-0.0262814239,
-0.0364369079,
-0.0281746816,
0.0179391056,
-0.0605529435,
-0.0172473509,
0.0176949725,
2.72e-7,
0.0450859517,
0.0056977416,
0.014553884,
-0.0429794118,
-0.0003202818,
0.0298660845,
-0.0335347466,
0.0085556498,
0.0102229463,
0.000985037,
-0.0101271598,
0.0370819271,
0.053133823,
0.0359320529,
-0.0404403619,
-0.0073549552,
0.0176882371,
0.0090883924,
-0.0054069464,
0.0026319316,
-0.00659105,
0.0963475928,
-0.0293040294,
-0.0179961026,
0.008310603,
-0.0207167342,
0.0438526943,
-0.0314331725,
-0.033746291,
0.0140860491,
-0.001423939,
0.0148646543,
-0.0090825548,
0.039424777,
-0.0304987486,
0.04352393,
0.0285111498,
0.0216939468,
0.0129507035,
-0.0271976832,
-0.0089876782,
0.0188331045,
-0.004065366,
-0.0367655829,
0.1027497575,
-0.0499662533,
-0.038641721,
-0.0403606184,
-0.0406391807,
0.0474859625,
0.0330642462,
0.0017209711,
-0.0126105538,
0.0311168954,
0.0459609106,
-0.0359268486,
-0.0724502206,
-0.0054225056,
-0.0076071834,
0.0147256693,
-0.0319373906,
0.0069589969,
-0.0137633337,
-0.0525563881,
0.0325430073,
-0.0576260909,
0.0200613327,
2.064474122e-34,
0.0118572656,
0.0352060199,
0.0357975848,
0.0126358308,
0.0054033408,
-0.0364711247,
-0.0514587797,
-0.0042295819,
0.0006013443,
-0.0640767142,
-0.0020328204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00898v1 | An Early Categorization of Prompt Injection Attacks on Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T19:52:00 | 2024-01-31T19:52:00 | Sippo Rossi, Alisia Marianne Michel, Raghava Rao Mukkamala, Jason Bennett Thatcher | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models and AI chatbots have been at the forefront of
democratizing artificial intelligence. However, the releases of ChatGPT and
other similar tools have been followed by growing concerns regarding the
difficulty of controlling large language models and their outputs. Currently,
we are witnessing a cat-and-mouse game where users attempt to misuse the models
with a novel attack called prompt injections. In contrast, the developers
attempt to discover the vulnerabilities and block the attacks simultaneously.
In this paper, we provide an overview of these emergent threats and present a
categorization of prompt injections, which can guide future research on prompt
injections and act as a checklist of vulnerabilities in the development of LLM
interfaces. Moreover, based on previous literature and our own empirical
research, we discuss the implications of prompt injections to LLM end users,
developers, and researchers. | An Early Categorization of Prompt Injection Attacks on Large Language Models: Large language models and AI chatbots have been at the forefront of
democratizing artificial intelligence. However, the releases of ChatGPT and
other similar tools have been followed by growing concerns regarding the
difficulty of controlling large language models and their outputs. Currently,
we are witnessing a cat-and-mouse game where users attempt to misuse the models
with a novel attack called prompt injections. In contrast, the developers
attempt to discover the vulnerabilities and block the attacks simultaneously.
In this paper, we provide an overview of these emergent threats and present a
categorization of prompt injections, which can guide future research on prompt
injections and act as a checklist of vulnerabilities in the development of LLM
interfaces. Moreover, based on previous literature and our own empirical
research, we discuss the implications of prompt injections to LLM end users,
developers, and researchers. | [
0.0251451451,
0.049701158,
-0.0017310495,
0.0573625788,
-0.0322197787,
-0.0205600243,
0.0283068717,
0.0025394738,
0.0674020573,
-0.0270464756,
-0.0133544458,
0.010123047,
0.0064553558,
0.0371133089,
0.0601196289,
-0.0034403529,
0.0623220652,
-0.0410755873,
-0.0326079428,
-0.0101181325,
-0.036289867,
-0.0139517998,
-0.0015288781,
0.0665646717,
-0.0113606211,
-0.0346009247,
-0.0314287171,
0.0387127846,
-0.0130331293,
-0.0155775398,
-0.0171642024,
-0.0006667168,
0.0058009196,
0.0393700488,
0.0000019974,
-0.0496205725,
-0.0015697216,
0.0492526554,
-0.0771557093,
0.0161389094,
-0.0138807883,
0.0152408741,
-0.0444003008,
0.0401010104,
-0.0015002248,
0.0303968769,
0.024000857,
0.0103595154,
0.0749690607,
0.0728116781,
0.0032156466,
0.0560647696,
0.0642782748,
0.0105234878,
0.0272624735,
-0.0232751239,
0.0075466111,
-0.0522014014,
0.0458509959,
0.0498072281,
0.0089104231,
-0.006187133,
0.0303749479,
-0.0310922656,
-0.0393106341,
0.0326235816,
-0.0070196376,
-0.0405374505,
-0.0441071913,
0.018120328,
-0.0154990554,
0.0229714774,
0.0187043529,
0.0143003855,
0.0235987157,
0.0217342619,
0.0014985387,
0.0368933156,
-0.0146513432,
-0.0239742622,
0.026684057,
-0.0484625325,
0.0236005466,
-0.0133644016,
-0.0259668939,
0.0562965684,
0.0474846512,
-0.0175472517,
-0.0042076292,
-0.0488621183,
0.0248684362,
-0.0832371637,
-0.0520736016,
0.0377528146,
-0.0369546786,
0.0230937134,
-0.0573048443,
0.0092596449,
0.0297872089,
-0.0272729695,
0.0046683238,
0.065069437,
-0.0258675702,
0.0218794569,
0.0248926915,
0.0590984076,
-0.0299520586,
0.0497403704,
0.0502804294,
0.0195869692,
0.0067390543,
-0.0217964333,
-0.0142235821,
0.0267732367,
-0.0112072807,
0.0221393779,
0.0072313515,
0.0996732712,
-0.015660692,
0.068725884,
-0.0576297343,
-0.0261499994,
0.0050657149,
0.0154632088,
0.0076269717,
-0.0532676987,
0.0083452575,
-0.0344012342,
0.0080165947,
-0.1294749081,
-0.0200246535,
0.0107429894,
-0.0620407462,
-0.0095605841,
-0.0070530549,
0.1166545376,
0.0192492157,
-0.0178970732,
-0.0208187532,
-0.0988111794,
-0.0102236355,
-0.0239204131,
-0.0100213662,
-0.0527754985,
-0.0170704965,
-0.0090510268,
-0.0316108689,
-0.0611855574,
-0.0024802489,
0.0203632861,
-0.0392023437,
0.0573615432,
-0.0457732528,
-0.0159782078,
0.0346084535,
0.0507997125,
-0.0387445539,
0.030553855,
-0.0000995297,
0.0388126038,
0.0345650688,
-0.0163812917,
0.0733871832,
0.0420093052,
-0.0292946231,
0.0456890464,
0.0017905018,
0.018781554,
0.0532782115,
-0.0019153601,
-0.0268768761,
0.0548029132,
-0.0016551282,
-0.0228320956,
0.0796478465,
0.081767112,
-0.0553401336,
-0.0050417869,
0.0222596135,
0.0091089616,
0.0043790163,
0.0137214037,
-0.0766499639,
-0.0221325736,
-0.0653470829,
-0.0121404789,
-0.0082877791,
0.0246387236,
-0.0015269006,
-0.0239854269,
0.0092479959,
-0.0252320301,
-0.026909031,
0.0060165497,
0.0083300238,
-0.0030583295,
0.0093868198,
0.0259510446,
-0.0004729068,
-0.0406372473,
-0.0286538899,
-0.1024627015,
-0.0122042177,
0.0606716424,
0.0660574883,
-0.0189846475,
-0.042589467,
-0.0113412375,
0.0070178863,
0.0404155329,
0.0311390758,
0.0281693712,
-0.0260179881,
0.0241432041,
-0.0139877368,
-0.0048812949,
0.0011765119,
0.0453219675,
-0.0238974858,
0.0109842159,
-0.0270245317,
0.0140358927,
-0.0030322291,
0.0241962504,
-0.0232641399,
-0.072623685,
-0.0266690161,
0.0427269675,
-0.0140996436,
0.0170571338,
-0.0098295044,
0.0139513155,
0.0605818331,
0.0199694745,
-0.0143986279,
-0.0176471807,
-0.0155696841,
0.0369922966,
0.0504204705,
0.0111424606,
-0.0282475483,
0.0118824923,
-0.0173063818,
-0.0184333045,
0.0282351337,
-0.0334191062,
0.0469208248,
0.0042076632,
0.0177929197,
-0.0072459774,
0.0176199768,
-0.0375425294,
-0.0125726098,
0.0068707359,
-0.0107877832,
0.0375016108,
0.0627184883,
-0.0096659493,
-0.0401921235,
-0.053301502,
0.056567736,
-0.0065248688,
0.016935708,
-0.0088271936,
0.023561649,
-0.0056205946,
-0.0319908336,
-0.058325965,
-0.0073251985,
-0.0036312453,
0.0333378501,
0.0144353509,
0.0342235379,
-0.0499881282,
-0.014211108,
-0.0223778598,
-0.0264322832,
-0.0125462404,
0.0368551388,
0.0472914428,
-0.0183592979,
-0.05371245,
-0.0008345614,
0.0153781343,
-0.0367754176,
0.0453087576,
-0.0234339461,
-0.0550150387,
-0.0493518412,
0.0570977814,
-0.0112466281,
0.0066033034,
-0.0261226613,
-0.0318345986,
0.0351746641,
0.0096157258,
0.0086524775,
0.0689322352,
0.0044415877,
0.0693203732,
0.0579505861,
0.0095078247,
-0.0589029081,
-0.0165670495,
0.0565040149,
-0.0512323044,
-0.0266689677,
-0.0026626328,
0.0500344932,
0.0453035422,
0.008903685,
-0.0053689196,
-0.013880345,
0.0493659079,
0.0135926791,
-0.0299531128,
0.0042090318,
-0.0536104776,
-0.0713749826,
0.0428952463,
0.005623037,
-0.0876352713,
0.0520256385,
-0.0956582204,
-0.004014059,
0.0088236453,
-0.0473212004,
-0.0105306394,
0.0258123893,
-0.0326129608,
-0.0115018524,
0.0440928638,
-0.0610263608,
-0.049964264,
-0.005321864,
0.0170511417,
-0.0298405886,
0.0376268178,
-0.0249676034,
-0.025748482,
-0.0415692478,
-0.0423169471,
-0.0426236466,
-0.0565521382,
-0.013688447,
-0.0273019318,
0.0201640017,
-0.0297282226,
0.0218130518,
-0.031711895,
0.0220058728,
-0.0154307922,
-0.0049207555,
-0.025046343,
-0.0476119071,
-0.0346117131,
0.0159985796,
-0.0044539603,
-0.0119259041,
0.0115398811,
0.0528798737,
0.0692499727,
0.0146202184,
-0.0136253899,
-0.0234785751,
-0.0098886946,
0.0344062634,
-0.0238797031,
-0.0031312825,
0.0469367877,
0.0406344719,
-0.0406589061,
-0.0070201773,
0.0573226511,
0.0166749414,
-0.0588212572,
0.0063692634,
-0.0231367722,
0.0328144729,
0.036770504,
0.0387543216,
-0.1103726327,
-0.0022418343,
0.0467406735,
0.0410565138,
-0.0253616925,
-0.011027785,
-0.0251387376,
-0.1213585958,
0.035463158,
-0.0031017733,
-0.0133719146,
-0.0153055573,
-0.016427543,
0.0085846707,
0.0572616272,
0.0633976385,
-0.0161145981,
-0.0056481971,
0.0094210235,
0.0194893125,
-0.0476392731,
0.0052519818,
-0.0073742317,
-0.0312287938,
0.0856232867,
0.044202216,
-0.0102197872,
-0.0097359885,
0.0420799963,
0.0910998583,
0.0212208051,
-0.0129744262,
0.0125111537,
0.0133180059,
0.0099611729,
-0.015843356,
0.0224047042,
0.0119445026,
-0.024143286,
-0.0109776566,
0.0348614603,
0.0487312041,
-0.0665924251,
0.0261446927,
-0.0245451275,
-0.0271622706,
0.0344387479,
0.0381461494,
0.0351360627,
-0.0358624533,
-0.0151821505,
-0.1000673026,
-0.0106855007,
0.0363594741,
-0.0576237403,
0.0124813216,
-0.0003435858,
-0.0512818322,
-0.0283883419,
-0.0269815642,
-0.0005601286,
0.011170771,
0.0586882979,
-0.0092487959,
-0.0221940745,
0.0175867397,
0.0286818966,
-0.0024276965,
-0.0461638123,
0.028270103,
-0.0565381348,
0.05232713,
-0.0051549692,
-0.0375388265,
0.008496495,
0.0141717969,
-0.0215831511,
-0.0906895548,
0.0068277139,
0.0570321456,
0.0310057923,
-0.0011718664,
-0.0333155245,
-0.0250596665,
0.0556779988,
0.0427947715,
-0.022797348,
0.0334579088,
0.0500436127,
0.0486917086,
0.0197566431,
0.000678097,
-0.050476145,
-0.0490526408,
0.0569274351,
-0.0307198577,
-0.0511652939,
-0.0695960149,
0.0055859494,
0.0599025302,
0.0294825882,
-0.0044174218,
0.0356833898,
0.0114720622,
0.0181843694,
-0.0428959094,
-0.0109110884,
-0.009673316,
0.0004224163,
-0.056899555,
-0.0064865476,
0.0457375199,
-0.0169803295,
0.0026672715,
0.0564382486,
0.0050586504,
0.0456548966,
0.0218732115,
0.0319490694,
0.0436661728,
0.0268627685,
0.0062645529,
0.0683404654,
0.0171605572,
0.0309988484,
0.0051715244,
0.0422733761,
0.0016991153,
-0.002451088,
0.0029606575,
0.0408131853,
-0.0829443634,
-0.0989854634,
0.0747743919,
0.068282567,
0.0119617339,
0.0481119938,
-0.0278155562,
0.0030785839,
0.0044153458,
-0.0220712237,
-0.031851355,
0.009810199,
-0.0219225772,
0.0088560712,
-0.0157414693,
-0.0149426786,
-0.0081338491,
0.0487220772,
-0.0019649703,
0.0591332018,
0.0131358691,
-0.0287697483,
-0.0424244851,
-0.0095743919,
0.0511994548,
-0.0234838258,
-0.0212432519,
-0.0667827278,
-0.0666962638,
-0.0684238896,
-0.0087717772,
-0.0072358241,
0.0007836958,
0.0018818756,
-0.0033250975,
0.0420580283,
0.0405439399,
0.0141202137,
-0.0536919981,
0.0238009803,
-0.020846121,
-0.0691945404,
0.0337068699,
-5.265691597e-33,
0.0065389504,
-0.0601221323,
-0.006626687,
0.0302326195,
0.0043374719,
0.0098690074,
-0.0107779,
0.0261060875,
-0.0216156431,
-0.0279523227,
-0.0340547673,
-0.0102957198,
0.0205990076,
-0.0079887407,
-0.0040707705,
-0.0185300894,
-0.0101156514,
0.0092905862,
-0.0215813816,
0.0187035631,
0.042677898,
0.000742854,
-0.0024039561,
-0.0380432494,
0.0447829738,
-0.019595949,
0.0010006978,
0.0009321028,
-0.0243114065,
0.0385438353,
0.0103521841,
0.0155891832,
-0.0134731568,
-0.0246566292,
-0.0060405405,
0.0800548345,
-0.0032229875,
-0.0427231342,
-0.0119699296,
0.0050182198,
0.0092982901,
-0.0914700478,
0.0087653277,
-0.0338926464,
-0.0244779941,
0.0146470005,
0.0141610047,
-0.0102690514,
-0.0171756838,
-0.0207967851,
-0.0182649679,
-0.0186430961,
-0.0232740007,
0.0041158297,
-0.0018768113,
-0.0046649007,
0.0339303277,
-0.0086091924,
-0.0195829365,
0.0308586191,
0.013489848,
0.0075890161,
0.0553215817,
0.0147094699,
-0.0004341516,
0.0367554873,
0.028747268,
0.0009592164,
-0.0189675912,
-0.0011121414,
-0.0102194445,
0.0227159373,
0.0104909632,
0.026047105,
-0.0214984398,
-0.0199866034,
-0.020929141,
0.0205708109,
0.0505466424,
0.0214391742,
0.0140408464,
-0.0051606218,
-0.0733903646,
-0.0109789809,
-0.0107771195,
-0.0057505793,
-0.0251377523,
-0.0308094341,
0.0110933771,
-0.0391180404,
0.0306717549,
-0.0592499897,
0.0136869205,
-0.0469718762,
0.006110678,
-0.0372777656,
-0.0020945463,
-0.0336132795,
-0.0087396996,
0.0069466587,
0.0330678597,
0.0009999028,
-0.0086489487,
-0.0520686284,
0.0494455285,
0.008453331,
-0.0201627556,
0.037450444,
-0.0781840459,
-0.0192887783,
-0.0310663283,
0.0254502967,
0.0301698819,
0.0397458114,
0.0454298034,
-0.054281123,
0.022122262,
0.0083142156,
0.0304914024,
0.010172721,
-0.0515292436,
0.026898697,
-0.0405386239,
-0.0083383191,
-0.0204469264,
0.0203232709,
-0.0314974189,
0.0925899819,
0.0420213342,
-0.0502328165,
-0.0069777197,
-0.0482648499,
2.808e-7,
-0.0158170089,
0.0264712889,
0.0329403169,
0.0510340817,
0.0240055528,
0.0571562275,
-0.0205185916,
0.0548268296,
-0.0049116393,
-0.027128499,
-0.0186979938,
0.001826402,
0.0340118632,
0.0093454188,
-0.0839207172,
-0.0087061133,
-0.0439761765,
-0.008647766,
-0.087617524,
0.0114315562,
0.060127534,
0.0519665144,
-0.0145332776,
-0.0404492654,
-0.0042184829,
-0.0615058765,
-0.0097454553,
-0.0376647301,
-0.0353716463,
-0.0110038659,
0.060682714,
0.0307823885,
0.0333829336,
0.0469372347,
-0.0176513195,
-0.0281267259,
-0.0445650741,
0.0285534058,
0.0337221846,
-0.0168261826,
-0.0117104929,
-0.0588754565,
-0.0058860462,
-0.0183601417,
0.04266252,
0.0153923156,
-0.0271080062,
-0.0180241149,
0.0019627423,
-0.0792400017,
0.0200286731,
-0.0341663398,
0.0056610382,
0.0146160973,
-0.0002157772,
-0.0011581986,
0.0306259021,
-0.0393000245,
-0.0221608356,
-0.0308254361,
-0.0315313563,
-0.0707463995,
0.0049552065,
0.031139357,
0.0087442677,
-0.0128085306,
-0.008864196,
3.000536574e-34,
-0.0300495811,
-0.0347423255,
0.03424583,
0.0292721279,
0.0334523432,
0.0333674476,
0.0203397907,
0.0257675331,
0.0321564339,
-0.0235258192,
-0.0285337493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00143v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00143v1 | Making a Long Story Short in Conversation Modeling | 2024-01-31T19:48:58 | 2024-01-31T19:48:58 | Yufei Tao, Tiernan Mines, Ameeta Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Conversation systems accommodate diverse users with unique personalities and
distinct writing styles. Within the domain of multi-turn dialogue modeling,
this work studies the impact of varied utterance lengths on the quality of
subsequent responses generated by conversation models. Using GPT-3 as the base
model, multiple dialogue datasets, and several metrics, we conduct a thorough
exploration of this aspect of conversational models. Our analysis sheds light
on the complex relationship between utterance lengths and the quality of
follow-up responses generated by dialogue systems. Empirical findings suggests
that, for certain types of conversations, utterance lengths can be reduced by
up to 72% without any noticeable difference in the quality of follow-up
responses. | Making a Long Story Short in Conversation Modeling: Conversation systems accommodate diverse users with unique personalities and
distinct writing styles. Within the domain of multi-turn dialogue modeling,
this work studies the impact of varied utterance lengths on the quality of
subsequent responses generated by conversation models. Using GPT-3 as the base
model, multiple dialogue datasets, and several metrics, we conduct a thorough
exploration of this aspect of conversational models. Our analysis sheds light
on the complex relationship between utterance lengths and the quality of
follow-up responses generated by dialogue systems. Empirical findings suggests
that, for certain types of conversations, utterance lengths can be reduced by
up to 72% without any noticeable difference in the quality of follow-up
responses. | [
0.0746681169,
0.0161773749,
-0.0316596031,
0.0149119627,
-0.0357325971,
-0.0130950101,
0.0147099271,
-0.010980498,
-0.0251819883,
-0.0266373195,
-0.0040454986,
-0.0547008216,
0.0154811693,
0.0507332385,
-0.0005750747,
-0.089500621,
0.0091944458,
-0.0186639298,
0.0508401431,
0.0006168072,
0.0432379544,
0.0114104431,
-0.0156013211,
0.0633535832,
-0.0123667242,
-0.0187056214,
-0.056888517,
0.0151142422,
-0.0257760491,
0.0036780681,
0.0351144262,
0.0737987906,
0.0043458249,
0.0464836434,
0.0000017552,
-0.0450332277,
0.0244851317,
-0.0277814437,
-0.0304784942,
0.0496014282,
0.0070581646,
0.0412483104,
0.0038977594,
0.0401760451,
-0.038862925,
0.0078134667,
0.0432846136,
0.0699083284,
0.0626400188,
0.0530839674,
-0.0092956796,
-0.0003894871,
0.0214828625,
-0.027304804,
0.0035153979,
-0.0403294265,
-0.0218609851,
0.0323453695,
0.0200696848,
0.017446762,
-0.0024834108,
0.0233267248,
0.0052949032,
-0.0202737655,
-0.0113414293,
-0.0004110877,
-0.0131544489,
-0.0030654843,
-0.0092305932,
0.0614758097,
0.0537852347,
0.007785141,
-0.0051785605,
-0.0185314566,
0.0273593608,
-0.0391360112,
-0.0707155243,
-0.0157116409,
-0.0103647858,
-0.0500479415,
-0.0717301741,
0.0140116783,
-0.0330406241,
-0.020922929,
-0.0172652546,
0.0222061463,
-0.0061243461,
-0.0388863944,
-0.0706174895,
-0.0120395245,
0.0488812886,
-0.0643611401,
-0.0068136859,
0.0020599887,
-0.0582577586,
0.0196238011,
-0.0270371754,
0.0368733667,
0.0379092246,
-0.0165514778,
0.0214526653,
0.0278784912,
0.0315685496,
-0.0086720744,
0.0492895618,
0.0245110691,
-0.0143571282,
-0.0222369898,
-0.0064104176,
-0.0026895937,
-0.0531856492,
-0.0344293527,
-0.0176500008,
0.0115744574,
-0.040218465,
-0.0371599123,
-0.0267811418,
0.0490199849,
0.0405472517,
-0.0100269997,
0.0205834191,
0.0239662454,
-0.0128268115,
-0.0088614328,
-0.0382939354,
0.0464156158,
-0.0391450152,
0.0112967584,
0.0349969342,
-0.0599345081,
0.0033939031,
0.0141150914,
0.018007854,
-0.0193625484,
-0.0202361923,
0.0596812516,
-0.005650009,
-0.0291563906,
0.0207675397,
-0.0256686304,
-0.0470661297,
-0.0838248432,
-0.0322456695,
-0.0334647559,
0.0250683594,
0.0333811305,
-0.0251296461,
-0.0067795743,
0.0003657875,
0.0232377928,
-0.0343406238,
0.0072703338,
-0.0024983122,
0.055357568,
0.0595129617,
0.0116291577,
0.0140121216,
0.0278246142,
0.0746256113,
-0.0094397459,
0.0662336722,
-0.0494099073,
0.0501680896,
0.0425780118,
-0.0103335856,
0.0098615419,
0.0366872847,
0.0353214704,
-0.0072132852,
0.0284959506,
0.0074061402,
0.0547181964,
-0.0306676254,
-0.0238295123,
0.1020493656,
0.0740480423,
0.0151333455,
0.0396039523,
0.0457929485,
0.0414324366,
0.0145931784,
0.0640826374,
-0.014807391,
0.0063560563,
0.0092326337,
0.0456598178,
0.051251296,
0.0261812657,
-0.0242244899,
-0.034093596,
0.003536758,
0.0150486128,
0.0099149654,
-0.0102925496,
-0.0145452898,
-0.0134208966,
-0.0587829798,
0.0317080542,
-0.0332624689,
-0.0868426114,
-0.0449336655,
-0.0372261293,
-0.0075703501,
0.110005796,
0.0241754893,
0.0240086,
-0.0226229355,
-0.0481547378,
0.0041609686,
0.0447063409,
0.0569510087,
0.0045211636,
0.0455671959,
-0.035388343,
0.0122342063,
0.0072922991,
-0.0004652391,
0.0243487544,
0.0031949189,
0.0047347774,
0.0246605873,
0.0050501833,
-0.0033773987,
-0.0153724682,
-0.0498445891,
0.0007038378,
-0.0194835905,
-0.0050881803,
0.0256588571,
0.0195859075,
-0.0161050335,
0.0059546973,
-0.001067759,
0.0417358093,
0.0017041679,
0.0399837904,
-0.0486351401,
-0.0015230215,
0.0263575856,
-0.0126820682,
0.0005453123,
-0.0119443676,
0.00939193,
-0.0554299466,
0.012960148,
-0.0792117491,
0.0545899235,
-0.0223093778,
0.0192308966,
0.0117254928,
0.0193362199,
-0.0126733398,
-0.0109517267,
-0.0103662228,
0.0151227172,
0.0036916065,
-0.0142452512,
0.0158639308,
-0.0767165199,
0.0139328726,
0.0332625844,
-0.0046805697,
0.0182372611,
0.0397168919,
-0.0110144205,
-0.0540759377,
-0.0437566265,
-0.1192189008,
0.0177757032,
-0.0102872727,
-0.007043656,
0.014538981,
0.0473808609,
-0.0403601676,
-0.0152685223,
-0.067900233,
-0.0495366342,
0.0604796112,
0.0171024241,
0.0357056521,
0.0153587395,
-0.0355346091,
-0.0591309778,
-0.0067729894,
-0.0030103163,
0.042544432,
-0.0184697919,
-0.0136991311,
-0.036169894,
-0.0239413325,
-0.0317656882,
0.0078638084,
-0.0245728102,
-0.0649604127,
0.0157294124,
0.0226017721,
0.0736617371,
0.0508391336,
0.0820793882,
0.037873555,
-0.0430553928,
-0.0319869183,
-0.0278854705,
0.0331766643,
-0.0267232228,
-0.0076714288,
-0.0340131335,
-0.0575452857,
0.0367246307,
0.0378059149,
0.0257622618,
0.0425263122,
-0.0492821261,
0.0171065982,
0.0492493659,
-0.0355218202,
0.0293755606,
-0.0116257304,
-0.0431284457,
0.0528920889,
0.0038024944,
-0.0412987396,
0.0465468764,
-0.0483629964,
-0.0355106704,
-0.0089469887,
-0.0337272435,
-0.0272818301,
0.0493942536,
-0.001013999,
0.0081846751,
0.0141189508,
-0.0215426665,
-0.0372487865,
-0.0208861399,
0.0447204486,
-0.0333801731,
0.060890235,
-0.0133804269,
-0.0226875003,
0.0227145404,
-0.0356222615,
-0.0034444488,
-0.0445526578,
-0.0315944031,
-0.0188053548,
0.0416778661,
-0.0504675955,
-0.03034853,
0.0355646051,
0.0227391012,
0.0434650034,
-0.0532013178,
0.0185258146,
-0.0207044557,
0.0195904002,
0.0399343111,
0.0096126553,
-0.0021987131,
-0.0369276553,
0.0708184764,
0.0171471033,
0.010942894,
0.0170832071,
0.0161946919,
-0.0559016615,
-0.0048132995,
-0.0228009652,
-0.0640887618,
0.0380739272,
0.0770003945,
-0.0437637679,
-0.0116997212,
0.1056938022,
0.01533728,
-0.0071496698,
-0.0097017512,
-0.0367342345,
0.0870524123,
-0.0033690503,
0.0270513259,
-0.0343827531,
-0.0028327145,
-0.0052727605,
0.0150377005,
-0.0447615273,
-0.0059830579,
-0.0317168199,
-0.1025269404,
0.0192607101,
-0.0086776698,
-0.0656598285,
-0.0061623645,
-0.0173519235,
-0.0013867131,
0.0279720332,
0.0302769057,
0.000239975,
-0.0206409749,
-0.0047876649,
0.0011316643,
-0.080278866,
-0.0113127148,
0.0047994833,
0.0064165825,
0.0629737973,
0.0684684515,
0.0428179726,
0.0284258332,
-0.0216318481,
0.0132869333,
-0.0079213716,
0.0272739381,
0.0394274555,
0.0663007572,
-0.0224444717,
0.0205294881,
-0.0675555915,
0.0362601019,
0.0104196183,
0.0193947367,
0.047352206,
-0.0128908437,
-0.0387583822,
0.0009976104,
-0.038771268,
0.0500240102,
0.0350723714,
0.0595837459,
0.064457871,
-0.0682089329,
-0.0606395267,
-0.0407199189,
0.0002550825,
-0.0625712499,
0.0000849192,
-0.0255475901,
0.0020994258,
0.0083192959,
-0.0332433879,
-0.1025823876,
-0.0121402862,
-0.0120086987,
-0.0315094255,
0.019463703,
-0.0093197944,
0.031507533,
-0.0064760963,
-0.0349058956,
0.0063944855,
0.0261640958,
-0.0684328824,
0.0007909597,
0.0275270361,
-0.0374110118,
0.011811181,
0.0007903425,
-0.0802176446,
-0.0564685687,
-0.0210290477,
0.0481504463,
0.0355689824,
0.0546624549,
0.0335258804,
-0.036985863,
-0.0593198463,
-0.0158915166,
-0.006638417,
0.014044797,
0.0379412174,
0.0642643049,
-0.0059293383,
0.0148067316,
0.0095197689,
0.0065840273,
-0.038808275,
0.0262350254,
-0.0407624729,
-0.113083303,
-0.0325823613,
-0.0059687765,
0.015499996,
0.0355601981,
-0.0064030909,
0.026401097,
0.0209388249,
-0.0619939826,
0.0114203691,
-0.0381427705,
-0.0097827893,
-0.0363014191,
-0.0125868656,
-0.0081522437,
-0.0265133195,
-0.0821656212,
0.0275138263,
-0.0408575758,
-0.0051766089,
-0.0026225387,
-0.035400752,
0.012383352,
-0.0273989644,
-0.0339887738,
0.0216199029,
0.0209188685,
0.0162056889,
0.0336202458,
0.0879129842,
0.0006432296,
-0.0307790823,
0.0484658852,
0.0564006418,
-0.099693276,
-0.0252433028,
-0.0150401192,
0.0282649808,
-0.0124436766,
0.0033713435,
0.060367316,
0.0054412549,
0.043128036,
-0.0294770859,
0.0685709119,
0.0132958908,
-0.0184532087,
-0.0145653263,
0.0318306945,
-0.0415221527,
-0.0047613992,
0.0782532096,
0.0274794959,
0.0181221422,
-0.0168628991,
-0.0292152036,
-0.0522218645,
-0.0330312736,
-0.0018483108,
0.0323482752,
0.0275586247,
-0.0094819786,
-0.0721742287,
-0.0300719868,
0.0143483747,
0.0039458293,
0.0478911474,
-0.0424652956,
0.0244145375,
0.0636641085,
-0.0074207275,
-0.020415077,
-0.0264801402,
-0.0110597601,
-0.0255627241,
-0.0047787395,
-0.0283292346,
-5.50325827e-33,
-0.0036413253,
-0.0431419946,
0.0191568453,
0.0208106879,
-0.0613508336,
-0.0393560641,
-0.0269921664,
0.0342841111,
-0.0018152806,
-0.0048341909,
-0.0543520153,
0.0462584049,
0.0039562448,
0.035274215,
0.0026902752,
0.0019612722,
0.0643447936,
0.0095753856,
-0.0382951722,
0.0387044065,
0.0198010523,
-0.0005974292,
0.0040841373,
-0.0625059679,
0.0377101749,
-0.0543033034,
0.0024086782,
-0.0183906257,
0.0044356766,
0.0622411333,
-0.0112197669,
0.0433859378,
0.029495772,
-0.0320047215,
-0.0212883875,
0.0364566371,
-0.0070666573,
-0.0010466826,
0.0363381729,
0.0155483549,
0.0265033729,
-0.0221739486,
-0.0019331677,
-0.0168728232,
-0.0107318005,
-0.021141395,
0.0389656238,
-0.005052974,
-0.0058599031,
0.0071305605,
-0.037241362,
0.0181943905,
-0.0327693485,
-0.0648553595,
-0.0419952013,
0.0824153796,
0.0173599292,
-0.0298673101,
-0.0224065017,
0.0374117754,
0.0001442716,
-0.002727045,
0.0130864037,
0.0277078506,
0.0146236336,
0.0155074382,
0.0270835757,
0.0462637059,
-0.046013277,
-0.0379603542,
-0.0078622662,
0.0296138451,
0.019914953,
0.0616165735,
-0.0188901257,
-0.0212088022,
-0.0052681929,
0.0226340145,
0.0070232712,
0.0089754779,
0.0173127819,
0.0036803689,
-0.0540559255,
-0.0298306979,
-0.0133470539,
-0.0098473364,
0.0024849833,
-0.0504898727,
0.0323480368,
0.0005111717,
0.0124943238,
-0.0246508066,
0.0520233326,
-0.0289758611,
-0.0285107847,
0.0116745345,
-0.0656794384,
0.0313850567,
-0.0064740139,
0.0095563298,
-0.0049148626,
0.0139616057,
0.0220927745,
0.0554499365,
0.0058565005,
0.0133582084,
0.0002344257,
-0.0005521243,
-0.0703043416,
-0.0104348389,
0.0059978142,
0.0539897457,
-0.0392783061,
0.0067513133,
0.0068785516,
0.0013766151,
-0.036208611,
0.0817160904,
-0.0189682227,
-0.0032336488,
-0.0522656292,
-0.0602333136,
0.0096903834,
0.0142442407,
-0.0470298156,
-0.0080884481,
-0.0214472469,
-0.0220593289,
0.0159435887,
-0.0207240134,
-0.0157678723,
-0.0349038132,
2.406e-7,
-0.0077595883,
0.0515866056,
0.0545581765,
0.0062641334,
0.0426539667,
0.0451459289,
0.0340251364,
0.0111115696,
0.026552923,
-0.0070624314,
0.0045420039,
-0.0127526075,
0.0648260638,
0.0039328272,
-0.0839599371,
-0.0429399274,
-0.1092509553,
0.0037689707,
-0.0453668125,
0.0189286023,
0.063324973,
0.020758504,
0.0075101419,
0.0206173006,
-0.0103273354,
0.0176628996,
0.0333134793,
-0.0404955223,
-0.0130135221,
0.0182243474,
0.0456318818,
-0.0309111811,
0.0171447601,
0.0215850994,
-0.0032289734,
0.0254691951,
0.0109629408,
0.0757292882,
-0.0097112413,
-0.0441864133,
0.0072607691,
-0.0043800911,
-0.0167444274,
-0.0479961783,
0.0346375555,
-0.0250650384,
-0.0238223318,
-0.019620169,
-0.0176746622,
-0.0316815823,
0.0290061943,
-0.0253287405,
-0.0199444592,
0.0315102339,
-0.0023513655,
-0.009760865,
0.0532012731,
-0.0514790528,
0.0065079322,
0.0067289406,
-0.0375173241,
-0.0608609691,
-0.0403422751,
-0.028554868,
0.0451868214,
-0.0411922485,
0.0102046113,
1.749638623e-34,
0.0499307364,
-0.0014518097,
0.0413629413,
0.0377512313,
0.0471463203,
-0.017078599,
0.0676394552,
0.0118518611,
0.0558197573,
-0.0624074973,
-0.0330717675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00126v1 | Common Sense Reasoning for Deep Fake Detection | 2024-01-31T19:11:58 | 2024-01-31T19:11:58 | Yue Zhang, Ben Colman, Ali Shahriyari, Gaurav Bharaj | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | State-of-the-art approaches rely on image-based features extracted via neural
networks for the deepfake detection binary classification. While these
approaches trained in the supervised sense extract likely fake features, they
may fall short in representing unnatural `non-physical' semantic facial
attributes -- blurry hairlines, double eyebrows, rigid eye pupils, or unnatural
skin shading. However, such facial attributes are generally easily perceived by
humans via common sense reasoning. Furthermore, image-based feature extraction
methods that provide visual explanation via saliency maps can be hard to be
interpreted by humans. To address these challenges, we propose the use of
common sense reasoning to model deepfake detection, and extend it to the
Deepfake Detection VQA (DD-VQA) task with the aim to model human intuition in
explaining the reason behind labeling an image as either real or fake. To this
end, we introduce a new dataset that provides answers to the questions related
to the authenticity of an image, along with its corresponding explanations. We
also propose a Vision and Language Transformer-based framework for the DD-VQA
task, incorporating text and image aware feature alignment formulations.
Finally, we evaluate our method on both the performance of deepfake detection
and the quality of the generated explanations. We hope that this task inspires
researchers to explore new avenues for enhancing language-based
interpretability and cross-modality applications in the realm of deepfake
detection. | Common Sense Reasoning for Deep Fake Detection: State-of-the-art approaches rely on image-based features extracted via neural
networks for the deepfake detection binary classification. While these
approaches trained in the supervised sense extract likely fake features, they
may fall short in representing unnatural `non-physical' semantic facial
attributes -- blurry hairlines, double eyebrows, rigid eye pupils, or unnatural
skin shading. However, such facial attributes are generally easily perceived by
humans via common sense reasoning. Furthermore, image-based feature extraction
methods that provide visual explanation via saliency maps can be hard to be
interpreted by humans. To address these challenges, we propose the use of
common sense reasoning to model deepfake detection, and extend it to the
Deepfake Detection VQA (DD-VQA) task with the aim to model human intuition in
explaining the reason behind labeling an image as either real or fake. To this
end, we introduce a new dataset that provides answers to the questions related
to the authenticity of an image, along with its corresponding explanations. We
also propose a Vision and Language Transformer-based framework for the DD-VQA
task, incorporating text and image aware feature alignment formulations.
Finally, we evaluate our method on both the performance of deepfake detection
and the quality of the generated explanations. We hope that this task inspires
researchers to explore new avenues for enhancing language-based
interpretability and cross-modality applications in the realm of deepfake
detection. | [
0.0151613597,
0.0522069633,
-0.0085347211,
0.0559239611,
-0.001369341,
0.0328405127,
0.0610463098,
0.0349648893,
0.0036199919,
-0.0043962086,
0.0068964935,
-0.0375423208,
0.0071494337,
0.0868609771,
0.0478118919,
-0.0785915628,
0.0017806708,
-0.0215828661,
0.0391130559,
0.0126796868,
0.0617830418,
0.0322132818,
-0.0036981746,
0.0525977276,
-0.0673226565,
-0.0387056395,
-0.0117494119,
0.0359232686,
0.0692478418,
0.0479395054,
-0.01063364,
0.0037334447,
0.0054350793,
0.0244314708,
0.0000020446,
-0.0199491419,
-0.0174025726,
0.0015302843,
-0.0334703922,
0.0039836937,
0.0085680168,
-0.0382238775,
-0.0400013514,
-0.0143374735,
-0.0295127966,
-0.0040848041,
0.0525346249,
0.0760971755,
0.0627514049,
0.0623197407,
-0.0352707207,
-0.0380115919,
0.0005048987,
0.0155880246,
0.0207859743,
-0.0561460331,
-0.0180998016,
0.0045340257,
-0.0553606115,
-0.0165231563,
-0.0120165721,
-0.0212288741,
0.016264081,
-0.0704625919,
0.003723488,
-0.0060172305,
-0.0578630269,
-0.048972629,
0.0347899944,
0.0649891645,
-0.0844770372,
-0.0168168973,
0.0148686953,
-0.0348076299,
0.0089933975,
0.0570476241,
0.0307657551,
0.0207144879,
-0.0133367553,
0.0276922192,
-0.032636445,
-0.0016356312,
0.0463394709,
0.0034321568,
-0.0307964161,
-0.0065235319,
-0.0163602028,
0.0557874218,
-0.0197315682,
-0.0143900439,
-0.0281434786,
-0.0310974512,
0.0165032316,
0.0168704242,
0.0130024711,
-0.0451516397,
-0.0494077131,
-0.0065990901,
-0.0290458426,
0.003925045,
0.0343415737,
0.0072689587,
-0.0823635608,
0.0559802875,
-0.0003228114,
0.0680670962,
-0.0235987324,
0.0474651493,
-0.0252566952,
-0.0206258334,
-0.0298499465,
-0.026730122,
0.0183730368,
-0.0687064528,
-0.0048785093,
-0.0014891883,
-0.0194957331,
-0.0261111259,
-0.049435772,
0.0023408527,
0.007530889,
0.0444659702,
-0.0515225232,
-0.0165255107,
-0.040772967,
0.0257096346,
0.0178405326,
0.0231720284,
-0.0184911042,
-0.0667269602,
-0.0243982393,
0.056444671,
0.0280668866,
0.0078659467,
0.0395090468,
-0.0209379382,
0.0097117033,
0.0042910408,
-0.0341044925,
-0.0054879966,
-0.0389419086,
-0.0309048109,
-0.0018919243,
-0.0463864431,
-0.0043131579,
-0.0775303543,
0.01210027,
-0.0207936764,
-0.0256177075,
-0.017090885,
-0.0096523287,
0.0707189292,
-0.0161867309,
-0.0068790722,
0.0408472531,
0.0081777247,
-0.0176378526,
0.0157959983,
0.0186967906,
0.0447926186,
0.0394468755,
-0.0283697341,
0.0460376404,
-0.0065129101,
0.0106091937,
0.0021238786,
-0.0322864987,
-0.0434406921,
-0.0416320637,
0.0414265767,
0.0436335802,
-0.012625942,
0.0029811375,
-0.0332876518,
0.049759265,
0.0294880532,
0.012082668,
-0.0237696581,
0.0349155664,
0.0387546979,
-0.0216857623,
-0.0042384523,
-0.0455545038,
0.0599031001,
-0.0135034267,
-0.000339646,
-0.0499292128,
0.0282308329,
-0.0466512181,
-0.0376720168,
0.0104084378,
-0.0299950149,
0.000131945,
-0.0023763494,
0.02635625,
0.0172902122,
-0.0117093632,
-0.0088845454,
-0.0329490639,
-0.012942344,
-0.0069883158,
-0.0968408808,
0.0343898423,
0.0617634431,
-0.0155193349,
0.0269821826,
0.0100770229,
-0.0056217667,
0.0177214891,
0.0011258376,
-0.0151414694,
0.0104292538,
0.0345873125,
-0.0182465371,
-0.0289075319,
-0.0476504937,
-0.0064198705,
-0.0152196027,
-0.0497757085,
-0.0138912685,
0.0368052199,
-0.0189003702,
0.005044376,
0.0104530277,
-0.0063044988,
0.005533461,
-0.0290931445,
0.054767359,
0.0073169954,
0.0099088643,
0.0315787084,
-0.0115064569,
0.0192539599,
-0.0250552408,
0.0156051023,
0.0062782937,
0.0159849115,
-0.0173820984,
0.0430671796,
-0.0972216949,
-0.0332892612,
0.0589404441,
-0.0576397739,
-0.0201351941,
0.009827002,
-0.0271912962,
-0.0096996017,
-0.0512390286,
-0.0192762539,
0.0064310245,
0.0164016765,
0.0219502654,
0.0926008448,
0.0151491063,
-0.0385948643,
-0.010437266,
0.0077936249,
0.0027004452,
-0.032514628,
0.0037969905,
-0.0007980029,
0.0060938471,
-0.0101531614,
-0.0216950234,
0.0008189144,
-0.0484818816,
0.0373762473,
-0.0340312831,
-0.0138883553,
-0.0240959059,
-0.0247054566,
0.0069333832,
-0.0286061782,
0.017390633,
-0.016680792,
-0.06342417,
0.0192969311,
-0.0463918671,
-0.0442581512,
0.0184016656,
-0.0193049498,
-0.018960366,
-0.0137626166,
0.0290236957,
0.0199236292,
0.0451785736,
0.0269212238,
0.0331091247,
-0.061188709,
0.0066429228,
-0.0259126741,
0.0384467058,
-0.0114759728,
-0.0468954965,
0.0117512746,
0.0094222976,
-0.0157053806,
0.0730786622,
0.0393951274,
0.0338988379,
-0.0166174024,
0.0360075086,
-0.0054300372,
-0.0322383456,
0.0181512069,
0.0346019492,
-0.0154109579,
-0.0855481848,
-0.0262034461,
0.0089372983,
-0.0035014895,
0.0055089756,
-0.0647178218,
0.0576246008,
0.0382224061,
-0.0384871662,
0.0062037921,
-0.0251406077,
0.0052119959,
0.0593702197,
-0.025935201,
-0.060083095,
0.0919984728,
-0.0213147663,
-0.0088817002,
0.0596241988,
-0.0158300735,
0.0045924801,
0.0490609184,
0.0126627889,
0.0236351117,
0.0411313139,
-0.013952516,
-0.0159403663,
-0.0171991158,
0.0613155812,
-0.0191735607,
0.0276158135,
-0.0470118113,
-0.0123843141,
0.0188238192,
0.0361469314,
-0.0420186371,
-0.0555086918,
-0.0505926423,
-0.0321736373,
-0.0573005453,
-0.044041656,
-0.021096224,
0.0204177052,
0.0270373579,
0.014730447,
0.0108457943,
0.013589344,
0.0154668586,
0.0133969989,
0.1069852188,
0.0434859134,
0.013732262,
-0.0138565423,
-0.0189164113,
0.0692005679,
-0.0136957644,
0.0065826806,
-0.079913035,
-0.0083780773,
-0.0033585397,
0.0765221715,
0.0100727724,
-0.0093437312,
0.0056140241,
-0.0374570191,
-0.0019459573,
0.0668892786,
-0.0067199678,
0.0083831009,
0.0338113643,
-0.000114272,
0.0012551985,
0.0065777861,
-0.0063813212,
-0.046660088,
-0.0553094223,
0.0255070142,
0.0124904728,
-0.0309754331,
0.0186196044,
-0.0040549035,
-0.0473516509,
0.0751282349,
0.0150355734,
0.006041022,
-0.0433830209,
0.019574536,
0.0051363115,
-0.0369718336,
0.0168700013,
-0.016049644,
0.0376979224,
0.0045232,
-0.0171343852,
0.055311773,
-0.0522033013,
0.022285996,
-0.0177285094,
0.0415224358,
0.0492460243,
0.0309321694,
-0.0017627617,
-0.1193559468,
-0.0444556475,
-0.0234930236,
0.0441806801,
0.0184537638,
0.0550822169,
-0.005966437,
-0.0387832485,
-0.02397318,
0.0788085237,
-0.0379142836,
-0.0027645244,
-0.041407723,
0.0314643942,
-0.034097448,
-0.0362772122,
-0.0205528941,
-0.0112308348,
-0.0074688527,
0.0431554057,
0.0227674972,
-0.001134245,
-0.0098793972,
0.0071899649,
0.0136981672,
-0.0110980095,
-0.0976065099,
0.0493443832,
0.0295736771,
-0.0692406371,
-0.0125209084,
0.0169176795,
-0.0167160891,
0.0498057567,
-0.0408778638,
-0.0555244051,
0.0034987999,
-0.0038912671,
-0.0285083018,
0.0959212705,
0.010608214,
0.0475865304,
0.0026191091,
0.0069376118,
-0.0073969727,
-0.0493899919,
-0.0157845039,
0.0111000594,
-0.0276996605,
-0.0153062288,
-0.0014838284,
0.058651682,
0.0176153164,
0.0667181909,
-0.0205682646,
-0.070672676,
0.0043052244,
0.007666104,
0.0055046384,
-0.0157885719,
0.0562515445,
-0.0695601031,
0.0127203539,
0.0483553,
-0.004620417,
0.0152264172,
0.0036080994,
-0.0272747632,
-0.064603053,
-0.0356044136,
0.0340241715,
-0.0008942678,
0.0497724898,
-0.0287987851,
0.0371919163,
-0.0207045283,
0.0001009972,
0.0087318607,
-0.0048302328,
-0.0493588708,
0.0247478038,
0.0025465041,
-0.0166717693,
0.010977583,
-0.0536059514,
-0.0511902422,
0.0204498861,
-0.0090925461,
0.0019768758,
-0.0013721542,
0.0525849089,
-0.0164528303,
0.0284687057,
0.0490715243,
0.0249883048,
-0.0077740601,
0.0527569987,
0.0198058467,
0.0487934053,
0.0473559164,
-0.0250155274,
-0.0050525335,
0.0058832946,
0.0063356296,
-0.0220364239,
-0.0017133021,
-0.0001692175,
0.0181554761,
-0.0600115135,
0.0033298491,
0.0236938391,
-0.0063416623,
0.0006025695,
0.067509152,
0.0385145321,
-0.0593605936,
0.0149027081,
0.0235060342,
-0.0228649396,
-0.0177056678,
0.0456090383,
0.000383573,
-0.0286487341,
-0.012378254,
-0.0243188106,
-0.042997025,
0.0199153163,
0.0275073703,
0.0261578728,
-0.0182974841,
0.0166220088,
-0.0524038598,
-0.0808431879,
0.0002116587,
0.0079722544,
-0.0114744846,
0.0644133985,
0.0265534408,
0.0549415499,
-0.0246695038,
-0.0071931779,
-0.0089143226,
0.0149766225,
-0.0099348119,
0.0159080103,
0.0202133786,
-6.512913878e-33,
0.0445674658,
-0.0443388037,
-0.0296033174,
-0.0318119526,
-0.000286812,
0.0365485549,
-0.0271781776,
-0.0241601318,
-0.0137374895,
0.0757196099,
0.0184451081,
0.0679274797,
-0.0006223093,
0.0227447283,
-0.0593053736,
-0.0307876673,
0.0210715421,
0.0347418934,
-0.0229438059,
0.0226407386,
0.0471352078,
-0.0148354238,
0.0802999735,
-0.0736141205,
0.0075750505,
-0.0109795025,
-0.059215188,
0.025913015,
0.0004781529,
0.0614544675,
-0.0112686679,
0.0112859448,
0.0017883166,
-0.0059903716,
0.0285581984,
-0.0144515717,
-0.0083201407,
0.000608347,
-0.0106543656,
0.0212454591,
-0.0533626825,
-0.0181221478,
0.0472375154,
-0.0186915584,
0.028635921,
-0.0227569025,
0.0684751794,
-0.0418340638,
0.0409146473,
0.0009321775,
-0.0333531983,
-0.0001945526,
-0.0262114648,
-0.024568513,
0.0514475554,
0.0551334321,
0.0014788349,
0.0060746926,
-0.0705290139,
0.0097498344,
-0.0337260291,
-0.0339265354,
0.0700418353,
0.0012741602,
-0.0108606862,
0.0593229756,
0.0319460593,
-0.0424290039,
-0.0590290204,
-0.0119149843,
0.0211456884,
0.0655182973,
0.0649406388,
0.0942461342,
0.0526146814,
-0.0266377442,
-0.0647294968,
0.007110124,
-0.0881764814,
0.0345156603,
0.0020865332,
0.0135946982,
-0.0383432806,
0.0163564421,
-0.0081356345,
0.0138526903,
-0.061586637,
-0.0076551931,
-0.010080561,
-0.0162801854,
-0.0750125423,
0.0546288416,
0.007247983,
-0.0281050522,
0.0525015704,
-0.0285003614,
-0.0038682795,
-0.0011591035,
0.0148626547,
0.0439745225,
0.0279172901,
-0.0421904027,
0.0772249773,
0.0103103118,
0.0553308763,
0.0074638408,
0.0298398323,
0.0344112366,
0.0192026347,
-0.0166501272,
-0.0451280847,
0.0141403247,
-0.0248706993,
0.0275181159,
-0.0021323343,
0.0187050253,
-0.0488805324,
-0.0095442738,
-0.0243625119,
-0.0015644378,
-0.0138040697,
0.0341696963,
-0.0272848867,
0.0099915657,
-0.0415317826,
-0.0308569148,
-0.0222982671,
-0.0955118015,
0.0517876223,
-0.0785434321,
-0.0205339603,
0.0165470988,
2.766e-7,
-0.0327320285,
0.0062384792,
0.0187886208,
-0.0339845009,
0.0031352881,
0.0954929367,
0.0187202115,
-0.0141443014,
0.005358085,
-0.0958747938,
0.0142163103,
0.0399919152,
0.0302502234,
-0.0059349104,
-0.0107083293,
0.0391487181,
0.030718388,
-0.0219814014,
-0.0137629667,
0.0316525586,
0.0299368184,
0.0551507249,
0.0358021073,
-0.0523964874,
0.1094263569,
-0.0209674742,
0.0171397682,
0.0009461207,
0.0191304162,
-0.0329550952,
0.0522212386,
-0.0158098023,
0.0020796019,
0.0585393608,
-0.0064711007,
-0.0329868868,
0.0203906819,
0.0153356334,
-0.0463237837,
-0.0170746725,
-0.0707532689,
0.0019605986,
0.0169523656,
-0.0744303539,
0.0415788926,
-0.0013883057,
-0.0236796513,
-0.0450634025,
-0.0630627945,
-0.0120384097,
-0.0102420459,
-0.0008727803,
-0.0034985803,
0.0439451039,
0.0425883681,
-0.045876272,
-0.0155854467,
-0.0498844236,
-0.0300837569,
-0.0094375294,
-0.0347040333,
0.0514470153,
-0.0456277505,
-0.0192318764,
0.0915155932,
-0.0041935942,
-0.0301093198,
2.053444908e-34,
0.0094048996,
0.0216351058,
0.024288144,
-0.0328484289,
0.0163120348,
0.0485927388,
-0.0161277521,
-0.0086108791,
0.0167887304,
-0.0103853755,
-0.02463484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00123v1 | Comparing Template-based and Template-free Language Model Probing | 2024-01-31T19:07:37 | 2024-01-31T19:07:37 | Sagi Shaier, Kevin Bennett, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The differences between cloze-task language model (LM) probing with 1)
expert-made templates and 2) naturally-occurring text have often been
overlooked. Here, we evaluate 16 different LMs on 10 probing English datasets
-- 4 template-based and 6 template-free -- in general and biomedical domains to
answer the following research questions: (RQ1) Do model rankings differ between
the two approaches? (RQ2) Do models' absolute scores differ between the two
approaches? (RQ3) Do the answers to RQ1 and RQ2 differ between general and
domain-specific models? Our findings are: 1) Template-free and template-based
approaches often rank models differently, except for the top domain-specific
models. 2) Scores decrease by up to 42% Acc@1 when comparing parallel
template-free and template-based prompts. 3) Perplexity is negatively
correlated with accuracy in the template-free approach, but,
counter-intuitively, they are positively correlated for template-based probing.
4) Models tend to predict the same answers frequently across prompts for
template-based probing, which is less common when employing template-free
techniques. | Comparing Template-based and Template-free Language Model Probing: The differences between cloze-task language model (LM) probing with 1)
expert-made templates and 2) naturally-occurring text have often been
overlooked. Here, we evaluate 16 different LMs on 10 probing English datasets
-- 4 template-based and 6 template-free -- in general and biomedical domains to
answer the following research questions: (RQ1) Do model rankings differ between
the two approaches? (RQ2) Do models' absolute scores differ between the two
approaches? (RQ3) Do the answers to RQ1 and RQ2 differ between general and
domain-specific models? Our findings are: 1) Template-free and template-based
approaches often rank models differently, except for the top domain-specific
models. 2) Scores decrease by up to 42% Acc@1 when comparing parallel
template-free and template-based prompts. 3) Perplexity is negatively
correlated with accuracy in the template-free approach, but,
counter-intuitively, they are positively correlated for template-based probing.
4) Models tend to predict the same answers frequently across prompts for
template-based probing, which is less common when employing template-free
techniques. | [
0.044546172,
-0.0245516393,
-0.0260105431,
-0.0159552824,
-0.0553409718,
0.0238626637,
0.0405545346,
0.0141380774,
-0.017993981,
-0.0420785248,
-0.0628802031,
-0.0618188903,
0.0225268416,
0.0294094663,
0.0391024761,
-0.0235589985,
0.0346862301,
-0.0066841384,
0.0570293181,
-0.0096189873,
-0.0115395682,
-0.0099372808,
0.0088794054,
0.03371213,
0.0623717867,
-0.0260278899,
-0.0062536779,
-0.0021758231,
-0.0197538137,
-0.0112680532,
0.0134492302,
0.089376837,
0.0327699669,
0.0131097408,
0.0000021449,
-0.0451655909,
0.0079277549,
-0.0002752116,
-0.0285721328,
0.0430254042,
0.0352583639,
0.0326278023,
0.0348361395,
0.0480857417,
-0.0270678736,
-0.051814232,
0.0249517485,
0.0176305287,
-0.0044172034,
0.0201981701,
-0.0171569772,
0.0165097229,
0.0024474943,
-0.0251281522,
0.0022286461,
-0.0281152651,
0.0279768687,
0.0064851823,
0.0474046096,
0.0285094269,
-0.0079097683,
0.040826425,
0.0071995547,
0.0105865533,
-0.000632576,
0.0273047984,
0.0601855628,
-0.0485711098,
-0.0097648529,
0.0411120094,
0.0029594207,
-0.0189004578,
0.0058198706,
-0.0069156201,
0.0196856596,
0.0939980596,
-0.0591344759,
0.0284429509,
0.014133051,
-0.0022783803,
0.0523822382,
-0.021731101,
0.013760725,
-0.0126207033,
-0.0210678428,
0.0477587543,
0.0278175287,
-0.0413117968,
-0.0029652982,
-0.0081341462,
0.0014742225,
-0.0561983176,
0.0041981041,
0.0082928166,
-0.0152976681,
-0.0070845857,
0.0089823548,
-0.0464774892,
0.0427406207,
0.0207732711,
0.0704088956,
0.0324143171,
-0.0093898745,
0.0340539142,
0.014009486,
0.0420991592,
0.0031589498,
0.0189437456,
-0.0459958799,
0.0248448215,
-0.0475513339,
-0.0398517251,
0.0022515657,
0.0160686187,
-0.0120248655,
-0.0343481898,
-0.0247005876,
-0.0053014643,
0.0393699557,
-0.0489269979,
-0.015729215,
0.0174115002,
-0.0120489253,
0.0399082713,
-0.0350569524,
0.0169061273,
-0.0263124723,
0.0341742076,
-0.0154904304,
-0.0551667288,
-0.0056131897,
0.0252748206,
-0.013285445,
-0.0448847078,
0.0164793842,
0.0294948183,
-0.0153839039,
-0.0366211273,
0.0620996468,
-0.0051729809,
-0.0406970717,
-0.0568443313,
0.0163155571,
-0.0890471339,
0.0173754469,
0.0703517571,
-0.001738994,
-0.0368078426,
-0.0035363056,
0.0105849225,
-0.0606054924,
0.0200738385,
0.0165224206,
0.0543057397,
0.0162412636,
0.0062904065,
0.0267889537,
0.0343462713,
-0.0148123726,
-0.0343303569,
-0.0097509157,
-0.0628966391,
0.034639813,
0.0425608382,
-0.0092760641,
-0.0017258794,
-0.0292060934,
0.031143222,
0.0446230248,
0.0159655046,
0.0409977473,
0.0398222134,
-0.0100038378,
0.002533054,
0.0494517572,
0.0895119905,
0.0130751394,
-0.0279569067,
0.0293891858,
0.0302534141,
0.0546409339,
0.0322362557,
-0.0313569419,
-0.0228960738,
-0.0132559119,
0.0172334872,
-0.0092845066,
0.0136506939,
-0.0326050892,
-0.0241766591,
-0.0674075857,
0.0106218616,
0.0212665629,
0.0035991112,
0.0548465177,
-0.0180326998,
-0.0247295424,
0.0500788838,
0.005716315,
-0.0249770731,
-0.0219603088,
-0.0461178795,
0.0148398858,
0.0291200969,
0.0263534877,
0.0018514054,
-0.0485896952,
0.0073382477,
-0.0225992668,
0.0672304705,
0.015649844,
0.004250627,
0.0085965581,
-0.0295249522,
-0.0168902241,
-0.0239750035,
0.0155408364,
-0.0159327965,
-0.0097277947,
-0.0070456224,
-0.002593878,
-0.0422899984,
-0.0413672142,
0.0233388785,
-0.0335849859,
0.0114587033,
-0.0134978024,
-0.0170693938,
0.0034736446,
0.0132028544,
-0.0238913558,
0.0697617829,
0.0482955091,
-0.0428675078,
0.0028957941,
-0.0012099815,
-0.0497435443,
-0.023971267,
-0.0020175485,
-0.0004202364,
0.0088221142,
0.0225809515,
0.0251552165,
-0.0450985245,
-0.0070761507,
-0.0591814332,
0.0970867798,
-0.0189996418,
0.0350612886,
-0.047133401,
0.0010485877,
-0.0486841276,
0.0539054237,
-0.0199063104,
0.0456302166,
0.0329670236,
-0.0282829814,
-0.0000550859,
-0.0434136577,
-0.0210450478,
-0.0278048571,
-0.0069428864,
-0.0115232272,
0.0080403397,
0.0062228916,
-0.0537782162,
-0.0056981621,
-0.087898545,
-0.029716203,
-0.0043160585,
0.0263347924,
0.0440438688,
0.0005696594,
-0.0224773344,
0.00731197,
-0.0461320132,
-0.0460732579,
0.0230906717,
0.0615067072,
0.0173551012,
-0.018758608,
-0.0048640301,
-0.0499566384,
-0.0261554085,
-0.0498041622,
0.0457963832,
0.0087280655,
-0.0194843039,
-0.0309757963,
0.0773255527,
-0.0254247505,
-0.0340779573,
0.003418914,
-0.0367826037,
0.0302756317,
-0.0168637782,
0.0765843615,
0.0245897882,
-0.0368697681,
0.0087730708,
0.0380545221,
-0.0203231964,
-0.0528848656,
-0.0225561503,
-0.0249725953,
0.0132282982,
-0.0077559636,
-0.0612687282,
-0.010555299,
0.0984813571,
0.0383170545,
0.0101233898,
-0.0375439227,
0.0461736545,
-0.0523887835,
-0.0111557124,
-0.0697087348,
0.008824762,
-0.0257342402,
0.0821171477,
-0.0206973851,
-0.0597813651,
0.0617510155,
-0.0201763809,
0.0023936071,
-0.0682778433,
0.0142541574,
-0.010744567,
0.0120682605,
0.0058520595,
0.0027428847,
0.0443139821,
-0.0657153875,
-0.0474193655,
-0.0047300719,
-0.0004458246,
-0.0360594802,
0.0244894568,
-0.0230282061,
-0.0101662083,
0.0240149926,
-0.0110364091,
-0.0248593017,
-0.024841018,
-0.009929616,
0.021100061,
0.0678635761,
-0.0075301109,
-0.011661076,
0.0470719822,
0.0287456978,
0.0129479393,
-0.0386844724,
0.0148594929,
-0.0175093357,
0.0666384026,
0.0726284385,
0.0263548288,
0.0484570116,
-0.0424478427,
0.0210327711,
0.0101592913,
0.0395075046,
0.0225881543,
0.0265062638,
0.0068129036,
0.0503860824,
-0.0272196699,
-0.0584908687,
0.0168854371,
0.0331053771,
-0.0388796255,
-0.0163119547,
0.1341081709,
0.0440309234,
-0.040184617,
-0.0003112739,
-0.0659175813,
0.0137150269,
0.0418737978,
0.0114200804,
-0.0272353496,
-0.0209240913,
0.0101750502,
0.011587441,
-0.0193241071,
-0.0016184561,
-0.0044791154,
-0.0833773017,
0.0155615341,
-0.0220661145,
-0.0151707456,
0.0087159863,
-0.0650976598,
0.0336433388,
0.0349221639,
0.0191260967,
0.0367905721,
-0.0325630121,
0.0307861213,
0.0085446434,
-0.0798382461,
-0.0989169776,
0.0446941815,
-0.024681339,
0.0454638004,
0.0536533967,
-0.0187268946,
-0.0535361543,
-0.0338546783,
0.0404520966,
-0.0327469483,
0.0257289726,
-0.041267056,
0.013415792,
0.0474522449,
0.0127881672,
-0.0615000203,
0.0264043733,
-0.041499164,
0.0277297758,
-0.0189710055,
0.0783958882,
-0.0104363402,
-0.021841405,
-0.0364433266,
-0.0202926137,
0.0077907704,
0.1208657995,
0.067528449,
-0.0776112974,
-0.00546468,
0.0175825935,
-0.0004513926,
0.0429194272,
-0.0424717814,
-0.0186172258,
-0.0104571246,
-0.0075396909,
-0.0545026064,
-0.0446889214,
0.0690895766,
0.0208890196,
0.0292014517,
0.0468774028,
-0.0374041907,
-0.0387241431,
-0.0329300798,
0.047676228,
0.0361824967,
0.0285352822,
-0.1106243655,
-0.0154344849,
0.00680982,
-0.0285896733,
-0.0222953893,
0.0166401751,
-0.0647755563,
-0.0567052364,
0.0116172871,
0.0025237079,
0.0308416914,
-0.0191366691,
0.002879909,
-0.0246222615,
0.0537604652,
-0.0017110235,
-0.0618028864,
0.0388447158,
-0.0041512591,
-0.0439852364,
-0.0019564321,
0.0071214209,
-0.0334004723,
0.0047023953,
0.0216821693,
0.0396742448,
0.0006530139,
-0.0284066442,
0.0064488775,
0.0196116325,
0.0818338394,
0.0273344573,
-0.0109876292,
-0.0219491012,
-0.0144745521,
-0.0110307001,
-0.0113422694,
-0.021664869,
-0.0377888046,
0.0004504358,
0.0302016493,
-0.0355399661,
-0.0104355467,
-0.090353623,
0.0528473295,
-0.0657100156,
0.0222773496,
-0.038327653,
0.0043133581,
0.015900502,
-0.0101968357,
-0.0024766093,
0.0309004672,
-0.0365328006,
0.0266373977,
0.006874844,
0.0702285394,
-0.035550151,
0.0012293283,
0.0011543793,
0.0367195047,
-0.0431110151,
-0.0409017839,
0.0160134565,
-0.0106735975,
0.0032445691,
-0.0254925359,
0.06732703,
0.0015993613,
0.0110032018,
-0.0358591713,
-0.0124171041,
0.0227006283,
0.0078676622,
0.0655393302,
0.0117397057,
-0.0246583801,
-0.0356664918,
0.0806692615,
0.0548122451,
0.0035806401,
0.010192601,
-0.0352488942,
-0.0283884425,
0.0094570592,
0.0307746883,
0.0160746388,
-0.055084046,
-0.0174651835,
-0.0927286968,
-0.0480520986,
0.0239429753,
-0.0048822979,
-0.0184294861,
-0.0321850069,
-0.0076272599,
0.0667857751,
0.0064160619,
-0.0544016398,
-0.0368155986,
0.0658030435,
-0.0087862089,
-0.0293572415,
-0.0142221125,
-6.919287418e-33,
-0.0197249167,
-0.0444452502,
-0.0118470062,
-0.0278225094,
0.0162915178,
0.0423024148,
-0.0477545336,
0.0394756421,
-0.0171874445,
0.0141508467,
-0.02401275,
-0.0010564489,
0.0253699534,
-0.0159083419,
0.043063689,
0.002307653,
0.0093462048,
-0.0109469881,
-0.0296588317,
-0.00556739,
0.0190822259,
0.0353565887,
0.0602133833,
-0.0125429519,
0.0542538837,
-0.0325313173,
0.0529139079,
-0.0068611046,
-0.028019933,
0.0385509357,
-0.0361362211,
0.0384564176,
0.0443761647,
-0.0529640839,
-0.0256766137,
0.0067459564,
-0.0511538535,
-0.0489509553,
0.0829136074,
-0.0207329076,
-0.0345793217,
-0.0078806672,
0.0323589891,
-0.0117860623,
-0.0291994996,
0.0152652925,
0.041329097,
-0.0181537215,
-0.0070049106,
0.0168683752,
-0.036042057,
-0.0092891818,
0.0059830523,
-0.0284889508,
-0.0101825614,
0.0649756193,
-0.0380435288,
0.0144168539,
-0.0359348468,
0.033656545,
0.0497279987,
0.0518173724,
0.052938804,
0.0312139411,
0.0367809422,
0.0362819433,
-0.0159349516,
-0.0226603225,
-0.0259659104,
-0.0152078494,
0.058606524,
0.0252859425,
0.0444092639,
-0.0080173127,
0.0231779199,
0.0192943607,
-0.0575444251,
0.0280871615,
0.0431490913,
0.0307742022,
0.0417183489,
-0.0320819505,
-0.0257804673,
-0.0718612298,
-0.0234503672,
-0.0135742333,
-0.0446181037,
-0.0197552703,
0.0278355349,
-0.0444392301,
-0.0185153987,
-0.0392720662,
0.0422558039,
-0.0020146545,
-0.0210721437,
-0.0015753645,
-0.0243930593,
0.0317613259,
0.0016349049,
0.0376916565,
-0.0985169485,
0.0104531655,
0.0019478352,
0.0449189469,
0.0205102582,
0.0128883999,
-0.0246011429,
-0.0104032317,
-0.0496034287,
-0.0312498063,
-0.0147786643,
-0.0109997662,
0.0027132733,
-0.0166320447,
0.0546013452,
0.0010338465,
-0.0022965644,
0.0191596746,
0.0461661518,
-0.0235705134,
-0.0577497557,
0.0327866115,
-0.0027440013,
0.0205507781,
-0.0078535816,
-0.0068798671,
-0.0182806086,
0.0148002533,
0.0445974432,
0.0086465422,
-0.0164359342,
0.0161412228,
2.773e-7,
0.0812088326,
0.068280004,
-0.0189419966,
0.007223912,
0.024773024,
0.0274880342,
-0.0221341085,
0.0028224993,
0.0298643541,
-0.0112813488,
-0.0094338162,
-0.0191587899,
0.036514841,
0.0025903725,
-0.0623075105,
0.0418413654,
-0.0771216452,
0.0350679755,
-0.0439893492,
0.0253308956,
-0.0069599119,
0.0492331237,
-0.0300763641,
-0.0176150873,
-0.0352642201,
0.004269924,
0.0382729284,
-0.0307739042,
-0.0111558381,
0.0318824463,
-0.0022402285,
0.0261905808,
0.0320060663,
0.0821080357,
0.0203795061,
0.0234688576,
0.0299972761,
0.0245600399,
-0.0098695224,
-0.007060959,
0.0123496596,
-0.0287931487,
0.0033711293,
-0.1029557288,
0.0645248517,
-0.0651279837,
-0.0403995402,
-0.0200519431,
0.0072651817,
0.0046533076,
0.0420912504,
-0.0179411527,
-0.0125804665,
0.0120812338,
0.0225535017,
-0.03321914,
-0.0165214315,
-0.0155841997,
-0.0373273082,
-0.0139281582,
-0.0437919423,
-0.0554525442,
-0.0339295082,
-0.031933222,
-0.0103893429,
-0.0776366666,
-0.0113015072,
3.074582846e-34,
0.0385465547,
0.0089317784,
0.0285388269,
0.0250261575,
0.0145578841,
-0.011733178,
0.0123165483,
0.0184262842,
0.0020998006,
-0.1353868097,
-0.0165189374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18070v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18070v2 | Do Language Models Exhibit the Same Cognitive Biases in Problem Solving as Human Learners? | 2024-01-31T18:48:20 | 2024-06-17T15:08:05 | Andreas Opedal, Alessandro Stolfo, Haruki Shirakami, Ying Jiao, Ryan Cotterell, Bernhard Schölkopf, Abulhair Saparov, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | There is increasing interest in employing large language models (LLMs) as
cognitive models. For such purposes, it is central to understand which
properties of human cognition are well-modeled by LLMs, and which are not. In
this work, we study the biases of LLMs in relation to those known in children
when solving arithmetic word problems. Surveying the learning science
literature, we posit that the problem-solving process can be split into three
distinct steps: text comprehension, solution planning and solution execution.
We construct tests for each one in order to understand whether current LLMs
display the same cognitive biases as children in these steps. We generate a
novel set of word problems for each of these tests, using a neuro-symbolic
approach that enables fine-grained control over the problem features. We find
evidence that LLMs, with and without instruction-tuning, exhibit human-like
biases in both the text-comprehension and the solution-planning steps of the
solving process, but not in the final step, in which the arithmetic expressions
are executed to obtain the answer. | Do Language Models Exhibit the Same Cognitive Biases in Problem Solving as Human Learners?: There is increasing interest in employing large language models (LLMs) as
cognitive models. For such purposes, it is central to understand which
properties of human cognition are well-modeled by LLMs, and which are not. In
this work, we study the biases of LLMs in relation to those known in children
when solving arithmetic word problems. Surveying the learning science
literature, we posit that the problem-solving process can be split into three
distinct steps: text comprehension, solution planning and solution execution.
We construct tests for each one in order to understand whether current LLMs
display the same cognitive biases as children in these steps. We generate a
novel set of word problems for each of these tests, using a neuro-symbolic
approach that enables fine-grained control over the problem features. We find
evidence that LLMs, with and without instruction-tuning, exhibit human-like
biases in both the text-comprehension and the solution-planning steps of the
solving process, but not in the final step, in which the arithmetic expressions
are executed to obtain the answer. | [
0.030966742,
0.0256775245,
-0.0389996022,
0.0292554032,
-0.0713207722,
0.0152408089,
0.0075697182,
0.0041932696,
-0.0212032609,
-0.0237176009,
0.0080979243,
-0.0147333359,
0.0161907561,
-0.0197428744,
0.0254400689,
-0.0338394344,
0.0472355075,
-0.0559264757,
0.0665670037,
-0.0028301668,
-0.0637567863,
-0.0132108871,
-0.0467221104,
-0.0128245382,
-0.0174647477,
-0.0326970555,
0.0111318752,
-0.0707036257,
-0.0215950944,
-0.026907932,
-0.0363692641,
0.0378405526,
0.0309627037,
0.0295460802,
0.0000020654,
-0.0595387369,
0.030079674,
-0.0172423106,
-0.0394505523,
0.0426326878,
0.0222010706,
0.0105300136,
-0.0033515375,
0.0179755744,
-0.0368174687,
0.0366394818,
0.026708601,
0.0251511019,
0.0029906114,
0.0240967963,
0.0024100572,
0.0033365458,
0.0158657562,
0.0124160368,
0.0679729879,
-0.0482518412,
0.0221921671,
0.0542795099,
0.0364378281,
-0.0149555765,
-0.0524837561,
0.0152766202,
0.0339907408,
0.0301762782,
-0.0442315787,
-0.0056845704,
-0.0056627919,
0.0099303573,
-0.0213413294,
0.0200999696,
0.0029744492,
-0.014281827,
-0.0227467064,
-0.0058502234,
0.0103202919,
0.0324179754,
-0.0818758383,
0.0717391893,
0.0080209449,
-0.0005871904,
0.0163984112,
-0.0355359465,
0.0113206105,
0.0371386185,
-0.0016061977,
0.0873283818,
-0.009965593,
-0.036787264,
0.0213742387,
0.0158782192,
-0.0439188406,
-0.0483550504,
0.0260763746,
0.0622073524,
-0.009759699,
0.0386611149,
-0.0045697652,
-0.0195666756,
-0.0212305505,
-0.051579278,
0.0686280355,
0.0815942213,
0.0502122976,
0.0077860383,
-0.0207161214,
0.0663094819,
-0.0274816491,
0.0378998369,
-0.038774509,
0.0689462945,
-0.0019510788,
-0.0574464612,
-0.0333830528,
0.0198827926,
0.0082840361,
-0.0105861435,
-0.0375208892,
0.0149351601,
0.0136970086,
-0.0155404964,
-0.0172273368,
-0.0169790927,
0.0367123634,
-0.0186060593,
-0.0634208918,
0.0126669379,
-0.0480235629,
0.0536191277,
-0.0442145765,
-0.0132156909,
-0.0029595855,
-0.0076547465,
-0.023491323,
-0.0271877162,
0.0174932759,
0.0670030937,
-0.0353541113,
0.0167859793,
-0.0126603395,
-0.0256424751,
0.0205860566,
-0.0749046206,
0.0320998728,
-0.0490147658,
0.0074856002,
0.0655723438,
-0.0163081866,
-0.0302035194,
0.0085066874,
0.0073934393,
0.0110659832,
0.0133573711,
0.0571411289,
0.0403046869,
0.0530816205,
-0.0060430085,
-0.0149732614,
0.0579719357,
0.080326438,
-0.0195554476,
-0.0280308407,
-0.0180008076,
-0.0102208117,
0.0332473069,
-0.0018975349,
-0.0063412217,
-0.0489597209,
-0.029227253,
0.0185020268,
0.0593932234,
0.0214487482,
0.0593290776,
-0.0164541584,
0.001125405,
0.0546432324,
0.0659579486,
-0.0256620087,
0.0177548863,
0.0011555633,
-0.0289688352,
0.0616574399,
0.0319889821,
-0.0754931793,
0.0616125502,
-0.0311343428,
-0.0093900179,
-0.0184888113,
0.012540577,
-0.0085577564,
-0.0363949127,
-0.0397017784,
0.0495360307,
0.0215705782,
0.0221725032,
0.0382392742,
-0.0156819634,
-0.0211314037,
0.0281724073,
-0.0337583944,
-0.0027519907,
0.0170675498,
-0.0539628826,
0.0475948639,
0.0094265174,
0.0571422093,
-0.0129145756,
-0.0016863674,
0.0318544284,
-0.0182382409,
0.0127533479,
0.0420425273,
0.0099940449,
-0.030880183,
-0.0216305666,
-0.0065979934,
-0.0354357362,
0.0073052864,
-0.0326190069,
0.0200321805,
-0.0092761554,
-0.0014980002,
-0.0265238266,
-0.0131228771,
0.0461461917,
-0.0582358949,
-0.0345601477,
-0.0752101764,
0.0096886121,
-0.0107116438,
-0.0178979766,
0.0182045717,
0.0618518256,
0.000889901,
-0.0122186765,
-0.0039385138,
0.0068393531,
-0.0807555616,
-0.0069691734,
0.0499335118,
-0.0553795733,
-0.0070236367,
0.0167609025,
-0.003573315,
-0.0023657456,
0.0885033086,
-0.0871864632,
0.0219707433,
0.0316140689,
0.0602558516,
-0.0195291601,
-0.048760578,
-0.0375068486,
0.0839330256,
0.0052154739,
0.0379991829,
0.0057752887,
-0.0184089672,
-0.003615788,
-0.0205442254,
-0.0025206385,
-0.0086723752,
-0.0112307332,
-0.0041849809,
-0.0274620764,
-0.0250458475,
-0.0663655624,
-0.0065234816,
-0.0073262043,
-0.0344537571,
0.0376802832,
0.0520668812,
0.0050897971,
-0.0446367115,
-0.0211318452,
0.0052168565,
-0.008368914,
0.0198675748,
-0.0039799623,
0.0444634408,
0.0171404164,
0.0089653339,
-0.0167400166,
-0.0475060083,
-0.0280663967,
-0.0700382888,
0.0240068976,
0.05269612,
-0.0119692534,
-0.0607730336,
0.0642905682,
-0.0267913807,
0.0152295399,
-0.0007646405,
0.0115295229,
0.0266718771,
0.008700816,
0.0445245802,
0.0928396583,
0.0014773972,
0.0355043933,
0.0523907654,
-0.0404341258,
-0.06009252,
0.00362525,
-0.0016845671,
-0.0103866812,
0.0053582946,
-0.0719987676,
-0.0260979068,
0.1106187776,
0.0189364012,
-0.0074059246,
0.0029089043,
0.0784584358,
-0.0487882979,
-0.0126214884,
-0.04244674,
-0.0657744184,
-0.0247949567,
0.0465478525,
-0.0229782239,
-0.0492944606,
0.0706523582,
0.0318365693,
0.007085958,
-0.0666817948,
0.0593984723,
-0.0459671579,
0.0460788459,
-0.000973516,
-0.0036732643,
-0.0285657868,
-0.0101154102,
-0.0946651772,
-0.0090985317,
0.0166600496,
-0.0228778943,
0.0484590717,
-0.0659020618,
-0.0233786982,
-0.01729412,
-0.0321223773,
-0.0313828588,
0.01372129,
-0.0218931828,
0.0161399841,
0.0335395969,
-0.0210737064,
-0.0471598804,
-0.0143850818,
0.0691867471,
0.0065155518,
-0.0354809687,
-0.0135738654,
-0.0050261738,
-0.0131363897,
0.0277195834,
0.0132433334,
0.050303258,
-0.0569691025,
0.0078686522,
0.0186117794,
0.0639734641,
0.0060807713,
0.018330412,
0.046759095,
0.0578838587,
-0.0272708759,
-0.0190040339,
0.0659795478,
0.0254114009,
-0.0581111349,
0.0128348917,
0.0706542581,
0.0750389919,
-0.0198417418,
0.0229043905,
-0.0823710784,
-0.0284073688,
0.024721561,
0.0148844235,
-0.0476020016,
0.0006500209,
0.0230870619,
-0.0421412103,
-0.0151014701,
-0.0419089161,
-0.0238773916,
-0.0984018371,
0.0053360062,
0.0144046219,
-0.0367878154,
0.0076267533,
-0.0207986776,
-0.0065932758,
0.0348259769,
0.0133734187,
0.0239262674,
-0.0302025713,
0.0221040752,
0.0089444425,
0.0041832649,
0.0094302101,
0.0259019397,
0.0045135329,
0.0089100311,
0.0060609542,
-0.0102127697,
-0.0490244254,
-0.0601213649,
0.0714394599,
0.0084711444,
0.0075418293,
-0.024585655,
-0.0086710518,
0.0108919051,
0.0193181466,
-0.0500792786,
0.0113877403,
-0.0055241087,
-0.045465976,
0.0229865555,
0.1002836898,
0.0099502252,
-0.0117142117,
-0.0078113824,
0.0233397055,
-0.0212262906,
0.0559926257,
0.0309746396,
-0.0480276048,
-0.0111453095,
-0.0120999971,
-0.0332288519,
0.0099494355,
-0.0455229767,
0.0115074506,
0.0411357954,
0.0397177637,
-0.0354302488,
-0.0157545265,
0.0726126358,
0.0256094635,
0.0258176159,
-0.0204896107,
0.027941443,
-0.0312674493,
-0.0316747427,
0.029137753,
-0.0091387564,
0.0419668183,
-0.0568232685,
0.0158159826,
-0.0313860849,
-0.0688854828,
-0.0126510933,
0.0065822764,
-0.0679594949,
-0.0573785044,
0.0033469934,
-0.0093733734,
0.0306969676,
-0.0708243474,
0.0364095345,
-0.0574612543,
-0.0201661587,
-0.0105071608,
-0.0326234587,
0.0249693878,
-0.0440511666,
0.0463041589,
0.0314324796,
-0.0127896406,
-0.0014450052,
0.0165681336,
0.0230805632,
0.0667155087,
-0.0318790674,
0.0025519957,
0.0249025766,
0.0303968545,
0.0185213797,
0.0036397926,
0.0174476877,
-0.0229062904,
-0.0011982924,
-0.0307628307,
-0.0305514839,
0.0137009593,
-0.0504970513,
0.0054599936,
0.0071234042,
0.0025969974,
-0.0355584472,
-0.0007814408,
0.0228214953,
0.0223141722,
0.0587869734,
-0.0121976286,
0.0193899982,
0.0234712549,
0.0181370005,
0.0168444868,
0.0061534047,
-0.0421645604,
0.0522702821,
0.0500845201,
0.0779799819,
-0.0098646795,
0.0159429554,
-0.091433309,
-0.0575313866,
-0.0214769505,
-0.0740163103,
0.0302860662,
-0.0054652635,
-0.0051856115,
-0.0358700305,
-0.0255613942,
-0.0645990074,
0.0132358763,
-0.0064343615,
-0.0427582301,
-0.0034430949,
-0.0070094075,
0.0589669123,
0.0296249799,
0.0458215959,
-0.0494114645,
0.0170644037,
-0.0063768257,
0.0387080386,
-0.0152674355,
-0.002318437,
0.0072775609,
-0.0338897519,
0.0223755166,
-0.0002089497,
-0.0064016567,
0.016822746,
-0.0850694031,
-0.052507326,
-0.0428994335,
0.0062663779,
0.0130408546,
-0.0484700426,
0.0204712469,
0.0374756753,
-0.0416366756,
-0.0528417937,
0.0272882078,
0.0573644228,
-0.0367343761,
-0.0256855171,
-0.0602410287,
-5.699202158e-33,
-0.0317589045,
-0.0544891357,
0.0522977747,
-0.0061594201,
0.0241932422,
-0.0361981913,
-0.0388059355,
0.0827117935,
-0.0384356976,
-0.01336045,
-0.0189494025,
-0.0268302523,
0.0091092028,
-0.0318741128,
0.0232780259,
0.0097461063,
-0.0263749063,
-0.0266185366,
-0.0409809053,
-0.0809848681,
0.0018129058,
-0.0499153882,
0.0499978699,
-0.0132733481,
0.0166394152,
0.0034797585,
0.028842682,
0.0058573782,
-0.0314715728,
0.0264727641,
-0.0134503748,
0.0324220732,
0.0410814546,
-0.0030560927,
-0.0180842448,
0.0182115193,
0.0108368946,
-0.0372876041,
0.0868661329,
0.020892024,
-0.0241321269,
-0.0362236202,
0.0339082889,
0.0080401758,
-0.0480406731,
0.0011300964,
0.0065904208,
-0.0350924209,
0.0095109669,
0.0444763377,
-0.0848850757,
-0.0076058498,
-0.0225832872,
-0.0016675278,
0.0100795226,
0.0092615196,
-0.043256484,
-0.0283381026,
-0.0332544744,
0.055665262,
0.0493589193,
0.0106233237,
0.0326250494,
0.0095567722,
-0.0039772214,
0.0208912585,
0.0565215424,
0.0151673388,
-0.0429502018,
-0.0266144741,
0.0257313699,
0.0201316793,
0.0605168454,
-0.0098269489,
0.0697452947,
0.0376355201,
-0.0243672635,
-0.0324547179,
0.035201408,
0.0605343953,
0.0510471575,
0.0158086363,
-0.0436331108,
-0.0322992429,
-0.0649307966,
0.0245222431,
-0.0536900088,
-0.0022998527,
0.0096296147,
-0.0358502567,
0.0454856977,
-0.0373480879,
0.0078042015,
-0.0028199644,
0.001181756,
0.0085614203,
0.0185318869,
0.0440650508,
-0.0135429054,
0.0080238394,
-0.0774889588,
-0.0322921574,
-0.0122273797,
0.0252678134,
0.0273853298,
0.0343024172,
-0.0305564683,
0.0026928242,
-0.024891356,
-0.0202466082,
-0.045249179,
-0.0328854434,
0.0704663694,
-0.0304458849,
0.0282752495,
-0.0104251625,
-0.0122994911,
-0.0560908131,
-0.0179490373,
-0.0731950551,
-0.006144789,
0.0311011299,
-0.0393925235,
0.0174937341,
-0.0056711575,
-0.0099555319,
-0.0279940013,
0.046271041,
0.0115630217,
-0.0360584967,
-0.0117472094,
0.0005195329,
2.831e-7,
0.025508156,
0.0693731532,
0.0159048177,
0.0489939451,
0.0314691402,
0.0001378944,
-0.0180526562,
-0.0652464256,
0.0535162129,
-0.006877433,
-0.0186142959,
0.0565447025,
0.0144061344,
0.0009231878,
0.0165189896,
0.0357050449,
-0.0036463926,
0.060527131,
-0.0324813947,
0.0443204194,
0.0220554825,
-0.0118172746,
0.0138592627,
0.0074525517,
-0.0586886741,
-0.0158966184,
0.0252118669,
-0.0393100716,
0.0295384098,
0.0017621322,
-0.0325393528,
-0.0047122906,
0.0363397524,
0.0645225793,
0.0206295382,
0.0266506448,
0.0097067729,
0.0380757712,
0.0211585779,
0.0322511122,
-0.0178799722,
-0.0250724889,
-0.0441028327,
-0.0495193116,
0.0449937321,
-0.0464492589,
-0.0306218583,
0.0208900142,
0.0353489108,
-0.017079616,
0.0161489025,
-0.0044305352,
0.049388364,
0.002270112,
0.0234217234,
0.0063322848,
-0.0117183439,
-0.0272471979,
-0.0311095044,
0.0319946669,
-0.0456205569,
-0.0414040722,
-0.0569587387,
0.0248797406,
0.0332648717,
-0.0148988822,
0.0060885451,
2.169612908e-34,
0.0136254514,
-0.0100722462,
0.0460532233,
0.0086855898,
0.0199073888,
-0.0101004699,
-0.0113585107,
0.0424756221,
0.0586566143,
-0.0532708243,
-0.0132838767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18059v1 | RAPTOR: Recursive Abstractive Processing for Tree-Organized Retrieval | 2024-01-31T18:30:21 | 2024-01-31T18:30:21 | Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh Khanna, Anna Goldie, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented language models can better adapt to changes in world
state and incorporate long-tail knowledge. However, most existing methods
retrieve only short contiguous chunks from a retrieval corpus, limiting
holistic understanding of the overall document context. We introduce the novel
approach of recursively embedding, clustering, and summarizing chunks of text,
constructing a tree with differing levels of summarization from the bottom up.
At inference time, our RAPTOR model retrieves from this tree, integrating
information across lengthy documents at different levels of abstraction.
Controlled experiments show that retrieval with recursive summaries offers
significant improvements over traditional retrieval-augmented LMs on several
tasks. On question-answering tasks that involve complex, multi-step reasoning,
we show state-of-the-art results; for example, by coupling RAPTOR retrieval
with the use of GPT-4, we can improve the best performance on the QuALITY
benchmark by 20% in absolute accuracy. | RAPTOR: Recursive Abstractive Processing for Tree-Organized Retrieval: Retrieval-augmented language models can better adapt to changes in world
state and incorporate long-tail knowledge. However, most existing methods
retrieve only short contiguous chunks from a retrieval corpus, limiting
holistic understanding of the overall document context. We introduce the novel
approach of recursively embedding, clustering, and summarizing chunks of text,
constructing a tree with differing levels of summarization from the bottom up.
At inference time, our RAPTOR model retrieves from this tree, integrating
information across lengthy documents at different levels of abstraction.
Controlled experiments show that retrieval with recursive summaries offers
significant improvements over traditional retrieval-augmented LMs on several
tasks. On question-answering tasks that involve complex, multi-step reasoning,
we show state-of-the-art results; for example, by coupling RAPTOR retrieval
with the use of GPT-4, we can improve the best performance on the QuALITY
benchmark by 20% in absolute accuracy. | [
0.0260881931,
0.0197858848,
0.0003095635,
0.0230278466,
-0.0146687487,
-0.0059273322,
-0.0916726515,
-0.0279817097,
-0.032516405,
-0.0411509126,
0.010612024,
-0.0134497425,
0.0051949844,
0.0021718284,
-0.0098116798,
-0.0716257244,
0.0376312062,
0.0061524878,
0.0467406623,
0.0068627773,
0.0355717316,
0.0357612222,
0.0334315374,
0.0118844593,
0.0040010237,
-0.0212817229,
-0.021702759,
0.0057181735,
0.0118280575,
-0.0272104926,
0.0149038564,
-0.0201758817,
0.0557581782,
0.0369243361,
0.0000019921,
-0.0140425805,
-0.0554620177,
-0.0056691254,
0.0003342054,
-0.0231840443,
0.015488199,
-0.0234627295,
0.0368318222,
0.0317503735,
-0.0191968102,
-0.0477040336,
-0.0024163213,
0.0628580377,
0.0720022321,
0.0801836401,
-0.0085311858,
-0.0695870668,
0.0729308426,
-0.0140437605,
-0.0131211681,
-0.026142342,
-0.0020107608,
0.0164326914,
0.0158582646,
0.0393073075,
0.0003208501,
0.0175413433,
0.0423243046,
0.0153393848,
0.0127923796,
0.0349994637,
-0.0586277246,
0.0438475497,
0.014441249,
0.047601942,
0.008694265,
-0.041896563,
-0.0012618842,
0.0045755301,
-0.0103419302,
-0.0230964087,
-0.0698627532,
0.0362892598,
-0.0384356044,
0.0164334849,
0.0128512066,
0.005749831,
0.0268656388,
0.0265244264,
-0.0462934487,
0.0877172276,
-0.0006916899,
-0.0491085164,
-0.0095682554,
0.0203901771,
-0.0013676588,
-0.0330641828,
0.0010001542,
0.0585670471,
-0.0360886343,
0.0264800452,
-0.0100713121,
-0.0390343778,
0.0238257572,
-0.0126667628,
-0.0121221906,
0.0560691059,
0.0126404604,
0.0626318306,
-0.0294547472,
0.0277960375,
-0.0089559499,
-0.0097473385,
-0.0348903798,
-0.0576556139,
-0.0599669628,
-0.0372781493,
-0.0559619404,
0.0674781874,
-0.0646617487,
-0.011695818,
-0.0004525647,
0.0492814183,
0.0158139914,
-0.0287554897,
-0.0180311576,
0.0070744934,
-0.0311437342,
0.0074949618,
-0.0192291662,
0.023172034,
-0.0557756387,
-0.005420689,
0.0428478643,
0.0016895251,
-0.0089184744,
-0.0143641727,
0.0227714386,
-0.0129685169,
-0.0050069378,
0.0045412728,
-0.0084759183,
-0.0318420306,
0.007228143,
-0.0394185372,
0.0054112785,
-0.0358178206,
-0.0073761987,
-0.0753044188,
0.0314777456,
-0.0014394276,
-0.0228195749,
0.0274933334,
-0.0053062811,
0.0741215497,
-0.0161110517,
0.0503364578,
0.0001347359,
-0.0081930468,
0.0258007087,
0.0109485546,
-0.0115307821,
0.0340522937,
0.0266497377,
0.0417100005,
0.0397658907,
0.0212625321,
0.0154560376,
-0.0047683674,
0.0019536519,
-0.0112023875,
0.0509669073,
0.0243872069,
-0.0798958838,
-0.0105251279,
0.0059999377,
0.0343659446,
-0.0352737419,
0.0147542255,
0.0190596636,
0.0632352307,
0.0040610731,
0.0067871939,
0.0128756948,
0.0123409322,
-0.0085126422,
0.0077280933,
-0.0522110015,
0.0296540447,
-0.0674838945,
0.0588143878,
0.0146028958,
0.0198273715,
-0.0283436812,
-0.0383397117,
-0.0080274465,
0.0278716292,
0.0166801922,
0.0229802672,
0.0404083245,
0.0173155386,
-0.0327642672,
0.0199767612,
-0.0008400911,
-0.05553817,
-0.0003953752,
-0.0283680335,
0.0335275829,
0.0575954318,
0.0654796585,
-0.0484969541,
0.002943228,
0.0133221699,
0.013562547,
0.0265814383,
0.0042764451,
-0.009654033,
0.0025807156,
-0.0432253592,
-0.0379907154,
-0.0239049103,
0.0048685237,
0.017131472,
0.053151004,
-0.0120712752,
0.0563772209,
-0.0357042179,
0.005949466,
0.0258025844,
-0.0101407543,
-0.007074092,
0.0040593417,
-0.0128016397,
0.0166334044,
0.0161711164,
0.0144439489,
0.0183914378,
0.0446042605,
-0.0257388372,
-0.0698642358,
-0.0060716872,
-0.0535939448,
-0.0494556352,
0.0208473373,
-0.0022559152,
-0.0140751423,
0.0381992832,
-0.0442616343,
-0.0587391146,
0.0083763814,
-0.0553788915,
0.0843174234,
-0.0603510886,
0.0046437364,
0.0384340286,
-0.0231581721,
-0.0259793885,
0.1110633612,
-0.0161034279,
-0.0041094474,
-0.0018546249,
-0.0104555972,
-0.007981333,
-0.0251948815,
-0.0440252349,
-0.0169324297,
-0.011947046,
0.015087829,
0.0581311323,
-0.0182846412,
-0.0501191355,
0.0056098322,
-0.0835044309,
0.0310429055,
-0.0343605056,
0.0221198834,
0.0191894695,
0.0247816667,
0.0190060921,
-0.0025280365,
-0.0510299429,
-0.0182333142,
0.0138630383,
0.0437910967,
0.0265599918,
-0.0149308592,
0.0014599635,
-0.0395676643,
-0.0399677642,
-0.0170750115,
0.0164346453,
-0.0503510125,
-0.034471903,
-0.0206090305,
-0.0147930086,
-0.0506294146,
0.0257780068,
-0.0310596619,
0.0248730835,
0.0112280343,
-0.0600692853,
0.0412651747,
0.0482163988,
0.0045286785,
0.0201747511,
0.0241622385,
0.0027693228,
-0.0603593029,
0.03017148,
-0.0120634455,
0.0022142224,
0.0525084138,
-0.0126362639,
0.0212355014,
0.0540456288,
-0.0125536462,
0.0015478849,
-0.0244989023,
-0.0120904511,
-0.0012535296,
0.0191041324,
-0.0454602838,
-0.0482975394,
-0.0056264871,
0.0250610821,
-0.0670337006,
-0.0446432792,
0.0811953768,
-0.0263009854,
-0.0232439321,
-0.0451803356,
-0.0079077268,
-0.0590360165,
0.0844764113,
0.0100407777,
-0.0033292663,
-0.0213554446,
-0.0286003333,
-0.004135957,
-0.0229933113,
0.01162594,
-0.039854493,
0.0684326589,
-0.0150358146,
0.0422730036,
-0.0023410518,
-0.0400962122,
-0.0167053323,
-0.0236575212,
-0.016358966,
0.0422133058,
-0.0210298449,
-0.0071684895,
-0.0502157435,
-0.0002383087,
0.0602447726,
0.0327744223,
-0.0271220654,
-0.0324257985,
-0.0158261172,
0.0442781933,
0.0533961914,
-0.0134439962,
0.0175863951,
-0.0287503991,
0.0311811492,
0.0868746936,
0.059399657,
-0.026032364,
-0.0352835581,
-0.0196362324,
0.008801043,
-0.0336092189,
-0.0243935771,
-0.011286688,
0.021600306,
-0.0864183158,
-0.0153000066,
0.0975621045,
0.0355799571,
-0.0422440395,
-0.0373481363,
-0.0489607155,
0.0659264475,
0.0192472935,
0.0329804681,
-0.0324273705,
-0.0355230533,
0.0346352085,
0.0235026628,
0.0295923091,
-0.0239421595,
0.0272295494,
-0.1173278615,
0.0198995266,
-0.0042952062,
-0.1050501242,
-0.0384499244,
-0.0371475071,
0.0020841614,
0.0229132492,
-0.0183132216,
0.0589805022,
-0.0227649622,
0.0024714202,
-0.008346783,
-0.0546450056,
0.0604148433,
0.0298833754,
-0.0198255163,
-0.0477693006,
0.074555926,
0.0284231286,
0.0240560621,
-0.0031058993,
0.0306396838,
-0.0758746564,
-0.0027950115,
-0.0043537347,
0.0064283395,
-0.0314610265,
0.0289268866,
-0.0370724127,
0.0177067332,
-0.0132699385,
0.0009986905,
0.0002629967,
0.0848446637,
-0.004763972,
0.0059527219,
-0.0455363914,
-0.0260894783,
-0.0443333201,
0.0726522431,
0.0153420484,
0.03269732,
-0.0722074881,
-0.0286741871,
0.0217132103,
-0.0077671972,
-0.0043940158,
0.0004720727,
-0.0096393814,
0.0336437933,
-0.0715697706,
-0.0623404048,
0.0254651867,
0.0123783806,
-0.049913533,
0.0016857055,
-0.0235107727,
-0.0232504625,
-0.0693465397,
0.0289604049,
-0.0479553752,
0.0171494205,
0.0087416647,
0.0271308888,
0.0533219464,
0.001696791,
-0.0134595511,
0.0281139314,
-0.0198416747,
-0.0466600619,
-0.0512220412,
0.0225682147,
0.0186961256,
0.0692467391,
-0.010735509,
-0.0081505682,
0.0414208062,
-0.0377446935,
-0.0523108914,
0.0107800309,
0.0205558538,
0.0410388857,
0.0046015289,
0.0440036096,
-0.0900329724,
0.0086963587,
-0.0303482972,
0.0632396191,
-0.0272103772,
-0.0009770881,
0.0213952474,
0.0196918175,
0.0316019915,
0.0278887935,
-0.0100946547,
-0.0020636353,
0.0103991376,
-0.0461557508,
-0.0274545699,
-0.0262548495,
0.0407072045,
-0.0027143944,
-0.0248393584,
-0.0146456147,
0.0376999341,
0.0303785615,
0.0329621807,
-0.0151830856,
-0.0258260984,
0.0076930393,
-0.0372789465,
-0.0086419964,
-0.0004935067,
-0.0440960862,
-0.0449367762,
-0.0096680019,
0.0418943763,
-0.0134209031,
0.0114162508,
0.0272821672,
0.0040777177,
-0.0565208383,
0.0081595406,
-0.1105792001,
-0.0397715308,
-0.0234428942,
-0.0184031036,
0.0200070459,
-0.0311963111,
0.046681866,
0.0039340192,
-0.0178396553,
-0.0081728846,
-0.0102790995,
0.0294484273,
-0.0610518865,
0.020627087,
0.0500079952,
-0.0180155393,
0.0208226368,
0.0608138554,
-0.0366659537,
0.0073014731,
-0.0011115923,
-0.0110071804,
-0.0158619992,
-0.0075294194,
-0.0148422644,
0.057441704,
0.0037701793,
-0.0185746383,
-0.0337525122,
-0.0568136908,
0.0053294911,
0.013396726,
-0.0182576831,
-0.015146005,
0.0399346761,
0.0563694537,
0.0411890671,
-0.0539447665,
-0.0257658157,
0.0015945702,
-0.0393203497,
-0.0054442273,
-0.0256595034,
-6.258547921e-33,
-0.0300149061,
-0.0006630299,
0.0293438248,
0.0063497238,
-0.0549070127,
0.0277731959,
-0.0546357222,
0.0026275082,
-0.0113349967,
0.0081835492,
-0.0348372087,
0.0350671038,
-0.0075967447,
0.0516681485,
0.0106144566,
0.0202697907,
0.0166947395,
0.0060096034,
-0.0293837357,
0.023545213,
0.0646731555,
0.0244589988,
0.0144233229,
-0.0239454322,
-0.0047053401,
-0.0103071118,
0.0238181427,
0.0467078574,
-0.0102154464,
0.0482269488,
0.0118419472,
0.0242537782,
0.0436315052,
-0.0370464437,
-0.0270801652,
0.034380842,
-0.139565438,
-0.0248483215,
0.011775841,
-0.0518363528,
-0.0775931701,
0.0023441603,
0.0630624145,
-0.019797666,
0.0760470852,
-0.0568867996,
0.0323001556,
-0.0283637233,
-0.0519816019,
-0.0421600416,
-0.0245328378,
0.0278051496,
0.0071085459,
0.0044567301,
0.0161306188,
0.0556351691,
0.0226561129,
0.0553388894,
-0.0547023043,
-0.0118800187,
-0.0502650775,
0.0345732346,
0.0077691316,
0.0091948006,
0.0142822322,
0.0504604355,
0.0185433105,
0.0039865798,
-0.0453322977,
-0.0145120425,
-0.0157711506,
0.021281939,
0.0348170623,
-0.0033981542,
0.0378436334,
0.0251013394,
-0.037022423,
0.0422435291,
0.0056241918,
0.0884139836,
0.0046246517,
0.056005694,
-0.0430608205,
-0.0266236197,
-0.0282493271,
0.032478191,
-0.0395802446,
-0.0085665109,
0.0156883877,
0.0300732888,
0.0022272936,
-0.0182886384,
0.0192419663,
-0.0157805048,
0.0362944305,
0.0546913706,
-0.013470686,
0.0110920295,
-0.0028031687,
0.0369440764,
-0.0189742539,
0.0251319148,
0.000972301,
-0.0098492466,
-0.0417950936,
0.0198752899,
0.0248755757,
-0.008671158,
-0.0728888363,
0.010671244,
-0.0062668202,
0.0218981132,
-0.0496412702,
0.021094827,
0.0380872637,
0.0399239771,
0.0242260639,
0.0597323515,
0.0017327409,
0.0237576496,
-0.0343197025,
-0.0108800679,
0.0057922676,
-0.0082838442,
0.0172338989,
0.0367785953,
-0.0109079191,
0.0371041447,
0.0239291415,
-0.054515738,
-0.0044918261,
0.033196073,
2.685e-7,
0.0391006395,
0.0165952183,
0.0589842983,
0.0332678221,
0.0180579871,
0.010245394,
0.0184931401,
0.0157604627,
0.0437299386,
-0.0419962034,
-0.0056431536,
0.0353654176,
0.0692905337,
0.0356207564,
-0.1179409772,
0.004679902,
-0.0800293237,
-0.0468213558,
-0.0235257559,
-0.036977455,
0.0322044343,
0.0848926604,
0.0152189098,
0.0007896625,
-0.0200154148,
-0.0443807542,
0.0582142659,
0.0190930143,
-0.0040746983,
-0.0176091325,
0.0266599953,
0.0415553227,
0.0058304449,
-0.0208352841,
0.0038076323,
0.0479873046,
0.0157100633,
0.0476740226,
-0.0169005226,
-0.0446135066,
0.0287940782,
-0.0316508412,
0.0049827457,
-0.0201499015,
0.0779445991,
-0.0355592892,
0.0173277184,
0.0052574738,
-0.0566173382,
0.0000393034,
-0.0191749148,
0.0301759727,
-0.0372860059,
0.0447424836,
-0.0181306023,
-0.0047931997,
-0.000694781,
-0.124851957,
-0.0191108566,
0.0177846421,
-0.0300365631,
-0.0014473825,
-0.0309975166,
0.0278222263,
-0.00544813,
-0.0535312817,
-0.0248174425,
2.399739345e-34,
0.0580138192,
-0.0165131669,
-0.0033619597,
0.0516954139,
0.0502002314,
-0.0132779879,
-0.0012005031,
-0.0040128171,
0.0219190083,
-0.0997809172,
-0.025509581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18058v1 | LongAlign: A Recipe for Long Context Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T18:29:39 | 2024-01-31T18:29:39 | Yushi Bai, Xin Lv, Jiajie Zhang, Yuze He, Ji Qi, Lei Hou, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Extending large language models to effectively handle long contexts requires
instruction fine-tuning on input sequences of similar length. To address this,
we present LongAlign -- a recipe of the instruction data, training, and
evaluation for long context alignment. First, we construct a long
instruction-following dataset using Self-Instruct. To ensure the data
diversity, it covers a broad range of tasks from various long context sources.
Second, we adopt the packing and sorted batching strategies to speed up
supervised fine-tuning on data with varied length distributions. Additionally,
we develop a loss weighting method to balance the contribution to the loss
across different sequences during packing training. Third, we introduce the
LongBench-Chat benchmark for evaluating instruction-following capabilities on
queries of 10k-100k in length. Experiments show that LongAlign outperforms
existing recipes for LLMs in long context tasks by up to 30\%, while also
maintaining their proficiency in handling short, generic tasks. The code, data,
and long-aligned models are open-sourced at https://github.com/THUDM/LongAlign. | LongAlign: A Recipe for Long Context Alignment of Large Language Models: Extending large language models to effectively handle long contexts requires
instruction fine-tuning on input sequences of similar length. To address this,
we present LongAlign -- a recipe of the instruction data, training, and
evaluation for long context alignment. First, we construct a long
instruction-following dataset using Self-Instruct. To ensure the data
diversity, it covers a broad range of tasks from various long context sources.
Second, we adopt the packing and sorted batching strategies to speed up
supervised fine-tuning on data with varied length distributions. Additionally,
we develop a loss weighting method to balance the contribution to the loss
across different sequences during packing training. Third, we introduce the
LongBench-Chat benchmark for evaluating instruction-following capabilities on
queries of 10k-100k in length. Experiments show that LongAlign outperforms
existing recipes for LLMs in long context tasks by up to 30\%, while also
maintaining their proficiency in handling short, generic tasks. The code, data,
and long-aligned models are open-sourced at https://github.com/THUDM/LongAlign. | [
-0.0009114473,
0.085630551,
0.0078998562,
0.0505872369,
-0.0438565575,
0.0117466701,
0.0164902192,
-0.0240634196,
-0.0158749148,
-0.0391587429,
-0.0540584959,
-0.0632582754,
-0.0002652463,
-0.0127516408,
0.0682393312,
-0.0222149566,
0.0349683315,
-0.0290769786,
-0.0465374067,
0.0077288374,
-0.0002197367,
0.017962493,
-0.0120072337,
0.0259433296,
-0.0037801918,
-0.0302245058,
-0.0394811854,
0.0290153231,
0.0021590395,
-0.028120514,
0.0383325331,
0.0373068005,
0.0193669628,
0.0166366454,
0.0000018057,
-0.0381165855,
-0.022536004,
-0.017243797,
-0.0599197708,
0.0138769262,
0.0168183316,
-0.027749056,
-0.0072853989,
0.0439255014,
-0.0233532265,
0.0208661854,
0.0326158293,
0.0115419561,
0.0466782041,
0.1049454287,
0.012035273,
-0.0338659547,
0.0216916408,
-0.0695736334,
0.0322360173,
-0.0532740876,
0.0118252207,
-0.0190290622,
0.0193560533,
0.0215420686,
-0.0386968069,
0.0388088562,
0.0346507169,
0.0001583714,
-0.0235985052,
0.0093154805,
-0.0328643918,
-0.0019237834,
0.0095667932,
0.0781962574,
-0.0182083528,
-0.0127662858,
0.0003207748,
0.0055023022,
0.0157710649,
-0.070718497,
-0.0269436166,
0.0234276708,
0.025668269,
0.0029177128,
0.0266703907,
-0.0208581798,
0.0357321762,
-0.0144281136,
-0.0554211661,
0.0407082178,
0.0242338404,
-0.0217631143,
-0.0338572524,
-0.0282283891,
-0.0178120788,
-0.0462744422,
-0.0299077071,
0.0372414403,
-0.0528680645,
0.0388824083,
-0.0552611351,
-0.0123963933,
0.0191546604,
-0.0219271965,
0.0142141376,
0.0580221936,
-0.025940204,
0.0525642671,
-0.0254436005,
0.0595526695,
-0.0067590838,
0.0203652717,
-0.0590827651,
-0.000663805,
-0.0323877856,
0.0251031294,
-0.0351823047,
-0.0159536935,
-0.048391819,
-0.0263854563,
-0.0470879152,
0.0314182378,
0.0107781468,
0.0360228531,
0.0397083312,
-0.0109748775,
-0.0568041317,
-0.0061170259,
0.0190765094,
0.046331346,
-0.0174257308,
0.0058084494,
0.0162696671,
-0.0427349173,
-0.0267354641,
0.0328492299,
-0.0068602022,
-0.043668326,
0.0123416241,
0.0684052929,
0.0107680485,
-0.0395093709,
-0.0580452979,
-0.0173449963,
-0.0350087099,
-0.072130464,
-0.0244887043,
-0.0706305131,
0.0450005122,
-0.0087533901,
0.0037130276,
-0.030672539,
0.0057092588,
0.0017166456,
0.018470224,
0.0918340683,
0.0373288989,
0.0165876243,
0.0067817718,
0.0035988581,
0.0398168117,
0.0901566669,
0.0017832012,
0.0120365014,
0.0256224014,
-0.007514209,
-0.0310281925,
0.0452877507,
0.0355606079,
0.0087823318,
-0.0418403707,
0.0396008715,
0.0500632823,
0.0674932897,
0.0432311818,
0.0450603701,
0.0011057772,
-0.028381452,
0.0256892238,
0.0311093926,
0.0652410164,
-0.0319915973,
0.0421878509,
0.0041266638,
-0.0422146432,
0.0081927022,
-0.0749399215,
0.0153686516,
0.0093865814,
0.0350366719,
0.0471192189,
0.0268099178,
-0.0403899178,
-0.0164051615,
-0.0155105684,
-0.0237714909,
-0.0153059643,
0.0123904813,
0.017942816,
-0.0013521499,
-0.048779238,
0.0436908007,
0.0204601623,
-0.0344157144,
0.0013210615,
-0.0018364855,
0.0036572604,
0.0675866231,
0.0050472259,
-0.031450931,
-0.0801208541,
0.0011676134,
0.0223075598,
0.0254308395,
0.0045394511,
-0.0129534584,
0.0307608489,
-0.0510594882,
-0.0311821662,
0.0054640006,
0.0047486932,
-0.0047741602,
0.042572286,
0.0074474635,
0.0298432708,
-0.0327211842,
-0.0031632318,
0.0442133918,
-0.0903455317,
-0.0694212317,
-0.038176015,
0.0334224664,
0.0284523033,
0.0020970162,
-0.0027887023,
0.0182012208,
0.048363544,
-0.0368786193,
0.0231133346,
-0.0288010277,
-0.0742201656,
-0.0589625351,
0.0650276765,
0.0015945995,
-0.0297549628,
-0.0158210322,
-0.0490243435,
-0.0572245717,
-0.0051227999,
-0.0199230928,
0.0376921594,
-0.0065200357,
0.0363713354,
0.0206508301,
0.0023170738,
-0.0610551089,
0.0290745478,
-0.0140165407,
0.0230710581,
0.0302619524,
0.0278723352,
-0.0229064245,
-0.057943929,
-0.0063202102,
0.0090188952,
0.0033860905,
-0.0051081772,
-0.012200986,
0.0165036805,
-0.0465444103,
-0.0345829949,
-0.0999655873,
0.0492818281,
-0.0462263413,
0.0502956659,
0.0285447128,
0.0175562911,
-0.0098504135,
-0.0128647322,
-0.075375177,
-0.0189326517,
-0.0059766937,
0.0193791091,
0.0288901161,
0.0228363518,
-0.0535254851,
-0.0598053597,
-0.0208315235,
-0.0223023966,
0.0127181122,
-0.0438388772,
-0.0009162017,
-0.0675079748,
0.0235595349,
-0.0073178229,
0.0277003981,
-0.0315917358,
-0.0450907759,
-0.033805199,
-0.0299239643,
0.0397880189,
0.065647006,
0.0189621598,
-0.0023708178,
0.0098511446,
-0.0035845404,
-0.0407705642,
0.0106995068,
-0.0201085508,
-0.0309187155,
-0.0622970574,
-0.0107936477,
-0.0202059094,
0.0612816438,
-0.0266182125,
0.0069538262,
-0.0470817685,
-0.0459347777,
0.0107485242,
0.0112392511,
-0.003727196,
0.0147534516,
-0.0179408081,
-0.0001958427,
-0.0344661474,
-0.0439155512,
0.0508051068,
-0.0519104339,
-0.0030988797,
-0.0262313765,
-0.0391502269,
-0.0676313341,
0.0717754886,
0.0179592054,
0.0173510276,
-0.0112932138,
-0.0349554271,
-0.0691906437,
0.0038580161,
-0.0116091166,
-0.0228332374,
0.0668385103,
-0.0321656168,
0.008837834,
-0.0274109673,
-0.0308651607,
-0.0289699361,
-0.0081134159,
0.0142119201,
0.0055539897,
0.0507505611,
-0.0271830074,
-0.0185845997,
0.0124047408,
0.0109042637,
0.0585847162,
-0.0095541328,
0.0416186452,
-0.0379859619,
0.0039206017,
0.056142576,
0.0237854049,
0.0057272702,
-0.0357956402,
0.009715016,
0.0344111249,
0.0640075281,
-0.0157996994,
-0.0278572366,
-0.0067548929,
0.0350796096,
-0.0363469273,
-0.0098147569,
0.0195432715,
0.0690319762,
-0.0755484626,
-0.0126343928,
0.1036915109,
-0.0026625048,
-0.0573203824,
0.0122548938,
0.0256072208,
0.0406906679,
0.0337095298,
0.0262508001,
-0.0956118777,
-0.0427995436,
0.0168156661,
0.0149958106,
0.0393677801,
-0.0091164103,
0.0026799389,
-0.1326233745,
-0.0021802019,
0.0268494859,
-0.0629244521,
-0.035743203,
-0.0259765889,
0.0044058119,
-0.0118424436,
0.0541887209,
0.0530151278,
-0.0352121592,
-0.022514632,
0.0276717935,
0.0151217123,
-0.0446431227,
0.0201937277,
-0.0553465709,
0.0998206511,
0.0408290625,
-0.0030722809,
0.0319051929,
-0.0069789919,
0.0665018037,
-0.014854881,
-0.0160349011,
0.0212765448,
0.0341446064,
-0.041303996,
-0.0175180119,
0.0411437899,
0.0472533405,
-0.057204593,
0.0216037687,
0.0212331563,
0.0705510229,
-0.011310772,
0.0379559472,
-0.0126227289,
-0.0277928747,
0.0236113854,
0.0729984269,
0.0354583897,
-0.0046992362,
-0.0330027193,
-0.0178827327,
-0.0276101753,
-0.0323336311,
0.0126296682,
0.0290977377,
-0.0475258753,
-0.0095881987,
-0.0487423763,
-0.0333113968,
0.0401142053,
0.0590908825,
0.010732037,
0.0062117893,
-0.0089197988,
-0.0311521515,
-0.0638075396,
0.0342716165,
-0.044829566,
0.0419968069,
-0.0924212262,
0.0040029362,
0.028404491,
0.0124020725,
0.0124501251,
0.0339957066,
-0.1132719442,
-0.0824735463,
-0.0078108208,
0.0239887722,
0.0117504084,
0.0766565502,
0.0019944306,
-0.0105002224,
-0.0012596177,
0.0289347153,
-0.0352920219,
0.0197779499,
0.0209700093,
-0.0041265576,
-0.0011091335,
0.0444931127,
-0.0362790786,
0.007530998,
-0.0031205793,
0.0620560013,
-0.0250724647,
-0.0344483852,
0.0052901637,
0.0026887828,
0.0060576596,
-0.0146440035,
-0.006046914,
-0.0090514291,
0.0692665577,
-0.0224265233,
-0.0255006775,
-0.0059152376,
-0.0015784123,
0.0286532901,
-0.0067784009,
0.0368776917,
-0.0091335503,
0.0193554312,
0.0181896575,
-0.0362490043,
0.0520643368,
-0.0081685232,
-0.004327016,
0.0438158736,
0.0259015262,
-0.0053931964,
0.0101259528,
0.0190495476,
0.0531696044,
-0.0409211703,
0.0203163717,
0.0439644977,
0.0346820541,
-0.0218309145,
0.0265928563,
-0.0331561454,
-0.0041229012,
-0.0287812352,
0.0055481773,
0.0689832717,
-0.0453187265,
0.0279566422,
0.0049636033,
-0.0129327411,
-0.0326855928,
0.0466426685,
-0.0334733725,
0.015083218,
0.0183908232,
0.055361852,
-0.0188663453,
0.015481838,
0.074492991,
0.0240679216,
0.0565582812,
0.0332624801,
0.0153870666,
-0.0285744891,
-0.0311583132,
0.0196594149,
0.0183733907,
-0.0301061589,
-0.0010244371,
0.0100078601,
-0.0800557807,
-0.0073174862,
0.0159198232,
-0.0184651613,
-0.0039853579,
0.0561542623,
0.0577904135,
-0.0104336469,
0.0015299114,
-0.0115844076,
0.0154426051,
0.0121808546,
-0.0514237247,
-0.0111556081,
-5.976244504e-33,
-0.0384380408,
-0.0155113218,
0.0534265935,
-0.022177374,
-0.059940882,
0.0033825131,
-0.0337759741,
-0.0132090952,
-0.0001257308,
-0.0027627556,
-0.0153397536,
0.0080852788,
0.0083940756,
0.0543893427,
0.0221549254,
-0.0298990496,
0.0307135731,
0.0168571603,
0.0095868818,
0.0115338163,
0.0141642466,
0.0387188829,
0.0423355438,
-0.0242525022,
0.0019437628,
0.0027015212,
0.0129861515,
0.0384843387,
-0.000777987,
0.0698181838,
-0.0012938393,
0.0072660409,
0.0118235033,
-0.0411373787,
-0.0255870875,
0.0131346518,
-0.0822312608,
0.0084378812,
0.0192539766,
0.0085525578,
-0.0382670872,
-0.0518828891,
0.0410313159,
-0.016466694,
-0.0198434945,
-0.0028669452,
0.0145691149,
-0.039206706,
-0.0236604046,
0.0157971624,
-0.0392633639,
0.0204726178,
0.0000110254,
-0.046432361,
0.0340694115,
0.013147396,
0.024117684,
0.022229135,
-0.0280587468,
-0.00074152,
-0.0205690712,
0.1114201769,
0.084158875,
0.039627146,
0.0069962703,
0.021899486,
0.002657399,
-0.0171813536,
0.0126213953,
-0.0173401013,
0.0089815892,
0.0544586517,
0.0201486982,
0.0112592038,
0.0379993245,
-0.0028516843,
-0.0445570722,
-0.0022959821,
0.0000131523,
0.0252674837,
-0.0026392743,
0.034010727,
-0.0319591127,
-0.0112285959,
-0.0291419942,
0.0073957802,
-0.0237327777,
0.005453073,
0.039918825,
0.023211956,
0.008431837,
-0.0078005628,
0.0451447293,
-0.0300912056,
-0.0352851339,
0.0279744472,
-0.0034898217,
-0.0149262398,
-0.0079447804,
0.0476563834,
-0.0511401705,
-0.0382619537,
0.0101694856,
0.0014063057,
0.0161875281,
-0.0124181164,
0.0613558814,
0.0174761936,
-0.0630963966,
-0.008877988,
-0.0610027798,
0.0140200518,
-0.039003659,
0.0307118036,
0.0464213863,
0.0133161433,
0.0080020754,
0.0959843472,
0.0119177615,
-0.024676742,
-0.0073310658,
-0.0466435291,
-0.0024604159,
0.012828161,
-0.0309456903,
0.0133372825,
-0.0325466953,
0.0248804316,
0.0104613779,
-0.0519477911,
-0.0040762792,
0.0201506522,
2.527e-7,
0.0428152308,
0.0247582141,
0.0884084553,
0.0294045005,
0.0002367145,
-0.0000928097,
-0.033560887,
0.0405254066,
-0.0320741124,
-0.0210784823,
0.0026727351,
0.0146476496,
0.0515336432,
-0.0095660705,
-0.0862126872,
0.0166668203,
-0.0484966636,
0.0185322873,
-0.0620282665,
-0.0002429797,
0.0248951688,
0.1404785067,
-0.0058764527,
0.0023124136,
0.0083753681,
-0.0206598472,
0.0122124376,
-0.0278174058,
-0.0165635403,
0.0309608262,
-0.011876449,
0.0073975339,
-0.0021066954,
-0.0207118653,
-0.0135159604,
0.0215617754,
-0.0188644864,
0.0837302133,
0.0155224027,
-0.0402463526,
0.0056949169,
-0.009319419,
-0.0304575767,
-0.0180808548,
0.0421084426,
-0.0396911986,
-0.0029941711,
-0.0384337902,
-0.0129461978,
-0.0121584143,
0.0166913643,
0.0048133675,
0.0236709788,
0.0261332951,
0.0601873137,
-0.0315798633,
-0.0292581953,
-0.1025414914,
-0.0349825248,
0.0256316978,
-0.0388514511,
-0.0017211664,
-0.0378730856,
-0.003046388,
0.0158627108,
-0.061211206,
-0.0288576726,
2.785731971e-34,
0.028979959,
-0.015027157,
0.0172803737,
0.0430589989,
0.0255942624,
-0.0396251902,
-0.0595387742,
0.040382538,
0.0202964768,
-0.0727085546,
-0.0417789072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18046v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18046v2 | Multipath parsing in the brain | 2024-01-31T18:07:12 | 2024-06-06T13:40:47 | Berta Franzluebbers, Donald Dunagan, Miloš Stanojević, Jan Buys, John T. Hale | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans understand sentences word-by-word, in the order that they hear them.
This incrementality entails resolving temporary ambiguities about syntactic
relationships. We investigate how humans process these syntactic ambiguities by
correlating predictions from incremental generative dependency parsers with
timecourse data from people undergoing functional neuroimaging while listening
to an audiobook. In particular, we compare competing hypotheses regarding the
number of developing syntactic analyses in play during word-by-word
comprehension: one vs more than one. This comparison involves evaluating
syntactic surprisal from a state-of-the-art dependency parser with LLM-adapted
encodings against an existing fMRI dataset. In both English and Chinese data,
we find evidence for multipath parsing. Brain regions associated with this
multipath effect include bilateral superior temporal gyrus. | Multipath parsing in the brain: Humans understand sentences word-by-word, in the order that they hear them.
This incrementality entails resolving temporary ambiguities about syntactic
relationships. We investigate how humans process these syntactic ambiguities by
correlating predictions from incremental generative dependency parsers with
timecourse data from people undergoing functional neuroimaging while listening
to an audiobook. In particular, we compare competing hypotheses regarding the
number of developing syntactic analyses in play during word-by-word
comprehension: one vs more than one. This comparison involves evaluating
syntactic surprisal from a state-of-the-art dependency parser with LLM-adapted
encodings against an existing fMRI dataset. In both English and Chinese data,
we find evidence for multipath parsing. Brain regions associated with this
multipath effect include bilateral superior temporal gyrus. | [
0.0069805458,
0.0638190359,
-0.0419313386,
0.0158404578,
-0.0294681154,
0.0175208077,
0.0236711558,
0.0145621467,
0.0045210221,
0.0069063664,
-0.0093424916,
-0.0354367718,
0.0505686328,
0.0093432264,
0.0508257225,
-0.0506018214,
0.0268449336,
-0.0325093083,
-0.0113266204,
0.0166200344,
-0.0342562459,
0.0089783799,
-0.0458387956,
0.0138244648,
-0.0196305327,
-0.0605081096,
0.0261811912,
-0.0179101415,
-0.0181416087,
-0.0280797519,
-0.0381779969,
0.0543367341,
0.0167341866,
-0.0002310779,
0.0000019552,
-0.0395633169,
0.0293475054,
0.0053812265,
0.0009824262,
-0.0007886672,
0.0005673934,
0.0013075585,
0.0136505906,
-0.0191841759,
-0.0239203274,
0.0014909514,
0.0001682057,
0.05998905,
-0.0248374175,
0.0270940177,
-0.0289125182,
-0.0606919006,
0.0153748794,
-0.0301405527,
0.0270677805,
0.0095128035,
0.0123392381,
0.0079622054,
-0.0169815645,
-0.001190369,
-0.0497778021,
0.0040767821,
0.0270629264,
0.0540904664,
-0.0212741699,
0.0644559413,
0.0385682806,
0.0258668605,
-0.0066072112,
0.044606667,
0.0417354256,
-0.0404818431,
-0.0125657627,
-0.0034965223,
0.0043272148,
0.0165914763,
-0.0356107056,
0.0639043897,
-0.0594004057,
0.0347037949,
0.0462998189,
-0.0854963884,
0.0027957216,
-0.0313025676,
0.0143231442,
0.0898547769,
-0.0248324834,
-0.0643730536,
0.0309180748,
0.0269741435,
-0.10221228,
-0.0330687873,
0.0236480869,
-0.0294733644,
-0.0233304519,
0.0150393462,
-0.0146359066,
-0.0483102091,
0.0026446683,
-0.0610069297,
-0.0205922835,
0.0437081046,
-0.0561762527,
0.012465396,
0.0016461806,
0.0189941954,
-0.0441353768,
0.0359777883,
-0.0323528834,
0.0674268156,
-0.0275121368,
-0.0379109457,
-0.021071963,
0.0243209042,
-0.059732981,
-0.0223271511,
-0.0343161263,
-0.0155929197,
0.0265421532,
-0.043548122,
-0.0232281908,
-0.0010898019,
-0.023696309,
0.0581137203,
-0.0227047913,
0.0055292835,
-0.0363639556,
0.0671593174,
-0.0305338539,
-0.0301965214,
-0.039633777,
0.062325947,
-0.0283985268,
-0.0334586576,
-0.0267820079,
0.0300214104,
-0.0342545435,
-0.0073444447,
-0.0449434221,
-0.0300535541,
-0.0236167237,
0.0000443815,
0.0332817957,
-0.0596874356,
0.0184524655,
0.0497404411,
-0.0234607011,
-0.0224296376,
-0.0154201621,
0.0152376294,
-0.0356359631,
0.0200264603,
0.036861863,
0.0087634083,
0.0245965235,
0.0100626452,
-0.0254315287,
0.0232604463,
0.0448232815,
-0.0551574677,
-0.0374785624,
0.0037483545,
-0.0406948701,
0.0188505165,
-0.0672483668,
-0.0423496664,
-0.0583991706,
-0.0493430384,
-0.031031508,
0.0273517407,
0.0741635114,
0.0302983113,
-0.0372850709,
0.0017357786,
0.0028538259,
0.0596313179,
-0.0279504638,
-0.0068584676,
0.0270509105,
-0.0064783627,
0.0250111613,
0.0773009732,
-0.0196858644,
0.0277277771,
0.0355074592,
0.0017847271,
-0.0523064546,
-0.0145726902,
0.0367557183,
0.0006799476,
-0.008128182,
-0.0082137464,
0.0216161963,
0.0050498107,
0.022338042,
0.0007273333,
-0.0264023822,
0.0297953114,
0.0151805077,
0.0008246883,
-0.0048709139,
0.027018249,
-0.0245532207,
0.0317983069,
0.0067929393,
-0.0074844393,
0.0044757435,
0.0088079777,
-0.0052866302,
0.0670373514,
-0.0242240988,
0.0437004194,
0.0575796664,
-0.0078270072,
0.0201001447,
0.0076350388,
-0.0023583961,
0.0041383379,
-0.0701974407,
-0.0268330444,
-0.0462424867,
0.0032963927,
-0.0043999245,
0.0513503142,
-0.0294047259,
0.0244133528,
-0.0132177137,
-0.0065403483,
0.0384631902,
-0.0338382125,
-0.0403327905,
0.0291839745,
0.0096179461,
-0.0220912136,
0.0035480508,
0.0441588052,
-0.0669240281,
-0.0378155895,
-0.0041621183,
-0.0057817469,
-0.0592690445,
0.0030073707,
0.0201391652,
-0.0138212079,
0.0145038264,
-0.0216764119,
0.0488327369,
-0.0173318852,
0.0079058297,
0.0018833595,
0.0663518012,
-0.0469158143,
0.0444985665,
-0.0121502308,
0.0361013189,
-0.0352995545,
-0.0059723556,
0.0311280601,
-0.0076063648,
-0.0284544677,
0.0477754362,
-0.0126270493,
-0.060892906,
-0.0460414439,
-0.0047244783,
-0.0586720146,
-0.0265152119,
-0.0493321158,
-0.0111390185,
0.039995525,
0.0390446894,
0.0147627266,
-0.0259744432,
0.0024323009,
0.0157434139,
0.0322088562,
-0.0029421889,
0.0051417784,
0.0303207133,
-0.0031996637,
-0.0017262779,
0.0011617068,
-0.0079484042,
-0.0108272573,
-0.0667480454,
0.0321877412,
0.0045230351,
-0.0494694486,
-0.0635022372,
0.0354933105,
-0.013643655,
-0.0028063091,
0.0122130523,
0.0021551927,
0.0562802292,
0.0227853153,
0.0754686445,
0.0551120006,
-0.0404299125,
0.0394005626,
0.0631085113,
-0.0441732705,
-0.0034841567,
-0.0009910422,
0.0305497888,
0.0277016498,
-0.0531250909,
-0.0115988636,
-0.0158964116,
0.1034216508,
0.0960350409,
0.0163691007,
0.0058234786,
-0.0199239906,
-0.0602501221,
-0.041435387,
-0.0140097272,
-0.0620965026,
-0.0710211024,
0.0409024954,
-0.0444981232,
0.0118063288,
0.0812156647,
-0.009673751,
-0.035678681,
-0.0491244979,
0.0393512659,
-0.0049356711,
0.061130669,
0.0159709249,
-0.0090004802,
0.0251642186,
-0.0930160284,
-0.0675373524,
0.026605932,
-0.0001778921,
-0.0041057752,
0.0409981012,
-0.0538975261,
0.0022925546,
0.0194760617,
-0.0196520183,
-0.0057259616,
-0.0137223899,
0.0210641678,
-0.0065343715,
0.0100901434,
0.0246423688,
-0.0016612252,
-0.0279453732,
0.0398072004,
0.0207126886,
-0.0329720229,
-0.0281584524,
-0.019066995,
0.0471088812,
-0.0107433535,
0.0172451418,
0.0109273409,
-0.042628672,
-0.0216850303,
0.0467702337,
0.0118501727,
0.0355083123,
-0.0091188252,
0.0321324877,
0.0206302814,
-0.007998188,
-0.0643311068,
0.0176262334,
-0.0064198943,
-0.0312052034,
-0.0081481189,
0.0867151842,
0.0107891392,
-0.0300096571,
0.0358919837,
-0.0300952606,
0.0373919122,
0.0177906435,
0.0064382819,
-0.060299404,
0.0077217822,
0.0099235,
0.0127338497,
-0.0027536689,
-0.0276983213,
0.0156264678,
-0.0336990207,
0.0403163433,
-0.0003386834,
-0.0446348302,
0.0475634411,
0.0009735528,
0.0005302427,
0.0568874255,
0.0531770959,
0.007090834,
-0.0180255398,
0.0239182804,
0.0252701174,
0.0040128282,
-0.0081008691,
-0.0230988935,
0.0030824768,
0.0459295772,
0.0168062262,
0.0190627761,
-0.0570454821,
-0.0106586944,
0.0390817262,
0.0265813731,
0.0269255154,
-0.0277577434,
0.0200855266,
0.0689500272,
0.014246623,
-0.0418403,
0.0051226164,
-0.0073378091,
-0.0645342246,
-0.0160988774,
0.0541811138,
-0.0361370035,
0.0076409038,
0.0413791724,
0.0378908738,
-0.0194351096,
0.0497819148,
0.0378579348,
-0.0392639376,
0.00106158,
-0.0070033176,
0.0463113077,
-0.0490837581,
-0.0211469084,
0.0417586118,
0.0169990566,
0.019405596,
-0.0609432012,
-0.0399654694,
0.0059552183,
-0.0045894398,
0.0116597097,
0.0428726226,
0.057121411,
-0.0616937615,
-0.0213303175,
0.0143967345,
0.0476733372,
-0.0014773767,
-0.0242425241,
-0.0255965739,
-0.017464824,
-0.004966808,
-0.0327099524,
0.0395425595,
-0.0548444875,
-0.0377793051,
0.0574954301,
-0.005376983,
0.0176794231,
-0.0142117394,
-0.0029731379,
-0.0261591654,
-0.0338871107,
0.0198726412,
-0.0305899847,
0.1062920317,
-0.0356899239,
0.0299344119,
0.0158300977,
-0.0045765606,
0.0081003299,
-0.0192932449,
0.001038525,
0.032060463,
0.0171021521,
0.0414952375,
0.0393212065,
0.0239528678,
0.0767088607,
-0.0207448192,
0.0499771871,
-0.0610450096,
-0.0007603624,
-0.0287506003,
0.0411565937,
-0.0015878687,
-0.0262639802,
0.048989825,
0.0298252311,
-0.0483046882,
-0.0270235371,
0.0150155136,
-0.0078207366,
0.0146238357,
-0.0217257645,
-0.0277409405,
-0.057292182,
-0.0029364168,
0.0394133925,
0.0045494316,
0.001683954,
-0.0260762796,
0.0010914929,
0.0258751549,
0.0499171205,
0.0210029464,
0.0035926225,
-0.0360361971,
-0.0507300682,
-0.0141976941,
-0.0422318541,
0.0592624396,
-0.0224350411,
0.0213689059,
-0.0208048318,
0.0931478217,
-0.0395536348,
0.0587455109,
-0.0119723026,
-0.0117216315,
-0.0373130776,
-0.0158163309,
0.0300493594,
-0.0035844564,
0.011931967,
-0.0330076516,
0.1053388491,
-0.0130848717,
0.0099421935,
-0.0314646475,
-0.0086694043,
-0.0315976292,
-0.0717959478,
-0.0408434682,
0.0113931764,
-0.0595784076,
0.0320806392,
-0.0402368233,
-0.029197624,
-0.0089309253,
-0.0181049909,
0.0445743725,
-0.0457124114,
-0.0137883741,
0.0441114418,
-0.0055239298,
-0.0913915485,
0.020768201,
0.0256524403,
-0.0019056778,
-0.066450499,
-0.045918379,
-6.105339497e-33,
-0.0544503443,
-0.009348412,
0.0087495493,
0.0503472798,
-0.0437358618,
-0.0181312058,
-0.0577489436,
0.0565746091,
0.0433436073,
0.0005968165,
-0.012613521,
0.0097813653,
0.0292270351,
0.0241195783,
0.0875286832,
0.0177984592,
-0.0085147126,
-0.0300837476,
0.0077649499,
-0.030871395,
0.0869565904,
0.0354473293,
0.1029578447,
-0.0286874808,
0.0108008124,
-0.0009850617,
-0.000391055,
0.0103822183,
-0.0802870914,
0.0477000102,
-0.0217610188,
0.0458251871,
0.0723321512,
0.0066580405,
-0.0179007128,
-0.0098748775,
-0.04026049,
-0.0189730432,
0.0752447173,
0.0378475003,
-0.0595926009,
-0.0076513169,
0.0729333162,
-0.0349142663,
0.0275879987,
0.0425131135,
0.0438650995,
-0.0352628157,
0.0176379308,
0.0391242467,
-0.0726107135,
-0.048337806,
-0.0051461249,
0.0350654647,
-0.0134283938,
0.0370491929,
-0.0534185693,
-0.0153188724,
-0.0446904115,
-0.0289261993,
-0.0194548685,
0.0663195997,
-0.0220197253,
0.0173524115,
0.0367042013,
0.0444757007,
0.0436728522,
-0.0420153514,
-0.0141068874,
0.0241957549,
0.0694282353,
0.0171453487,
-0.0555908829,
-0.0172580555,
0.0503848307,
-0.0262294486,
-0.0231470373,
-0.0225264896,
0.0674893185,
0.0373504646,
-0.0058477987,
-0.0022556928,
0.0352008492,
-0.0333791971,
-0.0138068637,
-0.0173916072,
-0.0335864909,
-0.0431738496,
0.0037567799,
-0.0349533819,
0.0604435503,
-0.0230401102,
0.0545625873,
0.0184499081,
-0.0188813806,
-0.0585115775,
-0.0314703807,
0.0396593064,
0.0162276421,
0.0205198564,
-0.0266440418,
-0.0237722788,
0.0161712188,
-0.0290373322,
0.0731210038,
-0.0063771876,
0.0291640591,
-0.0263115689,
-0.0169106778,
0.0091114575,
-0.0312819742,
-0.0326043442,
0.0420420878,
0.0033662003,
0.0356799997,
0.0210501626,
-0.0231362265,
-0.0092221294,
0.0032213286,
0.0231635179,
-0.0724674314,
-0.0088257333,
-0.047965806,
0.0393914729,
-0.0079186587,
-0.022470722,
0.0222052541,
-0.0158308502,
0.0413739644,
-0.0625019744,
-0.0482768901,
0.0328030549,
2.852e-7,
0.0652061775,
0.0541876107,
-0.0006147773,
0.033924982,
0.0535861626,
-0.0324034765,
-0.0376509018,
0.0162526052,
-0.001618761,
-0.0258971993,
-0.043979194,
0.0299432129,
0.019200772,
0.0057515777,
-0.0515832826,
-0.0118390275,
-0.0394310541,
0.0574309193,
-0.0529315658,
-0.0014467305,
0.0521948151,
-0.0045374646,
-0.0425644554,
-0.0156322829,
-0.0370882712,
0.0324229077,
0.068912141,
0.0098701213,
0.0106361881,
-0.0047567454,
-0.0163920578,
-0.0494236946,
0.0242887679,
0.0412442461,
0.0215008594,
-0.0083026951,
0.0106056491,
0.0316190422,
0.0322408117,
0.0011567872,
0.0184596423,
0.0458907522,
-0.0212863553,
-0.0208691657,
-0.0067717396,
-0.0651619881,
-0.0739673749,
0.0674128607,
-0.0195163805,
0.007337722,
0.0313033536,
0.023273984,
-0.0027683463,
0.000900025,
0.0164723117,
0.0018963328,
-0.018128356,
0.0048875604,
-0.0169829763,
0.0827915147,
-0.0665663928,
0.0127636837,
-0.0054245568,
-0.0164450184,
0.0168938283,
-0.0345229954,
-0.047619503,
2.286029093e-34,
-0.0291469004,
-0.0018690368,
0.0684715062,
0.0240910947,
0.0049546035,
-0.0326817855,
-0.0136580039,
0.035522826,
-0.0567525662,
-0.0802578256,
-0.0175400339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18045v1 | SpeechComposer: Unifying Multiple Speech Tasks with Prompt Composition | 2024-01-31T18:06:29 | 2024-01-31T18:06:29 | Yihan Wu, Soumi Maiti, Yifan Peng, Wangyou Zhang, Chenda Li, Yuyue Wang, Xihua Wang, Shinji Watanabe, Ruihua Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent advancements in language models have significantly enhanced
performance in multiple speech-related tasks. Existing speech language models
typically utilize task-dependent prompt tokens to unify various speech tasks in
a single model. However, this design omits the intrinsic connections between
different speech tasks, which can potentially boost the performance of each
task. In this work, we propose a novel decoder-only speech language model,
SpeechComposer, that can unify common speech tasks by composing a fixed set of
prompt tokens. Built upon four primary tasks -- speech synthesis, speech
recognition, speech language modeling, and text language modeling --
SpeechComposer can easily extend to more speech tasks via compositions of
well-designed prompt tokens, like voice conversion and speech enhancement. The
unification of prompt tokens also makes it possible for knowledge sharing among
different speech tasks in a more structured manner. Experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed SpeechComposer can improve the performance of
both primary tasks and composite tasks, showing the effectiveness of the shared
prompt tokens. Remarkably, the unified decoder-only model achieves a comparable
and even better performance than the baselines which are expert models designed
for single tasks. | SpeechComposer: Unifying Multiple Speech Tasks with Prompt Composition: Recent advancements in language models have significantly enhanced
performance in multiple speech-related tasks. Existing speech language models
typically utilize task-dependent prompt tokens to unify various speech tasks in
a single model. However, this design omits the intrinsic connections between
different speech tasks, which can potentially boost the performance of each
task. In this work, we propose a novel decoder-only speech language model,
SpeechComposer, that can unify common speech tasks by composing a fixed set of
prompt tokens. Built upon four primary tasks -- speech synthesis, speech
recognition, speech language modeling, and text language modeling --
SpeechComposer can easily extend to more speech tasks via compositions of
well-designed prompt tokens, like voice conversion and speech enhancement. The
unification of prompt tokens also makes it possible for knowledge sharing among
different speech tasks in a more structured manner. Experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed SpeechComposer can improve the performance of
both primary tasks and composite tasks, showing the effectiveness of the shared
prompt tokens. Remarkably, the unified decoder-only model achieves a comparable
and even better performance than the baselines which are expert models designed
for single tasks. | [
0.0029376235,
0.0515074059,
0.004649845,
-0.0234068539,
-0.0273121148,
-0.0339942761,
0.0612474047,
0.0005814593,
-0.0643910915,
-0.0281774439,
-0.0419864655,
-0.0129141975,
0.0396165662,
0.0356231704,
0.0225727055,
-0.0925741121,
0.0272095427,
-0.0689139217,
0.0002203638,
-0.0060807914,
-0.0086111501,
0.0278456248,
-0.0321911797,
0.0636980981,
-0.0306097027,
0.0009747445,
-0.0250809416,
0.0025906404,
-0.0093491171,
0.0244925469,
-0.0033242996,
0.019698482,
0.0260663796,
-0.0096495682,
0.0000019668,
-0.0453996025,
0.0059610615,
0.0030185988,
-0.0347637497,
-0.0103599466,
0.0425237864,
0.0129206842,
0.0056234403,
0.0820606425,
-0.0069249878,
-0.0280481838,
0.0541795976,
0.0396339037,
0.03840385,
0.0480762944,
-0.0089341691,
-0.0055066068,
0.0271388739,
-0.0084378915,
-0.0285390001,
-0.0060394914,
-0.0234408826,
-0.0443022959,
0.0243851971,
-0.0266073532,
-0.0187854413,
0.0517381765,
0.0118334675,
0.005782004,
0.0281290207,
0.004558872,
0.0169308148,
-0.0646771193,
-0.0698505938,
0.020740455,
-0.0403650813,
-0.0173669737,
0.0245300904,
0.0157742146,
0.0155904023,
-0.0211292133,
-0.0231073555,
0.0118540591,
-0.0008661966,
0.0038295554,
-0.0056353589,
0.0402519815,
0.0087994142,
-0.0326859541,
-0.0434797741,
0.034399543,
0.035564594,
-0.0147738513,
-0.0287168194,
-0.0290791988,
0.0122764558,
-0.0524469353,
0.0614127181,
0.0325856172,
-0.0684903935,
0.0003590823,
-0.0638546273,
-0.0557131507,
-0.0111985216,
0.0228400994,
0.0254246984,
0.0656655431,
-0.043297682,
0.0104729747,
-0.0091252094,
0.053367395,
0.0178052541,
-0.012955199,
-0.0436186045,
-0.0482142419,
-0.0237666275,
-0.0159169436,
-0.0561820604,
0.0640007854,
-0.0799499676,
-0.0622811653,
0.0123228543,
0.028780276,
0.0091021927,
-0.0219301004,
0.0705780834,
0.0145205697,
-0.0190697461,
-0.0320760049,
0.0153209353,
0.0191196334,
-0.0042323098,
0.0605848059,
0.03421041,
-0.0679399967,
0.0014655201,
-0.0012663968,
0.0348285064,
0.0106643764,
-0.026890805,
0.0640917867,
-0.0437611416,
0.0074039008,
-0.0036383378,
-0.0420397185,
0.000387268,
-0.0289906878,
-0.0437331572,
-0.0527655855,
0.0576234423,
0.0111405104,
0.0030877755,
-0.0115246661,
0.0045927833,
-0.0104982322,
0.0135572096,
0.0757495016,
-0.0235697124,
0.0401948094,
0.0728440061,
0.0013061402,
-0.0160539504,
0.043765232,
0.0325632505,
-0.0024424698,
-0.0032500108,
-0.0187531393,
0.0041302326,
0.0565003306,
-0.0181684829,
-0.0465719216,
0.0124762151,
-0.0268909726,
-0.0032259966,
-0.0292399339,
0.0381922275,
0.0529568754,
-0.0339010879,
0.0497255139,
0.0543271229,
0.0425243042,
0.0190699603,
-0.0012727058,
0.0586054586,
0.0367845111,
-0.0079911351,
-0.0090307537,
-0.0361282453,
-0.0006895358,
-0.0290321577,
0.0013435647,
0.0412674062,
0.0560351014,
-0.0328084864,
-0.0303572938,
0.0305533782,
-0.0530619472,
0.0055695232,
0.0246333182,
0.0360158682,
0.0232172199,
-0.0816022679,
0.0427407175,
-0.0041935043,
-0.1034415439,
0.0363712236,
-0.0249229502,
0.0056387298,
0.0745119601,
0.0107840747,
0.0148070995,
-0.0127405822,
-0.0201360993,
-0.019191999,
0.0242162663,
0.0291369017,
-0.0074300766,
0.0450893007,
-0.0612648316,
-0.0240603145,
0.0397543348,
0.0123444451,
0.0506057255,
-0.0175596122,
-0.0028025727,
0.0199966338,
0.0068693319,
0.0512376949,
0.0003188623,
-0.0014374226,
0.0132087488,
0.0241706837,
0.0026723321,
0.0393510796,
0.0077139186,
-0.0088030808,
0.0313448198,
0.009266926,
-0.0537915044,
-0.0216841977,
0.0522737354,
-0.064509213,
-0.0356547907,
0.0372591019,
-0.0059856791,
0.0368010327,
0.0410804711,
0.0116688274,
-0.1225112602,
0.0056650462,
-0.0236737598,
0.0541074239,
-0.0053466246,
0.0547696277,
0.0147667546,
0.0033234947,
0.0302609466,
-0.0109357787,
0.0105122263,
-0.0244060755,
0.0773686022,
0.045871865,
-0.0226443857,
-0.0622813292,
-0.0159774963,
0.0012394212,
-0.0425745808,
0.0325578414,
0.0135570327,
-0.0250522699,
0.0073954314,
-0.0336629711,
-0.1097950786,
0.0100628529,
-0.0091017652,
-0.0097869746,
0.0213353373,
0.0377595574,
0.0178636052,
-0.0186621509,
-0.039263051,
-0.0452717431,
0.0049863295,
-0.0193315074,
-0.0586282052,
-0.0330129191,
-0.0415703543,
-0.0263158567,
0.0149728367,
0.0305668376,
0.0047964547,
-0.0354376212,
-0.0580973215,
-0.0447797552,
0.0117043331,
0.0335607976,
0.0533627719,
0.0053626429,
0.001495149,
-0.0010736397,
0.0000390837,
0.0721672401,
0.0166348722,
0.0224215295,
-0.0217634346,
0.0140379658,
-0.0273540448,
-0.0768354908,
0.0189006496,
0.0051160781,
0.0140217198,
-0.0145106558,
-0.025086686,
0.0143429125,
0.0220802389,
0.0716937259,
0.0245185606,
-0.0810157061,
-0.0239153206,
-0.0118171256,
-0.056840051,
-0.0343156531,
-0.0496972613,
-0.0656718686,
0.0339676663,
-0.0227945279,
-0.0318840444,
0.011904601,
-0.0786567777,
-0.0317667834,
-0.0002891101,
-0.0175118893,
-0.0068687103,
0.0208831802,
-0.0224106573,
0.0114989998,
-0.0186570268,
-0.0578885041,
-0.0111348452,
0.0329091661,
-0.0176605769,
-0.0754391551,
-0.0008330612,
-0.0511792675,
-0.0139569314,
-0.0167050548,
-0.0437255949,
-0.0475286022,
0.0430047661,
-0.0320336632,
0.068037346,
0.0282370672,
-0.0249816608,
0.0087383054,
0.0333101191,
0.0018576478,
0.0628317297,
0.0026958124,
0.0228070859,
-0.0392940529,
0.0178809501,
0.0302958265,
0.0381514467,
-0.042006433,
-0.0094093736,
0.0408809148,
-0.0106261242,
0.0963743851,
0.0231199805,
-0.0247135777,
-0.0033897355,
0.0599656068,
0.0020309221,
-0.0255210567,
0.0494059362,
0.0586588569,
-0.0454312824,
0.0205509551,
0.1288916469,
0.0122259771,
-0.0118259713,
-0.0247383751,
-0.0039614569,
-0.0012009495,
0.0027669237,
-0.0039200205,
-0.0479216836,
-0.032355424,
0.0654933751,
0.025391534,
0.0250287913,
0.035714902,
-0.0374543853,
-0.0967229754,
0.0324775763,
0.0150080668,
-0.0385960303,
-0.0491266809,
-0.0277165994,
-0.022098951,
0.0051379632,
0.0343670882,
0.0312941112,
0.0077986782,
-0.0273460839,
0.0419942625,
-0.0472668149,
-0.0398364365,
0.0086457999,
-0.0110225314,
0.0978438109,
0.0713437125,
0.0036585969,
0.0168689862,
-0.0082055163,
0.0136025827,
0.0086654341,
0.0094256522,
0.0007614193,
0.0056300042,
0.0014523144,
-0.0014691808,
0.0241384357,
0.0491356589,
-0.0520728007,
-0.0033767452,
0.0133563885,
0.0543638393,
0.0068823192,
-0.0083789565,
-0.0249692164,
-0.0015799272,
0.0085520502,
0.0626984313,
0.0199680664,
-0.0506701507,
-0.0339936465,
-0.0130882291,
0.0002290603,
-0.0682855174,
0.0026082476,
0.0248015542,
0.0096677886,
-0.0455314703,
-0.02990756,
0.018484503,
0.044727888,
0.031305287,
0.029774446,
0.037511792,
0.0136111015,
0.0039173607,
-0.0270581264,
-0.0339306071,
0.0060069244,
0.0264727529,
-0.0867154151,
-0.0187764838,
0.0185276736,
-0.0566031858,
0.0055337111,
0.0203833338,
-0.0281376448,
-0.0493779518,
-0.0260027647,
0.0185320042,
0.0258381311,
0.0417681336,
-0.0544093214,
-0.0553518087,
0.0596236438,
0.0340550616,
-0.0577658154,
0.0294204075,
0.0520847142,
-0.0127057219,
-0.014765488,
0.007999205,
-0.0634534284,
0.0184481852,
-0.0235887766,
0.0070852493,
0.0030740215,
-0.0567102544,
0.0120410314,
0.0452387258,
0.0156167075,
-0.0279290583,
0.0597479679,
-0.0227253698,
0.0062577603,
-0.0033620074,
0.02561244,
-0.0575350523,
0.0415321514,
0.0301438719,
0.0173852965,
0.029146526,
0.0119476905,
0.0040719113,
-0.0023800896,
0.0021554439,
0.0137038827,
-0.0069612693,
0.0158364382,
0.0352116264,
-0.0093053123,
-0.0216166042,
0.0094389729,
0.0026518728,
-0.0352244824,
-0.0260032751,
0.0005263726,
-0.0200309828,
0.007932228,
-0.000439443,
0.0247549713,
-0.0471937507,
-0.0590237081,
-0.0254158955,
0.0377422273,
0.0193951204,
0.0393754803,
0.0572028756,
-0.0070323995,
0.0348408818,
-0.0332600325,
0.0364898331,
0.007354409,
-0.0171284657,
0.0081551783,
-0.0039893603,
-0.0150384242,
-0.0421694256,
0.0574478246,
-0.0295914393,
0.0398588292,
-0.0471350178,
0.0248120241,
-0.0361446291,
-0.0344019197,
-0.0040648966,
0.0315945745,
-0.0361217111,
-0.0180804078,
-0.018688729,
-0.0330185145,
0.0258355346,
-0.0030877069,
0.0198312327,
-0.0201230664,
0.0456222929,
0.0002244332,
-0.0622616373,
-0.0138287125,
-0.0053007351,
-0.0312359352,
0.0280232169,
-0.0023512261,
0.0037065723,
-5.795120661e-33,
-0.0428716354,
0.0332073122,
0.0338912755,
-0.0180504937,
-0.0187921505,
-0.0161708258,
-0.0176256988,
0.0045084991,
-0.0110482424,
-0.0262680706,
-0.0332244262,
-0.0068860766,
0.0294672046,
0.0406438895,
-0.0006103086,
0.0485519804,
0.118114382,
-0.027071381,
-0.0063183955,
0.0142187541,
0.0303337779,
0.0325702876,
0.0050814063,
-0.0348204747,
-0.0340994634,
0.0011001587,
-0.0374432839,
-0.0145124029,
0.0259206649,
0.0144908354,
0.013334333,
0.0488470942,
-0.0100625986,
-0.0655421242,
-0.0599008985,
0.0902259499,
-0.0807180777,
-0.0020564571,
0.0560568422,
0.0301421005,
-0.0473389439,
-0.0455772653,
0.0138152316,
0.0113310749,
-0.0003114626,
-0.0052586184,
0.0170225482,
-0.0233838484,
-0.0072144782,
-0.0458542146,
-0.0244651977,
0.0092530269,
-0.0199373774,
-0.0408725962,
0.0599910393,
0.068926774,
-0.0188959595,
-0.0302182436,
-0.031054629,
0.0508311428,
0.0195366535,
0.0310663395,
0.0486395657,
0.0498002842,
-0.024659846,
0.0180468224,
0.0385367088,
-0.0615753904,
-0.0099053169,
0.0093953768,
0.0143366093,
0.0750789717,
0.0326794684,
0.0265177228,
0.0181860309,
-0.0629740134,
0.0212011971,
0.0081127277,
0.0411455929,
-0.0371315554,
0.0362149812,
0.0309639741,
0.0013668353,
-0.0042827786,
-0.0912196189,
-0.0100807426,
-0.0224528685,
-0.0002865804,
0.0805666,
0.0435674414,
0.0007460535,
-0.0410037898,
0.0746600181,
-0.0057202722,
0.0393104702,
0.0330086723,
-0.0089996504,
0.0352768861,
-0.0311439447,
0.0096747829,
-0.0237103067,
-0.0461605117,
0.0879047886,
0.0072559351,
0.0008664464,
0.0040565082,
-0.0472609028,
0.0452466197,
-0.0555804707,
0.0047200792,
-0.0214582384,
0.0472367778,
0.0231741015,
0.0054495791,
0.0440361388,
-0.0001752937,
-0.0307917167,
-0.0014598352,
-0.0406546928,
-0.0141097894,
-0.0223370809,
-0.0101095149,
-0.0213037431,
0.0133403698,
-0.0271254145,
0.011951169,
-0.0330699757,
-0.0040685595,
0.0596307851,
0.0256446097,
-0.0218015332,
0.0133995935,
2.692e-7,
-0.0163478367,
-0.0194755476,
0.0240322221,
-0.0138091315,
0.0209030304,
0.0037077288,
0.0043384223,
0.034052331,
0.0097921425,
-0.0017801751,
-0.0263596289,
-0.0095056668,
0.0579048395,
-0.0058976929,
-0.0963729024,
-0.0549798496,
-0.0613241158,
0.0136097781,
-0.0238066614,
0.0211386047,
0.0358390808,
0.0780862421,
-0.0141580282,
-0.0229996741,
-0.0076146354,
0.0093373442,
0.018191535,
-0.0229725838,
0.0057115844,
0.0188191086,
0.0025165763,
-0.0193699636,
-0.0089366147,
0.0242752563,
-0.029883096,
0.0363164023,
0.0439930297,
0.0856178254,
0.0077672638,
-0.0476281755,
0.0074025788,
0.0260938425,
-0.0472370572,
0.0121620316,
0.0542592369,
-0.0086269472,
0.0358196124,
-0.0409060046,
-0.0593259521,
0.0491081551,
-0.0397917368,
-0.0070796041,
0.0076736505,
0.0245339461,
-0.0037631521,
0.022045888,
-0.0186195858,
-0.0722856671,
-0.0225096196,
-0.0078909136,
-0.0802055672,
-0.0506244488,
-0.0387940034,
-0.0166234635,
0.008479801,
-0.0619159453,
-0.0051184506,
2.274945926e-34,
0.0134069761,
-0.0246057659,
0.0407992229,
0.0336331949,
0.0091709848,
-0.0467943996,
-0.0256910808,
0.0568315648,
0.0110233128,
-0.0519031845,
-0.0672404543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18040v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18040v2 | Enhancing End-to-End Multi-Task Dialogue Systems: A Study on Intrinsic Motivation Reinforcement Learning Algorithms for Improved Training and Adaptability | 2024-01-31T18:03:39 | 2024-03-25T23:03:58 | Navin Kamuni, Hardik Shah, Sathishkumar Chintala, Naveen Kunchakuri, Sujatha Alla Old Dominion | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | End-to-end multi-task dialogue systems are usually designed with separate
modules for the dialogue pipeline. Among these, the policy module is essential
for deciding what to do in response to user input. This policy is trained by
reinforcement learning algorithms by taking advantage of an environment in
which an agent receives feedback in the form of a reward signal. The current
dialogue systems, however, only provide meagre and simplistic rewards.
Investigating intrinsic motivation reinforcement learning algorithms is the
goal of this study. Through this, the agent can quickly accelerate training and
improve its capacity to judge the quality of its actions by teaching it an
internal incentive system. In particular, we adapt techniques for random
network distillation and curiosity-driven reinforcement learning to measure the
frequency of state visits and encourage exploration by using semantic
similarity between utterances. Experimental results on MultiWOZ, a
heterogeneous dataset, show that intrinsic motivation-based debate systems
outperform policies that depend on extrinsic incentives. By adopting random
network distillation, for example, which is trained using semantic similarity
between user-system dialogues, an astounding average success rate of 73% is
achieved. This is a significant improvement over the baseline Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO), which has an average success rate of 60%. In addition,
performance indicators such as booking rates and completion rates show a 10%
rise over the baseline. Furthermore, these intrinsic incentive models help
improve the system's policy's resilience in an increasing amount of domains.
This implies that they could be useful in scaling up to settings that cover a
wider range of domains. | Enhancing End-to-End Multi-Task Dialogue Systems: A Study on Intrinsic Motivation Reinforcement Learning Algorithms for Improved Training and Adaptability: End-to-end multi-task dialogue systems are usually designed with separate
modules for the dialogue pipeline. Among these, the policy module is essential
for deciding what to do in response to user input. This policy is trained by
reinforcement learning algorithms by taking advantage of an environment in
which an agent receives feedback in the form of a reward signal. The current
dialogue systems, however, only provide meagre and simplistic rewards.
Investigating intrinsic motivation reinforcement learning algorithms is the
goal of this study. Through this, the agent can quickly accelerate training and
improve its capacity to judge the quality of its actions by teaching it an
internal incentive system. In particular, we adapt techniques for random
network distillation and curiosity-driven reinforcement learning to measure the
frequency of state visits and encourage exploration by using semantic
similarity between utterances. Experimental results on MultiWOZ, a
heterogeneous dataset, show that intrinsic motivation-based debate systems
outperform policies that depend on extrinsic incentives. By adopting random
network distillation, for example, which is trained using semantic similarity
between user-system dialogues, an astounding average success rate of 73% is
achieved. This is a significant improvement over the baseline Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO), which has an average success rate of 60%. In addition,
performance indicators such as booking rates and completion rates show a 10%
rise over the baseline. Furthermore, these intrinsic incentive models help
improve the system's policy's resilience in an increasing amount of domains.
This implies that they could be useful in scaling up to settings that cover a
wider range of domains. | [
0.0503064394,
0.0507786646,
-0.0138505623,
-0.001125913,
-0.0281282198,
0.012575279,
-0.0107760988,
-0.015051716,
-0.0092400843,
-0.0153707545,
-0.0395123549,
-0.0090939552,
-0.037506707,
0.0523773693,
0.0065835784,
-0.0752429888,
0.0400647782,
-0.0335596055,
0.079259105,
0.0048851799,
0.0201213751,
-0.030647587,
-0.0228334386,
0.0651142076,
0.0099337017,
0.0053495686,
-0.0489494205,
-0.0160374437,
0.0517419539,
-0.0617486127,
0.0173207838,
0.0141443927,
0.0697508603,
0.0487070456,
0.0000023017,
-0.0748673603,
-0.0337094441,
-0.03733325,
-0.0282925572,
-0.0614899993,
0.0481090173,
0.0893103033,
0.0174766462,
0.0360249728,
-0.0321883224,
0.0367127135,
0.0421624593,
0.0841632113,
0.0541382357,
0.0437924154,
-0.0009572066,
-0.0262484904,
-0.0124770794,
-0.0023827376,
0.0219620857,
-0.0473863855,
-0.0060559036,
0.0201812088,
0.0051176636,
-0.0268842392,
-0.0021370032,
-0.041218996,
0.0314889327,
-0.0284597799,
0.0043801325,
0.0384726487,
-0.0148473503,
-0.0251217261,
-0.0365973189,
0.0892639533,
-0.0107603371,
0.0233307965,
0.0118445102,
-0.0119171301,
0.0091622965,
-0.0336955339,
-0.0490040742,
-0.0126688369,
-0.0214882288,
0.0150081059,
0.0108131925,
0.0576432832,
0.0045019044,
0.0135268737,
-0.0338295735,
0.013913013,
-0.0270320717,
-0.0546324588,
0.0437262058,
-0.0012591168,
0.047757715,
-0.0577392057,
-0.0048005166,
0.0240108427,
-0.0859156698,
0.0278653037,
-0.0013590722,
0.0141836861,
-0.0010592284,
-0.0194217581,
0.0147336842,
0.0325212181,
-0.0149911428,
0.0377984308,
0.0188651588,
0.0372663178,
-0.0105260564,
0.0441214852,
-0.0089244321,
0.0323605463,
-0.0813214555,
0.0081843035,
-0.0614653863,
0.0525377579,
-0.0563872084,
-0.0533166602,
-0.0188141167,
0.0530422404,
-0.0318037681,
0.0227724146,
0.0117679108,
0.0497716963,
-0.0276007615,
0.0255204253,
-0.0839916319,
0.0211099107,
-0.0571061037,
0.0466607437,
0.05613859,
0.0231306404,
-0.0171666518,
0.0112064537,
0.016176071,
0.0031143741,
0.0074000773,
0.1062080264,
-0.0261699688,
-0.0379072204,
-0.0228964295,
-0.0258513745,
-0.0024436936,
-0.0543360785,
-0.0091255726,
-0.0248792004,
0.0236528758,
-0.0521663986,
-0.0348575674,
-0.0293760523,
0.0047640437,
-0.0071909274,
0.002450255,
0.0539337471,
0.0312457122,
-0.0254627187,
0.0245417804,
0.0129209133,
-0.0282554943,
0.036632251,
0.0468973555,
0.0467520393,
0.0384679027,
0.0089311637,
0.0033455007,
-0.0072553405,
0.0155543406,
0.0307555124,
0.0772595778,
0.0084862206,
-0.0140689667,
0.0270170122,
0.0002245116,
0.0471788123,
-0.062137574,
0.0288171247,
0.0528408401,
0.0563697442,
0.0058095981,
-0.0551170297,
0.0071463259,
0.0436044745,
-0.0057338844,
-0.0262772571,
-0.0077021378,
0.0594564192,
0.0827724189,
-0.0026761261,
0.0938117802,
0.0072303503,
-0.0396576151,
-0.0661855787,
0.0449235588,
0.0141673433,
0.0571534559,
0.0511325933,
0.0596477911,
0.0106590893,
-0.0703906193,
-0.0499498472,
0.0213403571,
0.0012177745,
-0.0243710522,
-0.0826607421,
0.0486857891,
0.0554269068,
0.0152013628,
0.0055281073,
-0.0185299404,
-0.0686887726,
-0.0311049726,
0.045427382,
0.0221396722,
-0.0542144217,
0.0260736439,
-0.0389489755,
-0.0706511736,
-0.0321583487,
-0.0020066379,
0.0478380993,
-0.012009385,
-0.0083543677,
-0.0216687024,
0.0132272942,
-0.0245808866,
0.0043974514,
-0.008129077,
-0.0025522197,
0.0160734206,
0.0097876694,
0.046886526,
0.034452498,
0.0068154195,
-0.0232597906,
0.0111478101,
0.0105806654,
0.0064939358,
0.0530989245,
-0.0201918688,
-0.0177459065,
0.0305715054,
-0.0328037366,
0.0017985407,
-0.0160437375,
-0.0097829178,
-0.0384855941,
0.0417439565,
-0.0262518935,
0.0217276551,
-0.0345657952,
0.0129260262,
-0.0064091068,
-0.0143860038,
-0.0457205847,
0.0345103145,
0.017004123,
-0.0183249302,
0.0335769169,
-0.0118385907,
0.0568168052,
-0.0997639969,
0.0173687097,
-0.0113073625,
-0.0052089035,
0.0167499296,
0.0298077781,
0.0146185942,
-0.059454903,
0.0101834964,
-0.071413897,
-0.0021853507,
-0.0153188761,
0.0034037593,
0.0032150329,
0.0132247917,
0.0099772457,
-0.0428592563,
-0.0220356937,
-0.0032818131,
0.0371728204,
-0.0050290986,
0.0445130095,
0.0534403808,
-0.0272459649,
-0.0421708897,
0.0249966718,
0.0034839862,
-0.0106214359,
0.0096294647,
0.0408205315,
-0.0475112833,
0.0019331612,
-0.0397504978,
0.0047032563,
-0.0314188972,
-0.0253654923,
0.0584595837,
0.0101503534,
0.007345092,
0.0292762835,
0.0275990386,
0.0220932681,
0.0119097987,
-0.0057425979,
-0.1009010151,
0.0435727537,
-0.031735912,
0.0210232474,
-0.0468689725,
0.0128225321,
0.0469081439,
0.0643418208,
-0.0072924425,
0.040881712,
-0.0517868958,
0.0610714816,
0.0092044631,
-0.0418355465,
-0.0534974299,
0.0199835524,
-0.04202554,
0.0175132118,
-0.0228650682,
-0.0404399484,
0.0990239605,
0.0418021344,
-0.0081113502,
-0.0759200603,
-0.0468069464,
-0.0165720358,
0.0306940284,
-0.048884213,
0.0140467882,
0.0320435837,
-0.0527202189,
-0.0427057333,
-0.0072275908,
0.0238996372,
-0.031971138,
0.0453676581,
0.0045866184,
0.0055198828,
0.0114709586,
-0.07012292,
-0.0678439736,
-0.0276613235,
-0.0086084679,
-0.0363659449,
0.0015862039,
-0.0180574339,
0.0013343479,
-0.0081755761,
0.0236142725,
0.0025042046,
0.0096360166,
-0.0335543714,
-0.0127441669,
-0.0047224653,
0.0547103137,
0.0213191863,
0.0045293695,
-0.0195103083,
0.0349654406,
0.0103215985,
0.0215225406,
-0.0660550371,
-0.0181319881,
0.0270984732,
-0.0042381003,
-0.0190884322,
0.0325716287,
0.0252011567,
0.0577836297,
-0.0392575748,
-0.0176815167,
0.0659986064,
0.0270976275,
-0.0255415849,
-0.0128216464,
-0.0476424843,
0.0467453785,
0.0151700042,
0.0444936715,
-0.0617305152,
-0.0241584256,
-0.0055685593,
0.0575060137,
-0.0164935067,
-0.0417581908,
0.0023508302,
-0.0890542716,
-0.00111215,
-0.0291836765,
-0.0475841947,
0.005107787,
-0.02716011,
-0.0016863951,
-0.0141811809,
0.0046626139,
-0.002425849,
0.0276931524,
-0.025058195,
0.0308988746,
0.0561817959,
-0.0046700574,
0.0011760861,
-0.0350105613,
0.0572624132,
0.070734337,
0.0445082076,
0.0150576551,
-0.021295676,
-0.0069502126,
0.0316338874,
0.0146227125,
0.0042782356,
0.0455014743,
-0.0163458642,
-0.0034981344,
-0.031261269,
0.0485873185,
0.0108060241,
-0.0277741253,
0.0127148861,
0.0620266199,
-0.0418208055,
-0.0015371679,
-0.0237331744,
-0.0028093236,
0.0715302527,
0.0552513711,
-0.0209515933,
-0.049583979,
-0.0514884368,
-0.0397988781,
-0.0555148497,
-0.0739741623,
0.019461954,
-0.0241202191,
-0.0264947414,
0.058071956,
-0.043675065,
-0.0646808371,
0.0027461851,
0.038576398,
-0.0142449653,
-0.0117605058,
-0.0181365721,
0.0580203198,
0.0105458489,
-0.0120382747,
-0.0064182165,
0.0079024127,
-0.0379010066,
-0.0058473242,
0.0140617602,
-0.0471017025,
-0.0299043711,
-0.0208041612,
-0.0462290645,
-0.0482936874,
-0.0584141798,
0.0822546035,
0.0208359901,
0.052375026,
0.0204430446,
-0.005164362,
0.0170284919,
-0.0159676205,
-0.0293985214,
-0.0527579673,
0.0602139048,
0.0676173866,
-0.0174421519,
0.0033021076,
-0.0500659458,
0.0092808651,
-0.0176686719,
0.0328896604,
-0.0072087422,
-0.0047747134,
0.0227552839,
-0.0202307049,
0.0214166082,
0.0025910533,
-0.0544740297,
-0.0347231142,
0.0255672522,
0.0270700529,
-0.0229424909,
-0.0429477803,
-0.0103064245,
0.0019452407,
-0.0007198457,
0.0202987939,
-0.0173768029,
0.0118432976,
0.0068570753,
-0.0056955414,
-0.0085603753,
0.0276393648,
0.0108917244,
-0.0079050008,
0.004333179,
0.0181073826,
0.0383438878,
0.0441731662,
0.030473629,
0.0025762033,
0.0808713213,
0.0319929421,
-0.01113874,
-0.0030097414,
0.0281490646,
-0.0658033341,
-0.0290463734,
0.0098445415,
-0.0073197684,
0.0184780583,
0.0589874908,
0.009585239,
-0.0249327645,
0.0273069646,
0.0205734242,
0.0175222289,
-0.0327522419,
-0.0046382654,
0.0086264974,
0.0242947675,
-0.0031044835,
0.0010118077,
0.0597025156,
-0.0303001609,
0.0392888635,
-0.0549861901,
0.0157608222,
-0.0598622113,
0.011634998,
-0.0085247988,
0.087242052,
0.0128292842,
-0.0075366036,
-0.0246430784,
-0.0150755988,
-0.0648034886,
0.0370407961,
-0.0037377148,
-0.0138723077,
0.0824587122,
0.0099543035,
-0.021082066,
-0.0055270079,
-0.0062929448,
-0.0515455678,
0.0000442357,
-0.0062441686,
-0.0428339988,
-5.932837538e-33,
0.0193546917,
-0.0116959754,
0.0595193543,
0.0145685412,
-0.0480219573,
-0.0691117048,
-0.0388370603,
-0.0006201818,
-0.0071642147,
0.0212300513,
-0.0146827362,
0.0033054175,
0.012865915,
-0.0064503518,
0.0105963647,
-0.0339634046,
0.0735294819,
-0.0088309469,
-0.0296199489,
0.0438799635,
0.0738864318,
0.0028391418,
0.0305201672,
-0.0744586214,
0.0214927848,
0.042318888,
0.0134497099,
0.0431510359,
0.0296084136,
0.0330182984,
0.0109064244,
0.018802112,
-0.0016166164,
-0.0601510219,
-0.0099937432,
0.0356347151,
-0.061795447,
-0.0753636509,
0.0095106829,
-0.0453985333,
-0.0442861542,
-0.0393042788,
0.0042889905,
-0.000246829,
-0.0125282928,
0.0105038313,
0.0005971123,
0.0186144505,
0.0152418911,
0.0084571429,
-0.0389117859,
-0.017897252,
-0.0449326709,
-0.0194260776,
0.0012938845,
0.0442979001,
-0.0096694129,
-0.0095299184,
-0.0134407301,
0.0710432604,
-0.045044452,
-0.0291562602,
0.0369999446,
0.0178609006,
0.0115910685,
0.0508668721,
0.0254628509,
0.0190999005,
0.0008363931,
-0.0313923359,
0.0064045331,
0.0460770391,
0.0044056717,
0.036767561,
0.0299807638,
-0.0011361637,
-0.0414895713,
0.0515159145,
0.0383363068,
0.0451216735,
0.0066684964,
0.0321104527,
-0.0134623423,
-0.0213508978,
-0.04176341,
-0.0049023647,
-0.005387886,
-0.0792687014,
0.0573984608,
0.0567153767,
0.0124662882,
-0.0214764681,
0.0371903703,
-0.0693335608,
-0.0091294693,
0.0589697585,
-0.027706366,
0.0154426675,
0.0175869726,
-0.0762984157,
-0.0964603573,
-0.0387033708,
-0.0057009296,
0.0370998718,
0.0233600698,
0.0077704377,
-0.0154674519,
-0.0069939564,
-0.0260413103,
0.0238683373,
-0.0217493828,
0.0385486856,
-0.0170517843,
0.0274617318,
0.0164587479,
0.0059659253,
-0.0276535824,
0.0381650552,
-0.0019098548,
-0.009042142,
-0.0432824008,
-0.0245583747,
0.0046219453,
0.0098125907,
-0.0199196786,
0.0089715915,
-0.051306136,
0.0021571964,
-0.0245143455,
-0.0666832104,
-0.0188560784,
0.0119817322,
3.015e-7,
-0.0750000104,
0.031748116,
0.0203208067,
0.0277896617,
0.0191578735,
0.0469859764,
0.0008100961,
0.0146048432,
0.0116587961,
-0.0327815153,
0.0179505181,
0.0154587785,
0.0046105376,
0.0073284139,
-0.0982799828,
-0.0837890878,
-0.0360521488,
-0.0125837866,
-0.028320631,
0.0098266862,
0.027419351,
0.0354743451,
0.0334329084,
0.011840187,
0.0407745391,
-0.0116267111,
0.0189353693,
-0.0096866637,
0.001990983,
-0.0036614828,
-0.0227619745,
-0.0064040432,
-0.0190597977,
-0.0082263527,
-0.0214329492,
0.0687046424,
-0.0291956216,
0.0208185986,
0.000487524,
-0.0726797208,
-0.0401101895,
0.0101193395,
0.0366470106,
-0.0373989269,
0.0166477729,
-0.0591828562,
-0.0238341633,
-0.0055501126,
0.0103504248,
-0.0338473134,
0.0194525942,
-0.0155951651,
-0.0228046924,
-0.0363834649,
-0.0073631867,
0.0333237872,
0.0145150684,
-0.0921811983,
0.0383636542,
-0.0002148259,
-0.0193072464,
-0.074078165,
-0.0420850962,
0.0219145957,
0.0115785841,
-0.0422477312,
-0.0141698038,
2.320627427e-34,
0.0005013449,
-0.0209027138,
0.0270307977,
0.0167957786,
-0.0161868669,
0.0310987979,
-0.0151898172,
-0.0253462251,
0.0890453234,
-0.0405960791,
-0.0143799856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18034v1 | Paramanu: A Family of Novel Efficient Indic Generative Foundation Language Models | 2024-01-31T17:58:10 | 2024-01-31T17:58:10 | Mitodru Niyogi, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present Gyan AI Paramanu ("atom"), a family of novel language models for
Indian languages. It is a collection of auto-regressive monolingual, bilingual,
and multilingual Indic language models pretrained from scratch on a single GPU
for 10 Indian languages (Assamese, Bangla, Hindi, Konkani, Maithili, Marathi,
Odia, Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu) across 5 scripts (Bangla, Devanagari, Odia,
Tamil, Telugu) of varying sizes ranging from 13.29M to 367.5M.The models are
pretrained with a context size of 1024 on a single GPU. The models are very
efficient, small, fast, and powerful. We have also developed an efficient most
advanced Indic tokenizer that can even tokenize unseen languages. In order to
avoid the "curse of multi-linguality" in our multilingual mParamanu model, we
pretrained on comparable corpora by typological grouping using the same script.
We performed human evaluation of our pretrained models for open end text
generation on grammar, coherence, creativity, and factuality metrics for
Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit. Our Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit models
outperformed GPT-3.5-Turbo (ChatGPT), Bloom 7B, LLaMa-2 7B, OPT 6.7B, GPT-J 6B,
GPTNeo 1.3B, GPT2-XL large language models (LLMs) by a large margin despite
being smaller in size by 66 to 20 times compared to standard 7B LLMs. To run
inference on our pretrained models, CPU is enough, and GPU is not needed. We
also instruction-tuned our pretrained Bangla, Hindi, Marathi, Tamil, and Telugu
models on 23k instructions in respective languages. Our pretrained and
instruction-tuned models which are first of its kind, most powerful efficient
small generative language models ever developed for Indic languages, and the
various results lead to the conclusion that high quality generative language
models are possible without high amount of compute power and humongous number
of parameters. We plan to release our models at https://www.bharatgpts.com. | Paramanu: A Family of Novel Efficient Indic Generative Foundation Language Models: We present Gyan AI Paramanu ("atom"), a family of novel language models for
Indian languages. It is a collection of auto-regressive monolingual, bilingual,
and multilingual Indic language models pretrained from scratch on a single GPU
for 10 Indian languages (Assamese, Bangla, Hindi, Konkani, Maithili, Marathi,
Odia, Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu) across 5 scripts (Bangla, Devanagari, Odia,
Tamil, Telugu) of varying sizes ranging from 13.29M to 367.5M.The models are
pretrained with a context size of 1024 on a single GPU. The models are very
efficient, small, fast, and powerful. We have also developed an efficient most
advanced Indic tokenizer that can even tokenize unseen languages. In order to
avoid the "curse of multi-linguality" in our multilingual mParamanu model, we
pretrained on comparable corpora by typological grouping using the same script.
We performed human evaluation of our pretrained models for open end text
generation on grammar, coherence, creativity, and factuality metrics for
Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit. Our Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit models
outperformed GPT-3.5-Turbo (ChatGPT), Bloom 7B, LLaMa-2 7B, OPT 6.7B, GPT-J 6B,
GPTNeo 1.3B, GPT2-XL large language models (LLMs) by a large margin despite
being smaller in size by 66 to 20 times compared to standard 7B LLMs. To run
inference on our pretrained models, CPU is enough, and GPU is not needed. We
also instruction-tuned our pretrained Bangla, Hindi, Marathi, Tamil, and Telugu
models on 23k instructions in respective languages. Our pretrained and
instruction-tuned models which are first of its kind, most powerful efficient
small generative language models ever developed for Indic languages, and the
various results lead to the conclusion that high quality generative language
models are possible without high amount of compute power and humongous number
of parameters. We plan to release our models at https://www.bharatgpts.com. | [
0.0208239723,
0.0396839492,
-0.0126739172,
0.0202002004,
-0.0499849841,
0.0016873707,
0.0138654988,
-0.0072007366,
-0.0248797294,
-0.0351081453,
-0.0288655013,
-0.0701004341,
0.0175628792,
0.0577524267,
0.0217568763,
-0.0508335307,
0.0252201296,
-0.0295129213,
0.0220313892,
0.016643608,
0.0141225839,
0.0538911782,
-0.0211661775,
0.0394369587,
-0.0465741344,
-0.0361643061,
0.002015528,
0.0033372482,
-0.0119353859,
-0.0299488716,
-0.0313003063,
0.0625597984,
-0.0133974077,
0.0341637135,
0.0000022425,
-0.0574960373,
0.0025995995,
-0.0289163981,
0.0255435016,
0.0233404934,
0.0683462918,
0.001577394,
-0.0093831979,
0.0345976278,
-0.0227589589,
0.0055754823,
0.0626829192,
0.0144838765,
0.0239398833,
0.08739914,
-0.0304116867,
-0.0442270376,
0.0387568809,
-0.025581684,
-0.0415360145,
0.0489420742,
-0.0226397924,
-0.0234742668,
-0.0061060954,
-0.0215404071,
-0.0252409093,
-0.0122874519,
0.0240786821,
-0.0206577666,
0.001848264,
0.0378522389,
-0.0360024609,
-0.0568714365,
0.0273744296,
0.0290523022,
-0.0658087805,
-0.0540928282,
0.0101452591,
-0.003746846,
-0.0464750342,
-0.0630075112,
-0.0423292629,
0.0666939467,
-0.0226563178,
0.0571907684,
0.1042393297,
0.0207829103,
0.0061323955,
0.010253476,
0.0395715497,
0.005695811,
0.0488507077,
0.0191457756,
-0.0364211537,
0.0174898505,
-0.0291182958,
-0.058890786,
-0.0136749018,
0.0173351653,
-0.0360307768,
0.0274223313,
-0.0647572055,
-0.0475897864,
0.0338269547,
-0.0380232818,
0.0147064049,
0.0487985723,
-0.0003561254,
-0.0098167798,
-0.044349771,
0.0362367928,
0.002363703,
0.0163451601,
-0.0210740194,
-0.0083027873,
0.0385337397,
-0.0419569537,
-0.0349270292,
0.0202871785,
-0.0550907888,
-0.0170925986,
-0.0581519939,
0.0370988883,
0.006929961,
-0.0452202633,
0.025322333,
-0.0057209674,
-0.0693085939,
-0.0177466795,
0.0270158369,
-0.0115636801,
-0.0496067815,
0.0145240529,
0.0266348235,
-0.1070439592,
0.0114271892,
0.0582005121,
-0.0226659402,
-0.0206168126,
-0.005418574,
0.0325163007,
-0.0271801222,
-0.0185774826,
-0.0758353323,
-0.0082012899,
0.0091089439,
-0.0831123069,
-0.0266609378,
-0.0967848077,
0.0545674004,
0.0420209244,
-0.0081504425,
-0.0429769084,
0.0193792526,
0.0331376307,
0.0073419004,
0.0083431732,
-0.0082988031,
-0.003110121,
0.0463001393,
-0.0037402867,
0.0525528416,
0.0492871739,
0.0490913764,
0.0445606895,
0.0194360968,
-0.0185834207,
0.0164506361,
0.0269031264,
-0.0075265882,
0.0216055736,
-0.0223910511,
-0.0064315498,
-0.0040470869,
0.054503452,
0.03658171,
0.0868818015,
-0.0105334995,
0.0385697708,
0.0385826863,
0.0344712995,
0.0159885529,
0.0843210369,
0.0719637796,
-0.0018833086,
0.0228836797,
0.0142111247,
0.0023866077,
0.0364490785,
0.0104416031,
0.0237600934,
0.0690634176,
0.0576048046,
-0.0027796838,
-0.0159503669,
-0.0159724671,
-0.0441085473,
-0.0280441996,
-0.0616563074,
0.0394039787,
0.0170979854,
-0.0641456172,
0.0038641265,
0.0552257411,
-0.1033156216,
0.0354447626,
-0.0316175111,
0.0675412565,
0.0249848533,
0.0367287621,
0.0167640392,
0.0031936916,
0.0053697787,
0.0193965156,
0.068791084,
0.0242498387,
-0.0003380425,
-0.0061630644,
-0.0538013019,
0.0543301329,
-0.0110535845,
-0.0144620892,
0.0494857766,
-0.0255813319,
0.0323691592,
0.0166686531,
0.0133163873,
-0.0260583162,
0.051207494,
-0.0437525287,
0.0006244767,
-0.0098277433,
-0.0200610999,
0.0405685417,
-0.0010814939,
-0.0371388458,
0.0099163475,
0.0193613749,
-0.0309471413,
-0.0066999993,
0.0413756482,
-0.043922171,
-0.0398376137,
0.0137141179,
-0.0217831433,
0.0535119474,
-0.0186117701,
-0.0070736618,
-0.0687323734,
0.0434202179,
-0.0022789461,
0.0311765727,
-0.0607207753,
0.0375568233,
0.0066515799,
0.0081285797,
0.0062188474,
0.0458366238,
-0.0026800835,
0.0017589233,
0.0278578475,
0.0387266837,
0.0801168382,
-0.0698396266,
0.0150485616,
0.0299812574,
0.0187087785,
0.008682169,
0.0296309907,
0.0158625338,
-0.0162463039,
-0.0494084582,
-0.1189371124,
0.0098987799,
-0.0358489454,
-0.0080407793,
0.0072729876,
0.0334745571,
-0.0182394218,
0.0071625048,
-0.0138536561,
0.0015926219,
0.06770996,
-0.007394548,
0.0340968072,
-0.0265118703,
0.0130815431,
-0.0310217626,
-0.0034568142,
0.0049879882,
0.0553379282,
0.0385360569,
-0.0389268734,
-0.0071257441,
-0.0048231715,
-0.0376980416,
0.0007968466,
0.0017914342,
-0.0824371129,
-0.0024561184,
-0.0361465812,
0.0629886687,
0.0159139726,
0.0332460441,
0.0026050983,
0.009815949,
0.002907031,
0.0024347666,
-0.0201455299,
0.0094460091,
0.0123959742,
0.0174065884,
-0.0138695203,
0.0139234923,
0.0512682386,
0.0288119726,
-0.0125121865,
-0.0446727499,
-0.0063558291,
-0.0357394218,
0.007425996,
0.0197565705,
0.0361691266,
-0.0180191528,
0.038633436,
-0.0107623655,
-0.0681547374,
0.0292685218,
-0.08311598,
-0.0011167692,
-0.0485596918,
0.0081990464,
-0.039428737,
0.0132737895,
0.0225028042,
0.0287848227,
-0.0209664498,
0.0011242267,
-0.0446796939,
0.0914493129,
-0.0047319578,
-0.0155686596,
0.0088207358,
-0.0635686815,
0.0350969434,
-0.0345955864,
-0.0413664617,
-0.0359548479,
-0.0326058939,
0.030339364,
-0.0104881106,
0.059542764,
-0.0003413252,
0.0332677327,
0.055306036,
-0.0142209418,
0.0230390988,
-0.0348071791,
0.0169432461,
0.0107884295,
0.0024160899,
0.0670186877,
-0.0199337043,
-0.0192013271,
-0.0055649923,
0.0197295006,
0.0098182112,
0.0266564842,
0.0113266949,
-0.0465279631,
0.0114012249,
0.0101485485,
-0.0108514903,
-0.023487391,
0.0131880092,
0.0264678057,
0.0021793209,
-0.0194902383,
0.096707575,
0.0188778304,
0.0059859515,
-0.0069192494,
-0.0297029298,
0.0352876969,
0.0067076548,
0.0259727705,
-0.0685549229,
-0.0129364617,
0.0123953549,
-0.0149747198,
-0.0108499797,
-0.0048300484,
-0.0408642888,
-0.1245910004,
0.0230165254,
0.0203865487,
0.001220517,
-0.0223339759,
-0.0036826835,
-0.062267527,
0.0086520547,
-0.0203337129,
0.0440710783,
-0.0336593278,
0.0078967074,
0.0429242775,
-0.0217256192,
-0.0212543365,
-0.0448060967,
-0.0160515439,
0.0107472157,
0.0411037207,
0.0004901108,
-0.0301013738,
-0.0309852771,
0.0229319185,
0.0039485586,
-0.0015318514,
-0.0230226982,
0.0349055044,
-0.0111559406,
0.0045296391,
-0.0127988886,
0.0436890014,
-0.0134438416,
-0.0302236229,
-0.0030524863,
0.0182264596,
-0.0094343554,
-0.0243889727,
-0.0020472063,
-0.0039368221,
0.0069408976,
0.0343226306,
0.0293011367,
-0.0487985276,
-0.0598808825,
-0.0412710905,
0.0077485549,
-0.0709635988,
0.0163653456,
-0.0025489684,
-0.0002657317,
-0.0452401936,
-0.0558045991,
-0.0471216775,
-0.0096169887,
0.0510539152,
0.0262731351,
0.0280873328,
-0.0440616384,
-0.0112299072,
-0.0128275473,
-0.0198498331,
-0.0001284298,
0.0019025388,
-0.1250247955,
-0.0074650408,
0.012238008,
-0.0453953221,
-0.0222681351,
0.0241249967,
-0.0459942445,
-0.0627037436,
0.0145722274,
0.0511869378,
0.0154301059,
-0.0119493781,
-0.0015507962,
-0.0540293232,
0.0463319942,
0.0112369386,
-0.0250747632,
0.0306753032,
-0.0033174581,
-0.002746044,
-0.0059471163,
0.0376901403,
-0.0135250818,
0.0283724517,
-0.017145602,
0.0341174677,
0.0374559574,
0.0127455322,
0.0320777521,
0.0362306051,
0.0135059506,
-0.1012538522,
0.0346300304,
-0.0788581744,
-0.0230911933,
-0.0172442906,
0.003092767,
-0.0373436697,
0.0110418331,
0.063385427,
0.0149629042,
-0.0205903761,
-0.0426007472,
0.0082421964,
0.0225252453,
0.0020046839,
0.0197586026,
-0.0028910923,
0.0735922307,
0.0198418852,
-0.0205714945,
-0.0314916894,
-0.0103814611,
-0.0505473725,
0.0133251073,
-0.0395655818,
0.0712994263,
0.0047512064,
0.0080355676,
0.0311556775,
0.0435940214,
0.0519077219,
0.003975485,
-0.0501137152,
0.043362692,
0.0774412975,
0.0270015802,
0.0746589378,
-0.0546108633,
0.0196723007,
-0.0348886065,
0.0703290626,
0.0136994543,
-0.0356297828,
0.012978497,
-0.0205909517,
-0.0474146418,
-0.018576365,
0.0905579925,
0.0176523104,
-0.0024921757,
0.0212750528,
0.01092098,
-0.034949284,
-0.008305368,
-0.0526643172,
0.0098296842,
0.0236063115,
0.0236799922,
-0.0538739488,
-0.0202860963,
-0.0060353549,
-0.0067116944,
0.0220382344,
-0.0346714593,
0.0317294784,
0.0452316701,
0.0034149087,
0.0067797685,
-0.0359144509,
0.026644187,
-0.0431729667,
-0.0059800809,
-0.0108574405,
-6.348966946e-33,
-0.0536015108,
0.0005441631,
0.0028441669,
-0.0214279648,
-0.0082324808,
-0.0223413762,
-0.053944245,
-0.013137267,
0.0324075893,
-0.0010101038,
-0.0105250822,
-0.0072709159,
0.0055266982,
0.0279476009,
0.0166242439,
0.0240771957,
0.0501536429,
0.0177079327,
-0.0308095235,
0.0420213901,
0.0624757037,
0.0223772973,
0.0462031662,
0.0036432277,
-0.0372862853,
-0.0630418584,
-0.0058641164,
0.0074176746,
-0.0330293961,
0.0150294537,
-0.0265020747,
0.0413473435,
0.0262665637,
-0.0113223549,
-0.0092921201,
0.0004520791,
-0.040024586,
-0.0297284871,
0.0123107545,
0.0377355181,
-0.0268063787,
-0.0476048961,
0.0182994734,
-0.0030477482,
-0.0245939679,
0.0082442909,
-0.0091091301,
0.0126176737,
0.0036245605,
-0.0288351551,
-0.1074680164,
0.0400698744,
0.0127490992,
0.0105008138,
-0.0051468937,
0.0029895988,
-0.0171174835,
-0.0073613175,
-0.0347151011,
0.0013939661,
0.0156527795,
0.0649338067,
0.0653160736,
0.0219807513,
-0.026339367,
0.0289319884,
0.0066499268,
-0.0356444418,
-0.0089904089,
0.072626844,
-0.0085714646,
0.0263232272,
0.0064512603,
0.064456664,
0.0381509401,
-0.0801192522,
-0.0653438121,
0.0216050111,
0.0292817447,
0.0152900089,
0.0273813903,
-0.009702527,
-0.0031768784,
-0.0371626727,
0.0215616934,
-0.0558574498,
-0.0059332005,
-0.0408102386,
0.066267848,
-0.0119081112,
0.0061927116,
-0.0264323913,
0.0407593399,
0.0091312658,
0.0177293997,
0.0253336988,
-0.080297403,
0.0350388847,
-0.0217583235,
0.0339288041,
-0.0378596894,
-0.0817761049,
0.0060036932,
0.0081326272,
0.01469405,
-0.0066536209,
0.0156046338,
0.0179654099,
-0.054516837,
0.0145404488,
-0.055166021,
0.0535405055,
0.0394207947,
0.0242540147,
0.0081858486,
0.0112769883,
-0.0177413113,
0.0071157524,
0.0077961101,
0.021778306,
-0.0161199924,
-0.0688099191,
0.0033278712,
0.007378397,
-0.0453035347,
0.0423899069,
-0.0488946214,
-0.0082987184,
0.0474797599,
-0.0543720052,
-0.0232411884,
0.0359254256,
2.942e-7,
-0.0004917182,
0.0326810107,
0.0568308011,
-0.0246407706,
-0.0113877002,
0.0003611096,
-0.0303439777,
0.0285391584,
0.0006094018,
0.0513909124,
-0.0159202926,
0.0043189968,
0.0531241708,
0.0204003789,
-0.091307126,
0.0422106981,
-0.1026347503,
0.0231804512,
-0.0767268538,
-0.0214627516,
-0.0373368934,
0.06402082,
0.0036455025,
-0.00152873,
0.0087841377,
-0.0187607445,
0.0643421561,
0.0154220266,
-0.0044421703,
0.0394722149,
0.021638291,
-0.0041986275,
-0.0362806171,
-0.0419828519,
-0.0141078541,
0.0182002466,
0.0290854443,
0.0589386597,
-0.0207936075,
0.0270390343,
0.0823527351,
-0.0005288494,
-0.0096822958,
-0.0644482151,
0.0426477306,
0.036982324,
-0.0138984928,
-0.0174174216,
0.002322725,
0.014079514,
-0.0069642817,
-0.0395380035,
-0.0092208991,
0.0106412442,
0.0119378995,
-0.053673625,
-0.0289650355,
0.0043665646,
-0.0496413559,
0.0148380436,
-0.0290133823,
-0.0447643809,
-0.0378929563,
0.0329919793,
0.032113716,
-0.0460580438,
0.0023611644,
2.756867616e-34,
0.055681292,
-0.0216353796,
0.0203272924,
-0.0179205332,
0.0460935012,
-0.0197720267,
-0.0040885475,
0.0158712417,
-0.0049363622,
-0.0462081879,
-0.0385331549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18028v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18028v2 | Evaluating the Capabilities of LLMs for Supporting Anticipatory Impact Assessment | 2024-01-31T17:43:04 | 2024-05-20T23:34:39 | Mowafak Allaham, Nicholas Diakopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Gaining insight into the potential negative impacts of emerging Artificial
Intelligence (AI) technologies in society is a challenge for implementing
anticipatory governance approaches. One approach to produce such insight is to
use Large Language Models (LLMs) to support and guide experts in the process of
ideating and exploring the range of undesirable consequences of emerging
technologies. However, performance evaluations of LLMs for such tasks are still
needed, including examining the general quality of generated impacts but also
the range of types of impacts produced and resulting biases. In this paper, we
demonstrate the potential for generating high-quality and diverse impacts of AI
in society by fine-tuning completion models (GPT-3 and Mistral-7B) on a diverse
sample of articles from news media and comparing those outputs to the impacts
generated by instruction-based (GPT-4 and Mistral-7B-Instruct) models. We
examine the generated impacts for coherence, structure, relevance, and
plausibility and find that the generated impacts using Mistral-7B, a small
open-source model fine-tuned on impacts from the news media, tend to be
qualitatively on par with impacts generated using a more capable and larger
scale model such as GPT-4. Moreover, we find that impacts produced by
instruction-based models had gaps in the production of certain categories of
impacts in comparison to fine-tuned models. This research highlights a
potential bias in the range of impacts generated by state-of-the-art LLMs and
the potential of aligning smaller LLMs on news media as a scalable alternative
to generate high quality and more diverse impacts in support of anticipatory
governance approaches. | Evaluating the Capabilities of LLMs for Supporting Anticipatory Impact Assessment: Gaining insight into the potential negative impacts of emerging Artificial
Intelligence (AI) technologies in society is a challenge for implementing
anticipatory governance approaches. One approach to produce such insight is to
use Large Language Models (LLMs) to support and guide experts in the process of
ideating and exploring the range of undesirable consequences of emerging
technologies. However, performance evaluations of LLMs for such tasks are still
needed, including examining the general quality of generated impacts but also
the range of types of impacts produced and resulting biases. In this paper, we
demonstrate the potential for generating high-quality and diverse impacts of AI
in society by fine-tuning completion models (GPT-3 and Mistral-7B) on a diverse
sample of articles from news media and comparing those outputs to the impacts
generated by instruction-based (GPT-4 and Mistral-7B-Instruct) models. We
examine the generated impacts for coherence, structure, relevance, and
plausibility and find that the generated impacts using Mistral-7B, a small
open-source model fine-tuned on impacts from the news media, tend to be
qualitatively on par with impacts generated using a more capable and larger
scale model such as GPT-4. Moreover, we find that impacts produced by
instruction-based models had gaps in the production of certain categories of
impacts in comparison to fine-tuned models. This research highlights a
potential bias in the range of impacts generated by state-of-the-art LLMs and
the potential of aligning smaller LLMs on news media as a scalable alternative
to generate high quality and more diverse impacts in support of anticipatory
governance approaches. | [
0.0440735109,
0.0679959804,
-0.04206305,
-0.0250536818,
-0.0558312275,
-0.0109399557,
0.0088925548,
-0.0140539827,
0.0586305372,
-0.0442083888,
0.0701669678,
0.0520476401,
-0.0331865512,
0.0470150784,
0.0093839187,
-0.042631276,
0.0389454775,
0.0079861367,
0.0115698967,
-0.014282681,
0.0088723516,
0.0123681221,
0.0151534472,
0.0626551658,
-0.0266005173,
-0.0151237771,
0.0095757376,
0.0199020579,
0.0246571377,
-0.0479259863,
0.0034273763,
0.0286337193,
0.0292483177,
0.0130636478,
0.0000024949,
-0.0691073537,
-0.0028652758,
0.0191297811,
0.0129600829,
0.0134556107,
0.0667507499,
0.0181132816,
0.0176613405,
0.0015658472,
-0.0254932102,
0.0731216371,
-0.0007086824,
-0.0338331349,
0.0131641077,
0.0078164749,
0.0076551219,
-0.0359242409,
0.0704558194,
0.0080884174,
0.0057344246,
0.0007473555,
0.0220859442,
0.0120319501,
-0.0049588098,
0.0002472745,
0.0148375724,
0.0573602132,
0.0189895369,
-0.0072745583,
0.0008908713,
-0.0200117361,
0.0104997568,
-0.0307491925,
-0.0017620402,
0.0405852087,
0.091657117,
0.0039436831,
-0.000791888,
-0.0459633805,
0.0596576557,
0.0440331511,
-0.0521622226,
0.0105890622,
-0.0190892369,
-0.0161698777,
0.0370023139,
0.0103619313,
0.0396082737,
0.0585484356,
0.0033539629,
0.0877224728,
-0.0215706769,
-0.0444624349,
-0.0100438101,
0.0145742279,
0.0338140391,
-0.0175312255,
-0.0022321634,
0.0016103024,
-0.0190964397,
0.0147258956,
0.0044068513,
-0.0069814273,
0.0142875649,
-0.0547579825,
0.0249974914,
0.0211234987,
-0.0097861923,
0.0139563689,
0.026187947,
-0.0081139058,
-0.0463436656,
0.0069964365,
0.0068273689,
0.0290585794,
-0.0690061375,
-0.0129422508,
0.00265328,
0.0464570783,
-0.0453354642,
-0.0124376891,
0.0210070964,
0.0152179739,
-0.0782575011,
0.027941484,
-0.0065755653,
0.0223781355,
0.020335095,
-0.029228352,
-0.0386412442,
0.0024321338,
-0.053738419,
0.0841029361,
-0.0143522806,
-0.0119326515,
0.0084101968,
0.0136810709,
0.0030122006,
-0.0001958977,
0.00813682,
0.0882875025,
0.0539704487,
-0.0009584228,
-0.0305983964,
-0.0621793605,
-0.0058772611,
-0.0483193956,
0.0107576214,
-0.0590484738,
-0.0472760908,
-0.0017382405,
0.012543764,
-0.0540076829,
-0.0072858715,
0.0066174585,
-0.0346413702,
0.0010757999,
-0.0652866066,
0.0350467451,
0.0276299976,
0.0255163759,
-0.0049826265,
0.0736588687,
0.0221598912,
0.0582551733,
0.0100743547,
0.0039209863,
0.0303631481,
0.0138329575,
-0.0147073464,
0.0276248083,
-0.0454457514,
0.0086864866,
-0.064193286,
-0.0097884946,
0.0004466406,
0.0337020494,
0.0045215487,
0.0775891095,
0.0719228014,
0.0118858786,
-0.0291259848,
0.0210944768,
0.0323238149,
0.0034642008,
-0.0191329159,
0.0036712172,
-0.023420373,
-0.0013319565,
-0.0352948382,
-0.0272047129,
-0.0022789016,
0.0103011681,
-0.0223401394,
-0.0472741835,
0.016160395,
0.0121763488,
0.0664770678,
0.0469078161,
0.0132576562,
-0.0214573629,
-0.0367996767,
-0.0262918919,
-0.0314978547,
-0.0030634017,
0.0068169371,
-0.0696791187,
0.0430121087,
0.0849738345,
0.0642239302,
-0.0369556211,
0.0112278992,
-0.0270793624,
-0.0229027607,
0.0234171338,
0.0068743369,
-0.0047965404,
-0.0678608194,
-0.0001147021,
-0.0419520847,
-0.0388548635,
0.0389684774,
0.0237258971,
0.0039631459,
0.0075392853,
-0.0081566079,
0.0144288819,
-0.0407645293,
0.0274594184,
-0.0112330113,
0.011510686,
-0.0591557659,
0.0139999753,
0.0407783575,
0.0566706806,
-0.0121834464,
0.0305892006,
0.0130038671,
0.0008965529,
-0.0531287491,
-0.0258903168,
0.0054964377,
0.0928253233,
-0.0150355473,
-0.0380337201,
-0.0074628713,
0.0498844758,
0.0008712445,
-0.013067591,
0.0610875897,
-0.0277288705,
0.0120711029,
-0.0054848809,
-0.0082074758,
-0.0662885085,
-0.0244294479,
-0.0156078022,
0.0356479771,
-0.0461722501,
-0.0435092039,
0.0150594348,
-0.022352336,
0.017431695,
0.0297173709,
-0.053551808,
0.0080034658,
0.0060215965,
0.0158214532,
0.0905684903,
-0.041530095,
-0.0196339265,
-0.0377214253,
-0.0666064098,
-0.005475922,
-0.0225745626,
0.0065952959,
-0.0040711579,
-0.0218120106,
-0.0117287263,
0.0297267027,
0.0237382501,
-0.0441497602,
0.0042530154,
0.0550212674,
-0.0175905898,
0.0053611575,
-0.0342818201,
-0.026210092,
0.0009000421,
-0.0270243678,
-0.0034173452,
0.0374847576,
-0.0624589734,
-0.0361121632,
0.0060537276,
-0.0310401991,
-0.0303102806,
0.0129301669,
-0.031143669,
0.025022056,
0.0264389813,
-0.022669049,
0.0285212826,
-0.0020990989,
0.0578101762,
0.0403089933,
-0.0015665805,
-0.052808404,
-0.0103287017,
-0.0054720775,
0.0064053996,
-0.0291934721,
-0.0445111319,
-0.0154914651,
0.0262963064,
0.0187956318,
0.0106291715,
-0.051026199,
0.0759767368,
-0.0761125609,
-0.0744150281,
-0.0061757779,
-0.0968036279,
-0.0240240414,
0.0541170388,
-0.0152092604,
-0.059848696,
0.0331336334,
0.0303382538,
0.0681678131,
-0.0131903403,
-0.0089329761,
-0.0153169055,
0.0613827631,
0.0082883984,
0.0148291923,
-0.0134287551,
-0.0131803611,
-0.0416357107,
-0.0186797194,
0.0209767651,
-0.0036490473,
0.0007964292,
-0.0742849186,
-0.0095845712,
0.0103830965,
-0.0171116255,
-0.0040782718,
-0.038849026,
-0.0037563518,
0.0454985574,
0.0657048821,
0.0185415577,
-0.0278766099,
-0.0132352803,
0.0750076324,
-0.0020137376,
0.0060924808,
-0.0152009418,
-0.0216126759,
-0.0411968045,
-0.0003372971,
-0.0326673537,
0.0472187139,
0.0429256074,
0.0334247798,
0.0083254557,
0.0117975399,
-0.0115312738,
-0.0346438102,
0.017598344,
0.0111332778,
-0.0124866022,
-0.0219036993,
0.0244624745,
0.0542771481,
-0.0370646827,
0.0113860499,
0.0546473786,
0.0054083276,
-0.0281323157,
0.0170968808,
0.0023424833,
-0.0424096882,
0.0298127867,
-0.024927659,
-0.0954137966,
0.0177636165,
0.0233334415,
-0.0010501588,
-0.0939202607,
-0.0625434667,
0.0283054318,
-0.088271454,
0.0530784279,
-0.0122678271,
0.0465910099,
-0.0022454925,
-0.0217814893,
-0.0131688658,
-0.0225201603,
-0.0418469273,
-0.0064956681,
0.0079795094,
-0.0107042547,
0.0138145313,
-0.0817442089,
-0.0411752574,
0.0110201789,
-0.0024316625,
0.045309227,
0.0969758108,
0.0282040965,
-0.0656523556,
0.0339313596,
0.0291465633,
-0.0079184212,
0.008283996,
0.0235856418,
0.0120196017,
0.0181406457,
0.0358290859,
-0.0366251469,
0.007542809,
0.0489149168,
-0.0402385034,
0.0554937273,
0.0734452382,
-0.0319504254,
-0.0310714412,
-0.0389180742,
-0.0008240034,
0.0237818826,
0.0319490954,
0.0034707948,
-0.0482286848,
0.0015974286,
-0.0080415318,
-0.0110258432,
-0.0107966661,
-0.032657139,
0.0006196033,
-0.0017066393,
-0.0078031463,
-0.0054999487,
-0.0997845158,
-0.0281077083,
-0.0294764824,
0.0360331051,
-0.0004003838,
0.0404275693,
-0.0052769999,
0.0202337634,
0.0287682731,
0.0108713889,
-0.0013998942,
-0.0026019285,
-0.0089566028,
-0.0174748711,
0.0407511182,
0.001671788,
0.047161039,
-0.0260724649,
-0.062107116,
0.0512064919,
0.0439721756,
0.0330261923,
-0.0239581354,
0.0133288158,
-0.0394220464,
0.0656986013,
0.0150529062,
0.0021748778,
0.0048125791,
0.0391135551,
0.0046156677,
-0.0117898667,
0.0051440313,
0.0040699802,
0.0109042767,
0.0056602717,
0.0202111546,
-0.0557313226,
-0.0078501636,
0.0328605399,
0.0046920693,
0.0509735048,
-0.0642507523,
-0.0198596586,
-0.0237681381,
-0.0473582894,
-0.0378139243,
-0.0207179151,
-0.0131141208,
-0.0090057766,
0.0230209902,
-0.0117583275,
-0.0178156197,
0.0447002538,
-0.0456358492,
0.0071162577,
-0.0707115084,
0.0799569041,
-0.0097980322,
0.0624559186,
0.0040565492,
-0.0050853104,
-0.0545874424,
0.0098340474,
-0.0505686402,
-0.0083081871,
0.0169072337,
0.0408183783,
-0.0084286425,
0.0342767872,
0.0268388335,
0.028907923,
-0.0180088226,
-0.062169861,
-0.0244099237,
0.0617118031,
-0.0110781314,
0.0433372706,
-0.0188527703,
-0.0181195717,
-0.0190584455,
-0.0150206313,
0.0008635501,
0.0001007167,
-0.043558795,
0.0216604602,
0.0081334682,
-0.0693518221,
-0.0067309304,
0.0435488001,
-0.056435775,
0.0696511194,
-0.0165771581,
-0.0255908798,
0.0038235637,
-0.0818658471,
0.0232408643,
0.0315502733,
-0.0037840789,
-0.0018768157,
-0.0947370306,
-0.0056612026,
-0.0248238109,
0.0028822166,
0.0020961436,
-0.0378475338,
-0.0047100219,
0.0206880756,
0.0049925349,
-0.057692986,
-0.0328013897,
-0.0111838067,
-0.0922623873,
-0.000323729,
0.0172054581,
-6.621934367e-33,
-0.0141457738,
-0.0171481166,
0.0466784537,
-0.0319294594,
-0.0384482369,
0.0074418453,
-0.0014401292,
0.0524582639,
-0.0437517948,
0.0371826477,
0.0175532307,
-0.0117452079,
0.0001030643,
-0.0236853231,
0.0335536338,
0.0060056909,
0.0511079691,
0.0142760063,
0.0176587161,
0.0103860898,
0.0000011935,
-0.0206592176,
0.0101442132,
-0.079713136,
0.0893141255,
-0.0129575338,
-0.0502193496,
-0.0503667034,
-0.0078084068,
0.005166248,
-0.0040476848,
0.0543613099,
0.0304505769,
-0.0700176507,
-0.0149544841,
0.05836422,
-0.0008418079,
-0.0199460648,
0.0532306135,
-0.0395480432,
0.0299524423,
-0.0711309165,
0.0100887716,
0.001715537,
-0.0869385079,
0.0439887717,
0.02776278,
-0.0575794019,
-0.0033281469,
-0.027560195,
-0.103854008,
0.0246603265,
-0.0431498848,
0.0365346111,
-0.0438853391,
0.0726411715,
0.0121015795,
0.0763232112,
-0.0698789731,
-0.0045374772,
0.0297878738,
-0.0216418169,
0.0496395342,
-0.0430939831,
0.0201233234,
0.0434853435,
0.0215989184,
0.0307158902,
-0.0488399975,
-0.0216083769,
0.0280078724,
0.0237511285,
0.0288224332,
0.0709305629,
-0.0084911017,
-0.059253227,
-0.0548518822,
0.0070567913,
-0.0169175267,
0.0552602224,
0.0579745136,
-0.0078762863,
-0.0575815216,
-0.0227594767,
-0.0509787016,
-0.067117095,
0.0023567956,
-0.029408671,
0.0179415811,
-0.0131277991,
-0.0299738068,
0.04003774,
0.0255405996,
-0.0498966724,
0.026083136,
0.0182719976,
-0.0412072912,
0.0243268106,
0.0112550361,
0.0397847109,
-0.0627315342,
0.0066959774,
-0.0129367448,
0.0208644625,
0.0696745887,
0.0108902119,
0.0100491084,
0.0100348732,
-0.0264557004,
-0.0154920146,
-0.0252776369,
0.0274146218,
0.0291224476,
-0.0607724488,
0.047289867,
0.0364098996,
0.0233722292,
-0.0097855711,
0.0440929234,
0.0178568196,
0.0034619011,
-0.0399125665,
-0.0348931476,
0.0080721732,
-0.0281048901,
-0.0126146385,
-0.0260864608,
0.0330615006,
0.0216550864,
-0.0187558904,
-0.0199935809,
0.0190435145,
3.125e-7,
0.0314597487,
0.0595904179,
-0.0185261089,
0.0087798778,
0.0059037469,
0.0305359438,
0.0239413716,
0.0186685957,
-0.0039545218,
-0.0339234918,
0.0552586205,
-0.0012895096,
0.0192177091,
0.0194025449,
-0.0270142425,
0.0023828093,
-0.0645795986,
0.0024187907,
-0.0870773271,
0.051562883,
0.0315326527,
0.0168076735,
0.0355246551,
0.0175717417,
-0.044275213,
0.0150373532,
0.0228601526,
-0.0476619229,
-0.0371920802,
0.000884384,
0.0257911142,
0.0333504826,
0.0160386283,
0.0312448535,
0.0192156881,
-0.0130295996,
-0.0193174295,
0.0214103591,
-0.0060048741,
0.014055972,
0.0036444995,
-0.0395552032,
0.018363988,
-0.0557231531,
0.0839340016,
-0.0299257021,
-0.0522518791,
-0.0244956166,
-0.0368325002,
-0.017411394,
0.0670365468,
-0.0168534033,
0.0206861552,
-0.0074314019,
-0.0182687826,
-0.0016795676,
-0.001501139,
-0.0353641137,
0.0278511532,
0.0383096822,
-0.0258778576,
-0.0882424936,
-0.0101109995,
0.0107829506,
0.000539538,
-0.0720883831,
0.0550407507,
2.744507935e-34,
0.0262905918,
-0.0059686624,
0.0046818564,
-0.0365513191,
0.0489292145,
0.0519720651,
-0.044520326,
-0.0120591549,
-0.0074486951,
-0.0748953149,
0.0061544008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18018v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18018v4 | On Prompt-Driven Safeguarding for Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T17:28:24 | 2024-06-03T06:52:58 | Chujie Zheng, Fan Yin, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Kai-Wei Chang, Minlie Huang, Nanyun Peng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prepending model inputs with safety prompts is a common practice for
safeguarding large language models (LLMs) against queries with harmful intents.
However, the underlying working mechanisms of safety prompts have not been
unraveled yet, restricting the possibility of automatically optimizing them to
improve LLM safety. In this work, we investigate how LLMs' behavior (i.e.,
complying with or refusing user queries) is affected by safety prompts from the
perspective of model representation. We find that in the representation space,
the input queries are typically moved by safety prompts in a "higher-refusal"
direction, in which models become more prone to refusing to provide assistance,
even when the queries are harmless. On the other hand, LLMs are naturally
capable of distinguishing harmful and harmless queries without safety prompts.
Inspired by these findings, we propose a method for safety prompt optimization,
namely DRO (Directed Representation Optimization). Treating a safety prompt as
continuous, trainable embeddings, DRO learns to move the queries'
representations along or opposite the refusal direction, depending on their
harmfulness. Experiments with eight LLMs on out-of-domain and jailbreak
benchmarks demonstrate that DRO remarkably improves the safeguarding
performance of human-crafted safety prompts, without compromising the models'
general performance. | On Prompt-Driven Safeguarding for Large Language Models: Prepending model inputs with safety prompts is a common practice for
safeguarding large language models (LLMs) against queries with harmful intents.
However, the underlying working mechanisms of safety prompts have not been
unraveled yet, restricting the possibility of automatically optimizing them to
improve LLM safety. In this work, we investigate how LLMs' behavior (i.e.,
complying with or refusing user queries) is affected by safety prompts from the
perspective of model representation. We find that in the representation space,
the input queries are typically moved by safety prompts in a "higher-refusal"
direction, in which models become more prone to refusing to provide assistance,
even when the queries are harmless. On the other hand, LLMs are naturally
capable of distinguishing harmful and harmless queries without safety prompts.
Inspired by these findings, we propose a method for safety prompt optimization,
namely DRO (Directed Representation Optimization). Treating a safety prompt as
continuous, trainable embeddings, DRO learns to move the queries'
representations along or opposite the refusal direction, depending on their
harmfulness. Experiments with eight LLMs on out-of-domain and jailbreak
benchmarks demonstrate that DRO remarkably improves the safeguarding
performance of human-crafted safety prompts, without compromising the models'
general performance. | [
0.0363931432,
0.0637523383,
-0.015607751,
0.043046698,
0.0004569654,
0.0104661603,
-0.0004499115,
0.0029389607,
0.0528159775,
-0.0386588126,
-0.0215442237,
-0.0667681545,
-0.0450200438,
-0.005550473,
0.0292273816,
-0.0189495366,
0.0826715529,
-0.0639922693,
0.0025489561,
-0.0029122494,
0.0104581704,
-0.0181161426,
0.0256369989,
0.0609032847,
-0.0047991946,
-0.0178860277,
0.0007554916,
0.0168656223,
-0.0064010364,
-0.0374514982,
0.0221595839,
0.0431857444,
0.0121246846,
0.0676882118,
0.000002069,
-0.0460402034,
-0.0103001613,
0.0182606559,
-0.0415546373,
0.0113463085,
0.0227528326,
-0.058936689,
-0.0202726312,
0.0428541452,
-0.0186454467,
-0.0036237009,
0.0572453663,
0.0452476665,
0.0757150576,
0.0745671764,
0.0087271417,
0.0278677121,
0.026802931,
-0.0035338507,
-0.0084834816,
-0.0402236246,
0.004663026,
-0.0302896295,
-0.0034913812,
0.0308008902,
-0.0220303833,
0.0234054103,
0.0244402308,
-0.0367733501,
-0.0440877452,
-0.009442281,
-0.0298184752,
-0.0432434082,
-0.0076565472,
0.064686425,
-0.0517771728,
-0.0074610724,
-0.0056848926,
-0.0160482991,
0.03036125,
0.0229198448,
-0.0165153444,
0.0338085294,
0.0105282506,
-0.0088305613,
-0.0077493261,
0.0056654257,
0.0633961037,
-0.0068751224,
-0.0242212359,
0.0507470705,
0.0195959732,
-0.0275995042,
0.010400963,
-0.0362805948,
-0.0222709887,
-0.0497716814,
0.0032912188,
0.0044585695,
-0.0655736551,
0.0215899106,
-0.0511267334,
-0.0067726574,
0.0402772278,
-0.0481697917,
0.0235907491,
0.0391496941,
-0.0089576785,
0.0247907136,
0.0020519784,
0.0254123006,
-0.0247657374,
0.0676086098,
-0.0054391013,
0.0314539634,
0.00527533,
-0.0153698782,
-0.0307114478,
0.0277964063,
-0.0138681997,
0.0273975767,
0.01150472,
0.0620023049,
-0.0205636993,
0.0238474291,
-0.0202423353,
0.0055516083,
-0.0142054334,
-0.007802486,
0.0068251248,
-0.0277237911,
-0.0378477387,
-0.0061786785,
0.0114525985,
-0.0620867833,
-0.024510026,
-0.0126454923,
-0.0316202566,
-0.0304101761,
-0.0299804024,
0.1130040959,
0.0344162732,
-0.0077304402,
-0.0524461195,
-0.0674557537,
-0.0050931014,
-0.0302561037,
-0.0015576006,
-0.025841767,
-0.000665617,
-0.0062727695,
-0.0152998716,
-0.0828807876,
0.0033624554,
0.0409049802,
-0.04032401,
0.0656888932,
0.0155857736,
-0.0155864218,
-0.011845096,
0.0462709256,
-0.0365276113,
0.0801566169,
0.0263611563,
0.040716026,
0.0446676314,
-0.0110505708,
0.0311893709,
0.0443015397,
0.0146185337,
0.042692285,
-0.0481421426,
0.0223256219,
0.0630074143,
0.0069393525,
-0.0019092278,
0.0604137443,
-0.0237887967,
-0.0369063616,
0.0617271364,
0.0461288616,
-0.0276960786,
-0.0023812728,
0.0235837251,
-0.0035081548,
-0.035772875,
0.0012057344,
-0.1111854017,
-0.0064900885,
-0.0646991283,
-0.0229720734,
-0.0095852688,
0.0125959832,
0.0002975516,
-0.0231978633,
-0.0080643445,
-0.0090154037,
-0.003136687,
0.0261579268,
-0.0101673119,
-0.0013664548,
-0.0251718499,
0.0371882282,
0.016337486,
-0.036178343,
-0.038548477,
-0.0591443367,
0.0223344732,
0.068516463,
0.0454172343,
-0.0217449591,
-0.0321890004,
-0.0255692936,
0.0039036649,
-0.0029793994,
0.0361908861,
-0.0223695487,
0.0513797663,
-0.0314220637,
-0.0547222681,
0.0261411853,
0.0284508783,
-0.0042583155,
0.0146138035,
0.0012546175,
0.0266283192,
-0.0116681177,
-0.0664059743,
0.0463566966,
-0.0038624078,
-0.0554728359,
-0.0015312281,
0.0295343492,
-0.010626303,
0.0009718252,
-0.0024803365,
0.0178628992,
0.0392452665,
0.0007149841,
0.0213568322,
-0.0314245038,
-0.0808526501,
0.0023088765,
0.0363225937,
0.0155894924,
-0.0241969321,
0.0280064493,
-0.0196038838,
-0.004351336,
-0.0069291769,
-0.0278260112,
0.0429280028,
-0.0101988185,
0.0245862715,
-0.0158430003,
-0.0235659685,
-0.0488761105,
0.0262168944,
-0.0146332579,
-0.0232602023,
0.0198781509,
0.0145504586,
0.0260177553,
-0.0071274415,
-0.0578463934,
0.0212871581,
-0.0177127477,
0.0642611086,
0.0323676392,
0.0068529896,
-0.0237100832,
-0.0037691952,
-0.048872523,
0.0037632221,
-0.0347301066,
0.0035938213,
0.0061841342,
0.0321847238,
-0.0178530551,
-0.0294501614,
0.0091505358,
-0.035930641,
-0.0072469404,
0.0512939878,
-0.0037196779,
-0.0012491466,
-0.0328298211,
-0.0229847766,
-0.0092969416,
-0.0211989768,
0.0342257284,
-0.0375432633,
-0.0100988979,
-0.0474115051,
0.0324396528,
0.0125373118,
0.0336214863,
-0.0077903201,
-0.0376832075,
0.017781835,
-0.0161362328,
0.0092266519,
0.0724405646,
-0.0020005719,
0.0130442744,
0.0912643597,
0.0179974753,
-0.0707302243,
0.0049265092,
0.0186837558,
-0.0475709625,
-0.0175545085,
0.0023787925,
0.0164802223,
0.0416319109,
-0.0168321393,
-0.0201524049,
-0.0556331761,
0.0024894308,
-0.0274207406,
-0.0406453349,
-0.0284145195,
-0.0398961157,
-0.0450257324,
0.0509460345,
-0.0042327377,
-0.0629239753,
0.0865725204,
-0.0175740793,
0.0218057577,
-0.0047563682,
-0.0122686606,
0.0098205023,
0.0610403791,
-0.0103311418,
0.0212950595,
0.0498185977,
-0.0491610058,
-0.0597246923,
-0.0078425892,
0.0381024815,
-0.0268632099,
0.0508394167,
-0.0268020611,
-0.0253166743,
-0.0165216513,
-0.052557379,
-0.0633989275,
-0.0953868851,
-0.0240047667,
-0.0233501866,
0.0027912133,
-0.0112642478,
-0.0092123672,
-0.0012646477,
-0.0029864612,
0.0121620502,
-0.0358619317,
0.0059062336,
-0.0208662804,
-0.0313148387,
0.0477997251,
-0.0098889824,
0.0124993185,
-0.0329272971,
0.0629928261,
0.0702640414,
0.0421507657,
-0.0378523059,
-0.0053601447,
0.0230032876,
0.0616536252,
-0.0002987383,
-0.0259567816,
0.0613716915,
0.0487221256,
-0.0528168753,
-0.0309663005,
0.0731130242,
0.0321203619,
-0.0385008827,
0.0232518055,
-0.0344106033,
0.0764089972,
0.0322346725,
0.0307106823,
-0.0505528972,
-0.0351669118,
0.0401770175,
0.050736092,
0.0181426406,
-0.0201474894,
-0.0047435467,
-0.1174492538,
0.0276835263,
0.03016348,
0.0059811468,
-0.0165718105,
-0.0203138795,
-0.0205988269,
0.0000140041,
0.0592398979,
0.0043923398,
-0.0235758219,
-0.0097545069,
0.0228753574,
-0.0087548494,
-0.0222705379,
0.0112141464,
-0.0723251179,
0.033004038,
0.0924833491,
-0.0274049621,
0.0090411343,
-0.0108485371,
0.0497476198,
0.0262582637,
-0.0058326651,
0.001478154,
0.0116627859,
-0.0104517946,
-0.0040132008,
0.0072623477,
0.0200227797,
-0.0045928978,
-0.0358313695,
0.0382485762,
0.091018416,
-0.0288587213,
0.0121237235,
-0.0485510752,
-0.0194897335,
0.0356990024,
0.0629742369,
0.040247675,
-0.0347345322,
-0.0248200074,
-0.0633385181,
-0.0168838613,
-0.030195944,
-0.0215180106,
0.0161198918,
-0.0003204962,
-0.040397618,
-0.0227270294,
-0.0181619264,
-0.0055916901,
0.0306612123,
0.0498294979,
-0.0405983105,
-0.0075093247,
0.0090112239,
-0.0043493197,
0.0277967453,
-0.0453863889,
0.0320606343,
-0.0750937387,
0.0656441227,
0.0072978637,
0.0203898512,
-0.0180008281,
-0.0017545874,
-0.0292072743,
-0.0965701044,
0.0109223528,
0.0727920085,
0.0235917065,
0.0119049819,
-0.0415644124,
-0.0870596096,
0.0472351387,
0.0633772984,
-0.0644696131,
-0.020006761,
0.0458286963,
-0.0668368638,
0.0031272108,
0.0357731022,
-0.0606259555,
-0.037047632,
0.0178655852,
0.0143025527,
-0.0377879888,
-0.0306812618,
0.0164806135,
0.0379734896,
0.0353686251,
-0.0011469912,
0.0114820898,
-0.0075638448,
0.0228923038,
-0.0090952031,
-0.0349700488,
-0.0164584741,
0.0622794256,
0.0252115596,
-0.0390797108,
0.0064733499,
-0.008542046,
0.0106517747,
0.0453711711,
-0.0304938313,
0.0266204458,
0.0315216221,
0.0323586911,
0.0525354296,
0.022931274,
-0.0230373759,
0.0673248917,
0.010288951,
0.0152477548,
-0.0416224487,
0.0336047411,
0.0149551611,
0.0373884626,
-0.0362288356,
0.0483975299,
-0.074104622,
-0.0898062289,
0.005034857,
0.0297417548,
0.0037328575,
-0.0151905101,
0.0157832019,
-0.0011909213,
-0.0057048947,
-0.0441456288,
-0.011979742,
0.0142926527,
-0.0475408509,
0.0503908992,
0.0232058819,
-0.0067759408,
-0.0147700608,
0.0728661865,
0.0091488669,
0.0600858442,
-0.0015514434,
-0.0313694105,
-0.0433470272,
-0.022245083,
0.0810360983,
0.0285103209,
-0.0573715307,
-0.0201410204,
-0.091931425,
-0.0824601725,
-0.0399674848,
0.0168198198,
-0.0153049156,
-0.0131703569,
0.0011484491,
0.0344460756,
0.0234991834,
-0.017776303,
-0.0363202319,
-0.0089056091,
-0.0009764413,
-0.0213539284,
-0.0152606741,
-5.861449399e-33,
-0.0078244824,
-0.0020314495,
-0.0181634743,
-0.0626889542,
-0.0062897978,
-0.0300612245,
-0.0110794362,
0.0152169485,
-0.0174368471,
-0.0019797939,
-0.0466714539,
0.020368332,
0.0008469328,
0.0010540074,
0.0206588507,
-0.047497835,
0.0142731313,
-0.0143554425,
-0.0408871993,
0.0366309248,
0.028010061,
0.0213097204,
-0.021553589,
-0.0517839156,
0.0498807132,
-0.0059244512,
-0.0039690062,
0.0283908378,
-0.0389206521,
0.0769145861,
0.0000471056,
0.0257728864,
-0.0092269387,
-0.0387847349,
-0.0145862186,
0.0511063524,
-0.0416638255,
-0.0342854448,
0.0044151964,
-0.0102634784,
-0.0225278717,
-0.0645926148,
0.042574808,
-0.0020900704,
-0.0127308359,
-0.0216568783,
-0.0150837637,
0.0017053679,
-0.0503995158,
-0.0065044193,
-0.0465131737,
0.0042714914,
-0.0029595366,
-0.0371149853,
0.0402901247,
0.0207125973,
0.033376161,
0.0096704373,
0.0138194673,
-0.0063762683,
0.002893941,
0.0226193909,
0.0530666672,
0.0274348352,
-0.0360986814,
0.0565409884,
-0.0387667753,
-0.0203571655,
0.0287380796,
-0.0267218594,
0.0174552221,
0.0486571826,
0.0116136679,
0.0505207554,
0.0332527757,
-0.0509788468,
-0.0603990741,
0.0273194872,
-0.0113177914,
0.0428832248,
0.0131041044,
0.006114969,
-0.0327355377,
-0.0384715647,
-0.0534984022,
0.0079526026,
-0.0312806591,
-0.0181639828,
0.0507763326,
-0.0036271021,
-0.034612,
-0.0475387871,
0.0225368552,
-0.0559285916,
-0.0163678657,
0.0413437039,
0.011355754,
-0.046872057,
0.0079964539,
0.0636634678,
-0.0037471903,
-0.0158012696,
0.0041875588,
-0.0619020537,
0.0262568295,
0.0015554306,
0.0477216206,
0.0506876484,
-0.0697726235,
-0.0035359657,
-0.0329686031,
0.0351203419,
-0.005415922,
0.0493379831,
0.0488489904,
-0.0163213126,
0.0281840488,
0.0369222537,
0.0210740231,
-0.0115645202,
-0.0490789562,
0.0254410375,
-0.0079639759,
0.0112565635,
-0.0081244875,
-0.0231962968,
-0.0048876121,
0.0464496501,
0.0653079301,
-0.0716987625,
-0.0174634662,
-0.0027717005,
2.766e-7,
0.0188866109,
0.0207395647,
0.027029302,
0.0392300338,
-0.0099107493,
0.0940977037,
-0.0216266643,
0.0676557869,
0.0056427568,
-0.0121184532,
0.0153359985,
-0.009144471,
0.0280548763,
0.0434323773,
-0.0780231878,
0.0109977014,
-0.0644591302,
0.0254997201,
-0.0373613946,
-0.0170133281,
0.0544558503,
0.1108591333,
-0.0197746791,
-0.0194253121,
0.0047135903,
-0.0588807501,
0.02495878,
-0.0412019715,
0.0107423179,
-0.0115989577,
0.0277578346,
0.0330645815,
0.0293113217,
-0.0050772987,
-0.0124414898,
0.025840126,
-0.0200164411,
0.081615895,
0.0015872292,
-0.0102479653,
-0.0194036737,
-0.038164977,
-0.0043823379,
-0.0662064031,
0.0702585876,
0.0071308156,
0.0029738026,
-0.0272474736,
0.0310654603,
-0.0534321554,
-0.0042278091,
-0.0226109531,
-0.0226348992,
0.0121231992,
0.0214251354,
0.0124673266,
0.0220054071,
-0.075992614,
-0.0330536775,
-0.0188560616,
0.0065943012,
-0.0605476312,
-0.0240763426,
0.0603992492,
0.0165717173,
-0.0603883043,
0.0031671638,
2.914284217e-34,
0.0382835753,
-0.0472059026,
0.0441671871,
0.0175845399,
0.0588723943,
0.0163481012,
0.0297009256,
0.0051676091,
0.047312934,
-0.043424502,
-0.0372121297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18001v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18001v1 | Desiderata for the Context Use of Question Answering Systems | 2024-01-31T17:02:31 | 2024-01-31T17:02:31 | Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior work has uncovered a set of common problems in state-of-the-art
context-based question answering (QA) systems: a lack of attention to the
context when the latter conflicts with a model's parametric knowledge, little
robustness to noise, and a lack of consistency with their answers. However,
most prior work focus on one or two of those problems in isolation, which makes
it difficult to see trends across them. We aim to close this gap, by first
outlining a set of -- previously discussed as well as novel -- desiderata for
QA models. We then survey relevant analysis and methods papers to provide an
overview of the state of the field. The second part of our work presents
experiments where we evaluate 15 QA systems on 5 datasets according to all
desiderata at once. We find many novel trends, including (1) systems that are
less susceptible to noise are not necessarily more consistent with their
answers when given irrelevant context; (2) most systems that are more
susceptible to noise are more likely to correctly answer according to a context
that conflicts with their parametric knowledge; and (3) the combination of
conflicting knowledge and noise can reduce system performance by up to 96%. As
such, our desiderata help increase our understanding of how these models work
and reveal potential avenues for improvements. | Desiderata for the Context Use of Question Answering Systems: Prior work has uncovered a set of common problems in state-of-the-art
context-based question answering (QA) systems: a lack of attention to the
context when the latter conflicts with a model's parametric knowledge, little
robustness to noise, and a lack of consistency with their answers. However,
most prior work focus on one or two of those problems in isolation, which makes
it difficult to see trends across them. We aim to close this gap, by first
outlining a set of -- previously discussed as well as novel -- desiderata for
QA models. We then survey relevant analysis and methods papers to provide an
overview of the state of the field. The second part of our work presents
experiments where we evaluate 15 QA systems on 5 datasets according to all
desiderata at once. We find many novel trends, including (1) systems that are
less susceptible to noise are not necessarily more consistent with their
answers when given irrelevant context; (2) most systems that are more
susceptible to noise are more likely to correctly answer according to a context
that conflicts with their parametric knowledge; and (3) the combination of
conflicting knowledge and noise can reduce system performance by up to 96%. As
such, our desiderata help increase our understanding of how these models work
and reveal potential avenues for improvements. | [
0.0573473871,
0.0145543274,
-0.0203736927,
0.051170256,
-0.0199260525,
0.0094456198,
0.0292264856,
-0.0167303737,
-0.0158270951,
-0.0411172993,
-0.0301481821,
-0.0013685862,
-0.0188288633,
-0.0024771229,
-0.0109867183,
-0.0305874478,
0.0474289358,
-0.0196287725,
-0.0214576852,
-0.0267000683,
0.0094339885,
-0.0052404366,
0.0135464016,
0.026866911,
0.0100323968,
-0.0106891962,
-0.0111329854,
0.0067732539,
0.0252561513,
-0.0341824591,
0.0253208298,
0.0196707305,
0.0191248804,
0.0366668366,
0.0000020665,
-0.0527841598,
-0.0117007494,
-0.0083383061,
-0.0586663447,
-0.0136141628,
-0.0192701984,
0.0137415864,
0.0336060897,
0.0188394841,
-0.0646043792,
0.023620557,
0.0326324329,
-0.0124245184,
0.0302263163,
0.0015130843,
0.0004438267,
-0.0239317324,
-0.0166129638,
-0.0029379202,
0.0509900488,
-0.0952355564,
0.0508365594,
-0.0110100796,
0.0006060126,
0.0134376828,
-0.0230442286,
0.0243370868,
0.0322097838,
0.055117324,
-0.0227996204,
0.005585073,
-0.0026130266,
0.0256991256,
-0.0097878734,
0.1008898243,
0.0444177054,
-0.0242250077,
-0.0130391465,
-0.0019799236,
0.0216041673,
0.0031081464,
-0.0435421541,
-0.0278735701,
-0.0174179059,
-0.041399695,
-0.0150748733,
0.0541419126,
0.0003402701,
0.0361606963,
0.0019519059,
0.0445045717,
-0.0069599166,
-0.0649963096,
-0.0129674757,
0.0047080144,
-0.0296904072,
-0.0736471936,
0.0221577231,
0.0767497197,
-0.0315087698,
0.0414850712,
-0.0057248115,
-0.0272392482,
0.0532699786,
-0.023051085,
-0.0443564691,
0.0299139563,
0.0042466656,
0.0700767785,
0.0135453856,
0.0274851695,
-0.0009301441,
-0.0109533109,
-0.0486941971,
-0.043300923,
-0.0444996171,
-0.0073648226,
-0.0532156564,
0.0538152158,
-0.0508622564,
-0.0012048517,
-0.0433035791,
0.0565639958,
0.003678133,
-0.0118733821,
-0.0254800264,
0.0444848649,
-0.0003985481,
0.0162581299,
-0.046333205,
0.0097074201,
-0.0797831938,
0.050871335,
-0.0088996161,
-0.0583315417,
0.0054473761,
-0.008999696,
0.0182692483,
-0.0348108634,
0.0076114386,
0.0435748883,
0.0354569666,
-0.0486800969,
-0.0109160347,
-0.0312816128,
-0.0243872758,
-0.0390254781,
-0.0782813132,
-0.0546136647,
0.0244976934,
0.0578157827,
-0.0160657167,
-0.0081322463,
-0.0042104088,
0.0534373634,
-0.01118189,
0.1083598211,
0.0003231969,
-0.0018614938,
0.0536516421,
0.0380047709,
-0.0112409014,
0.0584657006,
0.0143730622,
0.0046024411,
0.0674309731,
0.0181316659,
0.0324958004,
-0.0043016155,
0.0145625006,
0.0125380894,
0.0097909486,
0.0954636484,
-0.0169593934,
-0.0231876839,
-0.0193500891,
0.0391358919,
-0.0246409681,
-0.0544284657,
0.0351723656,
0.0517839938,
-0.0088808266,
0.0148422681,
0.0178776477,
-0.0073158303,
0.0108690541,
-0.004324086,
-0.0214088913,
-0.0033751193,
-0.0641637295,
0.0130136423,
0.0015040638,
0.0093104718,
-0.0449346341,
-0.0616228096,
-0.0171289276,
-0.00695351,
0.0147250565,
0.0692718625,
0.035805162,
-0.0149678644,
-0.0125775356,
-0.0049437778,
-0.0068152808,
-0.0075382632,
-0.0288428105,
-0.0329836272,
0.0601292364,
0.0524647832,
0.0689491257,
-0.0737311468,
-0.0116306301,
0.0106065758,
0.0247629583,
-0.0107956333,
0.0237038042,
-0.021745488,
0.0228376389,
-0.0215451308,
-0.0462862179,
0.0011837033,
-0.0172843095,
-0.0002478141,
0.0372050218,
0.0410600565,
-0.0020256382,
-0.0418487601,
0.0186120812,
0.0061720326,
0.0102539426,
-0.033142399,
-0.0211095419,
-0.0007096324,
0.0353688709,
0.0122711454,
0.0265954752,
0.0156264398,
0.0459789224,
0.0030271513,
-0.0063048829,
0.0098640416,
-0.0633550733,
-0.0361123048,
0.013352152,
0.0234405361,
-0.0192321874,
0.0327024944,
-0.0186326653,
-0.0371752493,
0.0016333784,
-0.0534842685,
0.0080194231,
-0.0519934855,
-0.026028743,
0.0004217883,
0.0155222407,
-0.0802246332,
0.0793328807,
-0.0148728201,
0.0191600975,
0.0282374173,
0.0291831847,
0.0145578608,
-0.0486540236,
-0.0177541133,
-0.0303569864,
0.0025334812,
0.0109124891,
0.0176040921,
-0.01432034,
-0.0592728145,
0.0128605263,
-0.1044322178,
0.0018168823,
-0.0282779988,
0.012369087,
0.0460570753,
0.0418211482,
-0.0144541059,
-0.0471211635,
-0.0492964201,
0.0366918743,
0.0225823615,
0.0450916365,
0.0454795137,
0.0340576582,
-0.0070018684,
-0.0661709085,
-0.0098351762,
-0.0020663533,
0.0300303847,
0.0035444621,
0.0065879556,
-0.0613144264,
0.0111476015,
-0.0588121153,
0.0436810814,
0.002532783,
0.0100786854,
0.0192234498,
-0.0018255733,
0.0067973398,
0.0349538848,
-0.0104295015,
0.0225321054,
0.0250461735,
0.0185080506,
-0.0578717552,
0.0248485915,
-0.0374442935,
-0.0119572673,
-0.0147484764,
-0.0393928215,
0.0010709191,
0.0247535445,
0.0075517511,
-0.0180031806,
-0.0165834613,
0.0700989291,
0.0010734596,
-0.039234627,
-0.1047047526,
0.0014475496,
-0.0001469909,
0.0859341398,
-0.0046419683,
-0.0073842579,
0.0844771117,
0.0296699386,
0.0024610728,
-0.0534659885,
-0.0149378832,
-0.048395317,
0.0345316604,
-0.0206312388,
0.0189947281,
0.0151123535,
0.0029873408,
-0.0480308086,
-0.0459382832,
-0.0059242626,
-0.0622354224,
0.0251733232,
-0.0500175357,
0.0329226106,
-0.0069551659,
-0.0622838251,
-0.0782321617,
-0.0463986285,
-0.0354873799,
0.0146723129,
-0.0218967032,
-0.0060459389,
0.0172767304,
0.0351584628,
0.0232585147,
0.0342805795,
-0.0048217825,
-0.055700928,
-0.0175572746,
0.0750358924,
0.0713349953,
0.0575732701,
0.0471505299,
0.0172380675,
0.0236891229,
0.0698989704,
0.0582512096,
-0.0362090282,
-0.0079148933,
-0.0367336273,
0.0319753997,
-0.0314162299,
0.0042055952,
0.0304832365,
0.0533985794,
-0.0474724658,
-0.0352421924,
0.0969897136,
0.0506339893,
-0.0225360412,
-0.0096439747,
-0.0463446043,
0.0067022126,
0.0215698257,
0.0279634036,
-0.0752027258,
-0.0633971468,
-0.0249850713,
0.0639085248,
-0.0054718414,
-0.0356784612,
-0.0046709888,
-0.0727160275,
0.0031240294,
-0.0504796766,
-0.0763580278,
-0.031157624,
-0.0392077006,
0.0224759206,
-0.0135396784,
0.0272405688,
0.0164522845,
-0.0151579883,
0.0073671369,
-0.0175045673,
0.0144096389,
-0.0211183149,
0.0427041017,
-0.0156064108,
0.0128549142,
0.0505939648,
-0.0157315582,
0.0313612372,
-0.0387097262,
-0.0048870607,
-0.0842504129,
0.0131736621,
-0.0227892082,
0.0095276637,
-0.0040729186,
0.0023350967,
-0.0461972281,
0.0113334861,
-0.0479323752,
-0.0033107013,
0.053308785,
0.0424855314,
-0.0054272828,
0.019263031,
-0.0342662111,
0.0138968667,
0.0402733348,
0.0880079716,
0.0254191887,
-0.0369431973,
-0.0704689175,
-0.0207084939,
-0.0076364377,
-0.010837744,
0.004912734,
-0.025607368,
0.0227657873,
0.0198134985,
-0.0757861435,
-0.0733691454,
0.0378474109,
0.024595689,
-0.028854847,
0.045237001,
-0.0101715382,
0.0285420641,
-0.0361395888,
-0.0082502132,
-0.0353770293,
-0.0021267827,
-0.0092747174,
0.0166892204,
0.022717746,
-0.0373806693,
-0.0272219796,
0.0261342153,
-0.0746410713,
-0.0264352299,
0.0039355494,
0.0225804355,
0.0296234414,
0.0206525773,
-0.0314376913,
-0.0392114855,
0.0182067305,
0.0246921219,
0.002283544,
0.0172608718,
0.0225875955,
0.036065951,
-0.0152355283,
0.0316444002,
-0.0697738677,
0.0171089042,
0.0176440999,
0.043816153,
-0.1069371626,
-0.0294809435,
0.0247837435,
-0.0324071124,
-0.0004873668,
0.0197325815,
-0.0511340462,
0.0324736983,
0.0433871001,
-0.0125137419,
-0.0035085904,
0.0029885212,
-0.0098538464,
-0.0029623567,
-0.0170169119,
0.0091405576,
0.0117638241,
-0.0387839861,
0.0323580466,
-0.049762655,
-0.0023261423,
0.0503568389,
0.0299586318,
-0.0042979605,
-0.0181434676,
-0.0198518801,
-0.0003165917,
0.0262123793,
0.0657859072,
0.0143393418,
0.0738833994,
-0.0109935887,
-0.0517390221,
-0.0082316576,
0.0499354228,
-0.1098642051,
-0.0127260359,
-0.0002223888,
0.0339393839,
0.0286328774,
0.0305047892,
-0.019608479,
0.0110942554,
-0.0200429838,
-0.005044986,
-0.0344853736,
0.0497013181,
0.0107495869,
0.0689841732,
0.0568429008,
-0.0091333864,
0.0567208603,
0.0551070273,
0.0100628771,
0.0308512207,
-0.016717406,
-0.0312945023,
-0.0391940549,
-0.004977718,
-0.0252783336,
0.0551190153,
-0.0235289708,
0.0221761409,
-0.0577624366,
-0.0663171113,
0.0104704471,
0.0019183721,
-0.0055568479,
-0.0059115365,
0.0520200431,
0.0518884957,
0.0320235677,
-0.044116959,
-0.0116681829,
0.0400694087,
-0.0636517331,
-0.0216099098,
-0.0503753759,
-6.410791337e-33,
-0.0015795063,
-0.0425197333,
0.0113747427,
-0.0263367686,
0.0200812295,
0.0090304734,
-0.0025717942,
-0.0209227819,
-0.0545533523,
-0.0249184966,
-0.0324603245,
0.0177346058,
0.0064407275,
0.003777578,
-0.0245597716,
-0.0855517015,
-0.0036653734,
0.0004501718,
-0.0147368805,
0.0168718006,
0.0563870184,
0.0044046035,
0.0207098201,
-0.0562690906,
0.0229427554,
-0.0314048342,
0.0071782316,
0.0404397994,
-0.022470057,
0.0718122497,
-0.0233449582,
0.0688149184,
0.0431637317,
-0.0098023023,
0.0177574474,
0.0605633929,
-0.0838168785,
-0.0268262997,
0.0237449296,
-0.0042586336,
-0.0521675386,
-0.0248349663,
0.034249641,
0.0007877217,
-0.002499559,
0.0376153998,
0.0124343783,
-0.027032068,
-0.0137511287,
-0.0271410793,
-0.0203360524,
-0.0000203674,
0.0051153717,
-0.01634809,
-0.0425767861,
0.0803641826,
0.014254096,
0.0494747199,
-0.0568668097,
-0.0184239559,
0.0115577169,
-0.0080287643,
0.0502024591,
0.0075938753,
-0.0183160789,
0.0046179476,
0.0046072351,
-0.0206832327,
-0.0222009234,
-0.0658015087,
-0.056995295,
0.0099577438,
0.0722168088,
0.0613901615,
0.0136834001,
0.024564961,
-0.0777628645,
0.0363289863,
0.0000301438,
0.0086520184,
0.0399811268,
0.0046502035,
-0.0784263462,
-0.002641215,
-0.0460047089,
0.0416745916,
-0.0664329007,
0.0116652409,
0.0653223991,
0.025213154,
-0.0311620217,
0.0030442213,
0.003261853,
-0.0555118583,
0.0003703801,
0.0367186256,
0.0149491569,
0.0061598774,
0.0404525809,
0.0235344805,
-0.0412139818,
0.046772901,
0.0244610123,
0.0195410177,
-0.019955026,
-0.0026766902,
0.0102483891,
-0.0324800611,
-0.0298450962,
-0.005146543,
-0.0103547741,
0.0637857243,
-0.0279201586,
-0.0542329848,
0.0356892534,
0.0384881124,
-0.0098235644,
0.0275752265,
0.0384694338,
0.0012566508,
-0.0332738161,
-0.0369282886,
-0.0239736997,
0.015898129,
-0.0239471775,
-0.0017777365,
0.0094069652,
0.0307421181,
0.0075641153,
-0.0127607854,
-0.0017592611,
0.0425387584,
2.595e-7,
0.06602671,
-0.0043552737,
0.0209648535,
0.0298595726,
0.0416226164,
0.037164405,
0.0284331422,
0.0232859552,
0.0169275347,
-0.0000603887,
0.0234738365,
0.0229060426,
0.0183190126,
0.0215876121,
-0.0302595869,
-0.0392359383,
-0.0323706269,
0.0037271963,
-0.0333583206,
0.0240057185,
0.0660206005,
0.0672320202,
-0.0176698286,
-0.0006409863,
-0.0417152196,
-0.0438693054,
0.0312080421,
-0.0253666285,
0.0426594689,
-0.0047746901,
0.0255128536,
0.0038220636,
0.027424071,
0.0245419107,
0.0178266671,
0.0016366214,
0.0025055348,
0.0359644592,
0.0053771273,
-0.0753752589,
-0.0276971683,
-0.0141329793,
0.0454874188,
-0.0893165097,
0.1126362905,
-0.0467166118,
0.0078075775,
-0.0170060825,
0.0145408073,
-0.0018503786,
0.0358108394,
0.0132895252,
-0.0323397182,
-0.025950823,
0.0005559528,
-0.0032507721,
0.0116500398,
-0.0694486499,
0.0027243192,
0.0105041293,
-0.0041265879,
-0.0362052731,
-0.0422636904,
-0.0293604229,
0.0246481728,
-0.0459521487,
-0.0101944488,
1.959010238e-34,
0.0299889129,
0.0076016756,
0.0077692722,
0.0420425758,
-0.0058603743,
-0.0012805741,
-0.0271602441,
-0.0140290204,
0.0663225725,
-0.0772724524,
-0.0105314795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17979v1 | Entity Linking in the Job Market Domain | 2024-01-31T16:34:10 | 2024-01-31T16:34:10 | Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Natural Language Processing, entity linking (EL) has centered around
Wikipedia, but yet remains underexplored for the job market domain.
Disambiguating skill mentions can help us get insight into the current labor
market demands. In this work, we are the first to explore EL in this domain,
specifically targeting the linkage of occupational skills to the ESCO taxonomy
(le Vrang et al., 2014). Previous efforts linked coarse-grained (full)
sentences to a corresponding ESCO skill. In this work, we link more
fine-grained span-level mentions of skills. We tune two high-performing neural
EL models, a bi-encoder (Wu et al., 2020) and an autoregressive model (Cao et
al., 2021), on a synthetically generated mention--skill pair dataset and
evaluate them on a human-annotated skill-linking benchmark. Our findings reveal
that both models are capable of linking implicit mentions of skills to their
correct taxonomy counterparts. Empirically, BLINK outperforms GENRE in strict
evaluation, but GENRE performs better in loose evaluation (accuracy@$k$). | Entity Linking in the Job Market Domain: In Natural Language Processing, entity linking (EL) has centered around
Wikipedia, but yet remains underexplored for the job market domain.
Disambiguating skill mentions can help us get insight into the current labor
market demands. In this work, we are the first to explore EL in this domain,
specifically targeting the linkage of occupational skills to the ESCO taxonomy
(le Vrang et al., 2014). Previous efforts linked coarse-grained (full)
sentences to a corresponding ESCO skill. In this work, we link more
fine-grained span-level mentions of skills. We tune two high-performing neural
EL models, a bi-encoder (Wu et al., 2020) and an autoregressive model (Cao et
al., 2021), on a synthetically generated mention--skill pair dataset and
evaluate them on a human-annotated skill-linking benchmark. Our findings reveal
that both models are capable of linking implicit mentions of skills to their
correct taxonomy counterparts. Empirically, BLINK outperforms GENRE in strict
evaluation, but GENRE performs better in loose evaluation (accuracy@$k$). | [
0.0131015051,
0.0400137976,
-0.0239464771,
-0.033567179,
0.0260468442,
0.0136495419,
-0.0020467588,
-0.0113379238,
0.0232939739,
-0.0419583954,
0.0007394524,
0.0391717516,
0.0102675557,
0.0269765779,
0.076471597,
-0.0236362275,
0.0238566995,
0.0096371677,
-0.0173925664,
-0.002329516,
-0.0193331894,
0.05435073,
-0.011414228,
0.0680712536,
-0.0312397368,
-0.0045030536,
0.0586615354,
0.0002063101,
0.0577386655,
0.0047547077,
0.0115459487,
0.0413479619,
-0.002194732,
0.0192573406,
0.0000019049,
-0.0188738145,
0.0156889372,
0.0140668275,
-0.0435750596,
-0.0331702307,
-0.0140116774,
-0.0466316044,
0.0215367153,
-0.0042114127,
-0.0021072829,
-0.0370413065,
0.0164419673,
0.005010013,
0.0391309448,
0.0320946835,
0.0014641688,
-0.0398497544,
0.0196589306,
-0.0610741973,
0.0010333926,
-0.0177116748,
0.0211753622,
-0.0649293438,
-0.0109366998,
0.0420128219,
-0.013101561,
0.0594226271,
0.0377830863,
-0.0112697445,
0.052670151,
0.0369784907,
-0.0374628343,
0.0014528966,
0.0477611609,
0.0679475516,
0.0088940719,
-0.0256696567,
0.0056930394,
0.0092316614,
0.0387226604,
0.0605883598,
-0.0221045818,
-0.0033901117,
0.0115553504,
-0.0191433337,
-0.0084345844,
-0.0042425543,
0.0306541137,
0.0075615169,
0.0638319701,
0.043209739,
-0.0017998205,
-0.0378216058,
0.0551955625,
0.0221774951,
0.0280466527,
-0.0545590408,
0.0506108142,
-0.0075314087,
-0.0388437919,
0.008927186,
-0.0424807668,
0.0176183414,
-0.0078265453,
-0.0411781929,
-0.0726455674,
-0.0135542983,
-0.0020758563,
0.0330973007,
-0.0396594889,
-0.0339781195,
-0.0070900852,
-0.0096590286,
-0.0117913568,
-0.0670827031,
-0.080913417,
-0.0325170048,
-0.0651757792,
-0.0091970945,
0.0004652543,
-0.0130935824,
-0.0401539728,
-0.0597739965,
-0.0592230745,
0.0569386184,
-0.0042789266,
0.0146067692,
-0.0376370177,
0.0104961526,
-0.0623516627,
0.0035525525,
-0.0343276411,
0.0254789032,
-0.0036687979,
0.004923454,
-0.0087820133,
0.0106796008,
0.0039320816,
-0.0558528192,
0.0189607907,
0.0243206397,
0.0504600145,
0.0289525017,
-0.0166595653,
-0.0669441968,
0.0211047288,
-0.0390687138,
-0.0299091134,
-0.0488213561,
0.046190735,
-0.0076910602,
-0.0024569398,
-0.0820236057,
0.0167426076,
0.0257136468,
-0.071273081,
0.0705622286,
-0.0201973263,
-0.0332093164,
0.026812382,
0.0006378766,
0.0338030718,
0.0318451226,
0.0649447516,
0.0275469217,
0.0236826837,
0.0003574199,
0.021797888,
0.0184627455,
0.0192596503,
-0.0629906878,
0.0268810708,
0.0088711288,
-0.0110338433,
0.0732539594,
0.079391785,
0.0045164032,
-0.0427524373,
-0.0262445826,
0.0372715406,
0.0548364893,
0.0326737389,
0.0261449739,
0.0958047956,
0.0198392924,
0.0084370067,
-0.0401414968,
-0.0349804275,
0.0450721644,
0.0114643704,
-0.0074848603,
0.014687092,
0.0118033513,
-0.0604173876,
0.0083212536,
0.0120570464,
0.0087639075,
-0.0031992467,
0.0426644199,
0.034519393,
0.0344904773,
-0.023200931,
0.0993386135,
0.015494165,
0.0000515797,
0.0116116283,
-0.0136665674,
-0.0662633702,
0.0813435391,
0.0270381868,
0.0364914052,
-0.0313777812,
-0.0601913296,
-0.0058527426,
0.0570980906,
0.0412007421,
-0.0644965172,
0.0049649887,
-0.0204888638,
-0.0058031906,
-0.000794704,
0.0004292188,
-0.0014579995,
0.0049570282,
0.0426991396,
0.0293777715,
-0.0586921088,
-0.0142222522,
0.0238563232,
-0.0093927188,
-0.0246015973,
-0.0094906464,
0.0363823511,
-0.0642023459,
0.0274733827,
0.0084054479,
-0.002898185,
0.0108968746,
-0.0198116153,
-0.0005154036,
0.0194083005,
-0.0023211872,
-0.018296821,
0.0024359077,
-0.0538722724,
-0.0594894551,
0.0122843329,
-0.0333192088,
-0.0180953722,
0.0204768907,
0.0065308837,
0.0061685583,
-0.0142634539,
-0.0136868609,
-0.0019389424,
0.0191391446,
-0.0083020637,
0.0540326573,
0.0185713451,
0.0228888281,
-0.0317240432,
0.0028808382,
-0.0049136006,
-0.0968243554,
-0.0193305723,
-0.0268282816,
0.0373301171,
0.0210341606,
0.0097284066,
-0.0079843765,
-0.055148948,
-0.0119345542,
-0.0201301239,
0.0309814624,
-0.0146139944,
0.0067713237,
-0.0053513502,
-0.0440425389,
-0.0009891832,
-0.0239600167,
-0.0209073555,
-0.0165820792,
-0.0313784629,
-0.0095645096,
0.0304980204,
-0.0035765814,
0.0056475243,
-0.0239929445,
-0.0229232647,
-0.0312134661,
0.0448773168,
0.0283405166,
-0.0100086173,
-0.0582134351,
0.0174165368,
-0.0233380254,
-0.0010860483,
0.0038398781,
0.0263827033,
-0.0296056662,
0.0588809326,
0.0111234691,
0.0265263151,
-0.053167332,
0.0188299287,
0.0244601741,
-0.0040860134,
-0.0334083661,
0.0251521356,
0.0109850243,
0.0425646715,
-0.0406981669,
-0.0177340303,
-0.0031505013,
0.032288257,
-0.0141490465,
-0.0208043046,
-0.0226626135,
0.0003486436,
0.015335842,
-0.0108838379,
-0.0212604813,
0.0119359223,
0.0067250533,
0.0018970064,
-0.0253890157,
-0.0094110174,
0.0135642532,
0.0158699714,
0.0085021313,
0.0060060271,
-0.0251098629,
-0.0219685882,
0.0160979405,
0.0073828343,
-0.0041280235,
0.0146383075,
-0.0524913296,
-0.035212975,
0.0804519355,
0.0099060703,
-0.0086003719,
0.0116209583,
-0.0151748629,
0.0327493437,
0.0417398736,
-0.0099321883,
-0.0209222194,
-0.00896414,
-0.0157676879,
0.052907113,
0.0008470144,
-0.0000448145,
-0.0484791137,
-0.0021347154,
0.0062441118,
0.0345166549,
0.0346999578,
-0.047815945,
-0.0009449244,
0.0494760536,
0.0770842731,
0.0343452767,
0.0085584847,
-0.0144293299,
-0.0194128212,
0.0144488327,
0.0133223478,
0.0234448425,
-0.0146701951,
-0.0213345774,
0.0203081351,
-0.1119211838,
-0.0287482124,
0.003630742,
0.0119846035,
-0.060752131,
-0.0170879234,
0.1058461145,
0.0284291394,
-0.0523206554,
0.0248236544,
0.049381841,
-0.0160512235,
0.0276008584,
0.0415221229,
-0.0561281517,
-0.009299065,
0.0003056337,
0.0119429417,
0.0413922556,
-0.0531958081,
-0.0128873596,
-0.1168633774,
0.0394770578,
-0.0532233156,
-0.0127618155,
-0.0638612434,
-0.0592622012,
0.0075696739,
-0.0376954898,
0.0171898548,
-0.0307158232,
-0.0132923666,
0.0341547467,
0.0352240428,
0.0026537885,
-0.0670147613,
0.057724081,
-0.0935285687,
0.0963737294,
0.0242468379,
0.0431514941,
-0.001074558,
-0.0054598353,
0.0089090597,
-0.0193420444,
-0.0311891288,
0.023127025,
0.0863190666,
-0.0602850616,
0.0010544555,
-0.0048939465,
0.0119580692,
-0.0289593432,
-0.014526438,
-0.0262779687,
0.0377348401,
0.0194655843,
-0.003153926,
0.00783394,
-0.0030512384,
-0.0125055248,
0.096248515,
0.0031696321,
-0.0433393978,
0.0074045956,
-0.0488207974,
0.0137496628,
-0.0210182518,
-0.0704751983,
0.0255834032,
-0.0231932588,
-0.0174691658,
-0.0423004851,
-0.0825847462,
0.062541984,
0.0161083303,
-0.0179020036,
0.0043561147,
0.0271163471,
-0.0285788607,
-0.0628370568,
0.0529966094,
-0.0314086713,
0.0468026623,
-0.0097622946,
-0.0511648096,
-0.0071634022,
-0.0201111306,
-0.0620215051,
0.0074651041,
-0.1116338819,
-0.0024064917,
-0.0328831784,
-0.0059882607,
0.0159037467,
0.0455641486,
-0.039609313,
-0.0734176487,
0.0110990647,
0.085631378,
-0.0753070116,
0.0230378974,
-0.0299628694,
0.0289819352,
-0.0092561254,
0.049594678,
-0.0618320517,
0.0051614246,
0.0024138824,
0.0413555801,
-0.0215350278,
-0.0203420427,
-0.0057593198,
-0.0225532353,
0.0082964972,
0.0012595914,
0.0314873978,
-0.0652203485,
-0.0264472272,
0.0265523866,
-0.0206787568,
-0.015920205,
-0.0139684156,
0.0616040044,
0.0185769722,
-0.0110548018,
0.0361054465,
0.0433428399,
0.0278668627,
-0.0943670869,
-0.0173087902,
-0.0162921771,
0.0129595455,
-0.0272327513,
0.0073591932,
0.0107924016,
-0.0247016624,
0.030317137,
0.0848340914,
-0.0170527827,
-0.0155695705,
0.0115027241,
0.0158742908,
0.0160840079,
0.0284317192,
-0.0259455964,
-0.0544040576,
0.0067324406,
0.0234643221,
0.0487826169,
-0.0389025174,
0.0656311214,
0.0071937549,
-0.0204111803,
0.0332264677,
0.0037648694,
0.0070591089,
0.0044085146,
0.0292220227,
-0.0052921027,
-0.013287005,
0.0206166357,
0.0569901764,
0.0120696286,
0.0607296862,
-0.0092672287,
-0.0314615369,
-0.0239136647,
0.0003214333,
-0.0128889028,
0.0059699169,
-0.0130237527,
0.0313368142,
-0.0573348328,
-0.0880552009,
0.002335212,
-0.0315890051,
-0.0057245395,
0.0117054246,
0.0569721907,
0.0197725445,
0.0084733414,
-0.0149556352,
-0.0066068103,
-0.0624863729,
0.0168362278,
-0.0201481003,
-0.0734746754,
-6.013145475e-33,
-0.0626185909,
-0.0309812687,
0.0173158925,
0.0047112801,
0.0082164481,
0.0279481784,
0.0185107961,
-0.0432684124,
-0.057033252,
-0.0055890563,
0.0132141141,
0.0440060198,
0.0009243436,
0.0093240719,
0.0417478085,
-0.0235420559,
0.0615070164,
0.0151118152,
-0.0072563021,
-0.0013002753,
0.0126197645,
0.0145830717,
0.1077403054,
-0.0677437633,
0.0441327803,
0.0283716694,
-0.0164501499,
0.0121536804,
0.0396863967,
0.0651251897,
-0.0012705512,
0.0419990942,
0.0141541921,
-0.0522063188,
0.0036565233,
-0.011383093,
-0.1358245164,
-0.0258848108,
0.0019788097,
0.0152151203,
-0.0005739261,
-0.0453644469,
0.0598460659,
0.0212476719,
0.0080076279,
-0.0373535231,
0.0800327733,
0.0045008752,
0.0107582891,
-0.0369805507,
-0.0269401427,
0.0283314269,
-0.0159436315,
-0.0051788935,
0.0182640832,
0.0129658179,
-0.0128583005,
0.0198023152,
-0.1284631938,
-0.0114542693,
-0.0332113095,
0.0427788347,
0.0348288417,
-0.0453667901,
-0.0007352833,
0.0445589013,
0.0423125587,
0.0030031882,
-0.0131891044,
0.0226513762,
0.0327918343,
0.0054474538,
-0.0227886401,
0.0090972176,
0.0617078133,
-0.0054933205,
-0.0569304451,
0.0293498635,
0.0218742192,
0.0356894135,
-0.0391599275,
-0.0024520736,
-0.0326486751,
-0.0370337144,
-0.0531714037,
-0.0292246733,
-0.0137843788,
-0.0053888555,
0.015954854,
0.0262346994,
0.0525111444,
0.0691141784,
-0.0311993957,
-0.0181207769,
-0.0083449883,
0.0130825415,
-0.034389697,
0.0098737832,
0.0515690222,
0.0010477995,
-0.0953659713,
0.0052545718,
0.0206121225,
0.0090779727,
0.0453727357,
0.0378899276,
0.0341319889,
0.0159985498,
-0.0803980008,
0.0121163605,
-0.001171966,
-0.0087952856,
-0.0272874348,
-0.026241092,
0.037187811,
0.0133256996,
0.0067656953,
0.0110439733,
0.0310452972,
0.0002733512,
0.0114305401,
0.0358673856,
0.0258938074,
0.0088649625,
0.0063407952,
0.0057178061,
-0.0132032996,
-0.0336374007,
0.011821758,
-0.0766474754,
-0.0203235522,
-0.0212976374,
2.563e-7,
0.0583763197,
0.0429459102,
-0.0276155341,
0.0715996101,
0.0019352406,
-0.0050098351,
0.0559844784,
0.0429784507,
0.0016057923,
0.0089146951,
-0.0275576506,
0.0293132775,
0.0274176076,
0.003677628,
-0.0559451506,
-0.0102293566,
-0.0265579503,
0.012123798,
-0.0322015584,
-0.0512030758,
0.0115783429,
0.0538459234,
0.0491927117,
0.0083597843,
-0.0112721603,
-0.0485455468,
0.0598171502,
-0.0092873126,
0.0024559286,
0.0295372829,
-0.0242996644,
0.0444214158,
-0.0419492088,
0.0786195621,
-0.0267621614,
0.0522052497,
0.064875707,
0.0331653729,
-0.0270529594,
0.0037517257,
-0.0194019433,
-0.0388691612,
-0.0212249011,
-0.0000893754,
0.0493872799,
-0.0388285592,
-0.0154982414,
0.0138679398,
-0.0525365621,
0.0520131737,
-0.0036855994,
0.0123946052,
-0.0443733633,
-0.0189845916,
0.0368811525,
-0.002077545,
-0.0226570945,
-0.0608205087,
-0.0048545026,
0.0531133078,
-0.0244138613,
-0.0489848144,
0.0201173779,
-0.0294242632,
0.0140063763,
-0.0394565165,
-0.0163403414,
2.255829908e-34,
0.0189195909,
0.0486375578,
-0.0171081107,
0.0209903568,
0.0200625043,
-0.0198562555,
-0.0425837077,
-0.0162134655,
-0.0012010746,
-0.0378903262,
-0.0235473998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17974v1 | GUMsley: Evaluating Entity Salience in Summarization for 12 English Genres | 2024-01-31T16:30:50 | 2024-01-31T16:30:50 | Jessica Lin, Amir Zeldes | cs.CL | cs.CL | As NLP models become increasingly capable of understanding documents in terms
of coherent entities rather than strings, obtaining the most salient entities
for each document is not only an important end task in itself but also vital
for Information Retrieval (IR) and other downstream applications such as
controllable summarization. In this paper, we present and evaluate GUMsley, the
first entity salience dataset covering all named and non-named salient entities
for 12 genres of English text, aligned with entity types, Wikification links
and full coreference resolution annotations. We promote a strict definition of
salience using human summaries and demonstrate high inter-annotator agreement
for salience based on whether a source entity is mentioned in the summary. Our
evaluation shows poor performance by pre-trained SOTA summarization models and
zero-shot LLM prompting in capturing salient entities in generated summaries.
We also show that predicting or providing salient entities to several model
architectures enhances performance and helps derive higher-quality summaries by
alleviating the entity hallucination problem in existing abstractive
summarization. | GUMsley: Evaluating Entity Salience in Summarization for 12 English Genres: As NLP models become increasingly capable of understanding documents in terms
of coherent entities rather than strings, obtaining the most salient entities
for each document is not only an important end task in itself but also vital
for Information Retrieval (IR) and other downstream applications such as
controllable summarization. In this paper, we present and evaluate GUMsley, the
first entity salience dataset covering all named and non-named salient entities
for 12 genres of English text, aligned with entity types, Wikification links
and full coreference resolution annotations. We promote a strict definition of
salience using human summaries and demonstrate high inter-annotator agreement
for salience based on whether a source entity is mentioned in the summary. Our
evaluation shows poor performance by pre-trained SOTA summarization models and
zero-shot LLM prompting in capturing salient entities in generated summaries.
We also show that predicting or providing salient entities to several model
architectures enhances performance and helps derive higher-quality summaries by
alleviating the entity hallucination problem in existing abstractive
summarization. | [
0.0409048945,
-0.014328816,
0.0507287346,
-0.0184219331,
0.0041662315,
0.0305333715,
-0.0501981154,
-0.0391102023,
-0.0120045431,
-0.0442565493,
-0.0312055573,
0.0125379208,
-0.0110375276,
-0.0387286395,
0.0201716367,
-0.0637709796,
0.0351305269,
0.0215913132,
0.0091071967,
0.0119345244,
0.0286058038,
0.0291429535,
-0.0027666674,
0.0173184797,
0.0039357794,
-0.0264150016,
-0.0023359838,
0.0202918947,
0.0786497444,
-0.0159141831,
0.0493963473,
0.0357959941,
0.0106088771,
0.0133357365,
0.000001786,
-0.066122219,
-0.0241253041,
0.0067544482,
-0.0099088633,
0.0262964983,
0.0301258061,
-0.0109117441,
0.0059210984,
-0.0236736964,
0.0034539369,
0.0272544045,
-0.0067519881,
0.0725726709,
0.0751452446,
0.0784727633,
-0.0058355704,
-0.0529398434,
0.038509462,
-0.024432512,
-0.0243607517,
-0.0250956304,
-0.0059857788,
-0.0397293009,
-0.020352019,
0.0098421248,
0.0210087933,
0.0264283121,
0.0036562213,
0.0012338787,
0.0680151656,
0.0232996717,
-0.0931364,
0.0009155971,
0.0323311165,
0.0859891698,
0.0410318226,
-0.0074682785,
0.0447459891,
0.0330615491,
0.0152496379,
-0.0421760306,
-0.0410047285,
0.0274835043,
-0.0231892094,
0.025073031,
0.0389015079,
0.0483530909,
-0.0226886664,
0.0398973487,
-0.0129386438,
0.0313899703,
0.0124424128,
-0.0039931606,
0.0406043343,
0.0394491181,
-0.0374715365,
-0.0693482757,
0.0168161076,
0.0302899126,
-0.032808952,
-0.0180713255,
-0.0301216543,
-0.0025278237,
0.025541801,
-0.0835601091,
-0.0437484793,
-0.0091233402,
-0.0110076992,
0.0481634289,
-0.0049722777,
-0.0212082528,
-0.0034769988,
0.0235346369,
-0.0202510711,
-0.0282081347,
-0.0300453603,
0.024107419,
-0.0353533998,
0.0997906923,
-0.0399086326,
-0.0226131566,
-0.0328285471,
-0.0045936508,
0.0008488264,
0.0137661044,
-0.0043621343,
0.0313041396,
-0.006177682,
0.0134368241,
-0.02071031,
0.0344865248,
-0.0714930817,
-0.0141399186,
0.0179246645,
0.0225929674,
0.0010478561,
-0.0017149379,
0.0141198458,
-0.0251206495,
0.0216343999,
0.0005271667,
0.0055113579,
-0.0779344961,
-0.0779421553,
-0.0225957036,
0.0077781603,
-0.053606078,
-0.0196307041,
-0.0529834814,
-0.0078741023,
-0.0089515187,
-0.0080977734,
-0.038352944,
0.0081831235,
0.0239471886,
-0.0505810045,
0.0206108894,
-0.0435759276,
-0.0236470085,
0.0285867825,
0.0006470858,
0.0209436417,
0.0541317761,
0.0281545948,
0.0493228361,
0.0699834079,
0.0373154059,
-0.0126940133,
-0.0143455993,
0.0006418981,
0.0254990235,
0.0469173007,
-0.0024988453,
-0.0841522068,
-0.0071257665,
0.0655249879,
0.0462188683,
-0.0137474285,
-0.0078181559,
0.0336972065,
0.0729134977,
-0.0082729217,
0.025195973,
0.0204360113,
0.0328033529,
0.0346421637,
0.0842800289,
-0.0304602087,
0.0593589619,
-0.0407697484,
0.0293892045,
0.1172594726,
0.0148626715,
-0.0416107923,
-0.0364130922,
0.0229283217,
0.020296691,
-0.0260258559,
0.0201992411,
0.0110676289,
0.0136366282,
-0.0309612118,
0.047173541,
0.0403464958,
-0.095034793,
0.019460978,
-0.001571437,
0.0282371342,
0.0655058995,
0.0391801856,
-0.046851594,
-0.0329524651,
-0.0158674214,
0.0178189464,
0.0339778848,
0.0332850367,
-0.0344745554,
0.031716641,
-0.0229480248,
-0.0005717145,
-0.0286422614,
0.0386894196,
0.0096538942,
0.0025079669,
-0.0169808716,
0.0378689021,
-0.0290026721,
-0.0584796928,
0.0131395739,
0.0090909218,
-0.0188812092,
-0.024160523,
0.0043690451,
-0.0122956475,
0.0685889348,
-0.0170747917,
0.0011910135,
0.0197049733,
-0.0145095978,
0.0069790343,
0.0181432273,
-0.0013131294,
-0.0097299367,
0.0459131822,
-0.0441593416,
0.0062704338,
-0.0111000659,
-0.0117358873,
-0.0465630814,
-0.0010051549,
-0.0373774096,
0.0198995769,
-0.0360204391,
0.0196840055,
0.0268367268,
0.0017854635,
-0.0386851393,
0.0737564489,
0.0068189735,
-0.0033614235,
0.0092895469,
-0.0416531786,
0.0009895468,
-0.0473299064,
-0.0449934267,
-0.0096651362,
0.0338870287,
0.0078102369,
0.0667521805,
-0.0213238224,
-0.0666493997,
-0.004090426,
-0.107212618,
0.0246373545,
-0.0304184183,
0.0243325811,
0.0259882659,
0.0102602914,
-0.0072463942,
0.0055185622,
-0.0286047217,
-0.0610132478,
-0.0151985073,
0.0158906635,
0.0210130084,
0.028006563,
0.0510514304,
-0.0810005367,
-0.0214664899,
-0.0093240077,
0.0360507779,
0.0050503085,
-0.0156549234,
-0.0149120437,
0.0264149699,
-0.0334232897,
-0.0176347811,
0.013220327,
0.0263325665,
-0.0096469773,
-0.0037045586,
0.0453509614,
0.0395890139,
0.0195307974,
0.0227100719,
-0.005422431,
-0.0259262361,
-0.0330800712,
0.01991353,
0.005039305,
0.0300246999,
0.0321119726,
-0.0182252638,
0.0534532703,
0.0398730934,
-0.0204911921,
-0.0334687792,
-0.0391663797,
0.0147392862,
0.0009091359,
0.0103167351,
-0.0252807438,
0.0064609661,
0.0000220962,
0.0192754846,
-0.040468201,
0.004386642,
0.0540676676,
-0.016171284,
0.0081038335,
-0.0580202416,
0.0171896163,
-0.0579420589,
0.0201837122,
-0.0232275855,
0.0014924287,
-0.0064739957,
-0.0417755172,
-0.0074942848,
0.0120183937,
0.013159045,
-0.0229625441,
0.0946887881,
-0.0283089597,
0.0169671644,
-0.0024991552,
0.0123958755,
-0.0203122124,
-0.0109490473,
-0.0373930931,
0.0095654186,
0.0269744135,
0.0127581218,
-0.0182063673,
-0.0317578055,
0.035390038,
0.0537701659,
-0.0147035746,
-0.0310325157,
-0.0029884439,
0.0291345902,
0.0768456236,
0.0330083333,
0.0376918055,
-0.0149796531,
0.0353299789,
0.0352772772,
0.0139261195,
-0.0424577408,
0.0089427,
0.0015811535,
0.0119968364,
-0.1381244659,
-0.0248091761,
-0.0305748433,
0.0699269623,
-0.0339305326,
-0.0058002798,
0.112498723,
0.0263484921,
-0.0589536428,
-0.0133002838,
0.0136098899,
0.0044725901,
0.0202957951,
0.0055096354,
-0.029128693,
-0.02471219,
-0.0140855387,
0.0204812717,
0.0260449927,
-0.0636229962,
-0.0100703277,
-0.07215482,
0.0125342049,
-0.0028515772,
-0.0698493719,
-0.0006464685,
-0.0445084125,
0.0239471588,
-0.0355616584,
-0.0060890741,
0.0165162776,
-0.0233851708,
0.0329481512,
0.0046162512,
-0.0260879304,
0.0253778677,
0.0074371421,
-0.0722537264,
0.0051537757,
0.0797381997,
0.0529411435,
0.0025551778,
-0.007625333,
-0.0081091514,
-0.0493382774,
-0.0157149695,
0.0186246037,
0.1074518338,
-0.0325777642,
0.0286056995,
-0.0492007025,
0.0444886163,
0.0232310407,
-0.0097242789,
0.0202275515,
0.0073201284,
0.0170264933,
0.004265551,
-0.0534774736,
0.0294229705,
-0.0388345905,
0.0732437447,
0.0313971452,
-0.0210667271,
-0.003578438,
-0.0328918509,
0.017090233,
-0.0677679405,
-0.0275033433,
-0.0177030582,
-0.0636346862,
-0.0132054631,
-0.0869023427,
-0.0830229297,
0.011177768,
-0.0165478811,
0.0114806527,
-0.0010759181,
-0.0116810519,
0.0124841118,
-0.0488552675,
0.0330009423,
-0.0227013715,
0.0001523431,
-0.0583532192,
-0.0274523161,
0.0853815824,
-0.0174960513,
-0.0141105903,
-0.0113323247,
-0.0255451873,
-0.0488764681,
-0.0436103456,
0.0367092155,
0.0148082869,
0.0411158577,
-0.012054177,
-0.0415058956,
0.0316026546,
0.0175338816,
-0.0365331061,
0.0314623825,
0.0256212447,
0.067410551,
-0.0304761995,
0.0409784913,
-0.0499869511,
0.0391621701,
-0.01995885,
0.055996675,
0.0126868039,
-0.0402881466,
-0.0024980349,
0.0433460996,
-0.0002331881,
-0.0178329442,
0.0119503886,
-0.0477446951,
-0.0161708687,
0.0193218663,
-0.017729396,
-0.0135426885,
0.024157377,
-0.0202270187,
0.0105585596,
-0.0373522453,
0.066703558,
-0.0169950891,
0.0367203429,
-0.0702717528,
-0.0210666116,
-0.0142578268,
-0.0292812064,
-0.066440247,
-0.0042238706,
-0.0327589065,
-0.0218070969,
0.0002005318,
0.0379674584,
-0.0169182122,
-0.0036886614,
0.019261064,
-0.001003871,
0.0010255758,
0.0361439362,
-0.0615922734,
0.0370355584,
-0.0498378947,
0.0493401214,
0.0574310198,
-0.0503229201,
0.088696979,
0.0211964455,
-0.0295523386,
-0.0090118535,
0.0146509903,
0.0192059986,
0.01324936,
-0.048368711,
0.0238104127,
0.0115963127,
-0.0014561992,
0.0562875345,
-0.0612359419,
0.0160048045,
0.0451282822,
-0.0114091309,
-0.0529937483,
-0.0412005149,
-0.0355000645,
0.0329215191,
0.0155364815,
0.0094395345,
-0.0700836331,
-0.0210833475,
0.0737776309,
-0.0141396057,
-0.0095465928,
-0.0120717529,
0.0364938341,
0.0089114103,
0.0071569104,
-0.0089962333,
-0.0399784334,
-0.044382453,
-0.0150614576,
-0.0036224385,
-0.0019865008,
-6.15979464e-33,
-0.0535458438,
0.0202886965,
-0.0183158368,
0.0369341597,
-0.0569371581,
0.0212206226,
-0.0410258509,
-0.0046124021,
-0.009793058,
0.0066241003,
-0.0463792533,
0.0279535167,
0.0094024576,
0.0274975877,
-0.0148229459,
-0.0028226809,
0.0351333469,
0.0345605761,
-0.0608834475,
0.0421947651,
0.0221494287,
0.0130845672,
0.0760881752,
-0.0580359586,
0.0652194768,
0.0100193927,
-0.0211216025,
-0.0206119921,
0.0390865728,
0.0146416994,
0.0065110703,
0.0325296596,
0.0143510811,
-0.0351114124,
-0.0092493119,
-0.0272427052,
-0.1135549471,
-0.0386531204,
0.0390222967,
-0.0225799177,
-0.0152386166,
-0.0821398944,
0.0394487381,
-0.006328532,
0.0253274664,
-0.0264478847,
0.0647988915,
-0.0332470722,
-0.0112955421,
-0.0932368934,
-0.0404413342,
0.0225422401,
-0.0196141582,
-0.0260169953,
0.0128945792,
0.007018527,
0.0034696262,
0.0115374289,
-0.0662021711,
0.0323935151,
0.042920664,
0.00322887,
-0.005535868,
-0.0331401713,
-0.0074435659,
0.0622497872,
-0.0077499258,
-0.0160335544,
-0.0384884253,
0.0237930603,
-0.0016374566,
0.0154404454,
0.002304524,
0.0455321223,
0.0400162898,
0.0463270023,
-0.037284296,
0.1098601148,
-0.0131840371,
0.0070588398,
0.0053537837,
-0.0120510524,
-0.0177570432,
-0.0218700413,
-0.0173935182,
-0.0059858616,
-0.0334029756,
-0.0053133471,
-0.0265256464,
0.0014901465,
-0.0328217819,
0.0112706339,
-0.0190313589,
-0.0317872427,
0.0014360182,
0.0478565246,
-0.0044971611,
0.017499987,
0.0191190168,
-0.0547456294,
-0.0284989346,
0.0383818932,
0.0259243529,
-0.0341244005,
0.0042395499,
-0.009692234,
0.0541819744,
-0.0050850473,
-0.0308696646,
0.0066641052,
0.0166621935,
0.0421312153,
-0.0337255932,
0.0084750978,
-0.0041341311,
0.0137714418,
0.0030433526,
0.0542932823,
0.0341575406,
0.0190683361,
-0.0387900136,
0.0072163763,
0.0388847664,
0.0369700715,
-0.001336591,
0.0427501388,
0.0332418196,
-0.0017194572,
-0.0217375569,
-0.0417034663,
-0.0264651757,
-0.0265801065,
2.489e-7,
0.0205454808,
0.0043496862,
0.0705369338,
-0.0270021856,
-0.0425399989,
0.0222156495,
0.0141882375,
0.0571443141,
0.0139308367,
-0.0348453,
0.0137741584,
0.0331520326,
0.0480512343,
0.0272627138,
-0.1115472168,
-0.0451967232,
-0.0157516114,
-0.0229551066,
-0.0429621302,
-0.0313624404,
0.0383737795,
0.048511494,
0.0327949412,
-0.007144968,
-0.0040704324,
0.0178632513,
0.0200190078,
-0.028533129,
0.002025452,
0.0319040678,
0.0381990038,
0.0308573004,
-0.0409499966,
-0.018034691,
-0.0137602156,
0.0095137293,
0.0727870092,
0.0254136883,
0.0342102982,
-0.0688757002,
0.0029538085,
-0.025933817,
0.0381445251,
0.017658731,
0.0643803179,
-0.0289504752,
-0.0003082649,
0.0192393493,
-0.0664758533,
0.0242126137,
-0.0250112098,
-0.0238844659,
-0.0336980708,
0.0224595405,
-0.0061884448,
-0.0035022434,
0.0035382719,
-0.0860205442,
-0.0374087803,
0.0397474431,
0.0226002093,
-0.0300097968,
0.0159065258,
-0.0093041165,
-0.035118252,
-0.0936743617,
0.0049797622,
2.145514126e-34,
0.064486444,
0.0063202633,
-0.0181758162,
0.0274231657,
0.0172671638,
-0.010509857,
-0.0331362933,
-0.0584969744,
0.0266458672,
-0.0425337143,
0.0050457069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08795v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08795v1 | Ontologia para monitorar a deficiência mental em seus déficts no processamento da informação por declínio cognitivo e evitar agressões psicológicas e físicas em ambientes educacionais com ajuda da I.A* | 2024-01-31T16:15:41 | 2024-01-31T16:15:41 | Bruna Araújo de Castro Oliveira | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The intention of this article is to propose the use of artificial
intelligence to detect through analysis by UFO ontology the emergence of verbal
and physical aggression related to psychosocial deficiencies and their
provoking agents, in an attempt to prevent catastrophic consequences within
school environments. | Ontologia para monitorar a deficiência mental em seus déficts no processamento da informação por declínio cognitivo e evitar agressões psicológicas e físicas em ambientes educacionais com ajuda da I.A*: The intention of this article is to propose the use of artificial
intelligence to detect through analysis by UFO ontology the emergence of verbal
and physical aggression related to psychosocial deficiencies and their
provoking agents, in an attempt to prevent catastrophic consequences within
school environments. | [
0.0224844366,
0.0231932905,
-0.0026340971,
0.0114905713,
0.0032095085,
-0.0013511932,
0.046652656,
0.0074765831,
0.0260505565,
-0.0432570092,
0.0507080629,
0.0342905037,
-0.0413728021,
0.0474295281,
-0.0051037883,
-0.0531399697,
-0.0187645648,
-0.0448747166,
-0.0248758122,
0.0245520975,
-0.0347774923,
0.0177384205,
-0.0250616781,
0.0062581245,
-0.03866468,
-0.0433731936,
0.0505415276,
-0.0417024232,
0.0384090208,
-0.0181068685,
0.0076441434,
0.0242727976,
0.0163030121,
0.021711342,
0.0000020647,
-0.0443084873,
0.0027204591,
-0.011647637,
-0.0025071439,
-0.0601135828,
0.0008450779,
-0.0170438532,
0.0169221833,
0.0066862493,
-0.06628149,
0.0051746652,
-0.0114946831,
0.0408533402,
0.0141283544,
0.0004871212,
0.0014496198,
-0.0467906334,
0.0602333918,
0.0190997403,
0.0060519967,
0.0939490274,
0.017738929,
0.0084466599,
-0.0139657147,
-0.0282708183,
0.0092834281,
0.0007850553,
-0.0124812219,
-0.0371819511,
-0.020132659,
-0.0417923331,
-0.0147124268,
-0.0045794342,
0.004777512,
-0.0025262565,
0.0211012363,
0.0025930959,
0.0300640855,
0.0479121134,
-0.007319666,
0.0258571301,
-0.0130533604,
-0.0023843923,
-0.0296489168,
-0.0348606817,
0.0709126294,
0.0394895747,
-0.0007674385,
0.0091170752,
0.0329797752,
0.0846615881,
-0.0441690087,
-0.0108750602,
0.0008055671,
0.0035006108,
0.0273875967,
-0.0269916523,
-0.0292943921,
0.0128490934,
-0.0370641798,
-0.0091442876,
-0.0367016606,
-0.05681118,
-0.0072607114,
-0.0543716885,
-0.0272076838,
0.0165595841,
-0.001051899,
0.0000618992,
0.0693362579,
0.0473328568,
0.0117611066,
0.0021850509,
-0.0297232196,
0.044637423,
-0.1194903478,
0.0052908389,
-0.0400158428,
0.0223413929,
0.0550059453,
0.0198541079,
-0.0202081632,
-0.0061291512,
-0.0731696039,
-0.0074566277,
-0.0463765152,
0.0101103233,
0.0406058021,
-0.0003625221,
0.0301329847,
-0.0497852117,
-0.0050171828,
-0.023409538,
-0.0547236651,
-0.0701347888,
0.0676528364,
0.0235471893,
-0.0303164534,
0.0040709535,
-0.0321047306,
0.097479485,
0.0501210466,
-0.039473936,
-0.0450508446,
-0.0580623746,
0.0168600008,
-0.0407555103,
0.0239963923,
0.01684702,
-0.0277215149,
-0.0331869237,
-0.016514834,
-0.0233124141,
0.0042801746,
-0.0103142839,
-0.0133927623,
0.033936698,
-0.0388263501,
-0.0354641899,
0.0575983562,
0.0387918167,
-0.0477776378,
0.0134945549,
-0.0048225597,
-0.0270413551,
0.0047800592,
-0.0041336939,
0.040981099,
-0.0258207284,
0.0359784178,
0.0147651099,
-0.0191185363,
0.0121456319,
-0.0613157116,
0.0327829383,
-0.0202685054,
-0.0381212421,
-0.0322683342,
0.0745882168,
-0.0195792839,
0.0077461838,
-0.0703266487,
0.0357742198,
0.0606952868,
-0.0111119226,
-0.0164955463,
-0.0186656471,
-0.0151977576,
0.018853683,
-0.0498033091,
-0.0470017232,
-0.0289272889,
0.0209594332,
0.0117676482,
-0.0480997339,
-0.0181009248,
0.0189577471,
-0.0616836995,
0.0251996871,
0.0208764169,
0.0057735639,
0.0423780829,
-0.0308933239,
0.0295653865,
0.0251548868,
-0.0311332699,
-0.0226848498,
0.0542494394,
0.0519837029,
0.0057463506,
-0.0369132608,
-0.035706684,
-0.0800967067,
-0.0489893332,
0.0100553716,
-0.0659482554,
-0.0337645113,
-0.0325727537,
0.0295544025,
0.0229919329,
-0.0069636465,
0.0258978326,
0.0151252486,
-0.037743628,
0.0561021268,
0.0185171906,
0.040009588,
-0.0754961446,
0.0227938872,
0.0133777549,
-0.0654812753,
-0.0260810796,
0.0273756012,
0.0742414221,
0.0179137345,
0.005823527,
-0.0283972993,
0.0128913037,
-0.016830178,
-0.0111166202,
-0.0248434749,
0.0257777926,
0.0698686168,
0.0155125931,
-0.0421470366,
0.0281537827,
0.0135918036,
0.0420181863,
0.0091998782,
0.0531991906,
-0.0026331607,
0.0557944626,
0.0095973024,
0.0339448042,
-0.0069444356,
0.0408790298,
0.0107121216,
0.0188896786,
0.0031797842,
-0.00631767,
-0.0212836433,
-0.0682588369,
0.0494059324,
-0.0077840709,
-0.0174947474,
-0.0068231849,
-0.0303615071,
0.0137671651,
-0.0016672992,
-0.0163758006,
0.0151958978,
0.049775172,
0.0087367352,
-0.0116047999,
0.0012506656,
-0.0201303568,
-0.0089928582,
-0.0713354424,
-0.0360640623,
0.0112343915,
0.0561519526,
-0.0065728175,
0.0284762848,
0.0046927626,
-0.0352652818,
0.0243459027,
-0.0236547831,
-0.0168519225,
0.0100740278,
-0.0538124144,
0.0353304818,
0.048625838,
-0.0332319699,
-0.0518928617,
0.0281353667,
-0.0760320351,
0.0204516519,
-0.0032057704,
-0.0627154857,
0.041827064,
0.040610671,
0.0164949242,
0.0658871159,
0.0157798789,
0.0874423087,
0.098242484,
0.0096526425,
0.0141006438,
-0.0263640825,
0.0626102686,
0.0304767117,
-0.0270902701,
-0.0351203419,
0.0024466445,
0.038506791,
0.012717695,
-0.027437998,
-0.0221774559,
0.0959046111,
-0.0727458596,
-0.0081280787,
-0.0258231591,
-0.111490339,
-0.0119555052,
0.0545480363,
0.028512273,
-0.0248274989,
0.00560947,
0.0114973467,
0.0172214471,
-0.0300407857,
0.0005535624,
0.058050815,
0.0184175894,
0.0255672466,
0.0185707696,
0.0148627469,
0.0111239199,
0.0512369536,
-0.0255303178,
0.0444012024,
0.0105204079,
-0.088398546,
-0.0747332647,
0.0149220666,
0.0266017467,
0.0248015504,
-0.0697589815,
0.0768042281,
0.0053214985,
0.0173151661,
-0.0768466741,
0.0245240442,
-0.0498975404,
-0.0212093219,
0.0206214171,
-0.0111685134,
-0.0025854814,
-0.0336922444,
0.0266968086,
-0.0728851259,
0.041020412,
-0.0800931901,
0.0273726787,
-0.0143045858,
-0.0538032576,
0.0175355226,
-0.0563075654,
-0.0489041544,
0.0007748401,
0.0126454262,
-0.0054759756,
0.0210674386,
-0.0156369694,
-0.020361308,
-0.0158478841,
-0.0086595174,
-0.0067813471,
0.0345806666,
0.025633812,
0.0355344601,
0.0265804995,
-0.0033456327,
-0.129669711,
-0.032080356,
-0.0180781651,
0.0007467523,
0.064060919,
-0.0458643734,
0.0381109528,
-0.0427183323,
-0.026773965,
0.0226460602,
0.0407967828,
0.0564607009,
-0.0079276031,
-0.0152263837,
-0.0293648485,
0.0825046748,
0.0143757137,
-0.0472811945,
-0.0214603189,
-0.02105687,
0.0379518606,
0.0152567234,
0.0210179277,
-0.002005676,
0.0388429351,
0.0091337841,
-0.0289438479,
-0.0117807323,
-0.0115353419,
0.0418168306,
-0.0172595773,
-0.0466833599,
-0.0441276915,
0.0165575296,
0.0138443345,
-0.0112978909,
0.0360953398,
-0.0119311949,
0.0078895558,
-0.0516617186,
0.0537474751,
-0.0099424906,
0.0295393188,
0.077953428,
0.0934502706,
-0.050282903,
-0.0073006912,
-0.0353534669,
-0.0246518385,
0.0041286573,
-0.0124240853,
-0.0450676829,
-0.0039789928,
0.0011962316,
0.0033859666,
-0.0325140543,
0.0448240191,
-0.0293096621,
-0.0008314171,
-0.0104551231,
-0.1506421864,
-0.0205492396,
-0.0020426712,
-0.0092620831,
0.0608449988,
0.0093619917,
-0.0518614911,
-0.0075142714,
0.0206327401,
-0.0032825039,
0.0207939427,
0.041480463,
-0.0055772555,
-0.023814613,
-0.0054139527,
-0.0182383899,
0.0194459967,
-0.0060659787,
-0.0416827761,
0.015411268,
-0.0194532648,
0.0742631406,
0.0244848672,
0.0249751192,
0.0118993334,
0.0078454232,
0.0051125311,
0.0410524607,
-0.0443024635,
-0.0176002756,
0.0102824122,
0.0003123104,
0.0136369541,
0.0137121817,
0.003206505,
0.0469772853,
0.0126764439,
0.0005292175,
-0.0325910859,
-0.1178315058,
-0.0461418405,
-0.0490770712,
0.0166625734,
0.0382323414,
-0.0314237177,
-0.0359800942,
-0.0216704048,
-0.0371179208,
-0.0052636988,
0.011236418,
0.0400228947,
0.0331448652,
-0.0084957322,
0.0201413687,
-0.0152233122,
-0.0616022386,
-0.0787862241,
-0.0334019624,
0.0081645614,
0.0667873025,
0.0180210322,
0.028833406,
0.0301677026,
0.040979553,
0.0060593025,
-0.0085401619,
-0.0024737783,
0.0171915367,
-0.0150588788,
0.034996476,
0.029467741,
0.0529221147,
0.0085288696,
0.0252445415,
0.0781571567,
-0.0339302383,
-0.0100127328,
-0.0187835656,
-0.0245974511,
-0.0009325771,
-0.0034387242,
-0.0269591287,
0.0025121376,
0.0195970144,
0.0027487113,
-0.0167585872,
-0.0234318245,
0.0338100307,
-0.0042985855,
0.0024531689,
0.016189497,
0.0080884797,
-0.0175776444,
0.0202100016,
0.0320654921,
-0.0105278557,
-0.010007076,
0.0494642332,
0.0445296988,
0.0019140056,
-0.0106330868,
0.0234408416,
-0.0149652362,
-0.0109752938,
0.0157931987,
-0.0008038176,
-0.0359430239,
0.0149262389,
0.0104854433,
0.0294590835,
-0.0017807843,
-0.0631259754,
-0.0195823759,
0.0241136104,
-0.0170571804,
0.0171542894,
0.0083035761,
-5.374173562e-33,
-0.0323239639,
-0.0712325051,
0.0217310525,
0.0551196188,
-0.0466896668,
-0.0403309464,
0.0381200723,
0.0189247001,
-0.0403776355,
0.0010517149,
0.0878319666,
0.0012694731,
-0.0185701754,
-0.0489381775,
0.0515176132,
0.0209090356,
-0.0219401885,
-0.0151926111,
0.001279523,
-0.0268813968,
0.0228163768,
-0.0163101237,
0.0401065499,
-0.0966187194,
0.0377717055,
-0.0061657466,
0.0187826846,
0.0332747474,
-0.0086099412,
0.0001160257,
-0.024968667,
0.0055993996,
0.0262438748,
0.0099691413,
0.0489375927,
-0.0184640586,
0.0372694284,
-0.0567700751,
0.0475778356,
-0.0042983862,
0.0232484099,
-0.0580007546,
-0.0493576378,
0.0357531123,
0.0152741326,
-0.0145369237,
0.0409826152,
-0.0341562964,
0.0051237531,
-0.0040070168,
-0.0583472885,
-0.0088559333,
-0.008980534,
-0.0180345289,
0.0103858421,
-0.0081828693,
-0.0158506595,
-0.0357407629,
-0.0279766321,
0.0416601896,
-0.0171820968,
-0.0243174434,
-0.0225290731,
-0.0317454301,
0.0495451316,
-0.0121150911,
0.0256115627,
-0.0212388225,
0.0275274497,
-0.0051002456,
0.0677915514,
0.0335048735,
0.0171655547,
-0.0141512258,
-0.0007456802,
-0.0193001535,
-0.0361801982,
-0.0407554358,
0.0190662965,
-0.0013818757,
-0.0012250602,
-0.0026838044,
-0.0217131991,
-0.0035276096,
0.0811812207,
-0.011091142,
0.0064649484,
0.0022839184,
-0.0189794656,
-0.0357807018,
-0.030972017,
0.0036928987,
-0.0236087069,
0.0145872347,
0.0766160116,
0.0032426021,
0.0160933044,
0.0091381026,
0.0072124917,
0.0069418019,
-0.032930214,
0.0289859455,
-0.0111398418,
-0.0071304245,
0.0421668477,
0.0084167505,
-0.0157536231,
-0.02475111,
0.011223468,
0.0158862993,
0.030891411,
0.0432178229,
0.0272311624,
-0.0022346729,
0.010846165,
0.0059177973,
0.0190392528,
-0.0021581559,
0.0239903498,
-0.014960221,
-0.0479846783,
0.0400949977,
-0.0004071872,
-0.0355559327,
-0.0388461575,
-0.0327324793,
-0.0178977791,
-0.0232065991,
-0.0201990027,
-0.0571979247,
0.0132173523,
-0.0529434085,
2.802e-7,
-0.0565405078,
0.0584183894,
0.0244124811,
-0.0181058496,
0.0185174253,
0.0028206513,
0.0467916094,
0.0231373906,
0.0362032838,
0.0108468449,
0.019443823,
-0.0452489629,
-0.0057247533,
0.0579176545,
-0.0148213003,
-0.0238544475,
0.0610973611,
-0.0981341973,
-0.0633918643,
0.0278754625,
0.0377340391,
-0.0431747958,
0.0551418252,
0.0081015714,
-0.0142060006,
0.0059098918,
-0.072372593,
0.0733626634,
0.0063343351,
-0.022129165,
0.046501562,
0.0676550418,
-0.029333258,
0.048346892,
0.0050186939,
-0.0147094922,
-0.0107383886,
-0.0130495932,
-0.0239520036,
0.0435010046,
0.0157553889,
-0.0362239629,
-0.0151142552,
-0.0168117806,
0.0412126817,
-0.0028388621,
-0.0156238005,
0.0670630708,
-0.0231379531,
-0.0324827991,
-0.0321683064,
-0.0125942696,
-0.0053218701,
0.0280965045,
0.0478466488,
-0.0104578473,
0.036801517,
0.0230609756,
0.0529314056,
0.0904861614,
0.0034759238,
-0.0365398861,
0.0415364243,
-0.004473364,
0.03140698,
-0.0043339562,
0.0108246459,
1.99688113e-34,
-0.0264556669,
0.056519039,
-0.009426726,
-0.1322128773,
-0.0090087708,
0.0377433859,
-0.0700610653,
-0.0065569254,
0.0261025447,
-0.0156469643,
0.020764662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17922v1 | [Lions: 1] and [Tigers: 2] and [Bears: 3], Oh My! Literary Coreference Annotation with LLMs | 2024-01-31T15:35:21 | 2024-01-31T15:35:21 | Rebecca M. M. Hicke, David Mimno | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coreference annotation and resolution is a vital component of computational
literary studies. However, it has previously been difficult to build high
quality systems for fiction. Coreference requires complicated structured
outputs, and literary text involves subtle inferences and highly varied
language. New language-model-based seq2seq systems present the opportunity to
solve both these problems by learning to directly generate a copy of an input
sentence with markdown-like annotations. We create, evaluate, and release
several trained models for coreference, as well as a workflow for training new
models. | [Lions: 1] and [Tigers: 2] and [Bears: 3], Oh My! Literary Coreference Annotation with LLMs: Coreference annotation and resolution is a vital component of computational
literary studies. However, it has previously been difficult to build high
quality systems for fiction. Coreference requires complicated structured
outputs, and literary text involves subtle inferences and highly varied
language. New language-model-based seq2seq systems present the opportunity to
solve both these problems by learning to directly generate a copy of an input
sentence with markdown-like annotations. We create, evaluate, and release
several trained models for coreference, as well as a workflow for training new
models. | [
0.0539314039,
0.0357597731,
-0.0059199031,
0.0117723895,
-0.0314499326,
0.0159996226,
0.0052354122,
0.0043635648,
0.0464868657,
-0.088566184,
-0.0077140182,
0.0546812788,
-0.0226142332,
0.0066939527,
0.0318786837,
-0.0116033452,
0.0283467341,
-0.0229251925,
0.0426028371,
0.0231180377,
0.015461701,
0.0530472174,
0.0207858309,
0.0352875665,
-0.0285241175,
-0.0559624918,
-0.0142280841,
0.0407923125,
0.0262180604,
-0.0166594218,
0.0101558091,
0.044297602,
0.0210610013,
0.038165886,
0.0000017107,
-0.0495001115,
-0.0224798117,
-0.0091635166,
0.0266280845,
0.0371457823,
0.0248715598,
0.000643035,
0.0018194724,
-0.0027436297,
-0.0094157374,
0.0038004152,
0.0363050215,
0.0606823824,
0.0830182657,
0.0681266859,
-0.011039353,
-0.0145423403,
-0.017674366,
-0.0248873644,
-0.0246428233,
-0.0401166119,
0.0247884151,
0.0306883678,
0.0189959649,
0.0503561907,
0.0124035776,
0.033078108,
-0.0058627184,
-0.0439667292,
-0.0002954568,
0.0044650738,
-0.0445472263,
0.0284180343,
-0.0160411894,
0.029320145,
0.051639311,
-0.0246602334,
0.0072062048,
0.0163119789,
-0.0349346474,
-0.0050340807,
-0.0394461825,
0.0241194889,
-0.0095409956,
0.0278592259,
0.0388526917,
0.0078539513,
0.0010674202,
-0.0107461568,
0.011316889,
0.039490249,
0.0254117176,
0.0249529798,
0.0325943157,
-0.003193635,
-0.0748153925,
-0.0838550627,
0.0463700257,
0.0300599113,
-0.0040263706,
-0.0174059346,
-0.0570107736,
0.0054185619,
-0.0026007409,
-0.0319292061,
0.0464048982,
0.00441055,
-0.0004906653,
0.0300522447,
0.0068102609,
0.0330079272,
0.0066593685,
0.018257983,
-0.0351219848,
-0.0087043131,
-0.0204086434,
-0.0098180491,
-0.063746497,
0.0408415981,
-0.0439212956,
-0.0478940308,
-0.0393053368,
0.0073479088,
0.0487077832,
0.0218355637,
-0.0018553126,
0.0070573939,
-0.0342719182,
0.0064321076,
-0.0047543305,
0.004147396,
-0.0106823342,
0.0109315692,
-0.0288595166,
0.0031575856,
0.0010482185,
0.029635692,
0.0015238496,
-0.0602936968,
-0.0035976656,
0.0661478639,
0.0107884798,
-0.0237070899,
-0.0489673615,
-0.0313572213,
-0.022842437,
-0.0257361569,
-0.0602720231,
-0.0574716255,
-0.003332047,
-0.0041883932,
0.0088735679,
-0.0845067129,
0.0472987369,
0.0298443176,
-0.043916665,
0.0477774218,
-0.0263342671,
-0.0187728778,
0.0150894709,
-0.0053412123,
0.0311040133,
0.0518557169,
0.0856593475,
0.0183825083,
0.0618165135,
0.0187675674,
-0.0191612691,
0.0570902303,
-0.0220513847,
0.0169590302,
-0.0400747359,
-0.0326900855,
-0.0071325023,
0.0249461737,
0.0195677001,
0.0927098095,
-0.0161766801,
-0.0031300529,
0.0843989998,
0.0791064948,
-0.0017000295,
0.0074804868,
0.032673005,
-0.0014922194,
0.0144072967,
0.0474506877,
-0.051451765,
0.0098809274,
0.0276506357,
0.0018394719,
0.0139315724,
-0.0107100122,
0.0151782706,
-0.0204205457,
-0.0491225272,
-0.0063028452,
-0.037073113,
-0.0379845835,
0.0137608368,
0.0207802337,
-0.0491109639,
0.0260070041,
-0.0088825896,
-0.0637495965,
0.0200228952,
0.003200731,
0.0026215632,
0.0267400816,
0.0595314018,
-0.0190734509,
-0.030647384,
-0.0223639943,
0.031051375,
0.06406115,
-0.0042601633,
-0.0563714653,
0.0055277962,
-0.0344790444,
0.0167363584,
-0.0329408348,
0.03373776,
-0.0204909779,
-0.0037089135,
-0.0056892531,
0.0043066838,
-0.0032470608,
-0.0509161614,
0.0508564711,
-0.0568406768,
-0.0183853973,
-0.0250817407,
-0.0219626389,
-0.0030737186,
0.0106623136,
-0.0194688756,
0.0244513527,
0.0589242056,
-0.0630749539,
-0.0197562873,
0.0398792438,
-0.0159311611,
-0.0334259234,
0.0746290982,
-0.0812627226,
0.0037798358,
-0.0003860688,
-0.0222471058,
-0.0455777273,
-0.0248506535,
-0.0333468467,
0.0609789491,
-0.0482817814,
-0.0005524003,
0.0348634385,
-0.0298746191,
-0.071647346,
0.0352494866,
0.0049630105,
-0.0032210371,
0.0141991526,
0.0009017583,
0.0044058226,
-0.0166741312,
-0.0080360295,
-0.0401251353,
0.0524891205,
-0.0288946182,
0.0110619506,
-0.0061715115,
-0.034903191,
-0.0514192022,
-0.0684085786,
0.0441122353,
-0.027661534,
0.0135910166,
0.0323004015,
-0.0116874725,
-0.0014052461,
-0.0046003065,
-0.0094156563,
-0.0309062898,
0.0087817218,
-0.0022752306,
0.0497620516,
0.0156365,
-0.0177047309,
-0.0472101793,
0.0077926703,
-0.0422629267,
0.0589537956,
0.0133206937,
-0.0012712252,
-0.0370815285,
0.0303268153,
-0.005046064,
0.0263213851,
0.0000821634,
-0.0022453258,
0.0098508904,
-0.0022252384,
0.0103341043,
0.049488958,
0.0031574306,
0.0312649831,
0.0263541434,
-0.0555531606,
-0.0130087025,
0.0104379961,
0.0185099803,
-0.0422330461,
-0.036353454,
-0.0337643176,
0.0106845349,
0.0685219318,
-0.0115837837,
-0.0063550398,
-0.0216906276,
0.0666850731,
0.0162662212,
-0.0202404726,
0.0094496664,
-0.0366327837,
-0.0295132585,
0.0529304892,
-0.0288804509,
-0.0128427492,
0.0348954797,
-0.0556046702,
-0.0057276348,
-0.0028442354,
0.0118173892,
-0.0601932853,
0.0824214369,
0.0002884727,
0.0086034453,
0.0264831297,
-0.0407712944,
-0.0395782851,
0.0035718223,
0.0411045365,
-0.0091908807,
0.045163922,
-0.0267770365,
0.0140459398,
-0.0178298987,
0.0229969826,
-0.0414053723,
0.0427689068,
-0.0775431767,
0.0060065491,
0.0006656388,
0.005956572,
-0.0247055739,
0.0089195836,
-0.0379679874,
0.0278666653,
-0.0246596131,
-0.002086095,
-0.0482735224,
0.0387323014,
0.065870434,
0.0010227212,
0.000235871,
-0.0475557931,
0.051108174,
0.0517328978,
-0.0783230662,
0.0164563544,
-0.0078275539,
0.0268141702,
0.0440976769,
-0.0811006874,
-0.0084328838,
-0.023730224,
0.043669574,
-0.0461969078,
-0.0327241793,
0.1325115263,
0.0328789949,
-0.0385537818,
-0.0008969594,
-0.0246365312,
0.0172850713,
0.0540143438,
-0.0069974666,
-0.06325683,
-0.0286335088,
0.015746247,
0.0183779895,
0.0231348835,
-0.0611256845,
-0.0168913193,
-0.0805102512,
0.0511339083,
0.0204612948,
-0.0849378183,
0.0053983736,
-0.007959934,
0.0081467163,
-0.0310685914,
-0.034121573,
0.0198493488,
-0.0411804803,
0.0330125727,
-0.0159296021,
0.0260248929,
0.0513849407,
-0.0343353823,
-0.0649639368,
0.0145850154,
0.0365063287,
0.0499156564,
0.0247539785,
0.0149352774,
0.0315886959,
-0.0368274637,
-0.037490122,
-0.0143099036,
0.0191023704,
-0.0404528268,
0.0062456098,
-0.0191154499,
0.0732720271,
0.0205446295,
-0.0538812988,
0.048917152,
0.036794547,
0.0073695867,
0.0181552507,
-0.0343330987,
0.0568889938,
-0.0017323623,
0.0755206496,
0.0599435903,
-0.0151602216,
-0.0322880596,
-0.0387462601,
0.0217652973,
-0.0601669587,
-0.0781252533,
0.018536903,
-0.050220076,
0.0026952603,
-0.0898051634,
-0.0305683445,
0.0356871821,
0.0296350196,
0.0471353121,
0.0261774231,
-0.0179793369,
-0.0129984012,
-0.0327373371,
-0.0126225315,
-0.0309308674,
-0.0312514044,
-0.0472439714,
0.0246866122,
0.0601140782,
-0.0019435257,
0.0135799162,
0.0412999503,
-0.0775207579,
-0.0537847057,
-0.0216777641,
0.0281604063,
0.0269844308,
0.0327817798,
-0.021868797,
-0.0300678536,
-0.0296228658,
0.0419095345,
-0.011013777,
0.042927742,
0.004915813,
0.0357980877,
-0.0236974601,
0.0490569547,
-0.0124739511,
0.0458918549,
-0.0156622324,
0.0582868829,
-0.030408008,
-0.1068429053,
0.0129834367,
0.0034239434,
0.0167577453,
-0.0344908945,
-0.0034447678,
-0.0077505717,
0.0260858294,
-0.0368774012,
-0.0336615965,
-0.0441697687,
0.0543787666,
-0.0101366956,
0.0112256194,
-0.0292533729,
-0.0130555332,
-0.0453932062,
0.0868692473,
-0.0568376519,
0.0213028658,
0.0442265049,
-0.0047194841,
-0.0341790095,
-0.0205008704,
-0.0178143345,
0.0278948229,
-0.017016599,
0.0789560378,
-0.0056100809,
0.0165265668,
0.0197018441,
0.0005338874,
0.0172879957,
0.006796747,
-0.0492101014,
-0.0065282406,
-0.0433845818,
0.0066512646,
0.0706981048,
-0.0242152698,
0.1074559614,
-0.0026790353,
-0.0317667872,
-0.0144951167,
0.0577687509,
0.0261377301,
0.013567606,
-0.0376401767,
0.0119017558,
0.0062146583,
0.0502450354,
0.0291487016,
0.0183293913,
0.0182358865,
0.0688907877,
-0.0529663712,
-0.0207601674,
-0.0415416658,
0.0021963993,
-0.0129794572,
0.0314902775,
-0.0195722114,
-0.0651983023,
-0.051999934,
0.1122100204,
0.0307837445,
0.0109353578,
0.0146187833,
0.0011721323,
0.0110271471,
0.0246931817,
-0.0144062284,
-0.0586826615,
0.0430845357,
0.0116318138,
-0.0581751838,
-0.018204255,
-5.319355485e-33,
-0.0776132867,
-0.0291874148,
0.0034248142,
0.0342977047,
-0.0502498671,
0.015271307,
-0.0137922484,
-0.0109299291,
0.0545842461,
0.0147829019,
-0.0228850748,
-0.016349867,
0.000402601,
-0.0094776079,
-0.0049607987,
0.0192054603,
0.0554000176,
0.0114492942,
-0.0403903089,
-0.0116927084,
0.0443766937,
0.0428005382,
0.083909452,
-0.0645843744,
0.0123056648,
-0.0433338024,
-0.0197448432,
0.0033497955,
0.0229724627,
0.0324909911,
-0.01132893,
-0.0047627264,
-0.0113173043,
-0.004545168,
-0.0051249065,
-0.0221797079,
-0.0928963274,
-0.019548377,
0.0439035743,
-0.0020781094,
0.0145888766,
-0.0607687384,
0.0392687395,
-0.0206421465,
0.018406637,
-0.0184810087,
0.0641401932,
-0.0268532466,
-0.0287878402,
-0.0431567132,
-0.0667055324,
0.0201600995,
-0.0232708752,
0.0049034967,
-0.0046117455,
0.0498670079,
0.0135851568,
0.031530261,
-0.023214668,
0.0017403237,
0.0076861619,
0.0561720878,
-0.0123523539,
0.0077333446,
-0.0141532999,
0.0552161895,
-0.0448482856,
-0.0269175451,
-0.0276065413,
0.0587542057,
-0.0027238755,
0.0210812632,
0.0283034667,
0.0889521092,
-0.0200922936,
0.0309333671,
-0.0823820308,
0.0426116101,
0.0108333332,
0.0190879554,
0.0125172054,
-0.0136829885,
0.0220438037,
-0.0133477878,
-0.0693349168,
-0.046601966,
0.0059401733,
-0.0281972215,
0.01073441,
-0.0155639816,
-0.0566428453,
0.0228645429,
0.0108926743,
-0.0181170348,
-0.0305930879,
-0.0380021445,
-0.0109038865,
0.0339756124,
-0.0239924248,
0.0219576582,
0.0012778277,
-0.0032473679,
0.0319938771,
-0.0195940807,
0.0533526801,
-0.0177319162,
0.0337828211,
-0.0060251723,
-0.0559578165,
-0.0102052158,
-0.00912257,
0.0148467449,
-0.033311855,
0.0203139912,
0.0039680372,
-0.0260953698,
0.0088822246,
0.0206645895,
0.0015407911,
0.0109230336,
-0.0510734245,
-0.008812502,
0.0308516137,
0.0259646047,
-0.0198381599,
-0.0008077569,
0.0011614641,
0.0249122195,
-0.0119982827,
-0.0657002255,
0.0005613415,
-0.0105933789,
2.347e-7,
0.053135328,
0.0031900802,
0.0500583053,
-0.0240824576,
-0.0021446201,
0.0041595702,
-0.0308262259,
0.0525376461,
0.0205811262,
-0.0609017052,
0.002352311,
0.0335606784,
0.010156977,
0.0295116138,
-0.121561408,
-0.0144611644,
-0.0717410669,
-0.0099623995,
-0.0477005467,
-0.0089809624,
0.0242523737,
0.0511285514,
0.0488394722,
-0.0036366512,
-0.0100595802,
-0.0221165344,
0.0490144007,
-0.0270742718,
-0.0304049309,
0.0453068204,
0.0335483328,
0.0089138765,
-0.0185095668,
-0.0024041664,
-0.00538282,
0.0139957676,
0.0437447727,
0.0849286839,
0.0106621832,
-0.0222336948,
-0.0205116458,
0.0043077734,
0.0201545171,
0.0079668332,
0.057749629,
0.0094650723,
-0.0069547929,
-0.0660612658,
-0.0418706201,
0.0066856495,
0.0138244675,
-0.0071542794,
0.0022446709,
0.0452135205,
0.0137415389,
0.0246369317,
-0.0090656951,
-0.0660827011,
-0.0366677158,
-0.0094391741,
0.0018094961,
-0.0426949784,
-0.0115746306,
-0.0228970349,
-0.0656147972,
-0.0680264905,
-0.0205941554,
2.325321369e-34,
0.046960406,
-0.0158278253,
-0.0055102399,
0.0986489281,
0.0103224805,
-0.0143513549,
0.0011193499,
0.0127309551,
0.0108948527,
-0.0306956396,
-0.0182654373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17919v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17919v3 | LOCOST: State-Space Models for Long Document Abstractive Summarization | 2024-01-31T15:33:37 | 2024-03-25T12:52:42 | Florian Le Bronnec, Song Duong, Mathieu Ravaut, Alexandre Allauzen, Nancy F. Chen, Vincent Guigue, Alberto Lumbreras, Laure Soulier, Patrick Gallinari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | State-space models are a low-complexity alternative to transformers for
encoding long sequences and capturing long-term dependencies. We propose
LOCOST: an encoder-decoder architecture based on state-space models for
conditional text generation with long context inputs. With a computational
complexity of $O(L \log L)$, this architecture can handle significantly longer
sequences than state-of-the-art models that are based on sparse attention
patterns. We evaluate our model on a series of long document abstractive
summarization tasks. The model reaches a performance level that is 93-96%
comparable to the top-performing sparse transformers of the same size while
saving up to 50% memory during training and up to 87% during inference.
Additionally, LOCOST effectively handles input texts exceeding 600K tokens at
inference time, setting new state-of-the-art results on full-book summarization
and opening new perspectives for long input processing. | LOCOST: State-Space Models for Long Document Abstractive Summarization: State-space models are a low-complexity alternative to transformers for
encoding long sequences and capturing long-term dependencies. We propose
LOCOST: an encoder-decoder architecture based on state-space models for
conditional text generation with long context inputs. With a computational
complexity of $O(L \log L)$, this architecture can handle significantly longer
sequences than state-of-the-art models that are based on sparse attention
patterns. We evaluate our model on a series of long document abstractive
summarization tasks. The model reaches a performance level that is 93-96%
comparable to the top-performing sparse transformers of the same size while
saving up to 50% memory during training and up to 87% during inference.
Additionally, LOCOST effectively handles input texts exceeding 600K tokens at
inference time, setting new state-of-the-art results on full-book summarization
and opening new perspectives for long input processing. | [
0.0194792207,
0.0478836745,
0.0233544167,
0.0114988722,
-0.0190804992,
-0.0084998282,
-0.0007753482,
-0.0200671311,
-0.0525487773,
-0.0394726619,
0.036295943,
-0.0479110889,
0.024096664,
0.0492618456,
0.0115694525,
-0.0971215814,
0.0159406476,
-0.0266216602,
-0.0189291164,
0.0003906059,
0.0187083241,
0.0004576246,
0.0345322341,
0.0214921609,
0.0238753669,
-0.0286640227,
-0.0336088203,
-0.008793653,
0.0182617232,
-0.0385476202,
-0.0140959667,
-0.0027028583,
0.0553547628,
0.0019394378,
0.0000018643,
-0.0292550549,
-0.0295742042,
0.000178582,
0.0235915333,
0.0193702765,
0.0153398467,
-0.0638486743,
0.0229311064,
0.0071597989,
0.0081883771,
-0.0263777021,
0.016878888,
0.0563854054,
0.0497782342,
0.0820299461,
-0.0153787732,
-0.0365046188,
0.0654663742,
-0.0503463894,
0.0154086184,
-0.0347115248,
0.0046668393,
-0.0174892396,
0.0229647011,
0.0173178483,
-0.0452452451,
0.0361707881,
0.0657001063,
0.0092586474,
0.0156209385,
0.0615854897,
0.0119197452,
0.0188264232,
0.005281454,
0.0525518656,
-0.0180876292,
-0.0177271776,
0.0303343888,
0.0315956324,
-0.0142418817,
-0.0296551902,
-0.0434002876,
0.0497179329,
-0.0350649022,
0.0052512647,
0.0441071875,
0.0515167266,
-0.0057703126,
0.025830904,
-0.0641735569,
0.0135493502,
0.0167522039,
-0.043360509,
-0.0427199565,
0.0002440972,
-0.0273887925,
-0.0519385226,
0.046306245,
0.0598983765,
-0.0056315754,
-0.0112997079,
-0.0790316761,
-0.0672579706,
-0.0103429332,
-0.0008524462,
-0.0123319039,
0.0376426019,
0.0232525636,
0.0324970074,
-0.0318185352,
0.0352267399,
-0.0003842114,
-0.0087881293,
-0.0529874451,
0.0015972217,
0.0049560727,
0.0002693089,
-0.0525668971,
0.0342321582,
-0.0477205291,
-0.0489152521,
-0.0298005547,
0.0176097844,
0.0275521092,
-0.0011482091,
-0.0200377442,
0.0189141072,
-0.0436501317,
-0.0189050697,
0.0167436879,
0.023873277,
-0.0183335636,
-0.0327850729,
0.0596589521,
0.0191247445,
-0.0282183941,
0.0196676832,
0.0303996727,
-0.0101419427,
-0.0164373666,
0.0301910583,
-0.0276576877,
-0.0360979475,
-0.0056005195,
-0.0410849378,
-0.0125784166,
-0.0567411482,
0.0035558864,
-0.0593406297,
0.0103081902,
0.0208567996,
0.0033695612,
-0.000832213,
-0.0029144972,
0.0351172015,
-0.0079632318,
0.0181256831,
-0.0028171798,
-0.0239734147,
0.0339770094,
0.0317002758,
0.0225785132,
0.0152451908,
0.0342246033,
0.0595598593,
0.0001481925,
0.0232469719,
0.0147755388,
0.0235005021,
0.010201796,
0.0185279734,
0.0077788508,
-0.0055285995,
-0.0532543063,
-0.0021446748,
0.0546636656,
0.0739092007,
-0.0366295911,
0.0072306958,
0.0489290021,
0.0503815264,
-0.0048977965,
0.0389070362,
0.0599059761,
0.0235900171,
0.0000571738,
0.0376713946,
-0.0015906598,
0.0512312911,
-0.0034406474,
0.0628218874,
0.0714401305,
0.022359319,
-0.0318531618,
-0.0230131894,
0.0148392245,
-0.025336666,
0.0077242698,
-0.011812862,
0.0505168699,
0.0325678885,
-0.0931196064,
0.0422170833,
-0.0095267249,
-0.0696035847,
0.0315733775,
-0.0069037089,
0.0433959886,
0.0621330217,
0.0612682998,
-0.0210936405,
-0.024158081,
-0.0190081298,
-0.0108406153,
0.0647007525,
0.0070099062,
0.0036342174,
-0.0258083697,
-0.0666464344,
-0.0074884836,
-0.0149139175,
0.0049365503,
-0.0011043835,
0.0156491343,
0.023430137,
0.0607593544,
-0.0065372712,
-0.0384771749,
0.0226216689,
-0.0497566313,
-0.0321940891,
-0.0227991417,
-0.0082996963,
0.0267889295,
0.001870641,
-0.0013428236,
0.0430637635,
0.0253394973,
-0.0533340611,
-0.0040051551,
0.0027863428,
-0.0925508067,
-0.0545414425,
-0.0061779199,
-0.0537099279,
0.0228598733,
0.0468084738,
-0.0160255264,
-0.0796781927,
0.0077637769,
-0.0788809061,
0.0500466898,
-0.0252062641,
0.0001947922,
0.0634383485,
0.0139453141,
-0.0080017028,
0.0645798966,
-0.0390277505,
0.0040181917,
0.0418745279,
0.0299993418,
-0.014233822,
-0.0271365717,
-0.0321838483,
-0.0259718727,
0.0133854803,
-0.0269590281,
0.0439010598,
0.0024472824,
0.0017222698,
-0.0052203536,
-0.0811898559,
-0.0047546471,
-0.0238537677,
0.0153304432,
0.0310494695,
0.0467026792,
0.0165463779,
0.0163852554,
-0.0505418703,
-0.0015962722,
0.0253458675,
0.0037913925,
0.0091632446,
-0.0008437585,
-0.0180575475,
-0.0342117548,
-0.0316504054,
0.0162442904,
0.0307679214,
0.0003406189,
-0.0064228945,
-0.0432220362,
0.0450540259,
0.0174524486,
0.0026470635,
-0.0373106189,
0.0079402961,
-0.0110689932,
-0.0295502339,
0.0852432624,
0.0251884852,
0.0539994575,
0.0243530739,
0.0194516797,
-0.0090351021,
0.0125363609,
0.0122748381,
-0.031907659,
0.0506804883,
-0.0013197724,
-0.0251176804,
0.0276735239,
0.0657064542,
0.0043409276,
-0.0045232377,
-0.0440276824,
-0.0546913631,
0.0097382683,
-0.0110778725,
-0.0198795553,
-0.0380551443,
-0.0175652094,
0.0046716887,
-0.0366345383,
-0.0088234292,
0.0538635254,
-0.0444052704,
-0.0002795507,
-0.039616812,
0.0234104414,
-0.0566669852,
0.0470529459,
0.0484851375,
0.0138117876,
-0.0203606226,
-0.0110827228,
-0.0057681883,
0.016983714,
-0.021114368,
0.002312188,
0.0583390146,
-0.0194778554,
0.0273822658,
-0.0353939235,
-0.0168652311,
-0.0059811934,
-0.0203972887,
0.0036184043,
0.00522997,
0.0449026562,
-0.0231236909,
-0.0426759161,
0.0395488031,
0.0224831682,
0.0983719304,
-0.0312540196,
-0.0153345298,
-0.026500335,
0.0655467361,
0.0843690112,
0.0015777776,
0.0108121019,
-0.0977730453,
0.01388398,
0.0670701414,
0.0235099606,
-0.0120188454,
-0.0187211875,
-0.0250944402,
-0.0001513494,
-0.0380144119,
0.0244484022,
0.0212894473,
0.0277602151,
-0.0850522667,
-0.0452614203,
0.0992146507,
0.0141706867,
-0.0721526593,
0.0037716706,
0.0219893195,
0.0612359829,
-0.020691663,
-0.0106627578,
-0.0763861164,
-0.0230510812,
0.0001447461,
0.0131280189,
0.0173701234,
-0.018115418,
0.018834006,
-0.0546906516,
0.0000543743,
0.0174327791,
-0.0723288655,
-0.0413667411,
-0.0100745829,
-0.0105223646,
0.0267831627,
-0.0081971893,
0.0475984327,
-0.0316012911,
0.009051796,
-0.0042057978,
-0.0177249797,
0.0126447445,
-0.0212375131,
-0.0036893177,
-0.0282120779,
0.0605395287,
0.0113800764,
-0.0031566701,
-0.0035494473,
0.0270194802,
-0.0221955031,
-0.0166957229,
-0.0044446224,
0.0484390631,
-0.0237245765,
0.0331935659,
-0.0348916203,
0.0634489954,
-0.0148879951,
-0.0002772985,
0.0153590916,
0.027905738,
-0.010616648,
-0.0111715654,
-0.0561956018,
-0.0018581911,
-0.0232530683,
0.0732596889,
0.0347062424,
-0.0188068002,
-0.0941660404,
-0.0197532382,
-0.0195949078,
-0.1011361852,
0.0019648254,
-0.0435906425,
0.005149906,
-0.0327082686,
-0.0693379715,
-0.0505814068,
0.0084993728,
0.0004671796,
-0.0240471531,
-0.0049746572,
0.0199532285,
-0.0259414427,
-0.0512258522,
0.0211702213,
-0.0139275016,
-0.0036552362,
-0.0492538176,
-0.010683042,
0.0352926888,
-0.0203667674,
-0.0176406149,
0.0347705632,
-0.0770566463,
-0.0305290967,
-0.0136092212,
0.038113147,
0.0156610589,
0.0558929853,
0.0270169787,
0.0233051199,
0.090305388,
0.0043140929,
-0.0206707008,
0.037960995,
0.0099781267,
0.0232258514,
-0.0029251287,
0.0226526074,
-0.0236067511,
0.0188673474,
-0.0259145144,
0.0195588935,
-0.0135216909,
-0.0138884382,
-0.0169540308,
-0.0278277695,
-0.0145580964,
-0.0263388604,
0.0269309897,
-0.0249418262,
-0.0002552519,
-0.0245035589,
0.0128951827,
-0.0446075015,
0.0299583673,
0.0084845703,
0.0137871103,
-0.0007799453,
0.0688330829,
0.0564738251,
0.000618079,
-0.0353223793,
0.0221663155,
-0.0314475186,
-0.0257790834,
0.0134266978,
-0.0313823111,
-0.0444662049,
-0.0425512083,
-0.0397767648,
0.0261616055,
-0.0175913889,
0.0465767123,
0.0441429317,
0.0251155421,
-0.0018552255,
0.0212861765,
-0.0762504935,
0.0331098959,
-0.0496228598,
0.011282309,
0.0378807597,
-0.0471568815,
0.0702805221,
-0.0211789608,
0.01426192,
-0.0289063249,
0.0399798229,
0.0153324185,
-0.0157359298,
-0.0270975158,
0.0258189123,
0.0219439249,
0.0152649302,
0.0942285806,
0.0082731117,
0.0220148116,
0.0337337255,
-0.0072735818,
-0.0467636473,
-0.0047963155,
-0.021944318,
0.0300992802,
0.0038640364,
0.0019542924,
-0.0196571909,
-0.0262456182,
0.04645418,
0.0125820944,
0.009608469,
-0.0122787226,
0.0589577667,
0.0262339637,
-0.009391821,
-0.0178151764,
-0.031351544,
0.0257907137,
-0.0047762124,
-0.0304576308,
-0.0455244444,
-5.700362224e-33,
-0.0290370844,
-0.0197213404,
0.025420595,
-0.0102846753,
-0.0849801451,
0.0041867164,
-0.0939876288,
-0.041591309,
0.0511353314,
-0.0127133271,
-0.0094009694,
-0.0114970403,
-0.0138913775,
0.0778610185,
-0.002595156,
0.0130054541,
0.0489713885,
0.0261243116,
-0.0236469302,
0.0686825886,
0.0599321947,
0.0267321728,
-0.0074749738,
-0.0003843256,
-0.0023865597,
-0.0386545919,
0.0200997777,
-0.0463561155,
-0.010778999,
0.0107800551,
-0.0366151296,
-0.0017160028,
0.0390697345,
-0.0355790332,
-0.0512486435,
0.0480613597,
-0.0932198912,
0.0161611829,
0.0036583066,
-0.0362584665,
-0.0652066097,
-0.0613039397,
0.0386270173,
0.0149869965,
0.0251313671,
-0.0327586867,
0.0378341489,
-0.0434138998,
-0.0245508477,
-0.0757180974,
-0.0710616857,
0.0210306309,
-0.0267989747,
-0.0116508128,
0.042416919,
0.0685915276,
-0.0101574594,
0.0069270665,
-0.027561998,
-0.0031127504,
0.0310678668,
0.0763361305,
0.0233963244,
0.0358855501,
0.0109945629,
0.0307641141,
-0.0231808554,
-0.0215717163,
-0.049171228,
0.0496941395,
-0.0045314888,
-0.0074412804,
0.0063147433,
-0.019808216,
0.0627540052,
0.0190298501,
-0.0606752224,
0.0559323393,
-0.0221592616,
0.0415561609,
0.0583696067,
-0.005464639,
-0.0093826456,
-0.0004125262,
0.0114519149,
0.0310665928,
-0.0010438215,
0.0036427097,
0.0118856877,
0.0615751296,
-0.0157297496,
-0.0047536609,
0.0627893955,
-0.0094124572,
0.0304384362,
0.0205384437,
-0.0121925948,
0.0084876744,
-0.0005457483,
-0.0217600707,
-0.0477070883,
0.0003702439,
0.0204236954,
-0.0043871393,
-0.0410671197,
0.0155906202,
0.0440551192,
0.0092819231,
-0.0363939628,
-0.0092468401,
-0.0303943288,
0.020736672,
-0.0319835171,
0.0779157653,
0.02189615,
0.0078815846,
-0.0060922867,
0.062954776,
-0.0628040135,
-0.0021506508,
-0.0291796178,
0.0095045744,
0.0165460333,
0.032601539,
-0.0264430828,
0.0227674153,
-0.0484157987,
0.0342168473,
0.0179273449,
-0.0687458515,
-0.0093805576,
0.0354412273,
2.438e-7,
0.0078396657,
0.0076700272,
0.0873050615,
-0.0035797986,
0.0216191672,
-0.0115300333,
0.0314268991,
0.0421424508,
0.0044064708,
-0.0100075072,
0.0176082961,
0.0242612809,
0.0517418496,
-0.0067288401,
-0.1151109263,
-0.007084616,
-0.0858446881,
-0.0269312151,
-0.0408031717,
-0.0348653384,
0.0618157834,
0.0682701394,
-0.0313721113,
0.0083388751,
0.0303478092,
0.0028718978,
0.0500926524,
0.0255174953,
-0.0064033084,
0.0078591807,
0.0330109894,
-0.0099068191,
-0.0314048082,
-0.0451044068,
-0.0125291999,
0.0143349562,
0.0080274204,
0.0599819012,
0.030371096,
-0.0449817888,
0.0457537994,
0.0008763573,
-0.0181526076,
-0.0001903234,
0.0544004887,
-0.0406307913,
0.0146581596,
0.0062143719,
-0.0624026619,
0.0301538166,
-0.0595683828,
0.0323739648,
-0.0176920425,
0.0383075476,
0.0028851873,
-0.0273513962,
0.02456812,
-0.0790457577,
-0.0139472187,
0.0047166231,
-0.0641589761,
-0.0177579131,
-0.0673990175,
0.0144560533,
0.0066128103,
-0.0688404441,
-0.0432600975,
2.71539769e-34,
0.082291089,
-0.0270241164,
-0.0311766975,
-0.0050706388,
0.0144820511,
-0.0446249768,
-0.0011670843,
0.0004240121,
0.015155416,
-0.1079466268,
-0.0556629971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17911v1 | SNNLP: Energy-Efficient Natural Language Processing Using Spiking Neural Networks | 2024-01-31T15:16:25 | 2024-01-31T15:16:25 | R. Alexander Knipper, Kaniz Mishty, Mehdi Sadi, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As spiking neural networks receive more attention, we look toward
applications of this computing paradigm in fields other than computer vision
and signal processing. One major field, underexplored in the neuromorphic
setting, is Natural Language Processing (NLP), where most state-of-the-art
solutions still heavily rely on resource-consuming and power-hungry traditional
deep learning architectures. Therefore, it is compelling to design NLP models
for neuromorphic architectures due to their low energy requirements, with the
additional benefit of a more human-brain-like operating model for processing
information. However, one of the biggest issues with bringing NLP to the
neuromorphic setting is in properly encoding text into a spike train so that it
can be seamlessly handled by both current and future SNN architectures. In this
paper, we compare various methods of encoding text as spikes and assess each
method's performance in an associated SNN on a downstream NLP task, namely,
sentiment analysis. Furthermore, we go on to propose a new method of encoding
text as spikes that outperforms a widely-used rate-coding technique, Poisson
rate-coding, by around 13\% on our benchmark NLP tasks. Subsequently, we
demonstrate the energy efficiency of SNNs implemented in hardware for the
sentiment analysis task compared to traditional deep neural networks, observing
an energy efficiency increase of more than 32x during inference and 60x during
training while incurring the expected energy-performance tradeoff. | SNNLP: Energy-Efficient Natural Language Processing Using Spiking Neural Networks: As spiking neural networks receive more attention, we look toward
applications of this computing paradigm in fields other than computer vision
and signal processing. One major field, underexplored in the neuromorphic
setting, is Natural Language Processing (NLP), where most state-of-the-art
solutions still heavily rely on resource-consuming and power-hungry traditional
deep learning architectures. Therefore, it is compelling to design NLP models
for neuromorphic architectures due to their low energy requirements, with the
additional benefit of a more human-brain-like operating model for processing
information. However, one of the biggest issues with bringing NLP to the
neuromorphic setting is in properly encoding text into a spike train so that it
can be seamlessly handled by both current and future SNN architectures. In this
paper, we compare various methods of encoding text as spikes and assess each
method's performance in an associated SNN on a downstream NLP task, namely,
sentiment analysis. Furthermore, we go on to propose a new method of encoding
text as spikes that outperforms a widely-used rate-coding technique, Poisson
rate-coding, by around 13\% on our benchmark NLP tasks. Subsequently, we
demonstrate the energy efficiency of SNNs implemented in hardware for the
sentiment analysis task compared to traditional deep neural networks, observing
an energy efficiency increase of more than 32x during inference and 60x during
training while incurring the expected energy-performance tradeoff. | [
-0.017456267,
0.0385749862,
0.0106037874,
0.0854761079,
-0.0178769138,
-0.0259316768,
-0.0056468486,
0.00649489,
-0.0106734792,
-0.0213280115,
-0.0427909605,
0.0167089142,
-0.0013996272,
0.0503468812,
0.0024197146,
0.0035524187,
0.0785385892,
0.0273048114,
0.0258912221,
-0.0059857843,
0.0244208351,
-0.0214020927,
-0.0343801752,
0.0352033861,
-0.0182536654,
0.0095447944,
-0.0215779692,
0.0107895769,
0.0326462165,
-0.0333190933,
0.0236763358,
0.0196562279,
-0.0038981237,
0.0364261568,
0.0000018258,
0.0332131982,
0.0307625327,
0.0128207859,
-0.0055816434,
0.0024090069,
-0.0031516517,
-0.0349346027,
-0.0302968379,
-0.0102424994,
0.0042987987,
-0.0282002259,
0.0917426422,
0.0305809937,
0.0029655262,
0.0519177504,
-0.0252235401,
-0.0338187404,
0.0484541841,
-0.0118707409,
0.0672406927,
0.0289430246,
-0.0192185882,
-0.0543691106,
0.0067232233,
0.0460942723,
-0.0540366508,
0.0495739244,
0.025284797,
-0.0023731999,
0.0290539581,
0.046733506,
-0.0482464321,
0.0295714512,
-0.0472659431,
0.0405522846,
-0.0424914584,
0.0299049262,
0.0082529429,
-0.0043196562,
-0.0758477375,
-0.0775689185,
0.0161580388,
-0.0389304794,
0.0069002216,
0.0617537573,
0.0008983371,
0.0071611213,
0.053138122,
0.000982533,
0.0399724767,
0.0484115221,
-0.0000268583,
0.0088741546,
0.0099836458,
0.0239943471,
0.0297174696,
-0.0045540067,
0.0331419893,
0.013909026,
0.0116416747,
-0.0110653378,
-0.0737982765,
-0.0265856329,
-0.0109748524,
-0.0915214047,
0.0141017139,
0.0528184399,
0.043769557,
0.0403358974,
-0.0286383703,
-0.0401614942,
-0.0310871862,
0.013177298,
-0.0362998657,
0.0254629981,
-0.0190447439,
0.0390077382,
0.002461466,
0.0208587777,
-0.0512438565,
-0.079116255,
-0.0578100123,
0.0013089724,
-0.0131420027,
-0.0110026421,
-0.0519661754,
0.0254285242,
0.0362048782,
-0.0029774653,
-0.0088757444,
0.0417439938,
-0.0189091917,
-0.017018199,
0.0164566133,
-0.0616806187,
-0.0150225824,
0.0233742855,
0.013089492,
0.0031135993,
0.0484829582,
0.0287451614,
-0.0083200242,
-0.0489370264,
-0.0649487823,
0.0348137058,
-0.0087489113,
0.0228549577,
0.0006701493,
-0.0918570012,
0.0518774167,
0.0162469801,
-0.0257100295,
-0.0051518246,
0.0476646647,
0.0252971258,
-0.0141440285,
0.0711746737,
-0.0472439304,
-0.0342844799,
0.014650533,
-0.0237479508,
-0.014639087,
0.0551492944,
0.1019946039,
0.0095784524,
0.0244934727,
0.0077028936,
-0.0135394465,
0.0026189885,
0.041353941,
-0.0237884093,
-0.0182448328,
-0.0672137961,
-0.0587426051,
0.0007954583,
0.0661984906,
0.0615841001,
-0.0371791646,
-0.0533289984,
0.0443731733,
0.0319331102,
-0.0518149249,
0.0344057009,
-0.0038260655,
-0.0136388196,
0.0020980698,
-0.0607697256,
-0.0174822472,
0.0596486926,
0.0118055409,
-0.0338844918,
-0.0006769641,
-0.0138833057,
-0.0559709743,
-0.0375805944,
0.0006400233,
-0.0277583729,
0.01877575,
0.0431565791,
0.0267561395,
-0.0177649707,
-0.0341890194,
0.0710900724,
-0.0057806592,
-0.0114513421,
-0.0384242348,
-0.0411441512,
-0.0238303468,
0.0775702074,
0.0022971125,
-0.0008011641,
0.015946893,
0.0141030569,
-0.0677418336,
0.0395687707,
0.0114186713,
0.0079585016,
0.0636701509,
-0.0898931399,
0.0208880492,
-0.0173780434,
-0.0014234529,
0.0119234873,
0.0329109989,
0.0115838908,
0.0067177168,
0.0393531434,
-0.0570444763,
-0.0128254723,
0.0054387711,
-0.0422827676,
0.0447552428,
-0.0241189506,
0.017300237,
-0.0373430848,
-0.0110284947,
0.0225853864,
0.0274490342,
-0.0704425573,
-0.0135505591,
-0.00808986,
-0.024906069,
-0.0331567191,
-0.0225843247,
-0.0062453239,
0.0181046426,
0.0222556069,
-0.0106572006,
-0.0122422725,
0.0073756916,
-0.0558370166,
0.0580876432,
-0.0275966469,
-0.0159282405,
0.0156886298,
0.0326736458,
0.0081109973,
0.0131903924,
0.0008366048,
0.0289419703,
-0.0087116957,
0.0044453633,
0.0098819416,
-0.0293660983,
-0.0715516061,
-0.0046738656,
0.0015368205,
-0.0087144086,
-0.0044764262,
-0.0252858195,
0.0037825725,
0.0134951593,
-0.0800961331,
-0.0016751505,
-0.0016931208,
0.0168161355,
-0.0156095326,
0.0097143492,
0.0197145268,
0.0152698262,
-0.0187671818,
0.0240116958,
-0.0418485552,
0.0299213715,
0.0278522111,
0.0066569913,
-0.007635782,
-0.0508611649,
-0.0658438206,
-0.004880101,
0.0275014844,
-0.0182757452,
-0.0386314727,
0.004431338,
0.043391794,
0.0119657014,
0.0135607542,
-0.0029469721,
-0.0580011643,
0.0102540776,
0.0192409363,
0.048620306,
0.0622267872,
0.0012753464,
0.0043497761,
-0.0145337014,
-0.018761687,
-0.0015741648,
0.0548327714,
-0.0061816587,
0.0662630349,
-0.0161518026,
0.0107029118,
-0.0210363735,
0.0624080896,
-0.0000379971,
0.0211298931,
-0.0239224788,
-0.0565412939,
0.0080982167,
-0.0596408062,
-0.0170474872,
0.0071505061,
0.0025154673,
-0.0017165401,
-0.0118234064,
-0.0229995195,
0.027940996,
0.0161760785,
0.0138919326,
-0.0470523164,
-0.0234461371,
-0.0115007134,
0.037501689,
0.0421717167,
0.0647757351,
-0.069155708,
0.0262914989,
0.0125725139,
-0.0323819704,
-0.0238098055,
-0.0324567258,
0.0437845998,
0.0210076924,
0.0280500222,
-0.0391705371,
-0.0390021205,
-0.0031877037,
-0.0029189989,
-0.0308937151,
-0.0214717407,
0.0618586652,
-0.030751681,
-0.0160110164,
0.0220332425,
0.0171373747,
0.0337826461,
-0.0031004986,
-0.0283165704,
-0.0132312877,
0.0251856912,
0.0163497534,
-0.0408747979,
0.0389998779,
0.0091385711,
0.0017646897,
0.1049614027,
0.0394830741,
0.053002052,
-0.125052169,
-0.0091767535,
0.0026758634,
0.0403193049,
-0.0230373573,
-0.0115971938,
0.0242048036,
-0.0305202845,
0.0052060937,
0.0585925095,
0.019686088,
-0.0482451692,
0.0037178549,
0.0416285507,
0.0086010937,
-0.0290697142,
-0.0066174977,
-0.024033688,
-0.0380601585,
-0.024694059,
0.0038853534,
-0.0080041317,
-0.0104293246,
-0.0322801471,
-0.0440369919,
-0.0036597222,
-0.0057556503,
0.046954453,
-0.0283972472,
-0.0101576019,
0.0026275143,
0.0061566499,
-0.0198977944,
-0.0146125071,
0.0339728482,
-0.0111767761,
-0.0002161201,
-0.0244622845,
-0.0134101557,
0.020765204,
-0.0386617035,
0.0457976758,
0.069542259,
0.0101332413,
-0.0477956831,
-0.0592871718,
0.0215859935,
0.0124503756,
0.0026811936,
-0.0139875617,
0.0380576774,
0.0148241771,
-0.060382504,
-0.0085767452,
-0.0201386139,
-0.0474661812,
-0.0201608371,
-0.0424663648,
0.0419061817,
-0.0234591328,
-0.0011914721,
-0.0616976134,
0.030371964,
0.024266988,
0.053688623,
0.0008771053,
-0.043569833,
-0.0649966151,
-0.0076652104,
-0.0122944787,
-0.0990862697,
-0.0110806758,
0.0016279955,
0.045353245,
-0.0728606582,
-0.0226420742,
-0.0379761234,
-0.0208810922,
0.0260611903,
-0.0218168516,
-0.042127911,
0.0384475924,
0.0134765785,
-0.0452130847,
0.0107013294,
0.0100742839,
0.0206877124,
-0.0793304741,
-0.0332170948,
0.0522550344,
0.034771692,
-0.0008308535,
0.009221267,
-0.1059856564,
-0.023083223,
-0.0017722644,
0.0335718691,
0.0123850843,
-0.0104391305,
0.0346153639,
0.0405745581,
0.0159137826,
0.0957688317,
-0.0103914812,
0.0346010476,
0.0142279044,
0.0085880887,
-0.0079355109,
0.027483074,
0.0086588208,
0.061164178,
-0.0374615006,
0.0180617236,
-0.0321756303,
-0.0300735161,
-0.0226862431,
-0.0187207796,
0.0273963623,
0.0204449631,
0.008959746,
0.021260703,
-0.0184757728,
0.0294388477,
0.0700635388,
-0.0675971732,
-0.04446619,
0.0070847333,
0.0054535684,
-0.0377740078,
-0.0187276509,
0.066228658,
-0.066770725,
0.0129813049,
-0.0094030295,
0.0106470296,
0.0009657233,
-0.0402307622,
0.0239500124,
-0.0419889726,
0.0317170694,
-0.0054058419,
0.0128000984,
-0.0248588342,
0.0077403998,
0.0365556888,
0.0056805317,
-0.0697013885,
0.0305698775,
-0.0310172103,
-0.0326771289,
0.0439001881,
-0.0294991191,
0.0062425248,
0.0222577844,
-0.0000718828,
-0.0448031463,
-0.0117795374,
-0.0243171807,
0.0216023326,
-0.0030736148,
0.0190963391,
0.0035734689,
0.0504950993,
0.0173028056,
-0.0566221625,
0.0363336764,
-0.0388726704,
-0.0084284274,
0.0606553108,
-0.0081239175,
0.0015354301,
-0.0065059201,
-0.0853266418,
-0.0074506951,
0.024287805,
-0.018755015,
-0.0310182329,
-0.0220468715,
0.0470051728,
0.0058902786,
0.04948356,
-0.0153767848,
0.0699250251,
0.047079321,
0.0192878749,
-0.0323649868,
0.018554097,
0.0140730133,
0.0182399433,
-0.0232929531,
-0.0271641165,
-5.665430206e-33,
0.0234779865,
-0.0079163127,
0.0449102633,
0.0555866994,
-0.0131558888,
0.0737467855,
-0.0348622613,
-0.0348632969,
-0.050090611,
-0.0085183512,
-0.0180622004,
0.0396166742,
0.0200556163,
0.0504502617,
0.0430438258,
-0.0478682294,
0.0313052274,
-0.0060010948,
0.0412856862,
0.0187805351,
0.047129456,
0.0156505518,
0.0801485181,
-0.041785676,
-0.0045099715,
0.0383449718,
0.0094436621,
-0.0769462436,
0.0244078618,
0.0166039225,
-0.071853742,
0.0855152681,
0.007947932,
-0.0165308584,
0.0172177441,
0.0346147716,
-0.0599801838,
-0.0275302734,
-0.0316323712,
0.0093254801,
-0.0493495129,
-0.0142880976,
0.0521483161,
0.0222052485,
-0.0198904127,
-0.0057946956,
-0.0066863592,
-0.009940614,
-0.0088985628,
-0.0287810527,
-0.0356744714,
0.0182425939,
0.0411556289,
0.0081334822,
0.0110260714,
-0.006987188,
-0.0358133465,
0.0292853732,
-0.1165120527,
0.0137911309,
-0.000714695,
0.0813009366,
-0.0194570385,
0.0219600033,
0.0295023248,
0.0536698066,
0.0778603405,
-0.0135623254,
-0.0080964668,
0.077114895,
0.0603131689,
0.0241319854,
0.041484274,
0.0216469802,
0.1255903095,
-0.0515173934,
-0.0532219671,
-0.0088800192,
0.0717385113,
0.0056073186,
0.0496883877,
0.0036720007,
-0.0444022566,
-0.0454089493,
0.014302738,
0.03797815,
-0.0159835424,
-0.0411940068,
-0.0243691057,
0.0286271498,
-0.0186645705,
0.0219875462,
0.0255178865,
-0.0155962035,
0.017127689,
0.0253849979,
0.0341693796,
0.0258639976,
0.0359092094,
0.00131927,
-0.0493884794,
-0.019734202,
-0.0352967009,
-0.0125375334,
0.0090725869,
0.0125537775,
-0.0198328644,
0.0898933858,
-0.0300238356,
-0.0333115198,
-0.0498763025,
-0.0122633167,
0.0208762586,
0.0364120044,
-0.0107493289,
-0.0108193476,
-0.0023079203,
0.0295049138,
-0.0508895628,
0.0323558897,
0.0019624622,
0.0317914113,
-0.0093599241,
0.0326968506,
0.0045078578,
-0.0025264344,
-0.0488746874,
0.0348728076,
-0.0394395888,
-0.1290879846,
-0.0268517062,
0.0351361968,
2.737e-7,
0.0075004147,
-0.0065858518,
-0.0123781851,
-0.0145333232,
0.0315409154,
0.0374541581,
0.0665677264,
0.027111847,
-0.0093055191,
-0.0510928817,
-0.0155180972,
0.0540017523,
-0.0006472613,
0.0502787158,
-0.0675545409,
-0.057694003,
-0.018584799,
0.0537997782,
0.0157804955,
-0.0119011207,
0.0340046585,
0.0493344069,
0.01546429,
-0.0352407433,
0.0471851304,
-0.0026599898,
0.0508965217,
-0.006801568,
0.0220367685,
-0.0231064223,
-0.056742277,
-0.0066061346,
0.0061361142,
0.0148383025,
0.0070707491,
-0.0374927521,
-0.0213734992,
0.0073290411,
-0.0279751644,
-0.046265725,
0.0059321024,
-0.0188857485,
-0.0264950152,
-0.0027503537,
0.0350295156,
-0.0046086269,
-0.0535696335,
-0.0354635082,
0.0170815606,
-0.0060968017,
0.033289589,
-0.0002458962,
-0.0383411348,
-0.0374957249,
-0.0095814466,
-0.0434425063,
-0.0308491308,
-0.0491780788,
0.0419590063,
-0.008768836,
-0.0182052236,
-0.0109505318,
-0.0884549245,
-0.0001185692,
0.0357513502,
-0.0061025154,
-0.0291593615,
2.414850187e-34,
0.0198490769,
-0.0436020494,
-0.0002493847,
0.0475126877,
-0.0228329618,
0.0302389842,
0.0011820052,
-0.0621722527,
-0.0190848298,
-0.0182232726,
-0.0656490326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17902v1 | Revisiting speech segmentation and lexicon learning with better features | 2024-01-31T15:06:34 | 2024-01-31T15:06:34 | Herman Kamper, Benjamin van Niekerk | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We revisit a self-supervised method that segments unlabelled speech into
word-like segments. We start from the two-stage duration-penalised dynamic
programming method that performs zero-resource segmentation without learning an
explicit lexicon. In the first acoustic unit discovery stage, we replace
contrastive predictive coding features with HuBERT. After word segmentation in
the second stage, we get an acoustic word embedding for each segment by
averaging HuBERT features. These embeddings are clustered using K-means to get
a lexicon. The result is good full-coverage segmentation with a lexicon that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ZeroSpeech benchmarks. | Revisiting speech segmentation and lexicon learning with better features: We revisit a self-supervised method that segments unlabelled speech into
word-like segments. We start from the two-stage duration-penalised dynamic
programming method that performs zero-resource segmentation without learning an
explicit lexicon. In the first acoustic unit discovery stage, we replace
contrastive predictive coding features with HuBERT. After word segmentation in
the second stage, we get an acoustic word embedding for each segment by
averaging HuBERT features. These embeddings are clustered using K-means to get
a lexicon. The result is good full-coverage segmentation with a lexicon that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ZeroSpeech benchmarks. | [
-0.0630198941,
0.0384208895,
0.0297920574,
0.0172675438,
-0.0016959251,
-0.0359596275,
0.0263213869,
-0.013461275,
-0.0794967636,
0.0031379836,
-0.0075741359,
-0.030003095,
0.0142593794,
0.0127684027,
0.0185037646,
-0.0914674178,
0.0094800601,
-0.0390259475,
0.0039080838,
-0.0207674932,
0.0262717623,
-0.0069510639,
-0.0633387044,
-0.0284503736,
-0.0754971877,
0.003211153,
-0.0392521657,
-0.0137227839,
0.001491676,
-0.0371669084,
-0.0225610863,
0.0052421154,
-0.0008815161,
0.0108111864,
0.000001936,
-0.0463669002,
-0.0234052707,
-0.0260241181,
-0.0433099493,
0.0071920645,
0.038533017,
-0.0153399929,
0.0009118501,
-0.0153989056,
0.029166203,
0.0067490884,
0.0080137895,
0.0257801525,
-0.0160077661,
0.0492261238,
-0.0150243286,
-0.0468666553,
0.0140039651,
-0.0004437753,
-0.031068461,
0.0203081071,
-0.0052126846,
-0.0086517408,
0.0004303679,
-0.049201332,
-0.0264241155,
0.0426877812,
0.0053045102,
-0.025431877,
0.0595366172,
0.0524146818,
-0.083116442,
-0.0416987725,
-0.0095049972,
0.0554610305,
0.0007709964,
0.0511796474,
0.0358983912,
-0.0010531996,
-0.0318048932,
-0.047698129,
-0.0095403548,
0.0216212645,
0.0499512181,
-0.0075236699,
-0.011818612,
0.0649455935,
0.0238074288,
-0.0159689616,
-0.0236277916,
0.0366909541,
0.0069788774,
-0.0542332195,
0.0134081328,
-0.0046265852,
-0.024670057,
0.0150963124,
0.0041610827,
-0.0214258302,
0.0456622094,
0.009208547,
0.0099248393,
-0.0177375134,
-0.0291364938,
0.0039549503,
-0.0550398566,
0.0219874773,
-0.0103800101,
0.0179404784,
-0.0076397648,
-0.031712357,
0.0246478729,
0.0036276928,
-0.0527048297,
0.0150304595,
-0.0264718402,
0.0031230911,
-0.0521982647,
0.0251101106,
-0.0126013625,
-0.0148064299,
-0.0365989506,
-0.0057068495,
0.0193935484,
-0.0152015621,
0.0363591388,
-0.0081686974,
-0.0425057299,
0.0140991593,
0.030133374,
-0.0096171144,
-0.0603169799,
0.0185137186,
-0.0004293947,
-0.0071367449,
-0.0180061087,
0.0202388186,
0.0011725537,
-0.0233938862,
-0.0198117364,
0.0351533033,
-0.0134528717,
-0.0347804055,
-0.0406891815,
-0.0510120057,
-0.0658563972,
-0.0154614877,
-0.0151682673,
-0.0714241341,
-0.0115543809,
-0.0299687162,
0.0294145718,
0.0368169248,
-0.0303432699,
-0.0697873384,
0.0385965034,
0.0484417975,
0.0115220752,
0.0213825479,
0.0171934646,
0.0175961088,
0.062506102,
0.0870561227,
0.0453823619,
-0.0131439706,
0.0449432991,
0.0296939593,
-0.0352177583,
0.0515836366,
-0.0085932566,
0.0040841969,
-0.0673764646,
-0.0484616645,
0.0512616411,
0.0360464193,
0.0677006245,
-0.0133464383,
-0.0427801013,
-0.0548406653,
0.0226924885,
0.0944376886,
0.0359918773,
0.030802248,
-0.0241147336,
0.0354015119,
-0.0381792039,
0.0021894304,
0.0595666692,
-0.0542341769,
0.0031296019,
0.0242526848,
0.0721848756,
-0.0139037715,
-0.0403594524,
-0.0254107546,
-0.0159874782,
-0.0439792909,
0.0331030861,
0.0252660532,
0.0715604499,
0.01895082,
-0.0005913971,
0.0772259682,
-0.0097994739,
-0.057828892,
-0.0160053205,
-0.0085031362,
0.0337909125,
0.0148169091,
0.0250597708,
-0.0669829994,
-0.0055055227,
-0.0335459374,
-0.0069415485,
0.0441376567,
-0.014027833,
-0.0315659717,
0.0643888861,
-0.0748220384,
-0.0211842265,
-0.0020404293,
0.0000401911,
-0.0214504898,
-0.0039246413,
0.0336315669,
0.0032323473,
-0.0565654375,
0.074653022,
0.0044149151,
-0.0064076656,
-0.0317218341,
-0.0098173534,
0.0019390895,
0.0640771165,
0.0435400046,
-0.0301672947,
-0.0251803063,
0.0234685037,
-0.034167096,
0.0313922018,
-0.0038283302,
-0.0898141861,
-0.0783735663,
0.037707679,
-0.0397955328,
-0.0049760318,
0.0164511651,
0.0249219052,
-0.0843142346,
0.0363080911,
0.0185462032,
0.0520408377,
-0.0343173072,
0.0146531686,
0.0096430462,
0.0356942713,
0.0287722256,
0.0238390453,
-0.0180261955,
-0.0139475577,
-0.0241103526,
-0.0073936302,
-0.0116176233,
-0.0743807405,
-0.038273856,
0.0117766187,
-0.0266352072,
-0.0096848663,
-0.0207484644,
-0.0230686516,
-0.0197011828,
0.0176991969,
-0.0749698207,
0.0025339769,
-0.0217719413,
-0.0256931689,
-0.0329577066,
0.0315664709,
-0.0181392152,
0.0037497578,
0.0040408,
-0.0364846475,
0.0121896127,
-0.0137882251,
-0.0279094297,
-0.0123537537,
-0.0237364359,
-0.0103968373,
-0.022957541,
0.028105041,
-0.0065597882,
-0.0368189141,
-0.0007079069,
0.0153375138,
0.0348490626,
0.0168172363,
0.0055535962,
0.0088376338,
-0.0153921051,
-0.022326557,
-0.0077115577,
0.0095600635,
0.0450059548,
0.004248579,
-0.0144145014,
-0.0220096242,
-0.0314567573,
0.0213768221,
-0.0074653435,
0.0058355066,
0.0734360293,
0.0046870783,
0.0253907312,
-0.017879704,
0.1004711762,
0.0360169299,
0.0004379515,
-0.0095528569,
-0.1030074283,
-0.03462556,
-0.0522115417,
-0.0246552452,
-0.0003398391,
-0.0308887903,
-0.0010916719,
-0.0069222404,
-0.0247652978,
0.0150059834,
-0.0534831956,
-0.0290257055,
-0.0627713576,
-0.0774482191,
0.0225377325,
-0.0103529636,
-0.0056639118,
-0.0090130018,
-0.0250303019,
-0.0292122457,
-0.0114702769,
-0.0235830396,
0.0167281758,
-0.0071119722,
0.0554799773,
-0.0048098951,
0.0172891542,
0.0068571917,
-0.0081457701,
-0.0252532326,
-0.0085407346,
-0.0037701083,
0.0653985068,
0.0243392456,
-0.0382495113,
0.0075882496,
0.0665103942,
0.0202112328,
0.0640971735,
0.0421559811,
0.0059226584,
0.0073149977,
0.0763436109,
0.0133049637,
0.0325668119,
-0.0382095911,
-0.0042823567,
0.0397045203,
-0.0016297469,
0.1071811318,
-0.0029294498,
-0.0176670309,
0.013165704,
0.0071098274,
-0.0298364963,
-0.0233897492,
0.0024414966,
0.0466099121,
-0.0276343916,
0.0123875756,
0.1063379273,
0.0296277273,
-0.00726107,
0.007908768,
-0.0152051281,
0.0073321736,
0.0229153037,
-0.0577840991,
-0.0115392674,
-0.0221540406,
0.0145418849,
0.0659568831,
0.0212367754,
-0.0163687132,
0.0203625336,
-0.0643631443,
0.0286314599,
0.0179067999,
-0.0362460278,
0.0342037492,
-0.0495175608,
-0.0071194628,
-0.0624434128,
-0.0265968572,
-0.0177681502,
-0.0100207161,
-0.0528631732,
0.0330356769,
-0.0756863579,
0.039615754,
0.0017805988,
-0.0260983054,
0.0333350711,
0.0404457934,
0.0228090063,
-0.0069857482,
0.0141929751,
0.0215316992,
-0.0474759117,
-0.0468876213,
-0.008988806,
0.0158694852,
-0.0241307542,
0.0371997766,
0.0380691439,
0.0442284197,
0.0076822201,
0.0197165329,
0.026240062,
0.0790272206,
-0.0043026931,
0.0694069713,
-0.0214767959,
0.0334755816,
0.0016660552,
0.0711588413,
-0.006947712,
0.0054144915,
-0.018859338,
0.0125824558,
0.0360949785,
-0.0097425813,
-0.0074159019,
-0.0061288592,
-0.0191302933,
-0.0265743397,
-0.0448021181,
-0.014737675,
0.0592543185,
0.0816574693,
-0.0111242076,
0.0091391709,
-0.0191679318,
-0.0008772531,
-0.0873248354,
0.00084247,
-0.0241796914,
-0.0252951756,
-0.0605960675,
-0.0262381379,
0.0424465947,
-0.0363270082,
-0.0014584865,
0.0171413962,
0.0013653255,
-0.0613400564,
0.0162165798,
-0.0105539095,
0.0077003795,
0.0851839185,
-0.036483895,
0.0069589433,
0.1489794701,
-0.0198112018,
-0.0431663692,
0.0120421667,
0.0697955489,
0.0581300333,
-0.0066541992,
0.0293394011,
-0.0360853374,
0.0296300333,
-0.0235058907,
-0.0083333952,
-0.0728989467,
-0.0226421114,
-0.0635145083,
-0.0018400946,
0.0715341717,
-0.0109391352,
0.0504322648,
-0.049600035,
0.0233382825,
0.0244167075,
0.0567150675,
-0.0177553631,
0.0331319571,
0.020907741,
-0.0041259541,
-0.0187827777,
0.0606350675,
-0.0384750739,
-0.0297759548,
-0.0001825134,
0.0660009012,
0.0479620472,
-0.0151511738,
-0.0123708835,
0.017230913,
0.0384713896,
0.0153340138,
0.0081131691,
0.0100638987,
0.0341767371,
0.0083969347,
-0.0020909389,
0.0345737673,
-0.0332229175,
0.0002757877,
0.0021264751,
0.0240459088,
-0.0190750323,
0.0312442593,
-0.0287591424,
-0.0794085562,
-0.0084611485,
-0.0020916753,
-0.0003269857,
-0.0088562332,
-0.0029119924,
-0.0505730174,
-0.0169662964,
0.0018360151,
0.0395287648,
-0.0374688804,
0.0536694638,
0.057409551,
-0.0259271339,
0.0138479341,
0.0066421349,
0.0406873636,
-0.0562291183,
0.009325834,
0.0284424126,
0.0313872099,
-0.0195882842,
0.0189509541,
0.0102485791,
-0.0521258041,
0.04590258,
-0.0482306406,
0.0230476912,
-0.0009584852,
0.0729202628,
0.000422834,
-0.0202548765,
0.0186389722,
0.0292314608,
-0.0376441367,
0.0194665175,
-0.042284742,
0.0623053648,
-6.646978274e-33,
0.0029704205,
0.0030133438,
-0.0203524772,
-0.0280196443,
-0.0183596611,
0.0460137762,
0.0236908384,
0.0193888489,
0.0462267697,
-0.0037243969,
-0.0217656568,
0.0290726572,
0.031145202,
0.0685413927,
0.0200508106,
-0.0234896131,
0.0936707631,
-0.0338995792,
-0.0558439307,
-0.0050693201,
0.0337035134,
0.0584176071,
0.0244890247,
0.015468535,
-0.0354676098,
-0.0023087848,
0.0273971185,
0.0165827442,
0.0740813836,
0.0195014905,
-0.0334781297,
0.0380759649,
0.0055229142,
-0.0398836657,
-0.0255966168,
0.0081602614,
-0.081774272,
-0.004930845,
-0.019806223,
0.007132709,
-0.0189698283,
0.0272796191,
0.0295643937,
0.0395117067,
0.00664319,
-0.0273795314,
0.0316391215,
-0.0377960727,
-0.0674736202,
-0.0303477421,
-0.0180201009,
0.0531861186,
-0.0310965925,
-0.0456564389,
0.1128210276,
-0.0452040769,
0.0031226818,
-0.0484963804,
-0.0602633692,
0.0384077244,
0.0046676518,
0.0408613421,
0.0415821448,
0.0338424034,
0.018307969,
0.0199093688,
0.045275379,
-0.0643041059,
0.0554662533,
0.0183777809,
-0.0197502952,
-0.0045105284,
-0.0118379779,
-0.046201922,
0.0162602365,
-0.0425920822,
0.0128173102,
-0.0226801056,
0.017860705,
-0.0185693931,
0.0185209177,
0.0683759674,
-0.0545208007,
0.0084275762,
0.0032267966,
-0.0379045568,
0.0100033991,
0.0160674434,
0.0163343363,
0.0297492538,
-0.0230009351,
-0.0007668954,
0.0448072627,
-0.0035577626,
0.0549458303,
0.00484373,
-0.006187818,
0.0092425011,
-0.0041999677,
-0.0113147153,
-0.059641771,
-0.0082011195,
0.0289153121,
0.035010267,
-0.0215658639,
-0.0129381735,
-0.030312879,
0.0328240991,
-0.0017718608,
-0.0085717645,
0.0266338214,
0.0263372809,
-0.0453081988,
0.041780334,
0.058806289,
-0.0197273698,
0.0148672471,
0.0556994937,
-0.0038144533,
-0.0189417116,
0.012373969,
-0.0011065581,
-0.0213300586,
0.0301412418,
-0.0487247147,
0.0012987056,
0.0150560737,
-0.0474780127,
0.0438226722,
-0.0538885221,
-0.0018752147,
0.0114373751,
2.806e-7,
-0.0549751967,
-0.0101932958,
0.0375736095,
-0.0775327161,
0.0119346231,
0.0138118835,
0.0217011105,
-0.0180736482,
-0.0932968408,
-0.0362667926,
0.0208849907,
0.0288364496,
0.0856817737,
0.0270833336,
-0.0940195695,
0.0094556194,
-0.0049080439,
0.0293196291,
-0.0548316985,
-0.0202684365,
-0.0329828598,
0.0805670992,
0.0159987174,
-0.0165929142,
0.0156919844,
-0.0344633833,
-0.0524755828,
0.0150347855,
-0.0140512967,
-0.0471537225,
0.0324992724,
0.0495273806,
-0.003118417,
-0.0328801461,
-0.0024801928,
0.0482615456,
0.0471543372,
0.0475050285,
0.0063067032,
-0.0695199221,
0.0337106884,
0.0172479451,
-0.0373508185,
0.0619768389,
0.0515268408,
0.0144998711,
0.0003304762,
0.0077157211,
0.0225413255,
0.0110418992,
0.0438187234,
-0.0138300601,
0.0366382264,
0.0315051265,
0.0072010672,
-0.0039857822,
-0.0129718697,
-0.0393974856,
0.0419430919,
0.0253197122,
-0.0651084185,
-0.0118163014,
-0.0245129596,
0.031288337,
0.0118500553,
0.0023544459,
-0.0199469924,
2.304995878e-34,
0.0326207131,
-0.0129484823,
-0.0409781449,
0.0107139386,
-0.0026073207,
-0.0417674445,
-0.039213825,
-0.041831255,
0.0132712796,
-0.0217414144,
-0.0353270583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17897v1 | Employing Label Models on ChatGPT Answers Improves Legal Text Entailment Performance | 2024-01-31T15:04:01 | 2024-01-31T15:04:01 | Chau Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The objective of legal text entailment is to ascertain whether the assertions
in a legal query logically follow from the information provided in one or
multiple legal articles. ChatGPT, a large language model, is robust in many
natural language processing tasks, including legal text entailment: when we set
the temperature = 0 (the ChatGPT answers are deterministic) and prompt the
model, it achieves 70.64% accuracy on COLIEE 2022 dataset, which outperforms
the previous SOTA of 67.89%. On the other hand, if the temperature is larger
than zero, ChatGPT answers are not deterministic, leading to inconsistent
answers and fluctuating results. We propose to leverage label models (a
fundamental component of weak supervision techniques) to integrate the
provisional answers by ChatGPT into consolidated labels. By that way, we treat
ChatGPT provisional answers as noisy predictions which can be consolidated by
label models. The experimental results demonstrate that this approach can
attain an accuracy of 76.15%, marking a significant improvement of 8.26% over
the prior state-of-the-art benchmark. Additionally, we perform an analysis of
the instances where ChatGPT produces incorrect answers, then we classify the
errors, offering insights that could guide potential enhancements for future
research endeavors. | Employing Label Models on ChatGPT Answers Improves Legal Text Entailment Performance: The objective of legal text entailment is to ascertain whether the assertions
in a legal query logically follow from the information provided in one or
multiple legal articles. ChatGPT, a large language model, is robust in many
natural language processing tasks, including legal text entailment: when we set
the temperature = 0 (the ChatGPT answers are deterministic) and prompt the
model, it achieves 70.64% accuracy on COLIEE 2022 dataset, which outperforms
the previous SOTA of 67.89%. On the other hand, if the temperature is larger
than zero, ChatGPT answers are not deterministic, leading to inconsistent
answers and fluctuating results. We propose to leverage label models (a
fundamental component of weak supervision techniques) to integrate the
provisional answers by ChatGPT into consolidated labels. By that way, we treat
ChatGPT provisional answers as noisy predictions which can be consolidated by
label models. The experimental results demonstrate that this approach can
attain an accuracy of 76.15%, marking a significant improvement of 8.26% over
the prior state-of-the-art benchmark. Additionally, we perform an analysis of
the instances where ChatGPT produces incorrect answers, then we classify the
errors, offering insights that could guide potential enhancements for future
research endeavors. | [
0.0641153008,
0.0304525141,
0.0065731718,
0.0165486448,
-0.0698179975,
0.0412142016,
0.0038599323,
0.0198243205,
0.0837035924,
-0.0653572157,
-0.0065971813,
-0.0014873034,
-0.0296561792,
0.0002538086,
-0.017744381,
-0.02504085,
0.0565650575,
-0.0094541255,
0.0756235421,
-0.0168392807,
0.0380848981,
0.0100706788,
0.0216873102,
0.0112690236,
-0.0496229902,
-0.0167031568,
-0.00037948,
-0.006108847,
-0.0003724461,
0.0025278665,
0.039455086,
0.0842822418,
-0.0008479945,
0.0344260707,
0.0000018822,
-0.0492066778,
-0.0003977211,
0.0101938527,
-0.0010498661,
0.0038369577,
0.006213577,
-0.0102493335,
-0.0009170371,
0.010497042,
-0.0268985573,
0.0225868206,
0.0221437849,
0.059113808,
0.0578412749,
0.0629830211,
-0.0047629494,
-0.0212538149,
0.0510812849,
-0.02924354,
0.0567275062,
-0.0674839094,
0.0458860286,
0.0242450349,
0.0305400547,
0.0010969957,
0.0159757249,
0.0398063548,
0.0511899181,
-0.0114394706,
-0.0490380414,
0.0181165524,
-0.0603398457,
0.0047277687,
0.0032521673,
0.0327908546,
0.0208937265,
-0.0624921955,
0.0035229179,
0.0058112587,
0.0438775532,
0.0188936815,
-0.0256058369,
0.0551561713,
-0.0310769454,
0.0008973216,
0.0296582896,
0.0279175341,
-0.0072195157,
0.035025157,
0.0127065713,
0.1171000972,
0.0067382366,
-0.0654778704,
0.0210405868,
0.0301356632,
-0.0417211801,
-0.05948551,
0.0285993461,
0.0270848833,
-0.0164298099,
0.0242169611,
-0.0693916976,
-0.0295798648,
0.0461180471,
-0.0639006048,
-0.0646271929,
0.0036585138,
-0.0400778055,
0.1004936323,
-0.0488265678,
0.0317195691,
0.0267424397,
0.0388297178,
-0.0188443717,
-0.075087063,
-0.0275103543,
-0.0342417061,
-0.0390187763,
0.0483122058,
-0.0472053848,
0.0037462283,
-0.0135753369,
0.0015775019,
-0.0228893608,
0.0146262543,
-0.0034666078,
0.006724725,
-0.0165550355,
-0.0231462065,
-0.0392625518,
-0.031368278,
-0.0403424576,
0.0474693961,
0.007691314,
-0.0257457085,
0.0063372552,
0.0009141796,
0.0009140886,
-0.007190269,
0.0372816958,
0.0989192873,
-0.0165954493,
-0.00188132,
-0.0306327511,
-0.0744002163,
-0.0493871011,
-0.0779587626,
-0.0349902995,
-0.0617714673,
0.0175873395,
-0.0120189209,
-0.0118050883,
-0.0333325826,
0.0231318083,
0.0725703612,
-0.048463162,
0.0731470063,
0.0108071063,
-0.0144875422,
-0.0139753586,
0.038184952,
0.0039006723,
0.0204015262,
0.0083223507,
0.0308337156,
0.0336122103,
0.0242801048,
0.0420334786,
0.0237241294,
0.0273153894,
0.0277249627,
0.0156275108,
0.0196993537,
0.0287447926,
-0.01217971,
-0.0403802581,
0.0649292395,
-0.0027761115,
-0.0334013551,
0.0417322367,
0.0234052669,
-0.0239454042,
-0.0127968471,
-0.0092818765,
-0.0082934005,
0.0394335799,
0.006439629,
-0.0763154998,
0.0349525213,
-0.0797637403,
0.0049058008,
-0.0300079212,
0.0154569885,
-0.0226568822,
-0.0561706983,
-0.0135629782,
0.0065169381,
-0.0133578656,
0.0030325362,
0.0268801022,
0.0155571466,
-0.0174237434,
0.0067971507,
0.0436267741,
-0.0355160907,
-0.0279784463,
-0.0313578025,
0.029061133,
0.0323661119,
0.0418737307,
-0.0189000852,
-0.0450159721,
-0.0058247503,
0.0392773785,
0.0354055017,
0.0245444942,
0.0014571983,
-0.0325695463,
-0.0168126058,
-0.0332490914,
0.0316647477,
0.0501763709,
0.0143528022,
0.0326714776,
0.0143539784,
0.0402448922,
-0.0594444983,
-0.0032209873,
0.0354479328,
0.0132624423,
-0.031797424,
0.0051111062,
-0.0125708785,
0.037041802,
-0.0030495091,
0.0044010757,
0.0001571397,
0.0199987553,
0.0103121605,
-0.0670692399,
0.0007316279,
-0.0255518463,
-0.0400067866,
0.0217280407,
-0.0416039862,
-0.0373417735,
-0.02332481,
-0.0555155836,
-0.0453514047,
-0.0538470596,
-0.0302741062,
-0.0255471747,
-0.0662832558,
-0.0514533855,
0.0159506183,
-0.0392593481,
-0.0442262925,
0.0678929463,
0.0178769995,
0.0045035728,
0.0053306501,
0.008633581,
0.0221677646,
0.0071809436,
-0.0260023568,
-0.0326643325,
-0.0278702807,
0.0180616248,
0.0425079577,
0.0473836474,
-0.0276877005,
-0.0507204533,
-0.0928095281,
0.0094204303,
-0.022584321,
-0.0098142382,
0.0092384089,
-0.0289923269,
-0.0119273541,
-0.0217237808,
-0.0502991416,
-0.0352526233,
0.0146191856,
0.0202109721,
-0.0000998381,
-0.0403655618,
0.0015365963,
-0.0051902412,
-0.0070310533,
-0.0397510976,
0.008888552,
0.0219150707,
-0.0547114238,
-0.0221020505,
0.027213132,
-0.03404532,
0.0050948695,
-0.0180260018,
0.008743884,
-0.0074863047,
0.0124722514,
-0.0004150337,
0.0116751436,
0.007170408,
-0.0239062794,
0.0252218936,
-0.007233182,
-0.045496881,
0.0050379648,
-0.0217477605,
-0.011688685,
0.0216610581,
-0.0106770238,
-0.0100966217,
0.0355331339,
0.0022793061,
-0.0082115009,
-0.0590579845,
-0.0008315296,
-0.0223813541,
-0.002856164,
-0.0531001464,
-0.0046311873,
-0.0165323224,
0.0302433968,
-0.0022000631,
-0.0667669028,
0.0878602266,
0.0006671596,
0.0277745612,
-0.0689393207,
-0.0216798838,
-0.030615041,
0.0723444298,
0.0270326994,
0.0084501375,
0.0365563333,
-0.027382046,
-0.0245402362,
-0.0174846798,
0.0568684191,
-0.0337101407,
0.0431319885,
-0.0507209562,
0.0408302248,
-0.0059052315,
-0.0282694139,
-0.0488916151,
-0.0664508715,
-0.0096360398,
0.0261593256,
-0.0359660685,
-0.000724064,
-0.0279984195,
0.0012741069,
-0.0046038376,
0.0307261776,
-0.0165506583,
-0.0053299847,
-0.0478426479,
0.020030098,
0.0708836839,
-0.0164681319,
-0.0308598597,
-0.0183639731,
-0.0199896079,
0.0520461835,
-0.0139116039,
0.0022150069,
0.030603813,
-0.0016445324,
-0.0179113653,
-0.0123962136,
-0.0040794685,
0.0382554755,
0.0056741326,
-0.0625591651,
-0.000858013,
0.0988706276,
0.0298215039,
-0.0008121861,
-0.019043386,
0.0219131876,
0.0640842095,
0.0293098781,
0.0195268709,
-0.1033632681,
-0.0454402752,
0.0061184075,
0.0106361657,
-0.0256625358,
-0.0166182984,
-0.0183257665,
-0.0729043409,
0.0623828657,
0.0108090509,
-0.0479662381,
-0.0188339949,
-0.0346225426,
0.0106494026,
-0.0102961101,
0.0145638594,
-0.0049585626,
0.0081556132,
0.0096864859,
0.02185422,
-0.0411645919,
0.0146230506,
0.0473158024,
-0.0358949006,
0.0518089645,
0.0361669995,
0.0045702015,
-0.0195172057,
-0.0240419973,
0.0575578883,
-0.0001862105,
-0.0200169496,
-0.0110683581,
0.0365006365,
0.0027564999,
0.0129068866,
-0.0494068116,
0.0544625595,
-0.0294732545,
-0.0231545251,
0.0510518216,
0.0988172442,
-0.0286036544,
-0.0343872495,
-0.0448726825,
-0.0070728203,
-0.0129449815,
0.0816660747,
0.0044504921,
-0.0007101083,
-0.0620939657,
-0.0405276157,
-0.0355894752,
0.0051893773,
-0.0313057862,
-0.0038413093,
-0.0219613723,
-0.0143821714,
-0.050258249,
-0.0245854054,
0.0240641311,
0.0178298429,
0.0020531225,
0.0186760202,
0.0380417146,
-0.0031428679,
-0.0203344785,
0.0094791939,
-0.0696035475,
0.0104367351,
-0.0113250632,
0.0305856243,
0.0258682817,
0.0022389735,
-0.0280037355,
0.0231648125,
-0.0497944094,
-0.0216357429,
0.0032896947,
-0.0118781682,
0.0212282687,
0.0184721444,
-0.0777757466,
-0.0111721447,
0.0268549658,
0.0961479321,
-0.0199027695,
0.0158549659,
0.0442280956,
-0.0256036855,
-0.0071402709,
0.023474412,
-0.0291953757,
0.0378766879,
0.0220916849,
0.0279972032,
-0.0138410348,
-0.0254752059,
0.0572732836,
0.0416810922,
0.0323891938,
0.029634444,
-0.0012625948,
-0.016822448,
0.0166300721,
0.0012623139,
-0.0438313596,
-0.0129923588,
0.0184880029,
0.0163005535,
-0.0003605497,
-0.0378960706,
0.0380345061,
0.0001324028,
0.0379804522,
-0.0329681933,
-0.0296823904,
0.0346867032,
0.0049578673,
-0.0082297074,
-0.0519169122,
-0.009113458,
0.0407354087,
-0.0003776909,
0.0461912602,
-0.0117906453,
0.0374145284,
0.039386265,
-0.0216849074,
0.0100259408,
-0.0208846014,
-0.0913642198,
-0.0035760691,
-0.0324172564,
0.0868958309,
0.0272446219,
0.0120109981,
0.006424577,
-0.0477454923,
-0.01812586,
-0.0134031344,
0.0212585218,
0.0320456848,
-0.0193750393,
0.054839503,
0.006264104,
-0.0335851535,
0.0220077075,
0.0370610654,
0.015243087,
0.0574543774,
0.0218680426,
-0.0330469683,
-0.014713875,
-0.0312142093,
-0.0227201562,
-0.0082156202,
-0.0236765798,
-0.015830731,
-0.0530880801,
-0.0289134029,
-0.0122463377,
0.0202830452,
-0.0023939637,
0.0347151458,
0.021663161,
0.0489347503,
0.0228970814,
-0.0520403497,
-0.0104237283,
0.0157214087,
-0.0049955109,
-0.0289576296,
-0.0043451888,
-6.321929842e-33,
-0.0391194262,
-0.0564745851,
-0.0015060727,
0.0263208859,
0.0139758596,
-0.0172512978,
-0.012465545,
0.0012152029,
-0.0123860985,
0.0363596268,
0.0060626911,
0.0412184298,
0.0231973976,
0.0110888965,
0.0341589488,
-0.0805017799,
-0.0090540871,
0.0203717165,
0.0115697635,
0.0311171059,
0.0298153311,
-0.003926768,
0.0311243143,
-0.1117187887,
0.0515075289,
0.0070523242,
-0.0358418003,
-0.0049636178,
-0.0938756466,
0.0503260754,
-0.0073757372,
0.0400094241,
0.0241282638,
-0.0112827923,
0.0039163851,
0.053287968,
-0.0968655869,
-0.0359909683,
0.0144613106,
-0.0209148936,
-0.0152844926,
-0.0087347571,
0.0200834554,
-0.0021782601,
0.007387341,
0.004309129,
0.0549073704,
-0.030848749,
-0.0264980886,
-0.0675502419,
-0.0667851046,
0.0567567311,
0.0188740846,
0.0122742439,
-0.0140602635,
0.0410636589,
0.016666444,
0.013917366,
-0.0433996506,
-0.0100755133,
0.0081224255,
0.009717755,
0.0240296293,
-0.0531589985,
-0.0291329119,
0.0428095572,
-0.026046196,
-0.0092282323,
-0.0539888553,
-0.0268600751,
0.0143227372,
0.0768315196,
0.0888297781,
0.0403223932,
0.044249244,
0.0320217833,
-0.0843177289,
0.0009214121,
0.0261138398,
0.0174529813,
0.0056632156,
-0.0250177961,
-0.0672997311,
-0.0326118991,
-0.0279124547,
0.0210170541,
-0.0329146087,
0.0068284729,
0.0419337116,
0.0056764325,
0.0151504036,
-0.0274578743,
-0.0219666474,
-0.0514676459,
-0.0004412881,
0.0052487766,
-0.0148505606,
0.0012436716,
-0.0071310871,
0.0771421865,
-0.0677932352,
-0.0228811409,
0.0343828835,
-0.0058642169,
-0.0179954246,
-0.0104409438,
0.0912412107,
-0.0013550711,
-0.0635510981,
-0.0104016252,
0.0083710812,
0.0353740528,
-0.0019666944,
-0.0388245098,
0.0328129828,
0.0259924065,
0.0217721201,
0.0241516065,
0.0173372906,
0.0157928839,
-0.0499096625,
-0.0037886773,
-0.0143845528,
-0.0220334586,
0.0040052887,
0.0257145632,
-0.0049603959,
-0.0015913513,
-0.0017761097,
-0.0140439393,
0.0287763029,
0.0662664622,
2.647e-7,
0.0537149124,
0.0364345126,
-0.0127757881,
0.003612919,
-0.0176762715,
0.0510321893,
-0.0032363199,
0.037915051,
0.0193154942,
-0.0610614233,
0.0112235239,
-0.006616971,
0.0699024349,
0.0661242828,
-0.0599156395,
-0.0472606793,
-0.0622023605,
-0.0535147972,
-0.0432201587,
0.0320047699,
0.0954465419,
0.0941988975,
0.055417262,
-0.0228672437,
-0.0104950406,
-0.0390449315,
0.0524431132,
0.0110233687,
-0.0166199971,
-0.0130175501,
0.0704624653,
-0.0115129752,
0.0318123922,
0.0798091143,
-0.001006023,
0.0165529568,
0.0147474296,
0.0467663221,
0.0028149532,
0.0191149823,
-0.0440066494,
-0.0280647632,
0.0144109074,
-0.0280407257,
0.1029714793,
-0.0345479026,
0.0086299283,
-0.0217818972,
-0.0189604592,
-0.0263005663,
0.0103812199,
0.0189458076,
-0.0192147922,
-0.018379638,
0.0295199621,
-0.004251081,
-0.010816073,
-0.0879953653,
-0.0125555266,
0.0217547752,
-0.0243496206,
-0.0048886011,
-0.0142869139,
0.0478534587,
0.0558605269,
-0.0971858948,
0.0036813533,
2.5398259e-34,
0.0401031412,
-0.0130482949,
0.0071516456,
-0.0007712617,
0.0164239239,
0.0482888483,
-0.0012476597,
0.0112559823,
-0.0132876607,
-0.0665881261,
0.0053837229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01766v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01766v2 | LLM Voting: Human Choices and AI Collective Decision Making | 2024-01-31T14:52:02 | 2024-05-15T14:50:37 | Joshua C. Yang, Damian Dailisan, Marcin Korecki, Carina I. Hausladen, Dirk Helbing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC, 68T05, 91B14, 91C20, I.2.7; J.4; K.4.1 | This paper investigates the voting behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, their biases, and how they align with human
voting patterns. Our methodology involved using a dataset from a human voting
experiment to establish a baseline for human preferences and a corresponding
experiment with LLM agents. We observed that the methods used for voting input
and the presentation of choices influence LLM voting behavior. We discovered
that varying the persona can reduce some of these biases and enhance alignment
with human choices. While the Chain-of-Thought approach did not improve
prediction accuracy, it has potential for AI explainability in the voting
process. We also identified a trade-off between preference diversity and
alignment accuracy in LLMs, influenced by different temperature settings. Our
findings indicate that LLMs may lead to less diverse collective outcomes and
biased assumptions when used in voting scenarios, emphasizing the importance of
cautious integration of LLMs into democratic processes. | LLM Voting: Human Choices and AI Collective Decision Making: This paper investigates the voting behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, their biases, and how they align with human
voting patterns. Our methodology involved using a dataset from a human voting
experiment to establish a baseline for human preferences and a corresponding
experiment with LLM agents. We observed that the methods used for voting input
and the presentation of choices influence LLM voting behavior. We discovered
that varying the persona can reduce some of these biases and enhance alignment
with human choices. While the Chain-of-Thought approach did not improve
prediction accuracy, it has potential for AI explainability in the voting
process. We also identified a trade-off between preference diversity and
alignment accuracy in LLMs, influenced by different temperature settings. Our
findings indicate that LLMs may lead to less diverse collective outcomes and
biased assumptions when used in voting scenarios, emphasizing the importance of
cautious integration of LLMs into democratic processes. | [
0.0338824131,
0.0580448769,
-0.0283286255,
0.0209925491,
-0.0324245691,
0.0130737526,
-0.0154235242,
-0.0047234176,
0.0367869399,
0.0023505902,
-0.0076722102,
-0.0372698046,
0.0220351033,
0.0075288047,
0.0271764044,
-0.0781034082,
0.0019492272,
-0.0318967588,
0.0448404104,
-0.0437172167,
0.0168603286,
0.0246325787,
0.0217412189,
0.0396795198,
0.0129838455,
0.0193995833,
-0.0253363177,
-0.0256597418,
0.0366820246,
-0.0258688144,
-0.0257039275,
0.0196646284,
0.0119227329,
-0.0018627527,
0.0000022571,
-0.0335478783,
0.0209914334,
-0.0134429187,
-0.0180473179,
0.0090950858,
0.0444074981,
0.0754112229,
0.0017286591,
0.0255459901,
-0.0565191768,
0.0166977718,
0.0531128906,
-0.0027748696,
0.0256796293,
0.0267174654,
-0.0030308159,
-0.0169615354,
-0.002484485,
-0.0186484102,
-0.0323075876,
-0.0245366916,
0.0035912141,
-0.0685246885,
0.0084889568,
0.0118813263,
0.0134975035,
-0.0126145259,
-0.0026994485,
0.0032785165,
-0.014136361,
0.0392493047,
-0.0031682409,
-0.0312938131,
0.0185270105,
0.0720340237,
0.0430297293,
-0.0297989082,
-0.0178096835,
-0.0197387487,
0.0198877882,
0.0206927974,
-0.0286971871,
0.0172945652,
0.0107485689,
0.0514229871,
0.0231422,
0.0199088063,
0.0201862995,
0.0407414101,
-0.0402614698,
0.1430179477,
-0.0026141282,
0.0099529214,
-0.0218476504,
0.0249516852,
0.0080182683,
-0.078826867,
-0.0010009095,
0.0127639798,
-0.0593069308,
0.0331130661,
-0.0048384788,
0.061350435,
0.0248296373,
-0.0629000887,
0.0466949232,
0.0410102084,
0.0238007624,
0.0348132439,
0.0561354607,
0.0556505397,
-0.0289671011,
0.0452795029,
-0.032368619,
-0.0249939281,
-0.0109700393,
-0.0120216161,
0.0367335603,
0.0099474099,
0.001683405,
0.029713897,
-0.035529878,
0.024420321,
-0.0429588072,
0.0328217484,
0.0027986034,
0.0046880436,
0.0118242698,
-0.0318346694,
-0.1027650684,
0.0784737617,
-0.075800553,
0.054562062,
0.024819335,
-0.0345173217,
0.0220371913,
0.00466889,
-0.004380337,
-0.0089719528,
0.0055298493,
0.0681384504,
0.0114989858,
0.0085645001,
0.0157909859,
0.0038665889,
0.0120018404,
-0.0911546275,
-0.0384306386,
-0.0624318086,
0.0354782008,
0.0227769725,
0.0241112728,
-0.0299574304,
-0.0046852906,
0.0160135273,
-0.0122945877,
0.0685139522,
-0.0075471848,
0.0503296554,
0.0346160531,
0.0097557921,
-0.011460674,
0.0487555787,
0.062032003,
0.065246135,
0.0270499624,
-0.0385517925,
0.046705693,
0.0307060722,
-0.0367456675,
0.0349140093,
-0.0333756879,
0.0313280337,
-0.0416005924,
-0.0003076943,
0.0194299892,
0.0707541704,
-0.0067232973,
-0.0031373925,
0.1110709682,
0.0772354007,
-0.0514381267,
-0.0137241883,
-0.0156419836,
0.0196606349,
-0.0002009633,
0.0239437222,
-0.0517016128,
0.0572394021,
-0.0149289863,
-0.0166081619,
0.0218606852,
0.0352435708,
-0.0436334498,
-0.0315614976,
0.0002570402,
-0.0226557758,
0.0374821983,
0.0367592014,
0.0141444858,
-0.0508358441,
-0.015140933,
-0.0027845821,
0.0437918864,
-0.0490284674,
-0.0287520736,
-0.0634169057,
0.0435365513,
0.0746137127,
0.0185559895,
0.007180714,
-0.0036797407,
-0.0222725086,
-0.021467397,
0.0462168977,
0.0641792044,
-0.0248831362,
-0.0447103269,
-0.0482459776,
-0.0167974252,
0.0403785408,
-0.0058908383,
0.0832735747,
-0.0182896405,
-0.0043741637,
-0.0394840688,
0.0016134206,
-0.0094743269,
0.0021098501,
-0.0095308078,
-0.0055758432,
-0.0402558781,
0.0140613345,
0.0801828951,
0.0047653038,
0.0104629733,
-0.0023022373,
0.0171958115,
-0.0040248432,
-0.0351003259,
0.0122069558,
-0.0380009599,
0.0624999106,
0.0192551725,
-0.0088256383,
-0.0058138934,
0.0250864699,
-0.0133491857,
-0.0280667357,
0.0543402024,
-0.0052382583,
-0.0069981529,
-0.0093602138,
0.0180630088,
-0.0499019288,
-0.0223242883,
-0.0578823425,
0.0652135611,
-0.005647663,
-0.0210399665,
-0.0112301372,
-0.0114319241,
0.0122354189,
-0.0267340858,
-0.0049933665,
0.0769562721,
0.0446977913,
0.0256671384,
0.0544129349,
-0.0364769585,
-0.0197946187,
-0.0473441109,
-0.0668715686,
-0.0280595142,
-0.0092364755,
0.0132678319,
0.0116277114,
-0.0203114133,
-0.0069880914,
0.0229328256,
-0.0526361428,
-0.0016036086,
-0.0200140309,
0.0051725777,
0.0340090655,
-0.0074177692,
-0.0282246154,
-0.0522729531,
0.0013449623,
-0.0200103428,
0.0162398871,
0.0086798649,
0.000854192,
-0.0351946726,
0.0142050218,
-0.0531792454,
-0.0315411501,
-0.0449982584,
-0.0369096622,
0.0409254134,
0.0007444071,
0.0259076599,
0.0326827317,
0.021684723,
0.0446448103,
0.0860595778,
0.0304049421,
-0.0941004679,
-0.022151459,
-0.0299174804,
0.014844982,
-0.0495551936,
-0.0411840826,
-0.0041475031,
0.0534477755,
0.0142037328,
0.0162321832,
-0.032128945,
0.0687349066,
-0.0250277705,
-0.0361233801,
-0.0026340536,
-0.0566957518,
-0.0320635699,
0.079440929,
0.0089783547,
-0.0718703344,
0.0725846142,
-0.012304144,
0.0307193417,
-0.0321834385,
-0.001771589,
-0.0338806659,
0.0521389134,
0.0051056738,
0.0046338174,
-0.0266278796,
0.0039443276,
-0.072474204,
-0.0645695254,
0.0388831496,
-0.056071911,
0.0787858441,
-0.0455637202,
0.0040121512,
-0.0042152735,
-0.0433538333,
-0.0150388619,
-0.0315375775,
-0.0504484773,
0.0112053016,
0.0550560094,
-0.0458385609,
-0.010000159,
-0.0098636905,
0.0466987453,
-0.0347875133,
0.0031762312,
0.0141340243,
0.0057073319,
-0.024349317,
0.033743795,
0.0413116477,
0.0248536337,
-0.0324457213,
0.0028854273,
0.0163768101,
0.0564925671,
-0.0054375445,
-0.0397397541,
-0.0399083607,
0.044617407,
-0.0095505314,
-0.0262243655,
0.0153670348,
0.0414203368,
-0.024585953,
0.0673955157,
0.0700866729,
0.0243762359,
-0.0799124911,
0.0028632351,
-0.0128981853,
0.0550818108,
0.0337718129,
0.0101820873,
-0.0458020754,
0.0136838127,
0.0192683004,
0.0150497491,
-0.0372299775,
-0.0109332688,
-0.0031271982,
-0.1031645387,
0.0226848517,
0.0038587295,
-0.002894514,
0.0041558854,
-0.0641466007,
0.0255002324,
-0.024441395,
0.0148276128,
-0.004449015,
0.0363049321,
0.0093024578,
0.014212165,
-0.0478972569,
-0.0258091837,
0.0165377259,
-0.0375796966,
0.0848385394,
0.0996720344,
0.0849162787,
-0.0349972472,
-0.0341585167,
0.0031994863,
-0.0138664907,
-0.0149543537,
0.0117519516,
0.0167192817,
0.0035419075,
0.0061537833,
-0.0485368371,
0.0129895108,
0.0189907122,
0.0223127436,
0.0215838049,
0.0554589517,
-0.033230003,
-0.0358493999,
0.0138753848,
-0.0261526387,
0.0163329802,
0.0523754433,
0.0260579921,
-0.0513149537,
-0.0258947965,
-0.0567798577,
-0.008757689,
0.0006488766,
-0.0530300923,
-0.0353089832,
-0.0006242197,
0.0079283174,
-0.0310168713,
-0.0553055853,
-0.0052197045,
0.0154929683,
0.0252447203,
0.0405161232,
0.0465465784,
-0.0066865594,
0.0374937057,
0.0099312244,
-0.0104376283,
0.0354793333,
-0.023048535,
-0.0615546107,
0.0072600977,
-0.0209913645,
0.0097566266,
-0.0059141237,
0.0083443252,
-0.0655228347,
0.0161948744,
0.033798296,
0.0354000293,
0.0138974879,
0.0159763601,
-0.0822241604,
0.0406342484,
0.0043402039,
0.0048085069,
0.0195961595,
-0.002668936,
0.0481311344,
0.0020452882,
0.0463492125,
0.0077952123,
0.0227915794,
0.0308910795,
-0.0213534515,
-0.0574519932,
-0.0384883322,
0.0304235145,
0.0181891527,
-0.0189322829,
-0.0433244035,
-0.0009696169,
-0.0176475085,
-0.0134432558,
-0.0308017414,
-0.0132310204,
-0.0143165467,
-0.0451364927,
0.0508876629,
-0.013882108,
0.0014222466,
-0.0184502359,
-0.0246588457,
0.0146271698,
0.0129650226,
0.0707302243,
-0.0028628393,
0.0752492696,
0.0296129584,
0.0222877227,
-0.0039783553,
0.0161125306,
-0.0203581527,
0.0399231128,
0.0200658273,
0.0391040556,
0.0022110632,
-0.0393983945,
0.0090608317,
0.0307646096,
-0.0450341292,
-0.0722265169,
0.0255999248,
0.0106610637,
-0.0142205302,
-0.0054168124,
0.0522100292,
-0.0203057025,
0.0171490088,
-0.0215346906,
0.0041031535,
-0.00616448,
-0.0024598024,
0.0018168818,
0.0163449291,
-0.0594195016,
-0.0029252586,
0.0679218099,
-0.0206520502,
0.0159739852,
-0.0256102271,
0.0032265855,
-0.0125336582,
-0.0342167206,
-0.0189890917,
-0.0068451394,
-0.0443014689,
-0.0583269447,
-0.0738569424,
-0.013842551,
-0.0223659221,
-0.0067871641,
-0.0092696603,
-0.0218098313,
0.0087347217,
0.0362154171,
-0.0249646902,
0.0415220372,
-0.0457746573,
-0.0256999489,
-0.0604390353,
0.0184506606,
-0.0103131067,
-6.794909095e-33,
-0.0411995128,
-0.0352744013,
0.0252496284,
-0.0278987903,
0.0005728388,
-0.0246676859,
-0.0375911519,
0.0399322771,
-0.0308827683,
0.0184017867,
-0.0130260745,
-0.0055167344,
0.0157954637,
-0.0246580169,
0.0207179096,
-0.0287266131,
0.026065167,
0.0033669306,
-0.0413153507,
0.0180396419,
0.0332186036,
-0.0356600769,
0.0125092687,
-0.0807809606,
0.0292276796,
0.0323601216,
-0.0385447182,
-0.0311784688,
-0.0328809582,
0.0251252372,
-0.0229549278,
0.0133030275,
0.0195499081,
-0.0347841047,
-0.0214523189,
0.0540862419,
0.0145518724,
-0.0164583232,
0.0078335209,
-0.009520703,
0.0328561105,
-0.036306791,
-0.0153969517,
-0.0104028545,
-0.0531725734,
0.0283150263,
0.026833158,
-0.0209291335,
0.0088290563,
0.043349877,
-0.0269311536,
0.0067445491,
-0.0093380418,
0.0243887845,
-0.0246640649,
0.0306643061,
-0.0093697542,
0.050310526,
-0.0703545585,
0.0575306304,
-0.0040930975,
-0.0270209536,
0.0500043221,
-0.0089689586,
0.0219023991,
0.0713812262,
0.071472764,
0.0270105153,
-0.0960673019,
-0.0520640053,
0.0062358421,
0.052859284,
0.0805349946,
0.064460516,
-0.0078998897,
-0.0357853658,
-0.0237480048,
0.020558048,
0.0313256718,
0.0042400258,
0.0493400544,
0.0109626604,
-0.0685197189,
-0.0449974276,
-0.0213274732,
-0.0497543439,
-0.0319148786,
-0.0297332816,
-0.0005529885,
-0.0125365602,
-0.0117655927,
-0.0299708005,
0.035997238,
-0.0636615157,
-0.0233896971,
0.0120996628,
-0.0368095413,
0.0214194786,
0.0232663937,
-0.0173322968,
-0.0483501628,
-0.0005699191,
-0.0364892557,
0.0238446184,
0.0144993709,
0.0284319799,
-0.0290075038,
0.0201150049,
-0.0440514907,
-0.0270959605,
-0.0329170078,
-0.0312475376,
0.0276399683,
-0.0277215522,
0.0536295883,
-0.0162184741,
0.0244430304,
0.004124674,
-0.0054515307,
0.0146994209,
-0.009961741,
0.0000070127,
-0.0879966244,
0.0049334466,
-0.0256168395,
-0.0250222161,
-0.0483807027,
0.0130233653,
0.0527201705,
0.0045888517,
-0.0195967071,
-0.0319012068,
2.89e-7,
0.0147745805,
0.0967052877,
-0.0457067341,
-0.0164308958,
-0.0087040225,
0.0824392736,
-0.0278042834,
0.0122665642,
-0.0206662267,
-0.0327700563,
0.0179495476,
-0.000206211,
0.0529732667,
0.0551140904,
-0.0832529515,
-0.0044136439,
-0.024288496,
0.0047839498,
-0.0394967943,
0.0156168779,
0.0298956502,
0.0603265911,
0.0672516674,
-0.0095252451,
-0.0199294128,
0.0078330366,
0.0311486144,
-0.0848098993,
-0.0246278904,
0.033256717,
0.0254896563,
-0.0539678708,
-0.0165137853,
0.0246051494,
0.0168932732,
0.0021808443,
-0.0298309103,
0.0337647572,
-0.0190722123,
-0.0480694436,
-0.026286792,
-0.0201507509,
0.003750138,
-0.0707231537,
0.053043209,
-0.0140205501,
-0.0774817467,
-0.0461782068,
-0.0127930474,
-0.0185388215,
0.0339663327,
0.0000338914,
0.0184392724,
0.0004567577,
-0.009340344,
-0.0115949642,
-0.0073373495,
-0.0474863462,
-0.0108987996,
-0.0400295444,
-0.0405898131,
-0.0836340785,
-0.0357205905,
0.0416398458,
0.0343443379,
-0.0271935295,
0.0171414241,
2.336535402e-34,
0.0162439086,
0.0069699115,
-0.0036473221,
0.0140339676,
0.0426717848,
0.03064638,
0.0051921452,
0.0182205327,
0.0437643304,
-0.078189753,
-0.0044455407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17882v2 | I Think, Therefore I am: Benchmarking Awareness of Large Language Models Using AwareBench | 2024-01-31T14:41:23 | 2024-02-16T09:47:38 | Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Yuli Lin, Siyuan Wu, Yao Wan, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do large language models (LLMs) exhibit any forms of awareness similar to
humans? In this paper, we introduce AwareBench, a benchmark designed to
evaluate awareness in LLMs. Drawing from theories in psychology and philosophy,
we define awareness in LLMs as the ability to understand themselves as AI
models and to exhibit social intelligence. Subsequently, we categorize
awareness in LLMs into five dimensions, including capability, mission, emotion,
culture, and perspective. Based on this taxonomy, we create a dataset called
AwareEval, which contains binary, multiple-choice, and open-ended questions to
assess LLMs' understandings of specific awareness dimensions. Our experiments,
conducted on 13 LLMs, reveal that the majority of them struggle to fully
recognize their capabilities and missions while demonstrating decent social
intelligence. We conclude by connecting awareness of LLMs with AI alignment and
safety, emphasizing its significance to the trustworthy and ethical development
of LLMs. Our dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/HowieHwong/Awareness-in-LLM. | I Think, Therefore I am: Benchmarking Awareness of Large Language Models Using AwareBench: Do large language models (LLMs) exhibit any forms of awareness similar to
humans? In this paper, we introduce AwareBench, a benchmark designed to
evaluate awareness in LLMs. Drawing from theories in psychology and philosophy,
we define awareness in LLMs as the ability to understand themselves as AI
models and to exhibit social intelligence. Subsequently, we categorize
awareness in LLMs into five dimensions, including capability, mission, emotion,
culture, and perspective. Based on this taxonomy, we create a dataset called
AwareEval, which contains binary, multiple-choice, and open-ended questions to
assess LLMs' understandings of specific awareness dimensions. Our experiments,
conducted on 13 LLMs, reveal that the majority of them struggle to fully
recognize their capabilities and missions while demonstrating decent social
intelligence. We conclude by connecting awareness of LLMs with AI alignment and
safety, emphasizing its significance to the trustworthy and ethical development
of LLMs. Our dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/HowieHwong/Awareness-in-LLM. | [
0.020624727,
0.0562582165,
-0.0379887819,
0.0386616476,
-0.0258105323,
0.0150657976,
0.0055549848,
-0.0139345396,
0.0462639779,
-0.0230166223,
-0.0278767608,
-0.011309525,
-0.053601563,
0.0445766822,
0.0524633862,
0.0147511614,
0.0647756979,
-0.0344389454,
0.0389655307,
-0.0059278677,
-0.0008224205,
0.0204899497,
-0.0037637474,
0.0261476431,
-0.0057236562,
-0.0345333666,
-0.0322953276,
-0.0143638747,
0.0398936495,
-0.0175839029,
-0.0253953654,
0.0406420343,
0.0210644938,
0.0624808855,
0.0000020612,
-0.0859664604,
0.0115282992,
-0.0114846099,
-0.0518475473,
-0.0062691038,
0.0404752418,
0.0174951311,
-0.0060894969,
0.010852579,
-0.0806831717,
0.0151032489,
0.0128646009,
0.0015409095,
0.0073665986,
0.0385060683,
-0.0025704531,
0.0386528969,
0.0269824397,
-0.0165434126,
-0.0402326621,
-0.0545782894,
0.0309775323,
0.0134492638,
-0.0332208946,
-0.0136051262,
-0.0316041932,
0.0556802936,
0.0104770977,
-0.0364779346,
-0.0009389382,
0.0035639412,
-0.0111645544,
-0.0299677383,
-0.003581702,
0.0242500957,
0.0617155805,
-0.0159173533,
0.0016733962,
-0.0014595877,
0.0328500569,
0.0194090512,
-0.0297079179,
0.0236393753,
-0.0081391511,
0.0046291896,
0.0338608511,
0.0110601345,
0.0453074872,
0.0146477045,
0.0041823806,
0.0836324617,
-0.0298129339,
-0.0263405833,
0.0256857499,
-0.0054263016,
-0.0117336847,
-0.0807918534,
-0.0197505169,
0.0443694182,
-0.0307914298,
0.0317909457,
-0.0009079567,
-0.0345664211,
0.0210982375,
-0.0627940372,
0.063510485,
0.0395951718,
0.0015678168,
0.0359734334,
0.0591815189,
0.0859340504,
0.0018495482,
0.0413504317,
-0.0232573003,
0.0119221238,
-0.0170311462,
-0.0172218587,
-0.0070615485,
0.0072199623,
0.0080730449,
0.032328207,
-0.0309830401,
0.0430620536,
-0.041424796,
0.0421630107,
-0.0610095598,
-0.0107121766,
0.010920262,
-0.0077631995,
-0.0249462985,
0.0267572012,
-0.0297104046,
-0.018789025,
0.0068205311,
-0.0991538465,
0.0419449285,
0.0059137936,
-0.0303179659,
-0.0085187312,
0.0034877122,
0.0810929537,
0.0155651299,
-0.0435958803,
0.0015769416,
-0.011909361,
0.0170089733,
-0.045609422,
0.011760179,
-0.0542330332,
0.0098415809,
0.0206452757,
-0.0130023891,
-0.0546102151,
-0.0098362677,
-0.0002052015,
0.0057510263,
0.0209575612,
-0.0194910076,
0.037639726,
0.0246591829,
0.0142226638,
0.0036732506,
0.0971747935,
-0.0078657549,
-0.0069819377,
0.0408162586,
-0.004382947,
-0.0005891445,
0.0343909971,
-0.0153053096,
0.0067324089,
-0.0254033562,
0.0172326006,
-0.0234980583,
0.0353181064,
0.023297837,
0.0635027215,
0.0223505162,
-0.0157838874,
0.0633719265,
0.0622966997,
-0.0288235303,
0.0335386358,
0.032778088,
0.0088873636,
0.045710247,
0.0239994768,
-0.0628155619,
0.0173840243,
-0.0181494448,
-0.0180115346,
-0.0285087321,
0.00992407,
-0.0219847299,
-0.040553432,
-0.0355982669,
0.0118849473,
0.0097107776,
0.0603840165,
0.018813815,
-0.0397891402,
0.0245714393,
-0.0124114929,
0.0129830511,
-0.0464931391,
-0.0021457348,
-0.0691687241,
0.0239905417,
0.0545392074,
0.024899466,
-0.0578005575,
-0.0484726764,
-0.0141081261,
0.0065834327,
0.0644398257,
0.1094616652,
-0.0388752259,
-0.0066990806,
-0.0070907543,
-0.0086290231,
-0.0315322839,
0.0101047168,
0.013339743,
-0.0169267114,
0.0132278651,
-0.007723575,
-0.055527743,
-0.073141858,
0.0406830944,
-0.0848911926,
0.0223350115,
-0.0606732443,
-0.0046210908,
0.030460706,
0.0456377417,
-0.0150954314,
-0.0132764708,
0.0366562642,
-0.0120788505,
0.0014895911,
0.0551645681,
-0.0088214064,
0.048419416,
0.0551323295,
-0.0359383449,
-0.0242909119,
0.0597143658,
0.0167322792,
-0.0287016165,
0.0441424623,
-0.0252174642,
0.0546240322,
-0.0326641425,
0.0329802968,
-0.0820204914,
0.0022459822,
-0.0213570818,
0.039394252,
-0.0193085317,
0.0071616992,
0.0099554881,
-0.0375960805,
0.0278414562,
-0.0067790691,
-0.0511360429,
0.0159567986,
0.0010433791,
0.0006246637,
0.0145701971,
0.0213933829,
-0.0747366101,
0.0005726353,
-0.1142297611,
-0.0264267847,
-0.0174521785,
0.0192742497,
0.0180031806,
-0.0144863389,
-0.0271159932,
0.0198674127,
-0.0249258261,
0.0180727728,
0.0158628933,
0.0159949455,
0.0275578834,
0.0047119847,
-0.0103682401,
-0.0363711752,
0.0069837575,
-0.0376670398,
-0.012629495,
0.0277343392,
-0.0264238492,
-0.0418741852,
0.0500463955,
-0.0495764054,
0.0096019488,
-0.0284591764,
-0.0395971462,
0.0268665589,
0.0155598996,
0.0016873931,
0.0612717718,
0.0093782423,
0.0464677326,
0.0728305206,
0.0287016518,
-0.0535372794,
0.0120793264,
0.0422259718,
-0.0059167533,
-0.0650335327,
-0.0397446789,
0.0170297585,
0.0464457572,
0.0008547707,
-0.0045805154,
0.0021933974,
0.0132060489,
-0.0506820641,
-0.1040243432,
-0.0436504669,
-0.0123985205,
-0.018713085,
0.0516930111,
-0.0055725705,
-0.047459241,
0.0653099865,
0.0027590706,
-0.0172873531,
0.0013577936,
-0.030537175,
-0.0062786075,
0.0860221088,
-0.0122699235,
0.0361952074,
-0.0266714208,
-0.0280946586,
-0.0647541657,
-0.0008985215,
-0.0165173728,
-0.0303536765,
0.0449984521,
-0.0470448993,
-0.0104822572,
0.0110581815,
-0.0107406378,
-0.0690117925,
-0.0187230017,
-0.0753942803,
0.0193964709,
0.0088917762,
-0.0574867018,
0.0036527831,
-0.0254496187,
0.050636936,
0.0040892544,
0.0108646005,
-0.0024358705,
-0.016790539,
-0.0593438447,
0.0487598367,
0.029439941,
0.0791893154,
-0.0584406592,
0.0526034124,
0.0389359929,
0.0254138187,
-0.0045733275,
-0.0090571875,
-0.0246203132,
0.0350610539,
0.0018744902,
0.0086693568,
0.0312797762,
0.0749703497,
-0.0330978893,
-0.0316608585,
0.1259816587,
0.012457815,
-0.0458702482,
0.0155385975,
-0.0587334745,
-0.0167693663,
0.0495423637,
0.0371513553,
-0.0543336309,
0.0005108059,
0.0039205696,
0.0048894687,
-0.0403644033,
-0.0734311566,
-0.0064840019,
-0.0673628077,
0.0125226798,
-0.023019895,
-0.0540540367,
0.0013591966,
0.0109924609,
0.039632,
0.0201331489,
0.0160490721,
0.0180802364,
-0.0055277916,
-0.0385685489,
0.0036138056,
-0.0292154234,
-0.0536351539,
0.0308413133,
-0.0772350132,
0.0895198286,
0.0712003484,
0.0315465182,
-0.0476943888,
-0.0398819,
0.0276742056,
0.0118038841,
0.0247712415,
0.013664294,
0.0113207074,
-0.0415356979,
-0.0094844513,
-0.0135146128,
0.0020232073,
-0.0326977409,
0.0320355892,
0.018148452,
0.0920177698,
-0.0379987098,
-0.0419277698,
-0.0119819744,
-0.0131915957,
-0.0213940218,
0.0816270187,
0.0511502251,
-0.0277104732,
0.0220194422,
-0.0274346396,
0.0093950005,
0.0015536528,
-0.0039811986,
0.0440597944,
0.0143912667,
-0.0529010557,
-0.0514962673,
-0.0505015031,
0.0254135095,
0.0092441617,
0.0470256694,
0.0052421056,
0.0387912206,
-0.0112877907,
-0.0514401235,
-0.0084816897,
-0.0190191455,
0.0309884623,
-0.0242946092,
-0.0057813893,
-0.026659146,
-0.0158075541,
-0.0023878426,
0.0215275157,
-0.0379530266,
-0.0765219182,
0.0620248355,
0.0232590288,
0.0290377438,
-0.0079471972,
-0.0231391918,
-0.0589184836,
-0.0111758327,
-0.0052406802,
-0.0145885386,
0.0698231533,
0.0084430864,
-0.0179799329,
-0.0028489213,
0.0651573613,
-0.0210760999,
-0.0024423569,
-0.003076202,
0.0082587795,
-0.0203214493,
-0.0459739715,
0.0045187273,
0.0469067991,
0.0013598873,
-0.0387847088,
-0.0038249977,
-0.0334856324,
-0.0383287966,
-0.0383531488,
-0.0224150084,
-0.0199399162,
-0.0186471213,
0.0166999884,
0.0094281631,
0.0395523272,
0.017265819,
-0.0357103236,
0.0099519249,
-0.000696413,
0.0349845104,
-0.0339078009,
0.0423240028,
0.0053480431,
0.026479369,
0.0052774297,
0.0281320382,
-0.0064251036,
0.0240372717,
0.0416471139,
0.0601772182,
0.0167748034,
-0.0075516631,
0.0192147028,
0.0218502581,
-0.0366259441,
-0.0894288197,
0.0485235341,
0.0676591247,
0.0769770294,
0.0082759578,
0.054279469,
-0.0383460633,
0.0213368479,
0.0053959992,
-0.0074285767,
-0.0039730147,
-0.0571494997,
0.0304306969,
0.0272841584,
-0.0126479082,
0.014507344,
0.048879873,
-0.0323052518,
0.0388425998,
-0.0156334154,
-0.0048708245,
-0.0173942875,
-0.0002601926,
0.0278886687,
0.0296747666,
-0.0463337861,
0.0295081511,
-0.0848949105,
-0.0810719654,
-0.0065094591,
0.0404803231,
-0.0040942603,
-0.0658513755,
0.0080004781,
0.0650831237,
0.0059476425,
-0.0150598381,
-0.0423110016,
-0.0098050451,
-0.0467088558,
-0.0096840514,
-0.0083466349,
-6.056719949e-33,
-0.0214646198,
-0.0267239548,
0.0075609311,
-0.0196009073,
-0.0451456122,
-0.011191546,
-0.04947396,
0.03746479,
-0.0696243495,
0.0298940409,
-0.0373542532,
0.0589245148,
-0.0027183418,
-0.0241438951,
0.0450365953,
-0.0251636244,
-0.0067936894,
-0.0242340006,
-0.0047745672,
0.0052286121,
0.0242967214,
0.0103066312,
0.0667637661,
-0.0920215994,
0.0563658737,
-0.0092818756,
0.0126931779,
0.0442495048,
-0.0135708936,
0.0102982316,
-0.0179284792,
0.0618610904,
0.0391614661,
0.0024121099,
-0.0068757632,
-0.0096620014,
0.0096210754,
-0.0158009976,
0.0629980713,
-0.0004744836,
-0.0281612724,
-0.0369693972,
0.0266635902,
-0.0128790652,
-0.0599510819,
0.0365869217,
0.0105633531,
-0.0244961474,
0.0399980545,
0.015745515,
-0.0265341345,
-0.0024885635,
-0.0343367644,
0.0152999246,
-0.0057153436,
0.0127094854,
-0.0053797211,
-0.031496346,
-0.017668562,
0.0237114057,
-0.001959081,
0.0013547821,
0.1207270697,
-0.0014111209,
0.0160105508,
0.0777336508,
0.0293540396,
0.0612269565,
0.0351613685,
-0.0095489072,
0.0497046933,
0.0387132838,
0.0367502607,
0.0443841219,
-0.0452239178,
-0.017338898,
0.0024660211,
0.0047910567,
0.0403245799,
0.0149148069,
0.0348247215,
-0.0193830002,
-0.0848881453,
-0.0194485225,
-0.0158268288,
-0.0097946022,
-0.0141526274,
-0.0163399782,
0.017715957,
-0.0493471771,
0.0066055274,
-0.0391282029,
0.0117567116,
-0.0457612984,
0.0394693427,
0.000323242,
-0.0311008282,
0.0375618599,
0.0193646476,
0.0434139408,
-0.0454633199,
-0.0156054543,
-0.039063368,
0.0381543078,
0.0297542866,
0.0106854383,
-0.0027607083,
0.0033254768,
-0.0075287004,
0.0055697118,
-0.0367163271,
0.0205403436,
0.0150700379,
-0.025502041,
0.02282634,
-0.0295594949,
-0.0071242168,
-0.0022503568,
0.0226897411,
-0.0286056679,
-0.0480846874,
0.0224797931,
-0.0441181324,
-0.0057608383,
-0.050782159,
-0.0406295918,
-0.0462730825,
0.0472964421,
0.0688220859,
-0.0404183418,
-0.004445435,
0.0085060233,
2.82e-7,
0.0326610506,
0.0380667597,
-0.0070346766,
0.0043126582,
0.018917622,
0.0437895693,
-0.0543551035,
0.0555552021,
0.0052281246,
-0.0200628899,
-0.0155946352,
0.0304544438,
0.0558903068,
0.0162113048,
-0.072962299,
-0.0587865673,
-0.0458098911,
-0.0053865029,
-0.0500755683,
0.0238181818,
-0.0077341711,
0.0142997988,
0.011606006,
-0.0203449354,
-0.0206447467,
-0.0553415827,
-0.0031423187,
-0.0363265947,
0.0125134196,
0.0086548943,
0.0310861804,
0.0260560159,
0.013351663,
0.0265235696,
0.0113670724,
-0.0085789617,
-0.0151186138,
0.0615340546,
0.0180011168,
0.0439533591,
-0.0142173199,
-0.0006949172,
-0.0084052263,
-0.0604228266,
0.0352897607,
-0.0327031016,
-0.0518961661,
-0.0382852219,
0.0227042045,
-0.0515001193,
-0.016494859,
0.0021500241,
-0.011978209,
0.0388662294,
0.0022582794,
-0.0658440143,
-0.0002499286,
-0.0130297765,
-0.000302109,
-0.0356065184,
-0.0179925002,
-0.0810525715,
-0.0322752371,
-0.0017463306,
-0.010311408,
-0.0549329557,
0.0221563764,
2.318757427e-34,
0.0241126325,
0.0249050334,
0.0111176064,
0.0177521426,
0.0436819531,
0.0064619938,
-0.0789385587,
0.0132375937,
0.0079883039,
-0.0760220066,
0.0067344001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17858v1 | Probing Language Models' Gesture Understanding for Enhanced Human-AI Interaction | 2024-01-31T14:19:03 | 2024-01-31T14:19:03 | Philipp Wicke | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has affected various disciplines
that got beyond mere text generation. Going beyond their textual nature, this
project proposal aims to investigate the interaction between LLMs and
non-verbal communication, specifically focusing on gestures. The proposal sets
out a plan to examine the proficiency of LLMs in deciphering both explicit and
implicit non-verbal cues within textual prompts and their ability to associate
these gestures with various contextual factors. The research proposes to test
established psycholinguistic study designs to construct a comprehensive dataset
that pairs textual prompts with detailed gesture descriptions, encompassing
diverse regional variations, and semantic labels. To assess LLMs' comprehension
of gestures, experiments are planned, evaluating their ability to simulate
human behaviour in order to replicate psycholinguistic experiments. These
experiments consider cultural dimensions and measure the agreement between
LLM-identified gestures and the dataset, shedding light on the models'
contextual interpretation of non-verbal cues (e.g. gestures). | Probing Language Models' Gesture Understanding for Enhanced Human-AI Interaction: The rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has affected various disciplines
that got beyond mere text generation. Going beyond their textual nature, this
project proposal aims to investigate the interaction between LLMs and
non-verbal communication, specifically focusing on gestures. The proposal sets
out a plan to examine the proficiency of LLMs in deciphering both explicit and
implicit non-verbal cues within textual prompts and their ability to associate
these gestures with various contextual factors. The research proposes to test
established psycholinguistic study designs to construct a comprehensive dataset
that pairs textual prompts with detailed gesture descriptions, encompassing
diverse regional variations, and semantic labels. To assess LLMs' comprehension
of gestures, experiments are planned, evaluating their ability to simulate
human behaviour in order to replicate psycholinguistic experiments. These
experiments consider cultural dimensions and measure the agreement between
LLM-identified gestures and the dataset, shedding light on the models'
contextual interpretation of non-verbal cues (e.g. gestures). | [
0.0376330987,
0.0206120219,
-0.0545579977,
0.0409141853,
-0.0433042347,
0.0408586375,
0.050267484,
0.0363475159,
0.0336205103,
-0.0594923943,
-0.0587812774,
-0.057591334,
0.0517855361,
0.0212718192,
0.0358902588,
-0.0402017348,
0.032041762,
-0.0760639459,
-0.0111397216,
0.0354642048,
0.0167937465,
0.0233728606,
-0.0270951707,
0.0581726246,
-0.0418963023,
-0.010467804,
-0.0501541346,
-0.0123082837,
-0.0015786384,
-0.0288395509,
-0.0540009663,
0.0368795656,
0.0362207331,
0.0234828442,
0.0000020752,
-0.0329158306,
0.0718280226,
-0.0273119565,
-0.0191819482,
0.0418485142,
0.0684333593,
-0.0133011406,
-0.004997849,
-0.0179350358,
-0.0324381813,
0.0003385824,
0.0271501467,
0.0626238361,
0.0170478858,
0.0116814524,
-0.0015234107,
0.0320537165,
-0.0063925516,
-0.0063525233,
-0.003923479,
0.0104776006,
0.0391473211,
-0.0066255997,
0.03396523,
0.0074201529,
-0.0077728238,
0.0293494649,
0.0017534473,
-0.0308997873,
-0.0503811799,
0.049061913,
-0.0252721943,
-0.0473240055,
-0.0074305721,
0.026673058,
0.0612822175,
-0.0162926763,
0.0218854081,
-0.0188885164,
0.001016123,
0.0351293609,
-0.0354790352,
0.0468306057,
0.0056305621,
-0.0045101228,
0.0300448649,
-0.0161356293,
0.0122223515,
0.0115580438,
0.0334374346,
0.0595677458,
-0.0074062329,
-0.0084863007,
-0.0175936781,
-0.0244315844,
0.0225812159,
-0.0869737566,
0.0271992162,
0.0226834901,
-0.0340606309,
0.024747692,
-0.031660784,
0.0110581294,
0.0211903974,
-0.0262170527,
0.043287918,
0.0517153516,
-0.0130393896,
0.0283305123,
0.0370795839,
0.057925202,
-0.0076035541,
-0.0136306547,
-0.0322726369,
0.0159117896,
-0.0025433132,
-0.0433634259,
0.0032267156,
-0.0211756285,
-0.0180782452,
-0.0208331831,
-0.0078714881,
0.0333833694,
0.0009889627,
0.0113163078,
-0.0181527436,
-0.0079378234,
-0.001275972,
0.0117490208,
-0.013946251,
0.0092548272,
-0.02790365,
0.0542035773,
-0.0061978116,
-0.0803972483,
0.0125753284,
0.0218062289,
-0.0180925913,
-0.0173305664,
-0.0297257304,
0.0538437665,
-0.009923812,
-0.0287381243,
-0.0186073072,
-0.0108281961,
-0.0107629886,
-0.0314860493,
-0.0318564549,
-0.0362787619,
0.0182911437,
0.0031984674,
-0.0211321637,
-0.0101897586,
0.0121693918,
0.0131105101,
-0.0098942043,
0.022501912,
0.0026388145,
0.054600209,
0.0645059571,
0.0048682666,
-0.0057515143,
0.0503002703,
0.0353474878,
0.0268402882,
0.0214180835,
-0.0031241663,
0.0213256031,
0.0720633939,
-0.0597315021,
0.0093811415,
-0.0357797034,
-0.0203148723,
0.0117059303,
0.0142703103,
0.0492518693,
0.0414369963,
-0.0396664701,
0.0011221627,
0.0564434156,
0.1294284165,
-0.0428237617,
0.0022005506,
0.0428412296,
-0.0164110456,
0.0331409611,
-0.0225126129,
-0.0416540094,
-0.0144715626,
-0.0159291029,
-0.0221705586,
-0.0370601676,
0.0183762573,
-0.0314034671,
-0.0168674272,
-0.0257703066,
-0.0281970017,
0.0116040455,
0.0309208613,
0.0673330724,
-0.0330387205,
0.0320318304,
-0.0652031451,
0.0119678844,
-0.0265709348,
0.0043408824,
-0.0397509858,
0.0403320231,
0.0636880845,
0.0183888227,
-0.0033387521,
0.0051736389,
-0.0033690978,
0.025921002,
0.0555185378,
0.0207618624,
-0.0123850917,
0.0233342405,
0.0172240306,
0.0170727074,
-0.0021910765,
0.0135870809,
0.0359811261,
-0.0435690582,
0.0324904211,
0.0107523175,
-0.018916361,
-0.0101512233,
0.0402267091,
-0.0740103051,
-0.004303162,
-0.0131226107,
-0.0130622936,
0.004769492,
0.055076085,
-0.0452036262,
-0.0254381504,
0.0142534515,
-0.0156612936,
0.0548817329,
0.0309365671,
-0.02084627,
0.0260996483,
0.0064223032,
-0.0219457932,
-0.0294988155,
0.0039275642,
0.0254311264,
-0.046807453,
0.0296310857,
-0.005720654,
0.0257863924,
-0.0371684507,
0.0036677485,
-0.0051041264,
-0.0061932537,
-0.0090506719,
-0.0013557118,
-0.0030738309,
0.009498273,
0.0293138381,
-0.0003736122,
0.0264627673,
-0.0572460517,
-0.0330119953,
0.0462350771,
-0.0038717326,
-0.0090322569,
0.0324125029,
-0.0069904085,
-0.0482316092,
-0.0047681252,
-0.1157046854,
-0.0090299202,
-0.0087393979,
0.0133211417,
0.0296258274,
0.0054548453,
-0.0557320938,
-0.0051979306,
-0.0173271466,
-0.0329559483,
0.0228249971,
0.0162840672,
0.0330958143,
-0.0399557911,
-0.021846313,
-0.0402164869,
0.0111904955,
-0.0169719215,
0.0249049738,
0.0315888338,
-0.0314620398,
-0.0494180024,
0.0006485771,
0.0030421789,
0.010538456,
-0.0329831727,
-0.0306354463,
0.0469994135,
0.0042670025,
0.0087541565,
0.0752866268,
-0.025218768,
0.0411032103,
0.0678483769,
-0.0416316539,
-0.0339262113,
-0.0377708711,
0.0342810825,
0.0400235988,
-0.0550538339,
-0.0799514353,
0.0220755599,
0.0862986743,
0.0232797638,
0.0382415131,
-0.0115497932,
-0.0282929596,
-0.0263597798,
-0.0764223412,
-0.028684726,
-0.0386779979,
-0.0533236824,
0.0591359846,
-0.0121964486,
-0.0564187691,
0.0376380906,
-0.0630716085,
-0.0357466787,
0.0496630557,
-0.0400795117,
-0.0290849935,
0.1051122472,
0.0068813609,
-0.0010211846,
0.0077091567,
-0.0356220976,
-0.0167843495,
0.0214256868,
-0.0189710911,
0.001096879,
-0.0043640132,
-0.0807854384,
-0.0140896868,
-0.0116899246,
0.0370802768,
-0.0201524179,
0.0071374876,
-0.0445013009,
0.0108376462,
0.0065244064,
-0.0400176793,
0.0281503107,
0.023361329,
0.0542901866,
0.0375316031,
-0.0015541966,
0.0101547362,
-0.0360022336,
-0.0318444781,
0.0583665557,
0.0066543268,
-0.0621180646,
-0.0176507439,
0.0393810347,
0.0239407998,
0.0156967156,
0.0096170977,
-0.0285706911,
0.022823222,
0.0459307209,
-0.0321305841,
-0.0629450232,
0.0463676304,
0.0447265133,
-0.0236703157,
0.017868137,
0.1162251234,
0.0468283407,
-0.0513977967,
0.0387365222,
-0.0353872888,
-0.0030397426,
0.0062727076,
0.016494181,
-0.075331904,
-0.0011881604,
0.015773166,
-0.0139962872,
-0.0267211944,
-0.0410689451,
-0.0124913407,
-0.0915284008,
0.0352779254,
-0.0241058506,
-0.0537782311,
-0.0019860307,
-0.0441511199,
0.0677951798,
0.0181274768,
0.0158619117,
-0.0107796928,
0.0001865165,
0.0008251749,
0.0231216196,
-0.0383359976,
-0.0367093943,
0.0368396454,
-0.0213428363,
0.0633763149,
0.0225479156,
0.0322105289,
0.0126153277,
-0.0181146674,
0.0254198853,
0.0098271482,
0.0514474064,
-0.0266158506,
-0.0246395078,
0.0031091694,
0.0157698784,
-0.0117459018,
0.0355546586,
-0.0652578026,
-0.0455421284,
0.0454647616,
0.0720449388,
-0.0712474585,
0.0016406319,
-0.0052347849,
-0.0618516356,
0.009561413,
0.0227832552,
0.0471190549,
-0.0725604519,
-0.0303008836,
-0.01684862,
-0.0216567367,
0.0655006543,
-0.0372841991,
0.0107890703,
-0.0002585869,
-0.0772872344,
-0.0304726604,
-0.0954804718,
0.0451043658,
0.006649612,
0.0311752371,
0.0376905315,
0.0262602214,
-0.0151072433,
0.0177740678,
0.0404767506,
-0.0079312706,
0.076660037,
-0.0042734421,
-0.0241596568,
-0.0032276167,
-0.0550308079,
0.0007528948,
-0.0326551534,
-0.0390213057,
-0.0717805028,
0.0198876224,
0.0244945157,
0.0220672395,
0.0255803205,
-0.0033119642,
-0.0582374707,
-0.0222616587,
0.017783517,
-0.0144047514,
0.0496500954,
-0.0349975005,
0.0086390963,
0.0126282563,
-0.0044509517,
0.0015124318,
0.0207204949,
-0.0051998817,
-0.0021135297,
-0.0824862868,
-0.0682981759,
0.0154704703,
0.0262741484,
0.0310004186,
-0.0160922501,
-0.004190926,
-0.0335697532,
-0.0314670987,
-0.0440481156,
-0.0000064409,
-0.0472231805,
-0.035099823,
0.0004220579,
-0.0010681706,
0.0144093093,
-0.0378772169,
-0.0545676686,
0.0023399715,
0.0045802593,
0.0661942288,
0.020513488,
0.0743155554,
-0.0215967074,
0.0343114063,
0.0026846912,
0.0347964279,
-0.0536765233,
0.0212568473,
0.0125691118,
0.0761413947,
0.0164788738,
-0.0276103914,
0.0281044152,
0.0462986678,
-0.0348722972,
-0.0510166958,
0.0420678481,
0.0223223306,
0.0336880013,
-0.0341717936,
0.0521768071,
-0.0724852756,
0.0455875583,
-0.0122803533,
0.0477135479,
0.0109939957,
-0.0575208813,
0.0329693705,
0.0157714803,
-0.0357099883,
0.0167602338,
0.0448632427,
-0.0424569175,
0.0049138698,
0.02631489,
-0.0258516632,
-0.0226317812,
-0.0212468617,
0.0730457231,
-0.0229906328,
-0.0512620583,
0.0058988607,
-0.0503388457,
-0.0519792289,
-0.01650526,
0.0212369617,
0.0209998246,
-0.0727496147,
0.020462703,
0.0283435024,
-0.002803405,
0.0076657771,
-0.0399409197,
-0.0207245983,
-0.039878536,
-0.0300832652,
-0.0920040831,
-5.884633086e-33,
-0.0257854387,
-0.0706932023,
0.0200007502,
-0.0206836499,
-0.0507236086,
0.0052025323,
-0.0504496098,
0.0284938607,
0.0098820012,
-0.0195577405,
-0.0458452925,
0.0170163196,
0.0028036351,
-0.0225085393,
0.0365052819,
-0.0061968332,
0.0200085081,
-0.0220577139,
-0.0078623751,
0.0163282044,
0.0083929999,
-0.0335224681,
0.0521103553,
-0.0741102099,
0.0651900992,
-0.0154214203,
-0.0231260713,
-0.0193203669,
0.0128680998,
0.0298275072,
-0.0686116964,
0.0311327148,
0.0415691659,
0.0214362442,
0.0005915216,
0.0586643256,
0.0085627139,
-0.0343503132,
0.0383825786,
0.0710402802,
0.0010620765,
-0.0140765859,
-0.0234229621,
-0.0031762866,
-0.0450295359,
0.0642180592,
0.040440768,
-0.021577822,
0.0064899651,
-0.0047799209,
-0.0049967244,
0.0257201046,
-0.042077031,
-0.0185685959,
0.0066194651,
0.0586630441,
-0.0443430431,
-0.0204538666,
-0.0361413695,
0.0371158011,
0.047620371,
-0.0013305473,
0.0991954282,
0.0216009039,
0.0597751178,
0.0439427942,
0.0330546834,
0.0092620477,
-0.0216086954,
-0.0129112331,
0.0562450774,
0.0192604847,
-0.0459370501,
0.0614261664,
0.0192581639,
-0.0252319425,
0.0019162594,
0.0015971629,
0.0796278864,
0.0351048224,
0.0037346478,
-0.0021545859,
-0.0094435271,
-0.0147074806,
-0.0336022824,
-0.0227883272,
-0.0063844095,
-0.0330792703,
0.0416449271,
-0.0318471342,
0.0650859028,
-0.0231468286,
0.0427428,
-0.0297750905,
-0.026503345,
-0.0270331651,
-0.0100673139,
0.0548133589,
0.0447289459,
-0.0052726953,
-0.055659771,
-0.0318448544,
0.0083632283,
-0.0119068511,
0.0542231016,
0.0347311869,
-0.0441822112,
0.0231832936,
-0.0257150643,
-0.0071126153,
-0.003027695,
-0.0246879272,
-0.0002247469,
-0.0286204983,
0.0497066677,
-0.0253464747,
-0.040834967,
0.0238245204,
-0.0154781798,
-0.0270476937,
-0.0393437184,
0.0053625461,
-0.0416126549,
0.0015717152,
-0.0539618768,
-0.0163374227,
-0.0311237592,
0.017412439,
0.0751021355,
-0.028743498,
-0.0045380313,
-0.0039559836,
2.797e-7,
0.0022005395,
0.0456189178,
-0.0067503555,
0.0696399361,
0.0394558869,
0.02796451,
-0.0205689631,
0.0277471915,
0.0404565148,
0.0030349055,
0.0336462297,
-0.0028352151,
0.0341661572,
0.0019063266,
-0.0631156489,
0.0461006127,
-0.0300610103,
-0.0100659179,
-0.0741332769,
0.0564708151,
0.0242431238,
0.0298956931,
-0.022215046,
0.005245381,
-0.0209581293,
-0.0179685075,
0.0291844923,
-0.0999174267,
0.0248508491,
-0.0152755259,
0.0361319296,
-0.04675721,
0.0085688895,
0.0383541435,
0.0133801671,
-0.009310103,
-0.0124423038,
0.0436608382,
-0.0606358871,
0.0154201239,
0.0084609734,
-0.0114637651,
-0.0319820084,
-0.0625736415,
0.0712113604,
-0.0283948835,
-0.0216632932,
-0.0090117846,
0.0069668368,
-0.0106438259,
-0.0105700763,
-0.0111277541,
0.0258223619,
0.0467597395,
0.0073779915,
-0.0459426269,
0.0031727187,
0.0183206145,
-0.0144475726,
-0.0150152808,
-0.0334176309,
-0.0487361364,
-0.0445524603,
0.0017251871,
-0.0126079367,
-0.050037466,
-0.0121673355,
2.22338879e-34,
-0.0121640312,
0.0016503736,
0.0077313436,
0.0640709624,
0.036481306,
0.0069379606,
0.0329342186,
0.0800134912,
0.0613646433,
-0.0602628477,
-0.0349752195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03366v1 | Uncertainty-Aware Explainable Recommendation with Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T14:06:26 | 2024-01-31T14:06:26 | Yicui Peng, Hao Chen, Chingsheng Lin, Guo Huang, Jinrong Hu, Hui Guo, Bin Kong, Shu Hu, Xi Wu, Xin Wang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Providing explanations within the recommendation system would boost user
satisfaction and foster trust, especially by elaborating on the reasons for
selecting recommended items tailored to the user. The predominant approach in
this domain revolves around generating text-based explanations, with a notable
emphasis on applying large language models (LLMs). However, refining LLMs for
explainable recommendations proves impractical due to time constraints and
computing resource limitations. As an alternative, the current approach
involves training the prompt rather than the LLM. In this study, we developed a
model that utilizes the ID vectors of user and item inputs as prompts for
GPT-2. We employed a joint training mechanism within a multi-task learning
framework to optimize both the recommendation task and explanation task. This
strategy enables a more effective exploration of users' interests, improving
recommendation effectiveness and user satisfaction. Through the experiments,
our method achieving 1.59 DIV, 0.57 USR and 0.41 FCR on the Yelp, TripAdvisor
and Amazon dataset respectively, demonstrates superior performance over four
SOTA methods in terms of explainability evaluation metric. In addition, we
identified that the proposed model is able to ensure stable textual quality on
the three public datasets. | Uncertainty-Aware Explainable Recommendation with Large Language Models: Providing explanations within the recommendation system would boost user
satisfaction and foster trust, especially by elaborating on the reasons for
selecting recommended items tailored to the user. The predominant approach in
this domain revolves around generating text-based explanations, with a notable
emphasis on applying large language models (LLMs). However, refining LLMs for
explainable recommendations proves impractical due to time constraints and
computing resource limitations. As an alternative, the current approach
involves training the prompt rather than the LLM. In this study, we developed a
model that utilizes the ID vectors of user and item inputs as prompts for
GPT-2. We employed a joint training mechanism within a multi-task learning
framework to optimize both the recommendation task and explanation task. This
strategy enables a more effective exploration of users' interests, improving
recommendation effectiveness and user satisfaction. Through the experiments,
our method achieving 1.59 DIV, 0.57 USR and 0.41 FCR on the Yelp, TripAdvisor
and Amazon dataset respectively, demonstrates superior performance over four
SOTA methods in terms of explainability evaluation metric. In addition, we
identified that the proposed model is able to ensure stable textual quality on
the three public datasets. | [
0.0373932235,
0.0492772907,
0.00330559,
0.0326943882,
0.0117568839,
0.0047752657,
0.033843454,
0.003588571,
0.0275222063,
-0.0210027304,
-0.0072332933,
-0.0338949338,
-0.0241318624,
0.0469603054,
0.0099941343,
-0.048336491,
-0.0026308512,
-0.0410209782,
0.0274428651,
0.0088108312,
0.0036831324,
0.0446642525,
0.0241929386,
0.0378978699,
0.0491586514,
-0.018248016,
-0.0176631939,
-0.0017091115,
0.0142155597,
-0.0279159006,
-0.016797211,
0.0116163287,
0.0470893234,
-0.0363417082,
0.0000024295,
-0.0173539203,
-0.0297529548,
-0.0013059287,
-0.0532239638,
0.0039199344,
0.0068344753,
0.0726022869,
0.0323585682,
0.0138038695,
0.0113597475,
0.0265512001,
0.0304650925,
0.1000415608,
0.0402036719,
0.0393096395,
-0.0097367223,
-0.035944853,
0.0043383297,
-0.040929947,
0.0583711341,
-0.026283931,
0.0030187208,
-0.0270087644,
-0.009904216,
0.048558753,
0.0184909534,
-0.0373893455,
0.0183019284,
-0.0483468994,
0.0445161238,
0.0163043365,
0.0190217905,
-0.0151457675,
0.0076886276,
0.0633365661,
-0.0057357769,
-0.0111510213,
-0.0057437653,
-0.003417779,
-0.0134207048,
0.021912666,
-0.0486557968,
-0.0205962639,
-0.0138478614,
0.0480475388,
0.0017414409,
0.0016292785,
0.0737228245,
0.016700713,
0.0108125554,
0.1071563587,
-0.0007018979,
-0.010886333,
0.0017835649,
-0.0106357504,
-0.0623100773,
-0.0404278114,
0.0131506557,
0.0176787209,
-0.0864451081,
0.0065030414,
0.0398354568,
0.036959216,
-0.0075979349,
-0.0001314852,
0.0477560125,
0.0262338724,
-0.0152692692,
0.0661507696,
0.0128039271,
0.0703517422,
0.0042752502,
-0.010916925,
-0.0411438532,
-0.0098925028,
-0.0456038751,
-0.002795703,
0.0051806876,
0.0309270415,
-0.043816179,
-0.0137511147,
-0.0437905267,
0.0262663681,
-0.011085826,
0.0254194438,
0.0375046842,
0.0172816683,
-0.0205108263,
-0.0186619405,
-0.0814442411,
-0.0071248598,
-0.0472881123,
0.0348137319,
0.0158530679,
0.016729854,
0.0027088169,
0.0493156947,
0.0155022461,
-0.044731725,
-0.0084683169,
0.0205171853,
0.0028440526,
-0.021907717,
-0.0681149513,
-0.044974383,
-0.0150722321,
-0.077373676,
-0.0632592812,
-0.022503078,
0.0065265927,
0.0139950663,
-0.0028107048,
-0.047444772,
0.0124733616,
0.0091534648,
-0.0467272699,
0.0814074501,
-0.0133142993,
0.0052712541,
-0.013513458,
0.0225461256,
-0.0197221637,
-0.0056279274,
0.0107190413,
0.0768537149,
0.0632331595,
-0.0222894996,
0.0213118382,
-0.0481906906,
0.0094414186,
0.0208712388,
0.0051359059,
0.0101541365,
-0.0422630683,
0.0224424805,
0.0280217808,
0.0534669347,
-0.0314247757,
0.032104861,
0.0811823383,
0.0248589423,
0.0096248966,
0.0389530733,
0.0581304953,
0.0436685756,
-0.0414520465,
0.0043905792,
-0.037193317,
0.0546282232,
-0.0253776386,
-0.0044409479,
0.053089723,
0.0017074215,
-0.0525004342,
-0.0600558445,
0.0080711525,
-0.0432376191,
0.0340468958,
0.032893274,
0.0376151353,
-0.0396583714,
-0.0711010545,
0.0010057666,
0.0327816531,
-0.0373140052,
0.012946452,
-0.0443082936,
0.1225725934,
0.1278081983,
0.0256554577,
-0.0195653103,
0.0134141287,
-0.0519122779,
0.024755666,
-0.0147508467,
0.0153717771,
-0.0056321318,
0.0223761071,
-0.0674061105,
-0.0598721914,
-0.0022808292,
0.0098361569,
0.0096262097,
-0.0136947585,
-0.0010609039,
0.0365793183,
-0.0490229763,
-0.0529294722,
-0.0091910558,
-0.0029678133,
-0.0375680439,
0.0231351908,
-0.0000710838,
0.0464256555,
0.0285502821,
0.0448858328,
-0.0135114398,
0.0133430725,
-0.0144822383,
-0.0288599376,
0.0062632412,
-0.0147578865,
0.0115034785,
0.0271453578,
0.009414901,
0.0162252542,
0.0308163408,
-0.028615484,
-0.0585100763,
-0.0294920839,
-0.0128759565,
0.0074940026,
-0.0317137428,
0.0072091129,
0.0171121117,
0.0051743714,
-0.0405700505,
0.0501087308,
0.0168993361,
0.0202463977,
-0.0120596001,
-0.0061971159,
0.0179498196,
-0.0391492732,
0.0036849733,
0.0166227669,
0.0201283935,
0.0003120789,
0.023802666,
0.006122001,
-0.0250586122,
-0.0156684425,
-0.0586963892,
0.0075789564,
-0.0069436394,
0.0088277394,
-0.0152247846,
0.0103927674,
0.019428378,
-0.0110683674,
-0.0580151081,
0.0040027434,
-0.0249962341,
-0.0015175405,
0.0345947891,
0.0145345833,
-0.0391611978,
-0.0382086299,
-0.0023774148,
-0.0223797578,
0.0422520079,
0.004387713,
0.0105918581,
-0.0884786174,
0.0008523204,
-0.0123311989,
-0.0426554382,
-0.0203792583,
0.0034224831,
-0.0273505878,
0.01420925,
0.030274637,
0.0077996878,
0.0111337258,
0.0452211052,
0.0369438119,
0.0111607118,
-0.0450756885,
0.0104181562,
-0.0275821481,
-0.0234533213,
-0.0324969627,
-0.0455152541,
-0.0203010533,
0.0274046641,
-0.0287868623,
-0.0130935833,
-0.0806561038,
0.0146726491,
-0.004965906,
0.0384697802,
-0.0419553779,
-0.0455384254,
-0.0078440392,
0.0750605837,
-0.0119562242,
-0.0490845516,
0.0889483392,
-0.0321524143,
-0.0120612588,
-0.0338423587,
-0.0311903488,
-0.0341625176,
0.0453074798,
-0.0139065785,
0.0343434475,
0.0091941748,
-0.0169672947,
-0.012282203,
-0.007459031,
0.04501535,
-0.0225680731,
0.0368576199,
-0.0309638102,
-0.0154284071,
0.0231334213,
-0.0380771235,
-0.0200341009,
-0.0702965632,
0.0065664407,
0.003475847,
0.0302174948,
-0.0228226669,
-0.0298043601,
0.0021679669,
-0.0117576309,
0.0221535172,
-0.0338559039,
-0.0346755087,
-0.0061085699,
-0.0122392792,
0.0613278225,
0.0075491485,
0.004668742,
-0.0313578956,
0.0316827893,
-0.0113552241,
0.013023491,
-0.0567805059,
-0.0185515173,
0.0115985451,
0.0261418931,
-0.033958137,
-0.0290969834,
0.0370556861,
0.0584587939,
-0.0105305053,
0.0177148767,
0.1197667271,
0.0254482403,
-0.0905598029,
0.0021546362,
0.0070509017,
0.0076235584,
0.0130959377,
0.0260763094,
-0.0252073891,
-0.0297699496,
-0.0007835528,
0.0578957461,
0.0281900056,
-0.0051223342,
-0.0146621149,
-0.0758132115,
0.0472876132,
-0.018943876,
0.0133496756,
-0.0435261279,
-0.0849637315,
-0.02337211,
-0.0373565368,
0.0501478165,
0.0141369784,
0.0082239956,
0.0208434109,
0.0114511875,
-0.0065566367,
-0.0361798294,
0.0331159607,
-0.0404013693,
0.0424636677,
0.0520161092,
0.044192683,
0.0031940206,
-0.0260981973,
-0.0160783827,
-0.0082201846,
-0.0142685836,
-0.0077287932,
0.0546531901,
0.0066462173,
0.0142967524,
-0.0388031155,
0.0755720437,
-0.0572024919,
-0.0214201417,
-0.0104677947,
0.0739217922,
-0.0104572223,
0.0072244075,
0.0160263609,
-0.034041509,
0.0365145616,
0.1024100706,
0.0079604937,
-0.0436502174,
0.0000647852,
-0.0638070852,
-0.0370238125,
0.0097615225,
0.0055130757,
-0.01033697,
0.0097493753,
0.0021472415,
-0.030789027,
-0.0424102582,
-0.0157590359,
0.0266037527,
0.0024541959,
0.0593895912,
-0.0223814026,
-0.0283673983,
-0.0107197398,
0.0329743139,
0.0187389962,
0.038275931,
-0.0369628519,
0.0158377588,
0.0006087828,
-0.0674319714,
-0.0070289639,
0.0010757003,
-0.0269345753,
-0.0160248149,
-0.0717860609,
0.03738603,
0.0267105531,
0.0494164936,
-0.0459853522,
-0.078262642,
-0.0256910957,
-0.0070733125,
-0.0457970574,
-0.0500092134,
0.0216980409,
0.0570453331,
0.0260755047,
0.0519381166,
-0.038186539,
-0.0156355612,
-0.0137701016,
0.0080768941,
-0.01386749,
-0.0139422426,
0.03672041,
0.0322592221,
0.0643946603,
-0.0178739969,
0.0308547691,
-0.0536631458,
0.0194433518,
-0.0236727167,
-0.0300501734,
-0.0498104952,
0.0438701212,
0.061950963,
-0.0376296937,
-0.0265900679,
-0.0366276354,
-0.0128804818,
-0.0001659936,
-0.0483125113,
0.0130688939,
-0.0451238751,
-0.0341275595,
0.011449228,
0.0155367954,
-0.0069515426,
-0.0143035883,
0.0342631489,
0.0280024856,
0.0187443327,
0.0895328149,
0.0220518038,
-0.004269979,
-0.0128953606,
0.0226654578,
-0.0090182843,
-0.0671407282,
0.0090339752,
0.0060699056,
0.0106223067,
-0.0467414781,
0.0729335696,
-0.0184123777,
-0.008912011,
-0.0268301331,
0.0682564154,
0.0383281708,
-0.0022896102,
0.0421285219,
0.0361844599,
-0.0456681587,
-0.0009407574,
0.1061976403,
-0.0016689805,
-0.0241690204,
-0.008635723,
-0.0758222714,
-0.0239412468,
0.0011575487,
-0.0160928592,
0.0783530995,
-0.0431602001,
-0.0163736679,
-0.0037578321,
-0.0543020554,
-0.0359912589,
-0.0458649062,
0.0183126554,
-0.043812003,
0.0226919372,
0.0791616216,
-0.0234043468,
-0.0065616886,
-0.0701133311,
-0.0463955402,
-0.0148997651,
-0.0029115179,
-0.0287299417,
-7.030664038e-33,
0.0229460634,
-0.0521676652,
-0.0063154567,
-0.0072337314,
-0.0004597734,
0.0049750009,
-0.0456543565,
-0.0116929468,
0.0223787297,
0.042978093,
0.0061524906,
0.0123144574,
0.0129728867,
0.0260361563,
-0.0027823604,
-0.0361973345,
0.0553888641,
0.0579916388,
-0.0193805248,
0.0555713549,
0.0697291121,
0.023810843,
0.0177506898,
-0.0712757409,
0.0676027089,
0.0073862211,
-0.0341218486,
0.0241343603,
0.0009982766,
0.074600175,
-0.0217859074,
0.0649143606,
0.00723331,
-0.0679868162,
0.0255424529,
-0.0078025181,
-0.0602808557,
0.0050710463,
0.0550111085,
-0.0089025218,
-0.021644704,
-0.0402809568,
-0.0324804187,
-0.0057400493,
0.0111439256,
0.0063661714,
0.0394289121,
-0.0241302755,
-0.0310560428,
-0.0101706795,
-0.014389663,
0.0215648841,
-0.0279335771,
-0.0326648355,
0.0401888639,
0.0298510529,
-0.0125812078,
0.0581444129,
-0.0234453976,
-0.0086283591,
-0.0243179072,
0.0329141505,
0.0237736627,
-0.0457484946,
-0.0571157113,
0.0351996571,
-0.0204063393,
-0.0115443459,
-0.0387802646,
0.0202529524,
-0.0724022761,
0.0574574396,
0.0404902585,
0.0356355235,
-0.005362587,
-0.0122962194,
-0.0782990232,
0.0402664356,
0.0273260847,
-0.0071039945,
0.0619166307,
0.0395503044,
-0.0423842333,
-0.0516417474,
-0.0275476202,
-0.017490577,
-0.0510381684,
-0.0456214063,
0.0187966079,
0.0152144423,
-0.0375042409,
0.0066916831,
0.0016918256,
-0.0534476042,
-0.0422332101,
0.0219505895,
-0.0548857413,
-0.0261284821,
0.0216915477,
0.0225092378,
-0.0326658636,
-0.0068125743,
-0.0129890377,
-0.0269430671,
-0.0231697224,
0.0159927309,
0.0508599915,
0.0209599603,
-0.0290248003,
0.0097292,
-0.0315287299,
-0.0239348095,
-0.0400291048,
0.0225455351,
0.0208521113,
0.0146681732,
-0.0281904079,
0.0963207707,
0.0325177088,
0.0297717787,
-0.0014843041,
-0.0546154082,
-0.0177574959,
-0.010811734,
0.0008621051,
-0.0345207378,
0.0011029969,
-0.0411188193,
0.0419355668,
-0.0532161891,
-0.024415018,
-0.0138982199,
2.993e-7,
0.0092169922,
0.0551334359,
-0.0290068742,
-0.0131451618,
0.0187090021,
0.0491668135,
0.0406523198,
-0.0012407271,
0.0022516665,
0.0255808923,
0.0315878093,
0.0023580357,
0.0483220033,
0.0121040102,
-0.0313543901,
-0.0104054017,
-0.0340188146,
-0.0330680832,
-0.0724507496,
0.025260292,
0.0557259507,
0.0890976042,
0.0587644204,
-0.0004458022,
0.0288766362,
-0.0045102001,
0.0440756157,
-0.083878167,
-0.0278612413,
0.0194856841,
0.0749073029,
-0.0019015892,
-0.0017233127,
0.0044199894,
-0.0327760503,
-0.0048207408,
-0.0065608863,
0.051377032,
0.0073349341,
-0.0026123538,
-0.0039401376,
-0.018309148,
0.0347822756,
-0.1005782858,
0.0726099014,
0.0066183149,
-0.0449800231,
0.01466987,
-0.0427576043,
-0.0483546853,
0.0112151308,
-0.0197548438,
0.003752342,
0.0080921054,
-0.007248085,
-0.0184361506,
0.0081424797,
-0.0545445904,
-0.012845749,
0.0112269064,
-0.0207569618,
-0.0125539443,
-0.0381928645,
0.0038136898,
0.0518554822,
-0.0737999976,
0.0239680838,
3.004015073e-34,
0.0505389012,
0.0258146506,
-0.0020012339,
0.0012895092,
0.0528635643,
0.0268129222,
-0.0408369862,
-0.0033236491,
0.0597665384,
-0.0209590904,
-0.0143667022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17839v1 | Global-Liar: Factuality of LLMs over Time and Geographic Regions | 2024-01-31T13:57:24 | 2024-01-31T13:57:24 | Shujaat Mirza, Bruno Coelho, Yuyuan Cui, Christina Pöpper, Damon McCoy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The increasing reliance on AI-driven solutions, particularly Large Language
Models (LLMs) like the GPT series, for information retrieval highlights the
critical need for their factuality and fairness, especially amidst the rampant
spread of misinformation and disinformation online. Our study evaluates the
factual accuracy, stability, and biases in widely adopted GPT models, including
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, contributing to reliability and integrity of AI-mediated
information dissemination.
We introduce 'Global-Liar,' a dataset uniquely balanced in terms of
geographic and temporal representation, facilitating a more nuanced evaluation
of LLM biases. Our analysis reveals that newer iterations of GPT models do not
always equate to improved performance. Notably, the GPT-4 version from March
demonstrates higher factual accuracy than its subsequent June release.
Furthermore, a concerning bias is observed, privileging statements from the
Global North over the Global South, thus potentially exacerbating existing
informational inequities. Regions such as Africa and the Middle East are at a
disadvantage, with much lower factual accuracy. The performance fluctuations
over time suggest that model updates may not consistently benefit all regions
equally.
Our study also offers insights into the impact of various LLM configuration
settings, such as binary decision forcing, model re-runs and temperature, on
model's factuality. Models constrained to binary (true/false) choices exhibit
reduced factuality compared to those allowing an 'unclear' option. Single
inference at a low temperature setting matches the reliability of majority
voting across various configurations. The insights gained highlight the need
for culturally diverse and geographically inclusive model training and
evaluation. This approach is key to achieving global equity in technology,
distributing AI benefits fairly worldwide. | Global-Liar: Factuality of LLMs over Time and Geographic Regions: The increasing reliance on AI-driven solutions, particularly Large Language
Models (LLMs) like the GPT series, for information retrieval highlights the
critical need for their factuality and fairness, especially amidst the rampant
spread of misinformation and disinformation online. Our study evaluates the
factual accuracy, stability, and biases in widely adopted GPT models, including
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, contributing to reliability and integrity of AI-mediated
information dissemination.
We introduce 'Global-Liar,' a dataset uniquely balanced in terms of
geographic and temporal representation, facilitating a more nuanced evaluation
of LLM biases. Our analysis reveals that newer iterations of GPT models do not
always equate to improved performance. Notably, the GPT-4 version from March
demonstrates higher factual accuracy than its subsequent June release.
Furthermore, a concerning bias is observed, privileging statements from the
Global North over the Global South, thus potentially exacerbating existing
informational inequities. Regions such as Africa and the Middle East are at a
disadvantage, with much lower factual accuracy. The performance fluctuations
over time suggest that model updates may not consistently benefit all regions
equally.
Our study also offers insights into the impact of various LLM configuration
settings, such as binary decision forcing, model re-runs and temperature, on
model's factuality. Models constrained to binary (true/false) choices exhibit
reduced factuality compared to those allowing an 'unclear' option. Single
inference at a low temperature setting matches the reliability of majority
voting across various configurations. The insights gained highlight the need
for culturally diverse and geographically inclusive model training and
evaluation. This approach is key to achieving global equity in technology,
distributing AI benefits fairly worldwide. | [
0.056011416,
0.0691162869,
-0.0376442261,
0.0000237806,
-0.0501105115,
0.0071296403,
0.0505606644,
-0.0176414121,
0.0381627679,
-0.0330285393,
0.009696533,
-0.0280684065,
0.0349220783,
0.0166380927,
0.006334383,
-0.0455737449,
0.0696485192,
0.007284333,
0.0244909041,
-0.0487447679,
-0.0108974576,
0.01907086,
0.0001401049,
0.0447028801,
-0.0260200091,
0.0192630421,
0.025844859,
-0.0226919744,
0.014080788,
-0.0003748772,
0.0004273891,
0.0331275985,
0.0117918178,
0.042609401,
0.0000020866,
-0.0350706391,
-0.0319388397,
0.0022260705,
-0.0306002647,
0.0307255685,
0.0353967994,
0.0277674329,
-0.0021187549,
0.0287018772,
-0.0570564047,
0.0021055194,
0.037654344,
-0.000225567,
0.0440142155,
0.0611118674,
0.0059595737,
0.0282774642,
0.0067472877,
-0.0039523616,
-0.0314853974,
-0.0201669428,
0.0259580575,
-0.0057159066,
-0.0476453267,
0.0180450082,
0.0108749196,
0.0439682342,
0.0220003873,
0.0165758282,
-0.0232272018,
0.0424954332,
-0.0646366328,
-0.0236888472,
0.0204887297,
0.0027327794,
0.0801818669,
-0.0123371072,
-0.0139521658,
0.0075026765,
-0.0042785788,
0.0104950676,
-0.0261628106,
0.0373778939,
-0.0336352848,
0.0485075675,
0.0288053211,
-0.0046565379,
0.0284599531,
0.052345369,
-0.0438265279,
0.1478445083,
-0.015264282,
-0.065290764,
-0.0066654589,
0.037677981,
0.0115681831,
-0.0330294594,
0.0114642419,
-0.0174766202,
-0.0189540572,
-0.0025950936,
0.0113930106,
0.0498072319,
0.0195939094,
-0.0521903709,
0.0205218382,
0.0311564151,
-0.0097053871,
0.0321122929,
0.0326851532,
0.0633111969,
-0.001770466,
0.044981245,
-0.0025107553,
-0.037155956,
-0.0213632733,
-0.0002541408,
0.046575781,
0.0102265934,
-0.016402794,
0.0533187725,
-0.0554169491,
-0.0219299458,
-0.0536397807,
0.0190143175,
-0.0140306093,
-0.003334943,
-0.0289752446,
-0.0102334116,
-0.0778739154,
0.0426797867,
-0.0357023142,
0.0223477408,
-0.0103104413,
-0.0843246803,
0.0096938759,
-0.0060446314,
-0.0184223522,
-0.0034065319,
-0.0010039451,
0.0276121348,
0.0045133219,
-0.0005207589,
-0.0643170178,
-0.0082159946,
-0.0037106108,
-0.0646673739,
-0.0016458324,
-0.0347132273,
0.0122738611,
-0.0038618168,
-0.0011449918,
-0.0173995979,
-0.0228782892,
0.0214067325,
-0.0366277657,
0.0161078833,
-0.0066423719,
0.0264888294,
0.0722598508,
0.0182904787,
-0.0047421968,
0.0941143706,
0.025541015,
0.0524907596,
0.0769374743,
0.023686083,
0.0057922024,
0.0033085274,
0.02801775,
0.0707227215,
-0.0071296613,
0.0064768693,
-0.0293762628,
-0.0133344876,
0.0130885327,
0.04882586,
-0.0067608547,
-0.0128274653,
0.0857109651,
0.0131084854,
-0.0119422758,
0.0149761438,
0.0023180749,
0.0409502909,
-0.0118485959,
0.0067941649,
-0.0742728785,
-0.0167886168,
-0.055646237,
-0.0053398488,
0.0601205863,
0.0826539025,
-0.0179787129,
-0.0392271169,
-0.0048964885,
0.0223981217,
0.036876563,
0.0215730779,
0.0304459371,
-0.0725732148,
0.008856209,
0.0208020974,
0.0579457358,
-0.0277332738,
-0.021941131,
-0.0677137971,
0.0207658391,
0.0249294396,
0.0016401393,
-0.0023857688,
-0.0064068916,
-0.0040911008,
0.0014571807,
0.0307680648,
0.0435025506,
0.0153313251,
-0.0091848783,
-0.0131239025,
-0.0532813594,
0.0178303365,
0.0281086154,
0.0435018539,
0.0673382059,
0.0775725469,
0.0048826281,
-0.0607576445,
-0.0020035647,
0.0142985433,
-0.0198420137,
0.0170170758,
-0.0216709636,
0.0192677416,
0.0390464738,
0.0116592767,
-0.0319195166,
-0.0169577859,
-0.0089171138,
0.0119737517,
-0.0374055319,
0.0021041355,
-0.0392254815,
0.0640841499,
0.0178187769,
-0.0190808829,
0.0286641177,
0.0335856527,
-0.0087809544,
-0.004986125,
0.0253998637,
0.019487448,
0.0220509097,
-0.0234544948,
-0.005864758,
-0.0484144725,
0.0170179214,
-0.0109025938,
0.0438800827,
-0.0362853631,
-0.0123430267,
0.0005807853,
-0.0299092568,
0.0492726862,
-0.0298902113,
0.0077876919,
0.0412541442,
0.0286863912,
-0.0059899674,
0.0610045828,
-0.0057756626,
-0.0246843603,
0.0070822048,
-0.1153343394,
-0.014125159,
-0.0326921456,
-0.0060352995,
-0.0004929202,
-0.0183307305,
-0.0423317775,
0.0184292551,
-0.0399755836,
-0.0400091186,
0.0162259992,
0.0551620722,
0.0157473497,
-0.0219531339,
0.0256196409,
-0.0317011029,
-0.0140197389,
-0.0157442242,
0.0287244767,
0.0192948915,
-0.0393677428,
-0.0310006756,
-0.012295953,
-0.0746799782,
0.034469232,
-0.055483371,
-0.0220698267,
0.0096796341,
0.0229486022,
-0.0315136574,
0.0406202599,
0.0260718502,
0.0284921173,
0.0537176132,
0.0097120982,
-0.073196657,
0.0036163889,
0.0099026123,
0.0022912037,
-0.0078588752,
-0.0955964699,
0.001753012,
0.0307208002,
0.053932935,
0.0091867577,
-0.0240352191,
0.0315061398,
-0.0799247921,
-0.0717232376,
-0.0315199383,
-0.0113066379,
-0.0000458348,
0.072926119,
-0.0283813868,
-0.0922158882,
0.0544206277,
-0.0183357913,
0.0513215326,
-0.0274728294,
-0.0404716507,
-0.0196828656,
0.0245069731,
-0.0181650538,
0.0227709059,
-0.0029666456,
-0.0004889774,
-0.0441309921,
-0.0638746396,
0.0625387132,
-0.0280184206,
0.0192955304,
-0.0421837308,
-0.0019785964,
-0.0102208182,
-0.0560867861,
-0.0152452756,
-0.0574298874,
-0.0051931464,
0.0039799432,
0.0257109422,
-0.0637255907,
-0.0435604788,
0.0133034019,
0.0724741966,
0.0426254943,
-0.0344997793,
0.0052425815,
0.0217383336,
-0.061570283,
0.0272546709,
0.0118598007,
0.0351060517,
-0.0072152303,
-0.039568007,
0.0227744095,
0.0163651798,
-0.0051353876,
0.0068216259,
-0.0116600674,
0.0363106355,
-0.0216976888,
-0.0458217673,
-0.0192002431,
0.0341023542,
-0.0285676364,
0.0144099444,
0.0932988673,
0.0041470071,
-0.074985601,
-0.0227090623,
-0.00687738,
0.0202682111,
0.0102171907,
0.0087709408,
-0.1200001612,
0.0282704383,
0.0261077248,
0.0248884913,
-0.0710822791,
-0.0208595786,
-0.0100274887,
-0.1060819551,
0.0617454611,
0.0174013209,
-0.0068390802,
-0.0526119545,
-0.0679792762,
-0.0252369083,
-0.0274368059,
0.0390251428,
-0.0172925163,
0.016442474,
0.0169406421,
0.0141454116,
-0.0855810642,
-0.0398388617,
0.0280221999,
-0.0305288266,
0.0289196372,
0.0573865473,
0.0316831209,
-0.0255647451,
-0.0347750559,
-0.0084080081,
0.0222297497,
-0.0133239329,
-0.0140430033,
0.0420476682,
-0.0161074139,
0.0072093266,
-0.0281568021,
-0.0263394415,
0.0359848067,
0.0214884859,
0.0128393658,
0.0448567607,
-0.0139753958,
-0.0026894736,
-0.0186860785,
-0.0086327903,
0.0111727146,
0.0539953522,
-0.0264844391,
0.003014684,
-0.0175321251,
-0.0505042486,
0.020807622,
-0.0045942855,
-0.0308481641,
0.0511710681,
-0.0269754902,
-0.036827825,
-0.0119640157,
-0.0491544902,
-0.0210013464,
0.014349672,
-0.0079504577,
-0.02209167,
0.0612779297,
0.0066438536,
-0.0159256849,
-0.0072518229,
-0.0462841168,
0.0135875409,
-0.0038370439,
-0.0174320359,
0.0050329175,
-0.0149259167,
0.0069802795,
0.0166419297,
-0.0304059871,
-0.0441689789,
0.0391166732,
0.0101204328,
0.0337316766,
0.0420944095,
-0.0083289854,
-0.0063845944,
0.0779079646,
0.0247408003,
-0.0015071118,
0.0310007185,
0.0188275073,
0.0252864212,
0.000134722,
0.0248201769,
-0.0303296018,
0.0051072016,
0.0050633322,
-0.0180341732,
-0.0355802365,
-0.0229850486,
0.0449107923,
0.0059804074,
0.0485101826,
-0.0150742596,
-0.0316005312,
-0.0423455797,
-0.0066314382,
-0.0037034948,
-0.0096212113,
0.0000705485,
-0.0017984823,
0.0362725854,
0.0094026439,
-0.0072532366,
0.0140426494,
-0.0239091311,
-0.0061373473,
-0.0567489043,
0.0052295523,
-0.0310820062,
0.0656278357,
-0.015698202,
0.0073911459,
-0.0341027491,
0.0088655408,
-0.0110987714,
0.0508359037,
-0.0070509817,
0.0324889943,
0.0150177497,
-0.0179121606,
-0.0030405985,
0.0240484979,
-0.0832056925,
-0.053126093,
-0.0324769169,
0.0097863618,
0.0628802478,
0.0182950161,
0.0223468691,
0.0000657653,
-0.0138775967,
0.0061439364,
-0.0277574323,
0.0226269718,
-0.0200855918,
-0.0107566081,
-0.0217250567,
-0.0563935861,
0.0577757508,
0.0667412356,
0.004313637,
0.0459358841,
-0.0114912866,
-0.0683129132,
0.0031908548,
-0.0536041893,
-0.0081704659,
-0.0143206175,
-0.0123104723,
-0.0264581367,
-0.0896629095,
-0.0487226732,
-0.0030211725,
0.0035552399,
0.0008472507,
-0.0378082581,
-0.0210099258,
0.1059795767,
-0.0062074834,
-0.0247900374,
-0.0678498372,
-0.0160075054,
-0.0405702069,
0.0033282891,
-0.0065460624,
-7.133289103e-33,
-0.0119083636,
-0.0053140335,
0.0159976073,
-0.0437840223,
-0.0359555557,
0.0216659363,
0.015195922,
0.0051302775,
-0.0811995342,
0.0303271022,
-0.0154956086,
0.0257927105,
0.0252738073,
-0.0159489252,
0.0082711466,
-0.0143155353,
0.0131800408,
0.0110988142,
-0.0402531363,
0.019970281,
0.0588825382,
-0.0108970525,
0.0829384625,
-0.0927543342,
0.061690107,
0.0046642395,
-0.0333495885,
0.0147274332,
-0.0366239138,
0.0303568654,
0.0015816523,
0.0752096474,
0.03941283,
-0.0441529863,
0.0080950921,
-0.047095146,
-0.0379806235,
-0.0250801463,
0.0211877469,
-0.01023883,
0.0202640966,
-0.0048440392,
-0.0008352349,
0.0059305513,
-0.0722114816,
0.0332115106,
0.0312563069,
-0.0009424025,
-0.0085427864,
0.0009168455,
-0.0041783205,
0.0267980341,
0.0004808663,
0.0527640246,
-0.0729563013,
0.0625192672,
0.014521963,
0.0609058179,
-0.0869341269,
0.0409225896,
0.0633687153,
0.0150553929,
0.0673876628,
-0.0302996617,
0.010278469,
0.0778494999,
0.0255220849,
0.0235544778,
-0.0740946606,
-0.0843360126,
0.0315161198,
-0.0276793949,
0.0007509095,
0.0956591293,
-0.0023821981,
-0.0607633293,
-0.0570675842,
0.0170049388,
0.0364114568,
0.0455586314,
0.0118013974,
-0.0131925885,
-0.0870466977,
-0.0498862565,
-0.0177908745,
-0.0499036945,
-0.0219648331,
-0.0224889666,
0.0347392149,
0.0165989511,
0.0170522295,
0.0352282822,
0.0214663465,
-0.0284253657,
0.0005281334,
-0.0023230372,
-0.0022885632,
-0.0104506155,
0.0222850293,
0.0264312718,
-0.0639562011,
-0.0144025097,
-0.0414571613,
0.0513209291,
-0.0153435804,
0.0230284967,
-0.0119390814,
0.0165238976,
-0.059643764,
0.0145132383,
-0.0246573277,
0.015287525,
-0.0062164604,
-0.0605063699,
0.0143006584,
-0.0236706343,
0.0081930384,
0.0202739555,
0.0279137623,
0.0515445024,
-0.0338443853,
-0.0115768015,
-0.0224510636,
0.0355516449,
0.006748118,
-0.0091881528,
-0.0331154466,
0.0206587669,
-0.002788305,
-0.0461838357,
-0.0101628331,
-0.0206758566,
2.798e-7,
0.0077563901,
0.0563733131,
-0.004780421,
0.0200184043,
-0.0035258119,
0.0528804697,
0.0092749381,
-0.0006573505,
0.0212691315,
-0.0052340101,
-0.0149063924,
0.0331493914,
0.0329535902,
0.064558208,
-0.0526228733,
0.0202587172,
-0.0672843754,
-0.009061221,
-0.05680741,
0.0219024662,
-0.0007106099,
0.0630041882,
0.0412557609,
-0.0014143781,
-0.0099360971,
-0.0460539684,
0.0340156443,
-0.0412862636,
-0.041580148,
0.0045896852,
0.0589773841,
0.0063097198,
0.0396236256,
0.0008745933,
-0.006698804,
0.0116164787,
-0.0323408395,
0.034756273,
0.0104269153,
-0.0076506087,
-0.0414633155,
-0.0372445732,
0.0123568913,
-0.1087378338,
0.0737832412,
0.0169949941,
-0.0374672487,
-0.035455998,
-0.0147076081,
0.002899213,
0.0725832805,
-0.0158563256,
-0.0268227216,
0.0062765377,
-0.0138544869,
0.0330174863,
0.0018587079,
-0.031498082,
0.0158924423,
-0.0379760265,
-0.019958796,
-0.07350339,
0.0071205078,
0.0206606351,
0.009911784,
-0.0153300725,
0.0608414002,
2.723161233e-34,
0.0325371772,
0.0134953111,
0.0176655203,
-0.0206318907,
0.0692741126,
0.0341734253,
0.0032773525,
-0.0191357899,
-0.0039500822,
0.0018992237,
-0.0019994811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01765v1 | LLMs Simulate Big Five Personality Traits: Further Evidence | 2024-01-31T13:45:25 | 2024-01-31T13:45:25 | Aleksandra Sorokovikova, Natalia Fedorova, Sharwin Rezagholi, Ivan P. Yamshchikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; J.4; I.2.1 | An empirical investigation into the simulation of the Big Five personality
traits by large language models (LLMs), namely Llama2, GPT4, and Mixtral, is
presented. We analyze the personality traits simulated by these models and
their stability. This contributes to the broader understanding of the
capabilities of LLMs to simulate personality traits and the respective
implications for personalized human-computer interaction. | LLMs Simulate Big Five Personality Traits: Further Evidence: An empirical investigation into the simulation of the Big Five personality
traits by large language models (LLMs), namely Llama2, GPT4, and Mixtral, is
presented. We analyze the personality traits simulated by these models and
their stability. This contributes to the broader understanding of the
capabilities of LLMs to simulate personality traits and the respective
implications for personalized human-computer interaction. | [
0.0544709153,
0.0181485489,
-0.0478511192,
0.0136652999,
-0.0090780687,
0.0034809541,
0.0270890854,
-0.0186225288,
0.0447811373,
0.0107208146,
-0.0410961024,
-0.0139697548,
-0.0249741599,
0.0009329407,
0.0249817148,
-0.0611962527,
0.0569678359,
-0.0279002413,
0.0049866,
-0.017196903,
-0.0039688027,
0.0355037861,
0.0157509744,
0.0282270629,
0.0069381343,
-0.0209756587,
0.0072380463,
-0.0084169395,
0.0216320697,
-0.0175512861,
0.0118930992,
0.0607195012,
0.0280475654,
0.0148629304,
0.0000017972,
-0.0369876586,
0.0104606319,
-0.0097521655,
0.0242480636,
0.0405901,
0.1033030972,
0.0873648599,
-0.0010036209,
0.0565439127,
-0.0369297378,
-0.0224482976,
0.0152101163,
0.056776993,
0.0727964491,
0.0305747911,
-0.0055484772,
-0.0366914831,
-0.0155787505,
-0.0035209209,
0.0305653065,
0.0025152683,
0.0226749964,
-0.0135926409,
0.0242915377,
0.0351658612,
0.0111342762,
-0.0263097677,
-0.0159557443,
0.0149072744,
-0.0371166877,
-0.0046155434,
-0.0346482135,
-0.0197337475,
-0.0223312061,
0.0288623329,
0.0410684943,
-0.0267631374,
-0.0060527269,
-0.0096274624,
0.0317377821,
-0.0154139772,
0.0065235691,
0.0049046869,
-0.02202731,
-0.0323598571,
0.0370079093,
0.0140353115,
-0.0206856932,
-0.0071625998,
-0.0038828289,
0.0549000055,
0.0064023072,
-0.0339554586,
0.0073123109,
-0.0257094335,
0.0292407665,
-0.0278901868,
0.0187110659,
0.0032209905,
-0.0161874052,
0.0136615895,
-0.0421096683,
0.0324843489,
0.0405260548,
-0.0532433465,
0.0060649016,
0.0177852418,
-0.0255981777,
-0.0200016126,
0.0562686101,
0.0289896484,
0.0069007142,
-0.0305372123,
-0.0080294702,
0.0035628215,
-0.0526266322,
-0.0058447002,
0.0273776408,
0.0195090752,
0.0293444488,
-0.028439926,
-0.081472151,
0.0454245433,
0.0028336982,
-0.0000236145,
0.0043039555,
-0.0229966603,
0.012687277,
0.0459495224,
-0.0565130152,
0.0004431684,
-0.0751618817,
0.0018312265,
-0.0054395925,
-0.0498205237,
0.0671337321,
-0.0138067482,
-0.0093864482,
-0.0361480266,
0.0490941852,
0.0574110001,
0.0244688764,
-0.0336450264,
-0.0415251553,
-0.033062771,
-0.0073699155,
-0.0582811832,
0.0162760187,
-0.028637765,
0.0391014479,
-0.0082054483,
-0.0096853664,
-0.0313455313,
-0.0009848741,
0.0395504646,
0.0016079161,
0.0375424996,
-0.0197127257,
0.0045499485,
0.0277107749,
-0.0003496162,
0.0300355051,
0.0240864307,
-0.0308712553,
0.0226697885,
0.026116088,
-0.0591893606,
0.051912792,
0.0490388274,
-0.0298392456,
0.0157862101,
-0.0144078415,
-0.0330593809,
0.0230616331,
0.002113749,
0.0493623279,
0.0523828231,
-0.0213963594,
0.0051280688,
0.095853433,
0.0853479207,
0.0516119748,
0.0573475808,
-0.0088578407,
0.0309361629,
0.0698028207,
-0.0285903849,
-0.0271253902,
0.0266860556,
-0.0275724214,
0.0121634891,
-0.0384704657,
0.0477359258,
-0.0013857607,
-0.0253630411,
-0.0207817573,
-0.0158529542,
0.019025458,
0.0116724838,
-0.0280702971,
-0.0543522239,
-0.0028906439,
-0.0115725389,
0.0265408065,
-0.0682849735,
-0.056806583,
-0.0451478027,
0.0090508377,
0.1423734725,
0.0060037524,
0.0057107275,
-0.0031956278,
-0.031501703,
-0.0607031323,
0.0234276243,
0.0506633185,
0.004259862,
-0.0169452354,
-0.0626077577,
0.0332117267,
0.0012467921,
-0.0133874016,
0.0173646845,
-0.0112973973,
0.0177600048,
-0.0158338062,
0.0601470694,
0.0161386561,
-0.0224589407,
-0.0576939546,
-0.0433924347,
-0.024175467,
0.0093003269,
0.0359760784,
0.0256421175,
0.0147113819,
-0.0167222172,
-0.0078272866,
0.0095476471,
0.0133444751,
0.0397320762,
0.0117682004,
0.0406750552,
0.0256480444,
0.0207943767,
0.0160980653,
0.0165375415,
0.0322794877,
0.0018140955,
-0.0048033078,
-0.0408557132,
0.0549947433,
-0.013775018,
0.0277402122,
-0.0409914218,
0.0929044858,
0.0136057241,
0.0388247669,
-0.03095535,
-0.0148949567,
0.0280827843,
-0.0114107328,
-0.0237453692,
-0.0634862334,
-0.0412995927,
-0.034093596,
0.0183668323,
0.0526052564,
-0.016432425,
0.007592625,
-0.0503904596,
-0.0745215118,
-0.0436717495,
-0.0039267489,
0.0409163684,
0.0120461527,
0.0154870721,
-0.0094283,
-0.061369691,
0.0241057258,
-0.0364945456,
-0.0128402021,
0.0077711642,
0.0273858756,
0.0292450674,
-0.0264513101,
-0.0397139862,
-0.0578749068,
-0.0144543108,
-0.0417584218,
0.0033363719,
-0.0375198163,
0.0433613993,
-0.000126747,
0.0061002644,
-0.0506741516,
0.0153093953,
-0.0094845193,
-0.0670847371,
0.0356958732,
-0.0090242391,
0.0527596325,
0.0497047976,
0.0421527587,
0.0524698757,
-0.0001573392,
-0.0189246088,
-0.0178246032,
0.005902349,
-0.0055088405,
-0.0109054595,
-0.0324721895,
-0.0909966007,
-0.0266663134,
0.0505233034,
0.0032994258,
0.0350608118,
-0.0223655868,
0.0518521667,
0.0350457914,
-0.0409562513,
0.068911694,
0.0300035756,
-0.0425917283,
0.0520273373,
0.0417164117,
-0.0084157046,
0.0380980819,
-0.0236898884,
0.0189346727,
-0.0058066621,
-0.0433252007,
-0.0067620045,
0.0237323269,
-0.011427396,
-0.0294461269,
0.0406942554,
-0.0010733656,
0.0180507395,
-0.0592409372,
0.0146008851,
-0.0444512665,
0.0207303241,
0.0150928861,
-0.069309406,
0.0529252142,
0.0076684495,
0.0088783558,
-0.0459406078,
-0.0584731773,
-0.0258563496,
0.0469569378,
-0.0212423708,
-0.0240554474,
-0.0184889268,
0.0306146387,
-0.0319560505,
-0.0285712052,
0.005868305,
0.0185902789,
-0.0418922715,
0.0645912513,
0.0334804282,
0.002552618,
-0.069198817,
-0.0306499656,
-0.0331192426,
-0.0416965149,
-0.0053303251,
0.0002789166,
0.0087732794,
0.0280871838,
-0.0101019964,
-0.0400366485,
0.0277388897,
0.0106677758,
0.003275258,
0.0169879515,
0.1130789593,
0.0194115285,
-0.0061703436,
0.0221101493,
-0.0282159112,
0.0188432187,
0.0384532325,
0.0724520832,
-0.0277951695,
-0.0057924562,
-0.0262490176,
0.0199225619,
-0.0386882685,
-0.0291038807,
-0.0031068963,
-0.0801818371,
0.0257012304,
0.0086320434,
-0.0531635508,
0.0057063946,
-0.004572372,
0.0008168523,
-0.0110446336,
0.0075897588,
-0.0300303232,
0.0013075727,
-0.027977068,
-0.0093108835,
-0.0898374468,
-0.0242515244,
0.0945600718,
-0.0204500817,
0.056403432,
0.0149065424,
0.0264010467,
-0.0306105781,
-0.073276028,
-0.0683763251,
0.0192899741,
0.0260613486,
0.0152544631,
0.0353482515,
-0.0219878238,
0.0302317161,
-0.1127673686,
-0.0074634515,
0.0115960529,
0.0352476574,
0.0188874006,
0.0379701108,
-0.014011425,
-0.0531183295,
-0.0511430949,
0.0288941376,
0.0298963003,
0.0236527454,
-0.0195601974,
-0.1021753252,
-0.0146957524,
-0.0186846647,
-0.0247257277,
-0.0102542257,
-0.087544091,
-0.0173482355,
0.0415094122,
-0.0342920534,
-0.0151596544,
-0.0933787674,
-0.0226158034,
0.0206394885,
-0.0139123611,
-0.025565736,
-0.021177372,
0.0185610615,
-0.0040065842,
-0.0178426541,
0.0010050718,
0.0197656136,
-0.0379864462,
-0.0032793044,
0.0715842471,
-0.0575968139,
0.0163997412,
0.0316649564,
-0.0623220988,
-0.0429212004,
0.0434729047,
0.0407480039,
0.0272106547,
-0.0087371645,
0.0213632174,
-0.0590516962,
0.0061679701,
-0.010978098,
-0.0132694645,
0.0719022378,
-0.0000100759,
0.0483196191,
0.0139632029,
-0.0016633325,
-0.0104861092,
0.0316051245,
-0.0260619316,
-0.0214832611,
-0.0162418708,
-0.0861394405,
-0.0229671691,
0.0413172841,
-0.0394983217,
-0.0059336643,
-0.0029925799,
0.0001587915,
-0.0176425204,
-0.0720549971,
0.0044198139,
0.0188289955,
-0.0630012751,
-0.0163117703,
0.0050790044,
-0.0218568146,
-0.0737214163,
-0.0242625959,
0.0063017304,
-0.0270753149,
0.0249124877,
0.0117452685,
0.032811705,
-0.0269333459,
0.0033560065,
-0.0352377966,
-0.0069998461,
0.007212589,
0.0524578691,
0.0017261081,
0.0818363428,
-0.0511799455,
-0.007727596,
-0.0160487145,
0.0601740517,
-0.0205711275,
-0.0230836254,
0.0111769037,
0.0134165268,
-0.0156347379,
0.0077850395,
0.0355222784,
-0.034674719,
0.0136332763,
-0.0350852422,
0.0437451266,
-0.0027759988,
-0.030449938,
0.0257665142,
0.0053960518,
-0.0160799269,
-0.0497010686,
0.0166864228,
0.0278961454,
-0.0136471298,
-0.0036597035,
-0.0450402871,
-0.0682789758,
0.0291968267,
0.0151622528,
0.0246052295,
-0.0171793774,
-0.0443981662,
-0.0954694822,
-0.0884009302,
0.0677517503,
0.0151950568,
-0.0160444248,
-0.0393526629,
0.0218777843,
0.044094678,
-0.0112230973,
-0.017626632,
-0.0407864489,
0.0012715658,
-0.0330253467,
0.0052769179,
-0.0046589877,
-5.453294618e-33,
-0.0339539237,
0.0162268989,
0.0521707907,
0.0270276461,
-0.022483157,
-0.0729352608,
-0.0202102438,
0.0411449596,
-0.0296068415,
-0.0203340892,
-0.0440621711,
-0.0167361014,
0.0123277782,
-0.0546043403,
0.0314145498,
0.0304228868,
0.0205820408,
-0.005483862,
-0.0127034383,
-0.0095482254,
0.0026795976,
-0.0112084802,
0.0551050678,
-0.0683799535,
-0.0031366791,
-0.0393071659,
-0.0159650594,
-0.0322301723,
0.0211610831,
0.0585662834,
0.0039196671,
0.0485890694,
0.0171463173,
0.0100485645,
-0.0054011452,
0.0206875168,
-0.01450158,
-0.054816246,
0.0385913551,
0.0041334121,
0.0315865651,
-0.0519358367,
0.0108044725,
-0.0180349033,
-0.0466134548,
-0.0105171893,
0.0450173952,
-0.0093823271,
0.0174978916,
0.0328548625,
-0.0290579665,
-0.0125373136,
-0.008349956,
0.016600905,
-0.0188924726,
0.0058098086,
-0.0432106294,
-0.0002088495,
-0.0529573411,
0.0707230493,
-0.0094917966,
-0.036576055,
0.0291991923,
0.0271261018,
0.0383815989,
0.0294459108,
0.0722186267,
0.0638692901,
-0.0089094173,
-0.0303301644,
0.0568341687,
0.0465161242,
-0.0106827011,
0.0720213056,
-0.0486894771,
-0.082813397,
0.0374267735,
0.0079889214,
0.1370743662,
-0.0715476647,
0.0469040647,
0.0160410386,
-0.0543939695,
-0.0375388786,
0.0185247883,
0.0415560864,
-0.0168136787,
-0.0534151681,
0.0254955497,
-0.0581673048,
0.0097322892,
-0.0167807546,
0.0381923877,
-0.0193743948,
-0.0240397844,
0.0063853269,
-0.0385256931,
0.03294852,
-0.0212007966,
-0.0234976336,
-0.0352018699,
0.0006853467,
-0.0259528551,
0.0093552629,
0.0587000214,
0.0276198853,
-0.0281786881,
0.028894756,
-0.080076918,
-0.029668605,
0.0377408117,
0.0085426429,
0.0225525536,
0.0085043777,
0.0177577175,
-0.0279191993,
0.0089863464,
0.0076848036,
-0.0063195666,
0.0072803157,
-0.0482020602,
-0.0004334975,
0.0413196385,
-0.0066796592,
0.0001881319,
0.008922793,
-0.0723945349,
0.0397205837,
0.0386790968,
-0.0301962905,
0.0101266429,
-0.007107744,
2.523e-7,
-0.045626808,
0.0725234076,
-0.0395899937,
0.0354048908,
0.0259508267,
0.0584782399,
0.0188929122,
0.0031228235,
0.0547200106,
-0.0147542497,
0.021686241,
0.0276158061,
0.0270835198,
0.0338038951,
-0.0310230348,
0.0227399152,
-0.0047539403,
0.0292367302,
-0.036396347,
0.0088012619,
0.0602246337,
0.0528902411,
0.0400768444,
0.0021232585,
0.0061083636,
0.0423262045,
0.007342204,
-0.0089423405,
-0.0277795177,
0.0132979332,
-0.0400913022,
-0.0101815276,
-0.0086374022,
0.0442346819,
0.0027484188,
-0.0182617083,
-0.0109381489,
0.0696405172,
-0.0427286364,
-0.0032625759,
0.0504098237,
-0.006726644,
-0.0448606312,
-0.0212757159,
0.006446918,
0.0252754595,
-0.0388114825,
-0.0312413108,
-0.0325175449,
-0.049088452,
0.0193303935,
-0.0145421904,
-0.0016218043,
0.013626745,
-0.0092065781,
-0.0167029984,
-0.0137387058,
-0.0280800071,
0.0278636478,
0.0007524718,
-0.0451749451,
-0.0765857995,
-0.007500222,
0.0199709274,
0.05061692,
-0.0254348051,
0.0323931389,
1.853345808e-34,
-0.001404842,
0.0404426903,
0.0318594687,
-0.0014482606,
0.071476981,
0.0397050865,
0.0449104384,
0.0487141907,
0.0483170487,
-0.0550535433,
-0.0172390193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17827v1 | Neural Machine Translation for Malayalam Paraphrase Generation | 2024-01-31T13:40:00 | 2024-01-31T13:40:00 | Christeena Varghese, Sergey Koshelev, Ivan P. Yamshchikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.7.0; I.2.7 | This study explores four methods of generating paraphrases in Malayalam,
utilizing resources available for English paraphrasing and pre-trained Neural
Machine Translation (NMT) models. We evaluate the resulting paraphrases using
both automated metrics, such as BLEU, METEOR, and cosine similarity, as well as
human annotation. Our findings suggest that automated evaluation measures may
not be fully appropriate for Malayalam, as they do not consistently align with
human judgment. This discrepancy underscores the need for more nuanced
paraphrase evaluation approaches especially for highly agglutinative languages. | Neural Machine Translation for Malayalam Paraphrase Generation: This study explores four methods of generating paraphrases in Malayalam,
utilizing resources available for English paraphrasing and pre-trained Neural
Machine Translation (NMT) models. We evaluate the resulting paraphrases using
both automated metrics, such as BLEU, METEOR, and cosine similarity, as well as
human annotation. Our findings suggest that automated evaluation measures may
not be fully appropriate for Malayalam, as they do not consistently align with
human judgment. This discrepancy underscores the need for more nuanced
paraphrase evaluation approaches especially for highly agglutinative languages. | [
0.0646646693,
-0.0133634247,
-0.0238383077,
0.0594025403,
-0.0721061304,
-0.0208703391,
-0.0379944034,
0.0104224076,
-0.0423003957,
-0.0455611981,
0.0041369139,
-0.019340314,
0.0244862176,
-0.0463000722,
0.0302243605,
-0.0769499019,
-0.0060173129,
-0.0182148889,
-0.0144312847,
0.0262312256,
-0.005515127,
0.0404786021,
0.0052211517,
0.0553382859,
0.0240331013,
-0.0192793347,
0.0324281417,
0.0283619799,
0.0153535036,
-0.0389515311,
0.017100703,
-0.0067610345,
0.0041536391,
0.0411135741,
0.0000015408,
-0.0615708008,
0.0133353472,
-0.0224695075,
0.0300705377,
0.0302147139,
0.0704389662,
-0.0271883048,
0.043618314,
0.0275212731,
-0.0420070775,
0.0409800187,
0.0256189797,
-0.0242766514,
0.1086531952,
0.0417641178,
-0.017587468,
-0.0811830908,
-0.0180970579,
0.025839258,
-0.0137179662,
-0.024765553,
-0.0161556378,
-0.0256101377,
-0.0051741609,
-0.0512043387,
-0.0094705829,
0.0548828542,
-0.0325011127,
0.0173130222,
0.0183367208,
-0.0163372047,
-0.0149879307,
-0.0175418258,
0.0273170397,
0.0742661208,
-0.0608215258,
-0.02446297,
-0.0249140337,
0.0013091933,
-0.0470975935,
0.0315029137,
-0.0554453321,
0.0315523297,
-0.038556844,
0.0421313979,
0.0260038003,
0.0445120484,
-0.0089135244,
0.0339000039,
0.0663903356,
-0.0152367698,
0.0274287499,
-0.0163384303,
-0.0643576458,
-0.0037213825,
-0.0221132636,
0.0171289947,
0.0174423531,
0.0140303969,
-0.0060150502,
0.0263079219,
-0.0298410859,
-0.0690124929,
0.0430319868,
-0.103539139,
0.0718859732,
0.0373138934,
0.0219079256,
0.0132840071,
-0.0351817049,
0.0333034582,
-0.0283396933,
0.0586390831,
-0.0321890153,
-0.0208550245,
-0.0034667375,
-0.0085622333,
-0.0354404598,
0.0509976856,
-0.0280621145,
0.0054233014,
-0.0701187775,
-0.0044050356,
0.0395891778,
-0.0398807749,
0.0208859928,
0.0165055878,
-0.0458170772,
-0.0087614199,
-0.0177423712,
-0.0129382759,
-0.0149500081,
0.0202526655,
-0.0273706783,
-0.0595481358,
-0.0201622974,
0.0163802244,
-0.0066359406,
-0.0578465573,
-0.0322836228,
0.045836743,
-0.0125777628,
-0.0435516909,
-0.0410140269,
0.0010821201,
0.0102892434,
-0.0658366755,
-0.0223496258,
-0.0398842879,
0.066847153,
0.0176292416,
-0.0061997809,
-0.0367679857,
0.0128334425,
0.0442191437,
-0.0157794673,
0.0473821014,
0.0015162283,
-0.0031051454,
0.0011502742,
0.0214609373,
0.0332030319,
-0.0177415553,
0.0385349505,
0.028561376,
0.0385584161,
-0.0108224601,
-0.0176160783,
-0.0199633278,
0.0015535962,
0.002206974,
-0.0400667079,
0.0446212851,
-0.0354855582,
0.0854215547,
-0.0021279508,
0.0703845993,
-0.0249194261,
-0.0034395445,
0.0607628524,
0.0686227679,
-0.0022757174,
0.0809663311,
0.0692724884,
0.0309179556,
0.0506427623,
0.0287865549,
-0.0080885235,
0.0161315799,
-0.0138998833,
0.0586485118,
0.0307260063,
0.0638561472,
0.0058203456,
-0.0108987279,
-0.0203062445,
-0.0386589356,
-0.026976008,
-0.0302003324,
-0.026668679,
-0.0034044187,
-0.0669278204,
0.0332944654,
-0.0332410969,
-0.0810908899,
0.0427812673,
-0.063567102,
0.0287755653,
0.0583181344,
0.0644414127,
0.0008948597,
-0.0154580893,
0.0009615348,
-0.0195299126,
0.0635148585,
0.0249332711,
-0.0007037803,
0.0415264182,
-0.0411762781,
0.0412769355,
-0.0303153917,
0.0013203995,
-0.0049575656,
-0.0253365692,
0.0022086033,
0.0683063269,
-0.01045941,
-0.0721809939,
0.0534234755,
0.0249871388,
-0.0325071029,
0.0076542813,
-0.0040723607,
0.042325113,
0.0125567699,
0.0171257574,
0.0164730772,
0.0005297355,
-0.0162541457,
-0.0048719849,
0.04691834,
-0.0185780339,
-0.0538709946,
-0.0333890282,
-0.0918303728,
0.022883201,
0.0644198582,
-0.0030774649,
-0.0421276502,
0.0202889126,
-0.0519454107,
0.0513445511,
-0.0391832553,
0.0693316534,
-0.0550780743,
0.0082719242,
-0.0296097249,
0.033204671,
0.0300998352,
-0.0262975227,
0.0256648362,
-0.0400535762,
0.0720993206,
-0.0093065305,
-0.018822372,
-0.0089704059,
0.0853481069,
0.0445050709,
-0.0119615877,
-0.0083146365,
-0.0335268304,
-0.0360530168,
-0.057266783,
0.0036434892,
0.0012760692,
-0.0166232549,
0.050186038,
0.023182217,
0.0011664517,
-0.0232261755,
0.058020439,
-0.0085318238,
0.0535422526,
0.0069566527,
0.0428515039,
0.016175393,
0.0293613542,
-0.0725451261,
-0.0241948012,
0.0035443993,
0.0739393607,
0.0330126323,
-0.0179664325,
-0.0450619236,
-0.0210767575,
-0.0371730961,
-0.0501727238,
0.0212947503,
-0.0575662144,
-0.0047851396,
-0.0300958343,
0.0086255418,
0.0283868033,
0.0326553658,
-0.0276570935,
0.0225845054,
0.0279986765,
-0.0194764342,
-0.0533571653,
-0.0210738908,
-0.0246838611,
-0.0017929316,
-0.0041082902,
0.0320873074,
0.0145541355,
0.0507302843,
-0.0198513549,
-0.0403309353,
0.0337549746,
0.0040967404,
0.0227342229,
-0.0087699005,
0.0276333112,
-0.0439803898,
0.0326922946,
-0.0048790639,
-0.0376634263,
0.100384675,
-0.0422893949,
0.0156234531,
-0.0910084993,
-0.0099900952,
-0.0573062152,
-0.0012744672,
-0.0403391086,
0.0105590504,
-0.0347602367,
0.0113118282,
-0.0378636159,
0.0112124765,
0.0301925,
-0.0013778489,
0.053304702,
-0.072620526,
0.0058398484,
-0.0068638884,
-0.015818052,
-0.0141762951,
-0.1034517884,
-0.0000783492,
-0.0096221399,
-0.0010906891,
0.0063382527,
0.0080045098,
0.0475493073,
-0.0261223204,
-0.0139160501,
-0.0270627756,
-0.0088657998,
-0.0259617139,
0.0086925849,
0.0626483113,
0.0293490198,
0.0195183959,
0.0063938382,
0.0290777534,
-0.0547169857,
0.0290464256,
0.0226618648,
-0.0446215831,
-0.0048419135,
-0.010069862,
-0.0445525721,
-0.0173142646,
-0.0030228097,
-0.0019747219,
0.0056666997,
-0.0012416571,
0.0622893646,
0.0302969646,
0.0016339381,
-0.0055479929,
-0.0585655347,
-0.0018834161,
-0.0108203962,
0.0353123844,
0.0186886061,
-0.0065185344,
-0.034624435,
0.0071498514,
0.0513167381,
-0.0223496184,
-0.0408654064,
-0.0565755926,
-0.0263724755,
0.0103353243,
-0.0075504114,
-0.0449157506,
0.0137373852,
-0.0404731594,
0.0060996967,
0.0268485732,
0.0189686045,
-0.0748666003,
0.0306523535,
-0.0213703457,
0.0082676606,
-0.0500726178,
0.0032800299,
-0.0772477016,
-0.0212408733,
0.0335813127,
0.0335998572,
0.0004198257,
-0.0118361739,
0.0084344605,
-0.07049831,
0.0204073098,
0.0216001272,
0.036544539,
-0.0113623794,
0.0186058469,
-0.0193077289,
-0.013705343,
0.0043253703,
0.0132764429,
0.0298203826,
0.0636443719,
-0.0013214324,
-0.0112939682,
-0.0264473166,
0.027048355,
-0.0302960481,
0.0459567383,
0.0544393733,
0.0037149165,
-0.034999527,
0.0286611374,
0.003538541,
-0.0626925081,
-0.0323581807,
0.0195339788,
-0.057234887,
0.0199680496,
-0.0693501532,
-0.0645819232,
-0.0196741521,
0.0335299782,
0.0525002927,
0.0656551346,
0.0023269695,
0.0005751492,
-0.0026727763,
-0.0161146764,
-0.0169605259,
0.0242281072,
0.0102893151,
0.0243683513,
0.046667777,
-0.002636832,
0.0007677106,
-0.0326172374,
-0.036307361,
-0.0410837792,
-0.0037804961,
0.0584528223,
0.0323788598,
0.0060050441,
-0.0083185937,
-0.0399655923,
0.0095213307,
-0.0008613475,
-0.0248245299,
0.0257783867,
-0.0167839471,
0.0213199947,
-0.0213817451,
0.0572914593,
-0.0210512318,
-0.0435243584,
-0.0013412769,
0.0359205864,
0.012485425,
-0.0489054844,
0.0622550882,
0.012042583,
0.0165964141,
-0.089677833,
0.0181586109,
-0.0121763563,
0.0056869686,
0.0168716256,
0.0071433005,
-0.0043859808,
-0.0136129353,
0.0589573421,
0.0323788375,
-0.0213327277,
-0.0097600203,
-0.0418307669,
0.0198264979,
-0.0077766436,
0.0154334428,
-0.0103306659,
0.0565830693,
-0.0245655347,
0.0124774557,
-0.026447393,
-0.0322316438,
-0.0774252266,
-0.0143271815,
0.0024887626,
0.0509676263,
-0.0044309576,
-0.0076843784,
-0.011722466,
0.0748380646,
0.0170150883,
-0.027907012,
-0.0174843036,
0.0484973751,
0.0578741729,
-0.0122938063,
0.0723578855,
-0.0002958896,
0.0057586404,
0.0118719926,
0.0703891143,
-0.0344472751,
0.0315036625,
0.0340957455,
-0.0337710008,
0.0158455186,
0.0020175476,
0.0467930287,
0.0147347217,
-0.0082988981,
0.0126664294,
-0.0385540687,
-0.0242494084,
-0.0648091212,
-0.040904507,
0.0378952175,
0.023190951,
-0.0147163579,
-0.0613021441,
-0.0288168397,
0.0139880413,
0.0271663293,
0.0317146331,
-0.0342794135,
0.0327060856,
0.0557608828,
0.0175939202,
-0.0222685523,
-0.0719137862,
0.0384497978,
-0.0233453251,
-0.0021152943,
-0.0642067492,
-5.256300132e-33,
-0.0323617719,
0.0420928784,
0.0062093721,
-0.0018573005,
-0.0331096537,
-0.0497006401,
-0.0314389057,
-0.0338284485,
0.0097613074,
-0.0312488377,
-0.0164510608,
0.0128975147,
0.008096165,
0.0005163739,
0.0456317812,
-0.012139624,
0.0348449834,
0.019669082,
-0.0139602209,
-0.003045005,
-0.0078480393,
0.0299745537,
0.0699592978,
-0.0388519205,
0.0207096469,
-0.0669501424,
0.0238988325,
-0.0019574098,
-0.0214115884,
0.0124394102,
-0.015689021,
0.0566001534,
0.035742633,
0.0162423272,
-0.0400043167,
-0.0409914143,
-0.0350821987,
-0.0093030399,
0.085157454,
0.0175074097,
-0.0670271292,
-0.0328534171,
0.0547645167,
-0.0250480548,
-0.0227358341,
0.0452852733,
0.0558512844,
0.0016395714,
0.0118917497,
0.0231750607,
-0.0666966215,
0.0042777699,
-0.0032471963,
0.0159606449,
0.0079653626,
0.0803713128,
-0.0366934948,
0.0203624796,
-0.0682996213,
0.0008967957,
-0.0310823824,
0.005822829,
0.0294224918,
-0.0036173114,
-0.0229796953,
-0.013128778,
0.0120923454,
-0.0472086854,
0.0126266275,
0.0736761689,
-0.0154673094,
0.0219849534,
0.037100371,
0.0730123669,
0.031666819,
-0.0439248495,
0.0182686727,
0.0151940668,
-0.0162919313,
0.0223684534,
0.0399127491,
-0.0295192823,
-0.0076920488,
-0.0194910392,
-0.0028017899,
-0.0291347299,
-0.015281219,
-0.0491350554,
0.0420601219,
-0.0251392387,
-0.0351243429,
0.0302448198,
0.0597711802,
-0.0321230255,
0.0479230471,
-0.0435170531,
-0.0235481597,
0.0240414347,
-0.0010991865,
0.0200105887,
0.0066561573,
-0.0219220892,
-0.0171448421,
0.0470205285,
0.0448656976,
-0.0163395144,
0.0122299306,
0.0003660624,
-0.0068046642,
0.0169542469,
-0.0445463695,
-0.0465962701,
-0.0314046443,
-0.0562750995,
-0.0293466784,
0.0417277552,
-0.0040031811,
-0.0253399834,
0.0222175233,
-0.0257633887,
-0.0028159476,
0.0283400528,
0.0683289617,
0.0225021373,
-0.0188329574,
0.0287781488,
-0.0553410351,
0.0153698605,
-0.0052761286,
-0.05462889,
0.012920741,
0.0123980483,
2.396e-7,
0.0092208283,
0.0307956003,
0.0332996771,
-0.0668547153,
-0.0223313551,
0.0001461511,
-0.0140720718,
-0.0082179429,
-0.015580805,
0.0265521165,
0.03173678,
-0.000304881,
0.0044940896,
-0.0209665317,
-0.1271110773,
-0.0116301393,
-0.110736914,
-0.0065265005,
-0.0546299033,
-0.0388371795,
0.0363493636,
0.0497695915,
0.0340854563,
-0.0313659869,
-0.0274023935,
-0.0347400606,
0.0519773364,
0.00997754,
-0.0183904227,
0.0182912964,
0.0319636278,
0.0099296421,
-0.0137741026,
-0.0010093191,
0.0154745793,
0.0075215003,
0.0634649843,
0.0537959263,
-0.0110224988,
0.0213851668,
0.0097462982,
-0.0399924666,
0.0144493105,
-0.0818523988,
0.0093339514,
-0.016358722,
-0.0074444637,
0.0233143885,
-0.0065327953,
0.0351444148,
0.0395179577,
-0.0342985317,
-0.0363734961,
-0.0015438835,
0.0079206713,
-0.0399334505,
-0.0056501762,
-0.0171072483,
-0.0286523271,
0.0286263749,
-0.0220937449,
-0.0203888379,
-0.0133926095,
-0.0008874621,
0.0740375593,
-0.0560941026,
0.0198844541,
1.313674974e-34,
0.0534769818,
0.0108455382,
0.0757145658,
-0.0202576611,
0.0239110831,
0.011527949,
-0.0032158585,
0.0242177304,
0.0252338424,
-0.0264476947,
-0.026049776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17824v1 | A Survey of Pre-trained Language Models for Processing Scientific Text | 2024-01-31T13:35:07 | 2024-01-31T13:35:07 | Xanh Ho, Anh Khoa Duong Nguyen, An Tuan Dao, Junfeng Jiang, Yuki Chida, Kaito Sugimoto, Huy Quoc To, Florian Boudin, Akiko Aizawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The number of Language Models (LMs) dedicated to processing scientific text
is on the rise. Keeping pace with the rapid growth of scientific LMs (SciLMs)
has become a daunting task for researchers. To date, no comprehensive surveys
on SciLMs have been undertaken, leaving this issue unaddressed. Given the
constant stream of new SciLMs, appraising the state-of-the-art and how they
compare to each other remain largely unknown. This work fills that gap and
provides a comprehensive review of SciLMs, including an extensive analysis of
their effectiveness across different domains, tasks and datasets, and a
discussion on the challenges that lie ahead. | A Survey of Pre-trained Language Models for Processing Scientific Text: The number of Language Models (LMs) dedicated to processing scientific text
is on the rise. Keeping pace with the rapid growth of scientific LMs (SciLMs)
has become a daunting task for researchers. To date, no comprehensive surveys
on SciLMs have been undertaken, leaving this issue unaddressed. Given the
constant stream of new SciLMs, appraising the state-of-the-art and how they
compare to each other remain largely unknown. This work fills that gap and
provides a comprehensive review of SciLMs, including an extensive analysis of
their effectiveness across different domains, tasks and datasets, and a
discussion on the challenges that lie ahead. | [
0.0362248197,
0.0384844877,
0.0117821498,
0.0153656099,
-0.0375737883,
0.0083134463,
0.025980439,
-0.0011606868,
0.0117894914,
-0.0476833545,
-0.0961259007,
-0.0151483407,
-0.0073984703,
0.0565253869,
0.0024370917,
-0.0172005836,
0.0623194985,
-0.0357293673,
0.054824736,
-0.0017274461,
-0.0132246297,
-0.004535594,
0.0030063321,
-0.007583668,
0.0353479907,
-0.032779742,
0.049316816,
-0.0182025135,
0.0420654565,
-0.0428467877,
0.0240595937,
0.0769315809,
0.0112602524,
0.057624314,
0.0000018473,
-0.0475107543,
-0.0198721439,
0.0005471077,
0.0040181875,
0.055167716,
0.0674493462,
-0.0466179587,
0.0189445317,
-0.0203632582,
-0.0402539857,
-0.0220060814,
0.0381262787,
-0.006092424,
0.000898442,
0.0303009003,
-0.0090601519,
-0.069224216,
0.0348618664,
0.0123323863,
-0.0144165084,
0.0106781498,
0.0693415701,
-0.0058707879,
0.0110041266,
0.0713393986,
-0.0025510055,
0.086123094,
-0.0132886479,
-0.0135424826,
-0.0047003594,
0.0443155691,
-0.0314576216,
-0.0124092652,
-0.0212529562,
0.0623592064,
-0.0383848287,
-0.0571299009,
0.0127171492,
-0.0349239111,
-0.0660863295,
-0.0106113795,
-0.035592854,
0.0304208808,
0.0215945449,
0.0068845893,
0.0324793234,
0.0275991019,
0.0175703298,
0.0242665969,
-0.0451253653,
0.0981465131,
0.0395907462,
-0.0417999886,
0.0075747031,
-0.0029732324,
0.0101690274,
-0.0251256805,
0.0578228757,
0.0164528042,
0.0098907454,
0.0213852879,
-0.050327234,
-0.0479390621,
0.038983766,
-0.0235230643,
0.0348329581,
-0.010166062,
-0.0058161775,
0.0531246401,
-0.0162401702,
0.0127467113,
0.0039802063,
0.0310246889,
-0.0009953676,
0.0077927266,
0.0022163447,
-0.0249950737,
-0.0113957217,
-0.0193850677,
-0.0368653089,
-0.0223740581,
-0.0191846509,
-0.0187663361,
0.0479060039,
-0.0407358445,
-0.0205835737,
-0.0484045334,
-0.0048869564,
-0.0083252033,
0.0065653175,
0.047137145,
0.0296844617,
0.0143148368,
-0.0173218213,
-0.062617451,
-0.0216428284,
0.0222993344,
0.0112713818,
-0.0292863976,
0.0184785277,
0.0228155106,
0.0533636883,
-0.0827109218,
-0.0034341344,
-0.0020433906,
-0.0100797499,
-0.0600712709,
0.0230416246,
-0.0358627029,
0.0451249741,
0.0232099891,
-0.0083724828,
-0.0259291977,
0.0082495986,
0.0125749689,
-0.0547868609,
0.0625292882,
-0.0719825923,
-0.0117034484,
0.0053511658,
-0.019176377,
0.0460087657,
0.0359307416,
0.0024881589,
-0.0208991859,
0.0376707464,
-0.0141114565,
0.0058170212,
0.0403812528,
0.0078651924,
0.0062874951,
-0.026077956,
0.0126575772,
-0.0197416972,
0.0211464204,
0.0313446783,
0.0319803543,
-0.0186045486,
-0.0353377089,
0.0088208597,
0.0723758414,
0.0363066308,
0.0059841075,
0.0411244407,
-0.0092901094,
0.0714904517,
-0.032222908,
0.0077879913,
0.006192917,
-0.0334606841,
0.009052502,
0.0012787312,
0.0393448547,
-0.0249149445,
-0.0294872802,
-0.0204559434,
-0.0110926926,
-0.0121656004,
-0.0359557793,
0.079623729,
-0.0331706516,
-0.0339226574,
-0.0307674613,
0.0466925837,
-0.0652358383,
0.0259176474,
-0.0014712327,
0.0122710457,
0.0271745939,
0.0571959242,
-0.0572330393,
-0.0581878424,
0.0263301432,
0.004954475,
0.0441181697,
0.0408231243,
0.0193337705,
-0.0199582372,
-0.0543144234,
-0.0441220179,
-0.0067478186,
0.0067132358,
0.0108343614,
0.0076305494,
0.0055298721,
0.0029826504,
-0.0079530058,
-0.0478505418,
0.0692156702,
-0.0703127608,
-0.016708497,
-0.0331625715,
-0.06006198,
0.0376624167,
-0.0024717886,
-0.0280376729,
0.0416780077,
0.0723271817,
-0.0294389483,
0.0266742222,
0.0026175873,
-0.0213265121,
-0.0488814041,
0.0514785871,
-0.0068959785,
0.0057094749,
0.0407333709,
-0.0028929203,
-0.0054520518,
0.0077301487,
0.0291386023,
0.0141995866,
-0.042761378,
0.0119378157,
-0.0133997304,
0.0077836807,
-0.0432352498,
0.0326071829,
-0.0219306611,
0.069499433,
0.0069648945,
-0.0055084089,
0.0194141362,
-0.0178763811,
-0.0425870083,
-0.0242312085,
0.0226171371,
-0.0252966117,
-0.0035365091,
-0.010717541,
-0.0288565233,
0.0061892592,
-0.0122517021,
-0.0104314741,
-0.0153033957,
0.0075160866,
0.0223628785,
-0.0366536081,
-0.0450649783,
0.0094518196,
0.0208712295,
0.0079788817,
0.0095138373,
-0.0072969096,
0.0361927226,
-0.0241339467,
0.0266390815,
-0.0471599922,
-0.0378882922,
-0.0261537228,
0.0365234911,
0.034257587,
-0.0431922972,
-0.0520235188,
0.0314495601,
-0.0107016023,
0.0175299104,
-0.0004164189,
-0.0086958362,
-0.0088268789,
-0.0568066798,
0.02147015,
0.0344576053,
0.0105674863,
0.0014134527,
0.0522082523,
-0.003767198,
-0.0272372626,
-0.0134201096,
-0.0319166183,
0.0388154089,
0.0048134564,
0.0391993597,
0.0695333555,
0.0653086752,
-0.0728773102,
-0.0195153765,
0.023612963,
0.026810497,
-0.0339953788,
-0.0323912017,
0.0214700531,
0.0060213893,
-0.0217813794,
0.053391993,
0.0176655129,
-0.0478633791,
0.039372161,
-0.074347958,
-0.0274436399,
-0.116558753,
0.0130195422,
-0.0343083665,
-0.0061251512,
0.0362485833,
0.0027249036,
0.012679588,
-0.0097682392,
-0.0040970403,
0.041191116,
-0.0477432832,
-0.0051638656,
-0.0345027596,
-0.0326627865,
0.0397372544,
-0.0052402937,
0.0613533743,
-0.006332126,
-0.0383465812,
-0.0434686616,
0.0316121243,
0.0205011796,
-0.043207638,
-0.0584628657,
0.0479200706,
-0.0030033761,
0.0585400835,
-0.027990967,
0.0115187336,
-0.047755681,
0.0095343189,
0.0436987951,
-0.0170533471,
0.0591416582,
-0.0185205173,
-0.0169036258,
0.0303527713,
0.0043022307,
-0.0187366176,
-0.0093285069,
-0.0173756201,
0.0530625656,
-0.0557718761,
0.0189230517,
-0.0184838139,
0.0388231389,
-0.0515275225,
-0.0151835075,
0.1308386922,
0.0434135757,
-0.0478103757,
-0.0251073018,
0.0095942607,
0.0067939218,
0.0094082709,
0.0127636148,
-0.0719667599,
-0.0074272496,
-0.0216541905,
-0.0274240486,
0.0151787968,
-0.0426693931,
-0.021567123,
-0.069055289,
0.0413719788,
0.023930477,
-0.0541857667,
0.0004394853,
-0.0566146262,
-0.0196658727,
-0.0068948562,
-0.0226726476,
0.0165620092,
-0.0438547432,
0.0110478289,
0.0203389954,
-0.0193600878,
-0.0835464224,
0.018904034,
-0.0299632605,
0.0183097292,
0.0378043838,
0.022181673,
-0.0302702375,
-0.0321186706,
0.0557572469,
-0.008441925,
-0.0197766181,
-0.036510013,
0.0003393351,
-0.006933467,
-0.0070998478,
0.0109765232,
0.0418742709,
-0.0591826737,
-0.0038945628,
-0.0051764646,
0.0957398638,
-0.0266219284,
-0.0145949265,
-0.073595345,
0.0342369042,
-0.0119800493,
0.0929489657,
0.0113302143,
-0.0252495725,
-0.0579254292,
-0.0065047448,
0.0165683422,
-0.0012306822,
-0.0683865696,
-0.0038422989,
-0.0370600186,
0.0006654117,
-0.0376828909,
-0.0131097287,
0.066930756,
-0.0055485419,
-0.0054723872,
0.0128332367,
0.0049126372,
-0.0232858546,
-0.0301499162,
0.0154498257,
-0.0302466359,
-0.0085368641,
-0.0819515958,
-0.0263606329,
0.0635357201,
0.0433366746,
-0.0358634554,
-0.005279033,
-0.0233442746,
-0.0523229241,
-0.0058962638,
0.0615347028,
0.0157482736,
-0.0235860161,
-0.0158910733,
-0.0353975631,
0.0461812429,
0.0256460197,
-0.0479551554,
0.0183937922,
-0.0129444487,
-0.0130436234,
-0.0166346114,
-0.0233332831,
0.0060439422,
0.0514432192,
0.0243737921,
0.0282251295,
-0.0165094174,
-0.0727071613,
0.0200740304,
0.0294845868,
0.0956564471,
-0.0176609736,
-0.0159364231,
-0.0245430898,
-0.0214773882,
-0.0406246819,
0.02280722,
-0.0361426622,
0.0069660535,
0.0173113998,
0.0222664811,
-0.0378652178,
0.0048250793,
-0.0609004572,
0.0284771379,
-0.0418057702,
0.0570508167,
0.0414340831,
0.0080707623,
0.0241356771,
-0.0200288203,
-0.003476202,
-0.0168847349,
-0.0282198768,
0.0044508646,
0.0030893628,
0.0139317745,
0.0208958834,
0.0269995276,
-0.0267688446,
0.039192915,
-0.1077566966,
-0.0275013,
-0.0363505334,
0.0180248264,
0.0211454183,
0.012505387,
0.0335706063,
-0.0454631187,
-0.03074052,
-0.0671722144,
0.0247846991,
0.0331500284,
0.0193872135,
0.0635587275,
0.0038762756,
-0.0416579768,
-0.0208864175,
0.0699966773,
0.0485902093,
0.0377627686,
0.0479369089,
0.0079330662,
-0.011408139,
-0.0175379869,
-0.0701160505,
-0.0132145081,
-0.0294357892,
0.0126500577,
-0.059599787,
-0.0208326504,
0.0595350489,
0.0099629518,
-0.0155298663,
-0.0374080725,
0.0128644928,
0.0503671393,
-0.0225134529,
0.01590495,
-0.0025191582,
0.0324556977,
-0.0136726294,
-0.0567428544,
-0.0000432886,
-5.697220348e-33,
-0.0066741901,
0.0032530851,
0.0256784502,
0.0335973464,
0.0154054919,
0.0260093883,
-0.0177316964,
-0.007779791,
-0.0135562578,
0.0147569515,
0.0116927801,
-0.0005640415,
0.0022854963,
0.0011751254,
0.0025757155,
0.0456347205,
0.0225917175,
-0.0345831104,
0.0070110173,
0.0028734598,
0.0197933726,
0.0607710369,
0.0628394634,
-0.0620315261,
0.0123524684,
-0.001095596,
0.0499938428,
-0.0092157042,
-0.0085158423,
0.0433784984,
-0.0651370063,
0.0102211023,
-0.0004286779,
-0.0372057408,
-0.0635118559,
0.0187249258,
-0.0590235665,
-0.0057152105,
0.006052372,
-0.0089116348,
-0.0203387309,
-0.0093164491,
0.0307618827,
0.0068302336,
-0.0283103362,
-0.008308637,
0.0390427001,
-0.0091519356,
-0.0270465761,
-0.0497534908,
-0.064135924,
0.0445249192,
0.0231694914,
0.037305288,
0.062070109,
0.0101578152,
-0.0151131023,
0.1067773998,
-0.0127877034,
0.0517804809,
0.0739562511,
0.0303659476,
0.0077936356,
-0.0319723003,
0.036483109,
0.0502683222,
0.0102373539,
-0.0388266258,
0.0242875163,
0.018881375,
0.0711926371,
-0.0010437777,
0.0537266545,
0.0115417549,
0.027891323,
0.0235294662,
-0.0766345635,
0.0197924804,
0.0084248204,
0.0070685484,
0.0048265317,
0.0240303297,
0.0389459543,
-0.0037612028,
-0.0112153701,
-0.0172605552,
-0.012598658,
-0.022270374,
0.0103590814,
-0.0367621705,
-0.0445987955,
0.0465968437,
0.0457360744,
-0.0485999137,
-0.0453467481,
0.0101515753,
0.0336317159,
0.0381834246,
-0.0059435302,
0.0689643919,
-0.1110146344,
-0.0226119179,
0.0166942496,
-0.0331659056,
-0.0074089789,
-0.0257816836,
-0.0069973529,
-0.0041737203,
-0.034814667,
-0.0105897011,
0.0194158945,
-0.0472842231,
0.0505958647,
0.0897034556,
0.0073135658,
0.0177878942,
0.0450630561,
0.0444899872,
0.0445399433,
-0.0049433191,
0.0118689546,
0.0200910773,
-0.0006113427,
0.0426311009,
-0.0186470989,
-0.0415813476,
-0.0441097096,
-0.0132909715,
-0.0168442745,
-0.052061975,
0.0338593014,
-0.0047345185,
2.356e-7,
0.0928220302,
0.0669592395,
0.0365989991,
-0.0609029196,
0.0290835332,
-0.0206082314,
-0.0188498553,
0.0044706012,
0.007500974,
0.0309787504,
-0.0117796604,
-0.0313739553,
0.007784782,
0.0030266191,
-0.059329398,
-0.0086244717,
-0.0556208529,
-0.0296442229,
-0.0685637072,
-0.0404481702,
0.0177233554,
0.0699522048,
-0.0267588571,
-0.0003879791,
-0.0188220888,
-0.0268956721,
0.0610942319,
-0.0539432168,
-0.0010079362,
0.0603070408,
0.0084872898,
0.0106366826,
-0.0005063575,
0.0243340302,
-0.0227178484,
0.0253675878,
0.0195806921,
0.0695447847,
-0.0127666648,
-0.0126535306,
0.0627208278,
0.0211662538,
0.0089206025,
-0.0378525294,
0.0558604263,
-0.0548465624,
-0.0166457854,
-0.0229631085,
-0.0225016177,
-0.0101964967,
0.0268011503,
-0.0245608538,
0.0016657683,
0.0233803708,
0.0155617548,
-0.0013870001,
-0.026724685,
-0.0895425528,
-0.005073424,
0.0222103186,
-0.0260169525,
-0.0394022986,
-0.0384039506,
-0.0228723492,
0.050943695,
-0.0465981252,
-0.0027487022,
2.34098024e-34,
0.0726634935,
-0.015339531,
-0.0092020445,
0.0537742674,
-0.0371201336,
-0.0112038543,
0.0009495524,
0.037927229,
-0.0240160264,
-0.1004103348,
0.0329443514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17809v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17809v3 | SWEA: Updating Factual Knowledge in Large Language Models via Subject Word Embedding Altering | 2024-01-31T13:08:45 | 2024-04-23T01:08:44 | Xiaopeng Li, Shasha Li, Shezheng Song, Huijun Liu, Bin Ji, Xi Wang, Jun Ma, Jie Yu, Xiaodong Liu, Jing Wang, Weimin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The general capabilities of large language models (LLMs) make them the
infrastructure for various AI applications, but updating their inner knowledge
requires significant resources. Recent model editing is a promising technique
for efficiently updating a small amount of knowledge of LLMs and has attracted
much attention. In particular, local editing methods, which directly update
model parameters, are more suitable for updating a small amount of knowledge.
Local editing methods update weights by computing least squares closed-form
solutions and identify edited knowledge by vector-level matching in inference,
which achieve promising results. However, these methods still require a lot of
time and resources to complete the computation. Moreover, vector-level matching
lacks reliability, and such updates disrupt the original organization of the
model's parameters. To address these issues, we propose an detachable and
expandable Subject Word Embedding Altering (SWEA) framework, which finds the
editing embeddings through token-level matching and adds them to the subject
word embeddings in Transformer input. To get these editing embeddings, we
propose optimizing then suppressing fusion method, which first optimizes
learnable embedding vectors for the editing target and then suppresses the
Knowledge Embedding Dimensions (KEDs) to obtain final editing embeddings. We
thus propose SWEA$\oplus$OS method for editing factual knowledge in LLMs. We
demonstrate the overall state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of SWEA$\oplus$OS
on the \textsc{CounterFact} and zsRE datasets. To further validate the
reasoning ability of SWEA$\oplus$OS in editing knowledge, we evaluate it on the
more complex \textsc{RippleEdits} benchmark. The results demonstrate that
SWEA$\oplus$OS possesses SOTA reasoning ability. | SWEA: Updating Factual Knowledge in Large Language Models via Subject Word Embedding Altering: The general capabilities of large language models (LLMs) make them the
infrastructure for various AI applications, but updating their inner knowledge
requires significant resources. Recent model editing is a promising technique
for efficiently updating a small amount of knowledge of LLMs and has attracted
much attention. In particular, local editing methods, which directly update
model parameters, are more suitable for updating a small amount of knowledge.
Local editing methods update weights by computing least squares closed-form
solutions and identify edited knowledge by vector-level matching in inference,
which achieve promising results. However, these methods still require a lot of
time and resources to complete the computation. Moreover, vector-level matching
lacks reliability, and such updates disrupt the original organization of the
model's parameters. To address these issues, we propose an detachable and
expandable Subject Word Embedding Altering (SWEA) framework, which finds the
editing embeddings through token-level matching and adds them to the subject
word embeddings in Transformer input. To get these editing embeddings, we
propose optimizing then suppressing fusion method, which first optimizes
learnable embedding vectors for the editing target and then suppresses the
Knowledge Embedding Dimensions (KEDs) to obtain final editing embeddings. We
thus propose SWEA$\oplus$OS method for editing factual knowledge in LLMs. We
demonstrate the overall state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of SWEA$\oplus$OS
on the \textsc{CounterFact} and zsRE datasets. To further validate the
reasoning ability of SWEA$\oplus$OS in editing knowledge, we evaluate it on the
more complex \textsc{RippleEdits} benchmark. The results demonstrate that
SWEA$\oplus$OS possesses SOTA reasoning ability. | [
0.0451478362,
0.0666907951,
0.0059316661,
0.0620869286,
-0.0560301356,
-0.0032224641,
-0.0137164695,
-0.0336374193,
-0.0237110797,
-0.0665984452,
-0.0388773493,
0.0000475394,
0.020557588,
0.0267118607,
0.012359838,
0.0083635971,
0.0783424601,
0.0024560138,
-0.0394572057,
-0.0195757262,
-0.0255238563,
0.0044134171,
-0.0007027482,
0.0062433835,
-0.0080683716,
-0.0026324175,
-0.0134306503,
-0.0097713582,
0.0203360207,
0.0553659983,
0.0022660482,
0.0776498616,
0.0281960368,
0.0831448957,
0.0000022649,
-0.033991944,
-0.0426879935,
0.0167385787,
-0.046947334,
0.043644432,
0.0286118537,
-0.0243163984,
-0.0245352909,
0.0024711024,
-0.014247342,
-0.031688083,
0.0793775469,
0.0388022326,
0.0858984813,
0.1035117656,
-0.0044351481,
-0.0111198537,
0.0350004919,
-0.0368994847,
-0.0647029281,
-0.0320114493,
0.0572107695,
-0.012898027,
-0.0618847087,
0.0196930207,
-0.0433983766,
0.0346209221,
0.0054430817,
-0.0371539183,
0.0401480608,
-0.0026809718,
-0.0612328909,
0.0041459748,
0.0146401254,
0.0555330142,
-0.0086674336,
-0.0254955627,
-0.0249314886,
0.0100035807,
-0.0024779814,
0.0359740332,
-0.0086316224,
-0.013044768,
0.0581985489,
0.028431138,
0.0036611054,
-0.0777608901,
0.049599465,
0.025654003,
-0.0405664071,
0.0581775345,
0.0635219812,
-0.0441832729,
-0.0410340056,
-0.0262771063,
-0.0132444585,
-0.0711857229,
-0.0050734142,
0.0261955559,
-0.0198749714,
0.036700882,
-0.0473667532,
-0.0438677296,
-0.0207451563,
-0.0637421981,
0.0425237045,
0.0527800508,
0.0070985998,
0.0721751675,
-0.049456358,
0.0281366017,
0.0073035834,
0.0132201985,
-0.0527755246,
0.0015577708,
-0.0230409782,
-0.0080163591,
-0.0324889831,
0.0289910398,
-0.068657048,
-0.0009107089,
-0.0326659121,
0.0107621597,
-0.0090259733,
0.0340226926,
-0.0055580633,
-0.0048197792,
0.0016414112,
-0.0265315492,
0.0005502621,
0.056893006,
-0.0022830274,
0.0101342481,
-0.0389985293,
-0.009495385,
-0.0349683426,
-0.0133419447,
0.0186608154,
-0.0197061636,
0.0170585644,
0.0213820767,
-0.0250379033,
-0.0386499427,
-0.0313370265,
-0.0117161917,
-0.0091034621,
-0.0538825095,
0.000874972,
-0.0592875518,
0.0589474663,
-0.0140151912,
-0.0436680801,
-0.0572411381,
0.0096524721,
-0.0091969399,
-0.0687957704,
0.1026877239,
-0.0054904376,
0.0155133745,
0.0205000173,
0.0003797328,
0.0005494715,
0.0527656786,
0.0157466047,
-0.0094135953,
0.062416479,
-0.0107967528,
-0.0353780016,
0.0434681587,
0.0343704,
0.0387904495,
-0.0474389419,
0.0008675399,
0.015511509,
0.0014711672,
0.0152071333,
0.0238236301,
-0.0150032444,
-0.0295275338,
0.0666914135,
0.0347943678,
0.0033558847,
0.0569453873,
0.0284614265,
-0.0085455701,
0.0151965879,
0.0015303314,
-0.0464083776,
0.0070389165,
-0.0424141102,
-0.0019976867,
0.0003963954,
0.0390556268,
-0.0018448298,
-0.0390891358,
-0.0259996802,
-0.0080426382,
0.0094875768,
0.0031793963,
0.0406424068,
0.0162860621,
-0.0282050408,
0.0763505548,
0.0495945364,
-0.0696510673,
-0.008745105,
-0.0485106036,
0.0161830392,
0.0409857482,
0.0623200275,
-0.0469895825,
-0.0655426309,
0.0044516446,
-0.0181457009,
0.0303791296,
0.050554622,
-0.0205265861,
0.002447007,
-0.0320803039,
-0.0277058724,
-0.0227955971,
0.0340753235,
0.0020541993,
0.0367681831,
-0.0197962429,
0.0262998827,
-0.0226686876,
-0.01067816,
0.0250907913,
-0.0464342274,
-0.0102892704,
0.0265111998,
0.0205766577,
-0.0027043859,
-0.0112599516,
-0.0175950322,
0.0035168158,
-0.004652319,
-0.0150760571,
-0.0638188645,
-0.0021558977,
0.0014999296,
-0.0406638309,
0.0638264343,
0.0056606475,
-0.0314369537,
0.033558283,
-0.0457673334,
-0.0172381047,
0.0274771824,
-0.027909128,
0.0456895418,
-0.0422064476,
0.0436677709,
-0.0081760911,
-0.0010236485,
-0.0114413714,
0.0476925299,
-0.0416329131,
-0.0259931311,
0.0176106524,
-0.0042779157,
0.010662443,
-0.000528983,
-0.0356023163,
0.0015029003,
0.0147573557,
-0.0192338843,
0.0045086159,
-0.0162992775,
-0.0132847968,
-0.0450898483,
-0.0610487238,
-0.0048664818,
-0.0263816211,
0.0006253448,
0.0199212264,
0.0226966348,
-0.0037858675,
-0.0023188051,
0.0148977973,
-0.0126078799,
-0.0453820527,
0.0286306515,
0.0206730794,
-0.0091029909,
0.0006741149,
-0.045842085,
-0.003718327,
-0.0210484378,
0.0619211867,
-0.0208011772,
-0.0108527662,
-0.0668904409,
0.0294163078,
-0.0735038817,
0.0245641507,
0.0115042645,
-0.0390170999,
-0.038640622,
0.0128731504,
0.1223425418,
0.062548317,
-0.0122061083,
0.0250175148,
0.0900945961,
-0.0267843809,
-0.004611304,
0.0097480901,
-0.0185808949,
-0.0091233291,
-0.0134217609,
-0.0234763473,
0.007484443,
0.0355770923,
-0.0023634981,
-0.0523384325,
-0.0438170731,
0.0343488157,
-0.0077562304,
-0.0188355315,
-0.0288306531,
-0.005149669,
-0.0228654444,
-0.0179455318,
-0.0535347722,
-0.0295414254,
0.0604000241,
-0.0411942676,
0.0251242872,
-0.0564492531,
-0.023010876,
-0.0358210914,
0.0152704772,
-0.0038873465,
0.0390195847,
-0.0605142675,
0.0337498076,
-0.0640714616,
-0.0045207655,
0.0264041685,
-0.0227514021,
0.0402874313,
-0.0656269714,
0.0180540234,
-0.0019188694,
-0.033076413,
-0.0312613286,
-0.0544790886,
-0.0021643988,
0.0193572659,
-0.0091612404,
-0.0580599159,
-0.0190206245,
-0.0212139096,
0.0293530356,
0.0761841163,
0.0021378975,
0.0162441488,
-0.0309397783,
-0.0087448908,
0.0586655103,
0.032591965,
0.0206643995,
0.0114450948,
0.0256168898,
0.0457538404,
0.0340225622,
-0.0719899088,
-0.0478281491,
-0.0029567736,
0.020747574,
-0.0376078188,
0.010918797,
-0.0344095677,
0.0496556163,
-0.0318346769,
0.0053582061,
0.1280473918,
0.0504193678,
0.0017628255,
0.0162966009,
-0.0487563126,
-0.0208212826,
0.0566790327,
0.0507262312,
-0.0438934751,
-0.0170443039,
0.024931889,
-0.0100845825,
0.003491163,
-0.0357588232,
-0.0340710767,
-0.1151303127,
0.0366758145,
0.0007906427,
-0.0037994147,
-0.0341672264,
-0.0299713016,
0.019315511,
-0.0121762445,
0.0047538481,
0.0100137331,
0.0142509555,
-0.0191905368,
-0.0504672751,
0.0147934947,
-0.0228596237,
0.0051626065,
-0.0302866772,
0.0550404266,
0.0177678689,
0.0286842417,
-0.0089241415,
-0.048919674,
0.0211176388,
0.0347942933,
-0.0267606899,
-0.0178680141,
0.0256768968,
-0.0166639611,
-0.0120234042,
0.0099972459,
0.047183942,
0.0252321269,
-0.0430053137,
-0.0084286015,
0.0943209976,
0.0104191378,
0.0222072862,
0.003049067,
-0.0272293966,
-0.0168413147,
0.0927108824,
0.0470799357,
-0.0348931141,
0.0259612855,
-0.0220265873,
-0.0289396252,
0.0289372262,
-0.0264010299,
-0.0361658856,
-0.0309068579,
-0.0034209888,
-0.0697391331,
0.0043273363,
0.0346588008,
0.0075783445,
0.0235709529,
-0.0120738223,
0.0217604078,
-0.0311141387,
-0.0411831997,
0.0380196385,
-0.0622316711,
0.0305659305,
-0.0066970745,
0.0122107249,
0.0366136134,
-0.0185756758,
-0.0311727598,
-0.0245158356,
-0.0506893657,
-0.0716807991,
0.0108651854,
0.0264480822,
0.0110233268,
0.0487170666,
-0.0321923196,
-0.0442116149,
0.0483381376,
-0.0015796545,
-0.0217237379,
0.0546962395,
0.0338331051,
-0.0141133433,
-0.0093622981,
0.0613994636,
-0.0282870028,
-0.0115921255,
0.0591179989,
0.047844287,
-0.0216638874,
-0.0183134452,
0.0173796695,
0.0226701777,
0.0549770258,
0.0230352301,
0.0044256425,
-0.0590087958,
0.0582726151,
-0.0587649755,
-0.0383413285,
-0.0333350413,
0.0022570654,
0.0029665777,
0.0035991115,
-0.0182446931,
0.0012975725,
-0.0168704148,
0.0362293832,
-0.0025881326,
-0.0160007514,
-0.0110651162,
-0.0066383206,
0.0276801717,
0.0321803987,
-0.0084844939,
0.0217483249,
0.0071751988,
-0.0053565428,
-0.0416170657,
0.0292791743,
0.0237378683,
-0.0216571968,
-0.0880649462,
0.0350349247,
-0.0522827767,
-0.003977723,
-0.0024568436,
0.0642571449,
0.0348215178,
-0.028294215,
0.004245494,
-0.0340906605,
-0.0603063852,
-0.015655525,
0.0289831348,
0.0094660502,
-0.0296599474,
0.0263799969,
0.0071487753,
-0.0171350837,
0.0530704483,
0.0479243472,
-0.0268352255,
0.1017014086,
-0.0340881906,
-0.0114982575,
-0.0362271219,
-0.0541801006,
0.0181601625,
0.0070008696,
-0.0590479374,
0.0354728401,
-0.0836006775,
-0.0974659175,
0.0055083656,
0.0040740822,
-0.0551746748,
0.0183446258,
-0.0051475982,
0.0556449778,
-0.0242586192,
0.0089691784,
-0.0145511329,
0.0133283567,
0.0156363975,
-0.0297573321,
0.0109531078,
-6.958053752e-33,
0.0029766236,
0.0021778378,
0.0187321752,
0.0003771729,
-0.0190096423,
0.0164554268,
-0.0277952347,
0.013198317,
-0.0137468688,
0.0098510645,
-0.0162515379,
0.0131845484,
-0.0081895487,
0.0161473285,
-0.0344884694,
-0.0039157914,
0.0738020465,
0.009299485,
-0.0371821634,
-0.0254637748,
0.0342729464,
0.0237789173,
0.0867311656,
-0.0431651995,
0.0361813344,
0.0251028128,
0.0070843077,
0.0723761767,
-0.0369213782,
0.0341636986,
-0.0144729484,
0.0217332244,
-0.0010938997,
-0.0393185429,
-0.0130032711,
-0.0289956536,
-0.0491655655,
-0.0040072338,
0.0338764451,
0.0280383565,
-0.032786075,
-0.0467207022,
0.0535584465,
0.0180281531,
-0.0220268201,
-0.0262154955,
-0.0005029532,
-0.0241386518,
0.0154666537,
0.0537126809,
-0.0874547139,
0.032547541,
0.0054773944,
-0.0232501645,
-0.0087435972,
-0.0424568206,
0.0419919901,
-0.0116460733,
-0.0662044957,
-0.007481325,
0.0093702255,
0.0432898402,
0.0565189645,
-0.0247857999,
-0.0106070861,
0.054601565,
-0.0012359321,
-0.0209248178,
-0.0191446953,
-0.0031175809,
0.0385257527,
0.037293233,
0.0604161583,
0.0705299452,
0.0086408528,
-0.0124436878,
-0.0643894374,
-0.007595717,
-0.0050708596,
0.0447516739,
-0.0117652528,
0.0325355604,
0.0004965881,
-0.0018804312,
-0.068238914,
0.0070117279,
-0.0661675632,
0.0059998548,
-0.0016453039,
0.0360082015,
-0.059002433,
-0.0188336372,
0.0016900311,
-0.0376160406,
0.0287168305,
0.0063468241,
0.0085532404,
0.0149512803,
0.006952378,
0.0140548451,
-0.0275285654,
0.0192723349,
0.0294943992,
-0.0264520142,
-0.0158542525,
0.0002746446,
0.0701691061,
0.0520589463,
-0.0605094172,
0.0154283419,
-0.0027523846,
-0.0195240621,
-0.0103395917,
0.0143809207,
0.0201343391,
0.0286843516,
-0.0001593371,
0.0192110073,
0.054613959,
0.0654405504,
-0.0221180785,
-0.0169727113,
0.0198260341,
0.0089434627,
-0.0075678742,
0.0254195593,
0.0080318842,
0.0142310485,
0.0306526832,
-0.0581955761,
-0.0090973089,
0.0051618316,
3.108e-7,
0.0528278761,
0.0590373948,
0.0185495242,
0.0015846095,
0.0093072513,
0.0411571488,
-0.0342322402,
0.0207539182,
0.0167218521,
0.0066395737,
0.008927362,
0.028028762,
0.0287102945,
0.0001938241,
-0.0684666857,
0.0034947479,
-0.0492710993,
-0.009140389,
-0.0330137536,
-0.0185516346,
0.018472271,
0.0892671049,
0.0580526255,
-0.0049224212,
-0.0375432856,
-0.0296318326,
0.0638072342,
-0.0144597841,
-0.0420451835,
-0.0034709729,
0.0405481271,
0.0265977886,
0.028657889,
-0.0018980274,
-0.0484737791,
0.0711025745,
0.0234642979,
0.0732772425,
-0.0133860847,
0.0333137698,
-0.0431081355,
-0.0202897955,
-0.0206717532,
-0.0150848562,
0.0866372436,
-0.0442593321,
-0.0234272871,
-0.0622285418,
-0.0113681648,
0.0423654281,
0.0110560739,
-0.0312805399,
-0.016997993,
0.0178208221,
0.025758341,
0.0310857706,
-0.0124161635,
-0.0626772493,
-0.0168023333,
-0.0274473149,
-0.0305185914,
-0.0548776276,
-0.0114428811,
-0.0314675607,
0.077490069,
-0.0602848791,
0.0061116447,
3.238701832e-34,
0.0290505383,
0.0145311095,
0.0113574732,
0.0159218516,
0.0505321845,
-0.0380665995,
-0.0131970551,
0.0134906555,
0.0101634478,
-0.0816656947,
-0.0248859264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17755v1 | CauESC: A Causal Aware Model for Emotional Support Conversation | 2024-01-31T11:30:24 | 2024-01-31T11:30:24 | Wei Chen, Hengxu Lin, Qun Zhang, Xiaojin Zhang, Xiang Bai, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Emotional Support Conversation aims at reducing the seeker's emotional
distress through supportive response. Existing approaches have two limitations:
(1) They ignore the emotion causes of the distress, which is important for
fine-grained emotion understanding; (2) They focus on the seeker's own mental
state rather than the emotional dynamics during interaction between speakers.
To address these issues, we propose a novel framework CauESC, which firstly
recognizes the emotion causes of the distress, as well as the emotion effects
triggered by the causes, and then understands each strategy of verbal grooming
independently and integrates them skillfully. Experimental results on the
benchmark dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and show the
benefits of emotion understanding from cause to effect and
independent-integrated strategy modeling. | CauESC: A Causal Aware Model for Emotional Support Conversation: Emotional Support Conversation aims at reducing the seeker's emotional
distress through supportive response. Existing approaches have two limitations:
(1) They ignore the emotion causes of the distress, which is important for
fine-grained emotion understanding; (2) They focus on the seeker's own mental
state rather than the emotional dynamics during interaction between speakers.
To address these issues, we propose a novel framework CauESC, which firstly
recognizes the emotion causes of the distress, as well as the emotion effects
triggered by the causes, and then understands each strategy of verbal grooming
independently and integrates them skillfully. Experimental results on the
benchmark dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and show the
benefits of emotion understanding from cause to effect and
independent-integrated strategy modeling. | [
0.0680899769,
-0.0022607641,
-0.0319394805,
0.0056698462,
-0.0132225575,
0.0346374959,
0.0087124184,
-0.0249297544,
0.0022120792,
-0.0397172719,
-0.0018717314,
-0.015958976,
-0.0208903588,
0.0172530133,
0.0051123733,
-0.0999568924,
0.0131346676,
0.0417380668,
0.0889623985,
0.0147344833,
0.0572107844,
0.0083202068,
-0.0295513906,
0.013393648,
-0.0539588481,
0.0005524614,
-0.0493051782,
0.0243426301,
0.0270952042,
-0.0395679362,
0.058847554,
0.0411581546,
-0.0019146384,
-0.0199453104,
0.0000021649,
-0.0221493375,
0.0037854393,
-0.0296924133,
0.0556384027,
-0.0676090568,
0.0595378391,
-0.0283115637,
0.0050665699,
0.0198520981,
-0.0157660712,
0.006416983,
0.0182244051,
0.1251804531,
0.0988965407,
0.0626934767,
-0.0438534692,
-0.0224055331,
-0.0232102368,
-0.0181817431,
-0.0228838082,
-0.029059181,
0.0154756177,
-0.0355445445,
0.0219397992,
-0.0637827143,
-0.0208203346,
0.0000246633,
-0.0284032859,
-0.0141618717,
0.0194337089,
-0.027765926,
0.009056869,
-0.0511990227,
-0.0019347492,
0.0783958584,
0.0271348301,
0.0593858697,
0.0188312121,
-0.0265638269,
0.0402135737,
0.0147685129,
-0.0296035614,
-0.0218514577,
-0.011004216,
-0.0086772591,
-0.0038156521,
0.0582486503,
-0.0036040631,
0.0276484843,
0.0320389159,
0.0482647903,
-0.0648047924,
-0.0400908217,
0.0205308627,
-0.0075688469,
0.0380323716,
-0.042179212,
-0.0054653166,
0.0480629653,
-0.066721715,
0.0221916474,
-0.0092119537,
0.0134300226,
-0.02748302,
-0.0371109955,
0.0125396103,
0.0273679011,
-0.0371126607,
-0.0044876607,
0.0429847687,
-0.0016469023,
0.0008357969,
-0.0692915618,
0.0173985809,
0.0360942855,
-0.0532794781,
-0.0051595806,
-0.0358226597,
-0.0101814149,
-0.078068167,
-0.0353341475,
-0.0372822806,
0.0196741186,
-0.0590412095,
-0.0099752536,
-0.0345342457,
-0.0020623745,
0.0032997124,
0.0554180518,
0.0111805703,
0.024918396,
-0.0409534834,
0.0218080059,
0.0413165651,
-0.0886238664,
0.0094311433,
0.0053603882,
0.0232894514,
-0.0250886027,
-0.0024194161,
0.014837699,
0.0046106568,
-0.012929555,
-0.0383479036,
-0.0332733095,
-0.0324179977,
-0.0593621209,
-0.0034583169,
-0.0084501682,
0.0251465961,
-0.0254080258,
0.008679498,
-0.0102253603,
0.0275732949,
-0.0377835445,
-0.0733955055,
0.0541866645,
-0.0074399621,
0.0185034666,
0.0014411832,
0.0603470132,
0.0513272993,
0.0636168942,
-0.0221719835,
0.038167838,
0.0330565162,
-0.0410284102,
0.0294753127,
-0.0093866829,
0.0010601107,
-0.0363272801,
-0.0058032195,
-0.031868089,
-0.0029307539,
0.0434628949,
0.0256357454,
-0.0075131515,
-0.008827135,
0.0207476597,
0.0192196239,
0.0243155602,
-0.0037003192,
0.0533587821,
0.0014077143,
0.0354319587,
0.0032742135,
0.009707843,
-0.0326381326,
0.0186528601,
-0.0372360907,
-0.0220650453,
0.0062029557,
-0.0249575283,
-0.0517446101,
-0.0576645248,
-0.0122916531,
-0.0343335979,
-0.0304979477,
0.0116311749,
0.0018762053,
-0.0207029376,
0.006692539,
-0.0204619691,
0.0243508592,
-0.0392903276,
-0.0225113966,
-0.0184206739,
-0.0037439703,
0.0864329636,
0.0198038351,
-0.0344143808,
-0.0413633473,
-0.0275462121,
0.0192334224,
0.0110975439,
0.0478051342,
-0.003292664,
0.0421031639,
-0.0278779231,
-0.023641618,
0.0118598808,
0.0209579468,
-0.000448946,
-0.0427365974,
0.0068410104,
-0.0401063524,
0.0940831676,
0.0096524144,
0.036537271,
0.0076857186,
0.0023931507,
-0.0318052955,
0.001497848,
0.063286528,
0.0405827351,
-0.0315815471,
-0.026608767,
0.0167786945,
-0.0299968161,
-0.0167569239,
0.0747705847,
-0.0148958741,
0.0069779614,
0.0028740701,
-0.0001707526,
-0.052872397,
0.0003716404,
-0.0496838354,
-0.0450489223,
0.0652951524,
-0.0261482969,
0.035108164,
-0.006505799,
0.0120268492,
-0.0137635935,
0.0160751846,
0.0184804201,
0.0088366047,
-0.0034695871,
0.0080387937,
-0.034463197,
-0.0205394197,
-0.0190947335,
-0.0733020902,
-0.0211742874,
-0.0116448179,
0.0019501809,
-0.0481935218,
-0.000734379,
0.0060501681,
-0.0679456443,
-0.0336091928,
-0.1006129459,
-0.0101950951,
-0.0075227008,
-0.0162745696,
0.0063775084,
0.0124924984,
-0.0358159803,
-0.0381046683,
-0.0415586494,
0.0087496592,
0.040926449,
-0.0107907224,
-0.0042576115,
0.0208273679,
-0.0090281731,
-0.0827234834,
0.023689894,
-0.0158312917,
-0.0214353092,
0.0115055367,
-0.0627890304,
-0.0335332975,
0.0166125484,
-0.0519417748,
0.0494674891,
-0.036070548,
-0.0737405345,
-0.022268258,
-0.0136986459,
0.009830757,
0.0372042879,
0.051996503,
0.0629282966,
-0.0189061984,
-0.0063374303,
-0.0545218699,
0.0407598875,
-0.0320747159,
0.0560998656,
-0.065231815,
-0.0519335121,
-0.0196180996,
0.0577818863,
0.001221206,
0.0423817597,
-0.0550970994,
-0.0377304181,
0.0519443639,
-0.0578945242,
-0.0508793108,
-0.0124776447,
-0.0003651021,
-0.0037898442,
-0.0069455821,
-0.0622680224,
0.0356554128,
0.0313909315,
-0.0434745997,
-0.003863028,
-0.0180009659,
0.0038765394,
0.0642445982,
-0.0254296567,
0.0076643741,
0.0430058986,
-0.0174347032,
-0.0016514604,
-0.0780231133,
-0.0109296972,
-0.0320157185,
-0.0550163724,
-0.0550415814,
-0.0128672142,
0.0616329759,
-0.0104968725,
-0.0462345965,
-0.0392548181,
-0.044342462,
0.0080287205,
-0.007886352,
-0.0081234872,
-0.0404008403,
-0.018968042,
0.054093007,
0.0250139199,
-0.0079649081,
-0.0163713209,
0.0039982093,
0.0269814637,
0.0646104962,
-0.0072421995,
0.0396880694,
-0.0101993056,
0.050669048,
0.0604204498,
0.020651022,
-0.0074014161,
0.0399168767,
0.0120837409,
-0.0049311509,
0.0167160556,
-0.0094773285,
-0.0175056886,
0.0347684547,
0.0002519611,
-0.014356263,
0.1249013916,
0.0193335358,
-0.011326259,
0.0119998176,
-0.0533288606,
0.0055846414,
0.0190036744,
0.0148379011,
-0.0367135033,
0.015586501,
-0.0059664636,
0.0371678732,
-0.0121412445,
-0.0142372968,
0.0096230488,
-0.031234432,
0.0691427961,
-0.0119513869,
-0.0050497428,
0.0223965924,
-0.0152949626,
0.0483817458,
0.01028853,
-0.0086164083,
-0.0263916384,
0.0149847884,
-0.0121907964,
0.0288319997,
-0.0297176596,
-0.0386943072,
-0.0028079336,
-0.0195856448,
0.0680440515,
0.0251532253,
0.0957758799,
0.0123205334,
-0.0013294359,
0.0241066776,
0.0384715423,
0.010405669,
-0.0312299058,
0.0425024964,
-0.0123293549,
0.0208284445,
-0.0156191057,
0.0690909401,
-0.0241496675,
0.0344123505,
0.0292929988,
0.0221783668,
-0.0725909397,
-0.0125484839,
-0.0171599071,
0.0309916735,
0.0472650006,
0.0536728762,
0.0267747808,
-0.0483875461,
-0.0091139665,
0.0154681252,
0.0108943051,
0.0565330163,
-0.0356948264,
-0.0365055203,
0.0079330122,
-0.0085386336,
-0.0529665872,
-0.0985933691,
0.0138375061,
0.0358775742,
-0.03013069,
-0.0326518305,
-0.0430413298,
0.016317904,
-0.0382038578,
0.0447953418,
0.0216650628,
0.044671271,
-0.0070151216,
-0.014231205,
-0.0319492146,
-0.0252735969,
0.0074228118,
-0.0398011059,
0.0749462694,
-0.0529069714,
0.0176020022,
0.0540713221,
0.0309525579,
0.0471167192,
0.0032436317,
-0.1034934148,
-0.0297448039,
0.0164006427,
-0.0306358039,
0.0277926307,
0.0220903493,
0.0184464436,
0.0018871047,
0.0355950855,
0.0070087221,
0.0954772532,
-0.0052697854,
0.012186246,
0.011874117,
-0.0405880362,
-0.0268377699,
-0.0095995925,
0.048477374,
-0.0072246958,
-0.0292974114,
-0.0063013565,
-0.0265404936,
-0.0237909481,
0.0008894114,
-0.0619180985,
0.0152783254,
-0.0559556,
0.0311094262,
-0.0265565012,
-0.0681978986,
-0.0653640553,
-0.0446580313,
-0.025518043,
0.0171724707,
0.0282284152,
0.0030574701,
-0.0183390398,
0.0331801325,
0.0346490555,
-0.0071024299,
0.0118745593,
0.0267781112,
0.0033913055,
0.093262814,
0.0426743068,
-0.008631275,
0.0372723006,
0.0334975459,
-0.0341129377,
-0.0364940912,
0.003338607,
-0.0011282881,
0.0205955934,
-0.0133909192,
0.0320951194,
-0.0164203197,
0.0169082228,
0.0134719573,
0.0291305874,
-0.0030649221,
-0.0535470471,
0.0412914976,
0.0291497987,
-0.0309128072,
0.003725132,
-0.0109458799,
-0.0476507396,
0.0544381328,
-0.0336089805,
-0.0064520678,
-0.0462353416,
0.0009821701,
0.0816962197,
0.0492934361,
-0.0248998236,
0.0341653302,
-0.0852150396,
-0.0303187352,
0.0099490043,
-0.0375600718,
0.0056145601,
-0.0494403616,
0.0645657629,
-0.0052895397,
-0.0110562434,
0.0184965059,
-0.0417713672,
0.011258753,
-0.0610933192,
-0.0257202797,
-0.02610364,
-5.54291945e-33,
0.0172096957,
0.0004089112,
-0.0244304184,
0.0112358583,
-0.0459289774,
0.0194851998,
-0.0459267534,
0.0083245272,
0.0116942339,
0.0614503659,
0.0140344622,
0.0924936086,
0.011563275,
-0.0046587032,
0.0115040913,
0.0341876149,
0.0269922186,
-0.010426959,
-0.0000721233,
0.0487684608,
0.0481633469,
0.0696973801,
0.0084861172,
-0.1165700704,
0.0481977761,
0.0093055414,
-0.0313789137,
0.0426826291,
0.0607441254,
0.0078102406,
-0.007421209,
0.0122654466,
0.0254293382,
0.0103149461,
0.0448003598,
0.0605886132,
-0.0194831993,
-0.0284621641,
0.0207245648,
-0.0200912431,
-0.0675409883,
-0.0029575902,
-0.0316854045,
0.0117988847,
0.0250311904,
-0.0038766842,
0.022017695,
-0.0117075946,
0.040262837,
-0.0057841903,
-0.0181699265,
-0.0018939095,
-0.0392424986,
-0.0208082814,
0.0193338152,
0.071657598,
-0.028597746,
0.0101251509,
0.0149952834,
0.0172615722,
-0.0385250337,
-0.0116616832,
-0.0000018813,
-0.0234351028,
-0.0118045555,
0.0739076659,
0.0301918089,
-0.008811621,
-0.0053736763,
0.0214248411,
-0.0098773595,
0.0764204562,
0.0215672459,
-0.0037125687,
-0.0463309139,
0.0103449496,
-0.0088946177,
0.0222925898,
0.0623800196,
0.017321853,
-0.0121925846,
0.0034768914,
-0.0429530442,
0.0093796076,
-0.020015575,
-0.0126929665,
0.0005972182,
-0.0223008562,
0.0449038371,
0.008745688,
0.0187988151,
-0.0324750915,
-0.0140708582,
-0.0344133489,
0.0353154279,
0.007482585,
-0.012889008,
0.0537799001,
0.0096516544,
-0.0101371109,
-0.0391518623,
-0.0279442593,
0.0123375608,
-0.0034094029,
0.0573845357,
-0.021213172,
0.0153250368,
-0.0006971078,
-0.0116184978,
-0.0190198589,
-0.0258404743,
0.101938881,
-0.0257371627,
-0.0122731542,
-0.0314252228,
0.0216889419,
-0.0349682607,
0.0232684202,
0.037792068,
0.0363092348,
-0.029358441,
-0.0334803239,
-0.0073157633,
0.0375735871,
-0.0436058752,
-0.0264014248,
-0.0180014372,
-0.0167390984,
0.0146922357,
-0.0055310228,
-0.0082376143,
-0.0151258064,
2.833e-7,
-0.0409522429,
0.0241479501,
0.0311236344,
-0.0226390585,
0.0620846115,
0.0250519738,
0.004170924,
0.0475320481,
0.0193662047,
-0.0252708718,
0.0412339233,
0.0278935228,
0.0491201691,
-0.0234391987,
-0.045991119,
-0.0428576358,
-0.0001160554,
-0.0663523152,
-0.0019997775,
0.0066794362,
0.0573240221,
0.0376263857,
0.0457528979,
0.0004336218,
0.0051562479,
0.0767166391,
0.0281043481,
-0.0488733985,
0.0324004404,
0.035338968,
-0.01048024,
-0.0539749637,
-0.0202361066,
-0.0009065049,
0.0014343405,
0.0452804156,
-0.0539121851,
0.0807439536,
-0.0390055031,
-0.0294731874,
0.0140566491,
0.0498282686,
-0.0241019838,
-0.0280160494,
-0.0035915654,
-0.0894399881,
-0.0475620665,
-0.016183598,
-0.038669195,
-0.0138025647,
-0.0318091325,
0.0305507556,
-0.0335540324,
0.0546416752,
-0.0195197966,
-0.0150520252,
-0.0017718535,
-0.0782970563,
0.0250231195,
0.0309525933,
-0.0225877948,
-0.0405035764,
-0.0317450128,
0.0571459047,
-0.0110176085,
-0.0360864587,
-0.0030452816,
1.686505048e-34,
0.0176146869,
0.0281715244,
-0.0149678905,
0.0277415365,
0.0227966364,
0.0147101171,
-0.0762282312,
0.0262717586,
0.0544509515,
-0.0406716503,
0.0075296396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17716v1 | Enhancing Large Language Model with Decomposed Reasoning for Emotion Cause Pair Extraction | 2024-01-31T10:20:01 | 2024-01-31T10:20:01 | Jialiang Wu, Yi Shen, Ziheng Zhang, Longjun Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction (ECPE) involves extracting clause pairs
representing emotions and their causes in a document. Existing methods tend to
overfit spurious correlations, such as positional bias in existing benchmark
datasets, rather than capturing semantic features. Inspired by recent work, we
explore leveraging large language model (LLM) to address ECPE task without
additional training. Despite strong capabilities, LLMs suffer from
uncontrollable outputs, resulting in mediocre performance. To address this, we
introduce chain-of-thought to mimic human cognitive process and propose the
Decomposed Emotion-Cause Chain (DECC) framework. Combining inducing inference
and logical pruning, DECC guides LLMs to tackle ECPE task. We further enhance
the framework by incorporating in-context learning. Experiment results
demonstrate the strength of DECC compared to state-of-the-art supervised
fine-tuning methods. Finally, we analyze the effectiveness of each component
and the robustness of the method in various scenarios, including different LLM
bases, rebalanced datasets, and multi-pair extraction. | Enhancing Large Language Model with Decomposed Reasoning for Emotion Cause Pair Extraction: Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction (ECPE) involves extracting clause pairs
representing emotions and their causes in a document. Existing methods tend to
overfit spurious correlations, such as positional bias in existing benchmark
datasets, rather than capturing semantic features. Inspired by recent work, we
explore leveraging large language model (LLM) to address ECPE task without
additional training. Despite strong capabilities, LLMs suffer from
uncontrollable outputs, resulting in mediocre performance. To address this, we
introduce chain-of-thought to mimic human cognitive process and propose the
Decomposed Emotion-Cause Chain (DECC) framework. Combining inducing inference
and logical pruning, DECC guides LLMs to tackle ECPE task. We further enhance
the framework by incorporating in-context learning. Experiment results
demonstrate the strength of DECC compared to state-of-the-art supervised
fine-tuning methods. Finally, we analyze the effectiveness of each component
and the robustness of the method in various scenarios, including different LLM
bases, rebalanced datasets, and multi-pair extraction. | [
0.0139949238,
0.1291119009,
0.0032461043,
0.0592853166,
-0.0080098407,
0.0500371754,
-0.0041251001,
0.0032562967,
0.0422301516,
-0.0397293195,
-0.0235454235,
0.0346691199,
-0.0401687697,
0.0025871689,
-0.0028432626,
-0.0622999072,
0.0072783194,
0.0269272346,
0.0586291663,
-0.0056499979,
0.0146167651,
0.0570569895,
0.00929501,
-0.0016844837,
-0.0398654118,
-0.0583948307,
-0.0112769641,
0.0414934084,
0.0385937989,
-0.0182839707,
0.0009260813,
0.0204243865,
0.0323423296,
-0.0011466726,
0.0000022915,
-0.0398926921,
-0.0310582761,
-0.0219681561,
-0.0056881146,
-0.006354013,
0.0317474939,
-0.007661189,
-0.0118072769,
-0.0061442009,
-0.0139372572,
-0.0187171977,
-0.0148989493,
0.0997801647,
0.0771218762,
0.117794089,
-0.0408663116,
-0.0397556163,
-0.0149289714,
-0.0182474889,
0.0257178918,
-0.0235975981,
0.0459694117,
-0.0086427145,
-0.0039785802,
-0.0366789885,
-0.0026820344,
-0.0244533755,
0.0195818003,
-0.0005165939,
-0.0182605926,
0.0095036048,
-0.027501408,
-0.0317415856,
-0.0014262309,
0.0879629105,
-0.027815856,
-0.0060576741,
0.0273053646,
-0.0161294453,
0.0105476622,
0.0032455784,
-0.0189987589,
0.0242269021,
-0.0266387966,
0.0383961722,
0.0619219691,
-0.0045607015,
0.0282704644,
0.0314934738,
-0.0481393896,
0.0363779515,
-0.014880185,
-0.0326592587,
0.0403706878,
0.0166098066,
-0.0473530367,
-0.0184698645,
0.0095956558,
-0.0011886335,
-0.0283021349,
0.0322649814,
-0.0246826578,
-0.0380558781,
-0.0411448926,
-0.047370933,
-0.0346855521,
0.0180355459,
-0.002628641,
0.0670596957,
-0.0159571059,
0.0049661966,
-0.0199936572,
0.0105349347,
-0.040307872,
-0.0086170016,
-0.0332443677,
0.0109291887,
-0.0073600961,
0.027967589,
-0.0548833571,
-0.0431332216,
-0.0352299549,
-0.0008208182,
-0.0136689059,
0.0157297608,
0.0096897241,
0.0026077754,
0.0011129586,
-0.0256639142,
0.0003519578,
0.0140336091,
-0.0402068533,
0.037615139,
0.0270263236,
-0.0218979623,
-0.0104728658,
0.0049519171,
0.0179062709,
-0.0184562393,
0.0377836078,
0.0066430839,
0.0036403481,
-0.0171988923,
-0.044055365,
-0.0457517989,
-0.0096183522,
-0.0380779617,
-0.0042337072,
-0.0506558418,
0.0335129462,
0.0022170229,
0.0072370996,
-0.0468505025,
0.0302748494,
-0.0159386322,
-0.0684878826,
0.0655731484,
0.0022141978,
-0.0188013185,
-0.0119984113,
0.012249684,
0.024620099,
0.0506135449,
0.0362374894,
0.0838107839,
0.0505046323,
0.0185235422,
0.0058458438,
0.0151033327,
0.0169199575,
-0.02651559,
-0.0175004583,
-0.0359492302,
-0.0016630653,
0.0341713317,
0.0493751839,
0.0325889997,
-0.0341782868,
0.0183000527,
0.0139900642,
0.0279187299,
-0.0043105506,
0.0608228445,
-0.0058596744,
0.0184047762,
0.0038299838,
-0.02418028,
-0.0263833143,
0.0099915424,
-0.0071520712,
-0.0046793553,
0.010995388,
0.0157387573,
-0.0254756659,
-0.0437103622,
-0.0082861949,
-0.0242476594,
-0.0341589563,
0.0168813858,
0.0478171259,
0.010567504,
-0.0608925,
0.0106394533,
0.0336024575,
-0.0805506259,
-0.0374449492,
-0.0154983886,
0.0288745165,
0.0335695371,
0.0401195996,
-0.0557760447,
-0.0222763252,
-0.0224834923,
-0.0118141389,
0.0234376304,
0.0061698821,
-0.0142972544,
0.0300562605,
-0.0501305237,
0.0073440773,
-0.0212373957,
0.0090059666,
-0.017315194,
-0.0329338796,
-0.0177645143,
0.0038652299,
-0.0065020663,
0.0065349559,
0.0245590042,
-0.0396764651,
-0.0260716509,
0.0018394061,
0.0436355174,
0.0472246483,
-0.0046358276,
0.0035462969,
-0.007405519,
0.0246292204,
-0.0531764738,
-0.0241578706,
0.0352333486,
-0.0288410578,
-0.085190855,
0.0378172249,
-0.0166826881,
-0.0455955677,
0.0190978684,
-0.0721642151,
-0.0103523219,
0.0155060012,
0.016766604,
0.0151647301,
-0.011898607,
0.015378369,
0.0125976624,
0.0115731107,
-0.0142213618,
0.0874392986,
-0.0009319754,
-0.0233997535,
0.0012163155,
-0.007023464,
-0.0006446437,
0.0271531306,
-0.0273130387,
0.0087057995,
0.0176127329,
-0.0254060291,
0.0126344366,
-0.0215350594,
-0.0769300535,
-0.0676673949,
-0.0795309693,
0.0118498532,
0.012484652,
0.0150866117,
0.0106080798,
-0.0152208665,
-0.0226810426,
0.0197427496,
-0.0199817307,
0.0121012945,
0.0167006385,
-0.0119394576,
0.0288388059,
-0.0315382928,
0.0089481184,
-0.0578288101,
0.0313453935,
-0.0519504137,
0.0502207093,
-0.0050089471,
0.0020506717,
-0.0191900488,
0.10327252,
-0.0178959686,
0.0218384601,
-0.006764859,
-0.0335714519,
0.0009092237,
-0.0443159565,
0.0165970679,
0.1209107786,
-0.0241278168,
0.0646603033,
0.0034551627,
-0.0155462399,
-0.0529486537,
0.0490550511,
-0.0392781571,
0.0284586046,
-0.0186580475,
-0.0101605821,
-0.033939898,
0.0747116655,
-0.0303259436,
0.0009565675,
-0.0361822546,
0.0295727514,
0.0162278768,
-0.0191364978,
-0.0419845171,
-0.0580602102,
0.0050463714,
0.037150126,
-0.0368196405,
-0.0452892035,
0.0461176746,
0.0266358033,
-0.0048603895,
-0.0738109499,
0.0340377465,
-0.0556062572,
0.1045584828,
-0.0182513148,
-0.009137514,
-0.0023022741,
0.0202525519,
-0.0399314612,
-0.038291797,
-0.0140576251,
-0.0220524166,
0.0315166228,
-0.0527382083,
-0.0156245166,
0.0146777499,
-0.0669083744,
-0.0355107151,
-0.0497060977,
-0.0566059574,
-0.0332260802,
-0.0031800715,
-0.0171308052,
0.0120702181,
-0.0590720177,
0.0360001475,
-0.0417843759,
0.0056881839,
-0.0295379851,
0.0029038491,
0.0306264386,
0.0678767934,
-0.0267401692,
0.0218637362,
-0.0328466222,
0.0619962104,
0.0572634302,
0.0371635519,
0.0171281733,
-0.0334501676,
0.0291614961,
-0.0062638461,
0.0404525511,
-0.0145550082,
-0.0414079577,
0.0004584154,
-0.0536519326,
0.0126913823,
0.1229227036,
0.0253235139,
-0.054917492,
0.003783986,
-0.0230398271,
0.0412156433,
0.0193051547,
0.0284246728,
-0.0517637096,
-0.0432405211,
0.0107518807,
-0.0173043311,
0.016158998,
-0.0429219417,
0.0122586405,
-0.1218667477,
0.0222501401,
0.0037243227,
0.0234071985,
-0.0051558516,
-0.0382580869,
0.0222803224,
-0.0061595174,
-0.0446520112,
-0.0174388271,
0.0137170544,
-0.0016993609,
0.0036734734,
-0.0140691316,
-0.0418561548,
0.029100243,
-0.0162943024,
0.0243976843,
0.031120602,
0.0925337598,
0.0137348324,
-0.0341707096,
0.0614652559,
-0.0149611812,
-0.0055507217,
-0.0115484502,
0.0447525121,
-0.0328118056,
-0.0169289056,
-0.0424881801,
0.0844586939,
-0.0544632487,
-0.0073832944,
-0.0155660333,
0.0927731693,
0.0009113183,
-0.0305645838,
-0.0136466054,
-0.0049705785,
-0.0253712609,
0.0682865456,
0.0393693149,
-0.0408052355,
-0.0383763611,
-0.0159487743,
0.0004850998,
-0.0102267982,
-0.0186384153,
-0.0245815404,
-0.011152464,
-0.0052728895,
-0.0799587891,
-0.0545492619,
0.0353103839,
0.0285363495,
-0.0188164841,
-0.0084423264,
-0.0002212329,
-0.0075770528,
-0.0143694449,
0.0528020374,
0.0204304941,
-0.0014431601,
0.0137693016,
0.0325411223,
0.0119511085,
0.002317497,
-0.0119295521,
0.0081390878,
-0.0506866574,
-0.0431196801,
0.0003998035,
0.0291911457,
0.0099674417,
0.0661250129,
-0.010305739,
-0.0267880745,
-0.0206253249,
0.0649441928,
-0.0076322509,
-0.0110026794,
0.0442147814,
0.0383835584,
0.0110451337,
0.0383355655,
-0.0260258745,
0.0442821048,
0.0408780873,
0.0317035727,
-0.0257284455,
-0.0410421081,
0.0336888358,
0.0396782011,
0.0617483817,
0.0034486968,
-0.034704227,
-0.052091673,
-0.0156848766,
-0.0450593159,
-0.0270920359,
-0.0556720085,
0.0405965336,
0.0229320116,
0.004197137,
-0.0610301308,
-0.0566233508,
0.0405721292,
0.0122868689,
0.0153078288,
0.034092959,
0.0146808345,
0.019155208,
0.0065132617,
0.0033881182,
-0.0058049154,
0.0059263399,
0.0152018331,
0.0222142804,
-0.028176412,
0.0547372848,
0.0568495393,
-0.0266672727,
-0.0048632757,
-0.0082623251,
-0.0216759332,
-0.0147845028,
0.0187903736,
-0.0305489935,
0.0549327508,
-0.0424683578,
0.0599272437,
-0.038052123,
0.0065989932,
0.0293752216,
0.032544896,
0.0238367282,
-0.0189493615,
0.0047614188,
0.0139987916,
-0.0324699357,
-0.0031066984,
0.031729918,
-0.0786396414,
0.0680939928,
0.0201730449,
-0.0076188971,
-0.0509026684,
-0.0152837289,
0.0362494402,
-0.0067407079,
-0.0087619498,
0.0416483395,
-0.0667613521,
-0.0500908382,
0.0099049397,
-0.0263910107,
0.0022227862,
-0.0237722769,
0.0207410194,
0.0818686336,
-0.0178699717,
0.0123695191,
-0.0242970362,
0.0315341279,
-0.0606995858,
-0.0647919625,
-0.0223512407,
-6.181443573e-33,
0.0010484058,
-0.0074726343,
-0.0217913408,
0.0257153455,
-0.0366115607,
0.024177283,
-0.0465133935,
0.0029962866,
0.0012057011,
0.073968403,
-0.0329123214,
0.0294976085,
-0.0031728989,
0.0108561553,
-0.0157395359,
-0.0109916115,
0.0334323347,
0.0029471661,
0.0039147059,
0.0166827962,
0.074225232,
0.0529459268,
0.0252018925,
-0.1135499105,
-0.0190417245,
0.0050717355,
-0.0319429226,
0.0055676643,
0.0258762147,
0.0229938161,
-0.0083418665,
0.0079627419,
0.0157257542,
-0.0123619195,
0.0151522644,
0.0483310334,
-0.0384715386,
-0.0130577637,
-0.0029916703,
-0.0286935903,
-0.0439073034,
-0.0542871021,
0.0048258761,
0.027374249,
0.0046756323,
-0.0289454423,
0.0195531826,
-0.0355989262,
-0.0064641275,
-0.0835628361,
-0.0499231964,
0.0312430486,
-0.0233511031,
-0.0097683938,
0.0219881143,
0.0223648269,
-0.0208097454,
0.0547035336,
-0.030283032,
-0.0111304298,
-0.007315902,
0.0110541498,
0.0005929747,
-0.0296010952,
0.0061527276,
0.1061734483,
-0.0031259714,
0.0201855041,
-0.0484244414,
0.0483726002,
0.0136907101,
0.0709032938,
0.0375742838,
0.056557022,
0.0283388328,
0.0021323813,
-0.0884765312,
0.0236354079,
0.0385146104,
0.0335997939,
0.0452712514,
0.0147946496,
0.0032683588,
0.0144483186,
-0.0121539719,
0.0230313353,
-0.0212860368,
-0.0054632588,
0.0127623174,
0.013730241,
-0.022668276,
-0.0231722835,
-0.0116482861,
-0.0294662043,
0.0035571316,
0.0656451657,
-0.0281761233,
0.0322463624,
0.0059023914,
0.0114257848,
-0.0499771908,
-0.0176034942,
0.0137548773,
0.0255841985,
0.0701448992,
0.0349208079,
0.0461427346,
-0.0295182243,
-0.048031047,
-0.0118119428,
-0.0635923594,
0.0118330186,
-0.0526501685,
0.0184754729,
-0.0201929938,
0.0386125743,
-0.011742142,
0.0087544024,
0.0209624991,
0.0539416522,
0.0013006106,
0.0095681008,
-0.0055241468,
0.0245290883,
-0.0117058288,
-0.0366419107,
0.0015419406,
-0.0275601875,
0.0176639464,
-0.0676020458,
-0.017873425,
-0.006411213,
2.964e-7,
0.0164729077,
0.0520422645,
0.0312525369,
-0.006987751,
0.0175196584,
0.0577711649,
0.0002995819,
0.0006020772,
0.050461594,
-0.0250860713,
0.0332190432,
0.0215731841,
0.0766868591,
-0.0061729741,
-0.1044258252,
-0.0036661904,
-0.0212202854,
-0.0337771364,
-0.0532427691,
-0.0059277518,
0.089441739,
0.0986240059,
0.0562080927,
-0.0203536842,
0.0172175765,
0.0400344022,
0.0462650694,
-0.054371912,
-0.0294701122,
0.0209778827,
-0.0150507987,
-0.0538510717,
-0.0191703886,
0.0109065017,
-0.0066496511,
0.0149072492,
-0.0056445245,
0.0638261661,
0.0274342336,
-0.0096455123,
0.0193143096,
0.0072167162,
0.0134054497,
-0.062046133,
0.0589250363,
-0.0506422631,
-0.040477667,
-0.0218608454,
-0.048207216,
-0.0015462183,
0.0163548291,
-0.0061701555,
-0.0278927404,
0.0110641746,
0.0029727849,
-0.0267665274,
-0.0169572271,
-0.1084486693,
-0.0204013996,
0.0163153075,
-0.0257309098,
-0.0219507068,
-0.0104781501,
0.0503779091,
0.0474315621,
-0.0611233041,
-0.0175123345,
2.975447805e-34,
0.0101642208,
0.0117499912,
-0.0079728309,
0.0363268219,
0.07862515,
-0.0011355882,
-0.0635855645,
0.0239845011,
0.0308280028,
-0.0823561475,
0.0297003016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17703v1 | WSC+: Enhancing The Winograd Schema Challenge Using Tree-of-Experts | 2024-01-31T09:49:22 | 2024-01-31T09:49:22 | Pardis Sadat Zahraei, Ali Emami | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7; K.4.1 | The Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC) serves as a prominent benchmark for
evaluating machine understanding. While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at
answering WSC questions, their ability to generate such questions remains less
explored. In this work, we propose Tree-of-Experts (ToE), a novel prompting
method which enhances the generation of WSC instances (50% valid cases vs. 10%
in recent methods). Using this approach, we introduce WSC+, a novel dataset
comprising 3,026 LLM-generated sentences. Notably, we extend the WSC framework
by incorporating new 'ambiguous' and 'offensive' categories, providing a deeper
insight into model overconfidence and bias. Our analysis reveals nuances in
generation-evaluation consistency, suggesting that LLMs may not always
outperform in evaluating their own generated questions when compared to those
crafted by other models. On WSC+, GPT-4, the top-performing LLM, achieves an
accuracy of 68.7%, significantly below the human benchmark of 95.1%. | WSC+: Enhancing The Winograd Schema Challenge Using Tree-of-Experts: The Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC) serves as a prominent benchmark for
evaluating machine understanding. While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at
answering WSC questions, their ability to generate such questions remains less
explored. In this work, we propose Tree-of-Experts (ToE), a novel prompting
method which enhances the generation of WSC instances (50% valid cases vs. 10%
in recent methods). Using this approach, we introduce WSC+, a novel dataset
comprising 3,026 LLM-generated sentences. Notably, we extend the WSC framework
by incorporating new 'ambiguous' and 'offensive' categories, providing a deeper
insight into model overconfidence and bias. Our analysis reveals nuances in
generation-evaluation consistency, suggesting that LLMs may not always
outperform in evaluating their own generated questions when compared to those
crafted by other models. On WSC+, GPT-4, the top-performing LLM, achieves an
accuracy of 68.7%, significantly below the human benchmark of 95.1%. | [
0.0736180171,
0.0751572773,
-0.0221042037,
0.0480268151,
-0.055602733,
0.0174662154,
0.0032873109,
-0.0357213803,
0.0249709804,
-0.0409650616,
-0.0065886523,
-0.0618743338,
-0.0160866473,
0.0401765332,
0.0161746889,
-0.0311931316,
0.0673163682,
-0.0406951383,
0.0118276402,
-0.0081235133,
-0.0013673548,
0.0204597563,
0.0012779507,
0.0293768868,
-0.0297267269,
-0.0258121192,
-0.0285809003,
0.0181931388,
0.0033279925,
-0.0519672297,
0.0250521656,
0.0781406686,
0.0158160739,
0.0709746629,
0.0000021843,
-0.0709988624,
-0.0292408746,
-0.0141570726,
-0.0412895307,
-0.011820104,
0.0478109382,
-0.0161709879,
0.0237915013,
0.0132466042,
-0.0451670587,
0.0183788817,
0.0233008713,
0.0719106719,
0.0690940842,
0.1074215025,
0.003662657,
-0.0244198944,
0.0130255139,
-0.0120443804,
0.0104620745,
-0.0595664605,
-0.0140230535,
0.0197044108,
-0.0366037861,
0.0049397903,
0.0000859501,
0.0073164925,
0.0244584624,
-0.0077570872,
-0.0016474199,
0.0122323427,
-0.0480927378,
-0.033661861,
-0.0145323239,
0.0857759491,
-0.0105650192,
-0.0177091286,
-0.0173175093,
-0.0076483274,
-0.0004248201,
-0.0024872643,
-0.0112086469,
0.0355076082,
-0.025640972,
0.0040081949,
0.0293879174,
-0.0052037714,
0.0183993969,
0.0125659639,
-0.0051830313,
0.0807079598,
0.0071453396,
-0.0442527831,
0.0327549689,
-0.0156851057,
-0.0463192351,
-0.0829970464,
-0.0160927325,
0.0242988653,
-0.0839985609,
0.0353238322,
-0.047999423,
0.0191203244,
0.0432730727,
-0.0346721373,
0.0552671477,
0.025433965,
-0.0100079635,
0.0332866348,
0.017093638,
0.0500854589,
0.016468117,
-0.0185549874,
-0.0510193817,
-0.0267122015,
-0.0413341485,
-0.022333974,
-0.0370393358,
0.009429194,
-0.0483991988,
0.000238567,
-0.0299346652,
0.0047523538,
-0.0135356355,
0.0087392731,
0.0316019654,
0.0515707657,
-0.0165556222,
-0.000378056,
-0.0456996709,
0.0023487788,
-0.0365246125,
0.0142303575,
-0.015911445,
-0.0437733904,
-0.0062204343,
0.0387484506,
-0.0315614641,
-0.0180323422,
0.0199627299,
0.0569101907,
-0.0093279406,
-0.0231948029,
-0.0254477076,
-0.0495854318,
-0.0354092568,
-0.07146357,
-0.0009054928,
-0.0551640689,
0.0255200267,
0.008651142,
-0.0174580012,
-0.0447137468,
0.0162832085,
0.0378863364,
-0.0215451121,
0.0548504032,
-0.0332330279,
0.0098110214,
0.0339348204,
0.0234054234,
-0.0571564399,
0.0644054487,
0.0115006585,
0.0499253944,
0.036256548,
0.0208263379,
0.0173459463,
0.032761652,
-0.007685822,
-0.0031607004,
-0.0003849281,
0.0525795072,
-0.0483986437,
0.0336937942,
0.0191817209,
0.061534483,
0.0092433318,
-0.0147185735,
0.0425675176,
0.0291381534,
-0.038864851,
0.0065133558,
0.0547987297,
0.0193648729,
0.0147786606,
0.0159518439,
-0.0702938065,
-0.0152162826,
-0.0512894206,
-0.0092249718,
-0.0514127463,
0.0216326844,
0.0030382772,
-0.052649904,
-0.03142621,
0.0244096611,
-0.0085456213,
0.0124784363,
0.0244008433,
0.0075787711,
-0.0349090435,
0.0368821807,
0.0096165584,
-0.0521353446,
-0.0133815948,
-0.038977012,
0.0352842622,
0.0438562967,
0.0490820184,
-0.0296420697,
-0.040313635,
0.0008951519,
0.0038990711,
0.0673470125,
0.036417827,
-0.0387703106,
0.0173951928,
-0.0330482684,
-0.0237618014,
-0.0419225618,
0.0421161726,
0.0041572824,
0.0305427946,
-0.0369455442,
0.0389324725,
-0.0759896785,
-0.0707568601,
0.050984405,
-0.0155287171,
-0.0348556787,
-0.0031415268,
0.0022760564,
0.0185860712,
0.0045722774,
-0.0254899133,
0.0128360353,
0.0120549332,
-0.0351269692,
-0.0243507531,
-0.0117753893,
-0.0667959973,
-0.0304544754,
0.0305493847,
-0.0403765365,
-0.0459654927,
0.0310913734,
-0.0433494858,
-0.0299679805,
-0.0042410656,
-0.0126382597,
-0.0000558392,
-0.0608623326,
0.0194945969,
0.0093404735,
-0.0079200966,
-0.0496042073,
0.1092228666,
-0.0068937521,
-0.0072626262,
0.0396375544,
-0.0341983102,
0.0398256071,
-0.0152635146,
-0.0170644931,
0.0199258495,
-0.0085429493,
0.0042639063,
0.025644457,
0.0339218453,
-0.0865593106,
-0.0271577295,
-0.0959788263,
0.0138846003,
-0.0229958314,
0.0306127369,
0.0375618339,
-0.0332572646,
-0.0232269447,
0.0121310698,
-0.0630883202,
-0.0310414042,
0.017046554,
0.0092256097,
0.0272159167,
-0.0449562185,
0.000530075,
-0.0331284255,
-0.0037980378,
-0.0478034206,
0.045790568,
-0.0099440049,
0.0356807932,
-0.0317924097,
0.0086645409,
-0.0394650549,
0.0053438912,
0.0073812939,
-0.0101328967,
0.0343913846,
0.008601116,
0.0288424678,
0.0305277053,
0.0275424495,
0.0593382306,
0.0469403565,
-0.0255290214,
-0.0185992662,
0.0034934347,
0.0048029907,
-0.0073502581,
-0.0183469206,
-0.0675980598,
0.0216495246,
0.0623715371,
0.0363040045,
-0.0059435377,
-0.0243895613,
0.0437914468,
-0.0486081876,
-0.042186439,
-0.0610209741,
-0.0379501693,
0.0087049492,
0.0667970106,
-0.041399695,
-0.0460720956,
0.0879152566,
-0.0493689142,
0.0090318304,
-0.0515000559,
-0.0081207044,
-0.0461866781,
0.1012172326,
-0.0007542392,
0.0286978446,
0.0363357924,
-0.0067783385,
-0.0715953037,
-0.0215863753,
0.0014592999,
-0.0272347629,
0.0219898224,
-0.0541342981,
-0.0071755578,
0.0058453497,
-0.0114722708,
-0.0753883868,
-0.0616728738,
-0.031989269,
0.0193805527,
0.0272404049,
-0.0051370887,
-0.0086256834,
-0.0036933206,
-0.0084550995,
0.0070466152,
-0.0372879021,
-0.0103865601,
-0.005621315,
0.0584910363,
0.0573301949,
0.0144099798,
0.0297668129,
-0.0200436115,
0.0447841398,
0.0356617719,
-0.0064250208,
0.0187562071,
-0.0280351099,
0.0409501456,
-0.0069557331,
-0.0184328128,
-0.0154961972,
-0.0082692122,
0.0608655289,
-0.0534647852,
-0.0121181943,
0.138689369,
0.0599293225,
-0.004697294,
0.0327638946,
-0.0375645235,
0.026632065,
0.0435994007,
0.0278857015,
-0.0903145,
-0.0451015234,
0.0100311143,
0.0096414927,
-0.0376983471,
-0.0523006432,
-0.0333629437,
-0.1226312891,
0.032899294,
-0.023165375,
-0.0283157639,
0.0109431632,
-0.0006057774,
-0.0104321437,
0.002124764,
0.0309275426,
0.0329599902,
0.012547886,
0.0107469633,
0.0089486865,
-0.0166952144,
-0.0413222387,
0.0490590744,
-0.0136045059,
0.047603894,
0.0566076562,
0.0209052097,
0.0194016304,
0.0054539582,
0.0255174041,
-0.029812552,
0.009325482,
-0.0303026419,
0.0496640243,
0.0089702904,
-0.025530532,
-0.015156311,
0.0282441825,
-0.0335658863,
0.0166330189,
0.0459973216,
0.0656945109,
-0.0177305639,
-0.0370650738,
-0.0202453341,
-0.01327956,
0.0133332079,
0.105069831,
0.0293740071,
-0.0090931933,
-0.0305390861,
-0.0399522223,
-0.0181645565,
-0.0036677865,
-0.0481014103,
0.0693377405,
0.0325012207,
-0.0058581391,
-0.050529249,
-0.0739987269,
0.0535533279,
0.0159106757,
-0.0023485289,
-0.0040995353,
-0.0596458539,
0.0166548025,
-0.0433157012,
0.0384439565,
-0.0259870794,
-0.0145953605,
-0.0366302431,
-0.0001397548,
0.0102258064,
-0.0231344681,
-0.0422138646,
0.0489004888,
-0.0626073033,
-0.0732080042,
0.0088040326,
0.0375694744,
0.0290850271,
0.0017178605,
-0.017155325,
-0.0332299061,
0.0064186165,
0.0385842025,
-0.0183438864,
0.0059536034,
0.0259742346,
-0.0183696989,
-0.0014289372,
0.0641180724,
-0.0224097408,
0.069449842,
-0.0082932673,
0.0693519637,
-0.0013058358,
-0.0223078784,
0.0676955581,
0.0433287881,
-0.0115763294,
-0.0341646783,
-0.0086100511,
-0.0203524325,
0.0153340111,
-0.0447628051,
-0.0449644886,
-0.0225835536,
0.0192993712,
-0.014242582,
-0.0263940617,
-0.0024741183,
-0.0354661755,
-0.0422424488,
0.0377102122,
-0.0173622984,
-0.0036185728,
0.0536530986,
0.0149646383,
-0.0053466219,
0.0021469546,
-0.0357877091,
0.0165458266,
-0.0190343894,
0.0425804891,
0.0191540997,
0.0505386144,
0.0108804861,
-0.000895488,
-0.0234095789,
0.0173210893,
-0.0291625466,
-0.064276658,
-0.0059568998,
0.0242413785,
0.0569119267,
-0.0082453862,
0.0397757664,
-0.0111151002,
0.0112945344,
0.0025460972,
-0.0025765281,
0.0234385207,
-0.021300504,
0.030076215,
0.0297694318,
-0.0286185257,
0.0007693118,
0.079841733,
0.0355034247,
0.0464464687,
0.0365559272,
-0.0148536144,
-0.0543355085,
-0.014233985,
0.0252893884,
0.0190480668,
0.0090210112,
0.0327265933,
-0.0854853988,
-0.0771793947,
0.0151853338,
0.0229265634,
0.0213785674,
-0.000112541,
0.0434275679,
0.092667006,
-0.006498246,
-0.0007480313,
-0.0171429217,
0.0089708697,
-0.0079397941,
-0.0203871578,
-0.0316040516,
-6.999993187e-33,
-0.0137633234,
-0.0502863005,
0.0160275903,
-0.0472261831,
0.0047541992,
0.0020866969,
-0.0511469766,
0.0084577724,
-0.0303915311,
0.0173710641,
-0.0063998611,
0.006239655,
0.0049386853,
0.022359537,
0.0159403384,
-0.0233549643,
0.0374105945,
0.0098972684,
-0.0283172932,
0.0019092108,
0.0367436111,
0.0175038073,
0.0689789429,
-0.045142401,
0.0348417982,
-0.0026259634,
-0.0385697074,
0.0416212864,
-0.0123862233,
0.03412145,
-0.0367652997,
0.0833814591,
0.0397036336,
-0.0132219661,
0.0149763701,
-0.0214898475,
-0.0641598031,
-0.0454299599,
0.043844413,
-0.0460419245,
-0.0456653945,
-0.0255538616,
0.0315146819,
-0.0088284267,
-0.0054332549,
0.0036034498,
0.0215430949,
-0.0076492694,
0.0131251914,
-0.0270496234,
-0.0649932995,
0.0184216332,
-0.0078725852,
-0.0219314564,
-0.0261836834,
0.0536175668,
-0.0105269291,
0.025060961,
-0.0195118375,
0.0002943132,
0.0423749648,
0.042168811,
0.0508903489,
-0.0234408677,
-0.0204287302,
0.0723700151,
0.0121295424,
0.0087690027,
0.0066373064,
-0.0090658143,
0.001911574,
0.0478391722,
0.0414167829,
0.0435227603,
0.0484574847,
-0.0088028004,
-0.0574169829,
0.0244623292,
0.0514963046,
0.0158051681,
0.0052106637,
-0.0498191416,
-0.0467316695,
-0.0184285436,
-0.0482794903,
-0.0298756696,
-0.0377857238,
-0.025985511,
0.050089974,
-0.0156981442,
-0.0065294346,
-0.0142895952,
0.0214406699,
-0.0065166503,
0.0132327648,
0.0186051428,
-0.0071266531,
-0.0073793787,
0.019722553,
0.0635010153,
-0.0244706422,
-0.0085183652,
0.0029657409,
0.0172661152,
0.0291123707,
0.0205108114,
0.0350551084,
0.0037725552,
-0.0503317751,
0.0089788744,
-0.030200325,
0.0348197818,
-0.0509757996,
0.0111547653,
0.0102473544,
0.0320092626,
-0.033431001,
0.0258963909,
0.0217880905,
0.0078772986,
-0.0535091981,
0.0001233514,
0.0011000221,
0.0206128601,
-0.0106143309,
-0.0115246503,
-0.0069594579,
-0.0285715256,
0.0306140911,
-0.0553069487,
0.0092433281,
-0.031602636,
2.88e-7,
0.0352682509,
0.0749909803,
0.0039200732,
0.0785480812,
-0.0102796853,
0.0270149615,
0.0042620078,
0.0200434532,
0.0030180584,
-0.0667564943,
0.0182342082,
0.013247259,
0.0299503282,
0.0594329052,
-0.0774315,
0.0168712195,
-0.0948358402,
-0.0025341013,
-0.0553682595,
0.0260623656,
0.071671851,
0.1039348468,
-0.0016144299,
-0.0355721451,
-0.0260935277,
-0.0166802667,
0.0246351119,
-0.0118212625,
0.0164220147,
0.0148022417,
0.058496438,
0.0031379901,
0.0179142039,
0.0415424854,
0.0144031998,
0.014063186,
-0.0104120187,
0.0358924456,
-0.0265295301,
-0.0216200165,
-0.0089926608,
-0.0259682313,
0.0023252019,
-0.0747876242,
0.0768080279,
-0.0391554981,
-0.035321001,
-0.0115566794,
-0.0198230166,
-0.0176684801,
0.0094791465,
-0.0368592441,
0.003897537,
0.0110487277,
-0.0112741198,
-0.0193421878,
0.0182051007,
-0.0427716486,
-0.0298446268,
0.0221232511,
-0.0104862824,
-0.0375516526,
-0.0099664256,
-0.0010595553,
0.0113987783,
-0.0537488833,
0.0163535569,
2.71263459e-34,
0.0694427788,
0.0092460942,
-0.0006325041,
0.0212496519,
0.0431905836,
0.0034722923,
-0.0141904689,
-0.0155530944,
-0.001227871,
-0.069839634,
-0.0285165533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17692v1 | Mitigating the Problem of Strong Priors in LMs with Context Extrapolation | 2024-01-31T09:28:06 | 2024-01-31T09:28:06 | Raymond Douglas, Andis Draguns, Tomáš Gavenčiak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have become important tools in a variety of
applications, from data processing to the creation of instruction-following
assistants. But despite their advantages, LMs have certain idiosyncratic
limitations such as the problem of `strong priors', where a model learns to
output typical continuations in response to certain, usually local, portions of
the input regardless of any earlier instructions. For example, prompt injection
attacks can induce models to ignore explicit directives. In some cases, larger
models have been shown to be more susceptible to these problems than similar
smaller models, an example of the phenomenon of `inverse scaling'. We develop a
new technique for mitigating the problem of strong priors: we take the original
set of instructions, produce a weakened version of the original prompt that is
even more susceptible to the strong priors problem, and then extrapolate the
continuation away from the weakened prompt. This lets us infer how the model
would continue a hypothetical strengthened set of instructions. Our technique
conceptualises LMs as mixture models which combine a family of data generation
processes, reinforcing the desired elements of the mixture. Our approach works
at inference time, removing any need for retraining. We apply it to eleven
models including GPT-2, GPT-3, Llama 2, and Mistral on four tasks, and find
improvements in 41/44. Across all 44 combinations the median increase in
proportion of tasks completed is 40%. | Mitigating the Problem of Strong Priors in LMs with Context Extrapolation: Language models (LMs) have become important tools in a variety of
applications, from data processing to the creation of instruction-following
assistants. But despite their advantages, LMs have certain idiosyncratic
limitations such as the problem of `strong priors', where a model learns to
output typical continuations in response to certain, usually local, portions of
the input regardless of any earlier instructions. For example, prompt injection
attacks can induce models to ignore explicit directives. In some cases, larger
models have been shown to be more susceptible to these problems than similar
smaller models, an example of the phenomenon of `inverse scaling'. We develop a
new technique for mitigating the problem of strong priors: we take the original
set of instructions, produce a weakened version of the original prompt that is
even more susceptible to the strong priors problem, and then extrapolate the
continuation away from the weakened prompt. This lets us infer how the model
would continue a hypothetical strengthened set of instructions. Our technique
conceptualises LMs as mixture models which combine a family of data generation
processes, reinforcing the desired elements of the mixture. Our approach works
at inference time, removing any need for retraining. We apply it to eleven
models including GPT-2, GPT-3, Llama 2, and Mistral on four tasks, and find
improvements in 41/44. Across all 44 combinations the median increase in
proportion of tasks completed is 40%. | [
0.0141507965,
0.0613349527,
-0.0334306471,
0.0121207256,
-0.0292020328,
0.0202479009,
-0.0343785137,
-0.0152316606,
-0.0194773581,
-0.0272631906,
-0.0242265463,
-0.0337148085,
0.0029400599,
0.0006467824,
0.0447518826,
-0.0714124814,
0.047972329,
-0.0987395346,
-0.0241060853,
-0.012219849,
-0.0359092653,
-0.023468595,
0.0027877835,
0.0446689837,
0.0388976149,
0.0059626391,
-0.0305419695,
0.0003489554,
0.0164111555,
-0.0123120509,
-0.0169502739,
0.0129780434,
0.0326142646,
0.0022725763,
0.0000021203,
-0.0378717668,
0.0055681877,
-0.0176474806,
-0.0373931341,
-0.0035005482,
0.0081605492,
-0.0086192396,
-0.005687254,
0.0325382873,
-0.0155084589,
-0.0161961671,
0.0419746563,
0.0311848465,
0.044254072,
0.0826383382,
0.0077496208,
-0.0046751075,
0.0244812276,
-0.0314724408,
0.0493413061,
-0.0603533313,
0.0183950495,
-0.038013868,
0.0464946665,
0.0288745966,
-0.0104035046,
0.0203063339,
0.0289770439,
0.0096197166,
-0.0349895805,
0.0539644249,
0.0658019185,
-0.0165896304,
-0.0295580998,
0.0317625441,
-0.0391466692,
-0.0087902024,
-0.0098725175,
-0.0400985256,
0.0153888548,
0.017696511,
-0.0589030683,
0.032646928,
-0.0147332819,
0.0296383854,
0.0373586789,
-0.0352023505,
0.047380507,
0.0023359642,
-0.0174996182,
0.0861602947,
0.0252874549,
-0.0294778384,
-0.0139532676,
-0.0092162043,
-0.0370550007,
-0.0639276728,
-0.0064162309,
0.0636686236,
-0.0372212641,
0.0316116102,
-0.0520484112,
-0.0018796808,
0.0238957424,
-0.0265960637,
0.0481340997,
0.0694817603,
-0.0578748807,
0.0042486675,
-0.0101812081,
0.039954219,
-0.0287398752,
0.0223402027,
-0.0338661857,
0.0322343782,
-0.0348169357,
-0.0115886303,
-0.026516702,
0.0203900803,
-0.05355056,
0.0096793175,
-0.0259038545,
0.0753095075,
-0.0119348178,
0.011084131,
0.0071889609,
-0.0105836857,
-0.0659647435,
-0.0097719096,
-0.0193287469,
-0.003575153,
-0.0282479804,
0.0515627675,
0.0308441855,
-0.0688014701,
-0.0384814404,
-0.0122610638,
-0.0217413343,
-0.022900654,
-0.0146137364,
0.1092984006,
-0.0196983106,
-0.0328440666,
-0.063615486,
-0.036261566,
-0.0138703287,
-0.058110375,
0.0122533292,
-0.0405341461,
0.0100957919,
-0.0005137548,
-0.0029136883,
-0.0124438666,
-0.0023888727,
0.0174196772,
-0.0488723963,
0.0822165161,
-0.0024237875,
0.0076024956,
0.0538823642,
0.0352642089,
-0.0663884729,
0.063783817,
0.0089483066,
0.0204525013,
0.005767094,
0.0181455631,
0.0285292044,
0.0283368472,
0.0017151196,
0.0291297194,
-0.0050794068,
-0.0113895079,
0.0102865258,
-0.0235847645,
0.0308353435,
0.0677791908,
-0.0269130673,
0.0197794363,
0.0835818425,
0.0260830335,
-0.0185385533,
-0.0161817968,
0.0809821412,
-0.0256424453,
-0.025381159,
0.0806983784,
-0.1077306569,
-0.0239984561,
-0.0263765492,
0.0220351964,
0.0036279501,
0.0271874629,
-0.0282354336,
-0.0418395847,
0.004127414,
-0.0187604036,
-0.0209030844,
-0.0060430164,
0.0658886731,
0.0139855519,
-0.0235901158,
-0.0087023899,
0.0253774934,
-0.037407808,
0.021837363,
-0.0954642221,
0.0165542495,
0.0603827871,
0.0219799057,
-0.0487355068,
-0.0246352628,
0.0032248825,
-0.0136294682,
-0.0008556251,
-0.006685941,
-0.0021968647,
0.0402589366,
-0.0240072589,
-0.0145811858,
-0.009071433,
0.0350965634,
0.0434195548,
-0.0264915153,
-0.0113774016,
0.0245655235,
-0.007173392,
0.0311404001,
0.0452187695,
-0.0245764945,
-0.0457258299,
0.0013094712,
-0.0164076705,
0.0469913296,
-0.0085186856,
0.0171244871,
0.0329303965,
0.0475638099,
-0.011152436,
-0.0053479425,
0.0167830326,
-0.0831912681,
-0.0281550158,
0.0231132414,
0.0301701669,
0.02254376,
-0.0374389477,
-0.030378364,
-0.0595023669,
0.0030875732,
-0.044418551,
0.0666437373,
-0.0115711996,
0.0494255982,
0.0286050439,
-0.022819085,
-0.039201159,
0.0674934611,
-0.0329151787,
-0.0170714483,
0.0778543651,
0.0130722327,
-0.0121989762,
-0.0664647818,
-0.0172735825,
-0.01063223,
-0.0010444951,
-0.0014575202,
-0.0039365562,
-0.0153457578,
-0.0242921896,
-0.0219429508,
-0.0552869663,
-0.0120497886,
-0.0362901725,
0.0228721499,
0.0185237769,
0.0282972809,
-0.0279150233,
-0.0182279907,
-0.0035213598,
-0.0245590955,
0.0222146511,
0.0465751626,
0.0064927489,
0.0628270879,
-0.0255733971,
-0.0462105833,
-0.009875712,
-0.0146031836,
0.0207394008,
-0.0181755051,
0.0105385836,
-0.1044654027,
0.035237629,
0.0013930002,
0.0507700555,
-0.0454420261,
0.0005940095,
0.0311744381,
-0.0212929472,
0.09535449,
0.063990958,
-0.0066030845,
0.0156857762,
0.0738126487,
-0.0211956222,
-0.024948135,
0.0124374526,
-0.0422891118,
-0.063189663,
-0.0338419415,
-0.0428180099,
-0.0111942887,
0.0639496446,
0.0258678943,
-0.0090626134,
-0.0407544337,
-0.0015719078,
0.0054117143,
-0.0413052402,
0.0018824622,
-0.0634820759,
-0.0472843423,
0.0288624372,
-0.0251397528,
-0.100600794,
0.0719867796,
-0.0533807538,
0.0349511355,
-0.0027630411,
-0.0305542275,
0.00931386,
0.0287639536,
0.0228102971,
-0.0172823165,
0.0023046331,
-0.0219663195,
-0.0631590709,
0.0059364238,
0.0144693106,
0.0000939063,
0.0535136722,
-0.0794654489,
-0.0215765033,
-0.0083104745,
-0.0354138613,
-0.0656598955,
-0.0242482778,
0.0073768906,
0.0058563552,
0.0150178075,
-0.0035201628,
0.009618178,
-0.0045548896,
0.0194313023,
0.0514640324,
-0.0290887281,
-0.0064232862,
-0.0455622412,
-0.0084889289,
0.0313149467,
-0.0129142543,
-0.0139019806,
-0.0741098076,
0.0242580324,
0.0255323965,
0.0968516544,
-0.0446502455,
-0.0337329283,
0.017077053,
0.0122998608,
0.0000313489,
-0.0330009982,
0.0708828196,
0.0958204493,
-0.0354752988,
-0.0329394229,
0.0847099125,
-0.0037640149,
-0.0412847213,
0.0224705879,
-0.0161056146,
0.044515904,
0.0053063328,
0.0178387687,
-0.0583559833,
-0.0199357029,
0.0481048375,
0.053534124,
-0.0218045469,
-0.0266067721,
-0.0047064475,
-0.1039601639,
0.0372346602,
0.0045291535,
-0.0242128279,
-0.0060996348,
-0.0681032836,
0.0130561162,
0.0032012356,
0.0297468547,
0.0172739513,
-0.0131789474,
0.001922438,
0.0314992145,
0.0110450573,
-0.0687454045,
0.0015463342,
-0.0285563301,
0.0407655239,
0.0542384647,
-0.0267693065,
0.0042169639,
-0.0098997001,
0.0490710102,
-0.0354863144,
0.0240430906,
0.0056875646,
0.013481196,
-0.018637849,
0.0012547272,
0.0421540216,
0.0594378114,
-0.0117827347,
-0.0411402918,
0.028740475,
0.0698594078,
-0.0441551805,
0.0042758784,
-0.0266998447,
-0.0171622075,
0.0450248197,
0.0583516508,
0.037207704,
-0.0413031541,
0.0109070688,
-0.0351034701,
-0.0058175405,
0.0352996476,
0.0435018763,
-0.0068759066,
-0.0277025104,
-0.0392749198,
-0.0444522575,
-0.0347587168,
0.0175090022,
0.0527350232,
0.0107258996,
0.0091850702,
-0.0121221701,
-0.0062943413,
0.0058429032,
0.020772567,
-0.0240109265,
0.0053851721,
-0.0555400513,
-0.0187856704,
-0.0008803813,
-0.0334037468,
-0.0171170216,
0.0126873972,
-0.1370602548,
-0.1038275138,
0.0076006628,
0.1062932462,
0.0331669748,
0.0533377714,
-0.005150747,
-0.043247927,
0.026944641,
0.0186699405,
-0.0208452884,
0.038484402,
0.0389972106,
-0.0118956696,
0.0204068385,
0.0168041345,
-0.0362060368,
0.0186595842,
0.0488932915,
0.011397142,
-0.0381728783,
-0.0370774195,
0.0215785354,
-0.000528841,
0.0607418343,
-0.0383830927,
0.0242142435,
-0.0310041141,
0.0212544817,
-0.0291311089,
0.0126043838,
-0.0380048268,
0.032706514,
0.0177485589,
0.0140228476,
0.017227944,
-0.0527771711,
-0.0328968205,
0.0503020436,
-0.0481012389,
0.0151371695,
0.052621007,
0.0275995806,
0.028665442,
0.0079749878,
-0.0161402933,
0.0074709989,
-0.0071225367,
0.0266697016,
0.0021319762,
0.0627749562,
0.0168677829,
-0.0044362112,
-0.0090575144,
0.0299604069,
-0.1027822196,
-0.0664190054,
-0.0335088298,
0.0378243327,
0.0277288798,
0.0050943657,
0.0217478517,
-0.0208147559,
0.0162587017,
-0.0371662453,
0.0294631124,
0.0314628854,
-0.0291889664,
0.020411687,
0.0405117907,
-0.0006529656,
0.0335857384,
0.0752818733,
0.0069764592,
0.0701435432,
-0.015204234,
0.0033568994,
-0.0298730824,
-0.0367025621,
0.03055517,
0.0532543138,
-0.0123383962,
-0.0261042602,
-0.0229356196,
-0.0709894076,
-0.02731934,
0.0250304341,
0.0218347013,
-0.0132853314,
0.037304379,
0.0421991944,
-0.0241069589,
-0.0353039503,
-0.0192986298,
-0.0095372042,
0.0434498899,
0.0075857635,
0.0005244315,
-6.425775217e-33,
-0.045790568,
-0.0078674825,
0.0191890579,
-0.0321123414,
0.0066777924,
-0.0111824526,
-0.0298652928,
0.0194276478,
-0.0071958201,
-0.0173343755,
-0.0307097118,
0.0001298855,
0.0232088808,
0.0091640539,
0.0148282629,
-0.0054690153,
0.0400672406,
0.0011407015,
-0.0338719711,
0.0257045012,
0.0273704529,
0.0157690123,
0.0410664678,
-0.0390158184,
0.0324515961,
0.0024761956,
-0.0494061783,
0.0244952329,
-0.0434346348,
0.0636303499,
-0.0180828273,
0.0380693041,
0.0226759221,
-0.0384239331,
-0.0532625131,
0.0304621346,
-0.0318248756,
-0.0394958295,
0.0381964296,
-0.0428149663,
-0.0294379294,
-0.0388156027,
0.0457457639,
0.0046911733,
-0.0204496477,
0.0111675402,
0.0202016942,
-0.0433496311,
-0.0073473738,
0.0517793633,
-0.0322645828,
0.0100253811,
0.0157221556,
-0.0150529984,
-0.0214288533,
0.0145261781,
-0.0060436311,
-0.0120921452,
-0.0094124554,
0.0316853523,
0.0902293697,
0.0354430787,
0.0610412024,
0.0472206101,
-0.0075240252,
0.0134719638,
0.0326062925,
0.0097186491,
-0.0120789967,
-0.0271476377,
-0.0099537307,
0.0303244907,
0.0064754458,
0.0028506925,
0.0382898338,
-0.0064392015,
-0.035181582,
0.0166678727,
0.0206632521,
0.0410817079,
0.0353455693,
0.0239404477,
-0.0333970524,
-0.0335775129,
-0.0432485603,
-0.0166580584,
-0.0119154342,
-0.0111712832,
0.0490868948,
0.0384501107,
0.0029687667,
-0.0080594933,
0.043525584,
-0.002508708,
0.01038583,
-0.0150838317,
-0.0263105724,
-0.0108395312,
-0.0042375731,
0.0072793141,
-0.0476375446,
-0.0480513833,
0.0360787846,
0.0017520763,
-0.0018012278,
0.0264752489,
0.0042670663,
0.0453547202,
-0.058405973,
0.0031427322,
-0.043763306,
0.0185102429,
0.0204832088,
0.0393225588,
0.0680726692,
-0.0324901715,
-0.0075206058,
0.0701863319,
-0.0069424645,
-0.045329012,
-0.028224567,
-0.0128671536,
0.0007890302,
0.0357862674,
-0.0319964215,
0.0022087542,
0.010134114,
0.0086502247,
0.0308783352,
-0.0601069294,
-0.0154451681,
0.0056349351,
2.911e-7,
0.0182699729,
-0.013813966,
0.0283546615,
0.0354357027,
-0.0050843041,
0.0274301488,
-0.0260808319,
0.046256572,
0.031101549,
-0.0271748919,
0.0183395315,
0.0256601963,
-0.0074676578,
0.0138876298,
-0.0506217331,
-0.0244194325,
-0.073776722,
0.008541272,
-0.0451632328,
-0.0043517631,
0.0471506603,
0.0976675823,
0.0108827865,
-0.0180900693,
0.0036077006,
-0.0329666026,
0.043083366,
-0.0394321568,
-0.0017458102,
-0.006505271,
0.0306177661,
0.040753413,
0.0104487212,
0.0308370832,
-0.0234003663,
0.0019244219,
-0.0401954837,
0.0527703613,
-0.0211446062,
-0.0189321339,
0.0244562794,
0.0071022245,
-0.0010882906,
-0.035338819,
0.0479018465,
-0.0286040716,
0.0133521594,
-0.0076998235,
-0.0295052566,
-0.0403953306,
-0.0242110007,
-0.0280519873,
0.0071367142,
0.0073588984,
-0.0078027868,
0.0445649102,
-0.0076103099,
-0.0806747749,
-0.0036231764,
0.0193502698,
-0.064167805,
-0.0736146867,
-0.0367506556,
-0.0124904867,
0.0406497866,
-0.0739405528,
-0.0191151984,
2.797631326e-34,
0.0220203213,
-0.0283896253,
0.0270364396,
0.0431061499,
0.0146398954,
-0.0040325071,
-0.0100563467,
0.0432332084,
0.0502098165,
-0.063228257,
-0.0659623817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17686v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17686v2 | Deductive Beam Search: Decoding Deducible Rationale for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-01-31T09:16:35 | 2024-02-04T13:18:34 | Tinghui Zhu, Kai Zhang, Jian Xie, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements have significantly augmented the reasoning capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs) through various methodologies, especially
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. However, previous methods fail to address
reasoning errors in intermediate steps, leading to accumulative errors. In this
paper, we propose Deductive Beam Search (DBS), which seamlessly integrates CoT
and deductive reasoning with step-wise beam search for LLMs. Our approach
deploys a verifier, verifying the deducibility of a reasoning step and its
premises, thus alleviating the error accumulation. Furthermore, we introduce a
scalable and labor-free data construction method to amplify our model's
verification capabilities. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach
significantly enhances the base performance of LLMs of various scales (7B, 13B,
70B, and ChatGPT) across 8 reasoning datasets from 3 diverse reasoning genres,
including arithmetic, commonsense, and symbolic. Moreover, our analysis proves
DBS's capability of detecting diverse and subtle reasoning errors and
robustness on different model scales. | Deductive Beam Search: Decoding Deducible Rationale for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning: Recent advancements have significantly augmented the reasoning capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs) through various methodologies, especially
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. However, previous methods fail to address
reasoning errors in intermediate steps, leading to accumulative errors. In this
paper, we propose Deductive Beam Search (DBS), which seamlessly integrates CoT
and deductive reasoning with step-wise beam search for LLMs. Our approach
deploys a verifier, verifying the deducibility of a reasoning step and its
premises, thus alleviating the error accumulation. Furthermore, we introduce a
scalable and labor-free data construction method to amplify our model's
verification capabilities. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach
significantly enhances the base performance of LLMs of various scales (7B, 13B,
70B, and ChatGPT) across 8 reasoning datasets from 3 diverse reasoning genres,
including arithmetic, commonsense, and symbolic. Moreover, our analysis proves
DBS's capability of detecting diverse and subtle reasoning errors and
robustness on different model scales. | [
0.0114572961,
0.0705213994,
-0.0121882977,
0.0438398644,
-0.0327691957,
0.005650647,
0.0070528812,
-0.0021747248,
0.0361144282,
0.0259205364,
0.0106079625,
0.0244605858,
0.0252963286,
0.0192856248,
0.0001731504,
-0.0005356799,
0.0367394648,
-0.0461397097,
0.0200905353,
-0.0250826534,
-0.0001370447,
0.0232680831,
-0.0421284363,
0.0056782267,
-0.0033712289,
-0.0120508522,
-0.0361306742,
-0.001177126,
0.0360168219,
-0.049399741,
-0.014762803,
0.0138324713,
0.0079551218,
0.0763671249,
0.0000024773,
-0.0286187027,
-0.0257958118,
0.0053585093,
-0.0946249068,
-0.0049202726,
-0.0176040791,
0.007147985,
0.007650747,
0.0417424478,
-0.0010599544,
-0.0197597928,
0.0354554318,
0.0249579009,
0.0668794736,
0.0545406155,
0.0160988942,
-0.0536305085,
0.0206584595,
-0.001098808,
0.0207954124,
-0.0693621933,
0.0249369852,
0.0592126697,
0.0413453169,
0.039924942,
-0.000976442,
0.0351022854,
0.0195947867,
-0.0102130529,
-0.0545441844,
0.0255004708,
-0.0147664063,
-0.0274709426,
0.0160847008,
0.0529113002,
0.006785342,
-0.0887224227,
0.0068602706,
-0.002748346,
-0.0224155523,
0.0210649073,
-0.0221698675,
0.0465670153,
-0.0253912508,
0.0061812853,
0.0595156625,
-0.0104352664,
0.0637053698,
-0.0032905166,
-0.0825064853,
0.0597071834,
-0.0124686221,
-0.0444654003,
-0.0064454754,
0.002712491,
-0.0408445224,
-0.0856358036,
0.0358735137,
0.024900198,
-0.0491839759,
0.0440381542,
-0.0139099183,
0.0028109711,
0.0008751249,
0.0192062147,
0.0165195242,
0.0393567942,
0.0277787168,
0.0383717492,
-0.0334817991,
0.0448442362,
-0.0331261493,
-0.0158304218,
-0.0262389649,
-0.0332852937,
-0.064792797,
-0.0172616281,
-0.0193558075,
0.0417357124,
-0.0095235687,
-0.0058148443,
-0.0201822203,
-0.0184857361,
-0.0186277237,
0.0190426596,
0.0308699813,
-0.0338088609,
0.0600974411,
-0.0221641492,
-0.0048686783,
0.043796625,
-0.0430447347,
0.0053597768,
0.045975633,
-0.0523440465,
-0.0069697089,
-0.0245343354,
-0.025630163,
-0.0107982075,
0.02119953,
0.0298230816,
0.004623163,
0.0019644613,
-0.0370572582,
-0.0353147611,
-0.0236423668,
-0.0624259226,
0.0249542166,
-0.086414896,
0.0267239325,
0.0316024646,
-0.0106887603,
0.0077652582,
0.0192633066,
0.0318363905,
-0.0439871661,
0.0687737614,
-0.0105796643,
0.0257098991,
0.00054564,
0.0191919822,
-0.0249018501,
0.0178929474,
0.0153973084,
0.0292335283,
0.0339790396,
0.0292714275,
0.022135539,
0.0094526988,
0.0402861275,
-0.0115105845,
-0.006731682,
0.0201542154,
-0.0131588681,
-0.0026874267,
-0.018575402,
0.023120502,
-0.0628097653,
0.0194046311,
0.0256363843,
0.060071826,
0.0544625446,
-0.0148456991,
0.016128635,
0.0190898459,
0.0088546854,
-0.0213412158,
-0.0342321508,
0.0041752649,
-0.0750722364,
-0.0126379598,
0.0026771617,
0.0116011789,
-0.0073910053,
-0.0240099933,
-0.0189752411,
0.0409402773,
-0.0074185883,
0.0398900397,
0.0432587564,
0.0042389124,
-0.0192698631,
0.0764492974,
0.0213417169,
-0.0762359872,
-0.0509707034,
-0.0453363322,
0.0383833908,
0.0184154958,
0.0790421218,
0.0170021132,
-0.0098030651,
0.0261485334,
0.0099625299,
0.0211300962,
0.0222742856,
0.0084820967,
-0.0275577009,
-0.0579729863,
-0.0271570124,
0.0229034852,
0.0200423561,
-0.0174198449,
0.0165040996,
-0.0164471846,
-0.0200633146,
-0.0465684421,
0.0025540965,
0.0050194794,
-0.0199514814,
0.0207289904,
-0.0099067241,
0.0131329698,
0.043341253,
0.0010228674,
0.0010533794,
0.0126783364,
0.0019679412,
-0.0026227764,
-0.0319194831,
0.0296177026,
-0.0392684489,
-0.0476701371,
0.0153650045,
-0.0396904014,
-0.0483125187,
-0.0145669729,
-0.0419871509,
-0.0294710696,
0.0348281972,
-0.0519327186,
-0.0551628135,
-0.0244953651,
0.03420306,
-0.0205409918,
-0.0377400368,
-0.0010404523,
0.1092295572,
-0.0148632284,
-0.0095890351,
-0.0537422784,
-0.0073086335,
0.0332851447,
-0.0157694127,
-0.0099496515,
0.0615422279,
-0.0001937554,
-0.0111781517,
0.0162899029,
0.011378739,
-0.0068935002,
-0.0245104823,
-0.0566613451,
-0.0063897967,
0.0207244754,
0.0089619346,
-0.0052761771,
-0.0036043259,
0.0222307239,
0.0275189187,
-0.0047424184,
0.0103598014,
0.0489820056,
-0.0112357531,
0.0193371531,
-0.0113351522,
-0.0445095785,
0.0069417977,
-0.0369624309,
-0.0472813286,
0.0519729517,
-0.01696443,
0.0072869244,
-0.0388130844,
0.0781973377,
-0.0384583399,
-0.0013880687,
-0.0110477218,
0.0044117454,
0.0411593243,
-0.0151558956,
-0.029298842,
0.0615573823,
-0.010424275,
-0.025196055,
0.0543029383,
-0.0511047095,
-0.05116174,
0.0139273796,
-0.0080661774,
0.0348730311,
-0.0053762635,
-0.0303589404,
-0.0113810208,
0.032406766,
-0.0115046976,
0.0093803164,
-0.0555877313,
0.0078004091,
0.005969198,
-0.0031070355,
-0.0479752794,
-0.024892848,
0.0128169823,
0.0867829397,
-0.019842755,
-0.0027650674,
0.048684746,
-0.0208919328,
0.0357360318,
-0.0631867498,
0.0191087462,
-0.0194463786,
0.0453203209,
-0.0297122858,
0.0046886234,
-0.0147365099,
0.0004597488,
-0.0004277301,
-0.0219984483,
0.0625620261,
-0.0480987728,
0.0725842118,
-0.0660308897,
0.0243770145,
-0.0024905228,
-0.0613552593,
-0.0598264262,
0.0177368354,
-0.0576061457,
-0.0122510931,
-0.0315077789,
-0.0190897379,
-0.0502572581,
-0.0096887602,
0.0377512574,
0.0137009751,
0.0061535742,
-0.0116547337,
-0.0239408109,
0.0435206294,
-0.0272550117,
-0.0394812264,
0.07043989,
-0.031065857,
-0.0070123938,
0.0483213775,
0.0640858263,
-0.0052256188,
-0.0490671359,
-0.0012537425,
0.0113938851,
-0.0035085829,
-0.0344049335,
-0.0092132185,
0.0315775089,
-0.0764108077,
-0.0153419487,
0.0892226323,
0.023289986,
-0.0217820369,
0.0062371199,
-0.0305276215,
0.0193989556,
0.0058799493,
0.0303436816,
-0.1282184273,
-0.0647364482,
0.0564957224,
-0.0105081676,
-0.0098060369,
-0.0491296239,
-0.004795698,
-0.1529530883,
0.0154479854,
0.0197102409,
0.0532824397,
-0.0112495795,
-0.0341089442,
0.0085146055,
0.0053248722,
-0.0384224579,
0.0488997623,
0.0260163192,
-0.0050928094,
-0.0072613717,
0.0005858392,
-0.0617314167,
0.0470205769,
-0.0216251705,
0.0553707294,
0.0179910827,
0.0277052131,
0.0276976265,
-0.0779490322,
0.009628403,
-0.0339343585,
-0.010169425,
-0.0256239418,
-0.0168062001,
0.0111574912,
0.0189059228,
-0.0432819165,
0.0362980142,
-0.0228268951,
-0.0393563062,
0.0248607974,
0.1023609117,
-0.0295199659,
-0.0170004833,
-0.0095657241,
0.0167722069,
-0.0298230611,
0.0607168637,
0.008337548,
0.0152097112,
-0.0548804775,
-0.0327351689,
-0.0702401474,
0.0056380713,
-0.0451892018,
0.0107234288,
0.0482047088,
0.0492985249,
-0.0266256332,
0.0283176191,
0.0032938428,
0.0510449931,
-0.0348383114,
-0.0106021194,
-0.0079254983,
0.0116104735,
-0.0154854218,
0.0212507453,
-0.0709664673,
0.0349802822,
-0.0189504027,
0.0937536508,
-0.0322864875,
-0.0451074615,
-0.0335471965,
0.0595877767,
-0.0484563969,
-0.0521910526,
-0.0005966016,
0.020454349,
0.0343399756,
0.0312497411,
-0.0372508578,
-0.0114129828,
0.0546364449,
0.0204084441,
-0.0241809953,
-0.004988173,
0.0408464186,
0.0018224664,
0.0096617127,
0.0283255875,
-0.0047762855,
0.014038262,
0.0089815687,
0.0759678558,
-0.0226704888,
0.0047528455,
0.0271464698,
0.050586734,
-0.0071879723,
0.0062937313,
-0.0286864843,
-0.045721896,
0.0455756299,
-0.0255160257,
-0.0149319116,
-0.0309968628,
0.0368822254,
0.0294333566,
-0.0259576943,
0.0081543764,
-0.0375580043,
0.0058286241,
0.0199786574,
0.0232398063,
0.0238644369,
0.0045934781,
0.0541603193,
0.0266183317,
-0.0434106812,
0.0207239296,
0.0034003127,
0.0193659347,
0.0350908004,
-0.0223301314,
0.0874333009,
0.0642518997,
-0.0297791325,
-0.0413604975,
0.0136118233,
-0.0582662635,
-0.0424249955,
0.0510582663,
-0.0096273273,
0.0508950204,
0.0346701853,
0.0420480333,
-0.0367070399,
-0.0190164149,
0.0090211593,
0.0056392876,
0.0181266554,
-0.029742131,
0.0070347148,
0.046351444,
-0.0022570142,
-0.0176195204,
0.0527418293,
-0.052602835,
0.023437446,
0.0109401811,
-0.0140569331,
-0.0325662754,
-0.0683462769,
-0.0602218546,
0.010034957,
-0.0219956338,
-0.016387919,
-0.0701533183,
-0.0704460964,
-0.0358463898,
0.0201840699,
0.0098759718,
-0.0053223609,
0.0254529547,
0.0666164607,
0.0240042079,
-0.0224990901,
0.0097142057,
-0.0240639057,
-0.0315563902,
-0.0075055021,
-0.0191519149,
-6.863603516e-33,
0.006087217,
-0.0385187231,
0.0365884267,
0.0141174542,
-0.0132027529,
-0.0104477089,
-0.0609414354,
-0.0032387821,
-0.0186315719,
0.0464386567,
-0.0304007307,
0.0440897904,
0.0158662982,
0.0104740504,
-0.0001835644,
0.0320900269,
0.0443497598,
0.0263156593,
-0.0352746062,
0.0103266397,
0.0602758825,
-0.021527227,
0.0013783177,
-0.0614491105,
0.0054467036,
-0.0078812027,
-0.0331816003,
0.060356427,
-0.0845904052,
0.043483112,
0.0151303178,
-0.0014214268,
-0.0080952039,
-0.0373957939,
0.0143264327,
-0.0156369414,
-0.0754885525,
0.0000622394,
0.0298849586,
-0.0420042612,
-0.027858343,
-0.0298417248,
-0.0303269736,
0.00949666,
-0.038178958,
-0.0158627462,
-0.0164173711,
-0.0164295416,
0.0156488121,
0.0154097909,
0.0111676995,
0.0388509482,
-0.0108548729,
-0.0142835369,
0.0121631669,
0.0234620329,
-0.0254022554,
-0.02727223,
-0.0518661551,
0.0398061834,
0.0081831366,
-0.0127973277,
0.073826015,
-0.0544006415,
0.0058216569,
0.0477879122,
0.0500152111,
-0.0358051397,
-0.0039965683,
-0.0018630908,
-0.0029388007,
0.0572961494,
0.0689440519,
0.0269435067,
0.0486365892,
0.0449235216,
-0.080771707,
-0.03624456,
-0.0097905677,
0.1084408909,
0.0477043316,
-0.0025224581,
-0.0333462618,
-0.0107113682,
-0.0530697294,
-0.0019864968,
-0.0489128754,
0.0004207323,
0.004998289,
0.0310723204,
-0.0248408895,
-0.0416141525,
0.0308687594,
-0.0520002209,
0.0221998133,
0.091446504,
0.004294564,
-0.0074550295,
0.001917539,
0.0445394553,
-0.0409093611,
-0.0027905265,
0.0040568234,
0.0003732323,
0.0006620262,
0.0205898248,
0.0099052861,
-0.0158219896,
-0.0220380649,
-0.0018230613,
-0.0575972646,
-0.0008670657,
-0.0653719231,
0.0289904773,
0.0846425071,
0.0206604842,
0.0106009142,
0.0057088155,
-0.0003761738,
0.0297294278,
-0.0282856617,
0.0528982282,
-0.0070052589,
0.0268406644,
0.0008052657,
0.0093718702,
-0.0611230284,
-0.0405044742,
0.0384344906,
-0.0480695181,
0.0095440336,
0.0519838966,
3.177e-7,
-0.0236723851,
0.0647043958,
0.0119498549,
0.0694551468,
0.0213509444,
0.0559701957,
-0.0171855055,
-0.0458509251,
0.0124497162,
-0.0458121449,
-0.0061496375,
0.0595322102,
0.0720448494,
0.0458058491,
-0.0211654473,
-0.0303462315,
-0.0268783197,
-0.0697936267,
-0.0421832614,
-0.023294244,
0.0046515563,
0.0358637385,
0.0345671065,
-0.0279148016,
0.0144714108,
-0.0168958995,
0.0293889791,
0.0201326944,
-0.0044660983,
-0.0113080097,
0.0238127522,
-0.0197014622,
0.0210573468,
0.056355238,
-0.0045487988,
0.0148010673,
-0.0386967808,
0.0402666368,
0.0210439712,
-0.0115016205,
-0.0358901843,
-0.0299156718,
-0.0049677291,
-0.0427356251,
0.0600509942,
-0.0324826017,
-0.0326841883,
0.0361947566,
-0.0046602334,
-0.0563815422,
-0.0210990049,
0.0182220042,
-0.0105658285,
-0.0133996326,
0.008236018,
0.0287993271,
0.0031764042,
-0.0832389221,
0.0001056878,
0.0054355534,
-0.0308506321,
-0.0216165744,
0.0008469167,
-0.0016632696,
0.0366506651,
-0.0714147761,
-0.0122474972,
3.401648307e-34,
0.0339262597,
-0.0159950107,
0.017969517,
-0.0347471237,
0.0605495609,
0.0081329057,
-0.0424019694,
0.0135538997,
0.0494291931,
-0.1171364114,
-0.0154214771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17671v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17671v1 | Contextual Feature Extraction Hierarchies Converge in Large Language Models and the Brain | 2024-01-31T08:48:35 | 2024-01-31T08:48:35 | Gavin Mischler, Yinghao Aaron Li, Stephan Bickel, Ashesh D. Mehta, Nima Mesgarani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC | Recent advancements in artificial intelligence have sparked interest in the
parallels between large language models (LLMs) and human neural processing,
particularly in language comprehension. While prior research has established
similarities in the representation of LLMs and the brain, the underlying
computational principles that cause this convergence, especially in the context
of evolving LLMs, remain elusive. Here, we examined a diverse selection of
high-performance LLMs with similar parameter sizes to investigate the factors
contributing to their alignment with the brain's language processing
mechanisms. We find that as LLMs achieve higher performance on benchmark tasks,
they not only become more brain-like as measured by higher performance when
predicting neural responses from LLM embeddings, but also their hierarchical
feature extraction pathways map more closely onto the brain's while using fewer
layers to do the same encoding. We also compare the feature extraction pathways
of the LLMs to each other and identify new ways in which high-performing models
have converged toward similar hierarchical processing mechanisms. Finally, we
show the importance of contextual information in improving model performance
and brain similarity. Our findings reveal the converging aspects of language
processing in the brain and LLMs and offer new directions for developing models
that align more closely with human cognitive processing. | Contextual Feature Extraction Hierarchies Converge in Large Language Models and the Brain: Recent advancements in artificial intelligence have sparked interest in the
parallels between large language models (LLMs) and human neural processing,
particularly in language comprehension. While prior research has established
similarities in the representation of LLMs and the brain, the underlying
computational principles that cause this convergence, especially in the context
of evolving LLMs, remain elusive. Here, we examined a diverse selection of
high-performance LLMs with similar parameter sizes to investigate the factors
contributing to their alignment with the brain's language processing
mechanisms. We find that as LLMs achieve higher performance on benchmark tasks,
they not only become more brain-like as measured by higher performance when
predicting neural responses from LLM embeddings, but also their hierarchical
feature extraction pathways map more closely onto the brain's while using fewer
layers to do the same encoding. We also compare the feature extraction pathways
of the LLMs to each other and identify new ways in which high-performing models
have converged toward similar hierarchical processing mechanisms. Finally, we
show the importance of contextual information in improving model performance
and brain similarity. Our findings reveal the converging aspects of language
processing in the brain and LLMs and offer new directions for developing models
that align more closely with human cognitive processing. | [
0.0227695405,
0.0434800088,
-0.034224771,
0.0728062168,
-0.0200399905,
0.0581532605,
0.0155490302,
0.0220708214,
-0.0072686519,
-0.0093891611,
-0.0562481619,
-0.0273597296,
0.0031123289,
0.0433385447,
0.03728012,
-0.0051843124,
0.0277964845,
-0.0624442473,
-0.0089076534,
-0.0241066702,
-0.0356266238,
-0.0110613508,
0.0080483519,
0.0210562199,
0.0405110307,
-0.0189664811,
0.0089090755,
-0.0397497974,
-0.0196994785,
-0.0104001174,
-0.0533620231,
0.0402802005,
0.0418070517,
0.05023361,
0.0000019313,
-0.0423607528,
0.0586361177,
0.0040029874,
-0.047870066,
0.0334055275,
0.0141872633,
-0.0120065259,
-0.0133581422,
-0.0594602041,
-0.0207385849,
-0.0160007421,
0.0217118133,
0.0382275581,
-0.0253951792,
0.0380794778,
-0.0038593609,
-0.0542900488,
0.0667253733,
-0.0091497554,
0.0208912529,
-0.0345980115,
0.0273905508,
-0.0086919526,
-0.0057164547,
0.0095283138,
-0.041625984,
0.03061435,
0.0197157003,
0.0343240052,
-0.02410396,
0.0871759579,
0.0498734415,
-0.0131880548,
-0.0020798827,
0.0634043291,
-0.0238646921,
-0.0225073919,
-0.0068429238,
0.0172687657,
-0.0244547985,
-0.0123356441,
-0.0505457111,
0.0318000875,
0.0101400986,
0.0522167571,
0.0489743985,
-0.0367708653,
0.0596660972,
-0.0009329834,
-0.0214396734,
0.0512176715,
0.0135165518,
-0.0442528948,
0.0169115774,
0.0070777815,
-0.0443038344,
-0.0130734406,
0.0206428226,
-0.0060384204,
-0.0054010553,
0.0103397677,
-0.0210229661,
-0.0231343657,
0.0110221552,
-0.0397705324,
0.0504875109,
0.0437221527,
-0.0233047307,
0.0468553081,
-0.0537973531,
0.0813757628,
-0.072978422,
0.0282444637,
-0.0358137153,
-0.0024244324,
-0.0311655141,
-0.014298954,
0.0380812958,
0.0369211957,
-0.0261268225,
-0.0426235981,
-0.0248782709,
0.0261158533,
0.0009968266,
-0.0278446712,
-0.0067318385,
0.0257343184,
0.0081419991,
0.0164683238,
-0.0508111417,
-0.016235901,
-0.0083313612,
0.0234494302,
-0.0076659834,
-0.0157890748,
-0.0091713695,
0.0340911485,
-0.0015194757,
-0.0352207907,
0.0140253054,
0.0701942742,
-0.0020395843,
-0.0340556242,
-0.0337256491,
0.0184315965,
-0.0063470541,
-0.0128391869,
0.0456641689,
-0.0400361679,
0.0594888739,
0.0187536459,
-0.0373002514,
-0.0363879576,
-0.0189627074,
-0.0100321015,
-0.0593718961,
0.0498729497,
-0.0207014456,
0.010932521,
0.0480383746,
0.0004856914,
-0.0027277921,
0.005843088,
0.0365799293,
0.0118565233,
-0.000871809,
-0.0013487994,
-0.0513019301,
0.0327862762,
-0.0223334245,
-0.0152468383,
-0.0465983152,
-0.028595075,
0.0094892457,
0.059425652,
0.0780340284,
0.03459749,
-0.0425245576,
-0.0788990483,
0.0666110665,
0.1078252047,
0.0022417263,
0.0335660614,
0.048681125,
-0.0234665722,
-0.0082928184,
0.0147785712,
-0.0778352246,
0.0309806131,
-0.0211486183,
0.0062032361,
0.0055643665,
0.0065664621,
-0.013389159,
-0.0251721889,
-0.0085598789,
0.0170795284,
-0.0086031184,
0.026267102,
0.0297741219,
-0.0464964993,
-0.0224917661,
0.0269740652,
0.0506119728,
0.0055147619,
-0.0068739229,
-0.07350339,
0.0397321396,
0.0460727029,
0.0130723566,
-0.0025637713,
0.0119960057,
0.0478610657,
-0.0076439003,
0.0635116696,
0.0051006451,
0.0017511208,
0.0568185188,
-0.0041526067,
-0.000501613,
-0.0028929303,
-0.0049793292,
0.0063045365,
-0.0190491546,
-0.0305325631,
-0.0031757983,
-0.0153007638,
-0.0084016621,
0.0586846545,
-0.0692038462,
-0.0224135257,
-0.027928317,
-0.0072550494,
0.0318992957,
-0.0237804856,
-0.0223062672,
0.0108460858,
0.0177783426,
-0.0556441844,
0.0017738674,
0.0003655757,
-0.0578160062,
-0.033346314,
0.0309444238,
0.0318479389,
-0.0045426372,
0.0173032898,
-0.0011305055,
0.0019058054,
0.015807163,
-0.0173733458,
0.0611759573,
-0.0526293777,
0.0216538813,
-0.0481228456,
0.026660867,
-0.0454706848,
0.0708978176,
-0.035091497,
-0.0099858046,
0.0181157868,
-0.0032610844,
-0.0187849849,
-0.0214071702,
-0.0276850145,
0.0364154279,
0.0092100305,
-0.0239831563,
-0.0523835905,
-0.0113372793,
-0.0339401104,
-0.0059137633,
-0.0788486153,
0.0021304337,
0.0216686111,
0.007315415,
0.0087699797,
-0.0370809659,
-0.0076432172,
0.0108658392,
0.0033161417,
0.0183041357,
0.0012158329,
0.0268595982,
0.0091078235,
-0.0077466681,
-0.0289952401,
-0.0608425774,
-0.033893615,
-0.0260225423,
0.0814564303,
-0.030358538,
-0.0257395469,
-0.0627215281,
0.0604845956,
-0.0153747536,
0.0367638431,
-0.0130503811,
-0.0089080594,
0.0281291977,
-0.0330290347,
0.0087817665,
0.0975970402,
-0.0096692005,
0.0428467654,
0.0943432972,
0.0070552011,
-0.0156748481,
-0.0248456635,
-0.027793033,
0.0048393407,
-0.0625540987,
-0.0159494616,
0.0061317654,
0.0875699744,
0.0411425978,
-0.0015990405,
-0.0050870166,
0.0177009702,
-0.0153876124,
-0.038803909,
-0.0334899984,
-0.003682316,
-0.0577266216,
0.0560209192,
-0.0582479537,
-0.0273303669,
0.0539370775,
-0.0235473588,
0.0241983831,
0.0032829333,
-0.0149550112,
-0.0259553678,
0.0592165217,
0.0419101268,
0.0364096314,
-0.0304581299,
-0.0281953029,
-0.0234570019,
0.0295873471,
-0.0356187858,
-0.0233412366,
0.0324635655,
-0.0370705388,
-0.0062816637,
0.0146442605,
-0.0221157279,
-0.0308294091,
0.0097455168,
-0.0284943972,
0.0406771675,
0.0039676484,
0.0066699465,
-0.0312242359,
-0.0298982244,
0.0306501817,
0.0482794456,
-0.0028297242,
-0.0103098992,
-0.0252151154,
0.0534754209,
0.0114454981,
0.0409577787,
0.0478808172,
-0.02464284,
0.0571720004,
0.0648859963,
0.0143840071,
0.0404347405,
-0.0448164456,
0.0455684178,
0.0343949795,
-0.0188150033,
-0.0231678393,
0.0201185253,
0.0062437495,
-0.0617992058,
0.0009724547,
0.1325228512,
0.0248839874,
-0.0457881317,
0.0127688376,
-0.028109163,
0.0187212359,
0.0349679589,
0.0073902193,
-0.0303549711,
-0.008509866,
0.0026916843,
-0.010213214,
-0.0072901775,
-0.0373748243,
0.0153089799,
-0.0690171048,
0.0360231139,
-0.0160158724,
-0.0702998266,
-0.0069206972,
-0.028674908,
0.0201848075,
0.041833479,
0.0548340343,
0.0280108973,
0.0012045298,
-0.0341252051,
0.0191636942,
0.0100223925,
-0.060506206,
0.0591790564,
-0.0481085889,
0.0706630424,
0.0549585335,
0.0393125154,
-0.0091181444,
-0.0083159478,
0.0311128683,
-0.0007711313,
0.04192397,
-0.0233252589,
0.028523244,
0.0314831585,
-0.0008226217,
-0.0360997096,
-0.0032255664,
-0.0218571071,
-0.0446545966,
-0.0339997187,
0.0793005154,
-0.012598169,
-0.0461865105,
0.0093905758,
0.0178508833,
-0.0607294068,
0.0690015107,
0.0742083192,
-0.0611626878,
-0.0409299359,
0.0135487216,
-0.0120278196,
-0.0041197222,
-0.0665714294,
0.0237592179,
0.0170738585,
0.0117588826,
-0.0310065132,
0.0039230529,
0.0075496356,
-0.0165073425,
0.0188340582,
0.0083341226,
0.0267277099,
-0.0792533085,
-0.0290872864,
0.0231557507,
-0.0175803732,
-0.0312248487,
-0.0688775256,
0.0007052516,
0.0194949396,
-0.0492903739,
-0.0210053679,
0.0046955147,
-0.0796808228,
-0.0702815801,
0.0346429273,
-0.0168096963,
0.015785547,
0.0159807447,
0.0232671276,
-0.0839163065,
0.0555002838,
0.0101369945,
-0.0025897368,
0.0639895424,
-0.0360321552,
0.0059987921,
0.0110274088,
0.0310447812,
-0.0151007604,
0.0120265344,
0.0423599929,
0.0167757701,
-0.0009590093,
0.0073721311,
0.0114165256,
0.0055077756,
0.0623349436,
0.0155799082,
-0.0109601002,
-0.0362210274,
-0.0098698651,
-0.00219087,
0.0253203567,
0.0057076588,
-0.0647273436,
0.0490493365,
0.0313679948,
-0.0038775948,
-0.0174306557,
0.0302805975,
0.0360142514,
-0.0424493216,
0.006175885,
-0.0338859558,
-0.0068653724,
0.0068377024,
0.046416048,
-0.0113079529,
0.0351173431,
-0.0508263931,
0.030971067,
-0.0097333873,
0.0274109095,
-0.0210840814,
-0.034357097,
-0.0707289577,
0.0248235483,
-0.092952922,
-0.0697785988,
-0.0009059479,
0.023003431,
0.0304726902,
-0.0183170214,
0.0250046495,
-0.003936179,
-0.0051387404,
-0.021522209,
-0.0328472778,
-0.0322164856,
-0.0009771027,
0.0644474402,
0.0336825252,
0.0002384333,
-0.0276430417,
0.0446072407,
0.030908538,
0.0106947599,
0.0145459594,
-0.0038015426,
-0.0017126185,
-0.0277959108,
0.0011155943,
0.0284027644,
-0.0709146708,
-0.0004750221,
-0.023920659,
-0.0731302872,
0.0076552397,
0.0151184555,
0.0196858849,
-0.0349987075,
-0.024786016,
0.0471331887,
-0.0040538572,
-0.0290890355,
0.0016868603,
0.0087082451,
-0.0268429685,
-0.0427384898,
-0.0025148063,
-6.273897673e-33,
-0.0313324966,
-0.0057953037,
0.0186691601,
0.0079311728,
-0.0251221173,
0.0131344888,
-0.0361772664,
0.0282821171,
-0.0383237861,
0.0024018646,
-0.0194744188,
-0.0128830587,
0.0085092857,
0.008773393,
0.0019468223,
-0.0136259915,
0.0046013086,
-0.0402753018,
0.0406942703,
-0.0120186051,
0.0358018093,
0.0167338867,
0.0554815792,
-0.0769230127,
-0.0039606853,
0.0178304613,
0.0325297974,
0.0626909137,
-0.0087503437,
0.057042148,
-0.0953930393,
0.0577067956,
0.0655124336,
-0.0083521437,
-0.018084012,
0.0138177276,
-0.0372186191,
-0.0058095581,
0.0429623276,
-0.0210143551,
-0.0224109292,
-0.0416736528,
0.0856670439,
-0.0097795716,
-0.0273717102,
-0.0281027257,
0.029763639,
-0.0367664732,
-0.0532759614,
0.0143938838,
-0.1046365201,
-0.0031804752,
0.01062016,
0.0402357094,
0.0317949019,
-0.0053346492,
-0.0394711681,
0.0679424927,
-0.0686114505,
0.0002469841,
-0.0071652425,
0.0211281013,
0.0468987636,
0.0216939524,
0.0491148308,
0.0802609771,
0.10482537,
0.0060706032,
-0.0380198061,
-0.0288503785,
0.0679772422,
0.0627428368,
0.0147713553,
-0.0018928725,
0.047783643,
-0.0146216378,
-0.0455490425,
-0.0311151743,
0.0075963009,
0.0005398268,
0.0490715802,
0.0043998794,
-0.0264438186,
-0.0034561418,
-0.0556745641,
-0.0081504565,
-0.0592025705,
-0.0169901252,
0.0359716639,
-0.0357928276,
0.0170899071,
-0.0329100117,
0.0170638561,
-0.0518316217,
0.025204543,
-0.0014455642,
-0.0058894292,
0.0208483823,
0.0252013449,
0.0127901621,
-0.0374910049,
-0.0478009693,
-0.019760048,
-0.0385288298,
0.0366460197,
-0.0007542546,
-0.0191887636,
0.0038658478,
-0.0139350677,
-0.0172829982,
-0.0446977019,
-0.0615675785,
0.049039308,
0.0236508641,
0.0118575552,
-0.0131234266,
-0.0123379864,
-0.0135034965,
0.0296846367,
-0.0100115938,
-0.0395470001,
0.0172648765,
-0.0192718487,
0.0380364135,
-0.0160388984,
-0.007377726,
-0.0137564763,
0.0146570383,
0.0446168445,
-0.0505608767,
-0.0255406797,
0.0270870775,
2.692e-7,
0.0417665131,
0.0648774281,
-0.0059793098,
-0.0010891034,
0.051931493,
0.015354841,
0.0014662744,
0.0004057975,
0.0395757407,
-0.0445435047,
-0.0227249619,
0.0715057552,
0.0390418433,
0.0053826207,
-0.0381622091,
-0.0135090444,
-0.0346693955,
0.0099087097,
-0.0520703718,
0.0004644585,
0.0266481806,
0.0587572679,
-0.0108624808,
-0.0594005063,
0.0153864659,
-0.0135035338,
0.0804972351,
-0.0731464252,
0.0208954886,
-0.0087918798,
-0.0590136126,
0.0018517388,
0.0205949675,
0.0245779399,
0.0201367754,
0.043011196,
0.0044051833,
0.0486937054,
0.0175141077,
-0.0011493767,
0.0076418319,
0.01108847,
0.0191759188,
-0.069009982,
0.0754804164,
-0.0533388853,
-0.0673751086,
-0.0437731072,
0.0058304984,
-0.0111953188,
-0.0078919539,
-0.0127971144,
0.0018470696,
-0.0159999672,
0.0133120576,
-0.0219077598,
-0.0161160566,
-0.0604141988,
-0.0244179405,
0.0390184708,
-0.1003302857,
-0.0234459452,
-0.0579921864,
-0.0146427639,
0.0662932545,
-0.0281451568,
0.0074301772,
2.497519583e-34,
-0.0198235381,
0.0235633962,
0.0616473816,
0.0323859677,
0.0189378932,
0.0119555648,
0.0221722145,
-0.0210425109,
-0.0068146149,
-0.0960717946,
-0.0014128871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17658v1 | Document Structure in Long Document Transformers | 2024-01-31T08:28:06 | 2024-01-31T08:28:06 | Jan Buchmann, Max Eichler, Jan-Micha Bodensohn, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long documents often exhibit structure with hierarchically organized elements
of different functions, such as section headers and paragraphs. Despite the
omnipresence of document structure, its role in natural language processing
(NLP) remains opaque. Do long-document Transformer models acquire an internal
representation of document structure during pre-training? How can structural
information be communicated to a model after pre-training, and how does it
influence downstream performance? To answer these questions, we develop a novel
suite of probing tasks to assess structure-awareness of long-document
Transformers, propose general-purpose structure infusion methods, and evaluate
the effects of structure infusion on QASPER and Evidence Inference, two
challenging long-document NLP tasks. Results on LED and LongT5 suggest that
they acquire implicit understanding of document structure during pre-training,
which can be further enhanced by structure infusion, leading to improved
end-task performance. To foster research on the role of document structure in
NLP modeling, we make our data and code publicly available. | Document Structure in Long Document Transformers: Long documents often exhibit structure with hierarchically organized elements
of different functions, such as section headers and paragraphs. Despite the
omnipresence of document structure, its role in natural language processing
(NLP) remains opaque. Do long-document Transformer models acquire an internal
representation of document structure during pre-training? How can structural
information be communicated to a model after pre-training, and how does it
influence downstream performance? To answer these questions, we develop a novel
suite of probing tasks to assess structure-awareness of long-document
Transformers, propose general-purpose structure infusion methods, and evaluate
the effects of structure infusion on QASPER and Evidence Inference, two
challenging long-document NLP tasks. Results on LED and LongT5 suggest that
they acquire implicit understanding of document structure during pre-training,
which can be further enhanced by structure infusion, leading to improved
end-task performance. To foster research on the role of document structure in
NLP modeling, we make our data and code publicly available. | [
0.0324780643,
0.0142187271,
-0.0081953593,
0.043389596,
-0.0217628703,
0.0072916783,
-0.0082187364,
0.0085763922,
-0.0140577378,
-0.041856315,
-0.0445418023,
-0.0129495682,
0.0218302496,
-0.0033167426,
0.0156988204,
-0.0436305143,
0.0373689272,
-0.0348378755,
-0.0270325001,
0.0523067452,
0.0192588735,
-0.0161634218,
0.0170735978,
-0.0088103116,
-0.013803456,
-0.0523304045,
-0.0383059308,
0.0050965524,
-0.0147071006,
-0.0388356596,
0.0073701357,
0.0504699759,
0.0046041505,
0.0389087833,
0.0000016714,
-0.0185735598,
-0.0268553849,
0.0336333774,
-0.026368849,
0.0218906496,
0.0486068875,
-0.0739877,
-0.003711842,
-0.0055874507,
-0.0074140825,
-0.0187796354,
0.0360114574,
0.1146550998,
0.0158200301,
0.0905672237,
-0.0206417497,
-0.0403094292,
0.0444807373,
-0.0300414115,
0.0340186134,
-0.0064363508,
0.0159550179,
-0.0286159515,
-0.00323806,
0.0287121795,
-0.0368741788,
-0.0130224545,
0.0382534787,
-0.0036699015,
0.0189243983,
0.0423174128,
-0.0086018192,
-0.0076446072,
-0.0077285939,
0.036695037,
0.0049280985,
0.0049403473,
0.0202708133,
-0.0111139938,
-0.0137151089,
0.0089496356,
-0.0571273193,
0.0160358939,
-0.0271064918,
-0.00693904,
0.0600875169,
0.0271687042,
0.0085883681,
-0.0067136977,
-0.0340070054,
0.085738644,
0.0045183487,
-0.0478882082,
0.0091971187,
0.0246960782,
0.0081718387,
-0.0641008914,
0.0179714952,
0.0063903434,
0.0198746584,
0.021624675,
-0.017587943,
-0.0469718762,
0.0226548295,
-0.0399060547,
0.0033026293,
0.0106220944,
-0.0401547551,
0.0396185219,
-0.0668134764,
0.0355086029,
-0.0409282483,
0.0332744755,
-0.0181845948,
0.0033813387,
-0.0395332165,
-0.0322840326,
-0.0320756473,
0.0027751536,
-0.0460914485,
-0.0683097765,
0.0023016613,
0.0088079562,
0.0334206857,
-0.0259283744,
0.0006379765,
0.0057606655,
-0.0703120902,
0.0029152969,
-0.0042081662,
0.0552535988,
-0.0292815957,
0.000769439,
0.0234918445,
-0.0046450994,
-0.0423928611,
0.0374235436,
-0.0084658954,
-0.0565754659,
0.0009965326,
0.0419005565,
-0.0212111287,
-0.0505480878,
-0.0122179817,
-0.0232560337,
-0.0424434915,
-0.060319677,
0.0868506879,
-0.0508842617,
0.004955559,
0.0210261215,
0.0305318739,
0.0203814395,
0.0020772454,
0.0280610807,
-0.0041375556,
0.0680416152,
0.0109851863,
-0.0303868987,
0.004043913,
0.015335666,
-0.0057277242,
0.0751378909,
0.0075767329,
0.0318603963,
0.0247501787,
-0.0335375108,
0.0032934241,
0.0142344469,
-0.0009285438,
-0.0063170153,
0.0142969545,
0.0109117366,
-0.0399388932,
-0.0054510711,
0.0366689414,
0.0284249447,
-0.0409766696,
-0.0034175145,
0.0293814428,
0.0613319241,
0.0524423644,
-0.0063158041,
-0.0000884605,
-0.0286500473,
0.0001016955,
0.068633996,
-0.0354189128,
0.0213261172,
-0.0023111682,
0.0250006542,
-0.0231706351,
0.0107210064,
-0.0108095435,
-0.0105309123,
-0.0477093235,
0.0022451947,
0.0248487368,
-0.0479080155,
0.0710146353,
0.0843335018,
-0.0131887272,
0.0294833053,
0.0004570705,
-0.0350795686,
0.0014926122,
-0.024878623,
0.008788608,
0.0250580981,
0.0480129942,
-0.0191205051,
-0.0136883128,
-0.001578144,
0.0031206172,
0.0641195923,
0.0168277547,
-0.0196700711,
0.0100409482,
-0.0278887898,
-0.0164073016,
-0.0380348228,
0.0176990852,
-0.0104678217,
0.0294839498,
-0.021338908,
0.0315675884,
-0.078095682,
-0.0000368946,
0.0532699898,
-0.0229781047,
-0.0181867462,
0.0017099282,
-0.0116348611,
0.0041047232,
-0.0165424701,
0.0014258386,
0.0135017857,
0.0391446836,
-0.0168237351,
-0.0165505428,
-0.0259502903,
-0.0650507063,
-0.0268922281,
-0.003576044,
-0.0392964184,
-0.0021290488,
0.0216433648,
-0.0221083015,
-0.0320905484,
-0.0188246667,
-0.0437947027,
0.0371990278,
-0.020235762,
0.0185064357,
0.0188766755,
0.0408037677,
-0.0311950147,
0.0458000042,
0.0231360383,
-0.0049958224,
0.0241612718,
-0.0124882655,
-0.0079322523,
-0.0092238653,
-0.0041590342,
0.0176998395,
-0.0109497337,
-0.051587712,
0.0392234474,
-0.0026275711,
-0.0565797985,
-0.0334388316,
-0.0941040143,
0.0299861748,
-0.0370919742,
0.0462157764,
0.0278487578,
0.0118849874,
-0.0062117181,
-0.0261279866,
-0.0327912904,
-0.0246999897,
-0.0038966991,
0.0398906656,
0.0302090123,
-0.0039910073,
-0.0000917746,
-0.0266242046,
-0.0585722998,
-0.0412836708,
0.0712772608,
0.0078894002,
-0.0687944219,
-0.0583020784,
0.0082613798,
0.0283048861,
0.0031725327,
-0.0347837172,
-0.0140434885,
0.000829033,
-0.0136166308,
0.1007825583,
0.0827024281,
0.0213935561,
0.0269717947,
0.0343289115,
-0.0103433486,
-0.0096286451,
0.0092171216,
-0.0316764526,
0.0454328246,
-0.0569191612,
-0.0022065339,
0.0265047867,
0.0898946077,
-0.0024705026,
0.019218456,
-0.0072374004,
-0.0147966016,
-0.0374382623,
-0.0218410846,
0.0401692167,
-0.0373032838,
-0.007621353,
0.0373895206,
0.0012471462,
-0.038715411,
0.0615885369,
-0.0541776232,
-0.0359588414,
-0.0555160865,
0.0206285343,
-0.0485259891,
0.0554562695,
0.048512131,
-0.0277452376,
0.0161544792,
-0.0555260852,
-0.0270392057,
0.0414723866,
0.0070992867,
0.0019146466,
0.0336122662,
0.0162797347,
0.0155087188,
-0.036168687,
-0.0438566618,
-0.0270374138,
-0.0195369776,
0.0092664557,
0.0152893392,
0.0347728617,
-0.0256880336,
-0.0406380519,
0.0256947726,
0.0500004068,
0.0778453499,
-0.0421002656,
-0.0285954308,
-0.0363140665,
0.0612134933,
0.0468927659,
-0.0302626826,
0.0733680055,
-0.0892914757,
0.0090577668,
0.0530187227,
0.0260911696,
0.0204866342,
-0.0036816811,
-0.0242985114,
0.0002322706,
-0.0476054288,
-0.0234495327,
-0.0005296031,
0.0269496236,
-0.0894593894,
-0.0289639309,
0.0849156603,
0.0345523916,
-0.0664197654,
-0.010266372,
-0.031110689,
0.0293245316,
0.0200452115,
0.0058658342,
-0.0951318964,
-0.0256233942,
0.0400152616,
0.0158220287,
0.0073047318,
-0.0178893637,
0.0160943717,
-0.0719567239,
0.0499668457,
-0.026860049,
-0.0059421156,
-0.0054030055,
-0.0596410558,
0.011199249,
0.0028537421,
0.0376868211,
-0.00077766,
-0.057000462,
-0.0141472723,
0.0116478009,
-0.0404761024,
0.0141668962,
0.0110710282,
-0.0124979485,
-0.0085988576,
0.08193966,
-0.0167432949,
0.0138197541,
0.0039093881,
0.0279567856,
-0.0249180105,
0.0250706691,
0.0110181859,
0.0537504852,
-0.0167653281,
0.0356240198,
-0.0328680053,
0.0231872201,
-0.043919012,
-0.0000550909,
-0.0066011003,
0.0467850082,
-0.0088919131,
-0.0525957942,
-0.0288547967,
-0.0068295067,
-0.0229748227,
0.0619679652,
0.0304198507,
-0.0038457327,
-0.0551447459,
-0.0129422136,
0.0201974101,
-0.0074618962,
-0.0150034623,
0.0268822834,
-0.0092418371,
0.0101797823,
-0.0793769583,
-0.07288865,
0.0108484747,
-0.0024398093,
-0.0228411853,
-0.0040807929,
-0.0015835384,
-0.041929245,
-0.0636705682,
0.0447320677,
-0.0116776787,
0.0061157928,
-0.0640985668,
0.0162107963,
0.0284278188,
0.004154515,
0.000588486,
0.044496607,
-0.0983274281,
-0.0431812815,
0.0327039286,
-0.0092157237,
0.021693211,
0.0540584475,
-0.0186262242,
-0.021517083,
0.0504816473,
-0.0028789234,
-0.0743722245,
0.0245476495,
0.0196102466,
-0.0606306866,
-0.0051124375,
0.0085417423,
-0.0201711953,
0.0233890861,
0.0009386301,
0.0192882493,
0.0308355745,
0.0115352683,
0.0112557104,
0.0179764405,
0.0553404912,
0.0284236595,
0.0229996517,
-0.0241656248,
0.0283309966,
-0.053445816,
-0.026412677,
0.0019805075,
-0.0034635297,
0.0220881552,
0.0301835854,
-0.0077915411,
0.1003422514,
0.0059556258,
0.0480110534,
-0.0445440225,
0.0060633137,
0.0499523245,
-0.0487732589,
0.01679153,
0.008224587,
0.0151650924,
-0.0032294302,
0.0033098627,
0.0681578889,
-0.0166679639,
0.0774068087,
0.0520666316,
0.0037515615,
-0.0292090364,
0.0131068472,
-0.0885130167,
0.000999502,
-0.0335386321,
-0.0097136227,
-0.0083300434,
-0.0455430113,
0.0762263834,
-0.0505388416,
-0.0022715181,
0.0133982655,
0.0163223185,
0.0068676891,
-0.0074497936,
0.0072110863,
0.0311797056,
-0.0087757949,
-0.0092097959,
0.0753251389,
0.0284438413,
0.0228669979,
0.0060644345,
-0.019524157,
-0.0221960489,
-0.0152171133,
0.0266540069,
0.0088896332,
-0.0080150561,
-0.0270553026,
-0.0261479095,
-0.0180265494,
0.0508349426,
-0.0186188165,
0.0083022593,
-0.0343147777,
0.0198025107,
0.0773252174,
-0.0014540254,
-0.0718124136,
-0.0099881059,
-0.014551064,
-0.0005706932,
-0.0247489829,
-0.0121679585,
-5.998802608e-33,
-0.042042654,
-0.0444805585,
0.0044674464,
0.0229699221,
-0.0234312192,
0.0507418104,
-0.0426259376,
-0.0248852,
0.0261916015,
0.0423504524,
-0.0355217941,
0.0374636389,
0.0265994109,
0.0158841964,
0.0299205109,
-0.0096638622,
0.0488371849,
-0.0144306049,
-0.0489183292,
0.011804142,
0.0211737417,
0.0093590068,
0.0759724453,
-0.0179365557,
0.0211372059,
0.0338065401,
0.0170799661,
-0.0172741245,
-0.0173130557,
0.0698680803,
-0.0362430476,
-0.0197434388,
0.0446106568,
-0.0509800315,
-0.0340288207,
0.0563312545,
-0.1018779054,
0.0213533118,
0.0011008653,
0.0243539829,
-0.0624421574,
-0.0130212381,
0.0397543982,
-0.0159157347,
0.0623104386,
-0.0616615303,
0.0501892418,
-0.0007077423,
0.0124328388,
-0.0362687707,
-0.0942741707,
0.039572686,
-0.0028575356,
0.0015221017,
0.030774096,
0.0261111036,
0.0095010241,
0.0476742834,
-0.0530867428,
-0.032041356,
-0.00146733,
0.0767879114,
0.0139579345,
0.0288339406,
-0.0238092691,
0.0386074744,
0.0388518684,
0.0622711591,
-0.0158616509,
-0.0246059,
0.0424820259,
0.0265255757,
0.0454888307,
-0.0069214725,
0.0891893208,
0.0574195608,
-0.0376744382,
0.0127329035,
0.0179089978,
0.0432917699,
0.0131123653,
0.0105116768,
-0.0230276808,
-0.0038445999,
-0.0236605778,
-0.0007773988,
-0.0248165112,
-0.0122939916,
0.0153648201,
0.0435647629,
0.0004634886,
-0.0034794826,
0.0497679003,
-0.0053028245,
0.0233279578,
0.0035646216,
-0.0347537957,
0.0543341003,
-0.0167420842,
-0.0049896571,
-0.0558260195,
-0.0010963934,
0.0507530123,
0.0161941051,
-0.0061460589,
-0.0099591687,
0.0672421753,
0.005670751,
-0.0817158893,
-0.0051013115,
-0.0100441724,
0.0219420344,
0.0052154954,
0.0315650813,
0.0485278033,
0.0125732878,
-0.0222415254,
0.0818006098,
0.0294336323,
0.023688158,
-0.0361683182,
-0.0156806763,
0.0067193587,
0.0114684086,
-0.0155226486,
-0.0186456107,
-0.0463791378,
-0.0166494828,
0.0446605012,
-0.0612318367,
0.0038603263,
0.0432900526,
2.399e-7,
0.0513990782,
0.0478451997,
0.0860677287,
0.0228772294,
0.0202602595,
-0.0078157261,
0.0038505741,
0.0330308788,
0.0051659951,
-0.0413699299,
-0.0260616113,
-0.0128622875,
0.0546821728,
0.0390930213,
-0.09190882,
-0.0338864103,
-0.0730588213,
-0.0193948466,
-0.0632559136,
-0.0522779413,
-0.003489827,
0.0669635385,
-0.0544683821,
-0.0077475784,
0.0015541192,
-0.022939587,
0.0678207502,
0.0191299226,
0.0077768471,
0.0307509601,
0.0364323705,
-0.0337371714,
0.0121889021,
0.0070507396,
-0.0064775269,
0.0348802507,
0.0055860914,
0.0500453338,
0.0256546736,
-0.0241371226,
0.0080157705,
-0.0093306806,
-0.0133771105,
-0.0204264242,
0.046762079,
-0.0908012018,
-0.0349613242,
-0.0290085897,
-0.0595406666,
-0.0326781087,
-0.0157178733,
0.0112287272,
0.0088644531,
0.0519909188,
0.0170174297,
-0.0040072785,
-0.0189330969,
-0.0855597258,
-0.0271994323,
0.0104665793,
-0.0317906514,
-0.0045712516,
-0.0493013412,
-0.027630765,
-0.0070833117,
-0.0621638857,
-0.0432332344,
2.556331034e-34,
0.0279883444,
-0.0065825228,
-0.0149615379,
0.0133040044,
0.0561611876,
-0.0559552759,
0.0036633802,
0.0082851015,
-0.0251511708,
-0.1167765111,
-0.0272047278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17633v1 | Navigating the OverKill in Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T07:26:47 | 2024-01-31T07:26:47 | Chenyu Shi, Xiao Wang, Qiming Ge, Songyang Gao, Xianjun Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Xun Zhao, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models are meticulously aligned to be both helpful and
harmless. However, recent research points to a potential overkill which means
models may refuse to answer benign queries. In this paper, we investigate the
factors for overkill by exploring how models handle and determine the safety of
queries. Our findings reveal the presence of shortcuts within models, leading
to an over-attention of harmful words like 'kill' and prompts emphasizing
safety will exacerbate overkill. Based on these insights, we introduce
Self-Contrastive Decoding (Self-CD), a training-free and model-agnostic
strategy, to alleviate this phenomenon. We first extract such over-attention by
amplifying the difference in the model's output distributions when responding
to system prompts that either include or omit an emphasis on safety. Then we
determine the final next-token predictions by downplaying the over-attention
from the model via contrastive decoding. Empirical results indicate that our
method has achieved an average reduction of the refusal rate by 20\% while
having almost no impact on safety. | Navigating the OverKill in Large Language Models: Large language models are meticulously aligned to be both helpful and
harmless. However, recent research points to a potential overkill which means
models may refuse to answer benign queries. In this paper, we investigate the
factors for overkill by exploring how models handle and determine the safety of
queries. Our findings reveal the presence of shortcuts within models, leading
to an over-attention of harmful words like 'kill' and prompts emphasizing
safety will exacerbate overkill. Based on these insights, we introduce
Self-Contrastive Decoding (Self-CD), a training-free and model-agnostic
strategy, to alleviate this phenomenon. We first extract such over-attention by
amplifying the difference in the model's output distributions when responding
to system prompts that either include or omit an emphasis on safety. Then we
determine the final next-token predictions by downplaying the over-attention
from the model via contrastive decoding. Empirical results indicate that our
method has achieved an average reduction of the refusal rate by 20\% while
having almost no impact on safety. | [
0.0374060422,
0.0537729561,
-0.0193113293,
0.0402015261,
-0.0103303855,
0.0322071612,
-0.0168314539,
0.0000393658,
-0.0162533391,
-0.042528227,
-0.0401927233,
-0.0204546414,
-0.0158194099,
0.014019182,
0.016198175,
-0.0359271616,
0.0615582913,
-0.0665526241,
0.0151547762,
-0.0053228699,
-0.0103710424,
0.0146982735,
0.0056284508,
0.053370364,
0.022879051,
-0.0333506949,
-0.0116531551,
0.0232700817,
-0.0168735795,
-0.0509053506,
0.0103357192,
0.0559021942,
0.0013458998,
0.0325567424,
0.0000019991,
-0.0470570549,
0.0104549471,
-0.0103480406,
-0.0587117039,
0.0310494117,
0.0636699796,
-0.0327893607,
-0.0067766737,
0.015464372,
-0.0260004699,
-0.038797155,
0.0494105257,
0.0709198713,
0.0259334035,
0.0571693741,
0.0041307206,
-0.0249943398,
0.0160945188,
0.0023925931,
-0.0371428728,
-0.0474209748,
0.0184642039,
-0.0093074525,
0.0046732649,
0.0112587065,
-0.0550926961,
0.0649247989,
0.0213398132,
0.0148991039,
-0.0367278866,
0.0355489999,
-0.0024957429,
-0.0360652469,
-0.0251424275,
0.0660247207,
-0.0564613678,
-0.0253740139,
0.0101151811,
-0.0234620087,
0.0000789034,
-0.0446485132,
-0.0154681476,
0.0036415819,
-0.0036198781,
0.0107166013,
0.0399297364,
0.0352324694,
0.0239989031,
0.0002587616,
-0.02195438,
0.0423829406,
0.0137109542,
-0.0212700497,
0.0308078118,
-0.0126832537,
0.0001300154,
-0.0522530191,
-0.0028745779,
0.0083081368,
-0.0711501092,
0.0213979837,
-0.0449506454,
-0.0314738601,
0.0394162014,
-0.082976073,
0.0298957154,
0.0450958684,
-0.0321372673,
0.0316748731,
-0.0091357613,
0.0141266175,
-0.0178181361,
0.0175357554,
-0.0350385569,
0.0196315143,
-0.0127817262,
-0.0113284541,
-0.0618848577,
0.023666637,
-0.0188966282,
-0.0144861005,
-0.0191251431,
0.031576436,
0.0067703412,
-0.0253080782,
0.005188203,
0.0254100598,
-0.0465640761,
-0.013090577,
0.0152954794,
0.0244021825,
-0.0221516248,
-0.0033151389,
-0.0075844405,
-0.06804353,
-0.0060961545,
-0.0103894994,
-0.0215553157,
-0.053652063,
-0.0107532796,
0.0927500427,
-0.0178246647,
-0.0273400676,
-0.0300853997,
0.0013687904,
-0.0292888265,
-0.0380225889,
-0.0219783485,
-0.051146917,
0.0048864135,
0.0097594494,
-0.0052441331,
-0.0425773971,
0.0136700431,
0.0016838181,
-0.0498471297,
0.0875309333,
0.0139090996,
0.0095718596,
0.0186864715,
0.0216196962,
-0.0146849919,
0.0987104177,
0.0119042471,
0.0312683694,
0.0232539196,
-0.0053647426,
0.0383448452,
0.0327110477,
0.004109161,
0.01198027,
-0.048444055,
0.020592846,
0.0032094959,
-0.007975651,
0.0701681376,
0.0878266096,
-0.0159189198,
-0.0404094011,
0.057252802,
0.0171164293,
0.0009483009,
0.0095439255,
0.0456522852,
0.0378457531,
-0.0234443396,
0.0231733825,
-0.0822599232,
0.0152880019,
-0.0383883454,
0.0052709519,
0.0094104949,
0.0203772094,
-0.03124482,
-0.0229093712,
0.0020869954,
-0.0016034277,
0.0304348767,
0.0302726161,
0.0512456,
0.0075990125,
-0.0503301658,
0.0142301051,
0.0232434999,
-0.0316321589,
-0.0080298577,
-0.0734139383,
0.0031913302,
0.0754740685,
0.0523902997,
0.0206610169,
-0.0185705535,
0.0108543513,
0.0048506018,
0.0402948223,
0.0446435921,
-0.0051632635,
0.0447646081,
-0.0359931588,
-0.0436345078,
0.0292646829,
0.0164274387,
0.0041654422,
0.003857987,
-0.0021844218,
0.0084144063,
-0.0213762559,
-0.0616867878,
0.0424584858,
0.0028343524,
-0.0781067908,
-0.0088328319,
0.0113150505,
0.004283234,
-0.0188149735,
-0.0076626153,
0.0177094173,
0.01457748,
-0.0148056205,
0.0063742832,
-0.0082105109,
-0.0802262351,
-0.0268758573,
0.0205676164,
-0.0056821178,
-0.0128996698,
0.0542047732,
-0.0106085809,
-0.0267063938,
0.0111629581,
-0.0720774606,
0.0592208728,
-0.0019919765,
0.0370215066,
-0.0060414867,
-0.0061476734,
-0.0354093164,
0.0452348068,
-0.0177953094,
-0.0167902187,
-0.000064905,
0.0064582597,
0.0036656109,
-0.0467738509,
-0.0605797358,
0.0205020327,
-0.0160854049,
0.029090954,
0.0206456222,
0.0102024348,
-0.0346039683,
0.004720666,
-0.0534714572,
-0.0178089179,
-0.0299925152,
-0.0032538706,
0.0281354375,
0.0013578029,
-0.0281727221,
-0.0300823301,
0.0084473267,
-0.0157031845,
-0.0061970185,
0.0455129929,
-0.0134091005,
0.022938842,
-0.0166559983,
-0.0391425416,
-0.0304728542,
-0.0103535093,
0.0311854314,
-0.0471714512,
-0.0398501009,
-0.0407857634,
0.0761940256,
0.0258962475,
0.0450567417,
-0.0039235917,
-0.0809536278,
0.0287100952,
-0.0018768568,
0.008561993,
0.0875997469,
0.0142962653,
0.0025638074,
0.0917848945,
-0.0086268336,
-0.0707854256,
0.0157247335,
-0.0225911736,
-0.0681796297,
-0.0168776866,
-0.0393982492,
-0.0130582759,
0.0988115892,
0.0184689295,
0.0218904223,
-0.0727411658,
-0.019458361,
-0.0417137146,
-0.08120621,
-0.0208283328,
-0.0242759567,
-0.0316362046,
0.0512537807,
0.0063349032,
-0.0310806315,
0.0897054076,
0.0161228776,
0.0026762404,
-0.0168004688,
0.0025224148,
0.0076791989,
0.0539373159,
-0.0341069028,
0.0222178139,
0.0537450835,
-0.0750047565,
-0.0387808643,
-0.0507220104,
-0.0087963566,
-0.0297857244,
0.0619740933,
-0.027569076,
-0.0063777892,
0.0004466951,
-0.0619676821,
-0.0659099668,
-0.0424458236,
-0.0582840703,
-0.0119880373,
0.0305626746,
-0.0234461538,
-0.0055704517,
-0.0034035535,
0.001997174,
0.0314417966,
-0.0350451879,
-0.0121888444,
-0.0202673767,
0.0004399533,
0.0880396962,
-0.0323525406,
0.043659512,
-0.0306245834,
0.066878058,
0.0806392804,
0.0220814887,
-0.0084449966,
-0.0223514643,
0.026311947,
0.0538045354,
-0.0099569988,
-0.0156912431,
0.0578059964,
0.0210141912,
-0.0653774664,
-0.0298366603,
0.0902514905,
0.0215475187,
-0.0555897355,
0.0302246101,
-0.0405668207,
0.0449237376,
0.0256592389,
0.026728807,
-0.0390168764,
-0.0486329794,
0.0164415222,
0.0538394041,
-0.0141215967,
-0.018416062,
0.0150495516,
-0.119203411,
0.0379590727,
0.0148784975,
-0.0402033292,
-0.0043031201,
0.0028728503,
0.0102305682,
-0.0251945723,
0.0375570022,
0.0402961932,
-0.029858714,
-0.0226318315,
0.022499593,
-0.0107433507,
-0.040913403,
0.0331542902,
-0.0382312126,
0.0670733228,
0.080369018,
0.0078198807,
-0.0006732452,
-0.0108725075,
0.0349739492,
-0.0313228071,
0.016103439,
-0.0229950119,
0.0621689484,
-0.0191935413,
-0.0035661347,
-0.033033099,
0.0022274926,
-0.0074126921,
-0.0237165652,
0.0121436166,
0.0593376048,
-0.0289881695,
-0.0387818813,
-0.0349729322,
0.0199907273,
0.0421899818,
0.0931565166,
0.0411355421,
-0.0524331219,
-0.0479897335,
-0.0246320702,
-0.0226662196,
-0.0670742914,
-0.0401670039,
0.0004900476,
-0.0093711857,
-0.0453016087,
-0.0416938365,
-0.0546834432,
0.0313591175,
0.0006139576,
0.0156080648,
-0.0061291493,
-0.02007672,
0.016232403,
-0.0255325194,
0.0099368999,
-0.0142520899,
-0.0029987684,
-0.0703939423,
0.0332463495,
0.0152061293,
-0.0015184248,
-0.0010399556,
0.0318896249,
-0.0271024033,
-0.0853377879,
0.0346563756,
0.0681669861,
0.0257323962,
0.0151592372,
-0.0283324551,
-0.0906058848,
0.0330648012,
0.0490689687,
-0.0505447835,
0.006636967,
0.0613091476,
-0.0254593715,
0.0129669858,
0.0445317477,
-0.0433316492,
0.0115453666,
0.0385047682,
0.0623472109,
-0.05518502,
-0.0274369009,
0.0319353417,
0.0090607777,
0.0384666696,
-0.0342293605,
0.0036293566,
-0.0161177274,
0.015980646,
-0.0204330254,
-0.0089946939,
-0.0277666189,
0.042723719,
0.0163234323,
0.0100190192,
-0.0096442625,
-0.02045081,
-0.0357762165,
-0.0001721678,
-0.0076268036,
0.0055459794,
0.0214558598,
-0.0021908386,
0.0554068908,
0.0208502077,
-0.0501156971,
0.0386718363,
0.0252370145,
0.0343225263,
0.0051298975,
0.0339489728,
0.0126634315,
-0.000863888,
-0.0199413951,
0.0340380594,
-0.0551756285,
-0.0709355623,
-0.0102182953,
-0.0295123234,
0.0258287583,
-0.0165455043,
0.0436700359,
-0.0233882535,
0.0071637789,
-0.038701497,
0.0141026862,
-0.0077419756,
-0.014670739,
0.017221339,
0.0413544998,
-0.0172247775,
-0.0187229402,
0.0671872348,
-0.0141117647,
0.0532704964,
0.0419321731,
0.0050000874,
-0.0260138158,
-0.0264695454,
0.0319198146,
0.0264449753,
-0.0596753694,
-0.0027629151,
-0.0799951255,
-0.0804239661,
-0.0240372438,
0.0325325057,
-0.0093356082,
-0.0162517764,
0.0349764451,
0.0244074576,
0.0167287178,
-0.049498152,
-0.0378920399,
0.0153022055,
0.0047030277,
-0.0218613464,
-0.04132469,
-6.164679554e-33,
-0.0172737315,
-0.0045771217,
0.0067597022,
-0.034112785,
-0.0013059985,
-0.0072844983,
-0.0253654476,
0.0417200737,
-0.0362559929,
0.0189535078,
-0.0347365662,
0.0289440192,
0.0186493509,
0.0011713034,
0.0434964821,
-0.0206379686,
0.0309724007,
-0.0094734356,
-0.0281710289,
0.0160431899,
0.033578001,
0.0383310057,
0.0500090756,
-0.0800991058,
0.0058368878,
0.025144564,
-0.0070368638,
0.0213423949,
-0.0100460397,
0.0658436418,
-0.0253427196,
0.0553740077,
0.0085300533,
-0.023513481,
-0.037221048,
0.0369877368,
-0.0589179844,
-0.015134084,
0.053249266,
-0.0075853397,
-0.0240389686,
-0.0472872742,
0.0305746123,
-0.0014720905,
-0.0398395285,
-0.0308821313,
0.0065559782,
-0.0275845509,
-0.01902592,
-0.0142492848,
-0.0693374649,
0.0129137253,
-0.0002000209,
-0.0349487439,
0.0330448113,
0.0704175681,
-0.0152954515,
0.0229985993,
-0.0350188725,
0.0105692539,
0.0468107685,
0.0373428762,
0.0826260597,
0.0491250828,
-0.0115858428,
0.042200245,
0.0026314429,
-0.0097950697,
0.009745365,
-0.0401012599,
0.0418644398,
0.0591957234,
0.0336022303,
0.0294983163,
0.0579867512,
-0.0272285212,
-0.0311898701,
-0.0002855502,
-0.0300961416,
0.0584991425,
0.0457529984,
0.0119891874,
-0.0815567747,
-0.0493683852,
-0.0092110829,
-0.0143242842,
-0.036256142,
-0.04022827,
0.0533187874,
0.0031174447,
-0.0122654587,
-0.010845582,
0.0340408273,
-0.0340646319,
0.0177069735,
0.0195948035,
0.0087129725,
0.0034812915,
-0.010129747,
0.0327583961,
-0.0280208029,
0.0023837178,
0.0005956859,
-0.0191614553,
0.0132754277,
0.0138594108,
0.0166234504,
0.0260041598,
-0.0718341023,
-0.0168905761,
-0.0205747541,
0.0165429451,
0.0146536892,
0.0097450726,
0.0563682057,
-0.0106854383,
0.0029441437,
0.0159448665,
0.0076614846,
-0.0333327129,
-0.0598048903,
0.0056174952,
0.0035799174,
0.0296956636,
-0.0108210379,
-0.0059940093,
-0.0330541395,
0.0494821034,
0.0561936907,
-0.0540085807,
-0.026862435,
0.0377789885,
2.663e-7,
0.0398266613,
0.0408870243,
0.0202300902,
0.036866501,
-0.0281301253,
0.0700969547,
-0.0007643591,
0.0506926887,
0.0368062556,
-0.0071909726,
0.0244805627,
0.0353692472,
0.0567580611,
0.0323812179,
-0.0705452934,
0.0100588873,
-0.0673362836,
0.0166483279,
-0.0480632596,
-0.0305530336,
0.0629085749,
0.0999699757,
-0.0071146237,
-0.0152828461,
0.0059572407,
-0.0166939106,
0.0045469543,
-0.0495181754,
0.01810335,
0.0035092563,
0.006711808,
0.007914884,
0.0223821402,
0.0318105631,
-0.0034349968,
-0.0144579709,
-0.0082694059,
0.075278759,
-0.0222472828,
-0.064014852,
0.0085166339,
-0.0193609651,
-0.0116623938,
-0.0800657347,
0.0523470528,
-0.0623976886,
-0.012047221,
-0.0284667127,
0.0040675513,
0.0083308872,
-0.0173511282,
-0.0467268601,
-0.0185148679,
0.0048132744,
0.040399693,
0.0080753602,
-0.0025396743,
-0.0691353232,
-0.0179045536,
0.0276657697,
0.0033063968,
-0.0780514926,
-0.0275396444,
0.0445415974,
0.0213066172,
-0.0464674383,
-0.0035420302,
2.233269141e-34,
0.0408238657,
0.0082797287,
0.037288934,
0.027030047,
0.0150795141,
0.0215923227,
-0.014692313,
0.0277672093,
0.0352009013,
-0.0735009834,
-0.0492937975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17632v1 | What Do Self-Supervised Speech and Speaker Models Learn? New Findings From a Cross Model Layer-Wise Analysis | 2024-01-31T07:23:22 | 2024-01-31T07:23:22 | Takanori Ashihara, Marc Delcroix, Takafumi Moriya, Kohei Matsuura, Taichi Asami, Yusuke Ijima | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-supervised learning (SSL) has attracted increased attention for learning
meaningful speech representations. Speech SSL models, such as WavLM, employ
masked prediction training to encode general-purpose representations. In
contrast, speaker SSL models, exemplified by DINO-based models, adopt
utterance-level training objectives primarily for speaker representation.
Understanding how these models represent information is essential for refining
model efficiency and effectiveness. Unlike the various analyses of speech SSL,
there has been limited investigation into what information speaker SSL captures
and how its representation differs from speech SSL or other fully-supervised
speaker models. This paper addresses these fundamental questions. We explore
the capacity to capture various speech properties by applying SUPERB evaluation
probing tasks to speech and speaker SSL models. We also examine which layers
are predominantly utilized for each task to identify differences in how speech
is represented. Furthermore, we conduct direct comparisons to measure the
similarities between layers within and across models. Our analysis unveils that
1) the capacity to represent content information is somewhat unrelated to
enhanced speaker representation, 2) specific layers of speech SSL models would
be partly specialized in capturing linguistic information, and 3) speaker SSL
models tend to disregard linguistic information but exhibit more sophisticated
speaker representation. | What Do Self-Supervised Speech and Speaker Models Learn? New Findings From a Cross Model Layer-Wise Analysis: Self-supervised learning (SSL) has attracted increased attention for learning
meaningful speech representations. Speech SSL models, such as WavLM, employ
masked prediction training to encode general-purpose representations. In
contrast, speaker SSL models, exemplified by DINO-based models, adopt
utterance-level training objectives primarily for speaker representation.
Understanding how these models represent information is essential for refining
model efficiency and effectiveness. Unlike the various analyses of speech SSL,
there has been limited investigation into what information speaker SSL captures
and how its representation differs from speech SSL or other fully-supervised
speaker models. This paper addresses these fundamental questions. We explore
the capacity to capture various speech properties by applying SUPERB evaluation
probing tasks to speech and speaker SSL models. We also examine which layers
are predominantly utilized for each task to identify differences in how speech
is represented. Furthermore, we conduct direct comparisons to measure the
similarities between layers within and across models. Our analysis unveils that
1) the capacity to represent content information is somewhat unrelated to
enhanced speaker representation, 2) specific layers of speech SSL models would
be partly specialized in capturing linguistic information, and 3) speaker SSL
models tend to disregard linguistic information but exhibit more sophisticated
speaker representation. | [
-0.0250066929,
0.0501081981,
-0.0085399002,
0.0368478112,
-0.0143848881,
-0.0109299719,
0.070443891,
-0.0410735235,
-0.0292737074,
-0.0154552944,
-0.0942343473,
0.0159996822,
0.0295329839,
-0.0321522169,
0.0066680475,
-0.0621738583,
0.028777495,
-0.0338893868,
-0.0117050745,
-0.0295378473,
-0.0028172948,
-0.0038628501,
-0.0116237309,
0.0228018817,
-0.0184126217,
-0.0297200736,
-0.0230480451,
0.0019402253,
0.0046340069,
0.0248306692,
-0.024556011,
0.0418320261,
0.0577125959,
0.0161038656,
0.0000019095,
-0.0229493249,
0.0049920278,
-0.0147046596,
-0.0740341023,
0.0443479642,
0.0226694774,
0.0165841747,
-0.0266155526,
0.0088925837,
-0.007408957,
-0.0376025215,
0.0073960004,
0.0528194979,
0.0315297134,
0.0325121693,
0.0224012434,
-0.0531714894,
0.0055283071,
-0.0007963299,
0.0155621916,
-0.0212756339,
-0.0118558407,
-0.031691324,
-0.0195581168,
-0.0039886562,
-0.0203570314,
0.0595505349,
-0.0045842091,
-0.0056848363,
0.048435811,
0.022961827,
0.0091871889,
-0.0285994112,
0.025536716,
0.0144577026,
0.0086567244,
-0.0020321428,
-0.0083586033,
0.0060115131,
0.0066880407,
-0.0109944036,
0.0209020767,
0.0044577722,
0.0384387597,
-0.0074093458,
-0.0320717953,
0.0888708457,
0.0313811824,
-0.0257088114,
-0.0203583259,
0.0592530742,
-0.0316117108,
-0.0363718979,
-0.0062829852,
-0.0411019921,
0.0594246611,
0.0198089182,
0.024238361,
-0.0265168492,
0.0193870701,
-0.0123618646,
-0.0171510633,
-0.0061916769,
-0.0100374892,
-0.0418052524,
0.0229630731,
0.0074440539,
-0.0574948564,
0.0021881761,
-0.0243898463,
0.0772477761,
0.0140005602,
0.0150475623,
-0.0063360636,
0.0160931647,
-0.0448012054,
-0.0030403812,
-0.0459976904,
0.0433559343,
-0.0020341249,
-0.0098460997,
-0.0339701548,
0.0157029759,
-0.0485892184,
0.0041934066,
-0.0146280602,
0.0342147499,
-0.0185296852,
0.0042218263,
-0.0069422615,
0.0307695735,
0.0187386833,
0.0264375843,
0.0045572836,
-0.0367572941,
-0.0040655211,
-0.0066063376,
0.0512266532,
-0.0056093424,
-0.0007378697,
0.0640490949,
0.0369491987,
-0.0406519473,
-0.0063638687,
-0.0064345039,
-0.0435865261,
-0.0431474857,
0.0009543977,
-0.0450842604,
0.0078497231,
-0.0235050898,
0.0199435428,
-0.0380052924,
-0.0204484891,
-0.0350947678,
0.0407084823,
0.0586755611,
0.0091945007,
0.0272571128,
0.0465034917,
0.0166353583,
0.0185715351,
-0.0035334423,
0.0254176781,
-0.0109049296,
-0.0172781888,
-0.1035699472,
0.0097390627,
0.0204142425,
0.0436848812,
-0.0317162462,
-0.0217331424,
0.0223377682,
0.0002603648,
0.0450187251,
0.0615738481,
0.0012459337,
-0.0337971076,
-0.0761752352,
0.0912662596,
0.0713855252,
0.039647337,
0.0362639613,
0.0366231911,
0.0233614128,
0.0553267747,
0.0388577767,
-0.0402163789,
0.0102041727,
0.0047899056,
-0.0078426981,
0.0136307655,
0.0022141521,
-0.0588749051,
-0.0474540144,
0.0085965982,
-0.0377502888,
0.0047521228,
0.0064174365,
-0.0020878562,
0.0281466506,
-0.0163381435,
0.0272388626,
0.0131522473,
-0.0204277281,
-0.0011061624,
-0.0723179132,
-0.0071180668,
0.0243830662,
-0.0387597121,
0.0023639775,
0.0030813003,
-0.0383522511,
-0.0420637019,
0.0262449794,
0.0112991259,
0.0185179934,
0.0788604766,
0.0101884184,
-0.0307719875,
-0.043858327,
0.0069887466,
0.0611622222,
-0.0352695212,
-0.0411938801,
0.0295205712,
-0.0565345325,
0.0040422552,
-0.0129060196,
-0.000843812,
-0.066480808,
0.0430130549,
0.0123999128,
0.0398654155,
0.0315235145,
-0.0379333422,
0.0140532022,
0.0179086216,
-0.0008138681,
-0.0305933543,
0.0006398573,
-0.1210333481,
-0.0329842418,
0.0157935899,
-0.0300095994,
0.0209804866,
0.0827939361,
0.022986073,
-0.0534529947,
0.0788402557,
-0.0441417992,
0.0350121558,
-0.0550669432,
0.0071522389,
0.0124406014,
0.0525556616,
0.0392288528,
0.0438949354,
0.0310564842,
-0.0426747873,
0.004994032,
0.0595719777,
0.0166942161,
-0.0744423792,
-0.0327195935,
-0.023827767,
-0.0375278778,
0.0462370738,
-0.0031575963,
-0.0367868692,
-0.0311543941,
-0.0011371444,
-0.0714064166,
-0.0138924653,
-0.0251681581,
-0.009389881,
0.0034185972,
-0.0037512421,
-0.0092001809,
-0.0394384153,
-0.0159437303,
-0.090291895,
-0.017330246,
-0.015037803,
-0.0423895828,
0.0128095038,
-0.0072475201,
-0.0340958834,
-0.0125546576,
0.0083903866,
0.0174993649,
-0.0332853831,
-0.008243111,
0.0014317121,
-0.0218942687,
-0.0064098183,
0.0042330655,
0.0369166359,
-0.0161906593,
-0.0072842017,
0.0159085263,
-0.0109782871,
0.0590964146,
0.0375576168,
0.025193803,
0.010143456,
-0.0260554645,
-0.0573761873,
0.0276983809,
-0.0123549309,
0.0505220257,
-0.0377368964,
0.0232968107,
-0.0214301292,
0.0744925067,
0.035036236,
0.0093457783,
-0.0420569852,
-0.0012868051,
-0.0113970088,
-0.0854126737,
-0.0134132635,
-0.0219493303,
-0.0268733166,
0.0140687265,
0.0032823251,
-0.0449805036,
0.0302308258,
-0.0741477832,
-0.032993339,
-0.0303684194,
-0.0741037354,
0.0036525547,
0.015530196,
-0.003836374,
0.0372844897,
0.0191474371,
-0.0285477508,
-0.0007511222,
-0.0261447877,
0.0362174846,
-0.0331907533,
-0.0375945158,
0.0354153179,
-0.0150641436,
0.0109983739,
-0.0292797145,
-0.037255697,
-0.0357801542,
-0.0098353792,
0.0150613934,
-0.0124296043,
0.0099793496,
0.002059099,
0.00678522,
0.0137515729,
-0.0099700186,
-0.0235990304,
0.00612059,
-0.0082407892,
0.0317774452,
0.0043824781,
0.0380486995,
0.0254237466,
0.0194423962,
0.0598273203,
-0.0313922018,
0.0738200098,
0.0423187874,
-0.05975217,
0.0393626355,
-0.002215466,
-0.0035998856,
-0.0356458127,
0.0384370536,
0.0423128679,
-0.0454637818,
0.0107530169,
0.1235087365,
0.0085623432,
-0.0038321526,
-0.0261737537,
-0.0154171931,
-0.033781562,
-0.0012019528,
0.0120157264,
-0.0010650556,
0.0091789067,
0.005246243,
0.0258222669,
0.0036951143,
0.0261286329,
0.0111205829,
-0.0748209581,
0.0541029572,
0.0174471121,
-0.0400767997,
0.008477251,
-0.0615164302,
-0.0142938877,
-0.0387524851,
0.0742884129,
-0.0181019269,
-0.0408232138,
-0.0356404819,
0.0522076041,
-0.0750824586,
-0.009833876,
0.063038595,
-0.0175447371,
0.0797642171,
0.0678395778,
0.0304010473,
-0.0165328365,
-0.0491515696,
-0.0083151115,
-0.0370501243,
0.0270902943,
-0.0146318395,
0.065267615,
0.0127791865,
-0.0142345224,
0.0012770132,
0.0364757851,
0.0167639274,
-0.0135810291,
-0.0434837267,
0.0386707895,
-0.0074459938,
-0.0203338265,
-0.0114257867,
0.0596263856,
-0.0054668942,
0.06999062,
0.0599804744,
-0.0335768014,
-0.0425991043,
0.027094733,
0.0636022314,
0.0001676832,
-0.0536830425,
0.0697923899,
0.0414971188,
-0.0607011132,
0.0176763926,
-0.0608462654,
-0.0274938252,
0.01821547,
-0.0170985237,
-0.0041174595,
-0.0266542025,
-0.0054881149,
-0.0109934695,
0.0375035852,
-0.0247917511,
0.0223174337,
0.0071214801,
-0.026622314,
0.0423682369,
-0.0508571379,
-0.0148193035,
-0.0140689872,
-0.0479578301,
-0.0351511911,
0.0342360921,
0.0211097021,
0.0193325952,
0.0818522945,
-0.0246313568,
-0.0573694035,
0.1125056297,
0.0219202749,
-0.0775290951,
0.0179422144,
0.0947867632,
-0.0237162653,
-0.027505802,
0.0301979519,
-0.0189278517,
0.0693440884,
-0.0256486144,
-0.0438550413,
-0.0032752967,
-0.0630486459,
0.0331524946,
-0.0171793774,
0.0483866967,
0.0130249755,
0.0417698249,
-0.0057828831,
0.0003207134,
-0.0079911463,
0.030149037,
-0.0148577224,
-0.053727001,
0.0407874659,
0.0485926904,
0.0259290226,
0.0226300452,
-0.0530972071,
0.0393398553,
-0.0347585604,
0.0147551224,
0.0055280542,
-0.0333329849,
-0.0592755415,
0.0646803379,
-0.0044653001,
0.020387765,
0.048968818,
0.0068600592,
0.0425678231,
-0.003676865,
-0.0328747742,
0.055238165,
-0.0128517589,
0.0173000544,
-0.0806380436,
-0.049629353,
-0.0103385765,
-0.0182495546,
0.0080446117,
-0.0365419947,
0.0184058268,
0.0193038452,
0.0355168842,
-0.0281784087,
0.0028659096,
-0.0332757048,
0.026733838,
0.0384559594,
-0.0243785009,
-0.0190252438,
-0.0480061993,
0.0260132663,
0.0371218994,
0.0325207897,
-0.0188661031,
0.0388455652,
-0.042226281,
-0.0319153406,
-0.0096214563,
0.0100712413,
-0.0234729182,
-0.0533353537,
-0.0208649766,
-0.0859821737,
0.0519591086,
-0.020538168,
0.0212686826,
-0.0077239415,
0.0208469536,
-0.0002686555,
-0.0204709899,
-0.000703424,
0.0230547022,
-0.0414395444,
0.0211767126,
0.0072440794,
0.0748516172,
-6.083873501e-33,
-0.0424984321,
0.0414084941,
0.0179352611,
-0.0041684052,
0.0107936906,
0.0304980893,
-0.009249947,
0.0405261628,
0.0020633168,
0.0061425264,
-0.0122271441,
0.0003615607,
0.0337814651,
0.0191936679,
-0.0240339767,
-0.0071574473,
0.0953361019,
-0.03401177,
0.0125941951,
0.0050086994,
-0.0006163928,
0.0314870961,
0.0337344334,
-0.1096956953,
-0.0203640945,
0.0073917704,
-0.0190388653,
-0.0555941388,
0.0088639027,
0.0756103992,
-0.0435251668,
0.0158090126,
-0.0101530459,
-0.0408898368,
-0.0774237067,
0.0463110246,
-0.0932696387,
-0.0313945189,
0.001853277,
0.0189822726,
-0.0413668454,
-0.0263858419,
0.0446471982,
0.0244172085,
-0.0444758423,
-0.0549055077,
0.0509914197,
0.0238802433,
-0.0092040272,
-0.0223911554,
-0.004991842,
0.0153942443,
-0.0221023615,
-0.0340247713,
0.0950516537,
0.0565470457,
-0.025621755,
-0.003959646,
-0.0483671427,
0.0123487338,
-0.0114823943,
0.0064569321,
0.0557208918,
0.0369689874,
0.0185002349,
0.0550219752,
0.0873169601,
-0.0384383425,
0.024176335,
-0.0473257825,
0.0703749508,
0.0659096316,
0.0232011471,
0.0039852373,
-0.0062486138,
-0.0146475099,
-0.0232164115,
-0.0187053531,
-0.0147829968,
-0.027120553,
0.0071439594,
0.0311396047,
-0.0128880441,
0.0096090706,
-0.0811290964,
-0.0574453473,
-0.0093590124,
-0.0203923155,
0.0437073447,
0.0070005604,
-0.0186564885,
0.015645951,
0.0617290623,
-0.0662448406,
-0.0018962832,
-0.023393847,
-0.0311132986,
-0.0072433669,
0.025878083,
0.0269767568,
-0.0263798684,
-0.0209243335,
0.0256716162,
0.0223738123,
0.0264026951,
-0.0170771983,
-0.0073912502,
0.0498810746,
-0.0613180622,
-0.0203082021,
-0.02425877,
0.0061215991,
-0.0159668662,
-0.017593639,
0.0494856648,
0.0202445909,
-0.0172207411,
0.0013080603,
0.0025667239,
0.0233000461,
-0.013923388,
0.0124499043,
0.0059542987,
0.0273940545,
-0.0119212335,
-0.0300994385,
-0.0231825244,
-0.0251394175,
0.0503634326,
-0.0287720263,
-0.0020556101,
0.0045370408,
2.619e-7,
-0.0388654843,
0.0020040241,
0.0384979807,
-0.019026408,
0.0789764524,
0.0604693927,
-0.0098461872,
0.0296669509,
0.0269412436,
-0.0199524872,
-0.006604258,
0.0323584676,
0.0500852801,
0.0215228107,
-0.0531672388,
-0.0017526571,
-0.0735905766,
0.0113340039,
-0.0231447332,
0.0347371027,
0.0071125878,
0.0753371045,
0.0118521592,
-0.0339612849,
0.0027339186,
-0.0045078858,
0.0734662563,
-0.0339868814,
0.000515577,
-0.0108689666,
0.0085062832,
0.0232164916,
0.0038290743,
0.0228049699,
-0.0067277309,
0.0599422678,
-0.006715484,
0.0432943664,
0.0064735524,
-0.062207073,
-0.0149328364,
0.0614581928,
-0.0295697618,
-0.0151979644,
0.0529226288,
-0.027381584,
-0.0366399921,
-0.0472046509,
-0.0416462086,
0.0282629542,
0.043186605,
0.0129163433,
0.0234330688,
-0.0013446002,
-0.018181473,
-0.024977861,
-0.0383450985,
-0.050546024,
-0.0348235145,
0.0133256475,
-0.0746680871,
-0.0113516115,
-0.059207309,
0.0162620824,
0.0684217364,
-0.0180268679,
0.0220520534,
1.433373245e-34,
-0.0309834015,
0.0010882968,
-0.0070616989,
-0.0265998896,
-0.0571842417,
-0.0434647985,
0.0203858241,
0.0263521075,
0.032243941,
-0.0264901984,
0.0006834582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17623v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17623v2 | Neighboring Perturbations of Knowledge Editing on Large Language Models | 2024-01-31T06:49:36 | 2024-05-27T03:52:43 | Jun-Yu Ma, Zhen-Hua Ling, Ningyu Zhang, Jia-Chen Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their exceptional capabilities, large language models (LLMs) are
prone to generating unintended text due to false or outdated knowledge. Given
the resource-intensive nature of retraining LLMs, there has been a notable
increase in the development of knowledge editing. However, current approaches
and evaluations rarely explore the perturbation of editing on neighboring
knowledge. This paper studies whether updating new knowledge to LLMs perturbs
the neighboring knowledge encapsulated within them. Specifically, we seek to
figure out whether appending a new answer into an answer list to a factual
question leads to catastrophic forgetting of original correct answers in this
list, as well as unintentional inclusion of incorrect answers. A metric of
additivity is introduced and a benchmark dubbed as Perturbation Evaluation of
Appending Knowledge (PEAK) is constructed to evaluate the degree of
perturbation to neighboring knowledge when appending new knowledge. Besides, a
plug-and-play framework termed Appending via Preservation and Prevention (APP)
is proposed to mitigate the neighboring perturbation by maintaining the
integrity of the answer list. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of APP
coupling with four editing methods on four LLMs. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/mjy1111/PEAK. | Neighboring Perturbations of Knowledge Editing on Large Language Models: Despite their exceptional capabilities, large language models (LLMs) are
prone to generating unintended text due to false or outdated knowledge. Given
the resource-intensive nature of retraining LLMs, there has been a notable
increase in the development of knowledge editing. However, current approaches
and evaluations rarely explore the perturbation of editing on neighboring
knowledge. This paper studies whether updating new knowledge to LLMs perturbs
the neighboring knowledge encapsulated within them. Specifically, we seek to
figure out whether appending a new answer into an answer list to a factual
question leads to catastrophic forgetting of original correct answers in this
list, as well as unintentional inclusion of incorrect answers. A metric of
additivity is introduced and a benchmark dubbed as Perturbation Evaluation of
Appending Knowledge (PEAK) is constructed to evaluate the degree of
perturbation to neighboring knowledge when appending new knowledge. Besides, a
plug-and-play framework termed Appending via Preservation and Prevention (APP)
is proposed to mitigate the neighboring perturbation by maintaining the
integrity of the answer list. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of APP
coupling with four editing methods on four LLMs. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/mjy1111/PEAK. | [
0.0529856607,
0.0525988378,
-0.0267149489,
0.0326216258,
-0.0281592682,
0.0117949657,
-0.0334047563,
-0.003995874,
0.0206254385,
-0.0481830798,
0.0081131579,
-0.0106799323,
0.0242029522,
-0.0237929691,
0.0312840343,
-0.0260689408,
0.0979769602,
-0.0432010628,
-0.0217148904,
-0.0170863867,
0.0045894752,
-0.0251374785,
0.0107150078,
-0.0117270006,
0.0234636404,
-0.0359443091,
-0.0336605385,
-0.004150935,
0.0224010255,
-0.026566036,
-0.0277147871,
0.0700755194,
-0.0450854227,
0.0778772831,
0.0000022361,
-0.0568600856,
-0.0540968329,
0.0179422814,
-0.044963412,
0.0434160717,
-0.0174957849,
0.0154483607,
-0.0320902914,
0.0049388553,
-0.0321815237,
0.0222914238,
0.0453841537,
0.015060815,
0.0988184735,
0.061596401,
0.025715882,
0.0443443544,
0.037325412,
-0.0176482294,
0.0647936463,
-0.0270466581,
0.0647309572,
0.0115137668,
-0.016238451,
0.0226448216,
-0.010115806,
0.0373160765,
0.0027616727,
-0.0582109317,
-0.0018998201,
0.0120740291,
-0.0313040279,
0.0175463296,
0.0057099611,
0.0239650551,
0.0252288356,
-0.0521854386,
-0.0171168335,
0.0075178836,
0.0354008786,
0.0348970518,
-0.0310304333,
-0.021938866,
0.0006572278,
-0.042001728,
-0.0023126635,
-0.1066879705,
0.0431306921,
0.0143137863,
0.027111724,
0.0595307872,
0.0263650287,
-0.041417636,
-0.0632506311,
0.0016043728,
-0.0328657739,
-0.1375778168,
-0.0165267438,
0.0641555861,
-0.0126325898,
0.0100894142,
-0.0245738421,
-0.019233657,
0.0536570624,
-0.0561287105,
0.0074676783,
0.0186930653,
-0.011308304,
0.0463321693,
-0.0381790735,
0.0345889926,
-0.0117661851,
-0.0061855479,
-0.0506418683,
0.0345952995,
-0.039959453,
-0.0487450324,
0.0123892305,
0.0700477734,
0.0058447942,
0.037375059,
-0.0124135204,
0.0390927531,
-0.0162391216,
0.0346441679,
-0.0454993844,
-0.0052083842,
0.0061872606,
-0.0216343757,
-0.056712348,
0.0437311344,
-0.0030550018,
0.0491899811,
0.0209121779,
-0.0129295252,
-0.0163558964,
-0.0383796319,
-0.0007569306,
-0.0023535087,
0.0264620092,
0.0295335948,
-0.0325906053,
0.008290044,
-0.0551551692,
-0.0814928338,
-0.0074593178,
-0.0434305854,
-0.0393440537,
-0.0820276216,
0.0274001136,
0.0053767171,
-0.0464430302,
-0.0558088794,
0.0047663022,
0.0371784717,
-0.0373311378,
0.0418226644,
-0.0533366613,
0.0377959982,
0.0635183081,
0.0139050055,
-0.0412285738,
0.0434896499,
0.0195203461,
-0.0183726996,
0.0424002185,
-0.0184434112,
-0.0009728173,
-0.0061770221,
0.0314358957,
0.0264363736,
-0.0045142556,
0.0375017971,
0.0272174627,
0.0078342538,
-0.0219701305,
0.0338808708,
-0.0276749227,
-0.0013425869,
0.0907398909,
-0.0183736291,
-0.0308221318,
0.0421588756,
-0.040283788,
-0.06214514,
0.0277166627,
0.043150451,
-0.0552124456,
0.0379092284,
-0.0496671647,
-0.0019957402,
0.0210376997,
-0.0017407364,
0.00038153,
-0.0184516944,
0.0084218495,
0.0336337872,
0.0059309932,
-0.0084080771,
0.0036891247,
0.0221982729,
-0.0077244923,
0.0662886873,
-0.0041670259,
-0.037225645,
0.0238917712,
-0.0311149154,
0.0070227375,
0.0547605529,
0.0552622378,
-0.0550458878,
-0.0721542761,
-0.0198423564,
-0.0150448363,
-0.0089029055,
0.0775272623,
-0.0216764882,
-0.0243520588,
0.0222548712,
-0.0344328061,
-0.0138564445,
0.0312365554,
-0.0134680327,
0.0277648699,
0.0174535289,
-0.0023880773,
-0.0199063066,
-0.0239031743,
0.0177144073,
-0.046670381,
-0.0058495277,
-0.0198688004,
-0.0101421364,
-0.0258820243,
0.0110024102,
-0.0325142629,
0.0230078045,
0.0215843357,
0.0279902369,
-0.0550961718,
-0.0104481028,
0.0069350591,
0.001746421,
0.0694734529,
0.0284487791,
-0.0341099389,
-0.0027381182,
-0.0216627996,
-0.0358267799,
-0.0159688108,
-0.042697072,
0.0623385683,
-0.0395383313,
0.0387539491,
-0.005928108,
-0.0370002389,
-0.0133389113,
0.0558860265,
-0.0195975695,
0.0122744925,
0.0267780907,
-0.0222164616,
-0.0007634727,
-0.014061735,
-0.0018898718,
-0.0084417406,
-0.0003074126,
0.008838214,
0.0259549469,
-0.0262376536,
-0.0368603989,
-0.0327895023,
-0.0844299644,
-0.0093122059,
-0.0093333777,
0.0204166248,
0.0074853897,
0.0087193297,
-0.0058970107,
-0.015590162,
-0.0024943757,
0.000595759,
0.0154312029,
0.0809994116,
0.0132979183,
0.0332708657,
0.0205988418,
-0.038913615,
0.0049953558,
0.0017871223,
0.0194836557,
0.0261270311,
-0.0130742984,
-0.0639101043,
-0.0076263975,
-0.1038750336,
0.0122992629,
0.0288593471,
-0.0222558286,
-0.0185156222,
0.0129565476,
0.0756843388,
0.0346225537,
0.0197946839,
-0.0465585813,
0.0814820528,
-0.0117229298,
-0.0179715808,
-0.0001176727,
-0.0146501819,
-0.0548848845,
-0.0139840543,
-0.0093492949,
-0.0104777915,
0.0314951316,
-0.0065012267,
-0.0482800603,
-0.0175375734,
0.0273254849,
-0.03049477,
-0.055153694,
-0.0484422706,
-0.0505535081,
-0.0263827536,
0.0486295149,
-0.0353686698,
-0.0494905896,
0.0609337725,
-0.0041411212,
0.0564282611,
-0.0369336195,
0.013079145,
0.0003250684,
0.0450756289,
0.0117285512,
0.0479330979,
-0.0046391604,
0.0132207153,
-0.1068876237,
-0.0103726741,
0.0586271472,
-0.0487927869,
0.0469994359,
-0.0779731497,
0.0118195787,
-0.0088167815,
-0.0084509859,
-0.057333678,
-0.0477032885,
0.0035031778,
-0.0340222232,
-0.0098537346,
-0.0298960786,
0.0096555548,
-0.0433243513,
0.0880968571,
0.0471523404,
-0.0089289211,
-0.019512007,
-0.015364117,
0.0252831075,
0.0882505551,
0.0188236926,
0.0778165981,
-0.0465175509,
0.0346814208,
0.0941281021,
0.0457136929,
-0.0186384097,
0.0431035869,
-0.0252783112,
-0.0175563358,
-0.0643709823,
-0.0322462581,
0.0087055434,
0.0298061986,
-0.0557533763,
-0.0084564639,
0.063639462,
0.0469832234,
-0.030699715,
0.0145302713,
-0.0468065739,
0.0076200571,
0.0354289524,
0.0749749392,
-0.0806948021,
0.0131592145,
0.0372705236,
-0.0087498063,
-0.0234622639,
-0.0593787543,
-0.0208589882,
-0.104700394,
-0.0102136638,
-0.0005098929,
-0.0445747003,
-0.0177721996,
-0.0318228044,
0.0025365795,
0.0590748601,
-0.0037149726,
0.0481657833,
-0.0053465217,
-0.0015737283,
0.0071832011,
-0.0230016802,
-0.0007462708,
0.0001306532,
0.0148473782,
0.0470574647,
0.0455455482,
-0.0036052489,
-0.0227615517,
-0.0091719711,
0.0562507585,
0.0137617476,
-0.0088183274,
-0.0053071813,
0.0273189116,
0.0352257267,
0.027339695,
0.0005441445,
-0.0201482568,
0.0401391424,
-0.0438913777,
0.0587002076,
0.083316423,
-0.0149694709,
-0.0012328961,
0.0088417819,
-0.0392435044,
-0.0027917835,
0.0483639948,
0.006886194,
-0.0090430249,
0.0218124278,
-0.044889167,
-0.0067118816,
0.0177743342,
-0.0060583348,
-0.0096986331,
-0.0147840073,
0.0400157757,
-0.0922879949,
-0.0283903703,
-0.0217266288,
-0.0167604275,
0.0407359526,
0.0493562631,
0.0064314855,
-0.0029582579,
0.0027596958,
-0.0342733674,
-0.0223342646,
0.0236736387,
-0.0078470213,
0.001261763,
-0.0099538956,
-0.0095076328,
-0.0089976294,
-0.0571045689,
-0.0871794969,
-0.0547545217,
0.032855399,
0.0466699153,
0.0264479723,
0.0407032371,
0.0195299406,
-0.0420267619,
0.013722023,
0.0215420146,
-0.0243472513,
0.0712772459,
0.0011409619,
-0.0193815846,
0.0001725393,
0.0195724722,
-0.0544650331,
-0.0306159351,
0.0258648619,
0.0138520719,
-0.0491273627,
-0.0226058364,
-0.0024320402,
0.023589097,
-0.0047645601,
0.0114071527,
0.0037990303,
-0.0049273153,
0.071226567,
-0.0139707904,
-0.0177147519,
0.0083456729,
-0.0205879379,
-0.0177036617,
0.0157948006,
0.028489776,
0.0140004661,
0.0295165293,
0.0258895382,
-0.0155854737,
-0.0348375998,
0.0265966766,
0.0078229364,
0.0434785336,
0.0324876644,
-0.0229069069,
0.0028718053,
-0.0010056077,
0.0455978811,
-0.0178490374,
0.0331265703,
0.0275911838,
-0.0364520997,
0.00305347,
0.0075892727,
-0.1012388915,
-0.0602704138,
-0.0102414666,
0.0338276103,
0.0344005115,
0.0119736111,
0.040580783,
-0.0295277219,
-0.0186976995,
-0.044661954,
-0.0119673535,
0.028087331,
-0.0243320595,
-0.0121088726,
0.0172182638,
-0.0033859722,
0.0538391881,
0.0617403127,
-0.0486324951,
0.0886323377,
-0.0169704519,
-0.015480103,
-0.013129876,
-0.034866143,
-0.0267428923,
0.0194116328,
-0.0394403376,
-0.0048958515,
-0.0739409477,
-0.0690668076,
-0.0118462369,
0.0163781792,
0.00638169,
-0.0007004734,
-0.0149457511,
0.0138267744,
0.0113735953,
0.0102327885,
-0.0214007925,
0.0266539622,
-0.0325283892,
0.0280641038,
0.0251639783,
-6.447141296e-33,
-0.0053877179,
-0.0208289456,
0.0194714926,
0.0125924237,
-0.0278191399,
0.0148434797,
-0.0443728156,
0.0124966167,
-0.005063077,
-0.0012680467,
-0.0128712486,
0.0323350132,
-0.0138922501,
0.0009996541,
0.0062829982,
-0.0281770378,
0.0468125083,
0.026249947,
-0.035094168,
0.019092638,
0.0289493967,
-0.013056838,
0.0468353853,
-0.0291127879,
0.0719445422,
0.0033139593,
0.0129388459,
0.0323822089,
-0.0838629529,
0.0499401912,
0.0048001893,
0.0418992899,
-0.0077433558,
-0.054173205,
-0.04979828,
-0.0340674482,
0.001758815,
-0.0494491495,
0.0151907075,
-0.0036501049,
-0.0172834154,
-0.0173405837,
0.0262939446,
0.0133140171,
-0.0063881865,
-0.031236656,
0.0043560551,
-0.0204472896,
-0.0227282643,
0.0432202183,
-0.0171071421,
0.0138867535,
0.0333091728,
-0.0119646071,
-0.0317750201,
0.0071982699,
0.0335245058,
-0.0544870272,
-0.1010987982,
-0.0007732027,
0.0583048314,
0.0681975782,
0.0316206254,
-0.0267317612,
-0.0000713589,
0.0479689799,
0.0333524495,
0.0461891741,
0.0039547789,
-0.0023909477,
-0.0380153805,
0.0010643485,
0.0628121719,
0.0465714484,
0.0269682072,
-0.0096442811,
-0.0276050605,
-0.0020083347,
-0.0195189659,
0.0446994863,
-0.0160977691,
0.0088756941,
0.0275293756,
0.0015721439,
-0.0654481128,
0.0615440086,
-0.038988784,
-0.0094515104,
0.0168769918,
0.031284079,
-0.0262113418,
-0.0132843498,
0.018409973,
-0.0276578534,
-0.0239182692,
0.0088241957,
-0.0079703024,
0.0052492083,
0.020660853,
0.019532891,
-0.0326328315,
0.0512069352,
0.0044685779,
-0.0179323331,
0.0101296613,
0.0117554748,
0.0400970057,
0.050841134,
-0.0673034787,
0.0308171641,
-0.0085102981,
0.0296489913,
0.005652769,
-0.0610507168,
0.0236058943,
-0.000968339,
0.0081642848,
0.0037658154,
0.0727824867,
0.0266183186,
-0.0383654237,
0.0283375084,
0.0076856627,
0.0039966106,
0.0028490042,
0.0204267856,
-0.0212169774,
0.0282749105,
-0.0233298652,
-0.0332838409,
0.0003257027,
-0.0184709113,
3.002e-7,
0.0248089861,
0.0489206091,
0.0261538401,
0.0012104644,
0.061851725,
0.0457143076,
-0.0355071463,
0.0031651084,
0.0603336915,
0.0083506787,
-0.0071511311,
0.0006734005,
0.0215602834,
0.0501012504,
-0.023572376,
-0.0192615278,
-0.067305848,
0.0007132461,
-0.0309398081,
-0.0190607943,
0.040108189,
0.0226701722,
0.0164598208,
-0.0050667934,
-0.0464955382,
-0.0284511428,
0.0769045204,
-0.0047541992,
0.0088987844,
-0.0018815084,
0.0454511903,
0.0125320312,
0.0360304154,
0.0422035046,
-0.050321769,
-0.0352900885,
-0.0165468343,
0.0173153635,
-0.0323785394,
0.001858815,
-0.0133637739,
0.0024045962,
0.0160951763,
-0.0695464909,
0.0793844238,
-0.0276014637,
0.0254584476,
-0.0204116572,
-0.0448356196,
-0.0133616989,
0.011168858,
0.009992444,
-0.0281278118,
0.0030538461,
-0.0030952841,
0.0934452862,
-0.0132094985,
-0.0231369752,
-0.0870479867,
0.022102328,
-0.0079750651,
-0.0858631656,
-0.0474825464,
-0.0262121633,
-0.0235647019,
-0.0999055952,
-0.0114336638,
2.804749266e-34,
-0.0149520645,
-0.0157563034,
0.0300099291,
0.0277024154,
0.0118536605,
-0.0203246977,
0.011727849,
-0.0057696672,
0.0173959322,
-0.0759185702,
-0.0303651672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17602v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17602v1 | Assertion Detection Large Language Model In-context Learning LoRA Fine-tuning | 2024-01-31T05:11:00 | 2024-01-31T05:11:00 | Yuelyu Ji, Zeshui Yu, Yanshan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we aim to address the task of assertion detection when
extracting medical concepts from clinical notes, a key process in clinical
natural language processing (NLP). Assertion detection in clinical NLP usually
involves identifying assertion types for medical concepts in the clinical text,
namely certainty (whether the medical concept is positive, negated, possible,
or hypothetical), temporality (whether the medical concept is for present or
the past history), and experiencer (whether the medical concept is described
for the patient or a family member). These assertion types are essential for
healthcare professionals to quickly and clearly understand the context of
medical conditions from unstructured clinical texts, directly influencing the
quality and outcomes of patient care. Although widely used, traditional
methods, particularly rule-based NLP systems and machine learning or deep
learning models, demand intensive manual efforts to create patterns and tend to
overlook less common assertion types, leading to an incomplete understanding of
the context. To address this challenge, our research introduces a novel
methodology that utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) pre-trained on a vast
array of medical data for assertion detection. We enhanced the current method
with advanced reasoning techniques, including Tree of Thought (ToT), Chain of
Thought (CoT), and Self-Consistency (SC), and refine it further with Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) fine-tuning. We first evaluated the model on the i2b2 2010
assertion dataset. Our method achieved a micro-averaged F-1 of 0.89, with 0.11
improvements over the previous works. To further assess the generalizability of
our approach, we extended our evaluation to a local dataset that focused on
sleep concept extraction. Our approach achieved an F-1 of 0.74, which is 0.31
higher than the previous method. | Assertion Detection Large Language Model In-context Learning LoRA Fine-tuning: In this study, we aim to address the task of assertion detection when
extracting medical concepts from clinical notes, a key process in clinical
natural language processing (NLP). Assertion detection in clinical NLP usually
involves identifying assertion types for medical concepts in the clinical text,
namely certainty (whether the medical concept is positive, negated, possible,
or hypothetical), temporality (whether the medical concept is for present or
the past history), and experiencer (whether the medical concept is described
for the patient or a family member). These assertion types are essential for
healthcare professionals to quickly and clearly understand the context of
medical conditions from unstructured clinical texts, directly influencing the
quality and outcomes of patient care. Although widely used, traditional
methods, particularly rule-based NLP systems and machine learning or deep
learning models, demand intensive manual efforts to create patterns and tend to
overlook less common assertion types, leading to an incomplete understanding of
the context. To address this challenge, our research introduces a novel
methodology that utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) pre-trained on a vast
array of medical data for assertion detection. We enhanced the current method
with advanced reasoning techniques, including Tree of Thought (ToT), Chain of
Thought (CoT), and Self-Consistency (SC), and refine it further with Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) fine-tuning. We first evaluated the model on the i2b2 2010
assertion dataset. Our method achieved a micro-averaged F-1 of 0.89, with 0.11
improvements over the previous works. To further assess the generalizability of
our approach, we extended our evaluation to a local dataset that focused on
sleep concept extraction. Our approach achieved an F-1 of 0.74, which is 0.31
higher than the previous method. | [
0.0623381957,
0.0514940955,
0.0156158162,
0.0027830908,
-0.0449998155,
0.0326030105,
-0.0326718055,
0.010058254,
0.0039605098,
-0.0227096789,
0.0251296759,
-0.0690268949,
0.0091197649,
0.0036681055,
-0.004348665,
0.004188824,
0.0398277789,
0.021090297,
0.0630867481,
0.0247396268,
-0.0260101594,
0.0136840837,
-0.0335042588,
0.0300181378,
-0.0275796782,
-0.0510150604,
0.0298724081,
-0.0091224825,
0.0336824469,
-0.1217848137,
-0.0208464544,
0.038120579,
-0.0179223493,
-0.0122068692,
0.0000022125,
-0.0715737268,
-0.0324343853,
-0.0000511979,
-0.0297659002,
-0.0414132215,
-0.0061553824,
-0.0201870184,
-0.003865408,
0.0024242688,
-0.042050492,
-0.0492813401,
0.0134369582,
0.0752062201,
0.0261273738,
0.0835344791,
-0.0314985998,
-0.0096636023,
-0.0150768887,
0.0089302203,
0.0168679245,
-0.0647019893,
0.0791879967,
0.0243423525,
0.0033595471,
-0.0591962598,
0.0155497994,
0.0131613081,
-0.0220391471,
0.0312024299,
-0.0188486688,
0.0212833434,
-0.0440493822,
-0.0287808795,
0.010764949,
0.0597740337,
-0.0050992449,
-0.0220609922,
0.0032882597,
0.0007606887,
-0.0185652934,
-0.0164848994,
-0.0394868813,
0.0351206139,
-0.0344354026,
0.0254495703,
0.0619846359,
0.0272205211,
0.0228948947,
-0.0158305094,
-0.0792134628,
0.0289123487,
-0.0021121618,
-0.0463663563,
0.0470627584,
-0.0053024394,
-0.0517330393,
-0.0500128381,
0.0296170339,
0.0229859054,
-0.0490549468,
0.0151666766,
0.0018367448,
-0.0340734385,
0.0670414343,
-0.0616064556,
0.00445147,
0.0173044056,
-0.0236159787,
0.0484257825,
-0.0483860709,
0.0063186157,
-0.021729324,
0.0062470636,
-0.0092640677,
-0.0043986505,
-0.0418049283,
0.0046933983,
-0.0155971712,
0.0180502124,
0.0121903522,
-0.0048403316,
-0.0667621568,
-0.0117356693,
-0.0221857,
0.047272291,
-0.0238065347,
0.0178490039,
0.0070743128,
-0.0123087792,
-0.0022496704,
0.0187302083,
0.0427409299,
0.0159203149,
-0.0169224404,
-0.038361039,
0.0064796959,
0.0304277446,
0.0339931212,
0.0121782543,
0.0475254394,
0.010808167,
0.0343430601,
-0.0155031607,
-0.0362708569,
-0.0173026882,
-0.0248758383,
-0.0327105448,
-0.0173598137,
-0.0663982183,
-0.0199331492,
-0.0126870833,
0.0227830112,
-0.0337367542,
0.025153961,
0.0303529482,
-0.0176520851,
0.0395272523,
-0.041030407,
-0.0074839839,
0.0006120338,
0.0338098332,
0.0391929038,
0.0008690428,
0.0469233245,
-0.0200666636,
0.0138346385,
0.0052513513,
0.0238151625,
0.0058014002,
0.0008560616,
-0.0632180274,
0.0158573315,
0.0340431407,
-0.0061795763,
0.0529270694,
-0.0712395459,
0.0783319622,
0.026402792,
-0.0114755929,
0.032278914,
0.0375195444,
-0.0023445589,
-0.0036412412,
0.0125558022,
-0.0520532429,
0.0121891443,
-0.0247941706,
0.0056781829,
-0.0214919914,
0.0033378871,
-0.010131998,
-0.0439854786,
-0.005980283,
-0.0011473278,
-0.0571379364,
-0.0923831612,
0.0129456921,
-0.0486798175,
-0.0072041,
0.0429395735,
0.0060947565,
-0.062409427,
0.0272538755,
0.0287040118,
-0.0005433246,
-0.0351998694,
-0.0507147089,
0.0246948767,
0.0099287089,
0.0428787656,
-0.0427859463,
0.0002024528,
-0.0471252315,
0.0393559672,
0.0449814387,
0.0134848356,
-0.0181369912,
0.008657597,
-0.033751063,
0.0009794727,
0.0533759631,
0.0181253348,
-0.0313213393,
-0.007706508,
0.0309262071,
-0.0306886453,
-0.0279244464,
-0.0697631538,
0.0569033772,
-0.0122971945,
-0.0362408757,
0.0253716651,
0.0113049643,
0.0474203937,
0.0232909266,
-0.0168042369,
0.0078624189,
0.0245539527,
-0.0472060293,
-0.0615299605,
0.02486795,
-0.0829931274,
-0.0275446624,
0.0347209834,
0.003077294,
-0.0385744832,
-0.0498330072,
-0.0484824404,
-0.0138805639,
-0.0456848629,
-0.0312662348,
0.0289123692,
0.0016428881,
0.0285596624,
0.0358186066,
0.0271311011,
-0.038601771,
0.0446687862,
-0.0186521895,
-0.0139735024,
0.0089084292,
-0.0160642378,
0.0240620989,
0.0079245344,
-0.0236255154,
0.017510809,
-0.0393287353,
-0.0045184931,
-0.0081486553,
0.034519501,
-0.0377701037,
0.0143705131,
-0.1366207153,
0.0111085996,
-0.0099570984,
0.021033641,
0.0050561479,
0.0109636271,
-0.0096211992,
-0.0158580281,
-0.0453144349,
-0.0278429929,
0.0162296761,
0.0157942548,
0.0366723575,
0.0385280363,
-0.0180260167,
-0.0367998742,
0.0248742048,
-0.0742516369,
0.0205321107,
-0.0111959064,
-0.0333405174,
0.0084505295,
0.0068900976,
-0.0353468955,
0.0071779802,
-0.0033393728,
0.0022815589,
0.0264137723,
-0.0268530361,
0.0093203653,
0.0749755874,
0.0166798607,
0.0177288391,
0.0466902703,
0.0055273375,
0.003185343,
0.0293696523,
-0.0263425708,
-0.0053095804,
0.0021717949,
-0.0380343497,
-0.0040324945,
0.0904410779,
0.0548357628,
-0.0103734136,
-0.0226567965,
-0.0352522098,
-0.0235248208,
0.0363865271,
-0.0020040649,
0.0093348511,
-0.0239070896,
0.041104652,
-0.0059005204,
-0.0079514263,
0.0930851996,
-0.033167202,
0.0115648732,
-0.0725897402,
-0.0233641509,
-0.0425538011,
0.0342744514,
-0.0067174258,
0.0028800517,
0.0363259614,
-0.0062133544,
0.0254161451,
-0.011547639,
0.0161015335,
-0.0477255508,
0.0433595218,
-0.0444280393,
0.0280266088,
0.0036219729,
-0.0652010143,
-0.0592774861,
-0.012379813,
-0.0203447994,
-0.018442899,
-0.0522249527,
0.0297043547,
-0.04320601,
0.0126219662,
-0.0293776467,
0.0803084522,
0.0223001279,
-0.0228575207,
-0.0134547409,
0.0225781966,
0.0308555644,
-0.0032351671,
0.019040402,
0.0141322641,
0.0352368988,
0.084045656,
-0.022378156,
0.068749547,
-0.0241763312,
0.014836207,
-0.0186066702,
-0.0098396577,
0.0124531891,
0.0250266623,
0.046098683,
-0.0699243695,
-0.0041097994,
0.1248403192,
0.0272934251,
0.002014094,
0.0289517529,
-0.0317369252,
-0.0112515073,
-0.0018678324,
-0.0005808111,
-0.1036853343,
-0.0429330617,
0.0029057625,
-0.0043122452,
-0.0411329456,
-0.0429112017,
0.0248030312,
-0.0313919373,
0.0182788856,
-0.021971669,
-0.0281817801,
-0.0207474511,
-0.0729635507,
0.0266585518,
-0.0207365453,
0.0131942509,
-0.0085328575,
0.0008912017,
-0.0216059666,
-0.0016233377,
-0.0921308324,
-0.0558177605,
0.0602719933,
-0.0237592757,
0.0442111753,
0.0252382252,
0.0483529381,
-0.0063393638,
-0.0225419234,
0.0251053777,
-0.0338845775,
-0.0191983171,
-0.0158310626,
0.0129673658,
0.0044843964,
-0.0014003115,
-0.0409118608,
0.0259988904,
-0.0424916074,
-0.0116833551,
0.0122115705,
0.0952471644,
-0.0328200422,
-0.0695839003,
-0.0461624525,
0.0341441184,
0.0171244647,
0.0539858378,
-0.0080517456,
0.025445072,
-0.0318230465,
0.0214898419,
0.0025737695,
0.0011835888,
-0.0014954448,
0.0467370935,
-0.0149145182,
0.0379937291,
-0.0631811172,
-0.0014145263,
0.0138220079,
0.009697427,
0.0167639945,
0.0410656035,
0.025230784,
0.0186833479,
-0.0972300395,
0.0464750193,
0.0472166315,
-0.0055992422,
-0.0046053268,
-0.0064193131,
0.0659827888,
0.0396681391,
-0.018407749,
0.0331297033,
0.0071567828,
0.0010093926,
-0.0233611614,
0.0252148844,
0.0147705125,
0.036469616,
-0.0007033778,
0.0253446922,
0.057035096,
0.0269850139,
0.0006074792,
-0.0244432893,
0.0181407835,
-0.0032730475,
0.0068320963,
0.0277795363,
-0.001672585,
0.0442356244,
0.0122704646,
0.0428198501,
0.0080694668,
-0.0216851514,
0.0349830799,
0.0428581052,
0.0186701138,
0.0046746386,
-0.043500796,
-0.004771905,
0.0106987003,
-0.0344043076,
-0.0001591131,
0.0006162871,
0.0272245947,
0.0115195103,
0.0010688934,
-0.0254281536,
0.0356863067,
-0.0419601724,
-0.0507173389,
-0.0137921721,
0.0414876975,
0.0016045917,
0.0216385294,
0.0369011313,
-0.0343345441,
-0.0353682525,
-0.0146124475,
0.018837478,
0.0348931514,
0.0034890482,
0.051129479,
0.0305468496,
0.0145765636,
-0.0249770638,
0.0394355804,
-0.0130441682,
0.0013713818,
-0.0437606797,
-0.0370771028,
0.0494368598,
-0.0110982824,
0.0348631181,
-0.0301411264,
0.0127784293,
-0.0025807652,
0.0290680602,
-0.0311790165,
0.0229534321,
0.026298726,
0.0126371412,
-0.0177156664,
0.0200519338,
0.0229047239,
0.0158213302,
0.0535452813,
0.0091203749,
-0.0426662639,
-0.0637685061,
-0.0078357616,
-0.0053361342,
0.0379267819,
-0.0380524136,
0.0278778411,
-0.0586190559,
-0.0452517495,
0.0574769266,
0.0085963178,
0.0063372715,
0.0204535127,
0.0030263562,
0.0549489856,
0.0269193463,
-0.0405973718,
0.0151784942,
0.0174818523,
-0.001894746,
-0.0237086806,
0.0048668357,
-6.146134661e-33,
0.0049245488,
-0.054940477,
0.0218113363,
0.0003958587,
-0.0094094658,
0.0288919769,
-0.067388244,
-0.0136224153,
-0.0217771586,
0.0616612174,
-0.0330152735,
0.0014772135,
0.0162574779,
0.0522421077,
0.0126093775,
0.0046654977,
0.0273747798,
0.032003101,
-0.0240504518,
-0.0005684725,
-0.0048847343,
0.0444925539,
0.0768837854,
-0.1078977138,
0.0038256175,
0.0217906609,
0.0155918468,
0.008004358,
-0.0543345772,
0.0554378368,
-0.0662441552,
0.0506354943,
0.0609963015,
0.0013040674,
0.0311384443,
0.0038748288,
-0.0790887922,
-0.0129812174,
0.0100429552,
-0.0331914797,
-0.0544251911,
0.0083054667,
0.047867056,
0.0124684507,
-0.0140179452,
0.0174936093,
0.0203353614,
-0.0616164878,
0.0323128551,
-0.04925327,
-0.05710743,
0.0569602698,
0.0135978563,
0.0140593005,
-0.0173436776,
-0.0325960927,
-0.0495603047,
0.0192507058,
-0.0684188977,
-0.030216435,
-0.0506088361,
0.0266952813,
-0.006716379,
-0.048998408,
-0.0463854447,
0.0773140341,
0.0045049489,
-0.0044875387,
-0.0484133922,
0.0179639068,
-0.0399546772,
0.0431448296,
0.056054756,
0.0368743166,
0.0221827049,
0.00307808,
-0.1321770251,
-0.005368168,
-0.0058434037,
0.0453691855,
0.0379653685,
-0.0261416081,
-0.0603447892,
-0.0000467724,
-0.0120358858,
-0.0237578414,
-0.0232677031,
0.0217833761,
0.0323039852,
0.0241391379,
0.0136071797,
0.0307152458,
0.0102216611,
-0.0224967878,
-0.0031052222,
-0.0398203917,
0.010996596,
-0.0155888768,
-0.0153124267,
0.0154467775,
-0.0239387546,
-0.0182363894,
0.0104340184,
-0.0043343916,
0.0634851009,
0.014679472,
0.0588232987,
-0.0199856441,
-0.0459842719,
-0.0137855345,
0.024806641,
-0.0063862642,
-0.019472288,
0.0535930172,
0.016815912,
0.0175184347,
0.0020803958,
0.0885079131,
-0.0235535055,
-0.0013517995,
-0.0441283099,
-0.0056185722,
0.0175670478,
-0.0178163424,
-0.0404065438,
-0.0357348025,
-0.0228968374,
0.0493934117,
0.0071845306,
-0.0721129924,
0.0207034685,
-0.0006567431,
3.011e-7,
0.0361269377,
0.068160966,
0.0068195346,
-0.0529827587,
0.058419358,
0.0179344807,
0.0003425834,
-0.0068465793,
0.0087110028,
-0.0614744015,
0.0218026713,
-0.0048503568,
0.029961545,
0.0310392901,
-0.0556867495,
-0.0488653779,
-0.0534980521,
-0.0240779389,
-0.0441679284,
-0.0134849725,
0.0796109661,
0.0796586797,
-0.0333288796,
-0.0370153897,
0.0134224761,
-0.0118651083,
0.0216225106,
-0.0039599645,
0.0204878524,
0.0410298705,
0.0262031369,
-0.0019777482,
0.0304848552,
0.0667972714,
-0.0111297322,
0.0157882944,
-0.032724116,
0.0981282368,
-0.0537844263,
0.0302451309,
0.0175703391,
0.0234844089,
0.0265826769,
-0.0599615872,
0.0792022794,
-0.0744940266,
-0.0606412925,
-0.0044080596,
-0.0211129598,
-0.0311766844,
0.0570281148,
0.0121543342,
-0.015386791,
0.0194287468,
0.0355693661,
0.0299242493,
-0.0585349612,
-0.0980384797,
-0.0032919815,
0.0347708948,
-0.0307158362,
0.0060487152,
0.0562379584,
-0.0295245461,
-0.0108474651,
-0.0793725625,
0.0100287842,
2.999518578e-34,
0.0359795243,
0.0093861129,
0.0123257348,
0.0170718767,
0.0453677289,
0.0077177999,
-0.0118575906,
0.0080884909,
-0.0012350439,
-0.083243534,
-0.0011149374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17600v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17600v1 | Good at captioning, bad at counting: Benchmarking GPT-4V on Earth observation data | 2024-01-31T04:57:12 | 2024-01-31T04:57:12 | Chenhui Zhang, Sherrie Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Large Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance
on complex tasks involving visual input with natural language instructions.
However, it remains unclear to what extent capabilities on natural images
transfer to Earth observation (EO) data, which are predominantly satellite and
aerial images less common in VLM training data. In this work, we propose a
comprehensive benchmark to gauge the progress of VLMs toward being useful tools
for EO data by assessing their abilities on scene understanding, localization
and counting, and change detection tasks. Motivated by real-world applications,
our benchmark includes scenarios like urban monitoring, disaster relief, land
use, and conservation. We discover that, although state-of-the-art VLMs like
GPT-4V possess extensive world knowledge that leads to strong performance on
open-ended tasks like location understanding and image captioning, their poor
spatial reasoning limits usefulness on object localization and counting tasks.
Our benchmark will be made publicly available at https://vleo.danielz.ch/ and
on Hugging Face at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mit-ei/vleo-benchmark-datasets-65b789b0466555489cce0d70
for easy model evaluation. | Good at captioning, bad at counting: Benchmarking GPT-4V on Earth observation data: Large Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance
on complex tasks involving visual input with natural language instructions.
However, it remains unclear to what extent capabilities on natural images
transfer to Earth observation (EO) data, which are predominantly satellite and
aerial images less common in VLM training data. In this work, we propose a
comprehensive benchmark to gauge the progress of VLMs toward being useful tools
for EO data by assessing their abilities on scene understanding, localization
and counting, and change detection tasks. Motivated by real-world applications,
our benchmark includes scenarios like urban monitoring, disaster relief, land
use, and conservation. We discover that, although state-of-the-art VLMs like
GPT-4V possess extensive world knowledge that leads to strong performance on
open-ended tasks like location understanding and image captioning, their poor
spatial reasoning limits usefulness on object localization and counting tasks.
Our benchmark will be made publicly available at https://vleo.danielz.ch/ and
on Hugging Face at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mit-ei/vleo-benchmark-datasets-65b789b0466555489cce0d70
for easy model evaluation. | [
0.0234266613,
0.0867538229,
0.0135662286,
0.0696282834,
-0.0099841291,
0.0276813954,
-0.0004180147,
-0.0922262967,
0.0122009162,
-0.0094165076,
0.0079635512,
-0.0267532766,
0.0074903974,
0.0619390905,
0.0081618764,
-0.0592119694,
0.0318095386,
-0.0697897896,
0.0000932615,
-0.0128754945,
-0.0129147386,
-0.0137612857,
-0.0097080246,
0.0092533939,
0.0151614575,
0.0043014647,
-0.0074983225,
0.0191673022,
0.0706102774,
-0.0334530063,
-0.0094185304,
0.0312434714,
0.0537642576,
0.0240418296,
0.0000018239,
-0.0140878875,
-0.0087404232,
0.0304673109,
0.0072022732,
0.0079934038,
0.0202600136,
-0.079321973,
-0.0157274511,
-0.0048226696,
-0.0137660038,
-0.0524164103,
0.0722443461,
0.0232590027,
0.0633895323,
0.0770930201,
0.0013404428,
-0.0214904491,
0.0465541482,
-0.0058118445,
0.0223964714,
-0.0442875326,
0.0148262056,
0.0469503924,
-0.0336861387,
0.0132855065,
-0.0263328701,
0.0492845289,
0.0467271768,
-0.0233957376,
-0.0232141204,
0.0784438252,
-0.0680441558,
-0.0095053716,
-0.0613782518,
0.0151147069,
-0.0117284795,
0.0183616206,
-0.0064641014,
0.0081808306,
-0.023046257,
-0.0303778406,
-0.0628140345,
0.0170634761,
0.0197503809,
0.0043119541,
-0.0573032796,
0.0207038019,
-0.0110301422,
0.0240722653,
-0.0364775397,
0.0238568243,
0.0160522908,
0.0319330133,
-0.0240386613,
0.0082541788,
-0.0403732285,
-0.0355794579,
-0.0068350425,
0.0178161506,
-0.0061318106,
-0.0117052849,
-0.0428005755,
0.0414242484,
-0.0302655268,
-0.0418141223,
0.0295294635,
0.0323889218,
-0.0532878973,
0.1260339916,
-0.0237377249,
0.0952927321,
0.0148747638,
0.0445643663,
0.033732079,
-0.0525596961,
-0.0588111579,
-0.0244725775,
-0.0360948108,
-0.016835412,
-0.0288154799,
-0.0433227159,
0.0081289103,
0.0154855624,
0.0128877992,
0.0153368283,
-0.0189939886,
0.0052256086,
-0.039884802,
-0.0340447985,
-0.0023253448,
0.011968472,
0.0142928259,
-0.004471065,
0.0039353748,
-0.0955010578,
0.0181562807,
0.0112999612,
0.0398322307,
-0.0146821588,
-0.0317814909,
0.0390888453,
0.0099473838,
-0.0409268104,
-0.0322816148,
0.0330561176,
-0.0469633415,
-0.0409738086,
0.0167259015,
-0.0609897412,
-0.0269974228,
-0.0420915894,
0.006480711,
-0.0167056136,
0.0200513043,
-0.0127166482,
0.0039413334,
0.0730293095,
-0.0185477827,
-0.0085153477,
0.0072121853,
-0.0193031915,
0.0154501507,
0.1078942791,
0.0463026799,
0.0503443368,
0.042011559,
0.0081597976,
0.035307698,
0.0238290895,
-0.0222577192,
0.0679939687,
-0.0402740352,
0.0259542521,
-0.0522582531,
0.0098169344,
0.0207797829,
0.0240267254,
0.0017560745,
-0.0141748469,
0.0888830572,
0.0089848107,
-0.0256986655,
-0.0173162539,
0.0212413464,
0.0375921018,
-0.0219658911,
-0.0255204681,
-0.0840432197,
0.0803331137,
-0.0361673832,
-0.0199681092,
-0.0285698157,
0.0063491105,
-0.0321715325,
-0.0377786979,
-0.0223617386,
0.0176870711,
-0.0159688257,
-0.0209184811,
0.0473890193,
-0.0445807464,
0.0134966532,
-0.0182402879,
-0.0175582189,
-0.0142450035,
0.0198779404,
-0.0269538984,
0.0167710744,
0.0249027461,
-0.0171750411,
-0.0000549238,
-0.0527426079,
0.0064859348,
0.0513506979,
0.0635574386,
0.039511025,
0.0377086364,
0.0338310972,
-0.0221287347,
-0.0561386943,
-0.0195889268,
0.0037629367,
0.0088950153,
0.0346093848,
0.018264465,
0.0535820201,
-0.0659137145,
-0.0249487143,
0.0325545296,
0.0439902022,
-0.0128803169,
-0.0008654359,
0.0352404676,
-0.0078570964,
-0.016330177,
-0.0178060941,
-0.0182503499,
0.0137460558,
0.0025096256,
-0.0167863276,
0.0279205814,
-0.0113123963,
-0.0360656641,
0.0417613052,
-0.0545594543,
-0.0351940431,
0.0867509097,
-0.0575816408,
-0.036009673,
0.0185876694,
-0.037941698,
-0.0017860384,
-0.0471739955,
-0.0359990671,
-0.0144618312,
0.0087253274,
-0.0144943381,
0.0313047394,
-0.0214376971,
-0.0302231777,
-0.0266566221,
0.0213940907,
0.0190471541,
-0.0094412174,
-0.0085330326,
-0.0432624891,
0.0117751453,
0.0057029836,
0.0180038661,
0.0393929593,
-0.0475329384,
-0.0091918716,
-0.0808401927,
0.0139237149,
-0.051269047,
0.0139204366,
0.0171222314,
-0.0296139903,
-0.0153860971,
-0.0213143304,
-0.0284064002,
0.0052205794,
0.0112438295,
0.0181475673,
-0.0003114886,
-0.0152609991,
-0.0196868498,
-0.0262710433,
0.0211158767,
0.0115220454,
0.0013481628,
0.0316427499,
-0.0626700446,
-0.024664674,
-0.0131430114,
-0.0372443944,
0.0202600863,
-0.0314277597,
-0.0301806405,
0.0185723584,
-0.027844118,
0.0052605835,
0.018488897,
-0.0022364766,
0.0299229883,
-0.0012498338,
0.0093969703,
-0.0191089232,
-0.0020220545,
-0.0245194137,
-0.0750816762,
0.0009627423,
0.0074516167,
-0.0405752622,
-0.0022090212,
-0.0479046144,
-0.0088681821,
-0.0391929038,
0.0400417112,
-0.0198235437,
-0.0348464884,
-0.0468692183,
0.0372953974,
0.0058758254,
0.0153156677,
-0.0442126766,
-0.0738243312,
-0.0175567511,
-0.0266638193,
-0.0246119313,
-0.0103868907,
0.001148394,
-0.0352076441,
0.0713805407,
0.0521420725,
0.0273362305,
0.0044091623,
0.0128077362,
-0.0282153003,
-0.0531345271,
-0.0382379368,
0.0284697674,
0.0394925922,
-0.1259394437,
0.0515747741,
-0.0453928337,
-0.0040390277,
-0.0231467187,
0.0025012481,
-0.0374880657,
0.0355655774,
-0.0478759818,
-0.0366521515,
-0.0000418172,
0.0370267443,
0.0547097102,
0.0616921373,
-0.0217963438,
-0.0105531076,
-0.0268711075,
-0.0060472954,
0.0746558085,
0.0474172607,
0.0175029524,
-0.0197061934,
-0.0074484134,
0.021179175,
0.0121873701,
0.0272583123,
-0.0776032731,
0.0408178307,
-0.0153947342,
0.0429863334,
0.0263957102,
-0.0036839589,
0.0854374692,
-0.0585343055,
-0.0164598431,
0.0850263312,
-0.0009685064,
-0.0112982923,
-0.0070065414,
-0.0057836859,
0.0050449735,
0.0405155718,
-0.0314902514,
-0.0310128611,
-0.0424531437,
-0.0024703045,
-0.0271918587,
0.0374583825,
-0.0056017311,
-0.029737208,
-0.0860587656,
0.0709737167,
0.0162867885,
-0.0883945599,
-0.0495940261,
-0.0031769597,
0.0114557305,
-0.0493657365,
-0.0600519031,
-0.0383269712,
-0.0050086132,
0.031584207,
0.0218360815,
0.0085665071,
-0.0205208529,
-0.0016410548,
-0.0669567361,
0.000674929,
0.0487657338,
0.0113973916,
-0.0107376119,
-0.0578347184,
0.0186224077,
0.0375339538,
-0.0105747981,
0.0358280875,
0.0347202867,
-0.0113800345,
-0.0333999582,
0.0407220684,
0.0355488807,
-0.0533428825,
0.0098467553,
0.0109331645,
0.028095983,
0.0018722875,
-0.0009330953,
-0.0253337622,
-0.0145549765,
0.0190444943,
0.0257510189,
0.0184004791,
0.0389608145,
-0.0471557118,
-0.0146909207,
-0.0046878019,
-0.038829647,
-0.0327900685,
0.0241214987,
0.0075968727,
-0.0491811782,
-0.0220206566,
-0.0304270834,
0.0697764605,
0.039117489,
-0.0228988435,
-0.0485584736,
0.0559387915,
0.0059579671,
-0.0336927734,
0.0583479963,
-0.0508453995,
0.0465056971,
-0.0377984345,
-0.0136492718,
0.0205608997,
0.0095804827,
-0.0120331869,
0.0096668694,
-0.0891297683,
0.0115302857,
-0.0339094624,
0.0792642236,
0.0171876531,
0.006815102,
-0.0129785854,
0.0247631576,
-0.0134202633,
0.0212477483,
-0.0019632513,
0.0263391919,
-0.0031604855,
-0.0195200834,
0.0079601854,
0.0248279516,
-0.0343357064,
0.010720022,
0.0386893265,
-0.0103036063,
-0.0290614981,
-0.0041263462,
-0.0222997963,
-0.0040451698,
0.0987089872,
-0.0034896994,
-0.0207332615,
-0.0033413544,
-0.0035343124,
0.0229601823,
-0.0101918671,
-0.0631904528,
0.0203945469,
0.0217043031,
0.0716280043,
-0.0076419087,
0.0369223021,
0.0166550633,
-0.005165555,
-0.0346598439,
-0.0360645317,
0.0407137424,
-0.0181465708,
0.0035003736,
0.0166522525,
-0.034963984,
-0.0100478567,
0.0135092679,
0.0331728905,
0.0333895087,
0.0063613155,
0.0430774353,
0.0082453955,
-0.0070029926,
0.0535978302,
-0.0453703813,
-0.0945633873,
-0.0387933664,
0.0321920477,
0.0573561564,
-0.0248238314,
0.0407204218,
-0.0266574565,
-0.0054986933,
-0.0600846298,
0.0058973716,
0.0405702256,
-0.0416693203,
0.0493849926,
0.0080557726,
-0.0088166799,
0.0272935648,
0.0717357174,
0.043713592,
0.0290959589,
0.023400953,
0.0122504067,
-0.0142166847,
-0.0090857437,
0.0288986769,
-0.0223093629,
0.0176490415,
0.0578114279,
-0.0189784952,
-0.0345615074,
-0.0211445671,
0.012511122,
0.0011415175,
0.0276479274,
0.0177650694,
0.0192237049,
-0.0337998532,
-0.0265528895,
-0.0271550175,
-0.0490046516,
-0.0333144255,
0.0518289246,
0.028970236,
-5.514340611e-33,
-0.0469485857,
-0.0426959321,
0.0577792935,
0.0039368547,
-0.0053049875,
0.025230037,
-0.0227826275,
0.0049000354,
-0.0085273767,
0.0135884508,
0.0287493225,
0.0178999528,
0.0194057543,
0.03042881,
0.0148128625,
0.0247047339,
0.0358782597,
-0.0141645204,
-0.0350248888,
-0.0191220548,
0.0104814749,
-0.0152219841,
0.0741987899,
-0.0476081818,
-0.044297725,
0.0724924281,
-0.0075946655,
0.0092974072,
-0.0084711621,
0.0291747898,
-0.0231820736,
-0.0063863588,
0.0134314541,
-0.0097203674,
-0.0632915571,
0.012838766,
-0.0161229558,
-0.0209130254,
0.0172011573,
0.052509442,
-0.0445753746,
0.0070513762,
-0.0052890335,
-0.003724583,
0.0177000035,
-0.0354208127,
0.045894634,
-0.0364900343,
-0.0435381345,
0.0170271304,
-0.0438226983,
0.0614684336,
-0.0092417486,
-0.0449207835,
-0.0103309955,
-0.0087464433,
0.0128655834,
0.0467496552,
-0.0427195691,
-0.0018070734,
0.0545839742,
0.0051051062,
0.0544372313,
0.0156519078,
0.0124825686,
0.0756007507,
0.0265734941,
-0.0515203364,
-0.0257498771,
-0.0305010993,
0.0210920498,
0.0469130278,
0.058850728,
0.0459013209,
0.0329730809,
0.0430488661,
-0.0482881255,
0.0036595385,
-0.0713982508,
0.0950394794,
0.0185814854,
0.0195743684,
0.0180732515,
0.0188672785,
-0.0318790488,
-0.0041645789,
-0.0372700803,
0.0231904555,
0.0551561527,
0.0271956436,
-0.05799428,
0.0478759594,
0.0351239666,
-0.0232575126,
-0.0033835978,
0.0177617762,
-0.0065189619,
0.0517740287,
0.0268309712,
0.0580755845,
-0.0762124211,
-0.0019996248,
0.0352563076,
0.0461736135,
-0.0359459817,
0.0085160937,
0.0257861204,
0.0645342693,
-0.0291508511,
0.0002206431,
-0.0886567831,
-0.0119993528,
-0.049159795,
0.0231018513,
0.0090484908,
-0.0386692733,
-0.020677384,
0.0254752338,
-0.0421158932,
-0.0465677381,
0.0059878952,
-0.0213567223,
-0.0093047256,
0.0199302323,
-0.0038320126,
-0.0138766905,
-0.0515878461,
-0.033739429,
0.0046759658,
-0.0123192603,
0.0139325829,
0.034049727,
2.593e-7,
0.0129404264,
0.0320657194,
0.0522735231,
-0.0160583276,
-0.0004444464,
0.0455351807,
-0.0624351725,
0.0379310139,
0.000860699,
0.00706121,
0.0014416282,
0.0617180802,
0.0594868436,
0.0059331646,
-0.0183066428,
0.0527976789,
-0.0209683161,
-0.0004297468,
-0.0643133968,
-0.0247045625,
0.0467926897,
0.0763416514,
-0.0281485692,
0.0035080062,
0.055463139,
-0.0729699284,
0.0743649229,
-0.0480386056,
-0.0102365147,
-0.0107810674,
0.0011067229,
0.0552257374,
0.0015251364,
0.0082904734,
0.0053839306,
-0.0155134173,
0.0472076908,
0.0753737763,
-0.045249939,
0.0093120765,
-0.0186417196,
-0.0024640085,
-0.009407864,
-0.0655477419,
0.0831677392,
-0.0424360782,
0.0067251166,
-0.0060704858,
-0.0100862952,
-0.0025918039,
0.0256931186,
-0.0076792794,
-0.0635161772,
-0.0198755711,
0.0296763405,
-0.0352149382,
-0.0385419056,
-0.0353242494,
0.0329168253,
-0.0226748846,
-0.0059127263,
-0.036261227,
-0.0675242692,
0.0122903781,
0.0308034252,
0.0551692508,
-0.0237992797,
1.749029524e-34,
0.0106788538,
0.0038297009,
-0.0029504958,
-0.0537237115,
0.0047265757,
0.0198804494,
-0.0291244909,
-0.0200326871,
-0.0452811457,
-0.0176234357,
0.0112868967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17597v1 | SPECTRUM: Speaker-Enhanced Pre-Training for Long Dialogue Summarization | 2024-01-31T04:50:00 | 2024-01-31T04:50:00 | Sangwoo Cho, Kaiqiang Song, Chao Zhao, Xiaoyang Wang, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-turn dialogues are characterized by their extended length and the
presence of turn-taking conversations. Traditional language models often
overlook the distinct features of these dialogues by treating them as regular
text. In this paper, we propose a speaker-enhanced pre-training method for long
dialogue summarization, which leverages the inherent structure of multiple-turn
dialogues. To support our study, we curate a diverse dataset that includes
transcripts from real-world scenarios, movie or TV show transcripts, and
dialogues generated by a Large Language Model. We then perform a pre-training,
which encompasses the detection of speaker changes, and masked utterance
generation. Experimental results of fine-tuned models demonstrate that our
model achieves state-of-the-art performance on downstream benchmarks with long
context, surpassing baseline models and highlighting the effectiveness of our
approach. Our findings highlight the importance of curating pre-training
datasets that exhibit diversity and variations in length distribution to ensure
effective alignment with downstream datasets. | SPECTRUM: Speaker-Enhanced Pre-Training for Long Dialogue Summarization: Multi-turn dialogues are characterized by their extended length and the
presence of turn-taking conversations. Traditional language models often
overlook the distinct features of these dialogues by treating them as regular
text. In this paper, we propose a speaker-enhanced pre-training method for long
dialogue summarization, which leverages the inherent structure of multiple-turn
dialogues. To support our study, we curate a diverse dataset that includes
transcripts from real-world scenarios, movie or TV show transcripts, and
dialogues generated by a Large Language Model. We then perform a pre-training,
which encompasses the detection of speaker changes, and masked utterance
generation. Experimental results of fine-tuned models demonstrate that our
model achieves state-of-the-art performance on downstream benchmarks with long
context, surpassing baseline models and highlighting the effectiveness of our
approach. Our findings highlight the importance of curating pre-training
datasets that exhibit diversity and variations in length distribution to ensure
effective alignment with downstream datasets. | [
0.0296840258,
0.0394137874,
0.017325392,
0.0167808738,
0.0065736244,
-0.0179362912,
-0.0012066722,
-0.0123936208,
-0.0120891249,
-0.0460316464,
-0.0184564088,
-0.0052309888,
0.0013235852,
0.0450796224,
0.0096628116,
-0.0912743881,
0.0158598144,
-0.0483079292,
0.0191987883,
-0.0030601602,
0.0376727693,
0.0055781468,
-0.0049999235,
0.0127222175,
-0.028261831,
-0.0065569738,
-0.0280167442,
0.009603247,
0.0559358969,
-0.008968587,
0.01984955,
0.0504148901,
0.0449681357,
0.0113570774,
0.000001835,
-0.0453131311,
-0.0191060975,
-0.0181223005,
-0.040192537,
0.0472877026,
0.0062172278,
-0.0241093952,
0.0184881166,
0.026764933,
-0.0238058101,
-0.0082562594,
0.016816929,
0.047872752,
0.0951827243,
0.0767010972,
-0.0117073525,
-0.0372795798,
0.000960449,
-0.043149855,
-0.0196065921,
-0.0396040604,
-0.005134332,
-0.0045169559,
-0.008496467,
-0.0205858573,
-0.0239476971,
0.0269964151,
-0.0040025422,
-0.031499736,
-0.0007796142,
0.0119714821,
-0.0568648726,
0.0382089913,
0.0171168912,
0.1113098487,
-0.0098588597,
0.0259822737,
0.0272722486,
-0.0067436001,
-0.0025633376,
-0.0446668565,
-0.0399036035,
0.0138782086,
0.0520889945,
-0.0193191823,
-0.0495680235,
0.0581440739,
-0.0268242862,
0.0023971545,
-0.0594686419,
0.0020338099,
0.015478217,
-0.0235035885,
-0.0775558949,
-0.0237033702,
0.0016278108,
-0.0720419511,
-0.0024759367,
0.0171306971,
-0.0387770087,
0.0090929931,
-0.053110335,
-0.0059587345,
-0.0157141369,
0.002431419,
-0.0094301552,
-0.0035621433,
-0.0395120606,
0.0455094874,
-0.0118488325,
0.0238256305,
0.0139602199,
-0.0018572017,
-0.0468488745,
-0.0090178726,
-0.0147708505,
0.0116953216,
-0.0584005415,
0.0018459213,
-0.0618842691,
-0.0553773306,
-0.0316183157,
0.0233453941,
0.0077449237,
0.0001615924,
-0.0005151056,
0.0162930358,
0.0131551353,
-0.0271736868,
0.0187309887,
0.0345981307,
-0.0162046682,
-0.0249976758,
0.0372144356,
-0.0338805653,
-0.0346893556,
0.0328241624,
0.0227273013,
-0.0041676564,
-0.001740025,
0.043732211,
-0.0204398446,
-0.0367402993,
0.0303491671,
-0.0263148006,
-0.0728212595,
-0.0435462408,
-0.0176135786,
-0.0192393865,
0.0642093122,
-0.0251381267,
-0.0003839215,
-0.0020597256,
0.0102716424,
-0.0132891349,
-0.0221679192,
0.0411702469,
0.012582886,
0.0285897069,
0.0454063825,
0.0035416088,
0.0211622752,
0.0412739925,
0.0553689152,
-0.0068196873,
0.0616609193,
-0.0181124434,
0.0169364084,
0.0694111064,
0.0275360849,
0.0307687055,
0.0339877754,
0.0157497916,
-0.0264128428,
0.0117828976,
0.0399182811,
0.0406222157,
-0.047913149,
-0.0181074981,
0.0436511189,
0.0480365716,
-0.0010145982,
0.017305132,
0.0441816524,
0.0605594553,
0.0047073592,
0.0611681007,
-0.0183343347,
0.0021779018,
-0.0188808963,
0.041374106,
0.0653700158,
0.0119551895,
-0.049059771,
0.0023134144,
0.0212159082,
-0.0146169737,
0.0190648716,
0.0167670287,
-0.0016579862,
0.0233600792,
-0.067560412,
0.0891912133,
-0.0011791384,
-0.0866018757,
-0.0001019189,
-0.0164250098,
-0.0248631369,
0.0650029853,
0.0316055566,
-0.0408738293,
-0.0106480969,
-0.0517908707,
0.0080453651,
0.0321218893,
0.034404587,
-0.034922272,
0.0604538508,
-0.0497854054,
0.011978372,
-0.0180722773,
-0.0059802164,
0.0250055324,
-0.0065660332,
-0.0128015401,
0.0489018336,
0.0098434109,
-0.0066479705,
0.0165976547,
-0.0376503915,
-0.0243448317,
-0.0052586189,
-0.0086039575,
0.0203729495,
0.0109971566,
-0.0405501649,
-0.0200701728,
0.0156378802,
-0.0065968251,
0.0096710371,
0.0498677865,
-0.0903952643,
-0.07368128,
0.025426371,
-0.0425080769,
0.0053563798,
0.034623608,
-0.0400664136,
-0.0724955499,
0.0233279299,
-0.0269227643,
0.0247089583,
-0.0240875911,
0.0333006941,
0.0343286134,
0.0427654833,
-0.012420061,
0.0171040613,
0.0172537845,
-0.0330209956,
0.0229966398,
0.0147410091,
0.0207805131,
-0.0609666146,
-0.0006787871,
0.0153823532,
0.014359423,
0.0032091385,
0.0384542868,
-0.0096737724,
-0.0383390598,
-0.0250741728,
-0.1167286411,
-0.0093451794,
-0.0238317419,
-0.0321136229,
0.0301821269,
0.0302090328,
-0.0168272406,
-0.0066512059,
-0.0538979806,
-0.06875249,
0.0603873804,
-0.021725826,
-0.0131511716,
0.0315211006,
0.0105481427,
-0.0589341968,
-0.0171161909,
0.0207593124,
0.0755338147,
-0.035327699,
-0.0137801515,
-0.0154320346,
-0.0073247701,
-0.0056818514,
0.0222124904,
-0.0250050556,
-0.0087544713,
-0.0342966095,
0.0202932768,
0.0778015628,
0.0287535414,
0.0709912479,
-0.0076787332,
0.0014043188,
-0.0547932051,
-0.0132126091,
0.0257669035,
-0.0162062868,
0.0056565553,
-0.0233831201,
0.0027866608,
0.047204338,
0.0163838807,
0.0232215822,
0.0137768211,
-0.0443219319,
-0.0266548451,
0.0188948121,
-0.0391486622,
-0.0062509738,
-0.0469981059,
-0.0491006449,
0.0252913442,
-0.0347776636,
0.0056916638,
0.0583955981,
-0.0651540384,
-0.024237942,
-0.0333342776,
-0.0282693934,
-0.0615007728,
0.0290000904,
0.0223902296,
0.0226034131,
-0.014331121,
-0.0222012307,
-0.0300592463,
-0.0425932854,
0.0298795588,
-0.019895317,
0.0899794772,
-0.0245478973,
0.0058611957,
-0.0133321825,
-0.0067495452,
-0.0305817332,
-0.0642627627,
-0.0167239606,
0.0008892554,
0.053850472,
-0.0318373926,
-0.012095267,
0.0360744633,
0.0015792716,
0.0736318976,
-0.0248459503,
0.0279741585,
-0.0204802938,
0.0663239136,
0.0410359241,
-0.0226182248,
-0.0038286797,
-0.0484392755,
0.0697189718,
0.0048447698,
0.0271948408,
-0.021056015,
-0.00953505,
-0.0200860128,
-0.0100868903,
-0.0357073247,
0.0090930182,
-0.0092054093,
0.0709289536,
-0.0212203413,
0.0125490343,
0.1143788472,
0.0067510852,
-0.029183628,
-0.0096341716,
0.0076827016,
0.0386943743,
0.0068470552,
0.0121035473,
-0.085747458,
-0.0232288837,
0.0001626753,
0.0148485973,
0.0214597844,
-0.0308111347,
-0.0426092222,
-0.0790405571,
0.0215527043,
0.0288890712,
-0.0502328239,
0.0058399145,
0.0131318858,
0.0004589248,
-0.009864362,
0.0319883339,
0.0014793396,
-0.0157265477,
-0.0172337107,
0.0031889123,
-0.0704722404,
0.002076494,
0.0210615043,
-0.0140552726,
0.0263947025,
0.041417364,
0.0364487432,
0.0314575695,
0.0312813222,
0.0425952151,
-0.0428206772,
-0.0003047046,
0.0363597646,
0.0896304846,
-0.027151661,
-0.0199018493,
0.0069457679,
0.0529252626,
0.0320447944,
-0.0243544001,
0.0266867839,
-0.0218188446,
0.0035410996,
-0.0038992262,
-0.00135247,
0.0730866119,
0.0027474486,
0.0602443181,
0.0547025353,
-0.0346779972,
-0.0131162386,
-0.016595263,
0.0088627934,
-0.0610263981,
-0.0250202846,
-0.0222756304,
0.0023677864,
0.0209390633,
-0.061935164,
-0.0493938215,
0.0245353635,
-0.0297780186,
-0.0224289764,
-0.0115107885,
-0.0062246476,
0.0128264669,
-0.0114350002,
0.0170659702,
-0.0456602797,
0.0038338585,
-0.052135054,
-0.0220297966,
0.0666032434,
-0.017967999,
-0.0080069248,
0.0459101014,
-0.0976709351,
-0.0654854476,
0.0120904651,
0.0304329544,
0.0227430835,
0.101489678,
0.0153149655,
-0.0037517888,
0.0523856357,
-0.0045180526,
-0.0261993371,
0.0447001904,
0.0530896895,
0.0204907916,
-0.0443508402,
0.0112217506,
-0.0317848288,
0.0404365771,
-0.0340428278,
0.0074405675,
-0.0638972148,
-0.1182693094,
-0.0102770552,
0.0057822997,
0.0134853078,
-0.0002870427,
0.0161171313,
-0.0160638373,
-0.0074848183,
-0.0352739207,
-0.0113292011,
-0.0305776168,
0.0161349941,
-0.0249476507,
-0.0088491244,
0.0043214262,
0.0447555147,
-0.0626243725,
0.0162521824,
-0.0314156711,
-0.011224417,
-0.0208181571,
-0.0583412051,
-0.0043845926,
0.0168338045,
-0.0293761585,
0.0191005971,
-0.0197331216,
0.0027799881,
0.0008628832,
0.047192242,
0.0015559682,
-0.0143403923,
0.0178994033,
0.0431646258,
-0.0819397792,
0.0012401042,
-0.0243402105,
0.0071590655,
0.0301676225,
-0.0467221066,
0.0822641477,
0.0359138697,
0.0113340877,
-0.0125041176,
0.0443610065,
-0.0222019907,
-0.0196315534,
-0.0263219792,
0.0205515288,
-0.0025193193,
0.0556708686,
0.0806909204,
0.0075753224,
0.0229528695,
0.0276645105,
0.0204470307,
-0.0614471696,
-0.0528409518,
-0.0059996857,
0.0286774542,
-0.0022048785,
-0.0100107817,
-0.0145313293,
-0.0107838539,
0.0225524921,
-0.0226873308,
0.0081824893,
0.0052509597,
0.0504643582,
-0.0019290473,
0.0052450229,
0.0100044329,
-0.0068707792,
-0.0115108276,
0.0263750479,
0.0099504655,
0.0078864088,
-5.459984282e-33,
-0.0426626876,
0.0046598031,
0.0026255429,
0.0108350255,
-0.0640881732,
0.006040629,
-0.039646998,
0.0073380461,
0.0028415374,
0.0011692728,
-0.0267557316,
0.025189884,
0.006429181,
0.0587784313,
-0.0330612399,
-0.0218562931,
0.093682304,
0.0008374833,
-0.0196993239,
0.0654317215,
0.0119710742,
0.0299540423,
0.0281740911,
-0.064146176,
-0.0098437276,
-0.0519736446,
-0.0410444327,
-0.014162465,
0.0083912546,
0.0185847487,
-0.0151235526,
0.0000209038,
0.0025732671,
-0.0387776718,
-0.0795614198,
0.0089789322,
-0.0616920926,
0.0181287695,
0.0121083762,
0.0155951045,
-0.0211076308,
-0.0235989094,
0.0007602988,
-0.0254004002,
0.0335859098,
-0.0573204458,
0.0447754413,
-0.0488054678,
-0.0116691357,
-0.043806944,
-0.0315699279,
0.0275777932,
-0.0554161519,
-0.064810425,
0.0146924546,
0.0811731219,
0.0290961359,
-0.0133107156,
-0.070180051,
0.0572417714,
0.0363128595,
0.0107797096,
0.0232502371,
0.0500833653,
0.0022765233,
0.0655731931,
0.0149736451,
-0.0133588808,
0.0087363319,
-0.0098964013,
-0.0125499079,
0.0271866694,
-0.0051710093,
0.0336458385,
0.0174877476,
0.0010626155,
-0.0390417539,
0.020796651,
-0.0380022116,
-0.0060407016,
0.0117503749,
0.0071033253,
0.0340750702,
-0.0233784672,
-0.0311549976,
-0.0048926105,
0.0152899539,
-0.0164161902,
-0.0081710322,
0.0556933209,
-0.0239108745,
-0.0218946487,
0.0651123971,
-0.0232964288,
0.020000549,
0.0337870978,
-0.0597716346,
0.0030882508,
-0.0043573962,
0.0208916701,
-0.0193779357,
0.0045390395,
0.0941521823,
0.0235054232,
0.0091972221,
-0.0094998078,
0.0275804847,
0.0193515625,
-0.0538404211,
0.0248264968,
0.0413295776,
0.0531455427,
-0.051547125,
0.03316392,
-0.026391685,
0.0217697099,
-0.0145261474,
0.0967664495,
-0.0171676259,
-0.0043360149,
-0.0034823152,
-0.0089186709,
0.0410794467,
0.0532517806,
-0.0580374114,
0.035723418,
-0.0014444363,
-0.0017962571,
0.0792865455,
-0.0344787687,
-0.0113697946,
-0.0166381765,
2.361e-7,
0.0190331303,
0.0149319693,
0.0912275985,
-0.0020134374,
0.0165165495,
0.0283891894,
0.0057052611,
0.0188736059,
0.0353698991,
0.007285709,
0.0314688496,
0.0378309079,
0.0627585351,
-0.0030805347,
-0.0794247389,
-0.0601247624,
-0.0981622413,
-0.0356585272,
-0.0397330895,
-0.0404697433,
0.0471012071,
0.0756246299,
-0.0058947816,
0.0165505875,
-0.0092341173,
-0.0143887019,
0.0655498654,
-0.0235778391,
-0.0497049242,
0.0274359956,
0.0239951275,
-0.0040427237,
-0.0471526422,
-0.0046061962,
-0.0145488083,
0.0167999323,
0.0204423871,
0.0543474853,
0.0225665607,
-0.0271719713,
-0.0114666279,
0.0527093969,
-0.025832681,
0.0033222234,
0.0604768395,
-0.0663893074,
0.0005010063,
-0.0545773581,
-0.0589209795,
0.0142934183,
-0.0063937446,
-0.0278693419,
-0.01380534,
0.0527576059,
0.0162304975,
0.0181786567,
0.0175137483,
-0.1166314334,
-0.0497006625,
0.0170405172,
-0.0335336402,
-0.0110757845,
-0.0043831742,
-0.0492420085,
0.0184015483,
-0.0275158659,
0.0310565215,
2.157068409e-34,
0.0566525348,
0.0276407897,
-0.0159960929,
0.0056631803,
0.0251865201,
-0.0633929223,
0.0274854265,
-0.030513959,
0.0367090516,
-0.0660205856,
-0.0303790774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17588v1 | Local and Global Contexts for Conversation | 2024-01-31T04:19:22 | 2024-01-31T04:19:22 | Zuoquan Lin, Xinyi Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The context in conversation is the dialog history crucial for multi-turn
dialogue. Learning from the relevant contexts in dialog history for grounded
conversation is a challenging problem. Local context is the most neighbor and
more sensitive to the subsequent response, and global context is relevant to a
whole conversation far beyond neighboring utterances. Currently, pretrained
transformer models for conversation challenge capturing the correlation and
connection between local and global contexts. We introduce a local and global
conversation model (LGCM) for general-purpose conversation in open domain. It
is a local-global hierarchical transformer model that excels at accurately
discerning and assimilating the relevant contexts necessary for generating
responses. It employs a local encoder to grasp the local context at the level
of individual utterances and a global encoder to understand the broader context
at the dialogue level. The seamless fusion of these locally and globally
contextualized encodings ensures a comprehensive comprehension of the
conversation. Experiments on popular datasets show that LGCM outperforms the
existing conversation models on the performance of automatic metrics with
significant margins. | Local and Global Contexts for Conversation: The context in conversation is the dialog history crucial for multi-turn
dialogue. Learning from the relevant contexts in dialog history for grounded
conversation is a challenging problem. Local context is the most neighbor and
more sensitive to the subsequent response, and global context is relevant to a
whole conversation far beyond neighboring utterances. Currently, pretrained
transformer models for conversation challenge capturing the correlation and
connection between local and global contexts. We introduce a local and global
conversation model (LGCM) for general-purpose conversation in open domain. It
is a local-global hierarchical transformer model that excels at accurately
discerning and assimilating the relevant contexts necessary for generating
responses. It employs a local encoder to grasp the local context at the level
of individual utterances and a global encoder to understand the broader context
at the dialogue level. The seamless fusion of these locally and globally
contextualized encodings ensures a comprehensive comprehension of the
conversation. Experiments on popular datasets show that LGCM outperforms the
existing conversation models on the performance of automatic metrics with
significant margins. | [
0.0342047624,
0.0584462807,
-0.0064998656,
0.0450991653,
0.0026845895,
0.0010187571,
0.0254778583,
-0.012782434,
-0.0306166764,
-0.0433415733,
-0.0561948642,
-0.0330994278,
0.0108600436,
0.0588117093,
-0.0177185498,
-0.0615743175,
0.01484829,
-0.0028608884,
-0.0228105895,
0.0079451995,
-0.0198444426,
0.0019475602,
-0.0270163883,
0.0560676083,
-0.0048192693,
-0.0017486196,
-0.0372619592,
0.0241720844,
0.028745411,
0.0037330964,
0.0286317803,
0.0342143774,
0.0573706441,
0.0026588903,
0.0000018483,
-0.0097222999,
-0.0062957993,
-0.0608096942,
-0.0102771744,
-0.0450330153,
-0.0053545749,
-0.0178024061,
0.0028919927,
0.0191547014,
-0.0706408322,
-0.0132476976,
0.02182265,
0.0815703571,
0.0654597655,
0.0663752928,
-0.0260950159,
-0.0686895698,
0.0183407031,
-0.0252085589,
0.0060094707,
-0.0673420355,
0.0057006003,
0.0452620946,
-0.0445644446,
0.0188240297,
-0.0428629741,
-0.0011147549,
0.0330921486,
-0.0456869192,
0.024724381,
0.0262833163,
-0.0143374559,
-0.0077682436,
-0.0085038599,
0.1196738109,
-0.0027599309,
0.0078147361,
-0.0187654849,
-0.0079405587,
-0.0179391652,
-0.0476044603,
-0.0587948635,
0.0302656703,
0.0143694188,
0.0102976719,
-0.0419679582,
0.0626820549,
-0.03762329,
-0.0010028383,
-0.0523914024,
0.0465286672,
-0.0139390612,
-0.0102627128,
-0.0349339359,
0.0013482495,
0.0289652292,
-0.0591158569,
0.02465792,
0.0433008634,
-0.0458529517,
0.0110604921,
-0.0095903762,
0.0514264554,
-0.011056276,
-0.0257584024,
-0.0391743407,
0.0238629431,
-0.0245550331,
0.0505314469,
0.0136107076,
0.0529992692,
-0.0415392071,
-0.0054647881,
-0.0210338254,
-0.0405982286,
-0.0454033352,
0.0019970641,
-0.0411048792,
0.0057044621,
-0.112887539,
-0.0392920449,
-0.0224704836,
0.0430113226,
0.0090147108,
-0.0093683526,
0.011306393,
0.0286153201,
-0.0426366627,
0.000607165,
0.0058960845,
0.0629894361,
-0.0375385582,
0.0313146785,
0.0250588935,
-0.0553180166,
-0.0322536044,
0.0407060497,
0.0389460288,
-0.0350931957,
-0.0300155319,
0.0325222351,
-0.0139176482,
-0.0325396582,
0.0014582156,
-0.0020762023,
-0.0504825823,
-0.0395433158,
-0.0037686417,
-0.0014547321,
0.0459581874,
-0.0157023538,
-0.0042460025,
-0.0001252937,
-0.0041087153,
-0.0102690896,
-0.0073038717,
0.0179376975,
0.0350240357,
-0.0163737219,
0.0501368977,
0.0326986276,
0.0250272304,
0.0453701355,
0.029303398,
0.0271862429,
0.03963314,
-0.009708792,
0.0155678894,
0.0163586996,
0.0265080668,
-0.0114038493,
0.0006429969,
0.0304512642,
-0.0013322545,
0.0274970997,
0.0148466062,
0.021629544,
-0.0617735721,
-0.0175879933,
0.0530538186,
0.0467922948,
-0.0064713266,
0.0219212826,
0.0386857279,
0.0426586233,
-0.0332671106,
0.0160052981,
-0.0164336413,
0.0271712299,
-0.0011301129,
-0.0190116595,
0.0202084649,
0.0158733651,
-0.0579808913,
-0.0139494408,
0.0450970866,
-0.0274781063,
-0.005580599,
-0.0208475925,
0.0216337126,
0.0466387235,
-0.0710050091,
0.0685468167,
0.0012850247,
-0.0546567403,
-0.0158574246,
-0.0095392903,
0.0148963146,
0.0013427098,
0.033772219,
0.0253128596,
-0.0380232297,
-0.0642869696,
0.0079877274,
0.052992437,
-0.0078478977,
-0.0219561458,
0.0797746554,
-0.0477976575,
-0.0361903459,
-0.0317911468,
-0.0142545616,
0.011294201,
0.0099837808,
-0.0154044982,
0.0230930876,
-0.006232027,
0.0782273561,
-0.0074055744,
0.0021623122,
0.0111502241,
0.035043478,
0.0027818866,
0.0257156659,
0.0214002747,
-0.0081990073,
-0.0301634315,
0.0372714251,
-0.0052310769,
-0.0309623834,
0.0440009497,
-0.1045555994,
-0.0652124882,
-0.0057346537,
-0.0383083932,
-0.0111256493,
-0.0075304909,
-0.0242219064,
-0.0520522334,
0.0114570213,
-0.0140788155,
0.0641949698,
-0.0339686871,
-0.0029289203,
0.0047488068,
0.0311432201,
-0.011495051,
0.0544212013,
-0.0000234103,
-0.0139795765,
0.0211760774,
0.0352920294,
0.0225777775,
-0.0427005291,
0.0083345538,
-0.0120752594,
-0.0278724544,
-0.0257431548,
0.0268271659,
0.0288691018,
-0.061595466,
-0.038147714,
-0.1206480414,
-0.014447622,
-0.0173404124,
-0.033682134,
0.0284991283,
0.0371248052,
0.004761864,
-0.0371602923,
-0.0413206518,
0.0100407731,
0.0290334839,
0.0029449298,
0.0492062159,
0.0129535105,
-0.0096862968,
-0.0347987227,
0.0159065966,
0.0345114432,
0.0741391256,
-0.0094578061,
-0.0107617993,
-0.0193156544,
-0.0023482204,
-0.0243928302,
0.0399907939,
-0.0380317792,
-0.0355336741,
0.0113003729,
0.0116153415,
0.0393228792,
0.0576740503,
0.0622806177,
0.0455976874,
-0.0168188512,
-0.0343963988,
-0.03612056,
0.0139836827,
-0.044233989,
-0.0290741771,
-0.0406093709,
0.0241692569,
0.0077566579,
0.0599843338,
0.0152780544,
0.0295442026,
-0.0342586562,
-0.020182481,
0.0294147469,
-0.0215481799,
-0.0406128205,
-0.0239177868,
-0.0209647287,
0.0613674261,
-0.0247078165,
-0.0326243825,
0.0424559154,
-0.0239374097,
-0.0334011614,
-0.0160057154,
-0.0014858729,
-0.0329970978,
0.0440381989,
-0.0219640974,
0.0146838306,
-0.0026085537,
-0.058782693,
-0.0266838558,
-0.0106672393,
0.0096236346,
-0.0089100767,
0.0514893718,
-0.0254701115,
-0.0072706635,
0.0065468298,
-0.045986861,
-0.0670464486,
-0.0293008443,
-0.0119543318,
-0.0083480431,
0.0034679424,
-0.0270918962,
-0.0550036617,
0.0083026858,
0.0038539954,
0.0437305011,
-0.0171449203,
0.0106116198,
-0.017956594,
0.0620412417,
0.0345358141,
0.044969935,
-0.0113302935,
-0.0014441172,
0.0656457692,
0.0325377993,
0.001346344,
-0.0189691912,
-0.0295409728,
-0.0007463962,
-0.001742264,
0.0353976935,
-0.0023201399,
0.0025785032,
0.0698380619,
-0.0020066656,
-0.0488205887,
0.1166281402,
0.0247479212,
-0.0605151244,
-0.0194685534,
-0.0214152504,
-0.022434691,
-0.0012403327,
0.0051057846,
-0.0947034657,
-0.028329527,
-0.0241285376,
-0.0449652262,
0.0335320197,
-0.0239839982,
0.0141216917,
-0.0796667486,
0.0007352456,
0.000591005,
-0.0605598278,
-0.0345866941,
0.013603298,
-0.0016649668,
-0.0114301145,
0.0375409499,
-0.0106144454,
0.0144980215,
-0.0464780815,
-0.0196394976,
-0.0043611689,
-0.0404839739,
0.0404095985,
0.0102536678,
0.0256472975,
0.032156568,
0.0415363163,
0.0478096493,
-0.0029789645,
0.0285763983,
0.0026261893,
0.0136294439,
0.0007519946,
0.0466234609,
-0.0303224754,
0.006010517,
-0.0048210528,
0.014004074,
-0.0312034637,
-0.0337618589,
-0.0048375488,
0.0106392428,
-0.0432349592,
0.0281721093,
0.0129790101,
0.0511379056,
0.039813187,
0.0586298257,
0.0256158691,
-0.0010032081,
-0.0080048908,
-0.0172010642,
0.0121578705,
-0.0150204143,
0.0000892053,
-0.0068821553,
0.0435768776,
0.006618937,
-0.0505117811,
-0.0326795727,
0.0021756433,
0.0178927258,
-0.0219741315,
-0.0456063487,
0.0060661444,
0.0041490658,
-0.0237224028,
0.0286888201,
-0.0479389876,
-0.0032410331,
-0.028364528,
-0.0004171062,
0.0814733952,
-0.0113058724,
-0.0298156999,
0.0342308544,
-0.0622701049,
-0.0123182638,
-0.0355446637,
0.0380757339,
0.0206387434,
0.0593593344,
-0.0032287342,
0.0057437308,
0.0106831994,
-0.0433624983,
-0.0465397239,
0.0104346965,
0.0542281382,
0.0442379527,
-0.0135551095,
0.0328116082,
-0.0390753411,
0.0549490266,
0.0106440773,
0.0281226635,
-0.0468262173,
-0.0971620083,
-0.0077044345,
-0.0934491307,
0.0757164061,
0.0289449487,
-0.020209983,
-0.0076769507,
0.0431773774,
-0.0325779505,
0.0143988021,
-0.0645913333,
-0.002785207,
0.0115752481,
-0.0064916369,
0.0221707933,
-0.0011681963,
-0.0649723783,
0.0525252931,
-0.0262201652,
-0.0126781119,
0.0221542083,
-0.0088989567,
-0.0120342579,
0.0232474655,
-0.0336226709,
-0.0026325306,
0.0428753644,
0.0301879663,
0.0212885514,
0.11574018,
0.0101161022,
-0.0119600492,
0.0145143559,
0.027471561,
-0.0831057429,
0.0244067814,
-0.0378551111,
0.0021167013,
0.0399152823,
-0.0071097361,
0.0256437063,
0.0363909602,
0.0295746624,
0.0009786086,
0.0946127474,
-0.0255672671,
-0.0792466849,
0.0404030867,
-0.0101680225,
-0.0159658529,
0.0530617312,
0.0561905056,
-0.0315736495,
0.0097989021,
0.0116590653,
0.039834138,
-0.047656659,
-0.0152375121,
0.0126362517,
0.0223760866,
0.0112141976,
0.0398225114,
-0.022536464,
-0.0253496859,
0.0078315949,
-0.0193317626,
-0.0098518254,
0.0330220461,
0.0640046,
0.0277080704,
0.0011309148,
-0.0178685077,
-0.0266530067,
0.0157602113,
0.0170971826,
-0.0106367078,
-0.0466158465,
-5.9003792e-33,
-0.033941403,
-0.036687322,
0.0027167455,
0.0184949525,
-0.05346011,
0.0007284775,
-0.0561996736,
0.0044769342,
-0.0306140725,
0.0087554362,
-0.0078774588,
0.0554746948,
0.0067838659,
0.0738660842,
-0.0267616082,
-0.0398291573,
0.0530169904,
0.0137712955,
-0.0003136266,
0.0536719672,
0.0212701391,
0.0140554328,
0.0729553849,
-0.092464298,
-0.0167068839,
-0.0087811332,
-0.0174345113,
0.0327540673,
0.0505351648,
0.048460044,
-0.0346881375,
0.0204357281,
0.0093573127,
-0.0506870672,
-0.01113779,
0.0473930463,
-0.0523055382,
-0.0079725347,
-0.0092594447,
0.0133336047,
-0.0119072767,
-0.0025610107,
-0.0157849509,
-0.0040967711,
0.0318184122,
-0.0426481925,
0.0189233385,
-0.0074518616,
-0.0237706732,
-0.0160426516,
-0.0396823101,
0.0107750706,
-0.029893728,
-0.0488253459,
-0.0350093991,
0.0611880198,
0.0311244782,
-0.0016880115,
-0.0125007834,
0.0357060544,
-0.0037543471,
-0.0112780351,
0.0163218118,
-0.016673509,
0.0059648152,
0.0680078119,
-0.0068676472,
0.0024285631,
-0.0432226174,
-0.0539606586,
-0.0214211941,
0.0316087641,
-0.0027459918,
0.0683989972,
-0.0175952949,
0.0128771858,
-0.0700068325,
0.0240686871,
0.0014378894,
0.0530950464,
-0.012915127,
0.0208706111,
0.0322524086,
-0.0059605613,
-0.0059420136,
-0.0030301646,
-0.0061671077,
-0.0168739073,
0.0170839727,
0.0272690151,
0.0078677824,
0.0112584643,
0.0663001761,
-0.0807777569,
0.0212531518,
0.0793022141,
-0.0094575221,
-0.0069892327,
-0.0042520259,
0.0273334663,
-0.0096539753,
-0.034373235,
0.0714046657,
0.0202776436,
0.0081828665,
0.0210010204,
0.0115967896,
0.0074436422,
-0.0522681437,
-0.0112023363,
-0.0135559831,
0.0083702188,
-0.0681893453,
0.0433115102,
-0.0046037082,
0.0304083079,
-0.0428970531,
0.1242857575,
-0.0349715576,
0.0175307281,
-0.0356938764,
-0.0445192009,
0.0439364128,
0.0481298305,
-0.0456057861,
-0.0134839211,
-0.0093045579,
-0.0169358682,
0.0609826297,
-0.0343826339,
-0.0152783282,
-0.0143212872,
2.505e-7,
0.0023073228,
0.0209418628,
0.0668504313,
-0.0396147557,
0.037931744,
0.0350982584,
0.0118519356,
0.016834626,
0.0286451075,
-0.0248936545,
0.0379536673,
0.0035509856,
0.059528742,
-0.0002274705,
-0.0822671354,
-0.0101629915,
-0.0973797664,
-0.053539902,
-0.015439284,
-0.0110474098,
0.0504862368,
0.0769425556,
-0.013851935,
0.0086843548,
-0.0165426899,
0.0060474151,
0.0794540867,
-0.0521044098,
-0.0116141513,
0.0133777941,
-0.0346465632,
-0.0069586053,
0.0030852377,
0.0064297616,
-0.0153302681,
0.0454989076,
0.0056598443,
0.0701511279,
-0.0062322901,
-0.0917794406,
-0.0069206343,
0.0155554507,
0.005668716,
-0.0527891591,
0.0338046663,
-0.1003559902,
-0.017861031,
0.0006351571,
-0.0340664051,
0.0183445029,
0.0213226136,
-0.0054778541,
-0.0202257875,
0.0141149471,
0.0293415748,
0.026658209,
0.0282454509,
-0.1137052253,
0.0234775785,
-0.0132187949,
-0.0592117049,
-0.0233983528,
0.0094545102,
-0.0606785603,
0.0335222371,
0.0438164324,
0.0247642361,
1.898319947e-34,
0.0129789496,
0.0014978372,
0.0013750879,
0.0550686307,
0.0248499047,
-0.0291318465,
-0.0130938143,
-0.0226673298,
0.0409943648,
-0.068950735,
-0.0081122918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17585v1 | Propagation and Pitfalls: Reasoning-based Assessment of Knowledge Editing through Counterfactual Tasks | 2024-01-31T04:12:59 | 2024-01-31T04:12:59 | Wenyue Hua, Jiang Guo, Mingwen Dong, Henghui Zhu, Patrick Ng, Zhiguo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME | Current approaches of knowledge editing struggle to effectively propagate
updates to interconnected facts. In this work, we delve into the barriers that
hinder the appropriate propagation of updated knowledge within these models for
accurate reasoning. To support our analysis, we introduce a novel
reasoning-based benchmark -- ReCoE (Reasoning-based Counterfactual Editing
dataset) -- which covers six common reasoning schemes in real world. We conduct
a thorough analysis of existing knowledge editing techniques, including input
augmentation, finetuning, and locate-and-edit. We found that all model editing
methods show notably low performance on this dataset, especially in certain
reasoning schemes. Our analysis over the chain-of-thought generation of edited
models further uncover key reasons behind the inadequacy of existing knowledge
editing methods from a reasoning standpoint, involving aspects on fact-wise
editing, fact recall ability, and coherence in generation. We will make our
benchmark publicly available. | Propagation and Pitfalls: Reasoning-based Assessment of Knowledge Editing through Counterfactual Tasks: Current approaches of knowledge editing struggle to effectively propagate
updates to interconnected facts. In this work, we delve into the barriers that
hinder the appropriate propagation of updated knowledge within these models for
accurate reasoning. To support our analysis, we introduce a novel
reasoning-based benchmark -- ReCoE (Reasoning-based Counterfactual Editing
dataset) -- which covers six common reasoning schemes in real world. We conduct
a thorough analysis of existing knowledge editing techniques, including input
augmentation, finetuning, and locate-and-edit. We found that all model editing
methods show notably low performance on this dataset, especially in certain
reasoning schemes. Our analysis over the chain-of-thought generation of edited
models further uncover key reasons behind the inadequacy of existing knowledge
editing methods from a reasoning standpoint, involving aspects on fact-wise
editing, fact recall ability, and coherence in generation. We will make our
benchmark publicly available. | [
0.0433050804,
0.0003691799,
-0.0133890454,
0.0230024066,
-0.0629019067,
-0.0099479062,
0.0104567176,
-0.0362752974,
-0.0109796021,
-0.0463022031,
-0.0040269974,
-0.0008856298,
0.0177697316,
0.0435608178,
0.0244337637,
-0.0567383729,
0.0709470138,
-0.0199790001,
0.0134937605,
0.0021698063,
-0.0190201234,
-0.0324385501,
-0.0275062546,
0.0009640245,
-0.0277349688,
-0.0659992322,
-0.0439265259,
0.0281184297,
0.0634242222,
0.0107943593,
-0.0212182235,
0.0505330414,
-0.0137509629,
0.0328565426,
0.0000023399,
-0.0294345059,
-0.046939671,
0.0194854587,
-0.0770176798,
0.002846536,
-0.0427625068,
0.0174544565,
-0.0285955258,
0.0091146287,
-0.0208572783,
0.0602296926,
0.0374710821,
0.0433293805,
0.0934809148,
0.0991926417,
0.0071717286,
-0.0013310454,
0.0200208332,
-0.0264440179,
0.0152523266,
-0.0185591504,
0.0313831344,
0.0461140536,
-0.0262973048,
0.0299424697,
-0.029847879,
0.0390778705,
0.0337760709,
-0.0335901044,
0.0124045787,
0.0102886194,
0.0004567503,
0.0009699889,
0.0109034255,
0.0317926295,
0.041161079,
0.0025219892,
-0.022823764,
-0.0101991883,
0.0389785133,
0.0166791882,
-0.0175038055,
-0.0115131224,
-0.0138754155,
-0.037148159,
-0.0271153413,
-0.060374774,
0.0353610851,
-0.0032903517,
0.0073155304,
0.0557765141,
0.0096300794,
-0.0482613742,
-0.042625919,
-0.0216640551,
-0.0214802064,
-0.0882254988,
0.0179728568,
0.0059567383,
-0.0326214023,
-0.0001473036,
-0.0354978442,
0.0092803081,
0.0034493809,
-0.0339121856,
0.0266753398,
0.0449162871,
-0.0134276077,
0.0556049496,
-0.017409198,
0.0188970417,
-0.0198837947,
0.0311071053,
-0.003123244,
0.0290441234,
-0.0636848733,
-0.0351976342,
-0.028045686,
0.0476411097,
-0.0594562665,
0.0347321555,
-0.0304805934,
-0.0060358336,
-0.0739462599,
0.0417310968,
0.0096104722,
0.0191265568,
-0.0175808668,
-0.0379942954,
-0.0412948355,
0.0244247857,
-0.0367055573,
0.0357677117,
0.036381457,
0.0058354852,
-0.0094830459,
-0.0577800125,
0.007411187,
-0.0162176881,
-0.008657218,
0.045023784,
-0.0211800132,
0.0056715342,
-0.0580140874,
-0.0889270231,
0.0029888519,
-0.0829399005,
-0.0168597773,
-0.0611443035,
0.0155301811,
-0.0244508926,
-0.0414594524,
-0.0659145042,
0.0011322196,
0.0084504867,
-0.0213180538,
0.0786064342,
-0.0395169295,
-0.0024641075,
0.0404012948,
0.0280027129,
-0.0541592501,
0.0533392057,
0.0320341699,
-0.0086335279,
0.0458521657,
0.024242742,
0.0053840578,
-0.0162921157,
0.042457737,
-0.0241435841,
0.0008932891,
0.0281946398,
-0.0166814625,
0.0514432564,
-0.0064475508,
0.0061050761,
-0.0349315926,
-0.0057804557,
0.0787398666,
-0.0427888595,
0.0189011209,
0.0154662933,
0.0038498749,
-0.0318917185,
-0.0046770717,
0.0128875719,
-0.0527117662,
0.0630585775,
-0.039160952,
0.0253868699,
0.0014353148,
0.0085386271,
0.002883492,
-0.0480702445,
-0.00084641,
0.047531981,
0.0091519766,
-0.0050064647,
0.0284563079,
0.0330214053,
-0.0185282677,
0.0022561394,
-0.0020902932,
-0.0390448421,
-0.008429558,
-0.0320017673,
-0.0363386162,
0.0857129171,
0.0738498122,
-0.0592454448,
-0.0868088901,
-0.0343402475,
0.0012142966,
0.0008712625,
0.0492773354,
-0.0142673999,
-0.0258144122,
-0.0070724287,
-0.0376896076,
-0.0521415025,
0.0352114998,
-0.0061585279,
0.0378920212,
-0.0097739045,
0.0183555465,
-0.0107776364,
0.0322725959,
0.0022128078,
-0.0427153744,
0.0295357741,
-0.0315123834,
0.0303560104,
-0.0309416987,
0.0246813819,
-0.0171122905,
0.0101677757,
0.0023333824,
0.0246571302,
-0.0310888588,
0.0244202875,
0.0067739398,
-0.0490561016,
0.0571757592,
-0.0293100402,
-0.0548431352,
0.0275297202,
-0.031109333,
-0.0203469079,
0.0285684541,
-0.0148228975,
0.0337891988,
-0.0264981445,
0.0407732241,
0.0084251594,
-0.0729263797,
0.0285732821,
0.0622700229,
-0.0144197401,
-0.027501341,
0.0033685802,
-0.0089645218,
0.0081876228,
-0.0579359531,
0.0241777897,
-0.0087644821,
0.0018183492,
-0.0324970149,
-0.0220265407,
-0.0242751464,
-0.0502785072,
-0.0004095517,
-0.0533757433,
-0.0007416244,
-0.0285665579,
-0.0090443157,
0.0416774042,
0.0053190901,
0.0025811505,
0.000634322,
0.022950083,
0.0029370068,
-0.0357045121,
0.0456053689,
0.0158021078,
0.0157939959,
0.0246948563,
-0.0234518945,
0.0070338384,
-0.0234968588,
0.0216492135,
0.0115144104,
0.0048784208,
-0.0345456749,
0.0193340871,
-0.0791337863,
0.0016926787,
0.0053752605,
-0.0165484007,
0.0109574767,
0.0301039089,
0.0575877689,
0.0507575087,
-0.0102042304,
0.0030627807,
0.0479531214,
-0.0331293382,
-0.0094836578,
0.0423211195,
0.008628644,
0.0184751078,
0.0052669989,
-0.0183519796,
-0.0425885506,
0.0271416511,
0.0025608435,
-0.0358256735,
-0.0403810404,
0.053394381,
-0.0004605831,
-0.0341325104,
-0.0516270772,
-0.0354569405,
-0.0077028563,
0.0397223309,
-0.0652628392,
0.0032474452,
0.0960054472,
0.0042726258,
0.0386865027,
-0.0162519533,
0.0318228938,
0.0217694603,
0.0720908493,
-0.0055743479,
0.0311517715,
-0.0189367551,
0.0346446298,
-0.0554277487,
-0.0263093561,
0.0688611493,
-0.0266678426,
0.0111571737,
-0.0805301443,
-0.0100780129,
0.0157852322,
-0.0315909199,
-0.040659301,
-0.001239344,
0.0090017049,
0.0109278671,
0.0029111241,
-0.0425842553,
-0.0179678891,
-0.0056520021,
0.0440376103,
0.0820449442,
0.0021505961,
-0.0256262347,
-0.0150319478,
-0.0240628682,
0.0449111983,
0.0288151708,
0.0478006676,
-0.0040901033,
0.0283574555,
0.0550912805,
0.0239692274,
-0.0811830014,
0.0121188248,
0.0043483442,
-0.0681523383,
-0.0708680302,
-0.0024845072,
-0.0187433381,
0.0550495759,
-0.0700732246,
-0.0369520076,
0.062187504,
0.0549163111,
0.0362623073,
0.0156683847,
-0.0601107962,
-0.0072003128,
0.0622634366,
0.030432323,
-0.0714090392,
-0.0236515757,
0.0572556667,
0.0164189152,
-0.0346242785,
-0.073656626,
-0.0216336492,
-0.0887688994,
0.0481943898,
-0.0155978044,
0.0092778476,
-0.0653826147,
-0.0214169975,
0.0169556234,
0.0130313663,
-0.0601653606,
0.0618538372,
0.0324413106,
0.0106139043,
-0.0276434198,
0.0017880156,
-0.0296084955,
0.0151321515,
-0.0137396632,
0.02533946,
0.0452715084,
0.0172042307,
0.0425834879,
-0.0119815459,
0.0338197723,
0.0347196572,
0.0289870501,
-0.0132599343,
0.0530565903,
-0.0133560831,
0.0208536666,
-0.0023869278,
0.0238817204,
0.0344998576,
-0.0697558075,
0.0265306458,
0.1136925742,
-0.0242056325,
0.021872608,
-0.0126574449,
-0.0070337853,
0.0141285332,
0.0652068108,
0.0298087802,
0.0126693882,
0.0064133983,
-0.0501481108,
-0.0064214184,
-0.0237304065,
0.0126480665,
-0.0238781963,
0.0229489151,
0.0292279217,
-0.0768717378,
-0.0508162975,
0.0331137665,
0.0515413955,
0.0167993475,
-0.005926474,
0.0285023674,
0.0006857871,
-0.0488462374,
-0.0291912574,
-0.0256883968,
0.022857137,
0.0101014422,
-0.0072129183,
-0.0194734689,
-0.0448544882,
-0.0302993581,
-0.0274264906,
-0.0375245847,
-0.0419963114,
0.0156023512,
0.0489607975,
0.0355529785,
0.0596149452,
-0.0008433405,
-0.0228085034,
-0.009388458,
0.0090228077,
-0.0362718105,
0.0333043709,
0.0386311151,
-0.0282053687,
-0.0001833477,
0.0415804423,
-0.0380623303,
-0.0344516411,
0.0349001139,
0.0495373644,
-0.0381635912,
-0.0070796008,
0.0188256688,
0.0056690639,
0.0289602708,
0.0262103304,
-0.0119314017,
-0.055352252,
0.0777709186,
-0.0606060885,
-0.0281207152,
-0.0107482364,
0.0181030706,
-0.0010467058,
-0.00150566,
0.0001379656,
0.0155805023,
-0.0054678065,
-0.0004110673,
0.0102655012,
-0.0208854359,
0.0191617385,
0.0195598397,
0.0393010527,
-0.0006374636,
-0.0075061424,
0.0136118075,
-0.0130014019,
0.0374148637,
-0.02487983,
0.0400638655,
0.0396580137,
-0.0237657502,
-0.059816923,
-0.001475736,
-0.1026603803,
-0.0318528377,
-0.0170306712,
0.0489746109,
0.0354944542,
0.0102426615,
0.0030215608,
-0.0423094705,
-0.0378048085,
0.0041413628,
0.0383505598,
0.0359130315,
-0.0336573534,
-0.0009773962,
0.0165764578,
0.0024169455,
0.0247937758,
0.044946868,
-0.0793539062,
0.1156258285,
-0.0462472737,
-0.057937149,
-0.0431778952,
-0.0675216839,
-0.0348425247,
0.018500803,
0.0008122494,
-0.0183518995,
-0.0960245058,
-0.0505012199,
0.0001392475,
0.0412913077,
-0.0084972633,
0.015066715,
0.0039967666,
0.0484184027,
0.0095376903,
-0.0445659161,
-0.0118449936,
0.0110878386,
-0.033571016,
0.0134829003,
-0.0026754856,
-6.283439748e-33,
-0.0413897783,
-0.0083450014,
0.050374072,
-0.0175414495,
-0.0242537241,
-0.0205736551,
-0.0469314121,
0.0066243843,
-0.0046306234,
0.0404561907,
-0.0233642254,
0.0342888162,
-0.0022014678,
0.0018115597,
-0.0181305613,
0.0135619463,
0.0827937871,
0.0245921239,
-0.0475854762,
0.0046479576,
0.0474250764,
0.0187319145,
0.0575412549,
-0.0667366982,
0.041970741,
0.0297709443,
-0.0067500724,
0.0469280072,
-0.0896667987,
0.0230896641,
0.0210574176,
-0.0045161508,
0.0093233911,
-0.0484122932,
-0.0097525492,
-0.0653320551,
-0.0379914232,
-0.0156326815,
0.0155742997,
0.0139190201,
-0.0256945472,
-0.0455753952,
0.0427835062,
0.0328148045,
-0.0161437225,
-0.0443401188,
0.012092825,
-0.0338385887,
0.0276122149,
0.0319305472,
-0.0741839856,
0.0071826475,
-0.0201574974,
-0.0503449067,
-0.0299970675,
0.0115017267,
0.0234710313,
-0.0615087152,
-0.1249385774,
0.0038107666,
0.0576957129,
0.0230336711,
0.0721403509,
-0.0138512282,
0.0022097989,
0.0481141619,
-0.0004574293,
0.053775508,
-0.0201195311,
0.0214266088,
-0.0349763483,
0.0645703152,
0.0428496525,
0.0908479393,
0.0376872085,
-0.0076271626,
-0.0582393818,
-0.0051142415,
-0.0926014856,
0.0451383665,
0.0010097047,
0.0158449486,
-0.0133282198,
0.019949412,
-0.0640149117,
0.0110410936,
-0.026829645,
-0.0217990279,
0.0251298547,
0.0254347529,
-0.0257696398,
0.0192581341,
-0.0132280877,
0.004068573,
0.0113072097,
0.0392014086,
-0.0141444625,
0.0399797857,
0.0033091358,
-0.0082644615,
-0.0446906425,
0.0532163121,
0.0471214354,
0.0310763996,
0.0154657885,
-0.0106259212,
0.056679368,
0.027439218,
-0.0421846397,
0.010961323,
-0.0339442082,
0.0479885861,
-0.0013086732,
-0.0442692973,
0.0211583003,
0.007683035,
-0.0062000896,
0.0027313775,
0.0440629534,
0.0226156935,
-0.0355708599,
0.043930538,
0.0028633683,
0.0077248882,
0.0145081533,
0.023412887,
-0.0067725852,
0.0102677513,
-0.0033356424,
-0.045546189,
-0.0150960824,
0.0372672118,
2.976e-7,
0.0293699652,
0.0429515168,
0.0372855961,
0.0103553636,
0.0413943008,
0.057772588,
-0.0405119173,
-0.0234395377,
0.045519691,
-0.0185845643,
0.0091129113,
0.0526946783,
0.0150552941,
0.0324182622,
-0.0055375323,
-0.0152214197,
-0.0288731661,
-0.0284901895,
-0.0407813229,
-0.0321154967,
0.0630555823,
0.000095365,
0.0445684083,
-0.0067571998,
0.0121421507,
-0.0167979673,
0.0580473319,
-0.00159519,
0.0071880319,
-0.0161162969,
0.0421275869,
0.0045912913,
0.0020998926,
0.0477850586,
-0.0190488547,
-0.0146483779,
-0.0491522886,
0.0139575815,
-0.0352942124,
0.0086048432,
-0.0418795235,
-0.0068154875,
0.0027830631,
-0.0378181078,
0.0711491033,
-0.0323728658,
0.0023541145,
0.0058027725,
-0.0230992846,
0.0272079166,
-0.0140116783,
-0.0068517034,
-0.0091643622,
-0.0170748197,
-0.0105149103,
0.0436555222,
-0.0116730947,
-0.0337696038,
-0.0515369512,
0.0470496789,
-0.0111837704,
-0.058852233,
-0.0274779759,
-0.0128332609,
0.0338628441,
-0.0736208409,
-0.0194518864,
2.548984883e-34,
0.0065587997,
0.0215805266,
0.0273996908,
-0.0069642263,
0.046887558,
-0.0266882721,
-0.0128013501,
-0.0335355625,
-0.0135482587,
-0.0319686644,
-0.030833127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17574v1 | Scavenging Hyena: Distilling Transformers into Long Convolution Models | 2024-01-31T03:39:07 | 2024-01-31T03:39:07 | Tokiniaina Raharison Ralambomihanta, Shahrad Mohammadzadeh, Mohammad Sami Nur Islam, Wassim Jabbour, Laurence Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs), epitomized by
architectures like GPT-4, has reshaped the landscape of natural language
processing. This paper introduces a pioneering approach to address the
efficiency concerns associated with LLM pre-training, proposing the use of
knowledge distillation for cross-architecture transfer. Leveraging insights
from the efficient Hyena mechanism, our method replaces attention heads in
transformer models by Hyena, offering a cost-effective alternative to
traditional pre-training while confronting the challenge of processing long
contextual information, inherent in quadratic attention mechanisms. Unlike
conventional compression-focused methods, our technique not only enhances
inference speed but also surpasses pre-training in terms of both accuracy and
efficiency. In the era of evolving LLMs, our work contributes to the pursuit of
sustainable AI solutions, striking a balance between computational power and
environmental impact. | Scavenging Hyena: Distilling Transformers into Long Convolution Models: The rapid evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs), epitomized by
architectures like GPT-4, has reshaped the landscape of natural language
processing. This paper introduces a pioneering approach to address the
efficiency concerns associated with LLM pre-training, proposing the use of
knowledge distillation for cross-architecture transfer. Leveraging insights
from the efficient Hyena mechanism, our method replaces attention heads in
transformer models by Hyena, offering a cost-effective alternative to
traditional pre-training while confronting the challenge of processing long
contextual information, inherent in quadratic attention mechanisms. Unlike
conventional compression-focused methods, our technique not only enhances
inference speed but also surpasses pre-training in terms of both accuracy and
efficiency. In the era of evolving LLMs, our work contributes to the pursuit of
sustainable AI solutions, striking a balance between computational power and
environmental impact. | [
0.0253377017,
0.0928209201,
-0.0047948691,
0.0669889301,
-0.0237984955,
0.0179625005,
-0.036765784,
-0.0131092081,
-0.022191545,
-0.0346577689,
-0.0568320751,
-0.0174311642,
-0.0152867157,
-0.0052002533,
0.0130234547,
-0.0324388929,
0.0408284068,
-0.0199486092,
-0.0433190838,
0.0100091873,
-0.0214596055,
-0.0030762278,
0.046063982,
0.0265133791,
0.0000511525,
-0.0184246134,
-0.0197747592,
0.0000229939,
0.0224888884,
-0.0067200125,
0.0005251833,
0.0468201227,
0.0031093138,
0.0546272621,
0.0000022401,
-0.0132371895,
-0.0067401486,
-0.0002857691,
-0.0209479593,
0.034708079,
0.0433862545,
-0.0131094242,
0.0039896574,
-0.0103720082,
-0.026773138,
-0.0436847284,
0.046621751,
0.0463672541,
0.0678031519,
0.0642845258,
-0.0078292675,
-0.0733206868,
0.0314366259,
-0.0653000101,
-0.0148342485,
-0.0820047706,
0.0311628319,
-0.047279533,
-0.0332246162,
0.0091346866,
-0.0461077839,
0.0610808693,
0.0353025161,
0.0379019491,
0.0055227019,
0.0251388606,
-0.0646146163,
-0.0089234244,
-0.0241901465,
0.07545311,
-0.0586977415,
-0.0233771186,
-0.0144404536,
0.0162175521,
-0.0252982266,
-0.0411410965,
-0.0595858432,
0.0225920621,
0.0171881039,
0.0211008042,
0.0174952913,
-0.0056378469,
0.0261398237,
0.0017598748,
-0.0505116843,
0.0402303673,
0.0207613967,
-0.0175929535,
0.0259410925,
0.010498547,
-0.0396373868,
-0.0440610796,
-0.0014852211,
0.0462868512,
0.0148701649,
0.0100263618,
-0.0436514094,
-0.0070618293,
-0.0057027387,
-0.0234587938,
0.0072022597,
0.0343530141,
-0.0168911181,
0.0429727472,
-0.0371764787,
0.0153106898,
-0.0852812827,
0.0089573106,
-0.0447269231,
-0.026136972,
-0.0421080887,
-0.0029476318,
-0.0625733584,
0.0113433301,
-0.0372833386,
-0.0275806766,
-0.0060460325,
0.013064241,
-0.0053980737,
-0.059539929,
0.0235435013,
0.0200293418,
-0.0304241963,
-0.0163200255,
0.001707221,
0.076176025,
-0.0200423282,
-0.001531248,
-0.004703932,
-0.0691493452,
-0.0343542621,
0.027481189,
0.0101164822,
-0.0379935205,
0.0006208323,
0.0824239627,
-0.0211301148,
-0.0560388006,
-0.0373075493,
0.0146464854,
-0.0145064564,
-0.0817296207,
0.0333881788,
-0.0299317781,
0.0224173684,
-0.0393822156,
0.022712294,
-0.0088319238,
0.0082771564,
0.0051484047,
-0.060522601,
0.0652020127,
-0.0080169905,
0.0126157682,
-0.0122823138,
0.008558061,
-0.0072379028,
0.0802244842,
0.0401056409,
0.032698974,
-0.0144641697,
-0.0260979943,
0.0066238069,
0.0466494188,
0.0153851202,
0.0174482986,
-0.0135219814,
-0.0095721679,
-0.0437895022,
-0.0168569945,
0.0492597707,
0.0683381781,
-0.0299276821,
0.0207380764,
0.0558093153,
0.0461802855,
0.0449414998,
0.0521043837,
0.0324906893,
-0.0088787172,
-0.0266018733,
0.0004126538,
-0.0747746751,
0.0307047274,
0.0063073328,
-0.0066784672,
-0.0036715462,
0.0626843125,
-0.0136725456,
-0.0179219879,
0.0205326043,
-0.0065139462,
0.0101525979,
0.0089498097,
0.0100705959,
0.0196130313,
-0.0278730262,
0.0670315474,
0.030968694,
-0.0494886264,
-0.0059208912,
-0.0576266386,
0.0238060504,
0.03738809,
0.0219516251,
-0.0063014226,
-0.0070463591,
-0.005587399,
-0.0108717447,
0.0281997994,
0.0087931966,
0.0110782133,
0.0194171518,
-0.0372372158,
-0.0280008893,
-0.0261795837,
0.0138081815,
-0.0064389864,
0.0441220962,
0.0139084887,
0.0408976898,
0.0077509391,
0.016082095,
0.0388879552,
-0.0019714795,
-0.0572525263,
-0.0168177709,
0.0307278447,
0.0324439295,
-0.0110373925,
-0.0078522693,
0.0023031768,
0.0504237637,
-0.0278615765,
-0.0339263305,
0.0212690979,
-0.0326236039,
-0.0253833458,
0.03030321,
-0.0395299122,
0.0164518636,
0.0575577393,
-0.0362017602,
-0.027847372,
0.0111808619,
-0.0472619981,
0.1203309223,
-0.0225487724,
0.0396040976,
-0.0116885528,
0.038286414,
-0.0227777287,
0.0726486742,
-0.0064617768,
-0.0413215086,
-0.0136715295,
-0.0168626215,
-0.0168100204,
0.0104282023,
-0.0173100941,
0.0265230834,
0.0058389138,
0.0032604558,
0.0223282743,
-0.0017336052,
-0.0286576562,
-0.0094642853,
-0.0810237825,
0.0193948876,
-0.0568282939,
0.0313760675,
0.0268329289,
0.018813014,
0.0109814098,
-0.0064726914,
-0.0149665149,
0.0235328916,
-0.0237244423,
0.0266193356,
0.0142053049,
-0.016103182,
-0.0197302606,
-0.0285415649,
-0.0481576808,
0.0035939685,
0.0652812123,
-0.0303795449,
-0.0216573495,
-0.0317406729,
-0.0004942225,
0.0229169875,
0.0259613637,
-0.0108854454,
-0.0421492904,
-0.0132993571,
-0.0092078289,
0.0259449687,
0.0688512474,
0.0248250514,
0.0035474082,
0.0452558324,
0.0163099803,
-0.0015220875,
0.046115391,
-0.047017213,
-0.0351159982,
-0.0361276306,
0.0182489417,
0.0169473235,
0.0745119825,
-0.0692291036,
-0.0152734704,
-0.0406565405,
-0.0033431428,
0.0210050568,
-0.0299718454,
0.0108129308,
-0.0152807925,
-0.0057799271,
0.0182929002,
-0.0335376486,
-0.0315773673,
0.0395570323,
-0.0275073089,
-0.0062177982,
-0.0318543911,
-0.0008537854,
-0.0414886922,
0.0813455582,
0.0175674018,
0.0155793149,
-0.0025963215,
0.0072719455,
-0.0318893977,
0.0200632624,
-0.0345001146,
-0.0063882349,
0.090384014,
-0.0079714656,
0.0192437097,
-0.009062483,
-0.0590384193,
-0.0357285514,
-0.0002143071,
-0.0468609668,
0.0121264551,
0.0400644168,
-0.0175333694,
-0.0407464206,
0.0319145285,
0.027194459,
0.0529897176,
-0.0086463969,
-0.009684138,
-0.0366297103,
0.0619952679,
0.050895527,
0.0300253257,
0.0389172845,
0.0017809704,
0.0304606874,
0.0702003315,
0.0364689045,
0.0249721669,
-0.0110343117,
0.0083908355,
0.0334515013,
-0.0263141673,
-0.0154635655,
-0.0026683765,
0.0401345715,
-0.0847372636,
-0.0210791174,
0.0743283331,
-0.0210763458,
-0.0456918441,
0.0315297171,
0.0294768885,
0.0241528694,
0.0305056423,
0.0299774446,
-0.082520552,
-0.0700916797,
0.0151090249,
0.0117406156,
0.0191582479,
-0.0217267089,
0.0031517502,
-0.0972987264,
0.0394465141,
0.0145769399,
-0.0263489932,
-0.0003130156,
-0.0101477401,
0.0105209984,
-0.0437028445,
-0.0145764854,
0.0156663395,
-0.0279129054,
-0.0236224681,
-0.0038614718,
0.0090949396,
0.001102632,
0.0192848276,
-0.0035393729,
-0.0015981357,
0.0813584402,
0.0243947729,
0.0142788393,
-0.0589131005,
0.0168158878,
-0.042703934,
-0.0085240351,
0.0187985953,
0.0474264026,
-0.0242714547,
-0.0289627369,
0.0117788613,
0.0368124656,
-0.0568834543,
-0.0046269796,
-0.0044610766,
0.0805999339,
0.0276103448,
-0.0496858694,
-0.0115053495,
-0.0258482397,
-0.0038850829,
0.0782695711,
0.0392743051,
-0.0201714616,
-0.0738155246,
-0.0057163523,
-0.028550595,
-0.0133201247,
-0.0302451551,
0.0257499479,
-0.0028777309,
-0.090713203,
-0.0417312682,
-0.0330367982,
0.0106528634,
0.021545196,
-0.0014457856,
-0.0371076278,
0.0654892027,
0.0215668995,
-0.0597847402,
0.0260342415,
-0.0490847081,
0.0021459754,
-0.0425183661,
0.0233341176,
0.0374629982,
0.0097044129,
-0.0225058682,
0.0468424745,
-0.1157548651,
-0.0515500829,
0.0128923841,
0.0544558354,
0.0208850261,
0.0382903665,
-0.0061038081,
-0.0060787508,
0.0312397294,
0.0179709811,
-0.0317750089,
0.0374293849,
0.0097538326,
-0.01682158,
0.0038303391,
0.0528640784,
-0.012370117,
0.0515131801,
0.0150292041,
0.0599378757,
-0.0300606526,
-0.0106478343,
0.0280068517,
0.0013021112,
0.030387003,
0.0038851537,
0.0230539963,
0.013286843,
0.0250606164,
0.0224771556,
0.0043138969,
-0.0657050908,
-0.0145557681,
0.0243558362,
0.0129655702,
-0.0036639324,
0.0418353863,
0.0364006087,
-0.013754772,
-0.0428407378,
0.0169608872,
0.0002203713,
-0.0122296503,
0.0181402341,
-0.0085255383,
-0.0096951723,
-0.0246988647,
0.0076258956,
0.0421729498,
-0.025808692,
0.0239557102,
0.025172811,
-0.0042378563,
-0.0363747478,
0.0335246623,
-0.0817103758,
-0.0552422367,
-0.0189276747,
0.0223905649,
0.0354083963,
-0.0293324441,
0.0439875387,
-0.0255947635,
-0.0370829552,
-0.0177699607,
-0.0146922991,
-0.0243769549,
-0.0215663705,
0.0120844608,
0.0205839034,
-0.029481845,
-0.0176112168,
0.0574202426,
-0.0352181979,
0.0662368983,
0.0056591406,
-0.0096235415,
-0.0206269771,
-0.0709908828,
-0.0115907071,
0.0046919375,
0.0193606261,
0.0094972672,
-0.0420963205,
-0.0877989978,
-0.0096662277,
-0.0359200872,
0.0001904151,
-0.0381249264,
0.0305128116,
0.0395386741,
0.0139265107,
-0.0953710377,
-0.0018406441,
-0.0126716262,
-0.0263367314,
0.0013628603,
0.0072883265,
-7.005686987e-33,
0.0011571735,
0.0073818099,
0.0110484986,
-0.0347040221,
-0.0861069709,
0.0224227495,
-0.0183519796,
-0.0468957834,
-0.042759914,
0.014991466,
-0.0159024633,
0.0079952655,
-0.0008744056,
0.0435355194,
0.003430201,
0.0072712493,
0.0411481895,
0.0076152063,
-0.0237045325,
0.0537862778,
0.0156897064,
0.0431490093,
0.0625740886,
0.0127228377,
-0.0858831331,
0.0152973207,
0.005255294,
0.0341624394,
-0.0165086091,
0.0095091825,
-0.04062929,
0.023401659,
0.0290139914,
-0.0695404708,
-0.0010386588,
0.0656963363,
-0.0850484371,
-0.0020044921,
0.0116383871,
-0.0044843298,
-0.0326341167,
-0.0324720629,
0.0542587861,
0.0232971013,
0.0241940413,
-0.0480457246,
-0.0036374633,
-0.0183097851,
-0.0127529502,
-0.0199951939,
-0.1021992564,
0.0031316667,
-0.0172639228,
-0.0235279948,
0.0325002596,
0.0301236287,
-0.0059206132,
0.0483903475,
-0.0567791723,
-0.0073784869,
0.0234973952,
0.0444789194,
0.049535837,
0.0328743346,
0.0050455178,
0.035855934,
0.0250764899,
-0.013584557,
-0.0733860359,
-0.0204022974,
0.0252032205,
0.0575536005,
0.003416582,
-0.0236098338,
0.0694253519,
-0.0155589348,
-0.0692531466,
-0.0430927277,
0.019527385,
0.075247027,
0.0081749391,
0.0147823282,
0.0155642349,
0.0036197209,
-0.0356230028,
0.0247734413,
-0.0228532366,
-0.004659438,
0.0237511303,
0.0204767566,
-0.0368917994,
0.0519931912,
0.0208640285,
-0.0586619489,
0.0414985567,
0.0358882062,
-0.0137789743,
0.037055023,
0.0093089668,
0.0499102026,
-0.0258301403,
0.0041072359,
-0.0017501123,
0.00838691,
0.0007380603,
-0.0218305495,
0.0445629619,
0.03255729,
-0.0605442189,
-0.0277553238,
-0.0634383708,
0.0260058064,
0.017494807,
0.0141941523,
0.0430249907,
0.0405933894,
0.005044396,
-0.0053268676,
0.0098846108,
0.0209048521,
-0.0376132466,
0.0312268808,
0.0222611781,
0.0233851075,
-0.0077351942,
-0.0073812986,
-0.0422788113,
0.0291374922,
0.0121288728,
-0.1066170558,
-0.0330944583,
0.0451903418,
3.02e-7,
0.0276677664,
0.0271305777,
0.026736049,
-0.0050655245,
0.0310651213,
0.007492973,
0.0290985201,
0.0399097688,
-0.012286705,
-0.0203881152,
-0.0077649523,
0.0599706955,
0.0563909262,
0.0022440287,
-0.0759449676,
-0.0423211344,
-0.0647152066,
-0.0276509598,
-0.0445132181,
-0.0437330492,
0.0211776067,
0.1204135418,
0.0139486715,
-0.0295572095,
0.027541345,
0.0154958526,
0.0549063943,
-0.0024486748,
0.0443351567,
0.0464838818,
-0.0116377668,
-0.0041037495,
-0.031874381,
0.0054898974,
0.0102291908,
0.0293112472,
0.0008067234,
0.0768657401,
-0.0063160378,
-0.0374681652,
-0.0031203304,
0.0067013963,
0.0074106068,
-0.0532635301,
0.0836258456,
-0.063016057,
-0.0260393731,
-0.0622586422,
-0.0203823913,
0.0029181591,
-0.0109181432,
0.0196420681,
0.0332654901,
0.0178334266,
0.0071117627,
-0.017986726,
-0.0347113535,
-0.113971889,
0.007374872,
0.0076528648,
-0.0488387868,
-0.0369831361,
-0.0714374185,
-0.0464965403,
0.0531169139,
-0.0334733091,
0.0170021132,
2.608463061e-34,
0.0184218735,
-0.0118164131,
0.0310395416,
0.0209600031,
0.0233716071,
-0.0194108114,
0.0302488431,
-0.0090651559,
-0.00353146,
-0.1015120447,
-0.0150704132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17536v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17536v2 | PipeNet: Question Answering with Semantic Pruning over Knowledge Graphs | 2024-01-31T01:37:33 | 2024-05-17T01:06:46 | Ying Su, Jipeng Zhang, Yangqiu Song, Tong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is well acknowledged that incorporating explicit knowledge graphs (KGs)
can benefit question answering. Existing approaches typically follow a
grounding-reasoning pipeline in which entity nodes are first grounded for the
query (question and candidate answers), and then a reasoning module reasons
over the matched multi-hop subgraph for answer prediction. Although the
pipeline largely alleviates the issue of extracting essential information from
giant KGs, efficiency is still an open challenge when scaling up hops in
grounding the subgraphs. In this paper, we target at finding semantically
related entity nodes in the subgraph to improve the efficiency of graph
reasoning with KG. We propose a grounding-pruning-reasoning pipeline to prune
noisy nodes, remarkably reducing the computation cost and memory usage while
also obtaining decent subgraph representation. In detail, the pruning module
first scores concept nodes based on the dependency distance between matched
spans and then prunes the nodes according to score ranks. To facilitate the
evaluation of pruned subgraphs, we also propose a graph attention network (GAT)
based module to reason with the subgraph data. Experimental results on
CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. | PipeNet: Question Answering with Semantic Pruning over Knowledge Graphs: It is well acknowledged that incorporating explicit knowledge graphs (KGs)
can benefit question answering. Existing approaches typically follow a
grounding-reasoning pipeline in which entity nodes are first grounded for the
query (question and candidate answers), and then a reasoning module reasons
over the matched multi-hop subgraph for answer prediction. Although the
pipeline largely alleviates the issue of extracting essential information from
giant KGs, efficiency is still an open challenge when scaling up hops in
grounding the subgraphs. In this paper, we target at finding semantically
related entity nodes in the subgraph to improve the efficiency of graph
reasoning with KG. We propose a grounding-pruning-reasoning pipeline to prune
noisy nodes, remarkably reducing the computation cost and memory usage while
also obtaining decent subgraph representation. In detail, the pruning module
first scores concept nodes based on the dependency distance between matched
spans and then prunes the nodes according to score ranks. To facilitate the
evaluation of pruned subgraphs, we also propose a graph attention network (GAT)
based module to reason with the subgraph data. Experimental results on
CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. | [
0.018212799,
-0.005805349,
0.0151818777,
0.033168599,
-0.0269111656,
0.0012720582,
-0.0205448046,
0.0109560173,
0.0537367947,
-0.0021352996,
-0.0105941882,
0.0527388416,
-0.0336152501,
0.0149375396,
0.0065584602,
-0.0202750918,
0.0243318621,
0.0283543374,
0.0245710444,
-0.0144089507,
0.0230644047,
0.0641592816,
-0.015343694,
0.0096826172,
0.0118123284,
-0.0422036871,
-0.0067223967,
0.0375849791,
0.0138105508,
-0.0131996945,
0.0186978094,
0.0325341485,
0.0072692614,
-0.0227523297,
0.0000019626,
-0.0007782034,
0.0193249322,
0.0122909574,
-0.0690539107,
0.0072976244,
-0.0491733477,
0.0149358353,
0.0490268804,
0.005681695,
-0.0281703603,
-0.0253590383,
0.0246209968,
0.0371267162,
0.0690469146,
0.0408557281,
0.0025763209,
-0.0269227773,
-0.0107410159,
0.009610584,
0.0198160075,
-0.0593505464,
0.0147242006,
0.0252442192,
0.0315710455,
-0.0008487779,
-0.0344764441,
0.0067726322,
0.0352130532,
-0.0144960666,
0.0552917756,
0.042544052,
-0.0289962869,
0.0455931984,
0.0418717265,
0.1267795414,
0.0027283614,
-0.0544470474,
0.014875113,
-0.0241740793,
-0.0176727511,
-0.0063641835,
-0.0469729938,
-0.0517520942,
-0.0207800549,
-0.0186769366,
-0.0199959837,
-0.0108432183,
0.0240536239,
-0.0056300233,
-0.0170522928,
0.0945881084,
-0.0064269621,
0.0092561264,
0.0356273316,
0.0172558483,
-0.0518878475,
-0.0375817455,
0.0108053628,
0.0425675921,
-0.04090029,
0.0131123485,
0.0018405443,
0.0225516185,
-0.0236241985,
0.0015281494,
-0.0326940231,
0.0420136862,
0.0544619225,
0.0650855377,
-0.0243895911,
0.0438032821,
-0.0321173519,
0.0320264511,
-0.0450624898,
-0.0477549508,
-0.0435865708,
-0.0253118239,
-0.0693643615,
0.0446014628,
-0.0392913185,
-0.0220231414,
-0.0185325369,
-0.0002310957,
-0.0276080649,
-0.0232407283,
0.0477339141,
0.071257703,
0.0290141795,
-0.0063445796,
-0.0310363173,
0.0666053891,
-0.0815819427,
0.0058617224,
-0.0132552218,
-0.0129466271,
-0.0412029959,
0.0144793186,
0.0433974788,
-0.0450541154,
-0.0026876975,
0.0426424332,
0.0312070753,
0.0059304372,
-0.0132130301,
-0.052346319,
0.0121613545,
-0.0226989351,
0.0012730329,
-0.0588300079,
0.0343530402,
0.0002875057,
-0.0329194479,
-0.0294087715,
0.0116353566,
0.0216699038,
-0.050388936,
0.0307585858,
0.0029200562,
-0.0069020893,
-0.0085584577,
0.017081596,
-0.0147522464,
0.0425194688,
0.0108284,
-0.0035831782,
0.0245481823,
-0.0126709864,
-0.068413429,
0.0003025878,
0.0790863931,
-0.0198576991,
0.051769428,
0.0321364515,
-0.0507204086,
0.0170376394,
0.0258982647,
0.0162074789,
-0.0275474079,
-0.0346150771,
0.0090415766,
0.0390286371,
-0.0141222049,
-0.0065344684,
0.0313683972,
0.0329700336,
-0.0096062049,
0.0371479057,
-0.0384545028,
0.0495222807,
-0.0015317311,
-0.0024458785,
-0.0208592508,
-0.0355805755,
-0.0420560129,
0.00675382,
0.0165738035,
0.0304247979,
0.0223432947,
0.0381840803,
0.016381871,
0.0303876977,
-0.0454787761,
0.0694312304,
0.0327585042,
0.0069320919,
0.0159958545,
0.0033534882,
0.0097740926,
0.0662766099,
0.0567714646,
-0.0001109176,
-0.0310420264,
0.0125040039,
0.0158476289,
-0.0362343006,
0.0065911859,
-0.0334792323,
-0.003162374,
-0.0437181555,
-0.0157015007,
-0.0325652994,
-0.0236283913,
-0.0307068899,
0.0614106208,
0.0307048205,
0.0074893706,
-0.0884087905,
-0.0067613707,
-0.0026314647,
-0.0034852307,
0.0071527087,
0.0073070414,
0.0036262798,
-0.0208666101,
0.018356951,
0.0148996552,
0.0447393693,
0.0286905337,
-0.0040637148,
-0.022549415,
-0.0088132489,
-0.0366811007,
-0.067411378,
0.0368102193,
-0.0294434,
-0.0202714056,
0.0121120233,
-0.0474046879,
-0.042039752,
0.0255731214,
-0.0512097962,
0.0450905599,
-0.0020437108,
-0.060623955,
0.0405362733,
-0.01767046,
-0.0315205455,
0.0702481121,
0.005173753,
0.0331029743,
-0.0388549194,
-0.0308452826,
0.0180446133,
-0.0429361537,
0.0124742733,
-0.0060872752,
0.0062059709,
-0.0168065634,
0.0290874541,
-0.0120501127,
-0.0834093764,
0.0523086749,
-0.0710145608,
0.0288659129,
-0.0123306829,
0.0467380583,
0.0180483852,
0.0310972854,
0.0293994658,
-0.0292861648,
-0.040509142,
0.0336908698,
0.0206805971,
-0.0067105377,
0.0186373889,
-0.0050489842,
0.0201611184,
0.0078974525,
-0.051196292,
-0.0151882162,
0.0624885187,
-0.0053006206,
0.0178933758,
0.0108271334,
0.0318066962,
-0.0591146983,
0.009500239,
0.0021359001,
0.0264300518,
-0.0206293669,
-0.010429563,
-0.0181163009,
0.0332188085,
-0.0464295037,
0.0101973852,
-0.0017982246,
0.0066859182,
-0.04526392,
0.0303593148,
-0.0348758698,
0.0290706996,
-0.0225132108,
-0.0023921507,
-0.0271206293,
0.024142582,
0.0063620741,
-0.035775587,
-0.0527144261,
0.0395256504,
0.0174426809,
0.0099183815,
-0.0367799476,
-0.0113668675,
0.04154028,
0.0033448262,
-0.059825018,
0.0246924609,
0.0831867829,
0.0289785452,
-0.0039239237,
-0.0141489143,
0.0096655469,
-0.041077625,
0.0630394667,
0.0082185268,
0.008141242,
-0.0316556767,
-0.02902041,
-0.0498052798,
-0.0344142951,
0.0393310338,
0.0031730384,
0.0376329683,
-0.0003884937,
0.0444300361,
0.0010957924,
-0.0055188127,
-0.0253436975,
0.0182302129,
-0.038627699,
0.0456534326,
-0.0038301696,
-0.0062777121,
0.0003433126,
0.0194427539,
-0.0015649818,
-0.0071559534,
0.0139469672,
0.0212210845,
-0.0086255437,
0.0739155635,
0.038318675,
0.0169136748,
0.0447406881,
0.0168937314,
0.04100997,
0.0597820915,
0.0196690448,
-0.0285393149,
0.0058285906,
-0.0150615815,
-0.0116144065,
-0.0519664735,
-0.0012028712,
-0.048026599,
0.0643847734,
-0.0556421019,
-0.0150310425,
0.0778666288,
0.0330901891,
0.0244195554,
0.0161158107,
0.0184826627,
0.0484537333,
0.0080825789,
0.0441849567,
-0.0690413788,
-0.0433727913,
-0.0116928266,
0.0279268119,
0.0499504507,
-0.0896808431,
-0.0030018282,
-0.0871448591,
-0.0021038735,
-0.0058197365,
-0.0753298476,
-0.0718455315,
-0.0484342389,
0.0145996856,
0.0118634086,
-0.0390903577,
-0.0026727172,
0.0139465891,
0.0143191116,
0.0202245265,
0.0105034309,
-0.0037513161,
0.0505520813,
-0.0117032072,
0.0139755141,
-0.012234021,
0.0497245453,
0.0259188395,
-0.0096642962,
-0.0129246777,
-0.0713244304,
-0.0139881689,
-0.0267737582,
0.0298002679,
-0.0063684899,
-0.0021486084,
-0.0496832281,
0.0155206891,
-0.0717850178,
-0.0166770015,
-0.0130224461,
0.1043290645,
-0.012391557,
-0.0584001206,
-0.0047385795,
0.015813088,
-0.0082793487,
0.0564723462,
0.033335261,
0.0508141927,
-0.0621102341,
-0.0206903759,
-0.0087553011,
-0.0786289424,
-0.034209732,
0.0211640708,
0.0152230719,
0.0266482476,
-0.0432983302,
-0.0263047405,
0.0503630079,
0.002213438,
-0.0468725003,
0.0012989667,
0.0353228301,
0.0123895938,
-0.0628910139,
0.0336961672,
-0.0358117968,
0.0357048884,
0.0108568314,
0.0090019936,
0.0157227907,
0.0112559218,
-0.0347305723,
0.0259369984,
-0.0701395869,
-0.0416659154,
-0.0585715324,
0.0014083908,
0.0084387744,
0.0504614264,
-0.051082477,
-0.0016667926,
0.0231949091,
-0.0011851513,
-0.0920587629,
-0.0014828346,
0.0079457238,
-0.0400020629,
-0.0240296535,
0.0604100227,
-0.0446297452,
-0.0136442417,
0.0367200039,
0.0738424212,
-0.0212770402,
-0.0274434295,
0.0021513402,
0.0473247394,
-0.0417268649,
0.0536531731,
0.0193769,
-0.0592771657,
0.0189510621,
0.0207110271,
-0.0200073998,
-0.0105031515,
-0.0027327964,
-0.0065854755,
-0.028699819,
-0.0232650191,
-0.0167953148,
0.0192215201,
0.0168832634,
-0.0124374032,
-0.0273835734,
0.0321585871,
-0.0393487439,
0.0520745292,
-0.0095234262,
-0.0302346796,
0.0052211247,
0.0147167239,
0.0524856783,
-0.0310317595,
-0.008827161,
0.0466142446,
-0.0069709495,
-0.0207933541,
-0.0186792687,
-0.0495607667,
-0.0519141704,
0.0039450526,
0.039429985,
0.0163264032,
0.0099230101,
-0.0030447559,
0.0131892776,
-0.0329221934,
-0.0100309653,
0.0222595185,
0.0164757594,
-0.0216951668,
0.0583213829,
0.0384080186,
0.0068430607,
0.0020489525,
0.0342764407,
-0.0068858354,
0.0638642088,
0.0186182894,
-0.0579830743,
-0.0403624475,
-0.0717029348,
-0.0421435349,
0.0719868392,
0.0078406306,
0.0526627861,
-0.0594288222,
-0.0929456428,
-0.040622849,
-0.0031462505,
-0.0411443971,
-0.0030093549,
0.0622985326,
-0.0004008309,
0.0553370379,
-0.0437836386,
-0.0080358312,
0.0292452518,
-0.0850582942,
-0.0221789796,
0.0047160937,
-5.938213955e-33,
-0.0310919527,
-0.0741056651,
0.0281867161,
0.0094030388,
-0.059748847,
0.0106403138,
-0.0643976256,
-0.0308231469,
-0.061243549,
0.0299254823,
-0.0140392957,
0.032820344,
-0.0153324595,
0.0020395271,
-0.0519977696,
-0.0397666022,
-0.0042773029,
0.0050910171,
-0.0058540809,
0.0691479146,
0.0400053598,
0.0252205115,
0.0390970595,
-0.0152867185,
0.0165202674,
-0.0213172771,
0.0238702763,
0.0342860743,
-0.0448773317,
0.0410108566,
0.0059591085,
0.049999278,
0.0209198017,
-0.0218924098,
0.0155545967,
0.0152220251,
-0.1431796253,
-0.0571615063,
0.0237533804,
0.0035862068,
-0.0803063959,
-0.0230950788,
0.0232857373,
0.0180939268,
0.069507122,
-0.0558076873,
0.035196919,
0.0221917536,
-0.0415057354,
-0.0022599723,
0.0079249348,
0.0223812982,
-0.0465572998,
0.0053727264,
-0.04079834,
0.0061850632,
0.0016961835,
-0.0012296226,
-0.065143168,
-0.0035506114,
-0.0283022746,
0.0060105175,
0.0106533337,
-0.0200842544,
0.0023183199,
0.0185583401,
-0.0093283365,
-0.0387947932,
-0.0384380929,
0.042491734,
-0.0027811821,
0.018366646,
0.0382869728,
-0.0294840802,
0.0093630143,
-0.0071676834,
-0.1266763359,
0.0020985031,
-0.0080615403,
0.0816024169,
-0.0168655235,
0.0040318435,
-0.0001893246,
-0.0518044308,
-0.0227988157,
-0.0030495212,
-0.0258915164,
-0.0233069155,
0.0025670817,
-0.0200020429,
-0.0366296358,
0.0273015928,
-0.0090284469,
-0.0576077513,
0.0308349635,
0.1001507416,
0.0249268562,
-0.0096535673,
0.0270667598,
0.0520803593,
-0.0698875263,
0.054449223,
0.0276267808,
-0.0519170575,
0.021365108,
0.0263423845,
0.004738465,
-0.014037475,
-0.0115343211,
0.0035741962,
-0.0669696555,
0.0328850411,
-0.0600868389,
0.015899295,
0.0240981635,
0.0575535744,
0.0099918181,
0.0209921729,
0.037704546,
0.0332277715,
0.0070117703,
0.0644300431,
0.0197512601,
0.0194049701,
-0.0190410316,
0.0051974612,
-0.0212245136,
0.029245479,
-0.015857704,
-0.049011074,
-0.0231991559,
0.0428738408,
2.616e-7,
0.0612570569,
-0.0231193155,
0.0437839814,
0.0563190542,
0.0169019438,
0.0122282254,
0.0379289202,
0.0252587162,
0.0025394943,
-0.0416616872,
0.0255773477,
0.0653875992,
-0.0214224178,
0.0352485441,
-0.0893071592,
0.0209273808,
-0.0282094795,
-0.0554836951,
-0.0224631727,
-0.0323366672,
0.03339855,
0.0381739102,
0.0338051394,
-0.0065810606,
0.0024848273,
-0.0374489836,
0.0239511635,
0.0437149778,
0.0202074107,
0.0001449807,
0.0327846818,
-0.0283093881,
-0.0269639529,
0.0720801726,
0.0032699611,
0.0131263025,
0.0330055282,
0.0279565845,
-0.0221789237,
-0.0255065225,
-0.0377487466,
-0.0566313565,
0.047044076,
-0.0446034968,
0.1023550257,
-0.0100508491,
-0.0296872593,
0.028103251,
-0.0133235324,
-0.0307826474,
-0.01496791,
0.0144870514,
-0.0095056919,
-0.0095806196,
0.0279084742,
-0.0221954398,
0.0234419852,
-0.0887537226,
0.0072348146,
-0.0005739998,
-0.0062563028,
-0.0493870117,
0.0194962285,
0.0069216648,
0.0228364058,
-0.0358799808,
-0.0041425112,
2.322196896e-34,
-0.0163819976,
0.0477128141,
0.0066826893,
-0.0060000662,
0.0331200436,
-0.0334186144,
-0.0154551975,
-0.0290986001,
0.0460033007,
-0.0811989382,
-0.0102316579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17514v2 | How Useful is Continued Pre-Training for Generative Unsupervised Domain Adaptation? | 2024-01-31T00:15:34 | 2024-04-01T20:40:40 | Rheeya Uppaal, Yixuan Li, Junjie Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in scale have enabled the emergence of powerful
generative language models, and the ability to fine-tune these models on
various tasks by casting them into prompts or instructions. In this landscape,
the problem of Unsupervised Domain Adaptation (UDA), or the problem of
leveraging knowledge from a labeled source domain to an unlabeled target
domain, has been left behind, with recent UDA methods still addressing
discriminative classification. In particular, two popular UDA approaches,
involving Continued Pre-Training (CPT) and learning domain invariant
representations, have been under-explored in the generative setting, signaling
a gap. In this work, we evaluate the utility of CPT for generative UDA. We
first perform an empirical evaluation to measure the trade-offs between CPT and
strong methods promoting domain invariance. We further evaluate how well the
benefits of CPT extend to different architectures, tuning methods and data
regimes. We then motivate the use of CPT by studying to what degree it benefits
classification performance on the target domain. Finally, we attempt to
understand the mechanism behind which CPT improves classification performance
on the unlabeled target domain. Our findings suggest that a implicitly learns
the downstream task while predicting masked words informative to that task. Our
work connects the body of UDA research with that of instruction tuning,
enabling an initial step towards a wider applicability of modern language
models. | How Useful is Continued Pre-Training for Generative Unsupervised Domain Adaptation?: Recent breakthroughs in scale have enabled the emergence of powerful
generative language models, and the ability to fine-tune these models on
various tasks by casting them into prompts or instructions. In this landscape,
the problem of Unsupervised Domain Adaptation (UDA), or the problem of
leveraging knowledge from a labeled source domain to an unlabeled target
domain, has been left behind, with recent UDA methods still addressing
discriminative classification. In particular, two popular UDA approaches,
involving Continued Pre-Training (CPT) and learning domain invariant
representations, have been under-explored in the generative setting, signaling
a gap. In this work, we evaluate the utility of CPT for generative UDA. We
first perform an empirical evaluation to measure the trade-offs between CPT and
strong methods promoting domain invariance. We further evaluate how well the
benefits of CPT extend to different architectures, tuning methods and data
regimes. We then motivate the use of CPT by studying to what degree it benefits
classification performance on the target domain. Finally, we attempt to
understand the mechanism behind which CPT improves classification performance
on the unlabeled target domain. Our findings suggest that a implicitly learns
the downstream task while predicting masked words informative to that task. Our
work connects the body of UDA research with that of instruction tuning,
enabling an initial step towards a wider applicability of modern language
models. | [
0.0360967964,
0.0586162768,
-0.0269602705,
-0.0217772946,
-0.0033749964,
0.0308600664,
0.053930074,
-0.0174741354,
-0.0094169946,
-0.0715312734,
-0.0783771053,
-0.0313224308,
-0.0531777591,
0.0363416113,
0.0205057263,
-0.0462423638,
0.051519338,
-0.0261116456,
-0.0403229557,
-0.0144890202,
-0.0328638181,
-0.0271130968,
-0.0173624903,
0.0071655293,
-0.0031812633,
-0.0304212794,
0.0189656485,
-0.0270968769,
-0.0226453692,
0.0024304073,
0.0220768321,
0.0709808469,
0.0566028059,
0.0046359343,
0.0000021183,
-0.0695617348,
-0.0164757911,
-0.0325891674,
-0.0103420969,
0.0174426697,
0.0313516594,
0.006753522,
-0.0141970469,
-0.0093871001,
-0.0517971888,
-0.0860071406,
0.0746187717,
0.0280327145,
0.0154651785,
0.0744433329,
-0.0188690573,
-0.0280818045,
-0.00547005,
-0.0633743927,
-0.0352254733,
-0.0720652863,
0.0221428145,
-0.0331025608,
-0.0309750829,
0.0171129219,
-0.0547913648,
0.020429682,
-0.0087386966,
-0.0029122168,
-0.0008398631,
0.0520022549,
0.0161277745,
0.0083003407,
0.0021647161,
0.0370041579,
-0.0116884597,
-0.0442429818,
-0.0061277444,
-0.0040031457,
0.008486242,
0.0297130179,
-0.0110689411,
-0.021327205,
0.0505139455,
0.0018396216,
-0.0034309628,
0.0212487523,
0.0179635677,
-0.0047369185,
-0.0055790893,
0.0212340746,
0.0329231285,
-0.0178618021,
0.0102382191,
0.0418402925,
-0.0526825525,
-0.0554854497,
0.0010022463,
-0.0007077446,
0.0103487587,
0.0188103504,
-0.0683514699,
-0.034896411,
-0.0353718176,
0.0248427615,
0.0476430953,
0.0198212489,
-0.0571895279,
0.0256081372,
-0.0475989506,
0.0329230353,
-0.0151406545,
0.055433467,
-0.0442535803,
0.025629472,
-0.0648383275,
-0.0270309728,
-0.0464321338,
0.0168064553,
-0.0073209913,
0.0123784654,
-0.0253800787,
0.0421413556,
-0.0022516365,
-0.0625724792,
0.0015399563,
0.0024932974,
-0.0699398816,
-0.0128892809,
-0.0190117285,
0.0208025686,
-0.043484468,
0.0545143783,
0.0056435908,
-0.0561147742,
-0.0310926829,
0.019032212,
0.0271199513,
-0.0369697064,
0.0217152759,
0.0970342979,
-0.0291189831,
-0.0538454577,
-0.0264055133,
0.0404724516,
-0.0308141913,
-0.052041281,
0.0718922764,
0.0020925279,
0.0146543337,
0.0006003742,
0.002097521,
-0.1083736792,
-0.0370189436,
-0.0308040883,
0.0093277339,
0.0804135948,
0.0203195699,
-0.0017353598,
0.0307441968,
0.0070990752,
-0.0018829065,
0.0464346297,
-0.0097673899,
-0.000900497,
0.0183281749,
-0.0154278977,
0.028656505,
0.033998739,
0.0444226153,
0.0228939615,
0.024789229,
-0.0007759142,
0.0284021795,
-0.0116129573,
0.0704353824,
-0.0251604356,
-0.0002275433,
-0.0062294551,
0.0430815592,
0.0316205621,
0.0212447252,
0.0447090119,
0.0710693225,
-0.0029622908,
-0.029592514,
0.0501750335,
-0.0483879074,
0.0082725547,
-0.0126299355,
-0.0160790514,
-0.00640865,
-0.0018229781,
-0.0616371371,
-0.0399959795,
0.0251072459,
-0.000621668,
0.0072116745,
0.0070897783,
0.0578583404,
0.0589579567,
-0.0196705423,
0.0275421515,
0.050304547,
-0.0388309136,
0.0310712066,
-0.0594327189,
0.0065103304,
0.009031279,
0.0092778765,
-0.0494710319,
-0.0070052445,
0.0228937138,
0.0519278422,
0.0372003093,
0.0412440635,
-0.0167171992,
0.0202645045,
-0.0295848679,
-0.039317552,
-0.0260680299,
0.0300498456,
0.0725568905,
0.0108883409,
0.0007260648,
0.016694203,
-0.0511624776,
0.0195255205,
0.0609193929,
-0.0433866456,
-0.0833901092,
0.0351046883,
0.0264804941,
0.0073089772,
-0.013769282,
-0.0360185318,
-0.0002177655,
0.001669058,
-0.0274181049,
-0.0115840035,
0.0054356246,
-0.0764344558,
-0.0186166521,
-0.001609418,
-0.0102365185,
0.0086381454,
0.0177055951,
-0.0075868722,
-0.0360794924,
0.0579906888,
0.0021254886,
0.0339417905,
-0.0490640104,
0.0211592074,
-0.0047138948,
0.0421113186,
-0.0340123698,
0.0549147576,
0.0491565205,
-0.0300060585,
-0.0060736062,
0.0199858751,
0.0045343284,
-0.0170941316,
0.0403603353,
0.0024186412,
0.005997418,
0.0106354905,
0.0073098321,
0.00911796,
-0.0218522754,
0.0113061154,
-0.0489974208,
0.0035575947,
-0.0473058857,
0.0201210417,
0.0249238852,
0.027660301,
-0.0293249246,
-0.0163733885,
-0.029317379,
-0.0216850899,
-0.0163565688,
0.0314764604,
0.0046769073,
0.0065813493,
0.0160396881,
-0.0234047808,
0.0053707375,
0.0112593342,
0.0352435485,
-0.0327446908,
-0.0159192104,
-0.0531473793,
0.0757086352,
0.0004855528,
0.0669049248,
-0.0028423821,
-0.0004801888,
-0.0239099842,
0.0030162798,
0.0878095701,
0.0394281484,
-0.0200586207,
0.0250272825,
0.0618757457,
0.0082635526,
-0.0213162154,
0.0095734876,
-0.063179329,
-0.0606567077,
-0.0018270416,
0.0471076332,
0.0429710373,
0.0701168701,
-0.0022099956,
-0.0510066561,
-0.0672039762,
0.0092582824,
-0.0352779739,
-0.0443941802,
-0.0273727532,
0.0033790024,
-0.0095057618,
0.032316193,
-0.0126059921,
-0.0487498976,
0.0608076006,
0.0026514835,
-0.0010553404,
-0.0658981949,
-0.0019012691,
-0.0095808124,
0.0549179949,
0.0318719149,
0.0078457016,
0.0526120476,
-0.0290618483,
-0.0631270185,
0.0415408649,
0.0052900375,
0.0167336594,
0.031766627,
-0.0543137714,
0.0205330681,
0.0128285224,
-0.0359505638,
-0.0413660482,
-0.0707314014,
0.0224152002,
-0.0053934939,
-0.0124240629,
0.016894538,
-0.0252572689,
-0.003696806,
-0.0028732282,
0.0746641457,
0.0047389576,
-0.0102084605,
-0.0146391913,
0.0356632471,
0.0236249324,
0.0207773522,
-0.0074428213,
-0.0142324809,
-0.0213752128,
0.020389555,
0.006201155,
-0.0389848799,
-0.0051592714,
0.0404562987,
0.0427211523,
-0.0300794169,
-0.0237209518,
0.0191905573,
0.0607862361,
0.0117730917,
-0.0554185584,
0.085576497,
0.0139225991,
-0.024869876,
0.0158756841,
0.0031331542,
0.0195400957,
0.0293985642,
0.0357907154,
-0.0452359132,
-0.0511017628,
-0.0173289143,
0.0219955985,
0.0148640312,
-0.013642448,
-0.0023020278,
-0.1131768823,
0.031681031,
0.0095964549,
-0.0129372459,
0.0052001565,
-0.0189607441,
0.0111162616,
-0.0058185193,
-0.0199446846,
-0.038487725,
-0.0144864023,
-0.0041925362,
0.0379269086,
-0.0143521558,
-0.075472042,
0.0173016116,
-0.0376798548,
0.0056141857,
0.1232801825,
-0.0175850578,
0.0215796437,
-0.037724033,
0.0706082284,
-0.0290842317,
0.0171212219,
-0.0061050537,
0.0536557548,
-0.0165589917,
-0.0099859145,
0.0300535262,
0.0306549426,
-0.0429283977,
-0.0299128406,
0.0124317389,
0.021475222,
0.007096203,
-0.0298559554,
-0.0115750991,
-0.0172288511,
0.0039423732,
0.0493751131,
0.0162946265,
-0.050391227,
-0.0133364052,
-0.0097458651,
0.0274791792,
-0.039195504,
-0.0429689959,
-0.0022049088,
-0.0370536409,
-0.0475992151,
-0.0602649711,
-0.0278916191,
0.0152941849,
0.0229327567,
0.039197389,
-0.039404273,
-0.0133786164,
0.0134095373,
-0.0337268077,
0.0247897338,
-0.0664572194,
-0.0050933845,
-0.0546908975,
-0.0675309747,
0.0486798473,
-0.0533175841,
-0.032374803,
0.0250527319,
-0.0460665748,
-0.0474290848,
0.0262337234,
0.0164560098,
0.0139089292,
0.0512861162,
-0.0184926409,
-0.0485978425,
0.0672681183,
0.0360588245,
-0.0251067095,
0.0322742052,
0.0338139683,
-0.034971416,
-0.0016694659,
0.013230334,
-0.0364702307,
0.0893132016,
0.0760243684,
0.0049128933,
0.0368481837,
0.0000319777,
0.0203709453,
-0.0415237509,
0.0954522863,
-0.0105734589,
0.0141295763,
-0.0593038499,
-0.002296943,
0.0075074523,
-0.0134715969,
-0.0243976917,
-0.0459099673,
0.0526775941,
0.0298679527,
-0.0299079549,
0.0583029501,
-0.0232666563,
0.0586919636,
-0.0535179414,
-0.0124292616,
0.0283741094,
0.0370737575,
-0.0310163349,
0.0344756432,
0.0081919702,
0.0261041466,
0.0167203229,
0.0497648045,
-0.0423402786,
0.0335908495,
0.0009579678,
0.0168058872,
-0.0194667354,
0.0284269657,
-0.0720922574,
0.0195032153,
-0.06070875,
0.0157314315,
0.0532019436,
-0.0682959631,
0.0472283512,
-0.0064963074,
-0.0091586737,
-0.0331985839,
0.0026511147,
0.0197819211,
-0.016371578,
0.0165856685,
0.0017213194,
-0.0162562225,
-0.0196024943,
0.0807502195,
0.0339878313,
0.0619526617,
-0.0087953806,
0.0160998479,
-0.0441722944,
-0.0292980485,
0.0104989661,
0.018633619,
0.0139466142,
0.0340882801,
-0.0237873644,
-0.0595494732,
-0.0359855592,
-0.0328259207,
0.0196610391,
0.005933465,
0.0497957654,
0.0451820455,
-0.0375753976,
-0.0318431146,
-0.0289997011,
-0.0029038836,
0.0418203473,
0.0161270164,
-0.0162785947,
-6.547494718e-33,
-0.0542568974,
0.0252708197,
0.012074098,
0.0090903016,
0.0073171244,
-0.0358496606,
-0.0416188985,
0.0065199221,
0.0169398412,
0.0083163986,
-0.0119835362,
-0.0148402881,
0.0227140673,
0.0263607148,
-0.0191694722,
-0.0259973109,
0.0721150637,
-0.0070142937,
-0.0308278929,
0.0193424392,
0.0102359466,
0.0306707099,
0.0467274301,
-0.0819856822,
-0.0027592189,
-0.0001124984,
-0.0026556018,
-0.0094543127,
0.0461059213,
0.0334946662,
-0.0379457287,
0.016915448,
0.0210214369,
-0.0534642972,
-0.0295082089,
0.0062646428,
-0.1224544272,
-0.0145086143,
-0.0021867591,
0.0165732466,
-0.0206593666,
-0.055416733,
-0.0093899006,
0.0087345932,
-0.048790656,
-0.0181709472,
0.0292518176,
-0.029481465,
-0.0038798817,
-0.0482467338,
-0.0893468484,
0.0052934932,
0.0156511068,
-0.0459911451,
0.0183060244,
0.0199510474,
0.017916983,
-0.0059171943,
-0.0694582164,
0.041921284,
0.0149881272,
0.0495763645,
0.0689093173,
0.0364934318,
0.0105086798,
0.0309598465,
0.0236318912,
-0.0140123507,
0.0062148036,
-0.0114006782,
0.027749164,
-0.0150427865,
-0.0267028324,
0.0060823169,
0.0521168634,
-0.044445347,
-0.0513572544,
0.0194646269,
-0.0569075197,
-0.0356698185,
0.0144971246,
0.0204025544,
-0.0105019193,
-0.0336485691,
-0.0342473276,
0.003726522,
-0.0198636428,
-0.0220261589,
0.0545412824,
0.020541843,
-0.0204588044,
0.0245172083,
0.0314414017,
-0.0418882929,
-0.0305067971,
-0.0247627478,
-0.024161892,
0.0006394025,
0.0089362422,
0.0082864584,
-0.0301129986,
-0.0372870602,
0.0533714443,
0.0108158672,
-0.0079495711,
-0.0142330723,
0.0425196476,
0.041903995,
-0.0710312128,
-0.0067341533,
-0.0213723388,
0.0126368944,
0.0366151109,
0.0253834911,
0.0033789689,
0.0428024903,
-0.025442753,
0.0620614663,
0.0482291728,
-0.0638226196,
-0.0241969526,
0.028716784,
0.0093484856,
0.0381313786,
-0.0400909223,
-0.0183200166,
-0.0061636795,
-0.0117589338,
0.0417886041,
-0.0850403681,
-0.023650663,
-0.026143698,
2.831e-7,
0.0360286683,
0.035335239,
0.0035439036,
-0.0207436047,
0.0246218573,
0.0435753129,
-0.0129482653,
0.0473640636,
0.0353614837,
0.0146124372,
0.0080401488,
0.0373469479,
0.0146326898,
-0.0096572051,
-0.028927315,
0.0128974309,
0.0299150404,
0.0485474765,
-0.0132244937,
0.0155551285,
0.0371394604,
0.1042196602,
0.0048771277,
-0.0077444944,
0.0051186597,
-0.040891014,
0.1041245833,
-0.0194893144,
0.0201846156,
0.0239528008,
-0.012200213,
0.0415615179,
-0.0135710826,
0.0244103093,
-0.034858305,
0.0431477614,
0.0413238667,
0.0577610098,
0.005723611,
-0.0160619747,
0.0100207459,
0.0414180271,
0.0176723786,
0.0114251506,
0.085631758,
-0.1038872078,
-0.0269147269,
0.0098095816,
-0.0184928626,
0.014990788,
-0.0218827184,
0.0099303713,
-0.0278099999,
0.0215870719,
0.034390077,
0.0453554802,
-0.0328223668,
-0.0864949301,
-0.0112633323,
0.0132617103,
-0.0476253554,
-0.0110476557,
-0.0291193742,
0.0034125496,
0.0529627874,
-0.048441004,
0.0198919419,
2.49005703e-34,
-0.0073863906,
0.0207585022,
0.0156922452,
-0.0184281468,
-0.0219013635,
-0.0408467464,
0.0437716059,
-0.0061940704,
0.0240962785,
-0.0656697303,
-0.0026372599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17511v1 | Linguistically Communicating Uncertainty in Patient-Facing Risk Prediction Models | 2024-01-31T00:08:44 | 2024-01-31T00:08:44 | Adarsa Sivaprasad, Ehud Reiter | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper addresses the unique challenges associated with uncertainty
quantification in AI models when applied to patient-facing contexts within
healthcare. Unlike traditional eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)
methods tailored for model developers or domain experts, additional
considerations of communicating in natural language, its presentation and
evaluating understandability are necessary. We identify the challenges in
communication model performance, confidence, reasoning and unknown knowns using
natural language in the context of risk prediction. We propose a design aimed
at addressing these challenges, focusing on the specific application of
in-vitro fertilisation outcome prediction. | Linguistically Communicating Uncertainty in Patient-Facing Risk Prediction Models: This paper addresses the unique challenges associated with uncertainty
quantification in AI models when applied to patient-facing contexts within
healthcare. Unlike traditional eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)
methods tailored for model developers or domain experts, additional
considerations of communicating in natural language, its presentation and
evaluating understandability are necessary. We identify the challenges in
communication model performance, confidence, reasoning and unknown knowns using
natural language in the context of risk prediction. We propose a design aimed
at addressing these challenges, focusing on the specific application of
in-vitro fertilisation outcome prediction. | [
0.0241588559,
0.0832194611,
-0.0228065215,
-0.0373473763,
-0.0038085522,
-0.0048953462,
-0.0067069721,
-0.0321980827,
0.0028770478,
0.0252148956,
0.0408984013,
-0.0365219228,
0.0001624114,
0.0462001227,
-0.0185285117,
-0.0666722506,
0.0181050133,
-0.0028935994,
0.0576350875,
0.0315299258,
-0.007779229,
0.0082988273,
-0.0288184639,
0.0365874954,
-0.0391021781,
-0.0069405427,
-0.0051984587,
0.026234027,
0.0181574281,
-0.1091017351,
0.0146941757,
0.0127342064,
0.0050474005,
-0.0387123227,
0.0000019252,
-0.0655433461,
-0.0125995344,
0.0254380368,
-0.0761631131,
-0.0549129732,
0.0315555036,
-0.0166905131,
-0.0032824597,
0.0115253264,
-0.0065199947,
0.0268369149,
0.0616307147,
0.0533814281,
0.0185732376,
-0.0062256306,
-0.0183203854,
0.0167299472,
0.0187321361,
0.0030351053,
-0.0064917048,
-0.0592996031,
0.0013562115,
0.0038476142,
0.0350998156,
0.016343385,
0.004715764,
0.0618507974,
0.0147845764,
-0.0202345531,
-0.0274290368,
-0.00429771,
0.0431520641,
-0.0638479292,
-0.0379220881,
-0.003130052,
0.0053368337,
0.026476305,
-0.0201111194,
-0.0116428938,
0.0126390094,
-0.0059492192,
-0.0566308163,
-0.003589934,
-0.0305116624,
0.0021526122,
-0.01743575,
0.0632765219,
0.0360818878,
0.0169579107,
0.0365828611,
0.059688285,
0.0018126374,
0.0050815539,
-0.0028104885,
0.0012567303,
-0.0036621282,
-0.0095484732,
0.010181509,
0.0478564166,
-0.0603295937,
0.0364202447,
0.0222505387,
-0.010899893,
0.0622583628,
-0.0796688944,
0.0249004997,
0.0145575684,
0.0360798649,
-0.0329566598,
0.0181343239,
-0.0041320883,
0.0102296006,
-0.0132397013,
-0.0246407501,
0.005338002,
-0.0522437058,
-0.0264574103,
-0.0148032578,
-0.0150724845,
0.0001245777,
0.0396560952,
-0.0834808648,
-0.0092166169,
-0.0873284042,
0.0065682279,
0.0267334692,
0.02515704,
-0.0555394962,
0.0001010803,
-0.0447451472,
-0.0300533306,
-0.0368365385,
0.0250487924,
0.0041508046,
-0.0806203112,
0.0117912805,
0.0054029771,
-0.0173171237,
0.0258467365,
-0.0520206392,
0.0835955143,
0.0155488076,
0.008150883,
0.0083956504,
-0.0272459444,
-0.0521438122,
-0.0094821369,
-0.0284349639,
0.0074396008,
0.001636107,
0.0215421822,
0.0054852897,
-0.0909258798,
0.022827033,
-0.0210199784,
-0.0033744478,
0.0729530528,
-0.0496156327,
0.0022837427,
0.0027175688,
0.0375935324,
-0.0180588476,
0.0249216463,
0.0392902903,
-0.0093006976,
-0.002694817,
-0.0096360547,
0.0296678711,
-0.0472996421,
0.0138468686,
-0.0396940224,
0.0031413571,
0.0000799438,
-0.04525299,
0.038002979,
-0.0351160988,
0.0362817198,
0.0569633842,
0.0322098508,
0.0280986708,
0.0331682004,
0.0136333387,
0.0017179013,
0.0516042933,
0.0007881827,
-0.0274706539,
-0.0330244564,
0.0074025155,
0.0084078098,
-0.0050218287,
0.0267569348,
-0.0365462303,
-0.01670851,
-0.0150311273,
-0.0842312425,
-0.0631412491,
-0.0414204858,
0.0070189117,
-0.0030490095,
0.0064149275,
0.0081762504,
0.0103847776,
0.0358903296,
0.0648196861,
-0.0037958226,
-0.033888977,
-0.0768029317,
0.0081850747,
0.0731932968,
-0.0023064727,
-0.0484321415,
-0.0258921534,
-0.0158007313,
-0.0126667833,
-0.0172199737,
0.0311309993,
-0.0143062212,
0.0048751915,
-0.0077057243,
-0.008590797,
0.0352834724,
0.022382604,
-0.0189426504,
-0.0215646103,
0.0056659621,
-0.0097909486,
-0.0227507446,
-0.0566961952,
0.033178959,
-0.0168073773,
-0.0192759745,
-0.0151870381,
-0.0371001735,
0.0423742086,
-0.0032631066,
0.0169149507,
0.0417639166,
0.0282079242,
0.0157920215,
-0.0515057296,
0.0370193273,
0.007412029,
0.0099676549,
-0.0265657827,
-0.0179607868,
-0.0174689386,
-0.0536830537,
-0.0703132451,
0.0017986071,
0.0063980906,
-0.0545234121,
-0.0083925677,
0.0151120676,
0.014049544,
0.0303784329,
-0.0126550263,
-0.0549309216,
0.0031820138,
-0.0107125808,
-0.033672601,
-0.0055918144,
-0.0492444411,
0.0145961037,
-0.0277924296,
0.0258874185,
-0.013051114,
-0.0049256771,
0.0100872647,
-0.0008804863,
0.0334929563,
-0.0093013635,
0.0069409213,
-0.0522365235,
-0.0358952656,
0.0146741085,
0.0109562809,
-0.0257649738,
-0.0093522873,
0.0187137388,
-0.015079705,
-0.0051372075,
0.0287013166,
0.003079999,
-0.0035559044,
0.0455631875,
0.0461128354,
-0.0091531295,
-0.009999577,
-0.0159728397,
-0.0406203009,
0.0473541431,
0.0625289604,
-0.0114046363,
-0.0294964425,
0.0181570631,
-0.0438663177,
-0.0411207154,
0.016052248,
0.0153058227,
-0.0030383379,
0.015153748,
-0.0304019284,
-0.0092903273,
-0.0098397611,
0.0678358153,
0.019976737,
0.0248864815,
-0.0081368657,
-0.0026178372,
-0.0662136599,
-0.0446438789,
0.0324950665,
-0.0321604311,
-0.0084819095,
0.0184841286,
0.0165097229,
-0.028084673,
-0.0208066553,
0.0527761541,
-0.0376134627,
-0.0098803518,
-0.0141683109,
-0.0207772311,
0.0250223,
0.1029019579,
0.0185484588,
-0.0524134822,
0.1153297573,
0.0320523493,
0.0526783504,
-0.0526737906,
-0.0546046495,
0.0039367611,
-0.0266079344,
-0.0287438035,
0.0186468214,
0.0478488989,
0.01427936,
-0.031078605,
-0.0206895601,
-0.0248084571,
0.0025590044,
0.0067164344,
-0.0661518425,
0.0066301157,
0.0620238297,
-0.0654793233,
-0.0326412879,
-0.0104193892,
-0.0402093083,
0.0203304421,
0.0268001966,
0.0159982145,
-0.0066813892,
0.0392856598,
-0.0325935148,
-0.0173121952,
0.002972458,
-0.0473399758,
-0.0099379849,
-0.0516105928,
0.0013255981,
0.0025374771,
0.0548118614,
-0.010332183,
0.0149130411,
0.0207074061,
-0.008763466,
0.0200323109,
-0.0274264552,
0.0320903324,
-0.0377164707,
-0.0194619577,
-0.00980948,
0.0686796159,
0.0374288298,
-0.0457550548,
-0.0229448248,
0.0840056092,
0.0178363826,
0.0560472645,
0.0495330282,
-0.0657326654,
-0.0073542418,
-0.0341597274,
0.0359177925,
-0.0251837391,
-0.0002205417,
-0.0132545,
-0.0002539961,
-0.0318039767,
-0.0190973226,
0.0097088208,
0.0008706081,
0.0382761918,
-0.0023606424,
-0.0164108947,
-0.0359579027,
-0.0804003254,
-0.0147327529,
-0.0298804231,
-0.0021355017,
-0.0367495529,
0.0264406931,
-0.0187696517,
0.0144902067,
-0.0875475556,
-0.0974279121,
0.0277901925,
0.0049704206,
0.0474004261,
0.0711122155,
0.0258933194,
-0.0111123221,
0.0081220809,
-0.0303867571,
0.0066413344,
0.019398829,
-0.0025409567,
0.0696799159,
0.0524525158,
0.0009547109,
-0.072086513,
-0.000150186,
0.0017407282,
-0.0263750348,
-0.019165149,
0.0736518949,
-0.0626347363,
-0.0427438617,
-0.0547249429,
0.0615499727,
0.0758478343,
0.0594241694,
0.0019240618,
-0.0210693907,
-0.0189569518,
-0.0263643116,
0.056382753,
0.0416867323,
0.0129997926,
0.0142068006,
-0.0110923816,
-0.0413990542,
-0.0308798775,
-0.0209349226,
-0.0125162164,
0.0043939874,
0.0472915471,
-0.0256694425,
0.0746547058,
0.0033487466,
-0.0430851988,
0.0479082763,
0.0675953552,
-0.0040533636,
0.0034563558,
0.0381445996,
0.041420117,
0.0001596588,
-0.0184050426,
0.0279973783,
0.0207339264,
-0.0111191226,
-0.012863907,
0.1075232551,
0.0322982036,
-0.0364913531,
-0.0144761,
-0.0500352159,
0.0487340651,
0.0091649387,
0.0077101616,
-0.054154817,
0.0261781681,
0.0497375615,
-0.0038340513,
0.032992281,
-0.0192864295,
0.0334157497,
-0.0099822329,
0.0094003174,
-0.0427841954,
-0.022024462,
0.0018594312,
0.0059962263,
0.0258208886,
-0.0253108889,
-0.0413477644,
-0.0053540054,
0.0025887561,
-0.0438949689,
-0.0039677103,
-0.0062304502,
0.0252807662,
0.0010523094,
0.0056076623,
-0.0108897975,
-0.0383214951,
-0.0451786332,
-0.0633843318,
0.0331488773,
0.0211203676,
0.0317164212,
0.0206426922,
-0.0080667976,
0.0398087576,
0.0178422108,
0.0076102456,
-0.0143032549,
0.0341891721,
0.0335230827,
0.0330518857,
-0.0117098838,
0.0066830087,
-0.0095226299,
0.0256655775,
-0.0155621879,
-0.1020696685,
-0.0264978092,
0.0097233132,
-0.035774231,
-0.0121307597,
0.0099445134,
-0.0635923892,
0.0049507325,
-0.0394922532,
0.0464549065,
0.0282812472,
0.0273700412,
0.0603136346,
0.0082549565,
-0.0304226782,
-0.0883409828,
0.0357013084,
0.0057024644,
0.035992045,
-0.0773724914,
-0.0696061477,
-0.0282953791,
-0.0221282039,
-0.0046351752,
-0.0049795667,
-0.0145382481,
0.0292995572,
-0.079431951,
-0.0402009301,
0.0484281778,
-0.011624692,
0.0061550196,
-0.0435928814,
0.0369984992,
0.0145581551,
0.0173964985,
-0.0192062706,
0.001089078,
-0.0178089943,
-0.0081329821,
0.0064806077,
-0.0433884896,
-5.336242196e-33,
-0.0123424055,
-0.0605404004,
-0.0203776564,
-0.023876166,
0.0517028831,
0.0243528038,
-0.0565650687,
0.0314927362,
-0.002586161,
0.0900481567,
0.0093216244,
0.0069964463,
0.0130944159,
0.045653712,
0.0186936688,
-0.0471474007,
0.0155818453,
0.012890161,
0.0273940209,
-0.0027100269,
0.0130657488,
0.0419887714,
0.0027047715,
-0.1124871895,
0.0750666782,
0.0249718968,
-0.0024902963,
0.0254205856,
0.0036516758,
0.0127876475,
0.0228032023,
0.0347508453,
0.0098514939,
-0.0370976366,
-0.0363741964,
0.0200783741,
-0.0078010513,
-0.0472013764,
0.0004415107,
-0.0065517719,
-0.0495925806,
-0.0166654307,
0.0265842769,
-0.0051979586,
-0.0631335899,
0.0151949879,
0.0405627899,
-0.0413221084,
0.03613263,
-0.0340518169,
-0.0079375785,
0.0190109964,
-0.043772269,
-0.0240346733,
0.0141469371,
0.0510600172,
-0.0538072176,
-0.0091843437,
0.0053431485,
-0.0249035303,
0.0034044839,
-0.0083548483,
0.0694192201,
-0.0414864235,
-0.0186043829,
0.0292012468,
-0.0103672147,
-0.0085576419,
-0.0547539778,
-0.0061675012,
-0.079539597,
0.0389483683,
0.0583098419,
0.030735733,
-0.0129074948,
0.0086864671,
-0.1259044707,
0.0405701809,
-0.0769580007,
0.0668490455,
0.0097233402,
-0.0039708256,
-0.0925741717,
-0.0204558279,
-0.0351637825,
-0.0401287042,
0.001185471,
-0.0308719408,
0.0115719205,
-0.0639105141,
0.0003449162,
0.0265722629,
-0.0180884972,
0.0047491542,
0.004297771,
-0.0430811867,
0.0643649697,
-0.029962711,
0.0000593508,
0.0370605104,
0.0359437093,
0.027759606,
-0.0010927577,
0.0196006,
0.0556826182,
0.0231086835,
0.02209723,
-0.008390517,
-0.0158985835,
-0.0034711529,
0.0057201982,
-0.0115755117,
0.0048068101,
-0.0142179374,
0.0051220888,
0.0347049423,
-0.008602744,
0.0804014206,
0.0344055556,
0.0287076551,
0.0225251541,
0.0019316589,
-0.0117989099,
-0.0083034756,
-0.0351658762,
-0.0360774957,
-0.0206837934,
-0.014187823,
0.0066350745,
-0.0613475665,
0.0011587524,
-0.0052295588,
2.729e-7,
0.1054903418,
0.0633919984,
0.0084955348,
0.0345440842,
0.0349948518,
0.0099659469,
0.0046696682,
-0.0234038923,
-0.0131410966,
-0.0208456274,
0.0539209917,
0.0172009431,
0.0336686261,
0.0005101842,
0.0122416047,
-0.0609040819,
-0.0429776385,
0.0049608215,
0.0019241042,
0.0133432662,
0.0797724798,
0.0674655437,
-0.0101991501,
0.0015075912,
0.0063847322,
0.0390287302,
0.013397553,
-0.0496792048,
0.0359315649,
0.0701168925,
0.0488645546,
0.0123388916,
0.01788426,
0.0505350716,
-0.0204559471,
-0.0804070085,
0.0029090864,
0.0817186758,
-0.0420184769,
-0.0018140879,
0.0305547491,
0.0105270958,
0.0740287378,
-0.0321616381,
0.0066493955,
-0.0439719409,
-0.0953670815,
0.0026177377,
0.0426527336,
-0.0145283006,
0.0864431411,
-0.0024881137,
-0.0153320143,
0.0076035694,
-0.0075562201,
0.0365330763,
-0.0063283662,
-0.0163375326,
-0.024776103,
0.0559917353,
-0.0063431249,
-0.0311633516,
0.0296518318,
-0.0168983769,
0.0366140567,
-0.0710698813,
0.0183163937,
2.157862327e-34,
0.0466847569,
0.0216666535,
-0.0186831634,
0.0061532846,
0.0621447749,
0.0347804949,
0.0121500259,
0.0041623469,
0.0749180913,
0.0118214823,
-0.0087864958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17505v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17505v3 | Arrows of Time for Large Language Models | 2024-01-30T23:46:35 | 2024-06-03T17:35:04 | Vassilis Papadopoulos, Jérémie Wenger, Clément Hongler | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We study the probabilistic modeling performed by Autoregressive Large
Language Models (LLMs) through the angle of time directionality, addressing a
question first raised in (Shannon, 1951). For large enough models, we
empirically find a time asymmetry in their ability to learn natural language: a
difference in the average log-perplexity when trying to predict the next token
versus when trying to predict the previous one. This difference is at the same
time subtle and very consistent across various modalities (language, model
size, training time, ...). Theoretically, this is surprising: from an
information-theoretic point of view, there should be no such difference. We
provide a theoretical framework to explain how such an asymmetry can appear
from sparsity and computational complexity considerations, and outline a number
of perspectives opened by our results. | Arrows of Time for Large Language Models: We study the probabilistic modeling performed by Autoregressive Large
Language Models (LLMs) through the angle of time directionality, addressing a
question first raised in (Shannon, 1951). For large enough models, we
empirically find a time asymmetry in their ability to learn natural language: a
difference in the average log-perplexity when trying to predict the next token
versus when trying to predict the previous one. This difference is at the same
time subtle and very consistent across various modalities (language, model
size, training time, ...). Theoretically, this is surprising: from an
information-theoretic point of view, there should be no such difference. We
provide a theoretical framework to explain how such an asymmetry can appear
from sparsity and computational complexity considerations, and outline a number
of perspectives opened by our results. | [
0.0082445331,
0.059250325,
-0.0125474846,
0.0237362143,
-0.0835999921,
0.0333408602,
-0.0285944697,
-0.0048918901,
-0.0524050444,
-0.0243517291,
-0.0001308468,
-0.0794593692,
0.0352503881,
-0.0012176068,
0.0065077236,
-0.0178683419,
0.0370724201,
-0.0899301469,
-0.0135692721,
-0.0492841117,
-0.0354227796,
-0.0552998036,
-0.0166134816,
0.042042952,
0.0387688763,
0.011546649,
-0.0123648662,
-0.025353618,
-0.040492747,
-0.030169066,
-0.0560202226,
0.025348084,
-0.0219990294,
0.070319511,
0.0000015345,
-0.0408018865,
0.032539662,
0.0131980218,
-0.0506213456,
0.0486459695,
0.0012756839,
-0.0038865653,
-0.0093275895,
0.0308653694,
-0.0124963736,
-0.0303860046,
0.0572856255,
0.0259239823,
-0.0388678275,
0.0478085876,
0.0125149237,
-0.0269675925,
0.0385204516,
-0.0634211376,
0.0496220067,
-0.042218253,
-0.0007412648,
-0.0307667479,
-0.0198699366,
0.0010278684,
-0.0718148127,
0.0448861159,
0.0064108511,
0.0383603685,
0.0063485862,
0.0599255897,
0.0434456468,
-0.0052015539,
-0.019694915,
0.0176362246,
-0.0268003698,
-0.0059939744,
-0.016813457,
-0.0068543935,
-0.0150755141,
0.0264988374,
-0.0407517739,
0.0140070552,
0.0222923551,
0.0298893955,
0.0727292821,
0.0225171186,
0.0637480244,
-0.0114338724,
-0.0370656401,
0.0623316951,
0.0269932579,
-0.0267504621,
-0.0191083457,
0.0043040132,
0.0167944618,
-0.0422928222,
-0.0655871108,
0.0359939709,
0.0272996724,
0.0103381183,
0.0052296147,
0.0406489447,
0.0001608961,
-0.0067935102,
0.0553883836,
0.0059209466,
0.0314981192,
0.0427514315,
-0.0156722832,
0.0397753455,
-0.0069792061,
-0.0080520939,
-0.0174611416,
0.0026551625,
-0.0280614104,
-0.0186841749,
0.0076754135,
0.0080771446,
0.0298229884,
-0.0127852401,
-0.0442940332,
0.0032113737,
0.0228288416,
-0.0143363243,
0.010704766,
-0.0209984127,
-0.0353402682,
-0.0185441524,
-0.0598522425,
0.0272280313,
-0.0039482238,
0.0276386011,
-0.0304623637,
-0.0191818234,
-0.027297413,
0.0203120541,
-0.0048700161,
-0.0151050491,
-0.0023956338,
0.0459482819,
-0.010233229,
-0.0197856426,
-0.0318723582,
0.0076638525,
-0.0223021712,
-0.0439292565,
0.0150090316,
-0.0380204916,
-0.0051544872,
0.056756299,
-0.0186163578,
-0.0153860869,
0.0122547876,
-0.0259575546,
-0.0325885788,
0.0683907643,
0.0418735482,
0.034545444,
0.0090970024,
-0.025723137,
0.0239996091,
0.0695326626,
0.0245316103,
-0.0182244498,
0.0141148036,
-0.0300355405,
-0.005244452,
0.0422319993,
0.0100153303,
0.0210423023,
-0.029424388,
-0.0200728718,
0.0430834778,
0.0453101732,
0.0495700985,
0.0690997019,
-0.0096144276,
-0.0318663567,
0.0416999273,
0.053586103,
0.0486031175,
0.000155382,
0.037159428,
-0.0188534651,
0.0071175355,
0.0513797216,
-0.0307262186,
0.0174578261,
-0.0050118584,
0.0257807355,
0.0317917541,
0.0077415365,
-0.0360133313,
-0.028624488,
0.0021766745,
-0.0213111546,
0.0086006634,
-0.0048569357,
0.0614998043,
-0.025032755,
-0.0430120565,
0.0303516239,
0.020287402,
0.0180384237,
0.0028892974,
-0.0637239516,
-0.0069157826,
0.0120096682,
0.0139999427,
0.0103532495,
0.0282813367,
0.0000130613,
-0.008215189,
0.007049717,
0.0267388523,
0.0093057379,
0.0220729336,
-0.0040700701,
-0.0056002666,
0.0323061943,
0.0152987633,
0.0203370117,
-0.00540207,
0.0422987789,
0.0115979388,
-0.0190815125,
-0.0234257448,
0.0273165405,
-0.0614500269,
-0.0461692475,
-0.0002373188,
0.009431405,
0.0583759919,
-0.018332094,
-0.0392694883,
0.0451081097,
0.0265690591,
-0.0761188492,
-0.0045762863,
0.0389251225,
-0.0591415949,
-0.0167979021,
0.0506377071,
-0.0021484834,
0.0203729104,
0.01625246,
0.0201638266,
-0.062924929,
0.060416773,
-0.0264154896,
0.1272565275,
-0.0105767734,
0.0326317623,
-0.0093806274,
0.0321648195,
-0.0295413733,
0.0440838225,
-0.0314729176,
0.0485895984,
-0.0201021358,
-0.0032091623,
-0.0021938344,
-0.0092302887,
-0.0013820768,
0.0370845236,
0.0129889473,
-0.0256384481,
0.0033212716,
-0.0504583679,
0.0180743169,
-0.049280148,
-0.0471478179,
-0.0401826389,
-0.0249306262,
0.0296403393,
-0.0379014872,
-0.0178102925,
0.0141318282,
-0.0040948298,
-0.0285709277,
0.0183970332,
0.01072622,
0.0351422653,
0.029437365,
0.0211281218,
-0.0678465515,
-0.0343491212,
-0.0469151139,
-0.0037609057,
0.0542736314,
0.0141128507,
-0.0119473673,
-0.04188646,
0.0461550876,
0.0025887911,
0.0226128548,
-0.0407834351,
-0.0335647129,
-0.004402244,
-0.029111458,
0.06093207,
0.057376802,
0.0325718671,
0.0427017547,
0.0364898592,
-0.0066843764,
0.0002234719,
-0.0199660659,
-0.0400955752,
-0.0247995388,
-0.059793748,
-0.0571253859,
-0.0054057455,
0.0820612386,
-0.0088613024,
-0.0128665399,
-0.0250601731,
-0.0036280977,
-0.029480949,
-0.0269581005,
0.0015331876,
0.0194889586,
-0.0181476902,
0.0281302258,
-0.0214231629,
-0.0762178227,
0.0296399239,
-0.0384707935,
0.0153130349,
0.0126223266,
-0.0276426375,
-0.0455166511,
0.1141999811,
0.0307152905,
0.0150342947,
-0.0095447432,
-0.041015774,
-0.0406291597,
-0.0118549932,
0.0563649014,
-0.014235571,
0.0426869877,
-0.0244985726,
0.0247367602,
-0.0065130726,
-0.0370747447,
0.0045269243,
-0.0759514719,
-0.0426324084,
-0.0082665468,
0.0207592752,
-0.0589345247,
-0.0088524912,
0.030724695,
0.0115246689,
-0.0060425433,
-0.0223334208,
0.0010420134,
0.012072322,
0.0070027011,
0.0520295426,
-0.0182172712,
0.0146460887,
-0.0530387238,
0.0572178252,
-0.0097601786,
0.0662903562,
0.0535376519,
-0.0213482417,
-0.0079522775,
0.0196231604,
-0.0225564893,
-0.0726391971,
0.044788342,
0.0118238591,
-0.0164447706,
-0.0000324014,
0.0937611237,
-0.0038306462,
-0.0589444786,
0.0265739653,
0.0031265086,
0.0281391479,
0.0211776029,
-0.0203296598,
-0.0219128001,
-0.0276042633,
0.0115628857,
0.0055100606,
-0.0132339392,
-0.0390551575,
0.0005821149,
-0.1119553968,
-0.0251137,
0.0109113632,
-0.0228719115,
-0.0580393709,
-0.0293598063,
-0.0303324368,
-0.0127046565,
0.0259494148,
0.0176125746,
-0.0555478781,
0.0124192564,
0.0347639769,
-0.0617427118,
-0.0219183601,
0.0226288736,
-0.0160160568,
0.0878049433,
0.0264798831,
-0.0022777123,
-0.04040635,
-0.0278394166,
0.0215664301,
-0.009395944,
0.0156622138,
0.0021876046,
0.0042173853,
0.0319544449,
-0.0162990578,
-0.0042620967,
0.0068881991,
0.0063743242,
0.0403813496,
-0.0136394212,
0.0589191541,
-0.0290222894,
-0.0509461425,
0.0088610873,
-0.0234146323,
-0.0000698237,
0.1061389223,
0.0069431262,
-0.0313256383,
-0.0655770004,
-0.0109186834,
0.0258620456,
0.0265952405,
-0.0306471884,
0.0131043633,
0.027302945,
-0.0523882024,
-0.0313717797,
0.0067640715,
-0.0188159011,
0.0672539473,
0.0048807347,
0.0695745498,
-0.0010701178,
0.0072651496,
-0.0173699688,
-0.0382395647,
-0.004355236,
0.0124223437,
-0.0976893678,
0.0008851356,
0.0374341309,
-0.013783982,
-0.0292622056,
-0.0183748491,
-0.1044263989,
-0.0770965144,
0.040376246,
-0.0257820804,
0.0305579677,
0.0411811173,
0.0378959365,
-0.0543916225,
0.0211263839,
0.0346586592,
0.0233555064,
0.0531069115,
0.0130347963,
0.037264999,
0.0101640113,
0.0647894591,
-0.028241355,
-0.0178938489,
-0.0112443836,
0.0081999535,
-0.0475667603,
-0.026218256,
-0.0147675285,
0.019886056,
0.0633121356,
0.0041057523,
-0.0148402993,
0.0200077146,
0.0093821809,
0.0077797668,
0.0149129098,
-0.0170831457,
-0.0126983579,
0.0670946538,
0.0120104272,
-0.0056340564,
0.0091127837,
0.0258703642,
0.0135837793,
-0.0273080897,
0.0005518695,
-0.0313753039,
-0.0060501089,
0.0447230823,
0.0121457381,
-0.009521028,
0.0339501612,
0.0007230403,
0.0197421201,
0.0307671726,
0.0048133177,
0.0058529149,
0.0483931862,
-0.0519248359,
-0.0567661561,
-0.1148468629,
-0.0724676028,
0.0401851982,
-0.0010447357,
0.0618840717,
-0.0159244742,
0.0412063561,
-0.0559974015,
0.0137540121,
-0.0125232087,
0.0104587236,
-0.0023096045,
-0.0094100721,
0.0588014834,
-0.0026613977,
-0.0191938039,
0.0361137837,
0.10500741,
0.0772498772,
0.0668428689,
0.0249249972,
-0.0113405194,
-0.0058828108,
-0.0413370132,
0.0172246713,
-0.015580087,
-0.0095446911,
0.0163291134,
-0.048407197,
-0.0705487728,
-0.0049802191,
-0.0205299333,
0.0151717896,
-0.0439372435,
0.0111568971,
0.0699353814,
0.0102040628,
-0.0302628484,
-0.0429260954,
0.0388262793,
0.0133367022,
-0.0090577845,
-0.0223347023,
-6.09057786e-33,
0.0068744416,
-0.0026556363,
-0.0100663891,
-0.0058289059,
0.0213793572,
0.0021057241,
0.010194676,
0.035332337,
-0.0419956669,
0.0033192637,
-0.0135162789,
0.0276273806,
0.0120077031,
0.0225956552,
0.0306269042,
-0.0246312432,
0.0413524173,
-0.0312513076,
0.0212923996,
0.0204866715,
0.0114063416,
0.0139043769,
0.0341210105,
-0.0190334544,
-0.0103524625,
-0.0119602056,
-0.0058450582,
0.0321472958,
0.0150964968,
0.0478033349,
-0.0261174198,
0.0283980779,
0.0173928067,
-0.0277798083,
-0.0168527607,
-0.0426702872,
-0.0142584806,
-0.0265599154,
0.0178050008,
0.0021231624,
-0.0009818665,
-0.0243705735,
0.0314296037,
0.0041980692,
-0.0803106427,
-0.0137910591,
0.0036483514,
0.0093863225,
-0.075235717,
-0.0108825509,
-0.0101955514,
0.0372635573,
-0.0044183251,
-0.01627912,
0.0184980556,
-0.0165711045,
-0.0025835466,
-0.0183852147,
-0.0171131156,
0.0156557653,
0.0230554789,
0.0875361711,
0.0128192147,
0.052425012,
0.0292405169,
0.0500496291,
0.0887912065,
0.0146986311,
-0.0311782993,
0.0074113477,
0.0284868237,
0.0053195222,
-0.0062021259,
-0.0420450829,
0.0977983102,
0.0074147512,
-0.0737991259,
-0.0399296731,
0.0544606075,
0.0507324599,
0.0276794136,
0.014212803,
-0.0838045627,
-0.0462838747,
-0.0510766581,
-0.0400480591,
-0.0067952219,
0.0112895248,
-0.0001099118,
0.0306153912,
0.0461526588,
-0.041660998,
0.0456974059,
-0.0198723916,
-0.0748062357,
0.0107957143,
-0.0076556397,
0.0179611072,
-0.0048979535,
0.0386990644,
-0.0658267736,
-0.0226321034,
-0.05391597,
0.0358655713,
0.0018421793,
-0.0056305318,
-0.0021196047,
0.0301635768,
-0.0978336185,
-0.0478689782,
-0.0244632252,
-0.0074859797,
0.0347416177,
-0.0417115688,
0.0793932676,
-0.0553804561,
0.0043768473,
0.0365646705,
-0.0026386993,
0.0045173909,
0.0053448286,
-0.0142793348,
-0.0000632661,
0.0164895281,
-0.019149214,
-0.0251171198,
-0.0466273166,
0.0059517482,
0.0641327649,
-0.0488179252,
-0.0286614206,
0.0183944069,
2.381e-7,
0.0143630849,
0.0283143502,
0.0227861051,
0.0674888492,
0.0519282483,
0.0210130271,
-0.0109786401,
-0.0006421591,
-0.0290619675,
0.0288534071,
0.001177749,
0.025951257,
0.0421557464,
-0.0172426645,
-0.0230833162,
-0.0142585468,
-0.0927538052,
0.0478302948,
-0.0450627953,
-0.0023835734,
0.0021047709,
0.0891776457,
-0.0183420926,
0.0006173317,
-0.010514765,
-0.0682908222,
0.0679661706,
-0.0476797707,
0.023719145,
0.005778037,
0.0318036117,
0.0022260942,
-0.0075637009,
-0.0005585032,
-0.0054811696,
0.0166530628,
-0.0416795611,
0.00292687,
-0.0199291445,
-0.0248646084,
-0.0066490709,
-0.0175680928,
-0.0176970772,
-0.0135169495,
0.0960310623,
-0.0261806939,
-0.0678375438,
-0.0611477345,
0.0317045711,
0.0260147117,
0.0277859606,
0.0218888819,
-0.0287202802,
0.0002702741,
0.0138645796,
-0.037934307,
0.0119336946,
-0.0727802292,
-0.0182077251,
0.0136825647,
-0.0376638435,
-0.0521708652,
-0.0602900013,
0.0382709131,
0.0741775781,
-0.0185520556,
-0.0126812905,
2.307933007e-34,
0.0793823674,
-0.0344761759,
0.0157971382,
0.0231473893,
0.0317840688,
-0.0297394004,
0.0237785392,
0.0017674502,
0.0281351823,
-0.1094254851,
-0.0246234313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01763v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01763v2 | When Large Language Models Meet Vector Databases: A Survey | 2024-01-30T23:35:28 | 2024-02-06T01:25:18 | Zhi Jing, Yongye Su, Yikun Han, Bo Yuan, Haiyun Xu, Chunjiang Liu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This survey explores the synergistic potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) and Vector Databases (VecDBs), a burgeoning but rapidly evolving
research area. With the proliferation of LLMs comes a host of challenges,
including hallucinations, outdated knowledge, prohibitive commercial
application costs, and memory issues. VecDBs emerge as a compelling solution to
these issues by offering an efficient means to store, retrieve, and manage the
high-dimensional vector representations intrinsic to LLM operations. Through
this nuanced review, we delineate the foundational principles of LLMs and
VecDBs and critically analyze their integration's impact on enhancing LLM
functionalities. This discourse extends into a discussion on the speculative
future developments in this domain, aiming to catalyze further research into
optimizing the confluence of LLMs and VecDBs for advanced data handling and
knowledge extraction capabilities. | When Large Language Models Meet Vector Databases: A Survey: This survey explores the synergistic potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) and Vector Databases (VecDBs), a burgeoning but rapidly evolving
research area. With the proliferation of LLMs comes a host of challenges,
including hallucinations, outdated knowledge, prohibitive commercial
application costs, and memory issues. VecDBs emerge as a compelling solution to
these issues by offering an efficient means to store, retrieve, and manage the
high-dimensional vector representations intrinsic to LLM operations. Through
this nuanced review, we delineate the foundational principles of LLMs and
VecDBs and critically analyze their integration's impact on enhancing LLM
functionalities. This discourse extends into a discussion on the speculative
future developments in this domain, aiming to catalyze further research into
optimizing the confluence of LLMs and VecDBs for advanced data handling and
knowledge extraction capabilities. | [
0.0099891759,
0.0760010779,
-0.0498030819,
0.0569494627,
-0.0202011131,
0.0216457266,
0.0162205566,
0.0247803275,
-0.0280646402,
-0.0427889042,
-0.0055546174,
-0.0827065632,
-0.0292732064,
-0.0222448055,
-0.0097072907,
-0.0196634885,
0.043887537,
-0.0533295721,
-0.0088719232,
0.003755755,
-0.006280113,
0.0163403209,
0.0264894851,
-0.0021315264,
-0.0019906429,
0.00139015,
0.010383958,
-0.0398423672,
-0.0223391131,
0.0217451975,
-0.0234777145,
0.0245984793,
0.0569752604,
0.0644811317,
0.0000020866,
-0.0155122885,
-0.0517218672,
0.0217813011,
-0.0244995225,
0.0343585685,
0.0262594186,
-0.0414726846,
-0.0229138602,
-0.0311115235,
0.0042710439,
-0.0485067405,
0.017177647,
-0.0317217559,
0.0297238883,
0.019317586,
-0.0168786254,
-0.0545389839,
0.0215872973,
-0.0024634392,
-0.0250878371,
-0.0289002266,
0.0589853004,
0.0425315052,
0.0296150558,
0.0223767255,
-0.021186024,
0.0568452477,
-0.0375556126,
-0.0119449245,
-0.0077599739,
0.0283659417,
0.0341380946,
0.0514993407,
-0.0008821528,
0.0177813079,
-0.0010953402,
-0.0042314953,
0.0613107607,
0.0227848217,
-0.0459723547,
0.0052176705,
-0.0457609966,
0.0573018156,
-0.013962361,
0.0104031619,
0.0200948175,
-0.0603163466,
0.0202815048,
0.0118970172,
-0.0595041886,
-0.0024703008,
0.0442384444,
-0.0374637246,
-0.0332500525,
-0.0472095758,
-0.0009974829,
-0.0442734659,
0.0185246021,
0.0075952951,
0.0182508137,
0.0495164953,
-0.0054887915,
-0.0649377853,
0.0392772704,
-0.1240862831,
0.0959040076,
0.0155510111,
-0.0120146172,
0.0630416051,
0.0121324463,
0.0524271652,
-0.0625152513,
0.0192858893,
-0.0274459198,
-0.0221921857,
-0.0486864746,
-0.0136381807,
-0.0126607399,
0.0508770682,
-0.0118831573,
-0.0000524344,
-0.0280655399,
0.0448075756,
0.0322244763,
0.0192000102,
-0.0394381769,
-0.0225254167,
0.0453842469,
-0.0131438924,
-0.023951672,
0.0352364331,
0.0034889753,
-0.0289359204,
-0.0425767899,
-0.0283701885,
-0.0098766349,
0.0035291864,
0.0160621703,
-0.0659993738,
0.0404385366,
-0.0043933513,
0.032493446,
-0.032443855,
-0.0021039152,
-0.00237884,
-0.0459622778,
-0.0702399462,
0.0143549042,
-0.0714474842,
0.0701455325,
0.0474566109,
-0.0398803689,
-0.0311826728,
-0.0169168171,
0.0123300357,
-0.0743402764,
0.0221401881,
0.000274782,
0.0236194767,
0.022073945,
-0.0057061864,
0.0688594282,
0.0111128399,
-0.0219729114,
-0.0039879926,
0.005823968,
-0.035072986,
-0.0120326234,
0.0258685444,
0.025124494,
-0.0018439313,
-0.0704962909,
0.0612033866,
0.0573775582,
0.0071835238,
0.0142812058,
0.0657333583,
-0.0275538489,
-0.0479801968,
0.0561350398,
0.042543944,
0.002936346,
0.0349548273,
0.0366350487,
0.0011500411,
0.018660143,
-0.0372985117,
0.0024553614,
-0.012933448,
-0.0377656221,
-0.010042889,
0.0093463343,
0.0376236178,
-0.0085650487,
-0.006979771,
-0.0464202724,
-0.0228214581,
-0.0011366842,
0.0188086219,
0.1001903266,
-0.0483548939,
0.0292695705,
0.0640803799,
0.020175375,
-0.0455846265,
-0.0098268641,
-0.0209208317,
0.045443926,
0.0328646712,
0.0345020294,
-0.039174363,
-0.0214433298,
0.0165168867,
0.0143787917,
-0.0128533365,
0.0430719592,
-0.0036390435,
-0.0136956312,
-0.0295910668,
0.0259844344,
0.0279439576,
0.0158243515,
0.0229030214,
-0.0040260591,
0.0123491632,
-0.004323082,
-0.0277254842,
-0.0461200923,
-0.0114788655,
-0.0193721894,
0.0051437202,
-0.0218202341,
-0.0176169407,
0.0305365827,
0.0339179859,
-0.0358040221,
0.0070644803,
0.0567388125,
-0.0704061761,
-0.0367962793,
-0.0084321955,
0.0091190068,
0.0612069964,
0.0455515943,
0.0543108433,
0.0236554965,
-0.0513050556,
0.013735855,
0.0090108486,
0.0190824885,
-0.0285564866,
0.0271800589,
-0.0552107207,
0.0433575734,
-0.0106425295,
0.01076183,
-0.0248284638,
0.0830102712,
-0.0157330409,
0.0293846466,
0.0432250388,
-0.0206876695,
0.0198434554,
-0.0218847487,
-0.0191229731,
0.064355284,
0.0238017552,
0.0334048569,
0.0092440573,
-0.0750581399,
-0.0005079139,
-0.0077940673,
-0.0470229648,
0.0377411321,
-0.0034141459,
0.0327826738,
-0.0329528637,
0.0154409716,
-0.0005251107,
0.0480554625,
-0.0315579213,
-0.0079031046,
0.0153735904,
0.0334337242,
0.0004470072,
0.0164400525,
-0.0384222418,
-0.0068763983,
-0.0409056693,
-0.0176035687,
0.051667463,
-0.0348849893,
-0.0072649941,
-0.0372267291,
-0.0004918702,
-0.0617412962,
0.0316547006,
-0.0377661698,
0.0196794681,
-0.0329915285,
-0.1141324788,
0.0239960253,
-0.0111089181,
-0.0097101526,
0.0105755311,
0.0577605255,
-0.0531187132,
-0.032382153,
-0.0071713571,
-0.0495403036,
-0.0108397705,
-0.0434914716,
0.024584379,
-0.0095621319,
0.0248953924,
-0.0083353445,
0.0067202151,
-0.0302035417,
0.015112198,
-0.0089751482,
0.0198298562,
-0.0398173258,
-0.0047272784,
-0.0209585764,
0.041468665,
0.008748956,
-0.02831438,
0.0297245122,
-0.0307474416,
0.0024065443,
-0.0209070724,
-0.0376295149,
-0.0584803857,
0.041643139,
-0.0045447662,
0.0287293028,
-0.0490633845,
0.0075153653,
0.022890972,
0.0227039531,
-0.0379106626,
-0.05562355,
0.0614441,
-0.0214143712,
0.0383378677,
-0.0083578229,
-0.0256652404,
-0.0377117656,
-0.015645735,
-0.015919419,
0.0069402158,
0.0641275346,
-0.0319430977,
0.0192455817,
0.053893391,
0.0135633675,
-0.00098548,
0.0176841393,
0.0074245553,
-0.018619461,
0.0397587344,
0.019359868,
0.0069731846,
0.0043076077,
0.0142477946,
-0.0266308244,
0.054638233,
0.0238001384,
-0.0299607068,
0.014388686,
-0.0094782794,
0.0653972477,
-0.0230345931,
-0.0157370567,
0.0013521654,
-0.0504448973,
-0.0571325496,
-0.0237691291,
0.0878075212,
0.0468596555,
-0.0395703204,
-0.0046807434,
0.0121322237,
-0.0242653638,
-0.0102175297,
0.0449307486,
-0.0991553888,
0.0331288315,
-0.0156208882,
0.0058907373,
0.0177845061,
-0.0218581166,
-0.0070885373,
-0.1075270772,
0.0396616124,
0.0174922291,
0.0124373483,
-0.0362313315,
-0.0477474555,
-0.0009445552,
0.0105415182,
0.0239499044,
0.0171929542,
-0.0257390048,
-0.026182089,
0.0246769581,
-0.0491967984,
-0.0525593013,
0.0357809551,
-0.0421128012,
0.033219263,
0.0365608074,
0.059118785,
-0.0159522258,
-0.0704923943,
-0.0690653846,
-0.0581141077,
-0.0164598115,
-0.0492308736,
0.0112906862,
0.0005757965,
-0.0205176752,
-0.0032637364,
-0.0046849963,
0.0123851141,
-0.0086928019,
-0.0127427708,
0.0780948102,
-0.031778641,
-0.0194763076,
-0.002570305,
-0.0328625552,
-0.0382234938,
0.0867940858,
-0.0032057534,
-0.0257038102,
-0.0138903018,
0.0009296981,
-0.0259617809,
0.0075274319,
-0.0631062463,
0.0028753493,
-0.0096801408,
-0.0165565014,
-0.0261810813,
0.0081395302,
0.040898677,
-0.0001155717,
-0.0088544739,
0.0337649211,
0.0187616032,
-0.038257774,
-0.0726122931,
-0.0105797602,
-0.0500599667,
0.0280485358,
-0.0213281307,
0.0065992852,
0.0243162438,
-0.0193954911,
-0.0342107862,
0.0183701869,
-0.0534750223,
-0.0829753056,
0.0488101244,
0.0352398343,
0.010030535,
0.0464626551,
0.0296886619,
-0.0485764109,
0.0319055691,
0.013996671,
-0.0016178834,
0.0056756856,
-0.0126085365,
0.0024510638,
-0.0049481536,
0.0246578511,
-0.0360901244,
0.0071555297,
0.0269397981,
0.0045547066,
-0.0336529166,
-0.0256672204,
0.0128512522,
0.0472794361,
0.0263200738,
0.0270736385,
-0.0260532498,
-0.0234983787,
0.0156898666,
-0.0770693496,
-0.0087580616,
-0.0200021528,
-0.0353772044,
-0.009329644,
0.0109986262,
-0.0433853902,
0.0228256658,
0.0198736731,
0.0027140588,
-0.0368719473,
0.0235489458,
-0.0036504967,
-0.001269179,
0.0651959926,
-0.0200843439,
0.0129924854,
0.0207051821,
-0.0024297202,
0.0547396392,
-0.0635098293,
0.0413151793,
0.0188912842,
-0.030178884,
-0.0183095001,
0.023804849,
-0.0261874143,
-0.0662958696,
0.0397608355,
0.0252382234,
0.0766582116,
-0.0298176538,
0.0575308539,
-0.0617348291,
-0.0280910879,
-0.0154394498,
-0.0173268989,
0.0452199988,
-0.0017020631,
0.0199475195,
0.0402395204,
-0.048884511,
-0.0106550995,
0.0250182319,
-0.0041333828,
0.0491512343,
-0.0140998969,
-0.026116766,
-0.007495048,
-0.0229721293,
0.0184682105,
0.0074022319,
-0.0430972874,
-0.0260353088,
-0.1170634031,
-0.0356308855,
0.0483731553,
-0.0007066399,
-0.0444419384,
-0.0519111603,
-0.0025730364,
0.0508718938,
0.0368079506,
0.0142185884,
-0.037868198,
0.0276632775,
-0.090758346,
-0.028420262,
0.0389942713,
-6.262657008e-33,
0.0098120011,
0.0161774233,
0.0142055573,
-0.0092678359,
-0.0205429643,
0.0072798003,
-0.0106718158,
-0.0075799949,
0.0205310863,
-0.0362915173,
-0.0153832491,
0.0022790264,
0.0061113117,
-0.0008315602,
0.0181809515,
0.0098508988,
0.0519073717,
0.0064450135,
0.0389309078,
0.0380102359,
0.0758756995,
0.0356828645,
0.0431363955,
-0.1085794941,
0.0411176197,
-0.0314342752,
0.0485513322,
0.0393250436,
0.0277090892,
0.0621667653,
-0.0477469377,
0.0395529307,
0.0012986789,
-0.0499814302,
-0.0009296885,
-0.0213694796,
-0.0597300492,
0.0627509579,
0.0383275151,
-0.001526507,
0.0384417921,
-0.0302126464,
-0.0021003485,
0.0153613305,
0.0076030632,
0.0293350592,
0.0054444293,
-0.0451376401,
-0.0482559428,
-0.0305296741,
-0.0306756105,
0.0215065628,
0.0141264191,
0.0581113063,
0.1206342354,
-0.069602333,
0.0208133925,
0.0134507203,
-0.0811351612,
0.0287555344,
-0.0070142788,
0.0263114739,
0.0505866669,
0.0260246173,
0.0096993558,
0.0513980798,
0.0553789362,
-0.0340158306,
-0.0039434694,
0.0531633347,
0.0263626128,
0.0628170669,
-0.0074973186,
0.0390712172,
0.0205029882,
-0.0112486519,
-0.0481651425,
0.0060353098,
0.0216228236,
-0.0066902535,
0.0447103977,
0.0001910992,
-0.0592890196,
-0.049721349,
-0.0094865402,
0.0160610266,
-0.0321279876,
-0.0049217539,
0.026441643,
0.0004947466,
-0.0336668305,
0.0457086749,
0.0491001271,
-0.0332843326,
-0.0878276974,
0.0454484858,
0.0164201651,
-0.0126554491,
-0.004766582,
0.0260735266,
-0.0326919816,
-0.0365057029,
-0.0277828667,
-0.0501868837,
-0.0021104147,
0.0136719625,
0.0161910374,
0.0107183065,
-0.0363829508,
0.0076648304,
-0.0280419514,
-0.0089251017,
-0.0393652394,
0.0425630882,
0.0165129863,
0.0392267928,
0.0284757894,
0.0256280173,
0.0776831955,
0.0164029095,
0.0116967764,
-0.0207735579,
0.0209338441,
-0.0122000342,
0.0050292574,
0.0089023085,
-0.0080861803,
0.0009758446,
0.0751030445,
-0.0365279764,
0.0096885832,
-0.0149073666,
2.697e-7,
0.0466180593,
0.0733682737,
0.0150064323,
0.0119510023,
0.0008226507,
0.0118685113,
-0.0173011795,
0.0014716515,
0.0095729232,
0.0347170234,
0.0338922068,
0.046183601,
0.0296024624,
0.0380479097,
-0.0640899092,
0.0183245167,
-0.0243910309,
-0.0146975024,
-0.0831395537,
0.0077635082,
0.0322996937,
0.0799530298,
-0.00085727,
-0.0268526487,
-0.0116556315,
-0.0131532876,
0.0457690842,
-0.0245651323,
0.000296869,
0.0198189095,
0.0264033247,
0.0154970353,
-0.0306616593,
-0.0275337268,
0.0237907432,
0.0575396121,
-0.0093819452,
0.0722134411,
0.0004126523,
0.021766305,
0.0188645869,
-0.0356102772,
-0.0278544314,
-0.0148923211,
0.0682246909,
-0.0370792411,
-0.0152772982,
-0.0272350982,
-0.0202111825,
0.0133474506,
-0.0419500358,
0.0254773926,
0.0041188607,
0.0268226247,
-0.0056598391,
-0.0251119342,
0.0243744683,
-0.08150509,
-0.0031940928,
0.0688291639,
-0.0383706503,
-0.0262072086,
-0.0079435483,
0.0429708585,
0.0134162819,
-0.0712346956,
0.0192657374,
2.912288402e-34,
0.0199132897,
0.0411745161,
-0.0327747315,
0.0269681197,
0.0098783784,
-0.0123216482,
-0.0081685018,
0.0238121916,
-0.0195460692,
-0.1133149117,
-0.0160710551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17498v2 | Improving QA Model Performance with Cartographic Inoculation | 2024-01-30T23:08:26 | 2024-02-01T20:43:02 | Allen Chen, Okan Tanrikulu | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | QA models are faced with complex and open-ended contextual reasoning
problems, but can often learn well-performing solution heuristics by exploiting
dataset-specific patterns in their training data. These patterns, or "dataset
artifacts", reduce the model's ability to generalize to real-world QA problems.
Utilizing an ElectraSmallDiscriminator model trained for QA, we analyze the
impacts and incidence of dataset artifacts using an adversarial challenge set
designed to confuse models reliant on artifacts for prediction. Extending
existing work on methods for mitigating artifact impacts, we propose
cartographic inoculation, a novel method that fine-tunes models on an optimized
subset of the challenge data to reduce model reliance on dataset artifacts. We
show that by selectively fine-tuning a model on ambiguous adversarial examples
from a challenge set, significant performance improvements can be made on the
full challenge dataset with minimal loss of model generalizability to other
challenging environments and QA datasets. | Improving QA Model Performance with Cartographic Inoculation: QA models are faced with complex and open-ended contextual reasoning
problems, but can often learn well-performing solution heuristics by exploiting
dataset-specific patterns in their training data. These patterns, or "dataset
artifacts", reduce the model's ability to generalize to real-world QA problems.
Utilizing an ElectraSmallDiscriminator model trained for QA, we analyze the
impacts and incidence of dataset artifacts using an adversarial challenge set
designed to confuse models reliant on artifacts for prediction. Extending
existing work on methods for mitigating artifact impacts, we propose
cartographic inoculation, a novel method that fine-tunes models on an optimized
subset of the challenge data to reduce model reliance on dataset artifacts. We
show that by selectively fine-tuning a model on ambiguous adversarial examples
from a challenge set, significant performance improvements can be made on the
full challenge dataset with minimal loss of model generalizability to other
challenging environments and QA datasets. | [
0.0319278911,
0.0836739913,
-0.0554964095,
0.0578112975,
-0.0026663309,
0.0438848138,
-0.0081228288,
-0.0474703275,
-0.0144198053,
-0.0085076969,
0.0142291561,
0.0173598472,
-0.0217050537,
0.008557138,
0.0322373621,
-0.0460486561,
0.0299171805,
-0.0148506798,
-0.0757217556,
0.0013259504,
-0.0356503241,
-0.0151364654,
0.0007521969,
0.0140287541,
0.0021660156,
-0.0175418016,
-0.0520059802,
0.0247708,
0.0394727215,
-0.0369539224,
0.0417504311,
0.0054598325,
0.0249775592,
0.012269441,
0.000002431,
-0.0138322245,
-0.0289138034,
0.0089905104,
-0.0620717444,
-0.0152216274,
-0.007153864,
-0.0024563619,
0.0334134325,
0.0210523158,
-0.0250300076,
-0.0078257592,
0.0502257794,
0.0628920719,
0.0535917878,
0.0398702249,
-0.0166809242,
0.0001817686,
-0.00665768,
-0.035304293,
-0.0074609821,
-0.058465708,
0.0211083721,
-0.002013762,
-0.016792139,
-0.0103177102,
-0.0157297812,
0.0020014578,
0.042695187,
0.0870341882,
0.0030704355,
0.0072514201,
-0.0109014334,
0.0463309996,
-0.0055857422,
0.0867752954,
-0.0275383722,
0.0192748085,
0.0113902381,
-0.0002199974,
0.0041311937,
0.0071699843,
-0.0282973647,
-0.0284684151,
-0.0230643153,
0.0109905601,
-0.0459882729,
0.0070945621,
0.0319135711,
0.0165412538,
-0.0576840155,
0.0343403108,
-0.0189695582,
-0.006162059,
-0.0170189105,
-0.0155792786,
-0.0481235646,
-0.0326730236,
-0.0252886638,
0.0365485884,
-0.0593681,
0.0016849214,
0.0166866109,
0.0186770577,
0.0255485587,
0.031143358,
0.0521892086,
0.0061551719,
-0.0169754308,
0.0271721575,
0.0065282895,
0.0411126278,
-0.0336216651,
0.0663634241,
-0.0351763666,
-0.0245357212,
-0.0375097431,
0.0228139441,
-0.0475405529,
0.0017594341,
-0.0375904217,
0.0375984311,
-0.0043443665,
0.0218874775,
-0.0396990068,
0.0389145352,
-0.0704852566,
0.0668402165,
-0.0373762101,
0.0035758168,
-0.0332549289,
-0.0381455198,
-0.0475632995,
0.0363470465,
0.0059138699,
-0.0284021385,
-0.0183849055,
-0.0171051454,
0.0115201231,
-0.0255735144,
-0.0198837612,
0.0818725526,
0.0334278382,
-0.0252075028,
-0.0455373637,
-0.0130519001,
0.000008602,
-0.0523750857,
0.0408459269,
-0.0485582687,
-0.0215988308,
-0.0103480471,
-0.0235924013,
-0.008890396,
-0.032701876,
-0.0177695844,
-0.0255005602,
0.1121807918,
0.0266935565,
-0.0084785251,
0.0639240369,
0.0405331142,
-0.003519201,
0.0851720423,
0.0066743949,
0.0554705374,
0.004220665,
-0.0008326893,
0.0130505878,
0.0021033201,
0.0262988042,
0.0289245918,
-0.0273809489,
0.0496034063,
0.0136816641,
0.0117145441,
0.0084975576,
0.0065615615,
-0.0529572368,
-0.0064546014,
0.0178711228,
-0.016037466,
-0.0272751302,
-0.0072605661,
-0.0187056549,
-0.0127856806,
-0.0483250506,
0.0041868868,
-0.0412418246,
0.0003813807,
-0.0026475245,
-0.0181821249,
-0.0329078473,
0.0169120524,
-0.0569465123,
-0.0568555854,
-0.0067577399,
-0.0241168682,
0.0300386213,
0.0280682072,
0.0078107612,
0.0405410491,
-0.0086639989,
-0.0265278313,
-0.0099721635,
0.0008938754,
-0.0424148515,
-0.0473288521,
0.0540869683,
-0.02478626,
0.0401193611,
-0.0725703761,
-0.0591984391,
-0.0195592735,
0.0534015447,
-0.009970543,
0.0659209862,
-0.0353706256,
0.0103935599,
-0.0454712957,
-0.0720520467,
-0.0672727674,
0.0288524963,
0.0227441527,
0.0349879898,
-0.0036225063,
0.0281100497,
-0.0737656876,
0.003741829,
0.0307474956,
-0.0254957024,
-0.0313074663,
-0.0037896249,
0.0491608903,
0.0299725495,
-0.043738395,
-0.0006160989,
-0.0036005611,
0.0156311188,
-0.0313953646,
-0.0235798676,
0.0255081356,
-0.0256566145,
-0.0144548593,
0.0000728002,
-0.0506284982,
-0.0460100137,
0.052342359,
-0.0728040263,
0.0005270803,
-0.0003789644,
-0.0109117199,
0.0443670489,
0.0118143512,
-0.0115827117,
0.0038651505,
0.0209745076,
-0.0473081656,
0.0527622253,
-0.0010129395,
-0.0096061863,
0.074038364,
0.0315088369,
0.034523949,
0.0400572531,
0.0042383363,
-0.0038489022,
-0.0238103047,
-0.0134079801,
-0.0245515853,
-0.0244831275,
-0.0426886901,
-0.0126325777,
-0.0305633042,
0.021240633,
-0.0052784332,
0.0058896644,
0.0156894345,
-0.0312802158,
-0.0160878692,
-0.0260370579,
-0.0158593953,
-0.0103593552,
0.0009571461,
0.0394816287,
0.0257353317,
0.0355468057,
0.0237558279,
-0.009718583,
0.0246496201,
-0.0181339141,
0.0519449152,
-0.0050502312,
0.0374796763,
-0.0371629931,
0.0544302426,
-0.0139897456,
0.0518421531,
-0.0485729426,
-0.0232899021,
0.0038355466,
0.0092559773,
0.0028660488,
0.0590339415,
-0.0286559276,
0.0090976711,
0.0577684194,
-0.0149165122,
-0.0332131684,
0.0301277712,
-0.0010995007,
-0.0289485529,
-0.005709975,
-0.0419800654,
-0.0181428343,
0.0332871191,
0.0036690601,
-0.0186231211,
-0.0164034292,
0.0790848807,
-0.0114208506,
-0.0193427987,
-0.0365340523,
-0.0262482222,
0.0168846697,
0.0743167549,
-0.0670766756,
-0.0223859604,
0.0602874607,
0.0026133005,
0.0149319908,
-0.038520813,
0.0197436549,
-0.0328673869,
0.0316707976,
0.0058251745,
0.0196993314,
0.0324730016,
0.0026662685,
-0.0642901137,
-0.0563290752,
-0.0518837161,
-0.0201152675,
0.0120914215,
-0.016508799,
-0.0498347282,
-0.0155204777,
-0.100464806,
-0.0817191377,
0.0068588695,
0.0447420888,
0.023682097,
0.0275583416,
0.0152149256,
0.0065079331,
0.0176002141,
-0.0150023447,
0.0637288317,
-0.0347684994,
-0.0268678963,
-0.0323135294,
0.0303146653,
0.0657002926,
0.0920775235,
0.0326389447,
-0.0224431716,
0.0046996288,
0.0125304209,
0.054798726,
-0.015752716,
-0.0170814153,
0.0386195257,
-0.0088419328,
-0.0036659285,
0.0041109417,
0.0301727504,
0.0484209619,
-0.0468410514,
-0.0599722899,
0.0531818308,
0.0503968857,
0.0019053291,
0.0060901572,
-0.0270989537,
0.0128886672,
0.0445550382,
0.0461750478,
-0.0606516264,
-0.0285994038,
0.0281835608,
0.0214558784,
-0.0120520173,
-0.0261790529,
0.0322585478,
-0.1045574844,
0.0614365265,
-0.0194559302,
-0.0967257097,
-0.0327194147,
-0.0180086773,
-0.0193248615,
-0.0410014875,
0.0127929104,
-0.0232436843,
0.0047141011,
-0.0065195067,
0.0446901061,
0.0044228244,
-0.02706182,
0.008505431,
-0.0552217737,
0.0083518382,
0.0687749162,
0.0270403754,
0.0012272673,
-0.0034557455,
-0.0240336731,
-0.0060974117,
0.0456940234,
0.0273787975,
0.0753471926,
0.0124382088,
-0.0358961523,
0.0284629315,
0.0248562321,
-0.0459307954,
-0.0159250442,
0.038750384,
0.0544087477,
-0.0002515639,
0.0469031297,
-0.0259684213,
-0.0255010258,
0.0394896008,
0.005821778,
0.0350463316,
0.0030820169,
-0.0576345958,
-0.0541670769,
0.0406991765,
-0.0701528564,
0.0329657309,
0.0638215393,
0.0396790542,
-0.0157912094,
-0.0336814411,
-0.0937617719,
-0.0021790215,
0.0397291034,
0.0251126718,
-0.0439122505,
-0.0559999645,
-0.0108780591,
-0.0429348983,
0.0426811092,
-0.0259603485,
0.0027369412,
0.0357604548,
0.0203047376,
-0.0080096219,
-0.0565632097,
-0.0198790096,
0.0483256578,
-0.0911304131,
-0.0480971076,
0.0398804508,
0.0608616173,
0.0224128403,
0.0834544897,
-0.0381924696,
-0.0173276979,
0.0519381277,
0.048406709,
0.0068619102,
-0.01927769,
0.0526612103,
-0.0272666067,
-0.0058592097,
-0.0039318004,
-0.0341332257,
0.029778935,
0.0554585718,
0.012084417,
-0.0607070699,
0.0649036765,
0.0297476053,
-0.0398494676,
0.0880568475,
0.0054503824,
-0.0491108447,
-0.0144566046,
0.0578352213,
0.0292343032,
-0.0088958964,
-0.0034603961,
-0.0149527229,
-0.0323762186,
0.0142803378,
0.0240360219,
-0.0196844265,
0.0245796815,
0.0381692015,
-0.052249331,
0.0126291141,
0.0756239071,
0.0235328805,
0.0141254235,
0.0342788063,
0.0009498326,
0.0233310461,
0.0273047164,
0.0385177992,
-0.0115163466,
0.045127593,
0.0414777212,
0.0574913248,
-0.0269395895,
-0.0082775056,
-0.0737063959,
-0.0581011251,
-0.0263150539,
-0.0008645882,
0.0563807115,
-0.0559700876,
-0.0657065585,
-0.0180808343,
-0.0109260147,
0.016216984,
-0.0209043901,
0.0115722539,
-0.0240168422,
0.0308772642,
0.0302534588,
0.001477006,
0.0026277837,
0.0388468876,
0.0005408356,
0.1236306876,
-0.0415320694,
-0.0255075134,
-0.0336756743,
-0.010370749,
0.1004548818,
-0.0041109924,
0.0058700247,
0.0075132987,
-0.0401841439,
-0.1053708717,
0.0175306797,
0.0248291139,
-0.0069089686,
0.0061916779,
0.0068494566,
0.0507785156,
-0.0260444041,
-0.0342770219,
-0.0157735832,
0.0003082727,
-0.0527650826,
-0.0111189531,
-0.0038824198,
-6.714566261e-33,
-0.0156648289,
-0.0390691608,
0.0392212197,
-0.0714305937,
0.0400101691,
0.0362407677,
-0.0193984006,
-0.0517583527,
-0.0188058261,
-0.0221781638,
-0.0331172608,
-0.0020658784,
-0.0018530145,
0.0190896615,
-0.006382037,
-0.0202971734,
0.0422698148,
0.017797308,
-0.0174511708,
0.00602441,
0.0006643391,
0.0141363936,
0.010120865,
-0.0712594315,
0.0049159983,
-0.0213918462,
-0.0291906148,
0.0216508973,
-0.0364219956,
0.0518835336,
-0.0183083639,
0.0154725853,
0.0272305906,
-0.0425728336,
-0.0078103309,
-0.0118358592,
-0.0566381663,
-0.0481101386,
-0.0243622847,
0.0231336597,
-0.0195819233,
-0.0461588092,
0.0441977158,
-0.0082340427,
0.0171035063,
0.0205476917,
0.0352055617,
-0.0313618928,
-0.0237891618,
0.0274878591,
-0.0447630659,
0.0140909282,
-0.0461716577,
-0.0325623006,
0.0048074573,
0.0598044805,
0.0434283987,
0.0370536856,
-0.0495140254,
0.0125578679,
0.0631828159,
-0.046124991,
0.0462375432,
0.0167755913,
-0.0064208098,
0.0382669494,
0.024659263,
0.018548334,
0.0037880007,
-0.0404823571,
-0.0067578345,
0.0599488914,
0.0451983064,
0.0688979775,
0.0390967801,
-0.0257204343,
-0.0887465328,
0.0576761551,
-0.0543264374,
0.0199957658,
0.0211350601,
0.0014061474,
-0.0659545138,
-0.0046988809,
-0.0536948517,
-0.0370560847,
-0.034405712,
0.0017167178,
0.0620333552,
-0.0012207943,
-0.0092418268,
0.0586729608,
-0.002203644,
-0.0511187725,
-0.0088799596,
0.0128015839,
-0.0036293229,
-0.0310012233,
-0.016582625,
0.0265429765,
-0.0406411923,
-0.0491102114,
0.0098425047,
0.0071429634,
0.0444712825,
0.0234213322,
0.0604731105,
0.0148332855,
-0.0625901222,
0.0118018007,
-0.0426014699,
0.0266489163,
0.0002183354,
-0.0006030456,
0.0286675356,
0.0092195617,
0.0044400143,
0.0133529361,
0.0151181296,
-0.012719701,
-0.0221692193,
-0.0404928364,
-0.0495114066,
0.0259673353,
-0.0074532847,
-0.0456798412,
0.0251737405,
0.0160639174,
0.0169967953,
-0.0647614151,
-0.0139168547,
0.0029715749,
3.021e-7,
0.007287553,
0.0371248722,
0.0151517708,
-0.0010337554,
0.0160959903,
0.0334969908,
-0.0442784987,
0.020080464,
-0.0269137174,
-0.0036984379,
0.0434523895,
0.0523958467,
0.0139000593,
0.0547327437,
-0.0710623488,
0.0151492544,
-0.0435249507,
0.0052157189,
-0.0451081544,
0.0146720409,
0.0356104635,
0.0825922042,
-0.0036956542,
-0.0257111229,
0.0177292489,
-0.0119649284,
0.0146663692,
-0.0421246365,
0.0367887467,
0.021311054,
-0.020626653,
0.0324874297,
0.0151447542,
0.031243179,
0.0053513707,
-0.0247470737,
0.0234572235,
0.0247720722,
0.0004799353,
-0.0616566502,
-0.0184782315,
0.0122376196,
0.0029574619,
-0.0749635622,
0.0890490636,
-0.0636561811,
-0.0448778868,
-0.0133730844,
-0.0083523616,
0.0044186609,
0.0317036211,
0.0262680631,
0.0080620386,
-0.0423197001,
-0.0242342446,
-0.0092538046,
0.0018004071,
-0.0646973774,
0.0173558295,
0.0138416709,
-0.0098526776,
-0.008100776,
-0.0192387588,
-0.0156381913,
0.0285129268,
-0.0315838419,
-0.0150310332,
2.951772155e-34,
0.0041947197,
-0.0053695366,
0.0264963824,
-0.0181110054,
0.0564887077,
-0.0203653984,
0.0335289352,
0.0010722572,
0.024624791,
0.002337967,
-0.0066001471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17477v1 | Detecting mental disorder on social media: a ChatGPT-augmented explainable approach | 2024-01-30T22:22:55 | 2024-01-30T22:22:55 | Loris Belcastro, Riccardo Cantini, Fabrizio Marozzo, Domenico Talia, Paolo Trunfio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI | In the digital era, the prevalence of depressive symptoms expressed on social
media has raised serious concerns, necessitating advanced methodologies for
timely detection. This paper addresses the challenge of interpretable
depression detection by proposing a novel methodology that effectively combines
Large Language Models (LLMs) with eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) and
conversational agents like ChatGPT. In our methodology, explanations are
achieved by integrating BERTweet, a Twitter-specific variant of BERT, into a
novel self-explanatory model, namely BERT-XDD, capable of providing both
classification and explanations via masked attention. The interpretability is
further enhanced using ChatGPT to transform technical explanations into
human-readable commentaries. By introducing an effective and modular approach
for interpretable depression detection, our methodology can contribute to the
development of socially responsible digital platforms, fostering early
intervention and support for mental health challenges under the guidance of
qualified healthcare professionals. | Detecting mental disorder on social media: a ChatGPT-augmented explainable approach: In the digital era, the prevalence of depressive symptoms expressed on social
media has raised serious concerns, necessitating advanced methodologies for
timely detection. This paper addresses the challenge of interpretable
depression detection by proposing a novel methodology that effectively combines
Large Language Models (LLMs) with eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) and
conversational agents like ChatGPT. In our methodology, explanations are
achieved by integrating BERTweet, a Twitter-specific variant of BERT, into a
novel self-explanatory model, namely BERT-XDD, capable of providing both
classification and explanations via masked attention. The interpretability is
further enhanced using ChatGPT to transform technical explanations into
human-readable commentaries. By introducing an effective and modular approach
for interpretable depression detection, our methodology can contribute to the
development of socially responsible digital platforms, fostering early
intervention and support for mental health challenges under the guidance of
qualified healthcare professionals. | [
0.0363446213,
0.0169772524,
-0.0353256054,
0.0107396878,
0.0087011317,
0.0260698274,
0.0228968635,
0.0177918412,
0.0750439018,
-0.017225815,
0.03699065,
0.0256826952,
-0.0459110625,
0.0325246789,
-0.0037040103,
-0.0747800246,
-0.0206072945,
0.0272904523,
0.0450906418,
0.0070512528,
0.0417949371,
0.0211285111,
-0.0111553455,
0.0550961122,
-0.0042308583,
-0.0310418569,
-0.0109889954,
0.0051918314,
0.0034503543,
-0.0225792807,
0.0001644217,
0.0210185107,
0.0163701661,
0.0127886124,
0.0000019593,
-0.009297071,
-0.0208353046,
-0.0043092966,
-0.0132176345,
-0.0227344073,
-0.013923252,
-0.0440573096,
0.0316997804,
0.0241698027,
-0.0277779046,
0.0151302172,
0.0418080948,
0.0761293769,
0.1042716056,
0.0566183478,
-0.0224290937,
-0.0117258402,
0.0050693904,
0.0069725979,
0.0070125079,
-0.0172347724,
0.0247861352,
0.0409352332,
0.0257111751,
-0.0022221645,
-0.0218826048,
0.0386581942,
-0.026025787,
-0.0077816974,
0.002949107,
-0.0110949846,
0.0025288616,
-0.0386870913,
0.0132776676,
0.0772677809,
0.0235206038,
-0.0067097479,
0.0371648706,
-0.0020918855,
0.0046691871,
0.0144514143,
-0.0415937006,
-0.014105319,
-0.0068632476,
0.0367512815,
0.0359476171,
0.006485167,
0.0409455299,
0.0213953387,
-0.0004884417,
0.0414435677,
-0.0370452367,
-0.0272611994,
-0.0470612757,
-0.0142089399,
-0.0617272072,
-0.0510671511,
0.0515616834,
0.0591712184,
-0.0421616994,
0.0252161156,
-0.0263095628,
-0.0770091414,
-0.0094477814,
-0.0085736699,
-0.0223347489,
0.0288742837,
-0.0496514514,
0.0235756189,
0.0377808921,
0.0410580784,
-0.0026192199,
-0.0058714659,
-0.0098609347,
-0.0364313908,
-0.0968938619,
-0.0075525069,
-0.0462877564,
0.0076346048,
-0.0022886295,
-0.0416424349,
-0.0333875269,
0.0408834442,
-0.0251611155,
-0.016266536,
0.0365095921,
-0.0110579384,
-0.0079452256,
-0.0002501624,
0.0198621135,
0.0300825536,
-0.0360438079,
-0.0371128321,
0.0020080758,
-0.0335923955,
0.0104563916,
0.0162551273,
0.0146730877,
-0.0136154089,
-0.0178948846,
0.0414216295,
0.0557068735,
-0.0181710143,
-0.0265241973,
-0.037735071,
-0.0275850315,
-0.0124790398,
-0.0211682022,
0.0000086059,
0.0018198055,
0.0408933498,
-0.0002856744,
-0.0249659847,
0.0357782319,
-0.0105479369,
-0.0447381213,
0.0657737702,
-0.0815164,
0.0321650952,
0.0029474921,
0.0223815124,
-0.0291722193,
0.0652822331,
0.0321688354,
0.0227185264,
0.0476089753,
-0.0577781461,
0.0335981101,
-0.0019882575,
0.0274638534,
-0.0306029189,
0.0227880999,
-0.0160043351,
-0.0863464773,
0.0322997086,
-0.0061451532,
0.0185932051,
0.0009625574,
0.0327235982,
0.0600703917,
0.0593685508,
0.0355558917,
0.0701085925,
0.0124201961,
0.0552197844,
-0.0246086195,
0.0110031078,
-0.0202528462,
0.0291307978,
-0.0243691374,
-0.0159961693,
-0.0034648862,
-0.0171250682,
-0.0129751666,
-0.0613262244,
-0.0231899451,
-0.0192277487,
0.039880991,
0.0055330456,
0.0078704925,
-0.0244506318,
-0.0184153914,
0.0854934454,
0.0433650389,
-0.0309854802,
-0.0384336524,
-0.0731982663,
0.0526829809,
0.1079588532,
0.0182008911,
-0.0526065603,
-0.0122069167,
-0.0090068206,
0.0499770641,
0.0455583967,
0.0019032112,
0.0359970741,
0.0227264687,
-0.0224466771,
0.0092724878,
0.0003852664,
0.0125537943,
-0.0222761557,
-0.0157663152,
-0.010216536,
-0.0257093851,
-0.0317760631,
-0.033980608,
0.0256843287,
0.0127696777,
-0.0367663801,
-0.005566238,
0.0134019805,
0.0378577597,
0.0414889418,
0.0253370628,
0.013057474,
-0.0014243815,
-0.0156878326,
-0.0586132109,
0.0342484973,
0.0171526205,
-0.0419537425,
0.0112876128,
-0.0256088637,
-0.0273219626,
0.0638009086,
-0.0393195786,
-0.039334517,
0.0537963733,
-0.0932255536,
0.0694942772,
-0.0219537038,
-0.0403105542,
-0.0000442277,
0.0252357926,
0.009262993,
0.0499216095,
-0.0193306599,
-0.0073639899,
-0.0003435191,
-0.0305207502,
-0.0379191302,
-0.0280436911,
-0.009979859,
-0.0173211284,
-0.0049199667,
0.0100161871,
-0.0200108159,
0.0001349446,
-0.0133613627,
0.0017157221,
-0.1272960901,
0.0046091583,
-0.0294006504,
0.0028213605,
0.0214503594,
0.0091246143,
0.0035354097,
-0.0088077188,
-0.0136258733,
0.0396183617,
0.0271153189,
0.0144771924,
0.0433471613,
0.0073894705,
-0.0332650132,
-0.0462494269,
-0.0144516733,
-0.0441223383,
0.036538709,
-0.0104051298,
-0.0701614246,
-0.0612161122,
-0.0150273936,
-0.0427182391,
0.0022866945,
-0.0064574555,
-0.0586928949,
0.011744393,
-0.0110894814,
0.0034316392,
0.0268359333,
0.0185295641,
0.104379341,
-0.010932995,
0.0210126452,
-0.0263704937,
0.0135382488,
-0.0209501982,
-0.0072338236,
-0.0233057346,
-0.0513993949,
0.0069351667,
0.0827741772,
0.0014420057,
-0.0025693125,
-0.0767061114,
-0.0122216223,
-0.0025075257,
0.0082944222,
-0.0057592043,
-0.0263570137,
0.0074513149,
0.0055841305,
-0.0041650343,
-0.0521165542,
0.0688739792,
-0.0008032592,
-0.0260182843,
-0.0168360639,
-0.0480017997,
-0.039941784,
0.0293576065,
-0.0011072059,
0.0286125578,
0.0233918261,
-0.0446944498,
0.0564787202,
-0.0255724359,
-0.0068215039,
-0.0172689296,
0.0134842247,
-0.0281532891,
0.0071151797,
0.0677045509,
-0.0071640448,
-0.0142762344,
-0.0669748113,
-0.0719897151,
0.0023156691,
0.0101460498,
-0.0299134403,
-0.0438086092,
0.0138619021,
0.0231890958,
-0.0040382515,
-0.0142937936,
-0.0166667178,
-0.010440533,
-0.0031041028,
0.0248429198,
0.0115419496,
0.0328209065,
-0.025027724,
0.0306238327,
0.0319296196,
-0.0264070611,
-0.0057644127,
-0.0341417603,
-0.0054062577,
-0.0427474156,
-0.0274286643,
-0.0161103774,
-0.0082783345,
0.0509046204,
-0.0314971507,
0.0077753002,
0.1214444935,
0.0055755409,
-0.0032589943,
0.0384484753,
-0.0221550204,
-0.0203754213,
-0.0237735733,
-0.0107328221,
-0.0264647175,
-0.0590785779,
-0.0406514108,
0.0568273664,
-0.0145172449,
-0.0093235848,
0.0128995776,
-0.002361512,
0.0300463177,
-0.0232892595,
0.0168587826,
0.0043980042,
-0.0331783369,
-0.002079729,
-0.0248899031,
0.0017448633,
-0.0277928319,
-0.0053769108,
-0.0044869906,
0.0086041987,
-0.0894076824,
-0.0283846781,
0.0551736243,
-0.006886045,
0.053117767,
0.0435134582,
0.0794517547,
0.0052699964,
-0.0380636379,
-0.0194452349,
0.0256893635,
0.0197983664,
0.0039249994,
0.0810538307,
-0.0067496514,
-0.0199005045,
-0.0807742998,
0.0531127304,
-0.0604456328,
-0.0171851311,
-0.0263574217,
0.0749248192,
-0.0268288907,
-0.0320010558,
-0.0216063187,
0.0380623341,
0.0403813794,
0.0845333412,
0.0786397979,
-0.0524546765,
-0.0356012695,
0.0119184572,
-0.0014160741,
-0.0216985177,
-0.0248594321,
-0.0111745149,
-0.0052345525,
-0.0510223955,
-0.0554262213,
-0.0525382981,
0.0244473293,
-0.0248711873,
-0.0326605439,
-0.0373925231,
0.0164370071,
0.0203233585,
-0.0491173193,
0.0656213984,
0.0429743007,
0.0050574541,
-0.0086882822,
-0.0293885171,
0.0117684351,
-0.0261356067,
-0.0008243485,
-0.001071992,
-0.0452813692,
0.0055945837,
0.0424894057,
0.0058556325,
0.0253591593,
-0.0081136497,
-0.0113481805,
-0.0780802071,
-0.0202901158,
0.0138287721,
0.004638914,
-0.0189881027,
0.0439679101,
0.0596074201,
0.028786879,
0.0707586855,
-0.0116499383,
0.0194398407,
-0.0123393899,
-0.0111188954,
-0.0446994342,
0.029879164,
-0.002393357,
0.0194608681,
0.0301785581,
0.0152144833,
-0.0588889532,
0.001671401,
-0.0360072441,
0.0005691164,
0.0067261639,
-0.0610098168,
0.0046697534,
-0.0058138543,
-0.0276116114,
-0.021708047,
-0.0474026725,
-0.0594807044,
-0.0730294809,
-0.0636667684,
0.0640989766,
-0.0256087612,
-0.0054574241,
-0.0140706711,
-0.0162508525,
-0.0254997332,
0.023523137,
-0.0206895284,
0.0132847894,
0.012107213,
0.1021344587,
0.0092496611,
0.0002883683,
0.0359246321,
0.0400170647,
-0.0522182137,
-0.0912718624,
-0.0058060563,
0.0160968471,
0.0343739204,
0.002859995,
0.0963551402,
0.0045098863,
0.0020292543,
0.0176824965,
0.0626707748,
-0.0084460191,
-0.0464239679,
-0.0170429535,
0.0040240451,
-0.0200742017,
-0.0281485133,
0.068932727,
-0.0233146083,
-0.001862456,
0.0483665504,
-0.0230587721,
-0.0150338355,
0.0076243207,
0.020759115,
0.0490899123,
-0.0167141613,
0.0119315432,
-0.0202694423,
-0.0642683581,
0.0127741909,
-0.0411929265,
-0.027424613,
-0.0300532617,
0.0146892695,
0.0469166823,
0.0138296233,
-0.031626977,
-0.0634130314,
0.0428907014,
-0.0420690142,
0.0003580378,
-0.0270420797,
-5.81874222e-33,
0.0186409317,
-0.0473823473,
-0.0275282264,
-0.0072099189,
0.0007551724,
0.0292491671,
-0.0681562945,
0.0117131379,
0.0145773329,
0.0574278757,
0.0273096804,
0.0843235552,
-0.0100275911,
0.0511264801,
-0.0253999755,
-0.0337986685,
0.011250983,
0.0264160596,
0.0053296541,
0.0485270135,
0.0393808745,
0.0592189841,
0.0465749912,
-0.085487403,
0.0392281227,
-0.0140438965,
-0.0064517451,
0.0230113119,
0.059448611,
0.0481203087,
-0.0263514388,
0.0538743511,
0.0481302738,
-0.00726989,
0.004561075,
0.0473386645,
-0.0391945578,
-0.0251320973,
0.0228395369,
0.0013351048,
-0.0467826389,
-0.0029163703,
0.0289839879,
-0.0239829123,
0.0181833468,
-0.0150698405,
0.0527345277,
-0.0167470276,
0.0376231968,
0.0092024207,
-0.0098151518,
0.0153152691,
-0.0535995737,
-0.0276641008,
0.0090597887,
0.0219706241,
-0.0098092416,
0.0329016671,
-0.0305473693,
-0.0244926959,
-0.000278884,
-0.0233130921,
0.0408306718,
-0.0651310831,
-0.0217085537,
0.0294504911,
0.0147388736,
0.0020184424,
-0.0610400029,
-0.0081559522,
-0.0390692912,
0.0621251278,
0.0816074908,
-0.0231258534,
0.0065734731,
0.0140816579,
-0.04261861,
0.0009942043,
0.0105639612,
0.0179527737,
0.0457282588,
0.0211253073,
-0.0650957748,
-0.0027157832,
0.0233801287,
-0.0040965718,
-0.0284888297,
-0.0338789225,
0.0008417587,
-0.0295697413,
-0.0404520594,
0.0031095762,
-0.0051195361,
-0.0495217517,
0.0157842617,
-0.0038142619,
0.0149944555,
0.0100285821,
0.0005739405,
0.0132665168,
0.0090876231,
-0.0109687829,
0.010922106,
0.0218693502,
0.0498286299,
0.0145218512,
0.0349932685,
-0.0183743164,
0.0164565202,
-0.0122695128,
-0.0330177322,
0.0005926549,
-0.0648737326,
0.0350560956,
-0.0049361265,
0.0338875316,
-0.0376250595,
0.0187545754,
0.0333117843,
0.0421736166,
-0.0408021361,
-0.0239452999,
-0.0236612707,
-0.0253875908,
-0.0214226265,
-0.0592613555,
-0.0272110756,
0.0118851606,
0.0218956266,
-0.0789772347,
-0.0058079311,
-0.0055596773,
2.663e-7,
0.0484824516,
0.083808817,
-0.0082640974,
-0.0080613438,
0.0488770492,
0.0197962727,
0.0377729908,
0.0352423117,
0.0061792652,
-0.0466494896,
0.0154191181,
0.0462298244,
0.0477461927,
0.0322452486,
0.0102229016,
-0.0678723007,
-0.0345629454,
-0.0352792144,
-0.0570158325,
0.0252514966,
0.0945613384,
0.0675039962,
0.0258817822,
0.0033012812,
0.0421291403,
-0.0192761477,
0.0246070977,
-0.0324289799,
0.0370043889,
0.0276550818,
0.0589191169,
-0.0073896772,
0.0268903133,
-0.0246671103,
-0.0070934556,
-0.0042135338,
-0.0135411536,
0.0637913495,
-0.0599513575,
-0.0099589061,
-0.0072145015,
-0.0064737243,
0.0186639447,
-0.0461963303,
0.0488072596,
-0.0689677373,
-0.0845864713,
-0.0196007211,
-0.0078952322,
-0.065366365,
-0.0147026796,
-0.0002979335,
-0.0231141821,
0.0475355946,
-0.0120238811,
-0.0366907828,
0.0138849495,
-0.0896730423,
-0.0386497453,
-0.018811401,
-0.0681327432,
0.0197854992,
-0.0383658595,
-0.0261061247,
0.0456518121,
-0.0703450441,
0.0310638677,
2.145622721e-34,
0.0240699016,
0.0371007025,
0.0050871549,
0.0323619023,
0.0482858568,
0.0402897,
0.0009260958,
-0.0123441489,
0.0461193249,
-0.0768965781,
-0.0046181199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00075v1 | D-Nikud: Enhancing Hebrew Diacritization with LSTM and Pretrained Models | 2024-01-30T22:07:12 | 2024-01-30T22:07:12 | Adi Rosenthal, Nadav Shaked | cs.CL | cs.CL | D-Nikud, a novel approach to Hebrew diacritization that integrates the
strengths of LSTM networks and BERT-based (transformer) pre-trained model.
Inspired by the methodologies employed in Nakdimon, we integrate it with the
TavBERT pre-trained model, our system incorporates advanced architectural
choices and diverse training data. Our experiments showcase state-of-the-art
results on several benchmark datasets, with a particular emphasis on modern
texts and more specified diacritization like gender. | D-Nikud: Enhancing Hebrew Diacritization with LSTM and Pretrained Models: D-Nikud, a novel approach to Hebrew diacritization that integrates the
strengths of LSTM networks and BERT-based (transformer) pre-trained model.
Inspired by the methodologies employed in Nakdimon, we integrate it with the
TavBERT pre-trained model, our system incorporates advanced architectural
choices and diverse training data. Our experiments showcase state-of-the-art
results on several benchmark datasets, with a particular emphasis on modern
texts and more specified diacritization like gender. | [
-0.0225215666,
0.0593604408,
-0.0057413881,
0.0653636232,
-0.0074962443,
0.0259764791,
0.0463475138,
0.00239035,
-0.014164418,
-0.0660766214,
-0.0506524071,
-0.0908005014,
0.0267039724,
-0.000010146,
0.0227085445,
-0.0180547684,
0.0195285119,
-0.0317266807,
-0.0354631618,
-0.0116974367,
0.0269745495,
0.0221742112,
0.002397235,
-0.00431896,
0.0197354034,
-0.003896259,
0.0634630024,
0.0205995664,
0.0160656627,
0.0058311624,
0.0305016283,
0.0415932275,
-0.0352169387,
0.0514887311,
0.0000017725,
-0.0284556579,
-0.0038820161,
-0.0155443382,
0.0109816808,
0.0055186846,
0.0581099615,
-0.0532361157,
-0.0658359006,
0.015147632,
-0.0404271521,
-0.0313558728,
0.0515802503,
0.0228146054,
0.0537921637,
0.0524121411,
-0.0032769474,
-0.0385904014,
0.0495873578,
-0.0155034196,
-0.0576164052,
0.0262465198,
0.0082216198,
-0.0671587586,
-0.0600350462,
0.0066107484,
-0.023629779,
0.0308930743,
0.0303907301,
-0.0105713224,
0.0016854632,
-0.0093994113,
-0.0139329582,
-0.0011578955,
0.0216392092,
-0.002266028,
-0.0168144144,
-0.0311240498,
0.012881699,
0.0245929472,
-0.0321542993,
-0.0374530852,
0.0021538008,
0.0213219039,
-0.0301401354,
0.0141733401,
-0.0016545542,
-0.0112065859,
0.0469577014,
0.0201459806,
-0.0605554394,
-0.0051798923,
0.0603030622,
-0.0663943291,
0.0056000273,
0.0232899487,
-0.0164630823,
-0.0213910248,
0.0528533421,
0.0019563118,
0.0235164706,
-0.0291854572,
-0.0145230759,
-0.0666493773,
-0.014454674,
-0.0195684824,
0.045528125,
0.042574048,
-0.0464969054,
-0.0453281552,
-0.0680744499,
0.0401718803,
0.04047947,
0.02821883,
-0.0124658979,
0.0106063168,
-0.0129032461,
-0.0002450943,
-0.0434933901,
0.0249199718,
-0.0087087359,
0.0427885056,
-0.0687559545,
-0.013127611,
0.0303008426,
-0.0495112278,
0.0002635443,
-0.0256009717,
-0.0192954522,
-0.0238701701,
0.0459991023,
-0.0156286638,
-0.0356889479,
-0.0027736567,
-0.0474694036,
-0.0390468054,
0.0107067795,
0.0167235415,
-0.0007668478,
-0.0347972214,
0.0194113571,
0.001001265,
0.0089973966,
-0.0525726415,
-0.05554251,
0.0344498418,
-0.0448946208,
0.014092206,
-0.0360988826,
-0.0477090217,
-0.0173948407,
-0.0245221388,
0.0049985847,
-0.0383065976,
-0.0158307645,
0.0354228728,
0.007909934,
0.0864491239,
0.0205136891,
-0.0423108004,
0.0329285488,
0.0038304827,
0.0295501575,
0.0125981988,
0.0557367653,
-0.0008218056,
0.0261848848,
0.0031888252,
0.0241522081,
0.062221583,
0.0035761411,
0.026800843,
-0.0533264093,
-0.0020147474,
0.0039246189,
0.027685456,
0.0394995287,
0.054371886,
-0.0326007418,
-0.0591315255,
0.0922106877,
0.0862945169,
0.0408148244,
0.0424317159,
-0.0057938811,
0.0025514171,
0.0427937545,
-0.0052901185,
-0.0215163194,
-0.0118307713,
0.0270459838,
0.0035138268,
-0.0111172125,
0.0452814884,
-0.0147114908,
-0.0519144572,
0.0101146512,
-0.0403920412,
-0.0278741755,
-0.028705705,
0.0180313084,
0.0675631836,
-0.0419230498,
0.0738688633,
-0.010945281,
-0.066695109,
0.0477684215,
-0.0229525138,
0.0088654887,
0.0418950729,
0.0649698004,
-0.0476039425,
-0.0652044713,
-0.0281247795,
-0.0100657018,
0.0785034224,
-0.0177137032,
0.0316321217,
0.0057981149,
-0.0791846216,
0.0263679456,
0.0139038777,
0.0123684583,
0.0106523614,
-0.0111003937,
0.0326550566,
0.0185226239,
-0.0079915272,
-0.0518434905,
0.0462905355,
-0.0079798866,
-0.0335044265,
-0.0040021092,
-0.0016004217,
0.0179111902,
-0.0196047928,
-0.0236630812,
-0.0212111752,
-0.0135464566,
-0.0676929876,
-0.0194817912,
-0.0369701348,
-0.0282439981,
-0.0096340608,
0.0336499773,
-0.0398691297,
-0.0261351895,
0.0448771752,
-0.0006898636,
-0.0266566519,
0.019983504,
-0.0309501942,
-0.0284686964,
-0.0418465361,
0.0280087516,
0.0161905177,
0.0352448374,
-0.020511914,
-0.0032194457,
0.0217417032,
0.0005577944,
0.0402383134,
-0.0188143682,
0.017407639,
0.0258997772,
-0.074568741,
-0.0056357556,
-0.0102424258,
0.0012925743,
0.007420511,
0.0002704413,
0.0278350357,
-0.0576142631,
-0.0645877346,
0.0030332848,
-0.0280263107,
0.0473193601,
0.0088128569,
0.0386028327,
0.0005127088,
-0.0080433059,
-0.0281646606,
-0.039897874,
-0.0015507622,
-0.0069473581,
0.0586134903,
-0.0299308188,
-0.0149231683,
-0.0603378825,
-0.0110653993,
-0.0195041765,
0.0485980585,
0.0216350742,
0.0044455221,
-0.0032843098,
-0.0497402251,
0.0214521829,
0.0283756666,
0.032227125,
-0.0545346886,
0.0168209597,
0.0258306079,
0.0559268519,
0.0187076479,
0.0132554313,
-0.032120537,
-0.0336590707,
-0.0244680438,
-0.0498036556,
-0.0007240798,
0.0174096674,
0.0098894043,
-0.0710374266,
-0.034196578,
0.012397144,
0.0370354243,
-0.0203794837,
-0.0168724693,
-0.0348393656,
0.0072386414,
-0.0446522981,
0.0283712558,
0.0317414105,
-0.0126115279,
-0.035191346,
0.0134980464,
-0.0222382843,
-0.024605155,
0.0469284244,
-0.0164443478,
-0.0328126289,
-0.0411464646,
0.0424413569,
-0.0456028469,
-0.0036440459,
0.0003551122,
0.0155120641,
-0.0441340096,
-0.0503027327,
-0.064814657,
-0.0039621554,
-0.0121089155,
-0.034767691,
0.0770935789,
0.0124530951,
-0.0043015825,
-0.0116711771,
-0.0551778115,
-0.0211900044,
0.0109436708,
-0.0206596982,
-0.0154157206,
0.0321474932,
-0.0077920435,
0.0019746674,
0.0160943866,
-0.0914390311,
0.0596596599,
0.0314508118,
-0.0093990816,
-0.0418775827,
0.0393786356,
-0.034057118,
-0.0446142219,
-0.0063267285,
0.0031735098,
0.0518590137,
0.00119062,
-0.0396339037,
-0.000155891,
-0.0441369489,
-0.0051999209,
0.0609147511,
-0.0449021682,
-0.0241796114,
-0.0401806161,
-0.0362797529,
-0.0450543277,
-0.02296439,
0.1176791117,
0.0152611518,
-0.0649128109,
-0.0186580159,
-0.0151824029,
-0.0196570847,
-0.0159966517,
-0.0003432163,
-0.0983753353,
-0.0180778466,
0.0180748235,
0.0468266904,
0.0438937023,
-0.0177636035,
0.0367052779,
-0.0334565789,
-0.0332981832,
0.0162561443,
0.0269546285,
-0.028181253,
0.0135757485,
-0.0320522077,
-0.0366337076,
0.0479314849,
0.0210215691,
-0.0266174655,
0.0113551579,
-0.0080420459,
-0.0455959663,
0.0028875228,
0.020439988,
-0.0691868439,
0.0391202867,
0.0580892712,
0.0511590205,
-0.0671119988,
-0.0249492545,
0.0153633421,
-0.0457420163,
-0.0562418364,
-0.0159910675,
0.0081563555,
0.0017777162,
-0.0197203178,
0.0095060766,
0.01452896,
-0.0257245116,
-0.0118425749,
-0.0089157159,
-0.0039366484,
-0.0023082127,
0.0177692082,
0.0226810127,
0.0483256243,
-0.0555185489,
0.0636163205,
0.0026554619,
-0.0434711426,
-0.0275058355,
-0.0261644851,
-0.0243808459,
-0.0818059817,
-0.0669413283,
-0.0129029267,
0.0302206893,
-0.0287958402,
-0.1165409386,
-0.0475653,
-0.0389586762,
0.0206205286,
0.0249586757,
-0.0310593955,
0.02104773,
-0.0053607738,
-0.0424733013,
-0.000778345,
0.0200808886,
0.0283958893,
-0.0707485229,
-0.0047044903,
-0.008131763,
-0.0475722663,
0.0146879898,
0.0112989051,
-0.0113430442,
-0.0220724754,
0.074165307,
0.0088980338,
0.0164035074,
0.0473404191,
-0.0507456437,
-0.0485950597,
0.0736049935,
0.023611851,
-0.0082242582,
0.0020319256,
0.0833198056,
0.0073448853,
-0.0125060044,
0.0323898531,
0.0327260606,
0.0451787785,
0.06051955,
-0.0297950208,
-0.0092177447,
-0.0301478188,
-0.0272835568,
-0.0340426005,
0.0448763631,
-0.0213659834,
0.0068311449,
-0.0599525236,
0.0065249181,
0.010264243,
0.0330949761,
-0.0273752064,
0.0458689071,
0.0703332499,
-0.0037078962,
-0.0477065146,
0.0251131728,
0.0086574275,
-0.0657213032,
-0.024240898,
0.057858862,
0.0445007011,
0.0361635387,
-0.0201204065,
0.0094052227,
0.0208455846,
0.0192626491,
0.0124309054,
0.0473397635,
-0.023928348,
-0.0182815846,
-0.0172904227,
0.0156210298,
-0.0091090696,
0.0439868048,
-0.0238355249,
0.000635577,
-0.0421061926,
-0.0166911669,
0.0386799388,
0.0287975185,
0.0421973802,
-0.002903593,
-0.0064169187,
0.0043091732,
-0.0246069729,
0.0338335298,
0.0593890138,
-0.0098209688,
-0.0071295272,
-0.0096231438,
-0.0345272571,
0.0519455411,
-0.008679688,
0.0373496637,
0.0413289443,
-0.0424598344,
-0.0270644594,
-0.0160601232,
0.0206832271,
-0.0090164039,
-0.0442362316,
0.0002320635,
-0.0323002562,
-0.0399256013,
0.0482100435,
0.0160838328,
0.010258764,
-0.0132592218,
0.0103588551,
0.0304145738,
-0.0100615779,
0.0262261741,
-0.0204522535,
-0.0091583757,
0.0572326481,
-0.0664089844,
-0.0332346931,
-5.599650644e-33,
-0.0126265436,
0.0547647439,
-0.0047790306,
-0.0046914062,
-0.0024304248,
0.0222911388,
0.0001962384,
-0.0404088832,
-0.0036097853,
0.0120601077,
-0.0052210642,
0.057733532,
0.027958544,
0.0122159896,
0.0225523561,
0.0008253937,
0.0632235557,
0.0169334132,
-0.032828372,
-0.0056310087,
-0.0088241464,
0.100708954,
0.0750243366,
0.0444280803,
0.0443690531,
-0.0257147159,
0.0045196521,
0.0037293865,
0.0518124364,
0.0423923694,
-0.0165159758,
0.0544850603,
0.0014593254,
-0.0288894456,
0.0114082778,
0.0663294569,
-0.0575673357,
0.0040022423,
0.000346099,
0.0768467635,
-0.0040573422,
-0.0352186114,
0.0137501555,
0.0099315792,
-0.0444864705,
-0.0011144781,
0.0272973049,
-0.0323871374,
0.0315888785,
-0.0418532491,
-0.0662254766,
0.0436409675,
-0.012502634,
-0.0331884921,
0.0662912279,
-0.0094960397,
-0.0114008887,
0.0256214347,
-0.0958560333,
-0.0513275862,
-0.0138514331,
0.0662034377,
-0.0107322726,
0.0020951051,
-0.069053039,
-0.0053208917,
0.0655160919,
-0.0061438163,
0.0549019873,
0.0086367391,
0.0203899797,
-0.0114651443,
0.0710249022,
0.0270400066,
0.0363099389,
-0.0017514218,
-0.0216962211,
0.0120759606,
0.0271947868,
0.0037081428,
0.0229429547,
-0.0182602759,
-0.0143413264,
-0.0020403839,
-0.0051157922,
-0.0526117422,
-0.0131782666,
0.0481750518,
0.0222060829,
0.0069294218,
-0.0151332011,
0.024574969,
-0.0052619618,
-0.0666505024,
0.0222872403,
0.0089242933,
0.0046646195,
-0.0194357838,
-0.0257286448,
0.0363957472,
0.0110582812,
-0.0404150411,
0.0264998302,
0.0033357826,
-0.0194801595,
-0.0115610296,
0.0499891602,
-0.0025371597,
-0.0800605863,
-0.0153792873,
-0.0233330969,
0.0444798842,
0.0188793018,
0.0775736943,
-0.0176882893,
0.0057825856,
0.0339595489,
0.031295415,
0.043884974,
-0.0376563296,
-0.002167159,
0.0413942374,
0.0187152065,
0.0074949469,
0.0094767911,
-0.0167686995,
0.0263319574,
0.0601038672,
-0.0038657328,
-0.07045798,
0.0072267763,
0.0104239974,
2.535e-7,
0.0816537291,
0.0402291007,
0.0324805826,
-0.0353637598,
0.0148923267,
0.0024239095,
0.0137727372,
0.0343009308,
0.002736707,
0.0671498775,
0.012556307,
0.0087219048,
0.0978142098,
0.0096557904,
-0.054457318,
-0.0670543537,
-0.0473994873,
0.0380511545,
-0.0408188812,
0.0097431093,
0.0311163384,
0.0978739411,
-0.0104001928,
-0.0488006547,
0.0281500611,
-0.0495042056,
0.0214188304,
-0.0044972748,
0.0485832542,
0.0619849376,
0.0808507651,
-0.016803734,
0.0127321724,
0.0035368057,
-0.0346835069,
0.0275220107,
0.0140642487,
0.0371437632,
0.013263477,
0.0196600277,
-0.0014409558,
-0.0240892861,
-0.0400523804,
-0.0387177505,
0.0298499018,
-0.0105537744,
0.0190952886,
0.0632664561,
-0.0553746,
-0.0221524108,
0.043217808,
-0.0027568832,
-0.079619512,
0.0363842882,
0.0741401985,
0.0217584558,
-0.0121984258,
-0.0824269205,
0.0020427259,
0.0214610286,
-0.0186740886,
0.0013157778,
-0.00843539,
-0.0155524975,
0.0095672663,
-0.0411903448,
-0.0009423235,
2.426834949e-34,
0.0698206946,
-0.035001833,
0.008939499,
0.0312429704,
0.0179612692,
0.0080021182,
0.053702455,
-0.0189329181,
-0.017851321,
-0.0362022519,
-0.0093509536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17464v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17464v2 | Efficient Tool Use with Chain-of-Abstraction Reasoning | 2024-01-30T21:53:30 | 2024-02-26T20:26:40 | Silin Gao, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Ping Yu, Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Ramakanth Pasunuru, Olga Golovneva, Koustuv Sinha, Asli Celikyilmaz, Antoine Bosselut, Tianlu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | To achieve faithful reasoning that aligns with human expectations, large
language models (LLMs) need to ground their reasoning to real-world knowledge
(e.g., web facts, math and physical rules). Tools help LLMs access this
external knowledge, but there remains challenges for fine-tuning LLM agents
(e.g., Toolformer) to invoke tools in multi-step reasoning problems, where
inter-connected tool calls require holistic and efficient tool usage planning.
In this work, we propose a new method for LLMs to better leverage tools in
multi-step reasoning. Our method, Chain-of-Abstraction (CoA), trains LLMs to
first decode reasoning chains with abstract placeholders, and then call domain
tools to reify each reasoning chain by filling in specific knowledge. This
planning with abstract chains enables LLMs to learn more general reasoning
strategies, which are robust to shifts of domain knowledge (e.g., math results)
relevant to different reasoning questions. It also allows LLMs to perform
decoding and calling of external tools in parallel, which avoids the inference
delay caused by waiting for tool responses. In mathematical reasoning and Wiki
QA domains, we show that our method consistently outperforms previous
chain-of-thought and tool-augmented baselines on both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution test sets, with an average ~6% absolute QA accuracy
improvement. LLM agents trained with our method also show more efficient tool
use, with inference speed being on average ~1.4x faster than baseline
tool-augmented LLMs. | Efficient Tool Use with Chain-of-Abstraction Reasoning: To achieve faithful reasoning that aligns with human expectations, large
language models (LLMs) need to ground their reasoning to real-world knowledge
(e.g., web facts, math and physical rules). Tools help LLMs access this
external knowledge, but there remains challenges for fine-tuning LLM agents
(e.g., Toolformer) to invoke tools in multi-step reasoning problems, where
inter-connected tool calls require holistic and efficient tool usage planning.
In this work, we propose a new method for LLMs to better leverage tools in
multi-step reasoning. Our method, Chain-of-Abstraction (CoA), trains LLMs to
first decode reasoning chains with abstract placeholders, and then call domain
tools to reify each reasoning chain by filling in specific knowledge. This
planning with abstract chains enables LLMs to learn more general reasoning
strategies, which are robust to shifts of domain knowledge (e.g., math results)
relevant to different reasoning questions. It also allows LLMs to perform
decoding and calling of external tools in parallel, which avoids the inference
delay caused by waiting for tool responses. In mathematical reasoning and Wiki
QA domains, we show that our method consistently outperforms previous
chain-of-thought and tool-augmented baselines on both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution test sets, with an average ~6% absolute QA accuracy
improvement. LLM agents trained with our method also show more efficient tool
use, with inference speed being on average ~1.4x faster than baseline
tool-augmented LLMs. | [
0.0033433249,
0.0300310515,
-0.0112524284,
0.0474944413,
-0.0312298257,
0.0289933216,
0.0004703805,
-0.0223558322,
-0.0185882188,
-0.0393663123,
-0.0082023786,
0.012297187,
-0.024793813,
-0.0006132242,
0.0181366708,
-0.056094341,
0.0234952793,
-0.0361228697,
-0.0159486514,
-0.0083746407,
-0.0367395207,
0.0104652494,
-0.0389913544,
0.0248742159,
-0.0074347132,
-0.0558220595,
-0.0254013408,
-0.0275692679,
0.0190248601,
-0.021870872,
-0.0059618847,
0.0372274481,
0.0332144238,
0.0299346112,
0.0000023419,
-0.0552444756,
-0.0079772267,
0.0212027729,
-0.0625335202,
-0.0116316322,
-0.0554618835,
-0.032715477,
0.026386179,
0.0202501696,
-0.0548397154,
0.0193670392,
0.0104157384,
0.011689974,
0.0636023358,
0.0640911013,
0.0142145921,
-0.0199435595,
0.0206619687,
-0.0104771331,
-0.0096821664,
-0.0772794336,
0.0166432094,
0.0538592301,
0.040776182,
0.0269636139,
-0.0122129498,
0.04049135,
0.0823293328,
-0.0076606027,
-0.0178114288,
0.0264919754,
-0.0056321868,
-0.0059917062,
0.0117783146,
0.0679890141,
-0.0155427651,
-0.0240775365,
0.0003530921,
-0.0184361544,
0.0111018047,
0.0349525735,
-0.0479495004,
0.0490275323,
-0.0348893218,
-0.0125729432,
-0.0154540045,
-0.0269040857,
0.0388752446,
0.0304649863,
-0.0501617715,
0.0938599631,
-0.0211127792,
-0.011845042,
0.0271527655,
0.0259302333,
-0.0261062682,
-0.0743108243,
-0.0014669361,
0.0684497803,
-0.0267134383,
0.0456303209,
-0.0107719563,
-0.0072332625,
-0.0233386159,
-0.0088205412,
0.0085427258,
0.0650362596,
0.0051277354,
0.0309638586,
-0.037810348,
0.0099901268,
-0.0210183226,
0.0450522862,
-0.0306934081,
-0.0048874882,
-0.0699797943,
-0.0112492032,
0.0032876616,
0.0583547018,
-0.0213059057,
0.0008805625,
0.0061824201,
0.035046313,
-0.0305596311,
0.0244570635,
0.0022961868,
-0.0153148798,
0.0139235212,
-0.0446619689,
-0.0628335699,
0.0409712717,
-0.0733516216,
0.0399054699,
0.0391534604,
-0.0288055558,
-0.0356145985,
-0.0101394663,
-0.021707207,
-0.0194952004,
0.0012657925,
0.1074424237,
-0.0057320883,
0.0398141928,
-0.0491779558,
-0.0616220348,
0.0620036274,
-0.0767551884,
0.0205232333,
-0.0756841972,
0.0481750779,
0.0440002605,
-0.0237815008,
-0.018217776,
0.0097599272,
0.0202843267,
-0.0087929135,
0.0592033565,
0.0134358807,
-0.0012588106,
0.0032065404,
0.014602581,
-0.0739071667,
0.0586695299,
0.0071546617,
0.0156874135,
-0.0088609625,
0.0224783551,
-0.0017465579,
0.0358464681,
0.0171078686,
-0.0023373193,
0.0148049248,
0.0263942927,
-0.0191643238,
0.0356897153,
0.0331020355,
0.0006385357,
-0.0533057228,
-0.006280846,
0.0124607896,
0.0160152558,
0.0013056051,
0.0152613409,
0.0653082728,
-0.0070578242,
0.0270608366,
0.0088424776,
-0.0992715061,
0.0369236358,
-0.0266071986,
0.0185188316,
-0.0278777853,
0.002884706,
-0.0229747612,
-0.052622579,
-0.017892478,
0.0175523311,
-0.0206966866,
0.0195196923,
0.0408195518,
0.0308678299,
-0.0109153446,
0.0815342367,
0.0170854609,
-0.0169080384,
-0.0227232743,
-0.0483438931,
0.0148064606,
0.0298508797,
0.0404636599,
-0.0196788609,
-0.038693253,
-0.0100124991,
0.0468061231,
0.0234611146,
0.0160518531,
-0.0368418321,
-0.0149978278,
-0.0456028394,
-0.0441414565,
-0.0352446027,
0.0011795959,
0.0167056136,
0.0673060045,
-0.0075169676,
0.0137127182,
-0.0771927387,
0.0230873264,
0.0340122208,
-0.0196195729,
-0.0357623734,
-0.0394111201,
0.0249107145,
0.0172908623,
-0.007088684,
0.0073040612,
0.0211064015,
-0.0108875176,
-0.022831494,
-0.056011036,
0.0049817283,
-0.0338859782,
-0.0190449748,
0.0427838527,
-0.0246384423,
-0.0417057127,
0.0186216459,
-0.0682418421,
-0.0071029193,
0.041963134,
0.0215411764,
0.0349021964,
-0.0101060141,
0.0007597769,
0.0283162259,
-0.0311985947,
-0.0023258706,
0.0997530222,
-0.0243391972,
-0.0394883864,
0.0071182996,
0.0248115472,
-0.0053467439,
0.0162080098,
0.0465651937,
0.0089275111,
0.0014985367,
0.0181293078,
-0.02829035,
0.0185947567,
-0.0482643954,
0.0046417313,
-0.0241121799,
-0.0048566228,
-0.0176695529,
0.0308020581,
0.0071142064,
-0.0213653985,
0.0161228124,
-0.0086703589,
-0.0148500316,
0.0284250509,
-0.0323409699,
0.013175725,
0.0084785903,
0.0068118721,
-0.0002107724,
-0.0034414269,
-0.0089418376,
-0.0483671129,
0.0489596017,
0.0044570239,
0.0028869242,
-0.0374666788,
0.0307032801,
-0.0423285551,
0.0082817506,
-0.0182529651,
0.0172759909,
0.0311342403,
-0.0126260919,
-0.0054638861,
0.0830578431,
-0.0359771065,
0.0149046434,
0.0594100393,
0.0111737968,
-0.0835027024,
0.0347590372,
0.0068102633,
-0.0263058506,
-0.0303245522,
0.021475086,
-0.0045123016,
0.0640834719,
-0.020556502,
0.0078859199,
-0.0292636659,
0.0139461346,
0.0143783409,
-0.0254554264,
-0.0289351773,
-0.0316684246,
-0.0032299892,
0.054950539,
-0.0080057103,
-0.0179363173,
0.0820309669,
0.0081988694,
0.0009548379,
-0.0526830293,
0.0181050897,
-0.0417683013,
0.0550470985,
-0.0171980709,
-0.0118187219,
-0.015243168,
0.0025583908,
-0.0608721972,
-0.0133948019,
0.0466951393,
-0.0059933369,
0.0505355969,
-0.0731483623,
0.0173686519,
-0.0109299701,
-0.0533350222,
-0.0633690357,
0.0355785899,
-0.0609884001,
0.0212356113,
-0.0473776236,
-0.0382165015,
-0.0070530106,
-0.0187237803,
0.0343631506,
0.0183666479,
-0.01281955,
-0.0129809668,
-0.0212764982,
0.033354193,
0.0332621895,
0.0311720483,
0.0464955345,
-0.0480614379,
0.0415963568,
0.0471598208,
0.0476606973,
-0.0230118968,
-0.0311992541,
-0.0009205212,
-0.020601362,
-0.0375433601,
0.0067974767,
0.0237168446,
0.0204427969,
-0.1031112447,
0.0112305693,
0.0927180052,
0.0289217252,
-0.0102807581,
0.0030610003,
-0.0586286671,
0.0360879675,
0.0307886545,
0.0446009263,
-0.1046113968,
-0.0397283472,
0.0277437158,
0.0090236682,
0.0285879709,
-0.0530618466,
0.0022822006,
-0.1332192719,
0.0247291718,
0.0078759706,
-0.0079835337,
0.0152104059,
-0.0268735997,
0.0273094345,
0.0258088056,
-0.0116645461,
0.0413282141,
0.0107583441,
0.0176442284,
0.0199919622,
0.0149956895,
-0.0256591421,
0.049678117,
-0.0184259042,
-0.0102988323,
0.0220958758,
-0.0109966081,
0.008962933,
-0.0553354062,
0.0886751413,
0.00342161,
0.0103592407,
-0.0252265371,
0.0099722324,
-0.0150242541,
0.0031199106,
0.0004184337,
0.0704066008,
-0.0409967303,
-0.0289739296,
0.0318538249,
0.1209007874,
-0.0118884286,
-0.0226993617,
-0.0005609312,
-0.0057722921,
-0.0238933135,
0.0450228341,
0.0200935882,
0.0024133159,
-0.0373073742,
-0.0536440499,
-0.0773575529,
-0.0277470443,
-0.0268589444,
0.0235295836,
0.020182671,
0.0085751824,
-0.0567488,
-0.0493279286,
0.0761946812,
0.0484562218,
0.0053805388,
-0.0222658049,
0.0360980406,
0.011425822,
-0.0446128733,
0.0414121188,
-0.0630379468,
0.0214351248,
0.0276252832,
0.0117833801,
-0.0072750212,
-0.0265832078,
-0.0248003509,
0.0437111743,
-0.0458040684,
-0.0505117998,
-0.0379447676,
0.0485127866,
0.0288819727,
0.0614254586,
-0.0215706583,
-0.0092025353,
0.0048722383,
0.001233969,
-0.0453569219,
0.0031665696,
0.0279616043,
0.0165565256,
0.0097179357,
0.0521815196,
-0.042998042,
0.0044975663,
-0.0107803233,
0.0591944121,
-0.0218552183,
-0.0066769123,
0.0295193195,
0.008865946,
-0.0463499762,
0.0317927599,
0.0148744322,
-0.0022821778,
0.0573503524,
0.0036136075,
-0.0243606772,
-0.0140177468,
0.0237304159,
-0.025113266,
-0.0150688319,
0.0202451665,
-0.0181051921,
0.0494980477,
0.0361018069,
0.0286171623,
0.0078518353,
-0.0020854354,
0.0423758924,
0.0311807711,
-0.0221087076,
-0.0048405551,
-0.0172512438,
-0.001262188,
0.0643237531,
-0.0394909121,
0.0575633571,
0.0468855314,
0.008332721,
-0.0666207299,
-0.0299643222,
-0.0512255579,
-0.1227789074,
0.0250114389,
-0.0162574053,
0.010438785,
-0.0052061542,
0.0050782529,
-0.0513708629,
-0.0164018907,
0.0306178238,
0.0160389207,
0.0077564414,
-0.0077272495,
0.0268379096,
0.0443584025,
0.011695873,
-0.0377806053,
0.0378778391,
-0.0524124093,
0.0568006076,
-0.0171806179,
0.0068127243,
-0.0418395586,
-0.0538161322,
-0.0511158071,
-0.0016890856,
0.0068054288,
-0.022757357,
-0.073841691,
-0.1053999141,
-0.0353028551,
0.0111779468,
-0.0413040482,
0.003225025,
0.0320094936,
0.0659058988,
0.0130544584,
-0.0425978117,
0.0077948994,
0.0079101864,
-0.0175838843,
-0.0287710112,
-0.0175325293,
-6.229015095e-33,
-0.0203102231,
-0.0283486936,
0.0654720068,
0.0191207528,
-0.0055961339,
-0.0092676934,
-0.057338886,
-0.0095385937,
-0.0348279476,
0.0207672361,
-0.0084981089,
0.0212246981,
0.01053969,
-0.0130024087,
0.0209061131,
-0.0046157138,
0.0168324932,
-0.0078362571,
-0.0389242098,
-0.0167625304,
0.0178642273,
0.007546809,
0.0459010676,
-0.0669065043,
-0.0027291318,
0.0147489067,
0.0067144157,
0.0326942652,
-0.0514658876,
0.0493199229,
0.0099865338,
0.0019361328,
0.0207461379,
-0.0267627016,
-0.006335102,
-0.0072881388,
-0.1044981107,
-0.0235948972,
0.0287363511,
0.0042353962,
-0.0555485561,
-0.0342272073,
0.0527457483,
0.0219867099,
0.0080497991,
-0.0537464842,
0.0119658345,
-0.0237385128,
0.0112486649,
0.0027406141,
-0.0588304289,
0.013951147,
-0.0152286757,
-0.0271659158,
-0.0062009851,
0.0190049578,
-0.0061197896,
-0.0049335384,
-0.0432025008,
-0.0045558377,
0.0243986752,
-0.0048103887,
0.0845089406,
-0.0162331071,
-0.0106589915,
0.0504183359,
0.0100181662,
-0.0323589593,
-0.0353063531,
0.0207865648,
0.026377188,
0.0686576217,
0.0274154339,
0.0037840451,
-0.0053791725,
0.0446553081,
-0.0662372634,
0.0257896185,
0.0027949894,
0.0872618333,
0.0135754906,
0.0059988294,
-0.035596136,
0.0082920557,
-0.0597837493,
0.0218341649,
-0.0403546505,
-0.0400795639,
0.0350033492,
-0.0100031095,
-0.0112672774,
-0.0161427818,
0.0024290609,
-0.0265092161,
-0.0209484883,
0.03813494,
-0.003202202,
0.0269437023,
0.0001713214,
0.03514909,
-0.0412081964,
0.0064885477,
-0.0043210639,
-0.006807161,
0.0277889632,
0.0054159793,
0.0231833961,
0.0111756139,
-0.0486721285,
-0.0241796151,
-0.0864010453,
-0.004295547,
0.0197860748,
0.0399802662,
0.0445139259,
0.0483585522,
-0.0078581301,
0.0248561148,
-0.0367455259,
-0.0453444123,
-0.0318618752,
0.065600656,
0.0025521112,
0.0121789798,
-0.0244817641,
-0.0140465042,
-0.0229286794,
0.004224129,
0.0475434773,
-0.0673350468,
0.0043237992,
0.0353797972,
3.006e-7,
0.0473012142,
0.0329037979,
0.0107936459,
0.0660870373,
0.0006438781,
0.0245622955,
-0.0191502664,
-0.0211167838,
0.027768448,
-0.0653772503,
-0.0000706765,
0.0809763297,
0.0220723059,
0.0420685373,
-0.0757931322,
0.0062522851,
-0.0005609061,
-0.0393831618,
-0.0614132099,
-0.0212328248,
0.0308539122,
0.0589045063,
0.0307405405,
-0.0176700931,
0.0066600507,
-0.0384268835,
0.0452799089,
0.0122829154,
0.0057852059,
-0.001315995,
-0.0362108797,
0.0050744726,
0.044731006,
0.0427867435,
0.0135483313,
0.035173513,
-0.014192231,
0.0730784163,
0.0139055038,
-0.0088015227,
-0.0516267121,
-0.054358609,
0.0238147266,
-0.0363036804,
0.0703017041,
-0.0602055416,
-0.0267097428,
0.0116071412,
0.0069801696,
-0.0282499213,
-0.0529861897,
0.017521264,
0.035521578,
0.0216280222,
-0.0056261877,
0.00164689,
0.0058820788,
-0.0691599473,
-0.0378598087,
0.0479240753,
-0.0231414177,
-0.059676636,
-0.0273463279,
-0.021819124,
0.0149316695,
-0.0492477529,
-0.0244934782,
2.914249779e-34,
0.0198229849,
-0.0147683434,
0.0430549495,
0.0969112888,
0.046340581,
-0.0057515479,
-0.0085161915,
0.0273245461,
0.0342627726,
-0.0851788521,
-0.0230683517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17461v1 | Synthetic Dialogue Dataset Generation using LLM Agents | 2024-01-30T21:49:30 | 2024-01-30T21:49:30 | Yelaman Abdullin, Diego Molla-Aliod, Bahadorreza Ofoghi, John Yearwood, Qingyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Linear programming (LP) problems are pervasive in real-life applications.
However, despite their apparent simplicity, an untrained user may find it
difficult to determine the linear model of their specific problem. We envisage
the creation of a goal-oriented conversational agent that will engage in
conversation with the user to elicit all information required so that a
subsequent agent can generate the linear model. In this paper, we present an
approach for the generation of sample dialogues that can be used to develop and
train such a conversational agent. Using prompt engineering, we develop two
agents that "talk" to each other, one acting as the conversational agent, and
the other acting as the user. Using a set of text descriptions of linear
problems from NL4Opt available to the user only, the agent and the user engage
in conversation until the agent has retrieved all key information from the
original problem description. We also propose an extrinsic evaluation of the
dialogues by assessing how well the summaries generated by the dialogues match
the original problem descriptions. We conduct human and automatic evaluations,
including an evaluation approach that uses GPT-4 to mimic the human evaluation
metrics. The evaluation results show an overall good quality of the dialogues,
though research is still needed to improve the quality of the GPT-4 evaluation
metrics. The resulting dialogues, including the human annotations of a subset,
are available to the research community. The conversational agent used for the
generation of the dialogues can be used as a baseline. | Synthetic Dialogue Dataset Generation using LLM Agents: Linear programming (LP) problems are pervasive in real-life applications.
However, despite their apparent simplicity, an untrained user may find it
difficult to determine the linear model of their specific problem. We envisage
the creation of a goal-oriented conversational agent that will engage in
conversation with the user to elicit all information required so that a
subsequent agent can generate the linear model. In this paper, we present an
approach for the generation of sample dialogues that can be used to develop and
train such a conversational agent. Using prompt engineering, we develop two
agents that "talk" to each other, one acting as the conversational agent, and
the other acting as the user. Using a set of text descriptions of linear
problems from NL4Opt available to the user only, the agent and the user engage
in conversation until the agent has retrieved all key information from the
original problem description. We also propose an extrinsic evaluation of the
dialogues by assessing how well the summaries generated by the dialogues match
the original problem descriptions. We conduct human and automatic evaluations,
including an evaluation approach that uses GPT-4 to mimic the human evaluation
metrics. The evaluation results show an overall good quality of the dialogues,
though research is still needed to improve the quality of the GPT-4 evaluation
metrics. The resulting dialogues, including the human annotations of a subset,
are available to the research community. The conversational agent used for the
generation of the dialogues can be used as a baseline. | [
0.0315373763,
0.0263596438,
-0.037414372,
0.0636662021,
-0.0168881323,
0.0090779383,
-0.0076425914,
-0.0063506817,
0.0171992481,
-0.0240547713,
0.0149503071,
0.0231794231,
-0.0246576667,
0.0485100895,
0.0114374114,
-0.0734264851,
0.001367165,
0.007074004,
-0.0025497882,
0.0158790909,
0.0245870873,
-0.0066926791,
-0.0338479318,
0.0318910182,
-0.0358033217,
-0.0007463165,
-0.0500011891,
0.0049940222,
0.0228956435,
-0.0126813315,
-0.0066798148,
0.0354412124,
0.0375147983,
-0.0202570278,
0.0000023175,
-0.0559328049,
-0.0108773028,
-0.0091941617,
-0.0482630245,
-0.031853579,
0.0231472105,
0.0361011736,
0.0121821351,
0.0107903639,
-0.0491089411,
0.0398919657,
0.032123208,
0.0374559015,
0.1102500334,
0.0764734372,
-0.0024133655,
-0.0098327128,
0.0089785643,
0.0274076946,
0.0328272618,
-0.0557699986,
-0.0069664107,
0.0485110655,
0.0366292447,
0.0037543187,
0.0194500182,
-0.0111712897,
0.0262699574,
-0.0140827429,
0.0220023971,
-0.0053550149,
-0.0572787784,
0.0077167293,
-0.0403470546,
0.0869033188,
0.0521543175,
0.0092994887,
0.0306645576,
-0.0245687999,
0.0467660688,
-0.0114088226,
-0.0293681193,
0.0214393809,
-0.0403970852,
-0.0059528528,
-0.0588644892,
-0.0134339416,
-0.0222708061,
-0.0295587648,
0.0027277048,
0.0534129553,
-0.0157135259,
-0.038063705,
0.0063806376,
-0.0196984448,
0.0069787265,
-0.0480671562,
-0.0022969479,
0.0465541184,
-0.0683737248,
0.0283793788,
-0.0183596946,
0.0153444847,
-0.0046651703,
-0.049558688,
0.0512564033,
0.0450833403,
0.0112279123,
-0.0029292793,
-0.0043384722,
0.0905782729,
0.0029477808,
0.0080131246,
-0.0381207652,
0.0406393856,
-0.0723585784,
0.0060226144,
-0.0614073761,
0.0710536018,
-0.0574312024,
0.0299228914,
-0.0305922199,
0.0721775666,
-0.0139988707,
0.0348842219,
-0.0321086273,
-0.0019826954,
0.0064220056,
-0.0054435828,
-0.0815333501,
-0.0301884972,
-0.0403927006,
-0.0146366237,
-0.0065411679,
-0.0666319355,
0.0001307928,
0.0352820605,
-0.0166572388,
-0.0001537297,
-0.0189074297,
0.1073255092,
-0.0114328275,
0.0195290223,
-0.0422155522,
-0.0554306246,
0.0264132842,
-0.0539072566,
-0.0642323345,
-0.0622264892,
0.0322078913,
-0.0113764443,
-0.0378979556,
-0.0179921594,
0.0049067633,
0.0236672703,
0.0261015948,
0.0784452632,
-0.0405263677,
0.0095892185,
0.065072991,
0.0122169387,
-0.0354986601,
0.0466632396,
0.0351588614,
0.0283454973,
0.0347639211,
-0.0192379635,
0.0308209267,
0.0304372478,
0.0051675676,
-0.0138248978,
0.0111232493,
0.0561966337,
0.0105520831,
0.0335438475,
-0.0390405767,
0.0443438515,
-0.0490373075,
0.0296220984,
0.0230205897,
0.0599188581,
0.0184178185,
0.0398170315,
0.0487861708,
0.0495408885,
0.0011813322,
0.0160969812,
-0.004444113,
0.0316666476,
-0.0194031429,
-0.0058298949,
0.0322720185,
-0.0202512443,
-0.0272620432,
-0.0788674653,
-0.0009169903,
0.0146157993,
0.0118661234,
-0.0021015168,
0.0008270157,
-0.016709974,
-0.0658437237,
0.0491625555,
0.0034396409,
-0.0825330839,
-0.0412502699,
-0.0318818986,
0.028872041,
0.087446101,
0.0327960812,
-0.0245892052,
-0.0409495011,
0.0001244601,
0.0197403226,
0.0219674148,
0.0781915933,
-0.0269721542,
-0.0298668463,
-0.0429698154,
-0.0259247422,
-0.0329863317,
-0.0182375535,
0.0195057802,
-0.0026823853,
-0.0159797408,
0.0243772101,
0.0272767488,
-0.0414605923,
0.0293130465,
-0.0521375872,
-0.0189333316,
0.0427900888,
0.0062605743,
0.0339492112,
0.0477929115,
-0.008710348,
0.0220517702,
0.0383467376,
0.0031213022,
-0.0361318588,
0.0165503658,
-0.0049725184,
-0.0053254203,
0.0403082222,
-0.069132857,
-0.0003754627,
0.0109223528,
-0.0277540591,
-0.0316020958,
0.018297771,
-0.0610228442,
-0.0146688838,
-0.0502087772,
-0.0024509851,
0.0139821516,
-0.0286141112,
-0.0432614498,
0.0601940304,
0.0339240655,
0.0127257314,
0.0340350196,
0.049896054,
0.041988913,
-0.088430576,
0.0199548025,
0.0108918715,
0.0187033117,
0.0140731679,
0.0080635147,
0.037664745,
-0.0401887782,
-0.0152342748,
-0.0812727064,
0.0132745337,
0.0132236863,
0.018451117,
0.0342460237,
-0.02439842,
-0.0170591567,
-0.0275012404,
-0.0854339898,
0.0159577746,
0.0168480352,
-0.0126695512,
0.0753420666,
0.0431024469,
-0.0325582214,
-0.022883201,
0.0237804856,
-0.0155732241,
0.0023652967,
0.0375467092,
-0.0089388276,
-0.0681644529,
0.0334979296,
-0.0222808477,
0.005339243,
-0.0211401954,
-0.0062247859,
0.0161950123,
0.0021573822,
0.0059635616,
0.0113054141,
0.0061316658,
0.0640604645,
0.0118739372,
-0.0259885322,
-0.0628285185,
0.044156529,
-0.0204886068,
-0.0056561423,
0.0061909053,
-0.0352291316,
0.0459117517,
0.0133960051,
0.0254483316,
0.0254826955,
-0.0372758619,
0.0385483094,
0.0543659627,
0.000873781,
-0.041501049,
-0.0257438403,
-0.0295097549,
0.0875224099,
-0.0070968736,
-0.0429339297,
0.0786378011,
-0.0137030482,
-0.0120909475,
-0.0341588482,
-0.0347730741,
-0.0593768843,
0.0220789947,
-0.0219044089,
-0.0091747595,
-0.0433893874,
0.0061292225,
-0.0122382659,
-0.0286538508,
0.0229879357,
-0.0247526504,
0.0711773336,
-0.0906782821,
0.0043412754,
-0.0070526414,
-0.0290119182,
-0.0532168075,
-0.0303911362,
0.0102937855,
-0.0194541197,
0.0277765878,
-0.0097309686,
0.0020728207,
-0.0007354547,
0.0031821635,
0.0268936083,
-0.0240835063,
-0.0115631912,
-0.0136718228,
-0.0264851339,
-0.0008260752,
0.0472913235,
-0.0130753126,
-0.0200520828,
0.0786301419,
0.0219931789,
-0.0206316505,
-0.0028011587,
-0.0385589339,
0.0028588073,
-0.0040319338,
-0.0125411525,
0.0096154446,
0.0375850461,
0.0292074755,
-0.0297973789,
-0.0044263089,
0.0958994702,
0.0407431126,
-0.0517709367,
-0.013284551,
-0.0409681313,
0.0086742593,
0.0127428342,
0.0466240644,
-0.0865501389,
-0.0060565039,
-0.0340944231,
0.0472035222,
-0.0411122516,
-0.0477994308,
-0.0433921702,
-0.1017379686,
0.0521115959,
-0.0081785442,
-0.0200751107,
-0.0016654201,
-0.0172443911,
-0.0207513329,
-0.0173845962,
0.0044764057,
0.0213984717,
0.0230316985,
0.0098407362,
0.009511414,
-0.0329493061,
-0.0010029315,
0.0110673113,
0.0334279723,
0.0343324505,
0.0575297289,
0.0298555233,
0.0040000845,
-0.0399747603,
0.0576885305,
0.0672175214,
0.0139260842,
-0.0083887316,
0.043151632,
-0.017828824,
-0.010770916,
-0.0064714989,
0.0490064546,
-0.0478368476,
0.001136261,
0.0649784207,
0.0224120561,
-0.0503193662,
0.0529336706,
-0.0109903459,
0.0412953384,
0.0237080734,
0.0456779227,
0.0340261422,
-0.0089926235,
-0.014123302,
-0.0565696135,
-0.0182203297,
-0.0362256654,
-0.0226561967,
-0.0100979805,
-0.0273277331,
0.0314849541,
-0.0538923219,
-0.0518421158,
0.0498897284,
0.0230254382,
-0.0059690862,
-0.0337106921,
-0.0135671496,
0.0351499654,
-0.0250489097,
0.0178095233,
-0.0011669494,
0.0203576256,
-0.0144042755,
-0.0220723376,
0.0165215451,
-0.0772823766,
-0.010351792,
0.0485730357,
-0.0660880283,
-0.0513491519,
-0.0606530942,
0.0494254753,
0.0275044255,
0.0358815864,
0.0066363164,
0.0070774062,
-0.0266276002,
0.0430720076,
-0.0081814909,
-0.0267339312,
-0.0227491334,
0.0941857249,
-0.0010191804,
0.003410104,
-0.0402711369,
0.0196689367,
-0.0249724947,
-0.0038279695,
-0.045628123,
-0.0915924534,
0.0403335355,
0.0386947431,
-0.0232959166,
0.0150557449,
-0.0627363697,
-0.0154277403,
0.0322679579,
-0.0474853367,
-0.0440934524,
-0.0622117296,
0.0075425743,
-0.0449876375,
-0.0182859916,
0.0757609457,
-0.0441784635,
-0.0713312924,
0.036467988,
-0.0064299437,
0.0263624396,
0.0094638672,
-0.0039708838,
-0.0006380911,
-0.0097627658,
-0.0141703477,
0.0066976021,
0.0056178924,
0.0367989168,
0.0339527763,
0.0729789957,
0.0307699814,
0.0270909946,
0.0363587216,
0.0186986625,
-0.0456731059,
-0.0598466843,
-0.0287825614,
0.0009570133,
-0.002710002,
0.0381250307,
-0.0074576167,
-0.0352365896,
0.0109718703,
-0.0014163016,
0.042354241,
-0.003632392,
-0.0123309689,
0.0397794694,
0.0368689075,
-0.0009394545,
-0.0736997053,
0.0482893288,
-0.0124569032,
-0.0024785034,
-0.0336087272,
-0.0268743578,
-0.0857727155,
-0.0192533489,
0.0190835521,
0.0103083095,
0.0100526176,
-0.031934306,
-0.0646920428,
-0.0332424678,
-0.0319351181,
0.0379674956,
0.0144372592,
-0.0160715319,
0.0770678893,
0.0359112322,
-0.0021508501,
0.0170971677,
-0.0227322299,
0.011398362,
-0.0464225821,
-0.0199128389,
-0.0380990282,
-5.675870065e-33,
-0.0441580638,
-0.0730969086,
0.0522324331,
0.0713304579,
-0.023714114,
-0.0393645316,
-0.0258560795,
0.0454710014,
0.0018688773,
-0.01938775,
0.0121282786,
-0.0245972406,
-0.0058431202,
-0.0222176295,
-0.0103466623,
-0.0229688175,
0.0183285661,
-0.0112099191,
-0.0370925069,
0.0104724839,
0.0144991819,
-0.0074112667,
0.0161903985,
-0.0620539226,
0.0600241721,
-0.03557292,
-0.0129749058,
0.0329043381,
-0.0077612079,
0.0461282991,
-0.0120626241,
0.052138593,
0.0277399532,
-0.0309040863,
-0.0370505936,
0.0267807003,
0.010808208,
-0.0631205067,
0.0480440781,
-0.0121031478,
-0.02911596,
-0.0330829658,
0.0313634016,
-0.0078147799,
-0.0685335845,
0.0129949301,
0.0411384851,
-0.0233936999,
0.0284436513,
0.0299457442,
-0.0326972529,
0.0307396334,
-0.0501557924,
-0.0449461639,
0.0159144066,
0.0253987797,
-0.0131131327,
-0.0231607556,
0.0209032893,
0.0471313484,
0.0495659709,
-0.0242384262,
0.0451863669,
-0.013237807,
0.0000885852,
0.0193342678,
0.0376078524,
0.0316742212,
-0.0672181472,
-0.0191444848,
-0.0474458337,
0.0493693873,
0.0357350558,
0.0759961307,
0.0105600711,
0.0103996526,
-0.008888117,
0.0698003173,
0.0179050304,
-0.0181994662,
0.0019998278,
-0.0081672892,
-0.0142711159,
-0.0097611453,
-0.0445323996,
0.0212434754,
-0.0243180376,
-0.0551593043,
0.0224315599,
-0.0283189639,
0.0432717092,
-0.0239963718,
-0.0147645902,
-0.0221690498,
0.0193718877,
-0.0159821175,
-0.0417086668,
-0.000238527,
-0.0019420374,
-0.028406946,
-0.0391084701,
-0.0122111375,
0.0191782154,
0.055965241,
0.0403999761,
0.011158186,
-0.009462513,
-0.0086962814,
-0.0196329746,
0.0222228542,
-0.0578293465,
0.0412935391,
-0.0157172363,
0.0325825661,
-0.0244885515,
-0.005948416,
-0.038272962,
0.0732198656,
-0.0500544421,
-0.050913617,
-0.0422321185,
-0.0114466501,
0.0095687686,
-0.0036509521,
-0.0225228779,
0.0064153778,
0.0054422352,
0.0528834537,
0.0502112024,
-0.0012434273,
0.0041175024,
-0.0140260383,
2.873e-7,
0.0045616236,
0.0065927599,
0.0544430315,
0.0370616913,
0.0126173338,
0.030925652,
-0.0205142312,
0.0242698807,
-0.0062233438,
-0.0406820513,
0.0362656862,
0.0202111565,
0.0471012257,
0.0284228045,
-0.0815978721,
-0.0177631285,
-0.023507107,
-0.0455611013,
-0.0582154058,
0.0290425662,
0.1492918879,
-0.0027899938,
0.0072994311,
0.0067617013,
-0.0207068752,
0.0089551639,
0.0161599107,
-0.0488460138,
-0.0237151831,
0.0137927439,
0.0123274736,
-0.0187239833,
0.0020351028,
0.0500308014,
0.0047024181,
0.0085337507,
-0.0021052293,
0.0681536719,
0.0150165576,
-0.075732924,
0.024778381,
0.0154930158,
0.0081401281,
-0.0126103843,
0.0077987844,
-0.0105084265,
-0.0303496812,
0.0051832534,
-0.0104706427,
-0.0363336839,
-0.0189115759,
-0.0487725921,
0.0226463582,
0.0105182556,
0.0023848477,
-0.0258152019,
0.0480020083,
-0.0299796052,
0.0095517281,
-0.013557204,
-0.0732112452,
-0.0622848757,
-0.0305431094,
0.0214761421,
0.0140606901,
-0.0220130235,
0.0189678185,
2.459560528e-34,
0.0301127639,
0.0203149188,
0.0200143158,
0.0346786231,
0.0464211106,
0.0232752077,
0.0062738066,
0.0265344009,
0.0380767249,
-0.0444656312,
-0.0163820013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17435v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17435v3 | Can Large Language Models Replace Economic Choice Prediction Labs? | 2024-01-30T20:49:47 | 2024-03-07T16:47:00 | Eilam Shapira, Omer Madmon, Roi Reichart, Moshe Tennenholtz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.HC | Economic choice prediction is an essential challenging task, often
constrained by the difficulties in acquiring human choice data. Indeed,
experimental economics studies had focused mostly on simple choice settings.
The AI community has recently contributed to that effort in two ways:
considering whether LLMs can substitute for humans in the above-mentioned
simple choice prediction settings, and the study through ML lens of more
elaborated but still rigorous experimental economics settings, employing
incomplete information, repetitive play, and natural language communication,
notably language-based persuasion games. This leaves us with a major
inspiration: can LLMs be used to fully simulate the economic environment and
generate data for efficient human choice prediction, substituting for the
elaborated economic lab studies? We pioneer the study of this subject,
demonstrating its feasibility. In particular, we show that a model trained
solely on LLM-generated data can effectively predict human behavior in a
language-based persuasion game, and can even outperform models trained on
actual human data. | Can Large Language Models Replace Economic Choice Prediction Labs?: Economic choice prediction is an essential challenging task, often
constrained by the difficulties in acquiring human choice data. Indeed,
experimental economics studies had focused mostly on simple choice settings.
The AI community has recently contributed to that effort in two ways:
considering whether LLMs can substitute for humans in the above-mentioned
simple choice prediction settings, and the study through ML lens of more
elaborated but still rigorous experimental economics settings, employing
incomplete information, repetitive play, and natural language communication,
notably language-based persuasion games. This leaves us with a major
inspiration: can LLMs be used to fully simulate the economic environment and
generate data for efficient human choice prediction, substituting for the
elaborated economic lab studies? We pioneer the study of this subject,
demonstrating its feasibility. In particular, we show that a model trained
solely on LLM-generated data can effectively predict human behavior in a
language-based persuasion game, and can even outperform models trained on
actual human data. | [
0.0298340004,
0.1036725417,
-0.0342428796,
0.0303276554,
-0.0142607633,
-0.0072726165,
0.0075532235,
0.0216337815,
0.0420509093,
-0.0059482167,
-0.0246854853,
-0.0146102924,
0.01225325,
0.0403793007,
0.0397917107,
-0.0212929174,
-0.001489062,
-0.0302812364,
0.0384808518,
-0.048279468,
-0.0290880222,
-0.0304536857,
0.003387305,
0.0295186527,
0.0123395519,
0.0127721801,
-0.0338370651,
-0.0506897941,
-0.0038414043,
-0.0396624692,
0.0051867403,
0.0323595107,
0.0498140007,
-0.0089789238,
0.0000018807,
-0.0455802456,
0.0165181085,
-0.0400900468,
-0.0602192283,
-0.0071273199,
0.0758996755,
0.0430308953,
0.0307725519,
0.0070666275,
-0.0670648664,
0.0477960072,
0.0505619124,
0.0069068316,
0.0300480239,
0.0412135422,
0.0041528135,
-0.0247105565,
0.0047514001,
-0.0453638509,
0.0092732562,
-0.0292358678,
0.0328871645,
-0.0486338921,
0.0082949037,
-0.0088843154,
-0.0144488895,
-0.0162352994,
-0.0053495369,
0.007690765,
-0.0417005643,
0.0669479743,
-0.0290425979,
0.0019720069,
-0.0250024013,
0.0459724739,
0.0087049995,
-0.016976798,
0.0287523419,
-0.0034843553,
0.0406286679,
0.0085950224,
-0.0195921622,
0.026209658,
0.0215046108,
0.0530706011,
0.0310804136,
0.0085067786,
0.042221874,
0.0431063324,
0.0144257704,
0.0880135968,
-0.0352345631,
-0.0362946428,
0.028918257,
0.0382961966,
0.0076249135,
-0.0651300997,
-0.0416734554,
-0.0039566034,
-0.0707113147,
0.0131408907,
0.0011526153,
0.0353559479,
0.0016206403,
-0.0624446012,
0.0521552861,
0.0369982347,
0.0175262485,
0.0176745299,
0.0311726388,
0.0493693985,
0.0062145945,
0.0009272281,
-0.0116745159,
0.0287098512,
-0.0180102624,
0.00675658,
-0.0179011263,
0.0260566156,
-0.0226104036,
0.0005841022,
-0.0531197526,
-0.0079783713,
-0.0682068542,
0.0558368452,
-0.0245748051,
0.046095036,
-0.0189477503,
-0.0074285702,
-0.1053599268,
-0.0175313018,
-0.0340802856,
0.0348070078,
0.0305251796,
-0.0090573858,
0.025999248,
0.0179617666,
-0.028309362,
-0.0125105986,
0.0541942753,
0.1129494682,
0.0246187281,
0.0138931656,
-0.0239800215,
0.0022136148,
0.0049910028,
-0.0773196816,
-0.0012632392,
-0.055802308,
0.0393232107,
-0.0044669574,
0.0006948537,
-0.0697003305,
0.003549976,
-0.0056979866,
-0.0486129969,
0.0895063505,
0.0463783927,
-0.0031759606,
0.0066312114,
-0.0191944465,
-0.0141241159,
0.0547395013,
0.0328952521,
0.0622119606,
0.0324871838,
-0.0259352773,
0.0410317369,
0.0603733882,
-0.0003262197,
0.0121820215,
-0.0451880097,
-0.0133984778,
-0.0411474817,
0.0433762893,
0.021558227,
0.0345016532,
-0.019963298,
-0.0282818154,
0.0953801349,
0.0579711534,
0.01312041,
0.0101804845,
0.0081809843,
0.048050154,
-0.0010638204,
0.0175988786,
-0.0222983528,
0.0043330044,
-0.0247030761,
0.0005025838,
0.0169215817,
-0.0084321313,
-0.023659382,
-0.0342489146,
0.0351483971,
-0.0515384488,
0.0590839349,
0.0545257069,
0.025041705,
-0.0614883825,
-0.0404027589,
0.0265082885,
0.0776404515,
0.0110359909,
-0.0194083154,
-0.0627384186,
0.0666465238,
0.0808428973,
0.0258562397,
-0.016138088,
0.0493654013,
-0.0325459689,
-0.0426632725,
0.0600456931,
0.0787671283,
-0.0396604203,
0.0005722532,
-0.0208724383,
-0.0077664726,
-0.0023591174,
0.0174924973,
0.0652893037,
0.0211979821,
-0.0352272242,
-0.0315290429,
0.0174785797,
-0.0062104096,
0.0136436448,
-0.0411299504,
-0.0480012223,
0.0010665449,
-0.0114665329,
0.059362594,
-0.0190648194,
-0.0080606313,
-0.0034399724,
0.0136872344,
-0.0046805455,
-0.0224676188,
-0.0144083537,
0.0000787967,
-0.0060754488,
0.015812356,
-0.0004286751,
-0.0131141422,
0.0076885298,
-0.0220602341,
0.0123841353,
0.0028117162,
-0.0120621296,
0.0607097298,
-0.00548886,
-0.0114455409,
-0.0202054977,
-0.0085467473,
-0.026727654,
0.0529713184,
-0.0013960797,
-0.0107940361,
-0.0008750237,
-0.0309913903,
-0.0366433486,
-0.0787069723,
0.0319948569,
0.0152687607,
0.0275095347,
0.0402564183,
0.0404740311,
-0.0024090675,
-0.0285820216,
-0.0245692786,
-0.0590021722,
-0.0290562157,
0.0251187887,
-0.0118151791,
-0.0177081227,
-0.0564363711,
-0.0123100234,
0.0111916484,
-0.0503009968,
0.0239554755,
0.0363698043,
0.0284850746,
0.0307209007,
0.0179120023,
-0.0025189337,
-0.033169996,
0.0053441045,
-0.003971843,
0.0499951988,
0.0167595949,
0.0075541991,
-0.0472869538,
-0.0009208518,
-0.0112500517,
0.0191367418,
-0.0244221222,
-0.0208420642,
-0.0045615323,
-0.0066007883,
0.0262751002,
0.0547371469,
0.0143612074,
0.0383640155,
0.0555592626,
0.0025186248,
-0.0817995742,
0.0085092299,
-0.0388923101,
0.002652365,
-0.0931489617,
-0.0451715104,
0.0185930431,
0.069134973,
-0.0052481652,
0.0206900481,
-0.0053895204,
0.0676401854,
0.0314372368,
-0.0570243746,
-0.0571076199,
0.0002032661,
-0.0489413179,
0.0534037128,
0.0047788257,
-0.0553257763,
0.0767607167,
0.0072917119,
0.0056214761,
0.0173978787,
-0.0216630157,
-0.0147640808,
0.0123982849,
0.0149582662,
-0.0241004378,
-0.0237379037,
0.0194768868,
-0.0414688475,
-0.0529097579,
0.0250362083,
-0.0232196767,
0.0521379597,
-0.0497768335,
-0.0059411596,
0.0247957334,
-0.0605132394,
-0.0464207865,
-0.0799440742,
-0.0590340607,
-0.0143329054,
0.0384394526,
-0.0294707417,
-0.0419131629,
-0.0383983105,
0.0202024821,
-0.0125955436,
0.014708709,
-0.015424802,
0.0240264609,
0.0203393716,
0.0493565574,
0.0284283664,
-0.0046203653,
-0.0649383739,
0.0153999347,
0.0173324887,
-0.0249891728,
-0.0003453477,
-0.0125620291,
0.0185666122,
0.0305264331,
-0.0064711338,
0.0252442844,
0.0818168074,
-0.0394780897,
-0.0291037392,
0.0113254767,
0.0792888328,
0.0055994894,
-0.0251961388,
0.0075145573,
-0.0001791817,
0.0412660502,
-0.0004112146,
0.0300566517,
-0.0675749034,
-0.0239611361,
0.0201655608,
0.0383901373,
-0.0213253088,
-0.0386055969,
0.0009838813,
-0.1216689199,
0.0270499252,
-0.012817489,
0.0007837767,
0.0030790353,
-0.0406166278,
-0.0197621267,
-0.0753824711,
0.0128369471,
-0.0217316281,
0.0116546052,
0.0006122782,
-0.0071333791,
-0.0206629317,
-0.0080486061,
0.0417877957,
-0.0143789472,
0.0454060435,
0.0553265736,
0.0625708178,
-0.0512840971,
-0.0122921048,
0.0087068491,
0.0475183725,
-0.0188875142,
0.0114702377,
0.0552130118,
0.0076323436,
0.0052578128,
-0.007671834,
0.0413902178,
0.0178141184,
-0.0223179329,
0.0367168263,
0.0082568387,
-0.0082970848,
-0.0716911033,
0.0646548793,
-0.0063626389,
0.045389276,
0.0743120313,
0.0085125687,
-0.0938967466,
-0.0253832303,
-0.0668764859,
-0.0496352054,
-0.0091787586,
-0.0745779797,
-0.0364419706,
0.0109206503,
0.0271437205,
-0.0376367532,
-0.0522905216,
-0.0072952881,
-0.0122752655,
0.0126806274,
0.0021117479,
0.0235377755,
0.0191014092,
0.0355291031,
0.0262783282,
-0.0497269183,
0.0001846651,
-0.0331790447,
-0.0154897105,
-0.0006182751,
-0.0775877535,
-0.0253153779,
0.000618468,
-0.0203710329,
-0.0811568201,
0.0108015761,
0.0704641119,
0.02749696,
0.0561100431,
0.0299161654,
-0.0016925883,
0.0076550767,
0.0351433009,
-0.0223092716,
0.0072256881,
0.0538159832,
0.0468765013,
-0.004252614,
0.0217357855,
-0.0149942404,
0.0410901867,
0.0216498505,
0.011880585,
-0.0632671863,
-0.0509211756,
0.0322571285,
-0.0103142001,
0.0348763242,
-0.0522246845,
-0.0097924983,
-0.0085356617,
0.0001869158,
0.0117964819,
-0.0164011531,
-0.0103914151,
-0.0822829753,
0.0404098406,
0.0122213401,
0.0242185127,
-0.0242913887,
-0.0309917852,
0.0070392704,
0.0065845861,
0.0379774459,
0.0260586515,
0.0337395258,
0.0569047257,
-0.0059695775,
0.0169914924,
0.0374250896,
-0.0089833355,
0.062320374,
0.0306485239,
0.0349485092,
0.0340751968,
-0.0317960456,
0.0149515374,
-0.0351136476,
0.0038810822,
-0.0604758523,
-0.000048397,
0.0242708866,
0.0195696522,
-0.0475766249,
0.0005139334,
-0.0586007014,
-0.0238360278,
-0.0197788794,
0.0012106051,
-0.0438748226,
-0.0513278358,
0.003143935,
0.0055560363,
-0.0677465051,
0.0143562965,
0.0755006298,
0.0391588621,
0.0318750367,
-0.0248183608,
-0.0018436054,
-0.0299339369,
-0.0254026335,
0.0201096218,
-0.0187302027,
-0.0182619262,
-0.0001641422,
-0.0630021617,
-0.0374135114,
-0.0330107659,
0.0375218764,
-0.0031262683,
-0.0416122675,
0.0225502402,
0.0113539575,
-0.022547761,
0.0896775573,
-0.0392524078,
0.0599742644,
-0.0255321693,
-0.0255938135,
-0.0719621032,
-5.523573384e-33,
0.0170784071,
-0.0557374433,
0.0353405438,
-0.0097616538,
0.031256821,
-0.0233079661,
-0.031681519,
0.0081426222,
-0.0043931231,
0.0195471905,
-0.0073307646,
-0.0423069634,
0.0137427542,
-0.0011965886,
0.0253830478,
-0.0396083519,
0.0218623504,
-0.0196736641,
-0.0365944915,
-0.0176333413,
-0.0169100761,
0.0033744865,
0.0318361297,
-0.0481306724,
0.0166024044,
-0.0091849798,
-0.0088983085,
0.0072608832,
-0.0173613951,
0.0377405137,
-0.0113742976,
0.0321068913,
0.0085484786,
-0.0515432321,
-0.0076594534,
0.0316206627,
-0.0207479782,
-0.0222506318,
-0.0076385955,
-0.0559642948,
0.0009924031,
0.0007729638,
0.0040299185,
0.0019775829,
-0.0434029251,
0.0304496679,
0.0265959762,
-0.0448985472,
-0.0064267274,
0.0282564089,
-0.0260332394,
-0.004233887,
-0.0186846573,
0.0086569786,
0.0323319845,
0.0943349451,
-0.0156791806,
0.0412230268,
-0.0165602677,
0.0889257565,
0.027347099,
-0.0388265885,
0.0266811699,
-0.0224025734,
0.0385134071,
0.0557993241,
0.0424703509,
-0.0047968151,
-0.0422014557,
-0.0299152303,
0.0035558918,
0.0597439297,
0.0418617241,
0.0578145534,
0.0058757737,
-0.0292212516,
-0.0101437112,
0.0260818321,
0.0819254816,
-0.0156520046,
0.0008541425,
0.0238963366,
-0.035636615,
-0.058500953,
-0.0472931787,
-0.036535494,
-0.0041103014,
-0.0276257712,
0.0250208806,
0.00904301,
0.0220712014,
-0.0189882945,
0.0345998183,
-0.0509958006,
-0.0680205822,
0.002207201,
0.0172658227,
0.0221077744,
0.0069386167,
-0.0341716744,
-0.0655681565,
-0.0444665477,
-0.0385610498,
-0.0016345164,
0.016141206,
0.0137594379,
-0.0013350655,
0.0019596415,
-0.0162617899,
0.0220810324,
-0.0165118631,
-0.0023210787,
0.0531849563,
-0.0172468107,
0.0386440046,
-0.0252716281,
0.0127589721,
-0.0203081481,
-0.03873384,
-0.0144498851,
-0.0094833625,
-0.0296337884,
-0.032002043,
0.0353391878,
-0.0107052987,
0.0117233722,
-0.0439864434,
0.0446236059,
0.0259154122,
-0.0242659003,
-0.001403539,
-0.0620663464,
2.487e-7,
-0.0101449899,
0.0769048259,
-0.0378039852,
0.017741017,
-0.0110971807,
0.0818436891,
-0.058255326,
0.0052945851,
0.0195074603,
-0.0229080971,
0.0329369903,
0.0246305019,
0.0614447445,
0.0119972602,
-0.0938266665,
-0.006182042,
-0.0499904938,
0.0016901194,
-0.0339557491,
-0.0116427364,
-0.0012334785,
0.0475663655,
0.060285978,
-0.0202785265,
0.0056531527,
-0.0100481287,
0.0493923873,
-0.1066246703,
-0.016321471,
0.0089607118,
-0.0128876911,
-0.0033566649,
-0.012666286,
-0.0110538946,
-0.0178827252,
0.0021069259,
-0.0485515185,
0.0449777618,
0.0419615731,
-0.0262329653,
-0.0118736811,
-0.0191296078,
-0.0030738299,
-0.015396758,
0.0359645709,
-0.071616143,
-0.0483226739,
-0.0494736619,
0.0035425841,
-0.0140357492,
0.0094781723,
-0.0346510001,
0.0126912771,
-0.0282410905,
0.0052538817,
-0.0081771966,
0.0351099782,
-0.0089288605,
-0.0408214517,
0.0278721061,
-0.0672661215,
-0.0501989052,
-0.0129105682,
0.0525184534,
-0.0036090955,
-0.0735484436,
0.0237170197,
2.016548161e-34,
0.0385127552,
0.0228438061,
-0.0031233109,
0.008503342,
0.046464853,
0.0187624376,
0.0256766994,
0.0245806091,
0.0655228198,
-0.0525165386,
0.0032205218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00070v1 | EvoMerge: Neuroevolution for Large Language Models | 2024-01-30T19:37:21 | 2024-01-30T19:37:21 | Yushu Jiang | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Extensive fine-tuning on Large Language Models does not always yield better
results. Oftentimes, models tend to get better at imitating one form of data
without gaining greater reasoning ability and may even end up losing some
intelligence. Here I introduce EvoMerge, a systematic approach to large
language model training and merging. Leveraging model merging for weight
crossover and fine-tuning for weight mutation, EvoMerge establishes an
evolutionary process aimed at pushing models beyond the limits of conventional
fine-tuning. | EvoMerge: Neuroevolution for Large Language Models: Extensive fine-tuning on Large Language Models does not always yield better
results. Oftentimes, models tend to get better at imitating one form of data
without gaining greater reasoning ability and may even end up losing some
intelligence. Here I introduce EvoMerge, a systematic approach to large
language model training and merging. Leveraging model merging for weight
crossover and fine-tuning for weight mutation, EvoMerge establishes an
evolutionary process aimed at pushing models beyond the limits of conventional
fine-tuning. | [
0.0080606043,
0.0961882547,
-0.0002191286,
0.0433810353,
0.0124206813,
0.050322555,
-0.0034934501,
-0.0159174092,
-0.0213723071,
-0.0110388752,
-0.031565275,
0.0262621623,
-0.0183022302,
0.0483942069,
0.0684288591,
0.0016249074,
0.0633797273,
-0.0366204269,
-0.0366546065,
-0.0181746781,
-0.0317935795,
0.0235888697,
0.0189509466,
0.0119934389,
0.0362271555,
0.0175431762,
-0.0089338524,
-0.0022245683,
0.0192020256,
0.0021209405,
-0.0000224945,
0.0400673337,
0.0275943968,
0.1045525819,
0.0000017215,
-0.0447605066,
0.0167775862,
0.0010909396,
-0.0264603924,
0.0145277372,
0.0490546152,
0.0021342307,
-0.0202465225,
0.0073582456,
-0.0326108895,
-0.0117207877,
0.0435402803,
0.0359746218,
0.0680986941,
0.0616853014,
0.0000262776,
-0.0649339929,
0.0562169887,
-0.0494324267,
0.0182316303,
-0.0117157837,
0.0384807996,
0.0029952857,
-0.0002717555,
-0.0049466803,
-0.0028121746,
0.0148411635,
0.0293855797,
-0.0273641162,
0.0035874743,
0.0398079269,
-0.0307630971,
-0.0255962908,
-0.0127436658,
0.0522115864,
-0.0402072556,
-0.0339854695,
-0.0181637909,
0.0288736578,
0.025328245,
-0.0497486852,
-0.0424702466,
-0.0279636998,
0.0323380381,
0.0363098308,
0.0407357551,
-0.0828883648,
0.0664508119,
0.0217826553,
-0.0369125195,
0.0471720845,
0.06895376,
-0.0079567209,
0.0026399705,
-0.0208900068,
-0.0247003306,
-0.0418236293,
-0.0087431939,
0.0250676982,
-0.0175422467,
-0.0024522156,
-0.0601206794,
-0.0370485149,
-0.0007125626,
-0.0093088774,
0.0474576578,
0.03257218,
0.0225667357,
0.0496744886,
-0.0477392338,
0.014265419,
-0.0357957892,
0.019168498,
-0.0489285924,
-0.0007795196,
-0.0618249439,
0.0108933821,
-0.0329330042,
-0.024224082,
-0.0374981947,
-0.0319016688,
-0.0378590748,
-0.0180473272,
0.0100988355,
-0.0361754596,
0.02362312,
0.0087010404,
-0.026332628,
-0.013727936,
-0.0131034767,
0.0485547632,
0.0010867188,
0.0384445079,
0.0133349476,
-0.0034112183,
-0.015625082,
-0.011306596,
-0.0110912556,
-0.0285207108,
0.0301014688,
0.0509892181,
-0.0196349118,
-0.015037098,
-0.0303077362,
0.0105054229,
-0.0040894742,
-0.0376739427,
-0.0149513269,
-0.0584438518,
0.0665984452,
-0.0469408296,
-0.0165396109,
-0.0413501151,
-0.0016162239,
-0.030428024,
-0.0341445208,
0.0678841174,
-0.0397663899,
0.0190250389,
0.0382085852,
-0.0112639936,
-0.0121119069,
0.0538312271,
0.0317932367,
-0.018182328,
-0.0124676693,
-0.0156407971,
-0.0358115882,
0.0341826156,
0.015360984,
0.0533835255,
-0.0183468889,
-0.0265857056,
0.0258925781,
0.0242230296,
0.0678067505,
0.0407023691,
-0.0443383716,
-0.0347574949,
0.0612792708,
0.0316693261,
0.0567784496,
0.0357528254,
0.0465362072,
-0.0522253588,
-0.0050447243,
-0.0359676406,
-0.0568021759,
0.0075895493,
-0.0416708998,
0.0064945323,
0.0230779462,
0.0801018327,
-0.0168241095,
-0.0282575469,
-0.0030397838,
-0.0044885427,
0.0224143397,
0.0056755175,
0.0460235365,
0.0180770382,
-0.0200018808,
0.0395846739,
0.0594610684,
-0.0273398366,
0.0033171447,
-0.0596915409,
0.0361419097,
0.0434806533,
0.0128867524,
0.0212646443,
-0.0157201085,
0.0161942523,
-0.0026129065,
0.060109321,
0.0696849898,
-0.016840402,
0.0423932597,
-0.0425874926,
-0.0212392062,
-0.0060945726,
0.0205607489,
0.0160672162,
0.01031431,
0.0141193345,
-0.0039653266,
-0.0008011028,
-0.0614668503,
0.0516574197,
-0.0715319887,
-0.011032057,
-0.0284164231,
-0.0443149544,
0.0203462429,
-0.0176384859,
-0.0219104271,
0.0192230213,
0.0141611155,
-0.0199685991,
-0.0374671817,
0.0208148602,
0.0030365633,
-0.0153844729,
0.0681033507,
-0.0003788832,
-0.0104742087,
-0.004454853,
-0.0443567894,
-0.045829121,
0.0142264124,
-0.0234236401,
0.0891705155,
-0.037755169,
0.0644981265,
-0.0278480258,
0.0097124549,
-0.0253869053,
0.0590537675,
-0.0075446707,
-0.0318343602,
0.0123725943,
0.0029968456,
0.0190301295,
-0.0167416129,
-0.0201936271,
0.0186917018,
0.00480654,
0.0125630172,
-0.0157730356,
0.0129539575,
-0.0223576855,
-0.051683981,
-0.0945863202,
0.0396541022,
-0.0079445215,
0.0313716307,
0.0350243896,
0.0014620757,
-0.0092641357,
0.0162695572,
0.0083425082,
0.0462021194,
-0.0052592969,
0.0190124344,
0.0153909493,
-0.0068986723,
0.0073242304,
-0.0484274551,
-0.0436486863,
-0.0368084162,
0.0779898912,
-0.0043593813,
0.0275379792,
-0.0926093385,
0.0162622239,
-0.0581387691,
0.0386456363,
-0.0080536334,
-0.0572588332,
-0.0022369113,
-0.0160597321,
0.0435458273,
0.0864310265,
0.0201687794,
-0.0156638958,
0.0601079166,
0.0096260617,
-0.013946143,
0.011051083,
0.0026652168,
0.0058152522,
-0.06778346,
-0.0213297363,
0.0009800241,
0.0679559708,
-0.0556077287,
-0.0358613804,
-0.0539286137,
0.0265537109,
-0.0099280514,
-0.0455517732,
0.0132681318,
-0.0100312158,
-0.0198322777,
0.0184170958,
-0.0616869666,
-0.0272466354,
0.0547802858,
-0.0158211105,
-0.0040711192,
-0.0719723403,
-0.0160267167,
-0.036107257,
0.0323533639,
0.0201241188,
0.0324540325,
-0.0207053758,
0.0074545764,
-0.0518583879,
-0.006218622,
0.0056991535,
-0.007515118,
0.049829416,
-0.0298388973,
0.0335826837,
0.0110239824,
-0.0491929129,
-0.0064658658,
0.0003615687,
-0.0479326695,
0.0014596594,
0.0252698921,
-0.0672874302,
-0.0812108815,
-0.0008178307,
0.0063067921,
0.0696125031,
-0.0252758339,
-0.0050739958,
-0.0116582168,
-0.0008461076,
0.081450589,
0.0398625918,
0.0500431098,
-0.0426507667,
0.0372767486,
0.0413643457,
0.0045470726,
0.0173407439,
-0.0653670654,
0.0519599281,
0.0269800462,
-0.0220111609,
-0.001495213,
-0.0140553322,
0.0250570178,
-0.055751022,
0.0182419457,
0.0913177207,
0.0068819886,
-0.0308105554,
0.0081656156,
-0.0568433106,
0.0506582037,
0.0312695093,
0.063065663,
-0.0600108914,
-0.0481172837,
0.0085348869,
-0.030291168,
0.0206857231,
-0.0301847104,
-0.0157001168,
-0.1229522675,
-0.0058538979,
0.0349148177,
-0.0524801612,
0.0121613462,
-0.0097922198,
-0.0073912991,
-0.0265801474,
0.0312632732,
0.0239915401,
-0.0263254549,
-0.0186082665,
-0.0085667828,
0.0375584625,
-0.0494210534,
0.0243433025,
-0.0600229204,
0.0801853314,
0.0550432466,
0.0185358599,
-0.0056624394,
-0.0707974583,
0.0885104313,
-0.0130120423,
-0.0144598568,
-0.0032188715,
0.0492342114,
0.0172564909,
-0.0235959999,
0.0009533426,
0.0314301476,
0.0051706578,
-0.0310631916,
-0.0078479331,
0.0423139408,
0.0138685061,
-0.0634196848,
-0.01734039,
-0.023482807,
-0.0232823789,
0.0526900366,
0.0130568724,
-0.04514255,
-0.0216979012,
-0.0046431064,
-0.0526825525,
-0.0153429406,
-0.0365718566,
0.0533616319,
0.0121642854,
-0.061763268,
-0.0599109083,
-0.0058711488,
0.0450231768,
0.0378413647,
0.0377111435,
-0.0040641995,
0.0018613627,
-0.0586649552,
-0.0347729027,
0.0612422973,
-0.0198885016,
-0.0194832645,
-0.0758367777,
-0.0074664843,
0.0426794067,
0.0005191083,
-0.0171282608,
0.0042921416,
-0.0814852268,
-0.0996422172,
-0.0078247664,
0.0600319952,
0.0321372263,
0.0395283625,
-0.0206374526,
-0.0536253303,
0.0427359603,
0.0160435569,
0.0122883776,
0.0221117903,
0.0055452818,
-0.0505271554,
0.0074448301,
0.0266337153,
-0.0216450896,
0.0233652964,
0.0132130124,
0.028688712,
-0.0305637866,
-0.0026352413,
-0.009348507,
-0.0057151825,
-0.014119152,
-0.0218781475,
-0.0155504439,
-0.0629333034,
0.0163138378,
-0.0097279465,
0.0049321936,
-0.0402560905,
-0.0161033832,
0.0381248742,
0.0245466605,
0.023022959,
0.0153392022,
0.0400801376,
-0.0087017538,
-0.0219168868,
-0.0042307526,
-0.0267999731,
0.0312046409,
0.0254100654,
-0.0071570356,
0.0091552623,
0.047122892,
-0.0070553203,
0.0443008691,
-0.0414801836,
0.0258067399,
0.0372398086,
-0.0163212754,
-0.0286991056,
0.0534938835,
-0.0767149851,
-0.0397011973,
-0.0224786904,
0.0053034085,
0.0474647433,
0.0028752612,
0.1040704027,
0.0018722118,
-0.0524809621,
-0.0049153571,
-0.0123717114,
-0.0343002714,
0.0029126452,
0.0546221025,
0.0242886338,
-0.0037640447,
0.0017157038,
0.0352224596,
-0.003131794,
0.0646674633,
0.0040430264,
0.0271911006,
-0.0080767293,
-0.0323268212,
0.015240998,
-0.0404313207,
-0.0389862657,
-0.0179966111,
-0.0013426526,
-0.0774745569,
-0.0110547058,
0.057346236,
-0.0204729792,
0.0345063955,
0.0091575757,
0.038656503,
-0.0158327222,
-0.0239712503,
0.0062895976,
-0.0294703897,
-0.0006735868,
-0.0450825989,
-0.0043516527,
-6.014911656e-33,
-0.0036811088,
0.0134072816,
0.0492572524,
-0.0108981496,
-0.0639419407,
-0.0235027522,
-0.0402138457,
-0.0098058162,
-0.0391959734,
0.0148342988,
-0.0086741559,
0.0436866172,
-0.0079142796,
0.0062149819,
0.0221030563,
-0.0036597534,
0.0476276055,
0.0125482799,
-0.0128272763,
-0.0088717993,
-0.0317297205,
0.0284361262,
0.0404047482,
-0.0110954009,
-0.0286316946,
0.0547603406,
-0.0047212974,
0.043867778,
-0.0209563877,
0.0577959977,
-0.0319411531,
-0.0023141457,
-0.0007994046,
-0.0257635303,
-0.0268717576,
-0.021829199,
-0.0402223989,
-0.0139883161,
0.0074404203,
-0.0191062596,
-0.0291689355,
-0.0362838432,
0.06959714,
0.0122910859,
0.0085553611,
-0.0240077414,
0.0312927663,
-0.0467270687,
-0.0014614398,
0.0142793767,
-0.0746968985,
0.0006892746,
0.0112864943,
0.0013850698,
0.0101587679,
-0.0330661982,
0.0142354034,
-0.0039016572,
-0.0249648131,
0.0216941182,
0.009565142,
0.0356589071,
0.0590700619,
0.021762535,
0.0237431247,
0.0518461354,
0.0287555493,
-0.0388892516,
-0.0117248986,
-0.0202115197,
0.0816919729,
0.063649036,
0.0572036095,
0.013729007,
0.0249213576,
-0.0187534578,
-0.0376573093,
0.0220146477,
0.0242506489,
0.0369306169,
-0.0189643465,
0.0561568104,
0.0248810071,
-0.0053202766,
-0.0517953411,
-0.0317296311,
-0.0457663275,
-0.0079992143,
0.0008491487,
-0.0157336183,
-0.0237325355,
-0.0156321693,
0.0228857119,
-0.0318882763,
-0.0245188866,
0.0162749682,
-0.0162053276,
-0.0053126211,
-0.0091485372,
0.0467607714,
0.0115906866,
-0.0466743521,
0.0187345278,
0.0365340337,
0.0332864746,
-0.011006793,
0.0271660257,
0.0283463374,
-0.0598556548,
0.0205743946,
-0.0221777968,
-0.0010331393,
0.0339133665,
0.0690862387,
0.0242162142,
0.0120521188,
0.0197802838,
-0.0303965695,
0.0371804871,
0.0087284315,
-0.0495443121,
0.0557172596,
0.055790104,
0.0295719989,
-0.0231107008,
0.0124140801,
-0.0227609538,
0.0504882261,
0.0259539671,
-0.0647821277,
-0.0498450808,
0.0460935719,
2.464e-7,
0.0448605642,
0.0330232941,
0.0042696018,
-0.0273881573,
0.0210718364,
0.02999519,
-0.0301350076,
0.013754474,
0.0370586775,
-0.0058721043,
-0.0126149356,
0.058875002,
0.0616978928,
-0.0003308761,
-0.0661235079,
-0.0215165317,
-0.0635064691,
0.0117889578,
-0.0796548203,
-0.0288231503,
0.0073850667,
0.110812068,
0.0384793133,
-0.0523572862,
0.0203532632,
-0.0427383184,
0.0506359525,
-0.0104380604,
0.0214792751,
0.0305038169,
-0.038638521,
0.0364890471,
-0.0161561929,
-0.0038573551,
-0.0187551212,
0.016874522,
-0.0372851975,
0.0549195223,
-0.0356306098,
0.0135712372,
0.0082284268,
0.0124856774,
-0.0326843634,
-0.038711872,
0.0615746528,
-0.054838635,
-0.0399847664,
-0.0753070936,
-0.0200584996,
-0.0360871516,
0.0253218543,
-0.046369832,
-0.0030968098,
0.0445801504,
0.0206632074,
-0.0073344838,
-0.0258753989,
-0.0800793171,
-0.0220065918,
0.0125407055,
-0.0639640912,
-0.0424527824,
-0.0367337391,
0.0081396149,
0.0184979737,
-0.0594104119,
0.0211062636,
2.324056106e-34,
0.0042328336,
0.0005909744,
0.0584681928,
-0.0054849344,
0.0388387814,
0.0046254187,
0.0056250547,
-0.0131127359,
0.0044962275,
-0.0826944262,
-0.0247391388
] |