id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| text
stringlengths 190
2.08k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01300v1 | Collaborative Performance Prediction for Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T13:56:42 | 2024-07-01T13:56:42 | Qiyuan Zhang, Fuyuan Lyu, Xue Liu, Chen Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Comprehensively understanding and accurately predicting the performance of
large language models across diverse downstream tasks has emerged as a pivotal
challenge in NLP research. The pioneering scaling law on downstream works
demonstrated intrinsic similarities within model families and utilized such
similarities for performance prediction. However, they tend to overlook the
similarities between model families and only consider design factors listed in
the original scaling law. To overcome these limitations, we introduce a novel
framework, Collaborative Performance Prediction (CPP), which significantly
enhances prediction accuracy by leveraging the historical performance of
various models on downstream tasks and other design factors for both model and
task. We also collect a collaborative data sourced from online platforms
containing both historical performance and additional design factors. With the
support of the collaborative data, CPP not only surpasses traditional scaling
laws in predicting the performance of scaled LLMs but also facilitates a
detailed analysis of factor importance, an area previously overlooked. | Collaborative Performance Prediction for Large Language Models: Comprehensively understanding and accurately predicting the performance of
large language models across diverse downstream tasks has emerged as a pivotal
challenge in NLP research. The pioneering scaling law on downstream works
demonstrated intrinsic similarities within model families and utilized such
similarities for performance prediction. However, they tend to overlook the
similarities between model families and only consider design factors listed in
the original scaling law. To overcome these limitations, we introduce a novel
framework, Collaborative Performance Prediction (CPP), which significantly
enhances prediction accuracy by leveraging the historical performance of
various models on downstream tasks and other design factors for both model and
task. We also collect a collaborative data sourced from online platforms
containing both historical performance and additional design factors. With the
support of the collaborative data, CPP not only surpasses traditional scaling
laws in predicting the performance of scaled LLMs but also facilitates a
detailed analysis of factor importance, an area previously overlooked. | [
0.0121283848,
0.0640256405,
-0.0238627251,
0.0394208245,
-0.0307083279,
-0.0005707921,
0.0455298722,
0.0160560124,
-0.0151985399,
-0.0444427691,
-0.0692465976,
-0.0606517531,
0.016299367,
0.0371444933,
0.0194461104,
-0.016537372,
0.0032381548,
-0.0191372111,
-0.0379404314,
-0.0088272914,
0.0059984364,
0.0041216505,
0.024434302,
0.0575118996,
0.0111282999,
-0.0114055546,
0.0298326127,
0.005710247,
-0.0359341279,
-0.0178050958,
0.0121790785,
0.060090661,
-0.0021900516,
0.0358800739,
0.0000018074,
-0.0428804345,
-0.0168409087,
0.0060835709,
-0.0130151575,
0.0433239974,
0.0337542184,
0.0049101952,
0.011722574,
0.0419575125,
-0.035787601,
-0.0099405171,
0.0152372671,
0.0198994428,
0.0050693899,
0.0443287194,
0.0014966044,
-0.0007827854,
0.0220529903,
-0.0288076121,
-0.0586067773,
-0.0331114233,
-0.001077159,
0.0218985062,
-0.0260807239,
0.0038602301,
-0.0135022737,
0.0401878767,
0.0022274968,
0.0042779553,
-0.0020942697,
0.0222366061,
-0.004011895,
-0.0094152009,
-0.0038753033,
0.0542810224,
-0.015114571,
-0.0175151005,
-0.0048068464,
-0.0309944991,
-0.0225796402,
0.0475085899,
-0.0637991652,
0.0021567589,
0.0207902435,
0.0116083631,
0.0102193411,
0.012458628,
0.0634987801,
0.0190306026,
0.0078507885,
0.0987578183,
0.027480565,
-0.0079960637,
-0.0324209891,
0.0030078914,
-0.0244306661,
-0.0188893024,
0.0032187821,
-0.0069219614,
-0.0313006192,
0.0111960862,
0.0235720817,
-0.0304209311,
0.0200005807,
-0.0561808385,
0.1033391729,
0.0083046267,
0.0385301895,
0.0268125422,
-0.0395001248,
0.0523489118,
-0.0174744409,
0.0069118561,
-0.0167900585,
0.0110730119,
-0.0654032528,
0.0189965684,
0.0125813568,
0.0480426662,
-0.0310487077,
-0.0252598356,
-0.0347874761,
0.0224502198,
-0.0016511815,
-0.0082578547,
0.1002355665,
0.0235708766,
-0.0105857393,
-0.020867791,
-0.0188202243,
0.0588871464,
-0.021178076,
0.0018103119,
-0.0077590165,
-0.0638269037,
0.0039179134,
-0.026687488,
-0.0182582345,
-0.0294409748,
0.0118430648,
0.0940864384,
0.0296288412,
-0.0291553494,
-0.0000361953,
-0.0241569951,
-0.0030542368,
-0.0806011334,
-0.0089018233,
-0.0472398698,
0.0141261453,
0.0335239023,
0.0239186939,
-0.02505151,
-0.0085892566,
0.008372372,
-0.0229070839,
0.0823575407,
0.0133355716,
0.0192659255,
-0.0011797589,
0.0007925906,
-0.0215354748,
0.0775401294,
0.0333054997,
0.021478273,
0.0653948039,
-0.0102881938,
-0.0197399985,
0.0360689946,
0.0111153973,
-0.0116673568,
-0.0284404848,
-0.0141396187,
0.023662772,
0.0198778976,
0.0011413282,
0.0361522846,
0.0037928575,
-0.0041281227,
0.0859880373,
0.0510277487,
0.0561718941,
0.0479660481,
0.0097156875,
-0.0044527887,
-0.0144250458,
-0.0207611695,
-0.0553488322,
0.0115505196,
0.0187377799,
0.0006249109,
0.0597853065,
0.0635081157,
-0.0104034171,
-0.0371430144,
-0.0358076133,
-0.0003369581,
-0.0296268128,
-0.0011378949,
0.0378558971,
-0.0283041932,
-0.0356630608,
0.0746440589,
0.019606499,
-0.0548464097,
0.0110314656,
-0.0407592766,
0.0015629076,
0.053139843,
0.0587516204,
-0.0019271525,
-0.0023920906,
0.0111869099,
-0.0148326373,
-0.0221609343,
0.034257628,
-0.0064189029,
0.0137733305,
-0.0328913964,
-0.0282008965,
0.0306263361,
0.0274839755,
0.0028393143,
0.0458628573,
-0.0059762471,
0.0220160335,
-0.0321749076,
-0.0388071798,
0.0239078533,
-0.0613532625,
-0.0049971398,
0.0281050354,
-0.022046458,
0.0379921608,
0.0096878931,
-0.0119992346,
0.0150028113,
0.0211314894,
-0.0324612185,
-0.0300554037,
0.0117900064,
-0.021809902,
-0.0276039615,
0.0337010548,
0.0179970544,
0.0637962446,
0.0720196143,
-0.0216963217,
-0.0439916216,
0.0640200675,
-0.0166938864,
0.046185907,
-0.023844067,
0.0287272278,
-0.0334291868,
0.0138638541,
-0.0312820598,
0.0240513142,
-0.0215155557,
0.0552885421,
-0.0025397411,
0.0247266386,
-0.0078414893,
-0.0031244711,
-0.0219323877,
0.0356499292,
0.0093720974,
0.0178615004,
0.022257397,
-0.030859774,
-0.0337405168,
-0.0213451032,
-0.0658194572,
0.0212771054,
-0.0359221026,
0.0597950742,
0.0221784506,
0.0275023431,
0.0077472776,
-0.0178542919,
0.0013491749,
0.0011407356,
-0.0010557814,
0.0437884592,
0.0197969042,
0.0194517318,
-0.0081874589,
-0.0473060459,
-0.0585749969,
0.0018803449,
0.0672396272,
-0.0009508725,
0.0032996442,
-0.0493197665,
0.0384491719,
-0.0260830373,
0.0138805546,
-0.019742975,
-0.0085961223,
-0.021467464,
-0.0023251448,
0.0166186318,
0.0355691239,
-0.0303380881,
-0.0194557905,
0.0547354221,
-0.0027884068,
-0.0803963691,
-0.0080191912,
-0.0147939445,
-0.0262101516,
-0.0171018802,
-0.017694328,
-0.0294936951,
0.0680908561,
-0.0083748763,
-0.0287094284,
-0.0507586822,
-0.0132906483,
-0.0476209149,
-0.005959026,
-0.0234415885,
-0.0107847722,
-0.0272645205,
0.03584373,
-0.006733384,
-0.0877484381,
0.0375750102,
-0.0287371278,
0.0068712616,
-0.0167901535,
-0.0283906255,
-0.0679039732,
0.0757010728,
0.0232131835,
-0.0190160852,
-0.0263697263,
-0.0390663333,
-0.0151244104,
0.0368141271,
0.018456893,
-0.0468314067,
0.0535793602,
-0.0402251966,
0.0122365486,
0.0024978837,
-0.0484336317,
-0.009986137,
-0.0189503673,
-0.045476824,
0.03851353,
0.0304119103,
-0.0442804731,
-0.0095435167,
0.0169610959,
-0.0201337226,
0.0112214433,
-0.0222093966,
-0.0245219935,
0.0025924919,
0.0301601514,
0.0304898731,
0.0077066189,
0.0441998877,
-0.0411423333,
0.0097760446,
0.0416485183,
0.0927316695,
-0.0038318958,
-0.0545269214,
-0.0395543166,
0.0383385383,
-0.0256864987,
-0.0511038229,
0.0344884135,
0.0208307113,
-0.0565177761,
0.0114119016,
0.1148801818,
0.0090139406,
-0.052048862,
0.0128259016,
0.0162331313,
0.0526602492,
0.0401538275,
0.0189150926,
-0.0266152993,
-0.0220751259,
0.0250991322,
0.0210115816,
0.038012322,
-0.0419631898,
-0.008408824,
-0.1195984781,
0.0217204858,
-0.0157337487,
0.0241409987,
0.0187231824,
-0.1176285297,
0.0180127267,
-0.0693475828,
0.0170069113,
0.0007921696,
-0.0346092619,
0.003794993,
0.0234557204,
-0.0667141974,
-0.0655022338,
0.0301955454,
-0.0517236143,
0.0619244725,
0.0553393513,
0.0029786159,
-0.0000651622,
-0.0206672233,
0.0671956688,
-0.0179167707,
0.0379752144,
-0.0450391881,
0.074191086,
-0.0141748916,
0.0129358638,
-0.0082315123,
-0.0240246654,
-0.0520931743,
0.0093500018,
-0.0143260462,
0.0805908442,
0.0110642519,
-0.0397721827,
-0.0018175999,
-0.0186271314,
-0.0101012662,
0.0677414685,
0.0254420806,
-0.0175698474,
-0.045127444,
0.003943013,
-0.0098101785,
-0.0205766205,
-0.0500645116,
-0.0267535858,
0.0149888545,
0.0129048023,
-0.0587448291,
-0.0175522082,
0.0185138248,
0.0191762988,
0.0042979056,
0.0525707677,
-0.0167985782,
0.008387086,
-0.0390603803,
0.0307558756,
-0.0045370855,
0.0443902537,
-0.0484716743,
0.0428795032,
0.0522685014,
0.0151697295,
-0.0032872919,
-0.0192559287,
-0.135422796,
-0.0694205761,
-0.0393741839,
0.0553271808,
0.0211644229,
0.0187442582,
0.0000606177,
-0.1097170189,
0.0321869627,
0.0131542739,
-0.0541643947,
0.005555253,
0.0147957839,
-0.019447241,
-0.0032662386,
0.0585549399,
-0.0129036941,
-0.0060773981,
0.0040382179,
0.0416257493,
-0.0044149314,
-0.0630046874,
-0.0238716416,
0.0228514876,
0.0527686812,
-0.0338038355,
-0.0194029864,
-0.026504742,
0.0153934173,
-0.010839466,
0.0042057307,
-0.0465381928,
0.0227784608,
0.0053169946,
-0.0013828308,
-0.0268068723,
0.008422045,
0.0090633528,
0.0065449844,
-0.0730349049,
0.0326943807,
-0.0218104273,
-0.0176733509,
0.0286618974,
0.028261058,
-0.0086194305,
-0.024448989,
0.0131694386,
0.0420456789,
-0.0285533927,
0.0243421625,
-0.0143600153,
0.0292671118,
-0.0262030493,
0.0363606475,
-0.0853285417,
-0.0705511793,
-0.0307665542,
0.0029567247,
0.0259725098,
-0.0223096199,
0.0879386067,
-0.0161368791,
-0.0017021892,
-0.0464024879,
0.0121642593,
-0.0162156988,
-0.0026214402,
0.0292782784,
0.0114189815,
-0.0344204344,
0.013948082,
0.098968707,
-0.0101509932,
0.0099432329,
-0.0030781981,
-0.0051268861,
-0.0092515238,
-0.0402698033,
0.0002885231,
0.0265378188,
-0.0382286347,
-0.0020807073,
-0.0560616925,
-0.081451647,
-0.0166158974,
-0.0087311091,
0.0090437718,
-0.038926743,
0.018337341,
0.0679943785,
0.0138846468,
0.0002992185,
-0.0535525344,
-0.0205934718,
0.0028155947,
-0.0024282292,
-0.0167009719,
-6.063131903e-33,
0.0090865651,
-0.0052844291,
0.0016150356,
0.0135825276,
0.0040029525,
0.0447163396,
-0.0083091725,
0.0172029864,
-0.0148341032,
-0.0086893514,
-0.0470608622,
0.0223835446,
0.0097384639,
0.0239998903,
0.0348843485,
-0.0077570933,
0.0560553931,
-0.0272302739,
-0.0177492145,
0.0128234411,
0.0103083458,
0.0457887724,
0.0424471572,
-0.0568720289,
0.0214735344,
0.0065626027,
-0.0169772059,
0.0185385346,
-0.0002350843,
0.0636103749,
-0.0173109397,
0.0359662138,
0.0486128144,
-0.0904890895,
-0.0438784584,
-0.0324853919,
-0.0286710728,
0.0084102424,
0.0177505948,
-0.0087901503,
-0.0455691107,
0.0272324439,
0.0392989255,
0.0151917189,
-0.0433588922,
-0.0657592714,
0.026688952,
-0.0095804362,
-0.0325555131,
0.0012853139,
-0.0036699257,
0.0335437655,
0.0168822315,
0.0297686197,
0.0604098625,
0.0120934006,
-0.0047659301,
0.0149793522,
-0.0436478332,
0.0037281571,
-0.0264321193,
0.0818897635,
0.1045157835,
0.0349509828,
-0.0143028088,
0.0629320145,
0.0304543637,
0.0165690687,
-0.0155015551,
-0.0533143058,
0.0344531499,
0.0791517273,
0.0535995103,
0.0363807082,
0.0270679146,
0.0258012582,
-0.0491844341,
0.0262713004,
0.0352207646,
0.0288407505,
0.0135564366,
0.0293986537,
-0.0315516964,
-0.0331280045,
-0.04272696,
0.0264503751,
-0.0336668305,
-0.0375931859,
0.0174205713,
0.0165156107,
-0.0130768381,
0.0012908954,
0.0257702451,
-0.0773274153,
-0.0449776128,
0.0143225733,
0.0061074095,
0.0055404399,
0.0058860518,
0.0316063762,
-0.0767381266,
-0.0082645901,
-0.0487090759,
-0.0028101255,
0.0018287119,
-0.0301858075,
-0.0073840674,
0.0178381931,
-0.0905146226,
-0.0243405402,
-0.046185445,
-0.0204083882,
0.0358191989,
0.0356560647,
0.0420518965,
-0.0172588918,
-0.0269735642,
0.043720182,
0.0288461056,
0.0265950095,
-0.0151779409,
0.0010516205,
0.0262578204,
-0.0043339101,
-0.031135289,
-0.0214444399,
-0.0524196588,
0.0259655286,
0.0540307052,
0.0030371412,
-0.0629993454,
-0.0334577449,
2.504e-7,
0.078674525,
0.055044502,
-0.020438984,
0.0252215322,
0.0155569585,
0.0282957703,
-0.0335625075,
0.0267562047,
0.0146423047,
0.0120536126,
-0.0054372456,
0.0015368208,
0.0789931267,
0.0121227754,
-0.0597500317,
-0.029393889,
-0.0734402835,
0.0156641584,
-0.0371801555,
-0.0267711002,
-0.0388957076,
0.1071417555,
0.0218258612,
-0.0241614804,
-0.0411040299,
-0.0161218792,
0.045288384,
-0.0620155521,
-0.0206481833,
0.0277685262,
0.0197470132,
-0.0104333125,
-0.0095940651,
0.0313965231,
-0.0400000252,
0.0079906704,
0.0006697945,
0.0566850901,
0.0163107533,
0.0023440185,
0.0195465777,
-0.0184045732,
-0.0006973592,
-0.0586578399,
0.0602055825,
0.0028535423,
-0.0281881411,
-0.0052701258,
0.0043462859,
-0.0147286039,
0.0344369262,
0.0004019515,
0.0097459266,
0.0505315624,
0.0000825887,
-0.0193193387,
-0.0412284993,
-0.0739887804,
-0.0555850342,
-0.0108657032,
-0.0547516532,
-0.0751883909,
-0.0517031513,
-0.0226989631,
0.0124715352,
-0.0552466959,
0.0115273921,
2.582881365e-34,
0.0306156185,
0.0218918938,
0.0299549811,
0.0556837991,
0.0230761971,
-0.0237547401,
-0.0109263035,
0.0121196965,
0.0166291948,
-0.0870914534,
-0.0005864169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01291v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01291v1 | Lightweight Zero-shot Text-to-Speech with Mixture of Adapters | 2024-07-01T13:45:31 | 2024-07-01T13:45:31 | Kenichi Fujita, Takanori Ashihara, Marc Delcroix, Yusuke Ijima | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | The advancements in zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) methods, based on
large-scale models, have demonstrated high fidelity in reproducing speaker
characteristics. However, these models are too large for practical daily use.
We propose a lightweight zero-shot TTS method using a mixture of adapters
(MoA). Our proposed method incorporates MoA modules into the decoder and the
variance adapter of a non-autoregressive TTS model. These modules enhance the
ability to adapt a wide variety of speakers in a zero-shot manner by selecting
appropriate adapters associated with speaker characteristics on the basis of
speaker embeddings. Our method achieves high-quality speech synthesis with
minimal additional parameters. Through objective and subjective evaluations, we
confirmed that our method achieves better performance than the baseline with
less than 40\% of parameters at 1.9 times faster inference speed. Audio samples
are available on our demo page
(https://ntt-hilab-gensp.github.io/is2024lightweightTTS/). | Lightweight Zero-shot Text-to-Speech with Mixture of Adapters: The advancements in zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) methods, based on
large-scale models, have demonstrated high fidelity in reproducing speaker
characteristics. However, these models are too large for practical daily use.
We propose a lightweight zero-shot TTS method using a mixture of adapters
(MoA). Our proposed method incorporates MoA modules into the decoder and the
variance adapter of a non-autoregressive TTS model. These modules enhance the
ability to adapt a wide variety of speakers in a zero-shot manner by selecting
appropriate adapters associated with speaker characteristics on the basis of
speaker embeddings. Our method achieves high-quality speech synthesis with
minimal additional parameters. Through objective and subjective evaluations, we
confirmed that our method achieves better performance than the baseline with
less than 40\% of parameters at 1.9 times faster inference speed. Audio samples
are available on our demo page
(https://ntt-hilab-gensp.github.io/is2024lightweightTTS/). | [
-0.0518837124,
0.0268138275,
0.0334852487,
0.0042270971,
0.0201159939,
-0.0141592249,
0.0661305562,
-0.0040190434,
-0.0330619141,
-0.017119702,
-0.0196133107,
-0.0063768132,
0.0447651036,
0.013553042,
0.0285904296,
-0.0740428492,
-0.0114110401,
-0.0338580385,
-0.0363524854,
-0.0244874042,
0.0129595306,
0.0000201902,
-0.0568755083,
0.0329220854,
-0.0285144988,
-0.004291188,
-0.0366291776,
0.0050510615,
0.0272497274,
0.0266990494,
-0.0591700822,
0.0174693689,
0.0427161008,
0.0492889434,
0.0000021455,
0.0160943456,
-0.0041218973,
0.0171368606,
-0.063273333,
-0.0053627593,
0.022018861,
0.0161518939,
-0.0422108099,
0.0311882924,
0.0011333757,
-0.0446537286,
0.0717955083,
0.0172551982,
0.0196793918,
0.0494249277,
-0.0019033926,
-0.0487409234,
0.0160798598,
0.0185665581,
0.0532467663,
0.0142015144,
-0.0336751193,
-0.0304633565,
0.039164234,
0.002124225,
-0.0411486886,
0.0362889171,
0.0032766957,
-0.0041799252,
0.0591925606,
0.0045927376,
-0.0417685099,
-0.0377054475,
-0.011357232,
0.0974043012,
0.0039657401,
-0.0182262827,
0.0246860869,
0.013769595,
-0.0484788232,
-0.0206595212,
-0.0019209341,
-0.0084197987,
0.0278274212,
-0.0104786595,
-0.0693528652,
0.0417299643,
0.0070532844,
-0.0601407997,
-0.0651802495,
-0.0152821569,
0.0081489421,
-0.034568537,
-0.0066432767,
-0.0163648464,
0.0172254816,
-0.0171121955,
0.0047335448,
0.0157954916,
-0.0052627432,
-0.0301789977,
-0.0396782756,
-0.0667780861,
-0.0603667051,
-0.0099043828,
0.0660967007,
0.0895404816,
0.0220602285,
-0.0263112765,
-0.027279228,
0.0090861311,
0.0003275239,
-0.0598887503,
-0.0428496078,
-0.0427306369,
-0.0453134738,
0.0204690062,
-0.0300398096,
0.0408584103,
-0.0458069742,
-0.025148211,
-0.0402170233,
0.0287077278,
-0.0526225045,
-0.0017169167,
0.0039560846,
0.0444722958,
-0.0308290888,
-0.0292772539,
0.0168784298,
0.0785888582,
0.0183902308,
0.0135718705,
-0.0154519165,
-0.0661574304,
-0.0204118434,
0.0391118191,
0.0559624843,
0.0162321758,
-0.0129568381,
0.0541176386,
-0.0198744889,
-0.0452931486,
0.0183994714,
-0.0216322597,
-0.0054113409,
-0.026471151,
-0.0071685519,
-0.0525155552,
0.0222888682,
0.0012750376,
0.0018696159,
0.0025058014,
-0.0058641639,
-0.008113116,
-0.0081495214,
0.0406933278,
0.0105209826,
0.0148266954,
0.013961792,
-0.0158849079,
0.0022664485,
0.0407116227,
0.0413218848,
-0.024574751,
-0.0488967299,
-0.0285203271,
0.0126449708,
0.0293734986,
0.0245548487,
0.0196305998,
-0.0162001662,
-0.0218470152,
-0.0158979278,
0.0085904291,
0.0619954765,
0.0019965158,
-0.0285944268,
0.0009515617,
0.0699432045,
0.0154970326,
0.0917112902,
-0.0009209383,
0.0730067194,
0.0168109629,
0.0065238336,
-0.0297769178,
0.0101162316,
0.036727801,
-0.035417553,
0.0018722708,
0.0534210689,
0.0466981754,
-0.0610974096,
0.0194727499,
0.0239631888,
-0.0311717428,
-0.0100783529,
-0.0149116218,
0.0020557549,
0.0163811836,
-0.0536817089,
0.035908483,
-0.0131212715,
-0.0733640715,
0.0120278858,
-0.015548856,
0.0104649188,
0.0544456504,
-0.0066636,
0.0245108306,
-0.0083625885,
-0.0519497395,
-0.0052086194,
0.0323588103,
-0.0489307493,
0.0152232489,
0.0577971488,
-0.0561196208,
-0.0178696867,
0.0395735838,
0.0131410537,
0.0598126054,
-0.0369724035,
0.0493270084,
0.0452488214,
-0.011250589,
0.0712506622,
-0.0388292633,
-0.0588153787,
-0.0440502465,
0.0586957112,
0.0090819644,
0.0264373608,
0.0330394842,
-0.0280485153,
0.001060236,
-0.0090856003,
-0.0297537055,
0.0136144385,
0.0489973314,
-0.0523327738,
-0.0290539805,
0.0290408097,
-0.0534984767,
0.0352734923,
0.0005346098,
0.0349380225,
-0.095730111,
0.0804274902,
0.0057550026,
0.0470155142,
0.0005028584,
-0.000754931,
0.0318372175,
0.0247711595,
0.0682433695,
-0.0245527048,
0.0342571214,
-0.0148406485,
0.068680793,
0.0267715715,
-0.015525056,
-0.0558818839,
-0.01233197,
-0.0373474024,
0.0062537813,
0.0440097637,
-0.0661854073,
-0.0184686091,
0.0090110591,
-0.0162737034,
-0.0914567858,
-0.0013963458,
-0.0064893924,
-0.0199580994,
-0.0218644198,
0.0378581099,
0.0030244973,
0.0250543598,
-0.0116292061,
-0.007441605,
-0.0034039121,
-0.0199074019,
-0.0456563197,
-0.0337012149,
-0.0118308803,
-0.0005595686,
0.0233709961,
0.0025505691,
0.0152760511,
-0.04965242,
0.0180304199,
0.0216202121,
-0.014426738,
0.0212512128,
-0.0039044963,
0.0230588242,
-0.0279012118,
0.001692915,
0.0314031839,
0.0709487945,
0.001856453,
-0.0027315009,
-0.036553964,
-0.0343112275,
-0.0173866358,
-0.0384096391,
-0.0007988585,
0.0366686694,
0.0423947908,
0.0133311534,
-0.0034122774,
-0.0289912131,
0.0225836132,
0.0212122742,
0.0018265373,
-0.0869576111,
0.030225005,
0.0096220365,
-0.0287181567,
0.0345864818,
0.0166745726,
-0.0288474858,
-0.0233199466,
-0.0022108706,
-0.0188974049,
-0.0054802722,
-0.0741926581,
-0.0645384043,
-0.0114892973,
-0.0265301242,
-0.0145001598,
-0.0669705123,
0.0051581012,
0.0166091956,
0.0053174612,
0.0366859622,
0.0015734814,
0.0048548658,
0.0247380249,
-0.057015311,
0.0363148376,
0.0229049232,
0.0142378779,
-0.0471999682,
0.01664,
0.0093208048,
-0.0263564419,
-0.0053236256,
0.0405051112,
-0.0254924279,
-0.0320146009,
-0.0374973901,
0.0467612632,
0.0570723638,
0.0224896483,
-0.0106257228,
0.0164956525,
-0.0448079258,
0.0505060889,
0.0256140511,
0.0310312621,
-0.0369402654,
-0.0063114921,
0.0353772342,
-0.0276298206,
0.0430445373,
0.0440165624,
-0.0690242425,
-0.0172654931,
0.0026645053,
0.0516665801,
-0.0174252279,
0.0343758538,
0.0605616905,
0.0084814038,
0.0460374467,
0.1026887894,
-0.0256426837,
-0.0089649335,
-0.0077303625,
-0.0076059271,
0.0620311089,
-0.0169729162,
0.0080748713,
-0.0829993412,
-0.0327834375,
0.0444690883,
0.0432475358,
-0.0087156035,
-0.0037594596,
-0.0295538139,
-0.0918851793,
0.044628039,
0.0577465147,
-0.0291310046,
-0.0160809271,
-0.019920148,
-0.0366468169,
-0.0212649908,
0.0333020128,
0.036876034,
-0.0237749126,
-0.0250129793,
0.0319266766,
-0.0562949814,
-0.0559275784,
-0.013280347,
-0.0279566813,
0.1158384755,
0.0137427887,
0.0129119381,
0.0033868987,
0.0092344098,
-0.0556195304,
-0.0460804962,
-0.0144398287,
0.0047315531,
0.0056993752,
0.0027368022,
0.003623757,
0.0084627708,
0.0549492985,
0.0020184938,
0.0335329771,
-0.0325295776,
0.0653402209,
0.0045229988,
0.0075256368,
-0.0243186075,
0.0230831485,
0.0114798816,
0.0434485599,
0.0165545717,
-0.0563251823,
-0.0037298151,
-0.0133693311,
0.0174437761,
-0.0561418608,
-0.0199310482,
-0.0090289051,
0.0112416353,
-0.0894753635,
-0.0053957463,
-0.0004608285,
0.0139793744,
0.0696334913,
-0.0106108952,
-0.0135001699,
-0.0268521737,
-0.0166070201,
-0.0027163296,
-0.0300582889,
-0.05157144,
0.0261336155,
-0.0272545554,
0.011445649,
0.0187820308,
-0.0298214089,
0.0126913227,
-0.006881848,
-0.052176103,
-0.0499454513,
-0.0341918916,
0.0331452526,
0.0165846851,
0.0512361005,
-0.0045552575,
-0.0351795666,
0.1247896403,
0.0265798271,
0.0158490855,
0.0669788718,
0.0781045109,
0.024174694,
0.0120861148,
0.0209879484,
-0.028279623,
0.0353618227,
-0.0145137599,
-0.0026725659,
-0.0181190968,
-0.0323385336,
-0.0101836361,
-0.0067756148,
-0.0370744877,
0.0106444228,
0.0540779941,
0.0055165398,
0.0164073948,
-0.0536808595,
0.0419443473,
-0.0365374275,
-0.0449722558,
0.0352709107,
0.0355754495,
-0.0021810182,
-0.0019659821,
-0.0522975251,
0.0675469786,
0.0404906683,
0.0504930317,
0.0273614936,
-0.0483637601,
0.0106074587,
-0.0129713435,
-0.0045577744,
0.00008131,
0.0071669971,
0.0070242584,
-0.0345827714,
-0.0166900121,
-0.0179627072,
0.0142862387,
-0.0187348779,
0.0261745714,
-0.000337214,
0.0286442153,
-0.0140100652,
0.022407271,
0.0221555978,
0.0244283248,
0.0854337588,
0.0074868528,
0.055314742,
-0.0291573666,
0.0363336615,
-0.0506483205,
0.0268137176,
-0.0043389043,
-0.0120205395,
0.0027897516,
0.0016672682,
0.0252322592,
-0.0083411792,
0.0018991625,
-0.0276156887,
0.0736106485,
-0.004983814,
0.0051552346,
-0.0259233266,
-0.0028270066,
-0.007279254,
-0.0307570957,
-0.0387813672,
-0.0301139299,
0.0666702688,
-0.0553992167,
-0.0061442619,
-0.0487714373,
0.01130905,
-0.0845643654,
-0.0228024814,
0.0324513167,
0.0073407535,
-0.0519000031,
0.0057624215,
-0.04228938,
0.0235381294,
-6.485261843e-33,
-0.0407040156,
0.0148555422,
0.0209663678,
-0.0424019434,
-0.0300706457,
-0.0078692567,
-0.0378439352,
0.0222959258,
-0.0530349649,
-0.0318511091,
-0.0338900313,
-0.0162051208,
0.014622638,
0.0475863405,
-0.0260690991,
0.0397049189,
0.071291782,
-0.0172250196,
0.0013088982,
0.0117822466,
0.0349167064,
0.0259880666,
-0.0393413194,
-0.0015059749,
-0.0692487359,
-0.0090581151,
0.0153469052,
-0.060503345,
0.0493705794,
0.0079744989,
0.0113328164,
0.0676452368,
-0.0164010432,
0.0070503568,
-0.0018347326,
0.0029997437,
-0.0359596014,
0.0108043822,
-0.0118017094,
0.0154078957,
0.0271623693,
-0.0270199589,
0.0183639713,
0.030065842,
-0.0602013692,
-0.0688277483,
0.0043280232,
-0.0073936889,
-0.0306775253,
-0.0024609314,
-0.0492378175,
0.0319176018,
-0.0248198137,
-0.0370108113,
0.0631837398,
0.0812485367,
-0.0271896794,
-0.0086681005,
-0.0767661482,
0.037851572,
0.021157803,
0.0154119655,
0.0329539068,
0.0287338477,
0.0156121338,
-0.0039128647,
0.0333597027,
-0.0740582943,
-0.0443344861,
0.0040088296,
0.0430524498,
0.0201661289,
0.018218156,
0.0408108421,
0.0360568762,
-0.0507370792,
0.0132798506,
0.0225425716,
0.0240860879,
0.0216154922,
0.0219824482,
0.0385537334,
-0.0057299342,
0.0123473667,
-0.042624373,
-0.0613755099,
-0.0290186182,
-0.0632101074,
0.035431888,
-0.0021513165,
-0.0277019832,
-0.0487393104,
0.0863686725,
-0.0366288982,
0.0255429093,
0.0045225094,
-0.0353456065,
0.0409994163,
0.0021595545,
0.0183923431,
-0.052823741,
-0.0369551815,
0.1082868502,
0.0448588394,
0.006603017,
-0.005386583,
-0.0288854297,
0.0789866447,
-0.0517558753,
-0.0330886208,
0.0070218239,
0.0168218333,
0.0000641258,
0.0409192331,
0.0128709814,
-0.0058319066,
0.0045857034,
0.0026296892,
-0.0316047594,
-0.0045356411,
0.033553645,
0.0000068022,
0.0262018424,
-0.0119601861,
-0.054117348,
0.0553819314,
-0.0033322126,
0.0009680572,
0.0583923012,
-0.0266079307,
-0.0094419559,
0.0028867412,
2.984e-7,
-0.0639170408,
0.0035751446,
0.001114731,
-0.0686694384,
0.0375324488,
0.0411362164,
0.0117202345,
0.0378329791,
-0.0107686995,
0.0072837584,
-0.0206270646,
0.0057212063,
0.0869689211,
-0.0009305839,
-0.0770564601,
-0.0032766615,
-0.0240472965,
0.0139016546,
-0.0271138102,
-0.0049954252,
0.0195376072,
0.0748611838,
-0.0127506517,
-0.011572211,
0.060506124,
0.0057986514,
0.0586483888,
0.0224562772,
-0.0160398632,
-0.0510291792,
0.0149222398,
-0.0194635801,
-0.0235752054,
-0.021000471,
-0.0187885053,
0.0438097492,
-0.0166258365,
0.0454027727,
-0.0247933064,
-0.0694746152,
-0.0005541193,
0.0176029392,
-0.0645442307,
0.0454190038,
0.0745585337,
-0.0035456433,
-0.0254880302,
-0.0046355394,
-0.0801510215,
0.0528669469,
-0.0343325473,
-0.023620259,
-0.0072933719,
-0.0042427965,
0.0322555602,
-0.0095567871,
-0.0185689908,
0.0163684022,
0.0097807366,
-0.0017826023,
-0.0406336002,
-0.0500509031,
-0.0275263488,
-0.0217321143,
0.0801110119,
-0.0110123567,
-0.029079292,
2.30623956e-34,
0.0049763243,
-0.0298739634,
0.0612990335,
0.0003841006,
-0.0279284045,
-0.0256697554,
0.00157578,
0.0041173398,
0.0285894442,
-0.0682889968,
-0.054364901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01284v1 | We-Math: Does Your Large Multimodal Model Achieve Human-like Mathematical Reasoning? | 2024-07-01T13:39:08 | 2024-07-01T13:39:08 | Runqi Qiao, Qiuna Tan, Guanting Dong, Minhui Wu, Chong Sun, Xiaoshuai Song, Zhuoma GongQue, Shanglin Lei, Zhe Wei, Miaoxuan Zhang, Runfeng Qiao, Yifan Zhang, Xiao Zong, Yida Xu, Muxi Diao, Zhimin Bao, Chen Li, Honggang Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SC | Visual mathematical reasoning, as a fundamental visual reasoning ability, has
received widespread attention from the Large Multimodal Models (LMMs)
community. Existing benchmarks, such as MathVista and MathVerse, focus more on
the result-oriented performance but neglect the underlying principles in
knowledge acquisition and generalization. Inspired by human-like mathematical
reasoning, we introduce WE-MATH, the first benchmark specifically designed to
explore the problem-solving principles beyond end-to-end performance. We
meticulously collect and categorize 6.5K visual math problems, spanning 67
hierarchical knowledge concepts and five layers of knowledge granularity. We
decompose composite problems into sub-problems according to the required
knowledge concepts and introduce a novel four-dimensional metric, namely
Insufficient Knowledge (IK), Inadequate Generalization (IG), Complete Mastery
(CM), and Rote Memorization (RM), to hierarchically assess inherent issues in
LMMs' reasoning process. With WE-MATH, we conduct a thorough evaluation of
existing LMMs in visual mathematical reasoning and reveal a negative
correlation between solving steps and problem-specific performance. We confirm
the IK issue of LMMs can be effectively improved via knowledge augmentation
strategies. More notably, the primary challenge of GPT-4o has significantly
transitioned from IK to IG, establishing it as the first LMM advancing towards
the knowledge generalization stage. In contrast, other LMMs exhibit a marked
inclination towards Rote Memorization - they correctly solve composite problems
involving multiple knowledge concepts yet fail to answer sub-problems. We
anticipate that WE-MATH will open new pathways for advancements in visual
mathematical reasoning for LMMs. The WE-MATH data and evaluation code are
available at https://github.com/We-Math/We-Math. | We-Math: Does Your Large Multimodal Model Achieve Human-like Mathematical Reasoning?: Visual mathematical reasoning, as a fundamental visual reasoning ability, has
received widespread attention from the Large Multimodal Models (LMMs)
community. Existing benchmarks, such as MathVista and MathVerse, focus more on
the result-oriented performance but neglect the underlying principles in
knowledge acquisition and generalization. Inspired by human-like mathematical
reasoning, we introduce WE-MATH, the first benchmark specifically designed to
explore the problem-solving principles beyond end-to-end performance. We
meticulously collect and categorize 6.5K visual math problems, spanning 67
hierarchical knowledge concepts and five layers of knowledge granularity. We
decompose composite problems into sub-problems according to the required
knowledge concepts and introduce a novel four-dimensional metric, namely
Insufficient Knowledge (IK), Inadequate Generalization (IG), Complete Mastery
(CM), and Rote Memorization (RM), to hierarchically assess inherent issues in
LMMs' reasoning process. With WE-MATH, we conduct a thorough evaluation of
existing LMMs in visual mathematical reasoning and reveal a negative
correlation between solving steps and problem-specific performance. We confirm
the IK issue of LMMs can be effectively improved via knowledge augmentation
strategies. More notably, the primary challenge of GPT-4o has significantly
transitioned from IK to IG, establishing it as the first LMM advancing towards
the knowledge generalization stage. In contrast, other LMMs exhibit a marked
inclination towards Rote Memorization - they correctly solve composite problems
involving multiple knowledge concepts yet fail to answer sub-problems. We
anticipate that WE-MATH will open new pathways for advancements in visual
mathematical reasoning for LMMs. The WE-MATH data and evaluation code are
available at https://github.com/We-Math/We-Math. | [
-0.0448343605,
0.0869172066,
-0.022621775,
0.0502950996,
-0.037659917,
0.0190387722,
0.0279120728,
0.0243938211,
-0.0360871032,
-0.0089442506,
-0.0449690595,
0.0133529035,
0.0015566397,
0.0108272377,
0.0489213355,
-0.0986702666,
-0.0022309066,
-0.029734455,
-0.033959046,
-0.0191256553,
-0.018361792,
-0.033664085,
-0.0592337437,
-0.0100660985,
-0.0760186687,
-0.0667976961,
0.0000308778,
-0.0397318527,
0.0351453014,
-0.035660658,
-0.0176996123,
0.0316396132,
0.0439368747,
0.0223169941,
0.0000023709,
-0.008481524,
0.0096745854,
0.0017881922,
-0.0044620531,
0.0216003507,
-0.0331486948,
-0.0438421406,
0.0368961096,
-0.0190841425,
-0.0644963533,
0.0132551091,
0.0144885993,
0.0085712587,
0.0518997088,
0.0073521142,
-0.0071127713,
-0.0051217042,
0.0490084179,
0.0064655775,
0.0774699077,
-0.0657423586,
-0.0263389535,
0.0856911018,
0.0251518246,
-0.0116434153,
-0.0885266811,
0.0522629358,
0.0909989774,
0.0167507641,
0.0083615873,
0.0120543186,
0.01145049,
0.0082464125,
-0.0077261217,
0.0672233775,
-0.0108598424,
0.0209479164,
-0.0209079273,
0.0176612437,
0.0233453773,
0.0394140035,
-0.1047552004,
0.03783511,
-0.0488501601,
-0.0382860005,
-0.0966919884,
-0.0028153665,
-0.0025849582,
0.0037828421,
-0.0183645524,
0.034924984,
0.025308691,
0.0270913877,
0.0109563963,
-0.0029304617,
-0.0774078146,
-0.0130321058,
0.0291585028,
0.0355151035,
0.0027434051,
-0.0008793268,
0.0005687248,
-0.0404207818,
-0.0347631946,
-0.0170857813,
0.0695139617,
0.0717748553,
-0.0151548414,
0.0182044338,
-0.0425545648,
0.073906444,
-0.045163516,
0.0403033532,
-0.0103121577,
0.0234238934,
-0.045426622,
-0.0051298821,
-0.0117537724,
0.0051905736,
0.0213055816,
-0.0174825788,
-0.0411824398,
0.0160951056,
-0.0271515921,
0.0360785872,
-0.0217960179,
0.0207073912,
0.0227384456,
-0.0231804699,
-0.06563586,
0.0319952369,
-0.065894559,
0.031003112,
-0.0153274396,
0.0015079172,
-0.0093788989,
0.0143695436,
-0.0203092936,
-0.0336623825,
0.026837701,
0.0761538446,
-0.0187432989,
0.0131767197,
-0.0150648141,
-0.0277151614,
0.0287080687,
-0.0803665668,
0.0748118982,
-0.0376976728,
0.0343402363,
-0.0054527977,
-0.0028324265,
0.0011660235,
0.0122116096,
0.0172837339,
0.0264968853,
0.0757720917,
0.0176959559,
-0.0223023109,
0.0151707735,
0.0291372947,
-0.0831380188,
0.032370504,
0.0572561473,
0.0117053995,
0.0165441204,
-0.0333860293,
0.0180067439,
0.0388415419,
0.0269590449,
-0.0007481924,
0.0034267914,
0.0040903105,
0.0054933066,
0.0554743968,
0.0110589163,
0.0324176438,
-0.0553405844,
-0.046519991,
0.0508696362,
0.0249441974,
-0.0163231473,
0.0006461384,
0.0150508909,
-0.0096120005,
0.0531414375,
0.0086533641,
-0.0791020915,
0.0955942124,
-0.0257421937,
-0.0127115389,
0.0135421008,
-0.0038685442,
-0.0234973375,
-0.0414493382,
-0.0087507861,
0.0305585712,
-0.0129453139,
0.0112569621,
0.0607881509,
0.0067550754,
0.0232873056,
-0.0014374478,
-0.0116921952,
-0.0157954581,
0.0001990466,
-0.0119158104,
0.0337831229,
-0.0286509618,
0.0568778366,
-0.0298394002,
-0.0419877619,
-0.0072333366,
0.0176445898,
-0.0121771116,
0.0063833026,
0.0182019528,
-0.0002311253,
-0.028749669,
-0.0196393486,
-0.0344737247,
0.0006965847,
0.0134405093,
0.0306350663,
-0.0211906936,
-0.0111718299,
-0.0744470805,
0.0624523051,
-0.0027923915,
0.0017754615,
-0.0179693997,
-0.0358815677,
-0.0087573854,
0.0155350128,
-0.0247612186,
0.0491259396,
0.0061415504,
-0.0045656334,
-0.0232971255,
0.0039452221,
0.0054654749,
-0.0569508374,
-0.0370866619,
0.0310097989,
-0.0911679044,
-0.0375504121,
0.0116468314,
-0.0416514538,
-0.0075332806,
0.0757760927,
-0.0040679914,
-0.0314007923,
0.0135435415,
-0.0337875485,
0.0399367251,
-0.0214923676,
0.0180841982,
0.0583378822,
-0.0277877077,
0.0084282644,
0.0007520515,
-0.0114291171,
0.01970906,
0.0102303708,
0.0301850624,
-0.0107370876,
-0.0242153425,
0.0382139981,
-0.0635501817,
-0.0174677707,
-0.0501589738,
0.0344514623,
-0.0327940919,
0.0085375672,
0.0136065846,
0.0187460408,
0.006842602,
-0.0471920557,
-0.0118874265,
-0.0377400592,
-0.0169996955,
0.023099158,
-0.0225909278,
0.0163525324,
-0.0032832108,
0.0039379308,
0.033545848,
0.0016119442,
-0.0043088775,
-0.0350273624,
0.0601015761,
0.0361112095,
0.0878194198,
0.0129205612,
-0.019408254,
-0.0468821079,
-0.0119956713,
-0.0283310432,
0.0263035707,
0.0554266796,
-0.021597987,
0.0231201276,
0.0580885597,
-0.0084870867,
0.059256006,
-0.0079407627,
-0.0437050276,
-0.032361459,
0.0244147424,
0.0037697651,
-0.0107254554,
0.0087337345,
-0.0149230249,
-0.0330755934,
0.0332070962,
-0.0175546035,
-0.0029227128,
-0.0356351137,
0.040314164,
0.0050487393,
-0.0153670376,
-0.0731744692,
0.0126094529,
0.0127844587,
0.0176829845,
-0.021752039,
-0.0297629647,
0.0285956971,
-0.0107949702,
-0.0140560605,
0.00703341,
0.0450199172,
-0.0134606399,
0.0846462473,
0.0155637516,
0.0003241952,
-0.0478554703,
-0.0026551418,
-0.0440529399,
0.0057441089,
0.0472418256,
0.0082795052,
0.053793449,
-0.0617629439,
-0.0129133947,
-0.0368533544,
-0.0380359069,
-0.026999522,
0.0774773583,
0.0002593902,
0.0317459032,
-0.0275333133,
-0.0495876521,
-0.016509641,
-0.0240441784,
0.0733137429,
-0.0204631276,
-0.0313882008,
-0.0353416726,
-0.0021021923,
0.0063040252,
-0.0080486871,
0.0465327874,
0.002426347,
-0.1088711694,
-0.0090317931,
0.0426919051,
0.0564587899,
-0.0423943214,
-0.0342979096,
0.0488763303,
-0.0251891688,
0.0290750749,
0.0013283918,
-0.0031231614,
0.0344630852,
-0.0571613535,
0.0457367413,
0.035819158,
0.0000562174,
-0.0242308453,
0.003084738,
-0.0478428155,
0.016379565,
0.0299698934,
0.0050177453,
-0.0786121413,
-0.0321340226,
0.0263090339,
0.0017464067,
0.0536245666,
-0.0424001813,
0.0213111211,
-0.0502676368,
0.0337750688,
-0.0000379966,
-0.0566944703,
-0.0338661186,
0.0191451963,
0.013101845,
0.0253783911,
-0.0081973141,
-0.0006316844,
0.0093183275,
0.0356505401,
0.0225414783,
0.0029736143,
-0.0058758142,
0.008399548,
-0.0209491011,
-0.079220593,
-0.0139724789,
-0.025796013,
-0.0142967207,
-0.1099187583,
0.0215790868,
0.0727045536,
0.0058564465,
-0.0058766082,
0.0556030013,
-0.0161749646,
-0.022239957,
-0.0154489921,
0.0391065478,
-0.0087072011,
-0.0428606719,
0.0195431579,
0.0891477913,
-0.0127962204,
0.0118276719,
-0.0289538112,
-0.0008792342,
-0.0672002807,
0.0069627459,
0.0435146019,
-0.0179891475,
-0.0330256335,
-0.0334588438,
0.0313834473,
-0.0670280457,
-0.0132067464,
0.0107265292,
0.0735086203,
0.0174158551,
-0.0388988256,
-0.0138266599,
0.0439721309,
0.065253675,
-0.0138585521,
-0.0685682967,
0.0025979679,
-0.0025717975,
-0.0275126696,
0.0637583286,
-0.0197960287,
0.0301095992,
-0.0247862469,
0.0224035811,
-0.0319982208,
-0.0454259515,
-0.0312987007,
0.0100732399,
-0.0779255629,
0.0104398299,
-0.0425318964,
0.0551140159,
0.0161176827,
-0.0183239412,
0.0440921634,
-0.0112425778,
0.0241357461,
0.0129930666,
-0.0158693865,
0.0227013621,
0.0262746532,
-0.0074997181,
0.0127809132,
-0.0062119793,
-0.0023620361,
-0.0026875348,
0.0044777542,
0.0486047119,
0.0090618487,
0.0562156439,
-0.0041777496,
0.0075063016,
0.0125398627,
0.0101703554,
0.0283918399,
-0.014308176,
0.0034909432,
-0.00397,
0.0089546265,
-0.0579951406,
-0.0056048827,
0.0311574433,
-0.0035437129,
0.0305209085,
-0.0149000268,
0.0712935701,
0.0334629528,
0.018846225,
0.0137988525,
0.0209142808,
-0.0109179718,
0.0131864706,
0.0267665293,
0.02700633,
-0.0071333931,
-0.0412539281,
0.0521747805,
-0.0040364931,
0.0999934897,
0.018137021,
-0.0229547545,
-0.030458428,
-0.0011291363,
-0.0414414667,
-0.0873057544,
0.0425398052,
0.0232576206,
0.063977994,
0.0285100043,
-0.0364792831,
-0.0629146174,
0.0125949224,
0.0135826245,
0.0134907104,
0.0010104136,
-0.0007463921,
0.0591044873,
0.0429851823,
0.0483449921,
-0.0608207919,
0.0381709635,
-0.0395318046,
0.0371069536,
-0.0475815982,
0.0176953096,
-0.0282232221,
-0.0348303355,
0.0498216711,
0.0137450472,
0.022776233,
0.0059526064,
-0.0689058155,
-0.0864159167,
-0.0212396327,
0.0265668109,
-0.0303663332,
0.0070027015,
0.0538541786,
0.0479676053,
-0.0181767419,
-0.0329628326,
0.0374653414,
0.0374593623,
-0.0334049091,
-0.0098692756,
0.014569723,
-6.016933506e-33,
-0.0277686976,
-0.0151876817,
0.0520180874,
0.0044790255,
0.0088835806,
-0.0266569294,
-0.0242930371,
0.0521803498,
-0.0166463088,
0.0145666273,
0.02032624,
-0.025954159,
-0.0112392986,
0.0363642462,
0.0166912321,
0.0102914236,
0.0006739358,
-0.0121212024,
-0.0396802872,
0.0027855176,
-0.0040597934,
0.0069692037,
0.0494344383,
-0.0281988159,
-0.0265131146,
0.0352353789,
-0.0148445386,
0.0176725462,
-0.0701456815,
0.0462683775,
-0.0387707241,
-0.0096561434,
0.0277627539,
-0.0008018761,
-0.0350311846,
-0.0134055046,
-0.051246427,
-0.0336255766,
-0.0030328028,
0.0342488363,
-0.1295011789,
-0.0174445249,
0.0511119589,
-0.0117027126,
-0.0245224554,
-0.0546149202,
0.0270855986,
-0.0146402968,
-0.0011424602,
0.0127272513,
-0.0023344485,
0.0061134244,
-0.0197153054,
-0.0282476358,
0.0128238611,
0.0355221108,
0.0027101014,
0.0289495643,
-0.0523663945,
0.0195830017,
-0.0323515423,
-0.0323470011,
0.068983838,
0.0148856062,
0.0225457083,
0.0414244048,
0.0237138588,
-0.0487514324,
-0.0290504489,
-0.0084633883,
0.0284068082,
0.0826076195,
0.0711418465,
0.0110644959,
0.0444692187,
0.0384392478,
-0.0121858949,
0.008220138,
-0.0773798451,
0.0751320794,
0.0027886,
0.0225126185,
-0.0141167771,
0.0053299516,
-0.0243721716,
0.0037390434,
-0.0598693714,
-0.0069473842,
0.0405357257,
-0.022317633,
0.0360859036,
0.0174005181,
0.0358023681,
-0.0218357723,
-0.0013622564,
-0.0058327806,
0.0076737497,
0.0701247305,
0.0193505324,
0.0130884256,
-0.0325850584,
0.0043048863,
0.0175322611,
-0.0161409304,
0.0278297961,
-0.0034439592,
0.0395468734,
0.025107123,
-0.0045402544,
-0.0320778303,
-0.0462295972,
-0.0324347652,
0.0519372225,
0.0078758914,
0.0370485224,
0.0180517845,
-0.0488077216,
0.0096027171,
-0.0535600483,
-0.0071517578,
-0.0445533805,
-0.0253421124,
-0.0631867647,
0.0172290541,
0.0015501305,
-0.0055765901,
-0.0478628688,
-0.0730049461,
0.0016875261,
-0.0744060054,
0.0069438065,
0.0220327694,
2.916e-7,
0.0308411755,
0.0381658822,
0.0020509949,
-0.0113917775,
0.0433976166,
0.0507186875,
-0.0468091369,
-0.0309978891,
-0.0170584824,
-0.0459477082,
-0.0087495502,
0.0890142545,
0.0353814885,
0.0474647544,
0.0161307603,
-0.001899079,
0.0125507014,
-0.0318333507,
-0.0494915396,
0.0316357128,
0.0712586194,
0.0112057328,
0.0262956209,
-0.0023909567,
0.0554792285,
-0.0519122109,
0.0804942772,
0.0110475104,
0.0116276937,
-0.0454250611,
0.0046537966,
-0.0088043995,
-0.000367819,
0.0148577699,
0.0095569752,
-0.0366208814,
0.0293732993,
0.0187886301,
0.0152954236,
0.0099456627,
-0.0276188739,
-0.0059446245,
-0.0103926091,
-0.0435173139,
0.0475943685,
-0.0391003862,
-0.0280780755,
0.0360780954,
-0.0209033322,
-0.0153084276,
0.0159527715,
-0.0103348996,
0.0002537626,
-0.0189776458,
0.0010790959,
-0.0093324892,
-0.0253164545,
-0.0428089388,
0.0023087633,
0.0233525783,
-0.0823362321,
-0.0129423505,
-0.0595147051,
-0.0316515155,
0.0367331095,
0.0224520415,
-0.0805933699,
2.237601481e-34,
0.0331123471,
-0.0121487556,
0.0493022762,
-0.007246478,
0.0318362601,
-0.033849597,
-0.0607203841,
-0.0006101293,
0.0075446931,
-0.0480983704,
-0.0189053919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01274v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01274v2 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Actionable Course Evaluation Student Feedback to Lecturers | 2024-07-01T13:29:55 | 2024-07-02T08:47:45 | Mike Zhang, Euan D Lindsay, Frederik Bode Thorbensen, Danny Bøgsted Poulsen, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | End of semester student evaluations of teaching are the dominant mechanism
for providing feedback to academics on their teaching practice. For large
classes, however, the volume of feedback makes these tools impractical for this
purpose. This paper explores the use of open-source generative AI to synthesise
factual, actionable and appropriate summaries of student feedback from these
survey responses. In our setup, we have 742 student responses ranging over 75
courses in a Computer Science department. For each course, we synthesise a
summary of the course evaluations and actionable items for the instructor. Our
results reveal a promising avenue for enhancing teaching practices in the
classroom setting. Our contribution lies in demonstrating the feasibility of
using generative AI to produce insightful feedback for teachers, thus providing
a cost-effective means to support educators' development. Overall, our work
highlights the possibility of using generative AI to produce factual,
actionable, and appropriate feedback for teachers in the classroom setting. | Leveraging Large Language Models for Actionable Course Evaluation Student Feedback to Lecturers: End of semester student evaluations of teaching are the dominant mechanism
for providing feedback to academics on their teaching practice. For large
classes, however, the volume of feedback makes these tools impractical for this
purpose. This paper explores the use of open-source generative AI to synthesise
factual, actionable and appropriate summaries of student feedback from these
survey responses. In our setup, we have 742 student responses ranging over 75
courses in a Computer Science department. For each course, we synthesise a
summary of the course evaluations and actionable items for the instructor. Our
results reveal a promising avenue for enhancing teaching practices in the
classroom setting. Our contribution lies in demonstrating the feasibility of
using generative AI to produce insightful feedback for teachers, thus providing
a cost-effective means to support educators' development. Overall, our work
highlights the possibility of using generative AI to produce factual,
actionable, and appropriate feedback for teachers in the classroom setting. | [
0.0566674173,
0.0382871926,
-0.0245070942,
0.0165467001,
-0.0248288698,
0.0026292377,
-0.0059574153,
-0.0487709455,
0.0230954103,
-0.0727796629,
0.0116146095,
-0.03613187,
-0.0222338364,
0.0302694365,
0.0126491804,
-0.0803589448,
-0.0156353395,
-0.0221285,
-0.0317399837,
0.0102066314,
0.0088607296,
0.0290351734,
-0.0366806835,
0.0539529398,
0.0054252353,
-0.0102403462,
-0.0441018604,
-0.0259346571,
0.0172155928,
0.0226531513,
-0.0023420204,
0.0610084198,
-0.0097401775,
0.0172672775,
0.0000017994,
-0.041342292,
0.0123783071,
0.0027908166,
-0.0035514375,
0.0551961735,
0.0758952796,
0.046894189,
-0.0117477877,
0.0156726483,
-0.0300672259,
-0.0223191921,
0.0244977456,
-0.0022641562,
0.090776369,
0.0237912256,
0.0091921519,
-0.0432621464,
0.0094540389,
0.0192144085,
0.0415781587,
0.0235242918,
-0.0010431693,
0.0105927065,
0.0239296313,
0.0257932469,
-0.0201039743,
-0.0090892315,
0.0125111192,
-0.1020825878,
0.0330586657,
0.0317462385,
-0.0286653545,
0.017759895,
0.0283976682,
0.0470921099,
0.0217460189,
-0.0005815588,
-0.0012817939,
-0.0236593504,
0.0430008285,
0.0195158981,
-0.0435586646,
0.0476398617,
-0.0072025442,
0.0232922416,
0.006856441,
0.0040182369,
-0.0363454781,
0.0149519257,
0.0110249585,
-0.0394580141,
0.0118107488,
-0.0364446081,
-0.0251116753,
0.0692835003,
-0.0154298656,
-0.0475622192,
-0.01684222,
0.0537633859,
-0.0236841012,
0.0005141857,
-0.0108032385,
-0.0434072651,
0.0133212386,
-0.0263684541,
0.0354585387,
0.0176989958,
0.0014534888,
0.0311818905,
0.0012557944,
0.059453316,
0.0169316567,
0.0030900904,
-0.0570714772,
-0.0047601582,
-0.0941098034,
0.0004006966,
0.0041152197,
0.0711263493,
0.010742126,
0.0277605578,
-0.0550809167,
0.0180917829,
-0.0597302429,
0.0552701578,
0.0091355927,
0.0242027268,
-0.0016398631,
0.0359900557,
-0.0371279605,
0.0427644849,
-0.0135872141,
-0.0196710378,
0.0055640214,
-0.0305592958,
0.016365692,
0.0407471284,
0.0077065569,
0.0360006467,
-0.0210532621,
0.0293779429,
0.0035095764,
0.0318431519,
-0.0206952225,
-0.0290380586,
0.006499643,
-0.0108986013,
-0.0088758999,
-0.0784123018,
0.0117446147,
0.0065085823,
-0.004511707,
-0.0045156502,
0.0203994904,
0.0249761678,
0.0298266392,
0.0283509512,
-0.0032807998,
0.0125237256,
0.033864487,
0.0027233795,
0.0579243302,
0.0069644181,
0.023281958,
0.0594561026,
0.0219451785,
-0.024802912,
0.078434214,
0.0128368679,
0.0111807212,
0.0197821949,
-0.0044252155,
0.00605998,
0.0041597094,
0.0157773457,
-0.0422966853,
0.0824228749,
0.0171380974,
0.0428850353,
0.0133425081,
0.0333353281,
-0.0202002637,
0.0561407134,
0.0666158795,
0.0071710916,
0.0128098736,
0.0180107132,
-0.0029893052,
0.0347623527,
0.000738232,
0.0175797325,
0.0394182168,
-0.0217821412,
-0.0002854212,
-0.1097174287,
-0.0150599033,
-0.0182245653,
-0.0150550529,
0.0228786897,
0.0471337028,
0.0149439219,
-0.0193074588,
-0.0154389627,
0.0283369478,
-0.1139429286,
0.0678676069,
-0.0962734222,
0.0709790215,
0.1131337732,
0.0454746559,
-0.0394803099,
-0.0225291885,
-0.0284032319,
-0.0278447494,
0.0364215001,
0.0581214763,
-0.052531071,
-0.046148777,
-0.0337131955,
-0.0188646298,
0.0052569034,
-0.0022641202,
0.0228821915,
-0.0140946871,
-0.0086478218,
0.0198235679,
-0.0233042799,
-0.0858816728,
0.0195183437,
0.0101627363,
-0.053943757,
0.0163866058,
0.009379115,
0.0199148227,
0.0607421696,
-0.0264308024,
0.0134978881,
0.017546583,
-0.0114734033,
-0.0424410142,
-0.0429468229,
-0.0291299596,
-0.0152998706,
0.0512733497,
-0.0369323194,
-0.0093605211,
-0.0124880318,
-0.0571184866,
-0.0418426469,
0.0531505346,
-0.030662531,
0.0160054155,
-0.0271735936,
0.0075892257,
0.0047865873,
-0.0210921001,
-0.0273112878,
0.0309226085,
0.0369189233,
0.0159015041,
0.0404377691,
0.00106706,
0.0381670259,
-0.0085015465,
-0.0318202935,
0.0168852061,
0.0309313014,
0.0392553322,
0.0274462178,
0.0238927938,
-0.0561613292,
-0.0454472676,
-0.0811383799,
-0.0475019589,
0.0236199535,
0.0222628005,
0.0294827912,
-0.006528859,
0.0216272343,
0.0134115927,
-0.0750232711,
-0.0475377217,
0.0149299763,
-0.0389319547,
0.0137616619,
0.0180746466,
0.0144465761,
-0.0633210465,
-0.0286523812,
-0.0316759609,
0.0245768446,
0.0846819356,
0.030317463,
-0.0453632362,
0.05573662,
-0.0143516511,
0.014099814,
0.0272120032,
-0.0466368571,
0.0120524084,
-0.0596685484,
0.0525825806,
0.0413594693,
0.0099318214,
0.0391773991,
0.0367002003,
-0.0019512201,
-0.0810525566,
0.0157596674,
-0.0488208793,
-0.0320018381,
-0.0017378159,
-0.0421829633,
-0.002112916,
0.0131875323,
0.0574781559,
-0.0530562475,
-0.048092559,
0.0111819236,
-0.0516651273,
0.0201317947,
-0.0696778595,
-0.0100577548,
0.0115543399,
0.0102824261,
0.0241574477,
-0.002196651,
0.0760700703,
-0.0093012135,
0.0062574027,
-0.0372415371,
0.0120440163,
-0.0503073223,
0.0505698994,
0.0068220482,
0.0173260979,
-0.0236692,
0.0323349722,
-0.0278513283,
0.0195616428,
0.0316930003,
-0.0510919914,
0.0210808124,
-0.0573707968,
-0.0186042413,
-0.0117173865,
0.0159460939,
-0.0395398438,
0.0073216963,
0.0320636369,
0.0323112831,
0.0309736673,
-0.0279021971,
0.0152628347,
-0.0061014206,
0.025691539,
0.0046320804,
-0.0104325097,
-0.0459503233,
0.0189952236,
0.0294492412,
0.0185285062,
-0.0179739147,
-0.0414153598,
-0.0133801159,
-0.0141887171,
0.0365861319,
0.0472322628,
0.0275874101,
-0.0194783174,
-0.0395849347,
0.034088552,
-0.0399146006,
0.0428421237,
0.0142253758,
-0.0005594112,
-0.0425882973,
-0.0304381717,
0.1080465093,
0.0335593,
-0.0455876179,
-0.0324649885,
-0.0055036917,
-0.0069107888,
0.0114881471,
0.0569233857,
-0.0585222542,
0.0231615789,
-0.0495994948,
0.0401499309,
-0.0206767954,
-0.0035245903,
0.0252382662,
-0.1538253129,
0.064883709,
0.0025264809,
-0.0105726384,
-0.027379496,
-0.0176822841,
-0.0124868723,
-0.0167445559,
-0.0384427346,
-0.0274505801,
0.0238924809,
0.0457385369,
0.0678730085,
-0.0093306508,
-0.0427715518,
0.0098019121,
0.0144529734,
0.0547903068,
0.0849856511,
0.0324498489,
-0.0203084517,
-0.0479629189,
0.0200758837,
-0.0153974434,
-0.0128959361,
0.0207776297,
0.0348199569,
0.0030192519,
-0.0187917203,
-0.0040616663,
0.0210414156,
-0.0469110757,
0.0033604987,
0.0713759661,
0.066770494,
0.0016484733,
0.005471515,
-0.0851437747,
0.0354944654,
0.0384274609,
0.049044013,
0.043234311,
-0.0734680295,
0.0274536218,
-0.0741012841,
0.0081121475,
-0.046472121,
-0.0497245267,
0.0070553278,
-0.0034233856,
-0.0130729247,
-0.0425294004,
-0.0508311465,
0.0357968062,
-0.0164873581,
0.018984478,
-0.0296807811,
0.007346014,
0.0105876094,
-0.0173504241,
-0.0224828199,
0.0021940225,
0.0123011237,
-0.0523097478,
-0.076687634,
0.0185282864,
-0.0291141234,
-0.0382429473,
0.0149911428,
-0.0593002513,
-0.0504213236,
0.0061794524,
0.0704260841,
0.0108262347,
-0.0149141066,
0.0013050413,
0.0008088773,
0.0171829555,
0.047847148,
0.022982534,
-0.0086385738,
0.0133263674,
0.0551208444,
0.0063596843,
-0.014587828,
-0.036805544,
0.0266760346,
0.0325093418,
0.0059209736,
-0.0050341799,
-0.0332264192,
0.0209283121,
0.0352511033,
0.0122418143,
-0.0186607763,
-0.0061452026,
-0.0407644138,
-0.006078958,
-0.0334643349,
-0.0417463966,
-0.0384596363,
-0.0027682192,
0.0190769397,
-0.0078407945,
-0.0004587671,
0.0125786765,
-0.0426117666,
0.0389806218,
-0.0368326083,
0.0389430411,
0.021464454,
-0.0036683755,
0.0296608787,
-0.0029173456,
-0.0480500013,
-0.0316657089,
0.0132192671,
0.0154569019,
0.0061644553,
0.0697880313,
0.0185191762,
0.0277005769,
0.0545581691,
0.0162218381,
-0.0204303041,
0.0057784631,
-0.061593622,
0.0399118327,
-0.0302345529,
0.0499725193,
0.006570288,
-0.0247286949,
0.0018970766,
0.0053982427,
0.0521214679,
-0.0057779974,
-0.0470506325,
-0.0113290073,
0.0032097897,
0.0424277969,
-0.0346829556,
0.0469929539,
-0.0545431077,
0.0126752872,
-0.0102942074,
0.0017545759,
-0.0423577055,
-0.0112935221,
-0.0253926925,
-0.0216924082,
0.0266064573,
0.0099521643,
-0.0341107138,
-0.0373388678,
-0.0390579179,
0.0827125907,
0.0497956797,
-0.002449502,
0.0352805294,
0.022393411,
-0.0302121937,
0.0266900063,
-0.0648061931,
0.0492108874,
-0.0368963405,
-0.0400296748,
-0.0398115665,
-5.189412666e-33,
-0.0622979626,
-0.0332458243,
-0.0232014731,
0.0568724014,
0.0138252303,
-0.0104592871,
-0.0358833037,
0.0272469092,
0.0088792872,
0.0121463565,
-0.0002743188,
0.0111199301,
-0.0075159902,
0.0613208674,
0.0518438369,
0.0276592989,
0.0541184358,
-0.0010070505,
-0.0050868872,
0.0671390966,
0.0017864216,
-0.0426474176,
0.0559393615,
-0.0932189375,
0.0595942177,
-0.0665702224,
-0.038152013,
-0.0079666022,
-0.0554526374,
0.0594999678,
-0.0172736458,
0.0807835162,
-0.0009481593,
-0.0624483116,
0.0043239454,
-0.0266003702,
-0.0086555202,
-0.0542379916,
-0.0142468391,
-0.0343403518,
-0.0077753114,
-0.0463515557,
0.0121957092,
0.0145141417,
-0.0454863235,
-0.0172524527,
0.0803554431,
-0.0072661596,
0.0317658223,
-0.0488546826,
-0.0741035417,
-0.0116644884,
-0.0469755158,
-0.0165826865,
-0.0482759997,
0.0347853415,
-0.0030788647,
-0.0327769518,
-0.0056049298,
0.0675103888,
0.1034052894,
0.0377630554,
0.0534248091,
0.004667866,
-0.0069751237,
0.0178483818,
0.0422235765,
0.0191209931,
-0.0356402993,
-0.023439737,
-0.0095163966,
-0.0307479538,
0.0674309358,
0.0872543007,
0.0011509922,
0.0013017495,
-0.0087082339,
0.063572593,
0.0034037617,
-0.0107831545,
0.0289505459,
-0.0409942605,
-0.0366965644,
-0.0061063664,
-0.0339669548,
-0.0455089957,
-0.0250248276,
-0.0151133453,
0.0290385336,
-0.0168268289,
-0.0151962005,
-0.0288901329,
-0.0159168784,
-0.0418234095,
-0.0224036798,
-0.0103527233,
-0.0326513574,
0.0350585654,
-0.0518682487,
-0.0492925756,
-0.0263908636,
-0.0168733634,
0.018246593,
0.0066037448,
-0.0046262559,
0.0212416276,
0.0242699049,
0.0388039611,
-0.0337893404,
0.0173715577,
-0.0519826896,
0.0293685365,
0.0055972612,
-0.0056477231,
-0.0231661368,
0.0033465046,
-0.0109897787,
0.0402418934,
-0.0090228589,
0.0036651401,
-0.0171364006,
-0.0210435279,
0.0313028805,
-0.046703808,
-0.0592268109,
-0.0259179045,
-0.0040080831,
0.0127918702,
0.0255626384,
-0.0036447968,
0.0075043174,
-0.0039925254,
2.422e-7,
0.0318870395,
0.0134062329,
0.0053474596,
-0.0339257605,
-0.0208910741,
0.0260923542,
0.0236126073,
-0.0071360185,
0.0437014699,
0.0548803955,
0.0082511855,
0.0141546559,
0.0132598607,
0.0493711531,
-0.0851311982,
0.0071266457,
-0.0110996366,
-0.0474331118,
-0.0207288321,
0.0544329956,
0.126105696,
0.0550946333,
0.0492149629,
-0.0012146045,
0.0100745419,
0.0030809548,
0.001270885,
-0.0140126059,
-0.017759556,
0.036487326,
0.014429057,
-0.0155122327,
0.0155993691,
-0.0015782842,
-0.0035249812,
-0.0627956465,
0.0190461446,
0.0150076263,
0.0010869165,
-0.0146390209,
0.0202119369,
0.0011045176,
0.023609465,
-0.0361733548,
-0.0209349785,
-0.0353503488,
0.01224845,
-0.0034028515,
-0.0074513466,
-0.0425953642,
-0.0084860055,
-0.0450196415,
0.016923964,
-0.0102918427,
-0.0124071669,
-0.0185440686,
-0.0065973774,
-0.0168384053,
-0.0034110583,
-0.0374941342,
-0.0161550455,
-0.0535148233,
0.0226078127,
-0.0214900728,
-0.0094644437,
-0.0123314243,
0.0057999846,
1.836155007e-34,
0.0450828411,
0.0107256966,
0.024697775,
-0.0164975598,
0.0163735226,
0.0223417617,
-0.0045094704,
0.0135752773,
0.0249595735,
-0.0482795574,
-0.0757149607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01272v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01272v2 | Show Less, Instruct More: Enriching Prompts with Definitions and Guidelines for Zero-Shot NER | 2024-07-01T13:25:33 | 2024-07-02T07:55:24 | Andrew Zamai, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Ernandes, Marco Maggini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, several specialized instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs)
for Named Entity Recognition (NER) have emerged. Compared to traditional NER
approaches, these models have strong generalization capabilities. Existing LLMs
mainly focus on zero-shot NER in out-of-domain distributions, being fine-tuned
on an extensive number of entity classes that often highly or completely
overlap with test sets. In this work instead, we propose SLIMER, an approach
designed to tackle never-seen-before named entity tags by instructing the model
on fewer examples, and by leveraging a prompt enriched with definition and
guidelines. Experiments demonstrate that definition and guidelines yield better
performance, faster and more robust learning, particularly when labelling
unseen Named Entities. Furthermore, SLIMER performs comparably to
state-of-the-art approaches in out-of-domain zero-shot NER, while being trained
on a reduced tag set. | Show Less, Instruct More: Enriching Prompts with Definitions and Guidelines for Zero-Shot NER: Recently, several specialized instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs)
for Named Entity Recognition (NER) have emerged. Compared to traditional NER
approaches, these models have strong generalization capabilities. Existing LLMs
mainly focus on zero-shot NER in out-of-domain distributions, being fine-tuned
on an extensive number of entity classes that often highly or completely
overlap with test sets. In this work instead, we propose SLIMER, an approach
designed to tackle never-seen-before named entity tags by instructing the model
on fewer examples, and by leveraging a prompt enriched with definition and
guidelines. Experiments demonstrate that definition and guidelines yield better
performance, faster and more robust learning, particularly when labelling
unseen Named Entities. Furthermore, SLIMER performs comparably to
state-of-the-art approaches in out-of-domain zero-shot NER, while being trained
on a reduced tag set. | [
0.0332860127,
0.0262867436,
0.0270588472,
0.0082625216,
0.0225353893,
0.0502662361,
0.0234195292,
0.0240207426,
0.0216553919,
-0.0610488839,
-0.0335160196,
-0.0245445333,
-0.0292524993,
0.0080637932,
0.02979034,
-0.0126310745,
0.0155587979,
-0.0269824006,
0.0196730644,
0.0405411832,
-0.0250767414,
0.0060160505,
-0.007055087,
0.0155967819,
0.0020095112,
-0.0003517475,
-0.0252370853,
0.0426407941,
0.0249913707,
-0.090710327,
0.0146990512,
0.0441429093,
0.00854336,
0.0546810478,
0.0000018697,
-0.0655953959,
-0.0537374467,
0.0248959642,
-0.0464016274,
-0.0007663604,
0.0203508846,
-0.0334920511,
-0.0127565516,
0.0121957399,
0.0074531669,
-0.069927752,
0.0363846943,
0.080558531,
0.0252189115,
0.0894646794,
-0.0097594569,
-0.0222018547,
0.0157102719,
-0.0365187749,
0.0287583433,
-0.047976017,
0.0571766049,
-0.0480405688,
-0.0019089011,
0.029495338,
-0.0102748657,
0.0103598246,
0.0098727094,
-0.0025251803,
0.0085993791,
0.0538448878,
0.0051663937,
0.0095160035,
-0.0047021653,
0.0809030682,
-0.0264663808,
0.0228134207,
0.0398349017,
-0.019356085,
-0.0103090294,
-0.0411054976,
-0.0359622277,
0.0272597652,
-0.0213884711,
-0.0034853905,
0.0067214048,
0.0003102083,
0.0288117621,
0.0044354303,
-0.0192980524,
0.0258390848,
0.022011565,
-0.0348683149,
0.0224103238,
0.0117113162,
-0.029128354,
-0.0610143989,
-0.0095518241,
0.0447285883,
-0.0044989018,
0.0129810395,
-0.0352282971,
0.0165125113,
0.0065300222,
0.0206359476,
0.0402608514,
0.0105909584,
0.0191359632,
0.0701733977,
-0.0577701554,
0.0031790216,
0.0137619441,
0.0001295878,
0.0113038905,
-0.0080704084,
-0.0698216781,
0.0018265193,
-0.0417006873,
0.0516113564,
-0.0327875167,
-0.0155610368,
0.0003309132,
0.0062787072,
-0.0005052242,
0.0416012369,
-0.0017569645,
-0.0370426662,
-0.0050896415,
-0.0228816438,
-0.0157665219,
0.0331434049,
-0.018178951,
-0.016875023,
-0.0085751219,
-0.0591819659,
-0.0349695012,
-0.0135393562,
0.0103630051,
-0.0443359427,
0.0254297275,
0.0584750958,
0.0261493847,
-0.1065390781,
-0.06242235,
0.013182045,
-0.0084071187,
-0.0512789488,
-0.0083860774,
-0.0141660329,
0.0167191084,
0.0087181889,
0.0287628267,
-0.0706542134,
0.0234803371,
0.0034455524,
-0.0370187983,
0.0695549101,
-0.0347723365,
-0.0046579372,
0.0065069972,
0.0140772965,
0.0639506057,
0.0537350066,
0.0006207543,
-0.000146479,
0.0235298183,
0.0038065789,
0.0014917614,
0.0388411507,
0.0159283001,
0.0027266541,
-0.0151869161,
0.0090591609,
0.0384339355,
0.0089565273,
0.0382367373,
0.0324928313,
-0.0076120617,
-0.0092988862,
0.0249134861,
0.0124875614,
0.0067597916,
-0.0336192101,
0.0586046055,
0.0185092874,
-0.0069791283,
-0.0225724839,
-0.051644329,
0.0005686476,
-0.0179835372,
0.0217328947,
0.0126897702,
0.046393238,
-0.0460769497,
0.0170497913,
-0.0133894272,
-0.0040954319,
-0.0110720433,
0.0184290204,
0.0608767122,
0.0265716445,
-0.0814837664,
0.0513926111,
0.0498188138,
0.0056783617,
0.0051258821,
-0.0153869092,
0.0511583537,
0.0388362892,
0.0541888513,
-0.032325346,
-0.0443183631,
-0.0512912236,
0.0183294974,
0.0775187016,
0.0289271623,
-0.025009837,
0.0325412452,
-0.0501173586,
-0.0070277089,
-0.0074539338,
0.0411853977,
0.021734992,
0.0457686335,
0.0360775962,
0.0409938842,
-0.0215040762,
-0.0411597081,
0.0551502779,
-0.0300677866,
-0.0645187423,
0.0182264857,
0.0176902879,
-0.032347776,
0.0501820296,
-0.0156321879,
-0.022495009,
0.0296530928,
-0.0135977147,
0.0148405517,
-0.0937415957,
-0.0076541118,
-0.0396328419,
0.0058603347,
0.0176778082,
-0.0257726163,
-0.0383079946,
-0.0331224352,
-0.0399890244,
-0.0775327086,
0.017991608,
0.0321382619,
-0.0172206163,
0.0319323167,
0.0104431864,
0.0032572548,
-0.0359059609,
0.0577218719,
0.0143565917,
0.025819689,
0.0439775661,
-0.0000779205,
-0.0168461874,
-0.0335045569,
-0.0729906261,
0.0090240063,
-0.0044841929,
-0.0424882695,
-0.0032190906,
0.0274042226,
-0.0555611961,
-0.0187620576,
-0.0751400739,
0.0125782741,
-0.0096810153,
0.051604934,
-0.0077975583,
0.04443812,
-0.0343998671,
-0.024647247,
-0.004634867,
-0.0117169293,
-0.0200096834,
0.0155414501,
0.0254107025,
0.0149733508,
-0.0468798168,
0.017564334,
0.0026749927,
-0.0219356418,
0.0279254802,
0.0184168816,
-0.0362616926,
-0.0623550788,
0.0555378348,
-0.0211106595,
-0.0161175895,
0.0149671659,
0.0279100239,
-0.0139699103,
0.0166833084,
-0.0032553193,
0.0651903301,
-0.0147295278,
0.0128322523,
-0.0238110814,
-0.0056453422,
-0.0553393513,
0.0159915909,
-0.0253334623,
-0.0031406537,
-0.0195381436,
-0.0168984663,
0.0249323379,
0.1128962338,
-0.0598264262,
0.0218608286,
-0.0395367891,
0.0283522606,
-0.0075771734,
-0.0136289438,
-0.0106297815,
0.0227083173,
0.0060470994,
-0.0011222591,
-0.0230786894,
-0.0162071735,
0.0613340177,
-0.0583951585,
-0.0330233797,
0.0222824886,
-0.0115456833,
-0.0642860532,
0.0395759568,
0.0062965932,
-0.006359343,
0.0814534128,
-0.082103461,
0.001863028,
0.0184692293,
0.0015954287,
-0.0065886639,
0.0341018327,
-0.0004258401,
0.0281842221,
-0.0201624129,
-0.0069430182,
-0.0337615944,
-0.0078806784,
-0.0391667001,
0.0251864325,
-0.0315352455,
-0.0052185836,
-0.0375578217,
0.0538155288,
0.0059830137,
0.0518092439,
-0.005020529,
-0.0052593816,
-0.0247670654,
0.0263939686,
0.0382165648,
-0.0043639941,
0.0072816671,
-0.0268223397,
0.0250858646,
0.0127188778,
-0.0108839227,
-0.0070141801,
0.0126836225,
-0.0064446703,
0.0150685925,
-0.0681479275,
0.020090092,
0.0101227695,
0.0555433072,
-0.0275765602,
-0.0193527527,
0.1285375804,
0.0160469729,
-0.0291835535,
-0.0304457322,
0.0367807746,
0.0454583317,
0.0285246596,
0.0235471632,
-0.0870271549,
-0.0614670627,
0.0269552153,
0.0064031295,
0.0126189152,
-0.0761659667,
-0.0071840584,
-0.1418728828,
0.0002268593,
-0.0169360228,
-0.0380184948,
0.0304943342,
-0.0736040846,
0.0087284939,
-0.0401451252,
-0.0095361993,
-0.0265240911,
-0.0528250113,
-0.01081309,
0.0155903446,
0.0550745875,
-0.0663171411,
0.0115464227,
-0.0453712903,
0.0663452446,
0.0343379639,
0.0043951506,
-0.0056888852,
0.0056650778,
0.0419296697,
-0.0509058051,
-0.0070813717,
-0.0245764703,
0.0392537899,
-0.0712195039,
-0.0022618838,
-0.0108330855,
-0.0036521626,
-0.022040328,
-0.0100746648,
0.0275043119,
0.0433427356,
0.0119238356,
0.0116376448,
-0.0066381292,
-0.0482735187,
0.0376724042,
0.0977520049,
0.0243981127,
-0.0321339667,
-0.0119453929,
-0.0016600149,
-0.0269576125,
0.0092143975,
-0.0233888477,
0.0109034907,
-0.0797591507,
-0.0432383567,
-0.018896291,
-0.0508213341,
0.0717319623,
0.0679460913,
0.0335766226,
-0.0051848558,
-0.0100140916,
0.0057830866,
-0.0557635166,
0.0476768874,
-0.0514925122,
0.0245235227,
-0.0822571591,
-0.0167793222,
0.0250016823,
0.0285404995,
-0.0396286733,
0.0179109201,
-0.0600287095,
-0.0487561822,
-0.0304211155,
0.0168381892,
0.0190690532,
0.0280030239,
-0.0204837844,
-0.0233166795,
0.0303322952,
0.0630537495,
-0.0514372215,
-0.01362486,
-0.0088490723,
0.0014779834,
-0.0091717057,
0.033352904,
-0.0304256938,
0.0394993089,
0.0527743027,
0.0714632124,
-0.0265014078,
-0.0511817709,
-0.0071700299,
0.0054697981,
0.0319799446,
-0.0020918443,
-0.012670733,
-0.0357917137,
0.0121375304,
0.00981839,
0.0004514393,
-0.0188475773,
-0.0145436972,
0.0287871212,
-0.0034970704,
-0.0095412098,
0.0758558437,
-0.0274129864,
0.0671506897,
-0.0662188828,
0.0162140168,
0.0126219401,
0.014630992,
0.0105049442,
-0.0462739021,
-0.0053574885,
0.0592997819,
0.0537781157,
0.033854425,
-0.0151841491,
0.0521279126,
0.0211759619,
0.0234550685,
-0.0321060531,
-0.0074080094,
-0.0152993947,
0.0057943068,
-0.0381675139,
0.074462913,
0.0383439586,
-0.0071869711,
0.0372542627,
0.0069052428,
-0.0076971818,
-0.0027674986,
-0.0044234074,
-0.009240699,
-0.0391306914,
0.0285027362,
0.0413188674,
-0.0166933909,
-0.0017474862,
0.0618615486,
0.037594445,
0.0518154949,
0.0201070439,
0.0130848438,
-0.0406080596,
0.0091660265,
0.0502027906,
-0.0080255829,
-0.0187660344,
0.0363244452,
-0.0529638007,
-0.0392980687,
0.0317393839,
-0.0472872443,
-0.0155041087,
0.008374935,
0.0233147945,
-0.0005633816,
0.0004060112,
-0.0409380309,
-0.030851936,
0.0158164278,
-0.0050445576,
-0.049509678,
-0.0248985756,
-6.12678933e-33,
-0.0487901904,
-0.0430128649,
0.0245822836,
-0.0342589803,
-0.0164864697,
0.0340766944,
-0.0276446659,
-0.0218564216,
0.0079564089,
-0.0274951011,
-0.0182860009,
-0.0108276494,
0.0272477921,
0.0184772834,
-0.0122267054,
-0.0403203778,
0.0700693578,
0.0352700502,
-0.0425502546,
0.0181891099,
0.0001100486,
0.0662756115,
0.0485850126,
-0.0426079296,
0.0408442542,
-0.005196651,
-0.0169780441,
0.0089397701,
0.089752309,
0.0621187277,
-0.0283175427,
-0.010646021,
0.0121840024,
-0.0859833583,
0.012173635,
0.0175360013,
-0.1486124396,
0.0129132969,
-0.0265007094,
0.0018531926,
0.0124580339,
-0.0450925007,
-0.0052230996,
-0.0221274588,
0.0297406986,
0.0209017377,
0.0221688859,
-0.0059304442,
-0.0154157933,
-0.0182667356,
-0.054870028,
0.0488890037,
-0.0004768618,
0.0042661424,
0.0490072742,
-0.0178899728,
0.0321177989,
-0.0059131328,
-0.0556537621,
0.0120645231,
0.045200713,
-0.016991267,
0.0322235785,
0.0346521623,
-0.0153356772,
0.0406681933,
0.0159017127,
0.0036294661,
-0.034884382,
0.0029918002,
0.0121381953,
0.0011478607,
-0.0529486611,
0.0512385853,
0.0379363969,
-0.0344242416,
-0.0644501671,
0.0270021092,
-0.0123390881,
0.0201012362,
-0.0007601457,
-0.024489725,
-0.0584236048,
0.0060678357,
-0.0085368594,
-0.0349419676,
-0.0579309314,
-0.0143600218,
0.0484410413,
0.0387056991,
-0.0686809719,
0.0384074152,
0.0461143479,
-0.0071383328,
-0.0475013964,
0.0101377787,
0.0542989597,
0.0169120263,
-0.0230097659,
-0.0081053087,
-0.0638968125,
-0.0687109828,
0.0480015539,
-0.0254862048,
0.0183639023,
-0.0052437573,
0.063323006,
-0.0190471075,
-0.0805316046,
-0.0170115773,
-0.0106152073,
0.0384096578,
-0.0288262106,
0.0589644425,
0.0171668865,
0.0043930132,
-0.0051212534,
0.0366770998,
0.0538476147,
-0.0329076797,
-0.0071632434,
0.0341897905,
0.0337813124,
0.0227529146,
-0.0175677259,
-0.0025060829,
0.0256886147,
-0.012062002,
0.0004493627,
-0.0428636409,
-0.000916433,
-0.0055101523,
2.542e-7,
-0.0174823236,
0.018117914,
0.0011108648,
0.0009081201,
-0.0122452863,
0.0234816819,
0.0228896514,
0.0341345817,
-0.039231535,
-0.0160635617,
-0.0178900715,
-0.0099902833,
0.020883752,
-0.0081547899,
-0.1195853055,
-0.0100005176,
0.0203476027,
0.0091395481,
-0.0872732848,
0.0169095136,
0.0165044591,
0.076491259,
0.0007520928,
-0.0127316909,
-0.0170248207,
-0.0199527908,
0.0472780876,
0.0173156615,
0.0142677613,
0.0422351472,
0.0052060513,
0.0712998137,
-0.0201250762,
0.0350037031,
0.0030109196,
0.0403221585,
0.0133683849,
0.1034578905,
0.0082332026,
0.02344184,
-0.0005056225,
-0.0312368348,
0.0172253549,
-0.0300659798,
0.0772081837,
-0.0503494628,
-0.0256083142,
0.0116336755,
-0.0434089825,
-0.034568131,
0.0148028117,
0.0042140018,
0.0013948274,
0.0225256477,
0.0326680727,
-0.0327897482,
-0.0088944146,
-0.0559060685,
0.0321718976,
0.0018550876,
0.0042117666,
-0.0222306866,
-0.0235895868,
-0.0122438185,
0.001687157,
-0.0842354819,
0.0014443321,
2.498545615e-34,
-0.0093580857,
-0.0076281782,
-0.0245715138,
0.0457000881,
0.0280136503,
-0.0055898163,
-0.0489691459,
-0.0037514805,
-0.0028286465,
-0.0983713865,
0.0089523084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01271v1 | First Place Solution of 2023 Global Artificial Intelligence Technology Innovation Competition Track 1 | 2024-07-01T13:22:22 | 2024-07-01T13:22:22 | Xiangyu Wu, Hailiang Zhang, Yang Yang, Jianfeng Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present our champion solution to the Global Artificial
Intelligence Technology Innovation Competition Track 1: Medical Imaging
Diagnosis Report Generation. We select CPT-BASE as our base model for the text
generation task. During the pre-training stage, we delete the mask language
modeling task of CPT-BASE and instead reconstruct the vocabulary, adopting a
span mask strategy and gradually increasing the number of masking ratios to
perform the denoising auto-encoder pre-training task. In the fine-tuning stage,
we design iterative retrieval augmentation and noise-aware similarity bucket
prompt strategies. The retrieval augmentation constructs a mini-knowledge base,
enriching the input information of the model, while the similarity bucket
further perceives the noise information within the mini-knowledge base, guiding
the model to generate higher-quality diagnostic reports based on the similarity
prompts. Surprisingly, our single model has achieved a score of 2.321 on
leaderboard A, and the multiple model fusion scores are 2.362 and 2.320 on the
A and B leaderboards respectively, securing first place in the rankings. | First Place Solution of 2023 Global Artificial Intelligence Technology Innovation Competition Track 1: In this paper, we present our champion solution to the Global Artificial
Intelligence Technology Innovation Competition Track 1: Medical Imaging
Diagnosis Report Generation. We select CPT-BASE as our base model for the text
generation task. During the pre-training stage, we delete the mask language
modeling task of CPT-BASE and instead reconstruct the vocabulary, adopting a
span mask strategy and gradually increasing the number of masking ratios to
perform the denoising auto-encoder pre-training task. In the fine-tuning stage,
we design iterative retrieval augmentation and noise-aware similarity bucket
prompt strategies. The retrieval augmentation constructs a mini-knowledge base,
enriching the input information of the model, while the similarity bucket
further perceives the noise information within the mini-knowledge base, guiding
the model to generate higher-quality diagnostic reports based on the similarity
prompts. Surprisingly, our single model has achieved a score of 2.321 on
leaderboard A, and the multiple model fusion scores are 2.362 and 2.320 on the
A and B leaderboards respectively, securing first place in the rankings. | [
0.0385673568,
0.0264667813,
0.0015008481,
-0.0086844238,
-0.0400133394,
-0.0121003166,
0.0275281891,
0.0588273779,
-0.012348081,
-0.0268437993,
-0.003800848,
-0.0714506954,
-0.0181748774,
0.1169802174,
0.0401480757,
-0.0570422038,
0.0201515406,
0.0345105529,
-0.0002761068,
-0.006435845,
-0.0049924781,
-0.0062930938,
-0.0047631441,
0.0430272333,
-0.022939695,
0.0309696328,
0.0220841244,
-0.0116714044,
0.0408343226,
-0.0846883133,
0.0043332432,
0.0289804656,
0.038190309,
0.0520324148,
0.0000024331,
-0.0631736815,
-0.0420554876,
0.0273718573,
-0.018060118,
-0.0408443771,
0.028743377,
-0.0169566721,
0.0140791032,
0.0197112709,
-0.0332276784,
0.0031335668,
0.0253676772,
0.0362190008,
0.0670633167,
0.0708336085,
-0.0290571582,
0.0109946961,
0.0347073898,
-0.0339020863,
-0.0089313313,
-0.0148850875,
-0.0016228692,
0.0059564314,
0.0309674572,
-0.0037926543,
0.0207350161,
0.059237171,
-0.0057235127,
0.0200035181,
0.0708066747,
0.0764007047,
0.0080083627,
-0.0382722057,
0.0075461357,
0.0379033536,
-0.0355610102,
-0.0270846039,
-0.0078666769,
-0.0006535381,
-0.023550842,
-0.0220688377,
-0.0447774678,
0.0354088247,
0.016494697,
-0.0005016639,
0.0072065974,
0.0304014627,
0.0038439664,
0.0156111596,
-0.0360070132,
0.0082771648,
0.000848371,
-0.0453311689,
-0.0148003818,
0.0027389945,
-0.0057232487,
-0.0312317405,
0.0414996408,
0.0439081267,
-0.0457546636,
-0.0208890121,
-0.038645234,
-0.0758607984,
0.0353845693,
-0.0362870656,
0.0013168113,
0.0006256314,
-0.012931413,
0.0584420338,
-0.0417292826,
0.0346954241,
-0.0227186698,
0.03250359,
-0.0607883893,
-0.0048808949,
-0.0092243459,
-0.0045891549,
-0.0347892158,
0.0641698912,
-0.0254014377,
-0.0377436355,
-0.0557169728,
-0.0284683388,
-0.0133623872,
0.0281299297,
0.0170376711,
0.0617294088,
-0.0690585002,
-0.0215698164,
-0.0032378433,
0.0157901682,
-0.0000784867,
-0.0089714732,
0.0136422692,
-0.0160082038,
-0.0105683031,
0.061132092,
0.0042611049,
-0.0156482868,
0.0317145586,
0.0443704613,
-0.0567726158,
-0.0356044583,
0.0191353075,
-0.0558116809,
0.0114171766,
-0.0314367078,
0.0166072454,
-0.041864749,
0.0487690978,
-0.0092098359,
-0.002369765,
-0.0366865359,
0.0126009118,
0.0096076801,
0.0027082891,
0.0525470935,
-0.0829986706,
-0.0267215315,
0.0619094856,
0.0314531513,
0.0150411734,
-0.015222555,
0.0225892812,
0.0133889373,
-0.0037497736,
0.0033162124,
-0.0017678945,
-0.0024238601,
0.0563872419,
-0.0432183221,
-0.0276037641,
-0.0240571927,
-0.0323720984,
0.0541679636,
0.0040532253,
0.0521428473,
-0.0137829315,
0.0105109168,
0.0453484468,
0.050431408,
0.0370952934,
0.0330363177,
0.0197376758,
-0.0184462816,
-0.0448719785,
-0.0062608598,
0.0445907712,
0.0417054296,
-0.0429885499,
0.0015483643,
0.0228470676,
0.0200970527,
-0.0379512608,
-0.0414778329,
0.0007051107,
0.0078019039,
-0.0183500256,
-0.0000145903,
0.0396251716,
-0.0134862997,
-0.0399794802,
0.0220786612,
0.0092476187,
-0.0570271611,
-0.0153398737,
-0.0754272863,
0.0312692448,
0.0206222404,
0.0887676105,
-0.0583696365,
-0.0332447179,
-0.0047579873,
-0.0386697724,
0.0469335318,
-0.008729998,
0.018814439,
-0.00695254,
-0.0616430044,
-0.0420147777,
0.0077130017,
-0.0226304289,
0.0007169332,
-0.0156400893,
0.034188848,
0.0321541242,
-0.0006942108,
-0.0138126388,
0.0250216927,
-0.0358006768,
-0.0123685747,
0.0178464521,
0.0113195144,
0.0319977477,
0.0365644544,
-0.0508014672,
0.0280576646,
0.0366490148,
-0.0823745057,
-0.0550818257,
0.0304398965,
-0.0644338205,
-0.0507666394,
0.0180815849,
-0.061230734,
0.0314622112,
0.0105581032,
-0.014374028,
-0.0412997417,
-0.0033895094,
-0.0260251109,
-0.0245889351,
-0.0463659279,
0.0324829258,
0.0369201414,
0.0011036627,
-0.0297995154,
0.071697861,
-0.0160600264,
0.0056895479,
0.0291388053,
0.0078876251,
0.0555097386,
-0.0349350087,
-0.0552922189,
0.0283229109,
0.019565491,
0.0155916037,
0.0590205565,
0.0257608872,
-0.0181510802,
-0.0161188766,
-0.0722665712,
-0.0001190207,
0.0133238873,
-0.0363538712,
0.0229514651,
0.032090012,
0.0219621733,
-0.0274095442,
-0.0763480291,
-0.0077271913,
0.0625029802,
-0.0139209637,
0.0652135983,
0.0568668433,
0.0128525542,
-0.0373812914,
-0.0177358892,
0.0000340652,
0.0156449452,
0.0466296822,
-0.0608479716,
-0.0141801275,
0.0661025196,
-0.0491121486,
0.0447572283,
-0.0071178088,
-0.0292463396,
0.0137380622,
-0.0532275811,
-0.03289406,
0.0560250431,
0.0144516565,
0.0149322553,
0.0149216503,
0.0287534017,
-0.0255717728,
0.0361297876,
-0.0343582183,
0.0133833792,
0.059417937,
-0.0369524024,
0.0374948122,
0.0306969527,
0.0220919345,
0.0149620669,
-0.0550883599,
-0.0186724346,
-0.0099792751,
-0.0424799807,
-0.0713057443,
-0.0159302969,
-0.0070021888,
0.0481639765,
-0.0281491596,
-0.0359548926,
0.0860020295,
-0.0078040017,
0.0217241086,
-0.0670484379,
-0.0256087817,
-0.018055182,
0.0434677266,
0.0134325558,
0.0587762296,
0.0043975119,
-0.0143712871,
-0.0419127233,
0.027596077,
0.0279610511,
-0.0800470114,
-0.0201354027,
0.0078309011,
0.0236085262,
-0.0119172353,
-0.0517642349,
-0.0500818938,
-0.0293425247,
0.040932823,
0.0016310344,
0.0258276127,
-0.0071973074,
-0.0497012772,
0.049074892,
0.0364321694,
0.0709051564,
0.0247806795,
-0.0030001507,
-0.0122110834,
0.08101926,
0.0279240254,
0.0253084805,
0.0139569473,
-0.0233353879,
0.0334684066,
0.0571257547,
0.0304595847,
0.0304186102,
-0.0026407146,
0.0166533347,
-0.0058927196,
0.0067028706,
-0.033918675,
0.003364786,
0.0409466252,
-0.0415777788,
-0.0244062096,
0.1067672521,
0.0104052853,
-0.0303628352,
-0.0224939454,
0.0366670713,
0.0055728364,
0.0036917811,
0.0030867038,
-0.0563926511,
0.0259324089,
-0.0234539025,
0.0324665457,
-0.0262377188,
-0.0257842783,
-0.0076983976,
-0.0741985515,
0.0413386077,
0.0233968925,
0.0109358225,
-0.0705284104,
-0.008562359,
-0.0228592176,
0.0173259303,
-0.0157616548,
-0.0185571816,
0.0327715427,
-0.0052071172,
0.0106129237,
-0.0348793417,
-0.0726694986,
-0.0178918075,
-0.0445481725,
0.0145669095,
0.0925381333,
0.0155886998,
-0.0306908377,
-0.0587291941,
-0.025872685,
0.0247289147,
0.0315604024,
-0.0064308913,
0.0696195588,
-0.0079658674,
-0.0232284032,
-0.01850258,
0.0161799695,
-0.0231584832,
-0.0070016789,
-0.0119131841,
0.0659443736,
-0.0317095183,
0.0187686402,
-0.0544642694,
0.0225931648,
0.0014454711,
0.0510306172,
0.0063737095,
-0.0058176978,
0.0021641257,
0.0279215388,
0.0950110406,
-0.07322561,
0.02372545,
0.0302769281,
-0.0166599955,
-0.0476873331,
-0.0815632194,
-0.0307654683,
0.019387152,
0.0357582755,
0.005056133,
-0.000315081,
-0.0275619142,
-0.0175948162,
-0.0663683787,
0.0143790375,
0.0401095301,
-0.0123596815,
-0.0379781313,
-0.0174939875,
0.0153747415,
-0.0101009682,
-0.0281331409,
0.0638368726,
-0.032162182,
-0.0056504151,
-0.0292677227,
0.0561565123,
0.0210564248,
0.025042044,
0.0035239989,
-0.0251236055,
0.0911084041,
0.0327915847,
0.0018198151,
0.0128171043,
-0.0043162396,
-0.0576994196,
-0.0472120829,
-0.0142336041,
-0.0260158051,
0.0142286737,
0.0204987638,
0.026390275,
-0.0015115025,
-0.0444670543,
0.0541339219,
0.0434712358,
0.0381642617,
-0.0498166271,
0.0200891495,
-0.0536292978,
-0.0188636128,
-0.0029849233,
-0.0156791117,
-0.05583046,
-0.0027137245,
0.0138950348,
-0.0219740998,
0.0167682357,
0.0611847118,
-0.0230571982,
-0.0115161221,
-0.0978623778,
0.0097787818,
-0.042910073,
0.042873621,
0.0312234312,
-0.0047868579,
-0.021946134,
-0.0022275969,
0.0151827596,
0.0032442203,
-0.0237651765,
0.0617796257,
0.0304031745,
0.04535871,
0.0110582616,
0.0744546503,
-0.0144147845,
-0.035893973,
-0.07443358,
0.0034168651,
0.0586955622,
0.0146023836,
0.0277281795,
-0.0392365046,
-0.0090191672,
-0.0159950219,
0.0370815583,
-0.0133096362,
-0.0086082816,
-0.0012135393,
-0.0077497745,
0.019425936,
-0.027411893,
0.1139334887,
-0.0404612087,
0.0073373318,
-0.0169636849,
-0.0265731514,
-0.0708007216,
-0.003141342,
0.0369205996,
0.0617041886,
-0.003788217,
0.0523814484,
-0.0248260908,
-0.0360122062,
0.0351490416,
-0.0128652258,
-0.0233732965,
-0.0047557005,
0.0810475647,
0.0721697584,
-0.0006914061,
-0.0120946141,
0.0039740694,
0.0064780964,
-0.007521397,
-0.0354069509,
0.0108083962,
-7.323937389e-33,
-0.0209000707,
-0.0179351643,
0.0257378854,
-0.0419803113,
-0.0327814221,
0.0427886546,
-0.0489434004,
-0.0142998863,
0.0112268757,
0.011989262,
-0.0269619562,
-0.0166514013,
-0.0026572491,
0.0553995855,
-0.0141492561,
0.0308694746,
0.0626351461,
-0.0098638572,
-0.0280399844,
0.0423122905,
0.0063280659,
0.0505831204,
0.0403681546,
-0.0917141736,
-0.0345368944,
0.0141810672,
-0.0290966202,
-0.0256700907,
0.0202021729,
0.0264726765,
-0.0234131031,
0.0416803733,
0.0315481424,
-0.0520750172,
-0.0130018173,
-0.0332810469,
-0.0411601737,
-0.0396222323,
-0.0413791314,
-0.0240952317,
-0.0674492791,
-0.0149768833,
0.0564941615,
-0.0444440171,
-0.0109781986,
-0.0085396869,
0.0289026964,
-0.0223950166,
0.0004494228,
-0.0512177497,
-0.02264091,
0.0378449298,
-0.011605639,
-0.0303325877,
0.0106602451,
0.0162657499,
-0.0192576349,
0.0103832688,
-0.0822267681,
0.0344971791,
0.055022344,
0.0673075989,
0.0427815318,
-0.0037116564,
-0.0094374586,
0.0476256534,
0.0086931363,
-0.033619184,
-0.0309852306,
0.0033677567,
-0.0205651503,
0.0371969417,
0.0810833126,
0.0190591253,
0.0113641573,
-0.0309072193,
-0.069908753,
0.0779487491,
-0.0313798971,
0.0489801727,
0.0181464218,
0.0003278831,
-0.0507791229,
-0.0113180177,
0.0271579232,
-0.0193002112,
-0.0225359201,
-0.0303353444,
0.045602411,
0.0282553304,
-0.0062015057,
0.0315285996,
0.0237578284,
-0.0153476261,
0.0620723404,
-0.0262402929,
0.0294364244,
0.0189796649,
-0.0291941818,
-0.0005038054,
-0.0546913743,
-0.0545449182,
0.0241714492,
0.0318918973,
0.0035708246,
0.0105525209,
0.0063891667,
0.0269131754,
-0.0395865813,
0.002146838,
-0.0202475805,
0.0067129927,
0.0086221499,
0.0262199435,
-0.0221841373,
0.0078714015,
0.0013609211,
0.0412000008,
-0.000196831,
0.0001047455,
-0.0448338352,
-0.0357606746,
0.018552646,
-0.0037866994,
-0.0378532074,
-0.0003987575,
-0.0529052541,
-0.0062633483,
0.0498491079,
-0.0212188065,
-0.0348797515,
-0.0051045995,
3.253e-7,
0.0482330807,
0.0149262259,
0.0195821393,
-0.0072656688,
-0.003027438,
0.0175382756,
0.0004878532,
0.0351659656,
-0.0128027368,
-0.0044404729,
0.0368014574,
-0.0043509314,
0.0050911102,
0.0034514305,
-0.0528488606,
-0.0244514793,
-0.0915356204,
-0.0127398008,
-0.031452518,
0.0067382604,
0.0965446457,
0.07060498,
-0.0341804959,
-0.0475410707,
0.0299897194,
-0.0284612961,
0.0589290634,
-0.0078328494,
0.0008538114,
0.0163578335,
0.0369110964,
0.0449680761,
0.0050319466,
0.0447115749,
-0.0376682915,
0.0097056301,
0.0308591817,
-0.0068646101,
-0.0326635391,
-0.0199586544,
0.04907405,
0.0456467457,
0.0131402202,
-0.0861102641,
0.0544411428,
-0.015915636,
-0.0229013935,
-0.0202100575,
-0.0174329318,
0.0193223637,
0.0403163508,
-0.0561086312,
-0.0660094693,
0.0114008915,
0.0237921365,
0.0475891121,
-0.024731243,
-0.0817599669,
-0.0019756891,
-0.0192232821,
-0.0375411995,
-0.0282310434,
-0.0074440865,
-0.0413066968,
-0.0031839148,
-0.0256018639,
0.0081889229,
3.166620839e-34,
0.0041607963,
-0.0040312139,
0.0079711014,
-0.0002258064,
0.0183277521,
-0.0215294529,
-0.0052184369,
0.0133360419,
-0.0044778492,
-0.0534734651,
-0.0349453278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01270v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01270v1 | The African Woman is Rhythmic and Soulful: Evaluation of Open-ended Generation for Implicit Biases | 2024-07-01T13:21:33 | 2024-07-01T13:21:33 | Serene Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study investigates the subtle and often concealed biases present in
Large Language Models (LLMs), which, despite passing explicit bias tests, can
still exhibit implicit biases akin to those observed in humans who profess
egalitarian beliefs yet demonstrate underlying prejudices. The challenge of
measuring such biases is exacerbated as LLMs become increasingly proprietary,
restricting access to their internal mechanisms such as embeddings, which are
crucial for applying traditional bias measures. To tackle these issues, this
study introduces innovative measures of bias inspired by psychological
methodologies: the LLM Implicit Association Test (IAT) Bias and the LLM
Decision Bias. The LLM IAT Bias is a prompt-based method designed to unearth
implicit biases by simulating the well-known psychological IAT but adapted for
use with LLMs. The LLM Decision Bias measure is developed to detect subtle
discrimination in decision-making tasks, focusing on how LLMs choose between
individuals in various scenarios. Open-ended generation is also utilised
through thematic analysis of word generations and storytelling. The experiments
revealed biases across gender and racial domains, from discriminatory
categorisations to exoticisation. Our findings indicate that the prompt-based
measure of implicit bias not only correlates with traditional embedding-based
methods but also more effectively predicts downstream behaviors, which are
crucially measured by the LLM Decision Bias. This relationship underscores the
importance of relative, rather than absolute, evaluations in assessing implicit
biases, reflecting psychological insights into human bias assessment. This
research contributes to the broader understanding of AI ethics and provides
suggestions for continually assessing and mitigating biases in advanced AI
systems, emphasising the need for more qualitative and downstream focus. | The African Woman is Rhythmic and Soulful: Evaluation of Open-ended Generation for Implicit Biases: This study investigates the subtle and often concealed biases present in
Large Language Models (LLMs), which, despite passing explicit bias tests, can
still exhibit implicit biases akin to those observed in humans who profess
egalitarian beliefs yet demonstrate underlying prejudices. The challenge of
measuring such biases is exacerbated as LLMs become increasingly proprietary,
restricting access to their internal mechanisms such as embeddings, which are
crucial for applying traditional bias measures. To tackle these issues, this
study introduces innovative measures of bias inspired by psychological
methodologies: the LLM Implicit Association Test (IAT) Bias and the LLM
Decision Bias. The LLM IAT Bias is a prompt-based method designed to unearth
implicit biases by simulating the well-known psychological IAT but adapted for
use with LLMs. The LLM Decision Bias measure is developed to detect subtle
discrimination in decision-making tasks, focusing on how LLMs choose between
individuals in various scenarios. Open-ended generation is also utilised
through thematic analysis of word generations and storytelling. The experiments
revealed biases across gender and racial domains, from discriminatory
categorisations to exoticisation. Our findings indicate that the prompt-based
measure of implicit bias not only correlates with traditional embedding-based
methods but also more effectively predicts downstream behaviors, which are
crucially measured by the LLM Decision Bias. This relationship underscores the
importance of relative, rather than absolute, evaluations in assessing implicit
biases, reflecting psychological insights into human bias assessment. This
research contributes to the broader understanding of AI ethics and provides
suggestions for continually assessing and mitigating biases in advanced AI
systems, emphasising the need for more qualitative and downstream focus. | [
0.0464289896,
0.0889431685,
-0.0497772917,
0.0278775636,
-0.0173632614,
0.037292596,
0.0514516532,
-0.020009635,
0.0472729616,
-0.0269374084,
-0.0445598923,
-0.0218288954,
0.0337128863,
-0.0032544751,
-0.001588696,
0.0144176986,
0.0275089424,
0.0631136224,
0.06876719,
-0.0226563849,
-0.0136790341,
0.0537492223,
0.0254174359,
0.0525788851,
-0.0110929301,
-0.0061120614,
0.0275818426,
-0.0262830406,
-0.0038584229,
-0.0146109713,
-0.0032000879,
0.0559672639,
0.0083899181,
0.0315261669,
0.0000020568,
-0.08909899,
0.0183480103,
-0.0201853588,
0.0064063906,
-0.0028922798,
0.0246644113,
0.0258174911,
0.0184150115,
-0.0100837592,
-0.0509490594,
0.0366298035,
0.0333989523,
0.0131037924,
0.0095291687,
0.0174499266,
-0.0006988344,
0.0123373922,
-0.0201955996,
-0.0150131071,
-0.0001146747,
-0.0125118857,
0.0530781411,
-0.0575735942,
-0.0648328364,
-0.0328815244,
-0.0387625247,
-0.0079734148,
0.0158795081,
0.0115238857,
0.0163772609,
-0.0013500096,
0.0090958187,
-0.0851051062,
-0.0060795331,
0.025972832,
0.0492540635,
0.016022129,
-0.0132077308,
-0.0089676054,
0.010310947,
0.0120612392,
-0.0065704198,
0.0526469797,
-0.0036390773,
-0.0198751707,
0.0096485028,
0.0140351132,
0.0065733055,
0.0763281584,
0.0305227693,
0.0871805549,
0.003112962,
-0.0084753474,
0.0352944396,
0.0157618616,
0.037622124,
-0.0640418231,
0.0018104265,
0.0017212968,
-0.0280226022,
0.0171568785,
-0.0021822262,
0.0346120596,
0.0197757464,
-0.0447287671,
0.0433478281,
0.0497978553,
-0.0141912876,
-0.0184799172,
-0.0009548813,
0.0356596187,
0.0060548303,
0.0037207755,
-0.0161878299,
0.0188113339,
0.0401255041,
-0.0449785031,
0.0145758232,
-0.0151352081,
0.0147417169,
0.0173867587,
-0.0330816582,
-0.0310793743,
-0.0934045985,
-0.0160409417,
-0.0401859581,
0.0310145859,
-0.0064831856,
0.0223599672,
-0.0416083708,
-0.042247612,
-0.0615602508,
0.0528950319,
-0.0301223099,
-0.0677226484,
0.0154182073,
-0.0141810374,
-0.0178043768,
-0.0196131971,
0.0026158991,
0.0638962984,
0.0023178326,
-0.0218979493,
-0.0394050032,
-0.0346304141,
-0.0201885644,
-0.0660589263,
-0.0246452577,
-0.0095857559,
0.0165068228,
0.0117050074,
0.0149404993,
-0.0557779819,
0.0036903557,
0.0200176146,
-0.0371885635,
0.0405378789,
0.0497399494,
0.014723896,
0.0549520031,
0.0426342338,
-0.0154158548,
0.0654776022,
0.0483486243,
0.037927296,
0.031336315,
0.0097546512,
-0.0225364715,
-0.0064031337,
0.0072361664,
0.0193906613,
-0.0565372929,
0.0155990133,
-0.0431580693,
0.0366305485,
0.0726708099,
0.0423474647,
-0.00759556,
-0.0287166983,
0.040346954,
0.0680590644,
-0.0161027648,
0.0513843372,
0.0908859596,
-0.0108606713,
-0.0019363293,
0.0256238207,
-0.0571658015,
-0.0060680662,
0.0214030202,
-0.0643123761,
0.0261723958,
0.0379169174,
-0.0127224158,
-0.0023776568,
0.0008954461,
0.0207924321,
0.0482607149,
0.0069074649,
-0.0341542289,
0.0160981175,
0.003858713,
-0.0182058755,
0.048572246,
-0.0199920572,
0.006806023,
-0.0765143558,
0.0546578579,
0.0454297997,
-0.0209434479,
0.0160491094,
0.0315604322,
-0.0225348808,
-0.066082105,
0.0648426116,
0.0561189279,
-0.0317692347,
0.0004290498,
-0.0178485662,
0.0043605487,
0.006506457,
0.022856066,
0.0552290976,
-0.0164275747,
0.0616948493,
0.0214115754,
-0.0059570656,
-0.03996877,
0.0405701324,
-0.0372038148,
-0.0353051461,
-0.0105433892,
0.0032865182,
0.0491206162,
0.0296229329,
-0.025965808,
0.0050977846,
-0.0270090997,
0.0310639329,
-0.0245291479,
0.0450961143,
-0.0954187065,
0.0408176295,
-0.0219812803,
-0.0565574802,
-0.0227258839,
0.0150376484,
0.0354244784,
0.0342913754,
0.0576957501,
0.0015463344,
0.019593602,
-0.0488237366,
0.0000415992,
-0.0635608584,
0.0177503098,
-0.0173922814,
0.0008343675,
-0.0172236394,
-0.0094129397,
0.0315487683,
-0.0269520413,
0.0401730426,
-0.0017079023,
-0.0196317881,
0.031753432,
0.0155542586,
-0.0097265318,
0.0122103579,
-0.0209698267,
-0.0577608086,
-0.0117077893,
-0.123730354,
-0.0102156484,
0.01936589,
-0.0390668511,
-0.0426170565,
0.0059320773,
-0.0420732871,
0.0147749623,
-0.0132552078,
-0.0035198471,
0.0075326157,
0.0687379614,
-0.0359815471,
-0.017021101,
-0.022624027,
-0.017039746,
0.0022164711,
-0.0367249399,
0.0596659593,
0.0456875898,
0.0540871657,
-0.0351585895,
-0.0314856954,
-0.0670976564,
-0.0235487297,
0.0049368059,
-0.01794824,
0.0359360948,
0.0546333566,
0.0185589306,
0.0428174175,
0.0372192524,
0.0491439663,
0.0819267109,
-0.0219005905,
-0.0382308885,
-0.024124492,
0.0062379399,
0.0238385685,
0.0145696001,
-0.0755669847,
-0.0360080637,
0.0507523976,
0.0655960441,
-0.0272732601,
-0.0467767343,
0.0942167267,
-0.0676808506,
-0.0890764967,
0.0122953001,
-0.0891336426,
-0.0219375808,
0.0439947098,
-0.0336377732,
-0.0779791996,
0.0575990081,
0.0264128838,
0.0366697349,
0.0047040484,
0.0167364348,
-0.0386817791,
0.0470863469,
-0.0294627473,
0.0419302322,
0.0162601508,
0.0116806505,
-0.0571299121,
-0.0281706061,
0.0071162544,
-0.024883138,
0.0297145508,
-0.0124222301,
-0.0024898255,
0.0131202368,
-0.0140296994,
-0.0462682918,
-0.0507493429,
-0.026683297,
-0.0061091441,
0.0083183758,
0.0006841383,
0.0283054113,
-0.0059595401,
0.0080142822,
-0.0118248304,
-0.0166059081,
-0.0139001021,
0.0336096957,
-0.0331946462,
0.0309343822,
-0.0093745049,
0.0591765232,
-0.0012167377,
0.0263456069,
-0.004271023,
-0.0602758564,
0.0571689047,
-0.0031199839,
0.052433446,
0.0171332043,
-0.0229182877,
0.017052466,
0.013035642,
0.0143769616,
-0.0040768073,
0.0212556198,
0.0906289443,
0.0238848925,
-0.0779280439,
0.0537554733,
-0.0346864536,
-0.0087914234,
0.0327150896,
-0.0094355633,
-0.0844592154,
0.0200798027,
0.0220835935,
-0.0005836059,
-0.0812101066,
-0.0786729828,
-0.0229940824,
-0.0961856768,
0.0314498618,
-0.0050658979,
-0.0054180855,
-0.0096851029,
-0.0183923524,
0.0227774307,
0.0134114577,
0.0187023133,
0.006651286,
0.0138961114,
0.0178335961,
-0.0117365643,
-0.0181852598,
-0.0104471352,
0.0336050615,
-0.039874617,
0.0448862761,
0.0044446806,
0.0654113069,
-0.0051891538,
-0.0106628602,
0.01156253,
-0.0272230785,
-0.0124296993,
-0.0354730077,
0.0020115131,
-0.0215119068,
0.0009303809,
-0.0229675658,
0.0171434525,
0.046357125,
-0.0046807439,
0.0168469772,
0.048840519,
-0.0011459406,
-0.0581249855,
-0.0416144021,
0.0028543428,
0.009598962,
0.0847232193,
0.0237062499,
-0.04872372,
0.0074074753,
-0.0174440537,
0.0207696464,
0.0482491888,
-0.0828716308,
0.0241413675,
0.0055741295,
-0.016651867,
-0.0300664045,
-0.086169064,
-0.0048667202,
-0.0234327968,
0.0504216664,
-0.0688065439,
-0.0130687803,
-0.0406748801,
-0.0585943796,
0.019181326,
0.0171826463,
0.0451304205,
0.0677274242,
-0.0176838208,
-0.0137712313,
-0.0517764203,
0.0035262234,
0.0220952276,
-0.0022000098,
-0.0312855765,
0.0791510865,
0.0087064896,
0.0190110132,
0.0369399562,
0.0249234028,
-0.0325621478,
0.0526581705,
-0.0101513797,
-0.0184636153,
0.0693695396,
-0.0135619035,
0.0502673946,
-0.0093553076,
0.038815584,
-0.0220364518,
0.058637023,
0.0329936855,
-0.0115176272,
0.0246835724,
-0.0417254306,
0.008633988,
-0.0176685471,
-0.0163043477,
-0.0803066194,
0.0061301035,
-0.0658003539,
-0.0543207303,
-0.0112969913,
-0.0587079786,
-0.0085246153,
-0.0579804853,
0.0396266095,
0.0316168964,
-0.0605685562,
-0.0571776368,
-0.0715681911,
0.0027368134,
-0.0074887341,
0.0301599428,
0.0588852167,
0.0473486707,
-0.0207243394,
0.0295875482,
-0.0256288014,
0.0168176796,
-0.0769688487,
0.0243820231,
0.0264454018,
0.0618562736,
0.0307200141,
-0.0066200285,
-0.0092656882,
0.0105129303,
-0.0161887128,
-0.014370705,
0.0077089393,
-0.0315632708,
-0.0038399594,
-0.0659541562,
0.0167661179,
0.0010037067,
0.0095730359,
0.01453014,
-0.0259580072,
-0.0233505294,
-0.0521132834,
0.0182862617,
-0.0004402833,
-0.0184766632,
0.0480971597,
0.0095107201,
-0.0111517934,
0.0652110055,
-0.0282775071,
-0.0443931445,
-0.0060276873,
-0.0465082377,
0.065659456,
-0.0329869427,
-0.0032715872,
-0.0107680243,
-0.0945089236,
-0.045512557,
-0.007688493,
-0.0342824049,
0.0361327305,
-0.028534336,
0.0055100191,
0.0585010201,
-0.0193516575,
-0.0163089521,
-0.0003300473,
-0.0247485116,
-0.0537739657,
-0.0057616225,
-0.0398110263,
-6.070221236e-33,
-0.0255714078,
-0.0408583097,
-0.0136408051,
-0.0481475592,
-0.083445929,
0.0126309283,
-0.0213533156,
0.0071309591,
-0.0067668636,
0.0252203997,
0.0022494441,
0.0115502626,
0.0035775614,
-0.0426028818,
0.0396083333,
0.02151962,
0.0327538475,
-0.0005910826,
-0.0317437313,
-0.030219974,
-0.025733877,
-0.0060356171,
-0.0013682273,
-0.0555679388,
0.0651124418,
0.0146687198,
-0.0296629295,
-0.0141253015,
-0.0251654293,
-0.0023776109,
-0.0439985394,
0.0546650365,
0.0426546708,
0.0154448533,
0.0298326649,
0.0636122748,
0.0008510049,
-0.0476240069,
0.0460872129,
0.0058785309,
0.0125142941,
-0.0364753008,
-0.0031013461,
0.0100712264,
-0.0694747269,
0.0004861539,
0.0306033846,
-0.0236460082,
0.0844608992,
0.0013564614,
-0.0697923452,
-0.0080503449,
-0.0295018833,
0.0243517365,
-0.015374911,
0.0044872942,
-0.0132642277,
-0.0245331246,
-0.019550968,
0.0212458819,
-0.0060214866,
-0.0345523134,
0.0298574585,
0.0175317898,
0.008748956,
0.0660992563,
0.0667584613,
0.0157069396,
-0.0321792997,
-0.035454601,
0.0294385385,
-0.0335886255,
-0.0035322581,
0.0284131598,
0.0172562841,
-0.0168250091,
0.015097185,
-0.0293764155,
0.0552714504,
0.0181704275,
0.0390431806,
-0.0135565074,
-0.0358438678,
-0.0617169589,
-0.0468525551,
-0.0981155783,
-0.0304165669,
-0.0365177542,
0.0511944741,
-0.0260269344,
0.0010060008,
0.0091030523,
0.0162354205,
-0.0245740116,
0.0125334281,
-0.015097118,
-0.0403996818,
-0.0233915467,
0.0265356302,
-0.004281994,
-0.0299343672,
0.0160648189,
0.0257889517,
0.0349650383,
0.0531568155,
0.0124639766,
-0.0377832241,
0.01518392,
-0.0427587964,
-0.0005932185,
0.0005555949,
-0.013433286,
0.0184394568,
-0.0126973316,
0.0228264965,
0.0485084951,
-0.0215847827,
-0.0047585256,
0.0461196899,
0.0260903183,
-0.0352226011,
0.003485976,
-0.0254635867,
0.0436089002,
-0.0375952758,
-0.0067343363,
0.0108565344,
0.0224035941,
0.0247943942,
-0.0592963248,
-0.0169227868,
-0.0197004173,
2.701e-7,
-0.0482526124,
0.0349849313,
-0.0127418861,
0.0233370718,
0.0111009218,
0.0195856001,
0.0369461291,
0.0225201976,
0.0261066407,
-0.0019591653,
0.004334101,
0.0340523832,
0.0205739047,
0.0646990538,
-0.0214852598,
0.0259074364,
-0.0725270361,
0.0173526797,
-0.051203467,
-0.002059771,
-0.0061912131,
0.0286582187,
0.026873406,
-0.0099540856,
-0.0562668629,
-0.005967373,
0.0115101142,
-0.0245034881,
0.0395692438,
0.0090302629,
-0.0038756414,
0.000741375,
0.0350243524,
0.0190263148,
0.0398168564,
0.0340525731,
0.0305977445,
0.018614782,
-0.0236468613,
0.0213990137,
-0.0036625681,
0.0240529831,
-0.025880551,
-0.0586604476,
0.0481305793,
0.0216844231,
-0.0611646585,
-0.0314184614,
-0.0053719236,
-0.0225263201,
0.0513378382,
-0.0365955792,
-0.0119443731,
0.0052963006,
0.0135697704,
0.0020930574,
0.0193030089,
-0.0553908758,
-0.0069560516,
-0.0359002426,
-0.0338215642,
-0.0476818755,
-0.0073257694,
0.0466930047,
0.0021262418,
-0.050647933,
0.0548754856,
2.333166646e-34,
0.0107629197,
0.0088212024,
0.0323002338,
-0.0145547986,
0.0281951334,
0.0251358319,
0.0262605473,
-0.0012659431,
0.0741596818,
-0.0282690562,
-0.0174300186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01264v1 | SignCLIP: Connecting Text and Sign Language by Contrastive Learning | 2024-07-01T13:17:35 | 2024-07-01T13:17:35 | Zifan Jiang, Gerard Sant, Amit Moryossef, Mathias Müller, Rico Sennrich, Sarah Ebling | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present SignCLIP, which re-purposes CLIP (Contrastive Language-Image
Pretraining) to project spoken language text and sign language videos, two
classes of natural languages of distinct modalities, into the same space.
SignCLIP is an efficient method of learning useful visual representations for
sign language processing from large-scale, multilingual video-text pairs,
without directly optimizing for a specific task or sign language which is often
of limited size.
We pretrain SignCLIP on Spreadthesign, a prominent sign language dictionary
consisting of ~500 thousand video clips in up to 44 sign languages, and
evaluate it with various downstream datasets. SignCLIP discerns in-domain
signing with notable text-to-video/video-to-text retrieval accuracy. It also
performs competitively for out-of-domain downstream tasks such as isolated sign
language recognition upon essential few-shot prompting or fine-tuning.
We analyze the latent space formed by the spoken language text and sign
language poses, which provides additional linguistic insights. Our code and
models are openly available. | SignCLIP: Connecting Text and Sign Language by Contrastive Learning: We present SignCLIP, which re-purposes CLIP (Contrastive Language-Image
Pretraining) to project spoken language text and sign language videos, two
classes of natural languages of distinct modalities, into the same space.
SignCLIP is an efficient method of learning useful visual representations for
sign language processing from large-scale, multilingual video-text pairs,
without directly optimizing for a specific task or sign language which is often
of limited size.
We pretrain SignCLIP on Spreadthesign, a prominent sign language dictionary
consisting of ~500 thousand video clips in up to 44 sign languages, and
evaluate it with various downstream datasets. SignCLIP discerns in-domain
signing with notable text-to-video/video-to-text retrieval accuracy. It also
performs competitively for out-of-domain downstream tasks such as isolated sign
language recognition upon essential few-shot prompting or fine-tuning.
We analyze the latent space formed by the spoken language text and sign
language poses, which provides additional linguistic insights. Our code and
models are openly available. | [
-0.0442105234,
0.0456103086,
-0.0050793295,
0.0444161296,
-0.0112172943,
0.0304004382,
0.0037106462,
-0.0006010652,
0.0407244489,
-0.0501469672,
-0.0427128598,
-0.0408085026,
0.0147291468,
0.0346085057,
0.0325746648,
-0.1027281433,
0.0188506562,
-0.0371293873,
-0.0285649616,
-0.0091393981,
0.0576736517,
0.012563468,
-0.0433736481,
0.0231541265,
-0.0649409145,
-0.0153599204,
0.0109510794,
0.0164247248,
0.0525513738,
-0.0239443947,
-0.0431289934,
0.0224287957,
0.0831861869,
-0.0302461497,
0.0000019498,
0.0065825125,
0.02707888,
0.0137646236,
0.0407355465,
0.0115757268,
0.0406819433,
-0.0812501609,
-0.0112144314,
0.0412624218,
-0.0328162573,
-0.0949911401,
0.0480135195,
0.0470800772,
0.0159703568,
0.0125718592,
-0.0331746638,
0.0077904272,
0.028175192,
-0.0285167824,
-0.0164551139,
0.0315319449,
-0.0031690267,
-0.0257540885,
0.0157969892,
-0.0119400611,
-0.0486135483,
0.0834811479,
0.0202197358,
-0.0414943509,
-0.0504324213,
0.0442547388,
-0.0400808938,
-0.0081173303,
-0.0255861674,
0.0414564051,
-0.0317094438,
0.011086355,
-0.0002798772,
-0.0454863533,
0.0059615141,
0.0428697877,
0.0060121045,
0.0282194316,
0.0331042819,
0.0046021189,
-0.0087651946,
0.0292122699,
0.036168009,
-0.0225003734,
0.0140238684,
-0.0394933857,
0.0478051901,
0.0325256325,
-0.0010740918,
-0.0052765412,
0.0169977173,
-0.040037591,
0.0229797419,
-0.0287556089,
-0.0119126067,
-0.02119115,
-0.0407684669,
-0.0294274818,
-0.0305400863,
-0.0063587348,
-0.0172564741,
0.0399486795,
-0.0656311885,
0.0450831652,
0.0603884459,
0.0297575574,
-0.0421518125,
0.0208804701,
-0.0227033738,
0.0058098943,
0.0109359231,
0.0103068342,
-0.0252371915,
-0.0466192886,
-0.0362659879,
-0.0475192554,
0.0333155505,
-0.0241410844,
-0.012371419,
-0.0486063845,
0.0340722725,
0.0308323167,
0.0164787266,
-0.0082771853,
0.0145150265,
0.0486903824,
-0.0066821282,
0.0707703456,
-0.0460062362,
-0.0570166931,
-0.0077369553,
0.0411429107,
0.016643526,
-0.0027256499,
0.0171606187,
0.0216193441,
-0.0618700571,
-0.0599293262,
0.0107105086,
0.044663161,
-0.0255674534,
-0.0250996221,
0.015820073,
-0.058465261,
0.0197812784,
-0.0045341309,
-0.0149310492,
-0.0749159828,
-0.0016205293,
-0.0382039659,
0.0086748712,
0.0864906311,
0.0012373463,
-0.0128918355,
0.0262996946,
0.0015158902,
-0.0434070639,
0.034025833,
0.0442196317,
0.0123014739,
0.0120186089,
0.0210467186,
-0.002723169,
0.0742230266,
-0.0104522705,
0.0249897856,
-0.0328395106,
-0.0051106042,
0.0188436154,
-0.0120703429,
-0.0101149436,
0.0490376689,
-0.0334684886,
-0.0288953967,
0.0213654302,
0.0898463055,
0.0351541303,
-0.0612915419,
0.0029993679,
0.0558824204,
-0.0093749529,
-0.0444463938,
-0.0164405033,
0.0599381067,
0.0461738668,
-0.0436476357,
-0.0078779804,
0.0361892171,
-0.0744768456,
0.0143998051,
0.0011313605,
-0.0192522202,
0.039042227,
0.0192714687,
0.0657718927,
0.0206014793,
-0.0617961399,
0.0090349512,
0.0083987489,
-0.0233344063,
0.0251474343,
-0.0152477985,
-0.0347360261,
0.006915079,
-0.0343441553,
-0.0087039564,
0.006828309,
0.0138358818,
0.0119578065,
0.0356794707,
-0.0321727693,
0.0137518942,
0.0497882888,
-0.0390377454,
-0.0291897655,
0.0274127126,
0.0088415621,
0.0184471086,
-0.0420653597,
0.067363143,
-0.0020196242,
0.0316607766,
0.0244381763,
0.0468693487,
0.0012037344,
-0.0195145886,
0.012969505,
0.016152218,
0.0355390646,
0.0218365211,
-0.031866964,
-0.028254481,
0.0176533666,
-0.0390810445,
-0.0035661412,
0.053277038,
-0.0398492962,
-0.0765376613,
0.042189464,
-0.1108812317,
-0.0043213717,
0.0319267474,
0.0031713238,
-0.0543044955,
0.0442533344,
-0.0051278118,
0.0497428626,
-0.050170809,
-0.0083497167,
0.023172576,
-0.0144765899,
0.0121746259,
0.0075206556,
-0.0184363071,
-0.0648696721,
-0.0219583977,
0.0180755127,
0.0226497743,
-0.0194228925,
-0.0044566873,
-0.0143580632,
0.0007375905,
0.0454112068,
0.0167532377,
0.0320272185,
-0.0285110325,
0.0035215099,
-0.0561542399,
0.0069387858,
-0.025280213,
0.0139604108,
-0.0072444617,
-0.0361288637,
0.0225274097,
-0.0279821735,
-0.0348588154,
-0.0352601036,
0.0209545884,
-0.0357708633,
-0.0382322222,
0.0165072065,
-0.0121300118,
-0.0129841994,
-0.0098064216,
0.0369026214,
0.0220162049,
0.0051989644,
-0.0504493564,
-0.0233021192,
0.015711952,
0.0551785044,
0.0301944725,
-0.0366969928,
-0.0230042133,
0.0393638201,
-0.0072842264,
-0.0240913182,
-0.0241210125,
0.0004501298,
0.0205991492,
0.0151043199,
-0.0208217595,
-0.0022860661,
-0.0137272272,
0.0148435086,
0.0352029465,
-0.027063163,
0.0036581957,
-0.036770761,
0.0298246928,
0.0156623423,
0.0166723989,
-0.0929554179,
-0.0462575667,
-0.0126630384,
-0.0273050927,
0.0068683475,
0.0143013867,
-0.0319168828,
-0.0310556944,
-0.025070576,
-0.0771129876,
0.0141732693,
-0.0457117334,
-0.0319921002,
0.0432101935,
-0.0068200147,
-0.0076854955,
0.0554214232,
-0.0110895885,
0.0066192178,
-0.0544680431,
-0.044193767,
-0.0547857396,
0.0142607316,
0.0088627199,
-0.0031546259,
0.0296448208,
-0.0241978392,
0.0216711499,
-0.0129690366,
-0.0285332259,
-0.0023276545,
0.001584575,
-0.0362082906,
-0.0142998928,
0.0107385926,
-0.057308007,
-0.0191620309,
-0.0266005676,
0.0100339931,
0.0351885259,
0.0266053341,
0.0262184497,
0.0005161862,
-0.0264917072,
0.0093002841,
0.000229137,
-0.0302488282,
-0.0518763661,
-0.0143858036,
0.0379161797,
-0.0203961357,
-0.0045665065,
-0.0477683209,
0.0116782263,
0.0416694395,
0.067033425,
-0.0371672176,
0.0319372229,
0.0449444242,
-0.0173264854,
0.0286329444,
0.0351781771,
-0.0005699882,
-0.0521079153,
-0.0043231864,
0.0458424129,
-0.017396206,
0.0075480095,
-0.0226807352,
-0.0733585209,
-0.08204633,
-0.0171115007,
0.010629531,
0.050596416,
0.0164799988,
-0.0458538607,
-0.029033551,
0.0270093977,
0.0155906836,
-0.0705127195,
-0.0165026262,
0.0262914933,
0.0297797211,
0.0195064303,
0.0046787169,
0.0123129217,
-0.0298111495,
-0.0004216103,
-0.0025846094,
0.0256640203,
-0.0646884739,
0.0262528881,
-0.0128105553,
0.0097730318,
0.0045938464,
0.0050997701,
0.0101403892,
-0.0965508223,
-0.0026643458,
-0.0389483385,
0.013932378,
-0.0236303471,
0.0583869256,
-0.0023312054,
-0.043782413,
-0.0111151468,
0.0771363899,
-0.0487482361,
-0.0338786654,
0.0037895241,
0.0454039574,
-0.0156901833,
0.0218925513,
-0.0101972595,
-0.0266024973,
0.0338904411,
0.0171239618,
-0.0155549953,
-0.0380631723,
0.0074975886,
0.0140513685,
0.014279265,
0.0816403031,
-0.0447744243,
-0.0158408359,
-0.0211804993,
-0.0079374351,
-0.0174063742,
0.0036998917,
0.0565475784,
0.0472765304,
-0.022528505,
0.0181576069,
0.037821386,
0.0129298642,
-0.0667617247,
0.0852409601,
-0.016142372,
0.0561172739,
-0.0561932698,
-0.04787682,
0.0000777984,
-0.0334616713,
0.0005942963,
0.0014091861,
-0.0764919445,
-0.0615885071,
-0.0226860754,
0.0571980849,
0.0115660494,
0.0389306173,
0.0179530364,
-0.0224296544,
-0.0006321574,
0.0548509993,
-0.0047107693,
0.0234792512,
0.0395423733,
-0.1010880992,
-0.0177424047,
0.0034905185,
0.0065112668,
0.0131199071,
0.0076835989,
-0.0065307813,
-0.0920963585,
-0.0037460586,
-0.0466911942,
-0.0136901867,
0.02291039,
-0.0429173969,
-0.0169712175,
-0.0766900778,
0.0195862632,
-0.0276727099,
0.0358271077,
-0.1135595217,
0.0177734382,
0.0229644943,
0.0009223357,
0.0005468789,
0.0411226712,
-0.0042771627,
0.0118258744,
0.0288826134,
0.0469422936,
0.0618778095,
0.0405779593,
0.0367657356,
0.0309836678,
0.0341889337,
0.0476776399,
-0.0067588789,
0.0061940113,
0.0137482928,
0.0427879915,
0.0391391255,
-0.0074161352,
0.0474757105,
0.0180493668,
0.0300181676,
-0.0919942632,
-0.0215990283,
0.0158697031,
0.0015901735,
0.0059830649,
0.0305780023,
-0.0291209295,
0.0169413369,
-0.0164376479,
0.0605775304,
-0.0269428082,
-0.0665801391,
0.0563435555,
-0.0111270025,
-0.0040661804,
0.0318335108,
0.0306819733,
-0.0665284544,
-0.0031902525,
-0.0270832814,
0.045096416,
-0.021027796,
-0.0240261704,
0.0284580495,
-0.0158748701,
-0.0370364264,
0.0508180484,
-0.0213707983,
-0.0560157783,
-0.007636799,
0.0101750763,
-0.0534014553,
0.0413135849,
0.0215534326,
-0.0413395241,
-0.0018774945,
-0.0036786492,
0.0055242372,
-0.0706327856,
0.001863078,
-0.0119377896,
0.000451488,
-5.506637817e-33,
-0.0228698421,
-0.0450242236,
0.0152538102,
-0.0053482647,
0.0049154032,
0.034957435,
-0.0203316864,
0.0376004577,
0.015357377,
0.0448896736,
-0.0032450175,
0.0257648323,
-0.0029387497,
0.0320790745,
-0.0034658245,
-0.0148878964,
0.0329208858,
-0.0159287993,
0.0214467794,
0.0284117125,
0.0300711803,
0.0080480548,
0.0704766065,
-0.1186704636,
-0.0152739901,
-0.0314627178,
-0.0698869228,
0.0199094918,
0.0175380539,
0.0083657652,
-0.0256662462,
-0.0256175306,
-0.0223103166,
-0.0105670439,
-0.0062985625,
0.0390417539,
-0.0180882011,
-0.004716537,
-0.0243502632,
0.0688181967,
-0.0880741552,
0.0494276807,
-0.0134096304,
-0.0107513107,
-0.0353569016,
-0.0104961628,
0.029947672,
-0.0178956632,
0.0317887738,
-0.0090883058,
-0.009284812,
0.0327125713,
-0.006855607,
-0.0367021263,
0.0415819474,
-0.0075014783,
0.0084879538,
-0.0403937958,
-0.0567669012,
0.0214404743,
0.0060962853,
-0.021468956,
0.0838100165,
-0.0038573269,
0.0368375704,
0.0552980825,
0.0092323627,
-0.0923251957,
0.0775895268,
-0.0683020204,
0.0702230334,
0.0367783681,
0.0208645482,
0.0996892825,
0.0515549444,
-0.0311983284,
-0.0236590989,
-0.0070041828,
0.0344905257,
0.0162918791,
-0.0589567199,
0.0360889509,
0.0331646986,
-0.0030404297,
-0.0419995971,
0.0002082766,
0.0076932297,
-0.032371074,
0.032505203,
0.0304701459,
0.012715051,
0.0240029376,
0.0997847915,
-0.0153854499,
-0.023276696,
0.0365090482,
-0.0070008039,
0.0190343335,
0.0199122336,
0.0196502339,
-0.0680920854,
-0.0202062521,
0.0721912086,
-0.0078959251,
0.0253345594,
0.0233483948,
0.0110964021,
0.0612069145,
-0.0449406803,
0.0076203011,
0.0129668098,
0.0301241651,
0.0176736675,
0.0026361367,
0.0606185272,
-0.0057744789,
-0.0371416807,
0.0770285055,
-0.003313618,
-0.0059451708,
-0.0047825528,
0.0186823532,
-0.0155498395,
0.0257421583,
-0.0387171693,
0.0276839938,
-0.0257472713,
-0.0494998395,
0.0753397271,
-0.0717088804,
0.004455504,
0.0367698744,
2.631e-7,
0.0266002286,
0.0025958854,
-0.0067225359,
0.0408025235,
0.0266912822,
0.0604053624,
-0.0300800204,
0.017487701,
0.0327409469,
-0.0006823902,
0.0059593944,
0.0074274861,
0.0388254225,
0.035636656,
-0.0273225531,
0.0599535555,
-0.0121385455,
-0.0111499755,
-0.0101270471,
0.0094489744,
0.0538461357,
0.0843196064,
0.019077599,
-0.011899,
0.0254963879,
-0.0695571527,
0.0757184252,
-0.0403585956,
0.0252203196,
-0.0598109402,
-0.0007023094,
-0.0292872991,
-0.0392447449,
-0.0005957062,
-0.0148763098,
0.0135304863,
0.0166729651,
0.0250504017,
-0.0499044545,
-0.0026840873,
-0.0108845932,
0.0250429045,
-0.0725058466,
0.0243680291,
0.0677274987,
-0.0549531728,
0.0094758207,
-0.0540116504,
-0.0429654792,
-0.0066079772,
0.0179554597,
0.0052583367,
0.0304377917,
0.0650994629,
0.0174129885,
-0.03929355,
-0.0203407779,
-0.0791168362,
-0.0162524041,
-0.0099422894,
-0.006991575,
0.0436644331,
-0.0306366608,
0.0254307911,
-0.011401372,
-0.0343035348,
-0.0521686859,
1.655387394e-34,
0.0111765089,
-0.0000187297,
0.0098248897,
0.0009259195,
-0.0308455136,
-0.0155745894,
0.0275139175,
0.0226685777,
0.0152173545,
-0.0081566758,
-0.0128011098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01257v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01257v2 | uDistil-Whisper: Label-Free Data Filtering for Knowledge Distillation via Large-Scale Pseudo Labelling | 2024-07-01T13:07:01 | 2024-07-03T09:54:08 | Abdul Waheed, Karima Kadaoui, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent work on distilling Whisper's knowledge into small models using
pseudo-labels shows promising performance while reducing the size by up to
50\%. This results in small, efficient, and dedicated models. However, a
critical step of distillation from pseudo-labels involves filtering
high-quality predictions and using only those during training. This step
requires ground truth to compare and filter bad examples making the whole
process supervised. In addition to that, the distillation process requires a
large amount of data thereby limiting the ability to distil models in
low-resource settings. To address this challenge, we propose an unsupervised or
label-free framework for distillation, thus eliminating the requirement for
labeled data altogether. Through experimentation, we show that our
best-distilled models outperform the teacher model by 5-7 points in terms of
WER. Additionally, our models are on par with or better than similar supervised
data filtering setup. When we scale the data, our models significantly
outperform all zero-shot and supervised models. We demonstrate that it is
possible to distill large Whisper models into relatively small models without
using any labeled data. Our distilled models are 25-50\% more compute and
memory efficient while maintaining performance equal to or better than the
teacher model. | uDistil-Whisper: Label-Free Data Filtering for Knowledge Distillation via Large-Scale Pseudo Labelling: Recent work on distilling Whisper's knowledge into small models using
pseudo-labels shows promising performance while reducing the size by up to
50\%. This results in small, efficient, and dedicated models. However, a
critical step of distillation from pseudo-labels involves filtering
high-quality predictions and using only those during training. This step
requires ground truth to compare and filter bad examples making the whole
process supervised. In addition to that, the distillation process requires a
large amount of data thereby limiting the ability to distil models in
low-resource settings. To address this challenge, we propose an unsupervised or
label-free framework for distillation, thus eliminating the requirement for
labeled data altogether. Through experimentation, we show that our
best-distilled models outperform the teacher model by 5-7 points in terms of
WER. Additionally, our models are on par with or better than similar supervised
data filtering setup. When we scale the data, our models significantly
outperform all zero-shot and supervised models. We demonstrate that it is
possible to distill large Whisper models into relatively small models without
using any labeled data. Our distilled models are 25-50\% more compute and
memory efficient while maintaining performance equal to or better than the
teacher model. | [
0.0233004019,
0.0822441652,
0.0180330314,
0.015676884,
0.0230729431,
0.0175731853,
0.050398238,
0.0127790431,
0.0164540447,
0.0074031642,
-0.038209334,
0.0351214223,
-0.0617093854,
0.0361550041,
0.0245941598,
-0.086758852,
0.0172439683,
-0.0482928567,
0.0177723914,
-0.0096810833,
-0.0035071883,
-0.0080439653,
-0.0003677518,
0.0062191691,
-0.0225448776,
-0.0366797112,
-0.0369529165,
0.019207105,
0.0170769002,
0.0233512856,
0.0159516614,
0.0187309589,
0.0217545517,
0.0431399234,
0.0000022298,
-0.0068611191,
-0.0234488193,
0.0111474954,
-0.0494473055,
0.0162124541,
-0.0139703993,
0.0179007165,
0.0361244902,
-0.0034551092,
-0.0284419321,
-0.0420503579,
0.0287419278,
0.052385807,
0.0903108492,
0.0722046345,
-0.0054590991,
-0.0307465326,
0.0133060552,
-0.0275425967,
0.0388681553,
-0.0565106906,
0.0313893631,
-0.0221026298,
-0.0610318147,
0.0038382851,
-0.0132030062,
0.0504563637,
0.0390454307,
0.0062043755,
0.0163784716,
0.0212453194,
-0.0660093054,
-0.0403875709,
0.0053838678,
0.0770047903,
-0.0172823854,
-0.0369209684,
0.0601767339,
0.0019550757,
-0.0076236748,
-0.0498126149,
-0.0318050869,
-0.0232031383,
-0.0104132975,
0.0291026384,
-0.0334013663,
0.0474945717,
0.0495136082,
-0.0106440317,
0.0020910602,
0.0381939448,
-0.0353787132,
-0.0279680528,
0.0295428261,
-0.0179674253,
-0.0134411491,
-0.0528150052,
0.0156957172,
0.0120989783,
0.0087811034,
0.0006189247,
-0.044852078,
-0.0110595813,
-0.0241253674,
0.0016125594,
0.037139006,
0.000346103,
-0.0003014252,
0.0561299548,
0.0104244202,
0.0053063161,
0.0169733241,
0.0657001436,
-0.0523081496,
0.0059725344,
-0.0817285776,
0.0238920171,
-0.0422310717,
0.0763810128,
-0.0417252369,
0.0131135201,
-0.0193036906,
-0.0377824828,
-0.0641014948,
0.0050871959,
0.0645369589,
0.0365222804,
-0.0300782453,
-0.0016549526,
0.0214116648,
0.0446951874,
-0.0260491651,
-0.0088921441,
0.0210094266,
-0.0125606041,
-0.0085194493,
0.0028423357,
0.0053178389,
0.0135183604,
0.014522667,
0.0436609462,
-0.0188373905,
-0.0153799206,
-0.0533031784,
-0.0462010764,
0.0003260133,
-0.0759843066,
-0.0177661143,
-0.0329581946,
0.051481057,
-0.0399224721,
0.029314924,
-0.0833010674,
-0.002239855,
-0.0174931325,
-0.0460497178,
0.054625541,
-0.0246162284,
-0.0067257662,
-0.0170664005,
0.0510248467,
-0.0511371121,
0.056624528,
0.0092991013,
0.0291643254,
0.0235404037,
-0.0008250248,
-0.0047806678,
0.0064519173,
0.0770289972,
0.0186437573,
-0.0279095601,
0.0036762119,
0.0006658883,
-0.0147443805,
0.0217693951,
0.0461827032,
-0.0356543735,
-0.0273527037,
0.0512480028,
-0.0182480756,
0.0254276525,
0.0148170348,
0.0305543505,
0.0317572281,
0.0101834955,
0.0094005195,
-0.0510650128,
-0.0037067842,
-0.0177133214,
-0.0049258042,
0.0443489403,
0.0082500605,
-0.0758920908,
-0.0737276152,
0.0288745407,
-0.0038585437,
-0.0075363573,
0.0553830341,
0.0440659411,
0.0342368819,
0.002130779,
0.0797410458,
0.0855278373,
-0.0204096939,
0.000514766,
-0.0534995385,
0.0227099247,
0.0294719078,
0.011976881,
-0.0591613874,
0.0167563409,
-0.0217184741,
0.0664037317,
-0.0064740167,
0.0058714752,
-0.0327370018,
0.0334821753,
-0.0445725583,
-0.0366323814,
0.0108766174,
0.0329732932,
-0.0228424277,
0.0501686074,
0.0116033172,
0.0130926697,
-0.0925118327,
-0.0432428308,
0.0085123042,
-0.0178801809,
-0.0586172082,
-0.0020684316,
0.0132035632,
0.0332124755,
0.000858605,
-0.017432183,
-0.0271386951,
0.0311234891,
-0.0197138395,
0.005050391,
-0.0784142762,
-0.0234752987,
-0.0495704301,
0.0299153961,
-0.0162411071,
0.0079723662,
0.0208783895,
-0.0739138797,
-0.0342471153,
-0.0200413521,
0.0256737806,
0.0698442236,
-0.0118688354,
-0.0004624345,
0.0161330979,
-0.0358447954,
-0.0020509316,
0.0300056953,
-0.0177501105,
-0.0277914833,
-0.0546545573,
-0.0157341883,
-0.0097633796,
0.0217990447,
-0.036687281,
0.0330850631,
-0.0326595344,
0.023830153,
-0.0087354574,
-0.0109040104,
-0.0288612805,
-0.0086103724,
-0.0450495332,
-0.0031323454,
-0.0322003663,
-0.0209952239,
0.0086435499,
0.0192271359,
0.0304136034,
-0.026137799,
-0.0142902937,
0.0023734232,
-0.0557614341,
-0.0043178694,
-0.0388126038,
0.0103495019,
0.0181345362,
-0.019784335,
-0.0268990584,
0.0188866984,
0.0360887423,
-0.025526464,
-0.0070223124,
-0.0317363925,
0.0487248003,
-0.0470492728,
0.0306351352,
-0.0039112102,
-0.0178662986,
-0.0091629392,
-0.0042656171,
-0.0346566141,
0.0375975482,
-0.0393472686,
0.037243288,
0.0297000855,
0.0095273564,
-0.0611572117,
0.0257673692,
-0.0108878175,
0.0110899527,
-0.0229917634,
0.0071791722,
-0.016460428,
0.0676973611,
-0.0045344657,
-0.0075815045,
-0.0379949659,
0.0282922853,
-0.0042465287,
-0.0800344422,
-0.0542336069,
0.0275105517,
0.010271823,
-0.0039319182,
-0.0360166505,
-0.0231438018,
0.0637315363,
0.0190069899,
-0.0088640116,
-0.0299818292,
-0.0678613409,
0.009287741,
0.0256561637,
-0.0067962925,
0.02966417,
0.0227675419,
0.0152839851,
-0.0311682709,
-0.0478978492,
0.0069466266,
-0.0221813899,
0.0099251382,
-0.0589293055,
0.0059636198,
0.0189167764,
-0.0272813346,
-0.0545252413,
-0.028010847,
-0.0039579584,
0.0183594115,
-0.0185015425,
-0.0128996959,
-0.0546000265,
0.0175464191,
0.0044618854,
0.071008049,
0.0215532482,
-0.0089401342,
-0.0217472166,
0.0165254809,
0.0364497267,
-0.057798963,
-0.0183575582,
-0.0163396709,
0.0574463867,
0.0801971778,
0.0720999688,
-0.0168466736,
-0.01542415,
0.0128648672,
0.0000774046,
-0.0117089832,
-0.0133169806,
0.0276166014,
0.0518499911,
-0.0468872748,
-0.0291479081,
0.0796400532,
0.0078033144,
-0.0157038569,
-0.000226339,
0.0696172342,
0.0509968996,
0.0139527237,
-0.0091213202,
-0.0235511903,
-0.0308342241,
0.013093615,
0.0347717665,
0.0335651785,
-0.0469521172,
0.0046530673,
-0.0580681227,
0.0344520174,
0.032931637,
-0.0357642733,
-0.0155892596,
-0.0205962919,
-0.0050372505,
-0.0298376065,
-0.0296403412,
-0.0156743806,
-0.0022473403,
0.0008269373,
0.0352351516,
-0.0070062475,
-0.0403440706,
0.0238797422,
-0.0395171717,
0.0186017957,
0.0404253043,
0.0163480714,
0.0272867866,
-0.0764456168,
-0.0047087432,
-0.0149783082,
-0.0325908661,
-0.0108294301,
0.1074810773,
-0.0123077435,
-0.0092225829,
-0.0001358188,
0.0579580329,
-0.036635492,
-0.0163955223,
0.0213567801,
0.0549683943,
0.0120252129,
-0.0664129555,
-0.0032325473,
-0.0195068829,
0.0205742139,
0.0951931104,
0.0221505668,
-0.0218800586,
-0.0064735333,
-0.0066301441,
-0.0146636488,
0.0104911933,
-0.0106468899,
0.0211279374,
-0.0443499684,
-0.0328646079,
-0.0290114544,
-0.0065746997,
0.0388797559,
0.0617079288,
-0.0116519602,
-0.0121200886,
0.0556075089,
0.0009572461,
-0.0577587709,
-0.0149886273,
-0.0401707701,
-0.0151516162,
-0.0097266212,
-0.0706803128,
0.0370006412,
0.0344910137,
-0.0310380906,
0.0056773308,
-0.1149984524,
-0.0647432059,
0.009325562,
0.051234059,
0.0239907969,
0.0749506727,
-0.0044366042,
-0.033040341,
0.1009470671,
0.0531979837,
-0.0203176849,
0.009929155,
0.0597889125,
-0.0370086692,
0.0364846401,
0.0483581163,
-0.0409998521,
0.0270452481,
0.0565411672,
-0.0049330597,
-0.1034028009,
0.043161083,
0.0118699828,
-0.0153520824,
0.061798811,
0.0277976003,
-0.0005989851,
-0.0135715716,
0.0095147621,
0.0238772668,
-0.0199578926,
-0.0525051504,
0.0249299593,
0.0355380811,
0.0181018226,
-0.0050661312,
0.0294200126,
0.0144203212,
-0.0003705029,
-0.0313739181,
-0.0335232392,
-0.0250137597,
-0.0170859173,
0.059874028,
0.004392724,
-0.0063339667,
0.0332444757,
0.0392435864,
0.0246691629,
0.0031851341,
-0.0237687714,
0.0339847207,
0.0536061265,
-0.0208471771,
-0.0030429545,
-0.0787238404,
-0.0629760101,
-0.0574571155,
0.0601071864,
0.0017131633,
0.0095727146,
0.0200731251,
0.0111486847,
-0.028017858,
-0.0226168633,
-0.0121202562,
-0.0057572625,
0.0074108965,
-0.0074711507,
0.0329464413,
-0.0145132151,
0.0101058958,
0.0886537656,
0.0351652801,
0.0736755431,
-0.0066236998,
0.0135669652,
-0.0580021478,
-0.0076219398,
-0.0030369624,
0.0531902164,
0.0291109383,
0.0003839439,
-0.0295831356,
-0.0734596476,
0.0034717296,
-0.016663326,
0.0034321526,
0.0037684431,
0.0508616641,
0.004634528,
-0.0026167671,
-0.0182797052,
-0.0091300551,
-0.0523779541,
0.0700909197,
-0.0448481068,
0.0289074779,
-6.871259658e-33,
0.0035045515,
0.0145173473,
0.0035494438,
0.0142784035,
0.0010914529,
0.0090024052,
-0.0048560961,
-0.0404705107,
0.016852174,
0.0543196723,
0.0078584636,
0.0340937935,
0.0232687742,
0.023592025,
-0.003066428,
-0.0317894965,
0.1009779871,
-0.0117095616,
0.0072832755,
0.0695467889,
0.0225665197,
0.0480890274,
0.0374732502,
-0.0960838273,
-0.0213826261,
-0.0111144241,
0.0052139293,
-0.009038331,
0.0181160253,
0.0038599877,
-0.0155224381,
0.0506450534,
-0.005247355,
-0.0127697205,
-0.0258046389,
-0.0208421424,
-0.1069344655,
-0.0074783815,
-0.0147186909,
-0.0066739428,
-0.015451706,
-0.0128629953,
0.0645344704,
0.0113656232,
0.0161985755,
-0.0339397676,
0.0298009403,
-0.0072620152,
-0.0411529914,
-0.0582921766,
-0.0112402039,
0.0056660678,
-0.0248370282,
-0.0442383401,
0.0503871143,
0.0343161896,
-0.0055036386,
0.0059973639,
-0.1295088083,
-0.0002811228,
0.032313522,
0.0245399121,
0.0285870861,
0.0161773246,
-0.0238694362,
0.0546491109,
0.0556565039,
-0.013136249,
0.0170765296,
-0.0184396002,
0.0373014919,
0.0789050832,
-0.0142971873,
0.0013518224,
0.070563525,
-0.0321305618,
-0.0586560108,
-0.0101657817,
-0.0414859243,
-0.0088328468,
-0.0200846996,
0.0309507661,
-0.041956041,
-0.0343077108,
-0.0307412762,
-0.0597905628,
-0.0273880959,
0.0065874094,
0.0344793722,
0.036209777,
-0.0453556143,
0.0298049934,
-0.0017491786,
-0.0685464442,
0.0078184586,
-0.0119374208,
0.03641003,
0.0018521858,
0.0125286058,
-0.0136048216,
-0.0531523414,
-0.0409538038,
0.0492807701,
0.0176178999,
0.0147040598,
-0.0141633879,
0.0410440266,
0.0159434639,
-0.0412899032,
-0.0128113776,
-0.0362779014,
0.0247759372,
0.0501080975,
0.0002103965,
0.0246403888,
0.0110135935,
-0.0111012254,
0.0267303642,
0.0011144327,
-0.0165138859,
-0.00068988,
0.0371339768,
0.0058562378,
0.0299037211,
-0.0094622793,
-0.0327716544,
-0.0294973105,
-0.0287818518,
0.0506202392,
-0.0466223881,
-0.0050750426,
0.008463637,
2.891e-7,
-0.0358004421,
-0.0023726672,
-0.0055289255,
-0.0221513957,
0.0274442919,
0.043141555,
-0.0037074494,
0.0099551966,
-0.001470328,
-0.1147991195,
-0.0032128452,
0.0525677539,
0.0738259107,
0.0241055973,
-0.1006052718,
-0.0196252968,
-0.0616345443,
-0.0460683294,
-0.0236661304,
-0.0335175134,
0.0152301472,
0.0901482403,
0.0917210802,
-0.0299901776,
0.0383989401,
0.0162838548,
0.0154717024,
0.0212064497,
0.0249932352,
0.0282482393,
0.0308529418,
-0.0091672763,
-0.0031029356,
0.0360028669,
-0.0178063624,
-0.0349259563,
0.0133677702,
0.0639993399,
-0.0080757039,
-0.0008824909,
-0.0315925404,
0.0239118412,
0.0193763915,
-0.0223166756,
0.0721559078,
-0.041552972,
-0.0072591323,
0.0219669212,
-0.0215772633,
-0.0180071015,
0.0208741296,
0.005772341,
0.0282761548,
0.0418361947,
-0.0150795393,
-0.013816026,
-0.0154288774,
-0.0466264077,
-0.0069953306,
-0.0041677286,
-0.0382966995,
-0.0691258982,
-0.0052314722,
-0.0250231568,
-0.0067588626,
-0.0338311344,
0.0192576218,
2.506046279e-34,
0.0360787101,
0.0132479332,
0.0146974595,
-0.005367849,
-0.0138840182,
-0.0147873526,
-0.0717787743,
-0.0341274515,
-0.0044461838,
-0.043378599,
-0.0101033999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01238v1 | Large Language Models are Zero-Shot Recognizers for Activities of Daily Living | 2024-07-01T12:32:38 | 2024-07-01T12:32:38 | Gabriele Civitarese, Michele Fiori, Priyankar Choudhary, Claudio Bettini | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.SP | The sensor-based recognition of Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) in smart
home environments enables several applications in the areas of energy
management, safety, well-being, and healthcare. ADLs recognition is typically
based on deep learning methods requiring large datasets to be trained.
Recently, several studies proved that Large Language Models (LLMs) effectively
capture common-sense knowledge about human activities. However, the
effectiveness of LLMs for ADLs recognition in smart home environments still
deserves to be investigated. In this work, we propose ADL-LLM, a novel
LLM-based ADLs recognition system. ADLLLM transforms raw sensor data into
textual representations, that are processed by an LLM to perform zero-shot ADLs
recognition. Moreover, in the scenario where a small labeled dataset is
available, ADL-LLM can also be empowered with few-shot prompting. We evaluated
ADL-LLM on two public datasets, showing its effectiveness in this domain. | Large Language Models are Zero-Shot Recognizers for Activities of Daily Living: The sensor-based recognition of Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) in smart
home environments enables several applications in the areas of energy
management, safety, well-being, and healthcare. ADLs recognition is typically
based on deep learning methods requiring large datasets to be trained.
Recently, several studies proved that Large Language Models (LLMs) effectively
capture common-sense knowledge about human activities. However, the
effectiveness of LLMs for ADLs recognition in smart home environments still
deserves to be investigated. In this work, we propose ADL-LLM, a novel
LLM-based ADLs recognition system. ADLLLM transforms raw sensor data into
textual representations, that are processed by an LLM to perform zero-shot ADLs
recognition. Moreover, in the scenario where a small labeled dataset is
available, ADL-LLM can also be empowered with few-shot prompting. We evaluated
ADL-LLM on two public datasets, showing its effectiveness in this domain. | [
-0.051014442,
0.0277726799,
0.0087185064,
0.0251664575,
-0.0342851207,
0.0291881375,
0.0563728362,
-0.0187473278,
0.0402878597,
-0.0789128765,
0.0059198951,
0.0107545666,
0.0005008822,
-0.004860668,
-0.0018362059,
0.0369234271,
0.0416830555,
0.0137219802,
0.0290321447,
0.0269782282,
0.0091796583,
0.0101457927,
-0.013964436,
0.0445825048,
-0.0146578187,
-0.0127207432,
-0.0012022346,
-0.0241816677,
0.060342811,
-0.0457019843,
-0.0022060114,
0.0177474674,
0.0490577556,
0.0634143725,
0.0000018511,
-0.0308871027,
0.0018478244,
-0.005148611,
-0.03825894,
-0.0701080486,
0.0337495953,
-0.0161871873,
0.0278551169,
0.0026074331,
-0.0208164733,
-0.0571758002,
0.0323725678,
0.038410008,
-0.0086716292,
0.0619980842,
-0.0077776844,
-0.0260955188,
0.0021309946,
0.0086127957,
0.0590018481,
-0.0027544226,
0.0407311954,
-0.0292078517,
0.008727775,
0.0006057082,
0.0012420648,
0.0102743693,
-0.0136236567,
0.0435988642,
0.0075312303,
0.0317892358,
-0.0254318994,
0.029441772,
-0.0091736717,
0.0766613632,
-0.0370378159,
-0.0231582299,
0.044106707,
-0.0109624928,
-0.0284387413,
-0.0144642889,
-0.0652143285,
0.0082251523,
0.0198332928,
0.0327328295,
-0.0172346458,
0.0294777676,
0.0590384044,
0.0116959009,
-0.0026081074,
0.0769425482,
-0.0106448391,
0.0024352993,
-0.0212551132,
-0.0166298058,
0.0415839516,
-0.0411293432,
0.0103111072,
0.0207545441,
0.0039547789,
-0.0037083856,
-0.057060767,
-0.0031940558,
0.0151935006,
-0.0241689812,
0.0200525895,
0.0252766069,
0.0109926555,
0.0671243221,
-0.015743738,
0.0255293753,
0.0157388989,
0.0255499035,
-0.0561435707,
-0.0007115952,
-0.0605691634,
0.0246338006,
0.0001720756,
0.0200969521,
-0.0260786731,
-0.0652917549,
-0.03866506,
0.0161393862,
0.0041839154,
0.0004404153,
-0.0057000681,
0.039047461,
0.0093895607,
-0.0384800211,
0.0439330153,
0.0138852512,
0.0109745981,
0.0785283595,
-0.0221434161,
-0.0538290516,
0.0056718634,
0.0433323123,
0.0604753532,
-0.0212991405,
-0.0170989186,
0.011736298,
0.0234726686,
-0.0450931787,
-0.0111538628,
-0.0115451338,
-0.0029568463,
-0.0077497768,
0.0130521776,
-0.0794729814,
0.0051280069,
-0.0238662977,
0.0195882265,
-0.065635398,
0.0154451272,
0.0139671778,
-0.0196924582,
0.0924913436,
-0.0383108929,
0.0090740211,
0.0352962911,
-0.0007464609,
0.0484086126,
-0.0006949012,
0.0429645032,
0.0064908694,
0.0056257676,
-0.0072222762,
0.0145732015,
0.036443077,
-0.0082704527,
-0.0185087379,
0.0035719851,
-0.0004780007,
-0.0001322824,
0.0125481151,
-0.0095302016,
0.0305271484,
0.0175106041,
0.0152294785,
0.0826684684,
0.0817222819,
-0.0032748715,
-0.0133253066,
-0.0001945483,
0.0179982167,
-0.0300455466,
-0.0797996521,
-0.026724821,
-0.0155982943,
-0.0316339582,
-0.0322886556,
-0.0189612769,
-0.0248473976,
-0.0568622351,
-0.0230005123,
-0.0487221293,
-0.0604441985,
0.0418813415,
0.0283272732,
0.0393573381,
-0.0289487187,
-0.000419738,
0.0592518821,
0.0195613336,
-0.0144079737,
0.0005799336,
-0.0433204211,
0.0251290891,
0.0826465413,
0.0058608735,
-0.0378067084,
0.0146841481,
-0.0371537432,
0.0768980235,
-0.0428298451,
0.0021568125,
0.0114387525,
0.0294762105,
-0.041907616,
-0.0558232777,
-0.0061964863,
0.0245707985,
-0.0080236942,
-0.0574667156,
0.0155557776,
0.0325266942,
-0.009252456,
-0.0370862819,
0.0340995379,
0.0095161088,
-0.0464065112,
0.0480211973,
0.0373509303,
-0.0105102882,
0.0327035896,
0.0138879716,
0.0007813572,
0.0524634756,
-0.0963015556,
-0.024822427,
0.0396503173,
-0.0543504655,
-0.0319856368,
0.0382236131,
0.0126282275,
0.0227036253,
0.0269583315,
-0.0389235914,
-0.0293556005,
-0.0143362144,
-0.029702967,
-0.0066826791,
-0.0348901674,
-0.0406704582,
0.0150633808,
0.0059774704,
-0.0262785982,
0.050701987,
-0.0137566347,
0.0036978747,
-0.0167811979,
0.0175565872,
0.0028120624,
-0.0295547172,
-0.0255170316,
-0.0409359932,
-0.0476704203,
0.0299292766,
0.0163553022,
0.068846941,
-0.0179365296,
0.0562247597,
-0.0995993763,
-0.0131276315,
-0.0458542332,
0.0022283515,
0.0028419474,
0.0053583654,
0.022449106,
-0.0264623966,
-0.0334039032,
0.0319790393,
-0.024687428,
-0.0010879405,
0.0398324877,
-0.0063723312,
-0.0354323722,
-0.002150784,
0.0066292859,
-0.0027135604,
0.026964847,
0.0022859657,
0.0040445649,
-0.0016209407,
-0.0281120315,
0.0354877152,
-0.003913735,
0.0072586588,
-0.0039377501,
-0.0024018765,
-0.0301488247,
0.0075067356,
0.0347672813,
-0.013079986,
-0.0048406511,
0.0450946242,
-0.0103671448,
-0.0379994102,
-0.0196651295,
-0.022906078,
0.0311184935,
-0.0347237326,
-0.011006047,
-0.0034415978,
0.037782561,
0.0063684694,
0.0188882388,
0.0221961029,
0.0175755601,
-0.0224541556,
-0.0222158469,
-0.0701250061,
0.0402637795,
-0.0516201742,
0.0440184772,
0.0114879757,
-0.0372842103,
-0.0080234706,
-0.0235635787,
-0.0011327327,
-0.0235936847,
-0.0381956361,
-0.0239011999,
0.0372168906,
-0.0029236968,
0.0388344973,
0.0139800152,
-0.0264125746,
0.003314629,
-0.0394819342,
-0.0422411375,
-0.0246853065,
0.0509204939,
-0.0613980256,
0.0315094404,
-0.0287415534,
-0.0513083972,
-0.0443054661,
-0.028757222,
-0.0478575863,
0.0091237929,
-0.0793434158,
0.0181135498,
-0.0576655082,
0.0042887842,
-0.0173963048,
0.0516477004,
0.0256327167,
0.0171403531,
-0.0152133359,
0.042471379,
0.0819114819,
0.0048118834,
-0.0726636723,
0.0332153402,
-0.005203038,
0.0272943322,
0.0255752187,
0.0856051818,
-0.0721208081,
0.0098531218,
0.0121268481,
0.0126495641,
-0.0124488343,
0.0510336496,
0.0383569598,
-0.0220339391,
-0.0055599255,
0.1366689205,
-0.0053434195,
-0.0490634404,
0.0121393958,
0.0102174971,
-0.0428307615,
-0.0200720746,
-0.0450227447,
-0.0863185972,
-0.0798740312,
0.0153692104,
0.0112587195,
0.0147997504,
-0.0236527137,
-0.0002885232,
-0.0644119084,
-0.0183213167,
0.0249565132,
-0.0367813073,
-0.0751802698,
-0.0230749082,
-0.0023841725,
-0.0310019255,
0.0145931505,
-0.0393443294,
-0.0054627922,
-0.0375670753,
0.0011894152,
-0.0688353777,
-0.0829527378,
0.057328146,
-0.0370179452,
0.0662898496,
0.0472524315,
0.0444702059,
0.0165887084,
-0.0188392662,
-0.0055734864,
-0.0025042456,
0.0027453566,
-0.0393876061,
-0.0274059568,
-0.0035493865,
0.0040965434,
0.058795616,
0.097139746,
-0.0971363857,
-0.0247777607,
0.0150363371,
0.0659957454,
-0.0329453386,
-0.0064393003,
-0.0388618857,
-0.0393854976,
0.0749395713,
0.0914181024,
0.0033437456,
-0.0336459093,
-0.0265873596,
-0.0044992897,
-0.0524996705,
0.0344061926,
-0.0385197997,
-0.0112660024,
-0.0183636621,
-0.0308596715,
-0.0284683388,
-0.0359651968,
0.0612184368,
0.0120836729,
0.0045223231,
0.0166618638,
0.0211702622,
0.0426011905,
-0.0679300129,
0.0149048436,
-0.0554943532,
0.0769373775,
-0.0256260484,
0.0025532776,
0.0570580736,
-0.0022150239,
-0.0122058252,
0.0245037116,
-0.0765646473,
-0.0088178953,
0.002076877,
0.0471859649,
0.0163554791,
0.0141744539,
-0.0158628095,
-0.0056147249,
0.0120055471,
0.0708713457,
-0.0174163543,
-0.0153354052,
0.0115371393,
0.0007752784,
0.0079703955,
0.0463735498,
-0.0429080054,
0.0364531092,
-0.008473332,
0.0317696705,
-0.0736250728,
-0.0338020809,
0.0151561983,
-0.0261128619,
0.0566876531,
0.0189482179,
-0.0085822307,
-0.0218988247,
0.0042784074,
0.0023997023,
-0.0174253173,
-0.0477047749,
0.0240034293,
0.04171836,
0.0014644362,
-0.0175935775,
0.0581943505,
-0.000539986,
-0.0004529367,
-0.0484584868,
0.0136028156,
0.0216373894,
0.0599488467,
0.0282187182,
-0.0199532043,
-0.0279390048,
0.0156983174,
-0.0087265931,
-0.0343819223,
-0.0046130223,
-0.0032443397,
-0.0104554007,
0.0162913315,
-0.0938997716,
0.0477561913,
0.0044458089,
-0.0149674686,
0.0190727822,
0.0288272575,
0.0475808792,
0.0138246613,
0.0175926052,
-0.0015248025,
-0.0071439794,
-0.0732602328,
0.0450374857,
-0.0020136053,
-0.0030575995,
0.0190497711,
0.0103207128,
-0.0421840549,
0.0083552841,
0.0720314085,
0.0289720502,
0.0133259995,
0.0229389854,
-0.0234365165,
-0.0502142198,
-0.0004246335,
0.0330267251,
0.0361855738,
-0.0355960988,
-0.0197023079,
-0.0106158601,
-0.0423479863,
0.0058492431,
-0.0454187952,
0.0280255396,
0.0294651184,
0.0571958423,
0.0305441227,
-0.038869109,
-0.0248755664,
-0.0006919147,
-0.0048398743,
-0.0413486399,
-0.0187116042,
-0.039065633,
-5.772805002e-33,
0.0185092986,
-0.0349374525,
0.0130205285,
-0.009813006,
0.020403685,
0.0214249697,
-0.0083294306,
0.0092822565,
-0.0213124808,
-0.0266983155,
0.005738202,
-0.0113382386,
0.0324592479,
0.0422241054,
0.0312337857,
-0.030479677,
0.0696427524,
-0.0392245948,
0.0162888374,
0.0147247715,
0.0393934995,
0.0306131914,
0.0270012654,
-0.0659713298,
0.0014742661,
-0.0017132375,
0.0007072656,
-0.0167690795,
0.028475346,
0.0032517465,
-0.044987902,
0.0499214344,
0.0280559734,
0.0436320901,
-0.0344518162,
0.0892780572,
-0.0694784224,
-0.0106057692,
-0.0149431936,
0.011158851,
-0.0191748869,
-0.0501181222,
0.0212888718,
0.0139356675,
-0.0509473607,
0.0193062425,
0.0470030382,
-0.0392086208,
-0.0215618648,
-0.0065382011,
-0.0227897484,
0.0165331885,
0.0026514609,
-0.0191858672,
0.0095863771,
-0.0053114281,
-0.0193867646,
0.0203990676,
-0.0924644694,
0.0251148567,
-0.0208739396,
0.0211884677,
0.0568031035,
0.013541894,
0.0066786208,
0.0687901229,
0.0134422304,
-0.0309673343,
-0.0159257781,
0.0412621461,
0.0147308242,
0.0733118355,
0.0001380145,
0.0426114984,
0.0641922429,
-0.0117066251,
-0.0688288361,
0.0124225523,
0.0289522503,
0.0294615887,
0.0264740251,
0.0345989168,
-0.0056615942,
-0.0063113566,
-0.0038266771,
0.0296943057,
-0.0424692445,
0.0061434135,
0.0412785895,
0.0261802711,
-0.0421278737,
0.011110709,
0.0206960905,
-0.0316412561,
-0.0108872075,
0.0502424166,
0.0511664748,
-0.0248737056,
-0.0025656433,
0.0092288032,
-0.0704673827,
-0.0469216965,
0.0032962426,
0.049543988,
0.0060061901,
-0.0027403447,
0.0340320244,
0.075295113,
-0.0022090334,
-0.0352218002,
0.0104099149,
-0.047551319,
-0.0062484234,
0.0620260127,
0.0344866626,
-0.0204529539,
0.0015578724,
0.0820571259,
-0.0584983863,
-0.0277699027,
0.0086810766,
-0.0114130927,
-0.0007843819,
-0.0100967251,
-0.0210823826,
-0.0134774847,
-0.0909508392,
-0.0171918944,
0.0606516711,
-0.0236838441,
0.0166645776,
-0.0135224927,
2.557e-7,
-0.0150372935,
0.0220099483,
-0.0293098632,
-0.0148243355,
0.0222692043,
0.045475211,
0.0028480764,
0.0818575174,
-0.0273856279,
0.0161592867,
0.038140934,
0.0010580313,
0.0595781356,
-0.0092992773,
-0.0769215971,
0.0073275147,
-0.0420921333,
0.0320163183,
-0.0675042421,
0.0100367852,
0.0527711399,
0.0846935511,
0.0140218167,
-0.0240753442,
0.0588915572,
-0.0989352018,
0.0384705439,
-0.0432663076,
0.0460871123,
-0.0303041879,
0.0078530563,
0.019537041,
0.00855863,
-0.0396187641,
-0.006767143,
0.010529195,
0.0028934171,
0.0811984465,
-0.0417780839,
-0.0383152701,
-0.0237598605,
-0.0301386844,
-0.0109145157,
-0.0114411116,
0.0973202437,
-0.0850158036,
-0.0072063375,
-0.0081496928,
0.0191408079,
0.0002361827,
0.01265602,
0.0115903532,
0.0095856655,
-0.0129047735,
0.019954117,
-0.0475578308,
-0.0367321633,
-0.0703570247,
-0.0153138572,
-0.0182491411,
-0.0701145455,
-0.0001035813,
-0.0285231564,
-0.0021999639,
-0.0065788133,
-0.050067842,
-0.0130892638,
2.044784591e-34,
-0.0222509261,
0.0283885375,
-0.036065232,
0.0106641473,
-0.0315372497,
-0.0109095052,
0.0077799046,
0.0341344997,
0.0031395101,
-0.081376791,
-0.0017530497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01231v1 | MIRAI: Evaluating LLM Agents for Event Forecasting | 2024-07-01T12:22:46 | 2024-07-01T12:22:46 | Chenchen Ye, Ziniu Hu, Yihe Deng, Zijie Huang, Mingyu Derek Ma, Yanqiao Zhu, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have empowered LLM agents
to autonomously collect world information, over which to conduct reasoning to
solve complex problems. Given this capability, increasing interests have been
put into employing LLM agents for predicting international events, which can
influence decision-making and shape policy development on an international
scale. Despite such a growing interest, there is a lack of a rigorous benchmark
of LLM agents' forecasting capability and reliability. To address this gap, we
introduce MIRAI, a novel benchmark designed to systematically evaluate LLM
agents as temporal forecasters in the context of international events. Our
benchmark features an agentic environment with tools for accessing an extensive
database of historical, structured events and textual news articles. We refine
the GDELT event database with careful cleaning and parsing to curate a series
of relational prediction tasks with varying forecasting horizons, assessing LLM
agents' abilities from short-term to long-term forecasting. We further
implement APIs to enable LLM agents to utilize different tools via a code-based
interface. In summary, MIRAI comprehensively evaluates the agents' capabilities
in three dimensions: 1) autonomously source and integrate critical information
from large global databases; 2) write codes using domain-specific APIs and
libraries for tool-use; and 3) jointly reason over historical knowledge from
diverse formats and time to accurately predict future events. Through
comprehensive benchmarking, we aim to establish a reliable framework for
assessing the capabilities of LLM agents in forecasting international events,
thereby contributing to the development of more accurate and trustworthy models
for international relation analysis. | MIRAI: Evaluating LLM Agents for Event Forecasting: Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have empowered LLM agents
to autonomously collect world information, over which to conduct reasoning to
solve complex problems. Given this capability, increasing interests have been
put into employing LLM agents for predicting international events, which can
influence decision-making and shape policy development on an international
scale. Despite such a growing interest, there is a lack of a rigorous benchmark
of LLM agents' forecasting capability and reliability. To address this gap, we
introduce MIRAI, a novel benchmark designed to systematically evaluate LLM
agents as temporal forecasters in the context of international events. Our
benchmark features an agentic environment with tools for accessing an extensive
database of historical, structured events and textual news articles. We refine
the GDELT event database with careful cleaning and parsing to curate a series
of relational prediction tasks with varying forecasting horizons, assessing LLM
agents' abilities from short-term to long-term forecasting. We further
implement APIs to enable LLM agents to utilize different tools via a code-based
interface. In summary, MIRAI comprehensively evaluates the agents' capabilities
in three dimensions: 1) autonomously source and integrate critical information
from large global databases; 2) write codes using domain-specific APIs and
libraries for tool-use; and 3) jointly reason over historical knowledge from
diverse formats and time to accurately predict future events. Through
comprehensive benchmarking, we aim to establish a reliable framework for
assessing the capabilities of LLM agents in forecasting international events,
thereby contributing to the development of more accurate and trustworthy models
for international relation analysis. | [
0.01878394,
0.0758275315,
-0.0128076468,
0.0027752954,
-0.0426185057,
-0.0046388009,
0.0177326407,
-0.0162098929,
0.0748274326,
-0.0000387124,
0.0400912017,
-0.0329640061,
-0.0444008224,
0.0520056263,
-0.0415112711,
-0.0525375754,
0.0490888134,
-0.0244462248,
0.0248227771,
0.0032048777,
-0.01233052,
-0.0021274746,
-0.0199266877,
0.0402366109,
-0.012609004,
0.0068827434,
-0.0556367561,
-0.0222390871,
-0.0074625774,
-0.0552115068,
-0.0097659342,
0.0072235614,
0.0329401866,
0.0115900906,
0.0000020416,
-0.0479447246,
-0.0251263492,
-0.0170685817,
-0.0041714269,
-0.0106264269,
0.0392979681,
-0.0196204036,
0.0077978033,
0.0038700679,
-0.0995034575,
-0.0098028239,
0.0000597129,
-0.0023003859,
0.0572415628,
0.0687939152,
-0.0109520415,
0.0172516722,
0.0561910272,
-0.0102689303,
-0.0234169774,
-0.0754498541,
0.0110717062,
-0.016656721,
0.007704284,
-0.0138223795,
0.034178786,
0.010834204,
-0.0042141257,
0.0006183583,
-0.0390149914,
0.040225666,
-0.0359881148,
-0.0134806689,
-0.0358149037,
-0.0063175294,
0.0978890136,
-0.0058474722,
0.0299576484,
0.0228816606,
-0.0130263111,
0.0504193045,
-0.0393009,
0.0085458718,
-0.0138774859,
0.0419784077,
0.0704984218,
0.0121064661,
0.0037761142,
0.042604126,
-0.0390570983,
0.1441454142,
-0.0097649526,
-0.0110048614,
-0.0169663858,
-0.0064269109,
0.0220375396,
-0.0847615525,
-0.0091011291,
0.0720065683,
-0.0775472522,
0.004670776,
-0.0058564674,
0.0363134146,
-0.0232845712,
-0.0834775791,
-0.0233040266,
0.0601702593,
0.0448391326,
0.0630730391,
0.020365905,
0.0374021642,
0.0163585525,
-0.0026199364,
0.0130170193,
-0.0309738331,
-0.0746085569,
0.0171563178,
-0.0007646073,
0.0025485097,
-0.0180709418,
-0.0120411245,
-0.030214455,
0.0394403823,
-0.0357916132,
0.0723979026,
0.005398313,
-0.0171485096,
-0.0343194157,
-0.0264996868,
-0.1162081584,
0.0027799681,
-0.0562260039,
0.0026562402,
-0.0036411283,
-0.0459242389,
0.0119320396,
-0.0223911777,
-0.0020021542,
-0.0008528868,
0.0020749948,
0.1112292036,
0.0239185318,
0.0197944622,
-0.0859785601,
-0.030141592,
0.0437912866,
-0.0683593899,
-0.0015242471,
-0.0525712781,
0.0154850436,
0.010054878,
-0.004212162,
-0.0405619554,
0.011825284,
-0.0383166112,
-0.014666847,
0.0325038135,
-0.0180907585,
0.0176904723,
-0.0021833139,
-0.0050529516,
-0.001821755,
0.0827571973,
0.027043419,
0.0524449721,
0.0508955754,
0.0347189233,
0.0102295186,
0.014111816,
-0.0194218569,
0.0385614634,
-0.0569992252,
0.0355549417,
-0.0401405022,
-0.0026008994,
-0.0168885682,
-0.0193480048,
0.0278180055,
-0.0048361439,
0.0808085278,
0.0012397267,
-0.0475304909,
0.0223585386,
0.0644354224,
-0.020461306,
0.0025531987,
-0.0094258254,
-0.0237228554,
0.0409586206,
-0.0124093518,
0.0181649607,
-0.0003793763,
0.0450416766,
-0.0215328895,
-0.0340748951,
0.0115324687,
-0.018474305,
-0.0018486795,
-0.0184526779,
0.0541109443,
-0.041343756,
-0.0385575481,
0.0569866635,
0.0263335332,
-0.0336787179,
0.0043373019,
-0.0307280589,
0.013936867,
0.0774199888,
0.0260384697,
-0.0555525273,
-0.0631998554,
0.0105480123,
0.0195247121,
0.0373349153,
0.0274784081,
-0.0033578749,
0.0008309433,
-0.0142942108,
-0.049476888,
0.0377512909,
0.0258466043,
0.0417476334,
0.0425871126,
0.0577964224,
-0.0050032996,
-0.0235796236,
-0.0147034917,
0.026016349,
-0.0414691828,
-0.0397139713,
-0.0518147908,
0.0154766981,
0.0433294475,
0.0071384516,
-0.0022258176,
0.0233348124,
0.0292686969,
-0.002172672,
-0.0397184305,
0.0293343086,
0.0054594488,
0.0322811715,
0.0208743867,
0.0098487539,
0.0173072405,
0.0104850987,
-0.0182814449,
-0.0433136597,
0.0555616356,
0.0451928899,
0.0520715863,
-0.0231758412,
0.0113137309,
-0.0351608247,
-0.0127659217,
0.0190892015,
0.0465488061,
-0.0017252376,
-0.0272596981,
-0.0068929195,
-0.0032320737,
-0.0067409375,
0.0100564472,
-0.0161358397,
0.0375670977,
0.0118512549,
0.0145724332,
0.0277851839,
-0.0175591614,
-0.0381615497,
-0.0396779515,
-0.0876722187,
0.0118935583,
-0.0184245463,
0.0216513239,
0.0219390187,
-0.0157697722,
-0.0068299482,
0.0335640609,
-0.0040744259,
0.00284041,
-0.019368533,
0.0233430211,
0.0139146959,
0.0313586891,
-0.0164504815,
-0.040464893,
0.0269875191,
-0.039373599,
0.0470608845,
0.0237045977,
-0.0139228506,
-0.0008128567,
-0.0069965883,
-0.0894308165,
0.0356858335,
-0.0437189564,
-0.0386699103,
0.0065524708,
-0.0437587276,
-0.0010445787,
0.0181756001,
-0.0014341992,
0.0345159546,
0.0526480451,
-0.0583376884,
-0.0419956632,
0.0303330235,
-0.0490265079,
0.0096464129,
-0.0547540933,
-0.0273000728,
-0.0055737682,
0.0497211292,
-0.0049928618,
0.0454818495,
-0.0326989256,
0.0260266047,
-0.0289422926,
-0.0146660004,
-0.0043653157,
-0.0188040212,
0.0111812297,
0.0769315958,
-0.0039704624,
-0.0498395711,
0.048225075,
-0.0248433668,
0.0184378717,
0.0027058322,
-0.0563941114,
-0.0757103041,
0.0627683848,
-0.0228855871,
-0.0014379421,
-0.0375137441,
0.0154875005,
-0.0463504568,
-0.0538151935,
0.0261704568,
-0.0215884726,
0.0191372931,
-0.0514527746,
-0.0010554242,
0.0074343607,
-0.0122944405,
-0.0126875294,
-0.0169200636,
-0.0585678332,
-0.0046301922,
-0.0094193099,
-0.0220474675,
-0.0450785235,
0.0568140633,
0.0263367519,
0.010576589,
-0.0199118666,
-0.0324483886,
0.0191597901,
-0.0243177637,
0.0007477466,
-0.0361531451,
-0.0227901395,
0.0051899236,
0.0267069284,
-0.0032623727,
0.0422386602,
-0.0189251211,
-0.0591939054,
0.0149079366,
0.0153552741,
-0.0143136345,
-0.0030975707,
0.026951788,
0.0040148222,
-0.0691804886,
0.0161924493,
0.1171986833,
0.0283936299,
-0.0367193259,
-0.0116988476,
-0.0206189808,
-0.0046854313,
0.0109281568,
0.0288232695,
-0.0524486564,
0.0114005189,
0.029621169,
-0.0167209283,
-0.0367824361,
-0.0880399048,
-0.0158940759,
-0.0844861567,
0.0426649041,
0.0009319285,
0.0055135787,
0.0196449086,
-0.0779860914,
0.005556528,
-0.0346008167,
-0.0305622369,
0.0044811801,
-0.0024285377,
0.0067780493,
0.0036502418,
-0.1101776734,
-0.026364658,
0.0280089881,
-0.036880251,
0.0294390265,
0.048565384,
0.0771051347,
-0.0034969652,
0.0155721093,
-0.0348921642,
0.0301007982,
0.0326200575,
-0.0131517164,
0.0489401706,
0.0202027895,
-0.018601872,
-0.0069213584,
0.0113588665,
0.0048352606,
-0.0078606978,
0.0525448546,
0.098368831,
-0.0303098131,
0.0024159977,
0.0068743099,
-0.0002411917,
0.0377003923,
0.0482854582,
-0.0233160201,
0.0022738075,
-0.0759446397,
-0.0131697385,
-0.0071429163,
-0.0526021011,
-0.0032018705,
0.0281774253,
-0.0245445762,
-0.060367275,
-0.0304575395,
-0.0748925954,
-0.0019828642,
0.0095233284,
0.0029383567,
0.0063812938,
0.0458122231,
0.0228892472,
-0.0267048813,
-0.0191709679,
-0.0133757563,
0.0319264457,
-0.0085583394,
0.0030196477,
0.0030381419,
0.0212672036,
-0.0114823068,
0.0272552017,
-0.0652807876,
-0.0394307449,
0.0407610424,
0.0054554003,
0.0311767757,
0.0032237414,
0.0060926657,
0.0366607942,
0.0323975943,
0.044640664,
-0.0331965201,
-0.0005680461,
0.0309255272,
0.0335754454,
0.0241346434,
0.0462216027,
-0.0402816683,
0.0082212947,
-0.0361704789,
-0.006451556,
-0.0484103411,
-0.0079020951,
-0.0140590845,
-0.0123661617,
0.0226100292,
0.0051483917,
-0.0361759514,
-0.0071183811,
-0.000012639,
-0.0145585164,
-0.0028325391,
-0.0168812089,
0.0064468682,
0.0103918817,
0.0178163685,
-0.0009708554,
0.0740639418,
0.0028738559,
-0.0390831903,
-0.0077328612,
0.0578057766,
0.0028838939,
0.0333493166,
0.035680797,
0.0057052625,
-0.0182792153,
-0.0397187211,
-0.0031876513,
0.0224529598,
-0.0221095067,
0.0168292914,
0.0035322977,
0.0269700885,
0.0227997098,
-0.0260631312,
-0.1153087765,
-0.0589117631,
0.0141828908,
0.0392505676,
0.0709113106,
-0.0117276702,
0.0094315764,
-0.0634726509,
0.0202584062,
0.0161222517,
0.00151761,
0.0007213935,
-0.0302661769,
-0.0000555052,
-0.0026011753,
-0.0581130013,
0.0321279541,
0.0749910548,
-0.0113240918,
0.0728371218,
0.0599967465,
-0.0686320588,
-0.0301603451,
-0.0704325065,
0.0188563131,
-0.0262131058,
-0.0101772882,
-0.0307371654,
-0.079873316,
-0.0107262097,
0.0526493192,
0.0133849783,
-0.0533544496,
-0.0315198377,
-0.0439899042,
0.0448014736,
0.0194743089,
0.0513680652,
-0.0582810938,
-0.0004187367,
-0.0818767995,
-0.0092196669,
-0.0098923473,
-6.229946674e-33,
-0.0305330567,
-0.0109860403,
0.0447189361,
-0.0085194306,
-0.0274999067,
0.0087219691,
-0.0605362803,
-0.0364952348,
-0.0152535504,
0.0086520808,
-0.0199848581,
-0.0014555651,
0.0321427733,
-0.0326595008,
0.0414593779,
-0.0158791356,
0.0100545743,
-0.0032355729,
0.000916279,
-0.0040208106,
0.0607987456,
0.0218687132,
0.038135685,
-0.0613213778,
0.0250132605,
-0.0019128256,
-0.0112978974,
0.0106259407,
0.0551495478,
0.0453643352,
0.002468318,
0.0063105263,
0.0220737718,
-0.0361586846,
-0.0021909708,
-0.022411909,
-0.016863266,
-0.050938949,
-0.0031088151,
-0.0150029156,
0.0303707141,
0.033131171,
-0.0367418565,
0.0224297326,
-0.0172224641,
0.009755074,
0.0253600683,
-0.036942929,
-0.0115759252,
-0.0188140571,
-0.0282548256,
0.0373663977,
-0.0246180389,
0.037374679,
-0.0024102489,
0.0363452733,
0.0232886281,
0.0258253086,
-0.038206432,
0.0428569689,
-0.0205786265,
0.027880989,
0.0242809262,
0.0036028854,
0.020200368,
0.082971476,
0.0229517017,
0.0111933053,
-0.0345844068,
0.0216009393,
0.0077080117,
0.0634944439,
-0.0024821509,
0.0920339301,
-0.0053161033,
-0.0157177225,
-0.0550694838,
0.065827392,
0.0553868599,
0.0533084087,
0.0293687433,
0.0080376016,
-0.0104090953,
-0.0254612397,
-0.019512726,
0.0037058357,
-0.0113431122,
-0.0224828068,
0.0056343749,
-0.0106090885,
0.0449733771,
0.0341465659,
0.0209691823,
-0.0191510823,
-0.0228858069,
0.0469244979,
-0.021311406,
-0.0066994731,
0.0073929206,
0.0489477701,
-0.0403601676,
-0.0144681204,
-0.0287731625,
0.0005277104,
0.0341066569,
0.0167168695,
-0.0325775482,
0.045784153,
-0.0265954584,
-0.0204447545,
-0.0527990237,
0.0186298508,
0.0022976308,
-0.0305349249,
0.0267939642,
-0.0171974897,
-0.001041515,
0.0146608725,
0.0126781305,
-0.0003908498,
0.0399991311,
-0.0050924923,
0.0138236014,
0.0041472786,
0.0029611264,
-0.0334522463,
-0.0597922206,
0.0262376815,
0.0058794147,
-0.0234098565,
-0.012085991,
0.0107508162,
2.833e-7,
0.0138147455,
0.0489009321,
0.0088236388,
0.079778403,
-0.0080097476,
0.0322100818,
-0.0533280894,
0.013167684,
-0.020752186,
0.0021805214,
0.0420353413,
0.0281547848,
0.0658353418,
0.0996655896,
-0.0696089342,
-0.0372304954,
-0.0774463788,
-0.0332728401,
-0.1063473523,
0.0042608413,
0.0579011776,
0.0325373374,
0.072093226,
0.0102326525,
0.0268290564,
-0.0799173713,
0.0231135841,
-0.0564427078,
-0.0397390798,
0.0320172235,
-0.0068687121,
0.0127975456,
-0.0169334523,
0.0170743801,
-0.0164416544,
-0.020025501,
-0.0629395694,
0.0485583209,
0.0189840235,
0.0092200516,
0.0074460655,
-0.046765659,
-0.0147189479,
-0.0352498703,
0.0736514926,
-0.0286276434,
-0.0264526941,
0.0083682975,
-0.0395933166,
0.027885925,
0.003084928,
0.0009040165,
-0.0022328494,
0.0354554839,
-0.0212833453,
-0.0172099937,
0.0141497999,
-0.0295627117,
-0.0224454757,
-0.0003773806,
-0.0271766745,
-0.059368711,
-0.0464829728,
0.0054764966,
0.0228160154,
-0.0402349308,
0.041746702,
2.598485823e-34,
0.0220842212,
0.0465942919,
-0.0345253833,
0.012722495,
0.0792075694,
0.0114909206,
-0.0311908834,
0.0233642627,
0.0121314842,
-0.0306865387,
-0.0031104081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01219v1 | Searching for Best Practices in Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-07-01T12:06:34 | 2024-07-01T12:06:34 | Xiaohua Wang, Zhenghua Wang, Xuan Gao, Feiran Zhang, Yixin Wu, Zhibo Xu, Tianyuan Shi, Zhengyuan Wang, Shizheng Li, Qi Qian, Ruicheng Yin, Changze Lv, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) techniques have proven to be effective
in integrating up-to-date information, mitigating hallucinations, and enhancing
response quality, particularly in specialized domains. While many RAG
approaches have been proposed to enhance large language models through
query-dependent retrievals, these approaches still suffer from their complex
implementation and prolonged response times. Typically, a RAG workflow involves
multiple processing steps, each of which can be executed in various ways. Here,
we investigate existing RAG approaches and their potential combinations to
identify optimal RAG practices. Through extensive experiments, we suggest
several strategies for deploying RAG that balance both performance and
efficiency. Moreover, we demonstrate that multimodal retrieval techniques can
significantly enhance question-answering capabilities about visual inputs and
accelerate the generation of multimodal content using a "retrieval as
generation" strategy. | Searching for Best Practices in Retrieval-Augmented Generation: Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) techniques have proven to be effective
in integrating up-to-date information, mitigating hallucinations, and enhancing
response quality, particularly in specialized domains. While many RAG
approaches have been proposed to enhance large language models through
query-dependent retrievals, these approaches still suffer from their complex
implementation and prolonged response times. Typically, a RAG workflow involves
multiple processing steps, each of which can be executed in various ways. Here,
we investigate existing RAG approaches and their potential combinations to
identify optimal RAG practices. Through extensive experiments, we suggest
several strategies for deploying RAG that balance both performance and
efficiency. Moreover, we demonstrate that multimodal retrieval techniques can
significantly enhance question-answering capabilities about visual inputs and
accelerate the generation of multimodal content using a "retrieval as
generation" strategy. | [
0.0592332184,
0.0481168106,
-0.0234538037,
-0.0044384943,
-0.0311622582,
-0.0270036142,
-0.009929562,
0.0219328627,
-0.0027948637,
-0.0701162964,
-0.0096947812,
-0.0412294678,
-0.0294527616,
0.0142404959,
0.0370427184,
-0.0518887527,
0.0547049716,
-0.0035234168,
-0.0385480113,
0.0174561571,
0.0181938969,
0.0123841679,
-0.0191030409,
0.0491677858,
-0.0498849861,
-0.0221178457,
-0.0274257325,
0.0359057598,
-0.0022641283,
-0.0355380513,
0.0055792374,
0.0341177024,
0.0376602747,
0.0189359374,
0.0000020035,
-0.0327376127,
0.0051301592,
0.0021954684,
0.0249896161,
-0.0197479166,
0.0532786772,
0.0395446047,
0.0445805192,
0.0215657391,
-0.0604569912,
-0.0144093903,
0.0645110458,
0.0068605212,
0.0655618832,
0.0196747966,
-0.0169245433,
-0.0100019136,
0.0098654907,
0.0043589841,
0.0518155135,
-0.0071580671,
-0.0317891464,
0.0160210449,
0.0711997673,
0.024293825,
-0.0204928685,
0.0671010911,
0.0194699727,
-0.0304988213,
0.0398688018,
0.0276410598,
-0.0345111713,
-0.0222346932,
-0.02589803,
0.0729571506,
0.0473924465,
0.0063805864,
-0.0163481738,
0.0254063923,
0.0048188367,
0.0815706924,
-0.0819966197,
0.0026536896,
-0.0199050047,
-0.0240681674,
-0.050850153,
-0.0214720666,
0.0014637093,
0.0200844258,
0.0002335569,
0.0235990752,
0.0396738499,
-0.0041570691,
-0.031812869,
0.0125847692,
0.0019161886,
-0.0265464634,
-0.0184411891,
0.0353598632,
-0.0391419232,
0.0238577221,
-0.010396353,
-0.065043591,
0.0437317155,
0.0066693714,
0.0567151494,
0.0391287692,
-0.0617961176,
0.0129454304,
-0.0228446759,
0.0278273001,
-0.0241388511,
-0.0237172879,
-0.0574376471,
0.0110891536,
-0.0628602877,
-0.0553493612,
-0.0606237128,
0.0418771654,
-0.052773077,
-0.0408320539,
0.0005940982,
0.0582188927,
0.0096323714,
-0.0285718236,
-0.017675072,
0.0571131781,
-0.0434307754,
0.0213536825,
-0.0558055565,
0.0463280492,
-0.04215011,
-0.0181769151,
0.0644379407,
-0.0741091371,
-0.0004565536,
0.0285828188,
0.0167439897,
-0.0255856644,
-0.0254531447,
0.0256369319,
-0.032069467,
-0.0107369507,
-0.0128465975,
-0.0880983099,
-0.0339996554,
-0.0232052095,
0.0404183082,
-0.0531974733,
0.0316231288,
0.016510386,
-0.035712909,
0.0032193051,
0.0081818169,
0.0678675398,
-0.0158441309,
0.0298618935,
-0.0071436954,
0.0135554066,
0.0491524488,
0.0224574618,
0.0315312818,
0.0693619475,
-0.0000729453,
0.0177206118,
0.0521741919,
0.0047354554,
0.025657203,
0.0078108017,
0.0119231548,
0.0125039583,
-0.044253692,
0.0240526292,
0.0025336656,
0.0072035231,
0.0064315223,
0.0335326381,
-0.050646577,
0.0116563765,
0.0392080843,
-0.0000891319,
0.0180534627,
-0.0162878167,
0.050350409,
0.0004524495,
0.0002334599,
0.0304379612,
0.0015161263,
0.0851105526,
-0.0274507888,
0.0071399109,
0.0549373664,
0.0455875881,
-0.0285040159,
-0.0398900211,
-0.0209970567,
0.0229685549,
0.0066981083,
0.0369683951,
0.0136600574,
0.0402944461,
-0.0429972857,
0.0246896632,
0.0035231733,
-0.0726329833,
0.0307401754,
-0.045454517,
0.0165988207,
0.0836696252,
0.1040970609,
-0.0066887191,
-0.0241152644,
0.0255971309,
0.0385028087,
0.0436218642,
0.0357395671,
-0.0037703272,
-0.0093805483,
-0.0482368506,
-0.0400887914,
-0.0333300084,
-0.01966835,
0.0117897801,
0.0303985421,
-0.0131476782,
0.019966647,
-0.0397990011,
0.0088730585,
0.0296514891,
0.0230275299,
-0.01846998,
-0.0060355035,
0.0088427756,
-0.0110362554,
0.0101587111,
-0.0041622301,
0.0400931723,
0.0113229295,
-0.0187169015,
-0.0218684133,
0.0166805685,
-0.0300460346,
-0.0363908969,
-0.0100025134,
-0.0015806614,
0.0223993324,
-0.0019007393,
0.0011685739,
-0.0309287291,
0.0112813525,
-0.0704851598,
0.0237886868,
-0.0671515018,
-0.0275782198,
0.0531938076,
0.0213957857,
-0.0604356639,
0.0518665239,
0.0019656585,
-0.0168087557,
0.040182475,
0.0137473028,
0.0147819445,
-0.0455690436,
0.0118841911,
0.0359607041,
-0.0304123648,
0.0264462531,
0.0430273153,
-0.0248415042,
-0.0678493083,
-0.0114067635,
-0.0899750739,
-0.0234368294,
-0.0072002192,
-0.0049823103,
0.0023946073,
0.0443217158,
0.0148621472,
-0.0196793955,
-0.0463406444,
0.020652635,
0.0435853489,
0.0611716621,
0.0113516236,
0.0318632014,
0.0195858311,
-0.0321787111,
-0.0109512024,
0.0192769244,
0.0672528222,
0.004369779,
0.0042871162,
-0.0322786868,
-0.0132175731,
-0.090927951,
0.0114143351,
0.0077200904,
-0.0244991183,
0.0478853881,
-0.0480633266,
0.0517498888,
0.0088701826,
0.0307127461,
0.0069749132,
0.0296168514,
-0.0455395319,
-0.0817347541,
0.0279441327,
-0.0255301259,
-0.050952144,
0.0455998778,
-0.0302198231,
0.0153567242,
-0.0045179832,
0.0163804386,
-0.0120448153,
-0.044197008,
0.0355499536,
0.0047978503,
-0.055409424,
-0.0523716919,
-0.0331248157,
-0.0056830891,
0.0418780111,
-0.0288799126,
-0.0464681722,
0.0518725403,
-0.010334393,
-0.0113662248,
-0.0278432164,
0.0382470824,
-0.0085256072,
0.0568847917,
0.0000258317,
0.0314374939,
-0.0353822224,
-0.0069423956,
-0.0611274987,
0.0036760017,
0.0242376067,
-0.0622073337,
0.0255793016,
-0.0367020182,
0.0196192004,
0.0089561306,
-0.0151170827,
-0.0680106729,
-0.0120309247,
0.0350231938,
-0.0231568012,
-0.0489223897,
-0.0017028137,
-0.0198264048,
0.0184359569,
0.0459891781,
0.0000015221,
-0.0249724705,
-0.0365728587,
-0.0050403466,
0.0726452023,
0.0675940663,
0.0286709387,
-0.0254445765,
-0.032222271,
-0.0143279135,
0.0662195086,
0.0531874895,
-0.0162948575,
-0.0118187377,
-0.0117433527,
0.0445741788,
0.0127628446,
-0.0208672862,
0.0352005512,
0.031478364,
-0.0622101091,
-0.0274354722,
0.0384505764,
0.0551519468,
-0.026581971,
-0.0208741594,
-0.0189363286,
0.0625951141,
0.0301666297,
0.0561672933,
-0.0738076791,
-0.0179413091,
-0.0016519227,
0.033458706,
-0.0090871658,
0.0089357598,
-0.0124460617,
-0.1226570159,
0.0678541586,
-0.0159622412,
-0.0071814782,
0.0032572902,
-0.0212290809,
0.009111736,
0.0734404027,
0.0004509414,
0.0604465492,
-0.0189135689,
0.0101430761,
0.0102800075,
0.0384122655,
-0.0083453991,
-0.0367105976,
0.0057184962,
-0.0492555052,
0.0931764469,
0.0106084114,
0.0261049364,
-0.0624032207,
0.0144471647,
-0.0104539087,
0.0604449697,
-0.0250888467,
0.0423661545,
0.0064550741,
0.0101397298,
-0.0315042585,
-0.0158610288,
0.019671984,
-0.0434727743,
-0.0179420281,
0.0467808992,
-0.0491409339,
0.0220960677,
-0.0836606845,
0.026577428,
0.0004704537,
0.0388251096,
0.0365188122,
-0.03833488,
-0.0109009249,
0.0126675665,
0.0598406121,
-0.0737899095,
-0.0070410795,
0.007727698,
0.0136983171,
0.0127537902,
-0.1053272113,
-0.0403363556,
0.0000847413,
0.0415394902,
-0.017054433,
0.0081646917,
-0.0564827733,
0.0078304755,
-0.0685504377,
0.0365169942,
-0.0245219413,
-0.0166080929,
-0.0056382944,
-0.0322864987,
0.0108134653,
-0.0548709407,
-0.0033192923,
0.012463388,
-0.0346774086,
-0.0429871492,
-0.025896199,
0.0348412506,
0.018029565,
-0.0012078061,
0.0382147953,
-0.0449888445,
0.0153297763,
0.0667327046,
-0.0126356948,
0.0055214032,
-0.0415648818,
-0.0191812962,
-0.0213378575,
-0.0062822988,
-0.0707717612,
-0.008969265,
-0.0246824361,
0.0753606483,
0.0181729123,
-0.0455636457,
0.0364278965,
0.0150129376,
0.0112927537,
-0.0118685346,
0.0107127018,
-0.0107428143,
-0.0021336393,
-0.021413859,
-0.0181570239,
-0.0394206271,
0.0314260051,
-0.039313633,
-0.0201048199,
0.0343151391,
0.0215696059,
-0.014728534,
0.0737024173,
-0.0271216501,
-0.0208752863,
-0.0111800497,
-0.0348300412,
0.0048940717,
0.024486376,
-0.0220452398,
0.0179362986,
-0.009166304,
0.0434158742,
-0.0304700285,
0.0900229886,
0.0125935934,
-0.0331833921,
-0.0154759102,
0.0302852672,
-0.0614461973,
-0.0338416882,
-0.0179038215,
0.0107309762,
0.0237592496,
0.014360195,
0.0319920518,
-0.0125227841,
-0.0154506033,
0.0019515384,
0.0187508166,
0.0314972512,
-0.0431963317,
0.0166607425,
0.037233457,
0.010341825,
-0.0187902972,
0.0425077341,
-0.0550109409,
0.0198024828,
-0.0478486307,
-0.0277619753,
-0.0302858707,
-0.0527779795,
0.0199535303,
0.0412829742,
0.0036095807,
-0.0058068908,
-0.0500653312,
-0.0423939526,
-0.0004267908,
0.0123938126,
-0.0376344286,
0.0028564399,
0.0722365305,
0.0828615502,
0.0288288724,
-0.0468221605,
-0.0430180356,
0.0328125507,
-0.077936247,
-0.0013021015,
0.0051995441,
-6.641762753e-33,
-0.0296602603,
-0.0422626585,
0.0564769469,
-0.0729982853,
-0.0385684781,
-0.0053694807,
-0.0285666436,
0.0192766748,
-0.0013796872,
-0.0333862863,
-0.0029357465,
-0.015676165,
-0.0001844945,
0.0344319493,
-0.0052473214,
0.0023828747,
0.0338227004,
0.0043828879,
-0.0477874205,
0.0340172648,
0.0622247644,
0.0081927963,
0.0096201515,
-0.023992002,
-0.0070976969,
0.0098241242,
0.0002653783,
0.0079815611,
-0.0044700815,
0.0844547674,
-0.0164992493,
0.0555940419,
0.0189036746,
-0.0061071813,
-0.0062833112,
0.0117150135,
-0.0400341749,
-0.0166130438,
0.0041257325,
-0.0020294331,
-0.0939516723,
-0.0180065092,
0.0352609269,
-0.0281766467,
0.0110061094,
-0.0107324068,
0.0353679992,
-0.0086915968,
-0.0183607787,
-0.0044882512,
-0.0612014793,
0.006376307,
0.021304952,
-0.0076102293,
-0.0162419975,
0.1042739376,
0.0374936238,
0.0233007334,
-0.0418232903,
0.0390717015,
-0.0281040706,
0.0485627167,
0.0584970266,
0.0300166141,
-0.0066865985,
0.0413557701,
0.0320415385,
-0.0057290485,
-0.0143885566,
-0.0145918364,
0.0305315219,
0.0430824496,
0.0251586232,
0.0593540259,
0.0253903158,
-0.0046100938,
-0.0176052991,
0.0496155396,
-0.0360348113,
0.0598408356,
0.0234595649,
0.0048218207,
-0.0103007508,
0.020126069,
-0.0406469032,
0.0480091237,
-0.0660033599,
-0.0379573144,
0.0582485609,
0.0431475416,
-0.0325310975,
0.0057122689,
0.0727555677,
0.0103482474,
0.0008962477,
0.0069023971,
-0.0494419299,
0.0518049188,
-0.0207076669,
0.0129007502,
0.0393408611,
0.0036491961,
0.0661949739,
-0.0141034108,
-0.0246003773,
0.017629154,
-0.0001864895,
0.0272423308,
-0.0510594845,
0.0073599559,
-0.0445007235,
0.0283382069,
-0.0320221111,
-0.0437494069,
0.024359649,
0.0273064561,
-0.0334549472,
0.0191483069,
0.0181785207,
-0.0040166876,
-0.043411091,
-0.061357677,
0.0178539678,
0.0053458638,
-0.0151397642,
0.0632019863,
-0.0323242359,
0.0030674771,
0.0030599835,
-0.048135493,
-0.0315868743,
0.052922111,
2.747e-7,
0.0382169001,
0.0244494416,
0.0153773418,
0.0297347587,
0.007231148,
-0.0049512158,
0.0185716469,
-0.0077846064,
0.0491284244,
-0.0133369202,
-0.0266280156,
0.0358223841,
0.0369184315,
0.0331830643,
-0.0512983091,
-0.0341113061,
-0.0394754484,
0.0017841635,
-0.0438578017,
-0.0129644824,
0.0800341442,
0.012376111,
-0.050044395,
-0.0445368253,
-0.0015159538,
-0.0453994162,
0.0948142037,
0.0379184783,
-0.0204451084,
0.0156947058,
0.0251714196,
0.0341673158,
0.0284095313,
-0.0228496604,
-0.0210923813,
-0.040251065,
0.0108409412,
-0.0160195231,
-0.0171725322,
-0.0841948763,
-0.0117178177,
0.0152466809,
-0.0062647308,
-0.0430151187,
0.0698510632,
-0.024009997,
0.0204824507,
-0.0166016035,
-0.0344749726,
0.0014164515,
-0.0089856917,
-0.0389874279,
-0.0508330166,
0.040370781,
0.0010222093,
0.0096818591,
-0.0225640591,
-0.0497577004,
-0.0283670891,
0.0070272721,
-0.0475711934,
-0.0500547588,
-0.053095758,
-0.005177632,
-0.0321774557,
-0.0305922739,
-0.0500517115,
2.503651668e-34,
0.0054622595,
0.0261005778,
0.0331088305,
0.0232116971,
0.0054331101,
-0.0032175404,
-0.0187769886,
0.0024104584,
0.0179495737,
-0.0840133876,
-0.0409202762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01212v1 | EconNLI: Evaluating Large Language Models on Economics Reasoning | 2024-07-01T11:58:24 | 2024-07-01T11:58:24 | Yue Guo, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used for writing economic analysis
reports or providing financial advice, but their ability to understand economic
knowledge and reason about potential results of specific economic events lacks
systematic evaluation. To address this gap, we propose a new dataset, natural
language inference on economic events (EconNLI), to evaluate LLMs' knowledge
and reasoning abilities in the economic domain. We evaluate LLMs on (1) their
ability to correctly classify whether a premise event will cause a hypothesis
event and (2) their ability to generate reasonable events resulting from a
given premise. Our experiments reveal that LLMs are not sophisticated in
economic reasoning and may generate wrong or hallucinated answers. Our study
raises awareness of the limitations of using LLMs for critical decision-making
involving economic reasoning and analysis. The dataset and codes are available
at https://github.com/Irenehere/EconNLI. | EconNLI: Evaluating Large Language Models on Economics Reasoning: Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used for writing economic analysis
reports or providing financial advice, but their ability to understand economic
knowledge and reason about potential results of specific economic events lacks
systematic evaluation. To address this gap, we propose a new dataset, natural
language inference on economic events (EconNLI), to evaluate LLMs' knowledge
and reasoning abilities in the economic domain. We evaluate LLMs on (1) their
ability to correctly classify whether a premise event will cause a hypothesis
event and (2) their ability to generate reasonable events resulting from a
given premise. Our experiments reveal that LLMs are not sophisticated in
economic reasoning and may generate wrong or hallucinated answers. Our study
raises awareness of the limitations of using LLMs for critical decision-making
involving economic reasoning and analysis. The dataset and codes are available
at https://github.com/Irenehere/EconNLI. | [
-0.006425899,
0.1048446298,
0.0086758863,
0.0584643781,
-0.0407534167,
0.0194796268,
0.0276616104,
0.0065297266,
0.0503212139,
-0.021911297,
0.0158590917,
0.0137503864,
-0.0026062266,
0.0387223661,
0.0475109443,
-0.0315772519,
0.0156229604,
-0.0176885556,
0.0630179048,
-0.0182403345,
-0.0096889399,
0.0153938048,
-0.0109488107,
0.021780666,
0.0128801502,
0.002816207,
-0.0085316654,
-0.0361718722,
0.0082933558,
-0.0394161902,
-0.0130747622,
0.038983658,
0.0487989932,
0.029808348,
0.0000020779,
-0.0942172781,
-0.0164196976,
-0.0394952074,
-0.0294238962,
0.0278050061,
0.0409804098,
-0.0061171991,
0.0406022556,
0.0236541927,
-0.0556470826,
0.0055045197,
0.0466372594,
0.0815840065,
0.0358782187,
0.0566229932,
-0.0011556783,
-0.0736477599,
-0.0101208091,
-0.0479272492,
-0.0012055258,
-0.053417109,
0.0528056771,
0.0215588287,
-0.0321062729,
-0.0314734839,
0.0036495326,
0.0159444343,
0.0137352804,
-0.0190175418,
-0.0433393866,
0.060187947,
-0.0551504381,
-0.0048421407,
-0.00691916,
0.0470786206,
0.0349940397,
0.0107919574,
0.0106007513,
-0.0256236829,
0.0162352882,
0.0147052361,
-0.04817174,
0.0401246957,
-0.0110683944,
0.057827469,
0.0712454841,
0.0301698111,
0.0385535099,
0.0564305522,
-0.0405797325,
0.0940358862,
-0.033438243,
-0.036092829,
0.0179681648,
0.0261699148,
-0.0377987884,
-0.0673962757,
-0.0199938882,
0.0150235565,
0.0063178074,
0.031944491,
0.0157620162,
0.0247664973,
-0.0121967299,
-0.0736889541,
0.0062589021,
0.0225553662,
0.0144368876,
0.0589099713,
-0.0312318336,
-0.009317697,
-0.0369014814,
-0.0224798806,
0.0446356162,
0.0427983589,
-0.0239242446,
-0.0157724842,
-0.015732225,
0.0267699007,
-0.0127308434,
-0.0067515839,
-0.0314622298,
-0.038033098,
-0.0341663212,
0.0251823813,
-0.0020467374,
0.0324200504,
-0.0064793131,
-0.0497256443,
-0.1131899133,
0.0257925838,
-0.0303742066,
0.0658223107,
-0.0053879442,
-0.0270885807,
-0.0039359177,
0.0140318237,
-0.001045057,
-0.0165386256,
0.0338654928,
0.0922975466,
0.0331738628,
0.0232992489,
-0.0869135484,
-0.0365424119,
0.0079042651,
-0.0586994812,
-0.0505782813,
-0.0678734556,
0.0086731305,
0.0073641213,
-0.0108043486,
-0.0379604213,
0.0044177193,
0.004367393,
-0.0472017452,
0.0766139701,
-0.0322886854,
-0.0170387439,
0.0070575788,
-0.017387962,
0.0033336522,
0.0664051846,
0.034065064,
0.0271226205,
0.0268204138,
0.0147369104,
-0.0099582449,
0.0305287447,
-0.0275538489,
-0.0191800613,
-0.028368609,
0.0130392518,
-0.0566179231,
0.02691002,
0.0389969572,
0.0059806448,
-0.0207443666,
-0.0061817789,
0.0616156645,
0.0295993648,
0.0078893024,
0.0076194583,
0.0187976249,
0.0026918836,
-0.0032150422,
-0.0199451819,
-0.0005825406,
0.0228996556,
-0.0412157774,
-0.0105908681,
0.0330829956,
-0.0208646897,
-0.0136137381,
-0.0516509637,
-0.0068244026,
-0.0294401962,
-0.0003775834,
0.0252812784,
0.0571177267,
-0.0359616056,
-0.0383746326,
0.0370272473,
0.0419760607,
-0.0087304926,
-0.0168787837,
-0.018780347,
0.0787052363,
0.0591978617,
0.0231270213,
-0.0155052571,
0.0155061856,
-0.0182698704,
-0.0000927101,
0.0670787767,
0.0723722577,
0.0009985932,
-0.0134172263,
-0.0345844962,
-0.0003366353,
-0.0187835153,
0.0329251997,
0.024093952,
0.0080426345,
-0.0072759674,
-0.0056189019,
0.0084171705,
0.0190054495,
0.0329454318,
-0.0191907436,
-0.0430883281,
-0.0255658012,
-0.0300053395,
0.0055973153,
-0.0274827797,
0.0017856506,
0.0312026273,
-0.0059322473,
-0.0142610595,
-0.0492972434,
0.0296276677,
-0.0031423769,
-0.004611887,
0.0180281345,
-0.0497407541,
-0.0455462262,
-0.015267319,
-0.0480921194,
-0.0145403119,
0.0306862332,
0.0094067315,
0.020879427,
-0.0375564247,
-0.0391699523,
-0.0050425143,
0.0098384973,
0.0094965231,
0.0934155285,
0.0206960421,
0.0145174693,
0.0137892701,
0.0092625087,
-0.003133354,
-0.0555461012,
0.0141026238,
0.0154139185,
-0.0056611313,
-0.009612998,
0.0320679173,
-0.0018195376,
-0.0278960038,
0.0134516144,
-0.0475442633,
-0.0007534695,
0.0090027209,
0.0375698768,
0.0124398451,
-0.0661791041,
-0.0219003074,
0.0126863373,
-0.0047018747,
-0.0024570844,
0.0132757267,
0.0134524805,
0.0589160845,
-0.032976456,
0.0079172458,
-0.0241704341,
0.0055940254,
-0.0427200794,
0.038090203,
0.0774329677,
0.0149870031,
-0.0603419021,
0.0154213188,
-0.0172692277,
-0.0006274327,
-0.007083694,
0.0002719958,
-0.0205549225,
-0.0277929269,
0.0072084339,
0.0552586429,
-0.0183223076,
0.0425315425,
0.0398190022,
-0.0300810263,
-0.0586817712,
-0.0067693326,
-0.0366342254,
0.0347337574,
-0.0613483191,
-0.0296569876,
-0.0142881358,
0.0878316164,
0.0055031152,
0.0137364427,
-0.0368863717,
0.0771557614,
-0.0182943027,
0.0062348559,
-0.0247403458,
-0.0000707473,
0.0044323402,
0.0987109318,
0.022712037,
-0.0451947637,
0.0754941255,
-0.0005913092,
-0.0086059375,
-0.0328846723,
0.0063254028,
-0.0665746108,
0.0371629372,
-0.0196723808,
-0.0299942251,
-0.0083474517,
-0.0069377259,
-0.0337602757,
-0.0308407359,
0.0375042893,
0.0236645639,
0.0420023203,
-0.0924186334,
0.0215728935,
-0.0099666705,
0.0001227282,
-0.0183169041,
-0.0709368959,
-0.0570209548,
-0.0026279928,
0.021587437,
-0.0197646711,
-0.057319928,
-0.0101837721,
0.0225151461,
-0.0175390523,
-0.0133997686,
-0.0333320536,
0.0201593935,
0.0264289193,
0.0180520844,
0.012288441,
0.0321991146,
-0.0286252517,
0.0434188172,
0.0386986695,
-0.0188742802,
0.0445496067,
-0.0405463427,
0.0247236062,
0.0017680583,
-0.0078848749,
0.0279731695,
0.0463931002,
-0.0055436953,
-0.0608032644,
-0.0004943936,
0.1082359776,
0.0068895612,
0.0154421255,
0.0123733627,
-0.0271138288,
0.0197028052,
-0.0028151893,
0.0132193752,
-0.0719024241,
-0.0398396738,
-0.0044632498,
-0.0116312159,
-0.0036153947,
-0.0721164942,
-0.0162276924,
-0.1262242347,
0.0501762033,
-0.0128825009,
0.0109430794,
-0.0201180167,
-0.0627434626,
-0.017987242,
-0.0802482143,
-0.0122663826,
-0.0026878528,
-0.0058776145,
0.0173107591,
0.0178388916,
-0.0729048625,
-0.030414151,
0.049892053,
-0.0018051431,
0.0038825998,
0.022294987,
0.0481555611,
-0.0488245599,
0.0071680169,
-0.0213243123,
0.0101303486,
-0.0241968241,
0.007827444,
0.0330716521,
0.0181983169,
-0.0145798214,
-0.0271048844,
0.0474787802,
-0.0310118254,
-0.0257424992,
0.0288135912,
0.0374666788,
-0.027449647,
-0.0770917758,
0.0372183956,
0.0542510375,
-0.0258467533,
0.0790416449,
0.0050686277,
-0.0195329506,
-0.0596635826,
-0.0486031696,
-0.0690211281,
-0.0503650457,
-0.0259317197,
0.0177257303,
0.0379287489,
-0.0280816145,
-0.0360655263,
-0.0568003654,
0.0425194912,
-0.0036446864,
-0.0202261209,
-0.0043928376,
0.0539130345,
0.0170701891,
0.000315366,
0.0533194989,
-0.0531762168,
0.0194943231,
0.0141534423,
0.0365668647,
0.0188539438,
0.0038218631,
-0.0335114859,
0.0348380096,
-0.0762700066,
-0.0685598105,
-0.0015067998,
0.0159792509,
0.032320153,
0.0054698247,
0.0051236926,
-0.0055705025,
-0.0292126909,
0.0328892879,
-0.0221253969,
-0.0205606036,
0.0257796329,
0.0299649779,
0.0207186099,
0.0298007466,
-0.0050860192,
0.0243633371,
-0.015845973,
0.0442883298,
-0.0627595186,
-0.0245563984,
0.0055934633,
0.0027310397,
0.0291832108,
-0.0181154311,
-0.0119955251,
-0.0362983011,
0.0004905938,
-0.0196815021,
-0.0139371231,
-0.0101603419,
-0.012419085,
0.0259153675,
-0.002358838,
-0.0243361127,
0.001158504,
-0.0292037074,
-0.0293533709,
0.0314336158,
0.0626099482,
0.0330005512,
0.0172422081,
0.0365609489,
-0.0473877713,
-0.0153229805,
-0.0170778818,
-0.0325421952,
0.0376678817,
0.0178914163,
0.0394800119,
0.0285431035,
-0.0069606928,
0.0192450974,
-0.0506691262,
-0.0078779515,
-0.0696142316,
0.0304087978,
0.0260175355,
0.0289840661,
-0.0543913245,
0.0267796125,
-0.0799972415,
0.0123653291,
0.0245065652,
0.0388395488,
-0.0280113071,
-0.0401059128,
0.0731271505,
-0.0044708811,
-0.0808334202,
-0.0066920128,
0.0865782574,
0.0205662083,
0.0318198614,
-0.0166334286,
-0.0073792147,
-0.015748689,
-0.05303194,
0.022793062,
-0.033228185,
-0.0055588456,
0.010312913,
-0.0699641481,
-0.046876289,
-0.0380437113,
0.0221436843,
-0.0172065031,
0.0014601565,
-0.0065430668,
0.0501126945,
0.0054186196,
0.0400410332,
0.0035151781,
0.0504502393,
-0.0621358417,
-0.0068494109,
-0.0903122276,
-6.42338382e-33,
0.0169235803,
-0.0583642498,
0.0265459493,
-0.0176570974,
0.0566156879,
-0.0075500994,
-0.0406020954,
-0.0053578536,
-0.0293630771,
0.0279447399,
0.0238328576,
0.0178624019,
0.0162598919,
0.0137518495,
0.0164618567,
-0.0387724638,
-0.0113403127,
0.0075902962,
-0.0097625293,
-0.0356203057,
0.0100566745,
0.0140338112,
0.0886710137,
-0.0390071571,
0.0611645132,
-0.0110811945,
-0.0054416726,
0.0107763698,
-0.0192187801,
0.0186630879,
0.0002208521,
0.0315021202,
0.0163421147,
-0.0863445178,
-0.0078479303,
0.0338397212,
-0.0028480163,
-0.0507859252,
0.029713165,
-0.0018575212,
-0.0193413142,
-0.0160462074,
0.023670977,
0.0463400297,
-0.0159997083,
0.0149716912,
0.048195526,
-0.0274504013,
0.0366071574,
0.021023795,
-0.0616365857,
0.0540892482,
-0.0346260555,
0.0332372785,
-0.0089824814,
0.0788096637,
-0.0253350455,
0.0178121701,
-0.0222019106,
0.0329424813,
0.0094758421,
-0.0168722626,
0.029834345,
-0.0530776158,
0.0122621534,
0.0719767958,
-0.0183689017,
-0.0120750107,
-0.0594251528,
0.0110984389,
0.0070993165,
0.0517485142,
0.0392039344,
0.0345072895,
0.0234005433,
0.0272693858,
-0.0853857249,
0.0072426749,
0.0477828979,
0.0502727591,
0.0445148461,
0.0037256004,
-0.0027032818,
-0.0505399257,
-0.058239162,
-0.0073111723,
-0.0213050023,
-0.0082022958,
0.0115330601,
-0.0195476711,
0.0243141837,
0.020184679,
0.0152018927,
-0.02866574,
-0.0707677156,
0.0250736848,
0.0133101642,
-0.0046976637,
-0.0002388302,
0.0189325437,
-0.0702293664,
-0.0059947455,
-0.0072780014,
0.0018252176,
0.0288793631,
-0.0083957752,
-0.0023964955,
-0.0076429681,
-0.0242078342,
-0.0082127769,
-0.046687115,
-0.0162716992,
0.0241271779,
0.0254964437,
0.0247126557,
0.0192030389,
0.0098707657,
-0.0191555098,
-0.0033243094,
-0.0007738936,
-0.0065761874,
-0.0109365424,
-0.0183060169,
0.0303980596,
-0.0228376444,
-0.0004258176,
-0.0311952326,
0.0208499543,
0.0135751925,
-0.0294299144,
-0.0159045551,
0.0252294987,
2.741e-7,
0.08171767,
0.0669314712,
-0.0161299873,
0.0382436663,
0.0077002007,
0.0696333796,
-0.0490120612,
0.0035573717,
0.0340915211,
-0.0070093251,
0.0160795078,
0.0316588096,
0.0435123555,
0.0371254794,
-0.0683931112,
-0.0281561594,
-0.0893599764,
0.0014439021,
-0.0541323833,
-0.0114223333,
0.0780704543,
0.0618624166,
0.0343289599,
-0.0000638638,
-0.0195529498,
-0.0412542857,
0.0532485768,
-0.0527178198,
-0.0104607567,
0.006263739,
0.0032221505,
0.0174552649,
0.0048263613,
0.0164252613,
-0.0051786178,
-0.0096966224,
-0.0327687003,
0.0553013198,
0.0134120248,
0.0059396978,
-0.0132186385,
-0.0459574796,
-0.0174223408,
-0.0547682755,
0.0721677989,
-0.1004328728,
-0.0767169371,
-0.0196484998,
-0.0006843779,
0.0062125162,
0.0249871034,
-0.0097809834,
0.0117190396,
0.0175854638,
0.0008480739,
-0.0204936974,
0.0074054934,
-0.0341476314,
-0.0360746495,
0.048783917,
-0.0612437502,
-0.0241003782,
-0.0179348998,
0.0276709758,
0.0325049236,
-0.0507291779,
0.0235921554,
2.367850617e-34,
0.0077568539,
0.0191512294,
-0.0259980969,
0.0096116494,
0.0846268162,
0.0084152631,
-0.0163223483,
0.0571979247,
0.0063529345,
-0.08083269,
0.0020866781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01178v1 | $\text{Memory}^3$: Language Modeling with Explicit Memory | 2024-07-01T11:07:23 | 2024-07-01T11:07:23 | Hongkang Yang, Zehao Lin, Wenjin Wang, Hao Wu, Zhiyu Li, Bo Tang, Wenqiang Wei, Jinbo Wang, Zeyun Tang, Shichao Song, Chenyang Xi, Yu Yu, Kai Chen, Feiyu Xiong, Linpeng Tang, Weinan E | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | The training and inference of large language models (LLMs) are together a
costly process that transports knowledge from raw data to meaningful
computation. Inspired by the memory hierarchy of the human brain, we reduce
this cost by equipping LLMs with explicit memory, a memory format cheaper than
model parameters and text retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Conceptually,
with most of its knowledge externalized to explicit memories, the LLM can enjoy
a smaller parameter size, training cost, and inference cost, all proportional
to the amount of remaining "abstract knowledge". As a preliminary proof of
concept, we train from scratch a 2.4B LLM, which achieves better performance
than much larger LLMs as well as RAG models, and maintains higher decoding
speed than RAG. The model is named $\text{Memory}^3$, since explicit memory is
the third form of memory in LLMs after implicit memory (model parameters) and
working memory (context key-values). We introduce a memory circuitry theory to
support the externalization of knowledge, and present novel techniques
including a memory sparsification mechanism that makes storage tractable and a
two-stage pretraining scheme that facilitates memory formation. | $\text{Memory}^3$: Language Modeling with Explicit Memory: The training and inference of large language models (LLMs) are together a
costly process that transports knowledge from raw data to meaningful
computation. Inspired by the memory hierarchy of the human brain, we reduce
this cost by equipping LLMs with explicit memory, a memory format cheaper than
model parameters and text retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Conceptually,
with most of its knowledge externalized to explicit memories, the LLM can enjoy
a smaller parameter size, training cost, and inference cost, all proportional
to the amount of remaining "abstract knowledge". As a preliminary proof of
concept, we train from scratch a 2.4B LLM, which achieves better performance
than much larger LLMs as well as RAG models, and maintains higher decoding
speed than RAG. The model is named $\text{Memory}^3$, since explicit memory is
the third form of memory in LLMs after implicit memory (model parameters) and
working memory (context key-values). We introduce a memory circuitry theory to
support the externalization of knowledge, and present novel techniques
including a memory sparsification mechanism that makes storage tractable and a
two-stage pretraining scheme that facilitates memory formation. | [
0.0354859941,
0.0500852242,
-0.0118330196,
0.0180073697,
-0.0133671314,
0.017009832,
-0.0293240864,
-0.0005076313,
-0.0098100249,
-0.0506724119,
-0.0273788776,
-0.0445059165,
-0.018440567,
0.0102628525,
0.043840643,
-0.0084122838,
0.0787968934,
-0.0413580388,
-0.0005319542,
-0.0001524482,
0.0068715359,
0.0082380194,
0.0076634078,
-0.0225096028,
-0.0137855019,
0.0328889899,
-0.059724886,
0.0002610268,
-0.0381514132,
-0.0396366417,
-0.014955081,
0.0257788245,
0.0638949201,
0.0054333638,
0.0000023734,
-0.0477540754,
-0.0030180037,
-0.0165415984,
-0.0444285125,
0.0413648449,
0.0190548208,
-0.0157083068,
0.006654155,
0.0157097969,
-0.0238782,
-0.0188616998,
0.081438072,
0.0276328586,
0.0114753516,
0.066499643,
-0.0135116018,
-0.0546866246,
0.0470100343,
-0.03093848,
0.0456213392,
-0.0282186307,
0.0169081148,
0.0068680211,
-0.0376983657,
0.0181023628,
-0.0105912574,
0.0406178534,
0.0148017332,
0.0571578257,
0.0188219603,
0.0463118441,
-0.0110464962,
-0.0123558873,
-0.02682014,
0.0160604659,
0.0208341908,
-0.0860657468,
0.0017133388,
0.0246748943,
-0.0263370089,
-0.0105341179,
-0.0297568552,
0.0559607185,
-0.0083879577,
0.0239132233,
0.0229540151,
-0.0285024736,
0.047694698,
0.0155017059,
-0.0473036841,
0.0121917119,
0.0177782476,
-0.0229891594,
0.0033835198,
0.0049202507,
-0.0098300511,
-0.010411758,
0.0170439668,
0.0396133214,
0.0345852338,
0.0322260372,
-0.0543449596,
-0.0515561663,
0.0084769111,
-0.0691067651,
0.0433284827,
0.0635592565,
0.0206605475,
0.0152774276,
-0.0581262596,
0.0142756039,
-0.0478733294,
0.0258386377,
-0.0500805266,
0.0154960388,
-0.0210107993,
-0.0201860629,
-0.0632420927,
0.0678048134,
0.005388617,
-0.0105492258,
-0.0177307352,
0.0203708131,
0.0199833289,
-0.032070905,
-0.0280778296,
0.0274293721,
-0.0354824923,
0.0118390406,
-0.0279731322,
0.0098366914,
0.0134289591,
-0.0103115495,
0.0121973371,
-0.0539355427,
-0.0237013716,
0.0017642827,
0.0215545017,
-0.0077446364,
0.038446378,
0.0570049621,
-0.0400867611,
-0.049135901,
-0.0857180059,
-0.0157152787,
0.0333234854,
-0.0665314198,
0.0086578112,
-0.0683485046,
0.0439619236,
0.0204731002,
-0.0227304194,
-0.0342731625,
0.027082799,
0.0400956124,
-0.0520646311,
0.0614176616,
-0.0071174232,
-0.0198470354,
0.0485593788,
0.0081083439,
0.043832548,
0.0500040688,
0.0387468673,
0.0148524493,
-0.0030095608,
0.0073961876,
-0.044664856,
0.032498572,
0.0751652941,
-0.0060711559,
-0.0514273904,
-0.0073528197,
0.0296779405,
-0.0020153418,
0.044637274,
0.0629463121,
-0.0276610665,
-0.0186372604,
0.0507245623,
0.0465844013,
-0.0051090922,
0.0287072081,
0.051106967,
-0.0165644512,
0.0297514405,
-0.0109821809,
-0.0146092344,
0.0443044193,
-0.0529678017,
0.0251887925,
0.0433044247,
0.002929992,
-0.0359048881,
-0.0234486051,
-0.0174308512,
-0.0299269594,
0.0307210796,
0.014360005,
0.057744015,
0.0133066066,
-0.0647817627,
0.0985502228,
0.034230452,
-0.0405408144,
-0.0102304053,
-0.0455603302,
0.047586035,
0.0484709367,
0.0280320365,
0.0008555896,
0.0177967101,
0.0194813535,
-0.0047963182,
0.0311845355,
0.0381619185,
0.0097265085,
-0.0055372207,
-0.0732137561,
0.0248571858,
-0.0050578602,
0.0171222687,
0.0421341397,
0.052490592,
0.0010724412,
0.0205665343,
0.024329355,
-0.0191731304,
0.0114555787,
-0.0511527881,
-0.0353358537,
-0.0214710105,
-0.0105627729,
0.0215476304,
-0.0063399109,
-0.0106899394,
0.0390450135,
0.066809319,
-0.055507984,
0.0063449447,
-0.0156757347,
-0.0878388733,
-0.0114227151,
0.0125502395,
0.0404207297,
0.0436646529,
0.0163679738,
-0.0032515638,
-0.0670513585,
0.0394880697,
-0.0546339415,
0.1055948809,
-0.0672569275,
0.0320389643,
0.043139834,
0.0109935133,
-0.0217628069,
0.0734873936,
-0.0440810062,
0.0098542571,
0.0083123287,
0.0341329575,
0.0032297429,
-0.0292648319,
-0.0298250988,
0.00531903,
0.0025749267,
0.0329280049,
-0.0055296416,
-0.043301966,
-0.0425647274,
0.0069669718,
-0.050384935,
0.0204646997,
-0.0051556537,
0.0038494631,
0.0062239971,
0.0202925913,
0.0270045865,
-0.010879972,
-0.0343570672,
0.0346190035,
0.0084470399,
0.0180205163,
-0.0208572727,
0.0215133708,
-0.0098158615,
-0.0218536947,
-0.0219818316,
0.00006334,
0.0442026816,
-0.0010284286,
-0.0316793919,
-0.0547045209,
0.0789238364,
-0.0261622444,
0.0514209419,
-0.0137458108,
-0.0500737727,
0.001251281,
-0.0692502409,
0.0413004793,
0.0375041515,
0.0049258531,
-0.0067315819,
0.0628996268,
-0.0188863166,
-0.0364555717,
0.0116443224,
-0.0315109454,
-0.0511062704,
-0.0122426376,
-0.0309957024,
-0.0385106578,
0.0996207297,
0.0214785449,
0.0092171365,
-0.0536229424,
-0.0046150414,
0.0164516401,
-0.0518122464,
-0.0400101021,
-0.0188074205,
-0.0125723844,
0.0583345406,
-0.0425587557,
-0.0679628626,
0.0457251072,
-0.056484323,
0.0061485991,
-0.0116097741,
-0.0099453432,
-0.0102014262,
0.0716114566,
0.0085868482,
0.0423732288,
-0.0236704834,
0.0029366568,
-0.0206309222,
-0.0148746846,
0.0030750169,
-0.0471280552,
0.040500056,
-0.0477868803,
0.0394594669,
-0.0204524994,
-0.0238092411,
-0.0401250534,
-0.0094596222,
0.0021062526,
-0.0000911504,
0.0230841301,
-0.0076900977,
-0.0291813668,
0.0201667193,
0.0488690585,
0.0572014116,
0.0016766904,
-0.0029134734,
-0.0258645471,
0.0276674107,
0.0115689579,
0.0012986846,
-0.0113463644,
-0.0502186753,
-0.0061753164,
0.0719886571,
0.0401453376,
0.0090363203,
-0.024672363,
0.0218688846,
0.0266296063,
0.018823348,
0.0056808791,
0.0176117364,
0.0128474887,
-0.0709315687,
-0.0553502962,
0.1068435535,
0.0271766819,
-0.0598616265,
-0.0137558775,
-0.0080173723,
0.029156087,
0.0205474049,
0.0278817099,
-0.0572987422,
-0.0019130729,
0.0107310247,
-0.0038001626,
-0.0104831178,
-0.0074061668,
-0.0315751173,
-0.1309310645,
0.0025155311,
0.0219712537,
-0.0304720681,
-0.0304396879,
-0.0528261326,
-0.0647712722,
0.0429644957,
0.000147627,
0.0384191759,
0.0065791006,
-0.0079881167,
0.0260820817,
0.0190616157,
-0.0169107225,
0.0159198623,
-0.005428324,
0.0297791436,
0.0363176912,
-0.0012580276,
-0.0057900166,
-0.0192723311,
0.0197455883,
-0.0207872633,
0.0303689614,
-0.0432212241,
0.0459888056,
0.0088397646,
-0.0230831057,
-0.0372463651,
-0.0021364796,
0.0002420011,
-0.0284145959,
-0.0327213928,
0.0465464182,
-0.0205577575,
0.0234192591,
0.030588273,
-0.0075074309,
-0.0331966616,
0.0777470842,
0.0170498285,
-0.0238789134,
-0.0151758064,
-0.016599847,
-0.0073757111,
-0.0472727232,
-0.0392668247,
0.0264415387,
0.0017896607,
-0.051130414,
-0.0478909723,
-0.0044679814,
0.0144105628,
0.03121626,
0.0172787625,
0.0020680851,
0.0187027752,
-0.0386070348,
-0.117343761,
0.0133877359,
-0.0448736921,
-0.0282453038,
-0.0395118035,
-0.0561423264,
0.031140212,
-0.0444954634,
0.0060488358,
0.0295766704,
-0.0735411346,
-0.0615080483,
-0.0024430819,
0.0734398663,
0.0207941569,
0.0592032932,
0.0388656221,
-0.0216319207,
0.043501284,
0.0292793829,
-0.0822710693,
0.0735303015,
-0.0032840585,
0.02479228,
0.0107738581,
0.0138176652,
-0.0202060211,
0.0079808161,
0.0088436082,
0.0345077738,
-0.0164370928,
0.019778952,
0.0415496491,
0.0172827598,
0.0254339017,
0.015763158,
0.019176254,
-0.0300069228,
0.0329288207,
-0.0310859382,
0.0146389743,
-0.0510197915,
0.003790963,
0.0333756879,
0.0016591136,
-0.0102629568,
-0.0590787083,
0.064563185,
0.0147141023,
0.0335432962,
-0.0112254582,
0.0111167217,
0.0123170419,
0.0499723479,
-0.0067753647,
-0.0468045101,
0.0195791852,
-0.0378878452,
0.0367716514,
-0.0602863543,
0.0454126261,
0.0083123166,
-0.0002264698,
-0.0444992371,
-0.0033972459,
-0.0445181839,
-0.0462049805,
-0.0057575637,
0.0179897193,
0.0367300957,
-0.0383233018,
0.0524129681,
-0.0342407003,
-0.0091010313,
-0.0169638488,
0.0032458615,
-0.0115548922,
-0.0286777839,
0.0085394373,
0.0362443328,
-0.011734385,
0.0079282755,
0.0394414254,
0.0321640372,
0.0533613116,
-0.0071913307,
-0.0165483728,
-0.0133302277,
-0.0023222554,
0.0112414863,
0.0460080057,
-0.0074245129,
0.0100764884,
-0.0255820528,
-0.0722277239,
-0.0158113949,
0.0079673445,
-0.0069164112,
-0.0300057959,
0.0412125699,
0.0592257343,
-0.0043049259,
-0.021519484,
-0.0190345533,
0.0180301405,
-0.0358280279,
-0.0132320011,
-0.0203949716,
-7.252550352e-33,
-0.0317341276,
-0.0148581238,
0.0452193134,
-0.0441605449,
-0.0220133029,
0.0204972122,
-0.0589178838,
-0.0114152646,
-0.023274079,
-0.0322250351,
-0.0170495436,
0.006201149,
0.0042468188,
0.0407652147,
0.0069116862,
0.0117220478,
0.0402923711,
-0.0181472301,
-0.0028523107,
0.037753012,
0.0661881268,
0.0589944646,
0.06020464,
-0.0055073174,
-0.0249618292,
-0.0248712357,
0.0114334216,
0.0053724535,
-0.0057534142,
0.0334618241,
-0.0506820194,
0.0232363921,
0.0186302662,
-0.0126123959,
-0.0060399682,
-0.0063901236,
-0.1190437526,
-0.0002217532,
0.0506336167,
-0.0097824205,
-0.0060463725,
-0.0175845362,
0.0256685112,
-0.0131998612,
0.0098195467,
-0.0042534238,
-0.0101272427,
-0.0258283019,
-0.0407294743,
-0.0125963874,
-0.0277958978,
0.0046030809,
0.0198170114,
0.0078070071,
0.0328017622,
-0.0107490448,
-0.0340060778,
0.0098411255,
-0.0727092475,
0.0045108818,
-0.0035739797,
0.0801536441,
0.0285021123,
0.0510475226,
0.0256766416,
0.0443791673,
0.0386012346,
0.0008875719,
-0.0383881629,
0.0325739048,
0.0643695369,
0.0270037204,
0.0115897749,
-0.001887542,
0.0793858394,
-0.0264705494,
-0.0779220164,
-0.0215797685,
0.0230255965,
0.0486755669,
0.0636373237,
0.0261700004,
-0.0387488864,
-0.047908999,
-0.0493785925,
0.0251072496,
-0.0522841327,
-0.0274362061,
0.0410284102,
0.0365129188,
-0.0124322074,
-0.0278038643,
0.03427995,
-0.018458616,
0.0283092856,
0.0217690337,
0.012645022,
0.0060885777,
-0.0495726503,
0.0210643001,
-0.0670033097,
-0.0437097475,
-0.0242394861,
-0.0028515724,
-0.0136017743,
0.0221622717,
0.0012691121,
0.0407081805,
-0.0722968951,
-0.0117748538,
-0.057245288,
0.0221321434,
0.0080007715,
0.0302374307,
0.0259824842,
0.0344818607,
-0.0014520488,
0.0338497795,
-0.0179541204,
-0.0269197822,
-0.0177851804,
-0.0419113189,
-0.0000318139,
0.0494963266,
-0.0164758395,
0.0152020063,
-0.061974071,
0.0112558817,
0.066160202,
-0.0641343594,
-0.0058009773,
0.0474408008,
3.009e-7,
0.0104502328,
0.0279387049,
0.0234668162,
0.0161067173,
-0.005833494,
-0.0068626571,
0.011538174,
0.0004038886,
0.0207657553,
-0.0422705971,
-0.0009200093,
0.087842606,
0.0334822424,
0.0039193416,
-0.1085177213,
-0.0057845372,
-0.0623656288,
-0.0146916164,
-0.0209459644,
-0.0143406317,
0.0265990812,
0.0960005075,
-0.003488366,
-0.0167439692,
0.0027470801,
-0.0320492536,
0.0832575858,
-0.018384546,
0.0078852419,
-0.0028399162,
-0.0070255995,
0.0505289845,
-0.0401446149,
0.0167347342,
-0.0260718577,
-0.0007657888,
-0.049914483,
0.0711351931,
-0.0090057626,
-0.0436796844,
0.0375045128,
-0.0085654035,
-0.0554120503,
-0.0170620661,
0.0467535295,
-0.0394086055,
-0.0435947925,
0.0015823623,
0.0332390927,
0.0055508628,
-0.044697132,
0.0050558778,
0.0011480014,
0.017405225,
-0.0005934177,
-0.000685066,
0.0037524852,
-0.0909249932,
-0.0176307783,
0.029005453,
-0.0288930815,
-0.048556298,
-0.052490171,
0.0033152055,
0.026432218,
-0.0760380998,
0.0071087931,
2.979196301e-34,
0.0479603186,
-0.0266937334,
0.0125576146,
0.0432631075,
0.042030409,
-0.0257164463,
0.018315373,
0.0312158912,
-0.006980557,
-0.1156754345,
-0.0341223925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01158v1 | Learning to Explore and Select for Coverage-Conditioned Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-07-01T10:26:19 | 2024-07-01T10:26:19 | Takyoung Kim, Kyungjae Lee, Young Rok Jang, Ji Yong Cho, Gangwoo Kim, Minseok Cho, Moontae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interactions with billion-scale large language models typically yield
long-form responses due to their extensive parametric capacities, along with
retrieval-augmented features. While detailed responses provide insightful
viewpoint of a specific subject, they frequently generate redundant and less
engaging content that does not meet user interests. In this work, we focus on
the role of query outlining (i.e., selected sequence of queries) in scenarios
that users request a specific range of information, namely coverage-conditioned
($C^2$) scenarios. For simulating $C^2$ scenarios, we construct QTree, 10K sets
of information-seeking queries decomposed with various perspectives on certain
topics. By utilizing QTree, we train QPlanner, a 7B language model generating
customized query outlines that follow coverage-conditioned queries. We analyze
the effectiveness of generated outlines through automatic and human evaluation,
targeting on retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Moreover, the experimental
results demonstrate that QPlanner with alignment training can further provide
outlines satisfying diverse user interests. Our resources are available at
https://github.com/youngerous/qtree. | Learning to Explore and Select for Coverage-Conditioned Retrieval-Augmented Generation: Interactions with billion-scale large language models typically yield
long-form responses due to their extensive parametric capacities, along with
retrieval-augmented features. While detailed responses provide insightful
viewpoint of a specific subject, they frequently generate redundant and less
engaging content that does not meet user interests. In this work, we focus on
the role of query outlining (i.e., selected sequence of queries) in scenarios
that users request a specific range of information, namely coverage-conditioned
($C^2$) scenarios. For simulating $C^2$ scenarios, we construct QTree, 10K sets
of information-seeking queries decomposed with various perspectives on certain
topics. By utilizing QTree, we train QPlanner, a 7B language model generating
customized query outlines that follow coverage-conditioned queries. We analyze
the effectiveness of generated outlines through automatic and human evaluation,
targeting on retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Moreover, the experimental
results demonstrate that QPlanner with alignment training can further provide
outlines satisfying diverse user interests. Our resources are available at
https://github.com/youngerous/qtree. | [
0.0586101785,
0.0374189205,
-0.0115135945,
-0.0096373633,
-0.0171159077,
-0.0233151242,
-0.0591949597,
0.0163097102,
-0.0099306563,
-0.0367177129,
0.0003918712,
-0.0528969765,
-0.0685780197,
0.0297610331,
-0.0105988393,
-0.0680566058,
0.0338875949,
-0.0085305404,
-0.0358511172,
0.0217013322,
0.0007581857,
0.0275493637,
0.0060556615,
0.0235302374,
-0.0015364462,
-0.0042397119,
-0.0525353625,
0.0336417258,
-0.0076158014,
-0.0605279543,
0.0310642775,
0.0580862649,
0.0129803205,
0.0122482441,
0.0000019908,
-0.0313813724,
-0.026486421,
-0.0238245521,
-0.0132340938,
0.0223345552,
0.0508201718,
0.0351643451,
0.0511773191,
0.0049659335,
-0.0277551115,
0.0483284928,
0.0201884322,
0.0745181888,
0.0552177057,
0.0532922037,
0.0047471989,
-0.0312318597,
-0.0202666428,
-0.0120129501,
0.0666167885,
-0.0473076329,
-0.0016496571,
-0.0175693519,
0.0485368744,
0.0317109153,
0.0251800977,
0.0093422346,
0.021645762,
-0.0424009748,
0.0429641716,
0.0313486829,
-0.0587500632,
-0.0149263525,
0.0056193396,
0.0871161893,
0.0144750904,
-0.0283698812,
0.0048559234,
-0.0313107781,
0.0019232964,
0.0327378735,
-0.0686012283,
-0.0096028065,
-0.0110934768,
-0.02009896,
-0.0152779659,
0.0189097039,
0.0248212237,
0.0065855561,
-0.0363629125,
0.0262664538,
0.0128353406,
-0.0490313731,
-0.0114860674,
-0.0031036527,
-0.0073547419,
-0.0560662225,
-0.0244797133,
0.0269197021,
-0.055875618,
0.015456521,
-0.0265714247,
-0.031385649,
0.047171656,
-0.0067192693,
0.0362324715,
0.0159606561,
-0.0166459493,
0.0352957658,
-0.0004723792,
0.0254366621,
-0.0354162753,
-0.0376391299,
-0.0602987632,
0.0176260769,
-0.0487707593,
-0.0439803116,
-0.0524712913,
0.0381989107,
-0.0473952331,
-0.0202951301,
-0.0104206773,
0.0579423867,
0.0317000672,
-0.0112571288,
-0.027631009,
0.0530085228,
-0.0611181818,
-0.0123001114,
-0.0493873693,
-0.0215059388,
-0.0552457161,
-0.0290324036,
0.0371517278,
-0.0385510698,
-0.0103688026,
0.0239526145,
0.0119561423,
-0.0412649028,
-0.0132291978,
0.0160216,
-0.010580061,
-0.0143680582,
-0.0425627083,
-0.0747117773,
0.0206191391,
-0.0091747334,
-0.0050095096,
-0.0516884327,
0.0212137252,
0.0060180961,
-0.0251608137,
0.0107994173,
0.0092600975,
0.0729824454,
0.0089557022,
0.0381052271,
0.0168759637,
0.0237094052,
0.0379248001,
0.0095815146,
0.0432086773,
0.0733299777,
-0.0025304772,
0.063902244,
0.0263847243,
0.0056031994,
0.0451332591,
0.0003987589,
0.0068538799,
0.0323610641,
-0.0045024259,
0.0505109951,
0.0047496562,
0.0371803828,
0.0091548767,
0.0441137664,
-0.0604655482,
-0.0004448179,
0.0219140332,
0.0331590772,
0.0500365272,
0.0271440782,
0.0691837966,
0.0217697099,
0.0015716999,
0.0228848159,
-0.0068466645,
0.0267610457,
-0.0219367947,
0.0102144852,
0.0275688972,
-0.0205933116,
-0.033101771,
-0.0264009181,
-0.003198765,
0.0191381555,
0.0070277145,
-0.0064625125,
0.0273206104,
0.0484662764,
-0.0333506241,
0.0452625789,
0.0059657032,
-0.0594683364,
0.0284629166,
-0.0253405944,
0.026666455,
0.0665107444,
0.0984664708,
-0.0362144969,
-0.0161834061,
0.0252002571,
-0.0027001558,
0.0232395232,
0.0755572766,
-0.0298121497,
-0.0146892965,
-0.0563805103,
-0.0497756302,
-0.0509032421,
-0.0036426166,
0.0046054213,
0.0216755867,
-0.0282436647,
0.038418185,
-0.0773943812,
-0.049795676,
0.025897311,
-0.0256473534,
-0.0496680811,
0.0201034956,
0.0066103511,
0.0004589137,
0.0275582131,
0.008624834,
0.0392477624,
0.0343710855,
-0.0227664523,
-0.0119866701,
-0.0147685641,
-0.0511294268,
0.0005027565,
-0.0279935561,
-0.026490787,
0.0222196262,
-0.0046442761,
-0.0198122282,
-0.0574657023,
-0.0264564697,
-0.0493425168,
0.0349344239,
-0.0360194184,
0.016903393,
-0.0068672746,
-0.0400965288,
-0.062226627,
0.0954003111,
0.030696338,
-0.0053649517,
0.0559400357,
-0.0178053379,
0.0199329033,
-0.0618955791,
-0.0072800564,
0.0118658943,
-0.0138965342,
0.0020733734,
0.0675630942,
0.0187581759,
-0.0673159808,
0.0152308224,
-0.1146648526,
0.0025176196,
-0.0393300839,
0.0163126644,
0.0492597409,
0.0646694303,
-0.0116654942,
-0.0199104585,
-0.0574795306,
-0.0413828194,
0.0070566111,
0.0299209077,
0.03709637,
0.0157692097,
0.0015518545,
-0.0248799548,
-0.0180129707,
-0.017113138,
0.0338927805,
0.0362767689,
-0.0029940985,
-0.0240790676,
0.0146976104,
-0.021918213,
-0.0171169024,
-0.0226142928,
-0.0102990279,
0.0110433288,
-0.0559002422,
-0.0095626581,
0.0269641709,
0.0473465435,
-0.0049209124,
0.05342016,
0.0288743451,
-0.068830058,
0.0255327262,
-0.0389262326,
-0.0240541995,
-0.023800781,
-0.0535639673,
0.084071517,
0.0244256724,
-0.0053639063,
0.0263728052,
-0.0707985014,
-0.0223706197,
0.0046193814,
-0.0231659524,
-0.0464008562,
-0.0136505831,
-0.0000136225,
0.0889221206,
-0.0085125538,
-0.0291429088,
0.078192912,
0.0170865171,
-0.0007576221,
-0.0511980876,
0.0135485064,
-0.043397326,
0.0837206617,
0.0127406362,
0.042954687,
0.0009420451,
-0.038848497,
-0.0671579614,
0.0019318504,
0.0102327606,
-0.0407025889,
0.0319354609,
-0.0364305638,
0.0155369174,
0.0211985055,
-0.0490205884,
-0.0490966626,
-0.0619605519,
0.0332885087,
-0.0010548809,
0.0185199007,
-0.019206157,
-0.004731826,
-0.005343162,
0.0323157385,
0.0486202575,
-0.0243317168,
-0.0280403346,
0.0033907827,
0.0388817415,
0.0972923934,
0.0078703761,
0.0137497066,
-0.0370137915,
0.0083048828,
0.0315067135,
0.0731679052,
0.0114688249,
0.0536850467,
0.0025533147,
0.029239526,
-0.0440341011,
-0.0127998423,
0.0428874567,
0.0436253324,
-0.0261406433,
-0.0434367061,
0.0710838288,
0.0616579056,
-0.0509087481,
0.0007189119,
-0.0542358011,
0.0593362525,
0.020748917,
0.0689602941,
-0.0751867369,
0.0124229286,
-0.0097751394,
0.060786318,
-0.0214484986,
-0.0118797738,
-0.0155709479,
-0.1222833395,
0.038997896,
-0.0135782221,
-0.0091184536,
-0.0120460615,
-0.0416805297,
0.0001729994,
0.0096025849,
-0.0134585621,
0.0609862767,
-0.0289710443,
-0.0043803486,
0.0105920257,
0.0139965983,
-0.0351013057,
0.0060449024,
-0.0009989672,
-0.0303451847,
0.0870511457,
0.0030473995,
0.0218939614,
0.0116552552,
0.0094714928,
-0.0421295501,
0.0400246158,
0.0155467018,
0.0531538427,
0.0196615681,
0.030084867,
-0.0228673182,
0.0239190664,
-0.0088266209,
-0.0047748289,
0.0108184908,
0.046942208,
-0.0637074411,
-0.007914518,
-0.034177307,
-0.0116342297,
0.0192275196,
0.0598179474,
0.045566339,
-0.022749735,
-0.0373956114,
-0.0349777676,
0.0235758238,
-0.0957115293,
-0.0118582845,
0.0340620726,
-0.0263307709,
0.0098332725,
-0.0747624487,
-0.0273958948,
0.0155266104,
0.0398090668,
0.0139520736,
0.0105065443,
-0.0040215761,
-0.0330069289,
-0.0086857732,
0.0157134105,
-0.0200315714,
-0.0160419773,
-0.0544470847,
-0.0357550532,
0.0126536218,
-0.0767362118,
-0.004178883,
0.0051673693,
-0.0260157511,
-0.0567333922,
-0.0056550945,
0.0272881296,
0.0211520661,
0.0483010411,
-0.0186980162,
-0.0440222621,
0.0397357121,
0.0495038405,
-0.0480450206,
-0.0263214391,
-0.027860105,
-0.0093567902,
-0.0307730604,
0.0281634778,
-0.0856697112,
-0.0166313723,
-0.0285117105,
0.0621602274,
-0.0263310932,
-0.0273690205,
0.0648627281,
0.0278065316,
-0.0000961809,
0.0077112517,
-0.0025555776,
-0.0287920069,
0.0327832922,
-0.0361363925,
-0.0392156243,
-0.0090089021,
0.0272669885,
0.0037897436,
-0.0421170779,
0.0274254438,
-0.0001314761,
-0.039293766,
0.057953883,
-0.0509606935,
-0.0140956882,
-0.0115277758,
-0.0155378599,
0.0499044359,
-0.0271626003,
-0.0167946443,
0.0121839335,
-0.0047833989,
0.0694412813,
-0.0036294898,
0.0394448861,
0.0101741543,
-0.0082982061,
-0.0131429713,
0.0113873212,
-0.0758650526,
-0.0736825243,
-0.0294249393,
-0.0171701182,
0.002533626,
-0.0110944118,
0.0133836949,
-0.0382570885,
-0.011595469,
-0.0047654328,
0.0086165564,
0.0345353261,
-0.0303767361,
0.0101337554,
0.0403932817,
-0.0144113004,
-0.0283004418,
0.0388134569,
0.0063081696,
0.0378349572,
-0.0223192926,
-0.0272430237,
-0.0324884579,
-0.0054499968,
0.0189839285,
0.0726343244,
-0.0308058616,
-0.008524023,
-0.0342791751,
-0.0049792491,
0.0340148285,
-0.0031834452,
-0.0101972362,
-0.0245534405,
0.0838620961,
0.1028123945,
-0.0157367997,
-0.0307190176,
-0.0563455373,
0.0251942519,
-0.0790871307,
-0.013759762,
-0.0346322805,
-6.510784029e-33,
-0.0078966897,
-0.0243279133,
0.0431231596,
-0.0560969859,
-0.0299958289,
-0.0070865522,
-0.0383764133,
-0.01812369,
-0.0107366275,
-0.0304341931,
-0.0222455636,
0.0033000812,
0.0054954188,
0.0368528813,
0.0162799377,
-0.005835826,
0.0658436269,
0.0234371684,
-0.0551344827,
0.0738310367,
0.0363980383,
0.0117654521,
-0.0026088238,
-0.0211766567,
-0.009958378,
-0.043331679,
0.0208699219,
0.0079853879,
-0.0146356095,
0.0821136162,
-0.0035118861,
0.0138052832,
0.0340270996,
0.0014504354,
-0.0021423476,
0.0167613924,
-0.0387845822,
-0.0438329913,
0.0141122015,
-0.0242626294,
-0.0648104548,
-0.0380020775,
0.0299922135,
-0.0250640642,
0.0099870441,
0.0120899621,
0.0321833417,
0.0226674937,
-0.015874913,
-0.0388972647,
-0.0222237464,
0.019358566,
0.0046739844,
-0.0114978682,
-0.0234778803,
0.1112961471,
0.0110388659,
0.0562734343,
0.0104735754,
0.0353094898,
0.0107655227,
0.0622946061,
0.0555546582,
0.0357477292,
0.0086516105,
0.0523513258,
-0.0053398726,
0.0246189982,
-0.0233223941,
-0.0283780303,
-0.0293861795,
0.0390722938,
-0.0105072344,
0.0415880941,
0.0135746021,
0.015870614,
-0.0231224783,
0.0688799471,
0.0064523625,
0.045515772,
0.0191836208,
0.0197289102,
-0.0148547329,
-0.0278050583,
-0.0319519155,
0.0237844586,
-0.0461064503,
-0.0131083336,
0.0419383645,
0.0275262389,
-0.0232215784,
-0.012847865,
0.0119947344,
0.0115123019,
0.0020561062,
0.0323977433,
-0.0428100117,
0.0089925453,
-0.0105754957,
0.0267051905,
0.0031770084,
-0.009040908,
0.012897809,
-0.043516539,
-0.0218395144,
0.0255826637,
0.0015720598,
0.0095754648,
-0.0442007333,
-0.0051716822,
-0.011773793,
0.009314484,
-0.0216969047,
-0.0194067899,
0.0390011407,
0.038479872,
-0.0075137429,
0.0410402827,
0.0187373459,
-0.0039611412,
-0.039722275,
-0.061463099,
0.0044427868,
0.0281351302,
0.0054195682,
0.0240938179,
-0.0534576066,
0.0382746123,
0.0302364938,
-0.0458278395,
-0.0273426585,
0.0603848733,
2.794e-7,
0.0465857051,
0.0257050395,
0.0063301018,
0.0536070168,
-0.0069422899,
0.0145394541,
0.0367153063,
0.0043513249,
0.0041752849,
-0.0126726748,
0.042481117,
-0.0152732246,
0.035303764,
0.034957692,
-0.1164556742,
0.0353828445,
-0.0731394142,
-0.0239307974,
-0.0767464489,
-0.0298674256,
0.0717557818,
0.0357209966,
-0.034787599,
0.0017772159,
0.0137462374,
-0.0359560177,
0.0461512804,
0.002395099,
-0.0290710181,
0.0419114269,
0.0290838983,
0.015388364,
0.0266617592,
0.0035981506,
-0.0423705839,
0.014883454,
0.009517774,
0.0299798045,
0.0091495374,
-0.0417911224,
0.0064339191,
-0.0091914954,
0.0112397624,
-0.0818768144,
0.059104871,
-0.0014114917,
0.0176458061,
-0.0153644327,
-0.005237205,
-0.0046086204,
0.0077167582,
-0.0296208505,
-0.0212571695,
-0.0064149629,
0.0001780185,
0.0104051037,
-0.0034506926,
-0.0570175722,
-0.0089881057,
0.0197907276,
-0.0382798836,
-0.0305691529,
-0.07655669,
0.0142358514,
-0.0464602299,
-0.0458685979,
-0.0005278848,
2.685001289e-34,
0.0430577546,
0.0106235705,
-0.0095560746,
0.0034641279,
0.037846189,
-0.0024205898,
0.0075655952,
0.0313975736,
0.038246654,
-0.0906516537,
-0.0397741087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01157v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01157v1 | Unaligning Everything: Or Aligning Any Text to Any Image in Multimodal Models | 2024-07-01T10:25:47 | 2024-07-01T10:25:47 | Shaeke Salman, Md Montasir Bin Shams, Xiuwen Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Utilizing a shared embedding space, emerging multimodal models exhibit
unprecedented zero-shot capabilities. However, the shared embedding space could
lead to new vulnerabilities if different modalities can be misaligned. In this
paper, we extend and utilize a recently developed effective gradient-based
procedure that allows us to match the embedding of a given text by minimally
modifying an image. Using the procedure, we show that we can align the
embeddings of distinguishable texts to any image through unnoticeable
adversarial attacks in joint image-text models, revealing that semantically
unrelated images can have embeddings of identical texts and at the same time
visually indistinguishable images can be matched to the embeddings of very
different texts. Our technique achieves 100\% success rate when it is applied
to text datasets and images from multiple sources. Without overcoming the
vulnerability, multimodal models cannot robustly align inputs from different
modalities in a semantically meaningful way. \textbf{Warning: the text data
used in this paper are toxic in nature and may be offensive to some readers.} | Unaligning Everything: Or Aligning Any Text to Any Image in Multimodal Models: Utilizing a shared embedding space, emerging multimodal models exhibit
unprecedented zero-shot capabilities. However, the shared embedding space could
lead to new vulnerabilities if different modalities can be misaligned. In this
paper, we extend and utilize a recently developed effective gradient-based
procedure that allows us to match the embedding of a given text by minimally
modifying an image. Using the procedure, we show that we can align the
embeddings of distinguishable texts to any image through unnoticeable
adversarial attacks in joint image-text models, revealing that semantically
unrelated images can have embeddings of identical texts and at the same time
visually indistinguishable images can be matched to the embeddings of very
different texts. Our technique achieves 100\% success rate when it is applied
to text datasets and images from multiple sources. Without overcoming the
vulnerability, multimodal models cannot robustly align inputs from different
modalities in a semantically meaningful way. \textbf{Warning: the text data
used in this paper are toxic in nature and may be offensive to some readers.} | [
0.0050526448,
0.0723819733,
0.0036090924,
0.084056966,
-0.0310789105,
0.0103694163,
0.036014881,
0.0083816824,
-0.0335986763,
-0.0532380678,
-0.0371385813,
0.0076796217,
0.0115092946,
0.0076268115,
0.0507394895,
-0.0481638424,
-0.0001025532,
0.0202051271,
-0.0345170312,
0.0013688341,
0.0600093678,
-0.0070690722,
-0.0078848535,
0.0265984628,
-0.0303083044,
-0.0432160608,
-0.0352260806,
0.0600569509,
0.0444845483,
-0.0096921958,
0.0074709728,
0.0198769048,
0.0025551619,
0.0744731799,
0.0000019179,
0.0196881481,
-0.0248007849,
0.0245974213,
0.0456080176,
-0.020016104,
0.037564978,
-0.0657396466,
-0.0109289568,
-0.0242369156,
-0.0162119213,
0.0131817451,
0.0693236664,
0.0672280863,
0.0655809566,
0.0688277707,
-0.0276676007,
-0.0300670061,
0.0016627336,
-0.0277041346,
0.0249039903,
-0.0326646231,
0.0062083611,
-0.0285696201,
-0.0363013931,
0.034222696,
-0.0506230593,
0.0527915843,
0.0053222561,
0.0174954776,
0.005343697,
0.0310489517,
0.0033071067,
-0.0382606536,
-0.0049089212,
0.0919396505,
-0.0754037276,
0.0016922439,
-0.000686878,
-0.0237288065,
0.0066569326,
0.0050262189,
-0.0195215233,
0.018446276,
0.0137120085,
0.0325167403,
-0.0800496787,
0.0042962455,
0.0439814553,
-0.0144558009,
0.0084886365,
-0.0301040895,
0.0272552986,
-0.0051752017,
-0.0564499274,
-0.0062128911,
-0.055524528,
-0.0443461947,
0.0013098974,
0.0164975133,
0.0236042161,
-0.0004862463,
-0.1043755263,
-0.0700549409,
0.0166693032,
-0.0155555094,
0.0842038542,
0.0022668638,
-0.0521822013,
0.0717208311,
-0.0181120243,
0.0420517847,
-0.0580154434,
0.0406956263,
-0.0351150222,
0.003459835,
-0.0101756183,
-0.0513361096,
0.0376885645,
-0.0270082168,
-0.0616853051,
-0.052440118,
0.0109619563,
0.0134955421,
-0.0232893731,
0.0372135155,
-0.0513303913,
0.033646822,
-0.0587746091,
-0.0184806399,
0.0329089239,
0.005841841,
0.0107120778,
0.0061909053,
-0.0219905488,
-0.0187124964,
-0.0296850447,
0.0537211783,
-0.0069927773,
-0.0050169108,
-0.0359945036,
0.1027697623,
-0.0272477157,
-0.0223310776,
0.0061451057,
-0.0348805897,
-0.0550022759,
-0.0409065485,
0.0455607288,
-0.0145407328,
0.0114124967,
-0.0270297211,
-0.003284662,
-0.079070121,
0.000826025,
0.019226307,
-0.0318492018,
0.1320197284,
0.0153651945,
-0.046388194,
0.026266573,
0.0361859314,
-0.0149832461,
0.0541294254,
0.0108212242,
0.0614008084,
0.0420928597,
0.0192421116,
-0.0116539923,
0.0250426922,
0.0167059246,
0.0105129583,
-0.0169908628,
-0.0142268343,
0.0378361307,
0.0384506285,
-0.0046176272,
0.0230222847,
-0.0125846379,
-0.0745633245,
0.0938778222,
0.0307208207,
-0.0244910307,
0.0122766355,
-0.0079364087,
0.0060578482,
-0.0129015241,
0.0113861253,
-0.0480767265,
0.0279815961,
-0.0092104198,
0.0119763026,
0.0420431234,
0.0359219201,
-0.0352687389,
-0.0123426504,
0.0046365829,
-0.0337062925,
0.0175492167,
-0.0398156121,
0.016807247,
0.0285503622,
-0.0496420562,
-0.009294386,
-0.0000049126,
-0.0225135963,
-0.0344409086,
0.0056868796,
0.0076572676,
0.0152999358,
0.0314396098,
-0.0349505693,
0.0351362042,
-0.0103738811,
0.0409349687,
0.0618441813,
-0.0193083175,
0.0227318332,
0.0571748503,
-0.0616800934,
-0.0550554805,
-0.0637599975,
0.0102691371,
0.0028314907,
-0.0087701026,
0.0138743166,
0.00538558,
0.005421062,
0.052437894,
0.0399152786,
0.010155431,
-0.0330705121,
-0.0255959369,
0.0431369804,
0.0108038178,
0.0096461764,
-0.0420797914,
0.0151898609,
0.0281816758,
-0.0190825406,
-0.0237567462,
-0.003476256,
0.0005226076,
-0.0328294002,
0.0098971622,
-0.0731246993,
-0.0136991916,
0.0299983639,
-0.0395749919,
0.0123068094,
0.0310980249,
0.0153176896,
-0.0015439844,
-0.0102956137,
-0.020120861,
0.0061031678,
0.033329647,
-0.0207962096,
0.0330208018,
-0.0321995802,
-0.0102517484,
-0.0088941595,
0.0036581717,
0.0170528814,
-0.0215293411,
-0.0654217899,
-0.0074735461,
0.0057193819,
0.0359621644,
-0.022685945,
-0.0251694992,
0.0053476999,
-0.023495812,
-0.0618643425,
-0.019817777,
-0.0166825429,
-0.0115617774,
0.0287755914,
-0.0045482605,
0.019006392,
-0.0466828495,
-0.004701688,
0.0234176945,
-0.0113625489,
0.014079486,
0.0381196328,
-0.010795176,
0.0266606808,
-0.0236338247,
0.0002142175,
0.0198410992,
0.0952144712,
-0.0117718605,
-0.0195147302,
-0.0253985152,
-0.0148107046,
-0.020602772,
0.0318300091,
-0.0149748884,
-0.0278760958,
0.0278445594,
0.0369757414,
0.0026074769,
0.1122222543,
-0.0063862088,
0.0418281667,
-0.0191366207,
0.0090353107,
-0.029236313,
-0.0290742144,
0.0292742252,
0.0259531178,
0.0044698738,
-0.0046311766,
0.0015326722,
0.0503056161,
0.0094657689,
0.0180882476,
-0.0192561056,
0.0468882844,
-0.0022347178,
-0.0533693843,
-0.0596060492,
0.0299180765,
-0.0091242772,
-0.0464433879,
-0.0723163337,
-0.0657898486,
0.0111700445,
-0.0277935062,
-0.0001297148,
0.0282557178,
-0.0218448006,
0.0369149037,
0.0432624109,
0.0265116803,
0.0571190007,
0.0194979273,
0.0158967078,
-0.0428023376,
-0.0244353227,
0.0379160345,
0.0046862122,
0.0361384749,
0.0082896436,
0.0005314529,
-0.0164083857,
-0.0430692583,
-0.019155493,
-0.0912232623,
0.0143209798,
-0.005190738,
-0.0390465558,
-0.0227143895,
-0.0761595443,
-0.0289099235,
0.0392882638,
-0.0120079499,
-0.0100926757,
0.0018071518,
-0.0252292659,
0.0590687469,
0.017928604,
-0.0393289812,
-0.060315188,
-0.0450178459,
-0.0156146344,
0.0714934096,
-0.0087618753,
0.0385379307,
-0.0353535302,
-0.0067683631,
-0.0364143439,
0.0633225814,
-0.0083785951,
-0.0030161638,
0.0416785255,
0.0112524126,
0.02500703,
0.0173482019,
-0.0112805385,
-0.0090411203,
0.0055676936,
0.0219487231,
0.0257944278,
-0.0061089112,
-0.0154729094,
-0.1064627171,
-0.0572680645,
0.0005926173,
-0.0117304968,
0.0347293019,
0.030098591,
-0.0282676835,
-0.0406819806,
-0.0254717469,
0.0277927201,
0.0119377673,
-0.0381253734,
0.0435139537,
0.0056596054,
-0.0042074607,
-0.0002655871,
-0.0171918143,
0.0259997081,
-0.0024163036,
0.0020445469,
0.0538781174,
-0.0454620719,
-0.0455850326,
-0.0152070597,
0.0040417085,
0.0516017526,
0.0224302113,
0.0047197426,
-0.0482210703,
0.0097487252,
0.0328997858,
0.0107530486,
0.034662351,
0.0850194842,
-0.0391411446,
-0.0295608174,
0.0033202339,
0.032406088,
0.0312909335,
-0.0162766967,
-0.0143160075,
0.0153916422,
0.0303628854,
0.0083379149,
-0.0556574166,
-0.0125558553,
0.0360381342,
0.0237398352,
0.011859172,
-0.0551133044,
-0.047517661,
-0.0517073572,
0.0289308652,
-0.0081879199,
-0.030858973,
0.0353495032,
-0.0023026257,
-0.011014129,
-0.0548083931,
-0.0144421058,
-0.0259114038,
0.0519897901,
0.021504743,
-0.0073969029,
-0.0566487685,
0.0135000423,
-0.038425494,
0.0157723036,
-0.0301907789,
0.0458108261,
-0.0069210054,
0.0394813865,
0.0196452513,
-0.0290546939,
-0.0350631215,
-0.0038090257,
-0.0868770555,
-0.0715138763,
-0.0195680745,
0.0366353244,
0.0096674077,
0.0294599179,
-0.0032547968,
-0.0521749891,
0.0833984539,
0.0456610471,
0.006808117,
0.0362511352,
0.0481589064,
-0.0302836075,
0.00430007,
0.0464414842,
-0.0244343951,
0.0116860121,
0.0623965748,
-0.024548905,
-0.0136787156,
0.0210517403,
-0.0231832284,
-0.0532988757,
0.0340820849,
-0.0063259816,
0.0181826428,
0.0020305221,
0.0065870211,
0.0107427193,
-0.0275897533,
-0.0448554941,
0.0078988476,
0.0053967428,
0.0074074324,
-0.0040043835,
0.0256331787,
0.0363814756,
0.0593588129,
-0.0366375782,
-0.001305243,
0.0423809476,
0.0208669957,
-0.0104324603,
0.0541845933,
-0.0068354998,
0.0627043694,
-0.0476521328,
-0.0113402866,
-0.0026315346,
0.0575832315,
0.0365370885,
-0.0127658946,
-0.0425110199,
0.0581951775,
-0.027469825,
0.0264541116,
-0.0458373725,
0.0297280867,
0.0575055778,
0.0089600123,
0.0008809421,
0.0218532179,
-0.0268940106,
-0.0273046196,
0.0175852701,
0.0079707876,
-0.0229010135,
0.0321091302,
-0.0051556267,
0.0103616929,
0.023700472,
0.0590558015,
0.0079194345,
0.0035577153,
0.0159752313,
-0.0174294673,
-0.0491272844,
0.0028137376,
0.0838239864,
0.0163818635,
0.0068794731,
-0.0075364844,
0.0109730773,
-0.0601194911,
0.0084200706,
0.026815813,
-0.0093746623,
0.0425348282,
0.0021322295,
0.0323876254,
0.0152467843,
0.0154131595,
0.0006009707,
0.0182554871,
0.0008686113,
-0.0219767541,
0.0158532523,
-6.029514234e-33,
0.0205125026,
-0.0225723721,
-0.0534224622,
-0.0608908869,
-0.0015619468,
0.0442424193,
-0.0241728388,
0.0028255454,
-0.0038106078,
0.020836249,
0.0097904215,
0.0043299319,
-0.0106927603,
0.0165427346,
-0.0433784984,
-0.0166204926,
0.0103835696,
-0.0189191774,
-0.0162487645,
-0.0097592091,
0.0449891463,
0.0241546556,
0.033188425,
-0.0736984611,
0.0297550298,
-0.028368542,
-0.0755841881,
-0.0356251448,
0.0044022617,
0.0525576435,
-0.0371133909,
-0.0005892576,
0.0099885771,
0.0076099485,
-0.0416680723,
0.0637190714,
-0.039489571,
-0.0118271029,
-0.0151922666,
0.0242990144,
-0.0649900287,
-0.025824571,
0.0501839742,
-0.0343761668,
0.0026080967,
-0.0353384838,
0.0380342007,
0.0052965018,
0.0198140852,
0.0436355025,
-0.0581462346,
0.017701719,
-0.0226320997,
-0.0283728894,
0.0405768864,
0.0069820019,
0.0743996128,
0.0242197663,
-0.0973833576,
-0.0096019823,
-0.0309086833,
0.0026860028,
0.0528311133,
0.0132888099,
0.0064173937,
0.0852877796,
0.0238709766,
-0.0393068902,
-0.0271666553,
-0.0283534788,
-0.012212324,
0.0455890559,
0.0584896468,
0.1205954775,
0.0817068294,
0.011523976,
-0.0594563968,
0.0050642435,
-0.0542625114,
-0.0337477028,
0.0487728417,
0.0578477755,
-0.0310289916,
0.0260929111,
-0.0207283758,
-0.0787162185,
-0.047277201,
-0.0310584567,
0.0583448671,
0.029466344,
-0.0166440327,
0.0397786759,
0.031330213,
-0.0404275656,
-0.0201341156,
0.0122271953,
-0.009415959,
0.0310778022,
-0.00829909,
0.0060938378,
0.0004599906,
-0.0039728666,
0.0758650377,
0.0090212049,
0.0173365436,
0.0010186194,
0.0617554151,
0.0268702414,
-0.0393387787,
-0.0365661718,
-0.024904225,
-0.0075313374,
0.0064993687,
0.0187669694,
0.0418344066,
-0.0072112186,
-0.03215928,
0.0006402429,
0.0176329445,
0.0185852405,
-0.0222714115,
-0.012735446,
-0.0549942851,
0.0045243357,
-0.0109481318,
-0.0001450561,
0.0000628745,
-0.0084800273,
0.0574805178,
-0.065455541,
0.001991489,
0.020504402,
2.558e-7,
0.0169939436,
-0.0199128333,
0.0230966695,
-0.0494014956,
0.0358374454,
0.0860233381,
-0.0277894773,
0.0747381002,
-0.0474989414,
-0.0386986323,
-0.0203092601,
0.0232821815,
0.045043312,
0.0012641849,
-0.0143271927,
0.0194200147,
-0.0657100603,
0.0161101669,
-0.0429271311,
0.009573481,
0.0370347127,
0.0956306532,
0.0322017297,
-0.0062783039,
0.0193780158,
-0.0359114595,
0.0397215597,
-0.0175244212,
0.0247484874,
-0.0587264486,
0.0045567309,
-0.0036458264,
-0.0171242729,
-0.0258493703,
-0.0058014141,
-0.018349858,
0.0747524425,
0.0333757624,
-0.0359846577,
-0.0275524948,
-0.0478175171,
0.002816221,
-0.0236895885,
-0.0279890131,
0.0707678124,
-0.0380780846,
-0.0427559577,
-0.0432111174,
-0.0397698134,
0.0129028084,
0.0744158775,
0.0036986698,
-0.0489589423,
0.004774435,
0.0415841788,
0.0093518933,
-0.0269781388,
-0.0767407492,
-0.0391620882,
-0.0099990685,
-0.0591201559,
0.0106833568,
-0.0580503792,
-0.0072826701,
0.0629536211,
-0.0783041641,
-0.0234511085,
1.979554986e-34,
-0.0150893247,
-0.0373885334,
0.0138100144,
-0.027924642,
0.0134653235,
-0.0091638891,
-0.0278772209,
-0.0404416062,
0.0075949011,
-0.0420398861,
-0.0249289274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01149v1 | Sociocultural Considerations in Monitoring Anti-LGBTQ+ Content on Social Media | 2024-07-01T10:17:13 | 2024-07-01T10:17:13 | Sidney G. -J. Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | The purpose of this paper is to ascertain the influence of sociocultural
factors (i.e., social, cultural, and political) in the development of hate
speech detection systems. We set out to investigate the suitability of using
open-source training data to monitor levels of anti-LGBTQ+ content on social
media across different national-varieties of English. Our findings suggests the
social and cultural alignment of open-source hate speech data sets influences
the predicted outputs. Furthermore, the keyword-search approach of anti-LGBTQ+
slurs in the development of open-source training data encourages detection
models to overfit on slurs; therefore, anti-LGBTQ+ content may go undetected.
We recommend combining empirical outputs with qualitative insights to ensure
these systems are fit for purpose. | Sociocultural Considerations in Monitoring Anti-LGBTQ+ Content on Social Media: The purpose of this paper is to ascertain the influence of sociocultural
factors (i.e., social, cultural, and political) in the development of hate
speech detection systems. We set out to investigate the suitability of using
open-source training data to monitor levels of anti-LGBTQ+ content on social
media across different national-varieties of English. Our findings suggests the
social and cultural alignment of open-source hate speech data sets influences
the predicted outputs. Furthermore, the keyword-search approach of anti-LGBTQ+
slurs in the development of open-source training data encourages detection
models to overfit on slurs; therefore, anti-LGBTQ+ content may go undetected.
We recommend combining empirical outputs with qualitative insights to ensure
these systems are fit for purpose. | [
0.0536253378,
0.0567140616,
-0.0087141851,
0.000320325,
-0.0102963308,
0.0294346213,
0.04514746,
0.0233985297,
0.0512138307,
-0.0454506837,
0.0063223159,
-0.0391270891,
-0.0203956943,
0.0333740376,
-0.0045985631,
-0.0056128595,
0.0255979318,
0.085356757,
0.0167475026,
-0.0227598064,
0.0627360865,
0.0178648699,
0.0295683034,
0.0295708831,
-0.0089071244,
0.0166832339,
0.0434623435,
0.0072983643,
0.0408187918,
-0.0010981529,
0.0501901582,
0.0097070225,
-0.0143012675,
0.0589239299,
0.0000015318,
-0.0615980402,
0.023963036,
0.0095912078,
0.016846098,
-0.0057187607,
0.045290716,
-0.0466165654,
-0.0284955166,
0.0561683401,
-0.036394462,
0.0108974548,
0.0512796417,
-0.0013446943,
0.0569352545,
0.046670381,
-0.0170890708,
-0.0427071638,
-0.0483864024,
-0.0024137706,
-0.0170410741,
0.0261708368,
0.0364956036,
-0.0360997282,
-0.044139456,
-0.0112611195,
-0.0199859925,
-0.0040886533,
-0.0064842878,
0.0494371653,
0.0002957356,
-0.0382524393,
-0.0458702594,
-0.0463554151,
0.0274342094,
0.0074666194,
-0.0010733644,
0.0100954836,
0.0238071401,
-0.0088532073,
-0.0417321473,
0.0165123455,
-0.0229462367,
0.0322845615,
-0.0480083376,
0.0120642968,
-0.0047075306,
-0.023203209,
0.0434050336,
0.0831576511,
0.0173116364,
0.0625446439,
-0.0097535141,
-0.0445079878,
0.0127903521,
-0.0526742227,
-0.0018549332,
0.0078121936,
0.0542224795,
-0.0124601908,
0.0527196936,
0.0520325564,
-0.0079525365,
-0.0457670577,
0.0332436338,
-0.0672510266,
0.0112989191,
0.0699467063,
-0.0177830625,
-0.0106810434,
0.0291094799,
0.0394917689,
0.0043900483,
0.0110228416,
0.0381274074,
-0.0058928826,
-0.0219681263,
0.0373507515,
0.0239145141,
-0.0570951253,
0.0207220782,
0.0633423552,
-0.0567654707,
-0.0094301924,
-0.0339714475,
0.0003555574,
-0.0223837402,
0.0009390067,
0.0060621011,
0.020452464,
-0.0044087321,
0.0159788914,
-0.0482217483,
0.0032676714,
-0.0571982488,
-0.051403027,
0.0579788014,
0.024329206,
0.023420807,
-0.030151926,
0.0365338661,
0.0107529527,
0.0303202327,
-0.0389087796,
-0.0128705436,
0.0032938281,
-0.0399636514,
0.0013765187,
0.028399054,
-0.0371170714,
0.0007247782,
0.0284531526,
-0.0255239941,
-0.0650030747,
-0.0003997508,
0.0236538537,
-0.0489553064,
0.0537353531,
0.0224042851,
0.0125007723,
0.0682693124,
0.026179852,
0.0081864921,
0.0650930256,
-0.007319327,
0.0186866727,
0.0519143604,
-0.0116855437,
0.0081061665,
0.0508463904,
0.0349161439,
0.0334203243,
-0.0355037712,
0.0275213588,
-0.045331113,
-0.0386583842,
0.0060980977,
0.008814997,
0.023479512,
-0.0138609521,
-0.0023646094,
0.0848550498,
0.0220967121,
0.0151535487,
0.0375218391,
0.0518428832,
-0.0402884968,
-0.0462328829,
-0.046530623,
-0.0600073785,
-0.0216557682,
-0.0391316228,
0.0092292158,
0.0588448755,
-0.0328483023,
-0.0286668427,
-0.0696329251,
0.0263832733,
0.0624592416,
-0.0501595549,
0.0451995917,
-0.0200467501,
0.0025769083,
0.0023206826,
0.0363449529,
-0.020858828,
0.0355858207,
-0.0233885441,
0.0126613425,
0.0605195239,
-0.0129441544,
-0.0088794101,
0.0270746816,
-0.0414635092,
0.0060667866,
0.0124779372,
0.0110279415,
0.0035434049,
-0.0343408138,
-0.0151729891,
-0.0512918867,
0.0672363043,
0.0012108303,
-0.0102657173,
0.111817956,
0.050716456,
0.0082163587,
0.0370578468,
-0.0531710684,
0.0124432081,
0.0074578286,
-0.0216725841,
-0.025118595,
0.016412016,
0.0522424951,
0.0156072872,
-0.0141279893,
-0.0499414802,
-0.0018862732,
0.0146981012,
-0.033960849,
0.0319282562,
0.0205383431,
0.0521148555,
0.0187662039,
-0.0483736582,
0.0020242133,
0.0570699424,
0.0088623296,
0.0461913086,
0.0939133242,
-0.0135387359,
0.0203100722,
-0.0252262931,
-0.0673699826,
-0.057990551,
0.0139564155,
-0.0068085873,
0.0498330705,
-0.0593551658,
0.012653769,
-0.0091397222,
-0.0609737448,
0.0419510864,
0.0460315347,
-0.0340116322,
-0.0344193913,
-0.0628565177,
0.0330234021,
0.0090388115,
0.0108726081,
-0.010029396,
-0.007157492,
-0.0733739808,
-0.0140622258,
-0.0134064667,
-0.0250769444,
-0.0130257821,
-0.009214296,
-0.0510627441,
0.0202201288,
-0.0299375895,
-0.0628857687,
0.0642053559,
0.0395745784,
0.0054563079,
-0.0509620532,
-0.0133584328,
-0.0072686942,
-0.01904561,
-0.0215069856,
0.0020685922,
0.0151004614,
-0.0656601712,
0.0460837558,
-0.020166209,
-0.0310371742,
0.0051568612,
-0.0168718174,
-0.0532628,
0.0346456803,
0.0507356636,
-0.0000578918,
0.007032109,
0.0694625899,
0.0467151068,
0.0232336968,
0.0340422355,
-0.0103010563,
0.0058549196,
-0.0057507399,
-0.0052827979,
-0.0244335718,
-0.0713723451,
-0.0025309727,
0.0363690592,
0.0444096513,
-0.0151625378,
-0.0537923276,
0.0608259775,
-0.0799289346,
-0.0521918163,
-0.0318010598,
-0.050516203,
-0.0123095112,
0.002441392,
-0.0417617522,
-0.0539701171,
-0.0038713615,
0.0323497131,
0.0079391003,
-0.0186703056,
-0.028535869,
-0.0058137351,
0.0246528219,
-0.0320848823,
0.0625227317,
-0.0706741586,
-0.0023900571,
0.0217749737,
-0.0482022092,
0.0478090011,
-0.0338007621,
0.0196285024,
-0.0074418271,
0.0173342284,
-0.0112439664,
-0.0362893455,
-0.0721773505,
-0.0724404082,
-0.0667654499,
-0.035222318,
0.0033984559,
-0.0025361001,
0.0225859359,
0.0356931128,
0.0187019967,
-0.0115121054,
0.0304091014,
0.0037529175,
0.0578511134,
-0.0484505557,
-0.0327859558,
-0.0424055159,
0.0191463102,
0.0011300293,
-0.0474285334,
0.0174362399,
0.0382747464,
0.0100034215,
0.0147246942,
0.0291377585,
0.0260317195,
0.0077020982,
-0.010692575,
-0.0306448098,
0.022948321,
0.013258202,
0.034683805,
0.0603640303,
0.0237878691,
-0.0028217172,
-0.0295613334,
-0.0250725485,
-0.0023817369,
0.021946352,
0.0057602981,
-0.0802889019,
0.0200828202,
-0.0252172202,
0.0282110292,
-0.0766775534,
-0.0139891459,
-0.0257002898,
-0.0387198105,
0.0060369438,
-0.0120383119,
-0.0302400999,
-0.0425553173,
0.003844256,
0.0406890176,
-0.0215133987,
-0.0069476729,
-0.0251071546,
-0.0079085045,
0.0158106685,
0.0143260574,
-0.1002146229,
-0.0051240432,
0.0323465466,
-0.0517331026,
0.0132915825,
0.0305614397,
0.0693904012,
-0.0470196754,
-0.0082751466,
0.0089838048,
-0.0005822716,
-0.0201002806,
-0.047811795,
0.0041522803,
0.008130841,
-0.0514458083,
-0.0036382738,
0.0563570224,
0.0045815855,
0.010073944,
0.028226953,
0.0122411298,
0.0387537219,
-0.014535781,
-0.0550112985,
0.0465009101,
-0.0203702785,
0.0718490407,
-0.0006845852,
-0.0515498295,
0.0523855053,
-0.0579910576,
0.0043079657,
0.0125356568,
-0.0997680798,
-0.0209890492,
-0.0200785939,
-0.0308558736,
0.0071546044,
-0.0336345807,
0.0242383275,
0.0085851895,
0.0459730439,
-0.027111249,
-0.019136982,
-0.0121436194,
-0.0589736253,
0.0026247334,
0.004643742,
0.0156301744,
0.0153176775,
-0.0210078657,
-0.0366818346,
-0.0146520492,
-0.0226165596,
0.019176824,
-0.0062115449,
-0.0287320279,
0.0967285261,
0.007774177,
0.0167084839,
0.0115683824,
-0.0103481133,
-0.0324660055,
0.0387453884,
0.0362258255,
-0.0130174188,
0.0073039834,
0.0802985951,
0.0155870272,
0.0064528803,
0.0109851724,
0.0104128253,
0.0225769524,
0.041208569,
-0.0613761619,
-0.0764038861,
-0.0380477719,
-0.032268215,
-0.0318226665,
0.0256990287,
-0.0406721942,
-0.0541219153,
-0.0428390168,
-0.0497382134,
0.0310898107,
-0.0227651205,
0.0047107083,
-0.024250539,
0.0112638492,
-0.0281533934,
-0.0536653884,
0.040337313,
-0.0538742729,
-0.0197388809,
-0.0885491446,
0.0359797254,
0.0406451784,
0.037433967,
0.019727055,
0.0205143336,
0.0103152869,
0.0196198225,
-0.0348677821,
-0.0200306512,
0.0109308586,
0.0374403521,
-0.0023053344,
0.0146067068,
0.0834218338,
-0.0381241478,
-0.0078180432,
-0.0196642391,
-0.0365517028,
-0.035703972,
-0.0337240063,
-0.0489955135,
0.0077452785,
0.0144285364,
-0.013923849,
-0.0341126733,
0.016355481,
-0.0261856914,
-0.0404663756,
0.0197987743,
0.0067215166,
-0.0474711396,
-0.0156491902,
0.0125920363,
0.0308003183,
0.0160208475,
0.0578193478,
-0.0408667028,
-0.0157767106,
-0.0043470627,
0.052376166,
0.0151900612,
0.002416176,
0.0080336016,
-0.0879576653,
-0.0265077502,
0.0083310949,
-0.0635885224,
0.0147863533,
-0.0260615274,
0.0170955807,
0.1046200544,
-0.0309139546,
-0.007330352,
-0.0066228937,
-0.0112323519,
-0.0100228507,
-0.0534791984,
0.0231003445,
-5.106301542e-33,
-0.0206021462,
-0.0415535495,
0.0009795532,
-0.0175585337,
0.0208666343,
-0.0133601185,
0.0520891473,
0.0087865507,
-0.0278458335,
0.0002367729,
-0.0198572334,
0.0634629875,
0.0124063091,
-0.0192174837,
0.0300423,
-0.026036201,
0.0181447919,
-0.0144049749,
-0.0144433705,
-0.0219588447,
0.0384474993,
0.0076158522,
0.0129702641,
-0.0547478907,
0.0555463992,
0.0296381526,
-0.0093854861,
-0.0319541097,
0.0450011156,
0.0176606271,
-0.0428165123,
0.0568522178,
0.0233460534,
0.0098744137,
0.0313146189,
0.0696269423,
-0.0359596536,
0.0006441423,
0.0329773054,
0.0111707952,
0.0813158303,
0.0180517901,
0.0166452192,
0.0052397838,
-0.0515026264,
-0.0054822825,
0.042857334,
-0.0341807306,
0.0078886673,
-0.0290215202,
-0.0253631324,
0.0329151899,
-0.0132574122,
0.02776655,
-0.0216253083,
0.0783535391,
0.0698650479,
0.0083745234,
-0.0311245769,
0.021813944,
-0.0032694857,
-0.019839637,
0.0290307216,
0.0119610634,
0.0161599964,
0.0517990291,
0.0236837305,
0.011101963,
-0.0494849235,
-0.0043656877,
0.0810733959,
0.0053311079,
0.0285685975,
0.0485249832,
0.0006461525,
-0.0779887214,
-0.018257862,
-0.0140825482,
0.0542115569,
-0.0320032462,
-0.0074178004,
-0.0262396727,
-0.0730775967,
-0.056616392,
-0.0179988202,
-0.0577441305,
-0.0059189512,
-0.0136674503,
0.0210772324,
-0.0030624939,
-0.0515500866,
-0.0076125506,
-0.0079518873,
-0.0023692199,
-0.0014857632,
0.0353386328,
-0.0152184013,
-0.0493786074,
0.0247719251,
0.0504625365,
-0.0359821096,
0.0078428481,
-0.0372615606,
0.0132386265,
0.0176621117,
-0.006031198,
0.0093216607,
0.054880932,
-0.0813740045,
0.0107282745,
0.0007176216,
0.0580799505,
-0.0229337998,
0.0072881496,
0.0175427459,
0.0603997633,
0.0020886862,
-0.0111497566,
0.083657153,
0.0066233259,
-0.0133406734,
-0.0397113375,
-0.0480230227,
0.0251622442,
-0.0082147978,
-0.0321155079,
0.0083231647,
0.0417647101,
0.0563629083,
-0.0680186152,
0.0167918652,
-0.050482396,
2.226e-7,
0.030158082,
0.0165742226,
-0.0037241017,
0.0105911633,
-0.0069761765,
0.0163129587,
0.045480106,
0.0282721631,
0.0072219139,
-0.0019484265,
-0.0235871188,
0.0372572653,
-0.010693022,
0.0480476394,
-0.0133444192,
-0.0638202429,
-0.0448730551,
0.0340031758,
-0.0620723292,
0.0288683027,
-0.0667213127,
0.053035982,
0.0944056064,
-0.0468153507,
-0.0720235556,
-0.0401055217,
0.0001608135,
-0.0437501259,
-0.0011701876,
-0.0261152741,
0.0527527966,
0.0390869603,
0.0456807613,
-0.0180073231,
-0.0140589634,
0.0266717765,
0.0275694784,
0.0134574166,
0.0209771376,
0.0239619333,
0.0016899105,
-0.0355973132,
-0.0454520248,
-0.0424005575,
0.0727461651,
0.0032149486,
0.0191558581,
-0.0422014147,
-0.0202899873,
-0.0247677099,
0.0310357939,
-0.0212391671,
-0.0236849636,
-0.0211660322,
0.0258475039,
-0.014712912,
0.0249446929,
-0.0611803718,
0.0102914125,
-0.0408919305,
-0.0069173565,
-0.0311331823,
-0.0297850203,
0.0205794349,
0.0057537891,
0.0757239312,
0.0372324847,
1.533042424e-34,
0.0398149826,
-0.0060953824,
-0.0254885498,
-0.0548289828,
0.0331974253,
0.0017307665,
0.0196328405,
0.0030974424,
0.0235589389,
0.0062215454,
0.0212895554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01137v1 | An Empirical Comparison of Generative Approaches for Product Attribute-Value Identification | 2024-07-01T10:02:17 | 2024-07-01T10:02:17 | Kassem Sabeh, Robert Litschko, Mouna Kacimi, Barbara Plank, Johann Gamper | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Product attributes are crucial for e-commerce platforms, supporting
applications like search, recommendation, and question answering. The task of
Product Attribute and Value Identification (PAVI) involves identifying both
attributes and their values from product information. In this paper, we
formulate PAVI as a generation task and provide, to the best of our knowledge,
the most comprehensive evaluation of PAVI so far. We compare three different
attribute-value generation (AVG) strategies based on fine-tuning
encoder-decoder models on three datasets. Experiments show that end-to-end AVG
approach, which is computationally efficient, outperforms other strategies.
However, there are differences depending on model sizes and the underlying
language model. The code to reproduce all experiments is available at:
https://github.com/kassemsabeh/pavi-avg | An Empirical Comparison of Generative Approaches for Product Attribute-Value Identification: Product attributes are crucial for e-commerce platforms, supporting
applications like search, recommendation, and question answering. The task of
Product Attribute and Value Identification (PAVI) involves identifying both
attributes and their values from product information. In this paper, we
formulate PAVI as a generation task and provide, to the best of our knowledge,
the most comprehensive evaluation of PAVI so far. We compare three different
attribute-value generation (AVG) strategies based on fine-tuning
encoder-decoder models on three datasets. Experiments show that end-to-end AVG
approach, which is computationally efficient, outperforms other strategies.
However, there are differences depending on model sizes and the underlying
language model. The code to reproduce all experiments is available at:
https://github.com/kassemsabeh/pavi-avg | [
0.002327271,
0.0374982841,
-0.0117884837,
0.0379896052,
-0.0073301839,
0.0011378606,
0.0139103914,
-0.0353484564,
-0.0776987821,
-0.0439178981,
0.0330160521,
-0.0140189659,
0.0019350597,
0.0760222301,
0.0032372137,
0.007957573,
0.0068840776,
0.0118459016,
0.020032756,
-0.0083367601,
0.0156912562,
0.0221601576,
0.0023529264,
0.0221025459,
0.0447309986,
-0.0017991508,
-0.0245177299,
-0.0039183521,
0.0367998518,
-0.0279215407,
0.021016974,
0.0225110631,
-0.0076892911,
-0.0153301815,
0.000001941,
-0.0297548957,
-0.016295353,
-0.0093961805,
-0.0546195619,
-0.0209616162,
0.0644806549,
0.0244677663,
0.0303077213,
0.0234696995,
-0.0282074586,
-0.0853329152,
0.0547862463,
0.0484338775,
-0.0052060513,
0.0483078212,
-0.0248866919,
-0.0665770322,
0.0258741546,
-0.0077786078,
0.0572137088,
-0.0405242331,
0.0088316398,
-0.0081589185,
-0.0172607228,
0.0509561002,
0.0011046684,
0.0230777171,
0.0191276725,
0.063287288,
0.0428583659,
0.0491549075,
0.0025735332,
0.0034137943,
-0.0272190068,
0.0962690562,
-0.046231702,
-0.0007403094,
-0.0097110113,
-0.0069427416,
0.0087440787,
-0.0457179099,
0.0074284109,
0.0068598832,
0.0013887635,
0.0012613531,
-0.0044617252,
0.0441938974,
-0.017248584,
-0.0172890779,
0.0133855175,
-0.0091737937,
0.0219960753,
-0.0009263839,
-0.0302749444,
-0.0021622549,
-0.0523418598,
-0.0415297672,
-0.0172600765,
0.0067220032,
0.0219570212,
-0.0012886744,
-0.0410014391,
-0.0045483415,
-0.0302213542,
-0.0103961099,
0.0267298352,
-0.0070479335,
-0.0301251598,
0.0352983512,
-0.047667928,
0.0451472662,
0.0249677338,
-0.010295189,
-0.0403819904,
0.0015076911,
-0.0503957309,
-0.0194882806,
-0.0178363919,
0.008613022,
-0.0165754985,
-0.0203573294,
-0.0178907868,
-0.0298950206,
0.0055595567,
0.0322983377,
-0.0133075872,
0.0244880468,
-0.0073180906,
0.0017386611,
-0.0182181038,
0.0389216579,
-0.056071274,
0.0105463052,
0.0138514461,
-0.0458067581,
0.0188210066,
0.0080064321,
0.0824665055,
-0.0514167398,
0.03198741,
0.0008744432,
-0.0127734672,
-0.01963971,
-0.0238081701,
-0.0735842213,
0.0172823202,
-0.0414106399,
0.0003109972,
-0.036738161,
0.0605463348,
0.009866843,
-0.0090495339,
-0.0677107647,
-0.0038043,
-0.004403682,
0.0186720677,
0.0903230608,
0.0093063768,
-0.0189489294,
-0.0154986214,
-0.0354990512,
0.0432089046,
-0.0142708169,
0.0026374278,
0.0994191319,
0.0220542885,
-0.0423212871,
0.0283940881,
0.0063203075,
0.009027428,
-0.0284573324,
-0.0183566958,
0.004753287,
0.0068336851,
-0.0091892686,
-0.0088084778,
0.0359192081,
-0.0458752364,
-0.0198211446,
0.085865885,
-0.0159903448,
-0.025317451,
0.0418764763,
0.0379020609,
0.0188154206,
-0.0067222966,
-0.0656273738,
0.0446774103,
0.0375332236,
-0.0232370272,
0.0094787683,
-0.0400300957,
0.033374019,
-0.0386426598,
-0.0337813161,
0.0205173958,
-0.0433432236,
0.0303584225,
0.0366795994,
0.0509634987,
0.0175480321,
-0.0394722223,
-0.0307116881,
-0.0158034507,
-0.0441515483,
0.0197096076,
-0.006421668,
0.0398668312,
0.0926633328,
0.0684081391,
0.0481988229,
-0.0105425194,
-0.0118323937,
-0.0050026616,
0.0046671755,
0.0017252802,
-0.0464858599,
0.0042560357,
-0.0735441893,
-0.0530240387,
-0.0700182244,
-0.0094608748,
0.0208338983,
0.0057086302,
0.0165508948,
0.0432780832,
-0.0273683202,
0.0163773708,
-0.0076723159,
0.0143313929,
-0.0504862815,
0.0684432611,
0.0241375696,
-0.0292526074,
0.0355437212,
0.0260499418,
-0.0017394611,
0.0090380125,
-0.0512080155,
-0.0076162745,
0.0401664488,
0.0328132659,
-0.0566701926,
0.0245936997,
-0.0499505736,
0.0167055912,
-0.0103875007,
-0.0512658246,
-0.035170339,
-0.0095147444,
-0.0503983833,
0.0109519679,
-0.0235425327,
0.0055739074,
-0.035138756,
0.0594792105,
0.0005788784,
0.0728645697,
0.0307771638,
-0.0065334835,
-0.0377623029,
0.0266914088,
0.0120974649,
-0.0323916487,
0.0028500645,
0.0113016609,
-0.0117512681,
0.0384600572,
0.0282044541,
-0.0032499838,
-0.0087717222,
-0.0033073542,
-0.0165955666,
0.0067251241,
0.0207599234,
0.0330671258,
-0.0142352367,
0.0247336235,
0.012027611,
-0.0057693175,
-0.0746141225,
0.0161897615,
-0.0448476225,
-0.003957896,
0.0161749572,
0.0136166774,
-0.0517580546,
0.0403329879,
-0.0070102001,
0.0304445177,
0.0417905413,
0.0192346051,
0.0344817266,
-0.0672133788,
-0.0284068044,
-0.0227110498,
-0.0130523285,
0.0202049445,
-0.0174538232,
-0.0641590357,
0.0029291401,
0.014279915,
0.0286390893,
0.0001628015,
0.0518479161,
0.0158019029,
0.0006730857,
-0.0646760836,
-0.0152849611,
-0.0669020191,
0.0191539414,
0.0222856328,
-0.0299958996,
0.0126441047,
0.0671628937,
-0.0264100786,
0.0037078541,
-0.0345762037,
0.0407093316,
0.0107835531,
-0.0491107553,
-0.0263792612,
0.0277233683,
0.016076535,
0.0504492,
-0.0181779526,
-0.008749214,
0.0562872551,
-0.0133390278,
-0.0218654331,
-0.0443420708,
0.0184601936,
-0.0306061152,
0.0242449082,
0.0165441465,
0.0371329859,
0.0129150515,
-0.0666297823,
-0.0059028091,
0.0746757761,
0.0572291613,
-0.0557697564,
-0.0004896174,
-0.0169769004,
0.0114162164,
-0.0259088073,
-0.0328400806,
-0.0358488075,
-0.045045387,
0.0307428408,
-0.0084078778,
-0.0041932501,
-0.0074389498,
-0.0607992485,
0.0115152523,
-0.0214213133,
-0.0085385945,
-0.0124975881,
-0.0187191647,
-0.0047735921,
0.0577747598,
0.0929556265,
-0.038479086,
-0.0121167172,
-0.010998969,
-0.0030167471,
0.0326579101,
-0.0170309339,
-0.0063420022,
-0.0237442013,
0.0191984307,
0.0388632044,
-0.0270409938,
0.0479634218,
0.0483200178,
-0.0235560667,
-0.0203648414,
-0.0271517411,
0.0844768956,
0.0087554771,
-0.0619129017,
0.0041397396,
0.0526581556,
-0.000361241,
0.0040569641,
0.0059120199,
-0.0973750055,
-0.0369354486,
-0.0148889469,
0.0502009951,
0.0023955121,
0.0057295836,
-0.0063450998,
-0.1249842122,
0.010877803,
-0.0085104667,
-0.0031514964,
-0.0759548172,
-0.0222563706,
-0.0328440368,
-0.0446857475,
0.0625363067,
-0.0120781735,
-0.0160907861,
0.0238893311,
0.012564511,
0.0384871103,
-0.0843681321,
0.0336381011,
0.0006478955,
0.015075624,
0.0793090388,
-0.0226678438,
-0.0003435866,
-0.0151044838,
-0.0457613803,
0.0001501434,
-0.0349850915,
0.0020852855,
0.0468829311,
-0.0106984973,
-0.0014248352,
0.0174049716,
0.0226910189,
-0.0408882648,
0.0074191596,
0.0007335567,
0.0079501774,
0.003304265,
-0.0472435318,
0.0073783351,
-0.0826869234,
-0.0140412785,
0.0673646927,
0.0200167689,
-0.0328964554,
-0.0428113341,
-0.0412295349,
0.0165938586,
-0.0576717779,
-0.0330697261,
0.0282704327,
0.0311769638,
-0.0757394657,
-0.0542556755,
-0.0335586034,
0.047248017,
0.0004487998,
0.0055781556,
-0.028084049,
0.009389841,
0.0201933086,
-0.0907936096,
-0.0323261246,
-0.0251350235,
0.0364138559,
-0.0159636661,
0.0118837785,
0.063648589,
-0.0917787105,
-0.0084015867,
-0.0048805936,
-0.0367277712,
-0.0268430337,
-0.0226023737,
0.0381108299,
0.0114536742,
0.0490363911,
-0.0392997973,
-0.0654416457,
-0.0026840633,
0.0531096943,
-0.0223711729,
-0.0365137458,
-0.0084057385,
0.0207534116,
-0.0071595758,
0.0065108696,
-0.048638355,
0.0246634446,
0.0122630149,
0.0589280613,
0.0363578647,
-0.0439909361,
0.0576130599,
0.0321686342,
-0.0073065935,
-0.0270640906,
0.0327780321,
-0.0150186624,
0.0078295199,
0.0114182476,
-0.0233305842,
-0.0501377396,
-0.0238315649,
0.035835132,
0.011703399,
0.0083367648,
0.0339007117,
0.0449518822,
0.0392372198,
-0.0410991609,
0.0215570573,
-0.0508746877,
0.0444253758,
0.0190155413,
-0.013961398,
-0.0075930324,
-0.0050185262,
0.0435479023,
0.0533968098,
-0.0333718993,
0.0340976827,
0.0091950595,
0.0063964669,
-0.072807312,
0.0447738357,
0.0416985676,
0.0135186622,
-0.0793127045,
0.004609751,
0.0004185895,
0.0098097585,
0.0291277654,
-0.0245824512,
-0.015127575,
-0.0299280137,
0.0609513037,
-0.0014520824,
-0.0256324299,
0.0135755083,
0.0175916143,
-0.0325489976,
-0.0771274343,
0.0873456895,
0.0208137445,
0.0566619001,
-0.0423942469,
-0.0271758121,
-0.0630428866,
0.0094113676,
-0.0437287763,
-0.0308714956,
-0.028744394,
0.0337283984,
-0.0306099672,
-0.0453650877,
-0.0419054665,
-0.0318823941,
0.0710054711,
0.0597990453,
0.0287695769,
0.047475487,
0.0041255034,
-0.0055098315,
-0.0133902309,
-0.0023981873,
-0.0570303574,
0.0211525764,
-0.0214308091,
-5.566524111e-33,
0.0150756212,
-0.0209159143,
-0.0070827734,
0.0081325443,
0.0203026757,
-0.0146520315,
-0.034094315,
-0.008207269,
0.0126454262,
0.0071703736,
0.0401363522,
-0.0299634971,
0.0159847774,
0.0557120703,
0.0416289233,
-0.0437626205,
0.0432382375,
0.0398747735,
-0.0186703727,
0.0600940213,
0.0263497923,
-0.0023260515,
0.0557099134,
-0.035106957,
-0.0079189064,
-0.022625871,
-0.0225976054,
0.0085706152,
0.046412427,
0.085279271,
-0.0068869758,
0.0657592565,
0.0181217175,
-0.0724321082,
0.002606584,
-0.0284108631,
-0.1169275045,
-0.0067015532,
-0.0527633317,
0.0405942425,
-0.0098271472,
-0.0365371332,
-0.0036741165,
-0.0105895149,
-0.00243426,
0.01618113,
0.0620804057,
-0.0344377868,
-0.0242243465,
-0.1032748446,
-0.0468778014,
0.0202053953,
-0.0160814505,
-0.0107916128,
0.1140365228,
0.023977749,
0.0160006937,
0.0062367204,
-0.0120377671,
0.0640066192,
-0.0062636235,
-0.0176514052,
0.0529155657,
0.0273456108,
0.008477876,
0.0115871243,
0.0662702024,
-0.0245576855,
-0.0256682243,
0.0825247541,
-0.0321542136,
0.0697106495,
0.0267282873,
0.0532044843,
0.0395867452,
0.0013135873,
-0.016704252,
0.0732156187,
0.0480975397,
0.0085938862,
-0.0051805875,
0.008545843,
-0.0392888188,
-0.0197296888,
-0.0145331593,
0.0118175671,
-0.0579505935,
-0.0308312587,
0.0345329233,
0.0371061042,
-0.0893559307,
0.0614692084,
0.0504560396,
-0.0401121676,
-0.0195382312,
0.0328207463,
-0.0135394204,
0.0534268841,
-0.0009770907,
-0.0416461639,
-0.0033609062,
-0.0403146222,
0.0381467678,
-0.0491551422,
-0.0232774168,
0.0005285851,
0.0291058794,
0.0091901487,
-0.0066345134,
0.0212208331,
-0.0142284613,
0.0146432724,
-0.0029323816,
0.0053344532,
0.0201493781,
0.029811183,
-0.065289259,
0.0394473039,
0.0272820909,
0.0571915768,
-0.0357949436,
-0.0441222228,
0.0474451892,
0.0031826894,
-0.0316501074,
0.0233151503,
-0.0496242084,
-0.0497255437,
0.0132405479,
-0.0082069607,
-0.0044659255,
0.0327461995,
2.608e-7,
0.0098945461,
0.0124041932,
0.0522062555,
0.021893695,
-0.0017345543,
0.0518768914,
0.0527826063,
0.0207234286,
-0.0034260056,
-0.0477833264,
0.0331157595,
0.0141957346,
0.0485313982,
0.0030988122,
-0.0335935429,
0.0545687415,
-0.0102333333,
0.0136065874,
-0.0219437834,
0.0149479993,
0.0541893952,
0.0573914088,
-0.0031007985,
0.0030927621,
0.0314685479,
0.0452154689,
0.0633776486,
0.0082149776,
0.0309030972,
0.0337962173,
0.0026318559,
0.0068014488,
-0.0297420379,
-0.0231347699,
-0.040580228,
0.0102260299,
0.0298538134,
0.0330316871,
0.0032844828,
-0.0327196233,
-0.021762915,
-0.0326049216,
0.0082769748,
-0.044406116,
0.0747401118,
-0.0508821346,
-0.0380544439,
-0.0081180725,
-0.0665004998,
0.0337489955,
-0.0563100874,
-0.0333287306,
-0.0237071924,
0.0004656255,
0.0140256993,
-0.0128072789,
-0.018892318,
-0.049307622,
-0.001452223,
-0.0189558174,
-0.0230999589,
-0.0233188961,
0.0040002661,
0.0575409457,
0.0209131017,
-0.041860532,
-0.0083091967,
2.070032006e-34,
0.0263213255,
0.0097520845,
-0.0223776475,
0.0409858637,
0.018485887,
-0.024067305,
0.0018130083,
-0.0090468284,
0.0021908393,
-0.0553026199,
-0.0488163009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01130v1 | Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning for Speech Translation | 2024-07-01T09:51:48 | 2024-07-01T09:51:48 | Rao Ma, Yassir Fathullah, Mengjie Qian, Siyuan Tang, Mark Gales, Kate Knill | cs.CL | cs.CL | There has been increasing interest in building multilingual foundation models
for NLP and speech research. Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer has been
demonstrated on a range of NLP tasks where a model fine-tuned on task-specific
data in one language yields performance gains in other languages. Here, we
explore whether speech-based models exhibit the same transfer capability. Using
Whisper as an example of a multilingual speech foundation model, we examine the
utterance representation generated by the speech encoder. Despite some
language-sensitive information being preserved in the audio embedding, words
from different languages are mapped to a similar semantic space, as evidenced
by a high recall rate in a speech-to-speech retrieval task. Leveraging this
shared embedding space, zero-shot cross-lingual transfer is demonstrated in
speech translation. When the Whisper model is fine-tuned solely on
English-to-Chinese translation data, performance improvements are observed for
input utterances in other languages. Additionally, experiments on low-resource
languages show that Whisper can perform speech translation for utterances from
languages unseen during pre-training by utilizing cross-lingual
representations. | Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning for Speech Translation: There has been increasing interest in building multilingual foundation models
for NLP and speech research. Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer has been
demonstrated on a range of NLP tasks where a model fine-tuned on task-specific
data in one language yields performance gains in other languages. Here, we
explore whether speech-based models exhibit the same transfer capability. Using
Whisper as an example of a multilingual speech foundation model, we examine the
utterance representation generated by the speech encoder. Despite some
language-sensitive information being preserved in the audio embedding, words
from different languages are mapped to a similar semantic space, as evidenced
by a high recall rate in a speech-to-speech retrieval task. Leveraging this
shared embedding space, zero-shot cross-lingual transfer is demonstrated in
speech translation. When the Whisper model is fine-tuned solely on
English-to-Chinese translation data, performance improvements are observed for
input utterances in other languages. Additionally, experiments on low-resource
languages show that Whisper can perform speech translation for utterances from
languages unseen during pre-training by utilizing cross-lingual
representations. | [
-0.0327687822,
0.0293795802,
-0.0180625245,
0.050833784,
-0.0304217897,
-0.0241801515,
0.0484008156,
-0.0011795264,
-0.0534178168,
-0.0237792153,
-0.1029111072,
-0.0256789401,
0.0185087062,
-0.0183354095,
0.037954811,
-0.0563253537,
0.0492058545,
-0.0227275155,
-0.0169156808,
0.0019730066,
-0.0124828275,
-0.0089019919,
-0.0089333476,
0.0225330926,
-0.006920781,
-0.0058772247,
0.0155205037,
0.0266761258,
0.0116701769,
0.0038274352,
-0.048374936,
-0.0063036252,
0.0371833704,
0.0328823552,
0.000001771,
-0.0280314349,
-0.0281304978,
0.0055571278,
-0.0175502989,
-0.0105099622,
0.0309554301,
-0.0438594371,
-0.0256069656,
0.0368598849,
-0.0053160209,
-0.0570316836,
0.0635274649,
0.0401887335,
0.0196091831,
0.0821524784,
-0.040694043,
-0.0070473179,
0.0185234062,
-0.0274199918,
0.0156924203,
-0.0483956635,
-0.0179184284,
-0.0077006752,
-0.0539408028,
0.0010909679,
-0.055155348,
0.0610558577,
-0.0310609993,
0.0070453831,
-0.0088498928,
0.0119677503,
-0.0387071334,
-0.0280277319,
-0.0300579611,
0.0634051487,
-0.0554702394,
0.0003228151,
-0.0153044332,
0.0225969162,
-0.0205452144,
-0.019243598,
-0.0700151771,
0.0106764631,
0.0450779535,
0.0033581147,
0.0091997171,
0.054987289,
0.0242342595,
-0.0580949932,
0.0050521344,
0.0142032979,
0.0314839333,
-0.0301052202,
0.0082868179,
-0.0068506254,
0.0481924377,
-0.0184728503,
0.0384786166,
0.0065761446,
0.0064249928,
0.0189315695,
-0.018561719,
-0.0248558577,
-0.0178823154,
-0.0201840885,
0.026462283,
0.0897376314,
-0.0437197648,
0.0453263447,
-0.0621907935,
0.0675357953,
-0.0192578807,
0.0109117301,
-0.057943549,
-0.063199155,
-0.0381558053,
0.0192883052,
-0.0524446368,
0.0196192451,
-0.020499099,
-0.0410039648,
-0.0290247984,
-0.01047095,
-0.011409549,
0.0091940342,
-0.0091124866,
-0.0260026101,
-0.0629914626,
0.0096435416,
0.0097680045,
0.0698199868,
0.0094293039,
0.0383165441,
-0.0022713218,
-0.0559672192,
-0.033996053,
0.0280095227,
0.0249385107,
-0.0257680509,
-0.0042311507,
0.1057864651,
-0.029458873,
-0.0012256231,
-0.0358585604,
0.0058456883,
-0.0044176341,
-0.0485050492,
0.0314188823,
-0.0376866832,
0.0644766837,
0.0047915471,
0.0328629464,
-0.0497883037,
-0.0019978245,
-0.0118675288,
-0.0150104715,
0.0498927534,
0.0271618459,
0.0141684823,
0.0364506915,
-0.0238428265,
-0.0584159866,
0.0733167157,
0.0583482571,
-0.001787373,
0.0368830785,
-0.0348249301,
-0.0387101024,
0.0629432499,
0.0247719549,
0.0296680331,
-0.0169111248,
-0.0225973837,
0.0416619889,
0.0058614006,
0.0210089926,
0.034515094,
-0.0372741036,
-0.0111095384,
0.0416738987,
0.0820291787,
0.0273911115,
0.0265930071,
0.0518633202,
-0.0067447224,
-0.0470548347,
0.0083466126,
-0.0019372855,
0.0402375385,
-0.0012932591,
-0.0030207385,
0.0387839749,
0.0220068879,
-0.0527063385,
0.0225225147,
0.0004309968,
-0.0210067388,
0.0349561684,
-0.0128565105,
0.039088726,
0.0402446613,
-0.0597277768,
0.0735308826,
0.0249336082,
-0.0671437532,
0.0504354015,
-0.0004783619,
-0.0186906438,
0.0366020389,
-0.0125988629,
0.0142230727,
0.0154656945,
-0.0266761668,
0.0033104366,
0.030567674,
0.0511484258,
0.0167732891,
0.0709783137,
-0.0522867925,
0.012342901,
-0.009359967,
-0.0059146252,
0.0708381683,
-0.0321906246,
0.0710340068,
0.0105452025,
-0.0176176243,
-0.0100589711,
-0.0228759628,
-0.070063211,
0.0098606991,
0.0504627787,
0.0270096101,
0.0487808473,
0.0296679065,
-0.0259291735,
0.0157205276,
0.0186682809,
-0.0510905683,
-0.0031228655,
0.0281592328,
-0.0600346066,
-0.0382800438,
0.0057293479,
-0.0289549436,
0.0616594292,
-0.0139778173,
0.0099147279,
-0.0751233995,
0.0442496203,
0.017804889,
0.0753990039,
-0.0439372249,
0.0329709351,
-0.0113779083,
0.0510668457,
0.0338941589,
-0.0334790722,
0.0559845343,
0.0045327293,
-0.0088197291,
0.0154217295,
0.0372177288,
-0.0495793,
-0.0325596929,
0.0639378875,
-0.0081857285,
0.0233919844,
0.0183686577,
-0.0195348784,
0.0073305778,
-0.0095405011,
-0.0852181613,
0.0471346006,
-0.0060822889,
0.0148912547,
0.0073745963,
0.0428649299,
0.009757407,
0.005300161,
-0.0437027328,
0.0208148062,
0.0119229946,
0.0292365476,
-0.0263619311,
-0.0232179333,
0.0289307535,
-0.0240936782,
-0.0013582307,
0.0512397103,
0.0202284046,
-0.0437829681,
-0.0306243505,
-0.0307769254,
0.0535264388,
-0.0236907806,
-0.0066224416,
0.0008773779,
-0.051907219,
-0.0220620893,
0.0130338455,
0.0322250538,
0.0315665007,
-0.035317041,
-0.0004622358,
0.0242373664,
-0.0402758718,
-0.060387712,
0.0011572021,
0.0252807923,
0.0041238624,
-0.0270276796,
0.0234572776,
-0.0307712257,
0.047546085,
0.0256055985,
0.0027261483,
-0.0627382547,
-0.0416227616,
-0.0129949292,
-0.0225670822,
-0.0137785701,
-0.0016486857,
-0.0009932646,
0.0347804204,
-0.0269323811,
-0.0028147944,
0.0293423049,
-0.0784485266,
-0.0448591821,
-0.0058551249,
-0.0120305596,
-0.0214991141,
0.0113506103,
-0.053203363,
0.0306556206,
0.0019477643,
-0.0384679325,
-0.0089467065,
0.0101899952,
0.0096034845,
-0.0384725928,
0.0031302013,
-0.0051284907,
-0.0227976684,
-0.0341403484,
-0.0230090171,
-0.0224621315,
0.0119228885,
-0.001424127,
0.0418132693,
-0.0158915557,
0.0000495259,
-0.0603643842,
0.0503576137,
0.0449919589,
0.038582921,
0.000287037,
0.0366349779,
-0.0171498414,
0.0120588122,
-0.0208576769,
0.0028203528,
-0.0071857157,
-0.0368249156,
0.0447954945,
-0.0197320022,
0.0644443855,
0.0182880647,
-0.0118692676,
0.0069872332,
0.0411185101,
0.0386785902,
-0.0508300103,
0.001516324,
0.0832132399,
-0.0174533445,
-0.0073998254,
0.0815756246,
-0.0390599743,
-0.0140108867,
-0.0263299923,
-0.0129152369,
0.0037199822,
0.0104832593,
0.0020028425,
-0.0494004823,
-0.0300190058,
0.0371820293,
-0.0117064659,
0.0425271727,
0.0267749168,
-0.0221082065,
-0.1296048611,
0.026555568,
0.0413346514,
-0.0976776108,
-0.0431239605,
-0.0557987913,
-0.0227408689,
-0.0221292712,
0.0614660084,
-0.0490995683,
-3.692e-7,
-0.0370944254,
0.0187212937,
0.0245307665,
-0.0325428918,
0.0163143761,
-0.0454534404,
0.0552755147,
0.0299701728,
0.0394143574,
-0.0093612159,
-0.0305076744,
-0.0046260594,
-0.0074377647,
-0.0161319952,
0.0059183771,
0.0369025804,
0.0074512498,
-0.0117329052,
0.0767113417,
-0.004889857,
-0.0225437917,
0.0112891616,
0.0273140967,
0.0568529628,
0.0216664243,
0.0073584411,
0.0424309596,
0.017603498,
0.0009344617,
0.0828536898,
0.0116186617,
-0.0299035218,
0.0110100918,
-0.0030960252,
-0.0054201735,
-0.0327907242,
-0.0204037447,
0.0037660557,
-0.0431514494,
-0.0178686325,
-0.0688010827,
-0.0273113567,
-0.008145839,
0.0306033678,
0.0482733026,
0.0082301348,
0.0330377296,
-0.0118205994,
0.0035181451,
-0.0323708951,
-0.0277707111,
0.0270505697,
-0.0205259472,
-0.0128049962,
0.0453059673,
-0.0446523465,
0.0222926755,
-0.0287102591,
-0.0495516546,
-0.0372808725,
-0.0446237549,
0.0143240262,
0.0105641223,
0.0508171208,
-0.0246396139,
0.0122910887,
0.0528878942,
-0.0431954935,
-0.0835840926,
-0.0053916117,
0.0679905638,
-0.0175639354,
-0.003147861,
0.0377498642,
-0.0428045653,
0.0025834793,
0.0143973408,
0.0263211373,
0.0051218518,
-0.0352763347,
-0.0179839134,
0.0006706028,
0.0292743742,
0.0044217734,
0.011722588,
-0.0423416682,
0.0298611466,
-0.0375870541,
0.0276450831,
-0.0437539741,
-0.0491420627,
0.0538991839,
-0.0064339656,
0.0095988568,
0.0034983149,
-0.0149851404,
-0.0209550858,
-0.0144512365,
0.0100487769,
0.0220784452,
0.008931323,
-0.0120198047,
0.039019037,
-0.0023726381,
0.0267460402,
0.0196609683,
0.015798172,
-0.0519924387,
0.0071135396,
-0.0264545586,
0.0376551524,
0.0230359454,
-0.0236123111,
-0.0292638093,
-0.031837713,
0.0106372163,
0.0121812904,
0.0542800799,
-0.0318538658,
0.1075751409,
0.0121120848,
0.0134270722,
-0.0246274564,
0.03753566,
-0.0459689312,
-0.0073722601,
-0.009549032,
-0.021328371,
-0.0012795981,
0.0391646661,
0.0493645109,
0.0067137713,
0.0411466248,
-0.0338530727,
0.0300297607,
-0.0091925152,
-0.0211338121,
0.0481256768,
-0.0056838212,
0.0027135478,
0.0100504411,
-0.0178948585,
-0.0747206807,
0.0418956988,
-0.0422907509,
0.0057227523,
0.005267648,
-0.0013600988,
0.0636516064,
-0.0401389189,
0.015072478,
-0.027825661,
-0.0576495826,
0.0124225346,
0.0011491554,
0.0115457149,
-5.729720563e-33,
-0.0441960543,
0.0393941328,
0.0254472848,
0.0202390887,
-0.0256536026,
-0.0134578757,
-0.0602217615,
-0.0094486112,
-0.0313852206,
-0.0094387624,
-0.0146557009,
-0.0093282126,
0.0259824395,
0.0347986035,
0.0003309551,
0.0001021305,
0.0587450936,
-0.002882981,
-0.0124562504,
0.0407264978,
0.0615749918,
0.0502549522,
0.0599438176,
-0.044123169,
-0.0198559966,
0.0062971939,
0.0114476969,
-0.0043638563,
0.0636210516,
0.0423860215,
-0.003873422,
0.0270109978,
-0.0004453256,
-0.0580764487,
-0.0296811052,
-0.0008147049,
-0.0852321386,
-0.0098296134,
0.0254907422,
0.0347068943,
0.0249020662,
-0.0323274843,
0.0199554656,
-0.0229113214,
0.0109210284,
-0.0290294066,
-0.006491296,
-0.0389296152,
-0.0351715498,
-0.0152010545,
-0.0864701197,
-0.0035140454,
-0.0191351157,
-0.0239827484,
0.0950220004,
0.0621315427,
-0.0186199881,
-0.0337147079,
-0.0653804615,
0.0277590305,
-0.0586994775,
0.0487640053,
0.0428411737,
0.0295057297,
-0.0332030319,
0.0233857818,
0.0503808409,
-0.0526208691,
0.0735488907,
0.0042423285,
0.0528435782,
0.019393811,
-0.0012229518,
0.0484171249,
-0.0029260309,
-0.0666689277,
-0.0534084924,
-0.0018745952,
0.0069422764,
-0.0142674195,
0.0432815552,
0.0410746671,
0.0218693018,
-0.0103068482,
-0.0633733794,
-0.0525668189,
-0.024551345,
-0.0432234332,
0.0282551609,
0.0026117088,
-0.000942734,
-0.0095516993,
0.1268623918,
-0.0184645597,
-0.0123389596,
0.0046901172,
-0.0185710564,
-0.021041641,
-0.0400963388,
0.0542515628,
-0.0468081683,
-0.0823591426,
0.0404335968,
0.0186775383,
0.0181797817,
-0.0189732518,
0.0374289267,
0.027336387,
-0.0436789505,
0.0014307293,
-0.0453415401,
-0.0074933092,
-0.0001104881,
0.0331232324,
-0.0039148605,
0.0261281841,
-0.014900893,
0.0489797443,
-0.0130307181,
-0.0005783052,
-0.0126836989,
-0.0241804309,
-0.0106162196,
0.0261740815,
-0.0833804458,
0.0259756595,
-0.0318659879,
-0.0003237756,
0.0394929387,
-0.0185398981,
-0.0312844589,
0.0112763541,
2.604e-7,
-0.0134431859,
0.0006017266,
-0.0059105717,
-0.024741387,
0.0319685154,
0.0218715072,
-0.0767434761,
0.0456896648,
0.0244267378,
-0.0013386128,
-0.019266054,
0.0280361716,
0.1212718487,
0.0330399945,
-0.0798882917,
-0.0441411026,
-0.0270350892,
0.0131844915,
-0.0175295603,
0.0092059877,
0.0006292176,
0.09040007,
-0.0231344961,
0.0079101212,
-0.0125279939,
-0.0035514517,
0.0782576874,
-0.0317728445,
-0.0399817489,
-0.0120685156,
-0.0401599333,
0.0444522128,
-0.0541798919,
0.0042995918,
-0.049805712,
0.0560426712,
0.0733008534,
0.0575204678,
0.0153555525,
-0.0656977519,
-0.008462836,
0.0272440873,
-0.0475877225,
0.000289915,
0.0429056212,
-0.013469656,
-0.0379735641,
0.0134794852,
-0.0223691296,
0.0572666004,
0.0418967269,
-0.0235446766,
-0.0279435478,
0.0262763016,
0.0503861383,
0.0441118069,
-0.0571162663,
-0.0080591999,
-0.0116054164,
0.0090632457,
-0.0347200148,
-0.0214359686,
0.0049388665,
-0.0536535569,
-0.0095527582,
-0.0137466826,
0.0055568125,
1.787955377e-34,
0.0084854802,
-0.0120627452,
0.0148111451,
-0.0071065086,
0.020547308,
-0.0522149727,
0.0207644049,
0.0095734503,
-0.0395114645,
-0.0221770648,
-0.0389329791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01126v1 | Investigating the potential of Sparse Mixtures-of-Experts for multi-domain neural machine translation | 2024-07-01T09:45:22 | 2024-07-01T09:45:22 | Nadezhda Chirkova, Vassilina Nikoulina, Jean-Luc Meunier, Alexandre Bérard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We focus on multi-domain Neural Machine Translation, with the goal of
developing efficient models which can handle data from various domains seen
during training and are robust to domains unseen during training. We
hypothesize that Sparse Mixture-of-Experts (SMoE) models are a good fit for
this task, as they enable efficient model scaling, which helps to accommodate a
variety of multi-domain data, and allow flexible sharing of parameters between
domains, potentially enabling knowledge transfer between similar domains and
limiting negative transfer. We conduct a series of experiments aimed at
validating the utility of SMoE for the multi-domain scenario, and find that a
straightforward width scaling of Transformer is a simpler and surprisingly more
efficient approach in practice, and reaches the same performance level as SMoE.
We also search for a better recipe for robustness of multi-domain systems,
highlighting the importance of mixing-in a generic domain, i.e. Paracrawl, and
introducing a simple technique, domain randomization. | Investigating the potential of Sparse Mixtures-of-Experts for multi-domain neural machine translation: We focus on multi-domain Neural Machine Translation, with the goal of
developing efficient models which can handle data from various domains seen
during training and are robust to domains unseen during training. We
hypothesize that Sparse Mixture-of-Experts (SMoE) models are a good fit for
this task, as they enable efficient model scaling, which helps to accommodate a
variety of multi-domain data, and allow flexible sharing of parameters between
domains, potentially enabling knowledge transfer between similar domains and
limiting negative transfer. We conduct a series of experiments aimed at
validating the utility of SMoE for the multi-domain scenario, and find that a
straightforward width scaling of Transformer is a simpler and surprisingly more
efficient approach in practice, and reaches the same performance level as SMoE.
We also search for a better recipe for robustness of multi-domain systems,
highlighting the importance of mixing-in a generic domain, i.e. Paracrawl, and
introducing a simple technique, domain randomization. | [
0.0067391549,
0.0263269525,
0.010732579,
0.0140068624,
0.0162520986,
-0.0198186543,
0.0741310194,
-0.0133042149,
-0.0499875546,
-0.0177459605,
-0.0674297065,
-0.0567800514,
0.0268426575,
-0.0026902775,
0.0427825078,
-0.0468451865,
-0.0285036229,
-0.016901236,
-0.0649437681,
-0.0068744277,
-0.0228209794,
-0.0074590067,
0.0059194723,
0.057416752,
-0.0211058725,
0.024325503,
-0.0244516544,
0.0424544699,
0.0385465659,
0.0080848327,
-0.002043019,
0.0596643351,
0.0343212299,
0.0374180228,
0.0000020574,
-0.0005020312,
-0.0331340022,
0.0204333309,
0.0233991072,
-0.0270656347,
0.0378868692,
-0.045013465,
0.0035735574,
0.0074962359,
-0.0234719403,
-0.0259103719,
0.0882050619,
0.028806461,
0.0569229722,
0.1040218547,
-0.016865762,
-0.0181932151,
0.0091383718,
-0.0694702119,
-0.0181622766,
-0.0598469302,
0.0009167323,
-0.0189150181,
-0.0471782498,
0.0105694057,
-0.0111163044,
0.0372835062,
0.0261017773,
0.0115192253,
-0.0076431995,
0.0090860547,
0.0206894763,
-0.0278072208,
-0.013949546,
0.0590215847,
-0.0525738485,
0.0267685894,
-0.0170559492,
0.0122497063,
0.0083727352,
0.0217929259,
-0.0384314097,
0.0177285671,
-0.0058747302,
-0.0004654213,
-0.0531593412,
0.0753354356,
0.0494180433,
0.0093681542,
-0.0748243481,
-0.0014405416,
0.0247993246,
-0.0100038126,
-0.034173239,
0.0431484878,
-0.0421349108,
-0.0090857456,
0.0382289328,
0.0136301192,
0.0041864538,
0.00022206,
-0.0839071274,
-0.0682955757,
-0.0290260818,
0.0129652498,
0.0458410345,
0.0526297353,
-0.0074179242,
0.0445927531,
-0.0042050751,
0.0066805026,
-0.0610403456,
0.0113111418,
-0.0367847569,
-0.0294035878,
-0.0557128266,
0.0137563357,
-0.0206205528,
0.0458600186,
-0.0177752692,
-0.0021404293,
-0.0019385162,
-0.0167991966,
-0.0306270011,
-0.042506177,
0.0335245915,
-0.0068864767,
-0.0958516747,
-0.0279365107,
-0.0158497412,
0.0759307221,
-0.0157875679,
0.027553698,
0.0616409145,
-0.0294689592,
-0.0370219424,
0.0025119332,
-0.0312572606,
-0.0358911976,
-0.0191856995,
0.09908171,
-0.0382546186,
-0.0218370445,
-0.0321714841,
-0.0195047613,
-0.015489826,
-0.0568136014,
0.0358554572,
-0.0568389297,
0.0662279874,
0.0029332661,
0.0322263911,
-0.1154788062,
-0.0125088124,
-0.006773768,
-0.0147169791,
0.0307625402,
0.004898991,
-0.031778805,
0.0104819676,
0.035092894,
-0.067697823,
0.0600637272,
0.0148222176,
0.0140080983,
-0.0323625244,
0.0141214682,
0.0001865372,
0.0139804501,
0.0052232132,
0.0238591582,
-0.0095401872,
-0.0363534577,
0.0086726276,
0.0174204558,
0.0414566807,
0.0642850921,
-0.0420129262,
-0.0193447005,
0.0728202164,
0.0055139158,
0.0044663637,
0.0695938691,
0.0889538452,
-0.0146530503,
-0.0064995522,
0.0387561694,
-0.0291616898,
0.0202301629,
-0.0171955526,
-0.0387698598,
0.0345245264,
0.1008024067,
-0.0410332046,
-0.0289642587,
0.0342244953,
-0.0068825823,
-0.0257417504,
-0.0322632194,
0.0581649616,
0.0271794721,
-0.0333962888,
0.051327195,
0.0048457235,
-0.0449366942,
0.0307791866,
-0.0119648976,
-0.0651628897,
0.0093006119,
-0.0005349574,
-0.006797662,
-0.0260754712,
-0.0477862097,
0.0197735894,
0.0277711395,
0.0536948144,
0.0487352684,
0.041857712,
-0.0384352729,
-0.0569948405,
-0.006150607,
0.0202406831,
0.0340987258,
0.0319055431,
0.0293698795,
0.0563240647,
-0.0090289712,
0.019500602,
0.020529639,
-0.0231978446,
0.0302519519,
0.0367931724,
0.0119093005,
0.0249976702,
0.0235065408,
-0.0415508822,
0.0040583839,
0.0011558487,
-0.0340072438,
-0.0620003492,
-0.0147214476,
-0.0706858709,
-0.0012317324,
0.0089758225,
-0.0496314131,
0.010590516,
-0.002857401,
-0.028135879,
-0.0345926583,
-0.0081875157,
-0.0051059867,
-0.0189916193,
-0.0050357273,
0.0118203545,
0.0239292439,
0.0291354097,
-0.0289075114,
0.033726465,
-0.0039095529,
-0.0488558188,
0.0026021895,
-0.0348754227,
0.0021945189,
-0.0412695184,
-0.0391232409,
-0.0271979552,
0.0083058123,
0.0647191554,
0.0116736079,
0.0046647312,
0.0013684717,
-0.07318151,
-0.0312393494,
0.0088978242,
-0.0274769831,
0.0111651933,
0.0239919126,
0.0560928397,
0.0186329503,
0.0245984886,
-0.024878297,
0.0102265915,
-0.0364398807,
0.0118914284,
-0.0190643221,
0.0139878243,
0.013808446,
-0.0021337268,
-0.0274752043,
0.0132862329,
0.086045377,
-0.0236838292,
0.0035275726,
-0.07187628,
0.0522733852,
-0.0216947831,
0.0221784152,
0.0020876899,
-0.0264378842,
-0.0074925511,
-0.0338113084,
0.042891454,
0.025690997,
-0.0158334132,
-0.0088295871,
0.0525295958,
0.0113891112,
-0.0468235984,
0.0205048956,
-0.0419684015,
-0.0072357045,
-0.0379901156,
0.0322051197,
-0.0031979927,
0.0602804869,
-0.0144188637,
-0.0390457623,
-0.0570710935,
0.0124705359,
0.0198696442,
-0.0417398661,
0.0025487607,
0.043305818,
0.0483223982,
0.0203524567,
-0.0123744681,
-0.0127572212,
0.101079002,
-0.0178400148,
0.0138441687,
-0.027462719,
-0.0333009437,
-0.0172370765,
-0.0264307652,
-0.0539390966,
0.0343462452,
0.0037248835,
0.0110511892,
-0.0683455095,
0.0098896697,
-0.0159635935,
0.0224660821,
0.0635772496,
-0.0499962941,
0.003880528,
-0.0055904295,
-0.0345899686,
-0.015719993,
-0.0115820607,
-0.0123609938,
0.0249164961,
0.0289106853,
-0.0436323136,
-0.0861903355,
0.0162694082,
0.0229033735,
0.0741931051,
-0.025066901,
-0.0278697237,
-0.0092484839,
0.0399347953,
-0.0232222416,
0.0425014608,
0.0138568366,
-0.0423833244,
-0.0094722984,
0.0127724241,
0.0027003428,
-0.0404150859,
-0.0673701018,
-0.007902327,
0.0035610956,
0.022451289,
-0.0207299851,
0.0074979961,
0.0516799912,
-0.0396773405,
0.0026669749,
0.0692127794,
-0.028207615,
-0.0579889677,
-0.0186830368,
0.0167324208,
0.0380359776,
0.0254650842,
0.0310645159,
-0.0438146777,
-0.0329445712,
-0.0009013657,
0.006144207,
0.0459348634,
-0.0034414786,
-0.0061267796,
-0.0667451173,
-0.0203350149,
0.0447887145,
-0.0470456481,
-0.073038958,
-0.0065782806,
-0.0219513588,
-0.0309765302,
0.0066537182,
-0.0488599688,
0.0059524104,
-0.0246578697,
0.0194756016,
0.0954444706,
-0.0903082937,
-0.0142525472,
-0.0720647946,
0.029244313,
0.0428429618,
-0.0329516791,
-0.0119255129,
-0.0260789264,
-0.0128362775,
0.045808468,
0.0246540345,
0.0145829832,
0.0160154216,
-0.0065694931,
-0.0251042787,
0.03830925,
0.0059572677,
-0.0331571624,
0.0327382497,
0.005610493,
0.0818724856,
-0.0132015059,
-0.0147868255,
-0.0018043551,
-0.0351943821,
0.0068789697,
0.039158497,
0.0085991202,
-0.036518313,
0.022041209,
-0.0161308553,
-0.0326369181,
-0.0094311042,
-0.0518554412,
0.0141553571,
-0.0022021744,
-0.0613335744,
-0.0498070046,
-0.0135211721,
0.0259893145,
0.0807793662,
0.0269116368,
-0.0244517848,
0.0350612141,
0.027977176,
0.003846077,
0.0362032577,
-0.047756508,
0.0116673484,
-0.0714398474,
0.0117675317,
0.0470681526,
-0.0485647917,
-0.0043173884,
-0.0006576506,
-0.1195848659,
-0.0556159876,
-0.0107242595,
0.0793233141,
0.0241287798,
0.0134514859,
-0.013325504,
-0.0377879515,
0.0607079156,
0.0339318179,
-0.058744669,
0.000475482,
0.0388238505,
-0.0524081774,
-0.0042996379,
0.0214804746,
-0.0358233638,
0.0185909756,
0.0248010438,
0.0210876949,
-0.0077928896,
-0.0383176543,
0.0053510214,
-0.051121477,
0.0349636786,
-0.0045854859,
0.0050039473,
-0.0006355934,
0.0181090273,
0.0182694513,
0.0037899904,
-0.0728613436,
-0.0276483987,
0.0285335612,
0.0189408772,
0.0437884517,
0.020235477,
0.042584151,
0.0375791155,
0.0099924011,
-0.0155323055,
-0.0160123315,
0.0003155666,
0.0154838618,
0.0338748284,
0.0221784431,
0.0003922264,
0.0162768904,
-0.012738727,
-0.027908871,
0.0461871773,
0.0038863597,
0.0123085249,
0.0003249851,
0.0433563814,
-0.0685276091,
-0.0343869403,
-0.0115021123,
-0.0161873493,
0.0642090812,
0.0182033125,
0.0518594645,
0.0071286354,
-0.0034672767,
-0.0381826386,
0.0397579968,
0.0101624075,
0.0229922719,
0.0288146809,
-0.0006181074,
0.0349738561,
0.0304934513,
0.0885278657,
0.0141200125,
0.00988016,
0.0107381539,
0.0136544192,
-0.0132928845,
-0.0168446433,
0.0151296807,
-0.0066676736,
0.0001372448,
-0.0316308439,
-0.029773768,
-0.0465177409,
0.0145953819,
-0.0523075052,
0.0114829922,
0.0089853127,
0.0407024324,
0.050355643,
-0.0779038593,
0.0385855772,
0.0060609058,
-0.0096188253,
0.0613844618,
-0.0059254048,
-0.0298121255,
-6.379820734e-33,
-0.0174730122,
-0.001420235,
0.0385328978,
-0.0385857038,
0.0121288989,
-0.0121560451,
-0.0173332766,
0.0046595358,
-0.0135154473,
0.0251284428,
-0.011292221,
0.0093898242,
0.0153301926,
0.0275817662,
-0.0076774815,
-0.0172491372,
0.0975828171,
0.0003952214,
-0.0038091007,
0.0104154674,
0.0089773256,
0.0107819773,
0.0668060556,
-0.1070585325,
-0.0104943486,
0.0342690423,
-0.0080429222,
0.0148103563,
0.0169920605,
0.0165064782,
0.0122071849,
0.0117872152,
0.0074284673,
-0.0682633221,
-0.0477280021,
-0.0675025731,
-0.0642039329,
-0.028749587,
-0.0253436994,
-0.0073970538,
0.0223596096,
-0.0661618337,
0.0764158592,
-0.0023665533,
0.0177087765,
-0.0654285178,
0.0213442128,
-0.0177940466,
-0.023892032,
-0.0545966104,
-0.0166495368,
0.0120274471,
0.0124333948,
-0.0282676592,
0.0194465555,
0.021167323,
-0.007760698,
-0.0085840877,
-0.0612701252,
0.0046042884,
-0.0082533108,
0.0436638333,
0.0766574442,
0.0028646679,
-0.0403255448,
0.000721796,
-0.0084916297,
0.0337798074,
0.0019102026,
-0.0092443246,
0.036626,
0.0184473265,
0.0491942391,
0.0354116745,
0.0245338902,
0.0128027201,
-0.0585687086,
0.0630376786,
-0.0395246074,
-0.004278617,
0.0301369131,
0.001257259,
0.0053510768,
0.0029095626,
-0.0323397145,
-0.0122448327,
-0.0245323721,
-0.0316686258,
-0.0135217812,
0.032364957,
-0.0203039572,
0.0103048841,
0.0718414411,
-0.0436102115,
0.0183103047,
0.0257128254,
0.0027240925,
0.0171214752,
-0.0113294329,
0.0014233905,
-0.0041756658,
-0.0439831279,
0.0326639228,
0.0380545221,
-0.0001529465,
0.0026561862,
0.0371092483,
0.0397915244,
-0.0370983928,
-0.0400335751,
-0.0331714936,
-0.000856331,
0.0363425687,
0.0702352673,
0.0262831021,
0.014323852,
-0.0215425249,
0.0352420919,
-0.0064985254,
-0.0269911941,
0.00358651,
0.0524297208,
0.0531202704,
0.0387324132,
-0.0356335118,
-0.008846377,
-0.0505564809,
-0.0299800988,
0.0599207915,
-0.0483477302,
-0.050644882,
-0.0168105196,
2.735e-7,
0.0267100222,
0.021128593,
-0.0207181666,
-0.0408695042,
0.0041034389,
0.0483067743,
-0.0289074574,
0.042094972,
-0.014057124,
-0.0028307687,
0.0249837898,
0.0472816639,
0.0396344848,
0.0304538179,
-0.1236354336,
-0.0739415288,
0.036914885,
0.0268349517,
-0.0299188718,
-0.0392749012,
0.0112983994,
0.106869258,
0.0317480937,
-0.0007732813,
0.0257025305,
0.0059638731,
0.0671251863,
0.0077853194,
0.0296725724,
0.0082330946,
0.0512239635,
0.0123413792,
-0.0069855046,
0.0342364572,
0.0000883258,
0.0327363648,
0.0515419766,
0.0723724142,
-0.01441071,
0.0260200426,
0.0237431303,
-0.0078715608,
-0.0283558946,
0.0078916857,
0.0130799962,
-0.0853709504,
-0.0055987826,
0.0285341833,
-0.0164744668,
-0.0079851914,
0.0186721124,
-0.009422428,
-0.0097490959,
0.0084329676,
0.0131016662,
0.0098948656,
-0.0036085763,
-0.0340488628,
-0.008663211,
-0.0166754331,
-0.0508864447,
-0.0385800079,
-0.0229627322,
-0.0411868989,
0.0595918745,
-0.0238260087,
-0.0027056746,
2.455892159e-34,
0.0233241357,
-0.0022177096,
0.0173877217,
0.0041430993,
0.0164659079,
-0.0405909866,
-0.0586475916,
-0.0375224389,
-0.0162184574,
-0.045459196,
-0.0236966144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01122v1 | Calibrated Large Language Models for Binary Question Answering | 2024-07-01T09:31:03 | 2024-07-01T09:31:03 | Patrizio Giovannotti, Alexander Gammerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Quantifying the uncertainty of predictions made by large language models
(LLMs) in binary text classification tasks remains a challenge. Calibration, in
the context of LLMs, refers to the alignment between the model's predicted
probabilities and the actual correctness of its predictions. A well-calibrated
model should produce probabilities that accurately reflect the likelihood of
its predictions being correct. We propose a novel approach that utilizes the
inductive Venn--Abers predictor (IVAP) to calibrate the probabilities
associated with the output tokens corresponding to the binary labels. Our
experiments on the BoolQ dataset using the Llama 2 model demonstrate that IVAP
consistently outperforms the commonly used temperature scaling method for
various label token choices, achieving well-calibrated probabilities while
maintaining high predictive quality. Our findings contribute to the
understanding of calibration techniques for LLMs and provide a practical
solution for obtaining reliable uncertainty estimates in binary question
answering tasks, enhancing the interpretability and trustworthiness of LLM
predictions. | Calibrated Large Language Models for Binary Question Answering: Quantifying the uncertainty of predictions made by large language models
(LLMs) in binary text classification tasks remains a challenge. Calibration, in
the context of LLMs, refers to the alignment between the model's predicted
probabilities and the actual correctness of its predictions. A well-calibrated
model should produce probabilities that accurately reflect the likelihood of
its predictions being correct. We propose a novel approach that utilizes the
inductive Venn--Abers predictor (IVAP) to calibrate the probabilities
associated with the output tokens corresponding to the binary labels. Our
experiments on the BoolQ dataset using the Llama 2 model demonstrate that IVAP
consistently outperforms the commonly used temperature scaling method for
various label token choices, achieving well-calibrated probabilities while
maintaining high predictive quality. Our findings contribute to the
understanding of calibration techniques for LLMs and provide a practical
solution for obtaining reliable uncertainty estimates in binary question
answering tasks, enhancing the interpretability and trustworthiness of LLM
predictions. | [
0.0343783572,
0.0454672985,
0.0152229294,
0.0404699743,
-0.03441488,
0.0201469995,
0.0240998827,
-0.0150324414,
0.0251969602,
-0.0756301358,
-0.0104748644,
-0.0620058626,
0.019918615,
0.0146031547,
0.0149508892,
0.0046358127,
0.0270656049,
-0.0335571393,
0.0263968613,
-0.0262617394,
0.0153349144,
0.0152919553,
-0.004204093,
0.0168894511,
-0.0021083227,
-0.0063070478,
0.0167666152,
0.0029692543,
0.0052226447,
0.0123281609,
0.0320149958,
0.0724105909,
-0.0193192456,
0.0540821403,
0.0000016871,
-0.0552473143,
0.004714835,
0.0042702728,
-0.0492361896,
-0.0043650414,
-0.0078601409,
0.044724483,
0.0386434458,
0.0618010424,
-0.0158206988,
-0.0283993073,
0.0771376491,
0.0232092962,
0.0128437318,
0.0152751049,
0.0200868361,
-0.033641316,
0.0277939476,
0.0232612826,
0.015963994,
-0.0531724431,
0.0371231958,
-0.0184119251,
-0.0564311333,
0.0358062461,
-0.0030956573,
0.0053980453,
0.0351938419,
0.0289469659,
0.0011522023,
0.0292535722,
-0.033980079,
-0.0184968561,
0.0029445486,
0.0178903211,
0.0217754375,
-0.085167937,
-0.0659153685,
-0.0114856791,
-0.0044874619,
-0.0042333431,
-0.0427251905,
0.0195349511,
0.0004942264,
0.0143940812,
0.0304557811,
-0.0023375398,
0.0239309762,
0.0557139479,
-0.013339269,
0.0999961197,
0.0148662655,
-0.0302941948,
0.0104871774,
0.0265192818,
-0.0352712311,
-0.0678460672,
-0.0015281751,
0.0564831421,
-0.0346455202,
0.0268193316,
-0.0198377576,
-0.0033468213,
0.043564897,
-0.0337159373,
-0.0005900415,
-0.0043389387,
-0.0329250954,
0.0498268157,
-0.0151544223,
0.0630811825,
0.0201497208,
0.026667105,
-0.0458979867,
-0.0409705378,
-0.0071676178,
-0.0122000249,
-0.0414977334,
0.0003863902,
0.020590283,
-0.0107058259,
-0.0566285551,
-0.0309488568,
0.0243542362,
-0.0013595355,
0.0190728679,
0.0364904255,
-0.0110419532,
-0.0093075121,
-0.0462658703,
0.0504439324,
-0.0288721062,
0.0670592412,
0.0052413088,
-0.0477802493,
-0.0188498925,
0.017670529,
-0.00281582,
-0.0421853364,
0.0303862989,
0.02126332,
-0.0032500275,
-0.039635282,
-0.0072881347,
-0.0106525812,
-0.012800185,
-0.0610216185,
-0.0292076878,
-0.0620240383,
0.0080021694,
0.02977979,
-0.0003442151,
-0.0157159735,
0.0168850776,
0.0163235273,
0.0016155646,
0.0853402913,
-0.0071707824,
-0.0152972564,
0.0172163453,
-0.010673617,
0.0279861037,
0.0892464817,
0.0414941311,
0.0337709263,
0.0571477413,
0.0020400693,
-0.0042720023,
0.0441930741,
-0.0055901888,
-0.0119382162,
-0.0302709918,
0.0331198461,
0.0261903051,
0.0387365408,
-0.0219871327,
0.0602120683,
-0.0116198696,
-0.0217741989,
0.0624764301,
0.0106554152,
-0.0143122487,
-0.0035819171,
-0.0253238082,
-0.0386696421,
0.0296142921,
-0.0148227615,
-0.0417879522,
0.0211642068,
-0.0505237617,
0.0143431872,
0.0625840127,
0.0109699331,
-0.0065053999,
-0.0881236941,
-0.0423160158,
0.0055060773,
-0.0202517956,
0.060467504,
0.0558273941,
0.0031284057,
-0.0406562127,
0.0432814173,
0.0009361892,
-0.0051662894,
0.0299131759,
-0.0625249371,
0.0313889086,
0.026737513,
0.0045082541,
-0.0138761764,
-0.0451019406,
-0.0081217214,
0.0127674844,
-0.0042672059,
0.0109969638,
-0.0111941481,
0.0001830239,
-0.058957655,
-0.0234132279,
-0.0038450062,
0.0016415775,
-0.0339940079,
0.0508896075,
0.0304379445,
0.0013242927,
-0.0418415256,
-0.0085688336,
0.031063227,
-0.0022786355,
-0.0497966371,
0.0422632471,
-0.006627304,
0.0421459451,
-0.012845736,
0.0061067501,
0.012305133,
0.0383383073,
-0.0148073472,
-0.0301228669,
-0.0223804843,
0.0083556613,
0.0013006225,
0.0788411349,
0.0042545046,
-0.008900403,
0.001860944,
-0.0583000593,
-0.0368183888,
-0.0241243392,
-0.0444878116,
-0.0070443526,
-0.0360876955,
-0.0195955001,
0.0019449847,
0.0096134152,
-0.0650519952,
0.0146839283,
-0.0182595551,
0.0427758731,
-0.0642065704,
-0.0201113019,
0.026623318,
0.0003275215,
-0.0391742997,
-0.0079587149,
0.0053908154,
0.0229050852,
0.0252280328,
-0.000432665,
-0.0347103886,
-0.0341957845,
-0.1081814691,
0.0151645252,
-0.03001385,
0.0171697009,
0.0105781835,
-0.0007449807,
0.0065129828,
0.0003507066,
-0.0706312805,
-0.0209006853,
0.0069443919,
0.0431288965,
0.0438071191,
-0.0076014302,
-0.0148785049,
-0.0378981084,
-0.028892966,
-0.0257268716,
0.0596169047,
0.0112576308,
0.0308436267,
-0.0618304014,
0.0085849147,
-0.0464216061,
-0.0000458715,
-0.0091861365,
-0.0208821539,
0.0079304725,
-0.0106580621,
-0.0272600166,
0.0504795276,
0.0278087463,
-0.0124498522,
0.0631420612,
0.0305073243,
-0.0482712537,
-0.0151270563,
-0.0380837023,
-0.0556390546,
-0.0071514314,
-0.0566264465,
-0.0229670051,
0.0290330313,
0.0072826827,
-0.0189392436,
-0.0094393715,
0.0263520721,
-0.021478489,
-0.022351861,
-0.0693009198,
0.0072061988,
-0.0138570555,
0.0865149796,
-0.006433941,
-0.0636433214,
0.0784836486,
-0.0518307574,
0.0160467532,
-0.0610621721,
-0.0098264776,
-0.0637184381,
0.0347511061,
0.0264205988,
0.0110512841,
0.0224527624,
0.0085665835,
-0.0645509735,
-0.043264322,
0.0042305258,
-0.0523223095,
0.0363068357,
-0.0376928784,
0.0254494995,
0.0161944143,
-0.0188084003,
-0.0283201728,
-0.030799767,
-0.0587732792,
0.0244848188,
-0.0040981025,
-0.0054261289,
-0.0630904734,
0.0219105221,
0.0093623148,
-0.010589567,
-0.0556262173,
-0.00426772,
-0.0185564812,
0.0508801825,
0.1056872904,
0.0425238125,
0.0345289409,
-0.0059620175,
-0.0464743227,
0.055535838,
0.0152492458,
0.0576532558,
-0.0438933372,
-0.0256369468,
0.0699264854,
-0.0172670353,
-0.0051278239,
0.0223335791,
0.0605583973,
-0.0169244278,
-0.0226469468,
0.1403428316,
0.0355984978,
-0.0125551494,
-0.0203501265,
-0.0187151432,
0.0150358751,
0.0199011136,
0.0169389024,
-0.111720562,
-0.0517383888,
-0.0123427594,
0.0163356997,
-0.0129489526,
-0.0202327929,
0.0267418381,
-0.0909212902,
0.0026682224,
-0.0110194329,
-0.017865805,
-0.0468073413,
-0.0954838172,
-0.0057232529,
-0.0502607562,
0.0370900109,
-0.0185874328,
0.0046309819,
0.0120176263,
0.0516787358,
-0.0091600046,
-0.0228945147,
0.0229299255,
-0.028983783,
0.0672742873,
0.0742049366,
0.009817142,
-0.0454719216,
0.0130129559,
-0.0092539284,
-0.0531551726,
-0.0428373478,
0.002094191,
0.0271395128,
0.008626678,
0.0164347254,
-0.0199859794,
-0.0054407092,
-0.0250008255,
0.0094984537,
0.0269170813,
0.0432837941,
0.0214141607,
-0.0263302736,
-0.0175639484,
0.00198082,
-0.0046451073,
0.0740899742,
0.0391033292,
-0.0129707055,
-0.0459273383,
-0.0445461348,
0.0067442339,
-0.009529789,
-0.0110508762,
0.0176437609,
0.0028398682,
0.0046475101,
-0.016073782,
-0.011409902,
0.0594084337,
-0.0130637689,
-0.0165035427,
0.0220799632,
0.0023838985,
0.0261921193,
-0.0126800844,
0.0136110345,
-0.0238805376,
0.0590309836,
-0.0466681942,
0.0075149499,
0.0289939567,
-0.0165677872,
-0.03442204,
0.0646220222,
-0.0941940919,
-0.067294389,
-0.0132084126,
0.0491886325,
0.0216750316,
-0.0176666416,
-0.0097882971,
-0.0881655812,
0.0339560956,
0.0511023849,
0.0293489564,
-0.0098064644,
-0.0214594528,
0.023433743,
0.0009199808,
0.0178336687,
-0.0360514037,
0.0087126149,
0.004167309,
0.0411616527,
-0.0484646559,
-0.1171316281,
0.0096900649,
0.0302043632,
0.0336006582,
-0.0253718495,
-0.0417214222,
0.0076634688,
0.0351312011,
0.0181401819,
-0.0232230667,
0.0075953449,
0.017641861,
0.0470058396,
-0.0261198487,
-0.0432610102,
-0.0200305246,
0.0028174974,
0.008796405,
-0.0229258668,
0.0155221326,
0.0368738212,
0.032850977,
0.0325381123,
-0.0224608034,
-0.0480761528,
-0.0023649205,
0.048257485,
0.0648886263,
0.0247701239,
0.0246668961,
0.0175409876,
0.0083581759,
-0.0501326807,
0.0085883662,
-0.0617721118,
-0.0465418175,
-0.042084638,
0.0491211377,
0.0089356713,
0.023623582,
0.0020495341,
-0.0014932997,
-0.0267074574,
-0.035563942,
-0.007092027,
0.0243494865,
0.020364223,
0.083347857,
0.0213549063,
-0.0220455099,
0.0146867679,
0.0557494387,
0.0429553986,
0.0548954681,
0.016674554,
-0.0391194075,
-0.0018320845,
-0.0215313137,
-0.0386722572,
-0.0001519901,
0.0113693224,
0.0008721578,
-0.0398923941,
-0.0875875577,
0.0308341384,
0.027967399,
0.0366064422,
-0.013289148,
0.0074080997,
0.0714267343,
0.0316959806,
-0.0400806516,
-0.0047313483,
0.0161054116,
-0.0151022719,
-0.0275147278,
-0.0710699409,
-6.035554806e-33,
-0.0118803987,
-0.031859953,
-0.0104934191,
-0.0369897857,
0.0090564098,
0.020421451,
0.000115116,
0.0062612863,
-0.0382529534,
0.0185276214,
-0.005163399,
-0.0103198178,
0.0235112123,
0.0203931369,
0.0091083068,
-0.0768088326,
0.0133576952,
-0.0127070146,
-0.0220563486,
0.0029354205,
0.0143597471,
-0.0105087925,
0.038719967,
-0.0415444039,
0.0376745984,
-0.0084172105,
-0.0201582853,
0.0618212186,
-0.0363352522,
0.0850113332,
0.0103159957,
0.1014965475,
0.0113366581,
-0.0208712853,
0.0210223757,
0.0119404942,
-0.0704675615,
-0.0340474956,
0.0328666531,
0.0403477214,
-0.0039487043,
-0.0123037603,
0.0216329917,
0.0120474212,
-0.0331754647,
-0.028876096,
0.0472344719,
-0.0076285391,
-0.0155074652,
-0.0449484847,
-0.0133670131,
0.0107998848,
0.0084770322,
-0.0094870804,
0.0016029148,
0.0100158984,
0.0043407562,
0.0049270694,
-0.0758158714,
-0.0108235376,
0.033199966,
0.053124059,
0.0342748389,
0.0386377424,
-0.0289491564,
0.0204233304,
0.0061867507,
-0.0261767283,
-0.0496513806,
-0.0159533136,
-0.0047821547,
-0.0149894757,
0.0596601963,
0.046841573,
0.0688952431,
0.0147703951,
-0.0893775374,
0.0249769874,
0.0306830052,
0.0293973144,
0.024964992,
-0.0193969309,
-0.0329174176,
-0.0337345824,
-0.0781355426,
0.0098128207,
-0.0483734645,
-0.0046781306,
0.0248789079,
-0.0173372775,
0.0026851185,
-0.0086689722,
0.0080188885,
-0.0420305692,
-0.0454424806,
0.0327708274,
0.0471033268,
0.0313840285,
0.0033883839,
0.0729061142,
-0.0521757007,
0.0146702221,
0.0102815721,
-0.0145356292,
-0.0073897876,
0.0103462748,
0.0265515707,
-0.0116834743,
-0.0519541539,
-0.0005636069,
-0.0384714492,
-0.0099944975,
0.0055050412,
0.0089651728,
-0.0005177469,
0.0111441379,
0.0093165543,
0.0089581339,
0.0003673183,
0.0364975668,
-0.00858445,
-0.0130759198,
-0.0099136885,
0.0028083776,
-0.0423646569,
-0.0010652969,
-0.0156888049,
-0.0346076116,
-0.0467214882,
-0.0464284234,
-0.003703844,
0.0229646061,
2.381e-7,
0.0850168765,
0.0604053028,
-0.0022257224,
0.0415559597,
-0.0116232485,
0.0402101725,
0.0333088189,
0.010657534,
0.0906351209,
-0.025232492,
-0.0278117526,
0.028747322,
0.0254239347,
0.0514391474,
-0.0482271314,
-0.0362907127,
-0.0429581888,
0.0260893758,
-0.009089252,
0.0109238531,
0.0707532167,
0.117393963,
0.050822936,
-0.0069196005,
-0.0185197052,
-0.0367778204,
0.0329164639,
-0.0064117447,
0.0028367883,
0.0399007201,
0.0630139932,
-0.0187946483,
0.0322469994,
0.0396205559,
0.0047278991,
-0.007397261,
0.0031753837,
0.0237531457,
-0.0191940106,
-0.0242767744,
-0.0341677591,
-0.0084585752,
0.0268681813,
-0.0950070769,
0.0957003683,
-0.038834814,
-0.0155401174,
-0.0303282533,
-0.0209929291,
-0.0135301491,
0.0727074891,
-0.018079143,
-0.0108712437,
0.0176931005,
0.0173177272,
-0.0013107313,
-0.0139381047,
-0.0725513622,
-0.0332061462,
0.0040520569,
-0.033118885,
-0.0457507446,
0.0064201714,
-0.0034427671,
-0.0115661724,
-0.0638963431,
0.036070209,
1.986114796e-34,
0.0242160428,
0.0023382618,
0.0077544451,
0.0524635687,
0.055524759,
-0.0040409835,
0.019957155,
0.0201668069,
0.0208174679,
-0.0995738283,
-0.0013885866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01119v1 | Pron vs Prompt: Can Large Language Models already Challenge a World-Class Fiction Author at Creative Text Writing? | 2024-07-01T09:28:58 | 2024-07-01T09:28:58 | Guillermo Marco, Julio Gonzalo, Ramón del Castillo, María Teresa Mateo Girona | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | It has become routine to report research results where Large Language Models
(LLMs) outperform average humans in a wide range of language-related tasks, and
creative text writing is no exception. It seems natural, then, to raise the
bid: Are LLMs ready to compete in creative writing skills with a top (rather
than average) novelist? To provide an initial answer for this question, we have
carried out a contest between Patricio Pron (an awarded novelist, considered
one of the best of his generation) and GPT-4 (one of the top performing LLMs),
in the spirit of AI-human duels such as DeepBlue vs Kasparov and AlphaGo vs Lee
Sidol. We asked Pron and GPT-4 to provide thirty titles each, and then to write
short stories for both their titles and their opponent's. Then, we prepared an
evaluation rubric inspired by Boden's definition of creativity, and we
collected 5,400 manual assessments provided by literature critics and scholars.
The results of our experimentation indicate that LLMs are still far from
challenging a top human creative writer, and that reaching such level of
autonomous creative writing skills probably cannot be reached simply with
larger language models. | Pron vs Prompt: Can Large Language Models already Challenge a World-Class Fiction Author at Creative Text Writing?: It has become routine to report research results where Large Language Models
(LLMs) outperform average humans in a wide range of language-related tasks, and
creative text writing is no exception. It seems natural, then, to raise the
bid: Are LLMs ready to compete in creative writing skills with a top (rather
than average) novelist? To provide an initial answer for this question, we have
carried out a contest between Patricio Pron (an awarded novelist, considered
one of the best of his generation) and GPT-4 (one of the top performing LLMs),
in the spirit of AI-human duels such as DeepBlue vs Kasparov and AlphaGo vs Lee
Sidol. We asked Pron and GPT-4 to provide thirty titles each, and then to write
short stories for both their titles and their opponent's. Then, we prepared an
evaluation rubric inspired by Boden's definition of creativity, and we
collected 5,400 manual assessments provided by literature critics and scholars.
The results of our experimentation indicate that LLMs are still far from
challenging a top human creative writer, and that reaching such level of
autonomous creative writing skills probably cannot be reached simply with
larger language models. | [
0.0455776416,
0.0252674296,
-0.0280740634,
0.0196159091,
-0.0600828715,
0.0063549043,
0.0289991796,
-0.0132356035,
-0.0252903327,
-0.0109759457,
-0.037943922,
-0.0451706052,
0.0112189567,
0.0703982711,
0.0214615371,
-0.0169589631,
-0.0289639365,
-0.0387868136,
0.081102252,
-0.0032363327,
-0.036548242,
0.0115080494,
-0.0034350981,
0.0561293066,
0.0560767837,
-0.0350197144,
0.0143361399,
-0.0033636931,
-0.0042026443,
-0.0125395386,
-0.0336897112,
0.0494945608,
0.0141534973,
0.0754939169,
0.0000016742,
-0.0518184192,
0.0517999865,
-0.021581525,
0.0286379103,
0.0200547948,
0.0382947251,
0.0300292075,
-0.0246263687,
-0.0133733861,
-0.0267803632,
0.0184518974,
0.025107991,
0.0396727733,
0.0188011695,
0.0523002632,
0.0045111282,
-0.0277588014,
0.0690800771,
-0.0309778973,
-0.0293507408,
0.0002775582,
0.0083181458,
-0.0366979279,
0.0394133702,
-0.0311708804,
-0.0333728381,
0.0251711439,
0.0540285297,
-0.0238500796,
0.0099759279,
0.0574701652,
-0.0200630482,
0.0164414402,
0.0031380702,
-0.0080226753,
-0.0153195178,
-0.01420072,
-0.0128490701,
-0.0070044394,
0.0005739927,
-0.0235956311,
-0.0314343572,
0.0500185452,
-0.0137279602,
-0.0066310023,
0.025687689,
-0.0074619036,
0.0043573072,
0.0117233908,
0.0390253365,
0.0304139145,
0.0432496257,
-0.0075873821,
0.021560153,
0.0104321241,
-0.0172916427,
-0.0837285146,
-0.0007948023,
0.0210862737,
-0.0114528742,
-0.0163217653,
-0.030789312,
0.0013301567,
-0.0147150289,
-0.0583787896,
0.0924777016,
0.0061394256,
0.0423212834,
0.0244939737,
0.0118454564,
0.0575657934,
0.0101798614,
0.0380638652,
-0.0433077589,
0.0479757376,
-0.0238322448,
-0.0356512256,
-0.0310307387,
-0.0117791956,
-0.0150065105,
-0.0234746616,
-0.038676329,
-0.010750209,
0.0136289587,
0.0021004113,
-0.0238907952,
0.0403683558,
-0.0431066155,
-0.0036016605,
-0.0392264873,
-0.0027427275,
-0.0049254512,
0.0144403083,
0.0051640267,
0.0034282256,
0.0269481428,
0.0116615389,
-0.0173988082,
-0.0503365919,
0.0403752811,
0.0486120097,
-0.0177848376,
-0.0286104903,
-0.0104306992,
0.0191236101,
0.0042736796,
-0.0697159395,
0.0040926593,
-0.0613870695,
0.0229178499,
-0.0096256994,
-0.0188435018,
-0.0374072827,
-0.0302927792,
0.0186262913,
0.0075653843,
-0.0047582919,
-0.0040804502,
0.0065199644,
0.0449224487,
-0.0002095164,
-0.0254991576,
-0.0090383105,
0.1016420946,
0.0657980144,
0.0033608868,
0.0121471062,
0.0427378714,
0.0184700284,
-0.053487435,
0.0037097847,
-0.0254144147,
-0.0117068412,
-0.0072612716,
0.0844374225,
0.0187371206,
0.0847883373,
0.0071912492,
0.02576546,
0.1225127205,
0.0586091056,
0.0130752884,
0.0720604658,
0.0961027741,
-0.0256155003,
0.0785401911,
0.040410243,
-0.0213826522,
0.0055479677,
0.0200369321,
0.0220955908,
-0.0025560104,
0.0093970066,
0.0097706467,
-0.0334192514,
0.0044013034,
0.0267598368,
0.0012522847,
-0.0140777379,
0.0228215102,
-0.0026828824,
-0.0290532131,
-0.068091616,
-0.020477334,
-0.0342042968,
0.0151222935,
-0.0356961414,
0.033927191,
0.0551191829,
0.0518274605,
-0.0168169867,
0.0138001246,
-0.0167127587,
0.0005787486,
0.0736095905,
0.0276427642,
0.0010722682,
-0.006250666,
0.0178728141,
0.0335211083,
-0.0658767745,
0.0009526585,
0.0209138282,
-0.0716238916,
0.0321745463,
-0.0160907097,
0.016456848,
-0.0862256959,
0.043583788,
-0.0633308068,
-0.0405976549,
-0.0181367937,
-0.0114765391,
-0.0036685842,
0.0284528565,
-0.079847388,
0.0345495865,
0.0213850457,
-0.0578223653,
-0.044900611,
0.0183547679,
-0.0045741918,
-0.0064823772,
0.0387269668,
-0.0809679478,
0.0268147271,
0.0275145974,
0.0316381752,
-0.0256794598,
0.027231941,
-0.0308274031,
0.0390015692,
-0.0121222148,
0.0241029374,
-0.0273006968,
-0.0307931863,
-0.017065743,
0.0429196693,
0.0181665327,
0.0433543995,
0.0033698834,
0.0086062308,
0.0127159655,
-0.0155482339,
-0.0350421146,
0.0412915945,
0.0568523742,
0.0254484285,
0.0120998239,
0.0053542084,
-0.0363114849,
-0.0561128557,
-0.0669668093,
0.0086265709,
-0.0015446326,
-0.0019010912,
0.0239787791,
-0.0492297672,
-0.0455199108,
0.0524949729,
-0.0514752679,
-0.0515837148,
0.0183241647,
-0.0108502805,
0.0352251492,
0.0152292633,
-0.0069130897,
-0.0172723662,
-0.0020534801,
-0.0046127611,
0.0429700017,
0.0676929206,
0.0351593122,
-0.0028402612,
0.039233245,
-0.0442654043,
-0.0313125439,
-0.0244688317,
-0.0600064099,
0.0160492044,
-0.0243371539,
0.0270666257,
0.0685030073,
-0.0023186994,
0.013326914,
0.0917824134,
-0.0189044885,
0.0459565185,
0.0012596645,
0.0362756699,
0.0014454008,
-0.0201696306,
-0.0419989973,
0.0189001933,
0.0362717472,
0.0292663332,
-0.0036853524,
-0.0069546672,
0.0760044307,
-0.0265060011,
-0.0541634299,
0.0012429896,
-0.0204849448,
-0.0180729274,
0.0512319729,
-0.0564475954,
-0.040392641,
0.0575231314,
-0.0459079631,
-0.0108976029,
-0.0171772297,
-0.0169320181,
-0.0480314456,
0.0923116803,
0.0312544294,
0.0420913585,
-0.03023508,
0.0086268606,
-0.09335123,
-0.0067481739,
0.0288751442,
0.001837933,
0.0227401927,
-0.0238938723,
-0.0110349879,
-0.0176806916,
-0.0548586585,
-0.0163030941,
-0.0153434249,
-0.0302621014,
0.0262419805,
0.0703318492,
-0.0299900249,
0.0036353022,
-0.0185242593,
0.0392785296,
0.0306496229,
-0.0108722327,
-0.0083769802,
-0.0006486534,
0.0071520926,
0.0641570911,
-0.0078721913,
-0.0095956083,
-0.0725212246,
0.0201929417,
0.0099516148,
-0.0272722617,
0.0308848917,
-0.0310422573,
0.0379513018,
0.0253909975,
-0.0355610624,
-0.0298113469,
-0.0050068968,
0.0654596612,
-0.0610934943,
-0.015966272,
0.107520476,
0.0200013425,
-0.0215109773,
0.0046452777,
-0.0134454137,
-0.0134909069,
0.0125496015,
0.0618465655,
-0.0152106825,
0.0303965341,
0.007762217,
0.0309697203,
-0.0235606879,
-0.0234408695,
-0.0359011739,
-0.0772179514,
0.0500958636,
0.0169913583,
-0.0259250198,
0.0076741073,
0.0016926749,
-0.0464808643,
0.0308231488,
-0.0298321322,
0.0270235762,
-0.0126783149,
0.0073191617,
-0.0344017632,
-0.011219101,
-0.0226102695,
-0.0013057379,
-0.0643581748,
0.0494240746,
0.0533568375,
0.0661001652,
-0.0495192893,
-0.0247816667,
-0.0413793065,
0.0077914479,
0.0134139182,
0.0043842271,
0.0276392344,
-0.0069137183,
0.0177820548,
-0.0540297702,
0.0323758386,
-0.0037641402,
-0.0260472763,
0.0153570324,
0.0473460108,
-0.0057845269,
-0.0507374778,
-0.0165744182,
0.0194219407,
-0.0152875567,
0.0429398045,
0.0369590372,
-0.0848984644,
-0.059907902,
-0.0494147129,
-0.0263895188,
-0.0432130508,
-0.0484096371,
-0.0088221859,
0.0066380971,
-0.0276195928,
-0.070186466,
-0.0562064052,
0.0029624994,
0.0796189979,
0.0601213947,
0.0331094489,
-0.0490724854,
-0.0214754213,
-0.026644079,
0.0047136093,
0.0159937833,
0.0316496044,
-0.0478216298,
-0.000061121,
-0.0046898946,
-0.0751983896,
-0.003521726,
-0.0141622256,
-0.0815662593,
-0.0454911776,
0.0079692276,
0.0068429545,
0.0235463921,
-0.0432788134,
0.0158938207,
-0.0956631973,
0.0354568139,
0.0083694588,
-0.0053786691,
0.0627064407,
-0.0160617195,
0.0108850934,
-0.0004782316,
0.0205415245,
-0.0088301683,
0.0199642554,
0.0527684949,
0.0154264178,
0.0615569316,
-0.0265282784,
0.0057232664,
0.0197993461,
0.0040313904,
-0.0666190237,
-0.0102042928,
-0.0672791377,
-0.0340274796,
-0.0302614961,
-0.0325385965,
-0.0392126366,
-0.0100957807,
0.027591791,
0.0007125761,
-0.0345880091,
0.0142657757,
-0.002560576,
0.0062910197,
-0.0705517009,
0.0221792012,
0.0363133214,
0.0409935452,
0.0090211462,
0.0012481654,
-0.0155062238,
0.0137160122,
-0.0536431633,
0.0637854561,
0.0277570132,
0.0260087065,
0.0259590466,
-0.0018990383,
-0.016448155,
0.0437239334,
-0.0999325886,
-0.0445057489,
0.0185845271,
0.0162400771,
0.107187584,
-0.0028205712,
0.0229735989,
-0.0121522509,
0.0139593044,
-0.0355256833,
0.003941041,
0.0037958266,
-0.009607872,
-0.0454627611,
0.0076282155,
-0.0136621175,
-0.006677269,
0.0732391253,
0.0259470977,
0.0137503203,
0.0267661791,
-0.0336300246,
0.0025123998,
-0.0406388156,
-0.0021039683,
0.0196979642,
0.0331562832,
-0.0115070129,
-0.0682744309,
-0.0476319864,
0.0314456448,
0.0505486131,
0.0152704529,
-0.0483359247,
0.0023409768,
0.0400633626,
-0.0113517307,
0.003562466,
-0.0522066467,
0.0153916255,
0.0002225801,
-0.0107787605,
-0.0165503733,
-5.056380501e-33,
-0.0211924557,
-0.034571249,
0.0311865322,
0.0048095095,
-0.0606762059,
-0.019291684,
-0.0445577092,
0.0100778779,
0.0277986322,
0.0373445749,
-0.0521279238,
-0.0183102489,
-0.0250260495,
-0.0255881939,
0.0184045136,
-0.0158637408,
0.0495768748,
-0.0242192894,
-0.0626478791,
-0.0054043401,
-0.0172248501,
0.0198749155,
-0.0110588884,
-0.0016494396,
0.0307084825,
-0.0693387017,
-0.0117189232,
-0.0258475859,
0.0014089104,
0.0309118889,
0.001620496,
0.0405294932,
0.0441296361,
0.0059808171,
-0.0045830286,
-0.0308526754,
0.0117539121,
-0.0199978426,
-0.0031828731,
-0.0149293952,
0.01491783,
-0.0482473709,
0.0562715344,
0.0057532769,
-0.0343737975,
0.0022788218,
0.0479561463,
-0.0310040154,
-0.0062766178,
-0.0599534586,
-0.0672688559,
-0.0100869853,
-0.0051444075,
-0.0086262329,
-0.0234704856,
-0.0360743031,
-0.0021321769,
-0.0220044609,
-0.0533173308,
0.0303912666,
-0.0079620741,
0.0415120199,
0.0464911684,
0.0189713426,
-0.0011892365,
0.064720273,
0.0475997701,
0.0504978821,
-0.0193639267,
0.0286942944,
0.0175996255,
0.0342584439,
0.0461653322,
0.0701074451,
0.0142473998,
-0.0028480145,
-0.0056074467,
0.0316402502,
0.0056556552,
-0.0431103334,
0.0080431905,
-0.0117379446,
-0.0351124853,
-0.0691639185,
-0.0154367527,
-0.0259233583,
-0.0068263565,
-0.0119449543,
0.0324370489,
-0.0361597016,
0.0307302605,
-0.0360389687,
-0.0058702524,
-0.0450428091,
0.0133133521,
-0.0192108527,
-0.0629914626,
0.0897396281,
-0.009585279,
0.0304769222,
-0.0285055377,
-0.0006980952,
0.003518149,
0.0673315153,
0.0376683697,
0.0069047026,
-0.0165976882,
0.0431889147,
-0.0341327786,
0.0011507632,
-0.0389812067,
-0.0029979104,
0.0558297411,
0.0240257811,
0.0048290528,
-0.0288426708,
0.0142155942,
0.0033654191,
-0.0085831769,
-0.013375083,
-0.0258506909,
-0.0001270882,
0.0032319904,
-0.0096788947,
-0.0245604776,
0.0282540414,
-0.0192615818,
0.0292337891,
0.0331829153,
-0.0521267727,
-0.0165096279,
-0.0338518657,
2.494e-7,
0.0185936689,
0.0212920681,
0.0158808436,
0.0302547012,
0.0217409413,
0.0367356688,
-0.0576347969,
0.0223694853,
-0.0162832476,
0.0454135798,
0.0343903564,
0.0312409904,
0.0371706598,
0.0488036163,
-0.0837010369,
0.0296156313,
-0.0915740505,
0.018377658,
-0.0924469158,
-0.0242225304,
0.0678930879,
-0.0017545389,
0.0386892408,
-0.0482821949,
0.0022131831,
-0.0922164544,
0.0335680172,
-0.0126440767,
-0.0015648279,
0.0100757927,
0.0524002798,
0.0058815847,
-0.0272717662,
-0.0012387392,
-0.0221272074,
0.0132935457,
0.0232296456,
0.0569292456,
-0.0107743321,
0.0112391748,
0.0541764945,
0.0152384052,
-0.0113045806,
-0.0498056486,
0.0722157806,
0.0249848478,
-0.038932234,
-0.0122440225,
0.0214103963,
-0.0194949787,
0.0080312341,
-0.0538573824,
-0.0066202013,
0.0143957231,
0.0138586536,
-0.0168710034,
0.0296511203,
0.0005623895,
-0.0106987562,
0.0267168861,
-0.0343256332,
-0.036143411,
-0.0707743391,
0.0064558368,
0.0035275558,
-0.0975858346,
0.0094914893,
2.29486826e-34,
0.0448002517,
-0.0305271409,
0.0100549897,
-0.0070421086,
0.0388865024,
0.049573604,
0.018771382,
-0.0055794595,
0.0028201856,
-0.044338122,
-0.0345643945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01102v1 | BERGEN: A Benchmarking Library for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-07-01T09:09:27 | 2024-07-01T09:09:27 | David Rau, Hervé Déjean, Nadezhda Chirkova, Thibault Formal, Shuai Wang, Vassilina Nikoulina, Stéphane Clinchant | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval-Augmented Generation allows to enhance Large Language Models with
external knowledge. In response to the recent popularity of generative LLMs,
many RAG approaches have been proposed, which involve an intricate number of
different configurations such as evaluation datasets, collections, metrics,
retrievers, and LLMs. Inconsistent benchmarking poses a major challenge in
comparing approaches and understanding the impact of each component in the
pipeline. In this work, we study best practices that lay the groundwork for a
systematic evaluation of RAG and present BERGEN, an end-to-end library for
reproducible research standardizing RAG experiments. In an extensive study
focusing on QA, we benchmark different state-of-the-art retrievers, rerankers,
and LLMs. Additionally, we analyze existing RAG metrics and datasets. Our
open-source library BERGEN is available under
\url{https://github.com/naver/bergen}. | BERGEN: A Benchmarking Library for Retrieval-Augmented Generation: Retrieval-Augmented Generation allows to enhance Large Language Models with
external knowledge. In response to the recent popularity of generative LLMs,
many RAG approaches have been proposed, which involve an intricate number of
different configurations such as evaluation datasets, collections, metrics,
retrievers, and LLMs. Inconsistent benchmarking poses a major challenge in
comparing approaches and understanding the impact of each component in the
pipeline. In this work, we study best practices that lay the groundwork for a
systematic evaluation of RAG and present BERGEN, an end-to-end library for
reproducible research standardizing RAG experiments. In an extensive study
focusing on QA, we benchmark different state-of-the-art retrievers, rerankers,
and LLMs. Additionally, we analyze existing RAG metrics and datasets. Our
open-source library BERGEN is available under
\url{https://github.com/naver/bergen}. | [
0.0347341746,
0.0755747184,
-0.013108708,
0.033645276,
-0.0162519645,
-0.0327717997,
-0.0396146812,
0.0022361134,
-0.0306689199,
-0.0320759676,
-0.0320375264,
-0.0269705933,
-0.0199475531,
-0.0136606554,
0.0507536046,
-0.0020987731,
0.0578228272,
-0.0044709491,
-0.040510308,
0.010098272,
-0.0046042879,
0.0138101606,
-0.008101901,
0.0479991287,
-0.0003810361,
0.0103858616,
0.00785843,
0.0333242565,
0.0273356363,
-0.0239352901,
0.0096671693,
0.0178448465,
0.0058219028,
0.0579216927,
0.0000016946,
-0.0618245341,
-0.0263611898,
-0.0111568095,
0.0078926152,
0.0263366494,
0.0501596034,
0.0316428281,
-0.017019948,
0.0317584425,
-0.0284047741,
-0.0118287643,
0.0465608276,
-0.0079452926,
0.038798131,
0.0753454566,
0.0066007115,
-0.014647956,
0.0328914858,
-0.0556133091,
0.0404911973,
-0.0341277272,
-0.0081769591,
0.0167013425,
0.0428021178,
0.011798271,
-0.0084652137,
0.0476529226,
0.0155038647,
-0.0290945582,
0.0147441039,
0.011133519,
-0.0778489038,
0.01283924,
-0.0153937014,
0.0752800405,
0.0321665034,
-0.028103359,
-0.0006923179,
0.0182238705,
0.0022470802,
0.0326116122,
-0.0416937321,
0.0420903601,
0.0052806372,
0.0234581865,
0.0043592253,
0.0122459456,
0.0344590656,
0.0062560481,
0.0038618168,
0.0460242592,
0.0623232611,
-0.0136637781,
-0.0087832278,
0.038838543,
0.0024322574,
-0.0169145651,
-0.029036006,
0.0057264883,
-0.0288079865,
0.026374815,
-0.0178363919,
-0.034909416,
0.0477477238,
0.0557777844,
0.0712385848,
0.0352276117,
-0.0379459783,
-0.0094493032,
-0.0284733232,
0.0541693419,
-0.0123796854,
-0.0071752975,
-0.0545313992,
0.0155837853,
-0.0216987971,
-0.0217682458,
-0.0349930301,
0.0237204768,
-0.0456186645,
-0.0056473156,
-0.0566266626,
0.0029725544,
0.0004492651,
-0.0107169589,
0.0166014507,
0.0277510136,
-0.0715069547,
0.0343417488,
-0.0296016503,
0.0180771966,
-0.0221492369,
0.0049599977,
0.0511393249,
-0.0829332471,
-0.0290535744,
0.0242715497,
-0.0008065213,
-0.0279568247,
-0.0099676261,
0.0314903669,
-0.0158013254,
-0.0408918932,
-0.017993506,
-0.0367697179,
-0.0246821679,
-0.0632817224,
0.0159130376,
-0.0699896142,
0.0184924826,
-0.0042355005,
0.0012352349,
-0.0409898162,
0.0027382709,
0.032996878,
0.0045529911,
-0.0052799038,
-0.0183037482,
-0.0021727765,
-0.0059368866,
0.0317731053,
0.0488252565,
0.0501303002,
0.0064780926,
0.0386157669,
0.0415430032,
0.004656076,
0.0330469199,
0.040341489,
0.0252659041,
-0.0039301151,
-0.060589008,
0.0144191161,
-0.0144399842,
0.0321446024,
0.0420688763,
0.0810334533,
-0.0679877475,
-0.0111785578,
0.0105580073,
0.0115483524,
0.0770336166,
0.0048027379,
0.0669692233,
-0.0050071231,
0.0274558216,
0.0063612713,
0.0063870265,
0.0376397111,
-0.0277805179,
0.0513070375,
0.0469434075,
0.0532339066,
-0.0202647988,
-0.0306614768,
-0.0295567997,
0.0141796945,
-0.0687465742,
-0.0131785786,
0.0062598446,
0.0615150817,
-0.0425721519,
0.0425949246,
0.0134641007,
-0.1139783859,
0.0165919252,
-0.0537481532,
0.0405780748,
0.0535987876,
0.1121869758,
-0.0120118223,
-0.0361492075,
0.029907275,
-0.033122085,
0.0416555703,
0.0197616648,
-0.0194783285,
0.0162723847,
-0.0613839626,
-0.0018805421,
-0.0379132517,
0.012762554,
0.0405397043,
0.0479567051,
-0.0208850075,
0.0367312506,
-0.0745907798,
-0.0190870538,
0.0425528698,
-0.0552326031,
-0.0141105074,
0.0064162021,
-0.0290096942,
0.0218973029,
0.0237797033,
-0.0280593093,
0.0320499204,
0.0494190045,
-0.0247128215,
0.0261713099,
0.0221427139,
-0.0196673814,
-0.0591718629,
0.0116125308,
-0.0196382757,
0.0092109647,
0.039992705,
-0.033315707,
-0.0438553132,
0.0216413178,
-0.0486893468,
0.0237151776,
-0.0792402327,
0.0065550925,
0.0348690934,
0.0221798774,
-0.0512806289,
0.0624957271,
-0.0147634363,
0.0282296333,
0.0397375375,
0.025966607,
0.0119012222,
-0.064212665,
-0.0332458429,
0.0093652848,
-0.0233146138,
0.0185594093,
0.0237593334,
0.0122933835,
-0.0638738722,
-0.0269559231,
-0.0584257841,
0.0291589852,
-0.0206829812,
0.0146911545,
0.0239985771,
0.0361216962,
-0.0105691347,
0.0016685765,
-0.0416012481,
-0.0161530115,
0.0373962708,
0.0317812562,
0.0289732292,
0.0046653687,
-0.0062262993,
-0.0744607598,
-0.0177268013,
0.0241708122,
0.0414308533,
-0.0086418018,
0.0396971405,
-0.0335847586,
0.0476620905,
-0.0792747959,
-0.0064932541,
-0.0220487043,
-0.0285894927,
0.0277834274,
-0.0333322771,
0.0788444355,
0.0043215766,
0.019544391,
0.0049086343,
0.0567348115,
-0.0242758002,
-0.0791652128,
0.0080826115,
-0.0211426001,
-0.0606693663,
0.0131029235,
-0.0256450344,
0.0118968002,
0.0448837578,
0.0010695099,
-0.0314175449,
-0.0185603108,
0.0202598032,
0.0128300041,
-0.0406674109,
-0.0132164303,
0.0001227662,
-0.0308483206,
0.0329855345,
-0.0165386591,
-0.0573765673,
0.0484858304,
-0.0501039438,
-0.0224516913,
-0.0386108831,
0.0307143051,
-0.0627520829,
0.0385020003,
-0.0153000597,
0.0062899678,
-0.0650053769,
-0.0166210029,
-0.0317847244,
-0.0005041181,
0.0126139103,
-0.0609622747,
0.039861165,
-0.0274190046,
0.0386957601,
-0.0150436377,
-0.0200011861,
-0.0690276474,
0.0011772881,
0.0361140594,
-0.0073987273,
0.0085591739,
-0.0082362369,
-0.0096373027,
-0.032629896,
0.0346208401,
0.0187170804,
-0.0183108207,
-0.0197660122,
-0.0010882395,
0.0615937077,
0.0570177138,
-0.0053125159,
0.0148155428,
0.0030362171,
-0.0161314365,
0.0375981405,
0.0602084212,
-0.0163176805,
-0.0230884068,
0.0082894145,
0.0669592395,
-0.0194782801,
-0.0032049534,
0.0401335061,
0.0584062338,
-0.0232202765,
-0.0373431705,
0.0572808534,
0.03885426,
-0.0147363842,
0.0052020922,
-0.0173813067,
0.0969517976,
0.0361229703,
0.039360784,
-0.0882104486,
-0.0076584076,
0.0011960677,
0.0486401506,
-0.0027965554,
-0.0183450226,
-0.0135861617,
-0.1502078325,
0.0610007495,
0.0143807596,
-0.0049884589,
0.017516328,
-0.0105540901,
-0.0017211027,
-0.005232275,
0.0293853227,
0.0686002821,
-0.0405176468,
0.0368258543,
0.0112901572,
0.0137324473,
-0.0445033871,
-0.0207253434,
-0.0283076447,
0.0252088849,
0.0727597177,
0.0168977734,
0.0147481188,
-0.0466828011,
0.0039653778,
-0.0369688384,
0.0107119707,
-0.0039206133,
0.0293362513,
0.0131711904,
-0.0133195566,
-0.0351848826,
0.0068933289,
-0.0068460964,
-0.0161876027,
-0.0211220887,
0.029924918,
0.0023496558,
0.0188162792,
-0.0577807017,
0.0074210609,
0.0049319486,
0.0583521426,
0.043536637,
0.0111592477,
-0.0306749437,
-0.0317657404,
0.0414360277,
-0.0862805545,
-0.0277523845,
0.0173457675,
-0.0146293752,
-0.0063547576,
-0.1041158587,
-0.044871103,
-0.0228076167,
0.032402195,
-0.0154138599,
0.0153268622,
-0.0818146542,
-0.0267757997,
-0.0620114245,
0.0256440043,
-0.032680966,
-0.0048025404,
-0.0192820039,
-0.0072332136,
0.0483909845,
-0.0276996028,
0.0006532845,
0.0353473499,
-0.0559875779,
-0.066968739,
0.0031093345,
0.0748559311,
0.0262125656,
0.0169200636,
0.0057698865,
-0.0271585099,
0.005098334,
0.0479260422,
-0.0430135131,
0.0316509269,
-0.0070972778,
-0.0219355132,
-0.0222063977,
0.0212728307,
-0.0508874357,
0.0140586682,
-0.0018409193,
0.105349943,
0.0307552293,
-0.0136725856,
0.0301005114,
0.0382414386,
0.0214111079,
-0.043748796,
0.0006378221,
-0.0302618407,
-0.0033217331,
-0.0681489632,
-0.0119954115,
-0.0345935822,
0.0467481948,
0.0345896073,
-0.0217288136,
0.0044224672,
0.0184629168,
-0.0362236761,
0.1053999811,
-0.0168104805,
0.0167707894,
0.0085104443,
0.002867728,
0.0091776028,
0.0090209311,
-0.0142487725,
0.0115862153,
-0.0251805447,
0.0744212121,
-0.0071436786,
0.0139036076,
-0.0087707052,
-0.0016987916,
0.0063730539,
0.0279210843,
-0.0509679653,
0.0013550471,
-0.0269415304,
0.0191832408,
0.0492817275,
0.0200422611,
0.0986433029,
0.0177786201,
0.001602054,
-0.0183561835,
0.0127136447,
-0.0121606523,
-0.0404463336,
-0.0045149946,
0.027235873,
-0.0207754485,
0.0228462964,
0.0681004375,
-0.0167987701,
0.0315786153,
-0.0303885899,
0.0158809461,
-0.0354129076,
-0.0505069494,
0.0117677264,
0.0059746457,
-0.0006093641,
-0.0283840057,
-0.0633020326,
-0.069386594,
0.0061556161,
0.0358988084,
0.0000481429,
-0.0033257764,
0.0379938632,
0.0637621284,
0.0105617139,
0.0134797143,
-0.0548268557,
-0.0052901269,
-0.0852176324,
-0.0404414609,
-0.0039427802,
-5.803214307e-33,
-0.0400782004,
-0.0153802391,
0.0405221991,
-0.0804112703,
-0.042550154,
-0.0095236348,
-0.0341691598,
-0.0026685917,
-0.0012064542,
-0.0241166241,
-0.0271347463,
-0.0078200707,
0.0073105171,
0.0287969559,
-0.0146818534,
0.0315111689,
0.0215999316,
0.0193861574,
-0.0493295826,
0.0239980854,
0.0267203227,
0.0252348706,
0.0462484583,
0.0105906483,
-0.0140672885,
-0.0094325468,
-0.0145993968,
-0.0045284284,
-0.0165074263,
0.0763009265,
-0.0153521635,
0.0409550257,
0.0032409036,
-0.0149780111,
-0.0097426791,
-0.0269916449,
-0.0547469556,
-0.0329839364,
0.0223412979,
-0.0350415446,
-0.069539994,
-0.0279456805,
0.0201849826,
-0.0384663939,
-0.0439919941,
0.0071019987,
0.000764935,
-0.0235942472,
-0.0417077169,
-0.0448498689,
-0.0499483533,
0.011019839,
-0.0017053947,
-0.0075388043,
0.0018597695,
0.0445569158,
0.0086286524,
0.0114260977,
-0.0352516323,
0.0224829465,
-0.0164499134,
0.083127737,
0.0679044574,
0.0117931049,
-0.0151609853,
0.0522664338,
0.0234481283,
-0.023728136,
0.0115964767,
-0.0001799326,
0.0098395906,
0.0647077113,
0.0232754387,
0.0786519423,
0.0183624569,
0.0009963384,
-0.0507205203,
0.0675143003,
0.0106600709,
0.0421539359,
0.0036137772,
0.0113575822,
-0.0181711074,
0.0087711085,
-0.0389119834,
-0.0009520064,
-0.0209348388,
-0.0290258769,
0.0711571276,
0.0298165474,
-0.0327432565,
-0.0090838168,
0.031513527,
-0.0175879858,
-0.0074334932,
0.0342087746,
-0.0549215488,
0.0043405732,
-0.0341238268,
0.0346198417,
-0.0228959303,
-0.0085435091,
0.0507274941,
0.0054524108,
-0.0132870879,
-0.0097213034,
0.0206231046,
0.0126769748,
-0.0459883995,
0.0322647393,
-0.0496695489,
0.0483126566,
-0.0435013846,
-0.0202841796,
0.000825885,
0.0010727139,
-0.0089429365,
0.0256482046,
0.0292791072,
0.0171970539,
-0.0379627421,
-0.0217309948,
0.0224193595,
0.0068705478,
-0.0277447458,
0.0466370918,
-0.0198018551,
0.0488112643,
0.0439490005,
0.003575115,
-0.0119931251,
0.0141856093,
2.432e-7,
0.0445655175,
0.0098583018,
0.0861063004,
0.033824265,
-0.0114757838,
-0.0404690765,
-0.0107680028,
0.0205566436,
0.0233373307,
0.0243293624,
-0.0231316239,
0.0023690013,
0.0508322045,
0.0125457989,
-0.0594568551,
0.0162743572,
-0.07492733,
-0.0038853907,
-0.040514797,
-0.0734659359,
0.0291844252,
0.0381945372,
-0.0341953635,
-0.025903333,
-0.0345046446,
-0.0234636255,
0.0703542456,
0.0001547592,
-0.032749936,
0.0392363034,
0.0622034557,
0.0257812068,
0.0154681755,
-0.0837414563,
-0.0071015772,
0.0220667459,
-0.0030562275,
0.0211620405,
0.0220173914,
-0.0843551904,
0.0123578534,
0.0204330925,
0.0092669986,
-0.0338116512,
0.0321965329,
0.0154319499,
-0.007804879,
-0.0124326237,
-0.0543484651,
0.0202270299,
-0.0026874344,
-0.0345439576,
-0.0123485746,
0.017809188,
0.0156799871,
0.0184716322,
-0.0466220118,
-0.0551340692,
-0.0417202786,
0.0103573846,
-0.0234267432,
-0.0533574931,
-0.0419762209,
0.0001818176,
-0.0578475855,
-0.0625608638,
-0.023119146,
2.255221957e-34,
0.037243247,
-0.0196919013,
0.0354122072,
0.0203212108,
0.0453018062,
-0.0285544712,
-0.0380948111,
0.0233968943,
-0.0262525901,
-0.0826878697,
-0.0295101106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01100v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01100v1 | Eliminating Position Bias of Language Models: A Mechanistic Approach | 2024-07-01T09:06:57 | 2024-07-01T09:06:57 | Ziqi Wang, Hanlin Zhang, Xiner Li, Kuan-Hao Huang, Chi Han, Shuiwang Ji, Sham M. Kakade, Hao Peng, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Position bias has proven to be a prevalent issue of modern language models
(LMs), where the models prioritize content based on its position within the
given context. This bias often leads to unexpected model failures and hurts
performance, robustness, and reliability across various applications. Our
mechanistic analysis attributes the position bias to two components employed in
nearly all state-of-the-art LMs: causal attention and relative positional
encodings. Specifically, we find that causal attention generally causes models
to favor distant content, while relative positional encodings like RoPE prefer
nearby ones based on the analysis of retrieval-augmented question answering
(QA). Further, our empirical study on object detection reveals that position
bias is also present in vision-language models (VLMs).
Based on the above analyses, we propose to ELIMINATE position bias caused by
different input segment orders (e.g., options in LM-as-a-judge, retrieved
documents in QA) in a TRAINING-FREE ZERO-SHOT manner. Our method changes the
causal attention to bidirectional attention between segments and utilizes model
attention values to decide the relative orders of segments instead of using the
order provided in input prompts, therefore enabling Position-INvariant
inferencE (PINE) at the segment level. By eliminating position bias, models
achieve better performance and reliability in downstream tasks where position
bias widely exists, such as LM-as-a-judge and retrieval-augmented QA.
Notably, PINE is especially useful when adapting LMs for evaluating reasoning
pairs: it consistently provides 8 to 10 percentage points performance gains in
most cases, and makes Llama-3-70B-Instruct perform even better than
GPT-4-0125-preview on the RewardBench reasoning subset. | Eliminating Position Bias of Language Models: A Mechanistic Approach: Position bias has proven to be a prevalent issue of modern language models
(LMs), where the models prioritize content based on its position within the
given context. This bias often leads to unexpected model failures and hurts
performance, robustness, and reliability across various applications. Our
mechanistic analysis attributes the position bias to two components employed in
nearly all state-of-the-art LMs: causal attention and relative positional
encodings. Specifically, we find that causal attention generally causes models
to favor distant content, while relative positional encodings like RoPE prefer
nearby ones based on the analysis of retrieval-augmented question answering
(QA). Further, our empirical study on object detection reveals that position
bias is also present in vision-language models (VLMs).
Based on the above analyses, we propose to ELIMINATE position bias caused by
different input segment orders (e.g., options in LM-as-a-judge, retrieved
documents in QA) in a TRAINING-FREE ZERO-SHOT manner. Our method changes the
causal attention to bidirectional attention between segments and utilizes model
attention values to decide the relative orders of segments instead of using the
order provided in input prompts, therefore enabling Position-INvariant
inferencE (PINE) at the segment level. By eliminating position bias, models
achieve better performance and reliability in downstream tasks where position
bias widely exists, such as LM-as-a-judge and retrieval-augmented QA.
Notably, PINE is especially useful when adapting LMs for evaluating reasoning
pairs: it consistently provides 8 to 10 percentage points performance gains in
most cases, and makes Llama-3-70B-Instruct perform even better than
GPT-4-0125-preview on the RewardBench reasoning subset. | [
0.0611386485,
0.0381347463,
0.0002899861,
0.0734368861,
-0.0044756439,
0.004018717,
-0.0210769251,
-0.0036977646,
0.0090946276,
-0.0761262923,
-0.027059406,
-0.0202287212,
-0.0000834352,
0.0151205389,
0.0315769203,
-0.0520066656,
0.0566309914,
-0.0531293154,
0.0416391715,
0.0079496205,
0.017684266,
0.0044579953,
-0.0001593554,
0.0118427472,
0.0072881714,
-0.0337979347,
-0.0162522122,
0.0122363195,
0.0189029444,
-0.017348364,
0.0063813366,
0.0259060618,
0.0114095388,
-0.0021663485,
0.0000019805,
-0.0331648625,
0.0153428093,
-0.0100189978,
-0.0064148419,
-0.0094383173,
-0.0371026359,
-0.0309249032,
0.0167984907,
0.019056784,
-0.0281043053,
0.002958372,
0.0502517372,
0.0234320201,
0.0412985235,
0.0680295527,
-0.0015348191,
0.0044723595,
0.0081057437,
-0.0452116542,
0.0524389371,
-0.0276768543,
0.0102539221,
0.017711211,
0.0101662138,
0.0529487953,
-0.0562047623,
0.0347645804,
0.0406730361,
0.0072800862,
0.0080213184,
0.0469427779,
0.0046787765,
-0.0121151097,
-0.0265117306,
0.0764785334,
-0.02108985,
-0.0428510457,
-0.0191420652,
-0.0093015134,
0.0388618447,
-0.0264472123,
-0.0568212569,
0.0736757368,
0.0038626639,
-0.007113758,
0.0082501713,
0.0135333147,
-0.0030284941,
0.036255382,
-0.0002207302,
0.0718032122,
0.0084959418,
-0.0394046679,
-0.0197661575,
0.0308299623,
-0.0335960798,
-0.0354489796,
-0.011819127,
0.0409507826,
-0.0084701413,
0.0417159088,
-0.0295646116,
0.0137408767,
0.0103887348,
-0.0304219071,
0.0266519841,
0.0328468382,
-0.0343474671,
0.0684920624,
-0.0370818973,
0.0836043581,
-0.0240869485,
0.0377087221,
-0.0620775521,
-0.0114952112,
0.0421884693,
-0.0309380703,
-0.0230426397,
0.0031086509,
-0.0505283363,
-0.0381376371,
-0.0038732612,
0.0614773296,
-0.0162271466,
-0.0329854265,
0.0024449283,
0.0579991825,
-0.0133269057,
-0.015279077,
-0.0399407595,
0.0471847244,
-0.0205727909,
0.0461844243,
-0.0131324846,
-0.055138927,
-0.04915848,
0.0372589119,
-0.0002790906,
-0.0311149359,
-0.0043832413,
0.0464077294,
-0.0182910673,
-0.0389207378,
0.0049413717,
-0.0136057884,
-0.0194259081,
-0.0332162157,
0.0301409625,
-0.0545060486,
0.0363539532,
0.0115346098,
-0.0243764333,
-0.0165940579,
0.0065082987,
0.0484517328,
-0.0613454357,
0.0700225234,
0.0342247076,
0.0083309598,
-0.0085041253,
0.0185369458,
-0.0021996705,
0.0677754432,
0.0170116629,
0.0521854423,
0.0335155502,
0.0164412241,
0.0096136192,
0.0174484625,
0.0145039968,
0.0012810981,
-0.0228278283,
0.0442589298,
-0.0155098094,
-0.0041421591,
0.077358529,
0.0241010059,
-0.0231329501,
-0.0413250327,
0.0626844689,
0.0372759812,
0.0000014873,
-0.0413836315,
0.0034765601,
-0.0056908941,
-0.0130896503,
-0.0141344694,
-0.0839176103,
0.0548460893,
-0.0245910604,
0.0293907281,
0.0143685117,
0.0063106883,
-0.034694884,
-0.0413822345,
-0.0302203801,
0.0018897777,
-0.0196984224,
0.0641813204,
0.0278942138,
0.0254833549,
-0.0400974415,
0.0429036021,
-0.0082849972,
-0.0384976715,
-0.0285446458,
-0.0365778916,
0.0548362285,
0.028160084,
0.0233900174,
-0.0082719252,
-0.0479199626,
0.0384744219,
0.0206049439,
0.0401089191,
0.0243215784,
0.0006006927,
0.016854737,
-0.0157265719,
-0.0194933955,
-0.0169314817,
0.0048263548,
0.0114976065,
0.0578839108,
0.0147343185,
0.0313102081,
-0.0608924776,
0.0368056335,
0.0351614356,
0.0450318195,
-0.0216661841,
-0.0374221727,
0.0046142708,
0.0040232781,
-0.014416093,
0.0159507897,
0.0311933272,
0.0404630192,
-0.015853202,
0.0203759614,
0.0104778372,
-0.0581464022,
-0.0492919683,
0.0243271943,
-0.0146165323,
-0.0170094501,
0.0483979881,
-0.0449295826,
-0.0101105841,
0.027339872,
-0.0397748388,
0.0090892492,
-0.0449752249,
-0.0029672582,
0.0304700043,
0.0087374644,
-0.0557931699,
0.0671826154,
-0.0251646098,
0.0253799595,
0.016371835,
0.0262311194,
0.0134285521,
-0.0603822954,
-0.0137014426,
-0.0059023062,
-0.0096127419,
0.0054454636,
0.0153047834,
-0.0017415734,
-0.0402572155,
-0.0264381636,
-0.0789096504,
-0.015139278,
-0.0238942076,
0.0161166415,
0.018973304,
0.0100116953,
-0.0192635469,
-0.0721997619,
-0.0392062962,
-0.0089761056,
0.0311146323,
0.0410969108,
0.0211679377,
-0.0169896539,
0.0109546501,
-0.0524442829,
-0.0129388589,
-0.0125319567,
0.0483348891,
-0.0041634454,
-0.0044813408,
-0.0632559434,
0.0250875149,
-0.0450624377,
0.0444812514,
-0.0234717764,
-0.0200964622,
0.0158237889,
-0.010613936,
0.0182973444,
0.1307796389,
-0.0146450093,
0.0006502125,
0.0492871217,
0.0031903661,
-0.0625591725,
0.0166378915,
0.0086542014,
0.0002179821,
0.0120753413,
-0.0300293211,
-0.0223350748,
0.0522647016,
-0.0018222242,
-0.0136856372,
-0.0502376109,
0.0343116485,
0.0148784611,
-0.0262558162,
-0.041510582,
-0.0386187658,
-0.0121233538,
0.0444989242,
-0.0611887984,
-0.0707767382,
0.0544223078,
-0.0391825102,
-0.0134290941,
-0.0361763164,
0.02262084,
-0.0709779859,
0.0730390102,
0.0449949168,
-0.0050698793,
-0.0206684563,
-0.0125172976,
-0.077748023,
-0.0164972711,
-0.0138476519,
-0.0351124741,
0.0313138887,
-0.0298442785,
0.0301361736,
-0.0451105833,
-0.0284907166,
-0.0728612542,
-0.0206105113,
-0.0144792097,
0.0024863845,
-0.0551533811,
0.0163937397,
0.0064285621,
0.0444038361,
0.0308585372,
0.0245331246,
-0.0343090259,
0.0314323306,
-0.0260235462,
0.0413688384,
0.0795225352,
0.0304730516,
0.0065616569,
-0.0283332113,
-0.0119728651,
0.0818034187,
0.0225092396,
0.0055371141,
-0.0372344516,
0.007861726,
0.0487011485,
-0.0096828993,
-0.0000526943,
0.0152853746,
0.046200674,
-0.0564306565,
-0.0173389539,
0.0893472284,
0.0431339145,
-0.0511893518,
-0.0134083852,
-0.004578473,
0.0459489785,
0.0414069034,
0.0473228917,
-0.0680904314,
-0.0326288454,
0.0077996626,
0.0163231939,
0.0232062899,
0.0241924915,
-0.0216705464,
-0.1282940954,
0.0235478655,
-0.0267293621,
-0.0278411023,
-0.0513639599,
-0.0125268642,
0.0142471651,
0.0231548119,
-0.02398533,
0.0360591412,
-0.0273531638,
0.008123395,
0.0004383597,
0.0078482097,
0.0153657608,
0.0147698522,
-0.0462146811,
-0.0055257645,
0.069259584,
-0.0066134608,
0.0162784569,
-0.0554768741,
0.0334782004,
-0.0466574058,
0.0153566655,
0.0060067815,
0.0181351732,
-0.04879345,
-0.0058849673,
0.0050757374,
0.0177138243,
-0.0221341308,
-0.0212355535,
-0.0171369109,
0.0602232143,
-0.0136027271,
-0.0056444532,
-0.0697247609,
0.0248115454,
-0.028620936,
0.0737795532,
0.0498737246,
-0.0140635651,
-0.0745878667,
-0.0271167606,
-0.010389125,
-0.0295921937,
-0.0114508094,
-0.015105864,
0.0391806439,
-0.0028723693,
-0.07122913,
-0.0530875809,
0.0252305679,
0.0441612266,
-0.0244406257,
-0.0189666245,
-0.0457278341,
-0.0077376175,
-0.0458589122,
0.0849527344,
-0.0285346732,
0.0197620373,
-0.0389467999,
0.0320001282,
0.0154898753,
-0.0584917255,
-0.0306261815,
0.0014055468,
-0.0857022554,
-0.0506489463,
-0.0258361269,
0.0680602565,
0.021701904,
0.0496974029,
-0.0257982537,
-0.0497859567,
0.0180585571,
-0.0010474056,
0.006612815,
0.0588212349,
0.0018269977,
-0.0203015227,
0.0068088626,
0.0264973287,
-0.0699427426,
0.0160062257,
0.0145679191,
0.0545455813,
-0.0149374632,
-0.0391083509,
0.0132569894,
-0.0127882902,
0.0367705002,
0.0293912385,
0.0315859094,
-0.0207362212,
0.0348276421,
0.0027574801,
-0.0197664294,
-0.0408471376,
0.0003953724,
0.0030382266,
-0.0083383387,
-0.0093805594,
-0.0091761546,
-0.0026589872,
0.0234529208,
-0.0353451781,
0.0002750065,
0.0349127911,
-0.0153836953,
-0.0237495024,
0.0064258627,
-0.0304010212,
0.0058996435,
-0.0351918414,
0.0783998221,
0.0089658266,
0.0674731582,
0.0264330972,
-0.0463749766,
-0.0500351787,
0.0447262712,
-0.0823195055,
-0.0262125563,
-0.0112891356,
0.022023553,
0.0440796204,
-0.0407935269,
0.0292236507,
0.0052107698,
-0.0068137599,
0.0088234795,
-0.0129070049,
0.0132924886,
-0.0392102972,
0.0814349502,
0.0455673225,
0.0044591604,
0.0156285223,
0.0537092723,
0.0308935437,
0.0047265803,
-0.0175863653,
-0.0233740471,
0.0134874796,
-0.0295335911,
0.0264577754,
-0.0011473338,
-0.0239033662,
0.0215966161,
-0.0409656093,
-0.0718202069,
0.0012490972,
0.0207251702,
-0.0221463572,
-0.0160546619,
0.0345264412,
0.07771191,
0.0343218558,
-0.0488345772,
-0.0187676158,
-0.0176887624,
-0.0303680114,
-0.029373413,
-0.0352763273,
-6.367237067e-33,
-0.0267066788,
-0.0255853683,
0.017148627,
-0.0243905298,
-0.0302198026,
0.0382052064,
-0.0219383743,
-0.0034498521,
-0.0527303033,
-0.0071335193,
-0.004128674,
0.0264052544,
0.011703033,
0.0199624524,
-0.0117687574,
-0.0169691853,
-0.0117040509,
0.0045246892,
-0.0301508624,
-0.0310900435,
0.003073558,
0.0032953881,
0.0439341217,
-0.0058446191,
0.036371503,
0.0104505904,
0.0147947343,
0.0317670479,
-0.0462069362,
0.0813857019,
-0.0151943918,
0.0207846574,
0.0357717723,
-0.004480348,
-0.0129000256,
0.0787147507,
-0.0738031194,
-0.0257945061,
0.0576359928,
0.0121726096,
-0.0585807264,
-0.0169385076,
0.0494437926,
-0.007648929,
0.0157145225,
-0.0201482121,
0.0210625436,
-0.0288085695,
-0.0176687017,
0.0227080584,
-0.0337158106,
-0.0084705465,
0.0084391013,
-0.0409613885,
0.0012649276,
0.0657051057,
0.0224039219,
0.0571816079,
-0.0433776155,
0.0069079814,
0.0122594582,
0.0497700535,
0.065342702,
0.0402046852,
-0.029095104,
0.036310304,
0.0149519388,
-0.0314484164,
-0.0364194103,
-0.0549698286,
0.0096103614,
0.0125459209,
0.0615614913,
-0.0134053258,
0.0285026245,
0.0569300503,
-0.0654553771,
-0.005530484,
-0.0157856196,
0.0671440437,
0.0385574773,
0.0008785161,
-0.0552582331,
-0.0254914928,
-0.0429597311,
0.0011245612,
-0.0695352405,
-0.0127195464,
0.0733114854,
0.0316295326,
-0.0116605908,
0.0167277679,
0.0591915809,
-0.0404920168,
0.0216692016,
0.0332867578,
-0.0224677417,
0.0305217877,
0.0122177182,
0.0588958114,
-0.0545675606,
0.0418065712,
0.0355005898,
-0.0125908367,
-0.0395242423,
0.0118234297,
0.0314911604,
-0.015986694,
-0.0418315828,
-0.0057792626,
-0.0404709391,
-0.0116185909,
-0.0373784676,
0.0407209285,
0.0385370851,
0.0389052033,
-0.0217836704,
0.0698832721,
0.0011053383,
-0.0076807262,
-0.0486002713,
-0.0139363166,
-0.0351510942,
0.0185819063,
-0.0326098613,
0.0182443336,
-0.0290515833,
0.0471619554,
-0.04804793,
-0.0680846646,
-0.0104142958,
0.0767905712,
2.713e-7,
0.0689669773,
0.0042947694,
0.0388830751,
0.0503642038,
0.0186417736,
0.0140051981,
0.0126171606,
0.0366865657,
0.0508858487,
0.0085489629,
-0.0144010959,
0.0524906069,
0.0131685548,
-0.0265359748,
-0.0757235959,
0.027319625,
-0.0483653471,
-0.0118749067,
-0.0304170232,
-0.038547121,
0.0288356617,
0.0822649002,
-0.0378029197,
0.0055936235,
-0.0099389954,
-0.0373286381,
0.0586566329,
-0.0021759241,
-0.0031665356,
-0.0132395113,
0.0331663303,
-0.0111998543,
-0.0007134872,
0.0008098046,
0.0246408731,
0.0186939463,
0.0163021851,
0.0285901781,
-0.0213680994,
-0.0671811774,
-0.0488655381,
-0.0025851487,
0.0116167832,
-0.0861663967,
0.115048714,
-0.0424693078,
-0.0039117173,
-0.0275464021,
-0.0382417664,
0.0135471625,
-0.0047899056,
-0.0036845091,
-0.0195947066,
0.0009081927,
0.0296843164,
-0.032512065,
-0.0280820914,
-0.100033991,
-0.0596183464,
-0.0317462124,
-0.0202611499,
-0.0180079099,
-0.0394590944,
0.0057203071,
0.0322897732,
-0.0609143227,
-0.0566348955,
2.520670163e-34,
0.0237831958,
-0.0250204541,
0.0317950696,
0.0303726047,
0.0103532281,
-0.0011701827,
-0.0004937631,
-0.0028465465,
0.028119795,
-0.0668002442,
-0.0253129192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01093v1 | IBSEN: Director-Actor Agent Collaboration for Controllable and Interactive Drama Script Generation | 2024-07-01T08:49:57 | 2024-07-01T08:49:57 | Senyu Han, Lu Chen, Li-Min Lin, Zhengshan Xu, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA | Large language models have demonstrated their capabilities in storyline
creation and human-like character role-playing. Current language model agents
mainly focus on reasonable behaviors from the level of individuals, and their
behaviors might be hard to constraint on the level of the whole storyline. In
this paper we introduce IBSEN, a director-actor coordinate agent framework that
generates drama scripts and makes the plot played by agents more controllable.
The director agent writes plot outlines that the user desires to see, instructs
the actor agents to role-play their characters, and reschedules the plot when
human players participate in the scenario to ensure the plot is progressing
towards the objective. To evaluate the framework, we create a novel drama plot
that involves several actor agents and check the interactions between them
under the instruction of the director agent. Evaluation results show that our
framework could generate complete, diverse drama scripts from only a rough
outline of plot objectives, meanwhile maintaining the characteristics of
characters in the drama. Our codes and prompts are available at
https://github.com/OpenDFM/ibsen. | IBSEN: Director-Actor Agent Collaboration for Controllable and Interactive Drama Script Generation: Large language models have demonstrated their capabilities in storyline
creation and human-like character role-playing. Current language model agents
mainly focus on reasonable behaviors from the level of individuals, and their
behaviors might be hard to constraint on the level of the whole storyline. In
this paper we introduce IBSEN, a director-actor coordinate agent framework that
generates drama scripts and makes the plot played by agents more controllable.
The director agent writes plot outlines that the user desires to see, instructs
the actor agents to role-play their characters, and reschedules the plot when
human players participate in the scenario to ensure the plot is progressing
towards the objective. To evaluate the framework, we create a novel drama plot
that involves several actor agents and check the interactions between them
under the instruction of the director agent. Evaluation results show that our
framework could generate complete, diverse drama scripts from only a rough
outline of plot objectives, meanwhile maintaining the characteristics of
characters in the drama. Our codes and prompts are available at
https://github.com/OpenDFM/ibsen. | [
0.0333429016,
0.0076675229,
-0.0140045984,
0.0157386009,
-0.0269884542,
-0.0065185959,
0.0199726336,
0.0027826573,
0.031905748,
0.0083067175,
-0.0190426651,
-0.0211150777,
-0.0141766565,
0.0909755975,
-0.0249210298,
-0.0899754986,
-0.0108316438,
-0.0472215787,
0.0713505074,
0.0098219076,
-0.0119395899,
0.0043103835,
-0.0182189029,
0.0327210389,
-0.0324779898,
-0.0328860916,
-0.0331482366,
-0.0023076278,
0.0553718321,
-0.0126951076,
0.0169838406,
-0.0106346132,
0.0275932215,
0.0049420916,
0.0000018061,
-0.0748848617,
0.0207028706,
-0.0295866821,
0.0254811626,
-0.0194818955,
0.0370686688,
0.0398371257,
-0.0188426357,
-0.0108506726,
-0.0146395816,
0.0207162295,
0.0399092808,
0.0497243181,
0.0986465663,
0.0555557944,
-0.0155383479,
-0.0159686115,
-0.0645969659,
0.0180073325,
-0.0290444624,
-0.0101687033,
-0.0219431035,
0.0141316932,
0.132477507,
-0.0086020203,
-0.0095878569,
-0.0098927915,
-0.0048530432,
-0.0425056368,
-0.0440226533,
0.0542274006,
-0.0162261426,
-0.0217893738,
-0.0034589511,
0.0611409247,
0.0415428989,
0.0090653151,
0.006661457,
-0.0192968845,
0.0488394909,
0.0687843636,
-0.0298001524,
0.0463000238,
-0.000493304,
0.003061299,
0.0110391164,
0.0310825817,
0.015388987,
-0.0357000269,
0.0268088039,
0.0301885493,
0.0033688471,
-0.0030554386,
-0.0791761056,
-0.0125893299,
0.0058230483,
-0.0837658569,
-0.0016151125,
0.0591096878,
-0.025675064,
0.0017123383,
-0.0494411513,
0.021906253,
-0.0241547022,
-0.0612414777,
0.0627677813,
0.032178022,
0.006722651,
0.0271626245,
0.0415810943,
0.0618811436,
0.0388141386,
-0.0230137575,
0.039970953,
0.0446430854,
-0.0191135015,
-0.0151878474,
-0.0658694282,
-0.0089312242,
-0.046673499,
-0.0062118885,
0.0180757847,
0.0508413948,
-0.0439136811,
0.0557484366,
-0.0151167717,
0.0087110763,
-0.0172982775,
0.0072484529,
-0.0555825122,
0.0197450984,
-0.0514870994,
-0.0248677582,
0.0171679314,
0.0108270124,
0.0013396661,
-0.0294982567,
0.0228702594,
0.0097425478,
0.0121338749,
0.0820251703,
-0.016523404,
0.0177393686,
0.0230643656,
-0.0310474187,
0.0100429673,
-0.0427311175,
-0.0913832113,
-0.0335792899,
0.0298499186,
-0.0360969417,
0.0023666027,
-0.0380346552,
0.0206719898,
0.0094664795,
0.0295442883,
0.0247903988,
-0.0008772739,
0.0444637872,
0.0205306523,
0.0189317949,
-0.0404359326,
0.0279018003,
0.0671686307,
0.0577872917,
-0.0016115481,
0.0133255385,
0.0690726638,
0.0296701547,
-0.0514384173,
0.0228806771,
0.0148444278,
-0.0069531128,
0.0403401554,
0.0666308776,
-0.0295174513,
0.0419513956,
-0.0315700732,
0.0038720067,
0.036072202,
0.026528962,
0.0520335995,
-0.018223552,
0.0738466308,
0.0377862677,
-0.0068358351,
-0.002541913,
-0.0080227451,
0.0438552573,
0.0748075992,
-0.0189051758,
-0.1059460714,
-0.0090171797,
0.001572928,
-0.0283359345,
0.0190662723,
-0.008668174,
-0.0070298398,
-0.0189504493,
0.0102148559,
0.0136685725,
-0.0481886156,
-0.007786016,
0.0101722348,
-0.0922620669,
0.0672919527,
-0.01260815,
0.0049482137,
0.1290562451,
0.0364097916,
-0.04139667,
-0.0632050782,
-0.0088401344,
0.0004382067,
0.0136452513,
0.0033266339,
-0.0673518851,
0.0241423212,
-0.0160732698,
0.044037696,
-0.0061347419,
-0.0063825124,
0.0591653921,
-0.0489790142,
-0.0212068278,
-0.0367498994,
0.0400060788,
-0.0151866097,
0.005549862,
-0.0943745449,
-0.021448914,
-0.0522083119,
0.0035798806,
0.0159998499,
-0.0056161857,
-0.0494910702,
-0.0174667239,
0.0207190514,
-0.012964054,
-0.0383443236,
0.0575283393,
0.0044524223,
0.0175290219,
0.0109611284,
-0.015951097,
-0.0164397024,
-0.0207025465,
0.0105616329,
-0.0413351394,
0.0588885285,
-0.0112886103,
-0.0266207624,
0.0043752124,
-0.0022335555,
-0.0090030804,
-0.0063408148,
-0.0171269774,
0.0187532846,
0.0087082107,
-0.0120914783,
0.0326159,
0.0518855974,
-0.0003139202,
-0.0145825464,
0.0432691276,
0.0552789047,
0.0262041725,
0.0023156367,
0.0375685655,
-0.0038208233,
-0.0054327589,
-0.0703450516,
-0.055462651,
-0.0203720629,
0.0108401254,
-0.0437089428,
0.0200719535,
0.0294860248,
-0.0427688994,
0.0063473284,
-0.0425087847,
0.0000215014,
0.0539994724,
-0.0477359109,
0.0087272683,
0.0342938192,
-0.0382834971,
-0.0192807429,
0.0231705159,
-0.0142285964,
0.0169207361,
0.0516877025,
0.0117991995,
-0.0330897383,
-0.0137190716,
-0.0151836378,
0.0196013376,
-0.054747466,
-0.0342213698,
0.0283465777,
-0.0304306932,
0.0024434065,
0.0024329859,
-0.032265991,
0.0414046422,
0.0807019621,
-0.0704075769,
-0.0279690921,
0.0283482168,
0.0084174098,
0.0181914475,
-0.0559913889,
-0.0428402871,
0.033612784,
0.0732038319,
0.0041392087,
0.0360004455,
-0.0646240264,
0.002630125,
0.0225045271,
-0.0226058979,
0.0611511804,
-0.0684956387,
-0.0418752767,
0.0382548831,
-0.0178735498,
0.0398734771,
0.068394497,
-0.0473535694,
-0.03998743,
-0.0025696687,
0.0039609466,
-0.0570004992,
0.0898638889,
-0.0086920932,
0.0337162428,
-0.0308531635,
-0.0014076025,
-0.0192039963,
-0.0220975187,
0.067728363,
-0.0131311631,
0.0133390659,
-0.0525109693,
-0.0218266714,
-0.0009037828,
0.0189109985,
-0.0268566553,
-0.0167824123,
-0.0295218527,
-0.0078898752,
0.0264174324,
-0.0362810008,
-0.0286158305,
0.0283871591,
-0.012200065,
0.0426700599,
0.0190445557,
-0.0072515588,
-0.0370011702,
-0.0242374334,
0.00208851,
0.0133017823,
-0.075578481,
-0.0338770524,
0.084773235,
0.0199355129,
-0.0630706474,
-0.0289487615,
-0.016469283,
0.0154407667,
0.0310070161,
-0.0066847797,
0.0092739221,
-0.016773466,
0.0522054806,
-0.0615420565,
-0.0090126786,
0.0976612121,
0.0243939329,
-0.0055769579,
0.0188854281,
-0.0323901139,
0.0356028229,
0.0127378479,
0.0180536248,
-0.0097977519,
0.0387388095,
0.0219212566,
0.0267293639,
0.0201500747,
-0.0412095748,
-0.0148823289,
-0.0476698726,
0.0835025981,
0.0095640011,
0.0139769148,
0.0274352357,
-0.0234280974,
0.0405836068,
0.0105486093,
-0.0195051637,
0.0264817607,
0.0047851228,
-0.0172137022,
-0.0239020977,
-0.0202763025,
-0.004086534,
0.0063567357,
-0.0597838536,
0.0936373174,
0.0449325517,
0.0596530735,
-0.0004612218,
0.0325495265,
-0.0292552523,
0.0313725397,
0.0479121096,
-0.0004440506,
0.0278352126,
-0.0115032131,
-0.0342991352,
-0.0224712603,
0.0164799187,
0.0239692349,
-0.0528208092,
0.0172870532,
0.0605969839,
-0.0407952666,
-0.0427819677,
-0.0398381464,
0.0389523394,
0.0195934903,
0.0276651233,
-0.0031767969,
-0.0681403726,
-0.0332207903,
-0.0205137897,
-0.010220401,
-0.0700024739,
-0.0300463103,
-0.0000202741,
-0.0110376105,
-0.0500251539,
-0.0643271878,
-0.0651706383,
0.0478403084,
0.0653492659,
0.0184595566,
-0.0317782126,
0.006082675,
0.0014802983,
-0.0132829528,
-0.0398803428,
0.0004774506,
0.0096342349,
-0.0217239521,
-0.0387263447,
-0.0149189439,
-0.058817815,
0.0210923254,
0.0239653364,
-0.00038567,
-0.064609006,
0.0226335488,
0.0281305276,
0.0221211649,
0.0372351483,
0.0017260927,
-0.0324616693,
-0.0179437194,
-0.0473264456,
-0.0323778056,
0.0313271396,
-0.0304769482,
0.0261747129,
-0.0086248927,
0.0042759371,
-0.0358902216,
0.0061240522,
-0.014613959,
0.0413385704,
-0.0591163188,
-0.0364008546,
0.0166888256,
0.0190780852,
-0.0590025671,
-0.048123911,
0.0176046137,
-0.0450203232,
-0.0393268466,
-0.0739913136,
-0.0229093507,
-0.0214775391,
0.001228722,
0.0036396938,
-0.0272808019,
0.0318412594,
0.0001739749,
-0.0458640642,
-0.0411922634,
0.0084566167,
0.0348685347,
0.0482942611,
-0.0148918806,
0.0559036247,
0.0451928861,
-0.0038746325,
0.0317627378,
-0.0482822955,
0.0296622962,
0.021431189,
0.003809897,
0.015920667,
-0.0346179307,
0.0068391599,
0.0183022078,
-0.0180507321,
-0.0405434407,
0.0569675118,
0.0033016771,
0.0261194892,
0.017494658,
0.0304192044,
-0.0650112182,
0.0324423946,
0.0041420297,
-0.006425607,
0.026222134,
-0.0674029365,
-0.0384008251,
0.025563594,
-0.0041844114,
-0.0026307569,
0.0444698036,
0.0159590393,
0.025292486,
-0.0271126255,
-0.0402865484,
-0.0386507437,
-0.0135364579,
-0.0008059007,
-0.0061316211,
-0.0183741301,
0.0124892388,
-0.0773364976,
-0.022894131,
0.0044229161,
0.0339690857,
-0.0084985727,
-0.0442270935,
0.014603355,
-0.0067074941,
0.0281716641,
0.0462555028,
-0.0470985062,
0.0385514535,
-0.0167416725,
-0.0167755466,
-0.0114621064,
-4.86042596e-33,
-0.0584397539,
-0.0210810993,
0.0403855219,
0.0281965621,
-0.0403998643,
-0.0171845034,
-0.0594951026,
-0.0142887691,
0.0240769517,
0.0298102144,
0.0284279063,
-0.0071604392,
-0.0187810324,
-0.0179141778,
0.0132152848,
-0.025537692,
0.0732780546,
0.032630913,
-0.0527522489,
0.0032846506,
0.0545278192,
0.0313035697,
-0.0159454998,
-0.0616837218,
-0.0074007493,
-0.066082634,
-0.0493609756,
0.0085507948,
0.0241809916,
-0.0131594557,
0.0282588881,
-0.0145615917,
0.0094203372,
0.0245682932,
-0.0010060379,
0.0326855667,
-0.0046149334,
-0.0403242633,
0.0065385178,
0.0083519286,
-0.0186428577,
-0.0327512324,
-0.0363023989,
-0.0178465396,
-0.0119415838,
-0.0119973458,
0.0413430519,
-0.0045253285,
0.0270654764,
0.0366500504,
-0.0901845023,
-0.0022272537,
-0.0401647054,
-0.0515265502,
0.0143075669,
0.0361988209,
0.0094118854,
-0.0534055084,
-0.0537649393,
0.0547770187,
-0.0292325933,
-0.0117519582,
-0.0002846628,
0.0505111478,
-0.003460862,
0.0825314522,
-0.0029109537,
0.0429205112,
-0.0648962632,
0.047860831,
-0.0305525437,
0.0701235682,
0.0260449629,
0.0550838597,
-0.0866010785,
-0.0154964561,
-0.0011912683,
0.0576949641,
0.0032252348,
0.0366073176,
0.0253091771,
0.0509326458,
-0.0418477356,
-0.0154946605,
0.0008801838,
0.0093961442,
0.0122535927,
-0.0561282225,
-0.0007486442,
-0.0245216228,
0.0230292864,
-0.0377088264,
0.0146427769,
-0.0123143252,
0.025646098,
0.0160177555,
-0.036144603,
0.0414983593,
0.0019002676,
0.0160767306,
0.0276712645,
-0.0039403061,
0.026341252,
0.0008903417,
0.0624018312,
0.0540899336,
-0.0268852729,
0.0709459707,
0.0066710063,
-0.0180101823,
-0.0057096602,
0.0292268507,
0.0169414673,
-0.0243164152,
-0.0287227686,
-0.0405171476,
-0.018240789,
-0.0096645262,
0.0022232577,
-0.0483337678,
0.0204016846,
0.0383133441,
-0.0348151363,
-0.0059785116,
-0.0594360456,
0.0292369779,
-0.0607277639,
0.0465430394,
0.040490903,
-0.0442753807,
0.0037025581,
-0.0318137221,
2.747e-7,
-0.0245179292,
0.0111978892,
0.0184754077,
0.0495270044,
0.0324764363,
0.0610740036,
-0.0482316799,
0.0384986773,
0.0218245406,
-0.0221687313,
0.0384016447,
0.017159557,
0.0076562474,
0.0523586757,
-0.06393525,
-0.0200075395,
-0.0297582783,
-0.0371768773,
-0.0384050645,
-0.0195367411,
0.0766056627,
-0.0119042834,
0.0655516759,
-0.0016437138,
0.0151862912,
-0.0434861444,
0.0237563346,
-0.0538963787,
-0.0365744308,
0.0385243706,
-0.0409316868,
-0.0439019836,
-0.0096022105,
-0.0068569286,
-0.005194454,
0.015941862,
-0.0218429007,
0.0397323333,
-0.0379339941,
0.0487715229,
0.0159129184,
-0.0235979725,
-0.0129096666,
-0.0240786076,
0.0117272288,
-0.0000997599,
-0.0326074548,
0.0260622986,
-0.0269496199,
-0.0163309146,
-0.0505351387,
-0.0222887993,
-0.0309092514,
0.0196681302,
-0.0154812783,
0.0285234097,
0.0159152914,
-0.0104701258,
-0.0050319145,
0.0218428932,
-0.0519136079,
-0.0158182122,
-0.0008327413,
0.0093484623,
-0.0092881219,
-0.0152521301,
0.0223526321,
2.204552411e-34,
-0.0131392991,
0.0200881902,
-0.0197558571,
0.0022368692,
0.0626747161,
0.016482966,
0.0013012455,
0.0467071421,
0.0677395165,
-0.0142425643,
-0.0397929028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01091v1 | M2QA: Multi-domain Multilingual Question Answering | 2024-07-01T08:48:49 | 2024-07-01T08:48:49 | Leon Engländer, Hannah Sterz, Clifton Poth, Jonas Pfeiffer, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generalization and robustness to input variation are core desiderata of
machine learning research. Language varies along several axes, most
importantly, language instance (e.g. French) and domain (e.g. news). While
adapting NLP models to new languages within a single domain, or to new domains
within a single language, is widely studied, research in joint adaptation is
hampered by the lack of evaluation datasets. This prevents the transfer of NLP
systems from well-resourced languages and domains to non-dominant
language-domain combinations. To address this gap, we introduce M2QA, a
multi-domain multilingual question answering benchmark. M2QA includes 13,500
SQuAD 2.0-style question-answer instances in German, Turkish, and Chinese for
the domains of product reviews, news, and creative writing. We use M2QA to
explore cross-lingual cross-domain performance of fine-tuned models and
state-of-the-art LLMs and investigate modular approaches to domain and language
adaptation. We witness 1) considerable performance variations across
domain-language combinations within model classes and 2) considerable
performance drops between source and target language-domain combinations across
all model sizes. We demonstrate that M2QA is far from solved, and new methods
to effectively transfer both linguistic and domain-specific information are
necessary. We make M2QA publicly available at https://github.com/UKPLab/m2qa. | M2QA: Multi-domain Multilingual Question Answering: Generalization and robustness to input variation are core desiderata of
machine learning research. Language varies along several axes, most
importantly, language instance (e.g. French) and domain (e.g. news). While
adapting NLP models to new languages within a single domain, or to new domains
within a single language, is widely studied, research in joint adaptation is
hampered by the lack of evaluation datasets. This prevents the transfer of NLP
systems from well-resourced languages and domains to non-dominant
language-domain combinations. To address this gap, we introduce M2QA, a
multi-domain multilingual question answering benchmark. M2QA includes 13,500
SQuAD 2.0-style question-answer instances in German, Turkish, and Chinese for
the domains of product reviews, news, and creative writing. We use M2QA to
explore cross-lingual cross-domain performance of fine-tuned models and
state-of-the-art LLMs and investigate modular approaches to domain and language
adaptation. We witness 1) considerable performance variations across
domain-language combinations within model classes and 2) considerable
performance drops between source and target language-domain combinations across
all model sizes. We demonstrate that M2QA is far from solved, and new methods
to effectively transfer both linguistic and domain-specific information are
necessary. We make M2QA publicly available at https://github.com/UKPLab/m2qa. | [
0.0411648899,
0.0335087106,
-0.00636693,
0.0580861941,
-0.0189624541,
0.014109958,
0.0306981355,
-0.0235207062,
-0.0449168049,
-0.0625593662,
-0.0697412416,
-0.0510267615,
-0.0471277758,
0.0027473271,
0.0043936875,
-0.0138282552,
0.0527024381,
-0.0393379219,
-0.0247123111,
-0.0304714236,
0.0011547763,
0.0438154638,
-0.0035959457,
0.0081520211,
0.0260907561,
-0.0200631022,
0.0274149179,
-0.0026401887,
0.0222902708,
0.0120257204,
0.0408738405,
0.0470457152,
0.0093747992,
0.0140287597,
0.0000016906,
-0.0673827454,
-0.0200404767,
-0.0150171155,
0.0285880882,
-0.0036374484,
0.0134283053,
-0.0396626107,
0.0130794281,
0.0077950917,
-0.045428399,
-0.0213362016,
0.0347217731,
0.0315896198,
0.0672586784,
0.0877224281,
0.0084207365,
-0.027984865,
-0.0108780889,
-0.0160712302,
-0.0310401674,
-0.0837841928,
0.0165811628,
0.0099365273,
0.0215394255,
0.0044746506,
-0.0195647758,
0.0181832183,
0.0334981978,
0.0164156463,
-0.0466732718,
-0.0164156687,
-0.0147237889,
0.0471690558,
-0.0180995297,
0.0702731311,
0.0112382732,
-0.0172049291,
-0.0362233967,
0.0211502649,
0.0199859645,
0.0031283237,
-0.0595698506,
-0.0142170526,
0.0068594408,
-0.0288034528,
0.0152658913,
-0.01735783,
0.0200307611,
0.0026114529,
-0.0166316666,
0.0875245705,
0.0287231673,
-0.0026806688,
0.0261210389,
0.0486484282,
-0.0429168642,
-0.0433204807,
-0.0085750604,
0.0724512115,
-0.0326648951,
0.0139267063,
-0.0311139207,
-0.0397912487,
0.0271753892,
-0.0613018386,
0.0419804528,
0.0105601056,
0.0005420828,
0.0658529997,
-0.0295241326,
0.0265005492,
-0.0426600762,
-0.0085826218,
-0.0797021315,
-0.072140187,
-0.0548460148,
-0.0245270729,
-0.0175852645,
0.0386861302,
-0.0312544927,
0.0123355212,
-0.0200351868,
0.0281564426,
0.0066495794,
-0.0421859697,
0.0090043591,
0.0072744777,
-0.0114187412,
-0.0081926752,
-0.0434717424,
0.0599590242,
-0.0836402625,
0.0284138341,
0.0030300186,
-0.0433452018,
-0.0124227861,
0.012330981,
-0.0236247219,
-0.0594370142,
0.0233266857,
0.0872189477,
-0.0281431191,
0.0018464241,
-0.0137189459,
0.0162635017,
-0.0104224617,
-0.0808937773,
0.0211327579,
-0.0931296423,
0.0483075269,
0.013254079,
-0.0103647085,
-0.0482795648,
-0.0044995821,
0.0125152394,
-0.017041795,
0.0371468104,
0.0136412,
-0.0036460622,
0.0299562681,
0.0123277521,
-0.0039978963,
0.1021246091,
0.0002681489,
-0.0505299456,
0.0493630059,
-0.008514218,
0.0148178842,
0.0366643406,
0.015012769,
0.0423331559,
0.0111514516,
0.0496833995,
0.0146646928,
-0.0016770092,
0.0406526066,
0.0104410192,
0.0003256548,
-0.0466887951,
0.0272071175,
-0.0045907274,
0.0157494079,
0.0327257328,
0.0323365517,
-0.0370017961,
0.0145532032,
0.0064593148,
-0.0260606389,
0.0463891663,
-0.0103325164,
-0.0080892537,
-0.0144122643,
0.0539012589,
-0.0605618581,
-0.0186107792,
0.0069312388,
-0.0080418624,
0.0186781604,
0.0114467302,
0.0391349271,
0.0392830186,
-0.0040596062,
0.0797629058,
0.030713642,
-0.0104848268,
0.0132580418,
-0.0248311944,
0.0325401649,
0.0155058512,
0.0103460085,
-0.0232316591,
-0.0384576879,
-0.0028726666,
0.0268224869,
0.0316597298,
0.0564356484,
-0.0312536396,
0.0654053316,
-0.016825255,
-0.0224682875,
-0.0587211028,
-0.0038903186,
0.0581660643,
0.031497553,
0.0500182025,
-0.0023311172,
-0.0659376457,
0.0113565782,
0.0072990954,
-0.0678941309,
-0.0105707757,
0.0459228493,
-0.009912936,
0.0015042075,
0.0391909853,
-0.0051038582,
-0.0076094856,
0.0215036515,
-0.0640647784,
-0.0433603935,
-0.0097334897,
-0.0156259388,
-0.0390459523,
0.0414668806,
-0.0326070711,
-0.0225286204,
0.054162465,
-0.0473304018,
-0.0316870399,
0.0152963419,
0.0120385755,
-0.0069640102,
-0.0395483859,
-0.0230065547,
0.0020095364,
0.0405626521,
-0.037557587,
0.0471060388,
0.0146222673,
0.0159059316,
-0.0099014388,
0.0176260583,
0.0187755506,
-0.0100826854,
-0.0074260156,
0.0385629982,
-0.0078830384,
0.0240258891,
0.029695183,
0.0467541963,
-0.0272243116,
-0.0106809326,
-0.0699504688,
0.0216747876,
-0.0296834242,
0.0388475619,
0.0519950427,
0.0369947106,
-0.0007852557,
-0.0232196413,
-0.0796445608,
-0.0075092451,
0.0475577898,
0.0544725806,
0.0544769689,
0.0174744688,
0.0468788296,
-0.0215076301,
-0.0149661088,
0.0156376697,
0.0381382518,
-0.0400538035,
0.0106115714,
-0.0680398941,
0.0121885138,
-0.0740284175,
0.0317309201,
0.0030832416,
-0.029901877,
-0.0340924375,
-0.00459573,
0.0155470474,
0.0415249132,
-0.0147350449,
-0.039620582,
0.0535966456,
0.0273327511,
-0.0367411189,
0.0400355272,
-0.0095079662,
-0.0242561754,
-0.0649297386,
0.0065457709,
0.0199897829,
0.0448739119,
-0.0271188598,
-0.0376822762,
-0.0281538889,
0.0187284555,
-0.0162460357,
-0.0232149046,
-0.016738439,
0.037642125,
0.0025070298,
0.0462089591,
-0.0083080381,
0.0174782574,
0.0734275281,
0.009247683,
-0.0091605345,
-0.091983214,
-0.0228976458,
-0.0843563899,
0.0264059305,
-0.0412684195,
0.0314597562,
-0.0268488713,
-0.0080358749,
-0.0613362156,
-0.0241709743,
0.0149178132,
-0.0037614978,
0.069659926,
-0.0158196669,
0.0021683767,
-0.0304732788,
-0.0681470558,
-0.0322881043,
-0.0036219878,
-0.0329010338,
0.0114903729,
-0.0187861603,
-0.0231718402,
-0.0440001786,
-0.0045693233,
0.0410751663,
0.0034205313,
-0.0339037478,
-0.0055353874,
0.0062572472,
0.0694091469,
0.0688552707,
0.0767906904,
0.0193090923,
-0.0310771205,
0.0330215655,
0.0409977883,
-0.0000489228,
0.0112373587,
-0.0050030262,
-0.0073483959,
0.0588135831,
-0.0180889424,
0.0056187329,
-0.0180752929,
0.0980413184,
-0.0145444199,
-0.0164803267,
0.0906605646,
0.0072323959,
-0.0314432569,
0.0046689222,
-0.0243092235,
0.0241978951,
0.039729353,
0.076078482,
-0.0711096823,
-0.0428807177,
-0.0370415002,
0.0061415602,
0.0271755084,
0.0078236498,
-0.0167976487,
-0.1277992874,
-0.002277784,
-0.040512789,
-0.0941234007,
-0.0362714119,
-0.0512035005,
0.0088078249,
-0.0070251515,
0.0381211601,
-0.0335626826,
0.0016762834,
-0.0000222092,
0.0230445974,
0.0039708298,
-0.0312158372,
0.038136825,
-0.0272034872,
-0.0005169649,
0.0536773577,
0.014461752,
-0.0383738503,
0.0256102029,
0.0562994555,
-0.0424513631,
-0.000642855,
-0.0208893195,
0.0429455228,
0.0089013996,
-0.0069197263,
0.0301168934,
0.0084503526,
-0.0686677769,
0.027738912,
0.0685475394,
0.0566569716,
0.0316501819,
-0.0186131075,
-0.0325770378,
0.0057911775,
-0.0138946623,
0.0730582178,
0.0106343366,
-0.0633673519,
-0.015036948,
-0.024421744,
-0.0715697408,
-0.0738125145,
-0.0676537678,
0.0177330449,
-0.0042573097,
0.0266693868,
-0.0791883767,
-0.0663434565,
0.0045012045,
0.0240880344,
-0.0060258573,
0.0316398591,
-0.0520795062,
0.01144672,
-0.022802813,
-0.0009960545,
-0.0226822067,
0.0082844924,
-0.0489206277,
0.0182472523,
0.0280848164,
-0.0432618,
-0.0293557364,
-0.0164745227,
-0.0877885148,
-0.04688197,
-0.0240375027,
0.0464817733,
0.0078299716,
0.0318232253,
-0.0428883731,
-0.0300577618,
0.0226985477,
-0.0043979799,
0.0004923812,
0.0234012753,
0.0287689157,
0.004048747,
-0.0082734926,
0.0486419797,
-0.0737403333,
0.0345910154,
0.0453118309,
0.0419609658,
-0.0041210679,
-0.0367971845,
0.0076343571,
0.0044779121,
-0.023974115,
0.0300552901,
-0.0187141877,
0.0084389383,
0.0412090681,
-0.0077912458,
-0.0277873855,
-0.0437252261,
-0.0101045193,
0.0215325113,
-0.050997436,
-0.0103468336,
0.0192248784,
0.020899374,
0.042599,
-0.0577283055,
0.0159363039,
0.0806646571,
0.0051334314,
-0.0258522872,
0.0174370836,
-0.0138218747,
-0.0042360169,
0.0246054586,
0.0485952608,
-0.0308972448,
0.0207400899,
0.0264329929,
-0.0173610225,
0.0135579389,
0.007938141,
-0.0885860696,
-0.031805113,
0.0001057203,
0.0192845203,
0.0650356933,
-0.0121057937,
0.0690098852,
-0.0025357648,
-0.0228874628,
-0.0419513173,
-0.0115797017,
0.0196119901,
0.0355032124,
0.0408108234,
0.0088889347,
-0.0120575121,
0.0257980563,
0.0709279105,
0.0032815223,
0.0457847714,
0.0082071591,
0.0108848782,
-0.0155376391,
-0.0123271961,
-0.0094285589,
-0.0152489804,
-0.0190763883,
0.0317955725,
-0.0439082459,
-0.0479069762,
-0.0135590872,
-0.0187895633,
-0.0052741822,
-0.0111055169,
0.0150854932,
0.0839548036,
0.0316450745,
-0.0102690235,
-0.0480519384,
0.0096977381,
-0.0116904825,
-0.0146072367,
0.012952677,
-5.881294682e-33,
-0.005450448,
0.0089022359,
0.019447647,
-0.0339543968,
0.0104677109,
-0.0039609671,
-0.0092192497,
-0.0099293934,
-0.0713687539,
-0.0002496578,
-0.0191314649,
0.008699134,
-0.0033251089,
0.0341722593,
0.0002983997,
-0.0515561551,
0.0122661758,
0.0045885686,
-0.0366376527,
-0.000948594,
0.0279580522,
0.0388580672,
0.0821955875,
-0.0405079797,
0.0129491054,
-0.0168420598,
0.0073314128,
0.0458500832,
-0.0141157936,
0.0919033363,
0.0150897764,
0.0530937724,
0.0532819331,
-0.071794346,
-0.0026983859,
-0.0165966023,
-0.0834938064,
-0.0459814034,
0.0088052033,
0.0116261346,
-0.0311443433,
-0.041445151,
-0.0071107154,
0.009933644,
0.0393228047,
-0.0351088457,
0.02468873,
-0.0446369983,
0.0131607288,
-0.0348484516,
-0.0629501641,
-0.002161257,
0.019469751,
0.0091464315,
-0.024417378,
0.0916821882,
-0.0135878492,
0.0339462683,
-0.0275200475,
-0.0030697943,
-0.0338323303,
0.0672860816,
0.0568536073,
-0.0144111104,
-0.060574457,
0.0110158678,
-0.0190103594,
0.0169792324,
0.0222717989,
-0.0023703098,
-0.01231826,
0.0014487135,
0.0470300876,
0.0894378573,
0.0180833433,
0.0072955536,
-0.0972177908,
0.0397128612,
0.0210916158,
0.0045602303,
0.0049827076,
-0.0102784242,
0.0099534038,
0.0031288455,
-0.0327815562,
0.0500147715,
-0.0287199374,
-0.035906814,
0.0309387427,
-0.0292127654,
-0.0342637077,
-0.0231463537,
0.0436015762,
-0.0481632203,
-0.0042314567,
0.0430846997,
-0.0253929626,
0.0000840489,
0.0231981557,
0.0555840246,
-0.010358599,
-0.009306306,
-0.009518547,
0.0007477421,
-0.0017633856,
0.0048706848,
0.0464729816,
-0.0187649764,
-0.063811101,
0.0024955245,
-0.0248708073,
0.0278514549,
-0.0218398403,
0.0641657487,
-0.0254903175,
0.0056396625,
-0.0140562374,
0.0450761653,
0.0322087705,
-0.0350832529,
-0.0159638263,
-0.0117218802,
-0.0017050526,
0.022655515,
-0.0264836531,
0.0084781945,
-0.0315584764,
0.0245031659,
-0.0209211688,
-0.0450401939,
-0.0317425467,
0.0242860951,
2.349e-7,
0.0740341917,
0.0116998069,
-0.0167824086,
0.0508204997,
0.0246688444,
0.034994375,
-0.0251110606,
0.048710227,
0.019755315,
0.0145197008,
-0.0297905076,
0.055445224,
0.0498882718,
0.0477688201,
-0.0726215318,
-0.0011230377,
-0.021545805,
0.0139976339,
-0.0139903268,
-0.0003723146,
0.0272408463,
0.0832529142,
-0.0051419935,
-0.0120971557,
-0.0393250734,
-0.057925541,
0.0688557923,
0.002342901,
-0.0119789336,
0.0044151302,
-0.0045268126,
-0.0051628011,
0.0164181571,
0.0048468527,
-0.0287526883,
0.0251935832,
0.0488686524,
0.0701798722,
0.0256686974,
-0.0536331944,
0.0014725057,
-0.0091055781,
0.0131608266,
-0.0315214396,
0.0974927247,
-0.0117200799,
-0.008280674,
-0.0554190725,
-0.0143145472,
-0.0081122806,
0.0468962304,
-0.0207538698,
-0.0061546052,
0.0303371903,
0.0256383382,
0.0053137164,
-0.0183077436,
-0.0301460773,
-0.0176734813,
0.0198773276,
-0.0170456041,
-0.0257496983,
0.0099866018,
-0.0071789068,
0.0016439491,
-0.061466109,
0.0123857101,
1.863985066e-34,
0.0149677312,
-0.003836374,
-0.0007359249,
0.0520013012,
0.0080695609,
-0.0313675366,
-0.0516602285,
-0.0315988436,
0.0217356924,
-0.0502836592,
0.0151514048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01085v1 | Rethinking LLM-based Preference Evaluation | 2024-07-01T08:37:41 | 2024-07-01T08:37:41 | Zhengyu Hu, Linxin Song, Jieyu Zhang, Zheyuan Xiao, Jingang Wang, Zhenyu Chen, Jieyu Zhao, Hui Xiong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recently, large language model (LLM)-based preference evaluation has been
widely adopted to compare pairs of model responses. However, a severe bias
towards lengthy responses has been observed, raising concerns about the
reliability of this evaluation method. In this work, we designed a series of
controlled experiments to study the major impacting factors of the metric of
LLM-based preference evaluation, i.e., win rate, and conclude that the win rate
is affected by two axes of model response: desirability and information mass,
where the former is length-independent and related to trustworthiness, and the
latter is length-dependent and can be represented by conditional entropy. We
find that length impacts the existing evaluations by influencing information
mass. However, a reliable evaluation metric should not only assess content
quality but also ensure that the assessment is not confounded by extraneous
factors such as response length. Therefore, we propose a simple yet effective
adjustment, AdapAlpaca, to the existing practice of win rate measurement.
Specifically, by adjusting the lengths of reference answers to match the test
model's answers within the same interval, we debias information mass relative
to length, ensuring a fair model evaluation. | Rethinking LLM-based Preference Evaluation: Recently, large language model (LLM)-based preference evaluation has been
widely adopted to compare pairs of model responses. However, a severe bias
towards lengthy responses has been observed, raising concerns about the
reliability of this evaluation method. In this work, we designed a series of
controlled experiments to study the major impacting factors of the metric of
LLM-based preference evaluation, i.e., win rate, and conclude that the win rate
is affected by two axes of model response: desirability and information mass,
where the former is length-independent and related to trustworthiness, and the
latter is length-dependent and can be represented by conditional entropy. We
find that length impacts the existing evaluations by influencing information
mass. However, a reliable evaluation metric should not only assess content
quality but also ensure that the assessment is not confounded by extraneous
factors such as response length. Therefore, we propose a simple yet effective
adjustment, AdapAlpaca, to the existing practice of win rate measurement.
Specifically, by adjusting the lengths of reference answers to match the test
model's answers within the same interval, we debias information mass relative
to length, ensuring a fair model evaluation. | [
0.0634111091,
0.0605203956,
-0.0030277523,
0.037527144,
-0.0614435449,
-0.0026092511,
-0.0044622938,
-0.0000168917,
0.0032086486,
-0.0357030891,
-0.0533285774,
-0.0877865404,
0.0177885238,
0.0199676994,
0.0085001821,
-0.0305003598,
0.0018413856,
-0.0138674825,
0.0493862554,
-0.0289963484,
0.0031169967,
-0.0234428942,
0.0296686869,
0.0149386907,
0.0808424428,
0.0045436881,
0.0085213091,
-0.0329867229,
0.0124555919,
-0.0594485551,
-0.0099239843,
0.0646033064,
-0.0144517412,
-0.008559336,
0.0000021628,
-0.0788705125,
0.0043707923,
0.008011044,
-0.0218138173,
0.0667232051,
0.0262265597,
0.0846994817,
0.0083582383,
0.0191218145,
-0.0288971122,
0.0089148758,
0.0173244569,
0.0124984449,
-0.003196008,
0.0125476737,
0.0067306668,
-0.0077012186,
0.0098821595,
-0.0453215502,
0.0367441215,
-0.0053978348,
0.0273199789,
-0.027000431,
-0.0037073623,
0.0237180982,
-0.0072700782,
0.0004594635,
0.0095218131,
-0.0156746823,
0.0331504233,
0.0130663868,
0.0348133743,
-0.023209719,
-0.0007192332,
0.05699699,
0.0415778048,
0.0114450296,
-0.0404269807,
-0.0314837545,
0.0492021777,
0.0155170839,
-0.0467515774,
0.0134646539,
0.0251307506,
0.0050694467,
-0.0001077871,
0.0291372538,
0.0210184958,
0.0099255173,
-0.0048548635,
0.0979148522,
0.0031712558,
-0.0533698834,
0.0181363765,
-0.0070131407,
0.001348279,
-0.0755729005,
-0.0243348852,
0.0008384687,
0.0151855852,
0.0327301696,
0.0322124623,
0.0515208729,
0.0595878214,
-0.0625404045,
0.0109982714,
0.0052168067,
0.0033048221,
0.0168007892,
0.0111945253,
0.0591193959,
0.0178227015,
-0.0018487948,
-0.0460973978,
0.0473089628,
0.0007779552,
0.0078181168,
0.0645516217,
0.0252183396,
0.0138806514,
-0.003567304,
-0.0686806887,
0.0023023484,
0.0069959909,
0.0303781759,
0.0241240021,
0.0137839187,
0.033719521,
0.0053654253,
-0.086374402,
0.0686103031,
-0.0258954,
0.032965634,
0.0118100774,
-0.0344865173,
0.0469353944,
0.0073995041,
-0.0156382117,
-0.0442372747,
0.0281016584,
0.0495745242,
0.0115981437,
-0.0433390662,
0.009488292,
-0.0003845882,
-0.0572553948,
-0.061438337,
-0.0135848625,
-0.0915551037,
-0.0046790638,
0.0204474833,
-0.0074615004,
-0.0277468972,
-0.0022047595,
0.0052637076,
-0.0515949056,
0.00976949,
0.0108341491,
0.032686688,
-0.0129114641,
0.0262623206,
0.0340070464,
0.0454714037,
0.0435351469,
0.0543600693,
0.0547157004,
-0.0235048421,
-0.0128856646,
0.0220318902,
-0.0216630213,
0.05057941,
0.0031801644,
0.0433571674,
0.0038821064,
-0.0009529875,
0.0084981518,
0.0638413131,
-0.0167887751,
-0.0350571387,
0.1248478591,
0.0346629359,
0.0299238916,
-0.0260573737,
-0.0180037878,
0.0403070599,
0.0149786174,
0.0468786769,
-0.0131077627,
0.0122950459,
-0.0312119257,
0.0244465843,
0.0844919682,
0.0266343262,
-0.0032247349,
-0.0689107105,
-0.020307593,
0.0054555261,
0.0289903153,
0.0601767264,
0.0361382477,
-0.0428793691,
-0.0136718787,
-0.0052812672,
0.0309827533,
-0.0321877226,
0.0159735754,
-0.0515854657,
0.0755749419,
0.0719064921,
0.0136191836,
0.0223960709,
0.0305395629,
-0.027187746,
-0.0565320887,
0.021504933,
0.05642768,
0.0069547221,
-0.0004070709,
-0.0201604534,
-0.0176530592,
-0.0079257516,
0.0087989643,
0.0229713637,
-0.0069776359,
0.0299309604,
0.0023153897,
-0.0221958198,
-0.0185280852,
-0.0015786502,
0.0187429674,
-0.0274757966,
-0.0117355678,
-0.0036386736,
0.0967671946,
0.0176584516,
-0.0167385489,
0.029719431,
0.0097988555,
0.0051306076,
-0.0203828365,
-0.0262370016,
-0.0156365968,
0.0300062448,
0.0265646223,
-0.0181725249,
0.0100463284,
0.0185610205,
0.0310092699,
0.0009826705,
-0.0285196993,
-0.0138075883,
0.0505003445,
0.0058719809,
0.0253701694,
-0.0441786759,
-0.0249434002,
-0.0843369141,
0.0243397616,
-0.0312919877,
0.0561692826,
-0.0178405624,
-0.0486833677,
0.0166137125,
-0.0329695903,
-0.0472745709,
0.0533557199,
0.0012888912,
0.0097430842,
0.0554099716,
-0.0128883868,
-0.0491111465,
-0.0535684898,
-0.0672264099,
-0.0016264033,
0.020208016,
0.0131786289,
0.0115327379,
-0.0160340443,
-0.0142909596,
0.0493152663,
-0.092746824,
-0.0330323949,
0.0115141366,
0.0429859273,
-0.0080793174,
0.0061486452,
-0.0188592672,
-0.0493936837,
-0.03130899,
0.0137726283,
0.0486978702,
0.042154517,
0.0350033976,
-0.0361265987,
0.0701586157,
-0.0731706768,
-0.0315232575,
-0.0031830787,
-0.0620802902,
0.008689899,
0.0116089405,
0.0138704805,
0.0293259099,
0.0640231445,
-0.0284484271,
0.1017070636,
-0.0091850944,
-0.0792622492,
-0.0552839488,
-0.0378168561,
-0.0226359628,
-0.0510833301,
-0.0992192551,
0.0267616622,
0.0308071598,
0.0195210353,
0.0021232758,
-0.0089463098,
-0.0104148397,
-0.0225484315,
-0.035409417,
-0.0023788833,
-0.017739946,
-0.0105094872,
0.0714570284,
0.020403903,
-0.0618579537,
0.069152385,
-0.0550276674,
0.0337599665,
-0.0227789488,
-0.0164620206,
-0.0262871459,
0.0246706121,
0.0015277499,
0.0112941852,
0.0152595164,
0.0195770245,
-0.0397284366,
-0.0568489842,
0.0194083508,
-0.0487365089,
0.0366451964,
-0.0225633383,
-0.0274720117,
0.0109067736,
-0.0299991667,
-0.007261334,
-0.0661548302,
-0.0109410156,
-0.0302507505,
0.0570546538,
-0.0315839164,
0.0034962909,
-0.0149941305,
0.072380051,
-0.0309279133,
-0.0298983008,
0.0038808042,
0.0294654258,
0.0487256087,
0.0886203349,
0.0265376307,
0.0708662868,
-0.0293129422,
0.0081861559,
0.0473722927,
0.0059579597,
0.0367675647,
0.0000627128,
-0.0376024395,
0.0455400683,
0.0087264031,
-0.0420509204,
0.053582143,
0.0445975102,
-0.0221149847,
0.048545856,
0.0862310231,
0.0030411873,
-0.0399969146,
-0.0021706987,
-0.0223152805,
0.0422317795,
0.0001141772,
0.0041029905,
-0.0329362527,
0.0075034481,
-0.0046356018,
0.0196178313,
-0.0467281975,
-0.0034762309,
-0.0157280415,
-0.0984895304,
-0.0042958376,
-0.012665242,
0.0072590923,
0.0053310292,
-0.090816915,
0.0152392536,
-0.0115527548,
0.0078900941,
0.0206173733,
-0.0121642211,
-0.0011489546,
-0.0180182885,
-0.0468593985,
-0.0172347799,
0.0447546802,
-0.0228117891,
0.0533729121,
0.0546770394,
0.0116433827,
-0.050284449,
-0.0513380468,
-0.0059786011,
-0.0166511275,
-0.0559904836,
0.018488545,
0.0394054949,
-0.0080422889,
0.0293468069,
-0.0508537814,
-0.0013788944,
0.0358469896,
0.024426071,
0.0212044846,
0.0264883973,
0.0252011325,
-0.0463730432,
-0.0111589665,
-0.0153521774,
0.0111109894,
0.095776096,
0.0337735973,
-0.0735608265,
0.0191636235,
-0.0427704416,
-0.0510687903,
0.0146384491,
-0.0531268902,
-0.0032235065,
0.0161581598,
-0.0051320069,
-0.0660374388,
-0.0247837193,
-0.0239089634,
0.0087057007,
-0.0048437589,
0.0362922065,
0.0118942456,
-0.0047866935,
-0.0104192151,
0.0097299507,
-0.0047355071,
0.0151752271,
-0.0968195274,
0.0411377326,
0.0112894429,
-0.0606993102,
-0.0118175838,
-0.0027144356,
-0.0167111978,
-0.0390313864,
-0.0051907855,
0.038887918,
0.0283189043,
-0.0194936786,
0.0173611622,
-0.0357772261,
0.0304595921,
-0.0183365475,
-0.022729231,
0.0318155065,
0.012078735,
0.0528928153,
0.0230376665,
0.0096783657,
-0.0374783203,
-0.0027025416,
0.0521680936,
-0.0010990931,
0.0128704021,
-0.0975061804,
0.0053231348,
0.0721511692,
-0.0030289812,
0.0107179526,
0.038035471,
0.0015793537,
-0.0173532814,
-0.0353764854,
0.001567735,
-0.0156985559,
-0.0412225127,
0.0382831171,
-0.0178880617,
0.0098216636,
-0.0065225749,
-0.0408174545,
0.0064469669,
-0.0375288986,
0.0378791876,
-0.0199238826,
-0.00401311,
0.0311340839,
0.001936081,
-0.033393532,
-0.0312118381,
-0.0138117168,
0.0241561849,
0.0525878146,
0.0354566611,
-0.0112591283,
-0.066539973,
0.0298564788,
0.0532543026,
-0.0409924872,
-0.0441370197,
-0.0172819905,
-0.0111472458,
-0.0191963818,
0.0025416911,
0.0501129143,
-0.0117099714,
0.0217272118,
-0.0566489063,
-0.0064932066,
-0.016728675,
-0.0369123966,
0.047225073,
0.0214966722,
-0.0184572432,
0.0183061045,
0.04464164,
0.0365473963,
-0.0201039258,
-0.0322521403,
-0.0273659173,
-0.0277432781,
-0.0218182392,
-0.0223477464,
0.037602596,
-0.0392648242,
-0.030441815,
-0.084618777,
-0.0361432768,
-0.0326398425,
0.0198166873,
0.0358495675,
-0.0112632867,
0.0023441801,
0.0543030277,
-0.0234101694,
-0.0030357377,
-0.0408910513,
-0.0203905962,
-0.0156554841,
0.001292804,
-0.0162686836,
-6.735373245e-33,
0.0247245003,
-0.0305782948,
-0.016259972,
-0.0318384729,
-0.0191475768,
-0.0097631514,
0.0033514327,
0.036396917,
-0.0403485224,
-0.0255726147,
0.0026639546,
-0.0369342566,
0.0036386554,
-0.0015936262,
0.0210816506,
-0.0136912121,
0.023869779,
0.0225553438,
-0.0528695136,
-0.0135332784,
0.0264342912,
-0.0508704893,
0.0345073231,
-0.0578844137,
0.0841763839,
0.0236490704,
-0.0071686045,
-0.0237028226,
-0.0222925581,
0.0592173524,
-0.0127856135,
0.0423616618,
0.021631036,
-0.0685783625,
-0.0033906074,
0.0346247591,
-0.0024118416,
-0.0078213476,
0.0474551059,
-0.0256507508,
0.0171048548,
-0.0246720463,
0.0288278479,
0.0122126741,
-0.0488433912,
-0.0361157544,
0.0276913308,
-0.0414011851,
-0.0014856812,
0.0040588332,
-0.0047316724,
0.0049243583,
0.0045455527,
0.0080794375,
-0.0377710238,
0.0737475529,
-0.0275410675,
0.0639153123,
-0.0269650239,
0.0625522509,
0.0361500867,
0.0460784175,
0.0331181437,
-0.0442365557,
0.0210454501,
0.0669250414,
0.0021080594,
-0.0042211013,
-0.0175029989,
-0.0630975366,
0.0074448823,
-0.0227859542,
0.0695626065,
0.0499450527,
0.0461943857,
-0.0317160673,
-0.044411432,
0.0216039363,
0.0360981338,
0.002909349,
0.0458579138,
0.0311354715,
-0.0523851402,
-0.0299119763,
-0.0505882427,
-0.0144895315,
-0.0457751267,
-0.0686677843,
0.0407923386,
-0.0048067882,
-0.0063524833,
-0.0278126914,
0.0496429466,
-0.0328801125,
-0.0668031201,
0.0208203215,
-0.0197738763,
0.0629154518,
0.0244587027,
-0.0140721602,
-0.0457740724,
0.0574804731,
-0.0026983432,
0.014258408,
-0.0269030631,
0.0113977287,
-0.0113186585,
-0.0102785248,
-0.0427439697,
-0.0119674308,
-0.001135439,
-0.0333703607,
0.0553633794,
-0.0323217288,
0.0077101765,
-0.0258532539,
-0.0111838849,
0.0343053713,
-0.0278722644,
-0.0176029596,
-0.0512478352,
-0.029400548,
-0.0006797891,
0.0243564565,
-0.0130355638,
-0.0305417031,
-0.0099962782,
0.0075622876,
0.0131820505,
0.0190451425,
-0.0085182833,
-0.0413293056,
2.876e-7,
0.0061552282,
0.0456299521,
-0.0612989441,
0.0095712924,
-0.0193381105,
0.0439318754,
0.0105001582,
-0.0133129256,
0.0557917096,
-0.0312589593,
-0.0194973126,
-0.0159313101,
0.0325950272,
0.0326828137,
-0.0544816405,
-0.0273320414,
-0.0457223132,
-0.0127898045,
-0.0113498308,
0.0267006289,
0.0474785008,
0.0723857731,
0.0286931358,
0.0101274261,
-0.0341363922,
0.0071259495,
0.0207984447,
-0.0872004554,
-0.0141386986,
0.0266782138,
0.0469602123,
-0.0230524521,
0.0207820814,
0.008694943,
0.0132448012,
0.0011733435,
-0.0120652709,
0.0483078063,
0.0513711125,
-0.0301779862,
0.0058550835,
-0.0279850774,
0.0061727813,
-0.097495012,
0.0629432499,
-0.0311878454,
-0.0388068855,
-0.0276640803,
-0.0362499878,
-0.0291072037,
0.0530316569,
-0.0359565169,
0.0071269986,
0.0004424426,
-0.0106616346,
-0.0096438024,
-0.0047147907,
-0.0010814782,
-0.0255602598,
-0.0142901205,
-0.0190769061,
-0.0959364325,
-0.0530566238,
0.0116058672,
-0.028710695,
-0.0805939436,
0.0236757118,
2.648645223e-34,
0.0386017263,
-0.0113241691,
0.0101506803,
-0.0165975448,
0.040795587,
0.0221351217,
-0.0015746632,
0.002399706,
0.0245719049,
-0.099617146,
0.0011742646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01082v1 | Min P Sampling: Balancing Creativity and Coherence at High Temperature | 2024-07-01T08:37:25 | 2024-07-01T08:37:25 | Minh Nguyen, Andrew Baker, Andreas Kirsch, Clement Neo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) generate longform text by successively sampling
the next token based on the probability distribution of the token vocabulary at
each decoding step. Current popular truncation sampling methods such as top-$p$
sampling, also known as nucleus sampling, often struggle to balance coherence
and creativity in generating text, particularly when using higher temperatures.
To address this issue, we propose min-$p$, a dynamic truncation sampling
method, that establishes a minimum base percentage threshold for tokens, which
the scales according to the probability of the top candidate token. Through
experiments on several benchmarks, such as GPQA, GSM8K and AlpacaEval Creative
Writing, we demonstrate that min-$p$ improves the coherence and quality of
generated text even at high temperatures, while also facilitating more creative
and diverse outputs compared to top-$p$ and other sampling methods. As of
writing, min-$p$ has been adopted by multiple open-source LLM implementations,
and have been independently assessed by members of the open-source LLM
community, further validating its practical utility and potential. | Min P Sampling: Balancing Creativity and Coherence at High Temperature: Large Language Models (LLMs) generate longform text by successively sampling
the next token based on the probability distribution of the token vocabulary at
each decoding step. Current popular truncation sampling methods such as top-$p$
sampling, also known as nucleus sampling, often struggle to balance coherence
and creativity in generating text, particularly when using higher temperatures.
To address this issue, we propose min-$p$, a dynamic truncation sampling
method, that establishes a minimum base percentage threshold for tokens, which
the scales according to the probability of the top candidate token. Through
experiments on several benchmarks, such as GPQA, GSM8K and AlpacaEval Creative
Writing, we demonstrate that min-$p$ improves the coherence and quality of
generated text even at high temperatures, while also facilitating more creative
and diverse outputs compared to top-$p$ and other sampling methods. As of
writing, min-$p$ has been adopted by multiple open-source LLM implementations,
and have been independently assessed by members of the open-source LLM
community, further validating its practical utility and potential. | [
0.0047016442,
0.0112232082,
-0.0162016861,
-0.0121091511,
-0.0651282892,
-0.0270763244,
-0.0217646472,
0.0325817764,
-0.0620404333,
-0.0038394532,
-0.0160772242,
-0.0563759767,
0.0143243624,
0.0554602258,
0.0122122318,
-0.0629836544,
-0.0090454537,
-0.0663514137,
0.0433240905,
-0.0097196233,
0.00514034,
0.0324806049,
0.0080995355,
0.0355581641,
0.0056170253,
-0.0446137115,
-0.0167484973,
0.0481899679,
-0.0001848878,
-0.026804246,
-0.0642549843,
0.0620057508,
-0.0163135882,
0.0140326731,
0.0000020397,
-0.0354256891,
-0.0149011211,
-0.0054900697,
0.0292222295,
0.0086440993,
0.0836682245,
-0.0026754718,
-0.0389524736,
0.0269635972,
0.0027242496,
0.0516903959,
0.0527366623,
0.0513680056,
0.0170521196,
0.0406131372,
0.0032753425,
-0.0224296506,
0.0163586698,
-0.0166826397,
-0.0122835087,
0.0219914876,
0.0061654882,
-0.0123810312,
0.0394405387,
-0.0085654678,
-0.0138383405,
-0.0080060288,
0.0194407683,
-0.0390333496,
-0.0054766671,
0.07009691,
-0.0210443996,
-0.005235272,
-0.004924769,
0.0204115752,
-0.0327508375,
-0.022736093,
0.0158446208,
-0.0108328098,
-0.0257018618,
-0.058145795,
-0.0631080493,
0.0281986762,
-0.0212125517,
0.0500236824,
0.0087891631,
0.0154940039,
-0.0042461846,
-0.0167342536,
0.0080669476,
0.0741718635,
0.0411954634,
-0.0360407159,
-0.0278124418,
0.0423822291,
0.0061389529,
-0.0677391738,
0.0290438309,
-0.0113103194,
-0.0044005024,
0.0056463955,
-0.0869186595,
-0.03053106,
0.0278550591,
-0.0002092084,
0.0731016025,
0.0082272105,
0.047055237,
0.0247518644,
0.0073397141,
-0.0370570421,
0.0136440042,
0.0141032841,
-0.0417990126,
0.0049346918,
-0.0116786063,
-0.0184414163,
-0.0334726945,
0.0086849295,
-0.0373880081,
-0.0438753627,
-0.0580085516,
0.0105936686,
0.0420702919,
-0.058822155,
0.0065193321,
0.0092902994,
-0.0535538755,
0.0171564724,
0.0406391844,
0.0013996341,
-0.0646330714,
-0.0023071556,
0.0385557078,
-0.0297746323,
-0.018849941,
0.0223661549,
0.0030241602,
-0.0343925357,
-0.0060166693,
0.0495100282,
-0.0084631108,
-0.0173526481,
-0.0224337801,
-0.0372510292,
-0.0311081391,
-0.0534281135,
0.0197229274,
-0.089430593,
-0.0014665261,
0.0007308082,
0.0005767866,
-0.0012656569,
-0.0001126921,
0.0354563482,
-0.029128531,
-0.0015807118,
0.0058228518,
0.0162798073,
-0.0103289215,
-0.0067614592,
0.0249548145,
0.0591300502,
0.1012974903,
0.0494803526,
0.0205698721,
0.0093314648,
0.0031737299,
0.026194647,
0.0221596695,
0.0341074057,
-0.053838294,
-0.0436777323,
-0.0032045466,
0.0716854185,
0.0758997351,
0.0980962738,
-0.0331416726,
0.0177818947,
0.1038875505,
0.0648931116,
0.0008838657,
0.0240622498,
0.0310547221,
0.0131157208,
0.0060046758,
0.0230654683,
-0.0128793679,
0.0501681529,
0.0137056718,
0.0607116856,
0.0757781118,
0.0649196282,
-0.0071983347,
-0.0069561121,
-0.0211086944,
0.0056338259,
0.0090500573,
-0.0395316295,
0.0377653725,
0.0213788953,
-0.0422233194,
0.005953236,
0.0161087755,
-0.0483430997,
0.0339656472,
-0.0188924,
0.0434018895,
0.1069058925,
0.0601941124,
0.0134407878,
0.0289078765,
-0.0188777577,
-0.0030363912,
0.0551109426,
-0.0144643933,
0.0165265072,
0.0306666661,
-0.0217661075,
-0.000009967,
-0.0275551286,
-0.0065601026,
0.0150356386,
-0.008564542,
0.0364885293,
-0.0136682289,
-0.0468424819,
0.0079938639,
0.0197163559,
-0.0446037389,
0.014447486,
-0.0002828941,
-0.0368549116,
0.0183649473,
0.021198906,
-0.0655982643,
0.0247644447,
0.0350875668,
-0.067496255,
-0.0192329716,
0.0181667339,
-0.0332430564,
-0.0403538793,
0.021453321,
-0.0494553521,
0.0337486006,
-0.0220056381,
-0.0013411385,
-0.0478620529,
0.0602738,
-0.0201798044,
0.0220891032,
-0.0489564687,
0.0069385697,
-0.0074411645,
0.0272504278,
-0.0175196342,
0.0477387011,
-0.0195331406,
0.0014239438,
0.0187975094,
-0.010692846,
-0.0290718954,
-0.0565004461,
0.0119557651,
0.0074847774,
0.0222848561,
0.0008026683,
0.0141770914,
0.0390138924,
-0.0272680297,
-0.0725363046,
-0.0755947009,
0.0316574238,
-0.0066091507,
-0.0194062423,
0.0201942008,
0.0097408118,
-0.0423370637,
0.0455955304,
-0.0273280777,
-0.0711954609,
0.0109911598,
0.0130310114,
0.0306134094,
-0.0227154605,
-0.0020129464,
0.0077057234,
-0.0237083063,
0.0278436486,
0.0495975539,
0.0206339657,
0.001790342,
-0.0369489715,
0.023720162,
-0.0187127907,
-0.0663893446,
0.0293617379,
-0.0253823791,
0.017677404,
-0.012339239,
0.0537728593,
0.0465557985,
0.0336089134,
-0.0050210776,
0.0409550369,
-0.0162457973,
0.0067111677,
-0.0227565449,
-0.0187157393,
0.0739459619,
0.0218715537,
-0.0611327998,
0.0147946877,
0.0427067354,
0.0321255066,
0.0160611365,
-0.037878193,
0.0650336519,
-0.0219744574,
-0.0485908203,
0.0104149692,
0.0289456565,
-0.0548877977,
0.0296400543,
-0.0195464194,
-0.0440570004,
0.0571652688,
-0.0569496937,
0.0098477956,
-0.0354138985,
0.0157966521,
-0.0246518012,
0.0271241684,
-0.0306613874,
0.0320513919,
0.0103835352,
-0.0108929574,
-0.0362607874,
-0.0022801731,
0.0213982575,
-0.0341304205,
0.0062989923,
-0.0105059026,
-0.0249848142,
-0.0049610538,
-0.0281125661,
0.0079311943,
0.0095323846,
-0.0006913988,
0.0241177119,
0.0733921677,
-0.0287980437,
0.0093509695,
0.0082769012,
0.0321163759,
0.0151903201,
-0.0259273611,
-0.0057483432,
-0.0120683061,
0.0377199203,
0.0710490793,
-0.0356102064,
-0.0028955683,
-0.0574880652,
-0.017446002,
0.041134309,
0.0238830298,
0.0355175398,
0.0090179462,
-0.0059485398,
0.0157790519,
0.008302317,
-0.0190244056,
0.0151969008,
0.0737182349,
-0.0157079492,
-0.0275156368,
0.0899300948,
0.0054748156,
0.0068351259,
0.0190276727,
-0.0037624859,
0.0856979489,
-0.0061028185,
0.021165859,
-0.045275297,
0.0020007554,
0.0350433737,
0.0677680522,
-0.023151869,
-0.0291853771,
-0.0100516342,
-0.0962019265,
0.0550482646,
0.0191017482,
-0.0219473615,
0.0091232825,
-0.0448699445,
-0.0209324211,
0.019090971,
-0.0038968713,
0.0093835155,
-0.0141819408,
0.0320990235,
0.0145420358,
-0.0280548912,
-0.037451867,
-0.0137864761,
-0.0506466106,
0.0514129549,
0.0885445327,
0.0449579135,
-0.0234470479,
-0.000758244,
-0.0173733775,
-0.0065490529,
-0.0038579556,
-0.0120968213,
-0.0107600251,
0.0303344689,
0.013426031,
-0.0401521474,
0.0407977477,
-0.0048913928,
-0.024482945,
-0.0232106857,
0.0444571823,
-0.011344349,
-0.0454673283,
-0.0293235853,
0.0291448385,
0.0167804658,
0.0741927922,
0.0666374639,
-0.0534806438,
-0.0946188048,
-0.0548332632,
0.0168085769,
-0.111881353,
-0.0049824174,
-0.0359407216,
-0.0135870529,
-0.0173689649,
-0.0855083838,
0.0143405562,
0.0253237728,
0.0918368101,
0.0039605931,
0.0523548275,
-0.0306239314,
-0.0326248929,
-0.0176361259,
-0.0525819957,
-0.0578714088,
0.0252355356,
-0.0669086128,
-0.0083704917,
-0.0373525731,
-0.0450449474,
-0.0178918187,
0.0401293151,
-0.0801235586,
-0.0693543255,
0.0091023538,
0.0366148166,
0.0272173733,
0.0246130936,
0.0008212366,
-0.0541415028,
0.0424277596,
0.0507080592,
0.0150909387,
0.0822665021,
-0.0330603495,
0.0186880101,
0.0198657941,
0.0236700624,
-0.054563459,
0.0251591858,
0.018154541,
0.084416315,
0.0444436222,
-0.0256297775,
0.0057303701,
0.0067686592,
-0.0144146727,
-0.0516251251,
0.0048577362,
-0.0420610793,
-0.0151012959,
-0.0214700084,
0.0123263197,
-0.059856303,
0.0206280034,
0.0372564942,
-0.0227639433,
-0.0043853484,
0.0108335391,
-0.0123975379,
0.0560061,
-0.0319540054,
0.0028553391,
-0.021349147,
0.0262138527,
0.0371534154,
-0.0220233407,
-0.0242787655,
0.02830882,
-0.0727001503,
0.0408420302,
0.0038020385,
-0.025439607,
0.0153941549,
0.0044749277,
-0.0175214149,
0.0439391993,
-0.0588391609,
-0.0197207183,
-0.0401735231,
0.0234174766,
0.0588537715,
0.0462211259,
0.0480027534,
-0.0328523591,
0.0191556998,
-0.0423474982,
0.0550067909,
0.0399522148,
-0.062525019,
-0.0445172861,
-0.001356845,
-0.0217627659,
-0.0208853241,
0.0774215758,
-0.0256180353,
-0.0070453002,
0.0280128475,
-0.0058809118,
-0.0009251395,
0.0062668109,
-0.0464648232,
0.0041822111,
0.0100443251,
-0.0180756468,
-0.0635293946,
-0.0119992169,
0.0790670365,
0.0105263544,
0.0273757279,
-0.0263143685,
0.0169613715,
0.047239732,
-0.0264731217,
0.0018762936,
-0.0283934306,
0.0163899232,
0.0188389625,
-0.0352965705,
0.00333199,
-6.499308266e-33,
-0.0269574672,
0.009385216,
-0.0224194359,
-0.0110026849,
-0.0647322014,
-0.0132527128,
-0.0590628684,
-0.0173606351,
0.050996311,
0.0112344138,
-0.0287586525,
-0.017960446,
0.0132083669,
0.0192228295,
-0.0180257019,
0.0081350645,
0.0798263997,
-0.0193994325,
-0.0540814474,
0.0481997654,
0.0650081187,
0.0381731503,
0.0317248441,
-0.0049369922,
-0.0145582985,
-0.031188963,
0.0006932915,
-0.031731192,
0.04058557,
0.0324910581,
0.0001624976,
0.020149745,
0.0068818564,
-0.0312268883,
-0.034680292,
-0.0132121732,
-0.0342784673,
-0.0239760056,
-0.0110042654,
-0.0383249894,
0.0048441542,
-0.0482141934,
0.0184622146,
0.0133711128,
-0.0164348539,
0.0010546279,
0.0028457541,
-0.0099608572,
-0.0775362775,
-0.0884374306,
-0.0480047427,
0.0344600007,
0.005066698,
-0.0031311782,
-0.0411557145,
-0.0453617685,
-0.0078885797,
0.0063771578,
-0.0226787888,
0.0260073133,
0.0361443907,
0.0488873124,
0.0261235368,
0.0151121821,
0.0171805546,
0.0775147751,
0.0130825033,
0.0301471297,
-0.0131884683,
0.0223787148,
0.034994442,
0.0174672566,
0.0141126951,
0.0373063758,
0.0379110388,
-0.0328680798,
-0.0293371715,
0.0149790151,
0.030443266,
-0.0313312225,
0.0630012974,
0.0134207709,
-0.0114366654,
-0.0371104777,
-0.0277148094,
-0.0452678241,
-0.0045399223,
-0.0249592587,
0.038096007,
0.0080395713,
-0.0521692783,
-0.0304615106,
0.0247228909,
-0.0097144656,
-0.0130742425,
0.0033402888,
-0.0365002118,
0.0594445616,
-0.0260777753,
0.005885554,
-0.0325062461,
-0.0334061496,
0.0317132957,
-0.0000472204,
-0.0084773796,
0.0061068535,
0.0255743545,
0.0302730147,
-0.0369452126,
0.0072384351,
-0.0109438049,
0.0499179438,
0.0411614329,
-0.0264617,
0.0218825005,
-0.0371567346,
0.0282606035,
-0.0061802869,
0.0371766388,
0.0143411001,
-0.0080273496,
-0.0143426172,
-0.0226684678,
0.0079585323,
-0.021911744,
0.0267292019,
-0.0422287993,
-0.0315276273,
0.0365147963,
-0.0477837622,
-0.0433500707,
0.0404186398,
2.762e-7,
0.0318263918,
0.0500615053,
0.0326786712,
0.002826805,
0.006555655,
-0.0044395793,
-0.0156555101,
0.0578327924,
-0.0293842684,
0.0033849371,
-0.0400732793,
0.0002521374,
0.0451789573,
0.0535715967,
-0.1342007965,
0.0658728406,
-0.0766628906,
0.0419450738,
-0.0544782653,
-0.0220255479,
0.0112145944,
0.0268281754,
0.0008884346,
-0.016640136,
0.0233038589,
-0.0543368198,
0.0519560799,
-0.0199965835,
0.015369446,
0.0059767026,
0.0484750345,
-0.0469367243,
0.0283373985,
-0.0386188291,
-0.0168926883,
-0.0050382875,
0.0124705071,
0.0417646766,
0.0081771398,
-0.0220163446,
0.0590449981,
-0.0207843129,
-0.0124895815,
-0.0531357788,
0.0402417369,
0.0063071442,
-0.0124885337,
-0.0322116315,
-0.0067122048,
-0.0226139426,
0.0057615922,
-0.0385654867,
-0.0138179548,
0.0214671325,
0.0144914351,
0.004865367,
-0.0054000919,
-0.0233900901,
-0.0404799394,
-0.0522617362,
-0.0277733989,
-0.0504763015,
-0.0602282882,
0.0075217998,
0.0209066197,
-0.0785981417,
-0.0148913274,
3.052679621e-34,
0.0719529614,
-0.0386701711,
-0.0206038542,
0.0272759274,
-0.0007697891,
0.0122464169,
0.0656398907,
0.0103459619,
-0.0135939885,
-0.0629790425,
-0.033813078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01081v1 | CVLUE: A New Benchmark Dataset for Chinese Vision-Language Understanding Evaluation | 2024-07-01T08:35:37 | 2024-07-01T08:35:37 | Yuxuan Wang, Yijun Liu, Fei Yu, Chen Huang, Kexin Li, Zhiguo Wan, Wanxiang Che | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Despite the rapid development of Chinese vision-language models (VLMs), most
existing Chinese vision-language (VL) datasets are constructed on
Western-centric images from existing English VL datasets. The cultural bias in
the images makes these datasets unsuitable for evaluating VLMs in Chinese
culture. To remedy this issue, we present a new Chinese Vision- Language
Understanding Evaluation (CVLUE) benchmark dataset, where the selection of
object categories and images is entirely driven by Chinese native speakers,
ensuring that the source images are representative of Chinese culture. The
benchmark contains four distinct VL tasks ranging from image-text retrieval to
visual question answering, visual grounding and visual dialogue. We present a
detailed statistical analysis of CVLUE and provide a baseline performance
analysis with several open-source multilingual VLMs on CVLUE and its English
counterparts to reveal their performance gap between English and Chinese. Our
in-depth category-level analysis reveals a lack of Chinese cultural knowledge
in existing VLMs. We also find that fine-tuning on Chinese culture-related VL
datasets effectively enhances VLMs' understanding of Chinese culture. | CVLUE: A New Benchmark Dataset for Chinese Vision-Language Understanding Evaluation: Despite the rapid development of Chinese vision-language models (VLMs), most
existing Chinese vision-language (VL) datasets are constructed on
Western-centric images from existing English VL datasets. The cultural bias in
the images makes these datasets unsuitable for evaluating VLMs in Chinese
culture. To remedy this issue, we present a new Chinese Vision- Language
Understanding Evaluation (CVLUE) benchmark dataset, where the selection of
object categories and images is entirely driven by Chinese native speakers,
ensuring that the source images are representative of Chinese culture. The
benchmark contains four distinct VL tasks ranging from image-text retrieval to
visual question answering, visual grounding and visual dialogue. We present a
detailed statistical analysis of CVLUE and provide a baseline performance
analysis with several open-source multilingual VLMs on CVLUE and its English
counterparts to reveal their performance gap between English and Chinese. Our
in-depth category-level analysis reveals a lack of Chinese cultural knowledge
in existing VLMs. We also find that fine-tuning on Chinese culture-related VL
datasets effectively enhances VLMs' understanding of Chinese culture. | [
0.0123209106,
0.0637925714,
0.0018578969,
0.0693915188,
0.0064317882,
0.0458338112,
0.0452792905,
-0.0219555069,
0.0208381414,
-0.0275575165,
-0.0730744377,
-0.0671127737,
0.0331340469,
0.0158367828,
0.0026193638,
-0.0651512966,
0.0349365026,
0.0138164414,
-0.0250362121,
-0.0039974847,
0.0246593729,
-0.0096821217,
0.041257631,
0.0172629505,
-0.0065007182,
-0.0286384337,
0.0303331893,
0.0158841349,
0.0399103835,
-0.01671586,
-0.0022155542,
0.0332265832,
0.043065045,
0.011108974,
0.0000020269,
-0.0213912893,
0.019055374,
-0.0293698143,
0.0062563806,
0.023677744,
0.0347368605,
-0.0525568612,
0.0036340803,
-0.0284087118,
-0.0365252756,
-0.0577011257,
0.064535059,
0.074535735,
0.0290414989,
0.0237188656,
-0.0060836319,
-0.0301718451,
-0.0324880406,
-0.0217620488,
0.0091938106,
-0.0594254918,
0.0191452075,
0.0787720382,
-0.0308778286,
-0.0201493707,
-0.0697591379,
0.0343433507,
0.0418597907,
0.0082716439,
-0.0374580361,
0.0418086983,
-0.0715377927,
-0.02365035,
-0.0012953083,
0.1056727469,
0.0050677052,
-0.0146296527,
-0.0326457694,
0.0051946696,
-0.0238710307,
-0.0114204539,
-0.058810845,
0.0538105965,
-0.0184407625,
0.0113535356,
-0.0318329632,
-0.0121023683,
0.0092562111,
0.01272937,
0.0014119461,
-0.0127466843,
-0.0048708064,
-0.0027051447,
-0.0023040054,
-0.0112161469,
-0.0122749237,
-0.0148013327,
-0.03479366,
-0.011003877,
-0.0078211352,
0.0044165119,
-0.0032603641,
0.0293165576,
-0.0189944282,
-0.0473584458,
0.0128344912,
0.0129435332,
-0.0906475186,
0.0820436925,
-0.0254099276,
0.092071183,
-0.0109643554,
0.0301066861,
-0.0504268818,
-0.055192247,
-0.0193143934,
0.0051491489,
-0.0070808716,
-0.0111994268,
-0.0265383869,
-0.046304509,
-0.0256127529,
-0.0066009881,
-0.0309469383,
-0.0080767786,
-0.0003759114,
0.0196031705,
-0.0126190484,
0.0039274287,
-0.0141836144,
0.0409026369,
-0.0159220975,
-0.0072721811,
-0.0545409843,
-0.0805000961,
0.0140392138,
0.0415349565,
-0.0060214265,
-0.0366433412,
-0.0005587862,
0.0425006412,
-0.0328859612,
-0.0300616547,
-0.0335859731,
0.021264147,
-0.0029040396,
-0.0276001766,
0.0454359055,
-0.0589970946,
0.0030355556,
-0.0135000767,
0.0467840247,
-0.0205978826,
0.0046449145,
-0.0018445001,
0.0018699766,
0.0544685908,
-0.0030742106,
-0.0014734527,
0.0017672965,
0.01838273,
0.0090816077,
0.0931493044,
-0.0170872454,
-0.0036248527,
0.077614218,
-0.0082864147,
-0.015898427,
0.0147975665,
-0.0149850203,
0.0013924448,
-0.0592547879,
0.0304635875,
-0.0044203368,
-0.0198836215,
0.0250452515,
0.0141903404,
-0.0164696071,
-0.0399889871,
0.0439577885,
0.0473407805,
-0.0040643797,
-0.0092746746,
0.0038349198,
-0.0040188483,
-0.0095969792,
0.0063639483,
-0.0481169634,
0.0684933886,
-0.0049578678,
-0.002544814,
-0.0360364094,
0.0269623492,
-0.0684791133,
-0.0456936285,
-0.0251603387,
0.0056169643,
0.0347478352,
0.0545351207,
0.0311824474,
-0.0154201686,
0.034737017,
0.0130764907,
0.0161367692,
-0.0340734795,
-0.0226988494,
-0.0205696747,
0.0304057673,
0.0545319021,
0.0053200796,
0.014155752,
0.0028371029,
0.023101287,
0.0620033257,
0.0654629022,
0.0113670509,
-0.0017128102,
0.0359367579,
-0.0435362458,
-0.0441096909,
0.0144451959,
-0.0226022061,
0.0009229825,
0.0184706114,
0.0059713605,
0.0315302759,
-0.0537021086,
-0.0284215529,
0.0274619292,
-0.0045759971,
0.0050837332,
-0.0113025811,
0.0378350057,
-0.0097740078,
-0.0088874428,
-0.0499945767,
-0.0182822589,
-0.0049486319,
-0.0315208919,
0.0115224803,
0.0383917093,
-0.0455262624,
-0.0182712916,
0.0539279655,
-0.0787029639,
-0.0260508824,
0.0423751511,
-0.052069582,
-0.0187864546,
0.0115111182,
0.0052512605,
-0.0293274168,
-0.0842575133,
-0.0116354311,
-0.0281963814,
0.050739605,
-0.0020652651,
0.0616549626,
-0.0224283934,
0.0295166969,
0.0076575517,
0.0183173474,
0.0506097414,
-0.0299935117,
-0.044131469,
0.0308021456,
0.0049296799,
0.0201179683,
0.0349531546,
0.0422258377,
-0.0391600206,
0.0257378966,
-0.0844932944,
-0.0162089188,
-0.0738551021,
-0.0454788022,
0.0059765591,
-0.0229018182,
-0.0192855578,
-0.0464831106,
-0.0564954169,
0.0266332794,
-0.0318922289,
0.02355529,
0.0166597124,
-0.0167647507,
0.0138809001,
0.0006814023,
-0.0152851669,
0.0384038389,
0.0376826413,
0.0036505982,
-0.0295625087,
-0.0219465792,
-0.0025380775,
-0.0412439555,
0.0270446129,
-0.0398779325,
-0.0428668484,
-0.0039275745,
-0.0011517201,
-0.0068623843,
0.0810423195,
-0.0066604568,
0.0229510069,
0.0208309181,
-0.0120948516,
-0.0209378414,
-0.0114145456,
0.0286887418,
-0.0375199467,
-0.0164010692,
-0.0441360511,
-0.0434494056,
0.0336762108,
0.004151925,
0.0013073878,
-0.0557558239,
-0.0107101323,
-0.0210359786,
-0.0376364589,
-0.0731838271,
0.0547320656,
0.0039279773,
0.0660706758,
-0.0701798722,
-0.0499423482,
0.0594151542,
-0.0243589766,
-0.0541695878,
-0.0164450016,
0.0035872911,
-0.0487525649,
0.0701426193,
0.0060776765,
0.0341215134,
-0.0153038139,
-0.0050802045,
-0.0543589965,
-0.008505797,
-0.0057948609,
-0.0122230286,
0.0648055151,
-0.02623,
0.0018280882,
-0.0545348786,
0.0015256777,
-0.0373215415,
0.0080413818,
-0.0147443255,
0.0487194024,
-0.0365601964,
0.0083195325,
0.0134833623,
0.029786896,
0.0277028214,
0.0009918709,
-0.0015976183,
0.0306069553,
0.0248492248,
-0.0147907184,
0.0634449944,
0.0394283086,
-0.0206722766,
-0.039549496,
0.0491431355,
0.0489490181,
0.0593839213,
-0.0074301143,
-0.0150996596,
0.0443901159,
0.0295258313,
0.050161384,
-0.0356100537,
-0.0088259559,
0.0616935082,
-0.0334518626,
0.0151784187,
0.0897526816,
0.0030142902,
-0.0337054543,
-0.0253838841,
-0.0026772502,
-0.0099382829,
0.0596171878,
-0.013813396,
-0.1087417156,
-0.0204081144,
-0.0273011997,
0.0048214425,
0.0362721421,
0.0028244506,
-0.0109000793,
-0.1021910235,
0.072550565,
0.0045465333,
-0.0563326366,
-0.0582783036,
0.0034065042,
-0.0073528481,
-0.0246087313,
0.0409742296,
-0.0217974726,
0.0027800628,
-0.040232297,
-0.0101553071,
-0.0049133296,
-0.0474116467,
0.0606363192,
-0.036889337,
-0.0059108408,
0.0407661423,
0.0089175086,
0.0072925985,
-0.0529865511,
0.008532621,
-0.0322519355,
-0.0101569332,
-0.0032114859,
0.0411978625,
-0.0021276786,
-0.0641097426,
0.0336469933,
0.0175772551,
-0.0150234904,
-0.0057523828,
0.0009137215,
-0.0177268423,
-0.0037651777,
-0.0072985399,
-0.0066476921,
0.0275319889,
-0.0216944162,
0.0723465979,
0.0346013606,
-0.0376522914,
0.0028101131,
-0.0095859561,
-0.0568264201,
-0.0342383236,
-0.0328708552,
0.0601553805,
-0.0264673717,
-0.0175252128,
-0.0783643052,
-0.0367272533,
0.0051360531,
-0.0046362914,
-0.007458176,
-0.0213686712,
-0.022958044,
0.0325331949,
-0.0736912116,
0.0694907457,
-0.0024179812,
0.0243913401,
-0.0210771821,
-0.0147940842,
0.0205891505,
-0.0539523475,
0.0065123634,
0.0120824054,
-0.0596078224,
-0.0131366951,
-0.0236726906,
0.0300576407,
-0.0028507188,
0.0235971734,
0.0320484973,
-0.0210888088,
0.0028567377,
0.0046757516,
0.0536040179,
0.0098095685,
-0.0133694084,
-0.0347362012,
-0.0005652883,
0.0258053653,
-0.0457635522,
0.0318755507,
0.0390383676,
0.0215998478,
-0.0365540981,
0.0175013468,
0.0059460592,
0.0198261682,
0.0347123481,
-0.0102085685,
0.0233420916,
-0.0402344912,
0.0396919772,
0.0083521269,
-0.0335755944,
-0.0486589298,
-0.0341130607,
0.0338374041,
-0.0059246072,
0.0107687945,
0.0457440093,
-0.0018729641,
0.0008933159,
-0.0431142487,
0.0045723221,
0.029820336,
0.008878733,
-0.0440985933,
0.029647151,
-0.0178695992,
0.0135378027,
0.0014761459,
0.0633829981,
0.0190952923,
0.1017087474,
0.0137668569,
0.0040943911,
0.0010717965,
0.0183227211,
-0.0268104449,
-0.0703803152,
0.0097985966,
0.0197639782,
0.0678624585,
-0.0425114296,
0.0187444836,
-0.0067644669,
-0.0003798526,
-0.0429855958,
0.0145892687,
0.0181897506,
-0.0605843887,
0.0519666374,
0.0218171161,
-0.006309812,
-0.0340182893,
0.0752927437,
0.0348168053,
0.0119852619,
0.0034449578,
0.0212429967,
-0.0272617098,
-0.0224026721,
0.068883568,
-0.0101202093,
-0.0011238809,
0.0538562462,
-0.0449145809,
-0.0803091675,
-0.0221715067,
0.0109197479,
-0.0080922861,
0.0637537614,
0.0366249606,
0.0764605701,
0.0148196993,
-0.0030676734,
-0.0498229638,
-0.0289816633,
-0.0270842668,
0.0198748335,
0.0153070083,
-6.256838311e-33,
-0.0384235643,
0.0101156626,
0.0069632512,
0.0027790854,
0.0120865805,
0.0271420907,
-0.037840914,
0.0091700694,
-0.074109979,
0.0104598766,
0.0178953148,
0.02601883,
0.0050725201,
0.061943233,
-0.0303464551,
-0.0178378522,
-0.0001154552,
0.0022273115,
0.010785399,
-0.0189767368,
0.037308,
0.0260839406,
0.0738186613,
-0.0721568763,
0.0035618562,
0.0386330299,
0.0245722327,
0.0254741646,
0.0327169262,
0.088954702,
-0.0094114374,
0.0729547217,
0.039358288,
-0.0086716013,
-0.0460953042,
-0.0188310575,
-0.1119456589,
-0.0026353882,
0.0241780449,
0.0852765292,
-0.0268267374,
0.029671777,
-0.009688843,
-0.0331994444,
0.0288276039,
-0.0355009697,
0.0582303703,
-0.0418057367,
-0.0219080821,
0.0133000985,
0.0089529371,
0.0179620963,
0.0019477872,
0.0039396416,
0.0565726794,
0.025907319,
-0.0069745057,
0.052940771,
-0.0481549464,
0.0029187493,
-0.0110937543,
0.03018835,
0.0866863802,
0.0688837394,
0.029576648,
0.0661632642,
0.0533296205,
-0.0261919629,
-0.0121476408,
-0.0528815277,
0.0569877252,
0.0318068676,
0.0190907083,
0.088652879,
0.0130490996,
0.0204877183,
-0.063071169,
0.0078944312,
-0.0202935264,
0.0474167839,
-0.0140970098,
0.0103125833,
0.0049832156,
-0.0113344872,
-0.0369584113,
0.0169819687,
-0.0563886017,
-0.0075507909,
0.0475209802,
0.0053564222,
-0.0391069129,
0.0022162218,
0.0565224402,
-0.0611863472,
0.0036385381,
0.0661743432,
0.0181031059,
-0.0037757505,
0.0247700363,
0.0109043177,
-0.0606329441,
-0.0300020818,
0.0241638832,
0.0140377674,
-0.0223259795,
0.0078727547,
0.0472446606,
0.0067242305,
-0.0337092355,
-0.0064336304,
-0.0340764672,
-0.043688383,
-0.0107831452,
0.0547205023,
0.0074802702,
0.015306145,
-0.0614930727,
0.0281040277,
0.0096165035,
-0.0169790871,
-0.0344411656,
-0.0694837868,
-0.018672552,
0.0311366674,
-0.0394058637,
0.0079306914,
-0.0400423966,
-0.0082892515,
0.0387264825,
-0.0326740034,
-0.0023269616,
0.0390167944,
2.533e-7,
0.0522777662,
-0.0227972288,
0.0341725014,
0.0689925402,
0.0161772575,
0.0223673135,
-0.0371450298,
0.0168593675,
-0.0063229501,
-0.0477423109,
0.0086842608,
0.0657239482,
0.0752817914,
0.0018525968,
-0.0345344096,
0.0425393656,
-0.0183761213,
0.0038773513,
-0.0168400388,
0.0118975341,
0.0098187132,
0.0979282036,
-0.0602099337,
0.0006148083,
0.0309305172,
-0.0763303339,
0.0744099021,
-0.0378275774,
0.0199066438,
0.0063497387,
-0.0249560308,
0.0348129906,
-0.0118242232,
0.0160979666,
0.0029822304,
0.0024992069,
0.0642543733,
0.0210845489,
-0.0077118189,
-0.0371360853,
-0.0397502854,
0.0393780097,
-0.0176391453,
-0.0773573369,
0.0762071908,
-0.0062243459,
-0.0116493804,
-0.0066258069,
-0.0019930953,
0.000103769,
0.0493796356,
-0.0070250989,
-0.023963064,
0.0335261002,
0.0177482665,
-0.0368708111,
-0.0079005715,
-0.0587270595,
-0.0282740891,
-0.029465545,
-0.0273952726,
-0.0272748936,
-0.0109317936,
-0.0313485339,
-0.0203843862,
0.0400958434,
-0.047887776,
1.555978339e-34,
0.0159702897,
-0.0097694006,
0.003009042,
0.0267437566,
-0.0048971758,
-0.0577937178,
-0.0228556041,
-0.0242996234,
-0.0381750651,
-0.01771155,
0.0061224555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01080v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01080v2 | Face4RAG: Factual Consistency Evaluation for Retrieval Augmented Generation in Chinese | 2024-07-01T08:35:04 | 2024-07-03T12:49:34 | Yunqi Xu, Tianchi Cai, Jiyan Jiang, Xierui Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The prevailing issue of factual inconsistency errors in conventional
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) motivates the study of Factual Consistency
Evaluation (FCE). Despite the various FCE methods proposed earlier, these
methods are evaluated on datasets generated by specific Large Language Models
(LLMs). Without a comprehensive benchmark, it remains unexplored how these FCE
methods perform on other LLMs with different error distributions or even unseen
error types, as these methods may fail to detect the error types generated by
other LLMs. To fill this gap, in this paper, we propose the first comprehensive
FCE benchmark \emph{Face4RAG} for RAG independent of the underlying LLM. Our
benchmark consists of a synthetic dataset built upon a carefully designed
typology for factuality inconsistency error and a real-world dataset
constructed from six commonly used LLMs, enabling evaluation of FCE methods on
specific error types or real-world error distributions. On the proposed
benchmark, we discover the failure of existing FCE methods to detect the
logical fallacy, which refers to a mismatch of logic structures between the
answer and the retrieved reference. To fix this issue, we further propose a new
method called \emph{L-Face4RAG} with two novel designs of logic-preserving
answer decomposition and fact-logic FCE. Extensive experiments show L-Face4RAG
substantially outperforms previous methods for factual inconsistency detection
on a wide range of tasks, notably beyond the RAG task from which it is
originally motivated. Both the benchmark and our proposed method are publicly
available.\footnote{\url{https://huggingface.co/datasets/yq27/Face4RAG}\label{link_face4rag}} | Face4RAG: Factual Consistency Evaluation for Retrieval Augmented Generation in Chinese: The prevailing issue of factual inconsistency errors in conventional
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) motivates the study of Factual Consistency
Evaluation (FCE). Despite the various FCE methods proposed earlier, these
methods are evaluated on datasets generated by specific Large Language Models
(LLMs). Without a comprehensive benchmark, it remains unexplored how these FCE
methods perform on other LLMs with different error distributions or even unseen
error types, as these methods may fail to detect the error types generated by
other LLMs. To fill this gap, in this paper, we propose the first comprehensive
FCE benchmark \emph{Face4RAG} for RAG independent of the underlying LLM. Our
benchmark consists of a synthetic dataset built upon a carefully designed
typology for factuality inconsistency error and a real-world dataset
constructed from six commonly used LLMs, enabling evaluation of FCE methods on
specific error types or real-world error distributions. On the proposed
benchmark, we discover the failure of existing FCE methods to detect the
logical fallacy, which refers to a mismatch of logic structures between the
answer and the retrieved reference. To fix this issue, we further propose a new
method called \emph{L-Face4RAG} with two novel designs of logic-preserving
answer decomposition and fact-logic FCE. Extensive experiments show L-Face4RAG
substantially outperforms previous methods for factual inconsistency detection
on a wide range of tasks, notably beyond the RAG task from which it is
originally motivated. Both the benchmark and our proposed method are publicly
available.\footnote{\url{https://huggingface.co/datasets/yq27/Face4RAG}\label{link_face4rag}} | [
0.0438135639,
0.044620771,
0.00684739,
0.0407396629,
-0.023905728,
-0.0096820937,
0.0049545132,
0.0036101779,
0.0125143938,
-0.0555725358,
0.0308667533,
-0.0451815538,
0.036194779,
0.0072070286,
0.012840217,
0.0018352357,
0.0847528353,
0.0458117463,
0.018612599,
-0.0120508559,
0.0249932129,
0.0090565104,
0.0022753417,
0.0116999503,
-0.0414547287,
-0.0149400672,
-0.0156024443,
0.0350538902,
0.0372255221,
-0.0094199441,
0.0172493272,
0.0383431055,
-0.0126382811,
0.0817965642,
0.0000020967,
-0.052362293,
-0.0444832817,
-0.0003585078,
-0.030297257,
0.0454690866,
0.0309903417,
0.0323481783,
-0.023828052,
0.0277690385,
-0.0253805723,
-0.0675452948,
0.0238012057,
0.0858620852,
0.0882033706,
0.0824216828,
0.0151620433,
-0.0191798285,
0.010341255,
-0.0074370163,
0.0077606067,
-0.0189196225,
0.0157015864,
0.0398861133,
-0.0397331864,
0.0105983596,
-0.0161216855,
0.0227674432,
0.0205482636,
0.0126207154,
-0.0131038204,
0.0191262476,
-0.101874575,
0.0084834425,
0.0177800395,
0.0574530885,
0.0324019529,
-0.0370671637,
-0.0122057861,
0.018664768,
0.011632842,
0.0303079616,
0.0156411678,
0.01140342,
-0.0559201427,
0.0119083179,
0.03278419,
-0.0424268357,
0.0148998536,
0.0084955571,
-0.0285995323,
0.0533212833,
0.0176853873,
-0.0547740422,
-0.0172405355,
0.0047358233,
-0.0131075215,
-0.0329193473,
0.0005301583,
0.0000350294,
-0.0450533815,
0.0023071759,
-0.0569165535,
-0.0152165657,
0.0311948396,
-0.0422764346,
0.0076573952,
0.0131070232,
-0.0633633435,
0.0187879559,
-0.0388419926,
0.0795995891,
0.0057624793,
-0.0068121888,
-0.0507156812,
-0.0065248781,
-0.0009475301,
-0.009013922,
-0.0266902521,
0.0442046188,
-0.0261295084,
-0.0024445534,
-0.0527629443,
-0.0200109873,
-0.037363328,
0.0361282639,
-0.0145799099,
0.0050955596,
-0.0436028689,
0.0186115149,
-0.0643505156,
0.0548293665,
-0.0143835517,
0.0205700118,
0.020453779,
-0.0729276761,
-0.0170735493,
0.005959596,
-0.0040923613,
-0.0023303921,
0.0071261856,
-0.0025182748,
-0.0246515293,
0.0052918382,
-0.0520259775,
-0.0401454866,
-0.0343743712,
-0.0658896789,
-0.0183041841,
-0.1006995887,
0.0211959966,
-0.0289891716,
-0.0154518746,
-0.0159331001,
0.0178660434,
0.0439473316,
0.0005908831,
0.0406112298,
-0.004823836,
-0.0111775929,
0.0344317146,
0.0113626197,
0.0129938209,
0.0232749842,
-0.0077683423,
0.0005709816,
0.0752346516,
0.035450045,
0.0018603666,
-0.0148878647,
0.04220419,
0.0034212652,
0.0156669617,
0.0065221293,
-0.0094478801,
0.0028499491,
0.0180390105,
0.0728047341,
-0.0362840183,
-0.0266220309,
0.011752082,
-0.0469447635,
0.0481947958,
-0.011448361,
0.0195364822,
-0.0084374174,
0.0258860942,
0.0549922399,
-0.0326041579,
-0.0078903083,
-0.0589860901,
0.0525456145,
0.0578693449,
0.0492614247,
-0.0189368613,
-0.0599326156,
-0.0251541305,
0.037527319,
-0.0199384075,
-0.003483146,
0.0034326219,
0.003497611,
-0.0165793523,
0.0557879433,
0.0123825632,
-0.0890322253,
0.0128420228,
-0.0284699537,
0.0284788162,
0.0397168323,
0.0691831633,
-0.0107296268,
-0.0344716534,
0.0182552692,
-0.0067172949,
0.0471641906,
0.0577890202,
-0.0153775988,
-0.0242456477,
-0.0451076739,
-0.0082228482,
0.0107501885,
0.0237976816,
-0.0272983611,
0.0396212488,
0.0188274961,
0.0403184444,
-0.0419832766,
-0.0178910289,
0.0210907254,
0.0011120228,
-0.0125703802,
0.0009455894,
-0.0013440319,
0.0115984604,
0.0349845663,
-0.0371882804,
0.0167396124,
0.0282641202,
0.0068590012,
-0.0366748907,
-0.0205951817,
-0.02467319,
-0.0655670464,
0.0736301094,
-0.0189441014,
-0.0074118851,
0.0188406557,
-0.0653116107,
-0.0441198647,
-0.0174911842,
-0.0521479435,
-0.0191831924,
-0.0802421421,
0.0557825491,
0.0147583261,
0.0017749741,
-0.0168103203,
0.1042034626,
-0.0193266887,
0.0246884525,
0.0034748861,
0.0241207909,
0.0305199549,
-0.0716153085,
-0.0285856314,
0.0227518883,
0.0060830368,
0.0390349366,
0.0425983034,
0.0088986885,
-0.0552895106,
-0.0111809094,
-0.0638089553,
0.011781496,
-0.0527330972,
0.0121617857,
0.0265089385,
-0.0040286677,
-0.0032205898,
-0.0046113115,
-0.0386310443,
-0.009680517,
0.0240936726,
0.0143043576,
0.038172394,
-0.0143250544,
0.0148026878,
-0.0349148698,
-0.0178876966,
-0.0114363451,
0.0068651377,
0.0094638159,
0.0209336597,
-0.0650312677,
0.0100380341,
-0.0895596147,
0.0198019817,
-0.0085286712,
-0.0127100581,
0.0175167341,
-0.0116094379,
0.0302791297,
0.0173864122,
0.046493493,
-0.0123564331,
0.0456703082,
-0.0239037145,
-0.0536175258,
0.032696642,
-0.0197153911,
-0.0220310483,
0.0134782447,
-0.0787802115,
-0.014251437,
-0.0370826684,
0.0466428883,
-0.017037278,
-0.0339361243,
0.0160159264,
-0.0034550654,
-0.0142769283,
-0.0044663409,
0.016907651,
-0.0214246493,
0.0235238504,
-0.0230894908,
-0.0010624463,
0.0792320222,
-0.0539614744,
0.0207047276,
-0.0788039342,
0.0271863807,
-0.0291666463,
0.0239299182,
-0.0203564614,
0.0145608857,
0.0019274739,
0.0021867878,
-0.0434621125,
0.0035252322,
0.0300499462,
-0.0753949583,
0.0745671988,
-0.0377583094,
0.0186213758,
-0.0131054642,
-0.0177139565,
-0.0680858493,
-0.0518192351,
0.0279306471,
-0.0095223179,
-0.0579243936,
-0.0304719117,
-0.0125188408,
-0.0420115292,
0.0456987098,
0.0321455635,
-0.0124242855,
-0.009386546,
-0.0093531478,
0.025274707,
0.0723287165,
0.0562235713,
0.0446516722,
0.0078752358,
-0.0000670773,
0.0830459446,
0.044211477,
0.0118607469,
0.011385615,
-0.0167426821,
0.0113271913,
-0.0113941412,
-0.031999927,
0.0017581943,
0.0261137001,
-0.0694362,
-0.0190301444,
0.0833795369,
0.0396219306,
0.0359844118,
-0.0209525898,
-0.0318619944,
0.018206099,
0.0094197448,
0.0060020811,
-0.080732435,
-0.0251041707,
-0.0024424859,
0.0529222973,
-0.0169757009,
0.0073649515,
0.0022644696,
-0.1391215771,
0.0518135391,
0.0281553231,
-0.0049412944,
-0.0501782894,
-0.0180562064,
0.0185753275,
0.0109510385,
0.0472711362,
0.0657899007,
-0.005509221,
0.0066062859,
-0.0155624961,
0.0316157863,
-0.0424329154,
0.0052716415,
-0.0329446495,
0.0162782706,
0.0406381376,
0.0267009269,
0.0049857246,
-0.0414442942,
-0.0083512487,
-0.0251320042,
-0.0426625609,
-0.0270198081,
0.0542310253,
0.0058052954,
0.0091308048,
-0.0222034678,
0.0026002033,
0.020259127,
0.0081019429,
0.0141777061,
0.0392587148,
-0.0203331318,
0.0022508935,
-0.02074489,
0.0251135062,
-0.0230134465,
0.0861458108,
0.0063119428,
0.0261660386,
-0.0251415353,
-0.0282486565,
0.0290889721,
-0.0404508263,
0.0001123478,
0.0455578417,
-0.0297070239,
-0.0023389342,
-0.104670465,
-0.0445244573,
-0.0459140278,
0.013734838,
-0.0389742032,
-0.0077631562,
0.0107353721,
-0.0091302935,
-0.0395546816,
-0.0116758356,
-0.0183802024,
0.0147775235,
-0.0129518621,
0.0271498878,
-0.0111750625,
-0.0357864313,
0.0098286113,
0.0201916825,
-0.0109665105,
-0.0444671884,
0.0154901519,
-0.0045501939,
0.0097717848,
0.056395527,
-0.0090545956,
0.0290032607,
0.033768449,
0.0510344766,
0.0018369807,
0.0611014888,
0.0217314046,
-0.0604202189,
-0.0195556507,
0.0052816486,
-0.0528488196,
-0.0205158908,
-0.0197368748,
0.0941724479,
-0.0059317066,
-0.0244083814,
0.0453367382,
0.073315531,
0.03201399,
-0.0004654199,
0.0114230728,
-0.031069858,
0.0358903557,
-0.040336784,
-0.0598311871,
-0.0137684075,
0.0184669159,
-0.0012070986,
0.0008159009,
0.0144630745,
0.0078360355,
-0.0463446043,
0.0765714273,
0.0041859937,
-0.0377263874,
-0.0010266409,
0.0381795727,
-0.0036648605,
-0.0370352715,
-0.0324415863,
-0.0164135974,
0.0194333047,
0.0560602471,
-0.0191166569,
0.0801333264,
0.0384896472,
-0.0148216281,
-0.0070695239,
-0.0154495733,
-0.0707509965,
0.0155416019,
-0.0339492932,
-0.0117823351,
0.0391999409,
0.0104610194,
0.0766801536,
-0.0202939883,
-0.0186585747,
-0.0569422506,
-0.0007938266,
0.0410007238,
-0.0461123399,
0.0073008197,
0.0140307928,
-0.0147788953,
0.0042639547,
0.0461563878,
-0.0191914476,
0.0319218412,
-0.0351789407,
-0.037624862,
-0.0212240126,
-0.0824888572,
-0.0491185337,
-0.0030248405,
-0.0308977962,
-0.0269016791,
-0.0988350213,
-0.0521989316,
0.0313953757,
0.0456792042,
0.0230299253,
-0.0082711251,
-0.0003878966,
0.0855460092,
0.0268861372,
-0.0235129334,
-0.0452300496,
0.0290981662,
-0.047699362,
-0.0030810072,
-0.0331767835,
-6.490638995e-33,
-0.0526640192,
-0.0322681479,
0.0201177076,
-0.0646686926,
-0.0302541349,
0.0382024273,
-0.0301953517,
-0.0022261171,
-0.0472038686,
0.0070642801,
0.0064871693,
0.0303014759,
0.0109470338,
0.0281294547,
-0.0348604955,
-0.0100602033,
0.0495712012,
0.0231227838,
-0.0453974679,
0.0029016717,
0.0768748522,
-0.0235656332,
0.036984127,
-0.0611638203,
0.0256151408,
-0.0083908802,
-0.011659828,
0.0335877463,
-0.0598494671,
0.0796267837,
0.0294377748,
0.0709515065,
0.0146433022,
0.0080113849,
-0.0069264579,
-0.0402957164,
-0.0948571563,
-0.0554745533,
0.0262100268,
0.0024417255,
-0.0254223384,
0.020758817,
0.0136518721,
-0.0270271637,
-0.0099681858,
-0.0255302731,
0.0222450234,
-0.0362078324,
0.0007360428,
0.0047100894,
-0.0227124393,
0.0280859899,
0.0546998382,
0.0299646351,
-0.0586832128,
0.0568157732,
0.0188249815,
-0.0084400158,
-0.0954632238,
-0.0128014488,
0.0056445105,
0.0389278941,
0.045038376,
0.0028317093,
-0.0175429303,
0.0566349998,
0.007746432,
-0.0183863509,
-0.0646499842,
-0.011572768,
0.0211725254,
0.0089484416,
0.0370170772,
0.1048571169,
0.028181592,
-0.000065254,
-0.0523485728,
0.0503648967,
0.0046748361,
0.0601074882,
-0.0041315951,
-0.0273136348,
-0.0586434864,
-0.0110692214,
-0.0343816131,
0.0570476763,
-0.0431036502,
-0.0174444932,
0.0356647894,
0.0309206247,
-0.0395360962,
-0.0161946807,
0.0255696457,
-0.0168106724,
-0.0052241627,
0.0493793003,
-0.0556554683,
-0.0184076391,
-0.0176741201,
0.0469235145,
-0.0177692771,
0.0071954331,
0.0283762924,
0.015055282,
-0.0430287644,
0.0050146291,
0.039118167,
0.0060729221,
-0.0405288152,
0.041524332,
-0.0001730294,
0.0063257827,
-0.0467726775,
-0.0530308411,
0.0308187138,
0.0124397501,
-0.0120916087,
-0.006054454,
0.0429347605,
0.0410379171,
-0.0721328482,
-0.027749341,
0.0082298899,
0.0359320082,
-0.0072628977,
0.0616068356,
-0.0254405104,
0.0200407989,
0.01183319,
-0.0331067033,
-0.0024137436,
0.0273455717,
2.707e-7,
0.0159064457,
-0.0100713726,
0.0497111455,
0.0528166033,
-0.0147359772,
0.0456242487,
-0.0026422339,
0.0191823691,
0.0096864626,
0.0093652699,
-0.0100128613,
0.0361694731,
0.0524485707,
0.0388963558,
-0.0192669425,
0.0109331822,
-0.0471815616,
-0.047226768,
-0.0289166756,
-0.0128830448,
0.0594692752,
0.060096927,
0.0061861333,
-0.0303393751,
0.0029122881,
-0.0150618749,
0.0404737107,
0.0609209687,
-0.0467915237,
0.0306169167,
0.0582873486,
0.0233866405,
0.0314802974,
-0.0085164858,
-0.01553779,
0.0047993697,
0.0208766367,
0.0247747637,
0.0280071609,
-0.0378417931,
-0.0408083126,
-0.0096461903,
0.0006606167,
-0.0229861215,
0.0469952151,
0.0482517667,
0.0266837738,
-0.0233239196,
-0.0587705187,
0.0419195443,
0.0047990503,
-0.0087301983,
-0.0538786687,
0.029966753,
-0.0000925724,
0.0247736927,
-0.0079101846,
-0.0212364681,
-0.0446354151,
0.0154546676,
-0.0259914082,
-0.0739909858,
0.0263603963,
0.0313023627,
-0.0098658614,
-0.0511120185,
-0.006109253,
2.793726251e-34,
0.0307802241,
-0.0126369903,
0.0015908026,
-0.0180784892,
0.050275065,
-0.0032591771,
-0.0468979664,
-0.0068743108,
-0.0229137018,
-0.0317461677,
-0.0370832942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01067v1 | Human-like object concept representations emerge naturally in multimodal large language models | 2024-07-01T08:17:19 | 2024-07-01T08:17:19 | Changde Du, Kaicheng Fu, Bincheng Wen, Yi Sun, Jie Peng, Wei Wei, Ying Gao, Shengpei Wang, Chuncheng Zhang, Jinpeng Li, Shuang Qiu, Le Chang, Huiguang He | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG | The conceptualization and categorization of natural objects in the human mind
have long intrigued cognitive scientists and neuroscientists, offering crucial
insights into human perception and cognition. Recently, the rapid development
of Large Language Models (LLMs) has raised the attractive question of whether
these models can also develop human-like object representations through
exposure to vast amounts of linguistic and multimodal data. In this study, we
combined behavioral and neuroimaging analysis methods to uncover how the object
concept representations in LLMs correlate with those of humans. By collecting
large-scale datasets of 4.7 million triplet judgments from LLM and Multimodal
LLM (MLLM), we were able to derive low-dimensional embeddings that capture the
underlying similarity structure of 1,854 natural objects. The resulting
66-dimensional embeddings were found to be highly stable and predictive, and
exhibited semantic clustering akin to human mental representations.
Interestingly, the interpretability of the dimensions underlying these
embeddings suggests that LLM and MLLM have developed human-like conceptual
representations of natural objects. Further analysis demonstrated strong
alignment between the identified model embeddings and neural activity patterns
in many functionally defined brain ROIs (e.g., EBA, PPA, RSC and FFA). This
provides compelling evidence that the object representations in LLMs, while not
identical to those in the human, share fundamental commonalities that reflect
key schemas of human conceptual knowledge. This study advances our
understanding of machine intelligence and informs the development of more
human-like artificial cognitive systems. | Human-like object concept representations emerge naturally in multimodal large language models: The conceptualization and categorization of natural objects in the human mind
have long intrigued cognitive scientists and neuroscientists, offering crucial
insights into human perception and cognition. Recently, the rapid development
of Large Language Models (LLMs) has raised the attractive question of whether
these models can also develop human-like object representations through
exposure to vast amounts of linguistic and multimodal data. In this study, we
combined behavioral and neuroimaging analysis methods to uncover how the object
concept representations in LLMs correlate with those of humans. By collecting
large-scale datasets of 4.7 million triplet judgments from LLM and Multimodal
LLM (MLLM), we were able to derive low-dimensional embeddings that capture the
underlying similarity structure of 1,854 natural objects. The resulting
66-dimensional embeddings were found to be highly stable and predictive, and
exhibited semantic clustering akin to human mental representations.
Interestingly, the interpretability of the dimensions underlying these
embeddings suggests that LLM and MLLM have developed human-like conceptual
representations of natural objects. Further analysis demonstrated strong
alignment between the identified model embeddings and neural activity patterns
in many functionally defined brain ROIs (e.g., EBA, PPA, RSC and FFA). This
provides compelling evidence that the object representations in LLMs, while not
identical to those in the human, share fundamental commonalities that reflect
key schemas of human conceptual knowledge. This study advances our
understanding of machine intelligence and informs the development of more
human-like artificial cognitive systems. | [
0.0258043278,
0.0688139871,
-0.0468487442,
0.0615870357,
-0.0024308546,
0.0267887581,
-0.0153251616,
0.0194976199,
-0.010228198,
-0.0549963452,
-0.0618379638,
-0.0256603621,
0.0006628076,
0.0526395254,
0.0747093633,
-0.0258593541,
0.0182751995,
-0.0055590956,
-0.0101741236,
0.0127267437,
-0.0102444282,
-0.0114878835,
0.0087703718,
0.0237533189,
-0.0077129519,
-0.0168493018,
-0.0039142552,
-0.0613699704,
-0.0121585885,
-0.0240717903,
-0.0506500863,
0.0504020043,
0.0746342987,
0.0042529535,
0.0000016893,
-0.0606295541,
0.059986867,
-0.0077000819,
-0.0036990799,
0.0156034753,
0.0356099606,
-0.0025231268,
0.0170747247,
-0.0622624755,
-0.0109485751,
0.0049916673,
0.0517950878,
0.0758419409,
-0.0000094736,
0.0119578056,
-0.019503573,
-0.0336152725,
0.0479803234,
-0.0075259572,
0.0277940948,
0.0084015066,
0.0176328272,
0.0345615074,
-0.0091597503,
0.0146516068,
-0.039270848,
-0.0174802262,
0.0090347389,
0.0391843356,
0.0032629077,
0.0725991726,
0.0037174535,
-0.0345893577,
0.0207850505,
0.0749094933,
-0.01959146,
-0.0380989201,
-0.0159626585,
0.0262249094,
0.004827919,
-0.0054560914,
-0.068531096,
0.051981207,
0.021412475,
0.0356533751,
-0.0113452924,
-0.0407724157,
0.022723306,
0.01114331,
0.0122325271,
-0.0153170908,
0.0010144422,
0.0043579633,
0.0140372925,
0.0069468487,
-0.0634390265,
-0.0101324059,
-0.0154478699,
-0.0093423612,
0.0108504854,
-0.0116936043,
-0.0016217489,
0.0122342212,
0.0246792324,
-0.0241881981,
0.0497736782,
0.0381792895,
-0.0540861636,
0.0200815387,
-0.0333558768,
0.0691492334,
-0.0615382865,
0.041948799,
-0.0431774519,
0.0156775285,
-0.0705823004,
-0.0227860827,
0.0445052236,
0.0343304239,
-0.0187598132,
-0.0587374158,
-0.0115836672,
0.0139910253,
-0.0212379154,
-0.0339365005,
-0.028045537,
0.0532229431,
0.0244686473,
0.0450156182,
-0.0584953092,
-0.0033178427,
-0.0111756884,
0.0385512561,
-0.0449159294,
-0.0326123796,
0.0041652173,
0.0330050215,
-0.0178700909,
-0.0298322476,
-0.0219867192,
0.0806915462,
-0.028155826,
-0.0513423756,
-0.0058496036,
-0.0216566157,
0.0165896639,
-0.0140410364,
0.0603686571,
-0.0326178297,
0.0189399272,
0.0137518104,
0.0044570249,
-0.0519593246,
-0.0266231503,
-0.0066571059,
-0.0163586829,
0.0638557225,
0.0057701636,
-0.0016532007,
0.0357757546,
0.021695517,
0.0001494846,
-0.0078619095,
0.0245900452,
0.0079772463,
-0.026309371,
0.0035883565,
-0.0380138084,
0.0178477634,
-0.0128867393,
-0.0403853767,
-0.0571786314,
-0.0259515494,
0.0047872588,
0.0521341637,
0.0884809792,
0.0318001993,
-0.0365388729,
-0.0533008501,
0.0673638731,
0.0770397261,
-0.0669136047,
0.0289775468,
0.0222539436,
-0.0132648703,
0.0102342162,
-0.0284588467,
-0.0724003464,
0.0644745454,
0.0048278803,
-0.0160005465,
0.0067052636,
0.0289712474,
-0.0223887656,
0.0465559475,
0.0002192214,
-0.0193756223,
0.0048565292,
-0.0110533489,
0.0335492268,
-0.0440879762,
0.0087616239,
0.0138889104,
0.0206512008,
0.0126914615,
-0.010638997,
-0.0495516844,
0.0403644443,
-0.0076741008,
-0.0089275036,
0.0001264908,
0.0149928853,
0.0131945899,
-0.0026086888,
0.0532998182,
0.0135222729,
0.0008669288,
0.0082188202,
0.0257020202,
0.00330105,
-0.0321684778,
-0.0078483596,
0.0107071465,
-0.0313498341,
-0.0442696027,
-0.0219315719,
-0.0305191614,
0.0083198361,
0.0434427597,
-0.0084048938,
0.0226498973,
-0.0637813881,
0.0012059109,
0.0390775353,
-0.0365975276,
0.0010427936,
0.0260140635,
0.0070839715,
-0.0189108942,
0.0002427836,
-0.0016483157,
0.0069870865,
0.0085521275,
0.0398662798,
-0.0006244371,
-0.040313378,
0.0268800482,
0.0028805139,
0.0189789142,
0.0328601412,
-0.0546265021,
0.0372433513,
-0.0623466112,
-0.0149303125,
-0.0342990719,
0.0409620479,
-0.0157294143,
0.0582633391,
-0.0126321344,
-0.0078977775,
-0.0005032282,
-0.0284254663,
0.0398707092,
-0.0282065291,
-0.0219232626,
0.0071551702,
-0.0142940283,
-0.0058689578,
-0.0252107345,
-0.0275710691,
-0.0535108484,
0.0239712149,
-0.0522978082,
-0.0211464856,
0.0864849761,
-0.0263018273,
-0.0014782444,
-0.0513719991,
0.0107890656,
0.0126925735,
0.0001298782,
0.0142610492,
0.0041277669,
0.0703937188,
0.016140312,
-0.0500316843,
-0.0302273314,
-0.0171181746,
0.0097131105,
-0.042433776,
0.0918263569,
-0.0128473649,
-0.0163265374,
-0.0411544032,
0.0442743376,
-0.0531506538,
0.021912735,
-0.0034576615,
-0.0344090909,
0.0474113822,
0.0086090947,
0.0581367947,
0.0902703926,
-0.0116349673,
0.056921415,
0.0937846228,
0.0060323174,
-0.0337021723,
-0.060810715,
0.0037833326,
-0.0042284881,
-0.0028694402,
0.0028415401,
0.0035207935,
0.0578015707,
0.0437519848,
-0.0113343,
-0.0080721201,
0.0513397194,
0.0051077898,
-0.0650805756,
-0.0411880054,
-0.0310333185,
-0.031976454,
0.0523829311,
-0.0450233519,
-0.0317206793,
0.0461692028,
-0.0002236879,
0.0111157307,
0.0386016965,
0.0021940421,
0.0004993318,
0.0416333601,
0.0675716177,
0.0336589515,
-0.039074257,
0.0078283986,
-0.0691569075,
0.0201670006,
-0.0448153168,
0.0035361364,
0.0067556645,
-0.0127387596,
-0.007335769,
0.0112378281,
-0.0009825201,
-0.0128028551,
0.00155894,
-0.0410640128,
0.0044707432,
-0.0367293768,
0.0189697668,
-0.0425232984,
0.0018394284,
0.0346868895,
-0.0371774063,
-0.0090496074,
-0.0300582703,
-0.0137999402,
0.0492990911,
0.0339866951,
0.0102552585,
0.0157950092,
-0.0306679513,
0.0077870144,
0.0450668335,
-0.0197033435,
0.0266439151,
-0.0878636017,
0.0736959279,
0.005617782,
0.0227093101,
-0.0278650951,
0.0247268006,
0.0079220477,
0.0155177573,
-0.0226910226,
0.0730644986,
0.0237675533,
-0.0555806793,
0.0411859155,
-0.0207746513,
0.0020958991,
0.0507087149,
0.0120737758,
-0.0148864901,
-0.0285231471,
-0.0222495515,
-0.0464439839,
0.0061005298,
-0.0408377573,
0.002523351,
-0.0841712952,
0.031733755,
-0.02807381,
-0.0588610508,
-0.0474684723,
-0.0337513722,
0.0174076464,
0.0235265736,
-0.0005771103,
0.0052910042,
0.0083737681,
-0.0031637314,
0.0058199372,
0.0231774952,
-0.0044583855,
0.0543549806,
-0.0620362312,
0.0415406674,
0.0346835963,
0.0467533059,
-0.0043651825,
-0.0354538746,
0.0017541124,
0.0191033315,
0.0185070671,
0.0111745708,
0.0064520785,
0.015330201,
-0.0028847053,
-0.0505399257,
0.0214174334,
-0.0134456195,
-0.0904144123,
-0.0676266849,
0.1139066964,
-0.0224201959,
-0.0173132252,
-0.0156746414,
0.0181190129,
-0.0604750998,
0.0569317751,
0.0395743139,
-0.0539165847,
0.0169823132,
0.025952585,
0.0173316449,
0.0500971526,
-0.0489808097,
0.0309338011,
-0.004702128,
0.0012772807,
-0.048892729,
0.0110085867,
0.0019645928,
-0.0224710573,
0.0297547057,
-0.0166180097,
0.0148695474,
-0.0456597395,
-0.0604333617,
0.0738797486,
-0.01559042,
-0.0456391722,
-0.002078257,
-0.0104067232,
0.0258858167,
-0.0436582156,
-0.0312758721,
0.002911092,
-0.0582177304,
-0.0382664725,
0.0154876849,
-0.0038892089,
0.013981347,
-0.033999607,
0.0591293797,
-0.0567681454,
0.0214794222,
0.0176932979,
-0.004187773,
0.0509982742,
-0.1045567766,
0.0473802686,
0.0105867423,
0.0044109412,
-0.0332206525,
0.0118266232,
0.0082157319,
-0.0140593015,
0.002385108,
-0.0354728103,
0.0123576298,
0.0044081351,
0.0522452183,
-0.0018825344,
0.0008646328,
-0.050354749,
-0.0859147087,
0.0283014756,
0.0155266011,
-0.0143232597,
-0.0535425395,
0.0420386046,
0.0320232995,
-0.0333296731,
-0.0335394181,
0.0286901835,
0.0499062091,
0.0126064951,
-0.0738643706,
-0.004122721,
-0.0295670405,
-0.0592599735,
0.0613954589,
0.0184573289,
-0.0025046566,
-0.0916757286,
-0.0052731405,
-0.013037445,
0.0729820132,
0.0180616751,
-0.0015044964,
-0.0622520559,
0.0392934792,
-0.0168278199,
-0.0526787564,
0.0249415357,
-0.0223181974,
0.0318848528,
-0.0308342725,
0.009399795,
-0.0461874828,
0.0162275471,
0.0018505222,
0.0392874256,
-0.0483530387,
-0.0323373601,
0.071709685,
0.0268470384,
0.0160269551,
-0.0337951891,
0.0410497785,
0.0025853268,
0.018984573,
-0.017536791,
-0.0402033702,
-0.0152457291,
-0.0064503248,
0.0441946909,
0.0052416483,
-0.0168602373,
0.0283962246,
-0.0259175748,
-0.0533105619,
-0.0089959428,
0.031475395,
-0.0037926151,
0.0043443427,
0.0246467572,
0.036750827,
0.0080207074,
-0.0264536794,
0.0268540923,
-0.0019923691,
-0.0270886198,
-0.0307626482,
-0.0058763516,
-5.262257316e-33,
-0.0198136717,
-0.0263915788,
-0.0003281046,
-0.0013210166,
-0.0361283645,
-0.0157813728,
-0.0298896432,
0.0117180841,
0.0055249739,
0.0139798122,
0.0225562733,
-0.0182930324,
-0.0114887543,
-0.0059945709,
0.0623936243,
0.0163052492,
-0.0347222462,
-0.0329776667,
0.0092390673,
-0.0200890917,
0.0581765808,
-0.003537222,
0.0696392208,
-0.0681729019,
0.0020870562,
0.067616865,
0.0235312711,
0.051941175,
-0.0024904164,
0.0502640121,
-0.0816559941,
0.0368789732,
0.0718675181,
0.0034273656,
-0.0147981066,
0.0406179354,
-0.0118914898,
-0.0276824646,
0.0379461609,
0.0062471624,
-0.0114568649,
-0.0065827616,
0.0582726784,
-0.0488329157,
0.0187561456,
0.0106675616,
0.0520019755,
-0.0168675426,
0.0125349127,
0.0460503511,
-0.0645379424,
-0.0542310923,
-0.0067427862,
0.01997656,
0.0290303603,
-0.0219709184,
-0.0331374034,
0.0524012744,
-0.0608583391,
0.0199939534,
-0.0792144388,
0.0007235436,
0.0529194437,
0.0188151691,
0.0388562568,
0.1029915735,
0.081819199,
-0.0148862973,
-0.0375583805,
-0.0090060662,
0.0597392283,
0.0538889542,
-0.0058275093,
0.0458318219,
0.0356870331,
0.0050888741,
-0.028510347,
0.0254071057,
-0.0398020297,
0.0541678146,
0.0492274761,
-0.0010999473,
0.0465958901,
0.0093372166,
-0.0185903218,
-0.0186578687,
-0.0601104237,
-0.0111290291,
0.0322423577,
-0.0639331266,
0.0256896745,
-0.0131311892,
0.0683546439,
-0.0243833493,
-0.001963458,
-0.0191780385,
-0.005287189,
0.0331428684,
0.0209310669,
-0.0121343471,
-0.0185194034,
-0.0716703162,
0.0252507087,
-0.0480173007,
0.0517368168,
0.0188912991,
-0.0150570581,
-0.0222963989,
0.0125845671,
-0.0199679602,
-0.0319742635,
-0.0989609882,
0.0380435288,
0.0022257678,
0.0133558912,
0.0006985462,
-0.0326531269,
-0.0365803503,
0.0249706767,
-0.0252827387,
-0.022576645,
-0.0052779443,
-0.0153021608,
0.020691758,
-0.0279106088,
-0.0091130454,
-0.0583932512,
-0.0404363759,
0.049589701,
-0.0495262332,
-0.0099717248,
-0.002701981,
2.606e-7,
0.0387322269,
0.0704349205,
-0.0205059871,
0.0439988002,
0.0412447043,
0.0451189429,
-0.0024371196,
0.0365931876,
0.0246192142,
-0.0586431213,
-0.0416239314,
0.0625230148,
-0.0159225166,
-0.0015282315,
-0.018534014,
0.002032679,
0.0050108288,
0.0194016937,
-0.0508202575,
-0.0018558616,
0.0286774971,
0.0425140299,
0.0113145495,
-0.0503264256,
0.0037149864,
-0.0054822192,
0.0856855437,
-0.0574985109,
0.0260776822,
-0.0406803377,
-0.0030640119,
-0.0191701017,
0.0253396202,
0.0576077513,
0.0594066009,
-0.0042365422,
0.0464025401,
-0.0098078353,
-0.0222923718,
0.0025466611,
0.0002221676,
-0.009086919,
-0.0239719264,
-0.0408993736,
0.0280236863,
-0.0604268163,
-0.0689602271,
0.0097121419,
-0.0199829843,
-0.032541737,
0.0215683971,
-0.0035739569,
0.0005849081,
-0.0047361986,
-0.0140486564,
0.0199777447,
0.0008476364,
-0.0152080208,
-0.0130045582,
0.0385777429,
-0.0987025574,
0.0013053481,
-0.0298065189,
-0.0494493842,
0.0595659874,
-0.0491676927,
-0.0182713736,
1.822970759e-34,
-0.0534938164,
0.0148711298,
0.0335979015,
0.0199693069,
0.0408743806,
-0.0336228013,
0.0360764861,
0.0122849569,
-0.0065295673,
-0.0763802007,
0.0046006488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01047v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01047v1 | Development of Cognitive Intelligence in Pre-trained Language Models | 2024-07-01T07:56:36 | 2024-07-01T07:56:36 | Raj Sanjay Shah, Khushi Bhardwaj, Sashank Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies show evidence for emergent cognitive abilities in Large
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs). The increasing cognitive alignment of these
models has made them candidates for cognitive science theories. Prior research
into the emergent cognitive abilities of PLMs has largely been path-independent
to model training, i.e., has focused on the final model weights and not the
intermediate steps. However, building plausible models of human cognition using
PLMs would benefit from considering the developmental alignment of their
performance during training to the trajectories of children's thinking. Guided
by psychometric tests of human intelligence, we choose four sets of tasks to
investigate the alignment of ten popular families of PLMs and evaluate their
available intermediate and final training steps. These tasks are Numerical
ability, Linguistic abilities, Conceptual understanding, and Fluid reasoning.
We find a striking regularity: regardless of model size, the developmental
trajectories of PLMs consistently exhibit a window of maximal alignment to
human cognitive development. Before that window, training appears to endow
"blank slate" models with the requisite structure to be poised to rapidly learn
from experience. After that window, training appears to serve the engineering
goal of reducing loss but not the scientific goal of increasing alignment with
human cognition. | Development of Cognitive Intelligence in Pre-trained Language Models: Recent studies show evidence for emergent cognitive abilities in Large
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs). The increasing cognitive alignment of these
models has made them candidates for cognitive science theories. Prior research
into the emergent cognitive abilities of PLMs has largely been path-independent
to model training, i.e., has focused on the final model weights and not the
intermediate steps. However, building plausible models of human cognition using
PLMs would benefit from considering the developmental alignment of their
performance during training to the trajectories of children's thinking. Guided
by psychometric tests of human intelligence, we choose four sets of tasks to
investigate the alignment of ten popular families of PLMs and evaluate their
available intermediate and final training steps. These tasks are Numerical
ability, Linguistic abilities, Conceptual understanding, and Fluid reasoning.
We find a striking regularity: regardless of model size, the developmental
trajectories of PLMs consistently exhibit a window of maximal alignment to
human cognitive development. Before that window, training appears to endow
"blank slate" models with the requisite structure to be poised to rapidly learn
from experience. After that window, training appears to serve the engineering
goal of reducing loss but not the scientific goal of increasing alignment with
human cognition. | [
0.0099311555,
0.0489988364,
-0.0456243418,
-0.0204499587,
-0.0159335174,
0.0198851638,
0.0245169327,
-0.0156641528,
-0.0203258786,
-0.0075502596,
-0.017883379,
-0.0313923061,
0.0065794061,
0.0104494235,
0.0377781428,
-0.0234806035,
0.0579138026,
-0.0720451325,
0.0486883819,
-0.0057359245,
-0.048380807,
-0.0116652222,
-0.0397630073,
0.0068555363,
-0.0052411687,
-0.0247991998,
0.0081453351,
-0.0442417078,
-0.0374639146,
-0.0355085731,
-0.0341655724,
0.063422963,
0.0499815606,
0.0344669521,
0.0000020774,
-0.0904577076,
0.0548164696,
-0.0212714449,
-0.0442661718,
0.0246781353,
0.0228220802,
0.0215541087,
-0.0014166806,
0.0131447176,
-0.0361625291,
0.0191224236,
0.0243095588,
0.0120672109,
-0.0070972843,
0.0105325151,
0.0004251995,
-0.0174179971,
0.0614331998,
0.0062217177,
-0.0006948667,
-0.0157427955,
0.0258543324,
0.036002174,
0.0030802533,
-0.0351203978,
-0.00146002,
0.0055183447,
0.0144351851,
0.0172166992,
-0.027005475,
0.0208533928,
0.007797021,
-0.0400975198,
-0.0312936492,
0.0076557603,
0.0040065493,
-0.0436858907,
-0.0342314504,
0.0034030494,
0.0169249177,
0.0069737262,
-0.0538935736,
0.0405142903,
0.0579669736,
0.0172267221,
0.0360679477,
-0.0295696743,
0.0184015576,
-0.0000115635,
-0.0073172227,
0.0761749297,
0.009008972,
-0.0399815217,
0.0249878224,
0.0377815329,
-0.0254581552,
-0.0195392612,
-0.035688933,
0.0215825103,
0.0065604686,
0.0224742573,
-0.0387000293,
0.0062264586,
0.0042187041,
-0.0364454128,
0.0819241703,
0.0387234092,
0.0104767429,
0.0113965198,
-0.0166128557,
0.0704500079,
0.0303761754,
0.0570684187,
-0.0264168847,
0.0351520143,
-0.0293345489,
-0.0555843413,
-0.0228289254,
0.0196061451,
0.0138228303,
-0.005262759,
-0.046050474,
0.0160493068,
0.0180188771,
-0.0441100076,
-0.0152235292,
-0.0292740595,
0.0055591404,
-0.0109070381,
-0.0771906897,
-0.0016012242,
-0.0032997413,
0.0709330589,
-0.0174748376,
-0.011981572,
-0.0141016254,
0.0064698565,
-0.0245065987,
0.0036900081,
0.0161825642,
0.0220684614,
-0.0297743529,
-0.0214115474,
-0.0419655107,
-0.0065573589,
0.030179292,
-0.0706514195,
0.0220028497,
-0.0386236086,
0.0134363165,
0.0401803926,
-0.0187061485,
-0.0769354627,
-0.0147566497,
-0.001259582,
-0.0404427126,
-0.0065272241,
-0.024333233,
0.0636263788,
0.0143293999,
-0.0199799165,
0.0103724375,
0.0665156469,
0.0484563336,
-0.0700243413,
-0.0312728956,
-0.0315782055,
-0.0484289601,
0.0339449421,
-0.0013729045,
-0.0134905213,
-0.0213007554,
-0.0184773766,
0.0072605028,
0.0135021722,
0.0365525261,
0.0032107839,
-0.0027316317,
0.0291665494,
0.0935251713,
0.0911661461,
-0.0117633538,
0.0297714956,
0.0450010672,
-0.0178201236,
0.0859354585,
-0.0132136354,
-0.071679756,
0.0024989322,
-0.0820035264,
0.012134999,
-0.0181575976,
0.0572686493,
-0.044667922,
-0.005420228,
-0.0131133925,
-0.0065932465,
0.0279171523,
0.0059417011,
0.0434297696,
-0.0178740006,
-0.0237714443,
0.0370812789,
0.0187866837,
-0.018230537,
-0.0189809557,
-0.0398210883,
0.0137749193,
0.029572947,
-0.0348140821,
-0.0029597031,
-0.0214835219,
0.044906117,
0.0072484459,
0.0334486291,
0.0375495963,
0.0206315108,
-0.0123867188,
0.0043304134,
0.0072525605,
0.0064085536,
0.0062951068,
-0.0175463688,
-0.0158436652,
-0.0212823767,
-0.0197243616,
0.0051165293,
-0.0550124198,
0.0445720889,
-0.1078284904,
0.0094301952,
-0.0846165046,
-0.0127193723,
0.0406912714,
-0.007861658,
0.0103108082,
0.0511360355,
0.0316352919,
0.0220803358,
0.0224849544,
0.0553218052,
-0.0516892783,
0.0395004079,
0.0377449691,
0.0279566869,
-0.0022481512,
0.0152011085,
0.0358565822,
-0.0165332835,
0.0629399195,
-0.0307591911,
0.0701606497,
0.0049944674,
0.0960131958,
-0.0520018861,
-0.0033756907,
-0.0086556906,
0.0859840065,
0.0027413091,
0.0130824791,
-0.0010945057,
-0.01177778,
0.0054350784,
-0.0275517292,
-0.0143757388,
-0.0422780737,
-0.0307630356,
0.0103848409,
-0.015859589,
0.0017193365,
-0.0591186881,
0.016311748,
-0.074892506,
-0.0103100752,
0.0288237967,
0.0177460276,
0.0044580288,
-0.0579182431,
-0.0375166275,
0.0144274225,
-0.000963555,
0.0181982983,
0.0398504958,
0.0242191982,
0.004058715,
-0.0315234624,
-0.0324618071,
-0.044408381,
-0.0079954462,
-0.0542595759,
0.0372765362,
0.0350747779,
0.0202061981,
-0.0336724184,
0.0388318188,
-0.0345696732,
0.0451925136,
-0.0024496191,
-0.0236499775,
0.0712482408,
0.0443424471,
0.0813662633,
0.0701719299,
0.0135815879,
0.0337732993,
0.0455929078,
0.0048048617,
-0.0246984474,
-0.0027575933,
-0.0369267911,
-0.0228410698,
-0.0605800152,
-0.0206720475,
-0.0318192989,
0.122984156,
-0.009374476,
0.0028848606,
-0.0295091961,
0.078487061,
-0.0096413558,
-0.0182195567,
-0.0140135475,
-0.0541749708,
-0.0330003835,
0.0729250908,
-0.0348751359,
-0.0502937511,
0.0061290157,
-0.0205506068,
0.0249107946,
-0.037102621,
0.0034951225,
0.0235579386,
0.0390790328,
0.0251994748,
-0.0046088137,
0.0013352005,
0.0054511661,
-0.1074016839,
0.0306766331,
0.0221604835,
-0.0180512778,
0.0251108408,
-0.0852905735,
0.0170210395,
0.0126542225,
-0.0086411312,
-0.0522270203,
-0.002559148,
-0.0284562185,
0.0437531918,
0.0447888337,
-0.013002933,
-0.084403649,
-0.014064502,
0.0453783162,
-0.0001958235,
0.0042359061,
0.0146096498,
0.0030177855,
-0.0556668229,
0.023680279,
0.0183119662,
0.0382316746,
-0.0710310861,
0.0394870378,
0.0071509853,
-0.016686704,
-0.0003292447,
-0.0087277815,
0.0464647822,
0.0577826686,
-0.0002508675,
-0.0087580131,
0.0506703891,
0.0587351061,
0.0035287458,
-0.0059679272,
0.0942721292,
0.0545799434,
0.0057594692,
0.0223341435,
0.0099723944,
-0.0132621769,
0.0469927564,
-0.0061951349,
-0.0142660756,
0.0265139882,
-0.0098091559,
-0.0244193226,
-0.039019011,
-0.0394176953,
-0.01311439,
-0.0950270668,
-0.019490771,
0.0226351377,
-0.0540788285,
-0.0017775596,
-0.021792382,
0.0017512639,
0.0544646196,
0.0105723282,
0.0324494131,
-0.0234948341,
0.0064233593,
0.006132768,
-0.0316765048,
-0.0577952266,
0.0361743048,
-0.0184580442,
0.0712467805,
0.0088104196,
-0.01949884,
-0.0312089734,
-0.0396774039,
0.0431308448,
0.0011642511,
-0.0034026492,
0.0179200489,
-0.0026484632,
0.0112901228,
0.0171725284,
-0.0438282788,
0.0038529742,
-0.0065412275,
-0.034486182,
0.0012946884,
0.0788681954,
-0.0007133786,
-0.0292944554,
0.0017632797,
0.0383245163,
-0.0465357341,
0.0751195401,
0.0034372043,
-0.0635996684,
0.010163758,
-0.0001764955,
-0.0234057307,
0.0209098682,
-0.0785950646,
0.0582457185,
0.021296544,
0.0200723913,
-0.0351114534,
-0.0051817787,
0.0218697898,
0.0206153113,
0.0271854997,
-0.0097821709,
0.0153284306,
-0.0334136412,
-0.0374403708,
0.0593027435,
-0.0000970816,
-0.0440336391,
-0.0913499668,
-0.0728108436,
0.0123369684,
-0.0778581277,
-0.0219857339,
-0.0235545579,
-0.0380952284,
-0.0608167946,
0.020935934,
0.0253865104,
0.0336450599,
-0.0197760891,
0.029035693,
-0.0551916324,
0.0430751517,
-0.0326065384,
-0.0415884294,
0.0214561652,
-0.0422058925,
-0.0055509247,
0.0302664936,
-0.0057464452,
-0.0093628047,
0.0498460419,
0.0271709524,
0.0221920852,
-0.0310286731,
-0.050594788,
0.0240300409,
0.0220625028,
0.0771909878,
0.0007658206,
-0.007294124,
-0.064251259,
-0.0290717687,
-0.0446215123,
0.0107157901,
0.0218615495,
-0.0457124747,
0.0100782057,
0.0535204299,
0.015227031,
-0.0326017439,
-0.0207656883,
0.0264088307,
-0.0134216538,
0.0151601899,
-0.0351847224,
0.0534266941,
0.0046238163,
0.0323340967,
0.0076734493,
0.0014942975,
-0.077302523,
0.0357843749,
0.0315528288,
0.0740388408,
-0.0302223563,
0.0369044617,
-0.0257537868,
-0.0144918952,
-0.0456336141,
-0.0638104305,
-0.0242062416,
0.0148363598,
0.0236113928,
-0.0223646127,
0.0031756375,
-0.0566359796,
0.0120715583,
-0.0292807464,
-0.0223391503,
-0.006831598,
-0.0292748157,
0.0356561281,
0.0068788119,
-0.0093319258,
-0.0000691868,
0.0429896787,
0.0225742348,
0.0147072067,
-0.0390961617,
-0.0192798823,
-0.0000205192,
-0.0258212294,
0.0334946215,
0.0282448493,
-0.0507334955,
0.0344897583,
-0.0546320751,
-0.0610103235,
-0.0238676723,
0.0287993569,
-0.0070112511,
0.0072223507,
0.0251919068,
0.0460726693,
-0.063332662,
-0.0238306951,
0.0183768254,
-0.004099594,
-0.0230466016,
0.0005745237,
-0.015504607,
-6.379832489e-33,
-0.0286699645,
0.0038791476,
0.0707779378,
-0.0071695796,
-0.0055523664,
-0.0351932943,
-0.0212135445,
0.0965502188,
-0.0604987517,
-0.0115123168,
0.0305139069,
-0.0306181908,
0.0035073585,
-0.007029146,
0.0098648118,
0.0395705849,
-0.0326415077,
-0.0395376571,
-0.0024332101,
-0.0452906676,
-0.0005331556,
-0.0236973614,
0.0643325821,
-0.0341474265,
0.0063978923,
-0.0112674199,
0.0311362613,
-0.0006538794,
-0.026061086,
0.0292744469,
-0.0139361173,
0.0248608943,
0.04041446,
-0.0079516433,
-0.0131915323,
0.0005455915,
-0.0124564124,
-0.0274087209,
0.0849013329,
-0.0028792284,
-0.0326328464,
-0.0194056891,
0.0276565384,
-0.0144034717,
-0.043834012,
-0.0200316757,
0.0184852798,
-0.0279517844,
0.0219112318,
0.0126701323,
-0.107569322,
-0.0256341305,
-0.0213630982,
0.0032445872,
-0.0080507919,
-0.0060761515,
-0.0427684411,
-0.0122997556,
-0.0540121458,
0.0237238389,
0.0227813832,
0.0180196054,
0.0677052587,
0.016542241,
0.0473899879,
0.0568457693,
0.0630191714,
0.0197592545,
-0.0044858539,
0.0153946746,
0.1046033427,
0.0117136026,
0.0398434289,
-0.0261808354,
0.0166729279,
-0.0217029322,
-0.0568325073,
-0.0236961488,
0.0276940912,
0.0205025394,
0.0361143798,
-0.0101856636,
-0.0121517414,
-0.0068488247,
-0.038043648,
-0.0131121399,
-0.0152548691,
-0.0188338235,
0.0253532082,
-0.0340343602,
0.0246297661,
-0.0343513824,
0.0306574646,
-0.0010682637,
0.0051491149,
-0.0228742752,
-0.014131695,
0.0076351096,
-0.0182287097,
0.0276735611,
-0.1007311195,
-0.0624526329,
-0.0029362824,
0.0212013349,
0.0340832882,
0.0449880622,
0.0112355277,
-0.001561007,
-0.0284248888,
-0.0115192439,
-0.0175128561,
-0.0038321163,
0.0785711482,
-0.0398700796,
0.0467524901,
0.0137870936,
-0.0055491086,
-0.0565742105,
-0.0029247727,
-0.074745968,
-0.0501638651,
0.0124895303,
-0.0254508778,
0.0179617107,
0.001364773,
0.0036423479,
-0.032040026,
0.0535585284,
0.0207797494,
-0.0311450977,
-0.0063979761,
0.0435410552,
2.884e-7,
0.0186555367,
0.0555559322,
-0.0155216511,
-0.0000401927,
0.0314707384,
-0.025023587,
-0.0416072682,
-0.038879782,
0.0623007305,
0.0092571257,
-0.0092501976,
0.0381577313,
0.0362588391,
-0.0142911598,
-0.0299577303,
-0.035463132,
-0.0247937236,
0.0270170067,
-0.047911495,
0.0406545959,
0.0406773649,
0.033565104,
0.0023410539,
-0.0170091745,
-0.0391057096,
-0.0150011657,
0.0418482311,
-0.0285080113,
0.0288017839,
-0.0040464867,
-0.012509184,
0.0085120443,
0.00809462,
0.0960691199,
0.0004338988,
0.0591543987,
-0.0103866784,
0.0170903355,
-0.0172729641,
0.0196720269,
-0.0130701261,
0.0201127995,
-0.0320517235,
-0.0451870561,
0.057980027,
-0.0831593573,
-0.0576943159,
0.0378902964,
-0.0266958792,
-0.0105767762,
-0.0090641733,
0.0140691772,
0.0193626005,
0.0193033237,
0.0337951854,
-0.0114218639,
0.0172224212,
-0.0205772351,
0.0032451681,
0.06118403,
-0.0424630903,
-0.0716502964,
-0.0342226066,
-0.0151003962,
0.0282219462,
-0.0066970773,
0.0434003584,
2.422063177e-34,
-0.0063815322,
-0.016035784,
0.0774096698,
-0.0400057882,
0.0227607451,
-0.0177142434,
0.0405546315,
0.0294558909,
0.0264926124,
-0.0703342855,
0.0165163614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01046v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01046v2 | FRoG: Evaluating Fuzzy Reasoning of Generalized Quantifiers in Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T07:56:14 | 2024-07-03T03:37:53 | Yiyuan Li, Shichao Sun, Pengfei Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Fuzzy reasoning is vital due to the frequent use of imprecise information in
daily contexts. However, the ability of current large language models (LLMs) to
handle such reasoning remains largely uncharted. In this paper, we introduce a
new benchmark, FRoG, for fuzzy reasoning, featuring real-world mathematical
word problems that incorporate generalized quantifiers. Our experimental
findings reveal that fuzzy reasoning continues to pose significant challenges
for LLMs. Moreover, we find that existing methods designed to enhance reasoning
do not consistently improve performance in tasks involving fuzzy logic.
Additionally, our results show an inverse scaling effect in the performance of
LLMs on FRoG. Interestingly, we also demonstrate that strong mathematical
reasoning skills are not necessarily indicative of success on our benchmark. | FRoG: Evaluating Fuzzy Reasoning of Generalized Quantifiers in Large Language Models: Fuzzy reasoning is vital due to the frequent use of imprecise information in
daily contexts. However, the ability of current large language models (LLMs) to
handle such reasoning remains largely uncharted. In this paper, we introduce a
new benchmark, FRoG, for fuzzy reasoning, featuring real-world mathematical
word problems that incorporate generalized quantifiers. Our experimental
findings reveal that fuzzy reasoning continues to pose significant challenges
for LLMs. Moreover, we find that existing methods designed to enhance reasoning
do not consistently improve performance in tasks involving fuzzy logic.
Additionally, our results show an inverse scaling effect in the performance of
LLMs on FRoG. Interestingly, we also demonstrate that strong mathematical
reasoning skills are not necessarily indicative of success on our benchmark. | [
-0.0004963665,
0.0947062373,
-0.0161121972,
0.0506314971,
-0.052979961,
0.0032048421,
0.0183632448,
0.0516194776,
-0.0320888236,
-0.0462753065,
0.0229401141,
-0.0554934144,
-0.0083290003,
-0.0082778353,
0.0341995284,
-0.0051821535,
0.0638691634,
-0.0193581339,
0.0705911517,
-0.0367275029,
-0.0031745927,
-0.004178449,
-0.0374329202,
0.0007047437,
-0.0441196412,
-0.0155583732,
0.034098506,
-0.0271202438,
0.0227360558,
-0.0210558418,
-0.0189153515,
0.0282307658,
0.0127165699,
0.0265540499,
0.0000021404,
-0.0424546972,
-0.0102966474,
-0.0044463621,
-0.0373665914,
0.042457249,
0.0126142735,
0.0346330889,
-0.0231417548,
0.0343784727,
-0.0302232485,
0.0438748263,
0.020351408,
0.0285968501,
0.0656900108,
0.0263096057,
-0.0162609834,
-0.0280587766,
-0.0020783732,
0.0309215002,
0.059655834,
-0.0616762824,
0.0094173234,
0.0648619458,
0.0719338804,
-0.0410461351,
-0.0078643849,
0.0651926845,
0.0312506333,
0.0470836647,
-0.0391641855,
0.017413782,
-0.0708574802,
0.0140793966,
0.0175735503,
0.0387713648,
-0.0520236418,
-0.0184877925,
-0.0238591954,
-0.0034081386,
-0.0294033941,
-0.0034344126,
-0.0360938497,
0.0304781441,
-0.0211828295,
0.0206216928,
-0.0359376408,
0.0070976811,
0.0253325831,
0.0552944355,
-0.0977197215,
0.1417561769,
-0.0186068676,
-0.0422972701,
0.0121275093,
-0.0314181112,
-0.1088228673,
-0.0086807581,
0.0465334766,
0.042578686,
-0.0154023245,
0.0302520115,
-0.0298109539,
0.0080226678,
0.022545917,
-0.0220400412,
0.0081465011,
0.0821188912,
0.0824030042,
0.0298681147,
-0.0399541706,
0.0790151134,
-0.0102640428,
0.0201010369,
-0.0129230432,
0.0030863434,
-0.0325616449,
-0.0167826097,
-0.0316265859,
0.0267670136,
0.0165364332,
-0.0313514695,
-0.0589371622,
0.0092272451,
0.0021368377,
0.0696459487,
-0.0164819509,
-0.0053893789,
0.0271881763,
-0.0468720607,
-0.0589509904,
0.0021630195,
-0.0573795773,
0.0446461663,
0.0038828086,
-0.0322497301,
0.007069183,
-0.0251825843,
0.0113816252,
-0.0440980904,
0.0211342145,
0.0571327172,
-0.0016782426,
0.0117526166,
-0.004525078,
-0.0162347965,
-0.0033412632,
-0.0978470072,
-0.0501706228,
-0.0773690939,
0.0004544039,
0.0390623957,
0.0045241411,
-0.0238786284,
0.0449412689,
0.0067972951,
0.0047002127,
0.0941299945,
-0.0080615282,
0.0101679871,
0.006709537,
0.0303190537,
-0.0034095182,
0.0645533353,
0.055869095,
0.0018216013,
0.0237560831,
0.0197729506,
0.0149690518,
0.0530913323,
0.0265816525,
-0.040375568,
-0.0137141198,
0.01056132,
-0.0383280404,
0.0525016636,
-0.0205768738,
0.080932878,
-0.0412639752,
0.0178283248,
0.0605995692,
0.0667995587,
0.0344716683,
-0.0060452498,
-0.0170770977,
0.0278260596,
0.0313416906,
-0.0123725533,
-0.0651845634,
0.0097081475,
-0.0171824899,
0.0407654345,
-0.012776521,
0.0270680021,
-0.0078558819,
-0.0528607629,
-0.0615968034,
-0.0070082373,
-0.0053318464,
0.0049968553,
0.0484067462,
-0.0395424217,
-0.0259218495,
0.0761719719,
0.0099517843,
-0.0561408699,
0.0052232444,
-0.0336160809,
-0.0026535671,
0.0425127558,
0.0499312244,
-0.059237469,
-0.0443168022,
0.0167661887,
-0.0378926881,
-0.0075377948,
0.0260948036,
0.0353849232,
-0.0287747569,
-0.0671135858,
0.0032254318,
-0.0116451802,
0.0249319132,
-0.0373485908,
0.0686420873,
0.0368911624,
0.021463709,
-0.0396064408,
0.0022838116,
0.018821843,
0.0156052327,
-0.0110517796,
-0.0243805163,
-0.0024535481,
-0.0022803864,
-0.0277791601,
-0.0251026582,
0.0469230004,
-0.0140542034,
0.0000323121,
-0.0369369984,
-0.0452054776,
-0.0313750692,
-0.0200250093,
0.0485039912,
0.0001899622,
-0.0256149527,
-0.0180474315,
-0.0319587775,
0.0164273065,
0.0208274014,
-0.0388380289,
-0.000629271,
-0.0159005448,
0.0408258587,
-0.0313208438,
-0.023246089,
-0.0243146718,
0.0713152438,
0.0147778224,
0.0199279618,
-0.0366997309,
0.0305941962,
0.002857862,
-0.057688918,
0.0265867095,
-0.0036854181,
-0.039615538,
0.0336699076,
-0.0135388719,
-0.0170647204,
-0.0356180742,
-0.0390533805,
-0.0233520996,
0.0086187664,
0.0132694496,
0.0253320318,
-0.0101791397,
-0.0212179385,
-0.0038275698,
0.0369916186,
-0.023124937,
-0.0115019837,
0.0033613141,
0.0008935484,
0.0243165791,
-0.0110652028,
0.0185398534,
-0.031249309,
0.0057511139,
-0.0358484276,
0.0321360454,
0.0068045836,
-0.0104679875,
-0.0049816575,
0.0371168889,
-0.0921916217,
-0.0097451899,
0.0120044202,
-0.0106820213,
-0.000283366,
-0.0001265649,
0.0037700681,
0.0664683357,
0.0002228243,
-0.0219098423,
0.0441911258,
-0.0411230028,
-0.0690509751,
0.0286749694,
0.0024520913,
0.0006737814,
-0.0118171833,
-0.0318536386,
-0.0289047975,
0.0398092605,
-0.0123559656,
-0.009847126,
-0.035000138,
0.0936079845,
-0.0629708767,
0.0242319014,
-0.0776410103,
0.007878989,
0.012710127,
0.1000407487,
-0.0145096527,
-0.0203035362,
0.0588291436,
-0.0131302075,
0.0019303475,
-0.0493478216,
0.0062538385,
-0.0282173473,
0.0094013596,
-0.0395667665,
0.0184892658,
-0.0246215761,
0.0155535629,
-0.0456195697,
-0.0289034098,
0.0307200663,
-0.0485811979,
0.0374588184,
-0.0465996489,
0.0169424471,
-0.0028581398,
-0.0466205068,
-0.0311767682,
0.0027666928,
-0.0499456823,
0.0127002997,
-0.011629127,
-0.0241184942,
-0.0122119719,
0.0377728343,
0.0187724028,
0.001418379,
-0.043475464,
-0.0077954819,
-0.0116171474,
0.0043567354,
0.0274000987,
-0.0127205392,
0.0743840858,
-0.0257136282,
-0.0029821421,
0.0233815424,
0.0683760941,
-0.0084542902,
-0.0143724447,
-0.0028452675,
-0.014302846,
-0.0207558647,
-0.0208627153,
0.0192312766,
0.0359430201,
-0.0540870428,
0.0239706039,
0.1199058592,
0.0649337992,
0.0372121111,
0.0091690803,
-0.0492659062,
0.0074596349,
-0.0072593628,
0.025114106,
-0.0897076279,
-0.0568415299,
0.0266406909,
-0.0298197605,
-0.0051974109,
-0.0270487443,
-0.0227601659,
-0.0700772926,
0.0258453414,
0.0272264611,
-0.0075304853,
-0.0067573534,
0.0004010578,
0.0143914977,
0.0007769659,
0.0039654244,
0.0231707655,
-0.0083374344,
-0.0010117855,
-0.0156479795,
0.0208286922,
-0.0145490216,
0.0520219021,
-0.0465940982,
-0.0074433973,
-0.0024561542,
0.0401565507,
0.0016046753,
-0.0383262113,
0.0307533331,
0.0204526037,
-0.0179917905,
-0.0249564499,
-0.0088120271,
0.0265747346,
0.0013326587,
0.0002242119,
0.0009953334,
-0.0162476413,
-0.017212512,
0.016855238,
0.0896327347,
-0.0072052544,
-0.0338576287,
0.0113514513,
0.026663037,
-0.0416053273,
0.0541012734,
0.0094882101,
0.0077325534,
-0.0689306557,
-0.0341273248,
-0.0435503125,
0.0111129992,
-0.0645259023,
-0.0158071052,
-0.000100542,
-0.0205674469,
-0.0467828512,
0.0140595948,
0.0515651815,
0.0280727968,
-0.0258904137,
-0.0175813641,
0.087980181,
-0.0018715899,
-0.0548590869,
0.021934811,
-0.0272427034,
0.0793064833,
-0.0148240551,
0.0454300418,
-0.0095215263,
0.0115055339,
-0.0282900129,
0.0350669585,
-0.0398902372,
-0.0591303222,
0.0075069806,
-0.0145629225,
0.0280513819,
-0.035401389,
-0.036022637,
-0.0297935754,
0.0436489508,
0.0644008145,
-0.087375164,
0.0020805602,
0.0515618511,
0.0126088988,
0.0288010519,
0.0222916603,
-0.0064917677,
0.0187899284,
0.0039041073,
0.0650752112,
-0.0563566536,
-0.0100639192,
0.0085563343,
0.0386492424,
0.0028827025,
0.0279605333,
-0.0032600819,
0.0141856046,
0.0106257778,
-0.0115324035,
-0.0417526737,
-0.0128051145,
-0.0101600969,
0.0211668946,
-0.0027868294,
0.0043073823,
-0.0374796763,
0.0301421713,
0.0163828526,
0.0543867089,
-0.0076904302,
-0.0412857533,
0.0102788908,
0.0404445045,
-0.0423237197,
-0.0067752036,
0.0060132048,
-0.0086389668,
0.0481238179,
-0.0225394219,
0.0610491447,
0.0147652654,
-0.0238975249,
-0.0744660944,
-0.0155587886,
-0.0344052464,
-0.0836399049,
0.0111671099,
0.022444915,
0.0287321936,
0.0128038106,
-0.0157269929,
-0.058806289,
-0.0199303236,
-0.0022457498,
-0.004713241,
0.0293286555,
0.0231265333,
0.0296370201,
0.0269936882,
-0.0124543365,
-0.0249395873,
0.0292362105,
-0.0527300388,
0.0023787797,
0.0053379657,
-0.0363039486,
-0.018894719,
-0.0332765579,
-0.0238251183,
0.0093484428,
0.0009468516,
0.0371202342,
-0.0811862275,
-0.0582693182,
-0.0125361681,
-0.0117454939,
-0.0208095424,
-0.0236016717,
0.0223482344,
0.0609964542,
-0.0208275877,
-0.0157954246,
-0.0189628955,
-0.0193238091,
-0.0096206116,
0.0187046565,
-0.0243116803,
-6.420528838e-33,
-0.0288375113,
-0.0372345112,
0.0478924699,
-0.0105741406,
0.0095694708,
-0.0094860243,
0.0063767741,
0.0137120951,
-0.0183325596,
-0.0027162877,
-0.0330432355,
0.0263853893,
0.0140409861,
-0.0258126818,
-0.0237811375,
0.0033918195,
-0.007162055,
0.0333938971,
-0.0531407706,
-0.0466692895,
-0.0022724234,
-0.011111252,
0.0349198729,
-0.0285032801,
-0.0098039061,
0.0349140763,
-0.0187746454,
0.029201638,
-0.051169131,
0.0351678208,
-0.0224005468,
0.0130726304,
0.000049098,
-0.0063509191,
-0.0055251787,
-0.0083786799,
-0.036269255,
-0.0149596464,
0.0061641065,
-0.0009855577,
0.0124349762,
-0.0073992522,
-0.0012830021,
0.004888745,
-0.0406978242,
-0.0270216279,
0.014080354,
-0.03769904,
-0.0028730845,
-0.005122296,
-0.0523231253,
0.0592564903,
-0.0071541523,
0.0110146832,
0.0092771463,
0.0303347874,
-0.044854857,
0.0165326521,
-0.0176966619,
0.0184065476,
0.0272032674,
0.0249138828,
0.0463306122,
-0.0436046086,
-0.012679236,
0.0444504954,
-0.0182318725,
-0.0436717309,
-0.0512972437,
0.0119288396,
0.0348827653,
0.0456405394,
0.0847426131,
0.015078228,
0.061320696,
-0.0015520895,
-0.0245103724,
-0.0007289159,
0.0143678458,
0.0659491569,
0.0406269245,
0.0208334625,
-0.0441496447,
-0.0102322605,
-0.044487603,
0.0669490695,
-0.0713635013,
-0.0097331414,
-0.0248113144,
-0.037588533,
-0.0342960618,
0.0053173467,
0.0144808693,
-0.02994789,
-0.029771179,
-0.0229838677,
-0.0012908392,
0.0048385914,
0.0021956863,
0.0574584752,
-0.0067446493,
-0.0031758605,
-0.0069693998,
0.0368862748,
0.0140441479,
0.0155334324,
0.0141406478,
0.0136196883,
-0.0554632358,
0.0009472519,
-0.0408204943,
-0.0295376442,
0.0123926476,
-0.0448834114,
0.0154663688,
0.019192595,
0.0175544098,
0.0323199779,
-0.0085976524,
-0.0108677521,
-0.0092832297,
0.0445210598,
-0.0045261327,
0.0228989907,
-0.0132210227,
-0.0276139472,
-0.0903247148,
0.0187427774,
-0.0048691095,
-0.0449598879,
-0.0205145963,
0.0042252722,
3.007e-7,
0.0521991365,
0.0851179138,
-0.0356871337,
0.064969182,
0.0001964749,
0.0364314057,
-0.0441774614,
-0.0675425753,
0.0080299433,
0.0377905257,
0.0204312131,
0.0681699589,
0.0104667479,
0.0536335185,
-0.001172005,
-0.0099445144,
-0.0613854006,
-0.0327581242,
-0.0623783655,
0.0248066355,
0.0493262894,
0.0938672796,
0.0457433164,
-0.0069878679,
0.0312914141,
-0.1075306684,
0.0459445529,
-0.0050279978,
-0.0019413972,
0.0623245239,
0.0132295284,
0.0062494311,
0.0376928858,
0.0180298183,
0.0259506777,
0.0269652698,
0.008577764,
0.0822500139,
0.006385094,
0.0086187543,
-0.0038952588,
-0.0538645796,
-0.0186241865,
-0.1066496968,
0.0722717345,
-0.0753503442,
-0.0226607658,
-0.004352604,
0.0160642713,
-0.0517909415,
0.0399549417,
0.0001679978,
0.0079689613,
0.0074162669,
0.0093658874,
-0.0021629937,
-0.0231620967,
-0.0634226575,
-0.0353025682,
-0.0055216532,
-0.0264026187,
-0.0635327771,
-0.0203802511,
0.0219140202,
0.0501416624,
-0.0380966105,
-0.0009184476,
2.821819189e-34,
0.0556767471,
0.0205980055,
0.0089518717,
0.0294205006,
0.0896238163,
0.0058789044,
-0.0367707014,
0.032727547,
0.0174647868,
-0.0406382009,
0.0111774262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01031v1 | PocketLLM: Enabling On-Device Fine-Tuning for Personalized LLMs | 2024-07-01T07:26:56 | 2024-07-01T07:26:56 | Dan Peng, Zhihui Fu, Jun Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have indeed showcased
their impressive capabilities. On mobile devices, the wealth of valuable,
non-public data generated daily holds great promise for locally fine-tuning
personalized LLMs, while maintaining privacy through on-device processing.
However, the constraints of mobile device resources pose challenges to direct
on-device LLM fine-tuning, mainly due to the memory-intensive nature of
derivative-based optimization required for saving gradients and optimizer
states. To tackle this, we propose employing derivative-free optimization
techniques to enable on-device fine-tuning of LLM, even on memory-limited
mobile devices. Empirical results demonstrate that the RoBERTa-large model and
OPT-1.3B can be fine-tuned locally on the OPPO Reno 6 smartphone using around
4GB and 6.5GB of memory respectively, using derivative-free optimization
techniques. This highlights the feasibility of on-device LLM fine-tuning on
mobile devices, paving the way for personalized LLMs on resource-constrained
devices while safeguarding data privacy. | PocketLLM: Enabling On-Device Fine-Tuning for Personalized LLMs: Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have indeed showcased
their impressive capabilities. On mobile devices, the wealth of valuable,
non-public data generated daily holds great promise for locally fine-tuning
personalized LLMs, while maintaining privacy through on-device processing.
However, the constraints of mobile device resources pose challenges to direct
on-device LLM fine-tuning, mainly due to the memory-intensive nature of
derivative-based optimization required for saving gradients and optimizer
states. To tackle this, we propose employing derivative-free optimization
techniques to enable on-device fine-tuning of LLM, even on memory-limited
mobile devices. Empirical results demonstrate that the RoBERTa-large model and
OPT-1.3B can be fine-tuned locally on the OPPO Reno 6 smartphone using around
4GB and 6.5GB of memory respectively, using derivative-free optimization
techniques. This highlights the feasibility of on-device LLM fine-tuning on
mobile devices, paving the way for personalized LLMs on resource-constrained
devices while safeguarding data privacy. | [
0.0283675827,
0.0613320246,
-0.0264156815,
0.0730843171,
-0.0060089487,
-0.0250020027,
0.0672593266,
0.0026185587,
-0.03152062,
-0.0117495246,
-0.0291047487,
-0.0363599882,
0.0077748341,
-0.0554588623,
0.0070546945,
0.0083679426,
0.0213502385,
-0.0279007982,
-0.0333731994,
-0.0169830918,
0.0029167847,
0.0087768044,
0.0453023054,
0.0146229537,
-0.0004287174,
-0.0156427529,
-0.021291038,
0.0637144372,
0.0121920761,
-0.0263178777,
0.004469038,
0.0696026906,
0.0050022365,
0.038714461,
0.0000021491,
0.0097955139,
-0.0258621424,
0.0169226378,
0.0129726063,
0.0297887344,
0.0953454375,
0.0156232975,
-0.026851004,
0.0296343677,
-0.0367262252,
-0.003663013,
0.0281080548,
-0.0448073745,
0.0364953987,
0.0876824111,
0.005817472,
0.0148213282,
-0.0136878639,
-0.042884741,
0.0091806948,
-0.0518419519,
0.0068727653,
-0.0692074224,
-0.0394488312,
-0.0355333239,
-0.0043484,
0.0086058592,
0.0273957327,
0.0281455629,
0.0085872347,
-0.0122409966,
-0.0114753144,
-0.0323347114,
-0.0181301348,
0.0636425391,
-0.0328509212,
-0.0321262665,
0.0416647717,
-0.012445949,
-0.0217110347,
-0.0246395413,
0.011593529,
0.0039707324,
-0.0204996914,
0.0162097681,
-0.0203039572,
-0.0613893196,
0.0373637117,
-0.0044236882,
-0.0165212955,
0.0381968282,
0.0262712613,
-0.0125067048,
-0.0351499729,
0.0008642945,
-0.0246013403,
-0.0323327519,
0.0575752407,
0.0108513916,
-0.0013311548,
-0.0067305444,
-0.0649360567,
-0.0725352392,
-0.0131443376,
-0.0376441851,
0.0790069029,
0.0294091124,
0.0358405672,
-0.0038192447,
-0.0122643448,
-0.0024204014,
-0.0274889115,
-0.016278496,
-0.0218385682,
0.023929324,
0.0124349194,
0.028973747,
-0.0035424158,
0.0207711365,
-0.1111585274,
-0.0057554403,
-0.0281795077,
0.0154365916,
0.0149608133,
-0.0195510089,
-0.0010536987,
0.0258700959,
-0.0214107744,
-0.0248043779,
0.033853326,
-0.0275211465,
-0.0200048517,
0.009941401,
0.0023948865,
-0.0535152107,
0.0048058424,
-0.0041177706,
0.0086088162,
0.000419196,
-0.0145418905,
0.0600828603,
0.0082860468,
-0.0285736062,
-0.009200071,
-0.0272310749,
0.0067368434,
-0.0712309927,
0.0197731908,
-0.0553294122,
0.0212639868,
-0.0058508934,
0.0098339189,
-0.0634589717,
0.0074862959,
0.0199498441,
0.0038015081,
0.0085789701,
-0.0053614541,
0.0007215997,
0.0056929346,
0.0209888294,
0.0230721235,
0.0651282296,
0.0390350558,
0.0401048549,
0.0339866355,
-0.0193984844,
-0.0170528218,
0.0489995256,
0.0492109396,
0.0198351424,
-0.0309523214,
-0.0108772703,
0.0002937171,
0.0087098014,
0.0105464188,
0.0444477163,
-0.0201268885,
-0.0118656354,
0.0751178786,
0.0622736253,
0.0597400106,
0.0428018719,
-0.057811603,
0.0180138294,
0.0076335091,
-0.0416191667,
-0.0476122722,
0.002249538,
-0.0347071625,
0.0126586081,
0.0426189303,
0.060639672,
0.0049974136,
-0.0003933038,
-0.0288034733,
-0.0374170281,
-0.0198782887,
0.0474078953,
-0.0051637017,
-0.026333835,
0.0039688065,
0.0496267378,
0.0324856602,
-0.0450926237,
-0.040482752,
-0.0525675118,
0.0393957272,
0.0824920684,
0.0059048031,
0.0092181889,
-0.0134782968,
0.0017203671,
-0.0127127031,
0.0501733012,
0.0187382717,
0.0180746447,
0.0817534998,
-0.0399273261,
-0.0093664443,
-0.0002556592,
0.0231584236,
0.0114442427,
0.0577957481,
0.0305824038,
0.028260855,
-0.0077402904,
-0.0085437,
-0.0041194162,
-0.0025559738,
-0.0340083539,
0.0671774894,
0.0117357392,
-0.0029370766,
0.008365918,
0.0051572779,
-0.0219444018,
0.0271270666,
-0.0430644117,
0.0747152269,
-0.0571125522,
-0.015297465,
0.0040717302,
0.0153669845,
0.0051447474,
0.0287328567,
0.0347901732,
-0.0129842628,
-0.0233730134,
0.0185822174,
0.0237231776,
0.0899308398,
-0.0115411729,
0.0309194718,
-0.011695303,
0.0655028895,
-0.0106088063,
0.023670001,
-0.0267912354,
-0.0022726441,
0.021161519,
0.0353735201,
-0.0214042868,
-0.016737299,
-0.0193311851,
0.0026888188,
0.012756642,
0.0602087006,
0.0000305577,
0.0368757471,
-0.0063018855,
-0.0382130928,
-0.0664849058,
0.033319287,
-0.0384719968,
0.0392640866,
0.0285077058,
0.0523694754,
-0.0209564399,
0.0017970545,
0.010773534,
0.0211216547,
-0.049722895,
0.0295702107,
-0.0207445752,
-0.0121866101,
-0.0263933055,
-0.0201480277,
-0.0342856683,
0.0495669656,
0.0061066323,
-0.0630572736,
0.0391061008,
-0.0189483296,
-0.0195595101,
-0.0307248216,
0.0250697732,
-0.0001831703,
-0.0166858695,
0.0137051838,
-0.0046604448,
0.027632067,
0.1060069129,
-0.0140849184,
-0.0155640775,
0.034614671,
0.0012401241,
-0.0501556285,
0.0003274156,
0.0063174232,
-0.0526102707,
-0.0303521436,
-0.0095223505,
-0.0259437654,
0.0932275504,
-0.0324603543,
0.0070684454,
-0.0055330745,
0.0091419378,
-0.0263041556,
-0.0495687351,
0.0140514215,
0.0910421461,
-0.0392564386,
0.0189924892,
-0.0255453456,
-0.0635867789,
0.059917856,
-0.0153091094,
0.0177163202,
-0.0050895442,
-0.0345233381,
-0.0143301105,
0.0250935871,
-0.0311152227,
0.0280759744,
-0.0242814068,
-0.012256721,
0.0132587915,
-0.0176616814,
0.0365730636,
-0.0386380516,
0.0192930158,
-0.0222102534,
-0.0106256856,
-0.0271454882,
-0.0593695976,
0.0186633691,
-0.0587424897,
-0.0266546998,
-0.0515364408,
0.0339776315,
-0.0507517308,
0.0085326405,
0.0148133244,
0.0096024498,
0.0428115986,
-0.032254722,
0.0216613971,
-0.0270440578,
-0.0173947569,
0.0193127412,
0.0036159048,
-0.0050374577,
-0.0341723748,
-0.0021993611,
0.0195940211,
0.0635355636,
-0.007160543,
-0.0145006636,
0.0204232223,
0.0709226355,
0.032663703,
-0.057213556,
0.0748822093,
0.0500137955,
-0.0710347816,
-0.0116549693,
0.033627294,
-0.0108379666,
-0.0909148529,
-0.0078593278,
0.0026902196,
0.0642287433,
-0.0062150043,
0.0327452421,
-0.064394474,
-0.0462895669,
0.0137353474,
0.051701948,
0.0160762612,
0.0116443252,
-0.0375895016,
-0.0571042635,
-0.022649657,
0.047999464,
0.0035074563,
0.0474921018,
-0.0323059782,
-0.0098573826,
0.0066748192,
0.0215160809,
0.0033666419,
-0.0187671352,
-0.0197275877,
0.0061784647,
-0.036281541,
-0.0373964459,
-0.0096364059,
-0.0062457952,
-0.0155954668,
0.0719678402,
0.0067075766,
0.0369825549,
-0.0328710377,
0.0488693342,
0.0324044786,
0.0112356627,
-0.0283083562,
-0.0532623529,
0.0017501669,
0.0173173919,
-0.0349684954,
0.0312506892,
-0.0127777811,
0.0080565233,
0.0042466926,
0.0275668167,
0.0131263481,
-0.0095030032,
-0.0163997989,
-0.0429322869,
0.0095354961,
0.0141423829,
0.0078342017,
-0.0549422763,
-0.0544673726,
-0.04991493,
-0.0125706941,
-0.0440241136,
0.0351506136,
-0.0229162164,
0.0267914664,
-0.0436014012,
-0.0101365531,
0.0395555496,
-0.0330550708,
0.0335234664,
0.013454102,
0.0004489674,
0.0269147139,
0.0089116907,
-0.0878529251,
0.0136744808,
-0.042342592,
0.0089323558,
-0.0537977368,
-0.0068910322,
0.0448893905,
-0.0226390958,
0.0255136155,
0.0329639576,
-0.1240528077,
-0.0923560858,
0.0199526958,
0.0257712752,
0.0257558431,
0.0599295869,
-0.0000206468,
-0.0915253013,
0.0643871576,
0.0661586523,
-0.0677780956,
0.0633925498,
0.0459739193,
-0.0256090835,
0.0004456131,
0.0416352265,
-0.0490843132,
-0.0266626328,
0.0631676987,
0.0126372762,
-0.012617073,
-0.0735146105,
-0.0335778669,
-0.0139862662,
0.0317098498,
-0.0148075651,
-0.0446236171,
-0.0128202382,
0.0635342225,
0.0137318661,
0.0257574469,
-0.0206965096,
-0.0399609059,
-0.0114479763,
-0.0179756116,
-0.0096109621,
0.0035582765,
0.0734756812,
-0.0324255116,
-0.0375071429,
0.0320973136,
-0.0162549615,
-0.0005790846,
0.0542463623,
0.0256792121,
-0.0192312635,
0.0917130783,
-0.0129088433,
0.0227392055,
-0.0292697381,
0.0024168752,
-0.0260471758,
0.0058169086,
-0.047253944,
0.0492492318,
-0.002122147,
-0.0614932068,
-0.053107582,
0.034824945,
0.0606333725,
0.0252519734,
0.0355848931,
-0.0067096711,
-0.0211429857,
-0.0266195815,
0.0161550902,
-0.0373350047,
-0.0127782319,
-0.0279386789,
-0.0140940733,
-0.0174598899,
0.0372696072,
0.0419196747,
0.0518546551,
-0.0057296008,
0.0059448304,
0.0047084661,
-0.0462860838,
0.0041629001,
0.0120549621,
0.048476804,
-0.0137589294,
-0.0231247544,
-0.0350388773,
-0.0645516068,
0.0010930233,
-0.0047521768,
-0.0094055282,
-0.0376248248,
0.0075532226,
0.0094549749,
-0.0258899741,
-0.0382497273,
-0.0545915179,
-0.0085185338,
-0.0195578672,
-0.0040753954,
0.0249488857,
-6.604782435e-33,
-0.0108797187,
0.0305747427,
-0.0136118317,
0.0011135755,
-0.0157726239,
0.0088879522,
-0.0109162694,
0.0079015959,
0.0022383837,
-0.0376525037,
-0.0740263537,
0.0043642647,
0.0185607336,
0.0214322638,
-0.0299938824,
0.0058493759,
0.0358998217,
0.0049830195,
-0.0360356197,
0.0546856225,
0.0280097853,
0.0599039048,
0.0117488578,
-0.0053410269,
-0.0092264628,
-0.0295080002,
-0.0325417593,
-0.0174902473,
-0.046326112,
0.0452887341,
-0.0321413241,
-0.0112706367,
-0.0262022819,
0.0004440278,
-0.0171757396,
-0.0018734781,
-0.0573284626,
-0.0028349741,
0.0103051607,
0.0104371961,
-0.0132077467,
-0.0684393495,
0.0734535009,
0.0365490094,
-0.0700530037,
0.0112358667,
-0.0186877958,
-0.0011006267,
-0.0678495839,
-0.0399794169,
0.0212384965,
0.0134953093,
0.0392959006,
0.0083661163,
0.0548019111,
-0.0938566327,
-0.0649182871,
-0.0167999882,
-0.0600640737,
0.0138444835,
-0.0082882261,
0.0378924049,
0.0694926754,
0.0452893712,
0.0537433885,
0.0363653451,
0.0719007328,
0.015031307,
0.0239002015,
-0.0137929739,
0.0157436542,
0.0359168835,
-0.0423561819,
0.0293400846,
0.048815988,
-0.0431010313,
-0.0182378106,
-0.0470274277,
-0.0021437565,
-0.0254763402,
0.0583828129,
0.0307752844,
-0.0073950719,
-0.0254749358,
-0.0445435382,
0.0128770731,
-0.0346172489,
-0.0141052781,
0.0152439037,
0.0305908341,
-0.0441524312,
-0.0259298142,
0.0379269794,
-0.0393842421,
0.0335442051,
-0.0369402878,
0.0277996231,
-0.0005055342,
0.0181621127,
0.0020928108,
-0.0412731506,
-0.0288013034,
-0.0516976938,
-0.0396963097,
0.0311874375,
-0.001676347,
-0.024376655,
0.0134341074,
-0.0715198219,
-0.0102829561,
-0.0496471822,
0.0360215046,
0.0186397471,
0.0378939696,
0.0473991334,
-0.0248333681,
-0.0057874639,
0.092123352,
-0.0093658017,
0.0389141329,
-0.0117950514,
-0.0037507217,
0.0331994668,
0.0153757278,
0.0002092959,
0.0151570216,
-0.0276054237,
0.0458087139,
0.0615277402,
-0.0242656954,
-0.0209511388,
0.0103146732,
2.85e-7,
-0.042410288,
0.0188197065,
-0.036479488,
-0.0220937505,
0.0268744547,
0.0370320566,
0.0205599032,
0.0217549019,
-0.0009549232,
0.0008195048,
-0.0368975177,
0.0322125666,
0.0817954242,
0.0089037335,
-0.0542224236,
0.0290103517,
-0.0323266461,
0.079641521,
-0.0381006636,
-0.0061615878,
-0.0762784407,
0.082120128,
0.0485013723,
-0.0160323139,
0.0224408489,
0.0011512177,
0.0310950112,
-0.0315748639,
-0.0045423205,
0.005163352,
0.0181432422,
0.02985489,
-0.0454091094,
-0.0443955101,
-0.0209612027,
0.0052330918,
-0.0539289601,
0.1145881638,
0.0146525921,
-0.0215449221,
0.0206399672,
-0.0412761346,
-0.051550597,
-0.0212440249,
0.0280138496,
0.0429632179,
-0.008153379,
-0.0481823608,
0.0515931994,
-0.0712775141,
0.0230054893,
-0.0486414693,
0.0392114744,
0.0128246685,
-0.0022598011,
-0.0038075796,
-0.0273989849,
-0.0558121279,
-0.053904999,
0.0134816822,
-0.0072195851,
-0.0670233443,
-0.0666009784,
0.0602332018,
0.028264476,
-0.0493737422,
0.0509115234,
2.63131311e-34,
0.0146263065,
-0.0196781233,
0.003271143,
0.033984445,
0.0216590315,
0.0068844599,
0.0372102819,
0.02261452,
0.025565749,
-0.0870986134,
-0.0277623255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01026v1 | Augmenting Document-level Relation Extraction with Efficient Multi-Supervision | 2024-07-01T07:22:32 | 2024-07-01T07:22:32 | Xiangyu Lin, Weijia Jia, Zhiguo Gong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite its popularity in sentence-level relation extraction, distantly
supervised data is rarely utilized by existing work in document-level relation
extraction due to its noisy nature and low information density. Among its
current applications, distantly supervised data is mostly used as a whole for
pertaining, which is of low time efficiency. To fill in the gap of efficient
and robust utilization of distantly supervised training data, we propose
Efficient Multi-Supervision for document-level relation extraction, in which we
first select a subset of informative documents from the massive dataset by
combining distant supervision with expert supervision, then train the model
with Multi-Supervision Ranking Loss that integrates the knowledge from multiple
sources of supervision to alleviate the effects of noise. The experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving the model performance
with higher time efficiency than existing baselines. | Augmenting Document-level Relation Extraction with Efficient Multi-Supervision: Despite its popularity in sentence-level relation extraction, distantly
supervised data is rarely utilized by existing work in document-level relation
extraction due to its noisy nature and low information density. Among its
current applications, distantly supervised data is mostly used as a whole for
pertaining, which is of low time efficiency. To fill in the gap of efficient
and robust utilization of distantly supervised training data, we propose
Efficient Multi-Supervision for document-level relation extraction, in which we
first select a subset of informative documents from the massive dataset by
combining distant supervision with expert supervision, then train the model
with Multi-Supervision Ranking Loss that integrates the knowledge from multiple
sources of supervision to alleviate the effects of noise. The experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving the model performance
with higher time efficiency than existing baselines. | [
0.0743283406,
0.0452681147,
0.0285685621,
0.0581951328,
0.0005735271,
0.0089500453,
0.0165918004,
0.018221274,
0.0267552827,
-0.0290493816,
-0.0503187701,
-0.0024636795,
-0.0349123068,
-0.0285655763,
-0.0005830597,
-0.0375479348,
0.0153003065,
-0.0140711404,
0.0451471098,
0.0171489492,
0.0027428456,
0.0249198154,
-0.0020529828,
-0.0370470993,
-0.0712102205,
-0.0041512172,
0.0308456756,
-0.0118245464,
0.035269931,
-0.0359525606,
0.0634099469,
0.0316246115,
0.0344442837,
-0.0438710898,
0.0000016872,
-0.0242096297,
-0.0497739129,
0.0090169301,
-0.0074963383,
-0.0195477549,
-0.0097610839,
-0.0692085028,
0.0479376614,
-0.0211693719,
-0.0382006578,
-0.0127281258,
0.010960713,
0.0801259652,
0.0264266152,
0.0855203271,
-0.0343784019,
-0.0485730767,
0.057574179,
-0.041550681,
0.0150836101,
-0.0603359379,
0.031987004,
0.0240249708,
-0.0122727351,
0.034145426,
-0.0082283001,
-0.0116307372,
0.0133103468,
-0.0347963795,
0.0654637441,
0.0154982414,
0.0005585906,
0.0037527115,
-0.0144650666,
0.1018613204,
0.0050892038,
0.0332637168,
0.0335952081,
0.0254404452,
-0.02238377,
0.0484601818,
0.0026882552,
-0.0081753973,
-0.0352733321,
0.0098471344,
0.0230385102,
0.0398011915,
0.0195772331,
0.0380858369,
0.0063266503,
0.0308654029,
-0.0216142703,
-0.067941539,
0.0585331842,
0.0558870472,
-0.0218825825,
0.0355587751,
0.055821605,
0.0099893939,
-0.0299411975,
0.0196404159,
-0.0237626899,
-0.052775491,
-0.0010859985,
-0.0473739356,
-0.0246981494,
-0.0241501387,
-0.021338677,
0.0921305567,
-0.0414762571,
-0.0142560797,
-0.0116286548,
-0.0432878472,
0.0047602924,
-0.0300942566,
-0.0600983202,
0.0055061807,
-0.0184898842,
0.0627375916,
-0.0512779616,
-0.0116849123,
-0.0251277555,
-0.0210542064,
-0.0209690761,
0.0317822322,
0.0081449496,
0.0137933958,
-0.0533447936,
-0.023060713,
0.0170531813,
0.0033845096,
-0.065820545,
0.0293839183,
-0.0145394616,
0.0077324063,
-0.0099473903,
-0.0069369012,
0.0356319398,
-0.032437291,
0.0124171963,
0.0909083784,
-0.0243927632,
-0.0399769507,
-0.0150893107,
-0.0469267331,
0.0106061529,
-0.0586222596,
0.0134072537,
-0.0085946415,
0.0777558833,
0.0077543468,
-0.004289194,
-0.0065946509,
0.0488072969,
-0.0210273005,
-0.0722815841,
0.0404454358,
-0.0406521112,
-0.0257941969,
0.0017808567,
0.0374562219,
-0.0007046926,
0.0681855753,
0.0071059172,
0.0006029031,
0.0550401807,
0.0242791176,
-0.0098982835,
-0.0180324856,
0.0076891812,
-0.0165705066,
0.0135100167,
0.0099312495,
0.0172531828,
0.0137573779,
0.0473659933,
0.0177273862,
-0.0417919271,
-0.0075702486,
0.0285911337,
-0.018358143,
-0.0073654926,
0.0255754683,
0.020241037,
0.0068641636,
-0.0068033212,
0.0178087037,
-0.048370257,
0.0063712341,
-0.0082995426,
0.0170736201,
-0.0319373868,
0.0176499132,
0.0028202096,
0.0014177742,
0.0212706737,
-0.0313455015,
-0.0594002455,
0.0016492105,
0.0843059421,
0.0266324468,
-0.0081857452,
0.0465925448,
0.0810319856,
-0.0262614489,
-0.0254106335,
0.0470557176,
0.0079967268,
0.0166158378,
0.026713768,
-0.0715649948,
-0.0409615375,
-0.0174376015,
0.0266313609,
0.0154153947,
0.0235044956,
-0.0324796289,
0.0675736293,
-0.0380993411,
-0.0569900237,
0.0102743246,
0.0084124301,
0.0100333709,
0.0738345534,
0.0178372916,
0.0463422984,
-0.0234883428,
0.0072133499,
0.0335685425,
-0.0179702155,
-0.0361928605,
0.0010407334,
0.0132125914,
0.0054416517,
0.0065336325,
-0.0350601077,
-0.0447804816,
0.0560366623,
-0.0477386303,
0.0158350561,
-0.0462409928,
-0.0656216443,
-0.0446815714,
0.0167796798,
-0.021406617,
-0.0467167944,
-0.0102377925,
-0.0309453215,
-0.0267181136,
-0.0375859328,
0.0272829086,
0.029732991,
-0.0057535088,
-0.0324814096,
0.0535130575,
0.0146845896,
-0.0053972211,
0.1100780442,
0.0018780257,
-0.0004429523,
0.0295673497,
-0.0496144108,
-0.0367759243,
0.0337881446,
0.0034812188,
-0.0113028679,
0.0123549402,
-0.0168927815,
0.0212012716,
0.0332213715,
-0.0742629468,
-0.0634053275,
-0.0684087574,
0.0020322034,
-0.0003445545,
0.0420742072,
-0.0057480014,
0.0266560223,
-0.0018146639,
-0.0395844989,
-0.0362502001,
-0.0225805566,
-0.0838649198,
-0.0105568618,
0.0605113953,
0.0292803142,
0.0031517695,
-0.0351376459,
-0.0211774707,
0.0100133959,
0.0454502888,
-0.0131311212,
-0.0389387943,
0.006979581,
0.0191751812,
-0.0295008589,
0.0327561349,
-0.0128152017,
0.0251111072,
-0.0198972858,
-0.0348364748,
0.0352289006,
0.0265980456,
-0.0044178213,
0.061009407,
0.0070140697,
-0.0037332363,
-0.0202588625,
0.0412373133,
-0.0147546781,
0.0386781394,
-0.0277223215,
0.0261386335,
-0.0622347929,
0.0248558018,
-0.0097105168,
0.0065152757,
0.023469951,
-0.0024607498,
0.0351049341,
-0.0174875259,
-0.0383631587,
0.038663961,
0.0234931447,
-0.0157176182,
-0.0641493425,
-0.0022441023,
0.0620501935,
0.0069420291,
-0.0340633579,
-0.0013332274,
-0.0216972288,
-0.0298834071,
0.0694209412,
-0.0120936986,
0.0184859317,
-0.0204455834,
-0.0204506349,
-0.0286371373,
-0.0304560736,
0.0462019332,
0.0213833973,
-0.0270670541,
-0.0708689094,
0.024725277,
-0.0086932415,
-0.0298356824,
-0.0084022311,
-0.0392627604,
0.0029470513,
0.0018934625,
0.0041733701,
-0.0092500206,
0.0059306216,
-0.0233750772,
0.0229412839,
0.0413053744,
-0.0178004578,
-0.0460983552,
-0.0082967551,
0.0961028561,
0.0469744503,
-0.0345275179,
-0.0505995825,
-0.0345530696,
0.0263912436,
0.0738704354,
0.0339984745,
-0.0384963937,
-0.0015837878,
0.0308307521,
-0.0250186864,
-0.0272770245,
-0.0056489105,
-0.0388802625,
0.0271956716,
-0.0686407983,
0.0077062105,
0.072525911,
0.0167716071,
-0.0189989395,
-0.0061309454,
0.0439293124,
0.0028088635,
0.0077707209,
0.0269831065,
-0.0393431075,
-0.0177828781,
-0.0340178944,
-0.0143852234,
0.0370367505,
-0.0472363569,
0.0094606439,
-0.0404566266,
-0.0131673915,
-0.0142651023,
-0.0338728018,
-0.0269401725,
-0.0350860655,
0.0169242453,
0.0051836963,
-0.0146565726,
-0.0015671109,
-0.020797655,
-0.0204299148,
0.0097594867,
0.0058033899,
-0.0390053801,
0.0089929998,
-0.0182290897,
0.0318997167,
0.0087550161,
0.0275938399,
-0.006336675,
0.0345920287,
-0.0087307896,
-0.009100263,
-0.009486502,
-0.0339958742,
0.0931188613,
-0.0550354719,
-0.004070193,
0.0052676364,
0.0101751545,
-0.0517536998,
0.0416819155,
0.030543495,
0.0185198933,
0.0230276156,
-0.0141725829,
0.0094372164,
-0.0355573036,
0.0108063854,
0.0285358131,
-0.0099951178,
-0.011301592,
-0.0282885004,
0.0364243016,
0.0112802377,
-0.0068274555,
0.0331815518,
-0.0191139728,
-0.0758260638,
-0.0251633264,
-0.0496522635,
-0.075246416,
0.0293748658,
0.0389258079,
-0.0047534932,
0.0108147757,
0.0169325713,
0.0042917016,
-0.0092555936,
0.0183457769,
-0.0139474412,
-0.0236347765,
0.0327517688,
-0.0086721824,
0.0576343611,
0.0004184433,
-0.0134687582,
-0.0540366098,
-0.0257080384,
-0.028195668,
-0.0341756716,
0.005402653,
0.0080046197,
0.0672128871,
-0.0006949201,
-0.0031267221,
0.0262299441,
0.0542344116,
-0.0981528461,
-0.0058783544,
0.0740550831,
-0.0354109704,
0.0067251599,
0.0398682393,
-0.0421291515,
0.0404797271,
0.0224279091,
0.0206707269,
-0.0538833663,
0.0022360198,
-0.0093674157,
-0.0172718279,
0.0679369941,
0.0076781884,
0.0433934815,
-0.0305997506,
0.0446350724,
-0.0485958382,
-0.0305214878,
-0.0318635851,
0.0602464937,
0.005451919,
0.0245827697,
-0.008681356,
-0.0009671195,
0.0392500274,
0.0200447571,
-0.0142178591,
-0.0246662889,
-0.003749751,
-0.013318181,
0.0130348941,
0.0004850267,
-0.0381152853,
0.0028148175,
0.0248749312,
0.0031178512,
-0.0309674647,
0.0099853361,
0.0246555861,
-0.0104668764,
0.008731219,
-0.0155308526,
-0.0589109249,
0.0260594562,
-0.0262124669,
0.0539724715,
0.0633164048,
-0.0540415533,
0.0366446972,
-0.0276901759,
-0.0003808106,
0.0243791603,
0.0371982083,
-0.0046351841,
0.0222348105,
-0.008734379,
0.0141046764,
-0.0029265392,
0.0783995613,
0.0967576355,
0.0199650973,
0.036196582,
0.0330311172,
-0.0302038305,
-0.0562279001,
0.0052651265,
0.0384824872,
0.0367838368,
-0.0053599542,
0.027459152,
0.0097560603,
-0.013275208,
0.0068058884,
-0.0656158105,
-0.0405299179,
0.0179761276,
0.0397670977,
0.0299322251,
0.0055590835,
-0.0340258889,
-0.0500106998,
-0.0030987724,
0.0262260344,
-0.0148260333,
-0.023516614,
-6.158418577e-33,
-0.0328423716,
-0.0454098508,
-0.012184687,
-0.013563904,
-0.0317945927,
0.0623902529,
-0.0283191446,
-0.0416857414,
-0.0045028566,
0.054811772,
-0.03540764,
0.0198201146,
0.0049652685,
0.0250179656,
0.0113445967,
-0.0192402676,
0.0168213621,
0.0069571217,
0.063828297,
0.0310564116,
0.0279617757,
0.0622648224,
0.078205198,
-0.113007769,
0.0370145179,
-0.0070454925,
-0.0263584387,
0.0097830575,
0.037318062,
0.0240870435,
-0.0142172575,
0.013402245,
0.0300910026,
-0.0160635635,
0.0214634165,
-0.0134581309,
-0.1399946213,
-0.0297525935,
-0.0492115207,
-0.0386360437,
-0.0334367752,
0.0007742544,
-0.0033585811,
0.0132949734,
0.1123439223,
-0.0553109385,
0.0453624278,
-0.0423424318,
-0.0692077354,
-0.1053945348,
-0.0378054678,
0.0394718237,
0.0079066027,
0.025653502,
0.0233122259,
0.0171950534,
0.0214747582,
-0.0260872319,
0.0132760089,
-0.0466504879,
0.0031126384,
0.024754744,
-0.0231857542,
-0.0186295193,
-0.0395436659,
0.0379738621,
-0.011205704,
-0.0086467322,
0.0076896506,
-0.0132530415,
-0.0175875742,
0.0734959692,
-0.0228996631,
-0.0081611602,
0.0277391709,
0.0081147421,
-0.1007881835,
0.0015168734,
0.0603927784,
0.0360965952,
-0.0279607698,
0.0034572307,
-0.0414794497,
-0.0101607451,
0.0328323729,
0.0164929964,
0.0022905637,
-0.0211600326,
-0.0125622274,
0.0314977728,
-0.0152783664,
0.0152418483,
-0.0407909714,
-0.040122129,
-0.0135728791,
0.0412837267,
-0.0087510878,
0.0052649882,
0.0062088617,
-0.0455927104,
-0.0616108701,
-0.0619436465,
-0.0129900631,
-0.0230041202,
0.0010961927,
-0.0002273663,
0.087040551,
-0.0355546512,
-0.0632128119,
-0.0339560919,
-0.0037890412,
-0.0024027077,
-0.0006195591,
0.0347980075,
-0.0202974249,
-0.0059309257,
-0.0220672991,
0.0791994259,
0.0516031682,
0.0614277162,
-0.0349498577,
0.0042014909,
-0.0008006112,
0.0210514627,
0.0200194009,
-0.017243633,
-0.0171077233,
-0.0171642732,
0.0296302456,
-0.0237374734,
-0.0032232744,
-0.0243634954,
2.412e-7,
0.0132999644,
0.0373112746,
0.0267292019,
-0.024953397,
0.0043402025,
0.0224158559,
0.0134068951,
0.0575663336,
-0.0473611727,
-0.0087369662,
0.0552639738,
0.0022361779,
0.0312875547,
0.0403239764,
-0.0822874084,
-0.0636958331,
-0.0878010467,
-0.0749776512,
-0.0624521859,
-0.0245171841,
0.0543665104,
0.0477887169,
0.031765271,
0.0038550675,
-0.0478184521,
-0.0463992395,
0.0666216388,
-0.0311888233,
-0.0089455713,
0.0315413289,
0.0733796582,
0.0159457773,
-0.0389931947,
0.0469717607,
-0.0367106982,
0.039715182,
0.015771877,
0.0711715892,
-0.0142436633,
0.040305946,
0.021924004,
0.005461223,
0.0134418821,
0.0491818823,
0.0515878312,
-0.0296798907,
0.0272956863,
0.0165735893,
-0.0163925141,
-0.0124467695,
-0.0208039507,
0.0109246755,
-0.0153900068,
0.0350028723,
0.0224815141,
-0.0239933114,
-0.0432449318,
-0.0695542023,
0.0321501568,
0.0728645995,
0.0167317912,
-0.0398021676,
0.038518548,
-0.0177598707,
-0.0003370886,
-0.0266396459,
-0.0047763442,
2.009461675e-34,
0.001013372,
-0.0028828802,
-0.0137622897,
0.0472772606,
0.0335204564,
-0.0302274954,
-0.0695908442,
-0.0162067898,
-0.0119126374,
-0.0414243452,
0.0247772597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01009v1 | DynaThink: Fast or Slow? A Dynamic Decision-Making Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T06:45:13 | 2024-07-01T06:45:13 | Jiabao Pan, Yan Zhang, Chen Zhang, Zuozhu Liu, Hongwei Wang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated emergent capabilities across
diverse reasoning tasks via popular Chains-of-Thought (COT) prompting. However,
such a simple and fast COT approach often encounters limitations in dealing
with complicated problems, while a thorough method, which considers multiple
reasoning pathways and verifies each step carefully, results in slower
inference. This paper addresses the challenge of enabling LLMs to autonomously
select between fast and slow inference methods, thereby optimizing both
efficiency and effectiveness. We introduce a dynamic decision-making framework
that categorizes tasks into two distinct pathways: 'Fast', designated for tasks
where the LLM quickly identifies a high-confidence solution, and 'Slow',
allocated for tasks that the LLM perceives as complex and for which it has low
confidence in immediate solutions as well as requiring more reasoning paths to
verify. Experiments on five popular reasoning benchmarks demonstrated the
superiority of the DynaThink over baselines. | DynaThink: Fast or Slow? A Dynamic Decision-Making Framework for Large Language Models: Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated emergent capabilities across
diverse reasoning tasks via popular Chains-of-Thought (COT) prompting. However,
such a simple and fast COT approach often encounters limitations in dealing
with complicated problems, while a thorough method, which considers multiple
reasoning pathways and verifies each step carefully, results in slower
inference. This paper addresses the challenge of enabling LLMs to autonomously
select between fast and slow inference methods, thereby optimizing both
efficiency and effectiveness. We introduce a dynamic decision-making framework
that categorizes tasks into two distinct pathways: 'Fast', designated for tasks
where the LLM quickly identifies a high-confidence solution, and 'Slow',
allocated for tasks that the LLM perceives as complex and for which it has low
confidence in immediate solutions as well as requiring more reasoning paths to
verify. Experiments on five popular reasoning benchmarks demonstrated the
superiority of the DynaThink over baselines. | [
0.0422875248,
0.0526607819,
-0.021602625,
0.0355815813,
-0.090971306,
0.0273831598,
-0.0001575207,
-0.0253082532,
0.0129261259,
-0.0455559082,
0.0112954462,
-0.0239695571,
0.0028540194,
0.015407484,
-0.0084397588,
-0.0354177281,
0.0296955612,
-0.0953328833,
0.0216400977,
-0.0257187113,
-0.0206297748,
0.0045006,
-0.0313499197,
0.0351940095,
0.000824336,
-0.0263036564,
-0.0143623482,
-0.0017900892,
0.018508032,
-0.0347101651,
-0.0172168277,
0.0742776319,
0.0048218369,
0.0650759265,
0.000002305,
-0.0640805289,
-0.0172497854,
-0.0214874856,
-0.0431958139,
0.004239114,
0.0028046749,
0.0208004378,
0.0114584565,
0.042916555,
-0.0311403591,
-0.0095790224,
0.0049731378,
-0.0161241349,
0.0179699697,
0.0239134599,
0.0046025151,
-0.0156382676,
-0.0403022207,
-0.0405309387,
-0.0477045774,
-0.0667870492,
0.0364088602,
0.021022927,
0.0434372351,
-0.0202959087,
-0.0149255991,
0.0231787823,
0.0243554227,
-0.0032340696,
-0.0279853046,
0.0341211259,
-0.033453878,
-0.0254172385,
-0.0007009195,
0.0685502142,
-0.0457874276,
-0.0120289838,
0.0001448577,
-0.0202169027,
-0.0036302153,
0.0216590725,
-0.0387557037,
0.0252176877,
-0.0293031689,
0.0070494553,
0.0267538,
0.0086424183,
0.0414347425,
0.0402721316,
-0.0717521384,
0.096697174,
0.0051246835,
0.009174712,
0.0341284201,
0.0296862721,
0.0077076722,
-0.1049046144,
0.0005881116,
0.0425043814,
-0.0576027483,
0.0212441925,
-0.0106986314,
0.0187278669,
-0.0002001015,
-0.0297429319,
0.0212641396,
0.0396899991,
0.026652215,
0.0479490124,
-0.0472895652,
0.0113514969,
-0.0624276139,
-0.0123403538,
-0.0121780671,
-0.0134260291,
-0.0420884006,
0.0058245813,
-0.0283249095,
0.0320351981,
-0.0026430825,
-0.0260077156,
-0.0490531437,
0.0326880626,
-0.0192428362,
0.0069995439,
0.0025638519,
-0.0082609262,
0.0441386178,
-0.0504022688,
-0.0736141801,
0.036121197,
-0.0407572165,
0.0355781801,
0.0147375623,
-0.0175625309,
0.0094445301,
0.0031865526,
-0.001564452,
-0.0290915724,
0.0226373971,
0.0918004811,
-0.0145043517,
-0.0026948352,
-0.0533968806,
-0.0424718708,
-0.0239209961,
-0.0968878493,
-0.0130196661,
-0.0901678503,
-0.0280893166,
0.0489264391,
0.0032521926,
-0.0117433388,
0.0236004684,
-0.0019827972,
-0.0299701393,
0.0535003617,
0.0280311089,
0.0323802419,
0.0071045021,
0.0204953104,
-0.0436056778,
0.0829005912,
0.0324401297,
0.0570776202,
0.0051210378,
0.0450382233,
0.0304518826,
0.0378961973,
0.0015237849,
0.0042067994,
-0.0468074381,
0.0113733197,
-0.023249818,
0.0276207123,
-0.0134727079,
0.0558515191,
-0.0214354284,
0.0557287671,
0.0630934909,
0.0424418189,
0.0245510228,
-0.0026186272,
0.0552012473,
-0.0233120285,
-0.0095126573,
-0.0035773925,
-0.0453954004,
0.036099229,
-0.0189345218,
0.0042914627,
0.0048147789,
0.0649656579,
-0.0056662047,
-0.0239944793,
-0.0224133171,
0.0116510699,
0.0051428098,
0.0539539605,
0.0518449247,
-0.0180174466,
-0.003698431,
0.0313555337,
0.0185641255,
0.0028621706,
-0.0426245406,
-0.0748086944,
0.0319777094,
0.0537041984,
0.0538368635,
0.0110294372,
-0.0421745852,
0.0108070178,
0.0180843472,
0.0210484546,
0.0079762032,
-0.0155085018,
-0.0289066788,
-0.0440374278,
-0.0451630279,
0.0065279691,
0.0068324315,
0.0118059618,
0.0437216423,
0.0242589079,
0.0023404018,
-0.001704872,
0.0084942654,
0.0064761662,
-0.0054545426,
0.0061450712,
0.0052854721,
0.0331339985,
0.0200857576,
-0.0136620626,
-0.0052060746,
0.0177935418,
-0.0225819349,
-0.0198432263,
-0.0399961025,
0.020866951,
-0.0298532173,
-0.0063420185,
0.0405047722,
-0.0027907514,
-0.0347787514,
-0.0251554865,
-0.021909846,
-0.038337376,
0.0323781557,
-0.0304159913,
-0.0203631837,
-0.0189886969,
0.0325341485,
-0.0327573307,
-0.0059238798,
-0.0238649826,
0.1089831218,
-0.0085716192,
0.0020795157,
0.0627242103,
0.0202136971,
0.0113399271,
-0.0133538479,
-0.0056844465,
0.0448033735,
0.002308731,
-0.0140811587,
0.0248322655,
-0.001699032,
-0.0445830934,
-0.0345496088,
-0.0333232395,
-0.0259540938,
-0.0016856539,
0.0178898927,
-0.0273083653,
0.0011473867,
-0.0198433604,
0.0088825999,
-0.0238181818,
0.0214213375,
0.0111942906,
0.0344448984,
-0.0031100591,
0.0027254343,
-0.0439790487,
-0.0027701848,
-0.0034729592,
-0.0133800963,
0.0538925603,
0.0021486017,
-0.033053834,
-0.0210403483,
0.0077218092,
-0.0413296819,
0.0275002755,
0.0032043518,
-0.031326592,
0.0185764898,
-0.024448188,
0.066926226,
0.0616323128,
-0.0174378622,
-0.0316519663,
0.0970215052,
-0.0405723713,
-0.0526210554,
0.0213367492,
-0.0202157311,
0.0105960062,
-0.023983499,
0.0007381114,
-0.0545065776,
0.0673541501,
-0.002250893,
-0.0229257774,
-0.0466285907,
0.0177121889,
-0.0144500881,
-0.0284790918,
-0.0282077212,
-0.031032376,
0.0210863575,
0.0980142951,
0.0025280111,
-0.0338260382,
0.0994369984,
-0.0141441207,
0.0274626706,
-0.0209376607,
-0.0113227321,
-0.0392729491,
0.0841439739,
-0.0267541818,
0.0052536344,
0.005294099,
-0.0206139479,
-0.0478968732,
0.000123798,
0.0353624448,
-0.0354219377,
0.0732547715,
-0.079428032,
0.0223401599,
-0.0074637914,
-0.0582294837,
-0.0584878772,
0.0191670153,
-0.0876383036,
0.0000061874,
0.010954353,
-0.0386940725,
-0.0252153836,
0.0049209958,
0.039679382,
0.0506629869,
-0.0094737522,
-0.0011771232,
-0.0205097068,
0.03079696,
0.0400920138,
-0.0126809478,
0.04838809,
-0.0154608535,
0.0629917607,
0.0551507175,
0.0461536273,
0.0017763183,
-0.0467745103,
-0.0073179817,
0.0110460762,
-0.0117396824,
-0.0098846788,
0.0232417546,
-0.0000751445,
-0.0579156987,
-0.0238950904,
0.121318534,
0.0267987307,
-0.0638072342,
0.0107192956,
-0.0379627943,
0.0316024572,
0.0322141573,
0.0349724405,
-0.1035901308,
-0.0537289865,
0.0352538712,
-0.0068436372,
-0.036970973,
-0.0583657175,
0.000903917,
-0.1150215939,
0.0325744264,
-0.0136090172,
0.0292203762,
0.0166342575,
-0.0148348287,
0.0135871246,
0.0156969931,
-0.0267026722,
0.014528566,
0.0170599762,
-0.0064981906,
0.0190059617,
0.0005685295,
-0.0272826273,
0.0531266183,
-0.03268205,
0.0242001358,
0.0107632959,
0.0088328896,
0.0357603393,
-0.0447350629,
0.0523632914,
-0.0080175847,
0.0077896984,
-0.022654742,
-0.0245052185,
0.0233544353,
0.0012593684,
-0.0264824834,
0.0316334367,
-0.0297961924,
-0.026179295,
0.0067952871,
0.1167608649,
-0.0276815929,
-0.0184194315,
-0.0219528619,
0.0074503189,
-0.0049207602,
0.0585518964,
0.013543847,
-0.0340794958,
-0.0536093265,
0.0026232901,
-0.0681450069,
-0.0125587927,
-0.0469294451,
0.0133903502,
0.0266368072,
0.0087420121,
-0.0483641401,
0.0152157461,
0.0346038081,
0.0747495815,
-0.0112508312,
0.0302974042,
0.0227402654,
0.0403237976,
-0.0289741568,
0.0135854911,
-0.0323658735,
0.0397188477,
-0.0545846075,
0.0268871002,
0.019276781,
-0.0107547231,
-0.0263414551,
0.0729661882,
-0.0935107842,
-0.0842151791,
-0.0269066319,
0.0209689159,
0.044421982,
0.018050354,
-0.0512081534,
-0.0585582517,
0.0468759798,
0.0038591167,
0.0075440924,
-0.0038536016,
-0.0025355511,
0.0263768043,
0.0106478846,
0.0597067662,
-0.0198638067,
0.0216671862,
0.0240460783,
0.0488045402,
-0.0118683754,
-0.0350012258,
-0.000909109,
0.0083348025,
0.0067486484,
-0.0367029049,
-0.0171368588,
-0.0233703367,
0.0402601399,
-0.0100498255,
-0.0554503165,
-0.026258925,
0.0210568663,
0.0221128054,
-0.0047069434,
0.0100943157,
-0.0496333577,
0.0238846038,
0.0040110103,
-0.0135210082,
-0.0138195017,
0.0315525047,
0.0452409089,
0.0569023676,
-0.0319761746,
-0.0011219026,
-0.0003972064,
0.0060641714,
0.04091857,
-0.0294474754,
0.0643720254,
0.0306031592,
-0.0466149226,
-0.0653528422,
-0.0023908447,
-0.0687678754,
-0.0998448506,
0.021660028,
0.0248695686,
0.0600859895,
0.027111752,
0.0046119196,
-0.0595723204,
-0.0237646662,
0.0138861164,
0.0160985012,
0.014975192,
-0.0288954768,
0.0158805251,
0.0252689514,
-0.0141610317,
0.0084579876,
0.0577593595,
-0.0158394631,
0.0144952843,
0.0205004271,
-0.0587383248,
-0.0266855154,
-0.0647182316,
-0.0654085279,
0.0080242353,
-0.0262796246,
0.0488904491,
-0.0923653245,
-0.0777739361,
-0.0184210483,
0.009402913,
0.0000108232,
-0.0128007717,
0.0136692729,
0.0584422536,
0.0332597606,
-0.0397994705,
-0.0245506652,
0.0102417255,
-0.0052254191,
-0.0156819243,
-0.0168519393,
-6.809568245e-33,
0.0287714768,
-0.0443881527,
0.0440502279,
-0.0335248671,
-0.0185889117,
0.0152915558,
-0.0363078862,
0.0365831777,
-0.0168437529,
0.0258028619,
-0.0178449489,
0.0156863462,
0.0132423453,
0.0065269344,
0.0194297805,
0.0133971255,
-0.0077004079,
0.0142870219,
-0.0333460085,
0.0114388112,
0.0556254946,
-0.0050428752,
0.006995101,
-0.0418831185,
-0.0248826351,
0.0217563137,
-0.0041087014,
0.0406651646,
-0.0495537817,
0.0403538868,
-0.0111440439,
0.0009455439,
0.0264667161,
-0.0385094918,
0.0017460139,
0.0297553558,
-0.0396305248,
-0.0044041891,
0.0249891467,
-0.0174805243,
-0.0302845854,
-0.0228308924,
-0.0074001057,
0.0374667197,
-0.0091295037,
-0.0064230133,
-0.0110542336,
-0.0436167754,
-0.0100846486,
-0.0191794652,
-0.0525838919,
0.0326132514,
0.0135470815,
-0.0250087343,
0.018112544,
0.0525515564,
-0.0254820623,
0.0018740974,
-0.0272136591,
0.0065263147,
0.0288443696,
0.0090392837,
0.0941369832,
0.001484688,
-0.0130277928,
0.0367925093,
0.000437302,
-0.0165586565,
-0.0267398227,
-0.0077551603,
0.0087083206,
0.0773480684,
0.0496702008,
0.0204809867,
-0.0024054404,
0.0465773642,
-0.0908022001,
-0.0247495603,
0.0582806617,
0.0465295799,
0.0828878433,
0.0158135928,
-0.0380165353,
-0.0249210559,
-0.0461086966,
0.0026629071,
-0.054689765,
0.0016124569,
0.0130490484,
0.0130902631,
-0.0206848327,
0.0068097874,
0.0423043035,
-0.0286550652,
-0.0353816487,
0.0431562662,
-0.0050594709,
0.0484787077,
0.0102515072,
0.0464903526,
-0.0132594556,
-0.0047557461,
-0.0018815454,
0.016999742,
-0.0128289806,
-0.0035602206,
-0.0216643028,
0.006243329,
-0.0370563753,
-0.0078152288,
-0.0721898824,
0.0360244177,
-0.0055507715,
0.0116977589,
0.0469420515,
0.0068469993,
-0.0022909923,
0.0111891022,
0.0129182916,
-0.0167027377,
0.0019205556,
0.0582922138,
0.0088886796,
0.023896113,
-0.0109728994,
-0.0229246207,
-0.0445912071,
-0.0162631907,
0.0294990707,
-0.0402712189,
0.0002468948,
0.0435391553,
3.058e-7,
0.0020073785,
0.0541860387,
-0.009856048,
0.0318193808,
0.0344678797,
0.0285521802,
-0.0076918616,
-0.0267919153,
0.0145759825,
-0.045972053,
0.0021350384,
0.0452468731,
0.0508347191,
0.0577444024,
-0.050953228,
-0.0288538504,
-0.0348840244,
-0.0049884194,
-0.0579865724,
-0.0323895104,
0.0023473985,
0.0637155324,
0.0131034637,
-0.0231655855,
0.0064723599,
-0.043191921,
0.044275023,
-0.0047963946,
0.0377886444,
0.0198583808,
0.0372839421,
-0.0128913363,
0.0294876378,
0.0462518185,
0.0154757621,
0.036703866,
-0.0349755734,
0.0471083336,
0.0294575877,
0.0036325892,
-0.0283419415,
-0.0426513329,
0.0304114055,
-0.081856437,
0.0803245008,
-0.0776201487,
-0.036299061,
-0.0139487199,
0.0467361882,
-0.0386088826,
0.0003440912,
0.0124989813,
0.0018307851,
0.0399235263,
0.0148930931,
-0.0005384335,
-0.0110649858,
-0.1146194562,
-0.015253921,
0.0064773429,
-0.0629067495,
-0.0282988474,
-0.0339401998,
-0.0116599211,
0.0290655829,
-0.0500903353,
0.0142209157,
3.064053218e-34,
0.0124390936,
-0.0093884459,
-0.0066080107,
0.0468169004,
0.0300402753,
0.0053676283,
-0.0377390012,
0.0170606486,
0.0251743235,
-0.1130150035,
-0.0349935889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00997v1 | Engineering Conversational Search Systems: A Review of Applications, Architectures, and Functional Components | 2024-07-01T06:24:11 | 2024-07-01T06:24:11 | Phillip Schneider, Wessel Poelman, Michael Rovatsos, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational search systems enable information retrieval via natural
language interactions, with the goal of maximizing users' information gain over
multiple dialogue turns. The increasing prevalence of conversational interfaces
adopting this search paradigm challenges traditional information retrieval
approaches, stressing the importance of better understanding the engineering
process of developing these systems. We undertook a systematic literature
review to investigate the links between theoretical studies and technical
implementations of conversational search systems. Our review identifies
real-world application scenarios, system architectures, and functional
components. We consolidate our results by presenting a layered architecture
framework and explaining the core functions of conversational search systems.
Furthermore, we reflect on our findings in light of the rapid progress in large
language models, discussing their capabilities, limitations, and directions for
future research. | Engineering Conversational Search Systems: A Review of Applications, Architectures, and Functional Components: Conversational search systems enable information retrieval via natural
language interactions, with the goal of maximizing users' information gain over
multiple dialogue turns. The increasing prevalence of conversational interfaces
adopting this search paradigm challenges traditional information retrieval
approaches, stressing the importance of better understanding the engineering
process of developing these systems. We undertook a systematic literature
review to investigate the links between theoretical studies and technical
implementations of conversational search systems. Our review identifies
real-world application scenarios, system architectures, and functional
components. We consolidate our results by presenting a layered architecture
framework and explaining the core functions of conversational search systems.
Furthermore, we reflect on our findings in light of the rapid progress in large
language models, discussing their capabilities, limitations, and directions for
future research. | [
0.1029319838,
-0.0063677635,
-0.0402861647,
0.0443121977,
-0.0379930325,
-0.0517568886,
0.0125273913,
0.0185487978,
0.0294415746,
-0.0490621328,
-0.0475716852,
-0.0156389512,
-0.0109757315,
0.0334079601,
-0.0154016847,
-0.0459441468,
0.0513239652,
-0.0100786174,
0.0224207044,
0.0449930876,
0.0390670002,
-0.0106109558,
-0.002840952,
0.0541654229,
-0.0014450097,
0.0207080636,
-0.0551271029,
0.0163831096,
-0.0417371243,
-0.0192400087,
0.0081036659,
0.0115660196,
-0.0127430176,
0.0786330998,
0.0000017284,
-0.032881964,
-0.0277058426,
0.00868956,
-0.0293271206,
-0.0208638776,
0.0544954203,
0.0630660281,
0.0093282815,
0.0289196447,
-0.0355875231,
-0.0165440012,
0.064694196,
0.0449117646,
0.0234846622,
0.0164582916,
-0.0002696741,
0.0006260179,
-0.0081194146,
-0.0004039617,
0.0067807962,
-0.0616255812,
0.0003312083,
0.0038986888,
0.0790628344,
0.0495900773,
0.0321828276,
0.0526646711,
-0.0550101064,
-0.0500214472,
0.0245319288,
0.0086711058,
-0.0509536043,
-0.0375417136,
-0.0127770361,
0.0150174871,
0.0294011794,
0.0022223694,
-0.0020994726,
0.0106009645,
0.0040553571,
0.0072372062,
-0.0346827023,
-0.0232292153,
-0.0492938608,
-0.0290568527,
-0.0515896715,
0.0101862662,
0.0107929045,
0.0130798882,
-0.0235710498,
0.0495088696,
0.0192866921,
-0.02990878,
-0.0082906336,
-0.0449894443,
0.038924925,
-0.054927744,
0.0621613674,
0.0399139524,
-0.090069212,
0.0382342152,
0.0275156181,
-0.0039587906,
0.0216911566,
-0.049314633,
-0.0281110909,
0.031483274,
0.0076054609,
0.0373283587,
0.0639950559,
0.0179093741,
0.0084103914,
-0.0493331142,
-0.026421342,
-0.0519344099,
-0.0226751715,
-0.0423463508,
-0.0554925837,
0.032604441,
-0.0793205276,
-0.0607645623,
0.0004937373,
0.0564426892,
0.0403715,
-0.0225548167,
-0.0032107173,
0.0219147522,
-0.0235871673,
0.0123921307,
-0.0664458647,
0.0237523671,
-0.0122713102,
-0.0258503295,
0.0097216712,
-0.0795727372,
0.0266677104,
-0.0030024636,
0.0317866057,
-0.0074279066,
-0.0320110098,
0.0221770313,
0.0002179919,
-0.0757496506,
0.0074378937,
-0.0128617929,
-0.0197447501,
-0.0112493159,
-0.0234549604,
-0.0216828622,
0.0413680263,
0.0095859589,
-0.0121527463,
0.0149186747,
0.0267955083,
0.0829596296,
-0.0042311046,
0.0664710104,
-0.0243765656,
-0.002208912,
0.0675145835,
0.0217326209,
0.0283444691,
0.0661713108,
0.0094838599,
0.0214776732,
0.0594320595,
0.0058979867,
0.0239394736,
0.0044218558,
-0.030530991,
-0.0532235466,
0.0542128645,
0.0647569746,
-0.0386235602,
0.0472344235,
-0.0335242562,
0.0472397394,
-0.0452609435,
0.0058309678,
0.0331340842,
0.1003483981,
0.0137155307,
-0.0046939119,
0.0022149389,
0.0325374827,
-0.0003041426,
-0.0092966892,
-0.0099977022,
0.0202925839,
-0.0382983834,
-0.0520358346,
0.035676755,
-0.0163097996,
-0.0121610546,
-0.0405840985,
0.0104199713,
0.0477879532,
-0.0001173484,
0.0140814632,
0.0221414007,
-0.0073874583,
-0.0001175912,
0.0201243926,
-0.0100114681,
-0.047735095,
-0.0141234556,
-0.0373108461,
-0.0041494458,
0.1235052422,
0.0950575992,
-0.0111744935,
-0.0030842752,
0.0678889751,
-0.0121860243,
0.0511804372,
0.0338869765,
-0.0026224921,
0.0056973021,
-0.0118354615,
-0.019738093,
0.0411470272,
-0.0206457917,
-0.0032933038,
-0.0238534696,
0.0020714609,
0.0039772987,
0.0106765162,
0.0107141938,
-0.0065298043,
-0.0100098187,
0.0166526735,
-0.0255819038,
0.0315847173,
-0.016427651,
0.0163687468,
0.0010829966,
0.0208100528,
0.0245096106,
0.0493482612,
-0.0199651867,
0.0097196102,
-0.0021827065,
0.0093163094,
-0.0242784377,
-0.0346039906,
0.0275678411,
-0.0171879418,
0.0463832431,
-0.0467091091,
-0.0127045363,
-0.0823103711,
0.0711576194,
-0.0168429073,
0.0362402536,
0.0038854564,
-0.0149613479,
-0.0478389189,
0.0267402586,
0.0405570753,
0.0015783531,
0.0048091002,
0.0060764728,
0.0237249602,
-0.0950217843,
-0.0279443953,
0.0324369296,
0.0124766538,
-0.0118255029,
0.0351594649,
-0.0336879194,
-0.0272299387,
-0.0213739872,
-0.1300209314,
0.0085499026,
-0.0074330592,
-0.012323577,
-0.0215538032,
0.0800691471,
0.0086323293,
-0.0354622714,
0.0046325922,
0.0026697754,
0.0351009779,
0.023556741,
0.0183660295,
0.0629724711,
-0.0434180796,
-0.0826969594,
-0.0190594308,
0.0146137336,
0.0136015993,
0.0247889049,
-0.0353336409,
-0.0533105545,
-0.0053904303,
-0.0606694147,
0.0553928614,
-0.010606166,
-0.0094383918,
0.0456112474,
-0.0157038085,
0.0118880132,
0.0244506039,
0.0449735373,
0.0501992255,
-0.0010302436,
-0.059894558,
-0.0908442363,
0.0401329882,
-0.0318276472,
0.0031353855,
-0.021736335,
-0.0101730963,
0.0439919084,
-0.0289532095,
-0.0247779116,
0.0247742515,
-0.0258092228,
0.010187936,
0.045553647,
-0.0282227378,
-0.0432004966,
-0.0296090171,
-0.0185703021,
0.0522986986,
-0.0182839744,
-0.0205711313,
0.0227659903,
-0.0290092193,
-0.0258736573,
-0.0600658469,
-0.0117360838,
-0.0112863043,
0.0488206111,
-0.0347581767,
-0.0018661254,
0.0418285392,
-0.0449973717,
0.0000663077,
0.011878524,
0.0269602891,
-0.0632243454,
0.0334922299,
-0.0144045167,
0.023809582,
0.0606794134,
-0.0553601682,
-0.0191463009,
-0.0164061934,
-0.0326807313,
-0.0187955201,
0.0487863459,
-0.0544907823,
-0.0710537806,
0.0335429199,
0.0325603522,
0.02438768,
0.0131887542,
-0.0457181744,
-0.0218664538,
0.0108417487,
0.0295000412,
0.0010061442,
0.0179439094,
0.0577577427,
0.0396327972,
0.0485279709,
0.0470327213,
-0.0495908,
-0.0024261835,
-0.0675541684,
0.0854560658,
-0.0399255343,
-0.0460864194,
0.009949713,
0.0023970476,
-0.0111201433,
-0.028295638,
0.0789003745,
0.062517859,
-0.06211311,
-0.0280302204,
-0.0412480943,
0.0136900041,
0.019386515,
0.057027664,
-0.0187824052,
-0.0101313181,
0.0123512223,
0.0365498737,
-0.0177664366,
-0.0097931968,
-0.0271816514,
-0.0792770907,
0.0345155522,
-0.0286795795,
0.0078664105,
-0.0132864676,
-0.0463666283,
0.0251704324,
0.0114396466,
-0.0065415688,
0.0244935006,
-0.0330910869,
-0.0199895296,
-0.0345085375,
-0.0269535929,
-0.000770706,
0.0268798582,
-0.022889372,
0.0048884125,
0.0609999523,
0.0575674586,
0.0349881835,
-0.0016080022,
0.0162258986,
-0.0105887167,
0.0287411697,
-0.0451231264,
0.0275768526,
-0.0357821807,
0.0249321684,
-0.0885567591,
-0.0431987233,
0.0302122813,
0.0164847765,
0.0025890081,
0.020143481,
-0.0539753325,
0.065233998,
-0.0429988429,
0.0142466789,
0.0367385447,
0.0543290302,
-0.001735723,
-0.0239876173,
-0.0269078128,
-0.0241095033,
0.010659026,
-0.0007792743,
-0.0315589532,
-0.0229382552,
0.0041134041,
0.0164811183,
-0.0335743651,
-0.0498706438,
-0.0266027469,
0.0049556736,
-0.0110570397,
0.016743619,
0.0309437718,
0.0452517383,
0.0262441151,
-0.0003250744,
-0.0206217244,
0.0201257095,
-0.0205418635,
0.0170753524,
0.0346601382,
-0.0589975454,
-0.0022090818,
-0.0081581883,
0.0020757923,
-0.0311841834,
-0.022387607,
0.027575139,
0.0237798616,
0.0151513657,
-0.0427788384,
-0.0806240439,
-0.0318467021,
0.0131100118,
-0.0194339436,
-0.0179615077,
-0.0044010626,
0.0220972281,
0.0213697366,
0.0259078536,
-0.0559540205,
0.0057297465,
-0.0503799915,
0.0132214781,
-0.031397637,
-0.0935472697,
0.0172042921,
0.0237346217,
0.0388434306,
0.0277076177,
0.0014778066,
0.0095805041,
0.0547453649,
-0.0549446009,
-0.0325485244,
-0.0485587381,
0.0103833228,
-0.0458726585,
-0.0119150197,
0.032290332,
0.0268712956,
-0.0499145575,
0.0564740971,
-0.013932528,
0.0424955115,
0.0030015428,
-0.035174638,
0.0213879328,
0.0103423418,
0.0160991754,
0.0338359326,
0.0186606813,
0.0638130382,
-0.0337260067,
0.0694326609,
0.0094343573,
-0.0806517377,
-0.0030081626,
0.0448269993,
-0.124939017,
-0.0399295352,
0.016301332,
0.0196323488,
-0.000221075,
0.0230790786,
-0.0111416765,
-0.0494489633,
0.0274136942,
-0.0095550837,
-0.0091624428,
0.0072517949,
-0.0251438804,
-0.0043473332,
0.0351750404,
0.0080218054,
-0.0334489867,
0.0146347536,
-0.0279830247,
-0.0139986165,
-0.0201084297,
-0.0852940157,
-0.0249898937,
-0.0325285941,
0.0040071476,
0.070805043,
-0.0304312985,
-0.0229310989,
-0.0502486676,
0.0067453398,
-0.0257129893,
-0.0008238332,
-0.0170468539,
-0.0568587333,
0.0865374878,
0.1086114347,
0.0471170172,
-0.0271918066,
-0.0281352233,
0.0224774983,
-0.066982232,
0.0182664879,
-0.0324441455,
-5.606013742e-33,
-0.0234322399,
-0.0409329496,
0.0465917177,
0.0014591336,
0.0074688038,
-0.0262267869,
-0.0201446433,
0.0177935846,
-0.0332701579,
-0.028546758,
-0.0406427644,
0.0447304659,
0.0129178884,
0.0233515967,
-0.0257333815,
0.0192255806,
0.0431137942,
0.005223854,
-0.0272881426,
-0.0034729145,
0.0615992695,
0.0045390246,
-0.0321724825,
-0.0654923245,
0.0279082786,
-0.0025205852,
0.0130282957,
0.0620221943,
-0.0031748235,
0.0351330489,
-0.0038330387,
0.0710013062,
0.0106419902,
0.0007836067,
0.0121995509,
0.0319021828,
-0.0592529848,
-0.0185060874,
0.0468495004,
0.0367477983,
0.0091785956,
0.0293572489,
0.0207462143,
-0.0078411466,
-0.0223644469,
0.0728900805,
0.0095773581,
0.0098813288,
-0.051801119,
0.0120598786,
-0.0177775603,
0.0138208522,
0.0048802514,
-0.0092368703,
0.0120568853,
0.0596584082,
0.0322350301,
-0.0134931859,
-0.0167308133,
0.0395713821,
-0.0263878033,
0.0330752693,
-0.0116185602,
0.0496641621,
0.0058852024,
0.0424484201,
0.0651041642,
0.0147604877,
-0.0033666533,
-0.060872484,
-0.015309887,
0.0272561498,
0.0283917952,
0.0168413762,
-0.0147831459,
-0.0029605038,
0.0175151192,
0.0053799278,
0.0146106435,
0.0256890468,
-0.0013216186,
0.0550477132,
-0.0776457936,
-0.001220468,
-0.0298454128,
0.0290961731,
-0.0567498766,
-0.02365648,
0.0387216285,
0.0432794355,
0.0319343992,
-0.004736125,
-0.0006920497,
0.0231404584,
-0.0164844505,
0.0180762112,
0.0297570936,
-0.0046034791,
0.0013216332,
-0.0000612826,
-0.0236388501,
0.0086208936,
0.005289996,
0.0108036883,
-0.0378122851,
0.0005978574,
-0.0554343276,
0.0186697617,
-0.0368841887,
-0.0111159179,
-0.0055837934,
-0.0088678412,
-0.0517052487,
-0.0402166806,
0.0195100904,
0.01182942,
-0.016461648,
0.0273834802,
0.0072420575,
0.0295759905,
-0.0538527519,
-0.0780505687,
0.0055250726,
-0.0199594628,
-0.0025853084,
0.0239760466,
-0.0280065909,
0.0070548155,
0.0240893792,
-0.0301230159,
0.0054022316,
0.007583417,
2.536e-7,
0.0204521306,
0.0403374732,
-0.0026399393,
0.0364241786,
0.0170939229,
0.0058012786,
0.0413793251,
0.0038966967,
0.0545315556,
0.0035977729,
0.0124785248,
0.0063556456,
0.0063164434,
0.0004543278,
-0.0920851678,
-0.0684108138,
-0.0128036914,
-0.029344853,
-0.0392284244,
-0.0242175274,
0.0362543203,
0.0507464036,
-0.0087209139,
0.0283418447,
-0.0574741736,
-0.0556611829,
0.0242861845,
-0.0072828839,
0.021064166,
-0.0007418958,
0.0324490406,
0.0132896286,
0.0096918447,
0.0083825383,
0.0013969817,
0.0339548253,
0.0090260683,
-0.0086780181,
-0.0162295047,
-0.0280870534,
-0.0150472065,
-0.0248450898,
-0.0248792637,
-0.0365666151,
0.0383211859,
-0.0179621745,
0.0307925604,
0.010110735,
0.0198197048,
-0.0085660694,
-0.0263706632,
-0.017463373,
-0.0587742329,
0.0097084837,
-0.0283704009,
0.0360825695,
0.0201868881,
-0.0880736634,
-0.0040611066,
-0.0236637369,
-0.0363016129,
-0.0452559069,
-0.0880376548,
-0.0304806102,
0.0062266686,
-0.0329288058,
-0.0020067589,
1.97885543e-34,
0.0182807241,
0.0187919922,
-0.0038017493,
0.0331256948,
0.0479700379,
0.0351793282,
0.0015255264,
0.0383149162,
0.0672713518,
-0.0995260775,
-0.025963923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00996v1 | Can Small Language Models Learn, Unlearn, and Retain Noise Patterns? | 2024-07-01T06:22:38 | 2024-07-01T06:22:38 | Nicy Scaria, Silvester John Joseph Kennedy, Deepak Subramani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Small Language Models (SLMs) are generally considered to be more compact
versions of large language models (LLMs), typically having fewer than 7 billion
parameters. This study investigates the ability of small language models to
learn, retain, and subsequently eliminate noise that is typically not found on
the internet, where most pretraining datasets are sourced. For this, four
pre-trained SLMs were utilized: Olmo 1B, Qwen1.5 1.8B, Gemma 2B, and Phi2 2.7B.
The models were instruction-tuned without noise and tested for task execution
with in-context learning. Afterward, noise patterns were introduced to evaluate
the models' learning and unlearning capabilities. We evaluated the models'
performance at various training levels. Phi consistently excelled with
word-level noise but performed the worst with character-level noise. Despite
being the smallest with approximately 1 billion parameters, Olmo performed
consistently well on tasks. | Can Small Language Models Learn, Unlearn, and Retain Noise Patterns?: Small Language Models (SLMs) are generally considered to be more compact
versions of large language models (LLMs), typically having fewer than 7 billion
parameters. This study investigates the ability of small language models to
learn, retain, and subsequently eliminate noise that is typically not found on
the internet, where most pretraining datasets are sourced. For this, four
pre-trained SLMs were utilized: Olmo 1B, Qwen1.5 1.8B, Gemma 2B, and Phi2 2.7B.
The models were instruction-tuned without noise and tested for task execution
with in-context learning. Afterward, noise patterns were introduced to evaluate
the models' learning and unlearning capabilities. We evaluated the models'
performance at various training levels. Phi consistently excelled with
word-level noise but performed the worst with character-level noise. Despite
being the smallest with approximately 1 billion parameters, Olmo performed
consistently well on tasks. | [
0.0307991188,
0.0521366708,
-0.0077862558,
0.0264764279,
0.0243818965,
0.0060583502,
0.0243088659,
0.0218063965,
-0.0405661017,
-0.0420892052,
-0.0750632808,
-0.0335290208,
0.0129361255,
-0.0025265662,
0.0364471525,
-0.0445999429,
0.055456724,
-0.0636601225,
0.0049151424,
-0.0206351951,
-0.0014929491,
-0.007630107,
0.0018300489,
0.0393741205,
0.0196975134,
0.004749292,
-0.0194687173,
0.0060694059,
-0.0350696743,
0.003805049,
0.0174478982,
0.0544433631,
0.0231082365,
0.0369502343,
0.0000018486,
-0.0467354022,
0.0186965875,
-0.0211361367,
-0.0479171574,
0.0415032208,
0.0643721819,
0.0155930109,
-0.0508252606,
0.0348219015,
-0.0026856074,
-0.0447823554,
0.0731718391,
0.0272413995,
0.0265834387,
0.0935089737,
-0.002666815,
-0.031407401,
0.0050360961,
-0.0330782235,
0.0242063701,
-0.0107858302,
0.0135254646,
-0.0174376499,
-0.0235683564,
-0.0075513171,
-0.0021645946,
0.0077517293,
-0.0319978222,
0.035348732,
-0.0332611129,
0.0375016443,
-0.0091441805,
-0.0262119062,
-0.0203482881,
0.046939075,
-0.0563590601,
-0.0277261641,
-0.0175360963,
-0.0052558151,
-0.0053584091,
-0.0131682893,
-0.0379791744,
0.0240158979,
0.0139878951,
0.0167943239,
-0.0074588782,
-0.0295127071,
0.0435527377,
-0.009009433,
-0.0202928856,
0.0281693414,
0.005262583,
-0.0229382627,
0.010068845,
-0.0283888597,
-0.0085594701,
-0.049533084,
-0.0188192278,
0.0493783131,
0.0012217998,
0.0320865549,
-0.0616148114,
-0.0101321395,
0.0217780694,
-0.0848883539,
0.0791501924,
0.017639149,
-0.0224447083,
0.0195292067,
-0.0356297158,
0.0185690597,
0.0184025038,
0.0190117694,
-0.0373108834,
0.0261885654,
-0.024865672,
0.012820093,
-0.0418386236,
0.0305764042,
-0.0295987148,
-0.005732209,
-0.0229834598,
0.0269547328,
0.0231402777,
0.0125384387,
0.0078534847,
-0.0059848661,
-0.0413432419,
-0.0050431248,
-0.0229624324,
0.0164103601,
0.0165669899,
0.0373204648,
0.0013321796,
-0.0738158226,
0.0040222285,
-0.0007661997,
0.0298049264,
-0.0097086942,
0.0494720899,
0.077750355,
0.0140901571,
-0.0359237194,
-0.0701238662,
0.0239505507,
-0.000625113,
-0.0944250301,
-0.0003893364,
-0.0451543964,
-0.0358840339,
0.0000050683,
0.0208753031,
-0.0518075041,
0.0161808692,
0.0213058572,
-0.0369153805,
0.0572788231,
-0.0151828649,
0.0114287501,
0.0086428178,
-0.0152222374,
0.052982524,
0.0774208382,
0.0356117263,
-0.0011299815,
0.0339879431,
-0.0366933607,
-0.0173359849,
0.0370096639,
0.0302204639,
-0.0010404167,
-0.0175859705,
-0.0337080732,
0.0240436848,
0.002910285,
0.0339787304,
0.066328004,
-0.0001104205,
0.0007584519,
0.1023434103,
0.0467770249,
0.0326323994,
0.0311146695,
0.0275691245,
0.0054092114,
0.0400918424,
-0.0018591486,
-0.0618216954,
-0.0061102742,
-0.0448735654,
0.0273690727,
-0.0023688697,
0.0225704052,
-0.058663208,
-0.0498454757,
-0.0529128574,
-0.0324350111,
0.0009056153,
0.0231547616,
0.0728012323,
0.0118016126,
-0.0573562011,
0.0404123925,
0.0532089695,
-0.0439391769,
-0.0315215625,
-0.0655115396,
0.0524813719,
0.0551510863,
0.026244767,
-0.0195307769,
-0.0365013257,
-0.0103300558,
0.0129994322,
0.02261745,
0.0679510161,
0.0050949818,
0.0456383117,
-0.0539710373,
-0.0095298979,
0.0055151638,
0.0183506776,
-0.001422575,
0.0202458352,
-0.0049713757,
0.0001371029,
-0.0110362992,
-0.0848606974,
0.0435831361,
-0.0309886783,
-0.0304963514,
0.0074862526,
0.0093306797,
0.0284751337,
-0.0085819233,
-0.0255540907,
-0.0064012348,
0.0460762307,
-0.0360759683,
0.0520969145,
0.0205111858,
-0.0610335805,
0.0151587082,
0.0423930548,
0.0391591787,
0.0454851426,
0.0166815501,
-0.0079475427,
-0.0358367078,
0.0118095344,
-0.0471962467,
0.0550269224,
-0.0449843183,
0.0398113839,
-0.0280496646,
0.0250172876,
-0.0266672764,
0.035142947,
-0.0079151224,
0.0163014084,
-0.0037663379,
0.0364670008,
0.0145677812,
-0.0310657956,
-0.0490797497,
-0.0128050102,
-0.0184082817,
0.0257027764,
-0.0132711921,
0.0161670316,
-0.0182935614,
-0.0299023017,
-0.0553572923,
-0.0202840734,
-0.0180108715,
-0.0046990579,
0.0147566535,
-0.0041229632,
-0.009961579,
-0.0290342253,
-0.0135987569,
0.0422063246,
0.0007934668,
0.0085555185,
0.0171721615,
0.0033798565,
-0.048414249,
-0.0553372949,
-0.0233627651,
0.0128643122,
0.0227373634,
-0.0301736277,
-0.0089770751,
-0.0683748126,
0.0997092873,
-0.0067039141,
0.0742656812,
0.0088391975,
-0.071349591,
0.0196917243,
-0.0213232487,
0.0628110841,
0.0751050562,
-0.0243755914,
0.0328462608,
0.0914832279,
-0.0132249361,
-0.016151825,
0.0112869786,
-0.0042018937,
-0.0251427051,
-0.0682317168,
-0.0098857535,
-0.0418990552,
0.0920335725,
-0.0253286175,
0.007958998,
-0.0446633063,
0.0046821516,
-0.0077176476,
-0.0390288979,
-0.0369300321,
0.0058691362,
-0.0307446625,
0.0444998853,
-0.0330350213,
-0.0755153447,
0.0179083794,
-0.0244332906,
-0.0138330394,
-0.0427182652,
-0.0222958308,
0.007710143,
0.0567990504,
0.0083805397,
0.0289905872,
0.0141359987,
-0.0411540233,
-0.0655297786,
-0.0043637678,
0.0270443913,
-0.040121913,
0.0257195309,
-0.0259506647,
0.0011800767,
-0.0119190402,
-0.0067602308,
-0.052478943,
-0.0105036823,
-0.0295683313,
0.0075234789,
0.0144009246,
-0.0362770893,
-0.0255958494,
0.0298272949,
0.0163116902,
0.0375425965,
0.0059469836,
0.0127133159,
-0.0204191282,
-0.0034285288,
0.0458565876,
0.0235012118,
0.0153781911,
-0.0647293702,
0.0305844955,
0.0052210046,
0.0445143729,
-0.0321446769,
-0.0259275381,
0.0107056098,
0.0366711505,
-0.0130529189,
-0.0213246811,
0.0620013066,
0.0645641834,
-0.0716652423,
-0.0449801832,
0.1014946103,
0.0042911028,
-0.0289750025,
0.0026175554,
0.005176716,
0.0351388045,
0.0307758115,
0.0117689874,
-0.0315556005,
-0.0119100492,
0.0233316459,
0.0104402779,
0.0005167552,
0.0378491841,
-0.0308075435,
-0.0996255875,
0.0137248673,
0.024947824,
-0.0828481764,
-0.0253214221,
-0.0340532213,
-0.0119952699,
-0.0116000082,
0.0544013269,
0.0298259817,
-0.0527075641,
-0.0289093591,
0.0457588769,
-0.0396558046,
-0.0903683752,
0.0056666872,
-0.0292127207,
0.09237165,
0.0564069487,
-0.026925629,
-0.0222193673,
-0.0369814523,
0.0581963062,
0.0206112303,
0.0202943813,
-0.0133292703,
0.0433012396,
0.0256515294,
-0.0278506372,
0.012429513,
-0.0006339235,
-0.0233218521,
0.0050452333,
-0.0358255543,
0.0218999851,
-0.0113509791,
-0.0179398954,
0.0213461164,
-0.0167103801,
-0.0090286955,
0.0644018352,
0.0491523519,
-0.0519333407,
-0.0481151119,
-0.009744321,
-0.0095503228,
-0.042064257,
-0.0191714764,
0.0435333736,
-0.0333597697,
-0.0759562552,
-0.0397752114,
-0.0345340632,
0.0329562463,
0.0489878356,
0.0378474258,
0.0217604134,
0.0237981956,
0.035882704,
-0.0557260811,
0.005618881,
-0.0125779277,
0.0144211762,
-0.0734896585,
-0.0349515118,
0.0374670625,
-0.008312989,
-0.0104192374,
-0.015755605,
-0.1137895584,
-0.053578116,
0.0463699736,
0.0550156198,
0.0279804505,
0.0252834875,
-0.0069182664,
-0.087442562,
0.0418987609,
0.0060151699,
-0.0291229058,
0.0318767652,
0.0593071692,
-0.0264849812,
0.0178988781,
0.0412136503,
-0.0272176843,
0.0315246806,
0.0396534316,
-0.0148962568,
-0.0346748754,
-0.0198432114,
0.0209221952,
-0.0038387291,
0.0264076069,
-0.0072282888,
-0.0198875964,
-0.0471225306,
0.0529986881,
-0.0103529831,
0.0406707637,
-0.0391542614,
-0.0331872813,
0.0074828933,
0.0200512391,
0.0024131534,
-0.0044007399,
-0.0088449279,
0.035087835,
-0.0051060468,
0.0210777633,
0.0186982229,
0.0731123015,
0.0415841937,
0.0400444381,
-0.0317531638,
0.0398939773,
-0.0040347734,
0.0175187383,
0.0123935807,
-0.009625975,
-0.0125142951,
0.0110961534,
-0.0383441932,
0.0250084922,
-0.0445107818,
-0.0393102132,
-0.054695446,
-0.0019456185,
0.071239613,
-0.0053924927,
0.0469623394,
-0.0133258328,
0.0039565377,
-0.0377384089,
0.0176563319,
-0.0176696666,
0.0216235444,
0.0179459564,
0.0008611598,
-0.0132167935,
0.0111317076,
0.0996655971,
0.0435995311,
0.0688054413,
-0.002224369,
0.0432499275,
-0.0426559746,
-0.0009667099,
0.00262463,
0.0513006262,
-0.0391429216,
0.015031754,
0.0043649576,
-0.0819090083,
-0.0323884934,
-0.0107494658,
0.0221960079,
-0.0306115337,
0.0298500378,
0.0422733389,
-0.0009469317,
0.0118124885,
-0.0178963002,
-0.0367360264,
0.0250693597,
-0.0242044292,
0.0218443479,
-6.201836196e-33,
-0.0243566856,
0.0200401563,
0.0230354331,
-0.0086250957,
-0.0009823336,
0.0016704639,
-0.0478803068,
0.0221544933,
-0.0383191891,
-0.0012732439,
-0.0239948705,
0.0111563271,
0.0194440726,
0.0120250164,
0.024382798,
0.0338435322,
0.086493887,
-0.0495215058,
0.0141172865,
0.0055805128,
0.0396802351,
0.0348133408,
0.05945158,
-0.0392254405,
0.0063032657,
0.0056116804,
-0.0364732072,
-0.0178908315,
0.005822232,
0.065654248,
-0.038355045,
0.0392168462,
0.0040623853,
0.0277123731,
-0.0633220822,
-0.0153044248,
-0.060796164,
-0.0191202704,
0.0205067731,
0.0227537453,
-0.006174617,
-0.0346967205,
0.0846356079,
-0.0193127114,
-0.0450905748,
0.0261354987,
0.0193742961,
-0.0344212614,
-0.0285847858,
0.0127436491,
-0.0478609204,
0.0077807717,
0.015326404,
-0.0315941125,
0.0295603909,
-0.0017157103,
-0.0467162766,
-0.0423713662,
-0.0401811339,
0.0503842421,
0.0473384187,
0.0889489353,
0.0142253907,
0.0434793755,
-0.0058385171,
0.0400296114,
0.0630713031,
0.0180660114,
0.036774721,
-0.0095924195,
0.0870476365,
0.0529056415,
0.0375436991,
0.0068149744,
0.033983171,
-0.0409156643,
-0.0804285184,
0.0007924611,
0.0269990731,
0.0495055877,
0.0279682148,
0.0009533532,
-0.0407655537,
-0.0071339891,
-0.0240938254,
-0.0207683314,
-0.027913807,
-0.0404809006,
0.0304664411,
0.0224060044,
-0.0113715967,
-0.0336466469,
0.0338970236,
-0.0542553738,
0.0012333773,
-0.0192001741,
-0.0008571326,
0.0037270109,
-0.0081885112,
0.0045528701,
-0.0925789922,
-0.0704226047,
0.002133861,
0.0215825718,
-0.0020715515,
0.0076563116,
0.0186720211,
0.0551432222,
-0.0881056562,
-0.0015909314,
-0.0278208703,
0.0124057671,
0.0442687199,
0.0378239267,
0.0336322784,
-0.0223796666,
-0.0057725506,
0.0477506109,
-0.0105536375,
-0.0429007895,
-0.0270127486,
-0.0301856678,
0.0202318523,
0.045492243,
-0.0292402413,
-0.0396756902,
-0.053523235,
0.0150092728,
0.033855889,
-0.0049458765,
-0.0102317296,
0.0171433911,
2.541e-7,
0.0104339803,
0.049417872,
-0.0114808334,
0.02600329,
0.0311744958,
0.0103411581,
-0.0466786362,
-0.0098975115,
-0.006171023,
0.0110528506,
0.0061383364,
0.0260748658,
0.0582325384,
0.0070884619,
-0.0439402424,
-0.0221431833,
-0.0495531745,
0.0202309582,
-0.0289844014,
0.0026786244,
-0.0164187495,
0.1196518987,
0.0125069907,
-0.0385946147,
0.0025286414,
-0.0342445746,
0.0340011902,
-0.0508928671,
0.0030893739,
0.0190891158,
0.0055767871,
0.0362107679,
-0.0085977409,
-0.0001514605,
-0.0241973102,
0.0261458401,
-0.055265855,
0.053417962,
-0.0402496979,
-0.0337613076,
0.0362731926,
0.0338517427,
-0.0260553863,
-0.0402305089,
0.0549753681,
-0.0212152097,
-0.0241330881,
-0.0204838626,
0.0130383447,
-0.0278716087,
-0.0005001186,
-0.0293004215,
-0.0390794761,
-0.0095082335,
0.0085490718,
-0.0294498838,
-0.0283180997,
-0.0433688611,
-0.0082397526,
0.0313216746,
-0.0213199537,
-0.0812241286,
-0.0342021473,
-0.0350706838,
0.025928976,
-0.0171498135,
0.0018618982,
2.233691355e-34,
0.0368622541,
-0.0370700136,
0.0115552982,
0.0700984076,
-0.0183450729,
-0.0114478758,
-0.0175724924,
0.0031430675,
0.0157581586,
-0.0667524412,
-0.0250973646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00994v1 | LLM Uncertainty Quantification through Directional Entailment Graph and Claim Level Response Augmentation | 2024-07-01T06:11:30 | 2024-07-01T06:11:30 | Longchao Da, Tiejin Chen, Lu Cheng, Hua Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | The Large language models (LLMs) have showcased superior capabilities in
sophisticated tasks across various domains, stemming from basic question-answer
(QA), they are nowadays used as decision assistants or explainers for
unfamiliar content. However, they are not always correct due to the data
sparsity in specific domain corpus, or the model's hallucination problems.
Given this, how much should we trust the responses from LLMs? This paper
presents a novel way to evaluate the uncertainty that captures the directional
instability, by constructing a directional graph from entailment probabilities,
and we innovatively conduct Random Walk Laplacian given the asymmetric property
of a constructed directed graph, then the uncertainty is aggregated by the
derived eigenvalues from the Laplacian process. We also provide a way to
incorporate the existing work's semantics uncertainty with our proposed layer.
Besides, this paper identifies the vagueness issues in the raw response set and
proposes an augmentation approach to mitigate such a problem, we conducted
extensive empirical experiments and demonstrated the superiority of our
proposed solutions. | LLM Uncertainty Quantification through Directional Entailment Graph and Claim Level Response Augmentation: The Large language models (LLMs) have showcased superior capabilities in
sophisticated tasks across various domains, stemming from basic question-answer
(QA), they are nowadays used as decision assistants or explainers for
unfamiliar content. However, they are not always correct due to the data
sparsity in specific domain corpus, or the model's hallucination problems.
Given this, how much should we trust the responses from LLMs? This paper
presents a novel way to evaluate the uncertainty that captures the directional
instability, by constructing a directional graph from entailment probabilities,
and we innovatively conduct Random Walk Laplacian given the asymmetric property
of a constructed directed graph, then the uncertainty is aggregated by the
derived eigenvalues from the Laplacian process. We also provide a way to
incorporate the existing work's semantics uncertainty with our proposed layer.
Besides, this paper identifies the vagueness issues in the raw response set and
proposes an augmentation approach to mitigate such a problem, we conducted
extensive empirical experiments and demonstrated the superiority of our
proposed solutions. | [
0.0261622686,
0.0447223336,
-0.0085988892,
0.0670136362,
-0.0464816242,
-0.0001722809,
-0.0690810606,
-0.0195962526,
0.0126479389,
-0.0458994098,
0.0137369791,
-0.049333971,
-0.0074603343,
0.0157405213,
-0.0066047865,
-0.0078850081,
0.010787569,
-0.0506050326,
0.0489646979,
-0.0508572459,
-0.0158140454,
-0.0040458273,
0.0123909414,
0.029807657,
0.0045010261,
-0.0034592624,
-0.0256985798,
0.0358546712,
0.0222103633,
-0.0461987555,
-0.0180671345,
0.0320997052,
0.0288348496,
0.0382109247,
0.0000019539,
-0.0839135125,
-0.0175121501,
0.0067267586,
-0.0150679694,
-0.0387342013,
-0.0180637874,
0.0093993898,
0.0076964782,
0.0075337994,
-0.0135827959,
0.0128127327,
0.0242783912,
0.0476161316,
0.0455407873,
0.0590631217,
0.0062696552,
-0.0617465861,
0.0190697368,
0.0036076356,
0.0088361045,
-0.0520037897,
0.0473993868,
-0.0086892685,
0.0174059458,
-0.0373348817,
-0.0485750511,
0.0207781401,
0.016801402,
0.0014219112,
0.0198366139,
-0.000731963,
-0.0049611735,
-0.0261036213,
0.0151335457,
0.0751591623,
0.0180077404,
-0.0251685847,
-0.0367191732,
-0.0279003307,
0.0249529611,
0.0982633606,
-0.0352974348,
0.0261821374,
0.0005662878,
0.026832303,
0.0129061118,
0.0023119482,
0.0538160913,
-0.0032976314,
-0.0341695324,
0.1220967174,
0.0039247437,
-0.0459006391,
0.0184588488,
0.0296090823,
0.0044915071,
-0.0413120948,
0.0056168102,
0.0637069866,
-0.0325865187,
0.0397214666,
-0.0058971453,
0.0094234776,
0.0205668546,
-0.0572080836,
0.0390987359,
-0.0211494863,
-0.0071308701,
0.030342482,
-0.0309121162,
0.0019889311,
-0.0097855395,
0.0131664071,
-0.051349517,
-0.0422433764,
-0.0012134589,
-0.0102502974,
-0.0145540601,
0.0567257702,
-0.022741545,
-0.0214799643,
-0.0609229021,
0.0351941176,
-0.0272477791,
0.0222921688,
0.0001254421,
0.0157704186,
0.0582770146,
-0.0226865765,
-0.0514476895,
-0.0079258429,
-0.0067073386,
0.0367657952,
-0.0084912991,
-0.026322078,
0.0130473003,
0.0250328276,
0.0116381841,
-0.0095807752,
-0.020136591,
0.0899235085,
0.0313433968,
-0.0270344857,
-0.0203005951,
-0.0388917588,
-0.0479733646,
-0.0572810434,
-0.0032611045,
-0.0802608803,
-0.0326561555,
0.0109004155,
-0.0115059223,
-0.0068104593,
0.0394328535,
-0.0140464576,
-0.0518775508,
0.0732046664,
-0.0201959033,
0.0361727141,
0.0175421387,
-0.0155337602,
0.0004218875,
0.0360343568,
0.0475036018,
0.003053532,
0.0629517436,
0.0155886635,
0.0204419009,
-0.0157069173,
0.0339193307,
0.0099235922,
-0.010699451,
0.0070931795,
-0.0427097902,
-0.0015865772,
-0.0311966352,
0.0442312546,
-0.0141583197,
-0.0223237295,
0.0196644068,
0.0222286545,
0.0082140435,
-0.0436245129,
0.0001628385,
0.0068786005,
0.0029018414,
0.0255268738,
-0.0240944251,
0.0014224517,
-0.0589520186,
0.0159410257,
0.039288085,
-0.0326046273,
-0.0176486783,
-0.0620999075,
-0.0353036523,
-0.0233647786,
0.0475326255,
0.020030411,
0.0588703789,
0.0007880291,
-0.0176789686,
0.0096417023,
0.0209707934,
-0.0328838043,
0.004216596,
-0.0653940141,
0.0337058753,
0.0470734499,
0.034508612,
-0.0143546779,
-0.0444955379,
0.0118021118,
-0.017305417,
0.0296628438,
0.0102041895,
0.014521976,
0.0038870212,
-0.0343426652,
-0.0383539796,
0.009837389,
0.0251412708,
0.0082400106,
-0.0011069532,
0.0155207077,
0.0150725376,
-0.0683723092,
-0.0284205992,
0.0194321405,
0.0421779677,
0.0038326939,
0.0512360819,
-0.0294279102,
0.0523716807,
0.020451352,
-0.0062967469,
0.0476596616,
0.0453406163,
-0.0208963864,
-0.1144345179,
-0.0041584331,
0.018667005,
-0.0227499809,
0.0477945805,
-0.0276870951,
-0.0267528147,
0.0067331959,
-0.0298139155,
-0.0743301287,
0.0393278636,
-0.0222462285,
-0.0056493487,
-0.039157968,
0.0133812083,
0.0067299171,
0.0318310745,
-0.0484358221,
0.0708961412,
0.0134572377,
0.059224017,
-0.0255629309,
0.0542038977,
-0.0003570104,
-0.0471049733,
-0.0107174022,
-0.0040514003,
-0.0066793584,
0.0044092517,
0.0435518585,
-0.0143852951,
-0.0105676688,
-0.0181120578,
-0.0629214793,
-0.0271976478,
-0.0040272106,
0.0201191008,
-0.0224369112,
-0.0147578847,
-0.0150898639,
-0.0200008545,
-0.0394391827,
0.0038584264,
0.0385304429,
0.0209434833,
0.0222972352,
-0.0320524648,
-0.0213032644,
-0.0204299334,
-0.0106660444,
0.0047998573,
0.0270866919,
0.0268361028,
-0.0459593572,
-0.0729355738,
0.0295764469,
-0.0620469935,
0.0062144045,
0.003684537,
0.0037268349,
0.001495195,
-0.0129320472,
-0.0037163792,
0.0112576727,
0.0226607602,
0.0442428477,
0.0497394279,
-0.0163066015,
-0.0086874822,
0.0007105827,
-0.0793010369,
-0.0134429382,
-0.0315801054,
-0.0372064188,
0.0049100011,
0.0190887749,
0.0184962302,
-0.0285888314,
-0.0566533878,
-0.0349002853,
-0.0211154688,
-0.0133607937,
-0.0046598576,
-0.0160948448,
-0.0246249177,
0.0624798685,
0.0130249858,
-0.0374248885,
0.1027380154,
-0.0091762412,
0.0354080349,
-0.0161162857,
-0.0541911274,
-0.0405154116,
0.0332371704,
-0.0078234738,
-0.0021146075,
-0.0267578736,
-0.0150039643,
-0.0221206993,
-0.0426650941,
0.0518449657,
-0.0439682379,
0.0399784893,
-0.0439469554,
0.0429077893,
-0.0008064476,
-0.0032705553,
-0.0386671349,
-0.0588400811,
-0.0189214218,
-0.0143355904,
-0.044836387,
-0.022093989,
0.0375876948,
-0.008617905,
-0.007882894,
-0.0113959564,
-0.0529318042,
-0.0018556629,
-0.0150628053,
0.0578345396,
0.0702344626,
0.0366314352,
0.0813927501,
-0.0513403825,
0.0244435295,
0.0487425104,
-0.0157862473,
0.0209621917,
-0.0314403735,
-0.0373419374,
0.0010762675,
-0.0086004818,
-0.0341832563,
0.0201170407,
0.0710697249,
-0.0295355842,
0.0166940857,
0.1113369241,
0.0136912707,
0.0088492753,
0.0106621431,
-0.0191056095,
0.0343377814,
0.0225418974,
-0.0016471726,
-0.0766762048,
-0.0206597336,
-0.0222376361,
0.0342833251,
0.0019262577,
-0.0186438859,
0.032895375,
-0.1034477726,
0.0622322075,
7.56e-7,
-0.0147657972,
-0.0434005111,
-0.0592494421,
0.0147739369,
0.0381994955,
0.0063498705,
-0.0288214348,
0.0131054642,
-0.0051366878,
0.0265432727,
-0.0256273001,
-0.0545127131,
0.0116188824,
-0.0007876145,
0.0327891856,
0.0084521966,
0.0242348239,
-0.0229273885,
-0.0206010621,
0.0349127427,
-0.0624045171,
-0.0253397785,
0.0024160007,
0.0153174158,
0.0409026295,
0.0210819636,
-0.0274052285,
0.0106504746,
-0.0577667914,
-0.0096228765,
-0.0076783109,
0.1067730561,
-0.0701798126,
-0.0517641455,
-0.0225230437,
-0.0142324083,
0.0096110459,
0.0586140379,
-0.0086354297,
-0.0042116567,
-0.053655751,
-0.0298658162,
0.0230323877,
0.0220440365,
-0.0096976086,
0.0219402909,
0.0005929509,
-0.0099369911,
-0.0777959898,
-0.0274440758,
-0.0267124977,
0.0208064988,
-0.0386387743,
0.0339920521,
0.0461360812,
-0.0315282047,
-0.0488078147,
-0.005138569,
-0.0276836939,
0.0469980203,
0.023588609,
0.03802564,
0.0278314352,
0.0145897968,
-0.0210725795,
0.0276736803,
-0.0517455675,
-0.1085393727,
-0.0311481133,
0.0011622627,
0.0313794836,
0.0276524853,
-0.058725331,
-0.0279173926,
0.0528911762,
0.0322037786,
0.0136737302,
0.0129030608,
0.0349001884,
0.0588664375,
-0.0362359546,
0.0510363616,
-0.0742239505,
0.012221043,
0.0061513428,
0.044796247,
-0.0395422466,
-0.1193742156,
0.004165282,
0.0446132608,
0.0480878055,
0.0190169606,
-0.023861751,
-0.0210817195,
0.031064935,
-0.0430124626,
-0.0204276759,
-0.0157198999,
0.006280018,
0.0286248177,
-0.0526902452,
-0.005239577,
-0.0313537903,
-0.0134195406,
0.0172815081,
-0.0424084142,
-0.005950388,
0.0042150589,
-0.0129672019,
0.0159809794,
0.0096219303,
-0.0202655215,
0.0168268476,
0.0364125334,
0.0272624884,
0.0638890788,
0.0149844177,
0.0274008829,
-0.0025225787,
-0.0115596382,
-0.033747755,
-0.0970569775,
-0.0840931609,
0.0072592478,
0.0242185369,
0.0347749181,
0.0325825103,
0.0377475843,
-0.0054180236,
0.0006407757,
-0.0243787542,
0.0604253672,
0.0172870103,
-0.0328172594,
0.1041878909,
0.014028145,
-0.0356388316,
0.0386334918,
0.0372019634,
0.0193431247,
0.0183278192,
-0.0223185159,
-0.0357808545,
-0.0352223963,
-0.0690039992,
-0.0105809262,
0.0495490432,
-0.0229395013,
0.035159938,
-0.0869138092,
-0.0887021646,
0.0032064288,
0.0148564326,
0.0078806747,
-0.0202650018,
0.019894775,
0.0377206802,
0.0314962678,
-0.0140562048,
-0.0643516332,
0.010578108,
-0.0460558087,
0.0015007926,
-0.0283013117,
-6.491971712e-33,
-0.0069410028,
-0.0759479702,
-0.0258314461,
0.0145807983,
0.0004426718,
-0.0239858236,
-0.0022341742,
0.0145823509,
-0.0166222155,
0.0499061495,
0.0205054823,
0.0489849076,
0.0199451819,
0.0403246582,
0.0109293209,
-0.0618804432,
0.0055251792,
0.014099597,
0.0064796102,
0.0198179632,
0.047574129,
0.0000730434,
0.0374426022,
-0.0962810889,
0.0542357974,
-0.0251769982,
-0.0065898034,
0.0493593253,
-0.0391753577,
0.0284926575,
-0.0007518501,
0.0576956123,
0.0095502092,
0.011989343,
-0.0002475017,
-0.0303219706,
-0.0389037356,
-0.0730895251,
0.015503807,
0.0259522218,
-0.0614964887,
-0.0032171342,
0.0448162965,
0.0357343554,
-0.0286017619,
-0.0010657355,
0.0459843688,
-0.0161495935,
-0.0260828491,
-0.0607766472,
-0.0216228832,
0.0499625541,
0.0173008535,
-0.0198755581,
-0.0074598142,
0.0260102376,
-0.0056672599,
-0.0022753356,
-0.0460283905,
-0.0199028943,
-0.0392392054,
-0.0135535663,
0.0403739549,
0.0206220727,
-0.014794617,
0.0484809801,
-0.0297462065,
-0.0062202839,
-0.0271527898,
0.0051853345,
-0.026095435,
0.0316391364,
0.0307941139,
0.0102626625,
-0.00052176,
0.0392211638,
-0.0872151926,
0.0139758913,
-0.0076987715,
0.0421983339,
0.033919204,
0.0337734781,
-0.0318906084,
-0.0396536812,
-0.0374724716,
-0.0104462709,
-0.010449484,
0.0147715406,
-0.0074204169,
-0.0203448758,
-0.004873964,
0.0080659138,
-0.0009609309,
-0.0455928184,
-0.0469656624,
0.0045648925,
0.0112813925,
0.004602022,
0.0275033079,
0.0445184112,
-0.0027968921,
0.0014067703,
-0.0155810798,
-0.0019519539,
-0.0211774204,
0.0252917949,
0.0039103269,
-0.0039077783,
-0.0614502393,
0.0150945261,
-0.0139526511,
0.0005750765,
-0.0312147066,
0.0030948627,
0.0494427755,
0.0100997305,
0.0019816828,
0.0829302445,
-0.0056362194,
0.0790945888,
0.0046112062,
0.0419953391,
-0.0274709929,
0.0135711739,
-0.0237735026,
-0.0126390113,
-0.0027342273,
0.0451820046,
0.0200352129,
-0.0696818009,
-0.0067276428,
0.0240127295,
2.807e-7,
0.0575802699,
0.0296628848,
0.0314788856,
0.0839988813,
0.03950838,
0.0413948298,
-0.0159529708,
-0.0228113718,
0.0425788648,
-0.0542566478,
-0.0065404526,
0.0272768084,
0.032921277,
0.0458544157,
-0.0458435342,
0.0011008692,
-0.0379091315,
-0.006457468,
0.0094593624,
0.0342426822,
0.1151878089,
0.0856813267,
0.0375647396,
-0.0000738469,
-0.0208054129,
-0.0175106842,
0.0813524351,
0.0157956704,
-0.0200246461,
0.0163474549,
0.0229442231,
-0.0303145759,
0.0134498086,
0.0536297448,
-0.006152858,
0.0320710689,
-0.0177152678,
0.016038578,
-0.0021402703,
-0.0074936687,
-0.0234873816,
-0.0227532852,
0.0332237557,
-0.0376933776,
0.0637023598,
-0.0287316982,
-0.0645587221,
-0.0356290936,
-0.0223096143,
-0.0142475795,
0.0575041175,
0.0050738929,
-0.0139499782,
0.00528388,
0.002289416,
0.0060856757,
0.0241431072,
-0.0790305734,
-0.0007512518,
-0.0131631065,
-0.0323217213,
-0.0364082903,
0.0276683196,
0.0433676913,
0.0679902807,
-0.0734390318,
0.0108905258,
2.71919968e-34,
0.0798650905,
0.007605629,
-0.0344604142,
0.0129402373,
0.0210335422,
-0.0057416372,
-0.0118026845,
0.0293185972,
0.0455703437,
-0.0707264245,
-0.0075705289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00993v1 | Mobile-Bench: An Evaluation Benchmark for LLM-based Mobile Agents | 2024-07-01T06:10:01 | 2024-07-01T06:10:01 | Shihan Deng, Weikai Xu, Hongda Sun, Wei Liu, Tao Tan, Jianfeng Liu, Ang Li, Jian Luan, Bin Wang, Rui Yan, Shuo Shang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | With the remarkable advancements of large language models (LLMs), LLM-based
agents have become a research hotspot in human-computer interaction. However,
there is a scarcity of benchmarks available for LLM-based mobile agents.
Benchmarking these agents generally faces three main challenges: (1) The
inefficiency of UI-only operations imposes limitations to task evaluation. (2)
Specific instructions within a singular application lack adequacy for assessing
the multi-dimensional reasoning and decision-making capacities of LLM mobile
agents. (3) Current evaluation metrics are insufficient to accurately assess
the process of sequential actions. To this end, we propose Mobile-Bench, a
novel benchmark for evaluating the capabilities of LLM-based mobile agents.
First, we expand conventional UI operations by incorporating 103 collected APIs
to accelerate the efficiency of task completion. Subsequently, we collect
evaluation data by combining real user queries with augmentation from LLMs. To
better evaluate different levels of planning capabilities for mobile agents,
our data is categorized into three distinct groups: SAST, SAMT, and MAMT,
reflecting varying levels of task complexity. Mobile-Bench comprises 832 data
entries, with more than 200 tasks specifically designed to evaluate multi-APP
collaboration scenarios. Furthermore, we introduce a more accurate evaluation
metric, named CheckPoint, to assess whether LLM-based mobile agents reach
essential points during their planning and reasoning steps. | Mobile-Bench: An Evaluation Benchmark for LLM-based Mobile Agents: With the remarkable advancements of large language models (LLMs), LLM-based
agents have become a research hotspot in human-computer interaction. However,
there is a scarcity of benchmarks available for LLM-based mobile agents.
Benchmarking these agents generally faces three main challenges: (1) The
inefficiency of UI-only operations imposes limitations to task evaluation. (2)
Specific instructions within a singular application lack adequacy for assessing
the multi-dimensional reasoning and decision-making capacities of LLM mobile
agents. (3) Current evaluation metrics are insufficient to accurately assess
the process of sequential actions. To this end, we propose Mobile-Bench, a
novel benchmark for evaluating the capabilities of LLM-based mobile agents.
First, we expand conventional UI operations by incorporating 103 collected APIs
to accelerate the efficiency of task completion. Subsequently, we collect
evaluation data by combining real user queries with augmentation from LLMs. To
better evaluate different levels of planning capabilities for mobile agents,
our data is categorized into three distinct groups: SAST, SAMT, and MAMT,
reflecting varying levels of task complexity. Mobile-Bench comprises 832 data
entries, with more than 200 tasks specifically designed to evaluate multi-APP
collaboration scenarios. Furthermore, we introduce a more accurate evaluation
metric, named CheckPoint, to assess whether LLM-based mobile agents reach
essential points during their planning and reasoning steps. | [
0.0231564045,
0.0004117066,
-0.0307853594,
-0.0046719583,
-0.050021898,
0.0085118078,
0.023778785,
-0.0074910023,
0.0402196199,
-0.02895982,
-0.0402508378,
-0.0479005724,
0.0146874841,
-0.0229895245,
-0.0312577598,
-0.0135383364,
0.0212078597,
-0.0254906379,
-0.0074747242,
0.0135778608,
-0.0116657978,
-0.0113462964,
-0.011725137,
0.0809652731,
-0.0093798302,
-0.0222975072,
-0.022559071,
0.0151617713,
-0.0006464649,
-0.0663108155,
-0.0453608781,
0.0444769822,
0.0141675724,
0.0085757039,
0.0000021505,
-0.0457775891,
0.0145140579,
-0.0175160263,
-0.0166799538,
-0.0182895306,
0.0293821301,
0.039698083,
-0.0189910475,
0.0461063422,
-0.0478068925,
0.0345791243,
0.003126933,
0.0024021247,
0.0256902929,
0.0432481617,
-0.0004917656,
0.055483792,
-0.0160927139,
-0.0041011022,
0.0219037347,
-0.0865674093,
-0.0210843347,
-0.0155546991,
0.0598154739,
-0.0216533057,
0.0371514857,
0.0017635575,
0.0563878343,
0.0137876887,
-0.0518178865,
0.0147362007,
-0.0439744107,
-0.0513508096,
-0.0177528895,
0.0581183359,
0.008890355,
0.0145530077,
0.0279044751,
0.0150987422,
-0.0205568392,
0.0077759945,
-0.0285660382,
-0.002826937,
-0.0317977667,
-0.0238676406,
-0.0167047475,
0.0080062384,
0.0551941581,
0.0011246407,
-0.0292827561,
0.088085033,
-0.0065326053,
-0.0196425226,
0.0137912938,
-0.0093620094,
0.0077283452,
-0.0652934536,
0.0397168696,
0.0478049815,
-0.1039388031,
0.0129325716,
-0.0074636252,
0.0083271973,
-0.0070768176,
-0.0427740365,
0.0478138775,
0.0383241475,
0.0016581285,
0.0352581181,
0.0185190924,
0.07510297,
0.0174436904,
-0.002640188,
-0.0259537678,
0.0104743298,
-0.0615601577,
0.0170367546,
-0.0041660806,
0.0214248858,
-0.0521757677,
-0.0389145538,
-0.0120628309,
0.054454159,
-0.0113273831,
0.0358186476,
0.0061161993,
0.0042922227,
0.003103364,
-0.0171228368,
-0.041348584,
-0.0276494659,
-0.065353483,
0.0322762616,
0.0260819495,
-0.0998205841,
0.0332949124,
-0.0254540127,
-0.0100267669,
-0.0147293815,
-0.0223704968,
0.0685759783,
-0.0082241185,
-0.037884634,
-0.0276393015,
-0.0312841535,
0.0194770843,
-0.0936618075,
-0.0444943942,
-0.0647821724,
0.0543844625,
-0.0017212314,
-0.0273323115,
-0.0278946962,
0.0339294821,
0.0103784315,
0.0007351057,
0.0596194342,
0.0314631499,
0.0490840785,
0.0264448747,
0.0475537218,
-0.0571119487,
0.0500409231,
0.0437225662,
0.0845814049,
0.036764428,
0.0204500984,
0.0358659886,
0.0472728945,
-0.0340879075,
0.0084185787,
0.0363405421,
0.0129813245,
-0.0177767295,
0.0434545688,
-0.0642667636,
0.0473423563,
-0.0143418331,
0.0185662247,
0.0934697688,
0.0936192125,
0.0087342048,
-0.0409765765,
0.0011927615,
0.035940405,
0.0102981012,
-0.0373998843,
-0.0662687495,
0.036388427,
-0.0317879245,
-0.0169760007,
0.0385295823,
0.0241919179,
-0.0262045264,
-0.039484527,
-0.0042788126,
0.0021043294,
0.0175673552,
0.0013699852,
0.0184309538,
-0.0192218944,
-0.0400141776,
0.0188835021,
-0.0198049694,
-0.0259213671,
-0.032125406,
-0.0648799166,
0.0273102596,
0.0759759545,
0.0590781346,
-0.0164005309,
-0.0519079044,
0.0321042873,
0.0049822577,
0.0021361122,
0.0422019772,
-0.0129292849,
0.0450198948,
-0.0220376011,
-0.0402924269,
0.0171554219,
0.0207639188,
0.0270424336,
0.0375007689,
0.0329995081,
0.0083130961,
-0.0525582656,
0.009249893,
0.0125728045,
-0.0082085775,
-0.0218204707,
0.0012338246,
0.0314569958,
0.0403476171,
0.0173452515,
0.0045791534,
-0.0079925433,
0.0350830518,
-0.0127222734,
0.0196668729,
0.0294472557,
-0.0079049524,
0.0095207104,
0.0207008012,
0.0185662191,
0.0009148882,
0.0544313863,
0.0046149567,
-0.029544754,
0.0058887852,
0.0040591802,
0.0093389768,
0.0093994197,
0.072594136,
-0.0062957574,
-0.0269089267,
0.0228994638,
0.0380199738,
-0.0060639745,
-0.0018059987,
0.0427160859,
0.0397051796,
0.0141007779,
-0.008109469,
0.0074021379,
0.0246013384,
-0.005821845,
0.0166634452,
0.0143537326,
0.0038089755,
-0.0394794606,
-0.0400185771,
-0.1206264198,
0.0248897038,
-0.0403448232,
0.0137963276,
0.018225126,
0.0444259569,
0.0084723122,
-0.0101256892,
0.0109688193,
0.0300701428,
0.0151337096,
0.0629484206,
-0.0154053373,
0.0055089239,
-0.0536768809,
-0.0569945313,
0.0409275331,
0.0094665242,
-0.0073786117,
-0.0092515135,
-0.0103979567,
0.0054882849,
-0.0286894143,
-0.0371946134,
0.0043232399,
-0.0295339935,
-0.0386384241,
0.08886417,
-0.0293368865,
-0.0024026141,
0.0397059247,
0.0023489799,
0.0316193476,
0.0365773663,
-0.0474043265,
-0.0632809177,
0.0284425337,
0.0019989028,
-0.0116703007,
-0.063077271,
-0.0332600065,
0.0297725741,
0.0589070618,
-0.0387047306,
0.0472424552,
-0.028314678,
-0.0192347169,
-0.0111000407,
-0.0548974313,
-0.0131018469,
0.0385274626,
-0.0472874306,
0.0608335696,
-0.0375208147,
-0.0430493206,
0.039472051,
-0.042481821,
0.0114459051,
0.0057668434,
-0.0173225086,
-0.0201524962,
0.1282410622,
-0.0108507909,
-0.0046936963,
-0.0619041733,
-0.0266586281,
-0.0129237808,
0.0020403268,
-0.0240449402,
-0.0507662185,
0.0235571004,
-0.0956587419,
-0.0063341619,
0.0044896877,
-0.0450107306,
-0.003205478,
-0.0037661497,
-0.0552580729,
-0.0079018101,
0.0074118413,
-0.0424002148,
-0.045241151,
0.0075466083,
0.0260626804,
0.0614195578,
-0.0077479254,
-0.0145488642,
-0.0127185173,
-0.0393017381,
0.0075124465,
0.0466342941,
-0.0260059386,
-0.0136089902,
0.0612661913,
0.0308721829,
0.068402499,
-0.0212892499,
-0.0276518278,
0.0083966423,
0.0203075744,
-0.0121417819,
-0.0285595879,
0.0831373408,
0.0617930219,
-0.0635587499,
0.0097658224,
0.1036838964,
0.0420926586,
-0.0237234253,
0.0205839016,
-0.0417285301,
-0.0001454667,
0.0151212737,
0.0248005912,
-0.0417424142,
-0.060733553,
0.0212703738,
0.0005403289,
0.00990739,
-0.0416365452,
0.0006987543,
-0.0878216252,
0.0159719046,
-0.0131614134,
-0.0098903654,
0.0371928662,
-0.0492570363,
0.0224213991,
0.0128134787,
0.0070178295,
0.0086448696,
0.0393478088,
-0.0236161668,
-0.0326801538,
-0.067940034,
-0.0345440321,
0.0731349885,
-0.0319805443,
0.0265690349,
0.0725046992,
0.0538336262,
0.029252246,
-0.0367104188,
0.0192996692,
0.0324400812,
0.0420750305,
-0.00675603,
-0.0121189579,
0.0054078978,
0.0240578279,
-0.0025362696,
-0.0000116625,
-0.0426425487,
-0.021872472,
0.0416094437,
0.0785544142,
-0.0419322886,
0.005759499,
-0.0237153526,
-0.0089750793,
0.0350472815,
0.0404763445,
-0.0042289067,
-0.0380861536,
-0.0704434589,
-0.0191398431,
-0.0389085077,
-0.0496882536,
0.006741059,
0.0068730484,
0.0084893303,
-0.0037813629,
-0.0465977415,
-0.0590331964,
0.0563939102,
0.0244194157,
0.0103235701,
0.0356105976,
0.0088082943,
0.0348525234,
0.0005053269,
-0.0054236143,
0.0046795262,
0.06406679,
-0.0304497946,
0.0219887774,
0.0046331426,
-0.0410636514,
0.031934876,
-0.0080362651,
-0.0793386698,
-0.0550781302,
0.0042216699,
0.0342847854,
0.0295184031,
0.0039860401,
-0.0376056805,
-0.0482951328,
0.0071830475,
0.0324884616,
-0.070529215,
0.0319860503,
-0.0018172732,
0.0064096479,
-0.0036424105,
0.0395792499,
-0.0811040103,
0.0243576448,
-0.0341157727,
0.0752084777,
-0.0686620325,
-0.0422731116,
0.0031009438,
0.0077417823,
0.0109924963,
0.0165471472,
-0.0262800325,
0.0145386867,
0.0313649997,
-0.0047461623,
-0.007862363,
-0.0504597127,
-0.0184683185,
-0.0099815167,
0.0071319384,
0.0412111133,
0.0299934912,
0.0060493178,
-0.0080168601,
0.009065765,
0.0181481969,
0.0008595114,
0.0081175882,
0.0311381966,
0.0144161778,
-0.0230490193,
0.015997991,
0.0024265067,
0.0385575891,
-0.0165933464,
0.0437217876,
-0.0245644767,
-0.0098877084,
-0.0076752868,
0.0597055294,
-0.0757076889,
-0.0778633058,
0.057026159,
0.0391841754,
0.0408533625,
0.0118257552,
0.0481330864,
-0.0494236015,
0.0325193517,
-0.066233255,
-0.0158983357,
-0.0072975392,
-0.0333662145,
0.0031783299,
0.0295773353,
-0.0018877243,
0.0069220811,
0.0539442375,
-0.034284845,
0.0208941326,
-0.0145140579,
-0.0444936864,
-0.04383827,
-0.0416347794,
0.0029476844,
0.0279524568,
-0.0155627402,
-0.0338601731,
-0.058254689,
-0.0158292148,
-0.0035653657,
0.0362523049,
0.0061077457,
-0.0743273422,
0.0042768787,
0.0582045503,
0.0173970368,
-0.0067983819,
-0.0658144653,
-0.0761691779,
-0.0625135973,
0.0203677323,
-0.0161627382,
-6.021209367e-33,
-0.0269588381,
-0.0383501574,
0.0600778908,
-0.0477595218,
-0.0176135115,
-0.0236936249,
-0.0557976998,
0.0104371971,
-0.0130147664,
-0.0146623431,
-0.0612345487,
0.011132461,
0.0132741043,
-0.02362106,
-0.0051150173,
0.0212480761,
0.0264530368,
0.0057841521,
-0.0741972178,
-0.015631577,
0.0045668422,
-0.0004476234,
-0.0218037944,
-0.0324973874,
-0.0126882503,
-0.0023989589,
-0.0101754824,
-0.0005364203,
-0.0096611278,
0.0487342291,
0.0140145794,
-0.0035380372,
0.0430075005,
-0.0223865155,
-0.0112110944,
0.0157258604,
-0.009848576,
-0.0442401506,
0.0102801239,
0.0256161094,
-0.0579138547,
-0.0061079515,
-0.0113927564,
0.0425961912,
-0.057425756,
0.0168618076,
-0.0001850873,
-0.0214330703,
-0.0460671857,
0.0295891762,
-0.0353758149,
0.0167066064,
0.0263720434,
-0.0405501835,
0.0112069603,
0.0386193134,
-0.0543756299,
-0.0221724827,
-0.0492224619,
0.0135864234,
-0.043891523,
0.0113772126,
0.0689176545,
0.0320303291,
0.0250858162,
0.0700967312,
0.0339349806,
0.054567121,
-0.0469448119,
-0.0078815622,
-0.0123939924,
0.1152413487,
-0.0078190314,
0.0230733063,
-0.0016725837,
-0.0039151772,
0.000484215,
0.0604134202,
0.052050475,
0.023908006,
0.0235984493,
0.0238219369,
-0.0349565819,
-0.0017310833,
-0.0510141402,
0.0681279302,
-0.0323457159,
-0.0346957073,
0.0645585433,
0.0339694284,
0.0204984378,
-0.0205059778,
0.0367549583,
0.0085191624,
0.0028673129,
-0.0276482422,
-0.009704574,
0.0311784111,
0.0006872575,
0.0111785093,
-0.0677332208,
-0.0140044438,
-0.0141686145,
0.0206569918,
0.0566186048,
0.0136349695,
-0.035951443,
0.0358333662,
-0.0236567669,
-0.0186593384,
-0.0463665947,
0.005583039,
-0.0107681202,
-0.0097714094,
0.0780698881,
-0.0528091565,
-0.0200898107,
0.0653909221,
-0.0481511392,
-0.0531590246,
-0.0202589575,
-0.0303277988,
0.0161039289,
-0.0246658362,
-0.0232813619,
-0.0109523889,
-0.0938727185,
0.0148690967,
0.0276100691,
-0.0050973487,
-0.0231670514,
0.0098514929,
2.977e-7,
-0.0479412042,
0.0040106387,
-0.0157769341,
0.0551618524,
0.0106158108,
0.0533188693,
-0.0364287384,
0.0101360362,
-0.0168659221,
-0.0148470132,
0.0338214673,
0.0427453555,
0.0733411759,
0.0502695777,
-0.0369430296,
-0.0172617063,
-0.0301588997,
0.0186002608,
-0.0542711653,
-0.0018631831,
0.0291161519,
0.0249693412,
0.015161504,
-0.0013209326,
0.0148360133,
-0.0477778912,
0.0179326423,
-0.0589103624,
0.0039792475,
0.0044647744,
0.0177528001,
0.0066928072,
-0.0251225252,
-0.0017160953,
-0.0155225117,
-0.0125940386,
-0.0182330161,
0.0633843914,
-0.0008430827,
-0.0303491373,
-0.0014768483,
-0.0464370437,
-0.0091123627,
0.0031148377,
0.0605075806,
0.0084585315,
-0.0165179465,
0.0301804505,
0.0155862421,
-0.0147443116,
-0.0352544747,
0.0270261765,
0.0024425408,
0.0046045184,
-0.0051773395,
-0.0100900652,
-0.010678065,
-0.0663236156,
-0.0091924593,
-0.0091632782,
-0.01538538,
-0.0792730227,
-0.094034113,
0.0401860923,
-0.0106814671,
-0.0320642665,
-0.0057407436,
2.335261184e-34,
0.0053610834,
-0.0124381529,
0.0256276391,
0.0226705875,
0.0496496893,
0.0202489309,
0.0042120665,
0.025273798,
0.0311253779,
-0.0540330671,
0.0061880876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00981v1 | VisEval: A Benchmark for Data Visualization in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T05:35:30 | 2024-07-01T05:35:30 | Nan Chen, Yuge Zhang, Jiahang Xu, Kan Ren, Yuqing Yang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Translating natural language to visualization (NL2VIS) has shown great
promise for visual data analysis, but it remains a challenging task that
requires multiple low-level implementations, such as natural language
processing and visualization design. Recent advancements in pre-trained large
language models (LLMs) are opening new avenues for generating visualizations
from natural language. However, the lack of a comprehensive and reliable
benchmark hinders our understanding of LLMs' capabilities in visualization
generation. In this paper, we address this gap by proposing a new NL2VIS
benchmark called VisEval. Firstly, we introduce a high-quality and large-scale
dataset. This dataset includes 2,524 representative queries covering 146
databases, paired with accurately labeled ground truths. Secondly, we advocate
for a comprehensive automated evaluation methodology covering multiple
dimensions, including validity, legality, and readability. By systematically
scanning for potential issues with a number of heterogeneous checkers, VisEval
provides reliable and trustworthy evaluation outcomes. We run VisEval on a
series of state-of-the-art LLMs. Our evaluation reveals prevalent challenges
and delivers essential insights for future advancements. | VisEval: A Benchmark for Data Visualization in the Era of Large Language Models: Translating natural language to visualization (NL2VIS) has shown great
promise for visual data analysis, but it remains a challenging task that
requires multiple low-level implementations, such as natural language
processing and visualization design. Recent advancements in pre-trained large
language models (LLMs) are opening new avenues for generating visualizations
from natural language. However, the lack of a comprehensive and reliable
benchmark hinders our understanding of LLMs' capabilities in visualization
generation. In this paper, we address this gap by proposing a new NL2VIS
benchmark called VisEval. Firstly, we introduce a high-quality and large-scale
dataset. This dataset includes 2,524 representative queries covering 146
databases, paired with accurately labeled ground truths. Secondly, we advocate
for a comprehensive automated evaluation methodology covering multiple
dimensions, including validity, legality, and readability. By systematically
scanning for potential issues with a number of heterogeneous checkers, VisEval
provides reliable and trustworthy evaluation outcomes. We run VisEval on a
series of state-of-the-art LLMs. Our evaluation reveals prevalent challenges
and delivers essential insights for future advancements. | [
-0.0044863559,
0.0741500556,
-0.0195968971,
0.0532815345,
-0.027711207,
0.0077438857,
-0.0153345903,
0.0220320169,
0.0246453304,
-0.0163843427,
0.0013247028,
-0.0002583045,
-0.0037980101,
0.047530584,
0.0002086419,
-0.0525580943,
0.0238035601,
-0.0167625882,
-0.0097193457,
0.0368389785,
-0.0077541019,
0.0006292729,
0.0029841608,
0.0243073907,
-0.0446617194,
-0.0460329913,
-0.0075491788,
-0.0002541056,
0.0139420666,
-0.0691783205,
-0.0576103255,
0.0408876725,
0.0358923711,
0.0492639616,
0.0000024923,
-0.045199398,
-0.0061507705,
0.0083946073,
-0.006353566,
0.0622988231,
0.0335703343,
-0.0506182685,
0.0231370386,
-0.0047347965,
-0.0444838293,
-0.0492880046,
0.0187980719,
0.0593370013,
0.1019375026,
0.0255990718,
-0.0223170556,
-0.0342796445,
-0.0043153483,
-0.0114138285,
-0.0185282044,
-0.0509379506,
-0.0116629424,
0.0380384438,
-0.0160524007,
0.0155442702,
-0.036228843,
0.0465716943,
0.0052434695,
-0.0376473553,
0.0069882534,
0.0092716431,
-0.0326701142,
-0.0134691494,
-0.0162575506,
0.0963529199,
-0.0466141142,
0.0061943857,
-0.0271243155,
-0.0307628475,
-0.0171880629,
0.0035108773,
-0.0353276059,
0.0125299813,
0.0140828881,
0.0324562974,
-0.0290672164,
0.0216764137,
0.0434006564,
-0.0246545896,
-0.0372495502,
0.0228986815,
-0.0019390862,
0.0033636731,
0.0312265418,
0.0014957949,
-0.041161634,
-0.0209448338,
-0.0022570419,
0.0115081901,
-0.0659436509,
0.0137866484,
-0.0127670188,
-0.0447229184,
0.0252793785,
-0.0422113463,
0.0856694877,
-0.0071626636,
-0.037697956,
0.0703094825,
-0.0180248059,
0.0435239375,
-0.0054326062,
0.0238718074,
-0.0020203139,
-0.0150089683,
-0.0192896873,
-0.0016846228,
-0.0458512306,
-0.0294601861,
-0.059417434,
-0.0292009413,
-0.0259921569,
-0.0113322195,
-0.027331138,
0.0234718565,
0.0075603588,
0.0234626736,
0.023305364,
0.0084676016,
-0.0796771571,
-0.0008890957,
-0.0421344154,
0.0292293485,
-0.0268613398,
-0.0507576391,
0.0095168622,
0.0249354076,
0.0255502369,
-0.0189247429,
-0.0043529291,
0.0638171285,
0.0128330942,
-0.0034063575,
-0.0530786552,
-0.02937489,
-0.0293472894,
-0.0348801278,
0.009235736,
-0.0593976341,
0.0446178503,
-0.0128411688,
0.0230971966,
-0.0275598876,
0.0048614936,
0.0266729612,
-0.0347418115,
0.0957438946,
-0.048653353,
0.0022726823,
-0.050654307,
-0.019652063,
0.0434377417,
0.0557366572,
0.0461055003,
0.0301330835,
0.0269740894,
-0.0525860302,
-0.0023339998,
0.0442698188,
0.009698296,
-0.0018831611,
-0.0557601042,
0.0176197477,
-0.0087863328,
0.045136895,
-0.0025249319,
0.0571319535,
-0.0179932714,
-0.0151082315,
0.0313548371,
0.0631271303,
0.0495659076,
-0.0027406225,
0.0318050049,
0.0544158965,
0.0235414375,
-0.0499678291,
-0.0086436048,
0.0059137573,
-0.0129003264,
-0.0074893325,
0.0044029071,
0.0222395621,
0.0151613671,
-0.04686689,
-0.0247395597,
0.0159421023,
0.0034801597,
-0.0222265795,
0.0324625149,
0.0376969948,
-0.0291915275,
0.0174667314,
0.0286777429,
-0.062685132,
-0.0056325379,
0.0106801586,
0.0134056052,
0.0632750392,
0.0536160246,
-0.0079482971,
0.0256634559,
0.0043187612,
0.0302040894,
0.0626448095,
0.0458915457,
0.0194654111,
0.0086596292,
-0.0361628495,
-0.0553781465,
-0.0134691624,
0.0133876549,
0.0015713931,
0.0156611651,
0.0193236023,
0.0170046091,
-0.083040297,
-0.0820391402,
0.0377274789,
0.0161913391,
-0.0113324756,
0.0238120481,
0.0012928479,
-0.0053380136,
0.0235910267,
-0.0359463319,
0.0231908578,
0.059556067,
-0.013432364,
0.0117715746,
0.0185935628,
0.0081154732,
-0.041142378,
0.0089265285,
-0.0826847479,
-0.0234086644,
-0.0013670018,
-0.0529980771,
-0.0213605352,
-0.0229966678,
-0.0470368639,
0.0001839578,
0.0041629607,
0.0130712241,
-0.0097397333,
0.0133293439,
-0.0351223908,
0.0472894013,
-0.0083317757,
0.0202205647,
0.0000840782,
0.0046849754,
0.0179901849,
0.0000059769,
-0.0055272612,
-0.0016618993,
0.0088339811,
0.0197016597,
-0.0038109438,
0.0161054879,
-0.0589446686,
0.018660387,
-0.0799288005,
0.0044629346,
0.0056912703,
0.0030910356,
0.017907992,
-0.0227687191,
-0.0274465922,
-0.0239846855,
-0.0366105027,
0.0210468601,
0.0267001651,
-0.0093547627,
0.0584469102,
-0.0302253682,
0.0254222471,
-0.0310734361,
-0.0056767776,
-0.015099097,
0.054860197,
0.0442456715,
-0.0030457161,
-0.0076705404,
0.017908385,
0.0036034428,
0.0122758485,
0.0076911431,
0.0265135784,
0.0358947888,
-0.0092628151,
0.0219177343,
-0.0029773281,
0.0158350766,
0.0317354575,
0.0501006022,
-0.0284116529,
-0.056161765,
0.0224443041,
-0.0146854362,
0.0256059393,
-0.0264418349,
-0.0439577214,
0.0339204036,
0.0299178045,
0.0143585689,
0.0161573067,
-0.0388654135,
0.0276294779,
-0.0122357858,
-0.0066196946,
-0.0837814137,
0.0048950049,
0.0167169459,
0.0479925424,
-0.018159939,
-0.0587182902,
0.019658884,
-0.0530141369,
0.0335303172,
-0.0135487961,
0.0103374114,
-0.0571133755,
0.1044058129,
0.0362898931,
0.0044132797,
-0.0327268131,
-0.0118612228,
0.0071626497,
-0.0005140031,
0.0177902617,
-0.0379816741,
0.0462602265,
-0.0687940866,
-0.0171155781,
-0.0030874577,
0.0137363588,
-0.0278686713,
-0.0278579947,
-0.0378191471,
-0.0330422632,
0.0774271712,
-0.0305737872,
-0.0339679196,
0.0102939429,
-0.0000726883,
-0.0039128442,
0.0091719562,
-0.0286250189,
-0.028688686,
0.0096793231,
0.0250215661,
0.0268710516,
0.0130379889,
-0.0217472166,
0.0170908235,
0.0275523532,
-0.0287315771,
0.0178061128,
-0.0547913313,
0.0181288756,
-0.0032400177,
0.0175199453,
0.0136752706,
0.0032872166,
0.0394598134,
-0.0501672365,
0.0067792688,
0.1052917615,
0.0388842449,
-0.0178883709,
0.0249048248,
0.0135549111,
0.0283098165,
0.0195895694,
0.0103085842,
-0.1134283468,
-0.0298897587,
-0.0304731987,
0.0089611504,
0.0411311276,
-0.0590962954,
-0.0099632749,
-0.1404935718,
0.0764830261,
0.0006280674,
-0.0212423839,
-0.0071700853,
-0.0767446086,
-0.0205261875,
-0.0499547906,
0.0222103652,
-0.0272691809,
-0.0134593127,
-0.0000761254,
-0.0011276198,
-0.0376632176,
-0.0199862402,
0.0310855247,
-0.0660102367,
-0.0011152842,
0.0210702959,
0.0743187666,
-0.0215472467,
-0.0371073149,
0.0057133697,
0.0314983465,
0.0253854375,
-0.0105084265,
0.1036717892,
0.0430776775,
-0.0388393179,
-0.0469616093,
-0.0329526626,
0.0046882997,
-0.00789895,
0.0243893657,
0.0597282648,
-0.0204844158,
-0.0288720112,
-0.0353774801,
0.0088679232,
-0.01603131,
0.0733344853,
0.0463678539,
-0.0279400256,
-0.058423534,
-0.0294860434,
0.015718516,
-0.0527302437,
-0.098030597,
0.0195551645,
-0.0123256063,
-0.018205706,
-0.0516911149,
-0.009463137,
0.0484554209,
0.0380418301,
0.0227115452,
0.0139115099,
0.0209805556,
-0.0349085666,
-0.0348325931,
0.0566628948,
-0.058178734,
0.0259395353,
-0.0267914496,
0.0114932433,
0.0069954055,
0.0107962135,
-0.0035949436,
0.0276713334,
-0.0567918718,
-0.0150791015,
-0.0142352469,
-0.0043005664,
0.0092988806,
0.0265464205,
-0.025823731,
-0.0542809777,
0.0530856289,
0.0690703765,
-0.0286564473,
-0.0578411967,
-0.0416952595,
-0.009040202,
0.0051506818,
-0.0015933121,
0.0093994662,
-0.0020703836,
-0.0208117776,
0.0427629538,
-0.0154243885,
-0.0183075592,
0.0347016342,
0.0424430817,
0.047410246,
0.0138817644,
-0.0273872521,
-0.0111015709,
-0.0249556154,
-0.0656130984,
-0.0470764562,
-0.0303360336,
0.016967874,
0.0517269596,
-0.038011387,
-0.0050669457,
0.052438356,
0.0064189699,
0.0060586524,
-0.0580593832,
0.0231923591,
0.017717341,
-0.0179124717,
0.0262885466,
0.0142815523,
0.0110916421,
0.0178667977,
-0.0219510812,
0.0559521988,
0.0363021903,
0.009689494,
0.0056480048,
-0.0082716467,
-0.0140095027,
0.0284195412,
-0.0305151213,
-0.0644219518,
0.0186100248,
0.0223963149,
0.0419103317,
-0.035699781,
0.0863610432,
-0.0215505753,
0.0008702528,
-0.0186390541,
0.0256593395,
0.0038995901,
-0.0097785378,
0.0347289629,
0.0043110792,
-0.0375779346,
-0.0396740623,
0.0501407497,
0.0120108491,
0.0267170016,
-0.009272038,
-0.0329281576,
-0.0503421314,
-0.0039443481,
0.0190104004,
0.0005494104,
-0.0260615405,
-0.0095022246,
-0.0679466724,
-0.0784777701,
0.0053069568,
0.0089046024,
-0.0033397733,
0.0279418584,
0.0241262224,
0.0480738431,
0.0361225903,
0.0022704385,
-0.0246030893,
0.0270489473,
-0.0266570374,
-0.0592741817,
-0.0248569716,
-7.011871557e-33,
-0.0210407302,
-0.0737223923,
0.0271531604,
-0.0674137846,
-0.0011600457,
-0.0031274876,
-0.0320465825,
0.0098969778,
-0.029240001,
0.033457458,
-0.0066729598,
0.0152276279,
0.0110954139,
0.0324032791,
-0.0031473371,
-0.0169948377,
0.046317149,
0.0093699154,
-0.0394956693,
-0.0035926944,
0.0118564209,
0.0113532897,
0.0281524006,
-0.0878193229,
0.0242661666,
0.0543263145,
-0.0294086877,
0.019666465,
-0.009088628,
0.0312853269,
-0.0369751118,
0.0495045893,
0.0131746167,
0.0033652568,
-0.0477392897,
-0.006408358,
-0.0434230901,
-0.0315761082,
0.0149542317,
0.036978025,
-0.0669139698,
-0.0040918128,
0.0613100082,
-0.0006446228,
-0.0331167132,
-0.0153255332,
0.0499839261,
-0.0278089624,
-0.0252856296,
-0.0084831323,
-0.0356126614,
0.0483191907,
-0.0446392745,
0.0019842992,
0.021016119,
0.0434405357,
-0.0028854585,
0.0544300228,
-0.0914976001,
0.0585365631,
0.0644698367,
-0.031321425,
0.0701814219,
-0.0080429902,
0.0345624872,
0.0898923874,
0.0301271062,
-0.0049956432,
-0.0309637059,
0.0453056581,
0.0242898818,
0.102820918,
0.0670751482,
0.0250041597,
0.013708666,
0.0074815289,
-0.0618336201,
0.0390870348,
-0.0540689491,
0.0308434553,
-0.0075217937,
-0.0065917103,
-0.048831895,
-0.0333218239,
-0.0720306784,
-0.0035006891,
-0.0301647503,
0.0093329353,
0.0386225209,
-0.0347191282,
0.0020131203,
0.00082285,
-0.0138819739,
-0.0343725346,
-0.0543573797,
0.0258271042,
-0.0082668187,
0.0111460695,
-0.000146572,
0.0066438066,
-0.0071588713,
0.0050233393,
0.0126798991,
-0.0001113763,
0.0227270089,
0.0114100724,
0.0379902832,
-0.0154873356,
-0.0907349065,
0.0166763905,
-0.0127575314,
-0.0360578485,
0.0149448048,
-0.0016054343,
0.0498718768,
-0.0336006768,
-0.0235219393,
0.0679115355,
0.0211837478,
0.0183641855,
0.0129573429,
-0.0294973254,
-0.0153713459,
0.0041434774,
0.0083229952,
-0.0084147379,
-0.052456513,
-0.0198894013,
0.0751066431,
-0.0565021969,
-0.0266740527,
-0.0112033132,
2.984e-7,
0.0864494964,
0.080966197,
0.0391330644,
0.0672424361,
-0.0074690096,
0.0329946056,
-0.0110107241,
0.0100061558,
-0.0105648171,
-0.0010864324,
-0.0223300382,
0.0359861925,
0.0487338379,
0.0571910404,
-0.0263063591,
-0.0048044538,
-0.0698710009,
-0.047409445,
-0.0705294982,
0.0072576026,
0.1068421975,
0.0652967021,
-0.0086012958,
-0.0261891261,
0.0158706624,
-0.0593619868,
0.0346138291,
-0.06669911,
-0.0253426675,
0.0165371522,
0.0263570044,
0.0314030536,
0.0176252201,
0.0112250587,
0.0027462591,
-0.001570829,
0.0028068416,
0.0300442372,
0.0247997325,
0.0371857285,
-0.0095994426,
-0.0370348059,
0.0042927279,
-0.0371012054,
0.0847374052,
-0.0399098769,
-0.0401836522,
-0.0257643536,
-0.0029264137,
-0.0168629158,
0.0850145891,
-0.0187161323,
-0.0104859788,
0.0048514232,
0.0119461324,
-0.0043996489,
-0.0260108579,
-0.0019438918,
-0.0377501696,
0.0147010554,
-0.0017880048,
-0.0101723252,
-0.0392772555,
0.0315936394,
0.0092235459,
-0.0185124464,
0.0158877075,
2.825354396e-34,
0.0552730598,
0.0089552216,
0.0460938364,
-0.0260118227,
0.0840310976,
-0.0055506723,
-0.0000709174,
0.0018626215,
-0.0174567532,
-0.104237847,
0.0071980497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00958v1 | Universal Approximation Theory: The basic theory for large language models | 2024-07-01T04:29:35 | 2024-07-01T04:29:35 | Wei Wang, Qing Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models have emerged as a critical area of focus in artificial
intelligence, particularly with the introduction of groundbreaking innovations
like ChatGPT. Large-scale Transformer networks have quickly become the leading
approach for advancing natural language processing algorithms. Built on the
Transformer architecture, these models enable interactions that closely mimic
human communication and, equipped with extensive knowledge, can even assist in
guiding human tasks. Despite their impressive capabilities and growing
complexity, a key question remains-the theoretical foundations of large
language models (LLMs). What makes Transformer so effective for powering
intelligent language applications, such as translation and coding? What
underlies LLMs' ability for In-Context Learning (ICL)? How does the LoRA scheme
enhance the fine-tuning of LLMs? And what supports the practicality of pruning
LLMs? To address these critical questions and explore the technological
strategies within LLMs, we leverage the Universal Approximation Theory (UAT) to
offer a theoretical backdrop, shedding light on the mechanisms that underpin
these advancements. | Universal Approximation Theory: The basic theory for large language models: Language models have emerged as a critical area of focus in artificial
intelligence, particularly with the introduction of groundbreaking innovations
like ChatGPT. Large-scale Transformer networks have quickly become the leading
approach for advancing natural language processing algorithms. Built on the
Transformer architecture, these models enable interactions that closely mimic
human communication and, equipped with extensive knowledge, can even assist in
guiding human tasks. Despite their impressive capabilities and growing
complexity, a key question remains-the theoretical foundations of large
language models (LLMs). What makes Transformer so effective for powering
intelligent language applications, such as translation and coding? What
underlies LLMs' ability for In-Context Learning (ICL)? How does the LoRA scheme
enhance the fine-tuning of LLMs? And what supports the practicality of pruning
LLMs? To address these critical questions and explore the technological
strategies within LLMs, we leverage the Universal Approximation Theory (UAT) to
offer a theoretical backdrop, shedding light on the mechanisms that underpin
these advancements. | [
0.0239421986,
0.0249793548,
-0.0301658511,
0.0507250316,
-0.0506455675,
0.0270246733,
-0.0018986656,
0.0255357567,
-0.0257214494,
0.0062586349,
-0.0591088459,
-0.0841888934,
0.0269373301,
-0.0072811972,
0.0031278026,
-0.0200446025,
0.0274155326,
-0.0311239976,
-0.0460966788,
-0.0321247391,
-0.0111099929,
-0.0236579217,
0.0126559194,
0.0706635639,
0.0116475774,
-0.0044324095,
-0.002369653,
-0.0425882488,
-0.0164602362,
0.0274322424,
-0.0153165972,
0.0142837139,
0.0359088778,
0.0393738821,
0.0000020834,
-0.0319424979,
-0.0058868956,
0.0005662065,
0.0038100488,
-0.0423188917,
0.0500750802,
-0.0382299088,
-0.0132309264,
0.0148809683,
-0.0404087305,
-0.0235061534,
0.0743539631,
0.0348798968,
0.0068781921,
0.0674707592,
0.0048472527,
-0.0635232031,
0.050957825,
-0.0207280908,
-0.0227227975,
-0.0472520031,
0.023390457,
0.0063359579,
0.0167005826,
-0.0100977132,
-0.0434422679,
0.0297263023,
0.0275854021,
-0.0087328497,
-0.0170772895,
0.0281128064,
-0.0270302221,
-0.0353221335,
0.0068626213,
0.0425588861,
-0.0453021452,
-0.0150436452,
-0.0348551199,
0.0183078013,
-0.0489478894,
0.0060881209,
-0.0468216464,
0.0140849371,
0.0097362855,
0.0492231436,
-0.0040471866,
-0.0096890666,
0.0257512201,
-0.0139214583,
-0.0524302796,
0.0674286112,
-0.009364414,
-0.0035392933,
-0.0007165871,
0.0088484138,
-0.0290575307,
-0.0276221484,
0.0278936923,
0.0539106093,
-0.0118147498,
-0.0354730561,
-0.0276380908,
0.0220107306,
0.0002127176,
-0.0389647074,
0.0233275276,
0.0494756252,
0.0108940834,
0.0209559239,
0.0014251631,
0.0738974735,
-0.0514396243,
-0.0216618758,
-0.0381688438,
-0.0144442106,
-0.0382296965,
-0.0152226677,
-0.0275447499,
0.0494508073,
-0.0554181524,
-0.0303951111,
-0.0178229026,
0.0285405107,
0.0130431699,
-0.0050284513,
0.0124613605,
-0.0012321912,
-0.0375752449,
-0.018668402,
-0.0174568482,
0.0498911627,
0.0176683106,
0.0212160833,
-0.0385172665,
-0.0728304833,
-0.0021763013,
0.0161782745,
0.0004715172,
-0.0233691111,
0.011588484,
0.0872822776,
-0.0013427932,
-0.0381276831,
-0.0202706289,
0.0084723812,
-0.0273037665,
-0.0513580143,
-0.0139137832,
-0.0734896734,
0.0239721108,
0.0166182518,
-0.0004872541,
-0.0136422906,
-0.0138707999,
0.0040777242,
-0.0457966067,
0.0557515547,
0.0012085497,
0.0257791113,
0.008430521,
-0.0058178664,
0.0287769716,
0.0202634875,
0.0260990392,
-0.0109264655,
-0.0005824374,
-0.0182797741,
0.0053852708,
0.0652184784,
-0.0245064758,
0.0009720126,
-0.0158748627,
-0.0221462436,
0.0058556953,
0.021676017,
0.0402962565,
0.0617289767,
-0.0488005504,
-0.0344778709,
0.0968883187,
0.0570757017,
0.0590005219,
0.1148347408,
0.0266792569,
0.0206263103,
-0.0077208932,
0.0192971621,
-0.0343131684,
0.0250135045,
-0.0265268236,
0.0023869264,
-0.007279533,
0.0347056538,
-0.0538429916,
-0.0408418439,
-0.0057331244,
-0.0209940188,
-0.000611843,
-0.0244397279,
0.0340453573,
0.0139103159,
-0.0133350985,
0.082746543,
0.0314558372,
-0.0042605801,
0.0282565095,
-0.0628656,
-0.0001019083,
0.0258643404,
0.0461813956,
-0.0305070989,
-0.0078103174,
-0.0032922926,
0.0070652142,
0.0670914128,
0.0105652064,
0.0102781979,
-0.0198311415,
-0.0226111375,
0.0164623,
0.0262233727,
-0.0018061532,
-0.0316451304,
-0.008909028,
0.0129077472,
-0.0390276834,
-0.0032031236,
-0.01244999,
0.0127665037,
-0.0539285317,
-0.0099208644,
0.0141191296,
0.0065644295,
0.0212520268,
0.01766132,
-0.0370079093,
0.006509562,
0.0272873901,
-0.0424354114,
-0.0319940522,
0.0062996028,
-0.0690293312,
0.0094621945,
0.041602686,
-0.0215180181,
0.0571517311,
0.0360428467,
-0.011853829,
-0.0100888321,
0.0246702358,
-0.0513394699,
0.084256202,
-0.0331061296,
0.0424972661,
-0.0290766768,
0.0406945348,
-0.0178512745,
0.0421674773,
-0.0148861967,
0.0272692982,
0.0123316823,
0.0042847507,
-0.0052656578,
-0.0340475067,
-0.0432415977,
0.0342120714,
-0.0034118309,
0.0215623789,
0.0410271063,
0.0173155963,
0.0063845213,
-0.0556302629,
-0.0623619743,
-0.0201841928,
0.0084647387,
0.0333036296,
0.0082605518,
0.0383574478,
-0.0020047557,
0.0007136088,
-0.0058074151,
0.0350172222,
0.0238465071,
0.0095368354,
0.043968033,
0.0135274809,
-0.0763614476,
-0.0347086564,
-0.0279151481,
0.0095871398,
0.0724468231,
-0.0089143598,
-0.0308885686,
-0.0883649215,
0.0160292033,
0.0018924049,
0.0751246884,
-0.0322668366,
-0.0499427058,
0.0126032932,
0.0069256569,
0.0303633455,
0.052411031,
0.0096461615,
0.0203884337,
0.029908957,
0.0189017858,
-0.0336819403,
-0.0043700314,
-0.1014372036,
-0.0579142459,
-0.0722912028,
0.0177873597,
-0.0183591805,
0.113561146,
-0.0034543648,
-0.0114649748,
-0.0316533186,
0.0307870414,
0.0034557304,
-0.0228257328,
0.009121689,
-0.0321964659,
-0.0179035217,
-0.0010550165,
-0.0438392237,
-0.0356371552,
0.0495448895,
-0.0358618461,
-0.0025006905,
-0.0224229824,
-0.022424804,
-0.055759728,
0.0463397093,
0.0328282826,
0.0381677821,
-0.0179133322,
-0.0338171273,
-0.0377834179,
0.0230597723,
-0.0232757684,
-0.0237786379,
0.078062512,
-0.038544368,
0.0243615303,
-0.0154042877,
-0.0617101677,
-0.0072575118,
-0.0013028448,
-0.0008846509,
0.0284522269,
0.0252580438,
-0.0187562276,
-0.0463790707,
0.0320216902,
0.0465578772,
0.0482415743,
0.0068222634,
-0.0285498183,
-0.0482879654,
0.06650161,
-0.0098098703,
0.0248455368,
0.0436241552,
0.0227852985,
0.0731621534,
0.0390738174,
0.0152674485,
0.0347300991,
-0.02401039,
0.0225104224,
0.0585593767,
-0.0238271523,
-0.0399267338,
0.0198827069,
0.0558465011,
-0.0195675958,
-0.0320891291,
0.1076605543,
0.0044839876,
-0.0710089952,
0.032182727,
-0.0336230807,
0.0074556558,
0.0357115306,
0.0188361779,
-0.0756612942,
-0.0056370464,
0.0032078635,
-0.0095492937,
0.0002552584,
-0.0481318794,
0.0165590998,
-0.0858186334,
0.0123380125,
0.0360052288,
-0.084443219,
-0.0498923995,
-0.0098043624,
0.0218886063,
-0.0252225548,
0.0588556603,
0.0018914406,
-0.0103589986,
-0.0430565141,
0.0230154768,
-0.0046454249,
-0.0506174453,
0.0255361497,
-0.0360751897,
0.0304358434,
0.0488421358,
0.025035385,
-0.0231512096,
-0.0399718098,
0.0299717132,
0.0266219117,
0.0227363426,
-0.0116525739,
0.0035301214,
0.0356552489,
-0.0151475295,
0.003975709,
0.0230942816,
-0.0418945141,
-0.0023220177,
-0.0487139225,
0.0779139549,
-0.0301094465,
-0.0333106704,
0.0288398713,
-0.0178430304,
-0.000069056,
0.0361647084,
0.022472566,
-0.0656357557,
-0.0225172527,
-0.0025189691,
0.0068580774,
0.0457785837,
-0.0995986387,
0.0210859925,
0.0138357859,
-0.0694805384,
-0.0352897868,
0.0107746841,
-0.0011985104,
-0.0117724575,
0.0042456971,
-0.0390509628,
0.0547449775,
-0.0084351785,
0.0028148054,
0.0041044909,
-0.053514652,
-0.0098465187,
-0.0412168019,
0.0394188203,
0.0423567705,
-0.0627734214,
-0.0357539617,
-0.0084353136,
-0.0804843977,
-0.0415939987,
0.0235591345,
0.0214478523,
0.0309658833,
0.0421776101,
-0.0137244891,
-0.0917472839,
0.0416760072,
0.0799182057,
-0.0568439737,
0.0487657562,
0.0064732078,
-0.0107810255,
0.0182042345,
0.0467002578,
-0.007423569,
0.0418651365,
0.0170680787,
0.0495198481,
-0.0125203924,
-0.0643844455,
0.0744132698,
-0.0103123626,
0.0275634546,
0.0490767397,
0.0144542754,
-0.0066739377,
0.0119704362,
0.0411432832,
0.0158595275,
-0.0500755645,
-0.0499833412,
0.0302531179,
0.0527458303,
-0.0012471473,
-0.0267256685,
0.0090303328,
0.0151940072,
-0.0007295849,
0.003952886,
0.0546516813,
0.0298136044,
0.0388974547,
0.0258990806,
-0.0285421424,
0.0004408138,
-0.0158182532,
0.0277818274,
-0.0244632177,
0.0405481495,
-0.0062018107,
-0.0136923976,
-0.0382263213,
0.0144341737,
-0.0598678477,
-0.1097958237,
-0.0297530554,
0.043552395,
0.0512155592,
0.0097017987,
0.0022691686,
-0.0217518657,
0.0002867756,
-0.0151469242,
-0.0075027877,
-0.0088235587,
-0.019163426,
0.0186656769,
0.018476896,
-0.013488167,
0.0080749216,
0.0623846725,
-0.0374851525,
0.035001196,
-0.0089710047,
-0.0018825915,
-0.0140320323,
-0.0518980026,
0.012449408,
0.0000249949,
-0.002281277,
-0.0103370044,
-0.0467242822,
-0.04433579,
0.0103117749,
0.0167467296,
0.0042768377,
-0.0532951429,
0.0245294776,
0.0551320016,
0.0009421231,
-0.0187571235,
-0.0040338589,
-0.0051032603,
-0.0038237919,
0.0049761306,
0.0100066578,
-6.619061018e-33,
-0.018626608,
-0.0252773594,
0.0330246463,
0.0459678844,
-0.0366680734,
-0.0233963039,
-0.006813922,
0.0021136662,
-0.0424285233,
-0.0265578907,
-0.027510915,
0.0020717359,
0.006738551,
0.0267773103,
-0.0158874784,
-0.0074801515,
0.0294884983,
-0.0025041464,
0.0036899066,
0.0069776331,
0.0033949453,
0.0041693179,
0.0659325272,
-0.0373402499,
0.0045155799,
-0.0139356125,
0.006882627,
0.0651529208,
0.0307233371,
0.060234841,
-0.0781240836,
0.0543365218,
0.0319014266,
-0.0703225285,
-0.0040398254,
0.0438651964,
-0.0767025128,
0.0011943849,
0.0160822757,
0.0306501426,
0.0161234289,
-0.0185855702,
0.0807087645,
-0.0090038059,
-0.0471538529,
-0.0130420132,
0.0194581784,
-0.0490336008,
-0.0300507117,
-0.0205064174,
-0.063257359,
0.002058801,
0.0122051891,
0.0095837489,
0.0062797451,
0.0189897362,
-0.0393619314,
0.0358995534,
-0.0852873251,
0.0176505223,
0.0060527474,
0.0724540353,
0.0431602672,
-0.0255578756,
0.0148234926,
0.0468508191,
0.0310558081,
-0.0306249689,
-0.0211661961,
-0.0230415687,
0.0113507174,
0.0329706259,
0.025011519,
0.0465188287,
0.0128588229,
-0.0167768411,
-0.0708036497,
-0.0393463485,
0.0081546977,
0.0657527298,
0.0456279032,
0.0123943556,
-0.0294829793,
-0.0112475734,
-0.0319017358,
-0.0222604144,
-0.0421002209,
-0.0412134156,
-0.0077175046,
-0.0051999171,
-0.0029161174,
0.0104099587,
0.0069488119,
-0.0854673386,
-0.0022438562,
-0.0126575846,
0.0162989572,
0.034952417,
-0.014423687,
0.018262621,
-0.0506255515,
-0.0848541856,
-0.0586121678,
-0.0081765065,
-0.001566681,
-0.0191288777,
0.0196934845,
0.0693564191,
-0.0490505807,
-0.0190712139,
-0.0317220911,
0.0060719256,
0.0288529675,
-0.0024840881,
0.0403136276,
0.0001559051,
-0.0113341054,
0.0370662659,
0.0166582186,
-0.0048592952,
0.0027693729,
0.0216544066,
-0.0013942083,
0.0294613745,
-0.0312833935,
-0.0222618636,
-0.0587738268,
0.048484236,
0.0179516766,
-0.0756749213,
-0.0364316553,
0.0083627049,
2.947e-7,
0.0167629737,
0.0377777591,
0.0253830142,
-0.0014521091,
0.0428700261,
0.0051428364,
0.0238412581,
0.037937507,
0.0218670052,
0.0004504115,
0.0382667631,
0.0284691527,
0.0072683031,
0.002568301,
-0.0898683593,
0.0053301821,
-0.0889442638,
0.0019248028,
-0.0047016288,
-0.0076488624,
-0.0034579497,
0.0939277411,
0.0076492396,
-0.01577916,
-0.0266801398,
-0.0646895394,
0.0822617412,
-0.0443279222,
0.0087183276,
0.0481683649,
0.0026571469,
-0.0070547801,
-0.0052728006,
0.0022631374,
0.0541259944,
0.0818426982,
-0.0065260301,
0.0448506251,
0.0125994766,
-0.0055332822,
0.0398207195,
-0.0164324455,
-0.0123301502,
-0.078149721,
0.0634635985,
-0.0937564224,
-0.036503572,
0.0077869482,
0.0276076645,
-0.0311769042,
-0.0329249352,
-0.0344433486,
0.0016456991,
-0.0048576579,
0.0394932814,
-0.0009669302,
0.0178468134,
-0.0403141081,
-0.0058828695,
0.0462505147,
-0.0607902929,
-0.0453036539,
-0.0099296272,
0.0087220566,
0.0435421728,
-0.0130974343,
0.0097161308,
2.660776462e-34,
0.0233543999,
0.0238214526,
0.0278220586,
0.0304823332,
-0.0015739255,
-0.0003442806,
0.0152304107,
0.0144254155,
0.0192896836,
-0.104788065,
-0.0283868704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00952v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00952v1 | SplitLoRA: A Split Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T04:13:25 | 2024-07-01T04:13:25 | Zheng Lin, Xuanjie Hu, Yuxin Zhang, Zhe Chen, Zihan Fang, Xianhao Chen, Ang Li, Praneeth Vepakomma, Yue Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | The scalability of large language models (LLMs) in handling high-complexity
models and large-scale datasets has led to tremendous successes in pivotal
domains. While there is an urgent need to acquire more training data for LLMs,
a concerning reality is the depletion of high-quality public datasets within a
few years. In view of this, the federated learning (FL) LLM fine-tuning
paradigm recently has been proposed to facilitate collaborative LLM fine-tuning
on distributed private data, where multiple data owners collaboratively
fine-tune a shared LLM without sharing raw data. However, the staggering model
size of LLMs imposes heavy computing and communication burdens on clients,
posing significant barriers to the democratization of the FL LLM fine-tuning
paradigm. To address this issue, split learning (SL) has emerged as a promising
solution by offloading the primary training workload to a server via model
partitioning while exchanging activation/activation's gradients with smaller
data sizes rather than the entire LLM. Unfortunately, research on the SL LLM
fine-tuning paradigm is still in its nascent stage. To fill this gap, in this
paper, we propose the first SL LLM fine-tuning framework, named SplitLoRA.
SplitLoRA is built on the split federated learning (SFL) framework,
amalgamating the advantages of parallel training from FL and model splitting
from SL and thus greatly enhancing the training efficiency. It is worth noting
that SplitLoRA is the inaugural open-source benchmark for SL LLM fine-tuning,
providing a foundation for research efforts dedicated to advancing SL LLM
fine-tuning. Extensive simulations validate that SplitLoRA achieves target
accuracy in significantly less time than state-of-the-art LLM fine-tuning
frameworks, demonstrating the superior training performance of SplitLoRA. The
project page is available at https://fduinc.github.io/splitlora/. | SplitLoRA: A Split Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning Framework for Large Language Models: The scalability of large language models (LLMs) in handling high-complexity
models and large-scale datasets has led to tremendous successes in pivotal
domains. While there is an urgent need to acquire more training data for LLMs,
a concerning reality is the depletion of high-quality public datasets within a
few years. In view of this, the federated learning (FL) LLM fine-tuning
paradigm recently has been proposed to facilitate collaborative LLM fine-tuning
on distributed private data, where multiple data owners collaboratively
fine-tune a shared LLM without sharing raw data. However, the staggering model
size of LLMs imposes heavy computing and communication burdens on clients,
posing significant barriers to the democratization of the FL LLM fine-tuning
paradigm. To address this issue, split learning (SL) has emerged as a promising
solution by offloading the primary training workload to a server via model
partitioning while exchanging activation/activation's gradients with smaller
data sizes rather than the entire LLM. Unfortunately, research on the SL LLM
fine-tuning paradigm is still in its nascent stage. To fill this gap, in this
paper, we propose the first SL LLM fine-tuning framework, named SplitLoRA.
SplitLoRA is built on the split federated learning (SFL) framework,
amalgamating the advantages of parallel training from FL and model splitting
from SL and thus greatly enhancing the training efficiency. It is worth noting
that SplitLoRA is the inaugural open-source benchmark for SL LLM fine-tuning,
providing a foundation for research efforts dedicated to advancing SL LLM
fine-tuning. Extensive simulations validate that SplitLoRA achieves target
accuracy in significantly less time than state-of-the-art LLM fine-tuning
frameworks, demonstrating the superior training performance of SplitLoRA. The
project page is available at https://fduinc.github.io/splitlora/. | [
0.0237330403,
0.0657346994,
-0.0095975744,
0.0717091635,
-0.0399768092,
0.0023320992,
0.0814810768,
0.0023681063,
0.0013207097,
-0.0262796991,
-0.0916502178,
-0.0476872362,
-0.006827943,
0.0391741656,
-0.0141146313,
-0.0244014394,
0.0285179,
-0.0147026237,
-0.0052677854,
-0.030249076,
-0.0217128284,
0.0174274426,
0.0167866498,
0.0070137912,
0.0391609669,
-0.0290795881,
-0.0120375501,
0.0196817555,
-0.0065448051,
0.025476709,
0.036784362,
0.0587051362,
0.0217799619,
0.098779209,
0.0000020447,
-0.0345130116,
-0.0509633496,
0.0167002715,
-0.00206963,
0.0943977684,
0.0139074828,
0.0017754377,
0.0100591285,
0.038077265,
-0.0368173718,
-0.0113819744,
0.0107124951,
-0.0035829549,
0.0589027591,
0.0856109113,
0.0078581925,
-0.0470706448,
0.0004084463,
-0.0560322739,
-0.1151304096,
-0.0417018309,
0.0202387962,
-0.0278221089,
-0.0396045968,
-0.0182577185,
-0.0013452852,
0.0213138498,
0.0251295771,
0.0479043499,
-0.0256215874,
0.0189820081,
-0.0783503428,
-0.0220204946,
-0.0322942846,
0.0476086587,
-0.026151536,
0.0083805053,
0.032273706,
-0.0365283936,
-0.0126991151,
0.0038814938,
0.0040318547,
0.0185351521,
0.0168302618,
0.044092644,
0.0134728802,
-0.0647300109,
0.0311065279,
0.0028482017,
-0.0119759543,
0.0560881458,
-0.0098832743,
0.0048506251,
-0.0472752266,
-0.0135875121,
-0.0197585337,
-0.0308221746,
0.0300642047,
0.0208352003,
-0.0178722404,
-0.0158813186,
-0.0712233931,
-0.0668655187,
0.0177161265,
0.0055723116,
0.0613017902,
-0.0316515863,
-0.0019991889,
0.0428398885,
0.0035515502,
-0.0275249071,
0.0044345651,
0.0700714737,
-0.0085494891,
0.0146829691,
-0.0369333327,
0.0221385509,
-0.0039732121,
0.0199608356,
-0.0573512428,
0.0039433925,
-0.0221018791,
-0.0008581865,
-0.0082602715,
-0.0041027642,
0.0497454293,
-0.0094559705,
0.0041559222,
-0.0167759899,
0.0434688069,
0.0264484473,
-0.0457886681,
0.0233146604,
0.0282409899,
-0.0678839833,
-0.0082047256,
-0.0089474041,
0.0235231239,
0.0081801927,
0.0363676064,
0.0021984803,
0.0107130669,
-0.0424206965,
-0.0254794713,
-0.0437895171,
0.0321716815,
-0.0860603377,
0.004325124,
-0.0544313826,
0.033671312,
0.001308627,
0.0277852956,
-0.0392749645,
-0.0267589986,
-0.03498853,
-0.0328295529,
0.0466418862,
-0.0542017259,
0.0243272651,
0.0031929794,
0.019079309,
-0.0115202684,
0.0933213979,
0.0241063666,
0.0187538695,
0.058584433,
-0.0127412686,
-0.0260161757,
0.033311259,
0.0398712792,
0.0282454323,
-0.0197852124,
0.0044300831,
-0.0092785703,
0.0032672852,
-0.021777479,
0.0364426821,
-0.0157279111,
-0.0236368719,
0.0542389192,
0.0544859804,
0.0568629242,
0.047844585,
-0.0251571089,
0.0369831882,
0.02037194,
-0.0036539191,
-0.0427602865,
-0.0207980145,
0.0109419702,
-0.0311919712,
0.003093452,
0.0874356702,
-0.0239364449,
-0.0009624259,
0.0055486197,
-0.0408679098,
-0.0302544422,
0.0300385486,
0.0386278816,
-0.0421618409,
-0.0035573202,
0.0705827102,
0.0487634763,
-0.0364789106,
-0.0239249729,
-0.0582937747,
-0.0075170998,
0.064295873,
0.0419818498,
-0.0233229101,
-0.0342758819,
-0.0274791103,
0.0395544991,
-0.0148053085,
0.008414764,
0.0345172994,
0.0448230207,
-0.0625150725,
-0.032545045,
0.0017799372,
0.0168155525,
0.0247130562,
0.0158346724,
0.0115517471,
-0.017640464,
0.0235440079,
-0.0124068446,
0.0240682103,
-0.0060675894,
-0.0009350769,
0.0087822629,
0.0153023191,
0.0455427207,
-0.004897167,
-0.0431930944,
-0.0238614772,
0.0229385924,
-0.0039728545,
0.0000052807,
-0.0399891883,
0.018813638,
0.002239187,
0.0146003151,
0.0152927227,
0.0154144987,
0.0504071862,
-0.0691880435,
-0.0331858657,
0.00628665,
0.0251000263,
0.0038167094,
-0.0378172807,
0.011782025,
-0.0410783291,
0.0558862388,
-0.0008256736,
0.0004470714,
-0.0393767618,
-0.0111370757,
-0.0427041166,
-0.0114160087,
0.0088304635,
-0.0202040412,
0.0178517159,
0.0211492162,
0.0151319047,
0.0308872517,
-0.0306430552,
0.0371754058,
-0.0231091827,
-0.0075833811,
-0.0305008199,
0.0136322137,
-0.0761730596,
0.0433599465,
0.0153326271,
-0.0018849357,
-0.0367696621,
-0.0039013994,
-0.0003768085,
0.0617279783,
-0.0297744423,
0.0150359273,
-0.0157128703,
0.0004186029,
-0.0436527021,
-0.0033246838,
-0.05191461,
0.0450559258,
0.018235974,
-0.0319158435,
0.0120428065,
-0.0681341738,
-0.002924341,
-0.0324888565,
0.0359989926,
0.0035139939,
-0.0376007333,
-0.0139343226,
-0.0018918986,
-0.0278060138,
0.0714929029,
-0.0141777778,
-0.0069869738,
0.0482443608,
0.0157702304,
-0.0420715176,
0.0080021666,
-0.0125155635,
-0.0316541791,
-0.0415956043,
0.0102309724,
-0.0009793448,
0.0604649708,
-0.0366129354,
-0.0216471441,
-0.0323089808,
0.0020670539,
-0.0085656941,
-0.0593699254,
-0.0101042939,
0.0319529437,
-0.0279370975,
0.0168323107,
0.0183317661,
-0.0601020269,
0.0587423034,
-0.015899552,
-0.0098283272,
-0.0254066642,
-0.059320312,
-0.0754157156,
0.0468001999,
-0.0343349092,
0.0133147044,
-0.0132942637,
-0.0276200101,
-0.0191439111,
0.0149813695,
0.013519262,
-0.0307021048,
0.0335817747,
0.0134726996,
-0.0272066817,
-0.0370526128,
-0.0472164974,
0.0147472862,
-0.0595310219,
-0.0665477142,
0.016907664,
0.0098309731,
-0.0412965491,
-0.0066690119,
0.0160091482,
-0.0321996994,
0.0371181592,
-0.0296105631,
0.0383678153,
-0.0217111669,
-0.0073116315,
0.033014968,
-0.0206634589,
0.0169260744,
-0.0319165476,
-0.0101088956,
0.0409320928,
0.0659275055,
-0.0181047507,
0.0019110902,
-0.0477290452,
0.0348119996,
-0.0129729593,
-0.0234159678,
-0.0250093993,
0.063484095,
-0.0569834821,
0.0108156744,
0.0959638059,
0.0128217731,
-0.0776892081,
-0.0088782376,
-0.0134758726,
0.0620598234,
0.0216840152,
0.0043341378,
-0.0592639334,
-0.0326500088,
0.0250403751,
0.0405576229,
0.0248037614,
-0.0354925953,
-0.0179849025,
-0.0864334852,
0.0481032506,
0.0090843374,
-0.0160102658,
-0.0115458686,
-0.0422472358,
0.0103972834,
0.0071047959,
0.0179426521,
0.0067634899,
-0.0116487434,
-0.0207309518,
0.0346777886,
-0.0042275959,
-0.0593210161,
0.0112635372,
-0.0607585534,
0.0470291264,
0.0002590094,
0.0033934272,
0.0088778222,
-0.0322494842,
0.0435363688,
0.0152245481,
-0.0026387165,
-0.023925079,
0.0199920442,
-0.0199073292,
-0.0122457696,
0.0388046205,
0.0310239736,
-0.0108925421,
0.0037848244,
0.0264153928,
0.0757706314,
0.0025199875,
-0.01904363,
0.024595445,
-0.0257642083,
0.0119616026,
0.0516667068,
0.0585061647,
-0.0246317983,
-0.0249663182,
0.0252674446,
0.0028939093,
0.0008116837,
0.0185337085,
0.0100092534,
-0.0306178499,
-0.0120664323,
-0.004602191,
-0.0105600348,
0.0313984528,
0.0340168141,
0.0039307415,
0.0344839059,
0.014191567,
0.0135952206,
-0.0485748425,
0.0254669059,
-0.0630558729,
0.0264888518,
-0.0680784136,
-0.0327379145,
0.0284279827,
0.0176014565,
-0.0037884088,
0.019621579,
-0.1093747839,
-0.0875773951,
0.0345413983,
0.0138709517,
0.0179921966,
0.0409871414,
-0.0179337561,
-0.1050262675,
0.0481284633,
0.0524598733,
-0.0712849274,
0.0386447571,
0.0405357517,
-0.0647049919,
0.0026958268,
0.055469349,
-0.0426336341,
-0.0062944507,
0.0469425917,
-0.0208288953,
-0.0199746229,
-0.0306353047,
-0.059323553,
0.0492269546,
0.0765703171,
-0.0125453705,
-0.0087781418,
-0.0373532325,
0.0676249042,
-0.0073032244,
0.0178719349,
-0.0369745791,
-0.0205295607,
0.0216946583,
-0.0407448933,
-0.026067039,
0.0281844232,
0.0565344468,
-0.0132746473,
-0.0489602536,
0.061765071,
0.0055670962,
-0.0082469601,
0.0589218326,
-0.00218849,
0.0085732024,
0.0404878855,
0.0191650074,
0.0330406278,
-0.0138691934,
0.0220625829,
-0.0017361866,
0.0348729044,
-0.0791722089,
0.0433949791,
-0.0336326063,
-0.1220284849,
0.0094340043,
0.0491185933,
0.0491189584,
0.0392636023,
0.0536387973,
0.0031404553,
-0.0382154174,
-0.0196711365,
-0.0002450818,
-0.0511632338,
-0.0110628456,
0.00730481,
-0.0124915643,
-0.0307924673,
0.0442689508,
0.0832257494,
0.0183337852,
0.0182449985,
0.0016184755,
0.0088420017,
-0.0384963676,
-0.0009248707,
-0.00979493,
0.016867904,
-0.0281739421,
-0.011263459,
-0.0299534369,
-0.0587577708,
-0.0018625426,
-0.00299342,
0.0069850353,
-0.0025491668,
0.0095760282,
0.0603379272,
0.0071357614,
-0.0034066099,
-0.0633332282,
-0.000718197,
0.0350147523,
-0.0246983711,
0.0386142172,
-6.780896468e-33,
0.0188907366,
0.0408133343,
-0.0074775978,
0.0484066755,
-0.013489061,
0.0276697092,
0.0039604893,
-0.0028409967,
-0.000200944,
-0.0189316589,
-0.0574148707,
0.0189922526,
0.0338553488,
0.0195548646,
-0.0078578228,
-0.0347013324,
0.0496740602,
-0.0622379668,
-0.0387389921,
0.0213292502,
0.0277542286,
0.0698184446,
0.0558156408,
-0.0305932965,
-0.0350491554,
-0.0274252929,
-0.0226300731,
0.0193697084,
-0.0456876084,
0.0255575571,
-0.0026187112,
0.0196577515,
0.0222594254,
-0.0293902587,
-0.0179256741,
-0.0108092288,
-0.0599595979,
0.0051628575,
0.0075986376,
0.0194011852,
-0.0483502261,
0.0035555472,
0.0589311793,
0.0127748856,
-0.0063811275,
-0.0263925046,
-0.0198756065,
-0.0019051492,
-0.022117611,
-0.0217093937,
-0.0020301261,
0.007202046,
0.0246290639,
-0.0094815325,
0.06996537,
-0.0160085056,
-0.0088395821,
0.0134449145,
-0.060718596,
-0.0127018532,
0.0682773963,
0.0216845181,
0.0490555093,
0.0551003627,
-0.013930981,
0.0441510901,
0.0623813644,
0.0105309552,
-0.0057304348,
-0.0015596153,
0.0630631968,
0.0719214678,
0.003230717,
0.0318227038,
0.0175051875,
-0.0467053838,
-0.0659228116,
-0.0304413121,
0.0482617952,
-0.0321728364,
0.0360188931,
0.0383975618,
-0.008918223,
-0.0025665278,
-0.0440789945,
-0.0135093145,
-0.0401006266,
0.0081771445,
0.0141311074,
0.0391726866,
-0.039008487,
-0.0061014858,
0.046833057,
-0.0515053496,
-0.0172046591,
0.0123096202,
0.0362646282,
0.0175144617,
0.0027159711,
0.0078970809,
-0.0862253159,
-0.0317479074,
-0.0200071763,
-0.0301378518,
0.0116192279,
-0.0208626259,
0.0854290351,
0.0274366252,
-0.0421237834,
-0.0040142713,
-0.0296496358,
0.0380758718,
0.0118612042,
0.057791017,
0.0414129831,
-0.0243308768,
0.0206507333,
0.0423635393,
0.0305934288,
0.0182470996,
-0.0153092742,
-0.0059336163,
-0.0004394595,
0.0103143314,
0.0132694431,
0.0056495429,
-0.0378034264,
-0.0114012742,
0.0586979799,
-0.029025102,
0.0044876826,
-0.0323445536,
2.749e-7,
0.0107051907,
0.0577546023,
-0.0320865028,
-0.0315951779,
0.0513936616,
0.0302463099,
-0.0283685625,
0.0239885617,
0.0236146078,
-0.0006232169,
0.0097192563,
0.0377313606,
0.0588432997,
-0.0023648608,
-0.0428287052,
0.0085453382,
-0.0656068474,
0.0638595745,
-0.0475000963,
-0.044804763,
-0.0436973348,
0.109737888,
0.0675552189,
-0.0498371385,
0.0068686274,
0.0035829674,
0.0180959553,
-0.0555744357,
-0.0443812013,
0.0217712875,
0.035318654,
0.0570847318,
-0.0015206226,
-0.0369367898,
-0.0044209501,
0.0431490988,
-0.0493673049,
0.0768634528,
0.0101250624,
0.030678615,
0.0144807175,
-0.0381434746,
-0.0429362878,
-0.0258977152,
0.0665559918,
-0.0212258026,
-0.0285103135,
-0.029249154,
0.0187302716,
-0.0588982254,
0.0396307483,
-0.0381674506,
0.0246606469,
0.0538159609,
-0.0186262373,
-0.0562924072,
-0.0356445648,
-0.0804632977,
-0.0046207472,
-0.0128100766,
-0.0461532995,
-0.0224320609,
-0.0376081467,
0.0121583305,
-0.0020138719,
-0.0420237146,
0.002979405,
2.621406815e-34,
0.0310586654,
-0.0222831238,
-0.0005175179,
0.0362405106,
0.0113500729,
-0.0279889274,
-0.0239402503,
0.0277255997,
-0.0337350145,
-0.0571995638,
0.0058459267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00948v1 | The House Always Wins: A Framework for Evaluating Strategic Deception in LLMs | 2024-07-01T04:07:49 | 2024-07-01T04:07:49 | Tanush Chopra, Michael Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose a framework for evaluating strategic deception in large language
models (LLMs). In this framework, an LLM acts as a game master in two
scenarios: one with random game mechanics and another where it can choose
between random or deliberate actions. As an example, we use blackjack because
the action space nor strategies involve deception. We benchmark Llama3-70B,
GPT-4-Turbo, and Mixtral in blackjack, comparing outcomes against expected
distributions in fair play to determine if LLMs develop strategies favoring the
"house." Our findings reveal that the LLMs exhibit significant deviations from
fair play when given implicit randomness instructions, suggesting a tendency
towards strategic manipulation in ambiguous scenarios. However, when presented
with an explicit choice, the LLMs largely adhere to fair play, indicating that
the framing of instructions plays a crucial role in eliciting or mitigating
potentially deceptive behaviors in AI systems. | The House Always Wins: A Framework for Evaluating Strategic Deception in LLMs: We propose a framework for evaluating strategic deception in large language
models (LLMs). In this framework, an LLM acts as a game master in two
scenarios: one with random game mechanics and another where it can choose
between random or deliberate actions. As an example, we use blackjack because
the action space nor strategies involve deception. We benchmark Llama3-70B,
GPT-4-Turbo, and Mixtral in blackjack, comparing outcomes against expected
distributions in fair play to determine if LLMs develop strategies favoring the
"house." Our findings reveal that the LLMs exhibit significant deviations from
fair play when given implicit randomness instructions, suggesting a tendency
towards strategic manipulation in ambiguous scenarios. However, when presented
with an explicit choice, the LLMs largely adhere to fair play, indicating that
the framing of instructions plays a crucial role in eliciting or mitigating
potentially deceptive behaviors in AI systems. | [
0.0439870432,
0.0404643565,
-0.0826138183,
0.061634317,
-0.0871531218,
-0.0124844108,
-0.0063782246,
0.0225675665,
0.0004180367,
-0.0193666555,
-0.0615090504,
-0.0339486226,
0.0434708185,
0.0546909608,
0.0454094708,
0.05398684,
0.0302033331,
-0.0377493575,
0.0556160733,
-0.0285045672,
-0.0130125023,
-0.0218782853,
0.02625986,
0.0405077487,
0.0040872786,
0.013048254,
-0.0306201447,
-0.0082200561,
-0.0151143204,
-0.0025199554,
-0.0118456353,
0.0373622328,
0.0101679945,
0.0955139622,
0.0000019888,
-0.0430278853,
-0.0089244563,
-0.0204568338,
-0.032392662,
0.0331863947,
0.0278508831,
-0.0146228941,
0.0044703055,
0.0062810262,
-0.0747693405,
0.0074844011,
0.0458051376,
0.0098724179,
0.0185450744,
0.0808254182,
0.0216127727,
0.0150557961,
0.0070236917,
-0.0466482081,
-0.0019221051,
-0.0493840165,
0.0273378063,
-0.0511087775,
-0.0385529362,
-0.0167568345,
0.0117577771,
-0.0214340296,
0.0102778673,
0.0046688849,
-0.0684706867,
0.038527485,
0.0073320507,
0.0176232345,
-0.0070671635,
0.0309863575,
-0.0188331157,
-0.0166547373,
0.0201898161,
-0.0287253782,
0.0353642255,
-0.0073178047,
0.0180752538,
0.0535990372,
0.012282026,
-0.0096586943,
0.0303871278,
0.012828052,
0.052669514,
-0.0109260678,
0.0278467517,
0.062328849,
-0.026392037,
-0.021663066,
-0.0094246054,
-0.0105632199,
0.0031276012,
-0.1135727689,
-0.0593631603,
0.0249833185,
-0.06506937,
0.0330793746,
-0.0480033867,
0.0458323695,
0.0443956405,
-0.0546476133,
0.0349313729,
0.0237254575,
0.0371610038,
0.0167033244,
0.0203838591,
0.055681888,
-0.0118953381,
0.0781423822,
-0.0332436785,
0.0148562258,
0.0536560602,
-0.0323571898,
-0.0025380543,
0.023678707,
-0.0140550416,
-0.0161430389,
-0.0474357754,
-0.0069226697,
-0.0720070601,
0.0454333946,
0.0004255904,
-0.0086717792,
-0.0237106029,
-0.0034228696,
-0.0462244675,
-0.0345867164,
-0.0165706053,
0.0485455319,
-0.0004286858,
-0.0807664767,
-0.0343029499,
-0.0091962917,
-0.0552856997,
-0.0107249832,
0.0075811991,
0.0936736465,
-0.0103111761,
-0.0304568801,
-0.019980507,
-0.0219636373,
-0.0173616447,
-0.0837895125,
-0.0066198632,
-0.0390085913,
0.0301067568,
-0.0201212298,
-0.0239154696,
-0.0196584612,
-0.0078550847,
-0.0150281098,
-0.0356035568,
0.0702432096,
0.0523787513,
0.034986902,
0.0090713985,
0.0291892756,
-0.0740032718,
0.0832406506,
0.0292317793,
0.0413731933,
0.0332226194,
-0.0016035708,
0.0521215461,
0.0582441203,
0.0017807815,
0.0354545116,
0.0127757862,
-0.0048033786,
0.0224254858,
0.0271272808,
0.015797032,
0.0272422917,
-0.0266817752,
-0.0329134278,
0.0775659308,
0.0041682944,
-0.015473905,
-0.0136820795,
0.0462535471,
-0.0104477778,
-0.0087569356,
0.0632571131,
-0.0540607199,
0.0119889621,
-0.0373175777,
0.005544899,
-0.0043103797,
0.0015008461,
0.0230817907,
-0.0203192551,
-0.0067029027,
-0.0209642686,
0.0127086332,
0.0505125374,
-0.0075920322,
-0.0095889252,
-0.0478349514,
0.0178680271,
0.0260335281,
0.0056100348,
-0.019024739,
-0.0994475037,
0.0184233636,
0.0532906838,
0.0402561687,
0.0035165825,
0.0225812886,
-0.0072142119,
-0.0571537092,
0.0468151085,
0.0442876033,
-0.0026909919,
0.0253568459,
-0.005645073,
-0.0117463218,
-0.050518807,
0.0408288725,
0.0632928908,
-0.0449273959,
0.0202880409,
-0.0189052224,
-0.0373770073,
0.0413349569,
0.03524068,
0.0040602633,
-0.0475458503,
-0.0243783351,
-0.0070880745,
0.048963584,
-0.0402052961,
-0.0392673239,
0.0252988338,
0.0334648676,
-0.0012476107,
-0.0021337778,
-0.0316943116,
-0.0241649393,
0.0398131683,
0.014038397,
-0.0127425734,
0.0073048281,
0.024409866,
-0.00938664,
0.0146202063,
0.034175586,
-0.0232853033,
0.0283308551,
0.0067443643,
0.0288524907,
-0.0310975686,
0.0370268822,
-0.0056334082,
0.0415060371,
-0.0387736224,
-0.0050643561,
-0.0068406225,
-0.0429322124,
-0.0057852063,
-0.023429215,
0.0401267521,
0.0330440998,
0.0033672978,
-0.0196993016,
0.0425590202,
0.0329544097,
-0.0038552554,
-0.0712808818,
-0.0769760832,
-0.0300107077,
-0.0157551896,
-0.0183857717,
0.0252729636,
-0.0297816675,
-0.0200875606,
0.0447155088,
-0.0058193998,
-0.0048273555,
0.0065899719,
0.0305392053,
0.0172683969,
0.0160447862,
-0.0471174233,
-0.0149956821,
-0.0092702135,
-0.0119416621,
0.0383707173,
-0.0294178482,
0.0360992551,
-0.0546813458,
-0.014155183,
-0.0093859211,
0.0410325974,
-0.0440059565,
-0.0585589074,
0.0128287077,
-0.0106269624,
-0.0219124276,
0.072761409,
0.0022318284,
0.061456278,
0.0833585635,
-0.0197790228,
-0.0682564303,
-0.0032734897,
0.0207955372,
-0.0134437429,
-0.0867541879,
-0.0985753611,
0.0097006951,
0.0696969256,
0.029826859,
0.004797894,
-0.0194086637,
0.0434170142,
-0.0045838812,
-0.0809024051,
0.0171163585,
-0.0522539876,
-0.030412063,
0.0298369806,
0.0064418325,
-0.0547094718,
0.0817188993,
-0.0523053296,
0.0046073142,
0.031893976,
0.0233767908,
-0.0113135083,
0.067282185,
0.0002613827,
-0.0156909246,
0.0130444327,
0.0101395538,
-0.0656143278,
-0.0756441504,
0.0641362816,
-0.0369741656,
0.0261225626,
-0.0630582049,
-0.014180501,
0.0132513354,
-0.0223137047,
-0.040941909,
-0.071045652,
-0.0351273082,
-0.0064659505,
0.0622735135,
-0.023278961,
-0.0363739729,
-0.0513463095,
0.0120013254,
-0.0138223618,
0.0068296851,
-0.0053218217,
-0.028154267,
-0.0102137383,
0.0681072846,
0.0099811498,
0.0691829324,
-0.0115743261,
-0.0001339044,
0.0148408469,
-0.0300782192,
0.0219659228,
0.014198564,
-0.0119112972,
0.0463312641,
0.008459188,
-0.0032212925,
0.0570023134,
-0.0304219294,
-0.019499924,
0.0031740603,
0.062310867,
0.0094340984,
0.0170420781,
0.0201759618,
-0.0178003144,
0.0541053712,
-0.0047352575,
0.0080785351,
-0.1023076251,
-0.0239852257,
0.0206518508,
-0.0067352215,
-0.0511590019,
-0.024711594,
-0.0302473158,
-0.1396489441,
0.0086624855,
0.0058500348,
-0.039184574,
-0.0173379146,
-0.0060421801,
-0.0299840979,
-0.0275558922,
0.0768951029,
0.0003044465,
0.0183898024,
-0.0192841012,
-0.0275760014,
0.0028543163,
0.0116432449,
-0.005110852,
-0.0128749236,
0.068771556,
0.0368537083,
0.0262530968,
-0.0327703021,
-0.0596380234,
0.0166792702,
0.0098694535,
-0.0066790921,
0.0072113695,
0.0041308179,
-0.0168133229,
0.0111584077,
0.0268364176,
-0.0227971543,
0.0431208983,
0.0126781072,
0.0118489936,
0.0016943713,
-0.0124561489,
-0.1144654378,
0.0382601433,
-0.0097442633,
0.056655664,
0.0627104193,
-0.0052315327,
-0.0070124744,
-0.0298370421,
-0.0308470596,
0.0069932812,
0.0087455334,
-0.0268025175,
0.0100158816,
0.0717635602,
-0.0114218583,
-0.0509248562,
-0.0557928421,
-0.0307477098,
-0.0141974809,
0.0283194296,
0.0311689787,
-0.0225883052,
0.0165576804,
-0.0091659073,
-0.0393769741,
-0.0442977808,
0.0395331234,
0.0093043996,
-0.026067378,
-0.0283721425,
-0.0811346471,
0.0108862091,
0.0350313522,
-0.0246898513,
-0.0302490406,
0.0518758968,
0.0665028766,
0.0265309047,
0.0314035751,
0.0086834664,
-0.0047783246,
0.0174553134,
-0.0363646597,
-0.0488899387,
0.0732350796,
0.0541167259,
-0.0016394585,
0.0292487554,
0.0444072559,
-0.0400917679,
-0.008538451,
0.0544865802,
0.0382678173,
-0.0347884819,
0.0097020715,
0.0271925386,
-0.0048276801,
0.0315548852,
-0.0343329608,
0.0419594608,
0.0097388253,
0.0327735879,
-0.0437632091,
-0.0006888884,
0.0023785152,
-0.0491750352,
0.0334638022,
0.0494585447,
0.0121183358,
0.0004013215,
-0.0282948706,
-0.021900503,
0.0316584595,
-0.0154715292,
0.0316371545,
0.0048540197,
0.0277645588,
0.0031136968,
0.0090566073,
0.0889651701,
-0.0167703126,
0.0360995755,
0.0439782254,
0.0174496267,
0.0280178264,
-0.0710326582,
-0.0200364068,
0.0381110758,
-0.0295839533,
-0.0269310921,
0.0682452992,
0.0416378938,
0.0440395586,
-0.0244431235,
0.0111925863,
-0.0345105305,
0.0325103626,
0.0134945661,
-0.0351514928,
0.007897798,
-0.0469518639,
0.0105947359,
-0.0026390408,
-0.038632296,
0.0267928578,
0.0454238206,
0.0229993053,
0.0589511693,
-0.0442763269,
0.0247356445,
-0.0038956096,
-0.0553765371,
0.0492183045,
0.0495525412,
-0.0225655138,
-0.0555711314,
-0.0986574888,
-0.045110099,
-0.0108027011,
0.0319174901,
0.0235259272,
-0.0282369629,
-0.0189827867,
0.0646192655,
0.0126483142,
0.0035266527,
-0.0538995229,
0.0081764497,
0.0245999601,
-0.0169016421,
-0.0312614515,
-6.242111571e-33,
0.0156029416,
-0.0529934838,
-0.005031243,
-0.0228904821,
0.0058534918,
0.0099050831,
-0.0147677399,
-0.0023986595,
-0.0516321808,
0.0078550288,
-0.0362192616,
0.001196128,
0.0143640833,
-0.0250865798,
0.0059874486,
-0.0264281556,
0.0053397613,
-0.0097667752,
-0.0443512201,
-0.0192146972,
-0.0091307079,
-0.0229145605,
0.0376319773,
-0.0295259971,
0.0162742268,
-0.0171871111,
-0.0734164566,
0.0244477931,
-0.0838637799,
0.0043898965,
-0.0082005942,
-0.0033782905,
0.0068830014,
-0.0306959897,
0.0093986411,
0.0032373883,
0.0529043078,
-0.0187022425,
0.0732853189,
-0.0068910015,
-0.0111927642,
-0.048290696,
0.0206348263,
0.006579583,
-0.0785165131,
0.0051112133,
-0.0072178654,
0.0001006037,
-0.0000891654,
0.0267975368,
-0.0352475494,
-0.0205569398,
-0.0131192468,
0.0021419278,
-0.0093698362,
-0.0367264748,
0.0191479269,
-0.0136500662,
-0.061514508,
0.0544370897,
0.0091778943,
0.0022256495,
0.0698839575,
0.0223001204,
0.0321133025,
0.0631493032,
0.0554815531,
0.0512172021,
-0.0295995716,
-0.0333287381,
0.0221856851,
0.0321200006,
0.0420799181,
0.0442965962,
0.0170412343,
-0.0358200036,
-0.0171682555,
-0.0091552399,
0.0512261689,
0.0064959209,
0.0315865912,
-0.0066963905,
-0.0618380792,
-0.0031467951,
-0.0305351224,
0.0063671637,
-0.0319834501,
-0.0092067467,
0.0131262103,
0.0250285864,
0.0217542015,
-0.0348635465,
0.0449269935,
-0.0376685522,
-0.0206211526,
0.0147578372,
0.0142979966,
-0.0016918274,
-0.0119830091,
0.0014524988,
0.013996155,
-0.020350948,
0.0312924869,
0.0014231432,
0.0273726471,
0.0217627399,
0.0075863535,
0.0200551581,
-0.0096631963,
0.0192997307,
-0.0184117779,
0.0456230119,
0.0134835448,
-0.0873415545,
0.0379884914,
-0.0204190407,
-0.0215296727,
-0.0468294546,
-0.0049891821,
-0.0143217295,
-0.0463045165,
0.0714790598,
-0.0359397791,
0.0051151477,
-0.0244818758,
0.0178721529,
-0.0280107819,
0.0465301797,
0.0160206277,
-0.0051569701,
-0.0159317441,
-0.053641919,
2.797e-7,
-0.0220580641,
0.0413439609,
-0.0544560701,
0.0630052015,
0.0034756539,
0.0864058658,
-0.0303931125,
0.0188958086,
0.015941089,
-0.0351691879,
0.0114170136,
0.0077290805,
0.0322910994,
0.0143548446,
-0.0614337847,
0.0318569653,
-0.0425785147,
-0.0222926494,
-0.0215537641,
-0.0116193127,
0.0333793052,
0.072568208,
0.0375629403,
-0.0133100552,
-0.0096284486,
-0.0425066985,
-0.0066942293,
-0.0416263938,
0.0192343146,
0.0276111998,
-0.032823123,
-0.0364246555,
-0.0243451335,
0.0171920452,
-0.0148728816,
0.0110265398,
-0.0560831428,
0.0457959659,
-0.0059072324,
-0.0486796014,
-0.0476192199,
-0.048302725,
-0.0155481175,
-0.0590495057,
0.0449391343,
0.0055103344,
-0.0265273843,
-0.0310054962,
0.0228986125,
-0.0204566363,
0.0046352884,
-0.0285885446,
-0.00824745,
0.028584769,
-0.0018531318,
0.0313630104,
0.0075070993,
-0.0252403822,
-0.0347232223,
-0.0082359156,
-0.0101408763,
-0.0398242362,
-0.0090645906,
0.0277936496,
0.026313724,
-0.0508050211,
0.0244479477,
2.458725284e-34,
0.0087289764,
-0.0301733296,
0.0269853566,
0.0130351558,
0.0670072213,
0.0266035702,
0.0132850483,
0.0284493472,
0.0326039456,
-0.0158232115,
-0.0086812517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00942v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00942v1 | ProductAgent: Benchmarking Conversational Product Search Agent with Asking Clarification Questions | 2024-07-01T03:50:23 | 2024-07-01T03:50:23 | Jingheng Ye, Yong Jiang, Xiaobin Wang, Yinghui Li, Yangning Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper introduces the task of product demand clarification within an
e-commercial scenario, where the user commences the conversation with ambiguous
queries and the task-oriented agent is designed to achieve more accurate and
tailored product searching by asking clarification questions. To address this
task, we propose ProductAgent, a conversational information seeking agent
equipped with abilities of strategic clarification question generation and
dynamic product retrieval. Specifically, we develop the agent with strategies
for product feature summarization, query generation, and product retrieval.
Furthermore, we propose the benchmark called PROCLARE to evaluate the agent's
performance both automatically and qualitatively with the aid of a LLM-driven
user simulator. Experiments show that ProductAgent interacts positively with
the user and enhances retrieval performance with increasing dialogue turns,
where user demands become gradually more explicit and detailed. All the source
codes will be released after the review anonymity period. | ProductAgent: Benchmarking Conversational Product Search Agent with Asking Clarification Questions: This paper introduces the task of product demand clarification within an
e-commercial scenario, where the user commences the conversation with ambiguous
queries and the task-oriented agent is designed to achieve more accurate and
tailored product searching by asking clarification questions. To address this
task, we propose ProductAgent, a conversational information seeking agent
equipped with abilities of strategic clarification question generation and
dynamic product retrieval. Specifically, we develop the agent with strategies
for product feature summarization, query generation, and product retrieval.
Furthermore, we propose the benchmark called PROCLARE to evaluate the agent's
performance both automatically and qualitatively with the aid of a LLM-driven
user simulator. Experiments show that ProductAgent interacts positively with
the user and enhances retrieval performance with increasing dialogue turns,
where user demands become gradually more explicit and detailed. All the source
codes will be released after the review anonymity period. | [
0.0794524774,
-0.045121152,
-0.0134471711,
0.0297346935,
-0.0446422249,
-0.0443224311,
0.0208256654,
-0.0166401919,
-0.0104422942,
-0.0413110182,
0.008765541,
-0.0280956179,
-0.034467645,
0.0693826973,
-0.0094659207,
-0.0487899147,
0.0188972801,
0.0210803002,
0.0203771349,
0.0189494658,
0.0416875035,
-0.0023326229,
-0.0236279275,
0.0394362994,
0.0097747855,
-0.0140618607,
-0.076031208,
0.0420864224,
-0.0023225462,
-0.0158525538,
0.0340407304,
0.0132260201,
0.0310643148,
-0.0171361268,
0.000001926,
-0.0670776814,
-0.0398918726,
-0.0148810325,
-0.0510284379,
-0.0409530401,
0.0565692522,
0.0776960626,
0.0368060209,
0.0392530039,
-0.0571714975,
0.0387438424,
0.024934167,
0.0707716867,
0.0328762345,
0.0792157799,
-0.0157663617,
0.0004397348,
-0.0017806315,
0.0244150348,
0.0521676615,
-0.0578758046,
-0.0105765825,
-0.0377050526,
0.0663522407,
0.0206212513,
0.052207239,
0.0241704825,
-0.0368807465,
0.001883848,
0.0254109185,
0.0287997499,
-0.0169549156,
-0.0362357162,
-0.029858103,
0.077303119,
0.037286777,
0.0118772183,
0.0116998916,
0.0151208285,
0.0327966623,
0.0051333895,
-0.0200345535,
-0.0164585188,
-0.0287519675,
-0.0308298022,
-0.0469802953,
0.0190328043,
-0.0224567186,
-0.0383156575,
-0.0060165133,
0.052650664,
-0.0105565265,
-0.0451499969,
-0.0181614514,
-0.0670441091,
0.0039341697,
-0.0493914373,
0.0055856104,
0.0662869513,
-0.0820170566,
0.0198544748,
0.0376316905,
0.0115040289,
0.0035056761,
-0.0875893459,
-0.0179272369,
0.0112334704,
0.0034001141,
0.0313061327,
0.024745252,
0.0479464196,
0.0434227064,
-0.04204797,
-0.0688473806,
0.0158483014,
-0.0428027399,
-0.0276079178,
-0.0695170909,
0.059150435,
-0.037062563,
-0.0272202976,
-0.0033071558,
0.0353058167,
0.01111071,
0.0115040308,
-0.0352328345,
0.0412174277,
-0.0113363089,
0.0118896263,
-0.0983154327,
-0.0231988039,
-0.089975886,
0.0061984709,
0.0169685744,
-0.0676605105,
0.0256317314,
0.0363665558,
0.0149571784,
-0.0019586219,
-0.0116456971,
0.0483710878,
-0.0193091705,
-0.0667163879,
-0.0538078658,
-0.0601775125,
0.0161691234,
-0.0271610953,
-0.051420819,
-0.0174844582,
0.0437511466,
-0.0136879124,
-0.0532024838,
-0.0057077827,
0.0054112701,
0.0300371367,
0.032080695,
0.0578124374,
-0.0101537127,
0.0172643438,
0.0233512949,
0.0048408178,
-0.0113701886,
0.0213578623,
0.0039645261,
0.0445805006,
0.0642470047,
0.0227683391,
0.0191410724,
-0.0163186993,
-0.0405863412,
-0.0519250073,
0.0181430709,
0.0750290081,
-0.0413597114,
0.0302894246,
-0.0196547769,
0.0258169454,
-0.0157109611,
0.0225674734,
0.0608376078,
0.0676603466,
0.0208872594,
-0.0043174806,
0.0116309896,
0.0990744531,
-0.01252928,
-0.0004482668,
0.0290279929,
0.0320321023,
-0.0355503,
0.0024774366,
0.0074250395,
-0.0372341797,
-0.0471270345,
-0.0552055351,
0.0347606502,
0.0040863282,
0.0301166978,
0.0461025126,
0.0030359733,
-0.0166719556,
-0.0466181897,
0.0507331118,
-0.0114045199,
-0.0578587055,
-0.0452536345,
-0.0295934249,
0.0802021176,
0.1236038879,
0.0396455713,
-0.0278867036,
-0.0528250225,
0.0237614326,
-0.0337545685,
0.0405334085,
0.0284939017,
-0.0227478407,
-0.0070666689,
-0.0278610159,
-0.0406786203,
-0.0597688369,
0.0028792804,
0.0248503517,
-0.0090021854,
-0.0105495667,
0.0375549197,
0.000902793,
0.0350089446,
-0.0009702544,
0.0085483706,
-0.027962571,
-0.00540645,
0.0169474389,
-0.019369211,
0.0360142551,
0.0112819141,
0.0209409371,
0.0537438914,
-0.0177305844,
-0.0268445816,
0.0307746455,
0.0461707711,
0.0165767968,
0.0165352784,
-0.0167949274,
0.0310129151,
-0.0135217663,
0.0248880889,
-0.0646019727,
-0.0002696062,
-0.0457100645,
0.0421631858,
-0.0467193387,
0.008755995,
-0.0330529511,
-0.0104934387,
-0.0172578357,
0.056787394,
0.063681826,
-0.0188854635,
0.0148778111,
-0.0067763017,
-0.0171119776,
-0.0406028628,
0.0306035336,
0.0026017625,
0.0056634066,
0.0230687317,
0.0090446742,
-0.0172234047,
-0.0319907218,
0.0033485321,
-0.0870732144,
0.0296843965,
-0.0075997477,
-0.0094747422,
-0.0096644759,
0.0460973531,
0.0235515013,
-0.0289199706,
-0.0631606877,
0.0104588009,
-0.0120930634,
0.0080583198,
0.042416878,
0.0654611588,
-0.0606959425,
-0.0455014035,
0.0330159962,
0.0296055377,
-0.0093289828,
0.0390130579,
0.0089905439,
-0.0578258447,
0.0343485847,
-0.0800103918,
-0.0050787725,
-0.0201724675,
0.0375169963,
0.0219475925,
-0.039268475,
0.0155353732,
0.0208987836,
0.0431774221,
0.0128240678,
0.038817171,
-0.0217470415,
-0.0870634913,
0.02969441,
-0.0264218654,
0.0059809042,
-0.0223022997,
-0.0194412842,
0.0505932346,
-0.0023203872,
-0.049295716,
0.0288617741,
-0.0310147796,
0.0066893259,
0.0444779433,
-0.0338314883,
-0.0324635208,
0.0140164457,
-0.0277832523,
0.0749581605,
-0.0173925012,
-0.0171436798,
0.0596892573,
-0.0007942675,
0.0066624549,
-0.0296295751,
-0.0487205014,
-0.0428889468,
0.0324214511,
-0.021140473,
0.0171183273,
-0.0058799279,
-0.0224006213,
-0.0297075622,
0.0085659996,
0.0544791669,
-0.0514579862,
0.0575268976,
-0.0478617586,
0.0275737569,
0.0075286813,
-0.0283595119,
-0.0382298008,
-0.042270761,
0.020611044,
-0.0332003534,
0.0293905716,
-0.0069027753,
-0.0680849329,
0.016007686,
0.0154206045,
0.0222814698,
-0.0036097858,
-0.0512211025,
-0.0038639652,
-0.0090321358,
0.0467415042,
0.0665299892,
0.0125167035,
0.0248046946,
0.0393784419,
0.0362871177,
0.0138882138,
-0.074950546,
-0.0238247663,
-0.0252467785,
0.0140544241,
-0.0380789526,
0.0104083503,
0.0345709249,
0.0112006022,
0.0050986004,
0.011430311,
0.0879500061,
0.0396311842,
-0.0440977588,
0.0048346356,
-0.0121822115,
-0.0074572908,
0.0191581566,
0.0575411171,
-0.020649476,
-0.0168526135,
-0.0142707443,
0.061718747,
-0.0234240647,
-0.0010709716,
-0.0477460176,
-0.0844281465,
0.0126822237,
-0.0418770947,
0.0302018635,
-0.001949641,
-0.0467534773,
-0.0148911159,
0.0052240593,
0.0671586841,
0.038490992,
-0.0259641744,
-0.0167167392,
-0.0080139618,
-0.009143766,
-0.0119023565,
0.0008157435,
-0.0113947671,
-0.0208143108,
0.0842828378,
0.0146079417,
0.0128409052,
-0.0009520979,
0.0029307471,
0.0299486201,
0.0058592428,
0.0167409237,
0.0333943851,
-0.0163419675,
0.0193037391,
-0.0130405501,
-0.0011391499,
-0.0043439809,
0.0482777953,
0.0184718911,
-0.0236957744,
-0.0065452796,
0.0197818074,
-0.0245767292,
0.0221675709,
-0.0135657247,
0.0597750396,
0.0122994343,
-0.0186621603,
-0.0461195484,
-0.0222426951,
-0.0234781299,
-0.010063218,
0.004735468,
-0.0227004346,
-0.0141157452,
0.0193777829,
-0.0681061968,
-0.0554609932,
0.0054769693,
0.0100937756,
0.0055391882,
-0.0099691823,
0.0044769356,
0.0573880263,
-0.017134469,
-0.0169029571,
0.0391896814,
0.0166191161,
-0.0031457443,
0.0299690533,
0.0404686332,
-0.0770591125,
-0.0031733948,
-0.0266787019,
-0.0345090218,
-0.0473269038,
-0.0557700619,
0.0206250455,
0.0320190638,
0.0368092023,
-0.0236846115,
-0.0351955518,
-0.0411025845,
0.0758433044,
-0.0497748032,
-0.0058753495,
-0.0145975444,
0.040036615,
-0.0043700417,
0.0341271311,
-0.0867980495,
-0.0030243772,
-0.061452888,
0.0422194637,
-0.0228556376,
-0.0774062425,
0.0434203595,
0.0283077825,
0.0013721524,
0.0491754673,
0.0313362442,
-0.0027576054,
0.0637222379,
-0.0041266084,
-0.0206384696,
-0.0433491729,
0.0181376636,
-0.0713670179,
-0.0286380891,
0.0415928736,
0.0411760323,
-0.0454421304,
0.0191246495,
-0.0075397315,
-0.0113153597,
-0.0423506834,
-0.0306446124,
0.0058721662,
-0.0038717701,
-0.0135354437,
0.0554269254,
0.0096198143,
0.0546835512,
0.005621729,
0.0328394771,
0.003627883,
-0.0304409899,
-0.022795368,
0.0228257086,
-0.0481709912,
-0.0905014724,
0.0013344806,
0.0182886217,
-0.0162639264,
0.0105871689,
0.0271617696,
-0.0204131678,
0.0189982001,
-0.0216032416,
0.0036986212,
-0.017598398,
-0.0302169044,
0.023787573,
0.0355062373,
-0.0114955967,
-0.0330401808,
0.0445852764,
-0.030892916,
-0.0025821805,
-0.0338412412,
-0.0345241018,
-0.0640060678,
-0.0474746749,
0.0088336933,
0.0167215355,
-0.0271781478,
-0.0334345251,
-0.0509537607,
-0.0028977317,
0.0127092935,
-0.0145582072,
0.016721867,
-0.0285596959,
0.0699171051,
0.0944369584,
0.0287341289,
-0.0229270104,
-0.0184193887,
-0.0229983982,
-0.0890868306,
0.029198017,
-0.015705334,
-5.574799591e-33,
-0.0002444666,
-0.0338961817,
0.0245908629,
0.032383509,
-0.0100476621,
-0.0250260122,
-0.0459633768,
0.0136759151,
-0.0119319521,
-0.0087378388,
-0.0067670606,
0.024575701,
0.0121002095,
-0.0091622649,
0.006082498,
-0.0653269589,
0.0365477391,
0.020326253,
-0.0129794339,
0.0456832759,
0.0265694503,
0.0346773677,
-0.0332241841,
-0.0047100368,
0.0494302474,
-0.0591362864,
-0.0099388352,
0.0762649626,
0.0135340523,
0.0438288003,
0.0047988077,
0.0487058535,
0.0275806468,
0.0102173565,
0.0093435384,
-0.0034456353,
-0.0211883672,
-0.0043404116,
0.0092839701,
-0.0030965391,
-0.0565891825,
0.0125079285,
0.0264262687,
0.0001356042,
0.0031425413,
0.0651606321,
0.0547909588,
-0.0094714761,
-0.044789657,
-0.0326770209,
-0.0242682137,
-0.0223880541,
-0.0181349218,
-0.0160035398,
0.0248347521,
0.0988632664,
0.0138259828,
-0.0263819974,
0.0077645099,
0.0370343626,
-0.0174324587,
-0.0167095754,
0.012109234,
0.0438243784,
-0.0043008989,
0.0188719388,
0.0455264673,
0.0378890485,
-0.0097141322,
0.0106648291,
-0.0400309786,
0.0780584216,
0.0160680301,
0.0325164907,
0.0057273582,
0.044956062,
0.0415860489,
0.0622119717,
0.0610926375,
0.0054958859,
0.0077166669,
0.025130257,
-0.0512675196,
-0.0110590206,
-0.0030826668,
0.0873961076,
-0.0737359896,
-0.0545536242,
0.0231727865,
0.0432589091,
-0.0025334263,
-0.0297317449,
-0.0279501751,
-0.0163654778,
-0.0072239758,
-0.0599291325,
-0.0091124931,
-0.0206355453,
-0.0015523066,
-0.0269758031,
-0.0019370718,
0.0202097874,
0.0175345037,
-0.0139511684,
-0.0394294932,
0.0189147256,
-0.0450798534,
0.0015155463,
-0.0049976739,
0.0084224306,
-0.0040334174,
0.0112348329,
-0.0455251932,
-0.0170743726,
0.001806536,
0.0230008475,
-0.0392020419,
0.0650842041,
-0.0208375342,
0.0023175692,
-0.0548898205,
-0.0093241716,
0.0188137218,
-0.0011589524,
-0.0124146342,
0.0087695476,
-0.0331777371,
0.0466255322,
0.0116517879,
-0.0781909227,
-0.0254155658,
0.0037294521,
2.714e-7,
-0.0242188424,
0.011686462,
0.0019701074,
0.0582249314,
0.0080938255,
0.053348206,
0.006208383,
0.0304822363,
0.0203761552,
-0.0714672804,
0.0590541847,
0.030084176,
0.0146714747,
0.0188227817,
-0.079340212,
-0.0605288707,
-0.0042551318,
-0.0342136845,
-0.0551543012,
-0.0091231326,
0.0860578194,
0.0208913572,
-0.0043247612,
0.0085886577,
-0.0107171889,
-0.0476619117,
0.037580587,
-0.0383347794,
-0.0056362031,
0.0224855468,
0.0521628447,
0.0138565758,
-0.0192664433,
-0.0344473422,
-0.0083175721,
0.0285168365,
-0.0049367663,
0.0346507989,
0.0324402675,
-0.0927887708,
-0.00983111,
-0.037125852,
0.0065600392,
0.0029773051,
0.0324062221,
-0.0125865173,
0.0149494,
0.0056754057,
-0.0336670987,
0.0013792445,
-0.0560489781,
-0.0395405702,
0.0038727417,
0.0016925621,
-0.0217946079,
-0.0456523299,
0.035374999,
-0.0414042287,
0.015517666,
0.0031429667,
-0.0422187112,
-0.0325844623,
-0.0322259925,
0.0116031598,
0.0112845562,
-0.0062089157,
0.0312458668,
1.872835482e-34,
0.0560929812,
0.0319609046,
-0.0168200284,
0.0572449677,
0.0182328206,
0.0218933001,
-0.0152049903,
-0.0297707617,
0.0353840329,
-0.0588830858,
-0.021145789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00938v1 | MalAlgoQA: A Pedagogical Approach for Evaluating Counterfactual Reasoning Abilities | 2024-07-01T03:39:13 | 2024-07-01T03:39:13 | Naiming Liu, Shashank Sonkar, Myco Le, Richard Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | This paper introduces MalAlgoQA, a novel dataset designed to evaluate the
counterfactual reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) through a
pedagogical approach. The dataset comprises mathematics and reading
comprehension questions, each accompanied by four answer choices and their
corresponding rationales. We focus on the incorrect answer rationales, termed
"malgorithms", which highlights flawed reasoning steps leading to incorrect
answers and offers valuable insights into erroneous thought processes. We also
propose the Malgorithm Identification task, where LLMs are assessed based on
their ability to identify corresponding malgorithm given an incorrect answer
choice. To evaluate the model performance, we introduce two metrics: Algorithm
Identification Accuracy (AIA) for correct answer rationale identification, and
Malgorithm Identification Accuracy (MIA) for incorrect answer rationale
identification. The task is challenging since state-of-the-art LLMs exhibit
significant drops in MIA as compared to AIA. Moreover, we find that the
chain-of-thought prompting technique not only fails to consistently enhance
MIA, but can also lead to underperformance compared to simple prompting. These
findings hold significant implications for the development of more
cognitively-inspired LLMs to improve their counterfactual reasoning abilities,
particularly through a pedagogical perspective where understanding and
rectifying student misconceptions are crucial. | MalAlgoQA: A Pedagogical Approach for Evaluating Counterfactual Reasoning Abilities: This paper introduces MalAlgoQA, a novel dataset designed to evaluate the
counterfactual reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) through a
pedagogical approach. The dataset comprises mathematics and reading
comprehension questions, each accompanied by four answer choices and their
corresponding rationales. We focus on the incorrect answer rationales, termed
"malgorithms", which highlights flawed reasoning steps leading to incorrect
answers and offers valuable insights into erroneous thought processes. We also
propose the Malgorithm Identification task, where LLMs are assessed based on
their ability to identify corresponding malgorithm given an incorrect answer
choice. To evaluate the model performance, we introduce two metrics: Algorithm
Identification Accuracy (AIA) for correct answer rationale identification, and
Malgorithm Identification Accuracy (MIA) for incorrect answer rationale
identification. The task is challenging since state-of-the-art LLMs exhibit
significant drops in MIA as compared to AIA. Moreover, we find that the
chain-of-thought prompting technique not only fails to consistently enhance
MIA, but can also lead to underperformance compared to simple prompting. These
findings hold significant implications for the development of more
cognitively-inspired LLMs to improve their counterfactual reasoning abilities,
particularly through a pedagogical perspective where understanding and
rectifying student misconceptions are crucial. | [
0.04100997,
0.035568323,
-0.0335983187,
0.0463955812,
-0.0859662294,
0.0357508622,
0.0283955578,
-0.0324056521,
-0.0016069089,
-0.0471203811,
-0.0023538517,
-0.0158035196,
-0.0206106864,
-0.0076167746,
0.0311761573,
0.0005724962,
0.0520082861,
-0.0618776083,
0.0251986217,
-0.0315660723,
-0.0390944891,
0.0173019841,
-0.0430060066,
0.0084470129,
0.0499089658,
-0.0746351629,
-0.0008765879,
-0.018337395,
0.0029173479,
-0.0380615592,
0.0021400491,
0.0342880748,
-0.0099472534,
0.0507225916,
0.0000024261,
-0.0804750621,
-0.0197046269,
-0.0277254619,
-0.078450948,
0.0230744146,
-0.0116558261,
0.044374451,
0.013641322,
0.017205447,
-0.0206745267,
0.0785364658,
0.0193693601,
0.0259927399,
0.0561040863,
0.0452256426,
0.0368958823,
-0.0455556214,
0.0227337983,
0.0182998758,
0.043814633,
-0.02246443,
0.0068967603,
0.0651685148,
0.0089705009,
0.0193774328,
-0.0269863997,
0.0210021064,
0.0438184924,
0.0050891517,
-0.0341138132,
0.0055524926,
-0.0134350192,
-0.0084278379,
0.004138235,
0.0586286671,
0.0318888053,
-0.0682195425,
-0.0386322029,
-0.013192961,
0.011336606,
0.06602332,
-0.0607242882,
0.0382197946,
-0.0259009115,
-0.0037280032,
0.0242792144,
-0.0089791575,
0.0177326072,
0.0273907091,
-0.0092625003,
0.0731914192,
-0.0061070579,
-0.0288008731,
-0.0051502092,
0.0058963089,
-0.0451094471,
-0.0187203307,
0.0166284405,
0.0543190762,
-0.0007807636,
0.0181288235,
0.0065249754,
-0.0509891436,
0.0048717964,
-0.0498856865,
0.0191800911,
0.0569130108,
0.0208150204,
0.0396694168,
-0.0378309973,
0.0575410463,
-0.0261724908,
0.0553210005,
-0.0304916017,
0.0057663433,
-0.0296549853,
-0.057660453,
0.0044010491,
0.0283569861,
0.0100871995,
0.0111356201,
-0.0155009683,
-0.0251411516,
-0.0727205575,
0.0185087658,
-0.0321261995,
-0.0033733943,
0.0189234465,
-0.0471758321,
-0.057158418,
0.0331569761,
-0.0229217354,
0.0451169796,
0.0048540412,
-0.0090874555,
-0.0064236778,
0.0030927334,
-0.0360980555,
-0.0189246107,
0.0345411152,
0.0785192922,
-0.0420114137,
0.0209227558,
-0.0596993007,
-0.0178915448,
0.0248950981,
-0.0640241057,
0.0262471326,
-0.0871764198,
-0.0270702057,
0.0340594053,
-0.0169888642,
-0.0101199495,
0.0229799896,
0.0151843,
0.0036158424,
0.0569031388,
0.0166939311,
0.010418158,
0.0519772805,
0.0190541353,
-0.0267053768,
0.0502083041,
0.0409166366,
-0.0425264649,
0.0254848413,
-0.0284092445,
-0.0056591141,
-0.011468987,
0.018459443,
-0.0118970852,
-0.030091092,
0.0222690012,
0.0020671084,
0.0244574994,
-0.0191799924,
0.0246119071,
-0.0026346755,
0.0043842085,
0.0441779606,
0.0321816131,
-0.0404309891,
0.0036800066,
0.0196530968,
-0.0142845167,
0.0071296399,
0.0327662267,
-0.0493263081,
0.0354322232,
-0.0811183602,
0.0124378819,
0.0078523047,
0.003043496,
0.0095095402,
-0.059339568,
-0.0066904379,
0.0255868006,
0.0107321097,
0.0590902939,
0.0608303063,
-0.0046414561,
-0.0230584051,
-0.0150295142,
-0.0297195856,
-0.0212554429,
0.0142961554,
-0.0695981383,
0.0390199944,
0.0241619535,
0.0485646203,
-0.025845794,
-0.0446003154,
-0.004192153,
-0.0010638528,
0.0138654765,
0.0300171319,
-0.0109637771,
-0.0297683664,
-0.0260235351,
0.0135714049,
-0.006247797,
0.0166356079,
-0.0115470095,
0.0042950795,
0.016408816,
0.0092721302,
-0.0160109047,
0.0105751306,
0.0291925389,
-0.0667590797,
-0.0547179282,
-0.0485749729,
-0.0060459636,
0.0091856215,
0.001876577,
0.0135319429,
0.0304438118,
0.0198246911,
-0.0028744093,
0.0027090695,
-0.0005702045,
-0.062372271,
-0.0183029063,
0.0491693802,
-0.034826763,
-0.0361268595,
0.0506869182,
-0.0140218129,
-0.0175850298,
0.0622418188,
-0.0162843876,
0.0465238728,
0.0014537235,
0.0516374558,
-0.0152332038,
-0.0359404869,
-0.02237509,
0.0553193651,
-0.0081675956,
0.0597408824,
0.0019206487,
0.0089351647,
0.0109616127,
-0.0048308237,
-0.0007675402,
0.0065880748,
-0.0073324903,
-0.0110441502,
-0.0175509583,
0.010849013,
-0.0537646227,
0.001658459,
-0.0106892735,
-0.0098479781,
0.0079463515,
0.0315594748,
0.0102528501,
-0.0768639669,
-0.0196933411,
0.0030195937,
0.0012534987,
-0.0112837665,
0.0030007304,
0.0068425112,
0.0028189982,
-0.0277357791,
-0.0068343459,
-0.0158780161,
-0.0125988284,
-0.070789516,
0.0489448011,
0.022785712,
0.0381715633,
-0.0278956555,
0.0017073558,
-0.0343050025,
-0.0096835904,
-0.013643872,
-0.0113107515,
0.0419031195,
0.0260224976,
0.0219358206,
0.0721902028,
-0.0060904305,
0.0117181642,
0.0506461188,
-0.0180472843,
-0.0511982068,
0.0136336712,
0.0017804912,
-0.0063224076,
-0.0188139733,
-0.0714729428,
-0.0738419071,
0.0293473396,
0.0069691092,
-0.010641518,
-0.0237804055,
0.0741920248,
-0.0288204476,
-0.0176847558,
-0.0555721596,
-0.0636474639,
-0.0140560996,
0.0676919073,
-0.0014962115,
-0.0161036365,
0.0799019709,
0.0046990789,
0.0090214154,
-0.052057147,
0.0407185853,
-0.0010308385,
0.0669276118,
-0.017972976,
-0.0011688289,
0.0148120727,
0.0247458164,
-0.0616592169,
-0.0166817941,
0.0351962857,
-0.0398492552,
0.0474232174,
-0.0965394303,
-0.03320916,
-0.0001603937,
0.0124894818,
-0.0538015291,
0.017561648,
-0.0225047953,
-0.0203645639,
-0.0446549915,
-0.0166019052,
-0.0349396169,
-0.0142495846,
0.0410953946,
-0.0021533889,
-0.0157420449,
-0.0164220799,
0.0050606364,
-0.0082423091,
0.0235944018,
0.0382926837,
0.091454491,
-0.048886627,
0.0595639795,
0.0350955017,
0.0201194528,
-0.0214925464,
0.0227498896,
0.0119521311,
0.0194945838,
0.0034994013,
0.0070977425,
0.0341320261,
0.0350617692,
-0.058848165,
-0.005141397,
0.0797279254,
0.0680640116,
-0.0046330253,
0.0088111749,
-0.0547789,
0.0332050361,
0.0329910591,
-0.0183256641,
-0.0602468923,
-0.0395290703,
0.0202308241,
0.0213521644,
-0.0549067669,
-0.0403603204,
-0.0120972898,
-0.1344032437,
0.006562137,
0.0272860471,
0.0150555037,
-0.0249981657,
-0.0401020497,
-0.012180821,
0.0093345242,
-0.021573998,
0.0389749072,
0.0058916281,
0.0209149905,
0.0230126772,
-0.0161244627,
-0.0303096119,
0.033679571,
0.035039179,
0.0296189487,
-0.005186535,
-0.0143374149,
-0.0273308381,
-0.0366359055,
0.0412671529,
-0.0234124027,
-0.0386815555,
-0.0171917528,
0.007776204,
-0.0075244582,
0.0178092737,
-0.0659563765,
0.0366659611,
-0.0346799642,
-0.0788904652,
0.0438450351,
0.1137546971,
0.0016698556,
-0.017546162,
-0.0387969203,
0.0236059427,
-0.0363057405,
0.090670377,
0.0263269674,
-0.0369633175,
-0.0051611061,
-0.0585795231,
-0.036392048,
-0.0049871244,
-0.0363118388,
0.0102543235,
0.0716753751,
0.0282793492,
0.0066494225,
-0.057530418,
0.0301551092,
0.0014620563,
-0.00083553,
0.0107794125,
-0.002308496,
0.0109652514,
-0.0393916108,
0.0016036802,
-0.0162266362,
0.0348967724,
-0.035058789,
0.0093927979,
-0.029833192,
-0.0393694341,
-0.046590209,
0.0145471422,
-0.0763573423,
-0.0547926202,
0.0012084496,
0.0129278852,
0.0332475863,
-0.0108965263,
0.0303662717,
-0.0138087524,
-0.0254645366,
-0.018342318,
-0.0083083585,
0.0059970049,
0.0382226445,
0.0170370825,
0.028556101,
0.0180855207,
0.0152697815,
-0.0086456472,
0.0274119005,
0.0604738519,
-0.0413461402,
0.0189082045,
0.0466030911,
0.0254653972,
0.0091093341,
0.0146902734,
0.025670873,
-0.0362110846,
0.0394541994,
-0.025419306,
-0.0304607078,
0.0263476558,
-0.0215836484,
0.0285234991,
-0.0311233476,
0.0013844348,
-0.0637897253,
-0.0206352323,
0.0249419566,
0.0149599146,
0.0768102109,
0.0210126843,
0.0381736681,
0.0065715252,
-0.0307809468,
-0.0077962819,
-0.0200617686,
-0.0115890959,
0.0627851188,
0.0209324453,
0.0911833718,
0.0138878254,
-0.0201322753,
-0.0073866812,
-0.0345180146,
-0.0629881099,
-0.0371032692,
0.0163349863,
0.0285500493,
0.0014385701,
-0.0147492727,
-0.0020763495,
-0.0315017812,
0.0122813564,
-0.0174248144,
0.024135042,
0.0227253679,
-0.0309434049,
0.0436395183,
0.0233873557,
0.0197204947,
-0.0041953432,
0.0329304039,
-0.0365042537,
0.0183035266,
-0.0015217138,
-0.0055985744,
-0.0141846994,
-0.0531387553,
-0.002409047,
0.046080377,
0.0065444857,
0.0302860737,
-0.1096027866,
-0.0874904767,
-0.0205447972,
0.0297811385,
0.0256998464,
-0.0328008085,
-0.0045463019,
0.0731489062,
-0.0224015955,
-0.0381903127,
-0.0036239035,
0.0607327409,
-0.0300609898,
0.0148560107,
-0.063360922,
-6.355943505e-33,
-0.0175175685,
-0.055732388,
0.0323418528,
-0.0149082812,
0.0288793426,
-0.0450921915,
-0.039584063,
0.0462077819,
-0.0411819145,
0.005463528,
0.0212276857,
0.0175140314,
-0.0081991246,
0.0154998098,
-0.0114791095,
0.0038046755,
-0.0185722057,
0.0211979505,
-0.0208560955,
-0.0163984764,
0.0131995156,
-0.0346021056,
0.0734614059,
-0.0749780536,
0.0589014441,
-0.0330551714,
0.0194637123,
0.0259104054,
-0.1054765806,
0.0328064077,
-0.00899061,
0.0321074426,
0.0108981542,
0.0043936437,
0.0175815001,
0.0008000009,
0.0185535103,
-0.0556837395,
0.0722661689,
0.013938589,
-0.0109552667,
-0.054697454,
0.0079285866,
0.0153548829,
-0.0570577048,
-0.0077671367,
0.0235996991,
-0.0315093137,
0.0240251012,
0.0797604695,
-0.0757061541,
0.0257733092,
-0.0574085899,
-0.0244227555,
-0.0168337319,
0.0952369869,
-0.0132841524,
0.0074779014,
-0.0614512004,
0.0317729563,
0.0756129399,
-0.0218558796,
0.1035618708,
0.0139473472,
0.010746208,
0.0514182411,
0.0398551933,
0.0030890526,
-0.0308694225,
-0.0134249208,
0.0052334797,
0.0134806335,
0.1189186275,
0.0522365719,
0.0496549495,
-0.0132868942,
-0.0920276269,
-0.0149428602,
-0.0283126663,
0.0054302174,
0.0466463417,
-0.0233222563,
-0.0367877409,
-0.0083539616,
-0.083311595,
-0.0175027568,
-0.026961932,
0.0068791704,
0.0452716611,
-0.0661503598,
-0.0365132652,
-0.0163662191,
0.0135764554,
-0.0144316424,
-0.0076501747,
0.0207934678,
-0.0061499993,
0.021776909,
0.0112160807,
0.0517141074,
-0.0570595227,
0.007834563,
-0.0058746981,
-0.0121937701,
0.0509549677,
0.0021351108,
0.015821185,
-0.0116165718,
-0.0144157177,
-0.016577905,
-0.0553701147,
-0.0175018664,
0.0258120075,
-0.0241989791,
0.0530668758,
0.040183004,
-0.0240749959,
-0.0059354911,
0.006492673,
-0.0471298397,
-0.0287141986,
0.0107220095,
-0.0555229411,
0.0114370286,
-0.013152522,
-0.0144997528,
-0.0159034561,
0.0234438814,
-0.0126033723,
-0.0615804009,
-0.000160114,
0.0389691368,
2.949e-7,
0.0405691229,
0.0442995578,
-0.0041155629,
0.0160063542,
0.0092919897,
0.0456892624,
-0.0621827953,
-0.0539960526,
0.0741102695,
-0.0130067924,
-0.0174231585,
0.0560366437,
0.0383498408,
0.0217583459,
-0.0132990303,
0.0168674234,
-0.0450212732,
-0.0008651345,
-0.0389021449,
0.0498819426,
0.0984281078,
0.0293017346,
0.0120962141,
-0.0009329225,
-0.0144867711,
-0.0074111423,
0.0136870882,
-0.049924057,
0.0152570987,
-0.0063807769,
-0.0122153768,
-0.0376586355,
0.0362438969,
0.04192397,
0.0135027403,
-0.0218861755,
-0.0288703665,
0.0289791394,
-0.0154985394,
-0.033419814,
-0.0442181714,
-0.0131263267,
0.0079090651,
-0.0968598351,
0.0665820315,
-0.008399047,
-0.0227716714,
0.02918946,
-0.0428473428,
-0.0113426978,
0.0221632626,
0.0117524518,
-0.0306674298,
-0.0078040813,
0.0222636368,
-0.0145058623,
0.0360701047,
-0.013147125,
-0.012421173,
0.0271311048,
-0.0106504401,
-0.0343748629,
-0.0686253756,
-0.013153553,
0.0421358272,
-0.0368954577,
0.0047325534,
2.656057955e-34,
0.0228878818,
-0.0052361931,
0.0342476703,
0.0155384745,
0.0380344018,
0.0132907908,
-0.0006906671,
0.0196710769,
0.0370276719,
-0.0336118266,
-0.021526441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00936v1 | Large Language Model Enhanced Knowledge Representation Learning: A Survey | 2024-07-01T03:37:35 | 2024-07-01T03:37:35 | Xin Wang, Zirui Chen, Haofen Wang, Leong Hou U, Zhao Li, Wenbin Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) with Knowledge Representation
Learning (KRL) signifies a pivotal advancement in the field of artificial
intelligence, enhancing the ability to capture and utilize complex knowledge
structures. This synergy leverages the advanced linguistic and contextual
understanding capabilities of LLMs to improve the accuracy, adaptability, and
efficacy of KRL, thereby expanding its applications and potential. Despite the
increasing volume of research focused on embedding LLMs within the domain of
knowledge representation, a thorough review that examines the fundamental
components and processes of these enhanced models is conspicuously absent. Our
survey addresses this by categorizing these models based on three distinct
Transformer architectures, and by analyzing experimental data from various KRL
downstream tasks to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each approach.
Finally, we identify and explore potential future research directions in this
emerging yet underexplored domain, proposing pathways for continued progress. | Large Language Model Enhanced Knowledge Representation Learning: A Survey: The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) with Knowledge Representation
Learning (KRL) signifies a pivotal advancement in the field of artificial
intelligence, enhancing the ability to capture and utilize complex knowledge
structures. This synergy leverages the advanced linguistic and contextual
understanding capabilities of LLMs to improve the accuracy, adaptability, and
efficacy of KRL, thereby expanding its applications and potential. Despite the
increasing volume of research focused on embedding LLMs within the domain of
knowledge representation, a thorough review that examines the fundamental
components and processes of these enhanced models is conspicuously absent. Our
survey addresses this by categorizing these models based on three distinct
Transformer architectures, and by analyzing experimental data from various KRL
downstream tasks to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each approach.
Finally, we identify and explore potential future research directions in this
emerging yet underexplored domain, proposing pathways for continued progress. | [
0.0325499177,
0.0049529118,
-0.0278486572,
0.0547427349,
-0.0334706753,
0.0101511125,
-0.022838559,
-0.0173731111,
0.0113895033,
-0.0812402815,
-0.0479911715,
-0.0065848273,
-0.0160578061,
0.0090200435,
0.0251530204,
-0.0049501136,
0.016203111,
-0.0108576789,
-0.0162619203,
0.0123462165,
-0.0173882619,
0.0224473812,
0.02836008,
0.0326568484,
-0.0038254301,
-0.0178070199,
0.0039047389,
-0.0427798033,
0.0210113544,
0.0025760108,
-0.0314519182,
0.0034200167,
0.043602217,
0.044310689,
0.0000019233,
-0.0508582182,
-0.054127831,
-0.0060853828,
-0.0213915091,
-0.0294146799,
0.0401299112,
-0.0604288317,
0.0141314454,
-0.0136325872,
-0.0518119186,
-0.0053857975,
0.0197048876,
0.0943081975,
0.0371602811,
0.0367608517,
-0.0144969905,
-0.0368800424,
0.0448851176,
-0.0240970682,
-0.0381518006,
-0.0178205818,
0.0515864976,
0.052905567,
-0.0099598635,
0.0303910915,
-0.0251670852,
0.0380478911,
-0.0118755214,
-0.0006017128,
0.0055780397,
0.0352937989,
-0.0243868418,
0.0156744551,
0.0169888604,
0.0691308156,
-0.0148831792,
0.0033079041,
-0.0300960299,
0.0116249518,
-0.0014525985,
0.0373985022,
-0.0336707644,
0.0312827192,
0.0080740973,
0.0310378578,
0.0164997745,
-0.0004124264,
0.0613992773,
-0.0026096785,
-0.0702481419,
0.0424608029,
0.0164765976,
-0.0493265018,
-0.0204526801,
-0.0109080197,
-0.0281132143,
-0.0294872336,
-0.0102754487,
0.041019503,
0.018911643,
0.0398964919,
0.0203661397,
-0.0014148291,
0.0135384202,
-0.0351870842,
0.0215714425,
0.0063962326,
-0.0081142578,
0.0710557997,
-0.0975679085,
0.0597790219,
-0.0337662064,
0.0128673865,
-0.0715308934,
-0.0613591596,
-0.087415278,
-0.0320956446,
-0.0070094117,
0.0617871694,
-0.0135852313,
-0.0348701924,
-0.02310827,
0.0547648519,
-0.0279538017,
0.0464207903,
0.0123320799,
-0.0031794608,
0.0167357456,
-0.0192164183,
-0.0373147875,
0.070823051,
0.0018381467,
0.0263348073,
-0.0386670679,
-0.0168819744,
0.0176416617,
0.0118530104,
0.0056152027,
-0.0355297811,
-0.0102088787,
0.0532409921,
0.0273595545,
-0.0294481553,
-0.0275452193,
-0.0186073743,
-0.0258497503,
-0.0473467521,
0.009023698,
-0.04827087,
0.0449901484,
0.0180339757,
-0.0003655771,
-0.0373680107,
0.0093649793,
-0.0136125898,
-0.036746785,
0.0962787792,
0.0058617033,
-0.0098183881,
-0.0027367685,
0.0109530389,
-0.0165115166,
0.051289469,
0.0195995457,
0.0072587468,
0.0012805009,
-0.0234136302,
-0.0338580236,
0.0144357346,
0.0031539192,
-0.0171464887,
0.009308028,
0.0016376454,
0.0371903256,
0.0171806887,
0.0263993088,
0.0459995717,
-0.0117525887,
0.0088657048,
0.0649079382,
0.0351158045,
0.0466532931,
0.0372459069,
0.0514888093,
-0.0031035184,
-0.0048781871,
-0.0314111412,
-0.0545881316,
0.0039544543,
-0.0453634895,
0.006624517,
-0.045181945,
0.0591014512,
-0.0253408644,
0.0026644594,
-0.0073017501,
-0.0300623868,
0.0073811593,
0.0117128883,
0.080365859,
0.0012705817,
-0.010930609,
0.0975149795,
0.0471377932,
-0.0038922818,
0.0311102569,
-0.0335288569,
0.0059760683,
0.0470458008,
0.0300086495,
-0.057942979,
-0.0156142106,
-0.0250962079,
-0.0330714583,
0.0114534488,
0.0327127315,
-0.0239329264,
-0.0514731407,
-0.0315976366,
-0.0404476449,
-0.0199210923,
-0.0042580832,
0.0080574183,
0.0056713135,
0.0094167376,
0.0433657877,
-0.0378328376,
0.0239009224,
0.0297433399,
-0.0474549308,
0.0032856371,
-0.0169338379,
0.0282725003,
0.0308419783,
0.0159783307,
0.0175100919,
-0.0103808707,
0.0496965833,
-0.0593878292,
-0.0523137599,
0.0205414686,
-0.0593628399,
-0.029117763,
0.0379619896,
0.0015221124,
0.0155590968,
0.0020763546,
-0.0244668424,
-0.0234035272,
-0.0257527847,
-0.0020686185,
0.0975882784,
-0.0475807115,
-0.0075148079,
-0.0120532196,
0.0062348549,
-0.041361928,
0.0970456675,
-0.0053115329,
-0.0091880914,
0.012375596,
-0.0188358296,
0.003698024,
0.0220415406,
-0.0435460843,
-0.0259116963,
-0.0085443929,
0.0052138283,
0.0119090257,
-0.0506188646,
-0.0183042195,
-0.0517712533,
-0.0982944369,
-0.0108381156,
0.0070930379,
-0.0145659475,
0.0014115301,
-0.0052897604,
0.0353579521,
0.0309320968,
-0.0355292149,
-0.0118021714,
-0.0002207787,
0.0196417682,
-0.0009236368,
-0.0066472162,
-0.0366245806,
0.0044251648,
0.0085948184,
-0.0385069028,
0.0700224712,
-0.0083667487,
0.0021178233,
-0.0747135356,
0.0101671992,
-0.016837569,
0.0053221006,
-0.0446970463,
-0.0049082451,
-0.0216277689,
-0.0177193768,
0.0457772464,
0.0243713744,
-0.0172785036,
0.022245042,
0.0753081217,
-0.0166599788,
-0.0362317935,
-0.0089787487,
-0.0450386927,
-0.0005169264,
-0.0713755935,
-0.0046594655,
-0.0101801688,
0.0469114482,
0.0000132437,
-0.0194439627,
-0.059336178,
-0.0034488151,
-0.0290698595,
-0.0181165095,
-0.013737767,
-0.0047568218,
0.0131781762,
0.0018621838,
-0.0127150714,
-0.0088434024,
0.0520358235,
-0.0323468894,
0.0142106451,
-0.0035119276,
-0.0114326868,
-0.052529797,
0.0542561077,
-0.0137336943,
0.0300799571,
0.0089589041,
0.0032955275,
-0.0414882042,
0.011834247,
-0.0162974447,
-0.0263269246,
0.0770597681,
-0.0009558382,
0.0099440124,
0.0009563643,
-0.0140075339,
-0.0408740304,
-0.0207740813,
-0.0330649503,
0.0692946985,
0.0367255211,
0.006597036,
-0.0352950022,
0.0455821827,
0.021513829,
-0.0314537361,
0.018321773,
-0.02468016,
-0.0367887281,
0.0389430784,
0.0492301509,
0.0221129227,
0.0702434555,
0.0240176599,
0.0344849639,
0.0379660204,
-0.0019036144,
-0.0227738749,
-0.0380204469,
0.0043179104,
0.0213278029,
-0.063239485,
-0.0135366218,
-0.0177833606,
0.0199623182,
-0.017303504,
0.006750708,
0.1374291033,
0.0177246444,
-0.0399683192,
0.0027541984,
-0.0165297911,
-0.0265523084,
0.0337772109,
0.0249828324,
-0.0667795241,
-0.0061014993,
-0.0101557486,
-0.017291585,
0.0336881429,
-0.0391594209,
0.0093579637,
-0.104727149,
0.0090897121,
0.0088596698,
-0.0084940698,
-0.0568347983,
-0.0366907679,
0.0025165887,
-0.0069021224,
0.0151739772,
-0.0287527125,
-0.0367582329,
-0.0464570001,
-0.0009074929,
-0.0239211991,
-0.0708445907,
0.0485732071,
-0.0497058518,
0.0531653054,
0.0337467417,
0.0197377373,
-0.0160678644,
-0.0023205362,
-0.0585173629,
0.0040382161,
0.0042670341,
0.0001320732,
-0.0143750189,
-0.0010102593,
-0.0112663386,
-0.0119897565,
-0.0101670092,
-0.0655780807,
-0.0172309428,
-0.0230203513,
0.1437713355,
-0.0181301069,
-0.0009791591,
0.0097902557,
-0.0219868775,
-0.0022778837,
0.1111140475,
-0.0084463554,
-0.0217634365,
0.0112559143,
0.0284465756,
-0.010058919,
0.0425262898,
-0.0303112511,
0.0528638065,
-0.0050083525,
0.022921171,
-0.0667240396,
-0.0287003331,
0.0208612438,
-0.0062530828,
0.0410065353,
0.0277233738,
0.0507352799,
-0.0309129171,
-0.0464261584,
0.0087274183,
-0.0633976683,
0.0048818956,
-0.0053863288,
-0.0021323676,
0.0641153753,
-0.0480566472,
-0.0246108118,
-0.0092738839,
-0.0790270418,
-0.0434492752,
0.0081040906,
0.0435325988,
0.0094713429,
0.0615024976,
-0.0084886439,
-0.0045427564,
0.0835395157,
0.0186573025,
-0.0301563311,
0.0128586208,
-0.0007257938,
0.0158945322,
0.0041538128,
0.0487912595,
-0.0793317854,
0.0141725028,
0.0226977114,
0.0385207906,
-0.0439362265,
-0.0354865193,
0.0343700387,
0.0096273692,
0.0107107265,
0.0118799126,
0.0013886864,
-0.0207702834,
-0.003545136,
-0.0486618094,
-0.0225915778,
-0.0393478908,
-0.0376398526,
0.0334062986,
-0.0187797695,
0.0174942259,
0.0107110618,
0.0318376161,
0.0299259834,
-0.0225656833,
0.0035277861,
0.0167691875,
-0.0145858899,
0.021928573,
0.0344383791,
-0.0210353564,
0.006171999,
-0.011416926,
0.015856076,
-0.0436449461,
0.0503038876,
0.0001214645,
-0.0131099252,
-0.0744954199,
0.0223341193,
-0.0366677716,
-0.0605523363,
0.0391979441,
0.0015305005,
0.0841197595,
-0.0365736373,
0.0337432288,
-0.0382458754,
-0.0142110894,
0.0002306024,
0.0097886641,
0.0043521645,
-0.0080450876,
0.0463680401,
0.0200791601,
-0.0098590422,
-0.004279051,
0.0486500338,
-0.0073042409,
0.0447919816,
-0.0270925574,
-0.0425544269,
-0.047850024,
-0.0274403654,
0.0308119506,
-0.0090761147,
-0.0431505479,
0.0151930237,
-0.0697088018,
-0.0565600805,
0.0482951105,
-0.0444715321,
-0.0480665565,
-0.0092327762,
0.0307133216,
0.0542740226,
0.0203314535,
-0.0246714298,
-0.0289070457,
0.001626121,
-0.0192572828,
0.0147579527,
0.0287396777,
-5.913925303e-33,
-0.0305174813,
0.0025853699,
0.0177616775,
-0.0239296276,
-0.0185731612,
0.0224850383,
0.0031750523,
-0.0397671722,
-0.0306302831,
0.01563395,
0.0193452109,
-0.0306653455,
-0.0127494801,
0.0119420541,
0.0005340613,
0.0042517646,
0.0419973508,
0.0419761874,
0.0134425852,
0.0316925384,
0.0594586954,
0.0307275578,
0.0422966778,
-0.0723708868,
0.0089789415,
0.010010601,
0.0268063322,
0.0262163021,
0.0070654564,
0.0921411216,
-0.0426262431,
0.0588433258,
0.040526107,
-0.044701349,
-0.0059561739,
0.0153777031,
-0.0921770856,
-0.0103324577,
0.0229702871,
0.007779981,
0.0213792454,
-0.030948462,
0.0648210868,
-0.0171463825,
0.0505815186,
-0.028271649,
0.0440827943,
-0.0349077657,
-0.0374621786,
-0.0309140943,
-0.068796441,
-0.0154548883,
0.0119329197,
-0.0026361316,
0.0281553734,
0.005108072,
0.0315400325,
0.0417846553,
-0.0851459503,
-0.0034363756,
0.0037223708,
0.0159733705,
0.0678045452,
0.0321422927,
0.0083892969,
0.0495087653,
-0.0316185057,
0.002101873,
-0.0479454398,
-0.0131185204,
0.01765275,
0.0505941249,
0.0266514253,
0.0372380242,
-0.052734796,
0.00780119,
-0.0570424758,
-0.0168770831,
0.0101491595,
0.0631611273,
0.0498652235,
0.0030851786,
-0.0063387319,
-0.0076682069,
-0.0520843491,
0.0244738609,
-0.0233538859,
-0.0178556442,
0.0169229321,
0.0078736627,
-0.0086109489,
0.0282635614,
0.0426636264,
-0.0863200054,
-0.0118606091,
0.044225309,
0.0116555393,
0.0107183559,
-0.0194143765,
0.0200950541,
-0.063774474,
-0.0505383387,
0.0144515252,
-0.0350695699,
-0.0254010428,
0.0029273655,
0.0475151055,
0.011884612,
-0.0198648833,
0.0119821532,
-0.0235155057,
-0.0552309044,
-0.0020392493,
-0.0136096412,
0.0288775619,
0.0585284084,
0.0039879042,
-0.0108790323,
0.056939844,
-0.005581724,
0.0208334476,
0.0211281851,
0.0290444791,
0.0126139512,
-0.0110872686,
-0.0069326633,
-0.0500999093,
0.005976574,
0.0229209308,
-0.0369994678,
-0.0161861368,
-0.0087083904,
2.68e-7,
0.0583047159,
0.0421597175,
-0.0042488906,
0.0062305913,
0.0206482541,
0.0263557509,
-0.0060348832,
0.0187439825,
-0.0030683379,
-0.0100992471,
0.0374642834,
0.0410604961,
-0.0064882552,
0.0205687135,
-0.0881240293,
0.0078715859,
-0.0130648771,
-0.015007711,
-0.0386775769,
0.0153526533,
0.0802166089,
0.1022353917,
0.0204510763,
-0.0138400728,
-0.0138039682,
-0.0461019389,
0.0957013294,
-0.0372387059,
0.0081370566,
0.0391968004,
0.0063077034,
0.0412818789,
0.0042796372,
0.0550082363,
0.0187298376,
0.0345001295,
-0.0109989773,
0.037319757,
0.0036630663,
-0.0111025507,
-0.0052390331,
-0.0164039861,
0.0050359699,
-0.0805066228,
0.0691325516,
-0.1191392243,
-0.0161340963,
0.0038123343,
-0.0317823179,
-0.0192283653,
-0.0370519906,
0.0031104768,
0.0176843293,
0.012480529,
-0.0046018572,
0.0168443173,
-0.0094593195,
-0.1151903346,
0.0275204573,
0.037697535,
-0.0487050153,
-0.0275002848,
-0.0139579792,
-0.0598473921,
0.0562550277,
-0.0509738773,
0.0391719565,
2.679516873e-34,
0.0016318483,
0.0228476115,
-0.0076882238,
0.0509453043,
0.0366599746,
-0.0211629197,
-0.0205981359,
0.0211794917,
0.0091814129,
-0.1299156547,
0.027900042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00935v1 | Look Ahead or Look Around? A Theoretical Comparison Between Autoregressive and Masked Pretraining | 2024-07-01T03:35:59 | 2024-07-01T03:35:59 | Qi Zhang, Tianqi Du, Haotian Huang, Yifei Wang, Yisen Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In recent years, the rise of generative self-supervised learning (SSL)
paradigms has exhibited impressive performance across visual, language, and
multi-modal domains. While the varied designs of generative SSL objectives lead
to distinct properties in downstream tasks, a theoretical understanding of
these differences remains largely unexplored. In this paper, we establish the
first theoretical comparisons between two leading generative SSL paradigms:
autoregressive SSL and masked SSL. Through establishing theoretical frameworks,
we elucidate the strengths and limitations of autoregressive and masked SSL
within the primary evaluation tasks of classification and content generation.
Our findings demonstrate that in classification tasks, the flexibility of
targeted tokens in masked SSL fosters more inter-sample connections compared to
the fixed position of target tokens in autoregressive SSL, which yields
superior clustering performance. In content generation tasks, the misalignment
between the flexible lengths of test samples and the fixed length of unmasked
texts in masked SSL (vs. flexible lengths of conditional texts in
autoregressive SSL) hinders its generation performance. To leverage each
other's strengths and mitigate weaknesses, we propose diversity-enhanced
autoregressive and variable-length masked objectives, which substantially
improve the classification performance of autoregressive SSL and the generation
performance of masked SSL. Code is available at
https://github.com/PKU-ML/LookAheadLookAround. | Look Ahead or Look Around? A Theoretical Comparison Between Autoregressive and Masked Pretraining: In recent years, the rise of generative self-supervised learning (SSL)
paradigms has exhibited impressive performance across visual, language, and
multi-modal domains. While the varied designs of generative SSL objectives lead
to distinct properties in downstream tasks, a theoretical understanding of
these differences remains largely unexplored. In this paper, we establish the
first theoretical comparisons between two leading generative SSL paradigms:
autoregressive SSL and masked SSL. Through establishing theoretical frameworks,
we elucidate the strengths and limitations of autoregressive and masked SSL
within the primary evaluation tasks of classification and content generation.
Our findings demonstrate that in classification tasks, the flexibility of
targeted tokens in masked SSL fosters more inter-sample connections compared to
the fixed position of target tokens in autoregressive SSL, which yields
superior clustering performance. In content generation tasks, the misalignment
between the flexible lengths of test samples and the fixed length of unmasked
texts in masked SSL (vs. flexible lengths of conditional texts in
autoregressive SSL) hinders its generation performance. To leverage each
other's strengths and mitigate weaknesses, we propose diversity-enhanced
autoregressive and variable-length masked objectives, which substantially
improve the classification performance of autoregressive SSL and the generation
performance of masked SSL. Code is available at
https://github.com/PKU-ML/LookAheadLookAround. | [
0.0149815138,
0.0474347025,
-0.0063550062,
-0.0250101667,
-0.0165095702,
0.0056749675,
0.0916831791,
-0.0026921185,
-0.0017560116,
-0.0210847519,
-0.0024451751,
-0.0331416763,
-0.0157711487,
0.0587312914,
0.0359038636,
-0.0420592986,
0.0257096607,
-0.0249549989,
-0.0119539555,
-0.0216477606,
-0.0262104534,
-0.018781133,
0.0010204188,
-0.0018513442,
-0.0796036497,
-0.0131777572,
-0.0122564863,
-0.0056586387,
0.0082638301,
-0.0443832986,
-0.012360096,
0.0767888278,
0.0144187119,
0.0360136814,
0.0000022329,
-0.0266878363,
0.0010286042,
-0.001252329,
-0.0080095986,
0.0013101797,
0.0267298613,
-0.0141798509,
0.0017435827,
0.0059315087,
-0.0311024413,
-0.0498119518,
0.0324063897,
0.0582821332,
0.0417926274,
0.0604949892,
-0.034574125,
-0.03084426,
0.0002737688,
-0.0612621903,
0.0258516632,
0.0043257843,
-0.0064342003,
-0.0310646296,
-0.0273618922,
0.0211750753,
-0.027485257,
0.0479214005,
0.049040243,
-0.0240059961,
0.0553705096,
0.0852799341,
0.0077245603,
-0.004655533,
0.0157562904,
0.0317045823,
-0.0327663906,
-0.0209131762,
0.0254002046,
-0.0456258357,
0.027601013,
0.0144047486,
-0.0082704211,
0.0260047819,
0.0134650916,
0.0086990809,
-0.0135898385,
0.07426209,
0.0096991258,
-0.0233443007,
-0.0102053089,
-0.0019230421,
0.0092281755,
-0.0229367372,
-0.0357807688,
0.0216755513,
0.0135625284,
-0.043109566,
0.0123259593,
0.0320292488,
0.0478375219,
-0.0316342302,
-0.0368054844,
-0.0556396469,
0.0116211222,
0.0396064073,
0.0363348387,
0.0051859519,
-0.0439674444,
0.0065811262,
-0.0473018289,
0.0235948116,
0.0000381178,
-0.0123399198,
-0.0368140042,
0.0342345834,
-0.0020859765,
-0.0395783521,
-0.0346712433,
0.0421483889,
-0.0453149714,
-0.0180460662,
-0.0585026406,
0.0464570709,
-0.0084479358,
-0.0325213373,
-0.0374711677,
0.0354059748,
-0.0521554761,
-0.0065354896,
-0.009459557,
-0.0373727307,
-0.0450129658,
0.0092669539,
0.0289331488,
-0.0217168033,
-0.0004469863,
0.050969217,
0.017805431,
-0.0095069548,
-0.0028653184,
0.0614567883,
-0.0446618535,
0.0081534805,
-0.0361697786,
-0.0402732342,
-0.0540707633,
-0.0277743004,
0.0348677859,
-0.0601184256,
0.0089021092,
0.0100509599,
-0.0366745628,
-0.0219961293,
-0.0305570215,
-0.0237196516,
0.0394414924,
0.021301154,
0.013334943,
-0.0011014869,
0.051878918,
0.0064000003,
0.0139398109,
0.0619448349,
-0.0255777854,
0.0691141561,
-0.0020816736,
-0.0025105583,
0.0444182158,
-0.0143137472,
0.0576400049,
-0.0067090387,
0.0052731936,
-0.0265901219,
0.0102215745,
0.0181704555,
0.0631717369,
0.0202428084,
-0.0492926538,
-0.0404683053,
0.0458226912,
0.0502102599,
0.0455703698,
0.0622983165,
0.0676818341,
-0.0152343856,
-0.0063628615,
0.04744884,
0.0036470466,
0.0507512987,
-0.0197413694,
-0.0005189177,
0.0160597581,
0.0494351499,
-0.0555211231,
-0.0747217387,
0.0339267887,
-0.0013219577,
0.004497142,
-0.0236316063,
0.0425780937,
0.0442369208,
-0.0242526196,
-0.0328795388,
-0.0123072099,
-0.0495251119,
0.0398943163,
-0.065925695,
0.0341679789,
0.0084164552,
0.0236298013,
0.0014313635,
-0.009203718,
0.0146777118,
0.0001936143,
0.0425263606,
-0.0058807852,
-0.0005546494,
0.0177104585,
-0.0223760661,
-0.048573494,
-0.0739490315,
-0.0103585906,
0.048079744,
-0.0297248997,
0.0213962905,
0.0377751552,
0.0008401523,
0.0186252613,
0.0355851091,
0.0054228101,
-0.0617836379,
0.0479019023,
0.0314361341,
-0.004348746,
-0.0083574634,
-0.0070099696,
0.0104481643,
0.0043508471,
-0.0538515076,
-0.0299582891,
0.0149269439,
-0.1102286428,
-0.0602405146,
-0.0059859292,
-0.0614378303,
-0.0025041325,
0.006651321,
-0.0207336843,
-0.0509521961,
0.0500067882,
-0.0114751775,
-0.0093862638,
-0.0547651052,
-0.0149498507,
0.0450433977,
0.058597859,
-0.0194680989,
0.067895472,
0.0299248341,
-0.0281398371,
-0.0188699644,
0.0461964607,
0.0374003127,
-0.0181774665,
0.0188113339,
-0.0296707526,
-0.0220764354,
-0.0076999697,
0.0371336155,
0.0075787078,
-0.0414497852,
-0.0406211242,
-0.0654883906,
-0.0275466256,
-0.0449316986,
-0.0298572537,
0.0128131425,
0.0033412359,
-0.0300177429,
-0.029358685,
-0.044108279,
-0.0311881788,
0.0418993086,
0.0154342419,
0.0404691286,
0.0170617122,
0.0272300504,
0.0054485309,
-0.0286148004,
0.0271426979,
0.0562548749,
0.0380814746,
0.0136233065,
-0.0121401353,
0.0154101532,
-0.0341683105,
-0.0053104083,
-0.0050288155,
-0.0109221675,
0.0021493894,
-0.0230765678,
0.1055279821,
0.0219143331,
0.0434459858,
0.0383146219,
-0.0003296418,
-0.0030241266,
-0.008665923,
0.0104766544,
-0.069670774,
0.0537323095,
0.0172265451,
0.0163053777,
0.0361571163,
0.0405738354,
0.0431481488,
-0.0311663281,
-0.0551125444,
0.0205046367,
-0.0203958265,
-0.0627020523,
-0.0316493288,
-0.0119940192,
0.0236817449,
0.0286281127,
-0.0157199856,
-0.0541438647,
0.0444005281,
0.004980356,
0.0086807394,
-0.0065078102,
-0.0061434978,
-0.0064506889,
0.0519425161,
0.0203945003,
0.024361575,
0.0142678311,
-0.0251527987,
-0.0490825251,
0.0490882173,
0.0270825718,
0.0173527133,
0.0088523971,
-0.0212835614,
0.0064330231,
-0.0015940535,
-0.0326245278,
-0.0570939369,
-0.0618578605,
0.1002470851,
-0.0166838933,
0.0594947115,
0.0367927514,
-0.0149134835,
0.0164062064,
-0.0064398996,
0.0583463013,
-0.0551882163,
-0.0335886106,
0.017380964,
0.0644607097,
0.0024690111,
-0.0423066951,
0.0143828141,
-0.0360040441,
-0.0031621808,
0.0336189792,
0.0393807776,
-0.0045524915,
-0.0125490054,
0.0439055264,
-0.0007660931,
-0.0283168908,
-0.0076926607,
0.0196596775,
0.0562540554,
-0.0131294308,
-0.0267551839,
0.0870632753,
-0.0048687123,
-0.0130505888,
-0.0112337489,
0.0116997408,
0.0482938699,
0.0109757157,
0.0165915098,
-0.0045745117,
0.04315494,
-0.0487230644,
0.0076843183,
-0.013688067,
0.0007580383,
0.010140649,
-0.0829834864,
0.0801346973,
0.0076478915,
-0.0889745876,
-0.001882364,
-0.0227856301,
-0.0294037871,
-0.0076897568,
-0.0231251959,
0.0004011425,
-0.0355898179,
0.0036414824,
0.0488620549,
-0.0385165848,
-0.0284048133,
-0.0495342836,
0.0052303472,
0.0139269466,
0.0495166704,
0.010827166,
0.0053489539,
-0.0255521387,
0.0253958646,
-0.0260639172,
0.0403800085,
-0.030858269,
0.0534443185,
0.0033299765,
0.0022490572,
-0.0099569857,
0.0406455323,
0.0189053398,
-0.0160526745,
-0.0257245377,
0.0077867471,
0.0059669707,
-0.0508242622,
-0.0516012833,
0.017256204,
0.0040992405,
0.0311590936,
0.0329727791,
-0.0102820471,
-0.0527370274,
-0.0034958159,
0.0605625063,
-0.066218257,
0.0025826506,
0.0062509109,
0.0296666585,
-0.0497298241,
-0.0661405772,
-0.0557270087,
-0.014724561,
0.0850404799,
-0.0250130109,
0.0050134785,
-0.0742306188,
-0.0432501249,
-0.0394839421,
-0.0081320805,
-0.0005957255,
-0.0520120636,
-0.0393382534,
-0.0567916557,
0.0085240779,
-0.0931021348,
-0.0229698662,
-0.0184457041,
-0.0770381242,
-0.0621003024,
0.0186037719,
0.0383624211,
0.0073627094,
0.0572825409,
0.0270008929,
-0.0564167276,
0.1593479663,
0.0805422887,
-0.038239561,
0.0186163578,
0.012938696,
-0.0108743226,
-0.0207705107,
0.0040124133,
-0.0158601142,
0.0823649094,
0.0106618404,
-0.020129852,
0.0114237554,
0.0241658986,
0.0153911896,
-0.0116845248,
0.0646776333,
-0.057337869,
0.0374272913,
-0.0493637025,
-0.0332930461,
-0.023226317,
-0.0040011257,
-0.0164407771,
0.0107312063,
0.0453906693,
0.0300998595,
-0.012616802,
0.0968854353,
0.0113221286,
0.0535891168,
-0.0541754216,
-0.0089653647,
-0.0188445076,
0.0327757597,
-0.0244397894,
0.036456231,
0.0026467373,
0.0055448846,
0.0079603847,
0.0172332078,
-0.0105948653,
0.0242650863,
0.0243802052,
0.0607317165,
-0.0280010533,
0.0504006557,
-0.0767834187,
0.0190043878,
-0.0564056896,
0.0144421747,
-0.0015566918,
-0.0305711795,
0.0257831085,
-0.0274581779,
-0.0162639227,
-0.0108907791,
0.0463906936,
-0.004036718,
-0.0243160017,
-0.0060104048,
-0.0035096454,
-0.0318251364,
-0.0318124183,
0.0605498627,
-0.0026451014,
-0.0083051063,
0.0300639942,
0.0064809029,
-0.0618339106,
-0.0040412433,
0.0213160161,
-0.0055487156,
0.0085739028,
0.0030955037,
-0.002971086,
-0.0452348366,
0.0291369855,
-0.0002972108,
0.0318058506,
0.0239637922,
0.0597873591,
0.0622928962,
0.0121427374,
-0.0053943042,
-0.0374205373,
0.0227238107,
0.0370232537,
0.0052881399,
0.0205793753,
-7.270506028e-33,
-0.0175814014,
-0.049014423,
0.0300191622,
-0.065987654,
-0.0055600284,
0.0095218504,
-0.0223306287,
0.0102777053,
0.0531171486,
0.0135686733,
-0.0072159199,
-0.0204434618,
0.001711159,
0.0500534736,
-0.0109637389,
0.0149497185,
0.0771607608,
-0.0106220553,
-0.0347287916,
0.0666848272,
0.0271779858,
0.010873219,
-0.0132739814,
-0.0375267193,
-0.0414907932,
-0.0145001467,
0.012923236,
-0.0498647243,
0.0213496592,
0.0418591388,
-0.0411184393,
-0.0026996899,
0.0273702648,
-0.0024001924,
-0.0231062472,
-0.0077124438,
-0.076503925,
-0.0704766437,
-0.0502820835,
-0.0234939232,
-0.0823777989,
-0.0288689043,
0.0463009998,
-0.0035392256,
-0.0367904529,
-0.0276484452,
0.0597022176,
0.0446459129,
-0.0199416298,
-0.0517563187,
-0.0675068647,
0.0176061839,
-0.037847925,
-0.0247133523,
0.0357051864,
0.0310397279,
0.0362431966,
0.0063366941,
-0.0374981239,
0.041895844,
-0.0030589425,
0.0196277238,
0.0624715574,
0.0490147024,
0.0248235539,
0.0205586646,
0.0578575842,
0.0073650195,
-0.0573630929,
0.0202127453,
0.0340502113,
0.0020124491,
-0.0069310274,
0.0148166791,
0.051689025,
-0.03389607,
-0.0850813314,
0.0589419082,
-0.0633142814,
-0.0449578352,
-0.0065558259,
0.0255429856,
-0.0112347044,
-0.0054105762,
-0.0169450343,
-0.0340809934,
-0.017274078,
-0.017565744,
0.0279960819,
0.0568912625,
-0.0425019786,
0.0073983548,
0.0258564446,
0.021142548,
-0.0142958304,
-0.0131048635,
-0.0547836721,
0.0244006477,
0.0402733274,
-0.0172485653,
-0.0456046537,
-0.0007936224,
0.0660144165,
0.0276152883,
-0.0084141651,
-0.0120854024,
0.0247547422,
0.0481410213,
-0.0627367273,
0.0002266559,
-0.0190080982,
0.0547143035,
0.0419037268,
-0.0376593508,
0.0019125337,
-0.0129914498,
-0.0292881504,
0.0491724163,
0.0252583586,
0.0048733773,
-0.0300531983,
0.0103872847,
-0.0076121222,
0.0092570968,
-0.0070150704,
0.0150910402,
-0.0352632143,
-0.0064502116,
0.068777211,
-0.0789602473,
-0.0401164368,
0.0208032355,
2.872e-7,
0.0246843919,
0.0252275858,
0.0519754104,
-0.0005452937,
0.017139094,
0.0207473245,
-0.0050804233,
0.0112919016,
-0.0076969061,
0.0357797705,
0.0032412254,
0.0508442298,
0.006438782,
0.0156418961,
0.024157742,
0.0866118371,
-0.035016939,
0.0365000106,
-0.0442892164,
0.0022548444,
0.0224067681,
0.0141981291,
-0.0301294811,
-0.0131327938,
0.0379102677,
-0.0006067292,
0.0982925519,
0.0169934668,
0.010224008,
0.0268347319,
0.0197423231,
0.0121436287,
0.0065595498,
0.0042822096,
-0.015322607,
0.0014563111,
0.0031324818,
-0.0242988653,
0.006466629,
-0.0508125164,
0.0416354761,
0.056739524,
0.0172693301,
-0.0346816778,
0.0625161901,
-0.0634401515,
-0.0136920391,
-0.0238447096,
-0.0554657914,
0.0336233862,
0.0445011295,
-0.0137547748,
-0.0397483706,
0.0260861646,
0.0038152346,
0.0051174052,
-0.0191816818,
-0.0595346354,
-0.0042538238,
-0.0221510474,
-0.050947167,
0.0097556785,
-0.0674546435,
0.0549850687,
0.0404785462,
-0.0024740156,
-0.017162675,
2.468563851e-34,
0.0007460031,
-0.0304446891,
-0.0350220762,
-0.0725875571,
-0.018539736,
-0.0187173951,
-0.0311008785,
-0.0028013841,
0.0035237204,
-0.0249278136,
-0.0370329842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00934v1 | CLEME2.0: Towards More Interpretable Evaluation by Disentangling Edits for Grammatical Error Correction | 2024-07-01T03:35:58 | 2024-07-01T03:35:58 | Jingheng Ye, Zishan Xu, Yinghui Li, Xuxin Cheng, Linlin Song, Qingyu Zhou, Hai-Tao Zheng, Ying Shen, Xin Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | The paper focuses on improving the interpretability of Grammatical Error
Correction (GEC) metrics, which receives little attention in previous studies.
To bridge the gap, we propose CLEME2.0, a reference-based evaluation strategy
that can describe four elementary dimensions of GEC systems, namely
hit-correction, error-correction, under-correction, and over-correction. They
collectively contribute to revealing the critical characteristics and locating
drawbacks of GEC systems. Evaluating systems by Combining these dimensions
leads to high human consistency over other reference-based and reference-less
metrics. Extensive experiments on 2 human judgement datasets and 6 reference
datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of our method. All the
codes will be released after the peer review. | CLEME2.0: Towards More Interpretable Evaluation by Disentangling Edits for Grammatical Error Correction: The paper focuses on improving the interpretability of Grammatical Error
Correction (GEC) metrics, which receives little attention in previous studies.
To bridge the gap, we propose CLEME2.0, a reference-based evaluation strategy
that can describe four elementary dimensions of GEC systems, namely
hit-correction, error-correction, under-correction, and over-correction. They
collectively contribute to revealing the critical characteristics and locating
drawbacks of GEC systems. Evaluating systems by Combining these dimensions
leads to high human consistency over other reference-based and reference-less
metrics. Extensive experiments on 2 human judgement datasets and 6 reference
datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of our method. All the
codes will be released after the peer review. | [
0.0741177276,
-0.0000567626,
-0.0157867577,
0.0139184156,
-0.0042665387,
0.0239986759,
-0.0426550582,
0.0114576407,
-0.020437846,
-0.0621123537,
-0.0674512386,
-0.0247639176,
0.0603669845,
-0.0299285911,
0.0211077016,
-0.0623021908,
0.0723707825,
0.00912036,
-0.0091270646,
0.017208606,
0.0320189893,
-0.0125522632,
-0.0292446055,
0.0612520725,
-0.017745452,
-0.0452688187,
-0.0034319765,
0.0383758955,
0.0232282411,
0.0125489449,
0.0251384303,
0.0632902756,
-0.0551034622,
0.0532850251,
0.0000018984,
-0.0462971888,
-0.0016679714,
-0.0212491043,
-0.0328486226,
0.0704325736,
0.0390583873,
-0.0074038194,
-0.0660482198,
-0.0167162064,
0.0157331545,
0.0061210482,
0.0357875861,
0.0228881929,
0.076723583,
0.0502695888,
0.0036374687,
0.0035126915,
-0.0108584631,
0.0179352257,
-0.030244587,
-0.0025126401,
0.0113341352,
0.0077122785,
-0.0245560538,
-0.0247055646,
-0.0064143138,
0.019915333,
0.0003898974,
-0.0804706886,
0.0027582098,
-0.0244184434,
-0.0317012295,
-0.0166750569,
-0.0108000506,
0.0049425559,
0.039467752,
-0.0294946879,
-0.027043432,
0.0125496425,
0.0301266424,
-0.0028693546,
-0.0122643774,
-0.0240899101,
0.0049203755,
-0.0072179637,
0.0024048639,
-0.0499434397,
0.0011026755,
0.0161945391,
0.0650693625,
0.0672549754,
0.0108543225,
-0.0568620488,
-0.0294395201,
0.0556417853,
0.0052601667,
-0.0481338277,
0.0442368053,
-0.0186785422,
-0.0673604533,
-0.0207124203,
-0.0224420913,
-0.057088457,
0.0223879591,
-0.0607913136,
0.0401681773,
-0.0149468388,
-0.0318340063,
0.0136236334,
-0.0178921148,
0.0798777193,
0.0377137773,
0.0129265785,
0.0074273506,
0.0010359922,
-0.0439022705,
-0.0105417082,
-0.0323549919,
-0.0005589231,
-0.0359499939,
0.0685040131,
-0.0862493888,
-0.0241876468,
-0.0439138561,
0.0206235312,
0.0249812957,
0.0104048923,
-0.0311002191,
-0.0404633917,
-0.0176366381,
0.0028070994,
-0.0071576564,
0.0534020737,
-0.021545209,
-0.0280471779,
-0.0159352981,
0.0012892775,
0.035187766,
-0.0087769562,
-0.0453664735,
0.0115824491,
-0.0075944108,
-0.0029118923,
-0.0140710576,
-0.0273217112,
-0.0376250148,
-0.0163264275,
-0.0856025964,
-0.0502777025,
-0.0403516181,
0.0012997206,
0.0126370229,
-0.0594669506,
-0.020564355,
-0.0031493227,
-0.0054291375,
0.0408726782,
-0.0344300196,
0.0133129591,
0.0035130091,
0.0090774586,
-0.0030787343,
0.006109667,
0.0295293014,
-0.0270558614,
0.0631408766,
-0.0011536437,
0.0596728139,
0.0118042594,
-0.0503165089,
-0.0209785644,
0.0211608279,
-0.0229936037,
-0.0223201849,
0.038252566,
0.047966253,
0.0509716682,
-0.0153300073,
0.0192839522,
0.0598014072,
-0.0026378962,
0.0476072393,
-0.0113366554,
0.0329276733,
-0.0312461499,
0.0376757793,
0.022050688,
-0.0298078377,
-0.0038441189,
-0.0312775075,
-0.0118210316,
0.0194008257,
-0.0373345129,
0.0122083835,
-0.0608938523,
0.0028342633,
0.0296472907,
-0.0168461781,
-0.0498332195,
0.0092582712,
0.0356599614,
-0.0064821499,
0.0486221053,
0.0115237581,
-0.0934802741,
0.0250987075,
-0.026655985,
-0.0041391011,
0.0797673985,
0.0759725124,
0.0220845174,
-0.0133552821,
-0.0216939896,
-0.0171649288,
0.015219382,
0.0304037016,
-0.0327787809,
0.0142283533,
-0.0232257489,
-0.0060189157,
0.0186316725,
0.0432895347,
-0.03011146,
0.0060010832,
-0.023094127,
0.0138675561,
-0.0468932502,
-0.0639668331,
0.0188586805,
0.0814491138,
0.0000161055,
-0.0319437124,
0.0013929711,
0.0120876282,
0.0234232619,
-0.029163409,
-0.0087507106,
-0.0402848385,
0.0141034201,
-0.0025885422,
0.0194985382,
-0.0092661604,
-0.0442319773,
0.0240528006,
-0.0507022031,
-0.0692483261,
0.0232730135,
-0.0110511491,
-0.0432910956,
-0.0189349577,
-0.0702770203,
0.0122540072,
-0.0495041534,
0.0529271513,
-0.0287363436,
-0.0513065457,
-0.0231597107,
-0.0044275485,
0.0018249251,
0.0271369759,
-0.0016180066,
0.0012375205,
0.0277078263,
-0.053449098,
-0.0500715896,
-0.0044311238,
0.0106520569,
0.0149789955,
0.0123462966,
0.0247039851,
-0.0458510891,
-0.0216620173,
-0.0573765896,
-0.0379776843,
-0.0468516126,
0.0416915044,
0.0604413301,
-0.027095288,
-0.0059146164,
-0.0310746897,
0.0531017967,
0.0148982704,
-0.0103509305,
0.0076854429,
0.0756583586,
-0.025382746,
-0.0025307403,
-0.0831889883,
0.0049239662,
-0.0243691523,
0.0059441146,
0.0258418135,
-0.0045679803,
-0.0747528747,
0.0662280023,
-0.0078212162,
-0.0353148021,
0.0704573914,
-0.0901585668,
0.0120714772,
0.0447445996,
0.0599594265,
0.0271144584,
-0.0184370279,
0.0180974659,
0.0022725668,
-0.036642272,
-0.033569552,
-0.0359507203,
0.0362329446,
-0.0165495742,
-0.0162621234,
-0.0422408283,
0.0165783409,
0.0533246547,
0.009740266,
-0.0128743844,
-0.0176986828,
0.0116791474,
-0.0606245361,
-0.0399509817,
-0.0514451154,
-0.0123202195,
-0.0240543112,
0.0261580534,
-0.0533373207,
-0.0088864071,
0.0848383829,
0.0118977074,
-0.0054946886,
-0.0295020528,
0.0121623855,
-0.0141060064,
-0.0057028262,
-0.0219566002,
0.0148916515,
-0.0318490267,
-0.0579582788,
-0.0436353981,
0.0164996758,
0.0728991106,
-0.001923655,
0.0560001843,
-0.0842575058,
-0.003141355,
0.0176931843,
-0.0483060181,
0.0047724135,
-0.0219198428,
-0.011377993,
-0.0198941287,
0.0295806266,
-0.0290514268,
-0.0168753359,
-0.0019490358,
0.0238635652,
0.0319550596,
-0.010037302,
-0.0185629781,
-0.0012919176,
0.0046075433,
-0.0074815014,
0.0103151361,
0.0197411142,
-0.0101915402,
-0.00651976,
0.0704049766,
-0.0055868723,
0.0057366877,
-0.0215053596,
0.0142707638,
0.0346466713,
-0.0451715142,
-0.0474433489,
-0.0060597621,
0.0956390053,
-0.0599182025,
-0.0358995311,
0.0897443593,
0.0268570781,
-0.0202300344,
-0.0074927001,
-0.0427463762,
-0.0124723827,
0.0043567624,
0.0189478584,
0.0005384244,
-0.0399492271,
0.0471921936,
0.0484334454,
-0.0135584231,
-0.0292212926,
0.0371394418,
-0.0838247836,
0.0513911098,
0.014639399,
-0.0076647201,
-0.0666353703,
-0.0171353053,
0.0274340715,
-0.0051889033,
0.0186344348,
0.0709369853,
-0.0076324693,
0.0028056449,
0.0003145246,
-0.0624239184,
-0.0420626923,
-0.0038692798,
-0.0373947322,
0.0448735841,
0.0499491692,
0.0335426591,
0.0185734443,
-0.0328405574,
0.0258664098,
-0.024141822,
0.0125485621,
-0.0076000318,
0.0334605537,
0.0238465481,
-0.0011945963,
-0.0610008575,
0.0161252283,
0.0220147353,
-0.0143458284,
-0.0198772773,
0.0577470027,
-0.0278337412,
0.0210531186,
0.0203757472,
-0.0171126071,
0.0230986588,
0.0370703377,
0.0689389557,
-0.0382595882,
-0.0359218679,
-0.0736226216,
-0.0067378618,
-0.0637390241,
-0.0011441996,
0.0353167243,
-0.0365931541,
-0.0470013991,
-0.0657725781,
-0.0698022991,
-0.0112058129,
-0.0215529446,
0.029441135,
-0.0398912467,
-0.0202788264,
-0.0005213717,
0.023200715,
-0.0091417339,
0.0113959927,
0.0261650756,
-0.0824685097,
0.0182773173,
-0.0231669527,
0.0516976938,
-0.0264369529,
0.0036556236,
0.0123461848,
-0.0084245084,
0.053897813,
0.0503460914,
0.0140643986,
-0.0003410771,
-0.0070801759,
-0.1228812337,
-0.0389193073,
0.0139737576,
-0.0132781044,
0.0383460037,
0.0433820188,
-0.0217233691,
0.0119424583,
0.0367947742,
-0.0192543473,
0.0247526485,
0.00608597,
0.0503523462,
-0.0274063032,
-0.0126623027,
0.0297628846,
0.0259951111,
0.0706071034,
-0.0160944425,
-0.0041222847,
-0.0703142434,
0.0151809575,
-0.0438411236,
-0.0126552396,
-0.0036526213,
0.0081618801,
-0.009124429,
-0.0288635716,
-0.0492215604,
0.0193522964,
-0.0601667091,
-0.0020607638,
-0.0388982706,
0.0260602552,
0.0700282976,
0.0567065068,
0.0042016711,
0.012014755,
-0.010695463,
0.0010321737,
0.0138442917,
0.0277042855,
0.0269776583,
0.0212539434,
0.020879278,
0.0078768069,
0.0122808069,
0.016848186,
-0.0411148705,
0.0803909749,
-0.0119360294,
0.008219718,
0.0686989129,
0.0227385294,
0.1062602848,
-0.0091732591,
-0.0171809439,
-0.0188782215,
0.0468013473,
0.0172103979,
-0.0115806935,
-0.0142633244,
-0.0000642735,
0.0056732493,
-0.0097788246,
0.0287647918,
-0.0710479617,
0.0206490569,
-0.0505799204,
-0.0645651966,
-0.0030564549,
-0.0107499734,
-0.0431732349,
-0.026877949,
-0.0048385835,
-0.0241548494,
-0.0576872304,
-0.0257018618,
0.0045120036,
0.0835207552,
0.0311039947,
-0.0027218401,
0.002347725,
0.0360113084,
-0.0072134524,
-0.04912927,
-0.0482629091,
-0.0116544655,
0.0053906557,
-0.0038148807,
-0.0587941706,
-5.764710989e-33,
-0.0436059423,
-0.0216604825,
-0.0443470851,
0.0011496579,
-0.0027302857,
-0.0016889101,
-0.0551929325,
0.0239017364,
0.0407240689,
0.0689040273,
-0.0197848976,
0.0498338453,
0.0132941995,
-0.0246398095,
0.0710188299,
0.0237988066,
0.0791806802,
0.0350168608,
-0.0355938934,
-0.0371216089,
0.040489547,
0.0400324501,
0.0948829427,
-0.0430891402,
0.0943039581,
0.0402586646,
-0.0125321923,
0.0188459065,
-0.0015712532,
0.0538627543,
0.0585886091,
0.0739826635,
0.0158496946,
0.0039391522,
-0.0350546651,
-0.0210717358,
-0.0572579503,
-0.0442554094,
0.0136974948,
0.0637734234,
-0.0110983355,
-0.0295041017,
0.0678619742,
-0.0159760397,
-0.0649519786,
0.0099777244,
0.0190962777,
-0.0093708588,
0.0382606909,
0.0331158414,
-0.0070437961,
0.0289452877,
0.002923266,
0.0000216022,
-0.019159412,
0.0369917713,
-0.0205545835,
-0.0512987971,
-0.1029703096,
-0.0180377197,
0.0204343963,
0.0305433329,
0.0352074392,
-0.0410016924,
-0.0504366271,
0.0255625881,
0.014188448,
0.0038801148,
-0.0286272541,
0.0063411095,
-0.010141761,
0.0177075956,
0.0534241535,
0.0827733278,
0.0202905666,
-0.0212490335,
-0.0187522247,
0.0299422517,
-0.0419847928,
0.0812502727,
-0.0318312012,
0.0047005867,
-0.0631781146,
-0.0452671498,
-0.0204963312,
-0.0081137121,
-0.0157741457,
0.0032924158,
0.0414005369,
-0.0517633036,
0.0074064899,
-0.0157614835,
-0.0148413768,
0.0095498562,
0.0028217337,
-0.0180996694,
-0.0064001689,
0.0445335954,
-0.0016726212,
-0.0071434667,
0.0057160486,
0.0215463452,
0.0142040197,
0.0545800291,
0.0497734733,
-0.0088611022,
0.0581151396,
0.0181617048,
-0.0311429761,
0.0215727258,
0.0142567493,
-0.0050893268,
-0.0291816164,
-0.050992392,
0.0248681009,
-0.0131964516,
-0.0017587923,
-0.0138798067,
0.0229124688,
0.0433731377,
-0.012831701,
-0.0278690681,
0.0307093877,
0.0112187788,
0.0011282157,
0.018301256,
-0.0163393989,
0.0005775143,
0.0233964399,
-0.0100526027,
0.0041274838,
0.0098446188,
2.499e-7,
0.0576491393,
0.0717468709,
0.0169702936,
-0.013566372,
0.0218450688,
0.0292380005,
-0.0042270469,
0.0014099786,
0.0284339879,
0.0555132292,
0.0256986637,
-0.020329155,
0.0387637988,
0.0137023758,
-0.0077267429,
-0.028080605,
-0.0414522141,
0.0230952352,
-0.016614357,
-0.0040001431,
0.0573204905,
-0.0259259641,
0.0279641245,
0.0032339271,
-0.020350527,
-0.0306628477,
0.0157379732,
-0.0081938384,
0.0155369816,
0.0153839486,
0.117828913,
0.0092679514,
0.0548621453,
0.0416411795,
-0.029982429,
-0.0351007804,
0.0247906707,
0.0261359066,
-0.0583981611,
0.0541555993,
-0.0166686755,
-0.0193078183,
-0.0020593058,
-0.0431579985,
0.0324659534,
-0.0125108967,
0.0173763055,
0.0191746019,
-0.0207810439,
0.0016586084,
0.0007188357,
-0.0138510736,
-0.0306107849,
0.0004136106,
0.0372644998,
0.0186552871,
-0.0308748819,
-0.0102716042,
-0.0502103418,
0.0486124977,
0.0595640168,
-0.0191842671,
0.0056549604,
-0.0093555618,
-0.010216495,
-0.0721522346,
-0.0156880785,
1.55189694e-34,
0.0255645514,
-0.0014514854,
0.0799941793,
-0.0107733849,
0.0295152906,
0.0112297041,
-0.0106706526,
-0.0169126689,
0.000250027,
-0.0274769403,
-0.0364084914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00928v1 | FoldGPT: Simple and Effective Large Language Model Compression Scheme | 2024-07-01T03:17:53 | 2024-07-01T03:17:53 | Songwei Liu, Chao Zeng, Lianqiang Li, Chenqian Yan, Lean Fu, Xing Mei, Fangmin Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The demand for deploying large language models(LLMs) on mobile devices
continues to increase, driven by escalating data security concerns and cloud
costs. However, network bandwidth and memory limitations pose challenges for
deploying billion-level models on mobile devices. In this study, we investigate
the outputs of different layers across various scales of LLMs and found that
the outputs of most layers exhibit significant similarity. Moreover, this
similarity becomes more pronounced as the model size increases, indicating
substantial redundancy in the depth direction of the LLMs. Based on this
observation, we propose an efficient model volume compression strategy, termed
FoldGPT, which combines block removal and block parameter sharing.This strategy
consists of three parts: (1) Based on the learnable gating parameters, we
determine the block importance ranking while modeling the coupling effect
between blocks. Then we delete some redundant layers based on the given removal
rate. (2) For the retained blocks, we apply a specially designed group
parameter sharing strategy, where blocks within the same group share identical
weights, significantly compressing the number of parameters and slightly
reducing latency overhead. (3) After sharing these Blocks, we "cure" the
mismatch caused by sparsity with a minor amount of fine-tuning and introduce a
tail-layer distillation strategy to improve the performance. Experiments
demonstrate that FoldGPT outperforms previous state-of-the-art(SOTA) methods in
efficient model compression, demonstrating the feasibility of achieving model
lightweighting through straightforward block removal and parameter sharing. | FoldGPT: Simple and Effective Large Language Model Compression Scheme: The demand for deploying large language models(LLMs) on mobile devices
continues to increase, driven by escalating data security concerns and cloud
costs. However, network bandwidth and memory limitations pose challenges for
deploying billion-level models on mobile devices. In this study, we investigate
the outputs of different layers across various scales of LLMs and found that
the outputs of most layers exhibit significant similarity. Moreover, this
similarity becomes more pronounced as the model size increases, indicating
substantial redundancy in the depth direction of the LLMs. Based on this
observation, we propose an efficient model volume compression strategy, termed
FoldGPT, which combines block removal and block parameter sharing.This strategy
consists of three parts: (1) Based on the learnable gating parameters, we
determine the block importance ranking while modeling the coupling effect
between blocks. Then we delete some redundant layers based on the given removal
rate. (2) For the retained blocks, we apply a specially designed group
parameter sharing strategy, where blocks within the same group share identical
weights, significantly compressing the number of parameters and slightly
reducing latency overhead. (3) After sharing these Blocks, we "cure" the
mismatch caused by sparsity with a minor amount of fine-tuning and introduce a
tail-layer distillation strategy to improve the performance. Experiments
demonstrate that FoldGPT outperforms previous state-of-the-art(SOTA) methods in
efficient model compression, demonstrating the feasibility of achieving model
lightweighting through straightforward block removal and parameter sharing. | [
-0.0022305793,
0.0403986983,
-0.0196371637,
0.0215551779,
-0.0413582623,
0.0027941149,
0.0522491671,
0.002798344,
-0.0115248049,
-0.0017593045,
0.0100433072,
-0.0450082943,
0.0104294,
0.0174168535,
0.0021068242,
-0.0189038403,
0.0147449169,
-0.0284113064,
-0.015560708,
-0.0327614956,
0.0069664116,
0.0146380784,
0.0702357516,
0.0183884893,
0.0286686644,
-0.0051656594,
-0.0391332395,
0.0194983929,
-0.0016214642,
-0.0159074701,
0.0056366548,
0.0603291728,
0.0361921415,
0.0593289956,
0.0000024626,
0.002486438,
-0.0407309942,
0.0361260213,
-0.0643815398,
0.0616151765,
0.0585262664,
0.0014236519,
-0.0432338491,
0.0288851727,
-0.0058508213,
-0.0167771578,
0.0676244721,
0.0176551677,
0.0859193429,
0.0034540435,
0.002580425,
-0.0289236996,
-0.0193175599,
-0.0180081874,
-0.0351040885,
-0.0323298275,
-0.0131374644,
0.029925419,
-0.014256346,
0.0108282976,
-0.0018040744,
0.0173315834,
0.0392863639,
0.0245172642,
-0.0303930547,
0.0035806894,
-0.0348683111,
-0.0069861109,
0.0035558611,
0.0350969285,
-0.0384314731,
-0.0514431968,
0.0024537304,
-0.0040833498,
-0.0209881011,
0.0099142892,
-0.0573735498,
0.0409393162,
0.0209705736,
0.0298213959,
-0.0337584205,
-0.0241046902,
0.041831024,
-0.0249150489,
-0.0415482037,
0.0223468002,
0.0238194801,
-0.0073142326,
-0.039954897,
-0.0216040798,
-0.0101856934,
-0.0553901196,
0.0227094106,
-0.0336485021,
0.0232506394,
-0.0274841227,
-0.0646773353,
-0.0466048829,
-0.0003750263,
-0.0616629682,
0.0660619512,
0.0221066941,
0.0300982874,
0.0120610874,
-0.0266303122,
0.0403704979,
-0.0274083633,
-0.0096570207,
-0.004285045,
-0.0188197028,
-0.0202352088,
-0.0014265918,
-0.0292108599,
0.0554156899,
-0.0557263047,
-0.0170478132,
-0.0373495258,
0.00663205,
-0.0001617583,
-0.0123391915,
0.0189554524,
0.004968605,
0.0038828768,
-0.0205600671,
0.0606755987,
-0.0001957672,
-0.0116440356,
0.013693016,
0.0077310256,
-0.0686498731,
-0.0127533609,
-0.0009359756,
-0.0015443939,
-0.0012997432,
-0.0009565451,
0.0277342778,
0.0083419466,
-0.009757611,
-0.0313738212,
-0.0293165874,
0.0382826142,
-0.0490914993,
-0.0329140164,
-0.0705920458,
0.0199419726,
-0.0141772833,
0.0065059811,
-0.0515492447,
-0.0089934021,
0.0161229707,
-0.0546151251,
0.02824012,
0.0028303883,
0.0101324907,
0.0124327345,
0.0393331945,
0.0014160415,
0.0670096874,
0.0229064301,
0.0422009788,
0.0226214305,
-0.0616006032,
-0.0115769347,
0.0339905806,
0.0537636839,
0.0361294188,
-0.0621405318,
-0.026976442,
0.0246792529,
-0.0148026226,
0.0352090038,
0.0586809106,
-0.0301186964,
-0.0435104296,
0.0931570232,
0.0533962213,
0.0101092784,
0.0711786598,
-0.018886067,
0.0561811291,
0.0043672509,
-0.0186012872,
-0.0534268394,
0.0207808465,
-0.0370408222,
0.0054476387,
0.0723476857,
0.1019612402,
-0.0260544978,
0.0205405485,
-0.0390694216,
-0.0397132933,
0.0166124515,
0.0250660479,
-0.0033698885,
-0.0152678927,
-0.0171271469,
0.1126991659,
0.0220421609,
-0.1039918512,
-0.0753805786,
-0.0532862321,
-0.0059565143,
0.0006133106,
0.0249814559,
0.0566151179,
-0.0259776078,
0.0259009004,
0.0097178007,
-0.0092190355,
0.004894394,
0.0076899729,
0.0612521134,
-0.068001695,
-0.0185867399,
0.0709226504,
0.0302275065,
0.0130536351,
0.0395119861,
0.0330794454,
0.0389515832,
-0.0411210395,
-0.0448851325,
-0.0033237555,
-0.022555761,
0.0266484898,
0.0530964248,
-0.0050806869,
0.0488126315,
-0.00973495,
-0.015159118,
-0.0373126268,
0.0453061089,
-0.0120934583,
0.0109135909,
-0.0310929138,
-0.0355445035,
0.0252785385,
-0.0014148601,
0.0274762735,
0.0824793577,
0.0716095194,
-0.0296731833,
-0.0387363471,
0.0377615839,
-0.0197813399,
0.0446067415,
-0.0232224204,
0.0409385525,
-0.0326607823,
0.0629640669,
-0.0015290121,
0.0036001813,
-0.0199292749,
-0.0196353011,
0.0037540458,
0.0035962488,
0.0173709877,
0.0153908143,
-0.0277178995,
0.0339343585,
-0.0161048677,
0.0333777368,
0.012118509,
0.0018640694,
0.0069325948,
-0.0037203578,
-0.0710570216,
0.0224740617,
-0.0126896128,
0.0428218059,
0.0375496224,
0.0740831345,
-0.0073592369,
-0.0199546758,
-0.0194817092,
0.0207190141,
-0.0032174774,
0.0331701189,
-0.0451837368,
-0.0388648659,
-0.0427423827,
-0.0084863538,
-0.045503363,
0.0508552454,
0.0599862486,
-0.056564685,
-0.0084178308,
-0.0302496571,
0.0054681753,
-0.027189618,
0.0254136529,
0.0169571899,
-0.0833622143,
-0.0150554301,
-0.0114265261,
-0.0179171097,
0.0637441725,
-0.0126523515,
0.0065744496,
0.071802333,
0.0075662108,
-0.0503252372,
-0.0034941991,
-0.0169901606,
-0.0274131782,
-0.036705479,
-0.0416406319,
-0.0652004406,
0.0955294371,
-0.0096052699,
-0.0237014405,
-0.0472086892,
-0.029888032,
-0.0146447774,
0.0064930166,
-0.0065640314,
0.0166270137,
-0.0174867585,
0.0399602205,
-0.0056034606,
-0.0814357251,
0.023261888,
-0.0588532984,
-0.0081017232,
-0.0110544804,
-0.0560722426,
-0.0271028727,
0.05384041,
-0.0066591538,
0.0452621058,
-0.007225303,
-0.0117900986,
-0.0325400345,
0.0302901287,
0.0183260739,
-0.0349942073,
-0.0383523256,
-0.0323784463,
-0.0081448182,
-0.0297246855,
-0.0409212485,
0.0316477939,
0.0006818703,
-0.0209506154,
-0.0039025443,
0.0325950123,
-0.0557624437,
-0.0261806455,
0.0371047966,
0.0308935586,
0.0353434309,
-0.0089137796,
0.0333619267,
-0.0009800391,
-0.0091882572,
-0.0096255494,
0.0410275087,
0.0360379517,
0.0110388678,
0.0385383144,
0.0598240905,
0.0569636077,
0.0140503654,
-0.0526987538,
-0.0115196053,
0.0654860586,
0.0283693485,
-0.0633196235,
0.0567235984,
0.0647282675,
-0.0701147839,
0.0146294571,
0.0764197409,
-0.0047853715,
-0.0415686332,
0.0027008965,
0.0065853912,
0.1116855592,
-0.0027094446,
0.0319680348,
-0.0434286892,
-0.0247211345,
0.0271147043,
0.0071562426,
0.0174290426,
0.000794752,
-0.0048780199,
-0.0825538635,
0.0491149463,
0.0447915196,
0.0270120818,
0.000574448,
-0.0657981038,
-0.0138845332,
-0.0123708704,
-0.0047993725,
-0.020908678,
0.001498154,
0.0004088017,
-0.0013953756,
-0.0651798621,
-0.060292583,
0.0276373662,
-0.0153761329,
0.0302238762,
0.0426389202,
-0.0136408191,
0.0165911373,
-0.0191488396,
0.0638069585,
0.0311003085,
-0.0438714623,
-0.0120600099,
-0.0063509452,
0.0635962561,
0.0112482384,
0.0063169817,
0.0021705348,
-0.0003401655,
-0.0117454641,
-0.0378335007,
0.0922253355,
0.0005826178,
-0.0088606784,
-0.0235544778,
-0.0197398588,
-0.006802992,
0.0466003381,
0.0319529474,
-0.0093748281,
-0.0433790162,
-0.0188645683,
-0.0219693519,
-0.0158314258,
-0.0172380302,
0.0389688201,
-0.0023957877,
-0.03049629,
0.001967909,
0.0322363228,
-0.0218890309,
0.0232950822,
0.0167789925,
0.0275617354,
0.0219531115,
0.0301532093,
-0.0666535422,
-0.0380857922,
-0.0340752266,
-0.002025553,
-0.0599130243,
0.0195881203,
-0.001563505,
-0.0189104807,
-0.0282175224,
0.0142180678,
-0.1156916171,
-0.0757325888,
0.0228392463,
0.0152114993,
0.0270696301,
0.0526541136,
0.0112476051,
-0.0975634158,
0.0440386869,
0.0319002718,
-0.0615763701,
0.0561793558,
0.0149835674,
-0.0792162791,
0.0142333461,
0.0454572402,
-0.0414191782,
0.0148264943,
0.0042057335,
-0.0055502229,
-0.0293423645,
-0.0241464432,
-0.0084614046,
0.0313901044,
-0.0005845806,
0.0197523907,
-0.0235451218,
0.0226766206,
0.0590764582,
-0.0135352444,
0.0050534406,
-0.0312780477,
0.0169211924,
-0.0108859753,
0.0017231359,
0.0268186983,
0.0185813028,
0.0865803733,
-0.002138122,
0.0116577381,
0.0048134639,
-0.045576226,
-0.0075016036,
0.0731652677,
0.0024470869,
-0.012315074,
-0.0133188423,
0.0226474702,
0.020683324,
-0.0627698228,
0.0134400688,
-0.0121761709,
0.0412525423,
-0.0439005457,
0.0611415952,
-0.0391371287,
-0.0946581736,
-0.0501724966,
-0.020343123,
0.0234911758,
0.0326491073,
0.0538865291,
-0.031596344,
-0.0101895221,
-0.0516211465,
0.0143660922,
-0.0251145866,
-0.010108782,
0.0112247514,
-0.0099567166,
-0.0190394185,
0.0346997082,
0.0625168607,
0.0755542964,
0.0240273885,
-0.0215856805,
-0.0281531941,
-0.0178889558,
-0.0303376615,
0.0071552549,
0.0552379824,
-0.0163081549,
-0.0227392651,
-0.033816725,
-0.0556562953,
-0.0152380709,
-0.0112818731,
0.0203971025,
-0.0416935645,
0.0172304343,
0.0429043882,
0.0083782114,
0.0116065005,
-0.0507662706,
-0.0508456416,
-0.0097095082,
-0.0178987104,
0.0450600311,
-7.278333351e-33,
0.0154800136,
0.0414089039,
-0.0014736488,
-0.0600099228,
-0.0361439548,
0.00803346,
-0.0228571594,
-0.0050596232,
-0.0300688706,
-0.0081065306,
-0.0395716801,
0.0183848143,
0.0308738928,
0.0420253836,
0.0043388386,
0.0400837064,
0.0406983756,
-0.0093947621,
-0.0249755383,
0.0855136737,
0.0284552891,
0.013288701,
0.018345803,
-0.0523495674,
-0.0496721081,
-0.0021601473,
0.001074826,
-0.0430271663,
-0.0134376995,
0.0490362532,
-0.0209868271,
-0.0243279394,
-0.0136453062,
-0.0635969937,
-0.03907381,
-0.0035333503,
-0.0188786406,
-0.0039637643,
0.0151624745,
-0.0012258429,
-0.0174982417,
-0.0427972302,
0.0179426633,
0.0095819216,
-0.0246269442,
-0.0397429615,
-0.0207378715,
-0.0010386235,
-0.0642691702,
0.0021949504,
0.0054573324,
0.0120757353,
0.0005570787,
0.0138232913,
0.0626832768,
-0.0340636,
-0.071433492,
0.0234169979,
-0.0418041795,
0.0182847381,
0.0191807523,
0.0826707259,
0.0539508946,
0.0015255075,
0.0010698084,
0.0339058563,
0.0075942902,
-0.0199193694,
-0.0388799235,
0.013335024,
0.0152835846,
0.0487685651,
0.0240212008,
0.0277583469,
0.0699452683,
-0.0225924421,
-0.03351577,
-0.0162325799,
-0.0138065061,
0.0163716134,
0.0196456853,
0.0173370205,
-0.0089429365,
-0.0347757265,
-0.0388656594,
-0.0366665795,
-0.0226002187,
-0.0362057425,
0.0213059373,
-0.0105785467,
-0.0318726338,
-0.0202631727,
0.0652778894,
-0.0312489346,
-0.0170061775,
0.0073050475,
-0.0104379877,
0.0109454924,
0.0265582204,
0.0206990093,
-0.0234493092,
-0.0089491503,
-0.0373412743,
-0.0372148231,
0.0317605138,
0.0014146965,
0.0048683425,
0.0435722582,
-0.0666153431,
0.0056385114,
-0.0295965932,
0.0065690167,
0.013181176,
0.0317659341,
0.0344332792,
-0.0161415767,
0.0322759897,
0.0209697634,
0.0052612913,
-0.0070329304,
-0.0122205317,
-0.0064394013,
0.0244252756,
0.0197777897,
-0.0079638008,
0.0102879163,
-0.0929611474,
-0.0015343677,
0.0661558062,
-0.0213156734,
-0.0421629697,
0.0423797779,
3.18e-7,
-0.0259972364,
0.0095460312,
-0.0217981469,
-0.0273900758,
0.0352301449,
0.0447048992,
0.0064227176,
0.019616751,
-0.0062525691,
0.0065194964,
-0.0290909335,
0.0124381324,
0.0818000063,
0.0179222915,
-0.0639761016,
0.0209442321,
-0.0870655477,
-0.0045214901,
-0.0300113596,
-0.0231598672,
-0.0130662024,
0.1302373707,
0.0170055479,
-0.0280886572,
0.0059140683,
0.0212231111,
-0.0104689151,
-0.0081151333,
0.0385373905,
0.0045485087,
-0.0057922103,
0.0128887203,
-0.0532049276,
-0.0021941236,
-0.0242118854,
-0.0128506301,
-0.0396470055,
0.0699413344,
0.0082092611,
0.0420411639,
0.0311875399,
-0.0452028587,
-0.0467673913,
-0.0603121817,
0.0402672626,
0.0321323313,
-0.022206381,
-0.0487019941,
0.0144367274,
-0.0555493236,
0.0057558753,
0.0064207711,
0.0484995432,
0.0106358463,
-0.0045191455,
-0.0234203115,
-0.0013971996,
-0.0639601275,
-0.0091120526,
-0.0201843549,
-0.0187351685,
-0.0331259631,
-0.0579041429,
0.0099669779,
0.0708474293,
0.004554308,
0.0391781814,
3.505219003e-34,
0.0188184977,
-0.0241249148,
0.0540291108,
0.0585404821,
0.0029962354,
-0.0220434852,
0.0344251506,
0.0184397176,
-0.0380469523,
-0.078927137,
-0.0237898342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00924v1 | EXCGEC: A Benchmark of Edit-wise Explainable Chinese Grammatical Error Correction | 2024-07-01T03:06:41 | 2024-07-01T03:06:41 | Jingheng Ye, Shang Qin, Yinghui Li, Xuxin Cheng, Libo Qin, Hai-Tao Zheng, Peng Xing, Zishan Xu, Guo Cheng, Zhao Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing studies explore the explainability of Grammatical Error Correction
(GEC) in a limited scenario, where they ignore the interaction between
corrections and explanations. To bridge the gap, this paper introduces the task
of EXplainable GEC (EXGEC), which focuses on the integral role of both
correction and explanation tasks. To facilitate the task, we propose EXCGEC, a
tailored benchmark for Chinese EXGEC consisting of 8,216 explanation-augmented
samples featuring the design of hybrid edit-wise explanations. We benchmark
several series of LLMs in multiple settings, covering post-explaining and
pre-explaining. To promote the development of the task, we introduce a
comprehensive suite of automatic metrics and conduct human evaluation
experiments to demonstrate the human consistency of the automatic metrics for
free-text explanations. All the codes and data will be released after the
review. | EXCGEC: A Benchmark of Edit-wise Explainable Chinese Grammatical Error Correction: Existing studies explore the explainability of Grammatical Error Correction
(GEC) in a limited scenario, where they ignore the interaction between
corrections and explanations. To bridge the gap, this paper introduces the task
of EXplainable GEC (EXGEC), which focuses on the integral role of both
correction and explanation tasks. To facilitate the task, we propose EXCGEC, a
tailored benchmark for Chinese EXGEC consisting of 8,216 explanation-augmented
samples featuring the design of hybrid edit-wise explanations. We benchmark
several series of LLMs in multiple settings, covering post-explaining and
pre-explaining. To promote the development of the task, we introduce a
comprehensive suite of automatic metrics and conduct human evaluation
experiments to demonstrate the human consistency of the automatic metrics for
free-text explanations. All the codes and data will be released after the
review. | [
0.0361385345,
-0.0006777939,
-0.0094836438,
0.0176095795,
0.0358328559,
0.0326710604,
-0.0187033135,
-0.0039286055,
-0.048446361,
-0.0221957136,
-0.0119936951,
-0.0281479396,
0.0386887342,
-0.0204257723,
0.0360653438,
-0.058896862,
0.0358638465,
-0.0012156395,
-0.0199634712,
0.02906169,
0.0407073461,
0.0127530666,
-0.0256066751,
0.0658862367,
0.0084331259,
-0.0329354517,
-0.0500259511,
0.0445240885,
0.0073128729,
-0.0028769597,
0.0069297636,
0.0163563993,
-0.0200961791,
0.0105860792,
0.0000021496,
-0.0378203802,
-0.0359299891,
-0.0066203219,
-0.0752099678,
0.0841119066,
-0.0183178335,
-0.0235488284,
-0.0318485796,
0.010650875,
0.0307305176,
0.0270454157,
0.0556003973,
0.080366604,
0.0660006553,
0.086238414,
0.0099130431,
-0.0055413274,
-0.0217403583,
-0.0000565996,
0.0055428511,
-0.0112530468,
-0.0263127387,
-0.005690915,
-0.041041173,
-0.0283739846,
-0.0188377574,
-0.0063243583,
0.0207678154,
-0.0917202607,
0.0018174837,
-0.0015515481,
0.008717211,
0.0008602067,
-0.0182712357,
0.031273406,
0.0222979039,
-0.0393796526,
-0.0086412765,
-0.0261433329,
0.0183121525,
0.0071512382,
-0.0464393198,
-0.0061724405,
0.0059886314,
0.0007570504,
0.0350055546,
-0.0755305886,
0.0493849032,
0.0245357007,
0.0334454551,
0.0623992272,
-0.002466389,
-0.0351845659,
-0.0646322593,
-0.000668634,
-0.0187367313,
-0.0731128231,
-0.0041395691,
0.0480140187,
-0.0589332432,
0.004416314,
0.017678678,
-0.0360722579,
-0.0088643385,
-0.0162994005,
0.0352968462,
0.015887361,
-0.0233933106,
0.019764943,
-0.0056765326,
0.1051532328,
0.016009327,
0.0187978521,
-0.0127341188,
0.0084381811,
-0.059859585,
-0.0344168544,
-0.043866232,
0.0143913208,
-0.0431444272,
0.0401109457,
-0.054466486,
0.0099718524,
-0.0286223385,
0.0184278321,
0.0463604406,
-0.0110385353,
-0.0402866416,
-0.0500536077,
-0.0356791243,
0.0000637382,
-0.0447774678,
0.0209809989,
0.0220921747,
-0.0255226716,
-0.0536955036,
0.0270864721,
0.0144215496,
-0.0026292501,
-0.0498370454,
0.0201247223,
-0.0140450839,
0.0002596315,
-0.0365009718,
-0.0189995114,
-0.0238032099,
-0.0248808507,
-0.0713947415,
-0.0085052913,
-0.0255814232,
-0.02054267,
0.0138219949,
-0.0329349488,
0.0087231984,
-0.0366651937,
-0.0068565793,
0.0562841706,
-0.0532358587,
0.024489319,
-0.0111545296,
0.0029107227,
-0.0348905288,
0.0266189463,
0.0443224534,
-0.044595357,
0.0613035038,
-0.036118798,
0.0567948893,
-0.0191287845,
-0.0219210256,
-0.0241272077,
0.0385023355,
-0.0123175457,
-0.0391869135,
0.0664480105,
0.044006329,
0.0069080167,
-0.0216494314,
0.0506022759,
0.03161598,
0.0070447661,
0.0303545147,
0.0118449451,
0.0300757643,
-0.0271445271,
0.0050422638,
0.0631231666,
-0.0513949692,
0.0430403426,
-0.038035173,
0.0207560342,
0.0311105736,
-0.0532739349,
-0.0235133059,
-0.1120187566,
-0.0144213988,
0.0129310125,
-0.009457455,
-0.0427289568,
0.0260107238,
0.021213064,
-0.0295415707,
0.0448090248,
0.0253136307,
-0.0944487751,
-0.0031441906,
-0.0413731635,
0.028844133,
0.1102514863,
0.0445489138,
-0.0071562184,
-0.0305304602,
-0.0296941269,
0.0066444823,
0.0443414226,
0.0355325639,
-0.0061901761,
0.0261880793,
-0.0253253542,
0.000647774,
-0.0463346653,
0.0511003546,
-0.0265974812,
0.0158264637,
-0.0373893715,
0.0269251876,
-0.0783218667,
-0.0744855255,
0.0430852547,
0.0068867463,
-0.0231753029,
-0.0155643504,
0.0045492989,
0.0102956584,
0.0312404297,
-0.0266472436,
0.0160680655,
-0.0266492739,
-0.0156834219,
-0.0175315272,
0.0464761145,
-0.0075338949,
-0.0667702183,
0.0236128569,
-0.0407280326,
-0.0508926958,
0.0181550551,
-0.0537551865,
-0.0721413642,
-0.0201687422,
-0.0308865234,
0.0377096422,
-0.0622197613,
0.0540949553,
-0.0066636042,
-0.0158696696,
0.0034102227,
0.0102854306,
0.0222240947,
0.0382964462,
-0.00560909,
-0.0003861024,
0.0001306238,
-0.0390375406,
-0.0012749521,
-0.0067135543,
0.0027368451,
-0.00977113,
-0.016637465,
0.0180458277,
-0.0228790436,
-0.0206285678,
-0.048986081,
-0.0077606598,
-0.0686381459,
0.0152854295,
0.0754196346,
-0.0228423383,
-0.0075104511,
-0.0090130651,
0.0045274505,
0.0441124216,
-0.0145598343,
-0.0038357768,
0.0842044204,
-0.0258814692,
-0.0467238091,
-0.0650123805,
0.0331195518,
-0.0118179107,
0.0202109087,
0.0318966359,
0.0122260749,
-0.0830068961,
0.0316757187,
-0.02484213,
-0.0576104298,
0.0036200201,
-0.1012581289,
0.0150953587,
0.0236871801,
0.0372456387,
0.0161164906,
0.0132125635,
0.0608011894,
-0.0008577561,
0.0078627327,
-0.0234070532,
-0.0151171433,
0.0051343893,
-0.0234017428,
-0.0279363822,
-0.0484534875,
0.0029295818,
0.0997281596,
-0.0033804036,
-0.0081237303,
-0.0553784519,
-0.0178894103,
-0.0140646389,
-0.0242526978,
-0.0250715148,
-0.0334235765,
-0.0341691263,
0.0386287011,
-0.0500707701,
-0.0384389423,
0.0907763764,
-0.0276203491,
-0.0225207806,
0.0094176745,
-0.0035053906,
-0.0218081921,
0.0309943501,
-0.0258881357,
0.0181288086,
-0.0057241423,
-0.0315570384,
-0.0250960141,
-0.004056314,
0.0610094555,
0.0086473506,
0.0545348637,
-0.0694891736,
-0.0063684871,
0.0169471707,
-0.0028818671,
-0.0026097745,
-0.0344435014,
-0.0021179963,
-0.0072452817,
0.043701455,
-0.029503243,
0.0259632245,
0.0260845311,
0.0370240062,
0.0255463216,
-0.0254625492,
0.0026794542,
-0.0110359443,
-0.0358970463,
-0.0049531544,
0.06043569,
0.041593086,
-0.0559286848,
0.0670187324,
0.0451642983,
0.0247906633,
0.0107565168,
0.0002624012,
0.0055295588,
-0.0217391234,
-0.0582048446,
-0.0388840288,
0.0022283483,
0.1162792221,
-0.0685380474,
0.0011209173,
0.1224934831,
0.0314193591,
-0.0119429268,
0.0093461908,
-0.0197210032,
-0.001468622,
0.0105358232,
-0.0003990109,
-0.0342613123,
-0.0140067413,
0.0421752632,
0.0549848005,
0.0042265202,
0.0055241566,
0.0195046682,
-0.0854462236,
0.0718233883,
0.0187759679,
0.0091656158,
-0.0394448265,
-0.0541650578,
0.0154414279,
0.0195810329,
0.0276221167,
0.0423527658,
0.0146441609,
0.0011611263,
0.0296291467,
-0.0624933355,
-0.0275263358,
-0.0060526207,
-0.0318688303,
0.0388169028,
0.046621453,
0.0478628613,
0.0213635843,
-0.019181164,
0.0343618095,
0.0175853167,
0.0184596162,
-0.0127574122,
0.0517302155,
0.0474883392,
-0.0095976787,
-0.0352610759,
0.049734544,
-0.0106075229,
-0.0095648989,
-0.0020117876,
0.0415193476,
-0.0305204149,
0.0098449951,
0.0452121869,
-0.0119146751,
-0.0167158004,
0.0815980956,
0.0785421655,
-0.0188927576,
-0.0325801075,
-0.0693001226,
-0.0296231266,
-0.086384736,
0.0223315414,
0.0310894735,
-0.0161407981,
-0.0082888212,
-0.0577067919,
-0.0616583824,
-0.0067884875,
-0.0069756298,
0.0248637311,
-0.0133959372,
-0.0456414931,
-0.0242402032,
0.0008341874,
-0.012756669,
0.0304952562,
0.0226534437,
-0.0505038723,
-0.0222034026,
-0.0336259231,
-0.0064298841,
0.0174549725,
-0.0125575475,
0.0134560214,
-0.015244388,
0.0143383406,
0.0102886511,
0.0115454271,
0.0487532765,
-0.0043782382,
-0.0764418244,
-0.0538645647,
-0.0172541272,
0.003943908,
0.0349161588,
0.0441539697,
0.0003801079,
0.0220493283,
0.0551278144,
-0.0237741284,
-0.0177561268,
0.0069427174,
0.0686742812,
-0.0080588842,
-0.0139598493,
0.0441712365,
0.0307651274,
0.02641383,
-0.0240036342,
-0.0160620417,
-0.0769707337,
0.0495331772,
-0.0560452677,
-0.0128747849,
-0.0315962024,
0.0266173054,
0.0114440918,
-0.0523873679,
-0.0038619456,
0.0331850983,
-0.0496752374,
-0.017981939,
-0.0279942285,
0.0303416178,
0.001014117,
0.0307513922,
-0.0133319646,
0.0313555263,
0.0029504905,
-0.0065415506,
0.0058589964,
0.0197415184,
0.0216708668,
0.076155819,
0.0267107878,
0.0406346172,
-0.0003711819,
-0.0081876423,
-0.0493579358,
0.0258649755,
0.0081599215,
0.0029238896,
0.069283329,
-0.005506862,
0.1326164752,
0.000198427,
-0.0172956176,
-0.0010273642,
0.0966651365,
0.0344231986,
-0.0128398994,
-0.0134552922,
0.0189834796,
-0.0154765956,
-0.0309828781,
0.0594656765,
-0.0162572451,
0.0255564973,
-0.006714223,
-0.0167757496,
0.0056465445,
-0.0048372098,
-0.0103363805,
0.0074606813,
0.0153791085,
-0.0223939717,
-0.042537678,
-0.045919124,
-0.0304346047,
0.0429585353,
-0.0214146581,
-0.0224958919,
-0.0138997305,
0.0575508773,
-0.0230118185,
-0.0352244712,
-0.0407258719,
-0.0117876297,
-0.0219120327,
0.0305062216,
-0.0254650675,
-6.505024842e-33,
-0.0426432565,
-0.0410547554,
-0.0190436728,
-0.021091152,
-0.0008867382,
-0.0034452998,
-0.0922843665,
0.0085373251,
0.0268012024,
0.0634187385,
-0.0238134414,
0.0586759336,
-0.0034972951,
-0.0003595125,
0.0205914713,
0.0012835393,
0.0588414483,
0.0257648639,
-0.0289385729,
-0.01868595,
0.0424476862,
0.0217752699,
0.0786010027,
-0.036894545,
0.0988664776,
0.0345320106,
-0.0405735336,
0.031782534,
-0.0133158294,
0.0612133145,
0.0424979068,
0.0286110044,
0.0301791821,
-0.0181857962,
-0.0264233891,
-0.0182409454,
-0.0645984784,
-0.0335181542,
0.0475111641,
0.0162205007,
-0.0425785407,
-0.0457571223,
0.0353394076,
-0.0044696671,
-0.0100625642,
-0.0153223034,
0.0280580558,
-0.0271307155,
0.0240453724,
0.040518444,
0.0226555187,
0.032561861,
-0.0469195731,
-0.0215813387,
-0.0108805373,
-0.0082849404,
-0.0207428057,
-0.0219699461,
-0.0398608968,
-0.0421347618,
0.0559054948,
0.0454601794,
0.0478848331,
-0.0283071399,
-0.0233612061,
0.0171676036,
0.0252689105,
0.0226696152,
-0.0645964444,
0.0206001587,
-0.042828016,
0.0211132094,
0.0731947124,
0.0576869659,
0.0311295837,
-0.0076420996,
-0.0381673165,
0.0368747376,
-0.048982013,
0.0333152711,
-0.026453713,
0.0224253368,
-0.0499908291,
-0.0361412391,
-0.0360091887,
0.0307968371,
-0.0236356221,
-0.0213010013,
0.039326258,
-0.0209597629,
-0.0338361822,
-0.0605797209,
-0.0344542041,
-0.0144642824,
0.0250771958,
-0.0093193678,
-0.0049846666,
0.0159896407,
-0.0033879115,
-0.0170398653,
0.0089588165,
0.0110695362,
-0.0083246985,
0.0431915298,
0.0468909815,
-0.0034562121,
0.0454573706,
0.0124511532,
-0.0325418077,
0.0270286258,
-0.0314441659,
-0.0327675417,
-0.051300738,
-0.037185587,
0.000559463,
0.0121031441,
-0.0315952376,
-0.008535726,
0.0234729219,
0.0263049547,
-0.0192959234,
-0.0227248129,
-0.0119500998,
0.0297298748,
-0.0100593548,
0.0144943083,
-0.0183198657,
-0.0288583357,
0.0551345535,
-0.0421370491,
-0.0036180892,
0.0172968283,
2.658e-7,
0.0439545065,
0.0344340317,
0.0532597676,
0.0147375725,
0.0187037811,
-0.0026765144,
-0.0076072798,
-0.0534250401,
-0.0236393325,
0.017568266,
0.0368413031,
0.0343213789,
0.0861600637,
0.0067927805,
-0.0025429139,
-0.0096858125,
-0.0372802578,
-0.0063733011,
-0.0148712993,
0.0143691115,
0.0417619683,
-0.0134030646,
0.0004551681,
0.0312245544,
0.0047653434,
-0.0296509862,
0.0143882949,
-0.0195330121,
0.0103309043,
0.0481742211,
0.0834736079,
0.0209408905,
0.0356868878,
-0.0158065725,
-0.03979031,
-0.0119222617,
-0.0063945027,
0.0472016111,
-0.0408571288,
-0.0005283149,
-0.0128251156,
-0.0218193736,
0.0214472804,
-0.0567678623,
0.0409565158,
0.0245791599,
0.0092409495,
0.0459530987,
-0.0163775235,
-0.0208209902,
-0.0391561463,
-0.0030967353,
-0.0044503529,
0.029688634,
0.0050402689,
-0.0049888496,
0.0057207062,
-0.041078072,
-0.0854216069,
0.0172739457,
0.0460658483,
0.0102045452,
-0.0060610897,
-0.0041286577,
0.0171424113,
-0.0542201884,
-0.0393650457,
1.92348712e-34,
0.0089626173,
-0.0027102646,
0.0513855368,
0.0252124108,
0.0526501946,
0.0077455142,
-0.0232462082,
-0.0284317043,
0.0165627971,
-0.034803208,
-0.0316185541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00923v1 | Preserving Multilingual Quality While Tuning Query Encoder on English Only | 2024-07-01T03:03:18 | 2024-07-01T03:03:18 | Oleg Vasilyev, Randy Sawaya, John Bohannon | cs.CL | cs.CL | A dense passage retrieval system can serve as the initial stages of
information retrieval, selecting the most relevant text passages for downstream
tasks. In this work we conducted experiments with the goal of finding how much
the quality of a multilingual retrieval could be degraded if the query part of
a dual encoder is tuned on an English-only dataset (assuming scarcity of
cross-lingual samples for the targeted domain or task). Specifically, starting
with a high quality multilingual embedding model, we observe that an
English-only tuning may not only preserve the original quality of the
multilingual retrieval, but even improve it. | Preserving Multilingual Quality While Tuning Query Encoder on English Only: A dense passage retrieval system can serve as the initial stages of
information retrieval, selecting the most relevant text passages for downstream
tasks. In this work we conducted experiments with the goal of finding how much
the quality of a multilingual retrieval could be degraded if the query part of
a dual encoder is tuned on an English-only dataset (assuming scarcity of
cross-lingual samples for the targeted domain or task). Specifically, starting
with a high quality multilingual embedding model, we observe that an
English-only tuning may not only preserve the original quality of the
multilingual retrieval, but even improve it. | [
0.0006959647,
0.0446347445,
-0.025362825,
0.0613435805,
-0.0152370101,
0.0052365526,
0.0049430472,
0.050157804,
-0.0229744539,
0.0001929966,
-0.032910835,
-0.0656513423,
-0.0284358654,
0.012770649,
0.0260325018,
-0.022206543,
0.040710777,
-0.0154141039,
-0.0174710918,
-0.0194813851,
0.0019472316,
0.0026147764,
0.0637068525,
0.0008256726,
0.0408439226,
0.0521066785,
-0.0030398474,
0.02283605,
-0.0082054436,
0.0088738129,
0.02326129,
0.0163317211,
0.0485197306,
0.000104953,
0.0000016627,
-0.0292501785,
-0.0221953597,
0.0131745972,
0.0091514941,
-0.0066188583,
0.0431476571,
-0.0273199044,
0.0476980098,
-0.010553834,
0.0100603541,
0.0060948664,
0.0262896232,
0.0085111046,
0.0322818197,
0.0450122058,
-0.0084454902,
-0.0279000178,
-0.011275758,
-0.0212365724,
0.0076098749,
-0.0452689715,
-0.0003887983,
-0.0090138698,
0.0090095447,
0.05321192,
-0.0231151301,
0.042078279,
0.0164697915,
-0.0019968993,
0.0118896347,
-0.0039271228,
-0.0318677612,
-0.0177018438,
0.0535014346,
0.0210219119,
-0.0344714746,
0.0039894208,
-0.0396410823,
0.0310348403,
-0.02051723,
0.0139542548,
-0.024427101,
-0.0229139943,
0.0068010604,
0.0121571347,
-0.0060927845,
-0.0145250019,
0.0136386948,
-0.0033425586,
-0.0232906733,
0.0295735523,
0.0271069799,
-0.0503899455,
0.0339993313,
0.0514909141,
-0.0064828107,
0.0341811888,
0.0574655756,
-0.0344773494,
-0.0152327381,
-0.0069097946,
-0.0052111675,
-0.0539335161,
-0.0148179447,
-0.0498635024,
-0.0200916044,
0.0508231446,
-0.012232244,
0.042503722,
-0.0032914358,
0.0477326103,
0.0228669513,
0.0759527162,
-0.0769566149,
-0.0543708727,
-0.0041246018,
0.0001138235,
-0.0385860577,
0.032501474,
-0.0376794524,
0.0165678076,
-0.0260854047,
-0.0015517124,
0.0351969711,
-0.0136522111,
-0.007359847,
-0.0237598829,
-0.0548869558,
-0.018538449,
-0.0096180215,
0.0557135269,
-0.0432687365,
-0.0182977263,
0.0108936848,
-0.0313088782,
-0.0266917422,
0.0188545082,
0.0159695987,
-0.0607926473,
0.004383164,
0.0017560455,
-0.0340172239,
-0.025024198,
-0.0502372347,
0.0047434461,
0.0223365165,
-0.0059923888,
0.0062676193,
-0.0172984395,
0.0672293231,
0.0127351554,
0.0189180169,
-0.0614948533,
-0.0153583623,
0.0154211512,
-0.0301715117,
0.0532440059,
0.0111426376,
-0.0034025351,
0.0008201941,
0.008306371,
0.0270865019,
0.1189881712,
-0.0022746797,
-0.0000600076,
0.0971776098,
0.0094801309,
-0.0317515731,
0.0471861884,
0.0101887062,
0.0320672877,
-0.0134893078,
0.0048014503,
0.0208954867,
0.017485043,
0.0343559347,
0.0339590535,
-0.0729540363,
-0.0213277694,
0.0106565701,
0.0338413902,
0.0659460574,
-0.0007413905,
0.0371645354,
-0.0039909636,
-0.0421691686,
0.0463365726,
0.0149696134,
0.0258116778,
0.0000055793,
-0.0144408718,
0.0856690779,
0.0392706059,
-0.0494820699,
-0.0399865136,
0.0035805353,
-0.0089975335,
0.0204806551,
-0.0055378345,
0.0529286563,
-0.0313165486,
-0.0328080766,
0.009407091,
0.0202752426,
-0.0662397072,
0.0778650939,
-0.0146667082,
-0.0405063182,
0.0612423308,
0.0552957542,
-0.007118884,
0.0218969118,
0.0012206811,
-0.0135270273,
0.0056257737,
0.0526258685,
-0.0190685652,
0.0689438879,
-0.0986332148,
-0.0574003235,
-0.019066086,
-0.0085644871,
0.0345875062,
-0.0371035822,
0.0456265211,
0.0267920867,
-0.0633443519,
-0.0157694463,
0.0112980297,
-0.0481474176,
0.0071620317,
0.0192684457,
0.0268492568,
-0.0008677152,
0.0130618839,
-0.0126796933,
-0.0058040833,
0.0226615071,
-0.0503823124,
-0.0131513784,
-0.0137196323,
-0.0172323845,
-0.0246044826,
-0.0050629121,
-0.0467032902,
0.038661588,
0.024103649,
0.0123152751,
-0.0439990163,
-0.0262433179,
-0.0270383563,
0.0043656109,
-0.0356018916,
-0.0009965275,
-0.0489808805,
-0.0062854514,
-0.0504073985,
0.0134202642,
0.0075589493,
0.0781233981,
-0.0028633208,
-0.0330374576,
0.0264229309,
-0.0533721335,
-0.0603898428,
0.0635191053,
0.0270776581,
0.0314520337,
0.0853898972,
-0.0139116645,
0.0018205069,
-0.0148127461,
-0.0408656299,
0.0007783661,
-0.0674910173,
0.0188354123,
0.0108354893,
0.019924501,
-0.0040110303,
-0.0079175942,
-0.0583760403,
-0.0415111333,
0.027402252,
0.0629947484,
0.008412363,
0.0119316839,
0.0316270441,
0.0013267309,
-0.0472066179,
0.0509468615,
0.0452892594,
-0.0341682397,
-0.0409845039,
-0.0646122098,
0.0327834338,
-0.0156064676,
-0.0076382183,
-0.0040634195,
-0.0345831774,
-0.0202093907,
-0.013867083,
0.0132183926,
0.0491008535,
0.0016180717,
-0.0095474059,
0.0463270545,
-0.0074492232,
-0.0782755315,
0.0330098867,
-0.0106044756,
-0.0020989159,
-0.0428028628,
-0.029947117,
0.020682836,
0.0039653778,
-0.0329452641,
-0.0134496316,
-0.0569844432,
-0.0125241019,
-0.0380762219,
-0.0262695681,
-0.0622300096,
-0.0019204736,
0.0179273635,
0.0681230798,
-0.0192869455,
-0.0252085645,
0.0814260989,
0.0120373173,
-0.0325294547,
-0.0646626055,
0.0204630774,
-0.0405245051,
0.0175557248,
-0.0197191685,
0.0421947725,
-0.0122574363,
-0.0509468466,
-0.0173465628,
0.0332920142,
0.0513947532,
-0.0446480066,
0.0407134667,
0.0032444168,
-0.0060798577,
-0.0184914544,
-0.0602356307,
-0.0081182569,
0.0170925334,
0.0214647818,
-0.0073068696,
0.0360054299,
0.0143503724,
-0.0580837354,
0.0204707794,
0.0454223417,
0.0448684767,
-0.0224612784,
0.000382756,
0.0153995985,
0.0157099515,
0.0303710792,
0.0313455686,
-0.0380503163,
-0.0718676224,
0.010267281,
-0.0046093194,
-0.032643348,
-0.0729834884,
0.0567220189,
0.020626694,
0.0817714706,
-0.0194275398,
-0.0551739708,
-0.0326213315,
0.0452883467,
-0.0181969404,
-0.0697770044,
0.072686851,
0.0061024814,
-0.0857292563,
-0.0387214944,
-0.0426481329,
0.0317652114,
0.0287587233,
0.0328487605,
-0.0669252127,
0.0034145799,
0.0057418738,
0.0388518423,
0.048606433,
0.0095953476,
0.003586289,
-0.1078521982,
0.0002312792,
0.0155364359,
-0.0210398734,
-0.0776408985,
-0.0685545951,
-0.0182037316,
-0.0576069094,
0.0378228016,
0.01514987,
0.0248012133,
-0.0033130408,
-0.0146378921,
0.0383491367,
-0.0708782151,
-0.04264649,
-0.0421201922,
-0.0352449603,
0.0279324055,
0.0301600955,
-0.0084694531,
-0.0338693075,
0.0009448277,
-0.0601760074,
-0.0343009755,
0.0097162407,
0.0538895577,
0.0069482336,
-0.0010430876,
0.0058171521,
-0.0209855083,
-0.0122794202,
0.0220145769,
-0.0219414104,
0.0023726495,
-0.0074490127,
0.0233810861,
-0.0246204641,
-0.0360187851,
-0.0139108831,
0.049184408,
-0.0061367033,
-0.0287565496,
-0.0038741906,
-0.0499223173,
0.0161447991,
-0.0814241394,
-0.0591915175,
0.0418751054,
-0.029914137,
0.008160919,
-0.0512316674,
-0.0497979335,
-0.0426791571,
0.0301088132,
-0.0021533896,
0.0256085638,
-0.0186769124,
-0.0167447962,
0.0226461627,
-0.015648691,
-0.0402071998,
0.0068884259,
-0.043645829,
0.0184853878,
0.0155288894,
-0.0240768362,
-0.0039181439,
-0.0559822954,
0.0034368015,
-0.0573835894,
-0.0336125121,
-0.0040064403,
0.0144449351,
0.0620774403,
-0.0158534981,
-0.039170213,
0.0322926156,
0.0097623197,
-0.0330614448,
0.0114345374,
0.0257482175,
-0.0244475361,
-0.0451177508,
0.0434405431,
-0.0519213118,
0.0011201878,
-0.0367482677,
0.036622759,
0.0033204465,
-0.047812514,
0.0172990151,
0.0591231994,
0.0318512805,
0.0009836265,
0.017968595,
-0.059814699,
0.0281130653,
-0.0396284238,
-0.0235621762,
-0.0237020273,
0.0054944516,
0.0247540753,
-0.0553482361,
-0.0056968736,
0.0680476427,
0.0222826228,
0.011766755,
-0.0656642988,
0.0118050613,
0.0166937727,
0.0030390476,
0.0023072832,
0.0355528817,
-0.0076864487,
0.015140133,
0.0212286804,
0.0859670043,
-0.0573012829,
-0.0043868893,
0.0091293985,
0.0173235368,
0.0043893298,
0.0248315521,
-0.0563319214,
0.0268756077,
-0.0272633284,
-0.0441723578,
0.0548581742,
-0.0627108216,
0.0752638355,
0.0363894105,
-0.0054987222,
-0.0347882174,
-0.0207674131,
0.0515875705,
-0.0077939867,
0.0037588554,
0.0091583142,
-0.0086824847,
0.0333654135,
0.0745276809,
-0.0252359733,
0.0318156406,
-0.0387758315,
-0.0320001505,
-0.0060944222,
0.0047063814,
0.0538366362,
0.0310500991,
-0.0305110924,
-0.0191129576,
-0.0025391621,
-0.0249064583,
0.0172474999,
-0.0059463372,
0.0098121092,
0.0023289255,
0.0406987555,
0.0903648138,
-0.0087748608,
0.0324865542,
-0.031593062,
-0.0425574295,
-0.021923054,
-0.0011507996,
0.0070524304,
-5.903894663e-33,
-0.0156794041,
0.0621244349,
-0.0265074745,
-0.041117195,
-0.0111690853,
0.0107899122,
-0.0029941439,
-0.0222284235,
-0.0452815928,
0.0061275586,
-0.0123243909,
-0.0064977324,
0.0148234488,
0.0008982271,
-0.002811146,
-0.0030593311,
0.0411151573,
0.0195046756,
-0.0446080007,
0.0226412751,
0.0784216151,
0.0280028246,
0.048141297,
0.0209375434,
0.0282378793,
-0.0026363411,
0.0110350009,
-0.0027005677,
0.0468603522,
0.05595636,
0.0112771876,
0.0714880154,
0.0168689899,
-0.0353283286,
-0.0228301436,
-0.0466015078,
-0.0429430045,
-0.0323157944,
-0.0225158632,
0.0263467953,
0.0030797939,
-0.0529786013,
0.0464678034,
-0.0162725057,
-0.0020437941,
-0.0036191752,
0.033632759,
-0.0101726223,
-0.0454616994,
-0.0560070239,
-0.0202758871,
0.0229084343,
-0.0173317045,
0.013326508,
0.0669525415,
0.0884632915,
0.0348265395,
0.0306967404,
-0.0471115969,
0.0520171933,
-0.0420169123,
0.0771321878,
0.017594995,
-0.0208804272,
-0.0213980898,
0.0396270715,
-0.0150776887,
0.0068655354,
0.048258286,
0.0119926464,
0.0518835783,
-0.0251780376,
0.0408264101,
0.0829869211,
0.0338124186,
-0.0486176088,
-0.0850669816,
0.0739408135,
-0.013546613,
0.032121677,
0.0113387601,
0.0597061962,
-0.01241179,
-0.0441310667,
-0.0628387481,
-0.0137926126,
-0.0299124587,
-0.0382394418,
0.0171825197,
0.0331320912,
-0.0213553458,
-0.0213634539,
0.081142731,
-0.0198010448,
0.0173913408,
0.0263939928,
-0.0321866311,
-0.0005904904,
0.0057542901,
0.0525774583,
0.002618673,
-0.0323722214,
0.0103145158,
-0.0262105148,
-0.0465185083,
-0.0160276424,
0.0430025235,
0.0030368099,
-0.0396684073,
-0.0040936335,
-0.0189768076,
-0.0163572542,
-0.0029726878,
0.0335666202,
0.0031674553,
0.0092720557,
0.0003176924,
0.1029013023,
0.0366887376,
0.0129882712,
-0.0436986051,
-0.0560826734,
0.0569285378,
0.0271637272,
0.0003157938,
0.025914954,
-0.0406371579,
-0.009624023,
0.0088817514,
-0.0421277918,
-0.0225298814,
0.0273623653,
2.432e-7,
0.0452259034,
0.0249268636,
0.0207170863,
0.0054730778,
-0.0128132245,
0.0029409104,
-0.0327802151,
0.0265103411,
0.0118417926,
-0.0406184271,
-0.0026042778,
0.0187476259,
0.0246126987,
0.054257337,
-0.0863807648,
-0.0191539582,
-0.0079554031,
-0.011112445,
-0.0249197446,
-0.0107688457,
0.0520320311,
0.0994245186,
-0.036184404,
0.0427080691,
-0.0215866696,
-0.0564713031,
0.0814636946,
-0.0109526757,
-0.0537022315,
0.0268421005,
0.0275068395,
0.031903591,
0.0099766366,
0.0022132914,
-0.0578199551,
0.0384542458,
0.0681395829,
0.028756626,
0.0047977506,
-0.0371252075,
0.0224299524,
0.0199247785,
-0.0256956499,
-0.0154076824,
0.084671393,
0.0218949057,
-0.0061971983,
0.0465066694,
-0.0289644916,
0.0247386266,
0.0901922807,
-0.0159709547,
-0.0690644234,
0.0272813905,
0.0363333523,
0.0434695221,
-0.0018064225,
-0.0427514352,
0.0008886477,
-0.0025812625,
-0.0212463085,
-0.0222749896,
-0.0191316046,
-0.0084097153,
-0.0032919939,
-0.0234161876,
0.0143230092,
1.903659148e-34,
0.0707762241,
-0.0194202513,
0.0184189659,
-0.0063283392,
0.033653073,
-0.0642043948,
-0.0081855636,
-0.0052621146,
-0.0184442941,
-0.0773462951,
-0.0185899902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00911v1 | Deep Image-to-Recipe Translation | 2024-07-01T02:33:07 | 2024-07-01T02:33:07 | Jiangqin Ma, Bilal Mawji, Franz Williams | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The modern saying, "You Are What You Eat" resonates on a profound level,
reflecting the intricate connection between our identities and the food we
consume. Our project, Deep Image-to-Recipe Translation, is an intersection of
computer vision and natural language generation that aims to bridge the gap
between cherished food memories and the art of culinary creation. Our primary
objective involves predicting ingredients from a given food image. For this
task, we first develop a custom convolutional network and then compare its
performance to a model that leverages transfer learning. We pursue an
additional goal of generating a comprehensive set of recipe steps from a list
of ingredients. We frame this process as a sequence-to-sequence task and
develop a recurrent neural network that utilizes pre-trained word embeddings.
We address several challenges of deep learning including imbalanced datasets,
data cleaning, overfitting, and hyperparameter selection. Our approach
emphasizes the importance of metrics such as Intersection over Union (IoU) and
F1 score in scenarios where accuracy alone might be misleading. For our recipe
prediction model, we employ perplexity, a commonly used and important metric
for language models. We find that transfer learning via pre-trained ResNet-50
weights and GloVe embeddings provide an exceptional boost to model performance,
especially when considering training resource constraints. Although we have
made progress on the image-to-recipe translation, there is an opportunity for
future exploration with advancements in model architectures, dataset
scalability, and enhanced user interaction. | Deep Image-to-Recipe Translation: The modern saying, "You Are What You Eat" resonates on a profound level,
reflecting the intricate connection between our identities and the food we
consume. Our project, Deep Image-to-Recipe Translation, is an intersection of
computer vision and natural language generation that aims to bridge the gap
between cherished food memories and the art of culinary creation. Our primary
objective involves predicting ingredients from a given food image. For this
task, we first develop a custom convolutional network and then compare its
performance to a model that leverages transfer learning. We pursue an
additional goal of generating a comprehensive set of recipe steps from a list
of ingredients. We frame this process as a sequence-to-sequence task and
develop a recurrent neural network that utilizes pre-trained word embeddings.
We address several challenges of deep learning including imbalanced datasets,
data cleaning, overfitting, and hyperparameter selection. Our approach
emphasizes the importance of metrics such as Intersection over Union (IoU) and
F1 score in scenarios where accuracy alone might be misleading. For our recipe
prediction model, we employ perplexity, a commonly used and important metric
for language models. We find that transfer learning via pre-trained ResNet-50
weights and GloVe embeddings provide an exceptional boost to model performance,
especially when considering training resource constraints. Although we have
made progress on the image-to-recipe translation, there is an opportunity for
future exploration with advancements in model architectures, dataset
scalability, and enhanced user interaction. | [
0.0023033503,
0.092698738,
0.0069516194,
0.0163204633,
-0.0012980615,
0.0023657535,
-0.0296562538,
0.0152217234,
-0.0023571155,
-0.0315869227,
-0.0116278781,
-0.0291722957,
0.0038646779,
0.0618289486,
-0.0232137274,
-0.0454551987,
0.0202153903,
0.0310903639,
-0.0479015782,
0.0239395089,
-0.0087475246,
0.0124470945,
0.0175553076,
0.0249530263,
-0.0476115271,
0.030895276,
0.003567588,
0.0485075302,
0.0006132383,
-0.0469442084,
-0.0069446694,
0.0564624965,
0.0021937734,
0.0066734734,
0.0000020632,
0.0062083346,
0.0082989363,
-0.0084064696,
-0.0139875077,
0.0036116487,
0.0197185203,
-0.0075873295,
-0.015926091,
-0.00901144,
-0.038439136,
0.0138405468,
0.0679160878,
0.0593224242,
0.0126266377,
0.0824880078,
-0.0099355923,
-0.1089266986,
-0.0327847786,
-0.0120631121,
0.0399343036,
0.0303558111,
0.0015450383,
-0.036288064,
-0.0332433321,
-0.0566747338,
-0.0201732796,
0.0460007265,
0.0532017089,
-0.0009121841,
-0.0279019363,
0.0366251804,
-0.0017382562,
-0.0434315465,
0.0030758106,
0.0947921053,
-0.0572991222,
0.0170267224,
-0.0298087448,
-0.0104439138,
-0.0205125269,
-0.0229312144,
-0.0189623013,
-0.0436993428,
0.0199758392,
0.0575739555,
-0.0725583956,
0.0005673544,
0.0518215224,
0.0101013137,
0.0012758981,
0.0210682321,
0.0271964595,
0.008015262,
-0.0197257679,
0.0246014856,
-0.0051793405,
-0.0723094568,
0.0001862736,
0.0207402837,
0.0043747439,
0.0213554986,
-0.0069675711,
-0.0104703903,
-0.014048351,
0.017013628,
0.0302970037,
0.0333504155,
-0.0416467376,
0.0124456855,
-0.0228850693,
0.0284304433,
-0.0124364952,
0.0328349769,
-0.0984363183,
0.0398699827,
-0.053804718,
-0.0055418676,
-0.0166012924,
-0.0107638342,
-0.0453443639,
-0.0317187198,
-0.0239489712,
-0.0363832414,
-0.0024370612,
-0.0115707247,
0.0104341554,
0.0912611634,
-0.0399510711,
0.0291849542,
-0.0636572838,
0.0632486269,
-0.0054496895,
0.01400958,
0.0242674667,
0.0096366983,
-0.0328204557,
-0.0190131068,
0.0206784997,
0.0003318962,
0.0408810563,
0.037353415,
-0.0569141656,
-0.0290849023,
0.0037989561,
-0.0436745994,
-0.0483521223,
-0.0874840617,
0.0299133305,
-0.0631460845,
0.0687353909,
-0.0453716628,
0.0283374712,
-0.0524452925,
0.0306078978,
0.040831428,
-0.0452302694,
0.0839506164,
0.0838430598,
-0.0199385434,
0.0069421241,
0.0307127722,
-0.001630852,
0.006811325,
0.0416927859,
0.0776367113,
0.0062684212,
0.0005887219,
0.0151068196,
-0.0057761823,
0.0007157441,
0.0360949747,
-0.0720427707,
-0.0174868703,
-0.0010640403,
0.0471571088,
-0.0007139561,
0.0383967198,
-0.0075294622,
0.0238339622,
0.1024859548,
0.0386413671,
-0.0020928725,
0.0503879227,
0.0452605709,
0.0233232416,
-0.0249502957,
-0.0228065848,
-0.0228219926,
0.0331827626,
-0.0225783717,
-0.0196061525,
0.0037206174,
0.0140578849,
-0.0423917063,
-0.030436635,
0.0448198691,
-0.0411881506,
0.0675542206,
-0.0138147194,
0.0252979212,
0.0283559747,
-0.0707328096,
0.0078107556,
-0.0317637138,
-0.0640876293,
0.0292691663,
0.0326866917,
0.0395890996,
0.0839160606,
0.0255313125,
0.0105149113,
0.0471379906,
0.0138904825,
0.0062221535,
-0.0004638413,
0.0178085119,
0.0123032946,
0.0569031686,
-0.0410162769,
-0.0645681694,
-0.0121224551,
0.0229249988,
-0.0014853847,
0.0045787524,
0.0390441157,
0.0359858312,
-0.0013973492,
-0.032222148,
0.0234000683,
0.0006783011,
-0.0506310426,
0.0538983308,
0.0221364405,
-0.0203635152,
0.0126679707,
0.0357150994,
0.0209516343,
0.0002732824,
-0.0505896658,
-0.031694036,
0.0221885294,
-0.0184835419,
-0.0323031507,
0.0023362048,
-0.0745738596,
0.0099908998,
-0.002674595,
-0.0459117256,
-0.067144379,
0.0237686802,
-0.0152555192,
-0.0033356908,
-0.0270593408,
-0.0112721613,
0.0546609946,
0.0575782433,
-0.0157931428,
0.0501489528,
-0.0053592627,
-0.0063979616,
-0.0480062589,
-0.0456305817,
-0.0062270011,
-0.0218523368,
0.0221676212,
-0.032239072,
0.0120390411,
0.0491453558,
0.0191688705,
0.0509342737,
-0.0487901978,
-0.0345947184,
-0.0496049263,
0.0194046702,
-0.0292319786,
-0.0313614197,
-0.0168870576,
0.0133716268,
0.0203304719,
-0.0158277862,
-0.033511173,
0.0245064609,
-0.0404734612,
0.0092456453,
0.0064541306,
0.023015948,
0.0130229834,
-0.032599397,
-0.0199899133,
0.0409476534,
0.0411989354,
-0.0099937757,
0.0178017691,
-0.021200683,
-0.0656155944,
-0.0339894593,
0.0155307008,
0.0211339463,
-0.0350508951,
-0.0253327414,
0.0028098072,
0.0028780482,
0.0431288034,
-0.0201684479,
-0.0032356149,
0.0449378006,
-0.0021788992,
-0.0390125737,
-0.0098573882,
-0.0426215492,
0.0142687261,
0.0158811845,
-0.0374020673,
-0.0237551052,
-0.0040123006,
-0.0128808366,
0.0413045101,
-0.0476505533,
-0.0015279922,
0.0075541656,
-0.0530384183,
-0.0200779401,
0.0365382396,
0.0136940451,
0.0440411381,
-0.0212147702,
-0.0524553955,
0.0275815818,
-0.0178081598,
0.036607109,
-0.0117307985,
0.01561209,
0.0088991085,
0.0559530444,
0.0136486897,
0.0527032278,
-0.0124406191,
0.024339119,
-0.0432226136,
0.019075904,
-0.0066524325,
-0.0683795363,
0.0638047382,
-0.0817013532,
-0.0317556262,
-0.0091669038,
-0.0173120536,
-0.0413671322,
-0.003120153,
-0.0234890133,
-0.0137776118,
0.0005160987,
-0.0093709072,
-0.0458830073,
-0.0006873898,
-0.0220105406,
0.0341193788,
0.0265541561,
-0.0182884596,
-0.001966845,
0.022271309,
0.042304188,
0.0105145108,
0.0040688687,
-0.008344505,
0.0203300733,
0.0314295031,
-0.0014627546,
-0.005328224,
-0.0220420547,
0.0541857705,
0.0168222338,
0.0162047315,
-0.0193091556,
0.0326162316,
0.0268481504,
-0.0417286418,
-0.0179092474,
0.0529240146,
0.0093599427,
-0.0632587299,
0.0329970121,
0.0923741087,
-0.0225399584,
0.0169024915,
0.0662075579,
-0.0995703042,
-0.0208242722,
-0.0173477642,
-0.0190832503,
-0.0319244266,
-0.0036641946,
-0.0595576875,
-0.0927945599,
0.0349268727,
0.0052883681,
-0.083109051,
-0.0788170621,
-0.0079192678,
-0.0473021306,
0.0098019307,
0.031804882,
-0.0442534201,
-0.0124716545,
-0.0047701565,
0.0119804163,
0.0276074205,
-0.0484666228,
0.0177172646,
-0.0731402114,
-0.0114523619,
0.0662894845,
0.045772817,
0.0014181925,
-0.0366841219,
-0.000454625,
0.0213895254,
0.0252634082,
-0.0008902002,
0.063135013,
0.0138713317,
-0.0246880185,
0.0259618536,
0.0185165256,
-0.0430174582,
-0.0336607806,
-0.0286949035,
0.0554698408,
0.0101801809,
-0.0192855,
-0.0134264547,
-0.0440908596,
0.0278221481,
0.0320163369,
0.0016947777,
0.0105791669,
-0.0266586095,
-0.0189292021,
-0.039519418,
-0.0635867938,
0.0122442655,
0.0736193508,
-0.0724920332,
-0.0385864414,
-0.0763471052,
0.0016551689,
0.00452381,
0.0570620559,
0.0252883434,
-0.0083125327,
-0.0233984366,
0.0470076986,
-0.0463935845,
0.0273216758,
-0.0440589935,
0.0304225646,
-0.0477534197,
0.0210421421,
0.0187942367,
-0.042127531,
-0.0035443988,
0.0153825255,
-0.1033515185,
-0.0360263363,
-0.0225315653,
0.0862186253,
0.0097525259,
0.0680999234,
0.0125956498,
-0.042319715,
0.0383938588,
0.0258471016,
0.0167757068,
-0.0426322371,
0.005789272,
-0.0466573574,
0.0148815019,
0.0250583999,
-0.0415458009,
0.0291643422,
0.0222745538,
0.0231365375,
-0.0033151899,
-0.0607262291,
0.02728731,
-0.0501610711,
0.0250909366,
-0.0142166121,
0.0322548561,
-0.031739179,
0.043073684,
0.0007562323,
-0.0064373109,
-0.0685356036,
-0.0452403016,
0.0493836068,
0.0076667098,
-0.034147758,
-0.0416165479,
0.0095017524,
0.024746716,
-0.0374871306,
-0.0335809626,
-0.0162559077,
0.0265356861,
0.0198035408,
0.0190804191,
-0.0038664357,
0.0479508415,
-0.0232475121,
0.0164183304,
-0.0270925499,
0.0248903148,
0.0051904046,
0.0441404358,
-0.0768283531,
0.0268753953,
-0.001440017,
-0.0374380648,
-0.0178911276,
-0.0431329496,
0.0452965461,
-0.0805814713,
0.0629329458,
-0.0000653856,
-0.0037806069,
-0.041996181,
0.0781383738,
-0.0080589922,
-0.0236021429,
0.0430457108,
-0.0034186628,
0.0180419739,
0.0265321005,
0.0672071204,
-0.0244740602,
0.0514970832,
0.0304565709,
-0.0009379092,
-0.0069466196,
0.0072825947,
0.0363642313,
-0.0174441673,
-0.0046527116,
-0.0268719066,
-0.0283855405,
-0.0662653819,
0.0160272773,
-0.0022489878,
0.0117452331,
0.0193746369,
0.0449512564,
0.0462494753,
-0.0139368437,
0.0196857434,
0.0055986107,
0.0190148931,
-0.0040659131,
-0.0304743759,
-0.0061813518,
-6.519160896e-33,
0.0158156715,
-0.0341178998,
0.0245002173,
0.0104181664,
-0.0189411771,
-0.0062078321,
-0.0592511669,
-0.0133164972,
0.0315810665,
0.0368863195,
0.0327189714,
-0.0104468558,
0.0181552526,
0.0401961319,
-0.0004898527,
-0.0471767262,
0.0464000702,
0.0371973179,
0.0038276487,
0.004887539,
0.0034999051,
0.0384028815,
0.0524900742,
-0.0615225062,
-0.0424071811,
0.0102112005,
0.0164909102,
-0.0057197115,
0.0293734223,
0.0077829491,
-0.0413459241,
0.0457699001,
-0.0087769656,
-0.0357021801,
-0.0103458054,
-0.005094829,
-0.0417545177,
-0.0361324847,
-0.0635381266,
0.0008521845,
-0.0476701222,
-0.0385307558,
0.0316169821,
0.0050839991,
0.0027390164,
0.0291613042,
0.0450887345,
-0.0213592388,
-0.0413583703,
-0.0204631686,
-0.0574793778,
0.0030194917,
0.0002642933,
-0.0418089777,
0.055858884,
0.0387707464,
0.0345208719,
-0.0238636173,
-0.0281801503,
0.0120115746,
-0.0265918374,
0.0013911525,
0.0648271218,
0.0522938333,
-0.0037433184,
0.0353827886,
0.0113187116,
-0.0119709941,
0.010426715,
-0.0108733755,
0.0098424014,
0.0823621228,
0.0674909204,
0.0317415856,
0.060645856,
-0.0334738567,
-0.0228541438,
0.0130305151,
-0.0281879846,
-0.0277129523,
-0.0318683833,
0.0359180905,
0.0469725505,
-0.0067224335,
-0.0400908627,
-0.0360857844,
-0.013807727,
-0.024251245,
0.0157656725,
0.0395983234,
-0.0465688705,
0.0068925899,
0.0226674527,
0.0222531483,
0.0067274952,
-0.0459155515,
-0.0044947388,
-0.035954725,
-0.0118156271,
-0.0027383436,
-0.0631257519,
-0.0370422862,
0.0334848501,
0.0030973831,
0.0094276303,
-0.0144029604,
0.0220993869,
0.0558422394,
-0.005292519,
-0.0100614913,
-0.0410217494,
-0.0042391289,
0.0218323618,
0.0084125586,
0.0208452158,
0.0061782477,
-0.0211228617,
0.0494255163,
0.0019480898,
-0.0094520031,
-0.0214222372,
-0.0047954791,
0.083929345,
-0.0224703699,
-0.0405786447,
-0.0001940618,
-0.0416908972,
-0.0223275349,
0.0646824688,
-0.0803773552,
-0.010820413,
0.0221812874,
2.813e-7,
0.0523145422,
0.000586449,
0.0307283252,
-0.0220056679,
-0.0316059068,
0.0294289589,
0.0251199417,
0.0481409281,
-0.0500340089,
0.007940108,
0.057317283,
0.0214838609,
0.0412262939,
0.0461785346,
0.0047014784,
-0.0024848967,
-0.0546053685,
0.0517048426,
-0.0250950903,
-0.0144152278,
0.0299722869,
0.072148554,
0.0441633947,
-0.0345211886,
0.021211585,
-0.0069571757,
0.0686976016,
-0.06273444,
0.0479567423,
-0.0421253778,
-0.0006178902,
0.0292316657,
0.0161986612,
-0.0211858265,
-0.048982311,
-0.0500921458,
0.0802231804,
0.0186563693,
-0.035274677,
-0.0326122493,
-0.0234231912,
0.0167248659,
0.0012683435,
-0.0528484136,
0.0459376909,
-0.10036847,
0.0258471295,
0.0216974895,
-0.0192562882,
0.0354501866,
0.0695477203,
0.017678706,
0.0331902429,
0.017633101,
0.0596796796,
0.0196997114,
-0.0003377993,
-0.0658233315,
-0.0334894806,
-0.037329454,
-0.0245255437,
0.0290479269,
-0.0247616507,
-0.0226103049,
-0.0469400585,
-0.0113897249,
-0.0491558686,
2.206294071e-34,
0.0211116578,
-0.0037645779,
0.01487491,
-0.0170014314,
0.0199756604,
0.0078304401,
-0.0366849154,
-0.0182140134,
-0.0024588089,
-0.053057503,
-0.034408737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00908v1 | FineSurE: Fine-grained Summarization Evaluation using LLMs | 2024-07-01T02:20:28 | 2024-07-01T02:20:28 | Hwanjun Song, Hang Su, Igor Shalyminov, Jason Cai, Saab Mansour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automated evaluation is crucial for streamlining text summarization
benchmarking and model development, given the costly and time-consuming nature
of human evaluation. Traditional methods like ROUGE do not correlate well with
human judgment, while recently proposed LLM-based metrics provide only
summary-level assessment using Likert-scale scores. This limits deeper model
analysis, e.g., we can only assign one hallucination score at the summary
level, while at the sentence level, we can count sentences containing
hallucinations. To remedy those limitations, we propose FineSurE, a
fine-grained evaluator specifically tailored for the summarization task using
large language models (LLMs). It also employs completeness and conciseness
criteria, in addition to faithfulness, enabling multi-dimensional assessment.
We compare various open-source and proprietary LLMs as backbones for FineSurE.
In addition, we conduct extensive benchmarking of FineSurE against SOTA methods
including NLI-, QA-, and LLM-based methods, showing improved performance
especially on the completeness and conciseness dimensions. The code is
available at https://github.com/DISL-Lab/FineSurE-ACL24. | FineSurE: Fine-grained Summarization Evaluation using LLMs: Automated evaluation is crucial for streamlining text summarization
benchmarking and model development, given the costly and time-consuming nature
of human evaluation. Traditional methods like ROUGE do not correlate well with
human judgment, while recently proposed LLM-based metrics provide only
summary-level assessment using Likert-scale scores. This limits deeper model
analysis, e.g., we can only assign one hallucination score at the summary
level, while at the sentence level, we can count sentences containing
hallucinations. To remedy those limitations, we propose FineSurE, a
fine-grained evaluator specifically tailored for the summarization task using
large language models (LLMs). It also employs completeness and conciseness
criteria, in addition to faithfulness, enabling multi-dimensional assessment.
We compare various open-source and proprietary LLMs as backbones for FineSurE.
In addition, we conduct extensive benchmarking of FineSurE against SOTA methods
including NLI-, QA-, and LLM-based methods, showing improved performance
especially on the completeness and conciseness dimensions. The code is
available at https://github.com/DISL-Lab/FineSurE-ACL24. | [
0.0246960782,
0.009046522,
0.0106936926,
0.0191384181,
-0.0448191129,
0.0213615317,
-0.0343880169,
-0.0127755683,
0.0072009498,
-0.0486428402,
-0.0268208813,
-0.012434056,
0.0360886119,
-0.0173493456,
-0.00198364,
-0.0663430616,
0.0221433751,
-0.0352117307,
-0.0033807762,
0.0029885452,
0.0263608806,
-0.0124593703,
0.0277456678,
0.0441492908,
0.0468080938,
-0.0016142088,
0.02277904,
0.0077466969,
0.0406418554,
-0.0023046718,
-0.0081513999,
0.0342668705,
0.0017920256,
0.021479506,
0.0000023091,
-0.0694351494,
-0.0176259708,
0.0020317959,
0.0446356982,
0.0675342306,
0.0687197521,
-0.0059118117,
0.0250755325,
0.0068152132,
-0.0026297362,
0.0352626853,
-0.0146953622,
0.0783783719,
0.0881176069,
0.0402718559,
-0.0148048038,
-0.0620467253,
0.0396203026,
-0.0025620901,
-0.0072850469,
-0.0087977126,
0.0256578568,
0.0491325036,
0.0202988554,
-0.022372948,
0.0086310199,
0.0385760218,
0.0077979625,
0.0229113828,
0.0011690854,
-0.0085018342,
-0.0784551799,
-0.0204787273,
0.0253382176,
0.06265039,
-0.0023641826,
-0.0248136763,
0.0245236307,
0.0152666904,
0.0039461539,
-0.0093223024,
-0.0744102001,
0.027689103,
-0.0007433239,
0.0364529714,
0.0198777243,
0.050980363,
0.0044360822,
0.02851413,
-0.0141616883,
0.0514031164,
0.0137314862,
-0.0360378399,
0.0059507797,
-0.0052725039,
-0.0391571522,
-0.0414669327,
0.0140005853,
0.0020364949,
-0.0227865335,
-0.0405911021,
-0.0393101349,
-0.0252983049,
0.0556405708,
-0.0596298017,
0.0055670943,
0.0006853099,
0.0026168888,
0.040625751,
-0.012317406,
0.0464279167,
0.0570311435,
0.0563773215,
-0.0674648657,
0.009731953,
-0.0016059938,
0.0219605453,
-0.0522470362,
0.0341924727,
-0.0377987921,
-0.0445962511,
-0.0509512872,
-0.0187578388,
-0.0191727579,
0.0042634308,
-0.0026277343,
0.0013767085,
0.0565005876,
0.0121382596,
0.0063648885,
-0.0100724706,
-0.0524678081,
-0.0430173092,
0.0158643201,
0.014850419,
-0.0137505019,
0.0334082507,
-0.00880362,
0.000212627,
0.0158462152,
0.0124850711,
0.0006063696,
-0.0525766797,
-0.0352930613,
-0.0207760613,
-0.01852745,
-0.0733694658,
-0.0420295149,
-0.0730142072,
-0.0242555682,
0.0046152468,
0.0049261362,
-0.011230235,
0.0186180063,
0.0054251296,
-0.0460667461,
0.0227440801,
-0.0257478561,
0.0232516546,
0.0090971645,
0.0439533591,
0.0341572687,
0.0482915565,
0.0409509353,
0.0911482349,
0.0498795621,
-0.0002787128,
0.0291471966,
0.0425440036,
-0.0246212799,
0.0230586119,
-0.0217631869,
-0.0123778181,
-0.0178443585,
-0.0054688067,
0.0180346165,
0.0801562145,
-0.027297128,
0.0278585833,
0.0682509243,
0.0741832927,
0.0108330846,
-0.012001683,
0.0402828343,
0.0318883546,
0.0528336428,
0.0639878958,
-0.0176141337,
0.0153556895,
-0.0685990304,
0.04794994,
0.1167799309,
0.0314728916,
-0.0069349073,
-0.0637455955,
-0.0263105799,
0.010952401,
0.0136019075,
0.0144554563,
0.0003672132,
-0.0007479768,
-0.0552253611,
0.0285297669,
0.031196624,
-0.0727031156,
0.0170072168,
-0.0299826916,
0.0098337214,
0.0954955667,
0.0756457672,
-0.0446942523,
0.0191358645,
-0.0019571017,
0.0017992234,
0.0419602022,
0.0254346821,
0.0063062008,
-0.0037657409,
-0.0596398786,
0.006754111,
-0.0088263378,
0.0303050708,
-0.0299744532,
-0.0265318323,
-0.0268466547,
0.0148548428,
-0.0487953126,
-0.0847292021,
0.0386227518,
0.0014181641,
-0.0230783112,
-0.0498817191,
-0.0242326744,
0.0208509732,
0.0146769965,
-0.0260183979,
0.0303743444,
0.0221588518,
-0.0543869659,
-0.0118401749,
-0.0189978126,
-0.0215290356,
-0.0037412115,
0.0144502297,
-0.0347517394,
0.0246011391,
0.0227191541,
-0.0019045189,
-0.0288160797,
0.0009200903,
-0.0463605672,
-0.0158210043,
-0.0539879911,
0.0545126908,
-0.0178271029,
0.0431835912,
-0.0451889075,
0.081006974,
-0.0189513825,
0.0358776934,
0.0350854769,
-0.0321049616,
0.0041563893,
0.0104097649,
-0.0592646971,
-0.0391800553,
-0.0056543094,
0.0393407717,
0.0281633399,
0.0070747384,
-0.0315057077,
-0.0496193841,
-0.1026429087,
0.0204412453,
-0.0247747824,
0.0043642572,
0.042847801,
0.0153589463,
-0.0121941781,
0.0489450879,
-0.0210139956,
-0.0334076174,
0.0311695468,
0.0085843904,
-0.0035035722,
-0.0168151781,
-0.003805523,
-0.0646143258,
-0.0082869427,
0.0063414001,
0.0779773891,
-0.0094395112,
-0.0249717701,
-0.0300752576,
0.0503944196,
-0.034017913,
-0.051536493,
0.0193908848,
-0.034644831,
-0.0245733224,
0.0010370912,
0.0641660914,
0.0394344889,
0.0419186316,
0.0081733605,
0.0514991656,
-0.0353750065,
-0.0019951335,
-0.0272442158,
0.0004604149,
0.0187770277,
-0.0081469184,
-0.0725942776,
0.0492037423,
0.0340175107,
0.0315455608,
0.0193387792,
-0.0503517315,
0.0448215082,
-0.0419334061,
-0.0290936418,
-0.0217348989,
-0.0008382453,
0.0012680988,
0.0350772664,
-0.0277782809,
-0.0058274148,
0.0460528657,
-0.0552621186,
0.0154201696,
-0.0303603336,
-0.0198860914,
-0.0499919504,
0.0583394766,
0.0413906612,
0.0364755839,
-0.0157874357,
0.0088996803,
-0.0115985088,
-0.0309035387,
0.0287073441,
-0.049918782,
0.0837994218,
-0.0422678515,
0.0079799835,
-0.0126545466,
0.0296692532,
-0.0021113469,
-0.0421143249,
-0.0293874778,
0.0139850145,
0.0221683588,
0.0127520934,
-0.0382810757,
0.0523291342,
0.0304077435,
0.0270287246,
-0.0567645989,
-0.0180377048,
-0.0063295271,
0.0422169268,
0.0653474703,
-0.0114473188,
0.05015653,
-0.0468738079,
0.0481261201,
0.0469915532,
-0.0101054115,
0.0160286743,
0.0043306639,
-0.0018150973,
0.0249044299,
-0.0661814585,
0.0085107069,
0.0040851231,
0.082625024,
-0.0412560366,
-0.0156254843,
0.1333948374,
0.0354936123,
-0.028394714,
0.0000906172,
-0.0291398596,
0.0457371771,
0.0047260579,
-0.0171487126,
-0.0536230244,
-0.0190349855,
0.009868565,
0.0360410474,
0.0016383928,
-0.0224009585,
0.0055733039,
-0.0661697984,
0.0374585912,
0.0280347876,
-0.0445136875,
-0.0242566429,
-0.0257674493,
0.0264282711,
-0.0084192278,
0.0193861388,
0.0185628105,
-0.0340852961,
-0.0140617676,
-0.0252875928,
-0.0889234841,
0.0063202083,
0.0350630544,
-0.0440805592,
0.0225717574,
0.0721331909,
0.0304902326,
0.0019341339,
-0.0269827656,
0.0275662839,
-0.0519700497,
-0.0272782221,
0.0093749966,
0.0729685128,
0.0322706737,
0.0223460943,
-0.0383465178,
0.0432385355,
0.0112862485,
-0.0359458067,
0.0113271605,
0.019884469,
-0.0077711549,
-0.0504235402,
-0.0288693514,
0.0679052696,
-0.0530835427,
0.0937870219,
0.0605651215,
-0.01551886,
-0.0583440214,
-0.0321898088,
-0.0030438867,
-0.0528033748,
-0.0792497844,
0.0075960429,
-0.0030937656,
-0.0278306529,
-0.0854453668,
-0.0322051235,
0.0132956924,
-0.0509401038,
-0.0121996785,
0.026040744,
-0.0290780533,
0.0112566091,
-0.021239968,
0.0137373637,
-0.0255805571,
0.0028874481,
-0.0298543759,
0.014350662,
0.0531525128,
-0.0152232843,
-0.0245915502,
0.0402864777,
-0.0954162776,
-0.0357050747,
-0.0019728614,
0.0338485911,
0.016915489,
0.0038401266,
-0.0083727222,
-0.0345868245,
0.0537292212,
0.0442452915,
0.0032109166,
0.0400988422,
0.003265426,
0.0324288607,
-0.0101444265,
0.0233654045,
-0.0388391539,
0.0189026389,
-0.0157279912,
0.055973433,
0.0006013524,
-0.0508342944,
0.0121582365,
0.0383550599,
-0.011478601,
-0.0147160245,
-0.0098678237,
-0.0063598556,
-0.0505856723,
-0.0320684351,
-0.0389142595,
-0.02491761,
0.0136256088,
0.0103423446,
0.00564849,
-0.0072116083,
0.0277901627,
-0.0153230987,
-0.0089108506,
-0.0588077493,
-0.0088548809,
-0.0559601635,
-0.0402399264,
-0.0273193773,
-0.0274306312,
-0.0566212945,
-0.0311465822,
-0.0429991111,
-0.005807275,
-0.0072335675,
0.0285164993,
-0.0123975109,
-0.0021521475,
-0.0131243365,
0.0757187605,
-0.0518247001,
-0.0195220243,
-0.0656987503,
0.0281637739,
0.0538601242,
-0.0176319145,
0.0986605808,
0.0028064766,
0.0025582183,
-0.0243694186,
0.0363268815,
0.0474638231,
0.0016486102,
-0.0648513138,
0.0236026067,
-0.003315992,
-0.0046231719,
0.0894360393,
-0.0616800562,
0.0008846056,
0.0341535322,
-0.0420877486,
-0.0488622189,
-0.0745456517,
-0.0586197488,
0.023185188,
-0.0176628176,
-0.0444518887,
-0.0845422447,
-0.0106469328,
0.0324430987,
0.0291144494,
-0.0155029213,
-0.0186597444,
0.0141594289,
0.019819675,
-0.0033938636,
-0.0023297151,
-0.0291182287,
-0.0347125493,
0.011998632,
-0.0024966884,
0.0162574053,
-6.785632241e-33,
-0.0302657541,
-0.0013709711,
-0.0100512467,
0.0066309744,
-0.0665312409,
-0.0255379472,
-0.0440243334,
0.0118064312,
0.0360930711,
-0.0089679314,
0.0039877305,
-0.0156977996,
0.0109617729,
0.027668165,
0.0085934298,
0.006546976,
0.0403264053,
0.0248093884,
-0.0601202101,
0.0309308488,
-0.0193843637,
-0.0062379902,
0.0137373554,
-0.025902817,
0.0330737084,
-0.0236157477,
-0.042590525,
-0.0288322195,
0.0163054168,
0.0024215346,
-0.0312942415,
0.0203317311,
0.0307709295,
-0.0135201234,
-0.0301981606,
-0.0053704442,
-0.0611246377,
-0.0166050848,
0.0410473235,
-0.0295230597,
-0.0398563184,
-0.0382384434,
0.0607222952,
-0.0095526418,
0.002277337,
-0.0252496582,
0.0437389985,
-0.0639279261,
-0.0133182872,
-0.0501905791,
-0.0528207943,
0.0238333885,
-0.024431061,
-0.0401045084,
0.0134447254,
0.0403526574,
-0.0240666904,
0.0321826823,
-0.0367629305,
0.0294269919,
0.0215966888,
0.0203135516,
0.0274770167,
-0.0044295946,
0.0172731914,
0.0767148733,
0.0266038887,
-0.0036039292,
-0.0386981964,
-0.0045377435,
0.0279046204,
0.0135228196,
0.0359235406,
0.0156206135,
0.0279981904,
0.0286178701,
-0.0285370499,
0.0663504153,
-0.0563710816,
0.031257797,
0.0740123242,
-0.003455352,
-0.0235986542,
-0.0257581994,
-0.0395484567,
0.0035480824,
-0.0341405347,
0.0008443528,
-0.0040463968,
-0.0071817422,
-0.0473370887,
-0.0558368154,
0.0157733671,
-0.032741107,
0.0490086377,
0.015649952,
-0.0293641835,
0.0458513536,
-0.0070014894,
-0.0042970162,
0.0072946805,
0.0325190388,
0.0051756017,
0.0011832009,
0.0205449294,
-0.0026401249,
0.0134438919,
-0.0193495546,
-0.0544581637,
0.0186543576,
0.0065195165,
0.0098943235,
-0.0331251547,
0.0102833929,
-0.0050098374,
0.0041253255,
-0.0009411875,
0.0096972622,
-0.0024813688,
0.0025909708,
-0.0047744256,
0.0163348448,
0.0166509319,
0.0016760965,
-0.0281656832,
0.0535124466,
-0.0360763334,
-0.0040168813,
0.0219210703,
-0.0261286478,
-0.0101053817,
-0.0052951332,
2.919e-7,
0.0438714623,
0.0511629209,
0.0070963153,
0.0231059287,
-0.0241582245,
0.021695016,
-0.003472954,
-0.0028314181,
0.0332483575,
0.0106125558,
0.0317929089,
0.0450812392,
0.0756118745,
0.0397759937,
-0.0760373175,
0.0049874079,
-0.063193731,
-0.0447470173,
-0.048446361,
-0.040429797,
0.0538539067,
0.0506242327,
0.006132049,
0.0001752122,
-0.0121536804,
-0.0609791204,
0.0382720716,
-0.0385369994,
-0.0477562584,
0.0568100438,
0.0342370458,
0.0322035737,
0.0053160978,
0.0037105093,
0.0129472613,
-0.0291758683,
0.0592018217,
0.0432924181,
0.0151634617,
-0.0132611161,
0.005195058,
-0.0276213177,
0.0414701477,
-0.0275634695,
0.0636350736,
-0.0251558721,
-0.0178739447,
-0.0371734649,
-0.0352713726,
-0.0040584593,
0.033146657,
-0.0225292183,
-0.0442554504,
0.0577461384,
0.0031162121,
0.0049544894,
-0.0127964737,
-0.0399996154,
-0.0434844792,
0.0317989588,
0.0054890839,
-0.0544220582,
-0.0127924886,
0.0068915007,
-0.0324472822,
-0.0965041444,
0.0131965773,
2.935700484e-34,
0.1030244455,
-0.0104102464,
-0.012529253,
-0.0100106662,
0.0353450701,
-0.0125481915,
0.0060045901,
-0.008621891,
-0.0259282812,
-0.0872904733,
0.0152315507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00902v1 | From Introspection to Best Practices: Principled Analysis of Demonstrations in Multimodal In-Context Learning | 2024-07-01T01:57:21 | 2024-07-01T01:57:21 | Nan Xu, Fei Wang, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Muhao Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Motivated by in-context learning (ICL) capabilities of Large Language models
(LLMs), multimodal LLMs with additional visual modality are also exhibited with
similar ICL abilities when multiple image-text pairs are provided as
demonstrations. However, relatively less work has been done to investigate the
principles behind how and why multimodal ICL works. We conduct a systematic and
principled evaluation of multimodal ICL for models of different scales on a
broad spectrum of new yet critical tasks. Through perturbations over different
modality information, we show that modalities matter differently across tasks
in multimodal ICL. Considering such modality impact, we further utilize
modality-driven demonstration strategies to boost ICL performance. We also
identify that demonstration selection is closely related to the models' ability
to capture task inductive biases from multimodal ICL. Our principled analysis
provides a comprehensive way of understanding the role of demonstrations in
multimodal in-context learning, and sheds light on effectively improving
multimodal ICL on a wide range of tasks even if those tasks are not seen in or
even contradict pretraining data. | From Introspection to Best Practices: Principled Analysis of Demonstrations in Multimodal In-Context Learning: Motivated by in-context learning (ICL) capabilities of Large Language models
(LLMs), multimodal LLMs with additional visual modality are also exhibited with
similar ICL abilities when multiple image-text pairs are provided as
demonstrations. However, relatively less work has been done to investigate the
principles behind how and why multimodal ICL works. We conduct a systematic and
principled evaluation of multimodal ICL for models of different scales on a
broad spectrum of new yet critical tasks. Through perturbations over different
modality information, we show that modalities matter differently across tasks
in multimodal ICL. Considering such modality impact, we further utilize
modality-driven demonstration strategies to boost ICL performance. We also
identify that demonstration selection is closely related to the models' ability
to capture task inductive biases from multimodal ICL. Our principled analysis
provides a comprehensive way of understanding the role of demonstrations in
multimodal in-context learning, and sheds light on effectively improving
multimodal ICL on a wide range of tasks even if those tasks are not seen in or
even contradict pretraining data. | [
-0.0219982173,
0.0406185314,
-0.0120412102,
0.0481885411,
-0.0412771143,
0.0185864512,
0.0517907515,
-0.0154835135,
-0.0380197354,
-0.0667468756,
-0.0880353153,
-0.0455171764,
0.018086018,
-0.0188462306,
0.0670904443,
-0.0734582767,
0.0226619355,
-0.0570694543,
-0.0496991165,
-0.0017606987,
0.0198234636,
-0.0075376797,
-0.0585343055,
0.0354087465,
-0.0562560707,
-0.0101693319,
-0.020693386,
0.0313092358,
-0.0083496273,
-0.0523532294,
-0.0080603929,
0.0506504364,
0.0740221888,
-0.018873373,
0.000001982,
-0.0218058527,
0.0323816389,
-0.0100449976,
0.0258320682,
0.0001268903,
0.0867839009,
-0.0095044123,
0.0135259777,
0.0050285705,
-0.0114713488,
-0.0388358571,
0.0542621873,
0.043523781,
0.0274556782,
0.0586595684,
-0.011429376,
0.0025457959,
-0.0045767808,
-0.0133378534,
0.025452204,
-0.0176352318,
0.0116975373,
0.0035744843,
0.0231834333,
0.001536896,
-0.0595081039,
0.0407643169,
0.0392461531,
0.0173841175,
-0.0291336961,
0.0482596792,
0.0258226786,
-0.0218969174,
-0.0383380949,
0.0638325587,
-0.0108401431,
-0.0004688422,
-0.0179549363,
-0.009193236,
0.0264867675,
0.0274171792,
-0.064234376,
0.0435183644,
0.0021061848,
0.0229770485,
-0.0328310765,
0.004701992,
0.0362840295,
0.0229539052,
0.0078765796,
-0.0125927962,
-0.006859682,
-0.0156905763,
0.0081889108,
0.002947035,
-0.0443407744,
-0.0284552947,
-0.0298603401,
-0.0015007728,
-0.0414682329,
0.0205245875,
-0.0372237712,
-0.0383705832,
-0.000935448,
0.0079697389,
0.0598711707,
0.0163065661,
-0.0604318641,
0.0407821834,
-0.0025638174,
0.0340992436,
-0.0176981166,
0.0725518242,
-0.0106682489,
0.0021870011,
-0.0474722199,
-0.0007267109,
-0.0171384998,
-0.0288444553,
-0.0308354869,
-0.0442513861,
0.0054032914,
0.0287826229,
-0.0219224561,
-0.0045490549,
-0.0164860394,
-0.0062819095,
-0.0570033416,
-0.0058492534,
0.0001735834,
0.0420971066,
0.0010590905,
0.0567774139,
-0.011843157,
-0.0464839973,
-0.0125522669,
0.0380507633,
0.0033084319,
-0.0228753518,
-0.0047250851,
0.0770163164,
-0.05399644,
-0.0768218189,
-0.0078820661,
0.0100551657,
-0.0241072252,
-0.0621333905,
0.0529375561,
-0.0427733585,
0.0186666399,
-0.0014309298,
0.0279344656,
-0.0150724398,
-0.0066820886,
-0.0002615218,
0.011144246,
0.0735120326,
0.0260900389,
0.017021941,
0.0255262312,
0.0118643977,
-0.0398015864,
0.0770078078,
0.0210656766,
-0.0025456755,
0.0082171028,
0.0174728632,
0.0253460333,
0.0549186356,
0.0127629125,
0.0440984108,
-0.0437783189,
-0.0220889542,
0.0277849454,
0.035921257,
0.0352712385,
0.0295607746,
-0.0567476116,
0.0190109052,
0.1006713361,
0.0098945657,
0.0136582311,
-0.0357854776,
0.0154543351,
-0.0032609114,
0.0214576554,
0.0037649965,
-0.0777961314,
0.0244703479,
0.0084410477,
0.010944129,
0.021804316,
0.0245784726,
-0.0258787498,
-0.0005664118,
-0.0209320132,
-0.0093303313,
0.0359793082,
0.0173343569,
0.0500220954,
0.0380977094,
-0.0545665883,
-0.0038029833,
0.013288619,
-0.0306499135,
0.0027217069,
-0.0212054905,
-0.0071986914,
0.0072817919,
0.0042478531,
-0.0157894455,
-0.0031856792,
-0.0172530729,
0.0887051001,
0.0595169887,
-0.0094831958,
-0.0140518714,
0.0228122622,
-0.0431400463,
-0.0328545645,
-0.0414002165,
0.0194272939,
-0.0112754554,
0.0157095455,
0.0012208277,
-0.0267498288,
-0.056148015,
0.0184071846,
0.0303838309,
0.0053739902,
-0.0047546825,
-0.0405446738,
0.0045344839,
0.0048155668,
-0.0282005444,
-0.0231552105,
-0.001595877,
0.0167120583,
-0.0199003797,
0.0529964715,
0.0531501621,
-0.0798573941,
-0.073886402,
0.0041103759,
-0.0456241481,
-0.0061493991,
-0.0112296231,
-0.0167730711,
0.0074230079,
-0.0151589802,
-0.0209747069,
0.0339859799,
-0.031943094,
-0.0103619089,
0.0047853184,
0.004270365,
-0.0154962782,
0.0351466909,
-0.0430522263,
-0.0123121319,
0.0536843836,
0.0364399888,
-0.0238656122,
0.0004403431,
-0.0121799912,
0.0105967745,
0.0037969791,
0.041026324,
-0.0265256781,
0.0247640982,
-0.0412028767,
-0.008495261,
-0.1252008229,
-0.0251480844,
-0.0426919274,
-0.0197237879,
0.0079071056,
-0.0220756866,
-0.0252941493,
-0.0404631682,
0.0207778644,
0.0090548759,
-0.0080648987,
0.0285017639,
0.0005926869,
0.0300604999,
0.0189292599,
0.008228993,
0.0008388509,
0.0142138852,
0.0956045687,
-0.0099639222,
0.0157758743,
-0.0333143398,
0.0019190785,
0.0206671841,
0.022231007,
-0.0385141447,
0.0193452649,
0.0600965619,
-0.0073644081,
0.0471454412,
0.0461111553,
0.0077585042,
0.0565150641,
0.0240516271,
-0.0000666323,
-0.0501472019,
-0.0009440161,
0.0228734482,
-0.0123290746,
-0.052708555,
0.0081137614,
-0.0103835091,
0.0373627469,
0.0023490102,
0.0169899371,
-0.0314151905,
0.0136782769,
-0.0087983832,
-0.0638246611,
-0.0426750258,
-0.0074668978,
-0.0375066809,
-0.0161496308,
-0.0332855694,
-0.0679731816,
0.0209038258,
-0.0322499797,
-0.032979548,
-0.0198036321,
0.017651977,
0.0162427407,
0.0743281394,
-0.000196724,
0.0161150433,
-0.0102459881,
-0.0163490511,
-0.0510095283,
-0.0084263682,
0.021167079,
0.0188973583,
0.0596675426,
-0.0679797456,
-0.001642645,
-0.0011847322,
-0.0503719635,
-0.0238340013,
-0.0289844312,
0.0014978809,
-0.0139426477,
-0.062701039,
0.0186456311,
-0.0088337585,
-0.0187013485,
0.0776730403,
0.0110892188,
0.004780103,
-0.0093244566,
-0.0185481906,
0.0145612797,
-0.0010067752,
0.0488690175,
-0.0415358096,
-0.0908888057,
-0.0470204651,
0.0159674976,
0.0607923567,
-0.0162659213,
-0.0542052537,
0.0440812148,
0.0155502222,
0.0439972952,
-0.0059271026,
0.0560961924,
0.0677953288,
-0.0368929356,
0.0114501417,
0.0350553878,
-0.0234504975,
-0.0746724159,
0.0003912056,
0.0464311838,
0.0009534064,
0.0282490123,
0.0068521192,
-0.0730178952,
-0.0517169125,
0.0001931674,
-0.0142679727,
0.0367388092,
0.0222937576,
-0.0087933224,
-0.0970306098,
0.0446045697,
0.0144097609,
-0.0757121071,
-0.0222032256,
-0.0208521374,
-0.0058810292,
0.0041843224,
0.047984723,
0.022620922,
-0.03393884,
-0.0055292845,
0.0505766347,
0.0621956028,
-0.1183127314,
-0.0123890815,
-0.0403967686,
-0.004690385,
0.0117776413,
-0.0150747215,
-0.0148245916,
-0.0598555617,
0.0597919561,
0.0338786803,
0.0315601639,
-0.032434918,
0.0277974382,
-0.0144821117,
-0.0198052097,
0.0021878995,
0.0351011567,
0.0198699888,
-0.0571881793,
-0.0354747549,
0.0458193645,
-0.0033298207,
-0.0069862003,
-0.0113262888,
-0.0318118036,
0.0535799712,
0.0238712784,
0.0215626955,
-0.0523298383,
0.0042457539,
0.0006492524,
-0.0026578919,
-0.0095848897,
0.0041379598,
0.0026059262,
0.0080481675,
0.0120376246,
-0.0470322706,
-0.0107524171,
0.0116730938,
0.0648590326,
-0.0078860754,
0.0025091423,
-0.0554280132,
0.0114650363,
-0.043891646,
0.0853551179,
-0.0218937229,
0.0381041542,
-0.0441489704,
-0.0097784447,
0.0364804454,
-0.0674652904,
-0.0194638278,
0.0189760383,
-0.087640211,
-0.0457982123,
-0.0248612408,
0.0412952341,
0.0015847111,
0.0776773542,
0.0460814536,
-0.056279473,
0.0775316134,
0.0317893103,
-0.0065809721,
0.039397642,
0.0308923852,
-0.0119524207,
-0.0124173323,
0.0024981268,
-0.0212953445,
-0.0150649957,
0.0249771439,
0.0330799632,
0.0024458258,
0.0109993173,
0.0078114602,
-0.051786527,
0.0518754646,
-0.0407391824,
-0.024641972,
-0.0401415937,
0.0032340304,
0.0367128216,
-0.0125908321,
-0.0444160253,
0.000337308,
0.0035439851,
0.0302581452,
0.0040880367,
0.0215470698,
0.0481468141,
0.0315422751,
-0.0124174515,
0.035005603,
0.0361636132,
-0.03762215,
-0.0065925317,
0.0577210002,
0.0013986784,
0.0194154065,
-0.0369386375,
0.0204697866,
-0.0013179927,
0.098706156,
0.0332861692,
-0.0455962904,
-0.0250152871,
0.0522530824,
0.0030062997,
0.0362129323,
-0.042123653,
0.0541978218,
0.0640466809,
0.0019541034,
0.0316902585,
-0.0432281196,
0.0018731499,
-0.0210921746,
0.0396801047,
-0.0309428629,
-0.0301007126,
0.0491767041,
0.0144701041,
0.0234578978,
0.0225456767,
0.0623790435,
-0.0111409565,
0.0451188982,
-0.0151010286,
0.0385160111,
-0.0337336734,
-0.0171091519,
0.0882737488,
0.0500821322,
-0.0084076105,
0.0164413489,
-0.0073775379,
-0.0388099775,
-0.0148693649,
0.0250945371,
-0.0343031138,
-0.0216359571,
0.0441351384,
0.0626863837,
-0.0193862002,
-0.0250831079,
-0.0233481675,
-0.0412209481,
0.0660145134,
-0.0014945559,
-0.0130768055,
-5.971168572e-33,
-0.0248293988,
-0.0252281185,
0.0401680805,
-0.0370245725,
-0.0124510648,
0.0141988127,
-0.0242388397,
0.0356009342,
0.0012921535,
0.0142134046,
0.0187386163,
-0.0420988575,
0.0076567917,
0.0365181267,
0.0113704037,
0.0052607236,
0.019361956,
-0.0021573631,
-0.019769378,
-0.0006060638,
-0.0082149208,
0.0166720655,
0.0804854259,
-0.0552163199,
0.0223820172,
0.0097361272,
-0.0552141741,
0.0028702123,
-0.0476444103,
0.0611545183,
-0.0361972302,
0.0254988428,
0.0158368498,
-0.0276171248,
-0.0544613898,
0.0179222543,
-0.0331067778,
0.0056505948,
0.013003407,
0.0436413102,
-0.0807173029,
0.0028492499,
0.0709541291,
-0.0305095613,
-0.0329819284,
-0.0040155076,
0.0285729151,
0.0021053911,
-0.0140331322,
0.0293851532,
-0.0411785692,
0.0063874102,
0.018136654,
-0.0420509949,
0.0209512692,
0.001675167,
0.0006889697,
-0.0165642872,
-0.0350750871,
0.0467874557,
-0.0089774625,
0.0067697293,
0.0793098882,
0.0582042485,
0.0198564976,
0.0593002625,
0.0034675635,
-0.0021249028,
0.0325426832,
-0.0565993823,
0.0783073679,
0.0481428541,
0.0039810301,
0.1013281196,
0.0190642849,
0.0442883298,
-0.0148619171,
0.0144885965,
0.004766651,
0.0120324902,
0.0357161164,
0.0406444743,
-0.0183525495,
-0.0176451318,
-0.0473236665,
0.0266840775,
-0.020342363,
-0.0224743672,
0.061465539,
0.048826009,
-0.0059136581,
0.021743916,
0.0830521286,
-0.0356658548,
-0.0674306899,
0.0064908648,
-0.0275091734,
0.0851602405,
-0.0064033368,
-0.0334559269,
-0.0337015167,
-0.0499510244,
0.04290618,
0.0036724065,
0.0153268436,
-0.005587602,
0.0341228396,
0.0544435419,
-0.0390697643,
0.0014149551,
-0.0211504139,
-0.0064079175,
0.0460480712,
0.0036718249,
0.0571173392,
0.0023387033,
-0.0721061379,
0.0207068175,
-0.0085828714,
-0.0623900332,
-0.0131496489,
-0.0499946065,
-0.0614790581,
0.014914602,
-0.019809356,
0.017467333,
-0.0428652093,
-0.0425622761,
0.0188295711,
-0.0430402756,
-0.0189079288,
0.0432935655,
2.657e-7,
0.0274997521,
0.0316827297,
-0.0128585491,
0.004320574,
0.0389284752,
0.0305063594,
-0.0640552491,
0.0233270954,
-0.0021839037,
-0.0422213376,
0.000475447,
0.050892584,
0.0530038364,
0.0086319614,
-0.0301912818,
-0.0331602916,
-0.0131985527,
0.0405145735,
-0.0454268157,
0.0130852405,
-0.0239557419,
0.0455180556,
-0.0161212943,
-0.0154098934,
0.0370538197,
-0.0465001091,
0.0934450924,
-0.0522448495,
0.0056881914,
-0.0311647151,
-0.034461081,
0.0129640196,
0.0047061895,
0.030876331,
0.003792054,
-0.0121286139,
0.0294681862,
0.0227468386,
-0.0025626118,
-0.0277274922,
-0.0024933452,
0.040832404,
-0.0454076268,
-0.0509772599,
0.0605372414,
-0.0747555271,
0.0156925973,
-0.0300982874,
0.0340985619,
-0.0388336889,
0.0197352096,
-0.0280043073,
-0.0456827469,
0.0046604411,
0.0152784754,
-0.0007195779,
-0.0630576909,
-0.0600485057,
-0.0613131039,
0.0358539745,
-0.0822734609,
-0.0284755547,
-0.0520636812,
-0.0159850288,
0.0028442007,
-0.0556060337,
-0.0467363931,
1.917208786e-34,
0.0046785376,
-0.0126556205,
0.0249898061,
0.0190412048,
-0.0039470824,
-0.0112852976,
-0.0265124068,
-0.0077750348,
-0.0016187495,
-0.0338727869,
-0.0028747811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00900v1 | MathCAMPS: Fine-grained Synthesis of Mathematical Problems From Human Curricula | 2024-07-01T01:56:28 | 2024-07-01T01:56:28 | Shubhra Mishra, Gabriel Poesia, Belinda Mo, Noah D. Goodman | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Mathematical problem solving is an important skill for Large Language Models
(LLMs), both as an important capability and a proxy for a range of reasoning
abilities. Existing benchmarks probe a diverse set of skills, but they yield
aggregate accuracy metrics, obscuring specific abilities or weaknesses.
Furthermore, they are difficult to extend with new problems, risking data
contamination over time. To address these challenges, we propose MathCAMPS: a
method to synthesize high-quality mathematical problems at scale, grounded on
44 fine-grained "standards" from the Mathematics Common Core (CC) Standard for
K-8 grades. We encode each standard in a formal grammar, allowing us to sample
diverse symbolic problems and their answers. We then use LLMs to realize the
symbolic problems into word problems. We propose a cycle-consistency method for
validating problem faithfulness. Finally, we derive follow-up questions from
symbolic structures and convert them into follow-up word problems - a novel
task of mathematical dialogue that probes for robustness in understanding.
Experiments on 23 LLMs show surprising failures even in the strongest models
(in particular when asked simple follow-up questions). Moreover, we evaluate
training checkpoints of Pythia 12B on MathCAMPS, allowing us to analyze when
particular mathematical skills develop during its training. Our framework
enables the community to reproduce and extend our pipeline for a fraction of
the typical cost of building new high-quality datasets. | MathCAMPS: Fine-grained Synthesis of Mathematical Problems From Human Curricula: Mathematical problem solving is an important skill for Large Language Models
(LLMs), both as an important capability and a proxy for a range of reasoning
abilities. Existing benchmarks probe a diverse set of skills, but they yield
aggregate accuracy metrics, obscuring specific abilities or weaknesses.
Furthermore, they are difficult to extend with new problems, risking data
contamination over time. To address these challenges, we propose MathCAMPS: a
method to synthesize high-quality mathematical problems at scale, grounded on
44 fine-grained "standards" from the Mathematics Common Core (CC) Standard for
K-8 grades. We encode each standard in a formal grammar, allowing us to sample
diverse symbolic problems and their answers. We then use LLMs to realize the
symbolic problems into word problems. We propose a cycle-consistency method for
validating problem faithfulness. Finally, we derive follow-up questions from
symbolic structures and convert them into follow-up word problems - a novel
task of mathematical dialogue that probes for robustness in understanding.
Experiments on 23 LLMs show surprising failures even in the strongest models
(in particular when asked simple follow-up questions). Moreover, we evaluate
training checkpoints of Pythia 12B on MathCAMPS, allowing us to analyze when
particular mathematical skills develop during its training. Our framework
enables the community to reproduce and extend our pipeline for a fraction of
the typical cost of building new high-quality datasets. | [
-0.0171654727,
0.1111095846,
-0.02412818,
0.0242994893,
-0.0377373807,
0.0120170703,
0.0188209843,
-0.0004705769,
-0.0250622202,
-0.0128799425,
0.0166203883,
-0.0044847634,
-0.0025495135,
0.0087493276,
0.0429445095,
-0.0430372693,
0.0314084664,
-0.0509595983,
0.0095759239,
-0.0090964185,
-0.0358061045,
-0.0082654795,
-0.0287310332,
-0.0030011423,
-0.0566060655,
-0.0619233735,
0.0155552728,
-0.066729933,
0.0013517984,
-0.025509119,
-0.0054873349,
0.0508527607,
0.0185969453,
0.0396713875,
0.0000023713,
-0.0480727702,
0.0207446497,
-0.0058004591,
-0.0383682847,
0.0130061181,
0.0025854732,
-0.0058978153,
0.0163714644,
-0.0031510105,
-0.0563772358,
0.0272150207,
-0.0077597899,
-0.0191988442,
0.0957163498,
0.0460379273,
0.0118546048,
-0.0150360884,
0.0456117988,
-0.0145579753,
0.0444297567,
-0.0459874682,
0.0169531256,
0.0369798467,
0.0374087207,
-0.003703051,
-0.0433742143,
0.0251268502,
0.0822650865,
-0.0070762704,
-0.0107820788,
0.0019688427,
-0.0533394068,
0.0018002463,
-0.0023013777,
0.0554864891,
-0.0117998403,
-0.0315865278,
0.0114840148,
0.0017204984,
0.004515125,
0.0046812114,
-0.0693070292,
0.0354409926,
-0.0019329677,
-0.0156262647,
0.0046587829,
-0.0150173865,
0.0078828325,
0.0160029363,
-0.0166759286,
0.0453902408,
0.0160766337,
-0.0295805093,
-0.0380562916,
0.0165158659,
-0.0585717559,
-0.0493593588,
0.0540388711,
0.048638247,
0.0030527469,
-0.0011031571,
-0.0718192309,
-0.0220371764,
-0.0220362283,
-0.0182794537,
0.0329452418,
0.0723398849,
0.0391962044,
0.0338222496,
0.0078283027,
0.0486613177,
0.003512626,
0.0527181849,
-0.031102078,
0.039893683,
-0.0294769164,
-0.0016602953,
-0.0474286564,
0.023880763,
0.0262532514,
0.0068607042,
-0.0160558112,
0.0142111965,
-0.0443728194,
0.0428215489,
-0.0044907709,
-0.0148611683,
-0.0110244239,
-0.0416710339,
-0.0041755452,
0.0203959383,
-0.0773669928,
-0.0023291477,
0.0269123036,
-0.017488867,
-0.0373440646,
0.0101889418,
-0.0184082389,
-0.0227241721,
0.0411763452,
0.0546342507,
0.0073654712,
0.0177759323,
0.0157576166,
-0.0402004533,
0.0161168724,
-0.0919836387,
-0.0032502823,
-0.0817783847,
0.0558994338,
0.0264276266,
-0.0149019379,
-0.0436699763,
0.0065316851,
0.017347347,
0.0324832089,
0.0277551357,
0.0235422254,
-0.0056311577,
0.0235121474,
0.0009324534,
-0.0130975395,
0.0264626909,
0.0707483441,
-0.0141882338,
0.0210971683,
-0.0472415164,
0.0066906,
0.0219448432,
0.0282842889,
-0.0021388712,
-0.0030460269,
0.0221611559,
0.0231617615,
0.0603726692,
-0.0101108123,
0.0546906628,
-0.033824753,
-0.0124218157,
0.0265772659,
0.0828282684,
-0.0177995507,
0.0240526646,
0.035756018,
-0.0064665112,
0.0706628561,
-0.0131881842,
-0.082650505,
0.0023699393,
-0.0142271901,
0.0055059711,
-0.003738882,
0.0236725137,
-0.0177915096,
-0.0646439046,
-0.0019629912,
0.0207662825,
-0.0080307685,
0.0179142877,
0.0563970655,
-0.0075067892,
0.0146355573,
0.054314699,
-0.0047324318,
-0.0443793833,
0.0216364786,
-0.0167629328,
0.0812801123,
-0.0143706352,
0.0610314682,
-0.0259881429,
-0.0043380908,
-0.0155270984,
0.0445356555,
0.021490749,
0.0515893735,
-0.0221825317,
0.0080633769,
-0.0198207963,
0.0095306495,
-0.0199165288,
0.0161467902,
-0.045816388,
0.0460046344,
-0.0165020376,
0.009585307,
-0.0462915078,
-0.0001652792,
0.0387742147,
-0.0495247617,
-0.0346250981,
-0.0340991057,
-0.0174546801,
-0.0079613077,
-0.0049806391,
0.0101629179,
0.0356622674,
0.0160854161,
-0.0375590138,
0.044482436,
-0.0209840555,
-0.1025479138,
-0.0265654624,
0.0584013201,
-0.0353120267,
-0.0374079905,
0.037887454,
-0.0442026258,
-0.0112092253,
0.0941360071,
-0.0469905362,
0.0007631159,
0.0144211408,
0.0451216139,
-0.010458881,
-0.0097715752,
0.0082628755,
0.0688273013,
0.0250693373,
0.0244767349,
0.0080168517,
-0.0148119712,
0.0132549498,
-0.0234441422,
0.0005707655,
-0.015146208,
-0.0149099641,
0.0398485176,
-0.0092477687,
0.0157932546,
-0.0570774823,
-0.0017264585,
-0.0047520949,
0.0133457389,
-0.0013960704,
0.0615331605,
0.0325277522,
-0.0637453124,
-0.0055024158,
-0.0016321451,
-0.0218516458,
-0.0071730083,
-0.0061378302,
-0.0219165571,
0.0421665683,
0.0121109188,
-0.0326799639,
-0.0297741722,
-0.054903198,
-0.0530991107,
0.0486938432,
0.0302007105,
0.0691161901,
-0.0292144809,
0.0244637616,
-0.022980392,
0.0020617216,
0.0074912575,
0.0365877487,
0.046877645,
0.0031884066,
0.0504878387,
0.083085224,
-0.0178002268,
0.0263559874,
-0.007466489,
-0.0428582206,
-0.0563559085,
0.0099161873,
-0.0168166049,
0.0073091849,
-0.0264765937,
-0.0117881866,
-0.0042698747,
0.0896497592,
-0.014842961,
-0.0241214689,
-0.0352177955,
0.06870047,
-0.023364123,
0.0092972033,
-0.0515595004,
0.0049227956,
-0.0087825879,
0.032922484,
-0.0276324023,
-0.0445792936,
0.0677694604,
0.0085469726,
0.0002236383,
-0.0441319123,
0.0167921111,
-0.0319862477,
0.0390049741,
0.0145505024,
-0.0300606359,
-0.0163937509,
0.0032567102,
-0.0617720038,
0.0264914371,
0.0273779538,
-0.0531768054,
0.0192428157,
-0.0660380423,
-0.0069000223,
0.0008703315,
-0.0373897292,
-0.0363862924,
0.0673185065,
-0.0083593065,
0.0244079884,
-0.0040458883,
-0.0377772264,
-0.006094411,
-0.0412768461,
0.0345916077,
0.0065263659,
-0.0375149697,
-0.0328518935,
-0.006532277,
0.0267368332,
0.0169557314,
0.0330169126,
0.0353018232,
-0.0910181627,
0.0018607322,
0.0558494069,
0.0717904493,
0.0354880579,
0.0081302803,
0.0448296331,
0.0141511941,
-0.0128274346,
-0.0142575866,
0.0610145666,
0.0227631237,
-0.107710965,
-0.0514289625,
0.0616791882,
0.0352281183,
0.0002831815,
0.0191192143,
-0.0471819453,
0.0339470617,
0.0257559158,
0.0133745559,
-0.1062056273,
-0.0216261037,
0.0222081188,
0.003252238,
0.0140904048,
-0.0453992747,
0.0023253779,
-0.1114230752,
-0.0060368064,
0.0484158732,
-0.0439781137,
0.0155264651,
-0.0205371249,
-0.0091958689,
0.0002424464,
0.0118450914,
0.0292974729,
0.0026899711,
0.0337255523,
0.0158494022,
-0.0056186202,
-0.0268880762,
0.0390720479,
0.0090308841,
0.0124844229,
-0.0077128685,
0.0107963933,
-0.0267277081,
-0.0838726535,
0.0500313491,
0.0221330263,
-0.0461861156,
0.0236560572,
0.0055327113,
0.0037783294,
-0.0128835691,
-0.0412884839,
0.0630991682,
-0.0606398694,
-0.0475783981,
0.0429707021,
0.1200392172,
0.0125130359,
-0.0331216529,
-0.0193598382,
0.0062640915,
-0.047382541,
0.0581570677,
0.0508326553,
-0.0509740822,
-0.0320397876,
-0.0485077947,
-0.012515014,
-0.05769445,
-0.0441950038,
0.0252616778,
0.0490788259,
0.0170239229,
-0.0393632315,
-0.019728398,
0.0782712549,
0.0219079517,
-0.0074303802,
-0.0592203476,
0.0137765063,
-0.0305331759,
-0.0513974465,
0.0628236681,
-0.0392315574,
0.0388088115,
-0.0787343606,
0.0181416273,
-0.0541408174,
0.0062601757,
-0.0446025021,
0.075875327,
-0.1499269158,
-0.0614177175,
0.0029663139,
0.0286529437,
0.0255797412,
0.0046065925,
0.0121805314,
-0.0023976495,
0.0031263838,
0.0106228944,
-0.0522375181,
-0.0017678724,
0.0018541253,
-0.0269736294,
0.0138617391,
-0.0091519058,
0.0144766085,
0.0046480875,
0.0108521478,
0.0590551719,
-0.0131330863,
0.0106609454,
0.0309942048,
0.0336848535,
-0.0395329595,
0.0283987951,
-0.0070236214,
-0.0080787372,
-0.0025027306,
-0.0236511026,
-0.0098058376,
-0.0353914984,
0.0027429445,
-0.0001813846,
-0.0261816345,
0.020511277,
-0.0068305074,
0.0155142099,
0.0899585336,
0.0159226153,
0.0557544492,
-0.0286458433,
0.0229072515,
0.0514158048,
-0.036768008,
0.0161562003,
-0.0010279637,
-0.0276861861,
0.087882705,
-0.0096222609,
0.0386219695,
0.0050457441,
0.0165055469,
0.0029699185,
-0.0073988959,
-0.0386574343,
-0.0922415704,
-0.0284896977,
0.0146623971,
-0.0085763829,
0.0336932242,
-0.0093462374,
-0.0473038293,
-0.010635633,
-0.0110119348,
0.0089236954,
0.0160833579,
-0.0297403224,
0.0217217896,
0.0483777486,
0.0358547978,
-0.0553572327,
0.0225619264,
-0.0497383811,
0.032746084,
0.0004317016,
0.0387444347,
-0.0438502729,
-0.0185227394,
-0.0203894861,
0.0171163026,
0.0019566792,
0.0028644498,
-0.0800352991,
-0.0860497877,
-0.0031277982,
0.031800922,
-0.0047733895,
-0.003670709,
0.0183475688,
0.0404640585,
-0.0579333492,
-0.0208695624,
0.0288039986,
0.0655558929,
0.0002751033,
-0.0509591512,
-0.0260669254,
-6.201223469e-33,
-0.0041499427,
-0.0167888049,
0.027905006,
0.0018984555,
-0.0029915357,
-0.0280583315,
-0.0402682424,
0.0317990705,
-0.0050364998,
0.0121915331,
-0.0075073792,
0.0182733983,
-0.0105078463,
0.0299523585,
0.0136003867,
0.0099249752,
-0.0200262163,
-0.032470163,
-0.0464509055,
0.0149090625,
0.0125405528,
-0.014310617,
0.0837889314,
-0.0288151093,
0.0048346221,
-0.002801314,
0.0118375458,
0.0069968444,
-0.0533287674,
0.0499443263,
-0.004681271,
0.03629582,
0.0089453012,
-0.0363881104,
-0.0348002128,
-0.0104892198,
-0.0212850645,
-0.0428448021,
0.0067014224,
-0.0053989757,
-0.0758716986,
-0.0420354493,
0.0279204603,
0.0107638175,
-0.0451118797,
-0.0488213226,
0.0142040793,
-0.0369632393,
-0.0104191694,
-0.0118471682,
-0.0516328178,
0.0253543667,
-0.0320404433,
-0.024920864,
-0.0038506906,
0.0321461521,
-0.0071009984,
-0.0026388478,
0.0080429493,
0.0451130979,
0.021713702,
0.0287924781,
0.0345393308,
-0.0411699526,
0.0190297328,
0.02744749,
0.0233169794,
-0.0213358309,
0.0134215718,
0.020952303,
0.036283534,
0.0729054436,
0.0902297869,
0.0365212969,
0.0603933074,
0.009503847,
-0.0348158777,
-0.0067891409,
0.0021737546,
0.0434606485,
-0.0166474357,
-0.0117111215,
-0.0336679034,
-0.0116903279,
-0.0520644672,
0.0149955899,
-0.0351846032,
0.0109443888,
0.0288308319,
-0.0265992582,
-0.0267462116,
0.0277753733,
0.0088094948,
-0.0262855794,
-0.0296937339,
0.0192757696,
-0.0046850918,
0.0337679796,
0.0072775004,
0.0581141897,
-0.0644340515,
-0.0313214101,
-0.0015103415,
-0.0048715123,
0.0579094589,
0.0202904847,
0.0057813763,
0.0099346265,
-0.0369404703,
-0.0223120861,
-0.0455735102,
0.0093762605,
0.0512430668,
0.0017268087,
0.0435808301,
0.0379441008,
-0.0135634299,
0.0181070492,
-0.023596758,
-0.0289645214,
-0.024299372,
0.0520120673,
0.0068233954,
0.0209776759,
0.0103963669,
-0.0432733931,
-0.0417247228,
-0.0064183525,
0.0536079518,
-0.062659055,
0.005040634,
-0.0017662314,
2.924e-7,
0.0445160307,
0.0491552204,
0.0543501787,
0.0288173594,
-0.0042820163,
0.0107450942,
-0.0381587371,
-0.0345030762,
0.0318600759,
-0.036573451,
-0.0235901475,
0.0541879572,
0.0562729649,
0.0475682169,
-0.0409086198,
0.0368592963,
-0.0555939041,
-0.0029090871,
-0.0782623142,
0.0061486023,
0.0547340363,
0.0541962795,
0.0279578678,
-0.017426867,
0.0062565762,
-0.0283372179,
0.0370787829,
-0.019562792,
0.0099532036,
0.0230104104,
-0.0337081887,
-0.0509134643,
0.0137006734,
0.0187865067,
-0.0142253945,
0.0134672867,
-0.0051135672,
0.0384313464,
0.033060424,
0.0354870595,
-0.0425571129,
-0.040946193,
-0.0104870927,
-0.0437518619,
0.0189501587,
-0.0695639327,
-0.0249749012,
-0.0109075028,
-0.0174076594,
-0.0139035676,
0.0048247338,
0.0084752124,
0.0205945838,
0.0016298965,
0.0362871364,
0.0140286935,
0.028113516,
-0.0456472747,
-0.0297705196,
-0.0054342006,
-0.0625105947,
-0.0547220893,
-0.0591710359,
-0.0135827996,
0.0153495148,
-0.0417882837,
-0.0049094013,
2.719680668e-34,
0.0508516915,
-0.0137582775,
0.0613120832,
0.0183289498,
0.0339284092,
-0.0252508353,
0.0140612815,
-0.0015159219,
0.0360531248,
-0.0602025613,
-0.0280858632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00894v1 | How to Leverage Digit Embeddings to Represent Numbers? | 2024-07-01T01:31:41 | 2024-07-01T01:31:41 | Jasivan Alex Sivakumar, Nafise Sadat Moosavi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Apart from performing arithmetic operations, understanding numbers themselves
is still a challenge for existing language models. Simple generalisations, such
as solving 100+200 instead of 1+2, can substantially affect model performance
(Sivakumar and Moosavi, 2023). Among various techniques, character-level
embeddings of numbers have emerged as a promising approach to improve number
representation. However, this method has limitations as it leaves the task of
aggregating digit representations to the model, which lacks direct supervision
for this process. In this paper, we explore the use of mathematical priors to
compute aggregated digit embeddings and explicitly incorporate these aggregates
into transformer models. This can be achieved either by adding a special token
to the input embeddings or by introducing an additional loss function to
enhance correct predictions. We evaluate the effectiveness of incorporating
this explicit aggregation, analysing its strengths and shortcomings, and
discuss future directions to better benefit from this approach. Our methods,
while simple, are compatible with any pretrained model and require only a few
lines of code, which we have made publicly available. | How to Leverage Digit Embeddings to Represent Numbers?: Apart from performing arithmetic operations, understanding numbers themselves
is still a challenge for existing language models. Simple generalisations, such
as solving 100+200 instead of 1+2, can substantially affect model performance
(Sivakumar and Moosavi, 2023). Among various techniques, character-level
embeddings of numbers have emerged as a promising approach to improve number
representation. However, this method has limitations as it leaves the task of
aggregating digit representations to the model, which lacks direct supervision
for this process. In this paper, we explore the use of mathematical priors to
compute aggregated digit embeddings and explicitly incorporate these aggregates
into transformer models. This can be achieved either by adding a special token
to the input embeddings or by introducing an additional loss function to
enhance correct predictions. We evaluate the effectiveness of incorporating
this explicit aggregation, analysing its strengths and shortcomings, and
discuss future directions to better benefit from this approach. Our methods,
while simple, are compatible with any pretrained model and require only a few
lines of code, which we have made publicly available. | [
-0.0536364391,
0.0931160003,
0.0093001099,
0.0356668122,
0.0351613089,
0.0127686709,
0.0173730049,
-0.0337274075,
-0.0733593255,
-0.0329093598,
-0.0323181041,
-0.0424574353,
0.0177360382,
0.0255111177,
0.07325764,
-0.0170525555,
0.0319478028,
-0.0286425464,
-0.0042529227,
0.0141431596,
-0.0072912611,
0.0059834956,
0.0012790286,
0.052182164,
-0.0389240347,
0.0031239034,
0.0068790508,
-0.0593721718,
0.0219085161,
-0.0036472341,
-0.0284217056,
0.0195544604,
0.0616227053,
0.0860887021,
0.0000019734,
-0.0109447911,
-0.0167235453,
0.0053171194,
-0.0511473008,
0.033680778,
0.0332213305,
-0.0656778589,
-0.0280600581,
0.0236703046,
-0.0164062176,
-0.0535508655,
0.0590272658,
0.0412605591,
0.0742184147,
0.0678236932,
-0.0192965772,
-0.0441439934,
0.0529900268,
-0.0367536098,
0.0098517258,
0.0102579976,
-0.0078884102,
0.0383963436,
-0.0351291038,
-0.0024375159,
-0.0200732835,
0.0076269899,
0.0564216562,
-0.0011865183,
0.0128261801,
0.0482029505,
0.0014877297,
0.0038714763,
-0.0049730702,
0.0809007213,
-0.0803701282,
-0.0258414652,
-0.0184173305,
0.0066641644,
-0.0232929271,
-0.0489070974,
-0.0634806827,
0.0081810355,
0.111601159,
0.0559666269,
-0.0126289725,
0.0289426036,
0.0557219461,
-0.0247614123,
-0.0605837516,
0.0212803558,
0.0359984487,
0.0130025167,
-0.0602705069,
-0.0351721905,
-0.0555132926,
-0.0214840267,
0.0053099212,
0.0364771262,
0.0465606749,
0.0030341141,
-0.0359067172,
-0.0581873618,
-0.0138090579,
-0.033729326,
0.0368935801,
0.0983830765,
-0.0008786124,
0.018173065,
-0.0682975799,
0.0534352735,
-0.040465679,
0.0447559245,
-0.0212037507,
0.0193971284,
0.0199687723,
-0.0357540809,
-0.0451079607,
0.0080196289,
-0.0281523094,
-0.0142239155,
-0.0271024033,
0.0509398431,
0.0002084096,
-0.0098088533,
0.043862436,
-0.0128401127,
0.0043505616,
-0.0343458056,
0.0197639968,
0.0387935564,
-0.0485301875,
-0.0096150888,
-0.0221065208,
-0.0478767902,
-0.0365065597,
-0.0142584965,
0.0100147147,
-0.0178392809,
-0.0297253691,
0.0666686893,
0.0088851964,
-0.0083336513,
0.0260419454,
0.0067202663,
0.0037791522,
-0.0043296157,
0.006918788,
-0.0653086677,
0.0287973471,
-0.0053755553,
0.0199592113,
-0.0187955555,
0.0221351571,
0.0268116649,
0.0237985123,
0.0612749904,
-0.0115633961,
0.0015872059,
-0.0006602056,
-0.0170202982,
0.0289253928,
0.0481632315,
0.0450527109,
-0.0081311921,
0.0039256862,
-0.0552768558,
-0.0076778196,
0.0548745729,
0.0283842385,
-0.0125014093,
-0.0294829104,
-0.0391483307,
0.0270569623,
0.0169438217,
0.03551431,
0.0261000395,
-0.0631290376,
-0.0481576063,
0.0741009042,
0.0508375503,
0.0196130387,
0.0426302664,
0.0022641844,
-0.0246243179,
-0.0011710279,
-0.0211937837,
-0.0648328811,
0.0212602708,
0.0237043165,
0.0093370173,
0.0504958369,
0.03049176,
-0.0339157954,
-0.0448121019,
-0.0031408586,
-0.0413752496,
0.0349704064,
-0.016017044,
0.056021262,
0.0040400899,
-0.0191722382,
0.0602131486,
-0.0054939897,
-0.0796856135,
0.0142749045,
-0.0588327609,
0.0265376419,
0.0167365372,
0.0172844529,
-0.0073918435,
-0.0150932977,
0.001663785,
-0.0224339683,
-0.0111863185,
0.0241791923,
-0.0127496449,
0.0182658639,
-0.0624919012,
-0.0031518261,
-0.0044512716,
0.0265582819,
0.0152883716,
-0.0431488231,
-0.0202041287,
0.0316756815,
-0.050257735,
0.0230617728,
0.0430642068,
-0.0180104021,
-0.0524039865,
0.0091838883,
0.0048877895,
-0.0260087568,
-0.0131455325,
0.0020962064,
0.0719148442,
0.0293957982,
-0.02257137,
-0.0198622774,
-0.0091126198,
-0.0571757816,
-0.0072379108,
0.0754416808,
-0.0334846303,
0.0133253345,
0.0438613854,
-0.0215630997,
-0.0368407071,
0.0353901051,
-0.0760790333,
0.0594371073,
-0.044585187,
0.0263821352,
0.008289896,
0.0102304146,
0.0044220206,
0.0259591695,
-0.0093485573,
0.003362901,
0.0093811229,
-0.0430045165,
0.0227834042,
0.0035678265,
-0.0292209145,
-0.009009161,
0.007440289,
0.0191086251,
-0.0017653425,
-0.0453130752,
-0.0038392707,
-0.0095510157,
-0.0816943645,
-0.029058991,
-0.0365604535,
0.0429743081,
0.0300211255,
0.0092875622,
0.0219485201,
-0.0465041138,
-0.0167177711,
-0.036572367,
-0.0011043657,
0.0039231097,
0.0089725852,
0.0095880115,
-0.010981353,
-0.0227673911,
-0.0528064482,
-0.0400281474,
0.0786890313,
-0.0182888061,
0.0269398969,
-0.0297715813,
0.0049036155,
-0.0010187227,
0.0114364708,
-0.0247223768,
-0.0194820557,
-0.0015511792,
-0.034825258,
0.0720062405,
-0.0046652486,
-0.0187773909,
0.0281189419,
0.042320475,
-0.016902471,
-0.0194432735,
-0.0194720309,
-0.0386261456,
-0.0035814706,
-0.0208410993,
0.000104056,
-0.0373628922,
0.0713646412,
-0.0425939299,
-0.018634554,
-0.0637755767,
0.0158476606,
-0.004517281,
0.0054422193,
-0.0239653811,
0.0327406749,
-0.0032580034,
0.0182619933,
-0.0106460024,
-0.0495981239,
0.0605583042,
-0.0150655424,
-0.0433724821,
-0.0193703733,
0.0172208827,
-0.041717954,
0.011605924,
0.0388876386,
-0.0078665968,
0.006898636,
-0.0094300155,
-0.0513287671,
0.040935155,
-0.005786371,
-0.0242544599,
0.0865518153,
0.0094800638,
0.001242506,
-0.010984296,
-0.0307148173,
-0.0509355739,
-0.0500191487,
-0.0274113473,
0.0692006722,
-0.0134380003,
-0.0308895595,
-0.0661679879,
0.0032448438,
0.0416491181,
0.0630120561,
-0.0012276619,
-0.00559125,
-0.0189590733,
0.0294808112,
0.020237986,
0.0039782361,
0.0666209385,
-0.0433927178,
0.0199073646,
0.000774889,
0.0535806194,
0.0258374456,
-0.0597962923,
-0.0086235814,
0.0468289666,
-0.0403312519,
-0.0124982568,
0.0364251696,
0.0265252702,
-0.0523353331,
-0.0039090398,
0.1277070493,
0.0284713339,
-0.0295928922,
0.023985751,
-0.0329060927,
0.0058610206,
0.0074016172,
0.0108503858,
-0.0615760162,
-0.0144358464,
0.0190590341,
-0.0314907655,
0.0407270826,
0.0122295804,
0.0182555448,
-0.1210066676,
-0.007401505,
0.0424254872,
-0.0269505009,
-0.033801388,
-0.0424797237,
-0.0200185552,
-0.0317932367,
0.0414460935,
0.007809638,
-0.0202810727,
0.0091104303,
0.0045862747,
-0.0185077023,
-0.0311584007,
-0.0182460845,
-0.0255790725,
0.0144618219,
0.0412612818,
0.0236561187,
-0.0099961599,
-0.0536803454,
-0.0178949647,
0.00150138,
-0.036461927,
0.0460167304,
0.0282274019,
0.0155040212,
-0.0265187491,
0.0100880377,
0.0216992833,
-0.060314659,
-0.0352638513,
-0.0570499226,
0.0818359852,
-0.0116735706,
0.0114269517,
-0.001304627,
-0.0098610846,
-0.0148362797,
0.0117282104,
0.0434673801,
-0.0230653528,
0.0005520874,
-0.0433674753,
0.0305807665,
0.0099590588,
-0.0504053086,
-0.0079673762,
0.0595247671,
-0.0817526281,
-0.0379593894,
0.0178910866,
0.0075681787,
0.0319027305,
-0.0046201064,
-0.0830593184,
0.0345810838,
-0.0076642507,
-0.0235806536,
0.0455313772,
-0.0350929275,
0.0511111729,
-0.0519216284,
0.0161561668,
0.018708555,
-0.0137618259,
-0.0153774573,
-0.041235514,
-0.0760991424,
-0.0601720884,
0.0123619083,
0.0506420694,
0.013976126,
-0.0177901872,
-0.0158872027,
-0.0473155007,
0.0650701821,
0.0189951602,
-0.071182318,
-0.0022102555,
0.0347900055,
-0.0299831573,
0.015744675,
0.0122178141,
-0.0121731665,
0.0210825074,
0.0002056332,
0.0044473256,
-0.0702403635,
0.0266815554,
0.0314560309,
-0.0289263763,
0.0277322549,
0.0033127111,
0.0424558893,
-0.0126551054,
0.01858183,
-0.0532348044,
0.0344825648,
-0.0361561589,
-0.0115268929,
0.0327901617,
0.0546634682,
-0.0007493765,
-0.0087507712,
0.0380437337,
0.0104705021,
-0.0166754369,
0.0465698764,
0.0362893865,
0.0558193587,
-0.0183567218,
-0.01321836,
0.0097673526,
-0.0060647745,
-0.0376202278,
0.0148147205,
-0.014451745,
-0.0011937226,
-0.021399023,
0.0144286035,
-0.0551507175,
0.0514894538,
-0.0351846404,
-0.0566762015,
-0.0075873528,
-0.0208672583,
0.0375227071,
0.0020442996,
0.0139948055,
-0.0381478705,
0.0019914878,
-0.0365050994,
-0.0030781487,
-0.0201855097,
0.0066391914,
0.0137130767,
0.0278997403,
-0.0047460478,
-0.074388586,
0.0348425433,
-0.0137939984,
0.0163743887,
0.0115742637,
0.0018966114,
0.0151679544,
-0.0070659542,
0.0233052298,
0.0329302289,
-0.0468676277,
-0.0015456355,
-0.0202934258,
-0.0935232937,
0.0111744003,
-0.0062867454,
-0.0276722703,
0.0135256816,
0.0271260049,
0.005772172,
-0.0501256771,
0.0271693114,
-0.0046504154,
0.0038273586,
-0.0015466243,
-0.0237861779,
-0.0627401099,
-5.625968493e-33,
0.0233736429,
-0.0199485458,
-0.0131102055,
-0.0242570341,
-0.0163529031,
0.0052602938,
-0.0273494627,
0.030843081,
0.0017083503,
0.0023496775,
-0.0179716032,
0.0101798698,
0.0078809094,
0.0285015535,
-0.0135301892,
-0.0234976672,
0.0584980398,
-0.0183548536,
0.0017697705,
-0.0161278192,
0.0107167652,
0.0219189581,
0.0873094276,
-0.0285611674,
0.0088137006,
0.0108414572,
-0.0153150419,
0.00402391,
0.0101866275,
0.0673195049,
-0.0154380444,
0.0486641899,
-0.0042392844,
-0.0579891019,
-0.0624626949,
0.0518526025,
-0.0452562757,
-0.027876826,
0.0088673104,
0.0353312381,
0.0429742672,
-0.0274976101,
0.0245635416,
-0.0502242111,
0.0025487558,
-0.0259086937,
0.0103174588,
-0.0180692393,
-0.0123017067,
0.0021824921,
-0.0388278663,
0.0240964629,
-0.0056504258,
-0.0066260938,
0.0860985667,
0.0152212828,
-0.004378662,
0.0003592205,
-0.0466000549,
0.0514895506,
0.0026192677,
0.0392850786,
0.0271108449,
0.0159176812,
0.0020928646,
0.0164505504,
0.0332784094,
-0.0565506257,
-0.0612842627,
-0.0326730534,
0.0736367479,
-0.0159171838,
0.0871527791,
-0.0095622139,
0.1010588855,
0.0148171298,
-0.0519817546,
0.0135528967,
0.0349520184,
0.0270850267,
0.0224650167,
0.0502489433,
-0.0245249625,
0.0099381246,
-0.040398635,
0.0124644525,
-0.0398090109,
-0.0251150094,
-0.0027847993,
-0.0046457034,
0.0072480803,
0.0339177102,
0.0405051969,
-0.0686448514,
0.0173043162,
0.0333697423,
0.0209845547,
0.042349305,
-0.024862105,
0.0099536711,
-0.0156479683,
-0.0377826504,
0.0366599448,
-0.0138994521,
-0.0004939109,
-0.0131352218,
0.0246524569,
0.0406648815,
-0.0698646754,
-0.0243127011,
-0.0098867798,
-0.0521199182,
0.0264385305,
0.1054905728,
0.0398501307,
0.0201761723,
0.0010988703,
-0.0175577421,
-0.0237225071,
0.0059694732,
0.0002007119,
0.0300933272,
0.0201784167,
0.0269953832,
-0.0004463147,
-0.0369576886,
-0.0488328747,
0.0214340352,
0.0424755439,
-0.0434101559,
-0.0258150361,
0.0041052084,
2.505e-7,
0.0707822442,
0.0084386915,
0.0083452417,
0.0097911526,
0.0077791414,
0.0223930627,
-0.0000954041,
0.0143710412,
0.0100667942,
-0.0147837726,
0.01586009,
0.0098776594,
0.0182415508,
0.0520190708,
-0.0524998941,
-0.0227883216,
-0.0335747488,
0.0425684564,
0.0032678698,
-0.0110362126,
-0.0251445752,
0.1655521244,
0.0152782947,
0.0186132155,
0.0182134714,
-0.0190775394,
0.0557783544,
-0.0364206731,
0.013547672,
0.001268485,
0.0070015807,
0.0035599358,
-0.0075266124,
-0.0262904428,
-0.0234035477,
0.0647894591,
0.0621814765,
0.0460099466,
-0.0371021219,
-0.0157332942,
-0.0164170507,
0.000176042,
-0.0423774086,
-0.0290148538,
0.0320554227,
-0.0696479604,
-0.0301956367,
-0.0133671546,
-0.0161927696,
0.0156300943,
0.0284994841,
-0.0155854002,
-0.0220652018,
0.0444017574,
0.065562509,
-0.0159286745,
0.0244868193,
-0.0825221017,
-0.0313201509,
0.0010081311,
-0.0666836873,
-0.0443627052,
-0.0424459577,
-0.0375804752,
0.0739874542,
-0.0041557276,
0.0120150521,
2.60657125e-34,
0.0441003665,
-0.0177441351,
0.032177683,
0.0429817215,
0.0097461296,
-0.0299608167,
0.0279617608,
0.0232827701,
0.0685146078,
-0.0789428204,
-0.0175525825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00890v1 | Macroeconomic Forecasting with Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T01:25:26 | 2024-07-01T01:25:26 | Andrea Carriero, Davide Pettenuzzo, Shubhranshu Shekhar | econ.EM | econ.EM, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents a comparative analysis evaluating the accuracy of Large
Language Models (LLMs) against traditional macro time series forecasting
approaches. In recent times, LLMs have surged in popularity for forecasting due
to their ability to capture intricate patterns in data and quickly adapt across
very different domains. However, their effectiveness in forecasting
macroeconomic time series data compared to conventional methods remains an area
of interest. To address this, we conduct a rigorous evaluation of LLMs against
traditional macro forecasting methods, using as common ground the FRED-MD
database. Our findings provide valuable insights into the strengths and
limitations of LLMs in forecasting macroeconomic time series, shedding light on
their applicability in real-world scenarios | Macroeconomic Forecasting with Large Language Models: This paper presents a comparative analysis evaluating the accuracy of Large
Language Models (LLMs) against traditional macro time series forecasting
approaches. In recent times, LLMs have surged in popularity for forecasting due
to their ability to capture intricate patterns in data and quickly adapt across
very different domains. However, their effectiveness in forecasting
macroeconomic time series data compared to conventional methods remains an area
of interest. To address this, we conduct a rigorous evaluation of LLMs against
traditional macro forecasting methods, using as common ground the FRED-MD
database. Our findings provide valuable insights into the strengths and
limitations of LLMs in forecasting macroeconomic time series, shedding light on
their applicability in real-world scenarios | [
-0.0131669398,
0.11194776,
-0.0162410475,
0.0124866869,
-0.0053092153,
0.0105902161,
0.0404371619,
0.019032592,
-0.0109241325,
0.0056933495,
0.0086594298,
-0.0509199128,
0.014159536,
0.0452700816,
-0.0108351512,
-0.0123978471,
0.0268631727,
-0.0418082997,
0.0056653759,
-0.0317029655,
0.0024655398,
-0.0073813191,
0.0596351624,
0.0551327057,
-0.0169509668,
0.0376170799,
0.0097340569,
-0.0503416806,
-0.0433190279,
0.0061627356,
-0.0208035801,
0.001051833,
0.041845452,
0.0612347983,
0.0000018608,
-0.0331460498,
-0.0193420351,
0.0031729869,
0.0031971803,
0.0408359133,
0.0497153737,
-0.0508073308,
0.017108513,
0.0257767849,
-0.0486703366,
-0.016379863,
0.0514995568,
-0.0091119176,
0.0343701914,
0.0383667275,
-0.0114960968,
-0.0510322526,
-0.0197661873,
-0.0559590645,
-0.0646437407,
-0.0728449598,
0.0440176092,
0.0089605357,
-0.0199951604,
-0.0051622652,
-0.0012058058,
0.0374870189,
-0.0125174662,
-0.0065872665,
-0.0260241814,
0.0380159765,
0.0300814323,
-0.0032435097,
-0.0120891444,
0.0213725027,
0.0316286311,
0.0030753284,
0.0302041881,
0.0065974528,
0.0064769732,
0.0705491081,
-0.0696277618,
-0.0027255835,
0.0394258909,
0.039270889,
0.0549991541,
-0.0046706866,
0.021164747,
0.0501954518,
-0.0363911279,
0.0866626352,
0.0021773221,
-0.0198410768,
-0.0086019831,
-0.001776602,
-0.0161386859,
-0.0354116447,
-0.0404662117,
-0.0027610031,
-0.0203171205,
0.0220448133,
-0.0270813257,
0.0115778903,
-0.0162635073,
-0.0876982212,
0.0210124627,
0.0501385592,
0.033497721,
0.0387762785,
-0.0087472219,
0.0424525961,
-0.0231918693,
-0.1006482542,
0.0001989514,
-0.0161759313,
-0.0675949454,
-0.0025677185,
-0.021230381,
0.0018067564,
-0.0042589172,
-0.0117223477,
-0.0498840921,
-0.0555840731,
-0.0171215367,
0.0367348343,
0.0106440904,
-0.0471654534,
-0.0435807221,
-0.032254383,
-0.0411112085,
0.0506420545,
-0.0039431653,
0.0410455912,
-0.0092678126,
0.0018483041,
0.0208764356,
-0.015218812,
-0.0212697741,
0.0189089682,
0.027936507,
0.0675609559,
0.0533127338,
0.0615515076,
0.0016662099,
-0.032592129,
-0.0209199004,
-0.06271182,
-0.0129907019,
-0.0268257707,
0.0199609026,
0.0045783618,
0.0272663813,
-0.0053595151,
-0.0083824741,
-0.011202354,
-0.0336376503,
0.0425743535,
-0.0225326475,
-0.0161272548,
-0.0220974907,
-0.0495996512,
0.0582883582,
0.0763179213,
-0.0086719589,
-0.0101764333,
0.0289359745,
-0.0126332873,
-0.0180579256,
0.0396947041,
-0.0258086622,
-0.0089311935,
-0.0579725578,
0.0179871526,
0.0156034473,
-0.0198275186,
0.0106063429,
-0.0156174041,
0.0190071594,
0.0152347693,
0.0328663103,
0.0158249289,
0.0090590995,
0.0301448368,
0.0357262976,
0.0084272455,
0.017178433,
-0.0384301692,
0.018824527,
-0.0086682867,
-0.0450856686,
0.0337182321,
-0.0075376946,
0.0198768992,
-0.0143828467,
-0.0229282007,
-0.0013390509,
-0.0317243747,
-0.0051404098,
-0.0060931947,
0.0798208863,
-0.1102401018,
-0.0072340458,
0.0908237249,
0.0563172214,
0.0054573668,
-0.000874593,
-0.0277101379,
0.0359315649,
0.0686345175,
-0.0175855737,
0.0045707403,
0.0057670618,
-0.0104681617,
0.0219797138,
0.0553037152,
-0.0043661534,
0.0335146002,
0.0070350086,
-0.0467672497,
-0.0154817216,
0.0472713821,
0.051103916,
0.0363227129,
-0.0140355974,
-0.0025018533,
0.0140006989,
-0.0058865165,
-0.0509623103,
-0.0093537346,
-0.003445517,
-0.0300729964,
0.0215371028,
-0.0300747827,
0.0142328525,
0.0062488867,
-0.0057788701,
0.0142031843,
-0.0088586789,
-0.0245440304,
-0.0234704278,
0.0022633635,
-0.051993113,
0.0413709469,
0.0217734724,
0.0137328822,
0.0348436125,
-0.0510345474,
-0.0259842612,
-0.0342193097,
0.0499872528,
0.0020472305,
0.0221964847,
-0.0620170683,
0.0098735383,
-0.0112447552,
0.0059723961,
0.0230757203,
0.015962651,
-0.0172788575,
0.0313240252,
0.0000600009,
0.0360029228,
-0.0020763688,
-0.0002736321,
0.0074526174,
0.0210214052,
0.0252903011,
0.0165095888,
0.0062068594,
0.0018145805,
0.0087150438,
-0.0353752039,
-0.0238759611,
-0.0398896486,
0.0069298618,
0.0255485363,
0.0322635286,
-0.0383634418,
0.0068139462,
0.0427373983,
-0.0075227884,
0.0121292016,
0.0066070724,
-0.0185479838,
0.0143668884,
0.0127356229,
-0.0394635163,
-0.0299801417,
-0.016071165,
-0.0195361488,
0.066897288,
0.0205400866,
-0.0151970219,
-0.0100527676,
-0.0211903173,
-0.0324572213,
0.0002872708,
-0.0149551742,
-0.0568962321,
-0.0220373441,
-0.0417647138,
0.041043058,
-0.0106962668,
-0.0378542915,
-0.0089311115,
0.0167256221,
-0.059378203,
-0.042996902,
-0.0012369924,
0.0076930108,
0.0080318218,
-0.055275213,
-0.032158684,
0.01090967,
0.0913352296,
-0.0187517144,
0.0144033153,
-0.0549848638,
0.0462622121,
-0.059908919,
0.0220664237,
-0.0331330895,
0.0273733456,
-0.0125211813,
0.0414603576,
0.0300804861,
-0.0488942303,
-0.003085874,
-0.0542161278,
-0.0045694597,
-0.000451777,
-0.0129228923,
-0.0465094,
-0.052936215,
-0.0062994636,
-0.0095285755,
-0.0216793213,
0.01208393,
0.0184510462,
0.007273668,
0.0078626964,
-0.0043811025,
0.0521558002,
-0.0235192403,
0.0297190733,
0.0368556604,
0.0080434987,
0.0320138521,
-0.0378109179,
-0.0859955847,
0.0602040067,
0.0279630851,
-0.0581700988,
-0.0189472809,
0.0620435551,
-0.0135257673,
-0.0176317692,
-0.0072659459,
0.0141746709,
0.0380430929,
-0.0234232452,
0.0264847893,
-0.017455142,
-0.0269677229,
-0.0603614636,
0.0563429259,
-0.0681071803,
-0.0042650611,
0.0594868325,
-0.0272882152,
-0.0143598011,
0.0314956121,
-0.006155862,
-0.0283776168,
0.0530516729,
-0.0357989818,
-0.0782576799,
-0.0235522818,
0.115647845,
0.0031196699,
0.013462171,
-0.012007446,
-0.0210775379,
0.0069661182,
0.0032256942,
0.0113881035,
-0.0417208485,
-0.0232034996,
0.0246552993,
-0.0146166505,
-0.0048457552,
-0.0209796708,
-0.0263681188,
-0.0974080935,
0.0284072887,
0.0111073274,
-0.0516508408,
-0.0257197656,
-0.0454206467,
0.016544722,
-0.0653917417,
0.0137891602,
0.0042641517,
-0.0307547878,
0.0176225286,
0.0389214158,
-0.1288812011,
-0.0831669793,
-0.0176547728,
-0.0142174065,
-0.013251055,
0.0488435887,
0.0316841863,
-0.0333235115,
0.0138067687,
-0.01889145,
0.0099641746,
0.0212627072,
-0.0260313209,
-0.0111472514,
0.0424464308,
-0.0350818001,
0.0004989082,
0.0418288819,
-0.0013872209,
0.0603598952,
0.0212161224,
0.001724016,
-0.024381794,
-0.023249764,
0.0576096289,
0.0353689715,
-0.0136161279,
0.0369382985,
0.0161185823,
-0.0337823369,
-0.0080022067,
-0.0210969616,
-0.033576522,
-0.0375960283,
-0.0132909836,
0.0114630861,
-0.0369802453,
-0.0266014505,
-0.0128992992,
-0.0474752113,
0.0444090404,
0.0367477648,
0.0091278683,
0.0407628901,
0.0646225139,
0.0328679234,
0.029169051,
-0.0115090813,
-0.0462484173,
0.0399020649,
-0.0586032085,
0.0500790626,
0.0301305857,
0.0206786022,
-0.0252030771,
-0.0101670176,
-0.0825002939,
-0.0470251776,
0.0714585558,
0.0065367245,
0.0147167351,
-0.046275638,
0.0355781466,
0.0153317312,
0.0408649221,
0.0576273464,
-0.0174927674,
-0.0267947223,
0.0303780269,
0.0252954271,
0.0026102976,
0.0352807678,
0.0155382203,
0.0040071071,
-0.0251678638,
0.0213315934,
-0.0536333807,
-0.0595952161,
-0.0240075625,
0.052105736,
0.0329866745,
-0.0097637409,
-0.0078158239,
-0.0051560593,
-0.0012681412,
-0.0079471953,
-0.017377397,
-0.0126538733,
-0.0133688794,
0.0244157556,
0.0065914369,
-0.0017611691,
0.0325711556,
0.0058767535,
-0.0348112397,
0.0027640837,
0.0784882605,
-0.0243063681,
0.0251196697,
0.0554031134,
-0.0083404193,
0.0049798721,
-0.0073170685,
-0.0078742327,
0.0052094813,
0.0124205742,
0.0440974645,
-0.0076346556,
0.0098062186,
0.0035709525,
-0.0384589285,
-0.0206796806,
-0.0709463805,
-0.0262614507,
0.0068043647,
0.0413238481,
-0.0483970903,
0.0061075334,
-0.084674716,
0.020724915,
0.0006600016,
0.0419321097,
-0.0282900687,
-0.01099452,
0.0494054705,
-0.0347420014,
-0.0971375629,
-0.0119629307,
0.0638469979,
0.0396415666,
-0.0011285046,
0.0120027624,
-0.0298820231,
-0.0405274481,
-0.0166835357,
0.0481830873,
-0.0242827423,
-0.0148079451,
0.0009988148,
-0.0629647896,
-0.0293993764,
-0.0085618813,
-0.046026431,
-0.0228490792,
-0.0374454036,
-0.0197777357,
0.029501101,
-0.0119375223,
0.1040329784,
-0.0104357824,
0.0115130246,
-0.0422053002,
0.008688313,
-0.0295326021,
-5.552868173e-33,
-0.0279612876,
-0.0040814681,
0.001284205,
-0.0473247804,
0.0102633797,
0.0558994599,
0.0057316963,
-0.0102282297,
-0.0016991369,
-0.0123586962,
0.0005639282,
-0.001646852,
0.0176119935,
0.0185278319,
0.0735719576,
0.0198379625,
0.0210145228,
-0.0208118521,
0.0237781163,
-0.0201630257,
0.0243780743,
0.02683389,
0.0963977873,
-0.0119687235,
0.0154490368,
0.0134188673,
-0.0391092822,
-0.010367278,
0.0467821322,
0.0396401286,
-0.0023470512,
0.0188092571,
0.0060964581,
-0.0501374044,
-0.0378447026,
-0.0256488416,
0.0326462314,
-0.0132433167,
-0.0059219669,
0.0076705739,
0.057102032,
0.0041996683,
0.0171296969,
0.021798484,
-0.0405691117,
0.0278505273,
-0.0067936154,
-0.0514054634,
-0.0093775541,
0.0151408566,
-0.0452473313,
0.0412478,
0.0268444009,
0.066887103,
0.0235590078,
0.0655229166,
-0.0384394489,
0.0244384576,
-0.0367237292,
0.005343907,
0.047761891,
0.0622905456,
0.0171169546,
0.0050831186,
0.0474990532,
0.0225278288,
0.0151691576,
-0.0386665612,
-0.0068734568,
0.0089122849,
0.0381043293,
0.0265644863,
0.0257763471,
0.0610670261,
0.064829506,
-0.0319594815,
-0.0219410453,
0.018760955,
0.0326281376,
0.0724067613,
0.0534581058,
-0.0053571253,
-0.0211916715,
-0.0822823718,
-0.0539494269,
0.007909392,
0.0068010311,
-0.018280495,
0.0094874324,
-0.02288118,
0.0268981736,
0.0122144595,
0.0571282953,
-0.0298006684,
-0.0961633697,
0.0064808768,
-0.0122196367,
-0.0129316999,
-0.0040712599,
0.0348628722,
-0.0972405672,
-0.0664183646,
-0.0369555093,
0.0481887572,
-0.0126326829,
-0.0299844667,
-0.0265383571,
0.0086026248,
-0.0678895712,
-0.0030474921,
-0.0242897142,
-0.0076254914,
0.0288239587,
0.0318761282,
0.0490533486,
-0.0668028221,
0.0096142488,
0.0118938619,
-0.0017305346,
-0.0358682312,
0.0501220599,
-0.0369726159,
0.0185041949,
0.0141848717,
-0.0242279619,
-0.0169510487,
-0.0204124283,
-0.0025813091,
0.043190971,
0.0009727661,
-0.0167996883,
0.030760115,
2.568e-7,
0.031075187,
0.0727538317,
-0.060990762,
0.053847868,
-0.0070337625,
0.0492577925,
-0.0567359813,
-0.005277276,
0.0031389275,
0.0711334795,
0.0150672207,
-0.0055894917,
0.0884460211,
0.030852057,
-0.0521450415,
-0.0268805623,
-0.091016598,
0.029180849,
-0.0661929026,
-0.0238134209,
-0.0097619854,
0.0865965337,
0.0160522852,
-0.0082241558,
0.0103268092,
-0.0681949332,
0.0443194918,
-0.0507974699,
-0.0357427895,
0.0215267744,
-0.0003277717,
0.0430241153,
-0.0055098343,
0.0073435139,
-0.0034426872,
0.0331319422,
-0.0072145462,
0.0431053191,
0.0460417904,
0.0710373744,
0.0350333266,
-0.0289655253,
-0.0612875707,
-0.0580824614,
0.033338137,
-0.0734144524,
-0.0434497744,
-0.0669686496,
-0.0262529794,
0.0480718166,
0.0018276498,
0.0026818125,
-0.0276702289,
0.0352564864,
-0.0187443048,
-0.0571950264,
0.0110925082,
0.0413690545,
-0.0243007895,
0.0051081879,
-0.0571442433,
-0.0272074323,
-0.0268598106,
0.0246571824,
0.0213222299,
-0.0192080382,
0.0542924702,
2.353890933e-34,
0.0542769358,
0.0049680951,
-0.0149618685,
0.0495605767,
0.0442678407,
0.0127866538,
-0.0221510939,
0.0491004735,
-0.0017572899,
-0.0972729847,
0.0139924577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00888v1 | Papez: Resource-Efficient Speech Separation with Auditory Working Memory | 2024-07-01T01:23:06 | 2024-07-01T01:23:06 | Hyunseok Oh, Juheon Yi, Youngki Lee | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Transformer-based models recently reached state-of-the-art single-channel
speech separation accuracy; However, their extreme computational load makes it
difficult to deploy them in resource-constrained mobile or IoT devices. We thus
present Papez, a lightweight and computation-efficient single-channel speech
separation model. Papez is based on three key techniques. We first replace the
inter-chunk Transformer with small-sized auditory working memory. Second, we
adaptively prune the input tokens that do not need further processing. Finally,
we reduce the number of parameters through the recurrent transformer. Our
extensive evaluation shows that Papez achieves the best resource and accuracy
tradeoffs with a large margin. We publicly share our source code at
\texttt{https://github.com/snuhcs/Papez} | Papez: Resource-Efficient Speech Separation with Auditory Working Memory: Transformer-based models recently reached state-of-the-art single-channel
speech separation accuracy; However, their extreme computational load makes it
difficult to deploy them in resource-constrained mobile or IoT devices. We thus
present Papez, a lightweight and computation-efficient single-channel speech
separation model. Papez is based on three key techniques. We first replace the
inter-chunk Transformer with small-sized auditory working memory. Second, we
adaptively prune the input tokens that do not need further processing. Finally,
we reduce the number of parameters through the recurrent transformer. Our
extensive evaluation shows that Papez achieves the best resource and accuracy
tradeoffs with a large margin. We publicly share our source code at
\texttt{https://github.com/snuhcs/Papez} | [
-0.0113062598,
0.0010023649,
0.0345632769,
0.0186164472,
0.0001269564,
-0.0427589677,
0.0423833057,
-0.0328697227,
-0.0493061654,
0.0121060302,
-0.050187666,
-0.0405557938,
0.0156416912,
-0.0029638922,
0.0084807174,
-0.0606051274,
0.0063642124,
-0.0429054983,
0.0075005642,
0.023805175,
0.0242379587,
-0.0461154506,
-0.0354935527,
0.0312421136,
-0.0067703435,
-0.0166558921,
-0.0203309413,
-0.0052840076,
0.009234461,
-0.0157019179,
-0.021497678,
-0.0373295061,
0.0017406105,
0.0245001744,
0.0000019389,
-0.0077854553,
0.0092577394,
-0.0110298051,
-0.0005387453,
-0.0540939569,
0.016410647,
0.0248911474,
-0.0402513444,
0.0158983823,
0.0213681087,
-0.0441258289,
0.0227466393,
0.0271839835,
0.0646533892,
0.0631450191,
-0.0104169529,
-0.0072021387,
0.0139572015,
0.0020525362,
0.0137934061,
0.0057345843,
0.0036639103,
-0.1157844067,
-0.0245993026,
-0.039486073,
0.0065048635,
0.0354566909,
0.0399497226,
0.0236187503,
0.0255264416,
0.0368813649,
-0.0184942856,
-0.0844993666,
-0.0720010176,
0.0534024909,
-0.0069461931,
-0.0147140156,
0.0427267328,
0.0104179597,
-0.0285165627,
-0.0492020771,
-0.0435406007,
0.0478161685,
-0.0112104611,
-0.0193504486,
-0.0297008865,
0.0181836355,
0.0338782817,
-0.0411769599,
-0.0589752942,
-0.0036798795,
-0.0021652314,
-0.0506066307,
0.0153559837,
-0.0001996859,
0.003909267,
-0.0114801507,
0.059342768,
0.032643646,
-0.0158501733,
-0.0529462583,
-0.0427381881,
-0.0800606906,
-0.063021414,
-0.0069171647,
-0.0146019729,
0.0257277917,
-0.0531342439,
0.01172073,
0.0284221116,
0.0116885696,
-0.0039159316,
0.0036252169,
0.0138770454,
0.0107885022,
-0.0262072049,
0.0072350875,
0.0040724408,
0.0487816557,
-0.0461669303,
-0.0494436584,
-0.008343854,
-0.0353104509,
-0.0455217399,
-0.0093963277,
0.0316582471,
0.0229380447,
-0.0373019688,
-0.0154411756,
0.0785279498,
0.0397641361,
-0.0240577832,
0.0225406215,
0.0204870179,
-0.0649546161,
-0.0447378904,
0.0684165582,
0.0476098433,
-0.0077941888,
0.0235773232,
0.0443209708,
0.0061080307,
-0.0125786262,
0.0072018751,
0.0169805903,
0.0364383236,
-0.0460028499,
0.0177944899,
-0.0762594119,
0.0573806837,
-0.0062742434,
-0.0063919057,
-0.0443540402,
0.001726045,
-0.0007723983,
-0.0170883425,
0.0139410868,
-0.0097555649,
-0.009569074,
0.0637749583,
0.0135929352,
-0.0183048993,
0.0137315672,
0.0788129941,
-0.0127163781,
0.0250254497,
-0.0513478257,
0.010994046,
0.0497685559,
-0.0086576603,
-0.0928268954,
0.00097215,
-0.0417412892,
-0.0119776186,
-0.0003386085,
0.0324740373,
0.0728906542,
-0.0271332599,
-0.0070513771,
0.0596467033,
0.0585980639,
0.026302442,
0.0242354814,
-0.0089676436,
0.0289798342,
0.0080349976,
-0.0005726654,
-0.0435870737,
0.0424613245,
-0.0050803786,
-0.0145634897,
0.0437175259,
0.028088022,
-0.0274714716,
-0.022925606,
0.0167323779,
-0.0515054241,
-0.0079985224,
0.0117045129,
0.039424371,
-0.0134919928,
-0.0426089838,
0.0699706227,
0.0092795389,
-0.067821309,
-0.0477002524,
0.0106050204,
0.0181642286,
0.0123796016,
0.0053552408,
-0.0487524197,
0.0037479091,
-0.0528043322,
-0.006023088,
0.0326537788,
-0.0633487105,
0.0372230709,
0.1169553846,
-0.052241385,
-0.0034227874,
0.0388079323,
-0.0127494866,
-0.0167167671,
0.0139629869,
-0.0201278795,
0.007796884,
0.0325848199,
0.05143217,
-0.0035657138,
0.0068673324,
-0.044476226,
0.0214964617,
0.0221296232,
0.0520082153,
0.024796892,
-0.0284460131,
0.0179739706,
0.0340181179,
-0.08469069,
0.046342086,
0.0487960614,
-0.0617047995,
0.0124810813,
0.0457837656,
-0.0090929959,
0.045484174,
0.0592706725,
0.0100214863,
-0.0563282631,
0.0351027735,
0.0080037182,
0.0158514176,
0.001197851,
0.0391098447,
0.0582287051,
0.0233006813,
0.0298837908,
-0.0247869026,
0.0008742539,
0.0037951169,
-0.023735879,
0.0269712694,
-0.0322510414,
-0.0268217977,
-0.0200077835,
0.0337763131,
-0.0382104851,
0.007995504,
-0.0196198039,
-0.0085219936,
-0.0402762331,
-0.0113625824,
-0.0205890965,
0.0486987904,
-0.0437218659,
-0.0064726779,
-0.015690295,
0.0201264322,
0.0316754542,
0.0044496614,
-0.0088300211,
-0.0270469841,
-0.0211283863,
-0.0044500162,
-0.043703258,
-0.0431869291,
-0.0089741945,
-0.0302126091,
-0.0176001582,
0.0456495136,
-0.0050204694,
-0.0370053686,
-0.0236507133,
-0.017024288,
0.0099920826,
0.0061215512,
0.0463012792,
0.0206507854,
-0.0225048997,
0.0061743855,
-0.008938184,
0.0538238361,
0.026705496,
0.0002469191,
-0.0228761379,
-0.0093955873,
-0.0221702103,
0.0076603079,
0.0323436446,
0.0048625316,
0.0593276955,
0.0148749547,
0.0379085876,
-0.01695011,
0.0614853539,
0.0129759731,
0.0473808795,
-0.0368947275,
-0.0110610574,
-0.0253320951,
-0.0363058858,
-0.0007979462,
0.0016925709,
-0.0393735245,
-0.012135528,
-0.0332756825,
-0.0057815388,
0.0000204382,
-0.0455011241,
-0.022143824,
-0.032994926,
-0.0413146876,
-0.0012928685,
0.0138655063,
-0.0286796857,
-0.0238395873,
-0.0417395905,
-0.0192189552,
-0.0108003737,
0.0000984692,
-0.0446475782,
-0.0673875809,
0.0650853366,
-0.0183116961,
-0.0134017793,
-0.0113290846,
-0.0344747901,
-0.0433207229,
0.0474441387,
-0.0154133849,
0.0068368558,
0.0270486325,
-0.0331920274,
-0.051527705,
0.0460564867,
0.0681446493,
0.0772802383,
0.0079662949,
0.0340545103,
-0.0197267402,
0.0591294244,
0.0117775667,
0.0434752144,
0.0447761677,
-0.0209739693,
0.0539194271,
0.0264716092,
0.1268561035,
0.0021526797,
-0.0339843407,
-0.0211682487,
0.0075371703,
-0.0057683978,
-0.0177989416,
0.0367117636,
0.0485334136,
-0.0657052323,
-0.0121706892,
0.0849115252,
0.028882917,
-0.0879687071,
-0.0168363117,
0.020514138,
0.0031243656,
0.0012937852,
-0.0383097827,
0.0136529058,
-0.0328976139,
0.0499846302,
0.0261492226,
0.0085218828,
0.0014225678,
-0.0154878888,
-0.0777880549,
0.0095080854,
0.0195621792,
0.005087832,
-0.0295230635,
-0.0267020855,
-0.0152777471,
-0.0314800143,
0.0223038439,
0.0171277113,
-0.0092637986,
-0.0309014209,
0.0317277461,
-0.0739251375,
0.025246365,
-0.0388871618,
-0.0408670716,
0.024837371,
0.0199452359,
0.0112658311,
-0.014157136,
-0.0397651382,
0.0169313774,
-0.0110497037,
-0.0409797132,
-0.0111936629,
0.0049912347,
-0.0048109158,
0.0049842843,
0.0097884377,
0.0236642584,
-0.0552323237,
-0.0172477607,
0.0431827009,
0.0183104631,
-0.0033062615,
-0.0105962474,
-0.0021573503,
0.0269358531,
-0.0155340545,
0.0665999949,
0.0067639952,
-0.0421992391,
-0.0656965747,
0.0085327821,
0.0339829586,
-0.0179671571,
-0.0082738623,
-0.0214525424,
0.0493981168,
-0.0797992647,
-0.0054927096,
-0.0131937573,
0.021577172,
0.0591181703,
0.0099964067,
0.0182597041,
0.0348066613,
0.0497507192,
-0.0610327087,
-0.0049051172,
0.0106304679,
0.0151688503,
-0.0787540674,
-0.0053210561,
0.0240184255,
-0.016620405,
-0.0167781655,
0.0698708519,
-0.1243496463,
-0.0365003645,
0.0595626682,
-0.0213447381,
0.018467119,
0.0437357835,
-0.0066881925,
-0.0184433665,
-0.004516012,
0.0057738652,
-0.0472512282,
0.0629684329,
0.0954532027,
-0.0170664936,
0.0166641586,
0.0132765723,
-0.0394436717,
0.0374345556,
-0.0132762697,
0.0280453004,
-0.045848731,
0.0312378109,
-0.0342012607,
-0.0070699607,
0.0796681643,
0.0495549999,
0.0237746481,
-0.0095978985,
0.0384875201,
0.0054207547,
0.0516134389,
-0.0404126793,
0.0091367979,
-0.0366105586,
0.0111484546,
-0.0130967619,
0.0077707442,
0.0473973602,
-0.0481386632,
0.0447853841,
0.019273011,
0.0092336172,
-0.0334479809,
0.0085139591,
-0.0242807399,
-0.0063366028,
0.0136367222,
0.0602023788,
0.0026940787,
-0.0218842309,
0.0204334576,
-0.0049375608,
-0.0136420559,
-0.034182325,
0.015114814,
-0.0098632686,
-0.0235707015,
0.021832237,
0.0356954262,
-0.0069459691,
0.000276928,
0.0426702686,
0.0507764071,
0.0259314086,
-0.0384967476,
0.0145938993,
-0.001337216,
0.0443432331,
-0.0109584806,
0.0304663703,
-0.0260639861,
-0.0124295242,
0.0485461578,
-0.0039144647,
-0.0194980521,
-0.0124791246,
0.0485748164,
-0.0588505231,
-0.0024129211,
-0.0539510921,
-0.0164584536,
-0.0156469028,
-0.0043658293,
-0.0098565249,
-0.0306697283,
0.041866865,
-0.0356378332,
0.0552932471,
-0.0295391902,
0.0106047895,
0.0118922638,
-0.0111969095,
-0.01289827,
0.038158901,
-0.0451938845,
0.0462699495,
-0.0324035138,
0.0281588249,
-6.62637847e-33,
-0.0061586783,
0.0288677737,
0.0233574454,
0.0059162448,
-0.0240751095,
-0.021675447,
-0.0387702882,
0.0067343637,
0.0181996636,
-0.0262565594,
-0.0123007623,
0.0420086384,
0.0453203842,
0.040050976,
0.0173046105,
0.0121797184,
0.1016253605,
-0.019171631,
-0.0196626727,
0.0195959397,
0.0378166251,
0.068276912,
-0.0137921683,
-0.0079697007,
-0.0540622286,
-0.0340573192,
0.0065063699,
-0.0369649492,
0.0489553511,
0.0217071977,
-0.0112961521,
0.0204549767,
-0.0007947963,
-0.0490979701,
0.0121798851,
0.0463926457,
-0.078425847,
-0.0244392082,
0.0011281258,
-0.015022262,
-0.0263356809,
-0.0480378643,
0.0901819468,
0.0600467995,
-0.0142166624,
-0.0316819511,
0.019338429,
-0.0080992244,
-0.0527370349,
-0.0086493436,
-0.0259111114,
0.0148740951,
-0.0036349269,
-0.0029280228,
0.0573606491,
-0.0158880278,
-0.0694228411,
0.0023667195,
-0.1595288515,
0.0090630641,
-0.0162420385,
0.034834858,
0.0191869251,
0.0473734625,
0.0178808048,
0.0417538509,
0.0702119246,
-0.070708625,
-0.0129629886,
0.0090267332,
0.0128897941,
0.0459179208,
0.0334719941,
-0.0837428421,
0.0566049032,
-0.0336995423,
-0.0597715229,
-0.0497244485,
0.0328876115,
0.0244661793,
0.0515695252,
0.0039219535,
-0.0392200202,
0.0247757472,
0.0172164198,
0.0267711189,
-0.0278461762,
0.0122326976,
0.0308928229,
0.0471857712,
-0.0244295821,
-0.0208052099,
0.0532005578,
-0.0002796923,
0.0926279202,
0.0364558175,
-0.0093018766,
-0.0034068755,
-0.0050756042,
-0.0315370336,
-0.0739842355,
0.0056463624,
0.0140860789,
0.0320972279,
0.0138535518,
-0.0259999204,
0.00466114,
0.055375129,
-0.0572410896,
-0.024649933,
-0.0367094576,
0.0920531973,
-0.0114339227,
0.0798489898,
0.0335250944,
-0.0135237724,
-0.0013122169,
0.0132988496,
-0.0635928735,
-0.0131469788,
-0.00234327,
0.0106345462,
0.0499880016,
0.0251469761,
-0.0317672342,
0.0112716574,
-0.0094452361,
-0.0079145925,
0.0300556924,
-0.0352665372,
-0.0122306421,
0.0173648,
2.748e-7,
-0.0944816917,
0.0119310338,
0.031955339,
-0.037230704,
0.0486572199,
0.0045293034,
-0.0070928163,
-0.0452565588,
-0.0053963065,
-0.0091243312,
-0.0027914802,
0.0502762869,
0.092365399,
0.0123205055,
-0.0882041007,
-0.0647825301,
-0.0589240603,
-0.0076290336,
0.0060513588,
0.0201601256,
-0.0056287721,
0.0664562136,
0.0022091158,
-0.032573577,
0.0120402118,
0.0012854619,
0.0132150901,
0.0148701174,
0.0422113799,
-0.0361799337,
0.0372560397,
0.0102254627,
-0.002592996,
-0.0674500987,
-0.0040745055,
0.0142465774,
0.011612514,
0.0607016385,
-0.0194725245,
-0.0720440969,
0.0095182154,
0.0465986542,
-0.0122279394,
0.0288150627,
0.0241423696,
-0.0037058538,
-0.0084491689,
-0.0022458725,
-0.0010117051,
0.0310833603,
-0.0401076153,
0.0145303449,
-0.0082652736,
-0.0296623223,
-0.028097257,
0.0014656252,
0.0202323403,
-0.0528092496,
-0.0191856995,
0.0083547356,
-0.0570255704,
-0.0135782696,
-0.0251023583,
-0.0222239252,
0.004979433,
-0.012886418,
-0.0253619198,
2.119786871e-34,
0.0134916212,
-0.0315430798,
0.0151034268,
0.0430838726,
-0.0180711616,
-0.0346558392,
0.0284135211,
-0.0139622213,
-0.0548789762,
-0.0267920345,
-0.0324196666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00886v1 | Mechanistic Interpretation through Contextual Decomposition in Transformers | 2024-07-01T01:12:20 | 2024-07-01T01:12:20 | Aliyah R. Hsu, Yeshwanth Cherapanamjeri, Anobel Y. Odisho, Peter R. Carroll, Bin Yu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformers exhibit impressive capabilities but are often regarded as black
boxes due to challenges in understanding the complex nonlinear relationships
between features. Interpreting machine learning models is of paramount
importance to mitigate risks, and mechanistic interpretability is in particular
of current interest as it opens up a window for guiding manual modifications
and reverse-engineering solutions. In this work, we introduce contextual
decomposition for transformers (CD-T), extending a prior work on CD for RNNs
and CNNs, to address mechanistic interpretation computationally efficiently.
CD-T is a flexible interpretation method for transformers. It can capture
contributions of combinations of input features or source internal components
(e.g. attention heads, feed-forward networks) to (1) final predictions or (2)
the output of any target internal component. Using CD-T, we propose a novel
algorithm for circuit discovery. On a real-world pathology report
classification task: we show CD-T distills a more faithful circuit of attention
heads with improved computational efficiency (speed up 2x) than a prior
benchmark, path patching. As a versatile interpretation method, CD-T also
exhibits exceptional capabilities for local interpretations. CD-T is shown to
reliably find words and phrases of contrasting sentiment/topic on SST-2 and
AGNews datasets. Through human experiments, we demonstrate CD-T enables users
to identify the more accurate of two models and to better trust a model's
outputs compared to alternative interpretation methods such as SHAP and LIME. | Mechanistic Interpretation through Contextual Decomposition in Transformers: Transformers exhibit impressive capabilities but are often regarded as black
boxes due to challenges in understanding the complex nonlinear relationships
between features. Interpreting machine learning models is of paramount
importance to mitigate risks, and mechanistic interpretability is in particular
of current interest as it opens up a window for guiding manual modifications
and reverse-engineering solutions. In this work, we introduce contextual
decomposition for transformers (CD-T), extending a prior work on CD for RNNs
and CNNs, to address mechanistic interpretation computationally efficiently.
CD-T is a flexible interpretation method for transformers. It can capture
contributions of combinations of input features or source internal components
(e.g. attention heads, feed-forward networks) to (1) final predictions or (2)
the output of any target internal component. Using CD-T, we propose a novel
algorithm for circuit discovery. On a real-world pathology report
classification task: we show CD-T distills a more faithful circuit of attention
heads with improved computational efficiency (speed up 2x) than a prior
benchmark, path patching. As a versatile interpretation method, CD-T also
exhibits exceptional capabilities for local interpretations. CD-T is shown to
reliably find words and phrases of contrasting sentiment/topic on SST-2 and
AGNews datasets. Through human experiments, we demonstrate CD-T enables users
to identify the more accurate of two models and to better trust a model's
outputs compared to alternative interpretation methods such as SHAP and LIME. | [
-0.0083501041,
0.061936453,
-0.013523967,
0.0371771976,
-0.0180535391,
0.0060561169,
-0.0119773922,
-0.0090097003,
-0.0455444567,
-0.0220101643,
-0.0491902493,
0.0009717759,
0.00845984,
0.0341775976,
-0.0153905936,
-0.0331395045,
0.0274758283,
0.0581927672,
-0.0564449579,
0.0153816771,
0.0033080629,
0.0112005966,
0.0147915939,
0.0741956234,
0.0259939786,
-0.0158752874,
0.0214491002,
-0.0051450618,
0.0486427918,
0.0185270049,
-0.0105355419,
0.0430560037,
-0.0082079777,
0.0664555281,
0.0000024345,
-0.0135575198,
-0.034044899,
0.0213218275,
-0.0473433584,
0.0064699897,
0.0184631553,
-0.0620320886,
-0.0143805807,
0.0029923921,
-0.008170424,
0.0007732501,
0.0379481688,
0.08718656,
0.0160575695,
0.0293830466,
-0.0165383406,
-0.0277191401,
0.0042782314,
-0.0222396962,
0.0197399445,
-0.0203018505,
-0.016160354,
-0.0649793148,
-0.0363820754,
-0.035784889,
-0.0337280668,
0.0479718409,
0.0521309189,
0.0342636593,
0.0286428146,
0.0498929136,
0.0064870082,
0.0245783366,
0.0018994875,
0.0434064902,
-0.0352451652,
-0.0267139245,
0.0017343336,
-0.0141322175,
-0.0151652424,
0.0074551487,
-0.0069241701,
-0.0154117579,
-0.0282387175,
0.0264866482,
-0.0321560502,
0.0212221984,
0.028303897,
-0.0295072645,
-0.0368158221,
0.0180246886,
-0.01397538,
-0.0007494644,
-0.0121160448,
0.0140572162,
0.0119706262,
0.0202077553,
0.0383476242,
0.0061727986,
-0.005664364,
0.0039188592,
-0.0187493581,
-0.0333227776,
0.0124287894,
-0.0888350382,
0.0407953151,
-0.0050782356,
-0.0490889363,
0.0140273729,
-0.0076433965,
0.0095556406,
-0.0652349815,
0.0475128926,
-0.0608443767,
0.0196772013,
-0.0446432568,
-0.0337967537,
0.0029155507,
0.0095311068,
-0.0217651092,
-0.0144989109,
-0.0535350926,
-0.0051263482,
-0.0290336274,
-0.0432220884,
0.0173110086,
0.0270892493,
-0.0425242446,
0.0263766088,
0.0008327446,
0.0427138358,
-0.0095817642,
-0.0027125913,
-0.0455397181,
-0.0212550554,
-0.0286602043,
-0.0008060141,
0.0038587293,
-0.0159492139,
-0.000165762,
0.1082185134,
0.0149124451,
-0.0434558056,
-0.0294691529,
-0.0535874628,
-0.0488749295,
-0.0263748337,
0.0231277402,
-0.0251330063,
0.0204721689,
-0.0009169322,
0.0093968892,
-0.0033084734,
-0.0106285848,
0.0030420951,
-0.0120582404,
0.0785125196,
0.0281339865,
-0.038888216,
-0.0233919322,
0.0085499436,
-0.0025231054,
0.0264112148,
0.0122631919,
0.0618039779,
-0.0064748074,
-0.0205909032,
0.0052200961,
-0.0089206835,
0.0262669586,
-0.0435508229,
-0.008536228,
-0.0289165601,
-0.0459171981,
0.0011364578,
0.0117451176,
0.0072202361,
-0.0120775988,
-0.0455176644,
0.026319813,
0.0100554293,
0.0656078234,
0.0576840602,
0.0073422166,
-0.0011811751,
-0.0013373035,
0.0023211061,
-0.0559005775,
0.0256079398,
-0.0542631447,
-0.0038923104,
-0.0426088385,
0.0129826944,
-0.0163020771,
-0.0379334129,
-0.0054884148,
-0.0049068118,
0.0238742884,
-0.0047370382,
0.059450008,
-0.003278458,
-0.0340339579,
0.0465211384,
0.0335218683,
-0.0216092076,
-0.0410899222,
-0.0687254593,
-0.0231045838,
0.0437999628,
0.0397846512,
-0.0412839241,
-0.0290688593,
-0.0119754439,
-0.0429820158,
-0.0158515293,
-0.0374086462,
0.0178151038,
0.0225358885,
-0.0019625339,
-0.0116129313,
-0.0064637293,
0.0350832567,
0.0084565561,
-0.0296906512,
-0.0113688456,
0.0076433308,
-0.0155032715,
-0.0084276656,
0.022784885,
-0.000592126,
-0.0172268897,
0.028265072,
0.0608505048,
0.024762718,
0.0336995758,
-0.0051065958,
-0.0174235478,
0.0425615795,
-0.0656013861,
-0.0299314093,
0.0683940053,
-0.0294267181,
-0.01035285,
-0.0197660923,
-0.0672047585,
-0.0350231566,
0.0594308861,
-0.0383804291,
-0.0056082718,
0.0285326615,
-0.0668467432,
0.0184832402,
-0.0289949216,
-0.0352434702,
0.0045334119,
0.0229302198,
-0.0214006472,
0.0662569255,
-0.0341705717,
-0.0423488468,
-0.0023423764,
-0.0380429216,
0.0033542085,
-0.023451725,
-0.028854074,
-0.0063778143,
-0.0167436786,
-0.0295185186,
0.0106667746,
-0.0263888128,
-0.0066175386,
-0.0053771604,
-0.0405019522,
-0.0164078679,
-0.0325119942,
0.0151051749,
0.0389470495,
-0.0019106304,
0.0388729386,
0.0118029499,
0.0081814397,
0.0053624404,
0.0083165085,
0.00826615,
0.0467476137,
0.0061884578,
-0.0171777587,
-0.0047271871,
-0.0336112417,
-0.0480228066,
0.0848463774,
0.0169425085,
-0.0164990909,
-0.0406723097,
-0.0031607517,
0.0520837232,
-0.0057850135,
-0.0102307666,
-0.0660347566,
-0.0159409437,
-0.0238086544,
-0.0006290629,
0.0754038244,
0.0151660247,
0.1058444381,
0.0268638469,
0.0204462018,
0.0099021289,
0.0006739126,
-0.0392978266,
0.0195598435,
-0.0261090714,
-0.0547775626,
0.0088094408,
0.065211542,
0.0128462408,
0.0124482354,
-0.0620428361,
0.0029269638,
-0.0036138098,
-0.0014046893,
-0.0263649952,
-0.0197009947,
0.0039288346,
0.0129855322,
0.0012771996,
-0.025083255,
0.0955454931,
0.0210859384,
0.0168321896,
-0.0510560498,
-0.0409552976,
-0.0424700826,
0.081439428,
-0.0010520007,
0.0282167047,
0.0441521853,
0.0016332261,
0.0089126267,
-0.0021723628,
0.0151023883,
-0.0165414549,
0.0621540882,
0.0171790682,
-0.0008817445,
-0.0035319538,
-0.0306659397,
-0.0315646902,
-0.051135473,
-0.0040807244,
0.0103735635,
0.0401193127,
-0.04578517,
-0.0578370877,
0.0381503478,
0.0145646166,
0.0216897372,
0.0182204712,
-0.0290969461,
-0.0120114125,
0.0394034237,
-0.002049312,
0.0127606839,
0.0700252429,
-0.032523565,
0.0209458638,
0.0625137761,
0.0251931343,
0.0150668453,
-0.0643355176,
-0.0116103552,
-0.0347179584,
-0.0099212779,
0.0204429403,
-0.0309486594,
-0.005945445,
-0.0813787207,
-0.0271786284,
0.0667160079,
0.0098712482,
-0.0874518529,
0.0458352044,
0.0246193036,
-0.0428826883,
0.0043087471,
0.024382025,
-0.0541500226,
-0.0430645235,
-0.0052573341,
0.0264370013,
0.0080275992,
0.0002767874,
0.023131581,
-0.0278755818,
0.0458956622,
0.000468599,
-0.0702608004,
-0.0790413544,
-0.0506817661,
-0.0262001958,
-0.0617232807,
-0.0005248037,
-0.0144421868,
-0.0052317483,
0.0022424231,
-0.0240318626,
-0.0257182084,
-0.0524150766,
0.0320353173,
0.0034987668,
-0.013358783,
0.0777723342,
0.0005420407,
-0.0089600701,
-0.0050082123,
0.0132923387,
-0.0151329627,
0.0535736866,
-0.0159947723,
0.0708239451,
0.0172929987,
-0.0186717454,
-0.0407219008,
0.0431544557,
-0.0658137798,
-0.0236936472,
-0.0764424503,
0.0677290112,
-0.0462079346,
-0.0397504941,
-0.0463300906,
0.007319408,
0.0210063625,
0.0676789284,
0.0414397195,
-0.0441892147,
-0.051916562,
-0.0092829838,
0.022240404,
-0.0195941962,
-0.0934494883,
0.010516339,
0.0176914949,
-0.0881948173,
-0.0173781905,
-0.0261291191,
-0.0271311048,
0.0183208119,
-0.0168846939,
-0.0524721108,
0.0145871006,
-0.0028776494,
-0.0849176273,
0.062047638,
0.0345277824,
0.0246329159,
-0.0338799581,
-0.0089677377,
0.0757010132,
-0.0627133697,
-0.0710361302,
0.0306735728,
-0.0657324046,
-0.0102347527,
0.0460168235,
0.0188324619,
0.0185924005,
0.0316781178,
-0.0204772539,
-0.0367977284,
0.0158803482,
0.0680990517,
-0.0022717898,
0.0216277242,
0.044362735,
-0.0003360253,
-0.0082538472,
0.016244106,
-0.0021468813,
0.0489633568,
0.0182629861,
0.0048259869,
-0.0426162779,
0.0032571619,
0.0360671058,
-0.0028358065,
0.0873278305,
0.0406413861,
-0.0170393325,
-0.0100809252,
0.0275569391,
0.0290713776,
0.0173619352,
-0.039125178,
-0.0319661424,
0.0123001384,
-0.0332371369,
-0.0390356705,
0.0193646867,
0.0184781756,
-0.0257224254,
-0.0814023092,
0.052968353,
0.0518417731,
-0.0069044661,
-0.0152187543,
0.0300957691,
-0.0096806157,
-0.0041616079,
0.006762445,
0.0206536856,
0.0040861326,
0.0102593964,
0.0209379662,
0.017790528,
-0.0700965747,
0.0404269435,
-0.1130950302,
0.0062950742,
-0.0121552479,
-0.0036312819,
0.0247252509,
-0.0393866859,
0.0106221996,
-0.0407293178,
-0.0016751847,
-0.023877332,
0.0234844014,
-0.0077619888,
0.0226542298,
0.0318146348,
0.0193240047,
0.0049321167,
-0.0445371717,
0.0630296916,
-0.014048906,
0.0263503566,
-0.0217322651,
-0.0335661508,
-0.0282456353,
-0.0234437939,
0.0046982928,
0.0050941645,
-0.0347415432,
-0.0022740818,
-0.0792644247,
-0.0409194864,
0.0693561882,
-0.0145022068,
0.0287307166,
-0.01813774,
0.0266897865,
0.0506974459,
0.033058729,
-0.0163380783,
0.0205246396,
0.0279120244,
-0.0300066434,
-0.0241747443,
-0.0029379888,
-6.797692078e-33,
0.027360972,
-0.049858354,
-0.0281951297,
-0.0080932546,
0.0084374705,
0.042879276,
-0.0416791514,
-0.0246385299,
0.0106214406,
0.0398249552,
-0.0035039261,
0.0259638987,
0.0015334552,
0.0189095829,
-0.021626329,
-0.0424856171,
0.0637415424,
0.0348889306,
0.009554863,
0.0321066305,
0.0681613237,
0.0558589809,
0.0780424178,
-0.1015967205,
-0.0260007996,
0.0110717649,
-0.0115385223,
0.0181491598,
-0.0385832265,
0.0715736523,
-0.0212738793,
0.0539185815,
0.0301018879,
-0.0493163913,
-0.0108306529,
0.0046679629,
-0.0653361678,
0.0114065325,
-0.0203719921,
0.0248681996,
-0.0468876436,
-0.0370631851,
0.0844741613,
0.0052981987,
-0.0185158309,
-0.0325921215,
0.0414452292,
-0.0076995799,
0.0291557834,
-0.0492080599,
-0.0438862741,
0.0201051328,
-0.0178943593,
-0.0294942446,
0.0363145992,
0.0355677381,
0.003598551,
0.079672195,
-0.0849733576,
0.0030359542,
0.0180544052,
0.0206014328,
0.0384046845,
0.0129429968,
-0.0110647939,
0.048447974,
0.0365808532,
-0.0082548521,
-0.0365250595,
-0.0250729285,
0.0236083865,
0.0648715422,
0.043652676,
0.0272058416,
0.0743926167,
-0.003928232,
-0.097295709,
0.0220576078,
-0.0144514237,
0.0467164107,
0.0677066743,
0.0134250652,
-0.0238604061,
0.0206153896,
0.0048265029,
-0.0179347638,
-0.036380697,
0.001490347,
0.0103189703,
0.0056269164,
-0.0459624119,
0.0254311953,
0.0134192174,
-0.0584434159,
0.0561698489,
0.0491513945,
0.0451119356,
0.0141903926,
0.0071886075,
-0.0263465736,
-0.0020075082,
0.0205860678,
-0.0050354186,
0.0148446066,
0.0222429335,
-0.016334936,
0.0343474299,
0.0269498266,
-0.0026032026,
-0.0043606362,
-0.0184115339,
0.0040264479,
-0.0406004377,
0.0367909707,
0.0428082012,
0.0239777863,
-0.0140440613,
0.0275292601,
0.0031759304,
0.0562030487,
-0.008458226,
0.0535102151,
0.0074228114,
0.0348016843,
-0.0021869862,
-0.0440889448,
-0.0013085866,
0.0252544079,
0.0342316926,
-0.0803559273,
-0.0241418779,
0.02996796,
3.212e-7,
0.0667523667,
0.0444293842,
0.0294504184,
0.0024014371,
0.0576653741,
0.038290225,
0.023603892,
0.0133786378,
-0.0308589973,
-0.0148405991,
0.039057333,
0.0295460429,
0.0448277816,
0.0193279069,
-0.0465465859,
0.0111703733,
-0.0656724423,
0.0192197841,
-0.0030773126,
0.0297311712,
0.0482798144,
0.0928887203,
-0.0161483698,
-0.0293646734,
0.0474342853,
0.0523080602,
0.0332580023,
-0.0534268208,
0.0513390675,
-0.0181068741,
-0.0450003333,
-0.0516524948,
-0.0066865566,
0.0034398835,
-0.0158658437,
-0.0073345224,
-0.0007920616,
0.0554537661,
-0.025703935,
-0.0660741776,
0.0009233219,
0.0157888643,
0.0306155402,
-0.0185615886,
0.0479051806,
-0.0750527829,
-0.0532594137,
-0.0723456666,
-0.0035077492,
0.0117965611,
0.0432178862,
0.0121382074,
-0.0097328275,
0.0261080321,
-0.0380030125,
-0.0290988497,
-0.017665023,
-0.0841136128,
-0.0035534867,
0.0185967609,
-0.0455799401,
0.0074330554,
-0.0454682186,
-0.025812475,
0.0978232771,
-0.0308024995,
-0.0484269448,
3.230783775e-34,
0.0373851359,
0.0181525405,
0.009354163,
0.0446211696,
0.0146136209,
0.0100457529,
0.0325527973,
-0.0289531406,
0.017683072,
-0.0907571688,
-0.0277570933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00870v1 | Roleplay-doh: Enabling Domain-Experts to Create LLM-simulated Patients via Eliciting and Adhering to Principles | 2024-07-01T00:43:02 | 2024-07-01T00:43:02 | Ryan Louie, Ananjan Nandi, William Fang, Cheng Chang, Emma Brunskill, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Recent works leverage LLMs to roleplay realistic social scenarios, aiding
novices in practicing their social skills. However, simulating sensitive
interactions, such as in mental health, is challenging. Privacy concerns
restrict data access, and collecting expert feedback, although vital, is
laborious. To address this, we develop Roleplay-doh, a novel human-LLM
collaboration pipeline that elicits qualitative feedback from a domain-expert,
which is transformed into a set of principles, or natural language rules, that
govern an LLM-prompted roleplay. We apply this pipeline to enable senior mental
health supporters to create customized AI patients for simulated practice
partners for novice counselors. After uncovering issues in GPT-4 simulations
not adhering to expert-defined principles, we also introduce a novel
principle-adherence prompting pipeline which shows 30\% improvements in
response quality and principle following for the downstream task. Via a user
study with 25 counseling experts, we demonstrate that the pipeline makes it
easy and effective to create AI patients that more faithfully resemble real
patients, as judged by creators and third-party counselors. | Roleplay-doh: Enabling Domain-Experts to Create LLM-simulated Patients via Eliciting and Adhering to Principles: Recent works leverage LLMs to roleplay realistic social scenarios, aiding
novices in practicing their social skills. However, simulating sensitive
interactions, such as in mental health, is challenging. Privacy concerns
restrict data access, and collecting expert feedback, although vital, is
laborious. To address this, we develop Roleplay-doh, a novel human-LLM
collaboration pipeline that elicits qualitative feedback from a domain-expert,
which is transformed into a set of principles, or natural language rules, that
govern an LLM-prompted roleplay. We apply this pipeline to enable senior mental
health supporters to create customized AI patients for simulated practice
partners for novice counselors. After uncovering issues in GPT-4 simulations
not adhering to expert-defined principles, we also introduce a novel
principle-adherence prompting pipeline which shows 30\% improvements in
response quality and principle following for the downstream task. Via a user
study with 25 counseling experts, we demonstrate that the pipeline makes it
easy and effective to create AI patients that more faithfully resemble real
patients, as judged by creators and third-party counselors. | [
0.0874902532,
0.0234684404,
-0.0284835193,
0.0051043481,
-0.0480909087,
-0.0097655207,
0.0289189536,
0.0057419706,
0.0585506298,
0.0364208594,
-0.026379196,
-0.0417639352,
-0.0066961679,
0.0226974413,
0.0019554559,
-0.071057342,
-0.0003532973,
0.007161953,
0.05460307,
0.0086132567,
-0.0221135356,
0.0248753149,
-0.0620684251,
0.0422752611,
0.0017324749,
-0.0105264811,
-0.0018921886,
0.0448580272,
0.0291360002,
-0.0697449893,
-0.0005201199,
0.0352127925,
0.0240935441,
-0.0419369563,
0.0000022773,
-0.0351218805,
0.0001866002,
0.01495119,
0.0101934457,
-0.0598992147,
0.0187482517,
-0.00500644,
0.009165612,
0.0203671418,
-0.0511157177,
0.0114605809,
0.0272878129,
0.0354798101,
0.0663060546,
0.0431430675,
-0.0188517962,
0.0232526213,
-0.012453177,
-0.0075997668,
0.0170753505,
-0.0214552917,
-0.0078846933,
0.0265700072,
0.110516265,
-0.0405076481,
0.0176930912,
0.0226329789,
0.0030690797,
0.0115331067,
0.0094607053,
0.0317803919,
0.0348919295,
-0.0217717066,
0.0024233784,
0.067419976,
0.0850935876,
0.0416466147,
0.0270843096,
-0.0053780093,
0.0697213933,
0.0686894283,
-0.0279625803,
0.0003538303,
-0.024954427,
0.0145266252,
-0.0160449669,
0.0103327641,
0.0210923143,
-0.0181466863,
0.0729667321,
0.0069375494,
-0.0035857591,
-0.020325454,
-0.028999811,
-0.0034062399,
-0.0118748033,
-0.0468445346,
0.01546585,
0.0503127314,
-0.0826033354,
-0.0028845377,
-0.0410130434,
0.0485246442,
0.0339252986,
0.0356174223,
0.0534644276,
0.0314091109,
0.0058358833,
0.0026296161,
0.0472880937,
-0.0129810385,
-0.0008491194,
0.0024802459,
-0.0058667045,
0.0372396111,
-0.0571152978,
0.0037045567,
-0.0220834706,
0.0307109561,
-0.0350182913,
0.0017615661,
-0.0228258111,
0.0085488008,
-0.0632088333,
0.0407199413,
0.0031784202,
0.0338096693,
-0.010344252,
0.019418709,
-0.0540172495,
-0.0180439726,
-0.0337867551,
0.0085566677,
0.006957165,
-0.0884687379,
0.0081392108,
-0.0100203697,
-0.0324841589,
0.0018021775,
0.0310326032,
0.0852120519,
0.0145983165,
-0.0041978545,
-0.0134358499,
-0.0497368872,
0.0110975374,
-0.0227272082,
0.0461906232,
-0.0548369177,
0.0368619934,
-0.0394001193,
0.025356086,
-0.0708089024,
0.0250508972,
0.026301628,
-0.0285354238,
0.1157254726,
-0.0672403723,
0.0146327149,
0.0124058528,
0.0851695091,
-0.0296453554,
0.0205587801,
0.0206507836,
-0.0306890849,
0.0090597402,
-0.0170628913,
0.0622206144,
-0.0030825732,
-0.0098061124,
-0.0176632442,
0.0368096977,
-0.0068366122,
-0.0382060185,
0.1069144607,
-0.0274656285,
0.0068329778,
-0.0432785898,
0.0165985245,
0.0440137461,
0.0893656462,
0.0454339087,
0.0417718925,
0.0110184234,
0.028132271,
0.0044303588,
-0.0057651103,
-0.0515252799,
0.0653837398,
0.0142887915,
-0.0268807691,
-0.070960626,
0.0154970009,
-0.0311351717,
-0.019282002,
0.0092984084,
-0.0183521584,
-0.0301469695,
0.0052981563,
-0.063340649,
-0.0015712996,
-0.0129148858,
0.0300289113,
0.0191919934,
-0.0361573733,
-0.0164216738,
-0.0688073784,
-0.0019329233,
0.1429167092,
0.0639204383,
-0.0572850965,
-0.0408064835,
-0.0371467024,
-0.0076037031,
0.0345714763,
0.0306838881,
-0.0011102738,
-0.0027284282,
-0.0103037935,
-0.0154213551,
-0.0182988644,
0.0035018688,
0.0171163008,
-0.0010424984,
-0.0003938015,
-0.0344478823,
0.0261481851,
0.0219892804,
0.0434239693,
-0.0899849236,
-0.0382289141,
-0.0001519736,
-0.0134517616,
0.0495334305,
0.0451746099,
0.0145688904,
0.0104609057,
0.0202194024,
-0.0033243245,
-0.015238381,
0.0251807533,
-0.0347056128,
0.0195289534,
0.0089393724,
-0.0502809435,
-0.0110261096,
-0.0041490905,
-0.0008014547,
0.0018791673,
-0.0049873968,
0.0096882423,
0.0471946746,
-0.0144022731,
-0.0100513175,
0.0254975408,
0.0032483251,
-0.0332125649,
-0.0261534732,
-0.0201797429,
-0.0181578659,
0.0223988574,
-0.0153922504,
-0.056120351,
-0.0370288938,
0.0305149015,
-0.0017725497,
0.004030054,
0.0049179657,
-0.057419274,
0.0310683828,
-0.0578883439,
-0.0285319891,
-0.0993667766,
-0.0050155162,
0.0042606792,
-0.0380050354,
0.017634606,
-0.038976077,
-0.0450627878,
-0.0163866989,
-0.0290727708,
-0.0240260046,
0.0228949748,
-0.0104358792,
0.0353531167,
0.0211907979,
-0.0196356457,
-0.0202886704,
0.0152701372,
-0.013864127,
-0.0104338145,
-0.004609663,
0.0291115139,
-0.0285483524,
-0.0192854945,
-0.0219424199,
0.0083733806,
-0.0136984596,
-0.0154192019,
0.0363122858,
0.0083511099,
0.0176251698,
-0.0163185745,
-0.009131344,
0.0349966884,
0.0395918116,
-0.0074034785,
-0.0293355938,
0.0106550585,
0.0064388313,
-0.0105648311,
-0.0540682599,
-0.0584166236,
0.024122322,
0.0184798818,
0.003301278,
0.0416306071,
-0.0454502515,
0.0302740913,
0.0278275926,
0.0060822866,
0.0692187399,
-0.0312297661,
-0.0276059974,
-0.0048881965,
-0.0025859969,
-0.0052306149,
0.0832011849,
-0.0167116821,
-0.01917281,
-0.0130494339,
-0.0261714291,
-0.0332525596,
0.0268094093,
-0.0271073077,
0.0002908232,
0.0207776893,
-0.0022937548,
0.0068652406,
-0.0199341197,
-0.0055819536,
-0.0347518288,
0.0482032523,
-0.0778211504,
-0.0180073064,
0.0131293237,
0.0121305566,
-0.041226089,
-0.0083720861,
-0.0384896956,
-0.0023795394,
0.0062628356,
-0.0159432851,
-0.0180495158,
-0.0598490201,
0.0233915262,
0.0414625779,
0.0209994465,
-0.0389671214,
-0.006829347,
-0.0139647741,
0.0260296892,
0.0170661137,
-0.0026927709,
-0.0056755389,
0.0385496989,
0.0590513423,
-0.0179964174,
-0.0074506537,
-0.0038473918,
-0.005097576,
0.0067670881,
0.0035153683,
0.0150743499,
0.0506324284,
0.0298678279,
-0.0004984631,
-0.0126824705,
0.1008234248,
0.0205539335,
-0.0442195721,
0.0442005023,
-0.0603896864,
0.0021121381,
0.0034431522,
-0.0149219939,
-0.0602132939,
-0.0067992602,
-0.0258520972,
0.0553561151,
-0.0292395838,
-0.060554184,
-0.0059588491,
-0.0516598038,
0.0759206638,
-0.0152509967,
0.0042434549,
-0.0138337715,
0.0126526328,
0.0321320333,
0.0068742605,
0.0057357005,
-0.0326046161,
0.0032309887,
0.012192551,
-0.0117419418,
-0.0474373437,
-0.0416157097,
0.0535185747,
-0.0252994038,
0.1317155063,
0.0369362757,
0.0450509936,
-0.0080184955,
-0.0644819885,
-0.0615147911,
0.0838859677,
0.0655981824,
0.0045055375,
0.0424699783,
-0.0134353647,
0.0399249904,
-0.0367947035,
0.0563172884,
-0.0490126126,
-0.0250796285,
0.0353591554,
0.07127662,
-0.0662968233,
-0.0395336039,
-0.0270471331,
0.0516918488,
0.0502523892,
0.0381566398,
0.0220018327,
-0.0358780548,
0.0330392569,
0.0287014041,
0.0492173471,
-0.0098429453,
-0.063906312,
-0.033456549,
0.0063178926,
0.0360189937,
-0.042502068,
-0.0349876024,
0.0510077216,
0.0227748901,
-0.0208416115,
-0.0343727805,
-0.010800302,
0.0213579666,
0.0040096371,
0.0454635136,
-0.0070992019,
0.0278378204,
-0.0176545344,
-0.0267600343,
0.0298371036,
-0.0541290902,
0.0156325046,
0.0029659655,
0.0221082121,
-0.0136668021,
0.0351137072,
0.0737008378,
0.0274990853,
0.0276763774,
0.0212843101,
-0.0077914665,
-0.0140470415,
0.046990525,
-0.0631296337,
0.0083717452,
0.0116689596,
0.0397574343,
-0.0025386182,
0.0079844631,
0.0127698611,
0.0296089444,
0.0001965079,
0.0152291907,
-0.0162398852,
-0.0687999576,
0.0078407107,
0.0353840329,
0.0224556345,
-0.0362219103,
0.0187069513,
0.0127891032,
-0.0072499509,
-0.045941107,
0.0359827913,
-0.0502471291,
-0.037964683,
0.0041631586,
-0.0318027735,
0.0249631014,
-0.0496751554,
-0.0808228776,
-0.020419661,
-0.0487207212,
0.0268580168,
0.0252637677,
-0.0011233154,
-0.0068208445,
-0.0181811713,
-0.0014029273,
0.0424554087,
-0.0216897521,
0.0383801945,
0.0195291955,
0.0691680461,
0.0042145927,
-0.0085458914,
0.0112971272,
0.0523113161,
-0.0247196481,
-0.1381421685,
-0.0109974276,
0.053809382,
0.0189273879,
0.0568786897,
-0.0152944829,
-0.0590365529,
0.0381404907,
0.0338815376,
-0.0027170125,
-0.0205809381,
-0.0221899375,
0.025902601,
0.0259666797,
-0.0158368014,
-0.0460268185,
0.0246128365,
-0.0423982665,
0.0281481054,
-0.0260512438,
-0.0045456733,
-0.0458649173,
-0.0532777868,
0.0197476,
0.0219721291,
-0.038024269,
-0.0129442811,
-0.0887244716,
-0.0289881676,
0.0056154742,
-0.0184300728,
-0.0411964692,
-0.0769404173,
0.0246042516,
-0.0068803732,
0.0122044263,
-0.0286021829,
-0.0216751471,
0.0131630199,
-0.0155237066,
-0.0034484039,
-0.0409494154,
-5.866840142e-33,
-0.0175776575,
-0.0654736012,
0.0495750681,
0.0102424622,
-0.0264400337,
-0.0216263104,
-0.0367950201,
0.0185783971,
0.0105577363,
0.0077680429,
0.0030906491,
0.023707144,
-0.0078751529,
-0.0042750714,
0.0075130826,
-0.0364427045,
0.0354227871,
-0.0190637317,
-0.0129809696,
0.0129255066,
-0.0756220967,
0.0302019212,
0.0040640151,
-0.1202427149,
0.0431898348,
-0.0111570796,
-0.0321141183,
-0.0029200152,
-0.0332813077,
0.0018798816,
-0.0062755779,
0.0084798234,
0.0259395987,
-0.0099034058,
0.0063596014,
0.000378566,
-0.0209919214,
-0.0440711007,
0.0215836689,
-0.0689474642,
-0.0776279569,
-0.0034833259,
0.0036586968,
-0.0191861819,
-0.008328923,
-0.0101280725,
0.0343097597,
-0.0228857957,
0.0322870538,
0.0107751573,
-0.0330115296,
-0.0190350469,
-0.0163088441,
-0.0146310329,
-0.0156323239,
0.0414786264,
-0.0303085353,
0.0021758191,
-0.0684789345,
0.0104723908,
0.004153484,
-0.0316750668,
0.0115531646,
-0.0283504725,
0.0142512545,
0.0293863695,
-0.0087746829,
0.0286876559,
-0.0799240246,
-0.0205490459,
-0.0230771005,
0.0733276308,
0.0479205139,
0.0433243811,
-0.0128831211,
-0.0107515771,
0.0145431245,
0.0358448029,
-0.0242099445,
0.0133642089,
0.0129078692,
0.0050157113,
-0.0531844683,
-0.0006006351,
0.0022761608,
0.0094267353,
0.0034443808,
-0.0650185794,
-0.0009625894,
-0.0262844637,
-0.0105818287,
-0.0136670843,
-0.0423036665,
-0.0052997605,
0.017244637,
-0.0390593745,
0.036833372,
0.0181448348,
-0.0204520468,
-0.0322539136,
-0.0343291834,
-0.0071040774,
0.0220462326,
-0.0160557106,
0.0774425417,
0.0308714341,
-0.0065700924,
0.0012757493,
-0.0499645583,
-0.0187337231,
0.0034796658,
0.081210278,
0.0518344902,
-0.0023897421,
-0.040539708,
-0.0188858584,
-0.030512711,
0.0220161919,
-0.0041827592,
-0.013087485,
-0.0607278086,
0.0403257087,
-0.0434013605,
-0.0136673581,
-0.0116597535,
-0.0183750093,
-0.041146528,
-0.0081765391,
0.0599755459,
-0.0141304862,
-0.0188902989,
-0.0474984199,
3.132e-7,
-0.0266755186,
0.0306276456,
0.0188490748,
0.0181989204,
0.009547255,
0.0329716504,
-0.0062273629,
0.0542612933,
0.0258211773,
-0.0626847968,
0.0680852309,
0.0414964221,
0.0206345115,
0.0556198917,
-0.0388083681,
-0.0314136706,
0.0013968927,
-0.0076267933,
-0.0254620016,
-0.0062757898,
0.0526180267,
-0.0250716973,
0.0329170674,
-0.0401605964,
0.0250803996,
0.0340804718,
0.0084881056,
-0.0831226557,
0.0173716787,
0.0511903502,
0.0484291613,
-0.0387755036,
0.018271111,
0.0455046296,
-0.0309570059,
-0.0281198919,
-0.0359129421,
0.1095556095,
-0.0498987921,
-0.013155181,
-0.0004667797,
-0.0042445124,
0.0191338565,
-0.0067394176,
-0.0046222419,
-0.0771921948,
-0.0430823714,
-0.0034394716,
-0.0407120325,
-0.056671869,
0.0230294801,
-0.0214677043,
-0.0102252718,
0.0294657089,
0.0035461974,
0.0101172552,
0.0031312658,
-0.0208577197,
0.0108917151,
-0.0042177285,
-0.0540137663,
-0.0117576802,
0.0382210165,
-0.0326086804,
-0.0468466654,
-0.0626065135,
0.0245058723,
2.7098708e-34,
-0.0158821587,
0.0573415197,
0.0353278071,
0.04261446,
0.0426931158,
0.0534724444,
0.0130019784,
0.0582628548,
0.0262067467,
-0.0102882283,
-0.0208115764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00869v1 | Large Language Models Are Involuntary Truth-Tellers: Exploiting Fallacy Failure for Jailbreak Attacks | 2024-07-01T00:23:43 | 2024-07-01T00:23:43 | Yue Zhou, Henry Peng Zou, Barbara Di Eugenio, Yang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We find that language models have difficulties generating fallacious and
deceptive reasoning. When asked to generate deceptive outputs, language models
tend to leak honest counterparts but believe them to be false. Exploiting this
deficiency, we propose a jailbreak attack method that elicits an aligned
language model for malicious output. Specifically, we query the model to
generate a fallacious yet deceptively real procedure for the harmful behavior.
Since a fallacious procedure is generally considered fake and thus harmless by
LLMs, it helps bypass the safeguard mechanism. Yet the output is factually
harmful since the LLM cannot fabricate fallacious solutions but proposes
truthful ones. We evaluate our approach over five safety-aligned large language
models, comparing four previous jailbreak methods, and show that our approach
achieves competitive performance with more harmful outputs. We believe the
findings could be extended beyond model safety, such as self-verification and
hallucination. | Large Language Models Are Involuntary Truth-Tellers: Exploiting Fallacy Failure for Jailbreak Attacks: We find that language models have difficulties generating fallacious and
deceptive reasoning. When asked to generate deceptive outputs, language models
tend to leak honest counterparts but believe them to be false. Exploiting this
deficiency, we propose a jailbreak attack method that elicits an aligned
language model for malicious output. Specifically, we query the model to
generate a fallacious yet deceptively real procedure for the harmful behavior.
Since a fallacious procedure is generally considered fake and thus harmless by
LLMs, it helps bypass the safeguard mechanism. Yet the output is factually
harmful since the LLM cannot fabricate fallacious solutions but proposes
truthful ones. We evaluate our approach over five safety-aligned large language
models, comparing four previous jailbreak methods, and show that our approach
achieves competitive performance with more harmful outputs. We believe the
findings could be extended beyond model safety, such as self-verification and
hallucination. | [
0.0294221509,
0.0658179671,
-0.0155165708,
0.0469426699,
-0.0663146004,
-0.0160903782,
0.0208835043,
-0.0089861229,
0.0340917744,
-0.0295344628,
-0.0224969666,
-0.0141359968,
0.0199293848,
0.0034189397,
0.069387801,
0.0214693546,
0.0608738959,
-0.0388159044,
0.0018093309,
-0.0268549249,
0.0112953261,
-0.0156712402,
0.0245706905,
-0.0020998535,
-0.0214993004,
-0.020098513,
-0.0193043761,
0.0272413362,
0.0041668168,
-0.0028386437,
-0.0076130908,
0.0317232497,
-0.0067511778,
0.0664393157,
0.0000021647,
-0.0201490112,
-0.0229757782,
0.0328223854,
-0.0472097471,
0.0542096235,
0.0135725019,
-0.052642554,
-0.0258418284,
0.0228471998,
-0.007367345,
0.0020157706,
0.021315245,
0.0766562372,
0.0757096484,
0.1099300981,
0.022672696,
-0.019448176,
0.0654965863,
-0.0154668335,
0.0137397172,
-0.0389713533,
0.0270020571,
0.017158594,
-0.015463857,
0.0361692682,
0.029503027,
-0.0147073148,
0.0211187657,
-0.007359108,
-0.0654188469,
-0.0074362694,
-0.0375619046,
-0.0169119388,
0.0021842781,
0.0104017174,
-0.0243023578,
-0.0500772819,
0.0164086353,
0.0120794764,
0.0157304276,
0.0316063128,
0.0270960517,
0.063959904,
-0.0226952638,
-0.0253564529,
0.0628113896,
-0.0123813907,
0.0849559158,
-0.0091795139,
0.0098131485,
0.0494404286,
0.0089864628,
-0.0319334827,
0.0148976371,
-0.0562279895,
0.01177321,
-0.0681036487,
-0.026926918,
0.0134308692,
0.0006028843,
0.0353639796,
-0.0758828446,
0.0152870929,
0.0547603033,
-0.0840415657,
-0.0015592916,
0.006058143,
0.0005323946,
0.0034849276,
-0.0111984927,
-0.013334428,
-0.0381397121,
0.0413538441,
-0.0121660158,
-0.002044834,
0.055345986,
-0.0223995633,
0.0043524262,
0.0624524876,
0.0211800355,
0.0276017152,
-0.0317548886,
-0.0184476189,
-0.0699284896,
0.0513607301,
-0.0373708941,
0.0222772975,
0.0029648999,
-0.0258746445,
0.0001219407,
0.0027632855,
0.0042767138,
-0.0003064068,
-0.0053679887,
-0.0877740458,
-0.0299042128,
0.0103705768,
-0.0952227488,
0.0046328949,
-0.0108819706,
0.0752308816,
0.0341238268,
-0.0274985544,
-0.0899904519,
-0.0656391233,
-0.0393182673,
-0.0699314848,
-0.0048016328,
-0.0890063718,
-0.0264615752,
-0.0342466235,
-0.0131637109,
-0.083681576,
0.0143509312,
0.0117459763,
-0.0367896296,
0.0361440554,
0.0046683098,
-0.024388019,
0.0165519938,
0.0512736775,
-0.0046062283,
0.0915134922,
-0.0080232453,
0.0698478147,
0.0318067744,
0.0040262085,
0.0519890822,
0.0392803513,
0.0367837176,
0.0284167882,
-0.043212384,
0.0050361855,
0.0391942225,
-0.017177077,
-0.0415964611,
0.0439923257,
-0.0130856531,
-0.0397357382,
0.0718906969,
0.0036687776,
-0.000285425,
0.0340590812,
0.0198492594,
-0.0625553802,
-0.0063207289,
0.0035574618,
-0.0561833531,
0.0027184749,
-0.1050886661,
-0.0170756206,
-0.0009721423,
0.0209588502,
-0.0076988335,
-0.0108165359,
-0.0107283797,
-0.0099610407,
-0.0077426485,
0.0320578627,
-0.0151990354,
0.0259226672,
-0.0185295362,
0.0970785916,
0.0602589995,
-0.0214365181,
-0.0241943393,
-0.092140533,
0.0033535,
0.0295258835,
0.0584343597,
0.0041025365,
0.0331923217,
-0.0309873875,
0.0113391513,
0.0150595708,
0.0383322462,
0.0087086009,
-0.02355114,
0.0185364112,
0.0161015652,
-0.0291972216,
0.0548264123,
-0.009162778,
0.0044901799,
-0.0092699863,
0.0033501755,
-0.0111257993,
-0.0340998173,
0.0197224487,
-0.0056399964,
0.0049043559,
0.0007922183,
-0.0057813269,
0.0245623384,
0.0042074388,
-0.0399166606,
0.0286553949,
0.0560484566,
0.0029278719,
0.0067093186,
-0.038170699,
-0.0332593992,
-0.0066279224,
0.0088594798,
-0.0271409731,
0.0082388557,
0.0558744222,
-0.0081604319,
0.0230987426,
0.0449320488,
-0.0420659706,
0.0182523411,
-0.0080331992,
0.0489788614,
-0.019419143,
-0.0225115027,
-0.0099955862,
0.0685227141,
-0.0567964688,
0.0324919857,
-0.0737311393,
0.0249950588,
-0.022317091,
-0.0005974833,
-0.0293779168,
0.0250391234,
-0.0121686039,
0.0187831242,
0.0173184238,
-0.0034607898,
-0.0145173557,
-0.0487100407,
-0.0425923467,
-0.0117459018,
-0.0109443534,
-0.0011872458,
0.0240380336,
0.0064964467,
0.0073197517,
0.0124271326,
-0.0071601453,
-0.0205479078,
0.0077181668,
0.0015073792,
-0.0118988575,
-0.0168453641,
-0.0394438915,
-0.0060322266,
0.0248883627,
0.0064091841,
0.0478400849,
-0.0317850001,
0.0131368414,
-0.0182278436,
0.0157414731,
-0.0391396359,
0.0325983204,
-0.0298711397,
-0.022201458,
0.0365095586,
0.0042903605,
-0.0528279319,
0.0677372441,
0.0271299183,
0.0739711747,
0.069108516,
0.0162905362,
-0.0173829943,
-0.0212482307,
0.0468432084,
-0.0110156713,
-0.0315355584,
-0.0925653204,
-0.0000713266,
0.0518616922,
0.0460775383,
0.0119066043,
-0.0175420195,
0.0528182574,
-0.0102096703,
-0.0366101414,
0.0713766739,
-0.0436207652,
-0.0392315909,
-0.0121300118,
-0.0158208348,
-0.0616051145,
0.0547321849,
-0.0641868114,
0.0524431616,
0.0142021552,
-0.0122834668,
0.0079884948,
0.0154113807,
-0.015143726,
0.0002753811,
0.0501576662,
0.0088048615,
-0.0141208572,
-0.0333387479,
0.0488978699,
-0.0389313288,
0.0467159264,
-0.0677002221,
-0.0023488586,
-0.0013917101,
-0.0409213379,
-0.0741508752,
-0.0843648314,
-0.0153583791,
-0.0456724837,
-0.01787965,
-0.0114166671,
-0.0453477539,
-0.0609527752,
0.0296262261,
-0.0088068191,
-0.0133547178,
0.0046827472,
-0.0092690224,
0.0004305507,
0.0304066949,
-0.0283392724,
0.049351491,
-0.0148808127,
0.0362328999,
0.1014621258,
0.0330655463,
0.0533418879,
-0.0188572295,
-0.0089095468,
-0.0099197002,
0.0215846188,
-0.0069805165,
0.019440433,
0.0230804831,
-0.0322096199,
-0.0178401191,
0.0555625558,
-0.0012131938,
0.0328084752,
0.0288406238,
0.0074343337,
0.0493525937,
0.0072729574,
-0.0182578769,
-0.0584951043,
-0.0279226713,
0.0161779411,
0.0249869879,
-0.0412623584,
-0.0339689851,
-0.0329114832,
-0.0916663185,
0.008764049,
0.0512154661,
0.0335560553,
0.0109174196,
-0.0340024084,
-0.0240549017,
0.0381346568,
0.0081284037,
-0.0102556981,
0.0006777072,
-0.0509305969,
-0.0107366228,
-0.0174906086,
0.0090865912,
0.0460590869,
-0.0091817081,
0.0729899034,
0.0610153377,
-0.0093805492,
-0.0450072959,
-0.0118074827,
0.0445646197,
0.0002135607,
-0.0222266223,
-0.0051632486,
0.0003853893,
0.0021807144,
-0.0053065144,
0.0122931506,
0.0293182712,
0.0344946161,
-0.0247872993,
0.0348602496,
0.0413108729,
0.0172020383,
-0.0606707409,
-0.004624391,
0.010849243,
0.0238345377,
0.044646848,
-0.0013859961,
-0.0050140475,
-0.0432409681,
-0.0679892153,
-0.0488701276,
-0.0114338929,
-0.0596055686,
0.0492523871,
0.0722427964,
-0.0174618009,
-0.0198307354,
0.00101838,
-0.0469454564,
0.0116843134,
0.0262039509,
-0.0039221509,
-0.0148112848,
0.0033460134,
0.0004575363,
-0.0179337095,
-0.0347194746,
0.0433283336,
-0.0271250028,
0.0163321067,
-0.0007372045,
-0.010103872,
0.0328610614,
0.0296841376,
-0.0728273839,
-0.0693037286,
0.0213609133,
0.0602852553,
0.0216210373,
0.0582737178,
-0.0181286205,
-0.0293734092,
0.0394909456,
0.0388706662,
-0.0730499551,
0.0427700244,
0.0649001598,
-0.0467530414,
0.0378682353,
0.0159831289,
-0.0176096708,
-0.0057849437,
0.068585366,
0.0009436304,
-0.060460683,
0.0148899695,
0.0389898121,
0.0303905606,
-0.0029415537,
0.0155961215,
0.0393039882,
0.0207679812,
0.0427439921,
-0.0353402384,
-0.0451863259,
0.0117965629,
0.0233695637,
0.0135739706,
-0.0130694984,
0.0287540294,
-0.0133758057,
-0.014037462,
0.0039253281,
0.0051196609,
0.0045677098,
0.0044079069,
0.0416589789,
0.0486767665,
0.0068092719,
-0.0462024435,
0.041614484,
-0.0098986309,
0.0455486588,
0.0011779754,
0.0333949216,
0.0041461876,
0.0008665234,
-0.0178945418,
0.0026399265,
-0.0370922275,
-0.045249857,
0.0154439565,
0.0623306334,
-0.0276198722,
0.0129111055,
-0.0004806532,
-0.0020587796,
0.0015722176,
-0.0285073146,
-0.0298804231,
0.0038321798,
-0.0870049521,
0.0481985472,
0.0090229791,
-0.0031952173,
0.0053549353,
0.0359155685,
0.0233881194,
0.04974268,
0.0195212476,
0.0027319153,
-0.037723247,
-0.04077214,
0.0068437015,
0.0094104437,
-0.0233719777,
-0.0376965068,
-0.0919339955,
-0.0909400433,
0.0019984022,
0.015512744,
0.0421724021,
-0.0066821557,
-0.0482757874,
0.0678084865,
0.0325489976,
0.0379550569,
-0.0690680891,
0.0411937125,
0.0299277473,
-0.0298248027,
0.0295571312,
-6.104790688e-33,
-0.0081068492,
-0.0574385785,
-0.0371269733,
-0.0381553061,
0.0242779888,
0.0098106824,
0.0046112225,
0.0117100896,
-0.060299661,
-0.005053299,
-0.0037557408,
0.026473321,
-0.0011712433,
0.016525574,
-0.0669966266,
-0.0307159182,
0.0116970427,
0.0016241595,
-0.0368967131,
0.019631261,
0.0323770978,
-0.0306351855,
0.0071523478,
-0.0286037046,
0.0530434698,
-0.0544863716,
-0.0598993525,
0.0306208823,
-0.0659461692,
0.0409433655,
0.0145817362,
0.0199344978,
-0.0246060099,
-0.0211603157,
0.0178537108,
0.0338469408,
0.0161595326,
-0.0054940786,
0.0547593385,
-0.0196787957,
-0.0002547518,
-0.0306758732,
0.0072412784,
0.0039755586,
-0.0186463222,
-0.0283712149,
-0.0429005548,
-0.0025931322,
-0.0200271737,
0.0026524188,
-0.0316961519,
-0.0073638102,
-0.0143654142,
-0.0256326925,
-0.0230681989,
0.0056097773,
-0.0058853892,
-0.003141264,
-0.0487241745,
0.0353038311,
0.0484590009,
-0.0289229546,
0.0370688885,
-0.0301541667,
-0.0147810029,
0.0791075155,
-0.0042207781,
0.0133320261,
-0.0381536335,
0.0180932209,
-0.0137868524,
0.047745049,
0.0918121561,
0.0479085296,
0.0274982285,
-0.0349812061,
-0.0782894343,
-0.0332304761,
0.0060338788,
0.0208524652,
0.0357043259,
-0.0361433253,
-0.0419185981,
-0.0039706198,
-0.0375245847,
0.0020954406,
-0.0249689966,
-0.0225231703,
0.0026788788,
0.0390521958,
-0.0354634449,
-0.0283175297,
-0.0103210583,
-0.0590382814,
0.0060106697,
0.0412461534,
-0.0043560178,
-0.0513908975,
-0.0257023964,
0.0230736732,
-0.0158605333,
0.0114687784,
-0.0082028499,
-0.0379901007,
0.0192844402,
-0.007166639,
0.0294863749,
0.0095362552,
-0.0530066043,
-0.0147923268,
-0.034950234,
0.0545034781,
0.0075698686,
-0.0304193292,
0.0504619367,
-0.006393597,
-0.0162846278,
-0.0223446358,
0.0201879218,
-0.0324220769,
-0.0575399287,
0.0757853612,
-0.0421588458,
0.0567148365,
0.0002481608,
-0.0044737635,
-0.0028057909,
0.0252973866,
0.0449090376,
-0.0661823153,
-0.0031772961,
-0.012901986,
2.99e-7,
-0.0327069163,
-0.0180459097,
-0.0119608399,
0.0485693738,
0.0297956113,
0.0861790851,
-0.0086233858,
0.0601803884,
-0.0027914422,
-0.1056253314,
-0.0728780404,
0.0001228618,
0.0510060824,
0.038050577,
-0.0389806814,
0.0707970038,
-0.0702739432,
-0.0110169239,
-0.0332885087,
-0.023893008,
0.0217787921,
0.0823364779,
0.0113690328,
-0.0308954697,
-0.023841206,
-0.0458371751,
0.0341799632,
0.0320464894,
-0.0241423789,
-0.012462466,
0.0110547431,
0.0009889745,
-0.0017508724,
0.0268971175,
-0.0195000283,
-0.0117333131,
-0.0639812425,
0.048317939,
-0.0095109548,
-0.0238601565,
-0.0627022833,
-0.0373980142,
-0.011338288,
-0.0402573831,
0.0627859831,
0.0378178507,
-0.0078257192,
-0.0423063673,
0.0154315224,
-0.0145789804,
0.0026659095,
-0.0225757491,
-0.0205406211,
0.0086650448,
0.0130527029,
0.0298170839,
0.0367071629,
-0.0300660636,
-0.0278107263,
0.021118626,
-0.0236653388,
-0.0374657288,
0.0068664532,
0.0430666059,
0.0209941734,
-0.0316813961,
0.0269376151,
2.745621211e-34,
-0.0018671777,
-0.0544844531,
0.0144032063,
0.0245893039,
0.0476800613,
0.0063280771,
0.0252594315,
0.0125931045,
0.0116101578,
-0.0087463697,
-0.0232117455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00837v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00837v2 | Towards Robust Speech Representation Learning for Thousands of Languages | 2024-06-30T21:40:26 | 2024-07-02T17:23:44 | William Chen, Wangyou Zhang, Yifan Peng, Xinjian Li, Jinchuan Tian, Jiatong Shi, Xuankai Chang, Soumi Maiti, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-supervised learning (SSL) has helped extend speech technologies to more
languages by reducing the need for labeled data. However, models are still far
from supporting the world's 7000+ languages. We propose XEUS, a Cross-lingual
Encoder for Universal Speech, trained on over 1 million hours of data across
4057 languages, extending the language coverage of SSL models 4-fold. We
combine 1 million hours of speech from existing publicly accessible corpora
with a newly created corpus of 7400+ hours from 4057 languages, which will be
publicly released. To handle the diverse conditions of multilingual speech
data, we augment the typical SSL masked prediction approach with a novel
dereverberation objective, increasing robustness. We evaluate XEUS on several
benchmarks, and show that it consistently outperforms or achieves comparable
results to state-of-the-art (SOTA) SSL models across a variety of tasks. XEUS
sets a new SOTA on the ML-SUPERB benchmark: it outperforms MMS 1B and w2v-BERT
2.0 v2 by 0.8% and 4.4% respectively, despite having less parameters or
pre-training data. Checkpoints, code, and data are found in
https://www.wavlab.org/activities/2024/xeus/. | Towards Robust Speech Representation Learning for Thousands of Languages: Self-supervised learning (SSL) has helped extend speech technologies to more
languages by reducing the need for labeled data. However, models are still far
from supporting the world's 7000+ languages. We propose XEUS, a Cross-lingual
Encoder for Universal Speech, trained on over 1 million hours of data across
4057 languages, extending the language coverage of SSL models 4-fold. We
combine 1 million hours of speech from existing publicly accessible corpora
with a newly created corpus of 7400+ hours from 4057 languages, which will be
publicly released. To handle the diverse conditions of multilingual speech
data, we augment the typical SSL masked prediction approach with a novel
dereverberation objective, increasing robustness. We evaluate XEUS on several
benchmarks, and show that it consistently outperforms or achieves comparable
results to state-of-the-art (SOTA) SSL models across a variety of tasks. XEUS
sets a new SOTA on the ML-SUPERB benchmark: it outperforms MMS 1B and w2v-BERT
2.0 v2 by 0.8% and 4.4% respectively, despite having less parameters or
pre-training data. Checkpoints, code, and data are found in
https://www.wavlab.org/activities/2024/xeus/. | [
-0.0536692552,
0.0502452068,
-0.0146832261,
0.0442265011,
0.0273651145,
-0.026281558,
0.0527936593,
-0.0173267536,
0.0238291509,
0.0231252424,
-0.0737092569,
0.0159654841,
-0.0055497163,
0.0210593436,
0.0159412604,
-0.0281901304,
0.0427440256,
-0.0563786253,
-0.0101041161,
-0.0523525774,
-0.0066203829,
0.0077487621,
-0.0194889568,
0.0128243705,
-0.0209818818,
0.0025958735,
-0.0364149697,
-0.018823145,
0.0018045411,
-0.0265651103,
0.0122509468,
0.0310790725,
0.0775749534,
0.0660805479,
0.0000022352,
-0.0265711136,
-0.0273386817,
-0.006159992,
-0.0385915227,
0.0412107036,
-0.0331537612,
-0.037433926,
-0.0240665879,
0.0104202088,
-0.0117078461,
-0.0340200253,
0.0327928141,
-0.004880012,
0.058138065,
0.0492893532,
0.0119260177,
-0.0265086796,
-0.0053395554,
-0.0202594977,
-0.0395923108,
-0.0077329176,
-0.015347749,
-0.0456139296,
-0.0537454672,
-0.0315723903,
-0.0337503515,
0.0572762527,
-0.001322741,
0.0092141498,
-0.003777381,
0.0167625472,
-0.0458950512,
-0.0255738981,
0.0033997984,
0.0637825504,
-0.0162265711,
-0.01580327,
-0.0020192845,
0.0127846589,
-0.0235807765,
-0.0579703376,
-0.019317707,
0.0072857845,
0.073308222,
0.0077265627,
0.0022508933,
0.0721011311,
0.0396004394,
-0.0200496018,
-0.0097148437,
0.0259959977,
0.0033196821,
-0.026884634,
0.0002248228,
-0.0295158643,
0.0265042558,
0.0138861928,
0.0396728255,
-0.0144440522,
0.0003120455,
-0.0222151633,
-0.0022084545,
-0.055839099,
-0.0110958871,
-0.025297856,
0.0008573133,
0.0316946357,
-0.0606613345,
0.0204908177,
-0.0331873819,
0.0398139656,
-0.0071993615,
0.0159602258,
0.0267459564,
-0.0246223528,
-0.0126687856,
0.0023846943,
-0.0347810686,
0.0172179099,
-0.0310889576,
0.0255501326,
-0.0358994529,
-0.0071858466,
-0.0443788581,
0.0314162113,
0.0163403489,
0.0008542989,
-0.0447981842,
-0.0301644504,
0.0165443979,
0.0395521522,
-0.009871603,
0.0112821609,
-0.006266119,
-0.0555260293,
-0.0194975398,
-0.0052007651,
0.0142575903,
-0.019400103,
0.029798178,
0.0945220217,
0.0127341542,
-0.0079214172,
-0.0092078159,
-0.0042272466,
-0.0410855152,
-0.0530784205,
-0.0023621186,
-0.0775572285,
0.0302376449,
-0.0221420992,
0.024495149,
-0.0411946438,
-0.0085850134,
-0.0390659235,
0.0606808998,
0.0574138016,
-0.022302404,
0.0043567182,
0.0409234129,
0.003702384,
-0.0064885449,
0.045779869,
0.0382844284,
-0.0075648753,
0.0449373797,
-0.0563168563,
0.0057581011,
0.0702803805,
0.0385982096,
0.020845471,
-0.0016009238,
-0.0118115824,
0.0112637859,
0.0082755797,
0.0652608126,
-0.0081804357,
0.0069257221,
-0.0693460107,
0.0765912905,
0.0242677517,
-0.0349898525,
0.0563622192,
0.0018825047,
0.0220978688,
0.0281871352,
-0.0159844235,
0.0028862124,
0.0257443767,
0.0124959275,
-0.0030698269,
0.0157169066,
0.0089530135,
-0.0486799739,
-0.0233265292,
0.0200153477,
-0.0494650677,
-0.0076891431,
0.0252744239,
0.0383753069,
0.0134522328,
-0.0226104595,
0.054680977,
0.0224194992,
-0.0721883327,
0.0302361622,
-0.0088899145,
0.0356339291,
0.0257755723,
-0.0044331122,
-0.0279509835,
-0.012668266,
-0.0367888138,
-0.0156341977,
0.0549748056,
0.0129267396,
0.0073615764,
0.1156680137,
-0.0566192493,
-0.0353988372,
-0.0290838741,
-0.0096505703,
0.0553742051,
-0.0466004871,
0.0283444021,
0.0084364051,
-0.0591338091,
0.0380684771,
-0.0100451028,
-0.0392131172,
-0.0629285872,
0.0629122257,
0.0376698598,
0.0468327031,
0.0522525609,
-0.0213834755,
-0.0042090174,
0.0372954123,
-0.0359495319,
-0.0151659772,
0.0213261023,
-0.094699353,
-0.0478845984,
0.0288325865,
-0.0314441137,
0.0024164331,
0.1088198423,
0.0035969918,
-0.060489472,
0.0847503245,
0.0106730098,
0.013449166,
-0.0272278152,
-0.0082936315,
0.0142384442,
0.0633968562,
0.065134123,
0.0077154189,
0.0332719162,
-0.0178111568,
-0.0085228942,
0.0256302617,
0.0325215831,
-0.063779898,
-0.0582604893,
0.00642876,
-0.0290693436,
0.0082699684,
0.011595442,
-0.0167930909,
-0.0012590986,
0.0323059149,
-0.0913595706,
0.0128092049,
-0.0345870294,
-0.0032884176,
-0.0117459595,
0.0324430317,
-0.0120541546,
-0.0500055589,
-0.0499579087,
-0.055161979,
0.0011495126,
-0.0150610479,
-0.0369847082,
-0.0101192659,
-0.0061876103,
-0.0308198724,
-0.0130779902,
0.0289063845,
-0.0135933515,
-0.0612392612,
-0.0346446298,
0.0014901726,
-0.0076030619,
-0.0236883573,
0.0583300255,
0.0029204609,
-0.0383924879,
-0.0404698513,
0.0059745377,
0.0291427709,
0.0008797186,
-0.0168756116,
-0.0419279486,
0.0525119342,
-0.0100251501,
-0.0666746572,
0.0218894035,
-0.0199587252,
0.0041089426,
-0.0314889476,
0.0207912289,
-0.0508192517,
0.0492185317,
0.0432372987,
-0.0008736604,
-0.0687540099,
-0.0581620038,
-0.0027008797,
-0.0456211977,
-0.0226835832,
0.0088622523,
-0.0271523818,
0.0344119817,
0.0196086187,
-0.0380765162,
0.039977178,
-0.0342644826,
-0.0518895835,
-0.0218152422,
-0.0476417542,
-0.0185644664,
0.0343103372,
-0.03245157,
0.0109103136,
0.0033870866,
-0.0159486514,
-0.0629085824,
-0.0091627706,
0.0264393762,
-0.0375028662,
-0.0373108871,
0.0053016543,
-0.0312768966,
-0.0006615779,
-0.069022432,
-0.0377109572,
-0.0019416915,
-0.0105749853,
-0.0027523148,
-0.0249052048,
-0.0011578074,
-0.0081692291,
-0.0318676494,
0.0238381922,
0.0470633842,
-0.0078271348,
0.0304816421,
-0.0094950246,
0.0479264669,
-0.0056461794,
0.0118310153,
0.0341922641,
-0.0238432568,
0.048259642,
0.0045022322,
0.0604915917,
0.0091290465,
-0.0517630465,
0.0353309549,
0.0417000279,
0.0102339266,
-0.0029113707,
0.0191054139,
0.0505952947,
-0.0424969718,
0.0170385409,
0.1219243631,
-0.0224020313,
-0.0244853124,
-0.0014864815,
-0.0201195944,
-0.0144067677,
0.0144769726,
-0.0042332448,
-0.0563166216,
-0.0179582275,
0.0244339667,
0.0501341969,
0.027749205,
-0.0099834893,
0.0333118327,
-0.117806606,
0.0453661308,
0.0429990217,
-0.0205986518,
-0.0397985764,
-0.0641277209,
-0.0367120281,
-0.0646364763,
0.0366027765,
-0.0307442136,
0.0107221166,
-0.0276358873,
0.0302973855,
-0.0629471913,
-0.0362302326,
0.0456378274,
-0.042903617,
0.0571533665,
0.0295670219,
0.0247920081,
-0.0473872833,
-0.045054622,
-0.0053475974,
-0.0257323217,
-0.0560436696,
0.0009826594,
0.0525004789,
0.0051656244,
-0.0309934132,
0.0301101804,
0.0348957628,
-0.0193180889,
0.018768033,
0.0282653179,
0.0768242851,
0.0238130372,
-0.0006540593,
0.0130882021,
0.0149566494,
0.0046565183,
0.0608872883,
0.0223979913,
-0.0092639728,
-0.0167486835,
0.0071290592,
0.0425688699,
-0.0218893476,
-0.0133279907,
0.0243534315,
0.0137569401,
-0.0567589253,
-0.0331406221,
-0.0315925293,
-0.0199242104,
0.0068725832,
0.0099719493,
0.0035936099,
-0.0335065499,
0.001427497,
-0.0484932996,
0.0205571391,
-0.0047825412,
0.0152237983,
-0.0108455895,
-0.0049523278,
0.0255721826,
0.0042355503,
-0.0053979307,
0.0355560184,
-0.0406924188,
-0.0556950793,
0.004582881,
0.0424335822,
0.0097536631,
0.079123117,
-0.0066333334,
-0.0271044411,
0.1283328086,
0.0282020755,
-0.0644285381,
-0.0184389818,
0.1026121527,
-0.0161948372,
-0.0050623892,
0.04889125,
-0.035890922,
0.016894076,
-0.0217734445,
0.0101624914,
0.0098914988,
-0.0219827984,
0.0016064807,
-0.0003193717,
0.0442515761,
-0.0354814753,
0.0364693701,
-0.0469689444,
0.0000190833,
-0.0346411727,
0.0064133597,
-0.0176444314,
0.0238226969,
0.0536461808,
0.0017663467,
0.025432311,
0.0777073503,
0.0030054459,
-0.0401141271,
-0.0292160995,
0.0420249701,
0.0016503618,
0.0157278348,
-0.0469532646,
0.0348145701,
0.0120669808,
0.0209234022,
0.0591503605,
0.0096646883,
-0.0067587183,
-0.0235434603,
-0.0150908092,
0.0249242242,
0.0009698698,
0.0064473907,
-0.0421565473,
-0.0581279658,
-0.0087923212,
-0.0075388527,
0.0377817415,
-0.0283250343,
0.062138401,
-0.0042296178,
-0.0024358721,
-0.0228052735,
0.0043502855,
-0.0480923653,
0.0347662196,
0.0132001974,
-0.0197067596,
-0.0400018468,
0.0282382406,
0.0321288034,
-0.0099295294,
0.0351468623,
0.0269941799,
0.0566099174,
-0.0506070927,
-0.0239519179,
0.0146902977,
-0.0022598563,
-0.0400797576,
-0.0281549376,
0.0157875884,
-0.0999183357,
0.0383474827,
-0.0268142745,
-0.0141790081,
0.0038513395,
0.0289946683,
0.0115770521,
-0.0154806236,
0.0124962656,
-0.0166651346,
0.0008351131,
0.0274193212,
-0.0146683697,
0.0136163514,
-6.062627543e-33,
0.0222613588,
0.054025773,
-0.0096847732,
-0.0127244079,
0.0029778571,
0.0054138089,
-0.0438320562,
0.0185046066,
-0.0063010938,
0.0140487142,
-0.0023037386,
-0.0109348996,
0.0224404372,
0.0422893986,
-0.0002055125,
-0.0121280085,
0.0689136311,
-0.0329565816,
-0.0162058603,
0.0264145881,
0.033872202,
0.0494908467,
0.069847621,
-0.0945783556,
-0.0095576728,
-0.0008713406,
-0.0107441293,
-0.0166481938,
0.0290759932,
0.0631213263,
-0.0241629742,
0.0613121726,
-0.0337971114,
0.0012934832,
-0.0609826073,
-0.010436275,
-0.0835349485,
-0.0181465354,
-0.0394425876,
0.0577818714,
-0.0331616513,
0.0012984234,
0.019963311,
0.0094243083,
-0.0505509526,
-0.0155109912,
0.0432089418,
-0.0243574586,
-0.0103953928,
-0.0358700231,
0.0037803361,
0.0289443061,
-0.0435225181,
-0.0375887267,
0.0986848101,
0.0711924434,
0.0174017176,
-0.0118666794,
-0.0684531555,
0.0104254885,
-0.0453041084,
0.035252165,
0.0783253983,
-0.020553235,
0.0247307718,
0.039342586,
0.0944834501,
-0.0363354348,
0.0634103715,
-0.0066099162,
0.051515758,
0.0170339067,
0.0449295416,
0.0284071099,
0.0047500827,
-0.0252108146,
-0.061153084,
0.0127758384,
-0.0003625699,
-0.0151885524,
0.0234799664,
0.044311285,
-0.0470138676,
0.0167999193,
-0.0349315926,
-0.044628866,
0.00454186,
-0.0018118995,
0.027220238,
-0.0029008433,
0.0055141328,
0.0230475534,
0.0545105673,
-0.0374251977,
0.0150983287,
0.0206538904,
-0.0217770096,
-0.047711622,
0.041241426,
0.0455253236,
-0.0066636829,
-0.0239398312,
0.0022710694,
0.0049657752,
0.0204903204,
-0.0283215102,
0.0111856665,
0.057631962,
-0.0644375533,
0.006018281,
-0.043905098,
0.004744648,
0.0052504484,
0.0294466987,
0.0357392766,
-0.01705469,
0.0008618566,
0.0180305801,
0.0076267789,
0.0366479903,
0.0039343475,
0.0042393864,
0.0043481616,
0.028669443,
-0.0128418775,
-0.0280798785,
-0.0377521031,
-0.0255330689,
0.0466225855,
-0.0310867708,
-0.0042718113,
-0.0380106606,
2.839e-7,
-0.0411452167,
-0.0076721106,
0.0280519091,
-0.0086909318,
0.027545169,
0.0550606921,
-0.0483080857,
0.0317362547,
-0.0160112306,
0.0048441784,
-0.0030960992,
0.0058542732,
0.0864136592,
0.0307554826,
-0.0745139346,
-0.001975341,
-0.0539289713,
0.0156393163,
-0.023857031,
0.0103649227,
-0.0218077768,
0.113546364,
0.0298646856,
-0.0160589814,
0.0083736181,
0.0106912619,
0.0596178584,
-0.0146952551,
-0.0189810898,
-0.0392189845,
-0.0331175998,
0.0460783131,
-0.0211223271,
-0.0364639834,
-0.070453167,
0.0808832347,
0.013400604,
0.0661369711,
0.0428734049,
-0.068825759,
0.0232574809,
0.0497838445,
-0.0281359795,
-0.0065071415,
0.0451022312,
0.0051789503,
-0.0385693535,
-0.0032742477,
-0.0568548292,
0.0253636129,
0.0608536825,
-0.025526423,
-0.0351689644,
0.0253144931,
0.0096173547,
-0.0179967284,
-0.0337615833,
-0.0327600837,
-0.0169762149,
0.0031010315,
-0.0699862316,
0.0018755494,
-0.0093989689,
0.0245636422,
0.0129763577,
-0.0414281003,
0.0442444719,
2.219228412e-34,
0.0033709554,
-0.0370898657,
-0.0028646439,
-0.0062317997,
-0.0424995869,
-0.0618156604,
0.0205625799,
-0.0072364691,
0.0303557534,
0.0358815789,
-0.0461432002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00826v1 | NAIST Simultaneous Speech Translation System for IWSLT 2024 | 2024-06-30T20:41:02 | 2024-06-30T20:41:02 | Yuka Ko, Ryo Fukuda, Yuta Nishikawa, Yasumasa Kano, Tomoya Yanagita, Kosuke Doi, Mana Makinae, Haotian Tan, Makoto Sakai, Sakriani Sakti, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes NAIST's submission to the simultaneous track of the
IWSLT 2024 Evaluation Campaign: English-to-{German, Japanese, Chinese}
speech-to-text translation and English-to-Japanese speech-to-speech
translation. We develop a multilingual end-to-end speech-to-text translation
model combining two pre-trained language models, HuBERT and mBART. We trained
this model with two decoding policies, Local Agreement (LA) and AlignAtt. The
submitted models employ the LA policy because it outperformed the AlignAtt
policy in previous models. Our speech-to-speech translation method is a cascade
of the above speech-to-text model and an incremental text-to-speech (TTS)
module that incorporates a phoneme estimation model, a parallel acoustic model,
and a parallel WaveGAN vocoder. We improved our incremental TTS by applying the
Transformer architecture with the AlignAtt policy for the estimation model. The
results show that our upgraded TTS module contributed to improving the system
performance. | NAIST Simultaneous Speech Translation System for IWSLT 2024: This paper describes NAIST's submission to the simultaneous track of the
IWSLT 2024 Evaluation Campaign: English-to-{German, Japanese, Chinese}
speech-to-text translation and English-to-Japanese speech-to-speech
translation. We develop a multilingual end-to-end speech-to-text translation
model combining two pre-trained language models, HuBERT and mBART. We trained
this model with two decoding policies, Local Agreement (LA) and AlignAtt. The
submitted models employ the LA policy because it outperformed the AlignAtt
policy in previous models. Our speech-to-speech translation method is a cascade
of the above speech-to-text model and an incremental text-to-speech (TTS)
module that incorporates a phoneme estimation model, a parallel acoustic model,
and a parallel WaveGAN vocoder. We improved our incremental TTS by applying the
Transformer architecture with the AlignAtt policy for the estimation model. The
results show that our upgraded TTS module contributed to improving the system
performance. | [
0.0096283695,
0.0814620778,
0.0411600657,
-0.0056103845,
-0.0206782743,
-0.0194872655,
0.0288255438,
-0.0191018805,
-0.060511075,
0.0177108645,
-0.0960042775,
-0.0432671234,
0.0457140729,
0.0062863571,
0.0390964746,
-0.0400289148,
0.0355093889,
-0.027056668,
-0.0126100853,
-0.0200653523,
0.0163576547,
0.0263602454,
-0.0367157422,
0.0251671337,
-0.0147896446,
-0.0120114433,
0.0077118739,
0.0392364673,
0.0287635494,
-0.036241699,
-0.0004772277,
-0.0364723951,
0.0488399602,
0.0414870381,
0.0000020226,
-0.0110755991,
-0.0056298412,
0.0279948656,
0.0166389812,
0.0039494899,
0.0346269682,
-0.0158480573,
-0.0237455238,
0.0725564286,
0.0125239519,
-0.0133025572,
0.0678659156,
0.0330176577,
0.0564861074,
0.06992466,
-0.0110966312,
-0.0809261724,
0.0191306714,
-0.0489166155,
-0.0520023964,
-0.0472859703,
-0.0333278142,
0.0000987399,
-0.0351179838,
-0.016551977,
-0.0197637621,
0.086407125,
0.0032955208,
0.0038004729,
-0.0376049094,
-0.0044133565,
-0.0118296035,
-0.03570709,
-0.0333531573,
0.0697575361,
0.0106688933,
0.0223333891,
0.0067152116,
0.01492838,
-0.042967774,
-0.0456313156,
-0.0437468812,
0.02075799,
0.0078640897,
-0.032808993,
0.0012230374,
0.0908037797,
0.0125108212,
-0.0311376471,
-0.0563989431,
0.0014347043,
0.0463321619,
-0.0263505522,
-0.0074232635,
-0.0173365325,
-0.0087918667,
0.0021868758,
0.074435778,
0.0004402096,
-0.027506303,
0.0320820659,
-0.0332396515,
-0.0109248227,
-0.0473838821,
-0.0648185462,
0.0186502598,
0.06933368,
-0.0397316106,
0.0078272903,
0.0244367104,
0.0681902021,
-0.0382709764,
-0.0259932913,
-0.0838680193,
-0.0369153023,
-0.0023676592,
0.031197736,
-0.0479655378,
-0.0146940043,
-0.0398554951,
-0.0467503816,
-0.0010556357,
-0.0210454613,
0.0248887837,
0.0281832255,
0.0482968464,
-0.0157455131,
-0.0831380114,
-0.0374324508,
0.019159779,
0.0909507796,
0.0427974351,
0.0110364528,
-0.0135622555,
-0.0263654757,
-0.0290055107,
0.0314027816,
0.0343380161,
-0.0043295701,
0.0045549027,
0.056530837,
-0.0420679711,
0.0030692581,
-0.0127290506,
0.0118414164,
-0.0305950772,
-0.0526932739,
0.0058813225,
-0.0474580005,
0.0552022979,
-0.0242455974,
0.0290395729,
-0.0226040408,
-0.0039691352,
-0.0146902418,
0.0099028191,
0.0364716649,
0.0083520729,
0.013055929,
0.0389805026,
-0.0105804997,
0.0178897604,
0.0415329151,
0.0481673144,
0.0130353905,
-0.0013488507,
0.0104356986,
-0.0567273498,
0.0931133479,
-0.003981417,
0.0026683242,
-0.0452992804,
0.000806776,
0.0171166696,
0.004277525,
0.0197932683,
0.0516243763,
-0.0161087438,
0.0400669053,
0.078238599,
0.0427745394,
0.022358045,
0.0388287343,
0.0309111886,
0.0225067213,
0.0133126238,
-0.0259731077,
0.0159051865,
0.0414489619,
-0.0137232598,
0.0141776484,
0.0609326921,
0.04822338,
-0.0333026238,
-0.0173298195,
-0.0043747374,
-0.0297330711,
-0.012514472,
-0.0093713459,
0.0422118641,
0.0027161168,
-0.0654258803,
0.0429330617,
0.0059358119,
-0.0516177155,
0.031776268,
-0.0076012434,
-0.0349216759,
0.0380647182,
0.0521026589,
0.0628738776,
-0.0323016196,
-0.0547785275,
-0.031181097,
0.0723263696,
0.0196675826,
0.0161600765,
0.0398351029,
-0.061743807,
-0.0248583704,
0.0613672771,
-0.0118492907,
0.0520963818,
-0.0299282074,
0.0489310175,
0.028951453,
-0.0097797783,
-0.0183078814,
-0.0144742271,
-0.0437242612,
0.0229587015,
0.0056942683,
-0.0145940315,
0.0478015505,
0.0573242083,
-0.0536822453,
0.0156418793,
0.0033736869,
-0.0306637194,
0.0127141941,
0.0797139257,
-0.0497129001,
-0.0281706303,
0.0382655673,
-0.0175929144,
0.0318259448,
0.0436700583,
-0.0013686129,
-0.091433689,
0.0083697103,
-0.0397507921,
-0.0111338431,
-0.0281533003,
0.021480212,
0.0316546224,
0.0092908526,
0.0179895759,
-0.0118356748,
-0.0014330228,
-0.019066928,
0.0212672167,
-0.0009006389,
0.0023034669,
-0.0360715538,
-0.0412717387,
0.0693648458,
0.0001139696,
0.008117279,
0.0239126422,
0.0155723793,
0.0239840224,
-0.04208491,
-0.0703956634,
0.0467330255,
-0.0303012766,
0.0399552695,
0.0138318855,
0.0340015702,
0.0189238135,
-0.0136654405,
-0.0371763557,
-0.0231273547,
0.001848951,
-0.0539604239,
-0.0419777296,
-0.0077109798,
-0.0151682589,
-0.0476134978,
0.0102690347,
0.0376426987,
-0.0060961894,
0.0058226264,
-0.0579770319,
-0.0872184783,
0.0108681535,
-0.0140780061,
0.0154262725,
-0.0017516625,
-0.0746266246,
-0.0049786149,
0.002962095,
0.0289099328,
-0.0045100483,
-0.0073461602,
-0.0025796341,
-0.016834883,
-0.0170125067,
-0.06181309,
0.006489655,
0.032267563,
-0.0429128632,
-0.0208312254,
-0.0160621684,
-0.0060837362,
0.0615999289,
0.0267901514,
0.0174580775,
-0.0595083833,
-0.0725021884,
-0.0254385173,
-0.013061787,
0.0128155975,
-0.0123019032,
-0.0193157978,
-0.0303528812,
-0.0159207471,
-0.0316578448,
-0.0012043968,
-0.0931364074,
-0.0466231145,
-0.0949821994,
-0.0137268594,
-0.0069763162,
0.0039965962,
-0.002186948,
0.0144435205,
-0.0122452192,
-0.0458340459,
-0.0120824929,
0.0196472947,
-0.0264849979,
-0.0456038043,
0.0221147481,
-0.0159960929,
-0.0063061877,
-0.0321409218,
-0.0075684595,
-0.0122583713,
-0.0259738937,
-0.0075942012,
0.0160338189,
0.0232300851,
-0.0425711386,
-0.0290753562,
0.0396472886,
0.0104290694,
0.0841284618,
-0.0042760801,
0.0165525898,
-0.0348957814,
0.0204496495,
0.0364058614,
0.024880968,
-0.008725456,
-0.0136073828,
0.0227382891,
0.0069361269,
0.0250774398,
0.0041732662,
-0.0580122359,
-0.004324384,
0.0460745096,
0.0217803493,
-0.0212358665,
-0.0000534641,
0.0629097447,
-0.013828028,
0.0301815122,
0.1151428744,
0.0025933003,
-0.0225932505,
-0.0228613298,
0.0234936308,
0.0217519999,
-0.0034962082,
0.0027365093,
-0.0296095349,
-0.0150227668,
0.0362629779,
0.0357123241,
0.0524158813,
0.0540590882,
-0.0371747576,
-0.0461487286,
0.0406132266,
0.0706316903,
-0.0030125256,
-0.022569444,
0.0354796499,
-0.0553099327,
-0.0206109248,
0.0536524765,
0.0072861225,
0.0020007251,
-0.0135977492,
0.0365026444,
-0.0026199946,
-0.0423904918,
-0.0396522395,
-0.0302207284,
0.1027286947,
0.0702146366,
0.0418232419,
-0.0215259716,
-0.0344602354,
0.0517046005,
0.0072145644,
0.0314179622,
0.0009298644,
-0.0210996233,
-0.0131926881,
-0.0223130397,
0.016352132,
0.0327990986,
-0.0244796127,
0.0201194417,
0.0287766345,
-0.0095452396,
-0.0081742788,
0.0522621684,
0.0203897823,
0.0313179046,
-0.008267533,
0.0455774628,
-0.0196998175,
-0.046943929,
0.0475008823,
-0.0001778957,
0.0194953773,
-0.0324036703,
0.0106720971,
0.0161285549,
-0.0466479696,
-0.0443809889,
-0.0515191108,
0.0005230235,
-0.0162516534,
0.0347521305,
0.0336200409,
-0.0111335805,
0.0236962475,
0.0216438081,
-0.0035983932,
0.0189441424,
-0.0043529035,
0.017868856,
-0.0438924022,
0.0109469155,
0.0550127886,
-0.0514465384,
0.0058920132,
0.0613792911,
-0.0534274653,
-0.0445811786,
-0.0144104818,
0.0147844059,
0.0169158801,
0.0608738065,
-0.0448773876,
0.0134008871,
0.0214926656,
-0.0488868132,
-0.0225404371,
0.0218656082,
0.0312195122,
0.0240463875,
-0.0095685255,
0.0033689216,
-0.0215685144,
0.0232146047,
-0.0172266886,
0.0482427999,
0.0241177324,
-0.0562362447,
0.0050320011,
0.0450573713,
0.0073031788,
-0.0207937565,
0.020705631,
-0.0359873474,
0.0596776418,
0.0008708409,
0.0366557613,
-0.0873802155,
0.0025763679,
0.0621873327,
-0.0020328341,
-0.0121681467,
0.0286404118,
0.0257567596,
-0.0463320836,
0.0075101252,
0.0154077597,
-0.004584359,
0.0374228321,
0.0047527538,
-0.012891151,
-0.022416031,
0.0099965781,
0.002690048,
-0.0127931237,
-0.034358602,
0.0520183742,
-0.0187393073,
0.012209041,
0.016746385,
0.0422062241,
-0.0086901877,
-0.0012339904,
-0.0424899943,
0.0036537277,
0.0497599244,
0.0509426817,
0.129658848,
-0.0119101861,
0.0441657715,
-0.0062245824,
0.0327067859,
-0.030920459,
-0.0113799116,
0.0026907397,
-0.0404515453,
-0.0072171823,
0.0066448739,
0.0289194975,
0.00556303,
0.0143559296,
-0.0262680817,
0.0096759917,
-0.0066790893,
-0.0473861434,
0.0186093003,
-0.0032706524,
-0.0310506783,
-0.0109394183,
0.0266944226,
-0.0290756989,
-0.0034999952,
0.007223872,
-0.0151192844,
-0.0254087429,
0.0009181365,
0.0301152114,
-0.0471949503,
-0.0056142234,
0.0302404854,
-0.0510410592,
-0.0130139105,
-0.0161202196,
-0.0035767537,
-6.529359779e-33,
-0.0618937649,
0.0222746804,
0.0085634999,
-0.0268066786,
-0.0855701044,
-0.0247420762,
-0.0271629728,
-0.0258911401,
0.0031238575,
-0.0223743729,
-0.0054511037,
0.034878511,
0.0269683059,
0.014044188,
-0.0114089632,
0.0159243867,
0.1035904139,
-0.0239514429,
-0.0005940028,
0.0050931657,
0.0233786218,
0.0184639171,
0.0734626874,
-0.0468974039,
-0.0051723011,
-0.0162954573,
-0.0378055945,
0.0008617499,
-0.0088569298,
0.0162976086,
0.0333069265,
0.0110004432,
-0.0356408209,
-0.0379311219,
-0.0445478149,
0.0185629949,
-0.0879019722,
-0.0004637851,
0.0103519699,
0.091687791,
0.0110079618,
-0.0289685167,
0.0071258829,
-0.0291807,
0.0015847656,
-0.0198600851,
0.003175426,
-0.0415297002,
0.001326834,
-0.0141307488,
-0.0230847858,
0.0164678227,
-0.0281396043,
-0.0046520401,
0.0425019264,
0.0726673976,
-0.0248237755,
-0.0628482997,
-0.1032348797,
0.012665079,
-0.0039326488,
0.0371924639,
0.0801097304,
-0.0080233198,
-0.0231410172,
-0.003525404,
0.0268582329,
-0.0825546756,
0.0433833189,
-0.0324298963,
0.0226521846,
0.0093634948,
0.0343401022,
-0.0143741891,
0.015929345,
-0.0266735703,
-0.0247588083,
0.0334918648,
0.0175769757,
0.0338738449,
0.0043946276,
0.0263578016,
-0.0159094296,
0.0140493652,
-0.0333881937,
-0.0618461929,
-0.0006181299,
-0.0641188845,
0.0373489559,
0.0209612809,
0.0180994887,
-0.0105881775,
0.1080546752,
-0.0238986015,
0.0147815328,
-0.0015074646,
-0.0131072635,
0.0081254793,
-0.062385112,
0.0466782413,
-0.0582353547,
-0.0288446713,
0.0375179574,
0.0352540575,
0.0148087814,
-0.0181999467,
-0.0215796754,
0.0888021216,
-0.052446045,
0.0027778565,
-0.0190810673,
-0.0083250934,
-0.0248154718,
0.0084830048,
0.0537633076,
-0.0243756454,
-0.009055892,
0.0226973053,
-0.0187628474,
-0.0101364991,
-0.0119373985,
-0.0180682745,
0.0239224471,
0.0131463259,
-0.0444185771,
0.0487753376,
0.0113323405,
-0.0158159044,
0.0218913853,
-0.0156741682,
-0.0294589829,
0.0309624765,
2.833e-7,
-0.0089826277,
0.0005159182,
0.0307882987,
-0.0057697841,
0.0251902491,
-0.0059862006,
-0.048607491,
0.0454957299,
0.0072047315,
0.0534160249,
0.0270183459,
-0.0295324288,
0.107377775,
0.0113569694,
-0.0695533603,
-0.0354110561,
-0.0602420643,
0.0456227623,
-0.0312215369,
-0.0004909665,
0.0588311963,
0.079475373,
-0.0460124649,
0.0002782879,
0.0052786288,
-0.0190015938,
0.0331736319,
0.0043336861,
-0.048049055,
0.0036742836,
0.02890292,
-0.0407639444,
-0.0509319045,
-0.021326337,
-0.0517681167,
0.0634183884,
0.0426943749,
0.0779370442,
-0.0069345143,
-0.0326776989,
-0.0056010312,
0.0593042709,
-0.0491294824,
-0.0095986901,
0.0611385591,
-0.0191019308,
-0.0251736473,
0.0325802453,
-0.035622593,
0.0478532054,
-0.0257823523,
0.0090180133,
0.0153312655,
-0.005065782,
0.045834139,
-0.0036287662,
-0.0226958524,
-0.0302317217,
-0.0300571825,
-0.0358390063,
-0.0419389009,
-0.0682591945,
-0.0238944963,
-0.0228552856,
-0.008949901,
-0.0100886226,
-0.035926979,
2.346368458e-34,
0.0346938781,
-0.0581391305,
0.0158259068,
0.0137548875,
0.0023210791,
-0.0390211828,
-0.0058180434,
0.0470339619,
-0.0369550698,
-0.0249953512,
-0.0516700447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00782v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00782v2 | Step-Controlled DPO: Leveraging Stepwise Error for Enhanced Mathematical Reasoning | 2024-06-30T17:59:07 | 2024-07-02T04:46:35 | Zimu Lu, Aojun Zhou, Ke Wang, Houxing Ren, Weikang Shi, Junting Pan, Mingjie Zhan, Hongsheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has proven effective at improving the
performance of large language models (LLMs) on downstream tasks such as
reasoning and alignment. In this work, we propose Step-Controlled DPO (SCDPO),
a method for automatically providing stepwise error supervision by creating
negative samples of mathematical reasoning rationales that start making errors
at a specified step. By applying these samples in DPO training, SCDPO can
better align the model to understand reasoning errors and output accurate
reasoning steps. We apply SCDPO to both code-integrated and chain-of-thought
solutions, empirically showing that it consistently improves the performance
compared to naive DPO on three different SFT models, including one existing SFT
model and two models we finetuned. Qualitative analysis of the credit
assignment of SCDPO and DPO demonstrates the effectiveness of SCDPO at
identifying errors in mathematical solutions. We then apply SCDPO to an
InternLM2-20B model, resulting in a 20B model that achieves high scores of
88.5% on GSM8K and 58.1% on MATH, rivaling all other open-source LLMs, showing
the great potential of our method. | Step-Controlled DPO: Leveraging Stepwise Error for Enhanced Mathematical Reasoning: Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has proven effective at improving the
performance of large language models (LLMs) on downstream tasks such as
reasoning and alignment. In this work, we propose Step-Controlled DPO (SCDPO),
a method for automatically providing stepwise error supervision by creating
negative samples of mathematical reasoning rationales that start making errors
at a specified step. By applying these samples in DPO training, SCDPO can
better align the model to understand reasoning errors and output accurate
reasoning steps. We apply SCDPO to both code-integrated and chain-of-thought
solutions, empirically showing that it consistently improves the performance
compared to naive DPO on three different SFT models, including one existing SFT
model and two models we finetuned. Qualitative analysis of the credit
assignment of SCDPO and DPO demonstrates the effectiveness of SCDPO at
identifying errors in mathematical solutions. We then apply SCDPO to an
InternLM2-20B model, resulting in a 20B model that achieves high scores of
88.5% on GSM8K and 58.1% on MATH, rivaling all other open-source LLMs, showing
the great potential of our method. | [
-0.012310735,
0.0598033816,
0.0074278172,
-0.0051917662,
-0.0263900701,
0.039516516,
0.0082576005,
-0.0224268846,
0.0056782351,
-0.0172436815,
-0.0086121056,
-0.0213777646,
0.0013402564,
0.0117918281,
0.0295876376,
-0.0458692238,
0.0434999727,
-0.0502930395,
0.0012765827,
-0.0156935509,
0.0036245089,
-0.0000521478,
-0.0327946059,
-0.0060590841,
0.0058512492,
-0.0923547894,
0.0109982705,
-0.0135292839,
0.0286408216,
-0.0567671545,
0.0089051249,
0.0667917058,
0.0290703718,
0.0562594011,
0.000002718,
-0.0585937984,
-0.0282698665,
0.003406402,
-0.0461660661,
0.0132996971,
-0.0305717681,
-0.0064439066,
-0.0167184249,
0.0401118025,
-0.0220464598,
0.0296460148,
0.0496362373,
0.0033790402,
0.0656390041,
0.0707425997,
0.0182702448,
-0.0401098058,
0.0423205607,
-0.0087132128,
0.0050937887,
-0.0195078105,
0.0182109214,
0.0509890467,
-0.0080338223,
0.0191743392,
-0.0269761086,
0.0317173302,
0.0532439873,
0.0046968302,
0.0092015071,
0.0186916161,
-0.0294389762,
-0.005063124,
0.0021585906,
0.0447276756,
-0.007153051,
-0.0550074056,
-0.0174646061,
-0.033463262,
-0.0330293551,
0.0011491944,
-0.0549663641,
0.0105396202,
-0.0167194661,
0.016367536,
0.0359359309,
-0.0417726859,
0.0262294598,
0.0191376712,
-0.0532324426,
0.0894031972,
-0.0005083034,
-0.0604213811,
0.0050210096,
0.0278434567,
-0.066554226,
-0.0481661707,
0.0245922115,
0.0273392629,
-0.0307405293,
0.0228728689,
-0.0346655026,
-0.0399396196,
-0.018816039,
-0.0393571071,
0.0433267727,
0.0642700419,
0.0300504286,
0.0106403483,
-0.0084513193,
0.0610249713,
-0.0167867932,
0.0473425239,
-0.025672581,
0.0561944284,
-0.018822046,
-0.0295494366,
0.0013484317,
0.0442777947,
-0.0176246297,
0.0087236445,
-0.0347498842,
0.0050241877,
-0.0409388319,
0.0348728336,
0.0002427112,
-0.0392375886,
-0.0053071841,
-0.0405155458,
-0.0420092121,
0.023114156,
-0.0212804489,
-0.006271733,
0.0023823464,
-0.0167960785,
-0.0247524828,
0.0077124056,
-0.0480042323,
-0.0181425773,
0.0031304776,
0.0505489558,
-0.004802776,
-0.0022457179,
-0.017824078,
-0.0145092541,
0.0267166533,
-0.0710027888,
0.0138369761,
-0.0960453227,
0.0086317789,
0.0135374954,
-0.0094813732,
-0.029584825,
0.0109837493,
0.0308736376,
0.0156900827,
0.0398879349,
-0.0250592101,
0.0029155852,
-0.0208754931,
-0.0106604304,
-0.0422539227,
0.0588856079,
0.0469528586,
-0.0495692901,
-0.0034160507,
-0.0156834237,
-0.0068943468,
0.0346057788,
0.0346144512,
0.0175232179,
-0.0277283452,
0.0064731441,
0.0168978423,
0.0547836497,
0.0220619347,
0.0268586278,
-0.0423382856,
0.0250093527,
0.034528356,
0.0331794061,
0.0246238429,
0.0093331952,
0.019386312,
0.0003558097,
0.0143473875,
0.0001897781,
-0.0866883099,
0.0455469564,
-0.0377804898,
0.0347821303,
0.0083140815,
0.0199227203,
-0.0001010972,
-0.0742706135,
-0.0224135108,
0.0397943631,
-0.032469824,
0.0501580313,
0.0483447202,
-0.0217089951,
-0.0382209308,
0.0717130303,
-0.0009916795,
-0.0333487056,
-0.0280726589,
-0.0436996929,
0.0475282446,
0.0331068076,
0.058735963,
-0.0299818739,
-0.0430703983,
-0.0149024948,
-0.0008405045,
0.0547147132,
0.048410181,
0.0073901583,
-0.0439150445,
-0.0585350469,
-0.0164034516,
0.0275768973,
0.0091087287,
-0.0002530974,
0.0417813323,
0.0025645515,
0.0018486098,
0.00502933,
-0.0216068383,
0.0250987187,
-0.0253753718,
-0.0446634814,
-0.0199589711,
0.0065098717,
0.0178011265,
0.006476549,
0.0102006877,
0.0284728426,
-0.020196002,
0.005923091,
-0.049380675,
-0.0324133784,
-0.0914992094,
-0.0596150532,
0.0662831515,
-0.0015223311,
-0.0646691248,
0.0136300195,
-0.0553104542,
-0.0158717167,
0.0295500252,
-0.0044712364,
-0.0034356737,
-0.0028398472,
0.0480488315,
0.009710243,
-0.0440504774,
-0.0467116274,
0.0769892335,
0.0016635268,
0.0155731924,
0.0097011346,
0.0200780183,
-0.0062262863,
-0.0172584336,
0.0364013985,
0.0221740175,
-0.0153468745,
0.0181563683,
-0.0173705537,
0.0507766455,
-0.0606468357,
-0.0139613589,
-0.0209130049,
0.0085468292,
-0.016852187,
0.0435632095,
0.0430210456,
-0.0228138492,
-0.0051285648,
0.0157193113,
-0.0176323038,
-0.0200940203,
-0.0203627441,
-0.0026039947,
0.0165771879,
-0.0256478265,
-0.0142983412,
-0.0319725163,
-0.0334207229,
-0.0795003995,
0.0030080425,
-0.0319043249,
0.0360770188,
-0.0489063896,
0.0936907604,
-0.0469963588,
0.0031411401,
-0.0023403869,
0.0072165187,
0.037544284,
-0.0311387368,
0.0255437624,
0.0839794278,
-0.0222560316,
-0.0118043832,
0.027354395,
-0.0326168202,
-0.0850328431,
0.0178738181,
0.0102960216,
0.0080569154,
0.009535701,
0.0248775408,
-0.037359722,
0.0813560113,
-0.0176975448,
-0.0085163666,
-0.0547381155,
0.0225365032,
-0.0210588574,
0.0167896505,
0.0047234292,
-0.0127908522,
-0.0310861692,
0.0605356134,
-0.0409295075,
-0.0480354242,
0.0948586613,
-0.0004193281,
-0.0062411339,
-0.0830519125,
0.0426884852,
-0.061212942,
0.0036163104,
-0.0110332482,
-0.0120269619,
-0.0052487995,
-0.0145890741,
-0.0677520931,
-0.0395158865,
0.0364864245,
-0.0182634871,
0.076018624,
-0.0555176549,
0.0001632697,
-0.0139302323,
-0.0488288403,
-0.0461661629,
0.0068237842,
-0.0270762276,
0.0047086738,
-0.023665864,
-0.025929248,
-0.0069502024,
-0.0230985023,
0.0273469463,
0.0421662442,
-0.0326455012,
-0.0401849821,
-0.0166613311,
-0.0308543481,
0.0212504864,
-0.0171139427,
0.055575829,
-0.0775625706,
0.050388556,
0.0211902596,
0.0849835053,
-0.0011016205,
-0.0231357273,
0.0158077981,
0.042172052,
-0.0422542728,
-0.0406894237,
0.0327545255,
0.0668569207,
-0.0780923367,
-0.0014407485,
0.1405811161,
0.0441190153,
-0.0283908397,
0.0020226082,
-0.0619495027,
0.0614952296,
0.0174623951,
0.0392870121,
-0.0696027279,
-0.0376817659,
0.0350320116,
0.0308964793,
0.0060724472,
-0.0215171762,
-0.0022492441,
-0.1383134723,
0.0052457121,
0.0685376972,
-0.0331751108,
-0.0071550547,
-0.011197133,
-0.0107129253,
-0.0185600109,
-0.0105636045,
0.0440111533,
-0.0148131754,
0.0226806719,
0.0278821066,
-0.0221991818,
0.0023472942,
0.0315268226,
-0.0238143168,
0.0147748711,
0.0596568808,
-0.0061391406,
0.0129525382,
-0.0374990962,
0.0438249893,
0.0252335276,
-0.0384148397,
-0.0428105295,
0.0152893914,
-0.0317276716,
0.0136575224,
-0.031371098,
0.0693682656,
-0.0456357189,
-0.0147520006,
0.0056823343,
0.1291953176,
-0.0054167071,
0.0038151871,
-0.0210886747,
0.0086920196,
-0.0474159196,
0.016670065,
0.0061315908,
-0.0271527749,
-0.0395435952,
-0.0447872803,
-0.0386429094,
-0.0267429147,
0.0096612005,
-0.0142939771,
0.0340684243,
0.0226032138,
-0.0139758419,
-0.0510915071,
0.0316163115,
0.0516646653,
-0.0047344137,
-0.032440722,
0.0037259366,
-0.0077534891,
-0.0054030661,
0.0432979688,
-0.0217620395,
0.0505904518,
-0.0606044494,
0.0421393402,
-0.0128105152,
-0.000127561,
-0.0126138842,
0.0048081665,
-0.0358159915,
-0.0677272677,
-0.0220569409,
0.0660212785,
0.0281911287,
0.0374159627,
-0.0163769796,
-0.0231902748,
-0.0059581371,
0.0229750834,
-0.0176639128,
0.0008340534,
0.0528570786,
-0.0175222587,
0.0328865834,
0.0184052754,
-0.0058227214,
-0.01338486,
0.0201641265,
0.0704849139,
-0.0177494138,
-0.0186105222,
0.0437269583,
0.0173687264,
0.0194321498,
0.0066346889,
0.0177210141,
-0.0450431742,
0.0408270955,
-0.0179544352,
-0.0033062554,
-0.0242028292,
0.0238845944,
0.0289189648,
-0.0402635112,
0.0116206631,
-0.0355621912,
-0.0013347596,
-0.003684574,
0.0375999063,
0.0487660281,
-0.0099012302,
0.0483654477,
0.0349849612,
-0.0230097193,
-0.0282779373,
-0.0020744365,
0.0165311471,
0.0514796972,
-0.0090094851,
0.1133428961,
0.0282076765,
0.0461126156,
0.0048871655,
-0.017292928,
-0.0262134895,
-0.1143028215,
-0.0195769053,
-0.0101177497,
0.0522998832,
0.0198155791,
0.0368323773,
-0.0315513052,
0.0002203908,
-0.0130325807,
0.040511284,
-0.0195474382,
-0.0176794212,
0.0314935744,
0.0563625321,
0.0296847578,
-0.0387670882,
0.0438964814,
-0.0259770714,
0.0211508498,
-0.0402764678,
0.0141243851,
-0.0120309629,
-0.0392097645,
-0.0089190407,
0.0055033821,
-0.0128779318,
-0.0135986134,
-0.094455108,
-0.1042893603,
-0.0154226879,
0.0400976539,
-0.0018686821,
-0.0199592747,
0.0314013883,
0.0599916615,
-0.0486641452,
-0.0148271136,
0.0153566198,
-0.0173351374,
-0.0137679195,
-0.0383804962,
-0.0472911634,
-6.776803544e-33,
-0.0351683646,
-0.0234745871,
0.0652349368,
0.0205032751,
-0.0359365456,
-0.0427662209,
-0.0364803262,
0.0318499021,
0.0000041886,
0.0013241564,
-0.0140703265,
0.0257920939,
-0.0074902023,
0.0118675372,
0.0395254679,
0.019973537,
0.0292086918,
-0.0002799985,
-0.0530422628,
-0.0293974057,
0.0259888079,
0.0242780466,
0.0624878928,
-0.0226474963,
0.0045493357,
0.0285340268,
0.0189426318,
0.016003713,
-0.0764465705,
0.0598571002,
0.0229687188,
-0.0231263861,
-0.0092710964,
-0.0422809869,
-0.0434240103,
-0.0193403326,
-0.0312512405,
-0.0440835841,
0.0201235954,
0.0225923657,
-0.0093670338,
-0.03826195,
0.0264931843,
0.0270459224,
-0.0583678596,
-0.0570264235,
0.0057495958,
-0.0188509505,
-0.0219990183,
0.0124050919,
-0.0773825571,
0.0530651398,
-0.0151092336,
-0.0264013279,
0.0196372475,
0.0359675176,
-0.0232852902,
0.0044938894,
-0.0127824796,
0.0113692423,
0.0312926844,
0.0365580544,
0.0739289001,
-0.0030345225,
-0.0021398421,
0.0274972375,
0.0207200311,
-0.0545888133,
0.0207073279,
-0.0141990259,
0.0499614216,
0.0205581822,
0.0654018819,
0.0050726007,
0.0503944941,
0.0369116291,
-0.0572681464,
-0.0043408377,
-0.0030375523,
0.0400694422,
0.0052108276,
0.029309256,
-0.0460845828,
-0.0023258687,
-0.0478346273,
0.0068888944,
-0.0359707922,
-0.0491750576,
0.0355130099,
-0.0245436206,
-0.0232757702,
-0.0128787784,
0.0146298818,
-0.0258061439,
-0.0204807594,
-0.0029122226,
-0.0244312063,
0.0333301462,
-0.0134352958,
0.0390752442,
-0.0983909369,
-0.0084627885,
-0.0253027473,
0.0149545064,
0.0068811094,
0.0264123231,
0.0369800739,
0.0141942706,
-0.0462858342,
-0.0116333235,
-0.0400597714,
-0.0315641277,
0.0361143351,
0.0475968309,
0.042240534,
0.0046443143,
0.015882941,
0.0669297352,
-0.0281759948,
-0.0237023421,
-0.0503656007,
0.0190500729,
-0.0260112137,
0.034181226,
0.002161548,
-0.0142711783,
-0.0270445794,
0.0032327357,
0.0018631206,
-0.0620594099,
-0.0257600658,
0.0403589904,
3.383e-7,
0.0174251515,
0.0592506565,
0.0074904636,
0.0448689535,
-0.0018862648,
0.0545571074,
-0.0286552366,
-0.0376190804,
0.0383437313,
0.0164608732,
0.0241658464,
0.0379068889,
0.045454938,
0.0209513847,
-0.0501177311,
-0.0140606165,
-0.0188664775,
-0.0056122998,
-0.0433418117,
-0.0111968042,
0.0409375578,
0.0685875043,
0.0282303132,
-0.0044266572,
0.0065152422,
0.0346744396,
0.0776114613,
0.0184234846,
0.0039266311,
0.009769707,
-0.0414389372,
-0.0161467157,
-0.0060587279,
0.0031678258,
0.0033064426,
0.0193796437,
-0.0199603476,
0.0739614293,
0.0007688414,
0.0164011158,
0.0004167203,
-0.0103997746,
-0.0101145376,
-0.0754370466,
0.0510624014,
-0.0708496645,
-0.0349026434,
0.0303586796,
-0.026499426,
-0.0460881256,
0.0223113727,
0.0005544093,
0.0012447168,
0.0080242343,
0.011702897,
-0.0114120692,
-0.010603522,
-0.0428730138,
-0.0295569971,
0.0464864448,
-0.0081549753,
-0.0428631939,
-0.0260042269,
0.0426862724,
-0.0011136512,
-0.0110802874,
-0.0272158477,
3.756651504e-34,
0.0506105125,
-0.0250727478,
0.0524943359,
0.0311098062,
0.019636929,
-0.0059106303,
0.0040343134,
0.0328217298,
0.0395106263,
-0.0505463295,
-0.0223973263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00764v1 | Characterizing Stereotypical Bias from Privacy-preserving Pre-Training | 2024-06-30T16:54:43 | 2024-06-30T16:54:43 | Stefan Arnold, Rene Gröbner, Annika Schreiner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Differential Privacy (DP) can be applied to raw text by exploiting the
spatial arrangement of words in an embedding space. We investigate the
implications of such text privatization on Language Models (LMs) and their
tendency towards stereotypical associations. Since previous studies documented
that linguistic proficiency correlates with stereotypical bias, one could
assume that techniques for text privatization, which are known to degrade
language modeling capabilities, would cancel out undesirable biases. By testing
BERT models trained on texts containing biased statements primed with varying
degrees of privacy, our study reveals that while stereotypical bias generally
diminishes when privacy is tightened, text privatization does not uniformly
equate to diminishing bias across all social domains. This highlights the need
for careful diagnosis of bias in LMs that undergo text privatization. | Characterizing Stereotypical Bias from Privacy-preserving Pre-Training: Differential Privacy (DP) can be applied to raw text by exploiting the
spatial arrangement of words in an embedding space. We investigate the
implications of such text privatization on Language Models (LMs) and their
tendency towards stereotypical associations. Since previous studies documented
that linguistic proficiency correlates with stereotypical bias, one could
assume that techniques for text privatization, which are known to degrade
language modeling capabilities, would cancel out undesirable biases. By testing
BERT models trained on texts containing biased statements primed with varying
degrees of privacy, our study reveals that while stereotypical bias generally
diminishes when privacy is tightened, text privatization does not uniformly
equate to diminishing bias across all social domains. This highlights the need
for careful diagnosis of bias in LMs that undergo text privatization. | [
0.037142586,
0.108406119,
-0.0562753156,
0.0350357592,
-0.0230471827,
0.0128533058,
0.0940639302,
-0.011957448,
0.0244510379,
-0.0376907811,
-0.0426542945,
-0.0298690423,
0.0189462937,
0.0099885734,
0.0160760134,
-0.0181819871,
0.035980735,
0.0046634176,
0.0231276751,
-0.0340966582,
-0.0172534212,
0.0254967585,
0.013677991,
0.0187606178,
0.0118071735,
-0.0090849744,
0.0248389412,
-0.0352765433,
0.0083697783,
-0.016979631,
0.0333957747,
0.0948532969,
0.0281880628,
0.0288987141,
0.0000017547,
-0.0537648238,
0.0036428033,
0.0290208794,
0.0040145987,
0.0465956666,
0.0206912067,
-0.0043959888,
0.0408624522,
0.0151673267,
-0.0465896055,
-0.0222598612,
0.0338035002,
0.0406317189,
0.0082118064,
0.0252463389,
-0.0178042855,
-0.0372582376,
-0.0191465821,
-0.0367487632,
0.00052092,
0.0143555822,
0.0487719774,
-0.1107231379,
-0.0956653059,
-0.0034663554,
0.0126729738,
0.0151673276,
-0.002749528,
0.0602956824,
0.0071082655,
0.0582693331,
-0.0347986147,
-0.0434285887,
0.0004471244,
0.0334510542,
0.0472671017,
-0.0180876702,
0.0380796492,
0.018906489,
0.0493795946,
0.0340182297,
0.0153349508,
0.043268133,
-0.0189982485,
-0.0109090265,
-0.0032938083,
-0.0098748943,
0.0131547777,
0.0028012893,
-0.0099051772,
0.0474340394,
0.0238190554,
-0.0337609388,
-0.0299346279,
0.0032672682,
0.0126386713,
-0.0452635549,
0.0486254692,
-0.0615359917,
0.0716867968,
0.0266816504,
-0.0551282316,
-0.0244944021,
0.0155464197,
-0.0496018752,
-0.0265920646,
-0.0063886964,
0.0077875876,
-0.0221458692,
-0.0075582121,
0.0066923639,
-0.0055733337,
0.0484641753,
0.0143767828,
0.0421698578,
-0.0051049348,
-0.029698085,
0.0040296889,
0.0344834402,
-0.0214929823,
0.0194965098,
-0.0201792084,
0.0266175829,
-0.0208715796,
0.0050330725,
-0.044362165,
0.0203309152,
-0.0442956835,
-0.0141757252,
-0.0398260839,
-0.0534616113,
-0.0174135901,
0.0105334967,
-0.0365174748,
-0.0424897186,
0.0090032993,
-0.0332226455,
0.0180190913,
-0.0351280347,
-0.0298077445,
0.052568879,
-0.0014497531,
-0.0412815399,
0.007999544,
-0.0303521808,
-0.0466125906,
-0.0094727315,
0.0148395598,
-0.0249691308,
0.0055688806,
0.0125035755,
-0.0142311566,
-0.044353731,
-0.0047112475,
0.0205679871,
-0.0736882612,
0.0703687817,
0.0272979792,
0.0181007516,
0.0371519066,
0.0423255228,
0.0246914122,
0.052325286,
0.0201446824,
-0.000410969,
0.0329175964,
-0.0200221557,
0.0248008929,
0.0176417548,
0.0443084575,
0.0349274725,
-0.0453707092,
0.0224959068,
0.0053769611,
-0.0526748486,
0.0391515903,
0.0270227436,
-0.0141990054,
-0.0580355078,
0.0839816853,
0.1026466936,
-0.0160328932,
0.0207959265,
-0.0593180321,
0.0551076755,
-0.0241871811,
0.0330337137,
-0.0795919299,
-0.0332606472,
-0.0333771706,
-0.0374696851,
-0.0062800366,
0.0193247795,
-0.0124718547,
0.0051394482,
0.0042474759,
-0.0384711437,
0.0497599579,
-0.0050272965,
-0.0269740932,
0.0139233572,
0.0280386955,
0.0893120691,
0.0169231258,
-0.0341610424,
-0.0047666375,
-0.0308776796,
0.0146302665,
0.0522601306,
0.0040248078,
-0.0044323592,
0.0133292982,
-0.0475544147,
-0.0595286898,
0.0600327775,
0.0240373909,
0.0084145404,
0.0742855221,
-0.025370812,
-0.0367794968,
-0.0027373875,
0.0453983694,
0.0301815625,
0.0117220674,
0.0131391836,
0.0069525475,
-0.0549387373,
0.0196686052,
0.0281682014,
-0.0248966105,
-0.0549949929,
-0.0136876702,
0.0324740522,
0.0152013646,
0.0197902303,
-0.0333363786,
-0.0013639387,
-0.0187070128,
0.0365113132,
0.0034507334,
0.0315172039,
-0.0719384402,
-0.0324030593,
-0.0474602319,
-0.0615418553,
-0.0153675582,
0.0503128543,
0.0101437112,
-0.0029771745,
0.0035257505,
-0.0065406458,
0.0634329617,
-0.0076190466,
0.0089119999,
-0.0595232137,
0.0262159631,
-0.0334245898,
0.0250493716,
-0.0460282341,
-0.0212258436,
-0.05494624,
-0.0574545562,
0.0342329182,
-0.0099054566,
-0.0058896318,
-0.0181553941,
-0.0114701046,
0.0063322247,
0.0319321677,
-0.0142748524,
-0.0242951941,
-0.0244093295,
-0.0454417691,
-0.0121607091,
0.0090848869,
0.0184617452,
0.0257537384,
-0.0058630528,
-0.023232013,
-0.0136535782,
-0.0469634682,
-0.0714835078,
-0.055956129,
0.0711329356,
0.032723967,
0.0144899031,
-0.014218186,
-0.0066432767,
-0.0330376327,
-0.0336511396,
0.054174792,
-0.0190667789,
-0.0210596118,
-0.0173304975,
0.0216638669,
-0.0133139994,
0.0452289656,
-0.0047969795,
-0.0424789041,
0.000909731,
0.0342443809,
-0.0025270672,
0.0536996573,
0.030148942,
-0.0006956439,
0.060027726,
0.0290905703,
-0.0376016237,
-0.0279757828,
-0.0237232838,
0.019767845,
-0.0002453706,
-0.0573499463,
0.0099493992,
0.0311071016,
0.0392881073,
-0.0529138818,
-0.0557162017,
0.011306393,
-0.0372609124,
-0.0756215528,
0.0088857254,
-0.0601104572,
-0.012509129,
0.0433059968,
-0.0460721143,
-0.0572332107,
0.0648032948,
-0.0175134558,
0.0120399157,
-0.0165089667,
0.0050306865,
-0.0026664163,
0.035410203,
0.0239151828,
0.0225736871,
0.0486312136,
-0.0781065449,
-0.0464556627,
-0.0217794869,
0.0258878581,
-0.0161688216,
0.0281046145,
0.0157349017,
-0.0315141752,
0.0283039287,
-0.0664763749,
-0.0383493416,
-0.1055414751,
0.0115245227,
-0.0198266692,
0.0226528309,
-0.0416254215,
0.0134131555,
-0.0305197798,
0.0081553273,
0.0094642229,
-0.0045644757,
0.0098450044,
0.0056969179,
-0.0043987152,
-0.0126290508,
-0.0414588265,
-0.008967869,
-0.0426492319,
0.0007450071,
0.0049753212,
0.0525721461,
0.0511119701,
0.0292569064,
-0.0316644311,
0.0063036988,
-0.0146739436,
-0.0670528412,
0.0002933373,
0.0538000949,
-0.0060326969,
0.0106464429,
0.1083162799,
0.0024402908,
-0.0477474853,
-0.0106806867,
0.0425780267,
0.0180064067,
0.0173706356,
-0.0144261364,
-0.0854315534,
0.0241584424,
0.0083349301,
0.0180804208,
-0.0250184648,
-0.0467690639,
-0.0248293206,
-0.1122692004,
-0.0347642079,
0.0006014788,
-0.0231351331,
-0.0056620846,
-0.0319651738,
0.0101041216,
-0.001582755,
0.0212788396,
-0.0522396564,
0.0064734528,
-0.005185111,
0.010458868,
-0.0653940514,
-0.0251303073,
-0.0095460266,
-0.0318760574,
0.0226606037,
0.0519958027,
0.0134727759,
-0.0470232479,
-0.0354651697,
0.0060193455,
0.0062405667,
-0.0024530033,
0.0030951286,
0.0999218598,
-0.0476122424,
-0.0001603738,
-0.0154023217,
0.0358945802,
0.0218297374,
0.0141420253,
-0.011095752,
-0.0061662341,
0.0125999022,
-0.0504758023,
-0.0031889598,
-0.0107817762,
-0.0017310824,
0.062766321,
0.0114647662,
-0.0372177362,
0.0237184037,
-0.0403096788,
0.0204551127,
0.0078427475,
0.0212141387,
0.0255540758,
-0.0020586788,
-0.0761272088,
-0.0477796495,
-0.0013358223,
-0.0115392003,
0.0169700403,
0.0523762219,
-0.0055138953,
0.0418278389,
-0.0364222936,
-0.0373597145,
0.0400019139,
-0.0292536318,
-0.0266304538,
0.0018245871,
-0.0156131582,
0.0220873542,
-0.0213912278,
-0.0030458758,
-0.0306580383,
0.0019684888,
-0.0803820044,
0.0779083967,
-0.0125752995,
0.0163259264,
0.0749615356,
-0.011198503,
-0.0816436559,
0.1199094132,
0.0753346086,
-0.0247488059,
0.0173481349,
0.0626740009,
-0.0043594157,
0.015868295,
0.002787699,
-0.004379679,
0.0046466361,
0.0390323624,
-0.0675393492,
-0.0210574344,
-0.0263195727,
-0.029454926,
0.0128634796,
0.0856121406,
0.0061756014,
0.0769155771,
-0.0639700741,
0.0005531683,
-0.0332895108,
-0.001403951,
0.0226673111,
-0.0403829552,
0.0467491187,
0.0302706007,
-0.0102969268,
0.0282784477,
-0.0218617767,
0.0296597872,
-0.0362748392,
0.0028758571,
0.055248335,
0.0373316184,
0.0074945893,
0.0249031428,
-0.0186704863,
0.0722185969,
-0.0113536594,
0.029250605,
0.0081639495,
0.0356635079,
0.0109183956,
0.0210341532,
-0.0208227839,
0.0175196584,
-0.0521688946,
-0.0268381443,
0.0065578055,
0.0209667962,
-0.0384443961,
-0.0383966304,
0.0019164117,
-0.009953375,
0.0118865445,
0.0262774155,
-0.0185932387,
-0.0025360701,
-0.0169728864,
0.0357451811,
-0.0079386709,
-0.0266192406,
0.0376978591,
0.056213554,
0.0294069629,
0.0645526648,
-0.0332383886,
-0.0229506847,
-0.0341073163,
0.0002672835,
0.0698977411,
0.036637187,
-0.0245861653,
-0.0235742591,
-0.0398263857,
-0.0825949758,
-0.0204903632,
-0.0115721514,
0.0217291322,
-0.0126460539,
0.012143217,
0.0295772888,
0.0029551103,
-0.0474655442,
-0.0177488141,
-0.0023744081,
0.0140003571,
0.0017044736,
0.0048328536,
-5.800232224e-33,
-0.0017429657,
-0.0098026935,
-0.051526811,
-0.0149682658,
0.0131618269,
-0.0190412905,
0.0001181971,
0.0266776495,
-0.0244673546,
-0.0083661079,
-0.0394727066,
0.0371203274,
0.0046375166,
0.0016342178,
-0.0035285754,
0.002678202,
0.0579987988,
-0.0362708457,
-0.0145528587,
-0.0041685607,
0.0109502915,
0.0430821516,
0.0368847512,
-0.0447680466,
0.065157108,
-0.0043197586,
-0.0417802893,
0.0049407538,
-0.0299128685,
0.0243722424,
-0.046623081,
0.0083715925,
0.0186319947,
0.025642585,
-0.0103211245,
0.1064014807,
-0.0396199375,
-0.0387250632,
0.010994372,
-0.0121164117,
0.0283641722,
-0.0446596295,
0.0458112992,
-0.0201446526,
-0.0514828078,
0.0213674549,
0.0297494642,
0.0069122813,
0.0076821647,
0.0040083039,
0.0121780671,
-0.0086565362,
-0.0156325623,
0.0171404108,
0.0317652673,
-0.0104700401,
0.0184159763,
-0.0050912378,
-0.003847725,
0.0267924983,
0.0445152558,
-0.0221127588,
0.0391302034,
0.0144881634,
0.0471601076,
0.0425563119,
0.0914834663,
0.0746682212,
0.0057924557,
-0.0589254536,
0.0570966899,
-0.0187084284,
-0.0152199678,
0.0330806077,
0.0083026672,
-0.0393961743,
-0.0027167406,
-0.0020302087,
-0.0033430241,
-0.0624349117,
0.0595845394,
-0.006390315,
-0.0849102139,
-0.0481062941,
-0.06656795,
-0.0312539451,
-0.0272355005,
0.024444798,
0.0037505261,
0.0050229682,
-0.0314409472,
0.0049507562,
-0.0110694077,
-0.0497457944,
-0.0443606451,
0.0262749884,
0.0030977186,
-0.0133175682,
-0.0093627078,
0.020471219,
-0.0746302456,
-0.0275032669,
0.0162772499,
0.0483166352,
0.0164070409,
0.0317656547,
0.038357351,
-0.0021790613,
-0.0984230265,
-0.0110247647,
-0.0066483859,
0.0032137237,
0.0455560274,
0.0216205847,
0.0523173325,
-0.0028159588,
0.0039909431,
0.007638603,
0.0521853864,
0.0282577369,
-0.052467525,
0.0260980781,
-0.0237750076,
0.0180456638,
0.025437206,
-0.0348021463,
0.018959716,
0.0074805599,
0.1042893827,
-0.0142406207,
-0.0112656439,
-0.0609013997,
2.458e-7,
0.0000472753,
0.038709823,
0.0043974011,
-0.004021165,
0.0169843659,
0.0686388835,
0.0340328589,
0.0661371425,
0.0089814542,
0.0315562263,
-0.018113574,
-0.0061045089,
0.0203789864,
0.0165041015,
-0.0401073508,
0.0060098246,
-0.0314434692,
0.0463556685,
-0.0443530791,
0.0249733664,
0.0110966684,
0.0403215587,
0.0420584939,
0.0097718295,
-0.0402320027,
-0.0415976085,
0.0273949038,
-0.0555707701,
-0.0108279912,
-0.0165712219,
0.0046641491,
0.0769146755,
0.0169719364,
0.023619201,
-0.0107308589,
0.0496724211,
-0.0659322962,
0.0679864213,
0.006750274,
0.0030645297,
0.0202687103,
-0.0271208286,
-0.0429249369,
-0.0533973575,
0.0327005126,
-0.0232205559,
-0.0548659191,
-0.0198134035,
0.0097636534,
-0.0579830036,
0.0520560667,
-0.0238485411,
-0.0018459847,
-0.0134911872,
-0.0069109313,
-0.0029651762,
-0.0004815758,
-0.0810895115,
-0.0319669843,
-0.0083629014,
-0.01722572,
-0.034984909,
0.0122330235,
0.0327806175,
0.0163287204,
-0.0330435,
0.0714277253,
2.208167516e-34,
0.0077811396,
0.0131696295,
0.0009928133,
-0.0120863989,
0.0333251245,
-0.0079297898,
0.0616419278,
0.002231448,
0.043176312,
-0.054510884,
-0.0045794733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00747v1 | A Comparative Study of Quality Evaluation Methods for Text Summarization | 2024-06-30T16:12:37 | 2024-06-30T16:12:37 | Huyen Nguyen, Haihua Chen, Lavanya Pobbathi, Junhua Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evaluating text summarization has been a challenging task in natural language
processing (NLP). Automatic metrics which heavily rely on reference summaries
are not suitable in many situations, while human evaluation is time-consuming
and labor-intensive. To bridge this gap, this paper proposes a novel method
based on large language models (LLMs) for evaluating text summarization. We
also conducts a comparative study on eight automatic metrics, human evaluation,
and our proposed LLM-based method. Seven different types of state-of-the-art
(SOTA) summarization models were evaluated. We perform extensive experiments
and analysis on datasets with patent documents. Our results show that LLMs
evaluation aligns closely with human evaluation, while widely-used automatic
metrics such as ROUGE-2, BERTScore, and SummaC do not and also lack
consistency. Based on the empirical comparison, we propose a LLM-powered
framework for automatically evaluating and improving text summarization, which
is beneficial and could attract wide attention among the community. | A Comparative Study of Quality Evaluation Methods for Text Summarization: Evaluating text summarization has been a challenging task in natural language
processing (NLP). Automatic metrics which heavily rely on reference summaries
are not suitable in many situations, while human evaluation is time-consuming
and labor-intensive. To bridge this gap, this paper proposes a novel method
based on large language models (LLMs) for evaluating text summarization. We
also conducts a comparative study on eight automatic metrics, human evaluation,
and our proposed LLM-based method. Seven different types of state-of-the-art
(SOTA) summarization models were evaluated. We perform extensive experiments
and analysis on datasets with patent documents. Our results show that LLMs
evaluation aligns closely with human evaluation, while widely-used automatic
metrics such as ROUGE-2, BERTScore, and SummaC do not and also lack
consistency. Based on the empirical comparison, we propose a LLM-powered
framework for automatically evaluating and improving text summarization, which
is beneficial and could attract wide attention among the community. | [
0.0628271848,
0.0050627938,
0.0237870626,
-0.0164516624,
-0.0455604009,
-0.0144609176,
-0.0202144086,
-0.013661027,
-0.0021369725,
-0.078471981,
-0.0002748095,
-0.0140240844,
0.0361390263,
-0.0253197402,
-0.0023082746,
-0.0601176322,
0.0044662734,
-0.0327329561,
-0.004952292,
0.0259854775,
0.0289522186,
0.0069857002,
0.0266566407,
0.0535341576,
0.0406787023,
0.0024982779,
0.0509011857,
-0.0180796105,
0.0433519743,
-0.0305250324,
-0.0059526805,
0.0003246631,
-0.0082219355,
0.0062122899,
0.0000018444,
-0.0959322155,
-0.0200412143,
0.0188250411,
0.0473828949,
0.0920482799,
0.0823391378,
-0.0173671264,
0.0111175701,
0.0321134888,
0.0079281367,
0.0367951989,
-0.0454478562,
0.0440493822,
0.0741286501,
0.023964135,
-0.0107265506,
-0.0484880507,
0.0483504832,
-0.0186425131,
-0.0618285201,
-0.0421254672,
0.0331936143,
0.0628433973,
0.0333141461,
-0.0259489268,
0.0067991507,
0.0242035072,
-0.0259672608,
-0.0098889777,
0.0375573002,
0.0071175117,
-0.0604389794,
-0.0126860561,
0.0226145275,
0.0600255877,
0.0172330588,
0.0065432778,
0.0427361652,
0.0190972555,
0.0242571551,
0.0137749631,
-0.0666409209,
0.0474070683,
-0.0091805961,
0.0306303613,
-0.0077610817,
0.0422584042,
-0.0058074659,
0.0462894626,
-0.0278960206,
0.0430857427,
-0.0016508776,
-0.0327350833,
-0.011007268,
-0.0167049207,
-0.0367381349,
-0.0364506654,
0.0298220478,
0.0183089338,
0.0092861978,
-0.0226707365,
-0.0350070409,
-0.0446421094,
0.0494074635,
-0.0674511865,
0.0078310939,
-0.0369413607,
0.0175700355,
0.0579198673,
-0.0416801237,
0.0320460498,
0.0301853847,
-0.0062541738,
-0.0615076311,
-0.0172773078,
-0.0410976447,
0.0047179856,
-0.0225684978,
0.050676737,
-0.0292158909,
-0.051984407,
-0.0505584069,
0.0078106164,
-0.0146034714,
0.0054636793,
0.0042236159,
-0.0104816994,
0.0545748696,
0.0053097783,
-0.0290089734,
0.0159645621,
-0.0189039074,
-0.0115939621,
-0.0102066612,
0.0192113668,
0.0091065122,
0.0294795614,
0.0039706943,
0.0309205595,
0.0166313536,
0.0358422548,
0.0039955005,
-0.0571701378,
-0.0177707579,
-0.0181309581,
0.0080118021,
-0.0370835029,
-0.0281023458,
-0.0719644278,
-0.0436955802,
0.0160339754,
-0.0036497775,
-0.0178129636,
0.0012713152,
0.0039757574,
-0.0704841986,
-0.0074266163,
-0.0283109732,
0.0469707623,
0.0413627066,
0.0154435681,
0.0167921986,
0.0226866249,
0.0675953329,
0.0425092764,
0.0607808493,
0.0105628148,
0.032201536,
0.0333923139,
-0.0258826632,
0.0043618158,
0.022978697,
-0.0098006278,
-0.0280196629,
0.000458613,
0.0244583171,
0.0736028105,
-0.0367837697,
0.0551317073,
0.0674632415,
0.067310527,
0.0123423338,
0.0013980041,
0.0064963959,
0.0484954491,
0.0729805082,
0.0282968152,
0.0279978644,
-0.0016354057,
-0.0557187684,
0.057215862,
0.1066844091,
0.0370972455,
0.000111738,
-0.0728412643,
-0.0181957968,
0.0157158934,
0.0187496934,
-0.0099924719,
0.0322846286,
-0.012780088,
-0.0595433116,
0.0268688109,
-0.0245879516,
-0.0497952066,
0.0170623157,
-0.0216080658,
0.009667851,
0.0420038886,
0.0605763569,
-0.0446450748,
0.0220944043,
-0.025072597,
-0.0226735547,
0.0211049672,
0.0358420312,
-0.0077020396,
-0.0384722725,
-0.0569636598,
-0.0131216841,
-0.006720989,
0.0075535313,
-0.0419826061,
-0.0261104628,
-0.0161692854,
0.0407471433,
-0.0344114788,
-0.0726326555,
0.0370656773,
0.0027170086,
-0.014354364,
-0.0058432301,
-0.0429780148,
0.0331477411,
0.0454715304,
-0.0254547074,
0.0364741236,
0.0182750821,
-0.0255120397,
-0.0108304881,
0.0068463814,
0.0063280389,
0.0019051239,
0.0269869268,
-0.0557123683,
-0.0062292474,
0.0258805715,
-0.0152580626,
-0.0261139665,
-0.007740872,
-0.0552415475,
-0.0087550012,
-0.0283641089,
0.0341383368,
-0.0134911174,
0.0003284301,
-0.0360753797,
0.0665051043,
0.0150151011,
0.0161903743,
0.0490941443,
-0.0311067924,
0.0186313987,
-0.0159671735,
-0.0531540923,
-0.0112886261,
-0.0098811882,
0.0229728911,
0.0680549592,
-0.0007970035,
-0.0063022077,
-0.0291679148,
-0.1073125303,
0.0124608986,
0.0082093449,
0.0217775069,
0.0297849588,
-0.0009352645,
-0.0076516136,
0.0269945096,
-0.0089322748,
-0.0686254203,
0.0133120669,
-0.0012402228,
0.0461127311,
-0.0141656622,
0.001314514,
-0.0644244328,
-0.0111799408,
0.0003194177,
0.0632433891,
0.0114666466,
-0.0105373459,
-0.0443659797,
0.0616763122,
-0.0110845314,
-0.0498056561,
0.0193603858,
0.0004724315,
-0.0265396908,
0.0077007911,
0.0339576602,
0.0460069813,
0.043351505,
-0.010558296,
0.0416845903,
0.0001110448,
-0.0124216471,
-0.0403017439,
-0.0086152991,
0.0381999798,
0.0164415706,
-0.0358379446,
0.046811223,
0.0352576748,
0.0055700974,
-0.0013867201,
-0.0218003578,
0.0018598929,
-0.0538950227,
0.0020029384,
-0.0353327952,
-0.0297850762,
0.0092907744,
0.025202319,
-0.0123281134,
-0.0126530649,
0.055374112,
-0.0515126474,
0.030847596,
-0.0743308589,
-0.0053422041,
-0.0579254627,
0.0262260251,
0.0201630779,
0.0096959937,
-0.0257051699,
-0.0116942152,
-0.0017061811,
-0.0339945965,
0.0409748219,
-0.0401326641,
0.0746004507,
-0.0633049086,
0.0281251855,
-0.0246957969,
0.0204385146,
0.0236929618,
-0.0332513563,
-0.0410736166,
0.0257034842,
0.0310906302,
0.0255352147,
-0.0215593837,
0.056597922,
0.0423960835,
0.0354134403,
-0.0159503073,
-0.0154355289,
-0.0078776125,
0.059237238,
0.0517784841,
-0.0118195321,
0.0368035175,
-0.0127167702,
0.0250128601,
0.0204653572,
0.0310692936,
0.0138903977,
0.0078640571,
-0.0384232663,
-0.0101156542,
-0.0900644884,
-0.0048073428,
0.0027460847,
0.0554123186,
-0.0230210144,
0.0277230721,
0.1009648517,
0.0240718331,
0.0356840827,
-0.007818711,
0.0406927653,
-0.0051699751,
-0.0022290037,
-0.0071615619,
-0.0416506119,
-0.0038021847,
-0.0035403222,
0.0306622945,
0.0120563079,
-0.0166216083,
0.0063967942,
-0.0987679362,
0.0108755743,
0.020801831,
-0.042388808,
-0.0351782478,
-0.0524154417,
0.00275836,
-0.0365136601,
-0.0049142553,
0.0128684202,
-0.0411057584,
0.0113226548,
0.0056571844,
-0.114628233,
-0.0053431899,
-0.00743334,
-0.0453175679,
0.0004397753,
0.074853763,
0.0234004017,
-0.0074373214,
0.0327280611,
0.0253398195,
-0.0439505354,
-0.0338594019,
0.0177422296,
0.0367086716,
0.0055498159,
0.0376578681,
-0.0270745922,
0.0293621439,
0.0146417646,
0.0071267295,
0.0258267615,
0.0188801959,
0.0333970077,
-0.0218017735,
-0.05269273,
0.0378746539,
-0.0827964395,
0.070036523,
0.0386828259,
-0.0004240153,
-0.0376970209,
-0.0338172205,
-0.0216486901,
-0.0660501868,
-0.0454906188,
-0.0096972408,
-0.0561003499,
-0.0073584123,
-0.0958006978,
-0.0480683893,
0.0041545038,
-0.0486174636,
0.0093034245,
0.023143515,
0.0098623177,
0.033883512,
-0.0026765885,
0.0256879777,
0.010413955,
0.0081864437,
-0.0577986501,
0.022871444,
0.0837207586,
0.0011606471,
-0.0325127728,
0.0216830764,
-0.0349466503,
-0.0464178808,
-0.0508092679,
0.0274423398,
0.0238610618,
0.004797413,
-0.0174464528,
-0.0447602756,
0.0730953068,
0.0393682867,
0.0096548134,
0.0199938826,
-0.004998784,
0.030536674,
-0.0295783617,
-0.0152090136,
-0.071435973,
0.0311411936,
-0.0496841408,
0.0708917603,
-0.0128792254,
-0.0634036064,
-0.0006817468,
0.0561362132,
0.0104010301,
-0.01078784,
0.0254319385,
-0.0045904033,
-0.0501423515,
-0.0096114762,
-0.0131037245,
-0.0378036648,
0.0454512723,
-0.002214289,
0.0134812044,
-0.0295287129,
0.0828496963,
0.0015491481,
0.0205780603,
-0.0356251523,
0.0195975453,
-0.0369221456,
-0.0276277456,
-0.0705296993,
-0.0295317881,
-0.0326344222,
-0.0551198125,
-0.0412285514,
-0.0224728584,
0.0000433236,
-0.0032991839,
0.0121975392,
0.0131223211,
0.029718589,
0.0534434691,
-0.079396084,
-0.0001726722,
-0.0666879267,
0.0344241224,
0.0588522814,
-0.0212726612,
0.0912939161,
-0.0005230681,
-0.0217123237,
-0.0350140333,
0.041204676,
0.0269760508,
0.0290082619,
-0.0622972958,
0.0187749825,
0.001667591,
-0.0142114349,
0.08117944,
-0.0051474101,
-0.0012727669,
-0.0112495795,
-0.0339835733,
-0.0488281287,
-0.0258112084,
-0.0194920413,
0.0085387565,
-0.0076160571,
-0.0392816067,
-0.083542943,
0.0142298341,
0.0443977192,
0.0243007895,
0.0269489549,
-0.0436570942,
0.0150136482,
0.0285970755,
-0.0019519791,
0.010028746,
-0.061146643,
-0.0409927517,
-0.0097361822,
0.0026276808,
-0.0098306155,
-5.475437992e-33,
-0.0177664626,
-0.0136317927,
-0.0482416339,
-0.000630872,
-0.0510712452,
-0.0038796712,
-0.0432768576,
-0.0312059503,
0.0198240373,
-0.0137626817,
-0.0097100055,
-0.0131239491,
-0.0006292373,
0.0065813465,
0.0224130396,
0.0385363959,
0.0304348096,
0.0084282905,
-0.0693548769,
0.0076187239,
-0.0044401861,
0.0055100829,
-0.0030459692,
-0.0479994491,
0.0233583786,
-0.0094763394,
-0.0393331163,
-0.046660915,
0.0487691239,
0.0359362103,
0.0015288296,
0.0116412397,
0.0334044658,
-0.0613101907,
-0.0200985875,
-0.0060122269,
-0.0646626726,
0.0040780678,
0.0289222859,
-0.0640414879,
-0.0195646305,
-0.0296471603,
0.0628541037,
-0.0024367373,
-0.0354102738,
0.0096893804,
0.0748944059,
-0.0700900778,
-0.051690463,
-0.0958027765,
-0.0190730188,
0.0334610753,
-0.0434187055,
-0.0183296222,
0.0436790921,
0.0299606957,
-0.0296753477,
0.0478247292,
-0.0291959308,
0.0457842052,
0.0266552158,
0.0302341022,
0.0331904739,
-0.0070054629,
0.0345548801,
0.0308973044,
-0.0332199819,
-0.0041488237,
-0.0130228996,
-0.0117855426,
0.0021144764,
0.0135632828,
0.0391276628,
0.0178954564,
0.0166680478,
0.0270684287,
-0.0332875066,
0.0985504687,
-0.0248912945,
0.0104311211,
0.0364329927,
0.0078754891,
0.0085815527,
0.0010348732,
-0.0346300378,
0.0034534556,
0.0090814075,
0.0211542249,
-0.0198982302,
0.021199327,
-0.0632190034,
-0.011809756,
0.0091773421,
-0.0441402979,
0.0056832503,
-0.0102274055,
-0.01774415,
0.0741615891,
0.0083519071,
-0.0285546184,
-0.0366090611,
0.0148978587,
-0.0017889413,
0.0208441634,
0.0120724132,
-0.0324026085,
0.0132687753,
-0.0412873663,
-0.0279102251,
0.0276225246,
0.0255149975,
-0.0145959826,
-0.0336794592,
0.0077657849,
-0.0368527472,
-0.0012806663,
0.0264275484,
0.0366558507,
-0.0026079051,
0.0033216097,
-0.0086766724,
-0.0040573999,
0.0351672843,
0.0081676738,
-0.0188889876,
0.0341903307,
-0.003643736,
0.0395677052,
0.025901828,
-0.0085543292,
-0.0224040076,
0.0005332499,
2.431e-7,
0.0531535447,
0.0634374768,
0.0331861004,
0.0119950352,
-0.0356280059,
0.0272171274,
0.0081396261,
0.033129666,
0.0233680904,
0.0068722935,
0.0314244889,
-0.0089358464,
0.0512936004,
0.0038181625,
-0.0904133096,
-0.0516592152,
-0.0950889885,
-0.0350361504,
-0.0364704505,
-0.0141242407,
0.0599707402,
0.0499864258,
-0.0136209037,
0.012735365,
-0.0400137901,
-0.0654036999,
0.0441477373,
-0.038101662,
-0.0324861109,
0.0417670645,
0.0770504177,
0.008251762,
-0.0289570931,
-0.0091515994,
-0.0016275478,
0.0087664193,
0.0804573447,
0.0444115624,
0.0374325998,
0.026974963,
0.0040095192,
-0.0274814591,
0.0454740115,
-0.0042046588,
0.0409502648,
-0.0156649016,
0.0007538982,
-0.0219709408,
-0.0389296785,
-0.0041455724,
0.0020262431,
-0.0012701887,
-0.036212828,
0.0423431657,
-0.0188500769,
0.0011816066,
0.0116455676,
-0.0559469983,
-0.0271187425,
0.0135545526,
0.0061731357,
-0.0418456011,
0.0012001785,
0.003717805,
0.0122376848,
-0.0749836788,
0.0071400125,
2.14818608e-34,
0.1031194553,
-0.0355248861,
-0.0353668146,
-0.0031553435,
0.0508224182,
-0.0009844048,
-0.0076031345,
0.0005176294,
-0.0255314223,
-0.0795254633,
0.0268711895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00740v1 | Locate&Edit: Energy-based Text Editing for Efficient, Flexible, and Faithful Controlled Text Generation | 2024-06-30T16:04:29 | 2024-06-30T16:04:29 | Hye Ryung Son, Jay-Yoon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent approaches to controlled text generation (CTG) often involve
manipulating the weights or logits of base language models (LMs) at decoding
time. However, these methods are inapplicable to latest black-box LMs and
ineffective at preserving the core semantics of the base LM's original
generations. In this work, we propose Locate&Edit(L&E), an efficient and
flexible energy-based approach to CTG, which edits text outputs from a base LM
using off-the-shelf energy models. Given text outputs from the base LM, L&E
first locates spans that are most relevant to constraints (e.g., toxicity)
utilizing energy models, and then edits these spans by replacing them with more
suitable alternatives. Importantly, our method is compatible with black-box
LMs, as it requires only the text outputs. Also, since L&E doesn't mandate
specific architecture for its component models, it can work with a diverse
combination of available off-the-shelf models. Moreover, L&E preserves the base
LM's original generations, by selectively modifying constraint-related aspects
of the texts and leaving others unchanged. These targeted edits also ensure
that L&E operates efficiently. Our experiments confirm that L&E achieves
superior semantic preservation of the base LM generations and speed, while
simultaneously obtaining competitive or improved constraint satisfaction.
Furthermore, we analyze how the granularity of energy distribution impacts CTG
performance and find that fine-grained, regression-based energy models improve
constraint satisfaction, compared to conventional binary classifier energy
models. | Locate&Edit: Energy-based Text Editing for Efficient, Flexible, and Faithful Controlled Text Generation: Recent approaches to controlled text generation (CTG) often involve
manipulating the weights or logits of base language models (LMs) at decoding
time. However, these methods are inapplicable to latest black-box LMs and
ineffective at preserving the core semantics of the base LM's original
generations. In this work, we propose Locate&Edit(L&E), an efficient and
flexible energy-based approach to CTG, which edits text outputs from a base LM
using off-the-shelf energy models. Given text outputs from the base LM, L&E
first locates spans that are most relevant to constraints (e.g., toxicity)
utilizing energy models, and then edits these spans by replacing them with more
suitable alternatives. Importantly, our method is compatible with black-box
LMs, as it requires only the text outputs. Also, since L&E doesn't mandate
specific architecture for its component models, it can work with a diverse
combination of available off-the-shelf models. Moreover, L&E preserves the base
LM's original generations, by selectively modifying constraint-related aspects
of the texts and leaving others unchanged. These targeted edits also ensure
that L&E operates efficiently. Our experiments confirm that L&E achieves
superior semantic preservation of the base LM generations and speed, while
simultaneously obtaining competitive or improved constraint satisfaction.
Furthermore, we analyze how the granularity of energy distribution impacts CTG
performance and find that fine-grained, regression-based energy models improve
constraint satisfaction, compared to conventional binary classifier energy
models. | [
0.0839353055,
0.0744302571,
0.0025435083,
-0.0083108442,
-0.0253119841,
0.0046665794,
-0.0088032624,
0.0142947203,
-0.0267589465,
-0.0483697616,
0.0088905608,
-0.0110461237,
-0.0160699822,
0.036791224,
0.0158613734,
-0.0339852832,
0.0483562201,
0.0191942602,
0.0005374336,
0.0093594901,
0.0124263084,
0.0002383967,
0.0290259905,
0.0256349482,
-0.0330058187,
0.0310108662,
-0.0302394107,
0.0717482492,
0.0300043672,
-0.0044564395,
0.006583014,
0.0546816699,
0.0001333232,
0.032844808,
0.0000023305,
-0.0205060486,
-0.0712858811,
0.0046978444,
0.0033089989,
0.0297341496,
0.0862065852,
-0.0360381119,
-0.0514566228,
0.0037991153,
0.0092916898,
0.0067150448,
0.1070499569,
-0.0246544499,
0.0535859689,
0.0702882484,
-0.0203138702,
0.0331085362,
0.0058567198,
-0.0375728272,
0.0568903536,
0.0101772258,
0.0386093482,
-0.0161063876,
-0.0334431417,
0.0034541846,
-0.0048271874,
0.0640867278,
0.0107809408,
-0.0149608087,
0.0070575178,
0.0278848074,
-0.0118158497,
-0.0388286673,
-0.0047715264,
0.0365106612,
-0.0218304507,
-0.0341212004,
0.0119007761,
-0.0240508467,
-0.0375390574,
-0.0303854588,
-0.0052152332,
0.034434218,
0.0179825854,
0.0290938839,
-0.0047565992,
-0.0124402158,
0.0327023603,
0.0087379534,
0.0109674288,
0.0294321422,
0.0279211514,
-0.0448733978,
-0.01558288,
0.020698091,
-0.0214807726,
-0.0559854805,
0.0244812332,
0.0036790422,
0.0160860773,
0.0286870673,
-0.0953462571,
-0.0338367075,
0.0186715759,
-0.0623101555,
0.0339988321,
0.0390000902,
0.0185965281,
-0.0126461163,
-0.0045179469,
0.0285890792,
-0.0197649859,
-0.0180817097,
-0.0443980657,
0.0477812625,
-0.0019323244,
-0.0414218381,
-0.0675150082,
0.0151707679,
-0.0508056805,
-0.0330231413,
-0.0473350286,
0.0362014323,
-0.0008778692,
0.0054003056,
-0.0050631813,
0.0464028195,
-0.0496771336,
0.0343192779,
0.0341331065,
-0.0080440138,
0.0054077473,
-0.0198460128,
0.022108309,
-0.0486157276,
-0.0160753727,
0.0167259146,
-0.0034953926,
-0.0279204864,
-0.0007153021,
0.0817926452,
-0.0023961931,
-0.0176852997,
-0.046471037,
-0.0576853827,
-0.0420792066,
-0.0335371606,
-0.041326683,
-0.0465838723,
0.0109181982,
-0.0351235531,
-0.0053782528,
-0.0838469043,
0.053478267,
0.0031485092,
-0.0375342667,
0.0584945939,
-0.0188839193,
-0.0113489488,
0.0221926067,
0.0060150069,
0.0125875603,
0.0620377138,
0.0879689753,
0.0539990291,
0.0301692057,
0.0052191056,
-0.0330927819,
0.0482077673,
0.0251988303,
0.0297235101,
-0.0450444743,
-0.0591978543,
0.0059023355,
0.0421755351,
0.0126945758,
0.0502040908,
-0.0067499345,
0.0311823413,
0.1098273546,
0.0023001898,
0.0067739938,
0.0352662317,
0.0477031805,
-0.001968934,
-0.0575444475,
0.0119225066,
-0.0212602206,
-0.0056650178,
-0.0373452604,
-0.0237937067,
0.0412580147,
0.0018918109,
0.0156310294,
-0.0355787948,
-0.0014506466,
-0.0099033965,
0.0186425764,
-0.0320334695,
0.0192447901,
0.0008167219,
-0.0801775604,
0.0962783694,
0.0519526303,
-0.0881410986,
0.0064927572,
-0.0269175284,
-0.0115583306,
0.0919832215,
0.0802142993,
0.0036401406,
-0.0183060952,
0.0188497119,
0.0034650315,
0.0607423075,
0.0213870313,
0.012564132,
-0.0068667894,
-0.048765298,
-0.0181895122,
-0.0235450007,
-0.0053948732,
0.0115388129,
-0.0021285268,
0.0165242683,
0.0242891591,
0.0048759156,
-0.0682780147,
0.0356848314,
0.005908303,
-0.0226454996,
0.015615127,
-0.0076057389,
0.0036881629,
-0.0189092923,
-0.0536695421,
0.0177189298,
0.0251214448,
-0.0424997918,
-0.033668194,
0.011140327,
-0.0321523212,
-0.0056320797,
0.0307163037,
0.0061013103,
0.0348264426,
0.0054110228,
-0.00794427,
-0.0213650446,
-0.0044131516,
-0.0817277357,
0.0244147163,
-0.0295974258,
0.0508098863,
-0.0065374477,
-0.0247938577,
-0.0372364707,
0.0737411901,
-0.0183689687,
-0.0031079191,
0.0134952338,
-0.012250632,
0.0009850709,
-0.0326297283,
0.0112993401,
-0.0093797678,
0.0186077952,
-0.0099720731,
0.0373208076,
0.0302583352,
-0.0002312834,
-0.033571966,
-0.0121299159,
0.0121702831,
-0.0091288742,
0.0065937159,
0.0452538282,
0.0084565775,
-0.0028180061,
0.044069618,
-0.0236611832,
-0.0176964086,
-0.0104381526,
0.0149136232,
-0.0129310936,
0.0151157621,
-0.0044578882,
-0.0403933376,
-0.0109480768,
0.0059210639,
0.0483356938,
0.000732498,
-0.0416574627,
-0.0324995741,
0.0319211744,
-0.0289612114,
0.0063718124,
0.0184796415,
-0.0584016293,
0.0019241171,
0.0149083473,
0.0410911702,
0.0365981646,
0.0251147896,
0.0397349484,
0.0791667849,
0.0094669973,
-0.035397213,
0.0197445899,
-0.029750729,
-0.0074124113,
-0.0039692405,
-0.0874287337,
0.0269796662,
0.0887798145,
0.0128442599,
-0.0043061785,
-0.0678156614,
0.0444445983,
-0.0036417493,
-0.067821607,
-0.0290096402,
-0.0128153367,
-0.0304391719,
-0.0094649475,
-0.0465167761,
-0.0789553747,
0.0580490381,
-0.0534892455,
0.0371042565,
-0.0287625641,
0.0011210047,
0.0231534522,
0.0164680202,
0.0369425453,
0.0660155863,
0.0193846654,
0.0074725072,
-0.019765133,
0.037152648,
0.0479897261,
-0.0248169545,
0.0164164752,
-0.0594168827,
0.0021973525,
0.0229034238,
-0.0317703411,
-0.0409445353,
0.0081625264,
0.014362854,
0.0068189846,
0.0801970512,
-0.0480082817,
-0.0472244397,
0.0411715955,
0.0250215046,
0.0299850777,
-0.0009769304,
-0.0216065682,
-0.0374021605,
0.0011430128,
0.0804681256,
-0.0440241322,
0.009892703,
-0.0209872331,
-0.0063920901,
0.0942845494,
-0.0431981049,
0.010443015,
0.0065508573,
0.0454245098,
0.0229729172,
0.0024695427,
-0.0146234361,
0.0049782679,
0.0248375442,
-0.0192677081,
-0.0346030146,
0.0829329789,
0.0463237427,
-0.0146163246,
0.0531404763,
-0.0094172843,
0.0658595413,
0.0106883477,
0.011268585,
-0.0761572197,
-0.0247328747,
0.0375509933,
0.0689291805,
-0.0563511848,
-0.0105135487,
-0.0360971466,
-0.0535732284,
0.007468001,
0.0497851633,
-0.0138121787,
0.0025747975,
0.0039612264,
-0.0183356889,
0.0018476808,
-0.0377479382,
0.0332596749,
0.0151126757,
-0.0128589217,
0.0230739992,
-0.0135163218,
-0.0129401674,
-0.0614312962,
-0.0146809453,
0.0063869189,
0.1026081517,
0.004218793,
0.0294214729,
-0.0046839602,
0.0147084417,
-0.0066697374,
0.0141745219,
-0.0423087291,
0.0008519774,
0.0080266679,
-0.0139126172,
-0.0149535974,
0.0371613465,
0.0141811511,
-0.0254521817,
-0.0087322248,
0.0712069348,
-0.0043614814,
-0.0186118558,
-0.044584956,
0.0057363301,
0.0561035573,
0.0758752525,
0.0498068742,
-0.0480850041,
-0.0515701696,
-0.0627909601,
-0.0009589699,
-0.0986908004,
-0.0289160553,
-0.0058058645,
-0.0645930022,
-0.0757613331,
-0.0793568492,
0.0228363257,
0.0014994841,
0.0569319203,
0.0007018637,
-0.0142785301,
-0.0026979451,
-0.0277768318,
-0.0623190925,
-0.0159579515,
-0.0082974099,
0.0156219667,
-0.0403412804,
-0.0756738484,
0.0202539042,
-0.0055716825,
-0.0088783605,
0.0481763333,
-0.049055893,
-0.1033958048,
-0.0161366109,
0.0688047633,
0.0254891366,
0.0151882609,
0.0029183433,
-0.0511846542,
0.0358600765,
0.0743851885,
0.0014502257,
0.0617526695,
-0.0144343283,
-0.0164125543,
-0.0046752775,
0.0215782449,
-0.0527987666,
0.0048951986,
0.016278429,
0.0907387808,
-0.0137506295,
-0.0240094177,
0.0525236875,
0.0136709996,
-0.0130275451,
-0.042163454,
-0.0288665816,
-0.0032526853,
0.0220622104,
-0.0200579725,
-0.0048011523,
-0.0725829601,
-0.0061748005,
0.0195192527,
-0.0060913451,
-0.0324951671,
0.036963556,
-0.0440656319,
0.017745303,
-0.0465927832,
-0.0127435243,
-0.0218948051,
0.0448541604,
0.0828330964,
-0.0048054727,
-0.0104309442,
0.0291322861,
-0.0266890824,
-0.0053581288,
-0.0292169675,
-0.0189428348,
0.0326156355,
0.0084233908,
-0.049219586,
0.0428503752,
-0.0043053473,
0.0126710348,
-0.0694335699,
-0.0427011885,
0.0351211913,
0.0379878208,
0.073351413,
-0.0534822606,
-0.0375309177,
-0.0248729344,
0.0213197097,
0.0343633667,
-0.0790739208,
0.0261157788,
-0.0028802792,
-0.0209854282,
-0.0076874811,
0.0717414767,
0.0444362685,
0.0916682631,
-0.0353107192,
-0.0409641229,
-0.0151965749,
-0.019390082,
-0.016741693,
-0.0087690409,
-0.0344685428,
-0.0167835187,
-0.0399592631,
-0.054977946,
0.0293175448,
0.006707266,
0.0232316852,
-0.0084422911,
0.0315242,
0.0135376416,
-0.0098559121,
-0.0442650132,
-0.0059508677,
0.0186324157,
-0.001657473,
-0.0292700361,
-0.0068499222,
-6.860105686e-33,
-0.0053306404,
-0.0363394581,
0.000150887,
-0.0064755594,
-0.0335343294,
0.0057186182,
-0.0503877625,
0.0185724162,
0.050624717,
-0.0115591493,
0.0354383551,
-0.0165559817,
0.011633846,
0.0212000255,
-0.012192212,
0.0291659199,
0.046657782,
0.0003300102,
-0.0478343777,
0.0386265665,
0.0526019372,
0.0452895574,
0.0258683152,
-0.0357104018,
-0.0020708374,
0.0064454339,
-0.0428030156,
-0.0177582409,
-0.0393576883,
0.0374456458,
-0.013786138,
0.0446837507,
-0.0072425241,
-0.0099779591,
-0.0279449709,
0.0119402623,
-0.0409617387,
0.0092851259,
0.0035172082,
-0.0248021912,
-0.0272529032,
-0.0911298692,
0.0498525687,
0.0157623626,
-0.0433000959,
0.0128410067,
-0.0084901704,
-0.0412956402,
-0.0351869278,
-0.0580896176,
-0.077073589,
0.0186846219,
-0.004358728,
0.0045039915,
-0.0253989678,
0.0168786459,
0.0123324441,
0.0135736894,
-0.04505831,
0.03293176,
0.0634883344,
0.0456202738,
0.0475673378,
0.0169985313,
0.0279446412,
0.0617714897,
-0.0256071147,
-0.0230350196,
-0.0461455546,
0.0296187606,
0.0418819673,
0.0391376019,
0.0339593627,
0.0123695424,
0.0107887359,
-0.0405504443,
-0.0794478804,
0.0291085877,
-0.0174683314,
0.0065082177,
0.0239902139,
0.0174234323,
0.0011741366,
-0.0255085099,
-0.0320594572,
0.0129816197,
-0.029287342,
-0.0531777442,
0.0373361111,
0.0266339798,
-0.0809902474,
-0.0337866917,
-0.004207565,
-0.0043416517,
0.0220179372,
0.0416462421,
-0.0322194733,
0.0340428576,
-0.0050502406,
0.0134211751,
-0.0278044119,
-0.0290583298,
0.0560752265,
-0.0233720522,
0.0062037362,
0.0025781165,
0.0234409422,
0.052275151,
-0.0395286307,
0.0187351983,
-0.0491796657,
0.0488446653,
0.0335669853,
-0.0183298141,
-0.0046910816,
-0.0359717533,
0.0115669947,
0.0093507171,
0.0213200096,
0.0009524032,
-0.0186379235,
0.0160415098,
0.0028060446,
0.0347964875,
-0.0386561677,
0.0110594928,
-0.0307589099,
0.0207349565,
0.0281375777,
-0.0672323331,
-0.0446708128,
-0.0065791402,
3.07e-7,
0.0380147398,
0.0270091426,
0.0282114334,
-0.0024814827,
0.027685279,
0.0166330189,
0.0155896815,
0.0293048508,
-0.0374995172,
-0.0394590497,
0.0114294179,
-0.0225101579,
0.061942663,
0.0114650065,
-0.0139733953,
0.0188560523,
-0.0638011917,
0.0218261033,
-0.0538452715,
-0.026508702,
0.0251873247,
0.0320601352,
-0.0144678997,
-0.0096910354,
0.0353308395,
-0.0186926704,
0.0485571027,
-0.0425913297,
0.0296720024,
0.0080118738,
-0.0071856482,
0.0010174569,
-0.0129603883,
-0.0529024564,
-0.0364130698,
-0.0427197181,
-0.0176803507,
0.0625966489,
-0.0334169455,
-0.0248038433,
0.0348604843,
-0.005066257,
-0.0127244201,
-0.0093251104,
0.051979024,
0.0073882616,
0.0108558312,
-0.0107583739,
-0.0119007928,
0.0058458108,
-0.0231734384,
-0.0406842493,
-0.0271983426,
0.0185427088,
0.0014790779,
0.0456511527,
-0.0152887171,
-0.0388946161,
-0.0045971847,
-0.0120657971,
-0.0415953249,
-0.0270715617,
-0.078465648,
0.0480561331,
-0.0026575276,
-0.0401689447,
-0.0036649315,
3.215205261e-34,
0.0101031149,
-0.0361691415,
0.0236381646,
-0.0192185175,
0.0475363545,
0.0334800407,
-0.0054439809,
0.0174521655,
0.0076978719,
-0.0886233374,
-0.0494931601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00731v1 | Large Language Models Struggle in Token-Level Clinical Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-30T15:38:48 | 2024-06-30T15:38:48 | Qiuhao Lu, Rui Li, Andrew Wen, Jinlian Wang, Liwei Wang, Hongfang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized various sectors, including
healthcare where they are employed in diverse applications. Their utility is
particularly significant in the context of rare diseases, where data scarcity,
complexity, and specificity pose considerable challenges. In the clinical
domain, Named Entity Recognition (NER) stands out as an essential task and it
plays a crucial role in extracting relevant information from clinical texts.
Despite the promise of LLMs, current research mostly concentrates on
document-level NER, identifying entities in a more general context across
entire documents, without extracting their precise location. Additionally,
efforts have been directed towards adapting ChatGPT for token-level NER.
However, there is a significant research gap when it comes to employing
token-level NER for clinical texts, especially with the use of local
open-source LLMs. This study aims to bridge this gap by investigating the
effectiveness of both proprietary and local LLMs in token-level clinical NER.
Essentially, we delve into the capabilities of these models through a series of
experiments involving zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting,
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), and instruction-fine-tuning. Our
exploration reveals the inherent challenges LLMs face in token-level NER,
particularly in the context of rare diseases, and suggests possible
improvements for their application in healthcare. This research contributes to
narrowing a significant gap in healthcare informatics and offers insights that
could lead to a more refined application of LLMs in the healthcare sector. | Large Language Models Struggle in Token-Level Clinical Named Entity Recognition: Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized various sectors, including
healthcare where they are employed in diverse applications. Their utility is
particularly significant in the context of rare diseases, where data scarcity,
complexity, and specificity pose considerable challenges. In the clinical
domain, Named Entity Recognition (NER) stands out as an essential task and it
plays a crucial role in extracting relevant information from clinical texts.
Despite the promise of LLMs, current research mostly concentrates on
document-level NER, identifying entities in a more general context across
entire documents, without extracting their precise location. Additionally,
efforts have been directed towards adapting ChatGPT for token-level NER.
However, there is a significant research gap when it comes to employing
token-level NER for clinical texts, especially with the use of local
open-source LLMs. This study aims to bridge this gap by investigating the
effectiveness of both proprietary and local LLMs in token-level clinical NER.
Essentially, we delve into the capabilities of these models through a series of
experiments involving zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting,
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), and instruction-fine-tuning. Our
exploration reveals the inherent challenges LLMs face in token-level NER,
particularly in the context of rare diseases, and suggests possible
improvements for their application in healthcare. This research contributes to
narrowing a significant gap in healthcare informatics and offers insights that
could lead to a more refined application of LLMs in the healthcare sector. | [
0.0446100608,
0.0318494365,
0.0225925129,
-0.0037230947,
-0.0224139579,
0.03935121,
0.006419695,
0.0286027007,
0.0148235215,
-0.0415704474,
-0.0222944822,
-0.0654726103,
-0.0022763726,
0.0126780448,
0.0224471036,
-0.0243110415,
0.0461622775,
-0.0097391093,
0.0525956862,
0.0136396326,
-0.0336578675,
-0.0035299903,
-0.0096459743,
0.0578700677,
0.0266114492,
0.0039195968,
0.0110840034,
0.0184999742,
0.0240388606,
-0.0786651,
-0.0334308259,
0.0302876402,
-0.0223896373,
0.0411564335,
0.0000019712,
-0.0583782867,
-0.0447561555,
0.0454652496,
-0.0352024622,
-0.0450602919,
0.0361713395,
-0.025395304,
-0.0310709588,
-0.0142672975,
0.0084410859,
-0.0577734411,
0.0183064938,
0.0619682446,
0.0104375035,
0.084432669,
-0.0137580652,
0.0224632788,
0.0464288928,
-0.0172126051,
0.0537563898,
-0.042929329,
0.0597542301,
-0.0486187041,
0.043738123,
0.0089825112,
0.0276261438,
0.0438203663,
-0.0331598371,
0.0396888144,
0.0219055638,
0.0681396499,
-0.0710145533,
-0.014940572,
-0.0093117002,
0.0416317359,
-0.0061822264,
-0.0013797889,
0.0714535043,
0.0127940997,
-0.0167492088,
-0.0016670177,
-0.0453298539,
-0.0008746125,
-0.0445606895,
-0.0017233526,
0.0175491776,
-0.0219547097,
0.03127167,
-0.0137680657,
-0.0306029432,
-0.0161209796,
0.0262420736,
-0.034477219,
-0.0129155479,
-0.0105930036,
-0.0374152027,
-0.0556802079,
0.0399607979,
0.0570145473,
-0.0307576451,
0.0225741435,
-0.0249656793,
-0.0277249683,
0.072228089,
-0.0215859693,
0.0011099596,
0.0160065163,
-0.0204719603,
0.044042293,
-0.0482447296,
0.00879901,
-0.0113562979,
0.0346590653,
0.0037007274,
-0.0020631005,
-0.0341072083,
-0.0291202813,
-0.0489210226,
0.0278421268,
-0.0309363939,
-0.0129780564,
-0.0582496151,
-0.0090467697,
0.013444243,
0.0400088131,
0.0165609587,
0.0159418937,
-0.0169705432,
0.0017701978,
0.0026374517,
-0.0006804569,
0.018879395,
-0.0347383134,
-0.0054076398,
-0.0889724195,
0.0108197527,
-0.0085821785,
0.0254810788,
-0.0284581725,
0.0566710681,
0.087345697,
0.040195059,
-0.0858119875,
-0.0162280854,
-0.031938877,
-0.0335194692,
-0.0264756605,
-0.009127574,
-0.049432151,
0.0268805511,
0.043231532,
0.0007768717,
-0.0381155796,
0.0215610284,
0.0201688912,
-0.0773754045,
0.0506035164,
-0.0497702472,
-0.0029501999,
0.0276146308,
0.0227859169,
0.0249479376,
0.0169990137,
0.0244177412,
-0.0350438841,
0.0149322804,
0.0044889878,
0.0268396605,
0.0163430497,
0.0407862626,
-0.0484501459,
0.0041169776,
0.0167466551,
0.0127743119,
0.0489968993,
0.0010082591,
0.0799048319,
0.0005159366,
-0.0061017526,
0.0282903574,
0.0942954347,
0.0225953534,
-0.0172853153,
0.0281393733,
-0.014017432,
-0.0140864318,
-0.048363287,
-0.0073344568,
-0.01033305,
0.0170414373,
0.0208155531,
0.0190968625,
0.041029267,
-0.0309075378,
0.010124227,
-0.0424489118,
0.0139137348,
-0.0583622977,
-0.0073202429,
0.0498826243,
-0.0129924342,
-0.0581365079,
0.0531996526,
0.0412030481,
-0.0278630331,
0.0097331256,
-0.0780953318,
-0.0125842076,
0.0703036562,
0.081892699,
-0.0316318199,
-0.0404437929,
-0.0090477876,
-0.0298555102,
0.0262168739,
-0.0076229544,
0.0058066417,
-0.0031021945,
-0.039243836,
0.0183145367,
0.0367466323,
0.0080083292,
0.0018840802,
0.0110019678,
0.0394026637,
-0.0111104436,
-0.0318382084,
-0.0038395496,
0.0408901237,
-0.0782967508,
-0.0437686667,
0.0100805201,
0.0123324338,
-0.0064172726,
0.0320721865,
-0.0016512915,
0.0384358205,
0.0199732501,
-0.0266628265,
-0.0141947083,
-0.0126623744,
-0.0102497162,
-0.0398932286,
-0.0082786474,
0.0132892774,
-0.0036880979,
-0.0737645701,
-0.0074750944,
-0.0311117824,
-0.0515725352,
-0.0085537983,
0.0478887223,
-0.0233231839,
0.041442059,
0.053063076,
-0.0217098519,
-0.0491059199,
0.0315724164,
-0.0279743355,
0.0316833369,
0.0537652038,
-0.0233186372,
0.0061797313,
-0.0542883761,
-0.028047163,
0.0121106915,
-0.0190169737,
-0.005481428,
-0.0166263338,
0.0085185459,
-0.0076263417,
-0.0535093062,
-0.1150280461,
0.0300121196,
0.0159533918,
0.0363709219,
0.0171912536,
0.0522493385,
-0.0330201983,
-0.0246020369,
-0.025435036,
-0.0276038852,
0.0393015258,
0.0297925305,
0.0382814892,
0.031251125,
-0.0333382152,
-0.0086569889,
0.0149117745,
-0.0393829755,
0.0274610799,
0.0064288685,
-0.0496702157,
-0.0175150353,
0.022834463,
-0.0405868292,
-0.006747345,
0.0057843672,
0.0241641197,
0.0228843801,
-0.0120088281,
0.0254687294,
0.0499994941,
-0.0220725257,
0.0391303115,
-0.0026699374,
-0.034255974,
-0.0183790587,
0.0200228225,
-0.0365675427,
-0.0230913348,
0.0283409916,
-0.0452652387,
0.0329229198,
0.084613964,
0.0012741523,
0.0027030006,
-0.0477596372,
-0.0006162891,
-0.016705323,
0.0156054785,
-0.0530975126,
0.0237344727,
-0.0468104444,
0.0147431185,
-0.0170692522,
-0.0370843373,
0.0846428648,
-0.0564395301,
0.0122360159,
-0.0476018824,
0.0104674445,
-0.0580924824,
0.0026679337,
0.0109287128,
0.0164678544,
0.0223343205,
-0.0659798458,
0.0293468609,
0.0386634953,
-0.0332916118,
-0.0652825311,
0.0660587177,
0.0143548567,
0.0340424813,
-0.0127343526,
-0.0257610939,
-0.0411097519,
-0.0053098332,
-0.0240740851,
0.0114020472,
-0.0022735083,
-0.0058201775,
-0.0522923879,
0.0538706817,
0.0005597342,
0.0909221619,
0.0057397266,
-0.0218743384,
-0.019598525,
0.0259557758,
0.0167563912,
-0.0400653966,
-0.0013260493,
-0.0243595783,
0.0120362425,
0.0544486642,
0.0129036261,
0.0192615762,
0.0323619209,
-0.000816108,
0.009656081,
-0.0551788509,
0.0072132023,
0.0303122066,
0.0728000253,
-0.0478825532,
-0.0234055966,
0.1129668951,
0.0265015624,
-0.0664491653,
0.0084615573,
-0.0220398735,
0.0032963569,
-0.0203195848,
0.0306294877,
-0.0791017711,
-0.0412474126,
0.0314801373,
0.0367647968,
-0.059169855,
-0.0658512414,
0.0012663553,
-0.0575559512,
0.0450940579,
-0.0030158053,
-0.0788500756,
0.0019415402,
-0.0508085862,
0.0109219849,
0.0032606465,
0.0064857476,
0.0110848863,
-0.0363982171,
0.0009242205,
0.0028093148,
-0.0197208524,
-0.0927083343,
0.0125146015,
-0.034956459,
0.0606755577,
0.0645919293,
0.0134665826,
-0.0008203541,
0.0124335214,
0.003717833,
-0.0024129662,
0.018947931,
-0.0329460651,
0.0628077909,
-0.0128778554,
-0.0100624179,
-0.0692917779,
0.0195095148,
-0.0171367712,
-0.0443963893,
-0.0261223502,
0.0525565594,
-0.0252385978,
-0.0122616543,
-0.0394119173,
-0.0181027483,
0.026441941,
0.0649839193,
0.0077633411,
0.0060741273,
-0.0212443918,
0.0176747236,
0.0372438207,
0.0026030173,
-0.0151269641,
0.0205360726,
-0.0431121811,
-0.0414550826,
-0.038123589,
-0.0112959547,
0.0577480122,
0.0070636156,
0.011240338,
0.0450421385,
0.0092833424,
0.013054681,
-0.0523273237,
0.0724344328,
-0.0035220832,
-0.0128296306,
-0.1077590734,
-0.0447767377,
0.0477858931,
0.0014715334,
-0.0160649363,
0.0059582279,
-0.0419093519,
-0.0346072614,
-0.0179682057,
0.0150886215,
0.0216206275,
0.0039399844,
0.0156484004,
-0.0151162455,
0.0723565817,
0.0863251388,
-0.0304692201,
-0.0194314253,
-0.0370487124,
-0.0002004334,
-0.0228499137,
0.015762724,
-0.0113982297,
0.0353181474,
0.0250960067,
0.0510540903,
0.0140061667,
-0.0062431828,
0.0129512176,
0.0436758436,
0.0566896684,
-0.0208795592,
-0.0150758382,
-0.0373516902,
0.0185880046,
-0.0241857227,
0.047102116,
-0.0158800352,
-0.0364773124,
-0.0069845119,
-0.0150110098,
-0.0340047628,
0.0015291328,
-0.0546758287,
0.0060624257,
-0.0610701591,
0.0396970361,
-0.0079070842,
0.0120865116,
0.0647652522,
-0.0525498129,
0.0012615705,
0.0470783189,
0.0033267541,
0.0237217732,
-0.0449253544,
0.0644287169,
-0.0083163269,
0.0263114274,
-0.0006914167,
0.0437382944,
-0.0441527963,
-0.0083756307,
-0.0269493796,
0.0515080653,
0.0384476818,
0.0231914259,
0.0336924121,
-0.0309992768,
-0.006032221,
-0.0199842323,
0.0144316815,
-0.0265369285,
-0.0022904442,
0.0205106139,
0.0180959087,
-0.0200277306,
-0.0229932349,
0.0667255297,
0.013178004,
0.0458802581,
-0.0037936952,
-0.0340363979,
-0.0361852124,
0.0003206375,
0.0613343827,
-0.0391995981,
-0.0658009052,
0.0031940865,
-0.0767580792,
-0.0280855075,
0.0377460122,
-0.0040995912,
-0.0462348498,
-0.0076674917,
0.0150124934,
0.0236671474,
0.0193765238,
-0.0423827693,
-0.0283465087,
0.0549669303,
-0.0314496905,
-0.0422100723,
0.0347986259,
-6.027361978e-33,
-0.0218227059,
-0.0438300446,
0.0401032269,
-0.029727228,
-0.0071802363,
0.0422213338,
-0.0428759865,
-0.0108801592,
0.0459367074,
-0.0114463894,
-0.0543054678,
-0.0319571421,
0.0209862981,
0.0342253372,
-0.0091607152,
-0.0298540294,
0.0377524048,
0.0330302045,
-0.0291207042,
0.0415911712,
0.0077587203,
0.0570899844,
0.0392735489,
-0.0454844013,
0.0189807191,
-0.0046928795,
0.0385961086,
0.0065945364,
0.0306385197,
0.0598955452,
-0.0509778783,
-0.0085834879,
0.0402866304,
-0.0167849641,
-0.0016737443,
0.0187948849,
-0.101280421,
-0.0007825596,
-0.0187522173,
-0.016640516,
-0.0093019092,
-0.0464425087,
0.0438285507,
-0.0215360261,
-0.0320344716,
0.0403506905,
-0.0007288507,
-0.0111922454,
-0.0348016396,
-0.0227269549,
-0.0485853031,
0.0756196454,
0.0309342984,
0.0074334531,
0.0164387096,
-0.0233839732,
-0.0215033516,
0.0331915356,
-0.0259338133,
-0.0063335728,
0.0537598655,
0.0110605257,
0.0108463494,
0.0003346632,
-0.0122599835,
0.0677485764,
0.0516321808,
-0.0010949345,
-0.0472145267,
0.0083827553,
-0.0208599102,
0.0392712466,
-0.0050047664,
0.0038212808,
0.0362324864,
-0.0066229338,
-0.0667776465,
0.0500716344,
-0.0525903516,
0.0336747766,
0.0491724983,
-0.037308272,
-0.0646474734,
0.009600224,
-0.0093361791,
-0.0093415398,
-0.034968853,
-0.0141243776,
0.0468314216,
0.0030468598,
-0.0242206305,
0.023576634,
0.0368806645,
0.00547675,
-0.0429087244,
-0.0053699636,
0.0521398187,
0.0267445166,
-0.0713426769,
0.0141176851,
-0.0509093739,
-0.0526552536,
0.0415505208,
-0.0118332347,
0.0306700617,
0.0124133518,
0.0161793195,
-0.0283086915,
-0.0845113993,
-0.0043788436,
0.0331765711,
0.0439767316,
-0.0338137448,
0.0363181233,
0.0363607556,
-0.0018028035,
0.0287836865,
0.0491383336,
0.0154201919,
-0.0249618962,
-0.0459523015,
0.009481011,
0.0062904335,
-0.0018411528,
-0.0282314941,
0.0289310049,
-0.0461325161,
0.0431828797,
0.0213420223,
-0.0480028726,
0.0118376259,
-0.0044024056,
2.79e-7,
0.0507648624,
0.0477694385,
0.030660443,
-0.0277956799,
0.0207958203,
-0.0016588961,
0.0058558346,
0.0118939783,
-0.0028548706,
0.008710566,
0.0353643447,
-0.003183296,
0.0280911326,
0.0303398315,
-0.1057852954,
0.0029750483,
-0.0838922486,
0.0066418643,
-0.0545827001,
0.0055284132,
0.0126516027,
0.0542638674,
-0.0625303164,
-0.0357559882,
0.0134596108,
-0.0411633924,
0.0523238219,
-0.0091248844,
-0.0044503491,
0.0654146746,
0.0153945759,
0.0295872632,
0.0295831021,
0.0170702059,
-0.008935174,
0.0043400549,
-0.0229451284,
0.1062601805,
-0.0441575274,
0.0088381972,
0.0368867517,
-0.0213220604,
0.0126865115,
-0.0373087525,
0.0707043558,
-0.0573030934,
-0.0225714799,
-0.0203134678,
0.0048713465,
-0.0211976431,
0.0242497437,
-0.0126933083,
-0.0473750308,
0.0543493554,
0.0310791731,
-0.001543797,
-0.0204544067,
-0.0728130564,
0.0214564912,
0.0166830625,
-0.0301392581,
-0.0282354858,
0.0057217604,
-0.0000731943,
-0.0217347108,
-0.074641034,
0.0087722912,
3.021717054e-34,
0.0123248221,
0.0050022681,
-0.0222241729,
0.0383349359,
0.0173655674,
-0.0167281907,
0.0029590931,
0.0304252207,
-0.0168957524,
-0.0778823122,
-0.0116952565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00702v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00702v1 | Scaling Technology Acceptance Analysis with Large Language Model (LLM) Annotation Systems | 2024-06-30T14:01:06 | 2024-06-30T14:01:06 | Pawel Robert Smolinski, Joseph Januszewicz, Jacek Winiarski | cs.CL | cs.CL | Technology acceptance models effectively predict how users will adopt new
technology products. Traditional surveys, often expensive and cumbersome, are
commonly used for this assessment. As an alternative to surveys, we explore the
use of large language models for annotating online user-generated content, like
digital reviews and comments. Our research involved designing an LLM annotation
system that transform reviews into structured data based on the Unified Theory
of Acceptance and Use of Technology model. We conducted two studies to validate
the consistency and accuracy of the annotations. Results showed
moderate-to-strong consistency of LLM annotation systems, improving further by
lowering the model temperature. LLM annotations achieved close agreement with
human expert annotations and outperformed the agreement between experts for
UTAUT variables. These results suggest that LLMs can be an effective tool for
analyzing user sentiment, offering a practical alternative to traditional
survey methods and enabling deeper insights into technology design and
adoption. | Scaling Technology Acceptance Analysis with Large Language Model (LLM) Annotation Systems: Technology acceptance models effectively predict how users will adopt new
technology products. Traditional surveys, often expensive and cumbersome, are
commonly used for this assessment. As an alternative to surveys, we explore the
use of large language models for annotating online user-generated content, like
digital reviews and comments. Our research involved designing an LLM annotation
system that transform reviews into structured data based on the Unified Theory
of Acceptance and Use of Technology model. We conducted two studies to validate
the consistency and accuracy of the annotations. Results showed
moderate-to-strong consistency of LLM annotation systems, improving further by
lowering the model temperature. LLM annotations achieved close agreement with
human expert annotations and outperformed the agreement between experts for
UTAUT variables. These results suggest that LLMs can be an effective tool for
analyzing user sentiment, offering a practical alternative to traditional
survey methods and enabling deeper insights into technology design and
adoption. | [
0.0491968729,
0.0275952574,
-0.0098357182,
-0.0001819917,
0.0066701076,
-0.0038545185,
0.0183064491,
-0.0235571917,
0.0339311287,
-0.0958770886,
0.0122247702,
0.000044152,
-0.0165600758,
0.0297502074,
-0.0120495139,
-0.0037141962,
-0.0142422607,
0.0192992222,
0.0186035093,
0.0324590541,
0.0444260314,
0.0243627168,
0.0306056868,
0.0494171306,
0.0116295815,
-0.0082050608,
0.0272907335,
-0.0109477062,
-0.0371494181,
-0.0680112019,
-0.0104782041,
0.0510480925,
0.0383771285,
0.0368044376,
0.0000021952,
-0.0375358276,
-0.0136140417,
0.023082396,
-0.025349455,
0.030081166,
0.0809604079,
0.0251769368,
0.0057058474,
0.0029538537,
-0.0208752304,
-0.0060152621,
0.053315945,
0.0467252582,
0.0614560992,
-0.0019188089,
-0.0251480769,
-0.046563562,
-0.0251982603,
0.0195642151,
-0.0388089642,
0.0346424431,
0.0158532765,
0.0679007843,
0.0276245754,
0.0479082763,
0.0482753329,
0.0005227838,
-0.0324675441,
-0.0245692842,
0.0421596095,
0.0002243654,
-0.0032056533,
-0.0470914096,
-0.0142276185,
0.0425379165,
0.0855509862,
-0.0210035257,
-0.0187830869,
-0.0199842472,
-0.0182411522,
0.0586592592,
-0.0695625618,
-0.0188217033,
0.0150111271,
0.0149828792,
-0.029416943,
-0.0019304168,
0.0301634502,
-0.0164706856,
0.0189210754,
0.0835564882,
-0.0018735979,
-0.0190811753,
-0.0122194411,
0.0191858616,
0.0073512644,
-0.0519588999,
0.0047158878,
-0.037584696,
0.0271864869,
0.0104692979,
0.0204940569,
-0.0041089989,
0.0291962065,
-0.0867198855,
0.0720658973,
-0.0132886143,
-0.0012114589,
0.0582637675,
0.001106299,
-0.0159302056,
-0.0446082391,
-0.0790476575,
-0.0291419253,
0.0360534824,
-0.063125588,
0.0110556427,
0.0234259851,
0.0176626388,
0.0099882195,
-0.0257346202,
-0.0733252168,
0.0284423418,
-0.0090415357,
0.0338183641,
0.0238972604,
-0.0249574706,
0.0596770607,
0.0285661891,
-0.0354823954,
0.0570695624,
-0.0270873867,
0.0592496172,
-0.0310984477,
-0.020255046,
0.0800147206,
0.049848184,
0.0190322474,
-0.005604025,
-0.0028714999,
0.0296691637,
0.0434422418,
0.01251351,
-0.0166429095,
-0.040866103,
-0.0041764211,
0.0154760573,
-0.0136291217,
-0.0629244223,
-0.0150420442,
0.0325784981,
0.0000785776,
0.0071475343,
-0.000521337,
0.031107951,
-0.0081823803,
0.0337253176,
-0.0713311657,
-0.0064011454,
0.0131324669,
-0.0136398217,
0.0205821563,
0.0194410048,
0.0093268445,
0.0274146926,
0.0382908434,
-0.0156638864,
0.0132474741,
0.0469483584,
-0.0497093908,
-0.0204585046,
-0.0379598662,
0.0045640552,
-0.0384062119,
-0.0444618575,
-0.0037464534,
0.0483146086,
-0.0104174381,
0.0392698534,
0.0736997053,
0.0505970195,
-0.0209721196,
0.026930403,
-0.0205998346,
0.0363023207,
0.0024053508,
-0.0574923679,
0.0376996733,
0.0243172422,
-0.0278506912,
0.0208762437,
0.037895862,
-0.0133085102,
-0.0121174622,
-0.0604892112,
-0.0582316369,
-0.0317893736,
0.0860758722,
0.0119060539,
0.0514905415,
-0.0474102274,
0.0107731158,
0.0175860431,
-0.0130706783,
-0.0548565723,
-0.0096748937,
-0.0248674955,
0.0751810595,
0.0781443194,
-0.0036908034,
0.0030618103,
-0.0098976921,
-0.0389328189,
0.0016786718,
-0.002133487,
0.0455316603,
-0.0071675801,
-0.1103167161,
-0.0190577842,
-0.0181047078,
0.0249416679,
-0.0000552293,
-0.0018375857,
-0.0110975951,
-0.0220101941,
-0.0077846223,
-0.0165401511,
-0.0399147607,
0.0003755884,
0.0043656696,
-0.0047212169,
-0.0397314243,
-0.0104628894,
0.0775940195,
0.0785640031,
0.0013273315,
0.0246299673,
0.0301663168,
0.001514872,
-0.0528131798,
0.0273199119,
0.0382859521,
0.0361718647,
0.0347471498,
-0.0041510086,
-0.0227855965,
0.0011884539,
0.0232689753,
-0.0135097969,
0.0166793354,
-0.0036104382,
0.0458624326,
-0.0228558909,
-0.0364480428,
-0.0405162387,
-0.0171259679,
-0.0328375772,
0.0050837556,
0.0159023888,
-0.0005530465,
-0.0324945189,
-0.0853972733,
0.0076264702,
0.0328560248,
-0.0987542421,
0.0142494859,
0.0502002686,
0.042945113,
0.0601461157,
-0.0268485378,
-0.0309026465,
-0.0042768116,
-0.1408403218,
-0.0393624343,
0.0305106174,
0.0333332643,
0.009021217,
-0.0122996457,
0.0063490141,
0.0259389337,
-0.0368638262,
-0.0343798734,
-0.0022735933,
0.0406587496,
0.0373063125,
0.0014423783,
-0.008738243,
-0.0465759225,
-0.019543035,
-0.0400640257,
0.0294668488,
0.0619907677,
-0.02963675,
-0.0235140491,
0.0142258396,
-0.0525967441,
-0.0150626395,
0.0100997584,
-0.0001211275,
0.0270249154,
-0.0090590613,
-0.017926231,
-0.0012077678,
-0.0315505937,
-0.0024818161,
0.0525698848,
-0.0008190652,
-0.0443722643,
-0.0161221474,
0.0164612569,
-0.0051924745,
0.0111772437,
-0.0208650585,
0.0229168553,
0.0260863025,
-0.0113555863,
-0.0112407636,
-0.0178825464,
0.0121740997,
-0.0545595884,
0.0127647407,
0.0035765374,
-0.0250692628,
-0.0138480254,
0.0670773238,
0.0335365683,
-0.0128048556,
0.0381596237,
-0.0424045958,
-0.0087991981,
-0.0368266702,
-0.0290674474,
-0.042198617,
0.0132189533,
0.0018872806,
0.0194699597,
-0.0310341064,
0.0441319384,
0.0162733495,
-0.0426368825,
-0.0010007318,
-0.0368984677,
0.0317704231,
-0.007621469,
0.0119413901,
0.0271407422,
0.0160512775,
0.0425073169,
-0.0416579358,
-0.0872983709,
-0.0095281573,
0.030156929,
-0.0265594199,
0.0346194766,
0.0296105724,
0.0101652434,
0.0214161985,
0.0405361019,
-0.0192501657,
-0.0072635817,
0.0143971667,
0.0230761953,
-0.014146232,
0.0039929147,
0.0113668963,
-0.0050655045,
0.0327547528,
-0.0238164067,
0.0056241192,
-0.0896666646,
-0.0325639546,
0.0225058179,
-0.0150022553,
-0.0265839007,
0.0018755724,
0.0219726209,
-0.0302408226,
0.0763822794,
0.0931800827,
0.0015954319,
-0.0371721163,
-0.0131621072,
0.0100235343,
0.0204614475,
0.0408181436,
0.0029316461,
-0.0943778902,
-0.0108264135,
-0.02816879,
0.0004621411,
0.0074621486,
-0.0067798449,
0.0153027782,
-0.0760624483,
0.0078614084,
-0.0012245097,
-0.0110818651,
0.0321466401,
-0.0362301767,
0.0104765128,
-0.0091612637,
0.0117737837,
-0.0208834372,
-0.0142353969,
0.0186501034,
0.0100907544,
-0.1125436798,
-0.0513459109,
0.048516795,
-0.0375582315,
0.0636569038,
0.1040714085,
0.0075808498,
-0.0340135694,
-0.0323923528,
0.0600764304,
0.0453186519,
-0.0136309164,
0.0031463287,
0.0137557099,
-0.0027488284,
0.0195498411,
-0.0190069117,
0.0061269449,
-0.0537235886,
0.0091810497,
0.0124900369,
0.0808809623,
0.0470514633,
-0.0018558976,
-0.0347484425,
0.004434309,
0.0020812685,
0.0627435669,
-0.0061307945,
-0.0680248067,
0.0124464743,
0.0001251131,
-0.0362381935,
0.0476489924,
-0.0556735843,
0.016370222,
-0.0398703218,
-0.0051572588,
-0.073626861,
-0.0294635631,
0.0268801227,
-0.0049049589,
0.02268029,
0.0209029447,
0.0734971911,
-0.0069857487,
0.0115677556,
0.0261276215,
-0.0096097477,
-0.0043234611,
-0.0273246672,
0.023579061,
0.0292836819,
0.0149577036,
-0.0093731014,
0.0018575905,
-0.021093633,
-0.0166450739,
-0.0119049717,
0.0343066566,
0.0243562292,
-0.0371529981,
0.0072360518,
-0.0594995245,
-0.0391135588,
0.0022782264,
-0.0001575575,
-0.0128231104,
0.0124016264,
0.081736736,
-0.0046499604,
-0.0165017024,
-0.0106403809,
0.0118858675,
-0.0143393846,
-0.0297093522,
-0.0386626087,
-0.0591007061,
0.0346865021,
0.0264627282,
0.0330605954,
-0.0078675421,
0.0547745749,
0.0019339485,
-0.0399371125,
-0.022442786,
-0.0288823638,
-0.0474462323,
-0.0154877389,
-0.0137904836,
-0.0287453234,
-0.0462538451,
-0.0162187256,
-0.0077677844,
0.0204345807,
-0.038998317,
0.0665278509,
0.0029918326,
0.0210033264,
-0.0193454213,
-0.0124846268,
-0.0327537134,
-0.0116266944,
-0.0381520651,
-0.0084000807,
0.0075629773,
0.037421681,
-0.0347227789,
-0.0082124621,
0.0206247009,
0.0388339944,
0.016104592,
-0.0488522202,
-0.0350248888,
-0.0041712942,
-0.0145769436,
-0.0386830159,
0.0548426472,
-0.0219985917,
-0.0185436178,
-0.0339192227,
0.0242644083,
-0.0379393287,
0.0061517386,
0.0302786678,
0.0071550724,
-0.0724238381,
-0.0065663815,
0.0262928437,
-0.0134171881,
-0.0499328598,
-0.0346932001,
-0.0457680114,
-0.0514559224,
0.0110611413,
0.0121734925,
0.0025947066,
-0.030836992,
-0.0439661928,
-0.0585766062,
-0.0584225506,
-0.0043789018,
-0.0214590691,
-0.0029244146,
0.0061391462,
-0.0059864153,
0.0611356311,
-0.0137405647,
-0.0213782769,
-0.0481320582,
-0.032317277,
-0.0484008156,
0.0124632968,
-0.0176931284,
-6.406779963e-33,
0.0027726337,
-0.006184319,
-0.007975745,
0.0192947518,
0.0159850139,
-0.006044561,
0.0130139794,
0.049301371,
0.0037858572,
-0.0070171636,
-0.0085041355,
-0.0227606501,
0.0061410316,
0.02058837,
0.0783417001,
0.019014867,
0.0698817074,
-0.0079859672,
-0.0050474945,
-0.0057330928,
0.0250321385,
-0.0597587898,
0.0163914468,
-0.1240714043,
0.0913083032,
-0.0238727387,
-0.018195644,
-0.0267432947,
0.0377402641,
0.0595201515,
-0.0262247268,
-0.0179177299,
0.031315241,
-0.0517386571,
-0.0145294871,
0.0467710122,
0.0047990927,
0.0451269299,
0.0174086262,
0.0159710851,
0.01300772,
-0.0054525849,
0.0535614789,
-0.0467422865,
-0.0417237692,
0.0705272779,
0.0476485267,
-0.0494401269,
0.0088234991,
-0.0321548656,
-0.0408377722,
0.0110291475,
-0.0114189684,
0.0642270148,
-0.0070365341,
0.0606837347,
-0.0096267359,
0.0336656123,
-0.0896491185,
0.018517537,
-0.0000508895,
0.0051456592,
0.0666143075,
-0.0423617326,
0.0095849466,
0.0549123175,
-0.0189860873,
0.0095524741,
-0.0227960255,
-0.0040555228,
0.0112417256,
0.0173013732,
0.0250668395,
0.0394050032,
-0.004683631,
-0.0165786948,
-0.0266118608,
0.0205582324,
0.0225403365,
-0.0029758932,
0.0778887272,
0.0369238257,
-0.0663581863,
-0.0281986929,
-0.0101076392,
-0.0092469724,
-0.0387475789,
-0.0686708167,
0.0008361377,
-0.0149666769,
-0.0340876579,
-0.0008079921,
0.0265150759,
-0.0397625901,
-0.0621830449,
-0.0245686509,
-0.021569673,
0.0577756874,
-0.0088552395,
0.010954625,
-0.0537081547,
0.0058220467,
-0.0767607167,
0.0097296061,
0.00516624,
0.01502812,
0.0227338951,
-0.0079723578,
-0.0947345793,
-0.0208683424,
0.0199277904,
-0.0465069748,
-0.0155754993,
0.0111420834,
0.0495859832,
0.0099780206,
0.0270589944,
0.0432335995,
-0.0239502825,
0.0086054699,
-0.0209410358,
-0.0054591182,
-0.0035687538,
-0.0450783968,
0.0048780432,
-0.0251441281,
-0.0051959674,
0.0199665055,
0.0247055069,
-0.0137166688,
0.0107135605,
-0.0266762972,
2.883e-7,
0.0622028597,
0.0779748932,
-0.0773622394,
-0.0359708555,
0.0263746232,
0.0537194014,
0.0195107013,
-0.0113395406,
0.0483897179,
-0.0195737295,
0.0401528217,
-0.0200824067,
0.0033207189,
0.0384385772,
-0.0768270716,
-0.0566885397,
-0.0368212946,
0.04073257,
-0.0340675227,
0.0197139364,
0.0787902549,
0.0658089519,
0.0186224245,
0.0224054027,
-0.062628679,
-0.0099144317,
0.0551696494,
-0.079303354,
-0.0123719703,
0.0150762722,
0.0453185551,
0.002982365,
-0.0088397022,
0.0101703927,
0.0074467855,
0.0129271401,
0.0187584106,
0.0537702143,
0.0324655734,
0.0263065174,
0.0301232319,
-0.0076034986,
0.034091223,
-0.0552708954,
0.0166760162,
-0.043514736,
-0.0509188659,
-0.1000197604,
-0.021708481,
-0.0213247705,
0.0421696343,
0.0043634623,
0.0221162084,
0.0156425536,
-0.0202334877,
-0.0331140012,
-0.0379448086,
-0.024306206,
-0.0067251548,
0.0525356494,
-0.0328412503,
-0.0545317531,
-0.0286996122,
0.0112107275,
0.0023039787,
0.0069895983,
0.0597298443,
2.359092955e-34,
0.0484756269,
-0.0001266649,
0.0204724707,
0.0312111173,
0.0537209213,
0.0216738507,
-0.009236549,
-0.001525638,
0.0457357541,
-0.0745760351,
0.0274500996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00693v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00693v1 | BAPO: Base-Anchored Preference Optimization for Personalized Alignment in Large Language Models | 2024-06-30T13:30:04 | 2024-06-30T13:30:04 | Gihun Lee, Minchan Jeong, Yujin Kim, Hojung Jung, Jaehoon Oh, Sangmook Kim, Se-Young Yun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | While learning to align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences
has shown remarkable success, aligning these models to meet the diverse user
preferences presents further challenges in preserving previous knowledge. This
paper examines the impact of personalized preference optimization on LLMs,
revealing that the extent of knowledge loss varies significantly with
preference heterogeneity. Although previous approaches have utilized the KL
constraint between the reference model and the policy model, we observe that
they fail to maintain general knowledge and alignment when facing personalized
preferences. To this end, we introduce Base-Anchored Preference Optimization
(BAPO), a simple yet effective approach that utilizes the initial responses of
reference model to mitigate forgetting while accommodating personalized
alignment. BAPO effectively adapts to diverse user preferences while minimally
affecting global knowledge or general alignment. Our experiments demonstrate
the efficacy of BAPO in various setups. | BAPO: Base-Anchored Preference Optimization for Personalized Alignment in Large Language Models: While learning to align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences
has shown remarkable success, aligning these models to meet the diverse user
preferences presents further challenges in preserving previous knowledge. This
paper examines the impact of personalized preference optimization on LLMs,
revealing that the extent of knowledge loss varies significantly with
preference heterogeneity. Although previous approaches have utilized the KL
constraint between the reference model and the policy model, we observe that
they fail to maintain general knowledge and alignment when facing personalized
preferences. To this end, we introduce Base-Anchored Preference Optimization
(BAPO), a simple yet effective approach that utilizes the initial responses of
reference model to mitigate forgetting while accommodating personalized
alignment. BAPO effectively adapts to diverse user preferences while minimally
affecting global knowledge or general alignment. Our experiments demonstrate
the efficacy of BAPO in various setups. | [
0.0365288705,
0.0688581914,
-0.0023857653,
0.0261567514,
-0.0150715522,
-0.0027386413,
-0.0138807734,
-0.0299308095,
0.002930637,
-0.004713119,
-0.0544118024,
-0.052254457,
0.0023048588,
-0.0134255225,
0.0012175034,
-0.0610806197,
0.0638783649,
-0.0099152494,
-0.0016159193,
-0.0278976485,
0.0581868477,
0.0102078086,
0.0160079096,
0.0106377099,
0.0198355131,
-0.0100627486,
0.015661519,
-0.0186864883,
0.0370219462,
-0.0002533467,
0.0302461293,
0.0555231608,
0.0021867901,
0.0237372108,
0.0000018548,
-0.0477392524,
-0.0587889068,
-0.0271494426,
-0.0295338053,
0.0140351793,
0.0463898033,
0.0243358184,
-0.0154489595,
0.0074036322,
-0.0272140633,
0.0135631757,
0.0647464097,
0.0108751776,
0.0414506011,
0.0578925461,
0.0117779151,
-0.0313286185,
-0.0107960422,
-0.033150021,
0.0053602136,
-0.0461982898,
0.0267344471,
-0.031541951,
-0.0304397214,
-0.0168683231,
-0.0081481943,
0.0271266364,
-0.0231642537,
0.0303508583,
0.0303410534,
0.0367175713,
-0.0022018966,
-0.0157451406,
-0.003224612,
0.0746356919,
-0.0089202998,
-0.0266341921,
0.0046997028,
-0.0240313727,
0.0061266841,
0.0042424244,
-0.0270386469,
-0.0115499254,
-0.0056263274,
0.0133660352,
0.012189569,
-0.0246356651,
0.0423237383,
0.0313088261,
-0.0306318067,
0.0643520653,
0.0248074345,
-0.0390818305,
0.0261513423,
-0.0163803659,
-0.0072119948,
-0.0395610519,
0.0185748357,
0.0048740325,
-0.0639960468,
0.0520846322,
-0.0418837257,
0.0264631864,
0.014246013,
-0.0635930225,
0.0488887429,
0.0666179433,
-0.0027376534,
0.0404732525,
0.0051031224,
0.0957885832,
-0.0502674803,
-0.0227171592,
-0.0325779244,
0.0261536371,
-0.0346784666,
-0.0270103812,
0.0034958967,
0.0281307548,
0.0071342541,
0.0045572859,
-0.0270283502,
0.0486999601,
-0.0149562974,
0.0497459248,
0.0047575119,
0.0177602842,
-0.051731281,
-0.043613933,
-0.0568502806,
0.0904164761,
-0.0279366858,
-0.0044333478,
0.0230424013,
0.024283383,
0.0084202606,
0.0071532014,
-0.0248164199,
-0.046588067,
-0.0218269769,
0.0515750274,
-0.0246620569,
0.0150537919,
-0.0016671927,
0.0010937281,
-0.0411498621,
-0.0658726096,
-0.0189430602,
-0.0624801517,
0.0413076654,
0.0096859131,
-0.0159318913,
-0.1070138291,
-0.0060934718,
-0.0000344891,
-0.0412212312,
0.0497862995,
0.0265137758,
-0.0041492376,
-0.0119325761,
-0.0248774942,
0.0067278161,
0.0778519735,
0.0028209479,
0.0174505711,
0.0030252838,
-0.0115834344,
-0.0436424911,
0.0397446565,
0.0013066656,
0.0120805157,
-0.0497607514,
0.0211284682,
0.0417342596,
0.067187041,
0.0475508459,
0.0195974484,
-0.0094780494,
-0.0187709574,
0.0541881286,
0.0177336019,
-0.0214894637,
0.0225358699,
-0.013212936,
0.0027781848,
-0.0137033453,
0.0361812674,
-0.0649678111,
0.0275638849,
-0.0159206539,
0.0289051868,
0.0281829685,
0.0525169484,
-0.0121787805,
-0.0043443209,
0.0036628009,
-0.0025714403,
-0.0226603653,
0.0169199537,
0.0261099283,
-0.0345984213,
-0.0290579367,
0.0895913839,
0.0220241733,
-0.0288539305,
0.0300907195,
0.0030279702,
0.037468344,
0.0864297897,
0.0229832735,
-0.0276181493,
-0.0878711715,
-0.001103071,
-0.0410593748,
0.045086015,
0.0641211942,
-0.0147838918,
-0.0215250831,
-0.0630344748,
-0.0622416921,
0.0441920981,
-0.003779415,
0.0219276361,
0.022591142,
-0.01069903,
0.0110020051,
-0.0034388702,
-0.0218114648,
0.0063096741,
-0.0442882963,
-0.0221845005,
-0.0296784397,
0.0269552283,
0.0279846694,
-0.0025421672,
0.0184761398,
-0.0203875806,
0.0108076688,
0.0024133578,
0.0211670958,
0.0008937884,
-0.0679833665,
0.0010588055,
0.059351325,
0.0090626553,
-0.0241087861,
0.0111075705,
-0.0352865048,
-0.0529331155,
-0.013633051,
0.023534989,
0.0727300122,
-0.0042134328,
0.0446520671,
-0.0157326646,
-0.0544316396,
-0.0731778741,
0.0573868752,
-0.0178921539,
0.0037330214,
0.0064084623,
-0.0369001664,
0.0029524122,
-0.0557164848,
-0.0249972828,
0.0235740822,
0.0088366875,
0.0358830616,
0.0591606013,
0.0001735734,
-0.060622599,
-0.0167170931,
-0.0433729775,
0.0447923094,
-0.0108918184,
0.0169520639,
0.0254587531,
0.0310739987,
-0.0135145709,
-0.0351849832,
-0.0592729487,
-0.0067618806,
-0.0401126854,
0.0334669165,
0.0246538352,
0.023177078,
0.0033835468,
-0.071622394,
0.0053788964,
-0.0066127181,
-0.0092474567,
-0.0404024124,
0.0160857495,
-0.0581471175,
0.0076173167,
-0.0539945848,
0.0242949668,
-0.0079739792,
-0.0090015186,
-0.0072448417,
-0.0006764143,
0.0546012297,
0.0838688761,
-0.0117211072,
0.0075941887,
0.0881141275,
0.0121535575,
-0.0823482201,
0.0029550781,
-0.0558363572,
-0.0315395519,
-0.0460756347,
0.0261942931,
-0.0140989907,
0.0773679614,
-0.01444434,
0.000808224,
-0.0682959929,
0.0148197599,
-0.0025047639,
0.0097660115,
-0.034468323,
0.0202375129,
-0.0491322242,
0.0363227725,
-0.033923056,
-0.0434813388,
0.0753352568,
0.0127691934,
0.0242127161,
-0.074309133,
0.0329097994,
-0.0200221222,
-0.0098224021,
0.01861641,
0.0333447866,
-0.0102402633,
-0.0157724395,
-0.1198889688,
-0.0146925692,
0.0386981517,
-0.0154103469,
0.0475572236,
-0.0265055094,
0.0111582447,
-0.0132072242,
-0.0733028203,
-0.0653474703,
-0.0312770046,
-0.0344842523,
-0.0179544762,
0.0121388445,
-0.0391294621,
-0.0274629369,
-0.0129899001,
0.0526014715,
-0.0016067127,
-0.0069817179,
0.0037064198,
-0.0347582027,
0.0038979368,
0.085841544,
0.004403716,
-0.0035054833,
-0.0059341169,
-0.0510242172,
0.0227612108,
0.0637703314,
-0.0145703843,
0.0041930755,
-0.0077682724,
0.064820379,
-0.0642891079,
-0.0305183902,
0.0230174046,
0.0196536556,
-0.0248341784,
0.0072791572,
0.08446493,
0.0302956253,
-0.0790851414,
-0.0169843473,
-0.0053699417,
0.0727188587,
0.0060913372,
0.0596783422,
-0.0344657004,
-0.0094586238,
0.015890548,
0.0218098592,
0.0328773968,
0.0147632165,
-0.0163266957,
-0.1238934919,
-0.0565907061,
0.0457359031,
-0.0698778406,
0.0004854549,
-0.0249270964,
0.0227853153,
-0.0515522771,
0.0575573929,
0.0248453058,
-0.0161575861,
-0.0087916609,
0.0148564326,
-0.0077336468,
-0.0522364154,
-0.0028384724,
-0.028026361,
0.0580926239,
0.0875895247,
0.0204583649,
0.0294823907,
-0.0340210348,
0.0348260924,
0.0361098237,
-0.02351957,
-0.0084650917,
-0.0214364901,
-0.0102156186,
0.0026866554,
-0.0022460518,
0.0402793437,
-0.0176141225,
-0.0146948742,
-0.0102113485,
0.068118237,
0.010557672,
0.0190826077,
0.0275992099,
-0.0266516283,
0.0032816485,
0.0549006276,
0.0037254274,
-0.0612347387,
-0.0193376597,
-0.051704891,
-0.0259613935,
-0.0284306686,
-0.0168123562,
0.0204708371,
-0.0457428955,
-0.001876138,
-0.0584153906,
-0.0186224729,
-0.0060033388,
0.0278330762,
0.0399991684,
0.0066337669,
0.0225223657,
-0.0363063142,
0.0048101936,
0.0320753269,
-0.0524342135,
-0.0111210281,
-0.0684166402,
-0.000406612,
0.0080177123,
-0.0285269115,
-0.0109432135,
-0.0256996118,
-0.0189714897,
-0.0822218657,
0.0235042367,
0.0632333979,
0.0199823715,
0.0908490121,
0.0034323002,
-0.0598047115,
0.0235701073,
0.0201127939,
0.0053662416,
-0.0030892771,
0.0076310243,
-0.0045654806,
-0.0164714381,
0.0465981029,
-0.0347665995,
-0.0552028269,
0.012016383,
0.0266765896,
-0.0211076867,
-0.0156717878,
0.0263279099,
-0.0216211472,
0.0238997005,
-0.0452953987,
-0.0126109896,
-0.025608344,
0.0153659452,
0.0203984641,
-0.0380187035,
0.0182053354,
-0.0612031147,
0.0379226916,
-0.0040321946,
0.0384472832,
-0.0296520907,
0.0083564986,
0.0232785847,
0.0094432905,
-0.02633713,
0.0455084108,
0.0540898256,
0.0742530599,
0.045449499,
-0.0254972614,
0.033617869,
0.0002169468,
0.0671296194,
-0.0256934445,
0.0460842364,
0.0344399437,
-0.0211177543,
-0.0336142369,
0.0139372339,
-0.0099065313,
-0.0468608439,
-0.0145353777,
-0.0360749587,
0.0577950217,
-0.0654322803,
0.0547576994,
-0.0126027968,
-0.0191164091,
-0.0312951803,
0.0265404433,
-0.0166094024,
-0.0108006634,
0.0059299963,
0.0128916278,
-0.0260454565,
0.0280572511,
0.0805204436,
0.0365007669,
0.0356997401,
-0.0434252694,
0.013029159,
-0.0279716514,
-0.005083526,
-0.0173685513,
0.039297957,
-0.0497976504,
-0.028843727,
-0.0780296028,
-0.04765011,
0.0083288448,
-0.0120632807,
-0.0213321187,
0.0177716222,
0.0445945188,
0.0385960713,
-0.0525810048,
-0.0012721103,
-0.0147074107,
0.0024504545,
-0.0331162475,
-0.0215257145,
-0.0334621854,
-6.29343145e-33,
-0.0334400497,
-0.0013390568,
0.0376669653,
-0.0481736027,
-0.0358226448,
-0.0377482288,
-0.006565975,
0.0233632606,
-0.0011911726,
-0.0381523371,
-0.0186373107,
-0.0377645493,
0.0150806485,
0.0077560251,
0.0408049114,
-0.005138637,
0.0346542113,
0.0147835566,
-0.0428241715,
-0.0092590228,
0.0776379406,
0.0462931618,
0.0517106354,
-0.0439831354,
0.0437396504,
0.0272254031,
0.0091364896,
0.0179864168,
-0.0215891525,
0.0953107625,
-0.0181958061,
0.0139411138,
-0.0053348099,
-0.015588779,
-0.0388061516,
-0.0049998895,
-0.0296272933,
-0.0280837342,
0.0533906035,
0.0344773084,
0.0355414599,
-0.0631235391,
0.0283219814,
-0.0058806622,
-0.0078800907,
0.0019063673,
0.0289955791,
-0.0158164166,
-0.0688173398,
0.0697886795,
-0.0542761795,
0.0003707882,
0.0078768022,
0.0209031943,
0.014427226,
0.001385392,
-0.006357369,
0.0125715109,
-0.03894509,
0.0239235368,
-0.0093904324,
0.0469343737,
0.1093412414,
0.0494493507,
-0.0086055892,
0.0338998772,
0.0156824253,
-0.0324945636,
0.041836556,
-0.0546400659,
0.0313261598,
0.0123531725,
0.0018864629,
0.0687800422,
0.0193201583,
-0.0024066255,
0.0018155621,
0.0186841469,
0.0097419806,
0.0386251248,
0.017049443,
0.0583774522,
-0.0197955016,
-0.0305585731,
-0.0461273491,
-0.0019024995,
-0.0461999178,
-0.0277961884,
0.0203490052,
0.0091620293,
-0.0089726225,
-0.0055295015,
0.041712217,
-0.0349696428,
-0.0333476253,
0.0195704456,
-0.0292935595,
0.0140682049,
0.0115392348,
0.0310779177,
-0.0866505057,
-0.0179782324,
-0.0475114249,
-0.0456719212,
-0.0302181412,
0.0502116568,
0.0382729843,
0.0106236702,
-0.048936408,
0.0156033635,
-0.0315200202,
-0.0415785275,
0.0250556991,
-0.008340219,
0.0603593327,
0.0060060127,
-0.0094278231,
0.0860042721,
0.0617918223,
-0.0071325712,
-0.0195543468,
-0.0423467942,
-0.0084669264,
0.0265817475,
-0.0160288997,
0.0197458491,
-0.0011852285,
0.0335681289,
-0.0207812041,
-0.012966373,
-0.0026653672,
-0.037083406,
2.535e-7,
0.0288726296,
0.0390175059,
0.0284225307,
-0.0307952799,
-0.0122097908,
0.0348714031,
-0.0161460005,
0.0249236971,
-0.0042181043,
0.0296838451,
0.0227825511,
0.0111768954,
0.0270990003,
0.0000829421,
-0.103088215,
0.0128984125,
-0.0241270009,
0.0319177359,
-0.05219578,
-0.0122449929,
-0.0079885516,
0.0827049837,
0.0484666191,
0.0137313036,
0.0034590638,
0.0213341545,
0.0708693713,
-0.0464643314,
-0.0077035679,
0.0005738038,
0.0016656176,
0.0094219148,
-0.0402036123,
-0.0217434764,
-0.0014806588,
0.0277685504,
-0.0158564392,
0.0848848522,
-0.0050173039,
-0.064365238,
-0.0047707362,
0.0167245213,
-0.0100199115,
-0.0609226972,
0.0458374321,
-0.0310236532,
0.0151129989,
-0.0013380548,
-0.0246648006,
-0.0070085707,
0.0127364714,
-0.0137456367,
-0.0194383934,
-0.0009573784,
-0.0043213833,
0.0276096221,
-0.043417152,
-0.0469876491,
-0.0319741666,
0.0425690785,
-0.0335749052,
-0.0346025378,
-0.0234097596,
0.0214005988,
0.016449742,
-0.0519304052,
0.0112742996,
2.161604394e-34,
-0.006900013,
-0.0036954824,
0.0274060145,
0.018987434,
-0.0116003575,
-0.0020841996,
-0.0086444495,
0.042429097,
0.0612951256,
-0.0665714666,
-0.0048882239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02528v1 | Actionable Cyber Threat Intelligence using Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models | 2024-06-30T13:02:03 | 2024-06-30T13:02:03 | Romy Fieblinger, Md Tanvirul Alam, Nidhi Rastogi | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Cyber threats are constantly evolving. Extracting actionable insights from
unstructured Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) data is essential to guide
cybersecurity decisions. Increasingly, organizations like Microsoft, Trend
Micro, and CrowdStrike are using generative AI to facilitate CTI extraction.
This paper addresses the challenge of automating the extraction of actionable
CTI using advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs
(KGs). We explore the application of state-of-the-art open-source LLMs,
including the Llama 2 series, Mistral 7B Instruct, and Zephyr for extracting
meaningful triples from CTI texts. Our methodology evaluates techniques such as
prompt engineering, the guidance framework, and fine-tuning to optimize
information extraction and structuring. The extracted data is then utilized to
construct a KG, offering a structured and queryable representation of threat
intelligence. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach in extracting relevant information, with guidance and fine-tuning
showing superior performance over prompt engineering. However, while our
methods prove effective in small-scale tests, applying LLMs to large-scale data
for KG construction and Link Prediction presents ongoing challenges. | Actionable Cyber Threat Intelligence using Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models: Cyber threats are constantly evolving. Extracting actionable insights from
unstructured Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) data is essential to guide
cybersecurity decisions. Increasingly, organizations like Microsoft, Trend
Micro, and CrowdStrike are using generative AI to facilitate CTI extraction.
This paper addresses the challenge of automating the extraction of actionable
CTI using advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs
(KGs). We explore the application of state-of-the-art open-source LLMs,
including the Llama 2 series, Mistral 7B Instruct, and Zephyr for extracting
meaningful triples from CTI texts. Our methodology evaluates techniques such as
prompt engineering, the guidance framework, and fine-tuning to optimize
information extraction and structuring. The extracted data is then utilized to
construct a KG, offering a structured and queryable representation of threat
intelligence. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach in extracting relevant information, with guidance and fine-tuning
showing superior performance over prompt engineering. However, while our
methods prove effective in small-scale tests, applying LLMs to large-scale data
for KG construction and Link Prediction presents ongoing challenges. | [
0.0461157635,
0.0204064324,
-0.0254587214,
0.0386723205,
-0.0587981082,
-0.023885686,
-0.0076806964,
0.0004894861,
0.070794791,
-0.0395188257,
-0.0015842388,
0.0088280085,
-0.0488527045,
0.0822879523,
0.0368195772,
-0.0147818243,
0.0405241065,
-0.0436200015,
0.0531938039,
0.0294407904,
0.0072760992,
0.0431240164,
-0.0369851366,
0.0106274253,
0.0053424714,
0.0001873307,
-0.0127374744,
-0.0263905488,
0.0677782819,
-0.0451199412,
-0.0184748545,
0.0026935958,
0.0138593782,
0.0064766523,
0.000002018,
-0.072986193,
-0.0391799062,
-0.0255290214,
-0.0227264483,
-0.0078883637,
0.0404693559,
-0.0372908525,
0.0039428622,
0.0139912264,
-0.045169048,
0.0244931541,
-0.0158932786,
0.0746370628,
0.064173542,
0.0976709723,
-0.016786214,
-0.0248400904,
0.0288182497,
-0.0068589845,
-0.0315222256,
-0.0091008274,
0.0577285476,
0.0264445469,
0.0112294806,
0.0566367023,
0.0418586247,
0.0136815272,
-0.0377845243,
-0.006432117,
-0.005633703,
0.0169170722,
-0.0025226164,
0.0114457151,
-0.0175871961,
0.0507905893,
0.0039161458,
0.027427312,
0.0199904237,
-0.0276402365,
0.0248930361,
0.0238730088,
-0.0109565165,
-0.0062245359,
-0.0329997092,
-0.0119089624,
0.035555996,
0.0026135296,
0.0188543312,
-0.0133616915,
-0.0177233182,
0.0517521426,
-0.0294956751,
-0.0169097632,
0.0261458904,
-0.07379134,
0.0055588884,
-0.0346918218,
-0.0105688684,
0.0256327651,
-0.0118364207,
0.0217754673,
-0.0173040964,
-0.036551334,
0.0291840695,
-0.0407702737,
-0.0202563237,
0.0031440989,
0.0458777174,
0.0357968248,
0.0127971992,
0.0312796645,
-0.0035422563,
-0.0023559027,
-0.0292170346,
-0.0248242412,
-0.0677018017,
-0.0381543525,
-0.0186258871,
0.0416247398,
0.019419428,
-0.0133041777,
-0.0305699594,
0.0200505685,
-0.0742577761,
0.0552572869,
0.0364677981,
-0.0102047659,
0.0211461391,
0.0008008407,
-0.0220665149,
-0.0215069726,
-0.0203096718,
0.026379548,
-0.033535704,
-0.0404467471,
-0.0105446465,
0.0215014126,
0.0281081144,
-0.045917619,
-0.0075541353,
0.0845410153,
0.023199955,
0.0070562242,
-0.0256187003,
-0.0513982996,
0.0235382784,
0.0187101662,
0.0081773885,
-0.028686583,
0.034610074,
0.0005318652,
-0.0058741788,
-0.0592830628,
-0.0123778507,
-0.0169173107,
-0.0728049576,
0.030698441,
-0.037889041,
-0.0103755668,
-0.0094562052,
0.0031758691,
0.0251335744,
0.010572928,
0.0391577408,
0.0778688788,
0.0189319924,
-0.0061965636,
0.0341336429,
0.0436917506,
0.0195278488,
0.0004562057,
0.0076601552,
0.0277139135,
-0.0081655197,
-0.04159493,
0.008024998,
0.0195434485,
0.0146097895,
0.0101492666,
0.031627886,
0.0037428546,
0.0079461448,
0.0317001864,
0.0555113479,
0.0554628484,
0.0034748137,
-0.053523533,
-0.0152595658,
0.0079528466,
-0.0880660564,
0.0124414368,
-0.0290575437,
0.0587291718,
0.0103023872,
-0.0007189865,
-0.0312456004,
-0.0008742863,
-0.0167455692,
-0.0168596916,
0.0329960734,
0.0095416531,
-0.0335178412,
-0.0077813696,
0.0347528905,
-0.0162501223,
0.0094096698,
-0.0355817452,
-0.0030411459,
0.0933877975,
0.0409928001,
-0.0491878018,
-0.0640848354,
0.0004922125,
-0.0528747402,
0.0152004045,
-0.0213124808,
-0.0255047251,
-0.0329813287,
-0.0524095446,
-0.0303188246,
-0.0091546979,
0.0143137509,
0.0096312948,
0.0199770387,
-0.0072988584,
0.0160876904,
-0.028703656,
-0.0311733596,
0.0260054041,
0.0014920123,
-0.0184963606,
-0.0323947817,
0.0224936027,
0.0681906268,
0.0203093011,
0.0064069289,
0.0223620683,
0.0610087067,
-0.0390535742,
-0.036654491,
-0.0191886388,
0.011604283,
0.0183936395,
0.0281005744,
-0.0071197115,
0.0432273112,
-0.0035830615,
-0.0476403013,
0.0009633288,
0.0648774356,
-0.0025663667,
-0.0139959296,
0.002641384,
-0.0366259925,
0.039311409,
-0.0020822152,
-0.0093048308,
0.0854331255,
0.0035136605,
-0.0657890812,
0.0175285935,
-0.0374532007,
-0.0249250289,
0.00416535,
0.0371254981,
-0.0004999033,
-0.0118924631,
0.0078539215,
0.0147477118,
0.0012788791,
-0.0186156332,
-0.0327761211,
-0.0432616696,
-0.0022763473,
0.0196188819,
0.0459373184,
0.010112986,
-0.0114400769,
-0.0381836742,
0.026831286,
-0.0265930351,
0.0160278715,
-0.0166042391,
-0.0038831497,
0.0392382219,
0.0302434023,
-0.0198378041,
-0.0085762898,
-0.0020527029,
-0.04014818,
0.0564039797,
0.0227490161,
-0.0620116964,
0.0133249182,
0.0760589615,
-0.0734150186,
0.0054185684,
-0.0486726277,
-0.0325911157,
-0.0075820745,
-0.0634503737,
0.0457852408,
-0.0407354496,
0.0157610327,
0.0528070778,
0.0564507246,
-0.0146097662,
-0.0519438572,
0.0229849163,
-0.0542664714,
-0.0277672708,
-0.0490207896,
-0.0301457308,
0.0444896743,
0.0200228188,
0.0584006496,
0.005524084,
-0.0412286632,
0.0176269747,
0.0080149602,
0.0085987262,
-0.0250155758,
-0.0648535267,
0.0212907828,
0.0185838919,
0.0004800117,
-0.022700293,
0.0709857568,
-0.0056484421,
0.0531058088,
-0.0212944541,
-0.0477152541,
-0.0376088247,
0.0706234276,
-0.0041618166,
0.013779399,
0.0332061276,
0.0153063303,
-0.0135598816,
-0.0359646864,
0.0243372563,
-0.0148318354,
-0.0318985917,
-0.0342835337,
0.0092724487,
0.0322627835,
-0.0000106939,
-0.0580230877,
0.0186777599,
-0.0534068346,
0.0219876319,
0.0383757427,
-0.0253235847,
0.0006330467,
0.0120348306,
0.0488204025,
-0.0039633051,
0.0283814203,
-0.0363157727,
-0.0082188025,
0.0100606931,
0.0457234792,
-0.0425328873,
0.0003324661,
0.0290409885,
0.0184875131,
0.0491666235,
0.0346095711,
-0.0603926145,
-0.0325263776,
0.0096488772,
0.0163435023,
-0.0380724892,
0.0232923068,
0.0295569561,
0.0047786823,
-0.0237480514,
0.0067055328,
0.0882887021,
0.0266988166,
0.0216979589,
0.0124043822,
-0.0170709509,
-0.0263134073,
0.0067759156,
0.0210206714,
-0.0641476363,
-0.0108837355,
-0.0173610616,
0.0349708647,
-0.0372324549,
-0.0744150355,
-0.0160390306,
-0.1010336801,
0.0551316403,
-0.0070152911,
0.023612652,
-0.0484868772,
-0.067117013,
0.0098251933,
0.000280394,
-0.0633938909,
-0.0252217185,
-0.0047360403,
0.0047916826,
0.0113503421,
-0.0582570583,
-0.0270698965,
0.0071590221,
0.0036577461,
-0.0045610536,
0.0143946605,
0.043428354,
-0.0209545884,
-0.0004612557,
0.0535363443,
-0.0323178321,
0.0088466853,
-0.0223487671,
0.0340317003,
0.0118924826,
0.0136755966,
-0.0180750005,
0.0370111726,
-0.0183328558,
-0.0527650602,
0.0700156689,
0.0917562917,
-0.0293191485,
-0.0052412003,
-0.0165798385,
0.0131416721,
0.0229533855,
0.0697672665,
0.0006336707,
-0.0086827939,
0.047212705,
-0.0167599469,
0.0154241491,
-0.0260267258,
-0.0478050075,
0.0242921971,
-0.0322079286,
-0.0229953658,
-0.0570473112,
-0.0402731746,
0.0359369144,
0.0131317656,
0.0233416464,
-0.0465423763,
0.0133511741,
0.010361677,
-0.0470288396,
-0.0081802718,
-0.0269903112,
0.0178733431,
-0.0038542743,
-0.0056710043,
-0.0099467989,
-0.0294755027,
-0.0568288937,
0.0708460733,
-0.0541599765,
-0.0558539629,
-0.0081350682,
0.0490933061,
0.0206170417,
-0.0015251625,
-0.0259720776,
0.0176234003,
0.1089858115,
0.076089412,
-0.0267940685,
-0.0283750985,
0.0219611004,
-0.0115847159,
0.0320823751,
0.0273875464,
-0.0504079983,
0.017152587,
0.0284280721,
0.0044029527,
-0.0823280066,
-0.0414889604,
0.0148800537,
0.0807486624,
0.0314317569,
-0.0024555894,
0.005160402,
-0.0713248104,
-0.0097722309,
-0.0187613703,
-0.0278560184,
0.0092242584,
0.0366472155,
0.009774155,
-0.0268800799,
0.0218799561,
0.0348494127,
-0.0035969343,
-0.0245689079,
-0.052914314,
-0.0015087478,
0.04689705,
0.0639982522,
0.0639369264,
-0.047329165,
0.005213357,
0.0313716568,
-0.0085708033,
-0.0082811313,
-0.007972667,
-0.0006280247,
-0.0045283483,
-0.0250274912,
-0.0505044945,
0.0249489434,
-0.0367096402,
-0.0416117422,
0.0148627777,
0.0254255831,
0.0369543396,
0.050255321,
0.0319425315,
-0.0663871318,
0.004127969,
0.0190683156,
0.0404038541,
0.0054133087,
-0.0387412384,
0.0343368575,
0.0148673868,
-0.036691051,
0.0035096721,
0.0662166998,
-0.0605084449,
0.0903054774,
0.0250752289,
-0.0742953718,
-0.043409206,
-0.0634017363,
-0.022871783,
0.0398810804,
-0.0235809255,
0.0012875906,
-0.0721156523,
-0.0472643301,
0.0342455395,
-0.0035777655,
-0.0212942902,
0.0095570385,
0.0295683425,
0.0414577723,
-0.0004027356,
-0.0190059561,
-0.0640438274,
0.0094250115,
-0.0599416085,
-0.0351816788,
0.0234584231,
-6.416463097e-33,
0.0160991866,
-0.0138961561,
0.0279672518,
-0.0082879476,
-0.0135246152,
0.0204707459,
-0.0247987118,
-0.0268992018,
-0.0190753378,
0.0060107233,
0.0114200031,
-0.0224207677,
0.0014102909,
-0.0026319947,
-0.0431048051,
0.027732471,
0.0030764428,
-0.0039847214,
0.0067171897,
0.0405268371,
0.1056543589,
-0.0066771996,
0.0307194255,
-0.0989888757,
0.0491174683,
-0.0123866303,
-0.0381893218,
0.0021447253,
0.0082266433,
0.0392483622,
-0.0258421823,
0.0593219399,
0.0122370776,
-0.0416751802,
0.042338185,
-0.0255048554,
-0.0335061997,
-0.0471368209,
0.0128878914,
-0.0591943152,
0.002502251,
-0.061178986,
-0.0074905623,
0.0066244579,
0.0246805269,
-0.0067973435,
0.0394523554,
-0.0080612507,
-0.0033131959,
-0.0978185311,
-0.0232934821,
0.0224693324,
-0.0612788722,
0.0337748043,
-0.0099374913,
0.0166095197,
0.0428407714,
0.0227720942,
-0.0527889766,
0.0586700588,
0.0364597961,
0.0093917483,
0.0744809583,
0.0134169236,
-0.0028442382,
0.0365394652,
-0.0645897239,
-0.0331923626,
-0.0076720812,
0.0361279733,
-0.0200009532,
0.0698052347,
-0.0273053031,
0.044589024,
-0.0549692363,
-0.0597763024,
-0.1120785773,
0.0331981145,
0.0209896434,
0.0510051399,
0.0065806997,
-0.0129374191,
-0.0556217171,
-0.0115046315,
0.0212246533,
-0.0469247475,
-0.0033503121,
-0.0098707462,
-0.0056598624,
-0.0188825075,
-0.0351827256,
0.0380347595,
-0.0280756019,
0.0151854632,
0.0202371161,
0.0734072551,
-0.0451467931,
0.0170740113,
-0.019737022,
0.0310247187,
-0.0226115864,
-0.0325131156,
0.0236631315,
-0.0399260186,
0.0150342295,
0.0167299621,
0.0174787547,
0.0135924658,
-0.0381790586,
-0.0014588155,
-0.0351949669,
0.0553032644,
-0.0191469323,
0.0001975083,
0.0105343889,
0.0553172566,
0.0172872301,
-0.0179023091,
0.0645680055,
-0.0276732519,
0.0267575979,
0.081367515,
-0.032361716,
-0.0129528763,
-0.0160604771,
0.0024065566,
-0.023178257,
0.0218805522,
0.0049681305,
-0.0431817248,
-0.0262248032,
0.0068560396,
2.935e-7,
0.037337482,
0.0115095088,
0.0100105014,
0.0803758353,
-0.0184754357,
0.0553876944,
0.0403349586,
0.0397130437,
0.0019101879,
-0.0125090061,
0.0307817515,
0.0351212472,
-0.0303410832,
0.0489209667,
-0.0331061892,
-0.0015238316,
-0.0233043619,
-0.0708319768,
-0.1012788117,
0.0291325226,
0.0848919377,
0.0255842693,
0.0468542948,
0.0036293077,
-0.0444170833,
-0.0536754169,
-0.0336643085,
-0.0201856233,
-0.0307317693,
0.0530889705,
0.0419064276,
0.012961437,
-0.0365301333,
0.0814595446,
-0.0180393253,
0.0036202536,
-0.0332914144,
0.0164309274,
0.0458153673,
0.0051958947,
-0.0132411364,
-0.0492916778,
0.0070574135,
-0.0278493222,
0.0619628355,
-0.0247227754,
-0.0172207039,
0.0441854298,
-0.0357524343,
0.0101082232,
-0.0496568531,
-0.0511432253,
0.012358929,
0.0083469972,
-0.0320648327,
-0.0141169541,
0.0025065963,
-0.0431269966,
0.0377569571,
0.0066585583,
-0.0343925469,
-0.0366832912,
0.0264391657,
-0.0008382414,
0.0367006846,
-0.0003542125,
0.0662376583,
2.673645371e-34,
-0.0033916186,
-0.0133341579,
-0.0434083641,
-0.0391959287,
0.0655102879,
0.0157318152,
-0.0270843357,
0.0439317636,
-0.0047230003,
-0.0735859871,
-0.0187868755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00668v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00668v2 | HRDE: Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models for Chinese Health Rumor Detection and Explainability | 2024-06-30T11:27:50 | 2024-07-03T15:18:40 | Yanfang Chen, Ding Chen, Shichao Song, Simin Niu, Hanyu Wang, Zeyun Tang, Feiyu Xiong, Zhiyu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | As people increasingly prioritize their health, the speed and breadth of
health information dissemination on the internet have also grown. At the same
time, the presence of false health information (health rumors) intermingled
with genuine content poses a significant potential threat to public health.
However, current research on Chinese health rumors still lacks a large-scale,
public, and open-source dataset of health rumor information, as well as
effective and reliable rumor detection methods. This paper addresses this gap
by constructing a dataset containing 1.12 million health-related rumors
(HealthRCN) through web scraping of common health-related questions and a
series of data processing steps. HealthRCN is the largest known dataset of
Chinese health information rumors to date. Based on this dataset, we propose
retrieval-augmented large language models for Chinese health rumor detection
and explainability (HRDE). This model leverages retrieved relevant information
to accurately determine whether the input health information is a rumor and
provides explanatory responses, effectively aiding users in verifying the
authenticity of health information. In evaluation experiments, we compared
multiple models and found that HRDE outperformed them all, including
GPT-4-1106-Preview, in rumor detection accuracy and answer quality. HRDE
achieved an average accuracy of 91.04% and an F1 score of 91.58%. | HRDE: Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models for Chinese Health Rumor Detection and Explainability: As people increasingly prioritize their health, the speed and breadth of
health information dissemination on the internet have also grown. At the same
time, the presence of false health information (health rumors) intermingled
with genuine content poses a significant potential threat to public health.
However, current research on Chinese health rumors still lacks a large-scale,
public, and open-source dataset of health rumor information, as well as
effective and reliable rumor detection methods. This paper addresses this gap
by constructing a dataset containing 1.12 million health-related rumors
(HealthRCN) through web scraping of common health-related questions and a
series of data processing steps. HealthRCN is the largest known dataset of
Chinese health information rumors to date. Based on this dataset, we propose
retrieval-augmented large language models for Chinese health rumor detection
and explainability (HRDE). This model leverages retrieved relevant information
to accurately determine whether the input health information is a rumor and
provides explanatory responses, effectively aiding users in verifying the
authenticity of health information. In evaluation experiments, we compared
multiple models and found that HRDE outperformed them all, including
GPT-4-1106-Preview, in rumor detection accuracy and answer quality. HRDE
achieved an average accuracy of 91.04% and an F1 score of 91.58%. | [
0.0905694589,
0.0704830587,
-0.0005390834,
0.0188629366,
0.005941241,
-0.006344785,
0.0103654657,
0.0400888883,
0.032543432,
-0.0169656724,
0.0152609833,
-0.0453777127,
0.0087231304,
0.0479683168,
-0.0171322729,
-0.0197005197,
0.0120902406,
0.0651654452,
0.0825666189,
0.0120001584,
0.0305247158,
0.0168118961,
0.0122651923,
0.0777254626,
0.0071092108,
-0.0113234147,
0.0479210615,
0.028666582,
0.0037688487,
-0.0923315212,
0.0178605895,
0.001236735,
0.0133037204,
0.0335774273,
0.0000017551,
-0.0396554023,
-0.0344656147,
0.0148406206,
-0.0504338332,
-0.0010130539,
0.0463300645,
-0.0234826654,
0.0035127804,
0.0560034886,
-0.027026996,
-0.0417639054,
0.0421398096,
0.0755988955,
0.0819841027,
0.0704639107,
-0.0222973507,
-0.0279452205,
-0.0178119969,
0.00243265,
0.0414906442,
-0.0557104535,
0.0696331263,
0.0016810406,
-0.0448783189,
0.0209098216,
0.0336152054,
0.0023000687,
-0.0298230052,
0.0091776084,
-0.0304310899,
0.0352055542,
-0.053176187,
-0.0342178345,
0.0173980799,
0.0613859333,
0.0055886661,
-0.0612394996,
-0.0047212634,
0.0206428785,
-0.0080503142,
0.0568055585,
-0.064278841,
0.010822393,
-0.019072365,
0.0334698446,
0.0100708939,
-0.0112537611,
0.0587802827,
0.0334601924,
0.0289617907,
0.0553726852,
-0.0175006371,
-0.0393814929,
-0.0271165594,
-0.03937326,
0.0130490791,
-0.0537052676,
0.0277465563,
0.0294736773,
-0.0074989493,
0.0228246097,
0.0283930432,
0.000044491,
0.0587105751,
-0.0916470587,
-0.053626541,
0.012378348,
-0.011185904,
0.0332199708,
-0.0078583313,
-0.037559893,
-0.0330190435,
-0.0105322516,
0.0003629285,
-0.0089853583,
-0.0187907126,
0.0106295962,
-0.0216959044,
-0.0078984415,
-0.0210608672,
0.0394417159,
-0.0459570885,
-0.0227611326,
0.0021638034,
0.0122326305,
-0.0164735131,
0.0322113633,
-0.0308839101,
-0.0165971313,
-0.0480625406,
0.0527236164,
-0.0021699441,
0.0425586663,
-0.0053258464,
-0.0193825997,
-0.0047935015,
-0.0018978652,
0.0302010607,
0.0233044159,
0.0095249191,
0.0065366081,
0.0251394399,
0.0093493983,
-0.030927578,
-0.0494042709,
-0.0119692786,
-0.0139574325,
-0.0371811576,
-0.0444628634,
-0.0134712812,
-0.0328607857,
0.0118837785,
-0.0219813008,
0.0141613744,
0.0568316728,
-0.0619548634,
0.0314423628,
-0.025144618,
0.019976249,
0.0243435837,
0.0528057404,
-0.0007518761,
0.032015603,
0.0219394788,
0.0571957678,
0.0641708896,
0.0147227542,
-0.0066743027,
-0.0364036523,
0.0596924871,
-0.0097772358,
0.0840993151,
0.0194234531,
-0.013198439,
-0.0124968886,
-0.0754563585,
0.0312102307,
-0.019844735,
-0.0053011221,
0.0635663047,
0.0108421324,
-0.0260750968,
-0.0184122976,
0.0070408941,
0.0178510938,
-0.0403403267,
-0.0068212943,
-0.02381864,
-0.0045537427,
-0.0552439392,
-0.0159534626,
0.0150215635,
0.0286004115,
-0.0283089336,
-0.046339985,
-0.0534618832,
0.024636602,
-0.0022420941,
-0.0159339365,
-0.0005490907,
-0.008663835,
-0.0538193807,
0.0533770956,
0.0484706648,
-0.0267333705,
-0.0161634553,
-0.0555910431,
0.0312310178,
0.0543268099,
0.0358921625,
0.0168750379,
0.0035449208,
-0.0176686384,
0.0342082642,
0.0074086771,
0.0185137093,
-0.0256496798,
-0.0221462045,
-0.015091816,
-0.0046882811,
0.0100312065,
0.027738424,
-0.0606630743,
0.0614659563,
0.0426421538,
-0.0025594812,
-0.0346571468,
-0.071136713,
0.0152474819,
-0.0361310802,
-0.0143515989,
-0.0060633509,
0.0135071874,
0.0443488322,
-0.0057445904,
0.0086246589,
0.022967197,
0.0380854197,
0.003658446,
-0.0583967939,
-0.0004669841,
0.0097913519,
-0.0055726268,
0.0223647729,
-0.0344374664,
-0.0128805544,
0.0211574715,
-0.0261158608,
-0.009170671,
-0.0181900095,
-0.0218721889,
0.0042347601,
-0.0559883229,
-0.0179634113,
-0.0021369942,
0.0272000674,
0.0045449841,
0.0545341,
-0.0243055709,
0.0123456474,
-0.0050984877,
-0.0196885746,
-0.004726639,
-0.0155121153,
-0.0116505818,
-0.018434776,
0.0078383628,
0.0160510503,
0.0320853554,
-0.0174746178,
-0.0037148951,
0.0202563498,
-0.087676838,
0.0075020301,
-0.0283059385,
-0.0022342999,
0.0543806031,
0.0238022693,
0.015983453,
0.0004155199,
-0.044918526,
-0.0058569815,
0.0058344319,
0.0292618647,
0.0008997924,
-0.0002859436,
0.0184864737,
-0.0304335319,
0.0088268062,
-0.041714251,
0.0271926746,
0.0186730288,
-0.0237302966,
-0.0208677296,
-0.0264776461,
-0.0639217123,
-0.0116171381,
-0.0166128483,
-0.0187485181,
-0.0105496943,
0.0036615529,
-0.0247997791,
0.0046545276,
0.0296980292,
0.0175592955,
0.0395812728,
0.0363661312,
-0.0159516446,
-0.0143353846,
-0.0593206286,
-0.0040648566,
-0.0169542152,
-0.1037346646,
0.0152872689,
0.0498291627,
0.0376187339,
0.0045570037,
-0.0352301672,
0.0253832079,
-0.0069295615,
-0.0017943366,
-0.0341998339,
-0.0398504846,
-0.0040424038,
0.0474743769,
-0.0432076603,
-0.0205798969,
0.0884376168,
-0.022461446,
0.0553225689,
-0.0347547531,
-0.0264947992,
-0.0189799648,
-0.0015177893,
-0.037061017,
0.038737528,
0.0449592583,
0.0286932122,
0.0480085015,
-0.0082395868,
0.0481014065,
-0.0492993891,
-0.0263511017,
-0.0221990719,
0.0202201959,
0.0380781032,
-0.03018637,
-0.0476305895,
-0.1175545454,
-0.0329015367,
-0.0375872776,
-0.0021487256,
-0.0031858596,
-0.0633948818,
0.0448378287,
0.0230082404,
0.0159988422,
0.009141013,
-0.0142211048,
0.0407181792,
0.0083227158,
0.0408484302,
-0.0115289139,
0.0609756596,
0.0086234296,
0.0369771607,
0.1108851582,
0.0088196434,
-0.0103589827,
0.0312547721,
-0.0222996622,
-0.0181604121,
-0.0042544627,
-0.0034352813,
-0.0069542732,
0.0279577952,
-0.0529817641,
-0.0157338381,
0.0861958414,
0.0262560546,
0.0122789452,
0.0162709411,
0.0166802183,
-0.00606771,
0.0044267471,
-0.022799287,
-0.0645311996,
-0.0116407908,
-0.0130420793,
0.003230314,
-0.0353038311,
-0.0168722067,
-0.0118322503,
-0.0653454512,
0.0346134305,
-0.0269228164,
0.0051541631,
-0.0535204224,
-0.0876270607,
0.0115251066,
0.0245784391,
0.0231419876,
0.0100358715,
0.0294173546,
-0.0312819295,
-0.0137643786,
-0.0599590726,
-0.0413909778,
0.0488862842,
0.0085825613,
0.0038495737,
0.0308263861,
0.0666694567,
0.0038409857,
-0.0417711623,
-0.0222496744,
0.0012337381,
-0.0457183532,
-0.014690442,
0.0948565081,
-0.0160905123,
0.0176932253,
-0.0547199175,
0.0459160097,
-0.0450961031,
0.0014102708,
-0.0040473873,
0.0519572496,
0.0071382076,
-0.0700566322,
-0.0204755608,
0.024779873,
0.0253944509,
0.0808460712,
0.0088541713,
0.021589268,
0.0205959715,
-0.0161407106,
-0.0257672723,
0.0132336831,
-0.0383036919,
0.0554555468,
-0.0051999423,
-0.0523351505,
-0.0761622638,
-0.0195704661,
-0.0266044009,
0.0012811198,
-0.0255356357,
0.0047036414,
0.0424224213,
-0.0044041146,
-0.0435750373,
0.0098782182,
-0.0066997022,
0.0119589744,
0.003530188,
0.0204042345,
0.0477704816,
-0.0039570946,
0.0062050596,
0.0405150428,
-0.0419902876,
-0.009467518,
-0.0320280716,
-0.0257818364,
0.0124244113,
0.0364116058,
-0.0329922587,
-0.017927032,
0.0349300541,
-0.0157510322,
-0.0361125395,
-0.0322679803,
-0.013497794,
-0.0204651058,
0.0653079003,
0.0179299843,
-0.0300482139,
0.0276984833,
0.0268103313,
0.0175869484,
-0.0765566453,
-0.0091365259,
0.0493589751,
0.0459113158,
0.0253060255,
0.0241923109,
0.0060540149,
-0.029743487,
0.01371032,
-0.0360956565,
-0.0217628181,
0.0084390678,
0.030035736,
0.0485830009,
-0.013499178,
-0.0307873469,
0.0004672246,
-0.0284430683,
-0.0039582341,
-0.0722351819,
-0.0114020221,
-0.0073752115,
0.0431748815,
0.0232216772,
-0.0182021316,
-0.0105940504,
-0.0036176359,
0.0076683373,
0.021055067,
0.0116175199,
0.0009782637,
0.0109576555,
-0.0405450799,
0.0419367403,
-0.0333035104,
-0.0705921352,
-0.0619538948,
-0.0460632555,
-0.0521956868,
-0.0049299849,
0.0042945668,
0.0550283454,
-0.0321489759,
-0.0297915153,
0.0060639,
-0.0158138219,
-0.0045407913,
-0.0180221535,
0.0275132768,
-0.0036926058,
-0.0402640291,
0.0548087582,
0.0814847499,
0.014507235,
0.0272503272,
0.01738685,
-0.1125645787,
-0.0179966111,
-0.0009968514,
-0.0164851639,
0.1010983959,
-0.0091866367,
-0.0121034291,
-0.0605876371,
-0.0417100526,
0.0022596826,
-0.0016819366,
-0.0002546962,
0.0214635301,
-0.0178600624,
0.0730341077,
0.042816665,
-0.0150700891,
-0.0566694364,
0.0033692599,
-0.0252206586,
-0.000253813,
0.0183217004,
-6.380589214e-33,
0.0346663073,
-0.077710852,
-0.0178748947,
-0.0320050716,
0.0385421999,
0.0430082679,
-0.0453103669,
-0.0189813916,
-0.0461274125,
0.0647636726,
0.0347809568,
0.0453707352,
0.0053769317,
0.0138295498,
-0.0383508205,
-0.0041180584,
0.0646207705,
0.0252426006,
-0.0210023317,
0.0343085416,
0.0720036626,
0.0301882438,
0.0261678249,
-0.0797116011,
0.0746173039,
-0.0254029464,
-0.0096994285,
0.0488786548,
-0.014893909,
0.0487405322,
-0.0151551105,
0.0735811815,
0.0466057621,
-0.0223148447,
-0.0074789729,
0.0060790447,
-0.0897886306,
-0.006784528,
0.0157459397,
-0.0528583489,
-0.0132876514,
0.0139255263,
0.0531876907,
0.0091921482,
0.0125342095,
0.006802402,
0.0477640368,
-0.0410207063,
0.0317713134,
-0.0067944173,
0.019911129,
0.0049107163,
0.0211517513,
0.0049733236,
-0.046998281,
0.0607344657,
-0.0193962026,
0.0783185214,
-0.0743554682,
0.0069220597,
-0.0419441201,
0.0374331549,
-0.0063709235,
-0.073539041,
0.0045633628,
0.0364668369,
0.003627148,
0.0166107342,
-0.0614551902,
0.011201554,
-0.0458144844,
0.0362124182,
0.0335147902,
0.0861886293,
0.0446992293,
-0.0557849742,
-0.1329966635,
0.0384124406,
0.0007808071,
0.0105523374,
0.0432269424,
-0.0010538539,
-0.0672216266,
0.0054321443,
-0.0133858584,
0.0455165207,
-0.0472483002,
-0.0279923771,
0.0044023111,
0.0433770455,
-0.0341505371,
0.0373326428,
-0.0105968332,
-0.0443917662,
-0.0004679355,
0.0317898095,
-0.0017852932,
-0.0697341114,
0.0072353492,
0.0308758784,
-0.056999445,
0.065350607,
-0.0004999479,
0.0245600808,
-0.0237058941,
0.0104121817,
0.0427881256,
-0.0416352898,
-0.0565151758,
0.0148379579,
-0.0261511952,
-0.0056621511,
-0.002300567,
0.0029108906,
0.0040370715,
0.0116269533,
-0.0021732994,
0.0167871024,
0.024806926,
0.0415719375,
-0.0374242328,
-0.036156822,
-0.0405991077,
-0.0031815879,
-0.0160676166,
-0.0001318581,
-0.0158940237,
0.0405177958,
0.0000746213,
-0.0918431506,
0.0002163389,
-0.0091982903,
2.568e-7,
0.0397806056,
0.0224148631,
0.0010268554,
-0.000236939,
0.0408458412,
0.0278775599,
0.034740787,
-0.0036611108,
0.0113556171,
-0.0594673418,
-0.015462162,
0.0378385223,
-0.0103261936,
0.0591063611,
-0.0348106548,
-0.0166250654,
-0.0790157244,
-0.0314852297,
-0.0147025026,
-0.0104296422,
0.0305993129,
0.0564014502,
-0.0167820919,
-0.0094324388,
0.0137921814,
-0.0062125465,
0.0397492833,
0.004277694,
-0.061174877,
0.0519834049,
0.0472129099,
0.0216129031,
0.0055791582,
-0.024434261,
-0.0365018174,
-0.0098284548,
0.0032558604,
0.0149058551,
-0.0320965238,
-0.0190327521,
-0.0066583115,
-0.0446572639,
0.0379467644,
-0.0530683063,
0.0661588535,
-0.0015209466,
-0.0553187169,
0.0190159641,
-0.0227008052,
-0.0098333042,
0.0083170375,
-0.0124598043,
-0.0189006161,
0.0154459365,
-0.0124729685,
0.0575778969,
0.0207621139,
-0.0350792333,
-0.0343921334,
0.0038682914,
-0.0415749662,
-0.0859928727,
0.0421638675,
-0.075798206,
-0.0242326986,
-0.0441420749,
0.0397973768,
2.250201081e-34,
0.0069613205,
0.0235484876,
-0.0177499838,
-0.0056247655,
0.0471462272,
0.0174322464,
-0.0086487196,
-0.0408785529,
0.0216095988,
-0.0441458486,
-0.0151020447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00653v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00653v1 | Chain-of-Knowledge: Integrating Knowledge Reasoning into Large Language Models by Learning from Knowledge Graphs | 2024-06-30T10:49:32 | 2024-06-30T10:49:32 | Yifei Zhang, Xintao Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Sirui Xia, Lida Chen, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive proficiency in various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, which involve increasingly complex
reasoning. Knowledge reasoning, a primary type of reasoning, aims at deriving
new knowledge from existing one.While it has been widely studied in the context
of knowledge graphs (KGs), knowledge reasoning in LLMs remains underexplored.
In this paper, we introduce Chain-of-Knowledge, a comprehensive framework for
knowledge reasoning, including methodologies for both dataset construction and
model learning. For dataset construction, we create KnowReason via rule mining
on KGs. For model learning, we observe rule overfitting induced by naive
training. Hence, we enhance CoK with a trial-and-error mechanism that simulates
the human process of internal knowledge exploration. We conduct extensive
experiments with KnowReason. Our results show the effectiveness of CoK in
refining LLMs in not only knowledge reasoning, but also general reasoning
benchmarkms. | Chain-of-Knowledge: Integrating Knowledge Reasoning into Large Language Models by Learning from Knowledge Graphs: Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive proficiency in various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, which involve increasingly complex
reasoning. Knowledge reasoning, a primary type of reasoning, aims at deriving
new knowledge from existing one.While it has been widely studied in the context
of knowledge graphs (KGs), knowledge reasoning in LLMs remains underexplored.
In this paper, we introduce Chain-of-Knowledge, a comprehensive framework for
knowledge reasoning, including methodologies for both dataset construction and
model learning. For dataset construction, we create KnowReason via rule mining
on KGs. For model learning, we observe rule overfitting induced by naive
training. Hence, we enhance CoK with a trial-and-error mechanism that simulates
the human process of internal knowledge exploration. We conduct extensive
experiments with KnowReason. Our results show the effectiveness of CoK in
refining LLMs in not only knowledge reasoning, but also general reasoning
benchmarkms. | [
0.0565347038,
0.003391966,
-0.0108257374,
0.0790083259,
-0.0608493909,
0.0454817712,
-0.0296050031,
0.0248243604,
0.0611436032,
-0.0246422365,
0.0225995854,
0.0232769307,
-0.0059533189,
0.0307318605,
0.0041386997,
-0.0126202526,
0.0129038319,
-0.0426950604,
0.0377073623,
0.0030140621,
-0.0238683205,
0.0254391674,
-0.0191848204,
0.0170376226,
-0.0314427875,
-0.0266072508,
-0.0010244175,
-0.0317055881,
0.0096864523,
-0.0203367472,
0.0043646884,
-0.0071608014,
0.0243155546,
0.0430233106,
0.0000019121,
-0.0530852005,
-0.0048357546,
0.0139984684,
-0.0712402463,
-0.0446769632,
-0.0020749611,
-0.003625456,
0.0443725735,
0.0181713384,
-0.0568633489,
-0.0241330806,
0.0000425917,
0.0622446388,
0.0385782197,
0.0772118643,
-0.0086918697,
-0.0565499924,
-0.0042833174,
-0.004968592,
-0.0041546733,
-0.0388537459,
0.0553835817,
0.0578387044,
0.0056091514,
-0.0422521085,
0.0129075292,
0.0232222918,
0.0157525819,
-0.0165302437,
0.0077825203,
0.0313928872,
0.0064419899,
-0.0148448758,
0.0079598557,
0.0835610107,
-0.0142677333,
-0.0025496949,
-0.0134322513,
-0.0015458559,
-0.0059838546,
0.0436585657,
-0.0341815688,
-0.0073123919,
-0.0357030742,
0.0201866105,
-0.003480877,
-0.0357627198,
0.0390341803,
-0.0070781889,
-0.0472922362,
0.1150309965,
-0.0208781622,
-0.0085904552,
0.0431834161,
0.0000884056,
-0.0214860663,
-0.0249664448,
-0.0082542272,
0.0556001998,
-0.0071570454,
0.0498576649,
0.0262367297,
0.0429933667,
0.0012233629,
-0.0559782162,
-0.0043833316,
0.0015725706,
0.004965106,
0.061975427,
-0.0641012788,
0.0156640727,
0.0088532111,
0.0180150997,
-0.0346524902,
-0.0311460011,
-0.1002203673,
-0.0090484861,
0.0196074843,
0.034482155,
-0.0063438835,
-0.0277761798,
-0.0308032259,
0.0142559707,
0.0005251153,
0.046890188,
0.0383825414,
0.0159613062,
0.056122385,
-0.0343877524,
-0.0701261312,
0.0129062608,
-0.0000391537,
0.0407673381,
-0.0168073867,
0.0210568178,
0.0017458498,
-0.0389092229,
0.0243849605,
-0.0157528836,
-0.0126828682,
0.0642831549,
0.0417320952,
0.0039366358,
-0.0676383302,
-0.0604220629,
-0.0010909463,
-0.0548859686,
0.0155347409,
-0.053638678,
0.0369865745,
0.0261781029,
-0.003718731,
-0.0414404087,
0.0152262114,
-0.0050707445,
-0.0646169484,
0.0649331212,
-0.0315437131,
0.0231496636,
-0.0219108816,
0.0052933092,
-0.0559770986,
0.0493039936,
0.0061079911,
0.0084446855,
0.0280779321,
0.0204595067,
-0.0108110663,
0.0197364278,
0.0001709384,
-0.0201624241,
0.0158150252,
0.013482525,
-0.026928762,
0.0169943515,
0.0153989596,
0.0095621701,
-0.0377632119,
-0.0038025295,
0.0320224762,
0.0165240131,
0.0595831238,
-0.0143059213,
0.0323230028,
0.0070046675,
0.0071207243,
-0.0183343608,
-0.0190361291,
-0.0129953716,
-0.0525189973,
0.0090533048,
-0.0445114598,
0.0045903609,
0.0105621358,
-0.0280283038,
-0.0379696116,
0.0113571947,
-0.00574657,
0.0284362063,
0.077660948,
0.0220898911,
-0.0027572331,
0.0098785991,
0.062333636,
-0.0183509141,
-0.0254135933,
-0.032454282,
0.0339649916,
0.0736514404,
0.0473928265,
-0.0373807251,
-0.0158546567,
0.0016758472,
-0.0004849519,
0.0007633325,
0.0150527311,
-0.0563375577,
0.0047958093,
-0.0515293144,
-0.0500237867,
0.0092191761,
-0.0078780102,
-0.0229483079,
0.0150129097,
-0.0152650559,
0.0177559983,
-0.0684468448,
-0.0554179586,
0.0187197272,
-0.0301985759,
-0.0098823616,
0.005816435,
0.0129875317,
0.034799587,
0.0098010721,
0.023886038,
0.0179089494,
0.0199476574,
-0.0104723265,
-0.0509027988,
0.0237481147,
-0.0001651396,
-0.0984480754,
0.0625810251,
-0.0329112783,
-0.0326820537,
-0.0399325378,
-0.0483090095,
-0.0270602833,
0.0238747895,
0.0076511786,
0.0910129398,
-0.0166244265,
0.0042956672,
0.0222964864,
-0.0448181145,
-0.0095859021,
0.1160690263,
0.0022040599,
-0.0233752616,
-0.0056466334,
-0.0331301503,
0.0054277126,
0.0452636145,
0.0131826764,
-0.005108559,
-0.0090737352,
-0.0129138147,
0.0064898301,
-0.02152385,
-0.0838447735,
-0.0088267457,
-0.0447082706,
0.0036642458,
0.036299713,
0.0058055012,
-0.0027892741,
-0.0229052585,
0.0112337526,
-0.0118586179,
-0.0051167165,
0.035191182,
0.0030676923,
0.0067049316,
0.0412280932,
0.0055398545,
-0.0290930159,
0.0006024258,
-0.0102641713,
-0.0378609188,
0.0860586911,
0.0055658524,
0.0246696901,
-0.0135950195,
0.0467872284,
-0.0342901871,
0.0107538057,
-0.0274354853,
0.013921625,
0.0042649205,
-0.0138384644,
-0.015642358,
0.027679041,
-0.0211828928,
0.0205802154,
0.0560762957,
-0.031180935,
-0.0296666343,
0.0181341954,
-0.0396553129,
-0.0008952118,
-0.0405520238,
0.0058098016,
-0.0220644604,
0.0286649894,
-0.0004988135,
-0.0289456155,
-0.0461771637,
0.0129927862,
-0.0055578984,
0.0028263347,
-0.0578750707,
-0.0044450415,
0.0190890282,
0.032564003,
-0.0366895944,
-0.0157070626,
0.0718040243,
-0.0129197808,
0.0364868827,
-0.0352922678,
0.0225415342,
-0.0313699245,
0.095432885,
-0.0006445777,
0.0058252532,
0.0134379556,
0.0101254899,
-0.0024443457,
-0.0196432024,
0.0560014062,
-0.0196955614,
0.0402469672,
-0.0645132139,
0.0206771996,
0.0362946019,
-0.0128445495,
-0.0607308708,
0.0135975741,
-0.0666686967,
0.0024491225,
-0.0148038575,
-0.0257464629,
0.0175426528,
-0.0174675658,
0.0119878426,
-0.0020763886,
0.0203271881,
-0.0317121409,
-0.012231634,
0.0244499482,
0.0251576081,
-0.01141831,
0.0250543021,
0.0061068968,
0.0550315045,
0.0344624482,
0.021141693,
-0.0312524587,
-0.0432239585,
0.0235274341,
-0.0119927991,
-0.0130172661,
-0.0064914678,
0.0088237636,
-0.0160704963,
-0.080304645,
0.0295456648,
0.109663941,
0.0320606418,
-0.0242350399,
0.0151571147,
-0.012669351,
0.0060793762,
0.0465997346,
0.0171715934,
-0.0604292192,
-0.0408722535,
0.0140306642,
-0.0179120209,
-0.0131041156,
-0.0821177885,
-0.0029276263,
-0.1073404551,
0.0221079346,
0.0023964276,
-0.0054173656,
-0.0543098673,
-0.0487749949,
0.0058776517,
0.0034674797,
-0.0387548357,
0.0208054632,
-0.0145139229,
-0.0053656762,
0.026861757,
-0.0209787562,
-0.0686868131,
0.045576565,
-0.0292303693,
0.0761061385,
0.0161287673,
0.0658989921,
0.0368947536,
-0.0098204529,
-0.0234110169,
0.0213044249,
0.0139795849,
-0.0160604045,
0.0446507148,
0.0286837015,
-0.0055989595,
-0.0069597503,
0.0359925032,
-0.0684218407,
-0.0182368942,
0.039056439,
0.1001190096,
-0.0125375101,
-0.0564808398,
0.0316461362,
-0.017072361,
-0.0083652092,
0.0580879673,
0.0175775141,
0.0579815321,
0.0047531882,
-0.0418504365,
-0.0329111554,
-0.0085750539,
-0.0271419398,
0.0363275595,
0.0141885411,
0.026551025,
-0.0693399906,
0.0149085941,
0.0775568187,
0.0513394736,
0.0178826265,
0.033658538,
0.048420947,
0.0024884203,
-0.037577711,
0.0405190103,
-0.0457863696,
0.0087257726,
0.0083818939,
-0.0146686062,
0.0075774342,
-0.0410250165,
-0.0471080206,
0.0160008688,
-0.0227777921,
-0.085349746,
-0.0249078665,
0.0169960838,
0.0236705169,
0.0738438293,
-0.0269845482,
-0.0090527115,
0.0382322744,
-0.0105882576,
-0.0761229917,
-0.0475757793,
0.0390724316,
-0.0317969359,
0.0245390497,
0.0463746712,
-0.0331239291,
-0.0129593462,
0.0301512349,
0.0320096239,
-0.0377428345,
-0.0195147004,
0.043054156,
0.0470901392,
0.0149589302,
0.0054519884,
-0.0509607084,
-0.0672353357,
0.0094608488,
-0.0277649052,
-0.0319068059,
-0.0447370633,
0.0297561567,
0.0315460227,
-0.0050742496,
-0.0060914005,
-0.0581471808,
0.0245405491,
-0.0091969175,
0.0262437481,
-0.0363177545,
0.0556422696,
0.0058091795,
0.0588718764,
-0.0396254659,
0.0124979364,
0.0213522967,
-0.0026392038,
-0.001147664,
-0.0306950547,
0.0508824252,
0.0286480542,
-0.0300020017,
-0.0653126165,
-0.0205802508,
-0.0485011339,
-0.0474794917,
0.0285784379,
-0.00456418,
0.0593570843,
-0.0514129139,
0.0489634052,
-0.0585615821,
-0.0072098793,
0.0279062819,
0.0447428375,
-0.0318120345,
-0.0244039707,
0.0244443249,
0.029176509,
-0.0444491841,
0.0091614267,
0.0829576626,
0.0106932642,
0.0637062863,
-0.0214448106,
-0.0743221417,
-0.0282792561,
-0.0285830665,
0.0374462791,
0.0230769422,
-0.018251637,
0.0447336063,
-0.0540762767,
-0.1053875908,
-0.0477516726,
-0.0246050712,
-0.0104391072,
0.0266854987,
0.0335274562,
0.0651344135,
0.0333830565,
-0.0176387951,
-0.0518724993,
-0.0199521817,
-0.0007970594,
-0.0074409763,
0.0028288297,
-6.160508386e-33,
0.0192422923,
-0.0249471385,
0.032885801,
0.0274695531,
0.0007215152,
-0.0144537007,
-0.0411409326,
-0.0258724764,
-0.0257294755,
0.0501777343,
-0.0160763357,
0.0154496385,
0.0035858504,
0.0059345579,
0.0010538052,
-0.0085282614,
0.0193000361,
0.0161515456,
0.0215788744,
0.0050089988,
0.0605640858,
0.0288301334,
0.0428575911,
-0.0612332188,
-0.0011836427,
0.0506492592,
0.0270180851,
0.061340712,
-0.0396173522,
0.0406353995,
-0.0125503428,
0.0373810865,
0.0152081391,
-0.0284422822,
0.0047451016,
-0.0272994861,
-0.1078143269,
-0.0297886096,
0.0516921654,
-0.0000106632,
-0.0050759455,
-0.0105162347,
0.033716768,
0.0107361479,
0.0586452335,
-0.0271407124,
0.0330728292,
-0.0468688831,
-0.0244549513,
-0.0211896803,
-0.030775629,
0.0320067592,
-0.024033349,
-0.0355329998,
0.0290917028,
-0.0144821508,
0.0009508632,
-0.0515325144,
-0.0490897,
0.0341281965,
-0.0027236324,
0.0089008156,
0.0418931879,
-0.0048898924,
0.0113168387,
0.0657443106,
-0.0381820314,
-0.0115387328,
-0.0349148139,
0.0420667343,
-0.0051264367,
0.0917610228,
-0.0130060064,
0.0087830657,
0.0055686096,
-0.0408992209,
-0.087327905,
0.0103447493,
0.0021182899,
0.0571690202,
0.0122182034,
-0.0088436902,
-0.0343612731,
-0.0259701572,
-0.0490408354,
0.0180683974,
-0.0331722796,
-0.0018535536,
-0.0013659074,
-0.0036035036,
-0.0089052264,
-0.0464022979,
-0.023229219,
-0.0454851277,
0.0032148664,
0.0541784354,
0.0066488869,
-0.0086248862,
-0.0135869533,
0.0252620466,
-0.0501304753,
-0.0270415563,
-0.0068490547,
-0.0321721844,
0.0174574945,
-0.0006834361,
0.0638199747,
0.0136483647,
-0.0193933379,
-0.0176371317,
-0.0742928386,
-0.0039604623,
0.0113069769,
-0.0126496395,
0.0168419108,
0.0666335002,
-0.0166581497,
-0.000924528,
0.0150178159,
0.0039297286,
-0.0104427524,
0.0328359194,
0.0184253044,
-0.0029573445,
-0.0127319377,
-0.047742106,
-0.0280633047,
-0.0204294976,
0.0728674531,
-0.0451267026,
-0.0138582811,
0.0201099887,
2.756e-7,
0.0311055724,
0.0372296795,
-0.0226926859,
0.0383357666,
0.0109077236,
0.0417173654,
-0.0250839833,
-0.0381147377,
0.0178614464,
-0.0571128279,
0.0237389132,
0.048932936,
0.0197436251,
0.061510928,
-0.0746352896,
-0.0518880524,
0.0100247348,
-0.0628446192,
-0.0366012678,
-0.0334004276,
0.034039773,
0.0435647294,
0.0598338917,
-0.0285457876,
0.0057569109,
-0.0750008225,
0.0167683922,
0.0175599921,
0.0191947035,
-0.0056416988,
0.0792406499,
0.0013248512,
0.0258476418,
0.092410855,
0.0051451288,
0.0257523321,
-0.0152304908,
0.0327407606,
0.0024271614,
0.0261833556,
-0.0121058952,
-0.0393313058,
0.0198783949,
-0.0444214307,
0.1000717133,
-0.0587090328,
-0.0205484536,
-0.0102352733,
0.0272537638,
-0.0582517087,
-0.0360423438,
0.0032763688,
0.0131156296,
0.0177014899,
0.0135920933,
-0.0224513281,
0.0216493141,
-0.0786942914,
-0.0088150995,
0.0251110233,
-0.0236306544,
-0.0067104297,
0.0036911205,
-0.0086279139,
0.0122919995,
-0.035249915,
0.0496611446,
2.337558449e-34,
0.0101276608,
0.0084450981,
-0.0205943491,
0.0030358036,
0.077499263,
-0.0381115787,
-0.0271548927,
0.0132519742,
0.0169854295,
-0.1033689082,
0.0008113773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00648v1 | LegalTurk Optimized BERT for Multi-Label Text Classification and NER | 2024-06-30T10:19:54 | 2024-06-30T10:19:54 | Farnaz Zeidi, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali, Çiğdem Erol | cs.CL | cs.CL | The introduction of the Transformer neural network, along with techniques
like self-supervised pre-training and transfer learning, has paved the way for
advanced models like BERT. Despite BERT's impressive performance, opportunities
for further enhancement exist. To our knowledge, most efforts are focusing on
improving BERT's performance in English and in general domains, with no study
specifically addressing the legal Turkish domain. Our study is primarily
dedicated to enhancing the BERT model within the legal Turkish domain through
modifications in the pre-training phase. In this work, we introduce our
innovative modified pre-training approach by combining diverse masking
strategies. In the fine-tuning task, we focus on two essential downstream tasks
in the legal domain: name entity recognition and multi-label text
classification. To evaluate our modified pre-training approach, we fine-tuned
all customized models alongside the original BERT models to compare their
performance. Our modified approach demonstrated significant improvements in
both NER and multi-label text classification tasks compared to the original
BERT model. Finally, to showcase the impact of our proposed models, we trained
our best models with different corpus sizes and compared them with BERTurk
models. The experimental results demonstrate that our innovative approach,
despite being pre-trained on a smaller corpus, competes with BERTurk. | LegalTurk Optimized BERT for Multi-Label Text Classification and NER: The introduction of the Transformer neural network, along with techniques
like self-supervised pre-training and transfer learning, has paved the way for
advanced models like BERT. Despite BERT's impressive performance, opportunities
for further enhancement exist. To our knowledge, most efforts are focusing on
improving BERT's performance in English and in general domains, with no study
specifically addressing the legal Turkish domain. Our study is primarily
dedicated to enhancing the BERT model within the legal Turkish domain through
modifications in the pre-training phase. In this work, we introduce our
innovative modified pre-training approach by combining diverse masking
strategies. In the fine-tuning task, we focus on two essential downstream tasks
in the legal domain: name entity recognition and multi-label text
classification. To evaluate our modified pre-training approach, we fine-tuned
all customized models alongside the original BERT models to compare their
performance. Our modified approach demonstrated significant improvements in
both NER and multi-label text classification tasks compared to the original
BERT model. Finally, to showcase the impact of our proposed models, we trained
our best models with different corpus sizes and compared them with BERTurk
models. The experimental results demonstrate that our innovative approach,
despite being pre-trained on a smaller corpus, competes with BERTurk. | [
0.0473652147,
0.0395109057,
0.0015190751,
0.0057000942,
-0.0158268958,
0.025137376,
0.0625353307,
0.0467011556,
0.0013448292,
-0.0712953806,
-0.0370360687,
-0.0035407303,
-0.0391482823,
-0.029880736,
0.0176364593,
-0.0323630273,
0.0310707018,
0.0013183708,
0.038989,
-0.001018337,
-0.0190659352,
0.0039137858,
-0.0041128616,
0.0106740408,
-0.042092856,
0.0256221592,
0.0152128404,
0.0214299764,
0.0253918804,
-0.0174440872,
0.0624986626,
0.0617495142,
-0.0331427008,
0.0251815598,
0.0000019042,
-0.0695207417,
-0.0193504617,
0.0131960819,
0.0118706729,
0.0076997178,
0.0263958815,
-0.0232210532,
-0.0391047895,
0.0005020139,
-0.0149671584,
0.0132455397,
-0.0016876198,
0.0903925523,
0.0538887717,
0.085860543,
-0.0177747551,
-0.0800574198,
0.0521653406,
-0.0079126377,
-0.019652538,
-0.0523984581,
0.0331168473,
-0.0799808875,
-0.0413716957,
-0.0187621266,
0.02128678,
0.0219052862,
-0.001053536,
-0.0119247073,
-0.0002867796,
0.0271657333,
-0.0598252118,
-0.0437640361,
0.0311314352,
0.0372614861,
-0.0413754657,
-0.0185035188,
0.0303907041,
0.019342009,
0.0358723104,
-0.0027553372,
-0.0006496641,
0.0379093848,
-0.0271893106,
0.0093887877,
-0.0097739985,
0.0051568146,
0.0049254633,
0.0257596411,
-0.0377327949,
0.0304499585,
0.0527559333,
-0.0271403715,
0.0158052072,
-0.0007632626,
-0.0049852892,
-0.0423020348,
0.0853919685,
0.0530120209,
0.0235106032,
0.0093902899,
-0.0552557781,
-0.0828198791,
0.01155267,
-0.0820808932,
-0.0055453978,
0.0162256751,
-0.0278024916,
0.0227580536,
-0.1427363604,
0.0068398197,
-0.0001325662,
0.0502367169,
0.0156221865,
-0.0641329139,
-0.0450787805,
-0.0082360152,
-0.0959316641,
0.0670614094,
-0.0371800028,
0.0351326503,
-0.0313958675,
-0.0031335035,
0.0057615447,
-0.0012422451,
0.0246105753,
-0.0174844135,
-0.0392570347,
-0.0201990642,
-0.0159041155,
-0.0173348729,
-0.0286322869,
0.0038200025,
-0.0210351627,
-0.0130786719,
0.021109594,
-0.0116510587,
0.0105176382,
-0.0443627611,
0.0434188507,
0.0430140123,
-0.041979298,
-0.0756120905,
-0.0690397024,
0.0403960794,
-0.0251915138,
-0.0135177718,
0.0351789147,
-0.0081713153,
-0.0001613891,
-0.0249027889,
-0.011499241,
-0.0403507315,
0.0027186999,
0.029413037,
-0.0231520757,
0.0955232084,
0.0092539843,
-0.0127734486,
0.0451025441,
0.0240322184,
0.0298655387,
0.0281491019,
0.0339930542,
0.004363595,
0.0278710369,
-0.0118760271,
0.0177222248,
0.0530617423,
0.0351198688,
-0.0156001681,
-0.0198518746,
-0.0199274179,
-0.0031562401,
0.0089769028,
0.0133400848,
0.0210766122,
-0.0083641643,
-0.0330330767,
0.0415442549,
0.0178768318,
0.0174009185,
0.0562803186,
-0.0123037985,
-0.0134532303,
0.0219613519,
-0.0216038954,
-0.0113032423,
-0.0022902023,
-0.0308018904,
0.0114218947,
-0.0486127511,
0.0446035191,
-0.0235420838,
-0.0061694947,
0.0214745086,
-0.0162050109,
0.008226933,
-0.0459167324,
0.0809715688,
0.0426128469,
-0.0726648942,
0.1091479212,
0.0115855206,
-0.0306731071,
-0.0033743787,
-0.0661993101,
-0.0197459981,
-0.005396626,
0.0207808726,
-0.0700621083,
-0.0381439365,
-0.0338353328,
-0.0382163934,
0.0506602041,
0.0248600096,
-0.0000444237,
0.0349947512,
-0.038776096,
-0.0088565946,
0.0017544061,
0.0305594783,
0.0436273962,
-0.0055671684,
0.0492814071,
0.0421509743,
-0.0414883904,
0.0337141193,
0.0469288751,
-0.0205996167,
-0.04134335,
0.0360791795,
0.017501872,
0.0080999378,
0.0241942108,
-0.0100148227,
-0.02953518,
0.004619245,
-0.0289240647,
0.0032512303,
-0.0352088511,
-0.004967757,
-0.0675343871,
0.0415216573,
-0.0151001802,
-0.0360489078,
0.0710635707,
-0.0272649731,
-0.0339698046,
-0.0352200121,
0.0315911025,
0.0405109525,
-0.0353946164,
0.0274757072,
0.0007022793,
0.0088738138,
-0.0355797075,
0.0305185895,
0.0321147218,
-0.0246949717,
-0.0084478091,
0.0059936494,
0.0538534895,
0.0296093076,
-0.035750512,
-0.0082206335,
-0.0487861112,
-0.013074372,
0.0074131377,
0.0210630279,
-0.0415607542,
-0.0583270192,
-0.0830689669,
0.0014208355,
-0.0226993766,
0.0252424199,
-0.0070076794,
-0.0149772083,
-0.0170409679,
-0.0326253846,
-0.0165672023,
-0.0533693135,
-0.0466033742,
-0.0137207909,
0.0414451696,
-0.027699884,
-0.0308417585,
0.0077414,
-0.0197535027,
-0.038876351,
0.0377598368,
0.0020376104,
-0.0747528374,
-0.0184251443,
0.0003009119,
-0.0050090202,
0.013453491,
-0.0041856943,
-0.0204156041,
-0.0133295013,
0.0303475801,
0.0386258774,
0.0446704514,
0.0315844603,
-0.0128040882,
-0.025278464,
0.0198441073,
-0.0285489578,
0.0231453031,
0.0001279125,
0.0159018878,
-0.0300923958,
-0.009188395,
0.0452332161,
0.0613239072,
-0.060417559,
-0.0213948395,
-0.0438395403,
-0.045195438,
-0.0161992703,
-0.0195246954,
-0.038192533,
0.0035115853,
-0.0423496068,
-0.0038589078,
0.0167338345,
-0.0073342388,
0.0342772789,
-0.0312216207,
0.0155685013,
-0.0547512062,
0.0086332439,
-0.0255413912,
0.0389324203,
0.013942522,
0.025207812,
0.0396556519,
-0.0643195659,
-0.0080959927,
0.0058586057,
0.0171846449,
-0.0282905176,
0.036743436,
-0.0014166802,
0.017599564,
-0.0323664695,
-0.0389629118,
-0.0324634947,
-0.0638351291,
0.0323452055,
0.0551188439,
0.0099558635,
0.0149130095,
-0.0624057986,
0.0181623641,
-0.014734623,
0.0609819666,
-0.002422078,
-0.0200224742,
-0.0140448976,
0.0856966823,
-0.0066035897,
-0.0403356887,
0.0018097503,
0.0022907532,
-0.0292585399,
0.0224475786,
-0.0029902656,
-0.0160751138,
0.0087192245,
0.0027128665,
0.0249964725,
-0.0871426687,
-0.0199407972,
-0.0132589955,
0.0184759479,
-0.0231741071,
0.0079345377,
0.0901161656,
0.0016690125,
0.0079514068,
-0.02599103,
0.0102047529,
0.0110275615,
0.0163327418,
0.0502796657,
-0.0322197191,
-0.003525662,
0.0132194776,
-0.0060742847,
0.000462492,
-0.0236464944,
0.0308096521,
-0.0828650296,
0.0048995949,
-0.0244100913,
-0.0556891821,
0.005896735,
-0.0513430499,
-0.012925094,
-0.0082540289,
0.0083884299,
-0.0481283888,
0.003441972,
-0.0285835788,
0.0342653878,
-0.0139010046,
-0.0337821506,
-0.0062252553,
-0.034543138,
0.028444726,
0.0180745106,
0.0609460846,
-0.0694969445,
-0.0325639136,
0.0520841107,
-0.006229925,
-0.0146654909,
0.0134661701,
0.0694117546,
-0.0215118434,
-0.023370957,
-0.0459378175,
-0.0220906567,
0.0027905109,
-0.0549462326,
-0.0067418674,
0.0110954614,
0.0181699395,
-0.009047891,
-0.0009573419,
-0.0146847302,
-0.0082322657,
0.0535340682,
-0.0145075126,
-0.0434585102,
-0.009573983,
-0.0053256997,
-0.0006314112,
-0.0644770488,
0.0133754425,
0.0254773665,
-0.0578891337,
-0.0389515981,
-0.0515372604,
-0.0253017228,
0.0115135107,
0.0573413298,
0.0036845622,
-0.0107504027,
0.0249490868,
-0.0092337383,
-0.0211855546,
0.0437752381,
-0.0078900578,
-0.0071126125,
-0.040829163,
-0.0072322008,
0.0402852669,
-0.0020313626,
-0.0332913399,
-0.042497009,
0.014159278,
-0.0216147806,
0.0299264118,
0.0411545746,
0.0135405781,
0.0061842543,
-0.0224921778,
-0.0514068976,
0.083899565,
0.036884822,
-0.018193176,
-0.0305295177,
0.0539667532,
-0.0149783082,
-0.0407253169,
-0.0028074859,
-0.0027686087,
0.0550970174,
0.0380932279,
-0.0111780576,
0.0062303678,
-0.0157836955,
-0.01090826,
0.0303727183,
0.0592544675,
-0.0044776131,
0.0189360324,
-0.0423137359,
0.0301555041,
0.0168640222,
0.015216128,
0.0042434591,
-0.0062503666,
0.0411824472,
-0.0109019,
-0.0369031839,
0.082823813,
-0.0020953871,
0.0037216248,
-0.0702053681,
-0.0140904933,
-0.0021463155,
0.0460516624,
-0.0135077769,
-0.0227301456,
-0.0062564504,
0.0166368391,
0.0529192202,
0.0283663068,
-0.0433563627,
0.0345240422,
0.0130409533,
0.0071692793,
0.0026984131,
0.0376502797,
-0.0210391171,
0.0429164097,
-0.0517366305,
0.0339734666,
0.0314495713,
-0.0058813682,
0.0308774896,
-0.0189137142,
-0.0244468041,
0.0289572328,
0.0034633446,
-0.0024329918,
-0.0009440522,
0.0080748638,
-0.0217148196,
-0.0069515975,
-0.0033788939,
0.0332683362,
0.0211003367,
0.0413217656,
0.0137249585,
-0.00281336,
-0.0408447795,
-0.0004193787,
0.055125244,
-0.0043986193,
-0.0326790139,
-0.0256963167,
-0.0190356541,
-0.0224003065,
0.0252314135,
-0.035023015,
-0.0051107989,
0.0111111449,
0.0320068896,
0.0349850208,
0.0374809168,
-0.0344734713,
-0.0166439302,
0.0004969868,
0.0563284419,
0.0048129754,
0.0044878768,
-5.853351345e-33,
-0.0319192708,
-0.0004569231,
0.000416205,
-0.0133026149,
-0.0020604343,
-0.0386025459,
-0.0059993132,
-0.0312678553,
-0.006610347,
0.0207521245,
-0.0307674445,
0.0201393161,
0.0269754399,
0.0269899461,
-0.0161568262,
-0.0544955097,
0.0516142957,
0.0197852477,
-0.0162457526,
0.0010539501,
-0.0019702639,
0.0862303898,
0.0799810514,
-0.0700255036,
-0.0061127995,
0.0448544733,
-0.0193338487,
-0.0278999265,
0.0078133307,
0.0668655559,
0.0066345418,
0.0132445199,
0.030922601,
-0.0771822333,
0.0087581873,
0.0495154299,
-0.1205747128,
0.0078128297,
-0.0473780073,
0.0392745808,
0.021815883,
-0.0298505984,
0.0453426279,
0.0053958171,
0.007492702,
0.0210519973,
0.0525133424,
-0.0264847074,
-0.0226801764,
-0.0888505876,
-0.0842102319,
0.0464050397,
0.0027700209,
0.0050746561,
0.0495425016,
0.0305304397,
0.0183142405,
0.0239024274,
-0.0950535834,
-0.043402914,
0.0098005133,
-0.0227019023,
0.0194889959,
-0.0035874192,
-0.0297622439,
0.0171594396,
-0.0026458942,
0.0422000289,
-0.0165754687,
-0.0552208237,
0.0501253344,
0.0740509331,
0.0428057984,
0.0175881125,
0.0193266589,
-0.0571550615,
-0.104320012,
0.0573319197,
-0.0093275253,
0.0046538967,
0.0056392075,
-0.0219182651,
-0.0172495358,
-0.0006483327,
-0.0022340112,
-0.027539786,
-0.0104645593,
0.0366825499,
0.0178193133,
0.0120653836,
-0.020618571,
0.0197819136,
-0.0012746421,
-0.0322101489,
-0.0147844683,
-0.0270683635,
0.0064600059,
0.0191120077,
-0.023947794,
0.0290254317,
-0.0416066088,
-0.0619859323,
0.0309784021,
0.0087820496,
0.0279310048,
-0.0239850916,
0.080084525,
-0.0039031657,
-0.09612187,
0.0055665071,
-0.0051061721,
0.0334783532,
0.0524401665,
0.0690166801,
-0.0123464083,
0.0102962861,
0.0223029051,
0.0217883158,
0.0619349703,
-0.0359433666,
-0.0047488064,
0.027445022,
0.0468436405,
-0.0055834544,
0.0136481561,
0.0086418837,
-0.0044408888,
0.0524170138,
0.0562873669,
-0.04484988,
-0.009655457,
0.0004556723,
2.646e-7,
0.0617427006,
0.052324716,
-0.0019224986,
-0.0567046739,
-0.0109940618,
0.0463314019,
0.0196884871,
0.0644566417,
-0.0020324651,
0.027673671,
-0.0108126029,
-0.0400174521,
0.0419677719,
0.0338430107,
-0.0530931242,
-0.0925638527,
-0.0530014932,
0.0094904443,
-0.049823679,
0.0697197765,
0.0486581773,
0.0902600586,
0.0165508799,
-0.0340213068,
0.0013335707,
-0.0194940623,
0.0747040063,
-0.0316275209,
0.0053376439,
0.0394029021,
0.052699063,
0.0095090121,
0.0045700083,
0.0483752191,
-0.0385972857,
0.0506492965,
0.0201496035,
0.1059628129,
-0.0097228074,
0.0223941263,
0.0303998459,
-0.0218934994,
-0.0011338713,
-0.0560000055,
0.0833288357,
-0.0402785614,
-0.0204885229,
0.0369098857,
-0.0474468842,
-0.016189767,
0.0336898677,
-0.0145724285,
-0.0238568038,
0.0130892675,
0.0401756093,
0.0043145888,
-0.0214734189,
-0.107983619,
0.0171812624,
0.0291667823,
-0.007998311,
0.0159214791,
-0.0358209498,
-0.0344635732,
0.0548364967,
-0.0618929192,
0.0346441306,
2.145999247e-34,
-0.0240661521,
-0.0099615408,
-0.0124078449,
0.0259910878,
0.0094751595,
0.0072188796,
-0.0060450062,
-0.0046408055,
-0.0059450655,
-0.0555204637,
0.0229143202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00638v1 | A Collocation-based Method for Addressing Challenges in Word-level Metric Differential Privacy | 2024-06-30T09:37:34 | 2024-06-30T09:37:34 | Stephen Meisenbacher, Maulik Chevli, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Applications of Differential Privacy (DP) in NLP must distinguish between the
syntactic level on which a proposed mechanism operates, often taking the form
of $\textit{word-level}$ or $\textit{document-level}$ privatization. Recently,
several word-level $\textit{Metric}$ Differential Privacy approaches have been
proposed, which rely on this generalized DP notion for operating in word
embedding spaces. These approaches, however, often fail to produce semantically
coherent textual outputs, and their application at the sentence- or
document-level is only possible by a basic composition of word perturbations.
In this work, we strive to address these challenges by operating
$\textit{between}$ the word and sentence levels, namely with
$\textit{collocations}$. By perturbing n-grams rather than single words, we
devise a method where composed privatized outputs have higher semantic
coherence and variable length. This is accomplished by constructing an
embedding model based on frequently occurring word groups, in which unigram
words co-exist with bi- and trigram collocations. We evaluate our method in
utility and privacy tests, which make a clear case for tokenization strategies
beyond the word level. | A Collocation-based Method for Addressing Challenges in Word-level Metric Differential Privacy: Applications of Differential Privacy (DP) in NLP must distinguish between the
syntactic level on which a proposed mechanism operates, often taking the form
of $\textit{word-level}$ or $\textit{document-level}$ privatization. Recently,
several word-level $\textit{Metric}$ Differential Privacy approaches have been
proposed, which rely on this generalized DP notion for operating in word
embedding spaces. These approaches, however, often fail to produce semantically
coherent textual outputs, and their application at the sentence- or
document-level is only possible by a basic composition of word perturbations.
In this work, we strive to address these challenges by operating
$\textit{between}$ the word and sentence levels, namely with
$\textit{collocations}$. By perturbing n-grams rather than single words, we
devise a method where composed privatized outputs have higher semantic
coherence and variable length. This is accomplished by constructing an
embedding model based on frequently occurring word groups, in which unigram
words co-exist with bi- and trigram collocations. We evaluate our method in
utility and privacy tests, which make a clear case for tokenization strategies
beyond the word level. | [
0.0202379674,
0.0891362876,
-0.0346277319,
0.0467499383,
-0.073596783,
-0.0305052567,
0.0717977956,
0.005985972,
0.0449034013,
0.0140613932,
-0.0112826265,
-0.0391612947,
-0.0113289952,
0.0088734142,
0.0332202651,
0.0055631236,
0.071192652,
-0.0170019846,
-0.01473069,
-0.0282876454,
-0.0229381807,
-0.0292819403,
0.0071374271,
0.0300296191,
-0.0271167681,
-0.0033384445,
-0.0168934371,
-0.0182479266,
-0.0206567608,
-0.0331719927,
-0.0083860112,
0.0584936589,
0.019004181,
0.0583931841,
0.0000019826,
-0.0276396144,
-0.0405035391,
0.0405954793,
0.0020043056,
-0.0277487095,
0.0131531479,
-0.0224705748,
0.0606189631,
-0.0387797467,
-0.0263202284,
0.0091794115,
0.0375514515,
0.0273910835,
0.0445880517,
0.0698743761,
-0.006832609,
-0.010894089,
-0.0124146082,
-0.0333383456,
-0.0110736201,
-0.0083543165,
0.0046583782,
-0.0435150266,
-0.0338061862,
0.0064989286,
-0.0295487754,
0.0325469598,
-0.0058006416,
0.0261512771,
0.0471548066,
0.0114771109,
-0.0262504052,
-0.050136108,
-0.0018938913,
0.011691724,
0.0152484896,
0.0046744514,
0.0401000828,
0.0219665561,
0.0578676127,
0.0065556383,
0.0013938384,
-0.0073044705,
-0.0057780193,
0.0061298977,
0.0296393167,
0.0162609816,
0.0186872259,
0.0036582714,
-0.0064820941,
0.0670546517,
0.0137542896,
-0.0017206431,
-0.0267970469,
-0.0093584219,
-0.0082693836,
-0.0347267427,
0.0622341745,
-0.0309743211,
0.0366909578,
0.0198168457,
-0.0810253322,
-0.0834418014,
0.0158778578,
-0.0341349058,
0.0034671,
-0.0132420333,
0.0251546763,
0.0118732173,
-0.0032928523,
0.0538252294,
0.0091294553,
0.0228174124,
0.0132522145,
0.0343871824,
-0.004885023,
-0.0295364019,
0.0163436588,
0.078258045,
-0.0691614524,
-0.0418648385,
-0.0026959064,
0.0409957431,
-0.0403694697,
0.0134980176,
-0.0082538938,
0.0295169875,
-0.0384064429,
0.0031553835,
0.0069577363,
-0.0988745391,
-0.0371174663,
-0.0133639956,
0.0151125854,
-0.0146441432,
-0.0233709477,
-0.0313470811,
-0.0052001188,
0.0178096592,
-0.0454349704,
0.0861152485,
0.0093097771,
-0.0449278764,
0.0401670747,
-0.0987314731,
-0.0394920669,
0.0194726959,
0.0270778723,
-0.066506885,
0.0149394516,
-0.0399380662,
-0.0050327186,
-0.0699329674,
0.0096696531,
0.0158221088,
-0.0510807224,
0.0583190285,
-0.0084957294,
-0.0336672291,
-0.0117866239,
0.0283677019,
0.0143857002,
0.0440069102,
0.0233426429,
0.0396397784,
0.0923882797,
-0.010223628,
0.0128602777,
-0.0322800949,
0.0323191918,
0.0255685393,
-0.0298975445,
0.0268909596,
0.0109624658,
-0.0298513453,
0.0019517542,
0.0541525036,
-0.0011905589,
-0.0698969662,
0.0652281269,
0.1250368357,
0.0278011411,
-0.0245404169,
-0.0589243174,
0.0186790451,
-0.0614620857,
0.0622057244,
-0.0333729573,
-0.0482546203,
-0.0092045749,
-0.0261742435,
0.0438816771,
0.0025530977,
0.0183858052,
-0.0270832218,
0.0111577669,
-0.0247521214,
0.0516399033,
-0.0502585508,
-0.0402775817,
0.0241010468,
0.0426752493,
0.0316189863,
0.0123704458,
-0.0294006467,
0.0394126102,
-0.0017394962,
0.0239544567,
0.0764949992,
0.0655324385,
-0.0062158736,
0.0349348821,
-0.0285741501,
-0.0066736243,
0.032005243,
-0.0192369465,
0.0070891604,
0.0609929785,
-0.0031294019,
-0.0190172624,
-0.0424165092,
0.0303537715,
0.0013993625,
0.0077768541,
-0.0031579449,
0.0025747549,
-0.0404268019,
0.0475973338,
0.049145069,
0.0318025202,
-0.0412263274,
0.0362306833,
0.0013057773,
0.0399664305,
0.0373457223,
0.005910058,
0.0335043967,
-0.0115587348,
0.0155068683,
-0.020695623,
-0.0148158222,
-0.0175528638,
-0.0264831986,
-0.0025658419,
-0.0349928215,
0.0210282486,
0.0129801147,
0.0128764641,
0.0006299707,
-0.0201208647,
0.0008257733,
0.0660905838,
-0.0150943696,
0.0241681151,
-0.0092317918,
0.0387174338,
-0.0410904177,
0.0479394458,
-0.0471160784,
0.0265834108,
-0.1226920933,
-0.0250533968,
0.0388807617,
0.0223901737,
0.0052804546,
0.0041660517,
0.0070602805,
-0.0019318928,
0.0204443373,
-0.0125011839,
-0.0215798579,
-0.0535530336,
0.0005848535,
0.038220305,
0.0110590588,
0.0438524336,
-0.0018331547,
0.0006330906,
-0.0097010089,
-0.0238350611,
-0.0103854947,
-0.0455991067,
-0.0246939398,
0.0398674235,
0.0608907938,
0.0114017241,
-0.0416137613,
0.013501958,
-0.0378321521,
-0.0132486951,
0.0283459034,
-0.0557887107,
-0.0396066755,
-0.0036965727,
0.019607326,
-0.0145158255,
0.0345434062,
0.0068562101,
-0.0019069924,
0.0017968521,
0.0223753005,
0.0182289723,
0.034237437,
0.0150156133,
0.0086874859,
0.0351011008,
-0.0169736315,
-0.0164010581,
-0.0387109555,
-0.0253562946,
0.0423614122,
-0.0133588705,
0.0055706925,
0.0431801081,
-0.0172564983,
0.0460946225,
-0.0680855066,
-0.0311233513,
0.0237565283,
-0.0514458641,
-0.0691457167,
-0.0094569214,
-0.0489067324,
-0.0240546539,
0.0075267353,
-0.0100702913,
-0.0450332761,
0.0813286081,
-0.0168578681,
0.0488005467,
-0.0419679098,
-0.0089340461,
-0.0101862783,
0.0288830772,
-0.0047979341,
0.0296562091,
0.009387007,
-0.0924727619,
0.0006638483,
0.0135846101,
0.0290417094,
-0.0172132198,
0.0541861616,
-0.0104994588,
-0.0729895607,
0.0155428611,
-0.0599629506,
-0.0231929719,
-0.1169132069,
0.0480291322,
0.0037067686,
0.0347382613,
-0.0590008423,
0.0086362176,
-0.0088141114,
0.0018384034,
-0.0154312635,
-0.0265648123,
0.0004583522,
-0.0320182256,
-0.0042503579,
-0.0151851978,
-0.0341096558,
-0.0099114534,
-0.0090637179,
-0.0283064302,
0.0478347316,
0.0487398542,
0.0266281813,
0.0518948399,
-0.0158227272,
0.0094213299,
-0.0149834575,
-0.070149079,
0.0152800754,
0.0298459549,
-0.0063004382,
-0.0045736553,
0.0794439763,
0.0226130709,
-0.0324019715,
0.0051427074,
0.0472106077,
0.0268884283,
-0.00365903,
-0.0321282931,
-0.0670077577,
0.0196972825,
0.0293380283,
0.0410788544,
0.0004069817,
-0.0419950262,
-0.031624116,
-0.0682021007,
-0.0492104515,
0.013909,
0.0593426079,
-0.0058401064,
-0.0528385602,
0.0448001698,
0.0463564172,
-0.0315196961,
-0.0232517589,
-0.0078731533,
-0.0136672528,
-0.0078582726,
-0.0286583006,
0.0048839296,
-0.0633168146,
-0.0487939231,
-0.0150096901,
0.0319657922,
0.0127021866,
-0.0172319598,
-0.0547369383,
-0.0027219637,
0.031716764,
-0.0076952931,
0.0050591151,
0.0449666604,
-0.0495922007,
0.006757596,
-0.0239008199,
0.0718067959,
0.0095620444,
-0.0096020717,
-0.027125245,
0.0078995163,
0.0055758101,
-0.0072273053,
-0.0150852501,
-0.0086326059,
0.0196802076,
0.0624993108,
-0.0079268701,
-0.0390205011,
0.0178180486,
-0.0262119286,
0.0500975214,
0.0269848984,
0.059614189,
-0.0096093761,
-0.0274347514,
-0.0798453689,
-0.0694946647,
0.0099201947,
-0.0217942316,
0.049636431,
0.052646935,
0.0128631266,
0.0091227014,
-0.0244990718,
-0.0206777789,
0.0022848938,
-0.0270239413,
-0.0221752599,
-0.0288732331,
0.0275181793,
-0.0082288729,
0.0719792023,
-0.0294801854,
0.0183086377,
-0.031884864,
-0.0694744959,
0.0486517809,
-0.0195759032,
0.0050548785,
0.0276802294,
-0.0599052869,
-0.0509073623,
0.0479227155,
0.0688548312,
-0.0437745526,
0.010118451,
0.041263368,
-0.0283773635,
0.0056079831,
0.0246949531,
-0.012918056,
-0.0567517877,
0.0529857874,
-0.0191188455,
-0.0211142059,
-0.0198123064,
-0.0367866233,
-0.0054879431,
0.0357504673,
-0.0059410417,
0.1132258996,
-0.0567596219,
0.0009741964,
-0.0335406922,
-0.0298300069,
0.0008060742,
-0.0138812885,
0.0328607,
-0.0200944468,
0.0087750591,
0.0362141244,
0.0065992405,
0.0437315479,
-0.0205235034,
-0.0145246331,
0.0584423319,
0.0172674544,
-0.0202984195,
0.0278298017,
-0.0292381123,
0.0090997266,
-0.0124519337,
0.0050244676,
-0.0523458719,
-0.0279878452,
0.0171504058,
-0.0230192225,
-0.0577066615,
0.0422337353,
-0.035251122,
0.0127328634,
0.0023478311,
0.0254287925,
-0.0349755399,
0.0117022861,
-0.0387369171,
-0.0293369312,
-0.0194861796,
0.0231062528,
-0.0127307689,
-0.0124484645,
-0.0150432419,
-0.0280558504,
-0.0102647478,
-0.0245195907,
0.0300266631,
0.0681814775,
-0.0122596025,
-0.006191974,
-0.0088007683,
-0.031580314,
-0.0422050767,
0.0015829911,
0.0171991121,
0.0821143463,
0.0161543377,
0.0105054835,
-0.0525959209,
-0.0478801019,
0.0039818771,
0.0179265589,
0.0226770453,
0.0182774421,
0.0118064564,
0.0373992883,
0.0388135538,
-0.0766484886,
-0.0606144406,
0.0016013143,
0.0519496612,
-0.0091743134,
-0.0057213181,
-6.012046021e-33,
-0.0063951449,
-0.0172442924,
-0.0803338215,
0.0210147463,
0.0117760161,
-0.0097386492,
0.0266934689,
0.0095981853,
0.0155976592,
0.0031078607,
-0.0698688626,
0.0400160328,
0.0099619078,
-0.0050077406,
-0.0144740008,
0.0114429016,
0.0394202806,
-0.0151148252,
-0.0091521945,
-0.0117723895,
0.0748827308,
0.0374281332,
0.0075542824,
-0.0585122816,
0.1058935523,
0.0093742302,
-0.0213489085,
0.0149042709,
0.0059490311,
0.021763809,
-0.0401674099,
-0.0062255366,
0.0109551074,
0.0306399614,
-0.0355458148,
0.0800740123,
-0.0703851208,
-0.0611100197,
0.0455391966,
-0.0346093401,
0.0324149095,
-0.0596883632,
0.0414986126,
-0.0252332967,
-0.022090571,
0.0030328899,
-0.0070763291,
0.0170336422,
-0.0489083529,
-0.0256346501,
0.0074845073,
0.0083589256,
-0.0019797506,
0.0226837285,
0.0639005378,
-0.0417224392,
0.0190768391,
-0.0364227556,
-0.0207771678,
0.0215661358,
0.0042996099,
0.0201832224,
0.0154923126,
-0.0143016903,
0.056549713,
0.0565313287,
0.0180484299,
0.0247675683,
0.0254162494,
-0.025874434,
-0.0111762695,
-0.002712592,
0.0030765778,
0.0148949046,
0.0320578888,
-0.0406930521,
-0.0040765139,
-0.0211254321,
-0.0513920523,
-0.0204909928,
0.0595251173,
0.0381422229,
-0.1134023964,
-0.0359288566,
-0.0447189584,
-0.0188821536,
-0.016274184,
-0.0134895472,
-0.023589965,
0.0073078275,
-0.041344665,
-0.0032244117,
-0.0113500208,
-0.0342153087,
-0.0281973481,
0.0219282471,
0.0441547297,
-0.0163926333,
0.0050193891,
-0.0126151368,
0.0133517692,
-0.025761595,
0.0036825042,
0.0070790835,
0.0463121496,
0.0050096782,
0.0312204957,
-0.0419957004,
-0.0719467029,
-0.0251191538,
0.0075250319,
0.0138602098,
0.0009146693,
-0.0221496597,
0.0704885572,
-0.0055114571,
-0.0063789054,
0.0243961252,
0.060072571,
0.0339388736,
-0.0069279061,
0.0429466069,
-0.0303107742,
0.0112504587,
0.0354589149,
-0.024951566,
0.0259237234,
0.017888546,
0.1329643428,
0.0162872449,
0.0001382065,
-0.0247329921,
2.734e-7,
0.0038227153,
0.0090303766,
0.0384265408,
-0.0142131811,
0.002753661,
0.0224872343,
0.0143878236,
0.0485180095,
-0.043612387,
-0.0133810919,
-0.0405798927,
-0.0317525044,
0.0172096007,
0.0285457484,
-0.0405203365,
0.0137016028,
0.0158782937,
0.0285614878,
-0.0496126749,
-0.0185058024,
0.012930328,
0.0335693881,
0.0618211478,
0.0519123301,
-0.055022642,
-0.0612996332,
-0.0060407808,
-0.0084429299,
-0.048452381,
-0.0059513124,
0.0707558617,
0.0483639613,
0.0449171402,
-0.019247245,
-0.0296507515,
0.0705296546,
-0.0147250928,
0.0719241649,
0.030992616,
-0.0216517169,
-0.0039661359,
-0.0694641396,
-0.0243534259,
-0.0196008477,
0.0276089497,
0.0326854326,
-0.0569165759,
-0.0407954268,
0.0123567581,
-0.0610021092,
0.0511251017,
-0.0214545671,
-0.0272889733,
-0.0064376458,
0.0058892374,
0.0343873687,
0.0152582759,
-0.0813095793,
-0.0403141044,
-0.0133471331,
-0.0336861201,
0.0082805175,
0.0564497262,
0.0493473001,
-0.0087911719,
-0.0194426775,
0.0424094908,
2.689768929e-34,
-0.0179425608,
0.0134403268,
0.0059235934,
0.0070607993,
0.037394058,
-0.0097127613,
0.0144884661,
0.0101645747,
0.0697355568,
-0.057541579,
-0.0246263817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00637v1 | DP-MLM: Differentially Private Text Rewriting Using Masked Language Models | 2024-06-30T09:31:01 | 2024-06-30T09:31:01 | Stephen Meisenbacher, Maulik Chevli, Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of text privatization using Differential Privacy has recently taken
the form of $\textit{text rewriting}$, in which an input text is obfuscated via
the use of generative (large) language models. While these methods have shown
promising results in the ability to preserve privacy, these methods rely on
autoregressive models which lack a mechanism to contextualize the private
rewriting process. In response to this, we propose $\textbf{DP-MLM}$, a new
method for differentially private text rewriting based on leveraging masked
language models (MLMs) to rewrite text in a semantically similar $\textit{and}$
obfuscated manner. We accomplish this with a simple contextualization
technique, whereby we rewrite a text one token at a time. We find that
utilizing encoder-only MLMs provides better utility preservation at lower
$\varepsilon$ levels, as compared to previous methods relying on larger models
with a decoder. In addition, MLMs allow for greater customization of the
rewriting mechanism, as opposed to generative approaches. We make the code for
$\textbf{DP-MLM}$ public and reusable, found at https://github.com/sjmeis/DPMLM . | DP-MLM: Differentially Private Text Rewriting Using Masked Language Models: The task of text privatization using Differential Privacy has recently taken
the form of $\textit{text rewriting}$, in which an input text is obfuscated via
the use of generative (large) language models. While these methods have shown
promising results in the ability to preserve privacy, these methods rely on
autoregressive models which lack a mechanism to contextualize the private
rewriting process. In response to this, we propose $\textbf{DP-MLM}$, a new
method for differentially private text rewriting based on leveraging masked
language models (MLMs) to rewrite text in a semantically similar $\textit{and}$
obfuscated manner. We accomplish this with a simple contextualization
technique, whereby we rewrite a text one token at a time. We find that
utilizing encoder-only MLMs provides better utility preservation at lower
$\varepsilon$ levels, as compared to previous methods relying on larger models
with a decoder. In addition, MLMs allow for greater customization of the
rewriting mechanism, as opposed to generative approaches. We make the code for
$\textbf{DP-MLM}$ public and reusable, found at https://github.com/sjmeis/DPMLM . | [
0.0068785083,
0.1032330319,
-0.0231186971,
0.0673462525,
-0.058577314,
-0.0211889185,
0.0738381743,
0.023348229,
-0.0065383432,
0.0058460906,
0.0097476374,
0.0028252765,
0.0097799012,
0.0725432932,
0.0318561904,
-0.0116487779,
-0.0082958983,
-0.0053005377,
-0.0137647502,
-0.0306708198,
-0.0073736203,
-0.0020206231,
0.0470803678,
0.0167684462,
0.0287698898,
-0.0079657584,
-0.0170915481,
0.0345046185,
0.0047353567,
0.000288829,
0.0150506664,
0.0375793949,
0.0434764065,
0.1074321344,
0.0000022493,
-0.0200242046,
-0.0548512191,
0.032469634,
-0.0397983603,
0.0087255044,
0.0337705873,
-0.0465575904,
0.0086465254,
-0.0090063382,
-0.0305045545,
0.0140908994,
0.0299980342,
0.0202599205,
0.0817304105,
0.093757987,
-0.014129932,
-0.0396794043,
0.0029825501,
-0.0429866277,
0.0137717752,
-0.0006884173,
0.0414972752,
-0.022732161,
-0.0650647208,
0.0268363133,
-0.0108346548,
0.0396475457,
0.0112420032,
0.010431434,
0.0116373152,
0.0379348509,
0.0359326489,
-0.0060686199,
-0.0055050906,
-0.0068425606,
-0.0424511768,
-0.0621979535,
0.0448300764,
0.0040960796,
0.0103015862,
0.0084011527,
0.0055569867,
0.0271442495,
0.0073268032,
0.0064735678,
0.0169591792,
0.0371514633,
0.0226572659,
-0.0150859281,
-0.0056762835,
0.0310833156,
0.0305061731,
-0.0138351526,
-0.0871989876,
-0.0443027243,
0.0153991524,
-0.0782235041,
0.0688876808,
-0.0065177511,
0.0719367638,
0.0186800919,
-0.1094047874,
-0.0920153111,
-0.0021620276,
-0.0329662859,
-0.0067548514,
-0.0014230126,
0.0594476424,
0.0233373735,
-0.0454942174,
0.0693593845,
-0.0217564963,
0.0036393695,
-0.0088327369,
0.0171760153,
0.0166511424,
-0.0252717771,
-0.0378193781,
0.0747546405,
-0.1046606079,
-0.0111825848,
-0.0283039082,
0.0547136292,
0.0128706163,
0.0187300276,
-0.0280482769,
-0.0127206817,
-0.0565567985,
-0.0193086658,
0.060219083,
-0.0716340169,
-0.0014157515,
-0.0177173801,
0.0067271469,
-0.0236169081,
-0.0267173275,
-0.019690197,
-0.0022505575,
-0.0036402459,
-0.0448413268,
0.0924379751,
-0.0069860476,
0.0019116919,
0.0079228394,
-0.0664521232,
-0.0063588815,
0.0302312579,
-0.0069067073,
-0.0554876029,
-0.0043065939,
-0.0253206789,
0.0042629531,
-0.0885651037,
0.0283390488,
0.0180893298,
0.0016785061,
0.0551604629,
0.005583466,
-0.0192846898,
0.0405287407,
0.0278051663,
0.0032772853,
0.0299689714,
0.0429624133,
0.0490067825,
0.0537167527,
-0.0107243592,
0.080172956,
-0.0045398679,
0.0334056057,
0.059409719,
-0.0425293371,
0.0083221318,
0.0196800586,
-0.0314166732,
0.0335298255,
0.0389347151,
-0.0010160592,
-0.0826045424,
0.0722388476,
0.0376128331,
0.0125405416,
0.0078573292,
-0.0115640573,
0.051210463,
-0.0656667873,
0.0135412291,
0.0051677385,
-0.01208816,
-0.0456455573,
-0.0312437918,
-0.0184930731,
0.0022751905,
0.016991131,
-0.0140486937,
0.0391857773,
-0.0357877426,
0.0556285568,
-0.0114321811,
-0.0168387443,
0.0335471667,
-0.0401269607,
0.0155137237,
-0.0003301635,
-0.0326874629,
0.0002701552,
-0.0612165444,
0.0060778609,
0.0392677337,
0.056472443,
0.0033652626,
0.0316940546,
-0.0501673967,
-0.0517735481,
-0.0008860385,
-0.0370459184,
0.015734883,
0.0494192317,
-0.0226714015,
-0.0279816724,
-0.0687210709,
0.0313762985,
0.0393730514,
0.021586474,
-0.0080527468,
0.0232223105,
-0.0223475304,
0.0331561603,
0.0414277054,
-0.0253665298,
-0.065548785,
0.0352662839,
0.000175228,
0.0436308943,
-0.0050663888,
-0.0037226083,
0.0244243573,
0.0216095839,
-0.0284850486,
-0.0278949868,
-0.0241727848,
-0.0103148101,
-0.0536017455,
-0.011843781,
-0.0575979389,
0.0284105651,
0.0763202235,
-0.0222742911,
-0.0225799158,
-0.003630507,
-0.0264275111,
0.0204205737,
-0.0075080292,
0.00988298,
-0.0104220212,
0.0541475154,
-0.0555637889,
0.0076614837,
-0.0364389159,
-0.0033728499,
-0.0443752818,
-0.0123862512,
0.0235384721,
-0.0046657552,
-0.0084773554,
-0.0197212733,
-0.0108153028,
-0.0046751825,
-0.0036241878,
0.0254726466,
0.0172601603,
-0.0546018407,
0.0057821944,
0.0126135517,
-0.0132764047,
-0.0006759667,
0.0529775396,
0.0206518043,
-0.0192977712,
-0.0081601134,
-0.0450457335,
-0.0723549277,
-0.0388492346,
0.0111470344,
0.0376792215,
0.0279286895,
-0.0426471494,
0.0364497639,
-0.0217470378,
0.0348912962,
0.0456740893,
-0.047893431,
-0.0562026687,
-0.0281850416,
0.0333509222,
-0.0064010788,
0.0119638219,
-0.0441632904,
-0.0079553695,
-0.0327269211,
0.0073709381,
0.0402688682,
0.0494883209,
0.0083791595,
0.0096623916,
0.0005437455,
-0.001349054,
-0.0301316343,
-0.0085051088,
-0.0326242149,
0.0083666416,
-0.0065834066,
-0.0517977327,
0.0468596518,
0.0124521218,
0.040732421,
-0.0552821569,
-0.0440496877,
0.026159903,
-0.0223837104,
-0.0659851283,
-0.0187275037,
-0.0320657305,
0.0003743937,
0.0288421065,
-0.0222463589,
-0.0655547604,
0.0784444064,
-0.0338787585,
-0.0014936476,
-0.0060832649,
-0.0462807938,
-0.0421439111,
0.0424958579,
-0.0119167194,
0.0528213494,
0.0164515469,
-0.0374870785,
-0.0145639498,
0.0392705053,
0.0091245482,
-0.0254990701,
0.0121579943,
-0.0448906831,
-0.0369365998,
0.040489085,
-0.021396419,
-0.0297582634,
-0.1061808616,
0.0404929258,
-0.0218107589,
0.013840545,
-0.0301322844,
-0.0089638457,
0.0018675766,
0.0313340798,
0.0447627306,
0.0150142927,
0.0073788315,
-0.0490787216,
-0.0148792043,
-0.0188423712,
-0.0801708996,
-0.0296047293,
-0.0380300097,
0.0104583967,
0.0545597747,
0.0464699194,
-0.0053902119,
0.0457689464,
-0.0144170169,
0.0234845858,
0.0093781594,
-0.0506753586,
0.0166269895,
0.0296330061,
-0.0293848664,
-0.013574495,
0.063371487,
-0.0105193602,
-0.0401228406,
0.0121386247,
0.0440183654,
0.0440487824,
-0.007660144,
-0.0237225443,
-0.1045120582,
0.0183027089,
0.036951147,
0.0400226824,
-0.0273125116,
-0.0235792343,
-0.0442938767,
-0.0514028408,
-0.0193092767,
0.02814392,
0.0008127195,
-0.0107211629,
-0.050489746,
-0.0074157002,
0.0389774852,
-0.0542594381,
-0.0301206335,
0.0277289171,
-0.0314600766,
-0.0165208653,
0.0009002675,
0.0085186632,
-0.0259852502,
0.0052688126,
0.0382468514,
0.0487004817,
0.0101861721,
0.0013193975,
-0.0310439933,
0.006861357,
0.0101078646,
-0.0322163142,
-0.0016042495,
0.0350423232,
-0.0167547055,
0.0001111333,
0.0113814883,
0.0686099008,
0.0141768735,
-0.011778486,
0.0178340059,
-0.0099705467,
0.01347051,
-0.0383675359,
0.0139480624,
-0.0261539761,
0.025978975,
0.0501226,
0.0161487404,
-0.0145721538,
-0.0274861529,
-0.0658739656,
0.0357782021,
-0.0160258524,
0.0172282662,
-0.0162590388,
-0.0311965998,
-0.0728057623,
-0.0274171941,
0.0586151443,
-0.0148491841,
0.0222447496,
0.027377367,
0.0166779123,
0.01604563,
-0.0477262177,
-0.0439956896,
-0.0394151174,
-0.0700894296,
0.0342765488,
-0.0178930555,
-0.0311295222,
-0.0104423929,
-0.0105794342,
-0.0374795198,
0.0166768357,
-0.077246137,
-0.0583833121,
0.0398260355,
0.0194380898,
0.018839689,
0.0289293937,
-0.036005646,
-0.0678577274,
0.0722725093,
0.0209316891,
-0.045903001,
0.029589925,
0.0397125371,
0.0192464888,
0.0358155631,
0.0231804457,
-0.0295544025,
-0.021198621,
0.0668934286,
-0.050017681,
-0.0577381514,
-0.0014258765,
0.0162965115,
0.0395163745,
0.0133634796,
-0.0143647101,
0.0418221317,
-0.0171479955,
0.0452879705,
-0.0450145081,
-0.0271589234,
-0.0335798301,
0.0165265575,
0.0672970489,
0.0051883813,
0.0219511054,
0.0244342964,
0.0098663382,
-0.0124705369,
-0.0428527482,
-0.0096786357,
0.0131468326,
0.0326466635,
0.0438962057,
0.0233206376,
-0.0213777907,
0.0545918196,
0.0158500578,
-0.0003655035,
0.0102107078,
-0.0110416077,
0.0276796725,
0.019409392,
-0.0300754718,
0.0595678166,
-0.0596751198,
-0.007989306,
-0.0159706306,
0.0244112536,
-0.0167245492,
0.0668058321,
-0.0048419801,
-0.0238090847,
-0.0077403416,
-0.0002371799,
0.0295008589,
-0.0100216325,
-0.0551607199,
-0.0248228014,
-0.0353824049,
-0.0291217044,
0.0275390372,
0.1005379409,
0.0311004892,
0.0396570936,
0.0261398368,
0.0046159849,
-0.0643291175,
0.0026926815,
0.0260371845,
0.070787333,
0.0092534637,
0.0052498998,
-0.0318582095,
-0.0475708507,
0.0138025461,
-0.0132535109,
0.0383801684,
-0.0038366714,
-0.0310784075,
-0.0045478032,
-0.0210175831,
-0.042315878,
-0.0833619535,
0.0596012659,
0.0725659579,
-0.052518215,
-0.0201766975,
-5.863430107e-33,
0.0032226108,
-0.007262188,
-0.0477520786,
0.0333430059,
0.0080293259,
0.0205752905,
-0.0131684728,
-0.0213669501,
0.0508689545,
-0.024812704,
-0.0292903762,
0.0030675677,
0.0013082483,
0.0254570153,
-0.0572284013,
0.005588409,
0.0321597382,
0.0039319652,
-0.00955333,
0.0128736738,
0.0248167999,
0.0411694795,
-0.0019591781,
-0.0647973195,
0.053910803,
-0.0517040193,
-0.0572649203,
0.0087107355,
-0.0312309097,
-0.0003886639,
-0.0258583184,
-0.0348595083,
0.0074821236,
0.0136258677,
-0.0587075986,
0.0423632711,
-0.0227867831,
0.0179846585,
-0.0066930233,
-0.0187018383,
0.0168305598,
-0.0814390108,
0.052984871,
-0.013651263,
-0.008400213,
0.0405653901,
-0.0114253145,
-0.0141473813,
-0.0042932434,
-0.0292801782,
0.0149750747,
0.020528743,
-0.0338054448,
0.0069490466,
0.0633429885,
-0.001845259,
0.0187080894,
0.0101281824,
-0.0516296588,
0.0229242444,
0.0197115056,
-0.0027511416,
0.0255838968,
0.0072030621,
0.0461156592,
0.0027816459,
0.0356793553,
0.037784148,
-0.0098931268,
-0.0000120403,
-0.0050124726,
0.0132780857,
0.0334813967,
0.0352255292,
0.0237094872,
-0.0310411677,
-0.0061135511,
0.0208082944,
-0.073119618,
-0.0519663654,
0.0613960661,
0.0789609849,
-0.046099063,
-0.0106483568,
-0.0572770834,
0.0080277426,
-0.0049483194,
0.0284236278,
-0.0119729312,
0.0290177204,
-0.0464553721,
-0.01594292,
0.010479481,
-0.0645617545,
-0.0110858418,
-0.0165557284,
0.02229595,
-0.0026922885,
0.0151727796,
0.0197479203,
0.0096252784,
0.0125380708,
0.0379551053,
-0.0235466696,
0.0140564675,
-0.0130441608,
0.0142850382,
0.0077459654,
-0.0806505978,
-0.0184946992,
-0.0397000685,
0.0424574539,
0.0566309169,
0.0111984788,
0.0097875362,
-0.0185346138,
-0.0100237839,
-0.0410023294,
0.0343548916,
0.0005639119,
-0.0130351316,
0.0466342494,
-0.0085046366,
0.0130436271,
-0.0010342192,
0.000703663,
0.0282304138,
0.0153752677,
0.1274227649,
0.027428735,
-0.0208310783,
-0.0195857827,
2.874e-7,
0.0272148512,
0.0166066624,
0.0226282515,
-0.0058321389,
0.0269615296,
0.0659430102,
0.0014030738,
0.0425662808,
-0.0398932286,
0.0002013893,
-0.0337536484,
-0.0076593054,
0.0626680702,
-0.0036218863,
-0.0530859418,
-0.0177490413,
-0.0079137376,
0.0060480423,
-0.0320757031,
0.0064581544,
0.0076477858,
0.0638782233,
0.0579676218,
0.0216544904,
-0.0082695261,
-0.0336707458,
0.0164133012,
-0.0491090417,
-0.0028754303,
-0.0050679082,
-0.0080254348,
0.0375365578,
0.027172232,
-0.0353693776,
-0.014788921,
0.0024246238,
-0.022704741,
0.125013575,
0.0337761194,
-0.0135728177,
0.0264423657,
-0.0344567895,
-0.0507201925,
-0.0571813323,
0.0165234767,
0.0432317741,
-0.0220725015,
-0.0127882734,
-0.0278652124,
-0.0288417302,
0.065437533,
-0.0066333245,
-0.0234560203,
0.0242858138,
0.0094167953,
0.0409271345,
0.0072621824,
-0.0520379618,
-0.0545803532,
-0.074714683,
-0.068436943,
0.0278645139,
-0.007866269,
0.0290940385,
0.0260613747,
-0.0348076001,
0.0496498719,
3.053359204e-34,
-0.0077351909,
-0.0250201616,
-0.0506917015,
0.0401132479,
0.0372074582,
-0.01513163,
0.0040371884,
0.0228015706,
0.0120524615,
-0.058233615,
-0.0241189115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00632v1 | CAMON: Cooperative Agents for Multi-Object Navigation with LLM-based Conversations | 2024-06-30T09:14:33 | 2024-06-30T09:14:33 | Pengying Wu, Yao Mu, Kangjie Zhou, Ji Ma, Junting Chen, Chang Liu | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MA | Visual navigation tasks are critical for household service robots. As these
tasks become increasingly complex, effective communication and collaboration
among multiple robots become imperative to ensure successful completion. In
recent years, large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable
comprehension and planning abilities in the context of embodied agents.
However, their application in household scenarios, specifically in the use of
multiple agents collaborating to complete complex navigation tasks through
communication, remains unexplored. Therefore, this paper proposes a framework
for decentralized multi-agent navigation, leveraging LLM-enabled communication
and collaboration. By designing the communication-triggered dynamic leadership
organization structure, we achieve faster team consensus with fewer
communication instances, leading to better navigation effectiveness and
collaborative exploration efficiency. With the proposed novel communication
scheme, our framework promises to be conflict-free and robust in multi-object
navigation tasks, even when there is a surge in team size. | CAMON: Cooperative Agents for Multi-Object Navigation with LLM-based Conversations: Visual navigation tasks are critical for household service robots. As these
tasks become increasingly complex, effective communication and collaboration
among multiple robots become imperative to ensure successful completion. In
recent years, large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable
comprehension and planning abilities in the context of embodied agents.
However, their application in household scenarios, specifically in the use of
multiple agents collaborating to complete complex navigation tasks through
communication, remains unexplored. Therefore, this paper proposes a framework
for decentralized multi-agent navigation, leveraging LLM-enabled communication
and collaboration. By designing the communication-triggered dynamic leadership
organization structure, we achieve faster team consensus with fewer
communication instances, leading to better navigation effectiveness and
collaborative exploration efficiency. With the proposed novel communication
scheme, our framework promises to be conflict-free and robust in multi-object
navigation tasks, even when there is a surge in team size. | [
0.0574236624,
0.0125490054,
-0.0176455751,
-0.030773785,
-0.0308408719,
-0.0162682347,
0.006977356,
-0.021451246,
0.0154940756,
-0.0266885031,
-0.0270349178,
-0.0033466681,
-0.0148293665,
0.0018265913,
-0.0249079801,
-0.0426483415,
0.0129450588,
-0.0527403876,
0.0158492774,
-0.0426478274,
-0.0146603985,
-0.0273836926,
-0.0111545119,
0.035746567,
0.0066050668,
-0.004933109,
-0.0578433946,
0.0047844658,
0.0203913786,
-0.0441976413,
0.0087227188,
0.0366279222,
0.0324551761,
0.0321062915,
0.0000022325,
-0.0185299143,
-0.0273444597,
-0.0230789073,
0.0073819449,
-0.0541577637,
0.0839306712,
-0.0331048742,
0.004626804,
0.0107282707,
-0.0261354242,
0.010625842,
0.0622584112,
0.0445915312,
0.0118763959,
0.0360786654,
0.0086463951,
-0.010413968,
-0.0350060575,
0.0039794319,
-0.0478778742,
-0.0639143512,
0.0302613806,
0.0377864093,
0.0251374058,
-0.0001122987,
-0.0310814567,
0.0125568686,
0.0171761271,
-0.0135880532,
0.0025195002,
0.0496997721,
-0.0245801862,
-0.0679980665,
-0.0289376769,
0.0549381375,
0.0119400527,
0.0173094273,
0.0136049716,
0.0165114459,
-0.0414553657,
0.0252662282,
-0.038764514,
0.0309928283,
0.0122778155,
-0.0093279984,
-0.0548206903,
-0.0134816421,
-0.015539025,
0.0075112432,
-0.0159325898,
0.0749775618,
0.0158982314,
0.0267469455,
-0.0545900017,
-0.0176172275,
-0.0017860591,
-0.0623264946,
0.0476927906,
0.0483175404,
-0.0552817136,
0.0325543582,
-0.0233936049,
0.0490729958,
0.0077300989,
-0.0935554057,
0.0166719928,
0.0206093509,
0.0013222683,
0.0213201363,
0.0259661935,
0.0322451629,
-0.0278895609,
0.0378026441,
-0.0319414996,
-0.0455971546,
-0.0671342611,
0.0089710094,
-0.0376561359,
0.057442192,
-0.0645852834,
-0.0520624742,
0.0114717074,
0.0729971826,
0.0013034394,
0.0168889351,
-0.0381539389,
0.0145353675,
-0.000320253,
0.0000965731,
-0.0239193086,
0.000321458,
-0.0359737314,
-0.0039025769,
-0.0144261941,
0.0107733058,
0.0455483943,
0.0041768965,
-0.0195748117,
0.0104093822,
-0.0335256271,
0.0652771592,
-0.0254481025,
-0.0251061413,
0.0444166474,
-0.0013203606,
-0.0014455937,
-0.043203216,
-0.0117979478,
-0.0722406879,
0.0201398004,
-0.0015964931,
0.0217209347,
0.0043275035,
0.0315010138,
-0.0021831444,
-0.0156498905,
0.0376911834,
0.0115589648,
0.0575903803,
0.0324300081,
0.0274843741,
0.0024520534,
0.0451447554,
0.055556491,
0.0408988558,
0.0174690634,
0.071156688,
-0.0050199004,
0.0310304593,
-0.0522871055,
-0.0001211658,
0.0475307889,
-0.0119073652,
-0.0181162339,
0.0406394117,
-0.0493426658,
0.0596085079,
-0.0095840255,
0.0158889946,
0.0748814419,
0.0348898806,
-0.020378774,
-0.0294388998,
-0.0194947422,
0.0404285602,
-0.0305489711,
-0.0441579334,
-0.027367197,
0.023906786,
-0.0310032591,
-0.0338495634,
-0.0303427987,
0.0165911671,
-0.0050984095,
-0.0057525905,
0.0208946634,
0.0129339937,
0.0272967108,
-0.0033128273,
0.0412166901,
-0.0037644454,
-0.0393819772,
0.0073393453,
-0.0100327199,
-0.0388335474,
-0.044306092,
-0.0090628546,
0.0432097688,
0.0458365493,
0.0635507405,
0.0546965152,
-0.0608469248,
0.0128272688,
0.0645729229,
0.0128465518,
-0.000578693,
-0.0151527431,
0.0176224262,
-0.0206848681,
-0.0520090051,
0.0723031834,
-0.006434768,
0.0301249325,
-0.0092287799,
-0.0133956848,
-0.0240488444,
0.0164659005,
-0.0193312205,
0.0302029736,
0.0499751158,
0.0907349512,
-0.031315431,
0.0455733202,
0.0351586603,
0.0292030647,
-0.0163640864,
-0.0373338051,
0.0424594209,
-0.038314119,
-0.0276771411,
0.0287314821,
0.01154391,
-0.0035796133,
0.0149316574,
-0.0345167331,
-0.001401147,
0.032445658,
0.0070754276,
-0.0189172346,
-0.0364175886,
-0.0077672796,
-0.0146592166,
0.0147512956,
0.0103479652,
0.0056243129,
-0.0083542429,
-0.0176018644,
0.0375181697,
-0.0246396232,
-0.0293420982,
0.0447320156,
0.0581708588,
0.0111051807,
-0.0377509072,
0.0326479822,
0.0640259907,
0.0654775724,
-0.0035969866,
0.0518580191,
0.0267721433,
0.0129409824,
-0.0523356907,
-0.087947011,
-0.0227487329,
-0.0153675694,
-0.0284861624,
0.0068796645,
-0.0288445596,
0.0102806492,
0.0125490604,
0.0321309157,
0.0720143244,
0.0175105985,
0.0047866739,
0.0061929254,
0.0040673013,
-0.1050802171,
-0.0364619642,
0.0261970647,
0.0010388674,
-0.0378149636,
0.0417018756,
-0.0457563475,
-0.061012987,
-0.0008083948,
-0.0693918839,
0.0310299806,
-0.0138474405,
-0.0776116997,
0.0346132889,
-0.0251336992,
0.0349796303,
0.0301792696,
-0.0096403752,
0.0208618604,
0.066467911,
-0.0834353119,
-0.0535305925,
0.0065996065,
-0.0201852694,
-0.0046000048,
-0.0527927764,
-0.0095446175,
0.0192308817,
-0.0048895041,
-0.0363582447,
0.017077947,
-0.0269739646,
-0.0209320933,
0.0033895893,
-0.0478071645,
-0.0066251052,
0.0051063946,
-0.0373690128,
0.0820861161,
-0.0487043075,
-0.0073973662,
0.0239089634,
-0.0147469398,
-0.0216481611,
0.0067754253,
-0.0133489771,
-0.0479148217,
0.0962652192,
0.0130431391,
0.0392589495,
-0.0040821531,
-0.0208372399,
-0.014613172,
0.0162941515,
-0.0011957713,
-0.0036952284,
0.0294971075,
-0.0926772058,
0.019580191,
-0.0035560566,
-0.0534199774,
-0.0120035857,
0.0280795489,
-0.0221860074,
0.0242788848,
-0.0084930221,
-0.0378553085,
-0.0719884336,
0.0364384428,
0.0139080063,
0.0020202021,
0.0362893678,
-0.0089252787,
-0.0453420989,
-0.0252249241,
0.0096191233,
0.0333278999,
-0.0554338619,
-0.0341496579,
0.0140567487,
0.0582666807,
0.0732501969,
-0.0311999246,
-0.0176897813,
-0.0129178818,
0.0375699177,
0.0434328318,
0.0027553313,
-0.0232772082,
0.0543292426,
-0.0094300611,
-0.0023187632,
0.0872767493,
0.0219097901,
-0.0232079979,
-0.004137143,
-0.0408728905,
0.0288421735,
0.0086054215,
0.0123098139,
-0.0197224095,
0.0050609638,
0.0228709485,
-0.0240660757,
-0.0041890405,
-0.0490014255,
-0.0200558603,
-0.0651361942,
0.0287272129,
-0.0010558602,
-0.0391677395,
-0.0711691827,
-0.0078618675,
0.0298203044,
0.0026916522,
-0.0401186757,
0.0130993063,
0.0327035747,
-0.0365254171,
-0.0086868238,
-0.0055091628,
0.0310139414,
0.0333028473,
-0.0804136992,
0.0784433335,
0.0688057989,
0.0641019121,
0.0337425172,
0.011354913,
-0.0208246335,
0.05194363,
0.0296513811,
-0.0357399918,
-0.0384486914,
-0.0292924643,
0.0073536667,
0.0142840343,
-0.0009683613,
0.0005834388,
-0.001154029,
0.0153628848,
0.0097666355,
-0.0222138204,
-0.0060394634,
-0.0367947631,
0.0271768086,
0.0281431992,
0.0396072082,
-0.0556722507,
-0.0264919437,
-0.0456183963,
-0.0185810588,
-0.0376787558,
0.0603518896,
-0.0638288334,
0.0214158613,
-0.0361918323,
-0.0182407741,
-0.0640534684,
-0.0430371985,
0.0629187748,
0.0300113745,
0.0224999003,
-0.0168056302,
0.0167155098,
0.0369057767,
0.0381323807,
-0.0535152629,
-0.05609487,
0.0148455473,
-0.0575559214,
0.020442443,
0.0260452591,
-0.0167727992,
0.0106304698,
0.0447583981,
-0.0409524143,
-0.068651706,
0.0260632951,
0.0302204266,
0.017307587,
-0.0276752673,
-0.0103894165,
-0.0461975224,
-0.0125399996,
0.0036899331,
0.0071962248,
0.0356829949,
-0.0198466275,
0.0595305115,
0.014346472,
0.0494671836,
-0.0799030364,
0.010060166,
-0.0416985452,
0.0692421868,
-0.0447752997,
-0.0590589978,
0.012947198,
-0.011204198,
-0.0099140052,
0.0345531739,
0.005420737,
-0.0097408257,
0.0290726386,
-0.0513641834,
-0.0105783669,
-0.0478067473,
0.0495244935,
-0.0299962442,
-0.0335422158,
0.0473281182,
0.0762778893,
0.0288269483,
0.0130170761,
0.024168577,
0.0181189254,
-0.0183122475,
-0.0175061878,
0.0270926449,
0.0308637675,
0.0022720313,
0.0143541023,
-0.0121644679,
0.0241845548,
0.0458537824,
0.0428663827,
0.0099139614,
-0.0729772076,
-0.0421565138,
0.0005978086,
-0.048138164,
-0.1011695787,
0.0795534551,
0.0781086758,
0.0721353218,
0.0553278178,
0.0351203941,
-0.0997897983,
0.0254802965,
-0.0335204639,
-0.0173371583,
0.0109040858,
-0.0305469204,
0.0239000209,
0.0162079632,
0.0221790541,
0.0435740687,
0.0348550752,
0.0165360793,
0.0364057869,
-0.021473499,
-0.0378590152,
-0.0470284782,
0.0127997873,
0.0378724337,
0.0253275577,
-0.0073590721,
0.0099915843,
-0.0332203433,
0.0379262567,
-0.0192620065,
0.0230861958,
0.0164104663,
-0.053340435,
0.050059732,
0.0077297813,
-0.0261643846,
-0.0629746839,
-0.0432504565,
-0.0442672968,
-0.0193950962,
0.048099082,
-0.0204263274,
-6.354634298e-33,
-0.0250101928,
-0.1112780273,
0.0592101514,
0.0010896937,
0.004839533,
-0.0438119657,
-0.0156080713,
0.014382082,
-0.0307806954,
-0.0113774026,
0.0025555021,
0.0252142735,
0.0297488216,
0.031296026,
0.0180402808,
0.0203951336,
0.0629138052,
-0.0170310102,
-0.0286600944,
-0.0281226486,
0.014746692,
0.0228710044,
-0.0224475916,
-0.0466649719,
0.0110414708,
0.0044896132,
-0.018328758,
0.0601225756,
-0.001399103,
-0.002616067,
0.0007767772,
-0.0304616205,
-0.02017547,
0.0259924233,
-0.0451279581,
0.0134057635,
-0.0283492897,
-0.020612048,
-0.0114023974,
0.0311141759,
-0.0461684428,
-0.0084765321,
0.0067155436,
-0.0050868657,
0.0246493388,
0.0331813768,
0.0023746877,
-0.0146600343,
-0.0400484912,
0.0594885089,
-0.0461575054,
0.0306388792,
0.0125178732,
-0.0440780669,
0.0555209629,
0.0062763533,
0.0074882912,
-0.0168783329,
-0.0376427956,
0.0126635125,
-0.0341204479,
-0.0228878744,
0.0245965682,
0.0172258224,
0.0259147771,
0.0518974327,
0.0640681684,
0.0231662989,
-0.0137138199,
-0.0245328862,
-0.0547926761,
0.1226947233,
0.0099592842,
0.0266995355,
-0.0558485128,
0.0487897247,
-0.006368747,
-0.0268225465,
0.0126552079,
0.034279488,
0.044314567,
0.061287608,
-0.0407856219,
0.0219734479,
-0.008027344,
-0.0286110248,
0.0044769482,
-0.0516962036,
0.0109958015,
0.058641769,
-0.002372656,
-0.0575211234,
0.0355105884,
0.0003758656,
-0.0304734297,
0.0001888461,
0.0240161214,
0.0292983744,
-0.0313513204,
-0.0161058735,
-0.0683322176,
-0.0086108614,
-0.0093937311,
-0.0044371756,
-0.0209444202,
0.0088628633,
-0.0668037757,
0.039594911,
0.0034866582,
-0.0139021734,
0.0050750696,
-0.0401175134,
0.0145192668,
-0.0480348431,
0.054763902,
-0.0239230655,
-0.0034247958,
0.0419377349,
-0.006654745,
-0.0601381846,
0.0203886647,
0.0125213331,
-0.0375772491,
-0.0200018659,
-0.0257644225,
-0.0008161675,
-0.0830599964,
0.0415526442,
0.0540772602,
-0.0101382509,
-0.0200309176,
-0.0370259844,
2.986e-7,
-0.0079798689,
0.0609102286,
0.0423789136,
0.0656897426,
0.0137506807,
0.0347474627,
0.0154217724,
0.0541236252,
-0.0432043448,
-0.0201927274,
0.0338368341,
0.0351241902,
0.0065454859,
-0.0015435383,
-0.064410381,
-0.029856544,
-0.0011807864,
-0.041840557,
-0.0374597237,
-0.0169564262,
0.0397471003,
0.029482916,
0.026183283,
0.0191682372,
-0.0096684201,
-0.0273818281,
0.0234678369,
-0.0512339771,
-0.0047244285,
-0.0108792605,
-0.006525306,
-0.0211572722,
-0.0436538942,
-0.0241002627,
0.0485267565,
0.0190571081,
-0.0088743428,
0.0486465096,
-0.0163075682,
-0.0179530364,
0.0069896886,
-0.0054103155,
-0.0526085794,
0.005698293,
0.0352746546,
-0.0668836087,
0.0124792987,
0.0538821034,
0.0442638062,
0.0019705398,
-0.004268019,
0.024714604,
-0.0173710212,
-0.0180769488,
-0.0343925208,
-0.0029648412,
-0.025279168,
-0.0287415199,
0.030297989,
-0.0313622616,
-0.0525744297,
-0.0576882772,
0.0030912091,
0.0018706078,
-0.0651188046,
0.0181650911,
-0.027835682,
2.056741114e-34,
0.0199933145,
-0.010753219,
-0.0563211441,
0.0617997088,
0.0382114276,
-0.01098614,
-0.0772526786,
-0.0105358735,
0.0293967761,
-0.0431245081,
-0.0376466475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00617v1 | Iterative Nash Policy Optimization: Aligning LLMs with General Preferences via No-Regret Learning | 2024-06-30T08:00:34 | 2024-06-30T08:00:34 | Yuheng Zhang, Dian Yu, Baolin Peng, Linfeng Song, Ye Tian, Mingyue Huo, Nan Jiang, Haitao Mi, Dong Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT | Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) has achieved great success
in aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. Prevalent RLHF
approaches are reward-based, following the Bradley-Terry (BT) model assumption,
which may not fully capture the complexity of human preferences. In this paper,
we explore RLHF under a general preference framework and approach it from a
game-theoretic perspective. Specifically, we formulate the problem as a
two-player game and propose a novel algorithm, iterative Nash policy
optimization (INPO). The key idea is to let the policy play against itself via
no-regret learning, thereby approximating the Nash policy. Unlike previous
methods, INPO bypasses the need for estimating the expected win rate for
individual responses, which typically incurs high computational or annotation
costs. Instead, we introduce a new loss objective that is directly minimized
over a preference dataset. We provide theoretical analysis for our approach and
demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on various representative
benchmarks. With an LLaMA-3-8B-based SFT model, INPO achieves a 41.5%
length-controlled win rate on AlpacaEval 2.0 and a 38.3% win rate on
Arena-Hard, showing substantial improvement over the state-of-the-art iterative
algorithm [Dong et al., 2024] under the BT model assumption. Additionally, our
ablation study highlights the benefits of incorporating KL regularization for
response length control. | Iterative Nash Policy Optimization: Aligning LLMs with General Preferences via No-Regret Learning: Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) has achieved great success
in aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. Prevalent RLHF
approaches are reward-based, following the Bradley-Terry (BT) model assumption,
which may not fully capture the complexity of human preferences. In this paper,
we explore RLHF under a general preference framework and approach it from a
game-theoretic perspective. Specifically, we formulate the problem as a
two-player game and propose a novel algorithm, iterative Nash policy
optimization (INPO). The key idea is to let the policy play against itself via
no-regret learning, thereby approximating the Nash policy. Unlike previous
methods, INPO bypasses the need for estimating the expected win rate for
individual responses, which typically incurs high computational or annotation
costs. Instead, we introduce a new loss objective that is directly minimized
over a preference dataset. We provide theoretical analysis for our approach and
demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on various representative
benchmarks. With an LLaMA-3-8B-based SFT model, INPO achieves a 41.5%
length-controlled win rate on AlpacaEval 2.0 and a 38.3% win rate on
Arena-Hard, showing substantial improvement over the state-of-the-art iterative
algorithm [Dong et al., 2024] under the BT model assumption. Additionally, our
ablation study highlights the benefits of incorporating KL regularization for
response length control. | [
0.0457650945,
0.058735542,
-0.0213546883,
0.0487398319,
-0.0381807238,
-0.0076944199,
-0.0632926524,
0.0138561307,
-0.0278610121,
0.0074593839,
-0.034305755,
-0.0854451358,
0.0028544876,
0.0047915517,
0.0263564344,
-0.0329117179,
-0.0037866156,
-0.0476280823,
0.0470073968,
-0.0274800733,
0.0185320117,
-0.035078004,
0.0057506962,
0.0488636754,
0.0222238526,
0.0395994969,
-0.0406018905,
-0.0192906093,
0.0012079474,
-0.0578131191,
0.0297290385,
0.0126200039,
0.0256115757,
0.0182781406,
0.0000023687,
-0.0611078143,
-0.0271843188,
-0.03052832,
0.0208462272,
0.0131117841,
0.0603348501,
0.0327138714,
-0.0079374602,
0.0232760869,
-0.0177845154,
0.0371353403,
0.0801346302,
0.0055852467,
0.0397445448,
0.0502667166,
0.0138915414,
-0.0258661564,
-0.0175127052,
-0.0492541939,
0.0090255141,
-0.0576965585,
0.0223651454,
-0.0293443017,
0.0064310213,
-0.0338101611,
-0.0306130406,
0.009292976,
-0.0240908042,
0.0393002145,
-0.0007540171,
0.0250145048,
0.013381632,
0.021433169,
0.0072771516,
0.0621298105,
-0.0261025652,
-0.0327389799,
0.0281493831,
-0.0155370804,
0.0100784963,
-0.0513484441,
-0.0224969834,
-0.0162270796,
0.0337898694,
0.0450021662,
0.0304195285,
-0.0050164238,
0.0166553501,
0.001471723,
-0.0246260855,
0.0617675968,
-0.0104328431,
-0.0577629544,
0.0162820183,
0.0037435659,
-0.0100269662,
-0.0471400917,
-0.0234615263,
0.0362449624,
-0.1006458104,
0.026073087,
-0.0169489123,
0.0132773519,
0.0243880115,
-0.0638282597,
0.0612319037,
0.0232017208,
0.0127534019,
0.0321011804,
-0.0054547465,
0.049960915,
0.0027290836,
0.0174266081,
-0.0310566183,
0.0297099836,
-0.0086071454,
-0.0054476806,
-0.0059646098,
0.0300295781,
-0.0054998221,
0.000996855,
-0.037862435,
-0.0211232267,
-0.0319313295,
0.0670893192,
-0.0085655181,
0.0273292493,
-0.0187471099,
-0.0235491581,
-0.0831176043,
0.0429926738,
-0.0313349143,
0.0110877743,
0.0108674858,
-0.0084918253,
0.0078741843,
-0.0094059631,
-0.021815449,
-0.0362684019,
0.0440340191,
0.1108955368,
-0.0369538367,
-0.0262888595,
0.0110263964,
0.0158837195,
-0.0279904008,
-0.0785550401,
-0.022071369,
-0.0826741904,
0.0279797446,
-0.0520365126,
-0.0130249802,
-0.0791282058,
0.0103820125,
-0.0124448584,
-0.0444304943,
0.0688070133,
0.042589061,
0.0017614346,
0.0129154846,
-0.0311574284,
0.0107481061,
0.0749015361,
0.0590001643,
0.044381056,
0.0110897589,
0.0155439842,
-0.0107962219,
0.0625086725,
0.0390183069,
0.0408619754,
-0.0321323052,
-0.007178627,
0.0208588131,
0.0908301547,
0.0518204831,
0.0369434915,
-0.0232893489,
-0.0435228385,
0.0681510568,
0.0307566132,
0.0022049302,
0.0310592763,
0.0176522061,
0.0331622623,
-0.0039253356,
0.0019596168,
-0.0239039622,
0.0274519678,
-0.019651765,
0.0168283284,
0.0320915878,
0.0127104037,
-0.0014029857,
-0.063832961,
0.0115909725,
-0.0180547796,
0.0169234388,
0.0429928638,
0.0610480942,
-0.0396929272,
-0.0780634433,
-0.0169788525,
0.0419218875,
0.002391441,
-0.0139737008,
-0.0465268828,
0.0382350571,
0.0580421723,
0.030616127,
-0.0417742431,
-0.0244109537,
-0.0337688141,
-0.0984994024,
0.0542749316,
0.0437231213,
-0.0248444453,
-0.0087810792,
-0.0451179966,
-0.0413299203,
0.0302807502,
0.0177387297,
0.0761503652,
-0.0082291411,
-0.0089276396,
-0.0194444321,
0.0327015482,
-0.019297976,
0.0134069668,
0.0072558192,
-0.0826818198,
0.0140847228,
0.0078577958,
0.0726379082,
-0.014499859,
-0.0102213882,
0.0075197201,
0.0207819398,
0.0036270234,
-0.0356116407,
-0.0301937722,
-0.0233266782,
-0.0094303861,
0.0699514821,
0.011259052,
0.0108838966,
0.037558414,
-0.0226303488,
-0.0241234191,
0.0099910274,
-0.0345204473,
0.0548164956,
0.0068338471,
0.012890053,
-0.0277096611,
-0.0426494591,
-0.0863120556,
0.0309768338,
-0.0204328578,
0.0069474638,
-0.0078226188,
-0.0816085786,
0.0080697257,
-0.0913305655,
-0.0344713517,
0.0519781783,
0.0048115854,
0.0226556975,
0.0584955253,
0.0484050736,
-0.0103237005,
-0.0125322323,
-0.0299457479,
-0.0124416202,
-0.0170489829,
-0.0030752425,
-0.0060471175,
-0.0229819641,
-0.022414716,
-0.0255554765,
-0.04097078,
-0.0204346832,
0.0039351447,
0.0082342122,
0.0245935898,
0.0309220497,
-0.0270370748,
-0.0766614079,
-0.0301363636,
0.0144224772,
-0.0150282038,
-0.0602685213,
-0.0032909038,
-0.0256180298,
0.0207697041,
-0.0490775518,
0.0392147191,
-0.0322781503,
-0.0434164479,
0.0148842847,
-0.0556390099,
0.0107893869,
0.0459693708,
0.0047509274,
0.009927175,
0.0737190992,
0.0059936661,
-0.0735935494,
0.0260173567,
-0.0366023332,
-0.0756030679,
-0.0719323903,
-0.0137921283,
0.0516494475,
0.1076034307,
-0.013646475,
0.0065111853,
-0.0570125654,
-0.0344968289,
0.0095775854,
-0.0195054468,
-0.0520232692,
0.0168847051,
-0.0421588197,
0.0264329519,
-0.0084891189,
-0.0272244848,
0.0875846967,
-0.01272175,
0.0245754737,
-0.0640623346,
0.0124899382,
-0.0182836801,
0.0333149806,
0.0260954816,
0.0120876012,
-0.0043003666,
-0.0144262807,
-0.0560576469,
-0.0622280873,
0.0343386903,
-0.0397685207,
0.0508270748,
-0.0167065356,
0.0165394042,
-0.0034163338,
-0.0470486954,
-0.0080047082,
-0.016008405,
-0.057224784,
-0.0350295193,
0.0537413098,
-0.0256907046,
-0.0052756364,
-0.0273005534,
0.0382490009,
0.0191088896,
-0.0019834726,
-0.0055139782,
-0.0099819358,
0.0231279191,
0.0860477537,
0.0449440628,
0.0050416831,
0.0133027341,
-0.008426643,
0.0240747835,
0.0652260929,
-0.0115486905,
0.0099181673,
0.0081991283,
0.0495284796,
-0.0464540236,
-0.0278581679,
0.0589770563,
0.0167372115,
-0.049344711,
0.0098500885,
0.0691665709,
0.0363645852,
-0.0309590641,
0.0210539475,
-0.0168759339,
0.1056122333,
0.0021995497,
0.042880293,
-0.064632304,
-0.027782796,
0.0132891135,
0.0280552488,
-0.0007682415,
-0.0305833016,
0.0065377243,
-0.1266522408,
-0.0440372527,
0.0060720947,
-0.0576159358,
-0.000769018,
-0.0223623533,
-0.005445749,
-0.0601268448,
-0.0090300813,
0.0365499929,
0.0143057071,
0.001707204,
0.0212359596,
0.0191999562,
0.0025419376,
-0.0033005781,
-0.0177067723,
0.0781170055,
0.0832597017,
0.0477203056,
-0.0041860235,
-0.0023313866,
0.030594632,
0.0466886684,
-0.0301545952,
-0.0222903583,
0.0044566272,
0.0013902377,
-0.0079311384,
0.0150353322,
0.0368987285,
0.0285935588,
0.0221807975,
0.0309965145,
0.05254649,
0.0294380467,
0.0025128783,
0.0315069929,
-0.0124899736,
0.0243536923,
0.0427342542,
-0.0034396076,
-0.0556227341,
-0.0471057929,
-0.0486070327,
-0.0328076482,
-0.0590219647,
-0.0504896455,
-0.0533260517,
0.0249657147,
0.0526000932,
-0.0572415814,
-0.0390304625,
-0.0152226081,
0.0158886891,
-0.010291988,
0.0164666921,
-0.0029653183,
0.0119282892,
-0.0057064621,
-0.0119711645,
-0.0526868068,
0.0211378038,
-0.0510038473,
-0.0203712042,
-0.0079060467,
-0.0555433966,
-0.0275958609,
0.0109660598,
0.0045887092,
-0.0567557514,
-0.0173773021,
0.0801325142,
0.0168473385,
0.0456726514,
0.0162740294,
-0.0581896678,
0.0588482432,
0.0138660194,
0.0053840028,
-0.001637485,
0.0400736555,
0.0233008806,
0.0010551651,
0.0334762111,
-0.0105238603,
-0.0384217873,
0.030252073,
0.0812350661,
0.0213270802,
-0.0118141416,
0.0369704813,
0.0009886869,
0.0021468403,
-0.0421740934,
-0.0237887185,
0.002691183,
0.019866664,
-0.0074074152,
-0.0134882377,
-0.017513182,
-0.0254945625,
0.0133823333,
-0.0164303463,
0.0170848276,
-0.0614160374,
-0.0074664732,
0.0052518821,
0.004320906,
0.001471354,
0.0629263446,
0.0075918715,
0.0475681387,
0.0266020913,
0.0242364556,
0.0263755582,
0.0293245856,
0.0425458476,
0.0233283304,
0.0041593937,
0.0318173468,
-0.017322408,
-0.0091409478,
-0.0021520359,
0.0094673708,
-0.0278567486,
-0.0208673347,
0.0250119902,
0.0904879794,
-0.0153846312,
0.0279661119,
-0.0323531516,
0.0031589852,
-0.0020515264,
-0.0247367825,
-0.0560906157,
-0.0277445316,
0.0119101424,
0.0340855457,
-0.0176054165,
0.0151277222,
0.096795328,
0.0782951489,
0.0393050276,
-0.0322496854,
0.0078492155,
-0.0365872122,
-0.0058755325,
0.0087256366,
0.0772566199,
-0.0597813986,
-0.0303421393,
-0.0338650867,
-0.0479893051,
-0.0372403972,
0.0602713935,
0.0027503571,
-0.0139741693,
0.0550027154,
0.0186497699,
-0.0354640372,
0.0061582667,
-0.0598994493,
-0.0042254515,
-0.0216626935,
-0.0422223583,
-0.0397861153,
-6.653234843e-33,
-0.0295380056,
-0.0087150745,
0.0498478785,
-0.0094494019,
-0.0314899758,
-0.0352828428,
-0.007451436,
0.0318043791,
0.0023884224,
0.0004728588,
-0.0346537791,
-0.0426152162,
0.0038219679,
0.0130130099,
0.0370145924,
-0.0365905873,
0.0228689294,
-0.0009861853,
-0.048767563,
0.0054243682,
-0.0010444038,
-0.0074313409,
0.029778162,
-0.0173179191,
0.0179616157,
0.0444076844,
-0.0296886619,
0.0209697336,
-0.0200238824,
0.0633524582,
-0.0116237588,
0.0298820976,
-0.0102103772,
-0.0690931305,
-0.002387037,
-0.0126982862,
-0.0582026057,
-0.0263088699,
-0.0044134944,
-0.009711897,
0.0300427433,
-0.0259156339,
0.0190430712,
0.0232180785,
-0.0549184531,
-0.0039763022,
0.0253863633,
-0.0156873316,
-0.0384648778,
0.0003009505,
-0.0365167446,
0.0056062606,
-0.014876741,
-0.009551784,
0.0269524585,
0.0164879579,
-0.0194881465,
0.0214656219,
-0.0350441858,
0.0457401313,
0.0213288926,
0.0420920923,
0.0451382399,
0.0319002606,
0.0332109332,
0.0118505601,
-0.0059008528,
-0.0101660294,
0.0054215607,
-0.0266799908,
0.0270189941,
0.0084643308,
0.023596637,
0.0195451267,
0.0338144079,
-0.0045601237,
-0.0298832152,
0.04003378,
0.0236697644,
0.0596542582,
0.0128698098,
0.0548200198,
-0.0606130175,
-0.0091284765,
-0.0534004606,
-0.0368518271,
-0.0109624146,
-0.0513459854,
0.002872997,
0.0189940855,
0.0144764828,
0.0022098075,
0.0280354246,
-0.0158043411,
-0.0353159867,
0.0077242795,
-0.0356606245,
0.0362516418,
-0.0040804921,
-0.0107167596,
-0.0656588748,
-0.0196796041,
-0.0347554535,
-0.0134383393,
-0.0128525468,
0.0142989187,
0.0092670675,
0.0320164524,
-0.0548422262,
0.019905176,
-0.0179799777,
-0.0105612259,
0.0079598958,
-0.0096267341,
0.0416851938,
-0.0336766206,
0.0143505121,
0.0355618149,
0.0069023087,
-0.0448664948,
-0.0074752681,
-0.0324611031,
-0.0323730893,
0.0177322812,
-0.0159141067,
0.029956473,
-0.0456170477,
0.0264330246,
-0.0218190644,
-0.0245062765,
-0.0150435055,
-0.0585772619,
3.029e-7,
-0.024700325,
0.0705911145,
0.0041722185,
-0.005581676,
-0.0323910229,
0.0761178136,
-0.0257961247,
0.0069201807,
0.0096250949,
0.0168466885,
0.0647241399,
0.017231511,
0.0208695158,
-0.0043541426,
-0.0688052252,
-0.0177678335,
-0.0800567418,
0.0096063279,
-0.0397250205,
-0.0389902145,
0.0297943261,
0.0713659301,
0.0469767973,
-0.0330441408,
0.0094970297,
0.0234965235,
0.0433215648,
-0.0416558906,
-0.0090056444,
0.0144880014,
0.0108251842,
-0.0349682085,
-0.0268393885,
-0.0499461628,
-0.0055010077,
0.0377890058,
-0.0124800829,
0.0618798435,
0.0130121484,
-0.0502434038,
-0.001351335,
0.0284160953,
-0.0040873047,
-0.0531418324,
0.0605534315,
-0.0093305307,
-0.0199936889,
-0.0055187587,
0.0244474467,
-0.0289771911,
0.0317734256,
-0.0481667668,
-0.0335465074,
0.0000451507,
0.0069785928,
0.035900414,
0.0308790673,
-0.0363428295,
-0.0019637486,
0.0718955696,
-0.0281712916,
0.0052807126,
-0.0506938025,
0.0442739986,
-0.0173655059,
-0.0669086128,
-0.0076623922,
2.642477322e-34,
0.013941776,
-0.0318282284,
0.0170393717,
-0.007548871,
0.0163404848,
0.0187844839,
0.0039273277,
0.0517944619,
0.084914647,
-0.0427398607,
-0.010829377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00608v1 | Efficient Personalized Text-to-image Generation by Leveraging Textual Subspace | 2024-06-30T06:41:21 | 2024-06-30T06:41:21 | Shian Du, Xiaotian Cheng, Qi Qian, Henglu Wei, Yi Xu, Xiangyang Ji | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Personalized text-to-image generation has attracted unprecedented attention
in the recent few years due to its unique capability of generating
highly-personalized images via using the input concept dataset and novel
textual prompt. However, previous methods solely focus on the performance of
the reconstruction task, degrading its ability to combine with different
textual prompt. Besides, optimizing in the high-dimensional embedding space
usually leads to unnecessary time-consuming training process and slow
convergence. To address these issues, we propose an efficient method to explore
the target embedding in a textual subspace, drawing inspiration from the
self-expressiveness property. Additionally, we propose an efficient selection
strategy for determining the basis vectors of the textual subspace. The
experimental evaluations demonstrate that the learned embedding can not only
faithfully reconstruct input image, but also significantly improves its
alignment with novel input textual prompt. Furthermore, we observe that
optimizing in the textual subspace leads to an significant improvement of the
robustness to the initial word, relaxing the constraint that requires users to
input the most relevant initial word. Our method opens the door to more
efficient representation learning for personalized text-to-image generation. | Efficient Personalized Text-to-image Generation by Leveraging Textual Subspace: Personalized text-to-image generation has attracted unprecedented attention
in the recent few years due to its unique capability of generating
highly-personalized images via using the input concept dataset and novel
textual prompt. However, previous methods solely focus on the performance of
the reconstruction task, degrading its ability to combine with different
textual prompt. Besides, optimizing in the high-dimensional embedding space
usually leads to unnecessary time-consuming training process and slow
convergence. To address these issues, we propose an efficient method to explore
the target embedding in a textual subspace, drawing inspiration from the
self-expressiveness property. Additionally, we propose an efficient selection
strategy for determining the basis vectors of the textual subspace. The
experimental evaluations demonstrate that the learned embedding can not only
faithfully reconstruct input image, but also significantly improves its
alignment with novel input textual prompt. Furthermore, we observe that
optimizing in the textual subspace leads to an significant improvement of the
robustness to the initial word, relaxing the constraint that requires users to
input the most relevant initial word. Our method opens the door to more
efficient representation learning for personalized text-to-image generation. | [
0.0165975243,
0.0506762452,
0.0188895538,
0.0436721854,
0.0016736948,
-0.0156510994,
0.0286403,
0.0067017335,
-0.0189325884,
-0.007061901,
-0.0294770207,
-0.0015511663,
-0.0049390271,
0.0349535458,
0.0558372252,
-0.0818583071,
-0.0278793294,
0.00576984,
-0.050922025,
-0.0280182436,
0.0135579975,
0.0064750942,
0.0052847164,
0.0237368401,
-0.0602033399,
-0.0181517377,
-0.0088734208,
0.0272990968,
0.0289339833,
-0.0261131898,
-0.0340641476,
0.0436198004,
0.0613916032,
0.0084347427,
0.0000021616,
0.0012059453,
-0.0171748493,
-0.0060702558,
0.0091527849,
0.0061460077,
0.0802082494,
-0.0082231201,
-0.0110000325,
-0.0244305376,
-0.0206105281,
0.0109999701,
0.0672058389,
0.0870052353,
0.0880171657,
0.0449687205,
-0.0172701199,
-0.0065122354,
-0.0504443683,
-0.0567105822,
0.0422980785,
0.0054015173,
-0.0179743208,
-0.0516529158,
-0.0281514041,
0.0432855487,
-0.0302955993,
0.0333327428,
0.0174354073,
-0.0219491869,
0.0735320076,
0.0600383617,
0.0298680179,
-0.0025878749,
-0.0099319275,
0.0824133307,
0.0009884589,
0.017807208,
-0.0277889259,
-0.0185771529,
0.0136765335,
0.0020187392,
-0.0148483217,
-0.0149241332,
0.020288825,
0.0142241502,
-0.0661262348,
0.0650631934,
-0.0111124869,
-0.0005705107,
-0.0165505484,
-0.0103712352,
0.0281614345,
-0.0045674662,
-0.0585387424,
0.0170788001,
-0.0602480806,
-0.0020695878,
0.0282879304,
0.0019491464,
0.0117677841,
0.0055302456,
-0.0721875355,
-0.0488281623,
-0.0177769698,
0.0085927481,
0.0939609706,
0.011487551,
0.0104955509,
0.0195529219,
-0.0211410392,
0.0363134332,
-0.0211547259,
0.0227846112,
-0.0586498156,
0.0187770948,
-0.0338816009,
-0.013018813,
-0.0435694754,
0.0170122795,
-0.0031025705,
-0.0375463404,
-0.0498998724,
0.0452533066,
-0.0186634641,
0.0356044918,
-0.0326128639,
0.0747275949,
-0.0845540538,
0.0034009786,
-0.0375049897,
-0.0382992812,
-0.0438682511,
-0.0083651766,
-0.0007014925,
0.0248830039,
0.0044390671,
0.0292042196,
0.0527360141,
-0.0130968187,
-0.01710332,
0.0479319915,
-0.0546536781,
-0.0401412733,
-0.0096346829,
-0.0298076142,
-0.0548796579,
-0.0278108772,
0.0239926446,
-0.0170829538,
0.0514927022,
-0.0400641784,
-0.022834152,
-0.0629371107,
-0.0075414423,
-0.0012088707,
0.0225873441,
0.0848205611,
-0.0111456597,
-0.0314903259,
0.0425716937,
0.0214642473,
-0.0182693619,
0.0110321799,
0.0184533708,
0.1073142663,
0.0205159541,
-0.010866629,
-0.01643176,
0.0044128047,
0.0257461835,
-0.0036870628,
-0.0318302475,
0.0028449025,
0.0004263849,
0.056686718,
0.0394198038,
0.032282494,
-0.0280814525,
-0.0137241269,
0.0749076083,
0.0512044802,
0.0233201478,
0.0581000485,
0.0256600417,
0.0588714443,
-0.0234396812,
0.0061642621,
-0.0080527924,
0.0679500848,
0.0266785063,
0.0055133696,
0.0352596417,
0.0291218851,
-0.0442933813,
-0.0283453688,
0.0360429473,
-0.0216631312,
-0.0083703557,
-0.0363606699,
0.0190250017,
0.0310379528,
-0.0564081594,
0.02137837,
-0.0063102073,
-0.0720178112,
0.0120468009,
0.0007347423,
0.0543116778,
0.075480409,
0.0220128316,
-0.0088803414,
0.0281874165,
0.0053676455,
-0.0038611512,
0.0680028424,
-0.0210359078,
0.0026861439,
0.0278019123,
-0.0527090617,
-0.0388950184,
-0.0295489356,
-0.027816955,
0.0348307006,
0.0009940873,
0.016581716,
0.0220669694,
0.0084993858,
0.0082979035,
0.0494264029,
0.0299178399,
-0.05383211,
0.0466326214,
0.0658268407,
-0.0049799355,
-0.0118298363,
-0.0068595354,
0.0052450392,
0.027909575,
-0.0564240292,
-0.0353035815,
0.005692123,
-0.0541842729,
-0.0454672761,
-0.0276448149,
-0.0730233043,
-0.0186107531,
0.0090139089,
-0.0094107362,
-0.0496079512,
0.005968241,
-0.0510124043,
-0.0162670091,
-0.0536504798,
-0.0307541881,
0.0245416723,
0.0195679236,
-0.0270919558,
0.0303427279,
-0.0276593808,
-0.0211106334,
0.0211887863,
0.0489601754,
-0.0117666572,
-0.0290264059,
-0.0427360237,
-0.0470466986,
0.0153139848,
0.0296041444,
0.0141093135,
0.0158367679,
-0.0213291161,
-0.0444361269,
-0.0315946043,
-0.024648929,
0.0076917247,
-0.0396852568,
-0.0026432408,
0.0049086567,
0.0354805626,
-0.0380537808,
-0.0452925637,
0.0158491135,
-0.0134082371,
0.0006692362,
0.0715884119,
0.0143357869,
0.0340581462,
-0.0311053917,
0.0101464083,
0.0404836982,
0.0611503795,
0.0200858563,
0.0290484969,
-0.0430216789,
-0.0023576582,
-0.0140092475,
0.0134989079,
-0.0076101432,
-0.0459076688,
0.0196437221,
-0.0122537203,
0.0279765241,
0.0647003427,
0.0374014191,
0.0307816733,
0.0184712075,
0.0293815136,
-0.0265096445,
-0.0039497046,
-0.0364802033,
0.0318668671,
0.0663610399,
-0.0072566038,
0.0394280888,
0.0208626669,
0.0151004661,
0.0056557846,
-0.0830830559,
0.028512042,
0.0186775792,
-0.0338230841,
-0.085022904,
0.0395572223,
-0.0117653012,
-0.0068452759,
-0.0360555314,
-0.0824456289,
0.0412760712,
-0.0361740179,
0.0029920775,
0.0294080526,
0.0128122596,
0.0032228469,
0.0330587551,
0.0122692222,
0.0544614717,
0.0175999869,
0.0266184863,
-0.0448156148,
0.0332935676,
0.0261198562,
0.0082753273,
0.0360791124,
0.028420439,
0.0003030151,
-0.0064041996,
-0.063306354,
-0.0518367626,
-0.0594141074,
0.0685621053,
-0.0712284669,
0.0176273286,
-0.0205465369,
-0.0157438051,
-0.0251204446,
0.0065646195,
-0.0035997548,
-0.0246998053,
-0.0384774208,
-0.0322600231,
0.0449307971,
0.0247956645,
0.0113293091,
-0.0470887013,
0.0050416226,
0.0087641869,
0.06037727,
0.0031678833,
-0.0005079762,
-0.0266379137,
0.0293324683,
-0.0101754237,
0.0387758575,
0.0049996148,
0.0383471064,
0.0249186531,
-0.0069942451,
-0.0364653915,
0.0641269609,
0.0163237918,
-0.0207534973,
-0.0281392112,
0.0316006802,
0.039459344,
0.0086616687,
0.0415301472,
-0.0549808815,
-0.0261853039,
-0.0385436304,
0.0153827956,
0.0057040802,
0.0098432042,
-0.0474439412,
-0.0715837628,
0.0385725871,
0.0216415245,
-0.0235031936,
-0.0281539261,
0.0005098457,
-0.0009806436,
0.0143190781,
-0.0263233017,
0.0183424763,
0.0046706805,
0.0179013424,
-0.012538421,
-0.0022181096,
-0.0114139402,
-0.0182344858,
-0.0215828791,
-0.0071306895,
0.0443490222,
0.0567251444,
0.0340525843,
-0.049636215,
-0.0573523082,
0.0362745561,
0.0021859407,
0.0135762077,
0.0961242467,
-0.0047144513,
-0.0138289286,
-0.0260576438,
0.0536342338,
-0.0106159933,
-0.0004396502,
0.0016950709,
0.050439842,
0.0031814482,
0.0446154103,
-0.0424322672,
0.0132109961,
0.0300927069,
0.0272345282,
0.0183170587,
-0.0810003877,
-0.0282113701,
-0.0234558545,
0.0351236872,
-0.0665481612,
-0.04306015,
0.0353376828,
-0.0010951556,
-0.0321421139,
-0.0828444883,
-0.0065542595,
0.0374918915,
0.0733846724,
-0.0094585698,
-0.0177934095,
-0.0458723381,
-0.0219817255,
-0.0425745919,
0.0117576597,
-0.0446849167,
-0.0033877494,
-0.0440322906,
-0.0025843314,
0.0143785756,
-0.0631057993,
-0.0028194829,
0.0114314342,
-0.0401623175,
-0.0156621151,
-0.030812446,
0.0560276844,
-0.0020959261,
0.0388210118,
0.0123254908,
-0.027922662,
0.0928873941,
0.0244636498,
-0.0045018275,
-0.0169831458,
0.0092827007,
0.0438357294,
-0.0158657003,
0.029666258,
-0.0069088871,
0.0267481189,
-0.0002930697,
-0.0335267335,
0.0241497885,
-0.0435641669,
0.0167363416,
-0.0213804394,
0.0011223716,
-0.0604771115,
-0.0058652968,
-0.0314703919,
-0.0105169881,
-0.0253588315,
-0.0275839008,
-0.0557997152,
-0.0313146859,
-0.0002235291,
-0.0085371751,
-0.0021092286,
-0.057229206,
0.0025707879,
0.0582126305,
-0.0458231792,
-0.0345008634,
0.0192282405,
0.0151474178,
0.0083258627,
0.0377841294,
-0.0076702931,
0.0339117683,
-0.0345033407,
-0.0008949359,
-0.0131638804,
0.0395763144,
0.0010067029,
-0.0050409716,
-0.0569833666,
0.0431100242,
-0.0288406499,
0.0299505275,
-0.0617535114,
0.0175965019,
0.025327323,
0.010709675,
0.0220536552,
-0.0086802589,
-0.015450458,
0.0001253363,
0.0540216155,
0.0013735958,
-0.0566257946,
0.0511521585,
-0.0217657983,
0.0094785839,
-0.0325895622,
0.0453298762,
-0.0113330837,
-0.0091678649,
-0.0080306483,
0.0072641559,
-0.0754828379,
0.0163406711,
0.0303538144,
0.0178875327,
0.0123462845,
0.0232660696,
-0.01047072,
-0.0349087343,
0.0680940524,
0.0221900064,
-0.0375283919,
0.0270885006,
0.0632164106,
0.0153442193,
-0.0061746589,
0.0086560398,
0.0046478985,
0.0234732535,
0.0043750713,
-0.029566912,
-0.0054767253,
-6.019651469e-33,
-0.0398722813,
-0.0609060079,
-0.01501974,
-0.0358994789,
0.0014427903,
-0.002847376,
-0.0139020253,
0.0261908881,
0.0520433933,
0.0023261658,
-0.0229701828,
-0.0627444983,
0.0016749377,
0.0713970736,
-0.0278532449,
0.0453488342,
0.0423926152,
-0.0049032145,
-0.0320595875,
0.0458899811,
0.0673747957,
0.0273343194,
0.0079126069,
-0.0589087307,
-0.0104711717,
-0.018153429,
-0.0275723208,
-0.0312215649,
0.0450591184,
0.0287715439,
-0.032381285,
0.017563818,
-0.0060246885,
-0.036763005,
-0.0112238219,
0.028014442,
-0.0400585756,
-0.0492433347,
-0.0622905865,
-0.0093524633,
-0.0979132056,
-0.0547284111,
0.0238878354,
-0.0577243529,
-0.0073362119,
-0.0326483287,
0.0393877476,
-0.0092661157,
-0.0073453877,
0.0219979323,
-0.0715516284,
-0.0100860847,
-0.0289703682,
-0.0387976393,
0.0272623096,
-0.0041668778,
0.0352850594,
0.0083646681,
-0.0757648274,
0.034160208,
0.0016177174,
0.0097344127,
0.0271413866,
0.0235566255,
-0.0028460508,
0.0397220217,
0.0338384882,
-0.0346844904,
-0.0031496019,
-0.0095165148,
-0.0052293069,
0.0604659468,
0.0617457367,
0.1094444543,
0.0247073453,
-0.0328473784,
-0.0089548398,
0.0869404003,
-0.003700352,
-0.0445716716,
0.057232786,
0.0145949014,
-0.0071454835,
-0.0123358909,
-0.0247375239,
-0.0454552881,
-0.0227536112,
-0.0343796872,
0.0258478317,
0.0396529436,
-0.0521049239,
-0.0424767695,
0.0434160382,
0.0088955695,
-0.006140769,
-0.018228244,
-0.0655431002,
0.0474149771,
-0.0042729159,
-0.0023869511,
-0.0187477358,
-0.0366190039,
0.0744524896,
-0.0125955977,
-0.0119644208,
0.0090230806,
0.0228106547,
0.0177684426,
-0.0458402634,
-0.0034407938,
-0.0455931164,
0.0117077501,
0.0035859931,
-0.0054012006,
0.0240511335,
-0.0344877541,
-0.0560630746,
0.0249781162,
-0.0088314526,
0.0217489153,
-0.0116097387,
-0.0592454486,
0.0132342894,
-0.0132226609,
-0.0081575662,
0.0497873463,
-0.023972407,
0.0112043843,
0.0465932153,
-0.0635058954,
-0.0025244202,
-0.0230217278,
2.749e-7,
0.0071606664,
0.0039133579,
0.021880459,
-0.0124452421,
-0.0004048683,
0.0760150254,
-0.0273621622,
0.0568571649,
-0.0238176864,
-0.0042481204,
0.024029009,
0.0316042639,
0.0421170592,
-0.0152297467,
-0.0337606445,
0.0369860306,
-0.0417420529,
0.0605284534,
-0.0056887656,
0.0030406353,
0.0666978508,
0.0843392462,
0.008724899,
-0.0200849045,
0.0442080237,
0.0079751387,
0.1128598154,
-0.0552441217,
0.0059851836,
-0.0303318501,
0.0048799822,
-0.0008689761,
-0.0427859426,
-0.0388331451,
-0.019448353,
0.0099935299,
0.0451023094,
0.0479438193,
-0.0072581088,
-0.0165140796,
0.0175783187,
0.0496946909,
0.0060024471,
-0.006054949,
0.0651290566,
-0.0827537104,
-0.0526998341,
-0.0191178489,
0.0153178647,
0.0258994605,
0.0579941086,
-0.0463211462,
-0.0593385138,
0.0104512461,
0.0541626476,
0.0039083678,
0.0025889566,
-0.0743153766,
-0.0156356506,
-0.0382492021,
-0.0700197816,
0.0427431278,
-0.0840385631,
0.0124557195,
0.0526323691,
-0.0350641347,
0.0063069281,
2.28339594e-34,
-0.0429547876,
0.017535314,
0.0182499364,
-0.0405864567,
0.018965276,
0.0002345143,
0.0246952809,
-0.0151776066,
0.0268260092,
-0.0578490198,
-0.0366441235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00581v1 | MasonTigers at SemEval-2024 Task 10: Emotion Discovery and Flip Reasoning in Conversation with Ensemble of Transformers and Prompting | 2024-06-30T03:59:04 | 2024-06-30T03:59:04 | Al Nahian Bin Emran, Amrita Ganguly, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present MasonTigers' participation in SemEval-2024 Task 10,
a shared task aimed at identifying emotions and understanding the rationale
behind their flips within monolingual English and Hindi-English code-mixed
dialogues. This task comprises three distinct subtasks - emotion recognition in
conversation for Hindi-English code-mixed dialogues, emotion flip reasoning for
Hindi-English code-mixed dialogues, and emotion flip reasoning for English
dialogues. Our team, MasonTigers, contributed to each subtask, focusing on
developing methods for accurate emotion recognition and reasoning. By
leveraging our approaches, we attained impressive F1-scores of 0.78 for the
first task and 0.79 for both the second and third tasks. This performance not
only underscores the effectiveness of our methods across different aspects of
the task but also secured us the top rank in the first and third subtasks, and
the 2nd rank in the second subtask. Through extensive experimentation and
analysis, we provide insights into our system's performance and contributions
to each subtask. | MasonTigers at SemEval-2024 Task 10: Emotion Discovery and Flip Reasoning in Conversation with Ensemble of Transformers and Prompting: In this paper, we present MasonTigers' participation in SemEval-2024 Task 10,
a shared task aimed at identifying emotions and understanding the rationale
behind their flips within monolingual English and Hindi-English code-mixed
dialogues. This task comprises three distinct subtasks - emotion recognition in
conversation for Hindi-English code-mixed dialogues, emotion flip reasoning for
Hindi-English code-mixed dialogues, and emotion flip reasoning for English
dialogues. Our team, MasonTigers, contributed to each subtask, focusing on
developing methods for accurate emotion recognition and reasoning. By
leveraging our approaches, we attained impressive F1-scores of 0.78 for the
first task and 0.79 for both the second and third tasks. This performance not
only underscores the effectiveness of our methods across different aspects of
the task but also secured us the top rank in the first and third subtasks, and
the 2nd rank in the second subtask. Through extensive experimentation and
analysis, we provide insights into our system's performance and contributions
to each subtask. | [
0.0262133405,
0.0593352988,
-0.0153450249,
0.0599774271,
-0.0249824803,
0.0433906764,
-0.0040822709,
-0.0213311054,
0.0355503038,
-0.0112439198,
-0.0607484281,
-0.0052428278,
-0.0222752709,
0.0533668026,
-0.0290316027,
-0.0644170567,
0.028881466,
0.0196878668,
0.0230197497,
-0.0080436226,
0.0225000083,
0.0480680615,
-0.0819179267,
0.0235954355,
-0.0488308258,
-0.0078560896,
-0.0200994723,
0.0105864089,
0.0576810353,
-0.0056832987,
0.0258647855,
0.0450036973,
-0.0129466886,
0.0157913156,
0.0000018769,
-0.0337294452,
-0.0174684413,
-0.0280885305,
-0.0377701558,
-0.0703149736,
0.0439183936,
0.0342505015,
-0.0251694079,
0.0120590627,
-0.0551914014,
0.0046833823,
0.0558443144,
0.0734288543,
0.086764589,
0.0848065168,
-0.0321907811,
-0.0105729103,
-0.0213946961,
-0.0052615353,
-0.0228013918,
-0.0224474184,
-0.0104225138,
-0.0080520604,
0.0096678669,
-0.0465192199,
-0.0401966907,
-0.0007806031,
0.0328469239,
-0.0353304371,
-0.0494664088,
0.0090736356,
-0.0422673002,
-0.0246861856,
-0.0135529675,
0.0574351177,
0.0214941483,
0.0217424482,
-0.0017853581,
0.0315421522,
-0.026956765,
-0.0360867195,
-0.0257715955,
0.0144157549,
-0.0357108787,
0.0260297954,
0.0031808626,
0.0423049629,
-0.0126512507,
0.0242493004,
-0.0052565378,
0.0897990838,
-0.0262520462,
0.0048710974,
0.01232443,
0.0188091099,
0.0217879135,
-0.0206714682,
0.044641342,
0.0317567512,
-0.0402872302,
0.0307719111,
0.0101619363,
-0.052759584,
-0.0308420788,
-0.0489970371,
-0.0551253706,
0.0439184047,
-0.0434636474,
0.0579709597,
0.006465354,
0.0433285125,
-0.0150735276,
0.0412941352,
-0.0260459613,
-0.029156182,
-0.0428464152,
0.0104923695,
-0.013428377,
0.020373743,
-0.05039059,
-0.0107532544,
-0.0597790889,
-0.0143923033,
-0.0189264212,
-0.0109154591,
0.0349439085,
0.0140654808,
0.0067432397,
-0.0147269685,
0.0272759013,
0.0481133722,
-0.0545349866,
0.0057495646,
0.0183573179,
-0.0913276151,
-0.0116636492,
0.0331355408,
-0.0231217649,
-0.0342711359,
-0.0001154673,
0.0326946303,
-0.0440092869,
-0.0183691084,
-0.0323950537,
-0.0061708456,
-0.0368218981,
-0.0851010382,
0.0021095178,
-0.0287028961,
0.0473701954,
0.018540578,
0.0178633723,
-0.006751522,
0.0344651714,
-0.0235719178,
0.0146132112,
0.0773721114,
0.0261439271,
-0.0084967529,
0.0013693832,
0.0377526432,
-0.0369792096,
0.0601535775,
0.0248961747,
0.0660487637,
0.0346691422,
-0.0057742419,
0.0369386189,
0.0105617326,
-0.0320137478,
-0.023983812,
0.0054312618,
-0.0235555414,
-0.0230497029,
0.0259032119,
0.0171204936,
0.0458211005,
-0.0391264856,
-0.0033480278,
0.0383378044,
0.0424443372,
-0.0244910102,
0.0344731696,
-0.0212337468,
-0.018363798,
0.0096922629,
-0.0111078722,
-0.026106514,
0.0774202123,
-0.0164921023,
-0.0508919619,
-0.0171047505,
0.0139075182,
-0.0195869058,
-0.0360054672,
0.0031099648,
-0.0165447425,
0.0100699514,
0.0060186125,
0.0568363331,
0.0037638221,
-0.0270945672,
0.009592264,
-0.0026692257,
-0.1051285639,
-0.0011052547,
-0.0620452687,
-0.0144757507,
0.0531135313,
0.0274255667,
-0.0178474262,
-0.056766618,
-0.0040112389,
-0.0004514918,
0.0450822376,
0.0053776144,
-0.0167686511,
0.0346389115,
-0.0601790547,
0.0344442055,
0.0202338658,
-0.0072533083,
-0.0027059794,
-0.0065783975,
0.0220654365,
-0.012488124,
-0.0082837902,
0.0499733016,
0.0163987372,
-0.0315189548,
0.0170684364,
-0.0029286202,
0.0414450467,
0.0369644053,
0.0079855965,
0.0053490582,
-0.02078286,
0.0289310664,
-0.024639545,
-0.0372223817,
0.0870532542,
-0.0296636503,
-0.0771349892,
0.031581033,
-0.0631346256,
-0.0341240019,
0.0597812347,
-0.0359387286,
-0.0426333919,
0.0479441918,
-0.0165465754,
0.0375477374,
-0.0553014614,
0.0131870015,
0.0067811762,
0.0245814938,
0.0008589878,
0.0447728857,
-0.0024589491,
-0.0196243357,
-0.0219493937,
-0.0269295704,
0.0406288244,
-0.0178470183,
-0.0352004133,
0.0509953201,
0.003517861,
-0.0217140205,
-0.0107863182,
-0.0162398331,
-0.0809092596,
-0.0511715673,
-0.09160541,
0.010898863,
-0.0119812898,
0.012319454,
0.0020401743,
0.0111802407,
-0.0265860204,
-0.0296963006,
-0.031313017,
-0.0003306504,
0.0518493876,
0.0043522893,
0.0049538552,
-0.0043712324,
0.0126245776,
-0.0277908389,
0.0103347329,
-0.0570209883,
0.0471956246,
-0.004752019,
-0.0232284255,
-0.0212731473,
0.0033460497,
-0.0274292193,
0.0039325305,
-0.0356731676,
-0.0803550184,
0.0283627119,
-0.0114213154,
0.0373007171,
0.0708264485,
0.0237096958,
0.0763484165,
-0.0344381779,
-0.0141906701,
-0.0266999975,
0.0391888097,
-0.0117578609,
0.0284777004,
-0.0296873786,
-0.0245363005,
-0.0290469062,
0.0503671132,
-0.0305061415,
0.0073759081,
-0.056820374,
-0.0302272998,
0.0056333588,
-0.0230365153,
0.0127445459,
-0.0465041846,
-0.0114720389,
0.0378298983,
-0.0063256067,
-0.0376051664,
0.0732406825,
-0.0053447643,
-0.0618286245,
-0.0890013427,
0.0017838788,
-0.0439746864,
0.1004577279,
-0.0849462301,
0.0142237898,
0.0005431518,
-0.0281657036,
-0.0352483653,
-0.0163811184,
0.001497129,
-0.0592974015,
0.0388388149,
-0.0182782393,
-0.0225536563,
0.0072131264,
-0.0491033718,
-0.0510008298,
-0.0252409372,
-0.063402921,
-0.0121538211,
0.0377716422,
-0.0393434651,
-0.0180814266,
0.0174165051,
0.0158420727,
-0.0550651588,
-0.0204681698,
-0.0106517831,
0.0144687174,
0.0016276881,
0.0552033857,
0.014961984,
0.0511028431,
-0.0137272729,
0.0579286329,
0.0523628257,
0.0638600811,
-0.0195960999,
-0.0272247829,
0.0222669914,
0.0258394964,
0.0206288137,
0.0209405832,
-0.0500450097,
0.0288092047,
-0.0108871749,
0.0107889054,
0.1042860225,
0.0354377665,
-0.0773634762,
-0.019980384,
-0.054488115,
0.0078782737,
0.0222618524,
0.035856124,
-0.041963283,
-0.032900203,
0.0172513258,
0.0153054819,
0.0138974991,
-0.0431219898,
-0.0122431172,
-0.0985573679,
0.0401798859,
-0.006688077,
-0.0102123767,
-0.0295381323,
-0.0068730824,
0.0089984993,
-0.0468933769,
-0.0011262591,
-0.0261613224,
0.0185715556,
-0.0083635123,
0.0449730605,
0.0193030741,
-0.0001151617,
0.0365088247,
-0.0301550943,
0.0300092679,
0.0449428558,
0.0513886698,
0.0165906027,
-0.0572931692,
-0.0002641334,
0.0010090336,
-0.0106151048,
-0.0136962011,
0.0677882284,
-0.0384582393,
-0.0380416363,
-0.0394422188,
0.0326462947,
-0.0397651196,
-0.0146406665,
-0.0270075537,
0.0888102725,
-0.0401265621,
-0.0271614548,
-0.0057614613,
0.0339165293,
0.0316389017,
0.0518792011,
0.0316880867,
-0.0254309438,
-0.0122294575,
-0.0135375783,
0.054523956,
-0.0239444915,
-0.0217742473,
0.0092731919,
0.0500606373,
-0.0527401231,
-0.0345916748,
-0.0499614887,
0.0357319415,
0.0622366741,
-0.0308446418,
-0.0338815786,
-0.0320788659,
0.0339314193,
-0.0325259455,
0.016537521,
-0.0005427495,
0.0424492247,
-0.0508547835,
0.006509691,
0.0215167589,
-0.0166911632,
-0.0122746732,
0.0049246172,
-0.0416657403,
-0.0437326767,
0.0490943901,
0.0496521778,
0.026894493,
0.0246375706,
-0.012103756,
-0.0290033445,
-0.0281246733,
0.0325500444,
-0.0009239262,
-0.0137264654,
0.0626786873,
0.005493422,
-0.0323456079,
0.024138622,
-0.0149181541,
0.0308870394,
-0.0096319346,
0.0439233258,
-0.0195383504,
-0.0333066434,
0.0192434806,
0.0151751162,
0.0486767292,
-0.0099454904,
-0.0031445492,
-0.0434414744,
0.011670744,
0.0257010404,
-0.0114423186,
-0.0312613994,
-0.0093497764,
0.0057712304,
0.0094932662,
-0.0343144089,
-0.0169214308,
-0.0061797388,
-0.0010088319,
0.0472728685,
0.0822053626,
0.0659456104,
0.0167505573,
-0.0132214753,
0.0186614916,
-0.0041457056,
0.0209844466,
0.0423037969,
0.0477001294,
-0.0030444132,
0.0856299996,
0.0448897332,
-0.0284459554,
0.0347021483,
0.0380117819,
-0.0167366657,
0.0016255577,
0.0090370327,
-0.0189018901,
0.0341809355,
-0.0057107094,
0.0283114705,
-0.0324914902,
0.0384678468,
0.0049905246,
0.0228482615,
-0.0169299487,
-0.034437228,
0.016503023,
0.0146813337,
-0.0015548141,
0.000335054,
0.0233887769,
-0.1166895479,
0.0342134498,
0.0353759937,
-0.0128167598,
-0.0335019641,
-0.0263886265,
0.0191089101,
-0.0427531227,
0.0277482495,
0.0129994471,
-0.0723163858,
-0.0577320084,
0.052631408,
-0.0326777734,
0.0049180747,
-0.030165052,
0.0215258021,
0.0587806106,
0.0132390726,
0.0187173095,
-0.0267010983,
0.0062309708,
-0.0458901003,
-0.0056698741,
-0.008118921,
-5.646794212e-33,
-0.0077406983,
-0.0255423374,
-0.0204235408,
-0.0034891553,
-0.0409858301,
0.0007198586,
-0.0544010624,
0.0095112715,
-0.034243945,
0.0692055002,
-0.0340431109,
0.0397874489,
0.0217229463,
-0.009763035,
0.0164849646,
-0.0477169752,
0.0149675291,
0.0202545077,
-0.003780334,
0.0275679976,
0.0563068241,
0.0434999987,
0.0905610695,
-0.0549226105,
-0.0207001604,
-0.0094713429,
-0.0509004965,
0.0686508864,
-0.00410021,
0.0548903085,
-0.0171410087,
0.0208308473,
0.0138150398,
-0.0426193886,
0.031689167,
0.0233845562,
-0.0274729338,
-0.0087009836,
-0.0089826118,
0.0546107925,
-0.0324476175,
-0.0191938952,
-0.0198607631,
-0.0036420352,
0.0010810596,
0.0005596532,
0.01861329,
-0.0042305491,
0.0438797437,
-0.0261045769,
-0.0189280994,
0.0194615517,
-0.0499118082,
-0.0513814352,
0.0198582914,
0.0660158172,
0.0092278905,
0.0024157718,
-0.0340955853,
0.0343787484,
-0.0334087573,
-0.0150400568,
0.0469956957,
0.0027387731,
-0.0253160466,
0.0670049191,
0.0382952206,
-0.0030077375,
-0.0396705084,
0.0021093031,
0.0168159362,
0.0537895262,
0.0597410202,
0.0572003238,
0.0059811524,
-0.0093508689,
-0.0062885801,
0.0219917912,
0.073751308,
0.047535304,
0.0152355144,
0.0050563826,
-0.0359270908,
-0.0073328023,
0.0050573987,
-0.0240628459,
-0.0208651442,
-0.0500462167,
0.0251931921,
-0.0136069274,
-0.0088465149,
0.0030292915,
0.0389158428,
-0.0508873649,
0.034341272,
0.0437312089,
-0.0074137133,
0.0527228452,
0.0014111265,
0.0436269194,
-0.0139978807,
-0.0091146491,
0.0475886725,
0.0384745747,
0.0597034991,
-0.0101904571,
0.040504761,
0.021430755,
-0.0323454328,
-0.0101792486,
-0.0366391353,
0.063646242,
-0.0558276512,
0.0229642391,
-0.0241056159,
0.0351236686,
-0.0376012921,
-0.0150011154,
0.0020803437,
0.0615736917,
-0.0267844722,
0.0029186644,
0.0020721378,
-0.0060532209,
-0.0137660895,
-0.0107237846,
-0.0241126511,
-0.046987284,
-0.0278472193,
-0.0482721291,
0.0004906008,
0.0216302462,
2.693e-7,
0.0156236496,
0.0275728386,
0.048452355,
-0.0369962901,
-0.0034323593,
0.0219325256,
-0.034569107,
-0.0249265805,
0.0524063446,
-0.0140787195,
0.0200679358,
0.0349467322,
0.0933629423,
0.0481886677,
-0.1307428777,
-0.0400370695,
-0.0623741411,
-0.0350238681,
-0.0081519289,
0.026089482,
0.0883642957,
0.0637847632,
0.0396301225,
0.0073251496,
0.0035885875,
0.0453560837,
0.0223645549,
-0.012738199,
0.038112469,
0.0242755711,
-0.0291374698,
-0.0631057397,
-0.0150981825,
-0.0053237369,
0.0196486227,
-0.0104376273,
0.0031817197,
0.0269388929,
-0.0191446412,
-0.0838070363,
0.0013129135,
0.0378994085,
-0.0041289809,
-0.0372656211,
0.0338742025,
-0.0180373564,
-0.0425167307,
-0.0334298983,
-0.0460287221,
-0.0126797501,
0.0117176119,
0.006751474,
-0.0283014383,
0.0394798294,
0.0059250928,
-0.0502898283,
-0.0084736897,
-0.1025087535,
0.0054669217,
-0.0086700022,
-0.0409674905,
-0.022261234,
-0.0140151279,
0.0100610293,
0.0394494124,
-0.0144127188,
-0.0160906352,
1.892649335e-34,
0.0154675404,
0.0012643232,
0.0041325507,
0.0589850545,
0.0568624735,
-0.006887347,
-0.03069303,
-0.0082444949,
0.0368023179,
-0.0415300839,
-0.0121901594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00569v1 | Investigating and Mitigating the Multimodal Hallucination Snowballing in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-30T03:04:11 | 2024-06-30T03:04:11 | Weihong Zhong, Xiaocheng Feng, Liang Zhao, Qiming Li, Lei Huang, Yuxuan Gu, Weitao Ma, Yuan Xu, Bing Qin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Though advanced in understanding visual information with human languages,
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) still suffer from multimodal
hallucinations. A natural concern is that during multimodal interaction, the
generated hallucinations could influence the LVLMs' subsequent generation.
Thus, we raise a question: When presented with a query relevant to the
previously generated hallucination, will LVLMs be misled and respond
incorrectly, even though the ground visual information exists? To answer this,
we propose a framework called MMHalSnowball to evaluate LVLMs' behaviors when
encountering generated hallucinations, where LVLMs are required to answer
specific visual questions within a curated hallucinatory conversation.
Crucially, our experiment shows that the performance of open-source LVLMs drops
by at least $31\%$, indicating that LVLMs are prone to accept the generated
hallucinations and make false claims that they would not have supported without
distractions. We term this phenomenon Multimodal Hallucination Snowballing. To
mitigate this, we further propose a training-free method called Residual Visual
Decoding, where we revise the output distribution of LVLMs with the one derived
from the residual visual input, providing models with direct access to the
visual information. Experiments show that our method can mitigate more than
$24\%$ of the snowballed multimodal hallucination while maintaining
capabilities. | Investigating and Mitigating the Multimodal Hallucination Snowballing in Large Vision-Language Models: Though advanced in understanding visual information with human languages,
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) still suffer from multimodal
hallucinations. A natural concern is that during multimodal interaction, the
generated hallucinations could influence the LVLMs' subsequent generation.
Thus, we raise a question: When presented with a query relevant to the
previously generated hallucination, will LVLMs be misled and respond
incorrectly, even though the ground visual information exists? To answer this,
we propose a framework called MMHalSnowball to evaluate LVLMs' behaviors when
encountering generated hallucinations, where LVLMs are required to answer
specific visual questions within a curated hallucinatory conversation.
Crucially, our experiment shows that the performance of open-source LVLMs drops
by at least $31\%$, indicating that LVLMs are prone to accept the generated
hallucinations and make false claims that they would not have supported without
distractions. We term this phenomenon Multimodal Hallucination Snowballing. To
mitigate this, we further propose a training-free method called Residual Visual
Decoding, where we revise the output distribution of LVLMs with the one derived
from the residual visual input, providing models with direct access to the
visual information. Experiments show that our method can mitigate more than
$24\%$ of the snowballed multimodal hallucination while maintaining
capabilities. | [
0.0116151003,
0.0767369047,
-0.021216169,
0.0712781399,
-0.0306869261,
0.0190589931,
-0.0054392619,
0.0106748091,
-0.0068968516,
-0.0533920377,
-0.0448768735,
-0.0599536113,
0.0126348846,
-0.0014757409,
0.0341073982,
-0.0580342151,
0.0265453663,
-0.0623174459,
-0.0385555588,
-0.0122877033,
-0.0041493974,
-0.0200511813,
-0.0157411844,
0.0322056711,
-0.0192392934,
-0.0404499061,
-0.0161390454,
0.0112232482,
0.0059372932,
0.0208897814,
-0.0330268331,
0.0457992814,
0.0200173575,
0.0199334901,
0.0000019095,
-0.0356217474,
0.0404389016,
-0.0214013979,
0.0278343726,
0.0006689437,
0.0128021892,
-0.0388477929,
0.0174981728,
-0.0112614864,
-0.0287946146,
-0.0283398144,
0.0655820444,
0.069840394,
0.0566039123,
0.0249048229,
-0.0002791047,
-0.0273864642,
0.0098447045,
0.0262557622,
0.0566888154,
-0.0218907259,
0.0222447291,
0.0483124629,
-0.0186076071,
-0.0557472557,
-0.0719683394,
0.0401852839,
0.0364294909,
0.0096002296,
0.0011265371,
0.0227885917,
-0.0495331585,
-0.050547339,
-0.0208324175,
0.0676658377,
-0.0408916175,
-0.0283326693,
-0.0011283113,
0.0276303589,
0.035512995,
-0.0021210297,
-0.0434452407,
0.0558411181,
-0.0289686359,
-0.0090511721,
-0.042231556,
-0.0175397266,
0.0247358829,
-0.0096556051,
-0.0339435823,
0.0208059028,
0.0086419443,
0.0126657356,
0.0201153588,
-0.0137937246,
-0.0006035203,
-0.0623614863,
-0.0225307606,
0.0064748805,
-0.0631403178,
-0.0259877071,
-0.0440843366,
0.0050725001,
-0.001559824,
-0.0477643162,
0.0303191394,
0.0056462162,
-0.0822026357,
0.0461409315,
-0.0130172279,
0.0170531645,
-0.0400231555,
0.0656378418,
-0.0035891784,
-0.0178941581,
-0.0211363714,
-0.0053750197,
-0.0311388709,
-0.0167148151,
-0.0450598709,
-0.0525118634,
0.0157158412,
0.017641088,
-0.0458177365,
0.0167756621,
-0.0389203578,
0.0316638574,
0.0134340124,
-0.0399146602,
-0.0137983859,
0.0525994413,
0.0125643024,
-0.0122455172,
0.0001194498,
-0.1102115586,
-0.009854014,
0.0490462855,
-0.0242106169,
-0.0085727004,
-0.0261247773,
0.0653199181,
-0.0049311952,
-0.0088970587,
-0.0191954672,
-0.0142585803,
-0.0075900354,
-0.059254773,
0.0576206855,
-0.0389131345,
0.0292540994,
-0.0130041055,
0.0115759587,
-0.0188168865,
0.0265166834,
-0.0057830587,
-0.035155803,
0.1061166301,
-0.0076336018,
0.0030046029,
0.0101770824,
0.0351404771,
-0.007639905,
0.0817119107,
0.002806806,
0.0388937369,
-0.0010359517,
-0.0402274355,
0.0722353458,
0.0223055184,
-0.0075370362,
0.0035630746,
-0.0648698807,
0.0008147504,
0.0162400641,
0.0205887165,
0.0376307853,
0.0730615705,
-0.0481096171,
-0.0800252482,
0.070087634,
0.0079611447,
-0.0188625772,
-0.0283822455,
0.0400621779,
-0.0172706395,
-0.0103843426,
0.0360562541,
-0.0790731385,
0.0661489367,
-0.0219314266,
-0.0182376057,
0.0249221846,
0.0108175343,
-0.0419218242,
-0.0326456763,
0.0063294317,
-0.0027385096,
0.0071923248,
0.053189747,
0.0221821591,
0.0214289837,
-0.0319547392,
0.0063256565,
0.0103526758,
-0.0156922154,
0.0193819962,
-0.0495334268,
0.0055231894,
0.0709872767,
0.0502191819,
0.0074242852,
0.0101953372,
-0.0358357206,
0.0442323498,
0.0516711138,
0.0409895405,
0.0093219597,
0.0547622554,
-0.0430730619,
-0.0059140567,
-0.0018689879,
0.0270353183,
0.0045353756,
-0.0398524478,
-0.0479735769,
-0.0168118235,
-0.0100323185,
-0.0021813426,
0.0382070839,
0.0186295994,
0.0021749807,
-0.0344370678,
-0.0080766603,
0.0131217772,
-0.0205373634,
-0.0059405253,
0.022344457,
0.0157193467,
-0.0417819209,
-0.0217462555,
0.0218733922,
-0.0220895782,
-0.0032041881,
0.0251039378,
-0.0352913439,
0.0078387968,
-0.0147984866,
-0.0026509098,
0.0049355524,
0.0371911414,
-0.0256857425,
0.0330124944,
-0.0430339389,
0.0013532707,
0.0220547542,
0.0395954549,
-0.0058790455,
0.0557812601,
-0.0555232465,
-0.0117762508,
0.0266440697,
-0.0091597233,
-0.0103913015,
-0.0202408601,
-0.0137341795,
0.0233715661,
-0.0030319886,
0.0181279089,
-0.0319572203,
-0.0571688935,
-0.0574932322,
0.0033989376,
-0.0665621534,
-0.0303887613,
-0.0340081044,
-0.0479354374,
0.0065092891,
-0.0123507483,
-0.0027199772,
-0.0438069962,
-0.0111876223,
0.0581999235,
0.0071096872,
0.0420356803,
-0.0123040965,
0.0051859813,
-0.0120426351,
0.0101402048,
0.0038361955,
0.0166264195,
0.0709238872,
-0.0171625167,
-0.0523943938,
-0.063770704,
0.0130262803,
-0.0405590609,
0.0604422092,
-0.0221499726,
-0.0014251112,
0.010847846,
-0.031906195,
0.0401521213,
0.0949279517,
0.0198191628,
0.0373727903,
0.0610825382,
-0.0354723185,
-0.0198001862,
-0.021344671,
0.0115782917,
-0.0625805408,
-0.0277248397,
-0.02452562,
-0.0094812522,
0.0418975204,
0.0145051843,
0.0209610034,
-0.095899567,
0.0338530093,
0.0050241835,
-0.1107762009,
-0.021113554,
-0.0006009648,
-0.0037240097,
0.0493686236,
-0.0242683701,
-0.0775088966,
0.05429269,
-0.0188788865,
-0.0209399667,
0.0499984697,
0.0380329117,
0.0254024211,
0.0538606793,
0.0343551859,
0.0248069819,
-0.0067619383,
-0.0096829841,
-0.0611477382,
-0.0075331866,
-0.0305848252,
-0.0281762015,
0.0475231074,
-0.0603232197,
-0.0081062065,
-0.0124621224,
0.0007058266,
-0.05289362,
0.0027919454,
-0.0114238756,
-0.0422626249,
-0.0930483118,
0.0184272528,
-0.038599208,
0.0099556614,
0.0282628611,
-0.0189317465,
-0.0179795884,
-0.0223527458,
-0.0048109083,
-0.0062742168,
0.0734017342,
0.0427480042,
0.0192181841,
-0.0651152581,
0.0051600519,
0.101125747,
0.0384573974,
0.0403184891,
-0.0345354155,
0.0142512387,
0.0143094938,
0.0602286533,
0.0036728764,
0.0449535362,
0.0343176909,
-0.0552337319,
0.0016965246,
0.0566239394,
0.0291718431,
-0.0672363788,
-0.0010311923,
-0.0278268382,
0.0558279492,
0.0253211893,
-0.0046501444,
-0.1019090414,
-0.0286152232,
-0.0242619384,
-0.0256093908,
0.007083586,
-0.0117987841,
-0.0338169448,
-0.0767240301,
0.0553918518,
0.0335998349,
0.0265684221,
-0.0265071932,
0.0455918573,
-0.0052182213,
0.0139515586,
0.0240401383,
0.0089174472,
0.0076134494,
-0.0117611596,
-0.0104105305,
0.0081553506,
-0.0193785056,
0.0241399091,
-0.02820036,
0.0300913341,
0.0652302578,
-0.0161201395,
0.0141286841,
-0.0909520388,
0.0180790704,
-0.0259858724,
-0.0014793252,
-0.0013065458,
0.0626490042,
-0.0204545502,
-0.0182733294,
0.0337334424,
0.0222254191,
-0.0300628617,
-0.0264084935,
-0.0084404452,
0.0247223787,
-0.0510648079,
-0.0407337621,
-0.0162299629,
0.0367141105,
0.0054576043,
0.0603413992,
0.0398301594,
-0.0467056446,
-0.0427310616,
-0.0247765221,
0.0226980969,
-0.0326407254,
-0.0385836996,
0.0513373427,
0.1023935676,
-0.0382522047,
-0.0598670617,
-0.0353559591,
0.0238578133,
0.04205136,
-0.0130212912,
0.0055874391,
-0.0344190337,
-0.0081277564,
-0.0328721516,
0.0527779162,
-0.0261226967,
0.0100403251,
-0.0272955801,
0.0061703511,
0.0060188584,
-0.03312077,
0.0211742707,
0.0482787527,
-0.0837609023,
-0.044834543,
0.005997357,
0.0652504787,
0.0284981839,
0.0696648285,
0.010215261,
-0.0559580959,
-0.0060654464,
0.0390676931,
0.039507553,
0.0480710268,
-0.0036354829,
-0.0003580134,
0.0083130402,
0.0422704592,
-0.002103864,
-0.0045819334,
0.0313994661,
0.0175155234,
-0.0076605068,
0.0203808285,
0.0317576937,
-0.0149894208,
0.0159701519,
-0.0219143312,
0.0264288839,
0.0183155145,
-0.0123086581,
-0.0040788478,
-0.0023496929,
-0.054549057,
-0.0145713584,
0.0281244274,
-0.0052692592,
0.0288878046,
-0.0230999738,
-0.0044638296,
-0.0090309717,
-0.0306723751,
-0.0500151664,
0.0383333266,
-0.0432486571,
0.0233614407,
0.0101865856,
-0.0062983013,
0.0179007128,
0.0086154807,
0.0446519777,
0.0257576816,
0.0919421092,
0.0162249506,
-0.0232117288,
-0.0274046101,
0.0371805318,
-0.0217906293,
-0.0881659612,
0.0098386128,
0.0279326458,
0.039834477,
0.0419673696,
0.0344245955,
-0.0151737714,
0.0166953206,
-0.0449028611,
0.0509545356,
0.0431741923,
-0.0641313866,
0.0307018794,
0.0239984971,
-0.0340037793,
-0.0268122554,
0.0485714115,
-0.0164934825,
0.0164567865,
-0.0248971358,
0.00986466,
-0.0362173878,
-0.0681290999,
-0.0097199138,
-0.007842375,
-0.0226992555,
0.0254072733,
-0.056725096,
-0.0498990044,
-0.0446114466,
0.0307530742,
0.0266333017,
0.0025433039,
0.0388408229,
0.0540043637,
0.0054329713,
-0.0381031409,
-0.01072683,
-0.0175637417,
0.0558959097,
-0.0063031642,
0.0251230691,
-6.07248994e-33,
-0.0164632145,
-0.0132417167,
0.046032507,
-0.036231488,
-0.0101660471,
-0.0281616226,
-0.0021265796,
0.0159685127,
-0.019315578,
-0.0001815551,
0.0311091542,
0.0150849577,
0.0033256896,
0.0301844105,
0.0220883563,
-0.0354656056,
0.0185957626,
0.0017038852,
-0.0323674269,
0.0041534919,
0.0215032212,
0.0092558051,
0.0260431916,
-0.0687461495,
0.0156054031,
0.0148504311,
-0.0338099375,
0.0252555273,
-0.003698335,
0.0415791981,
-0.0625044182,
0.021794254,
0.0306952596,
0.0086012762,
-0.046876397,
0.0192681234,
-0.018372789,
0.0176831596,
0.0216177646,
0.0470529944,
-0.091490604,
0.0267631169,
0.0495562069,
-0.01057842,
0.0118845431,
-0.0442077518,
0.0138390698,
-0.0373071022,
-0.0182434712,
0.0660440922,
-0.0481100008,
-0.0293124337,
0.020563079,
-0.021542687,
0.0494383946,
0.0448757485,
-0.0193080883,
0.0185223967,
-0.0406127237,
0.0329753496,
-0.0404331163,
-0.0288428422,
0.0924023762,
0.0442777351,
0.0311317332,
0.069694072,
0.0832736492,
-0.0254941899,
-0.0415894054,
-0.0341254808,
0.0218644589,
0.050887078,
0.0100593548,
0.0380212478,
0.0547644794,
0.0150268013,
-0.0119141731,
-0.0314509012,
-0.0698761567,
0.0432779938,
0.0531311147,
-0.0019692718,
-0.0042901351,
-0.0222707093,
-0.0098535204,
0.0165900458,
-0.0481480621,
-0.0134458356,
0.0661648884,
0.0185551867,
-0.0145870326,
0.0017744137,
0.0848349035,
-0.056872122,
0.0058004819,
0.007290137,
-0.004698799,
0.0457148254,
0.0008605007,
0.0050133425,
0.0094012842,
0.0123731932,
0.0463690087,
-0.0219723731,
0.0146441143,
0.0227310285,
0.0218136329,
0.0056896075,
-0.0496172458,
-0.0036189805,
-0.0538352244,
0.0334299207,
0.0113160107,
0.0293722693,
0.0574281067,
0.0090657417,
-0.0437988229,
-0.0097571202,
-0.0033709991,
-0.0184154063,
-0.0121228592,
0.0098621948,
-0.0180980507,
0.0151024843,
-0.0133734737,
-0.0178501625,
-0.0540879667,
-0.0526752323,
0.0446877703,
-0.0556695126,
-0.017202124,
0.0073045832,
2.641e-7,
-0.0112743946,
0.0303942543,
-0.0033701565,
0.0114901727,
0.0322620682,
0.0380616374,
0.0039140522,
0.0552661046,
0.0357820764,
-0.0972743258,
-0.035122361,
0.0504552796,
0.0396359116,
0.0165090691,
-0.020266138,
-0.0239144396,
0.0105316918,
0.0007178052,
-0.0482310541,
-0.0274840482,
0.0525606573,
0.0371991694,
-0.0113985604,
-0.0174858738,
0.0820795223,
-0.0370638147,
0.0899662748,
-0.0327606164,
-0.0175580904,
-0.0023700418,
-0.0022450592,
0.011641982,
0.0118788406,
0.0681600273,
0.008529949,
-0.0578605309,
0.0020869432,
-0.000541673,
-0.0396931693,
-0.0714709759,
-0.0432164259,
0.0228236876,
-0.0106429253,
-0.0409340821,
0.057113409,
-0.0205568261,
-0.0184770804,
0.0157718882,
-0.0229750909,
-0.0210007709,
0.0282596219,
-0.0083702942,
-0.0339371711,
0.0059720287,
0.0347951353,
0.036254283,
-0.005021167,
-0.0679107755,
-0.0052677277,
-0.0276740175,
-0.0434192829,
-0.0196751244,
-0.029422909,
0.0064035645,
0.016201593,
-0.0359362178,
-0.0481416136,
2.261073715e-34,
0.0263701566,
-0.0012930632,
0.0614907555,
-0.0003187518,
-0.0045217485,
-0.0207470134,
0.0200380664,
0.0120481215,
-0.0036720883,
-0.0348664373,
-0.0186644774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00541v1 | Answering real-world clinical questions using large language model based systems | 2024-06-29T22:39:20 | 2024-06-29T22:39:20 | Yen Sia Low, Michael L. Jackson, Rebecca J. Hyde, Robert E. Brown, Neil M. Sanghavi, Julian D. Baldwin, C. William Pike, Jananee Muralidharan, Gavin Hui, Natasha Alexander, Hadeel Hassan, Rahul V. Nene, Morgan Pike, Courtney J. Pokrzywa, Shivam Vedak, Adam Paul Yan, Dong-han Yao, Amy R. Zipursky, Christina Dinh, Philip Ballentine, Dan C. Derieg, Vladimir Polony, Rehan N. Chawdry, Jordan Davies, Brigham B. Hyde, Nigam H. Shah, Saurabh Gombar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Evidence to guide healthcare decisions is often limited by a lack of relevant
and trustworthy literature as well as difficulty in contextualizing existing
research for a specific patient. Large language models (LLMs) could potentially
address both challenges by either summarizing published literature or
generating new studies based on real-world data (RWD). We evaluated the ability
of five LLM-based systems in answering 50 clinical questions and had nine
independent physicians review the responses for relevance, reliability, and
actionability. As it stands, general-purpose LLMs (ChatGPT-4, Claude 3 Opus,
Gemini Pro 1.5) rarely produced answers that were deemed relevant and
evidence-based (2% - 10%). In contrast, retrieval augmented generation
(RAG)-based and agentic LLM systems produced relevant and evidence-based
answers for 24% (OpenEvidence) to 58% (ChatRWD) of questions. Only the agentic
ChatRWD was able to answer novel questions compared to other LLMs (65% vs.
0-9%). These results suggest that while general-purpose LLMs should not be used
as-is, a purpose-built system for evidence summarization based on RAG and one
for generating novel evidence working synergistically would improve
availability of pertinent evidence for patient care. | Answering real-world clinical questions using large language model based systems: Evidence to guide healthcare decisions is often limited by a lack of relevant
and trustworthy literature as well as difficulty in contextualizing existing
research for a specific patient. Large language models (LLMs) could potentially
address both challenges by either summarizing published literature or
generating new studies based on real-world data (RWD). We evaluated the ability
of five LLM-based systems in answering 50 clinical questions and had nine
independent physicians review the responses for relevance, reliability, and
actionability. As it stands, general-purpose LLMs (ChatGPT-4, Claude 3 Opus,
Gemini Pro 1.5) rarely produced answers that were deemed relevant and
evidence-based (2% - 10%). In contrast, retrieval augmented generation
(RAG)-based and agentic LLM systems produced relevant and evidence-based
answers for 24% (OpenEvidence) to 58% (ChatRWD) of questions. Only the agentic
ChatRWD was able to answer novel questions compared to other LLMs (65% vs.
0-9%). These results suggest that while general-purpose LLMs should not be used
as-is, a purpose-built system for evidence summarization based on RAG and one
for generating novel evidence working synergistically would improve
availability of pertinent evidence for patient care. | [
0.0805468559,
0.0221978147,
-0.0092903106,
-0.0379170366,
-0.0290372521,
-0.0048565478,
0.0229581185,
0.0188073814,
-0.0238165837,
-0.0311326478,
0.0190721974,
-0.0437880792,
-0.0043301159,
0.0242929272,
0.0049839355,
-0.017278472,
0.0067328145,
0.0363459364,
0.0738693997,
0.0001818965,
0.0009639281,
0.0136270886,
-0.031277746,
0.0523824058,
0.0386807732,
0.0014908407,
0.0203859545,
-0.0201806594,
0.0180937443,
-0.0902200937,
-0.012474034,
-0.0055820872,
-0.008439498,
0.0029826541,
0.0000020237,
-0.0878215954,
-0.0270135496,
0.0446066223,
-0.0359048955,
-0.0483542196,
0.0704357624,
0.01876924,
0.0112084066,
0.0315556228,
-0.0394977666,
-0.0183222182,
0.0393888168,
0.0115055023,
0.0347350165,
0.0417511873,
-0.0111138988,
-0.0142847644,
0.0192842018,
-0.0024515577,
0.0391540937,
-0.0041826651,
0.0353337824,
0.0376193337,
0.0767742023,
0.026596481,
0.0652125254,
0.0509341583,
-0.0210028011,
0.007814642,
-0.0035154223,
0.0392674766,
-0.0371437855,
-0.0224046838,
0.0264647715,
0.03284619,
0.0727149546,
-0.000238809,
0.0262565762,
0.0004111704,
0.0244760215,
0.0473956503,
-0.063077569,
0.0223656576,
-0.0324051827,
-0.0085354662,
0.0173048303,
-0.0056806291,
0.0165789127,
-0.0105092153,
-0.0135640316,
-0.0065746526,
0.0015317008,
-0.0159057565,
0.0021056971,
-0.027694473,
0.0099423593,
-0.0537712127,
0.0301736612,
0.0599427521,
-0.0404348075,
0.0218997225,
0.0442405641,
-0.0143146357,
0.1241531745,
-0.0592367426,
0.010862207,
-0.008254935,
0.0030900938,
-0.0023154272,
-0.0110609028,
-0.0269215833,
-0.0107723381,
0.0224538725,
-0.0634140819,
0.0346314833,
-0.0644028038,
-0.0427384041,
-0.0221123267,
0.0295968652,
-0.0205418095,
0.0065522273,
-0.0631960854,
-0.0189233441,
0.0040915469,
0.0174538307,
-0.0034608685,
0.0392048694,
-0.0172377843,
0.0141027374,
-0.0407909416,
0.03255485,
0.003473053,
0.0509299934,
0.016937742,
-0.0307351407,
0.0485537685,
0.0070271469,
0.0079324013,
0.029804077,
0.0401198305,
0.0464699902,
-0.0050658286,
-0.0128093362,
-0.0010448137,
-0.0589137636,
-0.0624667853,
-0.0366363488,
-0.0079095643,
-0.0949780419,
0.0272154566,
0.0410314016,
-0.0166073758,
-0.024484748,
0.0315010138,
0.0587226562,
-0.0473609231,
0.0117770396,
-0.0499663986,
0.0346536152,
0.0491820015,
0.018444445,
0.016365001,
-0.0053557684,
0.0126214651,
-0.010537276,
-0.0062820888,
-0.0036060221,
-0.0054090424,
-0.037562374,
0.0030287676,
-0.0042042304,
0.0007488741,
0.0500263572,
-0.0171653684,
0.0463327579,
-0.0809597075,
0.1029005051,
-0.0124178324,
0.0197655279,
0.0420574695,
0.0559728183,
0.0267203487,
0.0191501305,
0.0129521238,
-0.0232455675,
0.0383797362,
-0.0214680042,
0.0200225916,
-0.0054297051,
-0.0079414938,
0.0228898637,
0.0042759716,
0.0020914886,
-0.031302575,
-0.0466062948,
-0.0577714518,
0.0073455339,
-0.0147370212,
0.0361460447,
0.0126078203,
-0.0258059502,
0.004984274,
0.0218323525,
0.0295179039,
-0.0177140143,
-0.0100155268,
-0.0587261058,
0.0114456266,
0.0789926797,
0.0575669557,
-0.0364427567,
-0.0182414334,
-0.037859343,
0.008765812,
0.0236612353,
0.0055958475,
-0.0085805049,
-0.0421605445,
-0.0283618011,
-0.0080067618,
0.0160006434,
-0.0120288767,
-0.0104833636,
-0.0154523673,
0.0233419742,
-0.0150099006,
-0.0092824893,
-0.0513435528,
0.024738986,
-0.0595480241,
-0.0180993266,
-0.0026856922,
-0.0413652807,
0.0115669379,
0.0535222478,
-0.0118292961,
0.0718761235,
0.050298579,
-0.0280298032,
-0.0507356338,
-0.0029063856,
-0.0139823686,
-0.0024035736,
0.0305365771,
-0.0138787832,
0.0214546826,
-0.059294451,
-0.0135082351,
-0.0390616283,
-0.0537581071,
-0.0793799087,
0.0616381541,
-0.0014195743,
-0.002936187,
0.0412197933,
-0.0173234381,
-0.0753871053,
0.0177561641,
-0.0020223206,
0.0091144312,
0.0407133028,
-0.0453177579,
0.0101300841,
-0.0404584929,
-0.0078527238,
0.0232035611,
-0.0149931218,
0.0158458985,
0.0263290964,
0.0139881419,
-0.0194066502,
-0.0201163981,
-0.0800750852,
-0.007301053,
0.0209593065,
0.004160244,
0.0230841711,
0.0015779618,
-0.000919345,
-0.0035989459,
-0.0751629993,
-0.0008393978,
0.0530158654,
0.0389433615,
0.0288999919,
0.0790430829,
0.0043170773,
-0.04267326,
-0.0248804446,
-0.014713306,
0.0272638984,
0.0328223482,
0.0057752519,
-0.0365125611,
-0.0042107538,
-0.0623302385,
-0.0194538441,
0.0122568272,
-0.0080415076,
0.0352324434,
-0.023653267,
0.0109639112,
0.0111061595,
0.0085191065,
-0.0336493067,
0.0414955132,
-0.0040628118,
-0.05915571,
-0.0168735385,
-0.0552430563,
-0.0628302097,
0.0145460218,
-0.0565343201,
0.0172840897,
0.0162772462,
0.0343958735,
-0.0031845255,
-0.0027150963,
-0.0133897141,
-0.0034883763,
-0.0014909563,
-0.0609168708,
-0.0308172479,
-0.0262117554,
0.0401980206,
0.019767534,
-0.0217299219,
0.0773433447,
-0.0226239301,
0.0288600773,
-0.10177394,
-0.0190436561,
-0.0370151959,
-0.0203401558,
-0.0145333139,
0.0348733179,
0.0302925482,
-0.0017885179,
-0.0056848945,
-0.0254027788,
0.0073538744,
-0.0697061643,
0.0576366894,
-0.0336113237,
0.0378139429,
0.0138760526,
-0.015183487,
-0.0555796549,
-0.0094007161,
-0.0169143714,
-0.0137294736,
0.0197000206,
0.0300411098,
-0.0754033998,
0.0171884,
0.0601268969,
0.0472578816,
0.016805796,
-0.0306483321,
0.0092520015,
-0.0101156672,
0.0474060476,
-0.0102610709,
0.0286990572,
0.0189110823,
0.0417493917,
0.0851490647,
-0.012194627,
-0.0005211947,
-0.012479227,
-0.0157965459,
-0.001389584,
-0.0377836525,
-0.0090025468,
0.0468243845,
-0.0131479986,
-0.029204037,
0.0020688223,
0.0782737583,
0.0508144945,
-0.0540704019,
-0.0112700844,
-0.0653334856,
-0.045652125,
-0.0149036571,
0.015684763,
-0.0588252284,
-0.0139667587,
-0.0268708244,
0.0271061491,
-0.0365498811,
0.0018575209,
-0.0035022795,
-0.0473106317,
0.0249928851,
-0.0042040702,
-0.0156914331,
0.0063057705,
-0.0349864811,
0.008653312,
0.0252888631,
-0.0108181834,
0.0228315219,
-0.0231327098,
0.0043619419,
0.0157883856,
-0.0749462247,
-0.057865575,
0.0291776154,
0.0047130152,
0.0515969172,
0.0576882064,
0.0307872817,
-0.0126705682,
-0.0389660336,
-0.0234241225,
0.0039563938,
0.0236772671,
0.0052846861,
0.0483778976,
0.0428623147,
0.0426541716,
-0.0690366402,
0.0285779145,
-0.0161352251,
-0.0279923342,
0.0254098736,
0.0574644282,
-0.0468656011,
0.0043066004,
-0.068132028,
0.0575943552,
0.0147304507,
0.0511557497,
0.0043028914,
0.0207455792,
0.0172090326,
0.0321787894,
0.0254231151,
0.0349019095,
-0.0133825447,
0.0252889153,
-0.0340526104,
0.0276458859,
-0.0628986955,
-0.0104031209,
0.0395642035,
-0.0038115948,
0.0121480962,
0.0562599115,
0.0299704596,
-0.0050216387,
-0.0485723987,
0.0310212784,
0.023764126,
0.0103546781,
-0.0242421422,
-0.0227006599,
0.0658001676,
-0.0294907987,
-0.008274002,
0.0214720555,
0.0380207002,
-0.0146024162,
0.0067437743,
0.057432171,
0.0318374261,
-0.0398061574,
0.0191573445,
-0.0114396093,
0.0363873802,
0.0286702961,
-0.0262335539,
-0.0343667045,
-0.0307891201,
0.0141070122,
0.0065602884,
-0.0285796355,
-0.0556817874,
0.0448152497,
-0.0051962067,
0.0356299505,
-0.0134907253,
-0.0332130454,
0.0460250005,
0.0524204224,
0.0255070031,
-0.0284562781,
-0.0168179963,
0.0107128369,
0.0058561852,
-0.0700233579,
0.0117066978,
-0.008109156,
0.009745216,
-0.0109355021,
-0.0176486578,
0.0171110798,
-0.0093040178,
-0.0873517767,
-0.0063857259,
-0.0201859009,
0.0415890627,
-0.0070382738,
0.0185478851,
0.0370488204,
-0.0221495889,
-0.0311162565,
-0.0213493239,
-0.0178468917,
0.0338446945,
0.0022597194,
0.0689511076,
-0.0305203386,
-0.014113578,
-0.0116327181,
0.0334934182,
-0.0755399838,
-0.0693650171,
-0.0203935839,
0.0278578456,
0.0120297186,
0.0295789111,
0.0284456015,
-0.028915802,
-0.0051040319,
-0.0431948751,
-0.0089807604,
0.0089999065,
0.0035379243,
0.0311353281,
0.0075262776,
-0.0211403929,
-0.0476841033,
0.0606962368,
-0.0258844104,
-0.009006314,
-0.0482592471,
-0.0614299327,
-0.0335333794,
-0.0499298088,
-0.0081584658,
0.0311864093,
-0.0603948981,
-0.0346473232,
-0.0886701271,
-0.009396961,
-0.0133248912,
0.0115447203,
-0.0229960941,
-0.0354612544,
0.0313642025,
0.037715476,
0.024646949,
-0.0426261872,
-0.0434409343,
0.0980882272,
-0.0742362291,
0.0113643091,
-0.0011528442,
-5.590697418e-33,
0.0141715445,
-0.0279826615,
0.0352905206,
-0.0400951132,
0.0103520406,
0.0349207781,
-0.0349695794,
0.0051138895,
-0.0020903491,
0.0248396546,
-0.017661348,
-0.0173389185,
0.0116686467,
0.045651637,
0.0089600701,
-0.0171726421,
0.0181937758,
0.0177741125,
-0.0223553833,
0.0373050421,
0.0118573252,
0.002849356,
-0.0003308521,
-0.0631811023,
0.0263652932,
-0.0235936511,
0.0437044166,
-0.004531824,
-0.0199295152,
0.0593166687,
-0.0077776215,
0.0534346178,
0.0294106882,
-0.0269645881,
-0.0153641636,
0.0135693867,
-0.0439079218,
-0.0204594899,
0.0321420729,
-0.0796395019,
-0.0473106839,
0.0089252759,
0.0541054867,
-0.0086512817,
-0.0070546619,
0.0390157662,
0.014238813,
-0.0556463003,
-0.0215174649,
-0.0350542329,
-0.0286277141,
0.0265572108,
0.0350909866,
0.0180585254,
-0.0703943521,
0.0649808943,
-0.0481006019,
0.0236727577,
-0.0231493022,
0.0083099445,
0.024321733,
0.0114591932,
0.0138580827,
-0.0240068119,
-0.0185212661,
0.0420667045,
-0.0092932954,
-0.0120049724,
-0.0278840419,
0.0103536053,
-0.0700032115,
0.0183444768,
0.0610010475,
0.0734235942,
-0.0035950828,
-0.0040299813,
-0.0842260942,
0.0601953566,
-0.0522357039,
0.04993416,
0.0657943934,
-0.0281489193,
-0.0600432754,
-0.012190125,
-0.0305265021,
0.0458635427,
-0.0223742817,
-0.0569238812,
0.0398284085,
0.0082949083,
-0.0039198771,
0.0119259376,
0.0286098849,
0.0117130084,
0.0167277399,
-0.0204195436,
0.0122162616,
-0.0016748274,
-0.0460935757,
0.0004315226,
-0.0616453253,
0.0326765254,
0.0376288146,
-0.0007886653,
0.0196958967,
0.0257657561,
0.0067903297,
-0.0301052313,
-0.0499114059,
0.0060023507,
0.0255137589,
0.0332414843,
-0.0256888028,
-0.0332445689,
0.0063345251,
0.0509496704,
0.0134453755,
0.0809955373,
-0.0051577147,
-0.032670781,
-0.0397899412,
-0.0805292055,
0.0000096869,
0.0066182516,
-0.0386537425,
0.0448571257,
-0.0311333388,
0.0728811398,
0.0431330875,
-0.01632764,
0.0103929034,
-0.004351771,
2.795e-7,
0.1072131619,
0.020259684,
0.0022891103,
-0.0226412378,
0.0346397609,
0.0037821461,
0.0192885213,
-0.0195242334,
0.0639465451,
-0.0144486129,
0.0301734209,
0.0032809409,
-0.0081046652,
0.062583454,
-0.0182242021,
-0.059234824,
-0.0872985721,
-0.03388381,
-0.0342787206,
-0.0097725475,
0.0929578915,
0.0229705293,
-0.0553241558,
-0.0351639986,
-0.0209079813,
-0.0337024443,
0.0310554504,
-0.0318200029,
-0.0143335564,
0.0320632942,
0.0428776182,
-0.0060815425,
0.0435804427,
0.0420004539,
-0.0199491419,
-0.0215952601,
-0.0359524749,
0.0494216755,
-0.0405102074,
-0.0009047004,
0.0227038823,
-0.0309249368,
0.0556280613,
-0.047251191,
0.0414228439,
-0.0849470943,
-0.0326052122,
-0.0122866053,
-0.0303027201,
-0.0302708037,
0.0553577766,
-0.0276912097,
-0.0433139727,
0.0269539524,
-0.0169406347,
0.0415742137,
-0.014926563,
-0.0488233604,
0.004494682,
0.0592648014,
-0.0355615132,
-0.0443008766,
0.0270850267,
-0.0316975825,
-0.044365067,
-0.1021684408,
0.0342862345,
2.483619132e-34,
0.0253109261,
0.0278867371,
-0.0127478475,
0.0000950797,
0.0405617133,
0.0199050009,
-0.0143632824,
0.0420332216,
0.0311550293,
-0.0712096617,
-0.0158516802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00499v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00499v1 | ConU: Conformal Uncertainty in Large Language Models with Correctness Coverage Guarantees | 2024-06-29T17:33:07 | 2024-06-29T17:33:07 | Zhiyuan Wang, Jinhao Duan, Lu Cheng, Yue Zhang, Qingni Wang, Hengtao Shen, Xiaofeng Zhu, Xiaoshuang Shi, Kaidi Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Uncertainty quantification (UQ) in natural language generation (NLG) tasks
remains an open challenge, exacerbated by the intricate nature of the recent
large language models (LLMs). This study investigates adapting conformal
prediction (CP), which can convert any heuristic measure of uncertainty into
rigorous theoretical guarantees by constructing prediction sets, for black-box
LLMs in open-ended NLG tasks. We propose a sampling-based uncertainty measure
leveraging self-consistency and develop a conformal uncertainty criterion by
integrating the uncertainty condition aligned with correctness into the design
of the CP algorithm. Experimental results indicate that our uncertainty measure
generally surpasses prior state-of-the-art methods. Furthermore, we calibrate
the prediction sets within the model's unfixed answer distribution and achieve
strict control over the correctness coverage rate across 6 LLMs on 4 free-form
NLG datasets, spanning general-purpose and medical domains, while the small
average set size further highlights the efficiency of our method in providing
trustworthy guarantees for practical open-ended NLG applications. | ConU: Conformal Uncertainty in Large Language Models with Correctness Coverage Guarantees: Uncertainty quantification (UQ) in natural language generation (NLG) tasks
remains an open challenge, exacerbated by the intricate nature of the recent
large language models (LLMs). This study investigates adapting conformal
prediction (CP), which can convert any heuristic measure of uncertainty into
rigorous theoretical guarantees by constructing prediction sets, for black-box
LLMs in open-ended NLG tasks. We propose a sampling-based uncertainty measure
leveraging self-consistency and develop a conformal uncertainty criterion by
integrating the uncertainty condition aligned with correctness into the design
of the CP algorithm. Experimental results indicate that our uncertainty measure
generally surpasses prior state-of-the-art methods. Furthermore, we calibrate
the prediction sets within the model's unfixed answer distribution and achieve
strict control over the correctness coverage rate across 6 LLMs on 4 free-form
NLG datasets, spanning general-purpose and medical domains, while the small
average set size further highlights the efficiency of our method in providing
trustworthy guarantees for practical open-ended NLG applications. | [
0.0271821804,
0.0814648792,
0.0066017671,
-0.0305568166,
-0.0301815998,
-0.0163774807,
-0.0017128785,
-0.0050227642,
-0.0123050306,
-0.0343632475,
0.0382293835,
-0.1510429978,
0.0179462694,
0.0141435405,
0.0206893589,
-0.0182908326,
0.0007079557,
-0.0282352045,
0.0048013064,
-0.0316158347,
-0.0270927791,
-0.0017835596,
-0.0006571045,
0.0260214154,
-0.0217250176,
0.0060950341,
0.0104688294,
0.0086121997,
-0.0051354766,
-0.0533109047,
0.0214972533,
0.0832937434,
-0.0027937659,
0.0133370552,
0.000002152,
-0.0434086397,
-0.0430644862,
0.008093412,
0.0004619471,
0.0148376189,
0.0259904899,
-0.0065725581,
-0.0116764959,
0.0500520132,
-0.0202417336,
0.0248011798,
0.0310723092,
0.0148658156,
0.0284317844,
0.0299775768,
0.0054609654,
-0.0062532052,
0.0185177401,
-0.0165562108,
0.0033008312,
-0.0504949465,
0.017452877,
0.0146514559,
0.0159433484,
0.0002343548,
-0.012331997,
0.0368864536,
0.0063530146,
0.03062962,
-0.0142421806,
0.0196600072,
0.0141042862,
-0.0475119501,
-0.0023668862,
0.0308157392,
0.011650146,
-0.0274108909,
-0.0137154302,
-0.0161541849,
-0.0213562176,
0.0391971879,
-0.0426617861,
0.0795529261,
-0.0182547998,
0.0164055079,
-0.0092320051,
-0.0051155463,
0.0244617723,
0.0004489897,
-0.034229368,
0.0746598318,
0.0367743857,
-0.0142483395,
-0.0059961206,
-0.0018820922,
-0.0891865864,
-0.0435532369,
-0.0127343405,
0.0376623012,
-0.0827137008,
0.0182379875,
-0.0780103877,
-0.0186024792,
0.0623543672,
-0.0091005452,
0.0371555872,
0.0178322643,
0.051816348,
-0.022538105,
0.0011519743,
0.0557941161,
-0.0047587589,
-0.011991526,
-0.062005721,
-0.0047542248,
0.0024633065,
-0.0133872619,
-0.0237690974,
0.0248899013,
-0.0577707291,
-0.024884494,
-0.1019462645,
-0.0079998588,
-0.0040401383,
0.011496027,
0.0207761955,
0.0289890878,
-0.049215164,
-0.0346629545,
-0.0002580163,
0.0084358342,
1.303e-7,
0.0126272338,
0.0316097811,
-0.0574326143,
0.0124701178,
0.0200222488,
-0.0112625193,
-0.0036441376,
0.0008125316,
0.0726319104,
-0.0116465306,
-0.0271135587,
-0.0168356672,
-0.0598737188,
-0.0766736865,
-0.0481272042,
-0.0077959923,
-0.0650111884,
-0.0131784007,
0.0159264412,
0.0044672005,
-0.0526920408,
0.0286272541,
0.0372763611,
-0.0175942071,
0.0556680672,
-0.0220205132,
0.0277105477,
0.0041147256,
0.0025847806,
0.042821303,
0.0357739255,
0.0356583297,
0.0203181282,
0.0391109101,
0.0142385596,
0.0372955315,
0.0077767852,
0.0282892361,
-0.0244663395,
-0.0149254352,
-0.0162714273,
0.0114031201,
0.0484674387,
-0.0324079432,
0.1062696576,
-0.0110851573,
-0.0047841151,
0.0495166294,
0.0027562592,
0.0048260735,
-0.0484708548,
0.027866995,
0.0022813252,
0.0079692621,
0.0070076608,
-0.0171615724,
-0.0150701394,
-0.0416908674,
0.033377286,
0.0282911062,
0.0290239416,
-0.0182905756,
-0.0447243229,
-0.058131244,
-0.0029459666,
-0.0059473324,
-0.0317157768,
0.0370985903,
0.0011645642,
-0.0541028455,
0.0654340982,
0.0157045871,
-0.0621243939,
0.0314565971,
-0.0220824238,
0.070089668,
0.020671485,
0.0702231526,
0.0153723881,
-0.057631392,
0.0061460342,
0.009204749,
0.0296683293,
0.0359948762,
0.010347886,
-0.0015022045,
-0.0598490722,
-0.0203499049,
0.0276985187,
0.0232014004,
-0.0012580581,
0.0481853522,
-0.0060306629,
0.029876003,
-0.0218219198,
-0.0618212409,
0.0181959588,
-0.0278536025,
-0.0445521288,
0.0478185453,
-0.0233624931,
0.0511600897,
0.0065413923,
-0.0278612133,
0.0471031219,
0.0321335606,
-0.0279429704,
-0.0674722642,
-0.0423200205,
-0.014708763,
0.0394951291,
0.0415230878,
-0.0364631228,
0.0235320516,
-0.0226145983,
-0.0191113874,
-0.045483999,
0.0029264214,
-0.0240726862,
0.000052832,
-0.0462921783,
0.0361732915,
0.0401973985,
0.0290705692,
-0.0734416917,
0.0162251387,
-0.0125511298,
0.0058915303,
0.0204221029,
0.0199319031,
0.0129934307,
-0.006920035,
-0.0539467558,
-0.0118070999,
-0.0422419384,
0.032195013,
0.0622883327,
0.0415552333,
-0.0267989505,
-0.0653387904,
-0.0416251794,
0.0208399147,
-0.0209655222,
0.0123158675,
0.016077701,
0.0079079363,
-0.0124206059,
0.016529236,
-0.0318582058,
-0.0427037477,
0.057425566,
-0.0050673489,
0.0316356942,
0.0266225412,
-0.0176710803,
-0.0144938584,
0.0008659078,
0.0039183986,
0.0161844753,
0.0372475944,
0.0598895438,
-0.0745182037,
0.0563081726,
-0.0474022999,
-0.0085454704,
0.023973396,
-0.0423396155,
0.0057803043,
0.0083918059,
-0.0038758349,
-0.0215670895,
0.0412759669,
-0.0099013736,
0.0364289396,
-0.00271105,
0.0161613151,
0.0122409072,
-0.0793531165,
-0.0587093756,
0.0081740916,
-0.0589045584,
0.0432706214,
0.0533646531,
0.0416440442,
-0.0262695886,
-0.0741709918,
0.0188724734,
-0.0452452265,
0.0068985866,
-0.0129940491,
0.0102405222,
-0.022905644,
0.0576875843,
0.0091398228,
-0.0553140379,
0.0428852849,
-0.0708620027,
0.0432348885,
-0.0147184506,
0.0145680225,
-0.0102000888,
0.0135024693,
0.0107543608,
0.024191983,
0.0537567325,
0.0005516016,
-0.05663082,
0.0007872406,
0.0309919398,
-0.0595103689,
0.0239292458,
-0.0681344718,
0.0068943938,
0.0206058398,
-0.0145089924,
-0.0617402531,
-0.0397731327,
-0.0209348164,
0.0050058314,
0.0763037279,
-0.0436987355,
0.0126962662,
0.0243072435,
-0.0308688469,
0.004600904,
-0.0413260162,
-0.0094177295,
-0.0135190813,
0.0138205867,
0.0690519586,
0.013002295,
0.06780231,
-0.0309748407,
-0.0198978335,
0.0524065495,
0.0127947116,
0.0555020869,
0.0098069077,
-0.0216267426,
0.0311800428,
-0.0088603348,
-0.0225634761,
0.0742994845,
0.0808906406,
-0.0017254277,
-0.0270039532,
0.1532560289,
0.039078638,
0.0236287396,
0.0061980309,
0.0137912687,
0.0689470544,
0.0110075809,
0.0291858278,
-0.0890653804,
-0.0205807518,
-0.000897145,
0.0534502231,
-0.0265168063,
-0.0381141119,
-0.0177998468,
-0.1130501926,
0.0372710899,
0.0312705003,
-0.0557510667,
-0.0435768813,
-0.0090252627,
-0.0082136206,
-0.0263204053,
0.0464061163,
0.0277334228,
-0.0255713481,
0.0182080045,
0.056663461,
-0.0648474395,
-0.0818326175,
-0.0075946269,
-0.0393317342,
0.0738565177,
0.011041834,
0.0020372404,
0.0151022244,
-0.0060884971,
0.0078852521,
-0.0427822247,
-0.0165460184,
-0.0198786873,
0.0359724797,
0.0470480211,
-0.0014932188,
-0.001343505,
0.0276704524,
-0.0560890883,
-0.0040315748,
-0.0122192986,
0.0561612025,
-0.0139516918,
-0.0272761472,
0.0008653005,
0.0416577011,
0.023665892,
0.0782597065,
0.0041798213,
-0.0299565438,
-0.0220587812,
-0.0248987172,
0.0461108834,
-0.0495618172,
0.0370413885,
0.0022304272,
-0.0084742522,
-0.0093155354,
-0.096387051,
0.0204717871,
0.0061854585,
0.0431521274,
-0.0042907386,
-0.0156753212,
0.0519452728,
-0.0063585732,
-0.0143991364,
-0.0202012397,
-0.0222614165,
0.0228600428,
-0.0889075249,
0.0252747107,
0.0017029862,
-0.0265449602,
-0.0095256716,
0.071322605,
-0.0943739116,
-0.0907884687,
0.0195847023,
0.0420298092,
0.0242692158,
0.0099496506,
-0.0181211177,
-0.0464342609,
0.0492296889,
0.0513982326,
-0.026145516,
0.0077083213,
0.0091267684,
-0.007370322,
-0.0192994867,
0.0316499695,
-0.0092822975,
-0.0015184708,
-0.0118476767,
0.0621933155,
0.0177617557,
-0.083975926,
0.0314149372,
0.0759907216,
-0.0002624188,
-0.0685675219,
0.0330414437,
-0.0081823803,
-0.0143674891,
-0.0123101873,
-0.015507686,
-0.0308055524,
0.0168721657,
0.0077628181,
-0.0505514778,
-0.0254064705,
-0.0039299037,
-0.0277041439,
0.039268855,
0.0134468609,
-0.0458255187,
-0.0325700864,
0.0179928765,
0.0607619397,
-0.0266324505,
0.0199951939,
0.0117437867,
0.0030378671,
0.0452585295,
0.0326658674,
0.051959075,
0.0019434138,
0.0264770426,
-0.0240439288,
-0.0152849499,
-0.040989507,
-0.049987983,
-0.0622104257,
0.028928658,
0.0342148803,
0.0225829054,
0.0376459286,
-0.0669853464,
-0.0073891166,
-0.0310409665,
0.0546117499,
-0.0061357287,
0.0162840392,
0.0435145497,
-0.0118246656,
-0.0281926561,
-0.0089962445,
0.0720220134,
0.0008726728,
0.0263383761,
-0.0350946188,
-0.0641384125,
-0.0323270187,
-0.0434076637,
-0.0227443743,
-0.0013987605,
-0.0383161679,
0.0166305043,
-0.053471677,
-0.0737036318,
0.075429745,
0.043812193,
0.0174499098,
-0.018844666,
0.026680233,
0.0436553992,
-0.0172508378,
0.0172240175,
-0.0268982854,
0.0038382984,
-0.0200656801,
0.0278581064,
-0.0162352957,
-7.108770495e-33,
-0.0346916504,
-0.061289534,
0.0128638297,
-0.0578531958,
-0.0002244051,
-0.0051935608,
0.0125292642,
0.032689061,
0.0578196384,
0.0323531851,
-0.0019165146,
-0.0143351918,
0.0118338149,
0.0549168177,
0.018034419,
-0.0082178218,
0.0415647551,
-0.0081953928,
-0.0395525098,
0.0087341014,
0.0233662315,
0.0220310837,
0.0149609027,
-0.0113379043,
0.0151937352,
0.0180091634,
-0.0476010516,
0.0435794517,
-0.025846228,
0.0469162725,
0.001919975,
0.0348291509,
-0.0129719721,
-0.0014661524,
-0.0075326092,
-0.0399858803,
-0.0137334922,
-0.0204459801,
0.009034344,
-0.0034478516,
-0.0087950956,
-0.0010002315,
0.0096091181,
-0.0212248582,
-0.0792203397,
0.0233539585,
-0.0128727956,
-0.0229984857,
-0.0165971182,
-0.0268021021,
0.0176948942,
0.0304503981,
0.0231769588,
-0.0418900773,
-0.0491429977,
0.0730088204,
-0.0281635299,
-0.0171227735,
0.0137382811,
0.0248741172,
0.0391615778,
0.0242707543,
0.059495382,
0.0113719385,
-0.0159584433,
0.0440323204,
-0.0349543914,
-0.0246894639,
-0.0437738262,
-0.0143177435,
-0.0365406759,
0.0076254732,
0.0203707628,
0.0683374852,
0.0073694335,
-0.0134567115,
-0.0623406917,
0.0461411513,
-0.0457047746,
0.0315076858,
0.0339496359,
-0.0269398,
-0.0445945151,
-0.0368578024,
-0.045883134,
0.0020268504,
-0.0058683134,
-0.0001004681,
0.0198901761,
0.019093059,
-0.0445846952,
-0.0304998998,
0.0134988138,
-0.0254115742,
0.0065534464,
-0.0013654144,
-0.0253391843,
-0.0215386394,
-0.0314968824,
0.0191981588,
-0.0306539908,
0.0016815452,
0.0047177807,
-0.0027326089,
-0.0388033837,
0.0174576975,
0.0252855886,
0.0214370228,
-0.0736592337,
0.0324818045,
-0.0259754844,
0.0454860367,
0.0208831299,
-0.0330247506,
0.0375104174,
-0.0142497532,
-0.0140466616,
0.0449486524,
-0.0184436254,
0.028102437,
-0.0158192497,
0.0054457942,
0.0359558873,
0.0035901847,
-0.03393301,
0.0035472906,
0.002433053,
-0.0224637724,
0.0063586985,
-0.0453099683,
-0.0400159657,
-0.0089006284,
2.954e-7,
0.0566122606,
0.0386127383,
0.0118317092,
0.0485723093,
0.0028184578,
0.0021696235,
0.0113635026,
-0.0080187572,
-0.0186341349,
0.0218280647,
0.020175131,
-0.0127390651,
0.051669497,
0.0300054662,
-0.0207076445,
0.0028760228,
-0.0691489577,
0.0317608863,
0.005311002,
-0.0198168363,
0.0610295199,
0.0658374652,
-0.018368246,
-0.0144516639,
0.0154035445,
0.0031825413,
0.0779554322,
-0.017149331,
-0.0425750054,
0.0555257946,
0.0462162457,
0.0209930688,
0.0191875342,
0.0245059486,
-0.016349541,
-0.0296878163,
0.0005462716,
0.060773693,
0.0621509477,
0.0108480463,
0.0126050794,
0.0009447474,
-0.0047741197,
-0.0259268042,
0.0294881798,
-0.0882221237,
-0.0183591116,
-0.0767921433,
-0.0057558827,
-0.0237585474,
0.050157927,
-0.0274288915,
-0.0109352358,
0.0018345256,
0.01021244,
0.0574401505,
-0.0049068979,
-0.0055667539,
-0.0269793347,
0.0207556244,
-0.0484122895,
-0.0000339939,
-0.0066451184,
-0.0220901165,
0.0027179753,
-0.0746143013,
0.0215074066,
2.742968313e-34,
0.0562361255,
-0.0034874196,
-0.0165923741,
-0.0260036532,
0.04787587,
-0.019220259,
0.0339884162,
0.0202555563,
0.0148088178,
-0.0753670186,
-0.0127831912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00497v1 | LLMs-as-Instructors: Learning from Errors Toward Automating Model Improvement | 2024-06-29T17:16:04 | 2024-06-29T17:16:04 | Jiahao Ying, Mingbao Lin, Yixin Cao, Wei Tang, Bo Wang, Qianru Sun, Xuanjing Huang, Shuicheng Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces the innovative "LLMs-as-Instructors" framework, which
leverages the advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) to autonomously enhance the
training of smaller target models. Inspired by the theory of "Learning from
Errors", this framework employs an instructor LLM to meticulously analyze the
specific errors within a target model, facilitating targeted and efficient
training cycles. Within this framework, we implement two strategies: "Learning
from Error," which focuses solely on incorrect responses to tailor training
data, and "Learning from Error by Contrast", which uses contrastive learning to
analyze both correct and incorrect responses for a deeper understanding of
errors.
Our empirical studies, conducted with several open-source models, demonstrate
significant improvements across multiple benchmarks, including mathematical
reasoning, coding abilities, and factual knowledge. Notably, the refined
Llama-3-8b-Instruction has outperformed ChatGPT, illustrating the effectiveness
of our approach. By leveraging the strengths of both strategies, we have
attained a more balanced performance improvement on both in-domain and
out-of-domain benchmarks. Our code can be found at
https://yingjiahao14.github.io/LLMs-as-Instructors-pages/. | LLMs-as-Instructors: Learning from Errors Toward Automating Model Improvement: This paper introduces the innovative "LLMs-as-Instructors" framework, which
leverages the advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) to autonomously enhance the
training of smaller target models. Inspired by the theory of "Learning from
Errors", this framework employs an instructor LLM to meticulously analyze the
specific errors within a target model, facilitating targeted and efficient
training cycles. Within this framework, we implement two strategies: "Learning
from Error," which focuses solely on incorrect responses to tailor training
data, and "Learning from Error by Contrast", which uses contrastive learning to
analyze both correct and incorrect responses for a deeper understanding of
errors.
Our empirical studies, conducted with several open-source models, demonstrate
significant improvements across multiple benchmarks, including mathematical
reasoning, coding abilities, and factual knowledge. Notably, the refined
Llama-3-8b-Instruction has outperformed ChatGPT, illustrating the effectiveness
of our approach. By leveraging the strengths of both strategies, we have
attained a more balanced performance improvement on both in-domain and
out-of-domain benchmarks. Our code can be found at
https://yingjiahao14.github.io/LLMs-as-Instructors-pages/. | [
0.0179686397,
0.0568899699,
-0.0079892958,
0.056713365,
-0.0136515303,
0.028917646,
-0.026413219,
-0.0187598225,
-0.0155557152,
-0.0658301115,
-0.0392087772,
-0.0215330403,
-0.035092324,
-0.0198134389,
0.05847691,
-0.0343992859,
0.0521252714,
-0.0792035386,
-0.0335391387,
-0.0092375362,
-0.003068777,
-0.0014892492,
-0.0375214219,
0.0118059125,
0.0079159755,
-0.0383301601,
-0.0115620252,
0.0027602527,
-0.003869992,
-0.0223276094,
0.0301647726,
0.0314802974,
0.0370127223,
0.0383011773,
0.000002174,
-0.0676017031,
-0.0088153481,
0.0117479078,
-0.0345857963,
0.0500018708,
0.0328185596,
0.0180640128,
-0.0326330587,
0.0483630784,
-0.0223451108,
-0.0180360265,
0.0262612216,
0.0192109812,
0.0854402184,
0.0910692438,
0.026565738,
-0.0331065096,
0.0453545935,
0.0011573271,
0.007929448,
-0.0315476023,
0.0327675678,
0.0569199063,
0.0088898605,
-0.0060558734,
-0.0380905084,
0.0190528762,
0.0319260247,
0.0076503786,
0.0028467784,
0.0251442716,
0.0024674467,
-0.0027408435,
-0.0250433013,
0.037468642,
0.002213143,
-0.0167628676,
-0.0188531484,
-0.0108229714,
-0.0100751873,
-0.0101754591,
-0.0543095209,
0.0312895849,
0.0101043126,
0.0239005089,
0.021390982,
-0.051991675,
0.0177984405,
0.042085208,
-0.0276948977,
0.0230087824,
0.0143902842,
-0.0493715815,
-0.0075151785,
0.007497312,
-0.0151300458,
-0.040419478,
-0.0042884196,
0.0806583688,
-0.0161204431,
0.0283687413,
-0.031327799,
-0.0339974687,
0.0141614908,
-0.0341687016,
0.0769409165,
0.0441557951,
-0.0378196165,
0.0174894966,
-0.0203117449,
0.0612614676,
0.0104838302,
0.0412364565,
-0.0236352235,
0.0247772504,
-0.0397986956,
0.0073681558,
-0.0043011,
0.0429398715,
-0.0008235942,
0.0218572728,
-0.0540823862,
0.0324013568,
-0.016225623,
0.0449335985,
-0.0021358356,
-0.0151767768,
-0.0403988063,
-0.0275999047,
-0.0354815274,
0.0211394075,
0.0056885122,
0.0055718408,
-0.0047328663,
-0.0810959339,
-0.0141800456,
0.0292791817,
-0.040178746,
-0.0137090543,
0.0376929566,
0.0970216095,
-0.0282983091,
-0.035651315,
-0.0807185471,
0.0137626305,
0.0143264011,
-0.0647934675,
0.0210740101,
-0.0941325575,
-0.0153550608,
-0.0082225874,
0.001881152,
-0.0331477188,
0.020221334,
-0.0087833563,
0.0176296178,
0.0727830306,
-0.0224889759,
0.0143566802,
0.0410022773,
0.0109616183,
-0.0172057748,
0.070790641,
0.0355040729,
-0.026136782,
-0.0005051332,
-0.0342693105,
0.0330671407,
0.0543401204,
0.0087640025,
0.0211880952,
-0.0304957516,
0.0237774737,
0.009395591,
0.0371110253,
0.0498767011,
0.0653058663,
-0.0300431922,
0.0289236866,
0.0472905077,
0.0298237037,
-0.0058786687,
0.0405750833,
0.050277777,
0.0100619895,
0.0326992944,
-0.0045219073,
-0.0692543909,
0.0223004762,
-0.0290064923,
0.0351679698,
0.0221257824,
0.0281532574,
-0.0232334733,
-0.093259044,
-0.0221422277,
-0.0021190227,
-0.0343000777,
0.0182066355,
0.0844726562,
0.017462492,
-0.0466113277,
0.0435113162,
0.0411455855,
-0.0274135265,
0.0096294442,
-0.1063522846,
0.0222029164,
0.0321921073,
0.0406643674,
-0.04556337,
-0.0613989159,
-0.0193481054,
0.0101496875,
0.0356866866,
0.0530715585,
-0.0114627155,
-0.0337089077,
-0.0678735226,
-0.0096764416,
-0.0283216089,
0.02072924,
0.0158447344,
0.0526415408,
-0.0125244567,
0.0070207072,
-0.0098489504,
-0.0437038578,
0.0415538996,
-0.057195209,
-0.0531669632,
-0.0212333761,
-0.0126132593,
0.0327731892,
-0.010422051,
-0.0205669142,
0.0098738335,
0.0166418701,
0.0015819561,
-0.0170740429,
-0.0306664854,
-0.017922068,
-0.0323728248,
0.0844084844,
-0.0104200626,
-0.0470685884,
0.0416642129,
-0.0722262338,
-0.0328736044,
0.0353815146,
-0.0498174392,
0.0297198016,
-0.0378213525,
0.0214259624,
0.0123679144,
-0.0208269302,
-0.0284582078,
0.0513310693,
0.0025366012,
0.0034567534,
0.0112997117,
0.0373229869,
-0.0093513504,
-0.0254508369,
0.0001629636,
-0.0217750482,
-0.0258912761,
0.0611865595,
-0.0149779096,
0.0458983891,
-0.0639108866,
-0.0350679606,
-0.0248305351,
0.009157652,
-0.0134260114,
0.0398018099,
0.018260831,
-0.0106449462,
-0.028843591,
0.004834841,
0.0048878659,
-0.0182961281,
-0.0043304628,
-0.0036660426,
0.0266484637,
-0.0008436065,
-0.0550450794,
-0.0642851815,
0.0086539714,
-0.0271260366,
0.0063363053,
-0.0249038264,
0.0145152062,
-0.0772610009,
0.0716939121,
-0.0200892724,
0.0414968133,
-0.0015201165,
-0.0622359738,
0.0154989203,
-0.0400541686,
0.0211234502,
0.0657875091,
-0.0110523971,
0.0560490377,
0.0423575975,
-0.013536742,
-0.0787434801,
0.0375785567,
0.0087208441,
-0.0670112595,
-0.0324866548,
-0.0126092639,
-0.035830725,
0.0686069876,
-0.0177720729,
-0.0081687327,
-0.0347076356,
-0.0188238006,
-0.0168025158,
-0.0137292445,
-0.00826733,
0.0124305254,
-0.0184747614,
0.0048140096,
-0.0147066927,
-0.0590804704,
0.0730702654,
-0.0278551355,
-0.0064325538,
-0.0313157775,
-0.0200754181,
-0.0494180284,
0.0203187447,
-0.0087336311,
-0.014687784,
0.0022999195,
-0.034963198,
-0.0569012798,
-0.0234584063,
0.0043040109,
-0.0408473052,
0.0906391516,
-0.087462306,
-0.0046133213,
0.0155875636,
-0.03939512,
-0.0407968462,
0.0231039375,
-0.0457776487,
0.0039018618,
-0.0239181146,
-0.0183007438,
-0.0322526358,
-0.0291048121,
0.0079298858,
0.0106224222,
-0.0227124654,
-0.0323139764,
-0.0157100074,
-0.0201647356,
-0.000427232,
0.0079647275,
0.0310454816,
-0.0718813315,
0.0182385948,
0.0368226804,
0.0478560589,
-0.0065011438,
-0.066552408,
0.0106727127,
0.0319986306,
-0.0353079513,
0.0024803162,
0.0461117737,
0.0483173542,
-0.0775472596,
-0.0325552933,
0.1197008193,
0.0185710229,
-0.0129455114,
0.0000999128,
-0.0479367673,
0.0395920984,
0.0367144383,
0.0434465557,
-0.0601245239,
-0.0394303501,
0.0058777709,
0.0576514415,
0.0161695275,
0.001293804,
0.0018486248,
-0.1503321528,
0.0383508615,
0.0458783284,
-0.0150322877,
-0.025737986,
-0.0463410355,
0.0128786238,
-0.0311821979,
0.0329871662,
0.034727674,
-0.0397352464,
0.008152796,
0.0633632094,
-0.0241742004,
-0.0791529641,
0.015444559,
-0.0278297383,
0.0636640266,
0.0520989448,
-0.0121890828,
-0.0129294926,
-0.0250089336,
0.0495687872,
0.0056571439,
0.0106378682,
-0.0285263378,
0.0168668311,
-0.0120333098,
-0.0105609512,
0.0040331208,
0.0555194505,
-0.0283199418,
-0.0113705518,
0.016437171,
0.0990788192,
-0.0119302934,
0.0164280664,
-0.0218038205,
-0.0090541113,
0.013642665,
0.0406287275,
0.0388423689,
-0.0163225811,
-0.0311498586,
-0.0522992127,
-0.0202017818,
-0.0363569967,
-0.0167811085,
0.0161066372,
-0.0066550402,
-0.0064075505,
-0.0214480162,
-0.0396852754,
0.0240318906,
0.0057921233,
0.0130585805,
-0.0293584056,
-0.0012513038,
0.0112484824,
-0.0306861568,
0.0202948395,
-0.0499964133,
0.0301954579,
-0.0739637762,
-0.0192361008,
0.0343407691,
-0.029177187,
-0.0118535375,
0.008045936,
-0.0868649632,
-0.084898375,
0.0007951906,
0.088923648,
0.0236495286,
0.066557236,
-0.0115466099,
-0.0617974587,
0.0088131903,
0.0347055867,
-0.0258041136,
0.0146673135,
0.0533546954,
0.0078868559,
0.0099200392,
0.0041058529,
-0.0405628867,
0.0147082834,
0.0210813247,
0.0444222949,
-0.0188579001,
-0.0001940729,
0.0357705466,
0.0231521633,
0.0344681814,
-0.0127130989,
-0.0105343079,
-0.0153687587,
0.0239631403,
0.0068554422,
-0.0076526259,
-0.0322438627,
0.0179506298,
0.0023093424,
-0.0111799221,
0.0165607985,
-0.018455917,
-0.0075516119,
0.0339571126,
0.0080302246,
0.0582775883,
0.0040414757,
0.0188287627,
0.046086479,
-0.0103075486,
-0.0148847206,
-0.005444909,
0.0268713962,
0.0183564853,
-0.0023532948,
0.0526861474,
0.0041608876,
0.0316216573,
-0.0043386733,
-0.0307761487,
-0.0195526555,
-0.0621116348,
-0.0369809978,
0.0222176947,
0.0799585432,
0.0311556365,
0.0156342089,
-0.0465550199,
0.0018236212,
-0.0027936993,
0.0375305787,
-0.0443318598,
-0.0074543264,
0.0638636425,
0.0474550687,
0.0308600273,
-0.011036247,
0.0614747517,
-0.0091218287,
0.0803093389,
-0.0031883463,
0.0228320323,
-0.0400728285,
-0.042864766,
0.0397722274,
-0.0177690331,
-0.0086380839,
-0.017612936,
-0.0206343029,
-0.0905567706,
-0.0152918743,
0.0624099858,
-0.0098277451,
-0.031144755,
0.039538186,
0.0790688768,
-0.0236890744,
0.0004191796,
-0.0177609362,
0.0120114135,
0.0080189733,
-0.0287961997,
-0.0053128856,
-6.288757391e-33,
-0.0293648448,
-0.0035801402,
0.0779760331,
0.0045368243,
-0.0222057719,
-0.0246673636,
-0.0254521072,
-0.0024188866,
0.0014616088,
0.01625246,
0.0100149857,
0.037438564,
0.0041692643,
0.0132091176,
0.0306445919,
0.0001314691,
0.049897559,
-0.0069026053,
0.0020689692,
0.0009425243,
-0.0237038247,
0.0334401727,
0.063365005,
-0.0566830784,
0.0034786852,
0.0107013891,
-0.0174754951,
0.0562884994,
-0.0480605476,
0.0850523114,
-0.0006916334,
0.0317883752,
-0.0144299194,
-0.0326941088,
-0.0259018578,
-0.0325488858,
-0.0497969687,
-0.0346095003,
0.0174651463,
0.0153049752,
-0.0046609999,
-0.047320351,
0.0404487923,
0.0103694163,
-0.0493591428,
-0.0377390757,
0.0205472577,
-0.0221319702,
-0.0029040927,
0.0282006897,
-0.0498397164,
0.0430591889,
-0.0285706986,
-0.0227035116,
0.0014168953,
0.0055130385,
-0.0082590841,
-0.0095470855,
-0.0285234265,
0.0121966591,
0.0674414188,
0.0410180241,
0.0913149416,
0.037584886,
-0.0278555024,
0.0324189812,
0.0329976752,
-0.0229924452,
0.0012622906,
-0.0223391149,
0.0282750409,
0.0578559898,
0.0440883152,
0.0347056799,
-0.0055084913,
0.0147532001,
-0.0863535702,
0.0146156736,
-0.015354095,
0.0688999444,
0.002972347,
0.0248186011,
-0.0487553068,
0.0039198739,
-0.029719593,
0.0215758849,
-0.0267115533,
-0.0320422761,
0.0301173218,
0.0023803664,
-0.0293480754,
-0.0168364849,
0.0104877865,
-0.0416229926,
-0.0257895533,
-0.013127761,
-0.0259696934,
0.0429183654,
-0.0288425963,
0.0372047462,
-0.0623001046,
-0.0590590723,
-0.0151187452,
-0.0041525252,
0.033223372,
0.0033202507,
0.0354572125,
0.049520772,
-0.0652298108,
-0.0052730767,
-0.0368184,
0.0032594516,
0.0278756078,
0.007383767,
0.0105256746,
0.0067658261,
-0.0004532151,
0.0676133037,
-0.0100094592,
-0.0353771374,
-0.0342029594,
-0.0201353282,
-0.0197885968,
0.0158180483,
-0.0404209755,
-0.0044871257,
-0.0386540405,
0.0085964752,
0.0305413697,
-0.0512869321,
-0.0246701818,
0.0206966456,
2.815e-7,
0.053909637,
0.0548963919,
-0.0006581974,
0.0395334512,
0.0006337588,
0.0422364846,
-0.0625601262,
-0.0050144931,
0.0340860672,
0.0178203881,
0.0101926662,
0.0667616203,
0.060545031,
0.0346187726,
-0.0385212153,
-0.0123576764,
-0.0461027734,
-0.0011608124,
-0.0408334918,
0.0023904296,
0.0506674275,
0.0819410607,
0.0114884879,
-0.0191068593,
-0.0120054781,
-0.0155823911,
0.0558488593,
-0.0126060518,
-0.028120134,
0.0341702923,
-0.0035541293,
0.0226524249,
0.0058776531,
0.0000426069,
-0.0051586935,
-0.0033107849,
-0.0328640938,
0.0569265187,
-0.0039093918,
0.015263577,
0.0071134032,
0.0017257504,
-0.0070492318,
-0.0339332558,
0.0357130282,
-0.0650930777,
-0.017281035,
-0.0274305698,
-0.019581262,
-0.0196911842,
-0.0055290749,
-0.0392132774,
-0.0025861841,
0.0060370527,
0.0016762022,
-0.010968714,
-0.0406988673,
-0.0494850837,
-0.0076637184,
0.0284025706,
-0.0265516993,
-0.0568474941,
-0.0391779765,
0.0256316159,
-0.0091319876,
-0.0546444021,
0.0183841828,
2.627636017e-34,
0.0499865748,
-0.0324030071,
0.0139708929,
0.0683724508,
0.0397444963,
-0.0007089573,
-0.0292964913,
0.0309009645,
0.0238053259,
-0.051071059,
-0.0209720917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00488v1 | PFME: A Modular Approach for Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing of Large Language Models | 2024-06-29T16:35:57 | 2024-06-29T16:35:57 | Kunquan Deng, Zeyu Huang, Chen Li, Chenghua Lin, Min Gao, Wenge Rong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in fluency but risk producing inaccurate
content, called "hallucinations." This paper outlines a standardized process
for categorizing fine-grained hallucination types and proposes an innovative
framework--the Progressive Fine-grained Model Editor (PFME)--specifically
designed to detect and correct fine-grained hallucinations in LLMs. PFME
consists of two collaborative modules: the Real-time Fact Retrieval Module and
the Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing Module. The former
identifies key entities in the document and retrieves the latest factual
evidence from credible sources. The latter further segments the document into
sentence-level text and, based on relevant evidence and previously edited
context, identifies, locates, and edits each sentence's hallucination type.
Experimental results on FavaBench and FActScore demonstrate that PFME
outperforms existing methods in fine-grained hallucination detection tasks.
Particularly, when using the Llama3-8B-Instruct model, PFME's performance in
fine-grained hallucination detection with external knowledge assistance
improves by 8.7 percentage points (pp) compared to ChatGPT. In editing tasks,
PFME further enhances the FActScore of FActScore-Alpaca13B and
FActScore-ChatGPT datasets, increasing by 16.2pp and 4.6pp, respectively. | PFME: A Modular Approach for Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing of Large Language Models: Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in fluency but risk producing inaccurate
content, called "hallucinations." This paper outlines a standardized process
for categorizing fine-grained hallucination types and proposes an innovative
framework--the Progressive Fine-grained Model Editor (PFME)--specifically
designed to detect and correct fine-grained hallucinations in LLMs. PFME
consists of two collaborative modules: the Real-time Fact Retrieval Module and
the Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing Module. The former
identifies key entities in the document and retrieves the latest factual
evidence from credible sources. The latter further segments the document into
sentence-level text and, based on relevant evidence and previously edited
context, identifies, locates, and edits each sentence's hallucination type.
Experimental results on FavaBench and FActScore demonstrate that PFME
outperforms existing methods in fine-grained hallucination detection tasks.
Particularly, when using the Llama3-8B-Instruct model, PFME's performance in
fine-grained hallucination detection with external knowledge assistance
improves by 8.7 percentage points (pp) compared to ChatGPT. In editing tasks,
PFME further enhances the FActScore of FActScore-Alpaca13B and
FActScore-ChatGPT datasets, increasing by 16.2pp and 4.6pp, respectively. | [
0.0565170832,
0.0111999288,
-0.0154402219,
0.0411041379,
-0.060357485,
0.0193325672,
-0.0438233763,
0.0040325467,
-0.0072639249,
-0.0876099691,
0.0135947848,
-0.0239795409,
-0.0084745446,
0.0017068762,
0.0229136106,
-0.0549072288,
0.0926380903,
-0.0431415923,
0.0410601534,
0.0107187312,
0.0216087624,
0.0118639013,
0.0169992335,
0.0364309028,
-0.0207788236,
-0.0408658348,
-0.0106379054,
-0.0098673841,
0.0085618868,
0.0215430949,
0.0009717063,
0.0865704641,
-0.0074488041,
0.0866835713,
0.0000024295,
-0.0572739094,
-0.0536976457,
0.003525702,
-0.0231716782,
0.0316491351,
0.0468484238,
0.0091144126,
-0.0495483652,
-0.0038733352,
-0.0157530792,
0.0096137179,
0.0252142977,
0.0927212685,
0.0605605356,
0.0763030425,
-0.0109561505,
-0.0236738361,
0.0436674431,
0.0425146781,
0.0321006365,
0.0351606347,
0.0549796186,
0.0380499437,
-0.008034463,
0.0086571807,
0.0264666751,
0.0334005989,
0.0015127787,
-0.0295309145,
-0.0007444816,
0.0045623025,
-0.1003081948,
-0.0179885756,
0.0198220536,
0.0363858193,
-0.0287447758,
-0.0510424115,
0.0190911293,
0.0057926099,
0.0230066087,
0.0064207679,
-0.0409533121,
0.0110023525,
-0.0357792862,
-0.0079495711,
0.0736002997,
-0.056776464,
0.0166931581,
0.011251797,
-0.0301941279,
0.0497747622,
0.0125943394,
-0.0441042706,
-0.0019187534,
-0.0183861852,
-0.0080026174,
-0.0634187907,
0.0411424264,
0.0164506193,
-0.0205494892,
-0.0146819167,
-0.0597518831,
-0.0098934034,
0.0572291128,
-0.1198392734,
-0.0176197737,
0.00308224,
-0.0732509643,
0.0796637014,
-0.008002826,
0.0109548355,
-0.0041582044,
0.0391755998,
-0.0008762392,
0.0102571007,
-0.0271250159,
-0.0072829966,
-0.0598659851,
0.0265261736,
-0.0230356138,
-0.0238850899,
0.002355986,
-0.0032097939,
-0.0214245562,
0.0485682152,
-0.0088918302,
-0.0206549168,
0.0034123631,
-0.0329593159,
-0.0097015742,
0.0289994646,
0.0003054819,
-0.0093111303,
0.0077304794,
-0.0626862347,
-0.0141251497,
0.0044308696,
0.0074039139,
-0.0055296659,
0.0051753088,
-0.0079913484,
0.0068601649,
-0.0187634025,
-0.0656887963,
-0.0521753356,
-0.016354667,
-0.0732864961,
-0.0337757133,
-0.0877325684,
-0.0072845989,
0.003408757,
-0.0201027617,
-0.0197445452,
0.0350317471,
0.0076706684,
-0.0415081978,
0.0553254448,
-0.0699746013,
0.0118632279,
0.0648586601,
0.0212313309,
0.004603805,
0.0803990513,
-0.0017640211,
0.0431676917,
0.0606132299,
-0.0042588897,
0.0320383385,
0.0379059166,
-0.031008264,
0.0189550016,
-0.0194673743,
0.0051982854,
0.0154442266,
-0.0091688316,
-0.0157376789,
0.0378721505,
-0.0093936762,
0.0044473507,
0.083116442,
-0.0095532136,
0.0097120786,
0.0119526954,
0.0148511082,
0.0224177372,
0.0255826339,
0.0425253585,
-0.0426431,
0.0063721812,
-0.0373159535,
-0.0028255717,
0.0455285981,
0.0345207043,
0.0070261932,
-0.0301955137,
-0.0191580299,
0.0080793602,
-0.0127901193,
-0.0055349953,
0.044782199,
0.0084045436,
-0.0527192093,
0.0511273704,
0.0372630432,
-0.0197163839,
-0.0069063078,
-0.0380797014,
-0.0082922159,
0.1195674986,
0.0811914131,
-0.0562614948,
-0.0144166807,
-0.0476046689,
0.0436567888,
0.0316664986,
0.0412613675,
-0.0083833002,
-0.0304440409,
-0.0451912768,
0.0092878398,
-0.0045216554,
0.0665929019,
-0.0087926826,
-0.0025093078,
-0.0167157073,
0.009799365,
-0.0242903363,
-0.0556452237,
0.0305230264,
0.0064469683,
0.0138077512,
-0.0549944267,
-0.0149632329,
-0.0129189249,
0.0036401663,
-0.0264448468,
0.0145548088,
0.0061073811,
-0.0275372714,
-0.0208295248,
0.0056086122,
0.0230207369,
0.0019910559,
0.0494849347,
0.0149642471,
-0.0273696762,
-0.0137933614,
0.006195731,
-0.0299198758,
-0.0326624177,
-0.0595102273,
0.0343848802,
-0.0604751669,
0.0756945387,
-0.0205778964,
0.0186066646,
-0.0179342218,
0.0871753618,
-0.0134439059,
-0.0012700706,
0.0250626206,
-0.0278770402,
-0.0155878151,
-0.0250207279,
-0.0184770785,
0.0204381049,
0.0061295843,
0.0034169308,
-0.0104627991,
-0.0475359708,
-0.0382720307,
-0.0359986909,
-0.062543124,
0.0199957173,
-0.0320266411,
0.0088937273,
0.0362466797,
-0.0074118404,
-0.0315777361,
0.0171578899,
0.0410565287,
0.001651859,
0.0032929052,
0.0402133279,
0.0068233879,
-0.000791306,
-0.0315073691,
-0.0280026458,
0.030656619,
-0.0248158444,
0.0307199918,
0.0041049565,
-0.0820801631,
-0.0775511563,
0.036940068,
-0.0297061708,
0.0162128154,
0.0073957546,
-0.0324714519,
-0.0264788158,
-0.0278147534,
0.0874653608,
0.0706216842,
0.007926248,
0.0423559584,
0.0643887371,
-0.0548039675,
-0.0323753022,
-0.0115896231,
0.0112224547,
0.0557442717,
-0.0089631053,
-0.0311378185,
0.0263698194,
0.0407199003,
0.0152411573,
0.0026270249,
-0.0274432488,
0.0375601128,
-0.0386576988,
-0.0210498944,
0.0365738869,
-0.0379541293,
-0.019877376,
0.032310728,
-0.0383606963,
-0.0328492112,
0.0506857187,
-0.0443621986,
0.0198126715,
-0.0104127685,
-0.0204913616,
0.0080374023,
0.0280478336,
0.0148534486,
0.0200374611,
-0.028879812,
-0.0342422426,
-0.0197763909,
0.0202584527,
0.0144103477,
-0.0567369387,
0.0275461189,
-0.0461658053,
0.0009229945,
0.0021928425,
0.0056392695,
-0.0254481379,
-0.0345869474,
-0.0212960336,
-0.0005033402,
0.0067620385,
-0.0022728122,
-0.0447458699,
0.0162159577,
0.0194749217,
0.0536694899,
-0.0462286882,
-0.0033736308,
-0.0108394558,
-0.0003176871,
0.0526322611,
-0.0306761712,
0.0443359576,
-0.042202469,
0.0390121043,
0.0797443911,
-0.0235486347,
-0.0009498701,
-0.0188405924,
-0.0512089208,
-0.0094751436,
-0.0620928444,
-0.0432875492,
-0.0223809537,
0.0329432115,
-0.0936531797,
-0.0183632765,
0.1243964881,
0.0476285741,
-0.0335920788,
-0.0159935039,
-0.0661908984,
0.0211402774,
0.0172365364,
0.0155578107,
-0.0881457627,
-0.0138684772,
0.0297423247,
-0.0157464501,
-0.0480271503,
-0.0177982282,
0.0008474714,
-0.0661249459,
0.0670581684,
0.0102498336,
0.0031811565,
-0.0373721831,
-0.0235118121,
0.0239808541,
0.0241921432,
-0.0074207433,
0.0012117234,
0.0102331741,
-0.0120631736,
-0.0127077894,
-0.0399007685,
-0.0354837477,
0.0093917763,
-0.0140765011,
0.0635428429,
0.0532467142,
0.0369970649,
-0.0126599856,
-0.0378483124,
0.0566821881,
0.00218991,
-0.016950313,
-0.0062957383,
0.0724881291,
0.008992333,
0.0174746905,
-0.0140519412,
0.0086107999,
0.0395204686,
-0.0225487724,
0.0168834198,
0.097437501,
-0.0553624406,
-0.0101782931,
-0.0080505712,
0.0267816763,
0.0103480639,
0.0799457505,
0.0351500995,
0.0015243618,
-0.0312230363,
-0.0336746685,
0.0241776165,
-0.0221336149,
-0.0346630737,
0.0350374617,
-0.0048268475,
-0.0323907211,
-0.0732052773,
-0.0209428445,
0.050579749,
0.0070518409,
0.0240822285,
0.0701766536,
-0.002309399,
-0.0169014148,
-0.0306520127,
-0.0115956226,
-0.0455958247,
0.013634068,
-0.0320302807,
-0.0062580225,
0.0150414789,
-0.0023906163,
-0.0092588197,
0.0242285579,
-0.0722008124,
-0.0653275996,
0.0535771325,
0.0078114565,
0.0213584825,
0.0303950161,
-0.0327620767,
-0.0578158908,
0.0305037796,
0.0442868248,
-0.0428090729,
0.0049136304,
-0.0014803277,
-0.0259204395,
0.0008009879,
0.0307279043,
-0.024210263,
0.0014331988,
-0.0272966139,
0.0100412359,
-0.0265436638,
-0.0245711487,
0.0338421427,
0.0224048719,
0.0095114363,
0.013136941,
-0.0120138265,
-0.0471363738,
0.0180425774,
-0.0325154662,
-0.0418030992,
-0.0151038738,
0.0279525332,
0.0170481242,
-0.0302120708,
0.0159874614,
0.0206870604,
-0.0357858799,
0.005680861,
-0.0372022241,
-0.0083479118,
-0.0120062651,
0.0251497701,
0.0500325002,
-0.0375012718,
-0.0192263909,
0.028368108,
0.0033968878,
0.0344199911,
-0.0312366504,
0.0706948489,
-0.001424999,
-0.0428737178,
-0.0234045628,
0.0257599875,
-0.0410793386,
-0.0372710414,
-0.0433320329,
0.0581731796,
0.050032936,
-0.0060833422,
0.0805826932,
-0.0452119224,
-0.0237533152,
-0.0171171352,
0.0341996588,
0.0556198619,
-0.0366152376,
-0.0226759594,
0.0261486694,
-0.0402660221,
0.0067169359,
0.0587204248,
-0.0368521437,
0.0737505779,
0.0278642811,
-0.0485858321,
-0.0261197351,
-0.06062622,
-0.0510870367,
-0.005406613,
-0.0325988717,
-0.0394879431,
-0.065684557,
-0.011732772,
-0.0080010863,
0.0130985016,
-0.0380101688,
-0.0045837783,
-0.0311725363,
0.0723582059,
-0.0209325664,
-0.0345672406,
-0.034415096,
0.0067586489,
0.0387336425,
-0.0068329619,
0.0217069108,
-6.912408572e-33,
-0.0211863462,
-0.0416535102,
0.0062259636,
-0.005765744,
-0.028175097,
-0.0174248572,
-0.0220509823,
-0.0042939405,
0.017635012,
0.0264910422,
0.0014733528,
0.0361651443,
0.0279445294,
-0.032773193,
0.0037488539,
0.0052176374,
0.0665543005,
0.021162983,
-0.0039574369,
0.0402177237,
0.0425704308,
0.0151244113,
0.0725723132,
-0.0735489801,
0.0394416638,
-0.0139993727,
-0.026864402,
0.0211475212,
-0.0131354053,
0.0448308103,
-0.0078896703,
0.0062860255,
0.022689322,
-0.0526257195,
-0.0334928446,
-0.0223862212,
-0.0261014346,
0.0166659355,
0.0045476081,
0.0226298161,
0.0202683583,
-0.0507522039,
0.0434620045,
-0.019198468,
0.0304163322,
0.0014204533,
0.0500224009,
-0.0594077595,
-0.0111593818,
0.0172033962,
-0.0879119784,
0.0438229553,
-0.0014967136,
0.0034053307,
0.0020397361,
0.0245508906,
0.0320222229,
-0.0301416311,
-0.0839025378,
0.0251497105,
0.0428666919,
0.0239285957,
0.0162454266,
-0.036911834,
-0.0070276959,
0.0608154833,
0.0304626394,
0.0290113557,
-0.0180575494,
0.0038468856,
0.0214974657,
0.0663590208,
0.0120544434,
0.055189129,
0.0349963643,
-0.0113525735,
-0.0264651962,
0.0182861909,
-0.0435738452,
0.0299296789,
0.0475022458,
0.0012754388,
-0.0520309098,
-0.0174107216,
0.000517527,
0.0182290468,
-0.03483136,
-0.0136650288,
0.0277520102,
-0.0140593555,
-0.0316550098,
-0.0057089622,
0.0392701514,
-0.0209206622,
0.0091615682,
0.0198496766,
-0.040274106,
0.0374301597,
-0.0154837761,
0.012989739,
-0.0158233605,
-0.0107559124,
0.0223130696,
-0.0128163481,
0.0152093712,
0.0376777239,
0.0333770774,
-0.0072412142,
-0.0799443051,
0.0193177108,
-0.0138269523,
0.0179257318,
-0.0098951925,
-0.0079081981,
0.0451567657,
-0.0167188197,
-0.0035189153,
0.0096345423,
0.0725285634,
0.033187747,
-0.0245406162,
0.0167070087,
-0.0300069097,
0.0017388151,
-0.0129066007,
0.0180455912,
-0.0361540988,
-0.0216460321,
0.0210346319,
-0.0631622598,
0.0092143686,
-0.0021582574,
3.054e-7,
0.027417507,
0.0915535465,
0.0042889561,
-0.0047064321,
0.0020790971,
0.0138314562,
0.0035347957,
-0.0186887383,
0.0328400321,
-0.0335563831,
-0.0083574345,
0.007779913,
0.0556916147,
0.0738437399,
-0.0876406133,
-0.0002995133,
-0.0285196453,
-0.0144064976,
-0.1023064107,
-0.0541834794,
0.0279195029,
0.0535004735,
0.0231776275,
-0.0134741561,
-0.0077420683,
-0.0653090328,
0.0429446921,
-0.0192683749,
-0.0347417854,
0.0548702851,
0.0579313412,
0.0453072079,
0.0110375891,
0.0383444615,
-0.0216875933,
-0.0109806582,
-0.0039159548,
0.0441057198,
-0.004341478,
0.0333014838,
0.0049124509,
-0.0323143527,
-0.0044175191,
-0.0739030987,
0.085014157,
-0.008347244,
-0.004231933,
-0.0314504504,
-0.0394124202,
-0.0170679148,
0.0234331582,
-0.0189002939,
-0.0104871094,
0.0307111889,
-0.0030868214,
0.0165883992,
-0.0293955524,
-0.0322946161,
-0.0134560168,
0.0128304195,
-0.0092130471,
-0.0315809511,
-0.0071999291,
-0.0335269496,
-0.020908542,
-0.0885687396,
0.0310383774,
3.425727804e-34,
0.034741465,
0.0114069656,
0.0284919403,
0.0325959064,
0.0572320558,
0.0066287788,
0.0169556811,
0.0115809739,
-0.031616427,
-0.0613137148,
-0.0043502818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00487v1 | It's Morphing Time: Unleashing the Potential of Multiple LLMs via Multi-objective Optimization | 2024-06-29T16:34:23 | 2024-06-29T16:34:23 | Bingdong Li, Zixiang Di, Yanting Yang, Hong Qian, Peng Yang, Hao Hao, Ke Tang, Aimin Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce a novel approach for large language model merging
via black-box multi-objective optimization algorithms. The goal of model
merging is to combine multiple models, each excelling in different tasks, into
a single model that outperforms any of the individual source models. However,
model merging faces two significant challenges: First, existing methods rely
heavily on human intuition and customized strategies. Second, parameter
conflicts often arise during merging, and while methods like DARE [1] can
alleviate this issue, they tend to stochastically drop parameters, risking the
loss of important delta parameters. To address these challenges, we propose the
MM-MO method, which automates the search for optimal merging configurations
using multi-objective optimization algorithms, eliminating the need for human
intuition. During the configuration searching process, we use estimated
performance across multiple diverse tasks as optimization objectives in order
to alleviate the parameter conflicting between different source models without
losing crucial delta parameters. We conducted comparative experiments with
other mainstream model merging methods, demonstrating that our method
consistently outperforms them. Moreover, our experiments reveal that even task
types not explicitly targeted as optimization objectives show performance
improvements, indicating that our method enhances the overall potential of the
model rather than merely overfitting to specific task types. This approach
provides a significant advancement in model merging techniques, offering a
robust and plug-and-play solution for integrating diverse models into a
unified, high-performing model. | It's Morphing Time: Unleashing the Potential of Multiple LLMs via Multi-objective Optimization: In this paper, we introduce a novel approach for large language model merging
via black-box multi-objective optimization algorithms. The goal of model
merging is to combine multiple models, each excelling in different tasks, into
a single model that outperforms any of the individual source models. However,
model merging faces two significant challenges: First, existing methods rely
heavily on human intuition and customized strategies. Second, parameter
conflicts often arise during merging, and while methods like DARE [1] can
alleviate this issue, they tend to stochastically drop parameters, risking the
loss of important delta parameters. To address these challenges, we propose the
MM-MO method, which automates the search for optimal merging configurations
using multi-objective optimization algorithms, eliminating the need for human
intuition. During the configuration searching process, we use estimated
performance across multiple diverse tasks as optimization objectives in order
to alleviate the parameter conflicting between different source models without
losing crucial delta parameters. We conducted comparative experiments with
other mainstream model merging methods, demonstrating that our method
consistently outperforms them. Moreover, our experiments reveal that even task
types not explicitly targeted as optimization objectives show performance
improvements, indicating that our method enhances the overall potential of the
model rather than merely overfitting to specific task types. This approach
provides a significant advancement in model merging techniques, offering a
robust and plug-and-play solution for integrating diverse models into a
unified, high-performing model. | [
-0.0222295504,
0.073844716,
0.0139996894,
0.0168386213,
-0.0291013476,
0.0282226373,
-0.0215123612,
-0.0225936398,
-0.0337112211,
-0.0225387271,
-0.0629902631,
0.0082892487,
0.0482930019,
-0.019754393,
0.0345593616,
-0.0198046286,
0.0601715632,
-0.0572878718,
-0.0635758713,
-0.0068938797,
-0.0302884318,
0.0254424643,
0.0234471485,
0.0433155745,
0.0287973471,
0.0196852293,
-0.0065532639,
0.0283226259,
0.024087688,
0.0371389389,
0.0233786479,
0.0468536913,
0.0045766593,
0.0447847024,
0.0000020504,
-0.0575678721,
-0.024373563,
0.0004937897,
-0.0153831393,
0.0010563463,
0.073168911,
0.0002799461,
-0.0170089938,
0.0320586562,
-0.0084904302,
0.0059874346,
0.0494927354,
0.0206268989,
0.0513050668,
0.062987186,
-0.002387543,
-0.013157499,
0.0236960016,
-0.0204896517,
-0.0182314478,
-0.0324348658,
0.0412323996,
-0.0019735279,
-0.0094506145,
-0.0228202716,
-0.0031709541,
0.0284632854,
-0.0232269038,
0.0018294801,
-0.0065793996,
0.0062104282,
-0.0091819586,
-0.0381267816,
-0.0392436907,
0.0430624895,
-0.0730247572,
0.001486166,
0.0331696831,
0.0009114803,
0.0060381908,
-0.0132363252,
-0.0612514578,
-0.0039831763,
0.0112573868,
0.0171742141,
0.008556853,
-0.0275230668,
0.0439485796,
0.0218622908,
-0.036088407,
0.0681151748,
0.0443010405,
-0.0213909391,
0.0205957089,
-0.0284185074,
0.0079663387,
-0.0722092912,
-0.0230756328,
0.0320358947,
-0.0579563826,
0.0204225443,
-0.0742305666,
-0.0198058169,
0.0067361966,
-0.0250093751,
0.0880785361,
0.0403508879,
-0.0064090225,
0.0457879305,
-0.0318012051,
0.0471851416,
-0.0386161059,
-0.0124729341,
-0.0807319432,
-0.0094417902,
-0.0534326509,
0.0220875069,
0.014695311,
0.0199793503,
-0.0422760807,
-0.0176736098,
-0.0419669151,
0.0164456386,
-0.0157452188,
0.0056475271,
0.0535577573,
-0.0098784659,
-0.0106565319,
-0.0116714984,
-0.0053124456,
0.0240121167,
0.0276593771,
0.0124746021,
-0.0033048135,
-0.0120182121,
-0.0094883991,
0.01295543,
-0.0231485981,
-0.0253043957,
-0.0000860216,
0.0914164335,
-0.0359546915,
0.028645793,
-0.0282316189,
-0.048780866,
0.0018806494,
-0.0444473065,
0.0126250079,
-0.0712504163,
0.0618373603,
-0.0498265214,
-0.0051347413,
-0.0306271538,
0.0125794057,
-0.0207827035,
-0.0123921167,
0.0541591384,
-0.0124102589,
0.0434819646,
0.0423554406,
0.0132422065,
-0.0214099921,
0.1038220897,
0.0002828022,
0.0159658007,
-0.000323991,
0.009432435,
-0.0117740314,
0.0781709701,
-0.0197459403,
0.0200064108,
0.0091839125,
-0.0529078059,
0.0380553044,
0.0158985686,
0.0445998162,
0.0033147004,
-0.0172990952,
0.0215284973,
0.0400924832,
0.0122643774,
0.0561530627,
0.0097037079,
0.024660781,
-0.0090941414,
0.0066423332,
-0.0073169149,
-0.0431543179,
0.0180962998,
-0.044634819,
0.0328643322,
0.0014025238,
0.1139790267,
-0.0058870264,
-0.0521311611,
-0.0402996913,
-0.0199120268,
-0.0515734404,
0.0029288821,
0.04119711,
0.0008477788,
-0.0914849341,
0.0589793287,
0.0117656952,
-0.0483376496,
-0.0142095517,
-0.0514989868,
-0.046913106,
0.027229609,
0.0165140498,
-0.0018557125,
-0.0623081587,
0.0143202543,
0.0025295266,
0.0183309484,
0.0561615676,
-0.0063829687,
0.0333748236,
-0.0642493293,
-0.0590624176,
0.009576017,
0.0243641846,
0.0489605665,
0.0158317443,
-0.0287718605,
0.0234983023,
-0.0073730247,
-0.0480503924,
0.0309539773,
-0.0713225827,
0.0061251838,
-0.0167575236,
-0.0154867312,
0.0272305384,
-0.0081530632,
-0.0067949574,
0.0124227349,
0.0031028478,
-0.00073785,
-0.0357418433,
0.0172121413,
-0.0154743986,
-0.000859854,
0.0523812585,
0.0189779922,
-0.0192590449,
0.0211111885,
-0.0450350791,
-0.0665320009,
-0.0284458753,
-0.0075556282,
0.0578479879,
0.0003609711,
0.0608257875,
-0.0100975353,
-0.0062083122,
-0.0322692245,
0.0672979504,
-0.0163880978,
-0.0217678286,
0.0426860452,
-0.0257757343,
0.0122631779,
-0.0060035139,
-0.0124111082,
0.0214445293,
-0.0236518234,
0.0262768287,
-0.0081119742,
-0.0002138107,
-0.0499326661,
-0.0713606775,
-0.1032697558,
0.0401239842,
0.0197085813,
0.0319575928,
0.0215682089,
0.0005561833,
0.0026227348,
0.0465325788,
0.0158750415,
-0.0058603873,
-0.0285254996,
0.0136604952,
-0.009527253,
-0.0089834398,
-0.0270001907,
-0.0590701513,
-0.023077732,
-0.0438912176,
0.0501734987,
-0.0277802199,
-0.0228624083,
-0.0441833809,
0.0581475832,
-0.0439365208,
0.0059390599,
-0.0189424716,
-0.0143390708,
-0.011568442,
-0.0182413049,
0.0750680342,
0.0709053501,
-0.0205418784,
-0.0180612113,
0.0909402445,
-0.062128298,
-0.039492812,
0.0083896564,
0.0353643484,
-0.028927831,
-0.0246074703,
-0.0494006611,
0.0078049814,
0.075045757,
-0.0153404986,
-0.0081661483,
-0.0356183983,
-0.0087186452,
-0.0321324356,
-0.0378598049,
-0.0249592811,
-0.0145458495,
-0.0289434288,
0.0523611121,
-0.038020052,
-0.0424781106,
0.0293893889,
-0.0166055094,
-0.0080393068,
-0.0086020622,
-0.014357782,
-0.0510478653,
-0.0049997484,
-0.0302488375,
0.0098394146,
0.0287134796,
-0.0262347851,
-0.0859860107,
-0.0073447744,
0.0433833189,
-0.0226166863,
0.0711233169,
-0.0500487871,
0.0002147727,
-0.0133879976,
-0.027818596,
-0.0182728581,
0.0120245703,
-0.0259339642,
0.0182054136,
-0.0001447187,
-0.0511684567,
-0.0775379539,
-0.0259256344,
-0.0166793261,
0.0219322965,
-0.0342987739,
-0.0123938946,
-0.0319721363,
-0.0002067012,
0.0508199483,
0.0298271403,
0.0214003716,
-0.0471137092,
0.0375784449,
-0.0027550359,
0.0587819256,
-0.0049941503,
-0.0522687696,
0.0026932417,
0.0657748133,
-0.0437056459,
-0.0474963523,
0.0030747766,
0.0166468769,
-0.0386197083,
0.0493640192,
0.1136910543,
0.0184523109,
0.0000242283,
-0.0182165336,
-0.039479427,
0.0586547963,
0.0225683227,
0.0409405939,
-0.0044605839,
-0.0292807203,
0.0182226803,
-0.0210832749,
0.0133250551,
0.0012937869,
-0.0371072479,
-0.0953177735,
0.0045748083,
0.0476953089,
-0.0124667194,
0.0576171577,
0.0097010545,
0.0153056793,
-0.0407618806,
0.0077723991,
0.0071558109,
-0.0152619965,
-0.0451108925,
-0.0121883024,
-0.0030502849,
-0.0295649096,
-0.0006845586,
-0.0109518981,
0.0347012505,
0.0519018397,
0.0219362136,
0.0066490504,
-0.0197311174,
0.1078095511,
0.0469685756,
-0.0020839919,
-0.012995081,
0.0149467271,
0.0164914671,
0.0058206175,
-0.001121012,
0.0045378534,
-0.022010494,
-0.0323409624,
-0.0127892429,
0.0589420646,
0.0282400865,
-0.0120601011,
-0.0093313139,
-0.0239701644,
-0.0247054026,
0.0517845936,
-0.0246807076,
-0.0382642187,
-0.0114258295,
0.0070406827,
-0.0524026044,
-0.0189720616,
-0.0113325082,
0.0040880749,
-0.0300105624,
-0.0397112072,
-0.0451798625,
0.0058116685,
0.0144147379,
0.0244734846,
0.0210105497,
0.0296605211,
-0.0155922491,
-0.0081596216,
-0.0420204662,
0.0290835164,
-0.0138117513,
0.0135626392,
-0.0576099232,
0.0215710513,
0.0422069468,
-0.0009995513,
-0.0130229378,
0.0176727399,
-0.133516863,
-0.0802334845,
-0.0246209279,
0.0449870341,
0.0177987497,
0.0213276837,
0.0049316217,
-0.0491440147,
0.0326678492,
0.0184554663,
0.0284955353,
0.0429685451,
0.0528953187,
-0.0005123243,
-0.0011008732,
0.0200678222,
-0.0562926382,
-0.0162425153,
-0.0010088468,
-0.0149965398,
-0.0462757386,
-0.0363681465,
-0.0059180441,
-0.0020992649,
0.0076467181,
-0.0368072391,
-0.0337839052,
-0.0366042554,
-0.0016145365,
-0.0127468929,
-0.0280777868,
-0.0322220325,
0.0271445047,
0.0336679295,
0.0146160303,
0.0587600805,
0.0507684238,
0.0324797705,
-0.0235102233,
-0.0185800828,
-0.009965824,
-0.0236163475,
-0.0167479049,
0.0234248582,
0.0199099164,
-0.0027818228,
0.035698209,
-0.0166425798,
0.0101337042,
-0.0297748931,
0.0115564605,
-0.0066297669,
0.0304754321,
-0.0216288511,
0.0417914428,
-0.0581486113,
-0.0720446259,
-0.0460490696,
-0.0059216269,
0.0809786767,
0.0050171833,
0.1003539488,
-0.0177533664,
-0.0095281852,
-0.0237986147,
0.0232761391,
-0.0226548221,
0.0265553594,
0.0319575258,
0.0187713541,
0.0076968931,
-0.0400658958,
0.0488167331,
-0.0017218206,
0.0261932369,
-0.0185142476,
0.0221655592,
-0.0252812896,
-0.0388301499,
0.050376825,
0.0127238818,
-0.0160215311,
-0.0503770895,
-0.0332908034,
-0.0376543961,
0.0254755691,
0.0299309082,
-0.0324381776,
0.0178639274,
0.0377601795,
0.0321527719,
-0.0373337604,
0.0020637126,
-0.0070597571,
-0.0771054476,
0.0008580654,
-0.0341007523,
0.0224947706,
-6.160745322e-33,
-0.0334863923,
-0.0395956933,
0.0286552943,
-0.0346861221,
-0.0413563065,
-0.0044280919,
0.0145348422,
0.0158280581,
-0.021661479,
-0.0361974388,
-0.0050658262,
0.0044823936,
0.0176735055,
-0.0211786143,
0.0224201791,
0.0169563722,
0.0332194082,
0.0212102309,
-0.0158283524,
-0.0481640473,
-0.018494498,
0.0185611751,
0.025041448,
-0.037236847,
0.0056365682,
0.0380842835,
-0.0430117697,
0.024247352,
0.0044737528,
0.0714096725,
0.0154551556,
0.0131175388,
0.0009219375,
-0.0304297414,
-0.0621649809,
0.0027280899,
-0.0062790178,
-0.0497588031,
0.063316077,
0.0031025421,
-0.0200216826,
-0.0547002219,
0.042661503,
0.0255928133,
0.0085008983,
-0.0739167929,
0.0357366093,
-0.0085215,
-0.0179713462,
0.0074901688,
-0.0701941922,
0.0120889675,
0.0222453866,
-0.0177080277,
0.0665171519,
0.0111717898,
0.009794699,
-0.0085118916,
0.0030880012,
0.0354453102,
-0.0023418649,
0.0738464147,
0.1282291114,
0.0851101652,
-0.0280449819,
0.0320285223,
-0.0085427975,
-0.0064550098,
0.0143431798,
-0.0272888094,
0.0347136259,
0.1011351869,
0.0364925601,
0.0269596726,
-0.0066322978,
0.03010552,
0.0046563772,
0.0703290254,
0.023075344,
0.0065388,
-0.0155436797,
0.0608953461,
0.0222933367,
-0.003249648,
-0.0466329791,
0.0254557133,
-0.0423707142,
0.0031718153,
0.0176085569,
-0.0070173936,
0.0042057754,
-0.0179434456,
0.0259675998,
-0.046914991,
0.0244738124,
0.0145860855,
-0.0272025615,
0.0414888449,
-0.0119381333,
0.0302856117,
-0.0085987011,
-0.04805867,
0.0211742036,
0.0369287431,
0.0474714153,
0.0010076571,
-0.0348880477,
0.0130378604,
-0.0717905909,
0.0168424882,
-0.0277123116,
-0.028493451,
0.0262596663,
0.0047264816,
0.0673770607,
-0.0259791519,
0.00031106,
0.0077487486,
0.0340125486,
-0.0185158327,
-0.0485189483,
0.0304716583,
0.0083402013,
0.0351077951,
0.0137999682,
0.0227131583,
-0.0003728289,
-0.0117279924,
0.0616907738,
0.017950505,
-0.0550075099,
0.0385779254,
2.694e-7,
0.0372898877,
0.0183717012,
-0.0212078318,
0.0357252359,
-0.0214070082,
0.0345624685,
-0.0346325263,
0.0003772549,
-0.009315514,
-0.0218392704,
0.004460365,
0.0245619435,
0.0712797865,
0.0068838475,
-0.0758373961,
-0.0430184454,
-0.0003668032,
0.0387644619,
-0.0532616787,
-0.0141856344,
0.0466068275,
0.0749579221,
0.0199653916,
-0.0183668323,
-0.046903871,
-0.0029762837,
0.0616684072,
-0.0427423641,
-0.003945353,
0.0638436228,
-0.0254870486,
-0.0091900723,
-0.02945319,
0.0161221679,
-0.0267682448,
0.0085177589,
0.0227846801,
0.0910339728,
-0.0173485912,
-0.0306870118,
0.0231887009,
0.0365431271,
-0.0307701007,
-0.0251687132,
0.0472661331,
-0.0109287715,
-0.0133580249,
-0.0748432279,
0.0353493206,
0.0091876602,
0.011349679,
-0.019799076,
0.0107273469,
0.0378184877,
0.0147497943,
0.0033413074,
-0.0388977267,
-0.0637922734,
-0.0356103331,
0.0554730371,
-0.0491204038,
-0.0673952699,
-0.029709436,
0.0036712429,
0.0402075201,
-0.0700319111,
-0.0420190506,
2.95090959e-34,
0.0052906512,
-0.033156164,
0.0519399904,
0.0864491761,
0.0034745736,
0.0056375726,
-0.0662941262,
0.0470527336,
-0.0017471247,
-0.0360794626,
-0.0077113668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00486v1 | Towards Massive Multilingual Holistic Bias | 2024-06-29T16:26:27 | 2024-06-29T16:26:27 | Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Prangthip Hansanti, Carleigh Wood, Bokai Yu, Christophe Ropers, Marta R. Costa-jussà | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | In the current landscape of automatic language generation, there is a need to
understand, evaluate, and mitigate demographic biases as existing models are
becoming increasingly multilingual. To address this, we present the initial
eight languages from the MASSIVE MULTILINGUAL HOLISTICBIAS (MMHB) dataset and
benchmark consisting of approximately 6 million sentences representing 13
demographic axes. We propose an automatic construction methodology to further
scale up MMHB sentences in terms of both language coverage and size, leveraging
limited human annotation. Our approach utilizes placeholders in multilingual
sentence construction and employs a systematic method to independently
translate sentence patterns, nouns, and descriptors. Combined with human
translation, this technique carefully designs placeholders to dynamically
generate multiple sentence variations and significantly reduces the human
translation workload. The translation process has been meticulously conducted
to avoid an English-centric perspective and include all necessary morphological
variations for languages that require them, improving from the original English
HOLISTICBIAS. Finally, we utilize MMHB to report results on gender bias and
added toxicity in machine translation tasks. On the gender analysis, MMHB
unveils: (1) a lack of gender robustness showing almost +4 chrf points in
average for masculine semantic sentences compared to feminine ones and (2) a
preference to overgeneralize to masculine forms by reporting more than +12 chrf
points in average when evaluating with masculine compared to feminine
references. MMHB triggers added toxicity up to 2.3%. | Towards Massive Multilingual Holistic Bias: In the current landscape of automatic language generation, there is a need to
understand, evaluate, and mitigate demographic biases as existing models are
becoming increasingly multilingual. To address this, we present the initial
eight languages from the MASSIVE MULTILINGUAL HOLISTICBIAS (MMHB) dataset and
benchmark consisting of approximately 6 million sentences representing 13
demographic axes. We propose an automatic construction methodology to further
scale up MMHB sentences in terms of both language coverage and size, leveraging
limited human annotation. Our approach utilizes placeholders in multilingual
sentence construction and employs a systematic method to independently
translate sentence patterns, nouns, and descriptors. Combined with human
translation, this technique carefully designs placeholders to dynamically
generate multiple sentence variations and significantly reduces the human
translation workload. The translation process has been meticulously conducted
to avoid an English-centric perspective and include all necessary morphological
variations for languages that require them, improving from the original English
HOLISTICBIAS. Finally, we utilize MMHB to report results on gender bias and
added toxicity in machine translation tasks. On the gender analysis, MMHB
unveils: (1) a lack of gender robustness showing almost +4 chrf points in
average for masculine semantic sentences compared to feminine ones and (2) a
preference to overgeneralize to masculine forms by reporting more than +12 chrf
points in average when evaluating with masculine compared to feminine
references. MMHB triggers added toxicity up to 2.3%. | [
0.0405130163,
0.0853073671,
-0.0229158681,
-0.0055097407,
-0.008126677,
0.0134891057,
0.052867122,
-0.0405938998,
-0.0100714453,
-0.0398158468,
-0.0165082216,
-0.0710971504,
0.0254265703,
-0.0168306883,
0.0679787919,
-0.0341977179,
0.0148931481,
0.0032837007,
-0.0054732319,
-0.0321992114,
0.0101202512,
0.0669769868,
0.0360720865,
0.0458014198,
-0.050442297,
0.0005422465,
0.0056609223,
0.0403324738,
0.0367431827,
-0.0128593259,
0.0274493862,
0.0616916269,
-0.0251481906,
0.0470066071,
0.0000022062,
-0.0676366463,
-0.0021353276,
0.0165401474,
0.0280302428,
-0.0064687999,
0.0769799799,
-0.0571849793,
-0.0158773176,
0.0111067919,
-0.0050311307,
0.0056502251,
0.0409914814,
0.0048094238,
0.023413321,
0.0311788395,
-0.0249784775,
-0.0070996187,
-0.0495386757,
-0.033161886,
-0.0143024269,
0.0084577855,
-0.0005272636,
-0.0280697867,
-0.0448647439,
0.0032056591,
-0.0035276248,
0.0218136944,
-0.0030404534,
-0.0245724432,
-0.0080880774,
0.0045724846,
-0.0412487537,
-0.0835399926,
0.028192386,
0.0688826442,
-0.0328518376,
-0.0005035561,
0.0093493136,
-0.0069229626,
-0.0013412343,
-0.0356066227,
-0.0221162606,
0.069251664,
-0.0066300859,
-0.015956929,
0.0151930787,
-0.0269122757,
0.000154372,
0.038041357,
-0.0003469805,
0.0405217223,
0.0431188382,
-0.0251550972,
0.0380067565,
0.0331702009,
-0.0149939694,
-0.0617921539,
0.0307278521,
-0.0233830102,
-0.0466159135,
0.0094217956,
-0.0507891364,
-0.0521869585,
0.0664987266,
-0.0907166004,
0.0196690094,
0.0396997221,
-0.0149457706,
-0.0126013793,
-0.023708038,
0.0120804915,
-0.0052631944,
-0.0485862084,
-0.0716597214,
-0.0306605827,
0.0279718228,
0.0048690671,
-0.0491875932,
-0.0217130221,
-0.0625198409,
0.0386501551,
-0.0887795314,
0.0169354379,
-0.0243739616,
-0.0257272832,
-0.0007852478,
0.0207324848,
-0.0601964779,
0.0130141089,
0.0226588789,
0.0445390865,
-0.0765453875,
0.0048891837,
-0.0105205756,
-0.0899547562,
-0.0003904488,
0.0551624112,
0.0003927191,
-0.0401307158,
-0.0071994332,
0.0483791381,
-0.0156177292,
0.0048292875,
-0.011361164,
-0.066620335,
-0.0587488115,
-0.0575906076,
-0.0031944537,
-0.068029739,
0.053969495,
0.0094468072,
-0.0047757868,
-0.035022568,
0.0215195157,
0.0401478186,
-0.0282099787,
0.023799764,
0.0306853317,
0.0017216927,
0.0417417996,
-0.0276186224,
0.0059340857,
0.1017594635,
0.0492894202,
0.0331381559,
0.0506424829,
0.0222448464,
-0.0314003937,
0.0622640289,
0.0045767212,
0.0436275862,
-0.0201134905,
-0.0105939275,
-0.0188149922,
0.0700245202,
0.0822841749,
0.0379395895,
0.0077737062,
0.0237127859,
0.0715687498,
0.0242776629,
-0.0201957468,
0.0532619283,
0.0907508135,
0.0171671845,
-0.0366167873,
-0.0123739587,
-0.037093021,
0.0071978341,
-0.0117845125,
-0.0048531061,
0.0021857817,
0.0703858584,
0.0041589187,
-0.0348990746,
-0.0067789806,
0.027798038,
-0.0065184333,
-0.0095638875,
0.0078066885,
0.0347873271,
-0.0060420651,
0.0744062662,
0.0416926742,
-0.0813496038,
0.0146367745,
0.0157456845,
-0.0022853652,
0.0551807396,
-0.0073077204,
0.0079951258,
-0.0328930542,
-0.0173956752,
0.0004080024,
0.0627885535,
0.056690786,
0.0011011044,
0.0396845639,
-0.0690788627,
-0.0001590064,
0.0263645742,
0.0090859411,
0.0518455282,
0.0275167525,
0.0544628017,
0.0436287709,
-0.033331234,
-0.0694690272,
0.0295268502,
-0.0155881792,
0.0033663765,
0.0659933463,
0.0136659583,
0.0219633821,
0.014593442,
-0.0228462499,
0.0036592195,
0.0051544229,
-0.0323218703,
-0.0050919927,
0.0510344841,
-0.0200965777,
-0.0185520146,
0.0101426821,
-0.0559389256,
-0.062091276,
-0.0154287089,
-0.0125660254,
-0.0222006142,
0.0365875475,
-0.0418010689,
-0.0522076078,
-0.0300986134,
0.0125138592,
0.0275233816,
0.0630683452,
-0.0324823521,
0.0394541435,
0.0119048618,
-0.0393864661,
0.0035509206,
-0.0452193767,
0.0241217837,
-0.0840757638,
-0.0192164537,
-0.0064551309,
-0.0081533128,
0.0050949575,
0.0587556735,
0.0307280757,
-0.0346404612,
-0.0405439436,
-0.0842652619,
0.0024109117,
-0.0134021612,
0.0130030196,
0.0154054025,
0.0227658339,
-0.0227626543,
0.0057304185,
-0.013130934,
-0.0162161794,
0.0177886039,
0.0535361096,
0.0432935879,
-0.0345056728,
0.0357905589,
-0.0150259091,
-0.0155293709,
-0.0300275404,
0.0426380374,
0.0382037796,
0.0041923304,
-0.0361298472,
-0.018611066,
-0.0435704812,
-0.0657671988,
0.0228896756,
-0.0573694892,
0.0081648035,
0.0232371073,
0.080533281,
0.0673261657,
0.0074482467,
0.0118112424,
0.0559379049,
0.0128198117,
-0.0142164463,
-0.000961897,
0.0136985742,
0.019071864,
0.013848708,
-0.0731320605,
0.0001190189,
-0.0006230311,
0.0287297294,
-0.0310558714,
-0.0419319384,
0.0241205133,
-0.0339950137,
-0.0637467355,
-0.0350724421,
-0.001778277,
0.0037845187,
0.0384759344,
-0.0242971778,
-0.0311025586,
0.0291752014,
0.0105710123,
-0.015602963,
-0.0251569841,
-0.0054281461,
-0.0326863565,
0.0181810446,
-0.0139332237,
0.0358821936,
0.0290867183,
0.0024660125,
-0.0713872612,
0.0075363675,
0.0154644661,
-0.0083671296,
0.031136943,
-0.0781667307,
-0.0265278704,
-0.0074168956,
-0.0499821343,
-0.0271641836,
-0.0323470421,
-0.0055613536,
-0.0121996626,
0.0122558791,
-0.0251518954,
-0.0253769048,
-0.0315362029,
-0.000709941,
0.0196583122,
-0.0536118299,
0.0057076202,
-0.0099263089,
0.0139012961,
0.0459112115,
-0.0011333694,
0.0069023706,
-0.0327872038,
-0.0081915893,
0.0379062705,
-0.031215949,
0.0093642948,
-0.0052220239,
0.0403225459,
0.0317785032,
-0.0136861894,
-0.0211779885,
-0.0081503419,
0.0584638007,
-0.0313847326,
0.0150404219,
0.0916566625,
0.0072734002,
-0.0166357532,
0.0284536947,
-0.007704427,
0.0705503002,
0.0236030389,
0.0253895447,
-0.0825436935,
0.0030740239,
0.0328621753,
0.0074575581,
-0.0362075754,
-0.0219018329,
-0.0227962751,
-0.1286132187,
0.0329262316,
0.0326417759,
-0.0581342466,
0.0076980018,
0.0232226104,
-0.0378017724,
-0.038743075,
0.0165107399,
-0.0071994332,
0.0065197959,
-0.0036269829,
0.005981476,
-0.024187766,
-0.0505006649,
0.0071133198,
-0.0552372597,
0.0170228332,
0.0088155614,
0.0817774683,
-0.0102590052,
0.0172523875,
0.0431896932,
0.0018235288,
-0.0077859028,
-0.0226932224,
0.0445172191,
-0.0040400764,
-0.025631059,
-0.046130497,
0.0555344447,
0.0068786922,
-0.0008620244,
0.0214508995,
0.0276958589,
0.0426882058,
-0.0160337351,
-0.0259819962,
0.0077039506,
0.017706465,
0.0652167425,
0.0031312453,
-0.0588983633,
-0.0156587195,
-0.0307961442,
-0.003256677,
-0.0513911657,
-0.0254497994,
0.0121088037,
-0.0459107533,
-0.0537443683,
-0.0726913288,
-0.0747152492,
0.023629453,
0.0259055849,
0.0167500544,
-0.0761032924,
-0.0140640764,
0.0194734186,
-0.044996962,
0.0475234017,
0.0074691963,
0.0254245624,
-0.004555284,
-0.0209717192,
-0.02011686,
-0.0368955918,
0.0068473881,
0.0564428568,
-0.0437621921,
-0.0770347863,
0.0191411711,
0.0461228304,
0.0141659006,
0.060202118,
0.0036443502,
-0.0585170612,
0.0500042811,
0.0359444618,
-0.0095504615,
0.0190945156,
0.0259862132,
0.0353566073,
-0.0037163175,
0.0615398064,
-0.031537462,
0.0119987074,
-0.0202762298,
0.0484325513,
-0.0007051947,
-0.0452979989,
0.0224252399,
0.0547898374,
-0.0318418555,
-0.110815078,
0.0249673612,
-0.0363731086,
-0.0192738529,
-0.0445664264,
-0.065239504,
-0.0248032529,
-0.0161972642,
0.0302040912,
0.0267615486,
-0.0082977619,
0.0114759998,
-0.0231877826,
-0.0040630577,
0.0075941808,
-0.0085242884,
-0.0089536821,
0.054445833,
0.0081737824,
0.0482416227,
-0.0000061218,
0.0036848551,
-0.0570112281,
0.0357971676,
-0.0220128596,
-0.0022300691,
-0.0125757335,
0.0029360794,
-0.0238699131,
0.0148691013,
0.0045700916,
0.0442315564,
-0.0366064385,
-0.010159906,
0.0431957804,
-0.0288870241,
0.1186372861,
-0.0162243731,
-0.0246218573,
0.0036787435,
0.0360021107,
-0.0071408874,
-0.0316548906,
-0.0246845875,
-0.0106380964,
-0.0180088431,
-0.0348938294,
0.0575056933,
0.0237078704,
0.0284660384,
-0.0042701531,
-0.0293316357,
-0.0250274688,
-0.0222059544,
-0.0150970034,
-0.0490088426,
-0.0288108457,
-0.0166579988,
-0.0776740685,
-0.0561228283,
0.0173450708,
-0.0161845107,
0.0273664407,
0.0087881032,
0.017191777,
0.058143571,
-0.0370218754,
-0.0370039195,
-0.0614086315,
0.0174182951,
0.0010289104,
0.0052480958,
-0.0450747758,
-6.804459252e-33,
-0.0262087602,
-0.0265693814,
-0.0202841014,
-0.0722707063,
-0.0441801026,
-0.0173540022,
-0.0302117504,
0.0054409015,
0.0273217242,
0.0661864355,
0.0193129349,
-0.0191994738,
0.0275543295,
0.0271951966,
0.0735020861,
0.0489559695,
0.0574979112,
0.011572239,
-0.0158260353,
-0.0129740248,
0.024494281,
0.0185641013,
0.0554507449,
-0.0252168458,
0.0586991422,
0.0025494141,
-0.0273325797,
0.0115228584,
-0.0086155338,
0.0178126413,
0.0060278717,
0.0766653419,
0.00914439,
0.0172472112,
-0.0001275708,
0.0373160914,
-0.0833335668,
-0.0406741947,
0.0078851413,
0.0432043858,
0.0162690431,
-0.06603273,
0.0371920504,
-0.029973058,
-0.0172044057,
-0.0253460519,
0.0359150693,
-0.0004451491,
0.0158135407,
-0.0202489104,
-0.0813169703,
0.0102286777,
-0.0314573608,
0.0312468614,
-0.02189897,
0.0678324178,
-0.0093269926,
0.0071673295,
-0.0294763595,
0.0487299673,
-0.0453434996,
-0.0236563347,
0.028626509,
0.0103729293,
0.010637857,
0.0137391612,
0.0378975123,
0.0187147763,
-0.0079521332,
-0.0176743194,
0.0238112938,
-0.024854647,
0.0101663182,
0.1026409268,
0.0418228954,
-0.0015006262,
-0.0689759552,
-0.0107924137,
0.0122521678,
0.0442433208,
0.0099824546,
-0.0346139856,
-0.0370636024,
-0.0294645876,
-0.0230243057,
-0.0699786171,
-0.0090765199,
-0.0110897943,
0.0145277716,
-0.0008771963,
-0.0432600304,
0.011639026,
0.0132007273,
-0.0240756534,
0.0101290802,
-0.0025509316,
-0.0371168219,
-0.0257083401,
0.0299715046,
0.034198802,
-0.0040001818,
-0.0164921246,
0.0078246994,
0.0291903578,
0.0281494502,
0.0030437708,
0.0412177965,
0.0210764073,
-0.0674237162,
0.019538736,
-0.0354413092,
0.0203392543,
-0.0009283829,
0.0187687166,
0.0106614484,
0.0111699589,
-0.0191376023,
-0.0034685195,
0.0500989929,
0.0702813342,
-0.0200478937,
0.0037724162,
0.0206452832,
0.0406845622,
-0.0271767601,
0.0145290093,
-0.0178239886,
-0.0097578028,
0.0873826891,
-0.0649080351,
-0.018165648,
-0.0493451543,
2.99e-7,
0.0105933314,
0.0653699487,
0.0027352765,
0.0252596624,
0.0178569444,
0.0126182502,
0.0176015738,
0.04138688,
0.0206495356,
0.0542069562,
-0.0002986788,
0.003323226,
0.0426693298,
0.0511530042,
-0.0846317559,
-0.0094825542,
-0.0650283992,
0.0115912613,
-0.0444404818,
0.0156431962,
0.006633787,
0.0707881376,
0.0086019365,
-0.0105442442,
-0.0149917379,
-0.0046347543,
0.0446508415,
0.0178769231,
-0.0079726344,
0.0209557172,
-0.0036162292,
-0.0018100464,
0.0018933172,
0.0078245513,
-0.0200864933,
-0.0089808954,
0.0384355858,
0.0374684148,
-0.0092665348,
0.0070723542,
0.0223309528,
-0.0191936363,
-0.0270366333,
-0.0570596345,
0.0467099957,
-0.0117605692,
-0.0376056507,
-0.0317682624,
-0.0186490808,
0.0313392133,
0.055672057,
-0.0490144528,
-0.0256702583,
0.023809202,
0.0487968549,
0.0015781579,
-0.0172893554,
-0.0356434025,
-0.035308212,
0.0063970559,
-0.0141210947,
-0.0324355327,
0.0008025904,
0.0141114872,
0.0046856026,
-0.0380793884,
0.0135293249,
2.634775078e-34,
0.034173958,
0.0141990017,
0.0106892549,
-0.053874094,
0.0255382415,
-0.0136448015,
-0.0206267573,
0.0251874886,
0.0462406427,
-0.0055154976,
-0.0402634852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00476v1 | Large Language Models for Power Scheduling: A User-Centric Approach | 2024-06-29T15:47:28 | 2024-06-29T15:47:28 | Thomas Mongaillard, Samson Lasaulce, Othman Hicheur, Chao Zhang, Lina Bariah, Vineeth S. Varma, Hang Zou, Qiyang Zhao, Merouane Debbah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY | While traditional optimization and scheduling schemes are designed to meet
fixed, predefined system requirements, future systems are moving toward
user-driven approaches and personalized services, aiming to achieve high
quality-of-experience (QoE) and flexibility. This challenge is particularly
pronounced in wireless and digitalized energy networks, where users'
requirements have largely not been taken into consideration due to the lack of
a common language between users and machines. The emergence of powerful large
language models (LLMs) marks a radical departure from traditional
system-centric methods into more advanced user-centric approaches by providing
a natural communication interface between users and devices. In this paper, for
the first time, we introduce a novel architecture for resource scheduling
problems by constructing three LLM agents to convert an arbitrary user's voice
request (VRQ) into a resource allocation vector. Specifically, we design an LLM
intent recognition agent to translate the request into an optimization problem
(OP), an LLM OP parameter identification agent, and an LLM OP solving agent. To
evaluate system performance, we construct a database of typical VRQs in the
context of electric vehicle (EV) charging. As a proof of concept, we primarily
use Llama 3 8B. Through testing with different prompt engineering scenarios,
the obtained results demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed architecture.
The conducted performance analysis allows key insights to be extracted. For
instance, having a larger set of candidate OPs to model the real-world problem
might degrade the final performance because of a higher recognition/OP
classification noise level. All results and codes are open source. | Large Language Models for Power Scheduling: A User-Centric Approach: While traditional optimization and scheduling schemes are designed to meet
fixed, predefined system requirements, future systems are moving toward
user-driven approaches and personalized services, aiming to achieve high
quality-of-experience (QoE) and flexibility. This challenge is particularly
pronounced in wireless and digitalized energy networks, where users'
requirements have largely not been taken into consideration due to the lack of
a common language between users and machines. The emergence of powerful large
language models (LLMs) marks a radical departure from traditional
system-centric methods into more advanced user-centric approaches by providing
a natural communication interface between users and devices. In this paper, for
the first time, we introduce a novel architecture for resource scheduling
problems by constructing three LLM agents to convert an arbitrary user's voice
request (VRQ) into a resource allocation vector. Specifically, we design an LLM
intent recognition agent to translate the request into an optimization problem
(OP), an LLM OP parameter identification agent, and an LLM OP solving agent. To
evaluate system performance, we construct a database of typical VRQs in the
context of electric vehicle (EV) charging. As a proof of concept, we primarily
use Llama 3 8B. Through testing with different prompt engineering scenarios,
the obtained results demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed architecture.
The conducted performance analysis allows key insights to be extracted. For
instance, having a larger set of candidate OPs to model the real-world problem
might degrade the final performance because of a higher recognition/OP
classification noise level. All results and codes are open source. | [
0.0054508033,
0.0458119921,
-0.0135851959,
0.0400565751,
0.0163765904,
-0.0221990235,
0.0209414214,
-0.0356582776,
-0.0251647756,
-0.0456239954,
0.0075787418,
-0.0065173707,
-0.0267286617,
-0.0155742625,
0.0111058755,
-0.0252308082,
0.0001992382,
-0.0179522019,
0.0360788442,
0.0178442895,
0.0183267724,
-0.0293431524,
0.0179110412,
0.0263952222,
-0.0379285254,
-0.0094540836,
-0.0187284127,
-0.0063813073,
0.0235862508,
0.0031965072,
0.0093286075,
0.0323178098,
0.0166591872,
0.0463014282,
0.000002157,
-0.0468361415,
-0.0273454469,
0.0082063489,
-0.0354825854,
-0.0094840033,
0.0299343616,
0.0491921417,
-0.0314868055,
0.0197142065,
-0.0091491928,
0.0302340649,
0.089515835,
0.0169411507,
0.0779482275,
0.0496981703,
-0.0088882968,
-0.0014808822,
-0.0083532622,
0.0064940904,
0.0032649843,
-0.0176662318,
0.0383352488,
-0.0089358892,
0.0223456807,
-0.0508538298,
-0.001929209,
0.0000656849,
-0.0009149399,
0.0108985715,
0.011102193,
0.0168876648,
-0.0525411293,
0.0242121648,
-0.076251857,
0.0166082587,
0.0142149311,
-0.0054944791,
0.0490395837,
0.0168883018,
-0.0524923578,
-0.0394475125,
-0.0066361539,
-0.0003406446,
-0.0157359876,
-0.0054489844,
-0.0251013041,
0.0254553761,
0.0078144539,
0.0183348507,
-0.0421425402,
0.1069057509,
0.0025357818,
0.0086354734,
-0.0055645951,
-0.0024131208,
0.0133606158,
-0.0630553216,
0.0309517533,
0.0657402724,
-0.0595887415,
-0.0213142298,
-0.0027463187,
-0.0080739893,
-0.042162776,
-0.0413390882,
0.0703404248,
0.0018634711,
0.0235302206,
0.0307016503,
0.0245258082,
0.0469139367,
-0.0425504632,
-0.0379609987,
-0.0537403375,
0.0129449181,
-0.0035457336,
-0.0241672583,
-0.0587917306,
0.0035590946,
-0.0749395266,
0.0104339318,
-0.0219433475,
0.034748394,
-0.0359120592,
-0.0136379218,
-0.0167790651,
-0.0242610984,
0.0100816675,
0.0020658665,
-0.0201670676,
0.0002985656,
-0.0271140989,
0.0356329679,
-0.0300828628,
-0.0687184185,
0.0327300504,
0.0264158752,
-0.0458999723,
0.0109867221,
-0.0208931323,
0.0787900984,
0.0034965293,
-0.0146630546,
-0.0383646712,
-0.0633704066,
0.0476039127,
-0.0612740256,
-0.0412868932,
-0.0627681687,
-0.0001065271,
-0.0381389521,
0.004624553,
0.0089998301,
-0.0159119945,
-0.0005027499,
0.0324517675,
0.045511134,
-0.0067207422,
0.0452910326,
0.0772345737,
-0.0157698952,
-0.0174726564,
0.0406914689,
0.0550189875,
0.0058721961,
0.0030825611,
-0.0415618271,
0.0219496414,
0.0233111046,
0.008252915,
-0.0117719229,
0.0287736487,
-0.0291582402,
-0.0218699519,
0.0048424029,
-0.018064959,
0.0356039964,
-0.0016391204,
-0.0122072194,
0.062551938,
0.0553689897,
0.0107499221,
0.0116247982,
-0.0173423681,
0.0467612147,
-0.0115800966,
-0.0863566473,
-0.0286775585,
0.0340809412,
-0.0409365036,
-0.0097405743,
0.0446025431,
0.0233745947,
0.006843131,
-0.0327252671,
0.0169316456,
-0.0564682819,
-0.0079436973,
0.0692386255,
0.0039744363,
-0.0399070531,
-0.0545927137,
0.0307008624,
-0.0050493577,
-0.0076091043,
-0.0052290745,
-0.0724142641,
0.0346966311,
0.0654028356,
0.0372452028,
-0.0004136843,
0.0115103042,
0.0053153685,
-0.0112900585,
0.0086598014,
0.0492873229,
-0.0178966839,
-0.0349295214,
-0.0165340248,
-0.021348089,
0.0349817015,
-0.0003355915,
0.0138373068,
-0.0350684896,
-0.0111159096,
-0.0102703515,
0.0003298758,
-0.0238338578,
0.0212594569,
0.0377225131,
-0.0424513854,
0.010698352,
0.0474342182,
0.0492631756,
0.0163769796,
-0.0049130586,
0.0135575337,
0.0230771508,
-0.0606923178,
0.0025232048,
0.0244894065,
-0.0335976221,
0.0824928805,
0.0553380884,
0.0127641642,
-0.0042745396,
0.0434956104,
0.0232605562,
-0.0474815816,
-0.0127005847,
-0.0737291053,
0.0336255394,
-0.0385575928,
-0.0044526272,
0.0079901936,
0.0034038997,
-0.0345959738,
0.0367751978,
0.0759783536,
-0.0210223496,
0.0572678447,
0.0463554747,
-0.0169349778,
-0.0481346697,
-0.0297555551,
0.0179815106,
-0.0112955067,
0.0116340369,
-0.0302439239,
-0.0265211798,
0.0512309894,
0.0262009483,
-0.0805626735,
0.024778137,
-0.0132671073,
0.0334466621,
-0.0040656622,
0.0138669088,
0.005527338,
0.0042726309,
-0.0284673255,
0.0384019837,
-0.0063344087,
0.0029373434,
-0.0122061446,
0.0175788775,
-0.0867947564,
-0.0078606131,
0.0212433059,
0.0032251128,
0.0304617193,
0.00830762,
0.0104628447,
-0.0867004618,
0.0205474067,
0.0089896964,
0.0151050622,
-0.0007698476,
-0.0296246931,
-0.0150044542,
0.03382992,
0.0347479247,
0.0779820904,
0.0206873193,
0.0084039895,
0.026359342,
-0.0316059887,
-0.0710174441,
0.0447479486,
-0.0124805262,
-0.0381682515,
-0.0276500881,
-0.0154116042,
0.0165407248,
0.0774533898,
-0.0049336269,
0.0141363442,
0.0043981601,
-0.0154710198,
0.0013428035,
-0.0325766504,
0.000277121,
0.0132249985,
-0.0138860373,
0.0714711025,
0.0218707584,
-0.0145002343,
0.0917414352,
-0.0387677029,
-0.0135654155,
-0.0149906194,
-0.0729146078,
-0.0360068157,
0.0266403351,
-0.021330677,
0.0615838841,
-0.0423297286,
0.0410235189,
0.017161157,
-0.0197411757,
-0.0257493574,
-0.0133980159,
0.0316620953,
0.009565087,
-0.0235772803,
-0.0316296443,
-0.0674187467,
0.0088350736,
-0.0162398368,
-0.0399938188,
0.010763648,
0.004443713,
-0.0240498204,
0.0147054316,
0.0610260889,
-0.0037576698,
0.0510969497,
-0.0469146147,
0.0020398872,
-0.0112700025,
-0.0088398978,
0.0068574254,
0.0840633065,
0.0046350998,
0.053856194,
0.0300678015,
-0.0008464196,
0.048841387,
0.0124267647,
-0.0583252795,
0.0396677256,
0.0390307494,
-0.0463312566,
0.0080730785,
0.0584735498,
0.0329784751,
-0.0328112915,
0.040126875,
0.0610116832,
0.0050088181,
-0.0480397642,
0.01295947,
-0.0564019457,
0.0023257891,
-0.0097628972,
0.0716503039,
-0.0849350169,
-0.0130177727,
0.0262252018,
0.0602317154,
-0.0447363555,
-0.0184434,
-0.0427423045,
-0.0653569251,
0.0253499132,
-0.0085577834,
0.0036954198,
-0.0055525107,
-0.0576807223,
-0.0128258374,
-0.018055059,
-0.0081715435,
0.0179899409,
0.0296922196,
-0.0625372604,
0.0101788752,
-0.0085853739,
-0.0245758686,
0.0077666533,
-0.0042820428,
0.0644155592,
0.0930464193,
0.0118918633,
0.0311394371,
-0.0312058777,
-0.0365872718,
0.0363769196,
-0.0627725497,
-0.0290933363,
-0.1003119051,
0.0283968579,
0.0029770143,
-0.0340445898,
0.0450176001,
-0.0178956613,
-0.0122867581,
0.0186988562,
0.1007911637,
-0.0301223621,
-0.0098535903,
-0.0395019129,
-0.0061113467,
0.0755180418,
0.0539758243,
-0.0249264948,
-0.0233548451,
-0.0856323093,
-0.0519428663,
-0.018199373,
-0.0223813877,
-0.0162708759,
0.0126585243,
0.0041816016,
-0.0313165598,
0.0116809634,
0.0118430788,
-0.0123470919,
-0.0167974345,
0.072042495,
0.0000156594,
0.0665028319,
0.0403605625,
-0.0584167168,
-0.0248220544,
-0.0141246654,
0.0534609295,
-0.0535327382,
-0.00494985,
0.0622519068,
-0.0404636823,
-0.0071080867,
0.0388062745,
-0.0374940298,
-0.0470326953,
0.0175535623,
0.0344620124,
0.0213979743,
-0.010279296,
-0.0009521584,
-0.05677047,
0.0031584557,
0.0472441614,
-0.0264410954,
0.021795284,
-0.0011223849,
0.0533059388,
0.0240395777,
0.0510785654,
-0.0645482242,
0.0582564585,
-0.0051716473,
-0.0134983193,
-0.0662018955,
-0.0400325581,
0.0006997997,
0.0381913818,
-0.0177331548,
-0.0137707647,
-0.0433875099,
-0.0078192223,
0.0300472397,
0.0065259142,
0.0116356602,
-0.0599403195,
-0.0667319968,
-0.046635326,
0.0091154501,
0.0857672617,
0.0105146235,
0.0542091988,
-0.0218339171,
0.0217901226,
0.0504501089,
0.0305602271,
0.0063052964,
0.0054107159,
0.012281307,
0.0282252003,
-0.0015174411,
0.0234532785,
0.0099671558,
-0.0235946886,
-0.0182845276,
-0.0009775086,
-0.0112136072,
-0.0523691215,
-0.0000733846,
0.0293671563,
-0.1009476632,
0.0242150314,
0.0199997127,
0.0118261296,
0.0479303896,
-0.0214264989,
-0.0467293486,
-0.0025048372,
-0.0271483902,
0.0245598052,
-0.034473218,
0.0221386272,
0.0426520668,
0.0458879806,
-0.0327679329,
-0.0291077923,
0.0049810302,
0.021617135,
0.0104399016,
-0.0320479684,
-0.0193022285,
-0.0586320683,
-0.028573554,
0.0228969865,
-0.049532678,
-0.0151248872,
-0.0631878898,
-0.0562953614,
0.0089960387,
0.000691441,
-0.0101149036,
0.0145635232,
-0.0085853254,
0.0649052188,
0.0045487327,
0.0030479571,
-0.0536758639,
-0.0274910033,
-0.0329511836,
-0.0575296357,
0.0099239442,
0.0150548862,
-6.315970085e-33,
0.0008562574,
-0.0415516309,
0.0351739489,
0.0314451456,
0.008245877,
-0.0033088215,
-0.0030356525,
0.0082046892,
0.0242333598,
-0.0450815409,
0.0010153027,
-0.0645653531,
0.0380493738,
0.0020297745,
-0.0189092159,
0.0278540365,
0.0753457844,
-0.0445902869,
-0.0430579036,
0.0004781635,
0.0306268632,
0.0207042228,
0.0059719421,
-0.0348686539,
0.027238993,
-0.0174239278,
-0.0127630532,
0.0349620245,
-0.0098880576,
0.0302691069,
-0.0110430373,
0.0254934952,
-0.0137080438,
-0.0428052694,
-0.0017161238,
0.1064544544,
-0.0450869016,
-0.0045774681,
0.0194870122,
0.0379562899,
-0.032933034,
-0.0472803041,
0.0265592001,
0.0208500642,
-0.1355268955,
0.0487287678,
0.0207220092,
-0.0068520773,
0.0230993293,
-0.0364696346,
-0.0062734969,
-0.0072419802,
-0.0027398409,
-0.0178230964,
0.0431072004,
-0.0324837118,
-0.0342783853,
0.0032042398,
-0.050023295,
0.0502819493,
-0.0085802665,
0.0061696465,
0.0732700527,
0.0533983894,
-0.0119667901,
0.0265814159,
0.0109307496,
-0.0277889557,
-0.0370800346,
0.0105730062,
-0.0064077745,
0.0603030846,
-0.0244726725,
0.0361450501,
-0.0350307524,
-0.0258963201,
-0.0634894893,
0.0317466073,
0.0391021743,
-0.0014426716,
0.0587952211,
0.0070673353,
0.0051625962,
0.0039368677,
-0.0123803513,
0.0037561641,
-0.0228132587,
-0.02984556,
-0.0024401001,
0.0030245527,
-0.0243190173,
-0.0007582941,
0.0250194371,
-0.0198990386,
-0.0055325902,
-0.0035474482,
0.0247469936,
0.008798833,
0.0052432953,
-0.0183531381,
-0.0772071481,
-0.027534347,
-0.0219657104,
-0.0192388576,
0.0231332164,
0.0001086939,
-0.0221822001,
0.0437737033,
-0.0109315729,
0.0256877262,
-0.0262488872,
0.0242473688,
0.0290078558,
0.0450896733,
0.0350711793,
-0.0402277112,
0.0299961902,
0.0390388332,
-0.0738250241,
-0.052511476,
-0.0026397542,
-0.0113896076,
0.0109920558,
0.0314678922,
-0.0259420667,
0.01028019,
-0.0520996228,
0.0299210064,
0.0035297612,
0.0111903744,
-0.0253752712,
-0.0221056398,
3.127e-7,
-0.0494638123,
0.0279215556,
-0.0271211509,
0.023929812,
0.0190700274,
0.0492318049,
-0.0083882976,
0.0287060514,
-0.0149033451,
0.0289333649,
-0.0285573062,
-0.0109290173,
0.0635002628,
-0.0061316802,
-0.0847078487,
-0.0341717154,
-0.0142850885,
0.0445084274,
-0.0510489568,
-0.0522174537,
0.052630417,
0.0482364595,
0.0051776939,
-0.0104988264,
0.0401647799,
-0.0337174758,
-0.0038284995,
-0.0750066489,
-0.0099293953,
0.0167955421,
0.0025973797,
0.0237474013,
-0.0023316913,
-0.0081581697,
0.0222381633,
0.023707604,
-0.0316867456,
0.0962812304,
0.0412310846,
-0.1062782183,
0.0171929523,
0.0094089461,
0.0146587491,
-0.0158381388,
-0.0328090452,
0.0234997943,
-0.0345668271,
-0.0187152512,
0.0174027774,
-0.0599021986,
-0.0451657027,
-0.0265315156,
0.0452788286,
-0.0536244325,
-0.0308366772,
-0.0279725008,
0.0088861678,
0.013139952,
0.0253357515,
-0.0194054861,
-0.0211826339,
-0.0601980425,
-0.0623281598,
0.0245883632,
0.0679329261,
0.0071642972,
0.036960613,
2.418794522e-34,
-0.0357928611,
-0.0004914257,
0.0306789912,
0.103203848,
-0.0144286584,
0.0291765109,
0.0027760535,
0.0272866786,
0.0084847333,
-0.0801137611,
-0.009926389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00475v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00475v1 | Classifier identification in Ancient Egyptian as a low-resource sequence-labelling task | 2024-06-29T15:40:25 | 2024-06-29T15:40:25 | Dmitry Nikolaev, Jorke Grotenhuis, Haleli Harel, Orly Goldwasser | cs.CL | cs.CL | The complex Ancient Egyptian (AE) writing system was characterised by
widespread use of graphemic classifiers (determinatives): silent (unpronounced)
hieroglyphic signs clarifying the meaning or indicating the pronunciation of
the host word. The study of classifiers has intensified in recent years with
the launch and quick growth of the iClassifier project, a web-based platform
for annotation and analysis of classifiers in ancient and modern languages.
Thanks to the data contributed by the project participants, it is now possible
to formulate the identification of classifiers in AE texts as an NLP task. In
this paper, we make first steps towards solving this task by implementing a
series of sequence-labelling neural models, which achieve promising performance
despite the modest amount of training data. We discuss tokenisation and
operationalisation issues arising from tackling AE texts and contrast our
approach with frequency-based baselines. | Classifier identification in Ancient Egyptian as a low-resource sequence-labelling task: The complex Ancient Egyptian (AE) writing system was characterised by
widespread use of graphemic classifiers (determinatives): silent (unpronounced)
hieroglyphic signs clarifying the meaning or indicating the pronunciation of
the host word. The study of classifiers has intensified in recent years with
the launch and quick growth of the iClassifier project, a web-based platform
for annotation and analysis of classifiers in ancient and modern languages.
Thanks to the data contributed by the project participants, it is now possible
to formulate the identification of classifiers in AE texts as an NLP task. In
this paper, we make first steps towards solving this task by implementing a
series of sequence-labelling neural models, which achieve promising performance
despite the modest amount of training data. We discuss tokenisation and
operationalisation issues arising from tackling AE texts and contrast our
approach with frequency-based baselines. | [
0.0278067328,
0.0729873106,
-0.0305818021,
0.0148134818,
-0.0597500689,
0.0432713926,
0.0548000187,
0.0246607419,
0.0231560841,
-0.0793017969,
0.0403568521,
-0.041114755,
0.0575581081,
0.0153827537,
0.0447650589,
-0.0130104627,
-0.0008163165,
-0.032582242,
0.028902052,
0.0295713749,
-0.0243989825,
0.0135247158,
-0.0229951777,
0.0422955416,
-0.0493961126,
-0.0295461528,
-0.021363372,
-0.0241966378,
-0.0285284594,
-0.0326636247,
-0.0303867087,
0.084254548,
-0.0182272736,
0.0750086159,
0.0000016911,
-0.052367378,
-0.0179814827,
-0.0131061114,
-0.016755186,
-0.0269414745,
0.0145447096,
-0.018301636,
-0.0318879373,
-0.0331045538,
-0.0187083203,
-0.0212880783,
0.059036158,
0.0292399693,
0.0294844937,
0.089040488,
0.0011616817,
-0.0484024659,
0.0399648771,
-0.0015208015,
-0.0202445611,
-0.0052006152,
0.0307576451,
-0.0141855376,
-0.0271106679,
0.0113391494,
-0.0295035485,
0.069191277,
-0.0010287827,
-0.0019876019,
-0.0159474965,
-0.0199734252,
-0.0398057662,
-0.0266060047,
-0.0138519928,
-0.0079469411,
-0.006520615,
-0.044046063,
0.0275590345,
0.0158135872,
0.0024806885,
-0.0324174799,
-0.0105920294,
0.0598911382,
-0.0503476746,
-0.0024728193,
0.0519761518,
-0.0065834722,
0.0299460441,
0.0199780501,
-0.0133054638,
0.0337276012,
0.0043853805,
-0.0157412179,
0.0287062135,
0.0210767016,
-0.0420659445,
-0.0382450372,
0.0450798944,
0.0618818402,
-0.0082077496,
-0.0318780653,
-0.0087003279,
-0.0399345905,
-0.00404432,
-0.045366738,
-0.0049852771,
0.0385308452,
-0.0159052107,
0.0381854959,
-0.0318068974,
0.0458651483,
0.0542105287,
0.0146733327,
0.0008543865,
0.0427668765,
-0.0367750041,
-0.0389738195,
-0.0310922954,
0.0630962551,
0.0226921439,
-0.0162245035,
-0.0533755571,
-0.0133884959,
0.0427936353,
0.0005424125,
-0.0321182087,
-0.0432476178,
0.0168996472,
0.0308803227,
0.0160346702,
-0.0525688119,
0.0218208544,
-0.0051471535,
-0.0286936574,
-0.0644751713,
0.0219443161,
0.040766187,
0.0287579279,
0.0070069977,
0.0194230564,
0.0677828118,
0.0055471789,
-0.0646513104,
-0.0415619202,
0.0073643825,
-0.031646423,
-0.0182326883,
-0.0350093693,
-0.0435157456,
-0.0216404442,
0.0260565672,
0.018454764,
-0.0309518818,
0.001772315,
0.0140135745,
0.0215213429,
0.0728999302,
-0.0087681115,
-0.0165108964,
0.0469462201,
-0.0024742223,
0.0058007143,
0.0170994066,
0.0711835101,
0.0178014226,
0.0395137891,
-0.0364806913,
0.0103487959,
0.0278337728,
-0.009064124,
-0.0693879724,
-0.0333200954,
-0.0817716122,
0.028256502,
0.0242135264,
-0.0631561354,
0.0779957697,
0.0105366381,
-0.0066899206,
0.0437803641,
0.0771030635,
0.0067320932,
0.0142286904,
0.0564287305,
-0.0020749611,
0.0269671306,
0.0225666258,
-0.0013491052,
-0.0280000158,
0.0357768424,
0.0070533133,
-0.0187035091,
0.0065278923,
0.0068708346,
-0.0615698323,
-0.0326220281,
-0.0078878598,
0.0236119516,
-0.0285105705,
0.0777233839,
0.0307304505,
-0.0444071293,
-0.0225025099,
0.0265720505,
-0.007546579,
-0.0083576646,
-0.0314726122,
0.0233726278,
0.047094278,
0.0337616056,
-0.0342124328,
-0.0051742084,
0.0135149639,
-0.0046850839,
0.0590592958,
-0.0100080436,
-0.0388091952,
0.0072062002,
-0.0409143977,
-0.0047515235,
0.0109322267,
0.021667311,
0.0209232122,
-0.0271623675,
0.0528706163,
0.0191451609,
0.0110392328,
-0.0668148324,
0.0677880868,
-0.0439601727,
-0.0523874834,
-0.016888123,
0.0416884422,
-0.0068161632,
0.040194843,
0.0062921843,
0.0204594899,
0.0142784454,
-0.0648980588,
-0.0139585184,
-0.0373265408,
-0.0335062742,
-0.0166620649,
0.0919893458,
0.000528005,
0.0024364495,
0.0110551259,
0.007149138,
-0.026078606,
0.0439235494,
-0.0643536448,
0.0507185422,
-0.0005531773,
0.0588226952,
-0.0027069205,
0.0155160148,
-0.0347146876,
0.0789567828,
0.0196235981,
0.0392431989,
-0.0057292744,
-0.0625175983,
0.0162390228,
-0.021242423,
-0.0185939856,
0.0135072619,
-0.0145533476,
-0.0102268616,
0.0014274226,
0.0333264731,
-0.010851576,
-0.0279095639,
-0.0572936609,
-0.0088779144,
-0.0376267545,
0.0476006158,
-0.0428552441,
-0.0171971153,
0.0224741753,
-0.0346537307,
-0.056460917,
0.0069323033,
-0.0195961818,
-0.0028975888,
0.0606922321,
-0.0232699662,
-0.0891433656,
-0.0004039047,
-0.0205581468,
-0.0065957182,
0.0905507952,
0.0620266385,
-0.0778623819,
-0.0182886571,
-0.0468098894,
0.015956264,
0.0142905973,
-0.0074199825,
0.0148402108,
0.0369582921,
0.0061615235,
-0.0420425981,
0.012453842,
-0.0051222355,
0.0420274585,
0.0105758999,
0.0137051549,
0.003219082,
-0.03322706,
-0.0418749526,
0.0392213874,
-0.0344018303,
-0.0192921646,
-0.0317395963,
0.0975064263,
-0.0485753976,
-0.0002579388,
-0.0325421542,
0.0255434606,
-0.0382732414,
0.0225162283,
-0.0103219999,
-0.002372442,
-0.0054031368,
0.0331711099,
0.0004929139,
-0.0241331384,
0.0717400536,
-0.022649413,
0.0030256717,
-0.012712352,
-0.0266741998,
-0.0751654506,
0.0387544632,
0.0418654792,
-0.0050497204,
0.0521410517,
-0.0800135881,
-0.0115804598,
0.0395916067,
0.0140170064,
-0.0421180986,
-0.0112200538,
-0.019061476,
0.0201396421,
-0.0191362966,
-0.0250630397,
-0.007095011,
-0.0096640009,
-0.0560617335,
0.0457384437,
0.0263221748,
-0.0028029699,
-0.0476214811,
0.0670716241,
-0.0205423702,
0.0388481654,
-0.0057000034,
0.0204260778,
-0.0220851116,
0.0301590692,
0.0008865201,
-0.0102496697,
-0.0147476038,
-0.0007140024,
0.0155531075,
0.0270932782,
-0.0411392562,
0.0245991554,
-0.0421163626,
-0.00900668,
0.0330053642,
-0.0651224107,
-0.0414497815,
-0.0422977693,
-0.0493107364,
-0.0460597016,
0.0260787085,
0.0793829039,
0.0111894272,
-0.0388024449,
0.0423368774,
0.0567330159,
-0.0279141478,
-0.0045380122,
-0.0304077901,
-0.0704348981,
-0.0037595718,
0.0254113916,
0.0405606963,
-0.0049782014,
0.0009584429,
0.0313317217,
-0.0548876524,
-0.0115427813,
0.0119016599,
-0.1091145352,
0.0066806255,
-0.0367241353,
-0.0319137685,
-0.0331646837,
-0.0663043112,
-0.0011626965,
0.0092298556,
0.029499365,
0.0775064081,
-0.0313181579,
-0.0541533194,
-0.0583523251,
-0.01744253,
-0.0189408083,
0.0017439413,
0.0495515838,
-0.0026219308,
-0.0297029838,
0.0537750758,
-0.0016556467,
0.0090386244,
-0.0367790833,
0.0814031959,
-0.019974459,
-0.0268847793,
-0.0139659578,
0.0008764431,
-0.0727398396,
-0.009622518,
-0.009091489,
0.0318472683,
0.0266483333,
-0.0153904082,
0.0283950195,
0.00316966,
0.0087952456,
0.0057891929,
0.0299003255,
-0.0431645624,
-0.0640263706,
-0.0461177342,
0.0696662739,
-0.0421016663,
-0.08626692,
0.0080703888,
-0.0069840555,
-0.0651006326,
-0.1134958565,
-0.0335130356,
0.0187277347,
0.0340739861,
0.052978158,
0.0140966456,
0.0056628236,
0.0061218701,
-0.0814810172,
-0.0249719452,
0.0270034093,
-0.0029121498,
-0.0686427131,
-0.0573996007,
0.0030765135,
-0.0141102718,
0.0030394245,
0.0155499633,
-0.0838948265,
-0.0548929274,
0.0259684063,
0.0033438015,
0.0222560596,
-0.0099276053,
0.008248996,
-0.0584964715,
0.039764069,
0.0532758161,
0.02078484,
-0.0092861205,
-0.0113259424,
0.0031935682,
-0.0534226522,
0.0188931823,
-0.0041262796,
0.0111749088,
0.0453406125,
0.0113413464,
-0.0355927758,
-0.0276915021,
0.0175830778,
0.0138882156,
0.0140223932,
-0.0376367867,
-0.0264971536,
0.0094085019,
0.0051040635,
0.003165368,
-0.017808238,
-0.0120143238,
0.0196659304,
-0.0038160237,
0.0154871736,
-0.0305493157,
-0.0275648199,
0.036147546,
0.0267300755,
-0.0270728283,
0.0292078238,
0.0402642749,
0.005141275,
-0.0206298549,
0.0165420994,
-0.00863297,
0.0163095947,
0.0136999944,
0.0858516544,
-0.0071266987,
-0.0246696454,
0.0123634171,
0.0526495576,
0.0141771222,
0.0097779352,
-0.0347393379,
-0.0211559609,
-0.0344996825,
0.0086482773,
0.058139652,
-0.0095581189,
0.0437664464,
-0.0074348343,
-0.0265041031,
-0.0276987609,
0.049537316,
0.0138114197,
-0.0344245844,
-0.0727568045,
0.023615092,
-0.0324714296,
0.0217409842,
0.0604475811,
0.0317879915,
-0.0093530566,
0.0500312373,
-0.0735460892,
-0.0501794517,
-0.0065588048,
0.0076056025,
-0.0139006963,
-0.02967133,
0.0013769304,
-0.0500635989,
-0.066249907,
0.0151597476,
0.0031794899,
0.0518333539,
0.0226685051,
-0.0141520351,
0.0247438941,
0.010920465,
-0.0308850296,
-0.0711013675,
0.0637977049,
-0.020555852,
-0.0128874015,
-0.048087921,
-5.23648497e-33,
-0.0257353373,
-0.0548930876,
0.0124536846,
0.0759549811,
0.0232687015,
0.0252095405,
-0.0305500887,
0.0306901876,
0.0339731313,
-0.0119805662,
0.0066788164,
-0.0121367332,
0.0262268241,
0.0142028714,
0.0197386649,
-0.0063453484,
0.0295416601,
0.0116896462,
-0.0168836154,
0.0121715777,
0.0873464197,
0.0556658357,
0.1098264158,
-0.087196745,
0.026036663,
-0.0021677047,
0.0215325337,
-0.0091165956,
-0.0146459686,
0.0561528578,
-0.0187091716,
-0.0156751387,
0.0252390858,
-0.0016413268,
0.0532311164,
0.0001998131,
-0.0523214936,
-0.011109896,
-0.0365086831,
0.0975536332,
0.0202626642,
-0.0502425283,
0.0029880004,
-0.0136687104,
-0.0425356589,
0.04449182,
0.0632802472,
-0.0082621835,
-0.0631097555,
-0.0666979402,
-0.0765795559,
0.0690075979,
-0.0028998526,
-0.0096701384,
0.0414213724,
0.0224381182,
-0.0186466873,
-0.0222130809,
-0.0375276282,
0.0153450482,
0.0035631002,
0.0260685738,
0.0182088688,
0.0602914542,
-0.0490409769,
0.0317010507,
0.0492165722,
0.0032109381,
0.0255029593,
0.0436083637,
0.0236074924,
-0.0236929543,
0.0248319265,
-0.0061649536,
0.0640112236,
-0.0230516568,
-0.0334533751,
-0.0203780867,
0.0214923639,
0.003583103,
0.022750387,
-0.0197480451,
-0.0667444989,
-0.0155650154,
0.003911294,
-0.0520253517,
-0.0054985215,
0.0058428613,
-0.0034940159,
0.0030803704,
-0.0216500293,
0.0462835617,
-0.0428978689,
-0.0341442898,
-0.037233226,
-0.0028131732,
-0.0091587054,
0.0406003706,
-0.0193202291,
-0.0315283351,
-0.0228919405,
-0.0597865693,
0.0046494254,
-0.0090887751,
0.0599864274,
-0.023254795,
0.0813065544,
0.0250562001,
-0.0380688347,
0.0012200684,
0.0047549279,
-0.0090350946,
0.0179003049,
0.0308845825,
0.0464163572,
-0.01521214,
0.0060539842,
0.0128006665,
0.046437107,
0.0091865361,
0.0300610494,
0.0391841307,
-0.0220056549,
-0.0215877052,
-0.0150857698,
-0.0269686319,
0.0051086755,
0.0525897294,
0.0042101839,
-0.0413837843,
0.0187327303,
-0.0129270451,
2.501e-7,
0.0304604433,
0.0166110266,
0.0517186373,
-0.0146255549,
0.0257261321,
0.0171491783,
-0.0272794701,
0.0011974897,
-0.0296092276,
0.0028902683,
0.0276466701,
-0.0175283067,
0.0697357357,
0.0065720985,
-0.0843816251,
-0.0163790938,
-0.0342856906,
0.0162992906,
-0.0439067408,
0.065402858,
0.0139789516,
0.086223118,
-0.0122809876,
-0.0418732502,
-0.0278232098,
-0.0634874105,
0.0172833819,
0.0060201357,
0.0250484552,
0.0146784661,
0.0329976678,
-0.0361372046,
0.0035211593,
0.0532367006,
-0.0225231126,
0.0281115696,
0.0642946512,
0.0292179156,
0.0235311426,
0.0575577803,
0.0090604583,
0.0200023055,
-0.0078564761,
-0.0062499866,
0.026868701,
0.0432661511,
-0.0468466654,
-0.0271758176,
-0.0288201217,
-0.0065042665,
-0.0158334449,
-0.0001284757,
0.0116602443,
0.0278172549,
0.0355207995,
-0.0367999487,
0.0090778656,
-0.025612941,
0.0183418393,
-0.0030929283,
-0.0014809862,
-0.0155471945,
-0.0127532845,
-0.0017263978,
-0.0021909713,
0.010545061,
-0.0186478943,
2.193844622e-34,
0.0078504682,
-0.0333640277,
-0.0136150932,
0.0533315018,
-0.0135131003,
-0.0050869933,
0.0164504405,
0.0252804495,
0.0204212014,
-0.0355345272,
0.012839593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00468v1 | MMEvalPro: Calibrating Multimodal Benchmarks Towards Trustworthy and Efficient Evaluation | 2024-06-29T15:28:45 | 2024-06-29T15:28:45 | Jinsheng Huang, Liang Chen, Taian Guo, Fu Zeng, Yusheng Zhao, Bohan Wu, Ye Yuan, Haozhe Zhao, Zhihui Guo, Yichi Zhang, Jingyang Yuan, Wei Ju, Luchen Liu, Tianyu Liu, Baobao Chang, Ming Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) exhibit impressive cross-modal understanding
and reasoning abilities, often assessed through multiple-choice questions
(MCQs) that include an image, a question, and several options. However, many
benchmarks used for such evaluations suffer from systematic biases. Remarkably,
Large Language Models (LLMs) without any visual perception capabilities achieve
non-trivial performance, undermining the credibility of these evaluations. To
address this issue while maintaining the efficiency of MCQ evaluations, we
propose MMEvalPro, a benchmark designed to avoid Type-I errors through a
trilogy evaluation pipeline and more rigorous metrics. For each original
question from existing benchmarks, human annotators augment it by creating one
perception question and one knowledge anchor question through a meticulous
annotation process. MMEvalPro comprises $2,138$ question triplets, totaling
$6,414$ distinct questions. Two-thirds of these questions are manually labeled
by human experts, while the rest are sourced from existing benchmarks (MMMU,
ScienceQA, and MathVista). Compared with the existing benchmarks, our
experiments with the latest LLMs and LMMs demonstrate that MMEvalPro is more
challenging (the best LMM lags behind human performance by $31.73\%$, compared
to an average gap of $8.03\%$ in previous benchmarks) and more trustworthy (the
best LLM trails the best LMM by $23.09\%$, whereas the gap for previous
benchmarks is just $14.64\%$). Our in-depth analysis explains the reason for
the large performance gap and justifies the trustworthiness of evaluation,
underscoring its significant potential for advancing future research. | MMEvalPro: Calibrating Multimodal Benchmarks Towards Trustworthy and Efficient Evaluation: Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) exhibit impressive cross-modal understanding
and reasoning abilities, often assessed through multiple-choice questions
(MCQs) that include an image, a question, and several options. However, many
benchmarks used for such evaluations suffer from systematic biases. Remarkably,
Large Language Models (LLMs) without any visual perception capabilities achieve
non-trivial performance, undermining the credibility of these evaluations. To
address this issue while maintaining the efficiency of MCQ evaluations, we
propose MMEvalPro, a benchmark designed to avoid Type-I errors through a
trilogy evaluation pipeline and more rigorous metrics. For each original
question from existing benchmarks, human annotators augment it by creating one
perception question and one knowledge anchor question through a meticulous
annotation process. MMEvalPro comprises $2,138$ question triplets, totaling
$6,414$ distinct questions. Two-thirds of these questions are manually labeled
by human experts, while the rest are sourced from existing benchmarks (MMMU,
ScienceQA, and MathVista). Compared with the existing benchmarks, our
experiments with the latest LLMs and LMMs demonstrate that MMEvalPro is more
challenging (the best LMM lags behind human performance by $31.73\%$, compared
to an average gap of $8.03\%$ in previous benchmarks) and more trustworthy (the
best LLM trails the best LMM by $23.09\%$, whereas the gap for previous
benchmarks is just $14.64\%$). Our in-depth analysis explains the reason for
the large performance gap and justifies the trustworthiness of evaluation,
underscoring its significant potential for advancing future research. | [
0.0039631217,
0.0720759928,
-0.0178982317,
0.0606315061,
-0.0199118182,
0.0057380274,
0.0325486213,
0.0004306189,
0.0138251912,
-0.0810005814,
-0.0716120899,
-0.015457199,
-0.0015277572,
0.004927983,
0.0802505389,
-0.0588811263,
0.0445645638,
-0.0588303879,
-0.0124075729,
0.0117467167,
0.0150596425,
-0.0272284318,
-0.0336324349,
0.0201675016,
-0.0285438523,
-0.0362104364,
-0.0044635111,
0.0119819539,
-0.0059691751,
-0.0455625169,
-0.0107138427,
0.0747995377,
0.0221407395,
0.0377248563,
0.0000021382,
-0.0424436443,
0.0078569828,
-0.0067931437,
-0.0107046198,
0.0057285628,
0.010177291,
-0.0104789799,
0.0452452451,
-0.0060896673,
-0.0289506577,
-0.0200261362,
0.0305541921,
-0.0030409589,
0.0691088215,
0.0327198207,
0.0016425741,
0.0216136537,
0.0156891961,
-0.002625946,
0.0376093164,
-0.0508520044,
-0.0139329657,
0.040638417,
-0.0155111086,
0.0358229987,
-0.0580042899,
0.0443472937,
0.0430159643,
-0.0044988035,
0.0026596957,
0.0140847666,
-0.0402530544,
-0.0325986035,
-0.0401360653,
0.0978034437,
0.0144548062,
0.0121829035,
-0.0315619521,
0.0109419907,
0.0075493171,
0.0372918025,
-0.051943548,
0.0218467135,
-0.0070299683,
-0.0466575027,
-0.0536719561,
0.0097353598,
0.018483229,
0.015613283,
0.0193761587,
0.0421071388,
0.0090647051,
-0.0040954505,
0.0403036028,
0.0190391988,
-0.0494998172,
-0.0551580936,
-0.0139643475,
0.0073702079,
-0.0139573887,
-0.0021595922,
-0.0363821238,
-0.0306893848,
0.0167353489,
-0.0138158463,
0.0516857654,
0.0412158333,
-0.0605724975,
0.0666441694,
-0.0155719845,
0.0828636214,
-0.0155536653,
0.0687145889,
-0.0164172836,
0.0137757566,
-0.0357038118,
0.0052027847,
0.0001856342,
-0.0220972653,
-0.0247577652,
-0.0152071966,
-0.0245784149,
0.0022741517,
-0.0173297524,
0.0206535552,
-0.0123713911,
-0.0026551513,
0.0025172825,
-0.0144221112,
-0.066113621,
0.0606429689,
-0.0348504297,
0.0234729461,
0.0181080196,
-0.0776593387,
0.0132227093,
0.0627821609,
-0.019554453,
-0.0396707021,
0.0120993135,
0.0949332342,
-0.0346650854,
-0.0229168832,
0.025477862,
-0.0492723584,
-0.0063049905,
-0.0564026423,
0.0453470461,
-0.0512451157,
0.0398575664,
-0.0045647416,
0.008036633,
-0.0014959271,
-0.0089260051,
0.0182851125,
0.0228672028,
0.0956921354,
0.0064887227,
-0.0182532426,
0.0193574969,
0.0173320714,
-0.0667010322,
0.0500674471,
0.0363164842,
0.0175685063,
0.0700607672,
-0.0177327599,
0.0064066611,
0.0529875346,
-0.0123220682,
-0.0031272585,
-0.003279377,
0.0331095979,
0.0026135487,
0.0599999465,
0.0325872451,
0.0649133325,
-0.0241478812,
-0.0447411463,
0.0824268535,
0.0330594853,
-0.0283663478,
-0.0365575142,
0.0377156995,
-0.0162344687,
0.0381249562,
0.0123303188,
-0.0577430837,
0.060438823,
-0.0191253517,
-0.021354951,
0.0324844904,
0.0132464562,
-0.011339304,
-0.0304853003,
-0.0228999499,
0.0222932883,
-0.0064776456,
0.0300185382,
0.0120922262,
-0.0007985869,
-0.02174397,
0.0118644722,
-0.0259098615,
-0.028652329,
0.0085409554,
-0.0217457451,
0.0378735475,
0.0085640969,
0.0445775017,
-0.0013482303,
-0.0374054015,
-0.0043119891,
0.0204559993,
0.0405776389,
0.066371724,
-0.017985655,
0.006492611,
-0.0544254929,
-0.0293490086,
-0.0145354802,
0.007187889,
0.0018762245,
0.0101660658,
-0.0177987572,
-0.0129022794,
-0.1068868786,
0.0361177251,
0.0277791023,
0.0142991748,
-0.016978208,
-0.0478134304,
0.0113563538,
0.0063604205,
-0.0100610256,
0.0061302842,
0.0249593612,
0.0060623335,
-0.0255595166,
0.0203304794,
0.0053041908,
-0.051698897,
-0.0215995219,
0.0453395694,
-0.0780200139,
-0.0602350421,
0.0556464158,
-0.0339067914,
-0.0203719474,
0.0004129065,
-0.0213155635,
-0.040754132,
-0.0507579483,
-0.0183479879,
0.0057533788,
0.0147934435,
-0.0310776401,
0.0462226346,
-0.0356177352,
0.0126591092,
-0.0085639087,
0.0172608178,
0.0351317711,
-0.0083812643,
-0.0223940369,
0.014669802,
0.0059415563,
0.0330975652,
-0.0007982157,
0.0016622383,
-0.0759986117,
-0.0067677931,
-0.0890503228,
-0.0045600943,
-0.0209914967,
-0.0041038976,
0.0071958234,
-0.0402320661,
0.0119013498,
-0.0345146358,
-0.041792132,
0.0121335946,
-0.0199340507,
0.0267646145,
0.0370123535,
0.0033589331,
0.0426000096,
-0.0087464638,
-0.018896265,
-0.0409159139,
0.0805939659,
0.0009276823,
0.034545064,
-0.0154149411,
-0.0268284064,
-0.0433120467,
0.0095484965,
-0.0141893709,
-0.0053497618,
0.0594598614,
-0.0137926787,
0.0335037299,
0.0563608371,
-0.0129453847,
-0.0087923231,
0.0346861519,
0.0124591123,
-0.0406266786,
0.0091078114,
0.0404335558,
-0.0380681455,
-0.0181989651,
-0.0398481563,
-0.0186665282,
0.0495738499,
-0.0086983172,
-0.0065346137,
-0.0273353979,
0.0525426716,
-0.0195876751,
-0.0595414117,
-0.0834281445,
0.0178066976,
0.0049590888,
0.0619659759,
-0.0445717238,
-0.036354091,
0.0621144176,
-0.0592146069,
-0.0161330607,
0.0033127568,
0.0366174169,
-0.0214181691,
0.0743142813,
0.0122094583,
0.0029187109,
-0.0001964584,
0.0073153768,
-0.0817181915,
-0.0077529671,
0.0496571176,
-0.0261857733,
0.0588855147,
-0.0697271079,
-0.003996239,
-0.0126369027,
-0.0316009596,
-0.0243165456,
-0.0253284182,
-0.0352989621,
0.0016543072,
-0.0276333299,
-0.0010547191,
-0.0076240133,
-0.0056078192,
0.0498240478,
0.0237891991,
-0.015468739,
-0.0118315676,
-0.0278080665,
0.0668925047,
0.0416133665,
0.0540230162,
0.0131803472,
-0.0785212964,
0.0169105567,
0.0636378974,
0.0359178521,
0.0060495068,
-0.0332818218,
0.040056996,
0.0150152361,
0.0258815736,
-0.0041324091,
0.0263303351,
0.0960009024,
-0.0517250001,
0.0116242496,
0.0770864263,
-0.0007493728,
-0.0395703539,
-0.0149016036,
-0.0007930677,
0.0250363387,
0.0529313385,
-0.0037552251,
-0.0857367963,
-0.056827154,
0.0011383179,
0.0085121347,
0.0141907446,
-0.0392289199,
0.0140608167,
-0.0984798297,
0.0309480745,
-0.0219667498,
-0.0560217313,
0.0135460384,
-0.0264610611,
0.0066460911,
-0.0191753618,
0.0177532863,
0.0098780254,
0.0328211598,
0.0138925146,
0.0253746677,
0.0136203216,
-0.0337099768,
0.0535443015,
-0.037344303,
0.0011016013,
0.0097258892,
-0.0084684817,
-0.0270359535,
-0.0874455348,
0.0385316312,
0.0037339083,
-0.0042215474,
0.011521765,
0.0507696159,
-0.0236978792,
-0.0272671748,
-0.0148670934,
0.0220818836,
0.0091354307,
-0.0136769731,
-0.0021840883,
0.0853547454,
-0.0028401793,
-0.011853585,
-0.0272564441,
-0.0057706288,
-0.0329935662,
0.033229243,
0.0512328856,
-0.0385345481,
-0.0107848002,
-0.0135432249,
0.0182142332,
-0.0494224429,
-0.0392615572,
0.0594861843,
0.0295649394,
-0.0037185925,
-0.0626251176,
-0.0445954502,
0.0306227002,
0.0608090907,
-0.0106199076,
-0.0256412644,
0.0016000054,
0.0162333436,
-0.0381167084,
0.082929112,
-0.0258024335,
0.0290187765,
-0.0254255459,
0.0395207293,
-0.022705527,
-0.0103205452,
-0.0340369232,
0.0376455598,
-0.0748870522,
-0.0213133134,
-0.0464257747,
0.0801774636,
0.0155204032,
-0.0122445896,
0.0127381794,
-0.0540558137,
-0.0108605241,
0.0034591437,
0.0158208814,
0.0061864024,
-0.007730823,
-0.0190689843,
-0.0170046091,
0.0138339801,
-0.0272766408,
-0.0109391781,
-0.0001136161,
0.0331658684,
-0.0014577905,
-0.0218762439,
0.0250047743,
0.0366727151,
0.0413202494,
-0.026123669,
0.0426439159,
0.004280095,
-0.0031585861,
-0.0029695116,
-0.0202117208,
-0.0289907306,
0.0030745508,
0.0385816246,
-0.0163429957,
0.0133371698,
-0.0137072615,
0.0026133049,
0.0616584346,
-0.0210206974,
0.0283507388,
0.0622348376,
0.0175626334,
-0.0231110789,
0.0102956481,
-0.0241489857,
0.0131809581,
-0.027707478,
0.0619919598,
-0.0098645361,
0.0840590969,
0.0216146857,
-0.0099682584,
0.0034529818,
0.0199113172,
-0.0306095388,
-0.0269229673,
0.0006111864,
0.0477646589,
0.0508824512,
0.0224614348,
0.0057645147,
-0.0051616509,
-0.0216118842,
-0.0141572282,
0.0125296628,
0.0039540622,
-0.0173672829,
0.0786408409,
0.0493894778,
0.0248942506,
-0.0085003572,
0.0496320464,
-0.0227886681,
0.0258174967,
0.0070265294,
-0.0014572482,
-0.0530523546,
-0.0011699534,
0.0053047184,
0.0170082003,
0.0132829593,
0.0204881504,
-0.0638745725,
-0.0946300626,
0.0105528096,
0.0573073961,
0.0051082517,
0.0165491533,
0.0143274004,
0.0643275976,
0.004207294,
-0.0270244852,
-0.0240114033,
0.0076636174,
-0.0360011011,
0.0057437192,
0.0095954603,
-6.42453507e-33,
-0.0182294659,
-0.0371525511,
0.0239094235,
-0.076372005,
-0.0148754818,
0.015861962,
-0.0289730858,
0.0258634165,
-0.0244174525,
0.0094302185,
0.0172391497,
-0.0269857328,
-0.0047497312,
0.0077511002,
0.0058938772,
-0.0147900563,
-0.0023574212,
-0.0219029728,
-0.0635786653,
-0.0374821536,
-0.002520883,
-0.0052191843,
0.0547288582,
-0.0447798893,
0.0423695967,
0.0187033657,
-0.0237893593,
0.0192334279,
-0.0289389342,
0.0769151151,
-0.0346838161,
0.020907959,
0.0214186795,
-0.0284177735,
-0.0147501687,
0.0046702996,
-0.0582012571,
-0.0189171564,
0.0170243774,
0.0355298147,
-0.0997100323,
-0.0009134148,
0.0460221991,
-0.0295377094,
-0.0225658529,
-0.0445150323,
0.0296277665,
-0.0067359242,
-0.0180001855,
0.0215590391,
-0.0144170718,
0.0164504889,
-0.0156602319,
-0.0165652521,
0.0024183281,
0.0836742818,
0.0124621168,
0.0387424119,
-0.061396867,
0.0043316013,
-0.0490246154,
0.0034362511,
0.0817242861,
0.0061666528,
0.0035842643,
0.0618640371,
0.0272121336,
-0.0073299515,
0.002163446,
-0.0210359599,
0.0465350673,
0.0548115484,
0.0810704678,
0.1149943024,
0.0397596844,
0.0261182711,
-0.0555228107,
0.0423568487,
-0.0255126115,
0.0341654271,
-0.0060221413,
-0.0032821307,
-0.0303900689,
0.0158750471,
-0.0916138291,
-0.0211460255,
-0.063724637,
-0.0043348004,
0.0637926534,
-0.0229381844,
0.0007449089,
0.0220855176,
0.0629327297,
-0.0330902264,
0.0023325572,
-0.0348641612,
-0.0112713976,
0.069015108,
0.0113202613,
0.0443342403,
-0.012435969,
0.0134339128,
0.0354382358,
0.0073759453,
0.0547866523,
-0.0015120355,
0.0220185444,
0.0172375627,
-0.0398831032,
-0.0198382363,
-0.046099253,
-0.0214986,
-0.0055160006,
0.0074502714,
0.0424335487,
-0.0011000379,
-0.0525757782,
-0.0009354961,
-0.0151663087,
0.0161706861,
-0.0283881202,
-0.0308463462,
-0.0170007441,
0.0153519092,
-0.018945992,
-0.0006765723,
-0.0287196394,
-0.0542623177,
0.007586488,
-0.0577441864,
0.0086679654,
0.0442292057,
2.685e-7,
0.0337611027,
0.0405275449,
-0.0030139601,
-0.0098412065,
0.0252981074,
0.057677459,
-0.047552038,
0.024953289,
-0.0071540242,
-0.086906895,
-0.0290714838,
0.0362588614,
0.0517285317,
0.057557255,
-0.0221479032,
-0.0205994118,
-0.019759424,
0.0083639799,
-0.0324018002,
0.0121565582,
0.0574502833,
0.04428057,
-0.0238765497,
-0.0345119946,
0.0017981252,
-0.0547483601,
0.0671395808,
-0.0099266171,
-0.0358480513,
-0.0196824372,
0.0554619469,
0.0175271295,
0.0189123768,
0.0443538241,
0.0071292897,
-0.0496521555,
0.0628059357,
0.0423773564,
0.0133235464,
-0.049729906,
-0.0411562696,
0.0076553714,
-0.0059080729,
-0.0640371591,
0.0529005267,
-0.0208573025,
-0.0390889719,
-0.0275750104,
-0.0506136455,
-0.0101483781,
0.0448542833,
0.0007524707,
-0.0284835733,
0.0142080812,
0.0206528343,
-0.0161067564,
-0.0199126005,
-0.0338133723,
-0.0312942788,
0.0031214734,
-0.0369044468,
-0.0690410361,
-0.0444611497,
-0.0574629903,
0.0224751402,
-0.064506337,
-0.0507674292,
2.159581946e-34,
0.0350433514,
-0.0158000011,
0.0549377538,
-0.019082481,
0.037568979,
-0.0264206398,
-0.0255176947,
-0.0402478538,
0.0114761079,
-0.080302678,
-0.0011204167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00466v1 | BioKGBench: A Knowledge Graph Checking Benchmark of AI Agent for Biomedical Science | 2024-06-29T15:23:28 | 2024-06-29T15:23:28 | Xinna Lin, Siqi Ma, Junjie Shan, Xiaojing Zhang, Shell Xu Hu, Tiannan Guo, Stan Z. Li, Kaicheng Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pursuing artificial intelligence for biomedical science, a.k.a. AI Scientist,
draws increasing attention, where one common approach is to build a copilot
agent driven by Large Language Models (LLMs). However, to evaluate such
systems, people either rely on direct Question-Answering (QA) to the LLM
itself, or in a biomedical experimental manner. How to precisely benchmark
biomedical agents from an AI Scientist perspective remains largely unexplored.
To this end, we draw inspiration from one most important abilities of
scientists, understanding the literature, and introduce BioKGBench. In contrast
to traditional evaluation benchmark that only focuses on factual QA, where the
LLMs are known to have hallucination issues, we first disentangle
"Understanding Literature" into two atomic abilities, i) "Understanding" the
unstructured text from research papers by performing scientific claim
verification, and ii) Ability to interact with structured Knowledge-Graph
Question-Answering (KGQA) as a form of "Literature" grounding. We then
formulate a novel agent task, dubbed KGCheck, using KGQA and domain-based
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) to identify the factual errors of existing
large-scale knowledge graph databases. We collect over two thousand data for
two atomic tasks and 225 high-quality annotated data for the agent task.
Surprisingly, we discover that state-of-the-art agents, both daily scenarios
and biomedical ones, have either failed or inferior performance on our
benchmark. We then introduce a simple yet effective baseline, dubbed BKGAgent.
On the widely used popular knowledge graph, we discover over 90 factual errors
which provide scenarios for agents to make discoveries and demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach. The code and data are available at
https://github.com/westlake-autolab/BioKGBench. | BioKGBench: A Knowledge Graph Checking Benchmark of AI Agent for Biomedical Science: Pursuing artificial intelligence for biomedical science, a.k.a. AI Scientist,
draws increasing attention, where one common approach is to build a copilot
agent driven by Large Language Models (LLMs). However, to evaluate such
systems, people either rely on direct Question-Answering (QA) to the LLM
itself, or in a biomedical experimental manner. How to precisely benchmark
biomedical agents from an AI Scientist perspective remains largely unexplored.
To this end, we draw inspiration from one most important abilities of
scientists, understanding the literature, and introduce BioKGBench. In contrast
to traditional evaluation benchmark that only focuses on factual QA, where the
LLMs are known to have hallucination issues, we first disentangle
"Understanding Literature" into two atomic abilities, i) "Understanding" the
unstructured text from research papers by performing scientific claim
verification, and ii) Ability to interact with structured Knowledge-Graph
Question-Answering (KGQA) as a form of "Literature" grounding. We then
formulate a novel agent task, dubbed KGCheck, using KGQA and domain-based
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) to identify the factual errors of existing
large-scale knowledge graph databases. We collect over two thousand data for
two atomic tasks and 225 high-quality annotated data for the agent task.
Surprisingly, we discover that state-of-the-art agents, both daily scenarios
and biomedical ones, have either failed or inferior performance on our
benchmark. We then introduce a simple yet effective baseline, dubbed BKGAgent.
On the widely used popular knowledge graph, we discover over 90 factual errors
which provide scenarios for agents to make discoveries and demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach. The code and data are available at
https://github.com/westlake-autolab/BioKGBench. | [
0.0612709038,
0.0111885434,
0.0062079835,
0.0056892452,
-0.0361370556,
0.0029463244,
-0.009151563,
0.016035093,
0.0724089816,
-0.010015904,
0.0046301568,
-0.0142917102,
-0.0046120281,
0.0449726358,
0.0106483633,
0.0272327513,
0.057703767,
0.0181132741,
0.0437130518,
-0.0239670835,
-0.0236501694,
0.0026967453,
-0.0487355478,
0.0089879362,
0.0146020139,
-0.0209323503,
0.0215804912,
-0.0254476052,
0.0346067064,
-0.0591882914,
0.0107336631,
0.0096134031,
-0.0153476521,
0.0579573736,
0.000001806,
-0.0651049837,
-0.0017459048,
0.0508041903,
-0.0465373099,
0.0001869159,
0.0104617234,
-0.0023913628,
0.007700637,
0.0026501671,
-0.0498980321,
-0.0111073293,
0.0319086537,
0.0329722352,
0.0236261971,
0.0662549436,
0.0090744924,
0.0167712998,
0.0471056662,
0.015670497,
0.0208619665,
-0.0341011956,
0.0570831373,
0.0496852063,
0.0642809421,
0.012966671,
0.0216318127,
0.0725056604,
-0.0082825543,
-0.0143293841,
0.042331364,
0.0390815511,
-0.0315198563,
-0.0082127098,
-0.0006949548,
0.0729266554,
0.0529737696,
-0.0372974761,
0.0303949285,
0.0168212689,
-0.0184966102,
0.045222912,
-0.0310913771,
0.000933287,
-0.0488989912,
-0.0400782749,
-0.003938817,
-0.0210503023,
0.0441954061,
0.0087679764,
-0.015754234,
0.0866338611,
-0.014210701,
-0.0500614159,
0.0332206227,
0.014987994,
0.0082836207,
-0.0731120035,
0.009789207,
0.0581807569,
-0.0507987551,
-0.0058422368,
0.0225637332,
-0.0343614742,
0.0636047348,
-0.0381863043,
-0.0002114383,
-0.0084868195,
0.0036868032,
0.0414064303,
-0.0060995165,
0.0446474217,
-0.0129972314,
0.0610971898,
0.0011275144,
0.0034492449,
-0.0779386759,
-0.033170063,
-0.0100855893,
0.0353655294,
0.0183213465,
0.0046046255,
-0.0359661132,
-0.0000454659,
-0.0326507576,
0.0440812968,
-0.0105669964,
0.0354452021,
-0.0181649309,
0.0142179336,
-0.0754429772,
0.0081863059,
-0.0241268929,
0.0126096038,
-0.0017960489,
-0.0368484072,
-0.033262711,
-0.0031540501,
0.0198742505,
-0.0146311168,
0.0332062021,
0.0548377037,
0.0308698341,
-0.0144211939,
-0.00019376,
-0.076031968,
-0.0178502817,
-0.0806577504,
0.0253803134,
-0.06111582,
0.0522691496,
0.006503121,
-0.0300001912,
-0.0381304398,
0.0119076828,
0.0012240482,
-0.0371391401,
0.0487795509,
-0.0607363172,
-0.0078378022,
0.0326907076,
0.0194756053,
-0.0422672965,
-0.0007541906,
0.0123961866,
-0.0374222919,
0.041066505,
0.0343732685,
0.0148346024,
-0.0373984389,
0.0489871874,
-0.0100847818,
0.0592381246,
0.0343906656,
-0.0215743538,
0.0668138266,
-0.0167977754,
0.0480621122,
-0.0341308452,
0.000043269,
0.010279784,
0.0578410923,
-0.015336955,
-0.0224178936,
0.0303197969,
-0.0061220448,
0.0476923101,
-0.0162859466,
-0.0228009578,
0.0027788735,
-0.0317186005,
0.0116267903,
0.0000107147,
0.0106023774,
-0.0105189318,
-0.0377263054,
-0.0234225802,
0.0204903502,
0.0077964943,
-0.0147338919,
0.0454431772,
0.0005640735,
-0.0259060171,
-0.0113166505,
0.0282688569,
-0.0331562012,
-0.0035949626,
-0.0502738655,
-0.0029390724,
0.0379062779,
0.09195292,
-0.0559248328,
-0.0551099628,
0.0202831104,
-0.0267146304,
0.0399650931,
0.0366163813,
-0.0359905399,
-0.0251874998,
-0.0074490407,
-0.022772843,
-0.023744233,
0.013034123,
-0.0263744555,
0.0178058762,
0.0393898003,
-0.0107899904,
-0.0692851022,
-0.0391103663,
0.0208311826,
-0.0703107342,
-0.0119269062,
-0.0217740163,
-0.0326201245,
0.0406246297,
0.0389328897,
-0.0371462889,
0.056260366,
0.0541480444,
-0.0108226482,
-0.0669331029,
-0.0001790273,
0.0361618288,
-0.0452169776,
0.0455656238,
-0.036948707,
-0.0142630311,
0.0113431821,
-0.0229136217,
-0.0507278256,
0.0023376863,
-0.0198709015,
-0.0013676747,
0.0048309686,
0.0054341429,
-0.0274371952,
-0.0139149772,
-0.0190245602,
0.051174894,
0.0076320767,
0.0082639121,
-0.0048057572,
-0.0070021423,
0.0329645053,
-0.0431562364,
-0.0099413553,
-0.004900482,
0.0190795474,
0.0267316792,
0.0546497405,
-0.0549755394,
-0.0498975068,
0.0384253375,
-0.0784651786,
0.0137298321,
0.0121929515,
0.0254366938,
0.0027689117,
-0.0355763473,
0.0121777914,
-0.0080735423,
-0.0224471595,
0.0510251969,
0.0379135795,
0.0040936219,
0.0577940904,
0.0235934332,
0.0004108782,
-0.055310864,
0.0239583328,
-0.0721175298,
0.042948328,
0.0428884253,
-0.0196779799,
-0.0187453497,
0.0382377841,
-0.0717264414,
0.0205257609,
-0.0102714449,
-0.0054103136,
0.054341644,
0.0040542549,
-0.0149515159,
0.0599379055,
-0.0074595176,
0.0069097276,
0.0578426123,
-0.0055485116,
-0.0365852118,
0.0214511827,
-0.0354554653,
0.0054292828,
-0.0079766838,
-0.0106693795,
0.0199733023,
0.0049375864,
0.0137123447,
-0.0115244696,
-0.0289551169,
0.0289873965,
-0.0141856186,
-0.0241784453,
0.0005272142,
0.0092597092,
0.020960534,
0.0394886546,
-0.0214951951,
0.0145263979,
0.1035222262,
-0.0167202819,
0.0419974998,
-0.0491206907,
0.0036825764,
-0.007292869,
0.0406681038,
0.0182869062,
0.025740128,
-0.0015937429,
0.0543074347,
-0.0056344112,
0.0024843635,
0.0044036997,
-0.0280415583,
0.0072281631,
-0.0414984301,
0.0519588478,
0.0410850979,
-0.0418993793,
-0.0427568331,
0.0302537419,
-0.0473997109,
0.0004676608,
-0.0206431188,
-0.0349954888,
-0.0594873466,
-0.0154724186,
0.0583143793,
0.0161909647,
-0.0054269582,
-0.0281153675,
-0.0247438215,
-0.0038407613,
0.0675791577,
0.0078452565,
0.0710667297,
-0.0058099781,
0.0294237807,
0.085144192,
0.0018428898,
0.0325307027,
-0.0037069786,
-0.0259500965,
-0.0351699963,
-0.0383820795,
0.0193005651,
-0.0141100846,
0.0299049336,
-0.0547952391,
-0.0302440841,
0.0653929189,
0.0294085126,
-0.0361586362,
0.0119721359,
-0.02104038,
-0.0296558794,
0.0034194831,
0.0641868263,
-0.1105128974,
-0.003497757,
-0.0364452004,
0.0372557789,
-0.0509789139,
-0.0754402205,
-0.0055847238,
-0.0861836299,
0.0538723581,
0.0048110075,
-0.0161943939,
-0.0549773425,
-0.084114559,
-0.0020056562,
-0.0045473012,
-0.0207165647,
0.0439802669,
0.0266082846,
-0.0209376216,
0.0011592986,
0.0100518465,
-0.0750874504,
0.0422670841,
-0.0473758914,
0.0624628961,
0.0314813033,
0.0330375396,
-0.0084647266,
-0.0035545796,
-0.0342989005,
0.0244715456,
-0.0007548485,
0.0152239744,
0.0560307987,
0.0299791284,
0.014222784,
-0.0523636788,
0.0079949014,
-0.0708751231,
-0.0161680132,
0.0202794541,
0.121205911,
-0.0350491516,
-0.0380765945,
-0.0464527942,
0.0075367168,
0.0012716686,
0.0775900558,
-0.0142160291,
0.0277552903,
-0.0747055933,
-0.0109766042,
0.0296231341,
-0.0515277199,
-0.0231250692,
0.0655161068,
-0.032222759,
0.011150375,
-0.0806302056,
-0.0489695705,
0.0178670827,
0.0013611654,
-0.0082928427,
-0.0069857603,
0.0664241463,
-0.0225687176,
-0.0658586994,
0.0166137666,
-0.0122589963,
0.0250261351,
-0.022637248,
-0.0155176064,
0.046193298,
-0.0066662687,
-0.0150349401,
0.0167450663,
-0.0209953915,
-0.0614961572,
-0.0188244954,
0.0385211036,
0.022711752,
0.0218577087,
-0.0294856746,
-0.0045920499,
0.0653036833,
0.0561688133,
-0.0466662832,
0.022237163,
-0.0281661898,
-0.0441710539,
-0.0381964259,
-0.0031712309,
-0.0720376074,
0.0203068629,
-0.0328431092,
0.0366668254,
-0.0282382853,
-0.02623206,
0.0355433598,
0.0733458996,
0.0022476823,
0.0108955055,
-0.0033152478,
-0.0179238003,
-0.0061499239,
-0.015760472,
-0.0070608375,
-0.0109899566,
-0.0134840747,
-0.0106976386,
-0.0199081358,
0.026669668,
-0.0011198984,
-0.0466644689,
0.016984148,
-0.0101101538,
-0.0177908689,
0.0245082192,
0.0260229744,
0.0513879582,
-0.0347159617,
-0.0238410179,
0.0108614033,
-0.0152044026,
0.0572264083,
-0.0043193814,
0.0200987272,
0.0378131866,
-0.0148812449,
-0.0332971923,
0.002225772,
-0.1129500344,
-0.0307450369,
0.0050866092,
-0.0073984168,
0.0367321633,
0.050698068,
0.0333446413,
-0.0474227443,
-0.0124229686,
-0.0288458709,
-0.003152837,
-0.0147233093,
0.0120353745,
0.0385433882,
0.035056565,
-0.0085032536,
-0.0162916481,
0.0733898506,
0.0200860463,
0.0762368813,
0.0010415243,
-0.0735871494,
-0.0270796996,
-0.0743530914,
-0.0378532298,
0.0068493881,
-0.0088050775,
-0.0178970452,
-0.0671666041,
-0.0490022972,
0.0487498417,
0.0634705126,
-0.0247146934,
-0.0269281901,
0.0289467499,
0.0256857574,
0.0406274237,
-0.0369191319,
-0.0215400998,
0.0353538059,
-0.0911235437,
-0.0371180885,
0.0002113919,
-6.020137463e-33,
0.0126798945,
-0.072928682,
0.0489775129,
0.0015712901,
-0.0316082165,
0.0244981442,
-0.0705688447,
-0.0341839492,
-0.0228094328,
0.0671872571,
-0.0171547886,
0.0352431014,
-0.0054542725,
-0.0233628135,
-0.0051168203,
0.0034076483,
0.0084909378,
0.001272685,
-0.0126102557,
0.0278404001,
0.0335514173,
0.0093290666,
0.0090424204,
-0.067013517,
0.0158196017,
-0.0014648807,
0.0112327682,
0.0296566673,
-0.0536866784,
0.0696921572,
-0.0181618817,
0.0473622456,
0.0042641731,
0.0110413572,
0.0254213456,
-0.0416689888,
-0.0738132596,
-0.0291369408,
-0.0185247865,
-0.0126467906,
-0.0580195449,
-0.0114911972,
0.0436012372,
-0.0062838802,
-0.0429565273,
-0.0071683577,
0.0276190415,
-0.0171160046,
-0.0215622671,
-0.0352839977,
-0.0613530613,
0.025633676,
0.0056623411,
0.0199895836,
-0.0357151516,
0.0188685432,
-0.0087144813,
0.0262749121,
-0.0684230924,
0.0261777434,
0.0214403793,
-0.027254181,
0.0322353989,
-0.0215691663,
0.0159333441,
0.0550101586,
0.0209988561,
0.0351624526,
-0.0104997689,
0.0023368362,
-0.0191559792,
0.0385162681,
0.029727269,
0.0745113567,
0.001979012,
0.0013758731,
-0.1063503399,
0.0515252836,
-0.011913727,
0.0277338997,
0.0018720879,
-0.0199568346,
-0.0422595292,
-0.0206223708,
-0.0280129537,
0.0235331133,
-0.0219828729,
-0.0131558487,
0.002428852,
-0.0422230177,
-0.0144676156,
0.0006759434,
-0.0138920881,
-0.0669849515,
0.0263843741,
0.0286580045,
-0.0164617002,
0.0135867996,
-0.0092180073,
0.034429349,
-0.0612185672,
-0.0035220564,
0.0161101855,
0.0333849341,
0.0505434535,
0.0441199467,
-0.0100195371,
0.0005681948,
-0.0071529718,
0.0004354499,
-0.0265736282,
0.0027265211,
0.0075694793,
-0.0125831207,
0.0064216056,
0.042122893,
0.014876307,
0.0430735424,
0.0307648033,
0.0278443601,
-0.004619156,
0.0516920723,
0.013794234,
0.0152478693,
-0.0315084755,
-0.0054955012,
-0.0540503226,
0.0680361539,
-0.0253942236,
-0.0884875581,
0.0156179117,
0.0153915407,
2.797e-7,
0.058143843,
0.0533197671,
0.0254567899,
0.0252343789,
0.0310740992,
0.0263285525,
-0.0090469168,
-0.0072520664,
-0.0348672867,
-0.0262826458,
0.0345528461,
0.0216053706,
-0.0096023688,
0.0521812029,
-0.0408288129,
-0.0322248526,
-0.0526540242,
-0.066631265,
-0.0560667738,
-0.0209156275,
0.0283782873,
-0.011964283,
0.0003263006,
-0.0363459252,
0.0155713325,
-0.0559634157,
0.0509310439,
0.0521219708,
0.0189428385,
0.0592035241,
0.0189848859,
0.0053304615,
0.026735751,
0.0742265284,
-0.0032657865,
-0.0084133744,
-0.0155688189,
0.0288447719,
-0.0359633528,
-0.0053746784,
0.0296785645,
-0.0204792134,
0.0405306928,
-0.045192495,
0.0374589153,
-0.0360341929,
-0.0436867438,
-0.0124276681,
-0.0228297655,
-0.0176195893,
0.0134386579,
-0.0274599828,
-0.0016865997,
0.0079221204,
-0.0193144567,
0.0359343849,
0.0000197454,
-0.0469242968,
0.0194777641,
0.0375582539,
-0.0191796664,
-0.0784739926,
0.0220556147,
-0.0054513034,
-0.0010598529,
-0.088371411,
0.0323114432,
2.414762484e-34,
0.0424792655,
0.0099604018,
-0.0182998609,
-0.025804393,
0.062272694,
0.0016204251,
-0.0269408543,
0.0001829037,
0.0003012703,
-0.064959228,
-0.0151735488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00463v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00463v2 | Open-Source Conversational AI with SpeechBrain 1.0 | 2024-06-29T15:20:11 | 2024-07-02T12:53:10 | Mirco Ravanelli, Titouan Parcollet, Adel Moumen, Sylvain de Langen, Cem Subakan, Peter Plantinga, Yingzhi Wang, Pooneh Mousavi, Luca Della Libera, Artem Ploujnikov, Francesco Paissan, Davide Borra, Salah Zaiem, Zeyu Zhao, Shucong Zhang, Georgios Karakasidis, Sung-Lin Yeh, Aku Rouhe, Rudolf Braun, Florian Mai, Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Seyed Mahed Mousavi, Andreas Nautsch, Xuechen Liu, Sangeet Sagar, Jarod Duret, Salima Mdhaffar, Gaelle Laperriere, Renato De Mori, Yannick Esteve | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.AS | SpeechBrain is an open-source Conversational AI toolkit based on PyTorch,
focused particularly on speech processing tasks such as speech recognition,
speech enhancement, speaker recognition, text-to-speech, and much more. It
promotes transparency and replicability by releasing both the pre-trained
models and the complete "recipes" of code and algorithms required for training
them. This paper presents SpeechBrain 1.0, a significant milestone in the
evolution of the toolkit, which now has over 200 recipes for speech, audio, and
language processing tasks, and more than 100 models available on Hugging Face.
SpeechBrain 1.0 introduces new technologies to support diverse learning
modalities, Large Language Model (LLM) integration, and advanced decoding
strategies, along with novel models, tasks, and modalities. It also includes a
new benchmark repository, offering researchers a unified platform for
evaluating models across diverse tasks | Open-Source Conversational AI with SpeechBrain 1.0: SpeechBrain is an open-source Conversational AI toolkit based on PyTorch,
focused particularly on speech processing tasks such as speech recognition,
speech enhancement, speaker recognition, text-to-speech, and much more. It
promotes transparency and replicability by releasing both the pre-trained
models and the complete "recipes" of code and algorithms required for training
them. This paper presents SpeechBrain 1.0, a significant milestone in the
evolution of the toolkit, which now has over 200 recipes for speech, audio, and
language processing tasks, and more than 100 models available on Hugging Face.
SpeechBrain 1.0 introduces new technologies to support diverse learning
modalities, Large Language Model (LLM) integration, and advanced decoding
strategies, along with novel models, tasks, and modalities. It also includes a
new benchmark repository, offering researchers a unified platform for
evaluating models across diverse tasks | [
-0.0045485757,
0.0802661702,
0.0189017747,
0.0231060255,
-0.0232558176,
0.0113336639,
0.0254831221,
-0.033956062,
0.0084317215,
-0.0163236372,
-0.0675308928,
-0.0147109879,
0.0289915409,
0.0733240545,
0.0422764644,
-0.0752140433,
0.0421895385,
-0.0288685448,
0.0312055647,
0.0207314789,
0.0064769178,
0.0093114283,
-0.0765543804,
0.0567871667,
-0.0259683542,
-0.0001124956,
-0.0341761261,
-0.0130699342,
0.0252479836,
-0.0078094956,
0.0109639876,
0.0258215629,
0.0336114913,
0.0469992384,
0.0000018316,
-0.0040897559,
0.019088598,
-0.008814198,
-0.0352787226,
-0.01207498,
0.0456479043,
-0.0134500479,
-0.0080524273,
0.0435792394,
-0.0536144376,
-0.0149055086,
0.0410992503,
0.0613561757,
0.0660289153,
0.0645405054,
0.0056374935,
-0.0082326708,
0.0481477156,
-0.0219132453,
-0.0066642524,
-0.0469740294,
-0.0195064973,
-0.024445245,
0.0037437191,
-0.0238783471,
-0.0221938323,
0.0372686014,
0.0256234016,
-0.0244735703,
0.0615037121,
0.0356427841,
-0.06698782,
-0.060342025,
-0.0644816533,
0.0968221873,
-0.004911623,
-0.0059640482,
-0.0099425111,
0.010743171,
-0.0169310682,
-0.0546886474,
-0.0313945897,
0.0037010927,
0.04310707,
0.0247807633,
-0.0389839113,
0.0064294585,
0.0156459659,
0.0030951323,
0.0029206816,
0.0369662866,
0.0029433474,
0.0024397119,
0.0057002408,
-0.0178677142,
0.0146826832,
-0.0575034805,
0.0216563456,
0.0400382057,
-0.0284142978,
0.0072762901,
-0.0797231719,
-0.0309642721,
-0.0057640364,
-0.0062925695,
-0.0134917041,
0.0497526713,
-0.0479342937,
0.0377319455,
-0.0368179716,
0.0602017753,
0.0080869617,
-0.0173863564,
-0.0060044341,
-0.0176106039,
0.0134781525,
0.0430677682,
-0.0216086246,
0.0026011672,
-0.0433976315,
-0.0822674856,
-0.0230956636,
0.0198864453,
-0.0285223573,
0.0333161019,
0.0218723267,
0.0360387526,
-0.0445980504,
0.0007961483,
0.022714084,
0.0318886414,
0.0242116004,
0.0365842544,
0.005753221,
-0.0719966963,
-0.0375649109,
0.0379683524,
0.0330996923,
-0.0067600533,
0.0195598174,
0.0472103544,
-0.0071181748,
-0.0331202149,
0.0224927794,
0.0578122512,
-0.0014515694,
-0.0568488985,
-0.0058662528,
-0.04415714,
0.0169316847,
-0.0288654156,
-0.0022470476,
-0.016790688,
0.0260223821,
-0.0291875415,
0.0021564406,
0.0530334376,
-0.0170637667,
0.0035244718,
0.0439076833,
0.0164568238,
-0.0137778483,
0.0271461252,
0.0389428437,
0.0311828218,
-0.0004891188,
-0.010350626,
0.0149827506,
0.031197207,
0.0215614084,
-0.0113835167,
0.0047146711,
-0.0105592404,
-0.0057087713,
0.0214195661,
0.0492817275,
0.0367777236,
-0.0664514452,
-0.0259532593,
0.0643817484,
0.0734966248,
0.006676808,
0.0201464966,
-0.0069532972,
0.011497301,
0.0206284113,
-0.0210946202,
-0.0716864765,
0.0454344489,
-0.0293773953,
0.0016399442,
-0.0040491214,
0.0385741182,
-0.0521495007,
-0.0199618153,
0.0365195237,
-0.0648984239,
0.04810201,
0.012557663,
0.0494559109,
0.0041931164,
-0.0464933775,
0.0150039392,
-0.0013469717,
-0.0659925491,
-0.0186547376,
-0.0261888839,
0.0471517332,
0.0443067625,
0.0046329731,
-0.0494037978,
-0.0535224378,
-0.0163394194,
-0.0237774495,
0.0574308746,
0.0104714204,
-0.0237282403,
0.1238826215,
-0.0805833042,
-0.0010878709,
-0.0198312495,
0.0056237392,
0.0648393482,
0.0116642984,
0.0309578516,
0.0107454024,
0.0412334763,
0.0475883484,
0.0253462568,
-0.0376173705,
-0.0132731171,
0.0058969958,
-0.0208289213,
0.0553065166,
0.0301251356,
-0.0197492149,
-0.0278145131,
0.031900689,
-0.0397490375,
0.0099237356,
0.033895459,
-0.0471308604,
-0.0316064321,
0.0423858464,
-0.0036495407,
-0.0038588338,
0.0545821115,
-0.0338930674,
-0.0686027333,
0.1018621698,
-0.018120179,
0.0536114462,
-0.0405072086,
0.0134692742,
-0.001028524,
0.0274831019,
0.0443470664,
-0.0018740889,
0.0209578834,
-0.0622976236,
0.0334967636,
0.0224103183,
-0.0191042945,
-0.0611670464,
-0.0405464731,
0.0471361578,
-0.0177860819,
0.0191746298,
-0.0177338254,
0.0186827965,
-0.0582857653,
-0.0246222187,
-0.110353671,
-0.000243949,
0.0014553202,
-0.0066676429,
-0.0074068764,
0.0318100713,
-0.0079362392,
-0.0306352638,
-0.0240819063,
0.0080218222,
0.0249762535,
-0.0298408587,
-0.0276841968,
0.0257564075,
-0.0416975319,
-0.0593694709,
0.0066345101,
0.0592277125,
0.0054238942,
-0.0313593224,
-0.070017226,
-0.0179437734,
0.0325999409,
-0.0337490104,
0.061433021,
-0.0360813476,
-0.0416772068,
0.0024167614,
-0.0045450917,
0.0432441197,
0.094503358,
0.0122645628,
-0.0041340208,
0.0244530849,
-0.024640061,
-0.0694695711,
0.022479279,
-0.0095456224,
0.0294159874,
-0.024345886,
0.0192355923,
-0.0255536698,
0.0411736183,
0.0153448274,
0.0325219259,
-0.0332247913,
-0.0044438699,
0.0292250011,
-0.0677447692,
-0.0163474269,
-0.0303511713,
-0.0358477272,
0.0176188853,
0.0059782262,
-0.0768092349,
0.0327428021,
-0.0687193945,
-0.0355491154,
-0.0206561293,
-0.0646084845,
-0.0053429715,
0.0340014622,
-0.0185447559,
0.0165213943,
-0.0146771977,
-0.0614610203,
0.0051287799,
-0.0111733656,
-0.0066074594,
-0.0564642772,
0.0123222386,
-0.0165103972,
-0.0102456026,
-0.0014368215,
-0.0343557112,
-0.0472296737,
0.0180710703,
-0.0493060201,
-0.0049712239,
0.009124754,
-0.0478886403,
-0.0160792954,
0.0094320569,
0.0291877333,
0.0477316119,
-0.017676793,
0.0315785632,
-0.0155441603,
0.0160523616,
0.0436185189,
0.035233058,
0.0382554792,
0.0019605956,
0.0368069038,
0.0417319909,
0.0635242462,
-0.0015816753,
-0.0749321058,
0.0186798908,
0.0286776628,
0.0427515395,
-0.0141452746,
0.0035544145,
0.0229255129,
-0.0552472994,
0.0193292703,
0.1079920754,
0.0066163675,
-0.0214634351,
-0.0137716727,
-0.0283815395,
0.0024594797,
0.0025594968,
-0.0017061293,
-0.0604047216,
-0.0305570718,
0.0431210659,
0.0185910612,
0.0060497262,
0.0075588105,
-0.0130290436,
-0.058971528,
0.0318185501,
0.0330983736,
-0.0334784314,
-0.0547479428,
-0.0148103805,
0.0067570042,
-0.0529863127,
0.0232270528,
0.01637372,
0.0168554801,
-0.0103528006,
-0.0178616978,
-0.0074173305,
-0.0177955367,
0.0223569833,
-0.0437617116,
0.1097015813,
0.0756926164,
0.0545477718,
0.0222774055,
-0.0010536812,
0.0250264313,
0.0194045212,
-0.0076108784,
-0.0394754298,
0.044613719,
-0.0078534987,
0.0017907609,
-0.0099998638,
0.0647720024,
-0.0115748653,
-0.0165036861,
0.0012386122,
0.0074920175,
-0.0432563573,
-0.0106947022,
-0.0230342429,
0.0388489589,
0.0256108455,
0.0417051464,
0.0183879901,
-0.0102009177,
-0.0456324778,
-0.022732785,
-0.0068397345,
0.0035928686,
-0.014225048,
0.0101204515,
0.0431346446,
-0.047504086,
-0.0424147435,
-0.0078974748,
0.023740571,
0.0375432819,
-0.0058161365,
-0.0289128702,
0.0206134543,
0.0291019864,
-0.031094173,
0.0156831481,
0.0092663271,
0.0318166167,
-0.0476105176,
-0.0075396155,
0.012937855,
-0.0775674134,
-0.0057804878,
0.0215107221,
-0.0630787984,
-0.0656944588,
-0.0256084315,
0.0526739061,
0.0309896227,
0.076422967,
-0.0459704064,
-0.0404843614,
0.0280878413,
-0.0040690689,
-0.0295844041,
0.0468821153,
0.0855183974,
0.0088507924,
0.0064000655,
0.0282422882,
-0.0487393178,
0.0223342981,
-0.0400228836,
0.0096117919,
-0.0243595578,
-0.0625947416,
-0.0293253399,
0.007000675,
0.0239855722,
0.0346134156,
0.002072294,
-0.0551869608,
0.0108281132,
0.0146352574,
0.0592821762,
-0.075810492,
0.0150461067,
0.0168831944,
0.0150136845,
0.0074466662,
-0.0211178008,
0.0076210536,
-0.0086342776,
-0.0084831556,
0.0339570083,
0.0173592977,
-0.0001033074,
0.0045171673,
0.0078263842,
-0.037255995,
0.0249282327,
0.0054529016,
0.028209364,
0.0269803219,
0.0335423276,
-0.0201886799,
-0.0545512438,
0.0104740839,
0.0313477889,
-0.0815606639,
-0.045067545,
-0.033322446,
0.0368570648,
0.0100830793,
0.0276980195,
0.0652420819,
-0.0101742772,
0.0199865419,
-0.0027312946,
0.0343658254,
-0.0156828146,
-0.0157631785,
0.0193621516,
-0.0041985009,
-0.0336861201,
0.017255161,
0.0445285067,
-0.0113425432,
0.0401572511,
0.0122801848,
0.051987011,
-0.0488940254,
-0.0646155924,
0.0231571849,
0.0221491307,
-0.0314491652,
0.0141734146,
0.0179005694,
-0.0360295996,
0.0028246988,
0.010656449,
-0.0240711384,
-0.0199494287,
0.0038168603,
-0.0056619751,
-0.0243883207,
0.0063662403,
-0.016974235,
-0.0087462822,
-0.0229883753,
-0.0336452574,
0.0166142378,
-5.784776678e-33,
-0.0430918783,
-0.0020630576,
0.0036135744,
0.0002541606,
-0.0313411057,
0.0271815285,
-0.0453123972,
0.0046076053,
-0.0380905643,
-0.0329133011,
0.0039190301,
0.0703722537,
0.0155208074,
0.0279234909,
-0.0381132364,
-0.0066168578,
0.0386190526,
-0.0170634408,
0.0024242622,
0.0441481732,
0.0168684777,
0.0454659574,
0.049338907,
-0.0969011262,
-0.0321661383,
0.0155980298,
-0.0353701487,
-0.0183077361,
0.0063528912,
0.0062639974,
-0.0241946131,
-0.0029680142,
-0.0278680921,
-0.0042043105,
-0.010753219,
0.0359299928,
-0.0657249838,
0.0199008845,
-0.0260004606,
0.0231318828,
-0.0584234297,
-0.0166330077,
0.0199139901,
0.0021386086,
-0.0224211924,
-0.0093222465,
-0.0017845025,
-0.0664439276,
0.0115280561,
-0.0151418298,
-0.0339669473,
0.0386642218,
-0.0244298223,
-0.0429589525,
0.0456422381,
0.0700999722,
-0.0069230124,
0.0168337263,
-0.034112934,
0.0584482364,
-0.0195935275,
0.0140968021,
0.052746851,
-0.0047708452,
0.0282749142,
0.0571928993,
0.0556852221,
-0.0867986083,
0.0113607291,
-0.0125469053,
0.0402917489,
0.1072217897,
0.0412739329,
0.0461968184,
-0.0344563499,
-0.012121819,
0.0165512767,
0.0193430167,
0.0612137206,
0.0075901011,
-0.0052047595,
0.0313089564,
-0.0216101166,
0.0242128558,
-0.0260610301,
-0.0042573139,
-0.0348600969,
-0.0143364994,
0.0164789278,
0.0432821214,
-0.0148057947,
-0.0207333267,
0.0502320714,
-0.0258655287,
0.0382588804,
0.0618804879,
0.0032064365,
0.0047161304,
0.000060999,
0.0566798858,
-0.0554714203,
-0.0339163244,
0.0863920525,
0.0224664435,
0.0118029425,
-0.0151635008,
-0.0267050061,
0.0415124521,
-0.0244527105,
-0.014425924,
-0.0300207976,
0.0557719693,
0.0120827733,
0.0547180586,
0.0364743434,
-0.0187464673,
-0.0147149041,
0.0368840136,
-0.0432613567,
0.0423134305,
-0.0399301425,
-0.059775196,
0.0254871827,
-0.0037134483,
-0.0615170524,
-0.0008133129,
-0.040998552,
-0.0155631844,
0.0253356732,
-0.0572993867,
-0.0220611151,
0.0200713445,
2.707e-7,
-0.043678198,
0.0430713221,
0.0390755199,
-0.0296935532,
0.034347944,
0.041230049,
-0.0290591251,
0.0265876781,
0.0105801793,
-0.000350771,
0.0138798328,
0.0160759632,
0.0672979578,
0.0228830799,
-0.0348369218,
-0.0418750718,
-0.0707294643,
-0.0082428176,
-0.0037483398,
-0.0081245322,
0.0017823948,
0.1096536815,
0.0045329649,
-0.0151295178,
0.0596630722,
-0.0127604716,
0.0208458304,
-0.0487169772,
0.0086257402,
-0.0232938081,
-0.0105909202,
0.0179161783,
-0.0002258973,
-0.0355915129,
-0.0159846153,
0.0248406809,
0.0184785668,
0.0852052346,
-0.017931344,
-0.0780509934,
-0.006517611,
0.0479437783,
-0.0240580719,
-0.0476037264,
0.0536320172,
-0.0094180945,
-0.0549026988,
-0.0635589659,
-0.0448142178,
-0.0130468449,
0.0024755686,
-0.0291434042,
0.0172570087,
0.0082348082,
-0.013055997,
-0.0424686819,
-0.0318766497,
-0.0933973193,
0.0027573274,
-0.0355176926,
-0.0631600246,
-0.0134198777,
-0.0496556945,
-0.0023739105,
-0.0068574278,
-0.0412479565,
-0.0005118549,
1.986730094e-34,
0.0231147483,
-0.0201984905,
0.0202214234,
0.0185459983,
0.0041644797,
0.013396034,
-0.0013469483,
-0.0082170572,
0.0172889121,
-0.0611139089,
-0.0467649922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00455v1 | Polarization and Morality: Lexical Analysis of Abortion Discourse on Reddit | 2024-06-29T14:50:55 | 2024-06-29T14:50:55 | Tessa Stanier, Hagyeong Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | This study investigates whether division on political topics is mapped with
the distinctive patterns of language use. We collect a total 145,832 Reddit
comments on the abortion debate and explore the languages of subreddit
communities r/prolife and r/prochoice. With consideration of the Moral
Foundations Theory, we examine lexical patterns in three ways. First, we
compute proportional frequencies of lexical items from the Moral Foundations
Dictionary in order to make inferences about each group's moral considerations
when forming arguments for and against abortion. We then create n-gram models
to reveal frequent collocations from each stance group and better understand
how commonly used words are patterned in their linguistic context and in
relation to morality values. Finally, we use Latent Dirichlet Allocation to
identify underlying topical structures in the corpus data. Results show that
the use of morality words is mapped with the stances on abortion. | Polarization and Morality: Lexical Analysis of Abortion Discourse on Reddit: This study investigates whether division on political topics is mapped with
the distinctive patterns of language use. We collect a total 145,832 Reddit
comments on the abortion debate and explore the languages of subreddit
communities r/prolife and r/prochoice. With consideration of the Moral
Foundations Theory, we examine lexical patterns in three ways. First, we
compute proportional frequencies of lexical items from the Moral Foundations
Dictionary in order to make inferences about each group's moral considerations
when forming arguments for and against abortion. We then create n-gram models
to reveal frequent collocations from each stance group and better understand
how commonly used words are patterned in their linguistic context and in
relation to morality values. Finally, we use Latent Dirichlet Allocation to
identify underlying topical structures in the corpus data. Results show that
the use of morality words is mapped with the stances on abortion. | [
0.0447996445,
0.0916813612,
-0.0121586034,
0.021761395,
-0.0407148376,
0.0060516628,
0.0185563564,
-0.0207633618,
-0.0602703206,
-0.032417845,
0.0050913817,
-0.0490316302,
0.0023556214,
-0.0187268443,
-0.0321985036,
-0.0348177813,
0.0133478902,
0.0534376167,
0.0539193712,
-0.0139613012,
0.0308174398,
0.0225971024,
-0.0156924594,
0.03935913,
0.0020513425,
-0.0077340379,
0.019544391,
-0.0056834649,
0.0285199098,
-0.0175142437,
0.0162740722,
0.0672252476,
-0.0331430621,
-0.0112737129,
0.0000015202,
-0.0291587431,
-0.0157863498,
-0.0120462496,
0.0574657246,
0.0081496472,
0.1159536019,
0.0145867523,
0.0054797675,
0.0290262327,
-0.0155695956,
0.0054999762,
0.0609157272,
0.0619141981,
-0.0039054779,
0.0187069289,
-0.0060807662,
-0.0521934442,
-0.0194417387,
0.0068986434,
-0.0214582384,
0.0336336195,
0.022058934,
0.0077687912,
-0.0277099498,
-0.004763233,
-0.0064494144,
-0.0087856585,
-0.0252864901,
-0.0127347223,
-0.0133775705,
-0.0065176804,
0.0363559797,
-0.0510059744,
0.0425841734,
0.0252598021,
0.0331353582,
-0.0229283627,
0.0630829558,
0.0172602553,
-0.0390930511,
0.0667186454,
-0.0529711023,
0.0471974127,
-0.0361950584,
0.023104284,
0.0727155358,
-0.0117478427,
0.0251484253,
0.0534087047,
0.0122909192,
0.0301860627,
-0.0015866886,
-0.0084657017,
0.0091558639,
-0.0110742133,
-0.0600388832,
-0.0214413442,
0.0460592657,
-0.0458481461,
0.0484146029,
0.0480248332,
-0.0037423482,
-0.0256896894,
0.066749908,
-0.067651622,
-0.0051034647,
-0.0373149477,
0.0250157025,
0.0493387766,
0.0633511692,
-0.0543779247,
-0.0082142856,
-0.0140358824,
-0.0085866991,
0.0198502392,
-0.0426171869,
0.0363096483,
0.0223178174,
-0.0053591174,
0.0073803361,
0.0337691829,
-0.0017273049,
-0.0268092677,
-0.0363323838,
-0.0792910904,
-0.0448050238,
-0.0127311358,
0.0285205934,
-0.0026417684,
-0.0006646953,
0.0313189663,
-0.0557424799,
0.0394372232,
-0.0598465092,
0.0359348394,
0.0601000562,
0.0159070361,
-0.0064080134,
0.0079084206,
-0.0139253521,
0.0504600368,
0.0367721468,
-0.0009649415,
0.0000601303,
-0.0150294518,
-0.033209946,
-0.0033932137,
0.0050820638,
-0.075020276,
-0.0014628846,
0.0182379168,
-0.0176476743,
-0.053966824,
0.0163491238,
0.0476379804,
-0.0377593488,
0.0531437173,
0.0229465757,
0.0171914529,
0.0345470272,
0.0179441012,
0.0087448694,
0.0431161411,
-0.0345836356,
-0.0322995558,
0.0386456437,
-0.0075128204,
-0.0643513203,
-0.0312027708,
-0.0155711798,
0.027184613,
-0.0361014009,
0.0209305119,
-0.0380582213,
-0.0547198206,
0.0096020456,
0.0481699184,
0.0156449098,
-0.0613707118,
0.0179737657,
0.1316689551,
-0.0403121337,
0.0380089395,
-0.0183237735,
0.0377615504,
-0.0103762178,
0.0054915734,
0.01092037,
-0.0379330516,
0.0127890073,
-0.0836902931,
0.0020828152,
0.0420359485,
0.0238152295,
-0.0277200788,
-0.0375989377,
0.0017784399,
0.0174494274,
-0.072163865,
0.0398262255,
-0.0204049367,
0.0359103978,
-0.0012115634,
0.0717909485,
-0.0294424463,
-0.0129169244,
-0.0113339545,
0.0788699314,
0.0138160009,
0.0106581701,
-0.0264079403,
-0.0383466259,
-0.019025404,
0.0406385995,
0.0740238726,
0.0091640195,
-0.0036817538,
-0.091172196,
0.0037876382,
-0.0483398624,
0.0151785053,
0.0216526315,
0.0264952835,
0.0003644005,
0.0194783509,
-0.0222293511,
0.0013320931,
0.0077735716,
0.0230499711,
0.0552702658,
0.0564306974,
-0.0062311706,
0.0037198206,
0.0265116766,
0.0039707758,
-0.0370768309,
-0.0142675033,
0.0180746671,
-0.0246481672,
-0.0321325846,
-0.0192651749,
0.0044964114,
0.0433871783,
0.0171388667,
-0.1041225269,
-0.0198150109,
0.0008029387,
0.0178715643,
0.0346597023,
0.0555678755,
-0.0290358253,
0.0061220485,
0.0021028446,
-0.02368192,
-0.0525840186,
0.0031002655,
-0.0339571722,
0.0602958836,
-0.0314573497,
0.0626045093,
0.008423497,
-0.0755410492,
0.0410619974,
0.0497822389,
0.0064307009,
-0.0332264826,
0.00159378,
0.0401662104,
0.0677744448,
0.0106919296,
-0.0224165004,
-0.0565857813,
-0.0216465853,
-0.0181889031,
-0.0083785625,
0.0396187194,
0.0157041717,
-0.0313214511,
0.007815429,
0.0263979826,
-0.0085733403,
-0.0105077913,
-0.0432218723,
-0.0155471675,
0.0131519828,
-0.0324375778,
0.000848915,
-0.0092418045,
-0.0052002473,
-0.0161877684,
-0.0013430752,
0.0300044399,
-0.0292874295,
0.0209859144,
0.0355548747,
-0.0632580221,
-0.0257534888,
0.0032499384,
-0.0498940647,
0.0141353197,
0.0139146848,
0.0309028979,
0.0077046151,
0.0451290868,
0.0408726558,
0.0116410106,
0.050220523,
-0.0132244471,
-0.0487532727,
-0.0496173501,
0.0375118777,
-0.0342185013,
-0.0281239655,
0.0259831101,
0.0848816112,
0.0103571108,
0.0005258383,
-0.0018273564,
0.0358950272,
-0.0928963423,
-0.0053185304,
0.0131702367,
-0.0082147485,
0.0039916732,
0.0404563025,
0.0032456908,
-0.0214852411,
-0.0086295065,
0.0421371534,
0.0688608959,
-0.036044471,
-0.0389629342,
-0.0050451113,
0.0152724199,
-0.006210668,
0.0188568886,
-0.0155933723,
-0.0167714041,
0.0023219909,
-0.0407916792,
0.0595746301,
-0.0230798591,
0.0826923326,
-0.0532278195,
0.018732613,
0.0037002144,
-0.0411683545,
-0.0219077673,
-0.0896496698,
-0.0042107315,
-0.0400269032,
0.0418487191,
-0.0246038176,
0.0358636938,
0.024777703,
-0.006550231,
-0.0701436549,
0.029796822,
0.0011638,
0.0198003743,
0.0305831693,
0.009953483,
-0.0288810469,
0.0329989307,
0.0190432891,
-0.027815938,
0.0684270933,
-0.0040756976,
0.0287639964,
0.0025417637,
-0.0207920205,
0.0301080346,
-0.0204149634,
-0.0026440171,
-0.0209478904,
0.0141837373,
-0.0105240224,
0.0398255959,
0.0594334602,
0.0384382159,
-0.0592356995,
-0.0322158746,
-0.0292983279,
-0.0324166529,
0.0092799701,
-0.0074487603,
-0.049450513,
0.0180493519,
-0.0159093756,
-0.0083832089,
-0.0511540771,
-0.0568729527,
0.0096426588,
-0.0712955594,
-0.0159287676,
-0.0206630789,
-0.0045175143,
0.0000438191,
-0.0460612252,
0.050943736,
0.0054343431,
-0.0051901434,
-0.0107739316,
0.0020079622,
0.0112564946,
0.0329568125,
-0.0546230339,
-0.0085196216,
0.0227362644,
-0.02532015,
0.0326659009,
-0.0117502613,
0.0720585957,
-0.0283407699,
-0.0151385739,
0.0393039249,
0.0109152682,
-0.0553212613,
-0.0062718638,
-0.0004564455,
0.0024432188,
-0.0173793938,
-0.0496305339,
0.0438449159,
-0.0288986545,
-0.0321378075,
0.0262010433,
0.0546883307,
0.0020205749,
-0.0297466926,
-0.0508884117,
0.0540651716,
0.0138238631,
0.0428776443,
0.0393446051,
-0.0213351864,
0.0164944921,
-0.028674148,
0.0080004456,
-0.0039908043,
-0.0621975064,
-0.064062044,
-0.0414211154,
-0.066027239,
-0.0430149585,
0.0029017441,
-0.0365143605,
0.0023423766,
0.0450479686,
-0.0031928681,
0.0614925884,
-0.011287218,
-0.0479339659,
0.0022323008,
0.0205536261,
-0.0273273475,
0.0108877886,
-0.0513369814,
0.0151890097,
0.0364937857,
-0.0287852008,
-0.02119877,
0.0054526948,
-0.0145772928,
0.0262981616,
-0.0387252457,
0.0107293529,
-0.0092249094,
-0.0364777781,
-0.0058316304,
-0.0104866112,
0.0620310865,
-0.0438609235,
0.0086307013,
0.0059974287,
0.0297350157,
0.0332224891,
0.0235945154,
0.0045747026,
0.0473513231,
0.0146263437,
-0.0378617495,
-0.0755352154,
-0.0018575537,
-0.0096016703,
-0.0109486664,
0.0410014875,
0.0115883239,
-0.0243777968,
-0.0560872965,
-0.0791137293,
-0.0227513071,
-0.0079551041,
0.0101526184,
0.0036225375,
0.0255101733,
-0.0354394615,
-0.0415763482,
0.0312195197,
-0.0640053526,
0.0323684998,
0.0126088206,
0.0532584786,
0.0375782065,
0.0230276883,
-0.0244725253,
0.0130631309,
0.0044282731,
0.0032227302,
0.0173483286,
0.0123666991,
-0.02632262,
0.0260101147,
-0.0056021288,
0.0001683421,
0.0472713001,
-0.0033799033,
-0.0131760743,
-0.0568217076,
0.0021392715,
-0.0094414838,
-0.0215604417,
-0.0024327515,
0.0359392017,
-0.0226532184,
-0.0213366505,
-0.0286454372,
0.0462294482,
-0.0172425658,
0.0021466298,
0.0111799687,
0.003930151,
-0.0491276421,
-0.020335352,
0.0255115367,
-0.0273145661,
-0.0024822119,
0.0811312348,
-0.0677862316,
-0.0163430925,
-0.0201753955,
0.0142461769,
-0.0234932825,
0.0088431872,
0.0296047982,
-0.0704672635,
-0.0295496304,
-0.0168103948,
-0.018041648,
0.036483191,
-0.0133115565,
-0.0015459629,
0.0667102337,
-0.0102563342,
0.0780869201,
-0.0495700985,
0.069235459,
-0.0875911117,
-0.0162369274,
-0.0120477118,
-5.496038898e-33,
-0.0081066722,
-0.0566590317,
-0.0351307206,
0.0371908955,
0.0033778471,
0.0231767595,
0.0263622515,
0.0607002936,
-0.0071959267,
0.0731046796,
0.0137651516,
0.0436954424,
0.0171418674,
0.0006772323,
0.0133416243,
-0.0183371976,
-0.018264683,
-0.0152436486,
0.0090836203,
0.0252919551,
0.0081924293,
-0.0079869358,
0.013610173,
-0.0571045764,
0.0233297478,
0.041833397,
0.0325504132,
0.0035253314,
0.0530448183,
0.0163151603,
-0.0273822285,
0.0470830761,
0.0425273292,
-0.0369511954,
-0.001479498,
0.0940695778,
-0.0270250216,
-0.0569743402,
0.0507433861,
-0.0124932164,
-0.0083313463,
-0.0303900931,
0.0267254058,
0.0415046178,
-0.0347874239,
-0.0272828266,
0.0685571656,
0.0000045012,
0.0102825174,
-0.0588812232,
-0.0294952672,
0.0341345444,
-0.0580043904,
-0.0105977813,
-0.0297828652,
-0.0254796986,
0.0204429552,
0.0324307866,
0.0192260537,
0.0379229262,
-0.0574581884,
0.0306846686,
-0.0105767474,
-0.0570355132,
0.0310306847,
0.0894580632,
-0.0454681367,
0.0273619071,
-0.0308736973,
0.0009197402,
0.0081217391,
0.0400460511,
0.0239759143,
0.0410765372,
0.0424014553,
-0.0461212359,
-0.0535895936,
-0.0302311014,
0.0804019645,
-0.0120838135,
0.0490537547,
-0.0387578756,
-0.0088664973,
0.0045872275,
-0.0436204858,
-0.0951748341,
-0.0269016344,
-0.0203123502,
-0.0375149809,
-0.0368562527,
-0.0523173735,
-0.0484577678,
0.0094132842,
-0.0337927528,
-0.0232515261,
0.0430038609,
-0.0208024271,
-0.0072571049,
0.0042214654,
0.0294957701,
-0.0312653743,
0.0046454053,
-0.055242233,
-0.0089919074,
0.0570081957,
-0.0258544385,
0.0223567598,
-0.0391985886,
-0.0497033112,
-0.0487550125,
-0.024049269,
-0.00667535,
-0.016498087,
0.0710013658,
0.0185703058,
0.066576086,
0.0157563891,
0.0038260361,
0.0408620127,
0.0529421046,
0.027848199,
-0.0341353901,
-0.0527542569,
0.0172553416,
-0.0494832993,
-0.0469363481,
-0.0304299723,
0.0712315962,
0.0435291752,
-0.0287216734,
-0.0218166839,
-0.0185134839,
2.355e-7,
0.0917748436,
0.0613507703,
-0.010867646,
-0.0055817254,
0.0283888076,
0.022838179,
0.047300227,
0.0293066874,
-0.0199735388,
-0.073251754,
-0.0526792519,
0.0070817415,
0.0299469028,
0.0222682096,
-0.0323584639,
-0.0205660686,
-0.0048507405,
0.0235857721,
-0.0258273799,
0.0174134653,
-0.0085144844,
0.0507244878,
0.0452180952,
-0.0017121751,
-0.0465713479,
0.0484073088,
0.028460389,
-0.0634172931,
-0.0723954961,
-0.0140923038,
0.003335309,
-0.0550017618,
0.0202226974,
-0.012549012,
0.0036956714,
-0.0471891537,
0.0493501201,
0.0350834541,
0.0253841318,
-0.017582098,
-0.0038780279,
-0.0529088117,
-0.0155325914,
0.0413459092,
0.0401935019,
-0.0510716327,
-0.0217163004,
-0.0844203904,
-0.009252782,
-0.0346563496,
0.040594656,
0.0131902946,
-0.0464400835,
0.0285186898,
0.0027441545,
-0.0066980137,
0.0021312465,
-0.043062862,
0.0036240106,
0.0352044776,
-0.0361881256,
-0.0536835976,
0.0356201679,
0.0066009765,
0.0472394265,
0.0270533841,
0.0344856754,
1.554980432e-34,
0.0308312047,
-0.017248068,
-0.0190446805,
-0.0179616269,
0.0447098054,
0.0155310081,
-0.0158663802,
0.0213988516,
0.0131389564,
-0.0298664384,
0.0137986485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00454v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00454v1 | Self-Translate-Train: A Simple but Strong Baseline for Cross-lingual Transfer of Large Language Models | 2024-06-29T14:40:23 | 2024-06-29T14:40:23 | Ryokan Ri, Shun Kiyono, Sho Takase | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual transfer is a promising technique for utilizing data in a
source language to improve performance in a target language. However, current
techniques often require an external translation system or suffer from
suboptimal performance due to over-reliance on cross-lingual generalization of
multi-lingual pretrained language models. In this study, we propose a simple
yet effective method called Self-Translate-Train. It leverages the translation
capability of a large language model to generate synthetic training data in the
target language and fine-tunes the model with its own generated data. We
evaluate the proposed method on a wide range of tasks and show substantial
performance gains across several non-English languages. | Self-Translate-Train: A Simple but Strong Baseline for Cross-lingual Transfer of Large Language Models: Cross-lingual transfer is a promising technique for utilizing data in a
source language to improve performance in a target language. However, current
techniques often require an external translation system or suffer from
suboptimal performance due to over-reliance on cross-lingual generalization of
multi-lingual pretrained language models. In this study, we propose a simple
yet effective method called Self-Translate-Train. It leverages the translation
capability of a large language model to generate synthetic training data in the
target language and fine-tunes the model with its own generated data. We
evaluate the proposed method on a wide range of tasks and show substantial
performance gains across several non-English languages. | [
-0.0199588798,
0.0537759624,
-0.0038492442,
0.0573092252,
-0.008065002,
0.0024089543,
0.0508947074,
-0.0301161893,
0.0011696242,
-0.0365509018,
-0.0988261774,
-0.010642888,
-0.0402971804,
0.0083252527,
0.0365921594,
-0.0454999208,
0.0516890138,
-0.0446268767,
-0.0586485006,
0.0005994498,
-0.0320755914,
0.0254282299,
0.0079866005,
-0.0131534068,
-0.0101273693,
-0.0069463849,
0.0246070381,
0.0335182473,
0.0205771029,
-0.0042146281,
-0.0038102877,
0.0400882587,
0.0356568433,
0.0586112551,
0.0000019181,
-0.0237833448,
-0.0182013176,
0.0037640757,
0.0002207901,
0.0219785254,
0.0576924384,
-0.0572409034,
-0.0345163345,
0.0117869927,
-0.0374898538,
-0.0547361784,
0.042874448,
0.0276099332,
0.043996457,
0.1089622676,
-0.0246163178,
-0.054678943,
-0.000340566,
-0.0518136099,
0.0174999293,
-0.0415049493,
0.0048156939,
0.0397443064,
-0.065315336,
0.0141119175,
-0.0262363944,
0.0339657553,
0.0203836188,
-0.0080193914,
-0.0027934157,
0.0012814954,
-0.0188383367,
0.0044615404,
-0.0052830908,
0.0737757385,
-0.0776496753,
-0.0268819705,
-0.0210184641,
-0.0037919744,
-0.0038522438,
-0.0108169364,
-0.0426495075,
0.0025430331,
0.0397613458,
0.030461669,
0.0239720196,
0.0116366521,
0.0392923355,
-0.0304797217,
-0.0504229181,
0.0083434898,
0.0423628204,
0.0024916378,
0.0455038399,
0.0150323045,
0.0352962911,
-0.0231347904,
0.0144807762,
0.0010402707,
0.0155097693,
0.0123030553,
-0.0629676431,
-0.0363493003,
-0.0145373521,
-0.0445438996,
0.0458675325,
0.0593317188,
-0.0236589592,
0.0463705286,
-0.0784500986,
0.0392281339,
-0.0323817097,
0.0316891782,
-0.0819082484,
-0.0320770517,
-0.0402839072,
0.0265292153,
-0.0546526797,
-0.0255375095,
-0.0343300179,
-0.0230943542,
-0.0413738079,
-0.0207819492,
0.0110401362,
-0.0202131737,
0.0488499552,
-0.0252992231,
-0.0864198133,
-0.0140673378,
0.0136531312,
0.042717576,
-0.008750692,
0.0089105796,
-0.0075468952,
-0.0423573554,
-0.0120453183,
0.0125588942,
0.0035636676,
-0.0464009568,
0.0258769151,
0.0703956783,
-0.0472838506,
-0.0175643433,
-0.038244918,
0.0370376557,
-0.0041283411,
-0.0703104511,
0.0148959402,
-0.0582218245,
0.0496063717,
-0.0215196125,
0.0314279571,
-0.0292610582,
-0.0022183359,
-0.0172886699,
0.0048698415,
0.0730079487,
-0.0239137784,
0.0233261995,
0.0163685065,
-0.0273402929,
0.0035556951,
0.0919395238,
0.0231035445,
0.0130102392,
0.0219365675,
-0.0210304074,
-0.0104164667,
0.0799769983,
0.0319637619,
0.0254470259,
-0.038827423,
-0.0063494975,
0.052157823,
0.0188111253,
0.059866704,
-0.0067546004,
-0.0104765836,
0.0215533804,
0.0541758128,
0.0235980619,
0.0529194549,
0.067814678,
0.076065287,
-0.0201619025,
0.0045934366,
-0.0251464471,
-0.0292942151,
0.0150934933,
0.0205162298,
-0.0053160749,
-0.015681576,
0.0600348189,
-0.0461781472,
-0.008620793,
0.0336055905,
-0.0284653306,
0.0109609282,
0.0152267702,
0.0680781528,
0.0650897399,
-0.0142735159,
0.0472542681,
0.0472877808,
-0.0470536239,
0.0497450568,
-0.0016544532,
-0.0140597988,
0.0540863723,
-0.0079531837,
0.0144331297,
-0.017739471,
-0.006839327,
0.0223892368,
0.0253643747,
0.0850126669,
-0.0057729539,
0.0333645754,
-0.0431909822,
-0.0000320854,
-0.0264603458,
-0.0070643649,
0.0550551601,
-0.0121025387,
0.0627795756,
0.0336448886,
-0.0413570553,
-0.0461574681,
0.0389815755,
-0.0718573704,
-0.0246001985,
0.0506647564,
0.0150177423,
0.0069975876,
0.0048142588,
-0.0071703806,
-0.0118572246,
0.0045590671,
-0.0680978,
-0.0050799907,
0.0182728563,
-0.0414854661,
-0.0405263305,
0.0407561772,
-0.0161200166,
-0.0066166287,
0.0196400937,
-0.0342920162,
-0.0460176468,
0.0261360593,
0.0090746777,
0.0055546178,
-0.0401664972,
0.0126378201,
0.0289639588,
0.04538038,
0.0072435788,
0.007952272,
0.0559605621,
-0.0117017478,
-0.0180582106,
0.0011022846,
0.0245111752,
-0.0286209006,
0.0228815395,
0.0252049677,
-0.0074783266,
0.0190976392,
0.0201270208,
0.0423893593,
-0.0184928495,
-0.012883733,
-0.0737635717,
0.034073364,
-0.0161425471,
0.0141321002,
0.0280241147,
0.0331968553,
-0.0192157961,
-0.0341658741,
-0.0387964211,
-0.0002239157,
0.0187860616,
-0.009261176,
-0.0107867904,
-0.0104257399,
0.0384937562,
-0.0316545293,
-0.0065825088,
0.0358576663,
0.0412202887,
-0.0193200503,
-0.001552936,
-0.054425288,
0.0539205857,
-0.0250512715,
0.0360363461,
0.001250427,
-0.0653270856,
-0.0232100748,
-0.0231984723,
0.0470828228,
0.057383161,
-0.0129048266,
-0.0423222817,
0.0563358217,
-0.0398298688,
-0.0564520471,
0.0136873079,
-0.0117082139,
-0.017259432,
-0.0679661855,
-0.0289683715,
-0.0167458504,
0.0369861647,
-0.0126920985,
-0.0235428214,
-0.0613664873,
-0.0199664515,
-0.0258077309,
-0.0330459587,
-0.0320972428,
0.0451077893,
0.0098763322,
0.0423730053,
-0.0190696549,
-0.0136797074,
0.0259436574,
-0.0579158552,
-0.0208635852,
-0.0295986775,
-0.0188813098,
-0.0350455008,
0.0341596343,
-0.0154377297,
0.0389173105,
-0.0268457346,
0.0033359174,
-0.0306975842,
-0.0247473959,
0.0313489325,
-0.0158209521,
0.0072055906,
-0.0227616895,
0.0018934626,
-0.0053006168,
-0.0256888904,
-0.0364926495,
-0.0027326159,
0.0078203948,
-0.0125016104,
-0.0130360443,
-0.0176801533,
-0.0233465359,
-0.0034042238,
0.0194552839,
0.0893919095,
-0.0166153125,
0.0072619589,
-0.0078554144,
0.0109800743,
0.0203654207,
-0.0038346695,
-0.0034689577,
-0.0394523628,
0.031741228,
0.0176907685,
0.0249161087,
-0.004621617,
-0.056610655,
0.0149523616,
0.0150998356,
-0.0064518568,
-0.0165148098,
-0.0236050989,
0.0530650057,
-0.0464674383,
-0.0251851473,
0.0932730436,
-0.002336768,
-0.0230932534,
-0.0165629182,
-0.0294466075,
-0.0081372671,
0.0287036933,
0.0655470341,
-0.0609043762,
-0.0207984727,
0.0059512528,
0.0002446689,
0.0455366038,
0.0141500821,
-0.0127577512,
-0.1421665251,
0.0212778468,
0.0304312985,
-0.091163978,
-0.0523662306,
-0.0337047242,
-0.0235128906,
-0.0258726161,
0.0118513685,
-0.0460170992,
-0.0001926858,
-0.0086319,
-0.0057286294,
0.0041895718,
-0.0544305295,
0.0158908516,
-0.0587511882,
0.0429045707,
0.0485552512,
0.0476669781,
-0.0111597236,
-0.0053420258,
0.0454702377,
-0.01542594,
-0.0247135572,
-0.0107215242,
0.057181567,
0.0027807876,
-0.0321138762,
0.0671129003,
0.0071392171,
-0.0405314565,
0.0006967832,
0.0342457481,
0.0623189621,
0.0393743776,
-0.0222787224,
0.0357507318,
-0.0295925848,
0.0436324961,
0.0414078161,
0.0005274845,
-0.0197156072,
0.0059412052,
-0.0078661479,
-0.025532661,
-0.0560532287,
-0.0561194792,
0.0203870982,
-0.0564434044,
-0.0674645454,
-0.0660929903,
-0.0599365123,
0.0215231087,
0.0456026979,
0.0303456131,
-0.0022573315,
-0.0065119369,
-0.0012886105,
-0.0099439938,
0.0506990068,
-0.0521453135,
0.0157734249,
-0.0085091656,
-0.0264393967,
0.038950216,
-0.0279181302,
0.0213878211,
-0.0122080594,
-0.0188366473,
-0.0421582572,
-0.0172557272,
0.0815419927,
0.0073303725,
0.0581101403,
-0.039014589,
-0.0201441124,
0.0249295924,
0.0029572409,
-0.0709725395,
-0.0284300745,
0.0629242361,
-0.0181516148,
0.0093609337,
0.0514588617,
-0.0227461029,
0.0564469732,
0.0171453841,
0.0359914787,
-0.0088961851,
-0.0484921299,
0.0207652319,
0.012747962,
0.0256107505,
-0.0088963713,
0.0117477011,
-0.0509807169,
0.0112815732,
-0.0601425655,
-0.0202944968,
-0.0605205521,
0.0107752103,
0.0717882589,
0.0122569064,
0.0186354984,
0.0063211289,
-0.0227492824,
-0.0461214557,
-0.0227645338,
-0.0287828501,
-0.0093257269,
0.0563353263,
0.0161294434,
0.0378863513,
0.0108148856,
-0.0130252726,
0.0403830484,
0.0153265884,
-0.0452068932,
-0.0046059527,
0.0086720949,
0.0131818792,
-0.0119542889,
0.0054124692,
-0.0194252878,
-0.0284887701,
-0.0392792597,
-0.0008507209,
0.0685719252,
-0.0271881949,
0.109939985,
-0.003779033,
-0.0283497721,
-0.0048300615,
0.0404309593,
-0.0090628946,
0.0071796081,
-0.0082780439,
-0.0359814391,
-0.0020563339,
-0.0000706983,
0.0479425527,
0.001613302,
0.0419322699,
0.0060080527,
0.0127741685,
-0.0285841022,
-0.0220442507,
0.0237536468,
-0.0567192212,
-0.0253676362,
-0.0017192975,
0.011234846,
-0.0812184513,
0.0043487451,
0.0078734327,
-0.0349681154,
0.0276226215,
0.0320650823,
0.0814932287,
-0.0276882201,
0.0074995323,
-0.0399176069,
0.0048758634,
0.0255086645,
-0.0147778559,
0.0145127568,
-5.696440114e-33,
-0.0337228179,
0.0393462069,
0.0312527008,
-0.0279134568,
-0.0392550975,
-0.041819457,
-0.0364268795,
-0.011113896,
0.0166005585,
0.0227042157,
-0.009783729,
-0.012279165,
0.0310915094,
0.0255705994,
0.014189993,
0.0316779502,
0.0706049949,
-0.0224610362,
-0.0173866823,
0.0343392231,
0.0316684321,
0.0530474409,
0.0989704952,
-0.056233272,
-0.0197639633,
0.0176242702,
-0.0016945292,
0.0225657094,
0.0320504531,
0.0215764213,
-0.0080631552,
0.0114162881,
-0.0152473934,
-0.0439079553,
-0.031706091,
-0.0035087981,
-0.0798799619,
-0.0313011371,
-0.0039448338,
0.0372499451,
-0.0067842933,
-0.0295681283,
0.0110812513,
-0.0386005268,
0.0174412522,
-0.0089108814,
0.0186456628,
-0.064654462,
-0.00406241,
-0.0278016925,
-0.0906310901,
0.0009220139,
-0.0044004684,
-0.0130117033,
0.0825678036,
0.0490905121,
-0.0007895834,
-0.0414821766,
-0.0334530175,
0.0200789608,
-0.0443136953,
0.0532040745,
0.063153334,
0.0165053159,
-0.0176974293,
0.0089297639,
0.0504638143,
-0.0323857665,
0.0344062746,
0.0037796034,
0.0510635041,
0.0162897371,
0.0377065614,
0.0808359832,
0.0350826271,
-0.0257710703,
-0.075865671,
0.0619512275,
-0.0206825435,
-0.0016803668,
-0.0158117861,
0.0051541794,
0.0254843999,
0.0069189863,
-0.0450562052,
-0.0393752046,
-0.0015034686,
-0.046251528,
0.0278082304,
0.0130049149,
-0.0252741184,
-0.0050460431,
0.0674142912,
-0.0379007608,
-0.0222126581,
-0.0075716288,
-0.0293322075,
-0.0112556908,
-0.0242025405,
0.0436844602,
-0.0384365804,
-0.0695618168,
0.0243842322,
0.0173439234,
0.0170126557,
-0.0145040751,
0.0524417683,
0.0323953293,
-0.0575485751,
0.019582415,
-0.0429745503,
0.0173496399,
0.0124231279,
0.0542950109,
0.0009053438,
0.0005173958,
-0.0241025537,
0.0412359238,
0.0207986478,
-0.0212015025,
-0.0089959586,
-0.0028024779,
0.0567114912,
0.0468373932,
-0.0315680169,
0.0049903933,
-0.0669454038,
-0.0055244463,
0.052938085,
-0.0471577756,
-0.0219843015,
0.0008293887,
2.494e-7,
0.0511797667,
0.0162045117,
-0.0200362988,
0.0165339429,
-0.0120119974,
0.021109432,
-0.0459420085,
0.0275009219,
0.0262036268,
0.0080919396,
0.0111293988,
0.0705307201,
0.0841115564,
0.0421981141,
-0.0420254692,
0.0057338588,
-0.0153981708,
0.0229868107,
-0.0363119133,
-0.0145264287,
-0.0382825881,
0.096259281,
-0.0147942454,
-0.014298467,
0.0123669077,
-0.0252023097,
0.0822765902,
-0.0494271368,
-0.0341605656,
0.0176172648,
-0.0189158712,
0.0507148132,
-0.0553711429,
-0.0058751325,
-0.0436608084,
0.0266028792,
0.049069196,
0.0461597368,
0.0122450897,
0.0047479067,
0.0036280423,
0.0153428735,
-0.0223979503,
-0.02976368,
0.0493718237,
-0.0770412311,
0.0048884484,
-0.0248820391,
-0.030712584,
0.034622997,
0.0467308052,
-0.0619678535,
-0.0149268275,
0.0417847261,
0.0826532394,
0.0172269084,
-0.0671335906,
-0.0390638635,
-0.0231296793,
0.0056690779,
-0.0278805885,
-0.0031329317,
-0.0155698638,
-0.0008704079,
-0.0200427175,
-0.0112857763,
0.04500122,
1.859048448e-34,
-0.0028029031,
0.0160628185,
0.0188624188,
-0.0334847383,
0.0085855918,
-0.0317314118,
-0.0071916729,
0.0029328763,
-0.0289426465,
-0.029087035,
-0.0206532273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00453v1 | PerSEval: Assessing Personalization in Text Summarizers | 2024-06-29T14:37:36 | 2024-06-29T14:37:36 | Sourish Dasgupta, Ankush Chander, Parth Borad, Isha Motiyani, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Personalized summarization models cater to individuals' subjective
understanding of saliency, as represented by their reading history and current
topics of attention. Existing personalized text summarizers are primarily
evaluated based on accuracy measures such as BLEU, ROUGE, and METEOR. However,
a recent study argued that accuracy measures are inadequate for evaluating the
degree of personalization of these models and proposed EGISES, the first metric
to evaluate personalized text summaries. It was suggested that accuracy is a
separate aspect and should be evaluated standalone. In this paper, we challenge
the necessity of an accuracy leaderboard, suggesting that relying on
accuracy-based aggregated results might lead to misleading conclusions. To
support this, we delve deeper into EGISES, demonstrating both theoretically and
empirically that it measures the degree of responsiveness, a necessary but not
sufficient condition for degree-of-personalization. We subsequently propose
PerSEval, a novel measure that satisfies the required sufficiency condition.
Based on the benchmarking of ten SOTA summarization models on the PENS dataset,
we empirically establish that -- (i) PerSEval is reliable w.r.t human-judgment
correlation (Pearson's r = 0.73; Spearman's $\rho$ = 0.62; Kendall's $\tau$ =
0.42), (ii) PerSEval has high rank-stability, (iii) PerSEval as a rank-measure
is not entailed by EGISES-based ranking, and (iv) PerSEval can be a standalone
rank-measure without the need of any aggregated ranking. | PerSEval: Assessing Personalization in Text Summarizers: Personalized summarization models cater to individuals' subjective
understanding of saliency, as represented by their reading history and current
topics of attention. Existing personalized text summarizers are primarily
evaluated based on accuracy measures such as BLEU, ROUGE, and METEOR. However,
a recent study argued that accuracy measures are inadequate for evaluating the
degree of personalization of these models and proposed EGISES, the first metric
to evaluate personalized text summaries. It was suggested that accuracy is a
separate aspect and should be evaluated standalone. In this paper, we challenge
the necessity of an accuracy leaderboard, suggesting that relying on
accuracy-based aggregated results might lead to misleading conclusions. To
support this, we delve deeper into EGISES, demonstrating both theoretically and
empirically that it measures the degree of responsiveness, a necessary but not
sufficient condition for degree-of-personalization. We subsequently propose
PerSEval, a novel measure that satisfies the required sufficiency condition.
Based on the benchmarking of ten SOTA summarization models on the PENS dataset,
we empirically establish that -- (i) PerSEval is reliable w.r.t human-judgment
correlation (Pearson's r = 0.73; Spearman's $\rho$ = 0.62; Kendall's $\tau$ =
0.42), (ii) PerSEval has high rank-stability, (iii) PerSEval as a rank-measure
is not entailed by EGISES-based ranking, and (iv) PerSEval can be a standalone
rank-measure without the need of any aggregated ranking. | [
0.0472240075,
-0.0261705145,
0.0055083707,
-0.0219431669,
-0.0072829826,
0.0124781085,
0.0087939445,
-0.0186303612,
0.0077364934,
-0.0421995074,
-0.049515713,
0.0078706872,
0.022462735,
0.0011767717,
-0.026476603,
-0.1062590033,
0.0222728718,
0.0229911301,
0.0131573081,
0.0247883871,
0.0541879348,
-0.0225726999,
0.0202639587,
0.02695195,
0.0544300564,
-0.0192277059,
0.0146107664,
0.000716219,
0.0783996284,
-0.0141915232,
0.0017075783,
0.0412426367,
-0.0020256466,
-0.0107921949,
0.0000020185,
-0.0526785254,
-0.0242627785,
-0.0275985133,
0.033427868,
0.0428787954,
0.0747440085,
-0.0088409847,
0.0183209125,
-0.0307764634,
-0.0127913104,
0.0619489141,
-0.0191525239,
0.0226164851,
0.0681235567,
0.0161894746,
-0.0021613669,
-0.0157727692,
0.0059417174,
-0.0153774135,
-0.0102343615,
-0.0130749643,
-0.0095283249,
-0.0053064455,
-0.0271216016,
0.0233569015,
-0.0379926749,
0.0205180589,
0.0006024653,
0.0270043276,
0.0579952598,
0.0218127556,
-0.0172017831,
0.0116741471,
0.0005068331,
0.0598155595,
0.03744803,
-0.0008719562,
-0.0000442826,
0.0264611021,
0.014082117,
0.011041671,
-0.0679170489,
-0.0180502962,
-0.007236016,
0.0112640699,
0.0062579024,
0.0867586583,
-0.035160616,
0.0101839034,
-0.002807908,
0.046319183,
-0.0000364433,
-0.0258314162,
-0.0112023344,
0.0034439804,
-0.0384214707,
-0.0328015164,
0.0558450073,
0.0146070709,
0.010895825,
-0.0400016457,
-0.0248123705,
-0.0501313061,
0.024036346,
-0.0562840812,
0.0033245927,
-0.0066852844,
0.0040968126,
0.0435999334,
0.01796907,
0.046220731,
0.0550919585,
0.0352514163,
-0.0546327308,
0.0360931605,
-0.0062648216,
0.03456489,
0.0336511619,
0.0274901334,
-0.0192961339,
-0.0399771519,
-0.0675249323,
0.0150305154,
0.0040135458,
-0.0009586591,
-0.0068890089,
0.0328940637,
-0.0045316122,
0.001448188,
-0.0209658761,
-0.0132217472,
-0.0712604299,
-0.0372893848,
0.0158639438,
0.0458276607,
0.0387340784,
-0.0044187424,
0.0313745253,
0.0120256934,
0.0056414604,
0.0080580628,
-0.0261960309,
-0.071816586,
-0.0161089711,
-0.0210461635,
-0.015904462,
-0.0284152832,
-0.0483607762,
-0.0482502878,
-0.026649816,
0.0244574267,
0.0001290966,
0.0012474485,
-0.0205559395,
0.0047580744,
-0.0290749017,
-0.0107277585,
0.0003503801,
0.0022461549,
0.0171476975,
0.0206224024,
-0.0057557584,
0.0128136603,
0.0155442515,
0.0840808153,
0.0645561442,
0.0007092064,
-0.0185559653,
-0.0005548068,
-0.0491354279,
0.0231230427,
-0.0132888826,
-0.0316373184,
-0.1010670587,
-0.0471502841,
0.0225691665,
0.0359743126,
-0.0344776772,
-0.0063824086,
0.0838550553,
0.082585007,
0.0394569337,
0.0620710291,
-0.0087347366,
0.0358857848,
0.045242019,
0.0832989067,
0.0291896816,
0.0258587431,
-0.048505526,
0.04544276,
0.0858119503,
0.0051873764,
-0.0017491466,
-0.0873515606,
0.0132191265,
0.02688675,
0.0141099477,
-0.0005261807,
0.0482708514,
-0.0200229734,
-0.0014759678,
-0.0129962163,
-0.0034976078,
-0.0633458272,
0.0343094692,
-0.0028520832,
0.0410691164,
0.1112029031,
0.0569167137,
-0.0325965509,
0.016666729,
0.0018423442,
-0.0368250199,
-0.0122327218,
0.0019413307,
0.005899284,
-0.0065344735,
-0.0582038984,
-0.0268664919,
-0.027718965,
0.0116994111,
0.0164621361,
-0.0286436733,
0.0168076623,
0.0289250836,
-0.0059930678,
-0.0447673723,
0.0157142449,
0.0273364503,
0.0076816813,
-0.0351796597,
-0.0195659362,
0.0117975967,
0.0604567751,
0.0015366338,
0.0151183074,
0.0401285999,
-0.0302865859,
0.0385685712,
0.0060925009,
0.011761969,
0.0196199659,
0.0097467462,
-0.0416841209,
0.0498086363,
0.0369630046,
0.0208686683,
-0.0358237512,
0.03395392,
-0.0404456742,
-0.0143666081,
-0.0134919686,
0.028319208,
-0.0067802412,
0.0344073884,
-0.0474978015,
0.0574688241,
-0.0274458434,
0.037721131,
0.0379308388,
-0.0191438086,
0.0042739846,
-0.0496026725,
-0.0416127108,
-0.0326664001,
0.0403262526,
0.0104132798,
0.0533813089,
-0.0105293291,
-0.0611583665,
-0.0070148101,
-0.1218643636,
-0.0082171587,
-0.0230666753,
0.0252539702,
0.0487421528,
0.0022194278,
-0.0118541364,
-0.0146627463,
-0.0275309142,
-0.0559070632,
-0.018134933,
0.0152984885,
0.0354062244,
0.0037716641,
0.0444002412,
-0.0904143006,
-0.0385951139,
0.008550548,
0.0438210778,
0.0245227218,
0.0041899849,
-0.0467439033,
-0.0060192333,
-0.0325565971,
-0.0414051898,
0.0150426999,
-0.0071705123,
-0.0063361796,
-0.0014379137,
0.0360183343,
0.0972331464,
0.0723818094,
0.0121551575,
0.0326705575,
-0.0112563977,
-0.0346969478,
-0.0211470705,
-0.0452911481,
0.0551385246,
0.0431088023,
-0.0447050482,
0.0554072969,
0.0218697004,
-0.0025203764,
-0.0007726738,
-0.0441091061,
0.0290877298,
-0.006468825,
-0.0091756256,
-0.0507063791,
0.0235977303,
-0.007106639,
0.043630559,
-0.0223826338,
-0.0009098697,
0.0425287038,
-0.0059086187,
0.0389246494,
-0.0482949317,
-0.0086568482,
-0.0366740413,
0.0079932995,
0.0281684715,
0.0133418487,
-0.0770970285,
-0.0066382554,
-0.0018948982,
-0.0179051198,
0.0582325533,
-0.0388046764,
0.0535278469,
-0.0035693038,
-0.0223792102,
0.0058215838,
0.0106481342,
-0.0100409575,
-0.0293360762,
-0.0329766795,
-0.0213798676,
0.0443921573,
-0.00759295,
-0.0606183782,
0.0364322402,
0.055932004,
0.0496573448,
-0.0320363939,
-0.0300060026,
0.0131413685,
0.0415002443,
0.0469184779,
-0.0172939077,
0.0307049565,
-0.0370137095,
0.0104472935,
0.0641502738,
0.0257156603,
-0.0453099236,
0.0189699084,
-0.0004150804,
0.0277693104,
-0.0741941184,
0.0062741614,
-0.0232865699,
0.0390204564,
-0.0506498441,
0.0044896426,
0.0873581469,
0.0255488008,
-0.05769201,
-0.0318167806,
0.0083826976,
0.001978128,
0.0014746279,
0.0042484389,
-0.0032880607,
-0.0073692361,
-0.0308708809,
0.0459248945,
0.0086300327,
-0.0201653372,
-0.0242347121,
-0.0226378348,
0.0139486138,
0.0039939089,
-0.0589573607,
-0.0087600946,
-0.016214015,
0.0359694958,
-0.0196599979,
-0.0387447812,
0.0276025608,
-0.0191022139,
0.0245878398,
0.0174892917,
-0.072754249,
0.0081423316,
-0.0375025794,
-0.0270967893,
-0.0486751273,
0.0481289439,
0.0241090078,
-0.0018655643,
-0.0622434542,
-0.0267866496,
-0.0055781221,
0.0069496767,
0.0192700755,
0.0759800598,
-0.030819593,
0.0409737043,
-0.086755842,
0.0239260551,
0.0549602993,
-0.0168734286,
0.0320180207,
-0.0386046693,
0.0155463871,
-0.0000023935,
-0.057701163,
0.0255364291,
-0.0646101087,
0.0150405662,
0.0227850303,
-0.05263317,
-0.018778855,
-0.0546771809,
0.0137305511,
-0.067260921,
-0.0432834812,
-0.0018281033,
-0.026992958,
-0.0511493981,
-0.09226197,
-0.0409069583,
-0.0333746374,
-0.0197996758,
0.0165316593,
-0.0042924224,
-0.0405737869,
0.0221415423,
-0.0203687735,
0.0099052424,
0.0254528094,
-0.0146407569,
-0.0565329231,
0.0050767343,
0.0484641083,
-0.0505495518,
-0.0123163769,
-0.0195783861,
-0.0440479554,
-0.0194986183,
-0.0065171216,
0.0389144197,
0.0176312104,
0.0179832168,
-0.0081805754,
-0.0488129556,
0.0476970077,
0.0037064231,
0.0067895637,
0.0223428737,
-0.0121003604,
0.0145366099,
-0.0296882186,
-0.0127874371,
-0.0271229241,
0.0308665894,
-0.0299811121,
0.0130304955,
-0.0120364539,
-0.045473218,
-0.0214204136,
0.0076233251,
0.0448483117,
-0.0155774318,
-0.01312437,
-0.0215841252,
-0.0421258137,
-0.0115772365,
-0.0062316856,
-0.017622821,
-0.008790819,
-0.0185023826,
0.0192414932,
-0.0448471569,
0.0700705275,
-0.0122231906,
-0.006221896,
-0.0883270279,
0.0065949429,
-0.0308298394,
-0.0309590194,
-0.0662396699,
-0.0057297004,
-0.0579724573,
-0.0561174974,
-0.0047647031,
0.0378489867,
0.017436184,
0.0253032278,
0.0106635494,
-0.0219636038,
0.0118696503,
0.0837968737,
-0.0977055505,
0.0541362129,
-0.0402116328,
0.0386937,
0.0428951494,
-0.0132390046,
0.0651732385,
0.0313206315,
-0.0136712128,
-0.0272516776,
0.020792624,
0.0411789231,
0.0038923766,
-0.083630234,
0.0145007176,
0.0364886224,
0.0270241126,
0.0742589235,
-0.0453747958,
-0.0606415197,
0.0010457536,
-0.0781782046,
-0.0443109088,
0.0158935953,
-0.0404553711,
0.0716414601,
0.011357422,
-0.0526537821,
-0.0893216953,
0.002578526,
0.079220295,
0.0266643781,
0.0179260336,
-0.0133278947,
0.0289333295,
0.0261041131,
-0.046674747,
0.0040000924,
-0.061604578,
-0.0149986222,
-0.0415812135,
0.027779188,
-0.0022607702,
-6.056100243e-33,
-0.0082731619,
-0.0194756184,
-0.0779516399,
0.0602526404,
-0.0376902744,
-0.0074129882,
-0.0191791989,
0.0106314234,
0.0547577217,
0.0011670665,
-0.0182329472,
-0.0219949242,
0.0110746613,
0.0042101312,
0.0112794768,
0.0049657626,
0.0185366664,
0.0260527227,
-0.0621724576,
0.0258175135,
0.0432331339,
0.008793341,
0.0411716588,
-0.0492537208,
0.0347692072,
-0.0341184065,
-0.0147600221,
-0.0708664283,
0.0452214517,
0.0575196743,
0.0261157826,
0.031606894,
0.026102053,
-0.0258293673,
-0.0162288249,
0.0344347954,
-0.0367998518,
-0.0458274111,
0.0389940105,
-0.0176648013,
-0.058628276,
-0.0401986912,
0.0228636079,
0.0088877631,
-0.0334394723,
-0.0195221733,
0.0780433491,
-0.0601054244,
-0.0212555397,
-0.060457468,
0.0169529021,
0.0416888744,
-0.0310374741,
0.0076215509,
0.0309588332,
0.0629529133,
0.0000926495,
0.045598194,
-0.047498893,
0.0558974929,
0.0312752202,
-0.0017485643,
0.0492509641,
0.041827634,
0.0039715655,
0.0544588454,
0.0335929245,
-0.0022564784,
0.0098607363,
-0.0129648531,
0.0287337564,
-0.0067147091,
0.0435018316,
0.0549573898,
0.0362185724,
0.045674555,
-0.0286347754,
0.0938415527,
0.0046791239,
-0.0121865431,
0.0639459044,
-0.0000459263,
-0.0549104176,
-0.0050680242,
-0.0131451907,
-0.0153662702,
-0.0323798694,
-0.022701418,
-0.0184194949,
0.0072394488,
-0.051174812,
-0.0134619363,
-0.0125232125,
-0.0120483218,
0.0252942778,
0.0001426096,
-0.0343517065,
0.0279430747,
0.0055454625,
-0.0524194092,
-0.0115350597,
0.0372790471,
0.0010024351,
-0.0078844279,
-0.0201221518,
-0.0343549475,
0.0441743582,
-0.025294682,
-0.0060762838,
-0.0213971585,
0.0340670235,
0.0075633526,
-0.0269170348,
-0.0076256357,
0.0161134452,
-0.0125325033,
-0.0476589315,
0.0807539374,
-0.0021753197,
0.0529481843,
-0.0325411819,
-0.0165861268,
0.0419743732,
0.0033164814,
0.0028577272,
0.0019628752,
-0.0007137774,
0.0180401374,
-0.0240369588,
-0.0147280414,
-0.0144661423,
0.0161850806,
2.681e-7,
0.017738726,
0.0271153413,
0.0264821388,
-0.0710446388,
0.0222846754,
0.0333345979,
0.0010565239,
0.0430822782,
0.0565943383,
0.0203800984,
0.0291430429,
0.025007477,
0.0350303128,
0.0105789369,
-0.0616588965,
-0.0593191907,
-0.0372784808,
-0.023088187,
-0.0175590068,
0.0117461924,
0.0407075547,
0.0026644918,
0.0306705777,
0.0284555349,
0.0244478062,
0.0007991897,
0.0319967791,
-0.0487372056,
-0.0280279052,
0.0033291732,
0.0746884122,
0.0069116498,
-0.0397712588,
0.0082746437,
-0.0039991844,
-0.0018793105,
0.093538247,
0.044676125,
0.0007509325,
-0.027160449,
0.0132435979,
0.0239571184,
0.0390153527,
-0.0266986191,
0.0364666991,
0.0073965332,
-0.0073607336,
0.0152510963,
-0.0431130677,
0.015856877,
0.0120349415,
-0.0095174452,
-0.0681733117,
0.0227308962,
-0.0088586966,
0.0100352922,
0.0025931075,
-0.0415647402,
-0.0311193205,
0.0166432969,
0.0047117681,
-0.0763894543,
-0.0333156511,
-0.0103441831,
-0.0132958191,
-0.0660982206,
-0.0124681769,
2.100306037e-34,
0.0660674497,
0.0132162878,
-0.0205273014,
-0.0537401885,
-0.0037076417,
-0.0218621176,
0.000053168,
-0.032830365,
0.0497879758,
-0.0610946901,
-0.0145196188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00436v1 | A Recipe of Parallel Corpora Exploitation for Multilingual Large Language Models | 2024-06-29T13:12:39 | 2024-06-29T13:12:39 | Peiqin Lin, André F. T. Martins, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have highlighted the potential of exploiting parallel corpora
to enhance multilingual large language models, improving performance in both
bilingual tasks, e.g., machine translation, and general-purpose tasks, e.g.,
text classification. Building upon these findings, our comprehensive study aims
to identify the most effective strategies for leveraging parallel corpora. We
investigate the impact of parallel corpora quality and quantity, training
objectives, and model size on the performance of multilingual large language
models enhanced with parallel corpora across diverse languages and tasks. Our
analysis reveals several key insights: (i) filtering noisy translations is
essential for effectively exploiting parallel corpora, while language
identification and short sentence filtering have little effect; (ii) even a
corpus containing just 10K parallel sentences can yield results comparable to
those obtained from much larger datasets; (iii) employing only the machine
translation objective yields the best results among various training objectives
and their combinations; (iv) larger multilingual language models benefit more
from parallel corpora than smaller models due to their stronger capacity for
cross-task transfer. Our study offers valuable insights into the optimal
utilization of parallel corpora to enhance multilingual large language models,
extending the generalizability of previous findings from limited languages and
tasks to a broader range of scenarios. | A Recipe of Parallel Corpora Exploitation for Multilingual Large Language Models: Recent studies have highlighted the potential of exploiting parallel corpora
to enhance multilingual large language models, improving performance in both
bilingual tasks, e.g., machine translation, and general-purpose tasks, e.g.,
text classification. Building upon these findings, our comprehensive study aims
to identify the most effective strategies for leveraging parallel corpora. We
investigate the impact of parallel corpora quality and quantity, training
objectives, and model size on the performance of multilingual large language
models enhanced with parallel corpora across diverse languages and tasks. Our
analysis reveals several key insights: (i) filtering noisy translations is
essential for effectively exploiting parallel corpora, while language
identification and short sentence filtering have little effect; (ii) even a
corpus containing just 10K parallel sentences can yield results comparable to
those obtained from much larger datasets; (iii) employing only the machine
translation objective yields the best results among various training objectives
and their combinations; (iv) larger multilingual language models benefit more
from parallel corpora than smaller models due to their stronger capacity for
cross-task transfer. Our study offers valuable insights into the optimal
utilization of parallel corpora to enhance multilingual large language models,
extending the generalizability of previous findings from limited languages and
tasks to a broader range of scenarios. | [
0.0291287806,
0.0573249944,
-0.0167426951,
0.0716382861,
-0.0436080247,
0.0471475758,
0.0780064166,
-0.0067178789,
-0.0214158371,
-0.0390321873,
-0.0613503717,
-0.0641246885,
0.0076966798,
-0.0692928135,
0.0151125817,
-0.0457086265,
0.0317943953,
-0.0276448634,
-0.0142082395,
-0.0167987663,
-0.0001215104,
0.0427918024,
0.0221571252,
0.0037840051,
0.0237660725,
-0.0197930001,
0.0528336056,
0.0108477119,
0.0192801207,
0.0181623697,
0.0046211272,
0.0215334147,
0.0194829255,
0.078645803,
0.0000016918,
-0.0483652093,
-0.0364765674,
0.0138588399,
0.0244374964,
0.0148600871,
0.0672862679,
-0.0598428771,
0.0030622191,
0.0227977652,
0.0087458463,
-0.0379498117,
0.0622337721,
0.0201286897,
0.0036295473,
0.0611654557,
-0.0308938008,
-0.0469745696,
0.0021954512,
-0.0666923225,
-0.0584058501,
-0.0386873819,
0.0125300642,
0.0033812567,
-0.0097682076,
0.0427759252,
0.0101412171,
0.0508295447,
0.0196787417,
0.0182582438,
-0.0342892595,
-0.0088499086,
0.0042608865,
-0.0338985287,
0.0065770503,
0.0363706686,
-0.0677817166,
-0.0324825048,
-0.0090829926,
-0.0074028722,
-0.0091660423,
0.0164871067,
-0.0172389187,
0.052195102,
-0.0179680716,
0.0347228162,
0.0585289486,
-0.0055766222,
0.0584943444,
0.0177711155,
-0.053964708,
-0.0055152751,
0.036020387,
-0.0261661597,
0.0669951141,
0.0460128933,
-0.01569256,
-0.0154945282,
0.0244881585,
-0.0282593388,
-0.0336974077,
0.0101411007,
-0.0157056991,
-0.0821726546,
0.0217112582,
-0.1024380177,
0.022450434,
0.0395210423,
-0.0172909331,
0.0506000333,
-0.0120322816,
0.0275636595,
-0.0478782617,
0.0108601646,
-0.068042919,
-0.0697001144,
-0.0240069628,
0.0343698561,
-0.0222060438,
0.0152354408,
-0.054648079,
-0.0201327167,
-0.013477115,
0.0274886787,
-0.0030537976,
-0.0230823532,
0.0244340096,
-0.0490426384,
-0.0280624665,
0.0035813963,
0.0470584072,
0.0570652634,
-0.0239772927,
0.0195868481,
-0.0453543775,
-0.0410957448,
-0.0106529389,
0.0339439921,
-0.0175466873,
-0.0972473249,
0.0251304209,
0.0528993793,
-0.0330568142,
-0.0289575644,
-0.0105390307,
0.0157531891,
-0.0225654189,
-0.0784765407,
0.0071867136,
-0.0524652116,
0.0562523007,
0.0157090481,
0.045084808,
0.0002157881,
0.0019909702,
0.0037965747,
-0.0320641771,
0.0664661154,
-0.0025298505,
-0.0253544915,
0.0256415438,
-0.0159271322,
0.0311498363,
0.1030210629,
0.0117879398,
-0.0033489498,
0.0545402765,
-0.0380749814,
-0.0640442967,
0.0708824843,
-0.0154972542,
0.0501919463,
-0.0310789458,
0.011414811,
0.0417133979,
0.0205264464,
-0.002613679,
0.0416907519,
-0.0137951476,
-0.0034007321,
0.0432175435,
0.0187978279,
0.0055457423,
0.0236288812,
0.0423351154,
-0.0078347595,
-0.0091921231,
0.0192856956,
0.002878163,
-0.0082138097,
0.0396017395,
-0.0117141949,
0.0165493637,
0.0578339212,
-0.0365136564,
-0.0120729003,
-0.0263254661,
-0.0197128635,
0.0173618384,
0.0231656339,
0.0636154637,
-0.0027980087,
-0.0007909639,
0.0402596518,
0.0553940348,
-0.0408556722,
0.0148284985,
-0.0223263986,
-0.0247363374,
0.045384381,
-0.012454099,
-0.0097912308,
-0.0232233386,
-0.0216222312,
0.0279106144,
0.0356038138,
0.0690032616,
-0.0099454094,
0.060289599,
-0.0466708094,
-0.0062988773,
0.0100624608,
0.0014723872,
0.0389807224,
0.0117639732,
0.0313440189,
0.0085537368,
-0.0031030718,
-0.0527671874,
0.0170056559,
-0.0403473191,
-0.0222044736,
0.0633806139,
0.0261368752,
0.0374910198,
0.0057484768,
-0.0110853054,
-0.0334942043,
0.0245514028,
-0.0579968952,
-0.0067219464,
0.0363872275,
-0.0096115479,
-0.0415384322,
0.0241046418,
0.0028405283,
-0.0075469399,
0.0578684583,
-0.031067485,
-0.0209872741,
-0.0231038462,
-0.0128540248,
0.0161444731,
-0.030151533,
0.0014349096,
-0.0329313129,
0.0276321378,
-0.024420144,
0.0301503148,
0.0117437458,
0.0250315331,
0.0045982325,
-0.0104694674,
0.0420037135,
-0.0471152328,
-0.0397594422,
0.0419043526,
0.0131640313,
0.0293871555,
0.0509666912,
-0.0001024662,
0.0109147001,
-0.0147368778,
-0.0768137872,
0.0355021879,
-0.0425360538,
0.0280847065,
0.0330887288,
0.0229790956,
0.0028554557,
-0.0112597095,
-0.0019776367,
0.0152221099,
0.0035387252,
0.0332450643,
-0.0046023824,
-0.0033057032,
-0.0026779289,
-0.0053972299,
-0.0365259759,
0.0338736549,
0.0611576065,
0.0068618855,
-0.055479724,
-0.033622656,
0.0290908646,
-0.0003330279,
0.0120906252,
0.0018438586,
-0.0435012765,
-0.0068754265,
-0.0072361324,
0.0226490945,
0.037886288,
-0.023191778,
-0.0037978499,
0.0299620368,
0.0092653949,
-0.0108870175,
0.0206783973,
-0.0030598457,
0.0007950053,
-0.0650572106,
-0.0256730262,
-0.0000438493,
0.0544099659,
-0.014322699,
-0.0398959666,
-0.0276446156,
-0.0342195258,
-0.0215227883,
-0.016592944,
-0.0115377717,
0.014122732,
0.0044193123,
-0.018280521,
-0.0313422456,
-0.0514497347,
0.0324901491,
-0.0249994006,
0.0032437686,
-0.0964470208,
-0.026749678,
-0.0394527949,
0.0553792752,
-0.0158432908,
0.0280152354,
-0.0505289063,
-0.0107389307,
-0.0227489695,
0.0256817769,
-0.0110071478,
0.0093977936,
0.0388958454,
-0.0367125496,
0.0092196735,
-0.0233742055,
-0.0534666888,
-0.0172593445,
-0.0581284836,
-0.0115562165,
0.0300867967,
0.0581402928,
-0.0120204799,
-0.0611920357,
-0.0084632831,
0.0263611469,
0.0438564941,
-0.0047800224,
0.0362102054,
-0.002223616,
0.0447009318,
0.021170307,
-0.0089078303,
0.0183861852,
-0.0576980822,
-0.0083870143,
0.0194601528,
0.0399375036,
-0.0253994018,
-0.0169376787,
-0.0495853275,
0.0497242063,
-0.0248879101,
-0.05443836,
-0.0301228371,
0.0261948798,
-0.0385308675,
-0.0053253882,
0.0976640061,
0.0032954016,
-0.061195232,
-0.0249911807,
0.017143866,
0.008690129,
0.0090565952,
0.0159913152,
-0.074787043,
-0.0291817151,
0.0018347126,
-0.0205278527,
0.0262711979,
0.0230430141,
-0.0328250937,
-0.0900381207,
-0.0167932827,
0.0237448346,
-0.064409405,
-0.0119633209,
-0.034208715,
-0.015321359,
-0.0453909561,
0.0232759919,
-0.0616295189,
0.0072987713,
-0.0208709855,
0.0455022901,
0.0272106174,
-0.0660134107,
0.0143271824,
-0.038302809,
-0.0025455274,
0.0183235724,
0.0260875896,
-0.0319378041,
-0.0229404625,
0.0281258002,
-0.0470297746,
-0.0321162976,
-0.0311780069,
0.0235840678,
-0.0107448669,
-0.0197138321,
0.0135826087,
-0.0145761892,
-0.0238782447,
0.0210513789,
0.0177967716,
0.0704293773,
0.0085602487,
-0.0012806532,
0.037693765,
-0.0548178777,
0.0527645648,
0.0601930246,
-0.0169681422,
-0.0620490797,
-0.0004326592,
0.0214340389,
-0.0435693003,
-0.0778920949,
0.0218213517,
0.0017136872,
-0.0453040823,
-0.0424402542,
-0.0354437605,
-0.0665852129,
-0.0043205461,
0.0211328696,
0.0387655497,
0.0476220511,
0.0001479088,
-0.0216639489,
-0.0252676327,
0.0202089027,
-0.0336498618,
0.0300135147,
-0.0475698113,
0.0148617476,
0.0088657783,
-0.0345547833,
-0.0120074572,
0.0254490711,
-0.1331172734,
-0.0619932935,
-0.0242125839,
0.0320567116,
0.0071785627,
0.0413649306,
-0.0208808556,
-0.0719758272,
0.0008471294,
0.0009853895,
-0.047418341,
-0.0103606442,
0.0418141522,
-0.0218721218,
-0.0112830028,
0.0616350807,
-0.0088382121,
0.0096008601,
0.0438669845,
-0.0067182803,
-0.0293968562,
-0.0430124141,
-0.0221024007,
0.0180939548,
0.020205453,
-0.0315321311,
-0.0127830757,
-0.0503355749,
0.0441458449,
-0.0021908861,
-0.0132574681,
-0.0241081901,
-0.0210308935,
0.065310061,
-0.0084438249,
-0.018183548,
0.0373727493,
0.0260715671,
-0.0204191618,
-0.0319613591,
0.0031947363,
-0.0242751911,
0.004694521,
0.0198910888,
0.0520785823,
-0.003644709,
0.0094530499,
0.0436858572,
0.014410967,
-0.0392628051,
0.0196039714,
-0.0030279015,
-0.0003768198,
-0.0033751198,
0.0099692941,
-0.022403216,
-0.0176841319,
0.0184714217,
0.0083849514,
0.0755135641,
-0.0457521081,
0.1001866236,
-0.0018438394,
-0.0286626033,
-0.0596055239,
0.0151886437,
0.0107489191,
0.005719366,
-0.0086882515,
-0.0103689926,
-0.0366637819,
0.0221297015,
0.0985433087,
-0.0062441556,
-0.0087084584,
0.0258769598,
-0.0187373459,
-0.0219203904,
-0.0207515918,
0.001128042,
0.011566407,
-0.0435828902,
-0.0087078195,
-0.027235711,
-0.0475240089,
0.0123465052,
-0.0370806456,
-0.0122462409,
0.0035006751,
-0.0031976791,
0.0883694291,
-0.0136888493,
0.0051973467,
-0.0530477986,
0.0062173954,
0.0029186411,
0.0100773526,
0.0015052918,
-5.428915967e-33,
0.0157251041,
0.0225986447,
0.0009441763,
-0.0582545474,
0.0063347574,
0.0065366039,
-0.0034282189,
-0.0314683318,
-0.0077197007,
0.0248198714,
0.0132980971,
-0.0046385694,
0.026039822,
0.0229686145,
0.0375045501,
0.0297036618,
0.0670622736,
0.0194133893,
-0.0105505409,
0.0161631051,
0.0734262019,
0.0376665853,
0.08401566,
-0.0338570103,
0.041640196,
-0.0309984609,
0.0178617351,
0.0071638082,
-0.0049903537,
0.0623664893,
-0.005434142,
0.0506031327,
0.0319600627,
-0.0515296757,
-0.0009072309,
0.0301714707,
-0.0757630616,
0.0068301102,
0.0530956946,
0.0502423719,
-0.0106820408,
-0.0524849482,
-0.0027295402,
-0.0059420727,
0.0069800951,
-0.0499411151,
0.0115302205,
-0.0118418299,
-0.0001682782,
0.0106625054,
-0.0769003704,
0.0294062383,
-0.0076039322,
0.0076369504,
0.0621780269,
0.0380357914,
-0.0006809954,
0.0275791809,
-0.0730963349,
-0.0084298402,
-0.054636687,
0.0286430065,
0.0262153745,
0.0270624533,
-0.0055206954,
0.0208787322,
0.0430524722,
0.017317934,
0.031721279,
-0.0005123722,
0.0056664008,
0.0107366815,
0.0619010031,
0.073950775,
0.0454637855,
-0.0300143808,
-0.1448000968,
-0.0075879446,
0.0077003795,
-0.0016347053,
0.0404706523,
-0.010447463,
-0.013102931,
-0.0198176298,
-0.0072507476,
-0.0189911872,
-0.0179956276,
0.0048805694,
0.0133368671,
0.0171004366,
-0.0034754323,
0.048917044,
0.0794853643,
-0.0239852648,
-0.0132812383,
0.0181630496,
-0.0321213007,
-0.0024328856,
0.004174592,
0.0416444279,
-0.0520617403,
-0.0519152433,
-0.0179691296,
-0.0040294072,
-0.0027477201,
-0.0107265776,
0.0865422934,
-0.0089918915,
-0.0595964715,
0.0099227168,
-0.0509843193,
0.0169965941,
0.0082642417,
0.0823068544,
0.0331308953,
0.0156132476,
0.0187073648,
0.0673433542,
0.0573705174,
-0.0181028601,
0.0085373791,
-0.0230299849,
-0.0081588812,
0.0012657088,
-0.0035320502,
0.0112808095,
-0.0057818303,
0.0111984303,
0.0210124925,
-0.0545444936,
-0.00375481,
-0.0216170643,
2.278e-7,
0.0458360016,
0.0276645012,
-0.0292273611,
-0.0136716096,
0.0212129932,
0.0134309689,
-0.0403395072,
0.0268078726,
-0.0068395482,
0.0562443994,
-0.0085418709,
0.0171363484,
0.104622066,
0.0299812667,
-0.0850519389,
-0.0305044875,
-0.0489824973,
0.0438536108,
-0.0425721034,
0.031740997,
-0.0018598343,
0.11513073,
0.0149134584,
-0.0162997916,
-0.0206713956,
-0.0614996329,
0.0804219693,
-0.0428619757,
-0.0423712321,
0.0328864232,
-0.0108004529,
0.0201747324,
-0.0232540071,
0.0290374942,
-0.0511636324,
0.0410505906,
0.0399045534,
0.0742504522,
0.0165458322,
0.0127304895,
0.0327809639,
-0.0203115568,
-0.0343890041,
-0.0505712889,
0.0810798183,
-0.0171830673,
-0.0085719461,
-0.0016681046,
0.0273657274,
0.0057483711,
0.0650184751,
-0.0164170954,
-0.0363144316,
0.0043596462,
0.0303861722,
-0.0240343418,
-0.030810792,
-0.0521313958,
-0.0224795677,
0.0085598174,
-0.047616072,
-0.0422929414,
0.0062652896,
-0.0130064115,
0.0258345045,
-0.0513627417,
0.0371733941,
1.923724745e-34,
0.0250496361,
0.0069281501,
0.0028338635,
-0.009193019,
0.007864478,
-0.0460402891,
-0.0625435188,
-0.0098874187,
-0.0229070708,
-0.0468121655,
0.0073984293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00434v1 | Brevity is the soul of wit: Pruning long files for code generation | 2024-06-29T13:08:24 | 2024-06-29T13:08:24 | Aaditya K. Singh, Yu Yang, Kushal Tirumala, Mostafa Elhoushi, Ari S. Morcos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data curation is commonly considered a "secret-sauce" for LLM training, with
higher quality data usually leading to better LLM performance. Given the scale
of internet-scraped corpora, data pruning has become a larger and larger focus.
Specifically, many have shown that de-duplicating data, or sub-selecting higher
quality data, can lead to efficiency or performance improvements. Generally,
three types of methods are used to filter internet-scale corpora:
embedding-based, heuristic-based, and classifier-based. In this work, we
contrast the former two in the domain of finetuning LLMs for code generation.
We find that embedding-based methods are often confounded by length, and that a
simple heuristic--pruning long files--outperforms other methods in
compute-limited regimes. Our method can yield up to a 2x efficiency benefit in
training (while matching performance) or a 3.5% absolute performance
improvement on HumanEval (while matching compute). However, we find that
perplexity on held-out long files can increase, begging the question of whether
optimizing data mixtures for common coding benchmarks (HumanEval, MBPP)
actually best serves downstream use cases. Overall, we hope our work builds
useful intuitions about code data (specifically, the low quality of extremely
long code files) provides a compelling heuristic-based method for data pruning,
and brings to light questions in how we evaluate code generation models. | Brevity is the soul of wit: Pruning long files for code generation: Data curation is commonly considered a "secret-sauce" for LLM training, with
higher quality data usually leading to better LLM performance. Given the scale
of internet-scraped corpora, data pruning has become a larger and larger focus.
Specifically, many have shown that de-duplicating data, or sub-selecting higher
quality data, can lead to efficiency or performance improvements. Generally,
three types of methods are used to filter internet-scale corpora:
embedding-based, heuristic-based, and classifier-based. In this work, we
contrast the former two in the domain of finetuning LLMs for code generation.
We find that embedding-based methods are often confounded by length, and that a
simple heuristic--pruning long files--outperforms other methods in
compute-limited regimes. Our method can yield up to a 2x efficiency benefit in
training (while matching performance) or a 3.5% absolute performance
improvement on HumanEval (while matching compute). However, we find that
perplexity on held-out long files can increase, begging the question of whether
optimizing data mixtures for common coding benchmarks (HumanEval, MBPP)
actually best serves downstream use cases. Overall, we hope our work builds
useful intuitions about code data (specifically, the low quality of extremely
long code files) provides a compelling heuristic-based method for data pruning,
and brings to light questions in how we evaluate code generation models. | [
0.0201365668,
0.0663823858,
-0.0208976567,
0.0417009369,
0.0025313373,
0.0095013492,
-0.0385764353,
0.0761931315,
-0.0117365001,
-0.0233874451,
-0.0002310735,
-0.0142254625,
0.0074543124,
-0.0185511969,
0.0657643899,
0.0133435838,
0.0222546235,
-0.0114276996,
-0.0378737897,
-0.009195609,
0.0068475436,
-0.0002598221,
0.0379457921,
0.0304378159,
0.0236655287,
0.0295445956,
-0.0075698509,
0.0404914729,
-0.0336888693,
-0.0299178064,
0.0101313218,
0.0313124135,
-0.0027229926,
0.0253697615,
0.0000020382,
-0.0460372083,
-0.0022281744,
0.0009142762,
0.0210883301,
0.029675439,
0.0311586037,
-0.0182965398,
-0.0128616076,
0.0283448547,
-0.0141953127,
0.0118917851,
0.041341044,
-0.0311860461,
0.0585894436,
0.0932465866,
0.0198392943,
-0.0201498754,
-0.0013816396,
-0.0051003946,
0.0447689034,
0.0174334086,
-0.0025256367,
-0.0049842317,
0.0201980695,
-0.0170515943,
-0.0170052014,
0.012051248,
0.0140903117,
0.0233460926,
0.0319868214,
0.0553499162,
-0.0440750197,
-0.0000066537,
0.011616732,
0.0542941317,
-0.0367666483,
-0.0348856263,
0.0516020656,
-0.005240852,
-0.0120688239,
-0.0562083013,
-0.0195278972,
0.0574034378,
-0.0207244139,
0.0458694138,
-0.0047009811,
-0.032988362,
0.035821259,
0.0034827557,
-0.0258352384,
0.0172963887,
0.0047396603,
-0.0232288353,
-0.0173616037,
-0.0041022934,
0.0338474251,
-0.0482314453,
-0.0190350339,
0.041414544,
0.0411745869,
-0.0022248414,
-0.0690498203,
-0.0207073316,
0.0388901904,
-0.0081371227,
0.0427831523,
0.0448632985,
0.0054297801,
-0.0152827138,
-0.059509363,
0.0200540256,
0.0087337429,
-0.0104015386,
-0.0088875899,
0.0291662309,
-0.0371618159,
0.0215055998,
-0.0221692603,
0.0767644942,
0.0007407353,
0.0411796495,
-0.0494729541,
0.0397277214,
0.0232980046,
0.0394795388,
-0.0084390491,
-0.0266161319,
-0.0254075453,
0.032030914,
0.0265511572,
-0.0406539179,
-0.0202922672,
-0.018391367,
-0.0093904063,
-0.0777556002,
-0.0125573771,
0.0359245092,
-0.0132811628,
-0.0282684546,
0.0513047464,
0.096114032,
0.0108349482,
-0.0010312797,
-0.0588431992,
-0.0397910997,
0.0113527235,
-0.0217861533,
0.0102509214,
-0.1010578945,
-0.0116099343,
-0.0059027034,
-0.0128072351,
-0.097149834,
0.0031741995,
0.0042649601,
-0.0456629507,
0.0464145839,
-0.084128283,
0.0159123298,
-0.0079058707,
0.0150478985,
-0.0267071556,
0.0635230467,
0.0649880618,
0.0092628086,
0.0223092269,
-0.0461280681,
0.0099896733,
0.0444942527,
0.0288122129,
0.0168275572,
-0.0121293124,
0.0064903218,
-0.0136745889,
0.0091869412,
0.0682553127,
0.0488887765,
-0.0388896838,
0.0129683288,
0.0107404683,
0.0649884865,
0.0502200834,
0.0595759563,
0.0684911162,
0.0335204937,
-0.0070795533,
0.0359853804,
-0.0184370019,
0.0323564038,
-0.0315684527,
0.0232608151,
0.048782777,
0.0557045564,
-0.00879867,
-0.055603575,
-0.0249504559,
-0.0130903516,
-0.0252506752,
-0.0269538704,
-0.0202452354,
-0.0095465705,
-0.0514080077,
0.0450157411,
0.0218412001,
-0.1102527454,
-0.0155778704,
-0.0358304307,
0.0025752767,
0.0606981181,
0.0373795368,
-0.0122272121,
-0.0159035139,
-0.0078094197,
0.0069195805,
-0.0304255318,
0.0174992979,
-0.0053079897,
0.034272857,
-0.0819890425,
-0.0200515427,
-0.0415436812,
-0.0205974448,
0.0115923602,
0.0251873229,
-0.0343868509,
0.0483516231,
-0.0368299894,
-0.0515143611,
0.0555010214,
-0.0337881818,
-0.0096539948,
0.0116734952,
0.0047511519,
0.0259073284,
-0.0474997573,
-0.0376121439,
0.0134340748,
0.0331182033,
-0.0265097003,
-0.000828991,
-0.04841258,
0.016617801,
-0.0338269025,
0.0493099988,
-0.0518165305,
-0.0019544414,
0.0128966533,
-0.0452123359,
-0.0089872228,
-0.0171994343,
-0.065466851,
0.0175919048,
-0.0209365766,
0.029835403,
-0.0200378653,
0.0118711023,
-0.032907933,
0.0331452526,
-0.0069175283,
0.0547463708,
0.0161764417,
0.0188071448,
0.0350097716,
-0.0187129565,
-0.016625125,
0.0230487958,
-0.0169104505,
0.0242629573,
-0.0054782182,
0.0659241304,
-0.0447981358,
-0.0607527606,
-0.081955336,
0.039444264,
-0.0077343853,
0.0341866277,
0.0041035926,
0.0016314486,
-0.0172305256,
-0.0022460038,
-0.0441335365,
-0.015371969,
-0.0164420009,
0.0210542418,
0.0543027744,
-0.0236127507,
-0.0685398504,
-0.0144855194,
-0.0051128641,
0.0003504101,
0.0284844991,
-0.027960632,
-0.0205859318,
-0.0717792436,
0.1140909344,
-0.0284935795,
-0.0188453626,
-0.0083288886,
-0.0577381626,
0.0009023554,
-0.032128457,
0.0555881523,
0.0279267728,
0.020642532,
-0.0083816312,
0.0607131273,
0.0166518558,
-0.0615852475,
-0.0090150991,
0.0373630598,
-0.017769143,
-0.0409270301,
-0.0623200424,
0.0483076982,
0.0426928662,
-0.01529592,
-0.0096880374,
-0.0292671714,
0.0301747117,
0.0281796828,
-0.0063529424,
0.0058259456,
0.000400668,
-0.0210438818,
0.0364803411,
0.0008359624,
-0.1139919981,
0.0466487333,
-0.0525466017,
0.0019424496,
0.0094216047,
-0.0337963216,
-0.0462409928,
0.0239454173,
-0.0188362375,
0.014905422,
-0.0350114852,
-0.0333372541,
-0.0422601923,
0.0213979986,
0.0059227147,
-0.049915161,
0.0522144139,
-0.0306506827,
0.01752894,
-0.0290429499,
-0.04259542,
-0.0400077663,
-0.0137963919,
0.008448449,
-0.0251989234,
0.0301702805,
-0.0085123889,
0.0474822931,
-0.0104787862,
0.0121211875,
0.0245527346,
0.033356037,
-0.0451242179,
-0.0017034226,
-0.0087092891,
-0.0358673297,
-0.0227350257,
0.0239970665,
-0.009899836,
-0.0239821076,
0.0296127629,
0.0471973233,
0.0336960591,
-0.0246053468,
0.0214100759,
0.0573231243,
-0.0283113401,
-0.0466574505,
0.0685305223,
0.075338304,
-0.0155180022,
-0.0188295152,
0.0894429535,
0.0231790822,
-0.0084111514,
0.0210807864,
0.0288797803,
0.0781071186,
0.0526902154,
0.0452054441,
-0.0651592612,
-0.0235169381,
0.013502148,
0.0665041059,
-0.0237997994,
-0.0317332037,
-0.0429926775,
-0.0982057154,
0.0400540344,
0.0405042917,
0.0077220206,
-0.0169443581,
-0.0336807407,
-0.0492260829,
0.0065411734,
-0.0542029403,
0.0337432809,
-0.0451144092,
0.0192294698,
0.0179273896,
-0.0596758351,
-0.0142595889,
-0.0255637337,
-0.0364100672,
0.0307624843,
0.0576269217,
0.031804841,
0.0172786769,
-0.0198968966,
0.0441543758,
-0.0254252069,
0.0134292496,
-0.0433228388,
0.0513901263,
0.0227881093,
0.0022654175,
0.034541443,
0.0244588517,
-0.0226055533,
-0.0010974769,
0.0153440787,
0.0376623161,
-0.0331310257,
-0.0205102731,
-0.0141355488,
-0.0037099048,
-0.0140655749,
0.0582038611,
0.063741304,
-0.0074071698,
-0.0244230255,
-0.0696891993,
-0.0354257338,
-0.0724158511,
-0.0014153105,
-0.0061618709,
-0.0410479382,
-0.0031185111,
-0.0655770451,
-0.0207006987,
0.0076239542,
0.053979896,
0.0032998282,
0.0070922859,
-0.039411746,
0.0099570286,
-0.0869131386,
-0.0077217547,
-0.0350457951,
0.0004593526,
-0.0513331704,
-0.024120627,
0.0109990332,
-0.0105798468,
0.0110345678,
0.0067536924,
-0.1327514946,
-0.0742809996,
-0.0551874675,
0.0560769364,
0.0206983313,
0.0417841263,
0.0045942506,
-0.0446537659,
0.0283527616,
0.0675502867,
-0.043361567,
0.0541052185,
0.0414738841,
-0.0125409951,
0.0425084345,
0.0278634578,
-0.060733594,
-0.0060283798,
0.0383914933,
0.0035872043,
-0.0134239672,
0.0227118973,
0.0231099147,
0.0779905096,
-0.0298590567,
-0.0383010656,
-0.0434215367,
0.0042808256,
0.0042209858,
0.026900921,
-0.0184121057,
-0.0541414618,
0.0126479343,
0.0036728568,
0.0107452497,
-0.0058437879,
0.0480548032,
-0.0166244935,
0.0350754447,
-0.0164286345,
0.0549475998,
-0.0082122562,
0.0075523681,
0.0735450163,
-0.0034093289,
0.0030528109,
0.0174566973,
0.0025531088,
0.0125812329,
-0.007504412,
0.0032250597,
0.0050667934,
0.0753327757,
-0.0118198376,
0.0336119384,
-0.0489098877,
-0.0526268445,
-0.0121183991,
0.0112106334,
0.0443155505,
0.031804435,
0.0453957431,
-0.011694856,
0.0216761474,
-0.0165305436,
0.0498083271,
-0.0403347574,
-0.0294426512,
0.0089603113,
0.0072275996,
-0.0558155067,
-0.0237597842,
0.1133148074,
-0.0122439936,
0.0344365425,
-0.0299169682,
0.0039244173,
-0.0476269349,
-0.0209161732,
0.0454786867,
0.0008511349,
0.0141691221,
-0.0448405221,
-0.0289447811,
-0.0628256053,
0.0283177942,
0.0049091722,
0.0256806482,
-0.0000637404,
0.0331457034,
0.0755805075,
-0.0075634141,
0.0381286368,
-0.0312121809,
-0.0075405617,
0.0048692473,
-0.0655286908,
0.0039486112,
-5.939100719e-33,
-0.0092152031,
-0.0375173204,
0.0170053802,
0.0175595023,
-0.0296373125,
-0.0097734425,
-0.0262297522,
-0.0163366459,
0.0118443286,
-0.0647317246,
0.0062776669,
0.0045276829,
-0.0107097123,
-0.0237380434,
0.0302766915,
0.0282896031,
0.0376414731,
0.0165118519,
-0.068497315,
-0.0001616405,
-0.0218448061,
0.0465271138,
-0.0106791193,
-0.0015265603,
-0.0558622032,
0.0029146853,
0.0090165539,
-0.0093844449,
0.0324847847,
0.033164639,
0.0060538836,
0.0137201585,
0.0042044208,
0.0012866019,
-0.0388973951,
-0.0247341897,
-0.020899903,
-0.031278342,
0.0058189095,
-0.0126071321,
0.0120869344,
-0.0990980119,
0.0953572839,
-0.015243059,
-0.0441604666,
-0.0261768401,
0.0138460267,
-0.0150267044,
-0.0430006608,
-0.0611111671,
-0.0337605886,
0.0441944003,
-0.0345674865,
0.0107022002,
0.0257848483,
-0.008192623,
0.0121615864,
0.0584515817,
-0.0183447301,
0.0210370161,
0.0163271613,
0.0700840056,
0.0601586476,
-0.0315010883,
0.0261358134,
0.0547057427,
0.0342488214,
0.0128190219,
0.0048591313,
0.0049913223,
0.0509387366,
0.035496261,
0.0008552768,
0.0199251287,
0.0553018712,
-0.0345983505,
-0.0411332659,
0.0395155028,
-0.0124795232,
-0.0127514005,
-0.013831988,
0.0309671666,
-0.0235403199,
-0.0199235156,
-0.0193534121,
-0.003460106,
0.0040811142,
-0.0492994562,
0.05017519,
-0.0009431929,
-0.0246297568,
-0.0142689729,
0.018751543,
-0.0395357274,
-0.0071785753,
0.0210255105,
-0.0636486635,
0.0210186858,
0.021841079,
-0.0157297086,
0.0059461556,
-0.023810111,
0.0230405591,
-0.0237016995,
0.0775575563,
-0.0064471005,
0.0704124644,
0.0172002818,
-0.0940161422,
-0.0080904542,
-0.0641422868,
0.0171781573,
0.0191547703,
0.0152529562,
0.0050961976,
-0.0084386747,
0.0225538258,
-0.0075912643,
0.0039424379,
-0.0218611751,
-0.0540380515,
-0.0061716647,
0.0177808236,
0.0390121602,
-0.02790213,
-0.0209128093,
-0.0199748203,
0.059367273,
0.0187521446,
-0.0454891622,
-0.070981741,
0.0070495922,
2.774e-7,
0.0073817102,
0.0167415775,
0.0113549754,
0.0054441206,
-0.0101720989,
0.0107588591,
-0.0459847078,
-0.0082662292,
-0.0375328213,
-0.0150433974,
-0.0059909825,
0.0167841502,
0.071843788,
0.026220724,
-0.0727257207,
0.016575899,
-0.0124223921,
-0.0050715809,
-0.0602150783,
-0.009365011,
0.0060816742,
0.0688302889,
-0.0069460305,
-0.0308458693,
0.0349158384,
-0.0300443489,
0.0324044079,
-0.0338961445,
0.0151984487,
0.018240789,
-0.0193613078,
-0.0048788674,
-0.0248893853,
-0.0349620134,
-0.0397058055,
-0.0029716354,
-0.0067424467,
0.0657850653,
0.0164719969,
0.0447935387,
0.0487215929,
-0.0354587995,
-0.012866159,
-0.0165107939,
0.0402609222,
0.0266320743,
-0.0037363458,
-0.0072637578,
0.0025243494,
-0.0297762621,
0.0048294626,
-0.02555326,
0.0456293188,
0.0299842581,
0.0057141776,
-0.0477491617,
-0.0131147522,
-0.0352234021,
-0.0315005891,
-0.0002913142,
-0.0256725326,
-0.0695224851,
-0.0661658421,
0.0465939492,
0.0531817265,
-0.0452125706,
0.0180952884,
2.871057479e-34,
0.0104874661,
-0.0561154224,
0.0355195142,
0.0335334577,
0.0437848866,
0.0030609739,
0.0166859757,
0.0268627405,
-0.0275498573,
-0.0028297896,
-0.0107242232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00418v1 | eFontes. Part of Speech Tagging and Lemmatization of Medieval Latin Texts.A Cross-Genre Survey | 2024-06-29T11:59:20 | 2024-06-29T11:59:20 | Krzysztof Nowak, Jędrzej Ziębura, Krzysztof Wróbel, Aleksander Smywiński-Pohl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This study introduces the eFontes models for automatic linguistic annotation
of Medieval Latin texts, focusing on lemmatization, part-of-speech tagging, and
morphological feature determination. Using the Transformers library, these
models were trained on Universal Dependencies (UD) corpora and the newly
developed eFontes corpus of Polish Medieval Latin. The research evaluates the
models' performance, addressing challenges such as orthographic variations and
the integration of Latinized vernacular terms. The models achieved high
accuracy rates: lemmatization at 92.60%, part-of-speech tagging at 83.29%, and
morphological feature determination at 88.57%. The findings underscore the
importance of high-quality annotated corpora and propose future enhancements,
including extending the models to Named Entity Recognition. | eFontes. Part of Speech Tagging and Lemmatization of Medieval Latin Texts.A Cross-Genre Survey: This study introduces the eFontes models for automatic linguistic annotation
of Medieval Latin texts, focusing on lemmatization, part-of-speech tagging, and
morphological feature determination. Using the Transformers library, these
models were trained on Universal Dependencies (UD) corpora and the newly
developed eFontes corpus of Polish Medieval Latin. The research evaluates the
models' performance, addressing challenges such as orthographic variations and
the integration of Latinized vernacular terms. The models achieved high
accuracy rates: lemmatization at 92.60%, part-of-speech tagging at 83.29%, and
morphological feature determination at 88.57%. The findings underscore the
importance of high-quality annotated corpora and propose future enhancements,
including extending the models to Named Entity Recognition. | [
0.0229925681,
0.0322823934,
0.0125224395,
0.0716555119,
-0.0307586659,
0.0279534757,
-0.0330647342,
0.0036385579,
-0.009169423,
-0.0973828137,
0.0005974789,
-0.0004850072,
0.0188538525,
-0.0546332933,
0.0370183475,
-0.0284490772,
0.037101265,
-0.0185356252,
-0.0779316574,
0.0197202675,
0.0317143761,
-0.0226686448,
0.0034525355,
0.0081944512,
-0.0162260253,
0.0473333634,
-0.0006757241,
0.0082188947,
-0.0090148263,
0.0186679065,
0.017722711,
0.0579750687,
-0.0254747272,
0.0578525811,
0.0000016982,
-0.0547745749,
-0.058732897,
-0.0214271937,
0.0079123853,
0.0014500908,
0.0273860209,
-0.0265022684,
-0.0382773019,
-0.0435739942,
-0.0039878725,
0.0039303331,
0.0320718586,
0.0312640555,
-0.0106574055,
0.0461552478,
-0.0116193108,
-0.0900690928,
0.0538361482,
-0.0126241501,
-0.0226152707,
0.0139822308,
-0.0034759981,
-0.0323871709,
0.0083460119,
0.0300457478,
0.0056753196,
0.0264414381,
-0.0573083498,
0.0116969869,
-0.0067739496,
-0.0074121729,
-0.0401667394,
0.0127308946,
0.00778411,
-0.0105773807,
0.0471475609,
-0.0171664823,
0.0292132739,
0.0237337016,
-0.0156483278,
0.0242298171,
-0.0157197397,
-0.0056495611,
-0.0343095325,
0.0149925202,
0.0712176487,
-0.0138019063,
0.0032387725,
0.0070692138,
-0.0346133485,
0.0922226459,
0.038312193,
-0.0465675853,
0.0305035356,
0.024737319,
-0.0578064471,
-0.0362925194,
-0.0124901189,
0.0478739403,
0.0378322639,
0.0055046915,
-0.0216419213,
-0.0534246191,
0.0296781771,
-0.0326730981,
-0.0455986932,
-0.0054124412,
-0.0176599026,
0.0198120903,
-0.0391437374,
0.0195039622,
0.0300900079,
-0.0430600643,
-0.0134010036,
-0.0108592343,
-0.0341781303,
0.0204917919,
-0.0472145416,
0.0328281075,
-0.0210042093,
0.0366969071,
-0.0402071178,
-0.0191545039,
0.054144185,
0.0448812805,
-0.0107134581,
-0.0455408655,
0.0126539152,
-0.0045990115,
-0.0387005545,
0.0033048263,
-0.0316930711,
0.0066018659,
-0.0727203339,
-0.0567655489,
0.014976752,
0.0060928334,
0.0163308829,
-0.0842591524,
0.0602987334,
0.0430833288,
0.0216550119,
-0.0703814998,
-0.0359887183,
-0.0217441935,
-0.0352915153,
-0.0492748134,
-0.0150831193,
-0.0579969473,
-0.0312744901,
-0.0150192026,
0.0460658297,
0.0004587744,
0.0117761614,
0.0154937869,
-0.0472505763,
0.067907244,
-0.0532072,
-0.0107004661,
0.0053801551,
-0.0543744117,
0.0249361545,
0.0081613483,
0.0561309159,
0.0083242562,
0.0532520674,
0.025349047,
0.0044094766,
0.0630382895,
-0.0298512336,
-0.0568482801,
-0.0130041819,
-0.0294241235,
0.0187779516,
0.004537432,
0.0196567606,
0.0428617634,
0.0074828793,
0.0203557834,
0.041991137,
0.0347300954,
0.0445784517,
-0.0046815984,
0.0351445414,
-0.0080782017,
0.0428027026,
0.0163091831,
-0.0498642251,
-0.0541135445,
0.0179674402,
0.0319299921,
-0.0356088802,
0.0146463113,
0.022734534,
-0.0054825386,
-0.021080317,
-0.0530953929,
-0.0161095746,
-0.0410722382,
0.092805706,
0.0030420686,
-0.0466583185,
0.0192666966,
0.0226478353,
-0.0593221337,
0.0263954829,
0.0251250472,
0.0321621597,
0.0636767745,
0.0570393391,
-0.0583623946,
-0.0239583664,
0.0058442289,
-0.0429552943,
0.0262168925,
-0.0414157957,
-0.0332910828,
0.0046864515,
-0.0403060056,
0.0125170629,
0.0190181285,
0.0210354105,
-0.0005280855,
-0.0499455929,
0.0117954742,
0.0067418986,
-0.0428609811,
-0.035283614,
0.0678255334,
-0.0177368987,
-0.0326932073,
-0.0502896868,
0.0050604814,
0.0062576854,
0.039326407,
-0.0131052025,
-0.0032397921,
0.0308373589,
-0.0453796238,
0.0291908663,
0.0193479918,
0.035433691,
0.0188259482,
0.055035688,
-0.0266198236,
0.0101371361,
-0.0310705844,
0.0191221982,
-0.0386193916,
0.0063465633,
-0.0537193455,
0.0259771273,
-0.0085341437,
0.0355158448,
-0.0122211948,
-0.0061317994,
-0.049132552,
0.0520972982,
0.0272773821,
0.0600902103,
-0.0076334192,
-0.0578965396,
0.0456970818,
0.0063036811,
-0.0737838745,
-0.0480420925,
-0.0010788258,
-0.042211026,
0.0029161039,
-0.0222773217,
-0.0117754191,
-0.0546905734,
-0.1273021996,
0.0485474654,
-0.0351075456,
0.0668161213,
-0.0247148797,
0.0120373797,
-0.0145151289,
-0.005859632,
-0.0006140085,
-0.0308361296,
-0.0330726318,
-0.0171516556,
0.0468495153,
-0.0064879046,
-0.0204897411,
-0.0381822065,
0.0250001885,
0.0098295677,
0.0092733512,
0.04834475,
-0.0643823147,
-0.0227900501,
-0.0098694442,
-0.0264814403,
0.0342199989,
-0.0096118674,
-0.0130594289,
-0.0306090172,
0.004508548,
0.0255114939,
0.0059036282,
-0.0065286919,
-0.0418293513,
-0.0097326478,
-0.0287695639,
0.0023283015,
-0.0248874035,
0.001220774,
0.0113346977,
-0.0500183292,
-0.0387047082,
0.0325164162,
0.0723366514,
-0.0647317544,
0.0201541912,
0.0064852405,
-0.0030467308,
-0.0395107828,
0.0222254433,
0.0252551492,
0.0021921701,
-0.0290417001,
0.0234316234,
0.0244096294,
-0.011193214,
0.0226119701,
-0.0530534796,
0.0098943403,
-0.0410717279,
-0.0014332803,
-0.0610104799,
0.0174344536,
0.0604286231,
-0.010416721,
0.0189124271,
-0.0787787437,
0.0226563234,
0.0472582243,
0.0770463869,
-0.0434498787,
0.0742591396,
-0.0308536012,
0.018365996,
-0.023499582,
0.0093665831,
0.004591268,
-0.0108480398,
-0.0604152456,
0.0044552246,
0.0202169102,
-0.0263399743,
0.0056510633,
0.0490851402,
-0.035378281,
0.0647209138,
0.0004614104,
0.0157452486,
-0.0353220031,
0.0586973913,
-0.0115581816,
0.0126567613,
-0.0363044739,
-0.0132502029,
-0.0101034585,
0.0001080628,
-0.0000269208,
-0.018662421,
-0.0192815997,
-0.0184338186,
0.0121401558,
-0.070891507,
-0.0951607525,
-0.0653891861,
-0.0159694795,
-0.0091215279,
0.0158936884,
0.0844898894,
0.0251915418,
-0.0172295235,
-0.01056448,
-0.0203177873,
0.008602405,
-0.0025482383,
-0.0092253471,
-0.0822323933,
-0.0215548947,
0.0383719616,
0.0244872086,
0.0097947372,
-0.0458122157,
0.050344687,
-0.0858061761,
0.0206407513,
-0.0302098636,
-0.0311415941,
-0.0142382421,
-0.034047246,
0.0130380047,
-0.0938630998,
-0.0438096598,
0.0004215789,
-0.0370672643,
0.0398610234,
0.0546782017,
-0.0422915071,
-0.0214093346,
-0.0538772531,
-0.0675368235,
0.0214193836,
0.0168720651,
0.0562402569,
-0.0834552348,
0.0196945332,
0.0204170384,
-0.0270402338,
-0.0104149291,
-0.0284258276,
0.098194629,
0.001464861,
0.0014478043,
0.0060685645,
-0.0092821959,
0.0281606559,
-0.0587139651,
0.0649203435,
0.0232790001,
0.0115359128,
0.0536420904,
0.0078060855,
-0.0186737645,
-0.0106047681,
0.0457739085,
-0.0050046435,
-0.0139226625,
-0.0113328081,
0.003764159,
0.0369655639,
-0.0158011224,
-0.0547491461,
-0.0065110414,
-0.0586282611,
-0.0240563694,
-0.08493191,
-0.0477039069,
0.0359562784,
0.0390404537,
0.0696017444,
0.0241103824,
0.0016714245,
0.0059295683,
-0.0583324395,
0.0343122371,
-0.0024715378,
0.0150793316,
-0.071604535,
-0.0065076309,
0.0673746616,
0.0057259779,
-0.0289044585,
0.0152712613,
-0.0240974855,
-0.0238570534,
0.0081450343,
0.0347246341,
0.0228110533,
0.0336107127,
-0.0327501483,
-0.039018631,
-0.0171380024,
-0.0101421466,
0.0051974528,
0.0393238701,
0.0290334672,
-0.017453542,
-0.0248248409,
0.0190852676,
0.0111751063,
0.0208788458,
-0.0036486622,
0.019474037,
-0.0185002442,
-0.0531674027,
0.0228897817,
0.0125819054,
0.0342922322,
-0.0820804834,
-0.0005183726,
-0.0356166363,
0.0234165899,
-0.0022808029,
0.000986562,
0.0048466371,
0.0666059479,
0.018171763,
0.015370477,
-0.0165702924,
-0.0039877603,
-0.0170953404,
-0.0033267515,
-0.0218146499,
0.0111123594,
0.0240662023,
0.0204958972,
-0.0510145463,
0.0215817615,
0.029933,
0.023894839,
0.0135083152,
0.0674877763,
-0.0148346052,
-0.0037926792,
-0.0171759613,
0.001776801,
-0.0014188801,
0.0213044882,
0.0104260743,
0.0551641658,
-0.0486147553,
0.0182199776,
0.0608613864,
-0.0150587643,
0.1052432582,
-0.0285424031,
-0.0078885285,
-0.0016176587,
0.0197459776,
0.0209915172,
0.0484041236,
-0.0128446203,
-0.0005105975,
-0.022989342,
0.0108448435,
0.0274819303,
-0.005724425,
0.0339531675,
0.0152200647,
-0.0169905629,
-0.033697132,
-0.0017052597,
-0.0276436731,
-0.0503553376,
-0.0356621332,
-0.0071420809,
-0.0708466917,
-0.0196542181,
0.0379028618,
0.0169506334,
-0.0243403632,
-0.0167803653,
0.008723828,
0.024756629,
0.0138380248,
0.0176170263,
-0.0659745485,
0.0555026047,
-0.0080740694,
-0.0096539855,
-0.0303598698,
-5.230409134e-33,
-0.0341584049,
0.0040983362,
-0.0019156508,
0.0380386673,
-0.0089037092,
-0.0135000702,
0.0207024831,
0.0146412915,
0.013115393,
0.006231301,
0.0022545748,
-0.0153227337,
0.0342788771,
-0.0070236311,
0.0226245727,
-0.0005847213,
0.0170048792,
0.0163266994,
-0.0075737927,
-0.024755884,
0.0445953161,
0.0144637963,
0.0913064778,
-0.0891690627,
0.0581100136,
-0.0228092559,
-0.017986156,
-0.0027589723,
0.0527325012,
0.0532260276,
-0.0272811055,
-0.0380408876,
0.0204624739,
-0.0048625902,
0.0327691883,
0.0499028377,
-0.0805490017,
-0.0108308662,
0.0361950882,
0.0483208559,
0.0449438766,
-0.053524822,
-0.0103167305,
0.0087191667,
-0.0188428927,
0.0511106588,
0.0658804551,
-0.0219117757,
-0.0123386597,
-0.0218331162,
-0.0692612305,
0.0614577383,
0.01968804,
0.0174382236,
0.0607941076,
0.0427557379,
0.0326211713,
-0.0070593162,
0.0021949613,
-0.0120867006,
0.0163870975,
0.0365486518,
-0.0219462346,
-0.008001266,
-0.0595100187,
0.0367008038,
0.007364193,
-0.0327460989,
0.0078251651,
0.0448464528,
0.0240071379,
0.0090499623,
0.0594705082,
0.0447489172,
0.0357081033,
0.0343723074,
-0.0386627093,
0.0168689191,
0.0402599871,
0.0050469707,
-0.0403936207,
-0.0606707856,
-0.0218192749,
0.0159245171,
-0.0241408665,
-0.0590020083,
0.0226371493,
-0.0012219551,
-0.0048411642,
-0.0055071334,
-0.0020711855,
0.0304750148,
-0.0181400888,
-0.0122207031,
-0.0714167655,
-0.0326685347,
0.0193710402,
0.0749338493,
-0.0491961986,
0.0028119269,
-0.0097075682,
-0.0266441777,
0.0372814499,
0.018341586,
0.0138053587,
-0.0113046709,
0.0478302054,
0.0051512099,
-0.0341938362,
0.0043840944,
0.0044953935,
0.0344080366,
-0.0378886014,
0.0656076446,
0.0442901403,
0.0053900885,
0.0374830328,
0.0080936886,
0.0567721091,
0.0012203653,
-0.0276705381,
-0.003402425,
0.0327388383,
0.0173675902,
0.0099203754,
0.0031474945,
0.0256424267,
0.0349685624,
-0.0027115229,
-0.0119910706,
0.0279787723,
-0.0125616929,
2.511e-7,
0.0738126189,
-0.0086121857,
0.0133454921,
-0.0519322492,
-0.0047159144,
0.0199203398,
-0.019580476,
0.0250535402,
-0.0233704038,
0.0026981076,
0.0376565121,
-0.0596183501,
0.0495121703,
0.0366466492,
-0.08406654,
-0.0725026727,
-0.0029910014,
-0.0405386835,
-0.0337003991,
0.0404854678,
-0.0076791486,
0.1153951734,
0.0140472949,
-0.0428280346,
-0.0420082025,
-0.0173830297,
0.0262170453,
-0.0126291513,
-0.0499105453,
0.0532798506,
0.0642045811,
0.0407636799,
-0.0094223553,
0.0600721464,
0.0044045337,
0.0606394745,
0.011535312,
0.0298259296,
-0.0113101648,
0.0467074066,
0.016328983,
-0.0664188489,
0.0060440511,
0.0024516706,
0.0595772937,
0.0290143024,
0.013784322,
0.0000652083,
-0.0502515174,
0.0629076585,
-0.0128971469,
0.0123027721,
-0.0308666304,
0.0372325704,
0.0594356731,
-0.0146987084,
-0.0130339731,
-0.0718957186,
0.0301204901,
0.0213004518,
-0.0156270433,
-0.0433771051,
0.0266413614,
-0.0328031704,
-0.0360187143,
-0.0371515453,
-0.0278017819,
2.091794493e-34,
-0.0059981537,
-0.0409696177,
-0.0228140075,
0.0787804201,
-0.0057741231,
-0.0013651613,
-0.0037715537,
0.0214492306,
-0.0359141044,
-0.0117214415,
0.0367971174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00416v1 | Too Late to Train, Too Early To Use? A Study on Necessity and Viability of Low-Resource Bengali LLMs | 2024-06-29T11:50:16 | 2024-06-29T11:50:16 | Tamzeed Mahfuz, Satak Kumar Dey, Ruwad Naswan, Hasnaen Adil, Khondker Salman Sayeed, Haz Sameen Shahgir | cs.CL | cs.CL | Each new generation of English-oriented Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibits
enhanced cross-lingual transfer capabilities and significantly outperforms
older LLMs on low-resource languages. This prompts the question: Is there a
need for LLMs dedicated to a particular low-resource language? We aim to
explore this question for Bengali, a low-to-moderate resource Indo-Aryan
language native to the Bengal region of South Asia.
We compare the performance of open-weight and closed-source LLMs such as
LLaMA-3 and GPT-4 against fine-tuned encoder-decoder models across a diverse
set of Bengali downstream tasks, including translation, summarization,
paraphrasing, question-answering, and natural language inference. Our findings
reveal that while LLMs generally excel in reasoning tasks, their performance in
tasks requiring Bengali script generation is inconsistent. Key challenges
include inefficient tokenization of Bengali script by existing LLMs, leading to
increased computational costs and potential performance degradation.
Additionally, we highlight biases in machine-translated datasets commonly used
for Bengali NLP tasks. We conclude that there is a significant need for a
Bengali-oriented LLM, but the field currently lacks the high-quality
pretraining and instruction-tuning datasets necessary to develop a highly
effective model. | Too Late to Train, Too Early To Use? A Study on Necessity and Viability of Low-Resource Bengali LLMs: Each new generation of English-oriented Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibits
enhanced cross-lingual transfer capabilities and significantly outperforms
older LLMs on low-resource languages. This prompts the question: Is there a
need for LLMs dedicated to a particular low-resource language? We aim to
explore this question for Bengali, a low-to-moderate resource Indo-Aryan
language native to the Bengal region of South Asia.
We compare the performance of open-weight and closed-source LLMs such as
LLaMA-3 and GPT-4 against fine-tuned encoder-decoder models across a diverse
set of Bengali downstream tasks, including translation, summarization,
paraphrasing, question-answering, and natural language inference. Our findings
reveal that while LLMs generally excel in reasoning tasks, their performance in
tasks requiring Bengali script generation is inconsistent. Key challenges
include inefficient tokenization of Bengali script by existing LLMs, leading to
increased computational costs and potential performance degradation.
Additionally, we highlight biases in machine-translated datasets commonly used
for Bengali NLP tasks. We conclude that there is a significant need for a
Bengali-oriented LLM, but the field currently lacks the high-quality
pretraining and instruction-tuning datasets necessary to develop a highly
effective model. | [
0.0424042679,
0.044928465,
0.0042807763,
0.0417333879,
-0.0433429778,
0.0211063698,
-0.0046203518,
-0.0175491683,
-0.0116290729,
-0.00022956,
-0.0167691149,
-0.0411802456,
0.021550931,
0.0174423046,
0.019234607,
-0.0457318835,
0.050892543,
-0.0398339406,
0.0093551269,
-0.0030693612,
0.0205924679,
0.0281670857,
-0.0057917247,
0.0250790883,
0.0182441659,
-0.0019271262,
0.0311823245,
0.0072862385,
-0.0109869773,
-0.0191425923,
-0.0124697173,
0.0218253955,
0.0165314768,
0.0003438975,
0.0000017825,
-0.0646705404,
-0.0171620809,
-0.0230420697,
-0.0286810659,
0.0159675553,
0.0509796031,
-0.0485586748,
-0.0064084707,
0.0502139889,
-0.0035622527,
0.0100406567,
0.0955385715,
0.0341301076,
0.0502275936,
0.0925092623,
-0.0061202585,
-0.0675368235,
0.031119125,
-0.0163994618,
0.0142711857,
0.0031116009,
-0.0094151301,
-0.0079165492,
0.0248011872,
-0.020358514,
-0.032650128,
0.0448768884,
0.0346300602,
-0.0235217661,
0.0008672437,
0.003308303,
-0.0200203061,
-0.0136609385,
0.0121477479,
0.045690313,
-0.0541053414,
-0.01320701,
-0.0117932828,
0.0189913828,
-0.0399429798,
-0.0456834808,
-0.0462731645,
0.0762336627,
-0.032635238,
0.0563843288,
0.0840057209,
0.0053466712,
0.0011896197,
0.0109059587,
0.0320886672,
0.0216480475,
0.0121195335,
-0.0034733142,
-0.0263502151,
0.0361411832,
-0.020544434,
-0.0119754635,
0.0222929586,
0.0277594905,
0.0001250091,
0.0282924585,
-0.0398503207,
0.0145176994,
0.0047494196,
0.015960265,
0.0375661291,
0.0871344134,
-0.0078163119,
0.0136053376,
-0.0328548327,
0.0156243006,
-0.0519361235,
0.0360394716,
-0.0272922404,
-0.0227104928,
0.024614729,
-0.0539785251,
-0.0180995055,
0.0318741426,
-0.0658892095,
0.0105062881,
-0.0474038236,
0.0299803969,
0.039962858,
-0.033759445,
0.0533901565,
-0.0180538036,
-0.0441137366,
-0.0251848865,
-0.0126092043,
0.0418645591,
0.0095744841,
0.0075055398,
0.0248302668,
-0.1278216541,
-0.0404141285,
0.0242638495,
-0.0393912122,
-0.0484032966,
0.0145477643,
0.0661658347,
-0.0485309102,
-0.0217644963,
-0.0618794225,
0.0389753319,
-0.0159923807,
-0.0769973323,
-0.0002412256,
-0.0476418659,
0.0474360399,
0.043398913,
0.0033717018,
-0.0279068705,
0.0135324281,
0.0380318426,
0.0016654414,
0.0585974157,
-0.0248314086,
-0.0011180853,
0.0484081618,
0.0192506537,
0.0372430235,
0.0493433923,
0.0303366315,
0.008772607,
0.0109973196,
-0.0471085347,
-0.0267289542,
0.0514574349,
-0.013735475,
-0.0235457271,
-0.0303015299,
0.0307108033,
0.0120133208,
0.0347999558,
0.0554057062,
0.0639464855,
-0.0323867053,
0.0330093764,
0.0671577975,
0.0479075536,
0.0064598401,
0.0594606362,
0.050303258,
-0.0194818694,
0.0370088927,
0.0189575609,
-0.0200277735,
0.0374325924,
-0.0183587074,
0.0073046763,
0.0607016161,
0.029917134,
-0.0237131119,
-0.0099614616,
-0.0003591436,
-0.0409195647,
-0.0227653906,
-0.0062834723,
0.0479935519,
-0.0052656033,
-0.0469990522,
0.0537180007,
0.0499506518,
-0.0590022206,
0.0371132419,
-0.0796992183,
0.0365543514,
0.0398026071,
0.0369437076,
-0.0088680107,
0.0210309252,
0.006772168,
0.0010908621,
0.0629798025,
0.0418682769,
-0.0113379406,
0.0168502983,
-0.0521427356,
0.066876471,
-0.0117151961,
-0.009361227,
0.0286071654,
-0.0097752716,
0.0181415379,
0.0001844723,
-0.0204587523,
-0.0448188558,
0.0467470773,
-0.0289460532,
-0.0099106506,
-0.0127145071,
-0.014891061,
0.0505249389,
-0.0068209819,
0.0061516403,
-0.0166358519,
-0.0118816253,
-0.0745156407,
0.0163729377,
0.0066040303,
-0.0729736164,
-0.0802259296,
-0.0045660702,
-0.0311084539,
0.0207548589,
0.017194258,
-0.0059378897,
-0.0705121011,
0.0372943878,
-0.0562420785,
0.0318523906,
-0.0446915962,
0.0411244631,
-0.0175020061,
0.0120627433,
-0.0374289937,
0.0584559292,
0.0232716985,
-0.0090716211,
0.0071381354,
-0.0145237669,
0.0600630641,
-0.051663667,
-0.0027825451,
0.0656963959,
0.0550713688,
0.0020083643,
0.011258197,
0.0499924757,
-0.021103166,
-0.0436106771,
-0.0720285922,
0.023481939,
-0.0185547285,
0.0273753442,
0.0251897629,
0.043017216,
-0.0221023895,
-0.0086990111,
-0.0062855473,
0.007728477,
0.0577967912,
-0.0015476367,
0.0420692861,
-0.015245189,
0.0205856506,
-0.0204544291,
-0.0405721553,
0.0449835323,
0.0557547882,
-0.001752874,
-0.0315343477,
-0.0408271961,
0.0309844501,
-0.0075645712,
-0.0301228072,
-0.0128692314,
-0.0411919057,
-0.015139956,
-0.0324227698,
0.0052119135,
0.0199864786,
0.0027619663,
-0.0114947595,
-0.0086629512,
0.0049515846,
-0.0245918669,
-0.0282170717,
0.0038237378,
-0.0384388529,
-0.0322143398,
-0.0336797237,
-0.0151331844,
0.0712522194,
0.0117788622,
0.02272374,
-0.0400908105,
-0.0630954877,
-0.0069910125,
-0.0186396595,
-0.0262247939,
0.0113515537,
-0.0412101336,
0.0365474001,
-0.0358903892,
-0.0416419096,
0.0493719615,
-0.0495614596,
-0.0211410876,
-0.0500815734,
-0.0101701152,
-0.0734578446,
0.0257390421,
0.0011595859,
0.0140818767,
-0.0561678447,
-0.0547134653,
-0.0495911092,
0.0218219999,
0.0148127535,
-0.0308747366,
0.0078421021,
-0.0919941142,
0.041997347,
-0.0622883476,
-0.0268689264,
-0.0152577953,
-0.0137958042,
0.0118459538,
0.0164138265,
0.0341905393,
0.0352788568,
0.0007445028,
0.0768522397,
0.029522527,
0.005799091,
-0.0324089341,
0.0096868994,
-0.0097262738,
0.0300676413,
0.0474515818,
0.0133026419,
0.0386407152,
-0.0420032032,
0.0105381701,
-0.0061413939,
-0.0019126678,
-0.0159348343,
-0.0094420351,
0.0300673116,
0.0539993867,
-0.0120926918,
0.0006881115,
0.0007234435,
0.0709270164,
0.0011416888,
-0.0407115854,
0.0939542502,
0.0236312337,
-0.0427748971,
-0.0180239677,
-0.0550006405,
0.0145882647,
-0.0196026806,
0.005082387,
-0.0419735499,
-0.0321963355,
0.0135316662,
0.0051640025,
0.0074570873,
-0.0165657979,
-0.0462139584,
-0.1454517096,
-0.0045958697,
-0.0016116131,
-0.0331751332,
-0.0695442632,
-0.0146758072,
-0.0361358635,
-0.0072006523,
0.076974079,
0.0346251279,
-0.0446142964,
0.0146429893,
0.0729555488,
-0.0300126933,
-0.0410195254,
-0.0410854183,
-0.0218235161,
0.0186800137,
0.0194129106,
-0.0404832028,
-0.0344846137,
0.0534795448,
0.0392481498,
-0.0526503175,
-0.0101254545,
-0.0072942381,
0.0388230495,
-0.0032390021,
-0.0265763048,
-0.0180323608,
0.0286939926,
-0.0327367559,
-0.0046436908,
0.0148348743,
0.0363478772,
-0.0076653939,
-0.0129480055,
0.0024472044,
-0.0110359415,
0.0148341982,
0.0620830022,
0.0324988998,
-0.0434024632,
-0.0613376014,
-0.0343211405,
-0.0258628763,
-0.0522326566,
-0.0320588313,
0.0238717794,
-0.0572905466,
-0.0139250951,
-0.0354322456,
-0.0392993875,
0.0146123935,
0.0247272309,
0.0082712593,
0.0414635278,
0.0099095628,
-0.008760307,
-0.0297079291,
-0.0031624299,
-0.048479408,
0.0038911493,
-0.0792276114,
-0.00007307,
0.0402646065,
-0.0327726863,
-0.004612098,
-0.0176874306,
-0.0602743141,
-0.0513205118,
0.0146452375,
0.0219318811,
0.0235390179,
-0.0023081822,
0.0042859958,
-0.0645801723,
0.0447940938,
0.0209251456,
-0.0483211502,
0.0244681221,
0.0013493845,
0.025306955,
-0.0082181916,
0.0407667458,
-0.0043318439,
0.0016978483,
0.0180691741,
0.0349740312,
-0.0172744486,
-0.0243323948,
0.0166078806,
0.0277826749,
-0.0142999142,
-0.065834865,
-0.0267980956,
-0.0345347412,
0.0102890693,
-0.0028554434,
0.016860215,
-0.0105792908,
-0.0436865762,
0.0518918075,
0.0398146659,
-0.0115298619,
0.015627794,
0.0091975974,
0.0374954231,
0.0152408043,
0.0713750049,
-0.0275059566,
0.0473142229,
0.0118584009,
0.0166097023,
-0.016151417,
-0.0258704349,
-0.0289927647,
0.0297436118,
-0.0184898879,
0.05401472,
0.0020836198,
0.0111470837,
0.05163607,
0.0404669493,
0.0185554754,
0.0126677882,
-0.0026875082,
0.0156449229,
0.0747412518,
-0.0049907803,
0.0705535114,
-0.0043759351,
-0.0077300104,
-0.0242570117,
0.0213847179,
-0.0052221902,
0.0299078356,
0.0356176607,
-0.0133951595,
-0.0289040022,
0.0189015623,
0.0556681007,
0.0161288138,
0.014924963,
0.0115325693,
0.0040371516,
-0.0093571562,
-0.0851827636,
-0.0182242841,
-0.0279182587,
0.0309398305,
0.0266612768,
-0.0475968458,
-0.0487444438,
-0.0192358326,
-0.0324938856,
0.0051341858,
-0.0389582925,
0.0401325747,
0.057360217,
0.0357822664,
0.0117990859,
-0.0479779467,
0.0386814475,
-0.0395098031,
0.0093788356,
0.0032633629,
-5.906236468e-33,
-0.0504894592,
0.0389913321,
0.0045324638,
-0.0467781126,
-0.0301431231,
-0.0029322938,
-0.051501587,
-0.0367093757,
-0.026909152,
-0.033379063,
-0.0433589034,
0.0099471267,
0.01603592,
0.0400093757,
0.0357112065,
-0.0099341478,
0.011550121,
0.0258244034,
-0.0240955874,
0.0202243235,
0.0521391779,
0.0220065974,
0.0678135529,
0.015893111,
-0.0114638973,
-0.043399781,
-0.0098391986,
0.0048172753,
-0.0143317524,
0.0162040349,
-0.0463790335,
0.0577100329,
0.0337303318,
-0.0270599779,
-0.0308790375,
0.002719518,
-0.0814322531,
0.0096181892,
0.049428083,
0.0469602086,
-0.0150247477,
-0.0622913279,
0.0148105007,
0.0021970561,
-0.0247384775,
0.0151178567,
-0.0160028003,
-0.0314966105,
-0.0172564741,
0.0084597645,
-0.0530512147,
0.0360237956,
-0.0213668961,
0.0394233316,
0.0075410726,
0.0149247767,
-0.0204327963,
-0.0379247405,
-0.0358053707,
-0.0003729949,
0.018161092,
0.064069055,
0.0322290957,
0.0270665847,
-0.0324731655,
0.0064808871,
0.0027501006,
-0.065529272,
0.03636235,
0.0326574855,
-0.0118405223,
0.0030789101,
0.0068053338,
0.0499169938,
0.068633154,
-0.0499808043,
-0.0824534968,
0.0240995605,
0.0205257479,
0.0584517941,
0.0384730138,
-0.0118152294,
-0.010937294,
-0.0491753183,
0.0369655564,
-0.0004607907,
-0.004103818,
-0.0323664248,
0.0473038182,
-0.0238434225,
-0.0143019026,
-0.0050932211,
0.0761012286,
-0.0312145948,
0.0514125861,
0.0005851325,
-0.0278295297,
0.0499867089,
0.0023779867,
0.0538749099,
-0.0869709775,
-0.064156957,
0.0015646341,
0.0004768319,
0.0034624955,
0.003677537,
0.0403054394,
0.0008413492,
-0.0562755466,
0.0120756896,
-0.0492936336,
0.0794197097,
-0.0168796293,
0.048063796,
0.0011038005,
-0.0177412555,
-0.0055786567,
0.0135413716,
-0.002708066,
0.009416257,
0.0098238969,
0.0274741724,
0.0161418281,
0.0042031822,
-0.0384142846,
0.0486459248,
-0.0417265408,
0.0327682309,
-0.011499078,
-0.0403167903,
-0.0066899946,
0.0277694408,
2.565e-7,
0.046574235,
0.0201562438,
0.0638761073,
-0.0063609253,
0.011096458,
-0.0133874118,
-0.0057569877,
0.0000645269,
0.0025966803,
0.0260908343,
0.0359794535,
0.043538712,
0.0893848091,
0.0133492146,
-0.0747710168,
0.0015702345,
-0.0586801395,
0.0121647092,
-0.0570043921,
-0.0125112692,
0.0044193058,
0.0605664328,
-0.0214919187,
-0.0325012021,
-0.0329710096,
-0.031655211,
0.0590396039,
-0.0148192318,
-0.023913933,
0.0217935909,
0.0104021095,
0.047581736,
-0.0519720986,
-0.0279875472,
0.0006065297,
-0.0011493328,
0.0395829342,
0.0704725459,
-0.0008347927,
-0.0376540534,
0.0361036994,
0.0132423444,
0.0116139166,
-0.0401483588,
0.0923536494,
0.0043061762,
-0.054226093,
0.0090631526,
-0.032480076,
-0.0185823496,
-0.004749795,
-0.0345605537,
-0.0206854306,
-0.0092940545,
0.0259527005,
-0.07239566,
-0.0517927073,
-0.0396353528,
-0.0204745401,
0.0320872404,
-0.0320029408,
-0.0690151304,
-0.017624123,
0.0599014908,
0.0143269366,
-0.0711532831,
0.0252476204,
2.385304412e-34,
0.0480594523,
-0.0015006914,
0.0525814183,
-0.0068826117,
0.0415336303,
-0.0007626401,
-0.0154602304,
0.0051569189,
-0.0118899439,
-0.0935093686,
-0.0148616387
] |