### Question: Describe the physical and economic landscape of the jurisdiction as outlined in the plan. Include the name of the planning jurisdiction, its location, population, demographics, and average income. Include major geographic features such as mountains, rivers, deserts, and coastline, as well as any key infrastructure like airports or seaports. Highlight details about the local climate, including any mentions of aridity or water challenges. Additionally, summarize the city’s energy production (oil, gas, renewables) and natural resources, and provide information about industries and economic drivers that are crucial to the region. **Answer:** The plan provided does not contain specific details about the physical and economic landscape of the planning jurisdiction, including the name of the city or state, its location, population, demographics, average income, major geographic features, or local climate specifics such as aridity or water challenges. Furthermore, the plan does not detail the city's energy production, natural resources, or information about industries and economic drivers crucial to the region. The document focuses on the City of Bellingham's strategies and policies related to climate protection and action, but it does not include comprehensive details regarding the physical and economic landscape of the jurisdiction. ### Question: To what extent does the plan address resilience, mitigation, and adaptation? After providing a brief summary of how it addresses each component, classify the plan as a whole as one of the following: mitigation dedicated, adaptation/resilience dedicated, mitigation only climate action plan, mitigation primary climate action plan, equal mitigation and adaptation climate action plan, or sustainable/green plan. **Answer:** **Resilience:** The plan does not explicitly focus on resilience as a primary component. However, it implicitly suggests resilience through strategies like energy efficiency, conservation, and renewable energy, which contribute to the community's ability to cope with climate impacts. The plan's efforts to involve the community and create a sustainable future suggest a resilience aspect, as stated: "Bellingham will create jobs, improve health, save money, and enrich the community, all while preserving the natural beauty and resources it relies on" (*City of Bellingham Climate Protection Action Plan | 2018 Update, OverviewWhat’s Next*). **Mitigation:** The plan is heavily focused on mitigation, with specific strategies aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions. It outlines numerous ongoing and proposed measures across sectors like energy efficiency, renewable energy, transportation, green building, waste reduction, and land use. The plan states: "The 2018 Climate Protection Action Plan update is a guiding document that provides strategies for reducing greenhouse gas emissions at the municipal and community levels" (*City of Bellingham Climate Protection Action Plan | 2018 Update, OverviewWhat’s Next*). **Adaptation:** The plan has limited explicit focus on adaptation. It primarily concentrates on emission reduction measures and strategies. Adaptation is indirectly addressed through policy measures that improve environmental sustainability and energy systems, which may enhance the community's ability to adjust to climate impacts. **Plan Classification:** The plan can be classified as a **mitigation primary climate action plan**. It predominantly centers on reducing greenhouse gas emissions through a variety of strategies while only indirectly addressing resilience and adaptation. ### Question: Does the plan describe a scenario of climate change the planning jurisdiction will face and for which it is planning climate policies for resilience, mitigation, and adaptation? If so, please summarize any such scenario. **Answer:** Yes, the plan describes scenarios of climate change that the planning jurisdiction will face. Specifically, it mentions: - **Temperature Changes:** "2016 was the hottest year on Earth since recordkeeping began in 1880 and the third year in a row to break that record." It notes that "Of the 17 hottest years ever recorded, 16 have occurred since the year 2000" (Overview). - **Rising Sea Levels:** "Global sea level is rising faster than predicted" due to warming sea water and melting glaciers and ice sheets. This could "raise global sea levels more than three feet by 2100" (Overview). - **Local Climate Impacts:** The document highlights local impacts such as "the hottest year on record in Washington State" in 2015, record drought affecting salmon fishing, and unprecedented toxic algae blooms affecting fisheries (Overview). - **Future Climate Predictions:** The plan suggests that recent trends indicate a "new normal" in Bellingham with "hotter and drier summers and more intense rain events in winter, spring, and fall" (Overview). These scenarios inform the climate policies developed for resilience, mitigation, and adaptation within the planning jurisdiction. ### Question: What climate hazards does the plan identify as presenting climate risks for the planning jurisdiction? For each identified climate hazard, summarize the plan’s description of: 1. The climate hazard. 2. The climate risks it poses to the planning jurisdiction. 3. Areas or populations with the most climate vulnerability to the identified climate hazard.Generate a numbered list of every hazard identified in the plan. Make the list as long as necessary to accomodate every single hazard. **Answer:** **1. Heat Waves** - **Climate Hazard Description:** The plan notes the occurrence of record-breaking heat in Bellingham, with the city experiencing record-breaking summer heat in 2016 and mentions that "2016 was the hottest year on Earth since recordkeeping began in 1880" (_Overview, Climate Science Update_). - **Climate Risks:** The heat waves are indicative of the increasing temperatures associated with climate change, which can lead to health risks such as heat-related illnesses. - **Vulnerable Areas/Populations:** The plan does not specify particular areas or populations within Bellingham that are most vulnerable to heat waves. **2. Drought** - **Climate Hazard Description:** The plan highlights the "record drought in 2015" which affected salmon fishing due to stressed fish on the South Fork of the Nooksack River (_Overview, Local Impacts_). - **Climate Risks:** Drought conditions can lead to water scarcity, impacting natural ecosystems and water supply for the community. - **Vulnerable Areas/Populations:** The plan does not specify particular areas or populations within Bellingham that are most vulnerable to drought. **3. Toxic Algal Blooms** - **Climate Hazard Description:** The plan mentions "unprecedented toxic algae blooms" in warm ocean temperatures, impacting fisheries and leading to closures (_Overview, Local Impacts_). - **Climate Risks:** These blooms can threaten marine life and affect local fisheries, which are important for the local economy and food supply. - **Vulnerable Areas/Populations:** The plan does not specify particular areas or populations within Bellingham that are most vulnerable to toxic algal blooms. **4. Low Snowpack** - **Climate Hazard Description:** The plan references "low snowpack" as a result of heat and drought in 2015, impacting local activities such as the Ski to Sea race (_Overview, Local Impacts_). - **Climate Risks:** Reduced snowpack can affect water supply and winter recreational activities. - **Vulnerable Areas/Populations:** The plan does not specify particular areas or populations within Bellingham that are most vulnerable to low snowpack. **5. Wildfires** - **Climate Hazard Description:** The plan discusses the "worst-ever wildfire season" in Washington with over a million acres burned in 2015 (_Overview, Local Impacts_). - **Climate Risks:** Wildfires pose risks to life, property, and air quality, as well as significant economic costs. - **Vulnerable Areas/Populations:** The plan does not specify particular areas or populations within Bellingham that are most vulnerable to wildfires. **6. Sea Level Rise** - **Climate Hazard Description:** The plan warns of "rising sea levels" that could threaten residents due to the melting of glaciers and ice sheets (_Overview, Climate Science Update_). - **Climate Risks:** Sea level rise can lead to coastal flooding and erosion, impacting infrastructure and communities near the coast. - **Vulnerable Areas/Populations:** The plan indicates that "up to 94,000 Washington residents" could be threatened by sea level rise by 2100 (_Overview, Climate Science Update_). ### Question: What resilience options are identified in the plan? For each option, summarize: 1. The specific climate threat it addresses; 2. Details on cost, timeframe, and location, including any references found in tables, charts, or images that might contain this data; 3. Other important attributes, such as economic, environmental, or infrastructural considerations. **Answer:** Based strictly on the content provided from the "City of Bellingham Climate Protection Action Plan | 2018 Update," the document does not explicitly identify resilience options by name or provide detailed summaries of specific climate threats they address, costs, timeframes, or locations. The excerpts provided focus on emissions reduction strategies, climate policy updates, and progress towards climate targets. Therefore, I cannot provide specific resilience options, their associated threats, or detailed attributes as they are not mentioned in the provided text. ### Question: What mitigation options does the plan identify? For each identified mitigation option, summarize the information provided in the plan regarding cost, timing, location, and other important attributes. **Answer:** **Mitigation Options Identified in the Plan:** 1. **Energy Efficiency and Conservation:** - **Resource Conservation Management:** Ongoing since 2007, with a CO2e change of -1238 tons. It accounts for 52% of the 2020 target. Lead by COB Public Works and Facilities. (Section: New and Ongoing Emissions Reduction Measures) - **Parks LED Upgrades:** Proposed to start in 2019, with a CO2e change of -595 tons, accounting for 25% of the 2020 target. Lead by COB Parks. (Section: New and Ongoing Emissions Reduction Measures) 2. **Renewable Energy:** - **City Solar:** Ongoing since 2005, with a CO2e change of -332 tons, accounting for 14% of the 2020 target. Lead by COB Public Works. (Section: New and Ongoing Emissions Reduction Measures) - **Post Point Resource Recovery:** Proposed to start in 2025, with a CO2e change of -1558 tons. Not applicable to 2020 target. Lead by COB Public Works and Post Point. (Section: New and Ongoing Emissions Reduction Measures) 3. **Transportation:** - **Invest in Hybrid & Electric Vehicles:** Ongoing with multiple phases starting from 2007 and proposed for 2022 and 2028, with a CO2e change of -328 tons. Not applicable to 2020 target. Lead by COB Public Works and Fleet. (Section: New and Ongoing Emissions Reduction Measures) - **Limit Idling:** Ongoing since 2007, with a CO2e change of -117 tons, accounting for 5% of the 2020 target. Lead by COB Public Works and Fleet. (Section: New and Ongoing Emissions Reduction Measures) 4. **Green Building:** - **Promote Green Building:** Ongoing since 2007, with a CO2e change of -2,906 tons, accounting for 1.28% of the 2020 target. Lead by City Planning and Development Dept. (Section: Community Reduction Measure) 5. **Waste Reduction:** - **Construction and Demolition Recycling:** Ongoing since 2018, with a CO2e change of -4,122 tons, accounting for 1.81% of the 2020 target. Lead by City Planning and Development Dept. (Section: Community Reduction Measure) 6. **Land Use:** - **Habitat Restoration Program:** Increases carbon sequestration through planting vegetation to improve fish and wildlife habitat. The City’s Property Acquisition Program prevents development around the drinking water source to protect forests. (Section: Land Use) **Important Attributes:** - Timing: Many initiatives are ongoing, with some proposed to start in the future (e.g., Post Point Resource Recovery in 2025). - Location: Various initiatives are implemented by different departments within the City of Bellingham, affecting municipal and community sectors. - Cost: The document does not provide specific cost information for each mitigation option. - Other: The plan outlines the percentage of the 2020 target each measure contributes to, indicating their significance in achieving emission reduction goals. ### Question: What mitigation options does the plan identify? For each identified mitigation option, summarize the information provided in the plan regarding cost, timeframe, location, and other important attributes. **Answer:** **Mitigation Options Identified in the Plan:** 1. **Energy Efficiency & Conservation** - **Resource Conservation Management** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -1238" (Table 4). - **Post Point Best Management Practices** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -157" (Table 4). - **Operations and Employee Actions** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -19" (Table 4). 2. **Renewable Energy** - **City Solar** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2005. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -332" (Table 4). - **Post Point Resource Recovery** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Proposed for 2025. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -1558" (Table 4). 3. **Transportation** - **Limit Idling** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -117" (Table 4). - **Increase Biofuel Use** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -117" (Table 4). - **Free Employee Bus Passes** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -18" (Table 4). - **Invest in Hybrid & Electric Vehicles** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007, with additional investments in 2022 and 2028. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -40 and additional -328" (Table 4). - **Fleet Vehicle Telematics** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Proposed for 2018. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -88" (Table 4). 4. **Green Building** - **Promote Green Building** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2007. - *Location:* Community. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -2,906" (Table 5). 5. **Waste Reduction** - **Construction and Demolition Recycling** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing since 2018. - *Location:* Community. - *Attributes:* "CO2e change ‘15-’30 (tons): -4,122" (Table 5). 6. **Land Use** - **Habitat Restoration Program** - *Cost:* Not explicitly mentioned. - *Timeframe:* Ongoing. - *Location:* Municipal. - *Attributes:* "Increases carbon sequestration by planting vegetation to improve fish and wildlife habitat" (Land Use, Overview). These mitigation options are part of the strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in Bellingham, as outlined in the plan. ### Question: What adaptation options does the plan identify? For each identified adaptation option, summarize: 1. The climate threat it is addressing. 2. Information provided in the plan regarding cost, timeframe, location, and other important attributes. **Answer:** The document provided does not explicitly mention specific adaptation options. It primarily focuses on mitigation measures and strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Therefore, I am unable to provide information on adaptation options, their associated climate threats, costs, timeframe, location, or other important attributes based on the content of the document. ### Question: What climate policies does the plan identify to advance climate justice? For each climate policy, summarize: 1. The climate threat it is addressing. 2. Areas or populations with the most climate vulnerability to the identified climate hazard. **Answer:** The document does not explicitly identify climate policies specifically focused on advancing climate justice. However, it does emphasize the importance of community involvement and equitable measures in its general climate actions. Here are some inferred points that relate to aspects of climate justice: ### General Climate Policies Related to Climate Justice 1. **Transition from Fossil Fuels to Renewable Energy** - **Climate Threat Addressed:** This policy addresses the threat of climate change driven by greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels. - **Areas or Populations with Vulnerability:** While not explicitly stated, populations living in areas with high air pollution, low-income communities, and communities of color are often more vulnerable to the adverse effects of fossil fuel pollution. Transitioning to clean energy could help alleviate these disparities. 2. **Commitment to the Paris Climate Agreement and Local Climate Initiatives** - **Climate Threat Addressed:** The overarching threat of global climate change and its associated impacts, such as sea-level rise and extreme weather events. - **Areas or Populations with Vulnerability:** Coastal communities, low-income populations, and other historically marginalized groups are typically more vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. The plan's commitment to international and local climate initiatives may indirectly support climate justice by aiming to mitigate these broad threats. 3. **Community Involvement in Climate Actions** - **Climate Threat Addressed:** General vulnerability to climate change impacts. - **Areas or Populations with Vulnerability:** The plan highlights that the entire community needs to be involved, which can be seen as an effort to ensure that vulnerable populations have a voice in climate resilience and adaptation planning. While the plan mentions broader climate policies and initiatives, specific policies targeting climate justice and detailing precise vulnerable populations are not explicitly outlined in the document. ### Question: Identify any potential unforeseen maladaptive climate policies. For each identified climate policy, summarize: 1. The climate threat it is addressing. 2. The resilience, mitigation, or adaptation option that the climate policy proposes. 3. Why it may cause inadvertent maladaption. **Answer:** Based on the content provided from the City of Bellingham Climate Protection Action Plan | 2018 Update, there are no specific mentions or identification of potential unforeseen maladaptive climate policies. The document primarily outlines various climate policies, strategies, and efforts that focus on resilience, mitigation, and adaptation, as well as the challenges and setbacks faced at different government levels. However, without specific identification or discussion of maladaptive outcomes related to these policies, it is not possible to provide a summary of potential maladaptive climate policies based on the information given. ### Question: In what ways does the plan measure the success or failure of each adaptation, resilience, and mitigation option? List any specific metrics used, such as reductions in CO2 emissions, improvements in air quality, or other quantifiable impacts. Identify the exact units (e.g., tons, percentages, index values) mentioned in the plan for tracking these outcomes. Additionally, outline any concrete goals or targets set for each option, including deadlines or specific numerical objectives. **Answer:** **Success Measurement and Metrics:** The City of Bellingham Climate Protection Action Plan uses several metrics to measure the success of its mitigation options, with specific targets and units for tracking outcomes: - **Municipal Emissions Reduction:** - **Metric:** Reduction in CO2 emissions (tons). - **Targets:** - Achieve 85% reduction below 2000 levels by 2030. - Achieve 100% reduction below 2000 levels by 2050, making the city government carbon neutral. - **Current Status:** Municipal emissions dropped by 69.5% between 2000 and 2012, exceeding the target of 64%. However, emissions increased slightly in 2015 (Overview, Taking the Next Steps). - **Community Emissions Reduction:** - **Metric:** Reduction in CO2 emissions (tons). - **Targets:** - Achieve 70% reduction below 2000 levels by 2030. - Achieve 85% reduction below 2000 levels by 2050. - **Current Status:** Community emissions fell 17% between 2000 and 2012, exceeding the goal of a 7% reduction. Emissions increased in 2015, posing challenges to meet future targets (Overview, Community successes). - **Specific Measures and Their CO2e Change:** - **Green Power Initiatives:** Reduction of 57,465 tons CO2e by 2030, accounting for 25.23% of the 2020 target. - **Promote Hybrid & Electric Cars:** Reduction of 20,844 tons CO2e, accounting for 9.15% of the 2020 target. - **Vehicle Mode Shift Goal:** Reduction of 13,073 tons CO2e, accounting for 5.74% of the 2020 target. - **Industrial Energy Efficiency:** Proposed measure with a reduction of 12,711 tons CO2e, accounting for 5.58% of the 2020 target (Ongoing and Proposed Community Measures Included in Forecast, Community Reduction Measure Rating). **Concrete Goals and Targets:** - **Municipal Emissions Goals:** - Reduce emissions to 68.3% below 2000 levels by 2020. - Further reduce emissions to 85% below 2000 levels by 2030. - Achieve 100% reduction by 2050 (Overview, Executive Summary). - **Community Emissions Goals:** - Reduce emissions to 28% below 2000 levels by 2020. - Further reduce emissions to 40% below 2000 levels by 2030. - Achieve 85% reduction by 2050 (Overview, Executive Summary). These goals and measurements are part of the ongoing efforts to track progress and ensure the City of Bellingham meets its climate protection objectives. ### Question: Generate a table that summarizes the following features from the document: Location/City Name, Population, Threats Identified, Measures Identified **Answer:** ```markdown | Feature | Details | |----------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | **Location/City Name** | Bellingham | | **Population** | Increased by 15 percent in the last 10 years (specific number not provided) | | **Threats Identified** | - Increase in emissions since 2012 (Overview) | | **Measures Identified**| - 24 ongoing and proposed municipal emissions reduction measures (Overview) | | | - 56 community emissions reduction measures in six core strategies (Overview) | | | - Emissions reduction targets for 2012, 2020, 2030, and 2050 (Executive Summary) | | | - Specific measures include Resource Conservation Management, Parks LED upgrades, etc. | ```